Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Congressional research reportJan 5, 2007

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology

Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

(name redacted)

Specialist in Science and Technology Policy

(name redacted)

Specialist in Science and Technology Policy

(name redacted)

Specialist in Telecommunications Policy

(name redacted)

Section Research Manager

(name redacted)

Specialist in Internet and Telecommunications Policy

(name redacted)

Information Research Specialist

January 5, 2007

Congressional Research Service

7-....

www.crs.gov

98-67

CRS Report for Congress

Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Summary

In the decade between 1994 and 2004, the number of U.S. adults using the Internet increased

from 15% to 63%, and by 2005, stood at 78.6%. From electronic mail to accessing information to

watching videos to online purchasing, the Internet touches almost every aspect of modern life.

The extent to which use of the Internet continues to grow, however, may be affected by a number

of technology policy issues being debated in Congress.

First is the availability of high-speed—or “broadband”—Internet access. Broadband Internet

access gives users the ability to send and receive data at speeds far greater than “dial-up” Internet

access over traditional telephone lines. With deployment of broadband technologies accelerating,

Congress is seeking to ensure fair competition and timely broadband deployment to all sectors

and geographical locations of American society.

Next are a range of issues that reflect challenges faced by those who do use the Internet, such as

security, privacy (including spyware and identity theft), unsolicited commercial electronic mail

(“spam”), protecting children from unsuitable material (such as pornography), and computer

security, including the vulnerability of the nation’s critical infrastructures to cyber attacks.

Other issues include the Internet’s domain name system (DNS), which is administered by a

nonprofit corporation called the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers

(ICANN). With the Department of Commerce currently exercising legal authority over ICANN,

Congress continues to monitor the administration of the DNS, particularly with respect to issues

such as privacy, governance, and protecting children on the Internet.

The evolving role of the Internet in the political economy of the United States also continues to

attract congressional attention. Among the issues are what changes may be needed at the Federal

Communications Commission in the Internet age, federal support for information technology

research and development, provision of online services by the government (“e-government”), and

availability and use of “open source” software by the government.

A number of laws already have been passed on many of these issues. Congress is monitoring the

effectiveness of these laws, and assessing what other legislation may be needed. Other CRS

reports referenced in this document track legislation, and the reader should consult those reports,

which are updated more frequently than this one, for current information.

This report will not be updated.

Congressional Research Service

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Contents

Introduction ................................................................................................................................1

Background: Internet Usage and E-Commerce Statistics..............................................................1

Internet Usage in the United States........................................................................................1

Trends.............................................................................................................................1

Number of Users.............................................................................................................2

Geographic Distribution..................................................................................................2

International Internet Usage ..................................................................................................3

E-Commerce.........................................................................................................................3

Broadband Internet Regulation and Access..................................................................................4

Computer and Internet Security...................................................................................................6

Internet Privacy...........................................................................................................................9

Spyware.............................................................................................................................. 10

Identity Theft and “Phishing”.............................................................................................. 10

“Spam”: Unsolicited Commercial Electronic Mail..................................................................... 11

Protecting Children from Unsuitable Material ........................................................................... 12

Internet Domain Names ............................................................................................................ 13

Background ........................................................................................................................ 14

Issues.................................................................................................................................. 15

Governance................................................................................................................... 15

ICANN-Verisign Agreement and the .com registry ........................................................ 16

Protecting Children on the Internet ................................................................................ 17

Trademark Disputes ...................................................................................................... 18

Privacy ......................................................................................................................... 18

Government Information Technology Management ................................................................... 19

The Federal Communications Commission ......................................................................... 19

Information Technology R&D............................................................................................. 20

Electronic Government (E-Government) ............................................................................. 21

Open Source Software......................................................................................................... 22

Tables

Table B-1. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 105th Congress.............................................. 32

Table B-2. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 106th Congress.............................................. 33

Table B-3. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 107th Congress.............................................. 33

Table B-4. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 108th Congress.............................................. 33

Table B-5. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 109th Congress.............................................. 34

Appendixes

Appendix A. List of Acronyms .................................................................................................. 25

Congressional Research Service

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Appendix B. Legislation Passed by the 105th-109th Congresses .................................................. 28

Contacts

Author Contact Information ...................................................................................................... 34

Congressional Research Service

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Introduction

The continued growth of the Internet for personal, government, and business purposes may be

affected by a number of technology policy issues being debated by Congress. Among them are

access to and regulation of broadband (high-speed) Internet services, computer and Internet

security, Internet privacy, the impact of “spam,” concerns about what children may encounter

(such as pornography) when using the Internet, management of the Internet Domain Name

System, and government information technology management.

This report provides overviews of those issues, plus appendices providing a list of acronyms, and

a discussion of legislation passed in earlier Congresses. Other issues that are not directly related

to technology could also affect the use and growth of the Internet, such as intellectual property

rights and Internet taxation. Those are not addressed in this report.

This report does not attempt to track legislation. For more timely information, see the other CRS

reports identified in the following sections.

Background: Internet Usage and E-Commerce

Statistics1

A December 2006 survey by the Nielsen/Net Ratings market research firm found that 78% of

active home Web users connected via broadband during the month of November, up 13

percentage points from 65% of active Web users a year ago. Social activities dominate broadband

time online: websites for online gaming, instant messaging, e-mail and social networking all

made the top 10 list when ranked by average time per person among broadband users at home.

The Internet has become an integral part of everyday social life, particularly among children and

teenagers.2

A spring 2006 Pew Internet & American Life survey found that 48 million Americans—mostly

those with high-speed access at home—have posted content to the Internet. 3

Internet Usage in the United States

Trends

The Fifth Study of the Internet by the Digital Future Project Finds Major New Trends in Online

Use for Political Campaigns4 highlights the major findings in the Annenberg School’s Digital

1

By (name redacted), Knowledge Services Group.

2

Nielsen/NetRatings press release, Over Three-fourths of U.S. Active Internet Users Connect via Broadband at Home

in November, According to Nielsen/Netratings, December 12, 2006. See http://www.nielsen-netratings.com/pr/

pr_061212.pdf.

3

Pew Internet and American Life. Home Broadband Adoption 2006, May 28, 2006. See http://www.pewinternet.org/

PPF/r/184/report_display.asp.

4

USC Annenberg School, Center for the Digital Future. Online World As Important to Internet Users as Real World?,

November 29, 2006. See http://www.digitalcenter.org/pages/news_content.asp?intGlobalId=212&intTypeId=1.

Congressional Research Service

1

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Future Project, which is studying the impact of the Internet on Americans. Among the findings

are:

•

Internet users are finding growing numbers of online friends, as well as friends

they first met online and then met in person. Internet users report having met an

average of 4.65 friends online whom they have never met in person.

•

Although more than 40%of users say that the Internet has increased the number

of people with whom they stay in contact, a lower percent say that since starting

to use the Internet they are communicating more with family and friends.

•

While large percentages of Internet users say that going online increases contact

with family and friends, almost all users report that the Internet has no effect on

the time spent with close friends or family face-to-face.

Number of Users

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) issues biannual reports on broadband Internet

access service. 5 In its July 2006 report, the FCC reported that during the year 2005, high-speed

lines serving residential, small business, larger business, and other subscribers increased by 33%,

to 50.2 million lines. High-speed lines serving residential and small business subscribers

increased by 36% during 2005, to 42.9 million lines.6 Additional demographic information on

Internet users is compiled by MRI Cyberstats.7

Geographic Distribution

Rural Americans are less likely to log on to the Internet at home with high-speed Internet

connections than people living in other parts of the country. However, rural areas show fast

growth in home broadband uptake in the past two years and the gap between rural and non-rural

America in home broadband adoption, though still substantial, is narrowing. As of March 2006,

39% of adult rural Americans went online at home with high-speed Internet connections

compared with 42% of adults in urban and suburban areas.8 A Nation Online: Entering the

Broadband Age, the sixth report released by the U.S. Department of Commerce examining

Americans’ use of computers, the Internet, and other information technology tools, examined the

geographic differences in broadband adoption and the reasons why some Americans do not have

high-speed service. 9 According to the September 2004 report, although the rate of Internet

penetration among rural households (54.1%) was similar to that in urban areas (54.8%), the

proportion of Internet users with home broadband connections remained much lower in rural

areas than in urban areas.

5

For the purposes of the FCC report, broadband means high-speed lines that deliver services exceeding 200 kilobits

(kb) per second in at least one direction. Broadband Internet issues are discussed later in this report.

6

FCC. Federal Communications Commission Releases Data on High-Speed Services for Internet Access. Press release,

July 26, 2006. Available at http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-266593A1.pdf.

7

MRI Cyberstats, Internet Access and Usage in the U.S., Spring 2006. See http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/

A0908398.html

8

Pew Internet & American Life, Home Broadband Adoption 2006, May 28, 2006. See http://www.pewinternet.org/

PPF/r/176/report_display.asp.

9

U.S. Department of Commerce. A Nation Online: Entering the Broadband Age. September 2004. See

http://www.ntia.doc.gov/reports/anol/index.html. Rural/urban geographic distribution figures are on pp. 15-19.

Congressional Research Service

2

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

International Internet Usage

There are many different estimates of international Internet usage. Some sources which compile

Internet usage data are: the International Telecommunications Union (ITU), the Organisation for

Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the CIA Fact Book, and independent market

research firms such as Nielsen//NetRatings, eMarketer, and the Computer Industry Almanac.10

According to a January 2006 estimate from the Computer Industry Almanac, the worldwide

number of Internet users is 1.08 billion.11 The 2 billion Internet users milestone is expected to

occur in 2011. Much of current and future Internet user growth is coming from highly populated

countries such as China, India, Brazil, Russia, and Indonesia. In the next decade many Internet

users will be accessing the Internet with mobile devices, in addition to personal computers.12

Broadband subscribers in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)

member countries13 reached 181 million by June 2006. Over the past year, the number of

broadband subscribers in the OECD increased 33% from 136 million in June 2005 to 181 million

in June 2006. This growth increased broadband penetration rates in the OECD from 11.7 in June

2005 to 15.5 subscriptions per 100 inhabitants one year later.14 The main highlights for the first

half of 2006 are:

•

Northern European countries have continued their advance with high broadband

penetration rates. In June 2006, six countries (Denmark, the Netherlands, Iceland,

Korea, Switzerland and Finland) led the OECD in broadband penetration, each

with at least 25 subscribers per 100 inhabitants.

•

Denmark now leads the OECD with a broadband penetration rate of 29.3

subscribers per 100 inhabitants.

•

The strongest per-capita subscriber growth comes from Denmark, Australia,

Norway, the Netherlands, Finland, Luxembourg, Sweden and the United

Kingdom.

•

The United States has the largest total number of broadband subscribers in the

OECD at 57 million representing 31% of all broadband connections in the

OECD.

E-Commerce

The U.S. Census Bureau releases quarterly retail e-commerce statistics. On November 17, 2006,

its estimate of U.S. retail e-commerce sales for the third quarter of 2006, adjusted for seasonal

10

One source of comparative data is: Internet Usage Statistics - The Big Picture. World Internet Users and Population

Stats. See http://internetworldstats.com/stats.htm.

11

ClickZ Stats, Web Worldwide, See: http://www.clickz.com/showPage.html?page=stats/web_worldwide.

12

Computer Industry Almanac, Worldwide Internet Users Top 1 Billion in 2005, January 4, 2006. See http://www.c-ia.com/pr0106.htm.

13

OECD member countries include Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland,

France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Korea, Luxembourg, Mexico, The Netherlands, New

Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovak Republic, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, United Kingdom, and the

United States.

14

OECD Broadband Statistics to June, 2006. See http://www.oecd.org/sti/ict/broadband.

Congressional Research Service

3

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

variation and holiday and trading-day differences, but not for price changes, was $27.5 billion, an

increase of 4.5% from the 2nd quarter of 2006. Total retail sales for the 4th quarter of 2006 were

estimated at $991.7 billion, an increase of 0.7% from the 2nd quarter of 2006.15 E-commerce sales

in the third quarter accounted for 2.8% of total sales.

ComScore Networks reported its e-commerce sales estimates for the first three quarters of 2006

and forecasts for the entire year. Overall, comScore forecasts that total online spending in 2006

will reach approximately $170 billion. Of that total, the market research firm estimates that nontravel e-commerce will break the $100 billion threshold for the first time. Through the first three

quarters of 2006, total e-commerce spending rose 19 percent versus last year to $122.1 billion,

buoyed by a 24% increase in non-travel spending to $69.1 billion.16

Broadband Internet Regulation and Access17

Broadband Internet access gives users the ability to send and receive data at speeds far greater

than conventional “dial up” Internet access over existing telephone lines. Broadband

technologies—cable modem, digital subscriber line (DSL), satellite, wireless Internet, and fiber—

are currently being deployed nationwide by the private sector. While the numbers of new

broadband subscribers continue to grow, some areas of the nation—particularly rural and lowincome communities—continue to lack sufficient access to high-speed broadband Internet

service. In order to address this problem, the 109th Congress considered, but did not pass,

legislation to address the scope and effect of federal broadband financial assistance programs

(including universal service), and the impact of regulatory policies and new technologies on

broadband deployment. These issues are anticipated to continue to be a focus of the broadband

policy debate in the 110th Congress.

Some policymakers, believing that disparities in broadband access across American society could

have adverse economic and social consequences on those left behind, assert that the federal

government should play a more active role to avoid a “digital divide” in broadband access. One

approach is for the federal government to provide financial assistance to support broadband

deployment in underserved areas. In the 109th Congress, legislation was introduced, but not

enacted, to provide financial assistance (including loans, grants, and tax incentives) to encourage

broadband deployment. (For more information on federal assistance for broadband deployment,

see CRS Report RL30719, Broadband Internet Access and the Digital Divide: Federal Assistance

Programs, by (name redacted) and (name redacted).) Others, however, question the reality of

the “digital divide,” and argue that federal intervention in the broadband marketplace would be

premature and, in some cases, counterproductive.

The debate over access to broadband services has prompted policymakers to examine a range of

other issues to ensure that broadband will be available on a timely and equal basis to all U.S.

15

U.S. Census Bureau. Quarterly Retail E-commerce Sales, 1st quarter 2006, May 18, 2006. See

http://www.census.gov/mrts/www/ecomm.html.

16

comScore press release, “U.S. Non-Travel E-Commerce Spending By Consumers Increased 23 Percent in Q3 2006

Versus Year Ago, According to comScore Networks,” October 26, 2006. See http://www.comscore.com/press/

release.asp?press=959.

17

By (name redacted) and (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report

RL33542, Broadband Internet Regulation and Access: Background and Issues, by (name redacted) and (name redac

ted), which is updated more frequently than this report.

Congressional Research Service

4

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

citizens. One facet of this debate focuses on whether present laws and subsequent regulatory

policies are needed to ensure the development of competition and its subsequent consumer

benefits, or conversely, whether such laws and regulations are overly burdensome and discourage

needed investment in and deployment of broadband services. The regulatory debate focuses on a

number of issues including the extent to which legacy regulations should be applied to traditional

providers as they enter new markets, the extent to which legacy regulations should be imposed on

new entrants as they compete with traditional providers in their markets, and the treatment of new

and converging technologies.

For example, present law requires all incumbent local exchange (telephone) carriers (ILECs),

such as Verizon or SBC, to open up their networks to enable competitors to lease out parts of the

incumbent’s network. These unbundling and resale requirements, which are detailed in Section

251 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, were enacted in an attempt to open up the local

telephone network to competitors. Whether such “open access” regulations should be applied to

ILECs when they offer new non-dominant services such as broadband connections, or to new

market entrants such as cable television companies when they offer services (such as voice and

broadband) remains under debate. Whether regulators should play a role to ensure that the

Internet remains open to all, often referred to as “net neutrality” became a major part of and is

expected to continue to be, a major focus of the ongoing Congressional debate. Equally

contentious is the debate over whether legacy regulations, such as the requirement that cable

television companies obtain a local franchise as a prerequisite for offering video service, be

extended to other entrants, such as telephone companies, if they choose to enter the video market.

A third and related debate surrounds the appropriate regulatory framework that should be

imposed on new technologies such as voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) and other Internet

Protocol services as well as bundled service offerings.

The regulatory treatment of broadband technologies—whether offered by traditional or emerging

providers, or incumbent or new entrants—remains a major focus of the policy debate. Cities,

counties, and states have taken up the issue of whether to mandate open access requirements on

local cable franchises. In June 1999, a federal judge ruled that the city of Portland, Oregon had

the right to require open access to the Tele-Communications Incorporated (TCI) broadband

network as a condition for transferring its local cable television franchise to AT&T. On March 14,

2002, the FCC adopted a Declaratory Ruling which classified cable modem service as an

“interstate information service,” subject to FCC jurisdiction and largely shielded from local

regulation. After a series of conflicting court decisions the US Supreme Court in a June 27, 2005

action (National Cable and Telecommunications Association v. Brand X Internet Services), ruled

that the FCC should be given deference in its decision that cable broadband service should be

classified as an “interstate information service.” The classification of cable modem service as an

“interstate information service” will result in FCC treatment under the less rigorous Title I of the

1934 Communications Act. Similarly, in an August 5, 2005 action, the FCC ruled that the

regulatory treatment of wireline broadband services will be granted regulatory parity. The FCC

ruled that, subject to a one-year transition period, which expired in August 2006, wireline

broadband Internet access services (commonly delivered by DSL technology) are defined as

information services, thereby placing telephone company DSL services on an equal regulatory

footing with cable modem services. Regulatory parity was also granted to broadband over power

line (BPL) service, when the FCC, in a November 2006 decision, determined that such service

would also be classified as an “interstate information service” subject to Title I regulation.

Finally, emerging broadband technologies—such as fiber, wireless (including “3G”, “wi-fi” and

“Wimax”), and BPL—continue to be developed and/or deployed, and have the potential to affect

Congressional Research Service

5

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

the regulatory and market landscape of broadband deployment. The 110th Congress and the FCC

will likely consider policies to address the emergence of these and other new broadband

technologies. In addition, how and to what extent “social regulations” such as 911 requirements,

disability access, law enforcement obligations, and universal service support, should be applied to

emerging technologies is also under debate. A related issue, the emergence of municipal

broadband networks (primarily wireless and fiber based) and the debate over whether such

networks constitute unfair competition with the private sector has become a significant policy

issue (for more information on municipal broadband, see CRS Report RS20993, Wireless

Technology and Spectrum Demand: Advanced Wireless Services, by (name redacted)).

Computer and Internet Security18

On October 21, 2002, all 13 of the Internet’s root Domain Name System servers were targeted by

a distributed denial of service attack. While the attack had little overall effect on the performance

of the Internet, a more sophisticated and sustainable attack might have had a more deleterious

impact. As use of the Internet grows, so has concern about security of and security on the Internet.

A long list of security-related incidents that have received wide-ranging media coverage (e.g.

Melissa virus, the Love Bug, and the Code Red, Nimda, Slammer, and Blaster worms) represents

the tip of the iceberg. More recently, hackers using Trojan horses and other techniques, were able

to place keylogging software on the personal computers of people with online trading accounts to

surreptitiously acquire their personal account information. The hackers used the information to

access these personal accounts to buy little known stocks in which they (the hackers) had

invested, driving up the price. The thieves then dumped their shares for a profit.19 Every day,

persons gain access, or try to gain access, to someone else’s computer without authorization to

read, copy, modify, or destroy the information contained within. These persons range from

juveniles to disgruntled (ex)employees, to criminals, to competitors, to politically or socially

motivated groups, to agents of foreign governments.

The extent of the problem is unknown. Much of what gets reported as computer “attacks” are

probes, often conducted automatically with software widely available for even juveniles to use.

But the number of instances where someone has actually gained unauthorized access is not

known. Not every person or company whose computer system has been compromised reports it

either to the media or to authorities. Sometimes the victim judges the incident not to be worth the

trouble. Sometimes the victim may judge that the adverse publicity would be worse. Sometimes

the affected parties do not even know their systems have been compromised. There is some

evidence to suggest, however, that the number of incidents is increasing. According to the

Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT) at Carnegie-Mellon University, the number of

incidents reported to it has grown just about every year since the team’s establishment—from 132

incidents in 1989 to over 137,000 incidents in 2003. Since many attacks are now coordinated and

cascade throughout the Internet, CERT no longer tracks the number of incidents reported to them.

While the total number of incidents may be rising exponentially, it is interesting to note that,

according to the Computer Crime and Security Survey, the percentage of respondents that

18

19

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division.

See, Computerworld. ID Thefts Slam Online Brokers, by Eric Lai. Vol. 40. No. 44. Oct. 30, 2006. p.1,43.

Congressional Research Service

6

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

reported unauthorized use of their computer systems over the previous 12 months has declined

since the year 2000.20

The impact on society from the unauthorized access or use of computers is also unknown. Again,

some victims may choose not to report losses. In many cases, it is difficult or impossible to

quantify the losses. But social losses are not zero. Trust in one’s system may be reduced.

Proprietary and/or customer information (including credit card numbers) may be compromised.

Any unwanted code must be found and removed. The veracity of the system’s data must be

checked and restored if necessary. Money may be stolen from accounts or extorted from the

victim. If disruptions occur, sales may be lost. If adverse publicity occurs, future sales may be lost

and stock prices may be affected. Estimates of the overall financial losses due to unauthorized

access vary and are largely speculative. Estimates typically range in the billions of dollars per

major event like the Love Bug virus or the series of denial-of-service attacks of February 2000.21

Similar estimates have been made for the Code Red worms. Estimates of losses internationally

range up to the tens of billions of dollars. In the 2005 Computer Crime and Security Survey, 687

responders (out of a total of 700) estimated financial losses totaling $130 million in the previous

12 months. According to the survey, viruses accounted for the most financial losses ($43 million),

followed by loss of proprietary information. Denial of service attacks accounted for $7 million in

losses. Two of the online brokers whose customers’ accounts were used in the “pump-and-dump”

scheme mentioned above reported spending $22 million to compensate their customers.22 For

more discussion on the economic impact of attacks against computer systems, and the difficulties

in measuring it, see CRS Report RL32331, The Economic Impact of Cyber-Attacks, by (name red

acted) et al.

Aside from the losses discussed above, there is also growing concern that unauthorized access to

computer systems could pose an overall national security risk should it result in the disruption of

the nation’s critical infrastructures (e.g., transportation systems, banking and finance, electric

power generation and distribution). These infrastructures rely increasingly on computer networks

to operate, and are themselves linked by computer and communication networks. In February

2003, the President’s Critical Infrastructure Board (established by President George W. Bush

through E.O. 13231 but later dissolved by E.O. 13286) released a National Strategy to Secure

Cyberspace. The Strategy assigned a number of responsibilities for coordinating the protection of

the nation’s information infrastructure to the Department of Homeland Security. Most of the

Department’s efforts in cybersercurity are managed by the National Cyber Security Division

(NCSD) within in the Preparedness Directorate. As part of the Strategy, the NCSD has assumed a

major role in raising awareness of the risks associated with computer security among all users,

from the home user to major corporations, and to facilitate information exchange between all

parties. To this end numerous cooperative and coordinating groups and fora have been

established. One such activity is U.S.-CERT, a cooperative effort by the National Cyber Security

20

The Computer Crime and Security Survey is conducted by the Computer Security Institute (CSI) in cooperation with

the San Francisco Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Computer Intrusion Squad. The CSI/FBI Survey, as it has become

known, has been conducted annually since 1996, and surveys U.S. corporations, government agencies, financial and

medical institutions and universities. The 2005 Survey indicated a slight increase, after four straight years of decline.

Still over 50% of the respondents have reported unauthorized use. The CSI/FBI survey does not represent a statistical

sampling of the nation’s computer security practitioners. The survey can be found at http://www.gocsi.com. This

website was last viewed on July 10, 2006.

21

This refers to the series of attacks, in February 2000, directed at online giants Yahoo, eBay, Amazon, E Trade,

DATEK, Excite, ZDNEt, buy.com, and CNN.

22

Computerworld. Op. cit.

Congressional Research Service

7

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Division and Carnegie Mellon’s CERT, which among other services and activities, produces alerts

of new and existing attacks and guidelines for preventing or responding to them.

Congress has shown, and continues to show, a strong interest in the security of computers and the

Internet. Over the years this interest has been manifested in numerous hearings by a multitude of

committees and subcommittees, in both the House and the Senate. Legislation has also been

passed. The federal Computer Fraud and Abuse statute (18 U.S.C. 1030) was initially added as

part of the Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984 (P.L. 98-473). This act, as amended, makes

it a federal crime to gain unauthorized access to, damage, or use in an illegal manner, protected

computer systems (including federal computers, bank computers, computers used in interstate and

foreign commerce).23 Legislation specifically requiring system owners/operators to take actions to

protect their computer systems has been confined to executive federal agencies (most recently, the

Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, P.L. 107-347, Title III). Other legislation

is primarily aimed at protecting privacy by protecting certain personal information held by

government and private sector entities and affects computer security indirectly. For example, the

Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (P.L. 106-102, Title V) and the Health Insurance Portability and

Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA, P.L. 104-191, Title II, Subtitle F) require that entities have in

place programs that protect the financial and health-related information, respectively, in their

possession. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (P.P. 107-204) also indirectly affects private sector

computers and networks, by requiring certain firms to certify the integrity of their financial

control systems as part of their annual financial reporting requirements. To the extent that this

information resides on computer systems, these requirements extend to those systems. Congress

also supports a number of programs that help develop computer security education, training, and

research at selected universities. For an overview of federal legislation and other federal

documents associated with computer and internet security, see CRS Report RL32357, Computer

Security: A Summary of Selected Federal Laws, Executive Orders, and Presidential Directives, by

(name redacted).

It is not clear how these efforts have affected the overall security of the Internet. Given the

perceived rise in security threats and attacks, there is a general sense that more must be done.

Aside from the inherent vulnerabilities associated with highly interconnected information

networks, two major sources of vulnerabilities exist: software, and network configuration and

management. Operating systems and applications developers say they are paying greater attention

to designing better security into their software products. But it is still common to have

vulnerabilities found in products after they have been put on the market. In some cases, patches

have had to be offered at the same time a new product is brought onto the market. Although

patches typically are offered to fix these vulnerabilities, many system administrators do not keep

their software/configurations current. Many intrusions take advantage of software vulnerabilities

noted many months earlier, for which fixes have already been offered.

There are as yet no agreed upon industry standards for determining how secure a firm’s computer

system should be or for assessing how secure it is in fact. Some observers speculate that it is only

a matter of time before owners of computer systems are held responsible for damage done to a

third-party computer as a result of inadequately protecting their own systems.24 Nor are there any

agreed upon standards on how secure a vendor’s software product should be. The federal

23

Some of the penalties under this statute have been increased by both the USA PATRIOT Act (P.L. 107-56, Section

814) and the Homeland Security Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-296, Section 225(g)).

24

See “IT Security Destined for the Courtroom,” Computerworld, May 21, 2001, vol. 35, no. 21, pp. 1, 73.

Congressional Research Service

8

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

government, in cooperation with a number of other countries, has developed a set of International

Common Criteria for Information Technology Security Evaluation, to allow certified laboratories

to test security products and rate their level of security for government use. These criteria may

evolve into industry standards for certifying security products. Some in the security community

feel that security will not improve without some requirements imposed upon the private sector.

However, both users and vendors of computer software suggest that the market is sufficient to

address security in the most cost-effective manner. The Bush Administration, as the Clinton

Administration before it, has chosen to use engagement and not regulation to encourage the

private sector to improve security. However, both Administrations did not rule out the use of

regulation if necessary. For a discussion of the difficulties associated with setting standards, see

CRS Report RL32777, Creating a National Framework for Cybersecurity: An Analysis of Issues

and Options, by (name redacted).

During the 109th Congress, legislation was introduced that, again, primarily addressed privacy

issues with indirect impact on computer security. In light of large losses of personal information

through fraud, lost records, and unauthorized access, a number of bills were introduced that

extended the requirements to safeguard and protect personal information, similar to that found in

Gramm-Leach-Bliley and HIPPA, to “information brokers” and/or required any organization

engaged in interstate commerce holding personal information to inform consumers of any

security breach that may have compromised their information. Bills commonly referred to as

“Spyware” legislation were also introduced. These topics are discussed in the next section of this

report. The theft of a laptop computer from the home of a employee of the Department of

Veterans Affairs in May 2006, containing personal information of over 20 million military

veterans, while not an Internet-related incident, renewed focus on the ability of federal agencies

to enforce their own information security policies and procedures and to hold agency officials

accountable. Such concern led the House to pass the Veterans Identity and Credit Security Act of

2006 (H.R. 5835) that included amendments to the Federal Information Security Management

Act. The Senate did not take up the bill. Similar activity is expected in the 110th Congress.

Internet Privacy

Concerns related to Internet privacy encompass a wide range of issues. At the center of these

issues is how networks can facilitate the collection and transfer of data inexpensively and on a

large scale. While such data transfers can improve the efficiency and effectiveness of services,

they can also pose great risk if the information is not appropriately protected. One example is the

surreptitious installation of software (“spyware”) by website operators to collect personally

identifiable information (PII) and share that information with third parties, usually without the

knowledge or consent of the people concerned. Another example is identity theft, which is a form

of fraud in which the personal identifying information of an individual, such as a Social Security

number, name, or date of birth, is co-opted by another person to facilitate committing a criminal

or fraudulent act by impersonating the victim.

Congressional Research Service

9

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Spyware25

Spyware is another focus of congressional concern. There is no firm definition of spyware, but

the most common example is software products that include a method by which information is

collected about the use of the computer on which the software is installed, and the user. When the

computer is connected to the Internet, the software periodically relays the information back to the

software manufacturer or a marketing company. Some spyware traces a user’s Web activity and

causes advertisements to suddenly appear on the user’s monitor—called “pop-up” ads—in

response. Typically, users have no knowledge that the software they obtained included spyware

and that it is now resident on their computers. A central point of the debate is whether new laws

are needed, or if industry self-regulation, coupled with enforcement actions under existing laws

such as the Federal Trade Commission Act, is sufficient. Most recently, the 109th Congress passed

the Undertaking Spam, Spyware, And Fraud Enforcement With Enforcers beyond Borders Act of

2005 (US SAFE WEB ) (P.L. 109-455). The bill allows the FTC and parallel foreign law

enforcement agencies to share information while investigating allegations of “unfair and

deceptive practices” that involve foreign commerce.

Identity Theft and “Phishing”26

Identity theft is a form of fraud in which the personal identifying information of an individual,

such as a Social Security number, name, or date of birth, is co-opted by another person to

facilitate committing a criminal or fraudulent act by impersonating the victim. Identity theft, also

sometimes referred to as identity fraud, does not usually occur as a stand-alone crime. Instead,

identity theft is often committed as part of some other fraud or white-collar crime, such as

illegally obtaining credit, taking over existing financial accounts, or establishing cellular phone

service in the victim’s name. An identity thief could also take other actions on behalf of the

victim, such as establishing residency/citizenship, securing employment, obtaining government

benefits, and committing other crimes in the victim’s name. In addition, identity theft can play a

facilitating role in potentially more violent crimes such as drug trafficking, people smuggling, and

international terrorism.27

While identity theft is not solely an Internet issue, a number of high profile data breaches

involving the personally identifiable information (PII) of citizens and consumers has drawn

significant attention to the issue. Among the most recent incidents was the theft of a laptop

containing the names, dates of birth, and other information of more than 26 million veterans.

Although the laptop was eventually recovered and it is believed that the data was not accessed,

the incident highlighted the ease with which the PII of large numbers of people could be taken at

one time.

Another way identity theft can happen is through “phishing.” Phishing refers to a practice where

someone misrepresents their identity or authority in order to induce another person to provide PII

over the Internet. Some common phishing scams involve e-mails that purport to be from a

financial institution, ISP, or other trusted company claiming that a person’s record has been lost.

25

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division.

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division.

27

General Accounting Office, Identity Fraud: Prevalence and Links to Alien Illegal Activities, GAO-02-830T, 25 June

2002, p. 10.

26

Congressional Research Service

10

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

The e-mail directs the person to a website that mimics the legitimate business’ website and asks

the person to enter a credit card number and other PII so the record can be restored. In fact, the email or website is controlled by a third party who is attempting to extract information that will be

used in identity theft or other crimes. The FTC issued a consumer alert on phishing in June

2004.28

Several laws restrict the disclosure of consumer information and require companies to ensure the

security and integrity of the data in certain contexts—Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission

Act, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), and Title V of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act.

Congress also has passed several laws specifically related to identity theft: the 1998 Identity Theft

and Assumption Deterrence Act; the 2003 Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions (FACT) Act; and

the 2004 Identity Theft Penalty Enhancement Act. Those laws are summarized in CRS Report

RL31919, Federal Laws Related to Identity Theft, by (name redacted). For information on state laws

and pending federal legislation, see CRS Report RL34028, Identity Theft Laws: State Penalties

and Remedies and Pending Federal Bills, by (name redacted).

“Spam”: Unsolicited Commercial Electronic Mail29

One aspect of increased use of the Internet for electronic mail (e-mail) has been the advent of

unsolicited advertising, also called “unsolicited commercial e-mail (UCE),” “unsolicited bulk email,” “junk e-mail, “or “spam.” Complaints focus on the fact that some spam contains or has

links to pornography, that much of it is fraudulent, that it is a nuisance, and the volume is

increasing. Although consumers are most familiar with spam on their personal computers, it also

is becoming an issue in text messaging on wireless telephones and personal digital assistants

(PDAs).

In 2003, Congress passed a federal anti-spam law, the CAN-SPAM Act (P.L. 108-187), which

became effective on January 1, 2004. The act preempts state laws that specifically address spam

but not state laws that are not specific to e-mail, such as trespass, contract, or tort law, or other

state laws to the extent they relate to fraud or computer crime. It does not ban unsolicited

commercial e-mail. Rather, it allows marketers to send commercial e-mail as long as it conforms

with the law, such as including a legitimate opportunity for consumers to “opt-out” of receiving

future commercial e-mails from that sender. It does not require a centralized “do not e-mail”

registry to be created by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), similar to the National Do Not

Call registry for telemarketing. The law requires only that the FTC develop a plan and timetable

for establishing a “Do Not E-mail” registry and to inform Congress of any concerns it has with

regard to establishing it. The FTC reported to Congress in June 2004 that without a technical

system to authenticate the origin of e-mail messages, a registry would not reduce the amount of

spam, and, in fact, might increase it. Authentication is a technical approach that could be used to

control spam that is under study by a number of groups, including ISPs, who are attempting to

develop a single authentication standard for the industry. Additionally, the CAN-SPAM Act

28

FTC. “How Not to Get Hooked by a ‘Phishing’ Scam.” June 2004. See http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/conline/pubs/alerts/

phishingalrt.pdf.

29

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report RL31953,

“Spam”:

An Overview of Issues Concerning Commercial Electronic Mail, by (name redacted), which is updated more

frequently than this report.

Congressional Research Service

11

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

included a provision requiring the FCC to establish regulations to protect wireless consumers

from spam. 30

Many argue that technical approaches, such as authentication, and consumer education, are

needed to solve the spam problem—that legislation alone is insufficient. Nonetheless, there is

considerable interest in assessing how effective the CAN-SPAM Act is in reducing spam. The

effectiveness of the law may be difficult to determine, however, if for no other reason than there

are various definitions of spam. Proponents of the law argue that consumers are most irritated by

fraudulent e-mail, and that the law should reduce the volume of such e-mail because of the civil

and criminal penalties included therein. Skeptics counter that consumers object to unsolicited

commercial e-mail, and since the bill legitimizes commercial e-mail (as long as it conforms with

the law’s provisions), consumers actually may receive more, not fewer, unsolicited commercial email messages. Thus, whether “spam” is reduced depends in part on how it is defined.

In December 2005, the FTC submitted a report to Congress, as required under the CAN-SPAM

Act, on the act’s effectiveness and enforcement, and whether any changes are needed. 31 Based on

information from ISPs, the general public, e-marketers, law enforcers, and technologists, the

report concluded that the act has been effective in two areas: legitimate online marketers have

adopted the “best practices” mandated by the act, and the act provides an additional tool for law

enforcement officials and ISPs to bring suits against spammers. However, it also concluded that

some aspects of the spam problem have not changed, such as its international dimension. It also

reported on a number of “troubling” changes in the e-mail landscape, such as the inclusion of

malicious content (“malware”) in spam messages. The report outlined three steps to further

improve the effectiveness of the act: passage of legislation to improve the FTC’s ability to trace

spammers and sellers who operate outside U.S. borders; continued consumer education; and

continued improvement in anti-spam technologies, especially domain-level authentication.

Most recently, the 109th Congress passed the Undertaking Spam, Spyware, And Fraud

Enforcement With Enforcers beyond Borders Act of 2005 (US SAFE WEB ) (P.L. 109-455). The

bill allows the FTC and parallel foreign law enforcement agencies to share information while

investigating allegations of “unfair and deceptive practices” that involve foreign commerce, but

raised some privacy concerns because the FTC would not be required to make public any of the

information it obtained through foreign sources.

Protecting Children from Unsuitable Material32

Preventing children from encountering unsuitable material as they use the Web has been a major

congressional concern for many years.33 In response to this concern, Congress has passed such

laws as the 1996 Communications Decency Act (CDA), the 1998 Child Online Protection Act

30

The FCC issued those rules in August 2004. See also CRS Report RL31636, Wireless Privacy and Spam: Issues for

Congress, by (name redacted), for more on wireless privacy and wireless spam.

31

FTC. “Effectiveness and Enforcement of the CAN-SPAM Act: A Report to Congress.” December 2005. See

http://www.ftc.gov/reports/canspam05/051220canspamrpt.pdf.

32

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division.

33

Several laws have been passed related to this issue: Communications Decency Act (CDA) (1996), Child Online

Protection Act (COPA) (1998), Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) (2000), “Dot Kids” Act (2002), Amber Alert

Act (2003), and the Adam Walsh Act (2006).

Congressional Research Service

12

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

(COPA), and the 2000 Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA), all of which dealt in some way

with the content found on the Internet. More recently, however, additional attention has been

given to protecting children from exploitation and predators on the Internet. For example, in the

last few years, social networking sites, such as MySpace, have become popular with teenagers

and young adults. Unfortunately, there have been a number of incidents recently in which

children were abducted and/or lured to meet adults over these services. Because of these

incidents, Congress began exploring ways to limit children’s access to these sites, or at least to

limit the ability of adults to contact children. During the 109th Congress, H.R. 5319, the Deleting

Online Predators Act of 2006 (DOPA), would have amended the Communications Act of 1934 to

prohibit schools and libraries receiving “E-Rate” funding from providing access to these types of

websites to minors. The proposal was controversial because the definition of social networking

sites could potentially limit access to a wide range of websites, including many with harmless or

educational material. Although this bill did not pass, this issue is likely to receive continued

attention in the 110th Congress.

“Data retention” is another topic that is likely to receive continued attention from policymakers in

the 110th Congress. Data retention is the practice of ISPs maintaining electronic records of

subscriber activity, regardless of whether those records have been identified as being needed for

an ongoing investigation. At this time, ISPs typically discard records that log subscriber activity

when those records are no longer required for business purposes (e.g., network monitoring,

billing disputes). However, law enforcement agencies have expressed that they would like data to

be retained for longer periods—in general, the time periods suggested have ranged from one to

two years—to ensure they can successfully prosecute online child predators and individuals

producing and downloading child pornography. Proposals that have been discussed range from

simply maintaining records of what websites subscribers visit to requiring the storage of the

contents of e-mail messages and individual web pages visited. ISPs have expressed a number of

concerns, including the cost of retaining the data, web content being included in data retention

legislation, and the privacy and security risks of having such a massive data warehouse available.

Opponents of such legislation note that current law already allows law enforcement agencies to

mandate data retention for 90-days;34 further, privacy advocates are concerned that police would

potentially be able to obtain records of e-mail chatter, Web browsing, or chat room activity that

normally are discarded.

Internet Domain Names35

The 110th Congress will continue to monitor issues related to the Internet domain name system

(DNS). Internet domain names were created to provide users with a simple location name for

computers on the Internet, rather than using the more complex, unique Internet Protocol (IP)

number that designates their specific location. As the Internet has grown, the method for

allocating and designating domain names has become increasingly controversial.

34

Under 18 USC §2703(f), any governmental entity can require any service provider (telephone company, ISP, cable

company, university) to immediately preserve any records in its possession for up to 90 days, renewable indefinitely.

35

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report 97-868, Internet Domain

Names: Background and Policy Issues, by (name redacted), which is updated more frequently than this report.

Congressional Research Service

13

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Background

The Internet originated with research funding provided by the Department of Defense Advanced

Research Projects Agency (DARPA) to establish a military network. As its use expanded, a

civilian segment evolved with support from the National Science Foundation (NSF) and other

science agencies. No formal statutory authorities or international agreements govern the

management and operation of the Internet and the DNS. Prior to 1993, NSF was responsible for

registration of nonmilitary generic Top Level Domains (gTLDs) such as .com, .org, and .net. In

1993, the NSF entered into a five-year cooperative agreement with Network Solutions, Inc. (NSI)

to operate Internet domain name registration services. With the cooperative agreement between

NSI and NSF due to expire in 1998, the Clinton Administration, through the Department of

Commerce (DOC), began exploring ways to transfer administration of the DNS to the private

sector.

In the wake of much discussion among Internet stakeholders, and after extensive public comment

on a previous proposal, the DOC, on June 5, 1998, issued a final statement of policy,

Management of Internet Names and Addresses (also known as the “White Paper”). The White

Paper stated that the U.S. government was prepared to recognize and enter into agreement with “a

new not-for-profit corporation formed by private sector Internet stakeholders to administer policy

for the Internet name and address system.” On October 2, 1998, the DOC accepted a proposal for

an Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN). On November 25, 1998,

DOC and ICANN signed an official Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), whereby DOC and

ICANN agreed to jointly design, develop, and test the mechanisms, methods, and procedures

necessary to transition management responsibility for DNS functions to a private-sector not-forprofit entity.

The White Paper also signaled DOC’s intention to ramp down the government’s Cooperative

Agreement with NSI, with the objective of introducing competition into the domain name space

while maintaining stability and ensuring an orderly transition. During this transition period,

government obligations will be terminated as DNS responsibilities are transferred to ICANN.

Specifically, NSI committed to a timetable for development of a Shared Registration System that

permits multiple registrars to provide registration services within the .com, .net, and .org gTLDs.

NSI (now VersiSign) will continue to administer the root server system until receiving further

instruction from the government.

Significant disagreements between NSI on the one hand, and ICANN and DOC on the other,

arose over how a successful and equitable transition would be made from NSI’s previous status as

exclusive registrar of .com, .org, and .net domain names, to a system that allows multiple and

competing registrars. On November 10, 1999, ICANN, NSI, and DOC formally signed an

agreement which provided that NSI (now VeriSign) was required to sell its registrar operation by

May 10, 2001 in order to retain control of the dot-com registry until 2007. In April 2001, arguing

that the registrar business is now highly competitive, VeriSign reached a new agreement with

ICANN whereby its registry and registrar businesses would not have to be separated. With DOC

approval, ICANN and VeriSign signed the formal agreement on May 25, 2001. On September 17,

2003, ICANN and the Department of Commerce agreed to extend their MOU until September 30,

2006. The MOU specified transition tasks which ICANN has agreed to address, including

implementing an objective process for selecting new Top Level Domains; implementing an

effective strategy for multi-lingual communications and international outreach; and developing a

contingency plan, consistent with the international nature of the Internet, to ensure continuity of

operations in the event of a severe disruption of operations.

Congressional Research Service

14

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

On June 30, 2005, Michael Gallagher, Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and

Information and Administrator of the National Telecommunications and Information

Administration (NTIA), stated the U.S. Government’s principles on the Internet’s domain name

system. Specifically, NTIA states that the U.S. Government “intends to preserve the security and

stability” of the DNS, and that “the United States is committed to taking no action that would

have the potential to adversely impact the effective and efficient operation of the DNS and will

therefore maintain its historic role in authorizing changes or modifications to the authoritative

root zone file.”36 The NTIA statement also says that governments have legitimate interests in the

management of their country code top level domains, that ICANN is the appropriate technical

manager of the DNS, and that dialogue related to Internet governance should continue in relevant

multiple fora. On May 23, 2006, NTIA announced an inquiry and public meeting seeking

comment on the progress of the transition of the technical coordination and management of the

DNS to the private sector. The public meeting was held on July 26, 2006.

On September 29, 2006, DOC announced a new Joint Project Agreement with ICANN which

continues the transition to the private sector of the coordination of technical functions relating to

management of the DNS. The Joint Project Agreement extends through September 30, 2009, and

focuses on institutionalizing transparency and accountability mechanisms within ICANN.

Issues

Congressional Committees (primarily the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and

Transportation and the House Committee on Energy and Commerce) maintain oversight on how

the Department of Commerce manages and oversees ICANN’s activities and policies. Some

issues of current concern are discussed below.

Governance

The United Nations (UN), at the December 2003 World Summit on the Information Society

(WSIS), debated and agreed to study the issue of how to achieve greater international

involvement in the governance of the Internet and the domain name system in particular. The

study was conducted by the UN’s Working Group on Internet Governance (WGIG). On July 14,

2005, the WGIG released its report, stating that no single government should have a preeminent

role in relation to international Internet governance, calling for further internationalization of

Internet governance, and proposing the creation of a new global forum for Internet stakeholders.

Four possible models were put forth, including two involving the creation of new Internet

governance bodies linked to the UN. Under three of the four models, ICANN would either be

supplanted or made accountable to a higher intergovernmental body. The report’s conclusions

were scheduled to be considered during the second phase of the WSIS to be held in Tunis in

November 2005. U.S. officials stated their opposition to transferring control and administration of

the domain name system from ICANN to any international body. Similarly, the 109th Congress

expressed its support for maintaining U.S. control over ICANN. On November 16, 2005, the

House unanimously passed H.Con.Res. 268, which expresses the sense of the Congress that the

current system for management of the domain name system works, and that “the authoritative

36

Gallagher, Michael, Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications, Remarks to the Wireless

Communications Association, June 30, 2005. Available at http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/domainname/

USDNSprinciples_06302005.pdf.

Congressional Research Service

15

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

root zone server should remain physically located in the United States and the Secretary of

Commerce should maintain oversight of ICANN so that ICANN can continue to manage the dayto-day operation of the Internet’s domain name and addressing system well, remain responsive to

all Internet stakeholders worldwide, and otherwise fulfill its core technical mission.” A similar

resolution, S.Res. 323, was passed by the Senate on November 18, 2005 and calls on the

President to “continue to oppose any effort to transfer control of the Internet to the United

Nations or any other international entity.”

The European Union (EU) initially supported the U.S. position. However, during September 2005

preparatory meetings, the EU seemingly shifted its support towards an approach which favored an

enhanced international role in governing the Internet. Conflict at the WSIS Tunis Summit over

control of the domain name system was averted by the announcement, on November 15, 2005, of

an Internet governance agreement between the U.S., the EU, and over 100 other nations. Under

this agreement, ICANN and the U.S. will remain in control of the domain name system. A new

international group under the auspices of the UN will be formed—the Internet Governance

Forum—which will provide an ongoing forum for all stakeholders (both governments and

nongovernmental groups) to discuss and debate Internet policy issues. The Internet Governance

Forum is slated to run for five years and will not have binding authority. The group held its first

meeting on October 30-November 2, 2006 in Athens, Greece. The issue of ICANN and

international DNS governance was not formally addressed by the conference.

ICANN-Verisign Agreement and the .com registry

As part of a legal settlement of a long-running dispute between ICANN and Verisign, on February

28, 2006, the ICANN Board of Directors approved (by a vote of 9-5) a new .com registry

agreement with Verisign. Under this settlement, Verisign will run the .com registry until 2012

(with a presumption that the agreement will be renewed beyond that date), and will be able to

raise domain registration fees by 7% in four of the next six years. These registration fees refer to

the current $6 fee that a registrar (such as GoDaddy or Register.com) pays the .com registry

operator (Verisign) for each .com domain name registration purchased by the consumer. Under

the agreement, Verisign will pay ICANN a one-time sum of $625,000 to implement the

agreement, as well as a yearly registry fee, starting at $6 million per year, and going up over the

next two years to approximately $12 million.

Critics of the ICANN-Verisign settlement assert that the agreement is anticompetitive, giving

Verisign a virtually permanent monopoly over the lucrative .com registry, while also enabling

Verisign to raise registration fees without justification. Defenders of the settlement argue that the

agreement is necessary to ensure the stability and security of the Internet by ensuring the financial

stability of ICANN, and by allowing Verisign the flexibility to raise revenue for upgrading its

infrastructure. On June 7, 2006, the House Small Business Committee held a hearing on the

ICANN-Verisign .com agreement entitled, “Contracting the Internet: Does ICANN create a

barrier to small business?”

The ICANN-Verisign .com agreement was approved by NTIA/DOC on November 30, 2006. As a

condition of its approval, NTIA retains oversight over any changes to the pricing provisions of, or

renewals of, the new .com registry agreement. Approval of any renewal will occur if NTIA

concludes that the approval will serve the public interest in the continued security and stability of

the DNS, and in the operation of the .com registry at reasonable prices, terms and conditions.

Congressional Research Service

16

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Protecting Children on the Internet

In the 107th Congress, legislation sought to create a “kids-friendly top level domain name” that

would contain only age-appropriate content. The Dot Kids Implementation and Efficiency Act of

2002 was signed into law on December 4, 2002 (P.L. 107-317), and authorizes the National

Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) to require the .us registry operator

(currently NeuStar) to establish, operate, and maintain a second level domain within the .us TLD

that is restricted to material suitable for minors.

In the 108th Congress, P.L. 108-21/S. 151 (PROTECT Act) contains a provision (Section 108:

Misleading Domain Names on the Internet) which makes it a punishable crime to knowingly use

a misleading domain name with the intent to deceive a person into viewing obscenity on the

Internet. Increased penalties are provided for deceiving minors into viewing harmful material. In

the 109th Congress, the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 (P.L. 109-248),

signed into law on July 27, 2006, increases the maximum sentence from four years to ten years

for deceiving minors into viewing harmful material.

Meanwhile, on June 1, 2005, ICANN announced that it had entered into commercial and

technical negotiations with a registry company (ICM Registry) to operate a new “.xxx” domain,

which would be designated for use by adult websites. Registration by adult websites into the .xxx

domain would be purely voluntary, and those sites would not be required to give up their existing

sites. Announcement of a .xxx domain has proven controversial. With the ICANN Board

scheduled to consider final approval of the .xxx domain on August 16, 2005, the Department of

Commerce sent a letter to ICANN requesting that adequate additional time be provided to allow

ICANN to address the objections of individuals expressing concerns about the impact of

pornography on families and children and opposing the creation of a new top level domain

devoted to adult content. ICANN’s Government Advisory Committee (GAC) also requested more

time before the final decision. At the March 2006 Board meeting in New Zealand, the ICANN

Board authorized ICANN staff to continue negotiations with ICM Registry to address concerns

raised by the DOC and the GAC. However, on May 10, 2006, the Board voted voted 9-5 against

accepting the proposed agreement, but did not rule out accepting a revised agreement.

Subsequently, on January 5, 2007, ICANN published for public comment a proposed revised

agreement with ICM Registry to establish a .xxx domain. The revised agreement would include

additional safeguards intended to protect children online. 37

Meanwhile in the 109th Congress, on March 16, 2006, Senator Baucus introduced the Cyber

Safety for Kids Act of 2006 (S. 2426), which would require NTIA to compel ICANN to establish

a new top level domain name—such as .xxx—exclusively for material harmful to minors.

Websites with material harmful to minors would be required to switch to the new domain. Those

that do not would face civil penalties from NTIA. 38 S. 2426 was ultimately not enacted by the

109th Congress.

37

For more information, see: http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-05jan07.htm

See CRS Report RL33224, Constitutionality of Requiring Sexually Explicit Material on the Internet to Be

Under a Separate Domain Name, by (name redacted).

38

Congressional Research Service

17

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Trademark Disputes

The increase in conflicts over property rights to certain trademarked names has resulted in a

number of lawsuits. The White Paper called upon the World Intellectual Property Organization

(WIPO) to develop a set of recommendations for trademark/domain name dispute resolutions,

and to submit those recommendations to ICANN. At ICANN’s August 1999 meeting in Santiago,

the board of directors adopted a dispute resolution policy to be applied uniformly by all ICANNaccredited registrars. Under this policy, registrars receiving complaints will take no action until

receiving instructions from the domain-name holder or an order of a court or arbitrator. An

exception is made for “abusive registrations” (i.e., cybersquatting and cyberpiracy), whereby a

special administrative procedure (conducted largely online by a neutral panel, lasting 45 days or

less, and costing about $1000) will resolve the dispute. Implementation of ICANN’s Domain

Name Dispute Resolution Policy commenced on December 9, 1999. Meanwhile, the 106th

Congress passed the Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (incorporated into P.L. 106113, the FY2000 Consolidated Appropriations Act). The act gives courts the authority to order the

forfeiture, cancellation, and/or transfer of domain names registered in “bad faith” that are

identical or similar to trademarks, and provides for statutory civil damages of at least $1,000, but

not more than $100,000, per domain name identifier.

Privacy

Any person or entity who registers a domain name is required to provide contact information

(phone number, address, email) which is entered into a public online database (the “WHOIS”

database). The scope and accessibility of WHOIS database information has been an issue of

contention. Privacy advocates have argued that access to such information should be limited,

while many businesses, intellectual property interests, law enforcement agencies, and the U.S.

Government have argued that complete and accurate WHOIS information should continue to be

publicly accessible. Over the past several years, ICANN has debated this issue through its

Generic Names Supporting Organization (GNSO). The GNSO—composed of stakeholder

constituencies—is developing policy recommendations on what data should be publicly available

through the WHOIS database.

On April 12, 2006, the GNSO approved an official “working definition” for the purpose of the

public display of WHOIS information. The GNSO supported a narrow technical definition

favored by privacy advocates, registries, registrars, and non-commercial user constituencies,

rather then a more expansive definition favored by intellectual property interests, business

constituencies, Internet service providers, law enforcement agencies, and the Department of

Commerce (through its participation in ICANN’s Governmental Advisory Committee). At

ICANN’s June 2006 meeting, opponents of limiting access to WHOIS data continued urging

ICANN to reconsider the working definition. The GNSO will next decide what data should be

available for public access in the context of the working definition.39 On July 18, 2006, the House

Committee on Financial Services, Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Consumer Credit

held a hearing on ICANN and the WHOIS database.

Meanwhile, over the past several years, with the WHOIS database continuing to be publically

accessible, registrants who wish to maintain their privacy have been able to register anonymously

using a proxy service offered by some registrars. In February 2005, the National

39

See ICANN “Whois Services” page, available at http://www.icann.org/topics/whois-services/

Congressional Research Service

18

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA)—which has authority over the .us

domain name—notified Neustar (the company that administers .us) that proxy or private domain

registrations will no longer be allowed for .us domain name registrations, and that registrars must

provide correct WHOIS information for all existing customers by January 26, 2006. According to

NTIA, this action will provide an assurance of accuracy to the American public and to law

enforcement officials. The NTIA policy is opposed by privacy groups and registrars (such as Go

Daddy) who argue that the privacy, anonymity, and safety of people registering .us domain names

will be needlessly compromised.

In a related development, during the 108th Congress, the Fraudulent Online Identity Sanctions Act

was incorporated as Title II of H.R. 3632, the Intellectual Property Protection and Courts

Amendments Act of 2004, signed by the President on December 23, 2004 (P.L. 108-482). The act

increases criminal penalties for those who submit false contact information when registering a

domain name that is subsequently used to commit a crime or engage in copyright or trademark

infringement.

Government Information Technology Management40

The evolving role of the Internet in the political economy of the United States continues to attract

increased congressional attention to government information technology management issues.

Interest has been further heightened by national information infrastructure development efforts, egovernment projects, and homeland security initiatives. Although wide-ranging, some of the most

significant information technology management challenges facing the federal government include

FCC regulation of converging technologies, funding for information technology research and

development, ongoing development and oversight of electronic government (e-government)

initiatives, and the growing use of open source software by federal agencies.

The Federal Communications Commission41

One of the most significant issues facing the FCC is the evolution of the communications industry

towards an all-digital, broadband world that has blurred the distinctions between services, also

called “convergence.” The FCC has restructured over the past few years to better reflect the

realities of convergence, but the agency is still required to adhere to the statutory requirements of

its governing legislation, the Communications Act of 1934. Thus, while convergence has made

distinguishing among types of data increasingly difficult, the FCC must continue to differentiate

among services based on the distinctions drawn in the 1934 Act. Unfortunately, when all data

looks the same and functionally similar services are provided by companies governed by different

titles of the 1934 Act, questions of fairness and competitive advantage may arise. As newer

technologies and services are developed and deployed, applying legacy regulations to them may

begin to appear more strained.

40

See also CRS Report RL30661, Government Information Technology Management: Past and Future Issues (The

Clinger-Cohen Act), by (name redacted).

41

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. For more information, see CRS Report

RL32589, The Federal Communications Commission: Current Structure and Its Role in the Changing

Telecommunications Landscape, by (name redacted); and CRS Report RL33542,

Broadband Internet

Regulation and Access: Background and Issues, by (name redacted) and (name redacted), both of which are

updated more frequently than this report.

Congressional Research Service

19

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

The FCC has continued to address a number of issues directly related to convergence: the

regulatory classification of services via the Internet protocol (e.g., voice over Internet Protocol

[VoIP]) and law enforcement’s ability to conduct wiretaps effectively (i.e., using the

Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act [CALEA]). During the 110th Congress, as

there was during the 109th Congress, there may be legislation to enact a national franchising

system for video service providers. If so, this will likely require additional attention from the FCC

as well.

The FCC will also remain focused on broadband deployment. The agency will continue to

monitor its policies to encourage new providers to roll out new services (e.g., power companies

will be deploying broadband over powerlines [BPL]) as well as continue to promote deployment

to underserved areas and populations, i.e., rural and low-income communities, through universal

service and other programs (e.g., the E-Rate).

One of the difficulties in addressing the issues facing the FCC is that so many of them now

intersect. So many of the broadband issues are inter-related that it is often difficult to sort out

where one issue ends and another begins. For example, VoIP, CALEA, and BPL are all tied to the

concept of broadband convergence and reliance on the Internet for information and it becomes

difficult, if not impossible, to discuss one without touching on the others. Effectively addressing

these types of issues may well be the greatest challenge facing both the FCC and Congress in the

near future.

Information Technology R&D42

At the federal level, almost all of the funding for information science and technology and Internet

development is part of a single government-wide initiative, the Networking and Information

Technology Research and Development program (NITRD). This program was previously (19972000) called the Computing, Information, and Communications program (CIC) and, prior to that

(1992-1997), the High Performance Computing and Communications program (HPCC). The

NITRD is an interagency effort to coordinate key advances in information technology (IT)

research and leverage funding into broader advances in computing and networking technologies.

Under the NITRD, participating agencies receive support for high-performance computing

science and technology, information technology software and hardware, networks and Internetdriven applications, and education and training for personnel. The FY2007 budget calls for

$3.074 billion for the NITRD Program, an increase of $0.21 billion over the FY2006 budget

estimate of $2.855 billion.

Research emphases are focused on eight program component areas (also called PCAs): High-End

Computing (HEC) Infrastructure and Applications, HEC Research and Development, Cyber

Security and Information Assurance, Human Computer Interaction and Information Management,

Large Scale Networking, Software Design and Productivity, High Confidence Software and

Systems, and Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications of IT and IT Workforce

Development. Key issues facing congressional policymakers include whether NITRD is

accomplishing its goals and objectives to enhance U.S. information technology research and

42

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report RL33586,

The

Federal Networking and Information Technology Research and Development Program: Funding Issues and Activities,

by (name redacted), which is updated more frequently than this report.

Congressional Research Service

20

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

development, whether the funding level is appropriate or should be changed to reflect changing

U.S. priorities, and defining the private sector’s role in this initiative.

Electronic Government (E-Government)43

Electronic government (e-government) is an evolving concept, meaning different things to

different people. However, it has significant relevance to four important areas of governance: (1)

delivery of services (government-to-citizen, or G2C); (2) providing information (also G2C); (3)

facilitating the procurement of goods and services (government-to-business, or G2B, and

business-to-government, or B2G); and (4) facilitating efficient exchanges within and between

agencies (government-to-government, or G2G). For policymakers concerned about egovernment, a central area of concern is developing a comprehensive but flexible strategy to

coordinate the disparate e-government initiatives across the federal government.

The movement to put government online raises as many issues as it provides new opportunities.

Some of these issues include, but are not limited to: security, privacy, management of

governmental technology resources, accessibility of government services (including “digital

divide” concerns as a result of a lack of skills or access to computers, discussed earlier), and

preservation of public information (maintaining comparable freedom of information procedures

for digital documents as exist for paper documents). Although these issues are neither new nor

unique to e-government, they do present the challenge of performing governance functions online

without sacrificing the accountability of, or public access to, government that citizens have grown

to expect. Some industry groups have also raised concerns about the U.S. government becoming a

publicly funded market competitor through the provision of fee-for-services such as the U.S.

Postal Service’s now-discontinued eBillPay service, which allowed consumers to schedule and

make payments to creditors online http://www.usps.com/paymentservices/ops_discontinued.htm.

E-government initiatives vary significantly in their breadth and depth from state to state and

agency to agency. Perhaps one of the most well-known federal examples is the FirstGov website

http://www.firstgov.gov, which first went online on September 22, 2000. FirstGov is a Web portal

designed to serve as a single locus point for finding federal government information on the

Internet. The FirstGov site also provides access to a variety of state and local government

resources. Another example is the Grants.gov initiative http://www.grants.gov/, which is designed

to provide a single portal for all available federal grants, enabling users to search, download

applications, and apply for grants online. At the Department of Treasury, the Internal Revenue

Service (IRS) administers the Free File initiative http://www.irs.gov/efile/article/

0,,id=118986,00.html, which has partnered with industry to provide free online tax preparation

and electronic filing services for eligible taxpayers.

Pursuant to the July 18, 2001, OMB Memorandum M-01-28, an E-Government Task Force was

established to create a strategy for achieving the Bush Administration’s e-government goals. 44 In

doing so, the Task Force identified 23 interagency initiatives designed to better integrate agency

operations and information technology investments. These initiatives, sometimes referred to as

the Quicksilver projects, are grouped into four categories; government-to-citizen, government-to43

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report RL31057, A Primer on EGovernment: Sectors, Stages, Opportunities, and Challenges of Online Governance, by (name redacted), which is

updated more frequently than this report.

44

See http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/egovstrategy.pdf.

Congressional Research Service

21

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

government, government-to-business, and internal effectiveness and efficiency. Examples of

these initiatives include an e-authentication project led by the General Services Administration

(GSA) to increase the use of digital signatures, the eligibility assistance online project (also

referred to as GovBenefits.gov) led by the Department of Labor to create a common access point

for information regarding government benefits available to citizens, and the Small Business

Administration’s One-Stop Business Compliance project, being designed to help businesses

navigate legal and regulatory requirements. A 24th initiative, a government wide payroll process

project, was subsequently added by the President’s Management Council. In 2002 the e-Clearance

initiative, originally included as part of the Enterprise Human Resources Integration project, was

established as a separate project, for a total of 25 initiatives. Since that time, the Bush

Administration has reclassified the e-Authentication initiative as “a separate initiative that

provides secure and robust authentication services to the 24 [i]nitiatives,” bringing the official

tally again to 24 initiatives.45

As the initial round of e-government projects has matured, OMB has focused attention on

initiatives that consolidate information technology systems in nine functional areas, or Lines of

Business (LoB). These include financial management, human resource management, grants

management, case management, federal health architecture, information security, budget

formulation and evaluation, geospatial systems, and information technology infrastructure. These

initiatives were chosen, in part, because they represent core business functions common to many

departments and agencies, and/or have the potential to reap significant efficiency and efficacy

gains. These LoB initiatives are anticipated to create $5 billion in savings over 10 years.

On December 17, 2002, President Bush signed the E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-347) into

law. The law contains a variety of provisions related to federal government information

technology management, information security, and the provision of services and information

electronically. One of the most recognized provisions involves the creation of an Office of

Electronic Government within OMB. The Office is headed by an Administrator, who is

responsible for carrying out a variety of information resources management (IRM) functions, as

well as administering the interagency E-Government Fund provided for by the law.

For the 110th Congress, continued oversight of the Quicksilver projects, the implementation of the

E-Government Act, and the development and funding of the second generation Lines of Business

e-government initiatives are the primary oversight issues. Other issues include ongoing efforts to

develop a federal enterprise architecture, which serves as a blueprint of the business functions of

an organization, and the technology used to carry out these functions http://www.whitehouse.gov/

omb/egov/a-1-fea.html; the recruitment and retention of IT managers, at both the chief

information officer (CIO) and project manager levels; and balancing the sometimes competing

demands of e-government and homeland security.

Open Source Software46

The use of open source software by the federal government has been gaining attention as

organizations continue to search for opportunities to enhance their information technology (IT)

operations while containing costs. A growing number of state and local governments have also

45

See http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/egov/c-presidential.html.

By (name redacted), Resources, Science, and Industry Division. See also CRS Report RL31627, Computer

Software and Open Source Issues: A Primer, by (name redacted).

46

Congressional Research Service

22

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

been exploring the official adoption of open source software. Likewise, open source software

may also play a role in the growth of regional health information organizations (RHIOs), as part

of an effort to spread the use of e-health records. For the federal government and Congress, the

debate over the use of open source software intersects several other issues, including, but not

limited to, the development of homeland security and e-government initiatives, improving

government information technology management practices, strengthening computer security, and

protecting intellectual property rights. In the 110th Congress, the debate over open source software

is anticipated to revolve primarily around information security and intellectual property rights,

including the possible development of a legal definition of open source software. However, issues

related to cost and quality are likely to be raised as well.

Open source software refers to a computer program whose source code, or programming

instructions, is made available to the general public to be improved or modified as the user

wishes. Some examples of open source software include the Linux operating system and Apache

Web server software. In contrast, closed source, or proprietary, programs are those whose source

code is not made available and can only be altered by the software manufacturer. In the case of

closed source software, updates to a program are usually distributed in the form of a patch or as a

new version of the program that the user can install but not alter. Some examples of closed source

software include Microsoft Word and Corel WordPerfect. The majority of software products most

commonly used, such as operating systems, word processing programs, and databases, are closed

source programs.

For proponents, open source software is often viewed as a means to reduce an organization’s

dependence on the software products of a few companies while possibly improving the security

and stability of one’s computing infrastructure. For critics, open source software is often viewed

as a threat to intellectual property rights with unproven cost and quality benefits. So far there

appear to be no systematic analyses available that have conclusively compared closed source to

open source software on the issue of security. In practice, computer security is highly dependent

on how an application is configured, maintained, and monitored. Similarly, the costs of

implementing an open source solution are dependent upon factors such as the cost of acquiring

the hardware/software, investments in training for IT personnel and end users, maintenance and

support costs, and the resources required to convert data and applications to work in the new

computing environment. Consequently, some computer experts suggest that it is not possible to

conclude that either open source or closed source software is inherently more secure or more cost

efficient.

The official U.S. federal government policy regarding the use of open source software by

government agencies is described in a July 2004 Office of Management and Budget (OMB)

memorandum on software acquisition, M-04-16 Memoranda for Senior Procurement Executives,

Chief Information Officers, Software Acquisition. The memorandum states that the policies

guiding government information technology investment decisions are “technology and vendor

neutral” and that agencies’ technology choices “must be consistent with the agency’s enterprise

architecture and the Federal Enterprise Architecture.”47 Agencies are also instructed to take into

account a number of other merit-based factors, including information security, licensing

47

For more information about enterprise architectures generally, and the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA)

specifically, see CRS Report RL33417, Federal Enterprise Architecture and E-Government: Issues for Information

Technology Management, by (name redacted).

Congressional Research Service

23

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

requirements, and total cost of ownership. Implicit in these requirements is an expectation that

agencies will also make choices based on the quality of the product.

The growing emphasis on improved information security and critical infrastructure protection

overall, will likely be an influential factor in future decisions to implement open source solutions.

The rapidly changing computer environment may also foster the use of a combination of open

source and closed source applications, rather than creating a need to choose one option at the

exclusion of another.

Congressional Research Service

24

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Appendix A. List of Acronyms

Alphabetical Listing

B2B

Business-to-Business

B2G

Business-to-Government

BOC

Bell Operating Company

CIO

Chief Information Officer

DMA

Direct Marketing Association

DNS

Domain Name System

DOC

Department of Commerce

DSL

Digital Subscriber Line

FBI

Federal Bureau of Investigation

FCC

Federal Communications Commission

FTC

Federal Trade Commission

G2B

Government-to-Business

G2C

Government-to-Citizen

G2G

Government-to-Government

GAO

Government Accountability Office (formerly General Accounting Office)

GSA

General Services Administration

gTLD

generic Top Level Domain

ICANN

Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers

ILEC

Incumbent Local Exchange Carrier

IP

Internet Protocol

ISP

Internet Service Provider

IT

Information Technology

LATA

Local Access and Transport Area

LEC

Local Exchange Carrier

MOU

Memorandum of Understanding

NGI

Next Generation Internet

NIST

National Institute for Standards and Technology (part of Department of Commerce)

NSI

Network Solutions, Inc,

NSF

National Science Foundation

NTIA

National Telecommunications and Information Administration (part of Department of Commerce)

OMB

Office of Management and Budget

OPA

Online Privacy Alliance

OSS

Open Source Software

SSN

Social Security Number

TLD

Top Level Domain

Congressional Research Service

25

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

UCE

Unsolicited Commercial E-mail

WIPO

World Intellectual Property Organization

Categorical Listing

U.S. Government Entities

DOC

Department of Commerce

FBI

Federal Bureau of Investigation

FCC

Federal Communications Commission

FTC

Federal Trade Commission

GAO

Government Accountability Office (formerly General Accounting Office)

GSA

General Services Administration

NIST

National Institute of Standards and Technology (part of Department of Commerce)

NSF

National Science Foundation

NTIA

National Telecommunications and Information Administration (part of Department of Commerce)

OMB

Office of Management and Budget

Private Sector Entities

BOC

Bell Operating Company

DMA

Direct Marketing Association

ICANN

Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers

ILEC

Incumbent Local Exchange Carrier

ISP

Internet Service Provider

LEC

Local Exchange Carrier

NSI

Network Solutions, Inc.

General Types of Internet Services

B2B

Business-to-Business

B2G

Business-to-Government

G2B

Government-to-Business

G2C

Government-to-Citizen

G2G

Government-to-Government

Internet and Telecommunications Terminology

CIO

Chief Information Officer

DNS

Domain Name System

DSL

Digital Subscriber Line

gTLD

generic Top Level Domain

IP

Internet Protocol

IT

Information Technology

LATA

Local Access and Transport Area

NGI

Next Generation Internet

OSS

Open Source Software

Congressional Research Service

26

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

TLD

Top Level Domain

UCE

Unsolicited Commercial E-mail

Other

MOU

Memorandum of Understanding

SSN

Social Security Number

WIPO

World Intellectual Property Organization

Congressional Research Service

27

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Appendix B. Legislation Passed by the 105th-109th

Congresses

During the years that this report has been published (since the 105th Congress), various topics

have been covered based on congressional interest and action. Some of those issues continue to

be of interest to Congress and are discussed in this edition of the report. Others, however, appear

to be resolved from a congressional point of view, and therefore are not discussed in the main

text. Nevertheless, it appears useful to retain information about legislation that passed on those

subjects. Following is such a summary of all laws that have been tracked in this report over the

years, by topic. Tables showing which laws were passed in each Congress appear at the end of

this section.

Broadband Internet Access

The Farm Security and Rural Investment Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-171, Section 6103) authorizes

the Secretary of Agriculture to make loans and loan guarantees to eligible entities for facilities

and equipment providing broadband service in rural communities. The National Science

Foundation Authorization Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-368, Section 18(d)) directs the National

Science Foundation to conduct a study of broadband network access for schools and libraries.

The Commercial Spectrum Enhancement Act (Title II of H.R. 5419, P.L. 108-494) seeks to

make more spectrum available for wireless broadband and other services by facilitating the

reallocation of spectrum from government to commercial users.

The Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 (P.L. 109-171), Title III sets a hard deadline for the digital

television transition, thereby reclaiming analog television spectrum to be auctioned for

commercial applications such as wireless broadband.

Computer Security

The Computer Crime Enforcement Act (P.L. 106-572) establishes Department of Justice grants

to state and local authorities to help them investigate and prosecute computer crimes. The law

authorizes the expenditure of $25 million for the grant program through FY2004. The FY2001

Department of Defense Authorization Act (P.L. 106-398) includes language that originated in

S. 1993 to modify the Paperwork Reduction Act and other relevant statutes concerning computer

security of government systems, codifying agency responsibilities regarding computer security.

Internet Privacy (Including Identity Theft)

The Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act (P.L. 105-318) sets penalties for persons

who knowingly, and with the intent to commit unlawful activities, possess, transfer, or use one or

more means of identification not legally issued for use to that person.

Language in the FY2001 Transportation Appropriations Act (P.L. 106-246) and the FY2001

Treasury-General Government Appropriations Act (included as part of the FY2001

Consolidated Appropriations Act, P.L. 106-554) addresses website information collection

practices by departments and agencies. Section 501 of the FY2001 Transportation Appropriations

Act prohibits funds in the FY2001 Treasury-General Government Appropriations Act from being

used by any federal agency to collect, review, or create aggregate lists that include personally

Congressional Research Service

28

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

identifiable information (PII) about an individual’s access to or use of a federal website, or enter

into agreements with third parties to do so, with exceptions. Section 646 of the FY2001 TreasuryGeneral Government Appropriations Act requires Inspectors General of agencies or departments

covered in that act to report to Congress within 60 days of enactment on activities by those

agencies or departments relating to the collection of PII about individuals who access any Internet

site of that department or agency, or entering into agreements with third parties to obtain PII

about use of government or non-government websites.

The Internet False Identification Prevention Act (P.L. 106-578) updates existing law against

selling or distributing false identification documents to include those sold or distributed through

computer files, templates, and disks. It also requires the Attorney General and Secretary of the

Treasury to create a coordinating committee to ensure that the creation and distribution of false

IDs is vigorously investigated and prosecuted.

The USA PATRIOT Act (P.L. 107-56), passed in the wake of the September 11, 2001 terrorist

attacks, inter alia expands law enforcement’s authority to monitor Internet activities. The Cyber

Security Enhancement Act, included as section 225 of the Homeland Security Act (P.L. 107296), amends the USA PATRIOT Act to further loosen restrictions on Internet Service Providers

(ISPs) as to when, and to whom, they can voluntarily release information about subscribers.

Prior to the terrorist attacks, concern had focused on the opposite issue—whether law

enforcement officials might be overstepping their authority when using a software program

named Carnivore (later renamed DCS 1000) to monitor Internet activities. Although the USA

PATRIOT Act expands law enforcement’s authority to monitor Internet activities, Congress also

passed a provision in the 21st Century Department of Justice Authorization Act (P.L. 107-273,

section 305) requiring the Justice Department to notify Congress about its use of Carnivore or

similar systems.

The E-Government Act (P.L. 107-347), inter alia, sets requirements on government agencies as

to how they assure the privacy of personal information in government information systems and

establishes guidelines for privacy policies for federal websites.

The Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Protection Act (P.L. 108-458) was passed largely in

response to recommendations from the 9/11 Commission, which investigated the September 11,

2001 terrorist attacks. Among its many provisions, the act creates a Privacy and Civil Liberties

Oversight Board (Section 1061), composed of five members, two of whom (the chairman and

vice-chairman) must be confirmed by the Senate. The Board’s mandate is to ensure that privacy

and civil liberties are not neglected when implementing terrorism-related laws, regulations, and

policies. The 9/11 Commission had recommended creation of such a Board because of concern

that the USA PATRIOT Act, enacted soon after the attacks, shifts the balance of power to the

government.

Spam: Unsolicited Commercial E-Mail

The CAN-SPAM Act, P.L. 108-187, sets civil or criminal penalties if senders of commercial email do not provide a legitimate opportunity for recipients to “opt-out” of receiving further

commercial e-mail from the sender, if they use deceptive subject headings, if they use fraudulent

information in the header of the message, if they “harvest” e-mail addresses from the Internet or

use “dictionary attacks” to create e-mail addresses, if they access someone else’s computer

without authorization and use it to send multiple commercial e-mail messages, or engage in

Congressional Research Service

29

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

certain other activities connected with sending “spam.” Spam is variously defined by participants

in the debate as unsolicited commercial e-mail, unwanted commercial e-mail, or fraudulent

commercial e-mail. The CAN-SPAM Act preempts state laws that specifically regulate electronic

mail, but not other state laws, such as trespass, contract, or tort law, or other state laws to the

extent they relate to fraud or computer crime. It authorizes, but does not require, the Federal

Trade Commission to establish a centralized “do not e-mail” list similar to the National Do Not

Call list for telemarketing. The FTC has concluded that a do not e-mail list is not feasible at this

time.

The Undertaking Spam, Spyware, And Fraud Enforcement With Enforcers beyond Borders

Act of 2005 (US SAFE WEB), P.L. 109-455 would allow the Federal Trade Commission and

parallel foreign law enforcement agencies to share information while investigating allegations of

“unfair and deceptive practices” that involve foreign commerce.

Internet Domain Names

The Next Generation Internet Research Act (P.L. 105-305) directs the National Academy of

Sciences to conduct a study of the short- and long-term effects on trademark rights of adding new

generation top-level domains and related dispute resolution procedures.

The Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (part of the FY2000 Consolidated

Appropriations Act, P.L. 106-113) gives courts the authority to order the forfeiture, cancellation,

and/or transfer of domain names registered in “bad faith” that are identical or similar to

trademarks. The act provides for statutory civil damages of at least $1,000, but not more than

$100,000 per domain name identifier.

The Dot Kids Implementation and Efficiency Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-317) directs the National

Telecommunications and Information Administration of the Department of Commerce to require

the .us registry operator to establish, operate, and maintain a second level domain that is restricted

to material suitable for minors.

The PROTECT Act (P.L. 108-21) contains a provision (Sec. 108, Misleading Domain Names on

the Internet) that makes it a punishable crime to knowingly use a misleading domain name with

the intent to deceive a person into viewing obscenity on the Internet. Increased penalties are

provided for deceiving minors into viewing harmful material. (CRS Report RS21328, Internet:

Status Report on Legislative Attempts to Protect Children from Unsuitable Material on the Web,

by (name redacted), provides further information on this and other legislative efforts to

protect children from unsuitable material on the Internet.)

The Fraudulent Online Identity Sanctions Act (Title II of the Intellectual Property Protection

and Courts Amendments Act of 2004, P.L. 108-482) increases criminal penalties for those who

submit false contact information when registering a domain name that is subsequently used to

commit a crime or engage in copyright or trademark infringement.

The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 (P.L. 109-248) increases the penalty

from 4 to 10 years’ imprisonment for persons who knowingly use a misleading domain name with

the intent to deceive a minor into viewing harmful material.

Protecting Children from Unsuitable Material and Predators on the Internet

Congressional Research Service

30

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

The Child Online Protection Act, Title XIV of Division C of the FY1999 Omnibus

Appropriations Act, P.L. 105-277), made it a crime to send material over the Web that is “harmful

to minors” to children. Similar language was also included in the Internet Tax Freedom Act (Title

XI of Division C of the same act). Called “CDA II” by some in reference to the Communications

Decency Act that passed Congress in 1996, but was overturned by the Supreme Court, the bill

restricted access to commercial material that is “harmful to minors” distributed on the World

Wide Web to those 17 and older. This act also was challenged in the courts. See CRS Report 98670, Obscenity, Child Pornography, and Indecency: Brief Background and Recent Developments,

by (name redacted), for a summary of court actions.

The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (Title XIII of Division C of the FY1999

Omnibus Appropriations Act, P.L. 105-277), requires verifiable parental consent for the

collection, use, or dissemination of personally identifiable information from children under 13.

The Protection of Children from Sexual Predators Act (P.L. 105-314) is a broad law

addressing concerns about sexual predators. Among its provisions are increased penalties for

anyone who uses a computer to persuade, entice, coerce, or facilitate the transport of a child to

engage in prohibited sexual activity, a requirement that Internet service providers report to law

enforcement if they become aware of child pornography activities, a requirement that federal

prisoners using the Internet be supervised, and a requirement for a study by the National

Academy of Sciences on how to reduce the availability to children of pornography on the

Internet.

The Children’s Internet Protection Act (Title XVII of the FY2001 Labor-HHS Appropriations

Act, included in the FY2001 Consolidated Appropriations Act, P.L. 106-554) requires most

schools and libraries that receive federal funding through Title III of the Elementary and

Secondary Education Act, the Museum and Library Services Act, or “E-rate” subsidies from the

universal service fund, to use technology protection measures (filtering software or other

technologies) to block certain websites when computers are being used by minors, and in some

cases, by adults. When minors are using the computers, the technology protection measure must

block access to visual depictions that are obscene, child pornography, or harmful to minors. When

others are using the computers, the technology must block visual depictions that are obscene or

are child pornography. The technology protection measure may be disabled by authorized persons

to enable access for bona fide research or other lawful purposes.

E-Government

The E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-347) amends Title 44 U.S.C. by adding Chapter 36—

Management and Promotion of Electronic Government Services, and Chapter 37—Information

Technology Management Program, which includes a variety of provisions related to information

technology management and the provision of e-government services. Among its provisions, the

law establishes an Office of Electronic Government in the Office of Management and Budget to

be headed by an Administrator appointed by the President. It also authorizes $345 million through

FY2006 for an E-Government Fund to support initiatives, including interagency and

intergovernmental projects, that involve the “development and implementation of innovative uses

of the Internet or other electronic methods, to conduct activities electronically.” Additionally, the

law includes language that re-authorizes and amends the Government Information Security

Reform Act (GISRA), establishes an information technology worker exchange program between

the federal government and the private sector, promotes the use of Share-In-Savings procurement

contracts, and establishes coordination and oversight policies for the protection of confidential

Congressional Research Service

31

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

information and statistical efficiency (the Confidential Information Protection and Statistical

Efficiency Act of 2002).

Intellectual Property

Congress passed the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (P.L. 105-304) implementing the World

Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) treaties regarding protection of copyright on the

Internet. The law also limits copyright infringement liability for online service providers that

serve only as conduits of information.

Electronic and Digital Signatures

The Government Paperwork Elimination Act (Title XVII of Division C of the Omnibus

Appropriations Act, P.L. 105-277)directs the Office of Management and Budget to develop

procedures for the use and acceptance of “electronic” signatures (of which digital signatures are

one type) by executive branch agencies.

The Millennium Digital Commerce Act (P.L. 106-229) regulates Internet electronic commerce

by permitting and encouraging its continued expansion through the operation of free market

forces, including the legal recognition of electronic signatures and electronic records.

Electronic Commerce

The Internet Tax Nondiscrimination Act (P.L. 107-75) extended the Internet tax moratorium

through November 1, 2003. Facing expiration of that moratorium, Congress passed the Internet

Tax Non-Discrimination Act of 2003 (P.L. 108-435). Among its provisions, the act: 1) extended

the e-commerce tax moratorium for four years, from November 1, 2003 through November 1,

2007; 2) expanded the definition of Internet access to include both providers and buyers of

Internet access; 3) grandfathered through November 1, 2007, Internet access taxes enforced

before October 1, 1998; 4) similarly grandfathered through November 1, 2005 Internet access

taxes enforced before November 1, 2003; and 5) excluded Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP)

and similar voice services.

Table B-1. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 105th Congress

Title

FY1999 Omnibus Consolidated and Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act

Public law number

P.L. 105-277

Internet Tax Freedom Act

Division C, Title XI

Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act

Division C, Title XIII

Child Online Protection Act

Division C, Title XIV

Government Paperwork Elimination Act

Division C, Title XVII

Protection of Children from Sexual Predators Act

P.L. 105-314

Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act

P.L. 105-318

Digital Millennium Copyright Act

P.L. 105-304

Next Generation Internet Research Act

P.L. 105-305

Congressional Research Service

32

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Table B-2. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 106th Congress

Title

Public law number

Millennium Digital Commerce Act

P.L. 106-229

Computer Crime Enforcement Act

P.L. 106-572

FY2001 Transportation Appropriations Act, section 501

P.L. 106-246

FY2001 Treasury-General Government Appropriations Act, section 646 (enacted by

reference in the FY2001 Consolidated Appropriations Act)

P.L. 106-554

Internet False Identification Prevention Act

P.L. 106-578

Children’s Internet Protection Act (Title XVII of the FY2001 Labor-HHS Appropriations Act,

enacted by reference in the FY2001 Consolidated Appropriations Act)

P.L. 106-554

Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (enacted by reference in the FY2000

Consolidated Appropriations Act)

P.L. 106-113

Table B-3. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 107th Congress

Title

Public law number

Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools to Intercept and Obstruct

Terrorism (USA PATRIOT) Act

P.L. 107-56

Internet Tax Nondiscrimination Act

P.L. 107-75

Farm Security and Rural Investment Act (Section 6103)

P.L. 107-171

Cyber Security Enhancement Act (Section 225 of the Homeland Security Act)

P.L. 107-296

21st Century Department of Justice Authorization Act (Section 305)

P.L. 107-297

Dot Kids Implementation and Efficiency Act

P.L. 107-317

E-Government Act

P.L. 107-347

National Science Foundation Authorization Act of 2002 (Section 18d)

P.L. 107-368

Table B-4. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 108th Congress

Title

Public law number

PROTECT Act (Section 108, Misleading Domain Names on the Internet)

P.L. 108-21

CAN-SPAM Act

P.L. 108-187

Internet Tax Non-Discrimination Act of 2003

P.L. 108-435

Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Protection Act (Section 1061)

P.L. 108-458

Fraudulent Online Identity Sanctions Act (Title II of the Intellectual Property Protection and

Courts Amendments Act of 2004)

P.L. 108-482

Commercial Spectrum Enhancement Act (Title II of the ENHANCE 911 Act)

P.L. 108-494

Congressional Research Service

33

Internet: An Overview of Key Technology Policy Issues Affecting Its Use and Growth

Table B-5. Summary of Legislation Passed by the 109th Congress

Title

Public law number

Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 (Title III, Digital Television Transition and Public Safety)

P.L. 109-171

Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006

P.L. 109-248

Undertaking Spam, Spyware, And Fraud Enforcement With Enforcers beyond Borders Act of

2005 (US SAFE WEB)

P.L. 109-455

Author Contact Information

(name redacted)

Specialist in Science and Technology Policy

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....

(name redacted)

Section Research Manager

[redacted]@crs.loc.g

ov, 7-....

(name redacted)

Specialist in Science and Technology Policy

[redacted]@crs.loc.g

ov, 7-....

(name redacted)

Specialist in Internet and Telecommunications

Policy

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....

(name redacted)

Specialist in Telecommunications Policy

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....

(name redacted)

Information Research Specialist

[redacted]@crs.loc.gov, 7-....

Congressional Research Service

34

EveryCRSReport.com

The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the

Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on

issues that may come before Congress.

EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The

reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to

the public.

Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts

who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made

any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.

CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in

the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without

permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a

third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or

otherwise use copyrighted material.

Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public

understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in

connection with CRS' institutional role.

EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim

copyright on any CRS report we have republished.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.