Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Congressional research reportNov 16, 2015

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Congressional Budget Resolutions:

Historical Information

,name redacted,

Analyst on Congress and the Legislative Process

November 16, 2015

Congressional Research Service

7-....

www.crs.gov

RL30297

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Summary

The Congressional Budget Act of 1974 (Titles I-IX of P.L. 93-344, as amended; 2 U.S.C. 601688) provides for the annual adoption of a concurrent resolution on the budget each year. The

congressional budget resolution represents a budget plan for the upcoming fiscal year and at least

the following four fiscal years. As a concurrent resolution, it is not presented to the President for

his signature and thus does not become law. Instead, when adopted by Congress, the budget

resolution serves as an agreement between the House and Senate on a congressional budget plan.

As such, it provides the framework for subsequent legislative action on budget matters during

each congressional session.

In 32 of the 41 years under the Budget Act, Congress adopted at least one budget resolution for

the fiscal year beginning in such year. Congress did not complete action on a budget resolution

for nine fiscal years, most recently for FY2015. A second budget resolution for a fiscal year was

adopted in each of the first seven years, and a third budget resolution was adopted in one year (for

FY1977). Since 1982, Congress has considered only one budget resolution for each fiscal year.

Congress initially was required to cover only the upcoming fiscal year in the budget resolution,

but over the years Congress has expanded this time frame. Currently, the budget resolution must

include at least five fiscal years.

The budget resolution may include budget reconciliation directives instructing one or more

committees to recommend legislative changes to meet the direct spending and revenue levels

included in the budget resolution. In the past 41 years, Congress included budget reconciliation

directives in 22 budget resolutions. Such directives have resulted in 24 budget reconciliation

measures and the enactment of 20 of them. (Four budget reconciliation measures have been

vetoed.)

The House has considered and adopted fewer amendments to the budget resolution than the

Senate. For the last three decades, the House has considered the budget resolutions under special

rules that generally have made in order only amendments in the nature of a substitute. Since 1983,

the House typically has considered between three and seven such amendments to the budget

resolution each year, rejecting all but two of these. In contrast, during the period between 1975

and 2015, the Senate considered an average of almost 54 amendments per budget resolution,

agreeing to an average of about 31 of these.

The Budget Act sets April 15 as a target date for completing action on the annual budget

resolution. (Prior to 1986, the date was May 15.) During the past 41 years, when Congress has

completed action on a budget resolution, Congress adopted the budget resolution by the target

date only six times, most recently in 2003 with the FY2004 budget resolution. Budget resolutions

have been adopted an average of almost 36 days after the target date.

This report will be updated as warranted.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Contents

Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1

Development and Content of the Budget Resolution ...................................................................... 8

Development of the Budget Resolution .................................................................................... 8

Content of the Budget Resolution ............................................................................................ 11

Consideration and Adoption of the Budget Resolution ................................................................. 18

Amendments to the Budget Resolution ................................................................................... 21

Amendments in the House ................................................................................................ 21

Amendments in the Senate................................................................................................ 27

Timing of Action on the Budget Resolution ........................................................................... 29

Tables

Table 1. Congressional Budget Resolutions .................................................................................... 2

Table 2. U.S. Statutes-at-Large Citations of Budget Resolutions.................................................... 6

Table 3. Budget Resolutions Rejected in the House ........................................................................ 7

Table 4. Committee Reports to Budget Resolutions........................................................................ 8

Table 5. Number of Years Covered by Budget Resolutions ........................................................... 11

Table 6. Selected Components Included in Budget Resolutions Adopted by Congress ................ 13

Table 7. Budget Resolutions and Associated Reconciliation Acts ................................................ 16

Table 8. Special Rules Providing for the Consideration of Budget Resolutions in the

House.......................................................................................................................................... 18

Table 9. Number of Amendments to Budget Resolutions Considered in the House ..................... 21

Table 10. Amendments in the Nature of a Substitute to Budget Resolutions Made in

Order by a Special Rule in the House ........................................................................................ 23

Table 11. Number of Amendments to Budget Resolutions Considered in the Senate ................... 27

Table 12. Dates of Final Adoption of the Budget Resolution ........................................................ 29

Table 13. Timing of House Action on Budget Resolutions ........................................................... 30

Table 14. Timing of Senate Action on Budget Resolutions ........................................................... 33

Appendixes

Appendix. Modifications to the Procedures and Requirements Pertaining to the

Development, Content, and Consideration of the Budget Resolution ........................................ 36

Contacts

Author Contact Information .......................................................................................................... 39

Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 39

Key Policy Staff ............................................................................................................................ 39

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Introduction

The Congressional Budget Act of 1974 (Titles I-IX of P.L. 93-344, as amended; 2 U.S.C. 601688; hereafter referred to as the “Budget Act”) provides for the annual adoption of a concurrent

resolution on the budget each year. The congressional budget resolution represents a budget plan

for the upcoming fiscal year and at least the following four fiscal years. As a concurrent

resolution, it is not presented to the President for his signature and thus does not become law.

Instead, when adopted by Congress, the budget resolution serves as an agreement between the

House and Senate on a congressional budget plan. As such, it provides the framework for

subsequent legislative action on the annual appropriations bills, revenue measures, reconciliation

legislation, and any other budgetary legislation. While the programmatic assumptions (i.e., the

specific mix of revenue and spending policies that are assumed within the budget levels) are not

binding, the totals and committee spending allocations may be enforced through points of order

and through the budget reconciliation process (explained below).

This report provides current and historical information on the budget resolution. It provides a list

of the budget resolutions adopted and rejected by Congress since implementation of the Budget

Act, including the U.S. Statutes-at-Large citations and committee report numbers, and describes

their formulation and content. The report provides a table of selected optional components, a list

of the budget reconciliation measures developed pursuant to directives contained in budget

resolutions, and information on the number of years covered by budget resolutions. It also

provides information on the consideration and adoption of budget resolutions, including an

identification of the House special rules that provided for consideration of budget resolutions, the

amendments in the nature of a substitute to the budget resolution considered in the House, the

number and disposition of House and Senate amendments to budget resolutions, and dates of

House and Senate action on budget resolutions.

Congress has modified the congressional budget process several times since it was first

established in 1974. The Appendix identifies laws, budget resolutions, and other resolutions that

modified the procedures and requirements pertaining to the development, content, and

consideration of the budget resolution.

As originally enacted, the Budget Act provided for the annual adoption of two budget resolutions

for each year.1 The first budget resolution, adopted in the spring, set nonbinding “targets” to guide

the consideration of budgetary legislation. The second budget resolution, adopted in the fall

(about two weeks before the beginning of the fiscal year), was intended to provide Congress, after

considering and possibly completing action on specific budgetary legislation, the opportunity to

either reaffirm or revise the budget levels in the first budget resolution. Additional budget

resolutions, or revisions to the previous one, could be (and still can be) adopted at any time.

The Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit Control Act of 1985 (Title II of P.L. 99-177, 99

Stat. 1038-1101; hereafter referred to as the “Deficit Control Act”) eliminated the requirement for

a second budget resolution beginning in 1986 (for the FY1987 budget resolution). For several

preceding years, for FY1983-FY1986, Congress did not adopt a second budget resolution but

instead included a provision in the first budget resolution that made the spending and revenue

totals in it binding automatically as of the beginning of the fiscal year.

For a thorough review of the development and early implementation of the Budget Act, see Allen Schick, Congress

and Money: Budgeting, Spending and Taxing (Washington, DC: Urban Institute, 1980).

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

During the 41 years under the Budget Act (1975 to the present), Congress has completed action

on 40 budget resolutions, including in some years multiple budget resolutions for a single fiscal

year. In 32 of the 41 years, Congress adopted at least one budget resolution for the fiscal year.2

Congress did not complete action on a budget resolution for nine fiscal years, most recently for

FY2015.3 Congress also adopted a second budget resolution in seven of the 41 years.4 In 1977,

Congress adopted a third budget resolution for FY1977, further revising the budget levels that

fiscal year.

Table 1 lists all budget resolutions adopted by Congress, with the House and Senate votes on

initial passage and adoption of the conference report. It also includes, in italics, budget

resolutions reported or considered in one chamber but not the other for those fiscal years that

Congress did not complete action on a budget resolution. The U.S. Statutes-at-Large citations for

budget resolutions adopted by Congress are listed in Table 2. (Although concurrent resolutions

such as budget resolutions have no statutory authority, they are compiled in a special section of

the U.S. Statutes-at-Large.) Table 3 lists the budget resolutions rejected in the House. No budget

resolutions have been rejected in the Senate; however, the Senate rejected several motions to

proceed to different budget resolutions in 2011 and 2012.

Table 1. Congressional Budget Resolutions

Initial Passage

Congress

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)a

94th

1976

1977

95th

1978

Conference Report

Typea

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 32)

first

200-196

69-22

230-193

voice

H.Con.Res. 466

(S.Con.Res. 76)

second

225-191

69-23

189-187

74-19

S.Con.Res. 109

(H.Con.Res. 611)

first

221-155

62-22

224-170

65-29

S.Con.Res. 139

(H.Con.Res. 728)

second

227-151

55-23

234-143

66-20

S.Con.Res. 10 (H.Con.Res.

110)

third

239-169

72-20

226-173

voice

S.Con.Res. 19 (H.Con.Res.

214)

first

213-179

56-31

221-177

54-23

H.Con.Res. 341

(S.Con.Res. 43)

second

199-188

63-21

215-187

68-21

In 2013, the House and Senate agreed to establish a “Congressional Budget” in statute as an alternative to the budget

resolution for FY2014 (Subtitle B, Title I, of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2013 [Div. A of P.L. 113-67, Dec. 26,

2013]). The statutory provisions are not in the form of a concurrent resolution as provided for in the Budget Act and

therefore not treated as a budget resolution for purposes of this report.

In the absence of an agreement on the budget resolution, the House and Senate separately have agreed to “deeming

resolution” provisions for budget enforcement purposes. For further information on “deeming resolution” provisions,

see CRS Report RL31443, The “Deeming Resolution”: A Budget Enforcement Tool.

In two of these years (1979 for FY1980 and 1981 for FY1982), the House adopted the Senate version of the second

budget resolution rather than adopting its own; therefore, the chambers did not need to resolve differences between

different versions of the second budget resolution for those fiscal years in a conference committee or through an

amendment exchange.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Initial Passage

Congress

96th

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)a

1979

Typea

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

S.Con.Res. 80 (H.Con.Res.

559)

first

201-197

64-27

201-198

voice

H.Con.Res. 683

(S.Con.Res. 104)

second

217-178

56-18

225-162

47-7

H.Con.Res. 107

(S.Con.Res. 22)

first

220-184

64-20

202-196

72-17

S.Con.Res. 53 (H.Con.Res.

186)b

second

206-186

57-20

—

H.Con.Res. 307

(S.Con.Res. 86)

first

225-193c

241-174

68-28

205-195

61-26

H.Con.Res. 448

(S.Con.Res. 119)

second

203-191

48-46

voice

50-38

H.Con.Res. 115

(S.Con.Res. 19)

first

270-154

78-20

244-155

76-20

S.Con.Res. 50 (H.Con.Res.

230)d

second

206-200

49-48

—

1983

S.Con.Res. 92 (H.Con.Res.

352)

—

219-206

49-43

210-208

51-45

1984

H.Con.Res. 91 (S.Con.Res.

27)

—

229-196

50-49

239-186

51-43

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

250-168

41-34

232-162

voice

1986

S.Con.Res. 32 (H.Con.Res.

152)

—

258-170

voice

309-119

67-32

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

(H.Con.Res. 337)

—

245-179

70-25

333-43

voice

1988

H.Con.Res. 93 (S.Con.Res.

49)

—

voice

56-42

215-201

53-46

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

(S.Con.Res. 113)

—

319-102

69-26

201-181

58-29

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

(S.Con.Res. 30)

—

263-157

68-31

241-185

63-37

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

(S.Con.Res. 110)

—

218-208

voice

250-164

66-33

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

(S.Con.Res. 29)

—

261-163

voice

239-181

57-41

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

215-201e

224-191

voice

209-207

52-41

1994

H.Con.Res. 64 (S.Con.Res.

18)

—

243-183

54-45

240-184

55-45

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 63)

—

223-175

57-40

220-183

53-46

1980

1981

97th

98th

99th

100th

101st

102nd

103rd

Conference Report

1982

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Initial Passage

Congress

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)a

104th

1996

105th

106th

107th

108th

109th

110th

111th

112th

113th

114th

Conference Report

Typea

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

House

Vote

Senate

Vote

H.Con.Res. 67 (S.Con.Res.

13)

—

238-193

57-42

239-194

54-46

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

(S.Con.Res. 57)

—

226-195

53-46

216-211

53-46

1998

H.Con.Res. 84 (S.Con.Res.

27)

—

333-99

78-22

327-97

76-22

1999f

H.Con.Res. 284

(S.Con.Res. 86)

—

216-204

57-41

—

2000

H.Con.Res. 68 (S.Con.Res.

20)

—

221-208

55-44

220-208

54-44

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

(S.Con.Res. 101)

—

211-207

51-45

220-208

50-48

2002

H.Con.Res. 83 (no

companion measure)g

—

222-205

63-35

221-207

53-47

2003h

H.Con.Res. 353

(S.Con.Res. 100)

—

221-209

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95 (S.Con.Res.

23)

—

215-212

56-44

216-211

51-50

2005i

S.Con.Res. 95 (H.Con.Res.

393)

—

215-212

51-45

216-213

—

2006

H.Con.Res. 95 (S.Con.Res.

18)

—

218-214

51-49

214-211

52-47

2007j

H.Con.Res. 376

(S.Con.Res. 83)

—

218-210

51-49

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21 (H.Con.Res.

99)

—

216-210

52-47

214-209

52-40

2009

S.Con.Res. 70 (H.Con.Res.

312)

—

212-207

51-44

214-210

48-45

2010

S.Con.Res. 13 (H.Con.Res.

85)

—

233-196

55-43

233-193

53-43

2011k

S.Con.Res. 60 (no

companion measure)

—

2012l

H.Con.Res. 34 (no

companion measure)

—

235-193

—

2013m

H.Con.Res. 112 (no

companion measure)

—

228-191

—

2014n

S.Con.Res. 8 (H.Con.Res.

25)

—

221-207

50-49

—

2015o

H.Con.Res. 96 (no

companion measure)

—

219-205

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11 (H.Con.Res.

27)

—

228-199

52-46

226-197

51-48

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Notes: Congress did not complete action on the budget resolutions for the fiscal years in italics; for those years,

the concurrent resolution listed was reported by the applicable budget committee and/or was considered by the

applicable chamber.

a. For purposes of this table, “type” refers to whether the budget resolution was the first, second, or third for

the fiscal year. Originally, the Budget Act provided for the annual adoption of two budget resolutions for a

fiscal year and the option of additional budget resolutions. In 1985, the act was amended to eliminate the

second budget resolution; the option of additional budget resolutions remains.

b. The House rejected its version of the budget resolution (see Table 3 of this report) and adopted the

Senate’s version of the budget resolution; no conference report was necessary.

c. The question was divided, with separate votes on Sections 1-5 and 7 and on Section 6 (revised FY1980

budget resolution).

d. The House laid its version of the budget resolution on the table by unanimous consent and adopted the

Senate’s version of the budget resolution; no conference report was necessary.

e. The question was divided, with separate votes on Sections 1, 2, and 4 and on Section 3 (revised the

spending and revenue levels if certain legislation was not enacted into law before conferees on the budget

resolution were appointed).

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY1999. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to H.Res. 477 on June 19, 1998, and H.Res. 5 on January 6, 1999, which

provided that, among other things, the House-adopted FY1999 budget resolution (H.Con.Res. 284, 105th

Congress) shall have “force and effect” as if it were adopted by Congress. Likewise, the Senate agreed to

S.Res. 209 on April 2, 1998, and S.Res. 312 on October 21, 1998, which set forth budget levels enforceable

as if they were included in a budget resolution agreed to by Congress.

g. The Senate Budget Committee did not mark up or report a budget resolution for FY2002. Instead, the

Senate considered the House-passed budget resolution after the Senate Budget Committee was discharged

from its consideration.

h. Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2003. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to H.Res. 428 on May 22, 2002, and H.Res. 5 on January 7, 2003, which

provided that, among other things, the House-adopted FY2003 budget resolution (H.Con.Res. 353, 107th

Congress) shall have “force and effect” as if it were adopted by Congress. The Senate did not take similar

action in relation to the FY2003 budget resolution.

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2005. As indicated, the House agreed to

the conference report to S.Con.Res. 95 (H.Rept. 108-498), but the Senate never considered it. In the

absence of Senate action, the House agreed to H.Res. 649 (108th Congress) on May 19, 2004, and H.Res. 5

(109th Congress) on January 4, 2005, which provided that, among other things, the conference report to

S.Con.Res. 95 (H.Rept. 108-498) shall have “force and effect” as if it was adopted by Congress. As for the

Senate, Section 14007 of the Defense Appropriations Act, 2005 (P.L. 108-287), enacted on August 5, 2004,

established enforceable FY2005 spending allocations for the Senate Appropriations Committee.

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2007. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to H.Res. 818, which provided that, among other things, the House-adopted

FY2007 budget resolution (H.Con.Res. 376, 109th Congress) shall have “force and effect” as if it were

adopted by Congress. As for the Senate, Section 7035 of the Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act

for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Hurricane Recovery, 2006 (P.L. 109-234), enacted on June 15,

2006, established enforceable FY2007 spending allocations for the Senate Appropriations Committee.

k. Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2011. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to a “budget enforcement resolution” (H.Res. 1493) on July 1, 2010, which

provided through the end of the 111th Congress enforceable spending levels for FY2011, among other

provisions. At the beginning of the 112th Congress, the House adopted a separate order in H.Res. 5 (Section

3(b)) that provided for the enforcement of budget levels submitted for printing in the Congressional Record

by the chair of the House Budget Committee (HBC); in addition, on January 25, 2011, the House adopted

H.Res. 38, directing the HBC chair to submit such allocations that assume “non-security spending at fiscal

year 2008 levels or less.” The Senate did not take similar action in relation to the FY2011 budget resolution.

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2012. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to H.Res. 287 (112th Congress) on June 1, 2012, which provided that, among

other things, the House-adopted FY2012 budget resolution (H.Con.Res. 34) shall have “force and effect” as

if it were adopted by Congress. As for the Senate, Section 106 of the Budget Control Act of 2011 (P.L. 11225), enacted on August 2, 2011, provided for enforceable budget levels as an alternative to a FY2012 budget

resolution.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2013. In the absence of such budget

resolution, the House agreed to H.Res. 614 (112th Congress) on June 1, 2012 (amended by H.Res. 643 on

May 8, 2012), and H.Res. 5 (113th Congress) on January 3, 2013, which provided that, among other things,

the House-adopted FY2013 budget resolution (H.Con.Res. 112) shall have “force and effect” as if it were

adopted by Congress. As for the Senate, Section 106 of the Budget Control Act of 2011 (P.L. 112-25),

enacted on August 2, 2011, provided for enforceable budget levels as an alternative to a FY2013 budget

resolution.

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2014. In lieu of such budget resolution,

Subtitle B, Title I, of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2013 (BBA, Div. A of P.L. 113-67), enacted on December

26, 2013, provided for enforceable budget levels and other procedural provisions as an alternative to a

FY2014 budget resolution. Prior to the enactment of the BBA, the House agreed to H.Res. 243 (113th

Congress) on June 4, 2013, which provided that, among other things, the House-adopted FY2014 budget

resolution (H.Con.Res. 25) shall have “force and effect” as if it were adopted by Congress. The Senate had

not taken any similar action prior to the enactment of the BBA.

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for FY2015. In lieu of such budget resolution,

Subtitle B, Title I, of the BBA of 2013 provided for enforceable budget levels and other procedural

provisions as an alternative to a FY2015 budget resolution.

Table 2. U.S. Statutes-at-Large Citations of Budget Resolutions

Congress

Fiscal Year

Typea

94th

1976

first

second

H.Con.Res. 218

H.Con.Res. 466

89 Stat. 1197-1198

89 Stat. 1209-1210

1977

first

second

S.Con.Res. 109

S.Con.Res. 139

90 Stat. 3029-3030

90 Stat. 3044-3045

1977

third

S.Con.Res. 10

91 Stat. 1666-1667

1978

first

second

S.Con.Res. 19

H.Con.Res. 341

91 Stat. 1670-1673

91 Stat. 1683-1684

1979

first

second

S.Con.Res. 80

H.Con.Res. 683

92 Stat. 3870-3872

92 Stat. 3878-3879

1980

first

second

H.Con.Res. 107

S.Con.Res. 53

93 Stat. 1413-1416

93 Stat. 1428-1433

1981

first

second

H.Con.Res. 307

H.Con.Res. 448

94 Stat. 3655-3668

94 Stat. 3680-3688

1982

first

second

H.Con.Res. 115

S.Con.Res. 50

95 Stat. 1743-1759

95 Stat. 1778

1983

—

S.Con.Res. 92

96 Stat. 2647-2661

1984

—

H.Con.Res. 91

97 Stat. 1501-1523

1985

—

H.Con.Res. 280

98 Stat. 3484-3498

1986

—

S.Con.Res. 32

99 Stat. 1941-1959

1987

—

S.Con.Res. 120

100 Stat. 4354-4370

1988

—

H.Con.Res. 93

101 Stat. 1986-2003

1989

—

H.Con.Res. 268

102 Stat. 4875-4886

1990

—

H.Con.Res. 106

103 Stat. 2540-2554

1991

—

H.Con.Res. 310

104 Stat. 5163-5181

1992

—

H.Con.Res. 121

105 Stat. 2414-2433

95th

96th

97th

98th

99th

100th

101st

102nd

Congressional Research Service

Budget Resolution

U.S. Statutes-at-Large Citation

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Congress

103rd

104th

105th

106th

107th

108th

109th

110th

111th

112th

113th

114th

Fiscal Year

Typea

Budget Resolution

U.S. Statutes-at-Large Citation

1993

—

H.Con.Res. 287

106 Stat. 5165-5189

1994

—

H.Con.Res. 64

107 Stat. 2508-2538

1995

—

H.Con.Res. 218

108 Stat. 5075-5103

1996

—

H.Con.Res. 67

109 Stat. 996-1030

1997

—

H.Con.Res. 178

110 Stat. 4434-4482

1998

—

H.Con.Res. 84

111 Stat. 2710-2760

1999

—

2000

—

H.Con.Res. 68

113 Stat. 1968-1999

2001

—

H.Con.Res. 290

114 Stat. 3139-3173

2002

—

H.Con.Res. 83

115 Stat. 2486-2516

2003

—

2004

—

2005

—

2006

—

2007

—

2008

—

S.Con.Res. 21

121 Stat. 2590-2633

2009

—

S.Con.Res. 70

122 Stat. 5143-5190

2010

—

S.Con.Res. 13

123 Stat. 3506-3550

2011

—

2012

—

2013

—

2014

—

2015

—

2016

—

H.Con.Res. 95

117 Stat. 2910-2942

—

H.Con.Res. 95

119 Stat. 3633-3658

—

S.Con.Res. 11

Not available

Source: U.S. Statutes-at-Large, various volumes.

Notes: Although concurrent resolutions such as budget resolutions have no statutory authority, they are

compiled in a special section of the U.S. Statutes-at-Large. In this table, no U.S. Statutes-at-Large citation indicates

that Congress did not complete action the budget resolution for that fiscal year.

a. For purposes of this table, “type” refers to whether the budget resolution was the first, second, or third for

the fiscal year. Originally, the Budget Act provided for the annual adoption of two budget resolutions for a

fiscal year and the option of additional budget resolutions. In 1985, the act was amended to eliminate the

second budget resolution; the option of additional budget resolutions remains.

Table 3. Budget Resolutions Rejected in the House

Congress

Fiscal Year

95th

Budget Resolution

Date

Vote

1978

H.Con.Res. 195

04-27-1977

84-320

96th

1980

H.Con.Res. 186a

09-19-1979

192-213

97th

1983

H.Con.Res. 345

05-27-1982

159-265

99th

1987

H.Con.Res. 296

03-13-1986

12-312

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Congress

Fiscal Year

101st

1991

104th

1996

Budget Resolution

Date

Vote

H.Con.Res. 310

(conf. rept.)b

10-05-1990

179-254

H.Con.Res. 122

12-19-1995

0-412

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: All budget resolutions listed were first budget resolutions, except for FY1980, which was a second

budget resolution. The Senate has not rejected a budget resolution; however, the Senate rejected several

motions to proceed to different budget resolutions in 2011 and 2012.

a. The House subsequently adopted the Senate’s version of the second budget resolution for FY1980

(S.Con.Res. 53).

b. After this conference report (H.Rept. 101-802) was rejected, another conference report to H.Con.Res. 310

(H.Rept. 101-820) was agreed to on October 8, 1990, by a vote of 250-164.

Development and Content of the Budget Resolution

Development of the Budget Resolution

Following the submission of the President’s budget in January or February, Congress begins

developing its budget resolution. The House and Senate Budget Committees are responsible for

developing and reporting the budget resolution.

Within six weeks after the President’s budget submission, each House and Senate committee is

required to submit its “views and estimates” relating to budget matters under its jurisdiction to its

Budget Committee (Section 301(d) of the Budget Act). These views and estimates, often

submitted in the form of a letter to the chair and ranking Member of the Budget Committee,

typically include comments on the President’s budget proposals and estimates of the budgetary

impact of any legislation likely to be considered during the current session of Congress. The

Budget Committees are not bound by these recommendations. The views and estimates often are

printed in the committee report accompanying the resolution in the Senate or compiled in a

separate committee print in the House.

The budget resolution was designed to provide a framework to make budget decisions, leaving

specific program determinations to the Appropriations Committees and other committees with

spending and revenue jurisdiction. In many instances, however, particular program changes are

considered when formulating the budget resolution. Program assumptions sometimes are referred

to in the reports of the Budget Committees or may be discussed during floor action. Although

these program changes are not binding, committees may be strongly influenced by these

recommendations when formulating appropriations bills, reconciliation measures, or other

budgetary legislation.

Table 4 provides a list of the House, Senate, and conference reports to first budget resolutions

reported or considered in either chamber.

Table 4. Committee Reports to Budget Resolutions

Fiscal Year

1976

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

H.Con.Res. 218

S.Con.Res. 32

Congressional Research Service

House Report

Senate

Report/Print

H.Rept. 94-145

S.Rept. 94-77

Conference Report(s)

H.Rept. 94-198

S.Rept. 94-113

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

House Report

Senate

Report/Print

Conference Report(s)

1977

S.Con.Res. 109

(H.Con.Res. 611)

H.Rept. 94-1030

S.Rept. 94-731

H.Rept. 94-1108

S.Rept. 94-805

1978

S.Con.Res. 19

(H.Con.Res. 214)

H.Rept. 95-239

S.Rept. 95-90

H.Rept. 95-291

S.Rept. 95-134

1979

S.Con.Res. 80

(H.Con.Res. 559)

H.Rept. 95-1055

S.Rept. 95-739

H.Rept. 95-1173

S.Rept. 95-866

1980

H.Con.Res. 107

(S.Con.Res. 22)

H.Rept. 96-95

S.Rept. 96-68

H.Rept. 96-211

S.Rept. 96-192

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

(S.Con.Res. 86)

H.Rept. 96-857

S.Rept. 96-654

H.Rept. 96-1051

S.Rept. 96-792

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

(S.Con.Res. 19)

H.Rept. 97-23

S.Rept. 97-49

H.Rept. 97-46

S.Rept. 97-86

1983

S.Con.Res. 92

(H.Con.Res. 352)

H.Rept. 97-597

S.Rept. 97-385

H.Rept. 97-614

S.Rept. 97-478

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

(S.Con.Res. 27)

H.Rept. 98-41

S.Rept. 98-63

H.Rept. 98-248

S.Rept. 98-155

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

(S.Con.Res. 106)

[none]

S.Rept. 98-399

H.Rept. 98-1079

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

(H.Con.Res. 152)

H.Rept. 99-133

S.Rept. 99-15

H.Rept. 99-249

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

(H.Con.Res. 337)

H.Rept. 99-598

S.Rept. 99-264

H.Rept. 99-664

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

(S.Con.Res. 49)

[none]

H.Rept. 100-175

S.Rept. 100-76

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

(S.Con.Res. 113)

H.Rept. 100-523

S.Rept. 100-311

H.Rept. 100-658

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

(S.Con.Res. 30)

H.Rept. 101-42

S.Rept. 101-20

H.Rept. 101-50

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

(S.Con.Res. 110)

H.Rept. 101-455

[none]

H.Rept. 101-820

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

(S.Con.Res. 29)

H.Rept. 102-32

S.Rept. 102-40

H.Rept. 102-69

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

(S.Con.Res. 106)

H.Rept. 102-450

[none]

H.Rept. 102-529

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

(S.Con.Res. 18)

H.Rept. 103-31

S.Rept. 103-19

H.Rept. 103-48

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 63)

H.Rept. 103-428

S.Rept. 103-238

H.Rept. 103-490

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

(S.Con.Res. 13)

H.Rept. 104-120

S.Rept. 104-82

H.Rept. 104-159

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

(S.Con.Res. 57)

H.Rept. 104-575

S.Rept. 104-271

H.Rept. 104-612

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

(S.Con.Res. 27)

H.Rept. 105-100

Congressional Research Service

[none]

H.Rept. 105-116

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

House Report

Senate

Report/Print

Conference Report(s)

1999

H.Con.Res. 284

(S.Con.Res. 86)

H.Rept. 105-555

S.Rept. 105-170

—

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

(S.Con.Res. 20)

H.Rept. 106-73

S.Rept. 106-27

H.Rept. 106-91

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

(S.Con.Res. 101)

H.Rept. 106-530

S.Rept. 106-251

H.Rept. 106-577

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

(no companion measure)a

H.Rept. 107-26

2003

H.Con.Res. 353

(S.Con.Res. 100)

H.Rept. 107-376

S.Rept. 107-141

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 23)

H.Rept. 108-37

S.Prt. 108-19

H.Rept. 108-71

2005

S.Con.Res. 95

(H.Con.Res. 393)

H.Rept. 108-441

S.Prt. 108-365

H.Rept. 108-498

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 18)

H.Rept. 109-17

S.Prt. 109-18

H.Rept. 109-62

2007

H.Con.Res. 376

(S.Con.Res. 83)

H.Rept. 109-402

S.Prt. 109-57

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

(H.Con.Res. 99)

H.Rept. 110-69

S.Prt. 110-19

H.Rept. 110-153

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

(H.Con.Res. 312)

H.Rept. 110-543

S.Prt. 110-39

H.Rept. 110-659

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

(H.Con.Res. 85)

H.Rept. 111-60

S.Prt. 111-16

H.Rept. 111-89

2011

S.Con.Res. 60

(no companion measure)

—

S.Prt. 111-45

—

2012

H.Con.Res. 34

(no companion measure)

H.Rept. 112-58

—

2013

H.Con.Res. 112

(no companion measure)

H.Rept. 112-421

—

2014

S.Con.Res. 8

(H.Con.Res. 25)

H.Rept. 113-17

S.Prt. 113-12

—

2015

H.Con.Res. 96

(no companion measure)

H.Rept. 113-403

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

(H.Con.Res. 27)

H.Rept. 114-47

S.Prt. 114-14

H.Rept. 114-96

[none]

H.Rept. 107-60

—

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: This list includes first budget resolutions only. In this table, no conference report listed indicates that

Congress did not complete action on the budget resolution for that fiscal year.

a. The Senate Budget Committee did not mark up or report a budget resolution for FY2002. Instead, after the

Senate began consideration of the House-passed budget resolution, the SBC chair offered an amendment in

the nature of a substitute.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Content of the Budget Resolution

Section 301(a) of the Budget Act requires that the budget resolution include the following matters

for the upcoming fiscal year and at least the ensuing four fiscal years:



Aggregate levels of new budget authority, outlays, the budget surplus or deficit,

and the public debt;

Aggregate levels of federal revenues and the amount, if any, by which the

aggregate levels of federal revenues should be increased or decreased by

legislative action;

Amounts of new budget authority and outlays for each of the major functional

categories; and

For purposes of Senate enforcement procedures, Social Security outlays and

revenues (although these amounts are not included in the budget surplus or

deficit totals due to their off-budget status).

Originally, the Budget Act mandated that budget resolutions cover only the upcoming fiscal year

beginning on October 1 (referred to as the budget year). A desire to use the budget resolution as a

tool for budget planning and other factors prompted Congress to expand this time frame to

include the upcoming fiscal year as well as the two ensuing fiscal years. Congress used the

authority provided by the elastic clause of the Budget Act to adopt three-year budget resolutions

for the period covering the second budget resolution for FY1980 through the FY1986 budget

resolution. The practice of including three fiscal years was formalized by the 1985 Deficit

Control Act.

The Budget Enforcement Act (BEA) of 1990 (Title XIII of P.L. 101-508, Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1990, 104 Stat. 1388-573-1388 through 630) temporarily extended to five

fiscal years the period the budget resolution is required to cover. The 1990 BEA provision

originally covered five-year periods beginning in FY1991 and continuing through FY1995; this

provision was extended to cover the FY1996 through FY1998 budget resolutions in 1993 (Title

XIV of P.L. 103-66, Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993, 107 Stat. 683-685). As an

integral part of Congress’s goal of achieving a balanced budget by FY2002, the FY1996 and

FY1997 budget resolutions covered seven and six fiscal years, respectively. The Budget

Enforcement Act of 1997 (Title X of P.L. 105-33, Balanced Budget Act of 1997, 111 Stat. 677712) amended the Budget Act to require permanently that a budget resolution cover the budget

year and at least the four ensuing fiscal years (for a minimum of five fiscal years).

Table 5 provides information regarding the number of years covered by the budget resolutions

agreed to by Congress.

Congress also may revise budget levels for the current year in the budget resolution pursuant to

Section 304 of the Budget Act. Congress has adopted 15 first budget resolutions that revised

current-year budget levels.

Table 5. Number of Years Covered by Budget Resolutions

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Fiscal Year(s)

Covered

Current Fiscal

Year Revision

Number of Years

Covered,

Excluding Current

Year

1976

H.Con.Res. 218

1976

—

1977

S.Con.Res. 109

1976-1977

1976

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Fiscal Year(s)

Covered

Current Fiscal

Year Revision

Number of Years

Covered,

Excluding Current

Year

1978

S.Con.Res. 19

1978

—

1979

S.Con.Res. 80

1979

—

1980

H.Con.Res. 107

1979-1980

1979

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

1980-1983

1980

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

1981-1984

1981

1983

S.Con.Res. 92

1982-1985

1982

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

1983-1986

1983

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

1984-1987

1984

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

1985-1988

1985

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

1987-1989

—

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

1988-1990

—

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

1989-1991

—

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

1990-1992

—

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

1991-1995

—

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

1991-1996

1991

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

1993-1997

—

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

1994-1998

—

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

1995-1999

—

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

1996-2002

—

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

1997-2002

—

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

1998-2002

—

1999

—

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

2000-2009

—

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

2000-2005

2000

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

2001-2011

2001

—

2003-2013

2003

—

2005-2010

2005

—

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

—

H.Con.Res. 95

—

H.Con.Res. 95

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

2007-2012

2007

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

2008-2013

2008

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

2009-2014

2009

2011

—

2012

—

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Fiscal Year(s)

Covered

Current Fiscal

Year Revision

Number of Years

Covered,

Excluding Current

Year

2013

—

2014

—

2015

—

2016-2025

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

Sources: U.S. Statutes-at-Large, various volumes, and reports to accompany the budget resolutions.

Notes: This list includes first budget resolutions only. In addition, it includes budget resolutions adopted by both

chambers; that is, it does not include budget resolutions adopted by only one chamber.

In addition to the content required by the Budget Act, Section 301(b) lists several other matters

that may be included in the budget resolution. Table 6 provides a table indicating selected

components included in first budget resolutions for FY1976-FY2016 on which Congress

completed action (i.e., the House and Senate agreed).

Table 6. Selected Components Included in Budget Resolutions

Adopted by Congress

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Budget

Reconciliation

Directives

Credit

Levels

Number of

Reserve Fund

Provisionsa

Number of

Declaratory

Statementsb

Number of

Procedural

Provisionsc

1976

H.Con.Res. 218

—

1977

S.Con.Res. 109

—

1978

S.Con.Res. 19

—

1979

S.Con.Res. 80

—

1980

H.Con.Res. 107

—

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

1983

S.Con.Res. 92

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

—

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

—

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

—

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

—

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

—

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Budget

Reconciliation

Directives

Credit

Levels

Number of

Reserve Fund

Provisionsa

Number of

Declaratory

Statementsb

Number of

Procedural

Provisionsc

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

1999

—

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

—

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

—

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

—

2003

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

—

2005

—

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

—

2007

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

—

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

—

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

—

2011

—

2012

—

2013

—

2014e

—

2015f

—

131

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

Sources: U.S. Statutes-at-Large, various volumes, and reports to accompany the budget resolutions.

Notes: This list includes first budget resolutions on which Congress completed action only.

a. For purposes of this table, “reserve fund” provisions refer to any provision establishing procedures to

revise budget levels—except adjustments to discretionary spending limits—for certain legislation or if some

condition is met.

b. Declaratory statements express, in non-binding terms, the sense of the Congress, the sense of the House,

or the sense of the Senate on various issues.

c. Some examples of the procedural provisions include deferred enrollment; automatic second budget

resolutions; special budgetary treatment of certain activities, such as the sale of government assets; and

more recently, enforcement of pay-as-you-go rules in the Senate and limits on advance appropriations. The

number of procedural provisions does not include reconciliation instructions or reserve fund provisions.

d. The FY1984 budget resolution provided for a single deficit-neutral reserve fund for all legislative initiatives

included in the Manager’s Statement.

e. In lieu of the budget resolution, Section 111 of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2013 (BBA, Div. A of P.L. 11367), enacted on December 26, 2013, provided for enforceable budget levels and other provisions associated

with the FY2014 budget resolution. Several procedural provisions, including reserve fund provisions,

contained in the separate FY2014 budget resolutions adopted by each chamber were made to have force

and effect. For further information, see the text of H.Con.Res. 25 and S.Con.Res. 8 (113th Congress).

In lieu of the budget resolution, Sections 115 and 116 of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2013 (BBA, Div. A of

P.L. 113-67), enacted on December 26, 2013, provided for enforceable budget levels and other provisions

associated with the FY2015 budget resolution. Several procedural provisions—including reserve fund

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

provisions, updated by one fiscal year—contained in the separate FY2014 budget resolutions adopted by

each chamber were made to have force and effect. For further information, see the text of H.Con.Res. 25

and S.Con.Res. 8 (113th Congress).

The most important of the optional matters is arguably the inclusion of budget reconciliation

directives provided by Section 310 of the Budget Act. Budget reconciliation is an optional twostep process Congress may use to bring direct spending, revenue, and debt limit levels into

compliance with those set forth in budget resolutions.5 In order to accomplish this, Congress first

includes budget reconciliation directives in a budget resolution directing one or more committees

in each chamber to recommend changes in statute to achieve the levels of direct spending,

revenues, debt limit, or a combination thereof agreed to in the budget resolution. The legislative

language recommended by committees then is packaged “without any substantive revision” into

one or more budget reconciliation bills as set forth in the budget resolution by the House and

Senate Budget Committees. In some instances, a committee may be required to report its

legislative recommendations directly to its chamber.

Once the Budget Committees (or individual committees if so directed) report budget

reconciliation legislation to their respective chambers, consideration is governed by special

procedures.6 These special rules serve to limit what may be included in budget reconciliation

legislation, to prohibit certain amendments, and to encourage its completion in a timely fashion.

During the 41-year period since the congressional budget process was established, Congress has

included budget reconciliation directives to House and Senate committees in 22 budget

resolutions.7 Such directives have resulted in 24 budget reconciliation measures. On four

occasions (in 1982, 1986, 1997, and 2006), Congress adopted two budget reconciliation measures

in one year. Of the 24 budget reconciliation measures considered by Congress, 20 were signed

into law and four were vetoed. Table 7 lists the budget resolutions that contained budget

reconciliation directives and the associated reconciliation acts.

For a more detailed discussion of the budget reconciliation process, see CRS Report RL33030, The Budget

Reconciliation Process: House and Senate Procedures.

For a brief summary of these procedures, see CRS Report 98-814, Budget Reconciliation Legislation: Development

and Consideration, Budget Reconciliation Legislation: Development and Consideration.

The number (21) of budget resolutions containing budget reconciliation directives includes the FY1976 second budget

resolution (H.Con.Res. 466) and therefore is not included in Table 5. There has been an ongoing controversy about

whether the directive in this budget resolution was a budget reconciliation directive as set forth in Section 310 of the

Congressional Budget Act. The Senate treated it as such and considered the resultant legislation (H.R. 5559, as reported

by the Senate Finance Committee, 94th Congress) under the budget reconciliation procedures. The House did not,

however, consider and adopt its version of the resultant legislation as a budget reconciliation measure, and thus it

presumably did not consider the directive as a budget reconciliation directive. See Floyd M. Riddick and Alan S.

Frumin, Riddick’s Senate Procedure: Precedents and Practices (rev. ed.), S.Doc. 101-28, 101st Cong., 1st sess.

(Washington: GPO, 1992), pp. 622-623. The legislation subsequently was adopted by the Senate and House but was

vetoed by the President. For further information on these directives, see (1) CRS Congressional Distribution

Memorandum, Reconciliation Directives to House Committees in Budget Resolutions for FY1976-FY2005; and (2)

CRS Congressional Distribution Memorandum, Reconciliation Directives to Senate Committees in Budget Resolutions

for FY1976-FY2005 (available from the author).

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Table 7. Budget Resolutions and Associated Reconciliation Acts

Fiscal Years

Covered by

Reconciliation

Directives

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

1976

H.Con.Res. 466a

1976

Revenue Adjustment Act of 1975

(H.R. 5559)

12-17-1975

(vetoed)

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

1980-1981b

Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1980

(P.L. 96-499)

12-05-1980

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

1981-1984c

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1981

(P.L. 97-35)

08-13-1981

1983

S.Con.Res. 92

1983-1985

Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of

1982 (P.L. 97-248)

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1982

(P.L. 97-253)

09-03-1982

09-08-1982

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

1984-1986

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1983

(P.L. 98-270)

04-18-1984

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

1986-1988

Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation

Act of 1985

(P.L. 99-272)

04-07-1986

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

1987-1989

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1986

(P.L. 99-509)

10-21-1986

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

1988-1990

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987

(P.L. 100-203)

12-22-1987

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

1990 (Senate)

1990-1991 (House)

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1989

(P.L. 101-239)

12-19-1989

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

1991-1995

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990

(P.L. 101-508)

11-05-1990

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

1994-1998

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993

(P.L. 103-66)

08-10-1993

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

1996-2002

Balanced Budget Act of 1995

(H.R. 2491)

12-06-1995

(vetoed)

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

1997-2002

Personal Responsibility and Work

Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996

(P.L. 104-193)

08-22-1996

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

1998-2002

Balanced Budget Act of 1997 (P.L. 105-33)

Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 (P.L. 105-34)

08-05-1997

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

2000-2009

Taxpayer Refund and Relief Act of 1999

(H.R. 2488)

09-23-1999

(vetoed)

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

2001-2005

Marriage Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2000

(H.R. 4810)

08-05-2000

(vetoed)

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

2001-2011

Economic Growth and Tax Relief

Reconciliation Act of 2001

(P.L. 107-16)

07-07-2001

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

2003-2013

Jobs and Growth Tax Relief Reconciliation Act

of 2003 (P.L. 108-27)

05-28-2003

Congressional Research Service

Associated Reconciliation Acts

Date Enacted

(or Vetoed)

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Years

Covered by

Reconciliation

Directives

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

2005-2010

2006-2010

Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 (P.L. 109-171)

Tax Increase Prevention and Reconciliation

Act of 2005 (P.L. 109-222)

02-08-2006

05-17-2006

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

2007-2012

College Cost Reduction and Access Act

(P.L. 110-84)

09-27-2007

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

2009-2014

Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act

of 2010 (P.L. 111-152)

03-30-2010

Associated Reconciliation Acts

Date Enacted

(or Vetoed)

Sources: U.S. Statutes-at-Large, various volumes, and the Legislative Information System (LIS). For further

information on budget reconciliation measures, see CRS Report RL33030, The Budget Reconciliation Process: House

and Senate Procedures.

Notes: Each budget resolution listed was the first, or sole, budget resolution for the fiscal year, except for

FY1976, which was the second budget resolution for that year.

a. There has been an ongoing controversy about whether the directive in this budget resolution was a budget

reconciliation directive as set forth in Section 310 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974. The Senate

treated it as such and considered the resultant legislation (H.R. 5559, as reported by the Senate Finance

Committee, 94th Congress) under the budget reconciliation procedures. The House did not, however,

consider and adopt its version of the resultant legislation as a budget reconciliation measure, and thus it

presumably did not consider the directive as a budget reconciliation directive. See Floyd M. Riddick and

Alan S. Frumin, Riddick’s Senate Procedure: Precedents and Practices (rev. ed.), S.Doc. 101-28, 101st Cong., 1st

sess. (Washington: GPO, 1992), pp. 622-623.

b. The House and Senate Appropriations Committees were instructed in the budget resolution to submit

legislation (e.g., rescissions of previously enacted appropriations) to reduce spending for FY1980.

c. The Senate Appropriations Committee was instructed in the budget resolution to submit legislation to

reduce spending for FY1981 (budget authority and outlays) and FY1982-1984 (outlays only).

Beginning with the FY1981 budget resolution, Congress also included amounts for federal credit

activities. The 1985 Balanced Budget Act permanently required the inclusion of aggregate and

functional levels of direct loan obligations and primary loan guarantee commitments in budget

resolutions. The inclusion of federal credit levels, however, was made optional by the Budget

Enforcement Act of 1997 (Title X of P.L. 105-33; 111 Stat. 677-712). Of the 31 first budget

resolutions adopted by Congress, 18 included federal credit amounts.

Another optional component of budget resolutions has been the inclusion of reserve funds. The

reserve fund provisions generally provide for the revision of budget resolution aggregates,

functional allocations, and committee allocations if certain deficit-neutral legislation is enacted or

some other condition is met. Over the last decade, Congress often has included several reserve

funds in budget resolutions (as indicated in Table 6). For instance, the FY2016 budget resolution

(S.Con.Res. 11, 114th Congress) included 131 reserve funds.

As an indication of policy intent, Congress has often included declaratory statements in budget

resolutions. These nonbinding statements express the sense of Congress, the sense of the House,

or the sense of the Senate on various issues. As indicated in Table 6, Congress has included an

average of 21 declaratory statements in the last 14 budget resolutions (not including budget

resolutions for fiscal years on which the House and Senate separately adopted but did not agree)

but an average of only between two and three declaratory statements in the first 18 budget

resolutions.

The annual budget resolution also may require a deferred enrollment procedure (see Section

301(b)(3) of the Budget Act), under which all or certain bills providing new budget authority or

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

new entitlement authority for the upcoming fiscal year cannot be enrolled until Congress has

completed action on a reconciliation measure (or, prior to FY1987, a reconciliation measure or

the second budget resolution). Budget resolutions for FY1981, FY1982, FY1983, and FY1984

contained deferred enrollment provisions.8

Lastly, Congress has included several other procedural provisions in budget resolutions. Under

Section 301(b)(4) of the Budget Act, the so-called elastic clause, Congress may “set forth such

other matters, and require such other procedures, relating to the budget, as may be appropriate to

carry out the purposes of” the Budget Act in the budget resolution. The number of procedural

provisions included in budget resolutions is listed in the last column of Table 6. Some of these

procedural provisions include deferred enrollment; automatic second budget resolutions; special

budgetary treatment of certain activities, such as the sale of government assets; and more recently,

enforcement of a pay-as-you-go requirement in the Senate and limits on advance appropriations.

Consideration and Adoption of the

Budget Resolution

Floor consideration of the budget resolution differs in the House and Senate. Section 305 of the

Budget Act sets forth special procedures for the consideration of the budget resolution, generally

to expedite its consideration. The House, however, regularly adopts a special rule, a simple House

resolution, setting forth the terms for consideration of the measure. In particular, special rules

have been used for more than a decade to limit the offering of amendments to a few major

substitutes. Table 8 lists the special rules that provided for the consideration of budget resolutions

in the House.

In contrast, floor consideration in the Senate is governed by the procedures set forth in the Budget

Act. The procedures generally limit debate and prohibit certain amendments and motions.9

Table 8. Special Rules Providing for the Consideration

of Budget Resolutions in the House

Fiscal Year

Special Rule

Budget Resolution

Date Special Rule

Was Adopteda

Vote

1976

[none]

H.Con.Res. 218

—

1977

[none]

H.Con.Res. 611

—

H.Res. 515

[none]

H.Con.Res. 195b

H.Con.Res. 214

04-26-1977

—

400-1

—

1979

[none]

H.Con.Res. 559

—

1980

[none]

H.Con.Res. 107

—

1981

H.Res. 642

H.Res. 649c

H.Con.Res. 307

04-23-1980

04-30-1980

261-143

voice

1982

H.Res. 134

H.Con.Res. 115

04-30-1981

328-76

1978

The FY1983 budget resolution exempted legislation dealing with certain trust funds from its deferred enrollment

provision.

For a brief discussion of these procedures, see CRS Report 98-511, Consideration of the Budget Resolution.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Special Rule

Budget Resolution

Date Special Rule

Was Adopteda

Vote

1983

H.Res. 447

H.Res. 496

H.Con.Res. 345b

H.Con.Res. 352

05-21-1982

06-10-1982

voice

339-72

1984

H.Res. 144

H.Res. 243

H.Con.Res. 91

(conf. rept.)

03-22-1983

06-23-1983

230-187

voice

1985

H.Res. 476

H.Con.Res. 280

04-04-1984

302-89

1986

H.Res. 177

H.Res. 253

H.Con.Res. 152

S.Con.Res. 32

(conf. rept.)

05-22-1985

08-01-1985

273-141

voice

1987

H.Res. 397

H.Res. 455

H.Con.Res. 296b

H.Con.Res. 337

03-13-1986

05-14-1986

239-168

voice

1988

H.Res. 139

H.Res. 201

H.Con.Res. 93

(conf. rept.)

04-08-1987

06-23-1987

241-168

voice

1989

H.Res. 410

H.Res. 461

H.Con.Res. 268

(conf. rept.)

03-23-1988

05-26-1988

voice

1990

H.Res. 145

H.Con.Res. 106

05-03-1989

voice

1991

H.Res. 382

H.Res. 488

H.Res. 496d

H.Con.Res. 310

H.Con.Res. 310b

(conf. rept.)

H.Con.Res. 310

(conf. rept.)

04-26-1990

10-04-1990

10-06-1990

voice

339-94

285-105

1992

H.Res. 123

H.Res. 157

H.Con.Res. 121

(conf. rept.)

04-16-1991

05-22-1991

392-9

257-164

1993

H.Res. 386

H.Res. 463

H.Con.Res. 287

(conf. rept.)

03-04-1992

05-21-1992

239-183

253-160

1994

H.Res. 131

H.Res. 133e

H.Res. 145

H.Con.Res. 64

(conf. rept.)

03-17-1993

03-18-1993

03-31-1993

voice

251-172

250-172

1995

H.Res. 384

H.Res. 418

H.Con.Res. 218

(conf. rept.)

03-10-1994

05-05-1994

245-171

228-168

1996

H.Res. 149

H.Res. 175

H.Res. 309

H.Con.Res. 67

(conf. rept.)

H.Con.Res. 122b

05-17-1995

06-29-1995

12-19-1995

225-168

234-180

229-189

1997

H.Res. 435

H.Res. 450

H.Con.Res. 178

(conf. rept.)

05-16-1996

06-12-1996

227-196

232-190

1998

H.Res. 152

H.Res. 160

H.Con.Res. 84

(conf. rept.)

05-20-1997

06-05-1997

278-142

373-47

1999

H.Res. 455

H.Con.Res. 284

06-04-1998

216-197

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Special Rule

Budget Resolution

Date Special Rule

Was Adopteda

Vote

2000

H.Res. 131

H.Res. 137

H.Con.Res. 68

(conf. rept.)

03-25-1999

04-14-1999

228-194

221-205

2001

H.Res. 446

H.Res. 474

H.Con.Res. 290

(conf. rept.)

03-23-2000

04-13-2000

228-194

221-205

2002

H.Res. 100

H.Res. 134f

H.Res. 136

H.Con.Res. 83

(conf. rept.)

H.Con.Res. 83

(conf. rept.)

03-28-2000

05-08-2001

05-09-2001

282-130

409-1

218-208

2003

H.Res. 372

H.Con.Res. 353

03-05-2002

222-206

2004

H.Res. 151

H.Res. 191

H.Con.Res. 95

(conf. rept.)

03-20-2003

04-11-2003

voice

221-202

2005

H.Res. 574

H.Res. 649

H.Con.Res. 393

S.Con.Res. 95

(conf. rept.)

03-25-2004

05-19-2004

voice

220-204

2006

H.Res. 154

H.Res. 248

H.Con.Res. 95

(conf. rept.)

03-16-2005

04-28-2005

228-196

voice

2007

H.Res. 766g

H.Res. 817

H.Con.Res. 376

04-06-2006

05-17-2006

225-196

226-193

2008

H.Res. 275h

H.Res. 409

H.Con.Res. 99

S.Con.Res. 21

(conf. rept.)

03-28-2007

05-17-2007

229-197

225-194

2009

H.Res. 1036i

H.Res. 1214

H.Con.Res. 312

S.Con.Res. 70

(conf. rept.)

03-12-2008

05-21-2008

223-195

220-199

2010

H.Res. 305j

H.Res. 316

H.Res. 371

H.Con.Res. 85

S.Con.Res. 13

(conf. rept.)

04-01-2009

04-02-2009

04-28-2009

234-179

242-182

234-185

2011k

—

2012

H.Res. 223

H.Con.Res. 34

04-14-2011

243-181

2013

H.Res. 597

H.Con.Res. 112

03-28-2012

241-184

2014

H.Res. 122

H.Con.Res. 25

03-19-2013

224-189

2015

H.Res. 544

H.Con.Res. 96

04-08-2014

222-194

2016

H.Res. 163

H.Con.Res. 27

03-24-2015

237-180

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: A special rule is a simple resolution reported by the House Rules Committee to provide for

consideration of legislation by the House. This list includes first budget resolutions only.

a. No special rules were rejected.

b. The budget resolution was rejected. (See Table 3 in this report.)

c. The special rule provided for technical corrections of H.Res. 642.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

The special rule provided for consideration of a revised conference report (H.Rept. 101-820); the original

conference report (H.Rept. 101-802) was rejected. (See Table 3 in this report.)

The special rule provided for further consideration of H.Con.Res. 64.

The special rule provided for the recommittal of the conference report to the conference committee; two

pages reportedly were missing from the original printed conference report (H.Rept. 107-55).

H.Res. 766 provided for debate only.

The House also considered and adopted H.Res. 370, which provided for the consideration of S.Con.Res. 21,

as amended by the text of H.Con.Res. 99, as adopted by the House, in order to facilitate a conference with

the Senate on S.Con.Res. 21. The House adopted H.Res. 370 by a vote of 221-197 on May 8, 2007.

The House also considered and adopted H.Res. 1190, which provided for the consideration of S.Con.Res.

70, as amended by the text of H.Con.Res. 312, as adopted by the House, in order to facilitate a conference

with the Senate on S.Con.Res. 70. The House adopted H.Res. 1190 by a vote of 214-203 on May 14, 2008.

H.Res. 305 provided for debate only.

The House did not consider a budget resolution for FY2011. However, in lieu of the budget resolution, the

House agreed to a special rule (H.Res. 1500) that, upon its adoption, provided for the adoption of a “budget

enforcement resolution” (H.Res. 1493).

Amendments to the Budget Resolution

Amendments in the House

The House has considered an average of almost seven amendments per budget resolution.10 The

largest number of amendments considered was 45 in 1979; the largest number agreed to was 11

also in 1979. (The first FY1983 budget resolution also was amended 11 times, but it subsequently

was rejected.) Table 9 identifies the number of accepted and rejected amendments to budget

resolutions considered in the House. The amending activity in the House during the last few

decades is in marked contrast to the early years under the Budget Act. During the first eight years,

the House considered an average of 16 amendments per budget resolution, agreeing to an average

of four of them. In contrast, during the past 33 years, the House has considered very few

amendments to budget resolutions, averaging between two and three per budget resolution and

agreeing to even fewer of these. Of the 121 amendments considered by the House during this

time period, 5 have been adopted.

Table 9. Number of Amendments to Budget Resolutions Considered in the House

Amendmentsa

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Adopted

Rejected

Total

Success Rateb

1976

H.Con.Res. 218

50%

1977

H.Con.Res. 611

13%

1978

H.Con.Res. 195c

H.Con.Res. 214

60%

25%

1979

H.Con.Res. 559

19%

1980

H.Con.Res. 107

24%

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

The averages presented in this section are derived from all first budget resolutions considered on the House floor,

including those ultimately rejected by the House.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Amendmentsa

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Adopted

Rejected

Total

Success Rateb

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

50%

1983

H.Con.Res. 345c

H.Con.Res. 352

29%

50%

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

—

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

1986

H.Con.Res. 152

14%

1987

H.Con.Res. 296c

H.Con.Res. 337

—

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

25%

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

20%

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

25%

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

H.Con.Res. 122c

—

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

1999

H.Con.Res. 284

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

2003

H.Con.Res. 353

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

2005

H.Con.Res. 393

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

2007

H.Con.Res. 376

2008

H.Con.Res. 99

2009

H.Con.Res. 312

2010

H.Con.Res. 85

2011d

—

2012

H.Con.Res. 34

2013

H.Con.Res. 112

2014

H.Con.Res. 25

2015

H.Con.Res. 96

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Amendmentsa

Fiscal Year

Budget Resolution

Adopted

Rejected

Total

Success Rateb

2016

H.Con.Res. 27

17%

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: This list includes first budget resolutions only. The number of amendments in this table does not include

any amendments automatically agreed to upon the adoption of the special rule reported by the House Rules

Committee providing for the consideration of the budget resolution.

a. No amendments were withdrawn or ruled out of order.

b. “Success rate” is the percentage of amendments accepted.

c. The budget resolution was rejected. (See Table 3 in this report.)

d. The House did not consider a budget resolution for FY2011.

Contributing to this trend, the House special rule typically has allowed for consideration of only

amendments in the nature of a substitute to the budget resolution. For example, between 1983 and

2015 (for the FY1984-FY2016 budget resolutions), 117 of the 121 amendments to the budget

resolution made in order by the special rule were amendments in the nature of a substitute. Only

two of these 117 amendments in the nature of a substitute were agreed to; those two contained the

budget resolution text recommended by the House Budget Committee offered by its chair at the

time, Representative William H. Gray III and Representative Tom Price, respectively. Table 10

lists the amendments in the nature of a substitute to the budget resolution made in order by the

special rule.

Table 10. Amendments in the Nature of a Substitute to Budget Resolutions Made in

Order by a Special Rule in the House

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Amendment

Sponsor

Date

Vote

Disposition

1976

H.Con.Res. 218a

—

1977

H.Con.Res. 611a

—

1978

H.Con.Res. 195b

H.Con.Res. 214a

—

1979

H.Con.Res. 559a

—

1980

H.Con.Res. 107a

—

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

Obey

Ottinger

Holt

Rousselot

Latta

04-30-1980

05-01-1980

05-06-1980

201-213

70-336

164-246

191-218

175-242

rejected

1982

H.Con.Res. 115

Fauntroy

Obey

Latta

05-06-1981

05-07-1981

69-356

119-303

253-176

rejected

adopted

1983

H.Con.Res. 345c

Miller (CA)

Obey

Fauntroy

Rousselot

Latta

Aspin

Jones (OK)

05-24-1982

05-25-1982

05-27-1982

181-225

152-268

86-322

182-242

192-235

137-289

171-253

rejected

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Amendment

Sponsor

Date

Vote

Disposition

H.Con.Res. 352

Latta

Jones (OK)

06-10-1982

220-207

202-225

adopted

rejected

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

Lattad

—

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

Wirth

Dannemeyer

Roemer

Dixon

McHugh

MacKay

Latta

04-04-1984

04-05-1984

1-401

51-354

59-338

76-333

132-284

108-310

107-311

rejected

1986

H.Con.Res. 152

Dannemeyer

Pursell

Leland

Latta

05-22-1985

05-23-1985

39-382

87-335

54-361

102-329

rejected

1987

H.Con.Res. 296e

—

H.Con.Res. 337

Dannemeyer

Leland

Latta

05-15-1986

73-338

61-359

145-280

rejected

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

Gray (PA)

Dannemeyer

Dymally

04-09-1987

230-192

27-394

47-369

56-362

adopted

rejected

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

Dannemeyer

Porter

Penny

03-23-1988

75-347

64-354

27-394

rejected

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

Dannemeyer

Dellums

Kasich

Gephardt

05-04-1989

72-350

81-343

30-393

49-373

rejected

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

Kasich

Dannemeyer

Dellums

04-26-1990

05-01-1990

106-305

48-354

90-334

rejected

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

Dannemeyer

Kasich

Gradison

04-17-1991

79-332

114-303

89-335

rejected

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

Dannemeyer

Gradison

Towns

03-04-1992

03-05-1992

60-344

42-370

77-342

rejected

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

Kasich

Solomon

Mfume

03-18-1993

135-295

20-409

87-335

rejected

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

Frank (MA)

Solomon

Mfume

Kasich

03-10-1994

03-11-1994

105-313

73-342

81-326

165-243

rejected

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Amendment

Sponsor

Date

Vote

Disposition

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

Gephardt

Neumann

Payne (NJ)

05-18-1995

100-325

89-342

56-367

rejected

H.Con.Res. 122f

—

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

Payne (NJ)

Orton

Sabo

05-16-1996

63-362

130-295

117-304

rejected

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

Doolittle

Brown (CA)

Waters

Kennedy (MA)

Shuster

05-21-1997

119-313

91-339

72-358

123-306

214-216

rejected

1999

H.Con.Res. 284

Neumann

Spratt

06-05-1998

158-262

164-257

rejected

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

Coburn

Minge

Spratt

03-25-1999

2-426

134-295

173-250

rejected

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

Owens

DeFazio

Stenholm

Sununu

Spratt

03-23-2000

70-348

61-351

171-243

78-339

184-233

rejected

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

Kucinich

Stenholm

Flake

Spratt

03-28-2001

79-343

204-221

81-341

183-243

rejected

2003

H.Con.Res. 353

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

Hill

Toomey

Cummings

Spratt

03-20-2003

174-254

80-342

85-340

192-236

rejected

2005

H.Con.Res. 393

Cummings

Stenholm

Hensarling

Spratt

03-25-2004

119-302

183-243

116-309

194-232

rejected

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

Hensarling

Watt

Spratt

03-17-2005

102-320

134-292

165-264

rejected

2007

H.Con.Res. 376

Watt

Hensarling

Spratt

05-17-2006

05-18-2006

131-294

94-331

184-241

rejected

2008

H.Con.Res. 99

Kilpatrick

Woolsey

Ryan

03-29-2007

115-312

81-340

160-268

rejected

2009

H.Con.Res. 312

Kilpatrick

Lee (CA)

Ryan (WI)

03-13-2008

126-292

98-322

157-263

rejected

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Amendment

Sponsor

Date

Vote

Disposition

2010

H.Con.Res. 85

Woolsey

Jordan (OH)

Lee (CA)

Ryan (WI)

04-02-2009

84-348

111-322

113-318

137-293

rejected

2011g

—

2012

H.Con.Res. 34

Cleaver

Cooperh

Grijalva

Garrett

Van Hollen

04-15-2011

—

04-15-2011

103-303

—

77-347

119-136 (172 present)

166-259

rejected

—

rejected

2013

H.Con.Res. 112

Mulvaney

Cleaver

Cooper

Honda

Garrett

Van Hollen

03-28-2012

03-29-2012

0-414

107-314

38-382

78-346

136-285

163-262

rejected

2014

H.Con.Res. 25

Mulvaney

Scott (VA)

Grijalva

Woodall

Van Hollen

03-20-2013

154-261

105-305 (1 present)

84-327 (1 present)

104-132 (171 present)

165-253

rejected

2015

H.Con.Res. 96

Mulvaney

Moore

Grijalva

Woodall

Van Hollen

04-09-2014

04-10-2014

2-413

116-300

89-327

133-291

163-261

rejected

2016

H.Con.Res. 27

Ellison

Butterfield

Stutzman

Van Hollen

Price (GA)

03-25-2015

96-330

120-306

132-294

160-264

105-319

219-208

rejected

adopted

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: See Table 8 for a list of special rules providing for consideration of budget resolutions in the House. An

amendment in the nature of a substitute strikes all text after the resolving clause and replaces it with a different

text. This list includes first budget resolutions only. Text of the amendments may be found in the Congressional

Record and the report accompanying the special rule.

a. The budget resolution was not considered under a special rule.

b. The budget resolution was considered under an open rule (H.Res. 515); no specific amendments in the

nature of a substitute were made in order. H.Con.Res. 195 was rejected. (See Table 3 in this report.)

c. H.Con.Res. 345 was rejected. (See Table 3 in this report.)

d. The special rule (H.Res. 144) made in order an amendment in the nature of a substitute by, and if offered

by, Representative Latta, but he did not offer one.

e. The budget resolution was considered under a closed rule (H.Res. 397). H.Con.Res. 296 was rejected. (See

Table 3 in this report.)

The budget resolution was considered under a closed rule (H.Res. 309). H.Con.Res. 122 was rejected. (See

Table 3 in this report.)

g. The House did not consider a budget resolution for FY2011.

h. The special rule (H.Res. 223) made in order an amendment in the nature of a substitute by, and if offered

by, Representative Cooper, but he did not offer one.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Amendments in the Senate

In the Senate, the terms of debate and the consideration of amendments are not structured by a

special rule, as in the House, but instead are governed by the procedures set forth in Section

305(b) of the Budget Act. Typically, the Senate considers many amendments to the budget

resolution, most addressing specific issues instead of proposing a complete substitute as in the

House.

During the period between 1975 and 2015, the Senate considered an average of almost 54

amendments per budget resolution, agreeing to an average of 31 of these.11 The largest number of

amendments considered was 254 in 2015; the largest number agreed to was 146, also in 2015.

Table 11 identifies the number of amendments adopted, rejected, ruled out-of-order, and

withdrawn during Senate consideration of budget resolutions. In contrast to the House, the

number of amendments considered by the Senate has increased over the last two decades or so.

For the last 18 budget resolutions considered on the floor, for example, the Senate considered an

average of almost 90 amendments per budget resolution, agreeing to an average of over 56 of

these. Amendments have been agreed to in the Senate at a much higher rate compared to the

House as well. For instance, in 13 of the past 18 years in which a budget resolution was

considered on the floor, the success rate for amendments has equaled or exceeded 60%.

Table 11. Number of Amendments to Budget Resolutions Considered in the Senate

Amendments

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Adopted

(RC)

Rejected

(RC)

Fell on

Point of

Order

(RC)

1976

S.Con.Res. 32

1 (0)

4 (4)

5 (4)

20%

1977

S.Con.Res. 109

1 (0)

7 (7)

8 (7)

13%

1978

S.Con.Res. 19

5 (3)

2 (2)

7 (5)

71%

1979

S.Con.Res. 80

10 (10)

1980

S.Con.Res. 22

5 (4)

12 (12)

17 (16)

29%

1981

S.Con.Res. 86

12 (6)

30 (28)

42 (34)

29%

1982

S.Con.Res. 9b

4 (1)

31 (31)

1 (1)

41 (33)

10%

S.Con.Res. 19

2 (1)

17 (17)

20 (18)

10%

1983

S.Con.Res. 19

8 (1)

29 (27)

37 (28)

22%

1984

S.Con.Res. 27

7 (4)

24 (23)

31 (27)

23%

1985

S.Con.Res. 106

2 (0)

100%

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

15 (12)

24 (24)

39 (36)

38%

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

13 (5)

7 (7)

22 (12)

59%

1988

S.Con.Res. 49

5 (3)

8 (8)

15 (11)

33%

1989

S.Con.Res. 113

8 (4)

4 (4)

12 (8)

67%

Withdrawn

Total

(RC)

Success

Ratea

The averages presented in this section are derived from all first budget resolutions considered on the Senate floor.

Accordingly, they do not include the budget resolutions for FY2003 and FY2011, which were reported by the Senate

Budget Committee but did not receive floor consideration.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Amendments

Fiscal

Year

Budget

Resolution

Adopted

(RC)

Rejected

(RC)

Fell on

Point of

Order

(RC)

1990

S.Con.Res. 30

23 (2)

2 (2)

26 (4)

88%

1991

S.Con.Res. 110

1 (0)

100%

1992

S.Con.Res. 29

7 (0)

5 (5)

1 (1)

14 (6)

50%

1993

S.Con.Res. 106

15 (5)

3 (3)

2 (2)

21 (10)

71%

1994

S.Con.Res. 18

22 (15)

28 (28)

50 (43)

44%

1995

S.Con.Res. 63

26 (3)

9 (9)

39 (12)

67%

1996

S.Con.Res. 13

26 (11)

33 (33)

12 (12)

72 (56)

36%

1997

S.Con.Res. 57

41 (18)

21 (20)

2 (2)

66 (40)

62%

1998

S.Con.Res. 27

39 (6)

12 (12)

1 (1)

63 (19)

62%

1999

S.Con.Res. 86

57 (15)

8 (6)

12 (12)

106 (33)

54%

2000

S.Con.Res. 20

57 (5)

8 (7)

9 (6)

95 (18)

60%

2001

S.Con.Res. 101

38 (10)

10 (10)

5 (5)

56 (25)

68%

2002

H.Con.Res. 83c

51 (12)

10 (7)

2 (2)

66 (21)

77%

2003

S.Con.Res. 20d

—

2004

S.Con.Res. 23

44 (13)

35 (35)

2 (2)

82 (50)

54%

2005

S.Con.Res. 95

39 (5)

19 (17)

2 (2)

64 (24)

61%

2006

S.Con.Res. 18

48 (14)

24 (22)

73 (36)

66%

2007

S.Con.Res. 83

54 (9)

27 (25)

87 (34)

62%

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

63 (7)

24 (24)

1 (1)

91 (32)

69%

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

88 (16)

20 (20)

4 (4)

113 (40)

78%

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

101 (15)

17 (17)

3 (3)

121 (35)

83%

2011

S.Con.Res. 60e

—

2012f

—

2013g

—

2014

S.Con.Res. 8

77 (14)

29 (28)

4 (4)

114 (46)

68%

2015h

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

146 (31)

20 (20)

6 (6)

254 (58)

57%

Withdrawn

Total

(RC)

Success

Ratea

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: This list includes first budget resolutions only. This table does not include motions to recommit offered

during the consideration of the budget resolution. “RC” refers to the number of amendments on which a rollcall vote occurred in relation to the amendment. For purposes of this table, roll-call votes in relation to an

amendment to the budget resolution include roll-call votes on agreeing to an amendment, on a motion to table

an amendment, and on a motion to waive a point of order against an amendment.

“Success rate” is the percentage of amendments accepted.

b. The budget resolution was adopted by the Senate on April 2, 1981, by a vote of 88-10; no further action

was taken.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

The Senate Budget Committee did not mark up or report a budget resolution for FY2002. Instead, the

Senate considered the House-passed budget resolution after the Senate Budget Committee was discharged

from its consideration.

The Senate Budget Committee reported the listed FY2003 budget resolution, but the full Senate did not

consider it.

The Senate Budget Committee reported the listed FY2011 budget resolution, but the full Senate did not

consider it.

The Senate did not consider a budget resolution for FY2012; on May 25, 2011, the Senate rejected motions

to proceed to four different budget resolutions for FY2012.

The Senate did not consider a budget resolution for FY2013; on May 16, 2012, the Senate rejected motions

to proceed to five different budget resolutions for FY2013.

The Senate did not consider a budget resolution for FY2015.

Timing of Action on the Budget Resolution

The Budget Act sets April 15 as a target date for completing action on the annual budget

resolution. Table 12 lists the dates of final adoption of budget resolutions for FY1976-FY2015.

During this period, Congress adopted the budget resolution by the target date only six times, most

recently in 2003 with the FY2004 budget resolution. Under the original timetable (prior to 1986,

the deadline was May 15), Congress adopted the annual budget resolution by the target date

twice: in 1975 and 1976. After the target date was changed to April 15 by the 1985 Deficit

Control Act, Congress has completed action on the budget resolution by the target date four

times: in 1993, 1999, 2000, and 2003. Further, as noted above, Congress did not complete action

on a budget resolution for nine fiscal years, most recently for FY2015.

Table 12. Dates of Final Adoption of the Budget Resolution

Fiscal Year

Date Adopted

Fiscal Year

1976

05-14-1975

1997

06-13-1996

1977

05-13-1976

1998

06-05-1997

1978

05-17-1977

1999

[none]

1979

05-17-1978

2000

04-15-1999

1980

05-24-1979

2001

04-13-2000

1981

06-12-1980

2002

05-10-2001

1982

05-21-1981

2003

[none]

1983

06-23-1982

2004

04-11-2003

1984

06-23-1983

2005

[none]

1985

10-01-1984

2006

04-28-2005

1986

08-01-1985

2007

[none]

1987

06-27-1986

2008

05-17-2007

1988

06-24-1987

2009

06-05-2008

1989

06-06-1988

2010

04-29-2009

1990

05-18-1989

2011

[none]

1991

10-09-1990

2012

[none]

1992

05-22-1991

2013

[none]

1993

05-21-1992

2014

[none]

Congressional Research Service

Date Adopted

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Fiscal Year

Date Adopted

Fiscal Year

Date Adopted

1994

04-01-1993

2015

[none]

1995

05-12-1994

2016

05-05-2015

1996

06-29-1995

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

In those years in which Congress has adopted a budget resolution (that is, not including FY1999,

FY2003, FY2005, FY2007, and FY2011 through FY2015), it has adopted the budget resolution

an average of 36 days after the target date. The FY1991 budget resolution was adopted the latest,

on October 9, 1990, or 177 days after the target date. The earliest adoption of a budget resolution

was for FY1994 on April 1, 1993, or 14 days before the target date. Table 13 and Table 14

provide a list of dates related to the consideration and adoption of the budget resolution in the

House and the Senate, respectively.

Table 13. Timing of House Action on Budget Resolutions

Typea

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

1976

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 32)

first

04-30-1975

05-01-1975

05-14-1975

H.Con.Res. 466

(S.Con.Res. 76)

second

11-11-1975

11-12-1975

12-12-1975

S.Con.Res. 109

(H.Con.Res. 611)

first

04-27-1976

04-29-1976

05-13-1976

S.Con.Res. 139

(H.Con.Res. 728)

second

09-08-1976

09-09-1976

09-16-1976

S.Con.Res. 10

(H.Con.Res. 110)

third

02-22-1977

02-23-1977

03-03-1977

S.Con.Res. 19

(H.Con.Res. 214)

first

05-05-1977

05-17-1977

H.Con.Res. 341

(S.Con.Res. 43)

second

09-07-1977

09-08-1977

09-15-1977

S.Con.Res. 80

(H.Con.Res. 559)

first

05-02-1978

05-10-1978

05-17-1978

H.Con.Res. 683

(S.Con.Res. 104)

second

08-15-1978

08-16-1978

09-21-1978

H.Con.Res. 107

(S.Con.Res. 22)

first

04-30-1979

05-14-1979

05-24-1979

S.Con.Res. 53

(H.Con.Res. 186)

second

11-28-1979

—b

1977

1978

1979

1980

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Typea

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

1981

H.Con.Res. 307

(S.Con.Res. 86)

first

04-23-1980

05-07-1980

06-12-1980

H.Con.Res. 448

(S.Con.Res. 119)

second

11-18-1980

11-20-1980

H.Con.Res. 115

(S.Con.Res. 19)

first

04-30-1981

05-07-1981

05-20-1981

S.Con.Res. 50

(H.Con.Res. 230)

second

12-10-1981

—c

1983

S.Con.Res. 92

(H.Con.Res. 352)

—

06-10-1982

06-22-1982

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

(S.Con.Res. 27)

—

03-22-1983

03-23-1983

06-23-1983

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

04-04-1984

04-05-1984

10-01-1984

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

(H.Con.Res. 152)

—

05-22-1985

05-23-1985

08-01-1985

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

(H.Con.Res. 337)

—

05-14-1986

05-15-1986

06-26-1986

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

(S.Con.Res. 49)

—

04-08-1987

04-09-1987

06-23-1987

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

(S.Con.Res. 113)

—

03-23-1988

05-26-1988

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

(S.Con.Res. 30)

—

05-03-1989

05-04-1989

05-17-1989

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

(S.Con.Res. 110)

—

04-25-1990

05-01-1990

10-08-1990

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

(S.Con.Res. 29)

—

04-16-1991

04-17-1991

05-22-1991

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

03-04-1992

03-05-1992

05-21-1992

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

(S.Con.Res. 18)

—

03-17-1993

03-18-1993

03-31-1993

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 63)

—

03-10-1994

03-11-1994

05-05-1994

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

(S.Con.Res. 13)

—

05-17-1995

05-18-1995

06-29-1995

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

(S.Con.Res. 57)

—

05-15-1996

05-16-1996

06-12-1996

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

(S.Con.Res. 27)

—

05-20-1997

05-21-1997

06-05-1997

1999

H.Con.Res. 284

(S.Con.Res. 86)

—

06-04-1998

06-05-1998

—

1982

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Typea

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

(S.Con.Res. 20)

—

03-25-1999

04-14-1999

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

(S.Con.Res. 101)

—

03-23-2000

04-13-2000

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

(no companion measure)d

—

03-27-2001

03-28-2001

05-09-2001

2003

H.Con.Res. 353

(S.Con.Res. 100)

—

03-20-2002

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 23)

—

03-20-2003

03-21-2003

04-11-2003

2005e

S.Con.Res. 95

(H.Con.Res. 393)

—

03-24-2004

03-25-2004

05-19-2004

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 18)

—

03-16-2005

03-17-2005

04-28-2005

2007

H.Con.Res. 376

(S.Con.Res. 83)

—

04-06-2006

05-18-2006

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

(H.Con.Res. 99)

—

03-28-2007

03-29-2007

05-17-2007

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

(H.Con.Res. 312)

—

03-12-2008

03-13-2008

06-05-2008

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

(H.Con.Res. 85)

—

04-01-2009

04-02-2009

04-29-2009

2011f

(S.Con.Res. 60)

—

2012

H.Con.Res. 34

(no companion measure)

—

04-14-2011

04-15-2011

—

2013

H.Con.Res. 112

—

03-28-2012

03-29-2012

—

2014

S.Con.Res. 8

(H.Con.Res. 25)

—

03-19-2013

03-21-2013

—

2015

H.Con.Res. 96

(no companion measure)

—

04-08-2014

04-10-2014

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

(H.Con.Res. 27)

—

03-24-2015

03-25-2015

04-30-2015

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: Unless otherwise indicated, no date in the conference report column indicates that Congress did not

complete action on the budget resolution for that year.

a. For purposes of this table, “type” refers to whether the budget resolution was the first, second, or third for

the fiscal year. Originally, the Budget Act provided for the annual adoption of two budget resolutions for a

fiscal year and the option of additional budget resolutions. In 1985, the act was amended to eliminate the

second budget resolution; the option of additional budget resolutions remains.

b. The House rejected its version of the budget resolution (see Table 3 of this report) and adopted the

Senate’s version; no conference report was necessary.

c. The House laid its version of the budget resolution on the table by unanimous consent and adopted the

Senate’s version; no conference report was necessary.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

The Senate Budget Committee did not mark up or report a budget resolution for FY2002. Instead, the

Senate considered the House-passed budget resolution after the Senate Budget Committee was discharged

from its consideration.

Congress did not complete action on a budget resolution for FY2005. The House agreed to the conference

report on S.Con.Res. 95, May 19, 2004; the Senate did not consider it.

The House did not consider a budget resolution for FY2011.

Table 14. Timing of Senate Action on Budget Resolutions

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

1976

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 32)

first

04-29-1975

05-01-1975

05-14-1975

H.Con.Res. 466

(S.Con.Res. 76)

second

11-19-1975

11-20-1975

12-11-1975

S.Con.Res. 109

(H.Con.Res. 611)

first

04-08-1976

04-12-1976

05-12-1976

S.Con.Res. 139

(H.Con.Res. 728)

second

09-08-1976

09-09-1976

09-15-1976

S.Con.Res. 10

(H.Con.Res. 110)

third

02-21-1977

02-22-1977

03-03-1977

S.Con.Res. 19

(H.Con.Res. 214)

first

05-02-1977

05-04-1977

05-13-1977

H.Con.Res. 341

(S.Con.Res. 43)

second

09-07-1977

09-09-1977

09-15-1977

S.Con.Res. 80

(H.Con.Res. 559)

first

04-24-1978

04-26-1978

05-15-1978

H.Con.Res. 683

(S.Con.Res. 104)

second

08-25-1978

09-06-1978

09-23-1978

H.Con.Res. 107

(S.Con.Res. 22)

first

04-23-1979

04-25-1979

05-23-1979

S.Con.Res. 53

(H.Con.Res. 186)

second

11-16-1979

—b

H.Con.Res. 307

(S.Con.Res. 86)

first

05-05-1980

05-12-1980

06-12-1980

H.Con.Res. 448

(S.Con.Res. 119)

second

11-18-1980

11-19-1980

11-20-1980

H.Con.Res. 115

(S.Con.Res. 19)

first

05-07-1981

05-12-1981

05-21-1981

S.Con.Res. 50

(H.Con.Res. 230)

second

12-08-1981

12-09-1981

—b

S.Con.Res. 92

(H.Con.Res. 352)

—

05-14-1982

05-21-1982

06-23-1982

1977

1978

1979

1980

1981

1982

1983

Congressional Research Service

Typea

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

1984

H.Con.Res. 91

(S.Con.Res. 27)

—

05-02-1983

05-19-1983

06-23-1983

1985

H.Con.Res. 280

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

05-18-1984

09-26-1984

1986

S.Con.Res. 32

(H.Con.Res. 152)

—

04-25-1985

05-09-1985

08-01-1985

1987

S.Con.Res. 120

(H.Con.Res. 337)

—

04-21-1986

05-01-1986

06-27-1986

1988

H.Con.Res. 93

(S.Con.Res. 49)

—

04-28-1987

05-06-1987

06-24-1987

1989

H.Con.Res. 268

(S.Con.Res. 113)

—

04-11-1988

04-14-1988

06-06-1988

1990

H.Con.Res. 106

(S.Con.Res. 30)

—

05-02-1989

05-04-1989

05-18-1989

1991

H.Con.Res. 310

(S.Con.Res. 110)

—

06-14-1990

10-09-1990

1992

H.Con.Res. 121

(S.Con.Res. 29)

—

04-23-1991

04-25-1991

05-22-1991

1993

H.Con.Res. 287

(S.Con.Res. 106)

—

04-07-1992

04-10-1992

05-21-1992

1994

H.Con.Res. 64

(S.Con.Res. 18)

—

03-17-1993

03-25-1993

04-01-1993

1995

H.Con.Res. 218

(S.Con.Res. 63)

—

03-22-1994

03-25-1994

05-12-1994

1996

H.Con.Res. 67

(S.Con.Res. 13)

—

05-18-1995

05-25-1995

06-29-1995

1997

H.Con.Res. 178

(S.Con.Res. 57)

—

05-15-1996

05-23-1996

06-13-1996

1998

H.Con.Res. 84

(S.Con.Res. 27)

—

05-20-1997

05-23-1997

06-05-1997

1999

H.Con.Res. 284

(S.Con.Res. 86)

—

03-27-1998

04-02-1998

—

2000

H.Con.Res. 68

(S.Con.Res. 20

—

03-24-1999

03-25-1999

04-15-1999

2001

H.Con.Res. 290

(S.Con.Res. 101)

—

04-04-2000

04-07-2000

04-13-2001

2002

H.Con.Res. 83

(no companion measure)c

—

04-02-2001

04-06-2001

05-10-2001

2003

H.Con.Res. 353

(S.Con.Res. 100)

—

2004

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 23)

—

03-18-2003

03-26-2003

04-11-2003

Congressional Research Service

Typea

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Date

Consideration

Began

Date of Initial

Passage

Date

Conference

Report

Adopted

Fiscal

Year

Budget Resolution

(Companion Measure)

2005

S.Con.Res. 95

(H.Con.Res. 393)

—

03-08-2004

03-12-2004

—

2006

H.Con.Res. 95

(S.Con.Res. 18)

—

03-14-2005

03-17-2005

04-28-2005

2007

H.Con.Res. 376

(S.Con.Res. 83)

—

03-13-2006

03-16-2006

—

2008

S.Con.Res. 21

(H.Con.Res. 99)

—

03-20-2007

03-23-2007

05-17-2007

2009

S.Con.Res. 70

(H.Con.Res. 312)

—

03-10-2008

03-14-2008

06-04-2008

2010

S.Con.Res. 13

(H.Con.Res. 85)

—

03-30-2009

04-02-2009

04-29-2009

2011d

S.Con.Res. 60

(no companion measure)

—

2012e

(H.Con.Res. 34)

—

2013f

(H.Con.Res. 112)

—

2014

S.Con.Res. 8

(H.Con.Res. 25)

—

03-20-2013

03-23-2013

—

2015

(H.Con.Res. 96)

—

2016

S.Con.Res. 11

(H.Con.Res. 27)

—

03-23-2015

03-27-2013

05-05-2015

Typea

Source: Legislative Information System (LIS).

Notes: Unless otherwise indicated, no date in the conference report column indicates that Congress did not

complete action on the budget resolution for that year.

a. For purposes of this table, “type” refers to whether the budget resolution was the first, second, or third for

the fiscal year. Originally, the Budget Act provided for the annual adoption of two budget resolutions for a

fiscal year and the option of additional budget resolutions. In 1985, the act was amended to eliminate the

second budget resolution; the option of additional budget resolutions remains.

b. The House adopted the Senate’s version of the budget resolution; no conference report was necessary.

c. The Senate Budget Committee did not mark up or report a budget resolution for FY2002. Instead, the

Senate considered the House-passed budget resolution after the Senate Budget Committee was discharged

from its consideration.

d. The Senate Budget Committee reported the listed FY2003 budget resolution, but the full Senate did not

consider it.

e. The Senate did not consider a budget resolution for FY2012; on May 25, 2011, the Senate rejected motions

to proceed to four different budget resolutions for FY2012.

The Senate did not consider a budget resolution for FY2013; on May 16, 2012, the Senate rejected motions

to proceed to five different budget resolutions for FY2013.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Appendix. Modifications to the Procedures and

Requirements Pertaining to the Development,

Content, and Consideration of the Budget

Resolution

Full Employment and Balanced Growth Act of 1978 (“Humphrey-Hawkins Act”; P.L. 95523; 92 Stat. 1887-1908; October 27, 1978)



Called for a period of up to four hours for debate on economic goals and

priorities following the presentation of opening floor statements on the budget

resolution.

Temporary Increase in the Public Debt Limit (P.L. 96-5; 93 Stat. 8; April 2, 1979)



Mandated that the President’s budget and the Budget Committees’ reported

budget resolution for FY1981 and FY1982 be in balance. (Provision was

repealed in 1982.)

Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit Control Act of 1985 (Title II of P.L. 99-177; 99

Stat. 1038-1101; December 12, 1985)12



Required Congress to complete action on a budget resolution by April 15 of each

year (deadline moved from May 15).

Eliminated the requirement that Congress adopt a second budget resolution

annually by September 15.

Formalized the practice of adopting a three-year budget resolution, with the

second and third fiscal years non-binding. (Current law requires budget

resolutions to cover at least five fiscal years.)

Called for off-budget entities, except Social Security, to be included in the budget

resolution and the President’s budget.

Formalized the practice of including credit authority (direct and guaranteed

loans) in the budget resolution.

Mandated that neither chamber may consider a budget resolution, amendment to

a budget resolution, or conference report on a budget resolution that recommends

a deficit amount greater than the applicable maximum deficit amount established

in the 1985 Balanced Budget Act.

Excluded Social Security from budget totals, except for purposes of calculating

the deficit in order to determine if sequestration is required. The budget

resolution may contain two deficit totals: one with Social Security and one

without.

For more information on changes made by the 1985 Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit Control Act, see CRS

Report 86-713, Changes in the Congressional Budget Process Made by the 1985 Balanced Budget Act (P.L. 99-177);

and CRS Report 85-1130, Explanation of the Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit Control Act of 1985 – P.L. 99177 (The Gramm-Rudman-Hollings Act), both available from the author.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

Budget Enforcement Act (BEA) of 1990 (Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation

Act of 1990; P.L. 101-508; 104 Stat. 1388-573 through 630; November 5, 1990)13



Added language to the Budget Act allowing the option to include pay-as-you-go

procedures for the Senate and House in the budget resolution (Sections 301(b)(7)

and 301(b)(8)).

Required that the budget resolutions for FY1991-FY1995 cover five fiscal years.

(Current law permanently requires at least five fiscal years; see BEA of 1997

below.)

In the Senate, prohibited the consideration of a reported budget resolution calling

for a reduction in Social Security surpluses.

Changed deadline for submitting views and estimates reports from “on or before

February 25 of each year” to “within 6 weeks after the President submits a

budget.”

Added language to the Budget Act allowing the option of including Social

Security outlays and revenues in the budget resolution for purposes of Senate

enforcement.

In the Senate, created a point of order that prohibits the consideration of any

budget resolution that would exceed any of the discretionary spending limits.

(Initially, this point of order was added to the Budget Act as a temporary Section

(601(b)); the BEA of 1997 permanently added this point of order to the Budget

Act as Section 312(b) and applied the point of order to any legislation.)

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993 (Title XIV of P.L. 103-66; 107 Stat. 683-685;

August 10, 1993)



Extended through FY1998 the BEA requirement that budget resolutions cover

five fiscal years.

Budget Resolution for FY1995 (H.Con.Res. 218; 103rd Congress; May 12, 1994)14



Made permanent a temporary modification found in the budget resolutions for

FY1993 and FY1994, which applied Section 301(i) to a budget resolution at any

stage of consideration. Section 301(i) of the Budget Act prohibits the Senate from

considering any reported budget resolution that would decrease the excess of

Social Security revenues over Social Security outlays for any of the fiscal years

covered by the resolution, subject to a three-fifths waiver requirement. This

creates a “firewall” to protect Social Security balances.

Budget Enforcement Act of 1997 (Title X of P.L. 105-33; 111 Stat. 677-712; August 5, 1997)15



Permanently required the budget resolution to cover at least five fiscal years.

Made optional rather than mandatory the inclusion of total direct loan obligation

and total primary loan guarantee commitment levels in the budget resolution and

the accompanying report.

See CRS Report 90-520, Budget Enforcement Act of 1990: Brief Summary, available from the author.

Although budget resolutions, which are agreed to in the form of a concurrent resolution, do not have the force of law,

they can contain changes in congressional budget procedures.

For more information on changes made by the Budget Enforcement Act of 1997, see CRS Report 97-931, Budget

Enforcement Act of 1997: Summary and Legislative History.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information



Modified the optional contents of the budget resolution to include special pay-asyou-go procedures in the Senate pertaining to the use of reserve funds.

Allowed the Budget Committees to set an alternative deadline for committees to

submit their views and estimates instead of the usual deadline of within six

weeks after the President submits a budget.

Applied the Senate point of order against a budget resolution recommending a

decrease in the projected surplus in the Social Security trust funds to all its

legislative stages.

Budget Resolution for FY2000 (H.Con.Res. 68; 106th Congress; April 15, 1999)



Created a point of order that prohibited consideration of a revised FY2000 or a

FY2001 budget resolution setting forth an on-budget deficit for any fiscal year

(i.e., excluding any surplus resulting from the Social Security trust fund). The

provision did not apply if the deficit for a fiscal year resulted solely from

legislation that made structural programmatic reforms to enhance retirement

security.

Budget Resolution for FY2001 (H.Con.Res. 290; 106th Congress; April 13, 2000)



Applied the point of order against budget resolutions setting forth an on-budget

deficit for any fiscal year (see FY2000 budget resolution) to a revised FY2001 or

a FY2002 budget resolution. The provision would not apply if the economy

experienced low growth in two consecutive quarters or if a declaration of war

was in effect.

Specified that amendments that contain predominately “precatory” language,

such as sense-of-the-Senate amendments, are not germane, effectively

prohibiting such amendments to budget resolutions and reconciliation legislation.

Budget Resolution for FY2004 (H.Con.Res. 95; 108th Congress; April 11, 2003)



Extended through September 30, 2008, the three-fifths vote requirement in the

Senate to waive and to sustain an appeal of a ruling of the chair on certain points

of order specified in Sections 904(c)(2) and 904(d)(3) of the Budget Act.

Budget Resolution for FY2006 (H.Con.Res. 95; 109th Congress; April 28, 2005)



Extended through September 30, 2010, the three-fifths vote requirement in the

Senate to waive and to sustain an appeal of a ruling of the chair on certain points

of order specified in Sections 904(c)(2) and 904(d)(3) of the Budget Act.

House Rule XXI, Clause 7 (H.Res. 6; 110th Congress; January 5, 2007)



Created a point of order against the consideration of a budget resolution

containing budget reconciliation directives having a net effect of reducing the

surplus or increasing the deficit. (Clause was modified at the beginning of the

112th Congress; see below.)

Budget Resolution for FY2008 (S.Con.Res. 21; 110th Congress; May 17, 2007)



Extended through September 30, 2017, the three-fifths vote requirement in the

Senate to waive and to sustain an appeal of a ruling of the chair on certain points

of order specified in Sections 904(c)(2) and 904(d)(3) of the Budget Act.

Congressional Research Service

Congressional Budget Resolutions: Historical Information

House Rule XXI, Clause 7 (H.Res. 5; 112th Congress; January 5, 2011)



Modified the rule to prohibit the consideration of a budget resolution containing

reconciliation directives that would result in budget reconciliation legislation that

would cause a net increase in direct spending (i.e., mandatory spending) over the

period of the budget resolution.

Separate Order in House for 113th Congress (Section 3(e) of H.Res. 5; 113th Congress;

January 3, 2013)



Created a requirement that the budget resolution (as well as any amendments

thereto and any conference report thereon) include for means-tested direct

spending and non-means-tested direct spending the following information: (1)

the average growth rate (in terms of outlays) for the 10 years preceding the

budget year; (2) estimates under current law for the period covered by the budget

resolution; and (3) information on proposed reforms. (This requirement was

extended to the 114th Congress by Section 3(h) of H.Res. 5, 114th Congress,

January 6, 2015.)

Budget Resolution for FY2016 (S.Con.Res. 11; 114th Congress; May 5, 2015)



Extended through September 30, 2025, the three-fifths vote requirement in the

Senate to waive and to sustain an appeal of a ruling of the chair on certain points

of order specified in Sections 904(c)(2) and 904(d)(3) of the Budget Act.

Author Contact Information

(name redacted)

Analyst on Congress and the Legislative Process

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

, 7-....

Acknowledgments

Several analysts, including former CRS employees, assisted in compiling the information in this report and

contributed to its development. The current author, however, assumes responsibility for its current content.

Key Policy Staff

Area of Expertise

Name

Phone

Congressional budget procedure

(name redacted)

7-....

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

Congressional budget procedure

(name redacted)

7-....

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

Congressional budget procedure

Megan Suzanne Lynch

7-....

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

Congressional budget procedure

(name redacted)

7-....

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

Information research specialist

(name redacted)

7-....

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov

Congressional Research Service

EveryCRSReport.com

The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the

Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on

issues that may come before Congress.

EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The

reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to

the public.

Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts

who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made

any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.

CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in

the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without

permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a

third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or

otherwise use copyrighted material.

Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public

understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in

connection with CRS' institutional role.

EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.