Petition for A Writ of Certiorari — Seaboard & Western Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board
Supreme Court brief1959
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
i Office-sup
f |
‘s | | Jan
ms 639 c—-
a —— ' see ae
: a 3 '
In THe
Supreme Court of the Auited ) States
October ‘Term, 1958
Seeman & WESTERN AIRLINES, INc.,
Petitioner,
‘
Cr. AERONAUTICS Boarp,
Respondent,
and
, ; . y°
- Paw American Worip Airways, INC.. and |
. TRANS Wortp AIRLINES, a,”
Respondents.
scinaguvnsnesn
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
_ THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
~~ Harpy K. Maciay
» y Warten D. Hassen’ ©
1317 F Street, N.W.
Suite 408 -
Washington 4, D.C.
Attorneys for Petitioner.
WILSON - Epes PRINTING Co. - RE 7-6002 - WASHINGTON 2. &
vy
7 * °
C purer
: INDEX i .
- ; PAGE
Opinions renee LSAT Bast oticasne clas |
{ Jurisdiction ..... SE TT eae s, SER 5
|= . Questions Presented................... (TRE CT ee sles -.2
Statutes Involved Tee een K 3
CS Se eee Bree. es es 3
Reasons for Granting i he eee «+6
Conclusion ....:...:....--.--+-- SS ee aOR i ot ae ea ae
- Appendix A, Lower Court ERIE EE: Rie the
- Appendix B, Lower Court Tudgment 22... Sicilians 21
Hee SS, RENE ROOT RIOR "Sk 22 *
- Citation.»
wad ' Cases:
' American divthees v. CAB, oni £24 463... 7....-.. 1
Conley v. Gibson, 3! Sy Seeeeeeeeee Sees ics, 13
Czaplicki v. The Hoegh Silvercloud, 351 US. - 12
Eqstern Air Lines v. CAB, een. No.
| MRMPGSE ASSES Sh aes er nek eer Weiner eee 11
- Eastern: Air Lines v. CAB, 185 F.2d 426.......2..:.-.-.--- 10
° FCC vy. Allentown Broadcasting Corp., 349 US. |
Oe ie aa eee rainiehriotistnom serra eas "13
Poti ee oy a) hls Seen enema anes
« FHA v. The Darlington, 27 US. LW ais......:.-2:..--- . 13
FTC vy. Ameriéan Tobacco Co., 274 US. SEER ae +
-FTC v. National Casualty Co., 78 S. Ct. 1260. sande een
Greensboro-High Point Airport A uthority v. CAB,
ON nahi pes hnesesntienyannertinccmvenescn . Bh
La Buy v. Howe Leather Co., "352°U.S. 249............2.. 13
Massachusetts Bonding v. Unies States, 352 U. "
OO cues ceiclaaniane cies slegeninmnness SELES 4 2
Mastro Plastics Corp. v. NTRB. 35AU.S. 270... 12
eas:
2
te “« INDEX (Continued) ‘
a) ' -
_—-——~ NLRB v. Coca Cola Bottling Co., 350 U:S. 264.......
NLRB vy. Truck: Drivers Local Union, 353 US. 87...
Northwest Airlines v. CAB, 194 F.2d 339.0002... U1
Norwegian Nitrogen Prod. Co. v. United States, *
288 U.S. 294. ele 3
Reed +. Pennsylvania R. R. 351 v. s. 500. GES atts. 12
United Gas Pipe Line Co. v. Mobile Gas Service |
Corp., 350 U.S. . 332. AILS ee SA eee :. 13
Sea ere Enited States v. Ryan, 350 U.S: 299........ ies SEL “13
Wilko v. Swan, 346 US. 427 a ipa ndesibinet atlleantarirdes —
Cc AB Cases and eo Ricees:
| Air Freight Rate Investigation, 9 C.A. B 340... 12.
Large Irregular Air Carrier Investigation, i A. B:
Order No. E-9744............ 3 Sal ORC RR send. a
1957 C.A.B: AnnuakReport Dees Sid aes cahsssas ecaasochaanadoes * fh
. Statutes:
Civil Aeronauties Act, 52 Stat. 977, as amended,
49 USA. § 4401, et _ :
Oe I ae OA, Geet ae SAT
‘
AI gis oe ick: SRI Dies A ASI re OTN fo {Ys Oi
5 EEA A Oe rage” ae ie
S| ee EAD done races sa ae ee ..
*Bec. 406............ ELPA, Cae ae coy oe AI ae ce
Sec. Sheena Re Greene ge peat cutie “ws 3
a te oN Srna seats . Ven eae 4
a See. 409 .............. begun a pobip eipoavat nee te tuue ees es och bapisesewder’s 4
Le, SE aa ee SSA ES We ee +
.— < . So "sic be SP ae AEN fe oS eT ‘ ees
(BA ERALat ae a an e
: , oe Sie SEE cr eS Teer oer 4
2 ROAR see ee Ae ane ie ae 3
iS a Ee
( ‘ongrexsional Reports: : ,
H. Rep. No. 2360, 85th Cong, 2d ae
anit bate em
| Supreme Court of the United States
| October — 1958 -
ene
ve SeaBoarp & Wesrens Armiixes — oe 5
: Petitioner,
- @ ;
v. .
‘. Civi. AERONAUTICS Boarb,
pies ie - Respondent,
eae and |
Pax American Wor.p Airways, Inc., and . *,
Trans WoriLp AIRLINES, INc.,
Respondents.
a
ZS
PETITION FOR WRIT OF. CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
* THE ——* OF a CIRCUIT
v
Petitioner prays, that a Wi rit of Certiorari issue’ ,to
review the judgment entered in this.case by the United
- States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia - .”
Circuit which set aside an order entered by the Civil
Aeronauties Board. j
OPINIONS BELOW
‘The opinion of the Court of Appeals is Pint as #8
pendix A hereto. It is not vet reported. he orderof
the Civil’ Aeronautics Board, together. with its findings
is not as yet reported but appears at pages 105-110 of
the Reeord. ~-
ee ci ac Rar aaa,
JURISDICTION ~ =
The judgment of the Court of Appeals*was entered on
14 November 1958, It is printed as Appendix B hereto. |
No petition for rehearing was filed. ‘The Jurisdiction of
this Court is invoked under 28 U:S.C. § 1245 (1).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
Under section 401 of the Ciyil Aeronautics Act, 52 Stat.
- 987, as amended, 49.U.S.C. § 481, an aif carrier can carry
persons, property or mail in air transportaion only under
authority of a certificate of: public convenience and neces-
sity. Seaboard & Western Airlines, Inc., has certificate ©
authority to provide. transAtlantic ajr ‘transportation of
property but not of mail. :
a
_’, The Civil Aeronautics Board, under section 416 of the
- Aet, 52 Stat. 1004, as amended, 49 U.S.C. § 496,-is em- -
- powered to exempt air carriers frum the requirements
of section 401, supra, upon a finding that enforcement of
the section 401 requirement is not in'the publie interest.
and that such requirejnent fis or would be. an windue —
buen on such air carrier... by reason of the limited
extent of, or unusual circumstances affecting, the opera-
tions of su¢h air earrier. . . .” y
Seaboard applied for an-amendment tetts certificate
which would authorize Seaboard to carry mail. R. 26.
Subsequently Seahoard filed an application requesting
- an exemption under section 416 of the Act, sapra, from
the requirements of seetion 401 of the Act, so that Sea. «
hoard could earry mail pending ultimate disposition of
itx mail certificate amendment case. R. 49. The Boar!
granted the exemption authority requested by Seaboard.
R. 105. ° .
The court below set aside the Board’s order, holding
‘that the Boards findings were insufficiert under seetion
} Rave be
i i al ts i i a a
. © .
” » me | .
- of 1938 are set forth as Appendix C hereto.
404, 52 S
. a ‘
suhsidy suppor
§486):- regulatior
fe
4 /
416 (b) of the Act. App. A. This: Court ordee raises.
the following questions:
1) In Gection 416. of the Civil “Aeronautics Act, does
the term “limited extent” refer to the. pre- -existing, condi-
tidns-of the cargjer’s apeeeten, er to the scope ‘of the
exemption itself?
2) Can ‘financial Mickieiin and need for revenues if
sufficiently acute, constitute unusual circumstances sup-
porting a finding of undue burden under section 416 of
the Civil Aeronautics Act?
STATUTES INVOLVED
The pertinent provisions of the Civil Aeronautics Act
STATEMENT
‘Under Title 1V of the Civil Aeronautics Act,! the .
Civil Aeronautics Board has full responsibility and au-
thority for the economic regulation of the air transpor-
GF?
tation industry. There are provisions in this Title which | —
apply to every aspect of common carries transportation
by air: the- securing of original operating authority ‘and -
of permission to suspend or abandon service (section 401,
supra); the ‘filing, adherence to, and changes in tariffs
(section 403,.52 Stat. 992, 49 U.S.C. $483, and section
(section 406, 52 Stat 998, 49 TSC.
closure of stock ownership, form of ycounts (section 47,
a2 aes 1000, 49 T\S.C. $487): mergers, consolidations.
: The Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731. et seq., which
became effective December 31, 1958. reenacted the provisions here
involved without material change. Reenactment was for purposes
a on ~~ H.Rep. No. 2360, 85th Cong... 2d sess. 10-11
58). :
992, 49 U.S.C. $484); mail transportation,
f accounts, records. and repotts, dix-
ane P + con
eee !
common control (section 408, 52 Stat. 1001, 49 USC.
§ 488); interlocking relationships (section 409, 52 Stat.
1002, 49 U.S.C. § 489): ‘loans and financial aid (section
410, 42 Stat. 1003, 49 U.S.C. § 490); methods’ of compe-
‘tition (section 411, 52 Stat. 1003, as amended, 49 Agri
$491); pooling and other agreements (seétion 412,
Stat. 1004, as amended, 49 U.S.C. $492); immunity cs
‘anti-trust laws (section 414, 52 Stat. TW%4, 49 USL.
§ 494): and inquiry into air carrier management (section
* 415, 52 Stat. 1004, 49 U.S.C: § 495). Section 416, supra,
‘the last section of Title IV, authorizes the Board to
‘eréate classes of air carriers and to exempt any air car,
rier or any such class of air carriers from any or all:
provisions of Title IV. It is provided that any such ~
exemption granted by. the Board shall be, predicated
“upon certain findings: cag a
>
Except to the extent to which the Board may exempt,
-. prs section 416, supra, from any such economic regula-
tory requirement of the ‘Act, including any requirement
- imposed: thereunder by the Board. by way of rule, regula--
tions, condition, limitation or otherwise, every: air car-
rier must _casphy ‘fully with every * suck statutory and
regulatory requirement.
«a ’ ; ‘ ‘, . .
To exempt a carrier from the entire Title, i... all
economic regulation, or. from any Ppartieular: stabutors
or regulatory requirement, whether it be from the basic
one ofseenring a certificate: of publie convenience and
necessity by way of initial dr additional operating an-
thority or from some: lessor statutor¥ or regulatory re--
quirement such as that of’ filing of reports, the Board
must find that enforcement of the entire Title IV or of,
ahy particular section or regulatory ‘requirement there-
under “is or would be ant undue burder'. on such air cai-
rier or class of air earriers.’. . .” and that: such enforce- .
‘ment is not in. the public interest. Rin
o
“«
»
ce
. t]
°
a” 3
In addition, seétion 416 contains - language describing
the nat f required. subsidiary findings “by reason”
of whi “undue burden” éxists. It is provided that
the undue“Durdey be “by reason of the limited -extent: of
or unusual circumstances affecting, the dperations of suc h
air carrier or class of air carriers. . . fs |
By: section 401 a- certificate of public convenience and
necessity is required to authorize a cabrier to carry United
States mail. Seaboard, alraady having ‘a certificite au-
theorizing cargo operations, applied for a certificate amend-
‘ment to authorize it to" earry_mail. R. 26. ‘The grant of
‘this certificate amendment could be male only after
public hearing and al! of the procedural steps necessarily
incident to'a full administrative. proceeding. The mini-
mum time normally required. for such a proceeding would
be a matter of months, generally atleast a year. Sea- _ .
board's certifitate amendment application was filed on
7 February 1958, along with a motion for expeditions
eon R. 28, 20. Immediately after filing its application
and motion to expedite, Seaboard{ applied for authority
-by way of exemption to carry “mail ding final decision
on its certificate amendment application. R. 49.
_ The Board found in: its oping Prgating the ‘exemeion
which was. set aside -by the courf bow. that Seahoard’=
- financial. condition was so serious that its “existence. was
in jeopardy.” that to “deprive the carrier of the op-
portunity to earn these [mail] rev enues pending’ decision
mM its: certificate application wold’ impose an tune
g burden on “it and would not be in. the public. interest. ~,-
R. 198.109. ‘The Board enunciated its own conception”
'-of-the nature of its exemption powers ‘as being “desi:tned
to afford it the flexibility needed -to meet changine edn-
ditions for the over-all development and soed of- the -nir.
transportation system.” R. 108. With reference to its
responsibility under the Act, it stated: “We have sa 38
* duty to « give the carrier as much aid*and encouragement
ve
oF
4 a a s VS : 6 oat
3
for economie survival as we can within the_previsfons of
the Act.” R. 109. °. The Bosrd) concluded that the authority }
conferred by the exerp jon was “limited Méxtent and
in the public interest” pd that enforcement of the cer-
tifieate requirement insofar’ as it would prevent. Seaboard
from carrying mail,.“would be‘ an undue burden on Sea-
board by reason of the limited extent of, and. unusual’
circumstances affecting, its operation and.is not in the
‘public intérest.” HK: 109. as
That the extent of hardship on Seaboard which ‘would
have resulted: from enforcement of the certificate reap
ment would have been so great that for. lack of immed ate
.authorit¥ by way of exemption, Seaboard would have Keen
compelled to discontinue .operations, may be assumed on
the basis of. the Board’s opinion and_ the, opinion of the
court below. In addition, the Board’s finding that grant
of the exemption’ was in the public interest was not dis-.
turbed by the court. The equrt. Has held that the ffidings
subsidiary to arid in support: of the Board's findings .of:
“limited extent of? and “unusual gircumstances” affecting
Seaboard’s operations were not of ‘a kind contemplated
_ by the statute, i¢., that the circumstances were not “un-
~—usnal” and. that the operations Were not of “limitedgev-
tent,” it being the court's view that. the operations rp-
- ferred to in the statute must be those already conducted
by the carrier‘and not those authorized by the exemption
ax the ,Board eae eee :
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT |
-. The. economic regulatory provisions of Title FV are
alike applicable to every air cartier, whether it be an °
internationad domestic or overseas ecarier, and wheth@r
it be engaged in trunkline, lopal service, air taxi, heli- |
_ copter. or scheduled or non-schéduled air carrier opera-*
tions. But for seetion 416 and exemptions. which _
he preperly granted thereunder, there ean be. no flexibilky °°
‘ . 5 asi ©
7
<
e .
c
or selectivity in the lal of all.< economic regula-
tory requirements of Title TV. .
Regardless of the fact that the Board_mavy find, as it
= ngthis ease,. that enforéayent of Any such require-
mt ch a particular earrier lagS of carriers would
constitute extreme hardship, in this , instance, hardship
sufficient to jeopardize the caffier’s continued-existence, _
ryan of the fact that it may conclude that enforcement of —
any. such requirement is contrary to the. public interest
under standards set forth ingthe Act,? the hoard, under
the decision of the e vurt Went) eannot grant relief unless
it ean find: (1) that the afready authorized a.
of a carriep or clas of cHrriergQare “limited in extent” or)
(2). that such. éperations. are affected by “unusual eir- |
cumstances” and that by, reason of one or the ‘other of
such findings, enforcement of the economic regulatory )
requirements in question would be an. “umdue byrde
The court has held that financial distress, no matter hew
serious, cannot of itself, constitute thie NeECESSATY. “unusual
cSrewmistances.”. Tooth s os
®
_ That the bipket of thie. iécision on. ‘the. Meonrd’s an-
‘thority ‘and upon the industry which ‘it Must, develop
and promete i ix- great. requires no argument. That the
decision is contrary to the Board’s administrative inter.
psetation of its statute is equally apparent
The court's view -that “Jimited extent” ean re toe only:
*> to “a pre-existing condition of the carrier’s operations
: ° . > . ry : i -@
‘that qualifies it for an exemption”, of conrse, gives no
weight whatsoever to the Board's lor. Sanding. admin
istrative interpretation ' and is tlearly contrary to the.
2 Section 2 of the Civil Aeronautics Act, 25 Stat. 980, 49 U. s. C:
§ 402. .-
SR. 108. For previous cases in” which the court below has upheld
the Board’s interpretation. see pp. 10-11, — :%
<= fad 4
4 Ibid, | ‘ 7
/
' statutory intent. Under its hélding, all air carriers would at
once appear to fall into one of two groups; those whose
already: authorized‘operations are sufficiently limited itd @X-- ¢
tent to make them eligible for ¢xemption under section 416,
and those whose operations are not so limited and who are
therefore not exemptable.* A large carrier seeking au-
thority by way of exemption to conduct limited aduitiona!
service not authorized by its certificate would necessarily
he denied in the absence of “unusual circumstances”. so-
effecting its already authorized operations as‘to consti-
‘tute an, undue burden justifying the exemption. Any
small carrier seeking identiéal authority. might .secure
it by exemption, régardless of unusual circumstances and.
solely because its existing operations are limited in ev-
tent. If caYmot reasonably be contended that mere size
of carriers was intended to have any such, effect. The
Board's interpretation that. the “limited extent of the
operations to he authorized hy. exemption is a proper
‘consideration in determining the.-extent of the burden
incident to compliance with the applicable statutory Te-
quirenieg@ is more consistent with what must be consid-
ered to have heen the statutory intent. Regardless of
the extent of a carriér’s aready authorizéd operations.
¢
.
> Tacit in the court’s opinion would seem to be a holding that
no applicant for an exemption for initial operating authority could
be successful. There would be no pre-existing operations, limited
or otherwise. The Board authorized irregular. carriers having no
prior operating authority to engage in limited operations by ex-.
emption. Similarly, some two or three thousand air-taxi operators
were given such initial authority by way of exemption. Section. |
416(b)(Z) referring to certain labor provisions specifically author- .
izes the Board to exempt therefrom if ‘it finds that:
‘“.. . by reason of the limited extent’ of, or unusual circum-
stances affecting, the operations: of any such air carrier, the
enforcement of such paragraphs is-or would be such an undue
burden-on such air carrier ‘as to obstruct its development and
prevent it from beginning or continuing operations, and that
the exemption of such air carrier from such paragraphs would .
/ not adversely affect the public interest... ."" Emphasis added...
‘«e 4
9 pad
\
the burden of completing a certificate proceeding, for
example, to secure aythority to perform a service during:
a_single month of peak traffic demand would appear to
-be an undue burden by reason of the limited extent ‘of
the operations to be authorized by exemption. The: pro-
ceeding could not be .completed in time to perform the
service. A very- small carrier seeking an exemptien
which would have the effect of increasing its total opera-
tion many fold, could hardly have been intended. to be
in a more favorable position than a very large carrier.
seeking temporary authority to “perform an ‘extremely
limited additional service. . ae:
The court’s holding that financial ‘distress “standing -
alone” cannot constitute “unusual circumstances” appears,
equally insupportable. The qualifying phrase, “standing
alone” apparently ‘refers to the court's earlier Statement:
“Of course, an unusual cireunistance which causes,
financial ‘distress may he such a-circumstance as to
warrant relief. under its exemption provision. But
financial distress in and of itself, unrelated to cir-
cumstanees which would render the carrier eligible,
is not enough.” -Emphasis added.
‘The court has. held them that “financial distress”. no
hatter how eritical, cannot of itself; ameunt to an “un-
usual circumstance” justifying ‘a finding of undue burden,
hence an exemption, but .that the same financial distress:
‘caused by some “unusual circumstance” might. Financial
a sufficient “unuy
te
distress results from lack of revenue sufficient fo cover
expenses, and seffous financial distress would appear to be
ot ‘tance’ itself to justify. relief.
The cause of ‘phufficient revenues would seem to be irvele-
vant on thyjuestion of the extent of the burden resulting
therefrom. Possibly reduced revenues resulting from
extravagant management causing financial distress would
justify denial of an exemption regardless of the burden
shown. But such denial would-appear to be based on
a resulting finding that «xemption, under the cireum-
.
woe
“10
stances, ‘would not be in the public iiterest and not on a
finding thatno undue burden -Was’ shown because of. the:
faet that the cause of reduced revenues was not “unusual.”
It is difficult to visualize what cause of financial distress
under the court’s g$ opinion would “render the carrier eligi: ©
‘hle” for ex xemption; possibly a strike or an act of God
rendering operations impossible. In any: event, the court's
holding on “unusual circumstances” would appear virtually
lo eliminate economic considerations no mattér how seri-
ous, as a basts for the required finding of undue burden.
“Obviously, business corporations such as air carriers |
ean be “burdened” only in a financial sense and it is be-
lieved: that in the Board’s administration of section 416,
substantially every éxemption granted is in fact granted
on the basis of a need for revenue, or on the other side
of the-coin, the need to avoid unjustifiable expense. The
Board has frequently granted such exemptions: limited: in
point of time until the completion of certification pro
ceedings, and has ‘permitted unrestricted operations by
hoth large and sali carriers as to persons, property and
mail during the completion of the certificate proceedings.
The court below has held on three prior oceasions that
‘the Board may so exempt pending determination of cer
tificate applications. American Airlines vy. Civil Aeronau-
tics Board, 97 U.S, App. D. C. 324, 231 F.2d 483 (1956)
(supfhce mail exemptiott)": Eastern Air, Dines vy. Civil:
Aeronautics Board, 87 U.S. App. D. C. 331,-185 F.2d
426 (1950), (exemption to Capital for cargo Operations):
‘ Although the court below attempted to distinguish the cases.
it appears that the opinion of the court below is clearly in conflict
with the decision of that court in American Airlines v. CAB. 231
F. 2d 483 (U.S. App. D-C. 1956), in which Judges Bastian and
Prett¥man concurred and Chief Judge Edgerton'dissented in three
separate opinions interpreting section 416 of the Civil Aeronautic:
Act. In that case it was held that enfofcement of the certificate
‘ requirements was an undue burden because certain carriers could
not have secured certificates in sufficient time to participate in a-
sepia ‘mail experiment.
il
Eastern Air Lines, v. Civil Aeronautics Board, No. 10,671,
not reported (exemption for persons, property, and mail
to Piedmont). In two other instances the court expressly
indicated ‘that the Board might eXempt pending comple- +
tion of proceedings on remand, and the Board did so.
Northwest Airlines vs Civil: Aeronautics Board, 90 U.S.
App. D. C. 158, 194 F.2d 339 (1952) ; ‘Greensboro-High |
Point Airport Authority v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 97
U. S. App. D. C. 358, 231 F.2d 517 (1956). In ali of these
cases the justification for tlte exemption is revenues.
O oy eye . 2 ° ‘ ° .
Flexibility in the Board’s authority to use its exempiion
powers is essential to enable.it to carry Out.its duties and
i Dd « :
_regulatory functions tinder the Act and to assure to cag
riers statutory rights to which they are entitled. The
judgment and opinion of the court below unless set aside,
will seriously hinder future adininistration of the Civil
Aeronautics Act and proper promotion and development
-of the industry.’ The Supreme Court has held that: such
“7 In line with the Board’s duties of promotion and development
of the air industry in conformity with the public interest, it has
created’ new — df.air carriers and granted special exemptions
for required servites which have contributed substantially to the ,
air industry. Some examples are the following: 4
“Aside from helping to meet the immediate travel needs 9!
the public, the irregular air carriers have played acsignificart -
role as innovators in air transportation. It was. they whe
made an invaluable contribution to air transportation by risk
- ing their own capital to pioneer in and develop the .field of
low-cost coach-type air transportation. And it was largely as
a result of such successful experimentation that: the certifi-. —
‘M cated trunkline carriers became active participants in this
_ field. This has made air transportation available to travelers
who could not afford first class accommodgtions. Today, ir
coach travel is a vital and growing aie of the indus-
try... .” Large Irregular Air Carrier nvestigation, C.A.B._
Order No. E-9744 (mimeo. 1955). — eee
“The transportation of air freight on a common carrier
basis is truly a new. product of the postwar period. It was
not until the latter part of 1946 that any appreciable volume
of freight was carried, and even in October 1947, freight
12
circumstances justify issuance of a writ of certiorari PFC
wv. mexican LeobaccoCe., 274 U. oS. 5d57%(1927). Phe deci-
_ sion of the court below cénverns a question of suck in.
portance to the Board's. regulatory tunciion that jit, ur-
, &éntly ‘requires review by this Court. Massachlase
‘ Bonding y. United States, 352°U. S. 128 (1956) 3".
. Plastics Corp. v. NERB, - U.S. 270° (1996) ;-Rbed v.
' reanegevann AK. 391 U.S. d00 (1996); Ceapylichi ys 7
constituted only 15 percent of the. total traffic of
carriers. The all-cargo carriers, which during 1947 acdounted
for. approximately haif of the total air freight volume]o! the.
. industry, “have been permitted to offer regular serYice us
common carriers only since June 10, 1947, the effecti¥e. date
of section 292.5 of the Economic Reégulations. . Experience
during the war demonstrated the physical possibility of carry-
ing substantial volumes of cargo ‘by air. Fur , thé develop-
ment of new aircraft and ‘improved o rating ptocedur:s
pointed to cost reductions which indicated thy feasibilrty ot
rate levels which would attract 4 substantial volume of cargu
traffic. In the light of these conditions, a group of new
. carriers undertook to develop @ specialized treight service
without dependence on Government support to cover possible
operating losses. The entry of these carriers into the dir
freight field on tkis basis constitutes an experiment of great
importance to the publie as.a test of whether a specialized air
freight industry can be developed on the basis of” its own -
* economic ability to -exist.” Air Freight ‘Rate Investigation,
9 C.A.B. 340, 344 (1948).
““The Board continued, through the year July 1, 1956-dun:
30, 1957, t@ issue exemption orders permitting transatlantic
passenger charter flights to .be Operated” by carriers nv!
otherwise possessing authority for’ such service. About Buv
of these flights were of the type where cust. is prorated among
the passengers. Each of these/ authorizations was subject to.
restrictions and safeguards designed to permit bona Na:
groups to-obtain the advantages ot low-cost traphatlantic ai:
transportation while at the same time. protecti . intes-
preg = hemi ticketed services provided by Ec Sens
he ne Some 35v other charter flights were authorized.
° these \t ie ee ‘entity’ type where the entire transporta-
_ tio 0 is borne by the chagtering organization. Most 0!
these latter were for the Intérgovernmental Committee for
European’ Migration, and inciuded many flights which carried
Hungarian refugees to the United States last winter.” 1997
C.A.B. ‘Annual Report 15-16.
Hoegh © BitceMiona, : ool U. S. $05 (1956); United States
v. Ryan, 350 U.S. 299 (1956). The holding of the court
below is entirely petri to’ the longstanding interpreta-
tion of the Board which is entitled to, but was errone-
ously given, ne weight.by the court) FHA v. The Rar-
lington, 27 ULS. L. W. 4015 (Nov. 24, 1958) ; “"NLAB vy.
Coca Cola Bottling Co., 300 FL S. 24h (1996); “Norwegian
Nitrogen Prod. Co. v. United States, 288 Us S. 294 (1953).
Under such circumstances involving important statutory
“uiterpretation, the Supreme Court’ will grant certiorart
FTC National oe Co, (8 S. Cte 1260 (1958);
Conley v. Gibson, 355° U. S. 41 (1997): LaBuy v. Mowe -
Leather Co., 352 US, 240 yooh 2 NLRB vo Track Drer-,
ks Local Union, 3 3 U S\RT 9ST; United Gas Rin
"Line Cd. v. Mobile Gds Strvi
NLRB v. Coca Cola Bottling
town Broadcasting Corp., 34970.
Swan, 346 1. 8." 427 (19953): FC
FS (1953).. ae
Corp. BOO US. 852 Ab):
‘og supra: FCC vy. Allen.
So 358 (1955). Wilke wv.
» RCA, 346 U.S. 86
CONCLUSION cae
; » .
~. For the foregoing reasons, this petition for certiorari
should be granted. 3 ee | .
a ie
- Respectfully submitted,
sh * Harpy K. Maciay
. Water D. Hassrs
Atiorneys for Petitioner.
~
° F
14
APPENDIX +.
UNITED STATES’ COURT OF APPEALS
Sas FOR_THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
* | No. 14497 5
ae Se
we" Pax American Wortp Aikways, Ixc., PETITIONER
ae
. m . ye Vv.
Civin AkRONACTICS Boakb, RESPONDENT
SeEaBuaRD AND Western AikLINES, INC.) INTERVENOR
‘No. 14506"
« . "St . -
Trans. Wortp ARLEN, TNc., PETITIONER
Civin Agno AUTICS Boanv, KESPONDE | ar
SEABOARD’ AND WESTERN AIRLINES, ING. INTERVENOR
eee , | 4
? aS —_—_—-
Petrrions ror Review of-ORDER OF THE
Civin AERONAUTICS Boarv.
a
Filed Nove mber ‘Ts, hs r+
Ur. Elihu Schott of the bar et the Court of Appeals of
New York, pro hac vice, by special leave of court, with
whom Me NSTS, He nru rf Friv ndly and Rohe rl (s. Barnard
_ Were on the brief, for petitioner in Np: 14497,
Mr. Henry P. Bevans, of the bar of the Court of Ap
aa of New York, pro hae rice, by special leave of Court,
*
¢ 15
with whom’ Messrs. George A. Spater, William: Caverly
and Charles Pickett were on the brief, for spaced in
‘No. 14506. °
Mr. O. D. Ozment, Assistant General Counsel, Litigation
and Research, Civil Aéronautics Board, with. whom’
“Messrs. Franklin M. Stone; General Counsel, Civil Aero-
* nautics Board, John H. Wanner,.Associate General Coun-
sel, Civil Aeronautics Board, and Henry Geller Attorney,
Department -of Justice, were on the brief, for respondent.
‘Mr. Morris Chertkov, ae Chief, Litigation and Re-
~ search, Civil Aeronautics. Boarf, ang Mr. Daniel M. Fried-
stice, a also oe ap-
pearances for respondent.
man, Attorney, Departiment
Mr, Hardy K. Maclay, Yith whom Mr. Walter D. Han-
Yen was on the brief, for intervenor.
' Before PRETTYMEN, Chief Yar and WiLBcR K. MILLER,
and Buroer, Circuit Judges.
Burcer, Circuit Judge: On May 16, 1938, the Civil
Aeronautics Board granted Seaboard and Western Air-
_ lines, Ine." (intervenor) an exemption under § 416(b). of
the ¢ ‘ivil Aeronauties Act, 52 Stat. 1004 (1938), 49 U.S.C.
“ $496(b).. This-grant permits Seaboard to carry United
States mail-across the Atlantic while the Board considers
and determines Sealfoard’s application for certificate
authority to carry such mail. Pan American World Air-
ways, Inc and Trans World Airlines, Inc.,* the only.
United States airlines presently certified for transatlantic
mail carriage, separately petitioned this court for review
of the exemption grant. Civil Aeronautics Act, ) 1006, 02°
Stat. 1024 (1938), 49 U-S.C. § 646.° The cases were con-
solidated and came on for hearing.”
<
> | Hereinafter called Seaboard. —
? Hereinafter called Pan American.
-* Hereinafter called TWA.
poh 16.
‘Both petitioners. contend that this exemption grant
contravenes the certification requirements of § 401 of the
Act, 52 Stat, 987 (1938),49 UMC. 9 481, because itis Lot
supported by requisite findings “TWA additionally. con-
tends that the exemption was invalid because it lacked the
President’s signature, Civil Aeronautics Act, § 801, 52
Stat. 1614 (1938), 49 U.S.C. §.601. . :
+ . .L-Presidential AQproval
We are obliged first to consider TWA’s contention that
the exemption authorization, which is ag ¢xemption from.
the requirement fur a certificate, is invalid because it did
not have presidential )approval under “$801 of the Act.
The Board and inteWenor urge such approval is not re-
quired. No court hds passed directly on this question.
Section 801 of tha Act deals in terms of “issuance,
denial, ‘transfer, ametklment, cancellation, suspension or
revocation of, and pe terms, ¢onditions, and limitations
contained in any’ certifiéate authorizing an air carrier to
engage in overseas or foreigngair transportation... .”
_ and these require ‘presidential &ipproval. The Waterman |
ecase* makes clear that Board action. affected- by this
provision (§ 801) is not subject to judicial review. Hence,
if § 801 applies, these petitions must be dismissed for lack
of jurisdiction. co ra |
We are not persuaded, howevey,\ tha an eremption
which-for a limited period authorizes ‘a chevies to. trans- g
port everseas mail between points already receiving certi-
fied cargo, service from the same carrier is subject to the
réstrictions of § S01. Section S01 contains no reference to
exemptions although, it recites explicitly a wholé series of
Board actions . relative ‘to certificates - affected by the
statute. True, the exemption has operative effects -not
unlike an amendment of a certifieate, but the extraordi-
‘Chicago. & Southern Air Lines; Inc. v. Waterman S.S. Corp. <
333 U.S. 103 (1948). * ‘6
nary power vested in the Executive by thi
not be expanded beyond the needs of the
considerations which have been relied on to justify the ©
grant. Chicago & Southern Air. Lines, Inc. v. Waterman
S.S..Corp., note 4 supra at 111. ; : i
These factors—the uniqueness of the statutory provi-
sion, its drastic impact, the precise definition of the stat-
ute, and the Board’s interpretatiorfs fortify the conclu-
sion that Congress did not intend to include exemptions
- in §801. The enduring and continuing character—of the
operations under a certificate as contrasted with the
temporary and limited character of the exemption supply
the.mnost important basis for distinction.” y
ll.—Validity of the fixemption
» Section 416(b) of the Act* permits the Board to exem}
an dir carrier from the certificate requirements of § 401 if,.
but only if it first finds that enforcenient of those requifre-
ments would have certain specified results because of the
existence of certain specified conditions. The Board must
find that the “operations” of the air carrier seeking the
-exemption are either (1) of “limited extent” or (2) af-
fected by rie ciyeymstances.” Aside from ‘finding
that one of th se $0 ditions ix present, the Board must
also find that that Kondition causes enforcement of the
certificate requirgeffents to. work “an undue burden” on the ~
carrier. Fingtf, the Board inust find that enforcement ‘of
the reqy#fcments “is riot in the public interest.” In the
absence of any one of these findings the Board is not
authorized to suspend the normal statutory requirements
_ 5“The Board... may .. . exempt fram the requirements of
* this subchapter or any provision thereof ... any air carrier...
‘ if it finds that ‘the enforcement of this subchapter or such pro-
vision . . . is or would be an undue burden on such air carrier ...-
by reason of the limited extent of, or- unusual circymstances
affecting, the operations of such air carrier .. . and is not in the’
public interest.” 52 Stat. 1004 (1938), #9 U.S.C. § 496(b)(1)..
. oe
o*
of notice, heoring and requisite findings for issuance of a
» Certificate of public convenience and necessity.
Nor may these’ findings be merely a recital of § 416(b). .
The Board, “must, find what the statute requires it to find,
notin, conclusory fashion-in the statutory language but in
such fashion that a reviewing court can test the validity
» of the finding.” American Airlines, Inc. vy. CAB, 98
US. App.D.C. 348, 356, 235 F.2d 845, 853 (1956).
The Beard’s findings in this casé are short. and some-
what cursory, consisting of but three paragraphs. It found
that “Neaboard’s financial situation is acute,” and that
" .“Seaboard’s existence ;is in jeopardy.” — no further
preliminaries it found that
‘To deprive the carrier of the spinciaiaits to earn
* these revenues [from mail carriage] pending decision
on-its certificate application would imposé an undue
burden on it and’ would uot be in the public interest.
lt. found that -the diversion’ of mail revenues from Pan
American and, TWA would be slight but that “the benefit
to Seaboard ® be relatively substantial.” From these
premises the Board concluded “that the authority con-
ferred by exemption is limited in extent and in the public
interest. ”* Finally the Board's order recited the language.
of §416(b) in concluding that the exemption should be
granted acs a
W ithout considgring the problem of whether’ these find.
ings are supported by thy record, we Hold them inadequate
to meet the statutory requirements. The “undue burden” -
the Board has found is deprivation of revenues during the
course, of certificdtion proceedings. This “burden” is found
io be “undue” because of the financial straits in) which
Seaboard finds itself. Obviously, any carrier not granted
®“The Board seems to have misunderstood the “limited extent”
requirement. The statute does not refer to ‘the limited extent of
the exemption itself; instead it refers to a pre-existing conditich
of the ¢arrier’¢ sa rarnaaal that qualifies it for an ‘exemption.
,
oe
ia ab? ’ - ”
an exemption will be “deprived” of an oportunity. to earn.
revenues from a particular carriage until it is awarded a
certificate therefor.. The Board has found oniy one c.
~~ oomstance here that. is not present jn every certificatiyn
| proceeding : Seaboard’s financial distress. This is insufti-
cieng If Congress’ liad wanted’ to :exclude economically
marginal carriers from certification requirements, it would
have done so in ,more explicit terms than» those of ©
5 416(b)." OF course, an unusual circumstance which
‘vauses financial distress may be suclr a ciréumstance as to
warrant relief under this exemption provision. But finan-
cial distress, in and of itself, unrelated to circumstances
which wpuld render the carrier eligible, is net enoygh. —
‘In the /Surface Mail Exrgerimental Case awe upheld an.
exemptign: grant, but,even there the decision was closé*
‘under c/rcumstances far more vompelling, than those ere.
That exemption permitted certain ail-cargo ait carriets to
participate in a Post Office experiment to’ determine
whether it would be economical and feasible to send some
surface mail by air. It was found that certification pro-
ceedings, even on’ an interim. basis, could not be completed
in time. to enable the exempted carriers to participate in
the experiment. The court plainly relied heavily ot this
finding, and Judge ‘Prettyman in concurring said: “In
such event denial, of an exemption would’ be a total and
me)
.
- TIt is pertinent that, when Seaboard wae initially given a trans-
atlantic cargo certificate, the Board: said: . “. — ke
“Since the service will not, be subsidized, it becomes a matter ee Bes
for the new carrier and its shareholders to determine whether *\~ :
s as a matter of business judgment it desires to venture its
° capital in this enterprise .... sic} All, of the applicants Yire
fully awage of thé attendant risks, and all are actitely seek irky e
: the opportunity {tq prove the economic feasibility of this
venture.” Transatlantic Cargo Case, Ordér Nos £-9311, CCH
—AV.L.REP. (CAB Cas. 1954-57) * 21,845.02 at 14,310 (1955).
* American Airlines, Inc. ‘v. CAB, 97, U.S:App.D.C. 324, 231
F.2d 483, (1956). |
" er 4
eae
final deprivation of participation. That is not the case in
the usual application for exemption.” *°
7% c
Additionally, in the® Surface Mail Experiment. Case the
' « Post Office revtommended an exemption, reasoning $f \t
_ (8) additional mail volunm was anticipated; (b) the cigs
- ¢arriers would provide protection against service interrup-
tions; ,apd (¢). by ‘participation: in the experiment the
carriers” would gain vatuable- experience. In the present
_ case the Post Office has taken a position that at best might
_ be ‘called neutral. Et has said that “there is more capacity
than currently pag for the transportation of airmail +
from ‘the New Yobk Gateway to Kuropean points and
consequently there is not the peculiar need for exemption
Which existed because of ‘the airlift experiment .°; . .”
These comments by the Post - Office Department tend to
weaken the Board’s conclusory finding in ‘this case that
‘enforcement of the certificate requirements would not be
in the public interest. It is not ‘necessary: to hold, how-
— ever, that, this finding has “no rational basis.” We hold*
only that financial distress is Bot a circumstance which,
( , Standing alone, meets the requirements of §416(b)... Ac. +
- cordingly, we set aside the order granting. an exemption
to Seaboard... : ‘
Order Set Aside, -
Os
°97 U.S.App.D.C. at 329, 231 F.2d at 488.
° | . $ - evs
“21 ‘
APPENDIX B
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA — UIT
ae September Term 1958
— * No. 14,497.
Pan AMERICAN Worup Arrways,. [Nc., PETITIONER
_V. . | |
Civin AERONAUTICS BoarD, RESPONDENT
Seaspoarp & WesTERN ‘AIRLINES, INC., INTERVENOR
°
No. 14,506 ,
Trans Wortp ArruiNes, Lvc., PETITIONER te
; oe. ve 2
Civi, AERONAUTICS ‘Boarp, RESPONDENT
Cree & WesTERN AIRLINES, Ixc,, INTERVENOR
Before Pearenisn, Chief Judge, ‘and W ILBUR KX. MILLER,
and Burcer, Circuit Judges.
. Dated: NOVEMBER 14, 1958
_ ORDER.
The above- eutttled eases came on to be on on the
record from the Civil Aeronautics Board and w vere argued
hy counsel. ad
ON CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, it is ORDERED”
by the court that the order of the Civil Aeronautics Board
on review in these cases is hereby set aside. ne —.
Will be filed later..
‘It is FURTHER ORDE RED by the court that’s a’ cer-
tified copy of this order issue forthwith tg the Civil Aero-
nautics Board. ;
#, Per Curiam.
e-
a
e
29
APPENDIX ¢
RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF . — ‘
CIVIL AERONAUTICS ACT ~~
See. 2. [52 Stat. 980, as amended,.49 U.S.C. § 402} In
the exercise and performance of its Qowers ‘and duties.
under this Act, the Authority shall consider the follow.
ing, among other things, as being in the publie interest,
and in accordance with the ublie convenience and néces-
sitv—
(a) The eneouragement and development of an air
transportation system properly adapted: fo the present
and future neegls of the foreign and domestic. commerce
_ of the United States, of the Postal Service, and. of the
national defense; : eee
(b) . The regulation of air transportation in such man-
ner as to recognize and preserve the inherent advantaves
of, assure the highest degree of safety. in, and foster
sound economic conditions in, such transportation, and
to improve the relations between, and coordinate trans-
‘portation by, air carriers: :
’
ce) The promotion of adequate, economical, and effi-
cient service by air carriers' at reasonable charges, with-
out unjust diseyiminations, undue preferences or advan-
tages, or unfair or destructive competitive practices:
(d}@Competition to the extent neeessary ‘to assure
the sound development. of an air-transportation system
properly adapted to the needs of the foreign and: domestic
commerce of the United States. of the Postal Service,
and of the national defense: : | | ‘
{®) ‘The reenlation of air commerce and m sueh mai
ner as to hest promotes its development and safety: and
-(f) The encouragement and development df civil nero-
nauties. : ‘phi
quired by the public convenience and necessit
3. : . Oe
Z) e e ° al
See. 401 (52. Stat. .987, as amended, A9 US.C. § 481]
(a) No air carrier shall erigage in any air transportation
unless there is in force a certificate issued by the ‘Au-
thority authorizing such air carrier to engage in such
: transportation. . . . ~~. J
: ® >» _ as e a) ;
(a) (1) The Authority ‘shall issue a ieetificate au- .
thorizirig the whole or any part of the transportation .
covered by the application, if it finds that the applicant
is fit, willing, and able to perform such transportation
properly, and to conform to the provisions. of this Act
and the rules, regulations, and requirements of the Au-
thority ferennder, and that such’ = is re-
: - otherwise
‘such application shall be denied.
tz) ts the case of an application for a ouitifieate to
engage in temporarye air transpértation, the Authority
may issue a certificate authorizing ‘the whole or any. part
thereof for such limited periods as nfay’ be -required by
the publie convenience and. necessity, if it finds that the
applicant is fit, willing, and - able properly to perform
such transportation and to conform to the provisions of *
this Act and the rulés, regulations, and —— of
the Authority hereunder.
a fy ‘The _ Authority, - ‘upon petition or complaint or
upon its own initiative, after notice and hearing; may. |
alter, amend, modify, or suspend any such certificate, in
whole or in part, if the public convenience and necessity
80 require, or may revoke any such certificate, in whole
or in part, for intentional failure to comply with, any pro:
vision of this tifle or any order, rule, or regulation issued
hereunder. or any term, condition or limitation of such
certificate... .
oe @ ..
ze
Sec. 416. .{52: Stat. 1004, as amended, 49 USC. } 496]
(a) The Authority. may from time to time. establish
such just and reasonable classifications or groups of air
carriers for the purposes of this- .tifle as the nature of
‘the services ‘performed by such air carriers shall require;
and. such just and reasonable rules, and. regulations, pur-
suant to and consistent with the provisions of this title, °
to be observed by each such class or group, as the Au-
thority finds necessary in the public interest.
| (b) (1) The Authority, from’ time to tines and to
the extent necessary, may (except as provided in para-
graph (2) of this subsection) exempt. from thee require-
ments of this title or any provision thereof, or any rule,
i regulation, term, condition, or limitation prescribed. there.
‘udder, any air carrier or class of. air carriers, if it finds
that the enforcement of this title or such provisions, or
such rule, regulation, term, condition, or limitation is
or would be.an undue burden, on sueh air carrier or
class of air carriers by reason of’ the limited: extent of.
or unusual circumstances affecting, the operations of
such air carrier or class of air carriers and is not »
@
the public interest. Po toesee it 7 an
(2) The Authority’ shall not exempt any air carrier
from any provision of subsection (1) of section 401.
this title, except that (A) any air carrier not amy *
in sobedatel air transportatfon, and (B), to the extent
that the’ operations of: such .air carrier: are conducted
during daylight hours, any air carrier engaged in sched-
uled air transportation, may be exempted. frotn the pro-
-Visions of paragraphs (1) and (2) of such subsection if
the Authority finds, after notice and hearing, that. by
reason of the limited extent of. or unusual eireumstatces
affectinig> the: operations of any such air carrier, the en-
forcement. of such paragraphs . is or would he such an
undue burden on such air earrier as to abstruct its devel-
opment and prevent it. from beginning or continuing
25
operations, and that the exemption ‘of such air carrier
from such paragraphs would not. adversely affect’ the
public interest: Provided, That nothing in this subsection
shall be deemed to aythorize the Authority to exempt any
air carrier from any requirement of this: title, or any-pro-
vision thereof, or any rule, regulation, term,’ condition,
| or limitation prescribed théreunder which provides for.
maxitnum flying hours: for pilots or éopilots.
o>
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.