U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Congressional research reportFeb 18, 2014
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards:
Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
(name redacted)
Specialist in Industrial Organization and Business
(name redacted)
Analyst in Environmental Policy
February 18, 2014
Congressional Research Service
7-....
www.crs.gov
R43399
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Summary
In March 2013, President Obama notified Congress that his Administration would seek a
comprehensive Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) with the European Union
(EU). In addition to addressing tariffs and other trade restrictions, the negotiations seek to reduce
regulatory barriers to transatlantic commerce. Among the barriers under discussion are those
affecting motor vehicles. Although many automakers build and sell cars in both regions, they
must comply with very different safety, fuel economy, and emissions standards, as well as
different regulatory processes. TTIP negotiators are seeking to identify ways to narrow the
regulatory differences, potentially reducing costs and spurring additional trade in vehicles. U.S.
and EU automakers support this initiative, which they see as furthering economic and vehicle
design trends already under way. The complexity of complying with different greenhouse gas
emissions regulations is also a factor in the industry’s support.
This report looks at ways in which TTIP might lead to a convergence of motor vehicle regulatory
regimes on both sides of the Atlantic. These regimes govern three distinct aspects of vehicle
manufacturing and involve a number of U.S. and EU agencies.
•
Safety. U.S. automakers self-certify that they are meeting U.S. vehicle standards.
In Europe, vehicles must obtain “type approval” from a government before an
automaker can bring out a new model.
•
Emissions. U.S. and EU emissions regulations are administered by the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the European Commission (EC),
respectively. While U.S. and EC rules address a similar range of pollutants,
including carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, and non-methane organic oxides,
allowable emissions levels in the EU are different from those in the United
States—and they are stricter in more than a dozen U.S. states than in the other
states. The United States and the EU have similar “type approval” systems for
new engine models.
•
Fuel Efficiency. Auto manufacturers selling in the United States must meet the
Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards enforced by the National
Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Under the Obama
Administration, greenhouse gases (GHG) in vehicle emissions are being
regulated for the first time, making fuel economy standard-setting a joint venture
between NHTSA and EPA. The EU does not directly set fuel economy standards,
but it effectively does so by regulating greenhouse gas emissions of new vehicles.
There are several different ways a TTIP agreement could promote convergence of automobile
regulation, from harmonizing existing U.S. and EU rules to providing for mutual recognition of
some or all automotive standards. If a TTIP agreement is reached, it will be subject to
congressional approval. To the extent that such an agreement would require changes in motor
vehicle regulatory processes or standards, it is possible that Congress will be asked to modify
statutes that govern motor vehicle safety, emissions, and fuel economy.
Congressional Research Service
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Contents
Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 1
U.S.-EU Vehicle Trade..................................................................................................................... 3
How the United States and the EU Set Standards ............................................................................ 5
Safety Standards ........................................................................................................................ 6
Evolution of U.S. Safety Standards ..................................................................................... 6
The U.S. Approval Process ................................................................................................. 8
EU Vehicle Safety Regulation ............................................................................................. 8
The EU Approval Process ................................................................................................. 10
Emissions Standards ................................................................................................................ 11
Evolution of U.S. Vehicle Emission Standards ................................................................. 11
U.S. Vehicle Emission Standards and Implementation ..................................................... 13
U.S. Certification and Test Procedures.............................................................................. 14
EU Vehicle Emission Standards ........................................................................................ 14
Comparison of U.S. and EU Vehicle Emission Standards ................................................ 15
Fuel Economy and Greenhouse Gas Emission Standards ....................................................... 16
U.S. Standards Process ...................................................................................................... 16
EU Standards Process........................................................................................................ 18
Comparison of U.S. and EU GHG and Fuel Economy Standards .................................... 18
The Role of Nongovernmental Organizations (NGOs) ........................................................... 20
Recent Efforts for Regulatory Convergence .................................................................................. 20
Pathways to Convergence .............................................................................................................. 21
Figures
Figure 1. Major Global Auto Producing Regions ............................................................................ 3
Figure 2. Major EU Vehicle Producers ............................................................................................ 4
Figure 3. Emissions Standards for Selected Pollutants in the United States and EU .................... 16
Figure 4. Comparison of Historical and Proposed U.S. and EU Fuel Economy Standards
for Light-Duty Vehicles .............................................................................................................. 19
Tables
Table 1. Comparison of Major U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Regulatory Differences ...................... 2
Table A-1. U.S. Emission Standards for Light Duty Gasoline Vehicles ........................................ 25
Table A-2. Evolution of EU Emission Standards for Passenger Cars ............................................ 26
Table A-3. MY2016-MY2025 Combined Passenger Car and Light Truck
GHG and CAFE Standards ......................................................................................................... 27
Table A-4. EU Light Duty Vehicle GHG Targets........................................................................... 28
Congressional Research Service
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Appendixes
Appendix. Detailed Comparison of U.S. and EU Vehicle Emissions Standards ........................... 24
Contacts
Author Contact Information........................................................................................................... 28
Congressional Research Service
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Introduction
In November 2011, President Obama and leaders of the European Union (EU) named a High
Level Working Group on Jobs and Growth to recommend steps to broaden transatlantic economic
ties. In its final report, issued in February 2013, the working group called for a new bilateral
agreement to govern transatlantic trade and investment. Such an agreement, the working group
urged, should provide for “the promotion of more compatible approaches to current and future
regulation and standard-setting and other means of reducing non-tariff barriers to trade.”1
One month later, President Obama notified Congress that the United States would enter into
negotiations with the EU to seek a free trade agreement, referred to as the Transatlantic Trade and
Investment Partnership (TTIP). The negotiations, the President wrote, would
seek greater compatibility of U.S. and EU regulations and related standards development
processes, with the objective of reducing costs associated with unnecessary regulatory
differences and facilitating trade, inter alia by promoting transparency in the development
and implementation of regulations and good regulatory practices, establishing mechanisms
for future progress, and pursuing regulatory cooperation initiatives where appropriate.2
The formal TTIP negotiations began in July 2013.3 Motor vehicle safety and emissions standards
are areas where the United States and the EU could break new ground.4 Trade in vehicles and
parts between the United States and the EU reached $57 billion in 2012,5 and numerous
companies manufacture on both sides of the Atlantic. The major U.S. and European motor vehicle
manufacturer associations have called for TTIP to provide for mutual recognition of existing
technical standards and the creation of a U.S.-EU process for harmonization of future vehicle
regulations. Such steps, an industry alliance has contended, would “increase trade, lower costs,
create jobs and improve the international competitiveness of the industry” in both North America
and Europe.6 The alliance estimates that current non-tariff barriers on vehicles are equivalent to a
26% tariff on vehicle imports. It projects that elimination of tariffs7 and just 10% of non-tariff
1
U.S.-EU High Level Working Group on Jobs and Growth, Final Report, February 11, 2013, http://trade.ec.europa.eu/
doclib/docs/2013/february/tradoc_150519.pdf, p. 2.
2
Letter from Demetrios Marantis, Acting United States Trade Representative, to Honorable John Boehner, Speaker of
the U.S. House of Representatives, March 20, 2013, http://www.sice.oas.org/TPD/USA_EU/Negotiations/
03202013_TTIP_Notification_Letter.PDF.
3
For general information on the negotiations, see CRS Report R43158, Proposed Transatlantic Trade and Investment
Partnership (TTIP): In Brief, by (name redacted) and (name redacted).
4
President Obama issued Executive Order 13563 on January 18, 2011, laying out guidelines for pursuit of international
regulatory cooperation, http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2012/05/01/executive-order-promotinginternational-regulatory-cooperation.
5
Joint statement of the American Automotive Policy Council (AAPC) and European Automobile Manufacturers’
Association (ACEA), U.S-EU Automotive Regulatory Convergence, and statement of the Alliance of Automobile
Manufacturers, at the U.S.-EU High Level Regulatory Cooperation Stakeholders Forum, Washington, DC, April 11,
2013, p. 6, http://www.uschamber.com/sites/default/files/grc/AAPCACEA%20Joint%20Presentation%20at%20Regulatory%20Cooperation%20Forum%20April%2011,%202013%20FIN
AL%20PDF.pdf and http://www.autoalliance.org/index.cfm?objectid=EFFAD010-A2AD-11E2-9CE9000C296BA163.
6
Ibid., p. 4.
7
The U.S. tariff on passenger cars is 2.5%, and on pickup trucks, 25%. The EU tariff is 10% on passenger cars and
22% on pickup trucks, http://usitc.gov/publications/docs/tata/hts/bychapter/1301c87.pdf (for U.S. tariff schedule) and
http://export.gov/logistics/eg_main_018130.asp (for EU tariff schedule).
Congressional Research Service
1
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
barriers could raise U.S. vehicle and parts exports to the EU by over 200% and EU parts and
vehicle exports to the United States by 71%.8
Safety, fuel efficiency, and emissions standards differ between the two regions (see Table 1), due
to historical differences in producer and consumer preferences as well as the role of government
in industry practices. The United States and the EU have different standards even for an item as
simple as a seat belt. Some of these differences may reflect past efforts to protect domestic
vehicle industries against foreign competition, and others may result from different legal
traditions or divergent views as to the best way of achieving goals such as cleaner air and reduced
oil consumption.
Table 1. Comparison of Major U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Regulatory Differences
United States
Self-certification for safety regulations
European Union
•
Type approval for safety regulations
•
Government labs used for all testing
•
Type approval for emissions
•
•
Mutual recognition of regulations by other countriesa
Government sets fleet fuel economy standards
•
•
Fuel economy standard (miles/gallon)
In 2016
34.1
n/a
In 2020
38.9
n/a
•
•
Nitrogen oxides (NOx)
.07
.10/.29b
Non-methane organic gases (NMOG)
.09
.11/.14b
Carbon monoxide (CO)
4.2
0.8
Greenhouse gases (GHG, in 2016)
250
208
Greenhouse gases (GHG, in 2020)
213
152
FTPc
NEDCd
Government sets emissions standards
Emissions standards for pollutants (grams/mile):
Form of vehicle emission testing
Source: CRS analysis.
Notes: In the EU, gasoline and diesel standards differ.
a.
Through UNECE, the EU provides mutual recognition to other countries. The United States does not.
b.
Gasoline and diesel standards.
c.
Federal Test Procedure, described later in the report.
d.
New European Drive Cycle.
8
AAPC and ACEA, U.S.-EU Automotive Regulatory Convergence, U.S.-EU High Level Regulatory Cooperation
Stakeholders Forum, Washington, DC, April 11, 2013, p. 8.
Congressional Research Service
2
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Past auto agreements have been effective in leading to a more globalized auto industry. The 1965
motor vehicle agreement between the United States and Canada and the 1994 North American
Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) removed barriers to trade and cross-border trade in autos and
established a more regional motor vehicle industry in the process. The Trans-Pacific Partnership,
a separate negotiation involving the United States and 11 other Pacific Rim countries, could have
a similar effect. With respect to the auto industry, TTIP represents another effort to extend these
regional templates to encompass a greater share of trade and investment.
U.S.-EU Vehicle Trade
The EU and the United States are the second- and third-largest vehicle producers in the world
(see Figure 1), together accounting for nearly one-third of global auto production. In 2012, the
EU 279 produced more than the United States—16.2 million vehicles compared to 10.3 million.10
Sales in each region were about the same in 2012: 14.8 million vehicles sold in the United States
and 14.3 million in the EU. The remainder of EU production was exported, much of it to the U.S.
market.
Figure 1. Major Global Auto Producing Regions
million cars and commercial vehicles, 2012
Other 28.4
World Total, 2012:
84.1 million cars and
commercial vehicles
United States
10.3
Japan 9.9
EU-27 16.2
China 19.3
Source: International Organisation of Motor Vehicle Manufacturers, “World Motor Vehicle Production by
Country and Type,” http://www.oica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/total-production-2012.pdf.
Note: “Other” includes Mexico and Canada.
9
The 28th country to join the EU was Croatia on July 1, 2013. Data cited in this report cover the EU 27. For a full list
of EU members, see http://europa.eu/about-eu/countries/.
10
China produced over 19 million vehicles in 2012.
Congressional Research Service
3
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Seventeen of the EU member states manufacture vehicles. Germany is by far the largest auto
producer within the EU (see Figure 2). The five top countries—Germany, Spain, France, United
Kingdom and Czech Republic—manufacture more than 76% of all vehicles produced in the EU.
In the United States, vehicles are manufactured in 15 states.11
Figure 2. Major EU Vehicle Producers
million cars and commercial vehicles, 2012
EU Total, 2012:
16.6 million cars and
commercial vehicles
Other 0.9
Romania 0.3
Belgium 0.5
Germany 5.7
Poland 0.7
Italy 0.7
Slovakia 0.9
Spain 2.0
Czech
Republic 1.2
United Kingdom
1.6
France 2.0
Source: International Organisation of Motor Vehicle Manufacturers, “World Motor Vehicle Production by
Country and Type.”
Note: OICA data for France are for 2011.
Unlike some consumer goods, such as computers and apparel, most vehicles are sold in the region
where they are produced because of local consumer preferences and vehicle standards. In 2012,
imports constituted about 20% of U.S. sales,12 and about 17% of sales in the EU.13
In some cases, a vehicle that is entirely legal in one country may not be sold in another due to
differing fuel efficiency, safety, and emissions standards, unless the manufacturer is willing to
make major investments to bring the vehicle into compliance. For example, Ford Motor
Company’s ECOnetic high-efficiency diesel engine, made in Great Britain, gets up to 71 miles
per gallon (mpg) of fuel. This engine is not sold in North America because it does not comply
with U.S. and Canadian emissions standards. Ford has determined that expanding its Mexican
11
Alabama, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri,
Ohio, Tennessee, Texas and South Carolina. Automotive News data. U.S. imports are vehicles made outside of North
America.
12
Automotive News data. U.S. imports are vehicles made outside of North America.
13
EU data is for 2011. David Coffin, Passenger Vehicles: Industry and trade Summary, U.S. International Trade
Commission, Publication ITS-09, Washington, DC, May 2013, p. 62, http://www.usitc.gov/publications/332/
working_papers/pub_ITS_09_PassengerVehiclesSummary5211.pdf.
Congressional Research Service
4
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
engine plant to make a redesigned version of the ECOnetic for North America would cost $350
million, and it does not believe consumer demand justifies the expenditure. 14
Increasingly, however, auto manufacturers and their parts suppliers have sought to organize their
production on a global basis. The German automaker BMW, as an example, produces sport utility
vehicles for markets worldwide from a plant in South Carolina. Greater commonality in
regulation would make it easier for automakers and parts makers to coordinate production across
major markets. This is consistent with individual companies’ efforts to reduce costs with new
design and production plans, such as the following:
•
Reducing platforms. Automakers are developing global vehicle platforms15 that
will reduce the number of models sold around the world, while consolidating
suppliers and cutting costs. For example, the new Jeep Cherokee and Dodge Dart
are based on Fiat’s Compact Wide platform.16 The Ford Focus was developed in
Europe but is built with similar components in the United States, China,
Germany, Russia, and Thailand and sold in 130 countries.17
•
Joining forces to meet tightening world emission standards. Many countries,
including the United States, have adopted new standards that will be costly for
manufacturers to meet. Automakers have responded by creating partnerships to
develop more powerful batteries, multispeed transmissions, techniques to
improve engine efficiency, and other technological advances.18 Along these lines,
BMW and Toyota have agreed to jointly develop fuel cell technology.19
•
Growing U.S. interest in diesel-powered vehicles. About half of all the
passenger cars sold in Europe have diesel engines, which are more efficient than
gasoline engines and emit a lower level of some greenhouse gases. Many
automakers believe that offering diesels (as well as higher-performing gasoline,
electric, and hybrid vehicles) will be necessary to meet higher U.S. fuel
efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions standards currently projected between
now and 2025. Having similar standards for diesel engines in the two regions
could reduce design and manufacturing costs.
How the United States and the EU Set Standards
The processes by which the United States and the EU establish vehicle safety, fuel efficiency, and
emission standards have evolved in different ways. In the United States, private standards and
state regulation prevailed until the 1960s and 1970s, when federal legislation was passed. Since
14
Darren Quick, “Ford’s Most Fuel Efficient Passenger Car Ever,” Gizmag, March 25, 2012,
http://www.gizmag.com/ford-fiesta-econetic-technonlogy/21943/.
15
A vehicle platform is the core architecture in a vehicle. Global platforms will include the use of the same or similar
components and subsystems, such as a steering rack. The automakers’ supply chains may change as well to supply
global platforms, with suppliers providing similar parts for vehicles manufactured in North America, Europe, Asia and
Latin America.
16
David Sedgwick, “Global Platforms Prompting Supplier Shakeout,” Automotive News, August 6, 2013.
17
David Kiley, “Why Ford Focus is the New No. 1 Car in the World,” AOL Autos, April 10, 2013.
18
Jeff Bennett and David Pearson, “Car Makers Join Forces to Pare Exhaust Gases,” Wall Street Journal, January 25,
2013.
19
“Peugeot and GM Change Alliance Plan,” Euronews, December 20, 2012.
Congressional Research Service
5
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
then, Congress has delegated vehicle regulation to federal agencies, occasionally providing
specific direction through legislation. In Europe, a system of governmental control over autos was
more prevalent, first in each country and later through the EU. EU directives passed by the
European Parliament have the force of regulations, thereby vesting the legislators with a more
direct role in the regulatory process than is the case in the United States.
Safety Standards
Evolution of U.S. Safety Standards
In the early decades of the automobile, U.S. vehicles were lightly regulated by a combination of
state and private sector standards. While one industry magazine called for national motor vehicle
standards as early as 1902, it did so mainly to reassure would-be buyers of the structural integrity
these new, little-understood machines.20 Writing about this era, one author noted that
Regulating either driver conduct or vehicle design at the national level did not conform to
existing political ideas about the appropriate federal division of responsibilities or to
contemporary jurisprudential understandings of the federal government’s constitutional
power to regulate interstate commerce.... The only useful and politically acceptable action
Congress might take was to help the states and localities construct more and better roads.21
The Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE), a professional association founded in 1905, became
the primary source of vehicle safety and emission rules for many decades.22 State governments
often used SAE recommendations to enact requirements for vehicle equipment, such as dual
brakes, headlamps, and windshield wipers. Other SAE standards were adopted directly by
manufacturers.
The first step toward a nationwide system of vehicle regulation came in 1926, when a voluntary
Uniform Vehicle Code was drafted to replace the many different state rules.23 Among other
things, the code specified the types of lighting, reflectors, brakes, mirrors, and tires that cars
should have.24 These ideas were widely accepted by the states: by 1946, 30 of the then 48 states
(plus the District of Columbia) had adopted the Uniform Vehicle Code; 13 had implemented
portions and only six had taken no action.25
20
The industry publication Horseless Age called for national vehicle standard because so many small producers were
making vehicles with “scores of design characteristics” and the public had a limited understanding of these new
vehicles that did not use a horse for mobility. Jerry Mashaw and David Harfst, The Struggle for Auto Safety
(Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), p. 29.
21
Ibid., pp. 30 and 31.
22
SAE standards are proposed and vetted through committees that include academics, government and industry
representatives, and consultants. Standards that emerge are based on consensus of the committee members and
adherence is voluntary for automakers. SAE currently has over 8,000 volunteer members and 550 committees. Over
2,000 of its motor vehicle standards are active and current with the past five years. CRS interview with Jack Pokrzywa
of SAE, July 12, 2013.
23
J. Allen Davis, The California Vehicle Code and Uniform Vehicle Code, Vol. 14, Hastings Law Journal, 1963, pp.
377-390. The National Conference on Street and Highway Safety (NCSHS) called for the changes and Public Roads
Administration, Uniform Act Regulating Traffic on Highways, Act V of the Uniform Vehicle Code, 1945, pp. 30-46.
24
Public Roads Administration, Uniform Act Regulating Traffic on Highways, Act V of the Uniform Vehicle Code,
1945, pp. 30-46.
25
The state-by-state survey was conducted by a presidential Highway Safety Conference; the Code was updated and
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
6
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
With the start of the Interstate Highway system in the 1950s, greater automobile travel, and rising
highway deaths, the interest in vehicle safety grew. Between 1962 and 1964, Congress passed
three safety bills into law, including a seat belt regulation.26 These laws set the stage for more
ambitious legislation a few years later. For example, the legislation establishing safety
requirements for federal fleet vehicles led to the promulgation of 17 standards by 1966,
prompting some in Congress to question why similar standards did not apply to vehicles
purchased by average consumers.27
The most significant change in U.S. vehicle safety regulation came with the National Traffic and
Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966.28 Senator Abraham Ribicoff, one of the advocates of the new
legislation, said during floor debate that “this problem is so vast that the Federal Government
must have a role. It is obvious the 50 states cannot individually set standards for the automobiles
that come into those 50 States from a mass production industry.”29 Curtailing auto-related
highway deaths was a major impetus.30
As passed unanimously by both houses of Congress and signed by President Johnson, the
legislation had two parts:
•
the Highway Safety Act of 1966 mandated that each state put in place a highway
safety program in accordance with federal standards that would include
improving driver performance, accident records systems and traffic control; and
•
the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966 directed the Secretary
of Commerce (later changed to the Secretary of Transportation when that agency
was established in 1967) to issue safety standards for all motor vehicles
beginning in January 1967. A National Traffic Safety Agency was established to
carry out the provisions; it was renamed the National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration (NHTSA) in 1970.31
Senator Warren Magnuson, chairman of the Commerce Committee, argued that Congress was
implementing a limited type of regulation, saying in his floor statement,
(...continued)
reissued in 1956 and 1962. J. Allen Davis, The California Vehicle Code and Uniform Vehicle Code, Vol. 14, Hastings
Law Journal, 1963.
26
PL 87-637 required hydraulic brake fluid used in motor vehicles to meet certain standards established by the
Secretary of Commerce; PL 88-201 required the Secretary of Commerce to promulgate safety standards for seat belts,
and PL 88-514 required vehicle manufacturers to meet certain minimum safety standards for vehicles sold to the
General Services Administration (GSA) for the federal fleet.
27
Jerry Mashaw and David Harfst, The Struggle for Auto Safety (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), p.
61.
28
P.L. 89-563. Ralph Nader, whose 1965 book Unsafe at Any Speed: The Designed-in Dangers of the American
Automobile (New York: Grossman Publishers) argued that cars were unnecessarily unsafe and that the auto industry
should be regulated by a federal agency. Also influential was the report Accidental Death and Disability: The
Neglected Disease of Modern Society (Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences, 1966), which documented the
impact of accidental injuries, including those by motor vehicles. http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=9978.
29
Congressional Record, vol. 112, part I (June 24, 1966), p. S14232.
30
Upon signing the new law, President Johnson cited the 50,000 people killed on U.S. highways as the biggest cause of
death and injury among young Americans. The White House, “Remarks of the President at Signing of the Highway
Safety Act and the Traffic Safety Act,” press release, September 9, 1966, cited in National Traffic and Motor Vehicle
Safety Act of 1966, Legislative History, Vol. 1, p. 31, published by NHTSA in 1985.
31
Highway Safety Act of 1970, P.L. 91-605.
Congressional Research Service
7
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
The committee also recognizes that the broad powers conferred upon the Secretary, while
essential to achieve improved traffic safety, could be abused in such a manner as to have
serious adverse effects on the automotive manufacturing industry. The committee is not
empowering the Secretary to take over the design and manufacturing functions of private
industry. The committee expects that the Secretary will act responsibly and in such a way as
to achieve a substantial improvement in the safety characteristics of vehicles.32
The U.S. Approval Process
Since it was established, NHTSA has issued dozens of safety standards,33 and it maintains an
extensive database on vehicle crashes.34 However, the agency neither approves motor vehicles or
parts as complying with its standards nor collects information from manufacturers as to
compliance. The law puts the onus for enforcement of federal standards on automakers
themselves. It provides that “A manufacturer or distributor of a motor vehicle or motor vehicle
equipment shall certify to the distributor or dealer at delivery that the vehicle or equipment
complies with applicable motor vehicle safety standards prescribed under this chapter....
Certification of a vehicle must be shown by a label or tag permanently fixed to the vehicle ...”35
The law also makes manufacturers responsible for testing of vehicles and liable for recalls and
penalties if they are later found not to meet NHTSA’s standards. After a new model is in the
market, NHTSA buys vehicles from dealers and tests them at its own facilities to determine
whether they comply with current standards. If NHTSA determines there is noncompliance, it can
encourage the manufacturer to recall the model to correct the problem or can order a recall.36
EU Vehicle Safety Regulation
In contrast to the U.S. system of self-certification, the comparable EU vehicle system is based on
government regulatory approval in advance of manufacturing.
Until the 1950s, European vehicle safety regulations developed separately in each country.37
Interest in harmonizing vehicle regulation emerged as part of the process of European economic
32
Sen. Warren Magnuson, “Traffic Safety Act of 1966,” Remarks in the Senate, Congressional Record, vol. 112, part I
(June 24, 1966), p. S14222.
33
Standards include regulations affecting windshield wipers, hood latches, tires, brakes, seat belts and fuel economy.
All NHTSA (and EPA) regulatory actions follow the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946 (APA, 5 U.S.C. §551 et
seq.) which ensures that proposed rulemaking is publicized in the Federal Register, comments are taken and considered
and agency decisions are clearly explained. Court review of standards is allowed. Revisions to federal regulations must
also follow the APA. For a summary of NHTSA standards, see http://www.nhtsa.gov/staticfiles/ ... /pdf/FMVSSQuickRefGuide-HS811439.pdf.
34
NHTSA’s work in compiling data about vehicle crashes, fatalities and injuries has become an international resource
for traffic safety research. According to NHTSA, no other country has a similar database. Marine Moguen-Toursel,
“Emergence and Transfer of Vehicle Safety Standards: Why We Still Do Not Have Global Standards,” Center for
Historical Research, Ohio State University, vol. 5 (2007), p. 4 and CRS interview with NHTSA officials, June 2013.
35
P.L. 89-563, 49 U.S.C. §30115.
36
Vann Wilbur and Paul Eichbrecht, “Transatlantic Trade, the Automotive Sector: The Role of Regulation in a Global
Industry, Where We Have Been and Where We Need to Go, How Far Can EU-US Cooperation Go Toward Achieving
Regulatory Harmonization,” German Marshall Fund Academic Policy Research Conference, Ann Arbor, MI, May 8,
2008, pp. 8-9.
37
European vehicle standards could be quite different from each other. For example, until the early 1990s, a French
standard required yellow headlights while other European countries had standardized on white headlights. David W.
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
8
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
integration.38 The European vehicle regulatory regime now includes both EU directives, which
must be implemented by all member states, and standards promulgated through a United Nations
(UN) organization, which may be implemented at the discretion of a national government.
United Nations Agreement
In 1952, the United Nations (U.N.) established the Working Party on the Construction of
Vehicles—known as Working Party 29 or WP. 29—a subsidiary body of the Inland Transport
Committee of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE).39 The objective
of WP.29 is to “initiate and pursue actions aimed at the worldwide harmonization or development
of technical regulations for vehicles.”40 WP.29 administers a 1958 agreement on vehicle
construction and two related agreements which were adopted by some European countries to
promote EU-wide integration of vehicle design, construction and safety.41 UNECE standards deal
with vehicle safety, environmental protection, fuel efficiency, and anti-theft performance.
Signatories to the 1958 U.N. agreement42 commit to mutual recognition of approvals for vehicle
components, so that a component approved for use in one signatory country will be automatically
approved in all others. UNECE regulations do not cover the whole vehicle, only its parts. WP.29’s
voting members are limited to government representatives, but automakers, trade associations,
and other nongovernmental organizations also participate in its meetings.
The United States did not sign the 1958 UNECE agreement because it would require mutual
recognition of standards generated outside the United States. After U.S. self-certification began in
1967, the UNECE approach was seen as incompatible with the U.S. process.43 Because the
United States remained outside of UNECE, many U.S.-made vehicles could not be exported to
many countries without modifications.44
However, the United States did sign a 1998 UNECE agreement which establishes global technical
regulations (GTRs), effectively transforming the U.N. body into an organization with a global
approach now called the World Forum for Harmonization of Vehicle Regulations.45 It
(...continued)
Moore, Headlamp History and Harmonization, The University of Michigan, Transportation Research Institute,
UMTRI-98-21, Ann Arbor, MI, June 1998, p. 9.
38
The 1957 Treaty of Rome established the European Economic Community, often called the Common Market.
39
WP.29 is the regulatory and administrative entity that oversees UNECE activities and agreements, much like
NHTSA and EPA administer U.S. vehicle laws and regulations. In March 2000, as its membership expanded beyond
Europe, WP.29 became the “World Forum for Harmonization of Vehicle Regulations (WP.29).” U.S. representatives
from NHTSA and EPA regularly attend WP.29 meetings.
40
UNECE website, http://www.unece.org/trans/main/wp29/faq.html.
41
The 1958 agreement was revised in 1995 to promote the participation of non-European countries. UNECE website,
http://www.unece.org/trans/main/wp29/faq.html.
42
All signatories were European countries until 1995 when the agreement was changed to allow non-UNECE
members. http://www.unece.org/trans/main/wp29/faq.html.
43
UNECE website, http://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/trans/main/wp29/WP29-FAQ-2005.pdf.
44
Marine Moguen-Toursel, “Emergence and Transfer of Vehicle Safety Standards: Why We Still Do Not Have Global
Standards,” Center for Historical Research, Ohio State University, vol. 5 (2007), p. 8.
45
The 1998 UNECE agreement was in part the result of the Transatlantic Business Dialogue (TABD) established
between the United States and EU in 1995. Vann Wilbur and Paul Eichbrecht, Transatlantic Trade, the Automotive
Sector: The Role of Regulation in a Global Industry, Where We Have Been and Where We Need to Go, How Far Can
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
9
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
promulgates regulations affecting vehicle safety, environmental protection, energy efficiency, and
anti-theft performance. Unlike the 1958 agreement, there is no requirement for type approval and
mutual recognition of approvals. GTRs are issued in a UN Global Registry and contracting
parties use their own regulatory process to implement them.46
EU Directives
Alongside UNECE, the European Economy Community (renamed the European Community in
1993) and its successor, the EU, have sought to promote a single European market in motor
vehicles. Tariffs on cars traded between member states were eliminated in 1968.47 In 1970, the
European Community enacted a framework48 that laid the basis for vehicle approval
harmonization across all member states.
Initially, European working groups on vehicle safety issues based their work on U.S. standards
and practice because the United States had established a federal safety program earlier.49 It has
been suggested that one reason for the slow development of European standards (and hence
reliance on the UNECE standards process) was that some European automakers “preferred to
limit the extension of standards to those that would create obstacles to the invasion of foreign
vehicles into their national markets.”50 Over time, the balance shifted to favor more similarity
between U.S. and EU standards.51
The EU Approval Process
Since 1970, the EU has used the Whole Vehicle Type Approval system, under which production
samples of new model cars must be approved by national government authorities prior to the
vehicle entering the market.52 An automaker must submit the “type” of vehicle it intends to
manufacture and sell to the proper authority in any country that is a signatory to the 1958 UNECE
agreement. All EU member states enforce the EU standards. EU member states may choose
which UNECE standards they wish to incorporate into their national regulations. Unlike the
(...continued)
EU-US Cooperation Go Toward Achieving Regulatory Harmonization, German Marshall Fund Academic Policy
Research Conference, Ann Arbor, MI, May 8, 2008, p. 14.
46
Since 1998, 13 GTRs have been agreed to, including regulations for vehicle door locks, test procedures for
compression-ignition engines, and off-cycle emissions testing, UNECE, http://www.unece.org/trans/main/wp29/
wp29wgs/wp29gen/wp29glob_registry.html.The U.S. approval process for a GTR shows the limitations of
harmonization. A GTR for door locks was proposed in 2004, but NHTSA did not adopt the GTR as proposed. Its public
hearings produced comments urging changes, and NHTSA incorporated changes it its final rule. UNECE then changed
its GTR to align with the U.S. modifications. This process took over eight years. http://www.unece.org/fileadmin/
DAM/trans/main/wp29/wp29wgs/wp29gen/wp29registry/ECE-TRANS-180a1am1app1e.pdf.
47
EU website, “Ten Historic Steps,” http://europa.eu/abc/12lessons/lesson_2/index_en.htm.
48
Directive 70/156/EEC. The goal of EU regulation was initially to further remove internal barriers to the trade in
goods and hence the level of environmental protection was secondary. Roland Stephen, Vehicle of Influence: Building a
European Car Market (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2000), pp. 67 and.92.
49
Ibid., p. 5.
50
Ibid., p. 17.
51
Ibid.
52
The process of introducing such a system for trucks and buses is currently under way. Prior to 1970, there was no
whole vehicle Type Approval; automakers needed to seek approval for each component addressed by a standard.
Congressional Research Service
10
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
UNECE standards, the EU system applies to a complete vehicle, often taking into account the
UNECE standards promulgated for specific auto parts.
Nearly every EU country has either a government agency or designated privately-owned test
houses that conduct testing to ensure new models will meet all standards. Once formal approval is
obtained, the automaker then issues a “certificate of conformity” for each vehicle manufactured,
attesting that it conforms to the approved type.53 Once an EU member state approves a new
vehicle, it can be marketed throughout the EU.54
The EU agreed in 2007 that the UNECE regulations would be incorporated into the EU typeapproval procedure.55 Legislative work at the EU level is led by European Commission’s
Directorate of Enterprise and Industry. Vehicle safety promotion is also pursued by the European
Commission through initiatives such as DG Transport’s EU road safety action program and DG
Information and Society’s E-safety and Intelligent Car initiatives.
Emissions Standards
Evolution of U.S. Vehicle Emission Standards56
Programs to address air pollution in the United States originated in the first half of the twentieth
century and were accelerated after World War II. A critical aspect of the air quality problem in
urban areas has been ground-level ozone production, commonly referred to as “smog.”
Independent analysis in the mid-1950s57 identified the automobile as a key source of ground-level
ozone. Research has since demonstrated that cars and other mobile sources are responsible for a
variety of other air pollutants, including carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbons (HC), nitrogen
oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), air toxics, and greenhouse gases (GHG). Emissions of
hydrocarbons and NOx from motor vehicles are responsible for contributing to the formation of
ground-level ozone.58 Further, motor vehicles represent the largest domestic source of air toxics,
or pollutants known or suspected to cause cancer or other serious health or environmental
effects.59 Finally, vehicles have been determined to contribute approximately one quarter of
53
EU, “EC type-approval system for motor vehicles,” http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/internal_market/
single_market_for_goods/motor_vehicles/motor_vehicles_technical_harmonisation/n26100_en.htm.
54
An EU member state that challenges a vehicle’s compliance with regulations is required to raise the alleged
discrepancy with the government that certified it. The certifying government then works with the manufacturer to
address the issue.
55
EU Directive 2007/46/EC, http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=
OJ:L:2007:263:0001:0160:EN:PDF.
56
This historical summary is drawn, in part, from National Research Council, Committee on State Practices in Setting
Mobile Source Emissions Standards, State and Federal Standards for Mobile Source Emissions (Washington, DC:
National Academies Press, 2006).
57
Haagen-Smit, A.J., and M.M. Fox. “Photochemical ozone formation with hydrocarbons and automobile exhaust,” J.
Air Pollut. Control Assoc., vol. 4 (1954), pp. 105-109.
58
For more detail on ozone pollution, see EPA’s website at http://www.epa.gov/air/ozonepollution/.
59
Summaries of research on mobile source air pollutants and explanations of the findings can be found in literature
published by EPA’s Office of Transportation and Air Quality, http://www.epa.gov/otaq/, as well as in various CRS
reports.
Congressional Research Service
11
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
domestic GHG emissions,60 which trap heat in the earth’s atmosphere, contributing to global
climate change.61
The federal government first addressed air pollution in 1955 in the Federal Air Pollution Control
Act, which provided funding to state and local governments to “protect the primary
responsibilities and rights of the state and local governments in controlling air pollution.”62 In
1959, California became the first state to address pollution from cars with legislation directing the
state Department of Public Health to establish air quality standards and necessary controls for
motor vehicle emissions. Following California’s lead, in 1960 Congress directed the Surgeon
General to study the “various substances discharged from the exhausts of motor vehicles.”63
This regulatory pattern continued throughout the 1960s, as California authorities established
control requirements and the U.S. government followed suit a few years later. For example,
California required the control of crankcase emissions in 1961and set the first HC and CO
emissions regulations in 1964. The federal Motor Vehicle Air Pollution Control Act of 1965
adopted both the California crankcase and tailpipe emissions standards for 1968 model-year
vehicles.64 This act engaged the federal government for the first time in the actual regulation of
vehicle emissions.65
Congress’s provision for national emissions standards was based primarily on testimonies by the
Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) and the automotive industry about the
potential problems that would be created for vehicle manufacturers by divergent state standards.66
Congress strengthened federal authority in 1967 by explicitly preempting states from adopting or
enforcing new motor vehicle emission standards in the Air Quality Act of 1967.67 This
preemption provision (with California as the sole exemption) remains in effect today as Section
209(a) of the Clean Air Act (CAA).68
60
Transportation contributed 28% of domestic GHG emission in 2011, as reported by EPA’s Inventory of Greenhouse
Gases and Sinks. For more detail, see http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/usinventoryreport.html.
61
This section focusses on conventional pollutants. Greenhouse gas emission standards are surveyed in the section on
“Fuel Economy Standards.”
62
P.L. 84-159.
63
P.L. 86-493.
64
P.L. No. 89-272, §202(a), 79 Stat. 992, [1965].
65
Section 202 of the 1965 law authorized the federal government to set “standards, applicable to the emission of any
kind of substance, from any class or classes of new motor vehicles or new motor vehicle engines.” Congress delegated
this new standard-setting authority to the U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW). The U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) would not be established until five years later.
66
Testimony of James M. Quigley, Assistant Secretary of HEW, Hearings before the Subcommittee on Air and Water
Pollution of the Senate Comm. on Public Works, 89th Cong., 1st Sess. 33, 1965.
67
P. L. 90-148, §208, 81 Stat. 485, 501 [1967]. After hearings on this legislation, the Senate found that divergent state
standards would result in economic disruption and increased costs to consumers (S.Rept. 403, 90th Cong., 1st Sess. 33
[1967]). The House elaborated that the nature of motor vehicle manufacturing required the consistency and certainty
that could be provided only by uniform federal standards (H.Rept. 728, 90th Cong., 1st Sess. 21 [1967]).
68
42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq.
Congressional Research Service
12
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
U.S. Vehicle Emission Standards and Implementation69
At present, the federal government manages vehicle emissions controls, although the state of
California remains a major force in shaping national legislation and regulations. Emission
standards for engines and vehicles, including emission standards for greenhouse gases, are
currently established by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. EPA authority to regulate
vehicle emissions—and air quality in general—is based on the Clean Air Act.70 As with safety
regulations, the development of vehicle emission standards by EPA is in accordance with the
federal rulemaking process. New regulations are first published as proposed rules, and following
a period of public discussion may be withdrawn, approved, or amended before entering into
force.
Current EPA emissions standards for vehicles (referred to as “Tier 2” requirements) regulate CO,
NOx, PM, and HC emissions.71 Under the Tier 2 regulation, the same emission standards apply to
all vehicle weight categories, (i.e., cars, minivans, light-duty trucks, and SUVs have the same
emission limit). Further, the same emission limits apply to all vehicles regardless of the fuel they
use. While a number of U.S. states have a significant legal basis in advancing emissions
regulations to aid in their attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS),
California is the only state vested by the CAA with the authority to develop its own emission
regulations if EPA grants the state a waiver. California emission standards are administered by the
California Air Resources Board, a regulatory body within the California Environmental
Protection Agency. The CAA allows other states a choice between implementing federal emission
standards or adopting the California requirements.72
The evolution of U.S. emission standards for light-duty, gasoline-fueled vehicles is traced in
Table A-1of the Appendix. “Tier 2” standards—the current regulatory regime—have been in
place since 2004. EPA announced proposed Tier 3 standards on March 29, 2013.73 In addition to
exhaust emission standards, U.S. regulations address many other emission-related issues.74
69
Title II of the CAA covers a wide variety of “mobile sources,” including vehicles, engines, and equipment, and
applies to either “on-road” or highway sources such as cars and trucks and “nonroad” (also called “off-road”) sources
such as construction and farm equipment. On-road and nonroad sources are further divided into such categories as
“light duty vehicles” and “heavy duty vehicles.” This discussion focusses on “light duty vehicles,” principally
passenger cars and light trucks.
70
P.L. 88-206, and as amended (most recently in 1990).
71
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “Control of Air Pollution from New Motor Vehicles: Tier 2 Motor Vehicle
Emissions Standards and Gasoline Sulfur Control Requirements,” 65 Federal Register 6698-6870, February 10, 2000;
as codified in 40 CFR Part 86, “Control of Emissions from New and In-use Highway Vehicles and Engines.”
72
States that have adopted California Clean Car Standards include New Jersey, Connecticut, Washington, Vermont,
New York, Maine, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Oregon, Arizona, Pennsylvania, Maryland, New Mexico, Florida, and
the District of Columbia. These standards include the California LEV II and GHG emission standards. For further
information on the Clean Air Act and California vehicle emission regulations, see CRS Report RL30853, Clean Air
Act: A Summary of the Act and Its Major Requirements, by (name redacted) and (name redacted).
73
Links to the proposed Tier 3 standards and related materials are on EPA’s website at http://www.epa.gov/otaq/
tier3.htm.
74
The regulations include control of evaporative emissions, fuel vapor emissions from vehicle refueling, emissions
durability requirements, emissions warranty, in-use surveillance of emissions performance, and recall of vehicles found
not to be in compliance. Regulations that require on-board diagnostic systems that detect and identify malfunctioning
emission systems or equipment have also been implemented.
Congressional Research Service
13
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
U.S. Certification and Test Procedures
Anyone wishing to sell an engine or vehicle within the United States must demonstrate
compliance with the CAA and all applicable EPA regulations. This approval process differs from
the self-certification used by NHTSA and is closer to the EU type approval system for safety and
emissions regulations.
Once EPA sets emission standards for a particular engine and/or vehicle category, manufacturers
must produce engines that meet those standards by a specified date.75 Conformity is determined
under test procedures specified by EPA.76 The most common testing procedure used by EPA is the
Federal Test Procedure, as mandated by the Energy Tax Act of 1978.77 Tests are based on the
Urban Dynamometer Driving Schedule 78 to reflect typical driving patterns (e.g., city, highway,
aggressive, and use of air conditioning). Currently, EPA uses a three-tiered compliance strategy
for light-duty vehicles: (1) pre-production evaluation to certify vehicles prior to sale; (2) a
production evaluation on the assembly line for early evaluation of production vehicles, and (3) a
final clearance applied to verify that properly maintained vehicles continue to meet the standards
after several years of use.
EU Vehicle Emission Standards
History79
Environmental matters were not included in the EU’s founding Treaty of Rome. Prior to the mid1980s, UNECE produced regulations relating to safety, environmental protection, and energy
efficiency. It was a common practice for EU member countries to adopt standards and regulations
similar to those issued by UNECE, but each country retained authority to adjust the UNECE
standards as it saw fit.
The member states signed the Single European Act (SEA) in 1985 with a goal of unifying the
European market by 1992. Under the SEA, auto emissions regulations were harmonized across
Europe in 1987. Initially, the harmonized standards were less strict than US standards.80 Similar
to the 1970 U.S. Clean Air Act proviso for California, the SEA allows member states to enact
measures more stringent than those enacted by the EU.
75
Passenger cars and light-duty trucks are regulated by EPA at the level of the vehicle, whereas many of the heavyduty vehicle classes are regulated at the engine. Current federal regulations do not require that complete heavy-duty
diesel vehicles be chassis certified, instead requiring certification of their engines. As an option, complete heavy-duty
diesel vehicles under 14,000 lbs. can be chassis certified.
76
On January 8, 2014, the House of Representatives passed legislation (H.R. 724) that would eliminate a CAA
requirement for auto dealers to certify that new vehicles have an emissions system that complies with the CAA.
Vehicles would still be required to meet the CAA standards, but dealers would not have to offer written documentation.
77
P.L. 95-618.
78
The Urban Dynamometer Driving Schedule is defined in 40 C.F.R. §86 App I.
79
This historical summary is drawn, in part, from Asif Faiz, et al., Air Pollution from Motor Vehicles: Standards and
Technologies for Controlling Emissions (Washington, DC: World Bank, 1996), http://www.un.org/esa/gite/iandm/
faizpaper.pdf.
80
Roland Stephen, Vehicle of Influence: Building a European Car Market (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan
Press, 2000), pp. 21 and 85. The European law on emissions harmonization is Directive 88/76/EEC.
Congressional Research Service
14
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
EU Vehicle Emission Standards and Implementation
Vehicle exhaust emissions were regulated in Europe beginning in 1970.81 Directive 70/220/EEC
covered CO, NOx, PM, and HC emissions from gasoline-fueled light-duty vehicles. In June 1991,
the Council of Ministers of the European Council adopted the Consolidated Emissions Directive82
(commonly referred to as “Euro 1”) which ushered in the current regulatory regime for vehicle
emission standards in Europe. Current standards (referred to as “Euro 5”) cover CO, NOx, PM,
and HC emissions, and differentiate between gasoline and diesel vehicles. Euro 6 standards are
scheduled to be implemented in September 2014 (strengthening NOx standards for diesel
vehicles). The evolution of EU exhaust emission standards for light-duty, gasoline- and dieselfueled vehicles is traced in Table A-2 of the Appendix.
EU Certification and Test Procedures
Under the type approval process, emissions are currently tested using the New European Driving
Cycle (NEDC) (ECE 15 + EUDC) chassis dynamometer procedure. Effective in 2000 with the
Euro 3 standard, the test procedure was modified to eliminate the engine warm-up period before
the beginning of emission sampling, bringing the test more in line with the U.S. Federal Test
Procedure. Further, the Euro 5/6 implementing legislation introduced a new PM mass emission
measurement method which is similar to the U.S. procedure introduced in 2007.
Comparison of U.S. and EU Vehicle Emission Standards
Vehicle emissions standards established by the EU and the United States are not directly
comparable because of the differences in the testing procedures and approval processes.
•
Approval Process. Both the European and the U.S. systems of compliance are
based on a version of “type approval.” However, in the EU, emission standards
only apply when the vehicle is produced (conformity of production). Once the
vehicle leaves the factory and enters service, the manufacturer has no liability for
its continued compliance with emission limits. Surveillance testing, mandatory
emissions system warranties, recall campaigns, and other features of U.S.
emissions regulation are not incorporated in the European regulatory structure.
•
Test Procedure. A key difference between the EU and the United States is the
test procedure, in particular the drive cycle that a car has to go through on a roller
bench while the exhaust gas is being collected and analyzed. The EU uses the
New European Drive Cycle (NEDC) and the United States uses the Federal Test
Procedure (FTP). Differences between the two include distance, duration, and
vehicle speed, as well as factors such as whether the vehicle must begin at a cold
start or whether there is a warm-up period.
81
Ibid., pp. 92-93. Until the SEA agreement was reached, the EU based its limited environmental rules on other parts
of the Treaty of Rome, such as Article 100 dealing with free movement of goods. These early standards set maximum
emissions levels, but each member state could also permit the sale of autos that did not meet those standards within its
jurisdiction.
82
Council Directive 91/441/EEC of 26 June 1991, http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=
CELEX:31991L0441:EN:HTML.
Congressional Research Service
15
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
In terms of stringency—that is, the level of emission control technology required for
compliance—some observers have noted that the European emission standards have historically
lagged behind the U.S. standards.83 This lag may be attributed to the complex, consensus-based
approach to standard setting originally used by UNECE and by the difficulty of obtaining
agreement among so many individual countries. With the recent shift to decision procedures
requiring less-than-unanimous agreement within the European Commission, it has been possible
for the Commission to adopt more stringent emission standards. A comparison of current
emissions standards for selected pollutants (including non-methane organic gases [NMOG],
nitrogen oxides [NOx], and particulate matter [PM]) is shown in Figure 3. For a more detailed
survey of the standards in each region, see the Appendix.
Figure 3. Emissions Standards for Selected Pollutants in the United States and EU
non-methane organic gases (NMOG), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM)
EU standards converted from grams/kilometer to grams/mile
Source: CRS calculations, from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and European Commission Regulation
715/2007.
Notes: U.S. and EU emissions standards are not directly comparable because of differences in testing
procedures and approval processes. This chart shows EPA Tier 2, Bin 5 values for U.S. vehicles tested under the
FTP procedure and Euro 5 values for EU vehicles tested under the NEDC procedure. Shorter bars represent
more stringent standards.
Fuel Economy and Greenhouse Gas Emission Standards
U.S. Standards Process
In the United States, establishing fuel economy standards is a function of direct statutory
authority from Congress, with NHTSA administering the congressionally established standards.
83
This argument is made in Asif Faiz, et al., Air Pollution from Motor Vehicles
Congressional Research Service
16
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
The United States first issued vehicle fuel economy standards in response to the Organization of
the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) oil embargo of 1973, which caused imported crude
oil prices to rise by 300% in 1974. In the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1975 (EPCA),84
Congress established Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards for new passenger
vehicles starting with model year (MY) 1978. From 1975 to 1988, the average fuel economy of
new automobiles increased 81%, from 15.8 to 28.6 mpg. EPCA prohibited states from issuing
their own fuel efficiency standards. Prior to 2007, NHTSA had very little authority to modify
passenger car standards without congressional direction. However, under the Energy
Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA)85—which raised the fuel economy standards of
passenger vehicles, light trucks, and sport utility vehicles to a combined average of at least 35
mpg by 2020—Congress granted NHTSA broader authority to establish and modify CAFE
standards.
The most significant recent change in fuel economy standards took place outside of the previous
channel of congressional action. In 2009, the Obama Administration, some state regulators, and
the auto industry crafted a federal program to implement new light duty vehicle fuel efficiency
standards linked to greenhouse gas (GHG) emission standards. This agreement grew out of the
fuel efficiency standards passed by Congress in 2007, a Supreme Court decision confirming
federal authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions of vehicles under the CAA,86 and GHG
emission standards enacted in California and subsequently adopted by 13 other states and the
District of Columbia. The agreement enabled automakers to manufacture vehicles that are in
compliance with both federal and state requirements under the Clean Air Act as well as the CAFE
standards. The combined CAFE/GHG standards have made standard setting more complex, as
NHTSA and EPA issue separate standards but act in concert.
The combined standards call for fleet-average passenger car and light truck GHG emissions of no
more than 163 grams per mile by 2025. This translates to average fuel economy of 54.5 mpg.87
The CO2 emissions target for any given vehicle depends on its track width (the horizontal
distance between the tires) and its wheelbase (the distance from the front to the rear axles); no
specific vehicle must meet a specific target, but a manufacturer’s fleet average must be below the
sales-weighted average of the targets. This measurement procedure allows heavier cars to have
higher emissions than lighter cars while preserving the overall fleet average. As a result, each
manufacturer will have its own fleet-wide standard which reflects the vehicles it chooses to
produce. For a summary of the 2012 CAFE and GHG vehicle standards, see Table A-3 of the
Appendix.
The regulation also includes a system of averaging, banking, and trading (ABT) of credits, based
on a manufacturer’s fleet average CO2 performance. Credit trading is allowed among all vehicles
a manufacturer produces, both cars and light trucks, as well as between companies. Further
program flexibilities include Air Conditioning Improvement Credits, Advanced Technology
84
P.L. 94-163.
P.L. 110-140.
86
Massachusetts vs. Environmental Protection Agency, April 2, 2007,
http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/06pdf/05-1120.pdf. See CRS Report RS22665, The Supreme Court’s Climate
Change Decision: Massachusetts v. EPA, by (name redacted).
87
For a full description of the new standards, see CRS Report R42721, Automobile and Truck Fuel Economy (CAFE)
and Greenhouse Gas Standards, by (name redacted), (name redacted), and (name redacted).
85
Congressional Research Service
17
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Credits, Off-Cycle Innovative Technology Credits, Early Credits, and Flex-fuel and Alternative
Fuel Vehicle Credits.
CAFE and GHG emission certification is typically based on fuel economy and emission data
provided by vehicle manufacturers after two laboratory test cycles dictated by EPA. This
procedure is sometimes referred to as the EPA 2-cycle test. CAFE values—used to determine
manufacturers’ compliance with the average fuel economy standards—are generally higher than
typical fuel efficiency in real-world operation or as published by the government or posted on
new vehicles. This discrepancy reflects the fact that the EPA 2-cycle test is not wholly
representative of vehicle operation patterns and technology as well as the fact that CAFE figures
can include other credits and flexibilities.
EU Standards Process
The EU does not set fuel economy standards for vehicles directly in terms of fuel consumption
for a given distance traveled. Instead, it sets standards for GHG emissions in terms of the mass of
CO2, measured in grams, emitted from a vehicle’s tailpipe per kilometer driven (g/km). These
standards can be used to estimate fuel economy for vehicles sold in Europe.88
The first carbon dioxide emission targets for new passenger cars in Europe were set in 1998-99
through voluntary agreements between the European Commission and the automotive industry.89
These agreements targeted fleet-average CO2 emissions of 140 g/km by 2008-09. While
significant CO2 emission reductions were achieved in the initial years, after 2004 the
manufacturers failed to meet their targets through voluntary actions. In response, the Commission
developed a mandatory CO2 emission reduction program, and CO2 emission targets for new
passenger cars were adopted in April 2009.90 The regulation established a fleet-average CO2
emission target of 130 g/km by 2015 and defined a long-term target of 95 g CO2/km by 2020.
The standards include incentives for vehicles with CO2 emissions below 50 g/km and for those
running on a mixture of 85% ethanol (E85). Certain flexibilities are available for manufacturers,
including credits for technology innovations, pooling between manufacturers, and exemptions for
low-volume manufacturers. The regulations cover only CO2 emissions; other greenhouse gases
are not regulated. Emission limits are set according to the mass of vehicle using a fleet-average
limit value curve. As with the other EU regulated vehicle emissions, CO2 emissions are measured
over the NEDC test cycle.
Comparison of U.S. and EU GHG and Fuel Economy Standards
The United States regulates the fuel efficiency of each manufacturer’s new-vehicle fleet through
the CAFE standards, and separately imposes standards for GHG emissions from new mobile
88
An EU Labeling Directive enacted in the 1990s requires each country to place stickers on new vehicles showing that
model’s projected fuel economy.
89
For an overview of the European Automobile Manufacturers Association voluntary agreement, see Dieselnet’s
website at http://www.dieselnet.com/standards/eu/ghg_acea.php.
90
Regulation (EC) No 443/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 setting emission
performance standards for new passenger cars as part of the Community’s integrated approach to reduce CO2 emissions
from light-duty vehicles, http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:32009R0443:EN:NOT.
Congressional Research Service
18
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
sources. The EU does not directly regulate vehicle fuel efficiency, although regulation of GHG
emissions pushes manufacturers to achieve greater fuel efficiency.
Comparing vehicle GHG and/or fuel economy standards between the two regions is challenging
because these standards differ greatly in structure, form, and underlying testing methods. For
example, the EU and the U.S. test cycles differ in terms of average speed, duration, distance,
acceleration and deceleration characteristics, and frequencies of starts and stops—all factors
which significantly affect the data returned by the tests. Further, the U.S. standard regulates all
the GHG emissions from the vehicle (e.g., CO2, NOx, CH4) in terms of CO2-equivalents; the EU
regulates only carbon dioxide emissions. Additionally, the EU sets fleet-average GHG emissions
standards in relationship to the mass of a vehicle, whereas the United States sets fleet-average
standards based on the vehicle “footprint.” Finally, the EU and United States use varying
definitions of vehicle categories and weight classes, with proposed targets based on projected
sales of vehicles in different size and/or weight classes within each region.
In general the EU GHG standards—and by extension, fuel economy standards—return a greater
sales-based and fleet-wide emission reduction than those in the United States. Figure 4 represents
an estimate of historical and projected fuel economy targets, adjusted for the factors outlined
above.
Figure 4. Comparison of Historical and Proposed
U.S. and EU Fuel Economy Standards for Light-Duty Vehicles
MPG Gasoline normalized to CAFE test cycle
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
US-LDV
30.0
EU
20.0
10.0
0.0
1995
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
Source: CRS from data sourced at The International Council for Clean Transportation.
Notes: The International Council for Clean Transportation bases these comparisons on datasets generated
from (1) current historical regulations and proposals, (2) estimates of fleet-average sales, and (3) test-cycle
conversion tools to estimate target test cycles from original test cycles with similar metrics. For more on the
comparative methodology, see http://theicct.org/info-tools/global-passenger-vehicle-standards.
Congressional Research Service
19
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
The Role of Nongovernmental Organizations (NGOs)
In the United States and the EU, NGOs play a role91 in the setting of vehicle standards, including
these entities:
•
Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) remains involved in developing
recommended standards for industry and has issued or updated about 2,000
motor vehicle standards in the past five years. Many address manufacturing
processes, not auto safety or emissions. About 10% of NHTSA and EPA
standards are based on work SAE has already done and, in those cases, NHTSA
and EPA rules are based on the specific SAE standards.92
•
International Organization for Standardization (ISO) was founded in 1947
and develops voluntary international standards for many products and services.93
Standards are typically developed through negotiation in technical committees
comprising representatives of many countries. ISO has developed nearly 20,000
standards across a range of industries. For example, a 2010 ISO standard
addressed automotive crankshaft bearings.
•
International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) is a private organization
founded in 1906 that develops and publishes international standards for
electrical, electronic, and other related technologies. Its standards are voluntary
and based on consensus among government, academic, industry, and consumer
representatives. IEC standards related to motor vehicles concern charging system
architecture, lithium batteries, and other aspects of electric vehicles.94
Various other private-sector advocacy groups are engaged in identifying and publicizing new
vehicle standards. In the United States, these include the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety,
American National Standards Institute (ANSI), National Safety Council, the Center for Auto
Safety, and Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety. In the EU, nonprofit groups such as the
European Transport Safety Council and Transport & Environment participate in the EU standardsetting process.95
Recent Efforts for Regulatory Convergence
European, U.S. and Japanese auto industry groups96 sought common regulatory ground in 1996,
when they proposed that the United States, the EU, Japan, and UNECE harmonize regulation of
91
SAE and ISO not only develop standards but also have a commercial interest in seeing them used; these
organizations copyright their standards and sell them to automakers that want to build vehicles meeting the
specifications.
92
SAE estimate. The inclusion of SAE standards in federal regulations is a shortcut at the time a federal regulation is
established. In the long-term, SAE can more readily update and change its standards as technology changes, while
NHTSA and EPA must use an extensive public review process.
93
ISO website, About ISO, http://www.iso.org/iso/home/about.htm.
94
IEC website, http://www.iec.ch/about/?ref=menu.
95
Some of the American NGOs preceded federal regulation of the auto industry and others were founded after federal
legislation was enacted in the late 1960s. Similar European organizations began their advocacy after 1990.
96
American Automobile Manufacturers Association (AAMA), European Automobile Manufacturers Association
(ACEA) and Japan Automobile Manufacturers Association (JAMA).
Congressional Research Service
20
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
five vehicle components, including windshield wipers, defoggers, and seat belt assemblies. They
believed that these five components were functionally equivalent, although each was slightly
different. The regulatory bodies did not agree to any changes, however, because the data-driven
review process made it difficult to prove functional equivalency of even a standard component
such as a seat belt.97
This experience suggested that obtaining functional equivalency determinations from regulatory
agencies might be difficult.98 An alternative approach was developed in the 1998 UN agreement
on global technical regulations, which created a global registry of processes and common
technical standards. This initiative, resulting in the creation of the World Forum for
Harmonization of Vehicle Regulations, has resulted in agreement on only 13 global technical
regulations to date.
Simultaneously, there has been a transatlantic dialogue on autos since the mid-1990s through the
U.S.-EU High-Level Regulatory Cooperation Forum. In 1995, President Clinton signed an action
plan which sought to move the United States and Europe toward regulatory conformity and to
encourage collaborative testing and certification. The 1996 TransAtlantic Automotive Industry
Conference on International Regulatory Harmonization produced a report on the auto sector,
including ten principles to guide steps toward convergence. NHTSA sent a report to Congress in
April 1997 discussing potential harmonization of U.S. and European side impact standards.99 A
similar bilateral regulatory initiative has been under way since 2011 with Canada.100
An EU initiative, the Competitive Automotive Regulatory System for the 21s Century, or CARS
21, has also explored harmonization issues. A 2012 CARS 21 report recommended exploration of
ways to bring about “stronger internationalisation of the regulatory environment” related to
autos.101 In 2006, CARS 21 called for gradually replacing some EU laws with UN regulations,
and more than 40 EU directives have been replaced with corresponding UN regulations since that
time.102
Pathways to Convergence
There are different ways in which the United States and the EU could address convergence of
automotive regulations under TTIP. These include the following:
•
Harmonization of rules. Harmonization need not mean having identical rules in
both regions. From the viewpoint of auto manufacturers, it means minimizing
97
“Transatlantic Trade, the Automotive Sector: The Role of Regulation in a Global Industry, Where We Have Been
and Where We Need to Go, How Far Can EU-US Cooperation Go Toward Achieving Regulatory Harmonization,” p.
14.
98
Ibid.
99
http://www.nhtsa.gov/cars/rules/crashworthy/congrep7.html.
100
The U.S.-Canada Regulatory Cooperation Council has produced a joint action plan, including efforts to harmonize
NHTSA motor vehicle safety standards and share information, technical work, scientific collaboration, and testing
related to EPA light-duty vehicle emissions regulations. See http://www.trade.gov/rcc/.
101
CARS 21 High Level Group, CARS 21: A Competitive Automotive Regulatory System for the 21st Century, 2006, p.
8, http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/sectors/automotive/files/pagesbackground/competitiveness/cars21finalreport_en.pdf.
102
CARS 21 High Level Group, Final Report 2012, European Commission, June 6, 2012, http://ec.europa.eu/
enterprise/sectors/automotive/files/cars-21-final-report-2012_en.pdf.
Congressional Research Service
21
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
unnecessary differences in regulations so that a “single vehicle standard can be
built to satisfy all requirements.”103
•
Comprehensive mutual recognition. This approach would permit automakers to
sell vehicles in either market if they meet either a U.S. standard or a standard
accepted in the EU. A car certified as compliant with U.S. safety, emission, and
fuel efficiency standards would be accepted as compliant in the EU, and vice
versa. This approach is how the EU certification process works.
•
Selective mutual recognition. This approach would identify certain major
standards for which TTIP could provide mutual recognition, rather than
providing mutual recognition of all standards. U.S. and European automakers
have identified occupant crash protection, side impact protection, child restraint
systems, and some emissions standards as priorities for selective mutual
recognition.
•
Forward-looking rules. A fourth option would be to forge an agreement on
emerging regulations, such as those dealing with electric and fuel cell vehicles,
rather than focusing on existing regulations. Under this approach, the United
States and the EU would commit to jointly develop standards covering new
issues or technologies.
The pending free trade agreement between the EU and Canada104 may influence the direction of
TTIP. The full text of the agreement has not been released, but according to an EU statement,
“Canada will recognise a list of EU car standards and will examine the recognition of further
standards. This will make it much easier to export cars to Canada.”105 The agreement is also said
to allow Canadian vehicles to be certified in Canada for the EU market.106
Convergence of vehicle standards has potential drawbacks. One aspect pertains to the lack of
speed with which governmental agencies—whether in the United States or Europe—can address
new technologies and vehicle innovations. The rule-making process is already lengthy, and the
need for international coordination could make it even longer. This raises the prospect that
technologies that could reduce accidents—such as new types of headlamps that can illuminate the
road better without blinding oncoming drivers—may be delayed in reaching the market.
Additionally, the EU acknowledges that if vehicle standards become international, there could be
less room for legislative scrutiny and for involvement by regional and national interest groups.107
U.S. consumer advocacy groups have raised similar concerns, writing U.S. and EU leaders in July
2013 that TTIP “must not limit the United States or the EU (or its member states) from adopting
103
International Organisation of Motor Vehicle Manufacturers (OICA), http://www.oica.net.
Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA).
105
EU, “Facts and Figures of the EU-Canada Free Trade Deal,” October 18, 2013, http://europa.eu/rapid/pressrelease_MEMO-13-911_en.htm.
106
Government of Canada, How CETA Will Benefit Canada’s Key Economic Sectors, “New opportunities for Canada’s
automotive industry,” p. 4, http://www.actionplan.gc.ca/sites/default/files/pdfs/final-sectors-eng.pdf. No text of an
agreement has been released publicly.
107
European Commission, Mobility and Safety: Road Transport, “Who Regulates Vehicle Safety?” http://ec.europa.eu/
transport/road_safety/specialist/knowledge/vehicle/vehicle_safety_policy/who_regulates_vehicle_safety.htm.
104
Congressional Research Service
22
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
and enforcing standards that provide higher levels of consumer, worker, and environmental
protection.”108
Congress could play an important role if a TTIP agreement contains significant provisions related
to auto safety, emissions, and fuel economy regulations. Congress established the U.S.
government agencies whose regulations are the focus of the negotiations on automobile
standards, and it has retained a strong oversight interest in vehicle safety and emissions. If the
TTIP effort to obtain mutual recognition or harmonization affects agencies’ authority or changes
the ways in which automotive regulations are developed and implemented, Congress may well be
asked to modify the underlying statutes that govern motor vehicle safety, emissions, and fuel
efficiency.
108
http://www.citizen.org/documents/public-citizen-letter-to-obama-alerting-to-tafta-concerns.pdf.
Congressional Research Service
23
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Appendix. Detailed Comparison of
U.S. and EU Vehicle Emissions Standards
Emission Standards
U.S. Vehicle Emission Standards and Implementation
The Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) of 1990 (P.L. 101-549) established standards to limit
tailpipe emissions from new motor vehicles effective in 1994. These Tier 1 standards applied to
all new light-duty vehicles, such as passenger cars, light-duty trucks, sport utility vehicles
(SUVs), minivans, and pick-up trucks, and covered the four major pollutants (CO, NOx, PM, and
HC [subdivided as Total Hydrocarbons (THC) and Non-Methane Hydrocarbons (NMHC)]).
Separate sets of standards were defined for each vehicle category, with more relaxed limits for
heavier vehicles. The CAAA also required EPA to study the need for more stringent “Tier 2”
emission standards. Subsequently, EPA promulgated “Tier 2” standards on February 10, 2000.109
The Tier 2 regulations introduced more stringent numerical emission limits and a number of
additional changes that tightened the standards for larger vehicles. Under the Tier 2 regulations,
the same emission standards apply to all vehicle weight categories. Further, the same emission
limits apply to all vehicles regardless of the fuel they use. Since light-duty emission standards are
expressed in grams of pollutants per mile, vehicles with large engines (such light trucks or SUVs)
were required to use more advanced emission control technologies than vehicles with smaller
engines. To provide flexibility to vehicle manufacturers, the Tier 2 emission standards were
structured into eight permanent and three temporary certification levels of different stringency,
called “certification bins.” Manufacturers had a choice to certify particular vehicles to any of the
available bins, but were required to meet a fleet-average requirement for NOx emissions in any
given model year.
U.S. emissions standards are shown in Table A-1. (Note that Tables A-1 and A-2 are not strictly
comparable because U.S. standards are based on grams per mile and EU standards are based on
grams per kilometer.
109
EPA, “Control of Air Pollution From New Motor Vehicles: Tier 2 Motor Vehicle Emissions Standards and Gasoline
Sulfur Control Requirements; Final Rule,” 65 Federal Register 6698-6870, February 10, 2000.
Congressional Research Service
24
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Table A-1. U.S. Emission Standards for Light Duty Gasoline Vehicles
grams/mile
Model Year
Carbon Monoxide
(CO)
Non-Methane
Hydrocarbons (NMHC)
Nitrogen Oxides (NOx)
Pre-1966 (uncontrolled)
80.0
10.6
4.1
1967
34.0
4.1
n/a
1972
28.0
3.4
3.1
1975
15.0
1.5
3.1
1977
15.0
1.5
2.0
1980
7.0
0.41
2.0
1981
3.4
0.41
1.0
1994 (Tier 1)
3.4(4.2)
0.25(0.31)
0.4(0.6)
2004 (Tier 2, Bin 5)
3.4(4.2)
0.075(0.09)
0.05(0.07)
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Emission Standards Reference Guide, http://www.epa.gov/otaq/
standards/index.htm.
Notes: “N/a” denotes not-applicable. Standards are set over the “useful life” of the vehicle, which is defined as
50,000 miles or five years for automobiles. The durability of the emissions control device must be demonstrated
over this distance within allowed deterioration factors. Figures in parenthesis apply to a useful life of 100,000
miles for Tier 1, 120,000 miles for Tier 2.
EU Vehicle Emission Standards and Implementation
In June 1991, the Council of Ministers of the European Council adopted the Consolidated
Emissions Directive 110 (commonly referred to as “Euro 1”) under which exhaust emission
standards for all passenger cars, including diesels, were certified. The Council of Ministers has
since adopted several stricter revisions to the Euro 1 standards; and, in September of 2014, Euro 6
standards will be introduced.111
EU emission limits for each “Euro” stage are summarized in Table A-2.
110
Council Directive 91/441/EEC of 26 June 1991, http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=
CELEX:31991L0441:EN:HTML.
111
European Commission, Euro 5 and Euro 6 - emissions from light duty vehicles, including Regulation (EC) n°
692/2008 implementing and amending Regulation (EC) n° 715/2007 on type-approval of motor vehicles with respect to
emissions from light passenger and commercial vehicles (Euro 5 and Euro 6) and on access to vehicle repair and
maintenance information, http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/sectors/automotive/environment/euro5/index_en.htm.
Congressional Research Service
25
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Table A-2. Evolution of EU Emission Standards for Passenger Cars
emissions expressed in grams/kilometer
Stage
Year
CO
HC
HC+NOx
NOx
PM
Compression Ignition (Diesel)
Euro 1
1992
2.72 (3.16)
—
0.97 (1.13)
—
0.14 (0.18)
Euro 2
1996
1
—
0.7
—
0.08
Euro 3
2000
0.64
—
0.56
0.5
0.05
Euro 4
2005
0.5
—
0.3
0.25
0.025
Euro 5
2009
0.5
—
0.23
0.18
0.005
Euro 6
2014
0.5
—
0.17
0.08
0.005
Positive Ignition (Gasoline)
Euro 1
1992
2.72 (3.16)
—
0.97 (1.13)
—
—
Euro 2
1996
2.2
—
0.5
—
—
Euro 3
2000
2.3
0.2
—
0.15
—
Euro 4
2005
1
0.1
—
0.08
—
Euro 5
2009
1
0.068
—
0.06
0.005
Euro 6
2014
1
0.068
—
0.06
0.005
Source: TransportPolicy.net, http://transportpolicy.net/index.php?title=EU:_Light-duty:_Emissions.
Notes: Standards listed are for EU Category M1. Values in brackets are conformity of production (COP) limits.
HC values for Euro 5 and Euro 6 are for NMHC.
Fuel Economy and Greenhouse Gas Standards
U.S. Fuel Economy and GHG Standards and Implementation
The 2012 CAFE and GHG vehicle standards call for combined passenger car and light truck
greenhouse gas emissions of no more than 163 grams per mile by 2025. This translates into a 54.5
mile-per-gallon equivalent.112 The GHG standards are based on CO2 emissions-footprint curves,
where each vehicle has a different CO2 emissions compliance target depending on its “footprint”
value, related to the size of the vehicle—an approach first introduced in the reformed CAFE
(2008-2011) standards for light trucks. Table A-3 shows the projected fleet-wide CO2 emission
and fuel economy requirements. The EPA CO2-equivalent fuel economy figures are different from
the CAFE figures because the EPA allows additional CO2 credits for air conditioning
improvements and other flexibilities.
112
For a full description of the new standards, see CRS Report R42721, Automobile and Truck Fuel Economy (CAFE)
and Greenhouse Gas Standards, by (name redacted), (name redacted), and (name redacted).
Congressional Research Service
26
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Table A-3. MY2016-MY2025 Combined Passenger Car and Light Truck
GHG and CAFE Standards
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
GHG
Standard
(grams/mile)a
250
243
232
222
213
199
190
180
171
163
GHGEquivalent
Fuel
Economy
(miles per
gallon
equivalent)a
35.5
36.6
38.3
40.0
41.7
44.7
46.8
49.4
52.0
54.5
Fuel
Economy
(CAFE)
Standard
(miles per
gallon)a
34.1
35.4
36.5
37.7
38.9
41.0
43.0b
45.1b
47.4b
49.7b
Source: EPA and NHTSA, 2017 and Later Model Year Light-Duty Vehicle Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Corporate
Average Fuel Economy Standards, Prepublication Version, August 28, 2012.
a.
Because of the complexity of the CAFE/GHG system, these numbers are based on projected sales of
vehicles in different size classes. The standards are size-based, and the vehicle fleet encompasses large,
medium, and small cars and light trucks. Thus if the sales mix is different from projections the achieved
CAFE and GHG levels would be different. For example, the CAFE numbers are based on NHTSA’s
projection using the MY2008 fleet as the baseline. A newer projection, based on the MY2010 fleet, leads to
somewhat lower numbers (roughly 0.3—0.6 mpg lower for MY2017-2020 and roughly 0.7-1.0 mpg lower
for MY2021 onward).
b.
Projected. NHTSA has authority only to set CAFE standards in five-year increments. Thus, only rules
through MY2021 have been finalized. For MY2022 onward NHTSA must issue a new rule, which has not
been proposed as of September 2012.
In addition to the fleet-average CO2 emission targets, the rule also includes emission caps for
tailpipe nitrous oxide and methane emissions (N2O: 0.010 g/mile and CH4: 0.030 g/mile). The
regulation also includes a system of averaging, banking, and trading (ABT) of credits, based on a
manufacturer’s fleet average CO2 performance. Credit trading is allowed among all vehicles a
manufacturer produces, both cars and light trucks, as well as between companies.
EU GHG Standards and Implementation
The EU does not issue fuel economy standards similar to the U.S. CAFE standards. As shown in
Table A-4, EU fleet-average CO2 emission targets as required by EU Regulation (EC) No
443/2009 are 130 g/km to be reached by 2015 and a long-term target of 95 g/km to be reached by
2020.
Congressional Research Service
27
U.S. and EU Motor Vehicle Standards: Issues for Transatlantic Trade Negotiations
Table A-4. EU Light Duty Vehicle GHG Targets
in U.S. CAFE miles per gallon equivalent converted from EU g/km GHG emissions
2015
2020
GHG Standard (grams/kilometer)
130 g/km
95 g/km
GHG-Equivalent Fuel Economy
(miles per gallon equivalent)
45.5 mpg
60.6 mpg
Source: CRS from data provided by International Council for Clean Transportation.
Notes: The International Council for Clean Transportation bases these comparisons on datasets generated
from (1) current historical regulations and proposals, (2) estimates of fleet-average sales, and (3) test-cycle
conversion tools to estimate target test cycles from original test cycles with similar metrics. For more on the
comparative methodology, see http://theicct.org/info-tools/global-passenger-vehicle-standards.
Author Contact Information
(name redacted)
Specialist in Industrial Organization and Business
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....
Congressional Research Service
(name redacted)
Analyst in Environmental Policy
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....
28
EveryCRSReport.com
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the
Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on
issues that may come before Congress.
EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The
reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to
the public.
Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts
who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made
any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.
CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in
the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without
permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a
third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or
otherwise use copyrighted material.
Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public
understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in
connection with CRS' institutional role.
EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim
copyright on any CRS report we have republished.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.