Record and brief — The Wilson Packing Company, Arthur a Libby, Archibald Mcneill and Charles P. Libby, Appellants, vs. The Chicago Packing and Provision Co., Appellees

Supreme Court brief1882

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

i cess

q- by oe De

>_>

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1882. —

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY —ARTHUR A.

LIBBY, ARCHIBALD McNEIL anp CHARLES P.

LIBBY, Appellants,

| Us.

THE CHICAGO PACKING AND PROVISION CO.,

Appellees.

Appeal from Circuit Court for Northern District of Illinois.

SAME,

US.

ROBERT D. HUNTER er atn.,

Appeal from Circuit Court for Southern District of Illinois.

SAME,

Us.

ROBERT D. HUNTER er at..

slppeal from Circuit Court for Southern District of Illinois.

STATEMENT, POINTS AND ARGUMENT FOR

APPELLEES.

NOBLE & ORRICK,

Solicitors for Defendants.

Supreme Court of the United Stale,

OCTOBER TERM, 1882.

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY —ARTHUR A.

LIBBY, ARCHIBALD McNEIL ann CHARLES P.

LIBBY, Appellants,

VS.

THE CHICAGO PACKING AND PROVISION CO.,

Appellees.

Appeal from Circuit Court for Northern District of Illinois.

‘Pp

SAME,

Us.

ROBERT D. HUNTER er At.,

Appeal from Circuit Court for Southern District of Illinois.

SAME,

US.

ROBERT D. HUNTER er at.,

Appeal from Circuit Court for Southern District of Illinois.

STATEMENT, POINTS AND ARGUMENT OF

NOBLE & ORRICK FOR APPELLEES.

We shall treat the three cases as one; the issues, indeed,

being the same; only the first case against Hunter, and that

against the Chicago company involve the process of preserv-

2

ing, and the product of, boiled beef, compressed ; and the sec-

ond case against Hunter involves the novelty of the can

chiefly.

Our statement is more particularly in regard to the cases

against Hunter and others, wherein we are solicitors.

— The original bill was filed June 16, 1877, and the amended

bill October 27, 1877. |

There was a plea to the jurisdiction by the St. Louis Beef

Canning Company, filed November 5th, 1877, based on the

proposition that the defendant was not subject to process

within the Southern District of Illinois ; but this plea was held

bad for insufficiency. The point is in the record, but will not

be here discussed. .

So much of the answer as sets up a misjoinder of the par-

ties complainant was subsequently waived by stipulation, and

is not now, of course, insisted on.

The answer of Hunter & Merrill was filed February 2,

1878. Newman was never served, nor has he appeared. The

answer of the St. Louis Beef Canning Company was filed

March 5, 1878, and the general replication March 13, 1878.

There was a supplemental answer filed May 5, 1879, and an

amendment, by stipulation. (See vol. i, pp. 50,01).

sy the bill the complainants assert the re-issued patent

dated April 6, 1875, to the Wilson Packing Company,

assignee of Wm. J. Wilson, whose original patent was dated

March 31, 1874; and also the re-issued patent dated May 25,

1875, to Arthur A. Libby, assignee of Wm. C. Marshall,

whose original patent was dated July 12, 1864; that com-

plainants were interested therein sufficiently to maintain the

suit, and that defendants have infringed same. The St. Louis

Beef Canning Company’s answer denied the interest of the

complainants as averred, and asserted there was a misjoinder.

It also averred the re-issue to the Wilson Packing Co. was not

for same invention as original letters to Wilson, and were

therefore void. The same averment is made as to the re-issue

to Libby on the Marshall patent. The answer, at same time,

denies the original letters of either Wilson or Marshall were

for any real invention. It then avers the supposed improve-

ments were well known ‘to the people at large and practiced

ae

3

before said letters were granted. The answer also positively

denies any infringement by defendants.

It is then affirmatively averred by the answer that neither

Wilson or Marshall was the original or first inventor as

claimed as to the respective patents, and that said supposed

process or patented improvement was, long before said patents,

well known and in common use in the Unitsd States, Canada,

Great Britain, France, Germany, Australia, and elsewhere ;

and the state of the art was such throughout the United

States and Europe, that said pretended improvements were of

common knowledge and in daily use among manufacturers,

packers, and in the housholds of the people; that said pre-

tended improvements and processes had been described in

public works, in specifications of patents, and were the same

for which certain patents had been granted in England and

the United States.

(Lists of all which printed publications, specifications and

patents are given In the answer. )

That the process and pretended improvements were prior

to either Wilson or Marshall’s letters, known to persons

(named), who practiced the same at places (named ), as can

be proven by witnesses (named), and to persons unknown,

who may be brought in and named in supplemental answer.

The supplemental answer extends the lists of publications

and persons to whom said processes were known and by whom

practiced ; and avers that said supposed improvements were

in use and on sale in this country for more than two years

anterior to application for said original patents by patentees,

and with their consent.

The stipulated amendment to the answer further sets forth

that the specified Wilson process was useless and inoperative,

and if practiced would result in rapid putrefaction, and there-

fore was void: and that the Marshall description of process,

on re-issue, was .unintelligible to one schooled in the art, and

therefore void.

4

This portion of the answer has never been waived, and is

here insisted on.

The replication is general.

Taking these patents in their order, and comparing the

original with the re-issued patents, we find the original Wilson

patent was for a process (defendants’ book, p. 134) by which

the meat was first cooked at 212°, so that bone and gristle

can be removed and the meat yet retain its natural grain and

integrity. A measured quantity of this cooked meat, yet

warm, is pressed by apparatus into a prepared box or case,

with sufficient force to remove the air and superfluous

moisture and make the meat form a solid cake. The box or

case is then closed air-tight upon the meat.

The claim is, first, the process; second, a new article of

merchandise, cooked meat, put up in solid form in its natural

state, without disintegration or desiccation, in hermetically-

sealed packages, as set forth.

The re-issued patent (defendants’ book, p. 136) describes

the nature of the invention the same as the original, except

the words in the original ‘‘ while heated with cooking ’’ are

omitted from the re-issue. And the process is described the

same, except where the original says ‘* while yet warm with

cooking,’’ the meat is to be pressed, etc. The re-issue says,

‘¢ preferably, while yet warm with cooking.”’

In the first portion of the claim of re-issue, the words

‘¢ while heated with cooking ’’ are omitted ; inall other words

it is the same as the original. The second portion of the

claim in the re-issue is identical with the original.

&

The original and re-issue of Wilson’s patent therefore are

the same, except the re-issue permits the meat to be packed

cold, if preferred, while the original required that it should

be packed warm with cooking.

There is nothing in either patent as to boiling; nor as to the

meat being corned, or other than plain meat.

4)

But on October 13, 1880 (p. 920), the patentees executed

i. disclaimer and filed the same with Commissioner of Patents

October 26, 1880, disclaiming the word ‘* preferably,’’ and

ilso any process described to be for meat compressed into the

packages in any other condition than a warm or heated condi-

tion. (See p. 916, complainants’ testimony. )

On October 14, the same _ patentees executed another

disclaimer, filed October 26, disclaiming any interpretation or

legal construction to the words ‘* the meat is first cooked

thoroughly at a temperature of 212° Fahr.,’’ etc., broader

than is conveyed by the words ‘* the meat is first cooked thor-

oughly by boiling it in water so that the meat yet retains its

natural grain and integrity.’’ The claim is thus adjusted by

the disclaimer to this construction of boding as a limitation

upon the process of cooking.

The effect of the two disclaimers throws the patentees

back to a process of packing meat cooked by bodling, while

yet warm with cooking, into air-tight packages ; and a new

article of merchandise, meat cooked by boiling, put up while

heated with cooking, in solid form, in its natural state, with-

out disintegration or desiccation, in hermetically-sealed pack-

ages, as set forth.

The disclaimers themselves seek evidently to enlarge the

second part of the claim of the patent, but of course dis-

claimers cannot be perverted into claims.

These disclaimers were put in after the defendant’s testi-

mony-in-chief had been taken, and, we may presume, were

forced by the weight of the testimony adduced against the

patent as filed with and set forth in the bill.

In a word, the process of the re-issue is abandoned; the

only expansion made in it being now disclaimed, and the

process of the original patent is modified from cooked meat

to meat cooked by boiling.

The disclaimers say, in the om of the statute, that

the expansion in the re-issue was through inadvertence, acci-

dent or mistake. This is a self-contradicted statement, for

the whole re-issue was based on the matters afterwards dis-

cmaanes by the first disclaimer, which matters the court

6

bound to presume were first claimed and insisted on as a right,

and not through inadvertence, accident or mistake.

We pass this for the present, to continue our comparison

next between the original and re-issue of the Marshall patent.

The Marshall patent was abandoned at the hearing below ;

but a statement of its nature as compared with that of Wil-

son’s is material to show the history and development of the

Wilson pretension.

The original, vol. i, p. 128, states the nature of the Mar-

shall improvement to be exposing the meat to heavy pressure

by means of a press-box, expelling nearly all the water not

chemically combined with the meat, and a large quantity of

the air between the pieces and in the pores, before the meat

is put up in the packages; introducing the meat from the

press-box into the package to be filled, without exposing the

package to any undue strain. The meat is prepared by first

rendering the water of the meat temporarily proof against

putrefaction by any of the ordinary processes, and said water

being the only destroying agent, a large percentage is removed

and the remainder fixed by concentrated antiseptics ; a given

quantity of meat is then subjected to pressure in a box or cyl-

inder until all air is driven out and the space occupied by the

meat agrees with the size of a package it is intended to fill.

When the meat is in its place the box is hermetically sealed;

and in this state, retaining all its nutritive qualities, the meat

will remain perfect as long as the package remains intact.

The claim is:

Ist. Exposing meat, previous to putting in package, to a

heavy pressure.

2d. The press-box.

3d. A frame, ete.

The re-issue describes the nature of the improvement in

substance the same as the original (see p. 132, vol. ii), and

by the specification of the process, is modified, first, by de-

claring water the chief agent in destruction ; then by stating

a given quantity of meat is subject to pressure in a suitable

mold, ‘*and subsequently into the packages or boxes intended

to contain the same.’’ It then adds the words, ‘the air re-

7

maining in the same being expelled by the usual process in

canning,’’ to the words ‘* when the meat is in its place the

box is hermetically sealed ;’’ so that besides being hermetically

sealed, as in the original, the description of the re-issue re-

quires ‘‘the air’remaining in the same be expelled by the

usual process in canning.’’

The claim of the re-issue is, first, the process; second, a

new article of manufacture ; the above-described compressed

meat preserved in solid form, without disintegration or desic-

cation, in hermetically-sealed packages, substantially | as

herein set forth.

This re-issue is dated nearly eleven years after the original.

There is no cooking of the meat mentioned in the original,

and none in the re-issue, unless it is to be inferred from the

words, ‘* usual process in canning.’’ There is in neither orig- |

nal or re-issue any suggestion of cooking before placing in

the can.

The re-issue contains two new elements; in the process,

one pressure in the can as well as the mold, until the air is

driven out, and the other expelling the remaining air by usua]

process in canning. Thus the claim of the re-issue is ex-

panded ; the original stopped with the heavy pressure previ-

ous to putting the meat up in packages. (Vol. il, p. 131).

In a word, the pressure previous to packing is not insisted

on, and the usual process in canning Is expressly included in

the re-issue.

It suggests itself at once, and we mention it in passing,

that either the re-issue is void for being for a different inven-

tion from that contained in the original patent, or is impracti-

‘able because the canning process will destroy the compressed

solid form of meat, raw when packed, or the product being

still compressed and solid after canning, and necessarily

cooked while canning, is the actual product of’ the Wilson

patent, and antedates it.

But we proceed to the last of the patents asserted, that of

John A. Wilson. Improvement in sheet-metal cans for con-

taining cooked meats. Original dated April 6th, 1875. Re-

issue, October 23,1877. The original describes the can pyra-

midal shaped, rounded corners, and both ends slightly flaring

8

to form shoulders, against which the heads or end-pieces rest.

The description makes the shoulders interior. The edges of

the heads turned outwards ; the flaring edge of the end of the

can is turned inward over the flange, and the three thicknesses

of metal pressed together by machinery, with or without

solder, so as to make the points air-tight. The meat is to be

packed through aperture in large head, afterwards to be her-

metically sealed by means of cap, having 2 vent; and to pre-

vent the meat from closing the vent, it is protected by a

trough or gutter, attached to the underside of the piece, open

on both ends, or in its place a perforated diaphram. The

claim is first for the pyramidal form, rounded corners, and

off-set ends to support heads, and heads recurved as shown ;

second, perforated cap in combination with head provided

with protector.

The re-issue is substantially the same in stating the nature

of the improvement and the process, but the re issue extends

the claim, in addition to those features set forth in the original,

to a third, as follows:

Third. An improved article of manufacture, solid meat

compressed and secured within a pyramidal case or can, so

that said can forms a mold for the meat and permits its dis-

charge as a solid cake, substantially as specified.

At pp. 939 and 940, vol. ii, defendants’ testimony, the

court will find @ formal admission by complainants, that con-

ical tin cans were made and used for canning alimentary sub-

stances and sealed air-tight prior to the date of the Wilson

patents that are the subjects of controversy in the above-

entitled causes. |

We have left, then, only the pyramidal form as distin-

cvuished from the conical—but this with rounded edges ; the

flanges and three thicknésses, pressed and soldered together,

to make the can air-tight; the protector to vent; and the

solid meat compressed and secured within a pyramidal case.

It is not deemed worth while to say more as to this third

feature of the claim of the re-issue, than that the patent is for

an improvement in metallic tin cans; and solid meat com-

pressed and secured in the can is neither within the nature of

the invention stated, nor within the pertinent description of

the process of constructing the can, nor within the grant of

the patent. It is neither a process nor the product of a pro-

cess specified. And if it were, still it is the very thing

claimed by Marshall’s re-issue, and virtually by W. J. Wil-

son’s, inasmuch the meat in the cans may be cooked before

canning.

We have further to suggest that if the pyramidal can is

essential to the discharge, in solid form, of its contents as de-

scribed, the previous claims of both Marshall and W. J. Wil-

son were useless from want of this essential feature; and if

not essential, it is clearly not valuable. Besides the same

features of can are admitted to have existed before, that is

cans larger at one end than the other, and air-tight.

The issues having been made, by the proceedings, as above

shown, both sides proceeded to take testimony; and there

has been accumulated evidence enough to fill two great books

of at least eleven hundred pages each, which affects in the

main only the question of novelty. The history of meat-can-

ning in the United States from the earliest period to the

present time is given by witnesses who have been engaged in

the business from Portland, Maine, to Houston, Texas, and

from New York to San Francisco. We have in our argument

cited largely from the depositions, in illustration of our dif-

ferent points, and shall rather depend upon such development

of the case as will be thus made, than attempt to state the

case on the whole testimony, considered here, consecutively.

What is claimed by the defendants is as follows :

WILLIAM J. WILSON’S PATENT.

I. The disclaimers have been unreasonably delayed, and the

delay cuts off the complainants from the benefit of section

4917-U. S. R. Stats., and defeats his action, because

the re-issue without a valid disclaimer is unauthorized

and void.

Brooks vs. Jenkins, 3 MeLean R. 432.

Hall vs. Wiles, 2 Blatchford R. 194.

Winans vs. N. Y. & E. R. R. Co., 1 Fisher, 213.

Same case, 21 Howard R. 88.

Parker vs. Stiles, 5 MeLean R. 56.

Il. The disclaimer is obviously and essentially false, on

comparison with original and re-issue; inasmuch as

what it disclaims must have been inserted not through

tnadvertence, but most advisedly, for what it disclaims

was inserted in the re-issue to obtain tt, and without

such insertion the re-issue would not have been possible.

Secs. 4816, 4817, Rh. S. USN.

Seymour vs. Osborne, 11 Wallace R. 516.

Without a valid disclaimer the re-issue ts void, because

executed for other than the same invention as original.

Seymour vs. Osborne, supra.

Powder Company vs. Powder Works, 98 U. S. R. 126.

IV. There ts no patentable improvement in Wilson’s process.

a. This is admitted, virtually, by disclaimer.

6. The want of improvement is shown by the testimony.

c. The difference been roast and boiled meat affords no

room for patentable improvement, as there.is no improvement

in fact ; and if there were, none within meaning of the patent

law. |

d. Corning beef is no part of the process named in patent,

and its effect on the popularity of the product cannot be

claimed by complainants in favor of alleged improvements ;

yet it is the corning that is the chief attraction in the market,

and corned beef is the only kind made by defendants.

»

V. The Wilson patent does not include ‘* processing,’’? and

defendants ‘* process”’ all their products.

a. The process ends at closing the box air-tight.

‘¢ Air-tight’’ or ‘* hermetically sealed ’’ does not involve

the thought of ** processing,’’ either by definition or scientific

use.

Processing cannot be practiced on a wooden box.

b. By merely closing the package air-tight the meat will

not be preserved thereby, and no useful result is obtained.

c. The defendants preserve all their meats by the usual

processing method—heating, venting, ete.

VI. But taking (for the sake of argument) the Wilson patent

to extend to all that is claimed for tt, tt is void for want

of novelty.

The Appert patent destroys the novelty of Wilson’s claim

to any useful result.

a. It is the Appert process.

Sewell vs. Jones, 91 U. S. Rep. 81.

Brown vs. Piper, 91 U.S. Rep. 37.

Smith vs. Nichols, 21 Wallace R. 118.

Roberts vs. Ryer, 91 U. 8. Rep. 159.

Wilson could not enjoin Appert from using his ( Appert’s)

process, even on boiled meat packed warm and _ solid in

package.

6. The testimony shows exact process claimed by Wilson

on same material (boiled meat) was used as early as 1851

by many other persons.

W. C. MARSHALL PATENT.

I. The re-issue appears to be for a process essentially not the

same as the original, and ts void.

The re-issue contains what the original does not—

a. Packing znéto the can.

5. The Appert process.

II. That actually embodied in the patent is not a process, but

result of mechanical action; the pressure claimed is the

result of machinery, and ts not patentable.

Corning vs. Borden, 15 Howard R. 267.

12

Il. There ts no improvement tn the alleged process.

The process cooks the meat in the can, produces gravy or

gelatine, and is the same in result as meat put.up in 1845.

IV. There ts no novelty tn Marshall’s process, granting it all

claimed for it.

a. It works out the oldest known results in canning by

the very oldest process.

6. It amounts to nothing more than the Appert process.

c. It is void on its face, as claiming a process and pro-

duct in common domestic use when patent issued.

JOHN A. WILSON’S SHEET-METAL,CAN.

I. This is for an tmprovement in metal cans, and cannot

support a claim for solid meat.

a. An aggregation of parts is not a patentable combina-

eet an) co)

tion.

Curtis on Patents, 4th ed., sec. 111 ¢.

6. If 3rd claim is for form, it is same as the first part of

the claim, which is for the can itself.

c. As packed meat, even Wm. J. Wilson describes it, and

all the meats proven to have been canned in any way precede

and anticipate it.

II. There is no patentable improvement in the can as described.

a. The stipulation that conical cans air-tight were in prior

use, surrenders the whole principle of the supposed improve-

ment.

Winans vs. Denmead, 15 Howard R. 330.

6. All the principles of the can have been anticipated by

Redmond, Peltier and other patentees.

c. The form is in common domestic use,

aS ots oN RN As EET IR label ote

PF SSE WAS ce Be

13

NO INFRINGEMENT.

The testimony is positive that the defendants have not

infringed either of the patents, if valid.

We are now prepared to discuss these patents more at

large, and we beg fo consider first

W. J. WILSON’S PATENT.

I. The disclaimers have been unreasonably delayed.

As we have noted above, in passing, the re-issue on this

patent has by the first disclaimer been reduced back directly

and solely to the language of the original patent, and the lan-

guage of the original patent has been limited by the second

disclaimer to meat cooked by botling. These disclaimers,

‘made October 13th and 14th, 1880, and filed October 26th,

1880, were, in fact, subsequent to the time defendants had

put in their testimony-in-chief.

The statute (sec. 4917, R. S. U.S., last clause), reads,

‘¢But no disclaimer shall affect any action pending at the

time of its being filed, except so far as may relate to the ques-

tion of unreasonable neglect or delay in filing it.’’

We have shown, in our analysis of the pleading, that this

fault of the re-issue was averred and insisted on in defend-

ants’ answer; and, although its necessity was apparent,

the disclaimer was delayed until the proofs showing nu-

merous instances of compressed meat packed in cans,

cooked, were adduced and required to be adduced to de-

feat this re-issue. The complainants awaited the event, and

finally and by compulsion filed their disclaimer. This is. con-

fessed, virtually, by the act of disclaimer alone; but it is

stated in words and circumstantially by E. S. Renwick—

complainants’ testimony, pp. 1170 (347 cross inter.) to 1174

(end of ans. to 356 cross inter.). We quote. On page 1174

the witness says: ‘* There is no doubt that one of the rea-

sons, although not the only one, which influenced my opinion

as to the expediency of one of the disclaimers, was a piece of

evidence which has been put in by the defendants in this case,

viz.: the Lyman patent.”’

iN

An unreasonable neglect or delay to enter a disclaimer

cuts off the patentee from all the benefits of the section. He

not only cannot recover costs, but he can have no right of

action.

Brooks vs. Jenkins, 5 MeLean R. 482.

Hall vs. Wiles, 2 Blatehford R. 194.

Winans vs. N. Y. & E. R. R. Co., 1 Fisher, 213.

Same case, 21 Howard R. 88.

And if the objection exists the plaintiff cannot recover,

even if it is found the defendant has infringed the parts of the

plaintiff's invention that are original.

Parker vs. Stiles, 5 MeLean R. 56.

Il. The disclaimer is obviously und essentially false on com-

parison with original and re-issue.

The disclaimer is not only unreasonably delayed, but it is

on comparison with the original and re-issue, based on an ab-

solute misstatement of fact essential to its operation. The

misstatement appears on the face of the papers.

When the patentee claims more than that of which he was

the original or first inventor, his patent shall yet be valid,

provided such claim has been made through inadvertence, ac-

cident or mistake, and without any fraudulent or deceptive

purpose (sec. 4917, R. 5. U.S.), and a disclaimer may be

filed for such part as is chosen not to be claimed or held.

If there has been no inadvertence, accident or mistake, or

there has been a fraudulent or deceptive purpose, the patent

is void and a disclaimer will not avail. Thus the attempt to

gain purposely too much is punished by loss of the whole.

The disclaimer is a voluntary act, and upon filing, it be-

comes effective without any official or legal action by the com-

missioner. ‘There is nothing, therefore, about a disclaimer

making its assertion of inadvertence, etc., conclusive.

But upon a re-issue, it .zs conclusively presumed by the

court that it was authorized because of error in the original

15

patent arising from inadvertence, accident or mistake, and

without any fraudulent or deceptive intention ; because the

decision of this matter of fact is confided to the commis-

sioner, and is to be exercised judicially by him.

Seymour vs. Osborne, 11 Wallace R. 516.

The re-issue is, however, authorized only (sec. 4916 R.S.

U.S.) when the original is inoperative or void by reason of

a defective or insufficient specification, or by reason of the

patentee claiming as his own invention or discovery, more

than he had a right to claim as new, and when the error has

arisen by inadvertence, etc.,. as we have just above mentioned.

It must follow, therefore, ‘* ew-necessitate,’’ that those

matters in the re-issue curing the supposed defect of the origi

nal, were asserted therein (in the re-issue) not inadvertently,

but ex-7ndusiria, purposely, and under application made and

supported according to the regulations of the patent office, to

secure a right claimed under the law.

Now, in the re-issue of the W. J. Wilson patent, the only

changes made were such, as we have shown above, as extended

the process to packing cooked meat, whether warm with cook-

ing or not; these last words in the original being omitted in

the re-issue, and this was the whole extent of the change.

This change, therefore, was not inadvertent, but, being the only

one, was the one essential to distinguish the re-issue from the

original and to authorize the re-issue. It was, therefore, in-

sisted on and so purposely obtained. The decision of ithe

commissioner in granting the re-issue is conclusive in this court,

that the crnadvertence was not in inserting the word ‘+ prefer-

ably ’’ in the re-issue, but in leaving tt out of the original, and

so vice versa us to the words ** while yet warm with the cook-

° A

ne.

The disclaimer under the re-issue asserts just the contrary,

and says this inadvertence was in the inserting. them in the

re-issue, and that the original was entirely correct as to this

matter.

14

An unreasonable neglect or delay to enter a disclaimer

cuts off the patentee from all the benefits of the section. He

not only cannot recover costs, but he can have no right of

action.

Brooks vs. Jenkins, 3 McLean R. 482.

Hall vs. Wiles, 2 Blatchford R. 194.

Winans vs. N. Y. & E. R. R. Co., 1 Fisher, 213.

Same case, 21 Howard R. 88. | |

And if the objection exists the plaintiff cannot recover,

even if it is found the defendant has infringed the parts of the

plaintifPs invention that are original.

Parker vs. Stiles, 5 McLean R. 56.

Il. The disclaimer ts obviously und essentially false on com-

parison with original and re-issue.

The disclaimer is not only unreasonably delayed, but it is

on comparison with the original and re-issue, based on an ab-

solute misstatement of fact essential to its operation. The

misstatement appears on the face of the papers.

When the patentee claims more than that of which he was

the original or first inventor, his patent shall yet be valid,

provided such claim has been made through inadvertence, ac-

cident or mistake, and without any fraudulent or deceptive

purpose (sec. 4917, R. S.U.S.), and a disclaimer may be

filed for such part as is chosen not to be claimed or held.

If there has been no inadvertence, accident or mistake, or

there has been a fraudulent or deceptive purpose,.the patent

is void and a disclaimer will not avail. Thus the attempt to

ain purposely too much is punished by loss of the whole.

er

=‘

The disclaimer is a voluntary act, and upon filing, it be-

comes effective without any official or legal action by the com-

missioner. There is nothing, therefore, about a disclaimer

making its assertion of inadvertence, etc., conclusive.

But upon a re-issue, it 7s conclusively presumed by the

court that it was authorized because of error in the original

15

patent arising from inadvertence, accident or mistake, and

without any fraudulent or deceptive intention ; because the

decision of this matter of fact is confided to the commis-

sioner, and is to be exercised judicially by him.

Seymour vs. Osborne, 11 Wallace R. 516.

The re-issue is, however, authorized only (sec. 4916 R.S.

U.S.) when the original is inoperative or void by reason of

a defective or insufficient specification, or by reason of the

patentee claiming as his own invention or discovery, more

than he had a right to claim as new, and when the error has

arisen by inadvertence, etc.. as we have just above mentioned.

It must follow, therefore, ‘‘ ex-necessitate,’? that those

matters in the re-issue curing the supposed defect of the origi

nal, were asserted therein (in the re-issue) not inadvertently,

but ex-7ndusiria, purposely, and under application made and

supported according to the regulations of the patent office, to

secure a right claimed under the law.

Now, in the re-issue of the W. J. Wilson patent, the only

changes made were such, as we have shown above, as extended

the process to packing cooked meat, whether warm with cook-

ing or not; these last words in the original being omitted in

the re-issue, and this was the whole extent of the change.

This change, therefore, was not inadvertent, but, being the only

one, was the one essential to distinguish the re-issue from the

original and to authorize the re-issue. It was, therefore, in+

sisted on and so purposely obtained. ‘The decision of ithe

commissioner in granting the re-issue is conclusive in this court,

that the ¢nadvertence was not in inserting the word ‘¢ prefer-

ably ’’ in the re-issue, but in leaving it out of the original, and

so vice versa as to the words ** while yet warm with the cook-

° 993

ing.

‘The disclaimer under the re-issue asserts just the contrary,

and says this inadvertence was in the inserting them in the

re-issue, and that the original was entirely correct as to this

matter.

iN

16

It necessarily results, we submit, that the disclaimer is

false, and stultifies those executing it, in so far as it pretends

the change in the re-issue from the original was inadvertently

made ; because there could have been no re-issue but for the

change, and the patentee asked the re-issue and must neces-

sarily have obtained it by means and virtue of the change, now

pretended to have been made inadvertently, or by accident or

mistake. |

If, therefore, the re-issue is for a different invention from

that claimed in the original patent, and the disclaimer is inop-

erative to cure it, it is void, and void as to the whole claim ;

because it just clearly appears the excessive claim was not in-

advertent, but of set purpose, and persisted in with a decep-

tive purpose until defeated and overwhelmed by defendants’

testimony.

Ill. Without a valid disclaimer the re-issue is void as exe-

cuted for other than the same invention the original was.

That the disclaimer was really necessary to save the re-issue

(on the complainants’ theory that the alleged improvement is

in any part a novelty), need hardly be argued, as the com-

plainants, by their act of disclaimer, admit it, and Mr. Ren-

wick, advised it as necessary.

See Renwick’s testimony at pages above specified. (Com-

plainants’ testimony, pp. 1170-1174. )

A comparison of the specifications of the original and re-

issue exhibits the illegal expansion of the re-issue. The process

is a process of preserving and packing cooked meats solid, in

air-tight packages, and the original claims this package must be

done while the meat is yet warm with cooking. The re-issue

endeavors to leave this optional with the packer, and claims

the beneficial result can be arrived at without packing the

meat while yet warm, although it is preferable.

Here is a very great expansion of claim, and as the origi-

nal patent was for an improvement in process for packing

cooked meats, which required it to be done while the meat

was yet warm, that improvement was confined to that, and

17

did not suggest that it could be done with cold meat, but ex-

cluded that idea. If packing meat warm was an improvement

on the process, packing it cold, if it could be successfully

done, was just as much an improvement, but not the same,

evidently, as packing it warm, and therefore not to be included

in the re-issue.’ This is plain, we think, and, by the statute

and the authorities, the re-issue was, as to packing cold meat,

beyond the jurisdiction of the commissioner to

issue based on W. J. Wilson’s original patent.

grant a re-

Seymour vs. Osborne, 11 Wallace R. 516.

Powder Company vs. Powder Works, 98 U.S..R. 126.

The re-issue was, therefore, void, and the attempt to cure

it by a false disclaimer failing, it remains void, and will not

support this suit to any extent whatever.

IV. There ts no patentable improvement in Wilson’s process.

a. This is admitted, virtually, by the disclaimer against

any construction of the word cooked in the patent as applica-

ble to any other cooking than by boiling.

To the full extent of the ordinary meaning of the word

cooked, the complainants admit they cannot claim. This

appears in the second disclaimer, dated October 14, 1880, tes-

timony, vol. 1, pp. 920 and 922, where any construction of the

language of the specification to include cooking, by any other

means than by boiling the same in water, zs disclatmed. In

other words, the process, in all essentials, is admitted by W.

J. Wilson and his assigns to have been known and used by

others before him, as to meat cooked otherwise than by boil-

ing; or, to express it in another form, this disclaimer admits

the controlling feature of the improvement, as a discovery of

Wilson’s, rests in the fact, the meat packed is boiled meat,

and no other. That is, it is admitted any one may pack

cooked meats for transportation by compressing the same,

while heated with cooking, into an air-tight, hermetically

sealed package, so as to preserve the meat in its integrity, and

retain all the natural juices and nutritious qualities of the

meat, substantially as set forth in the Wilson patent; and if

2

only the meat is not cooked by boiling *n water, there will be

no infringement of Wilson’s patent. The meat may be

roasted, broiled, baked, stewed or steamed, and if so, there is

no infringement, although all the rest of the Wilson process

is adopted.

6. The want of improvement is shown by the testimony. -

What we have just said is plain from the language of the

disclaimer. But if any doubt were possible, it is removed by

Mr. Renwick, who never fails to reinforce and aid Mr. Wilson

on the retreat, whatever may be thought of the strength of

his support in an attack.

Mr. Renwick says (among much other to the same effect

and in the same connection, and we quote only the most

pointed declarations, pp. 1165-1166):

$339 a-Int. That is, you think, after the grant of the

‘¢ original patent as it is, it would have been a new invention

‘¢to pack a roast leg of mutton by the process described in

‘‘that patent in respect to every step except cooking, which

‘you say means boiling, provided that the same thing had

‘*not been done before.’’

‘¢ Ans. That is, as I understand the question, the leg of

‘¢mutton, after being roasted, is to be treated by the same

‘¢ operations that I understand to be required by the Wilson

‘‘ original patent to be performed upon the meat subsequent

‘¢to its cooking: and I think that under the circumstances

‘¢mentioned in the question, the thing stated would have been

‘a new invention, although the scope of the original Wilson

‘¢ patent is probably broad enough to cover it.

99

This witness also says (p. 1174), as once before quoted by

us, that one reason influencing his opinion as to the expediency

of the disclaimer, wasa piece of evidence which has been put

in by the defendants in this case, viz: the ‘* Lyman patent.”’

The Lyman patent is to be found in defendants’ testimony

(pp. 863-870). On p. 864, the patentee states his invention

19

to be ‘*secondly, an improved mode of preparing and _ pre-

serving roast meat in a condensed and concentrated form.’’

And pp. 866-868, the specification of the Lyman patent

reads : |

‘¢My improved condensed roast meat differs from the

‘Sabove (ordinary mode of preserving meat in cans) in its

‘¢ preparation as follows: Having deprived the meat of a large

‘sper cent. of its water, the juice being concentrated in it,

‘cand the meat at the same time roasted by means of a cur-

‘rent of dry air, which passes from the heater through the

‘¢meat chamber and off into the outer atmosphere, carrying

‘¢the moisture with it. I grind, or otherwise reduce the

‘¢roughest parts to about the consistence of thick mortar, or

‘¢putty, and then pack the best pieces in this reduced meat,

‘sand press it all into a compact mass ir the can, the inter-

‘¢ stices being filled with the reduced meat firmly pressed in,

‘so as to expel the air, instead of filling them with the gravy

‘¢or with water, as by the common modes. Sometimes I

‘¢orind the whole of the meat and pack the can with it, com-

‘spressing in it a solid mass, then heat and seal it up from the

‘cair,and re-heat it to combine any free oxygen that may pos-

‘‘sibly be left in the can.”’

And on page 870, the claim is: ‘6th. As a new manufac-

‘ture, concentrated roast beef, mutton, pork, or other meat,

‘sprepared and preserved substantially as specified.’’

This patent is dated July 22, 1869, while Wilson’s is dated

March 31, 1874. Proof of the exercise of this Lyman pro-

cess, its nature and existence and the sale of the product, oc-

cupies a large part of the mass of the testimony in this case.

In view of the admission of Mr. Renwick and the production

of the Lyman patent, we do not deem it necessary to ask the

court to wade through the hundred pages on this subject.

We think it unnecessary to enter into a discussion of all this.

The patent speaks for itself, and in so far as it is the same in

principle, it destroys the Wilson patent granted five years later

than the Lyman process. As we have said, complainants ad-

mit the Lyman and the Wilson patents the same save as to

difference between roast and boiled meat.

~

c. The difference between roast and boiled meats affords

no room for patentable improvement, as there is no improve-

ment in fact, and if there were, none within meaning of the

patent law.

We submit that such difference is not of a nature,on which

W. J. Wilson was entitled to a patent. The language of the

statute authorizing a patent is as follows :

‘¢Any person who has invented or discovered any new and

useful art, machine, manufacture or composition of matter, or

any new and useful improvement thereof, not known or used

by others in this country, etc., etc., etc., shall obtain a patent

therefor.”’

The grant to W. J. Wilson is for an improvement in pro-

cesses of preserving and packing cooked meats. But the

whole process is now asserted to be new only as to the meat

cooked by boiling. Can it be seriously pretended that one

who had observed the process in question practiced as to roast

meat, would be considered, within the meaning of the statute,

to have invented or discovered any new or useful improvement

by applying the same process to boiled meat. Wherein is the

improvement if one prefers roast meat? It is claimed to be in

the fact that the meat is boiled. But that may or may not be

an improvement, according to the taste or desire of the pur-

chaser. Surely no one will pretend that it is true as to man-

-kind in general, that boiled meat is considered an improvement

on roast. The lovers of the roast beef of: old Englind would

sturdily resist even a. judicial decree to this effect. It is

against common sense to assert a2 monopoly based on such a

difference.

But we have high authority to further establish the posi-

tion that even if it were an improvement to have the meat

boiled, it is not a patentable invention. In Pearce vs. Mul-

ford (102 U. 5. Reports, p. 112), it issaid, ‘*all improvement

is not invention, and entitled to protection as such. Thus to

entitle it, it must be the product of some exercise of the in-

ventive faculties, and it must involve something more than

what is obvious to persons skilled in the art.”’

21

In the case of the Glue Company vs. Upton (98 U.S.

Reps. 3) the following language is used :

‘A distinction must be observed between a new article of

commerce and anew article which, as such, is patentable ;

any change in form from a previous condition may render the

article new in.commerce ; as powdered sugar is a different ar-

ticle in commerce from loaf sugar ; and ground coffee a differ-

ent article in commerce from coffee in the berry. But to

render the article new in the sense of the patent law, it must

‘be more or less efficacious or possess new properties in com-

bination with other ingredients ; not from anew change of

form produced by a mechanical division. It is only where one

of these results follows that the product of the compound can

be treated as the result of invention or discovery, and be re-

garded as a new and useful article.’’

If new at all, the article produced by complainants is new

merely as an article of commerce, and not as a manufacture.

In fact, in the patent it is not claimed as a manufacture, but

merely as merchandise.

So, we think, without multiplying words or references,

we may rest assured this court will not hold the difference be-

tween the old process and the new depending solely upon the

fact of the meat being boiled instead of roasted, is such an

improvement in the art or manufacture as will support the

pretended patent of William J. Wilson.

Uriah H. Dudley, one of complainants’ witnesses, a large

dealer in canned products, illustrates how business men view

this matter. 20th int. (p. 673). ‘* How were these com-

pressed meats regarded here in New York, as far as your

knowledge and observation extended, as being an improve-

ment and a novelty, and how did you regard it? Ans. I re-

garded them as a novelty, but I don’t know whether they

would be called an improvement because not used in the same

way as the others; I suppose the trade regarded it much as I

do; it was brought into more general use in this form than it

had ever been before.’’

nN

22

d. Corning beef is no part of the process named in the

patent, and its effect on the popularity of the product cannot

be claimed by complainants in favor of alleged improvements ;

yet it is the corniny that is the chief attraction in the market,

and corned beef is the only kind made by defendants.

The complainants have endeavored to make a great deal

out of the fact that the canned corned beef of complainants, or

such as is like it, has, as an article of Commerce, taken pos-

session of the market, fairly driven out all competition ; and

therefore argue that it) must have been a decided improve-

ment, or it could not have done this. There can be no doubt

that canned cooked corned beef has met with great success in

sales singe it came into the market. But it 1s a remarkable

fact that the quality that has secured this success for the meat

is not the bodling, but the corning. Yet the corning is not in

the pateht ; pveither stated as part of the treatment by Wilson

or in the remotest manner hinted at.

By reference to the patent, the court will find nothing said

or suggested as to aught other than cooked meat—nothing is

said about the meat’s previous treatment, beyond cooking,

before canning. Yet the bulk of the meat sent upon the

market by the complainants is corned ; and that which sells it

is chiefly the fact that it is corned. Of course, if this is so,

there can be nothing made by complainants because of this

quality not even claimed as included in their [pretended new

article of merchandise. )

We refer to the testimony, and in connection therewith to

an admission found page 728, vol. of complainants’ testi-

mony. Deposition of A. A. Libby (one of complainants ),

24th cross inter. ‘* What do you first do with your meat in

preparing it for the can, that you call canned corned beef?”’

[Same objection, because there are no patents in this case

on corned beef, no issues involved therewith, and because it is

immaterial what any one of the complainants does. The

question ought to be, What do your patents cover? |

Ans. ‘* We usually put it in a pickle.’’

(Pages 728, 729,) 27th cross inter. ‘* Now, what I want

is a description of what is done to your meat, preparatory to

23

putting it in the cans, in the order of its doing and the length

of time given to each step. )

[ Same objection. |

‘Ans. ‘* We first take the quarters of the beef; then cut

it up in pieces; then pickle it, allowing it to remain in the

pickle according to circumstances, from ten to twenty days ;

then we remove it from the pickle, cook it 212° F. until well

cooked ; then remove the bone, cut it into pieces of a desira-

ble size; then press it solidly into the can until the entire in-

terior of the can is filled with meat; then we solder on the

cap of the can; and then subject it to the process of hermetic-

ally sealing; then we clean the can, paint and label it ; it is

then ready to be boxed for shipping.’’

Deposition of Horace K. Thurber, complainants’ witness

(p. 701), answer to 9th inter., speaking of complainants’

canned meat: **It was very much more tasty in appearance

than any meat I had ever seen canned.’’? Also, p. 700 (foot) :

‘¢ Every one that saw the goods that was in the trade would

buy it, and did buy it at once.’’ Page 703, cross examina-

tion, 17th cross inter.: ** When you: speak of the complain-

ants’ meat, you mean canned corned beef exclusively, don’t

you?”’

Ans. ‘I do.”’

20th cross inter. (p. 705): **And corned beef turned out

to be a favorite article ?”’

Ans. ‘*It did.’’

So W. W. Dodge, of San Francisco.

Examined by Mr. Offield, for complainants. p. 880. 14th

question. ‘* Are you familiar with the canned meat goods

consisting of solid compressed corned beef, manufactured and

sold by the complainant in this case, and if so, please state

when you first saw any such canned goods? ”’ |

A. ‘* We sell them every day and know them well, and

they are the first goods I ever saw in that kind of tins, and

put up in that condition—solid, compressed.”’

So complainants’ witness, Frank Norton, of San Francisco,

p. 887, 18th question: ‘* Are you familiar with the meats

S

aa .

‘ * pa +, - ss 8 . “ ae " Y Te ad “ >

SS , POSE REIT L Ne

24

packed by Messrs. Libby, MeNeill & Libby, of Chicago,

called compressed cooked corned beef?”

A, ** Tam familiar with it. That is all solid ; they shave

itrightup. * * * First saw it three or four years ago.

i never saw anything like 7 until then,” ete.

So of Jennings, p. 902, who is inquired of as to solid

corned beet.

So the exhibits of product produced will be found to be

chiefly corned beef.

Furthermore, it is corned beef only the defendants are

shown to have canned.

Frank S. Waters, p. 147.

(). © Please state in what manner the St. Louis Beef Can-

ning Co. packed its beef in cans prior to June Ist, 1877? ”’

A. ** After the beef was slaughtered, cut up and cured for

about ten days, it was then boiled,’’ ete., ete.

So as to proofs against Chicago Packing & Provision Co.,

witness Switzer, p. 170.

a-Q 3. ** What was first done to the meat which they

canned after it was slaughtered ? ”’

A. 6** It was pickled * * * between ten and twenty

days.”’

It need be only mentioned to the court that the corning by

sult or saltpetre causes the red color of boiled corn beef—

which, but for the curing, would be either dark or dull. This

is 2 matter of common knowledge, and is taken notice of by

courts as well as individuals.

7. The Wilson patent does not include ‘* processing,’ and

defendants have not infringed it.

The complainants assert, and have endeavored to main-

tain by the testimony, that the Wilson patent, in terms, in-

cludes the direction that the cans, when filled, shall be «§ pro-

cessed,’’ that is, bathed from two to six hours in boiling water

or some other appropriate hot mixture, vented and resealed.

They are driven to this position by two facts fully estab-

the meat

»

lished in the case: one, that unless ‘* processed,’

packed in the cans will spoil; and the other, that neither

they, the complainants, or, what is more important, the de-

fendants, have ever attempted to preserve meat in cans except

by the ** processing ’’? method ; that is, bathing and reventing.

79

If, therefore, ** processing’ is not included in the patent,

the complainants’ method is impractical. (See complainants’

testimony, Frank Gebbie, p. 179; George Burnham, Jr., pp.

213-214; Stephen H. Provost, p. 398—answers to 67th and

68th questions. )

>

‘¢ Processing ’’ 1s not included in the patent.

a. The process ends in closing the box air-tight.

To arrive at what is intended by the words, ‘* the box or case

is then closed air-tight upon the meat ;”’ or, if you choose, ¢* is

hermetically sealed upon the meat,’’ we should look at what

it is intended to effect by the process. The process is (p. 134)

for packing cooked meats for transportation in a compressed

form while heated with cooking, into an air-tight package, so

as to preserve the meat in its integrity, and retain all the nat-

ural juices and nutritive qualities of the meat. The meat is

first cooked thoroughly at a temperature of 212° Fahrenheit,

so that all the bone and gristle can be removed and the meat,

yet retain its natural grain and integrity. The meat is then in

proper condition for eating, and is wholesome and palatable.

It is pressed into a box or case, and the box or case is then

closed air-tight upon the meat. * * * ‘The meat, the

specification continues, thus put up is available at all times,

even when cooking is impracticable, as it is already cooked

before it is packed.

?

The box may be made of wood or metal, or both com-

bined, ete.

The volumes of testimony are full of statements by all

manner of witnesses, experts, canners, packers, etc., that the

process of boiling the cans, filled with whatever material is to

be preserved, to expel the air,, is @ cooking process. It is the

applicatlon for hours of boiling water or other heated sub-

iN

stance or heated air, to the exterior of the ean, and the neces-

sary result is cooking the contents of the can. So that even

‘aw beef becomes boiled. This is the tenor of the whole tes-

timony. Yet, we are told that before this ‘*processing,”’

especially so-called, is suggested, the meat under Wilson’s

patent is ‘cooked thoroughly,”’’ is in proper condition for eat-

ing, and is wholesome and palatable : that it is already cooked

before it is packed. What would be the effect of further cook-

ing that which is announced to be in such a perfect state as

cooked food? Necessarily depreciation, disintegration, 2 loss

of integrity, an expulsion of natural juices and nutritious

qualities—over-cooking.

If the boiling by processing had been contemplated by the

patentee, would he, in giving a reason why the food was

available at all times, even when cooking is impracticable,

have said, ‘tas it is already cooked before it is packed.”’

Yet, with all of these expressions naturally terminating

the process at closing the case air-tight, and with the fact that

this process is said to be applicable to a box or case made of

wood, or a barrel (where it is said a darrel of meat by the

patentee’s process would weigh only 110 pounds gross), it is

attempted to have the construction put on this specification

that it involves, necessarily, the further proceeding after clos-

ing air-tight, of boiling, venting and re-sealing.

We maintain that any one practicing the process just as

stated by W. J. Wilson, would stop at closing the package,

when packed, air-tight. The process would be finished when

the air outside was excluded ; and it is apparent the patentee

supposed the air would all be outside, for he distinctly directs

the hot meat shall be pressed by a suitable apparatus into the

box, with suffictent force to remove the air. If the air is re-

moved by pressure, and the meat is hot, the thought evidently

was no more will be needed than to close the box air-tight,

so no wr could get back. The object would be attained ; the

meat packed for transportation.

6. ‘*Air-tight’’ or ‘thermetically sealed’’ does not in-

volve the thought of ‘‘processing,’’ either by definition or

scientific use.

27

The word hermetically sealed has a definition in chem-

istry. The hermetic art is chemistry. A hermetic seal is one

perfectly close, ‘so that no air, gas or spirit can escape.

(Webster.) The process of preserving food is a process con-

nected with the art of chemistry ; a knowledge of it must have

been arrived at originally by a study of the effect of air and

water, or What air and water contain, on human food, and the

question is yet possibly an open one, whether as Mr. Mar-

shall states in his specification, water is the sole or chief cause

of decay of meat, or whether the germ of life causing putre-

faction, is in the air. ‘These were, at the date of the patents,

certainly questions in chemistry, and the Wilson specification

is to be interpreted by -the meanings words have in the her-

metic art, and in that art ‘shermetically sealed’? means ‘‘sealed

close,’’ so as to prevent escape of air, or if you choose, so as

to exclude air. It no more involves the further thought of

hot-water tanks, boiling, venting and re-sealing, than it does

re-packing the contents. The complainants’ expert, Mr.

Renwick, makes this admission, p. 999: ‘*As I understand

the matter; Winslow used the term in the sense in which |

have previously stated it, as used in reference to matters in

chemistry and instruments of natural philosophy, etce.’’

(Winslow’s patent here referred to is that passed on in Sewall

vs. Jones. )

A reference to the specifications of other patents will show

that, above stated, is the extent of the meaning of ** hermeti-

cally sealed,’’ among those endeavoring to use language

appropriate to the art of preserving fruit.

Thus also Rees’ cyclopedia, published in London, 1819, vol.

XXVill. ‘** Provision, preservation of,’’ (found in defendants’

testimony, p. 47, et seq.) At page 49, near foot, it reads:

‘* By Messrs. Donkin & Co.’s method, the meat or vegetable

to be preserved is first partially cooked by boiling, baking,

roasting or otherwise, and then enclosed in canisters or cans

of metal, or in bottles of glass or glazed stoneware, which

are very carefully closed, with every attention to render them

perfectly air-tight. In this state the cans or bottles are sub-

jected to a second boiling, which is sufficient to complete the

cooking, etc.

So Henry Gunter’s patent, January 6, 1841, defendants’

testimony, p. 66. ” " * <«¢] then solder on the other

end of each vessel, so that the vessel will be ermetically

closed, having, in filling, allowed a small quantity of room in

‘ach vessel to permit the substance therein to swell. I then

place a number of such vessels into a large boiler, ete.,”’

(describing the processing of the cans. )

Letters patent of Kermoal, 1854, defendants’ testimony,

p. @9.

ee * —«* The box is filled up through a hole in the

center, which is afterwards closed hermetically by soldering a

disc over it. The closed boxes are then exposed to steam, at

«a temperature of 250° F., ete.

So * the Winslow patent, complainants’ testimony, p,

994-995-996, cross-examination of Renwick ; 92—93 cross ints,

and answers, et seq.

On page 996, complainants’ expert says; ** In this patent

(referring to one of Winslow's), when speaking of the paten-

tee’s own Invention, or the invention which he states he made,

the term * hermetically sealed’ is undoubtedly used to express

an operation distinct from either the subsequent heating and

puncturing, or venting and re-sealing and re-heating of the

can.”’

If ** hermetically ’’ sealed or ‘* closed air-tight ’’ necessa-

rily involved the further processes here in all these patents

specified, why was so much trouble used to say again that

which had been already said? Evidently none of these per-

sons understood that it would be sufficient to say, and to stop

ut saying, ** the can is then to be hermetically sealed.”’

Whatever popular ‘sense may be, in an indefinite way,

applied to the product by dealers, there certainly is no scien-

tific sense in which ** hermetically sealed ’’. can be made to

include packing, venting and re-sealing.

c. Processing cannot be practiced on a wooden box

If ** processing ’’ was Mr. Wilson’s meaning, how did he

expect it to be practiced on a wooden box. Was some special

29

process to be pursued for wooden boxes, and some other for

metal cans, and still a third for those packages composed of

both wood and metal? ,Would not the person seeking to use

this process have to invent some means to practice it—become

the inventor of the means to exercise an invention? How many

boxes of wood would he have to boil before he discovered the

patentee meant they should be baked?

The trouble of Mr. Renwick, the complainants’ expert,

in keeping his wooden boxes (stewed or baked) from distor-

tion or destruction, remind one of the perplexities ,the Con-

federate soldiers had when, thinking them edible, they

attempted to boil, bake or fry the paper collars captured from

Union army on Red river, and failed very naturally to

arrive at any very satisfactory results.

Mr. Renwick, at last, under the close pursuit of defendants’

solicitor, abandons the box to its fate in the following remark-

able manner. (Complainants’ testimony, 1065-1066).

201 cross-inter.—Then, as you understand the Wilson

patent when it states that the box or case is then closed air-

tight upon the meat, that doesn’t refer simply to the putting

in the head or end of the box air-tight, but also means

that the wooden box, after it has been processed, shall, in

some way be treated with resin and beeswax, or some other

varnish, so as to close the pores of the wood. Is that so?

Ans. I understand that the description amounts to a

direction to the user, that the box or case, whatever it may

be composed of, is to be substantially hermetically sealed,

leaving it to the user, who may use a box of either wood or

metal, or partly of both materials, ¢o take such means for put-

ting the box in a suitable condition as he may see fil; etc., ete.

If we are correct in this position that the ‘‘processing’’ is

not included in the terms of the Wilson Patent, the testimony

is that the patent is worthless in practice.

This is a conclusion fairly to be drawn also from the stren-

uous exertion the complainants make to. have ‘‘processing”’

included by construction in their specification : for why should

30

they so exert themselves if they had a patent that was valu-

able without the method of ‘processing ?”’

The testimony of witnesses we refer to is that of S. H.

Provost (defendants’ testimony, pp. 3898-399), George Bern-

ham, Jr., (same, pp. 213-214), Frank Gebbie (p. 179), who

testify that the Wilson process is not practicable.

The testimony is also conclusive that the defendants have

at no time preserved, or attempted to preserve, meat in any

other way than by use of the method known as ‘processing ;”’

bathing the cans, and reventing, and that it is this alone that

has preserved their meat. So there is no case against defend-

ants, unless ‘*‘processing’’ is shown not only to be the com-

plainants’ patent, but to be their invention.

V. but taking (for the sake of argument) the Wilson patent

to extend to all that is claimed for it, itis void for want

of novelty.

W.J. Wilson was not the inventor or discoverer of any

new and useful art or manufacture; the improvement (if it

may be called so) was known er used by others in this coun-

try, and patented or described in printed publications in this

and foreign countries before the pretended invention or dis-

covery by Wilson, and was in public use and on sale for more

than two years prior to Wilson’s application.

The nature of Wilson’s improvement is described by him

to be new and improved processes for preserving and packing

cooked meats. |

As we have already seen, the preservation of the meat, in

a can or box, can be effected only by the exclusion of the air,

and the method by which this is to be done, under the Wilson

process, taking the complainants’ own construction, is by that

usually termed processing goods; that is by placing the can’

when packed into a bath of boiling water, allowing it to re-

main there fora sufficient length of time (from two to six

hours, according to size of package), venting same and re-

sealing the top. This at least, is the way the defendants pre-

serve meat, and unless this is Wilson’s patent there has been

no infringement by defendants. No matter what else is done,

nq eon Nsaedaag te = ~ eee a ep ne ET ge TILEY 2 odie ag gran eee a

2 SITE EE CATE 6 RTE SOT NE APE

ey ee Meet arnt ieee

whether the meat be salt or fresh, raw or cooked, put in by

mechanical pressure or gently inserted, made solid or soft, it

is the ‘*processing’’ that preserves the meat. This process is

that known as the Appert process, and has received the con-

struction of this Honorable Court in Sewell vs. Jones 91 U.5S.,

Rep., p. 187, where the following language is used in the

opinion: ‘*The discovery in question has been’ of immense

benefit to mankind. By means of food preserved in a com-

pact and nutritious form, protected from its natural tendency

to decay, deserts.are traversed, seas navigated, distant re-

gions explored. It is less brilliant, but more useful, than are

all the inventions for the destruction of the human race that

have ever been known. It isto France that the honor of this

discovery belongs, and to Appert, a French citizen. It does

not belong to America or to Winslow. Appert’s process pre-

sents all that we now know upon the subject. It contains ab-

solutely everything of value that is contained in Winslow’s

patent.’”’

a. <As to the process for preserving cooked meats then

claimed by Wilson, we may assert that it involves the Appert

process, or it does not. If it does not, the meat will not be

preserved, and the supposed patent is therefore worthless in

practice ; is not useful. If it does involve the Appert pro-

cess, it is that process alone that preserves the meat, and

there is no novelty in its practice by Wilson.

There are many other patents and publications printed in

the defendants’ testimony, from pp. 39 to 127, and elsewhere ;

but we shall at this time confine ourselves to the analysis of

the Durand (Appert) patent, made by this Honorable .Court

in Sewall vs. Jones, 91 U.S. Rep., p. 181, where the court

says: ** The points following are embraced in this patent :

‘sl, It is for the purpose of preserving for a long time

animal or vegetable food. |

‘2. The articles thus to be preserved are to be placed in

tin or other vessels, so arranged as to exclude communication

with the external air.

‘3. An aperture may be left in the vessel, at the choice

of the operator, until the effect of the heat shall have taken

place, when it is to be closed.

‘4. The vessels thus prepared are placed ina boiler filled

with cold water, which is heated to a boiling point, which

boiling shall be continued for such time as shall be required

by the substances contained in the vessels.

‘5. Although a water-bath is preferred, the inventor de-

clares that he avails himself of heat through an oven, stove,

steam-bath, or any other situation fit for gradually raising the

temperature and suffering it to cool again.

“6. Vegetables are to be put into the vessels in a raw or

crude state; animal substances raw or partly cooked.

“7, The invention is general in its terms, embracing all

vegetables and all animal substances capable of being thus dealt

with.”’ pes

It is admitted by complainants by a most formally executed

disclaimer, that Wilson claims nothing for any other kind of

meat than such as-is cooked by botling tn water. But they

insist that it is patentable to Wilson to unite with the Durand

process the previous cooking of meat by boiling in water only,

and compressing this meat while yet warm with the cooking

into the can, and then submitting to the Durand process.

But, we have just seen, Durand, or Appert, expressly

specified animal substances In cans, as subject-matter of the

process, whether raw or partly cooked, and that your Honor-

able Court says the invention, in its éerms, embraces all veget-

ables and all animal substances capable of being thus dealt

with. And among these is not cooked meat, put into the can

by whatever means, to be included, if it may not only be thus

dealt with, but must necessarily be thus dealt with to save it?

The insertion of corned beef into a can, and preserving it

by the Appert process, is no more than placing a fish into an

ice cream freezer—in place of ice cream—and so preserving

the fish. Yet this court has decided that this invasion of the

fish into the domain of the people’s ice cream, is not exactly

patentable. Reversing the Circuit Court of Massachusetts

which had held in favor of the fish.

Brown vs. Piper, 91 U.S. Rep. 37.

The Supreme Court bases its decision also, in part, upon

Fire

\.

~

ae

~~ a

the rather ghastly patent of John Good ‘‘for a corpse-pre-

server.’ |

The court says (p. 41): ‘The thing (the fish process )

wis within the circle of what was well known before, and be-

longed to the public. No one could iawfully appropriate it

to himself and exclude others from using it in any usual way,

for any purpose to which it may be desired to apply it. This

is fatal to the patent.’’

In this case Mr. Justice Swayne also uses the following

language, alike applicable here, we submit (p. 42):

‘Courts will take notice of whatever is generally within

the limits of their jurisdiction ; and if the judge’s memory is

at fault he may refresh it by resorting to any means for that

purpose which he may deem safe and proper. This extends

to such matters of science as are involved in the cases brought

before him.’’ And it is afterwards added :

‘Tt is known that Lord Bacon applied snow to poultry to

preserve it.. He said the process succeeded ‘ excellently well.’

The experiment was made in his old age, imprudently, and

brought on his last illness. Examined in the light of these

considerations, we think this patent was void on its face, and

that the court might have stopped short at that instrument,

and without looking beyond it into the answers and testimony,

sua sponte, if the objection were not taken by counsel, well

have adjudged in favor of defendant.’’

In Smith vs. Nichols., 21 Wallace. R., 118, Mr. Justice

Swayne, in delivering the opinion of the court, holds this

language :

‘¢A patentable invention is a mental result. It must be

new and shown to be of practical utility. Everything within

the domain of the conception belongs to him who conceived

it. The machine, the process or product is but its material

reflex and embodiment. A new idea may be engrafted upon

an old invention, be distinct from the conception which pre-

ceeded it and be an improvement. In such case it is patent-

able. The prior patentee cannot use it without the consent of

the tmprover, and the latter cannot use the original invention

without the consent of the former. But a mere carrying for-

3

ES

32

‘4. The vessels thus prepared are placed ina boiler filled

with cold water, which is heated to a boiling point, which

boiling shall be continued for such time as shall be required

by the substances contained in the vessels.

5. Although a water-bath is preferred, the inventor de-

clares that he avails himself of heat through an oven, stove,

steam-bath, or any other situation fit for gradually raising the

temperature and suffering it to cool again.

“6. Vegetables are to be put into the vessels in a raw or

crude state ; animal substances raw or partly cooked.

“7, The invention is general in its terms, embracing all

vegetables and all animal substances capable of being thus dealt

with.’’

It is admitted by complainants by a most formally executed

disclaimer, that Wilson claims nothing for any other kind of

meat than such as is cooked by boiling in water. But they

insist that it is patentable to Wilson to unite with the Durand

g of meat by boiling in water only,

and compressing this meat while yet warm with the cooking

into the can, and then submitting to the Durand process.

But, we have just seen, Durand, or Appert, expressly

specified animal substances in cans, as subject-matter of the

process the previous cookin

process, whether raw or partly cooked, and that your Honor-

able Court says the invention, in its erms, embraces all veget-

awbles and all animal substances capable of being thus dealt

with. And among these is not cooked meat, put into the can

by whatever means, to be included, if it may not only be thus

dealt with, but must necessarily be thus dealt with to save it?

The insertion of corned beef into a can, and preserving it

by the Appert process, is no more than placing a fish into an

and. so preserving

the fish. Yet this court has decided that this invasion of the

fish into the domain of the people’s ice cream, is not exactly

patentable. Reversing the Circuit Court of Massachusetts

which had held in favor of the fish.

ice cream freezer—in place of ice cream

Brown vs. Piper, 91 U. S. Rep. 37.

The Supreme Court bases its decision also, in part, upon

ie gm 1 a

SEE: Pee PA NCTE

Po Ri Se PR A ee a

the rather ghastly patent of John Good ‘‘for a corpse-pre-

server.”’

The court says (p. 41): ‘The thing (the fish process )

wis within the circle of what was well known before, and be-

longed to the public. No one could iawfully appropriate it

to himself and exclude others from using it in any usual way,

for any purpose to which it may be desired to apply it. This

is fatal to the patent.’’

In this case Mr. Justice Swayne also uses the following

language, alike applicable here, we submit (p. 42):

‘Courts will take notice of whatever is generally within

the limits of their jurisdiction ; and if the judge’s memory is

at fault he may refresh it by resorting to any means for that

purpose which he may deem safe and proper. This extends_

to such matters of science as are involved in the cases brought

before him.’’ And it is afterwards added :

‘¢Tt is known that Lord Bacon applied snow to poultry to

preserve it. He said the process succeeded ‘ excellently well.’

The experiment was made in his old age, imprudently, and

brought on his last illness. Examined in the light of these

considerations, we think this patent was void on its face, and

that the court might: have stopped short at that instrument,

and without looking beyond it into the answers and testimony,

sua sponte, if the objection were not taken by counsel, well

have adjudged in favor of defendant.’’

In Smith vs. Nichols., 21 Wallace. R., 118, Mr. Justice

Swayne, in delivering the opinion of the court, holds this

language :

‘©A patentable invention is a mental result. It must be

new and shown to be of practical utility. Everything within

the domain of the conception belongs to him who conceived

it. The machine, the process or product is but its material

reflex and embodiment. A new idea may be engrafted upon

an old invention, be distinct from the conception which pre-

ceeded it and be an improvement. In such case it is patent-

able. The prior patentee cannot use tt without the consent of

the tmprover, and the latter cannot use the original invention

without the consent of the former. But a mere carrying for-

3

ward, or new or more extended application of the original

thought, a change only in form, proportions or degree, the

substitution of equivalents, doing substantialky the same thing

in the same way by substantially the same means with Getter

results, is not such an invention as will sustain a patent.

These rules apply alike whether what preceded was covered by

a patent, or rested only in public knowledge and use. In

neither case can there be an invasion of such domain and an

appropriation of anything found there. In one case every-

thing belongs to the prior patentee ; in the other, to the pub-

lic at large.”’

See also Roberts vs. Ryer, 91 U.S. Rep. 159, citing and

approving the above.

Apply this rule. Let us suppose Appert an American

citizen, and one who has just made the great and beneficent

discovery of preserving human food, and to whom the broad

patent has just been given, that was conferred so long ago in

France. And let us suppose that at this very first period Mr.

Wilson could have become acquainted with the specifications of

Mr. Appert, so as to learn what was to be done, and he, Wilson,

had conceived the idea of preserving by Mr. Appert’s process

meat cooked by boiling in water and pressed, boneless, into the

can, so as to exclude the air and preserve the nutritious juices

and integrity of the meat. That finding afterwards that Mr.

Appert was also preserving by his process such boiled meat so

packed, but to the preservation of which his ( Appert’s ) process

was not only applicable but essential, Mr. Wilson should

apply to the court for an injunction against Appert. Would

your honors hold that Wilson was entitled to an injunction

against Appert, so far as boiled meat pressed hot into the can

and saved by the Appert process, was concerned ; or that

Appert would prevail against Wilson, for the Appert process for

any human food in the world, cooked or raw, so preserved ?

The less is included in the greater, and not the greater in the

less. ‘* Everything within the domain of the conception be-

longs to him who conceived it.’? Wilson is the smallest possi-

ble fraction of Appert, if you expand Wilson to his utmost.

Fy

All the world, the defendants included, ure the heirs of

Appert’s patent, and what could not be done to Appert, to de-

prive him of the reward of his great discovery, cannot be

done to any of all the people to whom he has left the enjoy-

ment of his discovery.

The complainants seem not to have anticipated the force of

these objections, and were quite indisposed to keep within the

very circumscribed limits of their original thought of cooked

meat, packed warm, and so extended their claim to all cooked

meat, packed hot or cold. Before they got down to the day

of hearing, however, the defendants presented to their gaze

not only the patent of Appert, Durand, Gunter, and the whole

army of encyclopedias, but also the patent of Ansel Storrs Ly-

man, of June 22, 1869, with many witnesses of the manufacture

and the sale of the product, showing it cooked meat, pressed

into the can and sealed hermetically. ‘Thereupon the complain-

ants fell back upon Renwick, and Renwick fell back upon a

disclaimer of all but that which was in the original patent,

and the most of that besides. The disclaimer was against

cold packing, and against any cooking but boiling in water.

But the expert said to the complainants, if they would just

stand to boiling in water and packing the meat hot, the im-

provement could be discovered over roasting and packing it

even hot, and the result would be a complete triumph ; that

preserving, by Durand’s process, boiled meat, packed hot,

was not only not within the domain of the conception of

Durand, but not even within the conception of Durand and

Lyman combined.

b. Roasting aud packing beef solid, in air-tight cans, no

more preceded Wilson, than boiling it and packing it in the

same way.

We are waiving for the present, but by no means surren-

dering, that great volume of testimony produced by both com-

plainants and defendants, proving that beef canned and _ pro-

cessed by the Durand process, so as to become boiled and solid

when cold, was made by the hundreds of thousands and even

millions of pounds, not only when California and Australia

summoned by their wealth the masses of America and En-

oland, but when the rebellion of 1861 called our armies to

the field and awakened at once the patriotism and inventive

faculties of our people, as they were never stirred before.

Yet all this product of boiled beef, which no one thought to

patent, was no more within the domain of, the conception of

Appert, than is the beef of Wilson, boiled before canning and

packed in the can. They were all within such conception.

Appert no more suggested boiled beef, boiled after putting

into the can and during the process, to be preserved, than

he did lobsters boiled before canning, or beef boiled before

canning. |

c. But we have the testimony of as good and _ responsi-

ble men as the United States affords, as to the boiling before

canning and pressing into the can and preserving by Appert’s

process.

Stephen Il. Provost, aged fifty-seven, New York city, a

manufacturer of preserved canned products since 1845, p. 390,-

latter part of answer to 9th inter., says: ‘*Our next: system

was to cook the meat either by boiling or roasting and pack-

ing them in cans without gravies or gelatine, and cook the

cans ina bath of boiling water, puncturing the caps of the

cans, after three hours’ boiling, letting the air escape, solder-

ing and re-boiling the cans in boiling water three hours more ;

* * from 1849, and running along about a year or two.

* * (p. 391) * at least a hundred tons. * * (p.

392) Ans. to 28th inter. The meat was put through the

aperture of the can and pressed down with a stick against

the sides of the can, and pressed under the lids with the

thumbs.’’ * * (p. 395.) Ans. to d1st int.: * the top

(of the can) being cut off below the rim, the can being in-

verted, the contents, from a slight jar or knock of the can, or

by the use of a knife, the thin blade run round against the

side of the can, so as to slightly loosen it, would come out in

solid form like the appearance of acolumn. * * * (to

the next question): if it had been kept in a cold atmosphere

it would cut down with a considerable degree of firmness, with

quite as much firmness as boiled beef. * * (p. 3896) *

the difference (from the product of the complainants) would

mainly be, between them, the difference resulting from the

POW AS LEMS Pome, « = ee

Pe a eS ye

37

corning of the beef before it was cooked and packed in the

can. This is repeated over and over under question and cross-

question.

George Burnham, Jr., ferty-eight years old, of Maine,

packer, of firm of Burnham & Morrill, page 199. As to

boiled beef prior to 1864. Answer to question 10. The meat

was first removed from the bone; then cut into pieces as near

as we could guess to the size of the can ; then placed in a pot

of boiling water and boiled ; then removed from the kettle,

weighed and filled into the cans; then they were sealed, put

through the process of boiling, cleaned, labeled and marked.

* * * (p. 209; answer 12.) We jammed the meats into

the can with our hands ; then put it under the lever made for

the purpose, and pressed it in.’’ (p. 201.) This was up to

about 1853, 1854. (p. 203.) The same was done at estab-

lishment of George F. Lewis. It issued in a solid cake and

was sliceable.

This witness repeats this all in detail over and over.

Charles S. Merrill, 43 years old, packer, Portland,

Maine, one of the largest inthe East (p. 244). At Rumery

& Burnham’s. ‘Ans. 14. ‘The meat was just taken from the

bone first ; then cut into pieces of one or two pounds’ weight ;

then either boiled or roasted ; then packed into cans. Well,

we used to take a small lever and press itin. * * * The

‘un would be full of solid meat. * * * It was then pro-

cessed. * * *

This and much more by this witness runs through many

pages.

He makes an important statement as to complainants’ pro-

duct, p. 259: ‘*IT never saw but two cans of complainants’

beef opened—one was warm, the other cold. The warm one

had some liquor in the can when opened; the other had not.’’

George fF’. Lewis, p. 222, age sixty-nine, canner, Portland,

p. 223. Steam the meat, half-cooked, pressed into can with

screw press, sealed air-tight. (p. 224). Bathed it; if opened

cold it would come out in one solid piece. * * * (p. 227.)

a8

‘¢T think Mr. Libby must have copied his idea from me.’’ > (p"

230. Cross-question, 53.) Do you now testify that the only

substantial difference between this article that you put up and

the Libby compressed meat is that theirs is corned? Ans.

‘¢7 do.”’

William Wt. Lewis, seventy-two years old, Boston, p. 292,

and following is to same effect. On page 309 he is asked in

cross-examination: Cross-question, 89. Did you, in the

process practiced by your firm, ever compress meat while yet

warm with cooking into the cans so as to remove the -air and

all superfluous moisture, and make the meat form a solid cake

of compressed meat in the can? Ans. Yes, we have, sir—

a great many times, sir. I don’t know how much air we

removed. We have filled cans in that way. I don’t know

What you call it.

This witness has much more to say to same effect, and

although somewhat eccentric he is evidently very much

earnest.

Joseph Stevenson, New York, forty-six years of ave,

stamper of tinware, states that he was with Wells, Miller &

Provost, and in 1850 and 1851 they (Wells & Provost) put

up meat, previously boiled, in cans, packed while yet warm,

solid. The meat was pressed in with sticks, pp. 705, 706.

Mrs. Ann McGuire Stevenson, p. 721, helped pack in cans

boiled meat, in 1850, at Wells G Provost’s.

Alexander Hamilton, p. 725, says in effect the same ; meat

packed solid and came out firm—a stick was used. On cross-

exunination, p. 733, we find the following :

68 x-Iné. Then when the English process was used there

was no gravy put in, was there?

Ans. No.

69 wnt, When was this English process used—what’

year?

Ans. The fall of 1850, the end of 1851; that is, to the

best of my recollection.

a9

George O. Sanborn, age forty-two, Cambridge, gives a

description of the solid corned beef he had seen prior to 1874,

jin 1862 and 1863; and he gives a description, among other

kinds of meat, of one quite familiar to Americans, p. 324, as

follows: 25 Int. Do you know what compressed beef or

meat is as understood in the trade? Ans. Yes.

26 Int. What is it?

alns. It is found in two forms in our markets and on our

tables. One being found in practice in New England of

pressing the corned beef bought from the butchers, and

after boiling the same and pressing the meat in divers ways,

commonly, as I have seen it at home from my boyhood, hav-

ing been put upon a platter, covered with a sheet-iron bake-

pan, and flat irons and other weights laid thereon, and then:

when served at the table, sliced therefrom and eaten cold.

Secondly, as practiced at the restaurants at New Orleans,

in 1862 and 1863. At the Moreau restaurant, such pressed

cooked beef was frequently served. And, thirdly, in the mar-

ket, in the provision shops, as it has been sold by local butch-

ers inthe New England markets in the place of canned corned

pressed meats. * ” * — And, fourthly, the pressed

canned meats of the various packers.

There is much more to same effect, proving boiled beef

packed solid in a can and processed, and sliceable when taken

out, was no novelty when W. J. Wilson obtained his supposed

patent.

To meet this proof, the complainants bring a number of

the persons employed by some of the defendants’ witnesses in

1850, who swear there was, as far as they know, no such beef

packed. And some of the defendants’ witnesses are also con-

fronted with certain ex parte affidavits, obtained from them

by the complainants’ agents and attorneys, written usually by

the attorney, and giving but a partial and meager statement

of what the witness knew.

The testimony shows that the defendants’ witnesses were

approached by Mr. Evarts, attorney for complainants, in ad-

rance of the examination pursuant to notice as required by

iN

statute ; and the methods of Mr. Evarts are stated by himself

in complainants’ testimony, p. 745.

Speaking of his efferts to get information from Mr. Isaac

Kaylor, one of defendants’ witnesses, Mr. Evarts says: ‘*Mr.

Kaylor has testified to this conversation with me, and I desire

to say about that, that he refused to tell me anything at first,

unless I paid him fifty dollars in advance ; [ talked with him

quite a while about that, until I saw I could get no informa-

tion from him as to these matters unless I paid him something,

and I finally offered him a five dollar bill as compensation for

his time and trouble in posting me as to the matters L inquired

about; he hesitated a good while before he would accept the five

dollars.

Mr. Kayior was called by complainants (p. 636), and sup-

ports the statements of Provost, Burnham and the others,

proving the packing solid meat cooked by boiling prior to

canning; and he says (pp. 649, 650) he told the gentleman

who visited him that he (witness) would have nothing to do

with the cases at all. He (the visitor) then said he would

pay me for my trouble or time, if I would answer him one

question, whether they put up meat boiled in Mr. Provost’s

factory in 1849, or raw; and I told him the beef was boiled

and roasted ; and he then gave me a five-dollar bill and left

me. I have not seen him since; I don’t know who he was.

What weight will this honorable court now give the testi-

mony of those other men whom Mr. Evarts visited, and who

have come forward to state what they did not see, to refute

what has been sworn to by the defendants’ witnesses, men of

intelligence, position, immense material interests in the com-

munities where they live; men who have risen, by their in-

dustry and integrity, from the first small beginnings of labor-

ing men, to the command of a vast commerce. |

But there is an additional witness, against whom even the

complainants are unable to say a word, even by way of criti-

cism. The testimony of this witness is conclusive against all

claim to invention of either process or product by Wm. J.

Wilson. We refer to the statements of Dr. Perl, to be found

on pp. 550-558 of the defendants’ testimony.

wey w-

4]

Michael Perl, 42 years of age, residence Houston, Texas,

practicing physician (p. 551), engaged in the meat-packing

business 1868-1869-1870 and part of 1871.

(J. 6. Please explain fully the process you used in put-

ting up meat in cans? .

Ans. I put up several kinds of meat ; some were Appert

system; the others were put up roast beef in cans; also,

roast beef put up in extract of meat, and corned beef in cans.

I put up a few smoked tongues in cans which I sent to a gen-

tleman, Mr. Newman, of the firm of Newman & Co., commis-

sion merchants, in New York City. The roast beef was first

roasted, and then put up in cans and sealed up, and then

filled up with this extract, or concentrated gravy, through the

stud hole, and put through the ordinary process. Zhe corned

beef was first cured as corn beef is, then boiled and cut in

suitable-sized pieces to fit the can; then it was rolled up and

put in the can, which was then sealed up without any gravy,

and then processed. ” ” .

(p. 552) Y. 13. Now the corned beef: did the cooked

corn beef entirely fill the cans when packed? Aas. It did.

@. 14. Was this corned beef pressed into the cans by

hand or otherwise? Ans. By hand only.

@. 15. How did the canned beef issue from the cans?

Ans. By cutting the can close to the rim, it could be shaken

out in a solid piece from the can.

@. 16. This solid piece could then be sliced down?

Ans. Yes, sir.

This witness testifies to using this canned corned beef in

his family, giving it to his friends, and (p. 558) he says: ¢1

also gave some to a gentleman who left on a trip nort h, and

he also took some to England.’’ 7

What becomes of the claim to the novelty of boiling meat

in this process, in view of the last quoted testimony? In this

last instance the various steps of the process appear to have

been taken by the witness. The meat is boiled, pressed into

the cans so as to fill the can, is processed, and comes out

whole and sliceable. If Wilson saw this in 1868, what did he

invent in 1874, so as to now exclude Dr. Perl and all the

“ ——" Se ee ae OG SE ey

= eT PRO Si ee ee Rash et « $

wah " “ts ere

‘ — Sirens in > Ys. > ete cbs Ge ee,

.

42

world from canning boiled beef? It may be well asserted

that Wilson has given nothing for his claim to a patent; he

has invented nothing, and the grant to him is without consid-

eration.

We may, therefore, we submit, conclude safely that the

W. J. Wilson patent will be held void for the following

reasons :

1. The disclaimer on the re-issue, if otherwise effective,

has been unnecessarily delayed.

2. The disclaimer is not effective, but false, in stating

that the claim disclaimed was inadvertent, when it was in fact.

the whole on which the re-issue was claimed and founded.

3. That the re-issue is therefore void as being for not the

sume improvement claimed in the original patent ; one being

for packing meat warm, the re-issue being for packing meat

warm or cold.

4. That the pretended improvement is not patentable, it

not being the result of discovery or invention : the disclaimer

admitting that roast meat is not included, and the proof show-

ing it, and the difference between boiled and roast being no

substantial difference on which the patent may be based,

especially when the success of the packed meat is shown to be

the result of corning; and which process of corning is not in

the patent, or combination.

9. Because the Wilson process in fact ends with the

merely closing of the can air-tight upon the meat, and neither

directs or suggests processing further, and is worthless ; be-

“use meat so packed will not be preserved, but soon. spoil.

6. That taken for all that is claimed for the process, it Is

not novel. a. It is in effect the Appert process applied to a

particular kind of food, boiled meat, and is within the domain

of Appert’s conception. 6. The identical process has been

practiced by Rumery & Burnham, Lewis & Bro., Wells &

Provost, and others, as early as 1850-1851, and by Dr. Perl

in 1868-1871.

THE MARSHALL PATENT.

The Marshall patent has expired by the limitation of its

own terms. This fact alone might not have affected the com-

SA =a ‘a . — ea

Ee PI te re te reget tree nnn rte eenag Narn ine —— oe ten © Sy eee AR : ryt noe

4d

plainant’s suit, but at the hearing below all claim under this

patent was abandoned in argument. This, we suppose, will

be done also here. We therefore state merely our positions,

out of abundance of caution. |

The Marshall patent rested on the original letters from

July 12, 1864, to April 6, 1875, nearly ten years, and by the

re-issue, it appears that the matter inadvertently omitted

from the original, which it was desirable, not to say neces-

sary, the re-issue should set furth, were :

Ist. That water, alleged in the original to be the only

destroying agent to meat, should be averred to be only the

chief agent in destruction.

2d. That where the original read, ‘¢I then subject a given

‘quantity of the meat to pressure, in a box or cylinder, un-

‘¢til all the air is driven out and the space occupied by the

‘smeat agrees with the size of the package it is intended to

fill,’ the re-issue should read, “I then subject a given quan-

tity of the meat to pressure in a suitable mold, and suhse-

quently into the packages or boxes intended to receive the

same, wnédl the air is driven out and the space occupied by the

meat agrees with the size of the package or box it is intended

to fill.”’

dd. That while the claim of the original reads, ‘* First,

exposing the meat to be preserved, previous fo putling it up

in packages, to «1 heavy pressure, substantially as, and for the

purposes, herein specified,’’ the re-issue claims, ‘*First, the

process herein described for pacxing and preserving meats, the

same consisting in subjecting the meat, after it has been ex-

posed to preserving processes, as described, to a heavy press-

ure and packing and hermetically sealing the so compressed

meat in packages or boxes, substantially as, and for the pur-

pose, herein set forth; and second, as a new article of manu-

facture, the above-described compressed meat, preserved in

solid form, without disintegration or desiccation, in hermet-

ee

ically-sealed packages, substantially as herein set forth.

4th. And where the original read in the specification,

‘cwhen the meat is in its place the box is hermetically sealed

\ and in this state, retaining all its nutritive qualities the meat

will remain perfect as long as the package remains intact,”’

44

the re-issue reads, ‘*‘when the compressed meat is in its place

the package or box is hermetically sealed, the air remaining

in the same being expelled by the usual process in canning.

In this state, retaining all its nutritious qualities, the meat

will remain perfect as long as the package remains intact.’

The expansion of the re-issue is evidently very great, as it

extends first to pressure ¢nfo the can until the air is driven

out, and to expelling the air remaining by the usual process

of canning.

That the intent of the re-issue is to require pressure in the

can, is apparent, because the words ‘‘exposing the meat to be

preserved previous to putting it up in packages,’’ are carefully

omitted from the claim, and words placed in lieu thereof,

‘ssubjecting the meat, after zt has been exposed to preserving

processes as described to a heavy pressure and packing and

hermetically sealing the so-compressed meat in packages and

boxes, substantially as, and forthe purpose herein set forth.”’

It also appears by other expressions to same effect in the re-

issue, as compared with the original.

I. The re-issue thus appears to be for a process essentially

not the same as the original, and is void.

Under this patent there is no disclaimer. We say essen-

tially not the same, because if these are not essential, then

the Wilson process that is based Jargely on the compression in

the can, with, as it is there claimed, the canning process added,

has itself nothing essentially patentable in it. If not essen-

tial to the Marshall patent, they amount to nothing patenta-

ble in the Wilson patent. And if essential, and to be included

in the suggestion of the specification of the Marshall patent,

then the Marshall patent itself destroys the Wilson patent. by

antedating it, so far as compression in the can is coneerned,

and processing.

II. The patent is not a patentable process.

In fact, the compression, and all that tends to make the

product claimed as a new article of manufacture under the

45

Marshall patent (being, as we have seen, compressed meat,

preserved in solid form, without disintegraticn or desiccation,

in hermetically-sealed packages ), is attributable to either the

antiseptics or the canning process (which are confessedly not

new ), or to the result of a mechanical operation, and is, within

the meaning of the patent, not a process at all.

This is clearly set forth in Corning vs. Borden, 15 Howard

Rep. 267: ‘*A process, ex nomine, is not made the subject

of a patent in our act of Congress. It is included under the

general term ‘useful art.’ An art may require one or more

processes or machines in order to produce a certain result. or

manufacture. The term machine includes every mechanical

device or combination of mechanical process and device to

perform some function, and produces a certain effect or result.

But when the result or effect is produced by chemical action,

“by the operation or application of some element or power of

nature, or of one substance to another, such modes, methods

or operations are called processes. A new process is usually

the result of discovery ; a machine of invention * * * *

p. 268. It is when the term process is used to represent the

means or method of producing a result, that it is patentable,

and it will include all methods or means which are not effected

by mechanism or mechanical combinations. But the term

process is often used in amore vague sense, in which it cannot

be the subject of a patent * * * In this use of the term

it represents the functions of a machine, and the effect pro-

duced by it on the material subjected to the action of the ma-

chine. But it is well settled that a man cannot have a patent

for the function or abstract effect of a machine, but only for

the machine which produces it. * * * In either case

(noted by the court) the iron (subject-matter, say) may be

said, in the secondary sense of the term, to undergo a process

in order to change its qualities by pressing out its impurities,

but the agent which effects the pressure is a machine or com-

bination of mechanical device.

If Marshall is not the patentee of the preparation by anti-

septics, nor of the preseryation by the canning process, and

has pressed the meat by a machine, is it not apparent that the

46

only patentable agent (if any) he has, is the machine—the

agent of the pressure, the mechanical devices.” eon

This, of course, it is not pretended that the defendants

have ever used to any degree whatever.

Ill. But there is, in fact, no tinprovement in any of Mar-

shall’s process.

a. If we adhere to the language and limit of the original

patent, it is enough to say that the defendants have never

practiced it.

We have considered the true meanmeg of the words ‘* her-

metically sealed,’’ as used in the original patent, and we have

found, we submit, in discussing the Wilson patent, that

both, in strict definition, and by common acceptation of

writers on the subject of preserving meat, and of patentees of

similar patents, the words ‘* hermetically sealed’? mean only

closed air-tight, and do not include or suggest the further

process of canning, that is, heating, venting, etc. The

assignees of this very patent were well aware of this, and so

were careful to insert the canning process as an essential to

success In the re-issue. If it is true that the words, ‘‘ehermet-

ically sealed,’’ mean no more than we here insist on, then the

defendants have never attempted to thus pack their product,

and there has been no infringement in any particular.

6. But if the canning process is included, the testimony

is, first, that the heating process will make ‘‘gravy’’ in the

can ; and second, that raw meat heated (boiled) in the can is

the one product, above all others, that has been made and sold

since Appert’s day: and with wonderful profusion in this

country during the California fever and the war of the re-

bellion.

If there is one thing that has been proven is this case, there

was ‘‘eravy’’ in Wells & Provost’s and Wells, Miller & Pro-

vost’s boiled beef; in Lewis & Bro.’s roast beef; and in Burn-

ham & Merrill’s boiled mutton ; yet there is sure to be gravy

on Marshall’s meat.

47

We will cite the words of a practical canner and an expert,

and inflict no more of the depositions, on this point, on the

court.

Amasa G. Smith (complainants’ testimony, p. 301) says

he is forty-seven, and a packer; has been with Lewis & Bro.

and Burnham & Merrill, from 1846 to the war. Ans. p. 302

to int. 7.

For the first six years that I worked for Mr. Lewis, each

quarter of beef was cut in two pieces ; the round of the hind-

quarter and the shoulder and neck piece of the fore-quarters,

were packed for boiled beef, packed raw ; the other portions

of the beef were roasted, as near as I can deseribe that they

were four or five pieces mixing In the round and fore-quarter,

part of each. —

‘Int. 8. Was there any stock or gravy put into the cans

with this raw meat, during the fourteen years referred to?

‘ns. Very seldom; but I have seen it used.

‘¢ Int. 9. From 1846 to 1860, was there any pressure, by

levers or sticks, used on the raw meat in the cans, in the

packing of it into them?

‘Ans. There was not.

‘Int. JO. From 1846 to 1860, what was the condition of

this beef thus packed raw, after the cans were ready for sale,

as to Juice or gravy in the cans?

‘Ans. ‘There would be on top of the can a small portion

of fat; underneath that, around the edges of the can, would

be a light beef stock or jelly.

‘SInt. JI. Have you ever opened any of those cans of

meat packed raw, put up before 1860, to see whether the

pieces would fall apart when poured into a dish out of the

can?

‘«<4dns. When a can is heated you can pour the gravy off,

and the meat will come out in pieces. When a can is cold

the can can be opened so that the meat will come out in a

solid-mass. What I mean by that is, the fat and gravy will

hold the meat together if the can is opened on the side and

not on the top. The top of the can is cut off round the

side.’’

48

Now, take the complainants’ expert, Mr. Renwick (p. 948) :

Int. 32. By Mr. Clifford—What would be the effect of

the process of hermetically sealing upon the compressed meat

put up as described in the Marshall process ?

Ans. According to the Marshall specification, the meat,

although treated with an antiseptic, is not cooked before it Is

pressed into the can, and is hermetically sealed ; consequently

the process of hermetically sealing would, cook the meat in

the can and cause it to shrink materially therein, the shrink-

uge permitting the piecés to separate; hence, when the pro-

cess was concluded the meat would nof be in a solid cake, fill-

ing the can, and there would be an excessive collapse of the

head or sides of the can as it cooled down after sealing.’’

( Adjourned. )

On cross examination, this expert, on page 987, again

says:

+ * * «Whereas, according to the said original Mar-

shall patent, the meat, although treated with antiseptics, and

although compressed into a solid cake before it is put into the

san, is, nevertheless, put in in the raw condition; and conse-

quently, when the can is subsequently hermetically sealed, as

it is described to bein the said Marshall patent, the heat.which

is used in the sealing will cause the meat to shrink in the

can, and to exude more or less gravy, so it would cease to be in

a solid cake in the can.’

See, then, the wonderful improvement. You press meat

into a can to make it solid, compressed, meat, and you imme- |

diately cook it to pieces, so it exudes gravy and ceases to be

solid, and the product turns out to be the old boiled beef of

California times and the rebellion. Whether this gravy be-

comes solid or not makes no difference in the argument. It

is gravy at the start in both cases, and runs the same course

in each.

We think this court will not expect us to urge the worth-

lessness of Marshall’s patent further on this point.

IV. There is no novelty in the pretended process of Mar-

We have just shown this in what we have said and

quoted, and the vast volumes of testimony, on either side, can

be opened, at random, and proof will appear that the whole

pretended process and product are old.

But, as we have already urged in regard to the Wilson

patent, so we say Marshall’s pretence is in all useful features

but the identical process of Appert. It is the preservation

of a raw animal substance by Appert’s process — patented

in France, and re-patented to Durand in England in 1810.

This Honorable Court has carefully analyzed this old pro-

cess, and its declaration is, as we have before quoted, ‘* The

invention is general in its terms, embracing all vegetabies,

and all animal substances capable of being thus dealt with.’’

We think we may rest safely on these considerations with-

out further analysis of the testimony, which can neither add

to, nor detract from, the effect of a mere comparison of the

two patents, Appert’s and Marshall’s, with each other in

terms and obvious results.

Since Appert’s process became the common property of all

the world, and was in common use and practice in the homes

of our people before either Marshall or Wilson endeavored

to appropriate it as a monopoly for themselves, and the want

of novelty in their pretended discoveries appears on the face of

their patents, this case comes within the principle of Brown

vs. Piper, $1 U.S. R. 37, and the decree below should be

affirmed without further inquiry than reading the letters them-

selves.

AS TO THE WILSON CAN.

We learn from this patent, it is for an improvement in

sheet-metal cans, and that what is claimed as new is:

Ist. A can for packing food, hermetically sealed, and

constructed of pyramidai form, with rounded corners and off-

set ends to support the heads, said heads being secured as

shown and described (that is, the three thicknesses of metal

pressed together by machinery, with or without solder, so as

to make air-tight joints).

4

20

2d. The perforated plate (D.) in combination with head

(B.) or (C.), provided with a protector, substantially as,

and for the purpose, set forth.

3d. As an improved articie of manufacture, solid meat,

compressed and secured within a pyramidal case or can, so

that said case forms a mold for the meat and permits its dis-

charge as a solid cake, substantially as specified.

lL. The third claim here is void.

First. Solid meat is not an improvement in sheet-metal

cans.

Second. Because, if it is the mold that is claimed, it Is

nothing more than the first part of the claim, describing the

can as pyramidal, with rounded corners, etc. ; and

Third. Because it is not novel as compared with even the

William J. Wilson process and specifications, to say nothing

of all the other meats in can of which so much has already

been said and quoted in this argument.

We pass to the form and other features of the can itself.

Il. There ts no patentable improvement in the can.

a. On page 940 (defendants’ book), Mr. Clifford’s stipu-

lation is in these words :

‘¢It is further stipulated and agreed that the complainants

admit that conical tin cans were made and used for ANNINE

alimentary substances, and sealed air-tight, prior to the date

of the Wilson patents that are the subjects of controversy in

the above entitled causes.”’

With this stipulation in force, we are left to consider only

the other features of the can, the rounded corners, which

effect the change from aconical to a pyramidal form, the fast-

enings of the heads, and the vent and shield.

These features, if they were new, are not patentable,

because there is nothing in them the product of an exercise of

the inventive faculties. They do not involve anything more

than is obvious to persons skilled in the art of can-making—

D1

or we may say more broadly, the art of working tin and making

tin vessels and canning food. The admission above set forth

presents an air-tight conical tin can, for alimentary substances,

prior to Mr. Wilson’s application for his can. With such a

can so used, would not the mind of a can-maker naturally

comprehend that the one might be changed into a vessel with

straight sides and rounded corners ; and seeing the top and

bottom of the truncated cone made of separate pieces and

fastened air-tight, can it be said any one would have exer-

cised any inventive faculty if he planned to make the top and

bottom fasten air-tight by any other particular joining togeth-

er of the pieces; or that seeing a vent used, as it has long

been in the canning process, it is an invention to put a simple

ond

euard over it to prevent clogging

In the hundreds of thousands of cans of provisions ¢* pro-

cessed”? for California, Australia, the army and the navy, all

of which were ‘+ vented,’’ as the whole testimony conclusively

proves, there must have been a guard against clogging by

Is a mere pretense.

9

shielding the vent,, or the ‘* clogging

The testimony shows one or the other, and the complainants

have not attempted to show the contrary. ;

Unless the improvement in the sheet-metal can is the pro-

duct of the exereise of the inventive faculties, and involves

something beyond what is obvious to persons skilled in the

art to which it relates, it is not entitled to protection under

the patent laws.

Pearce vs. Mulford, 102 U.S. R. 112.

Rubber-coated Harness Company vs. Welling, 97 U.

Ss. R. 7.

Collar Company vs. Van Dusen, 25 Wallace R. 563.

A mere aggregation of parts is not combination so as to

4

be patentable. The combination must be new itself, and

must produce a new and useful result, not due to the separate

action of any one of the devices used in combination, nor

attained thereby, but due to the co-operation or reciprocal

action of the combined devices.

Surtis on Patents (4th ed.), sect. 111, ¢. p, 123.

o2

The admission that the prior use of conical air-tight cans

for preserving alimentary substances surrenders the whole

principle of the pyramidal can without rounded corners.

There is no real difference in principle, in view of the pur- |

poses contemplated, between the conical can, admitted to have

been in prior use, and the pyramidal can with rounded corners

claimed by Wilson.

This is well illustrated in the case of ‘Winans vs. Denmead,

15 Howard Rep. 330, holding it an infringement by defendant

to have constructed octagonal and. pyramidal cars, when the

plaintiff had a patent for such cars in conical form.

The Supreme Court in this case uses the following language

applicable to the present case :

‘¢Where form and substance are inseparable, it is enough

to look at form only; where they are separable, where the

whole substance of the invention may be copied in a different

form, it is the duty of the courts and juries to look through

the form for the substance of the invention—for that which

entitled the inventor to his patent, and which the patent was

designed to secure: where that is found, there is an infringe-

ment; and it is not a defense that itis embodied in a form not

described, and in terms claimed by the patentee.”’

Thus the conical form of can, admitted to have had prior

use—in fact proven to have been in domestic use for forty

years (Pocock’s, defendants’ testimony, p. 924), precludes

the adoption of a new pyramidal form as patentable. The

substance of the advantage in each ean was the taper of the

can, so the contents could be easily removed.

Reverse the coal car, where it was intended to resist down-

ward pressure of the coal in transportation, and you have at

once the advantage of withdrawing resistance from downward

pressure, as in the can. If form of contour made no differ-

ence on which to base a defense, so will it not afford com-

plaints a eround for action, with the existence or common use

of the substance of the improvement, although in different

form or contour.

53

Ill. ut, in fact, the can, as described, is not new in any

of its features.

The Redmond patent, May 2, 1857 (defendants” book, p.

1000), is for improvement in the manufacture of metal boxes

used for containing sardines and other preserved food. On p.

1002 is the claim for the conical form.

The Peltier patent, April 1, 1859 (defendants’ book, p.

1008), is for new arrangements applicable to vessels or metal-

lic boxes, designed for various uses, especially for alimentary

preserves, and.for new processes for making the said boxes.

Specification. The object of the present addition has for

its principal aim to guarantee to me different methods proper

for making prismatic or pyramidal boxes. * * * Figure

318 a prismatic box with six sides; and figure 4 a pyramidal

box having also six sides. It can be seen by a description of

the apparatus which can produce these diverse forms, that the

number of sides to be given to the box is almost a matter of

indifference. On p. 1011, this patent says: ‘*If the box has

rounded corners the pressing devices may embrace the form

of these corners, which they compress simultaneously with

the sides.”’

On p. 1014, this patent says: ‘In the preserving business

when it is a question of submitting filled boxes either to evap-

oration or the boiling process, we make a small hole upon the

cover to allow the steam to escape.”’

In the fourth addition to Peltier patent of August 13, 1858

(defendants’ book, p. 1022), it is said (as to fastening bottom

and top to can), ** This bottom and this cover have their

edges stamped as represented in section (in Fig. 4), so that

the edges of the body of the box, slightly pressed, fit exactly

into the groove which surrounds the edges of the cover and

the bottom.’’

But the very same form of contour of Wilson’s can is

not new.

The want of novelty by comparison with patents issued

and known previous to John A. Wilson’s, is so fully and aceu-

‘ately set forth by Mr. Henry L. Brevoort, in his testimony,

that we cannot do better than to refer to and adopt, without

D4

repeating, his language, contained in defendant’s testimony,

pp. 955-968, and particularly 961—2—3-4.

The testimony, in a word, establishes that the St. Louis

Beef Canning Company does not make or use a can like the

John A. Wilson can; there is no offset to the St. Louis can ;

there is no flange to the body of the can; the top and bottom

are simply recessed and flanged over the margin of the can

body, the heads are not secured by turning the flaring edges

of the body of the end of the can over and on the outside of

the edges of the heads; but, on the contrary, the margins of

the top and bottom are turned and flanged over the straight

edges of the body, like a box cover. ae

Westerbeck, p. 104‘, swears distinctly the defendant never

used such a can as the Wilson.

But if the court arrives at the conclusion the cans are the

same in equivalents, then we submit, it is impossible to avoid

finding that the Wilson is the same as the Peltier’s in equiva-

lents, if not identically the same.

We, therefore, confidently submit that the decrees of this

Honorable Circuit Court, dismissing the biils,in each case,

were correct and should be affirmed. |

NOBLE & ORRICK,

; Solicitors for Defendants.

yest

R 8 1892

=.

Uvirep STATES

Northern District of Illinois.

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY anv LIBBY. McNEILL & LIBBY,

Vs.

THE CHICAGO PACKING ann PROVISION COMPANY.

THE SAME, )

VS. \.

THE ST. LOUIS BEEF CANNING COMPANY. |

THE SAME. ]

VS. |

ROBERT D. HUNTER, er At.

CERTIFIED COPY OF OPINION OF THE COURT.

Hon. THOMAS DRUMMOND,

Hon. HENRY W. BLODGETT,

PRESIDING.

CHICAGO:

BEACH, BARNARD & Co., LEGAL PRINTERS, 10k RANDoLPH Sr.

1882.

F c 2 . Mi diel Sabie iets : tat eT Ss BT ED ema dm,

Kanan ate Ber 1 SABIE AT A RTT wig i, ae, ‘

OPINION OF THE COURT.

Hon. Thomas Drummond, Hon. Henry W. Blodgett, presiding.

DRUMMOND, J.: These cases have all been argued to-

gether, and involve the same questions of law and fact,

and are founded upon the re-issued patent of William J.

Wilson, No. 6,370, of April 6th, 1875, for a new and use-

ful improvement in the process for preserving and packing

cooked meats for transportation, and in the re-issued pat-

ent of John A. Wilson, No. 7,923, of October 23d, 1877,

for anew and useful improvement in metallic cans for

containing cooked meat. The re-issued patent of Will-

iam C. Marshall, No. 6,451, of May 25th, 1875, for a

new and improved process for preserving meats, although

set forth in the pleadings, is not relied on in the argument,

and need not .be further considered as an independent

ground of relief. These patents were before us in 1879,

in the case of Zhe Wrlson Packing Co. et al. v. Pratt, 11

C. L. News, 353.

The most important questions in the case grew out of

the patent of William J. Wilson. In his original patent

he stated that, in carrying out his invention, the meat was

to be first cooked thoroughly, at a temperature of 212

degrees Fahrenheit, so that all the bone and gristle could

be removed and the meat yet retain its natural grain and

integrity-—that a measured quantity of this cooked meat

was then while yet warm with cooking, pressed by any

suitable apparatus into a previously prepared box or case,

hie

Se ee ae saiewvets

with sufficient force to remove the air and all superflu-

ous moisture, and make the meat form a solid cake, and

that then the box or case was closed, air-tight, upon the

meat. It will be observed that he did not distinctly set

forth in this original patent in what manner the meat was

to be first cooked.

There is in the re-issue no change in the description of

carrying out the invention, except that he declares that it

is a “ preferable” mode of putting the meat cooked into a

box or case while yet warm with cooking. The implica-

tion of course is that it was not an indispensable part

of his description of the invention that it should be thus

put in warm. There were two claims in the original,

as there are in the re-issue, and the only difference be-

tween them is, that, in the original, the first claim states '

that the cooked meat is to be pressed into an air-tight ,

package “ while heated with cooking,” these last words ;

wow” being omitted in the first claim of the re-issue. {

While these suits have been pending, the plaintiffs have. |

filed a disclaimer of the use of the word “ preferably ” in

the re-issue, thus eliminating it from the description therein

contained, and leaving the patent in this respect as it was

in its original form. They have also disclaimed the use dy:

of the following words of the description in the re-issued

patent: “The meat is first cooked thoroughly, at a tem-

“perature of 212 degrees Fahrenheit, so that all the bone

“and gristle can be removed and the meat vet retain its

“natural grain and integrity.” And, instead thereof, in-

sert the following words, namely: “The meat is first |

« cooked thoroughly by boiling it in water, so that all the

‘bone and gristle can be removed and the meat vet re- |

“tain its natural grain and integrity.”

?

J

Waiving the objections which have been made to the

validity of these disclaimers, we may now state what the

invention of the William J. Wilson patent is. The meat

is to be first thoroughly cooked by boiling it in water, so

that all the bone and gristle can be removed and the meat

yet retain its natural grain and integrity. While yet warm

with cooking, it must, by some suitable apparatus, be

pressed into a box or case, previously prepared, with

sufficient force to remove the air and all superfluous moist-

ure, and make the meat form a solid cake. The box or

case is then to be closed air-tight upon the meat. So that

the invention contains these elements:

Ist. Thoroughly cooking the meat by boiling it in

water, removing the bone and gristle.

2d. Placing it while yet warm with cooking intoa box

or case, and pressing it by some suitable apparatus with

sufficient force to remove the air and all superfluous moist-

ure, and make the meat form a solid cake.

3d. Closing the box or case air-tight upon the meat.

It will thus be observed that the first requisite is, that

the meat must be thoroughly cooked by boiling it in

water, that mode of cooking called “ stewing ” not being

necessarily excluded, unless the words declaring that

“the meat yet retain its natural grain and integrity,” have

that effect. The patent limits the cooking to this particular

mode. Baking, roasting, and steaming being excluded as

modes of cooking meat.

After the bone and gristle are removed, there is no de-

scription given of any particular manner in which the meat

is to be treated before itis put into the box or case, unless

the use of the language, that, “it is then wholesome and

palatable,” has that effect.

4

And although the evidence shows that all of the meat

put up by the plaintiffs and which has entered so exten-

sively into the markets of the country for sale is corned

meat, that is not a part of the patent, and fresh meat with-

out antiseptics of any kind, if thoroughly cooked by boil-

ing in water, with the bone and gristle removed, and if

while yet warm with cooking, put into a box or case,

closed air-tight, would be within the description of the

patent. Neither is anything said of the extent of the pres-

sure to which the meat is to be subjected when placed in

the box or case, except that it must be with sufficient force

to remove the air and all superfluous moisture, so that the

meat will ferm a solid cake; nor is the degree of warmth

named which must exist when the meat is put into the box

or case; neither is any description given of the manner in

which the box or case is to be closed air-tight upon the

meat.

It is claimed by ‘the plaintifis that this combination of

the manner of cooking and preserving meats for trans-

portation is new, and entitles William J. Wilson to a

patent.

It should be stated, that in the original, as well as in

the re-issued patent of William J. Wilson, it seems to be

implied, by the second claim which is made in each, that

the box or case must be hermetical/y sealed. Some criticism

has been made upon the use of this word. We do not

understand it to mean the same as if it were employed in

describing anything as hermetically sealed in a laboratory,

but oniy that the package should be so sealed as to

exclude the passage of air into or out of the box or

case. |

The patentee says, that this box or case may be made

of wood or metal, or both combined, of any: suitable form

i

et ape ag

5

or shape, and of any desired dimensions. It is, perhaps,

unnecessary for us to inquire, as all the parties in this

case use metal, whether or not the box or case could

possibly be made of wood, or whether in order to ac-

complish the object which the patentee had in view, it

must always be made of metal.

We will, therefore, direct our attention, in the first place,

to the question, whether or not what William J. Wilson

describes in his specifications as just stated, was the proper

subject of a patent. The cooking of meat thoroughly,

by boiling it in water so that the bone and gristle can be

removed, has always been known.

If it be admitted that the box or can must be hermet-

ically’sealed in order to be air tight, that was an old de-

vice. The Appert process described in Durand’s English

patent of 1810, required that the vessel (case or box) in

which the food was placed snould be air-tight, and that

has ever since been regarded as indispensable in any pro-

cess for preserving such food as is the subject of contro-

versy here. Before the date of the patent of William J.

Wilson, meat was placed in a package and subjected to

pressure to remove the air, and it is clear any superfluous

moisture was thus 1emoved from the meat. This is shown

in the Marshall patent of 1864, because it is manifest his

description of the process necessarily implies the removal

of the superfluous moisture from the meat, as well as

the removal of the air from the meat, by pressure, and

the hermetical sealing of the box or case in which the

meat is placed for preservation, transportation and _ sale.

De Lignac (1855) submitted meat to a high pressure in

the tin cans in which it was to be preserved, and which,

apparently, were hermetically sealed. Lyman (1869)

roasted his meat before putting it into the box or can, and

ne ne > ieee einen se eaten, deen dhe Te ,

}

|

©

he speaks in his specifications of stewing, doz/ing, or roast-

ing the meat, as being the ordinary mode at that time em-

ployed for preserving meat before packing it in cans.

It will thus be seen that, prior to the issuing of William

J. Wilson’s original patent, in 1874, meat was cooked in

various ways; was subjected to pressure by which the air

and the superfluous moisture was expelled from it, both

before and after it was put in the case or box for preser-

vation, and these boxes or cases were hermetically sealed

in order to make them air-tight.

The evidence seems to show that, at the present time,

in order most surely to preserve meat, it is necessary to

subject the case or can in which the meat is packed to

what is called “ processing,” which we understand to

mean this; there is an opening in the can through which

the meat is introduced; when the can is filled, the hole

is soldered up; it is then subjected to heat, a puncture

made. the air and steam permitted to escape, and then the

puncture also soldered up. This is not a new operation,

but has long been known: in fact, it is substantially de-

scribed in the Durand patent, as a part of the Appert

mode of preserving meat. For although the details here

described are not fully given in the Durand patent, still

they are necessarily implied from the statement that the

aperture 1s left in the vessel until the heat shall have pro-

duced the proper effect. when it is to be closed. In

Appert’s method of preserving animal and vegetable food,

vessels containing it were placed in a boiler filled with

cold water, and then heat was applied up to the boiling

point, and vegetables were to be put into the vessels in a

raw or crude state; animal substances. raw or partly

cooked. The “processing,” as it is termed, is not set

forth in the William J. Wilson patent, unless necessarily

-

implied from the statement that in thus preparing and

packing the meat in an air-tight box or case it is a part

of the operation. All that the patent says is, that after

the meat is put into the box or case and the proper press-

ure is applied, the box or case is then closed air-tight

upon the meat, and if it is also implied that the box, as we

have heretofore assumed, is hermetically sealed, stiil it is:

not stated that it is to be subjected to the “ordinary pro-

cess” in canning. It seems to be conceded that the rea-

sons which rendered this necessary in order to properly

preserve meat or vegetables, were not well known at the

time it was adopted. The theory at present received upon

this subject is, that it is necessary to expel from the can

or case the air, and what are called the germs of fer-

mentation and putrefaction which exist in the air, and

which are destroyed when a high degree of heat is applied,

and the air being thus expelled, before it can re-enter, the

box is made air-tight. These invisible germs, supposed

to be floating in the air, must be killed or removed, or they

will enter into the vegetable or animal substances, and in a

short time produce putrefaction, and,of course,destroy them

as an article of food. ‘There seems to be, therefore, nothing

left in the description of the mode of preserving meat

pointed. out in the patent of William J. Wilson, unless it

is in putting the meat, while warm with cooking, into the

box or case. Can that be said to be patentable as a part

of the mode of. preserving meat, even if it be conceded it

had never been done beforer We think not. No more

than if, prior to the date of the Wilham J. Wilson patent

in order to preserve meat, it had never been put into a

can or case thoroughly cooked. Neither of them seems

to require ingenuity, or the exercise of the inventive fac-

ultv. It is manifest, when we consider what was known

Q

at the date of the William’ J. Wilson patent, that these,

or other methods, could be adopted, of putting the meat

into the case or can for preservation without encroaching

upon the domain of the invention of any one. There can

be no doubt that, within a few years past, the method of

preserving meat adopted by William J. Wilson has

‘caused the article to be extensively used and sold in the

markets of this and other countries. } That argument has

been pressed with great force upon the court in this case.

It may be admitted that in all doubtful cases involving the

validity of a patent, the fact that a mode described in

the patent has gone into extensive use, has and often will,

induce courts to decide in favor of the patent. But

while this is so, courts ought not, merely because of

such use, to sustain a patent. The rights of the public

are to be protected as well as those of individuals, and

a monopoly should not be allowed unless the right to it

is clearly shown. |

But the true explanation of the success which has

attended this and similar modes of preserving meat may

be in the fact, that there has been a tendency in the

public of late years to use all kinds of canned meats and

fruits toa much greater extent than formerly, owing to

the increased care and skill in their preparation and pack-

ing; and we think all William J. Wilson, and those who

act under him can claim, is, that they have been partic-

ularly careful in the selecting, preparing, seasoning,

cooking and canning their meat, by which it has acquired

a high reputation, and upon that, in our opinion, they

must rely, and not upon a monopoly under the patent

law.

The John A. Wilson patent of October 23, 1877, re-

issue number 7.923, 1s for “an improvement in metallic

>

—_

- .

ea PRESSE ECS SER ecb ey Raat ee TDRSS a, St ea OS

Y ;

“cans for containing cooked meats,” ** x “i sk

and, as he describes it, “consists in a pyramidal-shaped

“can having rounded corners, and both ends slightly flar-

“ing to form shoulders against which the head or end

“ pieces rest.” |

> «x * * «A represents the body of my can made

“in the form of a truncated pyramid, with rounded cor-

“ners and of any desired number of sides, though I pre-

| “ fer to make it with four sides.” * * * * «In pack-

“ing cooked meats it is done by the means of a plunger

“ through an aperture in the large head £4, which open-

“ing is afterwards hermetically sealed by means of a cap

“or plate D2.” * * * * «The can is to be opened

‘at the larger end at or near the shoulder a, by means of

‘a suitable can-opener, so that when the can is reversed

‘a slight tap on the smaller head c, will cause the sol-

‘“idly-packed meat to slide out in one piece, so as to be

“readily sliced as desired.”

The claims in controversy here, are the first and _ third:

Ist. “A can for packing food hermetically sealed, and

“constructed of pyramidal form, with rounded corners

‘and offset ends to support the heads, said heads being

‘secured as shown and described.’’

3d. “As an improved article of manufacture, solid

“meat, compressed and secured within a pyramidal case

‘or can, so that said can forms a mould for the meat, and

“permits its discharge as a solid cake, substantially as

< specified.”

‘\

And to these claims, defendants interpose two defenses:

Ist. That the patent is void for want of novelty, so

TO

far “as the two features or claims in: question are con-

“ cerned.”

2d. That defendants do not infringe.

It will be seen that the case or can covered by this

patent must have certain features or characteristics:

tst. It must be of “pyramidal form, with round

“ corners.”

2d. It may have «any number of sides,” although the

patentee “prefers four sides.”

3d. It must have “rounded corners,” and the ends

must be “slightly flaring,” to form shoulders against

which the “ head or end pieces rest.”

There are some further details of construction, such as

the modes of fastening in the heads by turning the flaring

heads of the can inward over the flange of the head, so

as to make three thicknesses of metal, and, as he said,

make a tight joint, “ with or without solder,” and leaving

an aperture or stud hole in the large head, through

which the meat is to be forced, which hole is to be closed

by acap. But as no notice is taken of these in the claims,

we presume they are not considered as of the substance

of the patent.

By a stipulation filed in these cases found on page 942

of defendant’s record, it is admitted that “conical tin

“cans were made and used for canning alimentary sub-

“stances and sealed air-tight prior to the date of the

« Wilson patents that are the subject of controversy in

“ these cases.”

The proof also shows the French patent of one Emile

Peltier was recorded in April. 1859, wherein he describes

#-

s<

II

pyramidal shaped cans for the preservation of food by

hermetically sealing such cans. We may also add to this

from our common knowledge the well known glasses and

molds used by housekeepers in domestic life for preserv-

ing jellies, boned turkey, head cheese, &c., which were all

from the very necessity of the uses to which they were

applied more or less flaring, conical or pyramidal in shape,

and made so, presumably, for the purpose of turning out,

or discharging the contents in a solid cake. If, therefore,

there was occasion at the time this patentee entered the

field of improvement to use a pyramidal or conical

shaped can or case, there was no need to call in the aid

of inventive genius to secure or contrive its construction.

Those who wanted such a can or case had only to take

those forms of cans then in general use, and adapt them

by mere mechanical changes to the purpose for which

they were designed. With these conicai and pyramidal

shaped cans well Known and described in the art of

preserving food, there was not only no room, but abso-

lutely no need for invention in applying them to the pur-

poses of preserving cooked meats. There is nothing in

the proof showing, or tending to show, that cooked meats

require any different shaped cans to contain or preserve

them than do other alimentary substances. The only ad-

vantage gained by this shape suggested in the patent is

that the solidly packed meat can be more compactly turned

out of this form of can in a cake so as to be readily sliced,

but it could be equally well turned out of a conical can.

In fact, a conical or pyramid shape or flaring can would

seem naturally to suggest itself from kindred uses in

domestic life almost as pari of the idea or suggestion of

packing meat solidly in a can for preservation. “To come

within this claim of the patent the can must not only be

ity

pyramidal in shape, but it must have “ rounded corners,”

and “ offset ends to support the heads.” The cans shown

in the proof to have been used by the St. Louis Beef

Canning Company and by Robert D. Hunter e¢/ a/., are

eight-sided, pyramidal shaped cans, that is, they are made

with four narrow sides or panels, and four wider ones,

while those used by the Chicago Packing and Provision

Company are pyramidal shaped cans with rounded cor-

ners. But this peculiarity of construction alone can

hardiy be aeemed the subject matter of a patent. In

making a pyramidal shaped can of sheet metal it is ob-

vious that the corners would be naturally more or less

rounded, unless special pains were taken to avoid that

shape and turn the corners squarely. And with conical

and pyramidal shaped cans, known to the art, it would not

seem to be invention to vary the form of construction by

turning the corners with a curve instead of forcing the

sheet metal forming the shell of the can into an angle

more or less obtuse.

In his specifications describing the mode of construct-

ing his can, this patentee says, “both ends of the body

“are made slightly flaring so as to form shoulders or off

“sets against which the heads are to rest.” Waiving the

question whether this feature of construction in a sheet

metal can could be the subject matter of a patent, it is

sufficient to say that we do noi find this feature in the

cans used by any of the defendants, while the complain-

ants’ cans, put in evidence, show that they do not confine

themselves to this form of construction. All the defend-

ants’ cans which are shown as exhibits in the case are

made by turning a rim of the head down over the out-

side of the body, or shell of the can, and fastening the

head in place with solder, and none of them have the

haf aM

me a, ae EB ie eel a Ba Salas”? le» ena Ge We

NANT SET oe eatoue ge aes. NY

Rig as oP RES Ee

eas i

1 :

13 Ee

| | | “ offset ends,” called for by the specifications of this pat- | —

1 | ent; anc, as we have already said, this seems to be the

form of construction practically adopted by the plain-

| tiffs; probably because all packers find they can make a

| can just as tight and useful and more cheaply by turning

p the head over the outside of the shell than by following the

7 exact description of the patent. But we also find in the

h proof that the cans shown to have been used by Gibbie

| and by Perl as early as 1872, show the offset ends

claimed by this patent. The “ Gibbie ” can has both the

‘ rounded corners ” and “ offset ends,” while the “« Per] ”

can has “ offset ends ” as a distinctive feature of construc-

tion. We have, theretore, conical and pyramidal shaped

cans, and the “ Gibbie.” and “ Perl” cans with flat sides

but rounded corners and offset ends Known and in use long

before this inventor entered the field, and feel compelled

| to reach the conclusion that there was no novelty in the

device of a pyramidal shaped can with rounded corners

and oftset ends as described in this claim.

So that it seems clear to us that the first claim of this

patent must be held void for want of novelty. As to the

third claim, the proof shows that Marshall packed meat

solidly in a can in 1864. He says: “I then subject a given

“ quantity of the meat to pressure in a box or cylinder

« until all air is driven out, and the space occupied by the

“meat agrees with the size of the package it is intended

«to fill, Whenthe meat is in its place the box is hermet-

“ically sealed, and in this state, retaining all its nutritive

“ qualities, the meat will remain perfect as long as the

“ package remains intact.”

1!

So Lyman, in his patent of 1870, describes his process

of packing meats solidly in cans as follows: “1 grind or

+“ otherwise reduce the roughest parts to about the con-

14

“ sistency of thick mortar or putty, and then pack the best

‘“‘ pieces in this reduced meat and press it all into a com-

“pact mass in the can, the interstices being filled with the

“reduced meat firmly pressed in so as to expel the air,

“instead of filling them with the gravy, or with water, as

“by the common modes. Sometimes I grind the whole

‘of the meat and pack the can with it, compressing it

“ into a solid mass, then heat it and seal it up from the air,

“and re-heat it to combine any free oxygen that may

“ possibly be left in the can.”’

Here, we have in both cases, solid meats, and in one

case, cooked meats packed in cans for preservation.

Neither of these patentees tell us the shape of their cans,

but we cannot see how, with conical and pyramidal

shaped cans well known in the art as packages for the

preservation of meats and other food, and the old art of

packing or compressing meats solidly into cans, there can

be any inventions which should be protected by a patent

in taking these well known shaped cans and pressing into

them cooked meat so as to form a solid mass or cake.

The can was old and the meat cake was old.

The result is, that the bill will be dismissed.

NORTHERN DistTrRICT OF ILLINOIS, ss.

I, William H. Bradley, clerk of the Circuit court of the

United States for said northern district of Illinois, do

hereby certify the above and foregoing to be a true and

correct copy of the opinion filed in said court on the 24th

day of February, A. D. 1882, in the cause wherein The

Wilson Packing Company ef a/. are the complainants,

Pig iae e e 3 > ‘4 int ae “| oa’ ~ TP ee te Fa a et ee Pee Nene! Tei ea eR OM BN oh

ooh, os aes BF ae Ta. wy eer, nzsi-$% , oh 8 ge ak 3 . shoe egy 2 ane Te. ops e., xe. are

ack: gee a " Ae hee Pe cae ae. Posen a yi ox oak see See

Pe SO OER POG ene nt, ~ He MS BS ae es LA ME BN ERS IE OD SEE Ng oF: PAS Ad alien A

ia

) 5 a

and The Chicago Packing and Provision Co. e¢ a/. are |

the defendants, as the same appears from the original

thereof now remaining in my custody and control.

In testimony whereof I have hereunto

| set my hand and affixed the seal of said

. | SEAL. | court, at my office in Chicago, in said dis-

trict, this 27th day of February, A. D.

1882.

W.H. Brapwey, Clerh.

{ t

=

RENT MD

}

i

{

A

keel

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

No. 252.

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY, ARTHUR A. LIBBY,

ARCHIBALD McNEILL, AND CHARLES P. LIBBY, APPEL-

LANTS, | 3

VS.

WILLIAM B. CLAPP.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS.

FILED SEPTEMBER 20, 1879.

SUPREME COURIL OF THE UNITED STATES.

No. 252.

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY, ARTHUR A. LIBBY,

ARCHIBALD McNEILL, AND CHARLES P. LIBBY,

LANTS,

VS.

WILLIAM B. CLAPP.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS.

STATES FOR

APPEL-

THE

Original. Print.

INDEX.

Bond for costs......-.- Si Ninna adanlind at ahid Glau Sita < nla diceeak willed asian a Galan 2

ee ae ek ids pewter aonb dont nakees cobennsenoes aaa ee 2

Exhibit B(W. J. Wilson’s patent)..............-. a a 18

ie SE Fee amne cnnden chee dabnvdecend cesees+esaues 20

Te OE BG nono 0 ono on css conn cocces ceccws cece cos ccs cocces cnccee 22

ery i MeN TEE GE CMIRIIEIAING 25.5 oo 5c 6 oon cee n coins cose ceeeee ccwaces- 24

rr i i ae al dence g Ske ae Wa sven nese odabes dadawes 24

Hearing on motion for injunction ...... Pe Sa a VN Ne 99

Order of injunction.............. EELS Oh Se ET OT EN RD 99

Injunction dissolved ; time to answer... ... 02.22. 2... cece cece se ccccce ce 31

ee I IIE. ooo ee cen nwin cseisins seen sacs 2 cas sane cate acce 3

Demurrer to amended bill of complaint .... .... 2... 2... peewee ccc ee coee 31

eee Dicks eA RAE Phkwee sh abe a hedes-owee 3.

a ie Kens bee ROC Kh een de ak + AWed eee dbew eae eee eae « 36

IE ooo ene wrens sewn 06 + owes H 6 teen 8650 cone cence cocece coves De

Robert P. Harlow, of New York, appointed special examiner............- 54

eS I CI io a ones So die ha tbe One ocean cede center suenee 54

ENE, BEIGE ona o 066s wc ees a0 tines ont eS see ces saceee secces cecens covs Do

Stipulation as to letters patent... ...- 2. cece cose cies corccs cccccs ccccces- o@

ee nk NE OO id ccniad namie a een cas Wek sian <a%dennduens 58

Stipulation as to claim of estoppel .... 22.20.02 ccccee cone ccccce cece: vars 58

Costificate of division of Opimion Of COGrE. 6. 6.25 conc cone cccs + ccccce cece ag

SES OE OT ET ER ON Oe Lm rere Ree (ae ae OEE a 6:2

i ie css ish Ake hei Heke OSke onesie Kn snanda ou 63

COMPLAINANTS PROOFS.

Exhibit W. J. Wilson PD hii path enti ke ein meen aeen «20 bo

i i ee ee ee el aie ew aw ae bibaie ene aaeeme UY

“ Bet en ‘ > ~ os Se Bo 4 Bog ee et ra ee eed Mae og . a

SO iT eG ALF ets ee Pe A ROR oy VERE OE te ate FE Re CAF ty ge Se: ae

Re SI Rifles, hc Stick SE Sree PO abies wr iF Sg Se iat alae hele PR 1 NF te Se CPS ES MESES a OE ELS a2 ase os

me a Fe

II , INDEX,

Original. Print.

Exhibit Wa. C. Marshall Patent. .... ...... <<< c.cccccccc coccccccce ccce

een euws euene tunes dudes

Sy BD ae Ke en5e dase cues enes Cceviaes eRe unees

nie ce tviid kedde eee ebne widwhewe@e mene we

NG EE d.nee 6nse 26d0s Bekbes 060666 sane nee ane anes

John Winslow Jones...... 5h isn ag ete cadena Soreh aati

OT ET EE Te eS

ee Gs DGEE onc cocnee cone neni: sles tac tain Aeadiaapaani

on ton Seah circ: Hanae err GINNIE ANN Ne

NN We I 6 vn s ctnwes secees euseee sues sose2senes

rs ni bore seek 4000 Heenee vend eddene nese saw

Nl ies in ow mde CORR HAMORE OSCR wede ee

Ee

ee ddicne ¢twd eter ewe wikde nee wens qaed se

Cyrus Dupee..... ilies ala mania mba nicknaaddnemeret

James P. Smith....... ee ne

CE I Ee ee

is kth dae tence kee enee wiee-anbe ones *

IR Ee Tey

IN REBUTTAL.

Deposition of Samuel W. Allerton............... $000 00seee O60 conweeee

it ek Kee Kee ed cane eOMwe penheténemsuns

Mi ED dt noke daduen caved dons cavees oon dues ssaeuee

ER ne io

ie os cade ae + ene cnn hem wee °

I bie iii cide sesubwe exduaw sider ensdne neds ve

Isaac Waixel ............ Aili ietibincnintt aha drew eae

ace lela i aan wi ein bee Sanne emMewe

ie es linden Ree Ree HR RMON we we

EE TO

Arthur A. Libby...... ee ee ee en

ee NE CIID onc caw ens enedcceenone dooce on

S. Dana Hayes ...<<0 sec ialieh miki abiaibel tii: Laced nen

EE icc dike tkeeks ghedebbedanedeuins

ee NENTS CONNIE TT UOIINS oi ice e ons cine nce sone eddies onde osees

DEFENDANT'S PROOFS.

TE

SEALER BIOL AO ADEE

I i a i a ee ada a

eee ci eke Lee dae Koo cdenenenieeee kameNNem*

ee

ene BOWOMNG.. «6c occcs- ila laa abl ha A ag spina

ls

EL OT NTL TG ERR OE A eT NE

| EEE a Ty TT

De Lignac Patent.............. ihe ganecmdie i ewonek sie wee

74

78

79

Sl

82

83

&5

92

109

112

116

120

122

125

126

127

128

130

131

133

134

136

137

138

139

141

142

144

146

147

(148

149

150

151

157

160:

160

197

208

213

221

236

241

241

251

253

260

266

268

83)

30

30

' 36

OW

oO”

wo

“—

> | ca

S © & & WD OO ¢

ar

a |

> oN

61

‘

INDEX.

ne OD TO Fis iin host ons cerns cdoceecces cece cccceecevons

ee Ss icdicinn nai eNNREHe debe tone Cate enne womens

Exhibits to deposition of William Archdeacon......... peoseseun ond eens

Exhibit Deposition of W. H. Railton.............. pebeitienin telmmrainin ean atone

Crystal Lake Company’s Label......... ane nhee + cone seen donne

Wertheimer’s Specifications .......0 .ccccs ceccce cove osc coc voce ove e eeeces

Granholm’s specifications .... ...2.. eee. eee pnuudeeneesees nae sennqonwenes

Wolney’s specifications .... 2... . 2.20. cece cece oeanece POTTTTTTery e coccce

Appeal bond........-........ drseeeuneseane ¢ pemOOn cone need auence coves

Stipulation as to exhibits.............2.cee- eat men éanweennsons

re an vcticnaecsewes case sone bee cece cece sees eeanne see eens

Ill

Original. Print.

148

149

151

154

161

162

165

170

172

173

173

WILSON PACKING COMPANY ET AL. VS. CLAPP. l

Pleas in the cireuit court of the United States for the northern

district of Illinois, held at the United States court-rooms in the

city of Chicago, in the district aforesaid, before the judges thereot, on

Saturday, the fitth day of July, in the year of our Lord one thousand

: | eight hundred and seventy-nine, and of our Independence the one lun-

; dred and fourth.

l

WILLIAM H. BRADLEY, Clerk.

THE WILSON PACKING COMPANY, ARTHUR )

A. Libby, Archibald MeNeill, and Charles P.

Libby | > Tn chancery.

", |

B. CLAPP. \

WILLIAM

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS, sect:

Be it remembered that on the sixteenth day of November, A.D,

IS77, came the said complainants, by Messrs. Munday and Evarts,

¢ their solicitors, and filed in the office of the clerk of the circuit court of

As the United States for the northern district of Illimois, at Chicago, in

{ the district aforesaid, them bond tor costs and bill of complaint against

4 said defendant in said entitled cause, which said) bond and bill

y are, respectively, in the words and figures following, to wit:

f

I Bond for COStS,

t UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

4 Northern District of Illinois, ss:

Cireuit eourt, October term. A.D. 1S77.

WILSON PACKING COMPANY ET AL. )

v. : fn equity.

Wma. B. CLAPP.

I enter myself security for costs in this cause, and promise to pay all

costs Which may accrue to the opposite party in this action, or to any

- of the officers of this court, and in default of payvinent by the plaintiff

of any costs ordered or adjudged to be paid by them. Thereby agree

and stipulate that execution may issue against my property for amy

costs taxed against them. Dated this 16th day of November, A.D.

ISG.

| J. A. WILSON,

(Endorsed :) Filed Nov. 16,4. D. Ist. Win. TE. Bradley, clerk.

Ps

MA Bill of complaint.

In the United States cireuit court in and for the northern distriet of

Ilinois. In equity.

+ To the honorable the judges of the cireuit court of the United States

e in and for the northern district of Illinois. In chancery sitting.

| 3 The Wilson Packing Company, a corporation created and ex

| isting under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Illinois,

and Arthur A. Libby, Archibald MeNeill, and Charles P. Libby, part:

REc, 202—1

2 WILS)N PACKING COMPANY ET AL. VS. CLAPP.

ners, under the firm name and style of Libby, MeNeil and Libby, citi-

zeus of said State of Ilinois, bring this their bill of complaint against

William B. Clapp, who is a citizen of said State of Hlinois and a resi-

dent of said district.

And thereupon your oretors complain and say that before the sixth

day of April, eighteen hundred and seventy-five, John A. Wilson was

the true, original, and first inventor of certain new and useful lmprove-

ments in sheet-metal cans, not known and used by others betore lis

said invention thereof, and which had not at the time of his application

for a patent therefor been in public use or on sale for a period of two

vears, as your orators verily believe.

And your orators further show unto your honors that said John JA,

Wilson, so being the inventor of said improvement, and being a citizen

of the United States aforesaid, made application to the proper depart-

ment of the Government of the United States for letters patent there-

for, in accordance with the then existing laws of Congress; and he hay-

ing’ duly complied in all respects with the conditions and requisi-

4 tions of said laws, such proceedings were had that on the sixth

day of April, eighteen hundred and seventy-five, letters patent

of the United States forthe said improvement and invention, under the

seal of the Patent Oftice of the United States, signed by the Secretary

of the Interior and countersigned by the Comniissioner of Patents, and

bearing date the day and vear last aforesaid, were issued in due form

of law and delivered to said John A. Wilson, whereby was granted and

secured to him, and his heirs, executors, administrators, or assigns, for

Oa ET:

Pd

—

the term of seventeen years from the day of the date thereof, the full

and exclusive right of making, using, and vending to others to be used

the said improvement and invention, a description whereof is given in

the words of the said inventor in a schedule in writing, accompanied

by drawings and references, thereto duly annexed to said letters patent

When the same were issued, and made a part thereof, as by the said

original ietters patent, or a duly authenticated copy thereof, in ceurt to

be produced, will fully appear

And your orators further show unto vour honors that afterwards the

said John A. Wilson, by and with the consent of your orators, for good

and lawful cause, surrendered said letters patent to the Commissioner

of Patents and duly inade application for a new patent to be issued for !

the same invention, and accompanied such application with a

D corrected description and specification, and with the requisite

drawings, and in all respects complied with the acts of. Congress

In such case made and provided; whereupon, on the twenty-third days

of October, eighteen hundred and seventy-seven, new letters patent for

the same invention last mentioned were, in accordance with law,

duly granted, issued, and delivered to said John A. Wilson for the

residue of said term of seventeen years ; that said last-mentioned let- f

ters patent were Issued in accordance with and in due form of law, un-

der the seal of the Patent Office of the United States, signed by the

Secretary of the 4 ferior and countersigned by the Comiissioner of

Patents, and bear a. te the day and vear last aforesaid, and were desig-

nated as reissue No, 7923, and that there was, by said reissued letters

patent, secured to wale — A. Wilson, his heirs or assigns, for the

residue of said: term of seventeen years from the sixth di Ly of April,

eighteen hundred and se hon ‘five, the full and exclusive right of mak-

Ine, using, and vending to others to be used said original improvement

and invention; that a legal corrected description and specific ation of [

said original improvement and invention contained in said reissued

=

>.

a ae “a ” ge’ Few

4

i j

WILSON PACKING COMPANY ET AL. VS. CLAPP. 3

letters patent is given in the words of said John A, Wilson in a certain

schedule, accompanied by drawings and written references thereto,

Which was in due form of law annexed to said reissued letters

G patent at the time the same were Issued. and made a part thereof,

as-by the said last-mentioned original reissued letters patent, or

a duly authenticaced copy thereof, to be produced as the court shall

direct, will fully appear, a copy of which, without the drawings, is

hereto annexed, forming part of this bill, marked Exhibit A.

And your orators further complain and say that before the thirty-first

day of March, eighteen hundred and seventy-four, William J. Wilson

was the true, origmal, and first inventor of a certain new and useful

improvement in processes for preserving and packing cooked meats, not

known and used by others before his said invention thereot, and which

had not, at the time of his application for a patent therefor, been in

public use or on sale, as your orators verily believe.

And your orators further show unto vour honors that said William

J. Wilson,so being the inventor of said improvement, and being a citi-

zen of the United States aforesaid, made application to the proper de-

partment of the Government of the United States for letters patent

therefor in accordance with the then existing laws of Congress; and he

having duly complied in all respects with the conditions and requisi-

tions of said laws, such proceedings were had that on the thirty-first

day of March, eighteen hundred and seventy-four, letters patent

ri of the United States for the said improvement and invention, under

the seal of the Patent Office of the United States, signed by the

Secretary of the Interior and countersigned by the Comniissioner of

Patents, and bearing date the day and vear last aforesaid, were issued

in due form of law and delivered to said William J. Wilson, whereby

was granted and secured to him, and jus heirs, executors, administra-

tors, or assigus, for the term of seventeen years from the day of the

date thereof, the full and exclusive right of making, using, and vending

to others to be used, the said improvement and invention,a description

whereof is given in the words of the said inventor in a schedule in

writing, accompanied by drawings and references thereto, duly annexed

to said letters patent when the same were Issued, and made a part

thereof, as by the said original letters patent. or a duly authenticated

copy thereof, in court to be produced, will fully appear.

That said William J. Wilson afterwards, and before the second day

of April, A. D. 1875, by aninstrument in writing, conveyed said letters

patent to your orator said Wilson Packing Company, such assignment

being duly recorded in the Patent Office.

And your orators further show unto your honors that afterwards said

William J. Wilson, with the advice and consent of said) Wilson Pack-

ing Company, for good and lawful cause, surrendered said last-men-

tioned letters patent to the Commissioners of Patents and duly

8 made application for a new patent to be issued for the same in-

vention, and accompanied such application with a corrected de-

scription and specification, and with the requisite drawings, and in all

respects complied with the acts of Congress in such case made and

provided ; whereupon, on the sixth day of April, eighteen hundred and

seventy-five, new letters patent for the same invention last mentioned

were, in accordance with law, duly granted, issued, and delivered to

said Wilson Packing Company for the residue of said) term of seven.

teen years ; that said last-mentioned letters patent were issued in ac-

ecordanee with and in due form of law, under the seal of the Patent

Oftice of the United States, signed by the Secretary of the Interior

4 WILSON PACKING COMPANY ET AL. VS. CLAPP.

and countersigned by the Commissioner of Patents, and bear date the

day and year last aforesaid, and were designated as reissue No. 6570 ;

and that there was by said reissued letters patent secured to said Wil-

son Packing Company, its successors or assigus, for the residue of said

term of seventeen years from the 31st day of March, eighteen hundred

and seventy-four, the full and exclusive right of making, using, -and

vending to others to be used said original improvement and invention ;

that a legal corrected description and specification of said original im-

provement and invention contained i

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Record and brief — The Wilson Packing Company, Arthur a Libby, Archibald Mcneill and Charles P. Libby, Appellants, vs. The Chicago Packing and Provision Co., Appellees | Frix