Record and brief — The Suffolk Manufacturing Company, Plaintiff in Error, vs. Isaac Hayden
Supreme Court brief1864
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
No. +6: TZ. 1/4 e
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF
7 IN ERROR,
,
; VS.
: ISAAC HAYDEN,
o A
| |
| IN ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT
OF MASSACHUSETTS.
GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE.
.
.
-~
}
seni t
>
“ A BOON GS ae Ot Ct SCC EE REE Rn ay ae ee Pl CTE RTE IN Ge te A ee A OO fy ce Om —————————————
; ~ Se a rae
a yee worse ne otaee ets ene Po rman a ocean Sore Scores on areas : .
a eas SR ec Se RE NS Fe a eS RR ae = FORE hee SORT SSeS ROP OES <—<-meetee
pes —— eee we ~~ ~ - ee © n= bee ne ee — ~ Aenea * Bem ne ee Rs el ACO i et CA GIG AS Re ee Ce a ta, a eR ee Oar :
» - ate ae decease ~ thine nese einai i case ele apathy Ceca ate te iting manila tenn anette emtnmntia mee. smilpe lays lt inten tany nth Melina ttt aatt apts alii ne nin sutmagie at. +p: taentnllttt ttt COLO te ete = Vntitey Stlae AARON I LARA TIN LEAN A AAIOIE PEE I AGP BE os minnie RA eeeennanetinemmatinned
oy . .
wil - ee Sy Ce De ee eee ed
ERB LE OTIS ee
: Bugs ‘CSR ERIN NI RENNES AONE EI LENE I AERO IME IRE NE LE TRE SI EE AOR DOE REE AE BPE NERA TEN AF KITE MPT A RT NA ERE
ROARS ELIE LT LF EE TTT ;
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
No. 164.
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF
IN ERROR,
VS.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
IN ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT
OF MASSACHUSETTS.
a ‘ *
eof Nm Fo WW BW we Mm
Se
L. Ss.
1 UniTED STaTEs, ss:
The President of the United States to the judges of the circuit court
holden in and for the district of Massachusetts, greeting :
Because that in the record and process and also in the rende ‘ring of judgment
in a suit before you, or some of you, between Isaac Hayden, of Roxbury, in the
State of Massachusetts, plaintiff, and the Suffolk Manufacturing Company, a
corporation established in said State at Lowell, defendants, in a plea of trespass
on the case, a manifest error has intervened to the great damage of the said Suf-
folk Manufacturing Company, asin their complaint has been stated ; and as it is
just and proper that the error, if any there be, should be correeted in due
manner, and that full and speedy justice should be done to the parties aforesaid
in this behalf, vou are hereby commanded that, if judgment thereof be given,
then under your seal you do distinctly and openly send the record and process
in the suit aforesaid, with all things conecruing them, and this writ, so that
you have the same before the chief justice and the associate justices of the
Supreme Court of the United States, on the first Monday of December next, at
Washington, being the present seat of the national government, that the reeord
and process aforesaid being inspected, they may cause to be dene thereupon
what of right ought to be done.
Witness the honorable Roger B. Taney, esquire, Chief Justice of the said
Supreme Court, at Was shineton aforesaid, this fourteenth day of January, in the
year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred sixty-three, and of the independ-
ence of the United States the cighty-seveath.
TL W. FULLER, Clerk.
Allowed by—
P. SPR AGUE,
Judve U.S., Alass. Dist.
T have ree’d from the clerk a copy of this writ which was left for me by the
sdverse party.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
Jan. 15, 1863.
2 Circruir Court U.S,
Massachusetts District,
And now here the judges of the cireuit court within named make return of
this writ, by annexing herete and sending herewith, as within commanded,
under the seal of the said circuit court, a true and attested copy of the record
and process in the suit within mentioned, and of all proceedings therein.
In testimony whereof, I, Henry W. Fuller, cler k of said cireuit
fu. $.] court. kave hereunto set my hand and the seal of the said court this
twenty-second day ef Februar;, 1863.
ll. W. FULLER, Clerk.
3 United States of America, circuit court of the United States
MASSACHUSETTS DISTRICT, es :
To Isaac Hayden, of Roxbury, in 1 said district, greeting :
You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear before the chicf
justice and associate justices ef the Supreme Court of the United States, on the
tirst Monday of December next, A. D. 1863, at Washington, the present seat
of the national government, then and there to answer to a writ of error, this day
sued out of the clerk’s s office of the said cireuit court of the United States, wherein
the Suffolk Manufacturing Company, a corporation established at Loweil, in the
[Rec. cixiv, D. T., 1863. ]—1
2 Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden.
State of Massachusetts, are plaintiffs in error, and you are defendant, to show
cause, if any there be, why the judgment in said writ of error mentioned
should not be corrected and speedy justice done to the parties in that behalf.
Witness the Hon. Roger B. Taney, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the
United States, this fourteenth day of January, A. D. eighteen hundred and
sixty-three.
P. SPRAGUE,
Judge of the U. 8. Mass. District.
A true copy. Attest :
JOIN S. KEYES,
UY. S. Marshal.
4 U.S. or America,
Mass. Dist., ss:
| Boston, January 24, 1863.
I hereby certify that I have cited the within-named Hayden to appear as
within commanded, by giving him in hand the original citation, of which the
Within is a true and attested copy.
J.S. KEYES,
U. S. Marshal.
i i i al cu al a $2 12
a, ie a ee ee ee
5 Cireuit court of the United States, October term, 1862.
District OF MASSACHUSETTS, ss:
Isaac HAYDEN ?
Us.
Tue SuFFOLK MANUFACTURING Company. §
Know all men by these presents, that the Suffolk Manufacturing Co., as
principal, and we, James W. Paige and Henry V. Ward, of Boston, as sureties,
are holden and firmly bound unto Isaac Hayden in the sum of five thousand
doliars, to be paid to the said Hayden, his heirs and assigns, to which payment,
well and truly to be made, the said Suffolk Manufacturing Company binds
itself and its successors jointly and severally with said sureties, their heirs,
executors, and administrators; and we, the said sureties, bind ourselves,
each of us, jointly and severally, and each of us, our heirs, executors, and
administrators.
In witness whereof, the said Suffolk Manufacturing Company has caused its
corporate seal to be hereunto affixed, and these presents to be signed by their
treasurer, Henry V. Ward, thereto duly authorized ; and the said Paige and
Ward have hereunto set their hands and seals this 14th day of January, A. D.
1863.
6 Whereas the Suffolk Manufacturing Co. have sued out a writ of
error, returnable to the Supreme Court of the United States, on the first,
Monday of December next, on a judgment rendered in the cireuit court of the
United States for the district of Massachusetts, wherein the said Suffolk Manu-
facturing Company are plaintifts, and .saac Hayden is defendant, now, thereiore,
the condition of this obligation is such that if the above-named Suffolk Manu-
facturing Company shall prosecute its said writ of error to ettect, and answer all
Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden. 3
damages and costs if it shall fail to make good the same, then this obligation
shall be null and void; otherwise, remain in full force and effect.
HENRY V. WARD, [sEAt ]
Treasurer Suffolk M’g Co.
J. W. PAIGE. [| SEAL. |
HENRY V. WARD. |SEAL.|
In presence of—
H. W. FuLver.
C.C. U.S., Mass. District, January 14, 1863.
Approved by the court. Attest:
: H. W. FULLER, Clerk.
7 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Massachusetts Destrict, ss:
f° At a circuit court of the United States for the first circuit, begun and holden
at Boston, within and for the district of Massachusetts, on Wednesday, the
fifteenth day of October, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred
and sixty-two. Before the honorable Nathan Clifford, associate justice, and
the honorable Peleg Sprague, district judge.
Isaac HayDEN, of Roxbury, in the district
of Massachusetts, manufacturer, plaintiff,
vs.
‘THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY,
a corporation established by law at Lowell,
in our district of Massachusetts, defendants.
In a plea of trespass in the case, for that the said Jsaac Hayden was the
original and first inventor of a certain new and useful “ improvement
8 in long trunks for cleaning cotton,’ which is fully described in the
letters patent hereafter mentioned, which improvement was not known or
used before his invention thereof, and was not at the time of his application for
ietters patent therefor in public use, or on sale with his consent or allowance ;
and said Hayden was a citizen of the United States, and being such first in-
ventor, did indue form of law make an applieation in writing to the Commissioner
of Patents of the United States, for letters patent for his said invention, and
duly signed in the presence of two witnesses, and sworn to and filed a specifica-
tion and description in due, sufficient, and legal form of his invention for that
purpose; and said Hayden filed all necessary drawings and models, and com-
plied with all the conditions, requisitions of the statutes of the United States
for such cases provided, and paid into the Patent Office a fee of thirty dollars ;
and said Hayden was by law entitled to and did in dae form of law receive
letters patent of the United States, dated December first, eighteen hundred and
tifty-seven, which letters patent were sealed with the seal of the Patent Office,
aud were signed by Jacob ‘Thompson, Secretary of the Interior, and counter-
signed by J. [Lolt, Commissioner of Patents, and were entitled of and for an
§ “improvement in long trunks for cleaning cotton,” and in and by said
letters patent there was granted and secured to the said Hayden, his
heirs, administrators, and assigns, for the term of fourteen years from the date
of said letters patent, the full and exclusive right and liberty of mmaking, con-
structing, using, and vending to others to be used the said improvement, a
description whereof was given in the words of the said Hayden, in a schedule
which was annexed to said letters patent, and was made a part of the same, as
by said letters patent and schedule here in court to be produced will more
fully appear. And the plaintiff says that the right so seeured to him by said
4 Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Tiayden.
letters patent was of great value, and that the letters patent were lawfully and
rightfully issued to him; yet the defendants, though well knowing the premises
aforesaid, but contriving and wrongfully intending to injure the said plaintiff in
that behalf, and deprive him of the great advantages and profits which he might
and otherwise would have obtained from said invention, did heretofore, to wit,
on the first day of January Jast, at said Lowell, and on divers terms up to the
date of this writ, wrongfully and without the license or consent of
10 the plaintiff, infringe upon and violate the exclusive right so as aforesaid
granted to the plaintiff by making, constructing, and using the aforesaid
improvement and invention of the plaintiff’s, contrary to the form of the statutes
in such cases provided, whereby the plaintiff has been greatly injured and
deprived of great profits and advantages which he might and otherwise would
have derived from said invention, and has sustained actual damages to the
amount of twenty thousand dollars, whereby, and by force of the statutes in
such cases provided, an action hath aecrued to the plaintiff to have and recover
of the defendants the said actual damage and such additional amount, not ex-
ceeding in all three times the amount of such actual damages, as the court may
see fit to order and adjudge; yet the defendants, though requested, have not
paid the same, but refuses so to do; also, for that the said Isaac Hayden, a
citizen of the United States, was the first and original inventor and diseoverer
of a new and useful improvement in cotton-cleaners, as fully described and set
forth in the letters patent hereinaiter referred to, the same being a new and
11 useful improvement, and not known or used before his said invention
and discovery, and was not at the time of his application for said letters
patent therefor in public use or on sale, with his consent or allowance, and the
said Hayden so being the first and original inventor of said improvement in dué
form of law made an application in writing to the Commissioner of Patents for
the United States for letters patent for said improvement, and paid into the
treasury of the United States the sum of thirty dollars as a patent fee, and in
due form of law produced drawings, models, and specifications, deseribing his
aforesaid invention, and in all other respects the said Hayden complied with the
statutes of the United States in that behalf, and was legally entitled to receive
letters patent for the improvement and invention aforesaid; and thereupon such
proceedings were had, that on the eleventh day of September, in the year of
our Lord eighteen hundred and sixty, letters patent of and for the United
States of America, signed by Jacob ''hompson, Secretary of the ‘Interior, and
countersigned by Philip F. Thomas, Commissioner of Patents, and sealed with
the seal of the Patent Office of the United States, were in due form of
12 Jaw issued to said Hayden, wherein and whereby the exclusive right of
making, using, and vending to others to be used, the aforesaid invention
and improvement in cotton-cleaners was granted and secured to him, the said
Hayden, his heirs, administrators, and assigns, for the term of fourteen years,
next after the date of said letters patent, as by said letters patent here in court
to be produced will more fully appear.
And the plaintiff further saith that said invention and improvement so secured
to him is of great value, to wit, of the value of one hundred thousand dollars,
but that the defendants, wrongfully contriving and intending to injure the
plaintiff, heretofore, to wit, on the first day of November, eighteen hundred and
sixty, and at divers times before and sinee that day, have infringed upon the
rights so secured to the plaintiff, and have used and are still using the improve-
ment in cotton-cleaners described in said letters patent, and have made and used
machines and machinery for cotton-cleaning, the same as therein deseribed and
claimed in said letters patent, and without any right or license, whereby they
have deprived the plaintiff of the benefit and advantage of the said inven-
tion, and have prevented him from receiving the profits. which he rightfully
might and otherwise would have received in the premises, in violation of the
a oe! age et Ap wad
Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden. 5
13 statutes of the United States in that behalf. And the plaintiff alleges that
he has suffered actual damages to the sum of twenty thousand dollars,
by means of which premises, and by force of the statutes aforesaid, an action
has accrued to the plaintiff to have and recover of the said defendants the said
actual damages, and such additional amount, not exceeding in the whole three
times the amount of said actual damages, as the court may see fit to order and
adjudge; to the damage of the said plaintiff, as he says, the sum of twenty
thousand dollars.
This action was entered at the May term of this court, A. D. eighteen hun-
dred and sixty-one, when the plaintiff appear by William Whiting, his attorney,
and said defendants by Messrs. Brown & Maynadier, their attorneys; and at
the same term, (to wit, September 14, 1861,) the following pleas and notice of
defence are filed, namely:
And the said Suffolk Manufacturing Company, by its attorneys, comes and
defends the wrong and injury, when, &c., and says that it is not guilty of the
premises above laid to its charge in manner and form as the said Hayden hath
above complained. |
14 And of this said company puts itself upon the country.
BROWNE & MAYNADIER,
Defendants’ Attorneys.
And the plaintiff doth the like.
By WILLIAM WHITING,
Attorney for Plaintiff.
The said Suffolk Manufacturing Company gives notice that upon the trial, in
addition to all defences admissible under the plea of the general issue, it will
give in evidence special matter tending to prove—
I. That the said Hayden was not the first inventor or discoverer of the
things patented to him in the several letters patent declared on, or of a sub-
stantial and material part thereof claimed as new, but that the same was known
to and used by the following named corporations and individuals at the follow-
ing named places before the invention, if any, thereof, by the said Hayden;
that is to say, known to the Suffolk Manufacturing Company, a corporation
established by law of Massachusetts, and doing business at Lowell, in said
State, and used by said company at its mills in said Lowell, John Wright, of
said Lowell, being then its agent. Known to and used by William
15 Pctter, of and at said Lowell. Known to and used by John Wright, of
and at said Lowell.
Known to the Chicopee Manufacturing Company, a corporation established
by law of Massachusetts, and doing business at Chicopee Falls, in the town of
Chicopee, in said State, and used by said company at its mills in said Chicopee
Falls, Ezekiel Blake, of said Chicopee Falls, being then its agent.
Known to and used by Ezekiel Blake, of and at Chicopee Falls, Massachu-
setts.
Known to the Amoskeag Manufacturing Company, a corporation established
by law of New Hampshire, and doing business at Manchester, in said State, and
used by said company at its mills in said Manchester, David Gilliss, of Nashua,
N. H., being then its agent. |
Known to and used by David Giliiss, of said Nashua, at Manchester, New
Hampshire.
Known to the Salmon Falls Manufacturing Company, a corporation estab-
lished by law of New Hampshire, and doing business at Salmon Falls, in said
State, and used by said company at its mills in said Salmon Falls, Pliny Law-
son, of Cleveland, Ohio, being then its agent.
Known to the Agawam Canal Company, a corporation established by
16 law of Massachusetts, and doing business at Mittineague, West Spring-
6 Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden.
field, in said State, and used by said company at its mills at said Mittineague,
Wills Southworth, of New Haven, Connecticut, being then its agent.
Known to and used by Gilman Jacquith, of Nashua, New Hampshire, at
Manchester, New Hampshire, at Salmon Falls, New Hampshire, and at Mit-
tineague, West Springfield, Massachusetts.
Known to and used by William Melcher, of and at said Mittineague.
II. That the things patented to the said Hayden in the several letters patent
declared on were in public use with his, the said Haydon’s, consent and allow-
ance more than two years before his applications for patent therefor, respectively.
III. That the inventions patcnted in said several letters patent declared on
were respectively, before the obtaining of said patents, abandoned to the public,
and that said patents are void.
BROWN & MAYNADIER,
Defendants’ Attorneys,
The case is thence continued fom term to term to this present term, when the
honorable Peleg Sprague, district judge, presiding, the said parties, re-
17 spectively appear, by their said attorneys, and by additional counsel, and
by leave of court the plaintiff withdraws from the case the second count
in his aforesaid declaration, (on the patent of 1860;) and issue having been
joined as aforesaid on the first count in the said declaration, the cause, after a
full hearing, is committed to a jury, sworn according to law, to try the same,
who, after hearing all matters and things concerning the same, return their ver-
dict, and upon oath say :
The jury find that the defendants are guilty in manner and form as the plain-
tiff has alleged against them in his writ, and assess damages for the plaintiff in
the sum of seventeen hundred and seventy-four dollars.
DUNCAN BRADFORD, Foreman.
It is thereupon considered by the court (to wit, January 7, 1863) that said
Isaac Hayden recover of said Suffolk Manufacturing Company the said sum of
seventeen hundred and seventy-four dollars damages and his costs of suit taxed
at .
Upon the trial of the above-entitled case, after the evidence was closed on
both sides, and before the issue was submitted to the jury, the defendants
18 filed their bill of exceptions, which being found to be conformable to the
truth, was signed and allowed by the court, under the hand and seal of
the presiding judge, and is in the words and figures following, namely :
Defendants’ exceptions.
U.S. circuit court, Massachusetts district, October term, 1862.
The plaintiff, to sustain the action upon the first count in his declaration,
introduced letters patent, bearing date December 1st, 1857, a copy of which is
hereto annexed, and marked Exhibit.B, and to sustain the action upon the second
count he introduced letters patent bearing, date September 11th, 1860, a copy
of which is hereto annexed and marked Exhibit C, and also introduced evidence
tending to show an infringement of both.
The defendants in the opening of their defence introduced a certified copy of
letters patent issued to the plaintiff, and bearing date March seventecuth, one
thousand eight hundred and fifty-seven, a copy of which is hereto annexed and
marked exhibit A. It was agreed by the parties that these several letters patent
were applied for in the following order :
19 Patent C, applied for Dee’r 11th, 1854.
Patent A, “ “ Nov. Ist, 1855. a
Patent b, “ “« June 15th, 1857,
Suffolk Munufacturing Company vs. Ha den. 7
Evidence was introduced on both sides tending to show that prior to the
alleged invention or inventions of the plaintiff, cotton had been cleaned by
blowing it from an opening machine through long trenks of various lengths,
from twenty to one hundred feet long, prov ided with a sereen or grating, some-
times consisting of wooden bars, and sometimes of a plate of metal perfor: ated
with holes halt’ an inch wide and two inches long ; that some portion of the dirt
and waste fibres, as well as some of the good fibres, of cotton fell through the
openings in such screens or gratings, and descended into compartments ‘below
the screen, ne by cross partitions placed at varying distances, from three to
five tect Apart; but the plaintiff claimed and offered evidence tending to show
that the improvement which he claimed effected the separation and retention of
foreign substances and waste fibre more completely and successfully than the
old trunks, and produced new results that had not been before produced, and thus
produced the benefits and advantages set forth in his several specifica-
20 tions by ineans of the several improvements therein claimed.
And thereupon the defendants requested thre court to rule upon the
several letters patent A, B, and C, as follows
First. That the patent of December Ist, 1857, (B,) covers an elongated trunk,
having partitions covered by a woven wire screen whose crossings are filled with
metal, cement, or shetlae varnish, or any other varnish that will answer the pur-
pose; such trunk to be used for the purpose of cleaning cotton im connexion
with any opening and beating machine which can be made to produce either a
blast or suction, with or w shout the aid of a fan, to assist in passing the cotton
through the trunk over the sereen.
Second. That the patent B is inoperative and void, because the thing therein
described and claimed was fully describe d but not claimed in patent A, and was,
therefore, by the legal operation of patent A, surrendered to public use, if it
was the invention of the plaintitf before patent B was issued or applied for.
Third. Vhat patent B is inoperative and void, because it describes and claims
What is also embraced by the claim of patent C. |
21 And the — iudge, in accordance with the first prayer of the
detendanis’ counsel, did rule upon the construction of the said patent B
as follows, namely : That the patent of [iecember Ist, 1857, (B,) eovers an
elongated trunk, having partitions covered by a woven wire screen, whose cross
ings are filled with me tal, cement, or shellac varnish, or any other varnish that
will answer the purpose; such trunk to be used for the purpose of cleaning cot-
ton in connexion with auy opening and beating machine which can be made to
preduce cither a blast or suetion, with or without the aid of a fan, to, assist in
passing the cotton through the trunk over the screen. But the presiding judge
refused to rule the patent B to be inoperative and void, by reason of the legal
effect of the patent A.
And the presiding judge turther ruled that the patent of September 11th, 1860,
(C,) embraces what was already covered by the patent of December Ist, 1857,
(,) but refused to rule that patent Bois inoperative and void by reason of the
leval etiect of patent C. And there upon the said patent C, after the evidence
On both shies Was -_ sed, and | le fe re t! recuse Went to the 1 jury, was with-
22 drawn frem the case by the plaintiti’s counsel, and the jury found a ver-
dict for the plaintiff upon the patent of December Ist, 1857, (B.) To
which rulings, so far as the court held the patent of December Ist, 1S 57, to be
operative and valid, and to the refusal to hold the same inoperative and void, as
praye ‘d tor by the defendants, the defendants, betore the cause is submitted to
the jury, respectfully except, and pray that their exeeptions may be allowed
ad made part of the re cord the veot.
To show the damages stistaincd: by the plaintiff by the wrongful use of his
invention, the praintel atid as witness one Tlenry ‘K. Oliver, an e xperie need
manufacturer, Who testified that he was well aequ: minted with the plaintifi’s im-
Pee! eT
8 Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden.
provement, and its uses and advantages, as compared with the former methods
of cleaning cotton. And the plaintifi’s counsel not having previously shown
that the plaitiff confined the use of his improvement to his own business in
manufacturing cotton, but stating, in answer to a question from the court, that
the plaintifi had not a fixed or established price as a license fee for permitting
the use of his improvement by others, and had not made any sales at any
23 fixed or agreed price, and admitting that he had granted the right to use
the improvement in a limited manner, and for a specified purpose, expe-
rimentally, in one of the mills of which the witness Oliver was superintendent,
propounded to the witness the following interrogatory :
“State the practical benefits, if any, of using Hayden’s improvements in ecotton-
cleaning, as described in his patents, over and above the old machinery for
cleaning cotton.”
To this question the defendants’ counsel objected, and assigned the following
as grounds of objection: LTirst, that the plaintiff not having shown hew he ex-
ercises his rights under the monopoly of his patent, this question is not now
competent to be put. Second, that the evidence sought by this question of the
advantages, savings, or profits, resulting in the manufacture of cotton from the
use of the plaintifl’s improvement, as furnishing data from which the jury are
to infer the actual damage sustained by the plaintiff, would be admissible onky
when the plaintiff had previously shown that he confined the use of the pre-
tended imprevement in the manufacture of cotton to his own business.
24 But the presiding judge overruled the objections, and allowed the
question to be put, and thereupon the witness testilied that the general
results of using the plaintiff's improved trunk, as compared with the old ma-
chinery for cleaning cotton, were, in his experienee, more thorough eleaning of
the cotton; the saving of all the good fibres of the cotton, useful in manntacture ;
less damage to the staple in the act of cleaning; the frecing of the room from
dust; the freeing of the macliincry from dust, dirt, and sand; the keepiug of the
machinery in better order, and at less cost, and the dispensing with one griuder
of the cards in consequence of the diminution ef the amount of sand and dirt
passed to the cards with the cotton, getting out fine dust and dirt that had
never before been get out; that the yarns were made less liable to breakage,
and that the operatives consequently lad Jess annoyance in the manufacture;
and an improvement in the quality of the cleth produced by reason of the less
liability to breakage of she yarns, and knots to reconnect them. Also, that
cotton could be purchased at one or ove and a half cents per pound less,
25 and be cleaned in the pliintiii’s trunk, so as to produce goods as valuable
in the market as goods manutfreturea from cotton of the higher cost
cleaned by the old machinery. |
To which ruling the defendants excepted, and prayed that their exceptions
might be allowed and made part of the record.
And thereupon, and in further proof of the damages sustained by the plaintiff,
the plaintiff offered further evidenee tending to show the same advantages re-
sulting from the use of his improved trunk as had been testified to by the said
Oliver, and for the purpose of showing the extent to which the plaintiff's im-
provemeut had been used by the defeudauts, proved the amount of cotton that
had been cleaned at the defendants’ mills during the time covered by his writ,
iu the four truuks used by them, and complained of as infringements of his
patent.
To which evidence the defendants cbjected, but the presiding judge overruled
the objection, and admitted the evidence to go to the jury on the question of
damages.
To which ruling, and to the admission of said evidence, the defendants,
26 before the case is submitted to the Jury, respectfully except, and pray that
their exceptions may be allowed aud made part of the record thereof.
Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden. 9
And thereupon the defendants, in answer to the claim for damages founded
on the foregoing evidence, introduced testimony tending to show what compen-
sation the plaintiff had received from two manufacturing companies, (of one of
which the said witness Oliver was the agent,) for permission to use his patented
improvement. ‘The evidence was that the plaintiff, for the purpose of experi-
ment, allowed Oliver to test the applicability of his improvement to cleaning of
cotton for fine goods, and its results upon the general process of manufacturing
therein, Oliver being at liberty to give it up after trying the experiment, without
compensation, or retain the use of it in one mill only, if he and Mr. Hayden
could agree upon the terms, the price, if fixed, not to be deemed as the price for
any other mills. A similar arrangement was made with the agent of the other
company, a part of the consideration of the agreements being that the improve-
ment would be thus introduced into public notice, Mr. Hayden having the
27 right to bring other persons to those factories to exhibit the operation of
his invention.
After using the improvement for some time both companies wished to retain
it, and Mr. Hayden said that under the peculiar circumstances of these cases
he would allow the two agents to say what they would pay; and they, in con-
sultation with Mr. Thacher, who was either a referee or a party consulted, fixed
upon a price, which they paid to him; but Mr. Hayden was dissatisfied with
the amount, and requested them to keep it secret, as he was not willing to have
other parties use his improvement at the same rate.
The defendants also showed that the plaintiff had permitted the use of his
machine by a third manufacturer, with the statement that there would be no
difficulty in agreeing upon the compensation if this manufacturer found it sue-
cessful and wished to continue its use. There was a dittieulty, however, which
ended in a lawsuit that was subsequently compromised between the parties, but
what that compromise was did not appear at the trial. ‘hereupon, and
28 upon all the other evidence in the case, the defendants’ counsel prayed
the court to instruct the jury on the subject of damages:as follows:
First. That if the jury are satisfied, from the evidence in the case, that the
plaintiff had at the date of the writ any fixed or average price for a license to
use his pretended improvements, that fixed or average price is the measure of
damages to be applied to this case.
Second. That if the jury cannot find a fixed or average price, they are to
give as damages, not the profits made by the defendants from the use of the
machine, or any percentage on those profits, but only the loss which the plain
tiff has sustained in being deprived of an opportunity of agreeing with the de-
fendants on a voluntary sale; and in estimating that loss, the jury are to judge
of its amount by the dealings of the plaintiff with other manufacturers to whom
he has granted the right to use his patented improvements.
But the presiding judge refused to give the instructions prayed for, and in-
structed the jury as follows: The general rule is that you should give to
29 the plaintiff the actual damage he has sustained by his invention having
been used by the defendants. You will look at the length of time, in
the first place, that the defendants have used the trunks. Here it is material
to bear in mind that your verdict covers only the use from June, 1858, up to
the date of the writ in April, 1861. If the defendants have used the machine
since that time; they are liable (over and above what you will give in your ver-
dict) to pay the plaintiff tor such use sinee. Your verdict will cover no use
except up to the date of the writ. That is all which is sued for. For all sinee
that time the defendants are Kable in another suit by the plaintiff. You are
also to remember that if you render a verdict for the plaintitf, it will not give to
the defendants any right to use any of these trunks hereafter. It is not like a
license to use a trunk during the existence of the patent; so far from conferring
Rec. cux1v, D. T. 1863./—2
j
10 Suffolk Manufacturing Company vs. Hayden.
any right to use them hereafter, the plaintiff may apply to this court for an
injunction ; that is, for an order of court to prevent their using them. Such
will be his right if the patent be established. You to give the actual
30 damages which the plaintiff has sustained for the use of his patented
improvement from June, 1858, to the date of the writ. You have heard
from the counsel various means of ascertaining the damages. You are to take
the whole evidence, so far as it is applicable to that question, into view, and
form your judgment from the whole. There is some evidence derived from
General Oliver and Mr. Southworth, of the use by the Atlantic company in
Lawrence, and the company over which Mr. Southworth presided in Lowell, of
this machine of Mr. Hayden, by his consent, under particular circumstances, and
its being subsequently referred to them in connexion with Mr. Thacher, to de-
termine what compensation should be paid. I understand that this was a com-
pensation for the use of it as a license during the existence of the patent, and
not merely for the past time; and they fixed upon a certain compensation, which
“was named to you by General Oliver. That was not satisfactory to Mr. Hay-
den, and is not to be taken as price which he fixes, or an agreement that it was
a fair compensation for a license, even under the circumstances under
31 which they began to use it. But as that is evidence in the case, you will
take it into view, and give it such weight as it deserves, in ascertaining
the actual amount of the damage sustained by the plaintiff; then you will look
at the value of the thing used, and ascertain that value by all the evidence, as
to its character, operation, and effects. You will take into view the value of
that which the defendants have used, belonging to the plaintiff, to aid you in
forming a judgment of the actual damage the plaintiff has sustained.
To which refusal and instructions the defendants, before the cause is sub-
mitted to the jury, respectfully except, and pray that their exceptions may be
allowed and made part of the record thereof.
And the foregoing exceptions being severally found conformable to the truth
are hereby allowed, under my hand and seal.
P. SPRAGUE, [skat.|
Judge of the United States, Massachusetts District.
A true record. Attest:
H.W. FULLER, Céeri:.
UniTeD STATES oF AMERICA,
Massachusetts District, ss:
I, Henry W. Fuller, clerk of the cireuit court of the United States for the
first circuit, Massachusetts district, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true
copy of the record and of all proceedings in the cause of Isaac Hayden vs. The
Suffolk Manufacturing Company, in this court determined.
In testimony whereof, I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed the
seal of said court, at Boston, in said district, this twenty-third day of
February, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
sixty-three, and of the independece of the United States the eighty-
seventh.
_[SEAL.|
H. W. FULLER, Clerk.
Filed 4th Dee’r, 1865.
es”
aes |
ee ef eG + ert REO:
* SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
i Pot: ZA
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF IN
ERROR,
Vs.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
ADDITION TO RECORD.
SeVERERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE,
— &
— eran,
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
No. 16833. ]
| The United States of America to all to whom these letters patent
shall come: Whereas Isaac Hayden, of Lawrence, Mass., has alleged
that he has invented a new and useful improvement in machinery for clean-
ing and separating cotton, wool, fur, and other fibrous materials, which he
states has not been known or used before bis application; has made oath
that he is a citizen of the United States, that he does verily believe that he
is the original and first inventor or discoverer of the said improvement, and
that the same hath not, to the best of his knowledge and _ belief, been pre-
viously known or used; has paid into the treasury of the United States the
sum of thirty dollars, and presented a petition to the Commissioner of Pat-
ents signifying a desire of obtaining an exclusive property in the said im-
provement, and praying that a patent may be granted for that purpose:
these are therefore to grant, according to law, to the said Isaac Hayden, his
heirs, administrators, or assigns, for the term of fourteen years from the
seventeenth day of March, one thousand eight hundred and fifty-seven, the
full and exclusive right ‘and liberty of making, constructing, using, and
vending to others to be used the said improv ement, a description whereof is
given in the words of the said Hayden in the schedule hereunto annexed,
and is made part of these presents.
In testimony whereof, I have caused these letters to be made patent, and
the seal of the Patent Office has been hereunto affixed.
Given under my hand at the city of Washington, this seventeenth day of
March, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-seven,
and of the independence of the United States of ‘America the eighty-first.
[ SEAL. ] JACOB THOMPSON,
Secretary of the Interior.
Countersigned and sealed with the seal of the Patent Office.
C. MASON, Commissioner of Patents.
2 The schedule referred to in these letters patent, and making part of the
same.
To all whom it may concern: Be it known that I, Isaac Hayden, of Law-
rence, in the county of Essex and State of Massachusetts, have invented a
new and useful apparatus to be applied to machines for cleaning and sepa-
rating wool, cotton, fur, and other fibrous substances, and I do hereby de
clare that the same is described and represented in the following specifica-
tions and drawings.
To enable others skilled in the art to make and use my invention, I will
proceed to describe its construction, use and operation, referring to the
drawings, in which the same letters indicate like parts in each of the figures.
Fig. 1 is a plan of my invention, with one half of the top removed to
show the screen.
Fig. 2 is a sectional elevation, representing Fig. 1 cut though the line
The design and object of my appiratus, when applied to machines for
cleaning cotton and other fibrous substances, is to make the machine clean
the cotton more perfectly, by blowing or drawing it, when separated, into
very small flakes, or loose, open locks, through a long trunk provided with
numerous cross-partitions on its bottom. These partitions, and the spaces
between them, being covered with a wove wire screen or net, with open
meshes, large enough to allow the blast of air blown through.the trunk to
circulate freely through them, but so small that only the short fibres of cotton
will be blown through, while the dirt, dust, sand, and other refuse matter
(Rec. cixiv, D. T. 1864.]—1
2 Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
mixed with the cotton, which are heavier than the cotton, will fall through
the meshes in the wove wire screen, and remain between the parti-
3 tions until they are removed, while the cotton is blown through the
trunk, over the screen. After precipitating all extraneous matter
which was mixed with it through the screen, it passes out of the trunk into
the receptacle or devices prepared to receive it, being far better cleaned
than it has ever been done before by any machine heretofore known.
The area of the trunk above the screen may be increased by making it
larger towards its rear, and by gradually increasing its height or width, or
both, so that the blast of air which conveys the materials through the
trunk will move gradually slower, so as to allow the light and fine, or such
portions of the materials as are intended to be separated, time to be pre-
cipitated and fall through the screen before the current of air which holds
them in suspension escapes from or passes out of the trunk Some portion
of the trunk may be covered with shect metal or other baths, supplied with
cold water,so as to cool the upper stratum of air, to make it heavier, and
induce it to descend into the lower part of the trunk, betweea the partitions,
where there will be less motion than above the screen, so as to precipitate
vr allow the substances held in suspension time to fall and deposit them-
selves in the spaces under the screen.
The partitions in the trunk may be made wider, so as to make the spaces
between them gradually deeper towards the rear end of the trunk, so that
there will be less motion under the screen at that end, so as to allow the
finer or finest portions of the materials held in suspension time to precipi-
tate and deposit themselves.
In order to prevent the fibres of cotton or other substances blown through
the trunk from catching and hanging in the scores in the wove-wire screen
formed by the weft in crossing the warp, or at the junction of the
4 warp and weft, I fill these scores with melted metal, varnish, or some
kind of cement, so as to allow the fibres of the substance cleaned or
operated upon to pass freely over the screen, and save them from being
caught in the scores, as they would most certainly be if the scores were
not filled with some material to prevent them.
In the above-mentioned drawings aa are the sides of a long trunk con-
nected together by a series of cross partitions, c c, about one half the
width of the sides, placed about six inches apart, with their lower edges
even with the lower edges of the sides, as represented in Fig. 2.
There is a rebate a!, a, on the inside of both edges of the sides, a a, to
which the top and bottom of the trunk is fitted. The bottom pieces, f f,
are made just wide enough to fill the spaces between the partitions, c c, as
represented in Fig. 2, and are secured in their places by the buttons, g g,
fastened to the sides, a a.
The top, h h, may be made in sections, and fitted to the rebates, a! a}, and
fastened down by the buttons, a? a?, which are fastened to the sides, as
represented. The wove wire screen, b b, is made of wire about number
twenty-two, woven sv that the centre of the wires are about one eighth of ap
inch apart in each direction; and to prevent the fibres of cotton or other sub-
stances from catching and hanging in the scores in the wove wire formed by
the weft crossing the warp, or at the junction of the warp and weft, I fill them
with melted metal by dipping the wove wire into melted metal, either tin or a
composition of tin and lead, or instead of dipping the wove wire into molten
metal, it may be covered with a varnish made by dissolving gum shellac in
alcohol, and applying it with a brush upon one or both sides; if only one
side, the top should be varnished, and the wire placed in ‘a horizontal
5 position when it is varnished, and allowed to remain in that position
until it is dry. It should be brushed crosswise in applying the first
~~
— —— Ty ——
.
yz-- —_
eee em
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs Hayden. 3
coat of varnish, and when that is dry the second coat should be applied by
brushing it lengthwise, so as to fill the scores in each direction. Instead of
the varnish or melted metal mentioned, any other kind of varnish or cement
which will answer the purpose may be used to fill the scores; or, instead of
the wove wire, a screen made of twine might be prepared with varnish so as
to answer the purpose, if for any cause it should be preferred. This screen
of wove wire is fastened to the tops of the partitions, c c, so as to entirely
cover the space between the sides, a a; and some smooth cleats, k k, should
be fastened to the sides, over the screen, to fill the corners formed by the
screen and the sides, a a, so as to prevent the fibres from catching and hang-
ing in the corners.
If it is found necessary or desirable, some deflecting cleats, e e, may be
' fastened on the top of the oemen and on the under side of the top of the
trunk, as represented at Fig. 2, to deflect the blast as it passes through the
trunk. The rear end or part if the trunk is made wider and higher, as rep-
resented in the drawings, sc as to increase its area and reduce the blast
by alluwing it to expand, so that it will move slower, and allow the light
and fine, or such portions of the materials as are intended to be separated,
time to be precipitated and pass through the screen before the air
6 which holds them in suspension passes s out of the trunk. The parti-
tions, c c, are made wider towards the rear end of the trunk, so as to
make the spaces between them deeper, so that there will be less motion to
the air under the screen, where they are deeper, to allow the substances in
| suspensiun time to precipitate and deposit themselves between the parti-
tions.
The curved form of the wire in the screen presents a very different sur-
face to the flowing current of air from that presented by perforated sheet
metal; besides, there is fur more open space in a given area than if perfo-
rated metal or other substances were used, affording greater facility for the
sand, dirt, or other substances intended to be separated, to pass through
the screen.
In cleaning cotton, the fibre which is long enough to reach across more
than two spaces or meshes in the screen is carried forward over it, but that
which is shorter than two meshes is carried through the screen and deposited
in the spaces between the partitions. This apparatus separates the dust from
the cotton so perfectly and completely, that there is far less dust evolved from
it (the cotton) in passing it through the subsequent processes of manufacture.
Besides, the goods manufactured from cotton cleaned in this apparatus pre-
sent an appearance so much superior to others as to increase their market
value from five to eight per cent., and at the same time the cotton is worked
with far less loss in waste than heretofore; so that it enables the manufac-
turer tou make goods of a given quality out of a far cheaper and inferior
quality of raw material than he could do without it. And in addition
7 to the advantages already enumerated, the cards working cotton
cleaned in this apparatus will not require. more than two thirds as
much grinding as others; so that one third of the labur and expense of grind-
ing the cards is saved and one third or more of the wear and tear of the
card clothing also.
I contemplate that this apparatus may be used in working wool, and in
separating the hair from the fur fur making hats, by graduating the blast so
as tu allow the hair to fall through the screen while the fine fur would be
carried over it. And it is believed it can also be used to great advantage
in machines for cleaning and dressing feathers, hair, and other fibrous sub-
stances.
In using this apparatus, it is intended to apply it to such machines
fur beating, picking, scutching, and opening cotton, wool, fur, and other
RF TY a
.
y-- a
4 Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
fibrous substances, as can be made to produce either a blast or suction, with
or without the aid of a fan to assist in passing the substances to be operated
upon through the machine or apparatus. The wire used for making the
screen and the meshes formed in it, may be made of such dimensions as will
adapt it to the purposes for which it is intended to be used. And the trunk
may be made air tight or as nearly so as may be necessary for the purpose
for which it is intended to be used.
I believe my invention may be advantageously used in the manufacture of
lamp black, zinc white, and in collecting the products of sublimation of some
other substances.
1 believe I have described the construction, operation, and use of
8 the apparatus which I have invented, so as to enable any person
skilled in the art to make and use the same; also some of the several
uses to which it may be applied.
I will now specify what I desire to secure by letters patent:
Ist. I claim increasing the area of the trunk above the screen or making
it larger towards its rear end by increasing its height, or width, or both, as
may be desirable, so that the blast of air which conveys the materials into
or through the trunk.will move gradually slower, so as to allow the light
and fine, or such portions as are intended to be separated, time to be precip- |
itated and pass through the screen before the air which holds them in sus-
pension escapes from or passes out of the trunk.
2nd. And, in combination with a trunk made gradually larger towards its
rear end, as above claimed, I claim a screen of woven wire or twine, arranged
upon a series of partitions substantially as described for the purposes set.
forth.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
Witnesses:
Joun S. HouuinGsHEAD.
Samw’L GRUBB.
J. Dennis, Jr. ,
{Here follows diagram, marked “ Exhibit A.”]
No. 18742.]
9 The United States of America to all to whom these letters patent
shall come : |
Whereas Isaac Hayden, of Lawrence, Mass., has alleged that he has in-
vented a new and useful improvement in long trunks for cleaning cotton,
which-he states has not been known or used before his application; has made
oath that he is a citizen of the United States, that he does verily believe that
he is the original and first inventor or discoverer of the said improvement,
and that the same hath not, to the best of his knowledge and belief, been
previously known or used; has paid into the treasury of the United States
the sum of thirty dollars, and presented a petition to the Commissioner of
Patents signifying a desire of obtaining an exclusive property in the said
improvement, and praying that a patent may be granted for that purpose:
These are therefore to grant, according to law, to the said Isaac Hayden,
his heirs, administrators, or assigns, for the term of fourteen years from the
first day of December, one thousand eight hundred and fifty-seven, the full
and exclusive right and liberty of making, constructing, using, and vending
to others to be used, the said improvement, a description whereof is given
in the words of the said Isaac Hayden in the schedule hereunto annexed,
and is made part of these presents.
In testimony whereof, | have caused these letters to be made patent, and
the seal of the Patent Oflice has been hereuuto affixed.
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden. 5
Given under my hand at the city of Washington, this first day of Decem-
fh. s.] ber, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-
nile seven, and of the independence of the United States of America the
eighty-second.
JACOB THOMPSON,
Secretary of the Intervor.
Countersigned and sealed with the seal of the Patent Office.
J. HOLT,
Commissioner of Patents.
10 The schedule referred to in these letters patent and making part of
the same.
To all whom it may concern: Be it known that I, Isaac Hayden, of Law-
rence, in the county of Essex, and State of Massachusetts, have invented a
new and useful improvement in elongated trunks for cleaning cotton, and
other fibrous substances, and for separating hair from fur, and I do hereby
declare that the same is described and represented in the following speciti-
cation and drawings.
To enable others skilled in the art to make and use my improvement, I
will proceed to describe its construction and use, referring to the drawings,
in which the same letters indicate like parts in each of the figures.
Fig. 1 isa plan of an elongated trunk with my improvements, the top casing
being omitted.
Fig. 2 is a sectional elevation of the same through the line A B of Fig. l,
the top casing being supplied or as shown.
The nature of my invention and improvement in elongated trunks for clean-
ing cotton, and other purposes, consists in covering “the bottom, or parti-
tions on the bottom, with a woven screen, which has the scores formed by
the warp crossing the weft, or at the junction of the warp and weft, filled
with metal, or some kind of cement, so as to prevent the fibres of cotton, or
other materials, being passed over the screen, from catching and hanging in
said scores.
In the accompanying drawings the sides of a trunk are shown at a a, con-
nected together by cruss partitions cc, about one half the height
1] of the sides s; between the lower edges of these partitions there
are dvors f f, which form the bottom of the trunk, and are held in
their places by the buttons g g, so that they may be easily taken out to re-
move the waste and refuse matter that collects upon them. The top uf the
trunk is also covered with doors h h, fastened by the buttons 11, as shown
in the drawing, j) j rebates in the tops of the sides for the ends of the
doors h h.
The woven screen b b, i®fastened over or on the top edges of the parti-
tions cc, by means of cleats e! e!, fastened to the sides a a, or otherwise.
This woven sereen b may be made of wire or twine; but the best screens
for cleaning cutton, so far as I have tried them, are made of wire, about
number tweuaty-two, woven square, about one eighth of an inch from cen-
tre to centre of the wires, or eight wires to the inch each way. To prevent
the fibres of cotton, or other material blown over the screen, from catching
and hanging in the scores between the wires formed by the warp crossing
the weft, or at the junction of the warp and weft, I fill said scores with
melted metal by dipping the woven wire into it; the metal used may be tin,
or a composition of tin and lead. This woven screen may have the scores in
it filled with varnish, made by dissolving gum shellac in alcohol, and apply-
ing it with a brush upon one or both sides; if only one side it should be
the top.
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
_ The screen being placed in a horizontal position when it is varnished, and
allowed to remain in that position until it is dry. It should be brushed
crosswise in applying the first coat of varnish, and Jengthwise in the second;
so as to fill all the scores in each direction with varnish. Instead
12 of the varnish mentioned, some other kind of varnish or cement
which will answer the purpose may be used.
The partitions c c may be placed about six inches apart, and if necessary
or desirable, some deflecting cleats e e may be fastened on the screen over
each alternate partition; and there may also be some deflecting cleats fastened
to the under side of the top, midway between the deflecting cleats on the
screen, so as to give the blast blown through the trunk a serpentine or un-
dulating motion.
A trunk with my improvements may be applied to such machines fur beat-
ing, picking, scutching, and opening cotton, wool, fur, and other fibrous sub-
stances as can be made to produce either a blast or suction, with or without
the aid of a fan, to assist in passing the substances operated on through the
trunk over the screen. When cotton or other fibrous substances are blown
over the screen the fibres which are too short to reach across two meshes in
the screen pass through it and remain in the space d d, between the parti-
tions cc, while the longer fibre is blown over it, and passes out of the
trunk.
As the cotton is blown through the trunk it is separated into small flakes.
Most of the sand, dirt, dust, pieces of leaves, and other refuse matter heavier
than the cotton, is precipitated from it, and passes through the screen, re-
maining in the spaces between the partitions, where there is comparatively
little motion to the air; and all the substances above mentioned deposit
themselves on the bottom of the trunk between the partitions, where
13 they remain until they are removed by taking out the bottom This
: screen separates the dust from the cotton so perfectly and completely
that there is far less dust evolved from it (the cotton) in passing through
the subsequent processes of its manufacture. Besides, the goods mauufactur-
ed from cotton cleaned in this apparatus present an appearance so much
superior to others, as to increase their market value from five to eight per
cent.; and at the same time the cotton is worked with far less loss in waste
than if it was manufactured without this apparatus. And further, it en-
ables the manufacturer to make goods of a given quality out of a far
cheaper and infe:ior quality of raw material than he could do without it.
And in addition to these advantages, the cards working cotton cleaned in
this apparatus will not require more than two thirds as much grinding as
others, so that one-third of the expense and labor of grinding the cards is
saved ; and also one-third or more of the wear and tear of the card clothing.
The wire or twine used in making the screen and the meshes formed in it
may be of such dimensions as will adapt it to ghe purposes for which it is
intended to be used. I contemplate that a trunk with my improvements
may be used to great advantage in separating hair frum fur, to make hats,
by graduating the blast so as to allow the hair to fall through the screen,
while the fine fur is carried over it ; and that it can also be used in machines
for cleaning and dressing feathers.
14 This apparatus not only separates the dirt, dust, and refuse matter
heavier than the cotton from the cotton, but it also separates the short
staple from the long. The short staple or fibres pass through the screen,
while the long staple or fibres are blown over it.
_ I believe I have described and represented the construction and use of the
improvement which I have invented, so as to enable any person skilled in
the art to make and use it; also, some of the uses to which it may be ap-
plied. I will now specify what I desire to secure by letters patent, to wit :
~--
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden. 7
I claim covering the partitions of an elongated trunk or box for cleaning
cotton and other fibrous substances with woven wire, having the scores
formed by the weft crossing the warp of said wire screen, filled with metal
or cement, the whole combined in the manner and for the purposes set forth
in the foregoing specification.
. ISAAC HAYDEN.
Witnesses : Gipzeon WILKINS.
Rosert Cross.
[Here follows diagram, marked Exhibit B.]
No. 29971.]
15 The United States of America to all whom these letters patent shall
come :
Whereas Isaac Hayden, of Lawrence, Massachusetts, has alledged that
he has invented a new and useful improvement in cotton cleaners, which he
states has not been known or used before his application ; has made oath
that he is a citizen of the United States, that he does verily believe that he
is the original and first inventor or discoverer of the said improvement, and
that the same hath not, to the best of his knowledge and belief, been previ-
ously known or used ; has paid into the treasury of the United States the
sum of thirty dollars, and presented a petition to the Commissioner of Pa-
tents, signifying a desire of obtaining an exclusive property iu the said im-
provment, and praying that a patent may be granted for that purpose:
These are therefore to grant, according to law, to the said Isaac Hayden,
his heirs, administrators, or assigns, for the term of fourteen years from the
eleventh day of September, one thousand eight hundred and sixty, the full
and exclusive right and liberty of making, constructing, using, and vending
to others to be used, the said improvement, a description whereof is given in
the words of the said Isaac Hayden, in the schedule hereunto annexed, and
is made part of these presents.
In testimony whereof, I have caused these letters to be made patent, and
the seal of the Patent Office has been hereunto affixed.
Given under my hand at the city of Washington, this eleventh day of
f | ] September, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
‘4 sixty, and of the independence of the United States of America the
eighty-fifth.
| JACOB THOMPSON,
Secretary of the Interior.
Countersigned and sealed with the seal of the Patent Office.
PHILIP F. THOMAS,
~ Commissioner of Patents.
16 The schedule referred to in these letters patent, and making part of the
same.
To all all whom it may concern :
Be it known that I, Isaac Hayden, of Lawrence, in the county of Essex,
and State of Massachusetts, have invented certain new and useful improve-
ments in apparatus or machinery for cleaning cotton and other fibrous sub-
stances, and I do hereby declare that the same is described and represented
in the following specifications and drawings.
In describing my improvements in machinery, or apparatus for cleaning
cotton and other substances, I propose first to state briefly what was used
previous to the date of my invention, to wit.
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
Machines have long been in use for cleaning and opening cotton, consist-
ing of an endless band, carried by two rotating cylinders, and arranged to
supply the cotton to a pair of fluted rollers, which rollers feed the cotton to
a beater, or scutcher made to turn with great volocity to open the cotton
and blow it into a trunk about three feet wide and one foot deep, and from.
twenty to sixty or one hundred feet in length ; which trunk was divided
near the middle horizontally by a grate of wooden bars placed crosswise ; |
which bars were about three quarters of an inch in diameter, with spaces be-
tween them about one fourth of an inch in width, the cotton being blown ‘
over this grating, as it is opened by the scutcher, by the blast of thescutcher;
and to check the blast under the grating there were partitions placed cross-
wise about four feet apart. This grating was found very defective, for the
following reasons, to wit: the spaces between the bars being about three
feet long and one fourth of an inch wide, the long staple of the cotton pass-
ed between the bars, with the short in locks of considerable size, so that
much good cotton passed through though the bars as waste ; and a
17 still greater defect was, the partitions under the bars of grating were
so far apart that the blast under the grating was so near, as strong
as it was above the grate, that nearly all the fine sand, and dirt, and dust,
and refuse matter that passed down through the grate was carried up
through it back again, and so carried forward out of the trunk with the cot-
ton ; and although the cotton was opened, and the fine sand, dust, dirt, and
refuse matter were released, so as to be readily separated from the cotton,
this grating of wooden bars failed to effect the separation, as the sand, dust,
dirt, and refuse matter did not remain in the trunk in any cunsiderable
quantity, but were carried out by the blast with the cotton.
As this grate of bars failed almost entirely to separate the sand, dirt, dust,
and refuse matter from the cotton, perforated metal plate was tried asa
substitute; that is, sheet zinc was perforated with holes about one half an
inch wide, and about two inches long, with partitions placed vertically
crosswise under the perforated zinc, about four feet apart. This proved no
better than the grate of wooden bars; besides, the area of the surface occu-
pied by the wooden bars and zinc plate was three times as large as the
perforations or openings in the grate, which was one cause of the failure of
these devices. Another cause was, the openings were too large; that is,
they were much longer than the length of the staple of cotton; and the
third cause of its failure was, the partitions were so far apart that they did
not arrest the current of air, or blast of air, under the grate or perforated
metal, so as to retain the sand, dirt, dust, and refuse matter that passed
down, so as to prevent it from being carried up back again and out of the
trunk with the cotton.
The object and design of my improvement is to remedy the defects above
mentioned and pointed out, by using, instead of the wooden bars or per-
forated metal plate, a reticulated screen of woven wire or twine with
meshes so small that the staple or fibre of cotton long enough to be of any
value in making yarn will reach across two of said meshes or open-
18 ings, and therefore remain above the screen, while that portion or
sume of that portion of the fibre which is too short tu reach across
two of the meshes or openings falls through the screen with the fine sand,
dirt, dust, and refuse matter heavier than the cotton. And to break the
blast or current of air under the screen so effectually that it will not carry
much of the fine sand, dirt, dust, and short fibre up back again through the
screen, so as to be carried out of the trunk with the cotton, I place the ver-
tical partitions across the trunk under the screen, so near together as to stop
or prevent any or sufficient blast or current under the screen to bring much
of the matter up back through the screen again, but retain what passes
i ORR NRE
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden. 9
through the screen, or most of it, in the small cells formed under the screen
by placing the partitions but a little distance apart.
Another very important advantage gained by the use of the wire
screen is that the wire occupies less than one fourth of the area of the
space covered by the screen; therefore it leaves more than three fourths of
the area in open meshes or spaces between the wires, sv that the dirt, dust,
and refuse matter has three times as much area or open space in the screen
of woven wire to fall through and be separated from the cotton as it had
when blown over the grate of wooden bars or the perforated zinc plate; con-
sequently there is as much dirt, dust, etc., separated or screened from the
cotton in passing one foot over the screen as there would be in passing
over four feet of the grate of bars or perforated zinc. The nature of my inven-
tion and improvements in machinery or apparatus for cleaning cotton and
other substances consists in dividing the trunks used for that purpose cen-
trally and horizontally by a reticulated screen of woven wire or twine
with cells or compartments under said screen formed so small by vertical
partitions placed crosswise of the trunk, so near together as to break the
blast or current of air, or so far prevent any current or blast from
19 being formed under said screen that will carry much of the dust,
dirt, or refuse matter which falls through the screen up, back again
through said screen, but retain such dirt, dust, and refuse matter in the
cells under the screen until it is removed by opening the bottom of the
trunk.
To enable others skilled in the art of making and using machinery for
working cotton and other fibrous substances I will proceed to describe the
construction and operation of the improvements which I have invented, re-
ferring to the accompanying drawings in which the same letters of refer-
ence indicate like parts in cach of the figures Fig. 1 is a plan or top view
of a trunk with my improvements; the top of the trunk is omitted to show
the screen. Fig. 2 is a sectional elevation through the line A B of Fig. 1
with the top shown in place. Fig. 3 is an elevation of a machine, such as
are in common use for picking cotton, drawn on a scale of ?ths of an inch
to the foot. Fig. 4 is a cross section of a trunk with the wire screen on
a scale of six inches to the foot. Fig. 5 is a portion of a screen drawn full
size. :
In the above-mentioned drawings a strong frame is represented at ©, pro-
vided with a beater or scutcher arranged to turn in proper boxes mounted
on the frame C, which beater is covered by a semicircular case D on the
top, the ends of which case may have openings near the centres to admit
air to the beater. There is a case under the beater, as sliown by the dotted
line E, extending to the end of the trunk which conveys the cotton away
from the machine. To supply the cotton to the beater the frame F is con-
nected to the frame C, as shown in the drawing, and provided with two
cylindrical rollers, one of which is shown at G, which rollers carry an end-
less band or apron on which the cotton is spread, and as the top of the
apron moves forward towards the rollers H, these rollers take it between
them as they are rotated, and deliver it to the beater, which knocks
20 or beats it in small locks as the beater is turned rapidly in the direc-
tion in licated by the arrow, and blows or delivers the locks of cotton
into the trunk attached to the rear of the machine.
There is an open space between the rollers H and the end of the bottom
case K, through which space the heavy seeds are knocked when struck by
the beater, and separated from the cotton; and the air also rushes or is
drawn in through this open space, and is blown or forced by the beater
through the trunk, carrying the cotton with it. The beater may be turned
by a pulley and hand, and the rollers G and H by rear, and float boards
10 Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden.
may be applied to the arms of the beater to increase the blast through the
trunk if necessary. As the feeding apron, rollers, and beater are all well
known, and have long been used, a further description is deemed un-
necessary, and I will now proceed to describe the trunk connected to the
rear of the machine, with my improvements.
This trunk consists of two sides aa, which may be placed about thirty
inches apart, and connected together by partitions cc, placed about five
inches apart, and made to extend from the lower edge of the sides up to the
middle. The bottom of this trunk is closed by small doors, ff, held in place
by the buttons g g, so that the partitions with their bottoms form a series of
small cells, or compartments d d, in the lower half of the trunk, which cells
are covered by a screen b of woven wire or twine, extending across the
trunk from side to side, and supported by the tops of the partitions cc. The
screen 6 may be secured to the sides a a by cleats e'e', so as to hold it in place
op the tops of the partitions. The upper edges of the sides @ a are provid-
ed with a rebate 7 / to receive the edges of the top A h, which may be made
in sections so as to be easily and readily removed and replaced, and it is
21 held down by the buttons77. If it is desirable to agitate the blast
of air which carries the cotton through the trunk, some deflecting
cleats e e may be fastened alternately on the top of the screen over the par-
titions and to the underside of the top, as shown in the drawings. J have
found in practice that these trunks work well when the height of the space
above the screen was six inches, and the cell six inches deep under the
screen, and that wire about number twenty, woven so as to make about
twenty-five or thirty meshes or openings in a square inch of surface. These
screens’ should be made of smooth wire, and to prevent the fibres of cot-
ton or other substances from catching and hanging in the scores in the
woven wire, formed by the weft crossing the warp, or at the junction of the
warp and weft, I fill them with a varnish made by dissolving gum shellac
in alcohol, and applying it with a brush upon one or both sides of the wove
wire; if only one side the top is varnished. The wire should be placed in a
horizontal position when it is varnished and allowed to remain in that posi-
tion until it is dry. It should be brushed crosswise in applying: the first
coat of varnish, and when that is dry tne second coat should be applied by
prushing it lengthwise, so as to fill the scores in each direction. 1 contem-
plate that there are some other kinds of varnish that will answer the pur-
pose to fill the scores, and prevent the cotton or substaace blown over the
screen from catching and hanging in the scores above mentioned. The rear
end of the trunk may be arranged ¢o deliver the cotton into a room provid-
ed with screens to retain the cotton and let the air escape ; or it may be so
arranged as to deliver the cotton to a rotary screen to form the lap, if pre-
ferred.
In carding, drawing, roving, and spinning most cotton there is a great deal
of staple so short that it flies off or falls from the longer staple in the pro-
cesses mentioned, sv that it has to be frequently gathered up or wiped
22 from the machinery to prevent it from obstructing the proper operation
of the machinery. Now I have found that in blowing cotton through
the trunk over the woven screen that a large portion of the fibre that is too
short to reach across two of the meshes falls through the screen, and re-
inains below it to be removed with the waste ; while the fibre that is long
enough to reach across more than two meshes is blown through the trank
over the screen, This shows that my improvements effect what has never
been done before, nor ever attempted, that I know of ; that is, a separation
of the short fibres of cotton from the long before carding the cotton, which
isa vreat advantage, as it saves a great deal of labor in the subsequent pro-
cesses Which would otherwise be required to gather
+
EARS iy i Se Ree awa RA ae
Saree S
Suffolk Manufacturing Co. vs. Hayden. 11
it is thrown or falls off, so as to prevent it from accumulating and gathering
on the machinery, and from being drawn into the work so as to derange it,
Besides, the woven screen separates so much more of the fine dust and dirt
from the cotton, that there is far less in the carding room than there would
be if the wooden rods or perforated zinc were used ; and further, since the
wire screen has been in use, it is found that it separates so much more of
the dirt and sand from the cotton than anything previously used, that the
‘ards will run nearly twice as long without grinding as they did before,
and that fully one third of the labor of grinding the cards is saved with the
expense of grinding materials, and also one third of the wear and tear of
the card clothing. Lastly, goods made from cotton cleaned with the im-
proved screen and cells present an appearance so much superior to others
as to increase their value from five to eight per cent., and at the same time
the cotton is worked with far less loss in waste than heretofore, so that it
enables the manufacturer to make goods of a given quality, out of a far
cheaper and inferior quality of raw material than he could do with-
23 + out my improvements. I believe I have described and represented
the improvements in machinery or apparatus for cleaning cotton and:
other substances, which I have invented, so as to enable any person skilled
in making and working cotton machinery to make, use, and operate said
improvements. I will now state what I desire to secure by letters patent,
to wit :
What I claim as my invention and improvement in a trunk for cleaning
cotton and other substances is, dividing it horizontally or centrally with a
screen of woven wire or twine, with cells or compartments under said
screen so small as to prevent or break the current of air under said screen,
substantially as described, in combination with a machine, substantially such
as is described in this specification, or its equivalent, for opening the cotton
and blowing it through said trunk over the screen, substantially as described.
In testimony that the foregoing is a proper specification of my improve-
ents in apparatus for cleaning cotton, etc., I have signed my name.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
Witnesses: J. Dennis, JR.
J. F. CALLAN.
{Here follow 2 diagrams, marked Exhibit “C,” No. 1 and 2.]
Filed 9th December, 1864.
Supreme Court of the Anited States.
° | No. 90.
=
The Suffolk Manufacturing Company
) Isaac Hayden.
@
BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF IN ERROR.
BOSTON:
PRINTED BY ALFRED MUDGE & SON, 34 SCHOOL STREET. |
1865. |
:
Ve
Supreme Court of the Cites States.
No. 90.
D> e
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY
- ISAAC HAYDEN.
BRIEF FOR PLAINTIFF IN ERROR.
BOSTON:
PRINTED BY ALFRED MUDGE & SON, 34 SCHOOL STREET.
1865.
Fe
I.
INVALIDITY OF PATENT BY REASON OF
HAYDEN’S PRIOR PATENT.
The patent of Hayden, marked Exhibit B., and dated June 15th,
1857, being the patent on which he went to the jury and obtained the
verdict, is inoperative and void, and should have been so held at the
trial, because the thing therein described and claimed was fully described
but not claimed in Hayden’s patent A. granted March 17th, 1857 (before
patent B. was applied for), and was therefore by the legal opera-
tion of patent A. surrendered to public use (if it was the invention of
Hayden) before patent B. was issued or applied for.
PESCRIPTION OF APPARATUS IN PATENT B.
The thing described and claimed in patent B. (on which the verdict
was recovered), is an “improvement in elongated trunks for cleaning
cotton,’ etc. [fol. 10], consisting in “covering the partitions of an
elongated trunk or box for cleaning cotton, etc., with woven wire, having
the scores, formed by the weft crossing the warp of said wire screen,
filled with metal or cement, the whole combined in the manner and for
the purposcs set forth ” in the specification [fol. 14].
The “ elongated trunk ” to which the improvement relates is described
as applicable “to such machines for beating, picking, scutching and
opening cotton, wool, fur and other fibrous substances, as can be made
to produce either a blast or suction with or without the aid of a fan to
4
assist in passing the substances operated on through the trunk over the
screen ” [fol. 12]. The particular trunk shown in the patent is described
as having doors in the bottom for removing the waste matter, and doors
also in the top.
The partitions are described as placed about six inches apart cross-
wise of the trunk, on the bottom, and in height about one-half of the
height of the sides of the trunk [fols. 10, 12], and their purpose and
operation are to form receptacles in which there is little or no current
of air and im which the refuse matter precipitated from the fibres of the
cotton as they pass along through the trunk may rest and remain until
removed from below [fol. 12, 13].
The woven wire screen is described as fastened over or on the top
edges of the partitions, and as best made of wire about number twenty-
two, woven square, about one-eighth of an inch from centre to centre of
the wires, or eight wires to the inch each way [fol. 11]. But the
patentee says, “the wire or twine used in making the screen and the
meshes formed in it may be of such dimensions as will adapt it to the
purposes for which it is intended to be used” [fol. 13]. The described
operation of the screen is that not only the sand, dirt, pieces of leaves
and other refuse matter heavier than the cotton, but also those fibres of
cotton, which are too short to reach across two meshes in the screen,
pass through it into the spaces between the partitions [fol. 12].
The filling of the scores is described as accomplished by dipping the
woven wire into melted metal (tin, or a composition of tin and lead), or
by applying on one or both sides, with a brush, varnish made by dissolv-
ing gum shellac in alcohol, — the varnish being so applied as to fill all
the scores in each direction; and any other kind of varnish or cement,
which will answer the purpose, to be used at the option of the con-
structor [fols. 11, 12]. The described operation of the melted metal,
or varnish, or cement, is “to prevent the fibres of cotton or other mate-
rials being passed over the screen, from catching and hanging in said
scores” [fol. 10].
The trunk, the partitions, and the metal or cement, are combined by
placing the partitions crosswise on the bottom of the trunk, covering
them with the woven wire screen, and coating the scores of the screen
so as to completely fill them with the metal or cement, the purpose
being to form a screen floor through which the refuse matter will drop
4)
out of the current of air into receptacles beneath, and which screen
floor will permit the fibres of cotton to slip over it without hanging or
catching as they are blown through the trunk.
DESCRIPTION OF APPARATUS IN PATENT A,
The same elements combined in the same way for the same purpose, and
producing the same results, are fully described in the patent A, taken out
by Hayden before he applied for patent B, on which the verdict was
recovered. |
The invention described in patent A. is “a new and useful apparatus
to be applied to machines for cleaning and separating wool, cotton, fur
and other fibrous substances.” [Folio 2.]
The patentee says that the design and object of his apparatus, when
applied to machines for cleansing, etc., is to “make the machine clean
the cotton more perfectly by blowing or drawing it, when separated
into very small flakes, or loose, open locks [by the cleaning and sepa-
rating machine], through @ long trunk provided with numerous cross
partitions on its bottom ; these partitions and the spaces between them being
covered with a wove wire screen or net with open meshes large enough to
allow the blast of air blown through the trunk to circulate freely
through them, but so small that only the short fibres of cotton will be
blown through, while the dirt, dust, sand and other refuse matter mixed
with the cotton, which are heavier than the cotton, will fall through the
meshes in the wove wire screen, and remain between the’ partitions
until they are removed, while the cotton is blown through the trunk
over the screen. After precipitating all extraneous matter which was
mixed with it through the screen, it passes out of the trunk into the
receptacle or devices prepared to receive it, being far better cleaned
than it has ever been done before by any machine heretofore known
[fols. 2,3].
He proceeds to say that “the areca of the trunk above the screen
_may be increased by making it larger towards the rear,” etc. [fol. 3,] also
that “the partitions in the trunk may be made wider, so as to make the
spaces between them gradually deeper towards the end of the trunk,”
etc. [fol. 3.]
2
6
He describes the bottom and top of the trunk as made in sections”
removable for withdrawing the refuse matter [fol. 4].
He describes his apparatus as intended to be applied “to such
machines for beating, picking, scutching and opening cotton, wool, fur
and other fibrous substances, as can be made to produce either a blast
or suction, with or without the aid of a fan to assist in passing the
substances to he operated upon through the machine or apparatus ”
[fol. 7].
The trunk here described differs from that shown in the drawings of
patent B. in so far as it shows not only un elongated trunk with top and
bottom made in removable sections, but superadds the feature of enlarge-
ment toward the rear end.
The partitions (in patent A.) are described as “about one-half the
width of the sides, placed about six inches apart, with their lower edges
even with the lower edges of the sides [fol. 4], and their purpose and
operation is that the refuse matter may fall through the screen into the
spaces between the partitions, and there remain until they are removed
(fol. 2, 3]. |
They differ from those shown in the drawings of patent B. only in
superadding the feature of gradual enlargement of the spaces between
the partitions towards the rear end of the trunk.
In patent A. the woven wire screen is described as fastened to the
tops of the partitions so as entirely to cover the space between the sides
of the trunk, and as made of wire about No. 22 so that the centres of
the wires are about one-eighth of an inch apart in each direction
[fols. 4,5]. And the patentee says, “the wire used for making the
screen and the meshes formed in it may be made of such dimensions
as will adapt it to the purposes for which it is intended to be used”
[fol. 7].
The described operation of the screen is the same as in patent B
[fols. 2, 3].
The filling of the scores with “ melted metal, varnish, or some kind of
cement,” and the purpose of so filling them are described at fols. 4, 5,
almost verbatim as they are in patent B. |
The manner of combining the trunk, partitions and metal, or varnish,
or cement, is also the same as in patent B.
Cr Ly
Q@ e
CLAIM OF PATENT B.
This claim is susceptible of two interpretations:
(1) The more obvious interpretation is, that it covers the combina-
tion of 1, an elongated trunk or box for cleaning cotton and other
fibrous substances ; 2, partitions dividing the lower horizontal section of
such trunk into compartments; 3, woven wire screens extending length-
wise of the trunk, and resting upon the partitions; 4, metal or cement
filling the scores of the screen. |
(2) It may be interpreted as a combination of the above enumerated
elements with an opening or beating machine capable of producing either
a blast or a suction with or without the aid of a fan to assist in passing
the cotton through the trunk over the screen.
Whether the one or the other of these interpretations be adopted, the
claim of patent B. covers that which is fully described in patent A.
The parts claimed in combination in patent B. are found in the description
of patent A. constructed, combined and operating in the same way.
This is true although the claim of patent B. be construed to embrace
as an element of its combination only such a trunk as is shown in its
drawings, viz.: a trunk not widened towards the rear end. Because
(1.) The description of patent A. plainly includes two
forms of trunks, one which is widened at the rear end, and
another which is not; the widening being stated merely as an
optional or perhaps preferable form of construction.
(2.) The trunk of uniform depth and width being found
described in patent A. it is immaterial that a modification of
that form is also described.
(3.) Ifthe patent A. contained no description or suggestion
of any but widened trunks, it would still contain substantially
the trunk claimed in patent B. (supposing that patent to
cover a straight trunk only), because the widened trunk in
combination with the opening machine, and the partitions and
screen and metal or cement performs exactly the same office
in exactly the same way, and the uses of the two trunks
respectively are not only analogous but identical.
8
Horton vs. Mahon, 12 C. B. (N. S.) 437.
Brooks vs. Aston, 8 Ell. & Bl. 478; 1 Ell. & Ell. 1102.
Rallston vs. Smith, 9 C. B. (N.S.) 117.
Beley vs. Holden, 8 C. B. (N. 8S.) 666.
Harwood vs. The Great Northern R. R. Co. 8 Jurist (N. S.),
1120.
Bean vs. Smallwood, 2 Story, 411.
Hotchkiss vs. Greenwood, 11 Howard, 248.
But the claim of patent B. does not exclude the widened trunk
and partitions. It covers as an element of its combination an elongated
trunk, etc.; that is to say, any known elongated trunk capable of useful
employment in the same combination in the same way and for the
same purpose. The limitation, in the claim, to the preceding descrip-
tion, relates only to the manner and purpose of combining the before
described elements.
Doubtless, a defendant using the apparatus described in patent B.
with a widened trunk would be held to infringe the patent. And if the
patent B. includes a widened trunk for purposes of the question of
infringement, it includes it for the purposes of the present question.
us CLAIM OF PATENT A.
This improvement of filling the scores by varnishing, etc., the screen
is not claimed as a distinct feature of the monopoly intended to be
secured by the patent A. and if embraced at all by the second claim, is
adopted by implication only from the words “substantially as described
for the purposes set forth,” and if adopted by such implication, the claim
confines the monopoly to the use of varnishing, etc., in wire screens
when inserted and used in sucha widened trunk as is described and
claimed in the patent.
The result of the foregoing comparison of patents A. and B. is submitted
to be that the subject matter of patent B. 1s described but not claimed in
patent A.
|
— een erneta nen
9
ex
This being so, we submit that by operation of patent A. said subject
matter was surrendered to public use (saving the right of re-issue) and
that the subsequent and independent patent B. taken for said subject
matter, is void; and for the following reasons:
1. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent gives a
patentee the right to extend his term of protection unlawfully.
An inventor lodges at the Patent Office a model and drawings and
description of a certain apparatus comprising various features, some
new, some old. Of two new and patentable features which he describes
he claims only one. |
Now, if he may afterwards take an independent patent for the other,
he virtually protracts his protection beyond the period allowed by law.
For although he in such case does not hold a claim for more than the
period allowed by law, yet his first description, containing, as it does,
a feature which, being new and patentable, he may, when he pleases,
claim, deters the public from engaging in any manufacture embracing
that feature, lest they be stopped at a future day, if he pleases to take
a re-issue and stop them.
This state of things may continue so long as the patentee can prac-
tically enjoy a monopoly of the feature which he has so described and
not claimed, and this may be a longer or shorter period, according to
the nature of the business to which such feature is applicable.
Suppose a patentee to shew in his description a general mode of
construction, and also a subordinate improvement in one feature, giving
the machine a special value,—
So long as he, holding his claim to his general mode of construction,
can control the manufacture, he need not take a claim for the special
improvement. Sooner or later, whenever he finds it expedient, he may
introduce the special improvement into his manufacture, and two years
after that he may take a patent for that special improvement.
Clearly he may thus by management extend his monopoly much beyond
the term allowed by law, without any new act of mvention.
10
2. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent is zncom-
patible with the statute rights of assignees.
Suppose the original patent, containing two features described and
but one claimed, passes to an assignee,—
The assignee has a statute right to re-issue that patent and cover
both features.
Act of 1836, § 13.
Woodworth vs. Stone, 3 Story, 750.
McBurney vs. Goodyear, 11 Cush. 569.
Now, if the assignor has also a statute right to secure the second one
of those two features by a subsequent patent, there are two parties
entitled to separate patents for the same thing. |
The right of the assignee to secure to himself the unclaimed feature,
is a continuing right, co-extensive in duration with the term of the orig-
inal patent which he has bought, and no other man can have a right at
any time during that term to appropriate such unclaimed feature to
himself.
3. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent is in dero-
gation of the right of the public, acquired by the grant of the first patent, to
practise the invention as there described.
A specification is a statement of the invention or discovery and of the
manner of making, constructing, and using the same.
The contract between the patentee and the government is, that in
consideration of his being protected in the exclusive enjoyment of his
invention for a term of years, the public shall, after the expiration of
that term, have the right to use the invention zm the manner he has
described in his specification.
If at any time after taking his original patent he may take an inde-
pendent patent for a full term, covering part of the manner of construct-
ing and using described in the first patent, he thereby prevents the
public from that full and beneficial enjoyment of the subject of the first
woe i ha
11
patent from and after its expiration, which was the condition upon
which that patent was granted to him.
4. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent is excluded
by the language of the Acts of Congress giving to the Commissioner the
power to grant original patents.
There is no exclusive right to inventions, which the Court has
jurisdiction to enforce, except that which the Acts of Congress confer.
If it does not appear from these Acts that the Commissioner may
grant one original patent for one part of what is described, modelled
and drawn by the applicant, and may afterwards grant another and
independent patent for another part, and so on, the Court cannot affirm
the judgment in this case.
These Acts of Congress require the inventor to lodge a model and
drawings and description showing his invention and the manner of making,
constructing and using it. He must also describe the several modes in
which he has contemplated using it. He must furnish such information
as will enable skilful artisans in that department of industry to make
and use the invention. Having done this, he must “ particularly specify
and point out the part, improvement or combination which he claims as
his own invention or discovery.”
Act of 1836. Section 6.
He is not bound to describe any more than is necessary to make,
construct and use the invention. He may take his patent for as little as
he pleases and may describe, model and draw no more than is necessary to
make, construct and use that litile. |
But of that which he does so describe and model and draw, he must
particularly specify what he claims as new.
The purpose is twofold; 1, that when the term has expired and the
invention has become public property, the public may have at the Patent
12
Office the knowledge of the best way of practising the invention, and
2, that during the term, the public may know just what the patentee
claims and what they are prohibited from using.
Parker vs. Stiles, 5 McLean, 509.
Brooks vs. Bicknell, 3 McLean, 441.
Evans vs. Eaton, 3 Wash., 403.
S. C., T Wheat., 434.
When the patentee states what part of the thing described he does
claim, it is saying in effect that the remainder he does not claim.
He makes a voluntary communication to the public of certain things,
and by declaring that he claims as his own only some of them, he
surrenders to public use the remainder, except as he may be relieved
by the law of re-issue.
Battin vs. Taggart, 2 Wallace, Jr., 101, 8. C., 17 Howard, 74.
©emith vs. Ely, 5 McLean. 87, 88.
Odiorne vs. Amesbury Nail Factory, 2 Mason, 31.
Morris vs. Huntington, 1 Paine, 349.
Dixon vs. Mayer, 4 Wash, 73.
Langdon vs. De Groot, I Paine, 207.
do. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent is implicitly
denied by the provisions relating to re-issues.
The re-issue law (1836, section 13) provides that whenever a patent
is inoperative by reason of a defective or insufficient specification, the
Commissioner may re-issue the patent upon a specification so amended
as to secure the whole invention to the applicant, provided, 1st, that the
error arose by “inadvertency, accident or mistake, and without any
fraudulent or deceptive intention,” 2d, that the re-issue shall have effect
only for the residue of the original term.
It cannot be that the 6th and 7th sections of the same act, which give
the Commissioner all the power he possesses to grant original patents,
are to be so construed as to permit him to grant an original patent of
13
fourteen years for a part of the same invention which was previously
described but not claimed, and that, without its appearing that the omis-
sion to claim it in the first instances was by inadvertence, accident, or
mistake.
6. The right so to take a subsequent independent patent makes the
law of re-issue nugatory.
That law is expressly made for the purpose of making his patent
operative to secure to him the whole of that which was really new with
him in the thing modelled, drawn, and described; aud where a statute
prescribes a peculiar remedy, that alone can be resorted to.
2 Saund. Pl. & Evid. 1012 and cases cited.
Gregory vs. Des Anges, 3 Bing. N. R. 85.
Alborne ts. Pyke, 3 Town. R. 444.
Newton vs. Holford, 6 C. B. 926.
Upon the face of the specification of patent A. it is plain that Hayden
might have taken, in that patent, besides the limited claims there found,
1, a claim to an elongated trunk having cross partitions covered by
woven wire screens — whether widened at the rear or not— if it was
new: 2, a claim to a woven wire screen having the scores filled with
metal, etc., — whether used with a trunk and partitions widened at the
rear or not,—if it was new.
Wilson vs. Rousseau, 4 How. 670, 686.
Hogg vs. Emerson, 6 How. 483.
S.C. 11 How. 587, 605.
Wyeth vs. Stone, 1 Story R. 288.
14
7. There is,no question of abandonment in fact, to be tried by a jury.
There are but three cases which can be supposed of a patentee’s
omitting to claim a new thing which he has described.
1. That he omitted it by inadvertence, accident and mistake, and
without any fraudulent or deceptive intention.
For such case the law provides re-issue, and by implication
excludes any other remedy.
2. That he omitted it intentionally, with a purpose to claim it by an
independent patent afterwards.
This is that “ fraudulent and deceptive intention ’
re-issue law mentions, and which, if found to exist, debars him
from re-issue for the remaining term; a fortiori, from a new
patent for a full term.
3. That he omitted it intentionally without any purpose to claim
9
which the
it afterwards.
This is necessarily a surrender of it to the public use.
There can be but these three states of fact—the character and
consequences of each are matters of law.
IT.
INVALIDITY OF PATENT BY REASON OF HAYDEN’S
SUBSEQUENT PATENT.
The court below rightly decided that patent C. (applied for Dec.
11th, 1854, and granted Sept. 11th, 1860) embraced what was already
covered by patent B. (assuming that patent to be for the combination
of varnished sereen, trunk and partitions with the opening, etc., machine, )
—— nT pl :
15
and, that being so, should have ruled that patent B. was inoperative
and void by reason of the legal effect of patent C.
(1) . Because the action being brought upon both these patents B.
and C. and it appearing that they both claimed the same thing, and the
patent C. having never been surrendered, the policy of the patent laws
forbids the enforcing of etther of them.
(2) Particularly in the present case, it is submitted that the patent
C. in so far as it contains the same thing which is claimed in patent B.
must, if either be valid, be held to be the valid one of the two: because
it was properly applied for Dec. 11th, 1854, and that application was
never withdrawn; and, pending that application, the Commissioner had
no power to entertain any other application by the same person for
another patent for the same thing, but such other application and
all proceedings under it must be held to be irregular, unlawful and void.
III. :
DAMAGES.
It did appear in evidence, and is an obvious necessity of the case
from the nature of the invention, that the plaintiff derived his advantage
of monopoly from granting licenses to use.
As regarded the making of the trunks, there was no evidence offered
by plaintiff to show that he ever made any himself, or at what prices
they could be sold, and consequently no evidence of any damage by
defendant’s making.
As to defendant’s using, it was not true that “from the peculiar
circumstances of the case, no other rule could be found” than the
defendant’s profits — which therefore did not become the criterion of
the plaintiff ’s loss.
Seymour vs. McCormiek, 16 Howard, 490.
’ ee P
»
&
16
There was evidence for the jury to consider, whether or not the
plaintiff had fixed a rate of licensing the use of his invention, and the
Court should have therefore given the ruling asked for in the defend-
ant’s first prayer on damages [fol. 28]. It was error to instruct them
to consider, with that, the value of the invention, or, in other words, the
profits of the defendants.
It was error to instruct them [fol. 30] that the price fixed by refer-
ence in two cases, as testified by the witness Oliver, was not to be taken
as price which Hayden fixes for using his invention, because not satis-
factory to Hayden.
It was for she jury to say whether it was in fact the standard price
of Hayden.
The burden was upon the plaintiff to show his damages. It appeared
that his custom was to grant licenses. He was bound to show “ the loss
which he had sustained in being deprived of an opportunity of agreeing
with the defendants on a voluntary sale.” The second prayer of de-
fendants [fol. 28] should have been granted. :
But if the question of defendant's profits could properly enter at all
‘into the question what was a proper license fee to charge them, the evi-
dence of value observed in the use of the invention in other mills was
immaterial and misleading, and should have been excluded.
If evidence of value observed in the use of the invention was admis-
sible, it should have been limited to the question what value was
observed in long trunks with partitions and varnished wire screen, as
claimed in the patent, over and above the value observed in the
widened long trunks and partitions with unvarnished screen claimed
in the prior patent, A.
It was error to give the jury such instructions as would permit
them to find by their verdict as damages under patent B. above the
value of all “ the practical benefits, if any, of using Hayden’s improve-
ments in cotton-cleaning, as described in his patents, over and above the
old machinery for cleaning cotton.”
Ae Y= itm Caen
a
ieibcgien > seneea sesame ene ee SS we
Se
2
elie
ls et me te a eas, Le
“
-_ _~
a eno
Supreme Court of the Cites States.
No. 9O.
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY
US.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
BRIEF OF DEFENDANT IN ERROR.
BOSTON:
ALFRED MUDGE & SON, PRINTERS, 34 SCHOOL STREET.
1865.
16
There was evidence for the jury to consider, whether or not the
plaintiff had fixed a rate of licensing the use of his invention, and the
Court should have therefore given the ruling asked for in the defend-
ant’s first prayer on damages [fol. 28]. It was error to instruct them
to consider, with that, the value of the invention, or, in other words, the
profits of the defendants.
It was error to instruct them [fol. 30] that the price fixed by refer-
ence in two cases, as testified by the witness Oliver, was not to be taken
as price which Hayden fixes for using his invention, because not satis-
factory to Hayden.
It was for the jury to say whether it was in fact the standard price
of Hayden.
The burden was upon the plaintiff to show his damages. It appeared
that his custom was to grant licenses. He was bound to show “ the loss
which he had sustained in being deprived of an opportunity of agreeing
with the defendants on a voluntary sale.” The second prayer of de-
fendants [fol. 28] should have been granted.
But if the question of defendant’s profits could properly enter at all
‘into the question what was a proper license fee to charge them, the evi-
dence of value observed in the use of the invention in other mills was
immaterial and misleading, and should have been excluded.
If evidence of value observed in the use of the invention was admis-
sible, it should have been limited to the question what value was
observed in long trunks with partitions and varnished wire screen, as
claimed in the patent, over and above the value observed in the
w:dened long trunks and partitions with unvarnished screen claimed
in the prior patent, A.
It was error to give the jury such instructions as would permit
them to find by their verdict as damages under patent b. above the
value of all “the practical benefits, if any, of using Hayden’s improve-
ments in cotton-cleaning, as described in his patents, over and above the
oe
old machinery for cleaning cotton.”
i ae
ae NP ee
| :
: |
Supreme Court of the Cnited States.
No. 9O.
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY |
US.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
BRIEF OF DEFENDANT IN ERROR.
a —
ee ee Ve SS ea eae
BOSTON:
ALFRED MUDGE & SON, PRINTERS, 34 SCHOOL STREET.
1865.
¥
Jaa
be
4 :
"
ate
- wer *
*
BNE
4 ee
as
ie
+
ot
RS TR ge SS Sk a oie, ene ae 2
pea gee
“ ak K tf
Supreme Court of the Unites States.
No. 9O.
THE SUFFOLK MANUFACTURING COMPANY
US.
ISAAC HAYDEN.
BRIEF OF DEFENDANT IN ERROR.
x The defendant in error, who was plaintiff in the Court below,
} declared in his first count, on: letters patent, which are desig-
| nated in the Bill of Exceptions as Patent B.; and in his second
3 count on letters patent, designated in the Bill of Exceptions as
a Patent C.
~ At the trial, Patent C. was withdrawn from the case, and the
al verdict was rendered on Patent B. only.
4 The first question which arises on the bill of exceptions
4 respects the validity of Patent B.
be The material facts are,—that on the eleventh day of December,
fad 1854, the plaintiff, being the original and first inventor of new
a and useful improvements in Cotton Cleaners, made application to
45 the Commissioner for letters patent therefor.
- ™ The nature of these improvements may be characterized as
io consisting in certain described changes made by Hayden in the
Za interior arrangements of an elongated trunk previously in use
s for cleaning cotton.
While this application of December 11, 1854, was still pending,
Hayden made another distinct improvement, not in the interior
2
arrangements of the elongated trunk, but in the form of the
trunk. This improvement consisted in increasing, towards the
rear end of the trunk, that part of its area above the screen,
(which divided it horizontally into two distinct parts,) so that
as the air moved through the trunk towards its rear, the space
for its passage being enlarged, the air would move gradually
slower.
Hayden desired to claim this new improvement in the form
of the trunk, both separately, and in combination with his other
improvements in the interior arrangements of the trunk, as to which
his application was then pending; and accordingly, November
Ist, 1855, he filed his application for letters patent, and on the
17th day of March, 1857, letters patent (designated in the
bill of exceptions as patent A.), were issued to him, in the speci-
fication whereof he claims the improvement in the form of the
trunk, both separately, and in combination with his improve-
ments in the interior arrangements of the trunk; but he makes
no claim in this specification to his improvements in the interior
arrangements of the trunk, because an application for letters
patent for those interior arrangements had been pending before
the commissioner ever since the 11th of December, 1854.
This patent A is in supplemental record, pp. 1-4.
It did not appear at the trial, nor was it asserted by the de-
fendants, that Hayden was guilty of any laches, or was in any
default whatever in reference to the delay of the Commissioner
to act on his first application for letters patent for improve-
ments in the interior arrangements of the trunk made December
11, 1854. But for some cause, the Commissioner had not acted
on that application down to the 15th of June, 1857; and on
that day Hayden made another application, for letters patent,
for what the judge at the trial, at the request of the defendants,
ruled to be the same improvements, previously applied for on
the 11th of December, 1854; and upon this second application
rs
3
the letters patent (B.) were granted, bearing date December 1,
1857, being the same declared on in the first count of the
declaration, and on which the verdict for the plaintiff was found.
(This patent is in supplemental record, pp. 4-7.)
At the trial, the defendants’ counsel requested the judge to
rule that patent B. is inoperative and void, because the improve-
ments in the interior arrangements of the trunk, which are
described and claimed in patent B. being also described and
not claimed in patent A. by the legal operation of patent A. were
surrendered to the public use. |
The judge refused so to rule and this refusal raises the first
question.
I. The defendants are to be confined to the specific question,
whether Hayden, by the legal operation of putent A. did sur-
render to the public use, what is described and claimed in
patent B.
Brooks vs Marbury, 11 Whea. 78.
Cotts vs. Phalen, 2 How. 376.
II. Having made an invention in the interior arrangements
of the trunk, and duly applied for a patent therefor, and having
subsequently made an inyention in the form of the trunk, capa-
ble of being usefully employed either separately from or in
combination with his first invention, Hayden had the right to a
patent, covering both the separate and the combined use of his
improvements in the form of the trunk.
III. To apply for and obtain such letters patent, he was
compelled to describe his earlier invention, in combination with
which his second invention was claimed.
IV. Hayden had no control over the order in which the
respective letters patent would be issued by the Commissioner,
or the time when either would be granted.
4
V. The request for instruction excludes all fault on the part
of Hayden, and all control by him of the order or dates of
his patents, and all manifestations of his intent, and the neces-
sity he was under to describe his improvements in the interior
arrangements of the trunk; and rests wholly on the mere legal
operation of the fact that the Commissioner first issued patent A.
VI. The request for instructions makes the act of the com-
missioner, in issuing patent A. before he issued letters patent
for the other improvements, not only fatal to Patent B. but to
any letters patent for that improvement.
Hayden could not surrender Patent A. and claim the improve-
ments in the interior arrangements of the trunk separately, so
as to cover what is patented in Patent B.
Ist. Because it is manifest he did not fail to claim these in
Patent A., from inadvertence, accident, or mistake. He did not
claim them in Patent A. because he had all the time on file in
the office an application for distinct letters patent therefor.
Burr vs. Duryea, 1 Wallace, 531.
2d. The ability of Hayden to surrender Patent A., and ob-
tain a re-issue covering the subjects of both A. and B., involves
matter of fact, excluded by the request for instructions; which
was not that Patent B. was void 7f a case existed for the surrender
of Patent A., but that Patent B. was void by the legal operation
of A. without limitation or qualification.
VII. Patent B. bears date December 1, 1857; Patent A.,
March 17, 1857; less than nine months previously. If, at the
date of Patent A., the subject matter of B. had been described
in every scientific magazine in the world, and had been in public
use and on sale, with the consent of the patentee, this would
not have been by mere operation of law a surrender of the inven-
tion to public use, on or before the date of Patent B. It would
5)
still have been necessary to prove the intention of the inventor
to abandon his invention to the public.
Act of March 3, 1839, sec. 7.
Why should a description which the patentee was obliged to
insert in Patent A, to secure his rights, be deemed an abandon-
ment by mere operation of law, when he actually had pending
before the Commissioner an application for letters patent for
the thing supposed to be abandoned ?
VII. That Patent B. was not in fact issued upon the origi-
nal application for its subject matter, made December 11, 1854,
but upon an application made June 15, 1857; and that the
Commissioner afterwards issued another Patent, C., which cov-
ered the subject matter of Patent B., is of no importance in
reference to this question whether Patent B. was void by the
mere legal operation of Patent A.
Doubtless Doth Hayden and the Commissioner believed that
Patent C. did not cover the same subject matter as Patent B., or
it would not have been so issued.
But the defendants at the trial requested the judge to rule,
and he did rule, that patent C. embraces what was already
covered by patent B., and of course they are bound by that
ruling. Now the application covering the subject matter of
patent C., and therefore, according to the ruling, covering the
subject matter of patent B. was on file continuously from
December 11th 1854. Why letters patent were not issued upon
it does not appear; and the defendants are, as has been shown,
in no condition to suggest to this court, that Hayden was in any
fault for the delay. All that appears is that the office failed to
issue letters patent upon an application which Hayden was
entitled to have granted. In this state of facts, he applied a
second time, viz., June 15, 1857, for the same thing; and patent
6
B. was issued for that thing. In point of fact he always, after
December 11, 1854, had an application pending for that thing.
And the new petition which he filed for the same thing, June
15, 1857, though an unnecessary act, was clearly a part of the
same transaction, and the two constitute one continuous appli-
cation for that thing down to the date of Patent B.; and there
was no error whatever in issuing Patent B.
It is true, if the ruling of the judge at the trial, made at the
defendant’s request, was correct, that the subject matter of
Patent C. includes the subject matter of Patent B., Patent C.
ought not to have been afterwards issued. But this in no way
affects Patent B.; and as Patent C., though declared on in the
second count, was withdrawn from the jury, its invalidity is of
no importance.
Finally, it is submitted that the description of a thing not
claimed in a specification does not amount to an abandonment by
mere operation of law. By such description the thing becomes
known to the public by the consent and allowance of the pa-
tentee froin the date of the patent. Whether such consent and
allowance amount to an abandonment of the thing described, to
the public, cannot be determined without taking into view other
facts. If this public knowledge, with the consent and allowance
of the patentee, existed more than two years before his subse-
. quent application for a patent, and it is not a case for a sur-
render of the patent in which the thing was described, then,
far a-~~-Cand then only, is there an abandonment of the invention to the
public by mere operation of law.
iss In the case at bar, when the description in Patent A., of the
subject of Patent B., first came before the public (March 17,
1857), an application for the subject of Patent B. had been
pending more than two years before the Commissioner; the
renewed application for the subject of Patent B. was made
7
within three months afterwards (June 15, 1857); and Patent B.
itself was issued December 1, 1857, within nine months after
Patent A. What pretence can there be, in such a case, of an
abandonment by mere operation of law ?
The refusal to instruct that Patent B. was made void by
Patent C., was correct. (C. was void, if it covered only the sub-
ject of B. (which was not alleged); otherwise it was void pro
tanto—but it did not affect Patent B.
In reference to dumages:
The first exception cannot be sustained. It assumes that if
the patentee sells licenses, the price of a license to use a thing
of little utility will be as much as the price of a license to use a
thing of great utility, which is evidently false.
The second exception assumes that it was not material to the
question of damages, to what extent the defendants had unlaw-
fully used the plaintiff’s invention.
The first prayer for instructions was inapplicable to the case.
There was no evidence which would have warranted the jury to
find that the plaintiff had, at the date of his writ, any fixed or
average price for a license to use his improvements.
The second prayer was also, in part, not applicable to the
case; there being no evidence to warrant the jury in finding
dealings with other manufacturers which could afford any
standard or criterion of damages. And in the instructions
actually given, the jury were told to allow to this evidence such
weight as it deserved in ascertaining the actual amount of the
damage sustained by the plaintiif.
The learned judge’s instructions to the jury were full and
correct, and he was not bound to follow the prayers of the
defendant's counsel, or to modify them to suit the case.
Bb. R. CURTIS,
Of Counsel with Defendant in Error.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.