Brief for the Respondent in Opposition — Parks-Cramer Co. v. American Monorail Co. (No. 533)
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Docu
e sUPREME FILED
OCT 28 1957 .
‘I the Sopreme Court ofthe Unt
OCTOBER TERM, 1957. pert
No. 533.
="
PARKS-CRAMER COMPANY,
a Corporation of MassacHuseEtts,
™“* Petitioner, |
"VB
_ THE AMERICAN MONORAIL COMPANY,
a Corporation of Onto, eae
” BRIEF OF RESPONDENT
In Opposition to Petition for Writ of Certiorari.
‘
_F.O. Ricuery, —
B. D. Warts, eR
520 Union Commerce Bidg.,
Cleveland 14, Ohio,
Of Counsel:
Ricuey, Watts, EDGERTON, _
(McNenny & FarrINncTON,
520 Union Commerce Bldg., ~
‘Cleveland 14, Ohio.
J. B. CRAIGHTLL,
607-13 Law Building,
Charlotte 2, North Carolina.
wv
THE GATES LEGAL PUBLISHING CO.. CLEVELAND, OCHIO-—MAIN 1-8647
TABLE OF CONTENTS.
eae
Statement of the Case | &-- = 1
-The Patent in Suit - | . os. oe
Questions Presented — | e 5
(1) Did the Court of Appeals err in. reversing the .
trial Court and holding that the patent in suit '
was invalid.for lack of invention in view of
‘certain Findings of Fact by the District Court?
5
_ Long Felt Need __ eae .
Commercial Success - ~_ | 6
‘Obviousness hee . 7
(2) Did the Court of Appeals err in applying an
improper test of what constitutes patentable
-invention in view of the enactment of Sec-
tion 103 of Title 35 of the U.S. Code? —-s=s—ss 88
(3) Did the Court of Appeals err in holding that
the standard of what constitutes patentable
invention is a legal rather than a. factual
question? | ae \ . -
Conclusion _. , an ce «AB
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES.
Cases.
Beckton Dickinson & Co. v. R. P. penerer Caspevetion.
7 -11 Fed. (2) 835 : ee
Graver Tank & Mig: Co.; Inc., et al. v. Linde Air .
Products Co., 336 U.S. 271 : 10, 11,12
Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v: Supermarket
- Corporation, 340 U. S. 147 Ga 5
Lyons v. Untited States, 123 Fed. (2) 507 (CA 6) 8
Mahn v. Harwood, 112 U. S. 354
Seema |
Nobie Co. v. C. S. Johnson Company, 241 Fed. (2) i
469 g oe
Texas Co. v. Globe Oil & Refining Co., 225 Fed. (2) ?
725... 7 ae
Virtue’ v. ieee: ‘Package idles — :
pany and Owatonna Company, 227 U. S. 8 3
Statutes, :
cise occa ne SF
meetee.....°.....1- | «6
. R
nthe Supreme Court ofthe United Sts
OCTOBER TERM, 1957.
No. 533."
PARKS-CRAMER COMPANY,
a Corporation of MassacHUSETTS,
: P 2 tite ’ A .
THE AMERICAN MONORAIL COMPANY,
a Corporation ‘of Onto,
eee.
BRIEF OF RESPONDENT
In Opposition to Petition for Writ of Certiorari
STATEMENT OF THE CASE.
| “This is a ‘suit; in the usual form, for alleged infringe-
‘ment of one. claim of a patent containing six claims and
relating to a traveling blower for removing’ accumulations
‘of. lint from textile machines, particularly ita ma-
chines.
The District Court, in.a non-jury action, held the
claim in suit valid and infringed (147 F. Supp. 218). The |
Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held that the” :
claim i in suit was invalid for lack of invention and rev ersed
the decree of the-District Court (245 Fed. (2) 739).
The. decision sought to be reviewed is manifestly right.
It is not in conflict with any decision on the patent in any
’ other Circuit. It involves nothing more than the reversal
2 7
of the decision of the District Court on a question of law.
It is based on controlling principles - law which are well
established in this Court:
There is no question of general or public interest or.
. importance involved in this case. The patent is of interest
~ only to the parties to this suit: No showing has been, or
can be, made that there can be no litigation on this =
"in any other Court of Appeals.
The Court: of Appeals. did not decide - maguitant
question of Federal law—the issue decided was whether |
the patent was valid. The Court of Appeals did not depart |
from the accepted and usual course of judicial proceedings.
There was no conflicting testimony, the patented device |
was simple, and readily understood by laymen and much
of the evidence. was physical and documentary and the .
Court of Appeals saw and considered both. Thus the Court
of Appeals was as able to decide the issues as the District
~ Cgurt and, moreover, has had extensive. experience in —
deciding paterit cases. |
The -second question raised — Petitioner, i.e., as to.
whether 35 U. S. C. 103 was followed, is raised here for
the first time in. this case. It was not raised by Petitioner
in either of the lower Courts. Since it is a vated question,
it is now too late ts raise it.
_ This suit is merely a vain effort to stretch a patent,
after seven years of proven commercial failure of the de- .
vice disclosed therein, to cover a device which was. differ-
ent in structure, operation and results and met with suc-
There. is. no reason for granting a Writ of Certiorar?
in this case: ~ Coe 23
3
-THE PATENT IN SUIT.
Petitioner’ . description (3-5) * of the history of the a
cleaning of spinning frames is: generally correct but the
statements x6) .as to the problem allegedly solved by the
patentee Holtzclaw and the means by which he solved it
_ are not entirely correct. Furthermore, the-discussions of
~ the proofs (8-10) are quite optimistic, to say the least.
The patent in suit (91a-97a) does not disclose any
concept of, or apparatus for, using “air outlets (cuffs,
nozzles or sleeves) of appropriate size and shape to deliver
air currents of the right volumes and velocities at the right...
places and in the right directions, ” (6) for a —_— and
complete cleaning of a spinning machine.
The patent in suit describes the alleged invention, the
problem which it sought to solve and the solution’ with.
~ reference to certain prior cleaner patents identified in the -
specification. It claims merely to have improved the ap-
paratus of those patents.
It states the alleged invention as talliion: ;
“t * * the present invention relates only to improve- .
ments in the mechanism for directing the biasts of air
delivered by the fan.” (Col. 1, 41-42.)
‘. That “mechanism” ‘was nozzles “of highly. flexible
‘material” (96a, Col. 1, 1.35).
The patent states the alleged problem as 5 follows:
“For example, in the use of the traveling cleaner ‘for
cleaning a spinning frame blasts ** of air are not fully
effective in preventing accumulation of lint.and the
like upon the lower face of the creel board and upon
- the spools of roving located closely therebeneath and
the deposition or accumulation. _of bunches of lint
+O + +
* This sy intel ( ) ‘designates. pages in the petition.
' ** Emphasis throughout i is curs.
’ + - ;
- upon the roving running from said spools, "*(Col. 2,
ll. 3-10.)
, The patent states the alleged solution as fafininn:
“The nozzle 19, which conducts the blast of air wen ;
versely of the machines, is of highly flexible material ~
_and extends well below the end of the nozzle 18 and
is provided with an inwardly curved and preferably
tapering end portion which is positioned at such pre- —
determined height as to direct the air inwardly be-
neath the creel board 4 thereby.to prevent accumula-
tion of lint upon the under face of the creel board or
upon. the spool of roving 5 and the strand 20 leading
therefrom through the usual guide eye 21 and draw- .
ing.mechanism 22 to the ring rail 23 having the usual ;
ring and traveler for spinning and winding the strand
ce ee (96a, =. + at
es. * * « x
; “The — may°be of any desired Lsngils to posi-
‘tion its outlet at such predetermined height as to direct
‘the current of air transversely. across the machine
closely beneath the creel board of the spinning frame,
_** *." (96a, Col. 1, Il. 64-69.) :
' Thus it is seen that the aden disclosed i in » the pat-
ent was intended, and was useable, solely fer removing lint —
a little more efficiently than formerly from the“creel por-
tion of a spinning machine and that apparatus amounted |
merely to the substitution of two flexible. cuffs for two.
. metal cuffs of the cleaner of the Hodge Patents Nos. 2,047,-
558 (103a) or 2,184,880 (139a) (9a, 25a, 29a). Like the
apparatus of those patents, the apparatus disclosed in the
"patent in suit could not clean the underframe ofa nnn |
~ machine.
- The truth of the matter is . that. this alleged problem
was quite unimportant to the industry and the sol ation
i e |
- was of so little utility that its ae could not be measured
_in dollars and cents. (3m, 36a. )
a
toa QUESTIONS PRESENTED.
qa) Did the Court of Appeals err in reversing the
trial Court and holding that the patent in suit was invalid
for lack of invention i in view of certain Findings of Fact by
the District Court? .
Long Felt Need: There is no proof in-the record that
there was any demand for better cleaning between the top
and middle creel Saeaee than that afforded Y the ae
type cleaners..
There is no proof in the record that any on ats us
traveling creel cleaner felt any need for, or demanded, a |
better creel cleaner. There is no-proof in the record that —
_ anyone prior to Holtzclaw- ever tried and failed satisfac-,. -
torily to clean between the upper and middle creel ‘oards
with streams of air.
The claim (8) that there was a et felt need oe the
alleged: invention of the. patent in suit rests solely on the
testimony of two witnesses (7x,.37x) and on prior patents.
Both witnesses correctly testified that the prior Hodge
- . type cleaner did not do a complete job of automatic clean-
ing for that cleaner was incapable of cleaning the under-
frame and was capable of cleaning only the creel of a spin- |
| ning machine. The first witness testified that efforts made
prior to Holtzclaw to improve the quality of the cleaning _
included making the. air outlets adjustable and installing -
vanes in some of the outlets. These expedients were for
the purpose of mening the cleaning of the creel. The
prior patents-relied on were for devices to clean only the
* We shall discuss the questions stated on pages 2 and 3 of the -
¢ petition rather than the variations stated on pages 8, 13 and 21.
eed: of a spinning machine. Holtzclaw disclosed a the
cleaning of a creel. — 3
- Commercial Success: There is no prdet A premet and
large-scale acceptance of the apparatus disclosed. in the
- Holtzclaw patent. On the contrary, the proof is that plain-
_ tiff never built any traveling cleaner like, cane in
the patent. | The flexible cuffs shown in the patent con-
stituted: the “best mode contemplated by the inventor of
carrying out his. invention” (35 U.S. C. 112). They were: -
- sold for substitution for rigid nozzles of the Hodge cleaners
disclosed in patent No. 2,184,880, but the number so sold.
was so small that plaintiff gave no figures as to the sales \
(25a, 26a, 29a). The only proof as to the utility of those
cuffs was. the admission of one of: Petitioner’ s witnesses
that there was no noticeable difference in the labor of
- cleaning a spinning machine when using the device of the
patent in suit or the cleaner of Hodge —* No. 2, 184 ,880
(34a, 36a).
. The commercial success enjoyed by the apparatus of
Plaintiff's Exhibit 16 is not traceable to thie patent in suit.
The apparatus of that exhibit is quite different structurally ~
from the apparatus disclosed in the patent and by reason
thereof was able to remove lint from within the under- ©
frame, a function which could not be performed by the .
device disclosed in the patent or in any of the prior art.
Since the device of Exhibit 16 used the short curved cuffs
_of the Holtzclaw. patent which the proof showed had no _
commercial success, it follows that any commercial sut-
a cess enjoyed bythe apparatus of Exhibit 16 must be trace-
able to Aomething other than what was disclosed in the
patent in suit. That additional something was the long, |
vertical tubes which extended down to below the creel and ©
directed air streams into the underframe to remove ac- -
‘
cumulations of lint in . that area. This was something not :
suggested by or disclosed i in the patent i in suit..
Obviousness: The identified patents (10). to Hodge,
Smith, Moore and Miller & Becker do not establish lack
of obviousness of the alleged Holtzclaw invention. ,
Hodge and Smith were fellow employees with Holtz-
claw and each one was promoting his particular form of .
Creel cleaner. Hodge made several: minor. structural,
changes in his cleaner and Holtzclaw supplied a different — |
but also minor structural change to the Hodge cleaner. |
The Moore patent was for the totally different purpose _
_ of removing lint from wall surfaces of textile rooms.
It could.not be used to clean a spinning ine. More-
‘ever, the Moore application was not fil until “ae 16,
1948, over four menths after Holtzclaw ‘filed his ‘applica- _
tion’ and, of course, a much — time after he made his .
alleged invention.
_ The Miller & Becker patent was tos cleaning oy the
a underframe -of a spinning machine—not for cleaning the
creel.: It was the first successful underframe cleaner (21a).
Moreover, the. application for this patent was filed on
‘+ January 10, 1949, some thirteen montis after Holtzclaw
filed and an even _— time. after he made his alleged ——
invention. .
The Statute (35° U.-S. C. 103) fixes. the time when ~
the invention was made as the time when obviousness oe
_ to be. considered.. Both of the Moore and the Miller &
Becker patents were filed eid after, _— s date of.
: alleged invention. .
Thus the Moore and the. Miller & ites sista
. being for totally different devices and purposes and being ©
too late to come within 35 U. S. C. 103 are of no avail as”
regards showing lack of. obviousness of the alleged in-.
vention of the patent in suit. |
ne
on " .
tortie
®
igen
\ ‘
(2) Did the Court of Appeals err in ‘bie an _
. improper test of what constitutes patentable invention in
view: of the enactment. of Section. 103 of Title 35 of the
. UL S$ Code?
Neither. in the District Court’ nor in its Petition for
Rehearing in the Court: of Appeals did Petitioner contend
that error had been. committed in not following 35. USS:
C. 103. “Indeed, Petitioner did not so much as mention |
that Statute in its brief in either of those Courts. Neither
- Court passed on any such contention. Since the’ alleged
-eryor raises a. questjon of law which is raised for:the first
time in the Petition, it is too late for this Court we
sider. Virtue v. Creamery Package Manufacturing om-
pany and Owatonna Company, 227 U. S. 8, 38; Lyons v.
~~ United States, 123 Fed. (2) 507, 508 (CA 6),
‘The grounds (14) on which | it is claimed that the
t Court of Appeals: failed to apply Section 103 of the Statute
aa. have already’ been shown’ to be non-existent or of in-
significant force. There was’ no proof of extent of need ©
of the -alleged_ invention, no proof of. prior efforts and
. failure to. supply that need, no acceptance by the public
and no proof of lack of obviousness ai the time the alleged |
invention was made, as the Statute requires.
_ The obvious“reason why the Court of ‘Appeals did
_not mention the alleged - “many prior unsuccessful at- |
tempts” (11) is that there was no proof of any such at-
tempts, as just demonstrated. The Court of Appeals did
not violate any fundamental rules of patent law (13) fcr»
the proof failed’ to establish facts to which: the cited law
Ex would apply.
The. decision of te C Court a Appeals is impregnable :
toe held (App. 5):
4 “The bare idea’ cf using a Soft sleeve or pipe = to
convey air; fone teat veil materials is aid old and
\ o . - s
. ? . P 7 he
, 9
has been applied many times. Repeatedly it has been
held that the use of known devices in an analo“ous
> fjeld is not, invention.”
. There i is no invention here by ariy annie ioin—
ancient, current or modern. There is’ no invention here
whether invention be.a question of fact, a ‘question of law,
or a eae of mixed fact and law.
(3) Did the Court of Appeals err in holding that
the standard of what constitutes patentable- invention is
a legal rather than a factual question? ; |
_ .'That issue was not before the Court and was ‘not de-
cided by the Court. ~~. |
The Ctyurt held (p. 5 of sis — to the Petition),
as follows: ;
“The’ issue is whether, sealing to sselable ‘i:
standards, this is a cuevense invention. We hold
that it is not.’
Petitioner seems not to appreciate the difference be-
tween “standard of invention,” on the one hand, and
“validity” or “patentable invention,” on the other hand.
| Whether ‘the standard of what constitutes invention is
a legal or factual question was. not an issue in any oi the
cases cited. by Petitioner (21- 23); 8 and was not decided’ in
any of those cases. |
Thus the alleged conflict of decisions is non-existent.
‘But if it be assumed that Petitioner really meant
“patentable invention” or “validity” When it said»
“standard of invention,” there is still no conflict shown
by the cited a, &
This Court long ago, and silieaiee — held that
patentable invention or validity i is a question of law. :
., In Mahz ». Harwood, 112 U. S. 354, 358 this’ Court
held i in 1884 as follows:
a?
¥
“
——
46
“In cases of patents for inventions, a validity defense
not given by‘the Statute often arises where the ques-
- tion is, whether the thing patented amounts to a-
- patentable -invention.. This -being a question of law
the Courts are not bound by the decision of the Com- hae
missioner, although he must t necessarily pass on it.”
(Citing cases) .. | 3
In Graver Tank & Mfg. Co., Inc., et “ v. Linde Air
Products Co:, 336 U. S. hie 275, tis a held, in 1948
- . as follows:
“While. the ‘wtenste question of patentability is ie
’ of meeting the requirements of the statute, R. S. §
4886, as amended, 35 U. S. C. § 31, the facts as found ~
_ with respect to these. four flux claims warrant a con-
clusion here that as.a matter of law those Satetory
requirements have been met.”
ani, on page 280, where, in a concurring decision, “tke
Justice Black, with whom Mr. open Douglas concurred,
said: © | |
“While. ebcepting the findings of those two courts on
what I consider to be questions of fact, it is my view
that determination of the ultimate question of patent-
ability cannot properly be classified as a finding of —
fact. I would adhere to this Court’s earlier pro-
nouncement that ‘whether the thing patented
amounts to a patentable invention’ is a question a...
law to be decided by the courts as such.”
| In Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Supermarket.
Corporation, 340 U. S. 147, 153 this Court held in 1950
as follows:
“We set aside no anding of fact as to invention, for.
none has been made except as to the extension of the
counter. which cannot stand as a matter of law.”
and, on page 155, where, in a concurring opinion, Mr.
Justice Douglas with whom Mr. Justice Black ate neta
said: |
4a. oa,
“The standard of patentability is a constitutional
standard;:and a question of validity of a patent is a
question of law.” eae oe fae )
The decisions in five of the seven cases cited *(23).
’ held that patentable invention was a question of fact. How-
ever, those decisions were handed down before this Court °
decided the foregoing ‘cases of Graver v. Linde and Great
_ Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Supermarket. It is to be pre- . .
sumed that the Courts concerned in those five cases will
- not-go counter to what this Court held in these last two
_ decisions; and we have been unable to find that any of —
those Courts of Appeals has gone contrary to thése de- .
cisions of this Court since they were handed down. |
In the sixth of those cases, i.e., Beckton Dickinson &
Co. v. R..P. Scherer Corporation, 211 Fed: (2) 835, the
Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit had before it an.
issue of fraud. The question of invalidity “‘was not serious- .
ly contested. on ae evidence was uncontradicted.”
(p. 842.) aes |
In: the seventh of those cases, i.e., Pexés Co. v. Globe ©
Oil & Refining Co., 225 Fed. (2) 725, the Court of.Ap-
peals for the Seventh Circuit held that findings on factual
issues by a Master and approved by the District Court
should be accepted on appeal unless clearly erréneous.:
While the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit had-
decided one of those five cases? that Court followed—did |
“not go contrary to—the foregoing decisions. of this Court.
In Woble Co. v. C.S. Johnson sti de ted 241 Fed. (2) 469,
476, that Court held: .
“When the distiict court has-thus. nial the ulti-.
mate facts, it is then'its duty to decide, as a matter
of law, the over-all question of validity, which, of —
_ course, is likewise subject to review. In this con-
nection it should be noted that invention -dves not
connote patentability. Galland-Henning Co. v. Loge-
0
12
. mann Bros®Co., 7 Cir., 142 F. 2d 700; 703, certiorari
_ denied $23 U. S. 767,65 S. Ct. 120, 89 L. Ed. 614,
' and Harley C: Loney Co. v. Ravenscroft, 7 Cir., 162
F. 2d: 703, 704.”
Thus it appears that hon is no conflict between
Courts of Appeals on the question of whether patentable
invention or validity is a question of law since his Court’s |
decisions in cases of Graver v. Linde and Great Atlantic
& Pacific Tea Co. v. Supermarket.
- Invention is. absent in this case whether invention is
a question of law or a, question’ of fact.
All Holtzclaw did was to extend the old idea of using
‘a flexible hose to a new and analogous use.
All Holtzclaw did was to substitute a longer tube of
flexible material for a short tube of rigid material: This is
”. not distinguishable from the “extension of the counter” in
the Great Atlantic &-Pacific Tea Co. v. Supermarket case.
There is no invention in either of these acts by any
‘standard, old or new,. whether invention is a -question
of law or a question of fact.
In reality what Petitioner is asking this Court to do
is to reverse its decisions in such cases as Mahn v. Har-.
wood, Graver v. Linde and Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea
Co. v. ae tacnennaal
4
it,
1o
CONCLUSION.
For the reasons set forth above we respectfully >
mit that the Petition should be denied. _
F. O. Ricury,
' B.D. Warts,
520 Union Commerce Bidg.,
_ Cleveland 14, Ohio,
P Counsel for Respondent.
» Of Counsel:
_o B. CRAIGHILL,
607-13 Law ‘Bldg. %
G harlotte 2, North Carolina.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.