Respondents Brief Opposing Petition for Certiorari — Kress v. Aghnides (No. 508)
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ee os nena: “Gia: Supreme’ Cour s |
Sipps, *. FILED. |
: ee Ca eee OCT 23 1957
sy . Z : ; ‘
‘Inthe dees Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 19ST.
“a Ne. 508:
on 'S. H. KRESS & COMPANY,
¥ Petitioner, |
VS.
ELIE P. AGHNIDES and CHASE BRASS & COPPER _ INC.,
| e | | s — :
RESPONDENTS’ BRIEF OPPOSING .
PETITION FOR CERTIORARL
Ausert L. Exy, ,
Everett R. HAMILTON, . °
First National Tower,
Akron 8, Ohio,
ise : ene an Attorieys for Respondents.
<THE GATES LEGAL PUBLISHING CO., CLEVELAND, OHIO—MAIN 1-3647
‘ Statement of ae
»
«<dD
©. » TABLE OF CONTENTS.
: Jurisdiction SESE eee > Aes Sem
Respondents’ Statement of Questions Presented _ nie pe
Argument ae ee =. ea cae Rat
I. The Alleged Patent Misuse or Fraud Under the
International Patent en 2 |
‘- “The Conflict Between the Seventh and Fourth
‘Circuits ae ae a
Ill. No Decision Is Required by the Supreme Court to
_ Forestall Excessive Future Sn en ne
Conclusion a eRe PSN ee? elie RE as 3
i. - TABLE OF CASES.
te Auta ae iuidien Co. v. Kindler & Collins, 247
We ae
_ Borcherdt, In re, 197 F. 2d 550 (C.C. P. ee |
Jungersen v. Baden et al., 166 F. 2d 807 (C. A. + 7
Keystone Driller Co. v. General Excavator Co., 290
Be) PATER gee ete coonpeterect eer Re tre SiR
Lindberg, Application of 194 F. 2d ae — ce
Marconi Wireless Co. v. U: S., 320 U. _ BES eee ee
McCarn, Application of, 212 SO ——— nee
"Miller v. Kentucky, 40 F. 2d 820 (C. A. 6) . A aa
Commercial Success -._______- ne cee
Felten and Aghnides Differ a Principle cra taeia
_Fig. 8 of the Patent AIM RR Ee ee ee tae
te
; Precision Pestvamnenit Mfg. Co. v. Automotive Co., 324
Wis BO a tennant
Sarazin et al. v. Wright - . Aeronautical Corp. » 4 F.
RN I ens he asamceintinpiniange tami cmin
Stewart, Application of, 222 F. 2d 747 see Reda
Tracy v. Terminal R. Assoc., 170 F. 2d 635 (C. A. 8).
Triplett v. Lowell, 297 U. Si 638 Sip eae eee EEO ET
‘United States v. Bransen, 142 F. 2d 232 (C. A. “ee
- Universal Oil Co. v. Globe Oil Co., 322 U.S. 471___*
~
Jn the Supreme Court of the Unite States
OCTOBER TERM, —
oO
No. 508. rant
c Ss. H. ‘KRESS & COMPANY,
Petitioner,
VS. .
. ° ELIE P, AGHNIDES and CHASE BRASS & COPPER O., INC,,
_ Respondents
RESPONDENTS’ BRIEF OPPOSING
: _ “PETITION FOR ——
JU RISDICTION.
No actual basis now exists ; for invoking this Court's
jurisdiction’ relative to the pendency of substantial litiga-
‘tion in the Second and Fourth Circuits involving the
3 Aghnides patent 2,210,846. Since the patent. has expired,
the Marshall Metal Products v. Aghnides case, Civil Ac-
tion 85-272 | in the District Court for the Southern District °
of. New York, has been dismissed with prejudice by the
Court October 14, 1957, and the Aghnides v. Holden et al.
case, Civil Action. 50. C 1022 in the District Court for .
Northern ‘Illinois, Eastern Division, has been ‘dismissed |
with prejudice by the Court October 17, 1957. The Melard —
Mfg. Corpsv. Aghnides case in the District Court for the
Southern District of New. York, Civil Action 95-355, 08 ee
.Melard Mfg. Corp. v. Chase et al., Civil Action 55.C 84 |
the District Court for Northern Illinois, Eastern Div ae
f
na
‘ . ae me
involve the same parties. or their privies and Yeo.s same
‘patent as the present. case, * and as to those parties the
question’ of validity of said patent is res adjudicata.
co. There is no issue in this. case involving the Inter- |
national Patent Convention, and hence: no international .
_ treaty. issue which this Court need determine, as will be
_ readily apparent from ‘a true appraisal of the accepted :
facts. pak |
" RESPONDENTS’ STATEMENT OF QUESTIONS PRESENTED. :
I. Where the trial judge, long after coriclusion of the
trial, denies a motion to‘reopen on the ground (for which.
there was no basis in the record), that plaintiff had made
representations: in the Canadian Patent Office allegedly
contrary to. representations in the U. S. Patent Office
fully supported by the trial record, and the Court of Ap-
peals in affirming the denial of ‘the motion independently
- considers the merits of the matter on which the motion
is based, should the Supreme Court grant certiorari to
~ determine whether the motion to ee was properly de-
nied? . .
Il. Is there a ‘conflict of duttsiane with senpeet to
validity. of-a patent in the Seventh and Fourth Cireui its
requiring - determination by the Supreme Court, where
the Fourth Circuit has specifieally pointed out that their
-decision was based-on a different and later record con-
Benetton new -visual evidence disproving the. conclusions |
. drawn by the Court in the Seventh Circuit, and where -
the’ oe involved is now expired | and the only litiga- Lae,
* The District Court held (1 App. 104) that Melard conducted _
the defense and was bound by the judgment against Kress. This
= was not appealed to > the Court of —- for the Fourth |
_ Circuit. |
>
ey '
tion still pending easing said patent is between the
same parties as in the Fourth Circuit case, or their privies?
The collateral question - relating to Figure 8 of the
: patent. attempted to be presented by petitioner is a ques-
-tion which need not be determined by this Court, since
petitioner’s contention on this question was the specific
subject of a petition for rehearing which was, denied with
opinion by the sarah of — aw. |
STATEMENT OF. FACTS. .
Petitioner’s “Statement of Facts” relevant to question
i] contains misleading statements and unfounded con-
_ elusions. Aghnides’ original specification’ “(2 App. 50) *
—— of his. December. 31, 1937 patent a application, which re- _
sulted in U. S. patent 2,210,846, ‘stated that “this appli-
- cation is a continuation in part of 1 my: earliet application.
Serial No. 52,923, filed December 4, 1935,” which cor-
responded to the Belgian application. The original oath of \
the 1937 application stated that the annexed specification —
discloses and claims “certain matters** derived from an
earlier application filed by him on December 4, 1935, Serial
No. 52,923.” ‘The Aghnides British patent was cited later .
by the U. S. Patent Office (2 App. 71), and in response
Aghnides called attention to the fact that te ‘specification
of his 1937 application set forth that it was “‘a continuation |
in part of my earlier application Serial No. 42, 923” and 3
pointed out that the British patent was therefore not a
nd reference since. it corresponded to the earlier appli yeu
eB haw ” and “2 App: -_- ” refer to Volumes I and II,
O oan va Appellant's Appendix before the Court of Appeals
of the Fourth Circuit. “PA -__.” refers to Appellee’ s Appendix -
before that.Court. “Appendix _-_ page - ” refers to the ap-
pendices printed at the end of eerwen) s Petition for cnet
oe Emphasis supplied.
Ge ‘Felten’s specification, as folfows: |
4. Wes
aa cation. The British patent was not reasserted by the U. S.
Patent Office. - |
Thus, there is no otal tintin hieot for petition- |
er’s conclusion that the British patent “would have been.
insurmountable opposition to the issuance of a patent.” —
: Petitioner’s Statement of Facts relevant to Question
II is incomplete to say the least. Finding XXVII(£). of ©
the District Court below, which the Court of Appeals
held, was fully supported by the evidence, rel ‘to the |
“Not only was it deinciimailes that Felten’ s re-
sult is. different but that he secures his result by
_. different elements. and by a different mode of opera-
tion. The patent states that the result is secured by
means of a ‘conically widening chamber e, the widen-
‘ing of which produces in a well. known manner the
suction of the gas from the perforation d owing to
the flow of the liquid-from the perforation c into the
widened chamber e.’ (Felten Patent, p. 1, line 28). |
This has no counterpart it Aghnides.. Felten, to se- -
cure his result, must keep the chamber flooded—the
exact opposite ’ of ee. Mihai geet. A,
p. vi.) |
Petitioner S* statement that the U.S. Fuss ene
= shane Felten’s mixirig device mounted at the discharge _
end of an ordinary home faucet should be completed by .
pointing out that the suction inlet to the device is con-
nected to.a closed chamber for creating a oat vacuum
therein (2 App. 304). | :
Petitioner’ s statement, that tests of | a. Felten- devin |
- before thé Trial Court showed that it delivered a non-
| splash bubbly stream of air and water, ignores the ob-
servations of the District Court below based on the tests
= (1 App. 98):
“Felten as shown above did not produce aerated __
water. He did not _ Beek that result. He was en-. .
deavoring to provide a vacuum pump. This neces-- _
sitated the flooding of the chamber. to create vacuum,
the exact opposite of .Aghnides: Patents in suit. He.
did not obtain aerated water, nor a coherent, splash-
_ less stream. There is: nothing’ in Felten to indicate
_ he was concerned at all in these results. This applies —
a to Aghnides 1,912, 113, and to Fuss Patent 1,090,044.”
Petitioner’ s statement, that the holding of the Fourth
Circuit Court of ‘Appeals that Figure 8-of patent 2,210,846.
is outside the scope of the. claims is in direct ‘conflict with
the Opinion of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cir- _
cuit, is not correct.. The Seventh Circuit held that Felten
(not Figure 8) reads literally on the claims, and that one
form of —" may be used as a vacuum pump.
+ “The Alleged Patent Misuse or Fraud Under the
‘ International Patent Convention. We
‘The so-called issue of. patent misuse, or fraud, is not
|. an issue under the International Patent Convention be-
cause while Aghnides claimed the priority date of his ©
7 Belgian patent in the United States he could not and did
_.__ net-elaim it in Canada. His Canadian application was filed |
: five years after. the filing date of his Belgian application, |
: so that the Convention did not apply. |
; This issue ‘was not tried below but was the ‘aihaa a
if motion, filed by petitioner. almost two months after the
| evidence was closed by both sides, to reopen the case in .
the District Court. The District J udge denied the motion,
citing Marconi Wireless Co. v. U. S., 320'U. S.°1, 47, 48,
as authority for the decision being within his sound dis-
cretion, and held -in effect that there was no fraud. ©
“ f
"The Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit gave the
_ matter special consideration and held (pete A, pp. —
a xli-xiii) :
“In this case, we are the more. strongly disinclined _
_ interfere with Judge Hayes’ exercise of discretion, be-
: \ cause on the documents before us, we fully agree with
\ his comment that even if the case were reopened, the |
(proffered testimony would not alter the result. From
* ae own examination of the United States patent
846 and the Belgian patent, we think it unquestion-.
ably that they are, as Aghnides told the United
States Patent Office, the same invention. Whether or
not on another occasion Aghnides made an incon-
- sistent claim in Canada to obtain a patent there, isan .
3 issue that we need not decide. If he made a misstate-
ment there, this might bear upon the validity of his. |
Canadian patent., It would not alter the fact that
_ what he told the t Inited. States Patent Office was the
truth and thatthe patent here was obtained without
deception or fraud.” a added. ) | 3
(1) The contention that Aghnides falsified to ‘the
U.S. Patent Office i is completel answered by the fact that
the U. S. Patent Office decided. that Aghnides was entitled
to the Belgian priority, and both ‘the Courts below con-
curred. At the trial in the District\Court a medel con- |
, - structed exactly in accordance with Fig. 1 of the Belgian ,
_ patent was demonstrated to perform precisely the same as _
a model constructed in accordance with patent No. |
"2,210,846. = Pens aa \ °.
| (2) In Precision Instrument Mfg. ~~ v. " Aitomotive; 9
- 324.U. S. 806, the District Court in the exercise of its dis-
~ cretion found gross and manifest. fraud, ‘and the Supreme -;
-» Court sustained the District Court.: ‘Here . the Supreme —
Court is s ‘asked to reverse the finding 0 of-no fraud by the
| District Court i in the éxercise of its discretion, which | find--
aan ing was sustained by the Court of Appeals. ne
In the words of the District Court: below, the belated
e ‘motion. to reopen the case on the ground of newly discov- _
ered evidence had for its main purpose “to produce evi- -
dence of statements made by Aghnides to the Canadian
_ Patent Office and to impeach or contradict the evidence of
_ Aghnides.” (1 App. 92.) The District Court decided that
the new evidence would ‘not change his views: The Court -
of Appeals said specifically, “we fully agree with his com-
ment that even if the case were reopened, the —
hse testimony would not alter the result.” ao,
. ‘Similarly, in Tracy v. Terminal R. Assoc., 170 F: *
635, 640 (C. A.. 8, 1948), the Court held that newly dis-
covered evidence must be of such weight and nature that
"if added to: evidence already i in the case it would probably
change the result of trial. Again i in United States v.:Bran-
gen, 142 F. 2d 232,.235 (C. A. 9, 1944) . the Court held
that allegedly newly. discovered evidenee which would not.
- materially change the result and which is in a large part
not newly discovered at all, is not ground for.a new trial.
”: “Phis case also significantly held that the application will be
denied where it appears that the degree of activity or dili- -.
: gence which led to the discovery of evidence after trial
~ would have just as easily have. produced the evidence, had
+ been exercised . prior to trial. In Miller v. Kentucky, 40
me (2d) 820, 822. (C. A. 6, 1930) the Court held that newly
os discovered evidence which tends merely to’ afféct the
weight and credibility of evidence in the case does not
| constitute proper basis: for a new trial. |
(3) The so-called false pre-trial testimony was simply
a natural mistake of-one who had ‘many patent applica-
tions in many countries. There is no evidence ‘that it was
- made to cover up or hide mening, ie oe
f-
ae.
’
_ ae aan
-
Petitioner: had ample opportunity to examine » aah
nides during the trial, and did in fact examine him at
: length on the subject of the Belgian. patent at each of three
, trial sessions in the course of a period of ayear. —
The case of. Keystone Driller Co. v. General Excavator
oo, 290 U. S. 240, 245,-holds:
ts douiete of equity “ not aiid the quality of |
suitors the test. They apply the maxim requiring .
‘clean hands only where some unconscionable act of
*® .. Jotie coming for relief has immediate arid necessary
. relation to the equity that he seeks in respect of the
matter in litigation. They-do not close their doors. be-
“cause .of plaintiff's misconduct, whatever its char-
acter, that has no relation to anything involved: in
-. the suit, but only for such violations of conscience as
a: in“ some ‘measure affect the equitable relations be- —
- twéen the parties in respect. of something brought.
before the court for adjudication.” a
‘In the present. “ease . the Court of Appeals Gs the
| Fourth Circuit gave special consideration to this matter
of alleged fraud, and held in effect that Aghnides’ state-
menis in Canada had no immediate and necessary relation
“to the equitable relations between the parties in respect
_. to the matter brought before the court for adjudication,
~ to’ wit, the validity as infringement of U. S.. Patent
2,210,846. Py ee ee io
(4) There hie been no misuse of the International
- Patent. Conv ention to claim one date of invention in the
U. S.,.and a different date in Canada: In the Canadian.
application the Convention was not used to claim priestly
based-‘on the Belgian filing. date.
Moreover, Article 4 bis ‘of the International | Patent
Convention (Appendix D, page uxxvii) itself provides:
s
P
3 ; sad
“(1)' Patents applied for in the various countries
- of the Union by persons entitled to the benefits of the
Union shall. be independent of the patents obtained |
' . for the same invention in other countries, whether or
not such countries be parties to the Union.
“(2) This stipulation must receive a strict inter-
pretation; in particular, it shall be understood to mean
that patents applied for during the period of priority
are independent, both as regards the grounds for re-
fusal and revocation and as ‘regards their normal
duration. ” (Emphasis added. ) :
The Fourth Circuit committed no error of lew in .
‘declining to find Aghnides’: representations in Canada,
even if untrue, constituted such unclean hands as to dis-*
entitle him to the relief sought. They said that if he made
a misstatement.in Canada, such might bear upon the valid- .
- ity of his Canadian patent, but would not alter the fact
that h¢ told the U. S. Patent Office the truth, and that his
U.S. patent was obtained without deception or fraud.
. .. The Fourth Circuit decision is not in direct conflict
with the rule of law-of Jungersen v. Baden et al. (CA 2) -
166 F. 2d 807, cited by the Petitioner. . In that -case the
Court said that the inventor’s appraisal in a. foreign patent
’ of his invention in the United States was important. There,
| the appraisal was also supported by the prior art, and there
- was no proof to the contrary. Here, the statements by
-- Aghnides in his Canadian application tone‘ cateille made
_by his solicitors in the course ef argument to the Canadian
Patent Office. ce ca ?
| The case of ‘Sevasin et al. v. Wright Aeronautical
Corp., 54 F. Supp. 244, 251, cited. by. petitioner, merely
holds that statements in foreign applications may be re-
ceived in evidence as admissions against interest.
10
Petitioner has attempted to inject the issue of an In-
ternational treaty in this case by arguing that in some way
the grant of Aghnides’ U: S. patent provided the means to
perpetrate a fraud on Canada. We fail to see how any
"treaty is involved, regardless. of what Aghnides said in
Canada. All of the information needed to determine the
relationship and effect of the several Aghnides applica-
tions was before the Canadian Patent Office, including the
fact that the U. S. application claimed the priority of the
- Belgian application. The effect of the Belgian patent upon _
‘the Canadian application was a matter for independent de-
termination by the Canadian Patent: Office. The weight
given by the Canadian Patent Office to acts of the United
States. Patent Office i ina corresponding application i is again :
a matter within the sole discretion of the. Canadian Patent
Office: — «. > : 2
Regardless of when was said wy way , of Seirsunt in
- the Canadian Patent Office; the facts before it were that in
the corresponding U. S. application which had resulted in.
U. S.. patent 2,210,846, priority based on the Belgian ap-
plication. was claimed under the’Convention, and that
claims conforming to the U: S’ patent claims were being
asserted in the Canadian application, where priority based
‘on the Belgian applicatioh was not and ‘could not be
. claimed because the Canadian filing date was five years
after. the Belgian filing date. The Canadian Patent Office
had previously tited an Aghnides British patent which
was the counterpart of the Belgian patent. If the Canadian
Patent Office chose to ignore or disagree with the U. S.
| Patent Office as to the effect of the Belgian patent. or its
British counterpart on the claims being asserted in. the
Canadian Xpplication, that is clearly a matter for inde-
pendent determination .by the Canadian Patent Office.
bgt 11 |
7 Thus, Aghnides has done nothing in derogation to the '
. apes and purpose of an international treaty; in the United
tes he has validly claimed priority of his Belgian pat- .
ent under the International Patent Convention, and ‘in
Canada he has not claimed such priority; so that peti-
tioner’s attempt to inject into*this case the obligations of
the United States to support the “public welfare” pur-
poses of international treaties has no substance. _
II. The Conflict Between the Seventh and Fourth Circuits.
- . The case of Universal Oil Co..%. Globe Oil Co., 322
U.S. 471, 433; cited by petitioner, holds that the Supreme
Court will grant certiorari to resolve conflicting decisions
between Circuit Courts @f Appeals as to the same patent 3
. and upon substantially the same set of facts.
In the present case the Court of Appeals for ‘the
Fourth Circuit. and the District J udge below gave careful
' consideration to the previous, decision. by the Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, the District J Ne ob-
serving that he felt constrained to follow the Seventh
Circuit if the evidence warranted it. In their. opinion
(Appendix A, p. ii) the Fourth Circuit said that:
ee # to avoid unnecessary conflict’ between the
Circuits, we deemed it our dutyto—address~our-~*
selves independently and- with special care to an
examination of the District Court’s findings. Of
course, our review. is of the record made in the Dis-
trict Court below, which is different from the Goodrie .
record, and appears to be more detailed and com-
x prehensive.” (Emphasis supplied. )
_ This Court has held that a holding by a Court of Ap-
peals with respect to patent validity is not binding in a
’ later case even in the same circuit, if the record in the later _
case is different. Triplett v. Lowell 297 U. S. 638.
12 |
The Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit predi-
cated its decision essentially on the prior British Felten
patent and said (Appendix B,. page xxiv) that it had “the.
benefit of tests in open court.” Those tests were néces- _
sarily crowded into part of the time permitted for an ap-
pellant’s argument and. were observed by the court only
from the bench at a considérable distance. The tests in
‘the Fourth Circuit were demonstrations of transparent
and cut away mi@flels of the Felten and Aghnides devices
constructed so that the Court could see what actually takes
place inside the devices when they are operating, rather:
than having to reach conclusions based on the apparent.
j results, as the Seventh Circuit was forced to do on the
- record before it.
| By means of the new ana different demonstrations i in
the. Fourth Circuit, it was visually shown that the con-
clusions i in the Seventh Circuit were contrary to fact (PA .
96-100, 103-104, 107-111).
As stated by the Court of Appeals for the Fourth
Circuit (Appendix A, page iii):
b>
“After a long, trial a many experiments con-
ducted in his presence in the courtroom, District
Judge Hayes concluded that Felten operated on a
different principle and did not achieve the result of
Aghnides. One after another of the observations —
‘made in the Goodrie opinion, suggesting similarities
between Felten and Aghnides, were fully answered ..
_ by highly persuasive visual evidence to the contrary.” —
Petitioner's contention that the Seventh. Circuit’s
statement that ‘Felten reads literally én the claims of
_Aghnides”. stands unchallenged, is a mere play on words.
_ The Fourth Circuit says (Appendix, page v) that Felten
doeg, not anticipate the Aghnides patent; that the drawings
are different; that Felten operates on a different. principle:
13
is. , designed to chine a different result; = has never
been utiliz to,achieve the purpose of the —— in-.
— , | |
Sree Commercial Success. |
Petitioner’ s sta’ ment that the Fourth Circuit pn
great emphasis on commercial success and. disregarded |
’ the rule of this Court, that commercial success cannot
make an-invention where there_is none, is patently with-
out foundattort” “The Fourth Circuit merely said (Appen-
+. dix A, page iv) that the commercial success of the Agh-
nides aerator was “noteworthy,” and recognized that:
“While it is true that commercial success d not
determine either invention or the validity of a patent,
nevertheless, in a doubtful case it may be a convinc-
ing factor. Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co. v.
‘Supermarket Equipment Corp., 340 U. S. 147, 153;
_. Textile Machine Works v. Hirsch Textile Machines, .
‘Ine., 302 U. S. 490, 498; Smith v. Ball, 301 U. S. 216,
233. ee. |
; Felten and Aghnides Differ In Principle:
With respect to the difference in principle of opera-
tion between Felten and Aghnides, the Court of Appeals
- adopted and quoted Finding XXVII (f) of the. District
Court (Appendix A, page v.)) which states that in Felten
“the energy of ‘water is spent in creating vacuum and not
in securing aeration”; that Felten ‘adds less than 5/10 of
a eubic inch of air to 1 cubic inch of water whereas Agh-
nides’ aerator adds 6 cubic inches or 12 times as much”;
that Felten secures. his result by means of a conically
“Widening chamber which has no counterpart ih Aghnides;
' that Felten “must keep his chamber flooded,”’ whereas: the
, chamber in Aghnides is not a widening one and was not
flooded but contained only naked. watcr jets in free air
M)
| - oe
striking his resistance ‘screens; and that. Felten’s baskets
are not essential to his operation. and are not elements cor-
responding to Aghnides essential. resistance screens or
shoulders. -
Plainly, these cating: show unmistakably and with
great particularity the difference in principle between Fel-
ten and Aghnides. The Court of Appeals for the Fourth
~ Circuit summed it up as follows (Appendix A, page vii):
are supported by sub- _
- stantial evidence, pointed and convincing, and we are
persuaded that they should not be set aside. They
show that while in Felten some air was present, in-
crease: in the amount of\air would. defeat the opera-
tion of the device, since what was desired was a vac- _
uum; whereas in Aghnidés the presence of a large ©
quantity of air was desiredsto effect aeration, which
is the heart of the invention.”
_ With respect to quantitative any ellen at- |
tempts to show. that Felten and: Aghnides are the same by -
_ comparing the results obtained: by testing the Felten de-.
vice in épen court with the statements Aghnides made in
his foreign. patents:as to the results he expected his aerator
to. obtain. Clearly, the: proper comparison of results is’ -
with the models of Aghnides tested in open.court, whi¢h —
showed that the jet produced by the aerator of Fig. 4 of
the Aghnides patent contained 81.1% (4.3 cu. in. / 5.3 cu.
in.) by volume of‘air, and the jet produced by the Spring-
flo commercial Aghnides aerator contained 85.6% (6 cu.
in. ie i-cu. in.) by volume of air sas App. 217).
Fig. 8 of the Patent. = oa
The question of the possible effect of Fi igure 8 of pat-
ent 2,210,846 upon the claims thereof was considered
: _fully by the Court of f Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on
_ 1d
Ya
Bes two occasions: once on the appeal and again on the petition . 3
for rehearing of which specific subject was alleged. error
in the éourt’s ruling. on Figure 8.
The only reference to Figure 8 by the Count of rae 2
- peals for the.Seventh Circuit was an inferential one
_ wherein the court said’merely that one form of Aghnides
may be used as a vacuum pump. ,
7 On the appeal the —— Circuit held ‘Appendix 2 A,
_ page ix): .
edhe complete : answer is , that the claims are not.
| directed to this figure and do not read upon it any
more than they read upon Felten. The scope of the
claims is controlling, not the figures in the.drawing.
“*.%* * Whether the forms not covered by the
surviving claims remain in the patent or are cancelled
from the drawings is immaterial, for the claims, and |
not the drawings, control.. We consider it immaterial
, that Figure 8, which is not covered by any of, the
claims, was not omitted in the granted patent. De- |
nominati l Envelope Co: v."Duplex Envelope Co.,
4 Cir., 80 F..2d 186, 192; Bassick Co. v. Faultless_
Caster Corp.,.7 Cir.; 105 F. 2d 228, 231;‘'see also. .
Freedman, v. Friedman, 4 Cir., 242 F. 2d 364.”
These cases cited by the Fourth Circuit fully answer ~
petitioner’s contentions with respect to file wrapper es-
toppel, which contentions amount to an attempt to ‘make.
Figue 8 into something it actually isn’t, by likening Fig-
ure 8 to the other figures in the patent. ‘The above cases
hold that it is the language of the claims which controls, :
__and not statements of the solicitor in the course of the Pat=:
ent Office proceeding to. obtain the patent. See also Auto. -
Pneumatic Action Co. v. Kindler & Collins, 247 .. _ ‘
% A; 2, 1917). . .
Ce
In their. opinion Paar the petition for rehearing oo
_ the Fourth Circuit again: reiterated that the claims of the
' patent do not relate to Figure 8 (Appendix A, page
xviii). Aghnides testified length both with respect to
Figure 8 and with réspect to Feten. He gave reasons why
both were vacuum pumps as distinguished from aerators
(PA 52-53). /.. |
_ The Patent Office cited Felten and yet the Board of A
Appeals allowed the claims. : Came, it did not think they.
* read on Felten. |
Actually, Figure 8 is: ‘mere ‘aabins in 7 patent:
- carried over from the earlier patent application. of. which |
the one resulting in the patent, after, many changes in the
_ Claims,” was a’ continuation in’ part. As observed by the,
Fourth Circuit (Appendix A, page ix):
“When an application for a patent : is . “filed,” many
forms | may be shown and an attempt made to cover
them all in the claims as originally presented. During ©
the prosecution of the application, however, the. |
' » claims may be réstricted in-the light of the prior art. —
In the end, only certain of the forms shown may be
covered by the restricted claims.”
- The cases cited by petitioner. 4n an attempt to create a -
éonilict with’ the Court of Customs and Patent Appeals. are
not in point.* They do not cover situations where a figure
* The issue in the Ansiiiation al MeCorn, 212 F. 2d 797, 799,
was whether a minor mudification consisting of an abrupt differ-
ence in rate of pitch of a two-part screw was patentable over one
having a gradual difference, where the. specification stated that
- the rate of pitch wovld “depend upon convenience.” —
Application of ‘Stewart, 222 F..2d, 747, 754, relates to a
chemical, not a mechanical, invention and involves the eqtiva-—
lency of using a spray or a wash i in a process fér washing a water-
soluble emulsion from a plate, where the specification did not
indicate any difference. The case relies upon the doctrine of
equivalents set forth in’ In re Borcherdt, 197 F. 2d 550 (CEPA)
which is strictly limited to chemical cases. —
Applicetion of Lindberg, 194 F. 2d 732, 736, has to do with.
the equivalency of a hydraulic. drive with a. mechanical drive, -~
where the hydraulic drive was one element: in a Pleimed: com-
rt
\
we Alrives were equivalent
ae
, disclosed in an original application was’ not covered by .
-\the claims which finally issued in a continuation applica-
_- tion, and the specification shows that the. figure is not an._—
| equivalent. | a
. Il. No Decision is nearer by “the iene Court to
Forestall Excessive Future Litigation. ,
Petitioner’ s contentions with ‘respect to excessive
future litigation involving Patent 2,210,846 have already
— disposed of by pointing out that the only two cases
‘still pending involving the patent, concern parties hereto.
heir privies. \ \These are cases brought not by Aghnides
or Chase, but by Melard Mfg. anf _ is bound by o |
| Fourth Circuit decision. “
CONCLUSION.
We respectfully urge that the petition be denied.
_ Respectfully submitted, .
ag ni 4 ie i Bee, :
Everett R. HamMi.ton? |
. . Attorneys for Respondeiite |
) October, 1957.
. “4
4 Contin d from preceding page) .
‘bination of eleménts co prising a'spraying device, where a claim |
of the application broadly covered: both a hydraulic and a”
mechanical drive, and o ——— indicated that = two.
\
a
A i
fe x . . - <2
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.