Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — Brill v. Cohen & Miller Advertising, Inc.

Supreme Court brief1955

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

LE ¢ 4 way Se veury “ey

’ = fe 2 Lda 2

MAY 20 1955

HAROLD B. WILLEY, Cieri

In THE

Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1954

Isapore Briut, Trustee in Bankruptcy of

Phillip’s, Ine., ete. Petitioner

V.

Conen & Minter Apvertisine, Ixc., er au Respondents.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR

THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

ie M. SHINBERG

Washington Building

Washington, D. C.

Attorney for Petitioner

4

WILSON - EPES PRINTING Co. - RE 7-6002 - WASHINGTON 1. D. C.

CONTENTS

PAGE

Opinion Below — ... ii usar dkibaaliatinsisncteneacsees ‘sues 1

0 EE SRA ac Re Ripe eee Clean oO PER eae 2

ROTI OUT once ccisnicccnninrsscnsnconnesices are 2

Statute Involved .....................-..- dicdne tcne eota teed adnanegs 2

iss eacew nents te VS ASE 2

Reasons for Granting the Writ.......0.0...00..000........

Conclusion ...... SP RAN oe RFRA Re Rel IO OD

Appendix A (Opinion of U.S. Court of Appeals) HM)

I Tr I airs ecssierricsionsonicdicittinvinsennansiesnoctuns 1]

Appendix C (Judgment of U.S, Court of Appeals) 12

Citations

Grant v. First National Bank, 97 U.S. SO, 24 L.Ed.

REE ESRC reir Rg FO 5, 6,8

Inre M& M Manufacturing Co., 71 Fed. (2d) 140 6

Barbour v. Priest, 105 U.S. 298, 26 Liked, 478.0000... 6

Stucky v. Masonic Savings Bank, LOS U.S. 74, 27 L.

TN eet OE A ARR RI Re eae at Ree Redness |. ae

Cunningham v. Brown, 265 U.S. 1......................-02..-..-..-. 6,7

Statutes

Bankruptey Act of 1958, as amended, Sections 60 (a)

and (b) (United States Code, Tithe 11, Chapter 6,

RE BN oceicaddackrnaeseass atelagh hia SR REE TS Sits A de aah aa 4

In THE

Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1954

Isapore Batt, Trustee in Bankruptcy of

Phillip’s, Inc., ete. Petitioner

Vv.

Conen & Mitver Apvertisine, Ixc., ev au Respondents,

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR

THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

To The Honorable Chief Justice and the Associate Jus-

tices of the Supreme Court of the United States:

Isadore Brill, Trustee in Bankruptey of Phillip’s, Ine.,

ete, petitioner herein, respectfully prays that a Writ of

Certiorari issue to review the judgment of the United

States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia

Cirenit, entered in the above cause on February 24, 1955

OPINION BELOW

The opinion of the Court of Appeals (Appendix A,

infra, p. 9) is not vet reported.

— |

)

-

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the Court of Appeals was entered on

February 24, 1955. The jurisdiction of this Court is in-

voked under See. 24 of the Bankruptey Act, 1938 as

amended (United States Code, Title 11, Chapter 4, See.

47 «.)

QUESTION PRESENTED

The question presented is whether the evidence is suf-

ficient to support the findings of fact upon which the trial

court found that the payment to Cohen & Miller Adver-

tising, Inc. did not constitute a voidable preference under

Sees. 60(a) and 60(b) of the Bankruptcy Act.

STATUTES INVOLVED

The pertinent provisions of the Bankruptcy Act of

1938, as amended, Sections 60 (a) and (b), (United States

Code, Title 11, Chapter 6, Sec, 96) are set forth in Ap-

pendix B, infra p. 11.

STATEMENT

Prior to May 4, 1953, Phillip’s Television and Appli-

ances, Inc., was engaged in the business of selling tele-

vision and electrical appliances in the Washington area

through the medium of a chain of retail stores.

In the conduct of its business, Phillip’s Television and

Appliances, Ine. maintained a system of advertising which

included the Washington Times-Herald Newspaper. In

its arrangement with the Times-Herald it received perio-

dic rebates representing allowances made to it because of

a reduction in rate based upon volume.

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

3

Phillip’s Television and Appliances, Ine. employed

Cohen & Miller Advertising, Inc., respondent herein, as

its advertising agent in connection with its advertising

program,

On May 4, 1953, the Washington Times-Herald issued

its check for $5,830.16 made payable to Phillip’s Televis-

ion & Appliances, Inc., as a rebate.

On May 8, 1953, Phillip’s Television and Appliances,

Ine. endorsed the aforesaid check which it had received

from the Washington Times-Herald as a rebate and de-

livered the same to the Cohen & Miller Advertising, Ine.

as a payment on account of a past due indebtedness.

On May 8, 1953, the same day on which Cohen & Miller

Advertising, Inc., received the aforementioned Times-Her-

ald check from Phillip’s Television & Appliances, Inc., it

deposited the said check to its account at the Lincoln

National Bank.

On May 9, 1953, at 9:30 A.M. o'clock, Phillip’s Tele-

vision & Appliances, Inc. filed in the United States Dis-

triet Court for the District of Columbia its petition under

Chapter XI of the Bankruptey Act seeking an arrange-

ment with its ereditors.

On May 11, 1953, the Washington Times-Herald_ in-

structed its bank to stop payment on the aforementioned

check to Phillip’s Television and Appliances, Ine. drawn

May 4, 1953.

On June 30, 1953, Phillip’s Television & Appliances, Ine.

was adjudicated a bankrupt.

Thereafter, Cohen & Miller Advertising, Inc. brought

an action in the United States District Court for the

District of Columbia against the Washington Times-Her-

ald seeking to recover on the aforesaid check.

4

On July 31, 1953, the United States District Court for

the District of Columbia granted leave to Isadore Brill,

Trustee in Bankruptey of Phillip’s Television and Ap

pliances, Inc. to intervene in the action brought by Cohen

& Miller Advertising, Ine., against the Washington Times

Herald aforesaid.

On May 5, 1954, the aforesaid acticu was tried in the

United States District Court for the District of Columbia

before the Court without a jury. The Court found in

favor of Cohen & Miller Advertising, Ine. for the full

amount of $5,830.16 as claimed.

On February 24, 1955, the United States Court of Ap-

peals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed the

judgment of the trial court.

Intervention by the Trustee in Bankruptcy was granted

by the United States District Court for the District of

Columbia by virtue of See. 28 of the Bankruptey Act, 1938

as amended (United States Code, Title 11, Chapter 4,

Sec. 46).

REASON FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

The sole issue in this case is whether the evidence is

sufficient to support the findings of fact upon which the

trial court concluded that the payment to Cohen & Miller

Advertising, Inc., the appellee below, and the plaintiff in

the trial court, did not constitute a voidable preference

under See. 60 (a) and 60 (b) of the Bankruptey Act. The

United States Court of Appeals for the District of Colum-

bia held that the evidence was sufficient and affirmed the

judgment of the trial court.

The law applicable to this issue is clear. A reading of

the Act will quickly display that actual knowledge of in-

solvency hy the creditor is not essential. The creditor

comes within the inhibitions where the substantial facts

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

5

are of such significance as fairly to warrant the inference

that he knew or ought to have known of the bankrupt’s

financial condition. The nature of reasonable cause to

believe a debtor insolvent was defined by this Court in

Grant v. First National Bank, 97 U.S. 80, 24 L.Ed. 971.

At the outset it should be made clear that the peti-

tioner does not attack the veracity or credibility of any

of the testimony adduced in the trial court nor does it

attempt to contradict any of the evidence. All of the tes-

timony, as adduced, is admitted. It is the petitioner’s

contention that the trial court should be reversed in that

the uncontradicted evidence clearly shows that the re-

spondent had reasonable cause to believe the debtor to be

insolvent. No conflicts in evidence are requested to be

resolved. The question is merely as to the proper deduc-

tions or inferences to be made from undisputed facts.

If a review of this case is permitted by this Court, your

petitioner will show a close, cordial and personal relation-

ship between the principals of the respondent and the

principals of the bankrupt; the admitted desire of the

bankrupt to assist the respondent; the fact that the prin-

cipals of the respondent knew as much concerning the

financial condition of the bankrupt as did the bankrupt;

the attendance by the respondent at two creditor’s meet-

ings: the statement by the respondent that it had known

for more than 6 months of the financial condition of the

hankrupt: the time, mode and circumstances surrounding

the transfer of a third party’s check: the absence of pay-

ment to other creditors during the period; the filing of a

Chapter XT petition on the day immediately following the

subject transfer, and the fact that at the very moment

when all of the principals of both the respondent and the

bankrupt were present to effect the transfer, the necessary

documents were heing prepared for filing the petition.

Your petitioner contends that these facts clearly disclose

a situation in which the respondent was placed upon notice

6

of the debtor’s insolvency, or at the very least, would

have put the respondent to inquiry, which would have

disclosed insolvency.

It is true that when the trier of facts makes a decision

upon conflicting testimony involving the credibility of wit-

nesses, his findings should be upset only in exceptional

circumstances. But where his ultimate findings are based

upon inferences drawn from substantially undisputed

facts, they need not be accorded so conclusive an effect

by the reviewing tribunal. Jn re M & M Manufacturing

Co, 71 Fed. (2d) 140.

Since the decision of Grant v. First National Bank,

supra, in the October, 1877 term of this Court, your peti-

tioner has been only able to find the following decisions

in which this Court has passed upon the point. Barbour

v. Priest, 103 U.S. 293, 26 L.Ed. 478, decided in October,

1880 and Stucky v. Masonic Savings Bank, 108 U.S. 74,

27 L.Ed. 640, decided in 1883. The issue was _ briefly

touched upon in Cunningham v. Brown, 265 U.S. 1, de-

cided in 1924. Numerous decisions through the Circuit

Courts of Appeals are available, each of course, dealing

with various factual situations, some in which preferences

were held voidable, others not voidable. While your peti-

tioner does not argue with nor question the reasoning or

merit of the decision of Grant v. First National Bank,

supra, it is believed that both the trial court and the

Court of Appeals have read more into this opinion than

was intended. In the past 50 vears there have been many

changes in commercial business practices, information is

more readily obtainable, the naive business man is a char-

acter of the past. A more enlightened and realistie ap-

proach and application of modern modes of conduct must

be applied to a situation of this nature,

To permit a holding in this ease to the effect that the

respondent did not come within the inhibitions of the Act;

7

that the facts as adduced are of not such significance as

to fairly warrant the inference that the respondent knew,

or ought to have known, of the bankrupt’s financial condi-

tion; or to deny that the facts raised more than suspicion

of danger to put the creditor upon inquiry touching the

debtor’s insolvency, would render Secs. 60 (a) and 60 (b)

of the Bankruptey Act completely nugatory. It is re-

spectfully submitted that if this decision is permitted to

stand, without a review by this Court, for all intents and

purposes a trustee in bankruptcy would be compelled to

prove actual knowledge before he could prevail in an ef-

fort to recover a voidable preference. With complete

candor, your petitioner can not visualize of a factual sit-

uation, short of actual knowledge of insolvency, which

would compel a finding that a voidable transfer was

effected, stronger than the facts presented in this case.

As was stated by this Court in Cunningham v. Brown,

supra, at page 13 of the U.S. Reports, “It is a case the

circumstances of which call strongly for the principal that

equality is equity, and this is the spirit of the bankrupt

law. Those who were successful in the race of diligence

violated not only its spirit but its letter and secured an

unlawful preference.” (emphasis added) To permit the

respondent to prevail in this case, is to permit this eredi-

tor by virtue of its conduct to prevail over numerous

other creditors in the same position.

Admittedly the question of reasonable cause to believe

a debtor insolvent is as nebulous a theory as the question

of reasonable conduct in the determination of a personal

injury or negligence claim. Problems of reasonable con-

duct arise in many fields of the law. In such cases the

questions to he determined are generally treated as ques-

tions of fact. However to deny a review of this ease and

to foreclose the petitioner an opportunity to present facts,

so compelling, a it believes to warrant a reversal, would

wb.

a

Bt Ea Dah Bitte ob Gi is able:

8

result, in so far as at least the District of Columbia is

concerned, in an interpretation of Grant v. First National

Bank, far more stringent than the writer of that opinion

could have possibly anticipated and leave the trustee in

future cases absolutely without remedy lest he prove ac-

tual knowledge.

CONCLUSION

It is submitted that the serious question of law involved

in this application is of sufficient importance to require

the exercise of this Court’s supervisory jurisdiction by a

Writ of Certiorari.

Respectfully submitted,

Leon M. SHINBERG,

Attorney for Isadore Brill,

Trustee in Bankruptcy of

Phillips, Ine., ete.

Petitioner

9

APPENDIX A

Opinion of the United States Couart of Appeals

for the District of Columbiaa Circuit

United States Court off Appeals

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBI/A CIRCUIT

No. 12385

IsaporE Britt, Trustee in Bankruptccy for Phillip’s

Television and Appliances, Inc.,, APPELLANT

Vv.

Conen & Miniter Apvertisine, Inc:., WasHINGTON

Times-Herabp, Inc., APPEILLEES

Appeal from the United States D)istrict Court

for the District of Colurmbia

Decided February 24, 11955

Mr. Leon M. Shinberg for appellant.

Mr. Mare A, White, with whom Mir. James R. Sharp

was on the brief, for appellee Cohen & Miller Advertis-

ing, Ine.

No appearance for appellee Washington Times-Herald,

Ine.

Sr eet. |

10

Before Evcerton, Pretryman, and Baze.on, Circuit

Judges.

Per Curiam: The sole issue is whether the evidence is

sufficient to support the findings of fact upon which the

trial court concluded that the payment to appellee Cohen

& Miller Advertising, Ine. “constituted a preference but

not a voidable preference under the Bankruptcy Act.”

Since we think the evidence is sufficient, the judgment

below is

Affirmed.

a

11

APPENDIX B

Bankruptcy Act of 1938, as amended, Sec. 60 (United

States Code, Title 11, Chapter 6, Sec. 96)

“a, (1) A preference is a transfer, as defined in this

Act, of any of the property of a debtor to or

for the benefit of a creditor for or on account

of an antecedent debt, made or suffered by such

debtor while insolvent and within four months

before the filing by or against him of the peti-

tion initiating a proceeding under this Act, the

effect of which transfer will be to enable such

creditor to obtain a greater percentage of his

debt than some other creditor of the same class.

b. Any such preference may be avoided by the

trustee if the creditor receiving it or to be ben-

efited thereby or his agent acting with refer-

ence thereto has, at the time when the transfer

is made, reasonable cause to believe that the

debtor is insolvent. Where the preference is

voidable, the trustee may recover the property

or, if it has been converted, its value from any

person who has received or converted such prop-

erty, except a bonafide purchaser from or lienor

of the debtor’s transferee for a present fair

equivalent value: Provided, however, That

where such purchaser or lienor has given less

than such value, he shall nevertheless have a

lien upon such property, but only to the extent

of the consideration actually given by him.

Where a preference by way of lien or security

title is voidable, the court may on due notice

order such lien or title to be preserved for the

benefit of the estate, in which event such lien or

title shall pass to the trustee. For the purpose

of any recovery or avoidance under this sec-

tion, where plenary proceedings are necessary,

any State court which would have had jurisdic-

tion if bankruptey had not intervened and any

court of bankruptey shall have concurrent juris-

diction.”

ee SMEARS oar

12

APPENDIX C

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE DISTRICT OF CoL’/mBIA crrct!T

No. 12,385 January Term, 1955

Isapore Brrtt, Trustee in Bankrupt®Y

for Phillip’s Television and Appliances; Inc.,

APPELLANT,

v.

Conen & Miter Apvertisine, Inc»

WasHincton Times-Heravp, INc.,

APPELLEES.

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the District of Columbia

Before: Epcerton, Pretryman, and BazeLoN, Circuit

Judges.

JUDGMENT

This cause came on to be heard on the record from the

United States District Court for the District of Columbia,

and was argued by counsel.

On consideration whereof, It is ordered and adjudged

by this Court that the judgment of the said District Court

appealed from in this cause be, and the same is hereby,

affirmed with costs.

Dated: February 24, 1955.

Per Curiam

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.