The Federal Networking and Information Technology Research and Development Program: Funding Issues and Activities

Congressional research reportMay 4, 2006

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Order Code IB10130

CRS Issue Brief for Congress

Received through the CRS Web

The Federal Networking and Information

Technology Research and Development Program:

Funding Issues and Activities

Updated May 4, 2006

Patricia Moloney Figliola

Resources, Science, and Industry Division

Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress

CONTENTS

SUMMARY

MOST RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS

Overview of the Federal NITRD Program

Enabling/Governing Legislation

High-Performance Computing Act of 1991

Next Generation Internet Research Act of 1998

Context of Federal Technology Funding

Recent NCO, PITAC, and Related Activities

Federal Plan for Cyber Security and Information Assurance Research and

Development

NSA Superconducting Technology Assessment

Computational Science: Ensuring America’s Competitiveness

Cyber Security: A Crisis of Prioritization

Issues for Congress

Activity in the 109th Congress

Major Legislation

Hearings

Relevant Laws

LEGISLATION

FOR ADDITIONAL READING

IB10130

05-04-06

The Federal Networking and Information Technology Research and

Development Program: Funding Issues and Activities

SUMMARY

In the early 1990s, Congress recognized

that several federal agencies had ongoing

high-performance computing programs, but no

central coordinating body existed to ensure

long-term coordination and planning. To

provide such a framework, Congress passed

the High-Performance Computing and Communications Program Act of 1991 (P.L. 102194) to enhance the effectiveness of the various programs. In conjunction with the passage

of the act, the White House Office of Science

and Technology Policy (OSTP) released

Grand Challenges: High-Performance Computing and Communications. That document

outlined a research and development (R&D)

strategy for high-performance computing and

a framework for a multiagency program, the

High-Performance Computing and Communications (HPCC) Program.

Another aspect of government-funded IT

research is that it often leads to open standards, something that many perceive as beneficial, encouraging deployment and further

investment. Industry, on the other hand, is

more inclined to invest in proprietary products

and will diverge from a common standard

when there is a potential competitive or financial advantage to do so.

Finally, proponents of government support believe that the outcomes achieved

through the various funding programs create a

synergistic environment in which both fundamental and application-driven research are

conducted, benefitting government, industry,

academia, and the public. Supporters also

believe that such outcomes justify government’s role in funding IT R&D, as well as the

growing budget for the NITRD Program.

The HPCC Program has evolved over

time and is now called the Networking and

Information Technology Research and Development (NITRD) Program, to better reflect its

expanded mission. The NITRD Program is

composed of 12 agencies; its members work

in collaboration to increase the overall effectiveness and productivity of federal information technology (IT) R&D. A National Coordinating Office coordinates the activities of

the NITRD Program and reports to OSTP and

the National Science and Technology Council.

Critics assert that the government,

through its funding mechanisms, may be

picking “winners and losers” in technological

development, a role more properly residing

with the private sector. For example, the size

of the NITRD Program may encourage industry to follow the government’s lead on research directions rather than selecting those

directions itself.

The FY2007 budget calls for $3.074

billion for the NITRD Program, an increase of

$0.21 billion over the FY2006 budget estimate

of $2.855 billion.

Proponents assert that federal support of

IT R&D has produced positive outcomes for

the country and played a crucial role in supporting long-term research into fundamental

aspects of computing. Such fundamentals

provide broad practical benefits, but generally

take years to realize. Additionally, the unanticipated results of research are often as important as the anticipated results.

Congressional Research Service

In the 109th Congress, one NITRD-specific bill, H.R. 28, was introduced and passed

in the House; the bill was received in the

Senate and referred to the Committee on

Commerce, Science, and Transportation on

April 27, 2005.

˜

The Library of Congress

IB10130

05-04-06

MOST RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

The President’s FY2007 budget calls for $3.07 billion for the Networking and

Information Technology Research and Development (NITRD) Program,1 a $0.21 billion

increase (approximately 8%) over the FY2006 $2.86 billion estimate.2 The Administration’s

recently announced American Competitiveness Initiative has increased the NITRD budgets

of agencies that are part of the Initiative. The Initiative calls for a doubling over 10 years of

the investment in three Federal agencies that support basic research programs in the physical

sciences and engineering: the National Science Foundation (NSF), the Department of

Energy’s Office of Science (DOE/SC), and the National Institute of Science and Technology

(NIST) — are NITRD Program member agencies. All three received FY2007 NITRD budget

increases that exceed the percentage increase in the overall Program budget, as follows: NSF,

12%; DOE/SC, 35%; and NIST, 10%. The aggregated NITRD budget increase for these

three agencies from 2006 estimates to 2007 request is $186 million (17% above 2006

estimates), which accounts for over 85% of the overall NITRD Program budget increase for

2007.3

In the first session of the 109th Congress, one NITRD-specific bill, H.R. 28, was

introduced and passed in the House; the bill was received in the Senate and referred to the

Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation on April 27, 2005. The House

Committee on Science held two related hearings during the first session. There has been no

activity related to the NITRD Program thus far in the second session of the 109th Congress.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS

The federal government has long played a key role in the country’s information

technology (IT) research and development (R&D) activities. The Government’s support of

IT R&D began because it had an important interest in creating computers that would be

capable of addressing the problems and issues the government needed to solve and study.

One of the first such problems was planning the trajectories of artillery and bombs; more

recently such problems include simulations of nuclear testing, cryptanalysis, and weather

modeling. That interest continues today. That complexity requires there be adequate

coordination to ensure the government’s evolving needs (e.g., homeland security) will

continue to be met in the most effective manner possible.

1

The main website of the NITRD Program is [http://www.nitrd.gov].

2

The NITRD Program is funded out of each member agency’s individual budget, rather than in a

single appropriations bill (e.g., NITRD Program activities conducted by the National Aeronautics

and Space Administration (NASA) are funded through the NASA appropriations bill).

3

The NITRD Supplement to the President’s Budget for FY2007 is available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2007supplement/].

CRS-1

IB10130

05-04-06

Overview of the Federal NITRD Program

The NITRD Program is a collaborative effort in which 12 agencies coordinate and

cooperate to help increase the overall effectiveness and productivity of federal IT R&D.4 Of

those 12 members, the majority of funding, in descending order, goes to the National Science

Foundation, National Institutes of Health, Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science,

Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), and DOE National Nuclear

Security Administration. Figure 1 illustrates the organizational structure of the NITRD

Program.

Figure 1: Management Structure of the NITRD Program5

4

The members of the NITRD Program, as listed in the FY2006 Supplement to the President’s

Budget, are: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ); Defense Advanced Research

Projects Agency (DARPA); Office of the Secretary of Defense, Office of the Director, Defense

Research & Engineering; Department of Energy, National Nuclear Security Administration

(DOE/NNSA); Department of Energy, Office of Science (DOE/SC); Environmental Protection

Agency (EPA); National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA); National Institutes of

Health (NIH); National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST); National Oceanic and

Atmospheric Administration (NOAA); National Security Agency (NSA); and National Science

Foundation (NSF).

The history of agency participation can be found online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/about/history/agency-participants.pdf].

5

This diagram is available on the NITRD Program website, [http://www.nitrd.gov].

CRS-2

IB10130

05-04-06

The National Coordinating Office (NCO) coordinates the activities of the NITRD

Program. On July 1, 2005, the NCO became the “National Coordination Office for

Networking and Information Technology Research and Development.” The Director of the

NCO reports to the Director of OSTP. The NCO supports the Subcommittee on NITRD

(also called the NITRD Subcommittee)6 and the President’s Information Technology

Advisory Committee (PITAC)7:

!

The NITRD Subcommittee provides policy, program, and budget planning

for the NITRD Program and is composed of representatives from each of the

participating agencies, OSTP, Office of Management and Budget, and the

NCO. Two Interagency Working Groups and five Coordination Groups

reporting to the NITRD Subcommittee focus their work in eight Program

Component Areas (PCAs).8

!

The PITAC is composed of representatives of private industry and academia

who are appointed by the President. The group provides expert independent

advice to the President on the federal role in maintaining U.S. preeminence

in advanced IT and works with the NITRD Program agencies and the

NITRD Subcommittee.

6

The NITRD Subcommittee was previously called the Interagency Working Group for IT R&D

(IWG/IT R&D).

7

The PITAC was established on February 11, 1997, to provide the President, OSTP, and the federal

agencies involved in IT R&D with guidance and advice on all areas of high performance computing,

communications, and information technologies. Representing the research, education, and library

communities and including network providers and representatives from critical industries, the

committee advises the Administration’s effort to accelerate development and adoption of information

technologies. Additional information about the PITAC is available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac]. The most recent PITAC Executive Order expired on June 1, 2005.

8

The eight PCAs are: (1) High-End Computing Infrastructure and Applications (HEC I&A) — to

extend the state of the art in high-end computing systems, applications, and infrastructure; (2) HighEnd Computing R&D (HEC R&D) — to optimize the performance of today’s high-end computing

systems and develop future generations of high-end computing systems; (3) Cyber Security and

Information Assurance — to perform fundamental and applied R&D to improve the security and

assurance of information systems; (4) Human Computer Interaction and Information Management

(HCI&IM) — to develop new user interaction technologies, cognitive systems, information systems,

and robotics that benefit humans; (5) Large Scale Networking (LSN) — to develop leading-edge

network technologies, services, and techniques to enhance performance, security, and scalability;

(6) Software Design and Productivity (SDP) — to advance concepts, methods, techniques, and tools

that improve software design, development, and maintenance to produce more usable, dependable

and cost-effective software-based systems; (7) High Confidence Software and Systems (HCSS) —

to develop the scientific foundations and IT to achieve affordable and predictable high levels of

safety, security, reliability, and survivability, especially in U.S. national security and safety-critical

systems; and (8) Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications of IT and IT Workforce Development

(SEW) — to study the impact of IT on people and social and economic systems; develop the IT

workforce; and develop innovative IT applications in education and training. Additional information

about the program component areas is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/iwg/index.html].

HEC R&D and HEC I&A are both covered by the HEC Interagency Working Group. A diagram

illustrating the evolution of the PCAs, 1992-present, is available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/about/history/new-pca-names.pdf].

CRS-3

IB10130

!

05-04-06

The NITRD Program is funded out of each member agency’s individual

budget, rather than in a single appropriations bill (e.g., NITRD Program

activities conducted by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) are funded

through the NIH appropriations bill). The program’s NCO is not explicitly

funded; rather, the NITRD member agencies contribute toward NCO

operations.

The NITRD Program has undergone a series of structural changes since its inception

in 1991 and both it and the NCO have had a number of different names over the years. When

the Program was created in December 1991, it was named the High Performance Computing

and Communications (HPCC) Program, and when the NCO was created in September 1992,

it was named the NCO for HPCC. The name was changed to the National Coordination

Office for Computing, Information, and Communications per the FY1997 Supplement to the

President’s Budget (also known at that time as the “Blue Book”). The name was changed to

the National Coordination Office for Information Technology Research and Development

per the FY2001 Blue Book (that change was effective October 2000). Most recently, on July

1, 2005, the name was changed to the current name, the National Coordination Office for

Networking and Information Technology Research and Development. These changes were

made to reflect the evolution of the program as it came to encompass a broader range of

related topics. The chronology of funding since the NITRD Program was created as the

HPCC Program in 1991 is detailed in Figure 2.

Figure 2. History of NITRD Program Funding9

CRS-4

IB10130

05-04-06

Enabling/Governing Legislation

The NITRD Program is governed by two laws. The first, the High-Performance

Computing Act of 1991, P.L. 102-194,9 expanded federal support for high-performance

computing R&D and called for increased interagency planning and coordination. The

second, the Next Generation Internet Research Act of 1998, P.L. 105-305,10 amended the

original law to expand the mission of the NITRD Program to cover Internet-related research,

among other goals.

High-Performance Computing Act of 1991. This law was the original enabling

legislation for what is now the NITRD Program. Among other requirements, it called for:

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Setting goals and priorities for federal high-performance computing

research, development, and networking

Technical support and research and development of software and hardware

needed to address fundamental problems in science and engineering

Educating undergraduate and graduate students

Fostering and maintaining competition and private sector investment in

high-speed data networking within the telecommunications industry

Promoting the development of commercial data communications and

telecommunications standards

Providing security, including protecting intellectual property rights

Developing accounting mechanisms allowing users to be charged for the use

of copyrighted materials.

This law also requires an annual report to Congress on grants and cooperative R&D

agreements and procurements involving foreign entities.11

Next Generation Internet Research Act of 1998. This law amended the HighPerformance Computing Act of 1991. The act had two overarching purposes. The first was

to authorize research programs related to high-end computing and computation, humancentered systems, high confidence systems, and education, training, and human resources.

The second was to provide for the development and coordination of a comprehensive and

integrated U.S. research program to focus on (1) computer network infrastructure that would

promote interoperability among advanced federal computer networks, (2) economic highspeed data access that does not impose a “geographic penalty”, and (3) flexible and

extensible networking technology.

9

High Performance Computing Act of 1991, P.L. 102-194, 15 U.S.C. 5501, 105 Stat. 1595,

December 9, 1991. The full text of this law is available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/congressional /laws/pl_102-194.html].

10

Next Generation Internet Research Act of 1998, P.L. 105-305, 15 U.S.C. 5501, 112 Stat. 2919,

October 28, 1998. The full text of this law is available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/ congressional/laws/pl_h_105-305.html].

11

The first report mandated information on the “Supercomputer Agreement” between the United

States and Japan be included in this report. A separate one-time only report was required on network

funding, including user fees, industry support, and federal investment.

CRS-5

IB10130

05-04-06

Context of Federal Technology Funding

In the early 1990s, Congress recognized that several federal agencies had ongoing highperformance computing programs,12 but no central coordinating body existed to ensure longterm coordination and planning. To provide such a framework, Congress passed the HighPerformance Computing Program Act of 1991 to improve the interagency coordination,

cooperation, and planning of agencies with high performance computing programs

In conjunction with the passage of the act, OSTP released, “Grand Challenges: HighPerformance Computing and Communications.” That document outlined an R&D strategy

for high-performance computing and communications and a framework for a multi-agency

program, the HPCC Program.

The NITRD Program is part of the larger federal effort to promote fundamental and

applied IT R&D. The government sponsors such research through a number of channels,

including:

!

!

!

!

!

Federally-funded research and development laboratories, such as Lawrence

Livermore National Laboratory

Single-agency programs

Multi-agency programs, including the NITRD Program, but also programs

focusing on nanotechnology R&D and combating terrorism

Funding grants to academic institutions

Funding grants to industry.

In general, supporters contend that federal funding of IT R&D has produced positive

results. In 2003, the Computer Science and Telecommunications Board (CSTB) of the

National Research Council (NRC) released a “synthesis report” based on eight previously

released reports that examined “how innovation occurs in IT, what the most promising

research directions are, and what impacts such innovation might have on society.”13 One of

the most significant of the CSTB’s observations was that the unanticipated results of research

are often as important as the anticipated results. For example, electronic mail and instant

messaging were by-products of [government-funded] research in the 1960s that was aimed

at making it possible to share expensive computing resources among multiple simultaneous

interactive users.

12

“High-performance” computing is a term that encompasses both “supercomputing” and “grid

computing.” In general, high-performance computers are defined as stand-alone or networked

computers that can perform “very complex computations very quickly.” Supercomputing involves

a single, stand-alone computer located in a single location. Grid computing involves a group of

computers, in either the same location or spread over a number of locations, that are networked

together (e.g., via the Internet or a local network). House of Representatives, Committee on Science,

Supercomputing: Is the United States on the Right Path (Hearing Transcript),

[http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/science/hsy88231.000/hsy88231_0f.htm], 2003, p. 5-6.

13

National Research Council, Innovation in Information Technology, 2003, p. 1. This report

discusses all federal funding for R&D, not only the NITRD Program.

CRS-6

IB10130

05-04-06

Additionally, the report noted that federally funded programs have played a crucial role

in supporting long-term research into fundamental aspects of computing. Such

“fundamentals” provide broad practical benefits, but generally take years to realize.

Furthermore, supporters state that the nature and underlying importance of fundamental

research makes it less likely that industry would invest in and conduct more fundamental

research on its own. As noted by the CSTB, “companies have little incentive to invest

significantly in activities whose benefits will spread quickly to their rivals.”14 Further, in the

Board’s opinion:

government sponsorship of research, especially in universities, helps develop the IT talent

used by industry, universities, and other parts of the economy. When companies create

products using the ideas and workforce that result from federally-sponsored research,

they repay the nation in jobs, tax revenues, productivity increases, and world leadership.15

Another aspect of government-funded IT R&D is that it often leads to open standards,

something that many perceive as beneficial, encouraging deployment and further investment.

Industry, on the other hand, is more likely to invest in proprietary products and will diverge

from a common standard if it is sees a potential competitive or financial advantage; this has

happened, for example with standards for instant messaging.16

Finally, proponents of government R&D support believe that the outcomes achieved

through the various funding programs create a synergistic environment in which both

fundamental and application-driven research are conducted, benefitting government,

industry, academia, and the public. Supporters also believe that such outcomes justify

government’s role in funding IT R&D, as well as the growing budget for the NITRD

Program.

Critics assert that the government, through its funding mechanisms, may be setting itself

up to pick “winners and losers” in technological development, a role more properly residing

with the private sector.17 For example, the size of the NITRD Program may encourage

industry to follow the government’s lead on research directions rather than selecting those

directions itself.

Overall, CSTB states that, government funding appears to have allowed research on a

larger scale and with greater diversity, vision, and flexibility than would have been possible

without government involvement.18

14

Ibid, p. 4.

15

Ibid, p. 4.

16

Ibid, p. 18.

17

Cato Institute, Encouraging Research: Taking Politics Out of R&D, September 13, 1999,

[http://www.cato.org/pubs/wtpapers/990913catord.html].

18

National Research Council, Innovation in Information Technology, 2003, p. 22.

CRS-7

IB10130

05-04-06

Recent NCO, PITAC, and Related Activities

As explained earlier, the NCO provides technical and administrative support to the

NITRD Program, the NITRD Subcommittee, and the PITAC. This includes supporting

meetings and workshops and preparing reports. The NCO interacts with OSTP and OMB

on NITRD Program and PITAC matters.

Federal Plan for Cyber Security and Information Assurance Research and

Development. In April 2006, the NITRD Subcommittee released its “Federal Plan for

Cyber Security and Information Assurance Research and Development.”19 This report sets

out a framework for multi-agency coordination of federal R&D investments in technologies

that can better secure the interconnected computing systems, networks, and information that

together make up the U.S. IT infrastructure. The plan outlines strategic objectives for

coordinated federal R&D in cyber security and information assurance (CSIA) and presents

a broad range of CSIA R&D technical topics, identifying those topics that are multi-agency

technical and funding priorities. The plan’s findings and recommendations address R&D

priority setting, coordination, fundamental R&D, emerging technologies, roadmapping, and

metrics.

NSA Superconducting Technology Assessment. In August 2005, NSA

released its “Superconducting Technology Assessment”20 as part of its participation in the

High-End Computing PCA of the NITRD Program. NSA had been concerned about

projected limitations of conventional technology and wanted to explore possible alternatives

to meet its future mission-critical computational needs. This report presented the results of

the technology assessment, which found that

!

!

!

government investment is necessary, because private industry currently has

no compelling financial reason to develop alternative technologies for

mainstream commercial applications.

with aggressive federal investment (estimated between $372 and $437

million over five years), by 2010 next generation technologies would be

sufficiently mature to allow the initiation of the design and construction of

an operational petaflops-scale system.

although significant risks exist, the panel has developed a roadmap that

identifies the needed technology developments with milestones and

demonstration vehicles.

Computational Science: Ensuring America’s Competitiveness . In June

2005, the PITAC released “Computational Science: Ensuring America’s Competitiveness.”21

The report identified obstacles to progress in this field, including “rigid disciplinary silos in

academia that are mirrored in Federal research and development agency organizational

structures.” According to the report, these “silos stifle the development of multi-disciplinary

19

This report is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/csia/csia_federal_plan.pdf].

20

This report is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/nsa/sta.pdf].

21

This report is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac/reports/20050609_computational/

computational.pdf].

CRS-8

IB10130

05-04-06

research and educational approaches essential to computational science.” The report

recommends that

!

both academia and government fundamentally change their organizational

structures so that they promote and reward collaborative research.

!

the NSTC commission the National Academies to convene one or more task

forces to develop and maintain a multi-decade roadmap for computational

science, with a goal of assuring continuing U.S. leadership in science,

engineering, and the humanities.

!

the Federal government establish national software sustainability centers to

harden, document, support, and maintain long-term vital computational

science software.

!

the Federal government provide long-term support for computational

science community data repositories. These should include defined

frameworks, metadata structures, algorithms, data sets, applications, and

review and validation infrastructure. It should also require funded

researchers to deposit their data and research software in these repositories

or with other approved access providers.

!

the Federal government provide long-term funding for national high-end

computing centers at levels sufficient to ensure the regularly scheduled

deployment and operation of the fastest and most capable high-end

computing systems that address the most demanding computational

problems.

!

the Federal government implement coordinated, long-term computational

science programs that include funding for interconnecting the software

sustainability centers, national data and software repositories, and national

high-end leadership centers with the researchers who use those resources.

!

the Federal government should rebalance its R&D investments to: (a) create

a new generation of well-engineered, scalable, easy-to-use software suitable

for computational science that can reduce the complexity and time to

solution for today’s challenging scientific applications and can create

accurate simulations that answer new questions; (b) design, prototype, and

evaluate new hardware architectures that can deliver larger fractions of peak

hardware performance on scientific applications; and (c) focus on sensorand data-intensive computational science applications in light of the

explosive growth of data.

Cyber Security: A Crisis of Prioritization. In February 2005, the PITAC released

“Cyber Security: A Crisis of Prioritization.”22 That report outlined four key findings and

22

This report is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac/reports/20050301_cybersecurity/

CRS-9

IB10130

05-04-06

recommendations on how the Federal government could “foster new architectures and

technologies to secure the Nation’s IT infrastructure.” Specifically, the PITAC urged the

government to

!

significantly increase support for fundamental research in civilian cyber

security in 10 priority areas

!

intensify Federal efforts to promote the recruitment and retention of cyber

security researchers and students at research universities

!

increase support for the rapid transfer of federally-developed cybersecurity

technologies to the private sector

!

strengthen the coordination of Federal cybersecurity R&D activities.

Also in February 2005, the NCO released the FY2006 Supplement to the President’s

Budget.23 The supplement provides a brief technical outline of the FY2006 budget request

for the NITRD Program. The FY2007 Supplement has not yet been released.

Issues for Congress

Federal IT R&D is a multi-dimensional issue, involving many government agencies

working together towards shared and complementary goals. Most observers believe that

success in this arena requires ongoing coordination among government, academia, and

industry.

Through recent hearings, the House Committee on Science has been investigating issues

related to U.S. competitiveness in high-performance computing and the direction the IT R&D

community has been taking. Those issues and others remain salient and may merit further

investigation if the United States is to implement a comprehensive IT R&D policy. Included

among the possible issues Congress may wish to pursue are: the United States’ status as the

global leader in high-performance computing research; the apparent bifurcation of the federal

IT R&D research agenda between grid computing and supercomputing capabilities; the

possible over-reliance on commercially available hardware to satisfy U.S. research needs;

and the potential impact of deficit cutting on IT R&D funding.

Many Members of Congress as well as those in the research community have expressed

concern over whether the United States is maintaining its position as the global leader in

high-performance computing R&D. That concern was highlighted in 2003 when Japan

briefly surpassed the United States in possessing the fastest and most efficient supercomputer

in the world.24 While this was a reason for some concern, it was also viewed by some as an

22

(...continued)

cybersecurity.pdf].

23

This report is available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2006supplement].

24

House of Representatives, Committee on Science, Supercomputing: Is the United States on the

(continued...)

CRS-10

IB10130

05-04-06

indicator of how the United States’ research agenda had become bifurcated, with some in the

R&D community focusing on traditional supercomputing capabilities and others focusing

more on cluster computing or grid computing. Each type of computing has its advantages,

based on its application. Stand-alone supercomputers are often faster and are generally used

to work on a specific problem. For example, cryptanalysis and climate modeling

applications require significant computing power and are best accomplished using

specialized, stand-alone computers. Cluster computing, however, allows the use of

commercially available hardware, which helps contain costs. The cluster configuration is

useful for applications in which a problem can be broken into smaller independent

components.25 Therefore, one possible course for Congress could be to monitor closely the

work that was begun by the High-End Computing Revitalization Task Force and is now

being performed by the NITRD Program’s High-End Computing Interagency Working Group

and provide ongoing feedback and guidance.

Without a clear plan as to how to proceed, pursuing two disparate research agendas

(with goals that could be viewed as being at odds with each other) could split the research

community even further, damaging its ability to provide leadership in either area. The

NITRD Program already is working on a “roadmap” for future directions in supercomputing;

therefore, one possible course for Congress at this time would be to monitor closely the work

of the High-End Computing Revitalization Task Force and provide input or a more visible

forum for discussion (i.e., additional hearings involving task force participants). Congress

may wish to conduct its own inquiry into the debate over grid versus stand-alone computing.

For example, at the July 2003 hearing, one of the overarching questions the panelists were

asked to address was whether federal agencies were pursuing conflicting R&D goals and, if

so, what should and could be done to ensure they moved toward a more coordinated, unified

goal.

Another issue is whether the United States is relying too heavily on commercially

available hardware to satisfy its R&D needs. While use of computers designed for massmarket commercial applications can certainly be a part of a successful high-end computing

R&D plan, Congress may wish to monitor how this reliance may be driving the new

emphasis on grid computing.

As noted earlier, critics of IT R&D funding often state that industry should conduct

more fundamental R&D on their own, without government backing, and that fiscal restraint

dictates that less funding should be made available. Conversely, supporters of government

funding would point out that IT R&D has a very long cycle from inception to application and

that any reductions in funding now could have a significant negative impact for many years

to come in terms of innovation and training of researchers. Therefore, Congress may monitor

and assess the potential impact of deficit-cutting plans on progress in IT R&D.

24

(...continued)

Right Path? (Hearing Transcript), [http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/science/

hsy88231.000/hsy88231_0f.htm], 2003, p. 13.

25

Ibid, p. 6-7.

CRS-11

IB10130

05-04-06

Activity in the 109th Congress

To date, the 109th Congress has introduced one bill and held two hearings related to the

NITRD Program.

Major Legislation. Representative Judy Biggert introduced H.R. 28, the HighPerformance Computing Revitalization Act on January 4, 2005. The bill would amend the

High-Performance Computing Act of 1991 and further delineate the responsibilities of the

NITRD Program, including setting the goals and priorities for federal high-performance

computing research, development, networking, and other activities and providing more

specific definitions for the responsibilities of the PCAs. The bill was referred to the House

Committee on Science, which approved the bill on March 17, 2005.26 The committee also

approved, by voice vote, an amendment that stated that the results and benefits of federal

supercomputing research should be shared with the private sector. The committee rejected,

by a vote of 17-19, an amendment offered by Representative Brad Sherman that would have

directed the National Science Foundation to investigate the societal, ethical, legal, and

economic implications of computers that one day might be capable of mimicking human

abilities to learn, reason, and make decisions. H.R. 28 was agreed to by voice vote in the

House on April 26, 2005, and received in the Senate and where it was read twice and referred

to the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, on April 27, 2005.

Hearings. On February 16, 2005, the House Committee on Science held a hearing to

discuss the Federal R&D Budget for FY2006.27 This hearing covered the entire R&D budget

and included an overview of NITRD activities by Dr. John Marburger, the Director of OSTP.

On May 12, 2005, the House Committee on Science held a hearing entitled, “The Future

of Computer Science Research in the U.S.”28 That hearing focused on three primary areas

of investigation:

!

!

!

26

What effects are shifts in federal support for computer science (e.g., shifts

in the balance between short- and long-term research, shifts in the roles of

different agencies) having on academic and industrial computer science

research and development? What impacts will these changes have on the

future of the U.S. information technology industry and on innovation in this

field?

Are the federal government’s current priorities related to computer science

research appropriate? If not, how should they be changed?

What should the federal government be doing to implement the

recommendations of the recent PITAC report on cybersecurity?

See H.Rept. 109-36.

27

The charter and submitted testimony for this hearing is available online at

[http://www.house.gov/science/hearings/full05/index.htm].

28

The charter and submitted testimony for this hearing is available online at

[http://www.house.gov/science/press/109/109-71.htm].

CRS-12

IB10130

05-04-06

At this hearing, the committee heard testimony from Dr. Marburger, OSTP; Dr.

Anthony J. Tether; DARPA; Dr. William A. Wulf, National Academy of Engineering; and

Dr. Tom Leighton, Akamai Technologies and member of the PITAC. Testimony from Drs.

Marburger and Tether stressed the growing budget of computer research and their belief that

the overall health of the U.S. science and technology research community remains strong.

However, Dr. Wulf and Leighton, representing the research community, stated that they

believed government needed to provide even more funding, as industry was not willing to

fund the levels of fundamental research they believed necessary to sustain the United States’

research needs.

Relevant Laws

P.L. 102-194, the High-Performance Computing Act of 1991, expanded federal support

for research, development, and application of high-performance computing; and called for

improving the interagency planning and coordination of federal research and development

on high-performance computing and maximizing the effectiveness of the federal

government’s high-performance computing efforts.

P.L. 105-305, the Next Generation Internet Research Act of 1998, amended the HighPerformance Computing Act of 1991 to authorize appropriations for fiscal years 1999 and

2000 for the Next Generation Internet program; and required the President’s Information

Technology Advisory Committee to monitor and give advice concerning the development

and implementation of the Next Generation Internet program and report to the President and

the Congress on its activities.

P.L. 108-423, the Department of Energy High-End Computing Revitalization Act,

requires the Secretary of Energy to develop and deploy high-end computing systems for

advanced scientific and engineering applications. Among other specific requirements, the law

requires that the Department of Energy’s high-end computing program support individual

investigators and multi-disciplinary teams of investigators; conduct research on multiple

computing architectures; conduct research on algorithms, programming environments, tools,

languages, and operating systems; support technology transfer to the private sector; and

coordinate with industry and other Federal agencies. Further, it requires the Secretary to

establish and operate Leadership Systems facilities that would provide the U.S. research

community with sustained access to high-performance computing resources and to establish

at least one High-End Software Development Center to concentrate efforts to develop, test,

maintain, and support optimized software tools for HEC.

LEGISLATION

H.R. 28 (Biggert)

High-Performance Computing Revitalization Act. The bill would amend the HighPerformance Computing Act of 1991 and further delineate the responsibilities of the NITRD

Program, including setting the goals and priorities for federal high-performance computing

research, development, networking, and other activities and providing more specific

definitions for the responsibilities of the PCAs. The bill was referred to the House

Committee on Science on January 4, 2005; it was approved on March 17, 2005. The

committee also approved, by voice vote, an amendment that stated that the results and

CRS-13

IB10130

05-04-06

benefits of federal supercomputing research should be shared with the private sector. The

committee rejected, by a vote of 17-19, an amendment offered by Representative Brad

Sherman that would have directed the National Science Foundation to investigate the

societal, ethical, legal, and economic implications of computers that one day might be

capable of mimicking human abilities to learn, reason, and make decisions. H.R. 28 was

agreed to by voice vote in the House on April 26, 2005, and received in the Senate and where

it was read twice and referred to the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation,

on April 27, 2005.29

FOR ADDITIONAL READING

CRS Reports

CRS Report RL32799, Federal Research and Development Funding: FY2006, by Michael

E. Davey.

CRS Issue Brief IB10088, Federal Research and Development: Budgeting and PrioritySetting Issues, 108th Congress, by Genevieve J. Knezo.

CRS Report RL31175, High Performance Computers and Export Control Policy: Issues for

Congress, by Glenn J. McLoughlin and Ian F. Fergusson.

Websites

The National Coordination Office for Networking and Information Technology Research and

Development, [http://www.nitrd.gov/].

The President’s Information

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac/index.html].

Technology

Advisory

Committee,

The Subcommittee on Networking Information Technology Research and Development and

its Interagency Working Groups and Coordinating Groups,

[http://www.nitrd.gov/iwg/index.html].

Reports and Documents

“Federal Plan for Cyber Security and Information Assurance Research and Development,”

Subcommittee on NITRD, April 2006, available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/csia/csia_federal_plan.pdf].

“Networking and Information Technology Research and Development: FY2007 Supplement

to the President’s Budget,” Subcommittee on Networking and Information Technology

Research and Development, National Science and Technology Council, February 2006,

available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2007supplement/]

29

See H. Rep. 109-36.

CRS-14

IB10130

05-04-06

“Superconducting Technology Assessment,” National Security Agency, August 2005,

available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/nsa/sta.pdf].

“Computational Science: Ensuring America’s Competitiveness,” President’s Information

Technology Advisory Committee, June 2005, available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/

pitac/reports/20050609_computational/computational.pdf].

“Networking and Information Technology Research and Development: FY2006 Supplement

to the President’s Budget,” Subcommittee on Networking and Information Technology

Research and Development, National Science and Technology Council, February 2005,

available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2006supplement/].

“Cyber Security: A Crisis of Prioritization,” President’s Information Technology Advisory

Committee, February 2005, available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac/reports/

20050301_cybersecurity/cybersecurity.pdf].

“Networking and Information Technology Research and Development: FY2006 Supplement

to the President’s Budget,” Subcommittee on Networking and Information Technology

Research and Development, National Science and Technology Council, December 2004,

available online at [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/bluebooks/2005/index.html].

“Revolutionizing Health Care Through Information Technology,” President’s Information

Technology Advisory Committee, July 2004, available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pitac/reports/20040721_hit_report.pdf].

“Federal Plan for High-End Computing,” Office of Science and Technology Policy,

Executive Office of the President, May 2004, available online at

[http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2004_hecrtf/20040702_hecrtf.pdf].

“The Technology Industry at an Innovation Crossroads,” Electronic Industries Association,

May 2004, [http://www.eia.org/docs/innovation_playbook.pdf].

“Workshop on the Roadmap for the Revitalization of High-End Computing,” Computing

R e s e a r c h A s s o c i a t e s , 2 0 0 4 , [ h t t p : / / w w w . n i t r d . go v / h e c r t f - o u t r e a c h /

20040112_cra_hecrtf_report.pdf].

“Federal Plan for High-End Computing,” High-End Computing Revitalization Task Force,

2004, [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/2004_hecrtf/20040702_hecrtf.pdf].

“Getting Up to Speed: The Future of Supercomputing,” National Research Council,

Computer Science and Telecommunications Board, 2003,

[http://www7.nationalacademies.org/cstb/pub_supercomp.html].

“Innovation in Information Technology,” National Research Council, Computer Science and

Telecommunications Board, 2003, [http://www7.nationalacademies.org/

cstb/pub_itinnovation.html].

CRS-15

IB10130

05-04-06

“Future of Supercomputing: An Interim Report,” National Research Council, Computer

Science and Telecommunications Board, 2003, [http://www7.nationalacademies.org/cstb/pub_supercomp_int.html].

“Human Computer Interaction and Information Management Research Needs,” HCI&IM

Coordinating Group of the Interagency Working Group on Information Research and

Development, 2003 [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/hci-im_research_needs_final.pdf].

“Grand Challenges: Science, Engineering, and Societal Advances Requiring Networking and

Information Technology Research and Development,” NITRD Program National

Coordinating Office, 2003, [http://www.nitrd.gov/pubs/200311_grand_challenges.pdf].

“Supercomputing: Is the United States on the Right Path?,” House of Representatives,

Committee on Science (Hearing Transcript), 2003 [http://commdocs.house.gov

/committees/science/ hsy88231.000/hsy88231_0f.htm].

“Funding a Revolution: Government Support for Computing Research,” National Research

Council, Computer Science and Telecommunications Board, 1999,

[http://www7.nationalacademies.org/cstb/pub_revolution.html].

CRS-16

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.