Environmental Protection Issues in the 107th Congress

Congressional research reportMar 13, 2003

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Order Code IB10067

Issue Brief for Congress

Received through the CRS Web

Environmental Protection Issues

in the 107th Congress

Updated March 13, 2003

Coordinated by Martin R. Lee and Margaret M. Isler

Resources, Science, and Industry Division

Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress

CONTENTS

SUMMARY

MOST RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS

Clean Air Act (by James McCarthy)

Chemical Plant Security (by Linda Schierow)

Surface Transportation and the Environment(by David Bearden)

Clean Water Act Issues (by Claudia Copeland)

Safe Drinking Water Act (by Mary Tiemann)

Superfund and Brownfields (by Mark Reisch)

Solid Waste Issues (by James McCarthy)

Defense Cleanup and Environmental Programs (by David Bearden)

Global Climate Change (by Susan Fletcher and Brent Yacobucci)

Regulating Pesticides (by Linda Schierow)

Funding the Environmental Protection Agency (by Martin R. Lee)

Environmental Research and Development (by Michael Simpson)

IB10067

03-13-03

Environmental Protection Issues in the 107th Congress

SUMMARY

The 107th Congress enacted brownfields,

bioterrorism, and a sediment contamination

statutes. In addition, it provided FY2002

funding to the Environmental Protection

Agency (EPA) and other government agency

environmental programs, and continued

FY2002 funding into FY2003.

Many other bills received committee or

floor action. H.R. 4, the comprehensive

energy bill, which has numerous

environmental provisions; the EPA and

Department of Defense appropriations bills

for FY2003; bills authorizing HUD and the

Economic Development Administration

(EDA) brownfield programs; legislation

authorizing EPA regulation of pesticide exports; bills to extend water infrastructure funding programs; and legislation to address

chemical plant security. Table 1 provides a

summary of environmental legislation on

which there has been some action.

Superfund/Brownfields. In the first

session, Congress enacted P.L. 107-118, the

Small Business Liability Relief and

Brownfield Revitalization Act. On June 4,

2002, the House passed H.R. 2941 to enhance

the Department of Housing and Urban

Development’s brownfields program. The

Senate Environment and Public Works Committee reported S. 1079 (S.Rept. 107-244) on

August 28, 2002, to provide $60 million per

year for the EDA’s brownfield program.

Energy Bill.

House and Senate

conferees did not complete action on a

comprehensive energy package, H.R. 4, that

includes a number of environmental

provisions. Both versions address drinking

water contamination from MTBE, a gasoline

additive, and the Senate version would have

Congressional Research Service

banned future use of MTBE in gasoline. The

Senate version would have also required the

use of renewable fuels in electricity generation

and motor fuels. The House version of H.R. 4

would have reauthorized EPA’s climate

change programs, while the Senate version

would have established a new Office of

National Climate Change Policy and would

have created a national greenhouse gas

database.

Security Issues. S. 1602, as reported,

and its companion, H.R. 5300, would have

required EPA to identify and regulate sources

of potentially disastrous, accidental or criminal, chemical releases. Action also occurred

on several water infrastructure security bills.

The Bioterrorism Preparedness Act (P.L. 107188) authorized funding for drinking water

vulnerability assessments and security

upgrades.

Appropriations. In the first session,

Congress appropriated $7.9 billion for EPA,

for FY2002, plus another $176 million in

supplemental funding for anti-terrorism

activities. On July 25, 2002, the Senate

Appropriations Committee approved $8.3

billion for EPA for FY2003 in reporting S.

2797 (S.Rept. 107-222). The Administration

has requested $7.6 billion. In addition to

funding for EPA, consideration of

authorization and appropriations bills for

defense-related environmental activities is

also underway. A continuing resolution

provided funding at the same level as enacted

for FY2002, until a final appropriations bill

was enacted for FY2003. (The108th Congress

enacted P.L.108-7 (H.J.Res. 2), an omnibus

appropriation bill which includes about $8.1

billion for EPA for FY2003.)

˜ The Library of Congress

IB10067

03-13-03

MOST RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

House and Senate conferees did not complete action on their versions of the

comprehensive energy legislation, H.R. 4. The Senate-passed version of H.R. 4 would have

banned the gasoline additive methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), allow waiving the Clean

Air Act’s gasoline oxygen content requirements, required the use of renewable fuels in

electricity generation and motor fuels, establish the Office of National Climate Change

Policy, and create a national greenhouse gas database; the House version would have

reauthorized EPA’s climate change programs; both House and Senate versions would have

authorized funds to address MTBE contamination of drinking water.

On July 25, 2002, the Senate Committee on Appropriations approved $8.3 billion for

EPA for FY2003, in reporting S. 2797 (S.Rept 107-222). A continuing resolution provided

funding at the same level as enacted for FY2002, until a final appropriations bill was enacted

for FY2003. (The 108th Congress enacted P.L. 108-7 (H.J.Res. 2), an omnibus appropriation

bill which includes about $8.1 billion for EPA.) Congress completed actions authorizing and

funding most of DOD’s environmental programs.

Congress has acted on a variety of other environmental bills during the second session.

On September 5, 2002, the Senate passed S. 351, limiting the use of mercury thermometers

and encouraging proper management of mercury. The Great Lakes Legacy Act (P.L. 107-303,

H.R. 1070) authorizes $200 million for the Environmental Protection Agency to carry out

projects to remediate sediment contamination in the Great Lakes. The Senate Environment

and Public Works Committee reported S. 1079 (S.Rept. 107-244) on August 28, to provide

$60 million per year for the Economic Development Administration’s brownfield program.

On June 4, the House passed H.R. 2941, a bill to enhance municipalities’ ability to take

advantage of the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s brownfields program.

The Bioterrorism Preparedness and Response Act (P.L. 107-188, H.R. 3448), enacted on

June 12, authorizes funding for vulnerability assessments and security upgrades by drinking

water utilities.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS

This issue brief provides an overview of environmental protection legislation and issues

considered by the 107th Congress. (For a description of environmental protection laws, see

CRS Report RL30798, Environmental Laws: Summaries of Statutes Administered by the

Environmental Protection Agency.)

The authorizations for most environmental protection programs have expired, although

program authorities remain in effect and legislative action to provide funding has continued.

Table 1 shows the action taken on legislation in the 107th Congress.

CRS-1

IB10067

03-13-03

Table 1. Action on Environmental Protection Legislation

in the 107th Congress

P.L. 107- 118

(H.R. 2869combined

provisions of House

-passed H.R. 1831

and Senate-passed

S.350)

H.R. 2941

S. 1079

P.L. 107-73

(H.R. 2620)

H.R. 1/S. 1

S. 1731

H.R. 2581

S. 556

S. 950

H.R. 4

S. 1602

Superfund and Brownfields

Signed 01/11/02

Provides certain relief for small businesses

under Superfund, promotes the cleanup

and reuse of brownfields, provides

financial assistance for brownfields

revitalization

Passed House 06/4/02

Reported by Senate Environment

and Public Works 08/28/02

(S.Rept. 107-244)

Pesticides

Signed 11/26/01

Passed Senate 06/14/01

(dropped in conference)

Passed Senate 02/13/02

(dropped in conference)

Reported (amended) by House

Armed Services 03/08/02

(H.Rept. 107-297)

Air Quality

Ordered reported by Senate

Environment and Public Works

06/27/02

Reported by Senate Environment

and Public Works 12/20/01

(S.Rept. 107-131)

HUD Brownfield Program

Economic Development Administration

Brownfield Assistance

The FY2002 EPA Appropriations include

extending EPA authority to collect

pesticide reregistration fees for one year

Requires state pesticide management plans

for schools

Includes provisions on school pesticide

management plans and fees

Authorizes EPA to prohibit export of

certain pesticides and chemicals

Requires power plants to reduce emissions

of four pollutants (including CO2)

Bans the use of MTBE as a fuel additive

H.R. 4 also triples the use of ethanol

(§820)

H.R. 4, as passed by the Senate

04/25/02, includes S. 950

provisions as sections 831-839;

H.R. 4 passed the House 08/02/01.

Conferees continue to meet

Chemical Plant Security

Ordered reported by Senate

Requires EPA to identify high priority

Environment and Public Works

chemical risks and to issue regulations

07/25/02

requiring owners and operators of

stationary sources to take actions to

prevent, control, and minimize the

potential consequences of a release

Water Quality

P.L. 107-303

(H.R. 1070)

H.R. 3930

Signed 11/27/02

Ordered reported by House

Transportation and Infrastructure

04/17/02

CRS-2

authorizes assistance for remediation of

sediment contamination

Extends Clean Water Act wastewater

infrastructure funding

IB10067

S. 1961

P.L. 107-303 (H.R.

1070)

H.R. 5169

P.L. 107-188

(H.R. 3448)

H.R. 4, §504

H.R. 4, §832

S. 1850

H.R. 4, §3306

H.R. 4 §2310

S. 351

H.R. 4

03-13-03

Reported by Senate Environment

and Public Works 07/29/02

(S.Rept. 107-228)

Signed 11/27/2002

Extends wastewater and drinking water

infrastructure funding

Contaminated sediment legislation

Reported by House Transportation Authorizes funds for vulnerability

and Infrastructure 09/05/02

assessments of wastewater utilities

(H.Rept. 107-645)

Drinking Water

Signed 06/12/02

Authorizes $120 million for vulnerability

assessments and emergency response plans

to protect drinking water systems

(incorporates parts of House-passed H.R.

3178, Senate-reported S. 1593 and Senatepassed S. 1608)

Passed House 08/02/01

Both bills authorize $200 million to clean

Passed Senate 04/25/02

up MTBE at underground tanks. The

Senate bill authorizes additional funds for

enforcing tank regulations and for research

Ordered reported by Senate

Authorizes increased appropriations from

Environment and Public Works

the Leaking Underground Storage Tank

07/25/02

(LUST) Trust Fund for cleaning up

gasoline and MTBE leaks. Imposes new

requirements on states and tank owners

Solid Waste

Passed House 08/02/01

Tax credits for the production of energy

Passed Senate 04/25/02

from landfill gas; Senate version

encourages the production of ethanol from

municipal solid waste

Passed Senate 09/05/02

Authorizes programs to limit use of

mercury thermometers

Climate Change

Passed House 08/02/01

Both versions authorize EPA climate

Passed Senate 04/25/02

programs; Senate version establishes

Office of National Climate Change Policy

to develop a climate change response

strategy; Senate version establishes a

voluntary greenhouse gas database

Encourage U.S. leadership to reduce

greenhouse gas emissions and continue

participating in climate change

negotiations

H.R. 1646

Passed House 05/16/01

H.R. 2460

Reported from House Science

(H.Rept. 107-177) 07/31/01

Authorizes EPA Climate Change Programs

P.L. 107-228

(H.R. 1646)

Signed 09/30/02

Prohibits U.S. contributions to the United

Nations Budget from being used to

implement the Framework Convention on

Global Climate Change (Kyoto Protocol)

EPA Funding

P.L. 107-73

(H.R. 2620)

Signed 11/26/01

Appropriated $7.9 billion in FY2002 for

EPA programs

CRS-3

IB10067

03-13-03

P.L. 107-117

(H.R. 3338, Div B)

Signed 01/10/02

P.L. 107-206

(H.R. 4775)

Signed 08/02/02

S. 2797

Reported by Senate

Appropriations (S.Rept. 107-222)

07/25/02

Reported by House Appropriations

(H.Rept. 107-740)

H.R. 5605

H.R. 64

P.L. 107-117

(H.R3338)

P.L. 107-64

(H.R. 2904)

P.L. 107-66

(H.R. 2311)

P.L. 107-107

(S.1438)

P.L. 107-314 ( H.R.

4546)

P.L. 107-248 (H.R.

5010)

P.L. 107-249 (H.R.

5011)

S. 2784

H.R. 5431

P.L 107-206

(H.R. 4775)

P.L. 107-87

(H.R. 2299)

Appropriated $176 million in

supplemental FY2002 funding for EPA

terrorist-related activities

Appropriates $50 million to EPA in

supplemental funding for FY2002 for

drinking water vulnerability assessments if

the President requests emergency funds

Appropriates $8.3 billion for EPA for

FY2003

Appropriates $8.3 billion for EPA for

FY2003

Environmental Science and Technology

Passed House 05/30/02

Establishes an EPA Deputy Administrator

for Science and Technology

Defense Environmental Programs

Signed 01/10/02

Defense Appropriations for FY2002 and

Emergency Supplemental, includes

environmental activities

Signed 11/05/01

Military Construction Appropriations for

FY2002, contains funding for cleaning up

base closure sites

Signed 11/12/01

Energy and Water Development

Appropriations for FY2002, contains

funding for defense-related nuclear waste

management

Signed 12/28/01

Defense Authorization Act for FY2002,

includes environmental activities

Cleared 11/13/02

Defense Authorization Act for FY2003,

includes environmental activities

Signed 10/23/02

Defense Appropriations for FY2003,

includes environmental activities

Signed 10/23/02

Military Construction Appropriations for

FY2003, funding for closed bases cleanup

Reported by Senate

FY2003 Energy and Water Appropriations

Appropriations 07/24/02

contains funding for defense related

(S.Rept. 107-220)

nuclear waste management

Reported by House Appropriations FY2003 Energy and Water Appropriations

09/24/02 (H.Rept. 107-681)

contains funding for defense related

nuclear waste management

Signed 08/02/02

Provides supplemental funding of $70

million in FY2002 for security at DOE

defense nuclear waste cleanup sites, if the

President requests such funds

Environmental Streamlining Funding

Signed 12/18/01

DOT Appropriations includes funds for

environmental streamlining initiatives

CRS-4

IB10067

03-13-03

Clean Air Act (by James McCarthy)

Clean air issues were discussed at length in the 107th Congress, but little action was

taken, leaving the same issues for consideration in the 108th Congress. The most prominent

air quality issue was whether to modify state and federal regulations designed to protect air

quality in order to promote energy production. Of particular interest were the Clean Air

Act’s New Source Review requirements, which some argue have prevented power plants

from making improvements that would expand power output. A related issue is whether

Congress should modify Clean Air Act requirements for power plants by enacting “multipollutant” legislation, which, it is argued, would both reduce emissions and encourage

investment in new plants by providing certainty regarding future regulatory requirements.

Both the House and Senate passed comprehensive energy legislation (H.R. 4) in the 107th

Congress, but neither version of the bill contained provisions addressing these issues; the

bill died in conference. The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee narrowly

approved multi-pollutant legislation (S. 556) June 27, 2002, but the Administration and

much of the electric power industry opposed the bill, and it did not reach the Senate floor.

The bill would have required power plants to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen

oxides, mercury, and carbon dioxide.

A second set of air issues Congress considered concerns regulation of the gasoline

additive MTBE. MTBE is used to meet Clean Air Act requirements that gasoline sold in the

nation’s worst ozone nonattainment areas contain at least 2% oxygen, but the additive has

been implicated in numerous incidents of ground water contamination. The Senate version

of H.R. 4 would have banned the use of MTBE in gasoline within 4 years, eliminated the 2%

oxygen requirement, preserved the emission reductions achieved by reformulated gasoline,

and required a tripling of the use of ethanol or other renewable fuels in motor vehicles by

2012. The House did not have comparable requirements in its version of H.R. 4—one of

many areas in which the House and Senate-passed bills differed. On August 1, 2001, the

House rejected an attempt to exempt California from the oxygen requirement (the Cox

amendment to H.R. 4). H.R. 4 died in conference, leaving MTBE and other issues to be

considered by the 108th Congress. (For additional information on clean air issues, see CRS

Issue Brief IB10065, Clean Air Act Issues in the 107th Congress.)

Chemical Plant Security (by Linda Schierow)

The 107th Congress considered, but did not enact legislation to reduce risks of terrorism

at facilities handling large quantities of potentially dangerous chemicals. Such facilities

might be vulnerable to direct attacks or covert use of business contacts, facilities, and

materials to gain access to chemicals. Risks may be increasing, consequences for human

health and the environment could be severe, and limited evidence suggests that many

chemical facilities may lack adequate safeguards. Policy makers face three key issues: the

effect of public access to information about facilities’ hazards and risk management plans;

the relative importance of diverse risks; and who should be responsible for achieving results.

For more on this topic, see CRS Report RL31530, Chemical Plant Security.

S. 1602, as reported by the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, and

House companion H.R. 5300 would require EPA, in consultation with the Office (or

CRS-5

IB10067

03-13-03

Department) of Homeland Security, to identify high priority chemical risks and to issue

regulations requiring owners and operators of stationary sources to take actions to prevent,

control, and minimize the potential consequences of a release. Facilities would be required

to consider chemical and process changes that enhance inherent safety. The bill would

exempt vulnerability assessments and risk management plans from Freedom of Information

Act (FOIA) requirements. H.R. 4698 would have authorized the Secretary of Commerce to

issue licenses to qualified persons and to restrict the sale, purchase, and distribution of

certain chemicals to licensees. S. 2579 would have amended the Clean Air Act to eliminate

the names and locations of facilities from publicly available facility risk management plans,

and made public disclosure of such information by government officials a crime. The bill

also would have expanded official access to the plans.

The bill that established the new Department of Homeland Security, H.R.5005, does not

address chemical plant security directly. However, if facilities are part of the “critical

infrastructure” (as are water utilities, for example), the new law will exempt from FOIA

requirements information about the plants’ vulnerability to terrorism if it is submitted

voluntarily to the Department. The Department of Homeland Security is required to analyze

vulnerabilities and recommend methods of enhancing site security.

Surface Transportation and the Environment

(by David Bearden)

Meeting public needs for surface transportation, while ensuring that the protection of

the environment is not compromised, has been a longstanding issue among states and

affected communities in local areas. The Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century

(TEA21, P.L. 105-178) authorized funding for federal highway and mass transit programs

from FY1998 to FY2003. Of this amount, over $12 billion was reserved for several

programs to mitigate the environmental impacts of surface transportation. Most of this

funding was reserved for air quality projects to assist states in complying with federal air

quality standards. The law also increased funding for environmentally related transportation

enhancements, established several new programs, and required the environmental review

process for highway projects to be streamlined. (CRS Report 98-646 ENR, Transportation

Equity Act for the 21st Century (P.L. 105-178): An Overview of Environmental Protection

Provisions, provides additional information.)

During the 107th Congress, several oversight hearings were held to examine the

Department of Transportation’s implementation of TEA21. Oversight of the law’s

environmental provisions focused primarily on the implementation of requirements to

streamline the environmental review process for highway projects. While the law did not

specify a deadline for meeting these requirements, some Members expressed disappointment

that the Department of Transportation’s actions have mostly been administrative in nature,

and that 4 years after the enactment of the law, streamlining regulations have yet to be

finalized. The lack of final regulations has increased interest in legislative action to speed

project delivery and meet public demands for transportation infrastructure. Two bills were

introduced toward the end of the 107th Congress to address the streamlining issue: H.R. 5455

and S. 3031. Although there were differences between the two bills, both included proposals

to grant the Secretary of Transportation greater authority over the environmental review

CRS-6

IB10067

03-13-03

process, establish statutory deadlines for various aspects of the review process, and allow

qualified states to assume certain federal responsibilities. (CRS Report RS20841,

Environmental Streamlining Provisions in the Transportation Equity Act for the 21st

Century: Status of Implementation, provides additional information on this issue.)

Debate over the reauthorization of TEA21 is expected to begin early in the 108th

Congress. Due to ongoing concerns over highway project delays, whether to take firmer

actions to streamline the environmental review process will likely be a prominent issue, and

proposals similar to the two bills mentioned above may be considered. The use of federal

highway funding for air quality projects under the Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality

Improvement Program (CMAQ) will be a likely topic of discussion as well. The findings

of a National Academy of Sciences study have raised questions regarding the program’s

impact on state efforts to comply with federal air quality standards. Consequently, proposals

to enhance the effectiveness of the CMAQ program, or to possibly shift its focus away from

air quality to reducing traffic congestion in general, may be considered. The adequacy of

funding to support other environmentally related transportation programs may also be

addressed.

Clean Water Act Issues (by Claudia Copeland)

The 107th Congress did not enact comprehensive legislation affecting the Clean

Water Act (CWA). However, in November, the House and Senate gave final approval to a

bill amending one portion of the Act, legislation entitled the Great Lakes Legacy Act (P.L.

107-303, H.R. 1070). It authorizes $200 million for the Environmental Protection Agency

to carry out projects to remediate sediment contamination in the Great Lakes.

During the 107th Congress, committees focused attention on legislation to authorize

water infrastructure funding. The House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee

approved a bill to extend the Clean Water Act’s program that assists municipal wastewater

treatment projects through FY2007 (H.R. 3930); the Senate Environment and Public Works

Committee approved similar legislation (S. 1961, S.Rept. 107-228). (For information, see

CRS Report RL31344, Water Infrastructure Financing Legislation: Comparison of S. 1961

and H.R. 3930.) Neither bill received further action due to controversies about provisions

in both such as a new formula for state-by-state allocation of federal funds and application

of requirements under the Davis-Bacon Act to pay prevailing wages on federally funded

projects. Water infrastructure financing issues are likely to be a priority in the 108th

Congress.

More generally, following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the World Trade

Center and the Pentagon, congressional attention focused on security, preparedness, and

emergency response issues. One topic of interest is protection of the nation’s water

infrastructure facilities (both drinking water and wastewater) from possible physical damage,

biological/chemical attacks, and cyber disruption. (For information, see CRS Report

RS21026, Terrorist and Security Issues Facing the Water Infrastructure Sector.)

Policymakers considered a number of legislative options in this area, including enhanced

physical security, communication and coordination, and research. In December 2001,

Congress appropriated $176 million in funds to EPA for water infrastructure and other

security activities (P.L. 107-117), and in May 2002, Congress passed legislation authorizing

CRS-7

IB10067

03-13-03

funding for drinking water utility vulnerability assessments (P.L. 107-188). In October, the

House passed a bill authorizing grants for vulnerability assessments by wastewater utilities

(H.R. 5169, H.Rept. 107-645). Similar legislation was introduced in the Senate (S. 3037).

The CWA is the principal law that governs pollution in the nation’s lakes, rivers, and

coastal waters and authorizes funds to aid construction of municipal wastewater treatment

plants. The Act was last comprehensively amended in 1987, and authorizations for most

programs expired on September 30, 1990. Activities under the Act continue, however, as

Congress has regularly appropriated funds to implement the law. Although no

comprehensive reauthorization legislation was enacted during the 106th Congress, activity

on bills dealing with specific water quality issues did occur, and oversight hearings on some

existing provisions of the Act and Clinton Administration water quality initiatives were held.

Throughout this period, Congress has considered possible actions to implement existing

provisions of the CWA, whether additional steps are necessary to achieve the overall goals

of the Act, and the appropriate federal role in guiding and paying for clean water activities.

(For further information, see CRS Issue Brief IB10069, Clean Water Act Issues in the 107th

Congress.)

Safe Drinking Water Act (by Mary Tiemann)

The Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) is the principal federal statute for regulating the

quality of water provided by public water systems. Congress last reauthorized the Act in

1996, authorizing funding for SDWA programs through FY2003. (For a review of the Act,

see CRS Report RL31243, Safe Drinking Water Act: A Summary of the Act and Its Major

Requirements.) Key issues in the 107th Congress included drinking water infrastructure needs

and funding, and the security of the Nation’s water supplies. Water infrastructure financing

may continue to be of interest in the 108th Congress.

A major SDWA issue has concerned the ability of public water systems to comply with

a growing number of complex drinking water rules. Congress authorized a drinking water

state revolving fund (DWSRF) program in 1996 to help communities finance projects needed

to comply with SDWA rules. Since FY1997, Congress has provided roughly $5.2 billion for

the program, including $850 million for FY2002. However, a large funding gap remains and

is expected to grow as new rules increase needs and infrastructure ages. (See CRS Report 97677, Safe Drinking Water Act: State Revolving Fund Program.) On July 29, 2002, the Senate

Environment and Public Works Committee reported S. 1961 (S.Rept. 107-228), a drinking

water and wastewater infrastructure financing bill which would have increased funding

authority for the DWSRF and would have provided $5 billion over 5 years for a small

drinking water system grant program. (See CRS Report RL31344, Water Infrastructure

Financing Legislation: Comparison of S. 1961 and H.R. 3930.)

The 107th Congress also acted on drinking water security legislation. The emergency

supplemental appropriations for FY2002 (P.L. 107-117) contains $90.3 million for activities

including assessing the vulnerabilities of drinking water utilities, and $5 million for state

grants for assessing drinking water safety. On June 12, 2002, the President signed the

Bioterrorism Preparedness Act (P.L. 107-188, H.R. 3448) which authorized $160 million for

drinking water utilities to conduct vulnerability assessments, prepare emergency response

plans, and make basic security enhancements. Additionally, the Act authorized funding for

CRS-8

IB10067

03-13-03

water infrastructure security research and for emergency assistance to states and public water

systems. (See CRS Report RL31294, Safeguarding the Nation’s Drinking Water: EPA and

Congressional Actions.)

Legislation also targeted specific contaminants. At least 13 bills addressed the problem

of the gasoline additive methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) being detected in drinking water

supplies. (See CRS Report 98-290 ENR, MTBE in Gasoline: Clean Air and Drinking Water

Issues.) House and Senate versions of the energy bill, H.R. 4, proposed to authorize the

appropriation of $200 million from the Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) Trust

Fund to respond to MTBE contamination. (Also see CRS Report RS21201, Leaking

Underground Storage Tanks: Program Status and Issues.) Numerous bills were introduced

regarding the regulation of arsenic in drinking water, after EPA delayed a rule issued in

January 2001 to reduce the arsenic standard from 50 parts per billion (ppb) to 10 ppb. After

reviewing the research and analyses for the arsenic rule, EPA announced that the standard

will be 10 ppb. Many in Congress had objected to the delay, and the conference report for

EPA’s FY2002 appropriations (P.L. 107-73, H.Rept. 107- 272) prohibited EPA from using

funds to delay the rule. The rule entered into effect on February 22, 2002, with a compliance

deadline of 2006 for public water systems. Several bills (e.g., H.R. 1252 and H.R. 1413)

proposed new funding to assist small systems in complying with the arsenic standard

specifically. In addition, S. 1961 and other bills (e.g., H.R. 1178/S. 503, H.R. 3224, and S.

1299) would have authorized grant programs to help small communities comply with all

SDWA standards. S. 1593, a water security research bill, included $40 million to assist small

communities in complying with arsenic requirements. (For more information, see CRS

Report RS20672, Arsenic in Drinking Water: Recent Regulatory Developments and Issues.)

Superfund and Brownfields (by Mark Reisch)

The Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act passed both

chambers on December 20, 2001, and was signed into law on January 11, 2002 (P.L. 107118, H.R. 2869). It amends the Superfund Act, formally known as the Comprehensive

Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act, or CERCLA, which is the

principal federal law for cleaning up spills and other discharges of hazardous substances.

The brownfields program for cleaning up less serious hazardous waste sites was initiated

administratively by EPA under the aegis of the Superfund program, and the current

enactment establishes the statutory authority for the brownfields program as well as

providing it with funding separate from the Superfund program.

The Small Business Liability Relief Act, Title I of H.R. 2869, exempts from CERCLA

liability for cleanup costs those persons who disposed of “de micromis” quantities of material

containing hazardous substances (less than 110 gallons of liquid or less than 200 pounds of

solid material) at sites on the National Priorities List prior to April 1, 2001. It also exempts

from liability residential property owners, small businesses, and small non-profit

organizations who sent municipal solid waste to a site that was later listed on the NPL. A

party who sues someone who is exempted from liability due to these provisions must pay the

exempted party’s attorney’s fees and court costs. The act also authorizes EPA to reduce the

amount of a settlement for a small business or other person who demonstrates an inability

or limited ability to pay for cleanup.

CRS-9

IB10067

03-13-03

Title II of the Act would authorize $200 million per year for 5 years for grants to local

governments, states, and Indian tribes to inventory, assess, and clean up brownfield sites.

The lesser of $50 million or one-fourth of the annual appropriation would be dedicated to

cleaning up “relatively low-risk” brownfield sites contaminated by petroleum, which is not

presently allowed by CERCLA. The grants would be awarded competitively based on

ranking criteria in the Act. An additional $50 million per year would be provided to establish

and enhance state and tribal cleanup programs. EPA would be prohibited from enforcement

activities at sites in a state cleanup program except in certain circumstances, such as an

imminent and substantial danger to public health or the environment. Title II also provides

liability protection from CERCLA for property contaminated by a contiguous site, for

prospective purchasers, and for innocent landowners. It requires states to maintain a public

record of brownfield sites; and directs the President to defer listing an eligible site on

Superfund’s National Priorities List (NPL) if a state so requests, so long as the state is

making progress in addressing it.

On November 19, 2002, the Senate passed S. 606 (S.Rept. 107-320) to establish an

independent ombudsman in EPA to assist the public and conduct investigations concerning

the programs administered by the Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response. These

include the solid and hazardous waste programs, Superfund and brownfield activities, leaking

underground storage tanks, and oil spills.

The House passed H.R. 2941 on June 4, 2002. The bill enhances municipalities’

(especially smaller ones) ability to take advantage of the Dept. of Housing and Urban

Development’s brownfields program. The Senate Environment and Public Works

Committee reported S. 1079 on April 25, 2002, to provide $60 million per year for the

Economic Development Administration’s brownfield program.

Issues that the 108th Congress may consider are the dwindling balance of the Superfund

trust fund, oversight of the new brownfields law, and, if they are not enacted in the current

session, successor bills to those referred to above: S. 606, H.R. 2941, and S. 1079. (For

further discussion, see CRS Issue Brief IB10078, Superfund and Brownfields in the 107th

Congress.)

Solid Waste Issues (by James McCarthy)

The principal legislation affecting solid waste in the 107th Congress was in the

comprehensive energy bill (H.R. 4), which the Senate passed on April 25, 2002, and the

House passed August 2, 2001. The bill died in conference, leaving the solid waste issues and

other issues addressed by H.R. 4 for consideration by the 108th Congress.

In the House version of H.R. 4, Section 3306 contained tax credits for the production

of energy from landfill gas. The provision would have reinstated tax credits under Section

29 of the Internal Revenue Code that had expired in 1998. The credits would have been

equal to more than $1.00 per thousand cubic feet of gas produced, and would have been

allowed for facilities placed in service between July 1, 1998 and December 31, 2006. They

would have applied to all gas produced at such facilities for a 5-year period beginning on the

date of enactment or the onset of production (whichever was later). Facilities required to

collect gas under Clean Air Act regulations would have qualified for smaller credits.

CRS-10

IB10067

03-13-03

Section 2310 of the Senate version of H.R. 4 also would have reinstated Section 29

credits for production of energy from landfill gas, but for a more restricted period of time.

The credits would have applied for a 3-year period, and would have applied to facilities

placed in service after the date of enactment and before January 1, 2005. The Senate bill also

included provisions to encourage the production of ethanol from municipal solid waste; the

House bill had no comparable provision.

Interstate shipment of solid waste, caused in part by the closure of old landfills,

continues to be of some interest to the Congress. In March 2001, New York City closed

Fresh Kills landfill, the last remaining landfill within city limits. [The landfill was

temporarily re-opened to handle debris from the World Trade Center, but it is no longer

handling any municipal garbage.] Fresh Kills was once the largest landfill in the United

States, accepting 13,000 tons of waste per day in 1996, when the decision to close it was

made. The city has few in-state disposal options, and, as a result of the landfill’s closure, is

now sending virtually all of its garbage out of state. It has long been argued that the closure

of Fresh Kills, in addition to mounting exports of waste from other large cities, might

provide the stimulus for Congress to address solid waste legislation; but the event came and

went without congressional action. Several bills addressing interstate shipment of waste

were introduced but there was no action on any of them.

The Senate passed S. 351, a bill to amend the Solid Waste Disposal Act to limit the use

of mercury fever thermometers and to improve the management of mercury collected from

waste and from surplus stocks. The House did not take up the issue.

Defense Cleanup and Environmental Programs

(by David Bearden)

Although the Environmental Protection Agency is the primary federal agency

responsible for the control of pollution and the cleanup of civilian environmental

contamination, the Department of Defense (DOD) is responsible for remediating

contamination and controlling pollution at military facilities. DOD administers five

environmental programs, including cleanup, compliance, pollution prevention,

environmental technology, and conservation. In addition to DOD’s programs, the

Department of Energy (DOE) is responsible for managing defense nuclear waste and

cleaning up contaminated nuclear weapons sites. Some of the principal issues associated

with these programs are the adequacy, cost, and pace of cleanup, whether DOD and DOE

adequately comply with environmental laws and regulations, and the extent to which

environmental requirements encroach upon military readiness.

The first session of the 107th Congress authorized and appropriated funding in FY2002

for national defense programs: the National Defense Authorization Act for FY2002 (P.L.

107-107), Department of Defense Appropriations Act for FY2002 (P.L. 107-117), Military

Construction Appropriations Act for FY2002 (P.L. 107-64), and Energy and Water

Development Appropriations Act for FY2002 (P.L. 107-66). These laws provided nearly

$10.8 billion for DOD’s and DOE’s defense-related environmental programs, and the

Administration requested almost $11.2 billion for FY2003.

CRS-11

IB10067

03-13-03

The second session of the 107th Congress completed action on legislation to authorize

national defense programs for FY2003, including funding for DOD and DOE’s defenserelated environmental programs. As enacted, the conference agreement on P.L. 107-314

(H.R. 4546, H.Rept. 107-772) authorizes $1.32 billion for environmental cleanup at current

and former military installations, and it would authorize $565 million for base closure

activities, which would include the cleanup of environmental contamination. As in past

years, funding for environmental compliance, pollution prevention, environmental

technology, and conservation would be authorized primarily under the Operation and

Maintenance, Procurement, and Research and Development Accounts. A total of $6.76

billion would be authorized for DOE’s management of defense nuclear waste and cleanup

of contaminated nuclear weapons sites. The conference agreement also contains several

other environmentally related provisions, including an interim exemption for military

readiness activities from certain requirements under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act.

However, the conference committee did not adopt House proposals to provide broad

exemptions from the Endangered Species Act and targeted exemptions from the Wilderness

Act.

The second session also completed action on FY2003 appropriations for DOD,

including its environmental programs. P.L. 107-248 (H.R. 5010) appropriated $1.31 billion

for environmental cleanup at current and former military installations, $6 million less than

the funding level of $1.32 billion that would be authorized under H.R. 4546, and nearly $34

million more than the FY2002 appropriation of $1.28 billion. As in defense authorization

legislation, funding for environmental compliance, pollution prevention, environmental

technology, and conservation will come primarily from appropriations for the Operation and

Maintenance, Procurement, and Research and Development Accounts. P.L. 107-249 (H.R.

5011) appropriated $561 million for base closure activities, which includes support for the

cleanup of environmental contamination, $4 million less than the funding level of $565

million that would be authorized under H.R. 4546, and $72 million less than the FY2002

appropriation of nearly $633 million. The 107th Congress did not complete action on

FY2003 appropriations for DOE’s defense nuclear waste management and cleanup

responsibilities. A continuing resolution (P.L. 107-294, H.J.Res. 124) provides funding for

these activities at the FY2002 funding level of approximately $6.49 billion through January

11, 2003. Final appropriations for FY2003 are expected to be considered early in the first

session of the 108th Congress. Funding for FY2004 will be considered during the first

session as well. (CRS Report RL31456, Defense Cleanup and Environmental Programs:

Authorization and Appropriations for FY2003, provides additional information.)

Global Climate Change

(by Susan Fletcher and Brent Yacobucci)

The key piece of climate change legislation in the 107th Congress was the Senate version

of H.R. 4, the comprehensive energy bill. This version would establish an Office of National

Climate Change Policy to develop a climate change response strategy. Further, the Senate

version of H.R. 4 would, among other things, establish a voluntary greenhouse gas database

and promote research and development on climate change. The House version of the bill

contained reauthorization language for EPA’s climate-related programs. The Congress

adjourned without reconciling these bills. The 107th Congress had also included climate

CRS-12

IB10067

03-13-03

change provisions in the House and Senate State Department authorization bills (though

these were dropped in conference), in some versions of appropriation bills, and in a number

of other bills.

Concern that the increases in “greenhouse gases” in the atmosphere has caused warming

of the Earth’s climate has led to a number of international responses, as well as issues of

interest to the U.S. Congress. One of the main issues for Congress over the past several years

has been oversight of the U.S. negotiations related to the Kyoto Protocol to the 1992 United

Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), which involve potential

rules for how climate change might be addressed by the United States and other nations, and

what policies are appropriate domestically to address climate change concerns. However,

since the Bush Administration rejected the Kyoto Protocol, the issues for Congress have been

evolving as the Administration’s positions have developed. On February 14th, 2002, the

Administration announced a series of voluntary measures intended to reduce greenhouse gas

emissions, plus some increased climate related funding. The cornerstone of this new

approach is the reduction of greenhouse gas intensity – that is, greenhouse gas emissions per

unit of production.

It is likely that climate change and greenhouse gas issues will again be the subject of

legislation or hearings in the 108th Congress.

(For further discussion , see CRS Issue Brief IB89005, Global Climate Change; CRS

Report RL30692, Global Climate Change: The Kyoto Protocol; CRS Report RL31205,

Climate Change and Relevant Legislation in the 107th Congress; and the “Congressional

Bills” section of the CRS electronic briefing book on Global Climate Change, at

[http://www.congress.gov/brbk/html/ebgcc1.html].)

Regulating Pesticides (by Linda Schierow)

The 107th Congress considered, but did not enact legislation to reduce risks of terrorism

at facilities handling large quantities of potentially dangerous chemicals. Such facilities

might be vulnerable to direct attacks or covert use of business contacts, facilities, and

materials to gain access to chemicals. Risks may be increasing, consequences for human

health and the environment could be severe, and limited evidence suggests that many

chemical facilities may lack adequate safeguards. Policy makers face three key issues: the

effect of public access to information about facilities’ hazards and risk management plans;

the relative importance of diverse risks; and who should be responsible for achieving results.

For more on this topic, see CRS Report RL31530, Chemical Plant Security.

S. 1602, as reported by the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, and

House companion H.R. 5300 would require EPA, in consultation with the Office (or

Department) of Homeland Security, to identify high priority chemical risks and to issue

regulations requiring owners and operators of stationary sources to take actions to prevent,

control, and minimize the potential consequences of a release. Facilities would be required

to consider chemical and process changes that enhance inherent safety. The bill would

exempt vulnerability assessments and risk management plans from Freedom of Information

Act (FOIA) requirements. H.R. 4698 would have authorized the Secretary of Commerce to

issue licenses to qualified persons and to restrict the sale, purchase, and distribution of

CRS-13

IB10067

03-13-03

certain chemicals to licensees. S. 2579 would have amended the Clean Air Act to eliminate

the names and locations of facilities from publicly available facility risk management plans,

and made public disclosure of such information by government officials a crime. The bill

also would have expanded official access to the plans.

The bill that established the new Department of Homeland Security, H.R.5005, does not

address chemical plant security directly. However, if facilities are part of the “critical

infrastructure” (as are water utilities, for example), the new law will exempt from FOIA

requirements information about the plants’ vulnerability to terrorism if it is submitted

voluntarily to the Department. The Department of Homeland Security is required to analyze

vulnerabilities and recommend methods of enhancing site security.

Funding the Environmental Protection Agency

(by Martin R. Lee)

For FY2002, the President requested $7.3 billion in discretionary budget authority for

EPA. P.L. 107-73 (H.R. 2620), signed on November 26, 2001, provided $7.9 billion. P.L.

107-117 (H.R. 3338, Division B), the FY2002 Emergency Supplemental Act, provided

supplemental funding of $176 million for EPA activities related to anti-terrorism. P.L. 107206 (H.R. 4775) would have provided $50 million in additional supplemental funding in

FY2002 for drinking water vulnerability assessments, but in August, the President announced

he would not spend contingent emergency funds in the bill, including EPA funds.

For FY2003, the President requested $7.6 billion in discretionary budget authority for

EPA, nearly $460 million less than the FY2002 funding level of $8.1 billion, which included

the $176 million in supplemental funding for anti-terrorism activities. The requested decrease

is primarily due to the Administration’s proposal to discontinue funding for various activities

that received earmarked funding in FY2002, the majority of which consisted of water

infrastructure projects. As part of its FY2003 budget request, the Administration also has

proposed to shift more enforcement responsibilities to the states. On July 25, 2002, the

Senate Appropriations Committee approved $8.3 billion for EPA for FY2003 in reporting

S. 2797 (S.Rept. 107-222), restoring much of last year’s earmarked funding for water

infrastructure projects. Continuing resolution provides funding at the same level as enacted

for FY2002, until a final appropriations bill was enacted for FY2003. On October 10, 2002,

the House Appropriations Committee reported H.R. 5605, authorizing an FY2003

appropriation of $8.3 billion. (The 108th Congress completed action on the FY2003

appropriations adopting a level of $8.1 billion for EPA in P.L. 108-7 (H.J.Res. 2), signed

February 20, 2003). (See CRS Issue Brief IB10101, The Environmental Protection Agency’s

FY2003 Budget, for further discussion.)

Environmental Research and Development

(by Michael Simpson)

The 107th Congress acted to consider specific ways to improve the quality of

science at EPA, to fund Agency programs, and to authorize the EPA Office of Air and

Radiation and EPA’s climate change programs.

CRS-14

IB10067

03-13-03

S. 1176 (Environmental Research Enhancement Act of 2001) and House-passed H.R.64

would establish a Deputy Administrator for Science and Technology (S&T) and an Assistant

Administrator for Research and Development. Both proposed new duties for some EPA

offices to try to improve the quality of science acquired, reviewed, used by, and disseminated

from the Agency.

The Administration requested $641 million for EPA’s S&T account for FY2002. The

House-passed version of H.R.2620 included $680 million; the Senate-passed version, $666

million. Signed on November 26, PL107-73 provided $698million for S&T, and transferred

$37 million from the Superfund account. The Administration requested $670 million for

EPA Science and Technology for FY2003. In Senate Report 107-222 accompanying S.

2797, the Appropriations Committee recommended $710 million for S&T, $78 million

below the enacted level including supplemental funding, and the Committee recommended

transferring $86 million from the Superfund account, for a total of $796 million for S&T.

The Senate Appropriations Committee denied a proposal to cease funding the Science to

Achieve Results fellows grants program and recommended $9.75 million.

As passed by the House on August 2, 2001, and the Senate on April 25, 2002, with the

last conference held on October 3, 2002, H.R. 4 inter alia authorizes EPA climate programs.

Earlier, two bills in the 107th Congress would authorize appropriations for EPA’s Office of

Air and Radiation, and EPA’s Climate Change Protection Programs. Placed on the Union

Calendar on July 31, 2001, H.R. 2460 Subtitle G authorizes them for FY2002 at $157

million, FY2003 at $163 million, and FY2004 at $169 million. Of these amounts, the

following would be for science: $28 million for FY2002, $29 million for FY2003, and $31

million for FY2004. For climate change programs, $128 million would be allocated for

FY2002, $134 million for FY2003, and $139 million for FY2004. As placed on the Senate

Legislative Calendar on September 4, H.R. 4 Subtitle G would authorize $122 million for

FY2002, $127 million for FY2003, and $132 million for FY2004 for Climate Protection

Programs (information about these programs can be found in CRS Issue Brief IB10020,

Energy Efficiency: Budget, Oil Conservation, and Electricity Conservation Issues). H.R. 4

also makes EPA responsible for emissions monitoring, measurement, verification, and data

collection as part of a voluntary greenhouse gas database.

One significant issue for the 108th Congress likely will be funding EPA’s work on

homeland security and other concerns. EPA’s FY2003 S&T budget request included $75

million for homeland security efforts, including research and development of ways to more

rapidly and effectively decontaminate buildings, detect terrorism hazards, and transfer new

technologies to first-responders (see CRS Report RS21270 Counterterrorism Research and

Development for related information). Other FY2003 S&T budget requests include $10.8

million for researching aggregate exposure and cumulative risk of pesticide exposures, $9.8

million for a national competition to encourage the use of innovative environmental

technologies, and $4.9 million for research into possible allergenicity and ecological effects

of engineered crops.

CRS-15

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.