Petition for A Writ of Certiorari — Kress v. Aghnides (No. 508)
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
—— as - ‘ i) ee weruti, Ud. '
= oO | FILED | |
ANS SL SEP 27 1957
' 3 ve | JOHN T. FEY, Clerk |
IN THE
_ Supreme Court of the United States
Ocronen TERM, 1957.
e
508
.% ? KRESS & sania, :
a os - Petitioner,
OB.
ELIE P. AGHNIDES ‘AND CHASE BRASS & COPPER
‘ : -CO., INC.,
Respondents,
_
PETITION FOR & WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF. APPEALS. FOR
} : tHE. FOURTH CIRCUIT. rot
Wii Freeman;
Norman LeEttvin,
- D. D. ALLEGRETTI,
135 S. La Salle treet, 's
| Chicago 3, IMinois, |
i Att prmeys per Petitioner,
pt
THE GUNTHORP. WARREN PRINTING COMPARY, emeaed
aes
_ INDEX. ered
LOND oe ae PAGE
7 Petition for Writ of Cantinonn! eee Serer T err C er a
Opinions Below ....... heeed ee Weed owen Sensseus cas oa
Jurisdiction Baws meg? | Spr para ee ne eae caweent 3
~ Questions Pr -esented rave bead wee PS inks aa akaw kngesles 4
“Statutes and Treatiés POI: 5 ccc cen deuce scuneuas # F
Statement of 2 SE eee eee MPC OE oC Te wee 6
Reasons for,Granting the Writ........... asad ‘sais :
- Conclusion ...:....... enve déSe ena kGas VAROR EATERS 23
Appendix: er fg |
Appendix A—Opinion of Coart of “Appeals for the.
Fourth C ircuit tin Kress V. Aghnides, Teer ea
Supplementary. “Opinion of Court. of Appeals of
—- Fourth Cireyit in Kress v. Aghnides, et al......... xv
Appendix B—Opinion ‘of Court of Appeals: for the
Seventh Cireuit in Aghnides ‘v. Goodrie, et al. .... ” xix
_ Appendix C—Opinion of Court of Appeals ° for the Bee
Seventh Circuit in Aghnides v. Holden; et al.......XXvVl
Appendix D—Patent Statutes, 35°U. S. C. $102. Peews XXxi ;
International Patent Cofvention ..«............0. XXXiL.
| © x oe. * |
. CrTaTIons.
| | Cases. a
Similan Vv. Goodrie, a al., 210 F. 2d 859,” Sertisxari.
| ‘Denied 348 U.S. 826...... ny ee gerne pacus 2,9, 17,19
Aghnides v. Holden, et al., 226 F. 2d 949. pek aces eee, "y
ao v. mig Meyer’s Company, 117 F. ‘Supp. 839 ;
99 U. S. P. Q. 488; Findings of Fact at. 99 U.S... :
eet as eae ea oes -aebaneses ecrrrriore rer rr a Sek
.
~
e
Hazel- Atlas Glass Co. v. Hartford Empire Co., 322
U. S. 238; 64S. Ct. 997....... ae ei 10,16
Jungerson v. “Baden, et al., 2 Cir., 166 F, 2d 807, Af.
firmed 335 U. 8.°560; 69.8. Ct. 269. (1949). wads ne 4 ‘12
: Jungerson Vv. Ostby & Barton Co., et al., 335 U. ‘8. 560; .
- 69S, Ct. i tisiciitees che dei tadsehaeee es hee ees 18
Key stone- Driller Co. v. oo thasienta Co., 290.
UL S. 240; 54 S.Ct: rie
Lindberg, Application of, 194 F. 2d 732 (CCPA—1954)" Z1 |
_ MeCarn, Application of, 212 F; 2d 797 (CCPA—1954) 21
: Precision Instrument. Mfg. Co. v. Automotive Mainte-
“nance Machinery Company, 324 U. ‘S. 806; 65S. Ct.
993 “@g ies & 6: Oe RSS SAO RON SE OA Oe EO OO SM _. 10,16
-. Safazin, et oh se Sitch Aesetieiaihaas — 54 F.
G
or"
A <«
sete One,
Supp. ‘244, Affirmed 162 F. 2d 960 (2 Cir—1947).... 12 |,
Steele, et al. v. Bulova Watch Co., Inc., 344 U.S, 280;
73 St. 252.0... Spee meine Vib Sola Keer 15, 16 .
Stewart, Application of, 222 F. 2d 747 (CCPA~-4955) : 21
United States v."Be mont, 301 U.S. 324; 57 S. Ct.
eee? ft gh aieacee aa gts Re aans SOA .13, 16°
United States v. ‘The Libelants and Claimants of The
Schooner’ Amistad, ete. , 40 U.S. 518; 10 L. ‘Ad. 826. .13,; 15 |
Universal Oil Co. v. Globe, Oil Co., —_ U. S. 471; 64
| Sei Ne ee eran re Tg
Statuteg, and Treaties. ote
... Patent Statutes, 39 U.S. C..§ 108. .......6.....: aa ‘ete’
International Patent Conv ention, 53 Statutes 1748...
seen eee eeeewenceteesasceaees LD Sula uilee eed ae 5,6, 10-17
e°: ee w
IN THE
"Supreme Court of the United State
OcToBER TERM, 1957.
S. H. KRESS & COMPANY, ~') .°*.
7 : _-Petttioner,
\ ea <7 vs. |
- ELIE P. -AGHNIDES AND CHASE BRASS & COPPER.
CO., INC.;
.. eee a , Respondents,
——
-
_ PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT.OF APPEALS FOR
a berets
- &2
_- =
Your Patitipner, S. H. Kress & Gains, , prays that a — 2
“writ of certiorari issue e to review the judgment of the Court
of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, entered in the above
| entitled ¢ case on: _ 17, 1957. ee Sua
oe _ OPINIONS BELOW
The ‘Opinion of the District Court (1 App. 93- 104)* is
reported at 140 F. Supp. 582. The Opinion of the Court of
Appeals of the Fourth Circuit, reported at occ Fe 2d ceccony ’
is printed in Appendix A hereto, infra, pagés i to xiv. The
_ Court of Appeals’ Supplementary Opinion on Motions for
" “y App.. ..”? and ‘‘2 App....’* refer respectively to the
portion of the Trial Record printed | in Volume lzand Volume 2 of
Appellant’s (Kress’) Appendix before the’ Court of —- of the ;
* Fourth Cireuit.
t
Rehearing is printed in Appéndis A, tee. pages. xv to
“Xviii. oa
The prior Opinion of the Gian of Appeals of the Sev-
enth Circuit,-with which the Opinion of the Court of Ap!
peals. of the Fourth Circuit is in direct conflict, is Aghnides .
_ -v. Goodrie et al., 210 F. 2d 859, certiorari denied 348 U.S.
826', and is pees in- Agee B hereto, aren pages xix
to Xxv. .: |
The validity of the patent here involved, 2 was adjudicated
in an uncontested case in the District Court for the Middle .
District of North: Carolina, Greensboro Division, an thé _.
Fourth Circuit, in Aghnides v. The Meyer’s Company, } a
F..Supp. 839, 99 U. 8. P. Q. 488, feezmaend st SF eect No :
—— appeal was taker. re,
The validity of the subject patent was also adjudicated =
-. by summary judgment in the District Court for the North- -
er ern District of Illinois in Aghnides v.. Holden et al., 104
.. CREF. Q. 168; but the décision. of. the District Deut was —
| reversed by the Courtsof Appeals for the Seventh h Cirenit___-_--
. 226 F, 2d 949 (printed in Appendix C hereto, infra,’ ‘pages. |
“xxvii to XXX )p: on the basis that Summary Judgment should
not have been granted, , and the case was remanded and now ~
- awaits trial. ° oy a re
a Ly me ~ g
ieee ee P Nb J ee ° .
~ ; «
«> - ° .
Cie . ‘ i : . mi aH
. : Fe a
tr
o anh
1. _ Based in part upon the’ uncontested District Court Opinion
of validity, and the Seventh. Cireuit’s \Opinion..of invalidity,
Aghnides petitioned this Court for review, ‘but, ' Hghtfully, this
Court denied that Petition.. 348 U. S. 826. -
2. ‘U.S. Patent No. 2 ,210,846, issued to a r. "Aghnides and en-
titled “Figg Mixing Device”’. .-
2;
GF
‘3
sit -
. .
‘JURISDICTION ‘
The Judgment of the Court of Appeals for the Fourth
| Cireuit was entered on May 17, 1957. Kress’ timely Motion
‘for Rehearing was denied in a Supplementary Opinion
dated July 9, 1957. | .
‘This Court’s jurisdiction is invoked under Title 98 U.S.
C. § 1254(1). Jurisdiction is also:based upon a direct é6n-
o
‘flict in the Opinions of the Courts of Appeals of the Fourth
Circuit and the Seventh. Circuit. Universal Oil Co. v. Globe.
Ou Co., 322 U.S. 471, 473; 64 S. Ct. 1110, 1111,
Jurisdictién—is also based ‘upon the fact that there is .
pending substantial litigation in the Second Circiit® and
Seventh Circuit‘ involving the Aghnides patent 2,210, 846, . ,
-which is the subject of this Petition; and in the interest of
uniformity it is. submitted that the conflict ‘of. opinions
should be resolved.
> Jurisdiction is also. ‘based upon ee. fact that: one isa
ternational ‘‘treaty.’ to which the United States has ad-
heed since 1887. The issue presented is a substantial one,
is one of first i impression before this Court, and is of great. .
| public importance., It is important that this Court express
-itself on this substantial issue, since: it involves a Treaty.®
3(a). Marshall Mctal Products v. Aghnides, Civil Action 85-272,
Filed June 3, 1953. in the District Court for Southern District of
New York (2 App. 141).
‘ieain involves the International Patent Convention, an in- -
(b). Melard Mfg. Corp. v. Aghnides, Civil Action 95-355, Filed .
- New York (2 ‘App. 144)
4(a). Aghnides v. Holden et al, Civil Abtien 50.0 1022, Filed
_ July 19, 1950 in the District: Court for Northern IHinois, Eastern .
Division (2 App: 137).
.(b)., Melard Mfg. Corp. v. Chasd\ Brass é ‘Copper Co., Inc., et -°
al.’ Ciyil Action 55 C84, Filed Jan. 18, 1955, in the District Court
for Northern Illinois, Eastern Division ( 2 App. 145 A’).
5. United States Constitution—Article IIT, Section 2
x
ee | ne ae
+.
Questions PRESENTED
L Where a foreign inventor, seeking the spedial priv- .
ileges afforded him by the International Patent Convention,
first applies for d*patent in Belgium and thereafter er files in
both the United States and Canada other-applications for
patent, securing in both United States and Canada identical.
patent. -claims—monopolies—predicated upon “asserting in -
the United States, and repudiating in Canada, continuity -
with the same Belgian application, then do the opposite
_ positions of both asserting and repudiating continuity with
the same Belgian application constituté a background of.
- fraud oF inequitable conduct which renders the United
States patent invalid or unenforceable i in, equity?
In short—may an inventor misuse the International Pat- |
on ent Convention to remove a bar-ii order to obtain patent
claims in the United States, arid make a directly contradict-
- atory sworn statement in order to obtain the identical pat-
ent claims in another country, ‘both adherents to the In-
ternational patent Convention?
.. gids The Court of pon for the Fourth Circuit found *
patent 2, 210,846 ‘to be valid over the prior British patent
.to Felten.
The Court of Appeals for ihe Seventh Cireuit found pat-
nits ent, 2,210,846 ‘to be invalid in view of the Priot British
~
patent to Felten. |
. _ (A) The broad enables eeieaa by the, conflict; is—
Is the patent valid or invalid? |
claims of patent 2,210,846 read on the device shown i in
Figure 8 of the patent, and where Aghnides now ad- —
(B) A narrower collateral question srenuatin is
- Where Aghnideés and’the Patent Office. both agreed dur-
ing prosecution of the application for patent that the .
a
—~-: of lawt -
me)?
. a
aie
Oe ae
mits: that : Figure Bi is the same as s the Felten: prioreart 4
‘ patent, ‘then is not — 2,210, 846 invalid asa matter
sy be oh ®
‘STATUTES AND TREATIES INVOLVED ae
: The Statutes herein involved are the Patent Stafiites, nil
in particular, R. 8. 4886 and R. S. 4887, 35 U. S. CS § 102.
printed in ‘Appendix 'D. hereto,’ infra, ‘page XXX.
The Treaty involved i is the International Patent Conv en- |
tion, 53 Statutes 1748. Pertinent portions of the Treaty
are ; printed in Appendix D hereto, infra, pages »xxxii ‘to
XXXV ii. Pd af
< rr <i 3 : ; : Ss oO
. % rs 5 ¢ Bs hs
a
i , \
\ i
/
l
> @ .
io
Fs
6 °
oe ‘STATEMENT OF FACTS.
4 The facts relevant to Question I are: Bad
On December. 8, 1934, Aghnides, a citizen of Gresee ie;
App. 30), filed application for patent in! Belgium. The
Belgian patent issued on January 31, 1935 (2 App. 11-18).
. Another Aghnides patent corresponding to the Belgian ap-
plication issued in Great Britain on July 6, 1937 (2 App.
218-220): .
On December 4, 1935, claiming ae the: International |
Patent, Convention, Aghnides. filed. a first application for
patent i inthe United States (2 App. 19- 31).
~ The 1935 U. S. application corresponding to the Belgian
application did not issue as a patent (2 App. 47). While
the 1935 U. S.. application was pending, Aghnides filed a
second, new and different, U. S. patent application. on
December 31, 1937 (2. App. 49-60), reeling. in the eo
in suit, Ro. 2,210,846 (2 App. 1-5). . ve
During the prosecution of the 1937 U. S. Ssisttsanion: ‘the
issued Aghnides British ‘patent was cited by the Patent
Examiner as prior.art (2 App. 71-72). The British patent °
would have been insurmouhtable opposition to the issuance
of a patent. To avoid this basis of opposition, Aghnides -
asserted that the second filed 1937 U: 8. application was ;
for’ the same invention as,disclosed earlier in Belgium [2 :
App. 58-59, 72- 73), and hence was entitled to the benefits
of the ‘International Patent Convention, and to an effective = *
filing date of December 8, 1934. (Since ‘the Belgian filing
_date was prior to the filing date for the British. patent, the |
‘assertion of continuity and similarity between the Belgian °
and the second filed U. S. applications was effective to
obviate the Patent Examiner’s rejection.) Only said repre-
sentation and assertion to the U.S. Patent Office’ (of con-.
tinuity and similarity between the Belgian and the second _
filed U..S. applications} induced the U. S. Patent Office to no
a.
a
“longer consider the Aan British patent as a prior art
“reference. |
On August 6, 1940, paterit 2 210, 846 iene and bore on
its face {2 App. 3), the assertion of continuity betw een i!
and thé#934 Belgian application.®
On November 15, 1939, nearly five years after the filing
date of the 1934 Belgian applieation, Aghnides filed. an ap-
z plication for patent in Canada (2 App. 323-335). Aghnides - .
‘asserted in said application five: claims identical with the
five claims in the issued U.S; patent 2,210,846 (2 App. 345)
The Canadian Patent Office, like the U. S. Patent Office,
“Cited the 1937 British patent as a ‘prior-art reference (20
~ App. 359), and also inquired asto thé status of the Belgian
application upon which, Canada noted, the U. 8. - patent:
_ 2,210,846 based convention priority (2 App. 359).°°
Aghnides,.in his reply to the Canadian Patent Office, on
the question ‘of. Convention priority, repudiated any simi- -
larity between the U. S. patent 2,210,846 | and the 1934
Belgian application, stating (2 App. 361) ::
8 ‘There i is an important fact to remember, however; -
the said Belgian 1934 application™ did not disclose
fully the bubbly-stream principle disclosed in Holland,
weden, the United States patent No. 2,210,846, the
‘instant Canadian case and British Specification No.
| i 625 ,084. i is. Se crest 4.
&
ah 6. Incidentally, the Aghnides U. S. patent 2,316,832 which was
ple:
also in issue in the trial of this case, also bears on its face an asser-
-- tion of continuity between it and the 1934 Belgian application, as :
.. Aghnides asserted such continuity under the International Patent .
Convention before the U. S. Patent Office. The Trial Record .con-
clusively shows that no such continuity exists, and that the refer-
ence. in patent 2, 316, 832 ta the 1934 Belgian Convention application
is erroneous.
7a. This is the sathint ‘scihlantien which is referred ‘to in the
U.S. oath (2. App. 58-59), and which was relied upon to claim
_ Convention asia for ~ U.S. Patent 2 210, 846. .
» ?
° @
‘.. means of ‘making a bubbly-stream were disclosed when
’ the United States text (application No. 182,884) was.
rewritten, although the- Convention Belgian applica-
_ tiomdid mention the emulsion of air in a water stream. -
; ‘‘Therefore, tle priority claims in the present case
aré correct and support. ‘properly’ the insfant dis-
closure: if is the Belgian Convention. which, in the -
United States patent-No, 2,2 210,846 confuses the issue.
~ beeause, actually said Belgian case does not teach the
. bubbly-stream as itis known to-day. (Emphasis ours.)
a “The same remarks apply also to tk@ British Speci- .
1935, prior to the ¥xst ‘disclosure of the bubbly-streara
in United States cember 1937,’”*
, Bes, . ° . 6
' &: ‘The facts relevant to Question II are: © 7
fieation No: rit was filed Deéember 4th,
: The Aghnides patent! 9,910,846 is entitled ‘*F luid Mix-
“Ti is oily in asinine 1937" that the ways s and
av
9
| ing Device’’. It is ‘described as a device. “for intimately
mixing gas with a liquid’? (2 App. 3, Col: 1, Lines i- -2),.
and is now known as an “aerator”? for use on an ordinary
home faucet.
The Felten (British) patent of 1909 (2. App. 275- 277), -
upon whieh the Court of Appeals of the Seventh’ Circuit
relied in holding the Aghnides patent invalid, is entitled
. ‘Ifprovements in or relating ao Mision Devices’’. The
Felten specification states (2. App. 275) : |
“<This- invention relates to a new mixing’ device >
‘ehiefly intended for producing such mixtures from a
‘ gas>or. vapour-like substance and a liquid substance
@ @ @»» oa eee g
_ ” :
A specific | us? of Felten’s mixing device is shown in the
e
A “T., This date is 3 years after the Convention date claimed and’ .
. - appearing on Patent 2,210,846. —. me
7e. The intpert of this statement is. directly contrary to what
Aghnides told the U. S. Patent Office (2 App. 73) when it cited the
sa British panes 468, 687 | as 8 prior art-reference. -f
7
bs ;
¢
‘
. ;
aa ©
or
>. ar
vu S. he patent,’ 1,090, 044 (2° App. 299.305). as helas
mounted: at the discharge end of an ordinary home faucet:
| Tests of a Felten devi ice before the Trial Court showed
that it delivered a non- splash bubbly stream of air and .
- water. (1 App. 145, 149): )
Aghnides’. patent discloses a number of alternate pooner .
of. his device (2 App. 1). During @ the prosecution of his ap-
: plication for patent in the U. S., he affirmatively asserted
‘that claims, W which. are here in issue, read on the form of.
device shown in Figure 8 of the patent (2 App.. 95). ¢ —.
Patent Office agreed (2 App: 104).
Aghnides. now admits that Figure 8 is ‘Tike’ Felten and
thus is old in the prior art. ‘However, Aghnides now as- ~-
serts, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has so held, ..
that Figure-8 is«gutside the scope of the claims of the
patent which is here i in issue. |
_ =
This latter holding of the Court of Appeals of the Fourth |
_ . Circuit is in direct conflict with the Opinion of the-Court rt of |
oe iad ee for the Seventh Circuit’.
<>
~
:
ok.
os ;
Say
.
8.. Tn Aghnides v. Goodrie et. al., 210 F. F oP 250, 863 thguendie
B, infra, pages xxiv to-xxv),. the Seventh: Circuit stated: ;
__ <* ® * Felten reads literally on the claims of Aghnides idan
? . sae é BS * 2:
-- The important thing is that each 3 troduces a vapor, a gas,
ozone or air, into moving water in order to mix the two sub-
stances. It seems to us utterly immaterial that Felten’s ap-
paratus may also be used as a vacuum. pump; so Indeed may
~ one form of Aghnides. Element for element, the two are the
‘same * * * We conclude then that the trial court rightfully
found that Felten anticipated Aghnides and taught the latter
all, that he needed to know i in order to build his mixer of .gas
and. fluid, 1.e., air and water.’
. AV
_REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
. The Issues Relating to Patent Misuse, or Fraud, “Under ,
the ‘sion and J ‘Patent Convention Are Ones of First
Impression and Are of Great Public — hk,
" Aghnides’ claimed dates of invention, for the’ same in-
__-vention, in the U. S. and. in Canada aré wholly contra- _
dictory. The date claimed in the U. S. is expressly re-. .
pudiated in Canada. Both positions cannot be correet.
_ Fhe alternative defenses presented by: Kress were that— |
_ (1) Aghnides falsified. to the U.S. Patent Office (to
remove the 1937 British patent as a reference), and
therefore the ’846 patent was invalid, as it was pro-
‘ cured by fraud... Hazel-Ailas Glass Co. .v: Hartford
Empire Co.,. 822 U. S. 238, 250;'64,S.. Ct. 997, 1003. —
(2) The ‘undisclosed fraud perpetrated on either
equtroveiicy: diawnliDes the patentee to any. equitable
relief. Precision Instrument -Mfg. Co. v. Automotive, -
‘Maintenance Machinery Gompany, 324 U. S. 806, 816;
65 S. Ct. 993. 998. ~
(3) The false pre-trial teatiniony’. we “eover up”
and hide the fact that the claimed: date of invention in
- Canada conflicted with the claimed date of invention
in the,U. S., disentitles the patentee to equitable re-
lief, eystone- Driller Co. v. General Excavator Co.,
* 290 U- S-.240, 244, 54 S. Ct. 146, 147.
| (4) The misuse of the International Patent Conven- .
‘tion to claim one date of invention in the U. S. and to
« claim a different date of invention in Canada, for iden-
| _ tical claims here in controversy, disentitles the patent-
ee to equitable relief. | Precision Instrument M fg. Co.
"9. At pre-trial deposition Aghnides testified (1 App. 301), that,
his Canadian patent was based on his Belgian patent, and was filed
within the one year period following ‘the filing of the ‘Belgian ap-
plication (as provided for by the International Convention). The
Canadian application was actually filed nearly five years after the
. filing date of the Belgian application (2 App. 323) and its file
wrapper expressly denies that the Canadian application 1 is homes on. -
the Belgian patent (2 App. 361).
AA
ae
v. Suits Maintenance Machinery Company, 324 |
+ U.S. 806, 65 S. Ct. 993. , Lo
\
‘In its Opinion (Appendix A, infra, page xiii) the Fourth
-“Cireuit decided that. _Aghnides told the truth to the U. S.
Patent Office, and declined to find that Aghnides’ repre-
sentations in Canada, even if they were untrue, constituted
misconduct— _&
ue S-© closely related to the proceedings in this
country and the issuance of the patent to him here as
“ to invalidate the grant or. to constitute such unclean
hands as to disentitle him to the relief he asks in this
ease.’ 77
In so holding, the Fourth Circuit committed the follow- ”
~ ing. errors of law:
First. The facts show that Aghnides has admitted, in
Canada (2 App. 361):
steal the said Belvian 1934 application didnot dis- 3
: close fully the bubbly-stream. principle disclosed -in |
NSS 4 eee ‘States patent No. 2,210, — oo
and :
~ - “Tt is only, in “December 1937 that the ways and
means of making a bubbly stream were disclosed when
the United States text (application No. 182,884). was
rewritten * * *’’, and -
“*°* * actually said Belgian case abe not teach the
bubbly- stream as it is known todayg’’
‘Despite these ‘clear and ‘unequivoeal ,admissions_ by
Aghnides, the Fourth we Court stated ( Appendix’ A,
infra, page xill):.
«<* ** From our own examination of the U nited States
patent ’846 and the Belgian patenf, we think it, un-
questionably true that they are tas Aghnides told. the
United States: Patent Office, the same invention.’’
The Fourth Cireait? s failure to consider. the conclusive
| admissions against interest made by the patentee in a
e
12
foreign patent: corresponding -to the one in suit,-appears
to be in direet eonflict with the rule of law enunciated by
the Second Circtit in the case of Jungerson v. Baden et al,‘
2 Cir. 166 F.-2d 807, 809 —" 335 U. S. 560, 69.S. ot
269—Supreme Court—1949).
In the Jungerson case, the inv entor’s appraisal of his
own invention, as was found to be stated in his British
patent, was held; by the Second Cireuit Court of Appeals,
to be a controlling admission which was binding upon the |
inventor’s U, S.. patent. The Jungerson: ease thus stands
for the proposition of law that an inver‘or’s appraisal! of.
his own invention and ‘of ‘the prior art relating to it, as :
; appears in his own foreign patents, constitutes, a. binding
admission against interest.’°
- The failure by the Fourth Circuit j in .the ingtant caedo
_____ consider Aghnides’ statements in Canada to be binding -
admissions against interest thus appears to.be-in direct
conflict with the Second Circuit on this point of law.
- Second. (a) The question of withholding equitable .re-—
_ hef—because of the patentee’s misuse of the International
Convention, or by reason of his perpetrating a. fraud upon
'. Canada, under the Convention, based on his U. S. ’846
patent—is one of first impression before the U. S. Courts.
{b) The refusal by the Fourth Circuit to withhold -
equitable relief: baseds on thé patentee’s misuse or fraud
under the International Patent Convention, and the Fourth’
Circuit's s holding that Aghnides’ Canadian patent proceed-
ings (involving the identical patent claims here in issue
which were procured in the U.-S. under the Convention)
“would not be so closély related to'**.* the issuance of
the petent to him here’’, failed to take cognizance of the
pertinent Supreme Court decisions respecting rights and.
obligations under treaties, . : )
10. Also, see Sarazin et al. v. WwW right Ae ronautical Corp., 54-F..
Supp. 244, 25) (affirmed 162 F. 2d 960, 2-Cir.—1947).. wherein the
same rule of law'was invoked. _ . <—
&
The Sanedaie Court has stated with regard to ‘*treaties”’,
United States v. Belmont, 801 U. S. 324, 330, 57 S. Ct.°758,
761, that:
A treaty signifies ‘a seal made between. two or
.
more.independent nations, with a view to the yoene wel-
angel ’? (Emphasis ours. )
The. Supreme Court. has also stated in” rigand ‘to
‘‘treaties’’, in the case of The United States v. The Libel-
ants and Claimants of The Schooner Amistad, ete., 40 U.S.
518, 595, 10 L: Bd. 826, 854, that:
“«* * * Tn the solemn. treaties. betw ecn mations it
can never be presumed that either State intends to pro-
vide the means of perpetrating or protecting frauds;° —
* * #99 |
In view of what the Supreme Court stated in the Amistad
case, supra; it must be presumed that-thie, United States did
not ‘intend, in its grant of the. 7846 patent; to provide a
‘means, for perpetrating a fraud on Ganada. However, the .
record is clear that the claims i in the Canadian patent were
there entered and allowed primarily because they were iden-
tical with the ones that had been allow ed in the United
States Patent Office (2 App. 345- 346).
While it‘i is not incumbent upon the Canadian Patent Office
to be bound by the act&sf the Jnited States Patent Office,
it may be stated, as a matter of common knowledge, that in
the actual practice of patent law the -acts of the United -
States. Patent Office are given great weight (Almost full |
faith and credit) by the Canadian Patent Office. It will be
seen from the nature of the amendment (2 App. 345-346)
that Aghnides sought allowance of claims in the Canadian
-_ Patent Offiee’ solely on the basis that the United States
Patent Office had previously allowed the same claims.
Later, in the prosecution of his patent in the Canadian
Patent Office, Aghnides repudiated the convention. date
ES
claimed in the United ‘States allah, and thereby perpe-.
trated his fraud. .
‘Briefly, the facts show that Aghnides, to avoid a statutory
bar in the. United States (against the application resulting
in U_S.-patent-2,210,846), claimed his date of invention as + oan
“oy
~ of December 8, 1934 (the Belgian application’s filingidate)— _
and, to aveld a statutory. bar in Canada (based on the
Belgian application’s’ filing date), Aghnides claimed his .
_ date of invention as of December 31, 1937 (the filing date .
of the U. S. application resulting i in U. S. patent 2,210 846).
The patent claims in both U. S. and Canada are identical.
However, the dates of invention of. said identical. claims is ®
different. And, in the U. S., the Belgian 1934 application i is a
said to be for the identicalinvention ax inthe U.S} patent— |
‘while in Canada, the Belgian 1934 application is said to be |
for a-different invention than-in- the U_S. ahd Canada
For the purpose of getting patent claims in Canada, the-
U. S. patent claims (obtained from the U. S. only because
_ identity was asserted between the:U. S. application and the -
- 1934 Belgian application) were inserted into the Canadian
patent application; and, to avoid a statutory bar in Canada
(based on issued patents resulting | from the 1934. Belgian
application), the Canadian claims (identical with the U. S.
claims) were stated to be fora different invention than the —
1934- Belgian, application—with the explanation that:
+ «@ ® © it is the Belgian Convétition which, in the
United ‘States patent No, 2, 210, 846 confuses the issue
@ © @)) (2 App. 361). ! | °
“This jugeting of dates and Conbention priority by Agh:
nides was déliberate and with the intent te obtain patent
monopolies for which there was no legal justification, mor-
ally or in fact. . )
; Thus, it was not the sole issue in this case, whether | or
not Aghnides told fhe « truth in the United States or. in
45
Canada, and it was not an issue to’ etermine which of the
two patents was obtained by fraug’ If either of the two
patent® was obtained by fraud, ‘that is: sufficient for this —
Court io take an interest in the matter and to make its de-
termination thereon. For, as was stated by the Supreme -
Court:in the Amistad case (40 U. S. 518, 594, 10 L. Ed. 826, |
854) with regard to rights which were being asserted under,
‘the provisions of a treaty:
was yy hat we proceed u upon is this, that although -
public’ documents * *:* certainly are to be deemed -
prima facie evidence of. the facts which they purport-—
ae to state, yet they are always-open to” be impugned for
__— , fraud; sand whether that fraud be in the origénal
obtaining of these documents, or in the subsequent
. fraudulent and: illegai use of them,-when once it is
satisfactorily established it overthrows all their sanc- )
tity, and_destroys them as proof. Fraud: will vitiate —
any, even the most solemn’ transactions, and an as- .
serted title to property, founded upon it,. is Utterly.
void.’’ (Emphasis ours.) ei
_Aghnides’ purpose and scheme was te obtain patents in
as many countries as possible, By reason of the evidence
that has been presented, it is unquestignable that a portion
of his scheme was unlawful—regardléess whether the unlaw-
ful portion of the scheme occurred in.the United States 3
or in Canada—and the scheme also involved the steps of
obtaining of the U. S. patent, relyiig on the International
Convention so to. do, and thereafter using that’ patent as
_. the basis for obtaining the identical claims in the Canadian
/ patent, and: repudiating the very basis that procured the
- same Ciaims in the United States. As the.Supreme Court
has pointed out in the case of Steele et al. v. Bulova Watch
Co., Inc.. 344 U. S. 280, 287, 73'S. Ct. 252, 256:
“«* * * acts in themselves legal lose that character
when they become part of an. unlawful scheme *.* *
(Citing cases). In such a case it is not material that
the: source of the forbidden effects upon eo commerce
me
16
. arises in one phase or another of that program sae
,, (Citing cases) " (emphaats ours).
In the Steele ease, . supra, the Supreme Court ‘des stated
(344 U. S. 280, 282, 73 St. Ct: 252, 254) that :
«¢* © ® Congress in prescribing standards of ———
for. American citizen$ may project the inact of its
‘laws beyond the territorial boundaries. of the United
States * *.* ® (Citing cases). o Pa
& vA
} Corteialy the Courts of the United States, i in the exercise
of their equity power, may require, of those who seek equity
before them, a standard of conduct with respect to acts in-.-
volving the. subject matter befoye them, even if such aets
occurred outside the territorial: boundaries of the United ~
States, of the type which would have been required of the 3
__ same’ party had the acts taken placegpithin the boundaries |
“- of the United States. Steele et al: v. Bulova Watch Co., -
Inc., supra; Precision Instrument Mfg. Co. v. Automotives
Maintenance Machinery Co., supra; Hazel-Atlas Glass Co.
Sy. Hartford Empire Co.,-supra; Keystone-Driller Co, v.
. General Excavator Co., supra. Raita wee.
- The ‘‘public welfare’’ purposes with which trestion are *
endowed (as stated by the Supreme Court in the Belmont .
fase, supra), morally requires each signatory. nation of -a
- treaty oti | :
. (1) to affirmatively support the treaty’s intents and e
purposes, and -
(2) to. prévent persons, over which it has control,
from either defying the treaty’s intents and purposes,
or from perpetrating frauds under the treaty on other .
nations adhering to the treaty.
-
It is against the interests of ‘‘public welfare’’ to extend —
benefits under an international treaty to one who, for selfish
, purposes, ‘has both acted in. derogation to the intent and .
purpose of the treaty and has‘also — the treaty i in |
_-=gations of the U. S. to support the treaties to which itisa |
°
y ”
\G
a
such a manner: as to defraud another country adhering to
the treaty. . ‘
The ‘‘p elfare’”” purposes of treaties, and the obli-
party, and) basie equity principles, as ‘enunciated by the:
Supreme Court in the cases cited, compels granting this
Petition for Certiorari to permit the Supreme Court © rule
on this sare of great public ——"
TL. ‘The Conflicts Between Courts of Equivalent Standing,
_ Created by the Opinion of the Fourth Circuit, Can Only
“Be Resolved by the Supreme Court, and Gertiorari
Should Be Granted. :
The opinions of the Court of Appeals for the Fourth ar
’ Seventh Circuits are in direct conflict. The Fourth Cir-
cuit found patent 2, 210,846 valid, and the Seventh Circuit
- found. the same patent invalid. The conflict should be re-
solved. Universal Oil Co. v. Globe Ou Co., 322 U. S. 471,
473; 64.8. Ct. 1110, 1111.
~The Seventh Cireuit found the 346 ‘stant es be invalid .
in view ‘of the British patent to Felten, No. 6012, of 1909.
_ In comparing Felten and Aghnides the Seventh Circuit said
(210 Fed. 2d 859, 862) (Appendix B, infra, page win
««* © ® Felten introduced ozone into water under pres-
sure ‘and mixed them: Aghnides introduced air into |
‘ water under pressure and: mixed them. Hach called
‘ his process one for mixing a gas with a fluid. Felten
_ reads literally on the. oamne of Aghnides.’’ (Emphasis |
ours.) : | 3
‘The Fourth Ciréuit’ s opinion nowhere points out wherein |
Fel en fails to read literally on the claims of Aghnides, as
‘the Seventh Circuit has stated, and hence the aoe Cir-
" cuit’s: statement stands unchallenged.
The Court of Appeals of the Fourth Circuit’ alk the
' dix A, infra, page sade that J udge Hayes concluded in effect
that:
-as a resistance for mixing the ‘water 211 air. Felten uses
-
Trial Court before, -it) ota in three important respects |
in disregarding the Seventh, Cireuit’s opinion :.
First: The Fourth Cireuit Court placed oat emphasis
on commercial success: (Appendix A, infra, pages iv to v, ©
viii), completely disregarding this Court’s admonition that -
commercial success cannot make an invention where there |
‘is none. - Jungerson v. ‘Gutty &é Barton Co. et al., 335 U.S.
560, 567; 69 S. Ct. 269, 272. Re os
Sécond: The Fourth Ethouit’ Opinion states (Appen- |
Pye Felten sparse’ on edifferent principle md did:
not ‘achieve the result of Aghnides.’’.
However, that conclusion, affirmed by the Fourth Circuit’s 3 ee.
Opinion, is completely contrary to. the Opinion of the Sev-
-enth Circuit and to the unquestioned facts in this case.
What the alleged ‘different principle” is, cannot be dis- ee
cerned either from the patent’s specification, the’ claims of .
'. the patent, or from the facts educed at the trial. It is -
‘not controverted that’ both Aghnides (2 App. 1-4) and
_ Felten (2 App. 275-277) use a jet of water for-creating a -
suction that sucks air through a lateral inlet into a mixing
chamber, and, therefore, Aghnides and Felten are qualita-—
fively the same. Aghnides -sucks air. Felten sucks air
which contains ozone (2 App. 275). Aghnides uses. screens
perforated plates as a resistance to mix water and ozone-air —
¢2 App. 275-277). Both devices produce a bubbly non-splash
stream, as is disclosed .i in thg trial record: (1 App. 145, 149,
154)—and as was also noted by the Court of Appeals of the
Seventh Circuit, before whom tests were run in open court
(Appendix: B, infra, p. xxiv).
As to the quantitative results achieved, while both the =
Trial Court and the: Court of — state that. sicvacn go
4
19
does not’ obtain the same results, it is. uncontroverted that
Aghnides admitted in his foreign patents, corresponding
, to patent 2,210, 846, that. his resultant jet:
6¢* & *&
may comprise 30 to 40 per cent " volume
“of air’’ (2 App. 392). :
~The tests of the Felten. device in open court, on, were
made by Aghnides on models that Aghnides himself had
constructed, showed that Felten produced . a resultant jet
having:
~ (a) 334% by ‘alias of air (test of Plaintiff s Exhibit —
44,2 App. 217) and
~ (b). 41. 2% by volume of air (test of Plaintiff’s Exhibit
56; 2. App. 217). bade
- Thus, the facts herein eotablished that, hadnt and
Felten are, contrary to the Fourth Circuit’ *s: Opinion, ‘the .
same both qualifatively and quantitatively.
Os — jee Third: In disregarding the fact that the Claims of the
~» Aghnides patent read on Figure 8 of patent 2,210, 846, —
Court of Appeals of: the Fourth Circuit not only ignored
the Seventh Circuit’s opinion and misapplied the appli-
-eable Iaw, but also ignored unequivocal admissions in the
file wrapper of the patent and decided this case in. direct Fs
conflict with many. decisions of the Court of Customs and
Patent. Appeals: involving similar fact situations, thereby
creating an additional conflict between courts of ‘equiva- -
lent standing, which conflict may be reagived only by. this
oe Court. |
\ The Seventh Circuit hel stated ( 210 F. 2d 859, 863) :
dees It seems to us utterly immaterial that Felten’ s
apparatus may also be used as a vacuum pump; so in-
deed may one form of. Aghnides. Element for element,
mathe: two are the same.”’ ( Appendix B, infra, page xxv.)
In-so stating, the Sev enth Circuit was referring to Figure
8 of the Aghnides —
* ae
'. .of the Seventh Circuit, the Fourth Cireuit atated (Appen-
Pp: :
- In drawing an issue between its décision and the decision
dix A, infra, page ix): Ae sean
“<® * * We consider it immaterial that Figure g,
iwhich is not covered by any of the claims, was not
omitted in the granted patent.”
- And further, in: discussing the Seventh Circuit’s opinion,
the .Fourth Circuit stated {spp A, infra, pages ix a
. > pe S
ee © The ‘sadinaiion must have been to Figure 8,
the ‘only form of Aghnides . that can function .as a
' pump; but this: form is outside the claims, because it
_ does not respond to their terms or produce the desired
result of an aerated stream.”’ (Emphasis ours.)
Hewkeis in its decision does: the Fourth Circuit .show-
how Figure 8 does not respond to the terms of.the claims.
Furthermore, during prosecution of the: sae apega in: the i :
5 Patent Office, Aghnides-had- stated{2 App. 95):
“Claim 55 (Claim 2 of the issued patent) is ‘Mike
the same lines as Claim 54 ( Claim’1 of the patent) but.
‘specifies a means for finely breaking up the water and
for offering sufficient resist@nce-for thoroughly mixing _
it with air, and other means for uniting the aerated
. water to form acoherent jet. This form of claim will |
read on Figs. 4, 5, 6,7 and 8.’? (Emphasis ours.)
: ‘Thus, Aghnides asserted positively that the claims of the
patent read on ‘Figure 8.. And in his Brief before the
Board of Appeals, Aghnides stated (2 App. 106-107) that.
all of the modifications nore in — 1, 2, 4, 5, 6;
and 8:
jet and make it- in the same manner vba aiae
Ane, furthermore, the . Patent. Mxaminer agreed with
; Aghnides as to the readability of the claims, ‘and asserted,
}
t
“see produce the same kind of a soherent™ white -°
tothe Board of Appeals that claims which issued in the
- 846° patent, read on the species of Figure 8 (2: App. 104). :
When Figure 8 was again ‘called to the Tourth Cireuit’s.
attention by Kress’ Motion for Rehearing, the Fourth |
Circuit Court then conceded'in its Supplementary Opinion
_ that deviees covered by the claims of the patent embody
the Venturi principle as also embodied in Figure 8 (Ap-
pendix A, infra, page Xviii), but still insisted ‘that the
patent claims call for ‘‘more’’, and ' insisted that the
‘“‘more’’ is not found in Figure 8. In explaining: re the’
more’? the Fourth Circuit noted that ‘Figure 8 uses a
fluid flowing through a pipe fot drawing to itself fluid ~
from another pipe, while the patent claims are directed to. -
water flowing through a pipe for drawing to itself air
(App. A, page’ xviii). While the” Court was thus differ-
entiating between Figure 8 andthe. patent claims, it failed
~ to observe that Felten is the same as Figure 8 plus the
_ same ‘‘more’’ that the Court itself had stressed—namely, |
. Felten provides a Figure- &-type . device’ wherein water
flows. through a pipe for drawing to itself air; and henee
the - -patent claims, since they include and read on Figure, 2
: 8 -plus ‘‘more’’, must also read on. Felten.
: Additionally, Aghnideg’ present. position, as. sustained 2
by the Court ‘of Appealp for the Fourth Circuit, that cer-
tain forms of his device shown in his patent are patentable
over, and with respect: to the -admittedly old alternate
_ “form of device shown in Figure’8, isin. direct conflict with ;
‘a time-tested ‘and uniformly adhered ‘to rule of Patent _
- Law that has many times heen reiterated by the Court of
Ce and Patent —_ bis Court whose —
11. ‘ Some of these CCPA. cases are: .
Application of McCarn, 212 F. 2d 797, 799 ( COPA. 1954) ;.
-A pplication of Stewart, 222 F. 2d. 747,754 (CCPA-1955) :
Application of Lindberg, 194 F. 24.732, "136 (CCPA- ons
- ana the many supporting cases cited in these: decisions. .
. E . - « . ; a .*
*:
jurisdiction is ‘at the same Tevel as that of the Court of
Appeals of the Fourth Cireuit) to the effect that:
Where the inventor’s own specification discloses.
an équivelency between two alternate constructions,
@ - - and where one of the alternative constructions is an-.
| ticipated by the prior art, the inventor may not argue
+ fer patentability with respect to one e_ of the arent
tives as. compared to another. .
“Aghnides’ position, as sustained by the Court of Appeals '
for the. Fourth Circuit, is that certain of the alternative
-eqnstructions shown in the Aghnides patent are patent-
‘able with respect to the alternative shown in Figure 8.
But under the rule of law enunciated by the COPA, an
~ inventor may not argue:for patentability of one alternative-.—
as compared to another. This ‘conflict between Courts of .
equivalent standing should b@ resolved.
The foregoing errors clearly point up the conflict that
exists between#the decisions of the Court of Appeals of
' the Seventh Circuit and the Court of ‘Appeals of the
Fourth. Gireuit’ on the question of’ validity of patent
- 2,210,846. This question can ultimately be decided only
by this Coprt. OS Ser . a
_ II: a vesion by the Supreme Court of the Issues Raised
~~“ Would Settle the Confusion Created by the Conflicting < .
_ Opinions and Would Forestall Excessive Future Liti-
*~. gation Involving Patent 2,210,846.
The confliet in decisions between the Foutth and Seventh ss
Circuits ‘will now create confusion as to what the ‘law |
should be with Tespect to the validity of patent 2,210,846.
There are four (4) other cases involving this patent
| awaiting trial, two of the eases being ‘in the New York pee
District Court, ‘and the remaining two being in the Chi-
. cago District Court (se see footnotes 3 and 4 supra, on page 3
as
& . : : : =
Pe
<o
of this Petition). Both of Xhene oflastn have crowded
| calendars.
Unless the i issue of validity of this patent is autiote ely re- |
| ‘solved by this Court, there will be «a tendency to litigate .
each and every one of those cases, aS the patentee Aghitides
has shown his disposition toward trying and retrying, again
“and again, the question of validity of this, patent before the
Courts (See J udge Schnackenberg’s s Opinion, in Appendix
== tel infra, pages xxix to’ xxx). ‘The uncertainty which exists
- throughout the United States as to the validity of this pat- °
ent, now enhanced by the conflict i in decisi®ns, will probably
lead to expensive and time-tonsuming trials of ‘the pending 3
Aises, and to Appeals of.those cases to the-various Courts
of Appeals... . |
The inability of- lower courts to remedy ‘this sikundine
respecting this: particular patent was’ the basig of Judge
Schnackenberg’s separate concurring Spinion in n the Holden
case reported at 226 F. 2d 949 at page 951 a insceas C,:
infra, pages xxix to Xxx). : a
In the interests of aniformity of decisions, and to fore-
stall excessive consumption of lower courts’ time, this Peti-
tion should be granted. —
‘ CONCLUSION.
For the r reasons stated, this Petition for W it of Certi- _ i
= should be granted. D |
Respectfully submitted,
a maa Wi eeiiidices:
| a Norman Lertvin,
DoD. ALLEGRETTI; -
_ Attorneys for ‘Defendant:
rs are Appellant. a.
— 23, 1957. ar i
eee “(Appendix Follows) rat
' Appendia A, | |
APPENDIX A.
Unyren STATES Courr OF APPEALS”
For the Fourth Circuit.
- No. wae
_§. H. Kress & Company,
| —-
versus
| ‘ae P. Aghnides and
_ Chase Brass & Copper Company, Ine.,
3 —
APPEAL FROM THE Unitep Srates Disrricr Court ror
Tae MupLe. sacri or North. Carouina, aT ©
GREENSBORO. ; .
(Argued Jaxivary 9, 1957, Decided May 17, 1957.)
Before. Pasion; Chief Judge, and Soper and. Sope.orr,
‘Circuit Judges. 7
‘Sonntorr, Cireuit J udge:
* From a deeree of. the District: Court holding valid and
infringed two patents relating to devices for aerating water,
particularly adapted*for use in household faucets, this ap-
_- peal’ was taken. The patents are 2,210,846, issued to Elie
Aghnides; August 6, 1940; and 2,316,832 for an _improve-
ment thereon, issued to him April 29, 1943. ‘The suit was
ii. |) Appendia’ A.
priginally filed by the patentee, but later Chase Brass &
‘Copper Company, Inc., holder of a license from him, took
‘an assignment of the patents and, by leave of Court and
' . with the ¢onsent-of the defendant, became an additional
party-plaintrff.
‘The purpose of the patented devices is to obtain a co-
herent, aerated. stream of water that will not splash as it
a emerges from a domestic faucet. The,device is attached to
‘a kitchen water tap and consists essentially of a chamber ,
into which both water under ordinary pressure and air. ~
are delivered and intimately mixed ‘so that the stream |
issuing therefrom is a mixture of water and entrained.
bubbles.. Because of the great volume of air insthe mixture
‘the water is soft and produces a large volume. of suds
when mixed with.soap. The result is' effected by projecting |
water through small apertures in a diaphragm at the upper _
‘or inlet énd of the chamber, thereby breaking the water into
‘mulitple jets as it enters into the chamber. ‘Air is drawn
into the chamber through openings in| the side and i is mixed
with the water therein as a result \of turbulence of, the -
water as it strikes’ resistance element& in the chamber pre-—
venting the free through- flow. of the water. At the outlet
‘of the chamber .a fine screen or Seree s are loc “ied. The _—
combination is typically described in the first _— of the
r basic patent ’846, which is quoted -i in the margin."
1. ‘A device for producing a coherent jet of water containing
, air bubbles, comprising a chamber, the inlet end -of which is
adapted for connection with the discharge end of a tube containing
water under ‘préssure and the outlet end of which is adapted to
discharge the said coherent jet, a diaphragm’ at the upstream end .
of the chamber having at least one‘orifice through which the stream
_of water is adapted to be forced into the chamber with substantial
velocity, an air port opening into the chamber through which air
is induced by the stream of water, and means, in the path of the
stream of water after it leaves the orifice and before it dis-
charges at the outlet end, for finely. breaking up the water and
for offering sufficient resistance for ‘thoroughly mixing it with air
and for thereafter uniting the aerated water to form a coherent jet
-. having small. bubbles disseminated throughout the jet.’’
é
>
9g
Appendix A. cece |
The improvement patent, ’832, combines. the basic ele-
ments of the above with a second perforated diaphragm or
restricted orifice, or both, at the ‘upstream end of the .
aerator, to obtain a more pérfect stream of soft, splashless,
5 bubbly water.
The District J wet held both patente | in suit valid and in-
fringed, in spite’ of the fact that the first patent, ’846, had
previously been declared invalid-by the United States Court .
_ of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit: because anticipated by
the Felten. English patent. Aghnides v. Goodrie, 210 F.2d ©
859. The District Judgé’s opinion observed that in ap-
proaching his task hé felt constrained to follow the Seventh
Circuit if the evidence warranted it: Expressing proper
: deference for the.opinion of that Court he, however, found
himself unable to agree with it. As the Court of Appeals —
itself declared in Aghnides v. Holden, 226 F. 2d 949, its
Goodrie decision-is not res adjudicata, even in the same
_ Circuit, since there was no privity between the > defendants _~
_ in the two actions. : ,
After a long trial and many experiments sondinitnn in
his presence-in the courtroom, District Judge Hayes con: ©
- eluded that Felten operated ona different principle and, did
* not achieve the result of Aghnides. One after another ‘of
the observations made in the Goodrie opiriion, suggesting
similarities between Felten and Aghnides, were fully
answered by highly Persuasive visual evidence’ to the con-
’ trary.. : |
- he same Rule of “Practios (Rule 52(a) F.R.C.P.)
_ upon which our brethren in the Seventh Circuit*trelied in|
upholding the findings of their District Judge as not clearly —
erroneous would warrant our putting equal reliance in the
presumptive correctness of District Judge Hayes’ contrary ©
conclusions. However, to avoid unnecessary conflict be-
tween the Circuits, we deemed it our duty to address our- ©
. selves independently and with special care to an examina--
iv. | Appendix cg tome peavey
- tion of the District Court? 's findings. Of course, our review ~
‘is of the record made in the District Court below, which
is different from the Goodrie record, and appears to be
more detailed and comprehensive. |
‘Turning more -particularly to the 8.46 patent, ‘may
be noted that in ‘the instant case, further supporting this
presumption of correctness is the provision -of the Patent
Act (35 U.S.C.A. 282), which puts the: burden of estab-
lishing invalidity upon the party asserting it; and the.
usual presumption of validity is strengthened by the history
‘of this patent in the Patent Office. It was granted only after
considerable controversy and after review by the Board of
Appeals, where the references relied upon by the defendant
were all closely considered by administrative officials ° pos-
-sessing special: ‘competence in the field. |
It is_noteworthy that 21,000,000 units embodying ~the -
patented device have been sold in this country, and licenses a
have been taken by large concerns like Chase Brass &
Copper Co., Firestone Tire & Rubber Co., and Chicago
Faucet. Co. Chase Brass alone had up io the time of the
- trial paid royalties on more than 16,000,000 of its ‘‘Spring-
‘Flo’’ units made according to the Aghnides teaching. Be-
fore taking the license it had condacted an extensive search .
of the art.and made unsuccessful attempts to attain the re-
sults of the Aghnides invention. by other means. By the -
- payment of substantial royalties, suck business concerns.
attest their opinion of the merit of the patent. While it is
tru¢ ‘that commercial success does not determine: either
invention or the validity of a patent, nevertheless, in a
doubtful case it may be a convincing factor. Great Atlantic .
and Pacific Tea Co. ¥. Supermarket Equipment. Corp., 340 © 3
US. 147, 1535, Textile Machin@ Works v. Hirsch Tertile
"Machines, Inc., 302 U.S. 490,’498; Smith: x. Ball, 301 U.S.
216, 233-. Before this invention, no water aerator that
could be used in connection with a household-faucet had
g 3
Apeendio A. en i: ae
© all
— successfully marketéd. ‘The wide acceptance ‘and use
of this ‘item, which has become standard. equipment in-the ~
plumbing supply industry and-is used by ,leading faucet
manufacturers and has been installed in, millions of homes,
are circumstances not without significance.
‘Like the Distritt Court, we are unable to agree that this
patent was anticipated by the Felten British patent No.
-6912 of 1909, or the cofresponding United States patent
No. 1,090,044, sued to Fuss. ‘The drawings of the Felten
- patent have a superficial resemblance to: the patent in suit,
but on closer examination Felten will be found to be differ-
ent. Felten operates on a different. principle, is designed _.
to achieve a different result, and has never been. utilized,
as has the plaintiffs’ patent, to supply the householder with-
‘a soft, coherent, splashless stream of aerated water. The
. purpose of the Felten patent was to add vzone to water to
sterilize it, and it is not shown that. it. t. was ever actually
used even for this purpose. Judge Hayes had ‘the benefit of
| witnessing the operation ‘of demonstration equipment—a:
tank with faucets for the attachment of aerators, with a
pump for circulating water from the tanks through the .
faucets, and with a pressure gauge and a vacuum gauge. |
The testimony is singularly free from the confusions which |
“often ereep into the record of ‘courtroom demonstrations,
and is clear and understandable. With respect to the Felten
patent, the Court. found (Finding XXVII (fj ):
“This device is “also designed -to secure a vacuum.
Models thereof were demonstrated te the Court by .
plaintiff from which Felten’s. epnstruction,. mode of
P operation and results were made evident. Felten’s de-
_ vice does not produce the fully aeratéd, soft, stream. ~
¢ characteristic of Aghnides and does not operate Othe.
same principle or use the same combination of ele-
ments. * * *. Felten is so constructed that the ehergy
of the water is spent in creating a vacuum and not°in
securing aeration. , Demonstration showed that it adds *
less than 5/10 of a cubic inch of air to 1 cubic inch of —
» 2)
: = . . t Appendiz A.
a whereas-Aghaides’ acratot adds 6 eubic inches ©.
.* + or 12 times as much. itierrn care |
Not only was it demonstrated that Felten’s. result -
is different but that he secures his ‘result by different’
elements and by a different: mode of operation. The -
patent. states that the result ji is secured by means of. a.
-*eonically widening chamber e, the widening of which.
produces in a well known manner the suction of the
gas from the perforation. d owing to the flow of the
| liquid from the perforation c into the widened cham-
ber e’. (Felten Patent, p. 1, line 28). This has no
- counterpart:in Aghnides. Felten, to secure his result,
‘must keep the chatiber flooded—the exact opposite of
Aghnides. This was demonstrated by a transparent
model (Exh. 44) which made it possible to see that the
widening chamber was at all times flooded and that
there were no individual jets striking Felten’s baskets.
The flooding of the chamber was alse demonstrated .
by drilling a hole into a widening chamber whereupon
water squirted out and, when the air through the inlet |
provided by Felten above the chamber was.cut off ‘no
_air entered any place and the device became inopera-
tive-even as a vacuum pump. Felten’s necessity for
flooding was also demonstrated by eliminating .the
‘flooding (by removing the outlet baskets) under which —
circumstances the device produced a mere jet of water
with neither vacuum. nor aeration. This is a funda-
. mentally different mode of operation than Aghnides
as could be seen from the demonstration of an Agh-
. hides’ aerator. with the sides eut out (P. Exh. 39).
The chamber in Aghnides is not a widening one as in
Felten and was not flooded but on the contrary con-
_tained only the naked water jets in free air striking
his resistance screens.
‘‘The fundamental nature of the difference between ©
the Felten ‘device and the Aghnides’ aerator was also
visually demonstrated to this Court by providing a
Felten device (P. Exh. 42) with greatly increased
resistance below his baskets—in the amount of 21 _.
sereens! The device none the less created substantialiy
, the. same amount of vacuum, as‘it did without the :
?
+
Appdniia: A. vii -
screens, showing ‘that the intended finden of the de-
vice was not changed even bya great “change in the
amount ‘of resistance. Qn. the other hand, when, the
. resistance of an. Aghtlides’ aerator (P. Exh. 42) was
increased by adding only three screens its proper pra-
~ portioning was destroyed, the device flooded and it .
. became useless for its intended purpose. It was ‘also
demonstrated that Felten’s baskets are not essential to |
his’ operation and’are not elements corresponding. to
Aghnides’ essential resistance screens or shoulders; -_
when Felten’s: ‘baskets were removed, his device would
_. still operate with a flooded. chamber and ata his
: high vacuum. ” ie
The foregoing fines are supported by substantial evi-
dence, pointed and convincing, and we are persuaded that
they should not be set aside. They show that while j in Felten
some air was present,. increase in the amount of air would
defeat the operation of the device, since what’ was desired
was a vacuum ; whereas’ in Aghnides the presence of a
large quantity of air was desired to effect aeration, which
is the heart of the invention. U nless these solidly grounded
findings are to be disregarded completely, we must conclude __-
that the Felten British patent No. 6012 of 1909 and the
corresponding United States patent, Fuss, No. 1,090,044,
do_not anticipate the patent and do not indicate ry |
for lack of invention thereover.
The other patents cited by: the defendants also failed to
produce the objective of the Aghnides device. They were
never applied to the purpose’ of the Aghnides patent. In
‘Court these earlier pateuts emitted violent, splashing, diver-
gent streams without the desired aeration. None of them
refers to the problem to which Aghnidés addressed himself.
The prior art patents, other than Felten, which were chiefly —
relied on by the defendant, are Solomon and ‘Hyatt. ‘The
- Solomon British patent No. 405,316, for example, intended
to aerate beer, produces no bubbly stream comparable to
viii Bee » Appendia. A, .
1 that prodiined by the: -Aghnides totem The admission of a
slight quantity of air increases froth on beer sufficient for
the desired purpose. It will not perform the same: function
as Aghnides,, as was demonstrated before the Trial Judge.
The British patent: Hyatt, No. 326, 221, is a massive device
for purifying. rater. for cities or large industrial installa-
- tions, and is not addressed to the objective of delivering :
an aerated stream. of water at the point of use.
Other patent references are even wider of the mark.
None is the counterpart of patent. No. 2,210,846 in prin-
ciple, operation, or results,..as the demonstrations proved.
step by step and in deta Even the speculations as to how
certain modifications in pre- ‘existing devices might adapt
them.to achieve e thie desired result were refuted by actual
experiments in open court. The demonstrations in the Dis-
_ trict Courtroom are entitled to special-weight, because re-
semblances and differences not readily noted. from ‘verbal |
descriptions or graphic illustrations were made vivid by use
‘of models constructed of transparent material to make the’
operation of the various devices of the experiments clearly
visible. setae ot 3 eae
The usual defense that” the cenit weeld have been ob-
' vious to one skilled in the art cannot avail the defendant
_ here. _Obviowsness does-not mean that one skilled in the
"art can perceive the solution after it has been found and
- pointed ‘out by someone else; the test of obviousness: is as
of an earlier time, when the search is on. If the answer to
the riddle were in fact discoverable as readily as the de- |
- fendant. now claims, it seems incredible that with a latent /
demand strong enough to result in the sale of 21,000,000'
‘units of this device, the persistent researchers in the in- |
dustry who were engrossed by the problem would have -
heen blind to the solution found by Aghnides. ° a
We. conclude that the ’84 Aghnides device’ was. inven-
tive and not merely within the ordinary skill of the-art; and
‘- elaims.
-“Appendiz ma." = ae
that it was not anticipated - the prior art.‘ “The District
_ Judge’s findings \are not only adequately supported, but
accord with our own Jappraisal of: the evidence.
Defendant eentends that: because plaintiff admits that?
- Figure 8 of the °846 patent” is ‘the prior art, the claims -
in thée-patent are igwalid. The complete answer is that the
claims 'are not directed to. this figure ‘and do not read upon
it‘any more than they read upon Felten. The scope. of the
claims is aire org one ‘the figures in, the drawing. A
form shown in a drawi ing is not necessarily covered by the
gun claims. When an application for a patent is filed,
_ MImany forms may be shown and. an attempt made to cover
7 ‘them all in the claims as originally presented. During the
prosecution of the appligation, however, the claims may be
restricted in the light of the prior art. In the end, only.cer- —
tain:of the forms shown may be. covered by, the restricted.
ther. the forms. not covered by the surviving
claims remain in the patent or are cancelled from thedraw-. -
ing is immaterial; for the claims, and not the drawings, —
control. We consider it immaterial that Figare 8, which is
not covered by any of the claims,-was not omitted i in the
granted patent. ' Denominational Envelope Co. v. Duplex
Envelope Co., 4 Cir., 80 F. 24.198, 192; Bassick Co. v.
Faultless Caster Corp., 4. Cir., 105 F: 2d 298, 231; see aise
Freedman v. Friedman, 4 Cir., 242 F. 2d. 364.
- The opinion ‘of the Seventh. Circuit commented on the
fact that*one form of Aghnides’ device may be used as a
vacuum. pump and, apparently, largely. for this reason, in- |
‘validated the Aghnides patent as an equivalent of Felten’s :
~ prior/patent. The reference must-have been to Figure 8,
the only form of Aghnides that can function | as a pump;
2. Figure 8 illustrates ‘a. Cevice for. mixing two or more. fluids.
.It exemplifies what is known to the prior art as the Venturi prin-
ciple, namely, that a stream of fluid ‘under pressure in a pipe of
increasing diameter will create a suction —_ oraw to itself the fluid
from a conv erging pipe.
: rm ‘ * PA Fes
Y he . :
i. : ;
y - . - F . |
ne
°
e “%, s 2:
S 2 doe. ) Appendiz A, |
but this form is outside the claims, because it does not re- |
_ spond to their terms or — the desired result of - an
‘ aerated stream. :
Contesting the charge of infringement, the defendant
undertook to distinguish. the: accused device, called. ‘‘Mel-
O-Flo,’’ manufactured by Melard Manufacturing Co., from
that of the plaintiffs. The defendant’s aerator has, at the
top of the chamber, a diaphragm with small orifices through
_ which the water from the faucet goes, and below the dia- |
phragm is & casing with lateral holes for the adinission of u
air. The diaphragm is formed by. a ring and a plate that ©
is seated in the ring. The plate is provided with teeth. The
piate itself is not perforated, but when the parts are brought :
together, there are openings around the border through:
which the water can escape downward. This i is substantially
like the apertured plate or plates at the ‘upper end of the
_ chamber in the plaintiff’s device.’
s The defendant ’s contention of non-infringement is that
the accused device, unlike that of the plaintiffs, does not
utilize ‘‘resistance screens’’ to effect break-up or mixing of.
the water and air. The claims of the patent, however, are
broader and. are not limited:to:such screens. As pointed out
above, claim one simply calls for ‘‘means in the path of. the
stream of water . . . for finely breaking up the water and
for ‘offering sufficient resistance for thoroughly mixing
itwithair.,..” Clearly, this language applies as well to.
el accused structure as to numerous figures of the °846
\ >> patent. The fact thatthe defendant’s structure uses ati
\._ “onion”? and the inner surfaces in the chamber and.a single
~\. outlet sercen to create the necessary ‘resistance, whereas ‘
*\\Aghnides uses a plurality of screens, is an immaterial cir-
the ’846 patent clearly read on the defendant’s structure. .
Bee Graver Mfg. Co. v. eis 339 U.S. 605, 607.
nee
“. / Phe second sible. 1832, which is chide to be an im-
provement upon the first, covers the same general ‘com-
/ bination as the basic patent, plusn added elemeht, an addi- .
tional apertured diaphragm i in the upper. part of the cham-
-ber, or a restricted orifice upstream of the. chamber) or
both. - This‘is set forth in claim one as a ‘‘foraminous' mem-
_ber upstream of the. apertured diaphragm’?’; in claim two tee
- as a-‘‘restricted orifice ‘upstream of the apertured dia-
¥ phragm” ; ; in claim three as a ‘‘ ‘restricted orifice and foram-—
inous member upstream the apertured diaphragm”’; and in
| _ claim four as ‘‘ superposed apertured diaphragms at‘the .
“axpstream end %f the chamber’ through which water is
' adapted to be forced into the veges with substantial a
velocity. ie ee
But the A bhnides etait, or 846 patent, had already
taught the use of a perforated diaphragm at the upstream | :
end of the chamber: to force water into the chamber with .
_ substantial velocity. Merely adding another perforated. dia-
‘, phragm or diaphragms at the upstream. end, or another
screen or screens at the outlet end, introduces nothing new,
“+ especially. as the earlie? patent had showr that perforated
plates or screens could be used ‘in eithi r,position, and that
‘‘even better. results can be obtained if two or more super-
posed screens are “used in the outlet’ discharge. 4 Adding .
interchangeable screens or diaphragms at the other end-is ©.
ee merely a means of. maintaining the proportion between in-
let and outgo, and does not rise to tlie level of invention over :
the earlier patent. Nor does the second feature of the ’832
patent:introduce novelty in the device or in the result to be
achieved by it. Merely noting that ‘‘when the water is dis-
‘charged [into the chamber] through a restricted: orifice
_ [a narrow pipe] that the flow through the orifices in the’
upstream diaphragm is improved,” i isg-in the context of all
that had gone before, including Aghnides’ own contribu-
- tion—too meagre a discovery to be regarded as invention.
Appendi 4. ae oxi _
ee
eee Appendiz. A. a a
The changes seem to be the normal and obvious result of.
skill)and experience gained in the practice of the °846 in-
‘vention. They are entitled to no new patent, for they are
~ variations in the application of the principle already dis-
closed, and are of no. important consequence mechanically
and should be accorded no significance legally. We con-
clude that the °832 patent is invalid. See Atlantic Works v.
Brady; 107. U.S. 192, 200; Wine Ry. Appliance Co. v. an
B&O R.R. Cd, 4 Cir. 78 F. 2d 312, 319, and others there
cited. |
A “A considerable orto of the defendant’ ‘s briefs and the
argument before us<was concerned with matter het in the
| record, but attempted We be Taised by motion to reopen the
. case many. weeks after — of the-trial, w hich
lasted over a lorig-period ‘of months. Therein the defendant
-offered to, show that Aghnides had represented to the’
applications corresponding to the patents in suit, were not
the same inventions as those covered bysa prior, Belgian
~ application : made by Aghnides; whereas iit the United
ptates, to get the benefit of'an earlier date, he pre-
viously. representéd that the invention of the United States. §
' application was the same as that of the _— Belgian appli-
cation. |
‘Canadian. Patent Office.that the quired of his Canadian
se,
Ordinarily, whether or not a.case shall be reopened for
the reception of additional testimony is in the discretion
of the Trial Judge, w hich diseretion will not: be disturbed
“on appeal. Particularly is this so where the party moving
to reopen has had long and full opportunity-to develop the
information he now secks:. to present, but did nat do so
. during. the pendency. of the trial. In this case, wé are the -
more strongty disinclined to interfere with J udge Hay es’
“exercise of. diseretion, ‘because on ‘the documents before us,
/ we fully, agree with es comment that even if the case were :
reopened, the proffered te testimony would not alter the result.
-
ee
a .
tX%
4
i Appendia A. ~ ‘xiii
From our own examination of &. United States patent ’846.
_. and the Belgian patent, we think it unquestionably true
‘that they are, as Aghnides told the United States’ Patent ;
Office, the Same invention. Whether or not on another oc-
casion Aghnides made an inconsistent claim in Canada to
obtain a patent there, is an issue that we need not decide.
If he made a misstatement there, this might bear upon the
validity of his Canadian patent. It would not alter the fact
~~ that what he told the United States Patent Office was the
truth and that the patent here was obtained without: decep-
tion or fraud. Even if we were to assume what we are not -
prepared to adjudicate, that the inventor’s representations ;
to the Canadian Patent Office were untrue, this misconduct
would not be so closely related to the proceedings in this © —
-country and thé issuance of the patent to-him here as to -
invalidate the grant or to constitute such unclean hands as
to disentitle him to the relief ‘he asks in this case.
Def endant complains of the trial court's failure to eo
the“complaint as to Chase Brass and Copper Company, —
- Ine. .The argument is that although Chase became a party
plaintiff with the conscnt—almost insistence—of. the de-
fendant, and defendant does not complain of the interven- -
tion of Chase, nev ertheless, no relief should be entered in
favor of this plaintiff and the’ case should be dismissed as
to it, because Chase failed to, prove infringement after the .
assignment of the patent to it. Yet the defendant argued
’ that no injuaction should be granted at the instance of
Aghnides, because he no longer is the owner of the patent.
Accordingly, although the Court has _hefore-it*Aghnides,
who was the owner when the infringement occurred, and
' Chase, his assignee, in junctive relief, it is said, is not to be
allowed. We find no merit in the defendant’s contention,
= -
xiv ~ Appendia A.
- raised for the first time on this appeal, especially as it con-
sented to the admission of ‘Chase and announced its inten-
tion to utilize against Chase any decree that might be
rendered against it. With all parties in interest before the
se Court, it was in a ‘position to do complete justice.
: Affirmed m part aad reversed in part,
- and remanded for the passage of a -
_ decree im conformity with the views —
herein expressed. |
“a |
Appendix. A, | : oe
APPENDIX A. ~
Unirep States Court or APPEALS
For the Fourth Cireuit. | -
> No. 7294.
(SH: Kress & Company,
. Appellant, .
ioe versus: . &
. Elie P.. Aghnides and
Chase Brass & Copper Company, Inc. m
i; —.
APPEAL FROM THE Unrrep ‘States Disraicr Court. FOB
‘He Mippie District or Nortu CaRoLiNa,.
aT GREENSBORO.
zl
Before Paaie: Chief J udge and Soper and SoBExorr, Cir-
cuit J ud ncn
i.
“ SUPPLEMENTARY OPLTION « ON MOTIONS FOR.
" REHEARING. :
Filed sie 9, 1957.
Per Curiam: |
. Both parties have webeittinn motions for rehearing. The
plaintiffs contend that the Courf’s opinion, in holding the |
ee ewe ee
<d
ra
Cee Appendia, A.
_ improvement patent. No. 2,316,832 invalid over the ‘basic
patent No. 4,210,046, ignored the rule as to co-pending
_ patents.
-Ordinarily, a patent, ‘to be valid over the prior art, must
be an advance over the whole disclosure contained in the
' specifications or claims of a prior patent. This rule will
‘normally apply even where the applicant is the same per-
_ son to whom a prior patent was issued, because whatever.
is disclosed but not claimed by the former patent will be
- considered as abandoned to the public. However, where the
_ applicant files a second application while the earlier one is
still pending. i in the Patent Office, and the first patent con-
tains disclosures. not embodied in the claims, he is not —
barred from embodying the ‘unclaimed disclosures in the
later application. In such case, because the first application
has still not been made public when the second is filed, the
unclaimed disclosures of the first patent are not deemed an
abandonment preventing their being claimed in the second.
Fraitel Marble Co. v. Hungerford Brass and — Co. ™
2 Cir., 22 F. 2d 259, 261.
To be patentable, however, the ‘eines of the second
patent must be for a different invention than that claimed ay
-in the first patent: Traitel Marble Co. v. Hungerford Brass .
and Copper Co., supra; Montgomery Ward v. Gibbs, 4 Cir.,
27 F.2d 466; Jordan v. Hemphill, 4 Cir.,.180 F.2d 457;
Standard Brands v. Federal Yeast Corp., D. C. Md. (Soper,
J.), 38 F.2d 314; Weatherhead Co: v. Drillmaster Supply
Co., 7-Cir., 227 F.2d 98; Danbury Fur v. American Hatters,
2 Cir., 54 F.2d 344; Sturtevant v. Massachusetts Hair Co,
1 @ir., 122 F.2d 900; In Re Sherman, C.C.P.A.; 121 Pod ta
527. If the second application merely claims- the same in-
vention'on which the applicant has already been awarded a.
- patent, he will, of course, not be permitted, by double
patenting, to extend His monopoly beyond seventeen years...
The policy of the law is to protect the inventor by granting —
Appendix A. - ae
him a monopoly for a limited term, but upon its expiration
the public is entitled to practice his invention. in all j
modifications and variations. There is certainly no reason 3
to grant him a monopoly for an extended period upon a
variant of his patent. which would be obvious to one skilled
in the art.”
The Traitel case, supra, in which the épiaime was: by
Judge Learned Hand, is sonietimes cited for the proposition
that the claim of the second patent need not be inventive at
all, if the appliéation is filed while the applicant has a
- pending prior. application. But a careful reading of that
opinion, ‘as weil as the other cases cited abgve, shows that
what Judge Hand meant and said was that the claim of the
second application need not be a patentable advance over
the disclosures of the specifications {as distinct from the
| claims) of the first application. All agree that a patentee | |
eannot re-claim what has already been claimed and patented
_ by him, i
Neither the narrowing of the inlet end of the acrator, 1 nor.
the. addition of ‘‘a foraminous member’”’ makes the second
patent a separate invention. Even disregarding the specifi. ..
cations and looking Solely at the claims of the two patents,
it is plain that the two involve the same patentable inven-
tion. The claim.of the second patent speaks of ‘‘a foramin-.
ous member upstream the apertured diaphragm,’’ while the
claim of the first patent mentions only the upstream ‘‘dia-
phragm”; but the terms mean the same thing. It is true that
_ in the claims of the first patent, only one such diaphragm ‘is
_ prescribed, while the claim of the second is for more than
one such member; but: there is no significant difference
between the claims, of the two patents.
Changing some of the. functioning parts of a device may
constituté an independent invention, but merely adding more
of the same thing is not ordinarily a separate invention.
For example, in the Gibbs case, supra, of the five major .
xviii ea. - Appendix A,
functioning seal of the ‘nied patent, om tae had 2 ap-
peared in the tlaims of the earlier patent, and what the
court considered: the” heart of the second patent was not
claimed in the first. By contrast, in our case, nothing new
or different is claimed in the second patent that was not in
- the claims of the first.
Derenpant ’s Motion.
_ Defegdatnt Ss: motion’ for rehearing alleges error in the |
_ opinion with regard to the discussion of Figure 8 in the
basic patent No.-2,210,846. We held that the claims do not
read on Figure 8. The defendant? S petition for rehearing
says.that the plaintiff has admitted that his claims @perate,
like Figure 8, on the Venturi principle. While this is true, -
it does not follow that the claims read on Figure 8, because’
although they utilize ‘the Verituri principle, they do not
‘operate on that principle alone. Figure 8 embodies the
Venturi principle only, and nothing ‘more; .it. provides
amerely for a pipe, with a fluid flowing through it, drawing
to itself the fluid from another converging pipe. The claims,
however, which relate not to figure 8 but to the other fig- °
eran
Ww
ures, are for a device designed to draw air to the pipe con-
taining water, and to break up the. water,. mix it with air,
and achieve aerated water. .
Both motions = rehearing will is a
Denied.
Appendix B. oy neat xix
APPENDIX B.
Ix THE Unrrep STaTEs Court or APPEALS
‘For the Seventh Circuit
/
No. 10910 . Ocrtoser Term, 1953, January Srssion, 1954.
aes ss RS a rt eee : a
Exe P. Acun ies, re Appeal. from ‘the
: Plaintiff-Appellant, | District Court. of
ok: ; a -the United States
Defendants-Appellees.) Eastern Division:
February 24, 1954.
- Before Mason, Chief Judge, Lanner. and Swain, Circuit
Judges. : |
Linpiey, Cinewit Judge. Plaintiff’s suit for infringement
of his patent 2,210,846, applied for in the United States
- December 31, 1937, and in Belgium December 8, 1934, and
allowed. August 6, 1940, having resulted in a judgment
of invalidity and dismissal of the action, he brings this |
appeal. ; 3
_ The device of thie patent is not complicated i in structure
or operation. The inventor described it as a ‘‘fluid mix-
ing device,’’ ‘for intimately mixing a gas with a fluid.”*
Apparently the only practical use experienced has been in
- . mixing air and water, or ‘“‘aerating water.’’..Claim 1
— which i is typical of all, five in number, appears in the foot: 7
rx
AX ak
a | _. for the Northern -
JoserH J. Gooprif, ETAL; | . District of Mlinois, —
copes)
me Appendia B.
- note.' It is clear that: the patentee’s conception envisaged 3
- an-attachment for a water tap from which water flows’
under pressure and enters the contrivance at the top,
passes thr ough an. aperture or apertures or a screen near
the top thereof thus dividing and separating the stream
-as it continues ..to a mixing chamber, into which incoming
‘ air enters’through-air ports leading into the chamber, thus
‘mingling the air with the rushing water. The mixture of:
air and water then confinues to the outlet, passing over
barriers: or screens, thus causing to flow from ‘the outlet
into the kitchen sink or other receptacle an aerated stream
of water, which falls i in what is called a ‘“eoherent’’ stream. »
whitish in color, due to the added air, without splashing
or spattering. It is said also that such aerated water lends
itself mroré readily to the efficient use of soap. ‘Thus the ©
- housewife finds the ‘‘mixer’’ or ‘‘aerator’’ helpfui-in her |
housework: The whole idea then embraces water under ©
_ pressure flowing from an open faucet into a chamber after
'. it has been divided by a screen, then subjected to added air,
plus a further breaking up, after the air has been added,
by another sereen or barriers and then released. The
application, as plaintiff admits, had ‘‘a stormy time in the
Patent Office’’ and was first denied on various referenées,
7 ‘but eventually allowed by the Board of Appeals.
a: A device for producing a ‘coherent jet of water containing air |
bubbles, comprising a chamber, the inlet end of which is adapted
‘ for connection with the discharge end of a tube containing water
‘under pressure and the outlet end of which is adapted to discharge -
the said coherent jet, a diaphragm at the upstream end of the —
chamber having .at least one orifice through which the stream of
water is. adapted to he forced into the chamber with substantial
_ velocity, an air port opening into the chamber- through which air . -
aan induced by the stream of water, and means, in the path of the
stream of water after it léhves the arifice and before it discharges ~
at the outlet end, for finely t breaking up the water and for offering
sufficient resistance for thoroughly mixiug it with ‘air and for
thereafter uniting the aerated water to form a coherent jet having © Sl
: small. bubbles disseminated throughout the jet.
es |
ee
ix
Appendiz B, Later mi
The Distrie?J whine heard the sition of the plaintiff,
his expert and Mr. Goodrie, one of the defendants, re-
ceived certain documentary evidence and observed certain —
tests of the patented, the allegedly infringing and other —
devices: in open court, participated in: by both parties. He |
had before him evidence bearing upon alleged commercial
success and various references to the prior art. At the
conclusion of the trial, he took the cause under advise-
| ment, ‘giving the parties the privilege of filing written:
-briefs and argument, the time for filing which was extended
' at various times. Finally, when they were all in, the judge,
on November 3, 1952, announced his decision, . saying :
“In my opinion the Aghnides patent Number. 2,210,846
~ upon which plaintiff relies. in this case is ajiticipated by
British patents Number 6012 of 1909 and 405316 of 1933.
and i is therefore invalid. Counsel may prepare findings of
fact and conclusions of law and submit them to Casper W.
Ooms as Special Master in this case for the parpete of
se passing on such findings and conclusions.”’
Following the Special Master’s report on March 20) 1953.
- the court entered formal.findings and conclusions, in which,
after discussing thedetails of the patent,-pointing out the
salient elements of the prior-art and describing the tests,
performed i in open court, it found that all ‘the elements of —
_ Aghnides were old in. the art in the Felten British patent
No. 6012 of 1909, its counterpart, No. 1090044 to Fuss. 1914,
and Solomon British patent No. 405,316:of 1933; that
_ Aghnides’ assembly of old elements*performa:no new or
additional function, and achieves n@ new osaefiisual or sur--
prising result but that the devices of the pric: - patents
‘to Solomon and: Felten: achieved subs‘antieliy the same
‘results and that to produce the disclosure of the patent re-
‘quired no invention. The coyrt concluded that the claims *
“were anticipated by Felten and Solomon and were invalid
av
xxii | eee ppendix B.
3 bennnne of such anticipation and becnuen of lack of i inven-*
tion.
_ At the outsét-we are met with plaintiff’s contention that
the findings are not entitled to the proverbial weight to be
given trial court findings under Rule 52(a) of the Rules of
Civil Procedure. He-attacks only those heretofore sum-
marized, insisting that they were proposed by the Master,
who, though he had examined the. oral and documentary
- evidence, did not see the tasts performed i in open court and
'- that they were therefore wrongfully. adopted by the court,
after a. protracted interval’ had intervened between the
. conclusion of the trial and the date of the entry of the = |
findings. He argues that the court had forgotten the facts,
and merely accepted the Master’s proposals, which did not
take into consideration the tests which the court had ob-
At the aden of the trial, eowutine 15, 1951, both
parties waived oral argument. After various extensions.
of time, plaintiff filed its brief and argument on May: 22,
1952; thereafter defendants: filed their brief and argument
and plaintiff filed his reply brief. lh September, 1952,
_ Judge Holly suggested that, as he had been ill during the
summer and unable to work on his decision, perhaps the
. parties would desire to have the case assigned to another
jadge. Counsel for both parties consulted and agreed: that
the, case should remain with Judge Holly for decision.
Consequently, with the consent of both parties, J judge Holly
-retained the case and finaliy, on November 2, 1952, entered
the findings hereinbefore summarized that the patent in .
suit was anticipated and was invalid. At the same time
_ he directed that both parties submit suggested formal find-
-ings to‘Casper W. Ooms, an erndite and experienced pat-
ent attorney and former Commissioner of Patents, as
Special Master, to be considered by him. The formal ,
findings and conclusions and judgment dismissing the suit
were entered’ March 20, 1953. Denying a motion for new |
~
Mia
c
Bt
_”-Appendia B. aves mil
trial on April 10, 1953, thie court said that the Seiding were
- not affected by his illness in the summer of 1952 and that
_the motion for a rehearing was without merit.
_ The Master reported that there had. been a dispute be-
_ fore him only as to findings 9 and 13 inclusive; that he had.
examined the evidence and that the findings suggested were
based thereon. and not upon the tests in open court and
| that he submitted them for such action as the court might
consider proper upon the whole. record. The Master did ©
‘not make findings on the merits but explicitly stated that
_ it was up to the court to do so, based upon the record and .
the court’s knowledge of what had transpired at the trial.
- Of course, when the court entered the| findings, they be-
came its findings and not those of the Master: the latter’s
" report was merely advisory; the court made the final deter-
mination. Furtherfore the formal findings adopted were
in strict conformity with. ‘the court’s decision before it.
asked the parties’ ios suggest more formal findings and con-
clusions. Bese . ed
Under these circumstances, we find no o' justification for
‘lending to the trial court’s findings any less wright than
we normally do under Rule 52(a). Consequently our ques-
tion is the usual one of whether there is adequate evidence ©
to-support them. Such cases as Sales Affliates v. National ©
Mineral Co;, 172 F. 2d 608; Falkenbefo v. Golding, 195.
_ F.2d 483 and Chas. Peckat Mfg. Co. v, Jacobs, 178 F. 2d
794, decided by this court; wherein we were déaling with
records made up of documentary evidence, which we were
as capable of-interpreting as was the district court are not
: applicable here. The present case comes more clearly
- within our decision in National Rejectors v. A. B: T. Mfg.
Corp., 184 F. 24,612, where we said at 615: - ? ;
‘‘In view of the fact that the ‘court, having seen
the devices demonstrated. and heard the witnesses, ex-
pert and otherwise, of each‘of the parties, having their
conflicting testimony before it, made a finding which
a
\
xxiv 2S ee Appendiz B..
5 bstantiation i in the’ record, ander the —
- has adequate s
federal rules of procedure, we have no right to inter-
fere. Graver Tank\é Mfg. Co. v. Linde Air Products
Co., 336 U. S. 271, 69S. Ct..535, 93 L. Ed. 672; Hazel-
tine Research Inc..v. - Admiral t Corp. ” 7 Cir., 183 F. 2d
- 953.”
We, too, have had the sia of tests in open court at
the. time, of the argument before us; We, too, have the
transcript of the oral and docum ntary. evidence. After _
careful consideration of. all that has been presented, we
. think the trial court was ampl justified in entering the. .
, findings and conclusions of which complaint i is made. In-
~ deed, we are of the opinion that any determination to the
contrary would have-been erroneous. x. a:
' Felten is prior art. He designated his invention as
_ ‘improvements in or relating to Mixing Devices’? and
as a ‘‘Mixing device for. producing * ° mixtures from
a gas or vapor like substance and a liquid substance)” and
an‘‘apparatus for mixing gases with: fluids.”’ The patent.
in suit uses similar language. ‘‘This invention relates\to
a device for intimately mixing a gas with a liquid.”’ Felten
_ introduced ozone | info water under pressure and- mixed x
them. Aghnides introduced into water’ under pressure
and mixed them. Fach. called his -process’ one for mixing
a gas. with a fluid. Felten reads literally on the claims’
of Aghnides: An asserted difference is that the mix-
ing chamber of Aghnides is larger than that of Felten,
‘but that, so far as. the tésts and the evidence shows, is not
an inventive difference.’ Then, too, plaintiff ‘insists that
the air vent of Felten introducing air into the mixing char: --
pher does not in fact lead into the chamber but only into - 3
the top thereof, thus weakening the mixing effect. Yet in’
both Felten and Aghnides, the vent enters the: chamber just
below the diaphragm, which in turn, is just below the intake
for the water. Felten as well as Aghnides brings the gas
‘into the mixing chamber. If in practice, it nas proved
| Appendix - ee -
°
_ desirable to introduce the gas at a point lower than that
indicated by either, that low er placement cannot amount to
invention. The important ‘thing:is that each introduces a
vapor, &@ gas, ozone or air, into moving water in ‘order to
mix the two substances. It_seems “to us utterly. immaterial
that Felten’ s apparatus may also be used as a vacuum
_ pump; so indeed may one form of Aghnides. Element for.
clement, the two are the same. In ‘tests the two accomplish
the same results, though: perhaps not with equal efficiency. —
We. conclude then that the trial court rightfylly.found that -
Felten inticipated Aghnides and taught the latter all that
he needed to know: in order to build his mixer of gas and
¢
tailed discussion of other prior art. Suffice it to say that
in our opi ion, after carefully examining it, the teachings
_of the other: patents in evidence were such that, with them
before him, Aghnides did not achieve invention.
If for the moment we indulge the presumption of v slidity.
"we think Aghnides’ claims must. be. very narrowly con-"
strued and limited to the specific structure- disclosed by
him... Consequently, defendants, who dé not employ the
sanie structure, but preseribe a different means for sep-
arating the i incoming water into jets, does not infringe.
“We conclude that ‘Aghnides was anticipated ; that, if not.
take. notice, was such that any skilled delver In the art of
oe
mixing gases and fluids could have built Aghnides’ de- |
vice,—in other words, that he did not achieve invention but
3 accomplish the result of a'skilled mechanic. —
-In view of our conclusions we consider it unnece ssary
“to extend this discussion to other sees urged by the re
. spective parties. ,
~Atu
'™ - *df&ment is.
AFFIRMED.
a
fully anticipated, the prior-art, 6f which he was: bound to* 5 a
Slamvi °° 7) Appendia @.
‘ : Beige 2: : ms athe ‘ ‘ . \ ao : {
UA boy RS a tr
J ? Rat mes sg : ; » *% ; Rand .
Rares Ces Unrrep Srares Courr'¢ OF APPEALS
ae For Yhe Seventh Cirenit. oe
Ve, No BOB ‘eae Tena Anp Sxsston, 1955.
Mista S24 Reece . aes age
Rohe Rie P. Acumen and ‘Cuan Brass )
7 “AND Correr Company, Inc.) ‘Appeal ene de
| nt -A Wk oe, oo
ee Spey if's P —— _ District’ Court of
ar : ' the United Stat
is Ontorr Ww. Houpen and Marour- ° Rog bomy Northesn
i \ + Bit. Howpen, doing business as | District of Illinois,
! 5 ee IXNICKERROCKER Rupner ome: *. Bastern- Division. .-
5 RR : rapa
as Bs 9 ieee | Defendants-Appeees, 7
Seg me! “i . = ee :
November 3, my . |
Before “Mazor, Linviey and ScuNAcKENDERG, Circuit
Judges. ©: 6 pee es eae ¥ :
LINDLEY, Circuit cael. On n July: 19, 1950, ‘plaintiffs filed
a complaint i in the district court against defendants, charg- .
ing them with: infringement’ of the patent to Aghnides, .
number 2,210, 846. Issue. was joined and the cause remained ,
‘in status quo until the decision of this court on. February
24, 1954, in. Aghnides v. Goodrie, 210 F. 2d 859, wherein.”
| plaintit Aghnides had sued other defendants for infringe-
‘ment.of the same patent. In that case the district. court
had held each of the claims; five in. number, ipvalid and, —
* “wpon appeal, we affirmed the judgment.. Following this.
o devision, | the” defendants on November 4, 1954, in the suit
—<—$—
Appendix C. vee ee
at bar thei pending, filed a motion for summary judgment
setting up the findings, conclusions and judgment of the
district court and the decision of this court in the former
case, claiming that there remained no genuine issue as to
_ any material fact amd that under Rule 56 of the Federal -
Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U. S. C. A., they were entitled
| to judgment as a matter of law.
Plaintiffs filed an affidavit of. the patentee. in which he
stated that he had’made’a new model of the prior art
Felten device which we had held in the Goodrie case antici-_
pated the patent in suit. He averred that he was’ prepared.
to conduct new tests ‘and produce new evidence and show
that the_prior.art Felten device -did not accomplish the
-,. . same results or have the same mode of operation .as that
*—-of the patent: in suit; that he was prepared to show-by new
- and different models’ and tests of the’ prior art that the
_ + elements of the patented device are not old and do not per-
- form the same functions as they. performed in the prior
art devices; and that, element for element, Felten and—
Aghnides are not the.same and do not accomplish the same
results. The trial court held that the suggested. new evi-
dence was not fairly distinguishable from the, evidence in,
- the Goodrie case,.our decision in which established the in-
—_ of the plaintiffs’ patent, and that, as a matter of
_law, defendants were entitled -to judgment. This appeal fol-.
lowed. -
Defendants argue that the affidavit. of Aghnides is gen-
eral and ‘not specific; that it discloses merely a desire to.
relitigate the validity of the patent by producing new
models and Auch evidence as will convince the district court
/ that the decision in the- former case was wrong. In this
‘connection,-it is obvious we think, that the affidavit is gen-
eral and, in the ordinary ease, would not constitute a-suffi-
cient roan of a genuine issue as to any material fact.
‘ But, in jour opinion, this is immaterial under the facts of
the present case.
a
Sxviii | _ Appendiz C.
'Phis- suit was pending at the time of our former deci-
sions. It was against otlier alleged infringers who‘are not. .
_ shown to be identified in any wise with the defendants in
the former casé, or in privity with them. It would seem —
axiomatic therefore, that the rules of res adyadicata do not
apply and, indeed, defendants do not insist. that they. do.
Nor can it be said that our decision in the: former case is -
_ the law of this circuit to the extent that it is décisive in
other cases for infringemerit against other ‘defendants.
~ Plaintiffs have a yight, if they desire, to litigate ds against
_other defendants and not untiland unless it appears bythe
evidence submitted at the trial that ‘it does not differ essen-
tially from the evidence submitted in the former case, will
the‘decision in the first case become the law of the present
‘one. Thus, in Triplett v. Lowell, 297 U. S. 638, at 642-644,
. the Supreme Court said: ‘Neither reason nor authority .
‘supports the contention that an adjudication adverse to
* * * the claims of a patent precludes another suit
upon the same claims against a different defendant. While .
:. the earlier decision may by comity be given great weight
-~in.a later litigation and thus persuade the-court to render -
a like decree, it is not*res adjudicata and may not be
_ pleaded asa defense. See Mast, Foos & Co. v. Stover Mfg.
Co., 177 U. S. 485; Sanitary Refrigerator Co. v. Winters,
280 U. S. 30; 35. * * neither the rules of the com-
mon law ipplicshie to successive litigations concerning the
same subject matter, nor the disclaimer statute, precludes
-relitigation of the validity ofa patent claim previously
held invalid ina suit against a different defendant. oe
.. continued at 648: ‘*The fact that the Shit was brought in
the same circuit where the court of appeals had previously
held some of-the claims invalid is immaterial, for the court
must decide whether the issues of Jaw and fact in the two
eases are the same, a ‘if they are not it is not hound by —
the earlier ¢ecision.? [ *
=
Appendix C. gxie
A case similar to the one before us is Gold Seal Im-
sporters, Inc, v. Westerman-Rosenberg, Inc., 133 F. $8 192
(CA-2). There, by amended answ nt averre
that the patent had -been held invalid by the Court of |
. Appeals in the case of Gold Seal Importers v. Morris .
White Fashions, 124 ¥. 2d 141 (CA-2), and moved for
judgment on the pleadings. There, too, the distriet court
granted the motion merély because the validity of the pat-
ent had been decided adversely to the plaintiff in the for-
mer case. The judgment was reversed. -The court said
at pages 192-193: ‘‘* * * obviously that decision cén- .
not be pleaded as res judicata ina suit against a different
: infringer not ji in privity with Morris White Fashions.. Nor
is it a precedent which the district court was bound to
fullow, unless the evidence pertinent to the issue of validity
is the same in both cases. -Smith v. Hall, 301 U.S. 216, 218,
57 8. Ct. 711, 81 L. Ed. 1049; Lektophone Corp. v. Miller
Bros., D. €. Del., 37 F. 2d 580, met Minerals Separation v.
Butte é Superior Copper Co., D. C. Mont., 237 F. 401, 402.”
Of course it is desirable that there should be an end to
litigation. But this benefieent result cannot be attained
at the expe.ise of deprivitig’ plaintiffs of the right to. show,
ifethey can, that, as against defendants, who have not pre-
viously been in court, the patent is valid and infringed. .
The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded to the’
district court for further. procéedings consistent with this
opinion. * © | ers :
, ScHNACKENBERG, Circuit Judge, concurring. I believe
‘that Judge Lindley has correctly applied’ the law, in its
existing state, to the case before us. While the counter:
_affidavit of Aghnides is defective, I believe that it is super-
~ fluous and that he is entitled under existing law to-another °
day in court. where he may relitigate the same issue upor/
which he lost in the Goodrie case. The .uw does not require
"XXX - - : + Appendix C.
him to justify this indulgence. He i is entitled to it because
a suit testing the validity of-a patent is not a proceeding
in rem and hence Aghnides may litigate and relitigate
again and again the question of valid iy of his patent as
long as he selects a different defendant in each of the in-
fringement suits which he files, thug avoiding the whole-
some doctrine of res adjudicata. This queer result is one -
which we are unable to avoid. It is a situation which is
particularly abhorrent when considered against the back-
log of untried cases which clogs our federal courts. The
latter are cases where the litigant asks only for his day i
court, not a plurality of days in court as Aghnides is en-
titled to under the existing Jaw. The remedy lies not in
our harids.. The congress could ie legislation grant relief.
7
A ppendwx dD. | XXX)
APPENDIX D.
} * 35.U. 8. C. $102.
‘The pertinent oli of 35 U. S. C. .§102, 66 Stat. 797
(R. S. 4886 and 4887), 1 is. as follows:
~ $402. Conditions for patentability ; : novelty and loss of
right to patent. | !
A per son shall be. entitled to a potent unless—
(a) the invention was known or used by others in this
country, or patented or described in a printed publication. oa
in this or a foreign country, before the invention thereof as
by the applicant for patent, or
-@
(b) the invention was patented or described in a: printed
publication in this or a foreign country or‘in public use or -
on sale in this country, more than one year prior to the
date of the application for patent in the United States, or
ee « * _ * *
° “ 9 . 2 s
(d) the imvention was first patented or caused to be pat.
ented by the applicant or his legal representatives or _
assigns in a foreign country prior to the date of the appli-
cation ‘or patent in this country on an application filed
more than twelve months before the filing of the applica-
tion in the U nited States, or
(e) the invention was described in a satin granted on.
- an aplication for patent by another filed in the United
States before the invention thereof by the. applicant for
pate at, or ie ' oe |
r’
/
xexii —_ Appendia D:
CAPPENDIXD. —s_—-:—ss:
hs Ai
INTERNATIONAL PATENT CONVENTION.
| The pertinent portion: of the ‘International Patent Con- ~
* vention, o3 Stat. 1748, is as follows:
~ (53-Stat: 1748)
“dane 2 Convention between the United ‘States of ‘dengrion and
| other. powers for the, protection of industrial property,
' revising the Paris convention of March 20, 1883, revised
at Brussels on December 14, 1900, .at Washington on .
~ - June 2, 1911, and at.The Hague a, Kevcube 1925.
=o Signed at London June 2, 1934; ratification advised by
. the Senate June 5, 1935;,ratified by the President June
87, 1935; ‘ratification of the United States .of America
<* deposited at London July 12, 1935; proclaimed October
28, 1938. :
r By THE PRESIDENT OF THE Uxrrep STATES OF AMERICA.
9.
A PROCLAMATION.
: vention for the Whereas a convention revising ‘the convention for the
gna . 2b sigpeciagee of industrial property signed at Paris on March
2s Seas. 13744, 20, 1883, revised at Brussels on December 14, 1900, at Wash-_
Ce BS ton on June 2, 1911, and at The Hague on November 6,
1925, was signed by the respecti¢e plenipotentiaries of the.
United States of America and. certain other countries at.
London’ on June .2, 1934, which. convention. in the alana: “
Aanguage i is word for word as follows :'
\ .
7 alt
* ee a a or e .
3 SE
1 Note. For English translation see p. 1768.
. Appendix D.. a |
, + (53 Stat. 1768) «= |).
3 F ‘[Translation. ]
CONVENTION OF UNION OF PARIS OF MARCH 20,
1883, FOR THE PROTECTION OF INDUSTRIAL.
PROPERTY, REVISED AT BRUSSELS DECEMBER ~
14, 1900, AT WASHINGTON JUNS 2, 1911, AT ‘RHE
HAGUE NOVEMBER 6, 1920, AND AT LONDON
JUNE 2, 1934. |
The President of the German Reich; the President of the
Contracting
- powers
Republic of Austria; His Majesty thé>King of the Bel-
' - gians; the President of the United States of Brazil; the
President of the Republic of Cuba; His Majesty the King
of Denmark; the President of the Republic of Spain; the
President of the United States of America; the President
of the Republié of Finland; the President of the French © .
Republic; His Majesty: the King of Great Britain and Ire-
land and of the British. Territories Beyond the Seas,
Emperor of India; His Most Serene Highness the Regent
of the Kingdom of Hungary; His Majesty. the King of
Italy; His Majesty the. Emperor of Japan; His: Most
Serene Highness the Prince of ‘Liechtenstein ; His “Majesty
| the Sultan of Morocco; ‘the President of the United Mexi-. - J
can States; His Majesty the King of Norway; Her Majesty
the Queen of the Netherlands; the President of the Polish
- Republic (in the name. of Poland and the .Free ‘City of
Danzig); the President of .the Portuguese Republic; ‘His
Majesty the King of Sweden} the Federal Council of the .
Swiss Confederation; the President of the Czechoslovak
Republic; His Highness the Bey of Tunisia; the President |
of the Turkish Republic; His Majesty the King of Yugo- om
‘slavia,
Having deemed it expedient to make certain modifica-
tions and additions. in the International . Convention. -of .
. March 20, 1883, for the creation of an — Union
8
25 Stat. 1372.
2 Stat. 1936,
38 Stat. 1645:
47 Stat. 1789.
Plenipotentiaries —
XAaiv ~ Appendia 1.
for the Protection, of Industrial Property, revised at Brus-
sels on December 14, 1900, at Washington on June 2; 1911,
_ and at The Hague on November 6, 1920, have gee
as their plenipotentiaries, | to wit:
. eh ale « - @ * . 2
. ~ eo @ bad ia |
(53 Stat. 1772) |
Who, having communicated. their respective full pow-
ers, which were found to be in good. and due form, have’).
agreed upon the following provisions: |
* Uetem constituted.
‘Patents —
Mutual
tion of ae
against infringe-
tes mont of rights. |
trial
- shall, in all other countries of the Union, as regards the _
™
Aascts | a
(1) The countries to which the present convention ‘ap- ‘
_. plies constitute themselves into a Union for the Protection |
of Industrial Property. at
(2) The scope of the’ ‘protection of industrial property
‘shall include patents, utility models, industrial designs
and models,: trade marks, commercial names and indica-
tions of origin, or appellations of origin, as well as the
repression of unfair competition.
* , * , .-. oO: ae oe
(4) The term ‘patents’’ shall extend to the various
types of industrial patents recognized by the laws of the
countries of the Union, such: as patents of importation,
improvement patent
. ete." |
s, patents and certificates of: addition, »
ARTICLE 2.
: (Ay. Nationals of each of. the countries of the Union.
protection: of industrial property, ‘enjoy the advantages
that their respective laws now grant, or may hereafter
grant, to their own nationals, without any prejudice to the
rights epeoeey provided for by the. present convention.
ge
Yar
alien ad. . ‘ . ! AAAY
f
_ Consequently they shall Bee the same re as. a
latter, and the same legal remedy against any infringé-
ment of their rights, provided they observe the conditions
ard formalities imposed upon nationals. "
ee; . e ) ‘9 S. *
(3) The provisions of the legislation of each - of the Reservation.
. eountries of the Union relative to judicial and administra-
tive proceedings’ and to competent. authority, | as well as to-
the choice of domicile or the appointment of an authorized
‘agent, which may be required by the laws on industrial ;
property are expressly reserved. _ :
: - ; * ° ‘. ~~
7 . e
Asewas 4,
(1) Any person’ who has duly ametied: for a pat:.3
we ‘the registration of a utility model, industrial design
or model, or trade mark in one of the countries of the
(53 Stat: 1773)
Union, or. his legal representative or assignee, shall er joy
for the purposes of: registration in other countries: a right
of. priority during the periods hereinafter stated.
“Oo
(2) Any filing having the value of a formal national
filing by virtue of the internal:law of each country of the
Union or of international treaties concluded among sev:
eral countries of the Union shall be — as giving -
- rise to a right-of priority.
V
Right of priority.
filing; recognition.
B. Consequently, subsequent filing in one of the other : Effect.
countries of the Union before the expiration of these
periods shall not be invalidated through any acts accom- |
- plished in ‘the interval, as, for instance, by another filing, ©
by publication of the invention or the working thereof, >by
the sale of copies of the design or model, ot by use. of the
trade mark, and’ these facts cannot give rise to any: right.
a |
XXXVi “a oe Apy.ndia, D. - x. =
.” ‘Third parties, ete. of third parties or any wa possession. The rights —
acquired by third parties before the day of the first appli-
cation on which priority is based shall be réserved by. the
internal legislation of each country of the Union.
"Periods of priority. — (1) The above- mentioned periods of priority shall |
ee be - months for patents and utility models and 6 months
for industrial designs ‘and models and for ‘trade marks. »
(2). These periods shall start ‘from the date of filing .
5. of the first application ; the day of filing 1s not counted .
oe -in-this period. |
* * | » cree, ree
iy
mae DD. (1) Any person desiring to take sitiindiaia of the _
| priority of a previous application must make a declaration ©
¢ \ giving particulars as to the date. of such application and
the country in which it was made. Each country will de-'
termine the latest date at which such declaration must be
-made. 3
| a= (2) The particulars referred to shall be stated in the ; 3
publications issued by the ebmpetent authority, and in
particular in the patents issued: and. the specifications re-
lating thereto. . ge i ee ee
ebroduction of (3) +The countries of the Union. may require any per-
prior application.
son making. a declaration, of priority to produce a copy |
- of the application (with the specification, ‘drawings, etc.)
previously made. The copy, certified as correct by the
authority receiving this application, shall not require legal
authentication, and in all cases it can be filed, without fee,
‘at any time within the period of°3 months from the filing
of the applicatien. They may also-“require that the decla-_
~ ration later be accompanied by a certificate by the proper :
authority a the date of upplication, and. also bed ai
translation.
4 Forther formali- (4) No other fovmalitios may be- requires tor the doce
- ration of priority ‘at the time application is filed. _ Each
- 4 » .
Yi 3
Ne
— a:
a
| appendie LD. | : a XXXVii
of the countries of the Union shall teabdie upon the con- 7 :
sequences of the, omission of _the formalities prescribed
by this article, but such consequences . shall, in no case ex-
sn ceed the loss of the right of priority.
(5) Further proof. in support of the application may Further proof.
~ be required later. aes
(53 Stat. 1774) | |
A Priority ¢ cannot Be refused on the ground. that cor: Priority net to. —
~ tain elements of the invention for which priority i# claimed. FG
do not appear among the claims made in the application
in the country of origin, provided t hat the application, as
a whole, discloses: precisely the aforesaid elements. |
} . ‘ ® . eS
. ‘. —
Y — aa .
\ Aric 4 bis.
(4) “Patents applied for in the various countries of the nen + Se
Union by persons entitledto the benefits-of the‘Union shall et
be independent of the patents obtained for the same inven- | |
tion in other’ countries, whether or not such countries be |
4 parties to the Union. . ; | eee | °
(2) This stipulation must receive a strict interpreta-
tion; in particular, it shall be understood to mean that -
patents applied for during the period of. priority are inde- * — 7 yt
= pendent, both as regards the grounds for refusal and revo--
cation and as regards their normal duration. E
(3) This stipulation. shall apply to all patents already
| existing at the time when it shall come into effect.
. 5 ° “ %, :
o e : o e ‘ e. *
“>
yp
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.