Record and brief — Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer, Appellants, vs. Albert Graff and J. F. Donnell
Supreme Court brief1889
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD. -
wee eee ee ae ee ee
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1889.
No. 1408.
EMILE BOESCH AND MARTIN BAUER, APPELLANTS,
US.
ALBERT GRAFF AND J. F. DONNELL.
—
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA.
FILED OCTOBER 18, 1889.
Bill
Suby
Ame
Subr
Mars
Ansv
Repl
Inter
Mast
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 18330.
No, 1408,
EMILE BOESCH AND MARTIN BAUER, APPELLANTS,
US.
ALBERT GRAFF AND J. F. DONNELL.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA.
INDEX.
Original. Print.
aa sesh ine ee nsak o-akeh sce = wan etch emai shea l
Subpeena and i Ww
te Se Oe PRE iii oe 5 5 a ois 5 ew ned nce es 11
FN ia ial aii wi sic ss es Sealant ieee tence an wer omg cei 1)
Marshal’s return .-_~---- i aliibcs acts esalisbaabidiaabeiinacenaiebiniiig. sailing shania 20
—— pew
wi m= pe CF 2] ay
oe ode acs teed «> Se Saeae eiee esk se eh Se wn 20 l
ii cel Sabi Me eRe wee ws oiige ae wince 21 l
EE SILL LOPLI LLL MEO OTE ae L5
a a cand é 0k pain kh ow Annie ee daa 25 7
ai calh ck sane ms wien eon 26 17
Se tr I ooo sk ne See nn a eenen owes of 23
meron OF Mme Boece ........ 5 ow. +e. 2s. Ot 2
RN io ok os eee ll 53 30
Pete TETOE . .w kn oc | se own Pee as $5
I a clk wes iota welsel ean Wikia elves 4 L7
I A I I i i os ee 64 47
Evidence for complainants ee a ie ee eT a ek ag ae rate’ 50
I I iio vies 6 knoe a nena ~~ Hs BS “1
Jupn & Derwetter, PRINTERS, Wasuinaron, NoVEMBER 6, [TSS9
INDEX.
Complainants’ Exhibit, Exporters’ Statement.—Account._-.----
Complainants’ Exhibit Cireular.—Circular letter of A. S. Graff &
ieee een saa wane”
Complainants’ Exhibit Defendant’s Bill.— Bill of Emil Boesch to
Alta Publishing Company, February 28, 1886_ .---. ----------
Complainants’ Exhibit Defendant’s Business Card.—Business card
OF ne OD vicn standin dosandnens pki ated om ens
axcentions 60 mebster’s report ._....... ...... 5... -- 0. ++ 2 enone
Order everruling exceptions to master’s report ._--------------------
EE LEELA DEE DOE ENT Cte OLE TRAE AEE AN OR
NE iin! rcks sie enkns HRN SONNE R Rema O eons vee Pern
Memorandum of costs and disbursements... -.--------------------
Evidence for complainants ._....... 2. 22onn 6 sn woe 2s cee we -
Destimeny OF Altred Ww Bt0kt |. on 6 en oe ewes cece ewen
Oe PD Bes RONG signs hciccinn ccc cwsinsmcese ne
NN Te icinitncncaicccn engine oo assenene
ee i ee
Se i sic nik ern sichialnn asia ienenettinns since io ar irene 1
ee TIE a ince cnn wn vaneme mint enna
Evidence for respondents ~--~--- nities i halen lac sicnh sag te sehen
A OE OTR IE 8. 8 on hier ewe ee minonconcenaene
NE iain ani ire cane emp aiineome
Albert Graf (resumed@) ..... ........ ..-...--.. .-..
Martin Bauer (resumed) ------------ aieeteiaiaiig toads
ees Sor COMIIIRANES . . .. .. . none ne weenie ncieones soce
I OG Tt IT oc ice science ctinnn-c ne seme o<ne
iii ian scr eninn eine s+ nenome
Ribert Geral (roontied) ........-. 2.6 nencccsene
Complainants’ Exhibit E.—Assignment from Wilhelm Graff to Albert
EE ich ene H enna he Sine sen mewn ne
Complainants’ Exhibit F.—Assignment from Carl Schwintzger to
I Ny URS Giulia is che a nee cee Caen mmae
Complainants’ Exhibit H.—Translation of German decree, &e__-_--_-
I.—Decree of C. C. U.S., District of Califor-
nia, in care Schwintzer et al., vs. Wagenheim
Ps ia So rabenciin: hia Se 5s Site idan lintanss~ citlp. so teens
Respondent’s Exhibit 2.—Translation of German opinion, &e._-___. —
3.—Declaration of Wilhelm Herrman Hecht___
Declaration of Robert Koeppen _____-____-
5.—Contract between Carl Schwintzer and Al-
| Oe ene
Substitution of attorneys for complainants___.---......2--- 22.
SN TE NS isi, <r eae code een n ids knwooneeces
i aces Mick A slny 0 ah nite Ai ais weavers we
I ei ae ct canta wikeiieni name “
ald ie wah nk mcs ce mmices
a us aaa cama eee abel i gsc ailt ips sia Rea
I i
Complainants’ Exhibit A.—Letters patent No. 289,571 granted Carl
Schwintzer et al., December 4, 1883 .................._.....___..
Complainants’ Exhibit D.—Assigninent of Wilhelm Graff to Albert
I ;
Complainants’ Exhibit G.—Document in German. __.-._. 6.
Original.
68a
69
10
yo} 3 +1
Ci hm tO
GH
oe
ND
pan
ao
on
89
Print.
51
O38
ao asaanrckmnn oc tr °:
do Mwowmeaaadr ea i.
J
~~,
INDEX.
Respondent’s Exhibit 1.—Document in German -_-.-_-- ~~~ -- 2+. -
4.—Document in German ._______.__--2----
pn Ue i ed ee on ees hs ans oe ew in cco eee
en Re I shi i cane od ous sw dw dwn ae
Nee is si s'ue'ns wine ams “nocache
i ins ws ews ee ene wee ea
i ie nwt wae wm mer adenine
i a icine om ee onueunce
Re UU ic. ke enna a
I a in wes atl imen
Order denying petition for rehearing-_._..-.--..-.-..___.----.----
Original.
212
ITI
Print.
148
156
158
158
160
16]
162
165
164
165
166
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 1
bill of Complaine.
In the Cireuit Court of the United States in and for the Ninth
Judicial Circuit, Northern District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF and J. F. DoNNELL, Complainants,
US. In Equity.
EMILE Borscu, Defendant.
To the honorable the judges of the cirenit court of the United States
for the ninth circuit within and for the district of California :
8
Albert Graff, a resident of the eity and county of San Francisco,
in the State of California, and a citizen of said State and of the
United States, and J. F. Donnell, a resident of the city and county
of New York, in the State of New York, and a citizen of said State
and of the United States, bring this their bill against Emile Boesch,
a resident and citizen of the city and county of San Francisco,
State of California.
And thereupon your orators complain and say that heretofore and
before the 14th day of November, 1879. one Carl Schwintzer and Wil-
helm Graff, subjects of the King of Prussia, German Emperor, both
residing at the city of Berlin, Prussia, Germany, were the true, orig-
inal, and first inventors or discoverers of a certain new and useful in-
—_ vention, to wit, an improvement in lamp burners, of that class in
which a series of wick tubes — arranged equidistantly from the
axis of the burner and moved up and down in a series of guide
tubes, the burners of said class being known by the name of “ Mit-
trailleuse ” burners; and the invention consists of a ring-sh: aped
cap arranged at the upper part of fixed guide tubes, said eap
being provided with openings for the wicks. The pinion by
which the wicks and wick tubes are adjusted is placed entirely
within an annular casing of the burner, and is rendered accessible
by a detachable ring at the lower part of said casing. The actual
Pinion engages ar ack bar that is attached by an inwardly extend-
Ing arm to the center of the bottom plate of the wick tubes, said
rack being located between two adjoining wick tubes. The bottom
: plate of the wick tubes is provided with a hinged stop device, so as
. to prevent the wick tubes from projecting above the guide tubes,
and thereby avoid the burning of hooks arranged at the upper end
} of the wick tubes. And that letters patent have heretofore been
A granted to them by the Government of Germany, No, 10621, dated
' November 14th, 1879; No. 10846, dated January 15th, 1880, and
} No. 11718, dated Mareh 26th, 1580, and that the satd invention was
r not known or used by others before their invention or dis-
! 2 covery thereof, and was not at the time of the application
for letters patent therefor in public use or sale with the con-
° sent or allowance of sail Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff, as the
inventors or discoverers thereof, contrary to the provisions of the stat-
utes of the United States in such case made and provided ; that, being
1—1405
[erreeees wen ea
? EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
fa
such inventors so as aforesaid, the said Carl Seliwintzer and Wil-
helm Graff made application in writing to the Commissioner of
Patents of the United States for the granting of letters patent for
said invention in accordance with the then existing laws of Con-
gress and duly complied in all respects with the conditions and re-
quireinents of said laws.
That on the 4th day of December, A. D. 1885, letters patent of
the United States, bearing date on that day, were issued to the said
Car] Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff in due form of law, under the
seal of the Patent Office of the United States, signed by the Secre-
tary of the Interior and countersigned by the Commissioner of Pat-
ents of the United States, and numbered 289,571, whereby there
was granted to them, their heirs, executors, administrators, and as-
signs, for the term of fourteen years from the fourth day of Decetn-
ber, 1555, the full and exclusive right and liberty of making, con-
structing, using, and vending to others to be used the invention or
discovery aforesaid, a description whereof was given in the words of
the said Carl schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff in the schedule an-
nexed to the said patentand was made part of the same.
That by regular assignments made in writing and recorded in
the United States Patent Office an equal one-half interest in all the
rights and privileges by said patent conferred was granted, assigned,
and conveved by said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff to J. F.
Donnell, one of the complainants herein, the said assignment being
made to J. Ff. Donnell in the firm name used by him in his busi-
ness—viz., J. I’. Donnell & Co.—prior to the 4th day of December,
1883.
That by regular assignments made in writing and recorded in
the United States Patent Office the remaining one-half. interest of
said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff in said letters patent
issued to said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff and J. I’. Don-
nell as aforesaid and in and to all the rights and privileges by said
patent conferred was granted, assigned, and conveyed by said Carl
Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff to Albert Graff, one of the
v plaintiffs herein, prior to the 23rd day of April, 1885, since
which date last named the plaintiffs herein have been and
still are the exclusive owners of said letters patent and of all the
rights, liberties, and privileges by said letters patent granted and
conferred. | :
That from the time of the granting to Carl Schwintzer and Wil-
helm Graff of said letters patent until the assignment of the interest
in sald patent to J. If. Donnell and Albert Graff, the complainants
herein as aforesaid, the said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff put
said invention into use by making, using, and vending the same to
others, and since the date of said assignments to J. I’. Donnell and
Albert Graffas aforesaid your orators have been hitherto constantly
engaged in manufacturing and using and selling to others to be
used the said invention and improvement in lamp burners, to their
great advantage; and your orators further show that said letters
patent granted as aforesaid by the Government of Germany have
been in controversy before the superior court of justice at Berlin,
——-
AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
EMILE BOESCH ET
department two, criminal, in an action and suit founded thereon
wherein The King of Prussia was plaintiff and Julius Eckel
defendant; that said action came on for trial before said court at a
session of February oth, in the year 1885. Said defendant was rep-
resented by counsel and vigorously contested said action, denying
the infringement of said letters patent and denying the novelty of
the invention therein described, and attempted to prove that the
same had been previously known to and used by said Julius Eekel
at Berlin.
That said suit was argued by counsel at said term,and thereupon,
upon consideration thereof, decision was rendered in said suit de-
creeing that said letters patent were valid and that the defendants
had infringed the same, and sentencing him to pay the costs of court
anda fine of 200 marks, and in the event of failure to pay said fine
that he be imprisoned one day for each ten marks of said penalty,
and empowering said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelm Graff to take
possession of the burners under seizure.
And your orators have ever since the date of the assignment of
sald letters patent been and now are entitled to all the rights, in-
terest, and privileges thereby secured unto them in and to the said
invention or discovery in the said letters patent and assignments,
and are and ever since said date have been entitled to the exclusive
use of said invention and improvement. |
4 And your orators further show unto your honor that, so
being the owner of said letters patent and invention and of
all the rights and privileges granted and secured thereby, they have
expended and invested large sums of money, have been put to great
expense and trouble in and about said invention and for the pur-
pose of having the business of making and selling said invention
profitable to themselves and useful to the public; that said inven-
tion has been of very great utility and useful to the public, that the
same has been extensively introduced into public use, and that the
public have generally acquiesced in your orators’ exclusive right to
the same, and your orators would, but for the wrongful acts of said
defendants and others acting in concert with him, have made large
gains, profits, and advantages from the manufacture, sale, and use
of said invention so patented as aforesaid, and your orators would,
but for the wrongful acts and doings of the said defendant and others
acting In coneert with him, now be enabled to use the said inven-
tion to which they are entitled to the exclusive right as aforesaid
and with profit and advantage, but that by thes aid wrongful acts
and doings they are now prevented and hindered from so doing.
And your orators further show unto your honor, on information
and belief, that the said defendant, well knowing the premises and
rights and privileges secured unto your orators as aforesaid, but con-
triving to injure your orators, and in order to deprive them of al!
profits and benefits and advantages which might and otherwise
would accrue to them from said invention after said assignments of
said letters patent as aforesaid and before the commencement of this
action, without the license or allowance of vour orators or either
of them and against the will of your orators or either of them and
4 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AT.
without right to make, use, and sell and procure to be made,
used, and sold: has ever since the first day of May, 1885, within the
city of San I rancisco and elsewhere within the State of California,
and at various other places in the United States, unlawfully
and wrongfully made and used and sold or caused to be made,
used, or sold) Jaimp burners each and all containing
5 suid invention, discovery, Improvement, and combinations
described and claimed in said letters patent—
Ist. By the employment or use of the combination with the guide.
tubes of a ring-shaped cap provided with openings for the wicks,
such cap being ap plied to the upper ends of the guide tubes so as to
close the intermediate spaces between the same, for the purpose
described.
2nd. By the employment of the combination of fixed guide tubes,
a series of wick tubes moving therein, a rack for actuating the same
arranged at one side thereof,a pinion for engaging the rack, and an
annular inclosing casing made of a fixed portion, and a detachable
ring section, for the purpose described. |
ord. bv the employ ment of a system of wiek tubes connected by
a bottom plate, a series of guide tubes, means for raising or lowering
the wick tubes, as for the purposes described, the exclusive right to
which is secured to your orators as above set forth, and which said
unlawful use and sale by the defendant as aforesaid Is a violation
and infringement of your orators’ rights and privileges, and the said
defendant stil continu 's to use and Keep In use such lamp burners
within thea id city and at other places and threatens to con-
tinue to use and make and sell the same and cause the same to be
made, used, and sold, all in defiance of the rights acquired and
secured to your orators as aforesaid, to their great and Irreparable
loss and injury, by wit ie has been and still is being deprived of
oreat eains and protits which he might and otherwise would have
obtained, but shit have been received and enjoved and are being
received and enjoyed by the said defendant, and through his abite-
said unta W ful rane “ts OL doings, whereby Vour orators have been vreatly
damaged and : lifered great Loss, and from whieh said use said
defendant has derived and received and ts still der riving and recelv-
Ing great gains and profits, but to hat amount yeur orators are
lvnerant and cannot set forth, De Your orators bel lev © the Same to
he about the full sum of two thousand dollars, and so charge the
fact to be and prav that the defendant nhiny be required to m ake a
and profits, which said gains and
ay ae your orators are, OV virtue of | the act of Congress in such ease
seach anc ee entitied to have and recover from tlhe said
. BT ; ' . , +? ’ .
ruil «liseiosure of all sueh onAins
. Caeee
6 ae ud your orators in like manner aver that the defendant,
en? requested to desist from such unlawful use and to
pay your orators such guin sand profits as the defendant has actu-
ally Ura le, refuses so to do, by means whereof your orators are and
have been greatly injured and are now prevented from putting the
said invention or discovery into successful operation and ware de-
oa? _— OE oe OE GI Se ae ie ’ Ait
prived and prevented from receiving the gains and profits tu which
=
FMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 2
they are lawfully entitled from the exclusive rights and privileges
so granted and secured to them as aforesaid and which they would
have derived and acquired and would now derive and acquire but
for said wrongful acts of the said defendant. 3
And your orators further say that the use of said invention by
said defendant and his preparation for and avowed determination
to continue the same and his other aforesaid unlawful act in dis-
regard and defiance of the rights of your orators have the effeet to
encourage and induce others to venture to infringe said letters patent
in disregard to your orators’ rights; and forasmuch as your orators
can have no adequate relief except in this court, to the end, therefore,
that the said defendant may, if he ean, show why your orators should
not have the relief hereby prayed for—
Your orators pray that the defendant may upon his oath, aceord-
‘ing to his utmost knowledge, information, and belief, all true, direct,
and perfect answers make to the premises and to all the several
matters hereinbefore stated and charged as fully and particularly
as if severally and separately interrogated as to each and every of
said matters, and especially that said defendant answer and set forth—
First. Whether the said Carl Schwintzer ana Withelm Graff were
not, prior to the 14th dav of November, 1879, the true, first, and orig-
inal inventors or discoverers of the said Invention or discovery
described in said letters patent and every mate rial part thereof, and,
if not, who was or were the true, original, or first inventor or in-
ventors of the same; and if any other person or persons was or were
the true, first, and original inventors of the same, where he or they
reside and where and when he or they invented or discovered the
same, and how the invention or discovery of such other person or
persons, if any, differed, ifat all, from the said invention or discovery
of said Carl Schwintzer and Wilhelin Graff.
fi Seeond. Whether the said defendant has at any time and,
if so, where and when made, sold, used or caused to be made,
sold, or used any lamp burner or burners having, employing, or
using a series of wick tubes arranged equidistantly from the axis of
the burner and moved up and down ina series of guide tubes, as
and for the purpose described in said letters patent; or, if the lamp
burners differed from those described in said letters patent, in what
particulars they differed therefrom or in what respect they were dif-
ferently applied or combined from those described in -said letters
patent, if at all.
Third. Whether the lamp burner or burners now in use by the:
defendant was and is not substantially similar to the lamp
burner described in said letters patent; and, if not, how the
same differs therefrom.
Fourth. Whether the defendant has not made large gains and
profits from the use of such lamp burners; and, if so, to what
amount.
And your orators pray that the said defendant may be compelled
bv a decree of this honorable court to account for and pay over to
your orators the gains and profits by him acquired and the dam-
ages suffered by your orators from the aforesaid unlawful acts.
6 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. AIL-BERT GRAFF ET AL.
And your orators pray that the said defendant, Emile Boesch, and .§
his servants, agents, attornies, and workmen and each and every of if
them may be restrained and enjoined by the order and injunction 7
of this honorable court from directly or indirectly making, con-
structing, using, vending, delivering, or putting in use any lamp
burner made in accordance therewith or like or similar to those
which he has heretofore made, and from making or using or vend-
ing any lamp burners similar or substantially similar to those de-
scribed and claimed in said letters patent,as he has heretofore made
or used or sold, and that said defendant may be decreed to pay the
costs of this suit, and that your orators may have such other and
further relief as to this honorable court shall seem meet, just, and
shall be agreeable to equity. 3 : |
May it please your honor to grant unto your orators the writ of
injunction issuing out of and under the seal of this nonorable court 1
commanding, enjoining, and restraining the said Emile Boesch, his
agents, servants, attornies, and workmen, and each and every
8 of them, as is hereinbefore in that behalf prayed ; and also to
grant unto your orator the writ of provisional or preliminary
injunction restraining the defendant, Emile Boesch, his servants,
agents, attornies, and workmen and each and every of them, from
the use and sale of said invention during the pendency of this
action. May it please your honor to grant unto your orators the i
writ of subpoena issuing out of and under the seal of this honorable Re -
court, directed to the said defendant, Emile Boesch, commanding
him by a certain penalty to be and appear in this honorable court,
then and there to answer the premises and to stand and abide by
such order and decree as may be made against him.
And your orators will ever pray.
WM..H. SHARP,
: Solicitor for Complainants.
D. W. DOUTHITPT, Of Counsel.
9 Verification to Bill of Complaint.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, | __.
District of California, ts
Albert Graff, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that he is
one of the complainants in the foregoing bill of complaint named ;
that he has read the within and foregoing bill of complaint and
knows the contents thereof; that the same is true of his own knowl-
edge except as to the matters which are therein stated on his in-
formation or belief, and as to those matters that he believes it to be
true.
ALBERT GRAFF.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 17 day of September,
1886.
[SEAL] JAMES. L. KING,
Notary Public.
Endorsed: Filed September 17, 1886. . L. S. B. Sawyer, clerk.
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET ATL.
10 Subpunda.
UNITED SratkEs OF AMERICA:
Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern District
of California. In Equity.
The President of the United States of America to Emile Boesch,
Greeting :
You are hereby commanded that you be and appear in said cir-
cuit court of the United States aforesaid, at the court-room in San
Francisco, on the first day of November, A. D. 1886, to answer a
‘bill of complaint exhibited against you in said court by Albert
Graff, a citizen of the State of California, and J. F. Donnell, wiro is
a citizen of the State of New York, and to do and receive what the
said court shall have considered in that behalf; and this you are
not to omit under the penalty of five thousand dollars.
Witness the Honorable Morrison R. Waite, Chief Justice
[seAL.] of the Supreme Court of the United States, this 17th day
of September, in the year of our Lord one thousand elght
hundred and eighty-six, and of our Independence the 111th.
L. S. B. SAWYER, Clerk.
Memorandum pursuant to Rule 12, Supreme Court U. S.
You are hereby required to enter your appearance in the above
suit, on or before the first Monday of November next, at the clerk’s
office of said court, pursuant to said bill; otherwise the said bill will
be taken pro confesso. ~
L. S. B. SAWYER, Clerk.
I have been unable, after diligent search, to find the within-named
defendant in my district.
San Francisco, Oct. 19, 1886.
J. ©. FRANKS,
U. 8. Marshal,
By W. L. McEWEN, Deputy.
Endorsed: Filed October 19th, 1886. L.S. B. Sawyer, clerk, by
F’. D. Monckton, deputy clerk.
11 Amended: Bill of Complaint.
In the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern
District of California. ©
To the honorable the justices of the circuit court aforesaid, sitting
in equity :
Albert Graff, a citizen of the State of California, and J. F. Don-
nell, a citizen of the State of New York, by leave of court first had
and obtained, make and file this their amended bill of complaint
against Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer, residents of the city and
county of San Francisco, State of California, and thereupon your
orators complain and say—
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
That heretofore, to wit, on or prior to the 28th day of July, A. D.
1883, Carl Schwintzer and William Graff, subjects of the King of
Prussia, German [mperor, residing at the city of Berlin, Prussia,
Germany, were the joint, original, and first inventors of a certain
new and useful invention, to wit, a lamp burner.
That said invention had reference to an improved lamp burner
of that class in which a series of wick tubes are arranged equidis-
tantly from the axis of the burner and moved up and down ina
series of guide tubes, the burners of said class being known by the
name of “ Mitrailleuse ” burners, and the invention consisted of a
ring-shaped cap arranged at the upper part of fixed guide tubes, said
cap being provided with openings for the wicks; which said inven-
tion is more particularly described in the United States letters
patent hereinafter referred to.
That the same was a new and useful invention and was not
known or used in this country prior to the application for a patent
therefor hereinafter mentioned, and had not been in public use or
on sale for two years nor abandoned nor proved to have been aban-
doned.
That the said Carl Schwintzerand William Graff, being so as afore-
said the inventors thereof, did, prior to the 28th day of July, 1883,
for value received, sell, assign, transfer, and ‘deliver unto your ora-
tor J. F. Donnell, (doing business under the firm name of J. F. Don-
nell & Co.) the undivided one-half of all their right, title, and
interest in and to said invention; that said sale and = assign-
ment was made and evidenced by an instrument in writing
12 duly executed by the said Carl Schwintzer and William Graff
under their handsand seals; which said instrument in writing
was, prior to the said 28th day of July, 1855, duly filed for record and
recorded in the Patent Office ef the United States, at Washington,
with a request that any patent that might be granted for said inven-
tion by the Government of the United States should be granted
and issued to Carl Schwintzer, William Graff, and J. I. Donnell &
Co.
That thereafter, to wit,on the 28th day of July, A. D. 1883, s said Carl
Schwintzer and William Graff and J. F. Donnell made application
to the Government of the United States for the granting and issu-
ance to them of letters patent of the United States for said inven-
tion.
That prior to the said iast-named date letters patent for said in-
ventiun had been granted to the said Carl Schwintzer and William
Graff by the Government of Germany, being numbered and dated
as follows, to wit: No. 10621, dated November 14, 1879; No. 10546,
dated January 13, 1880, and No. 11713. dated March 26, 1880.
That such proceedings were duly and regularly had and taken by
the Patent Office of the United States in the matter of the said ap-
plication; that thereafter, to wit,on December 4, 1883, after due
application, letters patent were granted and issued by the Govern-
ment of the United States to the said Carl Schwintzer, William
Graff, and J. F. Donnell & Co. for the said invention, er: iting unto
them, their heirs and assigns, for the term of seventeen years from
/
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. | 4)
the 4th day of December, 18838, the exclusive right to make, use, and
vend the said invention throughout the United States and Terri-
tories, subject to the limitation preseribed by section 4587 of the
Revised Statutes of the United States by reason of said German
patents dated November 14, 1879, No. 10621, and January 13, 1880,
No. 10846, and March 26, 1880, No. 11713, hereinbe fore mentioned.
That the shortest term for which any one of said three German
patents was granted was the term of 15 years from the 14th day of
November, 1879.
That said letters patent of the United States were issued in due
form of law under the seal of the Patent Office of the United States
and were signed by the Secretary of the Interior and. countersigned
by the Commissioner of Patents; which said letters patent were and
are numbered No. 289,571 and bear date the 4th- day of De-
13 cember, A. D. 1883, and are ready in court to be produced by
— - your orators, or a duly authenticated copy thereof.
That prior to the issuance of said letters patent all proceedings
were had and taken which were required by law to be had and
taken prior to the issuance of letters patent for new and useful in-
ventions.
That thereafter and before the filing of this bill of complaint, by
a regular chain of assignment made in writing by the said Carl
Schwintzer and William Graff and ‘recorded in the Patent Office of
the United States, at Washington, all the right, title, and interest of
the said Carl Schwintzer and William Graff in and to said United
States letters patent No. 289,571, the same being the undivided one-
half of the entire interest and property in said “United States letters
patent, and the rights and privileges by them granted became vested
In your orator, Albert Graff, as by said assigninents ora duly au-
thenticated copy thereof, which are ready here in court to be pro-
duced, will fully appear; that by virtue of said assignments your or-
ators becaine, ever since have been, and now are the sole and ex-
clusive owners and holders of said United States letters patent. No.
259,071 and of all the rights, liabilities, and privileges by them
granted and conferred.
And your orators further show unto your honor that since they
becaine the owners thereof as aforesaid they have invested and ex-
pended large sums of money and have been to great trouble and
expense In and about said invention and for the purpose of Intro-
ducing the same and carrying on the business of making and selling
said lamp burners and of making the same profitable to themselves
and useful to the public; that said invention has been and is of great
benefit and advantage and valuable to your orators, and large quan-
tities of lamp burners have been made according to said invention
and sold by your orators, to the great advantage of the public, and
that the public have generally acknowledged and acquiesced in the
validity of said letters patent, and your orators believe that they will
realize and receive further and large gains and profits therefrom if
the infringements by the respondents hereinafter set up shall be
prevented.
2—1408
10 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
And vour orators further show that they have not granted licenses
to any person whatever to manufacture or sell lamp burners made
according to said invention, but bave adopted as their chosen mude
of enjoying said invention and the right and liberties con-
14 ferred by said letters patent and reserved to themselves the
exclusive monopoly of making and supplying the market
and selling to others lamp burners made according to said Invention,
and your orators are fully able to supply the demand therefor.
And your orators further show unto your honors that after the
granting of the several German letters patent hereinbefore mentioned
one Julius Eckel, of Berlin, Germany, infringed upon thesame, and
thereupon Carl Sehwintzer and William Graff, the owners of said
German letters patent, caused the said Julius Eckel to be prosecuted
in the 2nd department (criminal) of the royal superior court of
justice at Berlin, having jurisdiction in the premises, for and on ac-
count of his said infringement; that the said Eckel appeared in said
action and made appropriate answer and defense therein, whereby
he attacked the validity of said letters patent and denied the novelty
of the invention therein contained and denied that the said
Schwintzer and Graff were the inventors thereof; that the issues so
Joined came on regularly to be tried before said court, and witnesses
were examined and evidence heard and considered ; and thereafter,
to wit, on the oth day of February, 1585, a judgment and decision
was duly and regularly made and entered in said action by said
court, wherein and whereby it was adjudged and decreed that the
sald German letters patent were good and valid; that the said
Schwintzer and Graff were the inventors of the invention therein
contained ; that the said Julius Eckel had infringed upon the same,
and that he be sentenced to pay the costs of court and a fine of 200
-marks; that said judgement has never been altered, modified, or re-
versed, and is in full force and effect. |
That the court rendering said judgment was a court of general
Jurisdiction having a clerk and a seal and had jurisdiction under
the imperial patent laws of Germany to hear and determine all con-
troversies arising under said laws to the same extent as the circuit
courts of the United States have jurisdiction to hearand determine
controversies arising under the patent laws of the United States :
that the said prosecution was had and conducted under said impe-
rial patent laws and in accordance therewith, aud the said judgment
as to the validity of said German letters patent is of the same force
and etfect under said imperial patent laws as a judgment in an action
at law or a decree in a suit in equity for the infringement of
15 United States letters patent in a circuit court of the United
States is or could be under the patent laws of the United
States. ;
And your orators further show unto your honors that the in-
vention claimed, described, and protected in and by said German
letters patent and passed upon and adjudicated in and by the prose-
eution aforesaid against Julius Eckel is identically the same inven-
tion claimed, described,and protected in and by the aforesaid United
States letters patent No. 289,571.
EMILE BOESCH ET AI. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AM. 11
And your orators further show unto your honors that heretofore,
to wit, on the — day of , 1885, vour orators herein and Carl
Schwintzer and William Graff. being then the owners of said United
States letters patent No. 289,571, commenced an action at law in
this honorable court against Amiel W angenheim and Samuel Stern-
heim as defendants to recover damages of and from them for an al-
leged infringement of said United States letters patent ; that the de-
fendants in that action having been duly and regularly served with
process and having failed to appear and answer the complaint
therein in the time allowed by law and ‘having knowingly and
designedlvy admitted and acknowledged the validity of said United
States patent and being unable to make any bona fide attack upon
its validity, their default was duly entered, and thereafter, to wit,
on March 11,1885, a judgment in said action was duly made, given,
and entered in favor of the plaintiffs therein and against the de-
fendants therein for the costs of the suit and such damages as the
plaintiffs had sustained by reason of the infringements aforesaid
by said defendants; that said judgment has never been changed,
altered, modified, or reversed, and is still in full foree and effect.
— And your orators allege, on information and belief, that the publie
generally have acquiesced in the adjudications aforesaid and have
acknowledged and acquiesced in the validity of said United States
letters patent and the rights, privileges, and liberties of vour orators
thereunder and under the assignments thereof as aforesaid, and but
for the infringements of the respondents herein your orators would
be in the enjovment of the exclusive monopoly granted and con-
ferred by said United States letters patent; and vour orators fur-
ther show unto your honors that notwithstanding the premises, but
well knowing the same, and contriving to injure your orators and
to deprive them of the benefits and profits which might and
16 otherwise would acerue to them from said invention and the
practice thereof, the respondents herein, since the issuance of
said United States letters patent and since the various assignments
thereof as aforesaid and since the entire rights and property in said
United States letters patent became vested in your orators and
before the filing of this bill of complaint at the city and county of
San Francisco, and, as vour orators are informed and believe, a
divers other places in the northern district of California, without
the license of your orators or elther of them and in violation of
vour orators’ rights and privileges, have made, used, and sold to
others lamp burners containing the inventions described and claimed
in said United States letters patent and constructed according to the
specification thereof; that the lamp burners so made, used, and sold
bv respondents are infringements of the aforesaid United States
letters patent, and the exact number thereof so made, used, and
sold is unknown to vour orators, but they allege, on information
and belief, that said respondents have made and realized large gains
and profits from their s said use of said invention and their infringe-
ments of said United States letters patent, which wonld otherwise
have been realized and enjoved by vour orators, and your orators
have not only been thereby deprived of said gains and _ profits, but
I
i
i
*
12 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
have likewise been damaged by reason of the said infringements to
a large extent; and your orators further, show that they have re-
quested the respondents to desist and refrain from their aforesaid
unlawful useand practice of said invention and their infringements
of said United States letters patent, but said respondents have failed,
refused, and neglected and still do fail, refuse,and neglect to compiy
with said request or any part thereof.
That said respondents are still engaged in their unlawful use and
practice of said invention and in infringing said United States
letters patent, and threaten so to continue, and unless restrained
and enjoined therefrom they will continue so to act, to the great
and continual damage of your orators, who will thereby be deprived
of large gains and profits which would otherwise accrue to them,
and will suffer great and irreparable loss and injury.
Wherefore your orators humbly pray that the said respondents,
Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer, their and each of their servants,
agents, attorneys, and workmen, and each and every of them,
17 may be restrained and enjoined, both provisionally and per-
petually, by the order and injunction of this honorable court,
from directly and indirectly making, using, or vending any lamp
burners made or constructed according to the specifications of said
United States letters patent or containing the invention therein de-
scribed and claimed and from infringing upon said United States
letters patent, and that said respondents may be‘decreed to account
for and pay to your orators the profits unlawfully obtained by them,
the respondents, by reason of the aforesaid infringements, and also
the damages thereby suffered by your orators and the costs of this
suit, and that your orators may have such other and further and
additional relief as to this honorable court may seem meet and such
as may be agreeable to equity and good conscience.
And iorasmuch as vour orators have no plain, speedy, or adequate
remedy at law for the wrongs and grievances herein complained of
and are without any remedy therefor, save in a court of equity,
where such matters are alone cognizable, to the end, therefore, that
the said respondents and each of them may, if they can, show cause
why your orators should not have the relief herein prayed for and
may, but not upon their or either of their corporal oaths (an answer
under oath being specially waived and not required), according to
their and each af their best and utmost knowledge, recolleetion, in-
formation, and belief, full, true, and perfect ‘answers make to the
premises and to all and each of the several matters hereinbefore
stated and charged as fully and particularly as if separately and
severally interrogated as to each and every of said matters—
May it please your honors to grant unto your orators a writ of
injunetion, as well provisionally as perpetually, issuing out of and
under the seal of this court, commanding, enjoining, and restralning
the respondents, Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer, and each of them
and their and each of thetr servants, agents, attorneys, and work-
men and each and every of them, as is hereinbefore in that behalf
prayed. |
Mav it please your honors to grant unto your orators the writ of
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 13
subpoena issued out of and under the seal of this honorable court,
directed to the said respondents, Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer
commanding them and each of them to be and appear in this hon-
orable court by a day certain, according to the law and the
18 rules and practice, then and there to answer the premises
and to stand to and abide such order and decree as may be
made.
And your orators will ever pray, ete.
LANGHORNE & MILLER,
Solicitors for Complainants.
J. H. MILLER, Of Counsel.
Verification to Amended Bill of Complaint.
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, oe
City and County of San Francisco, Sag
Albert Graff, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he is one of
the complainants i in the above-entitled action; that he has read the’
foregoing amended bill and knows the contents thereof; that the
same is true, of hisown knowledge, except as to those matters which
are therein stated on information or belief, and as to those matters
that he believes it to be true; that he verily believes Schwintzer &
Graff to be the original and first inventors of the invention claimed
and described in the letters patent sued on.
ALBERT GRAFF.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 16th day of October,
1886.
(SEAL. | F. O. WEGENER,
Notary Public.
Endorsed: Filed October 19,1886. L. 8. B. Sawyer, clerk.
= Subpeena.
Unitep STatTes OF AMERICA:
Cireuit Court of the United States, Ninth Cireuit, Northern District
of California. In Equity.
The President of the United States of Americ a to Emile Boesch
and Martin Bauer, Greeting:
You are hereby commanded that vou be and appear in said cir-
euit court of the United States aforesaid, at the court-room in San
Francisco, on the sixth dav of December, A. D. 1886, to answer an
amended bill of complaint exhibited against vou in said court by
Albert Graff, who is a citizen of the State of California, and J. F.
Donnell, who is a citizen of the State of New York, and to do and
receive What the said court shall bave considered in that behalf;
and this vou are not to omit under the penalty of five thousand dol-
lars.
le DAE Hae bk PEND ATV Ie, a Pe a bee eer. ey
EaOCL Se
Sea oe me
i4. EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
Witness the Honorable Morrison R. Waite, Chief Justice of the
Supreme Court of the United States, this 19th day. of
aL.] October, in the vear of our Lord one thousand eight hun-
i eighty-six, and of our Independence the 111th.
L. 8. B. SAWYER, Clerk
Memorandum Pursuant to Rule 12, Supreme Court U..
You are hereby required to enter vour appearance in the above
suit, on or before the first Monday in December next, at the clerk’s
oftice of said court, pursuant to said bill; otherwise the said bill
will be taken pre COnTESssO.
L. 8S. B. SAWYER, Clerd.
20 (Endorsed.)
Un1tep States MarsHat’s OFFICE,
— tn ie ee
NORTHERN District oF Cat FORNIA.
l hereby yy certify that I received the within writ on the agree dav
of October, 1886, and personally serv ed the snr
> -
:
Sew ia —
~~ loth dav
ot Oct, 1836, by de ‘livering to and leav! x with Marti 1 Bauer. : said
defendant named therein, ies at th
Franc par. in sald district, a certified copy t
search | have been unable to find Emile Boesel
fendants, in my district.
~~
—d
4
rae
(sli
es . o " wv
tv & coun tv of 8an
3 Lc “38
— ere qi
1g. afier adi
Y} ,
id
-
.
FRANKS,
CT. SN Marshal.
By . H. PETERSON, Deputi.
“aun Franeiseo, Oetober 20th, prec ht
Filed October 20, 1856.
L. S. B. SAWYER. Clerk.
By F. D. MONCKTON,
Deputy Clerk.
~ ’ 2 — * . wr. a . > > .
> . | nited < 2 ? ABO ( 7 PA s¢:? . *2 ye Ninth 77 N72 f Norther? i Pe a? 0%
In ae G & wy bs sae — Siates irfeult OUP. - SAZUEZ ( ireutlt, a orinery Jistriet
*. ° .
a 3
=, ( re rn a
3
- rr é ~ 3 -_~
ALBERT (WRAFF ¢f @., Complainants,
i
bs -In Eq uty.
T . 4 b
- ina - - a
Evite Borsca +f al, Defendants. |
~ ° 9 % Pag ?
- + -- ‘ , a eo i ae ° ~ 7 . -
Now ée said defendants and denv generally and speeificalls
a - nw , . : — »
3 3 ri Yr et + PAN ; r
~ re" . . . v —_ ~¥ - 3 ~~ ws - ~ + ss V Th) a ik nan LS ) oO COuy-
. oe
- The ‘s, re
\\ : ig a } 5 } } t +
- S >s - = r > ~*~ Ss Ss fom ’ ~—>- ¥ ,
ere! ius { ’ Oe 2ucé dismissed With thelr rea-
° I
bn bo.ce Costs .£ Peres is = eet i Stistaied.
nai 1) ~
CR Iv NER & BOONE,
N eareu S ft Det PsN
Tra” r - TT? o
= 5 y\ ro g -
s ee, “ — a. , -
+ ; . : °
i< 7 7” er 7” - ° r - R _— see ; —
a 1 he a ery ict e Lh atiswer anet reeelpt of
c ‘
jo wo - mirrr . - * ee > - yt To.) ISNT | ey Y
¥v 4 So ~ SLs i vu e we oi a ail OT 2 uit. ~ 1. @ sth
J .
“Ace easels nahigcarctaiiesaions: yale WA Ne
Sit a9 ee mE Oe EN
EMILE ROESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 15
horne & Miller, solicitors for compl. Filed 5rd day of January,
A. D. 1887. L. 8. B. Sawver, clerk.
Replication.
In the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Cireuit, Northern
District of California.
ALBERT GraFF and J. F. DoNNELL, Complainants, )
vs. ;
Evite Borscy and Martin Baver, Respondents. J
The replication of Albert Graff and J. F. Donnell, complainants, to
the answer of Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer, defendants.
These repliants, saving and reserving to themselves all and all
manner of advantage of exception to the manifold insufficiencies of
the said answer, for replication thereto saith that he will aver and
prove fis said bill to be true, certain, and sufficient in the law to be
answered unto, and that the said answer of the said defendants is
uncertain, untrue, and insufficient to be replied upon by these rep-
liants without this, that any other matter or thing whatsoever in
the said answer contained material or effectual in the law to be re-
plied unto, confessed and avoided, traversed or denied, is true; all
which matters and things these repliants are and will be ready to
aver due prove as this honorable court shall direct, and humbly
pray as In n and by his said bill he hath already praved.
LANGHORNE & MILLER
Sol’ s for Complainants.
(Endorsed :) Service of the within rep. is hereby admitted this 51
dav of Jan., 1887. Scrivner & Boone, attorney for def’ts. filed
Jan’'y 31,1887. L. 8S. B. Sawver, clerk, by F. D. Monckton, deputy
clerk.
22 Interlocutory Decree.
In the Cireuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern
District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF and J. F. DoNNELL, Complainants, )
Us. >No. 4107.
Eire BoescH and Martin Baver, Respondents. j
At a stated term of the circuit court of the United States in and
for the ninth judicial circuit, northern district of California, held at
the court-room thereof,in the city and county of San Francisco,
State of California, on Monday, the 3rd day of October, A. D. 1ss7
being a day of the July term of said court for 1887.
Present: Honorable Lorenzo Sawver, circuit judge.
This cause having heretofore come on to be heard upon the
amended bill of complaint of complainants, the answer of respond-
ents thereto, the replication of complainants, and the proofs, oral,
documentary, and written, taken and filed in said cause and now of
16 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET Af.
record, and having been argued by counsel for the respective parties
and submitted to the court for its consideration and decision—
And the court having duly considered the same and being now
fully advised in the premises—
[t is ordered, adjudged, and decreed and the court doth hereby
order, adjudge, and decree as follows, to wit:
That the letters patent of the United States or anted and issued on
the 4th day of December, A. D. 1555, to Carl Schwintzer “ai Wil-
liam Gratf!, of Beriin, Germany, assighors of one-half to J. F. Don-
nell & Co., of New York, nu imbered No. 289,571 and entitied
23 “lamp burner,” and being the letters patent aed on herein,
is good and valid in law; that the said Cari Sehwintzer and
William Gratf were the joint, original, and first inventors of the in-
Ventions deseribed in said i claimed, covered, and
protected in ae by the first claim thereof.
That Albert Gratf and J. F. Donnell, the compl: ainants herein, are
the sole and exclusive owners holders of said letters patent.
That Emile Boeseh and Martin bauer, the respondents herein,
Without the Iigenpse or consent of complainants or either of them,
i of San Francisco, State of. California, and
4
tic
the C1LV and eounts
ae ) . r + ? ; a ae) 1. . ~ t > —~ s} | } l / } Bo an cot 4 5 }
Since the compiaimants bDecamMe Toe owners ana Noiders of sald Let-
} 7 °—fT ve . * ‘ an) ; ] + po ‘ ‘
ged Upon the mrst clam of said ietters patent
ues
> |
- aa
ters patent, Dav e lnirin
and the exelusive rights and privliieges Of con nplan nants under the
? - oe } t x ? ve
same—that Is to say, Dy selling lamp burners containing the inven-
2. S ce he ? }
tion and improvements covered, claimed, and oe . . In and by
— + >of ‘ } 5 eee +) : tee g ~ | ‘ » } } iil "£ , “i )
Said first Claim of said letters patent, as charged In the bill of com-
4 } — 7 : > ] . * J . . ] s) i. ho 5 7 > } a e , i. }
ADa L Is Turtner ordered, aadyudged, and ‘jecreed that the com-
} - > , . } , ¢?,.5 } a “yg >> } "ee . Fe As » bd i
‘Atacama “oO nave ahidy recover Of ahd [Tom Eutle Boesch ili id Nf: af-
. ‘ . . . ? ol
tin bauer, thie respotideiits Herel n,ine Galvts, profits, aoa a iVahtages
Which thev and euch of them have made or received or wl
&
4
arisen or acerued to tneln and eacn of them [from and OV reasou
of the infringement aforesaid, and also any and all damages which
the complainants and each of them have sutfered or ied from
and by re.son of said infringement, together with costs.of court.
And it is further ordered, adjudged, and decreed that the case be
referred to S.C. Houghton, Esq., the master in chaneerv of this
. : eee . -
court, tO ascertain, take, state, aud report to this court an aceount
of the number of lamp burners sold by respondents or a Of
them containing the tnveation claimed in and ny thie first claim of
suid letters patent, and also the cains, profits, and advantages which
the said respondents and each of them have made or received or
whieh have arisen or acerued to them and each of them sinee the
ith day of December, 1585, from and. by infringing upon the first
tt
Me
Clalin Of sald ietters Datent as atoresald, and also the amount of
mauve sulfered
Gauhages When the cotppialnants and eacn of thetn
: ae a i a . ;
liriIngement.
_
Or SuUSialned Trom and OY reasoh of sald
r
i
b } ; Ba ae ; 2? . # > j ‘ is om is P ] ~ } } > . } H - . .
4 And lt isturther ordered, adjudged, and decreed that Upon
fo
such ACCOUNTING the complainants have.the right Lu Cause an
oral examination. under oath of Emile Boesch and Martin Bauer,
ther respondents, and each of ti hem,and t their ; ents, Ser yants , cierks.,
Siaitiientecreneacionincaneda nent I ec en eee eT ann ae
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 17
book-keepers, salesmen, and workmen and each of them, and any
other witnesses necessary to take said accounting, and also the right
to inspect and have produced before the master all books, vouchers,
contracts, papers, and other documents belonging to or in the pos-
session of or contro! of the respondents and each of them, and of
the firm and copartnership business carried on by said respondents
under whatever name the same may be conducted, showing or tend-
ing to show any matters or things material to the accounting.
‘And it is further ordered, adjudged, and decreed that Emile
Boesch and Martin Bauer and each of them, their agents, servants,
_ workmen, and employees, be, and they are hereby, forever and per-
petually enjoined and restrained from making, using, or selling any
lamp burner or other burner containing the invention claimed, cov-
ered, and protected in and by the first claim of said letters patent
and from infringing upon the said first claim in any matter what-
ever.
Further ordered, adjudged, and decreed that complainants do
have and recover from respondents their costs and disbursements so
far incurred and heretotore taxed at $119.25, and such other and
further costs as may be hereafter incurred.
LORENZO SAWYER,
Circuit Judge.
(Endorsed:) Filed and entered October 17,1887. L.S. B. Sawyer,
clerk.
25 U.S. Cireuit Court, Northern Dist. of California.
ALBERT GRAFF
i's. 4107.
Emit Boescu ef al.
Master's Report in the Matter of the Reference for Accounting, Compris-
ing Interlocutory Decree, Report, Testimony.
In the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit,
Northern District of California.
NT
on)
ALBERT GRAFF and J. F. DonNeELL, Com- )
lainants
ee m | Interlocutory Decree.
>) - ron " A ( No. 4107.
EMIr—E BoescH and Martin Baver, Re- |
spondents.
At a stated term of the circuit court of the United States in and
for the ninth judicial circuit, northern district of California, held at
the court-room thereof, in the city and county of San Francisco,
State of California, on Monday, the 3rd day of Occober, A. D. 1887,
being a day of the July term of said court tor 1SS7
Present: Honorable Lorenzo Sawyer, circuit judge
This cause having heretofore come on to be heard upon the
amended bill of complaint of complainants, the answer of respond-
ents thereto, the replication of complainants, aud the proofs, oral,
o—1405
te ORS a
4
§
4
pa
3
u
i
*
Pi
t
>
+
a
f
q
3
2
f
t
1s EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET ATL.
documentary, and written, taken and filed in said cause and now of
it cord, ahd having been ar gued bs counsel for the respective parties
and submitted to the court for its consideration and deeision—
Aud the court having duly considered the same and being now
fully advised in the premises :
lt is ordered, adjudged, and decreed and the court doth hereby
order, adjudge, and decree as tullows, to wit: That the letters patent
of the Luited States vralited and issued on the 4th day of December
>) Isso, to Cari Schwintzer = Wilham Gratf, of Berlin, Ger-
any, assiguors of one-half to J. F. Donnell & Co., of New York,
numbered No. 250,071 and entitled “lamp burner,” and being ¢
viters patent sue don herein, is good and valid tn law; t
aid Carl Schwintzer and William Gralf were the joint, original, an
tirst Inventors of the Inventions deseribed tn said letters pateut
—
~ , } }
} i
aud claimed, covered, aud protecteu itd and DV the first Ci:
thereof.
27 Vhat Albert Graif and J. PF. Donnell, the complainants
nerelu, die tae soie and exciusive owners and holders of said
ictiel’s ere
‘e 63 fT ae. te 1 ; ) \I: + + ats I> at . ee . } ees
hat mile Boesca and Martin bauer, the responce Hts nerein,
Wilnoul tie license OLY Conseht ol vOlupiainants or elther of tnem, at
Liie CILY and CUOUNRTV Of San I: rancisco, state or & “aliforpia,. ail
tfhe a operat VeCalue fhe owbhers and noiders ot sali
pol the first ciain Of Said | ‘tters patent ahd
P y 17 ve! ete ge" yi ' yy; Rete: £3 Gyo. 4 Try ~sa ey
iit MLELUSAVE sik bits At VEIV Lic Ves Vi CUOMWIDaTNadeis | Lils let yLIC same ‘3
‘“ : escal é ° *
r 7a) f , r } ° ~ >i Bayes 1? 1 f , ¢ =e T9* s ry rsrxrvyrvis + } s 5) ‘3 f
linkt is LO Say. UY SUidiain pchaddy? OUUPLict’s CUlILaIT Lig Ltie vel it ani
x . J ie
: 7 ee ek 2 4 . 4 . eee Pere | iy ‘ ViF ; 1a 8 eer ; y* T 43 ge '? »3t ? ' 7 *s3 7 ; Ty yo.
MWUDITUVeEIDCOts CUOVelTeUd, Cidlllicd, aud Drovected ill etal OV SAA iLdi1A SU
. . . . . . } . 3 ; i ra
232% . » 7 " s>T ft ,>? ry 4 aut > a ‘he bos 7? , P , i | , 2 ; Be s
iil ROCs £20008 iw s27QUCC Lit. Ad Ciladioed ltl LLIt iid Ji Cot piaiht.
" 7 ‘ " e* . . . ‘ ] ? "
i . . . Y ’ +? > t+ ex 4 .
4 rea i 1 , vs . ,* Yj} «-
Ritu Ss iuboder ordered, adjudged, ahud decreed Nal de cou
° , — . 7 > .
. = ’ ? , ) ? vi * ye, Pye ig 7 > ae 1} Bare. NPrtin
> aaua + -~ ae) asda .& = a | : es bed Vv w & 4 »- chal i iTOin izlliiie Poe scl 4 bid = | ~ C46 G&S 2S
> >
; ; »? ‘ > , onmre , ? ae i Pea 1 Tia ae Saas Ler, Fs Tela Preae
Bresegere it .USp MsitaUiitls ATACLIT, LiIcT Vasilis, EJlils, and AG ivan ALCS
. . . < . . =
‘ . 3 . 2) coy s 4 ? "ie tae 4 “eo? & te ®
Wdilvli BY d44ib'4 UCU wee ge oe ae | vv tf MlLaue Vl received OL Wi Mieco ra\ C
ri ae?) YF i perio.) Ff rr Pry) ere 394 . tricorn ty Fr easgesy}) OFT
ve Lot .4 ~~ & 1iw ©& ataCla . S Vii taa iwi th CaAavil Wi lich (rou a id OY iCaSt7is Wi
v
. 7 _ > 6 , ,
1 £¢eeawe e277 tee i % ate 2} “yi Polo? Sa 18s FI Tra
eid Alda bbs CassCisal li Coaiua, vista aisoO ahiy and res @! dalnbayves ViliCl) ii tS
a —
» 5 : =" wn > *
’ ; + r @Bereven Ba G 4 +3 ii oy, i> a +? sat 7? ¢ 9 ty “372 7
Wiadd pracdds Qiitve dilta Calis Vi LUICcivdg wave sul Lieies d IP suUstailled (POU aiita
— i yr >> - ~ 3 rs _ mn Bane: >» 3 Tans war "21 eh . ° © > s get
.' ¥ Li teacrwis 474 OGSNA sibda liti ee Cisciin, w¥yeuller Witt i CUSte Gi COUT.
4 8 i : ; ‘ " * .* “ae . : ‘ ‘
, ; + > y * .? s F*sda : ‘ 2 4 rest 3 7 4 4 - ie > . - >.> 7 ¢
|e . . ee a Laivia WESAUEUAS 6 iinet | MUScCU, apd deereed (Liat Lil . Asc We
- ~~
. : yy — 2 " . ,
. cs ¥* fs ‘ ~ ; a | eRe r .r. ‘ 2% riy 7 . -* rh) 1} "2 _ + oo. 2 .
or hoe SE one | UY are i asus iad, RASA v0 Vi ss Ihdsiucl ii) \ “nauee yi y Pi Liki
— c 4 v
} rT ‘ 2 ee an r ¢3 2 4 i. }.? ¢ 9c, F ys Of ea rrasec 7 3? tr) Bseeag add Ii}8K
~~’ J w Sy LOL WE VEE ED coi act, “VAAL, cee ae t AO WL Y “e Lilis COU? cLid EAC APRA EL ~
- ’ , ) pia 7* , ? y y ? ¥°7 3 T° 2 w 4 4 ' . a . ; oe i é
it ai td abb ala J i: bch bed dy M/A LICIS wh FF ES | OY respol hie ibis a! veULics. SE
- “
. ,
, i> I 4 ee : {7 ; * r ° . *, . > , I
ws § es bad 4 . vw ; iS eA aw a - i cLiard Os ile ee ee 7 oe: SEE a ee |
7
> ; t)} 2 Tie ; ris rats bi ie om va. { «Feo LAr ea tage e
mart . s ~ i< > CALW Aa Vie ‘ | mio 4 eA W — ALLIS, AJL ULL, Liat2 atUaViatallales *y i§ vii
.. a -
. ‘ ‘ ? ‘ 7) : ‘ . t*rigary , . 4? " > : ; we ee bad? UP s > fo i
e SAA LOM) AW abd bkdth TAC Vi lietili iaiVe [haae of LGC. vyUss Va
*¥ asbawsdd A 2) we 444 ve, OE + = 3) Se | 14044 ne, vilSill eLiita eA il eS Leth SALI AEE
~~; , "yy ry » ; |
wha 44% ¥ 4 Cai « wt. A 2 satya i we Ls a y $4445 i. big’ 4 > Jia isS Lifst
w -
. ‘ > y* ? » e308! } . sf, Pee 62 ? ‘ a . " . - . +
Cictiiad wre S Se | Vitis VPeLeC idl GS liVilsadila, ailitd GLisV Beas aeeeLeLeeear Ja
. «
u ; , 5 ¥ t 3
s —, > ¥ ¥ ~ ~ 4 > L a Lis LS «at s°A Cav b | Ba ricihl 1iVet SU itered ‘ 4
. > : ‘ tyecy? P , ee ea? r ssa ts 7?) ye > yey ,
— bee VEE LZ MA PANZASLA GALESA 7 ¥ AU MAOVIE Vi SAbiltd LUI PLiive da C Su.
P34 a ? ee ieee Ss & *s go Peay } ci liktetifeoag ft ‘rhe 2 Ppa > Tg ag bg 9 Fepea Tt i i ’ P2407
CRASSA . & iS . AL UisiCsh ~~ & Awad “Ay , °J MMS u, a eS a | MoUL oC A Llbabe a eAsae such
> er 77} > se > . © ‘3 , : } og e" ee > -* = r nS “e ‘ > . > ®. ; es > . 2
ra 5 OS SESS wiki en viity iii piaiuanis Lich VC UllG & ten hay LU) wise ctii JP LC KXMGiii-
. : * "> , * Site . 3
+ - 3 tar 4 i 1 thi 5 > bug ?: sare Marit ae > * an oe -_ = i ’
laLION, UUUGer OAL, Vi it s9UCsVUil ALIU ALAIN i awuer, toe PUEOPULIG™
i
|
|
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 19.
ents, and each of them, and their agents, servants, clerks, book-
keepers, salesmen, and workmen, and each of them, and anv other
Witnesses necessary to take said accounting. and also the right to
inspect and have produced before the master all books,
28 vouchers, contracts, papers, and other documents belonging
to or in the possession of or control of the respondents and
each of them, and of the firm and copartnership business carried on
by said respondents, under whatever name the same may be con-
ducted, showing or tending to show any matters or things material
to the accounting.
And it is further ordered, adjudged, and decreed that Emile
Boesch and Martin Bauer and each of them, their agents, servants,
workmen, and employees, be, and they are hereby, forever and per-
petually enjoined and restrained from making, using, or selling any
lamp burner or other burner containing the invention claimed, cov-
ered, and protected in and by the first claim of said letters patent
and from infringing upon the said first claim in any matter what-
ever.
Further ordered, adjudged, and decreed that complainants do
have and recover from respondents their costs and: disbursements so
far incurred and heretofore taxed at $119.25, and such other and
further costs as may be hereafter incurred.
(Signed) LORENZO SAWYER,
Circuit Judge.
(Endorsed :) Filed and entered October 17,1887. L. 5S. B. Saw-
ver, clerk.
I, L. 8S. B. Sawver, clerk of the circuit court of the United States
for the northern district of California, do hereby certify the fore-
going to be a full, true, and correct copy of an interlocutory decree
filed and entered October 17th, 1SS87, in the eause entitled Alfred
Graff ef a/. vs. Emile Boesch ef a/., No. 4107, in said cirenit court.
Attest my hand and tlfe seal of said cireuit court this
[sEaL.] 25th day of April, A. D. 1888. |
L. S. B. SAWYER, Clerk.
29 ~=—s=In the Cireuit Court of the United States, Ninth Cirenit. in
and for the Northern District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF )
Us. >
Emre Boescu et al. J
In the matter of the reference to the master for accounting.
Master's Report.
To the honorable circuit court of the United States for the ninth
eireult and northern district of California :
In pursuance of the decretal order of this honorable court filed
and entered in the above-entitled cause on the 17th day of October,
1887, directing the undersigned, as master in chancery of said court,
pate PB OPT IRE AH mS,
AL. VS.
_
Oe fy
@
OESCH |!
B
al
.
«
MIL!
~
*
~
i
()
»)
“Ay a]
~
oe
-_—
os
me =
we —
ted
het »
- w
Cc) —_
oo
>
a.
aoa a)
Cn ¢m™
> al
—_
>
- —
an
a
r ‘
mR &
*
»> >
*.. .
at Ae
m |
ww ey
ee? —-
cot 13
wont _
a rant
'
a tis
a te | aiid
~
f | fl)
‘
~~
ro.
s 4
“ne ond
~ ow
rua ~-4
4
com)
eo? ~~
ov
7%
“ ~
.
a
Rn
Led ced
ape ow
few ‘on
os —)
—] a)
~ a)
ew + med
v
.
e tel
ie) ouad
pe 2
oo
~s
dé
”
ow _
_ f ‘ooo
-
—
a pneand
~ 2
4
et °
- oud
-) .
0
— (ond
an -
4) me
|) =—s
__ ed
led ow
ree /
on
ae
aed ’ amd
ay Pm
s. ,
wed a
vr
eo ~
a an
—_
_
i) ee
@ —
—
~/
Pano
4 -
a =
ow
bn +
*
rm
ters
sii lt
»gd1y?
_~ = -*
€
vii
Of
}
a
have arisen or acerued to
Yr
lic
"I Ti cpt %
sat
ow
~~
oo
—
we " es
re@®
vom
*
ane ~
- a)
ae
me
— pa
i ft)
a /
—t
co]
Coe] 1)
he
2 >.
r
ed
~
A 2
a8. “4
s
——e
und
+2 wo
ad
oe
a ’
oe
-
pf) _—
mrtennd
o@
4
red
/
4
os =
wood
wad ~~?
ad ~d
4 .
a]
|
«>?
eo | »|
rapa
a)
o/ 7
4 ~~
a a
if wt
eee ow
“a
, noadl
tmeg =)
~ Fe |
«<4
os
aoe
r =)
tN ed
a) ain
aud wii
—
daneedd =~
ad
7 et
a
~
bom! pag
te aw
ow od
- ~
a ad
by
/
f)
4
*
— ad
? } —
~
ote
ra
po)
baw
%
pnd amma)
twee
.
a
° J . et
eee
Se ee | e
tata
co 7
ud -
9 2 ed
’
Cc.
‘Oey
si :
fname
~
om.) 1)
Seed ed
.
— pent
’
| |
mo a
~
ee
es Fae oe |
-
ts |
a cate |
a4
La
~ mae
_ H
*
-—
a —
$f)
—
a)
1. peed
+
-_
~~e po
cr —
*
wot cel
~e 4
a=
ee a
-_
oe]
ent ad
me °
~~
--
ne | 42
‘ ~at
~
)
-~ 4
hmnet
= “—
m4
a
ve
“a
>
coe , ’
°°) faweed
‘
m= f:
oe
a ee.
oy ‘
~~ wand
wont ~
wee
an mad
a’ a
) ~
4
brad »
1) *
of ~
Paced
ye
4
a)
aot
pound >
“
at
>
tf
weg a
oor a an
f o
~~ ow
’
~~
o- ——
ya ) i
worn ~
sa
~ rad
oni
.
¢
a
.
Cie <b me
Pe ee ae |
sud od
‘ir
7
t}
£8
|
HnoVv
ret
ay
s
$.<
Ai
717 8? i¢
am) es
. oo rs
— —« ”
-—— ot « ted
roe
a ae
- = ~
.
pont al
psund
™
~ -
= of
ao ’ >
Date - »
—
-—*
wes
+
4-2
fa
- ae -
pitch —
at co
onad a
4
.
4 dened
a) f.
7 - >
ow ine
>
a '
+ yom
- a a
a ‘
. < oo]
—"
a
— ‘en!
wed a
nod a “yy
a —_
one "f ,
se tie:
5 4
— a] 2B
“a on
. ay
am,
: ’ Pemee 4
ated he
ant
~~ o.
al ®
L o4
_ we emal
aa wn,
wm. =
ee cod
da —
—s pe.
_ all :
se —_
Nero Sy
. ~
9 ~ alk
2 =
. a e
ads we
f one
Send » >
f —~—?
a
° -
~ dened “>
. }
meet “ay =
a -
id
~~ de tow
— eed =~
bnew -. a
~
— wa
ev —
s — tb
. ~~ :
*
° ,
a" .
ad ry ’
- = 4
-_ 4 .
re ne
on -
—< ind my
*) -. a
~ peta OOO
a —_
’ ow ~~
— fe ’ —
a 7 —
med CD i
asi ~
Gane _—| —
mm
= % “ey
gn ‘—
Poem ne *
amd
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. ?1
that the cap Is a nuisance, and that burners from which the caps
have been entirely removed are superior to those of complainant,
and he states that burners of that class were in general public use
~ long before the date of the patent in suit.
o1 It these assertions are true the infringement was wanton
and without excuse. It Is app arent that the removal of the
entire cap would have required less care and would have been at-
tended with less labor than the removal of a portion of the cap, and
would have given respondents a burner which they had an unques-
tionable right'to sell.
The evidence shows that the infringement was a wilful and per-
sistent violation of the rights secured to complainant by his patent.
That material injury resulted to complainant’s lamp-burner trade
from the infringemént of respondents there can be no doubt. It is
an admitted fact that complainant was at all times in a position to
supply the demands of the trade for burners of this class, and the
testimony clearly shows that in many cases the loss of sales by com-
plainant was directly attributable to the infringement.
By the testimony of complainant and his wife, Who Is his clerk
and book-keeper, it-is shown that complainant introduced his pat-
ented burners to the trade in the fall of 1835 ane that the goods
found a ready market, his sales prior to the time of dose commence-
ment of the sale of the infringing burners amounting to six or
seven thousand, and his entire sales up to the latter aie of the vear
ISS7 aggregating some ten or twelve thousand: that he granted no
licenses; that upon Intro uci ‘ing the patented article he fixed upon
a schedule of prices, which prices were maintained Until some time
In the spring of 1856, when, because wes the introduction and sales
of respondents’ lower-priced infringing burners, complainant’s trade
fell off, and he was compelled to reduce and did reduce both his
Wholesale and his retail prices.
It is a fact of common knowledge that there is to be found on sale
in the market a great variety of lamp burners, among which, as
shown by the evidence, have been for many vears burners of the
same general class as complainants. [In view of xe
number of sales made by complainant at high prices to a limited
trade affords sufficient proof that the efficiency and marketability of
his burners were due tu his patent improvement.
This, then, is a case where the owner of the patent cranted no
licenses and had no established license fee, but supplied the
22 demand for the burner himself, and was able to supply that
demand. He waives claim to the infringers’ protits and con-
fines his claim to the enforced reduction of price on the burners,
Which he (complainant) sold, caused by ithe iniringement.
* That this is a proper item of damages, if proved, is clear. It is
a pecuniary injury eaused by the infringement and is the subject of
un award of damages, although the defendant mav have made no
profits and the plainti itt mav have had no established leense fee.
awe ws &
ho 1a] itt. ail Car con —s at , + - °
As the Dialntill, at the tit ie Of the intrinygerms: Vailied ns rf
his c xcelusive Tl iohit OV kee ep nS fis i ifemt av Mm Libis. LV } g int ng
7 ° *
his pecuniary condition after the
no licenses, the ditference betwe
99 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
infringement and what. his condition would have been if the in-
fringement had not occurred is to be measured, so far as his own
sales are concerned, by the difference between the money he would
have eatiad 1 from such sales if the infringet t had not interfered
ith such monopoly and the money he di ize from such sales.
If such difference can be ascertained by proper and satisfactory ev1-
is a proper measure of damages. The damages to be re-
4
~-
dence. it
‘ e » ig ~ -~ . ~ ;* = oe mY r ~~
covered (Rey. Stat., sections 4919 and 4921) are tered damages,
.
" j a * - . _ m } ee ie t. ~ =e es 7 ~ ,
ana biey LAY properls eciude suecn Losses CO tne pial Mtl tf as were
1] . 1 aa ee ae. Sere oe ea pee,
allowe di Li this ense, to Wit. the losses ineurred OV reason of s wen
enforeed reduction in the patentee s prices.
Yale Lock M’f’g Co. v. Sargent, 117 U. S., 902.
ss : : rit . ry7
; KT: t . 7 2 ee rye PP? gd fr 13 yee mi? v5 4 4...
Lhe Vale Walls tlie esSentiui Teature of tae urrat ourner. ie iG
A .
a ; . ‘ ae ? ’ t a
. ; > ‘ F oO - ¥6 +t >, 8 F862 ae » 3 ry -. 3.9 ey i ;? > ' + ? ra rWIY
spoident ailopted Urratll s arral mwids liu Alits Ui L A Cem ulie price
. ‘ - : . we vi . a ann j — i 8 rot, } } eee
«4 , . r ; iy Be “ ¢ . r 3 ‘es ‘a \ i> " id ; | wa
‘ yi [ lic it H i ii ; - } 4 L i - { Xi 4 @ - ‘ 7ct aa . m } a a. & JA? aa ji 4 il ay
, t .
i . —. is b eer, 4 ar . , rv rPryaae may ¢ 63 +F
ad | iic ce ie Lite, 2 Vs ay i C4 Ui i = ae ® | ee ,* Tictii
> a
; ¢ o }
’ > ; Poe? i - se rameant . ” the ey]
yy Qa eo WS ¥ . s,s Ut? 4 : ; Cc. . A la & | f a c de of 4 Aa as Via uc Y¥ -
c . > eo . “"
; 4 > e » ar) ? ax 7” ~ i 7.7 ve +
4 3 &
ae ’*% 4 ’ ry¥ ne 4 ey ~ t { \ Ja N Lid Vii io Ai 4185 Cal ’
- ~ - > = . ~ - rs x
° > ‘ a a;* - Pga 7s ‘ t a Bate et yx Wri ;
» i . — aw ‘ a nll 4 = q}( on | f we - L1CCOU Vik 4 way? W . tee iw
= ¥) =_
: ; be
’ | ' - ;
> wt F _ 4
, ? 7
+ . 3 . : . > * > > > - . _- vr ; ae a
\ ws o> hy } a > oC ils i j ! a WD bel | s at VN 4 Cad 4
. * . « . " .
i t- j ‘ ; ; Ba = > ¥4¢ 3? ‘ hy @ : 742 Fie T:tAd } oo Vee ’M> HLiryrrnarea wT « YY Ppa
Me Gta j 4 Piss oachi & ) ‘ < Ais ids . tj 1 iti i \ sas é weg BY Vik f*aa LsGiw aL a ‘ait Ws
. ,’ .
iy - o i i} >» +} * ~~, . . ry rer ‘ve ~ 7,
y¥¥ } A t Te) ae Pe) it {Ut bth id ised il S JL PM LISGSL } C ALP UL
2 a > >
} ° ; } ; J t rT tA) r 7Jigeic iy re r rary . re > ton, ‘ ry ero 7)
LA By 8 | Li . L ; pWwCULVS-> y CK dU: icTtsS tu ab id ¥ ig, og Io Te icas . a ve tg WO as
‘ / i a > .
bo, ; .¢ - -> > + - r 7 i> >, e ~ ey UP CV}? t TTD rmrIrE. 4cQqQ
lred and ulnety-two sixfee-wick DUrners at seventy-fve cents iess,
. ; . ‘ wt, ‘ - | ; _ y ‘xy? ie ~. . . Are _ Str arn* tit? my cP cy
BU SC VC. Lh Ted 2bd sixteell UWeENLV-WICkK UUTHCLS du SCVECMLY-LI Ve
nat os : :
. t i+ — r¢ ; pee is = mm Vi } ee ae +r »*) Barn wee See gs
oe >) oie be ah Webel: A1LICCCUCE VEu A Coil uli UI Ly [ous CECE BES 2
’ ’ , > "ag * >
<4 ; . - a ; . . ~ yy * 847 > ee set v —
. : 4 *4-4¢9 : i - : ; ZS) 4 ‘ i 7 ‘ 34% ' / , we wh We at
Je) AUALEU PIUCS Wi Jiit mousand Ave nNunaread ana Adil rVriLVe
w
: - ‘ it | ee a | =
a = >
3 H fs ‘ ¥6 3 7 Oras YI? YY a7 r? 6 ayy
j i‘ { Sas bNA ti zLahligs 3ti Lil z 7% ber ee st cS ia t ied
. > J . 4 3 ?
are | -- j bg f FPg-ag f ; j -» {7 ¢a7 Po es ;* j } i I< ¢ oe MOT TAP ew NT) ra
pA 5NL 4 - taiats LF Riita “EVE iGthi JUS TLL he be 4adyv%> we A cu i si
, ? ? " ile > oe: 4 -
> 42 , y 4-2 : »r* ig te » {* i ;}” f a] 2 | ‘. 1 +r : oe f° » | eT. : . >
BB Ww V¥ titi si pa £& ope. VYCLS IPSt req td sty Riiti Cloves D ee a 5 A. J! : -
. : ; ?
" »7* r i? | Pe he €éate Pi cf 31 ’ + @are * *6} a | 5 arint . +o) $ 78,5, 4
Ata 3a IGA os yAS S i » is Be, SQ itL Jere 4 VO A1OUsSalled 4 = sv 4 ‘ ‘ &4 oe |
im : . » .
and Seventy, Whnicn Were soid ata Minimum reduction Of Ot ell CS
CD UNAGer OFTrigilal prices—a totai iiffere nce Vvetweed tue orligliual
liad tue New ices of fourteen hundred and thirtv-flve dollars
vhich sum, added to the said sum of one thousand tive hundred
Midd [0 ave doilars and itty Els, QiVes AN aygeregatce about
VO $nNOUsAnhG Hine NUNUPEG Bid seVenty loilars Lod lit & >
| therefore find and do report that the umber of Fiveuns ourners
en tO DaVe Veen SOLd VOY respoudents, sONtalnNings ne Invention
Nadinied Ih aad OV tne OPrst Claim of CcCompialnants ietters patent, is
iOuPrcveen, srrovided bblat OUOLY tne Capped ourners soid Contuli siuid
HVebncion, and t(nNat the. Lumuer = Ole lundred and fourteen hg Lie
bailf- 2p re burners so soid are to ye reid LO Coubtaill sail fnveiol
Liha COU ppicta bec ht VaAiVeS Cilaltad to anv Laid Lil of LNe Bailis, pre nis,
he i iv Nniages Which sald. respondents Nave recelve 7 ‘ whieb
bil "sel iif jedi CO them fre i} bled »\ bbaikiil r UDO Salita
: . 4 = ;
Lisi behitil i}{ sch dil letters Petlelit, Liltid Thiet bile tilifvdliis 4 iid te * °
which the « Vin plana obs sulfered aod sustained from a H »yV
EMILE ROESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 9 25
reason of said infringement is two thousand nine hundred and
seventy dollars and fifty cents.
‘Respectfully submitted,
HOUGHTON, Master, we.
Ap'l 30, ’88.
34 [n the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, in
and for the Northern District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF )
UN, >
EmiIte Boescu et a/. j
In the matter of the reference to master for accounting.
: WebNeEsDay, November 16th, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant; Mr. Boone, of
counsel for respondents ; Mr. Boone, respondent.
(The taking of testimony herein is continued, in conformity with
agreement of counsel, until Monday, the 21st instant, at two o'clock
p. m.)
Monpay, November 21st, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant; Mr. Boone, of
counsel for respondents. : ,
Examination-in-chief of EmiLe Boescu on behalf of complain-
ant (by Mr. MILLer):
Q. 1. You are one of the respondents in this suit, are you?
A. Yes, sir.
(J. 2. What is the name of your firm?
A. Emile Boesch & Co.
Q. 3. Who is the company ?
A. Mvself and Martin Bauer.
Q. 4. You two compose the firm ?
A. Yes, sir. 7
Q. 5. And you are engaged in the business of selling lamps, lam
burners, and chimneys aud things of that kind in this city, are you?
A. Yes, sir.
(. 6. Have you sold or has your firm sold any of the Diamond
burners which were the subject-matter of this suit?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. When did you commence to sell them ?
A. I imported the first about the first of January, 1SS6.
Oo (). 8. Was that the date you got the first invoice?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. Have you got that invoice here with you?
A. I think that is one of the Invoices that has been filed tn this.
ease. It might have been the latter part of December, L885, or the
first of January, Lss6, that [ got the tirst invoice.
Q. 10. W here did you get ‘these Diamond burners trom at that
time?
») . 7 > ar a wer 7 * _mm Tr ™ ‘pe sa [
24 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AT.
i 6? R '* at
* . . sa ; } . ’ ; * ;? Pe?) y>? 7 >
A. Pot a gvirtn iit PCPILOD, tre rtnalhhy
~
\ rat fhrm
(2 11 WN ohiat ii Pti
’ . > : if 7 hg f"
co Tee ; t » t 4 oa. . : —— + ; 12 : Gar to Bud ga
A L hie first ior COU 2 GO t teivelwvel S {heetass L bese Lit tis
/. as OW WMauiv dla Vou ~OCu @u tlicddy tilt
~ = —
\ Tt . 5 = } os j by oe os } ‘ H ‘ £ * oo ° } — j . a > , ,wea
d ie WOLrU Pialtwoia 1 Wait i ul H eEOTSta dd, 18 thie Nalle
4
’ : : . a
y ; +3 . ry ,_ > » y ‘ 7+ “ * o . +, we _~ 4 - ~ywer.y? ‘
. & 7) i-2 , -- -* ;
of A OuULrvel Llgat SULIICUUU Y Cie. ae 4 Ae 4s ie ap | 4 A ALG @ F--4e De? |
7 be i VE , F z a
— ' i t - ya . > 23 2 y : , .¥ Aner , . sar
mallie Vi Ciils eat ms & War “yo Ge VWRivid wee Go. a eS ae Lg Gebates iia .3 SG kd
- > io . i » 4 r r ’ wr’ i se Ln, + 343 . , ; s - > “3 i - — i _— waet=
known OV tlial Natn hE LLiteei ans atl Ligy Bie 50 MJ AGL TlaALksc
— « ~ s
> - . .
a = a * : 5 } . Et a © te wer? -¥¢ — vn
LJ. Lo Hlow ! loti v ” Ja weg ee tits , é _~ F A's 3 2u Lig we £4 8 25S
[ z — > . . .
\ (youTée +7} 4 rir ’ 7 ar. LT , <2 4 t x : Y — Te ay t ; 7 ro
aw wisi ¥ Aad ¥ ne “wth % ae J kh ) SS we “A ~ a+ ~ + Ns Ny Sabb « LA 444 cs Wo
a =~ . . ; > -
pene fr s PAs
Ment—ilItVy With Caps, i lea
oS Se | af ,
, ee Tom g ae . > + a "2
\ i+ ) > § Te Ge | a2tiuy VY iil o a | iL 4 LL A 4 2 a
A Y cao, wal ‘ sLichy } Ue
) } - & ty . > . )
> 4a § ae aay” af r We y onpners
XY i = \\V sven’ Y¥ AS v wv 24 Aw rt } re e Vv w 4 4 Be.
\ . scat oe Pa 7 <> re) , y> 4 7? . *Tr ty Fm ae oa - 6a t7 , .
re . » & w8 v¥ © ¥ Lu y i tsa lid we jas j ~ ned o-n a JAa%S 4 CA 1
~ ”)
‘ a a us mf
UWCLILY WiLAS, - ail lu ilisladatt
} \ y+ > °1> ‘ yo, 86) 7a my ¥,2i> ~, are 4 ae | ‘
“<x » ° - be - « J. Pi) & J th Utvis Vivi - 4 Vy? ti A Sig Y ~ ss gr ef iT. > sib Gia
—
1 » -> &
- -_ wo +76 ,
— r 1
’ ? Pc > ' . t ; vee 119 Os ;7 13 ar¢ € tr “<3 ‘% cB
a. & Vidg VOU Yet ANY Ober MilbLUTaAliieuse Quruers OV LOabt suide
- w 4
. ow f
s+ ~ Ak
. . °
3 te, 4-4 _ : / "tee * ts * i 44 >a 4 e P Y3 } } ~t og ie
ey AS Uitsi ge aN LeU ei 2 a= VIULLUCIILS ) Pre <a bah UY CELEXA hd bd a wes ~d&
H 4 H ; r P< + | fa ae le . .% & ’ Hey } Cisse 2 eS te ,Proc ~~ - a FF a ; a ae | ‘3
> as Sars we Ee | 4X4 - ty, Lil 7HA3C 3 YELL £4644 25/5885" ree ee I AGS ~ shat GU su Rae
“
i2VUiICe, GACC MELOY SUCH Utd Wau vapors
‘ ; ] i i be ” eye 2 ¢- ' 4 th rxiztrnOer = PT) IgA FY TA; YT PY
> iL AeeQAS. S24 LiuthiwwIe | Urbecti adhd di S141L3 701 view tSAUCTL eres
. , , \ : . ; ‘ t y “i : \ | a) ry ree
‘ . ; > cri ; ; . aa. ,
J\AU -tAy De SF z= Ja tCis \ nw | 1CL Ve VICKS ti) ry & Bc due Oh 2 4. 4 Jed LLers
‘ = r ‘ : R : — ,* ae paisa oie, sale a
> ; -< 13¢*@n ‘ 4 * + ‘ y } g-2 j }
JAUA BMALCCII VILA. - PIOUS b SAVIO Vi Mh -~at\ Am RPMS LW he
- ‘ -
ry . ‘>
wWeait,4). So. idee 3 Sici tec.
- - >
rd 4 eq i ™~ rir . yy } j ‘ 3 re | , Ss . tet rite ye VER beg ? 3 =‘ yY? i ee g
*~° a . be s ai Aw 5 AW + ae § i ww ‘4 Fh dt \e 14 No Ww "Sh a ~ fA NA ne a>
anee re ° , , > = . i . ; iy «3 t sry .
407 UVC OW Aes ae Se Be & | Li Ju yy ib iciu lmMae
a y =
} , ’
“ee be tn 44
, 45) 3 A t re iit = tw. we & Oy V < ; rinefs Woien rea? eT Wu 2 |
.° ow * / ~ k ‘4 & ‘J a ‘ P ¥ DN! NS 3 — & a‘ oA = 'sU uu Jat Oe
de ALZNG eee & S| ai ‘A sly Rice sty vA Ye shi # te } MALL Ji -~v iS } EG OF og | Ict,
' , N
me ¢ L Gate EE
. bd i ,
Le) ' : it t -itTa ae go = anew y% Ph 4a } ry? +e ~~ . oe agar.
%°> —4- A i eas 444404 WAL Jd 2 ‘4 ey LA 44h RLAi ad ep | 2h sLANG
4 ick
5 v “
% — abe @ of
,
> ‘ °
‘ ’ Yi ; ‘ rs ; ¥° qiti ste 7% st? Tt 34} ne a mis eees +. 5 .{P¢) . r ee yee, t
‘J hdd} AALLICILIY riure ALLA 5 i ¥ INST] Ree sta PULL LICt LIJOVE iCicileu
r : bine EG i ; +i +4 } = a 1; fe Ts. i]; Fas ae 'rauar
Ay, tdichi REG oF RAPPER AE SD Led Lae VY LUI MIuLl lic!
*
. sae ’
; sn ee if ‘ 4 ; s - . - — be
J a@ WiuOab Was the Next invoice 1 fob aiter that
" ° : oma ~
® ; ei i ii we he = ‘ t— * i ' on 7? 7 i i ie "+ 7: ’ Bw %
ee . ov JA 642 Lowe Sw ae aha AuUCi, Fiz is i cae Lis ‘BPER & i pC.
f ’ \ ! : }
ay = Richy AcLUC
\ a ‘ - - 5 } ‘es i } Ire ’ - - 7 } : . 1
4 L iu = hi. UCL phcbal WAS & ps et LU VILIClL YVUOULG I&
? ~ —
e ~ «&
42 > her u 6 | hcLaA . os biveg Also
o ;
‘ + \ > oe Ee vi } . 2 f } +? f : sii *FIe TS ,i 7 YO Li rv) a P
x - Le tas Se -i-daul aia ae & “ J 3 ~tA th * Ge AL iGis 24 eS a de 5 shite
~ ~
, . ve
bkAVUACH ctlit yw £4504) ¥.
-.
' " ‘ % a . Bae ; :
3 * & kichy eee =) ¥C AMS hw [ { = tei i- WW i Lteeee i. aane
» Ans - be *% “ . A L 4% A” 4'°\4A#44\44 WHA sh dm USSG A v4 Eu .% PLik ewe B.. Viuiai
a
~ o-/- - nena eters’
a
EMILE POFSCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 20
(J. 25. Now, vou got one hundred sixteen-wick burners with caps.
Now, did you get any at that time si ae to “ Exhibit 12-Wiek
A. No, sir; I have prepared a written statement from my books
which shows all these things vou are trving to get at.
(QQ. 26. You are positive that with this second invoice you only
had one hundred Metrailleuse burners ?
A. I didn’t state that. I received one hundred sixteen-wick
burners = one hundred twenty-wick burners.
(Q. 27. Then you got two hundred burners in all with that in-
voice?
A. Yes, sir.
Q@. 25. Were those caps on them”?
A. The same as the one which bas been held to be an infringe-
ment.
Q. 29. You didn't get anv at this time with those half caps like
“Exhibit 12-Wick Burner,” did you ?
A. No, SIP.
Q. 30. Did vou get any in any invoices after that ?
A. No, sir.
Q. 51. Now, going back to the first invoice, what did you do with
the fifty twenty-wick burners that bad eaps on them”
A. At the time that I received notice that they were infringe-
ments I altered them. Previous to that time I had sold four of
them.
(. 52. To whom did vou sell the four burners.?
A. I don’t know. They were sold for cash.
Q. 93. How did you alter them ? ,
A. I altered and made them the same as “Exhibit 12-Wick
Burner.”
Sy Q. 34. What did you do with those you altered ?
A. I sold them.
Q. 355. All of them ?
(Mr. Booye:) I object on the ground that it is immaterial whether
he sold them or not.
(The Mastrer:) The testimony will be taken pare to the objec-
tion.
(2. 36. So you sold all of those fifty burners after you had altered
them?
A. I sold forty-four of those which had been so altered. They
were of the same stvle as the burner “ Exhibit L2-Wick Burner.”
(). 37. Had you sold the other six which made up that fifty ig
A. I had sold four.
Q. 58. You sold four just as they were ?
A. Yes, sir. |
(2 39. And then you altered the remainder and sold forty-four
after the y were altered ? , :
A. Ye 3, Sir.
QQ. 40. What did you do with the other two burners?
4—]405
6 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
A. I don't know. I know that I took some burners to Mr. Boone's
oflice and leit them there.
Q. 41. What did you do with the fifty twelve-wick burners and
the fifty sixteen-wick burners that you got by the first invoice which
were like “ exhibit 'welve-Wick Burner?”
(The same objections by respondent.)
A. I sold twelve of the twelve-wick burners hows ‘aps of that
Jot and I sold forty-four of the sixteen-wick burners.
Q. 42. What: became of the rest of those burners of that invoice?
You say you sold twelve of the twelve-wiek burners and forty-four
of the sixteen-wick burners. What became of the others?
They are around the shop. That is all that I could find that
I sold.
(). 43. Where are the others? .
A. They are on hand now. <A few might be missing.
(). $4. Now,in regard to the second invoice, what did you do with
the one hundred sixteen-wick burners with caps that you got by
that invoice?
A. Most of them are on hand.
(). 45. [low about the twenty-wick burners ?
A. Most of them are on hand. When I say most I mean nine-
tenths.
35 (). 46. Did vou sell any of them ?
A. I sold four of those twenty-wick burners and sold six of
the sixteen-wick burners in that lot.
— (. 47. Did the four twenty-wick burners and the-six sixteen-wick
burners have the caps on them when you sold them ?
A. Yes, sir.
(). 48. What became of the rest of the burners of that lot ?
A. ‘They are most of them on hand now.
(). You say most of them are on hand ?
A. Well, | mean nine-tenths.
(). OU. What became of the other tenth ?
A. [ have altered some of them toa style which [ call the “ I.
Boesch ” style, a sample of which I now produce.
(The sample above referred to is introduced in evidence by
complainant and marked “ Complainant’s [exhibit Boesch Burner.”)
2. ol. How many of them did vou alter to the “* Boesch burner?”
A. | couldn’t say how many otf them I altered, but we altered
them as fast as we sold them. I[ sold three of the sixteen-wick
burners altered in that way and six of the twenty-wick burners
eee In that way.
Q). 52. And the rest you have in stock, | suppose ?
A. Y es, sir; except a few that might be lost.
(). 03. [lave you got a statement of the cost to you of those various
burners aud the profits that were made on them ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q). o4. What did the sixteen-wick burners cost vou in this way ?
A. The sixteen-wick burners cust me one doliar each.
—
-~4
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 27
a. oo. And what did you sell them for?
. Two dollars and a half each.
Q. ob. What did the twelve-wick burners cost you ?
A. The twelve-wick burners cost me seventy-five cents each.
Q). o7. And what did you sell them for ?
A. Two dollars each.
Q. 98. And what did the twenty-wick burners cost you ?
A. One dollar and sixty-five cents each. :
.o9. And what did vou sell them for ?
A. Three dollars and a half each. <All of the different stvles were
of one cost price and were sold at the same price.
ov (. 60. Have you in your possession now any Metratlleuse
burners with caps on them which were decided to be an in-—
fringement ?
A. Yes, sir; some that have not been altered vet.
(. 61. How many of those ?
A. I couldn’t tell. I haven’t counted them.
(J. 62. You stated that you altered them as you sold them ”
A. Yes, sir; altered about half a dozen at atime, and when we
were short of them we altered more. |
Q. 65. And those that vou have on hend and haven't sold you
have not altered yet, but vou will alter them when you sell them.
Is that the idea ?
A. Some of them are not altered yet.
Q. 64. I want to get at how many you have on hand that are not
altered and how manyjyou have that are altered.
A. Well, I don’t Lace. I was not told to bring such a statement.
Q. 65. Did you advertise those “ Diamond ” burners for sale ?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. 66. Did you advertise the Metrailleuse burners for sale ?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. 67. Did your partner do it or not?
A. That I can’t tell. I was absent from this city during the whole
of the year 1586. If there should be any advertising it would be on
my cards and on bill-heads. There were no advertisements put in
the newspapers.
Q. 68. Look at the card now shown vou and state if that is your
card,
A. We did no newspaper advertising, but on our business cards
we had the statement, among other articles, “ Diamond coal-oil
burners.”
Q). 69. Is that card which I have just handed you one of your
cards ?
A. Yes, sir.
@. 70. Are you using that kind of a eard now ?
A. No, sir. Its “ FE. Boeseh & Co.” now.
(). 71. This is “ Iémnil Boesch” on this ecard, is it ?
A. Yes, sir.
(). 72. When did you change to this firm ?
Changed before I went to Europe.
-
28 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
(). 73. Do you know when you issued this card IT have shown to
you ¢ |
40) A. No, sir: [ couldn’t tell until [ looked the bill-heads
Over.
(The eard above referred to is introduced in evidence by com-
plainant and marked “ Complainant's Exhibit Defendant’s Business
Card.’
). 74. Did you sellanv Di amoud Metratlleuse burners to the Alta
Publishing Company in this city ” |
A. | couldn't tell to whom they were sold.
(). 75. Look at this bill | now hand vouand see if that came from
your house. :
That is my bill-lhead.
76. Did you sell that bill of goods to the Alta Publishing
( ‘Ol pally at or about the date of the bill ’
Phat is one of my bill-heads, and no doubt the things have
been sold. [don’t keep my books in my brains. Yes; that is one
of my balls. ?
(The bill above referred to is introduced in evidence by com-
plainant and marked “ Complainant’s Exhibit Defendant’s Bill.”)
Mr. Boone: We object to that as immaterial and irrelevant.
The Masrer: Vhe testimony will be taken subject to the objec-
tion.
Q). 77. Did you sell any Metrailleuse burners to a saloon at Menlo
Park ?
\. | couldnt tel! where they go to.
). 7S. Did you seil any such burners to a saloon at Mayfield ?
\. IT couldn't tell. :
Q. 79. Did you sell any such burners to the Catholic church over
in Oakland ?
A. | couldn't tell.
Q. 50. Or to the Iixaminer Publishing Company here, in this
A. I dont know.
Q. Bhs Did you sell any to the firm of Nathan and Company, in
1G county
KLOW.
é 4 ; | — rey) “cel , , 4 ; sewn . gs 8)
ia. »s. I71G YOU se]! any Up LU Denicia, that ) "OU Cah think ot?
a
s
»
>
panna
°
—
~
‘J. SO, Did you seil aby Up AL ortia nad , Oregon, hint vou can
think of?
A. No, Sif.
(J. 54. Are you acquainted with the Barns Lantern Company, of
Q. 50. Are you acquainted with any person in the lamp business
Portland ?
A. No, sir; [might be, but I don’t know now.
i
'
a
—~ —
—. -
EMILE BOERSCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. PY
4] @. 86. Are you acquainted with the firm of Old and Sum-
mers, at Portland?
A. Not thai IT know of.
Q. S87. Well, I wish vou would make a memorandum of those
things that I have asked you and refer to vour books and let us
know about them.
A. If it is sold on time it will appear on my books, but if it is a
-e@ash sale it won’t.
Q. SS. Do vou enter your cash sales in any book ?
A. Not in name—not the details. Most of the things are entered,
and when | sold these Metrailleuse burners for cash most of them
were entered.
Q. 89. Did you get any Metrailleuse burners from any other place
than from Germany ?
A. I bought, in this eltv, from a party who claimed to be con-
nected with the firm of Hatton and Meladden, one dozen burners
of the same style of those sold by Mr. Graff.
Q. 90. What was this man’s name, do you know, that you bought.
the dozen burners from ”
A. MeFadden and Hatton.
@. 91. Was he a drummer from the firm of Mekadden and Ilat-
A. I believe he was one of the partners.
Q. 92. And he was out here selling these burners ?
A. Yes, sir. |
@. 95. And you bought a dozen burners of him ”
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 94. What did you do with those dozen burners ?
A. When I knew that J couldn't sell them [ wrote to them that
T wouldn't buy them, and didn't pay for them.
Q. 95. What became of them ?
A. They sent mean order to deliver them to Bb. Nathan and Com-
pany without consideration, and | lave a receipt for it
(). 96. Who did you get the receipt from; from Nathan and Coim-
pany?
A. Yes, sir.
Q). 97. What kind of a receipt was it?
A. A receipt that | received from them
@. 98. Was it a bill?
A. No, sir. |
QQ. 99. What was it, then ?
A. It was a receipt I received from thei.
@). 100. Of course, you don’t know what Nathan aud Company
did with thems ?
A. No, sir; that is none of my business.
4? (). 101. Do you know whether this tiah sold burners to
anybody else here in this city or not?
((Juestion objected to by respondent and withdrawn.)
(). 102. Did you vob ANY other Metrailleuse burners from wliy ollier
source except these you have stated ?
sy
aU) EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
A. | bought a half a dozen ten-wick burners from B. Nathan and
Company.
(). 103. When was that ?
A. | couldn’t tell you. It was about in 1886.
Q. 104. What did you do with them ?
A. ‘They were lying around my shop, except one, which was sold.
Q). 105: How did you come to buy those?
A. Like any other burner [ am -buying—that is, in the ordinary
course of trade.
(J. 106. Did they have caps on them ?
A. NO, SIP.
Q. 107. What kind of burners were they?
A. We enlled them the Edward Miller and Company burner.
Q. 108. Those Miller burners are made in New York, are they
hot ?
A. They have an office in New York and one in Meriden, Con-
necticut.
(Q). 109. You didmt buy any Metrailleuse burners in New York
from Kdward Miller ?
A. No, sir.
(). 110. Desertbe this Miller burner. Is it like any of these
burners we have here ?
A. | have one here, which is a sample of it, and [ now pro-
duce it.
(The sample above referred to is introduced in evidence by com-
pDlainant and marked * Complainant’s Exhibit Miller Burner.”)
Q. Lit. What did you pay for that half-dozen ten-wick burners
that you got from New York ?
\. | belleve the price is nine dollars a dozen.
(). 112. At what rate did you sell them ?
A. The one [ sold was for a dollar and a quarter.
J. L15. And the others vou lave around your place now ?
A. Yes, sir; except some of them may be lost.
(). 114. Are any of them lost?
\. Po canmt tell EF know that [ brought several to Mr. Boone's
ottice and never vot them back.
Q). Lio. Then you don’t know what has become of the others ?
43 A. | think they are at the shop.
| Q). 116. All of them ?
\. Pretty near.
(Ql. 117. Have you bought any Metrailleuse burners excepting
those you have testified to? |
A. No, SIV.
Q. 115. Phe haif-dozen Miller burners from New York and then
he one dozen from Hatton and McFadden, whieh vou turned over
oO Nathan and Company, and then those two invoices. whieh vou
nave testified to are all that vou have had ?
A Ve oer,
~~»
—_
EMILE ROESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. ol
Cross-examination of Emi Borscn (by Mr. Boone) :
Q.1. You carry quite a large stock of lamps, don’t you, Mr.
Boesch ?
A. Yes, sir. |
Q. 2. Do you know how many different styles of burners you
carry in stock ?
A. Styles and sizes, I think we could find one hundred va-
rleties. |
Q. 5. How about the names of burners; are there many of difter-
ent names ” |
A. A very large variety.
Q. 4. How long have you known this multiple-tube burner ?
A. It must be four or five years.
Q. 5. By what name have you known it?
A. Metrailleuse.
Q. 6. Do vou know how it got the name of “ Diamond ” burner ”
A. I believe the chimneys are marked “ Diamond.”
Q. 7. Do you know whether there is any burner in the market
called the “ Diamond ” burner ? : |
A. There isa Diamond burner in the market made by Mdward
Miller. |
«. 8. How long has that been on the market ?
A. About ten vears.
Q. 9. How long have you had it for sale in your stock ”
A. About that time—ten years.
@. 10. Had it most all the time?
A. Yes, sir.
@. 11. Call them by the same name as Mr. Graff calls this Metrail-.
leuse burner?
| A. Yes,sir; about that—* Diamond” or“ Diamond Light.”
44 @. 12. When you sold it how did you mark it down on
your books—by what name, “ Diamond” or “ Diamond
Light,” or what?
A. The Diamond burner.
(J. 15. You didn't testify in this main case in court, did you ?
A. NO, sir.
QQ. 14. Why not?
A. I was not present. i
Q). 16. Were you present at any time during the pendency of this
suit?
A. No, sir; it was begun while I was away.
(. 16. You say, Mr. Boesch, that you have sold some of tle Met-
railleuse burvers with caps, such as are made by Scliwintzer and
Graft ?
A. Yes, sir |
@. 17. Did you ever sell anv burners like the Seliwintzer and
Graff burners without the corrugations ” ,
A. J have sold tour burners of the kind whieh we bought bron
Germany from Hecht, a sampleet whieh is in evidence in tle main
case. ‘Those burners have the corrugations without a rit
Scat Lats AY AAT ee meee
oO? EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET ALT.
(). 18. Now, vou sold none of those with the full eap, such as was
manufactured by Schwintzer and Graff?
A. No, sIr.
Q. 19. ‘But you have sold four of the Hecht burners with the
corrugations on the inside?
A. Yes, sir. I have sold the sates I hate already stated.
Q). 20. Then you have sold a number of those called the Miller
burner?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 21. Then also you say you have sold some of the “ Boesch
improved ” burners ?'
A. Yes, sir. |
(). 22. Was there any difference in the selling price of any of these
burners ?
A. No, sir.
Q. 23. How about the burner called “Complainant’s Exhibit
Boesch Burner ;” was there any difference in the selling price of them
and the others ?
A. No, sir. |
Q. 24. Was there any demand for burners with a cap
Metrailleuse burner with a cap?
A. No, sir.
Q. 25. Did you ever have anybody ask you for a Metrailleuse
burner with a cap on it?
for the
No, sir.
45 Q. 26. Did you ever have anybody ask you for a Schwintzer
and Gratf Metrailleuse burner ?
A. i sir.
Q. 27. How about the selling quality of: the “ Boesch” burner,
the one vanaiiced in evidence here “Complainant’s Exhibit Boesch
Burner,” and the burner which you bought from Hacht. Is there
any difference in the selling quality of them ?
A. No, sir. |
Q. 28. Are there any peculiar advantages which would make one
better than the other’ Which is considered the best, the ‘ Boesch
improved ” burner or the “ Hecht ” burner?
A. I think the “ Boesch” burner is the best.
Q. 29. Any difference in the quality of the light made by them ?
A. [think the “ Boesch ” burner gives a whiter light and a better
light.
“Q 30. Y ou say you bought from McFadden and Hatton one dozen
burners?
A. I didn’t buy them, because I never paid for them.
Q. 31. How came you to have them in your possession ?
A. Well, they were sent to me,and as soon as I knew that I
coaldn’t sell them I didn’t pay for them.
Q. 32. They were sent to you by the firm of Hatton & McFadden ?
; Wen ¢ es, sir
Q. 33. And afterwards you were notified that they were an in-
fringement, were you ?
A. Y es, SIP.
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. KS
Q. 54. And as soon as you were notified that they were an in-
fringement you notified Hatton & Mcladden ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 55. And by their order you turned them over to Nathan and
Company ?
A. Yes, sir.
(J. 36. And took a receipt for them ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 37. Do you know how long this Miller burner has been on the
” market? | 7
A. Four or five vears. I couldn’t tell exactly how long.
Q. 38. How long since e you first saw them ?
A. It must be within four years—about four vears.
Q. 39. Do you know whether or not they are generally sold by
lamp manufacturers throughout country
A. I believe they are. They are entered in their business cata.
logues or illustrated c: ees
46 ~ Q. 40. Do you know whetier or not, prior to this suit, Mr.
Graff claimed that they were an infringement on this patent
of complainant’s ?
A. To my personal knowledge, he never said a word.
q. 41. During the time you were selling these burners was Mr.
Graff in your employ ?
{ A. No, sir; none of the time.
'
eee ee eee
saci ara of Emit Boresca (by Mr. Miter):
Q.1. Did Mr. Graff use to work for you ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 2. When did you go to Europe the last time ?
A. About the first of January, 1886.
Q. 3. And when did you return from the trip that vou made to
Europe about the beginning of 1886?
, A. About six weeks ago.
Q. 4. Now, you say you think the “ Boesch improved” burner is
better than the Graff burner ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. How long have you been i in business ?
A. Twenty years.
(). 6. Here and in Europe also?
| A. Yes, sir.
a (J. 7. Did you ever see a burner exactly like the “ Boesch im-
proved ” burner prior to the time the Schwintzer & Graft burner
ras Invented ?
| A. No, sir.
4 Q. 8. You are familiar with the burner trade and lamp trade, are
: you ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. Don’t you know, as a matter of fact, that prior to the issu-
ance of the Schwintzer & Graff patent’ there was on the market a
burner identically like the * Boesch improved ” burner, as you call
it—that is to say, a Metrailleuse burner with a band around the
o—1408
ee Bambee caeaacs CO SI ane NS SESE RAL SE RI SS On SIE
3 Ph wa es
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
wick tubes, with no cap on it—or that it was attempted to be intro-
dueed into use, and that it was a failure and never amounted to
anything; don’t you know that was a fact ?
A. No, sir.
. 10. ‘Don’ t you know, further, that in ondec to remedy that de-
fect this cap was gotten up, and that then with the cap that
47 burner turned out to be a perfect success ?
A. No, sir.
Q. 11. Do you know what the use of the cap 1s”?
A. It is a nuisance.
(2. 12. Then you think it has no use?
A. Not in the quantity of hght.
Q. 15. Is it of any use in any way?
A. I couldn't find out any use in the sale of the burners.
Q. 14. Do you know, as a scientific fact, what the cap accom-
plished in the Schwintzer & Graff burner?
A. Thev claim it makes a better light, and I claim that it doesn’t.
Q. 15. Why doesn’t it make a better light?
A. Because it stops the draft. There is too much cap on it.
Q. 16. Then your idea is that if it didn’t have a cap on it it would
be a better burner?
A. Well, it depends. There is a contrivance in the center of the
burner which regulates the draft. The contrivance in the Graff
burner is different from that in the Boesch burner.
Q. 17. Would the Graff burner be better with or without a cap?
A. I didn’t test it.
Q. 18. Do you know?
A. I don’t know.
Q. 19. Would the “ Boesch improved” burner be better with or
without a cap”
A. I have submitted already that I think it is the best without
the cap.
Q. 20. Where did you get this Boesch burner from, as you call it?
A. I explained that.
Q. 21. It was one of the Graff burners changed ?
That is a Hecht burner changed.
“4 22. Is not that made like the Graff burner?
A. No,sir; the Graff burner has a solid cap and the Hecht burner
has a cap with the corrugations on the inside.
(J. 23. Are not the two burners the same, with the exception of
the construction of the cap ?
A. If you are particular about the items, they are not, but as to
principles they are the same.
Q. 24. This burner marked “Complainant’s Exhibit Boesch
4§ Burner,” which I bold in my hand now, originally had a cap
on it, didn’t it?
A. No, sir; it was made like the Hecht burner. That was a Hacht
burner.
Q. 25. They were the ones that Graff sued you on as being an in-
fringement in this case, were they not?
A. Yes, sir.
—_
gies «
ES RS PR OW 2 Ge TE eR EES RESIN omen > a!
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. oD
Q. 26. Now, would this burner be better with or without a cap?
A. At present I prefer it that way—without a cap.
Q. 27. Why do you prefer it without a cap?
A. Because I like the light better.
(). 28. Then it is better now than it was with the cap?
A. I think it is better.
Q. 29. Then why was it that you sold them with the caps and
= \ never took the caps off until you were enjoined ?
A A. Because they were sent to me with caps.
- Q. 30. Why did you alter those burners?
| A. Because they were after the suit was commenced, and I wanted
to keep out of lawsuits.
Q. 51. Then it was because this was an infringement ?
| A. Yes, sir; and I wanted to keep out of lawsuits.
» Q. 382. Is that the reason you altered the burners ?
A. a with it and found that it gave a better heht
; without this ¢
Q. 35. Did ae alter it because you experimented with it and
found that it gave a better light without the cap or did you take off
' the cap because you were enjoined in this case?
| A. I found that they would burn better without the cap.
Q. 34. You didn’t alter them until after this suit was commenced,
did you? :
A, After the suit was commenced against me I altered the burners.
Q. 30. Did you ever see imported here from Germany one of these
. burners like this burner, “ Exhibit Boesch Burner,” without a cap
to it?
A. No, sir.
Q. 36. None of them ever came here in that shape, but they came
here with caps on, and you took the caps off. Is that it?
A. Yes, Sa
Q. 37. Now, with regard to these Hatton & McFadden burners,
you say that one of the members of this firm came over here him-
self into your shop?
49 A. I believe so
Q. 38. And he sold you a dozen burners ?
A. Yes, sir.
(). 59. What arrangement did you make with him,ifany? You
were to take them and pay for them at some future time?
A. He sold me the goods.
Q. 40. How long after that was it that you found out they were
claimed to be an infringement ?
A. When Graff sent me notice. It must have been before sixty
days before they were paid for.
Q. 41. And when you found out that they were an infringement
you wouldn’t pay for them ?
A. No, sir; I left them subject to Nathan’s order.
Q. 42. You say you believe the Miller burners are sold generally
by the trade?
A. Yes, sIr.
——
aniates
—_ -s
06 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AU.
Q. 43. When was the first time that you ever heard of a Miller
~—— being sold ?
. About four years ago.
~ 44. Where was it?
A. In this city.
Q. 45. Who was selling them ?
A. I believe it was Yates & Company, where I understood that the
agent had sold one hundred dozen or were talking about selling one
hundred dozen.
Q. 46. Is that all you know about them ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 47. Do you consider the Miller burner to be a than the
Boesch improved burner ?
A. No, sir.
Q. 48. Which do vou consider to be the best?
A. The Boesch improved burner.
Q. 49. Do you consider the Miller burner to be better than the
Graff burner ? :
A. There is a question of contrivance in it—that is, a question of
contrivance. There is a defect in the contrivance of the: Miller
burner. As you have it here, in the middle, it is just as good; but
when you come to put the contrivance in thecenter which. regulates
the draft, then there is a defect in the Miller burner.
Q. 50. Is it any better than the Graff burner?
A. I didn’t test it to see any difference.
Q. 51. What kind of a test did you make with the Boesch burner’ ?
A. Well, I lighted it.
o0 Q. 52. When was it that you made this test which you say
proved that the Boesch burner was better than the Graff
burner?
A. Four or six weeks ago.
Q. 53. Are you certain that you made the test since you came
back from Europe‘ ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 54. You made a test simply by lighting the burners and tak-
ing off the cap?
A. ¥ es, sir; and I am a pretty good judge about those things.
Q. 55. And your judgment is that it is better without a cap than
with it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 56. And you think the reason why it is better is because it has
more draft?
A. Yes, sir; but it depends all the time upon the contrivance
they put into the center.
Q. 57. You mean the contrivance through the center ?
The contrivance is on the outside and on the inside too.
. O8. The advantage in the Boesch burner does not come from
the cap, but from the other arrangements ?
A. In all these burners it depends on the contrivance.
Q. 59. Now, suppose you had two burners here, one of thetm
exactly like this one, the Boesch improved burner, and one exactly
9
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. od
like the Boesch improved burner, except that it had a cap on it
exactly like the cap on the Graff burner, then which would be the
best burner ?
Mr. Boone: I object to the question on the ground that it 1s mis-
leading and immaterial.
The Master: The testimony will be taken subject to the objection.
A. The Boesch burner is the best.
Q. 60. That is, if you were to puta cap on the Boesch burner it
would not be as good as the burner would be without a cap?
A. I think it is better as I have it.
Q. 61. And that is because it had more draft in it?
A. And it has more draft where it ought to !e.
Q. 62. Then it 1s because you have more draft?
A. No, sir; I don’t say that; it depends on how you regulate the
draft.
ol Q. 63. I ask you in regard toa burner constructed like it is.
You say it is better because it has a better draft. Does the
more draft you get into a burner constructed like the Boesch burner
make a better burner; is that the idea?
A. The way I use it the better it is.
Q. 64. What did vou do to accomplish that? To make it a better
burner you simply took off the cap, didn’t you ?
A. Took off the cap and experimented.
Q). 65. You simply took off the cap and it made it a better
burner ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 66. You got those burners alre: ady manufactured and then
took off the cap, and then you say it is better than the other
burner?
A. Yes, sir.
(. 67. And that is because it has more draft ?
A. Yes, sir; in the right place.
Q. 68. W hy do you have this band around back of the tubes ?
A. That is to hold the tubes together.
Q. 69. And if you took the band off there would be more draft,
wouldn’t there ?
A. Yes, sir; but not in the right place.
@. 70. You don’t want the draft on the inside, then ?
A. You want it in the right proportion.
Q. 71. Then in this Boesch burner, as it is, the draft is in the
right proportion, Is it?
A. Yes, sir. — |
(). 72. Then, of course, according to your theory, the Miller
burner would not be as good as the Boesch burner, because it has -
not got as much draft?
A. As it 1s, no.
Q. 73. W ell, how wend it be if it was made exactly like the
Boesch burner, except in regard to the cap?
A. If I make it exactly the same in every way it is the same
thing.
38 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
Q. 74. If you make the Miller burner the same way, except in
regard to the cap, it would not be as good as the Boesch burner
without the cap, would it? |
A. If I make it just like the Boesch burner it would be as
good. |
o2 7 Q. 75. You understand the English language, don’t you ?
A. Yes, sir. | :
Q. 76. Now, just put your thoughts together and see if you can’t
understand this question. If you had the cap off the Miller
burner, which was constructed just like the Boesch burner in other
respects, it would be as good as the Boesch burner, wouldn’t it ?
A. Well, it might spoil it to take the cap off, and I might have to
alier the contrivance.
Q. 77. Then it would not be as good as the Boesch burner ?
A. No, sir; it is not as good as the Boesch burner.
Q. 78. And the reason is that there is not enough draft there ?
A. There might be enough, but not around the wick ; it depends;
there is a contrivance put inside the burner to regulate the draft.
Q. 79. If you were to put on the Boesch burner a cap exactly like
the Miller cap would the burner as then constructed be better or not
so good as the burner as it is now constructed without a cap?
A. Not so good.
Q. 80. Why not?
A. Because the draft is more properly supplied now than it would
be with a cap on it.
Q. 81. It would be on account of not having as much draft as the
Boesch burner now has?
A. The amount of the draft depends on the contrivance.
Q. $2. Then suppose instead of being a Miller cap on the Boesch
burner you were to take and put a Graff cap on it, how would it be?
A. It would be still worse; the more cap you put on the more
spoilt it will be unless you change the contrivance.
(By Mr. Boone :)
Q. 83. Are either of these burners complete, ready to be used, or
is there something wanting ? |
A: No, sir; they would smoke like a smoke-stack.
Q. 84. What device do you use to give draft and still prevent
smoking ? |
A. There are perforated cylinders used inside of the burners of
different sizes.
Q. 85. Will you bring with you the next time you come here a
complete contrivance arranged for your Boesch burner when in op-
eration ?
A. Yes, sir.
DO (By the MASTER :)
(). 86. What was the selling price of the “ Diamond ” one-wick
burner ?
A. It is a very cheap burner ; we sell them for about fifty cents
apiece. .
OC
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. ov
(Examination continued, in conformity with nena of coun-
sel, until Friday, the 25th instant, at two o’clock p. m.)
Fripay, November 25th, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant; Mr. Graff, com-
plainant.
Counsel for respondent not attending, the hearing is further con-
tinued, at the request of complainant’s counsel, to. December 2nd,
1887, at two o’clock p. m.
Fripay, December 2nd, 1887.
Further continued, in conformity with agreement of counsel, to
Thursday, December 8th, 1887.
Tuurspay, December Sth, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for sate hnaeaind, Mr. Boone, of
counsel for respondents.
Examination-in-chief of ALBERT GRAFF on behalf of com-
plainant (by Mr. MILLER):
Q. 1. When did you commence to sell these patented “ Diamond ”
burners ?
A. I received the first lot shortly after the Mechanies’ Fair com-
menced in 1883 ;' that was. in August or September.
o4 Q. 2. And have you been selling burners ever since ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. Whereabouts ?
A. In San Francisco.
Q. 4. You havea store here?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. Where is your store ?
A. 47 Second street.
Q. 6. And what do you sell in that store ?
A. Lamps and coal-oil burners.
Q. 7. Have you sold any considerable number of these burners
since that time?
A. Yes, sir; about ten to twelve thousand.
Q. §. And you are still engaged in selling them ?
A. Yes, sir; I sell them still.
Q. 9. How many sizes of those burners are there?
A. Four sizes—ten-wick burners, twelve-wick burners, sixteen-
wick burners, and twenty-wick burners.
Q. 10. Do you manufacture these burners yourself ?
A. No; only the fixtures.
Q. 11. Where do vou get the burners from ?
A. From Germany.
Q 12. From whom in Germany ?
A. Schwintzer and Graff, in Berlin.
, Q. ha Then you import the burners from Germany and sell ions
vere ?
AQ) _ EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 14. Have you at any time since becoming the owner of this
patent granted to any other person or any other firm the right to
sell these burners?
A. No, except to agents who took them from me.
Q. 15. That is, you have endeavored to keep the patent to your-
self?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 16. Do you understand what is meant by giving a person a
license to operate under a patent?
A. I never gave any license, except that I have established
agencies in the country to sell my burners, but I have never given
them any licenses.
Q. 17. Can you tell us what has been the cost to you of those
burners you get from Germany ?
A. The ten-wick burner laid down here costs me one mark In Ger-
many, and, of course, the cost of importation is about one
DO hundred per cent. One mark is twenty-five cents. The
twelve-wick burner costs me thirty-two cents in Germany,
and the cost of importation makes their net cost to me, laid down
here, about sixty-five cents. The sixteen-wick burners cost me two
marks in Germany, and laid down here cost me about one dollar.
The twenty-wick burners cost me three marks in Germany, and
cost me laid down here about a dollar and a half each.
Q. 18. Did you establish the price of these burners when you
commenced selling them ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 19. How long did you continue selling them at that price ?
A. Until the spring of 1886.
QQ. 20. What was your list of prices up to that time?
A. The twenty-wick burner we sold at retail at six dollars; the
sixteen-wick burner at four dollars; the twelve-wick burners at
three dollars, and the ten-wick burner at two dollars each.
Q. 21. Did you sell any considerable number of burners at those
figures ?
A. Yes, sir; we sold about six to seven thousand at those figures.
Q. 22. Did you afterwards at any time reduce your price ?
A. Yes, sir; the Ist of March, 1886. I sent circulars out before
that time, in which I stated that on the Ist of March that I would
reduce the price. ) |
Q. 25. To what did you reduce the prices on the various sizes ?
A. We sold ten-wick burners at a dollar and a half; twelve-wick
burners at two dollars and a half; the sixteen-wick burners at three
dollars and a half, and the twenty-wick burners at five dollars.
Those were the retail prices.
Q. 24. What were your wholesale prices at first? Look at the
circular which [ show you and tell me what that is.
A. This is a circular which was sent around by me into the
country the Ist of March, 1886.
Q. 25. What was the purpose of the circular ?
A. To show that we reduced the prices.
f
4
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. Al
Q. 26. To whom do you refer by “ we?”
A. To sei
Q. 27. Does the circular show the prices to which you had re-
duced the burners ?
A. Yes, sir.
56 Q. 28. Is there any other writing on that circular to show
anything else?
A. Yes, sir; in my shop I made a new kind of lamp,{and that is
offered to the market in the circular.
(The circular above referred to is introduced in evidence by com-
plainant for the purpose of showing the prices to which the burners
were reduced after the Ist of March, 1886, marked “ Complainant’s
Exhibit Circular.”)
Q. 29. Does the circular show the wholesale or the retail prices?
A. The wholesale prices.
2 30. Is that your handwriting on the margin of the circular?
. Yes, sir.
”) 31. What do the figures written there show?
A. That shows our wholesale prices previous to that reduction.
. 32. What were those prices ?
A. The ten-wick burners were fifteen dollars per dozen, the twelve-
wick burners were twenty-four doilars per dosen, the sixteen-wick
burners were thirty-six dollars ‘per dozen, and the twenty-wick
burners were forty-eight dollars per dozen.
Q. 33. What were the prices to which you reduced them ?
A. The ten-wick burners were reduced to twelve dollars per dozen,
the twelve-wick burners to eighteen dollars per dozen, the sixteen-
wick burners to twenty-seven dollars per dozen, and the twenty- -wick
burners to thirty-nine dollars per dozen.
Q. 54. Why did you reduce your prices at that time ?
A. At this time we reduced the prices on account of the infringe-
ment of this burner, which caused me to reduce the prices.
Q. 3d. Infringement by whom?
A. By Mr. Boesch.
Q. 36. He had been infringing prior to that time, then ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 37. Are you familiar with the lamp and burner trade in San
Francisco?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 388. Did persons wanting to purchase a burner ever come to
your store and tell you that they could get it cheaper at any other
place than you were selling them “at! ?
57 A. Oh, yes; every day they came in and went right around
the corner and bought them there.
Q. 39. Who is right around the corner?
A. Mr. Boesch, on Mission street.
Q. 40. His store was right around the corner from you ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 41. What would those people say when they came into your
place for burners?
6—1408
cane a LIS Ek AST MERE MarR manent a senna ee it LN COT TCO CR OR OD TOD
4? EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AID.
A. First, they asked me for prices of the’ burners. Sometimes
they bought their goods from me. Then they would go around
he corner and come back or send back and countermand their order
for the goods.
Q. 42. When you would tell them the prices of these burners
what would they say ?
A. lf they had been already in Mr. Boesch’s place they would
say they could get them there.
Q. 43. Did any of them ever tell you that they could get them
cheaper at Mr. Boesch’s place?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 44. Did they tell you at what prices they could get them there?
A. Sometimes they told me and sometimes not. It was through
this that I first reduced the prices.
Q. 45. Did that thing occur frequently ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 46. And after that it was, as I understand you, that you re-
duced your prices ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 47. Do you know how many burners you have sold since you
reduced your prices
A. I have only a amount of burners we sold at wholesale. I
have that in the book. Of those I can give the account. If some-
body came in and bought a burner and paid for it I put the money
in my book, but I didn’t put any entry into the book.
Q. 48. You kept vour wholesale sales in your book ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 49. And didn’t keep your retail sales?
A. When [ sold them for cash and delivered them in the store
at retail I put the money in my book and made no entry in the
book. Sometimes when I sold them at wholesale for cash I made
no entry. Whenever I sold them to be sent away, then I put them
on my delivery book.
58 Q. 50. Have you got your books here which show an ac-
count of these last-mentioned sales—that 1 is, where you sold
them for credit ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 51. You kept entries of those sales in your books ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 52. Who kept those books ?
A. My wife kept the books.
Q. 53. Have you any way of telling the number of burners that
vou have sold for cash, at retail, in your store since you reduced your
prices ?
A. No. Sometimes [ sold twenty, sometimes three or four or
five,a day. The average would be perhaps five or six a day.
Q. 54. How high have your sales run in that way at any time—
that is, what is the highest number you have ever sold in one day
at retail ?
A. Say fifteen.
Q. 50. And what is the least number you have sold in a day ?
~~
EMILE BOFSCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF. ET AL. 43
A. Perhaps four burners.
Q. 56. Do you always sell some burners every day ?
A. Yes, sir. ;
Q. 57. Is there ever a day in which your store has been open in
which you didn’t sell any burners at all?
A. I sold every day the burners.
Q.58. And you say the average number of these burners that
you would sell per day would be five or six ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 59. Have you any way of ascertaining how many of those
burners you have on hand now? |
A. Yes, sir. I haven’t a large stock on hand now. I can count
how many I have on hand.
Q. 60. Have you any way of ascertaining how many burners vou
have imported here since the first of March, 1886 ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 61. Have you gota statement now showing how many burners
you have received trom Schwintzer & Graff?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 62. What is the paper I now show you?
A. That is a statement of all burners I have received from
Schwintzer & Graff from December 8th, 18838, up to the present
time. Where in this statement appears “10/’’” that refers to ten-
wick burners; where there appears “14’”” that refers to
a9 twelve-wick burners; “18/’’” refers to sixteen-wick burners,
and “ 30’”” refers to twenty-wick burners.
(The statement above referred to is introduced in evidence by
complainant and marked “Complainant’s Exhibit Importer’s
- Statement.”)
(By Mr. Boone:)
Q. 65. Where did you get this statement ?
A. It was sent to me by Schwintzer & Graff from Germany.
(). 64. Did you send for this list ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 65. Have you compared it with your shipping bilis of lading
that -you have received ?
A. Yes, sir; that is all correct.
Q. 66. Have you compared each of those items with your bilis of
lading ?
A. Yes, sir. . 7
().67. When did you do that?
A. At the time | received this statement.
Q. 68. At the time you received the statement you compared it
with your invoices, did you ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 69. Have you those bills of lading now?
A. No; not all.
(). 70. How many have you?
A. Two or three.
44 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
Q. 71. That is, you have only compared two or " three bills of lad-
ing with this statement ?
A. That 1s all.
Q. 72. Do you know of your own knowledge that each of these
items in this statement is correct. ?
A. Yes, sir; that I know exactly.
Q. 73. You say you haven’t got the bills of lading dioniing each
of the items?
A. No.
Q. 74. What means have you of knowing that this statement is
entirely correct, then? What means of knowledge have you by
which you know positively that each of these items is correct ?
A. By memory, and then from these statements that I have I
know that portion of it is correct.
Q. 75. Have you those items you refer to ?
A. Bills of lading, I mean.
Q. 76. As to the items of which you have no bills of lading, what
means have you of knowing whether or not this statement is cor-
rect ?
A. From my memory.
60 (Respondents object to the admission in evidence of “ Ex-
hibit Importer’s Statement ” on the ground that it is incompe-
tent and irrelevant ; objection overruled ; respondents except.)
(By Mr. Mrrirer:)
Q. 77. What, in your judgment, is the feature in this patented
burner which you consider makes it better than any other burner,
if it is any better?
A. It is the cap at the top.
Q. 78. Is that cap any advantage to a burner ?
A. It isa great advantage.
(). 79. What advantage is it to the burner?
A. It gives a better, whiter flame, and it keeps it clean; without
it it wouldn’t burn.
Q). $80. Suppose you were to take the cap off of your burner and
leave nothing except the round ends of the tubes around the top so
that it became ke the burner “ Exhibit Boesch Burner,” what
would be the effect on the efficiency of the burner ?
(Objected to by respondent and withdrawn.)
Cross-examination of ALBERT GRAFF (by Mr. Boone):
Q. 1. How long do you say you have been importing and selling
these burners ?
A. mone the latter part of 1883.
QJ. 2. And you say that from 1883 up to March Ist, 1886, you =
a fined schedule of prices?
A. Yes, sir.
(). 5. You stated that on the first of March | you changed your
prices, ‘reduced them ?
A. Yes, sir.
de
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 45
Q. 4. Both wholesale and retail ?
A. Both wholesale and retail.
Q. 5. Did you sell any more lamps after you reduced the prices
than you did before ?
61 A. No; Mr. Boesch sold them still cheaper than mine.
; Q. 6. What effect did this reduction of prices have on your
business; did it sell any more lamps for you?
A. No. |
Q. 7. How about the cost of these lamps? Has the cost been the
sanie to you during all this period of time?
A. The cost has been the same. It may have changed a trifle.
I pay the same to Schwintzer & Graff for burners now that I did in
1888. 3 3
Q. 8. Who got up the cireular “ Exhibit Circular?”
A. I got it up.
Q. 9. You circulated this circular among your customers through-
out the country, did you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. Is this circular true, as a matter of fact? Does it state the
truth ?
A. Yes, sir..
Examination-in-chief of ANTOINETTE GRAFF on behalf of
complainant (by Mr. MILLer):
Q. 1. You are the wife of Albert Graff, the complainant?
A. Yes, sir.
(). 2. Do you have anything practically to do with his business ?
A. | am always in the store.
@. 3. What do you do?
A. Attend to customers ; keep the store.
Q. 4. Who keeps the books that are kept?
A. Myself. 7
Q. 5. How long have you been keeping those books?
A. Ever since we opened the store.
(). 6. What kind of books do you keep?
A. [have got them here. Itis not regular book-keeping because
I don’t understand it; but when I get orders I write them in the
books, and then send people bills, and when they pay me I give
them credit. :
Q. 7. Do you put down in the books all the burners that you
sel] ? |
A. Not those that are sold for cash.
Q. 8. What sales do you enter?
62 A. Those sent to the country—the orders from the country.
(). 9. What class of burners is it that vou don’t put down
on your books?
A. Those sold to private people who come into the store and buy
burners for cash.
(). 10. Have you prepared anv statement from your books show-
ing the number of burners you have sold ?
BL PRE LE SARITA LOS OE e é VERS
46 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET ATI..
A. Yes, sir; I put all the burners together and put on a separate
page so many of each size.
Q. 11. Have you that statement here ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 12. Can you tell from that statement how many burners were
sold and the amount of which appears upon your books since March,
1886?
A. Ican do that better from my book than froma statement. That
statement shows how many we had altogether—how many we re-
ceived for the whole time from 1883 until now.
Q. 13. Does it show the different sales of burners, too ?
A. Yes, sir; and the different prices of burners.
Q. 14. Can you refer to your books and tell us, so far as appears
from the books, how many of those burners you have sold since
March, 1886, the time when you reduced your prices?
A. Yes, sir; I have in this book in my own handa record of sales
from March Ist to October 50th.
(.15. Does that represent all the sales which you made during
that time?
A. All the credit sales.
(). 16. It does not represent the cash sales ?
A. No.
Q. 17. From that statement how many burners were sold ?
A. Of the ten-wick burners, thirteen hundred and twelve; of the
twelve-wick burners, four hundred and fifty; of the sixteen-wick
burners, five hundred and ninety-two; of the twenty-wick burners,
seven hundred and sixteen.
Q. 18. That represents the credit sales during that time, I under-
stand ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 19. Did you make any cash sales during that time?
A. Yes, sir; but I haven’t put them down in the book.
Q. 20. Have you any way of judging as to the number of your
cash sales during that time?
A. No, sir; I cannot tell.
63 Q. 21. Did you make cash sales of those burners every day ?
A. Yes, sir.
(. 22. Could you tell about how many burners those sales would
average aoe day during that period from March Ist up to the 30th of
October ?
A. I reckon about five or six burners a day.
(Q). 25. At what price did you make these credit sales ?
A. The twenty-wick burners were sold at thirty-nine dollars a
dozen, the sixteen-wick burners at twenty-nine dollars per dozen,
the twelve-wick burners at eighteen dollars per dozen, and the ten-
wick burners at twelve dollars per dozen.
(. 24. Were those vour wholesale or retail prices ?
A. Wholesale prices.
Q. 25. Do you know why those prices were reduced * 4
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 26. Why?
<> ap
EMILE RBOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET, AL. Al
A. We were compelled to do so.
(). 27. For what reason ?
A. Our customers from the country would say, “ How is it that
you sell burners so much higher than Mr. Boesch does?” We sald,
“Well, we couldn’t sell them any cheaper,” and they said they
couldn’t buy them from us.
Q. 28. Did you receive letters from customers saying that ?
A. No sir; they came personally into the store and told us that.
(). 29. Did more than one person come?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 30. Can you tell how many persons came and made that state-
ment to you? |
A. No; I couldn’t tell the number, but I heard it every day.
(). 31. And you say that was the reason you reduced the prices?
A. Yes, sir.
(Continued, in conformity with agreement of counsel, to Decem-
ber 9th, 1887, at two o’clock p. m.)
Fripay, December 9th, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant; Mr. Boone, of
counsel for respondents; Mr. Boesch, respondent. |
The complainant Graff not appearing, the hearing is further con-
tinued, in conformity with agreement of counsel, to ‘December 13 sth,
1887, at two o’clock p. m.
64 | Tuespay, December 13th, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller,of counsel for complainant; Mr. Boone,
of counsel for respondents; Mr. Graff, complainant ; Mr. Boesch, re-
spondent.
tespondent admits that all times since the time oe respondent
commenced infringing upon complainant’s rights under his patent
complainant has been able to and in condition to supply the trade
with burners, including the patented invention.
(Continued, in conformity with agreement of counsel, to December
14th, 1887, at half past ten o onan a.m.)
(Complainant rests.)
WEDNESDAY, December 14th, 1887.
Present: Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant; Mr. Boone, of
counsel for respondents; Mr. Graff, complainant; Mr. Boesch, re-
spondent.
Examination-in-chief of Emit Borscu on behalf of respond-
ents (by Mr. Boone):
(. 1. You keep books in your business, do you ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 2. Do you enter upon your books the sales of burners that you
sell ?
A. Yes, sir. |
Q. 3. Do your books show all the sales made, wholesale and re-
tail?
OS AOE ANTE an ae me RY
AS EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
A. Yes, sir.
(). 4. Do your books show the number of “ Mitrailleuse”’ burners
having a cap which you sold ?
. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. When vou sell a “ Mitrailleuse ” burner or a multiple-
65 wick burner do you enter what particular style it is that you
sell; whether it has a cap or no cap?
A. No, s sir.
Q. 6. Is there anything in your books to distinguish what partic-
ular construction in that respect the burners sold by you have ?
A. No, sir.
Q.7. What means have you of determining the number of
“ Mitrailleuse ” burners sold by you which have full cap?
A. The means that I related the other day; that when we had
received the notice we had sold so many. Then we stopped selling
them that way. Then a few we sold when you told us to go ahead,
after the other suit was commenced. Then when this suit was
brought we stopped again.
Q. 8. Can you state positively from your own knowledge the num-
ber of “ Mitrailleuse” burners with a full cap, similar to the one de-
scribed in the complainant’s patent, your firm has sold at any time
up to the present date ?
A. No, sir.
Cross-examination of Emin Boescu (by Mr. MILLER):
Q. 1. What books do you keep in which you enter those sales ?
A. What we call our cash book and day books. |
Q. 2. Who keeps the books ?
A. There ts a book-keeper.
Q. 3. What is his name?
A. Artiques.
Q. 4. As the sales are made they are turned in to him and he
enters them in the book ? ,
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. Were any of those sales made while you were away in Eu-
rope ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. How do you come here, then, and testify positively that only
such a number of sales were made if they were made while you were
in Kurope?
A. Because I looked over the books.
Q. 7. Then the testimony that you have given was taken from the
books?
A. From the books and ‘conversations wi ith Mr. Bauer and the
salesman.
(J. 8. They told you how many sales had been made?
A. Yes, sir; the best proof I had was there was a certain number
of burners I had imported, and then there was what we had left and
what we had ordered.
%)
A A Oa AON aR ny RR > ee
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 49
66 Q. 9. You never received but two invoices of those goods ?
A. Only two.
Q. 10. The second invoice was received, I believe, after this suit
was commenced ?
A. Yes, sir; but they were ordered before I left, and Mr. Boone
told us to go on and sell them as we had _ before.
Q. 11. There were two suits against you, were there not ?
A. Yes, sir. |
Q. 12. And do you remember when the first suit was com-
menced ?
A. I could find out, if it was important.
Q. 18. The first suit was commenced after you went to Europe
and was dismissed ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 14. And after that suit was dismissed this present suit was com-
menced ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 15. While you were in Europe did you not know of the pend-
ency of this present case—didn’t Mr. Bauer write to you about it?
A. Yes, sir. |
Q. 16. Didn't you get the affidavits of certain people in Europe ?
A. No, sir; the affidavits have been gotten since I got back.
(). i7. ‘Some affidavits were introduced in this case taken in
Europe. Who attended to that?
A. I didn’t attend to them. I understand that Mr. Boone did.
Q. 18. Do you know Hugo Keppen or Robert Keppen, in Berlin ?
A. By name.
Q. 19. Not personally ?
A. No, sir.
Q. 20. Did you call on him while you were there ?
A. No, sir; I didn’t go to Berlin at all.
Q. 21. From whom did you get these burners in Germany; was
it from Hecht?
A. The first lot was from Carlo Holy, in Berlin, and the second .
lot was from Hecht.
(. 22. And you are certain that those two lots are the only ones
that you ordered ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 23. Did Mr. Bauer write to you about this suit while you were
in Kurope?
A. Yes, sir.
67 Q. 24. And he told you that it was pending?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 20. So that while you were there you knew that it was pend-
in
. Yes, sir; and I wished them to keep it back until I returned.
Q. 26. Were the burners in the first invoice which you got all of
them with caps when they first came?
A. No, sir.
Q. 27. How many of them had ~
A. Fifty had caps like “ Exhibit C
7—1408
OV EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
(). 28. What did the others have on top of the wick tubes ?
A. The same as “ Exhibit 12-Wick Burner.”
(), 29. The second invoice which you got included one hundred
twenty-wick burners and one hundred sixteen-wick burners. Did
they have caps on them when they came here?
A. Yes, sir; like “ Exhibit C.”
Re-examination (by Mr. Boone):
Q. 1. Did you ever sell any burners with a cap like “ Complain-
ant’s Exhibit B?”
A. No, sir. :
(Q). 2. Did you ever have any in your shop?
A. I had twelve.
Q. 3. What did you do with them ?
A. I returned them to the party from whom I[ bought them.
Q. 4. And you say you sold how many like “ Exhibit C?”
A. Fourteen, of different sizes.
Q.5. All the others that you sold were like “ Exhibit Boesch
Burner” and “ Exhibit Miller Burner? ”
A. Yes, sir.
(). 6. State what size those fourteen were that you sold.
A. Eight twenty-wick and six sixteen-wick.
(). 7. Were the sales of these fourteen burners before or after you
went to Europe ?
A. Four were made before and ten after.
(Respondents rest.)
68 Re-examination of ALBERT GRAFF on behalf of complainant
(by Mr. MrItier):
Q. 1. Have you prepared an account of the number of burners of
the kind described in the patent that you have on hand now ?
A. Yes, sir; I have on hand December 14th, 1887, four hundred
and ninety-one ten-wick burners, two hundred and _ sixty-seven
twelve-wick burners, three hundred and sixty-four sixteeu-wick
burners, and one hundred and sixty-nine twenty-wick burners.
[t is agreed that Mr. Miller, of counsel for complainant, shall visit
the place of business of respondents and exe vine their books of ac-
count, and that, should he so desire after such examination, the
books shall be produced before the master, or the witnesses may be
recalled for further examination.
[t is also agreed that in case the master should require further
testimony he shall be at liberty to recall any or all of the witnesses
for further examination.
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 51
68a U.S. C’t Ct., N. Dist. Cal.
GRAFF
Vv. Reference.
BogEscH.
Accounting.
CoMPLAINANT’s Exuipit EXportTer’s STATEMENT. S. C. H., Master.
BERLIN, den 2ten November, 1887.
Zinkgiesserei, Lampen- und Bronce- Waaren-Fabrick Berlins, Sebastian-
Strasse 18, von Schwintzer & Graff, Factura fiir [Herr Albert Greeff,
San Francisco, sandten Ihnen auf Ihre Ordere Rechnung und Gefahr.
S. &. G.
1888.
Decemb. &. 102 St. 10°-- Diamt.-Brenner, Brandsch. Amerik.
Gew'de........ 93 94.86
50 6 [gee a en Eee @ 1.30 65
oo “ ‘a RS i wali archaea 2.00 120
S.* @ “s sa Ee ENC Rn nem 0.29 19.50
1884.
Januar 26. 100 ‘“ 18 os a sai danas 2.00 200
200 ‘ 14 si 5 ili: tiinniak cabal teases 1.30 260
Marz 18. 100 “ 18: “ “ of curls, 4... T. 194
100 ‘* 10°: 6 é és PALA oF asia Racer T 100
100 * 14 “ “ eee T 130
Marz 31. 100 ‘ 14: “ ” me eae = 130
100 ‘ 18: “ i Oe a ai T. 200
96 ‘ 10: “ 4 aks 1.00 96
12 éc 30: ¢é 4 sor ek ee ORE 3 95 39
100 66 Qe 66 ‘6 a pP 100
Juni 5. 400 “ 10+: “4 " gine: en 1.00 400
396 10% “ " ee ee “ 396
Juli 15. 192 * 10 “ “ " bilan wan au 192
125 ‘“ i4 “ “ si canara 1.30 §=162.50
25 “ 18 s ” patio 2.00 50
20 * 30 " “ ” aia ah 3.25 65
1885.
Februar 26. “* ‘ 14--* Diamantbrenner, @ Rand .__.--.------- 1.30 5.20
96 * 4 oa nciiiiiaknSac aie santa ae 124.80.
301 * 10°": ” istdiabioinias Shcaise a
110 6! 618 Pr isi wine neni Se a
100 * «630 m a Likciaiabidin asa: OL)
Marz 16. 90 * 18: “ eitidictiibinisiin wcrc ae aa
6 ‘“¢ 200 * 10 eNO ae 2.10 420
100 * 30 seh eee near OH ere em T. 3b2
500 “ 10 sn @ Varrg.-_---- ere
100 ‘* 14: 6 ee aie =. 130
Novbr. i 2 * ee oe a TOO 93
20 § 30° + a i a 69
54. 10° 9 vernick. @ Varrg. -.-- 1.20 64.80
“ay * do IN ictal acres RO 64.80
24 s+ 14> os ii caceceiteitnieliciptel ce scsevni 1.50 37.20
be
52 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ATBERT GRAFF ET AL.
1884,
October i6. 3 * 30--- Diamantbrenner, Brenner............. 3.26 97.50
BD 8 «9s vs v4 (@, Varrg._._.. 1.00 50
0) é ]&--- as if ; a: eee ee La, TOO AO
AO Gt [R--- ts 66 : ete : » OO 100
30‘ 14s 6 wee rn eS ov
Decemb. So. aa. * . eee 2 74 Rfn. @ Varrg. ----- 1.50 ar)
Ree |4--- 7 Q. sé (a sé 1.65 9 90
yl ae 1&-:- ce q o¢ (a de | 73.50
Li = ** dees ce m. Kglod, @ * oo eae 14. 7¢
Us 50
10 8 14 6 (a, Kd., (a) * vce hoe 12.:
5H | «618 sc ee i 2 00 100
50 6! BOe cs J eo a a.
15) ** 10--- bs jicpaicaeltiagh Sa elec ciel aiicosts isc «RA 151
100 * «14 ot is WO. ck cw on a.
1885,
Januar 31. 299 * 10°: ‘4 | (a) a _.. 1.00 299
120 $6) [fee ss m. s aren ae 1.30 156
48 % 80>: ss ve LMS he mn 1d
$1) 66 BOs ee OG eto eRe nae ore ee ee is 130
19 66 [Rees os 2 OO 392
— —— — © ——_—— ee ee ee re mee
Ee a i ?.10
Mai oe (BM a Be Pe atin cicleaanctcaen eee 26
[2 zi ]&--- Pe a ee ee a sai 4
18 & gee oe is NEE Oe IA Pe eR Ne: 23.40
’ cé 10 a (a) Ra Qe elt Pen es PEM ae Oe ar Re ] aera 4
—
o
~
rman
_—
.
a
~~
eee
_— {
fj om \
~~
o
~
Le
Vw
~
iv
oe)
i-
t
'
{
i
'
— ee ee eee ee me
*
a
-
ose
_
-_—
-_
~
-“~
)
SS
pee
.
¥ KS
Se =
1.
—"
—
S
— ee ee ee eee ee
a
a
bot
—!
~~
ws
~
ae
==
~~ \
~
a
~
*
| ‘
. .
a
~~
ed
—"
o 4)
-
we
Am
—
to oo
—— ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee
66 1.55 }8.60
Deed
- tS
~ ~
~ e - .
~ nm 6 S °
ee ed
DP —
=
.
~ o~
o~ ~~
Lom d
—
~
te
+
Nee
—
New
©
-_~
~
S
te
Ts
om
2)
{
j
t
i
i
i
!
'
j
i
|
'
i
{
|
i
;
i
i
i
’
—
Ce
©
~j
to
Deceinb 21 150 66 BQee- 7 7 ce 450
SO Jee a Ot UE ide a: ee 77.090
ry kt 10+. is (a Varre FP I AEP LEON TT RT NED AD 1.00 8)
2.* Diamt.-Beemner 16 nickel ..............-... 2.30 27.60
asa vs 1O--- tomb, @ Vartg.......... 1.20 20.40
24 ‘© Untertheile a 1.30 31.20
10 (4 a2 Bue 2 OO 24
Teld)
ee ee ee ee ee eee ee ee ee ee
1&6,
t
Augus 23. 260 * Diamt.-Br. oo Daetertaes...........- 3.00 730
¢é sc
1QQ «5 cs IT TR a 3.28 328
1 “6 ans I re ee) ee 242.40
202. * $4 iO--- nickel (@ Ver uuu. 116 232
ip lO--- Messg. @ ee ee ene GH 336
3) ¢! be Be a | ae 432
QO + v6 | oe See | Rey 140
vw & s6 LS*> om. * ee ee a a 92.50
LRSH,
December 11, 2023 « eee Cee Re eRe eo me, fe 203
‘Ee oe pee a Oe ae L4s.80
| ié ié {-4--- be Sr RES Sere se 7 ff | HW)
Br 64 4 [Ss--- as 4, ea MRE AYO
}OO «+ i Is ‘ : = ss YOO
op. * i oe RA SEL Ome. L180
Pee
“ ~~,
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. 55
1887,
Septbr. 17. 300 “ Diamt.-Br. ESE ESSE 1 Maayan aes te a 3.00 900
RS ts oe i ag ?i4
100. ¢¢ 6 RCO ene perme on cr 135
Vee « ‘“ Bs Whe oe oi nese nen 1.15 331.20
765 ‘ 10+ @ Varrg.-. -_-- heal is G2 703.80
100 & be 1S8°-:- ss SSP TS Rae SO ON 5 S85
QO] v 10-5 a
23 4 “ eee ta eae eee 1.85 42.55
125 « ‘ 18-5 6 pel a ANE “981.95
55 «és ce 18:-> bs PIO OE ae eare ne ae 66 101.75
g 4 “ 145 4 So ae 9.20
3 v Oe. ee eee 96 12.48
69 CoMPLAINANT’s Exurpit Crrcutar. S.C. H., Master.
U.S. Circuit Court, N. Dist. Cal.
GRAFF
v. Reference. Accounting.
BoeEscH.
A.S. Graff & Co., importers and wholesale dealers in lamps and
patentees of the Diamond coal-oil burner, 47 Second street, San
Francisco.
SAN Francisco, J/’ch 1st, 1886.
Charles Schwartz, Marysville.
Dear Six: We wish to place before you this reduced price-list of
Graff’s patent Diamond burner.
Since the time that this burner was placed on the market it has
met with such approval and has convinced everybody of its merits
that we feel confident that with our reduction in prices it will be the
leading coal-oil burner throughout the States.
|
ou | Per doz.| | Per doz.
| | |
15 00 | 10-wick burners ---.! $12 00 | Chimneys for 10-wick burners__-. $1 75
24.00; 12 * Neo ee) “ ee wae, 2 OO
386 0O | 16 *& x onal oe ”" “36 * a anneal 2 60
48 00 | 20 « “ oi} 89 08 | «BQ oo
These reduced prices are for cash only. A full assortment of
founts, harps, and hanging table lamps always on hand, and we
call your special attention to our own manufactured “ common-sense
stand lamp.”
As there will be a large demand with these low prices, we would
advise you to place your orders as early as possible and oblige,
Yours truly, A. S. GRAFF & CO.
HA EMILE BOESCH
70
U.S. Cireuit Court, N.
GRAFF )
Uv.
ET AL. VS.
> Reference.
COMPLAINANT'S Exutipir DEFENDANT'S BILL.
ALBERT GRAFF ET AL.
S. C. H., Master.
Dist. Cal.
Accounting.
Borscn.
Pacific Lamp and Reflector Factory.
Opal and silver-plated
corrugated glass re-
flectors ; successor to
Robert Mills’ Orna-
mental Lamp Factory ;
Patent locomotive head-
lis ght s. mill and min-
ing lamps, ornamental
globe and plain stree. |, - ra
ae Payable in U.S
lamps °
Shi p, railroad, ear, coach gold coin. plum bers’ copper ware
and every other style and general metal
of lamps and reflect- spinning and stamp-
ors ing.
SAN Francisco, Feb’y 28, 1886.
Alta Pub. Co. to Emile Boesch, Dr., 583 & 585 Mission street, just
below Second.
Architectural ornaments of pressed and cast zine.
Jal OL SX F2 e, O BF. ccnnvndnnceiin o 20
ok Oe 10 sila palates siatapieaiiaiailiipiie diac itd 2
Poe) 6.) 2 POG TAI. bien scnonmneinanenien O
1 sha de IE ici he diens 1
1]. 2 jamps, D. founts & Diamond burner
7) SERRA alba sper races emer eNionpa ee sar gt ened gaa 5 SO
5. ] bracket lamp (B. burner, chim., & shade) 2
ie” S0F. 11 SRNRO i nonccuinee as satis es
Ee RE PONE owe nik ores 12 50
i7. 2jamps, D. founts & Diamond bur.---- dS 80
24. 2 18” tin shi NE scenic econ 2
~ 2 chimneys for Diamond burner__------ S0
oo 1d
As is " sale POT) AS SRA aA CeO eae SO
+e ond
e >) YD
Paid May J, ’86.
ee IE
a ae
wan wore Tinea wiabcne dP ig sok, eae pas oe f
EMILE BOESCIL ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. AO
71 CoMPLAINANT’S Exuipir DeEFENDAN?’s Business CAkD. S.C.
HI., Master.
U.S. Cireuit C’t, Cal.
— .,
| Reference. Accounting.
Sess KSCH
Pacific Lamp and Reflector Factory.
Emile Boesch, 588 and 585 Mission street, just below Second, San
Francisco. Patent locomotive, mining, cable-car, railroad, ship,
coach, and street lamps; opal and silver pl: uted corrugated glass
reflectors and sun liehts for lighting and ventilating churches,
halls, stores, ete.; Diamond coal-vil burners ; square, ‘round, and
tubular lanterns. Gold, silver, and bronze medals awarded for
best lamps and reflectors. Metal spinning and stamping.
(Endorsed :) Filed April 30th, 1888. L. 5S. B. Sawyer, clerk, by
I. D. Monckton, deputy clerk.
12 Exceptions to Master's Report.
In the Cireuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern
District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF et al., Complainants,
: Us.
EMitrE Borscu e al., Defendants. (
Exceptions taken by the said respondents to the report of S.C.
Houghton, Esq., the standing master in chancery of this honor-
able court to whom this cause stands referred, bearing date the
20th day of April, 1858.
First exeeption. For that the said master has in and by his said
report certificd on page six thereof that “the cap was the essential
feature of the Graff burner. ‘The respondent adopted Graff's ar-
pangement, and then reduced the price of the burner, forcing Grafl
to do the same in order to hold his trade. The evidence shows that
the reduction in prices by Gralf was solely due to the respondents’
Infr.igement. So far as the evidence shows, the only competitor
with Graff in the use of his cap arrangement during the period
covered by the accounting was the responaent;” whereas the said
master ought to have ce — tlisit Spapenatens CAINE Laeonniey
of kaneis ren Siren amend iclurers aleeeel: in Geri: any, atid
that immediately upon being notified that they were claimed to be
an infringement he ceased to sell the same. The evidence shows
that at about the time Graff made the alleged reduction in the price
of his burners there was thrown upon the market lanip burners of
other kinds of equal or greater power, which came di rectly 11s COM
OG EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AT.
petition with the Graff burner, and that the reduction in price was
the result of such competition ; that the sale of 14 infringing burners
by respondent in the course of three years’ trade could not have
been a sufficient competition to plaintiff’s business to cause him
to make a reduction of price, where the testimony shows
79 that during the period from March Ist, 1886, when com-
plainant reduced the price of burners, until Oct. dlst, 1887,
he sold about 6,000 of said burners.
Second exception. For that the said master hath wintiied “ that
the amount of damages which the complainant has suffered and
sustained from and by reason of said infringement is two thousand
nine hundred and seventy dollars and fifty cents ;” whereas he
should have reported nominal damages.
In all which particulars the report of the said master is, as the
said respondent is advised, erroneous, and the said respondent ap-
peals therefrom to the judgment of this honorable court.
May 24th, 1888.
SCRIVNER. & BOONE,
Solicitors for Responde nts.
(Endorsed :) Service and ayy of a copy of within exceptions
admitted this 24th day of May, 1888. Langhorne «& Miller, attor-
nevs for compl. Filed May 25,1888. L. 8S. B. Sawyer, clerk, by
F. D. Monckton, deputy clerk.
74 At a stated term, to wit, the November term, A. D. 1888,
of the circuit court of the United States of America of the
ninth judicial circuit in and for the northeri district of California,
held at the court-room, in the city and county of San Francisco, on
Monday, the 28th day of January, in the year of our Lord one thou-
sand eight hundred and eighty-nine.
Present: The Honorable Lorenzo Sawyer, circuit judge.
Copy of Order Overruling Exceptions to Master’s Report.
A. GRAFF
vs. No. 4107.
E. Borscn et al.
This cause, heretofore heard and submitted to the court for con-
sideration and decision upon the exceptions to the master’s report
herein, having been duly considered, it is ordered that said excep-
tions be, and the same hereby are overruled and a decree filed and
entered herein for complainant and for costs.
7a Enrollment.
In the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern
District of California.
ALBERT GRAFF et al., Complainants,
vs. | + No. 4107.
EMILE Boescu, Respondent.
The complainants filed their bill of complaint herein on the 17th |
day of September, 1886, which is hereto annexed.
mene aga 3 sail
ete 6”
lead
é
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. eo)
A subpcena to appear and rang) in said cause was thercupon
issued, returnable on the first day of November, A. D. 1886, which
is hereto annexed.
On the 19th day of October, 1886, an amended bill of complaint
was filed herein, which is hereto annexed, and a subpcona to appear
and answer said amended bill of complaint was thereupon Issued,
returnable on the sixth day of December, 1886; which subpcena is
hereto annexed.
The respondents appeared herein on the 6th day of December,
1886, by Scrivner and Boone, Esqs., their solicitors.
An answer was filed herein on the 3rd day of January, 1887, and
is hereto annexed.
A replication to said answer was filed herein on the Slst day of
January, 1887, and is hereto annexed.
An interlocutory decree was filed and entered herein on 17th day
of October, 1887, which is hereto annexed.
On the 30th day of April, 1888, a master’s report was filed herein
and is hereto annexed.
Exceptions to said master’s report were filed herein on the 25th
day of May, 1888, and are hereto annexed.
On the 28th day of January, 1889, an order overruling said ex-
ceptions was entered herein; a copy of which order is hereto an-
nexed.
Thereafter a final decree was filed and entered herein in the wun
and figures following, to wit:
716 7 Final Decree.
In the Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Cireuit, Northern
District of California. ;
ALBERT GRAFF and J. F. DONNELL, Jomplainants, }
US. No. 4107.
EMILE Borscu and Martin Bauer, Sieishininn 4
At a stated term of the circuit court of the United States of
America of the ninth judicial circuit in and for the northern dis-
trict of California, held at the court-room thereof, in the city and
county of San Francisco, on Monday, the 28th day of January, A.
D. 1859. :
Present: The Honorable Lorenzo Sawyer, circuit Judge.
This cause having been heard by the court at the October term
thereof, in the year 1888, on the pleadings and proofs, documentary
and oral, te cal filed therein, and an interlocutory decree having
been entered and filed in said cause on the 17th day of October, A.
D. 1587, wherein it was ordered, adjudged, and decreed that the
letters patent of the United States issued on the 4th day of Decem-
ber, 1883, to Carl Schwintzer and William Graff, of Berlin, Ger-
many, assignors of one-half to J. F. Donnell & Company, of New
York, numbered No. 289 71, entitled “ A lamp burner,” were vood
and valid in law; that the said Carl Schwintzer and William Graff
were the original and first inventors of the invention therein
S8—1405
58 EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET Atf..
claimed ; that the complainants herein were the sole and exclusive
owners thereof, and that the said respondents, Emile Boesch
77 and Martin Bauer, bad infringed upon the exclusive rights
of the complainants under the same, and which said inter-
locutory decree further ordered that the matter be referred to S. C.
Houghton, Esq., master in chancery in said court, to take, state, and
report to this court an accounting of lamp burners sold by respond-
ents containing the invention claimed in and by the first claim of
said letters patent, and also the gains, profits, and advantages which
the said respondents have made and received or which have arisen
or accrued to them since the 4th day of Dec -mber, 1888, from and
by infringing the said first claim of said letters patent, as well also
the amount of damages which the complainants have sustained by
reason of any infringement by said respondents of the first claiin of
said patent since said 4th day of December, 1883.
And the said master having filed his report in pursuance of the
order contained contained in ‘said decree assessing and fixing the
said damages sustained by complainants at the sum of. $2,970.50,
and the court having this day confirmed said report and ordered
that a final decree be entered in accordance therewith for said sum,
with costs.
And it further appearing that the complainants herein have
waived all claims for any and all gains, profits, and advantages
which respondents have received or have arisen or accrued to them
from and by reason of said infringement : 3
Now, therefore, it is ordered, adjudged, and decreed that the said
complainants, Albert Graff and J. F. Donnell, do have and recover
from the said respondents, Emile Boesch ana Martin Bauer, and
that the said respondents do pay to the said complainants the said
sum of $2,970.50, with interest thereon at the rate of seven per cent.
per annum from the 50th day of April, 1888, the same being the
day on which the master filed his said report, and for complainants’
proper costs and disbursements in this cause, taxed at the sum of
$212.60 (see cost bill on entry of interlocutory decree, and also one
filed on entry of tinal decree).
LORENZO SAWYER,
Cireuit Judge.
Dated February 13th, A. D. 1889.
(Endorsed :) Filed & entered Feb. 18,1889. L.S. B. Sawyer, clerk.
78 Memorandum of Costs, ete.
UNITED SraTES OF AMERICA:
Circuit Court of the United States, Ninth Circuit, Northern District
of California:
A. S. GRAFF et als., Plaintiffs
silica , Memorandum of Costs and
vs. ai
- Jisbursements.
Eurie Boescu et als., Defendants. Disbursements
Disbursements: _ |
Marshal’s fees, serving process ---~-. Pee AMR Cee Oe . 60
EEE ESO te ER EE OEE EEO 17 75
6 “ issuing subpoona for def’t Bauer ....--- meme ene 1 30
EMILE BOESCH ET AL. VS. ALBERT GRAFF ET AL. | 59
Marshal’s fees, serving same on Bauer _-----....---.---- $2 10
Counsel fee for examining & cross-examining eight wit-
nesses whose depositions were offered and admitted in
~ evidence (see names on back hereof), @ $2.50 each ---- 20
i us nanan cohteiaeile dh ie niga 20)
Fees of examiner for taking testimony.-----.---------- 5D
Affidavit to bill — complaint iss ademas hea ici 50
° ‘am’d ATE - side leila iad ened oO
s Oy Ee a dhitk ie ie rece inniaan 25
2.15 p. m., no one appearing to oppose same, taxed at ---- $119 40
L. S. B. SAWYER, Clert,
By F. D. MONCKTON, Dep’y CUR.
Unitep States oF AMERICA, .
Northern District of California, City and County of San Francisco, §
79 J. H. Miller, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he is
one of the attorneys for the complainant in the above-en-
titled cause, and as such is better informed relative to the above
costs and disbursements than the said complainant.
That the items in the above memorandum contained are correct,
to the best of this deponent’s knowledge and belief, and that the
said disbursements have been necessarily incurred in the said cause.
J. H. MILLER.
Subscribed and sworn to bef
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.