Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Congressional research reportFeb 4, 2013
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and
Industry
name redacted
Specialist in Energy Policy
name redacted
Specialist in Energy and Natural Resources Policy
name redacted
Specialist in Energy Policy
February 4, 2013
Congressional Research Service
7-....
www.crs.gov
R42950
CRS Report for Congress
Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Summary
For most of the twentieth century, the primary use of coal in the United States was for electric
power generation, and for most of the history of power generation in the United States, coal has
been the dominant fuel used to produce electricity. Even as recently as 2011, coal was the fuel
used for almost 42% of power generation in the United States accounting for 93% of coal use.
Industrial uses represented the remaining 7%. However, in April 2012, coal’s share of the power
generation market dropped to about 32% (according to Energy Information Administration
statistics), equal to that of natural gas. Coal was the fuel of choice because of its availability and
the relatively low cost of producing electricity in large, coal-burning power plants which took
advantage of coal’s low-priced, high energy content to employ economies of scale in steamelectric production. However, coal use for power generation seems to be on the decline, and the
magnitude of coal’s role for power generation is in question. Two major reasons are generally
seen as being responsible: the expectation of a dramatic rise in natural gas supplies, and the
impact of environmental regulations on an aging base of coal-fired power plants.
A recent drop in natural gas prices has been enabled by increasing supplies of natural gas largely
due to horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing (i.e., fracking) of shale gas formations. If the
production can be sustained in an environmentally acceptable manner, then a long-term, relatively
inexpensive supply of natural gas could result. Decreased natural gas prices are lowering
wholesale electricity prices, stimulating a major switch from coal to gas-burning facilities. The
electric utility industry values diversity in fuel choice options since reliance on one fuel or
technology can leave electricity producers vulnerable to price and supply volatility. However, an
“inverse relationship” may be developing for coal vs. natural gas as a power generation choice
based on market economics alone, and policies which allow one fuel source to dominate may
come at the detriment of the other.
Coal-fired power plants are among the largest sources of air pollution in the United States. More
than half a dozen separate Clean Air Act programs could possibly be used to control emissions,
which makes compliance strategy potentially complicated for utilities and difficult for regulators.
Because the cost of the most stringent available controls, for the entire industry, could range into
the tens of billions of dollars, some power companies have fought hard and rather successfully to
limit or delay regulations affecting them, particularly with respect to plants constructed before the
Clean Air Act Amendments of 1970 were passed. The expected retirement of approximately 27
GW of coal-fired capacity by 2016 has been reported to the Energy Information Administration
(EIA) by coal plant owners and operators, accounting for approximately 8.5% of U.S. coal-fired
capacity. While the costs of compliance with new Environmental Protection Agency regulations
are a factor, several other issues are cited by coal plant owners and operators as contributing to
these retirement decisions including the age of coal-fired power plants, flat to modest electricity
demand growth, the availability of previously underutilized natural gas combined-cycle power
plants, and the lower price of natural gas due to shale gas development. Even coal plants which
have made significant modifications to meet existing EPA regulations are being closed or
mothballed due to a combination of low natural gas prices, and the inability to sell power into
other markets.
EIA expects coal to be a significant part of the U.S. power generation industry’s future to well
past 2030. But given price competition from natural gas, and emerging environmental
regulations, that role will likely be smaller than in recent decades. Coal-fired generation is likely
to face a challenging future.
Congressional Research Service
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Contents
Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 1
Electric Power Generation ............................................................................................................... 2
Recent Changes in Markets for Electricity Fuels ...................................................................... 4
Potential Coal Plant Retirements ............................................................................................... 8
Role of New and Alternative Power Generation Technologies ............................................... 14
Industrial Coal Consumption ......................................................................................................... 16
Issues for Congress ........................................................................................................................ 17
Figures
Figure 1. Flow of U.S. Coal Consumption for 2011 ........................................................................ 1
Figure 2. Sources of Electric Power Generation.............................................................................. 2
Figure 3. Fuel Consumption for Electricity Generation 2002-2011 ................................................ 4
Figure 4. Cost of Fuel for Electricity Generation, 2002-2011 ......................................................... 6
Figure 5. Net Generation—Coal vs. Natural Gas ............................................................................ 7
Figure 6. Percentage of Electricity Generated from Coal by State, 2010 ...................................... 12
Figure 7. Industrial Sector Share of Total U.S. Coal Consumption ............................................... 17
Tables
Table 1. 2011 Industrial Sector Coal Consumption ....................................................................... 17
Contacts
Author Contact Information........................................................................................................... 18
Acknowledgments ......................................................................................................................... 18
Congressional Research Service
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Introduction
Coal has been the fuel most used for thermal energy since the early days of the Industrial
Revolution. However, the mechanization of factories quickly brought a shift in coal use from heat
to steam engines, and then to fuel steam turbines to power the electric motors of industry. The
advent of electrical lighting and the electrification of buildings and residences drove even greater
demand for electricity. For most of the twentieth century, the primary use of coal in the United
States was for electric power generation.
In 2011, 93% of coal consumed in the United States was for electric power production, according
to the Energy Information Administration (EIA). Figure 1 shows the use of the four major types
of coal produced in the United States, with bituminous and subbituminous coal dominating
electric power generation.
Figure 1. Flow of U.S. Coal Consumption for 2011
(Million Short Tons)
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration. See http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/annual/pdf/sec7_3.pdf.
The various types of coal differ mostly in carbon content and heating value:
•
Anthracite has the highest carbon content (between 86% and 98%), and a heat value of
about 15,000 British Thermal Units (BTUs) per pound.1 Anthracite coal is a small part of
the electric power market, and is mostly found in the Appalachian region of
Pennsylvania.
1
The heating value of any fuel is the energy released per unit mass or per unit volume of the fuel when the fuel is
completely burned. Higher heat value fuels liberate more energy per unit of mass or volume.
Congressional Research Service
1
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
•
Bituminous is the most abundant form of coal in the United States, and is the type most
commonly used to generate electricity. Bituminous coal has a carbon content of
approximately 45% to 86%, and a heat value between 10,500 BTUs and 15,500 BTUs.
•
Subbituminous coal is mostly found in six western states and Alaska. It has a carbon
content of between 35% and 45%, and a heat value of between 8,300 BTUs and 13,000
BTUs. Subbituminous coal generally has a lower sulfur content than other types of coal.
•
Lignite has the lowest carbon content of the four types of coal generally used for electric
power generation, averaging between 25% and 35%, and a high moisture and ash content.
It also has the lowest heat value ranging between 4,000 BTUs and 8,300 BTUs.
Electric Power Generation
For most of the history of power generation in the United States, coal has been the dominant fuel
used to produce electricity. Even as recently as 2011, coal was used to fuel almost 42% of power
generation in the United States, as shown in Figure 2. Coal has been the fuel of choice for many
decades because of its wide availability, and the relatively low cost of producing electricity in
large, coal-burning power plants. Coal’s low-priced, high energy content enabled the building of
power plants able to take advantage of economies of scale in steam-electric production.
Figure 2. Sources of Electric Power Generation
Net U.S. Generation 2011
Source: CRS. Data from Energy Information Administration. Electric Power Monthly. Table 1.1, All sources of
power.
In a steam power plant, coal (or other fossil fuel) is burned to provide heat for turning water into
steam in a boiler.2 The steam is then forced under pressure into a steam turbine-driven generator
2
A simple cycle natural gas power plant burns natural gas in a combustion turbine (like a jet engine) to turn a generator
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
2
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
which produces electricity. As of 2011, the U.S. coal-powered generation fleet consisted of 1,387
units with a nameplate capacity of almost 318 gigawatts3 (GW)4 representing approximately 30%
of total U.S. generating capacity.5 Electric utilities and independent power producers6 are the
primary entities involved in U.S. electricity production. Together, these electric power sector
participants have combined for an average annual consumption of almost 995 million tons of coal
in the period from 2002 to 2011,7 with electric utilities consuming between 60% to 70% of the
total (primarily in base load8 power plants).
The capital costs of power plant construction (i.e., the costs of finance and construction) vary
according to the type (for example, coal or nuclear), and size of power plant. The cost for these
plants to generate electricity is largely based on their cost of fuel, as well as operations and
maintenance costs, other capital costs, and how the power plant is operated (for example, whether
the facility is run as a base load or peaking9 facility).10 While the regulatory regime (i.e., under a
rate-regulated or competitive environment), costs of transmission and distribution, and weather
are strong determinants, the cost of fuel is often the major factor affecting electricity production
especially for power plants which have already recovered their capital costs of construction.
Transportation costs for coal have historically been a major consideration in the choice of coal as
a fuel. Barge transport is used where river access is available. But rail transportation is the most
common mode of transit for coal as unit trains11 offer the ability to transport large shipments to
power plants on a regular basis. However, rail transportation can be costly.
First, coal-burning electric power plants receive approximately 72 percent of their coal by
rail. Second, rail transportation costs account for a sizable share of total delivered costs.
While, on average, transportation costs account for approximately 20 percent of total
[delivered] costs, they can reach as high as 59 percent on shipments of coal originating in the
Powder River Basin.12
(...continued)
which produces electricity. When used in a combined cycle mode, the hot exhaust gases from the combustion turbine
are used to generate steam to turn a steam turbine to efficiently create additional electricity.
3
One billion watts or one thousand megawatts.
4
See http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=7290.
5
See http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/annual/showtext.cfm?t=ptb0811a.
6
A corporation, person, agency, authority, or other legal entity or instrumentality that owns or operates facilities for the
generation of electricity for use primarily by the public, and that is not an electric utility. See http://www.eia.gov/tools/
glossary/index.cfm?id=I#ind_pwr_prod.
7
EIA, Table 2.1.A. Coal: Consumption for Electricity Generation, 2002-2011, http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/
pdf/epm.pdf.
8
A plant, usually housing high-efficiency steam-electric units, which is normally operated to take all or part of the
minimum load of a system, and which consequently produces electricity at an essentially constant rate and runs
continuously. These units are operated to maximize system mechanical and thermal efficiency and minimize system
operating costs. EIA, EIA Glossary “Base Load Plant”, http://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.cfm.
9
A plant usually housing old, low-efficiency steam units, gas turbines, diesels, or pumped-storage hydroelectric
equipment normally used during the peak-load periods. See http://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.cfm.
10
Black and Veatch, Cost Report—Cost and Performance Data for Power Generation Technologies, National
Renewable Energy Laboratory, February 2012, http://bv.com/docs/reports-studies/nrel-cost-report.pdf.
11
Typically, all the freight cars on a “unit train” are filled with coal being shipped directly to a single destination.
12
See http://www.eia.gov/coal/transportationrates/.
Congressional Research Service
3
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
U.S. coal transportation costs are cited as a major reason why many utilities in the New England
states have chosen to generate electricity with natural gas, or import coal from overseas as a
lower cost alternative.13
Recent Changes in Markets for Electricity Fuels
The amounts of coal consumed for electricity generation from 2002 to 2011 are shown in Figure
3. While coal was the dominant fuel for electricity production in the period, the trend of
increasing consumption seems to be slowing with a recent downturn in coal consumption for
electricity beginning in about 2008. At the same time, natural gas use for electric power
production is rising.
Figure 3. Fuel Consumption for Electricity Generation 2002-2011
Electric Utilities and Independent Power Producers
Source: CRS, data from U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), Electric Power Monthly, Table 2.1.A, “Coal:
Consumption for Electricity Generation by Sector,” at http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/pdf/epm.pdf,
September 2012; CRS, data from U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), Electric Power Monthly, Table
2.4.A, “Natural Gas: Consumption for Electricity Generation by Sector,” at http://www.eia.gov/electricity/
monthly/pdf/epm.pdf.
Increasing supplies of natural gas are largely behind the switch in fuel for power generation.
Natural gas prices have been volatile over the last few decades, ranging from less than $2 per
million Btus (MMBTU) to over $18 per MMBTU.14 However, supplies of natural gas increased
markedly beginning in 2008-2009 largely due to development of unconventional shale gas
through improved drilling and simulation techniques. Horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing
13
See ISO New England, “Scenario Analysis Project—Long Term Forecast of Oil, Natural Gas and Coal Prices in New
England,” 2007, http://www.isone.com/committees/comm_wkgrps/othr/sas/mtrls/apr22007/fuel-price-forecast.pdf.
14
See Energy Information Administration, Office of Oil and Gas, An Analysis of Price Volatility in Natural Gas
Markets, “Figure 1: Daily Henry Hub Spot Price, 1994-2006,” August 2007, http://www.eia.gov/pub/oil_gas/
natural_gas/feature_articles/2007/ngprivolatility/ngprivolatility.pdf.
Congressional Research Service
4
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
(i.e., fracking) have dramatically improved shale gas production, and the increased supplies of
natural gas have caused prices to fall.
Power Plant Dispatch and Competitive Power Production
Many regions of the United States use competitive markets for power generation which sell into the wholesale
market. These markets are generally administered by regional transmission organizations (RTOs) which have a goal of
minimizing the cost of wholesale electricity to distribution utilities. The distribution utilities sell power to end-use
(retail) consumers. In RTO markets, power plants bid against each other to serve the electricity demand of the
wholesale market. Operators “dispatch” (or schedule the operation of) power plants based on the least costly choice,
considering forecast loads and transmission system constraints for specific load increments at various times of the day
or year. The most efficient power plants with the lowest heat rates (the efficiency with which a power plant turns fuel
into electricity) are typically dispatched more, and lower efficiency, higher heat rate units are dispatched less.
Lower natural gas prices have caused wholesale electricity prices to decline, lowering potential revenues. However,
many of the newer, more efficient natural gas combined cycle power generation plants have heat rates around 7,000
BTU/kWh (compared to today’s coal plants with an overall average heat rate of 10,000 BTU/kWh). As natural gas
prices have declined, natural gas plants have been dispatched more, and gross margins have increased with the spark
spread (a measure of the potential profitability of a natural gas-fired power plant based on the difference between the
price that a generator can obtain from selling one megawatt hour (MWh) of electricity and the cost of the natural gas
needed to generate the MWh of electricity).
For coal plants, the lower cost of wholesale power has combined with the rising costs of coal to decrease their
potential profitability. Older, less efficient coal power plants are especially at risk because wholesale prices of
electricity may be inadequate for such facilities to operate economically.
Figure 4 shows natural gas and coal fuel costs for electricity production from 2002 to 2012. The
right-most part of the chart is based on monthly data, illustrating the recent drop in natural gas
prices for electricity production while coal costs continue to inch higher. The drop in natural gas
prices is a major factor in the recent switch from coal to gas-burning facilities, since the cost of
fuel is a major determinant in the dispatch of electricity production. Switching from coal to gas
generation has largely involved a switch from base load coal generation to intermediate load15
natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) capacity. There are varying amounts of underutilized NGCC
capacity available in various regions of the United States. That underutilized capacity resulted
largely from the natural gas “bubble” of the 1980s and 1990s when natural gas prices were
generally about $2 per MMBTU.
Fuel cost to generate electricity is the key in the decision to switch from coal to natural gas
generation. If a power plant was 100% efficient, it would take 3.412 MMBTU to generate 1
MWh of electricity. Assuming that an intermediate capacity NGCC plant is 44.78% efficient, it
would consume 7.619 MMBTUs to generate 1 MWh of electricity. Similarly, a base load coal
plant with an efficiency of 33.64% would use 10.412 MMBTUs to generate 1 MWh of
electricity.16 The cost of fuel to generate 1 MWh of electricity from coal has historically been
lower than the cost to generate power from natural gas. The economics are now changing with
coal prices rising and the drop in natural gas prices in 2011 down to levels where it now becomes
15
The range from base load to a point between base load and peak load.
Sandy Fielden, “The Economics of Coal-to-Gas Switching,” Power Magazine, August 21, 2012,
http://www.powermag.com/business/The-Economics-of-Coal-to-Gas-Switching_4880_p4.html.
16
Congressional Research Service
5
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
more expensive to generate electricity from coal, especially when power plant efficiency is taken
into account.
Figure 4. Cost of Fuel for Electricity Generation, 2002-2011
Source: CRS, data from EIA, “Table 4.2, Receipts, Average Cost, and Quality of Fuel, Electric Utilities” at
http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/pdf/epm.pdf. CRS. Data from EIA, Table 4.2, Receipts, Average Cost, and
Quality of Fuel, Electric Utilities at http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/pdf/epm.pdf.
While the chart in Figure 5 shows the expected rise and fall of power production with the seasons
in the 2009 to 2012 timeframe, a look behind the numbers reveals the shift in generation as more
power is being dispatched from higher efficiency natural gas-fired power plants.17 During this
time, coal’s share of total U.S electricity generation has dropped and the use of natural gas to
generate electricity has risen as newer, more efficient natural gas-fired generating capacity are
being dispatched.18 In April 2012, for the first time in history, the amount of electricity generation
from natural gas equaled that of coal, according to EIA statistics, each with about 32% of the
market.19
17
EIA, “Natural Gas Spot Prices near 10-Year Lows Amid Warm Weather and Robust Supplies,” February 1, 2012,
http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=4810.
18
“Coal generation decreased 29 billion kilowatt-hours from March 2011 to March 2012, while natural gas generation
increased 27 billion kilowatt-hours during the same time period. In March 2012, coal’s share of total generation was
34% compared to natural gas at 30%.” See EIA, “U.S. Coal’s Share of Total Net Generation Continues to Decline,”
June 5, 2012, http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=6550.
19
U.S. Energy Information Administration, Net Generation by Energy Source: Total (All Sectors), 2002-June 2012,
July 2012, http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cfm?t=epmt_1_1.
Congressional Research Service
6
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Figure 5. Net Generation—Coal vs. Natural Gas
Period from 2009 to 2012
Source: CRS, data from EIA. See http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=6550.
Many in the energy industry believe that a structural change in the economics of natural gas use
has begun.
While coal is projected to retain the largest share of the electricity generation mix through
2035, analyses included in the Annual Energy Outlook 2012 ... anticipate its share declining
as more generation comes from natural gas and renewable technologies. Coal’s role as the
preeminent source of electricity generation in the United States has lessened in recent years,
declining from 49% of total electricity generation in 2007 to 42% in 2011.... Projected fuel
prices and economic growth are key factors influencing the future electricity generation mix.
The price of natural gas, coal’s chief competitor, has dropped significantly in recent years
due to the increase in domestic production of natural gas.20
Nevertheless, there is still much debate as to whether the “shale gas revolution” will result in a
predictable, long-term increase in supplies of natural gas at relatively low prices.
Considerable uncertainty exists regarding the size of the economically recoverable U.S. shale
gas resource base and the cost of producing those resources. Across four shale gas resource
scenarios from the [EIA’s] Annual Energy Outlook 2012, natural gas prices vary by about
$4/MMBtu in 2035, demonstrating the significant impact that shale gas resource uncertainty
has in determining future natural gas prices. This uncertainty exists primarily because shale
gas wells exhibit a wide variation in their initial production rate, rate of decline, and
estimated ultimate recovery per well (or EUR, which is the expected cumulative production
over the life of a well).21
20
EIA, “Fuel Used in Electricity Generation Is Projected to Shift over the Next 25 Years,” July 30, 2012,
http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=7310.
21
EIA, Projected Natural Gas Prices Depend on Shale Gas Resource Economics,” August 27, 2012,
http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=7710.
Congressional Research Service
7
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
If these previously unconventional shale gas resources can be economically developed and
produced in an environmentally acceptable manner, then a sustained, relatively inexpensive
supply of natural gas could persist. 22
As long as natural gas prices are “relatively” high, development of resources will continue. When
a surplus of natural gas supplies causes the price to drop, resource development activities solely
focused on natural gas tend to curtail. But fracking of shale gas resources is changing the outlook
for natural gas supplies, and the recovery of oil from wet shale plays is currently driving
development. Even so, the expectation of lower, less volatile prices from increased supplies is
encouraging the greater use of natural gas for electric power generation and other industrial uses.
Natural gas prices are still subject to forces of supply and demand, with the cost of developing
incremental supplies determining future supplies of the resource. Further development of the
interstate pipeline system may also be needed if these new natural gas supplies are to reach
markets.23
How the natural gas industry will accommodate the expected demands of the power generation
industry for gas supplies is also uncertain. Power plants purchase coal under long-term contracts,
amassing the fuel on-site in large, managed coal storage piles which may hold a 30-day supply.
Most natural gas power generation plants are served directly by pipelines, and manage the fuel as
more of a “just-in-time” resource, since power plants typically do not have large natural gas
storage capabilities. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission observes that based on recent
supply issues, this new volume of expected demand for natural gas may require more longer term
coordination and planning between the electricity and natural gas supply industries.24
Potential Coal Plant Retirements
All power plants are subject to retirement when they reach they reach the end of their useful
service life. While older coal-fired power plants are usually well-maintained, they are generally
not as efficient as newer power plants. As power plants age, they are generally upgraded to
continue operations, but the least efficient plants may be retired. Other plants may be shifted from
base load operations (in which they essentially operate around the clock) to less demanding
intermediate or peaking schedules. The cost of building a power plant is generally recovered over
the depreciable life of the asset, such that operations and maintenance (O&M) expenses become
the major component of an older power plant’s continuing costs. A major component of O&M is
the cost of fuel, and the expectation of continued lower prices for natural gas is weighing on
decisions concerning whether many older, less efficient coal power plants will be mothballed or
closed altogether. However, the costs of modernizing older power plants to meet new regulatory
requirements can be relatively high. When the cost of upgrades to meet new environmental
requirements is considered along with (perhaps increasing) O&M expenses, many older coal
power plants are likely to face outright retirement decisions.
22
For further discussion of natural gas production, see CRS Report R42814, Natural Gas in the U.S. Economy:
Opportunities for Growth, by (name redacted) and (name redacted)
23
Jack Buehrer, Natural Gas Boom Drives Pipeline Upgrades, Engineering News Record, May 7, 2012,
http://enr.construction.com/infrastructure/power_industrial/2012/0507-shaleboomhttpprimisphmsadotgovconstructionconstphmsahtm.asp.
24
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Natural Gas - Electric Coordination, August 2012, http://www.ferc.gov/
industries/electric/indus-act/electric-coord.asp.
Congressional Research Service
8
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Over the last 40 years, Congress has directed EPA to reduce the potential health and
environmental impacts of fossil fuel use by limiting emissions by-products or other consequences
of combustion processes.25 These environmental regulatory requirements have been evolving in
the last decade due to various challenges to the regulatory implementation of federal laws. Much
attention has focused recently on the resulting finalization of some of these regulations, and their
potential to contribute to the retirement of some coal-burning power plants.
In addition to being the largest source of electric power, coal-fired power plants are among the
largest sources of air pollution in the United States. Under the Clean Air Act (CAA),26 however,
they have not necessarily been subject to stringent requirements: emissions and the required
control equipment can vary depending on the location of the plant, when it was constructed,
whether it has undergone major modifications, the specific type of fuel it burns, and, to some
extent, the vagaries of EPA enforcement policies. More than half a dozen separate CAA programs
could potentially be used to control emissions, which makes compliance strategy potentially
complicated for utilities and difficult for regulators. Because the cost of the most stringent
available controls, for the entire industry, could range into the tens of billions of dollars, power
companies have fought hard and rather successfully to limit or delay regulations affecting them,
particularly with respect to plants constructed before the Clean Air Act of 1970 was passed.
However, EPA contends that such costs would be more than outweighed by societal benefits from
reduced respiratory and other illnesses—“externalities” that are largely not currently accounted
for in the price of electricity generation but which are estimated by EPA as costing the United
States billions of dollars annually in health care and environmental costs.27
Some of the new rules under development at the EPA would be implemented at the federal level,
while others would be implemented at the state level. They include the Cross-State Air Pollution
Rule28 (which replaced the Clean Air Interstate Rule); the Utility Maximum Achievable Control
Technology (Utility MACT) rule to reduce emissions of mercury, other metallic toxics, acid
gases, and organic air toxics; the wet ash classification rule for coal combustion residues; and the
Clean Water Act Section 316(b) guidelines for once-through cooling water systems. However,
only the Utility MACT rule is currently in effect. EPA also proposed standards for greenhouse gas
25
For example, with the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1970 (P.L. 91-604) and subsequent revisions, the Clean Water
Act of 1972 (P.L.92-500), and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (P.L. 94-580).
26
The Clean Air Act, codified as 42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq., seeks to protect human health and the environment from
emissions that pollute ambient, or outdoor, air. It requires the Environmental Protection Agency to establish minimum
national standards for air quality, and assigns primary responsibility to the states to assure compliance with the
standards. Areas not meeting the standards, referred to as “nonattainment areas,” are required to implement specified
air pollution control measures. The Act establishes federal standards for stationary and mobile sources of air pollution
and their fuels and for sources of 187 hazardous air pollutants, and it establishes a cap-and-trade program for the
emissions that cause acid rain. It establishes a comprehensive permit system for all major sources of air pollution. It
also addresses the prevention of pollution in areas with clean air and protection of the stratospheric ozone layer. For
more information, see CRS Report RL30853, Clean Air Act: A Summary of the Act and Its Major Requirements, by
(name redacted), (name redacted), and (name redacted).
27
USEPA Office of Air and Radiation, The Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act: 1990 to 2020, August 2010,
http://www.epa.gov/air/sect812/aug10/fullreport.pdf.
28
On August 21, 2012, in a 2-1 decision, the court vacated and remanded the rule, finding that EPA’s imposition of
Federal Implementation Plans, without first giving the states an opportunity to develop their own plans, was unlawful.
See CRS Report R41563, Clean Air Issues in the 112th Congress, by (name redacted). By vacating the rule, the
Court determined that the Clean Air Interstate Rule would still apply. But that rule was itself vacated, making future
implementation of any air transport rule unclear.
Congressional Research Service
9
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
(GHG) emissions which would require all new power plants to restrict carbon dioxide
emissions.29
EPA has yet to propose rules for GHG emissions from existing power plants, as is required by
court order. Due to a general perception in the electric power industry that these new and pending
environmental regulations present conflating requirements with unrealistic timeframes for
compliance, the regulations have come to be referred to by the industry as the “train wreck”
scenario30 due to a perception that a negative impact on reliability could result. However,
environmental groups, and some in the electric power industry—mainly those with significant
investments in nuclear or natural gas-fired generation—consider the concerns overstated.31
Electricity Reliability—State and Market Inputs
As retirement decisions are announced for growing amounts of coal capacity, questions are being asked about the
cost and types of generation which may replace that capacity. EIA defines electric system reliability as “the degree to
which the performance of the elements of the electrical system results in power being delivered to consumers within
accepted standards and in the amount desired.” Implicit in the definition is the necessity of generation adequacy to
ensure that there is sufficient power plant capacity to meet projected demand, and additional reserves for
exceptionally high demand periods. This includes voltage support (i.e., power injected into the grid to maintain voltage
at acceptable limits) and ancillary services (i.e., services which support the reliable operation of the transmission
system as it moves electricity from generating sources to retail customers) provided by retiring plants. Timely and
appropriate replacement of retiring coal capacity would be essential to maintain reliability levels.
Cost recovery for a new power plant entails not only financial and performance risks, but also potential regulatory
risk. In traditional cost of service states, adding a new power plant to a utility’s rate base can raise customer rates.
While alternatives to potentially expensive new power plant construction may exist (such as demand response), if it
appears that adding a new plant or plants to rate base will result in a significant rate increase, a reluctance may ensue
on the part of state officials to authorize the addition especially in times of economic hardship. Similarly, investorowned utilities are wary of taking on too much debt for new power plant construction as this may decrease earnings
and share price, possibly resulting in a downgrade of a company’s financial rating.
In states with traditional cost of service ratemaking (in which electric utility rates are approved by state utility
commissions), formal authorization is required before electric utilities can site, build, or place power plants into
service thereby receiving recovery of costs in electricity rates. The need for new power plants is typically determined
years in advance by a formal process estimating future demand and the ability of existing generation resources to
meet that demand. A commonly used process is integrated resource planning (IRP), which considers a variety of
supply and demand-side options, and assesses them against a common set of planning objectives and criteria, including
environmental impact. The IRP objective is to help meet future customer demand by identifying the need for
generating capacity, and determining the best mix of resources (including demand response) to fill the need at the
lowest overall cost. Electric utilities often seek to shift the financial risk of building new power plants to ratepayers by
obtaining regulatory approval to begin collecting the cost of the power plant in customer rates before the plant is in
service (i.e., as construction work-in-progress).
Even in RTO markets where power generation is a competitive business, siting of new power plants is subject to
state regulatory processes. However, in competitive markets, the financial risk of building a new power plant lies with
the generator as they seek to bid to sell electricity into the RTO market. RTOs use markets to make operational
decisions (such as generator dispatch) and to determine the provider(s) and prices for many of these services. RTOs
29
Environmental Protection Agency, Carbon Pollution Standard for New Power Plants, http://epa.gov/
carbonpollutionstandard/.
30
These regulations are discussed in separate CRS Reports: CRS Report R41914, EPA’s Regulation of Coal-Fired
Power: Is a “Train Wreck” Coming?, by (name redacted) and (name redacted), and CRS Report R42570,
Proposals to Amend RCRA: Analysis of Pending Legislation Applicable to the Management of Coal Combustion
Residuals, by (name redacted).
31
CRS Report R42144, EPA’s Utility MACT: Will the Lights Go Out?, by (name redacted).
Congressional Research Service
10
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
do not own generation, but rely on price signals (based on real-time prices) to incentivize entry of new generation
resources. Some RTOs employ forward capacity markets (up to three years in advance of expected needs) with
auctions using either vertical demand curves (establishing quantity and allowing price to be set by the market) or
sloped demand curves (regulating the price of new capacity) to contract for future capacity. Other RTOs use an
administrative approach to determine capacity requirements and set prices. However, there is some debate as to
how these market approaches work, and the resulting impact on prices. Other issues include whether forward
capacity markets result in new capacity actually being built, whether the appropriate type of capacity (i.e., base load vs.
intermediate load) is being incentivized and attracted, or even if the administratively-set or auction-determined
capacity price is above the actual cost of new entry in these markets. The issue of prevailing high electricity prices in
some areas (i.e., in load pockets) has led some states in RTO regions to consider authorizing the construction of
power plants or bilateral contracting for electric power independent of RTO capacity market processes.
In 2011, the North American Reliability Corporation (which has oversight of the bulk electric grid
for reliability purposes) analyzed the effects of the proposed EPA regulations for their potential to
accelerate retirement of fossil‐fired units.32 The 2011 assessment was a revision of a previous
analysis to take into account “updated assumptions determined from proposed rules, as well as
other viewpoints on how the rule will ultimately be carried out (i.e., how states may implement
regulations), to determine potential resource adequacy impacts.” NERC noted that the expected
retirements of electric generators are driven by many economic factors, “not simply the cost of
pollution control equipment.” However, NERC’s assessment estimated that between 35 GW and
59 GW of generating capacity could be potentially retired as a result of the proposed EPA rules.
NERC summarized its concerns as to the possible effects on reliability:
Existing and proposed environmental regulations in the U.S. may significantly affect bulk
power system reliability depending on the scope and timing of the rule implementation and
the mechanisms in place to preserve reliability.33
For its part, the Department of Energy (DOE) estimated in 2011 that new air pollution, water, and
waste disposal proposed rules could eventually result in the retirement of between 35 GW and 70
GW of coal-fired capacity.34
The expected retirement of approximately 27 GW of coal-fired capacity by 2016 has been
reported to EIA by coal plant owners and operators, accounting for approximately 8.5% of U.S.
coal-fired capacity. While the costs of compliance with new EPA environmental regulations are a
factor, several other issues are cited by coal plant owners and operators as contributing to these
retirement decisions including the age of coal-fired power plants, modest electricity demand
growth, the availability of previously underutilized natural gas combined-cycle power plants,35
32
North American Electric Reliability Corporation, Potential Impacts of Future Environmental Regulations—Extracted
from the 2011 Long-Term Reliability Assessment, November 2011, http://www.nerc.com/files/EPA%20Section.pdf.
33
Ibid.
34
Debra McCown, “EPA Regulations for Coal-Fired Power Plants Could Force Shut Downs,” Bristol Herald Courier,
May 24, 2011, http://www2.tricities.com/business/2011/may/25/wood-gives-dire-warning-due-epa-regulations-coal-far-1062322/.
35
An electric generating technology in which electricity is produced from otherwise lost waste heat exiting from one or
more gas (combustion) turbines. The exiting heat is routed to a conventional boiler or to a heat recovery steam
generator for utilization by a steam turbine in the production of electricity. This process increases the efficiency of the
electric generating unit. See http://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.cfm.
Congressional Research Service
11
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
and the lower price of natural gas due to shale gas development. 36 And some coal plants which
have made significant modifications to meet existing EPA regulations are being closed or
mothballed due to a combination of low natural gas prices, and either transmission congestion37
or a lack of transmission options to sell power into other markets.38
Figure 6. Percentage of Electricity Generated from Coal by State, 2010
Source: Government Accountability Office. See http://www.gao.gov/assets/600/592542.pdf.
The implications of coal-fired electric power plant retirements will likely play out on a regional
basis, as EPA’s rules go through inevitable challenges and modifications as the regulations are
finalized.39 Power generation in the United States varies according to local energy resources, and
cost and availability of infrastructure for fuels transportation.40 The Eastern (except New
36
EIA, 27 GigaWatts of Coal-Fired Capacity to Retire over Next Five Years, July 27, 2012, http://www.eia.gov/
todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=7290#.
37
A condition that occurs when insufficient transfer capacity is available to implement all of the preferred schedules for
electricity transmission simultaneously. See http://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.cfm.
38
Gib Snyder, “An Inside Look at the Process for Mothballing,” The Observer, September 9, 2012,
http://www.observertoday.com/page/content.detail/id/575844/An-inside-look-at-the-process-for-mothballing.html?
nav=5047.
39
InsideEPA, EPA Urges Appellate Court To Rehear Ruling Vacating Cross-State Air Rule, October 5, 2012,
http://insideepa.com/201210052412215/EPA-Daily-News/Daily-News/epa-urges-appellate-court-to-rehear-rulingvacating-cross-state-air-rule/menu-id-95.html.
40
“In New England, most of the coal that will be burned … will likely originate in South America or Indonesia, where
the chemical composition of the coal is less harmful to the environment. Western U.S. coals also have a favorable
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
12
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
England) and Midwest regions of the United States are more coal-dependent than the Northeast or
Western regions, as shown in Figure 6.
Several large regional transmission organizations41 (RTOs) have undertaken studies of the impact
of the new EPA rules. A major question being asked in these studies is whether there will be a risk
to reliability based on the timing of requirements, and the scheduling and availability of
equipment and personnel to accomplish retrofits of power plants to bring them into compliance
with EPA regulations. The results of a study42 by the Midwest ISO (MISO), the RTO serving 11
states and one Canadian province may provide insights into the implications of both EPA
regulations and lower natural gas prices. There is approximately 70 GW of coal-fired capacity in
the MISO market,43 with an average coal plant age of 45 years.44 The study identified potential
retirements because of proposed EPA rules, a low natural gas price, and various levels of carbon
mitigation costs. MISO summarized the results of its study noting that EPA regulations and lower
natural gas prices would likely result in between 3 GW and 13 GW of coal capacity retirements,
with MISO itself likely to see costs of between $32 billion and $33 billion due to EPA compliance
retrofit costs, new capacity charges, system energy costs, and transmission system upgrades to
maintain reliability. 45
MISO does not own or build power plants. State utility commissions still control the process of
new power plant construction in many states. States often require a utility to use integrated
resource planning methods46 to address system needs. If a determination is made that new
generating capacity is needed to ensure reliability, then how to requisition that capacity becomes
the responsibility of state public utility commissions or the RTO markets. The decision would
likely be made according to how they view the effects of coal plant retirements on the levels and
types (i.e., base load vs. intermediate or peak load power plants) of capacity that will be needed to
serve electricity demands.47 RTO markets generally rely on price signals48 to provide an incentive
(...continued)
chemical composition, but it is currently too expensive to deliver coal from the Rocky Mountains to New England
relative to foreign supplies.” ISO New England, Scenario Analysis Project—Long Term Forecast of Oil, Natural Gas
and Coal Prices In New England, 2007, http://www.isone.com/committees/comm_wkgrps/othr/sas/mtrls/apr22007/
fuel-price-forecast.pdf.
41
The purpose of a Regional Transmission Organization is to ensure the efficient and reliable delivery of power across
large areas. RTOs facilitate and promote efficiency in wholesale electricity markets and ensure that electricity
consumers pay the lowest price possible for reliable service by removing transmission barriers between buyers and
sellers. See http://www.pjm.com/about-pjm/learning-center/pjm-overview/energy-basics/what-is-a-rto.aspx.
42
MISO, EPA Impact Analysis- Impacts from the EPA Regulations on MISO, October 2011,
https://www.midwestiso.org/Library/Repository/Study/MISO%20EPA%20Impact%20Analysis.pdf. (MISO EPA)
43
Of the 70,000 MW of coal-fired capacity in the MISO market, less than half does not have plans for SO2 controls.
Furthermore, 38% have no SO2 controls or NOx controls, and 38% have no SO2 controls or Fabric Filters. (MISO
EPA)
44
The life expectancy of coal-fired power plants from a cost recovery basis is generally estimated to be 40 years.
45
MISO EPA.
46
“Integrated resource planning [IRP] is a crucial element for success in a constantly changing business and regulatory
environment and is based on comprehensive, holistic and risk aware analysis. The integrated approach considers a
broad spectrum of feasible supply and demand-side options and assesses them against a common set of planning
objectives and criteria, including environmental impact. The IRP objective is to help meet future customer demand by
identifying the need for generating capacity and determining the best mix of resources to fill the need. The capacity gap
is the difference between the projected firm (or known) requirements and existing firm supply.” See TVA, TVA’s
Environmental and Energy Future, Integrated Resource Plan, March 2011, p. 27, http://www.tva.gov/environment/
reports/irp/pdf/Final_IRP_Ch1.pdf.
47
Many electric utilities are required by states to undertake long-range planning. “Integrated resource planning
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
13
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
for new generation to enter the market, or employ forward capacity markets with higher prices to
encourage new generation to be built. Other “generation-like” resources (such as demand
response,49 energy efficiency, and conservation) would also likely be employed to reduce the need
for building new capacity.
Given that significant underutilized NGCC exists in various U.S. regions, the possibility of
further shifting from coal base load plants to natural gas intermediate capacity exists. A recent
study50 by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2011 noted that the existing U.S. NGCC
generation fleet had an average capacity factor51 of approximately 41%, while its design capacity
allowed such plants to operate at 85%. The MIT study looked at a scenario across selected
regions of the United States which mimicked the “full dispatch” of existing natural gas combined
cycle plants. The study concluded that under such a scenario (while noting that transmission
constraints exist), there is “sufficient surplus NGCC capacity to displace roughly one-third of
U.S. coal generation, reducing CO2 emissions from the power sector by 20%.”52
Role of New and Alternative Power Generation Technologies
According to the EIA, coal is expected to be a key part of electricity generation in the United
States well past the year 2030.53 Electric utilities value diversity in power generation options
since reliance on one fuel or technology can leave them vulnerable to price and supply volatility.
However, the choices for new power plant technologies will likely be subject to proposed EPA
rules limiting GHG emissions. The proposed rule published under the Clean Air Act’s New
Source Performance Standards program would limit emissions from new power plants to no more
than 1,000 pounds of carbon dioxide for each megawatt-hour (MWh) of electricity produced.
Today’s NGCC generation emits on average about 800 pounds of carbon per MWh compared to
current U.S. coal plants with average emissions of about 1,800 pounds of carbon dioxide per each
MWh of electric power produced.54 The proposed GHG rule would allow an exception for the
(...continued)
helps electric utilities choose the best resource options to generate electricity and other options to meet customer
expectations for energy services. Increasing competition, changing technologies, and environmental concerns
are among the many issues utilities must consider when developing their plans.” See “Purpose of and Need for
Integrated Resource Planning” at http://www.tva.gov/environment/reports/energyvision2020/ev2020_vol1ch01.pdf.
48
Shortages of capacity cause electricity prices to rise in a competitive market.
49
Demand response (also known as load response) is end-use customers reducing their use of electricity in response to
power grid needs, economic signals from a competitive wholesale market or special retail rates. See
http://www.pjm.com/markets-and-operations/demand-response.aspx.
50
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, The Future of Natural Gas, 2011, http://mitei.mit.edu/system/files/
NaturalGas_Report.pdf. (MIT Study)
51
The ratio of the electrical energy produced by a generating unit for the period of time considered to the electrical
energy that could have been produced at continuous full power operation during the same period. See
http://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.cfm.
52
MIT Study, op. cit.
53
“In the Reference case, the natural gas share of electric power generation increases from 24 percent in 2010 to 28
percent in 2035, while the renewables share grows from 10 percent to 15 percent. In contrast, the share of generation
from coal-fired power plants declines. The historical reliance on coal-fired power plants in the U.S. electric power
sector has begun to wane in recent years. Over the next 25 years, the share of electricity generation from coal falls to 38
percent, well below the 48-percent share seen as recently as 2008, due to slow growth in electricity demand, increased
competition from natural gas and renewable generation, and the need to comply with new environmental regulations.”
See http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2012).pdf.
54
40 C.F.R. § Part 60. See http://epa.gov/carbonpollutionstandard/pdfs/20120327proposal.pdf.
Congressional Research Service
14
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
approximately one dozen new coal plants that are permitted and beginning construction within
one year, and would not apply to existing plants. Only new coal plants with carbon capture and
storage (CCS) are likely to meet the proposed GHG regulations,55 and CCS technology is
estimated to add about 30% to a coal plant’s cost. However, according to EIA, there are no new
conventional coal plants expected to come on line after 2012; 2 GW of coal plant capacity with
CCS is expected to enter service by about 2017.56 New advanced NGCC plants entering the
market in 2017 are expected to cost approximately $63 per MWh, while new advanced coal
plants are estimated to cost $111 per MWh, and advanced coal with CCS is estimated at $139 per
MWh.57 Based on levelized cost estimates alone, new coal generation (even without CCS) may
not be competitive with new NGCC given the built-in expectation of future fuel costs in the
estimates.
Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS)58
Carbon capture and sequestration (or storage)—known as CCS—has attracted congressional interest as a measure
for mitigating global climate change. Large amounts of carbon dioxide (CO2) emitted from fossil fuel use in the United
States are potentially available to be captured and stored underground using CCS, and prevented from reaching the
atmosphere. Large, industrial sources of CO2, such as coal-fired electricity-generating plants, are likely initial
candidates for CCS because they are predominantly stationary, single-point sources. Electricity generation contributes
over 40% of U.S. CO2 emissions from fossil fuels. Currently, U.S. power plants do not capture large volumes of CO2
for CCS.
To date, there are no commercial ventures in the United States that capture, transport, and inject industrial-scale
quantities of CO2 solely for the purposes of carbon sequestration. In 2012, the U.S. Department of Energy’s CCS
research, development, and deployment program embarked on commercial-scale demonstration projects for CO2
capture, injection, and storage. The success or failure of these projects will likely bear heavily on the future outlook
for widespread deployment of CCS technologies as a strategy for preventing large quantities of CO2 from reaching
the atmosphere while U.S. power plants continue to burn fossil fuels, mainly coal.
The variability of most renewable electricity technologies means that these technologies offer
limited opportunities for replacing coal generation, and these opportunities vary across the United
States. Given that the best wind and solar resources are located far from population centers,
opportunities to use wind power and solar power are likely dependent on development of
transmission lines. Without major breakthroughs in technology efficiency or energy storage,
growth of power generation from all renewable sources59 is expected to be limited to no more
than 16% of all generation by 2035.60
55
“New coal-, coal refuse-, oil- and petroleum coke-fired boilers and IGCC [Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle]
units should also be able to meet this standard by employing carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology.” Ibid.
56
Diane Kearney, Coal Projections from the Annual Energy Outlook 2011 Early Release, EIA, April 6, 2011,
http://www.stb.dot.gov/stb/docs/RETAC/2011/April/EIA%20annual%20energy%20outlook%202011.pdf.
57
Total levelized system cost. “Levelized cost is often cited as a convenient summary measure of the overall
competiveness of different generating technologies. It represents the per-kilowatthour cost (in real dollars) of building
and operating a generating plant over an assumed financial life and duty cycle. Key inputs to calculating levelized costs
include overnight capital costs, fuel costs, fixed and variable operations and maintenance (O&M) costs, financing costs,
and an assumed utilization rate for each plant type. The importance of the factors varies among the technologies.” See
EIA, Levelized Cost of New Generation Resources in the Annual Energy Outlook 2012, Annual Energy Outlook 2012,
July 12, 2012, http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/electricity_generation.cfm. (EIA NewGen)
58
See CRS Report R42532, Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS): A Primer, by (name redacted), and CRS Report
R42496, Carbon Capture and Sequestration: Research, Development, and Demonstration at the U.S. Department of
Energy, by (name redacted).
59
Includes conventional hydroelectric, geothermal, wood, wood waste, all municipal waste, landfill gas, other biomass,
solar, and wind power.
60
EIA, Annual Energy Outlook 2012, Table A9, DOE/EIA-0383(2012), May 2012, http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service
15
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Since load must be balanced on a continuous basis, units whose output can be varied to
follow demand (dispatchable technologies) generally have more value to a system than less
flexible units (non-dispatchable technologies) or those whose operation is tied to the
availability of an intermittent resource.61
Development of joint renewable electricity and natural gas-fired power projects as “hybrid
generation” is a possibility in certain regions. This could make variable renewable resources like
wind and solar power more dispatchable, and would likely be dependent on state renewable
portfolio standard62 requirements.
Nuclear power may be able to take over more of the base load generation role from coal, but the
path forward for new nuclear generating units in such a role is uncertain. According to the
Nuclear Energy Institute, as of 2012, five new nuclear power units are under construction, and
maintaining nuclear energy’s current share of 20% of total generation would require “building
one reactor every year starting in 2016, or 20 to 35 new units by 2035.”63 The cost of building
new nuclear power units may present a barrier to this goal,64 as might concerns raised by the
nuclear incident at Fukushima.
Given current technological options for power generation in the United States, the long-term
expectation of lower natural gas prices in combination with existing and proposed EPA rules
suggests that the option of coal use as a fuel for electric power generation faces an uncertain
future.
Industrial Coal Consumption65
In 2011 approximately 72 Million Short Tons (MST) of coal were used by the U.S industrial
sector, which represented roughly 7% of total coal consumption in the country.66 The industrial
sector’s share of U.S. coal demand has declined substantially since 1949, when the industrial
sector accounted for nearly 45% of annual coal consumption (see Figure 7).67 The decline of the
industrial sector’s share of coal consumption is generally a result of three developments since
1949: (1) reduced coal use for coke production and steel making, (2) reduced coal use for
industrial process applications, and (3) increased coal use for electric power production, which
now represents more than 90% of U.S. coal demand.68
(...continued)
pdf/0383%282012%29.pdf.EIA, Table A9, Electric Generating Capacity. Annual Energy Outlook.
61
EIA NewGen.
62
Renewable Portfolio Standards are state programs requiring a percent of energy sales or installed capacity to come
from renewable resources.
63
Nuclear Energy Institute, New Nuclear Energy Facilities, 2012, http://www.nei.org/keyissues/newnuclearplants/.
64
The two units being built by the Southern Company at the Vogtle station in Georgia were originally estimated to cost
$14 billion. See Ray Henry, “Building Costs Rise at U.S. Nuclear Sites,” SouthCoast Today.com, July 15, 2012,
http://www.southcoasttoday.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20120715/NEWS/207150345/-1/NEWSMAP.
65
This section was written by (name redacted).
66
Energy Information Administration, Annual Energy Review, September 27, 2012.
67
Ibid.
68
Ibid.
Congressional Research Service
16
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
Figure 7. Industrial Sector Share of Total U.S. Coal Consumption
(1949-2011)
Source: Energy Information Administration.
Coal has a number of industrial uses including steel making, cement production, combined heat
and power (CHP), and process heating. Additionally, coal is used by a number of industrial
operations including alumina refineries, chemical producers, pharmaceutical companies, and
paper manufacturers.69 According to the World Coal Institute, there are thousands of products that
include coal or coal by-products: soap, aspirins, solvents, dyes, plastics, fibers, and specialty
products (e.g., activated carbon, carbon fiber, and silicon metal).70
The Energy Information Administration classifies industrial sector coal consumption into three
separate categories: (1) Coke Plants, (2) Combined Heat and Power (CHP), and (3) Non-CHP.
Table 1 indicates the amount of coal consumed in 2011 for each of these categories.
Table 1. 2011 Industrial Sector Coal Consumption
(Million Short Tons)
Coke Plants
CHP
Non-CHP
Total
21.4
24.7
25.6
71.7
Source: Energy Information Administration.
Issues for Congress
Given the expected increase in natural gas supplies and expected shift in electricity production
from coal to natural gas as a primary fuel, the issue of what level of coal generation should be
preserved for power generation in the United States may be a question Congress will be faced
69
70
“The Coal Resource: A Comprehensive Overview of Coal,” World Coal Institute, 2009.
Ibid.
Congressional Research Service
17
Prospects for Coal in Electric Power and Industry
with. While U.S. coal currently used for power generation may have options for markets
overseas, the domestic future of coal power generation is clouded by both market prices and
environmental regulations. The United States is believed to have a bountiful supply of coal. But
how much or whether the future of coal will include power generation may be a question of
national energy policy.
Congress may be also confronted with the question of whether an “all-of-the above” strategy for
energy is viable. The electric utility industry values diversity in fuel choice options since reliance
on one fuel or technology can leave electricity producers vulnerable to price and supply volatility.
However, an “inverse relationship” is developing for coal vs. natural gas as a power generation
choice based on market economics alone, and policies which allow one fuel source to dominate
may come to the detriment of the other.
Congress may also face a decision as to whether coal-fired power generation can be a viable
technology option for the future. New advanced NGCC plants entering the market in 2017 are
expected to cost approximately $63 per MWh, while new advanced coal plants are estimated to
cost $111 per MWh, and advanced coal with CCS is estimated at $139 per MWh. The cost
difference between these technologies, and proposed GHG emissions limits, raise concerns over
coal’s future as a viable fuel choice for power generation. It is not clear (at this point in time)
whether research and development will result in new technologies able to reduce the differential.
Author Contact Information
(name redacted)
Specialist in Energy Policy
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....
(name redacted)
Specialist in Energy Policy
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....
(name redacted)
Specialist in Energy and Natural Resources Policy
[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....
Acknowledgments
James Uzel and Amber Wilhelm contributed to the graphics of this report
Congressional Research Service
18
EveryCRSReport.com
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the
Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on
issues that may come before Congress.
EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The
reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to
the public.
Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts
who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made
any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.
CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in
the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without
permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a
third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or
otherwise use copyrighted material.
Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public
understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in
connection with CRS' institutional role.
EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim
copyright on any CRS report we have republished.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.