Brief and Appendix for Appellant — Slade v. Board of Education (No. 999)
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
LIPRARY on
bce ale gi
No. QO > S. !
Arh!
United States Cuurt of Appeals
For the Fourth Circuit
ROSALIND SLADE,
A ppe liand,
SCHOOL BOARD OF HARFORD COUNTY,
A ppe lee.
BRIEF AND APPENDIX FOR APPELLANT
Titrkcoop MarsHai,
107 West 43rd Street,
New York, N. Y..
Teeker R. Dearne,
627 Aisquith Street,
Baltimore, Md.,
F i a E D Juanita ot. MircHenr,
1239 Druid Hill Avenue,
ay Baltimore, Md.,
Ronee? B. arm,
1520 E. Monument Street,
RM. F. ‘WILLIAMS, SR Baltimore, Md.,
C_ERSX .
Jack GREENBERG,
107 West 43rd Street,
New York, N. Y..
Counsel for App Hlant.
Irma Rossins Fever,
af Counsel,
INDEX TO BRIEF
CS TONNE ERT, Pelee
Statement
Argument
S48. S 6 D-S- 2 25 OO 8-8. @ C.D 2 Oa 64. O18 a 610 6 216.454 4 oe Oe Oe
Table of Cases
Aaron v. Cooper, 243 F. 2d 361 (C. A. 8th 1957)
Booker v. Tennessee Board of Education, 240 F. 2d
GOD (Cth Cis. THETA cee
Brown v. Board of Edueation, 349 U.S. 294
(‘lemons v. Board of Education of Hillsboro, 228 F.
2d 853 (6th Cir., 1956), eert. denied 350 U.S.
ROM oo irda ats ene RC ee eee nee
Dann v. Board of Education of Greenbrier. 1 Ro Rel.
L. Rep: 319 (2 DS. Varese) oS
Garnett v. Oakley, 2 R. Rel. L. Rep. 303 (W. D. Ky.,
SG Te a ee ey
Jackson v. Rawdon, 235 F. 2d 93 (Sth Cir. 1956).
cert. denied 352 U.S. 925
Ve a we i tne Oe ee ae ee et
Kelley v. Board of Education of the City of Nash
Ville, 2. R. Rel. L. Rep. 21 (M.D. Tenn. 1957) |
Mitchell v. Polloek, 2 R. Rel. L Rep. 305 (WD. Ky.
1957) YN BH meatier e So hh
Pierce v. Board of Education of Cabell Counts
(SoD. Wl Val 1956. unreported)
School Board of the (itv of Charlottesville +. Addea,
40 F.2d 59 (4th Cir., 1957). eert. denied 3523 U. s.
410
1]
1]
1]
10
School Board of the City of Newport News v. Adkins,
946 F. 2d 320 (C. A. 4th, 1957), cert. denied
— U.S. —
6 64 be 6.6, 8 2S SE Oe ae Se 6 Re ee De ee
Shedd v. Board of Education of County of Logan,
i 8. Rel. 1. Rep. 323-{8. D. W. Va. 1906) 2.2...
Taylor v. Board of Education of County of Haleigh,
1 BR. Bet. f. Rep. Sob Re aow Va. 1996)
Willis v. Walker, 156 F.Supp. 177 (W. DL Key. 1955)
Other Authority
Black, Paths to Desegregation, New Republic, Octo-
ee SE ae oe ee ee a ee a a
ue og os Oe re oer ee a et eae
Opinion of November 25, 195600...
CVs Ole 6 ek ae ke a ae
Opinion of June 20, 1957
Excerpts from Testimony ..0...... SSue met Ceeeea
Charles W. Willis:
OGRE eee eee ea oa
{ ‘TOSS
hixcerpts from: Phaimtitf’s exhibit) lea
PAGE
10)
10
PAGE
la
4a
l6a
26a
eta tate 26a, 36a
Ba
$a
Question Presented
Whether appellants were denied rights secured by the
Fourteenth Amendment when the court below permitted
appellees” school sVstem to defer desegregation of certain
schools and grades for one to three years and prolong high
school desegregation until 1965 on a ‘stair step** basis
fexeept for Negro students who might be admitted tmime-
diately upon passage of special examinations) where appel
joes did not sustain the burden of demonstrating the neces
sity for sueh delay?
_
Statement
This cause commenced with an earlier (separate) action.
See 146 F. Supp. 91, brought on behalf of some of the
appellants here to desegregate the schools in Harford
County. Two da s betore that cause came to trial appellees
adopted a resolution stating that
‘any child regardless of race may make individual
application to the Board of Edueation to be admitted
to a schoo! other than the one attended by such child,
and the admissions to be granted by the Board of
Edueation in accordance with such rules and regula-
tions as it may adopt and in accordance with the
available facilities in such schools, effective for the
school year beginning September, 1956."° 146 F.
Supp. at p. 93.
Counsel for the Board asserted that ‘Since that plan
embraces the relief prayed for, | think that takes care of
that...’ Id. at p. 94. Relying on the Resolution, appel-
lants agreed to dismiss the action, and believed the con-
troversy concluded. [bid. (The court concurred in their
interpretation and iater, in a fresh suit (the instant one)
to require desegregation of the county's schools, wrote that
‘plaintiffs were justified in believing, as 1 did, that apph-
-eations for transfer would be considered without regard
to the race of the applicant."* 102 F. Supp. at p. 119. The
Court therefore held appellees estopped te prevent admis-
sion without regard to race of individual named plaintiffs
in the first suit. Jed. at 119-120. The estoppel phase of the
suit is not ai issue here and ts set forth as background )
Ou June 6, 1956 the Board annonneed its ‘* Transfer
Policy.” It reserved “the right during the period of
transition to delay or deny the admission of a pupil to any
school, if it deems such action wise and necessary for any
vood and sufficrent reason.’* 146 F. Supp. at p. 94.
On August 1, 1956 it adopted a™ Dosevregation Poliey.”’
Citing studies which allegedly indicated ‘lowering of
school standards ** upon desegregation and experience of
other areas with ‘‘bitter local opposition’? which prevents
“orderly transition... and also adversely affects the
shole educational program.” 146 F. Supp at p. 95, the
sonrd announced that it would only permit Negro appli-
eants for transfer to attend the first three grades of two
elementary schools in the county, Id. at p. 95. The reason
for selection of these schools was that they were, with
some slight exception, allegedly ‘tthe only elementary
buildings in which space is available for additional pupils
at the present time.” The Board relied, too, on **{sjocial
problems posed by the desegregation of schools. ...°” These,
it opined *tean be solved with the least emotionalism when
vounger children are invelved. The future rate of expan
“ion of this pregram,”* it concluded ‘tdepends apon the
cuceess of these initial steps.” Thid.,
Altogether sixty Negro children had applied for trans-
fer under the impression that ne racial distinctions were
tobe made. There were, at the time, about 1400 Negro and
12.600 white children in’ the school population. Of the
sixty npplicants fifteen were admitted and forty-five re-
jected pursuant to the *Desegregation Poliey* CApp. pp-
MGa-J7a).
Appellants, therefore, on Aneust 28, 1956, filed a fresh
suit alleging that defendants were under constitutional
duty to desegregate completely and that they were estopped
from retreating from their o1 iwinal resolution. (The Court
round an estoppel as to named plaintiffs, but held that the
County poliey, venerally, could not be fixed by estoppel.
Applicants here urge only their constitutional position. )
The trial court remitted appellant. to an administrative
remedy before the State Board of Education.
The appellants (ineluding intervenors who were eranted
leave to intervene, 1a2 FL Supp. at p- 115) tiled an appeal
with the State Board, While tt wa- pending appellers
ww
changed their policy once more on February 6, 1997. The
new policy provided that:
Applications for transter will be accepted from
pupils who wish to attend elementary schools in the
areas Where they live, if space is available in such
schools. Space will be considered available in schools
that were not more than tO overcrowded as of
February 1, 1957. All capacities are based on the
state and national standard ef thiriy pupils per
classroom, 102 F. Supp. at p. 116.
Under the then newest plain five elementary schools
and the sixth grade in two schools were opened. [bid.
The State Board held that the plan had been adopted in
good faith and constituted a reasonable start. [bid.
At a hearing of this cause on April 18, 1957 the plan of
February 6 was amplified to include ten elementary schools
and the sixth grade in one school; as well as three elemen-
tary schools as of September 1958, when contemplated con-
struction was projected to be completed. Three elementary
schools and the sixth grade of a high school would commence
receiving Negroes’ applications in September 199,
As a normal resalt of the plan, the Board observed,
sixth grade graduates would have been ‘tadmitted to Junior
high schools for the first time in September, 1958 and
would proceed through high schools in the next higher
wrade each vear. This will completely desegregate all
schools of Harford County by September, 1963.7" 152 F.
Supp. at p. 117.
At the April, 1957 hearing, the Court ruled tentatively
that the plan was ‘‘generally satisfactory for the elemen-
tary grades but not for the high school grades."" [bid.
Another hearing was scheduled for June 11, 1997. On
June Sth. the Board changed its plan onee more and noti-
fied the parties of the change just before the hearing.
(App. p. 39a). The new ylan——consisting of additions to
cr
the old—would permit Negro children to enter high school
hy a route additional to that of the esrtier plan Owhereby
they could enter ouly through uwermal promotions from
desegregated elementary schools). It would permit Negro
children to take special examinations and he spectally
evaluated for admission to nensegregated high schools,
192 KF. Supp. at 117; white children, and Negro children
entering Via the high school plan designed to evolve during
1958-1963, would not be required to take these tests. Under
the revised plan complete desegregation of the’ seventh
erade, however, was still deferred until September, Pos.
192 F. Supp. at 119.
The reason given for the seheme of desegregating the
high schools over a period of four years in conjunetion
with thie right of ~pecially qualified Negro applicants to
enter starting immediately, as summarized by the Court,
Was :
when a child transfers to a high school from
another high school he faces certain problems which
do not arise When he enters the seventh grade, which
‘< the lowest grade in the Harford County high
schools. After a year or so in the high schools so-
cial groups, athletic groups and subject-interest
eroups have begun to erystallize, friendships and at-
tachments have been made, cliques have begun to
develop. A child transferring to the school from
another high school does not have the support of a
croup Which whom he has passed through elementary
echool. A Negro child transferring to an upper grade
at this time would not have the benefit of older
brothers, sisters or cousins already in the school, or
parents, relatives or friends who have been active
inthe P.T. A. High school teachers generally, with
notable exeeptions, are less ‘pupil conscious’ and
more ‘subject conscious’ than teachers trained tor
elementary grades, and because each teacher has
the class for only one or two subjects, are Jess tikelv
to help in the readjustment. lo2 F. Supp. at p- 11s.
The pertinent parts of the plan of the scheol board,
viewed as a whole, as of the iast hearing. and as embodted
in the Court’s order from whieh plaintiffs appeal, are now
as follows: |
1. Defendants now and hereafter shall accept
applications for admission or transfer to all ele
mentary classes under their control (except in the
schools named in paragraph 2 as to which applica
tions will be accepted as deseribed in that para-
graph), in accordance with rules and regulations set
forth in paragraph 3 and every Negro child's ap.
plication to classes governed by the instant para
graph shall be considered and granted on the basis
upon which it would be considered and yranted if
he were white.
2 Defendants shall accept Negro children’s ap-
plications for admission or transfer to Old Post Road,
Bel Air and Highland elementary schools for the
school year 1958-1959 and thereafter; and shall ac-
cept Negro children’s applications for admission or
transfer to Forest Hill, Jarrettsville and Dublin ele-
mentary schools and the sixth grade at Edgewood
High School for the school year 1959-1960 and there.
after. Every Negro child's application to the schools
named in this paragraph for the respective schoo!
years specified herein and thereafter shall be con-
sidered and granted on the basis upon which it would
be considered and granted if he were white.
3. All applications for transfer to elementary
classes shall be made during the month of May on a
regular application form furnished by the Board ot
Education and must be approved by the applicant's
classroom teacher and the principal of the school the
applicant attends. Such applications will be re-
viewed at the regular June meeting of (he Board of
Education. Applicants and their parents wis be in-
formed of the action taken on applications prior to
the close of school in June of each vear. In no event
shall a Negro child's application for admission or
transfer be rejected if it would have been granted
had he been white.
4. A Negro child’s applieation for admission or
transfer to seventh grade classes commencing Sep
~4
tember. 1058. and thereafter, under defendant's con
trol shall be considered and granted on the bast= apon
whieh it would be considered aiad granted if he were
white, Such applications to the following classc-
shall he so treated during and after the vear set forth
alonyside the class, as follows:
eighth grade — Io
ninth grade —~ 1900
tenth wrade — 1961
eleventh grade liwiz
twelfth grade —— 163
In 1063 and therafter all Negro apolicants to al
classes shall be admitted on the same basi- upen
which they would be admitted if they were white
>. Commencing September, 157 application toy
wimission or transfer by Negro children not qualitied
for admission or transfer under paragraph 4 to hich
schools under defendants* coutrol will be considered
and granted if the applieants fulfill special qualities
tions pertaining to the probability of succes. of each
individual pupil. These qualifications will be mea.
sured by intelligence and achievement tests, grade
level achievements and other similar matters to be
adjudged by a committee consisting of the principal-
of the schools from which the pupil is transterring
and the <chool to which he desires to transfer, the
Director of Tustruction and the county supervisers
working in these schools. Apart from the fact that
these conditions may be applied oniy to Negro stu
dents not qualified for admission under paragraph 4
no racial distinetionds to be made in the administra
tion of these tests and evaluations. Sach application-
may be made to the Board of Education between July
land Jnty 14 of 1957 and vears following in which
these tests may be given,
7. No racial distinetions whatsoever shall le
made bey defendants in treating Negro children whe
have been admitted to schools pursuant to this decree,
(Ngep. Laaca)
The record reveals that problems of overcrowding,
pupil adjustment, ete. would not stand im the way of free
transfer for white chiidren who had never attended the
Harford County schools before and who moved into the
county:
“QQ. (By Mr. Greenberg) Tf white persons moved
hor Wilawaie or Wren an ew iane mad tie
Harford County, that is at the present time, such
as to work in an industrial plant, would their children
be admitted to the schools at the present time?
A. (By Mr. Willis. Superintendent of Senools)
Yes, sir, they would."’ (App. p. 29a)
See also App. Ra.
Moreover, whatever may be said of overerowding it
was not so severe that the Subcommittee on Facilities of
appellees’ Citizens Consultant Committee on Integration
could not conclude: ‘the committee is of the opinion that
provision can be made to aecommodate such colered
students as apply for admission to Harford County public
schoois for the vear 1956-57."" (Plaintitfs’ Exhibit) L-a.
App. p. 44a)
The reeord further shows that deferring desegregation
of the seventh grade is without even purported justifica
tion:
“The Court: Why can’t you admit a child to
the seventh wrade in Mor?
“The Witness: (Mr. Willis) |} can’t say why.
veur Loner, but the poliey was moving forward
three vears, and that was all.’ (App. pp. doa-36a)
“The Court: It ais a poliey reason and -there ts
no administrative reason Why you say the seventh
gerade in 1958 and not the eighth rade also, that 1
is only poliey reasons.
‘The Witness (Mr. Willis): The oniy extension
of the poltey that has heen accepted for the reason-
that have been given.
“The Court: And no administrative reasone?
“The Witness: Well, T won't say none, but at
the moment TL don’t think of any hiv one, let's put it
that wav.’ (App ppp. O6a-57a)
-
The Board’s plans were based not only on the allewed
considerations set forth above, but on apprehension that
proceeding otherwise might provoke public demonstrations
or oppesition like some which oceurred in) Delaware and
elsewhere, CApp. pp. 30a, 37a, see 146 F. Supp. at p. 95.)
Argument
Brown v. Board of Education, 349 U.S, 294 sets forth
the only standards coneerning What constitutes ‘deliberate
speed **: (a) “plaintiffs? ... admission to public schools
as soon as practicable on a nondiseriminatory basis’*; and
Ob) that ‘*|t}he burden rests upon the defendant to estab
lish that such jadditional| time is necessary in the public
interest and is consistent ith vood faith compliance at
the earliest practicable date" 34) U.S. at p. 300. While
the need to solve administrative problesis may he Geeasion
for delay, and plans inthe first Instanee are to he formulated
by school bor.ds, ‘the vitality of these conustitutiona!
principles cannot he allowed to vield) simpiy beeause oft
Hsggreement with them. * Thi.
The seeond Brown opinion has been considered by
District Courts and Courts of Appeals on a number of
occasions. In this Cireurt, district courts have ordered
complete desegregation by the next school year or term
in Charlottesville.! Ariington. Newport News * and Not
folk.) where loeal school officials had taken to steps what
ever towards desegregation, and, this Court has affirmed.
Moreover, ina series of West Vir vinia District Court ease-
in this Cirenit involving plans. ove rerowding, fiseal prob
lems. and time fer consideration, have been rejected: as
erounds for delay when it Wa clear that Negro children
School Hoard of the City of Charlott 40 2
Sy (4th Cir, 195705 cert den. 333 U.S. “ae
- fhud
i Sehool Reard «of fhe Cat tf Newport Virth ’ lik BPt
E24 325 1C. A. 4th 10571; cert. det Ee
‘find
10
could be admitted wotwithstanding the proferred reasons
for deferment. Shedd vy. Board of Education of County
of Logan, 1 R. Rel. L. Rep 521 (S. D. W. Va. 1956); Dunn
v. Board of Education of Greenbrier, VR. Ret. I. Rep. 349
(S. D. W. Va. 1956); Taylor v. Board of Education of
County of Raleigh, 1 Rel. L. Rep. 321 (8. D. W. Va. 1956);
Pierce v. Board of Education of Cabell County (S. 1.
W. Va. 1956, unreported). These cases have treated over:
erowding not as a racial problem but as a spatial one.
If there were to be a shortage of space, admissions could
be eonditioned on’ room being available—hut not on a
racial basis as appellees have done.
(Of course, such decisions did not outlaw the application
of normal transfer eriteria. But, in this case, the Negro
children barred by the Harford plan may not use normal
‘transfer procedure. )
Other jurisdictions which have reviewed plans divide
into two principal categories: on the one hand, eases in-
volving plans of districts in Kentucky, Ohio and the state
colleges of Tennessee; on the other, plans involving schools
in Arkansas and Nashville. The first group of eases ha-
uniformly rejected delay based upon overcrowding, fisca:
problems, transportation diffeulties and other administra.
tive considerations where it could net be shown that these
actually were a bar to admitting Negro applicants.
In other words, the courts held that it was uot enough
that problems existed: they eould not defer desegregation
nniess the burden of showing why time was required could
he met. In Willis v. Waiker, 186 F. Supp. 1 (W. D. Ky.
1955) the court pointed out that **no white children cithe:
before or after the application for admission of the plam
tiffs, were denied admission” and that ‘‘good faith alon
is not the test. There must be ‘compliance at the earliest
Ce Ne ileal
en
11
practicable date.’ °° 136 F.Supp. at p. 151 Desegregation
was ordered by the next school year.”
Moreover in Clemons V. Board ot bed ation of Hilishoro,
wos FF 2d 893 (6th Cir, Gob) cert. denied 350 U. S. 1006,
the Court of Appeals held that where as here, white chil-
dren were not rejqeeted during alleged overcrowding de
segregation could not be delaved for that reason. See also
Booker v. Tennessee Roara ut Kiducation, 240) I. Hd ost
eth Cir. 1957) cert. den. 1 TL. Kd. 2d lo reaffirming that
race May not be used as a standard to deal with crowded
conditions,
The second group of cases has approved plans riinine
into perhaps six years on thre basis of a reeital of problem
iy school administration. But there has been uo effort by
appellees in the instant case to catalogue in detail as prob
ems in Harford County the list of avowed reasons for delay
prottered in Aaron ve Cooper, 45 8 hh 36) (C. A. 8th,
1457) one of the cases justifymeg delay :
Foremost among the problems of the Little Rock
School District are those of finances, structural or-
canization, enrollment, and the seleetion and train-
ing of an adequate staff, These problems are not
new, but they will be greatly accentuated by mtegra-
tion. By its plan the School Board is seeking to in-
tegrate its schools and at the same time miaintait or
improve the quality of edueation available at these
schools. Some of its objectives are to provide the
fest possible education that is economically feasible,
te consider each child in the light of his individual
ability and achievement, to foster sound promotion
ee
‘
® See also Gorden v. Collins, 2k. Rel. L.. Rep. 304 W. D. Ws
1957) ‘(court rejecting alleged reasons tor delay which
vercrowding, transportation ditieulties, reallocation problems, nee
for time to study the problems, unfavorable social conditions; the
sesition of defendants ts unreported y: Mitchell v. f’ollock IR. Rel
> - A ‘ - = ‘
Ren. 305 ( W.. Dodsy., 49979. (IRIECMnS sinniar grounds tor de-
lat and see. for the same considerations and holding Gurnelt
lakley, 2 K. Rel 1 Rep. 303° (WD BY 1957)
12
policies, to provide necessary Hexibility in the schoo)
curriculum from one attendance area to another, to
select, procure, and train an adequate schoo! staf?,
to provide necessary in-service training for the
school staff, to provide a necessary educational pro-
gram for deviates (mentally retarded, physically
handicapped, speech correction, etc.), to provide the
opportunity for children to attend school in the at-
tendance area where they reside, to fosver sucnd ac.
ministrative practices, to maintaim extra-curricular
activities, to attempt to provide imformation neces.
sary for public understanding, acceptance and sup-
port, and to provide a ‘‘teachable* group of chi!
dren for each teacher. With regard to the later ol:
jective, it is the policy of the Board to group ehul-
dren with enough homogeneity for efficient planning
and classroom management. 143 F. Supp. at p.
860.°
Appellants submit that the alleged impedimenta prof
ferred by appellees for delay herein have not only been
rejected in the largest number of cases where considerd bys
the courts, but in those cases where reasons for delay have
been held sufficient the barriers have surpassed in com
plexity those advanced here.
The appellees are not in the dark as to how many Negro
applicants they may expeet: about 60 in a school system
of 14.000 children; at least 15 of these already have bee
admitted.
Their argument about overcrowding becomes meaning
less in view of this small number, when at the same tim
they concede that comparable white ehicdren transferring
6 The Nashville (Kelley v. Board of Education of the City o!
Nashville), 2 R. Rel. L. Rep. 21 (M.D. Tenn. 1957) deiay was found
to have been justified by “numerous administrative problems, 1
cluding increased difficulty in procuring and retaming teachers, teach
ing adjustments required because of differences mi achievement
levels of students among Negro and white children, problems arisiny
from a liberalized student transfer system supplanting a strict
transier systern, as well as other problems
‘
at
from out of the jurisdiction will be admitied, As to de-
ferring desegregation of the seventh rade they are at a
joss even to advance a reason. With respect to the high
schools they urge only that high school work is se allen
from earlier educational experience that Negroes must ©
‘ntroduced a few at a time so that there will be others with
whom they eau associate. But white children too meet novel
situations im high school, and tt defies experience to deny
that Negro children will mitke friends with their white
classmates.
The chief administrative problem that appellees have
experienced has been the formulation and reformulation
of so many plans. The clear imfcrence from the record
has been that the sole reason tor delay has been reluctance
to admit Negro children, not difficulties recognized by the
Supreme Court's decision. Indeed appellees have stated
on a number of occasions that they have put off desegrega-
tion because of fear of opposition. But compare, Jackson
v. Rawdon, 235 F. 2d 95 (oth Cir. 1956), cert. den. 3o2
U.S. 025. While one may net view lightly the attitudina:
contlict that may accompany revisien of school procedures
to comply with the Fourteenth Amendment, still the law
has recognized some and rejected other grounds for delay.
It does not recognize reluctance or social difficuities. More-
over, as Professor Charles Black, probabiy the most per-
ceptive commentator on the subject has demonstrated,
submitting to community opposition does not create the
acquiescence that purperts to justify deferring or denying
the rights of rejected Negro children pending the-delay.
Black, Paths to Desegregation, New Republic, October 21,
1957, p. 10.
Wreneronk it is respeetfuily cabmitted that the jreds
ment below be reversed and appellees be required to cease
if
denying appellants their constitutional rights by the
beginning of the next school term.
Respectfully submitted,
Tuercoop MARSHALL,
107 West 43rd Street,
New York, N. Y..,
Trekker R. DeaRINnG,
627 Aisquith Street,
Baltimore, Md.,
Juanita J. Mitcueny,
1230 Druid Hill Avenue,
Baltimore, Md.,
Ronert B. Warts,
1520 EK. Monument Street,
Baltimore, Md.,
Jack GREENBERG,
107 West 43rd Street,
New York, N.Y.
(ene l for A pope lant.
leMA RospBiN-= Feper,
of Counsel.
la
APPENDIX
Judgment
This eause having come on for tinal hearing by the court
without a jury on June 11, 1997 and the court having heard
all the evidence adduced and being fully advised in the
premises, it is herens ordered, adjudged and deereed a-
follows:
1. Defendants now and hereafter shall accept applica:
tious for admission or transfer to all elementary ciisses
ander their control (except in the schools named In paarat-
graph 2 as to which applications will be accepted as
deseribed in that paragraph), in aecerdance with rules
and regulations set forth in paragraph 3 and every Neuro
child's application to classes governed by the instant para
graph shall be considered and granted on the basis upon
which it would be considered and granted if he were white.
2 Defendants shall aceept Negro ehildren’s applica
Hons for admission or transfer to Ola Post Road, Bel Ai
and Highland elementary schools for the school year 125s.
1959 and thereafter: and shall accept Negro children’s
applications tor admission or transfer to Forest Hill,
Jarrettsville and Dublin elementary schools and the sixth
rade at Edgewood High School ter the school vears Phot
1960 and thereafter. Every Negro child's application Lo
the schools named in this paragraph for the respective
school vears specitied herein and thereafter shall be con
idered and granted on the basis upon which it would be
considered and granted if he were w hite.
3. All applications for transfer to elementary classes
Shall be made during the menth of May on a regular
application form furnished by the Board of Edvcation and
must be approved by the applicant's classroom teacher and
Za
Judgment
the principal of tue —chool the applicant attends. Such
applications will be reviewed at the regular June meeting
of the Board of Education. Applicants and their parents
will be informed of the action taken on applications prio.
to the elose of school in June of each year. In no even!
shall a Negro child's application for admission or transfe
be rejected if it would have heen granted had he beet
white.
4. A Negro child’s application for admission or transfe
to seventh grade classes commencing September, 1998, an
thereafter, under defendant's control shall be considere
and granted on the basis upon which it would be considere
and granted if he were white. Such applications to th
following classes shall be so treated during and after th
year set forth alonyside the class, as follows:
eighth grade -— 1959
ninth grade — 1960
tenth grade — 1961
eleventh grade —- 1962
twelfth grade — 1968
In 1963 and thereafter all Negro applicants to all class)
shall be admitted on the same basis upon which they wou
be admitted if they were white.
5. Commencing September, 1997 applications for adm
sion or transfer by Negro children not qualified for adm
sion or transfer under paragraph 4 to high schools und
defendants’ cor. rol will be considered and granted if t
applicants fulfill special sualifications pertaining to t
probability of success ef each individual pupil. The
qualifications will be measured by intelligence and achie’
ment tests, grade level achievernents and other sim
matters to be adjudged by a committee consisting of 1
Pala rmrntn tenes
eae EIT
—
TI OL ALA EAE OOO
ja
Judgment
principals of the sehools from which (he pupil is transfer
ring and the school to which he desires to transfer, the
Director of Instruction and the county supervisors work
‘ng in these schools. Apart from the fact that these cond:
tions may be applied only to Negro students not qualified
for admission under paragraph 4 no racial distinetion ts
to be made in the administration of these tests and evalua
tions. Such applications may be made to the Board of
Edueation between July 1 and July 15 of 1957 and years
following in Which these tests may be viven,
6. Infant plaintiff Moore shall be admitted te the
sixth grade at the Bel Air School. Infant plaintiff Sprige-
shall be admitted to the eighth grade at Edgewood High
School.
7. No racial distinctions whatsoever shall be made by
defendants in treating Negro children who have been
admitted to schools pursuant to this decree.
& This Court retains jurisdiction for the purpese of
eranting any other relief that may become necessary
da
Opinion of November 23, 1956
‘THomsen, Clief Judge.
This action, brought by four Negro children seeking ad-
mission to certain public schools in Harford County, Mary-
land, present: (1) the usual questions under Brown V.
Board of Education, 347 U. S. 483, 74S. Ct. 686, 98 L. Ed.
873: Id., 349 U.S. 294, 79S. Ct. 753, 99 L. Nd. 10835 (2)
the same questions of law which were raised by the de-
fendants in Robiasen v. Board of Education, D. C. D. Md.,
143 F. Supp. 481: and (3) a problem of equitable esterpel
arising out of a previous action brought by the plaintiffs
herein and others against the defendants herein, which was
dismissed by the plaintiffs in reliance upon a resolution
adopted by the defendants, the Board of Education of Har-
ford County.
Facts
Harford County is predominately rural, but in the
southern portion of the county there are two large govern-
ment reservations, the Aberdeen Proving Ground at Aber-
deen, and the Army Chemical Center at Edgewood. On
these reservations there are non-segregated housing de-
velopmients.
There are approximately 12,600 white students and 1,400
Negro students in the public schools of Harford County.
The defendant Board of Education operates a 6-3-3 sys-
tem: that is, G6 vears of elementary school, 3 vears of jun-
ior high and 3 vears of senior high. The white high schools,
at Bel Air. Bush's Corner (North Harford), Khdgewood,
Aberdeen, and Havre de Grace, are combination junior:
senior high schools: the colored schools, at Hickory ard
Havre de Grace, are ‘consolidated schools "*) comprising
elementary, junior high and senior high classes.
na
Opinion of Noven ser 25, 1996
On June 36, 1955, Just one month efter the second opin-
ion in Brown v. Board of Education, the Board of Educa-
ron of Harford County selected i. Citizens Consultant Com-
uittee of thirty-six metabers froin ail sections of ihe county,
five of whom were Negroes, to consider the problem of
Jesegregation of the public schools in Harford County
and to minke recommendations to the Board of Education.
On July 27, 1955, a group of Negro parents petitioned
‘he Board of Edueation, calling upon them “te take iimiaie-
diate steps te reorganize the public schools under your
surisdiction on a nondiseriminatory basis.”
The Citizens Consultant Committee held dts first mreet-
eon August 15, 1953, and was split up inte a nutnber of
~ab-committees, to consider facilitres, transportation and
coeinl relationships respectively, A imeniber of the staff
atthe Board of Education served a> consultant to cach sub-
committee, “The sub-committees inet at Various times dur-
ing the rest of the vear 155 and the first two inerths of
LO,
On November 20, 1955, the four intiaar plaintiffs in the
natant case, together with seventeen other Negro children,
‘hromeh their parents and next friends, brought suit in this
court against the defendants herein (Civil Action No. S615),
alieving that the Board had “refused te desegregate the
<chools within its jurisdiction and has not devised a plan
fap such desegregation,’ and praying that:
“)) The court advance this cause on the docket
and order a speedy hearing of the applleation for
preliminary injunction and the applieation for per-
Huainent imjunetion according to law and that upon
such hears :
62 ‘The Court enter preliminary and permanent
sudan nts that ans orders, custotis, practices, sane
usages pursuant to whieh said plaintifix are segre-
6a
Opinion of November 23, 1956
gated in their »chooling because of race, violate the
Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Con-
stitution.
oe?
3 ‘The Court issue preliminary injunctions or-
dering the defendants to promptly preserft a plan
of desegregation to this Court which will expedi-
tiously desegregate the sc ‘hools in Harford County
and forever restrain and enjoin the cefendants and
each of them from thereafter requiring these plain-
tiffs and all other Negroes of public school age to
attend or not to attend public schools in Harford
County because of race.
“The Court allow plaintiffs their costs and such
other relief as may appear to the Court to he just.”
On February 27, 1956, the Citizens Consultant Comunit-
tee held a meeting, at which all of the sub-e ommittees pre-
sented their final reports, and the fall committee unan.-
ously adopted the following resolution:
“Te recommend to the Board of Education for
Harford County that any child 1 ‘evardiess af race
may make individual application to the Board of Ed-
ucation to be admitted to a school other than the
one attended by such child, and the admissions to be
granted by the Board of! Education in accordance
with such rules and regulations 2s it may adopt and
in accordance with the available facilities in such
schools: effective for the school year beginning Sep-
tember, 1990."°
On March 7. 1956, the Board of Education of Harford
County adopted the resolution as <ubmitted by the Citizens
Consultant Committee.
ia
Opinion of November 23, 1956
On March 9, 1956. Civil Action Xo. 8615 eame on for
hearing before me on defendants’ motion to dismiss the
complaint, pursuant to Rule 20h). Fed. Rules Civ. Proc.
os U.S.C. AL At the beginning of the hearing, counsel for
defendants advised the court that the Board of Education
of Harford County had *tapproved or adopted”? the recon
mendation offered by the Citizens Consultant Committec
and read the resolution into the record. He then said:
“Sinee that plan embraces the relief prayed for, [E think
that takes care of that, and TP want to eall that to Yous
Honor’s attention’? Counsel for plaintiffs then said:
“We are in a position to enter into a consent deeree en.
hodving the terms of this resolution. We would Like to
discuss it, but I do not think there is any need for further
litigation.’” Counsel for the defendants replied: ‘th do
not think that the Court chomd enter a consent decree when
the relief prayed for is the polley adopted hi the Board.
| think the complaint should be dismissed ino open court
because there is really nothing before the Court to etfectu.
ate. TL then left the beneh +o that counsel could discuss
the matter more freely. When court reconvened the fol-
lowing colloquy took place:
“Mr. Greenberg: We discussed this resolution
that has Tyee adopted hy the Scliool Board and Wwe
have told counsel for che defendants that we are sure
they are proceeding 1 wood faith and this plan is
acceptable to UUs, anil Wwe will dismiss our sult ane
make that a matter of record in open court, and file
this.
“Mr. Barnes: ‘Phat’. avreeable to the defend
ants, your Honor.
“The Court: I think it would be well to have the
record show that in cjew of the fact that you have
been presented with this vou offered to dismiss thie
cuit, and attach this paper as an exhibit.
Dh
it
Opinion of November 23, 1956
“Mr. Greev berg: Yes, sir.
‘*The Court: Tam very happy this has worked
out ii a Very satisfactory way.”
The following stipulation, signed by counsel for all par.
ties, was filed in the case on the same day:
** Dismissal of Aetion
“1. This cause cnme to be heard in this Ceurt on
motion to dismiss the {th day ef Mareh, 1956.
“2. Defendants, by their counsel, presented to
the Court the attached Resolution of the Harford
County Citizens Consultant Committee, adopted by
the Harford County Board of Education, as sub.
mitted, at its regular meeting on March 7, 1956.
“3. Relying upon said resolution, as adopted,
plaintitfs hereby withdraw their complaint, and pray
that the same be dismissed, costs to be paid by
plaintiffs. *’
To this stipulation was attached a certified copy of the
resolution recommended by the Citizens Consultant Com-
mittee and adopted by the Hartord County Board of Edu-
cation.
On June 6, 1996, the Board of Education adopted the fol-
lowing ‘Transfer Poliey’*, which all parties agree was
reasonable :
“Tf a child desires to attend a school other than
the one in which he is eurolled or registered, it will
be necessary for his parents to request a transfer.
Apprcations for transfer are available on request.
These requests shonld be addressed to the Board of
Edueation, ¢ o Superintendent of Schools, Bel Air,
Maryland. Applications will be received by the
Na
Opinion of November 23, 1956
Board of Education between .me 15 and July 15,
ioe. AL applieation< for transfer must state the
reason for the request, and must be approved by
the principal ef the school whieh the pupil is now
attending.
“Applications for transfer will be handled
through the usual and normal channels now operating
under the jurisdiction of the Board of Education and
its executive officer, the Superintendent of Schools.
“While the Board has no intenvions of eompel-
ling a pupil to attend a specific school or of denying
hina the privilece of transferring to another school,
the Board reserves the right during the period of
transition te delay or deny the admission of a pupal
to any school. if itdecms such action wise and neces.
sary for any sood and suffieteut reason,
** All applications for transfer, with recommenda
tiens of the Superintendent of Schools, will be <b
mitted to the Board of Edueation for final econsidera-
tion at the regular meeting of the Board on Wednes
day, August 1.1956. When requests for transfer are
approved, parents must enroll their child at the
schoo! on the regular summer registration date,
Friday, August 24, 1956."°
The transfer poliey was advertised in all newspapers
published in Harford Conuty. Sixty applications for trans.
ferof Negro pupils were subinitted within the time specitied.
On Aucust 1, 1996, the Board of Edueation of Harford
County adopted at Desexregation Poley *, embodied in a
document which recited the appointment of the Citizen-
Consultant Committee, the coecommendation made by that
Committers, the resolution adepted by the Board of Eduea-
tion on Mareh ¢. 1996. and the transfer polies adapted by
the Board in June. The statement of Desceregation Polies
continued a follows:
10a
Opinion of November 23, 1996
“The Supreme Court decision, which required
desegregation of public schools, provided for an or-
derly, gradual transition based on the solution ot
varied local school problems. ‘The resolution of the
Harford County Citizens Consultant Committee is
i accord With this principle. The report of this
committee leaves the establishment of policies based
on the Ussessihe of local conditions of housing,
transportation, personnel, educational standards,
and social relationships to the discretion of the
Board of Education.
“The first concern of the Board of Education
must always be that of providing the best possible
school system for all of the children of Harford
County. Several studies made in areas where com-
plete desegregation has been practiced have indi-
cated a lowering of school standards that is detri-
mental to all children. Experience in other areas has
also shown that bitter local opposition to desegre-
vation in a sehool system not only prevents an
orderly transition, but also adversely affects the
whole educational program.
“With these factors in mind, the Harford County
Board of Kdueation has adepted a policy for a
vradual, but orderly, program for desegregation of
the schools of Harford County. he Board has
approved applications for the transfer of Negro
pupils from eolored to white schools in the first
three grades in the Eagewood Elementary Schoo!
and the Halls Cross Roads Elementary School.
Children living in these areas are already living in
integrated housing, and the adjustments will not
he co great as in the rural areas of the county where
cach relationships do not exist. With the exception
Gf two small schools, these are the only elementary
hnildings in which space is available for additional!
pupils at the present time.
lla
Opinion of Nove mbher 24, 1956
“Social problems posed by the desegregation of
sehools must be given careful consideration. These
can be solved with the least emotionalism when
younger children are involved. The future rate of
expansion of this program depends upon the sue-
eoss of these initial steps.”’
Pursuant to the Desegregation Policy so adopted,
“freon of the sixty applications were granted, and forty-
sve, ineluding these of the infant plaintiffs in the instant
vase, were refused, On August 7, 1956, the defendant
Charles W. Willis, Superintendent of Schools, sent the
following fetter to the parents of each of the infant plain-
tiffs:
“The Board of Education, at its regular August
meeting, adopted a policy for the desegregation otf
Harford County schools. Under the provisions of
this policy your child will not be allowed to transfer
from his present school. Your request for a trans-
fer has been refused by the Board of Edneation.
A copy of the desegregation poliey is enclosed.”
Neither the infant plaintiffs nor their parents appealed
te the State Board of Education from the action of the
County Superintendent denving their requests for transfer.
Nor have any appeals been filed by or on behalf of any of
the other Negro children whose requests for transfer were
refused.
On Angust 28, 1956, the four infant plaintiffs by their
parents and next friends filed the instant suit, pursuant to
Rule 23ia)(3). ‘for themselves and on behalf of all other
Negroes similarly situated”, alleging most of the facets set
out above and other facts, some of which are disputed,
whieh need not be detailed at this time.
Infant plaintiff? Moore seeks transfer from the Central
Consolidated Elementary School in Hickory to the elemen
Iva
Opinion of November 25, 1996
tary school in Bel Air, where he resides; Spriggs seeks
transfer from the schoo! in Hickory to the High Schoo!
(junior high) in Edvewood, where he resides ; Slade and
Garland seek transfer from the Havre de Grace Consohi-
dated Sehool to the Aberdeen High School (9th and 11th
vrades respectively). They pray that:
“4. The Court advance this cause on the docket
and order a speedy hearing of the application for
preliminary injunetion and applieation for perma-
nent injunetion according to law and that upon such
hearing;
“9 The Court enter preliminary and permanent
judgments, that any orders, customs, practices and
usages pursuant to which said plaintiffs are each of
them, their lessees, agents and successors in office
from denying to plaintiffs and other Negro residents
of Hartford County of the State of Maryland admis.
sion to any Public School operated and maintained
by the Board of Edueation of Harford County, on
account of race and color.”’ (sic)
Defendants filed a motion to dismiss the complaint pur
cuant to Rule 12(b). raising substantially the same points
which were vonsidered in Rebinsoen V. Board of Education
of St. Mary's County, supra. 1 overruled thet motion on
October 5, 1956. Defendants filed their answer on October
24 and the ease Was set for hearing on November 14. Both
sides offered testimony and documentary evidence. From
the testimony it appears that most, but not all, of the schools
in Harford County are overcrowded if the ‘tstandards”’
or **woals** set out by the State are considered, namely, an
average of 30 per class in elementary schools and Zo per
class in secondary schools. Pat defendants conceded tht
any White children moving into the county would be ail.
mitted to the appropriate white ~chool, however crowded
loa
Opinion of November 25, 1956
The factors considered by the rourd of Education !n adopt-
‘ng the August | Desevregation Polley were discussed at
come length. The President of the Board of Education and
‘he County Superintendent testified that they did not con-
calt counsel before adopting the Vugust 1 Desegregation
Policy, but that they thought this policy Was in accord
with the recommendation of the (Citizens Consultant Com-
jitter and with the March 7 resolution adopted by the
Board.
Plaintiffs’ counsel do net charge bad faith aarmoat either
the Board or ‘the Superintendent, but contend that:
ohey Me The Llartord County Sehool Board esol
tion of Mareh 7. 1996, meant that from the fellow-
ing school year and thereafter there would be no
legally compelled racial segregation of school chil-
dren in. Harford County;
“TL. The defendants are estopped trom any fur-
ther delay in complete integration by their action in
enusing plaintiffs to withdraw plaintitfs*’ original
cuit in reliance on the Board's resolution, which
resolution Was expressly incorporated by reference
‘nto the court's order of dismissal;
TTT. Plaintiff: are entitled to judicial rather
than administrative relief al this time in view of
the history and facts of this case:
nie, © Defendants, hy their aetions, are estopped
from asserting the doctrine of administrative ex
haustion an ua defense:
“BRB. Bven it defendants were not estopped trom
raising the defense of the doc trine of ackmiinisirative
exhaustion, the defense would neverthelss fail as the
doetrine is not here applicable;
STV. Even if defendant vould validly raise the
questions of necessary administrative delay,. their
l4a
Opinion of November 23, 1996
own actions clearly demonstrate the fact that no
additional time is needed to solve administrative
problemis ;
“A. Defendants are administratively ready to
effectuate desegregation ;
“B. ‘Community unreadiness’ constitutes ne
legal justification for continued segregation.”
DiscussION
fi] The Maryland statutes and decisions were analyzed
in Robinson v. Board of Education of St. Mary’s County,
supra, 143 i. Supp. at pages 487-491. I adhere to that
analysis, and it need not be repeated here, It is clear that
come of the factors considered by defendants in the instant
case when they adopted the August 1 Desegregation Policy,
and some of the points argued by counsel for plaintiffs in
opposition thereto, involve administrative problems, over
which the State Board of Education has jurisdiction, and
which should be appealed to that Board under the Maryland
authorities. Some of the other factors and points involve
legal questions, which under Maryland law are for the
courts. Most, if not all, involve both administrative and
legal problems. leven the estoppel point is a mixed ques-
tion, because the March 7 resolution leaves open at least
the question of available facilities, whatever other matters
may have been foreclosed.
Whether the court should attempt to segregate the legal
questions and decide them at this time, or should defer any
decision until the State Board has been given an oppor-
tunity toe pass on the problem as an integrated whole, is a
matter of comity and discretion, Since, at the time of the
hearing in the Sf. Mary's County case, the State Board
assurec, the court that it will give prompt attention to any
loa
Opinion of November 23, 1956
appeal filed by or on behalf of Negro students, Lam satisfied
that | should not make a final decision in this ease until
the plaintiffs have appealed to the State Board from the
action of the County Superintendent denying their applica-
tions for transfer. Brown v. Board of Education, 349 ULS.
mg, 74S. Ct. 753; Hood v. Board of Trustees of Sumter
County School District No. 2.4 Cir., 232 F. 2d 626: Carson
v. Board of Education of McDowell County, + Cir., 227 F.
+] 780; Robinson v. Board of Education of St. Mary's
County, D.C. D. Md. 143 F. Supp. 451. However, the final
decision in this court, if one is necessary after the State
Board has acted, should be rendered within such time that
the Josing parties may have an appeal heard by the Court
{Appeals for the Fourth Circuit at its June, 1997 term.
CONCLUSIONS
2) 9. The appointment of the Citizen- Consultant
Committee in the summer of 1955, its study, resulting in
‘ts recommendation to the Board of Education, and the
resolution adepted by the Board on March ¢, 1056, were
a prompt and reasonable start toward compliance with
the Supreme Court ruling.
» | intimate no opinion at this time with respeet to
the sufficiency or propriety of the Desevregation Poliey
-adopted by the Board on August 1, 196.
* | will enter a deeree dismissing this action unless
the plaintiffs appeal to the State Board of Education on
or before December 15, 1956, from the action of the County
Superintendent refusing their applications for transfer.
If plaintiffs enter such an appeal, 1 will stay further pro
ceedings in this ease until the State Board shall have
decided the appeal or shall have delaved decision for at
gureasonable time: provided that after the State Board
shall have rendered it~ decision, or atte) Mareh 194,
whichever is earlier, either plaintiffs or defendants may
request the court to set this case for further argument
ard prompt decoston,
loa
Opinion of June 20, 1957
THomsen, Chief Judge.
This action was brought by four Nero children, on
their own behalf and on behalf of those cimilarly situated,
cecking admission to certain public schools in Hartford
County, Maryland. The background and first stages of
the ease are detailed in an opinion filed herein on Novens
her 23, 1956, D.C. 146 FL Supp. 1.
Following that opinion, the four plaintiffs and eight
other children, whe have asked and been eranted leave
to intervene in this case, filed appeals with the State Board
of Edneation from the refusal of the Superintendent of
Schools of Harford County to grant thei applications for
transfer from consolidated schools for colored children to
various White schools whielr were not desegregated in Sep
tember, 1956.
While those sippeatts were pending before the State
Board, on February 6, 1857, the Harford County Board
adopted the following “Extension of the Desegregation
Poliey for 1957-1958""
“ Applieations for transfers will be accepted from
pupils who wish to attend elementary ~chools in the
areas where they live, if space ts available in such
~chools. Space will be considered avatlable in
schools that were not more than 10’ overcrowded
iim ot hebraary 1.94. All capacities “ure based (oth
the state and national standard of thirty pups
per classrooms.
‘Under the nhbove provision, applications will be
accepted for transfer to all elementary schools ex
cept Oil Po-t Road, Forest bqadi, Bel Air. Hlighlane.
Jarrettsville, the sixth vrade nat the idvewood High
School, and Dublin. © Such applications must be
made during the mouth of May ona regular apphea
ion form furnished by the Board of Education, and
:
lia
Opinion of June 20, 1957
must be approved by both tie child’s classroom
teacher and the prineipal of the school the child is
now attending.
“All applications will be reviewed at the regular
June meeting of the Board of Mdueation and pupils
and their parents will be informed of the action
taken on their applications prior to the close of
- 25
school in June, Mod.
After a hearing, the State Board dismissed the appeals,
finding that ‘the Harford County Board acted within the
poliey established by the State Board”’, that ‘tthe County
Superintendent acted in good faith within the authority set
forth in the August 1, 1956, Desegregation Poliey adopted
by the County Board™,’ that the Desegration Policy was
adopted im a bona fide effort to make a reasonable start
toward actual desegregation of the Harford County pub-
lie schools’’, and that ‘this initial effort ithe desegrega-
son of three grades in two elementary schools | has been
carried’ out without any untoward incidents"*. The State
Board also took ‘*cognizanece of the resolution of the County
Board of February 6, 195777, set out above herein, ‘as well
js the testimon to the effect that the proposed Harford
County Junior ¢ ‘ollewe. whieh is to be establizhed in Bel An
‘1 the fall of 1957, will open on a desegregated basis, and
also the testimony to the effeet that the present program
of new buildings and additions will make further desegre-
gation possible ’’.
After the decision of the State Board, plaintiffs set this
cave for further hearing, as provided in the earlier decree,
146 F. Supp. 2 page OS. That hearing was held on Agri
18. 1957. Charles W. Willis, the Harford County Supet
ntendent. explained and amplified the February 6, 17
?
-esolution of the Counts boare, The President of the
t See 146 F. Supp. at page 95.
Isa
Opinion of June 20, 1957
Board and its eoun- | aecepted that interpretation, Se
explained and amplified, the plan was substantially the
same as the plan which was later adopted by the County
Board on May 1, 157, as follows:
~The Board revie wed it ~ desegregation polices
of February 6, 1957. In accordance With this plan,
the following elementary schools will be open in all
six wrades to Negro pupils at the be vinning of the
1057-1958 school vear:
‘ramortou Iuledientary School
“Edgewood Elementary School
Aberdeen Elementary School
“Halls Cross Roads Elementary Sehool
“Perryinan Klementary School
“Churchville Hlementary School
“Youth's Benefit: Elementary School
“Slate Ridge Elementary School
“Darlington Blementary School
“Havre de Grace Klementary Sehool
“ath Grade at Aberdeen Ttgh School
“Schools now under construction ar conten
plated for construction in 1058, af no unforeseen
delays occur, will automatically open all elementars
schools to Negro pupils by september, 1959. Ax
result of mew coustruction, the elomentars schiowl-
at Old Post Road, Bel Air, and Highland will acceyn
applications for transfer of Negro pugals tor the
school year begining in September, Tos. Forest
Ah). Jarrettsville, Dublin and. the <ixth ywrade a!
the Made w ood High School would receive itprpelbed
tions “or the school yeas leeseinattitige dna Shegotermn cr,
Tiott
“AS no nermal result of this plan, sixth grade
eraduates will be admitted to junior high schools
for the first time in September, 108 and wall pro
t
.
‘
Te
ols
ro
19a
Opinion of June 20, 1957
ceed through high schools in the next higher grade
each vear. This will completely desegregate all
-chools of Harford County by September, 1963.
“The Board will continue to review this situation
monthly and may consider earlier admittance ot
Negro pupils to the white high schools if such seems
feasible. The Board reaffirmed its support of this
plan as approved by the State Board of Education.”
At the April, 1957 hearing. 1 ruled tentattrery—-ttat—
the plan was generally satisfactory for the elementary
grades, but not for the high school grades, and suggested
that the parties attempt to agree on a modified plan. Con-
ferences between counsel were held, but 10 agreement Was
reached. The County Board, however, on June 09, 1957,
wodified the plan as follows:
“The Board reaffirmed its basie plan tor the
desegrégation of Harford County Schools, but agreed
to the following modification for consideration of
transfers to the high schools during the interiun
period while the plan is becoming fully effective.
Beginning in September, 1957, transters will be
eousidered for admission to the high schools of Har-
ford County. Any student wishing to transfer to a
schoo; nearer his home must make appleation to the
Board of Edueation between July 1 and Jaly Lo.
Such application will be evaluated by a comunittes
consisting of the high school principals of the twe
schools concerned, the Director of Lustruetion, and
the county supervisors working tn these schools.
“These applications will be approved or disap
proved on the basis of the probability of success and
adjustment of each individual pupil, and the eommit-
tee will utilize the best professional measures of both
achievement and adjustment that can be obtained
in each individual situation. This will inelude, but
20a
Opimion of June 20, 1957
not be limited to, the results of both standardized
intelligence and achievement tests, with due con-
sideration being given to grade level achievements,
hoth with respect to ability and with respeet to the
vrade into which transfer is being requested,
“The Board of Education and its professional
staff will keep this problem under constant and con-
tinuous observation ard study.”
The modified plan was presented to the court at a hear-
ing on June 11, 1957. It was made clear that when an
elementary school has been desegregated, all Negro chil-
dren living in the area served by that school will have the
came right to attend the school that a white child living
in the same place would have, and the same option to attend
that sehool or the appropriate consolidated school that a
white child will have. The same rule will apply to the high
schools, all of which operate at both junior high and senior
high levels, as they leecotmne deseyvregated, vrade by yvrade.
Of course, the Counts Board will have the right to make
rensonable regulations for the administration of its schools,
co Jong as the regulations do net discriminate agetnst
anvone because of his reece; the ~pectal provisions of the
June 3, 1957 resolution will apply only during the transition
period,
'1) Willis also testified that the applications which will
be made pursuant to the June 3. 1057 modifieation will be
approved or disapproved on the basis of educational fac-
tors. for the best interests of the <tudent, and not for other
reasons. | have confidence in. the integrity, ability. and
fairness of Superintendent Willis and of the principals,
supervisers and others who wiil make the decisions under
his direction, Inthe leht of that confidence, TP must decide |
whether the modified plan meets the tests lad down in the
2la
Opinion of June 20, 1957
opinions of the Supreme Court and of the Fourth Circuit,’
with such guidance as may be derived from other decisions.’
The burden of proof is on defendants to show that a delay
during a transition period is necessary, that the reasons
for the delay are reasons which the court can accept under
the constitutional rule laid down by the Supreme Court, and
that the proposed plan is equitable under all the circul-
stances. In considering whether defendants have met that
jurden, the court must recognize that each county has a
different combination of administrative problems, tradi-
tions and character. Many counties are predominantly
rural, others suburban; some have large industrial areas
or military reservations. See 146 fF. Supp. at page 92.
{2} Eleven out of the eighteen elementary schools in
Harford County will be completely desegregated in Sep-
tember, 1957, three months from now. Three more will be
completely desegregated in 1958, and the remaining four
‘1 1959. The reason for the delay in desegregating the
eeven schools is that the county board and superintendent
lieve that the problems which accompany desegregation
can best be solved in schools which are not overcrowded and
where the teachers are not handicapped by having too
many children in one class. That factor would not justify
unreasonable delay; but in the circumstances of this case
t justifies the one or two years delay in desegregating the
«ven schools.
? Brown v. Board é6f Education, 349 U. S. 294. 73 5S. Ct. 753,
1. Ed. 1083: Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U. 5. 423, 74
< Ct. 686, 98 L. Ed. 873; Carsen v. Warlick, 4 Cir., 238 F. 2d 724:
Carson v. Board of Education of McDowell County, 4 Cir., 227
F. 2d 789
Maron v. Cooper, D.C. E. Do Ark. 143 F. Supp. 855; Kelley
Hoard of Education of the City of Nashville, M.D. Tenn., 2 Race
Rel. L. Rep. 21 (1937). Ci Mitchell v. Pollock. W. D. Kv., 2 Race
Rel. L. Rep 305 (1957). -
>)
Pap
Opinion of June 20, 1957
With respect to the high schools, other factors are
involved. Superintendent Willis testified that when a child
transfers to a high school trom another high school he
faces certain problems which do not arise When he enters
the seventh grade, which is the lowest erade in the Harford
County high schools. After a year or so in the high schools
social groups, athletic groups and subject-interest groups
have begun to erystallize, friendships and attachments have
been made, cliques have begun to develop. A child tran=
ferring to the school from anot er high school does not have
the support of a group with whom he has passed through
elementary school. A Negro child transferring to an upper
grade at this time would not have the benefit of older
brothers, sisters or cousits already in the school, or parents,
relatives or friends who have been active in the P. T. A.
High school teachers generally, with notable exceptions,
are less ‘‘pupil conscious”? and more ‘Subject conscious”
than teachers trained for elementary erades, and because
each teacher has the class for only one or two subjects, are
less likely to help in the readjustment, The Harford County
Board had sound reasons for making the transition on a
vear to year basis, so that most Negro children will have a
normal high schoo] experience, entering in the seventh grade
and continuing through the same school. But | was un-
willing in April to approve a plan which would prevent all
Neero children now in the sixth grade or above from ever
attending a desegr gated high school.
However, the modified plan adopted on June 9, 157,
permits any Negro child to apply next month for transter
to a presently white high school, and if his application is
granted, to be admitted in September, 1957, three months
hence. This plan is different from any to which my atten
tion has been ealled or about which T have read. It is an
equitable way of handling the transition period. My only
doubt is whether it is necessary te postpone until September,
23a
Qpinion of June 20, 1957
1958, the complete desegregation of the seventh grade. But
1am not charged with the responsibility of administering
the Harford County public school system. Although |
think the reasons given for the delay of one year are less
satisfactory than the reasons given for the rest of the
plan, a federal court should be siow to say that the line
must be drawn here and cannot reasonably be drawn there,
where the difference in time is short and individual rights
are reasonably p-otected, during the transition period,
as they are by the June 5, 1957 modification.
(3] Plaintiffs ave obviously worried whether the June
5 plan will be carried out in good faith, or waether it will
be used as a meaus of postponing the admission of Negro
children into the high schools without proper justification.
Although, as I have said, I have confidence in Superin-
tendent Willis and his staff, plaintiffs’ doubts are not un-
reasonable in view of the past history of this litigation.
I will, therefore, entér a deeree which will spell out the
rights of individual children under the plan, and will
retain jurisdiction of the case, so that if any child or his
parents feel that his application has been rejected for a
reason not authorized by the modified plan, a prompt hear-
ing may be granted.
‘here remains the question of estoppel, based upen
the resolution adopted by the County Board on March
7, 1956, and the interpretation of that resolution by its
counsel in open court in the earlier Harford County case,
as a result of which the plaintiffs therein dismissed their
action. The facts on this point are set out fully in 146
F. Supp. 95 et seq.
(4) The March 7, 1956 resolution was somewhat
ambiguous, but, as it was interpreted by defendants” coun-
sel in open court, plaintiffs were justified in believing, as
I did, that applications for transfer would be considered
without regard to the race of the applicant. The Counts
Jia
Opinion of June 20, 1957
Board interpreted it differently in the statement entitled
‘*Desegregation Poliey’’ adopted on August 1, 19956; see
146 F. Supp. at page 95. | cannot accept the interpreta.
tion adopted by the County Board, but | find that it was
adopted as a result of a mistake and not as the result of
any bad faith on the part of the Beard, the Superintendent,
or their counsel. The Board adopted the Desegregation
Policy of August, 1956, in the honest belief that it was to
the best interests of all of the children in the County.
Pursvant to that policy the Superintendent admitted
fifteen Negro children to two previously white schools,
but denied admission to forty-five others, including the
infant plaintiffs herein.
There is grave doubt whether a governmental agency
such as a county school board can be estopped from adopt.
ing a policy, otherwise legal, which it believes to be in the
best interests of all the people in the County. In the instant
ease it would be inequitable and improper, on the ground
of estoppel, to require the County Board to open all schools
to Negroes immediately, as requested in the complaint
The County Board should not be foreclosed by the facts
which I have found from taking sach actions, and adopt
ing and modifying such policies, as it believes to be in the
best interest of the people in the County, so long as thos:
actions and those policies are constitutional,
(5) The individual plaintiffs in the earlier ease, how.
ever, were prevented from pressing their individual rights
in this court and on appeal by the adoption of the March
7, 1956 resolution and by what took place in this court
in that case. See 146 FL Supp. $8 et seq. Two of thos:
infant plaintiffs are before the court in this case, and their
counsel urge that their individual richts, as well as an)
class rights, be enforced. The reasons which prevent an
estoppel against the County Board so far as its general
25a
Opinion of June 20, 1957
policies are concerned, do not apply with equal force to
the individual claims of those two children. It would not
be equitable to delay any further the enforcement of their
individual rights.
1 will, therefore, include in the decree a_ provision
enjoining the County Board from refusing to admit Stephen
Moore and Dennis Spriggs to whatever school would be
appropriate for them if they were white.
ST ae
Lhe
Excerpts from Testimony
Direct testimony of Citanios Wo Wins, Sapermtendent
of Schools.
Llo} Q. Plow niany Negro ehildren appite dc) AL We liad
oY appheations, and there was a tix-up oon one that we
later adiunitted,
blo) Q. Well approximate IVA. That ronde 60,
(). How many Nesre children are there in the Counts
School System altogether! A. A bitthe over 1400 at the
present tine,
Q. How qany white children are there in the Count
School System?) A. About 12,600, roughiv ten pereent Ne
ere children, about P4000 children,
@. Vhat is 60 children of the total school population
outoof hiow many > AL 14,000,
(). And how qaians Negro children were admitted? A.
Fifteen.
Q). Now, what was the reason for admutting fifteen
rejecting the other forty-tive? AL Vhe qian reason at
was We had facilities in the areas where the elildren wer
admitted, and we had integrated housing in those areas.
and we felt that we woold have les seeial adjustment prof
lems im the lower grades, amd this was the beginning of
the plan of gradual integration, and we felt that that would
work in our System,
We bread stindied all We ces led firied eriyt inbeouyt PreViaus w’-
tempts and we had found out that trouble usyally arose in
fii rural areas, quite a bit rere from rural areas, and
we had committees from these rural areas, protest any
action on the part of the Board, and this seemed like the
most Workable plan.
27a
Charles W. Willis—Dtrect
Q. Was there an absence of facilit: -~ to aamit the forty-
five who desired acinission? A. In some places, ves.
Q. For how : any places! A. Well, | can’t exacily say
specifically beca. ke | don’t know just where the applica-
tons were from. Which schools thes were made from.
Mr. Barnes: Maybe vou had better ask hin
about a specific school, Ask him about a specific
school.
The Court: Eventually | wan te knew about the
four applications as well as the others.
Bu Mr. Greenberg:
(. Now, in what instances was there an absence of facil-
‘tiesities——that is, tell us in something more than just gen-
eral terms with respect to not admitting any o* these
forty-five applicants who desired admission. A. That was
from the area in Bel Air, Havre de Grace, Aberdeen, Jat
retteville, Highland, Churchville, Yo th Benetit.
Mr. (jreenbery ‘ Should | give hiismt the dist?
The Witness: Yes, sir, | better look at it to be
~ure.
Old Post Road, Eamuimerton, Aberdeen, Youth
Benefit, Forest Hill, Churchville, Bel Air.
(1S! The Court: Jarrettsville.
Mr. Greenberg: Churchville.
The Witness: Highland. Dublin, Havre ds
Grace. Those are Blementacy Sehools.
The Court: Well, Aberdeen Elementary, Bel Aw
Elementary.
The Witness: All ot these are felerientary.
The Court: All of those Elementary?
The Witness: Yes, not high schools Bel Ag
\
28a
Charles W. Woillis—Direct
The Court: A matter of facilities?
The Witness: Yes. North Harford. Kadvewood
The Court: Jarrettsville.
By Mr. Cireenberg:
(). Mr. Willis, are you aware thict the (itizens Consul!
ant Comunitter reported that there is an ex
the Havre de Grace Jcleqmentars ane Thigh Sehool? A,
the Hlavre de Gerace
“ess Of space in
No, Lawas net aware thes reported: on
folermentars School, me.
(). Well, look at page 4. A. Well, this is a four-room
affair, and we hiel His nbandoned seb buifcing, ame this
is used for purpose: of specral echucation.
(). Wihiat about the high ~chiow!
didn’t list,
(1%) The Court: You just said.
The Witness: ‘The Havre de Grace Hah Sehoo.,
no, | didn't inehide that,
Livy Mr. (rreenbera:
Q. Youdisted about fifteen chools in which there was
supposed to be an ales nae acilities sis that corres \.
Yes, sir, according to Ub
tromally.
a). ‘Vhat i) ' mnoaveragze Oo bin x
dren out of the total in these schools, and there
white children that moved inte the area, wortiled thie
adnutted A. They would be anedematterd,
(). Sor if i rrcot the pheence of Yiye Shae hoya thi {
that the children wer Negro hi orree! \. | wo
any that te Rot vetiv it, 2 We have te consider a
eootare inclining the transportation factor, ©
20a
‘Charles W. Willis—Direct
of the big things im the County, as we ransport over 14,000
children, and | think there is the plan, | mean the idea of
adjusting the thing and if you wish, let me expla it.
(). Not at this tune, no,
The Court: € think sou should let him explain
it if he wishes to do so.
Vhe Witness: Now, | would like to deseribe it
in this way, your Honor. When the original opin-
ion, the orginal (20) opinion of the Supreme Court
came out in 1994, the first opmmion, the members of
the Board of Education felt about these clearly in
needed facilities in the schools and were approached
by a great many people particularly in our rural
areas about how impossible it was at the the for us
to do anything along these les.
The Court: In the matter of—
The Witness: In the daatter of integration, and
it was the thought that .f we woald de it gradually in
a matter of starting 6 in one area whieh was bet-
ter prepared for the integration program than un
another area we should do at that way, we would
have ra leettel chance i oft silecess TN these schools,
Ray Mr. Greenberg:
(). If white persenis moved from Delaware or Virginia
or elsewhere, moved into Harford County, that is at the
present tine, sueh as to work in an industrial plant, would
thace children be admitted te the sehools at the present
time? A. Yes, sir, they would.
a eo o
33. Q. Why did vou aud the Board tutewrate the first
three grades in Bel Air Elementary -Edgewood Elemen
School mod 4 Hall €ros~ Reads School and net
vecromy
30a
Charles W. Willis—Direet
the other grades in hese and the othe schools in Har
ford County? A. For these reasons: One reason Was
that space Was limited in these echools: Two, the peopie
were used to living together im integrated housing abd
working together In areas of industrialization, and we also
had been informed by Mr. Wilson, our attorney, that the
suggestion to begin with a control area had been made fast
year, and we got the impresston that the feeling was tha
if we could start in an area of decontrel than any othe:
place Wwe had a much better chanee of sucess.
(). Well, were there wines other reasets that moved: th:
Board? A. One was that on these specific areas we found
that little children had no prejudices: they can wad just tor
easily than older children who have fixed prejudices, or as
adults, and also there isthe problem that if you leeuriny WIT!
children putting them tovether that thei social adjus!
ments are much eaeaier, they can adjust thy selves mer
readily, and are tore emotionally stable, and this seemed
a more favorable climate in which to work, and our exper
enee has shown that what we have done ts working sat
factorily, andthe children ure vetting along all riuhit ane
eatisfaectorily. >
{). Ana it was Tor those reasons that the Board
nouneed [35] 1s losegregation policy of August Ist, 18%
that vou denied these application nn Auguet oth, 19967 \
IL had no other reason exeept this that
@ ¥es. aA. that the Board is primary concerl™
with the elucational problem, srtiel They were inter atid
eVvVerVvole vetting the truest possible eyention ot doalse iT
noninterference with the advancement or ext: naion of ft
whole educational prograu, ane we read ti the papers
principally in Delaware and other places that these thing
have caused problema. trouble with the iytewratior pr
lem, which was comething that could affect the whole sche
sVstem.
3la
Charles W. Wailis—Direct
Mr. Greenberg: To move te -trike out this testi
mony, Your Honor, problems in Delaware, and so
on, there is no eveidence that any of those things
have any effect here, and neaddition to that, | sub-
mit that it is totally irrelevant.
The Court: Well, if it is one of the things that
influenced them it haat bee ath niportant considera
tion. That was one of the points vou are making.
(471 The Court: As to the next question, Twill
allow [48] either side to object if they wish to abject
hecanse it is pretty close to what the Court has to
decide, but IT take it that a decision on these que
tions involves what might be called adm iustrative
factors and policy factors, and that in any final de
cision they may be mixed.
What administrative reasons were there for re
fusing the transfer of each of these fous children?
Mr. Barnes: Your Honor, don"t we have to detins
what an administrative reason ts or factor is?
The Court: Well, what he has said was that in
the case of two of the children there Was an over
crowded condition in the Bel* Air School, There
was an overcrowded eondition ino the Kduewood
school. There Was no overcrowded condition in
Aberdeen.
Perhaps this is the way to put it: In tanning
vour decision with respect To these sixty children,
did you consider the overcrowded condition of a
sehool, that is, an individual school, as a reason for
th
ora reason against transferring children, or was tie
consideration of the overcrowded condition of the
individnal school simply dayie of the factors Corsi pea
in adopting th general polies !
The Witness: I think there isa Vos or ho atiswet
which requires an explanation. [think the over-all
32a
Charles W. Willis—Direct
policy was pi Hieated upon the things that 1 hav
just mentioned 149] before which restricted the pe
Iission to transter the first three erndes, and with:
that polies facilities were coustdered,
The Court: So that confining it to the first three
wrades Was a question of
The Witness: Facilities.
The Court: = - facilities.
Phe Witness: Yes. he
The Court: No. so tine question ot confine
to the first three grades was a question of poke
That is, in the first three erades facilities were co!
sidered?
The Witness: That is correct. That is what I
meant to say.
The Court: Was the decision to limit it to the two
schools, vouts or the School Board ’~?
The Witness: Well, I guess we come back to the
other statement that if Was a matter of tactitties |
the earls schools that were avaliable.
The Court: Were thes the ands two schools that’
had the facilities available or were there a rural
of other schools in which had facilities been aVallatie
to which a child might have been admitted if he had
applied ¢
The Witness: There were [wo other schools. «
in Perrvinan and Dartington.
The Court: Two other schools were not ove
crowded!
“yl The Witnes- That is correct
The Court \ried thiess Wards satied vou ii
applications for Perryman?
The Witness: No
The Court: Qred there Was ot ptepoiteat anti 14
;
Darhneton
Charles W. Willts—Direct
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: And that was refused?
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: For poliey reasons?
The Witness: Polley reasons f would say ont
side of the original policy, ves.
The Court: Beeause it was a particularly sen
sitive spot?
The Witness: Yes, it is a very rural area, one
of our most rural areas.
The Court: | think that is all T have.
lf either side wishes to ask any further question-
based upon the line T have opened up, you are wel
come to do so.
Ru Myr. Gree nherd:
(). When vou speak ot ‘overcrowding " what do vou
mean by overcrowding? What is you definition of over
erowding? A. Over thirty in an elementary and over
twenty-five in a high school.
[51] Q. Then in each of these ~chools when they have
that many they are overerowded? A. No, vou can't say
that because in a high sehool you might have in on
class eight or ten or in another forty or forty-five
Q. So you mean the over all avecave? A. That is cor
rect, Those are the standard twure- rsead oon practieaias
all school analyses.
The Court: I think that is a fact that the (om
would have to find that vou will have to use another
method of calesiating crowding an the high ane cb
mentary becwtise there is a ditherence in courses
The Witness: Yes.
Charles W. Walis-—Drreect
By Mr. Greenhera:
(). Now, i passing upon the applieation of each ip
plicant for transfer, did you look at the school to whieh ti
applied, the grade in which he was applying and determin
that it Was ero wded or pet erowded? A. Yes,
@. You did that? A. Yes.
(). And it turned out that the only two ~chools in Hay
tora (counts that were nt eroweed were these two schools
to which the plaintitfs, e1 the two schools to which certan
applicants were seeking udtmisston!
52) The Court: | thought he said four.
The Witness: Yes.
bu Mr. Greenberd:
Q. But if a white child had applied to any of the se
called overerowded schools he would have been admitted?
A. That‘s correct.
The Court. Were there Negro schools ino thes:
overcrowded also!
The Witness: Slightly, yes, bat they are both
combination schools, part high and part elementary,
anid you have to use both standards on them, but
they are just slightly over capacity,
The Coart: Are they more overcrowded or tess
overerowded than white schools, or are they some
one Way and some the other!
The Witness: Lwonld say it would be about like
some of the others, vour Honor, but I would like te
answer vour question specifically this way that thes
would have about a ten percent over their-—thes
would be about ten percent over their capacity based
Upens the figures that we disenussed hefore.
35a
David G. Harry—Cross
The Court: You are talking about the Hickory
Consolidated?
The Witness: Yes.
(53) The Court: Is about ten percent?
The Witness: About that point.
The Court: How abcut the Bel Air High sehool?
The Witness: That is about thirty-five percent.
It has a capacity of 690, and it’s something like 800.
The Court: Is the Edgewood High School any
more overcrowded than the Hickory Consolidated
School?
The Witness: [don’t think so. I think they are
probably about the same. :
The Court: The other three were a matter of
poliey t
The Witness: Yes.
(Cross-examination of Davip G. Harry, President of
school Board.
62) Q. You say these rural areas are sensitive areas ;
‘s that correct? A. That is correct.
Q. And if these people moved in you would still refuse?
A. Well. it is part of the process of the educational system
in rural areas and when vou find it is working in one part
of the County vou have to work it ont as a County System
and not as an individual system, and when vou find it 1s
working in one part of the County vou can move it to the
other parts of the County, but it was my opinion and the
opinion of the Board that we must hmit it to the areas
which are at the present time integrated in housing and in
areas Where the -equests were greatest.
(). So vour reason was based on the fear that there
might be confliet or racial diffeulties? A. That is my
feeling.
36a
Charles W. Witlis—Direct
(104) The Court: Why can't vou admit a child to the
seventh grade in 1990?
The Witness: (Mr. Willis) I can’t say why, your Honor,
but the policy was moving forward three years, and that
was ail.
The Court: Is there any administrative reason as dis-
tinguished from the considerations whieh may legally be
applied under the plan- Tdon’t want to limit the question;
| want to get everything—but what ix the reason or reasons
why children cannot be admitted to Junior High School
in the fall of 1997?
You see, Tam not in passing upon your plan passing
Upon the validity of the reasons that vou offer for that
plan, Some reasons I presume are valid; some reasons
are invalid,
[ am not saying what the reasons are. Each one must
be applied to the facts of the particular case.
What is the reason why you can't admit people to the
seventh grade?
The Witness: The only thing that } can say is that in
extending the poliey it was a vradual, a poliey of gradual
ide segregation, and the Board in discussing it planned only
ty extend it three years at this time.
The Court: That‘s a matter of policy rather than [ 105!
a matter of administrative necessity.
The Witness: Or administrative convenience, and your
prolley reasons have been stated in the evidence.
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: T want to be sure that when you have ad-
tnihistrative reasons that they may be considered sepa
rately.
Now, I take it that vou are allowing a child te enter the
seventh grade there, would you permit a transfer to the
eighth and ninth grades?
The Witness: The poley tia~ net been extended beyond
that. .
The Court: Well, are there administrative reasons tor
saving that at the nich school level children should: start
37a
Charles W. Willis—Durect
at the seventh grade in junior high and the tenth grade in
senior high?
The Witness: | think nothing but policy reasons.
The Court: Nothing but policy reasons!
The Witness: That is correct.
The Court: It is a policy reason and there is no admin-
trative reason why you say the seventh grade in 1958
and not the eighth grade also, that it is only policy reasons.
The Witness: The only extension of the policy that
has been accepted for the reasons that have been given.
(106) The Court: And no administrative reasons?
The Witness: Well, | won’t say none, but at the mo-
ent. | don’t think of any big one; Jet’s put it that way.
(157) Mr. Barnes: Well, here is what I am afraid of.
It vou push this thing too fast, as my brother wants me
to do, you are going to have some incidents among the stu-
dents themselves in these high schools antil after this whole
problem: has been developed in the lower grades when you
are not likely to have those preblems. and the Board can
say honestly, “We have tried it in the lower yrades and
i+ worked well and there have been no ineidents*’, and you
vo in with an entirely different atmosphere, not only from
the public viewpoint, and T think myself it’s perfectly
absurd to say that you can’t give any consideration to
the publie reaction in the publie schools, but however that
nay be, the reaction of the ehildren themselves because,
¢ your Honor please, you can't get away from the fact,
can’t help but refleet the attitudes of their parents par-
th ularly in the adolescent age. and it’s nonsense to say,
well because vou don’t fear riots it has no effeet "upon the
madagogical system of the courty. It works on the minds
ot the children.
If these colored children are not accepted, if they are
eweetod, whether it be by eold indifference or by active
hostility, it is voing to adversed affeet their education.
38a
Charles W. Willis-—Direct
}158} The Court: Well, isn’t that just what the Su-
preme Court has said vou can’t consider?
Mr. Barnes: No, I don't think so, because that has to
do with the pedagogical system of education.
The Court: Well, if you can continue this prejudice
forever, then you will never get anywhere.
Mr. Barnes: No, not that.
The Court: You will never get anywhere.
Mr. Barnes: No, | agree you couldnt continue it for-
ever, that Tam quite willing to concede; but where you
are making a bona fide effort to do it reasonably and ration-
ally and to meet that problem, whitch we never have, cer-
tainly within a reasonable time to my way of thinking.
This segregation situation lias been with us for over a
comtury.
The Court: What ix voing to be better in 1958 than
in 19572?
Mr. Barnes: Because you will have vour complete ele-
mentary schools practicatly completely integrated.
The Court: No, not completely integrated.
Mr. Barnes: No.
The Court: You will have two or three children who
will have graduated from the elementary schools, two o:
three, or maybe a dozen, Negro children who will have had
one er two years in the elementary schools.
30) Mr. Barnes: That is very important, it seems
to mit.
The Court: And that’s all you are going to have.
Mr. Barnes: That's true, and that’= tmportant,
seetis TO The.
The Court: And most of them are going to have one
vear.
Mr. Barnes: Well, that’s so, because you have a prag-
matic sVstem as against a theoretical because the thing ts.
will it work?
39a
Charles W. Willis—Direct
If | were going to theorize about this, 1 would say,
“Well, nothing has ever happened, nothing is going to
happen’, and then it happens, what then?
Now, we have this system that has been adopted—
(175| Mrs. Mitchell: Your Honor, there has just been re-
ceived this last resolution, and it is the first knowledge we
have received of any action of the Board of Education of
Harford County, and we would like to have the opportu-
nity to go over the contents of the resolution which was
enacted on June 5, 1957, because we have not had an oppor-
tunity to confer about it.
The Court: Well, a copy was given to me about five
minutes azo; so we are in about the same situation.
4a
Excerpts from Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1-a
Aberdeen, Maryland
December 29, 1955
From: Subcommittee on Fae:lties
To: Hartford Consultant Committee on lutegration
Ernest H. Volkart, Chairman
I. AwdHoRITY
On September 23, Moo, a subcommittee consisting of
Harold Baker, Chairman, Mrs. Norman J. Schnepfe and
Mr. Paul Beatly Harlan, Associate Members, was ap-
pointed to investigate and repert on the various facilities
at the disposal of the Board of Edueation of Harford
County, particularly with reference to buildings, class-
rooms, and pertinent training aids. The subcommittee
interpreted its mission to be: To establish a definite rela-
tionship between the number of classrooms available
throughont the county, and the number of pupils enrolled,
using as a standard the optimum figures set by qualified
National and State authorities, and als», insofar as pos-
sible, to preview conditions in the <chool year 1956-57. (See
Appendix 1)
Il. AecTIVITIES
The subcommittees began its investigations on Septem.
ber 2S, 1955 and concluded them on November 2 VOD.
Kach of the twenty-three schools was visited by one or other
member of the group. Neither principals nor teachers re-
ceived advance notice of intended visits, thus assuring
observation of the normal routine of operations.
Duration of examinations, depending upon the size of
the unit. varied from one-half hour to two hours. Attention
was directed toward condition (both external and internal)
tia
Excerpts from Plamtiff’s Exhibit 1-a
of buildings. Heating and lighting facilities were carefully
noted. Cafeteria equipment and management, shops and
laboratories, domestic science rooms and equipment, safety
and health provisions, recreational and athletic space and
equipment, locker rooms, toilets, and all other adjuncts
pertinent to the comfort and well-being of teachers and st1-
dents were inspected. Special attention was foeused upon
classrooms With a view to determining whether the number
of occupants exceeded or fell short of the standard (twenty-
fve high school or thirty elementary students per class-
room) as determined by established authority. (See Ap-
pendix IT)
HI. Fixpincs
1. Buildinas (General). In the Harford school sys-
tem there are only three buildings of frame construction.
These include the elementary plants at Emmorton, Perry
man, and a four-room structure at Havre de Grace pur-
chased for the use of primary pupils who could not be ae
commodated at Havre de Grace Elementary School. All
other buildings are of brick-conerete construction, and are
either new, or in such state of preservation as to warrant
alteration or addition to meet the demands of increased
enrollment or new activities. All buildings are in safe
condition.
2 Heating plants. These are, in the main, adequate.
Where practicable, coal-burning unit» are oeing replaced
by fuel oil systems.
3. Light. Window area, in proportion to wall area, con-
forms to conventional specifications. Lighting systems are
adequate; fixtures are, for the most part, advantageously
located.
4. Cafeterias. All except two schools, Emmorton and
Perryman, have some provision for eafeterta service. The
dla
Excerpts from Plaintiff's Bahibit t-a
newer buildings incor: orate complete, modern dining rooms,
kitchens, and food-storage space and equipment. Meals
are adequate, of high quality, and designed to supply the
nourishment required by the growing child. Tnomany eases,
mothers of attending pupils volunteer for service in. the
eafeterias, Tn buildings in which the cafeteria was not in
eluded in the original lavout, evirnastiims, auditoriums, and
other adaptable rooms serve the purpose. ALL cafeteria.
are clean, orderly, and wellstatfed.
o% Domestte Science Roonws, Laboratories and Shape.
These facilities are confined to hich scehodls and eonsoli
dated schools. nereasing imlerest it loot voursel iY" pray
ects, tovether with the already existing trend in that diree
thon. is reflected in the inereasing demand for sueh train
ing. Some shop units have been added in the current vear,
others are it the process ot construetion, Additional shop
space and equipment is neeessary in several schdols. Thy
same may be affirmed of Domestic Serenee facilities,
GO. Recreation and Athletics. All schools na\ nade
such provision fer reereation and athieties as space ane
tinds Will perout. in some cases students themselves have
raised funds or performed the manual labor necessary to
eXpand athlete Taciittes and programs,
j ) oDafety and Mealth. Aj) schools have, in such mea
i
sure as space, personned, and equipment Will permit, estab
lyst if ~eotie sVsteni lookin tao Thye a] Hiination of sarety Jiaz
$4 ‘ls, and to the protmotpom af first -iiied treatment. first
‘
aid kits, cots, stretchers, and ether equiplent are at band,
{ a ‘ ; vr bee rae ° F }
Woere enrotinient justifies such aetion, perere tabries aay fall
the Miirses are employed \
~ ( fasxroom hb ypeollone yl Piati : f99- T99G, Ldeatas
! thine iHVes i , i Cvitignisttes “Vy?
} , he ih le pepo m4 I ) foedrnect if il,
i
doa
Kacerpts frow Platntiff’s Kerhibut 1-a
indieate that during the current school year (ioo-06),
TS0S elementary pupils are occupying LIT ehtesrooims, an
average of 3G per rooms that O479 high school students are
housed in 154 classrooms, an average of approxiuuatels
Sela per POO,
rt A Coserhe nw’ Clas sree ( onstrate tton, Ih til Tiehpel ian ad
neredused enroflment, thirty-bous adeiionad classrooms are
n the process of construction, and are expecte bto lw aval
the beginning of the [%5teo0 sehool sar,
able for use at
These are located us picdientecd helow,
MLE MENTARY
Hhicsus “ Hitvadus
Halls Cross Road- ¢
Bel Ain It
Nerden ‘y
Kilgeweod 4
bide wrod 4
i
; ae eee :
10. Classroom Knrollacal Ratios 1956-5, ihe esti-
the coming
tated elementary enrolinnent fos
S290, To accommodate these pupils, 220 classrooms are
avallable--an average of approXximaateis of.5 plipit> pel
room. High school registration is expected to total ofe
for Whieh TSS classrooms are pote bet] i erage Of ap
proximately Ob per rooi
H ‘
} | (), ote ; fry } \V by Tile iV: igfes~ fe
ermiined om the ahowe paarayragel woud 1 Pures genes
y conceded to be ideal they de indicate at Iprovernernt
ay 10ND dy evoonned) trTis tes peer spel F ir
ohpoats Pirie fie prosecution of t et
verte ih, waive mad fees D Po
a4 Pik 1, true preempt bicam Prereety [rd peng oft
' j “ tiges bis Per OX ‘ hes, dbbe thoy?
rit ! aul i > ! t i Mit
\ ! \! ’ oo en tk
£4 fay j bay Npopoet tare, n 4
tee ts val {? tejiyht schemas at Tieat Ypectedt To bp tilted
‘}? ' ra ‘ i i A
dia
Eacerpts froin Plaintiff's Eahibit tea
ELEMENTARY Hig
Emmorton Aberdeen
Kdgewood Havre de Grac:
Halls Cross Roads
Slate Ridge
Darlington
Havre de Grace (special)
It is also apparent that these eicht school: ean aecon
modate d10 more students than they expect to receive. This
condition may be attributed either te the fact that elas
rooms have been added or that population in certain spee:ti
“areas has deercased, It Hy niicl nol be construed as affect
ing in any Gegree the averages established i Paragraph 1b
What it actually indicates ts an riedpuial distribution ot
pupils, since it can be seen by referring to Appendix TV,
Column 3, that the sevedteen schools not mentioned
Paragraph 12 will have 1,050 pupils in excess of then
capacities. [t also points to the faet that the schools listed
in Paragraph 12 above may add to their rosters by admis
ting colored students residing an the area an whieh tt
school is located, or near enough to such area as to mas
use of existing transportation facuithes. Such acti
would materially reduce the pressure on other -chools whos
facilities are sorely taxed
IV. Conciustons. After carefully considering all tar
tors at its disposal, the committee is of the opinion thi
provision can be tnade to accommodate such colored sty
dents as apply for admission to Harford County publ
schools for the vear 1996-57.
Respeettully submitted,
Mics. NORMAN |. ScHNEPFE.
Me. Paci Bratiy Harcay,
Mrodi Elvpome Banker, | airing
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.