The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes by the Department of the Interior

Congressional research reportMay 28, 2014

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

The Administrative Process by Which Groups

May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes by

the Department of the Interior

name redacted

Legislative Attorney

May 28, 2014

Congressional Research Service

7-....

www.crs.gov

R43051

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

Summary

In 1978, the Department of the Interior (Department) adopted a final rule setting forth the process

by which a group may be recognized (also acknowledged) as an Indian tribe by the Department.

Prior to that time, the Department made decisions on an ad hoc basis. However, in the wake of the

treaty fishing rights case United States v. Washington and eastern land claims, more groups started

seeking recognition as Indian tribes, and the Department could no longer manage the recognition

requests on a case-by-case basis. The acknowledgement process, codified in 25 C.F.R. Part 83,

sets forth a uniform process and uniform criteria for acknowledging that groups exist as Indian

tribes.

The key to federal acknowledgment under the current regulations is continuous political existence

of an Indian group from historical times to the present. The federal acknowledgment process does

not create tribes, and it does not give groups sovereignty. Rather, it acknowledges a political

entity that already exists. To do this, 25 C.F.R. Section 83.7 provides seven mandatory criteria

that groups must satisfy in order to establish that they exist and have existed as an autonomous

political entity. First, in order to be acknowledged, a group must establish that it has been

identified as an Indian entity from 1900 to the present. Second, it must establish that it has existed

as a community from historical times to the present. Third, it must establish that it has exercised

political control over its members from historical times to the present. Fourth, the group must

provide a copy of its governing document, including membership criteria. Fifth, the group must

establish that its members descend from a historical Indian tribe or historical Indian tribes that

combined and functioned as a single autonomous political entity. Sixth, the membership must be

composed principally of persons who are not members of a federally recognized tribe. Finally, the

group must establish that it is not the subject of congressional legislation terminating or

forbidding the federal-tribal relationship.

The current regulations assign responsibility to the Assistant Secretary—Indian Affairs (Assistant

Secretary) to issue initial proposed findings and then final determinations. The Office of Federal

Acknowledgment (OFA) makes recommendations to the Assistant Secretary on the proposed

findings and the final determinations. A final determination may be appealed on limited grounds

to the Interior Board of Indian Appeals.

Acknowledgment as an Indian tribe means that the group becomes a federally recognized tribe

with which the United States has a government-to-government relationship. This relationship

makes the tribe and its members eligible for certain benefits, as well as subject to certain

protections. It also means that the tribe may exercise jurisdiction over its territory and members

generally free from state law, subject to limitations of federal law.

After years of criticism of the acknowledgment process, the Department of the Interior has

proposed several changes to the acknowledgment regulations. First, the proposed rule would

change some of the criteria. Second, the proposed rule would assign responsibility for the

proposed findings to OFA but keep responsibility for the final determinations with the Assistant

Secretary. In rendering the proposed finding, OFA would consider the criteria in stages.

Petitioners could appeal a negative proposed finding at any of the stages. The appeal would be

heard by a judge within the Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA) who would issue a

recommended decision for the Assistant Secretary to consider in issuing the final determination.

The Assistant Secretary’s decision would be final for the Department.

Congressional Research Service

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

Contents

Background ...................................................................................................................................... 1

The Acknowledgment Process ......................................................................................................... 1

The Documented Petition .......................................................................................................... 2

The Mandatory Criteria ............................................................................................................. 3

Identification ....................................................................................................................... 3

Community .......................................................................................................................... 3

Political Influence or Authority ........................................................................................... 3

Governing Document .......................................................................................................... 4

Descent from an Indian Tribe .............................................................................................. 4

Members Must Not Be Members of a Federally Recognized Tribe .................................... 4

Termination ......................................................................................................................... 4

Previous Federal Acknowledgment ..................................................................................... 4

Review of the Documented Petition .......................................................................................... 5

Expedited Negative Determinations.................................................................................... 5

Active Consideration ........................................................................................................... 5

Reconsideration ......................................................................................................................... 6

Grounds for Reconsideration by the IBIA .......................................................................... 6

Actions by the IBIA ............................................................................................................ 7

Reconsideration on Other Grounds ..................................................................................... 7

The Proposed Rule ........................................................................................................................... 8

Changes to the Criteria .............................................................................................................. 8

Changes to the Process .............................................................................................................. 9

Contacts

Author Contact Information........................................................................................................... 10

Congressional Research Service

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

Background

In the 19th century and first half of the 20th century, the federal government made determinations

about which groups of Indians were tribes on an ad hoc basis when negotiating treaties and

determining which groups of Indians could reorganize their governments under the Indian

Reorganization Act.1 In the 1970s, the number of requests for tribal recognition by the

Department of the Interior (Department) increased exponentially in the wake of the decisions in

United States v. Washington,2 which recognized tribal treaty fishing rights in the Pacific

Northwest, and Joint Tribal Council of Passamaquoddy v. Morton,3 which recognized a tribal

land claim on the East Coast.4 Faced with many requests for tribal recognition, in 1978, the

Department adopted a uniform process and uniform criteria for considering whether a group

should be acknowledged as an Indian tribe.5

Acknowledgment or recognition as an Indian tribe has important legal and practical significance.

One scholar on tribal acknowledgment explains the significance of tribal recognition as follows:

An administrative determination that a group is a tribe (i.e., that it merits federal

acknowledgment or recognition) establishes a government-to-government relationship

between it and the United States. A positive determination under the regulations means that

the group has inherent sovereign authority independent of the state in which it is located and

independent of the United States, although it remains a domestic dependent nation. A group

acknowledged under the regulations has continuously existed throughout history. A tribe,

consequently, has sovereign immunity and may exercise jurisdiction over its territory and

establish tribal courts, administer funds under the Indian Self-Determination and Education

Assistance Act, establish gaming facilities under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, bring a

land claim under the Indian Trade and non-Intercourse Act, exercise treaty hunting and

fishing rights, and obtain other federal benefits and exercise their own sovereign authority,

except as limited by federal law. General prohibitions or limitations also apply to federally

recognized tribes. For example, possession of liquor is prohibited in Indian country absent

publication of a certified liquor ordinance, and the sale of land is limited. Thus, a

determination that a group is or is not a tribe is a decision with significant impacts on the

group itself, federal and state governments, other Indian tribes, and non-Indians.6

The Acknowledgment Process

The process set forth in 25 C.F.R. Part 83 includes procedures that the Department must follow

and establishes the burden of proof for petitioners and the criteria that Indian groups must satisfy

in order to be acknowledged as Indian tribes. The acknowledgment process is available to

1

Barbara N. Coen, The Role of Jurisdiction in the Quest for Sovereignty: Tribal Status Decision Making: A Federal

Perspective on Acknowledgment, 37 New. Eng. L. Rev. 491, 491 (2003) [hereinafter “Coen”].

2

384 F. Supp. 312 (W.D. Wash. 1974), aff’d, 520 F.2d 676 (9th Cir. 1975), cert. denied, 423 U.S. 1086 (1976).

3

528 F.2d 370 (1st Cir. 1975).

4

Coen, supra note 1 at 492-493; William W. Quinn, Jr., Federal Acknowledgment of American Indian Tribes: The

Historical Development of a Legal Concept, 34 Am. J. Legal Hist. 331, 363 (1990).

5

Final Rule, “Procedures for Establishing that an American Indian Group Exists as an Indian Tribe,” 43 Fed. Reg.

39,361 (1978). The procedures were originally codified in 25 C.F.R. Part 54. However, after amendments in 1984, they

were codified in 25 C.F.R. Part 83.

6

Coen, supra note 1 at 491-492 (footnotes omitted).

Congressional Research Service

1

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

“American Indian groups indigenous to the continental United States.”7 Only “groups that can

establish a substantially continuous tribal existence and which have functioned as autonomous

entities throughout history until the present” may be acknowledged.8 Therefore, groups that

recently came together and “[s]plinter groups, political factions, communities or groups of any

character that separate from the main body of a currently acknowledged tribe” may not be

acknowledged.9 Groups that were subject to congressional termination may not use the process to

be acknowledged.10 Finally, groups that have been through the process and failed may not repetition for acknowledgment.11

The acknowledgment process begins when a group files a letter of intent, signed by the governing

body of the group, requesting that the group be acknowledged.12 However, the review process

does not begin until a group submits a documented petition. The minimum amount of time from

the start of active consideration of the group’s petition until a final determination is 25 months.13

The Documented Petition

Groups have an unlimited amount of time to file a documented petition. A documented petition

must contain “thorough explanations and supporting documentation in response to all of the

criteria.”14 In 2002, the office within the Department responsible for reviewing documented

petitions reported to Congress that petitions were ranging in size from 30,000 to over 100,000

pages.15

The Office of Federal Acknowledgment (OFA) reviews the documented petition and makes

recommendations to the Assistant Secretary—Indian Affairs (Assistant Secretary). Before OFA

actively considers the petition, OFA conducts a preliminary review for the purpose of providing

technical assistance to the group (petitioner) so that the petitioner may supplement or revise its

petition.16 After the petitioner responds to the technical assistance, OFA will inform the petitioner

in writing of any “obvious deficiencies or significant omissions.”17 The petitioner may

supplement the petition with additional information or withdraw the petition prior to OFA’s active

consideration to do further work on it.18 Once the documented petition is completed to the

petitioner’s satisfaction, it is ready for active consideration by OFA.

7

25 C.F.R. §83.3(a).

Id.

9

25 C.F.R. §83.3(d).

10

25 C.F.R. §83.3(e).

11

25 C.F.R. §83.3(f).

12

25 C.F.R. §83.4.

13

Coen, supra note 1 at 494-495. Frequently, this process takes longer than 25 months because petitioners and

interested parties may request extensions of time. As discussed below, the process may be extended further if a

petitioner or an interested party seeks reconsideration.

14

25 C.F.R. §83.6.

15

Coen, supra note 1 at 495, citing Work of the Dep’t of the Interior’s Branch of Acknowledgment and Research

within the Bureau of Indian Affairs: Hearing Before the Senate Comm. on Indian Affairs, 107th Cong., 2d Sess. 2, 1920 (2002).

16

25 C.F.R. §83.10(b)(1).

17

25 C.F.R. §83.10(b)(2).

18

Id.

8

Congressional Research Service

2

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

The Mandatory Criteria

A team within OFA, generally composed of a historian, a genealogist, and a cultural

anthropologist, reviews the documented petition to see if it satisfies all of the following

mandatory criteria.19 “A criterion shall be considered met if the available evidence establishes a

reasonable likelihood of the validity of the facts relating to that criterion.”20

Identification

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(a) requires that the group “has been identified as an American Indian

entity on a substantially continuous basis since 1900.” Section 83.7(a) lists the kind of evidence

of identification that is accepted. However, just about any evidence of identification as an Indian

entity by someone other than a member of the group is accepted.

Community

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(b) requires that “a predominant portion of the petitioning group comprises

a distinct community and has existed as a community from historical times until the present.”

Section 83.7(b) provides examples of the kind of evidence that can prove the existence as a

community, including marriage patterns; social or economic relationships connecting the group;

strong patterns of discrimination by nonmembers; shared sacred or ritual activities among most of

the group; and cultural patterns that distinguish the group from the surrounding non-Indian

population. A petitioner that can show the following is deemed to have provided sufficient

evidence of community at a particular point in time: more than 50% of the members live in a

geographical area exclusively or almost exclusively and the remaining members maintain

consistent interaction with members of the group; at least 50% of the marriages in the group

occur between members; at least 50% of the members have a distinct culture, such as a language

or religion; or distinct community social institutions encompass most of the group.

Political Influence or Authority

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(c) requires that “[t]he petitioner has maintained political influence or

authority over its members as an autonomous entity from historical times to the present.”

“Political influence or authority” is defined to mean “a tribal council, leadership, internal process

of other mechanism which the group has used as a means of influencing or controlling the

behavior of its members in significant respects, and/or making decisions for the group which

substantially affect its members, and/or representing the group in dealing with outsiders in

matters of consequence.”21 Section 83.7(c) identifies the kind of evidence that can demonstrate

political influence or authority. A petitioner will be deemed to have established this criterion for a

given point in time if it shows that group leaders or some other mechanism within the group

allocates group resources; settles disputes among members or subgroups; exerts strong influence

on the behavior of members; or organizes or influences economic subsistence efforts among the

19

Coen, supra note 1 at 495.

25 C.F.R. §83.6(d).

21

25 C.F.R. §83.1.

20

Congressional Research Service

3

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

group. Any petitioner that uses one of these methods for demonstrating political influence will be

deemed to have established community for that point in time.

Governing Document

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(d) requires the petitioner to provide a copy of the governing document,

including membership criteria.

Descent from an Indian Tribe

25 C.F.R. 83.7(e) requires that the petitioner’s membership consists of individuals who descend

from a historical Indian tribe or from historical Indian tribes that combined and operated as a

single entity. Section 83.7(e) also requires petitioners to provide membership lists.

Members Must Not Be Members of a Federally Recognized Tribe

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(f) requires that the petitioner’s membership is “composed principally of

persons who are not members of any acknowledged North American Indian tribe.”

Termination

25 C.F.R. Section 83.7(g) requires that the petitioner establish that “[n]either the petitioner nor its

members are the subject of congressional legislation that has expressly terminated or forbidden

the Federal relationship.”

Previous Federal Acknowledgment

If a petitioner can demonstrate “unambiguous previous Federal acknowledgment,” the proof

required for the mandatory criteria is different.22 The Assistant Secretary will make a

determination about previous federal acknowledgment during the technical assistance review.

Evidence to demonstrate previous federal acknowledgment can include treaty relations with the

United States; congressional or executive denomination of the group as a tribe; or federal

acknowledgment of collective interest in tribal lands or funds.23 The proof under the criteria

changes in the following ways. First, a petitioner with previous federal acknowledgment must

demonstrate identification as an Indian entity from the date of the last federal acknowledgment.24

Second, the petitioner needs to demonstrate only that it is presently a community.25 Third, the

petitioner must demonstrate political influence or authority at present, as well as from the last

date of federal acknowledgment, and it can use “identification by authoritative, knowledgeable

external sources[] of leaders and/or a governing body who exercise political influence or

authority” together with one form of evidence listed in Section 83.7(c).26 Alternatively, the

22

25 C.F.R. §83.8.

25 C.F.R. §83.8(c).

24

25 C.F.R. §83.8(d)(1).

25

25 C.F.R. §83.8(d)(2).

26

25 C.F.R. §83.8(d)(3).

23

Congressional Research Service

4

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

petitioner can demonstrate identification, community, and political influence or authority from the

date of last federal acknowledgment to the present.27

Review of the Documented Petition

Expedited Negative Determinations

After technical assistance but before active consideration of the petition, the team within OFA

reviews any petitions that it believes contains little or no evidence that establishes that its

members descend from a historical Indian tribe or tribes; its members are not members of a

federally recognized tribe; and it has not been the subject of congressional termination.28 If the

evidence “clearly establishes” that the group does not meet any of those criteria, the Assistant

Secretary will not review the entire petition. Rather, the Assistant Secretary will decline to

acknowledge the petitioner as an Indian tribe.

Active Consideration

The Assistant Secretary has one year from the time the team begins active consideration of a

petition until when he must publish a proposed finding in the Federal Register.29 The Assistant

Secretary may suspend consideration of the petition if there are technical problems with the

petition or administrative problems that temporarily prevent active consideration of the petition.30

The Assistant Secretary has discretion to grant a petitioner’s request for suspension of

consideration for good cause.31

Upon publication of the proposed finding, the petitioner, interested parties,32 and informed

parties33 have 180 days to submit arguments and evidence to rebut or support the proposed

finding.34 The Assistant Secretary has discretion to extend the comment period for up to 180 days

for good cause.35 Upon request by the petitioner or an interested party, the Assistant Secretary will

hold a formal hearing for the purposes of inquiring into the reasoning, analysis, and factual basis

for the proposed finding.36

27

25 C.F.R. §83.8(d)(5).

25 C.F.R. §83.10(e).

29

25 C.F.R. §83.10(h).

30

25 C.F.R. §83.10(g).

31

Id.

32

25 C.F.R. Section 83.1 defines an “interested party” to mean “any person, organization or other entity who can

establish a legal, factual or property interest in an acknowledgement determination and who requests an opportunity to

submit comments or evidence or to be kept informed of general actions regarding a specific petitioner. ‘Interested

party’ includes the governor and attorney general of the state in which a petitioner is located and may include, but is not

limited to, local governmental units, and any recognized Indian tribes and unrecognized Indian groups that might be

affected by an acknowledgment determination.”

33

25 C.F.R. Section 83.1 defines “informed party” to mean “any person or organization, other than an interested party,

who requests an opportunity to submit comments or evidence or to be kept informed of general actions regarding a

specific petition.”

34

25 C.F.R. §83.10(i).

35

Id.

36

25 C.F.R. §83.10(j)(2).

28

Congressional Research Service

5

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

The petitioner has 60 days to respond to the comments of an interested or informed party.

Depending on the extent of the comments, the petitioner’s response time may be extended at the

Assistant Secretary’s discretion.

At the end of the comment period, the Assistant Secretary consults with the petitioner and

interested parties to determine “an equitable timeframe” for consideration of the materials

submitted during the response period.37

The Assistant Secretary has 60 days from the time the team begins consideration of the arguments

and evidence supporting or rebutting the proposed finding to publish a final determination in the

Federal Register.38 The Assistant Secretary has discretion to extend this period depending on the

extent of the comments received in response to the proposed finding.39

The final determination becomes final 90 days from publication in the Federal Register unless a

request for reconsideration is filed by the petitioner or an interested party with the Interior Board

of Indian Appeals (IBIA).40

Reconsideration

There is an opportunity for review of the final determination if the petitioner or an interested

party requests reconsideration from the IBIA within 90 days of publication of the final

determination in the Federal Register.41 If the IBIA receives no request within 90 days, the final

determination becomes a final agency action for the Department,42 and becomes effective 120

days after the final determination was published in the Federal Register.43 The Department does

not defend the final determination during the reconsideration process. Rather, the petitioner and

the interested parties submit briefs supporting or challenging the final determination.

Grounds for Reconsideration by the IBIA

There are four grounds for limited independent reconsideration by the IBIA:

•

“[T]here is new evidence that could affect the determination;”44

•

“[A] substantial portion of the evidence relied upon in the [final] determination

was unreliable or was of little probative value;”45

•

The petitioner’s or the Assistant Secretary’s research “appears inadequate or

incomplete in some material respect;”46

37

25 C.F.R. §83.10(l).

25 C.F.R. §83.10(l)(2).

39

25 C.F.R. §83.10(l)(3).

40

25 C.F.R. §83.10(l)(4).

41

25 C.F.R. §83.11.

42

25 C.F.R. §83.11(a)(2).

43

25 C.F.R. §83.11(h)(1).

44

25 C.F.R. §83.11(d)(1).

45

25 C.F.R. §83.11(d)(2).

46

25 C.F.R. §83.11(d)(3).

38

Congressional Research Service

6

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

•

“[T]here are reasonable alternative interpretations, not previously considered, of

the evidence used for the final determination, that would substantially affect the

determination that the petitioner meets or does not meet one or more of the

criteria.”47

Actions by the IBIA

The IBIA can either affirm the Assistant Secretary’s determination, if it finds that the petitioner or

interested party has failed to establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, at least one of the

above grounds, or vacate and remand the determination, if it finds that the petitioner or interested

party has succeeded in establishing, by a preponderance of the evidence, one of the above

grounds.48 The IBIA does not have authority to reverse the Assistant Secretary’s final

determination.

Reconsideration on Other Grounds

If the IBIA affirms the final determination but finds that the petitioner or interested party has

alleged other grounds for reconsideration, the IBIA must send the requests for reconsideration to

the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary).49 The Secretary has discretion to request the Assistant

Secretary to reconsider the final determination on those grounds.50 In considering whether to

request the Assistant Secretary to reconsider, the Secretary may consider any information,

including information outside the record.51 When the IBIA has sent the Secretary a request for

reconsideration, the petitioner and interested parties have 30 days from receiving notice of the

IBIA’s decision to submit comments to the Secretary.52 If an interested party files comments

opposing the petitioner’s request for reconsideration, the petitioner has 15 days to respond.53 The

Secretary has 60 days after receiving all the comments to decide whether to request the Assistant

Secretary to reconsider.54 If the Secretary decides not to request reconsideration by the Assistant

Secretary, the final determination becomes final on the date the parties are notified of the

Secretary’s decision.55

Reconsideration by the Assistant Secretary

After a remand from the IBIA or a request for reconsideration by the Secretary, the Assistant

Secretary has 120 days from receipt of the IBIA’s decision or the request from the Secretary to

issue a reconsidered determination.56 A reconsidered final determination becomes final and

47

25 C.F.R. §83.11(d)(4).

25 C.F.R. §83.11(e)(9) and (10).

49

25 C.F.R. §83.11(f)(2). In addition to affirming or remanding to the Assistant Secretary, the IBIA must describe any

grounds for reconsideration, other than those listed above, alleged by a petitioner or interested party. 25 C.F.R.

§83.11(f)(1).

50

Id.

51

25 C.F.R. §83.11(f)(3).

52

25 C.F.R. §83.11(f)(4).

53

Id.

54

25 C.F.R. §83.11(f)(5).

55

25 C.F.R. §83.11(h)(2).

56

25 C.F.R. §83.11(g)(1).

48

Congressional Research Service

7

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

effective upon publication of the notice of the reconsidered determination in the Federal

Register.57

The Proposed Rule

In May 2014, Interior proposed a new rule for Part 83 that would comprehensively change the

acknowledgment process.58 The preamble to the proposed rule explains that Interior issued the

proposed rule in response to criticism that the acknowledgment process is too slow, expensive,

inefficient, burdensome, intrusive, less than transparent, and unpredictable. Accordingly, the

proposed rule would change Part 83 in an effort “to make the process and criteria more

transparent, promote consistent implementation, and increase timeliness and efficiency, while

maintaining the integrity of the process.” The public may submit comments on the proposed rule

until August 1, 2014.

Changes to the Criteria

The proposed rule would make several changes to the criteria.

First, the proposed rule would change criterion (a) from identification as an Indian entity from

1900 to the present to a narrative explaining, and proof of, tribal existence at some point in 1900

or before.

Current criteria 87.3(b) and (c) require proof of community and proof of political authority from

historical times to the present. Proposed criteria (b) and (c) would require proof of community

and political authority from 1934 to the present “without substantial interruption.” “Without

substantial interruption” would be defined to mean without gaps of more than 20 years. In

addition to the current bases for finding community and political authority, the proposed rule

would establish as acceptable proof maintaining a state reservation by the petitioner since 1934,

or the United States holding land for the petitioner at any point since 1934. For criterion (b) the

current rule requires that a predominant portion of the petitioner’s membership be a distinct

community. The proposed rule would require that at least 30% of the petitioner’s membership be

a distinct community. The proposed rule would also provide that proof of boarding school

attendance by petitioner’s children would constitute proof of community.

For criterion (e), descent from a historical tribe, the proposed rule would make three changes.

First, under the current rule the term “historical” is defined to mean the later of 1789 or first nonIndian settlement or government presence in the area. The proposed rule would define historical

as 1900 or before. Second, the proposed rule would change the requirement of proof that the

tribe’s membership descends from a historical tribe to proof that 80% of the membership

descends from a historical tribe. Third, the proposed rule would establish that criterion (e) may be

satisfied by a roll prepared either by Interior or at the direction of Congress, and that Interior will

rely on such a roll as an accurate roll of descendants of the tribe that existed in historical times. In

57

25 C.F.R. §83.11(h)(3).

The proposed rule is available on the Bureau of Indian Affairs website: http://bia.gov/cs/groups/xopa/documents/text/

idc1-026772.pdf.

58

Congressional Research Service

8

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

the absence of such a roll, the petitioner may rely on the most recent available evidence for the

historical period (1900 or before).

Criterion 83.7(f) requires that the petitioner is composed principally of persons who are not

members of federally recognized tribes. The proposed rule would add that members of a

petitioner who filed its petition by 2010 who then joined a federally recognized tribe would not

count against the petitioner.

Finally, criterion 83.7(g) now requires petitioners to establish that they are not subject to

legislation forbidding or terminating the tribal-federal relationship. The proposed rule would shift

the burden to Interior to show that Congress has forbidden or terminated the federal relationship

with the petitioner.

Changes to the Process

The proposed rule would make several changes to the acknowledgment process, the most

significant of which are described below.

Under the current practice, OFA makes recommendations to the Assistant Secretary, whom the

current regulations charge with making proposed findings and final determinations. Under the

proposed rule, OFA would issue proposed findings and the Assistant Secretary would make final

determinations. The Assistant Secretary’s decision would be final for Interior, with no

consideration by the IBIA.

The proposed rule would provide for consideration of the criterion in stages and provide that

petitioners receiving a negative proposed finding at any stage could appeal the finding to a judge

within the Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA). The OHA judge could hold a hearing and

would issue recommendations for the Assistant Secretary to consider in making the final

determination. During the first stage of making proposed findings, OFA would consider criterion

(e) (descent from a historical tribe). If a petitioner satisfied criterion (e), OFA would then consider

criteria (a) (tribal existence), (d) (governing document), (f) (membership), and (g) (congressional

prohibition or termination). Finally, if the petitioner satisfied those criteria, OFA would consider

criteria (b) (community) and (c) (political authority). If a petitioner made it through all stages of

review, OFA would issue a positive proposed finding.

The proposed rule would provide that, in limited circumstances, petitioners that received negative

final determinations under the current rule could re-petition. First, if the Assistant Secretary

issued a negative final determination and the petitioner appealed to the IBIA or federal court and

lost, the petitioner could re-petition if it obtained the consent of the prevailing party, if any, in

those proceedings. Second, if a petitioner did not seek review by the IBIA or a federal court, or it

did but there was no opposing party, a petitioner could re-petition if an OHA judge determined

that the petitioner had demonstrated by a preponderance of the evidence that changes in the rules

warranted a reconsideration of the final determination or that the wrong standard of proof was

used in the final determination.

Congressional Research Service

9

The Administrative Process by Which Groups May Be Acknowledged as Indian Tribes

Author Contact Information

(name redacted)

Legislative Attorney

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....

Congressional Research Service

10

EveryCRSReport.com

The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the

Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on

issues that may come before Congress.

EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The

reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to

the public.

Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts

who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made

any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.

CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in

the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without

permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a

third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or

otherwise use copyrighted material.

Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public

understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in

connection with CRS' institutional role.

EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim

copyright on any CRS report we have republished.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.