Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — Aircoach Transport Ass'n v. American Airlines, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OcToBER TERM, 1956
INDEPENDENT Miitary Arr TRANSPORT ASSOCIATION,
Petitioner,
Vv.
AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC., ET AL., and
NATIONAL AIRLINES, INC., ET AL.,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
CoaTEs LEAR
Cafritz Building
Washington, D. C.
THEODORE I. SEAMON
Woodward Building
Washington, D. C.
Counsel for Petitioner,
Independent Military Air
Transport Association
Dated: February 16, 1957
Washington, D. C.
Press or Byron S. Apams, Wasuincton, D.C.
Opinion Below
Jurisdiction
Questions Presented
Statute Involved
Statement
Reasons for Granting the Writ
Conclusion
Proof of Service
CITATIONS
American Airlines, Inc., et al. v. Civil Aeronautics
Board, et al., 235 F. 2d 845 (1956
American Airlines, Inc., et al. v. Civil Aeronautics
Board, 192 F. 2d 419 (1951)
American Airlines, Inc., et al. v. Civil Aeronautics
Board, 178 F. 2d 903 (1949)
Natural Gas Pipe Line Co. v. Slattery, 302 US 300,
82 L. Ed. 276, 58 S. Ct. 199
SraTurTEs:
Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, as amended, 52 Stat.
977, as amended by 62 Stat. 493, 65 Stat. 68, 66
Stat. 628, 49 U.S. C. 401 et seq.:
Section 401 2, 10, 11, 15
Section 416(b) 2, 3, 7, 11, 13, 15, 16
28 U.S.C., Section 1254
47 U.S.C., Section 402
ii Index Continued
Page
DEcISIONS OF THE CiviL AERONAUTICS BoarRD:
Eastern Airlines, Inc—Certificates of Public Con-
venience and Necessity, 1 C. A. A. 173 (1939) .... 13
Irregular Air Carrier Investigation, Docket 5132
on Ga Aah ede kek Cony ah iea cus Kade CRS ee 9, 15
Pennsylvania Central Airlines Corporation—Cer-
tificates of Public Convenience and Necessity, 1
She eee RD. WS ewan dovn 6a bn aa eka eee 12
MISCELLANEOUS:
12 Fed. Reg. 3076, 14 C. F. RB. 292.1 .............. 4
Economie Regulations of the Civil Aeronautics
Board:
Section 292.5 (later recodified as Part 295) .... 8
Section 292.6 (later recodified as Part 296) ... 10
PUNE CO sch Ucaand base LivGd> iseuiwenias eee 10
UE EE eke po ac aacacdads <ossNb cues bes eee ll
Special Order of the Civil Aeronautics Board:
St SES dah ha CGM aR Wan 044 b Caw oe das ae sane ll
Se Rk sen DOE MOVs os od xk dh chwaunece 12
i ES cn aa ie cea cee ha win bekaeenLawen 12
EE i Sia dius ahh she SOO maw bKED Koken 12
eect. GCE EES CURES T OP OR Ea ET ere Ce 12
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OcroBeR TERM, 1956
No.
——
INDEPENDENT Miuitary Arr TRANSPORT ASSOCIATION,
Petitioner,
Vv.
American AIRLINES, INC., ET AL., and
Nationa AIRLINES, INC., ET AL.,
Respondents.
———
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
—
To the Honorable The Chief Justice of the United
States, and the Associate Justices of the Supreme
Court of the United States:
Your Petitioner, Independent Military Air Trans-
port Association, respectfully prays that a writ of
2
certiorari issue to review the judgment of the United
States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia
Circuit, entered in the above entitled cause.
The Opinion of the Court below (Appendix A, infra,
pp. la-17a) is officially reported at 235 F. 2d 845,
The judgment of the Court of Appeals was entered
on July 19, 1956. Orders denying petitions for re.
hearing were entered on September 19, 1956. The
jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28 USC
1254 (1) and 47 USC 402 (J).
1. Whether the Civil Aeronautics Board exceeded
its statutory powers under Section 416 (b) of the Aet
(Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, as amended, 49 USC
496 (b)) in exempting from the Certificate require-
ments of Section 401 (49 USC 481) some 49 carriers
to perform the air transportation services permitted
on an interim basis pending final decision with respect
to their applications for Certificates of Public Con-
venience and Necessity.
2. Whether the Civil Aeronautics Board, in the
Opinion and Order under review, made sufficient
findings, as a matter of law, to support the conclusion
that enforcement of the Certificate requirements of
the Act would be an undue burden by reason of the —
limited extent of or unusual circumstances affecting
the operations of the exemptees and not in the public
interest.
—
3
3. Whether the Court below should have withheld
action ip the case until Petitioners below demonstrated
that they had exhausted their administrative remedies.
STATUTE INVOLVED
The statute involved is the Civil Aeronauties Act
of 1938, 52 Stat. 973, et seg., 49 USC 401 et seq., the
pertinent provisions of which are set forth in
pendix B, infra. Particularly involved is Section
416 (b) (1) of said Act which is set forth in Appendix
B at page
STATEMENT
This Petition seeks review of the judgment of the
United States Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia whereby it reversed the Opinion and Order
of the Civil Aeronautics Board granting to members
of your Petitioner’s Association certain enlarged
operating rights in air transportation pending final
decision with respect to the applications of such
members for Certificates of Public Convenience &
Necessity.
Your Petitioner is an Association of air carriers
composed principally of Supplemental Air Carriers
(formerly known as Irregular Air Carriers). The
Court below granted your Petitioner leave to inter-
vene in the proceeding by Order dated January 23,
1956.
The proceeding sought to be reviewed by this
Honorable Court arose on September 21, 1951 as a
result of an Order by the Civil Aeronautics Board
instituting a general investigation to determine what
place, if any, the so-called Irregular Air Carriers
should have in the field of air transportation.
4
Since the Civil Aeronautics Act became law in 1938,
Irregular Air Carriers had been permitted by exemp-
tion order of the Civil Aeronautics Board to engage
in air transportation on an irregular or “‘pon-
scheduled” basis. Although the term “irregular” or
‘**non-scheduled”’ was never precisely defined by the
Civil Aeronautics Board, it was generally conceded
that such carriers could operate between 8 and 12
flights per month on an individually ticketed basis
under regulations which had been in effect for many
years. These flights, however, had to be operated on
an irregular or infrequent basis and, indeed, the
precise number of flights which a carrier could operate
during a given period of time was not known to any
of the carriers.
At the end of World War 11, numerous war-trained
pilots sought to enter the field of air transportation
by establishing their own independent airlines,
Accordingly, in 1947 the Civil Aeronautics Board
revised its exemption regulation (12 Fed. Reg. 3076,
14 CFR 292.1) to require Letters of Registration as
a condition precedent to operations and to distinguish
between operators of transport-type aircraft (large
irregular carriers) and operators of small aircraft
(small irregular carriers ).' 142 large irregular carriers
were issued Letters of Registration pursuant to the
1947 regulation.
In 1949 the Civil Aeronautics Board again revised
the regulations (14 CFR 291) terminating the blanket
exemption authority under the 1947 regulations aud
' The latter carriers now known as air taxi operators are per-
mitted to engage in unlimited operations on a scheduled basis using
aircraft with a gross take-off weight of no more than 12,500 pounds.
(i.e., capacity of transporting about 8 passengers) (14 CFR 298).
—
5
requiring large irregular carriers to apply for
individual exemption authority. 97 of the 142 holders
applications for exemption authority (TR. 48585).
The Order of the Civil Aeronautics Board of
ber 21, 1951 consolidated in the proceeding
these applications for individual exemption authority
together with applications for Certificates of Public
Convenience and Necessity filed by the applicants.
(TR. 42494, 48586).
The applicants in the proceeding before the Civil
Aeronautics Board (known as the Irregular Air
Carrier Investigation, Docket 5132, et al.) for the
most part, sought authority to engage in unlimited
charter operations plus i4 flights per month between
any two points on indi: idually ticketed or waybilled
flights. (TR. 48649-48606).
The Petitioners below are holders of Certificates of
Public Convenience and Necessity (e-.€., American
After nearly four years of hearings (during which
time a record of over 50,000 pages was built) the Civil
Aeronautics Board on November 15, 1955 issued its
in the Large Irregular Air Carrier Investiga-
tion, Docket 5132, et al. In this Opinion the Civil
Aeronautics Board reclassified the large irregular air
:
carriers as ‘‘Supplemental Air Carriers” and granted
to each member of the class the authority to: (1)
operate up to ten (10) individually ticketed or way-
billed flights per month between the same pair of
points without regard to regularity, and (2) engage
in an unlimited number of charter flights where the
entire capacity of the aircraft is utilized by a single
person (except ticket agents, ete.) (TR. 48550, 48552,
48565, 48590, 48591 and 48688). The ten (10) flight
authorization was a substitute for the prior authoriza-
tion whereby there was no precise numerical limitation
on flights, but where from 8 to 12 flights could be
operated between the same points. The authority to
operate charter flights (except with ticket agencies,
ete.) was made unlimited whereas under the old
regulations, charter flights were counted in determin-
ing ‘‘regularity’’.
Throughout its decision, the Civil Aeronauties
Board repeatedly emphasized the fact that the
authority granted was on a temporary or interim basis
pending final decision with reference to the applicants’
petitions for Certificates of Publie Convenience and
Necessity.
6
The Civil Aeronautics Board unanimously approved
the granting of uniimited charter rights to the
applicants but the Board split 3 to 2 on the question
of whether the applicants should be authorized to
operate the 10 individually ticketed flights, the latter
having been vigorously opposed by the Petitioners
below. The Board also reserved jurisdiction over the
case for the purpose of further reducing the number
of permissible individually ticketed flights on an
expedited basis in the event the 10 flights should prove
—
7
unduly competitive with the established services of
the certificated air carriers.
The Court below did not vonsider the record built
up in the hearings before the Civil Aeronautics Board
put reversed the Board on the grounds that the
authority granted the applicants was a permanent
authorization and that the Board had not ‘‘as a matter
of law’? made sufficient findings of fact to justify the
conclusion that the granting of Certificates of Public
Convenience and Necessity to the applicants would be
an undue burden because of the limited extent or un-
usual circumstances surrounding their operations and
not in the public interest.
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
The United States Court of Appeals for the District
of Columbia Circuit had decided an important question
of Federal law which has not been, but should be,
settled by this Court. Specifically, the decision of the
Court below severely restricted the powers heretofore
exercised by the Civil Aeronautics Board pursuant to
Section 416 (b) (1) of the Act to develop air trans-
portation in the public interest and in the interests
of National Defense. The Opinion of the Court below
also overrules 18 years’ of consistent administrative
interpretation of Section 416 (b) (1) by the Civil
Aeronautics Board which interpretation has been
consistently upheld by the Circuit Courts.
Pursuant to Section 2 of the Civil Aeronautics Act
(see Appendix page 17a) it is the duty of the Civil
Aeronautics Board to foster the development of air
transportation to the maximum possible extent in the
public interest and in the interest of National Defense.
Since World War II the Board has made extensive
a
8
use of its exemption powers in order to foter the
development of new or experimental types of air
transportation services. Following are a few ex*™ples:
A. On May 5, 1947 the Civil Aeronautic: Board
adopted Section 292.5 of the Economic Regiations
which created a class of carriers engaged ex¢¥S!vely
in the transportation of air freight and pd™mitted
these carriers to engage in unlimited, schedul@ cargo
operation over all the principal airline route’ 1” the
United States until such time as the Board eoild pass
upon their applications for Certificates of Pub!¢ Con-
venience and Necessity which were pending at that
time. This was the fundamental regulatior Which
brought into being the air freight carrie 28 4
significant part of the air transportation indu¢tY- In
commenting upon Section 292.5 of the K/0nomic
Regulations (later recodified as Part 295) CAB
Member Gurney, formerly Chairman of ti? Civil
Aeronautics Board (and one of the disenting
Members herein) testified before the Senate Cof™ttee
on Interstate and Foreign Commerce on §-2647 as
follows:
“In addition to making provision for SUPP!e-
mental service, the Board has used its xe
authority under Section 416 (b) of th Civil
Aeronautics Act of 1938 fur development wee
Thus, as indicated a few moments ar?» the
authority was used to authorize the initia] °XPe™
ment of the all-freight carriers.
‘Part 295 of the Board’s Economic age?
tions, adopted in 1947, opened the way weir:
perimental scheduled all-freight services by“ of
noncertificated carriers. After the experi™°® °
2 or 3 years, some of these carriers we-® —
certificated and now hold certificates of PUX¢
9
convenience and necessity, authorizing them to
engage in freight-only operations.
“Tt is quite probable that had not the services
been tested by means of an experimental period,
there might not have been sufficient evidence to
warrant a finding of public convenience and
necessity for this type of operation.
‘A second type of experimental authorization
under the present Board powers related to an all-
expense tour operator. Successful operations,
pursuant to an exemption order, led to the sub-
sequent issuance of the certificate of public con-
venience and necessity.”’
The Board’s decision granting Certificates of Pubii-
Convenience and Necessity to a number of these cargo
carriers was appealed to the United States Court of
Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit by sub-
stantially the same carriers which appealed the
instant decision of the Board and substantially the
same arguments were advanced to the effect that the
Board had disregarded its statutory functions and
made inadequate findings or findings not supported
by substantial evidence. The Board’s opinion was
unanimously affirmed by the Cireuit Court. American
Airlines, Inc., et al. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 192
F, 2d 417 (1951).
The instant proceeding is exactly parallel to the
ease which gave birth to the air freight earriers. In
the instant proceeding the Board found that the
irregular (Supplemental) air carriers might reason-
ably suffer severe financial reverses under the then-
existing regulations; that these carriers had made
substantial contributions to air transportation (par-
ticularly in providing low cost ‘‘eoach service’? and
10
contract operations for the Military Establishment)
and that such carriers should be preserved as an
operating group in the public interest and in the in-
terest of National Defense pending final determination
of their applications for Certificates of Publie Con-
venience and Necessity. For all practical purposes,
the same findings were made with reference to the air
freight carriers and, as pointed out by Member
Gurney, ‘‘it is quite probable that, had not the services
been tested by means of an experimental period, there
might not have been sufficient evidence to warrant a
finding of public convenience and necessity for this
type of operation.”’
B. On July 1, 1949, the Board adopted Section
292.6 (now Part 296) of the Economic Regulations
and thereby established a classification of indirect air
carriers known as air freight forwarders. These
carriers, like the freight carriers, were exempted from
most of the provisions of Title IV of the Civil Aero-
nautics Act, including the Certificate provisions of
Section 401 (a). This decision by the Board, like the
Air Freight Case, was appealed by substantially the
same carriers and the principal contention was agen
that the Board had exceeded its statutory authority.
The Board’s opinion was unanimously affirmed by the
United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh
Circuit. American Airlines, Inc., et al. v. C. A. B.,
178 F. 2d 903 (1949).
C. On April 24, 1950, the Board adopted Part 297
of the Economic Regulations (15 FR 1866) and
thereby created a class of carriers known as inter-
national air freight forwarders, which, like the
domestic air freight forwarders, were granted exemp-
—_—"——
11
tion from most of the provisions of Title IV of the Act
including the Certificate provisions of Section 401 (a).
D. On February 20, 1952, the Board adopted Part
998 of the Economic Regulations (17 FR 635) and
thereby created a classification of air carriers known
as air taxi operators. These carriers, like the air
freight carriers and the air freight forwarders, were
granted exemption from most of the provisions of
Title IV including the Certificate requirements of
Section 401 (a).
E. The use by the Board of its exemption powers
under Section 416 (b) for the development of air
transportation has by no means been limited to the
period since World War II. Thus, as early as
December 7, 1938, the Board adopted Regulation 400-1
which created the non-scheduled air carriers and
exempted them from the provisions of Section 401 and
practically all the other provisions of Title Iv. In
1938 and 1939 the Board granted exemptions from the
provisions of Section 401 (a) of the Act to a number
of carriers and thereby authorized them to engage in
unlimited scheduled operations in air transportation
of mail, passengers and property over a number of
specific routes over which the statute required the dis-
continuance of service pending granting of Certificates.
Pennsylvania Central Airline Corporation was
authorized by exemption from the provisions of Section
401 (a) to render air transportation service “over the
route between Detroit, Michigan and Sault Ste. Marie,
Michigan via intermediate cities” for all classes of
traffic for which authorization was sought until an
application for certificate filed by such carrier could
be acted on. This exemption covered a period from
12
June 23, 1938 to and including 120 days thereafter
and beyond the 120-day period, provided only that
application for certificate was filed within a period of
120 days after June 23, 1938.2
National Airlines was similarly author 4 to engage
in air transportation of mail in addition to persons
and property ‘‘over the route between J acksonville,
Florida and New Orleans, Louisiana via Tallahassee,
Marianna, Pensacola, Florida, Mobile, Alabama and
Gulfport, Mississippi’’, pending action on its applica-
tion for certificate authorization to Serve that route.’
Eastern Air Lines was granted similar exemption
authorizations with respect to transportation of mail,
persons and property “over a route from Tampa,
Florida, to Tallahassee, Florida, and from Tallahassee,
Florida to Memphis, Tennessee”’ via intermadiate
points and from Tallahassee, Florida to Atlanta,
Georgia via Albany, Georgia; and ‘‘over a route from
Houston, Texas to Brownsville, Texas and from
Houston, Texas to San Antonio, Texas.’* As the
Board stated in its Opinion granting Eastern its grand-
father certificate :
“‘On and before that date (June 23, 1938) the
applicant was not engaged in air transportation
to any point on air mail routes Nos. 40 and 42.
2 Special Order 401-A-1; Pennsylvania Central was awarded a
Post Office coniract for this route on June 25, 1938 and its opera-
tions were not instituted until J uly 20, 1938. The statutory provi-
sions of Section 401 (a) of the Act would have required the discon-
tinuance of service on August 22, 1938 in the absence of the fore-
going exemption authorization. 1 CAA 66, 70 (1939).
* Special Order 401-A-6.
* Special Order 401-A-7 and Special Order 401-A-8.
13
Therefore, applicant was prohibited by the act
from engaging im air transportation on such routes
until certificates authorizing such transportation
should be issued. In order to enable the applicant
to commence operations on these routes prior to
the issuance of any certificates for the routes, the
Authority, pursuant to the provisions of Section
416 (b) of the Act, on October 10, 1938, promul-
gated Special Order 401-A-7 and Special Order
401-A-8 exempting applicant from the provisions
of Section 401 (a) of the Act with respect to the
commencement of operation on air matl routes
Nos. 40 and 42, respectively, wntil such time as the
Authority shall issue certificates of public con-
venience and necessity for the air transportation
service over such routes of applicant, or shall issue
its final order denying the application of the
applicant for such certificates.’ (Emphasis
supvlied).
Braniff was given similar exemption authorization
over a route between Dallas, Texas and San Antonio,
Texas via Waco and Austin.
In none of the above cases did the Board ever make
any findings as extensive as those which were made
in the instant proceeding. Indeed, in the great
majority of the above cases, the Board simply recited
the statutory findings required by Section 416 (b) (1)
without any discussion of the subsidiary reasons for
the granting of the exemption orders. In striking
contrast to practically all of the above proceedings,
the Board in the instant case made the following
principal findings:
51 CAA 173, 179 (1939).
® Special Order 401-A-9.
14
1. That the granting of the exception order was
necessary in order to preserve the carriers in the
public interest (Tr. 48540, 48541, 48550, 48558,
48630, 49199, and 49204).
2. That the preservation of the carriers is im.
portant in the interests of national defense
(Tr. 48541, 48550).
3. That the carriers had experienced a steady
worsening in position in terms of dwindling
revenues, resources, and number of carriers under
previous regulations and that more liberal regula-
tions were necessary to preserve the carriers
(Tr. 48536, 48585, 48598-99, 49198, and 49199),
4. That the carriers are small in relation to over-
all financial resources and revenues derived by the
entire aviation industry (Tr. 4865-77).
5. That the authority granted the small carriers
would not have any serious adverse competitive
impact upon the large certificated airlines (Tr.
48951, 48554, 48555, 48557, 48558, 49202, 49203).
6. That the ability of the carriers to operate
their aircraft in the interest of national defense
depends in large measure upon their commercial
activities (Tr. 48541, 48550).
7. That insufficient coach service has been pro-
vided by the large certificated carriers and the
existence of the small carriers is necessary to
accommodate peak traffic demands (Tr. 48634,
48683-85, 49201).
8. That the carriers have been forced to operate
under serious competitive disadvantages (Tr.
48626, 48634).
9. That there is a public need for the services
of the carriers in order to develop new and differ-
ent services and demands (Tr. 49196-97, 49203-04).
ee
15
The above are merely a few of the more important
subsidiary findings. In addition, the Board, of course,
made the statutory finding required by Section 416 of
the Civil Aeronautics Act to the effect that the enforce-
ment of the certificate provisions contained in Section
401(a) of the Act would be an undue burden upon the
carriers by reason of the limited extent of or unusual
circumstances affecting their operations and would
not be in the public interest.
F. The large certificated air carriers (the petitioners
below), did not either in the United States Court of
Appeals or before the Board raise any serious objec-
tions to the authority granted the supplemental
carriers to engage in unlimited charter operations. The
petitioners below did, however, object to the authority
granted the supplemental carriers to operate up to
10 (ten) trips per month on an individually ticketed
or individually waybilled basis.
Admittedly it was impossible for the Board to fore-
east with mathematical exactness what competitive
impact, it any, the 10-flight per month authorization
would have upon the certificated airline industry. This
is a matter about which reasonable persons may dis-
agree, as witnessed by the fact that the Board itself
was split three to two on the issue. The Board, there-
fore, specifically retained jurisdiction in the case for
the purpose of further limiting the number of per-
missible individually ticketed flights in the event that
practical experience showed that the 10-flight limita-
tion should prove unduly competitive upon the certi-
ficated airlines. The Board stated:
“Tf in actual practice it should develop that the
amount of service offered under the 10-flight pro-
vision proves excessive in terms of its impact upon
16
the certificated route structure, we should be free
to make the necessary adjustments to that pro-
vision and to do so promptly. Fer that reason,
we are expressly reserving the power to make
downward adjustments in the 10-flight provision
and to do so on an expedited basis if circumstances
so require.”’
The law is well settled that where a Government
agency has authority to pass upon the question raised
by a petitioner in a judicial proceeding and the agency
is able to modify the order under attack, the Court
should withhold its aid entirely until administrative
remedies have been exhausted. Natural Gas Pipe
Line Co. v. Slattery, 302 U.S. 300, 82 L. ed. 276,
58 S. Ct. 199. The Court below, however, refused to
pass upon this important question and, indeed, made
no mention thereof in its opinion.
CONCLUSION
The Court below has decided an important question
of administrative law which has not but should be
passed upon by this Honorable Court. Specifically,
the Court below has ruled that pursuant to Section
416(b) of the Civil Aeronautics Act, the Civil Aero-
nautics Board has no authority to grant supplemental
operating rights to a number of small airlines whose
existence the Board has found to be essential in the
public interest and in the interests of national defense.
Moreover, the opinion of the Court below overrules
eighteen years of administrative interpretation of Sec-
tion 416(b) of the Civil Aeronautics Act, which inter-
pretation has consistently been upheld by the various
circuit courts but has not yet been passed upon by this
Court. The findings of the Civil Aeronautics Board
in the case are set forth in detail in an elaborate
smennmcnanneninil
17
opinion and supplemental opinion on reconsideration.
The detailed findings of the Board are, in turn, sup-
ported by a record totalling over 50,000 pages, which
has been built up during proceedings lasting nearly
four years. If the opinion of the Court below is not re-
versed, there is grave danger that the supplemental
air carriers which have made substantial contributions
to air transportation and to the interests of national
defense wil! cease to exist.
WHEREFORE, it is respectfully prayed that this Hon-
orable Court issue a Writ of Certiorari to the Court
below.
Respectfully submitted,
Coates LEAR
Cafritz Building
Washington, D. C.
Turopore I. SEAMON
Woodward Building
Washington, -
Counsel for ;
Independent Military Air
Transport Association
Dated: February 16, 1957
18
Proof of Service
I, Coates Lear, one of the attorneys for the Inde-
pendent Military Air Transport Association, Inter-
venor herein, and a member of the Bar of the Supreme
Court of the United States, hereby certify that on Feb-
ruary 16, 1957, I served a copy of the foregoing
Petition for Writ of Certiorari upon the persons listed
below by mailing copies, in duly addressed envelopes,
with first class postage prepaid, as follows:
Honorable Herbert J. Brownell
Attorney General of the United States
Department of Justice 7
Washington, D. C.
Mr. Daniel M. Friedman
Attorney
Department of Justice
Washington, D. C.
Mr. Franklin M. Stone
General Counsel
Civil Aeronautics Board
Washington, D. C.
John T. Lorch, Esq.
231 South LaSalle Street
Chicago 4, Illinois
James Francis Reilly, Esq.
1625 K Street, N. W.
Washington 6, D. C.
Attorneys for United Air Lines, Inc.
Charles H. Murchison, Esq.
1016 Ring Building
Washington 6, D. C.
Attorney for Capital Airlines, Inc.
Hubert A. Schneider, Esq.
815 Fifteenth Street, N. W.
Washington 5, D. C.
Attorney for Braniff Airways, Inc.
~-O7~—
19
Gerald P. O’Grady, Esq.
1625 Eye Street, N. W.
Washington 6, D. C. -
Attorney for Pacific Northern™'"e* Inc.
Amos M. Mathews, Esq.
208 Union Station Building
Chicago 6, Illinois ;
Attorney for Abilene & Sout™® Railway
Co., et al.
Richard A. Fitzgerald, Esq.
920 Southern Building
Washington 5, D. C.
Attorney for National Airline!"
Intervenor
Albert F. Beitel, Esq.
905 American Security Building
Washington 5, D. C. tala
Attorney for Aircoach Trans} Association
and Quaker City Airways, I Intervenors
Mr. O. D. Ozment wr
Chief, Litigation and Research wyteron
Civil Aeronautics Board
Washington 25, D. C.
Coates LEAR
Attorney folndependent
Military At
gOS Cafr' Building
Washing® 8, D. C.
Se AEST
*
a:
t=
7
aa
—
- .
a
4x
la
APPENDIX A
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
No. 13044
American ArrLiNnEs, INO., PETITIONER
NaTIonaL AIRLINES, INc., INTERVENOR
Vv.
Crvi. AERonNAUTICS BoarD, RESPONDENT
Caprro: Arrways, Inc., QuaKER Crry Airways, Inc.,
Arrcoach Transport AssociaTIon, and LNDEPENDENT
Mumrrary Arr Transport ASSOCIATION, INTERVENORS
No. 13045
Trans Wortp AIRLINEs, INC., PETITIONER
Vv.
Crviz AgronauTics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13048
Eastern Arr Lives, INc., PETITIONER
v.
Crvir AERONAUTICS BoaRD, RESPONDENT
No. 13052
Pan Amextcan Wortp Airways, INC., PETITIONER
Vv.
Crvir Agronavutics BoarD, RESPONDENT
2a
No. 13054
Detra Arr Livzgs, INc., PETITIONER
Vv.
Civ. ArRonavuTics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13061
Untrep Ai Lings, INc., PETITIONER
v.
Crvm AERONAUTICS BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13063
ConTINENTAL Air Livzs, INc., PETITIONER
Vv.
Crviz Agronautics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13064
Nortuwest Air Linzs, Inc., PETITIONER
v.
Crviz AERONAUTICS BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13068
ALLEGHENY Arrives, Inc., et al., PETITIONERS
Vv.
Crvm, AERONAUTICS BoarD, RESPONDENT
3a
No. 13116
Western Arr Lives, INC., PETITIONER
v.
Crvi, Agronavutics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13117
CaprraL AIRLINES, INC., PETITIONER
v.
Crviz AERONAUTICS BoaRD, RESPONDENT
No. 13118
Branirr Airways, INc., PETITIONER
v.
Crviz Agronautics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13120
Pactric NorTHERN AIRLINES, INC., PETITIONER
v.
Crvut Agronautics BoarD, RESPONDENT
No. 13121
Apmene & SouTHERN Rattway Company, et al.,
PETITIONERS
Vv.
Crvm Arronavtics BoarD, RESPONDENT
4a
On Petitions for Review of Order of the
Civil Aeronautics Board
Decided July 19, 1956
Mr. Howard C. Westwood, with whom Mr. Clifton J.
Stratton, Jr., was on the brief for petitioner in No. 13044,
argued for all petitioners and for intervenor National
Airlines, Ine., in No. 13044. Mr. Richard A. Fitzgerald
was on the brief for intervenor National Airlines, Inc.,
in No. 13044.
Mr. John F. Floberg for petitioners in No. 13068. Mr.
Edward DeGrazia also entered an appearance for peti-
tioners in No. 13068.
Mr. J. D. Feeney, Jr., with whom Messrs. Amos M.
Mathews and Thormund A. Miller were on the brief, for
petitioners in No. 13121.
Mr. James K. Crimmins was on the brief for petitioner
in No. 13045. Mr. William Caverly also entered an ap-
pearance for petitioner in No. 13045. Mr. W. Glen Har-
lan was on the brief for petitioner in No. 13048. Messrs.
Henry J. Friendly, Robert C. Barnard and Leon Lipson
were on the brief for petitioner in No. 13052. Messrs.
L. Welch Pogue and James F. Bell were on the brief for
petitioner in No. 13054. Mr. Robert L. Stern was on the
brief for petitioner in No. 13061. Mr. James Francis
Reiliy entered an appearance for petitioner in No. 13061.
Messrs. C. Edward Leasuwre and Herman F. Scheurer,
Jr., were on the brief for petitioners in Nos. 13063 and
13064. Messrs. L. Welch Pogue and James W. Callison
were on the brief for petitioner in No. 13116. Messrs.
Robert B. Hankins and Macon M. Arthur were on the
brief for petitioner in No. 13117. Messrs. Hubert A.
Schneider and B. Howell Hill were on the brief for peti-
tioner in No. 13118. Mr. Gerald P. O’Grady was on the
brief for petitioner in No. 13120.
—
5a
Mr. O. D. Ozment, Chief, Litigation and Research Divi-
sion, Civil Aeronautics Board, with whom Mr. Franklin
M. Stone, General Counsel, Civil Aeronautics Board, Mr.
John H. Wanner, Associate General Counsel, Civil Aero-
nauties Board, Messrs. Robert L. Park, Gerald F.. Krassa
and Henry M. Switkay, Attorneys, Civil Aeronautics
Board, and Mr. Daniel M. Friedman, Attorney, Depart-
ment of Justice, were on the brief, for respondent.
Mr. Albert F. Beitel, with whom Mr. John H. Pratt
was on the brief, for intervenor Aircoach Transport As-
sociation, in No. 13044. Messrs. Albert F. Beitel and
John H. Pratt entered appearances for intervenor Quaker
City Airways, Inc., in No. 13044.
Mr. Coates Lear, with whom Mr. Theodore I. Seamon
was on the brief, for intervenor Independent Military
Air Transport Association, in No. 18044. Messrs. Coates
Lear and Theodore I. Seamon entered appearances for
intervenor Capitol Airways, Inc., in No. 13044.
Before Prerryman, Witpur K. Miuuer, and Fay,
Cireuit Judges.
Prettyman, Circuit Judge: These are petitions to re-
view an order of the Civil Aeronautics Board.’ This
order is the latest in a long series dealing with the
problem of the non-scheduled or irregular air carriers.
Petitioners are the certificated air carriers and certain
railroads. The intervenors in behalf of the respondent
are associations of irregular carriers. The respondent,
of course, is the Civil Aeronautics Board. It is unneces-
sary to recite here the background of the present con-
troversy. It appears in its various stages in a long line
of cases before this court and before the Board.’
1 Order B-9744. Technically, a subsequent order, E-9884, deny-
ing reconsideration of the first order, is also involved.
2 See, e.g., Air Transport Associates v. Civil ‘Aeronautics Board,
91 U.S. App. D.C. 147, 199 F.2d 181 (1952), cert. denied, 344 US.
922, 97 L.Ed. 710, 73 S.Ct. 386 (1953); American Air Transport
6a
The basic requirement heretofore imposed upon the ir-
regular carriers by the Board has been that they Oper-
ate without any reasonable semblance of regularity as to
schedule or route. The basic change wrought by the
present order is to remove this requirement of irregu-
larity and to substitute in its place a maximum limita.
tion upon the number of round trips permitted per month
between any two points. The Board accomplishes this
objective by granting these carriers an exemption under
Section 416(b) of the Act.* The petitioners contest
the validity of the order, so far as the present argu-
ment is concerned,* upon three basic grounds: (1) that
the Act grants the Board no power to issue such an
order; (2) that the order is not supported by the find-
ings required by the statute; and (3) that the order is
beyond the scope of the proceeding.
In 1951 the Board instituted a proceeding to deter-
mine its future policy with regard to Large Irregular
Air Carriers.’ Some sixty-six applicants were involved.
Two examiners began hearings, in which not only the
general problem was involved but the individual quali-
fications of the several applicants were treated as issues.
Testimony as to about half of the applicants had been
v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 92 U.S. App. D.C. 117, 206 F.2d 423
(1953) ; Eastern Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 87 U.S. App.
D.C. 331, 185 F.2d 426 (1950), vacated, 341 U.S. 901, 95 L.Ed.
1341, 71 S.Ct. 613 (1951); New England Air Express v. Civil
Aeronautics Board, 90 U.S. App. D.C. 215, 194 F.2d 894 (1952);
Large Irregular Carriers, Exemptions, 11 C.A.B. 609 (1950).
*52 Srar. 1004 (1938), as amended, 49 U.S.C.A. § 496(b).
*The petitions for review presented, generally speaking, issues
of law and also issues requiring examination of the evidentiary
record. This record totaled fifty thousand pages. By a prehear-
ing order under Rule 38(k) of the Rules of this Court, the court
ordered that the issues of law be briefed, argued and decided and
that pending such disposition the evidentiary issues be reserved.
*The proceeding was known as The Large Irregular Air Car-
rier Investigation, Docket No. 5132.
—
7a
presented when the Board deferred further hearing on
such qualifications and directed that the proceeding go
forward upon the general questions. The examiners pre-
sented an initial decision. Exceptions to it were filed,
and oral argument was held before the Board. A ma-
jority rendered a long opinion and an order. Two mem-
bers dissented. In the order the Board recited that the
enforcement of the certification provisions of the Act
(Sections 401(a),° 404(a)' and 405(e)*) would be an un-
due burden on the carriers by reason of the limited
extent of, and the unusual circumstances affecting, the
operations of such carriers. It ordered that forty-nine
of the applicants (naming them) be temporarily exempted
from the certification requirements, subject to certain
terms, and that each be issued an ‘‘Interim Operating
Authorization”? to terminate sixty days after the Board
should dispose of the several individual applications for
exemption authority. The terms attached to the order
were long and in some detail. The principal one was
that the carrier not engage in more than ten flights in
the same direction between any single pair of points in
any calendar month. In respect to this condition the
Board said in its order:
‘‘Whenever, in the judgment of the Board, there
is reason to believe that the foregoing ten flight limi-
tation is insufficient to confine the operations of
supplemental air carriers as a class to the rendition
of the supplemental services for which they are
authorized, and that the operations of such carriers
pose a substantial threat to the stability and sound-
ness of the certificated air carrier system, the Board
may at any time reopen the proceeding and, after
notice and opportunity for argument and with or
withont additional evidentiary hearing, make such
downward adjustments in the maximum flight limita-
652 Srar. 987 (1938), as amended, 49 U.S.C.A. § 481(a).
752 Srav. 993 (1938), as amended, 49 U.S.C.A. § 484(a).
852 Srar. 995 (1938), as amended, 49 U.S.C.A. § 485(e).
8a
tion as the Board may deem necessary or desirable,
The interim operating authorizations granted by this
order are herein expressly conditioned upon and
subject to the reserved right of the Board to make
further limitations, restrictions or modifications of
the ten flight limitation, including a reduction in the
number of such flights, to insure that the services
remain supplemental.’’
The opinion of the Board makes clear that the ten
flights per month may be conducted upon the basis of
a regular schedule. The opinion also makes clear that
the Board contemplated that these air carriers could offer
unlimited charter operations on a plane-load basis in
domestic carriage.
The reasoning of the Board may be summarized. It
found that the services performed by the irregular ear.
riers, including charter operations, individually ticketed
coach flights, specialized services, and military air-lift,
have proven of importance to both the irregular carriers
and the public, meeting real needs. It concluded that its
policy should be directed toward their survival and
healthy growth. It determined that the services rendered
by the irregular carriers could not be rendered satisfac
torily by the presently certificated carriers, which have
fixed commitments to route and schedule operation. It
found that the elimination of the restriction against regu-
larity would help the public and strengthen the supple-
mental carriers, and that it would aid in the administration
and enforcement of regulations. The Board emphasized
that it selected the number ten as the number of permis-
sible trips by taking into account on an average basis the
number of permissible trips which might be operated by
these carriers under heretofore existing regulations.
The Board turned its particular attention to the sug-
gestion that the new scope of supplemental operations
would open the door to unlimited competition which
would affect adversely the certificated carriers. It held
—
9a
that the hard facts of economic realism would operate
against such a situation, reciting in detail the considera-
tions which led to this conclusion. It said it would not
permit the supplemental carriers to combine and inte-
grate their operations. It said it would ‘‘underscore for
all concerned’? that the supplemental carriers are to be
restricted to needs they are designed to meet and that
if they posed a threat to the certificated system ‘*they
must face up to a prompt and effective diminution in the
maximum permissible flight frequencies.”’
The Board made a comparatively brief recital in re-
spect to the undue burden upon the applicants and the
unusual circumstances affecting their operations, a mat-
ter which we shall discuss in detail hereinafter. The
Board reserved decision as to the nature and form of
the authority to be granted for the supplemental air
transportation it contemplated until the completion of
the hearings upon the qualifications of the individual
applicants, in the meantime issuing temporary authoriza-
tion.
Petitioners vigorously attack the order upon the ground
that it is not authorized by the statute. Section 416(b)(1)
reads as follows:
“The Board, from time to time and to the extent
necessary, may (except as provided in paragraph (2)
of this subsection) exempt from the requirements of
this title or any provision thereof, or any rule, regu-
lation, term, condition, or limitation prescribed there-
under, any air carrier or class of air carriers, if it
finds that the enforcement of this title-or such pro-
vision, or such rule, regulation, term, condition, or
limitation is or would be an undue burden on such
air carrier or class of air carriers by reason of the
limited extent of, or unusual circumstances affecting,
the operations of such air carrier or class of air car-
riers and is not in the public interest.”
It is clear that the foregoing provision has two basic
parts. In the first place, in broad language, it empowers
16a
the Board to exempt any class of carriers from “any
provision’’ of the statute or ‘‘any rule, regulation, term,
condition, or limitation prescribed thereunder.” This is
sweeping language. The second basic provision in the
paragraph is that in order to exert this broad power of
exemption the Board must find that enforcement of the
statutory provision is or would be ‘‘an undue burden”
on the class of carriers by reason of the limited extent
of, or unusual circumstances affecting, the operation of
such carriers. The Board must further find that enforce-
ment of the provision is not in the public interest.
This first point of petitioners is that the Board has
no authority to issue this order as an exemption order
with or without findings such as the ones described in
the last clause of the quoted section. They say the order,
in and of itself, is outside the scope of the quoted exemp-
tion section. The order, they say, represents something
the Board cannot do by exemption. Although, as will
develop, we think another contention dispositive of this
proceeding, a ruling upon that other contention alone
would leave the controversy in a wholly unsettled state.
The parties have briefed and argued the point now be-
fore us, and we shall dispose of it. To treat it we must
assume arguendo that valid findings as to undue burden
and public interest are made.
The petitioners urge that the basic concept of the
statute enacted by the Congress for the regulation of
the air industry is of a certificated system. Section
401(a) specifically requires that no air carrier shall en-
gage in any air transportation unless there is in force
a certificate issued by the Board. Various subsections,
notably, inter alia, (d), (f) and (k) of Section 401, make
provisions respecting certificates and certificated carriers.
Petitioners say Congress did not intend that the Board
might, by the use of the exemption provision of Section
416(b), destroy the elaborate basic requirements of the
Act for a certificated system of airplane carriage. The
—
lla
petitioners are quite correct in that conteon. Despite
the broad language of Section 416(b) we ink it is per-
fectly clear that the Congress did not set | So elaborate
a series of provisions in respect to the rtification of
carriers, and the public interest, conveniee and neces-
sity therein involved, and at the some tingrant its ad-
ministrative agency power to destroy se elaborate
provisions. We think there is and must? a boundary
to the authority of the Board under its emption power
to impinge upon the certificated service.
But the Board does not disagree withhe foregoing.
Its position is that a sound national tranortation sys-
tem requires, from the standpoints bothf the normal
traveling public and of the national deise, a service
supplemental to that which is and can rendered by
carriers certificated to routes, schedules a services. It
declares that the proposed supplementatarriage must
not in the aggregate jeopardize the cericated carrier
system. It says that the main and basitransportation
system must be a certificated system but at in addition
there must be a supplemengal service. Jnot only thus
declares its position but, as we have sn, it inserted
both in its opinion and in its order a seifie provision
that, if experience should show that t supplemental
operation poses a substantial threat tohe certificated
system, adjustments will be made to prent that result.
The position of the Board is a rationayne, There is
undoubtedly a demand for charter serviiand for extra
ticketed service in times of peak demanc If there is to
be supplemental service rendered, it se@ rational that
supplemental carriers, devoted entirely toat task, should
be authorized to operate. We accept.e declarations
of the Board in these respects litereg and at full
face value. In agreeing with its positiowe do so upon
an acceptance of its concern for the cefcated carriers
and its purpose to protect them. We teve this is re-
quired by the general scheme of the stat},
—
12a
The real controversy, then, upon the present point is
not whether the Board may or may not unduly impinge upon
the certificated system by use of the exemption power but
whether it has in fact done so. Petitioners urge that ten
flights per month between any pair of points upon a
regularly scheduled basis are an obvious impingement
upon the certificated carrier serving those points. The
Board did three things in this respect. It found, upon
the basis of the evidence, that such impingement would
not be likely to occur. It next announced that it would
not permit combinations or collusions between the sup-
plemental carriers which might in total adversely affect
the certificated carriers. And, thirdly, as we have already
said, it announced that if the results proved different
from its anticipations it would revise the order to eliminate
the adverse effects.
We think we could not superimpose our judgment upon
that of the Board upon such an issue, even if we had a
judgment different from that of the Board. Experience
alone will demonstrate the true answer. The Board’s ex-
pert opinion is that the system it has devised, with its
terms and limitations, will not seriously conflict with the
interests of the certificated carriers. And it goes further
and says it will insure that such conflict does not ensue.
In sum it seems to us that the judgment of the Board,
that an air service supplemental to the certificated serv-
ices is in the public interest, is a rational judgment and
one which we must accept; that the finding of the Board
that its proposed supplemental service will not result in
adverse economic effects upon the certificated system is a
conclusion which the Board is entitled to draw if the ree-
ord supports it with evidence; and that the assurance of
the Board that it will not hereafter permit adverse eco-
nomic effects to jeopardize the certificated system or to
pose a substantial threat to it, should be accepted and
respected by this court. Having reached that point we
then conclude that if the Board makes the required find-
13a
ings as to undue burden, its present plan for a supple-
mental air carriage, affecting no excessive impact upon
the certificated system, would be within the statutory
exemption power (i.e., Section 416(b)).
The second main point urged by petitioners is that the
Board failed to make the findings required by the statute
to support the exemption under Section 416(b). That
section, as we have already noted, requires that the
Board find ‘‘that the enforcement of this title or such
provision, or such rule, regulation, term, condition, or
limitation is or would be an undue burden on such air
earrier or class of air carriers by reasons of the limited
extent of, or unusual circumstances affecting, the opera-
tions of such air carrier or class of air carriers and is
not in the public interest.’’
The exemption here involved is from the enforcement
of the provision of the statute requiring certification.
The question therefore is whether the requirement of
certification would be an undue burden on this class of
ait carriers by reason of either the limited extent of air
operations or unusual circumstances affecting their opera-
tions; and whether the requirement that this class of
carriers be certified is not in the public interest. We
find in the opinion of the Board a statement that “In
these circumstances, very little purpose would be served
by withholding the enlarged operating authority for what
may be a lengthy period, and to do so would constitute
an undue burden upon the applicants.’’ But that state-
ment does not support a conclusion that an exemption
rather than a certification should be granted. It supports
a conclusion only that some action should be taken
promptly. We also find in the order a conclusion stated
in the language of the statute, but the order contains no
findings to support that conclusion. We have examined
the opinion and the order with care, but we cannot ascer-
tain from them what the Board deems to be the limited
extent of the operations of the supplemental carriers
—
l4a
which would make a certification an undue burden on the
carriers, nor can we determine what unusual cireum-
stances affecting the operations of the supplemental ear.
riers would make certification an undue burden on these
carriers. Neither can we ascertain why the Board is of
opinion that the certification of these supplemental ear.
riers is not in the public interest.
We think the Board must make findings in the fore-
going respects in order that the court, in the exercise
of its review function, may determine whether the grant
of the exemption is within the statutory authority of
Section 416(b). It might be that the operating authority
granted these carriers should be exempted from the re-
quirement of Section 401(f) that the certificate specify
the terminal points between which the carrier is author-
ized to engage in air transportation, or from the required
specification of the service to be rendered. We do not
know whether that is what the Board had in mind. But
the question before us is not whether the supplemental
carriers should be exempted from one or more of the
subsidiary requirements of certification but whether they
should be exempted from certification altogether. We
repeat we cannot ascertain from the opinion or order
what undue burden the Board thinks certification would
be or why it thinks certification of this supplemental
service would not be in the public interest. We are of
opinion, therefore, that the case must be remanded in
order that the Board may make findings to support the
conclusions which the statute makes necessary to the ex-
ercise of the exemption power.
We are conscious of the fact that the operating au-
thority issued under the order before us is an interim
authority, to be effective only until the Board has con-
eluded its consideration of the qualifications of the vari-
ous applicants. If the Board had rested a finding of
undue burden upon the fact that the interim -for which
this operating authority is issued is short, whereas the
_—
lda
remainder of a certification proceeding would be long,
we would be close to the ruling of this court in the air
mail case. But we do not understand the Board to rest
upon the temporary feature of the order. The purport
of the discussion in the opinion of the Board is that the
exemption power may be exercised to accomplish the per-
manent ends it has in mind for these supplemental car-
riers and does not depend upon or revolve about the
temporary character of the exemption presently authorized.
The Board says no detailed findings are required, re-
ferring to the fact that this was a rule-making proceed-
ing and relying upon our opinion in Eastern Airlines v.
Civil Aeronautics Board.” But Section 416(b) itself re-
quires that the Board shall find these conditions to
exist, and it is clear that in order for the court to deter-
mine whether the Board acted within its statutory au-
thority it must know what the Board finds. The
Eastern Airlines case held only that Section 416(b)(1)
does not require notice and full hearing and that the
proceedings which occurred in that case were sufficient to
comply with the procedural requirements of the statute.
In its brief the Board points to various subsidiary
findings made by the examiners and adopted by the
Board which are factual in respect to the supplemental
carriers, such as comparisons between the new limitation
and the old limitations in the irregular air carrier regu-
lations, the overall financial resources and revenues of
these carriers, the history of thes. carriers, the steady
worsening iz: their position, and similar facts. But there
is nothing to indicate upon what facts or findings the
Board based its conclusion that a requirement of certi-
fication would be an undue burden upon these carriers.
® American Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Board, — U.S. App.
D.C, —, 231 F.2d 483 (D.C.Cir. 1956).
187 U.S. App. D.C. 331, 185 F.2d 426 (1950), vacated, 341 U.S.
901, 95 L.Ed. 1341, 71 8.Ct. 613 (1951).
16a
The opinion and the order leave us at a complete logs
upon that subject.
We fully realize that the irregular carriers have been
operating under exemption authority for many years, and
it seems possible, if indeed not probable, that the
Board has not heretofore stated its conclusions as to
undue burden and public interest in any more extensive
form that it does now. But until now these carriers have
not operated with any semblance of regularity. They
were truly irregular carriers, as they were called. Now
they are to become supplemental carriers and no longer
irregular. They are moved much closer to the certificated
services. The burden of certification is no longer cbvi-
ous. Moreover we are not referred to an adjudication of
a challenge to the presence of an undue burden upon the
irregular operation. There is now before us for adjudi-
eation a challenge to the burden asserted to exist upon
supplemental operation. We think that, if the Board ean
institute a regular supplemental air service without cer-
tification and merely by exercising the exemption power,
it may not do so without first clearly meeting the statu-
tory prerequisites to the exercise of that power.
The Board demonstrated, as we have indicated in the
first part of this opinion, that the supplemental carriers
have a place in the national transportation system and
that they should be authorized to operate. But the ques-
tion now under consideration is whether they should be
authorized by certificates, premised upon public conven-
ience and necessity and specifying in some fashion the
service which such carriers will be obligated to perform,
or whether their operation may be authorized by a simple
exemption from all the certification requirements of the
statute. To validate an order of exemption the Board
must comply with the statute; i.c., it must find what the
statute requires it to find, not in conclusory fashion in
the statutory language but in such fashion that a review-
ing court can test the validity of the finding.
—
17a
The petitioners’ third main point is that the order
finally issued was not within the scope of the proceeding
instituted by the Board’s initial orders. We agree with
the Board upon this point, basing that conclusion upon
the view of the order here under review which we have
heretofore described in this opinion.
The cases will be remanded for further proceedings.
APPENDIX B
The relevant provisions of the Civil Aeronautics Act of
1938 (52 Stat. 973), as amended (49 U.S.C. 401 et seq.), are:
* * aa * 7”
DecLARATION OF PoLicy
Src. 2. In the exercise and performance of its pow-
ers and duties under this Act, the Authority [Board]
shall consider the following, among other things, as
being in the public interest, and in accordance with the
public convenience and necessity—
(a) The encouragement and development of an air-
transportation system properly adapted to the present
and future needs of the foreign and domestic commerce
of the United States, of the Postal Service, and of the
national defense ;
(b) The regulation of air transportation in such
manner as to recognize and preserve the inherent ad-
vantages of, assure the highest degree of safety in, and
foster sound economic conditions in, such transporta-
tion, and to improve the reiations between, and co-
ordinate transportation by air carriers;
(c) The promotion of adequate, economical, and ef-
ficient service by air carriers at reasonable charges,
without unjust discriminations, undue preferences or
advantages, or unfair or destructive competitive prac
tices ;
18a
(d) Competition to the extent necessary to assure
the sound development of an air-transportation system
properly adapted to the needs of the foreign and do-
mestic commerce of the United States, of the Postal
Service, and of the national defense;
(e) The regulation of air commerce in such manner
as to best promote its development and safety; and
(f) The encouragement and development of civil
aeronautics.
* 7. * * *
Trrte [V—Air Carrier Economic Recuuation
CERTIFICATE OF PuBLIc CoNVENIENCE AND NECESSITY
Certificate Required
Sec. 401 (a) No air carrier shall engage in any air
transportation unless there is in foree a certificate is-
sued by the Authority [Board] authorizing such air
carrier to engage in such transportation: Provided,
That if an air carrier is engaged in such transporta-
tion on the date of the enactment of this Act, such air
carrier may continue so to engage between the same
terminal and intermediate points for one hundred and
twenty days after said date, and thereafter until such
time as the Authority [Board] shall pass upon an ap-
plication for a certificate for such transportation if
within said one hundred and twenty days such air ear-
rier files such application as provided herein.
* * . . *
Terms and Conditions of Certificate
(f) Each certificate issued under this section shall
specify the terminal points and intermediate points, if
any, between which the air carrier is authorized to en-
gage in air transportation and the service to be ren-
dered; and there shall be attached to the exercise of
the privileges granted by the cextificate, or amendment
—
19a
thereto, such reasonable terms, conditions, and limi-
tations as the public interest may require. A certifi-
cate issued under this section to engage in foreign air
transportation shall, insofar as the operation is to take
place without the United States, designated the termi-
nal and intermediate points only insofar as the Author-
ity [Board] shall deem practicable, and otherwise shall
designate only the general route or routes to be fol-
lowed. Any air carrier holding a certificate for foreign
air transportation shall be authorized to handle and
transport mail of countries other than the United
States. No term, condition, or limitation of a certifi-
cate shall restrict the right of an air carrier to add to
or change schedules, equipment, accomodations, and
facilities for performing the authorized transporta-
tion and service as the development of the business
and the demands of the public shall require. No air
carrier shall be deemed to have violated any term, con-
dition, or limitation of its certificate by landing or
taking off during an emergency at a point not named
in its certificate or by operating in an emergency under
regulations which may be prescribed by the Authority
[Board], between terminal and intermediate points
other than those specified in its certificate. Any air
carrier may make charter trips or perform any other
special service, without regard to the points named in
its certificate, under regulations prescribed by the
Authority [Board].
CLASSIFICATION AND EXEMPTION OF CARRIERS
Classification
Sec. 416 (a) The authority {Board] may from time
to time establish such just arid reasonable classifica-
tions of groups of air carriers for the purposes of this
title as the nature of the services performed by such
air carriers shall require ; and such just and reasonable
20a
rules, and regulations, pursuant to and consistent with
the provisions of this title, to be observed by each such
class or group, as the Authority [Board] finds neces.
sary in the public interest.
Exemptions
(b) (1) The Authority [Board], from time to time
and to the extent neeessary, may (except as provided
in paragraph (2) of this subsection) exempt from tie
requirements of this title or any provision thereof, or
any rule, regulation, term, condition, or limitation pre-
scribed thereunder, any air carrier or class of air car-
riers, if it finds that the enforcement of this title or
such provision, or such rule, regulation, term, condi-
tion, or limitation is or would be an undue burden on
such air carrier or class of air carriers by reason of
the limited extent of, or unusual cireumstances af.-
fecting, the operations of such air carrier or class of
air carriers and is not in the public interest.
(2) The Authority [Board] shall not exempt any air
earrier from any provision of subsection (1) of section
401 of this title, except that (A) any air carrier not en-
gaged in scheduled air transportation, and (B), to the
extent that the operations of such air carrier are con-
ducted during daylight hours, any air carrier engaged
in scheduled air transportation, may be exempted from
the provisions of paragraphs (1) and (2) of such sub-
section if the Authority [Board] finds, after notice end
hearing, that, by reason of the limited extent of, or
unusual circumstances affecting, the operation of any
such air carrier, the enforcement of such paragraphs is
or would be such an undue burden on such air earrier
as to obstruct its development and prevent it from be-
ginning or continuing operations, and that the exemp-
tion of such air carrier from such paragraphs would
not adversely affect the public interest: Provided, That
nothing in this subsection shall be deemed to authorize
—
2la
the Authority [Board] to exempt any air carrier from
any requirement of this title, or any provision thereof,
or any rule, regulation, term, condition, or limitation
prescribed thereunder which provides for maximum
flying hours for pilots or co-pilots.
Jupician Review or Avutsority’s [Boarp’s] Orpers
Orders of Authority [Board] Subject to Review
Sec. 1006 (a) Any order, affirmative or negative, is-
sued by the Authority [Board] under this Act, except
any order in respect of any foreign air carrier subject
to the approval of the President as provided in section
801 of this Act, shall be subject tc review by the courts
of appeals of the United States or the United States
Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upon
petition, filed within sixty days after the entry of such
order, by any person disclosing a substantial interest
in such order. After the expiration of said sixty days
a petition may be filed only by leave of court upon a
showing of reasonable grounds for failure to file the
petition theretofore.
Findings of Fact by Authority [Board] Conclusive
(e) The findings of facts by the Authority [Board],
is supported by substantial evidence, shall be conclu-
sive. No objection to an order of the Authority
[Board] shall be considered by the court unless such
objection shall have been urged before the Authority
[Board] or, if it was not so urged, unless there were
reasonable grounds for failure to do so.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.