Respondents Brief in Opposition — Shields v. Sharp (No. 773)
Supreme Court brief1960
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Oe cee me
e
—— ee
>
a
md
Py a
oe
-
+.
No. 773 >
™ : °
an the, Supreme Court of the Wnited States
; Ociobhr TERM, 195
—- —_—— = —- ee ee eee --- — +
JostrH SHIRL, PETLIIONER
-
e
r.
+ plby C. SHaRbe SECREPARY oF THE AIR Force
%
, z
CLIITION OR A WRET OF © PRIIORAKT 10 THE TNITBD
A. bY COURT OF APRE ABS BOK CHE DISTRICT OF COLT MBIA
’ iT 2 a . -
BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT. IN OPPOSITYON
_ ARCHIBALD cox.
WILLIAM H OKRICK, JR
Qiscesiant i’? oo fre Meer be
MORTON HOLLANDER.
.MARK R JOELSON.
‘ Allornepe
[vepartonent «* Juatice
Wash tmyt
- —_——- — —-— -- —- --- +---- - -- - a +
“a i settanstaa u
Miscellaneous—Continued
‘Air Forced{anual 40-1, Section 2, Paras.1-15. 5
Civil Service Regulations, 5 5C. F.R. 9.102(a) (1)
(1949 ed.)..--- sa aaeivke rman foeean ce anna tigen ae 8, 13
Federal Personnel Manual, 8 350 (Aug. 1,
EEOC a santa 13
»
m .
= the Spree Gourt of the United States
OCTOBER TERM; 1960,
No. 773
JOSEPH SHIELDS, PETITIONER
/
>
Dupiex C. SHarp, SECRETARY OF THE AIR FORCE
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THB UNITED
STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT IN OPPOSITION
The findings ‘of fact and conclusions of law entered
by the United States District Court for the District
of Columbia (R. 97-100)' are not reported. The order
of the United States Court of Appeals for the District
of Columbia Circuit affirming the judgment of the.
District Court (Pet: App. 1a) is not reported. —
» URIEDICTION
The judgment of the court of appeals was entered
on November 1, 1960. On January 24, 1961, the time
for filing a. petition for a writ of certiorari was ex-
‘All record references are to the Joint Appendix submitted
in the court of appeals and filed here pursuant to Rule 21 of
this Court. ae
2
(1)
2
: tended to March 1, 1961.. The petition for a writ of
certiorari was filed on February 28, 1961. The juris-
diction of this Court is invoked under 28 USS. C.
1254(1).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Whether the petitioner, having been dismissed
from civilian government employment under the ~
Lloyd:LaFollette Act after written notice of specific
charges and an opportunity to reply, was deprived of
statutory or constitutional rights by reason of the
informal procedures followed in a grievance proceed-
ing availed of by him under Air Force regulations.
2. Whether the allegedly unwarranted delay in
bringing a charge against — ae his dis-
missgal.
Be STATUTE AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED
The Lloyd-LaFollette Act of 1912, Sec. 6, 37 Stat.
555, as amended, 62 Stat. 354, 5 U.S.C. 652(a) pro-
‘vides, in pertinent part:
a: (a) No person in the classified crvil service
of the United States shall be removed or sus-
pended without pay therefrom except for such
cause as will promote the efficiency of such
service and for reasons given in writing. Any
person whose removal or suspension without
. pay is sought shall (1) have notice of the same
_ . and of any charges preferred against him; (2)
' be furnished with a copy of such charges; (3) _
be allowed a reasonable time for filing a written |
answer to such charges, with affidavits; and (4)
_be furnished at the earliest practicable date
with a written decision on such answer. No
examination of witnesses nor any trial or. hear-
v.
c=r
3 are
ing ‘shall be required except in the discretion |
of the officer or employee directing the removal
or suspension without pay. * * * .
The relevant regulations are set forth in the Aps
pendix, infra, pp. 13-16. .
STATEMENT “
_ On May 12,-1954, the petitioner, a non-ve teran
civilian employee of the Department of the Air Force,
received a “Notice of Proposed Removal” signed by -
C. R. Landon, Major General, US.A.F., advising
him that action was being initiated to remove him.
from his position because of ‘Immoral Conduet Off
Duty” (R. 70-73). The charge recited specifically —
tliat througli investigation it had been learned that
the petitioner had engaged in’ abnormal sex acts with
one Lieutenant Commander Herman Andrew Dudley,
U.S.N.R., in 1944; that he associated with known homo-
sexuals; and that he had resided at an address in Wash-
ington, D.C.,, which was a “hangout” for homosexuals
and had, failed to disclose this residence upon various
official forms filled out by him for the Air Force he-
tween 1948 and.1953 in connection with his employment
(R. 71-72). Since petitioner was not emploved bv: the
Air Force until 1948, all the allegations of misconduct,
-except the withholding of information, related to a.
period prior to his employment.
On May 19, 1954, the petitioner filed a writteri reply
to the charges (R. 73-78). He admitted that he knew
the individuals named and had resided at the Wash-
ington address; but he denied committing ebnormal . |
sex acts with Dudle ‘ve and also denied knowing that the
&
other individuals were homosexuals and the Wash-
ington address a homosexual “hangout” (sbid.). He
stated that the omission to list the address-was unin-
tentional.
The. portion. of the charge against the petitioner
concerning his conduct with Dudley referred to an
affidavit made hy Dudley in 1945 for another purpose
(R. 71). As the.affidavit was an official confidential
document belonging to another government agency, and
concerned many other. individuals as well-as the peti-
tioner, it was not made. available to the petitioner’s
counsel nor to the Air Force investigator (R. 9-10, 38).
However, the entire portion of the affidavit which con-
_ cerned the petitioner was — in the statement .
of charges (tbtd.).
On May 14, 1954, Air Force investigators inter-
viewed Dudley in Paris, France, and a report of the
interview was trarismitted to General Landon on
June 1, 1954, after the charge had been made against
the petitioner, but before the final notice of removal
(R. 41). ‘The petitioner’s counsel was later permitted
to see the part of the investigation report concerning
this interview with Dudley (R. 99). |
‘On June 14, 1954, the petitioner received a ‘‘ Notice
of Removal”’ stating that a’ final decision had been
made to remove him from his position, effective June
15, 1954 (R. 78-81). This notice explained that the
petitioner's reply had not been sufficient to warrant
~ withdrawal of the charges (R. 79):
The petitioner was advised that he could request
review of the removal decision by the Secretary of the
*
5
Air Staff, pursuant to the Air Force grievance pro-
cedure as set out in Headquarters Office Instruction
(“H.0.I.””) 40-47 (R. 81)." The petitioner, through
his attorney, invoked this procedure and requested
an oral hearing,. which was held on July 28, 1954,
‘before an Ad Hoe Grievance Committee appointed by
the Secretary of the Air Staff in accordance with the
provisions of Sec. 7(e)(1) of the Air Force Griev-
ance Procedure Regulations, H.O.I. 40-47 (R. 1-70):
The proceeding before the Ad Hoc Grievance Com-
mittee was, by its nature, an administrative, rather
than a quasi-judicial hearing, and the burden was
on the petitioner to furnish information concerning
his grievance (H.O.I. 40-47, Sec. 7(a) (App., infra, p.
14) (R. 99)). The committee was merely a fact finding
body, convened for the purpose of advising the.-Sec- .
retary of the Air Staff with regard to the petitioner’s
case (H.O.I. 40-47, Sec. 7(e) (2) (App., ingra, pp. 14-
15), R. 2). At the hearing, the petitioner did not pro-
duce any witnesses, and he did not testify, although he
~ was free to do so (R. 98-99). ;
The petitioner had requested that General Landon
be present at the hearing (R. 87). The committee,
*The Headquarters Office Instruction was issued by order of
the Chief of Staff as the grievance procedure applicable for
civilian ‘personnel of Headquarters USAF Office of the Secre-
‘tary of the Air Force, and Air Force field activiti:. serviced
by the Headquarters Civilian Personnel Office. The provisions
of the Instruction are consistent with the provisions of Air
Force Manual 40 1, Section 2, Paras. 1-15, which sets out the
grievance procedure generally applicable to Air Force
personnel. ‘
*See App., infra, p. 14.
_ 5
which did not have the power to compel the presence
of witnesses (H.O.I. 40-47, See. 7(¢) (App., infra, p.
16) ), had requested General Landon to appear, but he
was unable to be present on the date of the hearing (R.
7). The committee denied the petitioner’s request for
‘postponement of the hearing on the ground that
‘Colonel’ Breeze, General Landon’s exeeutive officer,
was present and could represent General Landon
‘fully with respect to the petitioner’s case (R. 15-16).
The petitioner had also requested the presence of
‘a representative of the District of Columbia. police
“department who could testify that certain persons
nained in the *‘Notice of ‘Proposed Removal’’ were
identified by the police .department as homosexuals.
‘The committee ascertained that it was the policy of
representatives of the police department not to appear
at such hearings and not to make their records available —
(R.13). Prior tothe hearing, the members of the com-
‘mittee went to the office of the Chief of the Morals Divi-
sion of the police department, to verify the police report
underlying the ‘*Notice of Proposed Removal” and
to attempt to obtain the presence of the officer at the
hearing (R., 36-37, 99).* ane
Subsequent to the petitiotier’s hearing before the
Ad Hoe Grievance Committee, the Secretary of the
Air Staff sustaihed his removal (R. 88). Pursuant
to the grievance procedure, the petitioner’s case was
%
further reviewed by the Office of the Chief of Staff.
” of the Air Force and his disnfissal was sustained by
*The officer adv — the committee that he would not attend
the hearing, and he did not do so (R. 35).
3
7
that office. Still under the terms of the grievance
procedure, the petitioner then appealed to the: Secre-
‘tary of the Air Force. On May 18, 1956, the Secre-
tary, acting through the Deputy for Manpower Per-
sonnel and Organization, advised the petitioner that
the decision removing him was final.(R. 99).
On June 26, 1956, the petitioner filed a suit for
reinstatement against Secretary of the Air Force
Donald A. Quarles. That suit was dismissed beeause
of the petitioner’s failure to make a timely substitu- .
tion of the part defendant. The present suit for
reinstatement was thereupon instituted.. The peti-
tioner urged that the Air Force had committed nu-
merous Violations of his procedural rights in removing
him (R. 91-93). The distriet court entered. judgment
for defendant, concluding that the petitioner’s dis-
missal was (R. 99-100) “in no way arbitrary nor
capricious” and that the petitioner **was afforded all
of the procedural rights prescribed” in the grievance
procedure. On the petitioner’s appeal, the Court of
Appeals for the District of Columbia Cireuit entered
a per curiam order of aftirmance. The order stated
that the petitioner ‘had been accorded his statutory
and procedural rights (Pet. la).
. : ARGUMENT
1. It is clear ly ‘settled that matters ielating to the
discharge of federal executive employees are within
the discretion of the employing agencies, and that
judicial review of such matters is limited to the de
termination of whether the dismissal was effected in
compliance with the applicable: procedures and stat-
588760—61——__2 .
r oe
utes. Eberlein v. United States, 257 U.S. 82; Keim
v. United States, 177 U.S. 290: see also Hargett v.
Summerfield, 243 F. 2d 29 (C.A.D.C.), certiorari
denied, 353 U.S. 970; Boylan v. Quarles, 235 F. 2d
834 (C.A.D.C.). In the present case, both courts below
held that, in discharging the petitioner, the Air Force
complied with all of the applicable procedural requiré-
“ments. Accordingly. there is no occasion for further
review by this Court.
In_ conformity with the L lovd- LaFollette Act;
U.S.C. 652(a), supra, pp. 2-3, and Civil Service Reg-
‘ulations, 5 C-F.R. 9.102(a) (1) (App.; ‘afra, p. 13), the
petitioner received a detailed written notice of thie
charges preferred against him, opportunity to file a
reply thereto, and a written decision stating that the —
charges had heen sustained. These steps fully satisfied
petitioner’s statutory rights under the Lloyd-LaFollette.
Act’ The statute gives no right to a hearing and im-
poses no substantive limitations upon the diseretion of
. the employing agency. And, contrary to the petitioner's
arg::ment, the Fifth Amendment does not grant govern-.
ment employees a right to a quasi-judicial, hearing prior
to removal.
*The petitioner alleges that the dismissal was in violation of
Civil Service Regulations (5 C.F.R. 9.102(a){1) (App., infra. p.
13)) on the ground that it was based in part on charges not speci-
fied in the notice (Pet. 17).“ The record (R. 36-57, 62-63)'
shows that the Air Force -made further inquiry of the peti-
tioner’s accuser after the notice of charges was issued and
considered the information so obtained in disposing of the case.
However, there is no indication whatsoever that any evidence
of additional acts of misconduct was received, rather than a.
reaffirmation ‘of the original accusations. The final action was
specifically based on the original charges (R.. 79).
9
) The original notice of proposed removal might per-
haps be open to the technical objection that the speci-
fications did not support the charge of ‘Immoral Con-
duct Off Duty” because the acts and associations speci-
fied were stated to have occurred prior to the petitioner’s
employment by the Air Forge in. 1948 (R. 70-72, 91).
The petitioner, who was represented by counsel, has
never raised this question, perhaps because he knew
that the-formal charge could have readily been amended
to specify his concealment of his residence, which was
‘alleged to be a “hangout for a Homosexual clique” (R.
72). That concealmett.took place during his employ-
ment by the Air Force at various times froin 1948 to
1953; was referred to in the charge (R. 71).; and was
specifically relied on in the dismissal (R. 80).
2. The bulk of the petitioner's argument deals with
the procedures followed in connection with the griev-
ance proceeding initiated by’ the petitioner to review
his dismissal. It is important’ to understand that an’
Air Force grievance proceeding is rot part of the dis-
missal procedure established under the Lloyd-LaFol-
lette Act, nor is itstablished for the specific purpose
of reviewing dismissals. It is a separate and an addi-
tional procedure adopted by the Air Force, following
‘the labor relations practices established under collective
bargaining, in order to enable the Secretary to deal with.
all kinds of complamMts by civilian employees arising .
. out of their employment. Thus, the petitioner had no -
constitutional or statutory richt toa grievance hearing,
_and no’ rights under the procedure beyond those which
_ the regulations gave him.
10
* The petitioner does not assert that the grievance pro-
cedure was not conducted in accordance with the regn-
lations. The burden of proof is on the grievant, as the
regulations make clear, and there is no obligation on
the Air Force to produce witnesses or present evidence
justifying the action involved. An ad hoc committee is
established to look into ‘the complaint, make such in-
vestigation as is appropriate, and hear the complain-
ant and his witnesses inthe event he desires to appear.
This is just what the committee here appointed did.
{t investigated the complaint and, after interviewing.
- the poli¢e, made the results of such investigation avail-
able.to the petitioner. It provided him with all the in-
formation he needed in order to present his case. It re-
quested the presence of the witnesses desired by him
arid: procecded without the presence of the person
responsible for his dismissal only when it had, reason
to believe that it would be possible to go ahead because
another officer equally able to present the necessary
information was present. This is not a situation
where an accused must be faced with his accusers.
because at this stage of the proceeding the petitioner
was himself the accuser.
Neither Greene v. McE Iroy, 360 U.S. 474, nor the
procedures established in connection with security
cases (Pet. 10-11) have any relevance to the present liti-
gation. The case and the regulations are both concerned
with procedures to be followed in connection with the .
dismissal of employees on- security grounds.. The dis-
missal here was pursuant to the Lloyd- LaFollette Act
-_
ll ‘ P a
and the procedures under attack are those followed
in the grievance proceeding.
3. The main complaint on the merits is that the affi-
davit which was the first item referred to in the speci-
fication of charges was executed nearly ten years before
the charges were filed. . However, there is no allegation
that the faets came to the attention of the petitioner’ s
» superiors at that time, or at any specified time before
action was taken. The petitioner’s failure'to list his
residence ata ‘*homosexual hangout** blocked investi-
gations which might have been made Sooner. There is
_ therefore no basis for an accusation of unreasonable
delay. .
Whether the misconduct in the past was sufficient
evidence of petitioner's undesirability as an employee
at the time of his dismissal—a question which petitioner
does not raise—was a substantive question of personnel
policy for the executive department; it is not review-
able by the courts. Eberlerm v. United States, 257 U.S.
anes
3 CONCLUSION ©
For the fore going reasons, it is respec tfully submitted -
that the petition for a writ of certidrari should be
denied.
An HIBALD Cox,
Solicitor. Areneral.
WuuiaM H. Orrick, Jr.
Assistant Altorney General.
Morton HOo.LiaNnber,
Makk R. JOELSON,
, Attorneys.
ApriL, 1961. -
APPENDIX |
Section 9.102(a)(1) of Civil. Service Commissfén ,
Regulations, 5 C.F.R. 9.102(a)(1)° (1949 ed.) pro-—
vides, in pertinent part: | |
. No.employee; veteran or nonveteran, shall be
se suspended, or demoted except for
such cause as will promote the efficiency of the
service and for reasons given in writing. The
agency shall notify the employee in writing of
the action proposed to be taken. This notice
shall set forth, specifically and in detail, the
charges preferred against him. The employee
shall be allowed a reasonable time for filing a
written answer to such charges and furnishing
affidavits in support of his answer. He shall
not, however, be entitled to an examination of
witnesses, nor shall any trial or hearing be
required except in the discretion of the agency.
If the employee answers the charges, his answer
must be considered by the agency. Following
consideration of the answer, the employee shall
——~.. be furnished at the earliest practical date with
a written decision. If the agency determines
that removal or other action is warranted, the
employee shall be notified in the decision of
the reasons for the action taken and its effec-
tive date. Copies of the charges, notice of
‘hearing (if any), answer, reasons for removal,
or other action, shall be made a part of the
records of the department oragency concerned.
\ * & * . ‘ a
The Federal Personnel Manual, TS 350 ( Aug. 1, 1951
to Sept. 17, 1959), provided in pertinent part (at
81-21): |
Decision by appointing officer —The question
* whether or not the reasons for the separation,
suspension, or demotion are sufficient is a mat-
(13)
~~
~
oO
14
ter for final determination by the appointing
officer. However, the separation, suspension,
or demotion, if made, must be upon one or more’
of the charges presented to the emplovee and
which he has had an opportunity to answer,
‘and not upon others.
Section 7(a) of Headquarters Office Instruction
-40-A7 provides: | } :
7. Grievance Procedure:
a. Employee Responsibility in Presentation
of .Grievance—An employee who wishes to
present a grievance must furnish detailed and
me: information concerning -his grievance
and will present it in accordance with thy pro-
eedures in b and/or ¢ below. The presenta-
tion, whether oral or written, must specify the
exact nature of the emplovee’s grievance and
cite the name(s) of the person(s) complained
against and specifie incidents leading to the
grievance, including date, time, place,-and cir-
cumstances, Snpervisors will be able to re-
Solve grievances: satisfactorily only if the
employee furnished specifie and complete in-
* formation concerning his grievance,
Seetion Tle) of - Headquarters Office: Instruction
40-47 provides: ‘ :
e. Grivaice Committee Hearings:
(1) Composition” of — the Committer.—Tlip
grievance committee will be appointed: on an
ad hoe basis by the Secretary of the Air Staff.
The committee will be composed -of ‘Air Force
personnel and will consist of four persons. A
representative of the Headquarters Civilian
Personnel Office will serve as a nonvoting
chairman. At least two. of the three votine
members will he civilian employees one. of:
whom will be of the same or similar workine
level as the employee presenting the grievance,
whenever feasible. Attendance of: the. full
membership of the eommittes will be required.
to constitute a quorum.
15
(2) Functions of the Committee—The com-
mittee will serve as a fact-finding and advisory.
body. It has one primary purpose which is to
assist the Secretary of the Air Staff in arriving
at a prompt and fair decision by:
(a) Making a full and complete investigation
of the evidence.
(b) Impartially appraising the evidence.
(ec) Reporting to the Secretary of the Air
Staff a record of the hearing proceedings, a
statement of the committee’s findings, and its
recommendations. )
a + *. € +
(5) Conduct of Committee Hearings:
+ * & = - *®
(d) Order of Proceeditigs. The order of
proceedings will be as follows: :
1. Testimony and other evidence by the em-
ployee and/or his representative; questioning
by the person(s) complained against. and com-
mittee members. |
2. Testimony and other evidence by the em-
loyee’s witnesses; questioning of each witness
y the person(s) complained against and com-
- mittee members. Each employee witness will
be released, subject to recall if necessary, :fol-
lowing completion of his testimony and
questioning. fees
8. Testimony and other evidence by the per-
sons who wish to refute or comment upon the
employee’s grievance; questioning by the em-
‘ployee, his representative, and. committee
members. 3 |
4, Witnesses of person(s) complained
against; questioning of each witness by the em- .
- ployee, his representative, and committee mem-
bers. Each witness will be released, subject to
recall if necessary, following completion of -his
testimony and questioning. |
5. Rebuttal and summation by both sides..
t.t @Wwtdcwwor « &
16
Section 7(g) of eet maiens Office Instruction
40-47 provides:
(g) Witnesses —The committee has no au- ©
thority to compel witnesses to give testimony.
However, if necessary to insure adequate pres-
entation of testimony for either the complainant
or the person(s) complained against, the com-
mittee may request appropriate administrative
authority to require the attendance of Air Force |
employees as witnesses. The committee may
also entertain a request from the employee and
other persons giving testimony .to call other
witnesses in addition to those originally pro-
~dreed. When such’a request is made, the com-
mittee May require an explanation of the pur-
pose and the basis for the request and an
indication that the testimony of the witness or
witnesses requested will be competent, relevant,
and material to the case. The committee may,
in its discretion, decide not to call any addi-
tional witness if it considers the action unneces- _
sary to a fair consideration of the grievance
or ctherwise impracticable for may demon-
strable reasons.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.