Record and brief — James Brown, et al. Appellants, vs. Enoch Piper Appellee
Supreme Court brief1875
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
JAMES BROWN, ET AL.
APPELLANTS,
Vs.
mer PrPirerm
ATrrE LA. Ss.
GEO. GIFFORD,
hor 4 lL ppellants.
EDWARD AVERY, | )
JERSEY CITY:
EVENING JOURNAL PRINT, 142 & 144 GREENE STREET.
1s75.
&
ess *
Rie
paake &
ar er e
.
» Qnited States Supreme Gourt.
. 7“ ‘
+
ee eee
JAMES BROWN ET AL.
Appellants.
gs
ENOCH PIPER,
A ppellee.
This is an appeal from a decree of the Circuit Court
of the First Circuit, District of Massachusetts, in a suit in
equity.
The suit was brought for-an alleged infringement of
two letters-patent; one No. 732, and the other No.
36,107. Only No. 732. is relied upon. This is for a
process consisting of preserving articles in a close apart-
ment by means of a freezing mixture not in contact with
the atmosphere of the preserving apartment.
The patent is printed at pages 74, 75 and 76 of the
Record.
The bill was in the usual form in such cases, and was
filed January 4, 1868.
The answer denied the novelty of the alleged inven-
tion.
A APNE VARI RDA RBA SITIES PIA 8
PPS S
2
The case was heard on pleadings and proofs, and de-
cided October 25, 1870.
The opinion of the Court is printed in the Record at
page 566.
* + . > a
A decree pursuant to this opinion was entered Novem-
ber 10, 1870, referring the case to a Master to take an
account of profits. This decree is printed in the Record
at page 10.
The Master proceeded to take an account, and submit-
ted to the respective counsel a draft report.
The counsel for the Appellants then addressed to the
Master a petition for leave to introduce further evidence,
which petition is printed at page 27 of the Record.
The counsel for the Appellants filed objections to the
draft report, which are printed at pages 27 to 29 of the
Record ; he also filed requests for specific findings, as per
Schedule K, page 29 of the Record.
The Master filed, February 7, 1872, a report, of which
a draft had been submitted to respective counsel, and
also at the same time an additional report, in which ad-
ditional report the Master refused to admit further testi-
mony, as prayed for in the petition of Appellants’
counsel, alleging as a reason that, as matter of law, it was
not competent for him to hear further evidence or grant
the petition. This additional report is printed at page
24 of the Itecord, and the refusal of the Master at page
24, folio 40.
The counsel tor Appellants filed exceptions March 30,
1872, to the Master’s report, which are printed at page
72.
a
a
_——_— ~
a
The case was heard on exceptions to the Master’s re-
port, and decided February 10, 1873.
The opinion of the Court delivered thereon is printed
in the Record at page 571, and the decree entered pursu-
ant thereto overruling the exceptions and confirming the
Master’s report, is printed at page 73 of the Record.
ASSIGNMENT OF ERRORS.
The Court below erred—
I. In deciding that the use by Charles I. Pike and
Otis P. Underwood of the patented process was only an
abandoved esperiment, and not sufficient to invalidate
the Piper patent.
lJ. In deciding that the process described in the Eng-
lish patent to Benjamin & Grafton, enrolled July 27,
1842, differs from that patented by the Appellee, and in
deciding that in the Benjamin & Grafton patent there is
no deseription that the freezing mixture contained in the
vessels in the preserving chamber is to be kept free from
contact with the atmosphere of the chamber itself.
III. In deciding that Gardiner T. Swartz did not use
the patented process prior to the time of the invention of
it by the Appellee.
IV. In not deciding that Joseph H. Racey, Jr., had the
patented process in use in Centre Market, in the City of
New York, in 1856, 1857, 1858.
V. In deciding that a use by Joseph H. Racey, Jr., in
t
the latter part of 1859 would be more than a year after
the Appellee’s invention.
’
VI. In holding that to ante-date the invention of’ the
Appellee it was necessary for the prior use to have been
such as to freeze the article in the preserving chamber, or
such as to reduce the temperature in the preserving
chamber below the freezing point of water.
VIt. In deciding that the patent granted to Appellee,
dated March 19, 1861, is a good and valid patent, and
that the Appellee had a right to recover from the Appel-
lants for the use of the alleged invention, and in referring
the case to a Master to take an account, and in granting
an injunction restraining the Appellants from using the
alleged invention.
VIII. In overruling the Appellants’ exceptions taken
to the Master’s report.
WLI A.
woo we
Construction of the Patent.
The first question in order is, what is the scope of
Appellee’s patent? To determine what is patented,
particular attention must be given to two parts of the
specification of the patent; the first is where the inventor
announces to the public what invention he has made, and
er
5
defines its nature; the second is the claim in which he sums
up by again defining what he intends to patent.
In Appellee’s patent in this case those two controlling
parts of the specification exactly agree with each other.
In the statement by the patentee of the nature of his
invention, he says :—
“The nature of my invention consists in a
method of preserving fish and other articles by
placing them within a chamber and cooling the
latter by means of a freezing mixture, so applied
that no communication shall exist between the
interior of the preserving chamber and that of the
vessels in which the freezing mixture is placed.”
He, for the purpose of further defining his alleged
invertion, and having it seen in contrast with what he
assumed was the old method, states what he understood
to be the only old method, thus :— :
* Hitherto the only method in use for preserving
this kind of fish in a fresh state, has been to pack
them with crushed ice in barrels or boxes. - This
method, however, owing to the melting of the ice
and the consequent moistening of the fish, fails to
preserve them fresh and good for more than a
month at most; whereas, by my new method and
treatment they can be kept as fresh and sweet as
when first caught, and for any desirable length of
time, even for years.”
He then, in conclusion, ignores all limitation to any
particular fend of apparatus, and all limitation to pre-
liminary freezing or coating, and asserts his claim in
absolute and unequivocal terms, thus :—
6
“Preserving fish or other articles in a close
chamber by means of a freezing mixture having
no contact with the atmosphere of the preserving
chamber, substantially as set forth.”
The patent is for preserving an article in an apartment
cooled by a freezing mixture not in contact with the at-
mosphere of that apartment. The article need not be
frozen to be within the patent. The preliminary freez-
ing, which the patentee states his patent is not to be lim-
ited to, is the only freezing provided for by the patent.
Therefore, as the patent is not limited to that preliminary
freezing, it is not limited to any freezing, but is a patent
for merly preserving an article whether frozen or not,
and this exactly avrees with what the patentee states the
nature of his invention is, and with what he claims,
and this is the only view which can be taken consistently
with that statement or that claim. The specification says,
“The fish are then packed closely together in a large
preserving box ;” but it does not say they are to be packed
in a frozen state; besides, as this preliminary freezing
may, according to the patent, be dispensed with, this being
done they would not be frozen when packed in the pre-
serving chamber. ‘The patent has no more to do with
freezing than it would have had if the word freeze or
frozen had not been used in the specification at all. The
patent no more requires the article to be treated to be
frozen than it does for it to be cooked.
II.
The thing patented.
It is plain and certain—
7
1st. That the thing patented is a process.
2d. That it is not limited-to any particular kind of
apparatus, but includes the doing of the thing by any
kind of apparatus in which the air of the preserving
chamber is excluded from the freezing mixture.
The patent twice distinctly disclaims any limitation to
the kind of apparatus described [folios 129 and 130 of
the Record]. The patentee first says, the apparatus
“may be constructed in various ways and of different
shapes ;” and then, after describing an apparatus, adds,
‘“‘T do not desire to be understood as confining myself to
39
oe
the use of the specific apparatus above described
sd. That the process patented consists of the act of
“ preserving fish or other articles in a close chamber, by
means of a freezing mixture having no contact with the
atmosphere of the preserving chamber.”
Such is the invention patented. The addition to the
claim of the words “substantially as set forth ” does not
restrict or modify the claim beyond what is above stated,
because, on referring to the description, nothing is found
which limits the scope of the claim beyond what is above
stated.
The specification explains that the method “substan-
tially as set forth” consists of placing the article to be
preserved “ within a chamber and cooling ” it “ by means
of a freezing mixture so applied that no communication
shall exist between the interior of the preserving chamber
and the freezing mixture.” That is the way substantially
set forth.
The process patented includes the doing of the thing
by the use of any kind of apparatus in which the article
2
¥
*
%
>
4
=
DIV aNEE em tubo tek
oe ee -
Ry:
8
to be treated is in a close vessel, the atmosphere of which
is not in contact with the freezing mixture. If the arti-
cle to be preserved is ina close vessel, the operation is
equally within the patent, whether the freezing mixture
is piled up on such close vessel, or is in another vessel
and surrounds the close vessel, or is enclosed in a vessel
placed within the preserving chamber. Whenever an
article is preserved in a close vessel by the use of a freez-
ing mixture, which freezing mixture is not in contact
with the air contained in the close vessel, the patented
process is practiced. If the article to be treated be en-
closed in a vessel, and the freezing mixture be enclosed
in another vessel, and this latter vessel be placed in the
former one, and the article be thus frozen or preserved,
the patented process is used; also, if a freezing mixture
be placed in a vessel either open or enclosed, and the ar-
ticle to be treated be enclosed in another vessel, and this
latter vessel be placed within the former, and the article
be thus treated or preserved, tlhe patented process is used.
So, too, if a fish or other article to be treated be enclosed
in a vessel setting on the floor, and the freezing mixture
be piled up around the vessel, and the fish or other arti-
cle to be treated be tlius frozen or preserved, it would be
using the patented process.
Such is plainly the scope of the patent, and such is the
construction given it by Judge Shepley, who decided this
case in the Court below. Judge Shepley, in his opinion,
says :-—
“The complainant’s bill claims as his invention
an ‘|mprovement in the method of preserving fish
and other articles.’ The method claimed is des-
cribed as ‘A method of preserving fish or other
artecles, by placing them within a chamber and
9
cooling the latter by means of a freezing mixture,
so applied that no communication shall exist be-
tween the interior of the preserving chamber and
that of the vessel in which the freezing mixture is
placed.’ The patent describes it as ‘ A new and
useful method of preserving fish.? The claim in
the patent is ‘ Preserving fish or other articles in a
close chamber by means of a freezing mixture,
having no contact with the atmosphere of the pre-
serving chamber substantially as set forth.’ ”
This construction of the patent by the learned Judge
is correct. His error was in not making a correct appli-
cation of the facts proved to the patent so construed. In
considering the prior inventions, he seems to have lost
sight of the fact that the process patented is for preserv-
ing the article whether frozen or not frozen.
Now let us see what essentials this patented process is
composed of. !
Ist. There must be an article to preserve.
2d. It must be in a close chamber. -
3d. There must be a freezing mixture.
4th. The freezing mixture must have substantially no
contact with the atmosphere of the chamber in which the
article to be preserved is placed.
5th. The article in the preserving chamber must by
a...
these means be preserved.
® Wherever and whenever these five things are found
together the patented process is employed. If the five
things be present no one need look further for the pat-
ented process.
eRe obi co Oh, oe cae aaiatial
See uy v Pram » / 0
10
The process patented being composed of the five ele-
ments or parts above enumerated, it follows that wherever
these elements are found in combination, there the pat-
ented process will be found, whether it be in an alleged
infringement or in a prior use. There must be an article
to be operated upon, a place for that article, a condition
of that place, an agency to extract caloric from that place,
a certain relation between the article to be preserved and
the agency for extracting the heat, and a preservation of
the article. Wherever those parts and conditions exist,
there is the patented invention. If they were in exist-
ence together prior to the time of the alleged invention
of Mr. Piper, then his patent, like many others from
BhetEh Ce: RICY
ITI.
What the patent 1s not limited to.
similar causes, is invalid.
1st. It is certainly immaterial to the patent as to what shall
be the size of the preserving chamber, or of what mate-
rial it shall be composed, or how thick or thin its sides
shall be. The patent has no limitation to anything of
that kind.
2d. It is not limited to any kind of apparatus, except
that the preserving chamber must be “close” and in such
relation to the* freezing mixture receptacle (which need
not be close) that the latter can extract caloric from the
former.
3d. It is not limited to any kind of article to be pre
served ; it includes the preservation of ice as fully as it
does of fish.
11
4th. It is not limited to any particular length of time
of preserving it.
5th. It is not limited to any particular temperature.
6th. It is not limited to treating a single kind of arti-
cle at one time. It includes preserving any number of
kinds of articles at the same time, and one of them may
be ice.
7th. It is not limited to freezing articles or preserving
them in a frozen state, but covers the preserving of them
by the means described, whether frozen or not.
The patent nowhere says that the article to be pre-
served must be frozen, nor does it describe conditions of
the operation from which, of necessity, the article to be
preserved must be frozen. It first states that the nature
of the “ invention consists in a method of preserving fish
and other articles by placing them within a chamber and
cooling the latter by means of a freezing mixture.” It
does not say to what degree it is to be cooled. Then,
after describing apparatus, it adds, “the temperature
of the preserving chamber can be maintained for-any
length of time below the freezing point, and fish sur-
rounded by this dry and freezing atmosphere will be pre-
served,” etc. This is a statement only of what can, not
of what must be done. It is not given as a limitation of
the process patented to a temperature below or at the
freezing point. It simply states what was well known,
that is, that by the use of a freezing mixture you can cool
the air in the interior of a vessel down to below the freez-
ing point. Cooling the interior of the preserving chamber
down to 34 degrees and preserving an article in it would
be as much an infringement of the patent as cooling it
down to 30 degrees.
s
*
TH temas
12
Preserving fruit by such means and in such apparatus
would be within the patent. Refrigerator railroad cars,
which are extensively used for the transportation and
preservation of fruit, have the interior of their preserving
apartments cooled by freezing mixtures, but, of course,
not cooled down to below the freezing point.
The learned Judge in stating the claim, said the claim
was—
“For the method of preserving fish or other
articles in a close chamber, by means of a freezing
mixture having no contact with the atmosphere of
the preserving chamber.”
What, now, is the evidence is this case of prior uses of
the process patented by Piper ?
IV.
The invention and use of the pa-
tented process by Charles F. Pike
constitute a full and complete de-
fence against the Piper patent.
The law announced several times by this Court, and
once as recently as at the last term, applied to the facts
fully proved and expressly found by the Court below,
independently of any other defence, entirely invalidates
the patent.
The law referred to as announced at the last term is in
Coffin vs. Ogden, 18 Wallace, 120. The facts proved
and found by the Court are the completion of an appara-
Ce DO me
13
tus suitable to work the process, and an actual practice of
the process itself by Pike and Underwood prior to the
invention by Piper.
Charles I’. Pike caused an apparatus to be constructed
in Providence, R. I., in the fall of 1855 or spring of
1856, for freezing animal substances, which contained a
metallic vessel for a freezing mixture and a preserving
chamber, the interior of the freezing mixture vessel not
communicating with the atmosphere of the preserving
chamber. This apparatus is described by Mr. Pike [page
529, ans. 8], and by Otis P. Underwood, who helped to
construct it :—‘“‘It was a full-sized practical apparatus ”
[page 517, ans. 8].
This apparatus was used for freezing a variety of ar-
ticles, such as meats, fruit and fish. [page 516, ans. 7, and
page 530, the latter part of ans. 8]. The freezing mix-
ture used was ice and salt, and when in operation for
freezing there was no contact between the freezing mix-
ture and the atmosphere of the preserving chamber | page
516, ans. 8 and 10, and page 530, latter part of ans. 8].
The articles were put into the chamber in an unfrozen
state and taken out thoroughly frozen [page 518, ans. 23,
24, 25 and 26]. This apparatus was completed ready for
practical use without anything more being done to it. The
process of freezing articles in it by the use of it was suc-
cessfully performed, and needed nothing added to or. ta-
ken from it to adapt it to general use. Further uses of
it to any practical extent would have been simply repeti-
tions of the use which was made of it. The invention,
therefore, was not only completed ready for use, but it
was actually and successfully used. This, according to
the law applied by this Court in the case of Coffin vs.
e 14
Ogden, was going further than was necessary to invali-
date the Piper patent. In that case this Court says :—
“The invention or discovery relied upon as a
defence must have been complete and capable of
producing the result songht to be accomplished,
and this must be shown by the Defendant. The
burden of proof rests upon him, and every reas-
onable doubt should be resolved against him. If
the thing were embryotic or inchoate ; if it rested
| in speculation or experiment; if the process pur-
i sued for its development had failed to reach the
point of consummation, it cannot avail to defeat a
: patent founded upon a discovery or invention
| which was completed, while in the other case
was only progress, however near that progress may
have approximated to the end in view. The law
requires not conjecture, but certainty. If the
question relate to a machine, the conception must
have been clothed in substantial forms, which de-
monstrate at once its practical efficacy and utility.
Se oe nh Se 1
The prior knowledge and use by a single person
is sufficient. The number is immaterial.”
wire
Pike’s invention was not embryotic or inchoate; it did
not rest in speculation ; the operation pursued for its de-
velopment did not fail to reach the point of consumma-
tion. His invention was not only completed, capable of
producing the result sought, but it was actually used and
produced that result, and this to the satisfaction of the
FC} SCCourrt below.
The learned Judge in the Court. below admits and says
that the Pike apparatus was completed, and that the pro-
cess was practiced. He says, in his opinion [page 570], “the
+ ° =) ae, | aire
15
Plaintiff's process was once practiced,” but holds that it
was only an experiment, and was abandoned. This is an
admission that the invention was completed, and had a
practical existence. This is all which this Court in the
case cited required. What was done by Pike and Under-
- wood was not an experiment made in pursuit of a thing
and abandoned before attaining it; if an experiment, it
was only an experiment in reducing the thing to practice,
illustrating its completion and proving it successful.
This having been done, the invention was complete, and
its completion was shown in the most. satisfactory man-
ner, which was by reducing it to practice. An abandon-
ment by the inventor in such case is not an abandonment
to an individual, but an abandonment to the public. Pike
had the invention, and if he abandoned it, he abandoned
it not to Piper, but to the public.
It is respectfully submitted that the invention of Pike
as proved, and as found by the Court below, is sufficient
to invalidate the Piper patent, and that the Court will
have no occasion to look further into the case.
Sf) a ‘4~ 4 y
~ Ne Aatrte 2 feet AL-e JSatted wv ted ast, | Nlatl
Wlritely # SP 4 vie 7 ZV atl-
. Agacrare Cr, ofordun, 7 Was
The English patent to Benjamin
& Grafton, [pages 557 and 558,]
contained a sufficient description
of the process patented by Appel-
lee, to ante-date his patent.
That patent was for preserving animal and vegetable
matters, by freezing or cooling them by the aid of freez-
ing mixtures, and the invention, as stated in the speci-
fication, was “ particularly applicable to preserving fish.”
16
The specification provides—
Fwst.—For a preliminary freezing of the fish, by the
use of a freezing mixture.
Second.—For preserving them in a frozen state, by a
continued application of the freezing mixture in the same
way it was applied to freeze them.
Third.—Preserving them in a frozen state in a close
chamber or apartment, the atmosphere of which was
cooled by a freezing mixture.
The preliminary freezing was done by putting the fish
in a metallic vessel, filling it with water, and depositing
it in a mixture of pulverized ice and salt. When the fish
were to be preserved in a frozen state in a close chamber,
the fish, after being frozen, were put into the chamber in
baskets, or on slabs, and the atmosphere of the close
chamber was cooled by coming in contact with the sur-
faces of metallic vessels containing freezing mixtures.
The cooling was facilitated by agitating the atmosphere
within the chamber by means of revolving fans, or other
suitable means, within the chamber, causing it thereby
to be brought more than it otherwise would, in contact
with the surfaces of the freezing mixture vessels, so that
the moisture taken up by the air would become frozen on
the surfaces of the freezing mixture vessels.
The specification states that by the means described,
“the fish will be kept cool and preserved, and if it has
been previously frozen, as before described, the keeping
it in a room or chamber, as here described, would retain
it in a frozen state.”
The Court below, disposed of this English patent by
17
holding that “there is no description that the freezing
mixture contained in the vessels in the preserving cham-
ber, is to be kept free from contact with the atmosphere
of the chamber itself” [page 570].
It is true the specitication does not in terms directly
state that there is to be no contact between the freezing
mixture and the atmosphere of the preserving chamber,
but the implication that such was the case is quite as
strong as the statement to that effect would have been.
The object of the patentees in bringing the air in contact
with the metallic surface of the vessels within the cham-
ber containing the freezing mixtures was to remove
moisture from the air by causing it to be frozen on those
surfaces. |
The liquefaction of the ice and salt furnishes vapor to
the atmosphere which is in contact with the ice and salt.
To have left the freezing mixture in contact with the at-
mosphere of the chamber would obviously have been the
most effectual way of defeating the object in view. No
man of common sense, having in view freeing the air
from moisture, would attempt to do it by means adapted
to supply it with moisture.
The specification of the patent is addressed to at least
common sense, and to attempt to free the atinosphere of
an apartment from moisture, and at the same time to
open a pool of water in contact with it, would not be in
accordance with, but contrary to, the exercise of common
judgment.
If a specification were describing a means of drying an
article, it would not be necessary for it to say that, during
the operation, no water must be poured on the article,
r y
nor is it necessary, when a specification is describing a
means of freeing the air of an apartment from vapor, for
it to state that no means should be at the same time em-
ployed for supplying it with vapor.
VI. .
Gardiner T. Swartz, in his use of
the Good apparatus for preserving
dead bodies, practiced the process
patented by Appellee.
He states that he used the Good apparatus for freezing
bodies, and, as nearly as he could remember, twenty .
years before the time of his examination [page 511, q. 4,
5], and that his freezing mixture was ice and salt [q. 6].
One of the ways in which he used the Good apparatus
for freezing the bodies of children was to have them sup-
ported in the chamber sufficiently high to bring them near-
ly up to the pan containing the freezing mixture, and there
being no contact between the freezing mixture and the
atmosphere of the chamber. This was one of the several
ways in which he used the apparatus “ ever since” he first
bought it, which is, as nearly as he recollects, in 1847
[page 512, Q. 12, 18 and 14, and page 513, X-Q. 1].
Lhe Court below admitted that the Good apparatus |
. ° : |
was capable of king the patented process [page 569, e |
fol. 958], but disposes of the testimony of Swartz by sta-
ting [page 570] that the witness is “ indefinite as to date,
and leaves it uncertain whether he ever produced the at- [
>
19
mosphere in the chamber below the freezing point of wa-
ter. This object was not to freeze the body so as to pre-
serve it forany length of time, but only by partially
freezing the surface to arrest the progress of decomposi-
*
tion.”’
It is understood that the indefiniteness of date refer-
red to by the learned Judge relates to the date of jfreez-
ing the body, and not to the date of preserving it un-
frozen.
It is respectfully submitted that, under a proper con-
struction of Appellee’s patent, it is entirely immaterial
whether Swartz produced a temperature of the atmos-
phere in the chamber below the freezing point of water,
or whether the body was frozen therein little or much, or
none at all, so long as it was preserved therein, as Swartz
said he did it, with no contact between the atmosphere
of the ‘chamber and the freezing mixture which was in
the pan isolated from that atmosphere.
The disposition which the learned Judge made of the
testimony of the witness Swartz was obviously caused by
his erroneously assuming that, to bring his practice with-
in the Appellee’s patent, the body must have been frozen.
VIL.
Joseph H. Kacey, Jr., used the
process patented by Appellee dur-
ing the years 1856, 1857 and 1858.
=Oy 4
The testimony of Racey’s use in the years 1856, 18°47
and 1858 seems to have been entirely ignored. by the
Jearned Judge of the Court below. For what reason
s
20)
does not very clearly appear; but it is believed that it was
because the testimony shows that in Racey’s use of his
apparatus during those years he put ice in the box with
the fish, and that the Court assumed that the preservation
of the fish in the presence of ice in the same chamber
with the fish was not practicing Appellee’s patented pro-
cess.
It is respectfully submitted that such an assumption is
erroneous, and that preserving fish in the presence of ice
in the preserving chamber is as fully within the Appellee’s
patent as preserving fish without the presence of ice. It
would be strange indeed if, while one were infringing
Appellee’s patent by preserving fish in a frozen or un-
frozen state in an apartment cooled by a freezing mix-
ture not in contact with the atmosphere of the apartment
without any ice in it, the infringement would be avoided
by putting a lump of ice in the apartment with the fish.
Even Appellee’s expert, Henry B. Renwick [page 91,
cross-question 43], was compelled to admit that, having
ice in the preserving apartment with the fish, and reducing
the temperature below the freezing point of water, would
be an infringement of Appellee’s patent, and, therefore, if
practiced prior to Appellee’s invention, would ante-date
and invalidate his patent.
During those years Racey had in use an apparatus in
Centre Market consisting of a large box with a zine pan in
the top of it, in which zine pan was a freezing mixture,
and in the box fish were preserved by the cooling agency of
the freezing mixture, the freezing mixture having no
contact with the atmosphere of the box.
An end view of this box is represented on page 90 of
the Record.
eo
=
we
»-
/
ea
q
JosEPH H. Racry, Jr, for many years a fish dealer in
the city of New York, testifies to such use of that appa-
g 21
ratus [page 309], thus :—
Q. 38. When did you first attempt to freeze fish
— artificially ?
- A. In 1856 and 1857.
q. 4. Where?
A. In Centre Market.
Q. 5. Will you please state what you then did ?
A. I froze Spanish mackerel—the first fish I
ever froze. Spanish mackerel run from one and
a half pounds to four pounds; some weigh as high
as seven pounds, but the general run is about
‘ three and a half pounds.
. Q. 6. Will you please state the manner in which
| you first froze Spanish mackerel, as stated in your
last answer?
A. The box [I built first to keep lobsters; at
that time [ used to sell from 500 pounds to 1,500
pounds of lobsters on a Saturday, and in order to
keep the water off the lobsters, I placed a pan on the
top of the box; the inside measurement of the box
was seven feet long, seven feet high, and five or
| six feet wide; I erected a zinc pan inside the box,
- on the top part, and making a shoulder:so as to
nail it, and made the pan slanting from the top,
and went down in the centre on to the rear of the
® box; there was a joist on the top, in front of the
pan, to hold it up; I have a model of the box
which I will put in as an exhibit.
29
I put a layer of ice in first, and then a layer of
Spanish mackerel, and so on until I got it up nearly
to the pan, with ice ground by a machine; in the
morning when I came there, the mackerel nearest
the pipes and pan were most frozen. In the top
pan I put salt and ice—ground ice and salt, mixed.
In 1857, I tried it on one salmon; on the 29th
day of April or June, 1857, I shipped the salmon
to General Sickles, at Washington; the salmon
was not frozen in the style we freeze them now;
the salmon was very hard, but would give; it was
frozen to a certain extent. I continued the same
process for three years, 1856, 1857 and 1858. I
sold some of the mackerel to W. M. Rogers & Co.,
Fulton Market; I sold some to Moon, Lamphier
& Co., of Fulton Market; those mackerel which I
sold to Moon, I bought for eight cents or ten cents
per pound, and sold them back for forty cents or
forty-five cents. Each morning I took out mack-
erel, the top layer was most frozen—the top parts
of the fish; all mackerel which were bare was
frozen; the portions which touched the ice were
not frozen, that which was above, was. I also sold
some to Mr. John Hawkes, Washington Market;
Mr. Penniman also bought some, as didalso Judge
Hitcheock ; that is all I wholesaled, I can think of,
and these I sold at from forty cents to fifty cents
per pound ; I retailed a great many at one dollar per
pound. I have frozen other fish, such as king-fish
and Lafayette; I also froze soft shell crabs there,
and did not think it would kill them; I put them
in alive, and found them all dead and stiff in the
morning ; during the season, I have frozen shad,
et
je Poae on a
oo Pvese & ae
23°
and almost all that kind of fish, in the same way
as the mackerel. By using the salt, with ice in
the pan, I found the ice in the box did not melt
SO Soon.
Q. 7. If you have not examined the exhibit
since produced by you, will you now proceed to
describe the internal arrangement of the box in
which you froze fish as above described ¢
A. I have not examined the exhibit since it was
produced. ‘To the best of my recollection, the box
was of the size previously mentioned. The box
inside was furnished with a pan similar to the one
now before you, with the exception of a flange
coming out on the under side, and a joist cross-
ways under the front of the pan, and from that
pan there were two pipes running down the sides
of the box from the pan through the box bottom.
The two pipes leading from the pan were in the
corners at the back of the box, from the bottom
of the pan.
' Q. 8. How were the lids or openings to the
box and pan arranged ¢
A. There was one lid dropped down from the
front, and another lid on the top about the same
size as the one in front; the edge of the pan was
projecting half way under the top lid; the box
was made of two inch lumber, all through clear
plank; there was no double wall. I used to put
a blanket on the top and front of box, under the
lids, so as to fit them tight.
@. 9. When the pan was filled with ice and
salt, and the lids closed, was there any contact be-
24
tween the air in the preserving chamber, and the
ice and salt in the pan ¢ ;
A. No, sir. That is why I used the blanket to
make it fit tight all over.
Q. 9a. Refer to the Exhibit No. 2, and state in
what, if any, particulars it differs from the origi-
nal internal construction of the box used by you.
[Exhibit handed witness. |
A. The edges of the pan were turned over the
top parts of the side walls and nailed on so as to
form a flange. There was a joist bevelled off so
as to fit under tlie mouth of the pan; the joist
rested on two pieces of two-inch stuff nailed to the
sides; the edge of the pan was fastened with
copper tacks to the joist.
@. 10. Were there any openings in the pipes
except at the top and bottom ?
A. No, sir.
Q@. 11. When the pan was filled with salt and
ice did you observe any peculiar collection on the
pan or pipes? If so, what ?
the ice were coated with frost, as also the pan on
the inside of the chamber. The greatest was on
the pipes at about one to two feet from the pan.
Q. 12. According to the best of your present
recollection, when did you first freeze fish in that
apparatus ¢
A. In the latter end of 1856.
A. I found the pipes where they did not touch -
a
ger
°
4
q
25
He testifies [page 310, question 6, and page 321, cross-
question 163], that he sold some of the mackerel which
he had preserved in said apparatus to W. M. Rogers &
Co., of Fulton Market, not, however, in a frozen state,
as his custom was to thaw them out in ice water before
cleaning them for delivery [page 320, cross-question 154].
In corroboration of these statements of Racey is the
testimony of W. H. Middleton, who was the bookkeeper
of W. M. Rogers & Co., [pages 488 and 489] who there
explains a settlement which was made between J. H.
Racey, Jr., and W. M. Rogers & Co., in October, 1858,
from which it appears that there was a running account
between W. M. Rogers & Co. and Joseph H. Racey, Jr.,
from January 23, 1856, to the 5th day of October, 1858,
the date of settlement, in which account W. M. Rogers
& Co. had charged to Racey $54 99, and Racey had
charged to that firm $71 29. On the back of the bill
which had been rendered to Racey by W. M. Rogers &
Co. was entered a memorandum of two items; one of
bass under date March 13, 1857, and another of mack-
erel, under date September 27, 1858. It should be re-
membered that W. M. Rogers & Co. were the predeces-
sors of Middleton, Carman & Co. [page 105, questions
67 and 68
or in the United States, in fresh fish” [page 105, ques-
, and “ the largest retail dealers in New York,
tion 72], doing business therein at the rate of $75,000 to
$100,000 per annum [page 106, question 75].
It is obvious that there must have been some special
reason why such a concern as W. M. Rogers & Co. pur-
chased fish of Racey, who was a small retail dealer. ‘The
reason of this doubtless was what [tacey swears to, that
“a vera aes "ohana agen
on - once tar naage
26
he had preserved fish, and could furnish them out of the
season for fresh fish.
Joun W. Danrorp was the carpenter whose firm con-
structed the box for Racey, which Racey describes. He
testifies thus [page 341] :—
Q. 4. Has your firm done work for Mr. Joseph
H. Racey, Jr. %
A. Yes.
Q. 5. Do you remember, in 1855 or 1856, build-
ing for Mr. Racey an ice-box which was placed in
the Centre Market ?
A. We made one for him about that time.
Q. 6. Have you any recollection of the size and
shape of that box ?
A. It was a high box, not very deep from front
to back; it might have been four feet, and I
should say about six feet high at the least ; I don’t
know but it was higher than it was long. —
@. 7. How was it entered? What doors or
openings had it?
A. It strikes me that there was one door which
opened from the top, and another door, I am pretty
sure, opened from the end of it to go right into it.
Wm. H. Racery, the brother of Joseph H. Racey, Jr.,
who was connected with him in business in 1856, and
afterwards in Centre Market, testifies thus [page 362] :—
f
()
:
6. During the time that you were there prior
to 1859, were you aware of his having and using
an ice box fitted with pan and pipes?
Sas a Te oe So we = ee
“
a Mi ee
q
>
ae
=>
|
|
&
|
oe
™y?
27
A. I was.
Q. 7. Please describe the arrangement of the
pan and pipes, as nearly as you can ¢
A. It was a nearly square box, with a lid open-
ing half way across the top, and ‘another lid let
down half way in front, fitted on the inside with
a metal reaching somewhat more than half way
across the top from the back, the bottom of the
pan slanting backwards; there were two drain
pipes leading from the pan, (placed,in the back
corners of the box,) leading downwards, and pass-
ing through the bottom of the box, to carry off
waste water.
Q. 8. When first do you remember to have seen
that box ?
A. In the Fall of 1856.
(. 9. Did you ever know any fish or other ani-
mal substances put into that box? If so, what
condition were they in when placed there, and
what when taken out ?
A. Yes; they were in a natural state when
placed in the box, and when taken out some were
frozen, and some partly frozen.
Q. 10. What, if anything, was placed or kept in
the pan at the top of the box ?
A. Ground ice and salt.
Q. 11. Do you know how long that box was
continued to be used by Mr. Racey?
A. I can’t tell how long it was used.
Q. 12. When did you cease your connection
A eet eee cer a eee
sa
SEES SS TE I
28
with Mr. Racey and the business in Centre Mar-
ket ?
A. In April, 1861.
And on page 363, thus :—
X-Q. 24. The fish that were put into the ice
box were put in in layers, alternately with layers
of ice ?
A. Yes.
X-Q. 25. You say you don’t know how long
that box was continued to be used by Mr. Racey ;
(in the manner described, I mean, of course :) do
you know whether it was one year, two years, or
three years ?
A. I am unable to state positive how many
years.
X-Q. 28. Can you name any one to whom fish
which had been kept in that ice box was sold ?
A. To his customers at that time; I forget their
names; the fish were not sold in a frozen state;
but had to be thawed in order to be cleaned, con-
sequently the customers did not know they had
been frozen.
Cuarites Haacerry, a witness not interested in the
case nor in the fish business, proves in the most positive
manner that an ice box was in J. H. Racey Jr.’s cellar
prior to the time of the construction of the freezer in
1859, and which corresponded in size with the one stated
to be there by Joseph H. Racey, Jr., John W. Danford and
William H. Racey ; saw fish and ice put into it in layers
such as the other witnesses state was done. He testifies
thus [page 336, 337] :—
i
i
bs
‘
;
;
}
}
'
29
X-Q. 63. Were you ever in the cellar of Mr.
Racey, in Centre Market, cellar No. 11, before
the time when you went with Councilman Burns to
see the freezing apparatus ?
A. Yes, sir; I was in the cellar occupied by
Mr. Racey.
X-Q. 64. How frequently do you think you
were in that cellar during the years 1856, 1857,
1858 ?
A. Three times or more.
X-Q). 65. State as nearly as you can how many
times you were in that cellar before the time when
yeu were there with Councilman Burns, and saw
the freezing apparatus which you have described ?
A. I was in there five or six times; I was in
there while it was being built.
X-Q. 66. What did you ever see in that cellar
before you saw the freezing apparatus there which
you have described ?
A. Brooms, baskets, ice-box, boxes, and such
things as that.
X-Q. 67. It was a place for stowing or keeping
various kinds of articles, was it not ?
A. Yes; such as butchers or fishermen would
use.
X-Q. 68. What do you mean by an ice-box?
A refrigerator ?
A. A box to keep ice in; I have seen fish put
in it.
X-Q. 69. Do you mean that it was a box in
coe ed intent
50
which ice was placed to keep to be taken out as
wanted ?
A. No.
X-Q. 70. Then state what you do mean and de-
scribe the box fully.
A. The box, I should say, was six or eight feet
long, from three to four feet wide, five feet or over
high, with the ice broke up small, and to preserve
the fish there were layers of ice and layers of fish,
and then ice put on top of it again.
X-Q. 71. Do you mean that you ever saw layers
of fish and layers of ice together in the manner
you have described in that ice-box ?
A. I have seen them put in in the manner de-
seribed.
X-Q. 72. This was before you were there with
Councilman Burns ?
A. Yes, sir.
X-Q. 73. Did you see this ice-box used in this
way repeatedly before that time ?
A. I have seen it twice or more.
X-Q. 74. What else was there about that ice-
box which you can describe? I speak of its in-
ternal construction. Had it any doors, or any
racks, or any drain-hole at the bottom, or anything
else ?
A. It had a door raised up from the top; all I
saw was the outside; I did not examine the box ;
[ only saw the ice and fish put in.
ee en aed
mE nie 31
X-Q. 75. Did you see them raise up that door
and put in the fish and ice and shut the place
up again ?
A. Yes.
© X-Q. 76. This door was a lid, if I understand
, you, which was lifted up from the top of the box ¢
A. Yes.
The testimony of one of Appellee’s own witnesses,
Matthew J. Tuomey is conclusive that a box bearing the
description of the one Racey had constructed in 1856 was
in the cellar which he occupied. The box constructed in
1856 had a door opening downwards. [Joseph H. Racey,
Jr., page 310, question 8. ]
“= Mr. Tuomey, at pages 151, 152 and 153, testifies
thus :—
Q. 5. Were you ever clerk of that market? If
yea, from what time to what time ?
A. I was appointed clerk in the year 1858,
about the middle of September or the first of Oc-
tober; I continued from that time till about the
latter part of January or the middle of February,
1862.
= @. 8. Who else, if any one, made use of the
cellar while you were clerk.
A. Mr. Racey—J. H.
@. 10. While you were clerk of the market
state what articles of property you saw in that
cellar.
32
A. I saw barrels, brooms, oysters, and rails used
for to hang meat on, belonging to myself, and an
ice box belonging to Mr. Racey. Among other
things there was a machine belonging to Mr.
Racey that he had to grind ice with.
Q. 11. Where was the ice box you speak of lo-
cated in that cellar ?
A. It was on the south side of the cellar, front-
ing on Centre street, right inside of the entrance
to the cellar; it was to the right hand of the door
as you enter, about eighteen inches or two feet
from the side of the door as you goin. It backed
up against the wall on the south side.
@. 18. Describe this box as to size.
A. It was a box in the neighborhood of five
feet high, about four feet or four and a half feet
wide, and about six to eight feet long, with a door
that dropped down from the top. The hinges of
the door were about three feet from the bottom.
It was a box made of thick boards, or inch or
inch and a quarter plank. It seemed to be from
the outer lining to the inner lining a space of
about four inches. Whether it was stuffed with
sawdust or charcoal, or anything of that kind, I
know nothing.
Q. 15. How was this door opened ?
A. It seemed to open from the top, and drop .
down towards the ground.
Q. 17. What, if anything, did you observe in-
side the box ? |
\
ot ye -
a=
ui
. ore a rk
” . a ce ‘ “—
“we
Sens ,
LO Lg > ~
0 As GIT nie AE EEA 8) ht Sie EE IE
” . ~~ * ’ ‘ es . oF a da
3
A. I saw some ice in there ground up or broken
in small pieces, and some fish covered over with
the ice so broken—that’s all.
(. 18. Did yousee any perpendicular metallic
tubes or pipes inside of the box ?
A. No.
And at page 156 he testifies thus :—
X-Q. 8. When first was your attention called to
the size, make and general description of the ice-
box which you have described, with reference to
your giving any description of it.
A. Well, as regards the date of the year, that I
ooh
wes
A ae.
can’t say; I have no memory as regards the year
i el
or the time of the year; but in this way | will
state it: Seein
f
the cellar open, and having occ¢a-
(ry
a)
a
| tere
sion to go down there on some private business, [
saw some of Mr. Racey’s help to work with the
ice grinding machine grinding ice there, and from
the fact of their grinding the ice there I saw the
ice-box.
An attempt was made to discredit Joseph H. Racey,
Jr., by testimony respecting his character for truth and
| veracity.
This effort entirely failed. The witnesses called for
ve that purpose were—
George W. Wingate,
yp D. 8. Riddle,
| Peter H. Miller,
Aaron Hardman,
Gilson Carman,
ciate Te
54
William H. Middleton,
William M. Rogers, ;
Thomas Boese.
Wma. M. Rogers admits that at the time he was exam-
ined he was not acquainted with the character of Racey,
and had not been for seven years [page 242, q. 21]. He
was examined in 1869, and he had not been acquainted
with his character since before 1862 [page 244, x-q. 27].
Wma. H. Mippteron. The question put to this witness
respecting the character of Racey was in the present
tense, but as he was not acquainted with his character at
the time of his examination, in 1869, his answer was in
the past tense [page 229, q. 3 and 4], and the time when
he professed to have been acquainted with his character
is shown to have been before 1865, as appears in his
cross-examination , [page 230, x-qs. 15 and 16]. From
eross-questions 18 and 19 it appears that the Appellee
was manufacturing testimony respecting Racey’s charac-
ter pending the examination, as all the knowledge which
this witness had of Racey’s character he received from
Piper the day before the examination.
Aaron HarpMan could not testify as to the reputation
of Racey at the time of his examination in 1869, because,
as he says [page 219, q. 15], “I don’t know anything about
his reputation at present.” This Hardman was a party
opposed to Racey in a litigation extending from 1859 to
1863. He says that at that time he heard Racey spoken
of as a bad man. He might have heard him so spoken
of by his attorney, Riddle, who had quarrelled with
Racey, and appeared to be practicing law in Centre Mar-
ket, among the stalls of the fish dealers, or hunting up
something there to practice on.
ze
a
f
35
Tuomas Borst. This witness says that, at the time of
his examination, he was not acquainted with the general
reputation of Racey for truth and veracity [page 215, q.
60.] From what this witness says [page 213, q. 51] it ap-
pears that what had been said against Racey’s character
for truth and veracity came chiefly from the party and
attorney opposed to him in the litigation.
The four witnesses above named not being acquainted
with the character of Racey at the time of his examina-
tion, and not having been acquainted with it for some six
years, by well settled principles of law, were incompetent
to testify as to his character.
Grorce W. Wrineaate was attorney against Racey in a
controversy which terminated in 1863, and although the
question is asked him as to Racey’s reputation at the time
he testified, it appears from the whole of the examination
upon that subject that he had no knowledge in regard to
it subsequent to the termination of the litigation some six
or seven years before the time of his testimony, and all
that he learned in regard to Racey’s reputation came
from parties connected with that litigation. It also ap-
pears that while this witness was being examined, he was
in fact ‘acting as counsel for the Appellee; that the
amount he was to receive for his services was unliqui-
dated, and he was under the temptation of making it ap-
pear that his services were of great value to the Appellee.
[Page 185, cross-question 164 to 168, inclusive ; page 187,
cross-question 179; page 188, cross-questions 197 and
198. ]
D. 8. Rippie was the attorney against Racey all through
the protracted and angry litigation referred to, and he and
Racey appear to have quarrelled and had much trouble
36
with each other [page 202, qs. 84, 85, 86 and 87]. At
the time Mr. Riddle was examined he had been acting
for Mr. Piper in hunting up testimony, drawing affidavits,
etc. [page 205], and had received some money for the
same, and expected still to receive an additional unspeci-
fied sum [page 206, qs. 116, 117, 118]. Of course he
had a motive in causing his testimony to be favorable to
Piper and unfavorable to Racey. Notwithstanding this
witness testifies on his examination-in-chief as if he were
acquainted with the character of Racey at the time of
his examination; it appears from his cross-examination
[page 207, x-q. 126] that he had no communication with
any one with whom Racey transacted business or was
dealing after the fall of 1861.
Gitson Carman. This witness is interested in sus-
taining the Piper patent. He is a member of the firm of
Middleton, Carman & Co. [page 100, questions 3 & 4],
who were the agents of Piper for the sale of all his frozen
or preserved fish, and had been since 1859. They were also
using, by Piper’s permission, an apparatus erected under
Piper’s patent [page 119, cross-question 212 to 235].
Carman was also a licensee of Piper { Piper’s deposition,
page 285, answers 160 & 161]. (it does not appear that
he paid anything for this license.) Although this witness
says that he has heard people speak of the character
of Racey, and that he knows his general reputation for
truth and veracity, and says that ‘it is bad wherever he
is interested,” yet, on his cross-examination, it appears
that he can’t name a single person whom he has heard so
speak of him, nora single time when he has heard any-
thing of the kind, and finally winds up by saying that he
thinks he has so heard, which has given him the general
impression he has [page 228, q. 9 to 18].
Sue
“: 37
In support of Joseph H. Racey, Jr.’s, character for
truth and veracity the following witnesses were ealled :—
Jacob L. Seixas.
Jacob Michaelis.
~y Joseph Murphy.
a Cortland Schuyler.
Patrick Collins.
Wardrop J. Hall.
Richard Briggs.
Edmor. Blankman.
Robert L. Lomas,
John M. Leaman,
Edwin Nichols.
Jacos L. Srrxas is a wholesale merchant in the city of
“ New York ; knows Racey’s reputation for truth and ve-
racity, and has known him for twenty-five years. He
says Racey’s reputation ‘for truth and veracity is “ very
good.” [Page 374, questions 1, 2, 3, 4.]
|
i;
i
ig
!
if
Jacop MicHae ts isa merchant in New York city, and
has known Racey eleven years, and as to his reputation
for truth and veracity says he “knows nothing but good
of him.” [Page 377, questions 1, 2, 3, 4.]
Josepn Murpny is a landsvape gardner, and late Su-
perintendent of Public Parks in New York, and Deputy
Collector of City Revenue; has known Racey upwards
? of twenty years; knows his reputation for truth and ve-
| racity ; says it is “ good.” [Page 380, questions 1, 2, 3,
4, 5.]
CorTLAND ScHUYLER keeps a stand in Centre Market ;
has known Racey for ten years, and knows his general
, . itt osteo
. “ a = ed ais Ai Mite ete ae? DRIAL He
sabe an Ae A NANCIE RENEE ND A ORME CRGN I OT HI LO ALE LEX ABE SEA AREE ALLIAGE DEE “
ele eeretenes oe
88
reputation for truth and veracity, and says it is “ good.”
[Page 381, questions 1, 2, 3, 4.]
,
Patrick Corus, Clerk of Centre Market. He, of
all other persons, must have had the best opportunity to
become acquainted with Racey’s reputation for truth and
veracity ; has known Racey ever since he was a boy, for
thirty years ; is acquainted with his reputation for truth
and veracity, and says it is “very good.” [Page 408,
questions 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.]
Warprop J. Hart, retired from business; a Director
in Manufacturers and Merchants’ Bank of the City of
New York, in which bank Racey transacted his business.
[Page 412, question 4.] Has known Racey for thirteen
years [ question 3], is acquainted with his general reputation
for truth and veracity, and says:—“ To my own know-
ledge it is unexceptionable.” [Page 413, question 19.]
Ricuarp Briaes, fish dealer in Washington Market, of
firm of Parks & Briggs, has known Racey since 1853;
knows his general reputation for truth and veracity, and
says :—““I know it to be good.” [Page 456, questions
1, 2, 3, 4, 5.]
Epmon Brianxkman, member of the New York bar;
known Kacey twelve years; knows his general reputa-
tien for truth and veracity, and says itis “ good.” [Page
458, questions 1,2; page 459, question 12,] and says,
X-Q. 16, 17, as follows :—
X-Q. 16. How many times have you heard his
character for truth and veracity spoken of? State
as near as you can.
A. I cannot tell the number of times, but I
have frequently heard him spoken of as a good and
ete ee a eg"?
eer
oa ee
truthful man, as a good and affectionate son to his
mother and father, and as a kind brother to his
sisters and his brothers.
X-Q. 17. Whom have you heard speak of it in
that way ?
A. I have heard his sisters, brothers, father,
mother and people who are strangers, Mr. Mar-
tinez, Mr. Michaelis—well, a great many others
whose names I cannot recollect; I never heard
anybody speak badly of him in my life; all whom
I have heard speak of him spoke well of Mr.
Racey, and I would believe him under oath or I
would believe him on his word as quick as any
man I ever knew.
Rosert L. Lomas is in the dry goods and other busi-
ness, known Racey for twenty-five years, knows his repu-
tation for truth and veracity and says it is “ good” [page
) § i
491, q. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.]
Joun M. Leaman is a butcher in Centre Market for
forty years, has known Racey for thirty years, and re-
garding his reputation for truth and veracity says he
“never heard anything against it” [page 492, q. 1, 2,
3, 4; 5].
Epwin Nicuots, formerly in the stove business in the
City of New York, has known Racey thirty years and
knows his reputation for truth and veracity, and that it
is “ good” [page 494, q. 1, 2, 3, 4].
Here are eleven good and reliable witnesses examined
in support of Racey’s good character for truth and ver-
acity. None of them are enemies to or even knew. Mr.
Piper, and none of them are friends or even knew the
ARIE enn treme remeinnene rant nerecerctmaarr nate teint nae aetna teeter ttt ttec tne ‘
40
Appellants in this case. They were entirely disinterested
witnesses, having no interest in the subject-matter of the
suit, and no bias for or against either party thereto. "They
are, therefore, in respect to qualifications rendering their
statements reliable, entirely unlike the witnesses called to
impeach Racey. This attack, therefore, of the Appellee,
upon the character of Racey, was not only a failure, but
the collision it produced had the effect cf rubbing up the
reputation of the old fish dealer, causing his excellent
qualities to shine more brightly than they otherwise
would have done.
The Appellee attempts to contradict Racey’s statement
that he sold Spanish mackerel which had been frozen or
partially frozen, to W. M. Rogers & Co., prior to 1859.
But the result of it was that no one of the members of
that firm remembers any such purchase.
But it does appear from the bill [page 488 of the
Record], and from W. H. Middleton [ pages 487, 488], that
Racey did sell fish, Spanish mackerel and bass, to Rogers
& Co., in 1857 and 1858.
It will also be remembered that Racey doesn’t pretend
that he sold the fish in a frozen state.
It is claimed that Racey purchased frozen fish of Mid-
dleton, Carman & Co., and therefore could not have had
a freezer of his own.
But it is to be remembered that Racey’s business was
small, and that the house referred to was the largest fish
house in New York, and that even Middleton, Carman
& Co. bought frozen fish of these Respondents and other
parties.
————— i?
TE" eee tee
, ne ee ae
41
VItt.
The Court below erred in over-
ruling the exceptions taken to the
Master’s report and in confirming
that report.
After the submission of the draft report by the Master
.to the respective counsel, and while it was still under
consideration, and before the preparation of the final re-
port, counsel for the Appellants filed with the Master a
motion for leave to take further testimony as to the
transactions of the year 1870 [page 24, folio 40; page 27,
folios 45, 46].
This motion was refused by the Master, who decided
“as matter of law that, at the time when said petition
was presented, it was not competent for the Master to
hear further evidence or entertain said petition” [page
24, folio 40].
To this ruling of the Master an exception was duly
taken [page 72, folio 122}.
This, together with the other exceptions of the Appel-
lants, was overruled by the learned Judge at the Cireuit.
[See opinion of Court, page 571, and final decree, page
73. |
This petition for leave to introduce further testimony
was supported by affidavits of the only two men who
worked Appellants’ apparatus at Charlestown in 1870.
The object .of this petition was to show that during
the whole of the year 1370 the Appellants’ apparatus
42
"as used in the manner and only in the manner which
the Master, at pages 12 and 16, reports to be not an in-
fringement.
In the denial of this petition for the cause stated by
the Master he was plainly in error, and the Court below
| should have recommitted the report with instructions for
g the taking of further testimony in accordance with the
prayer of the petition.
Pattison vs. Hall, 9 Cow., N. Y., 760.
Tvler vs. Simmons, 6 Paige Chan., N. Y., 180.
e y) = 3 5
at
| Bodge vs. Hull, 59 Me. 225.
Neither the draft nor final report of a Master is in the
nature of a judgment. The draft report is subject to
modification, and until the final report leaves the hand
seating
of the Master the whole subject is within his control. He
muy exercise a reasonable’ discretion, and his duty is to
ascertain the truth and preserve the rights of all parties.
Equity rule 77.
THE OPERATIONS OF 1870.
The Master finds that the apparatus was altered and
that the use of the apparatus as altered would not infringe
the Appellee’s patent [pages 12, 16].
This ruling is not only confirmed by the testimony of
Hervey Waters, who was called by the Appellants, but
this witness further proves that the apparatus was used
a3 altered, and on the 16th of December, 1870 [pages
64, 65).
-—— a
produced by Mr. Clapp [ page 65 |
43
The Appellant, Seavey, also testified before the Master
that the apparatus was used with these alterations, | pages
16, 17,] and was asked to produce an account showing the
quantity of fish frozen and preserved in the apparatus
“after the said alteration ” [page 17], which account was
|. This is the only account
of any operations in 1870, and fhe Mester [page 14]
embodies the whole of this account in his finding against
the Appellants [pages 14-23].
The claim made by the Appellee was that when the
Appellants used the apparatus they in some way restored
it to its original condition.
Upon this claim the burden of proof was on the Ap-
pellee; there was no presumption of law or fact against
the Appellants which they were required to overcome
by the production of any evidence.
The only remaining testimony on the subject was the
visit made by the Master on December 12, 1870, on
which occasion the Appellant, Seavey, his counsel being
absent, denied the Master the privilege of examining the
part of the apparatus then in use, [pages 16, 17,] and it
seems that because of this denial, which Appellants’
counsel knew nothing of until the Master’s draft repert
was submitted, the Master disregarded the testimony of
Seavey and Waters. As soon as this denial became
known to Appellants’ counsel, and because of this denial,
he presented the petition above referred to, to introduce
additional testimony to show the exact state of the appar-
atus in 1870 and how it was used.
The Master’s report should therefore not have included
the profits of the year 1870, and the Court erred in con-
firming the report in that regard.
44
Il.
THE OPERATIONS OF 1868 Aanp 1869. R
The exceptions taken to the Master’s report covering
these two years, and which were overruled by the learned
Judge, are printed on page 73, folio 123.
After the decision of the Cirenit Court against the Ap-
pellants in the process for contempt, the Appellants ad-
mitted their liability to account for the gain and profit
made in their operations at the Fruit House, Cambridge.
They produced their account, kept as in previous years,
in a pass-book. This account was accepted as correct so
fir as it stated the quantity of fish put in, the prices paid,
the quantity taken out, and prices received for the fish
sold, and is questioned only in one particular, viz.: As
to the price paid as rent or storage to the companies
which owned the building.
The entry of rent in the pass-book kept by the Appel-
lants was entered under the head of Exp. in 1868,
$3,500 ; in 1869, $4,000. [Page 19.]
These two items the Master disallows. His reasons for
disallowing them, as stated in his original report [page
20], are these, viz :—
1. The meager proof made by the Appellants
touching the terms of their agreements with the
Fruit Preserving Companies.
2. The discrepancies between the expenses of
1866 and 1867 and the rent paid.
3. The entry on the books of Appellants ex-
pressing the charge.
}
)
{
45
In his additional report he finds [pages 24, 25]:—
ee ee ee
1. That the Appellants paid to the Fruit Pre-
serving Companies both snms, viz., In 1868,
$3,500, and in 1869, $4,000.
2. That the services and rent were in value far
below the sums paid.
3. As a conclusion from the evidence reported,
that there was some arrangement by which the
whole or some part of these sums was to be paid
back to the Appellants, or that they were paid as
a reward to induce the companies to infringe the
patent of Appellee and violate the injunction of
the Court, and therefore are not to be allowed as
items of expense [page 25]. ,
These reasons, findings and conclusions are manifestly
wrong.
An examination in detail will demonstrate this.
(a.) As to the arrangement with the fruit preserving
companies. .
The agreement for 1869 was originally in writing.
» It was not, however, in the hands of Appellants, but in
a the custody of the Fruit Preserving Company.
This the Master finds as a fact [page 18].
© And Mr. Pike, the Superintendent of the company,
testifies that he had it in December, 1869, when he testi-
fied in the hearing on the process for*contempt. and
would not produce it.
Master’s Rep. Exhibit M.; p. 59.
See also Seavey’s testimony, p. 31; p. 38, q.
122; p. 41, q. 152. :
The Appellants were called on by Appellee to produce
this written contract, which the evidence showed, even
to the satisfaction of the Master, that they had not in
their possession [page 18].
The Master, however, holds them at fault for not pro-
ducing it {page 20], and reaches the conclusion that it
was a collusive agreement, as stated on page 25, and ap-
plies this conclusion to the year 1868, when it is not pre-
tended there was any written agreement.
It is submitted that had there been no other evidence
as to the nature of that contract, such a conclusion is in
violation of law.
There was before the Master full and ample evidence
of the terms of the contract.
The contract for both years, 1868 and 1869, is stated
by the several parties to have been this :—
The Appellants hired of the Fruit Preserving Com-
panies the right to fill a certain space in the fruit house,
called the freezing rooms, with such articles as_ they
chose. The Appellants were to deliver the articles at
the fruit house, where they were to be received, taken
charge of and manipulated by the employees of the com-
panies, and delivered to the Appellants, when called for,
in as good order and condition as they were when re-
ceived. ‘The companies were to do all that was necessary
to preserve them, to furnish all material and labor, and
were to take all risk of loss while in their charge, and for
LN
.
~~
nian. i ee
ee See ene
att ae
47
the use of this space, for the services to be rendered and
the risk assumed, the Appellants agreed to pay whether
they used the space or not, and did pay for the year 1868
the sum of $3,500, for 1869, $4,000.
The contracts were made with two different companies,
the Boston Fruit Preserving Company in 1868, and the
Massachusetts Fruit Preserving Company in 1869.
Master’s rep., page 11, 18.
Seavey, page 31, page 39, Q. 123 to 130;
page 42, X-Q. 9 to 11; page 43, Q. 3
to 8.
Doolittle’s Dep. page 43, Q. 3 to 53 page
47, Q. 106; pages 49, 50, X-Q. 1 to
11 and 16.
Brown’s Dep., pages 50, 51, Q. 21 to 46.
Pike’s Dep., page 59, Q. 1 to 13; page 61,
(). 36 to 40; page 62, X-Q. 1 to 5.
Mr. Brown and Mr. Seavey are the Appellants; they
made the contracts on their part ; Messrs. Pike and Doo-
little represented the companies as superintendents and
Mr. Pike as treasurer, and although he did not make
the contract, which was reduced to writing, for 1869, he
had the custody of it, collected the rent, and personally
directed the work done at the fruit house under it.
He is asked [Q. 38, page 61,]| to state the substance of
the contract, and does so.
There was, then, before the Master the evidence of
every person connected with the making and executing
of the contract. :
48
What further testimony could possibly be adduced in
relation to the contract of 1868, which was never reduc-
ed to writing, we fail to see.
It is submitted that the fullest proof that could possi-
bly be produced as to the terms of these contracts was
before the Master.
(b.) As to the difference in expense between the years
1866 and 1867, and 1868 and 1869.
In stating the expenses of the years 1866 and 1867,
the Appellants make no charge for interest on the capi-
tal invested, wear and tear and depreciation of their ap-
paratus, for their own time in superintending, for cart-
ing, for labor bestowed by regular employees, nor do
they claimn or estimate any profit on the work done at the’
freezer as a separate business.
It is absurd to suppose that a stranger, disconnected
with their general business, could or would take their
Charlestown apparatus and freeze fish for them or any
third party for just the bare cost of the labor expended,
the materials used and the rent paid.
A profit would be charged on every element of ex-
pense, and, in addition, a charge for the time bestowed
and the risk assumed, and the owner of such an appa-
ratus would undoubtedly estimate the probable length
of time his machine or apparatus would last, and add
wear and tear to both cost and profit.
In determining, therefore, whether or not there is so
great a discrepancy between the expenses incurred by
the Appellants in running their own apparatus, and the
amount they pay another party for doing a like work, as
@)
49
inevitably to lead to the conclusion that the sum thus
paid was not paid in good faith, the purposes and cir-
cumstances of each must be considered.
The Appellants did not run their apparatus as a distinct
business, intending and expecting to make a profit on
the work done there, but only as an incident to their
general business, making their gain or profit from the
sale of the articles frozen or preserved.
The fruit preserving companies, on the contrary, de-
rived their sole profit from the gain made in the business
of freezing and preserving. The salaries of their officers
the interest on the capital, insurance, Jabor, materials,
wear and tear, all had to be paid before any profit could
be realized and dividend paid to stockholders.
The cost to them was greater than to an individual,
and had they simply charged the actual cost of labor ex-
pended and materials furnished, it would have resulted
in a loss to them.
It is evident, therefore, that so far as the fruit preserv-
ing companies were concerned, there is no inference to
be drawn against the perfect fairness of the contracts
made. They were to keep the rented space at all times
ready for use, and their only possible profit resulted from
their charging an excess over the actual cost of running
the apparatus.
Any inference from the facts reported by the Master,
which implicates or connects these companies with a
fraudulent or collusive agreement, such as the Master
states, is wholly unwarranted.
oO)
In order to sustain the conclusion of the Master, both
the fruit preserving companies and the Appellants must
have become parties to the agreement.
If the evidence fails to connect them both, the result
attained by the Master is manifestly wrong.
(c.) As the Master finds that the two sums of $3,500
and $4,000, were actually paid by the Appellants to the
fruit preserving companies, the manner in which the pay-
ments were entered on the books of Appellants can fur-
nish no sufticient reason for disallowing the amounts.
(d.) The Master finds that the-sums paid were far above
the value received.
The suggestions under the third point, b, apply to the
consideration of this finding.
There was no competition with the fruit preserving
companies. They put their own price on the service
rendered. In ascertaining what those services were fairly
worth, it becomes necessary to learn the original cost of
their apparatus, the cost of operating it, including, of
course, the salaries paid to officers and employees. Upon
these points the Master had no evidence.
It was in evidence, however, that they employed a su-
perintendent and a treasurer; that Nathan Robbins paid
for a small part of the space the Appellants were entitled
to, $600, and that for a period less than a year; being a
little more than one-sixth of the entire rent for 1868.
Nickerson, p. 32.
It also appears that the Massachusetts Company in-
creased the rate from $3,500 to $4,000; that on the oper-
ation of 1868, the Appellants made a profit of $777.25 [p.
12] after paying the amount of rent and other inciden-
tal expenses, although the quantity of fish frozen was
much less than in any preceding year, and if the prices
received in 1868 had been maintained in 1869, their
profit on the operations of that year would have been
within $100 or $200 as great as that made on a like
quantity of fish frozen by them in 1867.
Rep. pp. 12, 22.
There was no evidence before the Master upon which
this finding can be based, except the difference in the
cost of running the apparatus of Appellants at Charles-
town, and the amount paid to the Fruit Preserving
Companies, and this, we submit, furnishes no basis for
this finding.
(e.) The conclusions of the Master should be supported
by the evidence.
They are not.
Mr. Seavey, Mr. Brown, Mr. Doolittle and Mr. Pike
each state the terms of the contract with the Fruit Pre-
serving Companies. Each of them was called and exam-
ined by the Avpellee. There is nothing to contradict or
control their evidence.
Messrs. Pike and Doolittle are in no wise interested in
the result of the suit.
They state the terms of the contract in answer to in-
quiries from the Appellee. There is not a particle of
evidence from them wliich tends to show that any part of
the sums paid by the Appellants to the Fruit Preserving
Companies was ever paid back.
ie
7 aes
f
a
a)
j
'
'
|
{
pA. NEI ES
52
No such inquiry was addressed to any one of the wit-
nesses, but the Appellee chose to put in the fact that the
sums were paid, and to leave the subject there, making
no attempt to control the testimony, but apparently
accepting the statements.
The Appellants produced the receipts given them for
the sums paid [p. 19], they testified to the payments, and
the persons to whom the payments were made testified
to receiving the money.
Seavey’s Dep., p. 35, qs. 77, 78.
Doolittle’s Dep., p. 47, gq. 105.
Pike’s Dep., p. 59, q. 3; p. 62, cross-q. 5.
The Appellee had the fullest opportunity for showing
any fact which would tend to prove that any of the
money thus paid was returned to the Appellants.
None was presented.
Nor is there the slightest evidence tending to show that
the sums paid to the fruit preserving companies were paid
as a reward or inducement to infringe the patent of Ap-
pellee and the injunction of the Court.
But assuming, for the sake of the argument, that they
were paid for that purpose, the Court has already imposed
its penalty for that, and it was no part of the duty of
the Master to impose penalties or assess damages. He
was to ascertain, by computation, the actual gain in mon-
ey made by the Appellants in practising the art or pro-
cess patented by the Appellee, by ascertaining the differ-
ence in money between the money actually expended
and the money actually received, according to the rule
laid down in Mowry vs. Whitney; to state the accounts
— —- — —
53
precisely as a merchant would state the account of his
own business in order to ascertain the profit or loss.
(f.) The standard adopted by the Master in determining
the expenses of the years 1868 and 1869, as allowed by
him, is radically wrong.
ev :
He assumes that the Fruit Preserving Companies could
do the work of freezing and preserving as cheaply as the
Appellants did it, and that they were not to be allowed
anything more than the actual cost to them.
This is manifestly wrong. The Appellants had no
regular superintendent of their apparatus, the Fruit Pre-
serving Company did; the Appellants charged up their
apparatus only when needed, and usually from the middle
of June to some time in November or December, and then
only such portion as they intended to use.
The fruit preserving companies were required to keep
their rooms charged at all times ready for use for an
entire year. The Appellants did not carry on their ap-
paratus as a regular business; the fruit preserving com-
panies did; the Appellants charged nothing but actual
expenses; the fruit preserving companies had to include
in their charge as part of the expenses, interest on their
capital, insurance, repairs, depreciation, salaries, a rea-
sonable sum for risk of loss by deterioration of the arti-
cles received, and, in order to make the business pay, a
margin for profit.
The true statement of the accounts of the years 1868
and 1869, upon the principle adopted by the Master in
stating the accounts of the previous years, is as fol-
lows :—
OLE ON
oo napcmete ate ate te tt Ce ee
ites seme mipcinatnamatin ee nee OAR SASL AS
as iii cio hk Ee $7,508 93
INE 5. 5 sain x wwe ns Vex dea 6,730 78
Profit without deducting any expenses of sale. $778 15
1869.
BI a iis 330 '0:05' nk vk vee nae vee $ 8,551 33
Ae MAE GOIN Sa 0. kn ngs Kees ohn weak 10,148 33
Loss incurred by B. and §............... $1,596 70
Master’s Rep. p. 12.
IV. The loss incurred by Appellants in the year 1869
should be deducted from the aggregate of profits made
in other years.
Troy Iron and Nail Factory vs. Corning, 6
Blatch., 328.
Rubber Company ws. Goodyear, 9 Wall., 788.
V. The.true account of gain or profit of Appellants.
Adopting the rule laid down by the Master for ascer-
taining profit, viz: the difference between the money
paid and the money received, the true statement is this,
viz :—
a ae nae vewe ae: ...91,223 43
“ORGS rane MG Brolga ONE i 1,197 20
EE ae pee MP ena eat ACNE EN ws aoe cee an TTT 25
TIGR SRA ene Rite ES ncieteHReE SA! OO A AIO PER atte) A
$3,197 88
Not allowing anything for the expense and cost of
selling. |
From this amount the loss of 1869 should be deducted.
-*
} &
=)
!
?
ads
-
Cog
5D
The account should be stated thus :—
Amount of profits for 1866, 1867 and 1868...$3,197 88
RA ROI oo kk wn eS debieii week we 1,596 70
PE 5 aR Kea $1,601 18
which, under the most favorable rule, the Appellee would
be entitled to recover.
Under the rule laid down in Mowry vs. Whitney, the
facts reported by the Master show that the Appellee
would not be entitled to anything.
VI. As to the first claim of Appellee.
Rep. pp. 14, 15.
The Appellants submit that the calculations and find-
ings of the Master as to the gain made, are not warranted
by the evidence.
The disallowance of the claim was correct.
Yee $e
~»-
Z24
0 ahi nt Nene er arm a ts
RARE RATT TT I aos ig oer tee a Le ~
a oy pen coreneane tie ” “me 7 “4
” its Pea ae pie hae cir she Pe . vk aie
SUPREME COURT OF THE’ UNITED STATES.
No. 239.
JAMES BROWN AND WILLIAM SEAVEY, APPELLANTS,
vs.
ENOCH PIPER.
BRIEF FOR APPELLEE.
ora Ne
a.
a
4
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
No. 239.
L
JAMES BROWN AND WILLIAM SEAVEY, APPELLANTS,
US. .
ENOCH PIPER.
BRIEF FOR APPELLEE.
BOSTON :
ADDISON C. GETCHELL, LAW PRINTER,
53 WASHINGTON STREET,
1875.
BRIEF FOR APPELLEE.
This is an appeal from a final decree of the Circuit Court of the
District of Massachusetts, for a perpetual injunction restraining the
ss
appellants from the use of the invention patented to the appellee by
United States letters patent dated March 19 1861, and for profits
and costs.
The questions raised are as to —
I. THE NOVELTY OF THE PATENTED INVENTION.
Il. INFRINGEMENT BY THE APPELLANTS.
Ill. THE AMOUNT OF PROFITS.
4 I. NOVELTY OF THE PATENTED INVENTION.
The patent is for an improvement in the art of preserving fish, &c.
It is printed on pp. 74~76 of the Record.
The patentee describes his invention as a method of preserving
fish, &c.
The term “preserving,” as used in the patent,’ clearly includes
freezing and keeping frozen.
The description and specification make the object of the inven-
tion plain. It is to provide a mode of freezing fish and other ar-
ticles of fuod, and preserving them in a frozen state, by which they
~ may be conveniently kept in any desired quantities and for any de-
sired length of time.
i: The patentee refers to the common method of packing fish “ with
. e crushed ice in barrels or boxes,” which, he says, “owing to the
melting of the ice, and the consequent moistening of the. fish, fails
to preserve them fresh and good for more than 2 month at most.”
He states that his invention “consists in a method of preserving
fish and other articles by placing them within a chamber, and
or
cooling the latter [meaning of course the air in zt] by means of a
—— Sane
4
freezing mixture, so applied that no communication shall exist be-
tween the interior of the preserving chamber and that of the vessels
in which the freezing mixture is placed;” and he says, “ The tem-
perature of the preserving chamber can be maintained for any |
length of time below the freezing point, and fish, surrounded by :
this dry and freezing atmosphere, will be preserved as fresh and
good as when first caught, and for a much longer period than by any
other method known to me.”
He says that the apparatus for freezing the fish, &c., and keeping
them in a frozen state, may be constructed “zn various ways and of
different shapes,” and that the apparatus shewn in the drawing will
suffice to ¢llustrate the principle and mode of operation. And after-
wards, “ J do not desire to be understood as confining myself to the
use of the specific apparatus above described.”
The described method is this: The atmosphere of the chamber
in which the articles are placed, which is kept from communication
with the external air by means of non-conducting walls, is reduced
to, and kept at, a temperature below the freezing point of water by
means of a freezing mixture, having no contact with the freezmg at-
mosphere of the chamber; and the fish, &c., immersed in this
atmosphere are frozen and kept so, and also kept from deterioration
as if they were ina natural freezing atmosphere.
This atmosphere, in which the fish, &c., are frozen and kept, is
described in the patent as.a “dry and freezing atmosphere.”
The apparatus referred to for illustration, when used as described
in the patent, is adapted to produce such an atmosphere ; viz., reez-
ing, because exposed to the influence of the freezing mixture, and
protected by double non-conducting walls from the outer air; and |
dry, because there is no communication between it and the freezing a
mixture or the outer air.
The claim is in apt words to secure sucb an invention as has been ee
described. It is — e yy
“ Preserving fish or other articles in a close chamber by means
of a freezing mixture having no contact with the atmosphere of the
preserving chamber, substantially as set forth.”
The practical result. accomplished by the invention thus patent- an’
ed is, that in a room or chamber suitable for storing fish, &c., in
5
desired quantities, and from which they may be taken as desired, the
atmosphere is kept below the freezing point and in a dry state.
The patent cannot be construed as for the apparatus described.
It is not a patent for a machine or a manufacture within the mean-
ing of the act of 1870, § 24, allowing patents for an “ art, machine,
manufacture or composition of matter,” but it is a patent for an
improvement in the art of preserving fish and other substances from
decay. The patentee calls it a method. It is really for a peculiar
process. Neither term is used in the patent act, but either sufficient- :
ly indicates the nature of the invention, and each is synonymous |
ASDA EPA PS 0 2 TLR PATTAYA ID ELLE SEY
tot ye al OER! pity.
with “ art,” as that term is used in the act.
Jorning v. Burden, 15 How. 252.
Curtis on Patents, §§ 9-18.
Tilghman v. Werk, 2 Fish. 578.
O’Reilly v. Morse, 15 How. 62.
It is plain that Piper’s actual invention was of the process or meth-
od above described of preserving fish, &c., by artificial congelation,
which was capable of being carried out in various forms, and has, in
fact, been so carried out by himself, always with very valuable
results.
?
ee
The. court, having ascertained what the invention actually was,
will give to the patent such a construction as will secure the whole
of that invention, interpreting the language of the specification
liberally for that purpose, if necessary.
Surtis on Patents, §§ 225, 231, 453, 456, and cases cited.
If the construction here put upon the patent is correct, the ques- j
tion of the novelty of Piper’s invention is, not whether the apparatus
described in the patent was new, nor whether any apparatus was in
ee existence before his invention which might have been so used as to
y o practise the invention; but whether the patented process as de- |
scribed was in fact so practised. ;
And to overthrow his patent for want of novelty, it must be proved
that before his invention fish or other articles had been frozen and |
ae’ preserved by a process in which the articles were frozen and pre-
a served by immersion in the freezing atmosphere of a chamber,
eaceeeeeetieeaion a ae a
nheueeteeemaineten anaen
6
that atmosphere being reduced and kept below the freezing point
by a refrigerating mixture, which had substantially no commupica-
»
tion with such atmosphere.
Before discussing alleged prior inventions, it is necessary to refer
to the evidence shewing the history of Piper's invention.
It does not appear that before his invention fish or other sub-
stances had ever been really frozen and- kept frozen so as to be fit
for the market ; now that that has ever been done since his invention,
save hy the use of it: and it clearly appears that the use of it has
added largely to the value of the fish business in this country.
Between 1858 and 1868, nearly 73,000 pounds of salmon preserved
by Piper’s process were sold by his agents in the city of New York.
The sales for the last of those years were 52,514 pounds. The sell-
ing price during the first nine years was from sixty-five cents to one
dollar. The selling price during the tenth year was forty to sixty
cents. |
G. W. Middleton, Rec. pp. 131, 1382, 133; direct 16, 25-33.
E. G. Blackford, Rec. pp. 134, 135-137; direct 5-7, 16, 17;
cross 55.
W. H. Middleton, Rec. pp. 142, 143, 144; direct 9-16, 21-
23, 25. .
Carman, Rec. p. 100; direct 8, 69, 70-77.
W. M. Rogers, Rec. pp. 240, 243, 244; direct 1-9; cross
8-20. i
FE. Piper, Rec. p. 267; direct 53-59.
He was engaged in the coasting business, in a neighbourhood
where the business of exporting salmon to points further South
was carried on.
His experiments began in the winter and spring of 1858.
Piper, Rec. p. 260; int. 2.
In the spring of 1858, he froze a few fish, principally to ascer-
tain whether fish artificially frozen would be the same as those natur-
ally frozen. The result was satisfactory. He used for this purpose
a small temporary apparatus, of which Piper Model No. 1 is a rep-
resentation. This had a chamber, the air in which (being the air
~
a ett wnte nl
“4
7
that the fish lay in) was reduced and kept below the freezing point
by the influence of freezing mixture put around the chamber, but
having no communication with the atmosphere thereof. Suitable
means of drawing off the pickle were provided.
Piper, Rec. pp. 260, 261, 272; direct 5-11; cross 32-38.
In June 1858, he constructed and used the apparatus of which
Piper Model No. 2 is « representation.
air in which (being the air that the fish lay in) was reduced and
This had two chambers, the
kept below the freezing point by the influence of freezing mixture
contained in vertical tubes within the chambers; the space around
the chambers being packed with a non-conducting substance, hav-
ing no communication with the atmosphere of the chamber. Suit-
able means of drawing off the pickle were provided. The use of
this apparatus, in the manner described, was a complete reduction
* to practice of the invention which is the subject of Piper’s first patent.
The apparatus was made to be used, and was in fact used, so as
to carry out the patented process.
Between forty and fifty salmon were frozen in one of these cham-
bers, the latter part of June and first of July 1858, and were
preserved in a frozen state in the other chamber from that time
till about the 1st of December following, when they were taken out,
brought to Boston, and sold to Wm. M. Rogers & Co., of New
York. -— :
Piper, Rec. pp. 261-2638, 272, 273, 283; direct 12-23; crass
89-59, 139, 140.
Eliza Piper, Rec. pp. 286, 287; direct 6-10, 25, 26.
John Marston, Rec. pp. 295, 296; direct 14-16.
Gilson Carman, Rec. p. 100; direct 8.
This apparatus, and the new process of freezing and preserving
fish, are described generally in Piper’s caveat, filed in July 1858.
Rec. p. 307.
Piper has furnished frozen salmon every year since to Rogers &
Co. or their successors. |
Piper, Rec. p. 263; int. 24.
G. Carman, Rec. p. 100; direct 8.
8
His Patent Office model was made in December 1858; and a sim-
ilar model is produced in two parts, marked Piper Model No. 3, A;
and Piper Model No. 3, B.
Piper, Rec. p. 263: int. 28, 29.
It was in an apparatus like the Patent ‘Office model that he froze
and preserved the catch of 1859.
Piper, Rec. pp. 264, 274, 275, 281, 282; direct 32, 34-37;
cross 63-69, 80-82, 121-129.
For preserving the fish in a frozen state he used the preserving
chamber of that apparatus up to 1865. (Piper, Rec. p. 264; int.
33.) He froze the catch of 1860 and subsequent years till 1865,
using the freezing part (No. 3, B) of that apparatus a little differ-
ently from the mode described; that is to say, he put the fish in
the pans, and the freezing mixture around them. (Rec. p. 263; ,
int. 30. Eliza Piper, Rec. pp. 286, 287; direct 16, 24.) He
found it froze the fish quicker. (Piper, Rec. p. 265; int. 47.
See also Rec. pp. 278, 279; cross 89-97.) But the process was the
same.
His Patent Office Model for his second patent (i.e., that dated
August 5 1862) was made in May 1862. In the same month he
put up an apparatus of that construction in New York for the
use of his selling agents, Middleton, Carman & Co. In the spring
of 1864 he put up similar apparatus at St. John, N.B., and used
it for freezing and preserving fish, and, except during the summer
of 1866, has used it ever since.
Piper, Rec. p. 265; int. 41-46.
Middleton, Rec. p. 180; int. 8-14.
Carman, Rec. pp. 100-105.
But as early as 1860 he constructed a model shewing the main
parts of this apparatus patented in 1862, viz., the non-conducting
walls, the receiving pans. and vertical descending tubes connected
with the pans by flanges, making the pans readily movable. This
model is produced, marked Piper Model No. 4.
Piper, Rec. pp. 264, 265; int. 38-41.
Eliza Piper, Rec. p. 287; direct 27-31, 18.
i OS UR ty te
i
9
Before passing from this part of the case, we may allude to the
use of salt and ice in the same chamber with the fish, as it may be
suggested that Piper’s actual invention included, and that his first pa-
tent includes, such use.
(1.) It made no part of his invention. If he ever tried it at all,
it was merely as an experiment, the result of which was not satisfac-
tory. (Piper, Rec. pp. 269, 270, 271, 278; cross 1-27, 82-88.)
A statement that he contemplated such a use was inserted in his
original application for his first patent (Rec. p. 548), but was
omited in his amended specification in which the patent was granted
(Rec. p. 554). It was so inserted in the original application by
mistake of the solicitor. (Piper, Rec. p. 271; cross 28, 85-88.)
(2.) Such a mode of using salt and ice is expressly excluded by
the language of his patent; and the objections to such a use are (1)
that the atmospheve of the chamber is corrupted by intermingling
with the salt and ice, so as to affect the flavor or appearance of
the fish; and (2) that where such communication exists, the salt
and ice cannot be replenished, as it needs to be every few hours,
without admitting the external warm air to the atmosphere of the
freezing or preserving chamber, and thus preventing the necessary
freezing temperature from being maintained.
THE BENJAMIN & GRAFTON PATENT.
~~
It is contended by the appellants that the process patented in Pi-
per’s patent of March 19 1861 is found described in the English pa-
tent granted to Benjamin & Grafton in 1842, the specification of
which is printed at Rec. pp. 557, 558.
This patent describes éwo plans for preserving fish, &c., one of
which is applicable when these articles are to be preserved for a
long time, and the other when they are to be kept preserved for
a short time.
Lhe first process is to immerse them in water in a metallic or oth-
er vessel, which is deposited in a freezing mixture contained in a
wooden trough, and left until the water and fish are frozen ina
solid block.
This process has none of the elements of Piper's, except that
ae ER ct A ETAL tt NET EN tN NNN ERC tt tnt et ters tt
10
freezing mixture is used. There is no dry freezing atmosphere to
put the fish in; whereas that is the fundamental idea of Piper’s in-
vention.
The process described by Benjamin & Grafton must be practi-
eally of little or no utility for the purpose, as Mr. Renwick says,
"In the first place, the fish cannot be frozen till all the water is
frozen. In the second place, there would be a great waste of ice
and salt in freezing the surrounding water. In the third place, the
ice near the fish, and the fish itself, would have to be frozen by cold
applving itself through the ice already formed, which is a good non-
conductor, and would thus incresse the waste of freezing mixture.
Fourthly, there would be.a great waste of room in the apparatus,
as it would not contain nearly as many fish as it would if no water
were used ; and lastly, it would be almost impossible to determine
when the fish were frozen. And even if the fish were frozen, it
would be necessary to transport it from place to place inside of its
block of ice, thereby materially increasing the cost of transportation.”
Ree. pp. 300, 301.
The second process described by Benjamin & Grafton is to employ
freezing mixtures to cool the air of a close room made of brick or
other suitable material sufficiently excluding the heat of the sun (no
non-conducting walls) and the fish having been placed in this room,
the air is caused to “circulate against the surfaces of metal vessels
containing freezing mixtures by means of revolving fans or other
suitable means within the room or chamber, the object being to keep
the air of the room in constant movement.” “ By this arrangement,”
the patentees say, “the fish will be kept cool and preserved, and ¢f it
has been previously frozen as before described (i.e., in blocks of ice),
the keeping it in a room or chamber as Jhere described would retain
it in a frozen state.”
Mr. Waters, expert witness for the appellants, suys, that he con-
siders the Benjamin & Grafton processes the same as the Piper pro-
cess, because in both the fish are frozen artificially by the thawing
of ice by means of salt, thereby extracting the caloric from the
“surroundings” of the fish, and consequently from the fish them-
selves, and are kept frozen by a continuation of the same means of
|
g
11
freezing, the fish being kept from contact with the oxygen of the
atmosphere and from any contact with the freezing mixture.
Ree. p. 541, int. 5.
Mr. Renwick, expert witness for the appellee, says, that he con-
siders the Benjamin & Grafton processes not the same as the Piper
process, and gives his reasons, viz., that the fish is not frozen by im-
9
mersion in “ surroundings” of cold air, which is one of the essentials
of Piper’s process, but is frozen while in a tank of water, and only
after the surrounding water has been frozen. He further says, “I
am unable to find in the Benjamin & Grafton patent any description
of freezing fish by immersion in an atmosphere‘of common air, re-
duced below the freezing point by means of freezing mixtures, con-
tained in vessels whose interiors are practically out of communication
with that atmosphere; neither am I able to find any deseription
stating that fish thus frozen are to be kept frozen, and therefore pre-
served in a similar atmosphere ; and this atmosphere, thus cooled and
kept from contact with a freezing mixture, is the essential element
in working out Piper’s: process. Benjamin & Grafton further de-
scribe a plan for cooling (not freezing) and preserving for a short
time ; but, in carrying out this latter plan, there is no description
that the temperature of the chambers enclosing atmosphere in which
the articles are to be immersed is to be kept below the freezing
point, nor any description that the freezing mixture centained in the
vessels within this room is to be kept out of contact with the atmos-
phere of-the room. The fact that the temperature, both for freez-
ing and for preserving, should be below the freezing point, and that
the atmosphere surrounding the fish should be out of contact with the
freezing mixture, are both essentials in Piptr’s process, and de-
scribed in his patent, and neither of them are described or even hinted
at in the patent granted to Benjamin & Grafton.”
Rec. pp. 300, 301.
It will be observed that Mr. Waters speaks twice of the fish
being kept from contact with the freezing mixture as one of the es-
sentials of the process of both Piper and Benjamin & Grafton.
As regards the Piper process, he can only gather the essentials
—
ate eteceeementer ae ee nate
Aleta aint sehies dint
12
of it from the Piper specification, and there the essential in ques-
tion is described, not as keeping the fish from contact with the freezing
mixture, but as keeping the atmosphere of the chamber in which the
fish are placed from such contact.
This, then, is what Mr. Waters means when he speaks of this
particular essential of Piper’s process.
Now, one of the reasons he gives for the opinion that Benjamin &
Grafton describe the same process that Piper does, is that Benjamin
& Grafton describe this protection from contact with the freezing mix-
ture; and how much his judgment depends upon this supposed fact
we cannot know. But it is certain that the supposed fact does
not exist. It is certain that Benjamin & Grafton do not describe
what Mr. Waters thinks they do; ‘that is, they do not describe
that protection of the atmosphere of the chamber from contact with
the freezing mixture which Piper describes.
They do, indeed, deseribe the formation of a block of ice around
the fish, which block of ice keeps the enclosed fish from contnact
with anything except the ice; but this is not what Mr. Waters
means, for no such thing as this is supposed to be in Piper’s patent,
and he is speaking of something which he finds in that patent.
This apparent misreading of the Piper specification by Mr.
Waters exposes his whole statement of opinion as to the nature of
the invention, and its novelty also, to more or less doubt.
As Mr. Waters and Mr. Renwick agree that the absence of any
substantial communication between the freezing mixture and the at-
mosphere of the chamber containing the fish zs an essential of Pi-
per’s process, the court can have no difficulty in disposing of the
Benjamin & Grafton patent when it is seen that that patent does not
describe such absence of communication.
The appellants volunteered on cross-examination to prove by Mr.
Piper that upon the rejection of his application by the Patent Office,
as anticipated by Benjamin & Grafton, he went out to England to
see them, and “ascertain the fact as to whether any such apparatus
was built, and whether any business was ever done with it,” and
that he did not, while there, see any apparatus claimed to be con-
structed after that patent, or any freezing apparatus at all.
Rec. p. 280; cross 114-119. +
—_
——
13
They also sought to prove that Mr. Piper had, in a certain conver-
sation with one Pike, stated what information Benjamin & Grafton
had. given him of their past doings with their apparatus (Pike,
Ree. p. 5382; direct 31, 33).
Mr. Piper, when recalled, gives a part of the statement which Pike
omitted, viz., that he informed him that he ascertained by informa-
tion in London that Benjamin & Grafton’s experiments proved a
total failure, after costing a thousand pounds. (Ree. p. 302;
direct 2.)
THe “Goop” APPARATUS AND PROCESS.
John Good, of Philadelphia, invented an apparatus for the preser-
vation of dead bodies, which he patented August 17 1843, and cer-
tain improvements thereon, which he patented December 12 1854.
Several witnesses are produced by appellants to prove the use of
the apparatus in such a-manner as to involve the practising of Piper’s
process.
The Court will observe that, as regards the validity’ of Piper’s
first patent, viz., for the process, the mere fact that any previously
existing apparatus could have been so used as to involve the practis-
ing of that process avails the appellants nothing. Doubtless there
have been many apparatuses long known, and used in other ways and
for other purposes, which might have been used in such a way, and
for such a. purpose, as Piper’s first patent covers. This is nothing
more than to say that his first patent is for a process, and not for the
apparatus, which he has (for illustration) described as suitable for
‘arrying out his process.
The Court will also observe that Piper’s invention is of « process
by which animal and vegetable substances are completely frozen —
frozen through — and preserved in that state for weeks, or months, or
yeare. No such thing is ever required to be done with a human
body. It will be found that ail the appellants’ witnesses claim is,
that they used ice and salt to bring the body more quickly to that con-
dition to which it is usually brought by the use of ice alone. They
used sometimes ice, and sometimes ice and salt; but they did so to
accomplish the same result in the two cases.
16
3 _~ ipparatus, using ice and salt only in the pan placed on the top of the
body.
Rec. p. 512; direct 12.
Afterwards he is asked, on ecross-examination, when he first so
used it, and he answers, “OiF and on for most of the length of time
that I have had them.”
Rec. p. 5133 cross 11.
(3.) He used the ice and salt only to get @ quick result.
Rec. pp. 512 et seg.; direct 8, cross 9, 14, 15.
(4.) He did not really freeze the body at all. He first says he
thinks he has frozen a body in less than six hours. (Rec. p. 514;
cross 20.) And if he means anything more than freezing the sur-
face, this is impossible. Afterwards he is asked, “Did you ever
freeze the body of an adult in an apparatus like the apparatus used
in the way inquired of? Ans. We have an idea that they were froze.
Did you know that they were frozen? Ans. No,sir. Do you know
that the bodies of children have been frozen, using the apparatus in
this way? Ans. No, sir.”
Ree. p. 514; cross 26-28.
John Good’s ex-parte affidavit is in the case by consent, in lieu of
his deposition. (Ree. pp. 564, 565.) He says, “After taking out
my first patent (1843), I occasionally used salt commingled with ice,
which I found froze the body,” &c. “I do not think that I have had
occasion to use sult commingled with ice since I received my patent
of 1854.” |
This deseribes simply the use of salt and ice where ice alone
had been used before; and referring to the previous part of his af-
fidavit, we find that the ice had been used tn the bottom of the box,
under the perforated plate, »s well as in the pan over the body. Ice
and salt thus used would not involve the process of Piper, because
of the free communication between the freezing mixture and the at-
mosphere of the chamber.
Mr. Waters testifies that ¢f the Good apparatus is “used in the
following manner, namely, placing the substance to be frozen on the
*
17
perforated false bottom elevated above the bottom of the box, the
pan, setting over and into the chamber in which the substance is
placed, filled with ice and salt, and the outside groove filled with
water, and the outside cover put on, so as to exclude the external air
from all contact with either the freezing mixture or the substance
to be frozen, and so continued long enough to freeze the substance
>
in. the chamber,” the process does not differ substantially from
Piper’s. (Ree. p. 542; direct 8.) But, as before shewn, there
is no satisfactory evidence that the Good apparatus was ever so used
before Piper's invention; and as to any of the other modes of its
use, Mr. Waters’ “silence gives assent” to the proposition that they
do differ substantially from Piper’s process. *
THe “ PrKe” PROCEss.
Charles F. Pike in 1856 made an experiment in a refrigerator,
using salt and ice. The evidence in regard to it is furnished by him-
self and his workman, Ottis P. Underwood.
The evidence strikingly illustrates the danger of relying upon
general statements as to things being “frozen.”
Underwood says the meats, fish, &c., put into the apparatus were
“frozen.” Pike says he was enabled by the use of his apparatus to
“freeze” substances placed in the preserving chamber.
Ree. p. 515; direct 7; p. 530; direct 9.
But Underwood says that together with the meat, fish, &c., there
was put in on one experiment @ bowl of water, and the water was not
Srozen.
Rec. p. 520; cross 62.
This single admission puts an end of course to the pretence that
Piper’s process was anticipated by Pike.
And it is certain there could not have been a freezing atmosphere
(viz., below 32°) within the chamber of the apparatus; for there
were openings expressly provided to keep up @ current of air from
outside, passing through the apparatus around the walls of the cham-
ber and out of the «apparatus at the opposite side. (Rec. p. 519;
cross 40, 42, 43.) Whereas non-conducting walls around the air
18°
chamber are prescribed by Piper, and are necessary to the practical
maintenance of the required temperature in the air chamber.
No attempt is made to prove by any expert (as was done in the
case of the “Good” process) that Pike’s described use of his appara-
tus involved the practising of Piper’s process.
The fact is, that Pike was engaged in improving refrigerators
only. He was the owner of the State right under the well-known
Schooley refrigerator patent from 1855 to 1865, during which time
he built as many as a thousand of the Schooley refrigerators. He
tried repeated experiments to get greater cold in those refrigera-
tors, while preserving the essential features of that class of appara-
tus. It isan advantage in a refrigerator to have a current of fresh
air constantly passing through it, “to carry off the perfumes, mould,
must, fungus,” as Mr. Pike expresses it, “that would arise from any
one or all articles in the chamber.” There are no such “ perfumes,”
&c., from articles which are really frozen. A refrigerator is de-
signed to keep articles cold without freezing them, and at the same
time keep them fresh. Hence it is practicable and advantageous
to have a current of air from without circulating through the appara-
tus. He had got the temperatnre of his refrigerator down to forty
or forty-eight degrees by using the apparatus with ice; and his ex-
periment with salt and ice was simply to see if he could not get
it colder still, but retaining the current of fresh air through the pre-
serving chamber, and consequently not having a temperature below
the freezing point therein. The feature in a refrigerator of having
a reverberation of the current of fresh air, as Pike had, was patented
by Schooley. (Rec. p. 344; direct 4; Rec. p. 515; int. 4; pp.
529, 530; int. 8; pp. 533, 534, 535; cross 1-4, 11-17, 24-31.)
Whatever may have been the object and the intended opera-
tion of the apparatus used as described with ice and salt, it was
a mere experiment, and was abandoned. But one such apparatus
was made, and that, after the experiments, was broken up. (Rec.
pp. 535, 536; cross 32-38.)
But the testimony of Pike proves somewhat more than his own
failure.
In'1860 or 1861, the appellants, Brown & Seavey, applied to Pike
~~ p
19
to build them “a refrigerator for freezing fish.” He says that he
supposes he described to them. his experiments in freezing made in
1856; but they did not give him the order then to make a freez-
ing apparatus for them. (Rec. p. 536; cross 40-42.)
July 16 1862, Pike wrote to Piper asking for the date of his pa-
tent (the first one — not the second, for that was not then granted),
so’ that he could get a certified copy of it. Afterwards, he did
proceed to build for Brown & Seavey the apparatus they were sued
for using. (Rec. p. 536; cross 43.)
Tue “ Wuttson ” PROCEsS.
An attempt is made to prove that one Willett P. Whitson, of New
York, practised substantially Piper’s process, before Piper’s inven-
tion.
Whitson had two apparatuses; the first is shewn at Ree. p.
384; and the second at Rec. p. 386.
By the use of the first one, he is supposed to have practised Pi-
per’s process. But the éime at which this use is proved is too
late to be of any service to the appellants.
The first apparatus was constructed and used in the fall of 1860
( Whitson, Ree. p. 391; cross 78. ice, Rec. p. 526; cross 6,
7), two years and more after Piper’s invention.
Tue “ Racry ” PROcEss.
One Joseph Racey, of New York, claims to have frozen fish by
the same process substantially as that which is patented to Piper,
and previously to Piper’s invention.
Racey had two freezers. The last was built in the latter part of
1859. (Joseph Tacey, Rec. p. 311; int. 14 e¢ seq.) :
This was more than a year after Piper’s invention in 1858.
Racey’s first apparatus was built and put in use, he says, as early
as 1856; but his process which he practised therein bore no resem-
blance to that which is the subject of Piper’s first patent.
Racey says (Rec. pp. 309, 310; int. 6) be put in a layer of ice
and then a layer of fish, and so on till he got it up nearly to the
20
pan. (See Model No. 2.) This is just what Piper says in his pa-
tent was the old and objectionable mode of keeping fish fresh.
Racey also says he put ice and salt in the top pan, by which
means he found the ice in the box did not melt so soon. (R. P. p. 6.)
He also says that a salmon which he put in there “ was not frozen
in the style we freeze them now [viz., by the use of Piper's in-
vention]; the salmon was very hard, but would give, — it was
frozen to a certain extent.” (Rec. pp. 309, 310; int. 6.)
Il. INFRINGEMENT.
The appellants have frozen fish and preserved them frozen, in an
apparatus which was inspected by Mr. Renwick, and by a method
or process which is described by Seavey, one of the appellants.
Renwick, Ree. pp. 82, 83; int. 4-7.
Seavey, Ree. pp. 80, &1.
The mode of using it was to put salt and ice into the pans at
the top, from which it passed into the perpendicular tubes, which
extended through the chamber, in which chamber the fish were
placed on racks or shelves, the temperature of the chamber being
kept at from 18° to 24°.
Mr. Renwick says, “I consider this apparatus substantially iden-
tical with that described in the patent of ‘Mr. Piper [meaning the
first patent]; and that the process worked out therein, as described
by Mr. Seavey, is substantially identical with the improvement in
an art or artificial process described in the same patent.”
Rec. p. 83; int. 6.
Mr. Waters, 2 distinguished expert, is examined on behalf of
the appellants, and does not controvert either of these statements.
There is really no question of infringement in the case, if the true
construction of the Piper patent be as submitted, and the improved
art or method or process be new.
Il. THE AMOUNT OF PROFITS.
It is found by the master’s report, confirmed by the Circuit Court,
é
ae |
‘
that the appellants used the patented invention in the vears 1866,
1867, 1868, 1869, 1870.
Rec. pp. 11-75.
In 1866 and 1867 they used it hy means of an apparatus owned
by them, at Charlestown, which they were using when the suit
was commenced; they were enjoined by the Circuit Court in 1867,
and in 1868 and 1869 preserved their fish, &e., in the establishment
of the Boston Fruit Preserving Company and its successor, the
~
Massachusetts Fruit Preserving Company, at Cambridge.
On proceedings in contempt they were held to have violated the
injunction by their operations of 1868 and 1869, and were fined
therefor; and in 1870 they returned to the use of the Charlestown
apparatus, which they claimed before the master, to have altered
meanwhile, so that its use in 1870 was not an infringement of the
patent.
1. ProFits oF 1866 anp 1867.
The master accepted the appellants’ figures of receipts and ex-
penditures for these years. The profit found is $1223.43 for 1866, °
and $1197.20 for 1867. (Ree. pp. 12, 21, 24, 26.)
The appellants claimed to deduct for each year ten per cent on
the gross sales of the year; five per cent as commission on the
sales, and five per cent for guaranty.
This‘claim was rightly disallowed. It is not pretended that the
appellants actually paid anything for commissions and guaranty ;
they bought and sold the fish themselves, on their own account.
It amounts to a claim for compensation to the appellants for their
own services In committing the infringement comp!ained of. This
is never allowed.
If the first and second objections of Schedule I, p. 28, are seri-
ously urged, they are sufficiently answered by reference to the mas-
ter’s additional report, p. 24.
2. PROFITS OF 1868 ANpD 1869.
The appellants’ receipts for these years were taken, as_ stated
by them, at $7508.03 for 1868, and $8551.63 for 1869.
Rec. p. 12; Schedules C and D, p. 20.
a a si
oes Nes Sx a, Se Ree ee ge Nee een SR e mil tay Micah 0 UALR le Sot Mi Ti. ‘ : ;
as Sy) eRe 4 aot Bu TP Ne ee Wher Ree OOS AY Re Pees as Se ae gee ere ee fo Res Tee i AED SY
ee yet Be See — tiga ve BS Ed Be By “ -3 ai 1 ee Vea me nts Se; ae i \ rane Oe ake
They claimed a deduction of ten per cent on the gross sales of
each year for commission and guaranty, as before, which was right-
ly disallowed.
They also claimed that the cost and expense for these years
(excluding commission, &c.) amounted to $6730.78 and $10,148.33,
respectively. They were allowed as cost and expense $3658.28 for
1868, and $6778.83 for 1869. |
The master rejected a charge of $3600 and $4200 for cost and
expenses of these years, respectively ; of which $3500 was claimed
to have been paid to the Boston Fruit Preserving Company, as rent
for 1868 of an apparatus at the company’s frnuit-house in Cambridge,
and $100 for sundry small items; and $4000 as rent for the same
apparatus, and $200 for other expenses for 1869; and allowed three
cents per pound as expenses for these years.
The reasons for the findings are fully stated in the master’s re-
port (Rec. pp. 18-20). 3
It is enough to ask attention to the fact that the appellants claim
to have paid $3500, as rent for 1868, for the use of an apparatus
substantially the same in size and construction as that for which
they charged $100 rent in 1866, and $400 in 1867; or, taking it per
pound for fish preserved, the rent was one cent per pound in 1866
and 1867, and thirteen cents per pound in 1868 and 1869. Con-
sidered as general expenses, the cost for 1866 and 1867 was three
cents per pound, and for 1868 and 1869 was seventeen cents per
pound.
The specific objections to the findings of the master are, —
(a) The appellants say he has not conformed to the genera! rule
of law regulating the ascertainment of profits in such cases, in that
he has not allowed actual payments made by the defendants, and
costs and expenses incurred by them in prosecuting the business.
As to this, he refused to allow the “actual payments” claimed
to have been made because he did not believe, on the evidence,
that they had been made; and in this he was fully justified.
?
e
He allowed as
was sufficiently favorable to the defendants, and of which they can-
‘costs and expenses” three cents a pound, which
not complain.
a
73. alien iC7k aad
2 7 Ce seas ae
ie aia
> 3
™ 2
(6) They say he has adopted an arbitrary standard, established by
himself, for ascertaining the costs und expenses, instead of con-
forming to the evidence introduced by the complainant.
But the evidence of payment for rent of this year was net in-_
troduced by the complainant. The’ statements of «a defendant on
cross-examination as to his account rendered before the master are
not to be regarded as testimony introduced by the complainant.
The master did not adopt an “arbitrary standard,” but found
au fact very favorable to the defendaiuts, by inference from the only
testimony in his opinion credible before him, in regard to the
amount to be allowed for costs and expenses.
(c) They say the basis on which the master estimated the costs
for this year is erroneous.
This has been sufficiently answered.
(d) They say there was no evidence to warrant the conclusion
that the alleged payments of $3600 in 1868 and $4200 in 1869.
were not dona fide payments, &., &e.
The complainant submits that there was such evidence, and suffi-
cient evidence, and that the finding is fully warranted.
(e) They say that “all the findings of the master relating to the
costs and expenses of the years 1868 and 1869 are contrary to the
evidence and the weight of evidence submitted to him and reported
to the court.”
The appellee insists to the contrary as before. “It is unnecessary
to go into an examination of the evidence in this regard. The point
is fully discussed by the master. |
(f) They say that the master erred in not finding as specifically
requested in Schedule K. (Ree. pp. 29, 30.)
Request 2 is to an allegation of fact which has already been suf-
ficiently answered.
Request 3 is, that they may be aliowed the alleged loss, $1500,
on the business of 1869, as a deduction from the general profits re-
ceived in other years.
As tothis: Ist, It is found as a fact that there was no loss on
the business of 1859, but a profit (Rec. p. 21). 2d, The appelice
submits that, it being a fact, as found by the master, “that the
business of each year stood by itself, was settled before another
24
year’s operations began, some months intervening between tlie close
of the operations of one year before the operations of the succeed-
ing year began” (Rec. p. 26), he was right as matter of, law in
holding that the losses of ene year should not be deducted from the
profits of other years.
3. Prorits oF 1870.
There is no question of figures as to the profits of this year. If
the appellee is entitled to anything for 1870, it is the amount stated
by the master, $2371.21.
The appellants make various objections to the master’s findings
as to this year, all amounting to this: that the master erred in find-
ing asa fact that the appellants used the patented invention in their
Charlestown apparatus. , Se
The appellee submits that the finding was justified by the evidence.
That the Charlestown apparatus was originally so constructed that
its use was an infringement of the patent, and that it was so used
for the two sensons of 1866 and 1867; that it was altered between
June 20 and December 3 1870, so that its use would not be an in-
fringement, but so that it could readily be restored to its original
condition ; that the fish preserved in it in 1870 were frozen, and in
other respects similar to those frozen und preserved in 1866 and
1867: that the appellants refused to allow an inspection of the only
chamber of the apparatus in use when the master visited it for that
purpose in 1870; that they made no explanation of the condition of
the apparatus in which the fish were frozen and preserved in 1870
(all which are facts proved, Rec. pp. 16, 17, 18), is sufficient justifi-
cation of the finding. The mere refusal to shew the only chamber in
use is enough. Contra spoliatorem omnia presumuntur.
The only excuse made for the refusal, that to open the chamber
would hurt the fish, is not suffczent, for an inspection had been con-
sented to; nor is it true, for the chamber was opened to take out )
fish “once or twice a day, according to need ” (Rec. p. 17).
They object also that the mastcr assumed that the burden of proof
was upon them to shew there was no infringement in 1870.
This is a mistake. There was no such assumption. The master
Rabat. 2° >!
ne
li aoe
og a ee
oops eee
be
25
finds as a fact, that when in use the apparatus had no openings; he
was satisfied of this on the evidence, notwithstanding that openings
had previously been made, and Seavey said they were still there,
because he refused to allow the master to inspect the only apparatus
in use, and he omitted to put upon the stdnd the men who worked
the apparatus at the time. This fact the master states as a “ pre-
sumption ;” that is an inference from the facts he had already stated.
He finds it as a fact, however, and the court will take it as fact ac-
cordingly.
But it is submitted that, it having been decided that this apparatus
aus used in 1866 and 1867 did involve infringement, the burden of
proof was upon ‘the appellants to shew that when its use was re-
sumed in 1870, with the fish and the freezing mixture in the same
chambers, respectively, as before, there was a communication be-
tween the two chambers which there had not been before.
The motion of appellants for leave to introduce further evidence
a as to the transactions of this year was rightly denied.
The master was right in deciding that, as matter of law, it was not
competent for him to hear further evidence on any of the grounds
upon which it was offered after having submitted a draft of his re-
port to counsel.
The grounds of offering it are stated on page 27. As to these,
1. The appeilants’ information and belief was on a point of law in
regard to the burden of proof, and no ground for re-opening the case.
2. Thére was evidence tending to shew that the apparatus did not
contain the alterations when in use in 1870; and the complainant’s
counsel in his argument insisted upon this point as a fact (Rec. p.
26), and the master so found. The real complaint of the appellants
is, that they miscalculated the effect of that evidence.
3. Testimony will not be re-opened upon the statement of a wit-
: ness that he did not testify as the master says he did testify, or that
ad he intended to testify differently.
Upon the whole case the decree of the Circuit Court should be
affirmed.
CAUSTEN BROWNE,
jor Appellee.
Ke
Supreme Court of the Anited States.
io JAMES BROWN et al.
Us.
; ENOCH PIPER.
SUPPLEMENT. TO POINT SEVEN OF APPELLANTS’ BRIEF.
Racey had two freezers, one was constructed in 1855, or
early in 1856, and was used through 1856, 1857, and 1858.
Another was constructed in 1859.
Both of these freezers ante-dated the patent of Piper,
which was issued March 19, 1861, but by rebutting proof
Piper proved his invention back to June, 1858, thus ante-
dating Racey’s freezer of 1859.
The proof respecting the use of Racey’s first freezer
through the years 1856, 1857, and 1858 standsunimpaired.
Racey, during the years 1856, 1857, and 1858, practiced
freezing fish in a closed chamber by the use of q freezing
mixture cooling that chamber. This he did by placing the
fish in the chamber with ice, and having tne freezing mix-
ture in a receptacle near the top of the chamber.
Neither this use nor the testimony concerning it was
mentioned by the court below, and was, therefore, ignored
or entirely forgotten.
The only reply now made to it. by appellee’s counsel, in
his brief, is that that method of Racey in packing the fish
was the same as Piper says in his patent was old and ob-
| re jectionable.
Piper does not say that that mode of cooling or preserving
2
the fish so packed was old and objectionable. He only says
that such packing was old and objectionable. This practice
of Racey was exactly within the Piper patent.
He preserved both fish and ice in a closed chamber by
means of a freezing mixture.
He also froze fish in a close chamber by means of a
freezing mixture so applied that the freezing mixture was
not in communication with the atmosphere of the preserving
chamber.
He distinctly says that the top fish were frozen.
The degree to which they were frozen is not material to
bring the practice within the Piper patent, nor was it
necessary for all of the fish in the chamber to be frozen to
bring the operation within the Piper patent.
One of Piper’s modes was to coat his fish with ice and
then pack them “ closely ”’ in the preserving chamber. So
packed they would be in alternate layers of fish and ice,
just as Racey said was his practice during the years 1856,
1857, and 1858. ‘The only difference being that Racey ap-
plied the ice in layers between the layers of fish as they
were packed, instead of applying it as a coating to the fish
before they were packed. Being thus packed, each party,
both Piper and Racey, applied the freezing mixture to pre-
serve them as they were packed. The effect of the freezing
mixture in both eases would be to preserve both fish and
ice.
Racey.did more to the fish after being packed than did
Piper. Racey says he actually froze them by the applica-
tion of the freezing mixture, after they were packed in the
preserving chamber. Piper’s patent does not say that he
freezes the fish after they are packed in the preserving
chamber. By his patent he packed the fish in either of
hy theee conditions:
1st. Frozen and coated with ice.
. 2d. Without being frozen or coated with ice.
3
Either of these modes of packing are within the direc-
tion of his patent, and all that the patent requires to be
done with them after they are packed is to preserve them
in a condition suitable for use.
To test the sufficiency or insufliciency of Racey’s practice
during the years 1856, 1857, or 1858 to defeat the Piper
patent, let us consider whether if one now were to pack and
preserve fish just as Racey did he. would thereby infringe
the Piper patent. For that purpose, let us suppose A to be
engaged 1 in packing fish in a chamber by alternate layers
of ice and fish; then placing in the top of the chamber a
metallic receptacle, containing a freezing mixture of ice
and salt, the freezing mixture having no contact with the
atmosphere of the preserving chamber ; then enclosing the
chamber at the top, the freezing mixture serving to produce
and maintain a cold atmosphere within the chamber con-
taining the fish—just as Racey did. What could A, under
the circumstances, say in defence, if sued under the Piper
patent ? |
He would be correctly charged with doing exactly what
Piper first defines and then claims % to be his invention—
the preserving of fish or other articles in a close chamber
by means or a freezing mixture, having no contact with
the atmosphere of the preserving chamber. If A- should
say that he packs the fish in an unfrozen state, the answer
would be, so does the Piper patent, for it expressly ignores
the preliminary freezing.
If he were to say that his fish are packed in ice, the answer
would be, so are Piper’s, that being one of his ways of
packing.
If he were to say that he did not freeze all of the fish
contained in the chamber, the answer would be, that is im-
material, hecause according to the Piper patent, freezing is
not a necessity.
If he were to say that his only object was to keep the fish
alerts 2.x
Fenner artainnr necesita
Py tnt RON sth.
;
:
;
ua
at
t
r |
i
i
i
i
:
4
sufficiently cool to prevent their spoiling, the answer anne
be, that such was Piper’s object.
There would, therefore, be no way by which A wil es-
eape the charge of infringement.
Whatever would be an infringement of a patent, is sufti-
cient to invalidate the patent if known ond used prior to
the patentee’s invention.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.