Record and brief — The Morse Arms Manufacturing Company, Appellant, vs. The United States

Supreme Court brief1895

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

.

SUPREME COURT OF THE. UNI

“«

"*

re

©

\

‘OCTOBER TERM

;

ea 2 sf

18

.

«

g

rd

No..

CTURING

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFA

a

~

&

SR Ugh is

v

¥

.

*

y

= 4

“

4

APPELLANT,*:

%

ea

a

f

VS.

«

.

fHE UNITED STATES. ..

4

-

APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS:

2

~

*

FILED OCTOBER

1892,

e

*

4,

‘

?

{

aed me oP Tie

s

>| om

z Pes 34

PP RE re Oe

(15,158.)

>. -~

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED S$

OCTOBER TERM, 1895.

No. 169.

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING COMPANY, _

APPELLANT,

Uv S.

THE UNITED STATES.

Caption .............

Petition...........

Traverse ...........

Findings of fact ....

Conclusion of law. . .

Opinion ............

eS EDGES Serre roe py oe

Application for and allowance of appeal

Clerk’s certificate............. .......

| ?

eee

BESSs

ii

Aa

:

Es

°F

aT ab rt re lens etn tt ee ee ee

|

1 In the Court of Claims.

THE Morse ARMS MANUFACTURING COMPANY

v8. e No. 14340.

THe United STATES. -:

I.—Petition. Filed April 12, 1884.

The claimant isa corporation duly organized under and pursuant

to an act of the legislature of the State of New York passed Febru-

ary 17, 1848, entitled “An act to authorize the formation of corpora-

tions for manufacturing, mining, mechanical, or chemical pur-

poses,” and the acts amendatory thereto, and has its place of busi-

ness in the city, county, and State of New York. |

Letters patent of the United States numbered 15995, for improve-

ments in breech-loading fire-arms, were granted to George W. Morse

on the 28th day of October, 1856, for a term of fourteen years, and

were extended for an additional term of seven years by an act of

Congress entitled “An act for the relief of George W. Morse,” ap-

roved March 11, 1872. Letters patent of the United States num-

ered 20503, for improvements in the alteration of muzzle-loading

into breech-loading fire-arms, were granted to said Morse on

2 , the 8th of June, 1858, for a term of fourteen years, and were

_ extended for a further term of seven years on the 7th day of

June, 1872. Letters patent. of the United States for improvements

in cartridges, numbered 20727, were granted to said Morse on the

28th day of June, 1858, for a term of fourteen years, and were ex-

tended for an additional term of seven years on the 29th day of

June, 1872. :

Before the 10th day of July, 1875, said Morse, for a valuable con-

sideration, assigned and transferred to the claimant all the right, —

title, and interest granted by said several letters patent, and there-

after the claimant was the sole owner of the same until the expira-

tion of their respective terms.

Since July 10, 1875, the defendants, with the consent of the claim-

ant, have used the inventions described and claimed in said letters

patent, numbered respectively 15995 and 20508, in the manufact-

i and alteration of rifles embodying said improvements, as fol-

ows:

Between July 10, 1875, and July 1, 1876, 15,414.

Between July 1,-1876, and July 1, 1877, 7,164. .

Between July 1, 1877, and July 1, 1878, 13,173.

Between July 1, 1878, and July 1, 1879, 9,113, and

Between July 1, 1879, and Nov. 29, 1879; 10,000, amounting in

the aggregate to 54,864 rifles. :

The defendants thereupon became indebted to the claim-

3 ant on an implied promise for the reasonable value of the

use of said improvements, which was the sum of $5 for each ©

rifle, amounting in the aggregate to $274,320.

1169

£ By AR nh eG St ee PL PONY RR RE OER SB EE fier Nk POR IEON Re ea S Oe tae ee Ea Fre ah

E RT ere MERE te © PO ee rt Le Te ee tox aa Aa ey . Wa ae ee * me

7a ye a e fab ge on ts >» Sad ‘ Ps a oye on 4 ~ . Osi any at a

os Fee epee uF es PSR bit > hee eR a ean a 5 = - x" a S 3 ve

bee a eae ns ¥, es 4 ray. Pe, 4 > A, af $e

MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES. 1 ~

eo

oa

oy

~ __ abetted, or given encouragement to rebellion against the said Gov-

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

: — have not paid said sum of $274,320 nor any part

thereof.

Since July 10, 1875, the defendants have, with the claimant’s

consent, used the inventions described and claimed in said letters

patent numbered 20727 in the manufacture of large numbers of

cartridges. The precise numbers so manufactured are not known

to the claimant, but when ascertained will, with the permission of

the court, be duly set forth in an amendment to this petition.

The defendants thereupon became indebted to the claimant on

an implied promise for the reasonable value of the use of said last-

mentioned invention, but have not paid the same nor any part

thereof. |

No assignment or transfer of said claim or of any part thereof

or interest therein has been made except as herein stated, and the

claimant is justly entitled to the amount herein claimed from the

- defendants after allowing all just credits and offsets.

No action has been taken upon this claim by Congress or by any

of the executive departments of the Government of the United

States. The claimant has always borne true allegiance to the Gov-

ernment of the United States and has not in any way voluntarily

aided, abetted, or encouraged rebellion against said Govern-

ment.

4 The claimant demands judgment against the defendants

for the sum of $274,320, and also for the value of the use of

the invention described and claimed in said letters patent num-

bered 20727, hereafter to be ascertained.

| ALFRED ELY,

Attorney for Claimant, # 25 Nassau St., New York City.

. Crry AND County oF NEw YoRK, 38:

_. Jacob F. Wyckoff, having been duly sworn, says that he is the

president of “The Morse Arms Manufacturing Company,” the

claimant named in the foregoing petition, and that he believes the

facts as stated in the said petition to be true.

JACOB F. WYCKOFF.

. Subscribed and sworn before me this 10th day of April, 1884.

[SEAL. ] H. D. INGERSOLL,

Notary Public, N. Y. Co.

5 II.—Traverse. Filed April 19, 1884.

And now comes the Attorney General, on behalf of the United

States, and, answering’ the petition of the claimant herein, denies

each and every allegation therein contained; and asks judgment

that the petition be dismissed.

- And as toso much of the said. petition as avers that the said claim-

ant has at all times borne true faith and allegiance to the Govern-

ment of the United States, and ha- not in any way voluntarily aided,

| ;

4g :

gun after either of the patents (which) have been exhibited, or a | ) q

THE UNITED STATES.

ernment, the Attorney General, in pursuance of the statute in such

case provided, denies the said allegations, and asks judgment accord-

ingly.

THOMAS SIMONS,

Assistant Attorney General.

rath

es

tan

6 III.—Findings of Fact and Conclusion of Law. Filed June 20,

1892.

This case having been heard by the Court of Claims, the court,

upon the evidence, find the facts to be as follows: |

Findings of Fact.

I.

A musket made by George W. Morse, under letters patent No.

15995, was presented by him to the War and Navy Departments of

the United States during the year 1857. March 5, 1857, Col. Craig,

chief of ordnance, wrote the following letter to Maj. Bell, commander

of the Washington arsenal:

Sir: Mr. Morse, of Louisiana, will present at the arsenal a breech-

loading rifle, which please cause to be tried, and report the result to

this office, with your opinion as to the fitness of the arm for the

military service. Maj. Bell reported that the arm, though compli-

cated in its machinery, was worthy the consideration of the depart-

ment, and were it not for its complicated machinery it would prob-

ably be as well suited to military as it certainly is to ciyil purposes. _

August 12, 1857, an order was issued from the War Department

directing a board of officers to assemble at West Point “ for the pur-

pose of making trials of breech-loading rifles, with a view to ascer-

tuin which arm of this description is best suited for the military

service.”

To this board Morse wrote a letter commending his gun. The

board reported as their unanimous opinion that ‘“ the breech-load-

ing rifle submitted by A. E. Burnside, of Rhode Island, is suited for

military service.” November 12, 1857, Morse wrote to John B.

Floyd, Secretary of War, alluding to experiments made with his

musket, and concluding thus: .

Now, sir, I only await your leisure, and from your known knowl-

edge of fire-arms confidently expect to prove to you the truth of my

assertions, “that mine is the best gun in the world.” ;

. December 9, 1857, Mr. Floyd, Secretary of War, issued the follow-

ing directions to the commander of the Washington arsenal : -

The colonel of ordnance will direct Maj. William H. Bell to have

a gun made at the Washington arsenal upon the plan of Mr. Morse’s

combination of them ; the work to be executed under the supervis-

ion of Mr. Morse himself, if he chooses.

4 THE MORSE. ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. Vs.

January 27, 1858, Morse was asked by Col. Craig, chief of ord-

nance, to send one of his rifles for the use of Lieut. Gen. Scott, with

cartridges. March 5, 1858, the Secretary of War directed that 100

of the Morse gun be purchased at $40 apiece to be paid for in lots of

twenty-five each.

In May, 1858, the Secretary of War asked the Committee on Mili-

tary Affairs of the House of Representatives to recommend an ap-

propriation of $100,000, to be used in altering old muskets and

rifles into breech-loading arms.

7 The act of June 12, 1858, appropriated $20,000 for breech-

loaders, of which, besides the amount paid Morse, $2,500 was

paid to William Mont Storm for the privilege of altering 2,000 arms

according to his plan.

February 26, 1858, Morse wrote to the “board of officers for the

examination of altered United States arms” urging the use of brass

cartridges, and stating that “I do not depend upon the gun for a

tight joint at the breech, but upon the cartridge, which seals it per-

fectly, and is renewable after each discharge, so that it can never

wear out.”

August 6, 1858, the board of officers who had met at West Point

reported to ‘the Secretary of War that they had selected Morse’s

model for this reason: “ Inasmuch as it differs from the others by

including the new and untried principles of a primed metallic car- |

tridge, which may, on actual trial, be found of advantage.” |

September 9, 1858, Morse wrote the Secretary of War authorizing

him to alter 2,500 old arms on his plans for $5 each. This was

ro for 2,000 arms and the Secretary said (11th September,

1858):

Let Mr. Morse have an order for three United States flint-lock

_ muskets, of the latest model, and for three United States percussion

rifles, seven grooves, to alter after his plan, for patterns. When

these patterns are ready let an order be given for the alteration, ac-

cording to the pattern arms, of 2,000 muskets of the same model at

either United States armory, as he may designate. * * * The

arms so altered to be rifled and sighted at the armory, and Mr.

Morse to have the privilege of superintending the process of altera-

tion and to be required to state that the work is done in a satis-

factory manner to him before the altered arms are issued for trial.

* * * Leta written grant of the privilege to alter 2,000 arms at

the rate proposed be obtained from Mr. Morse, payment to be made

to him ($10,000) out of the special appropriation, when the agree-

ment is signed, which agreement is to include all his patent priv-

ileges. |

Bcilesiber 13, 1858, Morse said: “ In consideration of the sum of

$10,000, paid to me by warrant on the Treasury of the United

States, I hereby grant, sell, and convey to thesaid United States the

right and privilege to alter 2,000 of the muskets now belonging to

the United States,” according to his pattern.

= February 6, 1860, Morse (and A. Anderson) proposed to the Sec-

s retary of War to change the order for 100 carbines at $40 each, and q!

; “instead of it to sell to the Government the right to manufacture

z bare ER oe : :

x oy ee Oe at cs, - a LE ee 3

5 gene” 2. Sa, ar ee ee . . ie so ws ae

so. Se th t, PA eS CER) s ‘ 2 ‘ $ ‘ ob Page eh RS on Sue PS 6 13

CS) Se Se ee Ss Se See Re Se Ser = - * Sty ; . : ; * é Seng % me se Ye eR:

q f _ < 3 els Shae Lae Yale tet ep RE Oy eR eS Be 5S 3 i ; Ps fer . PROS ~ A TRA ASD snes Geman a ere

2 5 eh 4 ew Pope es Yr. r * " ere Re ae he Se Le ol Pee, MeO oh teen MO Ce AD aS sai Noa

> Pa . oak pylon ak a Sy awh os v

_ posed to make the conveyance for $3,000, being at the rate of $3 on —

' retary of War: :

THE UNITED STATES.

1,000 carbines according to Morse’s invention for breech-loading

arms, and according to the particular plan thereof which has been —

applied in the alteration of the United States rifles: ” and they pro-

each gun. This proposition was accepted by the Secretary of War

February 9, 1860. Thereafter the following license was given :

License.

This agreement, made this eleventh day of February, eighteen |

hundred and sixty, witnesseth: That, whereas an order was given

on the 16th of March, 1868, by direction of the.Secretary of War, to

George W. Morse fur one hundred guns of his invention, at forty —

dollars each, for the use of the United States, and which was agreed _

to by said Morse; and, whereas none of said guns have been yet |

furnished, and said Morse has now proposed to have said order —

changed and in place of it that the Government shall purchase from _

him, at the rate of three dollars each, the right to manufacture one ©

thousand ‘carbines, according to his, said Morse’s, invention for —

breech-loading arms, and more particularly according to the par- —

ticular plan thereof which has been applied in the alteration of the —

United States rifle, which proposal has been assented to by the Sec- —

Now, therefore, be it known that I, the said George W. Morse, for -

and in consideration of the premises, and of the sum of three’

8 thousand dollars in hand, paid jointly to him and A. Ander-~

son, who joined in the application to have the order for the |

one hundred guns set aside and this agreement to be entered into in

lace thereof, and the receipt of which sum of three thousand dollars

is hereby acknowledged, do hereby grant, sell and convey to the —

Government of the United States of America the full right to manu-

facture, at any time or times it may determine, one thousand guns

called carbines, or by whatever other name known, of his, said

Morse’s, invention of breech-loading arms, and of cartridge cases for:

the same, and more particularly according to the particular plau~

thereof which has been applied in the alteration of the United States -

rifle; it being fully understood that this is to convey all the patent -

rights of said Morse to his inventions of breech-loading arms and

ammunition therefor, as described and secured in his patents, num--

bered 20503 and 20727, so far as regards the above-inentioned one

thousand arms, and also the right to apply, as far as regards said —

one thousand arms, any and all improvements he has made and may

make applicable to the same. eee

In witness whereof, I, the said Geo. W. Morse, have hereunto set —

my hand and seal, on the day & year first above written. es

Witness— |

_ And I, the said Anderson, have at the same time set my hand ¢

seal. : eee

‘Witness—The words “as described and secured in his patents,

. a

Spa

»

THE: MORSE ARMS ‘MANUFAC CTURING CO. VS.

numbered 20503 and 20707,”: being interlined between the 19th &

20th lines of the second page, before signature.

GEO. W. MORSE. [sEAt.

A. ANDERSON. SEAL.

Signed and sealed in presence of—

WM. MAYNADIER,

Capt. of Ord.

JONAS T. KELLER.

U. S. Patent OFFICE.

biniiesd 13 & recorded 15 Feb’y, 1860, in Liber R®, page 68, of

Transfers of Patents. In testimony whereof I have caused the seal

of the Patent Office to be hereunto affixed.

[SEAL. | PHILIP F. THOMAS,

Com’r of Patents.

Sixty of Morse’s muskets were made prior to November 12, 1859.

The Government paid Morse $13,000 under the agreements herein-

before set forth.

IT.

: nt the request of defendant’s counsel the following facts are

ound:

In February, 1861, Morse wrote to “ Jefferson Davis, President af

the Confederate States of America,” as follows:

In pursuance of my understanding with you respecting the ma-

cvineryforarms * * * [shall have the satisfaction of knowing

_ that my exertions and honest endeavors to benefit the Confederacy

will be crowned with success.

In March, 1861, he wrote to the Secretary of War of the Confed-

erate States of America as follows: 3

If success dues not attend the efforts now being made for the es-

tablishment of a Southern armory, these arms can | be manufactured

= in Europe or anywhere else at about the same cost as those of the

- ordinary kind. I shall be happy to make a trial of them before you

at any time you may indicate.

P. S.—It seems to me that the adoption of-a single plan of breech-

loader, with one caliber, for both the army and navy, would be ad-

vantageous.

April 6, 1861, he wrote to J. C. Grubb & Co. relative to the manu-

facture of 1 000 of his breech-loading carbines for the State of Texas,

to be made in Europe, saying:

I enclose you a circular in reference to this gun, and I doubt not

that if I can get its manufacture under way that any number of

them will be sold in the South, where some models of it have been

in use for some time past by Major McCulloch, and shown all over

the ie eney:

THE UNITED STATES.

July 18, 1861, he wrote the following letter: me

Ricumonp, July 18th, 1861. —

Hon. E. Pope Walker, Secretary of War, C. 8.

Srr: In accordance with your suggestion, I submit the following

as a list of machines which I hope to obtain for the purposes set

forth in a letter from the governor of the State of Tennessee to his

excellency President Davis:

1 trip-hammer, with such special 1 rifling machine.

tools for welding gun barrels 1 nut-boring do.

as are at hand. 1 smooth do. do.

2 small planers. 1 barrel-turning lathe.

1 screw machine. 1 — press.

1 cone machine. orizonta! milling machine for

2 small lathes. ramrods.

1 profiling machine. 1 old breech-screw-cutting ma-

2 drilling do. with 3 or 4 chine.

spindles each. 1 old index machine.

8 milling machines.

It is the loan of these tools only which is asked for, the value for

which may be fairly estimated at from eight to ten thousand dol-

lars. There are several good reasons why the request should be

granted, and one of them 1s, that under the representations of Gen’l

Polk that it would be done, the State of Tennessee has purchased

buildings and grounds for an armor

Another is, that at Nashville workmen from Louisville and St.

Louis are easily obtained to duplicate them and make more of the

same kind. +

Still another reason is, that the State has purchased large supplice Po

of war material, and the Confederate government has not only

already availed itself of a part of this in the form of percussion caps,

but will want large supplies of powder from her mills. All of

which is respectfully submitted for your consideration.

I am, sir, your ob’t servant, GEO. W. MORSE,

Sup’t Tenn. Armory.

April 11, 1861, Morse left Washington for Louisiana, where he

remained throughout the war. |

: IIT.

In the year 1855 the said Morse filed in the Patent Office a — 7

thus entitled: “ Description of improvements in breech-loadi ne 8

and cartridges for the same for either cannon or small arms,” ich

is made part of these findings.

Thereafter a patent, dated October 28, 1856, was issued to said

Morse, which with the specifications, claims, and drawings (and dis- —

claimer filed November 27, 1872) is made part of these findings. |

This patent (No. 15995) was extended by statute (act of March 11, :

1872) and expired November 29, 1879. 3

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

October 28, 1856, another patent (No. 15996) was issued to said

Morse, which with the claims and specifications upon which it was

issued are made part of these findings.

June 8, 1858, patent No. 20503 was issued to said Morse, which

with the claims and specifications upon which it was issued is made

part of these findings. This patent was extended by statute and

expired June 7, 1879. |

une 29, 1858, patent No. 20727 was issued to Morse, which with

the claims and specifications upon which it was issued is made part

of these findings. This was extended by statute and expired June

29, 1879.

10 In 1835, the following report was published in France; it

does not appear whether it was published in this country :

34 vear (No. 369).—March, 1835.

(Bulletin of the Society for the Encouragement of National Industry

: at Paris, 1835.)

Mechanical Arts—Fire-arms.

Report made by the Baron Séguier, in the name of the committee

of nechanical arts, on sporting guns loading at the breech, pre-

sented by Mr. Lefaucheux, gunsmith, Street de la Bourse, corner

of Colonnes, Paris.

For a long time it was known that the war guns called guns with

forced balls had a longer range than the others, and yet very little

affort had been made to give the same advantages to sporting arms

loaded with small shot. .

This was difficult; the only means of attaining this end was to

load them with cartridges with the charge of shot,separated from

the powder by a diaphragm of a larger diameter than that of the

un. Such a cartridge could not be introduced and pushed to the

bottom of the barrel without a great effort, and even in that case,

without losing a part of the advantages sought for, the intervening

body placed between the shot and the powder being thus com-

pressed at the time of loading, would place itself beforehand in

contact with the diameter of the arm. At the moment of the ex-

plosion a wad thus moulded would have a very little superiority

over ordinary wads.

.But this even could not be, inasmuch as the barrel of a sporting

gun, in order to carry the shot properly, should be at its orifice slightly

smaller than at its breech. To solve the problem, the cartridge,

prepared as we have just said, must be placed in the chamber of the

barrel of a diameter a little larger than the barrel, and connected

; with it by the section of a cone. These arms can, therefore, only

— . be loaded at the breech; this was what several armorers well under-

stood: when the first systems of sporting guns with movable breeches,

- ealled broken barrels, were thought of.

= Our purpese, gentlemen, is not, on the occasion of this report, to

trace here at length, the complete history of the modifications

THE UNITED STATES. .

which the sporting arms have already undergone; we will limit _

ourselves to saying that it was to a gunsmith by the name of Pauly, —

to whom is due, in our day, the introduction into commerce of

these kind of arms, which had heretofore appeared more curious

than useful. ae 3

The guns which we call to your. attention today were presented

by an armorer fora long while employed in the workshops of Mr. |

Pauly; this artist seemed to have at heart the desire of bringing to —

the highest possible point of perfection this kind of gun, on which

he worked from the beginning. :

M. Lefaucheux has exposed under our eyes the drawings of the

different modifications through which he carried the Pauly inven-

tion to bring it to the point where you now see it. Experience has

furnished him successively the indications of the practical incon-

veniences which each one of the preceding modifications carry with

it; and it is — that experience has, for a sufficient length of

time, sanctioned these last efforts that he calls upon you to appre-

ciate their merits.

The Lefaucheux gun is composed of a barrel fixed by a tangen-

tial hinge at its circumference to a piece of iron folded in a square,

against which comes and rests its lower extremity; the barrel is

firmly held in contact with that piece, which serves it as a breech,

by the aid of a drawing bolt in the form of a T, the head of which

engages itself between two hooks soldered under the barrel. The

piece forming a breech is made to function at the same time as tip-

ping piece, and comes and inserts itself ordinarily in the wood be-

tween the two plates, like the prolongation of the tipping piece.

The head of the T is constructed in such a fashion as to fill the

double office of drawing to a joint the barrel against the piece

forming the breech when it is desired to close the gun for firing,

and to raise lightly the barrel to overcome the adherence of the

pieces, one against the other, when it is required to introduce a new

cartridge. | ?

Sometimes it is a particular lever, at other times it is the handle

of the underguard which serves to put the T in motion. In this

gun the fire is put to the powder in the ordinary way by the per-

ree of the hammer on the cone (called piston) screwed into the

arrel. 3 |

In examining this arm with attention, you inquire, perhaps, why

the hinge which unites the barrel to the stock has thus been placed

under the barrel, and why the pulling is not done in the axis?

This reflectioir presents itself to our own mind. We should antici-

pate it on your part in communicating to you the motives which

caused Mr. Lefaucheux to act in this manner. Pulling in

11 __—i the axis to operate the juxtaposition of the extremity of the

barrel against the piece forming the breech can only be ob-

tained by means of side plates, but experience has demonstrated

that the plates very soon undergo, by the action of the fire, a very

remarkable alteration. *

This phenomena, observed in the guns with plates, is curious:

2—169

pith SS es HS, 64 eg ! st ¥ a

% fies SEI BS ae DA Faeries bon sie =

RE de ae abi aT, a » See. ys

ae PTE me

iz

ee

Ae Sey eer 3 oe Me ESE ee ee he Pk ve aetna

hee ae SO Sine Beta i a ae i ek, Sind ta ihn ha epee” Sh eats Caer a Pr aaia *) Sn

Fee eS SS Rg ae ee, eRe Oe “as SES cs So es eg a eae ed ee eae SP eee oa a

Ake ee ee ee” Bia Mien Fee as ease won k Soak wo ig ae LK, Petey ay Cn pl gS

10 THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

enough for you to permit us to entertain you on the subject for an

instant.

In these kinds of guns, after even a short service, a groove is soon

observed, corresponding to the point where the barrel terminates.

This scooping, which ends by becoming quite deep, operating in

either steel or iron case-hardened, which is harder still since its

temper is not reduced, is it the result of a mechanical action of the

gas in its flight, or, rather, is it not the product of a chemical action,

by the combination of the sulphur of the powder with the iron?

This, gentlemen, is the case in point which we have at heart to

make clear. After a careful examination we have found that the

corroded point acquires a hardness very superior to all the other

points of the plate. We have verified that such an alteration does

not show itself, or at least in a manner quite imperceptible, upon

the blade of brass inserted between the barrels, to oppose itself to

the communication of the fire from the one to the other. This

blade, under the most unfavorable conditions, lasted only an ex-

tremely short time when it was of steel, and it was this experience

and the observation which indicated to Mr. Lefaucheux the substi-

tution of brass for steel. .

The good condition of the intermediary blades of brass in the

guns, where the side plates were already deeply furrowed, leaves us

no longer in doubt as to the cause of that deterioration.

Without setting aside the influence of the mechanical action, we

attribute it principally to the chemical combination which we have

just described.

_ Mr. Lefaucheux could then have advantageously lined the side

lates with brass, but he preferred attacking the evil at its root; he

as endeavored to disembarrass himself entirely of the side plates,

and it is in this manner, gentlemen, that he has been led to avoid

. this last disadvantage by means of the arrangement which he sub-

mits to you.

_ This simple arrangement, which renders the manceuvring of the

gun simple and commodious, ought, it seems, finally to have com-

pletely satisfied the sportsman ; but it was otherwise ; in proportion

as the arm neared its perfection the exigencies increased ; being un-

able to find fault with the mechanism, they complained that it did

not overcome the complete loss of gas. 3

This loss of gas, according to the belief of the greater number,

offered the double inconvenience of diminishing the range and the

blacking of the fingers; as to. ourselves we can attribute to it only

this last inconvenience.

Althougii very slight, this last reproach had a foundation. Mr.

Lefaucheux, desiring to satisfy in all respects the many sportsmen

who honored him with their confidence, put himself again to the

task, without ever despairing of success; therefore, to surmount a

last obstacle, he was induced to apply to the guns the happy appli-

cation of the closing principle of hydraulic presses. We desire to

speak of that punched-up leather, the edges of which are applied

against the sides of a vase, with all the more force when the liquid

THE UNITED STATES.

which it contains finds itself more compressed, and has a greater

tendency to escape. eee

You conceive, gentlemen, that in adopting this principle of

closure for guns, as there is no question of the opposing of the _

of a 8 but that of inflamed gas,it was proper to modify the

. material of the stopper; therefore it is.not a cap of leather, but a

bottom of thin brass with which Mr. Lefaucheux caps his cartridges. _

The flexible edges of this hat, which has the form of a large capsule,

which, dilating at the moment of the explosion, and applying itself

to the-sides of the barrel with such exactness, that henceforth the

slightest escape of gas becomes impossible.

This method, which is as simple as it is ingenious, and which an

observing mind has kuown how to borrow from the hydraulic press,

to make of it a happy application, deserves to fix your attention.

We look upon it as one of the most useful improvements i

for a long time to sporting arms which are loaded at the breech.

This, according to our opinion, is a true service rendered to the

entire art of gun-making; by its use the combinations of closures,

which are less exact, will be safe from the escape of gas, and hence-

forth it will not be the exactitude but only the solidity of the closure

which renders the problem of the manufacture of arms with broken

breech difficult to solve.

_ Mr. Lefaucheux believed he should secure to himself the privilege

of the use of this powerful auxiliary of a closed: by means of a

patent of invention and a patent of improvement.

We have just given you a concise description of the Lefaucheux

gun; we have discussed and explained its construction; we have

nade known to you how Mr. Lefaucheux had found in the resources

of his inventive mind the ingenious means of surrounding the ob-

stacles as fast as they presented themselves; we should now speak

to you of the use of his arm and its results. co

12 Mr. Lefaucheux has requested that we should satisfy our-

selves of the good effects of his gun; not shrinking from any

test, he has himself solicited us to make comparative experiments;

we will submit the results for your inspection.

Official report of the comparative experiments made between sev-

eral guns of different systems, at the request of Mr. Lefaucheux,

by Messrs. Olivier and Séguer, commissioners of the Society of

Encouragement, in the presence of Messrs. Lefaucheux, Justin,

and others, the firing by Mr. Gosset. |

(Notr.—The “experiments were made on several papers—blue |

paper, partly sized, pinkish-white pares, gray paper, unglazed,

ach series of trials, however, took place for all of the guns onthe +

same kind of paper and under similar circumstances.) Sei:

First trial—Pinkish-white paper.

7 Penetration,

Lefaucheux gun.—Powder, 70 grains, shot No. 4, 1 oz.... 37 sheets.

Second shot. Powder, do. do. --» 49 do

Pottet gun. 55 do. 6 41 da |

2 et > F ‘7 Awd 2s >, ene *

0 OE RR ORR AN i 3-0 ts SCR IS Ni Sicha a tay Bs Sa ark a dk?

ee iit ae Ane ot Cie iS da cee Bae

92 THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

The comparisons being impossible, as the charges were unequal,

in the following shots they were brought to the same weights. To

obtain the same quality of powder the Lefaucheux gun made use

of the cartridges intended for the Pottet gun. We should cause you

to observe that those cartridges entered more easily in the Lefau-

eheux gun than in that of Pottet, for which they had been made.

Second experiment.

Shot No. 4, 1 0z.; powder, 55 grains; blue paper. Lefaucheux,

25 sheets; Pottet, 31 sheets.

The cartridge was rolled in a band of paper, so as to enter into

the Lefaucheux gun with less play.

Pinkish-white paper.—Lefaucheux, 46 sheets; Pottet, 50.

Gray paper.—Lefaucheux, 71 sheets ; Pottet, 74.

Lefaucheux, 51 sheets.

In this experiment the quires of paper were turned over, and

Lefaucheux fired on the paper which hoa already received the shot

of Pottet. The second shot was fired by Lefaucheux on new paper.

Third test.—Comparison of the Lefaucheux gun and the Robert

gun.

Gray paper.—First shot fired by the Robert gun, loaded with

loose ainmunition without a cartridge, 55 grains of powder, 49

sheets.

Second fire, with cartridge, 52 grains of powder, 66 sheets.

The Lefaucheux gun, loaded with the powder and shot of the

Robert cartridges taken to pieces, so as to make them into the

Lefaucheux cartridges, 52 grains, 73 sheets.

Third fire of the Robert gun, fired on paper which had already

been shot, 73 sheets.

Second shot, Lefaucheux gun, on paper also turned, 73 sheets.

We think it necessary to poiut out in our experiments this cir-

cumstance of the paper which had already been struck, because the

necessity of separating the sheets to count them destroys their jux-

taposition—they become more difficult to penetrate.

The object of the fourth test is to ascertain the best mode of igni-

tion, either upon the barrel or behind it.

These experiments were made with two guns of the Lefaucheux

system, but by a different arrangement as regards the ignition.

Gray paper.—First fire, inflammation in the back part and in the

bore of the gun, 70 grains powder, 71 sheets; second, iguition on

the barrel, same amount of powder, 72 sheets.

From all these experiments, one must conclude, as a general rule,

that it is a grave error to suppose that the ranges are more useful

when the charges of powder are heavier. Remark, gentlemen, that

we use the word utility, because we do not pretend to say that the

distance to which the projectile is thrown is not increased with the

force of the power which gives it its movement.

We have said useful because it is demonstrated for us, and the

experiments with which we have just entertained you proves it,

“< £ a * ng aT, > 4 ys APE eM, tat TO NE ONL ET Re hy Tee es eer! Bs Sha Se, Beer ay

< a Seogte Shit Soe : - cay Pas he ee £ ie ery x x PPG ie Pe Sheet ty Rap ee ae a hah es ry ri Akt 76 Pie! Pe tes ty * FP oN

> a oth pee Ma ae: zm in Tab A oy ey tees | < etal ED es oa . by teed shee Or BS ti N 7 ue 3 ee eR ee lee Pe Pee, sa ce ars Aey. S ss Phy a5 eed \ w

z Prsgis Be Se Seine Se wes se 2 ye ee ba a TOE Sen + hig k dae) Ge SPOS, re > cos tigtas' Jy pee pen Sone ing RN os eg fy ees Le 2 Ferhat sep hen, % ¥ (hen. “a 4s ae

[os eee) eae : We Fold ota SAD ts. eine tae ae te a PR ae Sree ae Pave ase PN EOTIS cB ye etn, ON Xe c OS es 5 vf OR aE ais Toh gine: CPSs ty FE tg Po oy Sot sot Re Sat <a oe 2

' OE, CEE Ry ee ets Re te See eae a ; pid Ri bars tn eh Tae % See meas ti en EGR OE ey RS <S : oe Ba % = Z oy

ee? : wes C waar aE) oa Me i

e = eas Sit goa | ‘ v Fest

~

ReaN Ri tances

Me Ne eee oe oe

RE) > Se Pee

it Posh ak a

Sa ta

THE UNITED STATES. | | 13 a8

that the penetration is much less when the velocity goes beyond a

certain limit; it can be very well understood when one reflects that

the penetration of a body is all the more difficult when the time

during which the separation of the constituent molecules has

13 _ been incited is in itself the shortest. It is in this manner,

gentlemen, that the fact, otherwise so strange, is naturally -

explained, that a ball fired close up, flattening itself on a board,

will pierce it through and through when fired from a distance.

We have rigorously established the fact that the Lefaucheux gun

offers no more escape of gas, a condition to which some sportsmen

attach a very high value, but as to ourselves we believe it to be of

very much less importance than is generally supposed. The limits

uf this report does not permit us to develop in this respect our

opinion ; for its foundation it has a new mode of viewing the phe-

nomena that accompany the ignition of the powder. We believe

that up to this date the chemical phenomina, such as the produc-

tion of a gas, have not been sufficiently discriminated from the

purely mechanical phenomena, such as the useful application of a

generated force. | | |

It will be sufficient to say that the experiments with which we

have been entertaining you come themselves to our support, since a

gun of the Robert system—that is to say, in which there is a sensi-

ble escape of gas, has obtained a range equal to those guns which

leave no other escape for the gas, except through the barrel itself.

We are pleased, therefore, to accord to the Lefaucheux gun every

advantage shown in its practice. We note, in the first place, the

solidity of its closure, tested several times by the simultaneous ex-

plosion of the double charges placed in each barrel; and then the

facility with which it is loaded, the small amount of cleaning neces-

sary which it requires; its cartridges, surmounted by their capsules,

being withdrawn almost entire after the explosion, preserving the

chamber from any fouling; with regard to the barrel, the forced

wad which passes through it at each explosion cleans it, each time,

of the smoke of the preceding fire, and so well that after a consider-

able number of fires this gun is as fit for use as at the moment when

it was first put into use.

These properties render the facility of its being taken apart, and

of its being cleaned of very little importance; nevertheless, as Mr.

Lefaucheux still claims for the gun, to which he gives his name, the

merit of simplicity of construction, we believe that we give proof of

impartiality in stating in favor of this report a comparative table

of the number of pieces which compose the guns of the different —

systems furnished by Mr. Lefaucheux, acknowledging, as to our-

selves, that the lesser figure is in favor of the Lefaucheux guns. —

The experience of Mr. Lefaucheux has produced its fruits, and, what

completely justifies the praises which we accord him, is the public

favor which he has so well known how to obtain, the best touch-

stones in matters of industry. We have under our eyes an album |

containing a considerable number of satisfactory attestations, given

by the sportsmen who have made use of his guns. The inspection _

aaa

cap

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

of commercial books have, by the importance of their sales, corrobo-

rated these declarations. |

We have, for some length of time, occupied your attention, and

nevertheless we have yet only spoken of the improvements applied

to sporting guns. The inventive mind of Mr. Lefaucheux has ac-

tually directed itself towards the modifications to which our war

guns could be usefully subjected, which are less improved than those

of some other European powers, of Sweden for instance; but has

Mr. Lefaucheux reflected well upon the extent and the difficulties

of the task which he imposes on himself? He will have to struggle

agaiust fixed habits, and then attack, one by one, the arrangements

which have been prescribed by the times, the numerous vices of

constructions which they conceal and which defy the judicious

critics of moderate practice, under the auspices of a learned theory.

But we trust to our colleague, Mr. Olivier, the charge of speaking to

you of the labor of Mr. Lefaucheux in this respect; we mention

them here briefly, only in support of the conclusions which we have

the honor to submit to you in the name of the committee of the

mechanical arts.

We therefore propose to you to return the name of Mr. Lefaucheux

to the commission of medals, so that he may receive from the society

one of thuse honorable distinctions which it holds in reserve for en-

-couraging persevering efforts, and recompense useful labors, and

crown happy inventions.

Approved in session the 18th February, 1835. |

(Signed) Baron SEGUIER, Reporter.

Deseription of the Sporting Gun of Mr. Lefaucheux, which Loads at the

: Breech.

The Fig. 1, pl. 616, represents the gun put together with all its

pieces.

é Fig, 2, double-barrelled gun, the barrels lowered and ready to re-

ceive the cartridges.

Fig. 3, longitudinal cut of the same, drawn on a double scale.

Fig. 4, the key, seen in elevation and in plan.

Fig. 5, the T seen in elevation and in plan.

14 Fig. 6, screw of the T in elevation and underneath.

Fig. 7, cartridge supplied with its culot.

Fig. 8, culot, front view. ,

The same letters indicate the same objects in all the figures.

a a, the barrel of the gun.

6 b, hooks applied under the chamber, between which a kind of

bolt called T engages itself.

c, pin cut in a bevel and used to hold the T.

d, cone or nipple, applied on the barrel to receive the priming

e, key placed under the tipper ; it is turned horizontally from left

to right, so as to disengage the hooks aud lower the barrel ; in the

aanere of that key enters the lower extremity of the T, which is held

ere by a screw.

ee 4

a

Pad

ae. Cee

« es ese} aah - s Bs, “dae i P .

~ °. LP PR ee PR RS SO ee are ee nox, 9 FS 5 Po so Oe ee

SR I SE OR OE Ee OE SSE Se ee em gd TS ce OE eS he a RCTS Oe a Ree a adh > Si

fe or ten FET OE PE RDS ST ES et Le ON? SANS SN AR SA AON aN tee ee So ER” NE Oe eM Se, Ble .

ee ae Cay ge ae le TO onl ARE ea es ERE REET Te Name SOE RT Oe Rae Sea ia? °c

< ° pote Fo a 4 (ye. et a reas

THE UNITED STATES. — 15

f, bolt called T, of which the part f! is cut in a bevel, so as to @

slide against the end of the pinc, cut in an inclined plane; a spring

which is not visible in Fig. 3, but which is indicated in Fig. 12, rests

against the T’ and holds the key apart whilst the gun is being

charged ; g, a screw which fixes the kes against the T.

h, ring which surrounds the T; it is hollowed on one part of its

circumference, so as to receive a little blade fixed at the bottom

of the tipper; 2, piece of iron folded ina square called tipper, solidly

fixed to the gun; on its extremity the barrel turns.

j, pin, which passes through the hinge & of the tipper, and serv-

ing as center of motion to the barrel.

k, hammer; J, under guard; m™, triggers; n, sight; 0, cartridge ;

p, brass culot of the cartridge.

Management of the gun: The gun is seized with the right hand ; ©

the left hand is passed under the barrel, and you bear against the

key, which turns at that moment and disengages the hooksce. The

barrel at once lowers itself and shows its open chamber. In this

position, indicated by the Fig. 2, the key remains in place and can-

not fall again, being held back by the spring which rests against

the T. Whilst the gun is held by the left hand the cartridge is

shoved into the barrel; then the barrel is raised, the key is put in

place,:as is seen in Fig. 1st, and the gun is loaded. There remains

nothing more to be done but to cap the cone d’ with a brass capsule

containing the priming of fulminate powder and to cock the ham-

mer; this hammer in falling sharply against the capsule crushes it

and inflames the fulminate powder, which sets fire to the charge by |

traversing the cartridge. After the load has been fired the barrel

“ —— , the culot is withdrawn, and you load as has been said

hefore. :

The cost of the manufacture of the Lefaucheux gun is from 150

to 350 franc; those made in Paris are sold at 550 francs, with twisted

barrels, and 650 francs with Damascus barrels: :

Letters patent, numbered as follows, were issued at the dates se

forth and to the persons named, upon drawings, specifications, and

claims which are made part of these findings :

No. 828 (French), M. Lafaucheux, May 2, 1845.

No. 203 (United States), Henry C. Ray, May 22, 1837.

No. 7172 (French), Pierre Francois Desnyau, May 4, 1840.

_ No. 3601 (French), M. Chaudun, December 9, 1847.

No. 2746 (French), M. Loron, January 4, 1847.

No. 6139 (United —— David Minesinger, February 27, 1849.

No. 635 (English), Charles Pryse and Richard’ Redman, Novem-

ber 4, 1852. |

No. 9058 (French), M. Gastinne, March 5, 1853.

ae 2778 (English), Auguste Loradoux Belford, November 29,

No. 4626 (English), Jean Samuel Pauly, May 14, 1816. |

No. 11127 (French), Messrs. Palmer and Bidault, June 3, 1854.

Reissue No. 279 (United States), Horace Smith and Daniel B.

Wesson, October 10, 1854. : ee

ae et es

APS ME Teast tg eg Ren Seige eR yA Pgh ee Te IN ont : : , 3 “.

A 6 ‘ Tee: ee Et re ¢ ye wees et a anne e ~ ee 4 AR Noh pee eee - ~

Ub = APE Ne BaD SA eh ote egy oY eae Re - tlk Ay te ae MES Come *, Sha: ters Five ee Ss 9 tek ts ae does ot Bs 3 ee:

3 Sf tag ae Sin Goths sans Sate i ar a Ee i gt PR Seen CN ah eR op ACR Ded ee SR he eS Bee

est = zy,

16 THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

No. 12446 (French), M. Pottet, February 26, 1855.

No. 8829 (French), M. Beatus Beringer, December 31, 1834.

IV.

In the Springfield gun (the official small arm of the U. S. Army)

the breech block is solid and fills all the breech chamber except in

this: It does not bear against the rear end of thechamber, and that

end of the chamber is not intended to take up any part of the recoil

except man the breech pin alone, nor does the forward end of the

breech block when shut come quite in contact with the head of the

cartridge. |

15 The breech block is fastened by a hinge at its forward end

to the top of the barrel. The hinge pin is of less diameter

than the hinge holes through which it passes, thus permitting some

slight movement or play in the hinge so that the pin may not be

cut during recoil.

There is a recess at the head of the breech pin; this recess is

somewhat concave in form, and into this the cam latch locks; the

shaft of the cam-latch hinge is smaller than the hinge holes through

which it passes, and this shaft extends horizontally beyond the

barrel, terminating in a handle or thumb latch, as shown in the

Allin gun; ‘when the breech lock is shut and locked, this handle

lies under the angle of the hammer, and is so arranged that with

a hammer in the third or lowest notch (or entirely down), the

breech block cannot accidentally unlock and open. In locking or

unlocking the cam latch, this handle turns across the head of the

firing pin, and thus operates to prevent premature firing, as in the

Allin gun.

In firing, the breech block sets back under the force of the recoil ;

the loose hinge at the forward end gives play there; the loose hinge

- of the cam latch gives play at that point, and the recoil is trans-

mitted through the breech block to the cam latch, with the head of

which it comes in direct contact, and then through the cam latch

to the head of the breech pin. By reason of the sinall diameters of

the respective pins or shafts of the two hinges, as compared to the

hinge holes through which they pass, no strain is brought upon

these hinges by the recoil. :

_ Extraction and ejection of cartridges was thus performed in all

Springfield guns, beginning with the model of 1868 and continuing

since.

Extraction.—By an extractor plate swinging on the hinge pin

and struck above its center of motion by the forward end of the

breech block near the completion of its movement in opening.

_ Bjection.—By accelerating the movement of the extractor by

means of a spiral ejector spring, which surrounds the stem of the

ejector spindle, and bears against the bottom of its hole in the -

receiver at one end and against the head of the spindle at the

other end. When the extractor is revolved by the opening of the

block, the ejector spring is compressed by the ejector spindle, the

- point of which rests in a cavity in the back of the extractor above

its axis of motion. The continued revolution of the extractor

Hin 5 Sate oe Me ae ers Aa kee Oe. Sos Beak Te

vr NTS ee a Oar a ae ae Pe ee

Fi i

Pa

‘

|

|

|

|

LEARN TE a ite elite EN gay, re i eae

‘

, pee ‘Saaeines

aera oe b c whe bi

PPR

gee

grate Pi rere tee

oe

LEARN 6 ED Sie 0th

‘

, ae een ella oy

me: y e er

* Ce ar a

: F, ee i 2a ee ra eyes eh ae fe *

pers SS Se Pipe et ere SR eee tea OE ack ae ee ¢ bn. ape Saxe ¥:

ta ey Re ee vEe e fames ep ee rey Te GP: Mg PO Nes a S %

sai ahs > Lyris ed

M a a £ ae AS eat bee

LSet, TELE n * . ot a 6c ee ee ene. rant At . Sy eae 4

Radi PE AE RSS Stee eR BOE ET PS Oe Te ey EE eee Oe

oe BS peas eee ae gp = Oo fad * Sx oF

THE UNITED STATES. |

finally brings the prolongation of the ejector spindle below the axis =

of motion; as soon as the center is passed, the sudden releaseof =

the ejector spring causes the ejector to rapidly rotate about its axis, a

‘and to carry the empty cartridge shell against the beveled surface

= _ ejector stud, by which it is deflected upward and thrown clear

of the gun. i: |

Between July 10, 1875, and November 29, 1879, defendants

manufactured new rifles of this model or changed old rifles to this

a e 4 number so manufactured or altered during said period

was 54,864. }

V.

The following models of guns were examined by the court

during the trial of this cause and are made exhibits herein: The

model filed in the Patent Office as showing the construction

described in patent 15595; the Morse gun, captured during the

late war; the Springfield rifle, models of 1866 and 1873; the

Winchester repeating rifle. :

16 3 VI.

Plaintiff is a corporation organized under an act of the legislature

of New York of February 17, 1848, entitled “An act to authorize

the formation of corporations for manufacturing, mining, mechan-

ical, or chemical purposes,” and the acts amendatory thereto, has

its place of business in New York city, and is the owner, by assign-

ment made prior to June 10, 1875, of all the right, title, and interest

granted by said hereinbefore-recited letters patent to said Morse

until their expiration.

VII.

A reasonable royalty for the use of the device claimed in claim 1,

patent 15995, if used by the Government, as contended by plain-

tiffs, for the period covered by the action, 7. ¢., prior to the expiration

of the patent, and not longer ago than six years before this action

began, would be $1 a gun. :

A reasonable royalty for the use of the device claimed in claim 3,

patent 20503, if used by the Government, as contended by plain-

tiffs, for the same period, would be 25 cents per gun.

Conclusion of Law.

Upon the foregoing facts the court find as conclusion of law that

the petition be dismissed. —

IV.—Opinion of the Court.

Davis, J., delivered the opinion of the court: |

In 1855 George W. Morse filed in the Patent Office a caveat which « . a

he entitled a.“ a of improvements in breech-loading guns

and cartridges for the same, for either cannon or small arms.” a

3—169 |

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

Speaking of the gun he said that the barrel should be so constructed

that the gun could be opened and closed at the breech by a movable

breech piece “which does not necessarily fit tight into the bore of

the breech of the gun, but only to remain firmly in its place when

the gun is in proper position for firing.” He proposed in this

caveat that what he named “ the cartridge or breech-pin (if it should

be made to enter the gun) should be so constructed of metal, or

combination of other materials behind the powder, that by the ex-

plosion of the powder it will expand and perfectly fill the bore of

the gun behind as the minie-ball fills the cavity of the gun by the

enlargement of the after part of the same by the explosion of the

eee He proposed that cartridges having a leaden case should

provided for his gun, the cartridges to be in any form consistent

with the principle which he thus claimed “although it (the

cartridge) or the breech pin may enter the gun loose, vet the effect

of the explosion will be to render the gun perfectly tight behind the

owder.” :

4 This caveat was followed by application for letters patent upon a

gun and cartridge. In the Patent Office the application was sepa-

rated and two patents were issued in the year 1856, the one, No.

15995, upon the gun, the other, 15996, upon the cartridge. The

first of these patents was extended by act of Congress and expired

November 29, 1879; the second (No. 15996) expired October 28,

1870. This action was begun April 12,1884. The statute of limita-

tions, therefore, runs against and bars any possible claim under this

: ' second patent.

17 The case turns primarily upon claim 1 in patent 15995,

which reads as follows:

1. Inserting the rim N, or its equivalent, without contact into the

chamber O, substantially in the manner and for: the purpose de-

scribed, contact being obtained through the medium of a cartridge

se.

This claim is thus construed by one of the counsel for the plain-

tiff:

The claimant asserts that George W. Morse, the grantee of letters

patent numbered 15995, was the. lawful patentee of a device for

-sealing a breech joint of a breech-loading gun, purposely made open,

by the expansion of a yielding metallic cartridge case, purposely

_ made to fit loosely in its chamber.

Another of plaintiff’s counsel states the scope of this patent in

argument substantially as follows: Morse discovered a method or

| art by which a breech block, so constructed as to be free in opera-

tion under all circumstances, shall be automatically sealed at the

moment when the use of the gun imperatively requires a close con-

nection between the breech block and the gun barrel. Upon either

statement the claim is for a broad device which shall practically

cover subsequent inventions for sealing loose-jointed breech-loading

military fire-arms by an expanding matallic cartridge.

~ In view of this contention it becomes necessary to examine the

state of the art in the year 1856, when this patent was issued.

The first form of fire-arm was the breech-loader; but, as the im-

a PO CR RO a tha ome

ee el

a ren

ire bea cegt tie I cat sade

woven

< secptis Sayre saat i.

THE UNITED STATES.

escape of gas and flame, the muzzle-loader was adopted and contin-

ued in practical use until the close of the last war; meantime, and

for many years, inventors had been searching for an efficient gas

check capable of practical application to a military breech-loading —

musket. At first all efforts were directed to the manufacture of a

mechanism which by the close fit of its parts should attain the de-

sired result.

far as appears) had much practical value unless possibly in light

sporting arms. The reason is plain. Thecarefullfy adjusted breech

mechanism was apt to become inexact (and might become danger-

ous) through wear, rust, or dirt. An absolutely mechanically cor-

rect adjustment of the parts was, in theory, possible, but in practice

the slightest injury to the gun, the least rust, or the presence of sand

or earth rendered it inefficient and sometimes dangerous.

Long before 1856 inventors had recognized the necessity of a com-

paratively loose mechanism in the breech block, combined with a

sufficient gas check through the expansive cartridge, if practical

efficiency in this class of fire-arms was ever to be attained. Several

patents are referred to in the findings of fact which show the en-

deavor of small-arms inventors in this century. A citation or two,

by way of illustration, may not be amiss.

In 1835 the Society for the Encouragement of National Industry

in France issued a bulletin headed “ Mechanical arts—fire-arms,”

being a report made by Baron Séguier. This report is set forth in

the findings, and from it we make only the following excerpts.

Alluding to the loss of gas, which offered (it was said) “ that double

inconvenience of diminishing the range and blacking the fingers,”

the report proceeds (we quote from translation): _ 7

Mr. Lefaucheux, desiring to satisfy in all respects the man

sportsmen who honored him with their confidence, put himself

again to the task, without despairing of success; so, to surmount a

last obstacle, he was happily led to apply to the guns the

18 closing principle of hydraulic presses; we speak of that

punched-up leather whose edges rub against the sides of a

vase with all the greater force as the liquid which it contains is the

more compressed and has a greater tendency to escape.

You understand, gentlemen, that in adopting this principle of

closure for guns, as there is no question of preventing an escape of

liquid but of burning gas, it was proper to modify the material of

the stopper, therefore it is not a cap of leather, but a bottom of thin

brass with which Mr. Lefaucheux caps his cartridges. The flexible

edges of this hat, having the form of a large capsule, dilates at the _ 4

moment of explosion, and rubs tightly against the sides of the barrel

with such exactness that the slightest escape of gas becomes impos-

sible. * * * Welook upon it as one of the most useful improve-

ments applied for a long time to breech-loading sporting arms.

This, according to our opinion, is a true service rendered to the -

entire art of gun-making. By its use the least exact breech closures —

are safe from the escape of gas, and henceforth it will not be the

perfect fitting of the breech mechanism permitted the reareadi.

Mauy devices of this kind were invented. None (so

exactitude, but alone the strength of the closure which shall render - 4

20 THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

the problem of the manufacture of arms with broken breech diffi-

cult to solve. :

Nearly twenty years before this (in 1816) Pauly had taken out his b

English patent for what he termed “apparatus and arrangements for

discharging fire-arms by means of condensed air, also cartridges ap-

licable thereto.” His description, which is long, contained the fol-

owing paragraph:

Having described the various forms and constructions which I

give to cannon or other large arms for the purpose of loading or

charging them at*the breech or butt end, I shall in the next place

describe my culot, plug, or cartridge stopper, which is an essential

part of invention, which must be used with any or all the construc-

tions of cannon, which have hereinbefore been described or men-

tioned by me, when the same are to be fired or discharged. The

great obstacle to the use of large arms, louding at the breech, has

hitherto been the difficulty of producing an air-tight or perfect

closure between the movable breech and the body or remainder of

the gun; and if the efforts of the explosion can at all make way

into this joint or closure, the construction becomes dangerous, inas-

much as the opening will become iarger, and eventually the mov-

ing breeching may be blown away or torn from its situation. This

effect will entirely be prevented by the adoption of my culot, plug,

or cartridge stopper, which is so placed in the gun as to come be-

tween the charge of gunpowder and the movable breech in all cases,

and is formed of lead, copper, or such other ductile material as will

give way to the explosive force of the charge, and so formed and

situated that by yielding or giving way it will completely and

effectually cover and close up the joint or joining between the mov-

able breeching and the gun itself.

Here, then, Pauly recognized the necessity of a gas check between

~ the “movable breech and the body or remainder of the gun,” and

_ proposed to furnish it by means of a cartridge “formed of lead,

copper, or such other ductile material” as should yield under ex-

plosion and seal the joint. Other citations might be made, but they

seem unnecessary. |

The state of the art in 1856 was not such in our opinion as would x Eo

_ permit a patent to issue covering so broad a claim as that made by

plaintiff’s counsel in this case. The advantages of loose breech

mechanism were known when Morse applied for his patent; the

metallic cartridge as an invention was old, although practical diffi-

culty had been encountered in manufacturing it; the use of a car-

tridge as a gas check was by no means a novel idea. It was not

open to Morse in 1856 to patent every “ device for sealing a breech

joint of a breech-loading gun, purposely made open by the expansion :

of a yielding metallic cartridge case, purposely made to fit loosely in

its chamber ;” quite the reverse ; this idea had been disturbing in-

ventors for many years; Morse came to the Patent Office limited to

some specific mechanical device which should solve the long-studied

problem, and he must be held to the one described in his applica-

tion. Morse was by no means the first in the field, and therefore

&.

9

- Z x

2 x eee ee ee rk . é

rn Sr jo Re Poe ee ae A a 4 Serre |G Pee s

. PEPSI Oe OSE. St Min ag Cee aee ce Some Ty Sn ee Re ig Oe ney ae et ae: Lo

€ VIE Se ty eg ee . BS eh ~ es Sr TER Leas e . \

ba aa het ete MD PE Ra o> AUREL) oho arg © eR Re >

ye : a we we vey ef er 4 z i> eee sg eee

he is not entitled to the very liberal construction which is here

asked.

19 The claim upon which plaintiffs rely (the first in patent

15995) is on its face a narrow one, limited to a specific device ;

they, however, contend that as the patent was issued under the act

of 1836 the question is (to quote from the brief) ‘“ whether in his.

specification as a whole, including the claim, this device was par-

ticularly specified and pointed out as his own invention for which

he demanded the protection of letters patent.”

Without deciding whether this contention as to the law is correct

we turn to the specifications and find the invention described as a

“newand useful breech-loading gun; ” this gun to be so constructed

that he could * blow through it or run water through it with facil-

ity, but when the charge is in it becomes comparatively air and

water tight, because I use a cartridge case which seals the breech

joint, both as to powder and the priming.” Here nothing novel is

described as a loose-jointed mechanism was known, and the use of

a cartridge as a gas check was known; the kind of cartridge was

not specified ; neither was the combination of the two asa broad

device then open to a patent. Further on he describes the mechan-

ism which he afterwards “claims” as his invention in the form we

have seen. Safety in the gun, and the fact that water will not im-

pair its efficiency, appear from this specification to have been Morse’s

main objects. fe :

Another patent, granted to Morse the same day (October 28, 1856),

did cover a metallic cartridge intended to be used as a gas check,

but that patent expired in 1870; because of the statute of limita-

tions no recovery can be had in this action prior to 1878 ; therefore

no rights under this patent can be urged here. . Ner can the car-

tridge patent be imported into the patent-for the gun. A claim for

a system founded upon two patents cannot be sustained where one

of the patents has expired by limitation.

The specific device described in the specification and claim of +

patent 15995 does not appear in the Government gun. (Morse

Arms Company vs. Winchester Arms Company, 33 Fed. Rep.,

170.)

Patent 20503, issued June 8, 1858, after being extended by statute,

expired June 8, 1879; it contained a claim for a cartridge-extractor,

_ and this extractor, or its equivalent, it is contended, is in the Spring-

field gun. The claim is as follows:

Third. The construction and use of the lever, when ——

substantially as described, for the purpose of retracting the cartridge

case.

Under this and the specifications set forth in the findings counsel

urge the broad claim for a lever when the toe is in front of the

flange, no matter how operated. We have discussed the question 4

of cartridge-extractors very fully in the case of the Berdan Fire-

arms Manufacturing Company. The extraction of cartridge shells

by leverage was not new in 1858, and Morse, in this patent, as in

the earlier one, must be confined to his specific invention and to 4

his use of a lever for pushing or pulling out a cartridge from a gun

THE UNITED STATES. ws

Cae

oe ec

_ and the conclusion of law thereon, of the opinion of the court, of

92 THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING CO. VS.

barrel. Bourcier’s patent (1847, 1848, and 1852), Gastinne’s patent

(1853), Belford’s (1853), and Hick’s (1857), all set forth in the find-

ings, sufficiently show that the automatic or mechanical extraction

of cartridges did not originate with Morse and that he was not the

first to use a lever whose short arm should engage the forward side

of the flange. Morse must in any event be limited to the specific ,

device described by him, and this device does not appear in the

Springfield rifle.

Petition dismissed.

20 V.—Judgment of the Court.

THe Morskt Arms MANUFACTURING CuUMPANY

v8 No. 143840.

THE Unitrep STATES.

At a Court of Claims held in the city of Washington on the 20th

day of June, 1892, judgment was ordered to be entered as follows:

The court, on due consideration of the premises, find for the de-

fendants, and do order, udjudge, and decree that the petition of the

claimant be dismissed.

: By THE COURT.

21 VI.—Application of Claimant for and Allowance of Appeal.

THe Morsk ArMs MANUFACTURING COMPANY

. VS. No. 14340.

THe UNITED STATEs.

From the judgment rendered in the above-entitled cause on the

20th day of June, 1892, in favor of the defendants, the claimant, by

its attorney, on the 13th day of September, 1892, makes application

for and gives notice of an appeal to the Supreme Court of the

United States.

: H. E. PAINE,

Claimant's Attorney.

Filed September 14, 1892. :

Allowed in vacation September 30, 1892.

WILLIAM A. RICHARDSON,

Chief Justice.

22 | In the Court of Claims.

Toe Morse ArMsS MANUFACTURING CoMPANY

v8. No. 14340.

THe UNITED STATES.

I, John Randolph, assistant clerk of the Court of Claims, do

hereby certify that the foregoing are true transcripts of the plead-

ings in the above-entitled cause, of the findings of fact by the court

. ie

ae et

ar

a Le ee 7 RR ees a F a

~ oe . aque,

yar sh gee ns — om

.

7.

THE UNITED STATES.

the judgment of the court dismissing the petition, of the applica- —

tion of the claimant for and the allowance of an appeal to the Su- |

preme Court of the United States.

In testimony whereof I have hereunto set

Seal Court of Claims. my hand and affixed the seal of saidcourt,at =

Washington, this fourth day of October, 1892. _™

JOHN RANDOLPH, |

Ass't Clerk Court of Claims.

Endorsed on cover: Case No. 15,158. Court of Claims. Term

No., 169. The Morse Arms Manufacturing Company, appellant, vs.

The United States. Filed October 4th, 1892.

Ne AON ie 4 7 i Mase a

—

> a , , ? - « ¥ - aie

“ é ; : . “ . oy » We a Pe oe

; he so? ; * gh By ar oS :

Supreme Court ofthe Waite States.

‘ OCTOBER TERM, 1895, eS oe

} THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING COMPANY,

_. APPELLANT, = a

yee | = 9 es DB ts hee Renee ae

: ;

5 | |

—. ; |

; : : 0 : .

‘ maj . ens a“ ;

= . °. , - -- 4

_ BRIEF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT ON: MOTION

ene

ee . Jaxens A. Sfixsos, % ee

' | . . . ‘ , .

‘ ‘ : ae Bees

2 ail Ma . a Ss ; } a : ; - : : x ek a v2

se / JUDD & DETWBILER, PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D.C. = > = >

-.

IN THE .

Supreme Court of the *uited States.

OCTOBER TERM, 1895.

No. 169.

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTURING COMPANY

APPELLANT,

v8.

THE UNITED STATES. .

BRIEF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT ON MOTION

FOR CONTINUANCE.

General Duncan was familiar with the Morse: patents

from 1870, when he himself, as Assistant Commissioner of

Patents, refused the extensions on the grounds stated in

my affidavit. He was employed in the various exten-

sion proceedings after they were commenced, under the

act of Congress, in the early part of 1872, till some time —

in the year 1874, during which time the prior state of

the art was brought forward, as shown in England, France,

and other countries, in the several applications for extensions

by:the examiners, and made studies of ‘the prior’ state of

the art so far as it could be found in the Patent Office rec-

ords. He was also employed at frequent intervals from

1874 down to the time of his death in proceedings and liti-

gations in reference to these Morse patents, and, in view of

these opportunities, was better qualified to deal with this

case than any other man, because he had had experience

that could now be obtained by no man, even by years of

study. : :

It is in one respect for this reason that it has been found

impossible to find and engage a substitute within the period

of time elapsed since the death of General Duncan.

The other attorneys and counsel who have become par-

tially familiar with the Morse cases and inventions, espe-

‘ cially Judge Benjamin R. Curtis, Benjamin F. Butler,

Thomas J. Durant, and Judge Emott, have died meantime,

while the Government was delaying the Morse cases in the

Patent Office and in the Court of Claims, and they have left

no substitutes or capable successors as counsel.

Furthermore, death has also removed some of the prin-

cipal owners of the stock of the Morse Arms Company, and

their estates are in process of distribution or in the midst

of entanglements. Time and delay have affected the stand-

ing and ability of others to protect the company, The stock

of others is locked up in other ways, and ever since the |

death of General Duncan, owing to the absence or death of |

trustees of the company,.it has not been found possible,

after continued effort, to have a single meeting of the

trustees or stockholders of the company to even consider

the situation of its affairs. Of these last-mentioned facts

T am aware, because, having been consulted since General

Duncan’s death, I have taken part in the effort to untangle

8

the affairs of the company so that it might be able to deal

with the appeal at this term, but without success. :

Further, this field of invention—breech-loading guns—is

so large, peculiar, and important that to master and under-

stand or qualify one’s self adequately to deal with this inven-

tion in breech-loading guns actually requires almost as

much time as most men give to the acquirement of a

liberal education. Few ordnance officers even, if any,

have been able to master the subject. How invent-

ors struggled for hundreds of years with what was

only accomplished in a momen} of inspiration by Mr.

Morse in our time, and years after he had, in his youth,

abandoned the breech-loading gun as a practical possibility,

lawyers cannot master and understand in months. For

_ that a longer time is required, if superficiality of view and

grasp are to be avoided and the Court is to be assisted ade-

quately in the disposition of the case.

My own experience with these inventions, in acquiring a

knowledge of them and of their relation to the art, as well

as my experience in training other lawyers and experts, in

the Patent Office and out of it, including the Ordnance De-

partment and the Frankfort and Springfield armories, is

the basis of my statement. I began with these cases in

November, 1871, but, although devoting my. time almost

exclusively thereto, I only began to understand the Morse

inventions and their relations to the art after more than

four vears of almost exclusive devotion thereto—that is

to say, from November, 1871, up to the time wben I began

to prepare the petition which was filed in the Court of Claims,

case known as No. 10270—and I was still engaged in experi-

ments nearly to the end of my term in connection with the

4

cases, about twelve years from the time I took the matter

up, in 1871, and, so far as I know, there is no one now living

except myself who is at all competent to. aid and qualify

counsel up to the stage and point where I went out of the

cases and some one else took charge.

As to what has been done in the Court of Claims cases

since that time——that is, during the last twelve or fourteen

years—I know practically nothing, having had nothing

whatever to do with the cases during that period.

The policy adopted when I went out of the cases

was against my judgment, and others were put in

charge for that reason, with the results existing to-day,

which amount to progress backward rather than forward

for the last fourteen years. All this, with resulting compli-

cations, it would take me many months to adequately

master, as they practically involve a restudy of the entire

art. I am, therefore, not qualified to take up the case as it

stands, as an expert, or to train others to deal with the case

which has been made on these new lines; and requiring

months to thus qualify myself, Iam unable, for a variety

of reasons, to undertake to do so.

If, however, the continuance. is granted, I believe that

during the vacation such steps may be taken as will pre-

vent the necessity of laborious preparation on the part of

counsel, and even eventually relieve the Court from the

burden of dealing with this, one of the most complicated

cases, so far as inventions are concerned, that ever came

before it. The petition I filed, No. 10270, was based on con-

tract. Practically this petition was based on infringement,

and brings in nearly every invention in breech-loading

arms, impliedly or directly.

A tr tn pe sesuee

AO 108 nett, eurnere ronnie

5

It is no small part of the complication of the. present

situation that through the procrastinations of the Solicitor

General’s office during the past twenty years the one man

who, knowing his own, understood the inventions better

than any other—that is, Morse himself—has. died, leaving

his wife an aged widow, his daughter an invalid, both

without male protectors or males in the family of an age

and opportunity to render adequate assistance.

In view of the internal situation of the company appel-

lant, Mrs. Morse and Miss Morse are or will become the

real parties in interest; and yet, encumbered with debt,

they are actually without means to live from day to day, to

say nothing of means to prosecute a litigation in the.Su-

preme Court of the United States, while the Government is

spending millions for guns that are the creation of the

genius of Morse and are deemed necessary for the defense

of this great nation.

When I first took up these cases Mr. Morse and his

family were in such a condition of poverty and distress,

although brought up in luxury and elegance, that, accord-

ing to the evidence produced in the extension cases, mother

and daughter had but one dress between them fit for pub-

lic and outdoor service, and when one went out the other

had to remain within. In addition, Mrs. Morse, whose

family was of the highest standing and wealth in Louisiana,

had been compelled to go into the fields and cultivate cot-

ton with her own hands and labor, in order to furnish ade-

quate supplies:for her family, everything in reach of their

once large possessions having been sold off or destroyed;

and it was in that condition that Mr. Morse commenced in

1870, and renewed his efforts in the latter part .of 1871 and

6

1872, to obtain extensions of his letters patent, the last

under my advice and with my aid, and, as stated in the

affidavit, under an act of Congress approved by General

Grant.

It seems to be my further duty to present to the

Court some facts showing the kind of persons with whose

rights they are dealing, in order that the Court may judge

properly whether as a part of the Government it would be

justified in refusing this continuance, after the Government

had been continuing and continuing for a generation, until

original patents, extensions, and life itself had come to an

end. When Mrs. Morse married Mr. Morseshe was the widow

of a United States Army officer, who died in the service,

and whose ancestors had served the Government in both the

Army and the Navy for many years; and as to her own

lineage, it was her own father who, in the great days of

Aaron Burr, Blennerhassett, and the Louisiana purchase, had

charge of the interests of the United States in taking and

maintaining possessiun of that part of the continent, and

it was a lady of her family who, with her own hands,

first drew to the top of the flagstaff and flung to the air the

United States flag, thereby typically bringing that purchase

into the Union and under the Constitution and laws of the

United States.

As to the subject-matters of these claims, the Morse inven-

tions, their history has been interwoven with the history

of the country from 1856 or ’57 and cannot be eliminated

therefrom, so far as the past is concerned, but are apparently

destined, as much as the work of any other man, to have

in the future to do with the preservation of the United

States Government. As early as 1858 they were the cause

ets Wi

ee SOE Me ag

- wenntiak an

eset ee

eatemielinntis eA iemiretnesteie cnet yegsten

of a controversy in the Senate, which it is believed then

sat in the chamber now occupied by the United States

Supreme Court, between Jefferson Davis and Judah P.

Benjamin, which for cays it was expected would end in a

duel likely to be fatal to one of the parties—a controversy

that might have affected the history of the United States in

important respects. If the Morse inventions had not been

suppressed by the United States Ordnance Department

during and throughout the war, the Morse inventions

might have made the war more short, sharp, and decisive,

but might have saved life and treasure and many other

things beyond calculation. But, on the other side and

in still further negative form, Mr. Morse and his inven-

tions did have directly to do with the preservation of the

Union in this way: Soon after the surrender of Fort

Sumter Mr. Morse was offered the command of the Fayette-

ville arsenal, in North Carolina, with authority to make his

guns for the Confederate army, at a time when the tools

and plans for making his rifle, that had been removed from

Harper’s Ferry, were within the control of the Con-

federate authorities and might have been turned over to

him for the manufacture of arms at Fayetteville. Later

these tools were placed in the control of Mr. Morse

and remained in his control till the end of the war.

It is in evidence in the extension cases, and a mat-

ter of knowledge in the possession of the Government,

that no arm of the type invented by Mr. Morse

was ever found on any one of the Southern battle-

fields, according to the testimony of the armorers, mechanics,

and machinists of the Washington arsenal and Springfield

armory, who not only knew Mr. Morse, but were familiar

with his inventions, and had with dread expected that soon

after the beginning of the war the Morse guns would be used

by the Confederate soldiers, but testified that it was a sub-

ject of conversation and wonder expressed between them,

when the arms were gathered in from the different battle-

fields, and particularly from the battlefields of Gettysburg,

that nowhere ‘among the thousands of arms gathered up

did they find a single gun of the Morse type. It will be

said by the Solicitor General that after the surrender Morse

arms were captured in South Carolina, and that specimens

of those arms are now in the Solicitor General’s possession.

Such, at least, is the fact, and admitted; but those arms

were made expressly, under contract, for use by the Home

Guard, composed mostly of aged men, for the protection of

women and children, in a portion of the State of South Caro-

lina; from marauders and criminals, and were not intended

for use and never were used against the United States Gov-

ernment or its soldiers.

It is impossible to go into full detail here, but the Morse

principle has been dramatic not only from birth, but from

and in its conception even, and seems to be destined to be so

to. the end, if its end ever comes. |

Mr. Morse found refuge and rest from the persecutions

and neglect of the United States Government in the grave

nine years ago; but his ideas in the field of invention are

marching on, and will continue to march on until wars

cease and the millennial reign comes. The armies of all

Europe are armed with guns the essential principle of which

is the idea and invention of Morse, as set forth in the pat-

ents involved in this controversy, and the European civiliza-

tions that eventually prevail, both on land and.on sea;-will

owe to him a debt which they can never pay and seem-

* ee aes

ingly may never recognize. The Morse idea is also march-

ing on, in, through, and around the entire continent of

Africa, carrying civilization with it, or at least behind

‘it, wherever it- goes. The same is true wherever civili-

zation of the present type is advancing thoughout the

world. And in our own country only two years ago, in the

city of Chicago, the authority of the courts of the United

States being overthrown in the persons of its marshals and

in the State militia called to their aid, it was only when the

United States troops appeared and were located by General

Miles with such admirable skill on the lake front that the

United States court began again to receive sia and ac-

customed respect.

It happened that almost if not quite in the. last train

that passed eastward from. Chicago out of the jaws of

that strike, that were at the moment closing and shut-

ting off communication, I was a passenger. It also

happened that I returned as a passenger to Chicago before

the strike was over, to find Genera] Miles with his small force

of United States troops, occupying the lake front and mak-

ing the Art Building, where the International Congresses had

met in 1893 to exhibit to the world the glory and perfection

of the American civilization, his center and possible citadel,

still held the mob at bay. Going among the soldiers. and

taking particular pains to examine their arms, it became

evident to me, as an expert, that every implement of the

nature of a fire-arm—whether carbines, pistols, muskets,

gatling guns, or rapid-fire guns—contained as.the controll-

ing, dominant factor, the Morse principle. And clearly, to

one who knew the history of the breech-loading fire-arm,

2

eS

it. was the: dead and unknown Morse and his idea that

overawed the mob, protected the court, its judges, officers

and process-servers, and the city, and. prevented a great

disaster and a great destruction of human life.

Under this state of facts and condition of affairs, can the

United States Government, as represented by. its law officers

or by its courts, low or high, afford to be harsh.or exacting

or to prevent all further effort on behalf of Morse, his widow,

his daughter, his descendants, and his own fame with the

present and future generations ?

As a citizen jealous of the reputation of my country for

justice and righteousness, having learned the early history

of the imperial implement from and through its inveutor

-and creator, I gave about twelve years of wretchedly unre-

-munerated service to Mr. Morse and his inventions. in order

_to aid in so informing the Government as to make impossi-

ble of continuance a great wrong to one of the greatest

inventors of this great inventive age; and after so many

years.more, I have returned to my place, under very trying

circumstances, rather as the friend of the Court than as the

_ attorney, either of the Morse Arms ‘Manufacturing Com-

pany, or of the inventor's aged widow, or of his sick daugh-

ter, to plead briefly ence more for justice and right

in this behalf; and, having done my duty to the best of

my ability and strength, I turn these two women over to

the tender mercies of this Court, with confidence that they

will receive due protection and will not be violently cut off

_ from the further prosecution of their rights.

And yet, knowing. that these two women are at. this

moment suffering in such a way that their constant prayer

_ js for death to come to their relief, 1 am not at all certain

arte

See ee ee

11

that if the Court could by its refusal to grant this motion

bring these women to execution and _to the termination of ©

their: lives and their struggle, it might not work the least

suffering and harm to them in the eud; but I am not will-

ing to become the instrument of heroic surgery and act the

part of executioner, nevertheless.

Iam informed that on his death-bed Mr. Morse, in ex-

pressing his last wish, pledged his wife and daughter to

continue the struggle to vindicate his reputation and fame

as the inventor of the modern breech-loading arm to the

end; and having an inheritance of gallant blood in their

veins from ancestors who for generations have served the

United States Government in arms, I have no doubt they

will maintain the struggle so long as life lasts. But having

: done my part as well as I know how, I can only leave to the

Court the final responsibility and opportunity, with full con-

fidence that it will decide justly in thé matter of this mo-

! tion, which, although only a motion, must, if denied, bring

this litigation to a close with what will be equivalent to an

adverse judgment, though without argument on the. merits,

since it will compel me to ask that this appeal be dismissed,

which, as I understand, must be done under the rule laid

down in the legal-tender case, 9th Wallace; and in that

event, such is my sense of the obligations imposed upon me

: by the strange circumstances that have brought me back

and put me in charge of the Morse claims again, that in the

| execution of my trust I shall, if life and strength permit,

appeal this case to the still higher courts of God and His-

| tory. ; v2

JAMES A. SHILTON,

Counsel for Appellant in this Motion.

SD ioe

RENE) SOONG SUOHURRERREREEINEN STII NURS ¢ bo nA CN Ie

ee Yar Taper mation t BB aoepahats eR WT Ag Ae nom ae 2

ees ¥ .

of met iS Y

Supreme Court of the Hnited

| Ocrosper Tzem, 1895.

—

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTOR-

ING COMPANY

\ No. 169.

v.

THE UNITED STATES.

-

Now comes the appellant, by its attorney, and moves the ©

court to postpone the hearing in this case, or a veitetionesearie |

until the next term of the Court. .

This motion is based on the death of Samuel A. Dunean,

the counsel of the company, who argued the case below and

was prepared to argue this appeal, and the facts set forth i in

the accompanying affidavits.

JAMES A. SKILTON,

Attorney for Appellant in this Motion.

: Dusresor or CoLuMBIA, 8 ;

‘ James A. Skilton, being duly sworn, deposes and says

that he resides in Brooklyn and has his office in the city of

_ New York, and has been retained by the appellant for the

purpose of making this motion.

The original claims upon which the petition filed in the

Court of Claims in this case was based, were for the ena j

=e ey lee

CRW RA Ota Se, BYE w

ieee oF Re eee Ere

» , De caeamianes a Lane

“iis “Pek or te ome sr ocarhectoteabemaiiiee lene terete eet tert ne a SAAS ieinenttenerententinenpaneenchnoetil ape ae

uty sencgel RP PUTS CAA EAS ranoason 3 +5 SS teh * ers slain seine ~ Fe Jor tginn sy »

anne Re

Me om

ya

—— ee

‘Daeber Caatenk, as.

‘Supreme Court of the United States.

Ocromes Teen, 1895.

a

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTUR- }

ING COMPANY |

+

vw.

THE UNITED STATES.

Now comes the appellant, by its attorney, and moves the

court to postpone the hearing in this case, or a continnanes,

until the next term of the Court. . | Be

This motion is based on the death of Samad A. Dunean, :

the counsel of the company, who argued the case below and —

was prepared to argue this appeal, and the facts set forth i in

the accompanying affidavits.

J AM ES A. SKILTON, _

Attorney for Appellant in this Motion. .

James A. Skilton, being, duly oem eg

New York, and has ae retained: ty. the 9 a

purpose of making this motion. —_—_

The ye elaine upon whirl the “3

ne pe kina

2 sige Pen eatemanncettaaen calorie rmomsnasseenuvaie;gmvomeeantesnpueraraanpenonamrveeserse CS TWEE Ge RRR fod eR”

Sat eG ae,

ei tremens — POM LISLE BLEED SIERO SSS he SOURIS ON LED LAINE AN PLN Re ea RA

N a Soaetetaaietins SNORE Veaeso mgt: iateaioeesnapoaiagl eraryomtiomaptty pronennlon The ste wha ee ose a x ay Mr?

WES ae OT

Supreme Court of the Eniter States.

‘Coronas Tame, 1895.

THE MORSE ARMS MANUFACTUR- a

ING COMPANY

vw.

THE UNITED STATES.

Now comes the appellant, by its attorney, and moves the

court to postpone the hearing in this case, or a continuance, |

until the next term of the Court. . ; an

This motion is based on the death of Samuel A. Dunean, 6

the counsel of the company, who argued the case belowand =

was prepared to argue this appeal, and the facts set forth i i.

the accompanying affidavits.

JAMES A. SKILTON,

Attorney for Appellant in this Motion. :

Districr-or CoLuMBIA, 88 ¢

James A. Skilton, being duly sworn, deposes and says oe

that he resides in Brooklyn and has his office in the city of

New York, and has been retained by the appellant for the See

purpose of making this motion.

The original claims upon which the petition filed in the 4

Court of Claims in this case was based, ‘were for the mek-

2

ing and using of certain inventions in breech-loading guns

and cartridges made by one George W. Morse, for which

he obtained certain letters patent of the United States in

the years 1856 and 1858, which inventions were, on invita-

tion and request of an authorized official of the Govern-

ment, submitted by the said George W. Morse, in the years

1857 and 1858, to certain boards, composed of ordnance ofti-

cers of the Government, at West Point, together with

inventions in breech-loading guns made by other inventors,

in competition. The board of 1858, althongh authorized by

Congress to “select and approve a model ” for breech-load-

ing gun and cartridges for adoption by the Government,

declined to select and adopt .a model, but selected the

Morse invention and model for the purpose of submission

to the test of use “ by troops in actual service,” because the

“Morse model included a new and untried principle.”

Whereupon the Secretary of War solicited and was given a

license to make and use 2,000 muskets under the said pat-

ents of the said Morse for the total sum of $10,000, being

at the rate of $5 per musket, and later another license.te—

make and use 1,000 carbines for the sum of $2,500, the total

amount received by said Morse therefor being $12,500.

The making of these muskets and carbines was entered

upon at the Springfield and Harper’s Ferry armories, and

proceeded under the general supervision of the said Morse,

and upon plans and models furnished by him, from which

drawings and tools for both muskets and carbines were

made, and accepted by the proper Government officials,

bat with constant modifications and delays made by Gov-

ernment officials and in the armories, so that when the war

of the rebellion began, in April, 1861, no arms had been

completed or tested, and all further attempts to complete

“and test by the Government were abandoned by it until July

“of 1866, when Secretary Stanton ordered the alteration of

NE ky OT Tae EI RO TP EOE SSE hee PP ae ee ee ee ee

3

25,000 rifled muzzle-loading muskets into “ hence os

of the best pattern,” which was done by = ne

inventions, but in an inferior way, in the absence and

without the knowledge of the said Morse, and ‘with —

results only partially satisfactory. Later, and by follow- —

ing more carefully the plans and instructions. of the ee

said Morse previously given, the arm known as the Spring-

‘field breech-loading rifle musket was made at the Springfie c

armory, with suitable cartridges, put into the hands of tr ane

in service, and reports from the field being made: thereon, ee

was submitted to the ordnance board of 1873, and was by

that board approved and adopted, the arm and the cartridges Ces =

therefor being in every minute particular like those invented

and patented to the said Morse, except as to the minor ue

feature of the fornt of the latch that locked and held wre

breech piece in place.

Meantime, during the war, modified beens and iodagane cae

tions of the Morse inventions had been-contrived and made

by private parties and companies and forced into. the hands =

of the troops by the people, and accepted by the Govern- __

ment: Some of them were in the hands of the troopetinder =

Sheridan at the finish at Appomatox, and contributed

greatly to the final result. Later the said: 1856, 14-year pat

ents of the suid Morse expired, extensions thereof having ae:

been refused on the ground that: Mr. Morse had been South, =~

where his home and all his property — dusty, the: war, es be

without explanation. Se

In 1871-72, under an act of Conan: approved ty oe

President Grant, said Morse renewed his applic tions

for extensions, on the ground of want of ade e rec

pense for his invention, and obtained the. extension o of t ie ace

three important patents out of five, including those of 1858.

After the adoption of the Springfield arm, in 1878, ¢f rt.

were made to secare on for the use of the Morse:

ene

a TTT WS

ee

ee ees

A ae Sete A

, 7 . x3 73s ye8oF) Bae 7 = — a , —— —_ _— , x 4 tee TE TS aif a 7 ” Tey 1 eteats p . , eo san « ee aging Dente ete Sth . q Vesa re oe ere

DE ee ee ee ARE ee cs ia setae te co ae - SS Ck TE ME OT ng gh zs nF yee “>. + oe ERR AON ES ed Py St Nl a OS Fl ie a) BA ae Gt HEN gg MA By) LL eR am rs oe ey EY cd SS ARR TANTS BoB lime Ne ae Ne Oi UE a i opm a od ‘s Ath ge k ne

" RARE i Re tg ES LS Bed ter RO tas ae ee a 6 PERCY ar Dr le tet hs SO of NOM HA pth Arn PIMMOY as Or OB ee BARS Oe SEAT Ft gain ee ARN page |e oe RES! SMES iy. Beal es Ne Raabe VES OLN SOLAN Za TEN NE SS MMA PLS CPE a BUC ee fa Pe RT| CERAM SBA * Re OT Sr ae

7 hE x Sie PGE PU PRS 4 a SAAT SRAVA gr Me Ley De Ph ae oe PR Ee ERGO ROR: es ea Lr WB ey AL NE Rs par Wa ge age LAE RAR hha cA odie PS cr Ae oN TS a i ARES So see a Bak al ES SNe 8 Ucar BENE AALS LEN PRAT CLES a Roa a fa MD a Ba Pe a See

SSS SRE PRI ES MLS Se PORMED . : y ; : ate. Poitates ‘ s - - ma ; i os

: ae ett ements A : 4 7 : ° ; aque = ae

\ ¥ f ‘ ¢ ‘4

ere

ae

| expert talent, to be acquired only by long preliminary train-

4

inventions therein, but failed for want of anthority in the

Ordnance Office and War Department to pay, and in Feb-

ruary, 1875, the first petition of claim. was filed in the Court

of Claims (December term, 1874, No. 10,270), and under

an order of the court a record, showing what had transpired

and been done by and between the said Morse and the War

Department, was produced and put in evidence on behalf of

Morse, to which reference is hereby made, in printed copy —

herewith, in confirmation of the facts stated herein. Copy

is marked Exhibit A, James A. Skilton, April 13, 1896.

Soon after, it is believed as early as 1876, the case was

entered npon the trial docket and pressed for hearing year

after year for many years, under this‘and other petitions,

in vain, until the hearing below in this case.

Among counsellors and attorneys retained and engaged

on behalf of the petitioner during this period were ex-judge

of the U.S. S. court B. R. Curtis, Benjamin F. Butler, of

Boston, ex-Judge Emott, of New York, Fisher and Duncan

and Tliomas J. Durant, all deceased, of whom all but one,

Samual A. Duncan, died before the vase could be brought

to a hearing. Mr. Duncan had been retained and occupied

in and about the various proceedings and litigations of these

patents, in the Patent Office and elsewhere, with intervals,

from May, 1871, toa day late in the year 1895, when he

also died, leaving no available counsel thoroughly informed

and competent, whose services could be obtained by the ap-

pellant, to argue this appeal at this term of the Court.

Meantime, practically the entire state of the art in all

lands and in all time since the invention of gunpowder had

been brought into the case, showing, indeed, a complete record

of futility and failure in all previous inventions, and none

of them in practical use, but requiring the most exacting

studies, often with experiments, and the highest qualities of

BOT OE ee ee ee

5

ing, to explain each one of the long list of them, and show .

why they failed, and why Morse succeeded, in closing the

breech joint by the use of fixed-ammunition cartridge cases

loaded with powder and ball, and primed.

And further, after devoting nearly forty years of his life

to the perfection of the imperial and supreme war imple-

ment of this age, and, prospectively, of the ages to come,

Mr. Morse himself joins the procession of his counsel to the

grave, in poverty and want, leaving those dependent on him

to the tender mercy of a Government he has so long faith-

fully served at its own request, to be paid chiefly by cruelty,

injustice, and neglect.

Still further, notwithstanding the fact that the Ordnance

Bureau asked to have the record on behalf of the petitioner

in case No. 10,270, December term, 1874, Court of Claims,

printed in excess of the usual number, to the extent of many

hundreds (copy of which has been made an exhibit herein),

to be used as an ordnance publication for distribution

throughout the [and and abroad in order to show that it

should have the credit of assisting to bring out the modern

breech-loader, because of what it did in making use of, and

testing or experimenting with the Morse inventions, another

branch of the Government, the Attorney-General’s ottice,

not familiar and not qualitied in the subject-matter as is that

Burean, seeks to follow this great inventor—upon whose in-

ventions the Government has already had to depend, even

to protect and sustain its courts, as in Chicago in 1894, and

will hereafter have to depend very likely for the continuance

of its own life and its own survival—into and beyond the

grave with a malignant and untiring purpose to take from

him even the name and fame that are his due in history.

There is, in-fact, in this case a greater issue than that of

a money claim or a claim for the honor of making an impe-

rial invention.. That question is whether this government

6

of the people, by the people, and for the people is compe-

tent and honest enough to deal justly with one of the peo-

ple who has rendered to it and to civilization a supreme

service, songht in vain to be rendered by many other in-

ventors, until now and here, in our day, the great feat has

been achieved in the inventions of Morse now before the

court.

It is indeed now claimed and held by the Government

that the modern breech-loading gun was invented aud made

in Europe by others, and not in America by Morse. But

no such European gun has been produced, nor has any wit-

ness been produced who has ever seen or tested any such

gun. And it is matter of universal public knowledge that

the first use of the modern breech-loader by European

troops was by the French, late in the war with Germany,

after Sedan, and consisted in the use of arms sold by the

‘Ordnance Bureau to the French through the Remington

agent, and for which the Burean made the cartridges ex-

pressly. Althongh the fact is not so publicly well known,

it is known to deponent, through information given to him

by the official head of the Byreau at the time of the “ French

arms scandal,” that the guns so sold and used were of the

25,000 ordered by Secretary Stanton in 1866, and injured

in the making, as above stated, but which contained the

Morse inventions. Later these same guns became the models

and instructors of all European nations, whose troops are

now, and since that time only have been, armed with breech-

loaders, made on what the West Point board of 1858 called

the “ Morse principle,” which it mentions at that time as

“the new and untried principle of a primed metallic car-

tridge,” p. 152.

It is confidently believed and urged that there is on record

no such monstrous history of injustice and wrong on the

part of any Government toward any inventor and imperial

rf

invention, as can be found in the history of. the dealings of

this Government for the past forty years with Mr. George

W. Morse and his inventions. And a half dozen, more or

less, of laboriously trained and eminent counsel having gone

hence during the last twenty-five and more years of tyran-

nical procrastination on the part of the defendant, it is urged

that the appellant, representing Mr. Morse and his inven-

tions, should not be now crowded to the wall by being forced

into a hearing in the absence of qualified counsel to pro-

tect its rights. And it is so urged for the very reason that

it would be a too fit and logical ending of at least twenty-

six years of cruel injustice inflicted op/an inventor merito-,

rious in the very highest degree. _£—

X

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 14th day of

April, 1896.

«

PEE

POR OETA GTO OI BGO RD NN ALON TN BRO ENEE ETE ETO

ee ae

aye

POSE Pig AIP OE.

en eee

Soe eT AT

Le A A ITT Es

- de pr ne aN FO OO AAALAC AS -

ee een nee opeereaemene mee nae arecom anon’ :

EET PL ROS LD AG LILLIA LLIGRLE PE AALES ALE» | SS IPT TN ONS NETS aA

. nar Nt LO AO SOA ET OTTTTT ee reg coen ceeeeeere ep oaaeale baie sprit

+ -

pak To GSN RE SE SS eae a oie Ske es

» at . an SS: Se mee f a

: } } <% ~

: es. os

/ PS

Fite

:

APR 16 189

JAMES H. McKENNEY, fb

oe

In the Supreme Gourt of the Wuited States, -

OcTOBER TERM, 1895.

THE MorsE ARMS MANUFACTURING

Company, appellant,

No. 169.

THE UNITED STATES. |

APPELLEE'S OBJECTIONS TO APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR A

CONTINUANCE.

‘The motion for a continuance, recently made by appel-

lant’s counsel in this case, is based on the death of Sam-

uel A. Duncan, a former counsel in this case. This event

occurred on or about October 20, 1895, since which time

nearly six months have elapsed, ample time within which

to secure counsel and have the case prepared for argument.

On March 6, 1896, appellant’s counsel asked to have

the Morse Case passed, if reached on the call, adding, “I

have a plan for disposing of the case, which I wish to

submit in person.” (See Exhibit A.) In consequence

of this request, the case was on March 17 passed on

appellee’s motion, subject to reinstatement under the

14729 ©

2

26th rule, appellant’s counsel joining in a request, filed

with the clerk, that the case be restored to the call on

the 13th instant.

On the 8th instant, in a letter stating that he was the

appellant’s attorney for the first ten or twelve years,

appellant’s connsel again expressed a desire “ to propose

a plan for dealing with the case, which I think will be

entirely satisfactory to you, without a hearing before the

United States Supreme Court.” (See Exhibit B.)

The affidavit of appellant’s counsel shows that he is

fully master of the facts in this case, as might be ex-

pected from his having been counsel therein for the first

' ten or twelve years, and hence, if he has neglected to

prepare for the coming argument, he is without excuse.

It seems, however, from his letter of the 8th instant, that

he does not desire any hearing of this appeal at all, and

hence, we submit, this motion, if granted, can only lead

to delay, without affecting the ultimate disposition of the

case. | |

_ The case has already been delayed, in deference to the

request of claimant’s counsel, and we submit that no sub-

stantial reason is shown for any further delay. Appel-

lant’s counsel should either file his brief and argue the

case, or he should allow it to be submitted on the appel-

16's brief, or lie should withdraw the appeal.

: CHARLES C, BINNEY,

Assistant Attorney,

HotmeEs ConrRAD,

Solicitor- General,

For Appellee.

ExuHisit A.

New York, March 6, 1896.

Sir: I have just been retained in the Morse Arms Case.

At the same time I am served with a notice to attend the

taking of testimony in a case in Missouri on the morning

of the 12th instant, and my relations to the case are such

that I can not substitute another attorney in my place.

From the state of the calendar, I presume the Morse

Case will be called during the coming week, if not early

in the week. I have to start for Missouri on Tuesday,

and can not, therefore, easily reach Washington in person

to arrange for a disposition of the case before going West.

I hope to be back by the 16th. Have you any objection

to holding the Morse Case, if it is called, until I can see

you, between the 16th and the 20th? Please let me know

by telegram to-morrow, and also by letter on the same

date. I have a plan for disposing of the case which |

wish to submit in person.

Respectfully, yours, ?

JAMES A. SKELTON.

Hon. HoLMEs ConRAD,

Solicitor-General, Washington, D. C.

EXHIBIT B.

New York, April 8, 1896.

s tims In reply to your letter of April 6: I have been.

disabled with grip since I last wrote you, and have there-

fore been delayed in completing my plans for dealing with

the case of the Morse Arms Manufacturing Company v.

The United States, No. 169, as-expected. :

I was the attorney for the Morse Arms Company for

the first ten or twelve years, but have not approved of

the method of dealing with the cases that has been fol-

lowed during the last ten years.

I expect to be in Washington on Friday morning, and

to call upon you in person, prepared to propose a plan

for dealing with the case, which I think will be entirely

satisfactory to you, without a hearing before the United

States Supreme Court. I regret that I have been una-

ble to do this at an earlier date, as originally none

Respectfully, yours,

JAMES A, Sikigirce:

Hon. Hotmes Conran,

Solicitor-General, Washington, D. C.

4 ice .

eo)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.