Record and brief — The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, Plaintiff in Error, vs. The Village of Hyde Park, Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, L. G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, L. Bradner, and H. Vanderbilt, Trustees of Said Village. 1878: V

Supreme Court brief1878

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

7 Cla f 019

BA. 7.1040

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

No. Mir FZ S

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF

IN ERROR,

V8.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK, CHAUNCEY M. CADY, W.-E.

HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L. G. FISHER, E. G. CLARKE, M.

DOYLE, J. M. BARNEY, L. BRADNER, AND H. VANDERBILT,

TRUSTEES OF SALD VILLAGE.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS.

FILED NOVEMBER 27, 1874.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

No. 245.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF

IN ERROR,

VS.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK, CHAUNCEY M. CADY, W. E.

HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L. G. FISHER, E. G. CLARKE, M.

DOYLE, J. M. BARNEY, L. BRADNER, AND H. VANDERBILT,

TRUSTEES OF SAID VILLAGE.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS.

Bill of complaint

Exhibit A

BROWEE 0000 cc cccs coccces cco. c0ce cncces onccce seceee oneces sees osee sees °

Supplemental answer

Bill of exceptions

Clerk’s certificate

Opinion of supreme court

Decree of supreme court

Clerk’s certificate

Assignment of errors

Petition for writ of error

Writ of error

SNE ho.nc cons cccdcs 06004000 060s ends 00bs bandas eehedeeanee .

ali

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 1

a At a supreme court begun and held at Ottawa, on Tuesday

the ninth day of September, in the year of our Lord one thou-

sand eight hundred and seventy-three, within and for the northern grand

division of the State of Lllinois :

Present: Sidney Breese, chief-justice ; Pinkney H. Walker, justice;

John M. Scott, justice; W. K. McAllister, justice ; Benjamin R. Sheldon,

justice; Johu Scholfield, justice; Alfred M. Craig, justice.

Appeal from the circuit court of Cook County.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY

v8. No. 457.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

b Be it remembered that heretofore, to wit, on the tenth day of

September, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred

seventy-three, came the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, appellant

herein, by Sweat and Herrick, its attorneys, and filed in the supreme

_ court its certain transcript of record and proceedings in the circuit

court of Cook County, State of Illinois; which is in the words and figures

following, to wit:

c STATE OF ILLINOIS,

Cook County :

Uv

THE NORTWESTERN FERTILIZING re

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

It is hereby stipulated that the following contains a true copy of the

record in the above cause, so far as the same becomes material for its

consideration by the appellate court.

LEONARD SWETT,

Solicitor for Complainant.

CHAS. HITCHCOUK,

Solicitor for Respondents.

CHICAGO, August, 1873.

1 Be it remembered that heretofore, to wit, on the 11th day of

January, A. D. 1873, the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, by

Bentley, Swett & Quigg, its solicitors, filed in said court its certain bill

of complaint, in the words and figures following, to wit:

In the circuit court, Januar; term, A. D. 1873.

STATE OF ILLINOIS,

Cook County:

To the honorable judges of the circuit court of Cook County, in chan-

cery sitting.

The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, a corporation created by

and organized under, the laws of the State of Illinois, and located and

transacting business in Cook County, in said State, brings this its bill

of complaint against the village of Hyde Park, a municipal corpora-

tion, also created by and organized under the laws of the State of Lli-

nois, and C. M. Cady, a trustee and president of the board of trustees

REc. 245—1

Fes a ee ee

2 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

of said village, and W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, S. G. Fisher, E. G.

Clarke, M. Doyle, J. F. Barney, L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbilt,

trustees of said village.

Whereupon the complainant savs:

SUMMARY OF THE CHARTER.—On the eighth day of March, A. D.

1867, an act was passed by the legislature of the State of Illinois, and

became a law, by which, among other things, Christian Wahl, Louis

Wahl, and John A. Lighthall, and their successors, associates, and

assigns, were constituted and appointed a body corporate and

2 politic, with power of continued succession, for the term of fifty

years, by the name of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, and

empowered by that name to contract and be contracted with, sue and

be sued as a natural person, to have and use a common seal, and the

right to purchase and hold sufficient real-estate for the free enjoyment

ot all the privileges granted, and to make by-laws and rules for the gov-

ernment of said corporation.

The act also provided that the capital stock of the company should be

fifty thousand dollars, with power to increase the same to any sum not

exceeding two hundred and fifty thousand.

It also provided that the incorporators named might, any time after

the passage of the act, organize said company upon stock being sub-

scribed to the amount of fifty thousand dollars, issue certificates, and

elect officers created by the by-laws, and that said officers should hold

their offices for the period prescribed.

CHARACTER OF THE WORKS.—The corporation was also authorized

and empowered to establish and maintain chemical and other works at

the place designated, for the purpose of manufacturing and converting

dead animals and other animal matter into an agricultaral fertilizer and

other chemical products, by means of chemical, mechanical, and other

processes.

The charter also provided that said chemical works should be located

in Cook County, Illinois, south of the dividing-line between townships

thirty-seven and thirty-eight, and that the corporation might maintain

depots in the city of Chicago, in said county, for the purpose of

3 receiving and carrying off any and all offal, dead animals, and ani-

mal matter which it might buy or own, or which might be deliv-

ered to it by the city authorities and other persons, and that the act

creating these corporate rights and privileges should take effect and be

in force from and after its passage.

THE SLAUGHTERING AND THE OFFAL.—The complainant craves leave

to refer to the said act of incorporation as a part of this its bill of com-

plaint, with the same benefit as if it had been herein set forth at length.

A copy of the said act is hereunto attached, marked “ Exhibit A.”

The complainant would also say that since the introduction of rail-

road transportation to the Atlantic cities and the region east of the Al-

leghanies, the city of Chicago has been rapidly becoming, and has now

become, in reference to the slaughtering and packing of animals for

human consumption, the largest market in the world. It receives more

largely than any other city the snrplus productions of animals from

Minnesota to the Rio Grande, and west to the Rocky Mountains. Since

1850 the rapid growth and development of the country west, northwest,

and southwest has increased this business with marvelous rapidity.

The age me of animals slaughtered in Chicago between Jan. 1, 1872,

and Jan. 1, 1873, the complainant is informed by the official Union

Stock Yards reports, and believes, is as follows:

N. W. FERTILIZING CoO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 3

Hogs alaughtered .. 2... coc cc sccccc ces ccevcese iSiect nn 1, 417, 029

Cattle - ees cou dbs un - hee oe 500060 beeG renee 174, 050

Sheep DV gee ee eee as aes 6 ddneeneee ep rE 165, 099

1, 756, 178

4 The amount of offal and blood which the slaughtering of these

animals produces borders on the horrible.

ZO CREGMS-ONeOE 1B. 2. 0c cecenc cacccese+svetuaben 647,500 gallons.

Hogs os o 00608 ces neewun: SkOSepes enehes 1, 500, 000 “

Sheep DL yeeetr ine tne eeen sae ae eee 58, 333 “

i eh ad eae eerie oe ecseccncs ae

Cattle-tank offal .......... ésmee hha ko ceeeene 4,675 tons.

Hog RD ge nesee raed 4046eun been ee 15,000 *

ee SF libs ones cannbswakeeesaea eee 1,500 *

BOGE a ccncecctsatttenssehnapesnnoeaue 21,175 tons.

The offal included in the above statement is the heads, livers, lungs,

lights, entrails, and other trimmings of the animal. These parts, as

soon as separated, are rendered in tanks at the slaughter-houses, by the

application of steam to extract the grease, and the residuum is ealled

tank-offal. The blood is not utilized by the packers. This gives as a

refuse or discharge from the packing-houses 21,175 tons of tank-offal

and 2,205,833 gallons of blood every year, consisting of materials which,

until recently, considered in such immense quantities, were valueless,

and in reference to which, as yet, the only object of the packers is to

get rid of it.

This business, as complainant is informed and believes, employs di-

rectly in slaughtering and handling the animals in the city and at the

Union Stock Yards, about three miles therefrom, some five thousand

men; about twenty thousand are engaged in industries dependent upon

it; and it supports in and around Chicago not less than 100,000 people.

It is the largest interest in the city.

5 LOCAL DIFFICULTIES.—AsS bearing upon the question of public

policy and necessity in construing its act of incorporation, the

complainant also would show that there are local difficulties attending

the disposal of this offal in Chicago, growing out of its geographical .

and topographical location. At St. Louis, Council Bluffs, Dubuque,

Burlington, Peoria, Cincinnati, in the West; and Allentown, Gordons-

ville, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Richmond, in the East; all have

large and rapidly-flowing rivers, and by the location of their slaughter-

houses upon the margins of such rivers, below the city, the difficulty is

at once solved. New York and Boston have the ocean, whose waters

are too vast to be corrupted, and tend to purify whatever they receive.

Chicago is absolutely without natural drainage.

The difficulty here is also enhanced by the suddenness with which

this material is produced and accumulates. The packing-season com-

mences the lst of November and ends the first day of March. Dur-

ing that time, of hogs alone, about 12,000 are slaughtered daily.

This, with the other slaughtering during the packing-season, produces,

every working-day between the first of November and the first day of

March, substantially 13533 tons of tank-offal and 14,697,3, gallons of

blood. Thus the sacrifice at the great Temple’s dedication was little

more than a common day’s work of our constant sacrifice to the re-

morseless appetites of modern times.

a 5 Pe ee a

4 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

It is self-evident that this material cannot be deposited upon the sur-

face of the ground to decay in the sun. It is so enormous and bulky

it cannot be buried, and even if it could, the earth would not hold the

noxious gases it would generate. It cannot be cast into the Chi-

6 cago River or the lake, and nothing remains but to convert it

into agricultural fertilizers and other chemicals, thus utilizing

and consuming it, or to drive the packing-interest from the city.

The history of the difficulties heretofore enumerated demonstrate this

conclusion.

GROWTH OF THE PACKING BUSINESS.—In the infancy of this busi-

ness, the quantity, being small, was buried and otherwise properly dis-

pused of with ease, but in time the business and the amount ot offal

increased, until neither the water nor the earth could hide it.

The following is a summary, showing the growth of the packing busi-

ness in Chicago:

Cattle slaughtered for city consumption and packed within the last sixteen

years.

i iiibired wikhcunidceds | eos e 157, 107

hai hiatal pia RE ERS Pane Eres eer 90, 596

Tih delintipiaiinn 74,006 | 1866.......... iinet 130, 454

Sa eee 54,601 | 1867 ........... a

ee ee» 51,631 | 1868...... k eieaeeee ais 108, 547

Se Et I beens on curing weenie 108, 385

a eee $0 twa hae EE 7 EE ha sihsin-nin ems Oxmeenes 141, 255

DEE <0: 66s seéwee pie bees SD | OE os wine bene sews we 141, 12.

Hogs packed in Chicago during the last twenty-one years.

1851-2........ PT Te re 22, G36 | 1868-3 2... occ cccece 970, 264

SI Cis ks Ski ces) és 44,156 | 1863-4 ........ wee... = 904, 659

ae .a kbs sGa bes 52,849 | 1864-5 ........ iichigs 760, 514

ee BEE Rees eww ies 13, 994 | 1865-6 .......... cose «=. OO, BDO

1855-6 ........... eee ce RED ft WR bs veces cindy 639, 332

0 Ee 74,000 | BOBTHR 2a... cece ccc 796, 226

Wie es cabbies ess sss 00, 902 | 2008-8 .........0...- 617, 558

1858-9..... p wake cade ones 179, 684. 1869-70.......... .... 635, 959

oat SEE ELE beeees macsint Linu Wocece.tygame METER 988, O87

A. Nes pee cbd Go oes OU5, GOL | 1871-2 .............- 1,225, 236

7 THE CHIcAGoO RIvER.—The slaughtering and packing houses

are generally located upon the Chicago River and its north and

south branches. These branches dow from northerly and southerly

directions and unite within the city, thus forming one main stream,

which flows through the central part of the city into the lake. The river

is muddy, the current sluggish, and its mouth at the margin of the lake,

upon a north and south line, is in the most populous part of the city.

As the offal and blood increased beyond the capacity of the packers for

its easy disposition, it found its way into the river, making it offensive

beyond description and beyond comprehension, except to those who re-

member it. So much as was not thus disposed of was deposited upon

the prairie everywhere, west, northwest, and southwest of the city, and

not very distant from it.

THE WATER-WORKS AND THE WIND.—The city water-works were

located near the mouth of the river, drawing their supply for family con-

sumption from the margin ot the lake. Three thousand six hundred

ceiieeaee

=

~

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 565

and thirty-six observations, taken at regular intervals during the last

five years, show that the wind blew from the east, northeast, and south-

east thirteen hundred and fifteen times. The shore-line of the city is so

situate that all of these winds strengthen the natural current of the lake

towards the shore, and blow the waters of the river back upon its mouth

and the adjacent shore-line. Out of the same number of observations

within the same time the wind blew trom the west, northwest, and south-

west eighteen hundred and thirty-two times. The city is so located that

all of these westerly winds blew the noxious gases generated by

8 the offal deposited upon the prairie into the city. Thus more than

five-sixths of the time the wind either blew the putrid waters of

the river back upon the margin of the lake to be pumped into the reser-

voirs and thence to be drunk in the tea and coffee or from the drinking-

cups of the citizens, or the city was filled with the breath of the pesti-

lence from the west, leaving about one day in a week as a kind of Sab-

bath to recuperate on a square breath either from the north or the south,

which did not bring the putrefactions in the air or the water. These

facts made Chicage the natural ally of disease. The pestilence came

here first and staid the longest.

THE LAKE.—The complainant also says that this offal could not then

and cannot now be taken out in barges and deposited in the lake, as in

New York and Boston, because most of it is produced in the winter, when

the lake is frozen; and, besides, there is a strong current towards the

shore where Chicagois located, which brings even soil from more northern

regions, and, depositing it upon the shore, forms aceretious of land in

front of the city several feet each year. In the ocean the salt water

arrests decomposition, and its turbulence and the tides scatter the offal

every Where, and the fishes devour it. Here the water is fresh and gen-

eraliv calm, with no tide, and the fish are wholly inadequate to the

lunch. As soon as decomposition commences, the offal rises to the sur-

tace, even if it sinks at first, so that 2,000,000 gallons of blood, deposited

in the lake at Chicago, with a never-varying current towards the shore,

would make the basin of the lake bloodier than the waters of Egypt,

aud 21,000 tons of offal would give its margin a fringe of rotten heads,

legs, livers, entrails, and lights.

9 THE SOLUTION —Under these circumstances, the proper solu-

tion of this difficulty became of vital importance, not only to

the city and the State, but to so much of the adjacent country as

found a market at Chicago for its animal productions. It was solved

in the following manner: The State agreeing ultimately to take the im-

provement and pay the expense, the city advanced about $3,000,000

to deepen the Illinois and Michigan Canal, so as to turn the Chicago

River up stream and form a current from the lake through it and the

canal to the [Illinois and Mississippi Rivers.

The city also, at an expense of more than $2,000,000, extended a tun-

nel under the bottom and two miles out into the deep water of the

lake, that it might have a supply of water cooler than from the rock

and absolutely tree from impurities; and the legislature chartered the

Northwestern Fertilizing Company, authorizing it for the period of fifty

vears thereafter to utilize and consume the offal and blood and dead

animals accumulating in the city, provided it would fix the location of

its works at a point in Cook County south of the dividing line between

townships thirty-seven and thirty-eight.

CHARTERED RIGHTS.—Your orator claims, as a matter of law, that

having become duly organized under said charter, and having invested

the full sum of €250,000 in the business especially authorized, and hav-

6 N. W. FERTILIZING CO VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

ing enlarged its works so to be able to take off, utilize, and consume in

a manner the most scientific now known, and with the least possible of-

fensiveness to the public, all the offal, blood, and animal matter the city

produces, it now has a vested right, subject to reasonable and

10 proper police regulations, to carry on said business for the period

of time named in the charter.

POLICK POWERS.—The complainant concedes its duty to handle said

animal matter in a skillful and scientific manner, and so as not to be

unnecessarily offensive to the sight or the senses, and to introduce into its

establishment the most approved of the tested and accepted processes

and machinery. Upon this point it avers that, from the date of the or-

ganization of said company until the time of the filing of this bill of

complaint, it has not only on all occasions handled the material prop-

erly, according to the methods known, so as not to be unnecessarily of-

fensive, and introduced as fast as they have been tested and accepted all

the improvements known in that business, but, that this question might

be successfully solved, it has until last year expended all its profits and

part of its capital in making and testing improvements and in throwing

away old machinery and getting new, and that it now has an establish-

ment the largest and, considering the magnitude of it, the most im-

proved and the best in the world. Your orator also claims that, having

complied voluntarily with all the requirements which proper police reg-

ulations could legally exact, it is not only entitled to prosecute its busi-

ness for the period named, but is entitled to do it in peace.

In order that your honors may understand what might be reasonably

required by way of care in handling the material, and the improvements

in machinery which' might be demanded, the following tacts are set

forth in reference to the character of the business permitted by the char-

ter, how it is done, what improvements have been made, to what

11 degree the obstacles have been overcome, and the extent to

which those remaining may reasonably be expected to be over-

come in the future.

THE BUSINESS BEFORE THE CHARTER WAS GRANTED.—In the year

A. D. 1865, the firm of Wahl Bros. & Lighthall, having been for many

years engaged in the manufacture of glue from the hoofs and other parts

of slaughtered animals, were induced by the packers, as a mode of re-

lieving them and the city from the accumulating mass of offal, to engage

in the business of converting it into an agricultural fertilizer at the place

where the works of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company are now sit-

uated. They were the first in the city to engage iy this business. Little

was then known of the manner in which such business should be ear-

ried on, and no machinery was in use or was known.

PROCESS OF MANUFACTURE.—The process of manufacturing fertil-

izers trom offal consists in vaporizing the water from the animal matter,

and obtaining a dry residuum, not offensive nor liable to immediate de-

composition, which contains ammonia. This residuum being placed upon

the ground and plowed or harrowed in becomes a fertilizer. The am-

monia produced from the flesh and blood and phosphate of lime pro-

duced from the bones etiriches and strengthens the land, and the dry

animal residuum placed in the ground itself decays and fructifies the

soil. The greater the quantity of animal residuum produced and the

less the amount of decomposition which takes during the process, the

greater will be the quantity of residuum and the percentage of anmonia

it will contain and the greater the value of the product. On the

12 contrary, the greater the amount of decomposition, the greater

the loss of ammonia and animal residuum, and the greater will be

the offensive smell produced.

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 7

FORMER PROCESS.—At the time said Wahl Bros. and Lighthall com-

menced this business in 1865, the only process known was to receive the

material in the winterand pile it up, and spread itout in thespring to dry

it in the air and the sun. This process would, in the end, vaporize and

expel the water and produce a dry residuum which contained some am-

monia, but the process also produced decomposition, by which the ani-

mal residuum and the percentage of ammonia it should contain were

both diminished.

THE TWO COMPARED.—The result of the process was that about

thirty per cent. of organic residuum was obtained, containing about

three per cent. of ammonia. By the process and machinery now used

by the complainant sixty per cent. of dry organic matter is produced,

which contains eight or nine per cent. of ammonia. The ammonia and

the animal matter lost by decomposition is what constitutes the offen-

sive smell, and the effect of the improved process is that thirty per cent.

of the animal matter and five or six per cent. of ammonia is saved which

formerly passed into the air and annoyed the public. This comparison

of the processes and the result refers to animal matter without bone,

and after thirty per cent. of water has been added to it by a steam pro-

cess of rendering at the packing-houses for the purpose of extracting

the grease. The animal matter as received by your orator from the

tanks contains on an average about nine per cent. of ammonia, and by

its process only about one per cent. is lost.

13 Between 1865, when this business was commenced, and 1867,

the date of the act of incorporation, Wahl Bros. & Lighthall carried

on said business as above described, spreading the material out upon

the ground or a platform, and saving what failed to decompose. They

also established platforms in the city for the reception of offal, and took

it out through the town of Hyde Park by way of the Pittsburgh & Ft.

Wayne Railroad to the place where the complainant now carries on the

same business. From 1865 to 1867 a large portion of the offal of the pack-

ing and slaughtering business found an outlet in this manner, and in order

that said business might not be interfered with or broken up, and that

it might be enlarged and improved by the introduction into it of suf-

ficient capital, and from public uecessity arising from the facts in refer-

ence to the packing-business previously stated, the legislature, in 1367,

chartered the business as it then existed, and authorized, under the pro-

tection of that charter, the investment of two hundred and fifty thou-

sand dollars in ic.

CORPORATE ORGANIZATION.—After the passage of said charter, to

wit, on the thirteenth day of December, 1867, the corporate organization

therein contemplated was lawfully perfected by a meeting of a majority

of the incorporators, the subscription of stock to the amount of $50,000,

the adoption of by-laws, the election of officers, and the performance ot

all the other acts named in the charter by said incorporators to be per-

formed. Said $50,000 subseribed was actually paid, and thereafter, to

wit, on the day of , the capital stock was increased to the sum

of ¥250,009, all of which has also been paid in and invested in said

14 business. Prior to the organization of the corporation, said Wahl

Bros. & Lighthall had invested in land, buildings, and improve-

ments, about $45,000. These were purchased by the complainants and

made the bases of the present works. Since then the complainant has

enlarged the buildings, bought machinery, perfected inventions, and im-

proved the process. As a result of these improvements, of ammonia,

one of the offensive elements, it saves two hundred per cent. more, and

of animal matter one hundred per cent. more, than was saved at first;

8 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

or, in other words, by its improved processes and machinery now, when

it utilizes and consumes nine-tenths of all the offal and blood which the

city produces, it does it with very much less than one-half the offensive

odor that the business produced when it was legalized and permitted by

the charter.

IMPROVEMENTS.—Your orator would further show, as some of the

items of expenditure to enable it to handle properly and utilize the

material, it has bought, for the sum of fifteen thousand dollars, includ-

ing the improvements since put upon it, four acres of ground for a depot

at the Union Stock Yards, about three miles from the city. The object

of this purchase was to fix thé depot outside the ity, and where it would

_be the least annoyance. Tothis depot, in tight box-wagons, the offal and

blood is hanled the same day it is ready for delivery trom the packing

and slaughter houses. At the depot it is loaded into tight box-cars

made expressly for this business. Each day, as a rule, except as to the

interruption of the village of Hyde Park, as hereinafter named, the

depot is cleaned up.

15 At the establishment twelve contiguous acres have been added

to what was purchased by Wahl Bros. & Lighthall. Additional

side-tracks, sufficient to handle the material with convenience, have been

put in, the buildings have been enlarged, aud the complainant has spent

more than $100,000 in erection and changes of building, improved proc-

esses, changes of machinery, experiments, and employment of the lead-

ing chemists of the country, in order to ascertain the best method

possible in which to prosecute this business.

Complainants and its stockholders have also obtained five patents for

improvements in their drying-machinery. This machinery, as com-

plainant is informed and believes, is now the best and reduces the

material with the greatest economy of any now in use. It may be de-

scribed as follows: A revolving cylinder, thirty feet long and thirty-six

inches in diameter, is arranged horizontally, with a revolving shatt pass-

ing through the center of it. Rakes or teeth are attached to the shaft,

and so arranged as to keep the material in constant motien and move it

along from the end in which it is introduced towards the opposite or

discharging end. The whole is so constructed and moved that while

the cylinder revolves once the interior shaft revolves twice at the same

time.

At the same end at which the matter is put into the eylinder is a

smoke-stack, with a communication between that end of the cylinder

and the stack. The cylinder is also enclosed on all sides by a brick wall.

Within this exterior wall, four coal-fires within two feet of the cylinder

are kept burning. These fires are so regulated as to envelop and apply

to the eylinder a mild and uniform heat. The brick wall, within

16 which the heated air is contained, confines the heat, and the dis-

charging end of the eylinder being open, and the matter within

the eylinder so introduced and moved as to give a draft through it, the

heated air passes into the discharging end, permeates and passes through

the animal matter within the cylinder, and thence through the smoke-

stack tothe air. A diagram ot the dryer described is hereunto attached,

marked * Exhibit B.” It is correct, except that sinee it was made the

machine has been so improved as to have four fires under it, instead of

two, as represented, and a tew other changes have also been made. The

object of the change in the number of fires 1s to give greater uniformity

to the heat.

Before the complainant commenced business under its aet of ineorpo-

ration, no blood had been utilized at Chicago upou any seale approxi-

lle od as

——

OR A te nn

ein a Seal

ES et eke ae anil oak

—

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 9

mating the need. The complainant now not only consumes substan-

tially all that is produced, but has succeeded in overcoming the obsta-

cles, and does it without creating any material offensive odor.

As itis taken from the slaughter-houses, three hundred pounds of

acid to the dry ton is mixed with it at the depot at the stock-yards.

This is done before decomposition commences. The acid coagulates the

blood and expels a large part of the water, leaving it a hard gelatinous

mass. When it arrives at the works it is passed through the machine

described, the water remaining is vaporized, and a residuum obtained

containing substantially all the ammonia it contained when fresh from

the animal. The amount of ammonia in blood is fourteen parts. Com-

plainant gets within a fraction of it.

17 The tank offal is rendered at the packing-houses in tanks by the

application of steam. When this offal comes from the animal, it

contains about fifty parts of watery matter. When it comes from the

tanks the matter is like a pulp or ajelly, and contains about thirty parts

more of water than naturally. The application of the steam in the tanks

hastens putrefaction. As soon as this material is received by the com-

plainant, it is taken to the factory and either dried immediately or

proper chemicals are immediately applied to it, by which decomposition

is arrested and prevented. Under the old process of exposing it to the

sun and the air, decomposition continued. Under the present process,

it is arrested, and, being introduced into the revolving cylinder described,

in five minutes it passes through it and becomes a fertilizer. If the ma-

terial was fresh when put into the cylinder, 10 more offensive odor

would arise trom the process than from the roasting of a piece of meat.

As it is, the only odor which arises is from vaporizing and expelling the

watery matter which has become tainted in the rendering. The only

thing remaining to make the process as it now is substantially odorless

is to condense the steam and burn the gases which may have been gen-

erated. This the complainant is and has been experimenting upon, and

has been able to do in part. Complainant believes that this difficulty

will eventually be overcome, and if left alone it will ultimately be able

to reduce the material without serious offensiveness to anybody.

CONTRACTS TO REMOVE OFFAL.—The complainant would further

show unto your honors that, although the tank-offal and blood are

18 of no value to the slaughterers and packers, they are careful to

secure some sure outlet, and relying upon the security of its char-

tered rights, it has been anxious to secure a regular and sufficient sup-

ply. For these reasons the complainant entered into contracts which

are binding and still in force, by which it has agreed to take all the offal

and blood which the principal packers produce. Those establishments

with which he has no binding contract, it receives their offal by agreement

pro tempore, without anything being binding upon either side. The

offal which complainant has contracted to receive would amount to from

seventy-tive to one hundred tons daily, and if it should be prevented

from fulfilling these contracts the damages would be large.

AMOUNT RECEIVED.—The slaughtering of animals for citv consump-

tion, not reckoned in the packing business, amounts to about as follows :

Cattle..... inva eneuel icbed + wen eaten pauiehewued 150, 000

DS ss wnvieen jie écku kaa 060 e00ceeceeame eel 200, 000

CET Pe Rows nse eee Keeene pvoeseteanssaune crekoaneen 150,000

Gs ksimincaeckentaaaenwae deena aah iat Pe eer ene hinhinnt aie * 0,000

During the packing-season, the material received by the Northwest-

ern Fertilizing Company amounts to about one hundred and seventy-

10 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

five tons per day, and during the remainder of the year from twenty-five

to seventy-five tons of bone and offal per day.

The only establishments in the city or in the vicinity which receive

offal from the packing and slaughter houses are the Northwest-

19 ern Fertilizing Company and that of Thompson & Edwards, at

the stock-yards. The capacity of the latter establishment is only

from 1,500 to 2,000 tons of tank-offal a year, with no facilities for using

blood. If the complainants’ establishment should be closed, there would

be about 19,000 tons of tank-oftal and 2,000,000 gallons of blood pro-

duced, without, as at present situated, anv way to dispose of it.

STOCK-YARDS DEPOT.—The complainant im establishing the depot at

the Union stock yards, was compelled to obtain permission for that pur-

pose from the town of Lake, in which it is situated, which permission is

conditioned upon the prompt removal of the offal every day.

This license, with the condition, is still in force, and the only author-

ity under which affiant has the right to maintain the depot there. About

the eighth day of January, 1873, complainant’s business was interrupted,

as hereinafter described, for about ten days, and during that time it

could take no offal from this depot to its factory. Within these ten days

there was no place to put the offal and blood except at this depot. It

could not remain at the packing-houses. It could not go anywhere else,

and it did go there and was deposited upon ground. This deposit cov-

ered one acre with blood from one to four feet deep, and another acre

with tank offal from one to six feet deep. Chemicals have been applied

to the blood, and every proper thing done which could be done, but the

weather was intensely cold, and it troze like a rock. This deposit is to

the west of Hyde Park, and near to its borders. The winds blow from

that direction towards the village more than eighteen hundred

20 times out of thirty-six hundred. The warm weather will thaw

this mass so it can be moved, but in the quasi spring days, when

the edges of it began to grow lively, it is respecttully submitted whether

the elite village of Hyde Park will not suffer from this, the consequence

of its own act, more than from the factory.

CONTRACTS FOR FERTILIZERS.—The complainant also avers, that re-

lying upon the vested rights created by its charter and the permanence

of its business under it, it has contracted for the delivery of about

twenty-five hundred tons of fertilizing material, to be manufactured and

delivered during the present year. The complainant expected and in-

tended to fulfill these contracts, and will do so, unless prevented by the

interruption hereinafter described. This complainant would also aver,

that if prevented from manufacturing said material and fulfilling said

contracts, the damages resulting from their breach, with the damages

to which it will be liable to the packers for not removing the offal and

blood it has contracted to remove, will cause great embarrassment and

pecuniary loss.

THE LOCATION SELECTED.—This complainant would further show

unto your honors, that the Northwestern Fertilizing Company is located

in the county of Cook, in the State of Illinois, south ot dividing line be-

tween townships thirty-seven and thirty-eight, as prescribed by the

charter. It is thirteen miles south, by about half southeast of the city

of Chicago, and substantially in the same direction from the village of

Hyde Park, and about six miles from what is known as the Hyde Park

Hotel, or central and thickly-settled portion of the village. This village,

or the thickly-settled portion of it, about the hotel, embraces about

21 3,000 inhabitants within the radius of a mile. Bevond the cirele

of a mile about the hotel, the country for the remaining five miles

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. l11

towards the works is sparsely settled, and in the main not settled at all.

The largest cluster of houses atter leaving the circle of a mile about the

hotel is at Ainsworth, where the works are located. This settlement

composes about five hundred people, the majority of whom get their live-

lihood from the ecomplainaut’s factory.

At the time the location was made, the whole county was scoured in

search of a spot given over to desolation, and where the winds would

blow the smell of the business away from the city and its environs.

With a wise discrimination, and for reasons most obvious, the explorers

settled upon Ainsworth, then in the town of Calumet, and in the midst

of the swamps and bayous of the Calumet River. It was the home of

frogs, turtles, lizards, and snakes, and the eye of a Mississippi alligator

would have looked longingly upon this choice retreat. From that point

for five miles there was not a house worthy of the name. Only a few

tishermew’s huts were to be found about the mouth of the Calumet.

In the main the features of the country are unchanged. The reptiles

still abound, and when spring unfolds her robes and birds chatter in the

groves, nature, kindly in her compensations, gives to the Calumet the

festive frog, and the touching notes of his melody fill the air. With his

friend, the turtle, he takes comfort in the sun, and when the duck-killer

questions a title perfected by nature and prescription, with a triumphant

thug he prosecutes an appeal to the water.

22 Notwithstanding these tacts, enterprising land merchants have

thrown out the pickets of a city there, and occasionally a large

building shows its lonesome tront and fights the desolation. By a

fashionable admixture of politicians in these enterprises, gentlemen have

induced the Government to spend large sums of money digging mud out

of the Calumet, and call it harbor improvements. They have also filed

plats and maps of paper cities, omitting scarcely a swamp, and on the

dry land of Stony Island, where practically, in the summer, the boys kill

snakes, and omnibus horses are pastured, your honors, by consulting

these maps, will find parks ealled the Elysian Fields, Marathon Avenue,

the Appian Way, and all the sweet names the honored past has given us.

The complainant would also state that the location at Ainsworth is

the most favorable which could be selected in reference to the prevailing

winds in the locality.

THE WINDS.—The shore line of the lake is north and south, bending

towards the east. The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, in direction,

is south by about half southeast. Thirty-six hundred and thirty-six ob-

servations of the wind, taken at regular intervals during the last five

years, as complainant is informed and believes, resulted as follows:

738 observations from the northeast.

200 66 66 ‘ east.

372 6 6 ‘ southeast.

286 66 é ‘ south.

939 és 6 ‘+ southwest.

j82 6 6 ‘ west.

511 6 6 ‘ northwest.

203 6 6 ‘ north.

23 Every wind above named would blow any smell from this fae-

tory away from Hyde Park and Chicago. Even the south wind,

owing to the curvilinear form of the lake-shore, would blow it over the

lake. Theonly wind which would blow the smeil, however bad it might

be, towards either place would be south by half southeast.

12 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

Assuming the wind blows from the south by half southeast as often as

from the south, this would give a wind from that point 256, of the year,

or about twenty-eight and one-third days.

PROSECUTIONS.—The complainant would also show that since its cor-

porate organization in December, 1867, it has upon three different occa-

sions been indicted as a nuisance, in the criminal court of Chicago. In

answer to said indictments, defendant plead its charter, upon which the

court held that it could only be punished by police regulation for not

handling the animal matter properly, and for creating unnecessary

offensiveness, but could not be punished for carrying on the business in

a reasonably prudent and careful manner, although doing the business

in the same manner, without a charter, would be a nuisance. Upon

such decision, each prosecution has been dismissed and another one

afterwards commenced.

The complainant would also show that such prosecutions were inau-

gurated and carried on by certain parties having an interest in, and, in

the main, residing in the town of Hyde Park, and that, finding the

chartered rights of the complainant received protection in the courts,

said parties have combined, and unlawfully confederated with the

24 municipal authorities of the said town of Hyde Park, to vex,

harrass, prosecute, and annoy the said complainant, until, by in-

terfering with its business, hindering and preventing it from carrying it

on, and by prosecutions and repeated suits, it might worry the complain-

ant out and drive it from the town.

HYDE PARK.—The complainant would also show that the village of

Hyde Park is a municipal corporation, created under the laws of the

State of Llinois. and located immediately south of the city of Chicago,

and at present embraces within its limits the establishment of the com-

plainant. Originally said establishment was in the town of Calumet,

but the said village of Hyde Park, since such establishment was located

in the town of Calumet, in fixing its boundaries, extended them so as

to embrace that portion of the town which contained the factory of the

complainant.

The complainant would also show that the said municipal corpora- .

tion, the village of Hyde Park, and the trustees thereof named in this

bill of complaint, colluding and combining with various parties to your

orators unknown, and pretending to exercise police authority under the

power given them by law, to make all regulations which may be neces-

sary and expedient for the promotion of health and the suppression of

disease, have undertaken to interfere with and utterly break up and de-

stroy your orator’s business, and prevent it from pursuing the same

according to the act of incorporation aforesaid, and have given out,

threatened, and publicly declared that they will continue said inter-

ference until the complainant shall be driven out of the said town, and

the privileges guaranteed by said act of incorporation shall be destroyed.

This unlawful combination and purpose is sought to be carried

25 out and entorced by the said trustees and their confederates and

co-conspirators under the pretense of police regulations, and by

virtue of said pretense said trustees have passed, published, and are

now endeavoring to enforce the following ordinance, viz:

‘No person shall transport, haul, or convey any offal, dead animals,

or other unwholesome matter, or material, into or through the village

of Hyde Park; and any person who shall be in charge of, or employed

on any train or team carrying or conveying any such matter or mate-

rial into or through the village of Hyde Park shall be subject to a tine

of not less than five nor more than fifty dollars for each oftense.”’

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 13

And the complainant avers that the carrying of the offal from its de-

pots in the city of Chicago and the Union Stock Yards, by means of

the Pittsburgh and Fort Wayne Railroad in the tight box-cars, before

described, is not injurious to the health or comfort of the people of said

village; but, on the contrary, the route of the said railroad passes

through portions of said village comparatively without population.

Aud the complainant would also show that there is no way in which

the offal or animal matter received at their depots in the city of Chi-

cago and at said Union Stock Yards can be transported to its factory

without hauling or transporting the same into and through the village

of Hyde Park ; and there is no way in which said material can be

hauled as aforesaid, except by way of the Pittsburgh and Fort Wayne

Railroad, and there is no way in which said business can be car-

26 ried on without violating said ordinance, nor can said ordinance

be obeyed without the entire abandonment of complainant’s busi-

ness, and relinquishing all the rights conferred upon it by its charter.

The complainant would also show that said ordinance has been passed

by the trustees of said village under color of law, and the same is not

an honest and reasonable exercise of the police powers of said village,

and was not passed for the purpose of protecting the health of the citi-

zens; but, on the contrary, itis an unlawful attempt, under the pre-

tense of police regulations, to prevent complainant from receiving any

supply of material at its factory, and to take away from the complain-

ant the privileges conferred by its charter, and for no other purpose

whatever.

The complainant would also show that pursuant to the said unlawful

combination and conspiracy between the said municipal corporation,

and the president and trustees thereof, and divers persons to your ora-

tor unknown, the said president did, on the sixth day of January, 1873,

address to General W. C. Cleland, assistant general superintendent of

the Pittsburgh, Fort Wayne and Chicago Ra lroad, the following com-

munication :

“Sir: By a resolution of the board of trustees of the village of

Hyde Park, I am directed rigidly to enforce our ordinances relating to

nuisances. Among the ordinances on this subject which I have ordered

our police officers to enforce on and after to-morrow, I call your atten-

tion to the following, namely, chap. 1, sec. 7: ‘ No person shall trans-

port, haul, or convey any offal, dead animals, or other offensive

27 or unwholesome matter or material into or through the village of

Hyde Park. Any person who shall be in charge of, or employed

on any train or teams, carrying or conveying any such matter into or

through the village of Hyde Park shall be subject to a fine of not less

than five or more than fifty dollars for each offense.’ We desire to oc-

easion no inconvenience to said roads extending into or through our

village, and so give you timely notice that Hyde Park will submit no

longer to be the dumping-ground for the offal of Chicago.

‘* Yours, truly, eo be Cane

“© Pres. of the Board of T. rustees.”

ARRESTs.—And the complainant would further show unto your

honor that said board of trustees and their said president, immediately

upon the passage of the aforesaid ordinance and the sending of the

aforesaid letter, caused said letter embracing said ordinance to be

published in the Chicago papers, and combining and confederating

with various parties to your orator unknown, caused the police of said

14 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

village of Hyde Park to be stationed at Ainsworth, near complainant’s

factory, with iustructions to arrest under said ordinance any and all

employees of your orator who should be found transporting offal by

rail from their said depots in Chicago to their establishment at Ains-

worth. And on or about the 8th day of January, 1873, while the engi-

neer, conductor, and brakemen, five in number, were engaged in run-

ning the train of cars on said Pittsburgh, Ft. Wayne & Chicago R. R.,

and the side-track aforesaid from said railroad to the works of your

orator at Ainsworth, which said train was conveying offal and

28 animal matter for your orator, for the purpose of being manufac-

tured by them in manner aforesaid and under provisions of their

charter, said police force actually arrested said employees, and forced

them to leave their train upon the side-track aforesaid at Ainsworth,

and brought them under arrest before a justice of the peace of the said

village, about six miles distant from said train, for a pretended viola-

tion of said ordinances, and fined them $50.00 each. And the com-

plainant would also show that said justice would not entertain a prayer

for appeal from said judgment, but threatened to imprison said em-

ploye’s at once unless said fine should be immediately paid. Where-

upon, in order to enable said employees to take care of their said train,

your orator paid said fines, in the aggregate amounting to $250.00.

The complainant would further show, that immediately upon the con-

clusion of the pretended trial, said police force were ordered back to

the side-track of complainant, at Ainsworth, to arrest the employees

upon the next train which should arrive.

THEIR EFFECT.—The complainant would further show, that it has

permanent arrangements with Pittsburgh, Ft. Wayne and Chicago Rail-

road, by which it furnishes to said railroad the box-cars for the transporta-

tion of offal and blood from Chicago to orator’s establishment at Ains-

worth, and that said railroad company furnish engines, engineers, con-

ductors, and brakemen for the hauling of said material; that your com-

plainant has no more cars than is necessary for the transportation of the

material constantly accumulating in its depots in the city, provided it

is uninterrupted in its business; and that said railroad company will

not furnish engines and cars if their men are constantly arrested

29 and their trains are to be left wherever the arrest may be made,

and that the employees will not work upon said trains if said

ordinance is enforced.

And the complainant avers that the said village of Hyde Park,

through their said president and trustees, openly threaten to continue

said arrests from day to day until they shall utterly break up and de-

stroy its business, and, in public speeches and private conversation,

said president and trustees openly avow and admit that such is their

object and determination. And the complainant avers that such inter-

terence will break up his business, and it cannot carry it on and con-

tinue it unless said village and its officers desist or are restrained from

making such arrests and persisting in such interference; and this com-

plainant avers that he fears said village will persist in and continue

said arrests and interference unless restrained and prevented by judicial

authority. Said complainant also avers that if said interference is per-

sisted in it will result in irremediable injury and mischief and damage

to complainant, and in effect will work a confiscation of its property.

THE FIRE.—The complainant would further show unto your honor

that its buildings at Ainsworth were recently destroyed by fire; that

prior to said fire orator had in said establishment eight dryers; that

the main portion of the drying-machinery, including the engines, were

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK Ef AL. 15

saved, and by the end of first week in February it will have five dryers

in operation, which will dry nearly as much material as the eight in

operation before the fire; that it is now engaged in the construction of

the buildings and additional dryers in lieu of those destroyed, and

30 is now substantially ready to commence the manufacture of fertiliz-

ing material thesameas before the fire, and at the rate of seventy-five

tonsaday. Your orator would also show that said material remains frozen

and is not offensive during the winter months, and with what your ora-

tors has done, and the additions to be made before the spring opens, it

will be able to take care of the material the coming summer as well as

in years past.

And your orator further shows unto your honor that its rights, privi-

leges, and immunities hereinbefore set forth, appertain and belong to

its shareholders as citizens of the United States, and that such rights,

privileges, and immunities are guarantied to your orator and its share-

holders by the Constitution of the United States and the laws thereof,

and that the said defendants are, by the means hereinbefore set forth,

attempting to deprive your orator and its shareholders of such rights,

privileges, and immunities, under and by virtue of the pretense of the

ordinance hereinbefore set forth, contr: ry to the Constitution of the

United States and the laws thereof, and that by reason of the premises

your orator is entitled to appropriate redress in the circuit court of the

United States.

In consideration whereof, and inasmuch as your orator is remediless

by the strict rules of the common law, and can only obtain relief in a

court of equity, where matters of this nature are properly cognizable,

said complainant prays that the village of Hyde Park, Chauney M.

Cady, a trustee, and the president of the board of trustees of said vil-

lage of Hyde Park, and his associate trustees, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron,

: Lucius G, Fisher, E.G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, Lester Brad-

ol nor, junior, and H. Vanderbilt, and their confederates, may be made

defendants hereto, and may be required to answer the same not

under oath, (their answer and the answer of each of them under oath

being hereby expressly waived,) and that said village of Hyde Park,

and said trustees above named, their confederates, officers, and agents,

and attorneys may be restrained by an injunction out of this honorable

court from in any way or manner interfering with, arresting, hindering,

or disturbing your orator, or any persons by it employed in carrying,

hauling, or transporting by railroad or otherwise, any offal or animal

matter from any of their depots aforesaid to Ainsworth, or the locality

of their works above described, or to said works, or in manufacturing

such material into an agricultural fertilizer, or other chemical products,

or in any manner otherwise prosecuting the business of the said com-

plainant under its act of incorporation, and that said defendants may

stand to and abide by all such orders and decrees as your honors may

make in the premises, and that your orator may have such other and

further relief in the premises as may be agreeable to equity and good

conscience,

And may it please your honors, also, to grant unto the complainant

the writ of subpcena, to be directed to thé village of Hyde Park, and to

Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius G. Fisher, E.

G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, Lester Bradnor, junior, and H. Van-

derbilt, trustees of the village of Hyde Park, commanding them, and

each of them, on a certain day, and under certain penalties,

32 therein to be inserted, to be and appear before your honors, then

and there to answer the bill of complaint, and further to stand to

16 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

and abide by such order and decree therein, as shall be agreeable to

equity and good conscience. And may it please your honors to grant

unto your orator the people’s writ of injunction issuing out of, and un-

der the seal of this court, directed to the said above-named trustees, their

counsellors, ofticers, agents, and employees, commanding them and each

of them absolutely to desist and refrain, as above prayed.

BENTLEY, SWETT & QUIGG,

BECKWITH, AYER & KALES,

Sol’rs for Complainant.

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, 88:

ROBERT W. RALSTON, being first duly sworn, on his oath deposes and

says that he is vice-president of the said complainant, the Northwest-

ern Fertilizing Company, and hereto duly authorized ; that he has heard

read the foregoing bill of complaint, and knows the contents thereof,

and that the same is true in substance and in fact, except such matters

as are therein stated upon information and belief, and that those he be-

lieves to be true.

ROBERT. W. RALSTON.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this thirtieth day of January, A.

D. 1873.

[NOTARIAL SEAL. | WILLIAM W. THAYER,

Notary Public.

33 EXHIBIT A.

An act to incorporate the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

SECTION 1. Be it enacted by the people of the State of Illinois, rep-

resented in the general assembly, that Christian Wahl, Louis Wahl, and .

John A. Lighthall, and their successors, associates and assigns, be, and

they hereby are, constituted a body politic and corporate; to have con-

tinued succession and existence for the term of fifty years, and to be

known as * The Northwestern Fertilizing Company,” and, by that name

and style, may contract and be contracted with ; sue and be sued, as a

natural person may; they may have and use a common seal; they shall

have power in their corporate name, for the use of said corporation, to

purchase and hold sufficient real estate for the free enjoyment of all

privileges herein granted, and to make all proper by-laws and rules for

the government of said corporation.

Sec. 2. The capital stock of said company shall be fifty thousand

dollars, with power to increase the same to any sum not exceeding two

hundred and fifty thousand dollars.

SEc. 3. The above-named persons, or a majority of them, may meet

at any time after the passage of this act, and organize said company,

on the stock therefor being subscribed for to the amount of fifty thou-

sand dollars; and they may issue certificates and then hold an elec-

tion for such officers as may be created by the by-laws which

34 may be hereafter enacted for the government of said company,

which officers shall hold their offices for the length of time fixed

by the said by-laws, to be enacted hereafter by the said company. Said

by-laws may be changed, from time to time, as may be provided by

said corporation, acting through its managers.

Sec. 4. Said corporation is hereby authorized and empowered to

establish and maintain chemical and other works at the place designa-

ted herein, for the purpose of manufacturing and converting dead ani-

a

ie i ees

ie a

<a Ae te

-CHauncy M. Capy, Wo. E. HALE, A. D. WAL- |

le 7 ~ RE RES gh

* e ie ay Tater _— at, 4 Se eee, NO ee aE, Sen

eg BFS hea og oe i oie 4, ee m2 WT eer ee To gs Te

; ; a %

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 17

mals and other animal matter into an agricultural fertilizer, and into

other chemical products, by means of chemical, mechanical], and other

processes.

Src. 5. Said chemical works shall be established in Cook County,

Illinois, at any point south of the dividing-line between townships

thirty-seven and thirty-eight. Said corporation may establish and

maintain depots in the city of Chicago, in said county, for the purpose

of receiving and carrying off, from and out of the said city, any and all

offal, dead animals, and other animal matter, which they may buy or

own, or which may be delivered to them by the city authorities and

otber persons.

Src. 6. This act shall take effect and be in force from and after its

passage.

Approved, March 8, 1867.

35 And thereupon afterwards, to wit, on the third day of Feb-

ruary, A. D. 1873, said defendants, by their solicitors, filed in said

cause their certain answer, in the words and figures following, to wit:

In the Cook County circuit court. In chancery.

STATE OF ILLINOIS,

County of Cook, 88:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY, }

complainant,

v8.

dron, L. G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, Michael Doyle, p Bill for injunction.

J. F. Barney, L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vander-

belt, trustees of the village of Hyde Park,

defendants. |

The joint answers of Chauncy M. Cady, William E. Hale, L. G. Fisher,

E. G. Clark, L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, sued as trustees of

the village of Hyde Park, detendants.

These defendants, now and at all times hereafter saving and reserv-

ing all and every benefit or advantage of exception which can or may

be had or taken to the many errors, uncertainties, and imperfections in

said bill of complaint contained, and protesting that for anything in

said bill of complaint contained or alleged this court ought not to have

or maintain jurisdiction in said cause and these defendants ought not

to be required to answer thereunto, for answer thereunto, or to so much

thereof as they are advised it is material for them to answer, say: |

Defendants admit that complainant, by an act of the legislatare

36 of the State of Illinois approved March 8, 1867, received a charter,

a copy of which is herewith filed, marked “Exhibit A,” and that

complainant has since been claiming to act under and by virtue of said

charter or an act of incorporation as a body-politic.

Defendants, further answering, say they have no knowledge, in-

formation, or belief as to whether or not the capital stock of complain-

ant was subscribed to the amount of $50,000 or any other sum and paid

up, or whether said capital stock was afterwards increased to $250,000

or to any other sum, and the capital paid in asin said bill of complaint

REc. 245—2

18 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. Vs. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

alleged, nor as to the organization of said company, beyond the fact that

said company has been doing business in the town of Hyde Park, and

afterwards in the village of Hyde Park, under the name stated in said

bill of complaint.

Defendants, further answering, deny that said act of the legislature

designated any poipt or place tor the location of the business of said

complainant, but defendants charge the truth to be that said act merely

limited the location of works by complainant to any point within the

county of Cook, south of the north line of township thirty-seven.

Defendants, further answering, admit that some time in the year 1868

complainant entered into the occupancy of buildings and grounds at or

near a station known as Ainsworth, on the Pittsburg and Fort Wayne

and Chicago Railroad, which buildings and grounds had been _ previ-

ously used, and were then being used, in the same business afterwards

earried on by complainant; but detendants say they have no knowl-

edge, information, or belief as to the amount of capital expended by

complainant in improving and enlarging such works, or whether s: id

complainant purchased any large tract or tracts of land or to what ex-

tent said complainant constructed buildings.

37 Detendants, further answering, deny that the station known as

Ainsworth was designated as the place at which complainant’s

works should be located by the terms of the act of the legislature afore-

said, and detendants deny that the said complainant located its said

works within the town of Calumet, but charge the truth to be that at

the time of the alleged organization of said complainant’s company, and

at the time of the approval of said act of incorporation, the territorial

limits of the then town and now village of Hyde Park included therein

the said station of Ainsworth and the grounds and buildings in and

upon which said complainant has conducted its manufacturing business

trom the date of the approval ot the act of ineorporation aforesaid

hitherto, and that the territorial limits of the town, and now village, of

Hyde Park have not been extended or changed since the date of the

approval of complainant’s said act of incorporation.

Detendants, further answering, say they have no knowledge, informa-

tion, or belief as to whether complainant expended the sum of $200,000

and other large sums in equipping and constructing its said works

and building and side-track, and purchasing box-ears, ete., about its

said business and in preparation therefor, or what sum or sums

said complainant expended in establishing depots in Chicago and in

the town of Lake, as alleged in said bill of complaint, or for the pur-

chasing of land in the town of Lake, or what, if any, contracts com-

plainant may have made and entered into with the packers engaged

in slaughtering and packing animals in said city of Chicago, or whether

such contracts are now in force, as in said bill alleged; but defend-

ants charge that whatever expenditures of money and whatever con-

tracts were made by complamant were made with full notice to com-

plainant of the requirements and obligations of the ordinances of the

town of Hyde Park and its successor, the village of Hyde Park,

38 and of the police and sanitary powers conferred upon the town

of Hyde Park, and afterwards upon the village of Hyde Park as

its successor; that by an act of the legislature of the State of Illinois,

entitled “An act to revise the charter of the town of Hyde Park, in

Cook County,” approved March 26th, 1869, giving full sanitary and po-

lice powers to the officers of said town, in the 16th clause of the 18th

section of said act, the following proviso was inserted, to wit: “ Pro-

vided, however, That the sanitary and police powers conferred by this

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 19

act shall not be exercised by said board of trustees as against the North

western Fertilizing Company or the Union Rendering Company, located

at or near the Calumet River, in said town, until the full expiration of

two years after the passage of this act.”

That pursuant to the powers and under the authority conferred by

the said last-mentioned act, the board of trustees of said town did, on

the 14th day of Febuary, A. D. 1870, adopt an ordinance, of which the

following is a copy of the 15th section thereof, to wit:

“Sec. 15. <All breweries, tanneries, packing-houses, distilleries,

slaughter-houses, butcher-shops, stock-yards, or establishments for the

steaming or rendering of lard, tallow, offal, or sach other substances as

can or may be rendered, boiled, or steamed, and all establishments or

places where any nauseous, offensive, unwholesome, or immoral business

may be carried on, are hereby severally defined and declared to be nui-

sances; and any person who shall own or keep or use any such places

so declared to be nuisances, and any person who shall own or keep or

use any of such places so declared to be nuisances, shall be deemed the

author of a nuisance, and on conviction thereof shall be subject toa fine

not exceeding one hundred dollars, and not less than ten dollars, in

every case, aud to a like fine for every day he or she shall tail

or refuse to abate such nuisance when notified by an officer

39 or trustee to abate the same.” And of the 16th section thereof,

towit: “Any owner or occupant of any shop, barn, grocery, cellar,

outhouse, yard, or other place, who shall suffer the same to become

nauseous, foul, or offensive, shall be fined in a sum not less than five

dollars and not exceeding twenty-five dollars in soul case, and in like

sum for each and every day after notice to cleanse such places.” And

of the 17th section thereof, to wit: “Any person who shall deposit any

night-soil, dead animals, manure, or other filthy, offensive, or nause-

ous substances upon any lot, street, alley, highway, or other place in the

town, shall be fined in a sum not less than fifty and not exceeding one

hundred dollars in every case,” which ordinance was in fall force and

effect in the said town of Hyde Park, from and after its adoption by

said board of trustees of the village of Hyde Park, November 29th,

1872, and was only limited in its application to complainant by the pro-

viso in said act of March 26th, 1869, above recited ; that on the 29th day

of November, A. D. 1872, an ordinance was adopted by the president

and board of trustees of the village of Hyde Park, pursuant to the 75th,

7th, 835d, and 96th clauses of article V of an act entitled ‘An act to pro-

vide for the incorporation of cities and villages,” approved April 10th,

1872, of the Laws of the State of Illinois, and in pursuance of which act,

and by virtue thereof, the village of Hyde Park had succeeded to and

become vested with all the rights, duties, powers, franchises, and privi-

leges of the said town of Hyde Park, and the powers, privileges, and

franchises conferred by said last-mentioned act, which ordinance so

adopted as aforesaid contained the following sections, to wit: Chapter

11, sec. 2: “All places or premises within the village of Hyde Park

kept, occupied, used for the purpose of steaming, boiling, or rendering

in any manner of any offal, tainted or damaged lard or tallow,

40 or the steaming or rendering of any animal substances, where

the same is or may be kept, occupied, or used in such manner as

to occasion any Offensive sinell, or to so taint the air as to render it un-

wholesome or offensive to the smell, and all places where any nauseous,

offensive, or unwholesome business may be carried on, are hereby sever-

ally declared to be nuisances. And any person or persons who shall

own, keep, occupy, or use any such place or premises in such manner a8

20 N. W. FERTILIZING CO VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

to occasion any offensive smell, or to so taint the air as to render it un-

wholesome or offensive to ihe smell, shall, on conviction, be subject to

a fine of not less than fifty dollars, nor more than two bundred dollars,

in every case, and to a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall con-

tinue to suffer such nuisance to continue after the first conviction, or

after being notitied by any officer or policeman of the village of Hyde

Park to abate the same ;” and of section 3 of same chapter, as follows :

‘* Any person or persons who shall own, use, or occupy any packing,

house, rendering-establishment, tallow-chandlery, bone-factory, soap-

factory, or tannery, who shall cause or suffer any offal, filth, refuse, foul

or nauseous liquor, or other offensive matter to be discharged out of or

fluw from any such premises into Lake Michigan, or into any lake lying

in whole orip part within the village of Hyde Park, or the Calumet

River or either of the branches thereof, or any of the slips or canals

connected therewith, or into any slough within the jurisdiction of the

said village, or in or upon any street, alley, public square, vacant lot,

wharf, dock, river-bank, or lake-shore, shall be subject to a fine

of not less than twenty-five dollars, and not exceeding two hun-

dred dollars, for each offense ;” and section 4 of same chapter as fol-

lows: “Any person or persons who shall permit or suffer any offal,

filth, refuse animal or vegetable matter, which is Hable to become

putrid or offensive, or injurious to health, to remain on any

41 premises, used or occupied by him, fora longer period than four

hours at any one time, shall be subject to a fine of not less than

three dollars, and not more than two hundred dollars, for each day the

same shall be allowed to remain after a conviction for the first offense ;”

and sect on 6 of the same chapter, as follows: ‘ All buildings, yards,

grounds, premises, and places of any and all description in the village

of Hyde Park kept or suffered in a toul, offensive, nauseous, or filthy

condition, are hereby declared to be nuisances, and any person who own

or keep or use any of such places so declared to be nuisances shall be

deemed to be the author of a nuisance, and on conviction thereof shall

be subject to a fine not exceeding two hundred dollars, and not less than

five dollars, and to a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall fail or

refuse to abate such nuisance when notified by an officer or policeman

of the village of Hyde Park to abate the same;” and section 7 of the

same chapter, as follows, to wit: **‘ No person shall transfer, carry, haul,

or convey any offal, dead animals, or other offensive or unwholesome

matter or material into.or through the village of Hyde Park. <Any per-

son who shall be in charge of or employed upon any train or team

carrying or conveying such matter or material into or through the village

of Hyde Park shall be subject to a fine of not less than five dollars nor

more than fifty dollars for each offense ;” and section eight of same

chapter, as follows, to wit: ** No person shall establish, maintain, or carry

any offensive or unwholesome business or establishment within the limits

of the village of Hyde Park, nor within one mile of the limits thereof.

Any person who shall violate any of the provisions of this section shall

be subject to a penalty of not less than fifty nor morethan two hundred

dollars for each and every offense, and to a like fine for each day such

business or establishment shall be continued after the first

42 conviction ;” and section nine of the same chapter, as tollows, to

wit: “ The depositing of any night-soil, dead animals, manure, or

other filthy, offensive, or nauseous substances upon any lot, street, alley,

highway, or other place in the village, is hereby declared to be a nuisance,

auy any person convicted thereof shall be fined not less than three dol-

lars, nor exceeding twenty dollars ;” and section ten of the same chapter,

lat

’

ee ee rene ane

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. V8. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 21

as follows, to wit: ‘“‘Whenever any nuisance shall be fonnd on any

premises within the village, contrary to any ordinance of said village,

the president of the board of trustees is hereby authorized in his dis-

cretion to cause the same to be summarily abated, in such manner as he

may direct.”

And defendants, further answering, say that the town of Hyde Park,

in pursuance of the act of the legislature of the State of Lilinois last

above mentioned, did, on the 13th day of August, A. D. 1872, become

incorporated and known as the village of Hyde Park.

Defendants, further answering, sav that it is not true, as alleged in

complainant’s bill of complaint, that by the act of incorporation of said

Northwestern Fertilizing Company the privilege of receiving offal and

animal matter from the packing-establishments of the city of Chicago

at the depots of complainant, and transporting the same to. the

place where complainant’s works were located in said village of Hyde

Park in the manner in which complainant is and has been conducting

such transportation, is expressly conferred by said act of incorporation,

but charge the truth to be that complainant, through its greed for profits,

has used open box-ears, allowed said animal m -tter, ete., to become pu-

trid before removal, and has provided insufficient places for its reception

at complainant’s said works, has not provided sufficient machinery

and means for the immediate disposition and manufacture of

45 said animal matter and offal, bat suffered the same to

accumulate at times in large quantities, and since the first day

of January, A. D. 1873, has had no works or machinery whatever for

the manufacturing into fertilizing or other chemical products, or other-

wise any of the animal matter, tank-stuff, and offal received and trans-

ported to said complainant’s grounds in said village of Hvde Park ; that

complainant is now daily dumping said offal, tank-stuff, and animal

matter on the ground or into open bins so carelessly constructed as not

to retain the blood emptied into them, but the same escapes and leaks

upon the ground, and the large masses of animal matter accumulated

is putrifving and decaying, becoming more and more offensive, and

tainting and corrupting the air to an extent that the health of the in-

habitants of said village is endangered, and the atmosphere of said vil-

lage rendered thereby nauseous and disagreeable to the inhabitants

throughout a large portion of the territory of said village, and a con-

tinuous and intolerable nuisance thereby created and maintained, That

Ainsworth Station aforesaid, where complainant’s works have heretofore

been located, and where said complainaut proposes to rebuild and con-

tinue the same, is five miles north of the south line of said village and

late town of Hyde Park, and by that much nearer the centre of popu-

lation than said south line; that the portion of Cook County lying

south of the dividing-line between townships thirty-seven and thirty-

eight constitutes a very large and extended territory, embracing more

than nine townships, viz, Bloom, Thornton, Calumet, Worth, Palos,

Lamont, Bremen, Orland, Rich, and the south part of Dower’s Grove,

and most of which territory was at the time of the approval of said com-

plainant’s charter, and has since continued to be, and now is, sparsely

inhabited, and is largely accessible by railway communication with Chi-

cago and the slaughtering and packing districts therein and in its

44 vicinity; that said territory did and still does afford many ©o-

venient and eligible locations for complainant’s work remote fro a

population, and where no nuisances dangerous to human health and life

would result from a proper exercise of complainant’s franchises, and

where complainant ought to locate its works, rather than in the imme-

diate vicinity of a populous district as it has done.

22 N W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

That the Union Rendering Company, formerly located at Ainsworth

aforesaid, and adjoining complainant, and whose business created at

Ainsworth a nuisance similar to the works of complainant, have re-

cently (but not until after conviction in the criminal court of Cook

County on indictment for public nuisance) removed to a point about

nine miles south of Ainsworth to a site on the Calumet River, in the

said town of Thornton, perfectly eligible and suitable for the works of

complainant, and where, as these defendants are informed and believe,

said Rendering Company are willing and desirous complainant should

locate, and the assent of town authorities of said town of Thornton to

sid location can be obtained, as such assent has already been given to

said Rendering Company.

Defendants, further answering, deny that complainant acquired any

legal or equitable rights to subvert or disregard the ordinances of the

village of Hyde Park, by reason of the police and sanitary ordinances

of the city of Chicago, or by reason of the arrangements or contracts

of complainant with said town of Lake.

Detendants, further answering, admit that the daily accumulations

of dead animals and animal matter in the city of Chicago is immense,

and that the conservation of the health of said city requires the rapid

removal or proper disposition of such dead animals and animal matter,

lest pestilence should be bred therefrom, and defendants aver that

the amounts of such offal and offensive matter is so enormous

45 thatit isimpossible forcomplainant orary othere »mpany with any

facilities it has heretofore possessed, and which 1° proposes to re-

establish, to work the same up at any one place fast enough to preveut

an accumulation of an immense mass of putrid matter, thus poisoning

the air in the vicinity, and creating a foul nuisance for miles around ;

that since its organization said complainant has, year by year, for pur-

poses of greed and of a monopoly of the profits of the business, under-

taken to dispose of such amounts of offal and so far beyond the ca-

pacity of its works; that large amounts thereof have been accumulated

by complainant at its works at Ainsworth, during each packing season,

(and which season usually lasts from some time in the mouth of Novem-

ber in each year till the first of March following,) and such offensive mat-

ter has been suffered to lie and fester, and rot and stink, till late in the

season of hot weather, and sometimes till nearly the commencement of

the next packing season.

That said complainant is now accumulating at said Ainsworth im-

mense masses of this offensive matter, and with its works destroyed and

the delay in rebuilding, the prospect for the coming warm season (unless

some check is put to this disregard of human life and health) is most se-

rious, calling tor prompt and immediate action on the part of the authori-

ties of said village of Hyde Park, 1n order to prevent pestilence among its

population. And detendants aver that complainant has heretofore, and

unless checked by legal proceedings will continue to conduct its busi-

ness at Ainsworth in a most careless, slovenly, and reckless manner,

spreading large amounts of putrid matter in the open air to dry, thus

facilitating and assisting the process of drying by its dryers, and in

other respects conducting its businessin such a careless and reeck-

46 less manner as to create a foul and dangerous nuisance, and it is

to prevent this that the authorities of said village of Hyde Park

have commenced a series of criminal prosecutions; and defendants sub-

mit that they should be permitted to continue the good work until the

lives and health of the citizens otf Hyde Park are made reasonably se-

cure; and defendants say that the sheds or inclosures in which com-

SPA tpccning

[a

|

g

4

#

@

a

%

4

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 23

plainant pretends it has been and is now confining this offensive mat-

ter are and have been loosely built, and wholly inadequate to confine

these offensive smells and prevent a great nuisance; nor is it possible

to so construct them as to prevent such an immense mass of accuma-

lated putrid matter from becoming a great nuisance. Defendants sub-

mit that they are not responsible for, or in any way bound to provide

an outlet or place of deposit for such dead animals, animal matter, and

offal, as may accumulate in said city of Chicago and its vicinity, or to

furnish complainant with any facilities for doing the same; and defend-

ants further deny that complainant has the right to violate the police

and sanitary ordinances of the village of Hyde Park, by reason of any

lack or negligence on the part of the city of Chicago or its citizens in

providing proper means and places for the removai to apd disposition

of such accumulations of dead animals, animal matter, and offal. De-

fendants, further answering, admit that complainant has heretofore

daily removed the materials collected at its depots to its works in the

village of Hyde Park, and converted the same ora large portion thereof

into fertilizing material, has shipped such manufacturers’ material to vari-

ous places, acquired reputation tor such manufacture and derived large

profits trom such business, but defendants deny that said complainant’s

works are now in operation, and further deny thatcomplainant is now en-

gaged in the manufacture of such material into a fertilizeror any product

whatever Defendants further deny that said complainant has

47 heretofore, or is now, transporting said animal matter and offal in

such way and manner as to occasion as little as possible offense

consistent with the business to the inhabitants of the village of Hyde

ark living on the line or using the route of transportation for such ma-

terial, and deny that said complainant is now receiving such matter at

its manufactory in such manner as to avoid as far as possible any dele-

terious influence therefrom; and deny that complainant has heretofore

used, or that complainant is now using, proper means to render said

transportation and manufacture ot said material innoxious and inoffen-

sive to the inhabitants of the said village of Hyde Park; and defend-

ants deny that complainant has heretofore used, or is now using, all

possible means to render such transportation and manufacture innoxious

and free from annoyance to the inhabitants of said village of Hyde Park.

Defendants deny that said complainant has heretofore, in the conduct

of its business, used, or now uses, the necessary care and means to pre-

vent said business from being annoving and noxious to the inhabitants

of the village of Hvde Park ; and defendants deny that complainant has

availed itself of every known discovery to prevent annoyance and dele-

terious influences to the inhabitants of said village of Hyde Park from

the business of complainant. And these defendants aver that there

are in use, and have been for years past, in many cities of Europe (as

these defendants are informed and believe) and elsewhere, well-known

processes for manufacturing animal matter into a fertilizing material

Without the production of offensive odors, and that such processes are

not used by said complainant, and because the same are more costly

than it chooses to employ.

Defendants charge the truth to be that the works of said complainant

have heretofore been located in close proximity to the main track

48 of the Pittsburgh, Fort Wayne, and Chicago and Michigan

Southern Rafroads, which are great through lines for travel be-

tween Chicago and all eastern points—witbin three miles of the track

of the Illinois Central and Michigan Central Railroad; that thousands

of persons daily pass on said railroads; that several new lines of rail-

24 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

roads are projected at or near the place where said works have hereto-

fore been located; that the population of the village of Hyde Park is

rapidly increasing; and in the immediate vicinity of said works there is

now a population of about 700 persons, and that such population would

be still more largely increased but for the nauseous and disgusting

effluvia exhaled from the putrifying animal matter uncared for at the

location of complainant’s said works, arid from the horrible stench pro-

duced by the manufactory of said complainant, when in operation, cor-

rupting the air and rendering it foul and offensive for miles about said

works; that the offal and animal matter accumulated by complainant

are transported in open box-cars; that said matter, at the time of trans-

portation, is often putrid and decaying, giving out unwholesome and

noxious odors, incommoding and offending persons traveling upon the

railroads and living along the line of said railroads over which said

matter is thus transported ; that said location of complainant’s works is

at or near all the lines of railroads leading into Chicago from the east-

ern portion of our county, and within a few rods of the highway leading

from Chicago to the State of Indiana.

Defendants, further answering, say they have no knowledge, infor-

mation, or belief as to the use said complainant may have made of its

grounds in thetown of Lake, but submit that the accumulated matter

alleged by complainant to have been deposited in said town of Lake

‘annot be deposited in the village of Hyde Park to putrify and

49 decay without great danger to the health of the inhabitants of

said village, as well as to their great discomfort.

Defendants, further answering, deny that the right to carry on the

business of complainant in the manner in which complainant is now

conducting the same has been several times decided in favor of com-

plainant in the criminal court of Cook County, or his ever been so de-

« ded on indictinent or otherwise.

Defendants, further answering, say they have no knowledge, informa-

tion, or belief respecting the alleged contracts of said complainant ; but

defendants aver that complainant has no means whatever provided for

the manufacture of said animal matter within the village of Hyde Park,

and defendants charge the truth to be that said complainant’s said

charter does not exempt said complainant from obedience to and com-

pliance with the ordinances of said village of Hvde Park, and that the

police and sanitary powers of said village extend to and include there-

under said complainant as well as citizens of said village.

Defendants, further answering, say that said village of Hyde Park

became tmcorporated under the general laws of the State of Illinois,

passed since the act incorporating complainant, but charge the truth to

be that the legislature of the State of Llinois has clothed the ofticers of

the village of Hyde Park with full powers to control and regulate all

sanitary and police matters within said village. Said defendants deny

that they have attempted to interfere with the lawful conduct of said

complainant’s business, but have, as officers of said village, adopted

ordinances and required the enforcement thereof, which detendants

believed and still believe were proper and necessary for the conserva-

tion of the health and good order of said village, and defendants

50 deny that they have sought in any way to use their corporate

powers to the injury of complainant, except in so far as com-

plainant has openly and notoriously violated the ordinances of said

village, alleging and claiming that it, said complainant, was in no way

or mazuner amenable to the police and sanitary authority of said village,

and exempt, by its charter, from all control by the officers of said

‘4

i

1%

‘fy

i

Ba

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 25)

village from all duty to obey the ordinances thereof. Defendants ex-

pressly deny that such exemption is either expressly or impliedly

granted said complainant by its said act of incorporation, and deny that

in the passage of said act of incorporation the legislature of the State

of Illinois surrendered or intended to surrender to complainant the

police and sanitary powers of said State. Defendants admit the adop-

tion of the section of the ordindnees recited in said bill of complaint

with other sections, but deny that the authorities of said village have

threatened to or attempted to interfere with complainant in the trans-

portation of any matter, in a lawful or careful manner, through said

village, and charge that said ordinances are necessary for the protec-

tion of the lives and health of the inhabitants of said village, and a

proper exercise of the powers conferred by the statutes of the State of

Illinois upen the president and board of trustees of said village, and

defendants submit that unless the power to prevent the dumping of

offal and animal matter within said village be exercised oy the officers

of said village, that the amount of such matter to be deposited, as shown

by complainant’s bill, would soon render the occupation of said village,

and even of a great portion of the city of Chicago, adjoining said vil-

lage, unfit for ocecupaney by anv human inhabitants.

Defendants, further answering, deny that said recited ordinance, or

any other ordinances of the village of Hyde Park, is in deroga-

51 tion of the rights and privileges of complainant under said act of

incorporation, and further deny that said complainant has ac-

quired any rights to violate or disregard the regulations and ordinances

of said village by virtue of its said charter, but defendants submit that

the rights, privileges, and franchises conferred by the act of incerpora-

tion upon complainant are no other or greater than exist by common

law in every other inhabitant of the State of [llinois, and that said

chartered and individual rights in no way derogate from the power of

the State to confer upon municipal corporations the necessary sanitary

and police powers for the good government of the same.

Detendants, further answering, deny all manner of combination to in-

jure in any way said complainant or its business, but defendants admit

that the police of said village have arrested certain men who were en-

gaged in dumping offal and animal matter from a train of cars, on or

about the 6th day of January, A. D. 1873, upon grounds in said village;

that said men confessed to the violation of the ordinance of said village

and were fined by the magistrate for such violation, but defendants

deny that said men applied for or were refused an appeal by the magis-

trate, and submit that these defendants have no control over any magis-

trate in said village or elsewhere, to compel such magistrate to perform

his duty, but that the law of the land gives ample redress to any per-

son who may deem himself ag’rieved by the action of such magistrate.

Defendants, further answering, admit the service of the notice upon

Gen’l W.C. Clelland, an officer of the Pittsburgh, Fort Wayne & Chicago

Railroad, as stated in said bill, and claim that such notice was designed

solely for the purpose of arresting the dumping and depositing of offal

and animal matter within the limits of the village of Hyde Park, where

no arrangements whatever existed for guarding or covering the

52 same in any manner, or fur making any use of the same, and the

accumulations thereof threatened to be so great as to render any

disposition of the same impracticable before the effluvia and odors there-

from would render life in said village almost intolerable as well as

perilous to health.

Defendants, further answering, say that they are informed and believe

26 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

that the Union Stock Yards, at which place complainant alleges it has

a depot established for the reception of its offal and animal matter, is

connected with all the lines of railroad which come into the city of Chi-

cago; that some of said roads run through large tracts of almost unin-

habited country where said offal and animal matter could be deposited

with little danger or inconvenience to men, and within easy transporta-

tion from said city of Chicago. That the Union Rendering Company is

in full operation some nine miles south of the late site of complainant’s

works, and the managers thereof would, as defendants are informed and

believe, receive and makejdisposition of said tank-stuff, offal, and animal

matter.

And these defendants submit to this honorable court, that all and

every of the matters in said complainant’s bill mentioned and complained

of are matters which may be tried and determined at law, and with

respect to which the said complainant is not entitled to any relief from

a court of equity, and these defendants hope they shall have the same

benefit of this defense as if they had demurred to said complainant’s bill of

complaint. And these defendants deny all and all manner of unlawful

combination and confederacy wherewith they are by said bill charged,

without this, that there any other matter, cause or thing in said bill

of complaint contained material or necessary for these defendants to

make answer unto, and not herein and hereby well and sufficiently an-

swered, confessed, traversed, and avoided, or denied, is true to the

53 knowledge or belief of these defendants or any of them. All of

which matters and things these defendants are ready and willing

to aver, maintain, and prove as your honors shall direct, and bumbly

pray to be hence dismissed with their reasonable costs, ete.

(Signed) CHAUNCEY M. CADY,

President of the Board of Trustees.

EK. G. CLARK.

H. VANDERBELT.

WM. E. HALE.

L. G. FISHER.

L. BRADNER, JR.

Sworn to before

HENRY M. BAERN,

Notary Public.

(Attached is “The act to incorporate the Northwestern Fertilizing

Company.”)

And thereupon, afterwards, the following proceedings were had and

entered of record in said cause, to wit:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co. )

v, - Bill.

C. M. CADY ET AL. \

This day, Feb. 3, 1873, came on to be heard the motion of the defend-

ants for a dissolution of the injunction Leretofore granted in said cause,

which was argued by counsel ; and the court, not ‘being fully advised in

the premises, doth take said motion under advisement.

And this day, Feb. 12, 1873, came again the said parties, by their re-

spective solicitors; and the court, having carefully considered the motion

of the defendants for a dissolution of the injunction heretofore granted

in said cause, and being now fully advised in the premises, doth over-

rule said motion of the defendants.

Re A Sa nen RR et

|

A A are ite Hi

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 27

54 THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING )

Co.

v.

C. M. Capy, W. E. HALE, A. D. WAL- | Bill

dron, L. G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, M. Doyle, ¢ Bll

J.T. Barney, L. Bradner, Jr., and H. Van-

derbilt, trustees of the village of Hyde

Park, and village of Hyde Park. ,

On motion of solicitors for defendants, leave is hereby granted said

defendants to file a supplemental answer in said cause instanter, which

answer was filed and is as follows, to wit:

Circuit court of Cook County.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co.

v.

CHAUNCEY M. Capy, WILLIAM E. HALE, L.

G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, L. Bradner, jr., H. > Bill for injunction.

Vanderbilt, A. D. Waldron, Michael Doyle,

and J. F. Barney, trustees of the village |

Hyde Park, and the village of Hyde Park.

And the defendants, Chauncey M. Cady, William E. Hale, L. G.

Fisher, E. G. Clark, L. Bradner, jr., H. Vanderbilt, A. D. Waldron,

Michael Doyle, and J. F. Bai ney, trustees of the village of Hyde Park,

now come, and by leave of the court, for supplemental answer to the

bill for injunction in this cause filed, say that on the 13th day of Feb-

ruary, 1873, last past, and after the filing of defendants’ answer in this

cause, the following amendments were duly made to chapter 2 of the

Revised Ordinances of the Village of Hyde Park:

55 Be it ordained by the president and board of trustees of the

village of Hyde Park, as follows, to wit:

SECTION 11. All establishments, places, or premises within the village

of Hyde Park so negligently conducted, managed, or used as to create

such offensive smells as to taint the air and render it unwholesome or

disagreeable to the public, or to the inhabitants of said village, are

hereby severally declared to be a nuisance, and every person or corpo-

ration who shall create or aid or assist in creating such nuisance, shall

be liable to a fine of not less than 850 and not exceeding $200, and to a

like fine for each twenty-four hours such nuisance shall be continued

and remain unabated.

SEc. 12. Any person or corporation engaged in the business of con-

verting dead animals or other animal matter into an agricultural fertil-

izer, or into other products within the limits of said village of Hyde

Park, and who or which shall so negligently conduct, or manage, or

aid or assist in so conducting or managing such business as to create

such nuisance as is described in section 11 of this ordinance, shall be

liable to a fine of not less than fifty and not exceeding two hundred

dollars, and to a like fine for each twenty-four hours such business shall

be in such manner continued by the procurement, aid, or assistance of

such person or corporation.

SEc. 13. No person or persons, or corporation, engaged in rendering,

reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into an agricultaral

fertilizer or other product, shall accumulate at any one place within the

jurisdiction of said village, matter or offal exceeding one hundred tons

or of blood exceeding one thousand gallons. Any person or corpora-

tion who or which shall vivlate this section shall be deemed guilty of

28 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

maintaining a nuisance, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be

56 . fined in a sum not less than fifty and not more than two hundred

dollars.

SEc. 14. Any person or persons who, or corporation which, shall cause

animal matter or offal to be brought into the village of Hyde Park for

the purpose of manufacturing the same into a fertilizer or other product,

or who shall aid or assist therein, shall transport the same in close,

tight, and covered vars or boxes, and shall deposit the same in close,

tight, and covered bins, so that no offensive or unwholesome odor shail

escape therefrom. Any person who shall violate this section shall be

subject to a fine of not less than fifty and not more than two hundred

dollars for each offense.

SEc. 15. Any person or persons, or corporations, engaged in render-

ing, reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into a fertilizer

or other product, who or which shall deposit within the limits of Hyde

Park any such matter or offal in a putrid or offensive condition, or who

or which shall aid or assist therein, shall be deemed guilty of creat-

ing a nuisance, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined in a sum

not less than $50 and not more than $200,

SEc. 16. Any person or persons, or corporation, engaged in rendering,

reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or

other product, who or which shall permit or suffer any animal matter

or offal to remain on premises occupied or used by him, or them, or it,

within the limits of the village of Hyde Park for a longer period than

48 hours before the actual reduction or manufacture thereof, shall be

deemed guilty of maintaining a nuisance, and,on conviction thereof, shall

be subject to a fine of not less than $50 and not exceeding $200, and to

a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate such nuis-

ance.

o7 Sec. 17. Every person or corporation engaged in manufactur’

ing animal matter or oftal into a fertilizer or other product with-

in the limits of the village of Hyde Park shall, before the reduction

thereof, thoroughly deodorize the same by the application of salt, acid,

or other chemicals, so that the same shall not be offensive. Any person

who shall violate this section of the ordinance shall be subject to a fine

of not less than $50 and not more than $200.

SEc. 18. Any person or corporation who or which shall operate or

use, or be employed in any factory or other place for the reduction,

rendering, or manufacturing of animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or

other product between the Ist day of April and the Ist day of Novem-

ber, within the limits of the village of Hyde Park, shall be guilty of

maintaining a nuisanee, and, on conviction thereof, shall be subject to

a fine of not less than $50 and not more than $200, and to a like fine

tor every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate such nuisance.

SEC. 19. Nothing contained in this ordinance shall be construed so

as to repeal any existing ordinance of the village of Hyde Park relating

to nuisances or the abatement thereof.

All which matters and things these defendants are ready and willing

to aver, ma’ntain, and prove, as this honorable court shall direct ; and

humbly pray to be hence dismissed, with their reasonable costs and

charges in this behalf most wrongfully sustained.

HITCHCOCK, DUPEE & EVARTS,

AND SIDNEY SMITH,

Defendants’ Solrs.

But said supplemental answer not to affect the injunction heretofore

allowed.

at AO RIE GRIN | SORT Sra

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 29

58 And after hearing counsel for the respective parties, the hearing

of motion filed by defendants to modify the injunction in the

papers now filed by defendants, and upon such papers as may in oppo-

sition thereto be filed by complainant, is set for March 6th next.

And thereupon afterwards, to wit, on the sixth and nineteenth days

of March, A. D. 1873, the following proceedings were had aud entered

of record in said cause, to wit:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co. )

v. Bill.

C. M. CADY:-ET AL. ¢

This day came the complainants by Leonard Swett, esq., one of their

solicitors, and the defendants by Messrs. Hitchcock & Smith, their so-

licitors; and thereupon came on to be heard the motion of the defend-

ants for the modification of the injunction heretofore granted in said

cause, which was heard on bill, answer, affidavits, and on certain affi-

davits filed in the case of Gaughan v. The Northwestern Fertilizing

Company, and read pursuant to stipulation. The court after hearing the

argument of counsel, and not being now fully advised in the premises,

doth take said motion under advisement.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY } 7

v. “ 5d45 857. Bill.

C. M. CaADY ET AL.

This day came again the said parties by their respective solicitors.

And thereupon the court having now on this day carefully considered

the motion of said defendants heretofore made in said cause, and being

now fully advised in the premises, doth overrule the motion of said de-

fendants, to wit, to modify the injunction heretofore granted in said

cause.

And on motion and by agreement of counsel, it is ordered that

59 the order heretofore entered setting said cause for hearing for

the 2ith day of March next, be, and it hereby is, set aside.

And that said cause be, and it hereby is, set for hearing for the 26th

day of March, instant.

And afterwards, to wit, on the Ist and 4th days of April, A. D. 1873,

the following among other proceedings were bad and entered of record

in said court, to wit:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY }

Us.

C. M. Capy, W. E. HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L.

G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. F. Barney, > Bill.

L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, trustees of |

the village of Hyde Park, and Village of Hyde

Park.

On motion and by consent of counsel, leave is hereby granted said

defendants C. M. Cady, William E. Hale, L. G. Fisher, E..G. Clark, L.

Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, part of the above-named defendants,

to amend their answer filed January 30th, 1873, instanter.

30 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY )

v8.

C. M. Capy, W. E. HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L.

G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. T. Barney, } 5545 857. Bill.

L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, trustees

of the village of Hyde Park, and Village of

Hyde Park.

60 This day came said parties by their respective solicitors, and

thereupon this cause came on to be heard upon the bill, answers,

and proofs adduced in open court. The court, after hearing the evidence

and arguments of counsel, and being fully advised in the premises, doth

find that the complainant is not entitled to the relief prayed for in its

said bill of complaint.

Whereupon it is ordered by the court that the complainant’s bill of

complaint be, and it hereby is, dismissed out of this court, at complain-

ant’s costs, for want of equity.

To all of which the complainant, by its solicitors now here, excepts, and

prays an appeal to the supreme court of the State of Lllinois, which is

granted on condition that said complainant doth within twenty days

from date execute and file an appeal-bond in said cause, in the penal sum

of five thousand dollars, (35,000,) with security thereto, to be approved

by the court.

And it is further ordered that said complainant be allowed thirty

days from date in which to prepare and file a certificate of evidence in

said cause.

It is hereby stipulated that all the conditions of the appeal have been

complied with, and that this case is now in accordance with said order

of appeal properly before the supreme court for the northern grand di-

vision of Illinois.

It is also stipulated that the following bill of exceptions is a full state-

ment of the evidence taken in said cause, the same having been con-

densed as follows by the agreement of the parties.

LEONARD SWETT,

Sol. for Complt.

CHAS. HITCHCOCK,

Sol. for Defts.

61 Circuit court, Cook County, March term, A. D. 1873.

SrATE OF ILLINOIS,

Cook County :

NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co. )

v. » Bill of exceptions.

C. M. Capy ET AL. \

Be it remembered that on the trial of this cause, at the March term

of 1873, of the circuit court of Cook County, honorable W. W. Farwell,

presiding as the judge of the said court, the plaintiff, to maintain the

issue upon his part, introduced the following testimony:

Louis WAHL:

I am a manufacturer of glue from the refuse of hides and the feet

and bones of animals, and have been thus engaged, in Chicago and at

Milwaukee, for the last twenty-seven years. Our firm, composed of

SBN a eI MAI a2 YAR a AI RIES By RIMS

i

;

4

Ra

4

&

a

{

3

4

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. Vs. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 3]

Christian Wahl, myself, and John A. Lightall, commenced to manu-

facture an agricultural fertilizer from offal and animal matter in the

city of Chicago in 1864.

The establishment was about four miles from the court-house in a

southwesterly direction.

In the fall of 1866 we moved the business to Ainsworth, which is in a

southeasterly direction from Chicago, and about thirteen miles dis-

tant. The location is about half a mile from the mouth of the Calumet

River.

At the time Wahl Brothers and Lightall commenced the fertilizing

business at Ainsworth, that country, in the main, was unsettled.

Between the Hyde Park Hotel and the factory there was one little

saloon called The Half-way House. This was the only house,

62 and was about two miles south of the present Hyde Park Hotel.

There was also a little hut at Clark’s Point, and an old house at

the Calumet light-house, and also another house belonging to a man by

the name of Cain; otherwise there were no settlements from the Hyde

Park Hotel to the Calumet River. In fact there was not over two or

three houses south of where the reform-schools are. The Hyde Park

Hotel mentioned is about two miles south of the present city limits.

The distance from 22d street to the factory was about thirteen miles,

and the distance from the Hyde Park Hotel to it is about eight or nine

miles.

When we commenced the business of manufacturing a fertilizer in

1864, the material which we obtained in the city produced about five

thousand tons of dry product each year, which must have been fifteen

thousand tons in its natural state. The material thus received was

partly steamed by the packers and partly in its natural state. The

head, ribs, backbone, and some of the entrails were steamed by the

packers for lard, but the livers, lights, and lungs came to us in their

natural state.

We steamed out the livers and lungs ourselves. We tried to get

machinery to aid us in the manufacturing, but found it cost more than

the product was worth. We tried first piling the material up, in hopes

that it would dry by spontaneous combustion. But this failing, we had

to spread it out in the sun and air. Thespreading was about six inches

thick, and it would dry in different periods, according to the weather,

from three or four days to as many weeks. After the material was

thus dried, we gathered it up and sold it. This was our process while

we were doing business at Bridgeport, and before going to Ainsworth.

All efforts to use machinery proved useless.

63 The material used by us from 1864 to 1866 increased about

fifteen to twenty per cent. It was produced at the slaughter-

houses by the slaughtering of animals, and embraced all the refuse parts

of the animal, and blood. These slaughter-houses then, in the main,

were located upon the Chicago River and its branches, and within from

one to two miles of its mouth ; and at first much of the offal and blood

found its way to theriver. The water-works for city consumption were

at that time and are now located near the mouth of the Chicago River,

at the margin of the lake. The water was then pumped up from the

edge of the lake at a point about eight points north of the mouth of the

Chicago River, and in a central part of the city. The current of the

lake, opposite the city, makes towards the shore. The deposits of sand

brought from more northern regions make constantly, along the whole

line of the city, accretions of land. This is particularly so upon the

north side, where the water-works are. The location of the packing-

pie nase et uilte

SR a ns F , se oh! stil ga ak Sat sais 6s ln seals Sse Pee oa

re gg Sr ae epee is” PO IP PN nF SRS os g ok ag RATE aah el 4 ede ea . Ay ote ety

* Se Sit aie fete eb aes Sinica, we 8 NEES YE Nee Te ae <b eee Somat SL . .

(Sls PPE ioe dines a Radian fer aia len «clam.

32 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

houses upon the Chicago River, with the offal and blood deposited in

the river, as it always was to a greater or less extent then, made the

water foul and offensive.

After Wahl Brothers and Lightall transferred the fertilizing busi-

ness from Chicago to Ainsworth, the process of manufacturing the fer-

tilizer at Ainsworth continued the same as in Chicago.

We built open sheds in which the material was piled up, and covered

several acres with planks, where we spread it out to dry. The material

was received in the winter time, piled up in sheds, and in the spring

and summer was spread out and dried as described.

The livers, lights, lungs, and other soft parts of the animal, which

came to us in the natural state and unsteamed, we steamed out in large

tanks, and we ran the water into the Calumet River.

64 From the factory the water passed from the steam-tanks into

a catch-basin. It was drawn from this basin into theriver. After

drawing off awhile the basin became filled with sediment, which we

scooped out, spread on the planks, and dried. During the two years we

were at Ainsworth we tried everything we could hear of in the shape of

machinery, but never succeeded in getting anything which did us much

good. After we went to Ainsworth we received large quantities of

blood. This we coagulated and spread in the sun. It was the worst

part to handle. Our receipts at the Calumet, during the packing-sea-

son, averaged 170 to 180 tons a day, and we received all the oftal and

blood which the city slaughter-houses produced. These receipts were

larger in weight than the same material at the present time, because

much of it was in the natural state and unsteamed.

I have examined the statistical report shown me, giving the extent

of the slaughtering business in the city of Chicago, of cattle for the

last sixteen years and of hogs for the last twenty-one years. This table

is authentic and correct, and what is stated as since 1854 is substanti-

ally within my present knowledge. The table is as follows:

Cattle slaughtered for city consumption and packed within the last sixteen

years.

hi inne dew éten nee eS Gb eid oNndasc ees enes 157, 107

ERE eee pec | Ms si a 90, 596

Sere ieee PE. be ces cicvewecese sees 130, 454

Nee eee ee Te ES (UE 5 bbw diicechis oacesys 114, 385

RE ee kg a eee 108, 547

ee ee ee ee Ny 108, 385

1862 ....- Lsew eens bess ees Re © aiid s dweds céunebdinss 141, 255

idan dais wn wae IS MI, cris’. os waa cae. 141, 123

65 Hogs packed in Chicago during the last twenty-one years.

io cca pieces SOUS | BOOS. osck cv viccis 970, 264

SS IORI eee eee eee 904, 659

ae eee § POOR... ic ccacc. ck. 760, 514

er eee eee 73, 994 | 1865-6.......... aa 507, 355

ere 80, 389 | 1866-7............ wee. 639, 332

ka cs dndhiaeedsee WOOO | BOGTAB. oo oc. vcon ck cw cc 796, 226

DENG hb G66 Vaideeb ues e ce 99, 262 | 1968-9.... 2.2... 20.2... 617, 558

DS cia ie aoe ernie ane’ 179, 684 | 1869-70.............. . 685, 959

Re eee - 151, 329 | 1870-1........... ».... 9838, 087

ES | Riis Vcsiesiaas 1, 225, 236

This year the slaughtering of hogs amounts to 1,345,000.

In July, 1868, Wahl Bros. & Lightall sold the fertilizing establish-

=m « ae

|

|

—

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 33

ment at Ainsworth to Baugh & Sons, of Philadelphia. They immedi-

ately took possession, and shortly thereafter the Northwestern Fertiliz-

ing Company was organized under the charter eutitled **An act to in-“

corporate the Northwestern Fertilizing Company,” approved March 8,

1867. Since that time they have carried on the business of manutactur-

ing a fertilizing material from the same kind of animal matter as was

used by Wahl Bros. & Lightall, and at the same place.

The general appearance of the country in the region of the Calumet,

and south of the city limits of Chicago, continued substantially the same

as it was when we first we’ there, up to the period Baugh & Sons took

possession in 1868. I did not see a particle of progress; the country

was low and swampy, the only high point being a strip ofland on which

the factory was located ; the surface of the ground from the Hyde Park

Hotel, about nine miles to the factory, was an alternation of sand-hills

and swamps, nearly the whole country being submerged with

66 water during the spring-months. Shortly after leaving the Hvde

Park Hotel there was a great marsh, a mile or 8» in extent. After

that there was a stripof dry land along the lake, and the balance was

marsh clear down to the factory. From Hyde Park Hotel tor teu miles

south and three or four miles back from the margin of the lake, |

should think three-quarters of the country was overflowed with water.

No system of drainage had been introduced in that region of country so

long as we were connected wiih the factory. Its coudition as described

is tue condition at the time we lett it, and up to the time the North-

western Fertilizing Company commenced to do business under their

act of incorporation. Within aradius of tive miles of the factory the

following is a description of settlements: there was a station-house on

the Pittsburgh and Fort Wayne road, Doyle’s house, and what is known

as Washington Heights, at a distance; there was also a lager-beer

saloom Within the radius of five miles three quarters of the land was

covered with water in the spring, until about the first of June. 1 looked

upon the whole country as a swamp; [ don’t know that [ would have

given 850 for the whole of it. When we located at Ainsworth we

thought we were going into a country where bo human being could get;

it was just the country we thought for doing a stinking bDasiness.

[ have been there about twice w year since the North westera Fertiliz-

ing Company have had control of the establishment,

When it commenced business their method of utilizing the material

Was very similar to ourown,. At first they made but few improvements,

but within the last few years they have spent a great deal of mo iey, and

have made luprovements which I consider a success They also use @

much greater amount of disinfectants than we did. Their machin-

OG ery is so great a success that | have bought one tor the glue-fac-

tory. We are compelled to handle some material by way of con-

verting it into a fertilizer. The diagram hereunto aunexed, marked

* Exhibit A,” shows the machine used by the Northwestern Fertilizing

Co.wpany correct y, except there s ould ve four fires quder the dryer in-

stead of two. Lhe machine referred to has a revolving eyli ider thirty

feet long and thirty-six inches in diameter, arranged horizontally, wita

arevolving shaft passing through the centre of it; rakes or teeth are at-

tached to the shaft and so arranged as to keep the material in constant

motion and move it alons from the end in which it is introduced towards

the opposite or discharging end. The whole is so constructed aud

moved that while the cylinder revolves once the interior shatt revolves

twice at the same time.

At the same end at which the matter is put into the cyiinder is a

REC. 245—3

34 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

smoke-stack, with a communication between that end of the cylinder

and the stack. The cylinder is also enclosed on all sides by a brick

wall. Within its exterior wall four coal-fires, within twe feet of the

cylinder, are kept burning. These fires are so arranged as to envelop

and apply to the cylinder a mild and uniform heat. The brick wall,

within which the heated air is contained, confines the heat, and the dis-

charging end of the cylinder being open, and the matter within the cyl-

inder being in constant motion and the cylinder about one-tenth filled,

gives a draught through it, and the heated air passes into the discharg-

ing end, and permeates and passes through the animal matter within

the cylinder, and thence through the smoke-stack to the air.

I have examined other establishments similar to the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company, but not as large. Taking into consideration the

immense quantities of animal matter that they are taking, | cannot

see how they could have done it better than they have. Their

68 machine is the only one [ have ever known that works success-

fully. The Northwestern Fertilizing Company have kept up with

all the improvements in the business that have been made and tested.

In my opinion they have spent more money in this direction than they

could atford to.

There is no other establishment in Chicago or in-its vicinity for the

manufacture of agricultural tertilizers from animal matter, except a

small one at the stock-yards, known as “Thompson & Edwards; and

since 1866 there has been no other outlet for ihe animal matter produced

by slaughtering, in Chicago, except at Ainsworth, first under the con-

trol of ** Wahl Brothers & Lightall,” and, second, the establishment of

the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

The way animal matter produced at the slaughter-houses was dis-

posed of as tar back as about 1854, and prior to that time, was, by

hauling it out to Thirty-first street, and spreading it out on the ground.

In the summer, when warm weather came, it made a horrible smell, and

the city took out the Brideweil prisoners to bury it. The material was

hauled out in wagons and thrown all over the prairie promiscuously.

This place at Thirty-first street is south trom the central part of the

city, and was the principal dumping-ground, but they svattered it all

over west of the city. At Thircy-first street there was about fifty acres

covered with it, and the place was about three and a half or four miles

south or southwesterly from the court-house in the city. It was at this

place that we first commenced to utilize this material.

I remember when the charter of the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-

pany was obtained from the legislature. At that time Ainsworth fur-

nished the only outlet, or practically the only outlet, tor the offal or

animal matter ot the city. At that time we had been established

69 in this business at Ainsworth about two years, and had about

$50,000 invested in the business. The material was conveyed

there by cars upon the Pittsburgh and Fort Wayne Road, and collected

at the depot at 26th street in the city. As soon as we commenced basi-

ness at Ainsworth we got this ground tor this depot at 26th street;

bought our own cars, and had our own side-tracks in the city and at

Ainsworth. We also built a platform at 26th street, 250 feet long and

40 feet wide, and inclosed the premises with a high fence, 14 or 15 feet

high. To this depot at 26th street the material was brought from the

packing-houses, thrown into the cars we owned, and taken out thence

daily to the factory at Ainsworth. At first we commenced with tive or

six cars a day, but the number increased to ten car-loads a day. From

this depot at 26th street it was taken to Ainsworth; we went through

———

———— = ee

te

_

ee ee ee ee oe 1 Se eee ee Ue ete,

a I a seat cere til,

—_

a

— *%

i ;

RASS POM 2

P

(|

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 35

the town of Hyde Park. There was no way in which this material could

be conveyed to the factory except through the town of Hyde Park, and

by means of the Pittsburgh and Fort Wayne Road. |

About two years ago the Northwestern Fertilizing Company moved

their depot from 26th street to the stock-yards. At the time the North-

western Fertilizing Company was chartered, Ainsworth was the only

outlet tor the offal of the city; and at the time the charter was granted

the process used, and the only known process, in converting the mate-

rial to an agricultural fertilizer was that of spreading it out upon the

ground, as previously described. We began this basiness in the city,

near 31st street, in 1863 or 1864. Our process then was spreading it out

upon the ground until it dried. In 1866 we moved to Ainsworth, and

continued the same process until 1868, when the Northwestern Fertiliz-

ing Company was organized under their charter, and they have

70 continued the business since. We were the only persons that

disposed of and took care of the offal produced between 1863 or

1864 and 1868; and the Northwestern Fertilizing Company is the only

establishment which has taken care of it since, with the exception of the

small amount utilized by Thompson and Edwards at the stock yards,

At the time we carried on business at Thirty-first street, the stench

and offensiveness Was very great, and grew worse and worse every year,

until we had to go away to Ainsworth.

It is admitted by the parties that the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-

pany was duly organized under their charter during the year 1863, and

their business has been carried on under and by means of said organiza-

tion and charter ever since. The copy of the charter, printed as Ex-

hibit A to the complainant’s bill, is admitted to be a true copy of the

charter of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

Cross-examination :

Wahl Brothers & Lightall was the name of our firm at Ainsworth.

We got the charter of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company passed

through the legislature, and theu sold our works and the charter to

Baugh & Sons. We organized the Northwestern Fertilizing Company,

and made the transfers to them. The sale included the real estate and

everything. We received for the sale about $50,000, and as a part of

this transaction we perfected the corporate organization.

I was down at the factory last summer, after the warm weather be-

gan, and | should think they had four or five hundred tons of material

on hand then. February and March, the year before last, they must

have had three or four hundred tons on hand. When the material is

nut into the dryers, it is not filled ; there is not more, probably,

i | than two inches of depth on the bottom of it. The cost or*the

dryers is $1,400 or $1,500 apiece. L consider that the Northwest-

ern Fertilizing Company will be in the best condition, in point of ma-

chinery, that it can be put in when they have dryers enough to dry all

the material as it comes to them daily. As to the vapor or smoke es-

caping into the air from the chimney, I believe that can be overcome.

[ have been at work. at a machine for this purpose for a year, and have

been looking into the question of machinery upon this subject for over

tiftteen years. I have now a double cylinder and machinery for the pur-

pose of controlling the vapor and preventing its escape into the air. It

is experimental yet, out L believe I will succeed. [| have experimented

on this subject to the amount of $10,000, and have often thought I have

obtained the object, but never have yet fully succeeded. I am, how-

ever, still spending mon~y and still trying. I am not familiar with Mr.

36 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS, VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

Allerton’s process. I consider the great trouble about the business of

the Northwestern Fertilizing Company has grown out of the accumula-

tion of material more rapidly than they could dispose of it. Piles thus

accumulated, and gave off offensive odors.

We picked out Ainsworth as the place for carrying ou this business,

because we did not consider it possible to carry on the business at all

without rendering it offensive; and after a thorough investigation of

the country we settled upon Ainsworth as the place that would be least

offensive to the community of any we could find. The only difficulty

with the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, so far as I can point out,

is that in years gone by they did not have machinery enough to work

up the material as fast as it came. The packing-season commences in

October for cattle, and November for hogs, and lasts until the first of

March. With sufficient dryers, the bulk of the business, substantially

all of it, could be done between the Ist of October and Ist of

72 April. If they had machinery enough, there would be no need

of accumulating at one time more than 100 tons. If the material

is reduced in a fresh state there is no stink from the provess. 1 think

the profits would be greater by reducing it in a fresh state.

I left Chicago and went to Ainsworth, because the smell was too bad

for the endurance of the citizens at Chicago. Before we left Chicago

the public indignation was so great that our buildings were burned, as

we supposed, by incendiaries. The feeling was oevasioned by the fact

that the business made such an offensive smell. They have taken more

material down than they had macliinery to dry. If they had inereased

the machinery sufficiently they woald have been able to Keep up with

the supply. LT have no doubt at all of this in my own mind. The ma-

chines for doing this business, which | am interested in, and which we

have been experimenting upon for the last four or five months, consists

of a double cylinder where we can let in the steam between two eylin-

ders. There is a space between the two 24 inches, or so; at the end of

the eylinder is a pump. By the means of a pump the steam is

passed through a series of pipes lying in cold) water, which condenses

it, and it flows away as water; the whole secret consisting in condens-

ing the steam and flowing it off in water instead of allowing it to pass

into the atmosphere. The gas which is in the steam we would burn.

With this machine | hope to solve the problem so that this offensive

business could be carried on anywhere without emitting any odors. — I

have had no experience In working up by machinery what is called the

soft tank-stuff, or livers, lights, and entrails, by means of machinery,

and have not tried to dry this sott tank-stuff in the dryers which Ihave

bought from the Northwestern Fertilizing Company. The mate-

73 rial which I use is of the harder and dryer parts of the animal;

and I dow’t know whether the soft tank-staif could be put through

the tanks at once, when it is taken to the factory, or whether it has to be

mixed with saltcake and other materials prior to drying it. | know

nothing about drying blood, as to whether it can be dried immediately,

by means of the machinery of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company or

by means of any machinery, or whether it has to drain off tirst.

What the manufacturer is trying to save, and what constitutes the

raluable part of the material, is what creates the offensive smell if it

goes into the atmosphere. The agricultural fertilizer which is pro-

duced is valuable in proportion to the amount of aminonia it contains :

and if the material is suffered to decay and decomposition to progress

before it is put into the tanks, what constitutes the offensive smell in

the neighborhood is lost to the manufacturer; and, in order to make it

eoe-—T awae. - — —_——oO «

Sc

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 37

profitable, the manufacturer should dry it as quick as possible, and save

the escape of all the offensive odor which is possible.

The following is about the amount of slaughtering by the city buteh-

ers, Which is not reckoned in the reports of the packing season. This

Slaughtering extends all through the year, and is tor city consumption :

150,000 cattle ; 200,000 hogs ; 200,000 sheep ; aud 20,000 calves. These

animals are slaughtered between the first day of October and the first

day of October again.

Under our process of producing agricultural fertilizers, by spreading

the material out, the dried material analyzed about 12 of ammonia.

The process, since we sold out to the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-

pany, has been constantly improving.

WiLLIAM N. THOMPSON:

I have been engaged in the manufacture of agricultural ferti-

74 lizers for about seven years. My place of business is west of the

stock-yards of Chicago, under the firm-name of Thompson &

Edwards. We are about a mile west of the stock-yards. We consume

from 5,000 to 5,000 tons of animal material in a year, and have recently

adopted the patented, dryer of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

The diagram marked “A,” which is shown me, represents this dryer

with substantial accuracy. We have two of these machines at our

establishment. Before the introduction of these dryers we dried the

animal matter in the open air by fermentation, and by adding chemicals.

We never have handled any blood to speak of. The process, before

we introduced machinery, consisted in piling the material up in piles or

win rows, and applying to it, when piled up, a small percentage of sul-

phateoflime. This wasdone during the winter months or packing season.

The piles were from two to six feet high and from one hundred to three

hundred feet long, and altogether the piles contained, on the first of

March, from two hundred to four hundred tons. The piles were within

six sheds, about six feet through at the bottom and sloping up toa

point, and several hundred feet long. After it is thus piled up, the

chemicals being introduced as it is piled, it is permitted to freeze, and

is left in that manner until the spring months. As the warm weather

comes the tops of the piles dry, and when thus dried it is raked off

from the top and ground. Then the pile is lett again to drv, and the

top again raked off until it all dries. After warm weather comes, say

March or April, we begin to spread it out on the ground, and this pro-

cess of drying and spreading 1t continues all the summer until August

or September, when we get through with our season’s work. Our pro-

cess Was to induce fermentation by the pile, then, as the top had dried,

to spread it out and complete the drying. The sheds were open sheds,

and left open forthe purpose .of giving ventilation through them.

75 [ have seen fertilizing establishments at Wilmington, Delaware ;

Reading, Penn.; Richmond, Va.; Baltimore, Maryland ; and Gor-

donsville, Virginia; but in these establishments the material was dried

betore received by them. The dryer of the Northwestern Fertilizing

Company, so tar as I know, is the first successful invention for drying

animal material. Before making purchases of them I traveled through

the Eastern States and made inquiries at all points where [ could gain

information regardingit. [went to Baltimore, Wilmington, Reading, and

Richmond, and the result of ny investigation convinced me that the patent

process used by the Northwestern Fertilizing Company was the best in the

country, and, acting upon this belief, [ purchased it. We purchased in Jan-

uary last. We receive no blood, but our material is what is known as “ tank-

38 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

stuff.” I have not tested my machine to know whether the soft tank-stuft

ean be put through it immediately. About one-third of the material which

we receive we do not pretend to utilize, but haul it off and throw it away.

This useless material is composed of the softer parts of the animal, like

livers, lights, and entrails; it contains nearly 90 per cent. of water.

What we utilize is what is known as the better class of the tank-stuff,

composed of the harder parts of the animal, meat and bone. There are

no other avenues in the city open for the deposition of the product of

the slaughter-houses except what we take, and what goes to the North-

western Fertilizing Company. Other cities in the country, like Balti-

more, Gordonsville, Richmond, and also Cincinnati, St. Louis, Peoria,

Council Bluffs, and Kansas City, in the West, where the slaughtering

of animals is carried on, have rapidly-running streams inco which the

material can be thrown without creating a nuisance; but Chicago has

no place where the material could be dumped ; if deposited in the

76 lake it will float upon the surface of the water; besides, the cur-

rent of the lake opposite: and near the city makes towards the

shore, which would bring the deposits and lodge them along the margin

of the lake, in the vicinity of the city. I have visited the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company. It was in 1867, and before any of the machinery

was putup. Under the old process the product manufactured contained

about 4 per cent. of ammonia; vow it contains 8 or 9, and is worth now

double what it was worth then.

Cross-examination :

We are endeavoring to arrange to dry the material as fast as we re-

ceive it, but portions of it—the livers, lights, and entrails—are so wet,

I hardly think it is practicable to dry it as soon as it Is received ; it

should drain off. I have had no experience in handling wet stulf.

CHARLES H. WILLIAMS:

I am a director of mines in the State school at Rolla, Missouri; went

there in 1871; but prior to that time was State chemist for the State of

Delaware; was also professor of chemistry in the Polytechnic College

of the State of Pennsylvania, and have been a practical analytical chem-

ist for about 18 years. | have been consulted by the stockholders of the

Northwestern Fertilizing Company for the purpose of advising them

from a professional stand-point. This consultation took place in 1365,

and stayed at the works at Ainsworth about a week. I also visited the

works in July, 1872. Besides, | have been frequentiyv consulted as to

the proper methods to be used, and have analyzed the products of the

factory.

The process of manufacturing a fertilizer out of animal matter consists

simply in vaporizing the water from if, and retaining in it as much am-

monia or phosphate of lime as is practicable.

wi I made an analysis for the Northwestern Fertilizing Company

in 1868. | have visited other tertilizing establishments—Wil-

mington, Communipaw, and New Jersey —in fact the most of the fertil-

izing establishments of the country, as my practice was largely in that

line. When Tl visited the Northwestern Fertilizing Company in 1872

I spent a day there. | found a great improvement had been made since

my previous visit in L868 in the manner of handling the material.

There was a much greater degree of cleanliness about the establishment,

the material not being handled in so careless and wastetul a manner ;

and in its general appearance there was a marked improvement. The

manner of handling the nitrogenous matter had been reduced to a sys-

SG i it ach RNS a TRE,

ver eee Seppe?

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 39

tem, and it was very satisfactory and effective. There are so many dif -

ficulties in the way of this business, that it is not so much a matter of

scientific knowledge as of practical business experience. I analyzed

the material produced by the dryers of the Northwestern Fertilizing

Company. At my last visit | fonnd it to contain from seven to nine

per cent. of ammonia. In 1868 it contained from four to six per cent.

What goes into the air and constitutes the offensive smell are the com-

pounds of nitrogen, or compound of ammonia.

In reference to the analysis made in 1868 and 1872, it is perhaps fair

to say that five per cent. would represent the one, and 8 per cent. the

Other; and the difference between the two shows the saving of the

amount of offensive matter which went into the atmosphere. My ob-

ject in visiting the works was to aid them by my advice and scientific

knowledge. I was asked to go through the establishment and make

suggestions for its improvement, so far as [ could, viewing it froma

scientific standpoint. My object in 1868 was the same, and at my last

visit I was not able to make any suggestions for improvements, although

I did make it a matter of study, care, and thought. They mix

13 with the tank-stuff salt-cake or commercial sulphate of soda. I

should judge about 25 per cent. of this material is added to the

tank stuff. The action of thisis that of a defectant, and arrests and

prevents decomposition. There is sulphuric acid in it, which prevents

decomposition and fixes the ammonia. It is the only commercial article

with which Lam acquainted that could be used for that purpose, and

which would be effective. I think they were using all of this material

that their business would justify.

I examined there, also, matter called dry blood, and have analyzed it

after it came through the dryers. I have not my note-books with me,

but the analysis was made in the sammer of 1871, and yielded some-

thing over 10 per cent. I should think that 500 pounds of sulphuric

acid applied to the dry ton of blood would be sutticient for its coagula-

tion and preservation; and | know of no better process for utilizing

this material than I found in operation at the works of the Northwest-

ern Fertilizing Company in 1872. it is impossible to carry on estab-

lishments of that kind without, to a greater or less degree, creating

offensive odors. It, is impossible even to handle that material in the

laboratory without creating the same odor, to a certain degree; and

the difficulty increases as the quantity is enlarged, because, aside from

other considerations, in the laboratory the cost is no obstacle at all; bat

even there it is impossible to handle it without some odor.

Cross-examination :

The establishments of which I spoke in my examination-in-chief ag

having visited were where the material is parchased after being par-

tially dried and mixed with other materials to make it marketable. I

have never visited but one establishment where they manafacture

a fertilizer out of the raw material, as at the Northwestern Fertiliz-

Ing Company. | never carried on the business.

9 lam a chemist, and have been consulting chemist for a large

number of fertilizing establishments. I have never visited Euro-

pean establishments of this kind, but have read descriptions of them,

and of the manner of handling the material. I don’t know what is be-

ing used to convert animal matter into a fertilizer at Communipaw, nor

do I know that I know all the various processes which may be in use.

At the time I visited the establishment last, it was the 28th or 29th of

July, 1872, they were running some dryers, and preparing others ,

*

oo ee ee. ork ee a eer ere 5 ais Sd ii TiS Bee Bete Be roe 9 a So Ta | I aes i Se aie le en as aaa dita. ies PO Siete CSUR cede fer fr yy

tee’ ( Te 7 6 Bh Ee ee eee it gO eR J a ‘as Neg eS 8 ‘ : Cee Me oe Ci i iets Ue mae on ious 2 : ‘Siete RITES eee +8 Tine Be abl tad a x atl

5 ii a a sa ae cin RS at Sis als SG a ie aR ORs eh SEE SE ota _ arin te 2 “

40 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

There was a considerable amount of animal matter on hand stored

there ; quite a large number of tons. Decomposition in this animal

matter had been arrested, and there was very little offensive smell from

it. The material was partially dry, and I could not tell how it had

smelled before [ went there. The time of my last visit [ was living in

Rolla, Missouri, where L now reside. I was passing through Chicago,

and meeting the gentlemen, was asked to visit the works. The request

was ade by Mr. Ralston. At the time I made this visit the company

was in some trouble, and it was partly with a view of advising with me

as to the improvement of their establishment that [ was asked to stop.

I understood there was a probability of a litigation, and that IT was

asked to make an examination with a view to that fact. [t was also

stated that I was expected to be a witness.

In using salt-cake as a disinfectant the profitableness of the business re-

quires thattbey should not usean extremeamount of it, because it lessens

the value of the product. For instance, if the material contained 10 per

cent. of ammonia, and an equal amount of salt-cake containing no

amount of ammonia should be mixed with it, the percentage ot the

product would be reduced to five per cent. This would lessen the value

of the product, and besides add dead weight to the transportation.

80 JOSEPH LESTER :

My business is to gather up bones and other matter about the city of

Chicago, and convert them into a fertilizer. | have been engaged in

this business, substantially, all my life. | visited the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company in September, 1872; also in the spring of that

year, spending two or three hours there each time. IT went all through

the establishment and examined the material that was lying there, after

it had been mixed with chemicals ; alsothe dried blood and the dryers.

I looked also to the manner in which they handled the material. I

bave visited other establishments like these in New York and New Jer-

sey. Considering the business that was carried on, the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company, when I visited it, was in good condition and

looked very clean. The best thing to be done with the animal matter

is to get it through the dryers as soon as possible. [| don’t consider that

an admixture of chemicals is of material benefit either in preventing

odor or promoting values.

I have had occasion to examine the various kinds of machines in use

in the United States for the manufacture of agricultural fertilizers from

animal matter. I have taken great pains and spent some thousands of

dollars in this investigaiion. Besides I invented one myself, and

worked at it for three years. The diagram A represents the dryer of

the Northwestern Fertilizing Company with substantial accuracy. I

have purchased and am just introducing one into my establishment on

the north branch of the Chicage River, within the city, at Halstead,

Elston avenue, or Elm road.

This machine is the best I have ever seen, in various ways. It has a

more uniform heat, and takes less fire, and is calenlated to make less

offensive smell. Any machine which creates too great a degree

81 of heat produces smell, just as you may cook a piece of beef-steak

slowly without smell, but burn it and you make a smell. Fires

spread all along under the cylinder as represented in the diagram

cause a mild and uniforin heat. After a careful examination, I have

adopted this machine as the best that can be found. So far as I could

judge, the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, from the two visits

»made to it, was carried on as well as that business can be done. With

— 2 —-_ —_———_

~-

— 2 —-_ CC —

~-

ae a AE On eed

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 41

the present experience, and in the present condition of inventions and

machinery for that purpose, it is not pessible to carry on this busi-

ness without creating offensive odors. Improvements are being con-

stantly made, and it is probable that in time all obstacles will be over-

come. The Northwestern Fertilizing Company have taken more trouble

and pains and spent more money than anybody I know of to carry on

this business without offensiveness,

I am acquainted with the tank-stuff as it comes out from the tanks,

Decomposition immediately takes place. It sets in as soon as the heat

is out of it. In from three to four hours offensive odors begin to arise

in the tank stuff. This results just as soon as it begius to cool.

From a knowledge of the location of the depot of the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company at the stock-yards, and of the various slaughter-

houses in the city, it would be impossible to get the tank-stuff hauled

from these slaughter-houses to the depot at the stock-yards before de-

composition would set in. After decomposition has commenced the ad-

mixture of chemicals will not destroy that decomposition or the effects

of it; but the only tendency of chemicals is to prevent future decompo-

sition. In reference to the decomposition which has begun, the only

way to get rid of it is to put it through the dryer. The establishments

which I visited in the East had no machinery for the utilization

82 of this material, but their process consisted in admixing chemi-

‘als with it and spreading it out to dry. I, know of no machine

which has been so far tested as to render its suceess certain to dry an-

imal matter immediately as it comes from the tanks, except the dryers

of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company. There have been many at-

tempted, and with a great show of success, but they have been failures.

There was the steam dryer, but that did not heat the material enough

to prevent decomposition after it passed through; and there was one

that raked the stuff, but it was too slow. There is another man here

now. He was at Reed & Sherwin’s with one, and bis institution was @

failure. His name was Storer, and he is from Boston. It was a failure.

They burned the material clear up The gentleman is now experiment-

ing with a machine upon the same principle, with fires passing through

the cylinder, lined with fire-brick. I don’t think this machine will work

as well as that of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

The mode of utilizing thé animal matter tormerly was to spread it out

upon the prairie. The slaughter-houses, in early days, were mainly on

the South Branch; some on the North Branch. Before the Northwestern

Fertilizing Company furnished au outlet, the offal lay in piles along the

side of the slaughter-houses, and when it got too bad they earried it

farther off on the prairie and dumped it in piles. In this way it stretched

along all the way west and south of the city, and south of Archer read.

It was piled up two feet thick all along here. There is in that region

land made by the decay of this matter a foot and a half thick—earthy

matter made of the decay of the animal matter. This was deposited

from 1860 to 1868. Always, until the canal was deepened and the cur-

rent of the river turned into it, the river was foul and in a feariul con-

dition. The reason was that the offal of the slaughter-houses got

83 into it. The city has no natural drainage, except the river, and

that is sluggish, and empties in the lake within the city, after

flowing through it. Other cities in the United States where slaughlter-

ing is done have natural drainage of rapidly-flowing rivers. In New

York tide-water will take anything ont without creating a nuisance.

At Commumpaw there are large slaughter-houses, but the tide-water

takes off the offal in New York Bay, and runs it down to Staten Island.

42 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

The livers, lungs, and lights, at New York, which will float, are car-

ried out to sea, and the wind and the tides scatter them. The distance

to take them out is nearly five miles. The blood is run into the ocean

right at the slaughter-hovse, and what is taken out to sea by the tide,

or what is put into the ocean at the slaughter-houses, makes no contam-

ination or nuisance.

Commumpaw is only about four miles from New York. AtSt. Louis

everything is run into the river, and there is current enough to take it

otf without its becoming offensive.

sross-examination :

I am not a theoretical chemist, but my opinion is, as I have expressed

it, that deodorizing the material does not do any good; and my theory

of handling this material is that it should be put through the drying-

machine as soon as possible. If it is put through before decomposition

takes place, there would be little or no offensive odor; but if the material

is allowed to accumulate, with the idea of deodorizing it, the result will

be that the amount of offensiveness will be increased.

Rh. W. RALSTON:

Iam vice-president of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company,and have

been either secretary or vice-president since its organization. I

84 have also had the practical management and control of the affairs of

the company since its organization. Edwin Baugh, the president

of the company, has visited Chicago about once a month, and the busi-

ness has been conducted by myself in consultation with him.

I am practically acquainted with the business of manufacturing fertil-

izers from animal matter, and have been engaged in the business ever

since 1867; for two vears previous to 1867 1 was engaged in a business

similar in Philadelphia.

The Northwestern Fertilizing Company is located north of the Fort

Wayne Railroad, at a place called Ainsworth, or what is now known as

South Chicago. The company was organized on Monday, December 9th,

1867, and since that time the organization has been kept up, and it has

been operated as an incorporated company. It has a president, vice-

president, secretary, and treasurer; and its office or place of business is

in the city of Chieago. It has a capital of 250,000 dollars, $247,000 of

which has been paid in. The first $50,000 of the capital stock was paid

in by the purchase and transfer to the company of the works’and grounds

of Wahl Brothers and Lightall, at Ainsworth, and the balance, making

in all $25",000, has since been subseribed, and 8247,000 paid in.

When we took possession of the factory of Wahl Bros. & Lightall at

Ainsworth, they had open sheds about 300 feet wide and 400 long.

These sheds were made of upright posts and a roof. The material was

piled up in the winter under these sheds and in the open air, and in

the summer spread out on planks and on the ground; they had about

10 acres of ground, Under their system the drying was done exclusively

in the summer, and by spreading the material out and exposing it to

the sun and air.

85 I went to the works on the 5th of July, at the time we took

possession, and the sheds of Wahl Bros. & Lighthall were then

filled with material whieh had been taken out the winter before, and

about one-half of the two acres of ground covered with planks was also

covered with material piled upon it. The piles in the shed extended the

entire length of them; when the material was spread out it covered two

acres, upon which planks had been spread, and two acres more upon

4

Cs < i Si p " ee ee i ce aes - ‘ . is t

eeieenlada danke arm Ca Se si te ee

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 43

which there were no planks. It was spread about four inches deep at

that time.

The harder parts of the animal, like the heads and legs, trimmings of

meat, and bone, were steamed at the packing-houses, but the livers and

lungs came in the natural state. Whatever came in the natural state

Was put into large vats and steamed by Wahl Bros. & Lightall at the

factory. Those tanks were six by six, and four feet deep. They ocen-

plied about four feet on eaeh side of the track; six feet wide and four

feet deep. The livers and lights. and so forth, put into these tanks were

heated by steam; after being thus heated the water was drained off

into a catch basin, about 100 feet in length, and 10 feet deep; aud from

this catch-basin it was drawn off into the river. In the bottom of these

vats a sediment was constantly accumulating which, after the water was

drawn off, was taken out and spread upon the ground and dried. We

continued the same process for about two vears, and used the same vats

as the Wahl Brothers did. The third year we buried the livers, lungs,

and soft parts, because we thought it cheaper to do so than to steam

and uti ize them.

The most valuable and least offensive part of animal offal is the blood.

The better class ot offal consists of the head, bones, back-bone trim-

mings, and other trimmings from hams, shoulders, and generally

86 the harder parts of the animal, excluding the livers, lungs, and

entrails. The third class in value are the livers, entrails, and

lungs; and the least valuable is blood that is mixed with water in wash-

ing out the vats. The livers, lungs, and entrails are not worth utiliz-

ing, and we should not take them if we could get rid of them in any other

way. We buried in the way I speak of about 300 car-loads from the

proceeds of one winter’s slaughtering.

During the two years we steamed out in tanks the livers, lungs, and

entrails, and our mode of utilizing was that of spreading out the mate-

rial like Wahl Brothers; we then got a machine, costing us about $5,000,

for the purpose of cutting up livers, lungs, and pressing them. These

soft parts naturally contain too much water to be easily utilized, and

steaming them adds more water. By cutting them up we thought we

could save the water added by the steaming process. During these two

vears, also, we enclosed the sheds and erected three, four, and five story

buildings. The machine for cutting up the livers was a powerful ma-

chine witha capacity of 100 tonsa day; it was on the same principle as

the sausage-cutter. The object was to cut the material into very fine

parts and then press it tor the purpose of pressing the water out of it.

The process proved a failure.

We then tried to dry the material by steaming. The idea was to heat

the material by passing steam around it, but not through it. That was

slow and proved a failure, and we cast it aside.

We next tried the building of a large furnace and a pump, forcing

heated air around shelves upon which the material was placed. That

didn’t succeed. Then we bought a large, powerful brick-press, and tried

to press the material into the form of bricks, intending then to dry if in

the sun; but we found after it had laid for six or eight months it

S7 was still wet, and we sold out the machinery for old iron. We

then tried a revolving cylinder, and worked a long time before we

could get it to run successtully. The hot air passing through caused

contraction and expansion, and we could not regulate it. It was con-

stantly breaking down, but we succeeded, after repeated experiments

and great difficulty, in finishing the drying of the material which had

been partly dried in the sun, thus furnishing it in this revolving cylin-

der with the heat which we forced through and around it.

VS dae RSCTA OR BED AAR EE I dR chai

46 N W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

and the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, the Union Rendering Com-

pany being to the left of the factory and the Northwestern Fertilizing

Company at the right.

Photograph D is a portion of the Calumet River, and the ground ad-

joining the slough. This shows something of the drains used by Wabl]

Brothers, but we do not use it now at all.

Photograph E represents the railroad-track, and on the right of ita

pile of tank-stuff. This photograph represents the present situation at

the factory. These piles are hard, and the horse on the top, in the pho-

| tograph, was put there to show that the pile is firm and solid. :

| F represents the building in part, and tank material, and the road- :

| way by the side of the building, and the planks of Wahl Brothers, as

laid down for drying purposes. G represents a portion of the building

| on both sides of the tract, and the railroad-track running through be-

| tween the buildings. The pile ou the right that is enclosed is’ blood.

The pile on the left is blood. There is no drainage from piles of blood

like these except wh

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Record and brief — The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, Plaintiff in Error, vs. The Village of Hyde Park, Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, L. G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, L. Bradner, and H. Vanderbilt, Trustees of Said Village. 1878: V | Frix