Record and brief — The Records and Briefs of the Supreme Court of the United States 1881-1890: Index
Supreme Court brief1881
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
TO
PART IV
THE RECORDS AND BRIEFS
OF THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
1881-1899
UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT RECORDS AND BRIEFS
Part Four
188L - 1890
Preface
The Records and Briefs contained in Part Four are arranged in a.
sequence which parallels the reporting of the opinions of the Supreme
Court in the Tables of Cases of United States Reports.
The index of Part Four is arranged so that the cases of each volume
in the Records and Briefs are keyed to the pages in the United States
Reports in which these cases appear.
Also, the Records of each case include an internal index, and the
Briefs follow the Records in sequence for each case. Illustrations can be
found at the end of each reel in which they occur, and their locations in
the original text are noted in the film. Some pages in the original docu-
ments were found to be damaged, but such pages form an incalculably small
percentage of the total.
The Records and Briefs of the Supreme Court of the United States were
produced by Scholarly Resources in cooperation with the Jenkins Memorial
Law Library of the Pennsylvania Bar Association. We would like to again
express our thanks to the Jenkins Library for permitting the use of its
set of the Records and Briefs, thus making this important source available
to lawyers and scholars everywhere.
Page l
(A) Reel (B) R & B Volume (C) U.S. Reports Page
acii.. (2884)
78-145
146-183
185 : 376 (14 Otto) 104
ee a. | 104
a6. ei
GaGa
nnn
378 104
379 104
380 104
183-216
216-310
310-356
qa GG
mn Wh
381 | 7 104
382 104
356-386
386-465
1 WN
oe i
, 465-515
515-554
554-618
383 104
384 (104
385 104
aaa
mW WN
386 2a
387 104.
388 104
618-668
668-736
131-169
aaa
mn WN
388 : 104
389 (15 Otte} 6s
390 105
. 7/0-End
. 1-37
41-97
Goa G
On N
— 105
ae 105
» OU
100
eo
On wn
3393 | ee
394 105
395 468
122-189
217-271
. 278-305
ada
Mm wf WH
395 105
396 | 105
aaf suo
398 105
305-328
334-401
- 408-447
451-467
mwMmN Y
ca 4 G
398 Jee
399 105
400 105
468-509
227=559
- 266-576
ceca G
Wn WN
401 105
402 105
266-576
5976-605
1) W
Cc
611-630
636-671
691-703
403 105
404 105
405 105
Cac
mn MN
406 105
—. 105
408 5 Otto) “106
709-739
751-End
Pee (1882)
1 WN W
a QGacG
408 106
409 } 106
410 106
17-47
86-124
142-163
nnn
(A) Reel
(B) R & B Volume
Page 2
U.S. Reports Page
199
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
420
421
422
422
423
424
425
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447]
448
(17 Otto)
U.
U.
U.
U.
166
181-255
260-315
320-371
379-423
429-487
- 505-546
II27 2/4
5976-589
589-623
629-644
644-672
679-End
1-69
69
85-98
102-132
147
147-192
205-325
348-445
454-478
- 485-546
957-586
291-631
636-676
678-End
1-30
32-76
90-132
143-218
» £40°285
292-319
389-462
462-466
© 4141°522
526-End
1-108
110-180
185-229
230-278
285-329
336-341
(1882/83)
(1883)
(B)
R & B Volume
Page 3
448
449
450
451
452
453
453
454
455
455 —
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
(C) U.S. Reports Page
109
LOZ |
109
LO9
109
109
109
109
109
109
110
110
110
110
110
110
bag
110
110
110
110
110
~110
ibe
Lil
Le &
Lik
ae
BG |
lil
iii
rae a
ja a |
Lhd
ab
bid
lil
bid
eos
341-385
398-446
- 477-504
oR Dabo
927-629
633-641
641
650-672
Wa
- 702-End
1-42
47-81
97-119
L31°200
205-229
238-301
304-321
321-368
389-471.
490-574
590
602-651
66 7-End
1-66
83-120
122-176
185-223
228-293
313-358
361-379
3/9~395
400-445
449-479
490-499
505-566
584-676
684
701-768
770
(1883)
(B)
R & B Volume
(C)
Page 4
U.S. Reports Page
482
483
484
484
485
486
487
488
489
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
498
499
500
S01
502
503
504
505
506
207
508
509
510
5 LO
ap me
346
na
514
S15
bm
112
Liz
Lid
Lig
Lae
112
112
Lhe
Lae
Liz
bee.
Li
112
re
Li3
Lig
Ee
113
Lis
ia9
113
Lis
be
ba
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
ge cs
Nn nN
Gace
nnn
aac
nn WN
aaa
Nn N
mM nm WN
ee “
cqcadcd
aaa
nM W
uw
—
ads
mnmwn
aa Cc
NNN
ca
Mm MN WN VY)
aaa
Nn nN
ca 4
mn WN
aa Ga
4
770-End
1-76
(85-123
L4 o> LoV
165-201
20 7"233
238-261
273-344
354-414
423
433-526
330-609
624-670
676-End
1-97
104-157
179-243.
249-310
316-322
322-408
~ 418-542
542-574
585-618
629-689
703-End
1-60
63-105
120-149
158-252
262-340
355-411
417-447
447-488
- 492-576
587-654
663
663
663
(1884)
Page 5
(B) R&B Volume >
(C) U.S. Reports Page
515 114 U.S. 663
516, 114 U.S. 663
516, 114 U.S. 663
Sa a 114 U.S. 663
Sil, 114 U.S. 663
518
eB
520
Pe
S21
i
523
524
322
526
927
927
528
ao
530
«eH
34
eK
534
oF he
222
536
237
538
339
540
541
542
543
544
945
546
547
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
114
115
Lid
L&D
115
115
115
Ai2
LiD
115
me
116
116
116
116
116
Be aS
116
116
116
116
116
116
117
Lig
BAS a
U.S. 665
U.S. 663
U.S. 663
U.S. 665
663
663
663
663
gaacdc
mnN WN
1-56
61-116
133-137
aqaaac
nn Nn
143-151
163-248
260-308
aac
mm wm Ww
321-373
384-469
477-587
aac
Nn WN
600-End
1-54
55-80
co ca G
nn Nn
98-135
438-161
L6o/-219
qaqa c
nN
* ®
MM WY)
a G
289-356
366-418
423-472
474-550
Mm WM Y
Goa Gc
567-642
661-End
1
ieee
m1 WM W
ci ¢
mm WN
227-277]
(1884/85)
(1885)
(B) R & B Volume —
Page 6
548
949
550
550
whe Bs
a be 9
952
ee
954
ee
a os Jo
556
a A:
958
558
I29
560
561
562
563
564
565
565
566
567
567
568
569
570
eg
S14
373
574
ia
376
oe a
978
279
579
580
581
582
(C) U.S. Reports Page
117
117
117
Lay
Lie
117
117
117
Li? Us
117
117
Lat
hat
Ea ie
117
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
118
L418
119
L19
Li9
119
iL?
i19
LL9
Li?
L139
L139
LL9
ils
120
120
aac
aGaaG
nn Nn
Gq ca Gc
MN NM
qaac
NNN N
qaaac
nN NHN
nn Nn
a GQ
OW
aaa
NWN WwW
aac
nn WwW
oS oS
mmnM OW
Cc. XS Se
mn wn
acc
1 WN WN
aSoacG
nNnN
mM WN W
Go. @.G
151-255
271-327.
336-346
346-370
379-406
411-419
419-430
434
434-490
904-519
2b 9-999
567-591
602-648
657-665
665-End
1-46
49-120
127-161
180-211
211-271
279-375
385-389
389-417
425-520
545-596
610-630
634-355
663-End
1-45
47-110
148-226
» £397 296
312-347
355-388
- 401-477
481-530
543-604
608-613
615-625
631-End
1-73
78-97
(1885/86)
(1886)
(B)
R & B Volume
(C)
Page 7
U.S. Reports Page
982
983
584
985
586
987
588
pee
390
oe
592
a
594
594
292
596
oA
598
eb
~ 600
601
— 602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
oll
612
612
612
613
6i3
614
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
hae
a
igs
Lie &
Led
121
Lak
L2i
121
Lee
Las
Let
121
Lei
Lge
L2e
Lee
122
Lae
Lé2a
Léa
by.
Lad
Léa
123
Le
123
U
U
U
U
gc a G4
Ga
goa 4 a G 260 i sa aac aa G
co G
a G&G G
addqad
mnwnWN YW
aac
mW W
mW WN
&
nnn MN
$ .
* &
nw
9
mM W
( YW
~ UW)
Mm YW) YW
mW WN
mnwWn WN
é
mM nN
9/=129
130-169
183-268
271
2la~23
Sawai
390
» 412-464
uo
479-534
556-630
649 |
678-End
L@27
27
67-102
iZi7i/9
182-215
. 230-284
286-310
325-383
388-421
430-469
- 474-558
215-637
to? se
24-121
132-197
911-220
326-413
432-501
518-543
Ifo~762/
627-640
640-End
1-59
61-186
189-249
(1886)
_(B)
R & B Volume
Page 8
615
616
616
617
618
618
619
620
621
621
622.
623
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
639
640
641
(c).6 Oh US a Reports Page
123
123
123
123
Las
123
123
123
123
123
123
123
123
124
124
124
124
124
124
124
124
124
122
Lé9
Lao
22
Lao
L2>
ied
ia
Leo
4
267
276-297
297
307
349° 369
369-376
392-443
349-34!
952-562
572-608
617-679
681-739
739-End
1-86
98-167
L69<225
261-351
360-394
400-510
515-581
601-652
656-End
1-98
109-128
136
161-240
2477-260
443
309-337
331~“307
426-614
618-End
(1887)
(1887)
642 A 146 U.S.
642 B 126 U.S.
(Telephone Cases )
( Telephone Cases _)
642 C i426 U.S.
~—642 ~«+D i126 U.S.
( Telephone Cases _ )
( Telephone Cases
Page 9
(C) U.S. Reports Page |
BBS
BBS
qaaaa
nnn N
aq da &
mn WN W
qa ada. 4
nnn on
1 (Telephone Cases)
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
(American Bell
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
Tel.
#1)
#2 )
#3)
#4)
#5)
#6)
# 7.)
#8)
#9 )
#10)
#11)
#12)
#13)
#1 4)
#15)
#16)
#17)
(American Bell Tel. #18)
(American Bell Tel. #19)
aeaqaaaaaa
NANNNnNNnNNMN NW
BEER EERE
1-58 (1887)
63-133
136-205 ~
U.S
U.S.
U.S
210-216
235-326
338-390
396-438
Gaac
1 WN WN W
438-457
457-518
932-563
972-622
® #
"Mm WNW VY
2a G4
622-640
649-731
780-End
nm WN W
aac
1-135
158-195
MM YW
a G
195
212-289
315-416
426-446
aqc G4
mw WN YU
» 493-503
206-557
560-578
Gace
nN Ww
(B)
R & B Volume
Page 10
660
661
662
663
664
665
665
666
667
668
668
669
670
671
672
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
682
683
684
New
New.
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
Orleans
Orleans
Orleans
Orleans
Orleans
Orleans
Orleans
Gaines
. Gaines
Gaines
Gaines
Gaines
Gaines
Gaines
Orleans v. Gaines
Orleans v. Gaines
7
Index
Addenda
(C) U.S. Reports Page
128
128
128
129
La?
L297
Lao
129
Lav
129
129
129
129
129
129
129
130
130
130°
130
130
130
130
130
130
a 34
ia.
131
3s
131
13}
131
131
34
131
Lae
i31
Ss
qc a4 a Gc qa ac aac
qa G
ac G a a Gc CG a Ga qc 4a G a G
Coa G
aac
mW WN
NnNNDN
cc
UW YW
aa
mn MN TM W
. to-
mW WN
mn WN
1) WM VY)
mW WN
@
Mm WM W
mn Yn
mn Nn
AWN WN
e
+
584-598
617-667
673-End
1-4/
52-128
141-178
178-206
2is~-29l
294-305
315
315-366
/~ 372-465
470-512
230-590
601
601-End
1-69 —
80-117
122-227
229-320
327-416
426-456
472-505
520-630
637-End
1-22
40-75
88-151
159-227
LOL
LOL
191
LOL
LOL
LOL
LOL
191
191
(1888)
(1888)
(B) R & B Volume
Page ll
Reports Page
684
685
686
687
688
689
689
690
691
692
693 —
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
702
703
704
705
706
707
7107
708
709
710
eG!
ae ee}
712
133
714
714
yp RS
716
aac
Wn Nn
aac
Nn Nn
ccc
mW W
WN
ac
aaa
nm WN W
aac
nn WN
ac
OW
ee
S
U
U.
aac
nn N
fa WM YW
oC 4 4
cd ¢
MM WN
adc
mM MN
mM WN YQ
aaa ec
aac
Nn N
227-287
. 293-352 -
371-405
428-441
442-End
1-21
47 39
20=75
84-107
118-190
191-192
19 /=239
252-304
313-406
415-478
487-565
571
592-662
69 3-End.
1-49
50
50-92
107-186
193-273
290-360
370-473
496
496-541
5953-626
655-End
1-110
117-176
178-206
230-276
291-351
361-381
388
398-467
483-500
(1888/89)
(1889)
(1889) _
(B) R & B Volume
Page 12
Reports Page
717
718
719
720
144
146
bs ae
7124
725
726
tat:
728
728
728
189
730
tae
731
732
tae
732
134
732
tae
734
432
736
13af
738
439
740
741
742
742
743
744
745
746
747
A
A
aqadacd
aac.
Mm WM WN
aac
Nn WN
Se
(1 WN
» ees ae
mnNn WN
: ®
aac
nnn
aa
mn N
cc
m1 WM
2:
wm WN
Gc Cc
WN Ww
daa
mn WN
da
Mm MN NM
aac
nn NW
914-547
959-650
688-End
1-161
167-176
195-244
255-326
342-449
457-478
492-576
584-End
1-88
89
. SF
104-152
211-257
257-313
330-356
386-468
479-586
629-636
639-646
646-653
L736
60-98
LL3—1 74
~ 202-300
310-386
395-457
458-576
579-End
1-109
114-124
196
223-298
306-380
389-414
425-483
486-509
(1889)
(1890)
Page 13
(B) R & B Volume
Reports Page
747
748
749
909-514
929°9/3
987-617
aa
mW WN
749 oe 623
750 635-End
750 1-18
751 19-118
752 128-136
qaaaac
NNnNNnNNN
752
t22
7354
136-176
19/-2/8
400-557
aac
nnn
7oo.
756
131
342
378-462
469-540
CC
nm WN WM
cq 4
758
tay
760
549-621
624-End
1-47
ca
WN WN
760
761
762
763
48-49
32-71
76<151
160-180
qoaaac
NnNnN
763
764
765
766
183-184
. 199-298
304-344
360-453
mnn Nn
Sc 2a 4
767
768
769
481
493-565
575-634
aad
mW WN
+
# /
770
eg
654-687
688-694
oe
M Ww
tté
694-End
a
ep.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.