Record and brief — Charles C. Harrison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W. Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Jr. Plaintiffs in Error, vs. Edwin A. Merritt, Collector of the Port of New York

Supreme Court brief1884

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SON aig Reet eed ee ER To . Raph Des id

a a SGN ASME acres Rn CnC Pe? gon St, SBS

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 183855.

No. 913.

CHARLES C. HARRISON, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER,

ALFRED C. HARRISON, WILLIAM W. HARRISON, AND

WILLIAM W. FRAZIER, Jr., PLAINTIFFS IN ERROR,

VS

EDWIN A. MERRITT, COLLECTOR OF THE PORT OF

NEW YORK.

IN ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR

THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.

FILED AUGUST 10, 1885.

PRS.

Fe

naa

a) Se

° +4 Se i,

3 ae

py *

bedi»

oe

‘SS Wk STF

75 ¢ « 7 ¢

ss

Bs Gla ees

ag,

is « 2

s ot as

i

RAS RPE E98 AD REY RORNT Rp EOE 5.8

ar 5 bss Tae CO ae ee ee

LORRI AA BN RAST EY PE

eeenari Aidpinhromnnetnnt iter!

fe

sacs

a

St

wan

rane

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1885

No. 913.

CHARLES C. HARRISON, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER,

ALFRED C. HARRISON, WILLIAM W. HARRISON, AND

WILLIAM W. FRAZIER, Jr., PLAINTIFFS IN ERROR,

VS

EDWIN A. MERRITT, COLLECTOR OF THE PORT OF

NEW YORK.

IN ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR

THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.

IN DEX.

Original. Print.

Writ of error .__-. sSibikc ak aie aca sic da ocala ava make. posiieh Weleda uals Sak uals auaate

Clerk’s certificate ... ...... ...--..

Summons asad Gidlcwens Saeiea a asec: Seba Sap cine Sb tas cals ecamansace

Certiorari _... .. Sa Rear

oles OE RPC on oe inks ins Sc eee cms sneies vanite seca

CIN Sia soci especies Za ts. db et dere Sin: anced Spin alain we

Answer... ..__ i ES

Minutes of trial ...... 2... 2.2. -- 22. Le

Judgment ° : isles ace sheeesior icsinpigarie Schoen oaiea

Bill of exceptions -.._-

Protests. 65. os ek < isecin sacl inio Geese aakeabdle ap ae dame

Testimony of Frank Henn -. sessile sleigh day Wana

Isaac W. Drummond sila asian

Hamilton H. Salmon... -—.. ..---. .--- ..-. -.---. --

Frederick W. Simmonds ....

Henry P. 8. Chambers

os

call caval cael

AWM wWmM DOMDODAM RN N & =

pe

Qo

i

Qo

JUDD & DETWEILER, PRINTERS, WASHINGTON.

INDEX.

Original. Print.

ll

Testimony of John Muller ...--.-._. ..-- -----. --- 2+. ---- ~~. - 45 21

John Kehoe 4 : 23

Hamilton H. Salmon (recalled) .--..---.. .. 5 24

Henry A. Simonds

en ONE SIG ood cia nun Ren es Sake heed sans iw ks bee basen

Assignment of errors. ... ...- .----- ---.------ ---- as

en ie I ia ais veins chtndidnidania wood cemte: Secelens dipeiaih

ee ee ee a ee ee le

Ne ee na alae eae enh idan Ws shee

ek ld idl cg! ca sh wd wb + uid sb

PRT Tc ane, |

RPE Pa ease

es

Pte, Me

patie: te

a ae et

: om

~~ r

Pug >

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS, VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT,

1 Unirep Sratxs or AMERICA, 8:

The President of the United States to the judges of the circuit court _

of the United States for the southern district of New York, Greet-

ing: |

Because in the recordsand proceedings and also in the rendition

of the judgment of a plea which is in the said circuit court before

you, between Charles C. Harrison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred

C. Harrison, William W. Harrison and William W. Frazier, Junior,

aascapeies and Edwin A. Merritt, defendant, a manifest error hath

appened to the great damage of the said Charles C. Harrison, Theo-

dore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W. Harrison, and

William W. Frazier, Junior, plaintiffs, as by their complaint appear:

We being willing that the error; if any hath been, shonld be duly

corrected, and full and speedy justice done to the parties aforesaid

in this behalf, do command you, if judgment be therein given, that

under your seal, distinctly and openly, you send the record and pro-

ceedings aforesaid with all things concerning the same to the Supreme

Court of the United States, together with this writ, so that you may

have the same at Washington on the second Monday of October,

eighteen hundred and eighty-five, in the said Supreme Court, to be

then and there held, that the record and p ings aforesaid, be-

ing inspected, the said Supreme Court may cayse further to be done

thereon to correct that error, what of right and according to the laws

and customs of the United States should be done.

Witness the Honorable Morrison R. Waite, Chief Justice of the

said Supreme Court, the 6th day of August, in the year of our Lord

one thousand eight hundred and signe Sve.

(Seal of the U. 8S. Circuit Court, South. Dist., New York.

TIMOTHY GRIFFITH, Clerk.

The forgoing writ is hereby allowed.

Aug. 6, 1885. ADDISON BROWN.

2 [Endorsed :] U. S. Supreme Court. Charles C. Harrison,

Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W:

Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Junior, plaintiffs in error, against

Edwin A. Merritt, defendant in error. Writ of error. Service of

copy of within notice is hereby admitted, this 6th day of August,

1885. Wm. Dorsheimer, U.S. att’y. [Stamped:] U.S. circuit court. ;

Filed Aug. 6, 1885. Timothy Griffith, clerk.

Unitep STATES OF AMERICA, \ es

Southern District of New York, :

I, Timothy Griffith, clerk of the circuit court of the United States

for the southern district of New York, in the second circuit, by

3 virtue of the foregoing writ of error, and in obedience thereto, do

hereby certify that the following er oe from four to

sixty-five, inclusive, contain a true and complete transcript of the

records and proceedings had in said court in the case of CharlesC. Har-

rison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W. Har-

rison, and William W. Frazier, Junior, plaintiffs in error, against

1—913

<a

te! p> TTT i Dat ti ei SS ie reir a er, wi a wats Lee Sete Ete ee ,

é. Sek” Cie” ae a eee Rs Ei IP aa oe Death OF et osx,

eee aA ae t r Sin nds:

2 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET AILS. V8. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

Edwin A. Merritt, defendant in error, as the same remain of record

and on file in said office. } |

In testimony whereof I have caused the seal of the said court to

be hereunto affixed, at the city of New York, in the southern dis-

trict of New York, in the second circuit, this sixth day of August, —

in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-

four, and of the Independence of the United States the one hundred

and tenth.

[Seal of U.S. Circuit Court, South. Dist. of New York.]

TIMOTHY GRIFFITH, Clerk.

4 Summons.

Superior Court of the City of New York.

CHARLES C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED C. HAr-

RISON, WILLIAM W. Harrison, WILLIAM W. FRazIrR, Jr., Plain-

tiffs,

against

Epwin A. Merritt, Defendant.

To the above-named defendant, Edwin A. Merritt:

You are hereby summoned to answer the complaint in this action

and to serve a copy of your answer on the plaintiff’s attorney within

twenty days after the service of this summons, exclusive of the day

of service, and in case of your failure to appear, or answer, judg-

ment will be taken against you by default, for the relief demanded

in the complaint.

Dated, New York, Nov. 14, 1881.

ISAAC PHILLIPS,

Plaintiff’s Attorney.

Office and post-office address: Isaac Phillips, No. 59 Liberty street,

New York city, N. Y. |

5 [Endorsed :] Superior court city of New York. Charles C.

Harrison & others ag’st Edwin A. Merritt. Summons. Isaac

Phillips, plaintiff’s attorney, 59 Liberty St., N. Y-

6 The President of the United States of America, to the judges

of the superior court of the city of New York, Greet-

[zt.s.] ing:

We, for certain reasons, being desirous that our circuit court of

the United States for the southern district of New York, in the

second circuit, shall be certified of a certain cause commenced before

you against Edwin A. Merritt, defendant, by Charles C. Harrison &

al., plaintiffs, do therefore commaind you that the record and pro-

ceedings in the said cause you distinctly and openly send to the

said circuit court, at the city of New York, on the 5th day of Dec’r,

1881, as fully and amply as the same are remaining before you, by

whatever names the said parties may be called therein, together

with this writ, that our said court may cause to be further done

thereupon what of right ought to be done.

Witness Morrison R. Waite, Esquire, Chief Justice of the Supreme

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &c. :

Court of the United States, the 30th day of Nov., in the year one

thousand eight hundred and eighty-one.

JOSEPH M. DEUEL, Clerk.

STEWART L. WOODFORD,

United States Attorney, Attorney for Defendant.

7 [Endorsed :] 7454. U.S. circuit court. Charles C. Har-

rison & al. versus Edwin A. Merritt. Certiorari. Stewart L.

Woodford, United States attorney, attorney for defendant.

Due service of a copy of the within and of the above notice is

hereby admitted.

ISAAC PHILLIPS,

Plaintiff’s Att’y.

‘09 F s9foul

-OABHT ‘UOST1IVH Jo wig

Suisodwoo “ae ‘iejzeag

. ne : “AM UIBITT MA ‘COs }1I8H “MM

18, ‘8@ Aju | 18, ‘sz Aine | 18, ‘og Aine 18, ‘26 oun | 18,°e oune [“"TopuEeR |***"elAsH "POUl¥as Cust itt *UO8I IIB HY °C) poly

‘ez Aine | 18,83 Ayne | 18, ‘og Aine 18, ‘12 Avy | 18, ‘ee Ldy | "yorwu0op, uvsieg |*uopuoy >| Jo ‘punois ‘poeuto -|V ‘s9A0Ul0ABH “Y e10p

%° 18, °% “ny | 18, ‘og Ajne 18, ‘42 eunr “""UDIBUOW! UBISlog | UOpUuO’y ) | -[8o ‘peuinq—seuo0g | -val], ‘aoofliey ‘¢ selIByD

“1881 “1881 "1881

‘esIpuByd

-10Ul JO UOTdII08eq ‘10}10d Wy Jo euByy

"128804 JO OUIBN

4803010

Suzy jo o%q

*‘poqiod uly

soUuey Mh A

A

*[sodds uo uo

-sjoap JO e}¥q

298 04

jsodds jo o48q

“qu9ul

-Avd jo 07%q

‘pouwsld sso

-xe jo JunOWY

‘asnoy Wo snd

qv £13U9 Jo 038

*VDIOAUT JO O78]

jo

‘ISSI ‘FI “AON podueutut0s ying = (T)

‘suppnoytog fo Ng

3

E

:

a

<

--

C3

a

=

>

4

<

B

:

0

eS

<

<=)

oS

B

|

=

:

4

. Superior Court.

Cuar.es C. Harrison & others against Enwin A. Mereitr. (1)

New York, November 28, 1881.

Str: Please take notice that the following or within is a bill of

particulars of the plaintiff’s demand in this action, which is brought

to recover money erroneously and illegally exacted of and from the

laintiffs by the defendant, as collector of customs of the port of

New York, and as for duties on merchandise imported in the vessels

and at the dates specified in said bill of particulars, to which add

legal interest on the amounts from the dates of payment, as afore-

said. :

Yours, &c., ISAAC PHILLIPS,

Plaintiffs’ Attorney.

STEWART L: WOODFORD, Escq.,

Defendant's Attorney.

[Endorsed:] N.S. 7454. Superior court. Charles C. Harrison &

others ag’t Edwin A. Merritt. Bill of particulars. Isaac Phillips,

attorney for plaintiffs. Due service of copy of within bill of partic-

ulars and notice is hereby admitted. New York, ——, 188—-. ——

, attorney for defendant.

10 Complaint. (1.) ‘

Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of

: New York.

CHARLES C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER,

Alfred C. Harrison, William W. Harrison, & Will-

iam M. Frazier, Jr., Plaintiffs,

against

Epwin A. Merritt, Defendant.

N. 8. 7454.

Plaintiffs complain :

1st. That defendant was, during the times hereinafter named, col-

lector of customs of the United States at the port of New York.

2d. That plaintiffs were, during said times, partners in trade,

under the firm name of Harrison, Havemeyer & Co., and as such

duly imported and entered at the port of New York the goods de-

scribed in the bill of particulars annexed, and as served on defend-

ant or his attorney.

8d. The defendant, as such collector, exacted from plaintiffs, as

and for duties thereon, viz, at the rate of twenty-five per centum ad

valorem. |

4th. That by the laws of the United States the said goods were

entitled to free entry and were exempt from duty, being “ bones

burned, calcined, ground, or steamed,” but plaintiffs, in order to

obtain said goods, were compelled to pay the defendant, as such

collector, the sum of seven thousand and two hundred twenty-four

tes dollars, in gold coin of the United States, in excess of the —

amount required by law.

he ne ae LSM BS ge

SE Sie ng sas beat

ce

: ARNE STE Rap are 9 ge

APOE DY oot hl AIS A Tea 5 DEER Si

Rae hal his jk m PRR gk 2 BS ae ate

6 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

5th. That plaintiffs filed with said defendant due and timely pro-

tests, in writing, upon each entry of said goods against his decision

exacting such duty, setting forth distinctly and specifically the

grounds of objection thereto, and also as above stated.

6th. That plaintiff- made due and timely appeals, in each case, to

the Secretary of the Treasury, who has affirmed the decision of de-

fendant as to certain of said entries, and as to the rest of said entries

has neglected to answer said appeals, and more than ninety days |

had elapsed since said unanswered appeals when this action was

commenced.

7th. That the bill of particulars hereto annexed, and as served on

defendant or his attorney, states for each importation separately the

date of entry at the custom-house of tle payment of duty in excess,

of the filing of the said protests, of the appeal to the Secretary of the

Treasury, and of his decision thereon, together with the other par-

ticulars required by law, and is made a part hereof. |

8th. That said sum, so exacted as aforesaid, has never been repaid

to plaintiffs, and is still due and owing to them.

Wherefore plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant for

seventy-two hundred & twenty-four 7;°, dollars in United States gold

coin, with interest on the several sums named in the bill of particu-

lars, from the several dates of payment as appear thereby, together

with costs and disbursements of this action.

ISAAC PHILLIPS,

Attorney for Plaintiffs.

11 STATE OF NEw YorK, \

City and County of New York, { *:

, of the plaintiffs, being duly sworn, says: He has read the

foregoing complaint; that the same is true to his own knowledge,

except as to the matters therein stated to be alleged on information

and belief, and that as to those matters he believes it to be true.

Signed and sworn to before me, , 188—.

[Endorsed :] N.S. 7454. United States circuit court. Charles C.

Harrison & others against Edwin A. Merritt. Complaint. Due

service of a copy hereof is hereby acknowledged this day of

; , att’y for def’t. Isaac Phillips, pl’ffs’ at-

torney, 59 Liberty street, New York city.

12 United States Circuit Court, Southern District of New York.

CHARLES C. Harrison & al.

versus ‘

Epwin A. Merritt, Collecto?, etc.

The answer of the defendant herein, by Stewart L. Woodford, his

attorney, to the complaint of the plaintiffs in the above-entitled

action.

I. He admits he was, at the times in said complaint mentioned, -

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. vB. EDW

collector of the port of New York, and in such official cap

ceived payment from the plaintiffs for and on account of duties due

to the United States, under the laws thereof, upon certain importa-

tions of merchandise imported by said plaintiffs into the port of

New York from foreign countries. |

II. He alleges that any and all moneys received by him from

plaintiffs, at the times in said complaint mentioned, were paid by

| said plaintiffs as a debt due by them to the United States, and not

< otherwise, and were received by defendant, by virtue of his office as

| said collector and under the direction of the Secretary of the Treas-

ury, and for and on account of the United States, and were forth-

with thereafter, and before the commencement of this action, or the

service of any protest, paid into the Treasury of the United States;

and that the amount of said moneys, so received from plaintiffs,

were the amounts due from them to the United States, according to

the rate of duty imposed by law upon the several articles of mer-

chandise by them imported and assessed with the duty, and no

other sums than duties regularly assessed, and ascertained and liq-

uidated, according to law, upon the plaintiffs’ import entry thereof

were collected or received by defendant from the plaintiffs.

III. And defendant further answering denies that he has at this

time sufficient information to form a belief as to the precise descrip-

tion of the merchandise contained in the several packages referred

rf «4 to in the said complaint, by the marks and numbers and description

there given, except in so far as to state, and defendant herein an-

» 2 swering doth aver and state, that said merchandise was not dutia-

ble, according to the laws of the United States, at the rates specified

in the complaint.

IV. And defendant further answering admits that plaintiffs filed

with defendant certain protests, but he denies that he has sufficient

information to form a belief as to whether, upon the importations

in question, protests and appeals were made by the plaintiffs con-

formable to the laws of the United States; and defendant leaves

plaintiffs to make such proof thereof as they may be advised.

V. And as to any other allegations in said complaint contained,

not hereinbefore fully answered or admitted, defendant denies the

same, and each thereof, and leaves the plaintiffs to make such proof

thereof as they may be advised.

Wherefore defendant demands judgment; that the complaint be

dismissed with costs.

| STEWART L. WOODFORD,

> 3 Untted States Attorney; Attorney for Defendant.

13 SouTHERN District oF NEw ee

City and County of New York,

Edwin A. Merritt, being duly sworn, says that he is the defendant

| above named, and that the foregoing answer is true to his own

knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated to be alleged on

city re

412

ate

re | i pie sex Sn Ba ght Rey ho PS tek Ay io PB hp Ly EN cin Sf aka Dee ey GARY ORE Ae «' Ry oi

et pre: ars rer t we ieee Steet! LP pesos z Ax ES AP Lior bk Bees OR ent ah ete) Sah ae Maal SAL GEt oe Tap meme A *

RAS SOP Fs PRE GS aay eh De SRO RE as ME MY eT ROS er ORES ME ie ned ea a deme A TTP PE Se AT EN PT ere et Pik ear Set et ed i a =

. . , 5 Tar i Ra oe ea *y 9) nega f Ter Leas te RL CRS eT aa Sa AE AY Be eee Pe

LO CPR GLI ON Reenter eases rae : - , oa : 5 cage ae ee . Ba Ne sia ath pat ATi) eee

4 aeaienes

2 eo wea PERT ae -

prea

ae ae {KS

\ | SSSR ia eerie once onesanrs meceecey,

os ARR SS at

eect abeohe Hesewey ae: onan adiveteh eee - ee 4

A . e ws oF ra ae

ve

mea 4

ea See Pecte ee ape Put ck esate Ce

BE Oy Raa

aastatnanenenn meee

(ate “ ae

PS ERO OBE ES Ae OR RRA A

Sa capeerne wearer tre NN

8 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

information and belief, and as to those matters he believes it to be

true.

Sworn to before me, this — day of ——, 188-.

Notary Public, New York County.

[Endorsed :] 7454. U.S. circuit court, southern district of New

York. Charles C. Harrison & al. vs. Edwin A. Merritt, collector, ete.

Answer. Stewart L. Woodford, United States attorney, attorney for

defendant. Due service of a copy of the within answer is hereby

admitted. New York, Jan’y 6th, 1882. Isaac Phillips, plaintiffs’

attorney. To Isaac Phillips, plaintiffs’ attorney.

14 At a stated term of the circuit court of the United States

of America for the southern district of New York, in the sec-

ond circuit, held at the United States court-rooms in the city of New

York, on the third day of June, in the year of our Lord one thou-

sand eight hundred and eighty-five—

Present: The Honorable Hoyt H. Wheeler, sitting as circuit

judge.

CHARLES C. HARRISON and al. vs. Epwin A. MERRITT.

Now come the plaintiffs, by Henry E. Davies, Esq., their attor-

ney, and move the trial of this cause. Likewise comes the defen-

dant, by Sam’! B. Clarke, Esq., ass’t U. S. attorney, his attorney.

Thereupon a jury is empanelled and the cause proceeded to trial.

After hearing the evidence of the parties and the argument of coun-

sel the court directs the jury to find a verdict for the defendant.

Thereupon the jury render a verdict, whereby they find for the

defendant. —

15 On motion of counsel for plaintiffs, the court ordered that

the plaintiffs have a stay of all proceedings for twenty days

within which to prepare and to serve a bil of exceptions.

A copy.

TIMOTHY GRIFFITH, Clerk.

Judgment. 1885.

16 United States Circuit Court, Southern District of New York.

- U8.

CHARLES C. HARRISON and 4

EpwIN A. MERRITT.

The issues in this action having been brought on for trial before

Mr. Judge Wheeler and a jury, at a circuit court of the April term,

1885, and the issues having been tried, and a verdict for the defend-

ant having been duly rendered on the third day of June, sins. and

his costs having been adjusted at $48.85:

Now, on motion of William Dorsheimer, United States ntGiirney

for defendant—

ie

ae

4 rs Pa av + « 7 re a »

ee ex ; * 4 ee ae

y bolety,- ore »* Agia ts ee RP ee re ois

. ~ ? 5 ee ae > Poe Yo 7 wt!

Ay a pao e eM nas tie hig ot na 4

; ae ik hat Se a TS

—_— =! mu "7 . - ty ~ ar

* fans I Picts

“sivas :

be.

”

A

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, €¢.

It is adjudged that the defendant have juc t against the

plaintiffs upon the issues in this action, and that he recover the sum

of $48.85, his taxed costs, and have execution therefor.

Judgment signed, this 27th day of July, 1885.

JOHN A. SHIELDS,

Deputy Clerk.

17 Endorsed :}] 7454. United States circuit court. Charles

C. Harrison and al. vs. Edwin A. Merritt. Judgment roll.

William Dorsheimer, United States attorney, for defendant. Filed

— 1885. Costs, $48.85. 12.15 o’clock. U.S. circuit court. Filed

June 27, 1885. Timothy Griffith, clerk. , :

18 United States Circuit Court, Southern District of New York.

CHARLES C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED

C. Harrison, Witi1aAM W. Harrison, and WILLIAM W.

FRAZIER, Junior, 7454.

v8.

Epwin A. MERRITT.

. This cause came on for trial at the April term, 1885, of the United

States circuit court for the southern district of New York, on the 3rd

day of June, 1885, before the Honorable Hoyt H.,Wheeler, district

judge, sitting as circuit judge, and a jury duly empanelled and

sworn. The parties were represented by counsel. In the course

of the said trial divers exceptions were taken by the counsel for the

plaintiff- to the rulings of the court, which said several exceptions

were then and there allowed by the court, and more fully appear in

this bill of exceptions.

The deferdant’s counsel offered the usual stipulation, that if the

plaintiffs are entitled to recover on the main question raised by the

protest, the verdict should be for the plaintiffs generally, subject

to adjustment at the custom-house as to formal requisites and

19 amount under the direction of the court, which offer was

duly accepted by the plaintiffs’ counsel, and it was so stip-

ulated.

The plaintiffs’ counsel then presented evidence tending to show

the following facts:

That in the year 1881 the plaintiffs imported into the port of

New York certain goods, wares, and merchandise, the invoices

whereof were put in evidence by the plaintiffs’ counsel, and which

were as follows:

Invoice of 4,800 bags animal charcoal bought by order and fr. acc’t

of Messrs. Havemeyer, Harrison & Co., of Philadelphia, shipped,

per St. “ Persian Monarch,” to New York.

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO.

a Ve : ory : » aed ev: Srhar.. ha Pin NO PRR Ord SRI Re UERE SEM PE : 3 te z x Sas, eet ae 42 rte

ORS MS ES aya Dik NY cot Sake 3 Pad 5s oe Ny NRO ae se: ¥ EPC ERR GS POR ORR i Rte ase 123 ; Aree a Sih ai set fa ats

. “om 7 , . ‘ ; : pial ‘ q nes ” é sities a Ki3 Asti!

Meee ah eeng tel PALEY: « ik eS te FONE ap etehtch Scan eee Pete fs

Sag tag Rowe, cise Gy Loe, canst Cassette at cits acetate eee

Se Se ts AOE ans a Pe ce Sk BES a may ee 4 ' # a

da be hi : i > REO RE ae

OES SR RSS VEN ES teh Sra Seat. WIE 7

ass SW Se ae Ryne hoa ter a oh at Lace -

es wa ee Se ay +. ¢ te B: aT te STA

EI peneath ye Y oa Pepe ee “a aoe pe tsrakes

m= 7 op Se a " 2 ae =. bitte | ak ome ye Ne ee ee eT — . oleae > ae ™ ;

EE ats ee ge ee eee ree, OO Ege Ree es Minh ry Bee EDR ES hy oA Ep Seas ES ee a es EEE Sp ee Soe mS et hee Syig de

dee ceca nta Lev ctor 3 7. ; " te f soul as Bt % oe eink ahs ee Zep

10 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

A. C. C. 4,800 bags wg. tons 300 @ 13 5 per ton-_-~-_ ‘£3,975

Charges:

RINNE oo iin cece one ene nnn £20 5 2

Consul’s fee & petties-...---.---- --.--- 18 0

Ns isenies wsclhesn issih ab halisak inroeieiek somianapin 2 6

Postage, &c. ...--.----- -cnacipieliainsa sleet 6 9

20 12 5

nafs

£3,995 12 5

E. & O. E. London, 23 April, 1881. ~—e

F. ENGLEHARDT & CO.

20 Original Inv. No. 574.

Facture a 470 sacs os calcines expedies par le soussigne par vapeur

danois “ Hermond ” du Havre a New York pour compte at par

ordre de Messieurs Drexel & Cie a New York. ‘

Fee, $2}. .

Am’t of inv., f’cs 9,397.15.

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO.

A! 236. 236 sacs pesant krs._. ---- 20,236

B'! 234. 234 “ «: errs 19,908 ef

470 sacs. Ks. 40,144 a fr. 24.625 par 100 ks. by Be

f. 9,885.45 |

Mois fret suivant connoissement.....--.-- 501.80 : |

3 f. 9,383.65

Cout de la facture consulaire___-.._.-- -~- " 13.50

F. 9,397.15

Quatre cent soixante dis sacs os calcines valeur neuf mille trois

cent quatre vingt dix sept francs quinze centimes. | |

Havre le 3 Juin, 1881. |

GUST. ESBRAU. i.

P. ROUSSELL. |

21 It is admitted by the counsel for the respective parties that

the following is a correct translation of the foregoing invoice :

Original Inv. No. 574.

Invoice of 470 bags calcined bones shipped by the undersigned, by

Danish steamer “ Hermond,” from aves to New York, . order

and for account of Messrs. Drexel & Co., New York.

Fee, $23.

Amt. of inv., f’es, 9,397.15.

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO.

“

oe

Se

'B! 234. 234 =“

aa

;

toa a

* e M 2 a a "

ee oe ee a

“on * Rhy COP XO oes a

ate

oe

5 oe

Bi,

‘2

~*

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. V8. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &c. 11

A! 236. 236 bags weighing, k’rs --____....<... 20,236

470 bags. K’rs, 40,144

At f’s 24.625 for 100 k’s.

| f’s 9,885.45

Less freight as per bill of lading -__.---.------.-..--2- 501.80

| f’s 9,383.65

Consular fee....--_--.-. iabiklcndeieik~ Walcime wieraca men im oaeeiae 13.50

f’s 9,397.15

Four hundred and seventy bags calcined bones of the value of

nine thousand three hundred and ninety-seven francs, fifteen cen-

times. '

Havre, June 3, 1881.

GUST. ESBRAU.

P. ROUSSELL.

22 Invoice of 1,334 burnt bones shipped per “ Persian Mon-

arch” from London to New York for acc’t of Messrs. Har-

rison, Havemeyer & Co., Philadelphia, and consigned to Messrs.

Drexel & Co., New York. 80tonscont., 26 April; 20 tons, 19 May.

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO., Phila.

A. C. C. 80 tons burnt bones, @ £14 5 per ton -----.- £1,140

20 = do. o £ie ae ~ 300

1,440

CORMIER 106 oii. nin bie cers Khe enen nas 14 10

£1,440 14 10

Less freight as per bill of lading—109 gr. 101 tons 4

ewt., 76 per ton, in full --.. ....---.-------..-.- 3 6519

| £1,404 15 10

London, 11 June, 1881.

P. ENGLEHARDT & CO.

23 That the collector of the port caused a duty of twenty-five

per centum ad valorem to be assessed upon the said $ as

“black of bone,” to which assessment of duty the plaintifis made

the following protests : 3

New York, July 28, 1881.

To hon. collector of customs, New York.

Sir: We are dissatisfied with the decision and liquidation made

by you on or about the 21st inst. on our consumption entry, No.

58105, ex “ Persian Monarch,” from London, arrived May 11th,

1881, and entered in your office on or about May 21, 1881, and we

hereby give you notice of our objection and protest against the same.

‘ s y Ay ? ee ad As Ts eohane St lege Ls age ee ote Oe et = a Pe oy

ae ce ae mae ak tee tome ants ee ee

’ ens nae bMS A os ie ut Saka 2h PS

yee OY oes as \ os

acl ca aah ha Sana

sks eae pete sai iis pee Vi wip i ten seis og

ieabiaititie cy Beles aS a Rare, Yin aR cal

Qos r + ag Set, * ne mas 7S ete FE Kt " gag {Re ‘ 45 ‘ ;

wa a PI SITY Se DEES, 5 een pags oe ee TOR cS 2 Ree! as eae 4 Sretcare r aes. eee Bs aed th kcal Ml uke ws Pe a ee er

ER ye Eee ey, Ie Neer ky La aca Cee et nin hte eee ete ee . : :

23 ® ete a faieae ae PELE BOTT ake te. Pe hn ee ag eee ats sai Rad fp ee Se ui ORCAS Ra ETI IS Fit Ik OT Rtg ieee sit

he

ss ats

Pye ciaty «

(eS e

a ee ee ee ee Bag ea a " 5 a i a a te ei te ahh ‘ Se ane

a OE ep tae ates nS Sot i 3 » 54 BS Sob aD ge ewer Cee Sept Ros dey BY mE ied an 6 Re, sae es ae RA AP OUD oO RP

“ ae ry + *

(cca mah ws Be ee ee ‘ te Bee i

a Bore Ren ee Rad eae eee . ~

‘

12 CHAELES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

The reasons therefor are that you have assessed a duty of 25 per

centum ad valorem on A. C. C. 4,800 bags animal charcoal, which .

are in fact calcined bones contained in said entry, and which we

claim are entitled to entry as such free of duty under section 2505

of the act of June 22, 1874 (Heyl., 1508). “ anes crude and not

manufactured, burned, calcined, ground, or steamed.” We pay the

amount of duty you unlawfully exact, $4,994.75, in order to obtain

or retain possession of our goods, and we shall hold. you responsible

for the same. | |

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO., _—

Per R. bE WARDENER, Att'y. oo ‘

24 re New York, July 28, 1885. |

To hon. collector of customs, New York.

Str: We are dissatisfied with the decision and liquidation made

by you on or about the 21st inst. on our consumption entry (No.

69884), ex “ Hermond,” from Havre, arrived June 22, 1881, and en-

tered in your office on the sane day. And we hereby give you

notice of our objection and protest against the same. The reasons

therefor are that you have assessed a duty of 25 per centum ad va-

lorem on A-B 470 bags of calcined bones, are entitled to free entry

under section 2505, act of June 22d, 1874 (Heyl., 1508). ‘“ Bones

crude and not manufactured, burned, calcined, ground, or steamed.”

We pay the amount unlawfully exacted in order to obtain or re-

tain possession of our goods, and we shall hold you responsible for

the amount of duty exacted by you on the decision and liquidation

aforesaid, being $469. 3

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO.,

Per R. DE WARDENER, Att’y.

25 New York, August 2, 1881.

To hon. collector of customs, New York.

Sir: We are dissatisfied with the decision and liquidation made

by you on or about the 25th day of July, 1881, on our consumption

entry (No. 71492), ex “ Persian Monarch,” from London, arrived

June 24, 1881, and entered in your office on or about June 27, 1881,

and we hereby give you notice of our objection and protest against

the same. The reasons therefor are that you have assessed a duty

of 25 per centum ad valorem on A. C. C. 1334 bags of calcined bones

contained in said entry, whereas we claim that calcined bones are

entitled to free entry under section 2505 act of June 22d, 1874.

(Heyl., 1508.) “ Bones, crude and not manufactured, burned, cal-

cined, or steamed.”

We pay the amount unlawfully exacted in order to obtain or re-

tain possession of our goods, and we shall hold you responsible for

the amount of duty exacted by you on the decision and liquidation

aforesaid, being $1,761.

HARRISON, HAVEMEYER & CO.,

Per R. bE WARDENER, Aitt’y.

~ om re nf

%

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A: MERRITT,

That the plaintiffs naid the duty so assessed.

26 To further maintain the issues on the part of the plaintiff-

plaintiffs’ counsel called as a witness Frank Henn, who, being

duly sworn, testified as follows: | sie

I reside in Philadelphia and am employed by Harrison & Have-

meyer, the plaintiffs in this suit; have been in their employ about

eight years. I remember the importations of animal charcoal and |

calcined bone made by them in the Persian Monarch and the Her-

s mond in 1881. The sample of goods now shown me is sample of

— the animal charcoal we received in 1881 by the Persian Monarch

: and the Hermond. I took these samples myself from those impor-

tations, out of the very goods themselves. (Marked Exhibit 1.)

The plaintiffs’ counsel then called as a witness Isaac W. Drum-

MOND, who, being duly sworn, testified as follows: |

I am a chemist and have been for six years. I am a member of

the firm of F. W. Devoe & Co., manufacturers of paints and so forth.

I have frequently testified as an expert in the United States courts

and other courts on questions of chemistry, and I am recognized as

un expert in those courts.

The substance now shown me, Exhibit 1, is animal charcoal. It

is produced from bones by taking the refuse bones from the slaughter-

houses and other places, boiling the fat out of them, and put-

as 27 ting them afterwards into closed vessels, to exclude the air;

then they are burnt in these vessels, calcined in these vessels,

> ae and after they are calcined they are ground to the consistency as

you see it here, and it is then termed “animal charcoal,” and is

used for the purpose of decolorizing sugar by refiners and manufac-

turers of sugar.

The size in which it is broken is an element of its use in that

regard ; it has to be of a size sufficient for the sugar in liquid form

of molasses to percolate through it. In manufacturing the thing,

grinding the bones to this shape, as it is in this sample, there is a

certain percentage of it which 1s very much finer than that, which

cannot be used, and that is used by the manufacturers of paint for

grinding into paint; but the percentage is about twenty to twenty-

five, and the rest of it is used for sugar refiners. The fine powder a

cannot be used by sugar refiners, but is sold as a by-product for paint 5

manufacturers. oe

Ivory drop black is the black obtained from burning ivory scraps,

grinding them to an en powder in water, and dropping it

into suitable forms and drying it according to the sample now

shown me, which is a sample of ivory drop black. It is used asa

pigment, but for no other purpose that I am aware of.

Similar treatment of finer ground bone produces a black

28 paint that is sometimes called “ivory drop black.” “Black”

is a distinctive term and is a frequently used designation of

paint and pigments. There are a great many blacks known to the

color trade, perhaps fifteen or twenty of them. I have a list here

that I have jotted down—twenty-one of them that I just thought of.

There is almond black, China black, black lead, black gum, cork

~ Cm ane vf

%

ar . Exe

Supe 3a 3

14 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. V8. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C. a a

black, ivory black, lamp black, etc., distinguished by the name and

substance of which it is made. |

The substance which I have before me in the sample of animal

charcoal cannot be used as a pigment, because it is in a very coarse

grain. We buy the powder of bone-black, which is the residue left

from making this coarse grain. We buy it for twenty-five dollars a

ton. The article now before me is worth, perhaps, eighty dollars a

ton. Wecan buy all we wish of the same material as that, in a

fine powder at twenty-five dollars a ton, and therefore we could not ,

afford to buy this at an enhanced price. Chemically considered the .- =

two articles would be the a coarse powder and this coarse’

grain and the fine powder, but it would have the same relation that |

a piece of marble which might be valued at five thousand dollars ,

for its size and it might not be worth one dollar if it is broken up

into very small particles, though, chemically, they would be the

same thing. And furthermore, it is material, where it is in such

coarse grains, that it would need further grinding and )

29 manipulation by us, which, of course, is expensive, in order

to bring it down to the point of a powder where we could

commence to use it asa pigment. Therefore I say it is not of ser-

vice or of value to us as a pigment and is not a pigment.

I have brought some recognized authorities with me. This which

I now produce is Watts’ Chemical Dictionary and is considered a

standard authority amongst chemists. It says, at page 624, under a

the caption “ Bone-black,” “a product obtained by heating bones to <b

redness in inclosed vessels,” and so forth.

Johnson’s Encyclopedia is also considered an authority. I read

ean page 551, volume 1, of that work, under the head of “ Bone-

ack”: |

“ Bone-black or animal charcoal is the residue left on calcining

bones in close vessels. On the application of heat destructive dis-

tillation takes place,” ete.

The articles from which I read was written by Dr. Chandler, of

the School of Mines of Columbia College.

I also read the definition of “bone-black” as given in Ure’s Dic-

tionary, at page 394:

“ Bone-black, or animal charcoal as it is less correctly called, is

the black carbonaceous substance into which bones are converted by

calcination in close vessels.” :

30 I do not know in my line of business nor have I ever heard |

of an article known as “ black of bone,” neither in my busi- 4

me “

ness nor in the arts, nor in any commercial business.

And being cross-examined by defendant’s counsel, the witness

says:

In order to manufacture the article the first thing done with the

bones is to boil them, as a matter of economy, to take off the fat ;

that is, to economize the fat, which is deleterious in the manufac-

ture. After they are boiled they are placed in closed vessels to ex-

clude the air and heated to redness, which drives oif the volatile

organic constituents, such as ammonical vapors, water, and several

of the qualities of gases. It leaves all the inorganic matter, chiefly

pret nt

ee e ~_«

> .

*

ses ae “

3 pi ing >. — ire

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET AIS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, 4c.

matter, which constitutes phosphate of lime; phosphate of lime to

a percentage of about ninety and the remaining ten is carbon ; frac-

tional percentages of other matters, which are immaterial, exist.

Q. It does not change the form or shape of the bones as they

entered the retorts, does it?

A. To answer that definitely, it would change the shape, but not .

in a general way. A bone can be put into a retort and as it comes

out you can determine the size and shape of the bone as well as

before it went in.

Q. Then I understand, in the manufacture of this sort of bone-

black which is used for decolorizing sugars, the bones

31 as they were in the retort were taken out, and there is a spe-

cial machine, is there not, for cracking it?

A. The bones after they leave the retort are put through two iron

cylinders to break them up into smaller particles. There is no special

machine made for that purpose that t know of. I am personally

familiar with the manufacture of this article; I have seen it donea

great many times. After being broken up, it is sieved so as to sepa-

rate the large particles from the smaller.

I do not know whatsizes are regarded asthe minimum and maxi-

mum for decolorizing sugars; practically I should consider the sam-

le now shown me as rather small for the sugur refiner’s ee,

it must be as small as that, and the largest as large as the head of

a pencil, I know it is used as large as the head of a pencil. I am

not familiar with the decolorization of sugar to know. Practically,

it runs from the size of wheat up to the size of the head of a pencil.

I am familiar with Wagner’s Technology. I do not consider it as

much of an authority as Ure’s Dictionary, or Watt’s Dictionary.

It is in good repute amongst students in schools, but I cannot

say how chemists regard it. I have not seen it quoted or cited as an

authority and I do not regard it as authority. I do not know

that it is used as a text-book 1n schools. I graduated in 1878, at the

: School of Mines, Columbia College, and have been ever since

32 __—ithen with De Voe & Co., in the paint business as their chemist.

I am familiar with Wagner’s Technology and Chemistry.

I agree with what he says at page 553, under the head of “ Animal

Charcoal ”—that “animal charcoal is the residue obtained by dry

distillation of bone.” Dry distillation is distillation as distinguished

from wet distillation, which is the general form of distillation. Dry

distillation is the placing of certain articles which will give off part

of their substance under heat, in a retort, and by heating them cer-

tain gases will be given off and those are the distillates or products

of the dry distillation. Animal charcoal is the residue.

Defendant’s counsel quotes from Wagner’s Dictionary and Cooley’s

Cyclopedia. |

The bone-black which we buy for pigment purposes cannot be

used as a pigment without further grinding by us. We have to

grind it in oil to make a paint of it. It is ground in the medium

we want to use it in, oil or varnish or water, or whatever we want

to make of it.

phosphate of lime. It leaves carbon, which is organic and inorganic .

4

16 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, 4€.

And being examined in the redirect by plaintiff’s counsel, says:

The sample now shown to me, Exhibit 2, is a sample of

33 the bones as they come from the retort before they are sub-

mitted to the grinding process.

This other sample, marked Exhibit 2, now shown to me is the

way it is after it has been in the retort.

It still retains its shape, and you can see the saw marks on it.

That piece of bone happens to have been sawn for some reason or

other. It comes in that condition after being exposed io heat in the

retort. fou

In all the various processes that have been described the boné ‘is

calcined while in the retort by the action of heat. Whether it is

called distillation, or carbonization, or any other term, it is a cal-

cination.

The sample now shown me, marked Exhibit 3, is raw bone before

it has been calcined.

The samples now shown me, marked Exhibit 4, are bones that

have been burned, calcined in the open air, so far as I can determine

by looking at them.

. They undergo that process to deprive them of carbon, and phos-

phate of lime is left. Phosphate of lime is white, and therefore those

samples are white, and that is the shape any bone will take if they

are burned or calcined with the action of air. If burned in closed

vessels the carbon is not taken off by the air in the burning, and

therefore the carbon remains with the bone, and is black because

carbon is black—in most cases it is black.

As the substance comes from the retort after the calcination, of

which I have spoken, it is chemically changed from bone. It

34 is a different substance chemically as well as physically.

The bones as put into the retort come of all sizes; they are |

utterly irregular.

The plaintiffs’ counsel then called as a witness for the plaintiff

Hamitton H. Satmon, who, being duly sworn, testified as follows:

I reside in Brooklyn, and do business in the city of New York as

an importer, and have been an importing merchant about twelve or

fourteen years. I know what the substance now shown to me is,

Exhibit 1. It is burnt bone, calcined bone, what is called animal

charcoal or bone-black. I have dealt in and imported that article

for some time past, and am familiar with the names by which it is

known in trade and commerce. By importers of that article it is

called and recognized as “animal charcoal,” sometimes “ burnt bone,”

und sometimes merely “charcoal.” It is designated by the names

by which it is imported. In Germany it is called “ Knochen Kohle,”

which is “burnt coal.” In France it is “animal noir,” which is

“animal black.” In this country it is mostly designated as “ bone-

black.” It would be known as recognized in this country by the

name of “ bone-black,” or as “animal charcoal.” I never heard it

called “black of bone.” The term “black of bone” is not used as the

designation of any imported article to my knowledge. The article

is imported and used principally for refining’ purposes and

35 decolorizing liquors and sugars: I am familiar with the

manufacture of it, and have seen it manufactured both in

this — and abroad. The bones from which it is manufactured

are generally cracked before they are put in the retorts, but some-

times they are put in whole. Some of the manufacturers in this

country crack the bones before they put them into the retort. I

know the manufacturers in St. Louis do, and I understand that the

manufacturers in Brooklyn do it. Some six or eight that are in St.

Louis all crack the bones to the required size before they are put

into the retorts, and they are not cracked after they are burnt, for

they come out complete, with the exception that they take some lit-

tle dust out of them by sieving them.

The sample now shown is Exhibit 2, the same article of a larger

size which is produced in the same way. It can be used for the

purpose of sugar refining, but not many use it now in that way.

Prior to 1874 I know that this article was always imported free of |

duty, but in that year the Department began to impose duties upon

it. |

And being cross-examined by the defendant’s counsel, he says :

I have known this article. about fourteen years since 1872. I

dealt in the article in 1872, 1873, and 1874. I did not import it,

but I was cognizant of a large quantity that was imported

36 in 1873. Prior to June 22nd, 1874, that article was known

in the trade and commerce of this country as “charcoal” or

“bone black ”—either “charcoal” or “animal charcoal ”—sometimes

“char” asan abbreviation. The usual name was. “bone-black.”

That has been its usual name since I have been in business, except

occasionally a man would say to me “ have you any char” or “char-

coal”?

My experience of foreign invoices in which this article is invoiced

and classified as “bone” or “burnt bone” is since the 22nd of June,

1874.

The article is sometimes manufactured by cracking the bones

before they are put into the retort. There are different kinds of

retorts. I don’t know whether you call it a retort or not. In St.

Louis they bake bones in a kiln, and this kiln is made up of fire

brick without any clay or iron whatever in the retort. It is merely

a kiln, in other words, with about a dozen holes in it, in which they

burn this article. It is not called a retort, but a kiln. Sometimes

it is made in pots, and sometimes in upright retorts, and sometimes

in horizontal,

In former years a large quantity of this largest size in the sample

before me was used, but now very little of that size is used. It

depends altogether upon the filters in the sugar refineries. Some

use the large size, and some cannot use the large size. Formerly

it was altogether different from now. Then they used a

37 larger size than they use now. In the manufacture the result

aimed at is to get it to a certain size. When it is cracked

before being put in the retorts, the size they crack it to, is just ex-

actly the size they wanted it, and they put it in the retorts at that

3—913

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERR ee

hae

ty Sas

ae

ee ak aS Pi aie tadee io BNE AP wy oe

one ere ee o ; + to

Sane hye gee ” Be a tee r ne! Gaeta. =e BaOie ete 12)

* Rs ee ee Se a SP ata re girs pee F we eee kon of Mee tee tn by: Oe IN Se 7 Y ;

< be it : z is tie te LS Bare Seah; Beye fe oA

. 3 £203 3 > 235 Y.

18 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

size. When it has been made by cracking the bones before they are

put in the retort or the kiln, they put it through a sieve merely to

take out the dust. :

The plaintiffs’ counsel then called as a witness, on the part of the

plaintiff, FREDERICK W. Simmonps, who, being duly sworn, testified

as follows:

I reside in New York, and do business as an importing merchant

there. I am familiar with the article of commerce shown in the

sample, Exhibit 1, before me. I have dealt in it, imported, and

sold it. I first imported it in 1881. The price was high here then

and moderate on the other side, and I thought it could be imported

to advantage. I went to the custom-house to inquire what the duty

was, and they said

The counsel for the defendant objected to this testimony on the

ground that what was said at the custom-house to the witness is im-

material.

38 The court sustained the objection and excluded the evi-

dence, to which decision the plaintiffs’ counsel duly excepted,

and prayed the court to seal this his bill of exceptions, which was

done accordingly.

I know by what name the article shown me is known and recog-

. — m4 ¢¢ . ?

nized among importers and dealers. It is called “ animal charcoal,

“ bone-black,” “burnt bone,” and “char.” I never heard it called

“black of bone,” and I never heard that name as descriptive of any

article of trade or commerce. |

And being cross-examined by the defendant’s counsel, he says:

I think I have heard that substance called “animal carbon.” My

experience in this article began in 1881; I had no practical knowl-

edge of it between 1874 and 1881. I never dealt in it before 1881.

The common name in this country is “ bone-black” and “ black,”

“ bone-black ” or “ bone-coal,” very often “ bone-coal.”

The plaintiffs’ counsel then read from “Webster’s Dictionary” the

definitions of the words “ burn,” “burned,” “ calcined,” and “ bone-

black.”

39 The plaintiffs’ counsel then rested his case:

The defendant’s counsel then opened his case, and, to main-

tain the issues on the part of the defendant, called as a witness

Henry P. 8. Coampers, who, being duly sworn, testified as follows:

I am a commission merchant and dealer in bone-black, fertilizing

materials, &c., and have been in that position for seventeen years.

My firm was formerly Chambers Brothers; it is now Chambers

Brothers & Co. We do business at No. 81 Pine street, in the city of

New York. I am familiar with the article now shown me, and have

known it during all the time that I have been in business. The

trade name under which it has been dealt in, in the trade and com-

merce of this country, is generally “ bone-black,’ or “ animal char-

coal,” commonly called “ black” in ordinary business. I have heard

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. V8. EDWIN A. MERRITT, 4c. 19

the phrase “ black of bone” applied to that article. That is not the

common name, but simply the literal translation from the French,

“noir d’os.” The article is never known in the trade and commerce

of this country as burnt bone, calcined bone, or ground bone. I have

. been familiar with the article in the trade in this country which is

described by the term “ burnt bone.” It is bones burnt in the open

air. It generally comes from South America, where the bones are

used for fuel. This sample now shown me, Exhibit 4, repre-

sn 40 sents it. I am familiar with the article dealt in, in the trade

~ of this country, called “calcined bone.” It is the same as

f ‘“‘ bone-ash ” or “ burnt bone,” excepting that there isa little more care

t tee

, exercised in the manufacture, which produces simply perfectly white

: ~ dust like that (referring to sample). The incineration is more per-

| fect, and the bone is reduced to a more impalpable condition. fe is

almost a powder. It is used to mix paint. That is the calcined

aie 4 bone of commerce. Ground bone is used for fertilizing pur .

Either the taw bone ground, or bone subjected to steam and ren-

dered soft, and groundup. It is a raw or steamed bone ground up.

It is what is known as “ ground bone” in the trade, ed used for

fertilizing purposes. The bone dust is simply the final distribution

of bone as ground bone, only more fine. Those are the trade

| terms.

My business is in this article, and all kinds of fertilizing mate-

i. a rials—dried blood, fish scrap, sulphate of ammonia, bone raw and

, steamed, ground or unground, and bone-black in all its forms, both

the new and the old. I mean, by the new, black used by sugar re-

finers, and the old, the same after it has gone through the process

and is no longer of any use tothem. They used the latter for a

: fertilizer.

The process to which the burnt bone and calcined bone that I

have referred to are represented by the white samples before

41 me, and the effect of the process of heat to which they have

been subjected, drives out the carbon. In the case of bone-

black the carbon remains.

Pa™

,

And being cross-examined by the plaintiffs’ counsel, he says:

The difference between the calcined bone and burnt bone is that

3 the calcined bone is made with more care than the burnt bone;

that is the distinction in the trade. In my mind there is no differ-

ence—a burnt bone is a calcined bone, and they are synonymous.

The black now shown me is not a calcined or burnt bone; it is

charcoal. In my mind it is not a calcined bone; it has been burnt

without exposure to the air. I say bone-black is neither calcined

nor burnt bone. In my mind the word calcined means the thor-

ough burning of bone in the open air. I differ from the scientific

authors, whose works on that subject have been read here; I think

I agree with the trade distinction, which is as far as my knowledge

goes. The trade distinction of the word calcined bone is a bone

burnt in the open air, and also of burnt bone; a bone cannot be

practically burnt or calcined and the air excluded.

The white residuum is known in the trade as burnt or calcined

20 CHAELES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

bone, and I dealt in that; we do not always advertise on our bills :

the article we deal in; the paper now shown me is one of

42 our bills; we did not state in our bills that we were dealers

in the substance I call burnt or calcined bone; we simply in-

cluded it under the head of fertilizing materials ; some of the man-

ufacturers of what I call burnt or calcined bone state on their bill-

heads that they are manufacturers of calcined bone; I think I have

seen it on their bill-heads, but 1 cannot give an instance now; I

cannot give an instance of any one who does it; my best recollec-

tion is that Prestons have it on theirs, but I am not sure. |

I know the firm of Lister Brothers; I do not know whether they

make what I call calcined or burnt bone or not; they manufacture

bone-black and fertilizing materials; by bone-black I mean this

charcoal; the fertilizers they make for distribution throughout the

Southern States for the raising of crops; they are made from bone

or from Charleston rock and refuse coal-black ; the black that I call

bone-black they call either bone-black or animal charcoal, or some-

thing of that kind, on their bill-heads; they do not call it “ black

of bone”; I do not know of any manufacturer or dealer who puts

upon bill-heads or advertisements the words “ black of bone” as de-

scriptive of bone-black ; I think none of them do it.

I have never watched the process of making what I call calcined

bone and burnt bone, but I know that calcined bone is made more

carefully than burnt bone from the statements of others to

43 me, and from the fact that it is generally sold at a much

higher price than the ordinary bone-ash or burnt bone; it is

made here now, and has been made here for years, by Prestons and

others connected in the trade; I instance Prestons because I have

bought this stuff from them, and they have made it for a number

of years; I never sold it in large quantities—only a few barrels at

a time; they make it in small quantities and charge a high price

for it; they call it on their bills when you buy it from them cal-

cined bone.

This sample which is now before me, Exhibit 4, is known in the

trade as bone-ash. If I ordered bone-ash I would expect to get

that; “bone-ash” is the general name and designation .of that in

the trade without regard to the degree of fineness of which it is

made, though it generally comes coarser than that sainple.

This sample now shown me is not bone-ash. When I want this

I do not say burnt bone ; the term burnt bone is very seldom used.

The trade term for this is generally “ ash.” :

And being examined upon the redirect by the counsel for the de-

fendant, he says:

The calcined bone, as I call it, where the article has been burnt

more carefully is used for making crucibles.

I know what the difference in value is between bone-black, such

as is represented in the tin, and the crude bone as it comes from the:

butcher’s shop.

44 The defendant’s counsel] then offered to ask the witness the

following question :

| CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. Vs. EDWIN A.

Q. What is the difference ? )

The plaintiffs’ counsel objected to the admission of this evidence .

as immaterial, and the court overruled the objection and admitted

the evidence ; to which decision the plaintiffs’ counsel duly excepted,

and prayed the court to seal this his bill of exceptions, which was

done accordingly.

A. The bone is worth about $22 a ton; the bone-black is worth

7 $65.

7c The defendant’s counsel then offered to ask the witness the follow-

ing question :

So Q. What is the difference in value commercially between the

| white article, the burnt bone or burnt ash or calcined bone, as the

| article usually dealt in, in the trade and the bone-black in the tin ?

‘ . The plaintiffs’ counsel objected to the admission of this evidence

: as immaterial, and the court overruled. the objection and admitted

| the evidence ; to which decision the plaintiffs’ counsel duly excepted,

, and prayed the court to seal this his bill of exceptions, which was

i done accordingly.

‘ 45 A. About $40 a ton is the difference in value. The bone-

7 ash was worth from $20 to $22, and the other $65. The

A: +: ground bone of commerce varies from $25 to $30 a ton, and the

bone-black is $65.

The defendant’s counsel then offered to ask the witness the follow-

ing question :

Q. What is the difference in value between bone-black before it is

used by the sugar refiners and after it is spent for that purpose ?

The plaintiffs’ counsel objected to the admission of this evidence

as immaterial, and the court overruled the objection and admitted

the evidence; to which decision the plaintiffs’ counsel duly excepted,

and prayed the court to seal this his bill of exceptions, which was

done accordingly.

: A, Before it is used it is worth $65, and after they throw it out—

. discard it—it is worth $17 to-day. ‘

The defendant’s counsel then called as a witness on the part of the

defendant, Joan MULLER, who, being duly sworn, testified as follows:

I am a manufacturer of bone-black, and have been in that

46 business since 1874. I had not been in that business before

1874. My first experience of it was in that year.

We have special machinery for cracking the bones as they come

from the retorts and kilns and for sieving it.

For the use of sugar refiners it must not be greater than a certain

size, and not below a certain size. It is not salable for that purpose

unless it comes within limits of size, and our machinery is adap

to bring about that result. I agree with Mr. Chambers as to the

RR SPR RN Te ee

ra hte °

22 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. V8. EDWIN A, MERRITT, &C.

difference in value between the bone-black now shown me and the

crude bone.

We always crack the bones after they come from the retort; we

never crack them before they are put into the retort. I know that

that is the usual way they are done in this country.

After the bones come from the retort it costs at a rough estimate

from $15 to $20 a ton to manufacture them into bone-black as it is

exposed for sale; that is, the part of the manufacture subsequent to

the burning.

The name of the article i in the trade and commerce of this country

is “bone-black ”’ or “black.” -That is the usual customary name.

It might be called “black of bone” to distinguish it from “ black of

ivory.” There is a black made from ivory. I have heard it

47 called that way to make the difference between black of ivory

and black of bone. Black of ivory is ground very fine to use

for paint and black varnish. I have heard it called so, but that is

not the usual name. The customary name is “black ” or “bone-

black,” but I have heard it distinguished that way.

The article of bone, as it comes from the retort before the grind-

ing, cracking, and sieving process, is not to my knowledge an article

of commerce in this country. In that condition it is not an article

of commerce.

It is my business to make myself familiar with all branches of my

business. I know what in the trade, while I have been in business,

is known by the phrase “burnt bone.” It is bone-ash. It is like

the sample now shown me, but sometimes finer. It is bone burnt

in the open air, and is imported from South America. I have re-

ceived cargoes of bone from South America, received, say, from

twenty-five tons of bone-ash similar to this here. It is the same

thing as that known in the trade as calcined bone. The difference

between burt bone and burnt ash and calcined bone is that calcined

bone is burnt admitting the air, and bone-black is burnt excluding

the air. ‘“Calcined bone,” “burnt bone,” and “bone-ash ” are all

one and the same thing.

I know ground bone, of course. That is not burnt, but

48 some times the bones are ground raw for fertilizing purposes.

The ground bone of commerce is raw bones before they are

burnt, Bone-dust is merely the dust that is nen s out of this bone

black. It is only used for fertilizing.

And being cross-examined by the counsel for the plaintiffs, he

says:

I am a manufacturer of “ bone-black ;” I am not a manufacturer

of bone. The term black of bone is used to distinguish this finer

ground article, which is suitable for paint—finely ground bone.

Sometimes the bone-black is ground down to such a size—not burnt

bone. You cannot use that for paint. By burnt bone I mean this

white substance, which is burnt bone or calcined bone or. bone-ash.

“ Bone-ash ” is not the term used in the trade to designate that. If

I wanted to buy it I would order “ bone-ash” or “calcined bone,”

it would not make any difference which. I don’t think I would

d

— re

ss

me te san eee a en ng,

,

: ‘ “~~? @ ote,

an ey ND 6 Sey Ng,

CHARLES C. HARRISON £T ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, 4c. 23

order “calcined bone.” I would order “ bone-ash.” There is not,

to my knowledge, a bone dust that is made from bones that have

not been burnt. I am not familiar with that article. I know what

bone-dust is. It is very fine stuff that is used for fertilizing pur-

poses. That is what is called bone-dust and is sold under that name.

The name boneburner is not the term generally used to

49 ~~ designate those employed in my business. I never heard the

term used and app ied to people doing my business. They

might call me a “ boneburner,” but I do not call myself that. I do

not burn bones; if I burnt bones they are good for nothing for ine.

They might call me that or they might call me something else.

The defendant’s counsel then called as a witness on behalf of the

defendant JoHN Krnog, who, being duly sworn, testified as follows:

I represent the firm of Lister Brothers, who manufacture a great

many things, and among the rest they manufacture this article of

“bone-black,” that is what they call it. They also manufacture

bone-ash, ground bone, and bone-dust. I represent the firm here

in- New York and do their buying and selling. Their factory is at

Newark. | .

I agree with what Mr. Chambers has said here as to the difference

in value between bone-black, as it is in this sample now shown me,

and bones as they come from the butchers. I have been in the

business seventeen years, which would carry me back to 1867. I

have known this article now shown me in all that time. Its trade

name in this country during all that time has been “ bone-black.”

That is what I have generally heard it called, but I have heard it

called by other names. I have heard it called “ animal char-

50 coal,” “ bone-black,” and “ bone char,” “ black of bone” and

“black.” Black is the general name. I understand that

when called “black” that is merely the abbreviation of “ bone-

black.” During the time I have been in business I never heard of

any article which has been dealt in under the name of “ burnt

bone.” “ Bone-ash ” is what I call burnt bone. “ Burnt bone” is

not the name, but “ bone-ash,” which is bones that have been burnt

in the open air, and “ calcined bone,” which is the same thing.

I don’t know any difference between calcined bone and burnt

bone. They take a little more care to make calcined hone and sell

it for certain purposes. Ground bone is raw bone ground for ferti-

lizers. We call it ground bone and bone-dust. They are usually

used as synonymous terms. I have never known in the trade the

article now shown me under the name of burnt bone, calcined bone,

or ground bone.

And being cross-examined by the plaintiffs’ counsel, he says:

By bone-dust I mean bone ground without having been previously

burnt or calcined; not necessarily ground to a powder, but ground

for fertilizing, bone-dust or ground bone.

On the bill-heads of Lister Brothers we call this black stuff

51 “bone charcoal;” but I very seldom see our bill-heads. The

paper now shown me is a bill-head of Lister Brothers, and

24 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

on that the substance is called “charcoal.” “Charcoal” is intended

for bone charcoal. It is this substance now before me. On our

bill-heads we generally call it “bone charcoal.” On this bill-head

now shown to me it is called “bone charcoal.” Perhaps that is an

error in printing the other one. The bill now shown me is for so

many bags of bone-black ; that is, bone charcoal, and is the sub-

stance now shown me in this tin box, Exhibit 1. In these bills of

Lister Brothers now shown me bone-ash means this article like the

sample before me, Exhibit 4. The other sample now shown me we

call “bone charcoal ;” but it is not ina marketable condition, it has

to be ground finer. That is only partially ground, partly manufac-

tured. I could not sell it readily to-day.

There were times when it could be sold; it is not wanted now.

Our house may have sold an article like this; I don’t know, I don’t

remember. It could have been sold some yearsago; but how many,

I can’t remember.

The defendant’s counsel here rested his case.

The plaintiffs’ counsel then recalled the witness Haminton H.

SALMON on the part of the plaintiffs in rebuttal, who testified as

follows:

52 The value at this time of this article, “bone-black,” for the

purpose of sugar refining is for some sizes, $40—some sizes

sell at $50, some sizes sell at $52.10, and the very best at $60. There

may be occasionally a particular size which is inade of a kind, in a

single instance, which may bring $65. But the general. price now

is from $40 to $45 and $50, and the very highest is $60. In 1881

it was about the same price as now, except that when those goods

were imported they were rather higher than in 1881.

The plaintiffs’ counsel then called Henry A.Srtmonps, as a witness

on the part of the plaintiffs in rebuttal, who, being duly sworn,

testified as follows:

I am in business in this city, with my father’s house, dealing and

importing merchants. I[ heard the evidence given here by the

witness, Mr. Keogh, with reference to the articles contained in this

paper box, now shown to me. I recognize the articles; I have seen

them before. I got them from Mr. Kehoe’s office. -They were given

to me as very coarse bone-black. I did not go there originally to

get that article, but while talking with Mr. Kehoe he mentioned ‘to

me that he had sold some of this stuff for shipment to France, and

as I had been buying their goods from time to time I suggested

taking a sample, which I sent over to the other side. He

53 gave me that as a sample of goods that he was prepared to

sell and I took it for that purpose, and subsequently I got

another one exactly like it. The sample now shown me is, I pre-

sume, the one I obtained then—it was just like it. The first sample

I got in December, 1883, and the other one in June, 1884.

Counsel for both parties then rested

The plaintiffs’ counsel then moved the court upon the evidence

qa’ + ce

in the case to direct the jury to find a verdict for the plaintiff-, which

motion was denied by the court, and the plaintiffs’ counsel duly

excepted to the decision, which exception was duly noted and allowed

by the court,

The defendant’s counsel then moved the court upon the evidence

in the case to direct the jury to find a verdict for the defendant,

whereupon the court ruled as follows:

The question in this case is whether bone-black is included in the

clause “bones crude and not manufactured, burned, calcined, ground,

or steamed,” in the free list of section 2504 of the Revised Statutes.

The evidence shows that it is made by subjecting bones

54 = after being steamed and cleaned to destructive distillation by

heat in close vessels until all is expelled but the carbon, and

then crushing that, and assorting the pieces into proper sizes for

clarifying sugar. |

Bones are understood to be calcined when they are subjected to

heat in open vessels, so as to produce bone-ash by being made fria-

ble, and to be burned when subjected to the direct action of fire.

This distillation appears to be different from either, and the crush-

ing and assorting is an important part of the process. |

By the whole a new article is made from bones. They are not

treated thus for the purpose of securing them or making them port-

uble, as grass is made into hay without becoming manufactured, as

was held in Franzee vs. Moffit, 20 Blatchf., 267, or as apples are cut

and dried, as in that case mentioned. The bones are manufactured

into bone-black by processes of several steps. Schreifer vs. Wood, 5

Blatchf., C. C. Reports, 215. These steps amount to more than:

either of those allowed by the statute without’ making the result

dutiable. For these reasons the jury are directed to find a verdict

for the defendant.

To which decision and direction the counsel for the plaintiff duly

excepted, which exception was duly noted and allowed by the court.

The jury thereupon, under the direction of the court, rendered a

verdict for the defendant.

55 And because none of the exceptions so offered and made

appear upon the records of the said trial, therefore, on the

rayer of the plaintiffs, by their counsel, the judge has signed this

bill of exceptions nunc pro tunc as of the third day of June, 1885.

HOYT H. WHEELER.

56 [Endorsed:] [In pencil:] Copy compared. 7454. United

States circuit court, southern dist. of New York. Charles C.

Harrison et als. vs. Edwin A. Merritt. Bill of exceptions. Isaac

Phillips, plaintiffs’ attorney. U. S. circuit court. Jul. 18, 1885.

Timothy Griffith, clerk.

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A: MERRITT, 4c. 25

=e

c ne oe eee * Re Se os Be

: . — ee SS ee eS BESS Fe Se aR ae eee ye tl EEE MEY OS 4

’ = so slhaies . Uses ees a ee GN ee Yt TAWw 38 he Se ne aye ae oF a WSS a ee SEs Ps :

RN a wha ak nak en oat NS Raed SaaS PS RTS Ae os Ake i sate : 7 Ret are

bad Soe ty ™ E> « Poe : hae :

> « & ; att $ 5

26 CHARLES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, &C.

57 Supreme Court of the United States. Of October Term,

in the vear of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and

eighty-five.

CHARLES C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED C. Har-

rison, William W. Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Junior, |

Plaintiffs in Error, hi

Us. |

Epwin. A. Merritt, Defendant in Error.

Afterwards, to wit, on the second Monday of October, in the same

term, before the Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States,

at the Capitol, in the city of Washington, come the said Charles C. .

Harrison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W.

Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Junior, plaintiffs in error, by

Isaac Phillips, their attorney, and say that in the record and pro-

ceedings aforesaid there is manifest error, in this, to wit, that

58 by the record aforesaid that the judgment aforesaid in the

form aforesaid given was given for the said defendant in

error against the said plaintiffs in error, whereas by the jaw of the

land the said judgment ought to have been given for the said plain-

tiffs against the said defendant.

And the said plaintiffs in error pray that the Judgment afore-

said for the errors aforesaid, and other errors in the said record <

and proceedings aforesaid, may be reversed, annulled, and alto-

gether held for nothing, and that the said plaintiffs may be restored

to all things which they have lost by occasion of the said judgment.

ISAAC PHILLIPS,

Attorney for Plaintiffs in Error.

Endorsed: U.S. Supreme Court. Charles C. Harrison, Theodore

, A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W. Harrison, and

59 William W. Frazier, Junior, pl’ffs in error, vs. Edwin A.

Merritt, def’t in error. Assignment of error. Isaac Phillips,

att’y for pl’ffs in error. Service of a copy of the within is hereby

admitted, this 6th day of Aug., 1885. Wm. Dorsheimer, U. S. att’y.

U.S. circuit court. Filed Aug. 6, 1885. Timothy Griffith, clerk.

“i

A

>

Ae

~~]

60 Joinder in Error.

Supreme Court of the United States.

CHARLES C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED

C. Harrison, WinttAM W. Harrison, & Wm. W. FRa-

ZiER, Jr., Plaintiffs in Error, 7454. | 4

against } Fe

{DWIN A. Merritt, Defendants in Error.

And afterwards, to wit, on the second Monday of October, in said

term, the said defendant in error, by Wm. Dorsheimer, his attorney,

comes here into court and says that there is no error either in the

record or proceedings aforesaid, or in the giving of the judgment

aforesaid. |

CHARLES C. HARRISON ET AIS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, 4c. 27

And he prays that the said Supreme Court, before the Justices

thereof now here, may proceed to examine as well the record and

proceedings aforesaid as the matters aforesaid above assigned for

error, and that the judgment aforesaid, in form aforesaid given,

may be in all thing- affirmed, &c, .

WILLIAM DORSHEIMER,

Attorney for Defendant in Error.

Endorsed: 7454. U.S. Supreme Court. Charles C. Harrison &

al. plaintiffs in error, versus Edwin A. Merritt, defendant in error.

Joinder in error. Wiliiam Dorsheimer, United States attorney, attor-

nev for defendant in error. Due service of a copy of the within is

hereby admitted. New York, Aug. 6th, 1885. Isaac Phillips, attorney —

for plaintiffs in error. To Isaac Phillips, attorney for plaintiffs in

error. U.S. circuitcourt. Filed Aug. 6th,1885. Timothy Griffith,

clerk. 3

62 Bond for Damages and Costs.

Circuit Court of the United States of America for the Southern Dis-

trict of New York, in the Second Circuit.

CHaRLEs C. Harrison, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED C. Har-

RISON, WILLIAM W. Harrison, Junior, and W11L1AM W. Frazier,

v8.

Epwin A. MERRITT.

Know all men by these presents that we, James,J. Thomson, of

309 West 35th street, N. Y. city, and Herman S. Phillips, of 36 West

12th street, N. Y. city, are held and firmly bound unto the above-

named Edwin A. Merritt in the sum of two hundred and fifty dollars,

to be paid to the said Edwin A. Merritt, for the payment of which,

well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, and each of us, our

and each of our heirs, executors, and administrators, jointly and

severally, firmly by these presents.

Sealed with our seals and dated this fifth day, of August, in the

‘year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-five.

Whereas the above-named plaintiffs have prosecuted a writ of

error to the Supreme Court of the United States to reverse the

judgment rendered in the above-entitled suit by the judge of the

circuit court of the United States for the southern district of New

York:

Now, therefore, the condition of this obligation is such, that if

the above-named plaintiffs shall prosecute their said writ of error to

effect, and answer all damages and costs if they fail to make

their plea good, then this obligation shall be void; otherwise, the

same shall be and remain in full force and virtue. :

JAS. J. THOMSON. L. 8.

HERMAN S. PHILLIPS. {[L.s.

Sealed and delivered and taken and acknowledged, this fifth day

of August, 1885, before me— \

[L. s.] CHAS. JAMES,

Notary Public, N. Y. Co.

28 CHAELES C. HARRISON ET ALS. VS. EDWIN A. MERRITT, £¢.

63 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \ pee

Southern District of New York,

James J. Thomson and Herman 8S. Phillips, both of New York

city, each being duly sworn, severally depose and say: That he is a

resident of the southern district of New York, and a freeholder

therein; that he is worth the sum of five hundred dollars over and

above all his just debts and liabilities.

JAS. J. THOMSON.

HERMAN S. PHILLIPS.

Sworn to this fifth day of August, A. D. 1885, before me—

[L. s.] CHAS. JAMES,

Notary Public, N. Y. Co.

[Endorsed:] Vol. —, page —. U.S. circuit court. Charles C.

Harrison et al. vs. Kdwin A. Merritt. Bond for costs on writ of

error. Isaac Phillips, att’y for plaintiffs in error. The within bond

approved as to form and sufficiency of sureties. August 6, 1885.

Addison Brown, U.S. circuit court. Filed Aug. 6, 1885. Timothy

Griffith, clerk.

64 Unitrep STATES OF AMERICA, 88:

To Edwin A. Merritt, Greeting:

You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear at a

Supreme Court of the United States, to be holden at Washington, on

the second Monday of October, eighteen hundred and eighty-five,

pursuant to a writ of error filed in. the clerk’s office of the circuit

court of the United States for the southern district of New York,

wherein Charles C. Harrison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C.

Harrison, William W. Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Junior,

are plaintiffs in error,and you are defendant in error, to show cause,

if any there be, why the judgment in the said writ of error men-

tioned should not be corrected, and speedy justice should not be

done to the parties in that behalf.

Dated August 6th, 1885.

ADDISON BROWN.

65 [ Endorsed :] U. S. Supreme Court. Charles C. Harrison,

| Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William W.

Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Junior, plaintiffs in error, against

Edwin A. Merritt, defendant in error. Citation. Service of a copy

of the within is hereby admitted, this 6th day of August, 1885.

Wm.Dorsheimer, U.S. att’y. [Stamped:] U.S. circuit court. Aug.

6, 1885. Timothy Griffith, clerk.

Endorsed on cover: S. New York., C.C. U.S. No. 913. Charles

C. Harrison, Theodore A. Havemeyer, Alfred C. Harrison, William

W. Harrison, and William W. Frazier, Jr., plaintiffs in error, vs. Ed-

win A. Merritt, collector of the port of New York. Filed August

10, 1885.

\

In the Supreme Court of the United States.

OCTOBER TERM, 1888.

No. 913.

CHARLES C. HARRISON, THEODORE A. HAVEMEYER,

ALFRED C. HARRISON, WILLIAM W. HARRISON anp

WILLIAM W. FRAZIER, Jr.,

Plaintiffs in Error,

US.

EDWIN A. MERRITT, COLLECTOR OF THE PORT OF

NEW YORK,

Defendant in Error.

BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFFS IN ERROR.

Cc. C. SUYDAM,

Attorney for Plaintiffs in Error.

HENRY E. DAVIES,

Of Counsel for Plaintiffs in Error.

Tax EVENING Post JOB PRINTING OFFICE, 208 Broadway, N. Y.

7

- 4 »

ae

Px v2

”

2 &

‘e

BS ihc n

Seth ee ts Se

: Supreme Court of the United States

i! nited States.

= eS CHARLES C. HARRISON, THEO-

c “a DORE A. HAVEMEYER, ALFRED

soe C. HaRRIsonN, WILLIAM W.

sae HARRISON AND WILLIAM W.

Be ” FRAZIER, JR., x - - =

oe Plaintiffsin Error. |, Brief for Plaintiffs in

gon aee: Se ‘ Error on case submitted.

nek » AGAINST

ated Epwin A. MERRITT, COLLECTOR

Sate OF THE Port or NEw YorK.

os ae ee. 4

ao oS Defendant in Error.

ee STATEMENT.

This action is brought to recover from the defendant,

Collector of the Port of New York, the sum of seven

4s oP thousand two hundred and twenty-four %5, dollars ($7,- 3

ees me 224.75), which, as charged in the declaration, was illegally : 4

GPe we assessed and collected as duties upon three several impor- ‘f

. tations of merchandise brought into the port of New York

ere by the plaintiffs in the year 18-1.

cca On the part of the plaintiffs it was claimed that at the

fod time the importations were made the goods in question

ais Ms were free of duty under the Revised Statutes of the United

a fs States, which contained the tariff law then in force.

"tee 5 In the section of the statutes which enumerates the ar-

, ticles which may be imported free of duty, the following

Clause is found:

| i ails, °

ae

er ‘

‘¢ Bones, crude and not manufactured; burned, calcined,

‘* ground, or steamed.

‘‘Bone dust and bone ash for manufacture of phos-

‘* phates and fertilizers.”

U.S. Rev. Stat., Ed. 1878, § 2505, p. 483.

Due protest against this exaction was made, and the

formal proceedings required to permit the bringing of the

action were taken, of which no question arises in the case

at bai, and in such protest, as now, it is claimed that

these importations were entitled to free entry under the

clause cited.

The cause was brought to trial before the Circuit Court

of the United States for the Southern District of New

York, and after the evidence of the parties to the action had

been presented, the learned Judge, before whom the trial

was had, directed the jury to find a verdict for the defend-

ant, and gave his reasons for such ruling in the opinion

which appears in the record.

Record, p. 25, fol. 54.

From the judgment entered upon that verdict, this ap-

peal is taken. :

Errors Assigned.

1.

That the Court erred in admitting evidence of the value

of bone black, the article in question, as compared with

values of crude hones, or of other products obtained from

bones.

Vide three exceptions, Record, p. 21, fols. 44

—46.

2.

That the Court erred in refusing to direct the jury to find

a verdict for the plaintiff upon the evidence, as prayed for

at the conclusion of the testimony.

Vide Exception, Record, p. 25, fol. 53.

3

3.

That the Court erred in directing the jury to find a

verdict for the defendant upon the evidence at the conclu-

sion of the testimony.

' Vide Exception, Record, p. 25, fol. 54.

LAW AND FACT.

Law.

1.

It is claimed on the part of the plaintiffs in error that

the goods in question, known in trade and commerce as

BonE BLACK, and by accurate scientific designation as

Animal Charcoal, are free of duty, and entitled to free

entry under the Tariff Act in force at the time of importa-

tion.

**§ 2505. The importation of the following articles shall

be exempt from duty. * * * * * * Bones, crude

and not manufactured; burned, calcined, ground or

steamed.

‘¢ Bone dust and bone ash for manufacture of phosphates

and fertilizers.” ;

U.S. Rev. St., Ed. 1878, p. 483.

' 9

On the part of the defeAdant it was claimed that the

goods in question were a manufacture of bone, and as such

were dutiable under the following provision of the Revised

Statutes:

‘*$ 2504. Schedule M. * * * Manufactures of bones,

horn, ivory, or vegetable ivory, thirty-five per centum, ad

valorem.”

U. S. Rev. St., Ed. 1878, p. 474.

The opinion of the Court found on page 25 of the Record

shows that this view was adopted in rendering the decision

appealed from, and that the Court «lecided the question of

fact raised, and held Bone Black to be ‘‘a manufacture of

bones,” and as such liable to duty.

4

3.

The goods imported were classified by the collector as

‘* black of bone,” and duty assessed upon them at the rate

of twenty-five per centum ad valorem, in pursuance of the

following clause of the Tariff Act:

‘<8 2504. Schedule M. * * * Black of bone, or ivory

drop black, twenty-five per centum ad valorem.”

U.S. Rev. St., Ed. 1878, p. 473.

It is apparent, however, from the record of evidence and

the opinion of the Court, that this clause of the statute

was not urged or relied on by the defendant as justifying

his action, or considered by the Court in reaching the de-

cision made.

Facts.

From the evidence the following facts appeared:

The goods in question were received by the plaintiffs

pursuant to three separate invoices, as follows:

The first from England under date of April 23, 1881,

and headed : :

** Invoice of 4,800 bags of animal charcoal * *”

Record, f. 19.

The second from France under date of June 3, 1881, and

headed :

** Facture a 470 sacs os calcinés” * * *

(Translated): ‘‘ Invoice of 470 bags calcined bones” * *

Record, ff. 20-21.

The third from England under date of June 11, 1881,

and headed :

‘Invoice of 1,334 bags of burnt bones” * * *

Record, f. 22.

The defendant collector caused a duty of twenty-five

per centum ad valorem to be assessed upon the goods

referred to in these three invoices, classifying them as

‘**black of bone,” on which the plaintiffs protested and

5

claimed the goods to be free of duty as ‘‘calcined bones,”

pues to § 2,505, U. S. Rev. St. cited.

Record, ff. 23-26.

The goods imported by the plaintiffs were identified as

represented by the sample, Ex. 1.

Record, p. 13, f. 26.

The expert witness, Drummond, testifies to the follow-

ing facts: That the substance represented by Exhibit 1 is

animal charcoa! obtained by cleaning refuse bones, plac-

ing them in closed vessels and calcining them, the result-

ing product is then ground to the size represented by the

sample, and used by sugar refiners as a decolorizer. The

_ $1ze in which it is broken is an element of its use. A fine

powder cannot be used by sugar refiners.

‘‘Ivory drop black” is a pigment made by burning

scraps of ivory, grinding them to an impalpable powder in

water, dropping it into suitable ‘forms, and drying it. It

is used as a pigment.

A similar treatment of finely ground bone produces

a black paint sometimes called ‘‘ ivory drop black.”

‘*‘ Black” is a distinctive term among dealers in colors,

and is frequently used as a designation of paints and pig-

ments.

There are many blacks known in the color trade distin-

guished by the name of the substance from which they

are produced.

The substance represented by Exhibit 1 cannot be used

as a pigment; is not a pigment.

Witness has never known or heard of an article known

s ‘‘black of bone” in business or in the arts.

Record, pp. 13-14, ff. 27-30.

In all the various processes that have been described

the bone is calcined while in the retort by the action of

heat. Whether it is called distillation or carbonization, it

is a calcination.

The sample shown, Exhibit 4, is bone that has been

burned or calcined in the open air; it undergoes that pro-

cess to deprive it of carbon, and phosphate of lime is

6

left. If burned in close vessels, the carbon is not taken off

by theair, and the resulting product is black in color.

As the. substance in question in this action comes from

the retort, it is chemically changed from bone. It is a dif-

ferent substance, chemically as well as physically.

Record, p. 16, ff. 33, 34.

The witness, Salmon, an importer familiar with the

article, and a dealer in it, testifies:

That the substance is known here $as ‘* bone black ”

or ‘‘ animal charcoal,” and has been so Known since 1874.

He never heard it called ‘‘ black of bone,” and that term

is not used as the designation of any 3 it article.

Record, p. 16, f. 34. oh

The witness, Simonds, an importer and dealer in this

substance, testifies to the same effect.

Record, p. 18, f. 38.

The following descriptions of the article in question

were read in evidence, taken from scientific works of rec-

ognized authority.

‘Bone black, animal black, animal charcoal * * *

a product obtained by heating bones to redness in close

vessels. Large quantities of stinking gas, empyreumatic

oil and volatile alkaloids are then evolved, and there re-

mains a black mass, consisting of an intimate mixture of

charcoal, containing nitrogen, with the mineral matter of

the bone, chiefly phosphate and carbonate of calcium.

It possesses the power of abstracting many solid sub-

stances from their solutions, and is used on a very large

scale as a decolorizing agent in the refining of sugar.

% & #99

Watts’ Chemical Dictionary, p. 624.

Record, p. 14, f. 29.

‘* BonE BLACK or animal charcoal is the residue left in cal-

cining bones in close vessels. The bones are

placed either in close retorts, like those used in

making coal gas, or in iron pots. On the applica-

f

tion of heat, destructive distillation takes place.

Combustible gases escape, accompanied by vapors,

which condense to ammoniacal water and offen-

sive oils. Bone or Dippel’s oil is thus produced.

The residue in the vessels amounts to about 50 per

cent. in weight of the original bones. It is passed

between rollers ani separated by sieves into dif-

ferent sizes. * * * Its chief application in the

arts is for the purification of sugar. * * *”

C. F. CHANDLER.

Johnson’s Encyclopedia, vol. 1, p. 551.

Record, p, 14, f. 29.

‘* BONE BLACK, or animal charcoal, as it is less correctly

called, is the black carbonaceous substance into

which bones are converted by calcination in close

Tenn. 7 7?"

Ure’s Dictionary of Arts, &c., p. 394.

Record, p. 14, f. 29.

Wagner’s Technology and Cooley’s Encyclopedia de-

scribe and define the word bone black, and the metl:od of

production in the same manner, with slight differences of

phraseology.

Record, p. 15, f. 32.

On the trial of the action the following definitions in or-

dinary and accustomed language of the words used in the

clause of the Tariff aw under discussion, and in the sci

entific descriptions of the substance bone black, were given,

all from Webster’s Dictionary, an acknowledged authority.

‘* Bone Buack. The black carbonaceous substance into

which bones are converted by calcination in close

vessels, called also animal charcoal.” * * *

‘‘Burn, * * 8. To affect by or submit to the action of

fire or heat, for some useful-or economic purpose,

or in the processes of the arts. As, to burn char-

coal, or to burn a kiln of wood, to reduce wood to

charcoal, to burn bricks to bake or harden them

aoe *

8

‘“CALCINATION. 1. The operation of expelling from a sub-

stance by heat some volatile matter, and thus

disintegrating it and reducing it to a friable state.

Thus carbonate of lime is reduced to lime by cal-

cination, or the expulsion of carbonic acid.

= & 99

‘*CaLcINE. 1. To reduce to a powder or to a friable state,

by the action of heat, or to expel some volatile

matter from, as carbonic acid from limestone.”

Record, p. 18, f. 38.

For the defense three witnesses were called, whose evi-

dence, when tested by cross-examination, corresponded

with that given on behalf of the plaintiff in error.

The witness Chambers testifies, on the direct, that the

article in question is generally known in trade or com-

merce as ‘‘ bone black” or *‘ animal charcoal,” while he

has heard the phrase ‘‘ black of bone” applied to it; that

is not the common name.

He identifies the sample shown as Exhibit 4, which, he

says, are bones burned in the open air, and states he knows

of articles dealt with in the trade called ‘‘ burnt bone” and

‘** calcined bone.”

Record, pp. 18 19, ff. 39-41.

On his cross-examination he states, that to his mind

there is no difference between a burnt and calcined bone;

that bone black is not calcined bone. and that he differs

from the scientific definitions that have been given in the

evidence.

Though dealing in the article, he does not state in his

bills that he is a dealer in burnt or calcined bone. He can

give no instance of any dealer who doves so state.

He does not know of any manufacturer or dealer in

‘*bone black”’ who describes it on his bills as ‘‘ black of

bone.” |

He knows nothing of the process of making what he

calls ‘* calcined bone and burnt bone.”

The sample, Exhibit 4, is known in trade as “‘ bone ash.”

‘‘ Bone ash ” is the general name and designation of that

9

in the trade, without regard to the degree of fineness of

which it is made.

The term burnt bone is very seldom used. The trade

term for this is generally ‘‘ash.”

Record, pp. 19, 20, ff. 41-44.

The witness then, under objection and exception duly

taken, gave evidence as to the comparative values of

‘‘pone black” and ‘‘crude bone,” ‘‘ bone ash,” and

‘* spent bone black.”

Record, p. 21, ff. 44, 45.

The witness Muller testified: That the name of the arti-

cle in question in trade or commerce is ‘* bone black” or

‘*black.” He has heard it called black of bone to distin-

guish it from black of ivory; that is not the usual name.

The article made by burning bones in the open air, which

he says is known in trade as burnt bones or calcined bones,

is ‘‘ bone ash.”

On CROSS-EXAMINATION he states:

That he is a manufacturer of ** bone black,”’ not a manu-

facturer of ‘‘ bone.” The term ‘black of bone” is used to

distinguish the finely ground article which is suitable for

paint. If he wished to buy the article he speaks of as

‘‘burned bones” or ‘‘ calcined bones,” he would order

‘* bone ash.” |

Record, p. 22, ff. 47, 48.

The witness Kehoe testifies: That the article in question

has been known in this country since 1867, by the trade

name ‘‘ bone black.”

Has never heard of any article dealt in under the name

of ‘‘ burnt bone.” ‘‘ Bone ash” is what he calls ‘‘ burnt

bone,” which is bones that have been burnt in the open

air, and ‘‘ calcined bone,” which is the same thing. He

knows no difference between calcined bone and burnt bone.

Record, p. 23, f. 50.

On his CROSS-EXAMINATION he states: On the bill-heads

of our house we generally call the substance in question

10

in this case ‘‘bone charcoal.” This bill of our house

shown, is for ‘‘ bone black,” which is the article repre-

sented by Exhibit 1. In these bills of our house shown, the

term ‘‘bone ash” means the article represented, by Ex-

hibit 4.

POINTS.

I.

It was manifest error for the Court to admit and con-

sider the evidence given on the tria] as to the value of the

article imported, as compared with that of the crude sub-

stance, from which it was produced, with the value of an-

other product obtained from the same crude substance by

a different process; and with the value of the article itself

after it had been used for the purpose for which it was in-

tended.

Record, p. 21, ff. 44, 45.

(a.

The question to be tried was simply whether or not the

article imported by the plaintiff in error was or was not

included in the clause of the Tariff act which exempts

from duty ‘*bones crude, or unmanufactured, burned,

calcined, ground, or steamed,” and upon that issue no pos-

sible question of actual or comparative value could arise.

The Court erred in refusing, as asked, to direct the jury

to find a verdict for the plaintiffs upon the conclusion of

the evidence,

a -

~2-

11

1. |

The evidence showed beyond dispute (see abstract of

testimony, supra) that the trade name or designation of

the article imported by the plaintiffs, and shown in Ex. 1,

was “‘ Bone Black.”

)

ade

That it was in fact and of necessity, through the

method of production, calcined bone, and that term, in

common and ordinary language and according to scientific

definition, aptly and correctly described the substance.

3.

That the Tariff Act contained in the Revised Statutes of

the U. S., ed. 1878, nowhere mentions or provides for

‘* Bone Black,” either eo numine or by any other of the

trade or technical terms by which it is known, such as

‘animal charcoal,” ‘‘ animal carbon,” ‘ char,” but does

provide that ‘‘ calcined bones” shall be free of duty.

+.

That the substance represented by Ex. 4, a product re-

sulting from burning bones in the open air, is not known

or recognized in trade or commerce as ‘‘ calcined bone,”

but the witnesses for both parties agree in saying that the

trade term and designation of this article is ‘‘ Bone Ash,”

and under that name we find it mentioned and provided

for in the Tariff Act cited, in the clause immediately fol-

lowing that providing for ‘‘ calcined bones,” thus showing

conclusively that this substance. ‘‘ Bone Ash,” was re-

garded and considered, in the intention of Congress, as an

article of merchandize produced from bone, separate and

distinct from any of those provided for in the preceding

clause.

5.

There was no evidence whatever to show that the article

of the plaintiffs importation could be classified under the

clause of § 2504, reading ‘‘ Black of bone, or ivory-drop

black.”

12

Plaintiffs’ expert witness, Drummond, testifies that

neither in business nor in the arts has he heard of an

article know as ‘“‘black of bone.” That ‘‘ivorydrop

black ” is a pigment produced by a peculiar process, and

that by similar treatment of this substanee a black pig-

ment can be produced that is also called ‘‘ivory-drop

black.” That bone black, in the condition in which it is

imported and as exhibited on the trial, is not adapted for

and cannot be used as a pigment.

That in the business in which he is engaged (manufac-

ture of paints) a number of black pigments are known

and used, which are distinguished, one from the other, by

the name of the substance from which they are produced.

Record, pp. 13, 14; ff. 27-30. )

This evidence, together with the wording and connec-

tion, shows that Congress, in the use of the phrase ‘‘ black

of bone,” with the alternative ** ivory-dop black,” intended

to cover the black pigment produced from bone as well as

that resulting from similar treatment of ivory.

This view is corroborated by the evidence of the witness

Muller, a manufacturer called for the defence. He says,

on his direct.examination,

(Record, p. 22, fol. 47):

peed ” "i It might be called ‘black of bone’ to

distinguish it from ‘black of ivory; there is a black

made from ivory; I have heard it called that way to make

the difference between black of ivory and black of bone.

% * % 99

On cross-examination he says, °

Record, p. 22, f. 48: .

ies . " The term ‘black of bone’ is used to

distinguish this finer ground article, which is suitable for

paint. ™ oi 7“

The other witnesses for the defense, Chambers and

Kehoe, say that the usual and customary name of the

substance imported by the plaintiff is *‘ bone black.”

They say that they have heard the phrase “ black of

ee ee Cae

13

bone” applied to it, but admit that is nota common name

or one in use for it.

Record, p. 19, ff. 39, 42; p. 23, ff. 50, 51.

e

b,

If this refusal to direct a verdict for the plaintiffs was

based upon the ground that the article in question was

either a ‘‘ manufactured article not otherwise provided

for,” or a ‘‘manufacture of bone,” as may be gathered

from the opinion of the Court, it is submitted that even

greater error exists than is shown in the previous points.

(at. )

That this article cannot be classed asa ‘‘ manufacture

not otherwise provided for” needs no argument.

The language of the clause of the statute in question,

‘* Bones crude, and not manufactured; burned, calcined,

ground, or steamed,” shows that Congress, after providing

for ‘‘ bones unmanufactured,” had also in view and under

consideration bones that had been subjected to the pro-

cesses of burning, calcining, grinding or steaming, and

that if bones which have heen treated in this manner can

in any sense be said to be manufactured, they are in this

clause described and provided for as distinguished from

bones unmanufactured.

(Db. )

This substance, ‘‘ bone black,”’ which is defined as ‘‘ the

black carbonaceous substance into which bones are con-

verted by calcination in close vessels,”’ can by no possibil-

ity be regarded either in fact or law as a ‘‘ manufacture of

bone.”

1.

This position is conclusively established by the case of

Meyer vs. Arthur, 91 U.S. Rep., 570.

In that case an attempt was made to classify ‘‘ as manu-

factures of metals,” white lead. and similar substances

produced from the metals zinc or lead, by a treatment

that includes, firstly, exposure to acids or heat, in such

14

manner as to cause a chemical change in the original

metals, and secondly, a grinding of the product thus ob-

tained.

This Court refused tosustain the proposition, and in the

opinion delivered, says:

‘“‘ Manufactures of metals refers to manufactured ar-

ticles in which metal forms a component part, and not to

articles in which it has lost its form entirely and become

the ingredient of new forms.”

With a substitution of the word ‘* bones ” for ‘‘ metals ”

the ruling covers the case now before the Court.

Such a treatment, the Court says, is ‘‘not a manufacture

but a process.” :

As to the effect upon classification of imported goods,

resulting from the processes of burning, grinding, exposure

to heat, &c., see

Arthur vs. Herold, 100 U.S. Rep., 75.

Frazee vs. Moffitt, 20 Blatchford, 267.

~

The defendant produces one case to support the position

that ‘‘ bone black” should be called a ‘‘ manufacture of

bone ”’ in the construction of the Tariff Laws, viz., Schriefer

vs. Wood, 5 Blatchford, U.S. Rep., 215, decided in May,

1864, in the District Court of the United States, and upon

this decision the opinion of the Court in the case at bar is

evidently based.

That case arose under the Internal Revenue Laws now

repealed, and was decided at a time when public necessity

demanded, and too often obtained, a strict construction of

such statutes. |

Examination of the case as reported, will show that it

was argued and decided with little thought or considera-

tion, and if ever authority, has been overruled by the

decision in Meyer vs. Arthur (supra).

A further suggestion is made, to show that at no time

could that case have had authority as controlling laws re-

lating to customs revenue, but that it was absolutely con-

trary to the spirit and letter of the statutes in forc

15

when the decision was given, for at that time not only

was ‘‘bone black” free of duty, but it was distinguished

in the Tariff Laws from ‘‘ manufactures of bone” which

were subject to duty.

‘Reference is made to the following citations from the

statutes then in force:

‘¢§ 29. From and after the day and year aforesaid there

shall be levied, collected and paid a duty of thirty per

centum on the importation of the articles hereinafter

mentioned and embraced in this section; that is to say, *

ae %

Manufactures of bone, shel], horn, ivory or vegetable

ivory.” x % x % x

Act of March 2, 1861 (U0. S. Stat., vol. 12,

p. 192.)

‘“*$ 23. From and after the day and year aforesaid the

importation of the articles hereinafter mentioned and em-

braced in this section shall be exempt fromduty * * *

animal carbon (bone black). * * *”

Act of March 2, 1861, U.S. Stat., vol. 12,

p. 193.

“$13. From and after the day and year aforesaid, in

addition to the duties heretofore imposed by law on the

articles hereinafter mentioned, there shall be levied, col-

lected and paid on the goods, wares and merchandise enu-

merated and provided for in this section, imported from

foreign countries. a duty of five per centum ad vurlorem ;

thatistosay, * * *

Manufactures of bone, shell, horn, or vegetable ivory.

% + #99

Act of July 14, 1862, U. S. Stat., vol. 12,

p. 557.

This was the law in force when the case of Schriefer vs.

Wood (supra) was argued and decided, but it seems to

have been disregarded or overlooked by counsel and by the

Court.

16

(c.)

If further argument is needed on the question of the

intent with which Congress used the term ‘‘ manufac-

tures of bones” in the Tariff Act under consideration, it

will be found in other clauses of that act, and especially

in Schedule M, where Congress has enumerated and im-

posed duty upon various articles made from bone, and

which are properly ‘‘ manufactures of bones ” in the sense

in which that phrase has been interpreted by this Court

in the case of Meyer vs. Arthur (supra).

Schedule M, U.S. Rev. St., Ed.,1878, p. 474, pro-

vides for ‘‘ buttons.” ‘‘ combs,” ‘‘ivory, or bone

dice,” ‘‘ draughts,” ‘‘chess men,” ‘‘ chess balls,”

‘* bayatelle balls,” all familiar well known articles

made by process of the arts from bone, and of which

bone as such is a component, unchanged chemically

or physically, but by the art or skill of the manu-

facturer given such shape as to adapt it to the uses

for which it may be designed.

(a. )

It is a well settled rule, that in the construction of a

Tariff Act a Court may refer to past as well as subsequent

statutes for the purpose of determining the intention of

Congress in framing the law under consideration.

Lawrence ws. Allen, 7 How. U.S. R, 785.

On the part of the plaintiffs in error it is submitted that

an examination of the laws relating to this substance

‘* bone black ” (animal carbon, calcined bones), shows that

Congress intended it to be, and that it was free of duty

from 1861 until March 3, 1883, when the Tariff Act now in

force was passed and the article was subjected to duty.

As shown above under § 23 of the Act of March 2, 1861

(supra), ‘animal carbon (bone black)” was exempted from

duty, and in the same: section, ** bones burnt and bone

dust ’ are also declared free of duty. No mention - cal-

cined bones is made in that act.

No subsequent mention is made in the statutes of ‘‘ ani-

SN a Na ale , x <

17

mal carbon (bone black),” nor is there any repeal actual or

implied of the clauses cited down to the time of the Re-

vised Statutes, and it must therefore be held to have been

free of duty until that period.

Reiche vs. Smythe, 13 Wall., 162.

Smythe vs. Fiske, 23 Wall., 374.

Arthur vs. Lahey, 96 U.S., 112.

By the Revised Statutes, previous laws, tariff as well as

others, were repealed, and we then find that while ‘‘ ani-

mal carbon (bone black),” is not specifically named, a

broad and sweeping clause is enacted covering all processes

or treatments to which bones can be subjected, other than

manufactures of bone for purposes of use or ornament, or

the production of pigment.

‘‘ Bones crude, and not manufactured, burned, cal-

cined, ground, or steamed.

Bone dust and bone ash for manufacture of phosphates

and fertilizers.”

U.S. Rev. St., Ed. 1878, p. 483.

This certainly must include bones calcined, the article

known in trade, commerce and the arts as ‘‘ bone black,”

or by the various other terms that have been cited.

Further and conclusive evidence of the fact that this

substance was intended to be and was regarded by Con-

gress as exempt from duty under the Revised Statutes, is

found in the terms of the subsequent act by which a duty

was finally imposed upon this substance.

The Tariff Act of March, 1883, contains the following

two provisions referring to this substance by specific

names, showing that the question had received more than

ordinary consideration, and a determination to effectually

remove it from the general clause under which it had

theretofore been exempt from duty:

‘¢ § 2,502. There shall be levied. collected and paid upon

all articles imported from foreign countries, and men-

tioned in the schedules herein contained, the rates of duty

18

which are by the schedules respectively prescribed,

namely:

Schedule A. * * * The pigment known as bone

black and ivory drop black, and bone char, twenty-five

(25) per cent. ad valorem. * * *”

§ 2503. The following articles, when imported, shall be

exempt from duty: * * *

Carbon animal fit for fertilizing only (free). * * *”

Act of March, 1883, U.S. Stat., vol. 22, pp.

494, 515.

As shown by the evidence, ‘‘ bone char,” ‘‘ bone char-

coal,” ‘‘char,” are names under which ‘* bone black ” is

known, and are descriptive terms applied to that sub-

stance by importers and dealers.

Salmon, Record, p. 16, ff. 34, 36.

Simonds, ‘‘ ‘* 18, f. 38.

Kehoe, ‘¢ pp. 28, 24, ff. 50, 51.

Could there possibly be a fuller recognition of the fact

that animal carbon, bone black, or bone char, had been up

to that time free from duty, and it was the intention of

Congress that thereafter this substance, except so much

thereof as was only fitted for use as a fertilizer, should be

subject to payment of import dues.

It is further to be noted that in the Act of 1883 (supra),

as well as in previous acts, ‘‘ bone black,” ‘‘ animal car-

bon,” ‘‘ bone char,” are specifically and by name provided

for and distinguished from ‘‘ manufactures of bone,”

which are provided for 2s follows:

*S 2502. * * Schedule M. Sundries * * * #*

Bone, horn, ivory or vegetable ivory, all manufactures

of, not specially enumerated or provided for in this act,

thirty (30) per centum ad valorem.”

Act of March 3, 1883.

U. S. Stat., vol. 22, p. 511.

19

The Court erred in refusing to permit the case to go the

jury and in directing a verdict for the defendant.

It was conceded that the tariff law, as given in the Re-

vised Statutes, did not mention or refer to the article im-

ported by the plaintiffs by a trade name or specific designa-

tion, and the plaintiffs claimed that it was covered by the

phrase, used in the act, ‘‘ calcined bones.”

The defendants claimed that it was covered by the one or

other of these expressions used in the act, ** black of bone ”

or ‘‘manufactures of bone,” and the Court decided the

case by holding the goods to be dutiable as ‘‘ manufactures

of bone.” :

It is apparent that the expressions used in the Tariff

Act, which were claimed by either party to the action to

refer to this article, were descriptive and not denomina-

tive, and the question to be determined upon the evidence

was the intention of Congress in using the terms referred

to and the meaning they should bear.

This was entirely a question for the jury, and the Court

had no right or power to decide it as a question of law.

Lawrence vs. Allen, 7 How., U.S. R., 785.

Frazee vs. Moffitt, 20 Blatch., 267.

Arthur vs. Herold, 100 U. S., 75.

AV. oe

As has been said in the last point, the various te=—

used or claimed to have been used in the Tariff Act under

consideration as designating the article imported by the

plaintiffs are descriptive, and not denominative.

It is apparent from the evidence that neither ‘‘ calcined

bones,” ‘‘ black of bone” or ‘‘ manufactures of bone ” are

trade or commercial names or designations of articles

dealt in. The commercial or trade denominative names

20

of the goods in question have been shown to be “‘ bone

black,” ‘‘animal charcoal or carbon,” ‘‘char,” ‘bone

charcoal.” ° :

The witnesses for the defendant attempted to testify

that ‘‘calcined bone” was a trade name for the bone

burnt in the open air, represented by Exhibit 4, but were

compelled to admit that the actual trade name and desig-

nation of that substance was ‘‘ bone ash,” the name by

which it is recognized and provided for in the Tariff Act

now considered.

Record, p. 20, f. 43; p. 22, ff. 47, 48; p. 23, f. 50.

It thus appears that none of the commercial or technical

terms used in the Tariff Act contained in the Revised

Statutes apply to, or describe, the articleimported by the

plaintiffs in error, but that article and the process by which

it is produced, is fully described by the term ‘‘ calcined

bones. ”’

The popular or received import of words furnishes the

general rule for the interpretation of public laws, as well

as of private and social transactions.

Maillard vs. Lawrence, 16 How. U.S. R., 251.

The language of tariff acts is construed as having the

same meaning in commerce, that it has in the community

at large, unless the contrary is shown.

Schneider vs. Barney, 113 U. S., 645.

Greenleaf vs. Goodrich, 101 U. S., 278.

Swan vs. Arthur, 103 U. S., 597.

V.

The Court in passing upon a question of this character

should endeavor to give effect tu the whole statute, as it

stands, so as to make all the parts harmonize, if practi-

cable, and give asensible and intelligent effect to each,

nor should it be presumed that the Legislature meant that

21

any part of a statute should be without meaning or with-

out force and effect.

Ogden vs. Strong, 2 Paine, 584.

U.S. vs. Warner, 4 McLean, 463.

U.S. vs. Barrett, 2 Story, 359.

U.S. vs. Kirby, 7 Wall., 482.

In reading the clause of the statute relied on by the

plaintiff in error, it will be found that the plaintiff’s goods

are provided for under the term ‘‘ calcined bones,” which

they are in word and in fact, and should this Court refuse

so to hold, it must be assumed that this phrase was used

without meaning or serious intent, and was idle and

superfluous.

| This conclusion, as above shown, would be in violation

of all accepted rules of statutory construction, and should

| be avoided, if possible. .

The phrase ‘‘calcined bones” cannot mean the bone

burnt in the open air, producing a white ash, composed

chiefly of phosphates, for that, as we have seen, has a

distinct and well known trade name, ‘bone ash,” under

which it is described and recognized in the Tariff Act.

U. S. Rev. St., Ed. 1878, § 2505, p. 483.

Vi.

The law should be interpreted in its clear and apparent

significance according to the usual and accepted meaning

of the words used, in the absence of scientific or technical

terms, and in case of existing doubt as to the meaning of

the words employed the statute should be construed favor-

ably to the importer.

(a.)

‘The words of the statute are to be taken in the sense

in which they will be understood by that public in which

they are to take effect. Science and skill are not required

99

in their interpretation, except where scientific or technical

terms are used * * *

4. If there is a doubt as to the liability of an instrument

to taxation, the construction is in favor of the exemption,

because in the language of Pollock, C. B., in Girr vs.

Scudds, a tax cannot be imposed without clear and ex-

press words for that purpose.”

U. S. v. Isham, 17 Wallace, 496 and cases

there cited.

(b.)

Duties are never imposed upon a citizen in cases of seri-

ous ambiguity in the language of an act, a doubtful classi-

fication of articles, or vague and doubtful interpretation,

and in all such cases the construction should be in favor of

the importer. |

Powers vs. Barney, 5 Blatchford, 202. —

U. S. vs. Ullman, 4 Benedict, 547.

Vil.

The judgment appealed from should be reversed, and

judgment ordered for the plaintiff.

HENRY E. DAVIEs,

Of Counsel for Plffs. in Error.

CHARLES C. SuUYDAM,

Att’y for Plffs. in Error.

[J7558]

RM,

5

Fo.

eae

y :

®

‘No. 913.

son, Will-

BRIEF. FOR DEFENDANT IN ERROR.

lliany W.

arri

error,

e

‘

THEODORE A.

d

e

ison,

inti

| .

jr, p

Epwin A. : Manarrr,

‘Alfred C. Hi

er,

Harr

Cartes C. Harrison,

vemey

W

ier,

Fraz

Ha

iam

+=

the port of New York, defendant in

error.

“tn the Supreme Court of the clavited States.

OcTOBER TERM, 1885.

CHARLES C. HARRISON, THEODORE A. )

Havemeyer, Alfred C.Harrison, Will-

iam W. Harrison, and William W.

Frazier, jr., — in error, \ No. 913.

Epwin A. MERRITT, COLLECTOR OF

the port of New York, defendant in

error. 7 J

BRIEF FOR DEFENDANT IN ERROR.

The plaintiffs in error brought this action in the cir-

cuit court of the United States for the southern district

of New York to recover $7,224.75 duties on importations

of merchandise from London and Havre, which amounts

they allege were illegally assessed and collected. The

amounts were paid by them under protest.

In their complaint, and in their bill of particulars,

plaintiffs describe the merchandise as “ bones burned, cal-

cined, ground, or steamed ” (record, p. 4).

In this description they have literally adopted the lan-

guage of section 2505, U.S. Revised Statutes, edition of

1878, p. 483.

5779

2

The defendant, in his answer, says the amounts collected

from the plaintiffs were the amounts due from them to the

United States, according to the rate of duty imposed by

law upon such imported merchandise, and not otherwise

(record, p. 7).

Upon the trial the plaintiffs reserved certain exceptions

to the rulings and proceedings of the court, and error is

assigned thereon in this court (record, pp. 9 and 26).

The errors assigned by plaintiffs will be taken up seri-

atim.

I.

That the court erred in admitting evidence of the

value of bone-black, the articles in question, as com-

pared with values of crude bones, or of other prod-

ucts of bones. (vide three exceptions, record, p. 21).

The witness Chambers stated that he knew the differ-

ence in value between bone-black and the crude bone.

The court permitted the witness to state the difference,

over the objection of plaintiffs’ counsel. Chambers an-

swered that “bone is worth about $22 aton; the bone-

black is worth $65.”

The defendant’s counsel then asked, by permission of

the court, over like objection of plaintiffs’ counsel :

Q. What is the difference in value commercially

between the white article, the burnt bone, or burnt

ash or calcined bone, as the article usually dealt in,

in the trade, and the bone-black in the tin ?

A. About $40 aton is the difference in value.

The bone ash was worth from $20 to $22 and the

other $65. The ground bone of commerce varies

from $25 to $30 a ton, and the bone-black is $65.

3

The defendant’s counsel then asked the witness, over

like objection of the plaintiffs’ counsel, by permission of

the court, thedifference in value between bone-black before

it is used by the sugar refiners and after it is spent for

that purpose.

A. Before it is used it is worth $65, and after they

throw it out—discard it—it is worth $17 to-day.

The first assignment of error is made on the admission

of the above evidence over the objections of plaintiffs’

counsel.

The evidence was material and competent to show that

the article imported was not, and could not have been, by

reason of its value, “bones, crude and not manufactured ;

burned, calcined, ground or steamed,” and exempt from

duty under section 2505 of Revised Statutes of 1878. It

shows the imported article to have been a manufactured

article, not within the above exemptions, and which, by

reason of such manufacture, enters into commerce with

another name, and an entirely different value. No doubt

the court admitted the evidence for this purpose, and for

none other. It had its weight in fixing the character of

the article imported, and it was a proper way by which to

establish such fact.

II.

‘That the court erred in refusing to direct the

jury to find a verdict for the plaintiffs upon the evi-

dence, as prayed for at the conclusion of the testi-

mony (vide exception, record, p. 25).

The evidence shows the name or designation of the

article imported to have been somewhat unsettled by the

BELONG ANE AEDES AEE OOS EG, EAI ENS IG! OSB RL SMR IME ETL AD BUR EER

4

trade. All agree that it was used for the purpose of de-

colorizing sugar. It is also established by the evidence

that after the bones from which it was made were taken

from the retorts they were manufactured by machinery

into a certain size for a certain purpose.

Mr. Drummond says it is animal charcoal (record,

p. 13). Has never heard of black of bone (id. p. 14).

Mr. Salmon says it is burnt bone, calcined bone, what

is called animal charcoal, or bone-black. Never heard it

called black of bone (record, p. 16).

Mr. Simonds says the article is called “ animal char-

coal,” “ bone-black,” “burnt bone” and “char.” Has heard

it called “animal carbon” and very often “ bone coal”

(record, p. 18).

Mr. Chambers testifies for the defendant that he is

familiar with the article. It is generally called in com-

merce “bone-black” or “animal charcoal,” commonly

called “black.” Has heard “ black of bone” applied to it,

which isa literal translation from the French. The article

is never known in commerce as “burnt bone,” “calcined ©

bone,” or “ground bone.”

The trade distinction of the word calcined bone is a

bone burnt in the open air, and also of burnt bone; a

bone cannot be practically burnt or calcined and the air

excluded (rceord, pp. 18, 19).

Mr. Muller testifies for defendant that the name of the

article in the trade is “bone-black” or “black.” It

might be called “ black of bone” to distinguish it from

“ black of ivory ” (record, p. 22).

From the above abstract of testimony it is clear that

P

the name of the article imported by the plaintiffs was in

dispute. The collector was, in the midst of such diver-

sity of opinion as to its name, justifiable in assessing and

collecting duty on said article as “black of bone,” under

section 2504, U.S. Rev. Stat., ed. 1878, p. 473.

This is not regarded as an absolutely material point,

however, in the presentation of this case, for the imported

articles are unmistakably dutiable under section 2504, U.

S. Rev. Stat., ed. 1878, p. 474.

The plaintiffs received the benefit of the payment of a

less ad valorem per centum by the action of the collector

than is actually provided for by law under section 2504

Revised Statutes, 1878, and should not be permitted to

complain of the same.

The merchandise imported by plaintiffs did not comsist

of crude bones ; nor of bones burned ground, calcined, or

steamed only. It had been by manfacture carried beyond

any of these designations, was used for a different specific

purpose, had by reason thereof greater value, and cannot

by the facts be found snch an article as is designated by

any of these names.

Whatever may have been the name of the article im-

ported (and it appears from the evidence that it may have

been called by any of a half dozen), it is established be-

yond question that it was a manufacture of bones.

The witnesses all agree that after it is taken from the

retorts it is manufactured into a certain size and shape, by

machinery, and made an article of traffic, and sold for the

special purpose of decolorizing sugars (record, pp. 15,

17, 22

«

4

6

The statute in fixing duties on articles provides:

Sec. 2504. Schedule M * * * “ manufact-

ures of bones, horn, ivory, or vegetable ivory, thirty-

five per centum ad valorem.”

* * * Black or bone, or ivory, drop black,

twenty-five per centum ad valorem. (U.S. Rev.

Stat., ed. 1878, pp. 473, 474.)

Then follow the exemptions :

‘Sec. 2505. The importation of the following arti-

cles shall be exempt from duty: * * * Bones,

crude and not manufactured; burned, calcined,

ground, or steamed.” Bone dust and bone ash for

manufacture of phosphates and fertilizers.” (U.S.

Rev. Stat., ed. 1878, p. 483.)

The plaintiffs’ imported merchandise must come within

one of these exemptions to be free of duty. They claim

it was calcined bone. (Plaintiffs’ brief, item 2, p. 11.)

It is plain from the evidénce that the importation was

not within either of the exemptions. It is another arti-

cle manufactured from bone, requiring more steps in its

process of manufacture, and having a distinct designation

and use. If Congress had intended to exempt it from

duty it would have included it with such exemptions by

its name, signifying its use, as is done in the instances of

bone ash and bone dust. It is clearly not ‘calcined bone

according to the definitions in plaintiffs’ brief at page 8.

Its manufacture did not stop at reducing it to a friable

state by the action of heat, but other process of manufact-

ure was resorted to in order to make it marketable mer-

chandise for the distinct purpose for which it was to be

used. Machinery was used for this purpose and not heat.

For a thorough and exhaustive review, including a final

7

decision, of a question identical with the one under con-

sideration, reference is had to the case of Schriefer vs.

Wood, 5 Blatchford’s Circuit Court Reports, p. 215.

The article imported was not the result of chemical ac-

tion solely, therefore was not a process. It was manu-

factured by machinery.

For definition of “manufacture,” and other points

bearing strongly in favor of defendant in this case vide

Schreifer vs. Wood, 5 Blatch. C. C. Rep., p. 215.

The plaintiffs refer with confidence to the case of Meyer

vs. Arthur, 91 U.S. Rep., 520, and say that if Schreifer vs.

Wood ( supra) was ever authority it has been overruled

by that decision. In this we do no agree with plain-

tiffs. Schreifer vs. Wood (supra) was cited by plaintiff

in error in that case. The plaintiffs in that case contended

that white lead, nitrate of lead, oxide of zinc, and dry and

orange mineral were manufactures of metals. The court

says: “ When the act speaks of ‘manufactures of metals’

it obviously refers to manufactured articles in which met-

als form a component part.” The court held that these

articles had become chemical ingredients of a new form,

in which metal was not a component part.

These articles also appear to have been dutiable under

other sections of the tariff’ act. '

It is not claimed by plaintiffs that the article imported

in this case has lost its component parts of bone, and be-

come a new article, but, on the contrary, they contend that

it is calcined bone, and for that reason exempt from duty,

under the subdivision of section 2505 Revised Statutes

1878, page 483, which places the bones therein specified

on the free list.

8

The scientific references of counsel for plaintiffs estab-

lish without doubt that component parts of the bone were

left after calcination.

There remains a black mass, consisting of an inti-

mate mixture of charcoal, containing nitrogen, with

the mineral matter of the bone. (Watts’s Chem. Dic.,

p- 624; Plaintiffs’ brief, p. 6.)

The residue in the vessels amounts to about 50 per

cent. in weight of the original bones. (Johnson’s

Ency., vol. 1, p. 551; Plaintiffs’ brief, p. 7.)

The evidence shows clearly that component parts of

bone remained after calcination.

Enough has been presented to sufficiently show that the

case of Meyer vs. Arthur (supra) is not applicable here.

Sections 2504 and 2505 of the Revised Statutes (supra)

ought to be construed together. By doing so the exemp-

tions are easily determined. There is no doubtful mean-

ing or ambiguity in the statute. It is plainly stated that

“ manufactures of bones” and “ black of bone ” are duti-

able, with certain specific exemptions. Plaintiffs claim

that the imported merchandise is calcined bone, and there-

fore free from duty, but the evidence shows it to be a dif-

ferent article, requiring additional steps in its manufacture

to any of the statutory exemptions. It is a manufacture

of bones, and chargeable with customs duties, no matter

in what name it may have been assessed.

IIT.

That the court erred in directing the jury to find a

verdict for the defendant upon the evidence at the con-

clusion of the testimony (vide exception, record, p. 25).

9

The ruling of the court, to which exception was re-

served, and upon which the above assignment of error

is made, reads as follows:

The question in this case is whether bone-black

is included in the clause “ bones crude and not man-

ufactured, burned, calcined, ground, or steamed,” in

the free list of section 2504 of the Revised Statutes.

The evidence shows that it is made by subjecting

bones after being steamed and cleaned to destructive

distillation by heat in close vessels until all is ex-

pelled but the carbon, and then crushing that and

assorting the pieces into proper sizes for clarifying

sugar.

Bones are understood to be calcined when they are

subjected to heat in open vessels so as to produce bone-

ash by being made friable, and to be burned when

subjected to the direct action of fire. This distilla-

tion appears to be different fiom either, and the crush-

_ ing and assorting is an important part of the process.

By the whole a new article is made from bones.

They are not treated thus for the purpose of secur-

ing them or making them portable, as grass is made

into hay without becoming manufactured, as was

held in Franzee vs. Moffit, 20 Blatchf., 267, or as

apples are cut and dried, as in that case mentioned.

The bones are manufactured into bone-black by pro-

cesses of several steps. (Schreifer vs. Wood, 5 Blatchf.,

C. C. Reports, 215.) These steps amount to more

than either of those allowed by the statute without

making the result dutiable. For these reasons the

jury are directed to find a verdict for the defendant.

There was no evidence to sustain the plaintiffs’ cause of

action in this case, and consequently nothing for the jury

to weigh and consider.

10

Under such circumstances it was within the province of

the court to direct a verdict for the defendant.

It is enough that a verdict for the plaintiff would

be against the clear weight and effect of the defensive

evidence, whatever may be its character.

But the practice * * * of directing a verdict

in proper cases, when the evidence is all in, in favor

of the party who may be entitled to it, seems never

to have been questioned. (Cutler vs. Hurlbut eé al.,

29 Wis. Rep., p. 165, and citations; Lamar vs. U.

S., decided at this term by this court, and cases cited

by defendant in argument.) :

And it will be presumed that such direction was rightly

given, and all instructions asked for plaintiffs rightly re-

fused until the contrary positively appears.

The bill of exceptions must show that there was error.

(Cuilér vs. Hurlbut (supra) p. 153.)

There could have been no doubt about the facts in this

case and the court did not commit error in directing a ver-

dict for the defendant. Upon this point see the following

references: (Dodge vs. Gaylord e al.,and the numerous

authorities therein referred to, 53 Ind., pp. 377, 8, 9;

Cutler vs. Hurlbut, 29 Wis. Rep., p. 153; Nicholas & Lee

vs. Goldsmith, 7 Wend., p. 160.)

A recent decision rendered by Wheeler, J., of the

United States circuit court, southern district of New

York, of date July 5, 1884, in the case of Peters vs.

Robertson, collector (not reported), is directly in point in

the case now under consideration, and it is printed here-

with as part of this brief.

: A. H. GARLAND,

Attorney-General.

$---- TTS i ne we a ~

11

UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT, SOUTHERN DISTRICT

OF NEW YORK.

U8.

WILLIAM R. PETERS

8053.

WILLIAM H. RoBeErrson.

WHEELER, J.:

The importation in question was made in September,

1881. The article is well known as bone-black. By sec-

tion 2504, Revised Statutes, “ black of bone,” or“ ivory

drop black” is made subject toa duty of 25 per cent. The

duty was assessed at this rate. The plaintiff made protest

that this article was free under the provisions of section

2505, exempting “bones crude and not manufactured,

burned, calcined, ground, or steamed.” “ Animal carbon”

(bone-black) was made free by the act of March 2, 1861,

12 Statutes at Large, 178, section 23. A duty of 25 per

cent. was laid upon “bone or ivory drop black” by the act

of June 30, 1864, 13 Statutes at Large, 202, section 10, an

“act to increase duties.” Animal carbon and bone-black

by name disappeared from the free list. Ivory drop black

is a pigment, and derives its name of drop from the mode

of manufacture.

Bone-black is not shown, or known, to be anything

like a pigment.

There is no such thing as bone drop black, as there is

ivory drop black ; nor is ivory drop black ever known as

bone-black. The expression in the act of 1864 of bone

or ivory drop black could hardly mean bone, or, in other

words, ivory drop black. The more natural meaning

12

under the circumstances would seem to be that either bone-

black or ivory drop black should be subject to a duty of

25 per cent. Still more wonld the expression of black of

bone or ivory drop black, in the Revised Statutes, seem to

have that meaning.

Black of bone could, as far as shown, be nothing but

bone-black. The expression is the equivalent of bone-

black or ivory drop black, 25 per centum. In this view

the assessment was correct.

The protest raised the question whether this article

came under the description of bones crude and not man-

ufactured, burned, ground, calcined, or steamed. It was

shown not to be bones ground or steamed. The question

whether the description of bones crude and not manufact-

ured or burned or calcined would cover it was submitted

to the jury and found for the defendant. That was the

question to be tried. (Davis vs. Arthur, 96 U.5., 148.)

The verdict should stand unless it is without evidence

to support it, or is against the substantial weight and ef-

fect. of the evidence... In Schreifer vs. Wood, 5 Blatchf.,

115, it is held that bone-black is a manufacture of bones.

That decision is decisive of this question unless bone

black is specifically burned or calcined bone. Bones are

exposed to heat in close vessels and charred to make bone-

black. The process is a distillation and not a combus-

tion. The bones are heated but not burned. The prod-

uct is ground and assorted for use.

Bones are calcined by being burned or heated accessible

to air. There was some conflict on the evidence as to

how these terms were understood in. commerce. The

whole was submitted to the jury to find whether this ar-

ioe ee

13

ticle was included in the terms burned or calcined bone.

The finding was well founded upon evidence, the effect of

which was for the jury.

Under the circumstances the verdict cannot be set aside

without an arbitrary exercise of the power of the court.

The motion must therefore be denied.

o)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.