Appendix — United States v. Williams
Supreme Court brief1955
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Gu the Gnited States Court of Claims
No. 50403
(Decided January 11, 1955)
RUSSELL H. WILLIAMS, d/b/a WILLIAMS EQUIP-
MENT CO., AND REED & MARTIN, INC., A COR-
PORATION v. THE UNITED STATES
Mr. William H. Ferguson for the plaintiffs. Mr. Donald
McL. Davidson was on the briefs.
Mr. Kendall M. Barnes, with whom was Mr. Assistant
Attorney General Warren E. Burger, for the defendant.
OPINION
Jones, Chief Judge, delivered the opinion of the court:
This case involves a contract between the plaintiffs and
the defendant for the construction of a paved road at Fair-
banks, Alaska. The facts have been set out in detail in our
findings and will be referred to only to the extent necessary
for an understanding of the issues which gave rise to the suit.
The principal issue has to do with the amount of borrow
material which was excavated by the plaintiffs and put in
place on the road. The contract provided for payment for
the borrow material at $1.29 per cubic yard and the payment
for hauling the material beyond a certain distance at a unit
price of 32 cents per cubic-yard mile. The borrow material
yardage to be paid for was to be measured in its original
position in the borrow pit, which yardage was to be computed
by the average end area method, and the overhaul item was
to be paid upon the measurement of material in its original
position times the overhaul distance in miles and fractions
thereof. In other words, an important consideration in de-
termining the amount due the plaintiffs was a determination
of the amount of borrow material in its original position.
(1A)
NR ADHERE AP ARO EH ORY sl BE ATI TAD EE BY aces ARG MOTT BE eR IE Cy Pm of ate " AL Roeser aii
2A
The face of the quarry rose from a flat surface at a steep,
though not vertical, angle. The average end area method
contemplated that surveys be made of the vertical profile of
the quarry at frequent intervals along its face, both at the
beginning and at the end of the quarrying operations. The }
extent to which the profile upon final survey had receded
from its original position would then be the basis for meas-
uring the amount of material that had been removed from
the quarry. At or about the time the plaintiffs began work a t
survey was made of the quarry. After some 30 or 40 percent
of the excavation work had been completed, a slide occurred
at the quarry in which a large amount of material moved
downward and outward toward the base line where the plain-
tiffs were operating. The amount of material moved was esti-
mated by a witness for the defendant as from 30,000 to 50,000
cubic yards, and by witnesses for the plaintiffs as from 200,000
to 400,000 cubic yards. <A fair statement from the evidence
would be that defendant’s witness was too conservative and
the estimates of plaintiffs’ witnesses excessive. Whatever
may be the correct amount, when we consider that the total
amount of material moved, as computed by plaintiffs, was
99,592 cubic yards and that 34,596 had been removed at the
time of the slide, the possible effect of such a slide on the com-
putation of material in place by the average end area method
can be seen.’ Not only did material come into the area from
FI RT ROE B 8
Fy
[ ,
“ae.
2The slide created several difficulties in applying this method of measure- 5
ment. A considerable part of the material which had broken loose as a result 2
of the slide was still on the face of the quarry at the time of the final survey. i
In fact, in certain parts of the quarry the final survey profiles indicated that |
the face of the cliff had expanded over the original profile lines. The slide
material, as a result of having been dislodged from its original position, had
expanded considerably beyond the volume it occupied in the original position.
This expansion tended to make the profile lines of the final survey appear to
have receded less than they would otherwise have done. To the extent, there-
fore, that such slide material was still on the face of the quarry the end area
method tended to understate the net volume of material in place actually
removed from the face of the quarry by the plaintiffs. The slide also created |
fissures, some of which had the effect of moving the face of the quarry forward v
beyond the point where it would otherwise have been. This again tended to
understate the amount of material removed by plaintiffs when using the end
area method. The defendant made no corrections for these factors in its
computations.
Furthermore, the slide carried substantial amounts of material from parts
of the quarry that had not originally been surveyed into parts where the
plaintiffs’ quarrying operations were going forward. It became necessary,
therefore, to find out the original profile of the unsurveyed parts of the quarry.
This could be done only by use of interpolations from those parts of the quarry F
3A
outside for which no cross section had been prepared, but also
certain points on the original survey were wiped out.
After the contract was completed the contracting officer
caused a final survey to be made and on a comparison of that
survey with the original survey computed the borrow ma-
terial excavated as 69,349.7 cubic yards. During the course
of the contract plaintiffs had been paid for this item on a
truck-measurement basis, on which basis the borrow material
removed had been computed at 99,592 cubic yards, that is,
some 30,000 more than the contracting officer computed on
the average end area method. The plaintiffs took an appeal
from that decision of the contracting officer to the Commis-
sioner of Roads for Alaska, the designated representative
of the head of the department, who affirmed the decision of
the contracting officer. This suit followed.
When this case was tried and when a report thereon was
filed by the commissioner, the last word on the question of
the finality of the decision of the head of the department had
been stated by the Supreme Court in United States v. Wun-
derlich, 342 U.S. 98, in which the Court said that a decision
made by the head of the department under the “Disputes”
clause of a government contract was final and conclusive un-
less fraud on his part was alleged and proved. The com-
missioner found that fraud, as measured by the formula set
out by the Supreme Court in that decision, had not been
established by the plaintiffs. However, after the report
had been filed, the Congress passed and the President signed
Public Law 356, 83d Congress, 2d Session, which provided
that the decision of the head of any department or agency
in any contractual dispute shall not be final and conclusive
where “the same is fraudulent or capricious or arbitrary or
so grossly erroneous as necessarily to imply bad faith, or is
not supported by substantial evidence.”
We are satisfied from the evidence and have found as a
fact that the decision of the head of the department was not
supported by substantial evidence. In reaching this con-
clusion we have considered the evidence on both sides in
order to determine whether it appears that the evidence in
support of the administrative decision can fairly be said to
which had been surveyed at the beginning, a process which tended to create
some inaccuracies.
4A
be substantial in the face of opposing evidence. See Willa-
point Oysters v. Ewing, 174 F. 2d 676, certiorari denied 338
U. S. 860. In a recent decision by the Supreme Court,
Universal Camera Corp v. National Labor Relations Board,
840 U. S. 474, 487, the Court made the following statement
with respect to the rule relating to substantiality of evidence
to support an administrative decision:
Whether or not it was ever permissible for courts to
determine the substantiality of evidence supporting a
Labor Board decision merely on the basis of evidence
which in and of itself justified it, without taking into
account contradictory evidence or evidence from which
conflicting inferences could be drawn, the new legisla-
tion [Administrative Procedures Act and Taft-Hart-
ley Act] definitively precludes such a theory of review
and bars its practice. The substantiality of evidence
must take into account whatever in the record fairly de-
tracts from its weight. This is clearly the significance
of the requirement in both statutes that courts consider
the whole record.
The fact that there is evidence, considered of and by itself,
to support the administrative decision is not sufficient where
there is opposing evidence so substantial in character as to
detract from its weight and render it less than substantial on
the record as a whole.
As we view the evidence, it is difficult to see how it could be
said that there was substantial evidence to support the de-
cision made by the contracting officer and the head of the
department in the face of the opposing evidence. What
these administrative officials tried to do was to compute the
amount of borrow material removed by the use of a method
which had been made impossible of accurate application
because of the slide which had occurred. It is true that the
contract provided for the use of this method but only as a
means of determining the amount of material removed for
which the plaintiffs were to be paid. The real question was
how much material had been removed. Not only were some
of the original survey elevations wiped out but also substan-
tial amounts of material came from outside into the area
where the plaintiffs were working and from which material
had been removed. These factors contributed to errors in
comparing the original survey with the final survey for the
oA
purpose of a comparison of the material removed. Defendant
recognized some of these difficulties and undertook through
interpolations or estimates to supply the original survey
elevations which were wiped out, and otherwise compensate
for the changed conditions. That it did not do so in a satis-
factory manner is plainly evident from the opposing evidence
which was before the administrative officials when the final
decision was made and which they contend confirmed the
original dec.sion.
In the first place, when the plaintiffs complained of the
decision of the contracting officer, the possibility of error was
recognized and an effort made to check that computation.
The first method used was to have a mass diagram prepared
of material in place on the road.?,- Then a computation was
prepared which would show the amount of borrow material
in place in its original position in the quarry which would
be required to produce the material in place on the road as
shown by the mass diagram. This computation resulted in
a determination of 66,566.5 cubic yards of borrow material
as compared with 64,735.9 cubic yards used in the contracting
officer’s determination for roadway embankment (69,349.7
less 4,613.8, which represented material rejected in spoils pile
at the quarry and overburden). While the amount so com-
puted was not substantially greater than the amount com-
puted by the contracting officer, it failed to take into account,
as shown by finding 25, substantial amounts of material
which were used and for which the plaintiffs were entitled to
be paid. With these omitted amounts added to the 66,566.5
cubic yards which were computed, the amount becomes sub-
stantially greater than that allowed in the final determina-
tion.
A second check on the accuracy of the average end area
method was made while the appeal was pending through
what is known as a specific gravity test. By such a test it
was expected that a determination could be made of a change
2This diagram was evidently made by comparing the plans of the vertical
cross sections before and after the road was built. The road as finished
deviated in certain respects from the plans with the result that additional
borrow was required over that contemplated on the plans. Furthermore, the
new road was built on top of an old road which sank in some places during
the construction and thus required additional fill. Neither of these factors
was accounted for in the mass diagram.
6A
in volume from a solid rock condition of the material in the
quarry to a disturbed condition of the same material in a
truck, that is, a determination of the percentage of swells or
voids in the material loaded in a truck as compared with the
material in a solid condition in the quarry.’ In spite of the
fact that in making the test a 3-ton truck was used instead
of a 6-ton or larger truck of the type in use by the plantiffs
during their operations, and that the allowance for the swell
factor was unfavorable to the plaintiffs, a yardage was com-
puted of 76,000 cubic yards instead of 69,349.7 determined
by the contracting officer. We are convinced that with the
use of a truck of the proper size and with the swell factor
appropriately resolved an even greater disparity would have
been shown.
3 The specific gravity method used by the defendant consisted of two parts.
The first part determined that a 3-ton truck loaded level to the bed of the
truck contained 33 percent voids and 67 percent solid rock by volume. The
33 percent figure was arrived at by taking the specific gravity of representative
samples of rock and applying this specific gravity to the weight and volume
of the load of a 3-ton truck loaded level to the top of its bed. It does not
appear, however, that this 33 percent figure was intended to represent the
exact increase in the volume of material from its virgin state to its volume
loaded on the truck since no account was taken of voids that might occur in
the material in the virgin state. Furthermore, the amount of voids in a small
3-ton truck might well be considerably less than the voids in 6-, 7-, or 8-ton
trucks which were the types of sizes actually used. The following computa-
tion, though not made by defendant’s engineers, is significant. Assuming that
the total cubic yards of plaintiffs’ truck-count figures took into account a
uniform swell factor of 25 percent, then the uncorrected volume of material
removed amounts to 132,789 cubie yards; if the plaintiffs’ truck-count figure
used a swell factor of 20 percent, then the uncorrected volume amounts to
124,490 cubic yards. Applying the 33 percent swell factor of the specific
gravity test to those figures yields 88,946 and 83,408 cubic yards, respectively.
The other part of the specific gravity method determined the percentage
of voids in the heaped load on a truck having a sideboard level capacity
of 6.35 cubic yards. The bed of this truck had inside dimensions of 6.6’ x
10.0’ x 2.6’ as compared to 6.5’ x 7.96’ x 1.56’ of the truck that was used in
the previous test. The volume of the heap on such a truck was estimated to
be ten-eighths of the volume of the heap on a test truck, or ten-eighths of
1.28 cubic yards which equals 1.60 cubic yards. The total load yardage for
such a truck in heaped condition was, therefore, 6.35 cubic yards plus 1.60
cubic yards, which equals 7.95 cubic yards. Applying the 33 percent figure
computed above, the engineers arrived at an actual volume of rock of 5.33
cubie yards. The defendant's engineers further assumed that such heaped
6.35 cubic yard trucks were credited with actually having hauled seven cubic
yards of material in the plaintiffs’ truck-count computation. The basis for
this assumption is not clear. Dividing 5.33 into 7, the defendant determined
that plaintiffs had only excavated 76 percent of the amount with which
they were credited under the truck-count method. This percentage was then
applied generally to the total cubic yardage which the truck-count method
had credited to the plaintiffs, that is, 76 percent of 99,592 cubic yards, which
is approximately 76,000 cubic yards.
LT eS Se te.
eet SR AME, GG SHORES. - ‘ A 6 ATE LL LD,
7A
The third type of evidence before the head of the depart-
ment when the final decision was made was the truck-meas-
urement basis contended for by the plaintiffs. Prior to the
commencement of the hauling operation, defendant’s resident
engineer and a representative of the plaintiffs measured each
of the trucks on the job and calculated the dimensions of their
gross load when heaped full. The volume of each truck as
measured was reduced by a swell factor to allow for voids in
the material in the trucks as compared with the material in
its undisturbed state in the quarry. Each load was checked
by inspectors of the defendant both upon departure from
the borrow pit and on delivery at the read. Monthly prog-
ress payments were made to the plaintiffs by the defendant on
the basis of these tabulations. The total yardage computed
by this method was 99,592 cubic yards. The major objection
raised by the defendant to the accuracy of such computation
was that sufficient allowance was not made for swells or voids
in the material. In our findings we have agreed that some
more allowance should be made for voids than was made in
that computation but we are satisfied from the evidence that
such allowance should be less than that contended for by
the defendant and therefore the amount computed on this
basis would likewise be substantially more than that allowed
by the head of the department.
What we have, therefore, is a situation wherein the head
of the department made a determination of an amount of
material removed which was substantially less than the
amount computed by any one of three other methods. When
we consider the inaccuracies which would certainly result
from an attempted use of the average end area method under
the changed conditions resulting from the slide, it is difficult
to see how three other computations, all of which resulted
in substantially greater amounts, could be said to give any-
thing approaching a confirmation of the amount determined
by the head of the department. The contradictory and con-
flicting evidence so detracts from the weight of the evidence
in support of the decision as to leave it without substantial
support. On the contrary we are convinced that the sub-
stantial weight of the evidence supports an amount in excess
of that allowed by the head of the department. In our find-
ee, ATRL gy LS TE
‘
.
e
:
: >
:
>
j
be
7
.
“1g
NRHA Tht
#Y NPD
ASST,
ELIOT RST
338960—55——_3
x
*
RY
ee
NYO PRS TAT TEL ALAR RENTS COG ET SNR =|
8A
ings we have found that 84,471 cubic yards of borrow ma-
terial were excavated which is 15,121.3 cubic yards more than
that allowed by the defendant. Since the contract price was
$1.29 per cubic yard for the excavation of this borrow mate-
rial, the plaintiffs are entitled to recover $19,506.48 on this
item.
Since the amount allowable for the overhaul item varies in
direct proportion to the volume of borrow material removed,
the cubic-yard miles allowable on this item is 267,727.8 in-
stead of 217,032.4, that is, 50,695.4 cubic-yard miles more
than allowed by the defendant. At the contract price of 82
cents per cubic-yard mile, this amounts to $16,222.53, which
the plaintiff's are entitled to recover on this item.
The other issue in the case involves questions of law and
arises out of an entirely different set of facts from those just
discussed. One of the items involved in the contract was the
paving of the road with asphalt. In order to do this work,
the plaintiffs had considered renting or buying an asphalt
plant in the State of Washington. The rental cost of such
a plant would have been approximately $10,700. After the
job got under way, the plaintiffs learned that there was a
plant located at Ladd Air Force Base which was under the
jurisdiction of one Major Russell who was responsible for
the maintenance of the roads at the Air Force Base. One of
the plaintiffs made inquiry of Major Russell as to whether
arrangements could be made for the plaintiffs to use the
plant. Major Russell suggested that certain roads on the
Base needed seal coating and if plaintiffs would do this work
they could use the plant on the road job. After certain
negotiations during which Major Russell represented that
he had been given authority to enter into the agreement, the
plaintiffs submitted a written proposal which was accepted by
Major Russell as Air Installation Officer, whereby the plain-
tiffs agreed to seal coat the main paved roads on the base in
return for the use of the asphalt plant to produce asphalt for
the road job.
Upon the approval of that agreement by Major Russell,
the plaintiffs proceeded to carry out their part of the agree-
ment which they did by seal coating some nine or ten miles of
roads in a manner satisfactory to the Air Force Base author-
ities. The value of such work was in excess of $10,000.
9A
In the meantime, Major Russell had forwarded to his
superior officer copies of the agreement which he had ap-
proved for seal coating of the roads in return for the use
of the asphalt plant by the plaintiffs. Shortly after the
seal-coating job had been completed but prior to the time
when the asphalt plant had been delivered to the plaintiffs,
Major Russell’s superior officer advised him that there was
no authority for such an agreement and that work there-
under should be stopped immediately. Major Russell re-
plied that the work had already been completed and urged
that since the plaintiffs had carried out their part of the
agreement and since the agreement was in the best interests
of the Government, the plaintiffs should be permitted to use
the asphalt plant. However, Major Russell’s superior of-
ficer refused to change his position. Major Russell advised
the plaintiffs of his inability to carry out the agreement but
suggested that arrangements be made to have the plant bor-
rowed by the Alaska Road Commission and then rented by
the Commission to the plaintiffs. Major Russell stated that
if this could be arranged he would arrange for payment for
the work which had already been done by the plaintiffs at
Ladd Field. As a result the asphalt plant was turned over
by Major Russell to the Alaska Road Commission which, in
turn, made it available to the plaintiffs at a rental figure of
$1.30 per ton. In agreeing orally to that rental figure, the
plaintiffs relied upon the assurance previously given by
Major Russell that they would be paid for the work which
they had already performed at Ladd Field.
The plaintiffs used the asphalt plant in paving the roads
under their contract. At or about the time the paving was
completed, Major Russell advised the paintiffs that payment
could not be made by the defendant for the seal-coating work
which had been performed by them at Ladd Field. There-
upon the plaintiffs refused to sign a change order prepared
by the Alaska Road Commission reducing the unit price of
asphalt by $1.30 per ton. However, the contracting officer, in
the final settlement under the plaintiffs’ contract, directed
that the change order be considered a written order changing
the specifications and that the rental stipulated therein be
deemed to be an equitable adjustment of the contract price.
ee — a
10A
Upon completion of the contract, it was determined that
7,820.3 tons of asphalt had been actually used and accordingly
$10,166.39 was deducted from payments to the plaintiffs,
On appeal to the head of the department, the decision of the
contracting officer was affirmed. No amount has been paid
to the plaintiffs on account of the work which they did at
Ladd Field.
What the plaintiffs are suing for is the amount just re-
ferred to which was deducted from amounts otherwise due
them under the contract involved in this proceeding. No
question is raised by the defendant as to the fact that the
plaintiffs performed the services or that the services were
worth at least the amount now sued for. The sole defense
of the defendant is that since Major Russell was not a con-
tracting officer with full authority to bind the Government
in the fullest contractual sense, the plaintiffs cannot recover
on this item. Surely, compelling reasons would be required
to have any court sanction any such inequitable result and
we do not think such reasons exist. Whatever might be said
with respect to the lack of authority on the part of Major.
Russell to enter into a binding contract, it is certainy true
that the plaintiffs proceeded in an entirely appropriate and
proper manner in entering into the agreement and did so
only after they were assured by Major Russell that he had
authority to do so. Likewise, Major Russell had also pro-
ceeded in good faith in the entire matter and had been assured
by Washington that such an arrangement would be satisfac-
tory. The roads that were seal coated were wholly within
the base where the contracting officer was located. It seems
incredible that he did not know all about the agreement and
by his inaction ratify it. Certainly he did not repudiate the
agreement, and he did not appear as a witness. The plaintiffs
carried out their part of the agreement for which the Gov-
ernment received the benefit. We feel that there then arose
an implied contract under which the defendant was obligated
to pay the value of the services rendered by the plaintiffs.
Recovery is accordingly allowable for this item in the amount
deducted under the contract, $10,166.39. Cf. W. H. Arm-
strong and Company v. United States, 98 C. Cls. 519, 529;
Lewis Joseph Stiers, et al. v. United States, 121 C. Cls. 157,
11A
172; and Pacific Maritime Association v. United States, 123
C. Cls. 667, 676.
Judgment will accordingly be entered for $19,506.48 for
the material item, $16,222.53 for the overhaul item, and
$10,166.39 for the asphalt plant item, making a total of
$45,895.40.
It is so ordered.
Laramore, Judge; Mavpen, Judge; Wurtaxer, Judge;
and LirrteTon, Judge, concur.
FINDINGS OF FACT
The court, having considered the evidence, the report of
Commissioner Richard H. Akers, and the briefs and argu-
ment of counsel, makes findings of fact as follows:
1, At all times material to this proceeding the plaintiff,
Russell H. Williams, was engaged in the contracting busi-
ness in Alaska as an individual under the name of Williams
Equipment Company with his principal place of business
in Fairbanks, Alaska. For convenience, that plaintiff will
sometimes hereinafter be referred to as “Williams.”
At all times material to this proceeding the plaintiff,
Reed & Martin, Inc., was an Alaska corporation with its prin-
cipal place of business in Fairbanks. It was engaged in the
contracting business, normally business construction.
2. During the early part of 1950, the plaintiffs entered into
a joint venture agreement for the purpose of submitting a
bid to the defendant, acting through the Department of the
Interior, Alaska Road Commission, for the construction of a
highway from Fairbanks to College and a portion of the
Steese Highway, a total distance of approximately 5.74
miles. Williams was the manager of the operation and the
other plaintiff did not actively participate therein except
in connection with the securing of an asphalt mixing plant
hereinafter referred to.
3. The plaintiffs were advised on March 16, 1950, by John
R. Noyes, Commissioner of Roads for Alaska, that their bid
in the total amount of $389,713.10 based upon the estimated
quantities set out in the invitation for bids and the unit prices
bid by them had been accepted, that the formal contract was
being prepared for their signatures, and that that letter would
BLS ILO OF SLL ETS
12A
constitute notice to proceed within 15 calendar days after
its receipt.
4. Under date of March 28, 1950, the formal contract cover-
ing the work was signed. That contract bore the number
1-arc—4263 and was signed on behalf of the defendant by A. F.
Ghiglione, Chief Engineer, Alaska Road Commission, as
contracting oflicer. It provided that the plaintiffs would
furnish the materials and perform the work for constructing
the highway from Fairbanks to College and a portion of the
Steese Highway in consideration of payment of the unit
prices set forth in the bid schedule in strict accordance with
the specifications, schedules, and drawings specifically desig-
nated in the contract. The contract further provided that
the work was to be commenced within 15 calendar days
after receipt by the contractor of notice to proceed and be
completed by October 15, 1950, subject to such extensions
as might be authorized under the contract. The work was
started at or about the time required, namely, about April 4,
1950, and, as will hereinafter appear, was completed
September 30, 1950, and accepted October 9, 1950.
5. The bid schedule, copy of which was annexed to and
made part of the contract, read in part as follows:
OAR Pay names, with unit bid price written in Unit
Item words (pay name defined on page shown | bid Amount
quantity in parentheses) | price bid
. . s e s
26 (1) 57,000 | Cu. Yds. Unclassified Excavation for Borrow,
Case 1, at One dollar and twenty-nine cents
Sr DE Fe Cay PE swank batd veseevemnwan $1. 29 $73, 530
.
28 (2) 187,000 | Cu. Yd. Mi. Special Overhaul of Borrow
(1,000’ freehaul), at Thirty-two cents per
FE Cia BP nce caw bans an secnenaanses .32 59, 840
. . . . .
140 (1) 8,000 | Tons (Class F Pavement, Type F-1) Plant
Mixture, Grading A-1, at Twelve dollars |
and no cents per ton (274).................. 12.00 96, 000
|
. . . . .
|
6. The contract contained, among other provisions, the
following:
Articie 4. Changed conditions.—Should the contrac-
tor encounter, or the Government discover, during the
progress of the work, subsurface and/or latent condi-
tions at the site materially differing from those shown
on the drawings or indicated in the specifications, or
Se i els Eee Se Nee Ne Se ee ee Oe ona oS ee ee ee Pn) Lh oon see) Oe oie heel ee. ee
«
f
|
'
if
;
t
13A
unknown conditions of an unusual nature differing ma-
terially from those ordinarily encountered and generally
recognized as inhering in work of the character provided
for in the plans and specifications, the attention of the
contracting oflicer shall be called immediately to such
conditions before they are disturbed. The contracting
oflicer shall thereupon promptly investigate the condi-
tions, and if he finds that they do so materially differ
the contract shall, with the written approval of the head
of the department or his duly authorized representative
be modified to provide for any increase or decrease o
cost and/or difference in time resulting from such
conditions.
Anricie 15, Disputes—Except as otherwise specifi-
cally provided in this contract, all disputes concerning
uestions of fact arising under this contract shall be
decided by the contracting officer subject to written
appeal by the contractor within 80 days to the head of
the department concerned or his duly authorized repre-
sentative, whose decision shall be final and conclusive
upon the parties thereto. In the meantime the con-
tractor shall diligently proceed with the work as directed.
Arricte 16. Payments to contractors.—(a) Unless
otherwise provided in the specifications, partial pay-
ments will be made as the work progresses at the end of
each calendar month, or as soon herentber as practicable,
on estimates made and approved by the contracting offi-
cer. In preparing estimates the material delivered on
the site and preparatory work done may be taken into
consideration.
* * * * *
7. Specifications FP-41 issued by the Federal Works
Agency, Public Roads Administration, and incorporated in
the contract by reference, provided in part as follows:
Irem 26.—Borrow
DeEscriIPpTION
26-1.1 This item shall consist of excavating approved
material from borrow pits, when sufficient quantities of
suitable material are not available from other excava-
tions, and the disposing of all excavated material, all in
accordance with these specifications and in conformity
with the lines, grades, and dimensions shown on the plans
or as directed by the engineer.
26-1.2 Material to be used as topping for embank-
ments, as a cushion for rock embankments, or for rein-
forcing unsatisfactory subgrade soil or for backfilling
FR AE MEIER LOT TE OR 7 OE A BEON,
14A
cuts, where excavation below de is authorized, shall
be obtained under this item when satisfactory material
for the special purpose is not obtainable from other
excavations.
26-1.3 Se.ecrion or Sources.—Material for this item
shall be obtained under the terms of case 1 and/or case 2
described below.
Case 1.—When case 1 is called for in the bid schedule,
the sources of borrow material shall be indicated on the
plans and/or designated by the engineer, and the con-
tractor shall be relieved of the responsivility of obtain-
ing the right to take the material from such sources.
s
e * r *
MATERIALS
26-2.1 Material for this item shall be material se-
lected by the engineer as —— ee for the
particular embankment or backfili for which the mate-
rial is intended. The material shall be obtained from
the approved borrow sources.
MernHop oF MEASUREMENT
264.1 The yardage to be paid for shall be the num-
ber of cubic yards of material (including the yardage
of overburden stripped from pits) measured in original
position and computed by average end area method, ex-
cavated and acceptably disposed of in embankment,
backfill, or as otherwise ordered, except that when case 2
is called for in the bid schedule, the yardage of over-
burden stripped from pits (unless used as borrow ma-
terial) shall not be included in the yardage to be paid
for. The measurement shall not fechas the yardage of
any excavation performed prior to the taking of eleva-
tions and measurements of the undisturbed ground.
Basis or PAYMENT
26-5.1 The yardage, measured as provided above,
shall be paid for at the contract unit price per cubic
yard for “Unclassified Excavation for Borrow, Case 1,”
or “Unclassified Excavation for Borrow, Case 2,” as the
case may be, * * *.
Irem 28.—SpectaL OvERHAUL or Borrow
(Cubic-yard-mile basis)
DESCRIPTION
28-1.1 This item shall consist of authorized haulin
in excess of the free haul distance of any material pai
PRGA #
= aad GRADY TREE TOAD OO IRL TERETE LES AE BASLE Cee Hea ek AE ECP DARE ASAE ARTE —7
15A
for under BORROW (case 1) and disposed of as re-
quired under the various items prescribed for the dis-
posal of such material.
The free haul distance shall be 500 feet or 1,000 feet,
whichever is called for in the bid schedule. Only one
free haul distance shall be provided in any one contract.
Meruop oF MEASUREMENT
98-4.1 The number of cubic-yard-miles of special
overhaul of borrow to be paid for shall be the product
of the volume of the pina oe material, measured in
its original position, in cubic yards, by the overhaul dis-
tance in miles and fractions thereof. The overhauled
material shall be the material comprehended within the
terms of 1.1 above and hauled as directed more than
the free haul distance (as designated in the bid sched-
ule). The overhaul distance shall be the distance be-
tween the centers of volume of the overhauled material
in its original position and after placing, less the free
haul distance (as designated in the bid schedule).
+ ’ * * *
Basis or PAYMENT:
28-5.1 The cubic-yard miles, determined as provided
above, shall be paid for at the contract unit price per
cubic-yard mile for “Special Overhaul of Borrow (500
feet free haul)” or “Special Overhaul of Borrow (1,000
feet free haul),” as the case may be, which price and
payment shall constitute full compensation for all labor,
—* tools, and incidentals necessary to complete
the item.
Under general requirements in the same specifications ap-
peared the following provisions:
Art. 7.14 No Warver or Lreat Ricurs.—The Gov-
ernment shall not be precluded or estopped by any meas-
urement, estimate, or certificate made either before or
after the completion and acceptance of the work and pay-
ment therefor from showing the true amount and char-
acter of the work performed and materials furnished by
the contractor, nor from showing that any such measure-
ment, estimate, or certificate is untrue or is incorrectly
made, nor that the work or materials do not in fact con-
form to the contract. The Government shall not be
precluded or estopped, notwithstanding any such meas-
urement, estimate, or certificate and payment in accord-
ance therewith from recovering from the contractor or
16A
his sureties, or both, such damages as it may sustain by
reason of his failure to comply with the terms of the
contract. Neither the acceptance by the engineer or by
his representatives, nor wd haga for or acceptance
of the whole or any part of the work, nor any extension
of time, nor any possession taken by the engineer shall
operate as a waiver of any portion of the contract or of
any power herein reserved, or of any right to damages.
A waiver of any breach of the contract shall not be held
to be a waiver of any other or subsequent breach.
;
k
8. Special provisions which were also made a part of the
contract read as follows:
Control of Material
*
* *
Materials suitable for Borrow, Item 26 (1) may be
obtained from the following source :
Deposit B-1
1.5 Mi. from Sta. 73+00+ Steese Highway, via Steese
signs and Lazelle Road.
eposit A-1 is an existing stockpile, therefore, no
clearing or stripping will be required.
Deposit B-1 is known locally as the Birch Hill Quarry.
The Contractor will be required to secure material from
a fresh face. The cost of cleaning an approach to the
face, and the cost of any necessary clearing and strip-
ping, shall be considered as included in the unit bid
price for Itean 26 (1), Unclassified for Borrow.
If it becomes necessary to obtain such material from
other sources, allowance will be made for actual net
increased haul and will be paid for at the unit price set
forth for Item 28 (2) Cu. Yd. Mi., Special Overhaul of
Borrow, provided that the quantity shall be determined
by truck measurement at point of delivery. The dis-
tance shall not be subject to freehaul, but shall be the
actual mileage of haul occasioned by the changed loca-
tion of the material sources as compared to the haul
which would have been necessary had all the material
been acquired at the designated point. No change in
the location of the source of the material shall be made
without approval in writing by the Engineer, provided
that no reduction in the contract unit price shall be
made if consideration of the entire contract undertaking
should result in a net decrease in haul.
* *
2 ERR: IGE Miah 35 LEP
So a
17A
9, The following “general notes” appeared upon sheet 2 of
the contract plans for the highway :
1. Alignment and grades are subject to adjustment.
2. Depths of surfacing, base course and borrow are com-
pacted thicknesses.
3. Curves shall be widened and super-elevated as staked
by the Engineer.
4, Approaches shall be constructed to all existing side
roads with a minimum width for driveways of 12’.
Approach fills shall be constructed with Borrow.
Surfacing shall consist of 6’’ of Crushed Gravel Base
Course. Pipes shall be installed according to the
Pipe List on sheet 3 of these Plans.
5. An extra allowance of 1820 cu. yd. of Excavation and
5500 cu. yd. of Borrow has been included in the Esti-
mate of Quantities to cover possible stripping and
backfilling of poor material encountered during con-
struction.
6. Deposits for Borrow, Base and Surfacing are shown
on sheet No. 1 and described in the Special Provisions.
On the cross-sections for the road an estimated quantity
of approximately 51,000 cubic yards of borrow material was
shown as required. To that was added the 5,500 cubic yards
of borrow set out in note 5 above, and the total amount so
arrived at was further increased by a small yardage to make
the even figure of 57,000 cubic yards which was shown in the
bid schedule as the estimated amount of borrow required for
the project. It was also considered that the borrow material
under compaction would yield approximately 62,700 cubic
yards of embankment. The cross-sections do not show any
separate amount computed as required for driveways and
intersections. The original survey was deficient in that
it had not taken full cognizance of these driveways and
intersections.
The pipe list which appeared on sheet 3 of the contract
drawings listed 87 different pipe locations, 70 of which re-
quired the installation of pipe for the first time, 8 of which
required the extension of existing pipe, and 9 of which
required the removal of an existing pipe and the placement
of a new one. It was estimated that 1,726 linear feet of
15-inch culvert pipe, 30 linear feet of 21-inch culvert pipe,
436 linear feet of 24-inch culvert pipe, and 146 linear feet of
:
TA cece |
18A
36-inch culvert pipe would be required, of which 30 feet of
21-inch pipe, 14 feet of 24-inch pipe, and 36 feet of 36-inch
pipe were for extensions to existing culverts. In carrying
out the work, the plaintiffs installed a total of only 69 more
linear feet of pipe than were called for on the above pipe list.
10. At the time the contract involved in this proceeding
was entered into and carried out, Col. John R. Noyes was
Commissioner of Roads for Alaska. Colonel Noyes was
graduated from West Point with a degree of Bachelor of
Science in 1923, and from Cornell University with a degree
of Civil Engineering in 1926. He has been on active duty in
the Army since his graduation from West Point and most of
his work has been of an engineering nature. During the
period 1926 to 1933, he was assigned as an assistant at the
Alaska Road Commission. In 1946 he was placed on an inter-
departmental committee dealing with Alaskan affairs which
later, in 1948, indirectly led to his appointment as Commis-
sioner of Roads for Alaska.
The contracting officer was Angelo F. Ghiglione. He
received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Wash-
ington, and a master’s degree from the Massachusetts Insti-
tute of Technology—both in civil engineering. Immediately
after his graduation he started working permanently for the
Alaska Road Commission in 1933 and, except for a period of
military service when he was in the Civil Engineering Corps
of the Navy from 1941 to 1944, he has been continuously
employed by the Alaska Road Commission. He held various
positions with the Alaska Road Commission prior to 1947, in
which year he was promoted to assistant chief engineer, and
in April 1949 to chief engineer. As chief engineer he became
the contracting officer on the contract involved in this pro-
ceeding. In 1951 he was made Commissioner of Roads for
Alaska.
11. In 1948, the road-building program in Alaska expanded
greatly. Prior to 1948 appropriations had not been more
than $5,000,000 a year. Commencing in 1948, they were
about $25,000,000 a year. This was brought about by the
adoption of a program for hard surfacing as well as by the
extension of the normal work for new construction and
maintenance. The Alaska Road Commission had to be ex-
SSS
OLEAN kein Rite
rR et
—_
19A
panded very greatly in order to take care of the work. It
utilized the services of the United States Bureau of Public
Roads very largely in initiating the program. The United
States Bureau of Public Roads prepared specifications and
supervised the work in a number of cases. The Alaska Road
Commission had been building roads in Alaska since 1905,
but not paved roads. Since this work had been carried out
by its own hired crews and not by contractors, the experience
of the Alaska Road Commission with road contracts of the
type involved in this proceeding was somewhat limited.
The contract involved in this proceeding was the first con-
tract entered into by the Alaska Road Commission for the
construction of a hard-surface road in the Fairbanks district
which was to be supervised by that Commission. It had
entered into two other contracts for hard-surface roads in
that area at or about that time but their supervision was by
the Bureau of Public Roads. On June 1, 1949, the Alaska
Road Commission had executed a contract for the construc-
tion of Haynes Highway, a distance of forty miles, and on
March 15, 1950, had executed a contract for the construction
of a road three and one-half miles long at or near Anchorage.
Both were hard-surface roads and both were under the com-
plete supervision of the Alaska Road Commission. They
were outside the Fairbanks district.
12. At the time the contract was entered into, Colonel
Noyes recognized the lack of knowledge and experience of
the personnel in the Fairbanks area with contracts of the
type about to be carried out. The district engineer, Frank
Nash, had grown up with the road work in Alaska but he was
not adequately informed on a jobof that kind. The assistant
district engineer, Milton C. Zimmerman, while a well trained
engineer with some years experience in Alaska, was likewise
inexperienced on a job of this character. Because of this
situation, Colonel Noyes gave more than the usual attention
to the job. In addition, the Alaska Road Commission
obtained for resident engineer James L. Foster, a competent
engineer who had had considerable experience in work of
the character involved. Because of the weakness in the dis-
trict office, Foster was granted more authority than was
usually given to a resident engineer in carrying out a job of
20A
that kind. Since this was the Commission’s first paved road
job in the Fairbanks district and one of their first jobs of
that kind which was being carried out without assistance
from the United States Bureau of Public Roads, he (Noyes)
told Foster he was anxious that a good job be done. Noyes
also told Foster that in the event he was unable to secure
decisions from Nash, he (Foster) should communicate di-
rectly with him (Noyes). On two occasions when Williams
took up matters with Nash, Nash told Williams that Foster
was resident engineer and that matters pertaining to the job
should be taken up with him. While Foster was under
Nash and Zimmerman, most of the decisions which had to be
made on the job with respect to carrying out the work were
made by Foster without much assistance from them. How-
ever, Foster submitted his reports through the district office
and conferred with both Nash and Zimmerman from time
to time with respect to the manner in which the work should
be carried on.
13. The Birch Hill Quarry which was designated in the
contract as the source of borrow material was located approx-
imately one and one-half miles east of the eastern terminal
of the road construction on the Steese Highway. The length
of the face of the quarry on which the plaintiffs were working
was about 650 feet and it had a height of 100 to 125 feet.
When the plaintiffs started work, the quarry, which was vir-
gin material not previously excavated, lay on about a 45 per-
cent slope, that is, it rose 45 feet for each 100 feet in the face
of the slope. In taking material from the quarry, the lay of
the material was changed in substantial part to about a
60 percent slope which was the steepest at which the material
would remain in place.
The material was a micaceous schist lying in planes four
to six inches in width. The deposit was conic in shape and
the plaintiffs were working on one of the sloping faces. The
material was not a solid wall of rock, but was laminated and
had further disintegrated to some extent by the action of the
weather upon it. While the evidence does not clearly estab-
lish the extent to which voids may have existed in the virgin
material before it was disturbed in the plaintiffs’ operation,
whatever voids existed, except for broken material on the sur-
21A
face, were smaller in magnitude than the voids in the material
after it was removed by the plaintiffs. Small slides, in addi-
tion to the major slide hereinafter referred to, occurred from
time to time during the operation. ‘The excavation was per-
formed by power shovel which operated from the toe of the
slope and loaded the material into trucks. No blasting was
required or employed except two small shots to loosen the
frozen toe area at the beginning of the operation. The ma-
terial, loaded as just described, was delivered by the trucks
to the road and formed the base course for the road. It was
compacted on the road by traffic, including the plaintiffs’
vehicles, moving over it during the period of operations and
by the use of a caterpillar tractor.
14. No survey had been made of the part of Birch Hill
Quarry where the plaintiffs were required to secure the bor-
row material prior to the execution of the plaintiffs’ contract.
However, since the contract provided that borrow pit mate-
rial, referred to in the bid schedule as Item 26 (1), and spe-
cial overhaul of borrow, Item 28 (2), were to be paid for on
the basis of the number of cubic yards of material measured
in original position in the quarry and computed by the aver-
age end area method, the defendant caused a survey to be
made of the quarry immediately before the plaintiffs began
excavation work. This survey was done in large part by the
stadia method by making profiles of the face of the quarry
at 25-foot intervals from an established base line 1,000 feet
long and parallel with the main slope of the quarry. There
was a relatively flat plane at the top and extending back from
the quarry, and the profiles just referred to extended back on
this plane for distances ranging from 25 to 50 feet. Since
the face of the quarry was irregular, inaccuracies could result
by the use of the stadia method under such circumstances.
However, this method is often used and is usually found rea-
sonably accurate within a margin of error of 5 percent. The
chain method of survey which was used to a relatively small
extent takes much longer but produces results accurate within
a margin of error of 1 percent.
15. It iscustomary on contracts of this type, where the final
quantity is to be established by cross-sections, to make prog-
ress payments on the basis of a measurement of trucks, a
22A
determination of the load carried by each truck including
the heap on the truck and swell in the material, and a count
of the number of trips made by each truck. Prior to the
commencement of the hauling of borrow from the quarry,
defendant’s resident engineer, James T. Foster, and a repre-
sentative of the plaintiffs measured each of the trucks on the
job and calculated the dimensions of their gross load when
heaped full. Each of the trucks was numbered and the
number painted on its side. The volume of each truck as
measured was reduced by a swell factor to allow for voids
in the material in the trucks as compared with the material
in its undisturbed state in the quarry. A somewhat larger
swell factor was used in the smaller trucks because of the
greater compaction of the load in a large truck, the greater
likelihood of fine material filling voids that might arise dur-
ing loading, and the fact that the cab on the larger truck
held a larger heap at that end. However, that difference in
the factor on the smaller trucks became of relative unim-
portance on the job for the reason that the so-called smaller
trucks, seven cubic yards in capacity or less, were used for
only a short time during the operations.
The yardage for each truck, adjusted in the manner indi-
cated above to represent yardage in place, was recorded
against the number of each truck. Thereafter, throughout
the course of the job, a representative of the resident en-
gineer’s office checked each truck that left the borrow pit and
listed its number, yardage, and time of departure. Another
inspector from the resident engineer’s office on the job noted
the time of arrival of each truck, yardage, and the place where
delivered. A representative of the plaintiffs also checked
yardage and placement of the material on the road. These
three reports on yardage were reconciled each day and the
resident engineer furnished to the plaintiffs a weekly report
on the yardage hauled and the yard mile tabulation based
upon the method of calculation just described. Monthly
progress payments were made to the plaintiffs on the basis
of these tabulations. Likewise the plaintiffs paid their
hauling subcontractors on the same basis of calculation of
yardage.
16. As shown in finding 14, the base line of the quarry for
the survey made by defendant was 1,000 feet long and par-
8 RCIA NIE AISNE SL OAR te NOE EE Y , : vom.
23A
allel with the main slope of the quarry. The plaintiffs’
operations in the quarry covered only approximately 650
feet, that is, from station 3+50 to station 10+00. The toe
of the slope at station 3+50, which was the eastern limit
of the plaintiffs’ operations, commenced about 90 feet back
from the base line and the toe of the slope at other points
between station 3+50 and station 10+00 varied from that
distance back of the base line to a close proximity to the
base line at stations 8+25 and 8+75 and approximately 50
feet at station 10+00. The power shovel operated at the
toe of the slope and toward the steep embankment of the
quarry, that is, in a northerly direction. Approximately 92
percent of the material excavated by the plaintiffs during
their period of operations came from between stations 6+ 50
and 9+ 50.
17. Prior to May 11, 1950, the plaintiffs had excavated and
moved from the quarry 34,596 cubic yards of material com-
puted on the truck measurement basis heretofore described.
On May 11, 1950, a large slide occurred at the site where
excavation work was being carried on by the plaintiffs in
the quarry—partially burying the shovel and killing the
shovel operator. At the time of the slide, the power shovel
was operating about in the area of station 7+00 to station
8+50, that is, from 150 to 300 feet from the western end of
the borrow area. A large amount of material moved down-
ward and outward toward the base line where the plaintiffs
were operating. The slide covered approximately 500 feet
along the face of the slope encompassing the area about
between stations 4+75 to 10+00. A large amount of mate-
rial moved as a result of the slide though no accurate
determination of the quantity can be made from the evidence
in the record nor was any attempt made to determine the
extent of the slide when it occurred. A witness for defendant
estimated that not more than 30,000 to 50,000 cubic yards
of material were involved in the slide, whereas witnesses
for the plaintiffs estimated from 200,000 to 400,000 cubic
yards. Cracks, fissures, and crevasses were opened up north
of the face of the slope and on the slope itself. The biggest i
crevasse was immediately above the slide area and was about Hy
50 feet along, 10 feet wide, and at least 20 feet deep. At
least some of the cracks, fissures or crevasses were outside
838960—55———4
iF
:
‘
Hd
Pd
:
4
i
&
é
¥
ie
;
f
A RAGA 2 HE ESO EEE
POI PET FAN EMER ICA
al atid
26A
21. The work on the contract involved in this proceeding
was completed on September 30 and formally accepted by
the Alaska Road Commission on October 9, 1950. As here-
tofore shown, the work under Item 26 (1), Unclassified Ex-
cavation for Borrow, was completed on or shortly after June
30, 1950.
Foster remained on the job as resident engineer until about
September 16, 1950, at which time, because of his own illness
or illness in his family or some other reason, he returned to
California and did not thereafter return to his job in Alaska.
At the time he left, the Alaska Road Commission expected
that he would return within a few days and his job was not
filled on a permanent basis until some months later when
it appeared that he would not return to Alaska. No one else
connected with the Alaska Road Commission was as familiar
with the work as Foster, and his absence from the job made
it more difficult for the Alaska Road Commission to prepare
the final estimates and ultimately deal with the controversies
involved in this proceeding. However, during the period
July to September, the greater part of which time Foster
was on the job, the survey referred to in finding 22 was
made. What connection Foster had with this final survey
does not definitely appear, though in his weekly reports for
July 23 and August 6, 1950, there are notations to the effect
that the survey was being made.
22. Under the average end area method provided in the
contract for computing the amount of borrow material re-
moved, it was contemplated that a survey would be made of
the quarry after the excavation was completed for compari-
son with the original survey. The excavation was completed
about June 30, 1950, and during the period July, August, and
September, 1950, the office of the Alaska Road Commission
at Fairbanks caused such a survey to be made. The same
base line was used as in the original survey and cross-sections
were prepared, using the same stations as in the original
survey, that is, stations 25 feet apart. Since the original
survey did not cover the entire area from which material
had slid into the quarry, the original profiles were extended
by interpolations, under recognized engineering procedure,
to cover certain areas not covered by the original survey.
7 —
-
BEE APA SRP RE # WLI
274A
The use of interpolations is subject to certain inaccuracies
but usually provides a reasonable degree of accuracy.
The interval between the original survey and the final
survey as plotted was used as a basis for computing the ma-
terial removed from the quarry. No allowance was made
for swell or voids in the quarry which may have been created
in the material remaining in the quarry by reason of the slide.
That computation showed the total amount of borrow ma-
terial excavated as 68,888.32 cubic yards and the number of
cubic-yard miles of special overhaul for borrow as 202,582.
On that basis the final estimate was prepared by the resident
engineer and approved by the district office of the Alaska
Road Commission. This estimate was a reduction in the
borrow material item from 99,592 cubic yards, as reported on
the truck measurement basis, to 68,888.52, that is, a reduction
of 30,703.68 cubic yards which, at the contract price of $1.29
per cubic yard, amounted to a reduction in the amount to be
paid to the plaintiffs of $39,607.75. Similarly on the over-
haul item, it meant a reduction from 311,570 cubic-yard
miles to 202,532, that is, a reduction of 109,038 which, at 32
cents per cubic-yard mile, amounted to a reduction in the
amount to be paid to the plaintiffs of $34,892.16.
23. In computing the final yardage of borrow material
which had been removed from the quarry by the use of the
two surveys, 27 cross-sections taken 25 feet apart were used,
that is, from station 3+950 to station 10+00 which was
the area where the excavation was carried out. Four of
these sections were found wholly negative and six others
partly negative. A negative section is one in which the final
ground is above the original ground, that is, more material
than there was at the start of the excavation. A partly nega-
tive section is where some portion of the final ground is above
the original ground. The defendant deducted yardage to the
extent of the negative and partly negative sections. The
following tabulation shows the amount of material com-
puted for each section, including the sections shown as nega-
tive or partially negative:
28A
Btation Cubic yards
3-+50 653. 7
38+75 1, 306.9
4+00 1,519.9
4425 1, 133.3
°4+50 618.5
Partially Negative___ 4+75 145. 4
TG oi ita tthe stats wons oe a ie ene 5+00 —12.5
Partially Negative___ 5425 —25.5
Negative__- 5+50 —31.5
Partially Negative____ = meee 5+75 157.4
POSHGliy NGGRIVG. 36s n oe cansimenenees 6+00 —29. 4
Negative i este ean anise arian 6425 417.1
Partinity NGGRUV6. <n ncn cc che c acne ncncacnssce 6+50 1, 852.3
6+ 75 3, 321.8
7+00 4, 613.8
7425 5, 291.2
7+50 5, 707.4
7+75 6, 289.3
8+00 6, 974
8425 7, 398.6
8+50 7,521.7
8+75 6, 116.6
9+00 4,156.4
9+25 2, 970. 4
9+50 1, 605.1
Partially Negative_____-_--.--- - 9475 — N22. a
Negative............. = 10+00
69, 349. 7
The total amount shown above differs from the final esti
mate referred to in the previous finding by 461.38 cubic yards
which represented overburden removed by the plaintiffs but
which the Commission did not at first recognize for pay
purposes as borrow material. In the final determination,
however, the total of 69,349.70 cubic yards was allowed. It
was allocated as follows:
64,735.90 cubic yards to roadway embankment.
4,152.42 cubic yards rejected in spoils pile at quarry.
461.38 cubic yards overburden.
24. Shortly prior to November 25, 1950, the district engi-
neer forwarded to the plaintiffs the final estimate referred
to in finding 22, and on November 25, 1950, the plaintiffs wrote
the district engineer as follows:
RS SI
4
%
oe”, TRE
LTRS REIT,
29A
This will acknowledge receipt of your final estimate
on the College Road job, Contract No. 1-arc—426s. |
In checking your quantities shown on the estimate
we find that there are great discrepancies between esti-
mate No. 4 and the final quantities.
Since the quantities of previous estimates were deter-
mined by load slips, weight slips, cross sections and
records which were compiled and maintained by the
Resident Engineer who furnished the supervision and
control on this job, and in view of the discrepancy be-
tween the final quantities and those previously approved
we cannot accept this estimate without complete
substantiating data used in the compilation of your
quantities.
It is impossible for us to understand how such a great
discrepancy could be possible on a job with competent
administration and control.
We hereby request that the Contractor be furnished
complete supporting data including copies of field notes
on quarry sections, all preliminary and final sections
and other supporting data used in determining the final
quantities.
25. Because of their dissatisfaction with the foregoing de-
termination by the district engineer, the plaintiffs took the
matter up with the contracting officer. Various conferences
and discussions were had with the contracting officer and
other representatives of the Alaska Road Commission in con-
nection with which, and other conferences after the decision
by the contracting oflicer, the Alaska Road Commission made
available to the plaintiffs and to a consulting engineer re-
tained by them all field books, profiles, and engineering data
of the Alaska Road Commission having to do with the proj-
ect. While these discussions were being had, the contracting
officer caused the district engineer to prepare a mass diagram
of the material in place on the road and compute the quan-
tity of borrow material in place on the road. This computa-
tion resulted in a determination of material in place in the
roadway of 66,566.5 cubic yards. The computation was
made as a check on the reasonable accuracy of the amount
of the borrow material which had been previously deter-
mined by the average end area method as used for roadway
embankment, namely, 64,735.90 cubic yards. It also afforded
a basis of comparison with the estimates of borrow material
required as set out in finding 9. For such purposes, it failed
30A
to take into consideration indeterminate amounts of material
as follows:
(a) The road in question was built on a gravel road which
had been in existence for many years and which had been
reinforced with gravel the preceding year. In that area
such roads, when subjected to traffic in the thawing period
during the spring, often give way due to frost or mud boils
and other soft conditions in the road. The plaintiffs began
placing material on the road before it had thawed. When
the ground underneath thawed, some of the material placed
thereon sank and had to be replaced. In addition mud boils
developed from time to time over the road and additional
material was required in the places where they occurred. It
had been estimated 5,500 cubic yards would be required to
replace unsuitable soil. The plaintiffs were authorized to
excavate certain areas where the major mud boils occurred.
The total area so excavated was 6,952 cubic yards and that
area was filled by material from the quarry. Allowing for
the expansion of the material, the estimated quantity in place
in the quarry of 5,500 cubic yards of borrow material to be
used to replace unsuitable soil would not be substantially less
than that required to fill the 6,952 cubic yards of excavation.
However, a reasonable conclusion from the evidence is that
additional borrow material was required on account of mud
or frost boils which were not excavated and on account of
places where the road sank during the thawing season.
(b) As shown in finding 9, the original survey was defi-
cient in that it had not taken full cognizance of driveways
and intersections for which borrow material was required.
The plaintiffs performed the work in connection with these
driveways and intersections as directed by the resident engi-
neer and in doing so used more borrow material than had
been included in the original estimate.
(c) During the course of construction it was found neces-
sary to make a change in the location of the road which
made an increase in the estimated quantity of borrow mate-
rial required of approximately 2,000 cubic yards. An error
in chaining occurred in the original survey which also in-
creased the estimated quantity by an indeterminate but
smaller amount than that required for the change in location.
(d) An indeterminate amount of borrow material, in ad-
Lo ramet
31A
dition to the original estimate, was required for a fill at a
place on the road known as the Noyes Slough by reason of
incomplete cross-sections which were available when the
original estimate was made.
26. After the study referred to in the preceding finding had
been made, a conference was held in April 1951 at the office
of the Alaska Road Commission in Juneau which was at-
tended by representatives of the plaintiffs and of the Alaska
Road Commission, and which lasted for two days. Follow-
ing that conference, the contracting officer allowed a number
of the claims which the plaintiffs had submitted, but denied
the claims for Item 26 (1) and 28 (2), Unclassified Exca-
vation for Borrow and Overhaul of Borrow Material.
27. The plaintiffs took an appeal from the foregoing deci-
sion of the contracting officer to the Commissioner of Roads
for Alaska, the designated representative of the head of the
department. At the conference in Juneau, referred to in
the preceding finding, the suggestion was discussed of having
a specific gravity test made of the material in the quarry as
a further check on the accuracy of the amount previously
determined through the use of the average end area method.
By such a test it was expected that a determination could be
had of the change in volume from a solid rock condition
of the material in the quarry to a disturbed condition of the
same material in a truck, that is, a determination of the
percentage of swell or voids in the material loaded in a truck
as compared with the material in a solid condition in the
quarry. Upon or prior to the return of Zimmerman, con-
struction engineer on the project at Juneau and a partici-
pant in the conference at Juneau, Noyes, Commissioner of
Roads, and Ghiglione, contracting officer, either authorized
or instructed Zimmerman to cause a specific gravity test of
the kind referred to above to be made. Samples of solid
rock material, varying in dimensions from head to fist size,
were obtained from two locations in the quarry and the
specific gravity of these samples was determined by standard
engineering methods. A truck load (using a 3-cubic-yard
truck) was taken from each location. The loads were
heaped at the quarry. After the trucks were driven to the
yard of the Alaska Road Commission in Fairbanks, some
two miles from the quarry, the heaped portion of the load
ef
seh SAE SEIT
NECN ET LO EEE LTTE TLL IODIDE DELILE LILLIE LEIS LA DEEL DERI AEE
32A
was struck off to make a water level and any holes visible
were filled by placing material from the quarry therein. The
trucks so loaded were then weighed and a determination
made of the weight of the material therein. By applica-
tion of the specific gravity of this material to the weight of
a 3-cubic-yard load, it was determined that a 3-cubic-yard
truck load contained 33 percent voids. By the application
of that percentage of voids to the yardage as determined
on the truck measurement basis contended for by the plain-
tiffs, a calculated quantity of 76,000 cubic yards was deter-
mined for the borrow material in place in the quarry which
had been removed by the plaintiffs. Sucha result was consid-
ered by the Alaska Road Commission as tending to support
its determination of the borrow material removed as com-
puted by the average end area method.
The plaintiffs did not know that the specific gravity test
referred to above was being made and were not given an
opportunity to participate therein. No 3-cubic-yard trucks
were used by the plaintiffs on the job—the smallest hay-
ing a capacity of six or seven cubic yards—and these
smaller trucks were used for only a short time at the begin-
ning of the job. The trucks used for most of the work had
a capacity in excess of seven yards. The representatives of
the Alaska Road Commission used the smaller truck because
such a truck happened to be working in the quarry at the
time, and without any intent to be unfair to the plaintiffs,
However, a more accurate determination and tending to be
more favorable to the plaintiffs would have resulted by the
use of trucks of the sizes which were used in performing
the work.
In considering the plaintiffs’ appeal, the Commissioner
of Roads made a study of the various items in controversy,
including the effect thereon of the specific gravity test re-
ferred to above, and under date of June 15, 1951, wrote the
plaintiffs allowing some of the claims on appeal. With
respect to the items “Unclassified Excavation for Borrow”
and “Special Overhaul of Borrow,” he increased slightly the
quantities which had been allowed by the contracting officer e
but otherwise disallowed the claims. On these two items his
rulings were as follows:
D Det
.
=
SI 24
eh :
é
¥
ps
i
33A
Ivem No. 26 (1) Unclassified Excavation for Borrow
The District Engineer has now completed further
studies of the Birch Hill Quarry rock. By careful
weighing of loaded trucks and laboratory determination
of the specific , ating of numerous representative rock
samples it has been determined that a truck struck to
water-level capacity after a two-mile haul contained
33% voids. In other words, it took only 4 yards of
solid rock to fill a 6-yard truck. These tests were made
with great care being exercised to obtain typical load-
ings, excessive oversize was avoided, and normal fines
were carefully included. When struck off after a two-
mile haul, any open holes in the top of the load were
carefully hand filled.
Heaped loads were also carefully weighed. These
tests proved that a heaped truck credited, during the
course of the work, with a 7-yard load actually contained
only 5.33 yards of solid rock. In other words, by actual
weight tests it was found that a typical heaped truck
contained only 76% of the solid rock that it was credited
with during the truck count tabulations. It is reported
by the Contractor that 15% swell factor was used in
determining the yardage credited to each truck by the
truck count method. Multiplying the 85% credited by
the 76% of credited yardage determined by weight meas-
urements gives an actual capacity of 65% of the in place
yardage, which closely checks the initial weight determi-
nation of voids in a struck load. It therefore appears
sound to apply to the truck load credit of 99,962 yards
a factor of 76%, which would result in a calculated quan-
tity of 76,000 cubic yards. This is based on careful load-
ing to the ideal capacity as explained above, so is con-
sidered a reasonable verification of the 64,736 delivered
cubic yards that our engineers have already established
from cross sections of the borrow pits and checked
against the 66,567 cubic yards found to exist in the
embankment.
It is therefore concluded that the truck count method
claimed by the contractor is not the most accurate
method of determination of the quantities contemplated
by the contract, and that the cross sections of the exist-
ing and reconstructed surfaces of the borrow pit, as used
by the resident engineer, are the most accurate and are
equitable and final. In regard to Mr. Ferguson’s brief,
it is not agreed that the Government representatives at
the Juneau conference accepted the conclusion that the
contract method of measurement became impossible as
a result of the slide. Neither is it conceded that Mr.
re ———— |
34A
Foster “recognized the impossibility of using the con-
tract method of measurement” or at any time intended
to rely upon the truck count for final determination of
uantities. Ifso, why did the resident engineer require
the continuation of cross sectioning of the quarry in uly
and August when the slide occurred on May 11
Under Article 6.1, Sources of Material, the Special
Provisions state that “the cost of any necessary clearin
and stripping shall be considered as included in the unit
rice bid Sa tern 26 (1).” The resident engineer there-
ore rule[d] 461.38 cubic yards of the spoil pile as over-
burden stripping for which no pe lange was due. How-
ever, Specifications FP-41, in Article 26-4.1 provide for
inclusion of the yardage of overburden stripped from é
borrow pits, and the Special Provisions of this contract
failed to modify the provisions of that Article. What-
ever the initial intent of Article 6.1 of the Special Provi-
sions, it is not conclusive, and it is therefore concluded
that Article 26-4.1 of Specifications FP-41 shall govern,
and that the entire 69,349.7 cubic yards calculated as j
excavated from the Birch Hill Quarry shall be allowed «
as the final pay bey under Item 26 (1). This yard- ie
age was disposed of by delivering 64,736 cubic yards to a
the roadway, wasting 4,152.4 cubic yards as rejected é
material, and removing 436.1 cubic yards of overburden.
* & s & s %
Irem No. 28 (2) Cu.-Yd.-Mile Special Overhaul
of Borrow
This item is, of course, directly proportionate to the
quantity of the borrow under Item 26 (1). Since the
truck count measurement of the borrow has been found
unreliable as to quantity, it must also be determined
unreliable as to overhaul. A recheck of the mass dia-
ms, showing the disposition of the borrow, gives a
nal quantity on this item of 217,032.4 cubic yard miles.
28. On July 20, 1951, the plaintiffs requested a reconsidera-
tion of the decision by the Commissioner of Roads and on
July 30, 1951, the Commissioner of Roads affirmed his prior
decision in a letter to counsel for the plaintiffs as follows:
We now have the letter, addressed to us by Mr. Fer-
uson under date of July 20, protesting the June 15
or he of the Commissioner of Roads for Alaska.
You refer to quantities supported by “sound engineer-
ing practices.” In view of the contract terms we con-
tend that the cross sections of the borrow pit are the
only engineering practices that may be relied upon in
—-
35A
this case. We believe that accurate results have been
obtained from the reconstructed position of that part of
the pit which was affected by the slide but had not been
initially cross sectioned. As previously explained, we
rely upon this cross sectional method of, a
volume of the material in its original position. We have
confidence in those quantities because the volume of the
embankment, as now in place, strongly supports the cal-
culated excavation quantities and a load rv specific
gravity test gives further confirmation. You contend
that the “test referred to in your decision clearly indi-
cates” erroneous calculations. We believe that a care-
fully loaded and subsequently hand packed test truck
would certainly hold more rock than the average of
trucks hauling under job conditions. We therefore be-
lieve that the factor derived from the load test, as applied
to the truck count, gives a very reasonable confirmation
of our calculated 64,736 excavated yards when it shows
an ideal, hand packed, capacity of 76,000 yards. :
You now suggest a compromise. In matters of this
nature the contracting officer, or other official of the
executive department of the Government, has no author-
ity to compromise. However, what you really offer is
not a compromise but the establishment of another
method of measurement, or rather the re-examination of
one of the methods we have already used asa check. We
do not believe that such a re-examination would produce
results materially differing from the test made by our
forces, which was conscientiously carried out under pro-
cedures stipulated by recognized authorities. We there-
fore see little to be gained by further tests, but certainly
have no objection to your client’s making whatever tests
he desires.
The June 15, 1951, decision of the authorized repre-
sentative of the head of the department is therefore
reaffirmed and is final.
29. The decision of the contracting officer, which was
affirmed on appeal to the Commissioner of Roads, with
respect to the total amount of borrow material excavated
and similarly with respect to the overhaul item, was not
supported by substantial evidence. When all the evidence
is considered, and the different methods of measurement are
put together, it is a reasonable conclusion that at least
84,471 cubic yards of borrow material were excavated in-
stead of 69,349.7 cubic yards allowed by the defendant, that
is, 15,121.38 cubic yards more than allowed which, at the
;
AOE SAE Ce eee |
36A
contract price of $1.29 per cubic yard, amounts to $19,506.48,
Since the amount allowable for the overhaul items varied
in direct proportion to the volume of borrow material re-
moved, the cubic-yard miles allowable are 267,727.8 instead
of 217,032.4; that is, 50,695.4 cubic-yard miles more than
allowed by the defendant, which, at the contract price of
32 cents per cubic-yard mile, amounts to $16,222.53.
30. One of the items involved in carrying out the contract
involved herein was paving the road with asphalt. To per-
form that work it was necessary for the plaintiffs to have
an asphalt plant. At the time they submitted their bid and
entered into the contract, the plaintiffs contemplated renting
or buying one of two asphalt plants located in the State of
Washington. The rental costs including transportation,
erection and dismantling would have been approximately
$10,700.
31. After the contract was executed the plaintiffs learned
that there was an asphalt plant at Ladd Air Force Base in
Fairbanks. In April 1950 a representative of the plaintiffs
called upon Maj. Leon Russell, the Air Installation Officer
at that place, to determine whether the plaintiffs could rent
the asphalt plant located there. Major Russell advised the
plaintiffs’ representative that the roads on the airfield needed
seal coating and that if the plaintiffs would seal coat certain
roads on the base, he would allow them to use the asphalt
plant in return for such service. On April 8, 1950, the
plaintiffs wrote Major Russell, in part, as follows:
We are now deferring our plans for the purchase and
shipment of any asphalt equipment for the College Road
job which we are under contract to the Alaska Road
Commission. Asa result of our talk with you concerning
this matter, we are sure that an equitable arrangement
can be consummated which will definitely work out to the
advantage of the Government, and also save our firm
considerable capital investment for such a small quantity
of asphalt mix required for this job.
32. The representative of the plaintiffs had further con-
versations with Major Russell and arrived at a mutually
agreeable proposal along the line indicated in the preceding
finding. Major Russell said among other things that he
would go through channels and find out if he had the author-
37A
fe ity to enter into such an agreement. About the middle of
3 May 1950, Major Russell advised plaintiffs that he had been
granted the authority to make the deal and that plaintiffs
should write him a letter setting out the agreement thereto-
fore reached. On May 17, 1950, the plaintiffs wrote the
following letter to the Office of the Air Installation Officer,
Ladd Air Force Base, for the attention of Major Russell,
on which Major Russell indicated his approval as set out
below:
Reference is made to our recent conversation regard-
ing the Asphalt Plant. We wish to submit the following
agreement for your consideration.
1. The Contractor agrees to accomplish the following
work items on Ladd Air Force Base for the Air
Installations Officer during the 1950 Construction
Season :
a. Seal coat the main paved roads which includes
approximately nine lineal miles of road. Seal coat
to consist of 30+ of chips and .25 gal. of asphalt per
square yard.
b. Operate and maintain the Asphalt Mixing Plant
located in the 500 zone, and produce a maximum of
10,000 tons of asphalt mix. Mix to be delivered to
A. I. O. operated trucks at the Asphalt Plant.
2. The Air Installations Officer agrees to furnish the
f Contractor with the following materials and equip-
‘ ment for prosecution of work items listed above:
a. Asphalt Plant and all allied equipment in oper-
ating condition.
b. Foreman for Asphalt Plant who will oversee
equipment only.
c. All fuel oil, oils, and grease for A. I. O. owned
equipment.
d. Chips and aggregate at bulkhead.
e. All equipment required for applying seal coat
with the exception of dump trucks. (The Contractor
is to hire a distributor operator specified by the
A. I. O. for operation of the Government owned
asphalt distributor.)
8. In return for the work to be accomplished by the
Contractor as listed in pee #1 above, the Air
Installations Officer will permit the Contractor to use
the Asphalt Mixing Plant for producing approxi-
E mately 10,000 tons of mix for the Contractor’s job
near Fairbanks, Alaska. At no time will the pro-
duction of asphalt mix for the Contractor’s require-
ments be allowed to interfere with production of
ena |
Leese, ee
vad attsesat a
int
ee eee eee
5 SRL Re LRAT PS
SN Seige
38A
asphalt mix for the A. I. O. requirements, providing
the Contractor is given three days advance notice.
Submitted:
[s]} Russernn H. Witii1aMs,
Williams Equipment Company.
Reed and Martin, Ine.
A Joint Venture.
Approved :
[s] Leon Russet,
Air Installation Officer.
33. Major Russell, the Air Installation Officer, had charge
of the maintenance of roads, buildings, and facilities of Ladd
Air Force Base. He was not, however, a contracting officer.
34. Seal coating referred to in the letter of May 17, 1950,
was the application of a surface dressing to an asphalt sur-
face to prevent water from entering into the pores of the
asphalt. It is maintenance work which is required to be done
at intervals of approximately two years. The plaintiffs did
the seal coating called for under the terms of the letter of
May 17, 1950, placing a seal coat on some nine or ten miles
of roadway at Ladd Field and otherwise fulfilling the terms
and conditions set out in that letter. The work was begun
about the middle of June 1950 and completed shortly after
July 1, 1950. The fair value of that work was not less than
$10,166.39, the amount deducted from the plaintiffs’ contract
price as shown in finding 39.
35. On June 9, 1950, Major Russell forwarded copies of the
letter of May 17, 1950 (referred to in finding 32) to his supe-
rior officer. Under date of July 13, 1950, Major Russell was
advised by radiogram by his superior officer that there was
no authority for an agreement of the type set out in the letter
of May 17, 1950, and that work thereon should be stopped
immediately. On July 18, 1950, in response to the foregoing
radiogram, Major Russell advised his superior officer that
the plaintiffs had already completed their part of the agree-
ment and urged that it was in the best interest of the Gov-
ernment that the agreement be carried out in its entirety.
His letter reads in part as follows:
c. Mr. Williams agreed that if the base would fur-
nish the plant, he would do the work, as per the attached
agreement.
39A
d. This was believed to be a good proposition whereby
the Government would gain pa ob ly by getting a
job done at very little cost, by the use of equipment which
would otherwise be idle.
e. This Agreement was cleared through Base Legal
Department and [wJas signed by the Air Installation
Oflicer and the Contractor.
f. This proposition was gprs rs to Washington and
no objections were received, provided certain facts were
covered in the Agreement, which are believed to be
covered.
g. On 1 June 1950 the Williams Construction Com-
pany started the seal coating and completed same. Mr.
Williams proceeded with the rest of the bargain and in
all ways has carried out his part of the Agreement.
2. It is felt that it is of the best interest to the Govern-
ment that this agreement be carried out in its entirety,
and is considered good business.
On July 18, the Headquarters of the Alaskan Air Com-
mand formally advised the Commanding General, Ladd Air
Force Base, that such an agreement was unauthorized and
that, therefore, favorable consideration could not be given
thereto.
36. Shortly after he received the radiogram of July 13,
1950, referred to in the preceding finding, Major Russell ad-
vised plaintiffs of his inability to carry out his agreement
to deliver the asphalt plant and suggested that arrangements
be made to have the plant borrowed by the Alaska Road
Commission from Ladd Air Force Base and then rented by
the Alaska Road Commission to the plaintiffs. Major Rus-
sell stated that if this could be arranged, he would arrange
for payment for the work which had already been done by
the plaintiffs at Ladd Field.
37. After discussions with the plaintiffs, officials of the
Alaska Road Commission and Major Russell, the District
Engineer of the Alaska Road Commission sent the following
letter to the Commanding Officer, Fairbanks, Alaska:
Williams Equipment Company and Reed & Martin,
Inc., have a contract with the Alaska Road Commission
for constructing the Fairbanks to College and portion
of Steese Highway Road Project.
We have been informed that there is an asphalt plant
at Ladd Field, which, if proper arrangements cob be
made between the contractor and the Air Installation
388960—55 5
dort, INGRAM I GAOL ANY AM PEER GAA et IM
ee
40A
Officer for use of the plant would materially aid in an
-—. completion of the road project.
our consideration of this matter would be greatly
appreciated.
On July 20, 1950, Major Russell transmitted the above
letter to his superior officer with the recommendation that
the request be granted.
The Alaska Road Commission had a policy against renting
Government-owned equipment to any of its contractors since
it was felt such action might prejudice other bidders on a
project. However, since no other asphalt plant could be
made available to complete this project before the close of the
season, an exception was made in this case and the request
made for the loan of the plant as set out above. The request
was granted and the plant was made available for the use
of the plaintiffs. It was not in good operating condition at
that time and it accordingly became necessary for the plain-
tiffs to do considerable work thereon and make certain
repairs before it could be used. It was thereafter used by
the plaintiffs as contemplated in the performance of the
contract.
38. Discussions were had between plaintiffs and repre
sentatives of the Alaska Road Commission as to the proper
rental for the asphalt plant. It was agreed that had plain-
tiffs rented the plant in the State of Washington as originally
contemplated, the rental, transportation charges, costs of
erection and dismantling would total about $10,700. That
amount was divided by the estimated quantity of plant mix
to be laid giving a figure of $1.30 per ton as a rental figure
for the plant. While the plaintiffs orally agreed to that
rental figure, when they did so they relied upon the assurance
previously given by Major Russell that they would be paid
by the Ladd Air Force Base authorities for the work hereto- 2
fore referred to which they had done at Ladd Field. Shortly —
thereafter Major Russell advised the plaintiffs that payment
could not be made for the seal coating which had been per-
formed at Ladd Field. As a result of the failure to receive
payment for the work which they had performed at Ladd
Field, the plaintiffs refused to sign a change order prepared
by the Alaska Road Commission reducing the unit price of
EE - © ae
aaa PRETRIAL NONE at mot sre ce ccrmneteamanaamemmmmmmmemmenasatsianiiadtesmanibiicmmadizainmsiminteasibeauemansaes
2
RDRP Rh OR ROR ETS onl
41A
asphalt per ton by $1.30 which reduced the estimated total
of the contract by $10,790.
39. Under date of October 13, 1950, the contracting officer
directed that the change order be considered a written order
changing the specifications and that the rental stipulated
therein be deemed to be an equitable adjustment of the con-
tract price. He advised plaintiffs of their right to appeal
from that determination to the designated representative of
the head of the department. This was one of the matters
discussed at the conference in April 1951 heretofore referred
to and was within the scope of the appeal taken by plaintiffs
to the designated representative of the head of the depart-
ment. In denying the appeal such representative stated in
his letter of June 15, 1951, as follows:
LOA AIRS:
Prant RENTAL
The decision of the Contracting Officer set forth in
his letter of October 13 has been reviewed and is hereby
affirmed by the undersigned as Authorized Representa-
tive of the Head of the Department. Since the Change
Order, previously presented to you, modifies the unit
price of Item No. 140 (1), in strict accordance with the
initial agreement, the modified price has been used in
the accompanying voucher rather than indicating a de-
duction for plant rental. In order that final settlement
on this contract may be made it is again requested that
you execute Change Order No. 2 and return the indi-
cated papers to this office.
The plaintiffs refused to execute the change order. Upon
completion of the contract, it was determined that 7,820.3
tons of asphalt had been actually used and accordingly
$10,166.39 was deducted from payments to the plaintiffs. No
amount has been paid to the plaintiffs on account of the
work done at Ladd Field.
CONCLUSION OF LAW
Upon the foregoing findings of fact, which are made a
part of the judgment herein, the court concludes that as a
matter of Jaw the plaintiffs are entitled to recover, and it is
therefore adjudged and ordered that they recover of and
from the United States forty-five thousand eight hundred
ninety-five dollars and forty cents ($45,895.40).
42A
Gn the Gnited States Court of Glaims
No. 47331
(Decided January 11, 1955)
GENERAL CASUALTY COMPANY OF AMERICA,
CENTRAL SURETY AND INSURANCE CORPO.
RATION, WACKER CORPORATION, AND N. E.
DAUGHERTY, D/B/A N. E. DAUGHERTY CON.
STRUCTION COMPANY
Vv.
THE UNITED STATES
Mr. Ernest Hubbell and Mr. Clifford B. Kimberly for the
plaintiffs.
Mr. Carl Eardley, with whom was Mr. Assistant Attorney
General Warren EF’. Burger, for the defendant.
OPINION
Laramore, Judge, delivered the opinion of the court:
This suit arises out of a contract to construct an airport
at Zanesville, Ohio, and the petition is stated in two counts,
Count one of the petition, a Lucas Act claim, was dismissed
by this court on January 8, 1952. Count two is a contract
claim for equipment rental and expense, ditch rock excava-
tion, gravel processing plant, overtime wages, delayed dam-
ages, unpaid balance of contract price, shale excavation and
rock excavation.’
Plaintiff Daugherty entered into a contract with defend-
ant, acting by and through the Civil Aeronautics Adminis-
tration, for the construction of an airport at Zanesville, Ohio.
The contract price was estimated to be $1,047,328. The ac-
1No mention is made in plaintiffs’ briefs as to processing plant claim or
the claim for overtime wages. We assume and will treat them as having
been abandoned. In any event the processing plant was installed at the
election of the contractor, since the contract permitted the use of any one
of several methods.
ll
43A
cepted bid price included a unit price of 25 cents per cubic
yard for grading and $1.35 per cubic yard for rock excava-
tion.
On May 18, 1943, plaintiff Daugherty executed and deliv-
ered to the defendant payment and performance bonds both
executed by plaintiffs, General Casualty Company and Cen-
tral Surety & Insurance Corporation, in the sum of
$418,931.20 each.
Plaintiff Daugherty received notice to proceed effective
June 10, 1943. The project was to be completed within 150
calendar days thereafter. Daugherty began operations on
June 17, 1943. The facts are sufficiently set out in the opin-
ion below.
The plaintiffs’ first cause of action is based upon the alle-
gation that the Government coerced plaintiffs into equipping
the job for full scale operations, after the cosureties had taken
over the work, before a resumption date was apparent or
determined.
Plaintiffs say that after the cosureties had taken over the
work and near the end of the winter shutdown under a stop
order issued by defendant, the cosureties were required to
equip the job with the large amount of heavy construction
machinery which would be required for full scale operations,
long before a possible resumption date was apparent or
determined.
Plaintiffs further say that the cosureties upon demand of
defendant furnished evidence that they would be ready to
perform when work could be resumed and for the purpose
had sufficient equipment on the job to begin full scale opera-
tions by April 1, 1944. But defendant required the cosureties
to comply with its demands that equipment be placed on
the job forthwith and threatened that if they did not comply
large payments due plaintiffs for work done would be with-
held and made the further threat to default the cosureties on
the contract. The cosureties say that such action on the part
of the defendant was coercion and that in the period when
they were required to equip the job from April 1 to May 10,
1944, they performed no pay item work and by having fur-
nished the equipment demanded incurred thereby an unneces-
sary expense of $13,283.97.
Be als
PE SIS SRST
—— RIPEN RENAN SEIN AN OGL OAR OE a
444A
The contract specifications provided, as to equipment, in
part as follows:
2.1 General. The Contractor shall maintain on the job
sufficient equipment of the types needed to complete all
the work in accordance with the requirements of this
specification within the contract time. He may use any
type of earth-moving equipment capable of accomplish-
ing the specified and required results. * * *
Daugherty made strong but unsuccessful efforts to get suffli-
cient equipment which was in working order. He fell behind
in rental payments on some equipment which was then with-
drawn from the job by the equipment owners. After numer-
ous warnings, it was finally necessary to terminate the right
of Daugherty to proceed effective as of November 24, 1943.
An examination of the evidence indicates that defendant
made two demands: (1) that plaintiffs furnish information
concerning equipment availability by March 10; (2) that
plaintiffs bring their equipment to the site by April 15, or
sooner, if weather conditions permitted.
Since the damage about which plaintiffs complain con-
cerns the loss of rental on equipment brought to the site in
April, it is apparent that the alleged breach of contract
concerns demand number two,
On January 28, 1944, the contracting officer advised plain-
tiffs that 52 calendar days remained for the completion of
the work; that to complete in the contract time plaintiffs
“must have sufficient equipment on the job by April 15, 1944,
or sooner, if weather conditions permit, to operate on a full
scale basis.”
Normal grading operations commence in the Zanesville
area about March 15, but due to unseasonable weather plain-
tiffs were not able to commence work until May 1 and notice
to proceed was not issued until May 10. In January the
reasonable expectation was that grading operations would
commence about March 15. At that time, January, such a
demand could not be called unreasonable. Thus, if the
demand was not a breach of contract in January, it was not
a breach of contract in April, for the plaintiffs’ loss resulted
not from compliance with the order but from the unseason-
able weather which prevented the issuance of the notice to
|
)
|
45A
proceed at the expected time. It has been held that the
Government is not responsible for the vagaries of the
weather. Warren Brothers Roads Co. v. United States, 123
C. Cls. 48, 79.
Inasmuch as grading operations would normally commence
about March 15, any prudent contractor would have been
prepared to proceed shortly thereafter. Hence plaintiffs’
movement of equipment to the site in April was a normal
action and one which would have taken place regardless of
any demand by the defendant.
Therefore, it must be concluded that plaintiffs brought the
grading equipment to the site in April not because of threats,
but because it was what any prudent contractor would have
done. It was not a breach of the contract by the Government
and the plaintiffs could not recover on this claim.
The plaintiffs’ second claim is for recovery of the alleged
cost of ditch rock excavation. Plaintiff Daugherty subcon-
tracted the drainage work to the Weikel Construction
Company.
The profile drawings of the drainage structures showed
them to be located in an area and in a strata of soil classified
on the boring log as “Horizon C” material defined as “hard,
impervious, silty clay” which was “relatively hard and
impervious.”
In digging the trenches rock was encountered which had
to be blasted and the subcontractor was paid therefor at the
rate of $5 per cubic yard.
The fact that plaintiff Daugherty anticipated rock is
evidenced by the terms of the subcontract. The uncontested
evidence is that the subcontract carried a provision, the pur-
port of which was to protect the subcontractor against rock
should it be encountered. It also appears from the evidence
that rock was anticipated below grade on this part of the
job. The evidence further shows that blasting is ordinarily
necessary because of the confined nature of this type of
excavation.
Thus plaintiffs’ contention that they are entitled to recover
an additional amount because of an alleged changed condi-
tion is without foundation. Furthermore, there is nothing
in the evidence to disclose that plantiffs ever called the atten-
¢
,
&
:
AERIALS MOREE Ne emer |
2 IIT CyB NNN TSE Nak LR PRAT PL RS TALIIE IRENA LPOG AT Me eT AREER
46A
tion of the contracting officer to an alleged changed condition
in connection with this portion of the work.
Either failure to show a changed condition or failure to
give notice of a changed condition would prevent recovery
of plaintiffs on this claim. Having failed to show a changed
condition, this item of plaintiffs’ claim is denied.
The third claim of plaintiffs is for the unpaid balance of
contract price withheld from plaintiffs’ cosureties and ap-
plied to payment of taxes owed by plaintiff Daugherty.
At the time Daugherty’s contract was terminated defend-
ant was indebted to him in the amount of $56,783.56 for work
performed.
Defendant accepted the offer of the cosureties to complete
the contract but stated that claim to all sums due under
the contract at time of termination could not then be al-
lowed since there was at the time of termination a valid
assignment of money due under the contract in favor of the
LaSalle Industrial Finance Corporation. This was satis-
factory to the cosureties who then did go ahead with the
work without a supplemental contract. On January 3, 1944,
the Comptroller General certified as due the LaSalle Corpo-
ration, as assignee of Daugherty, the sum of $56,783.56.
Before a check was issued, a tax levy was filed against the
contractor in the amount of $45,366, in connection with the
Zanesville contract and $12,863.10 assessed in connection
with other work. The defendant thereupon refused the de-
mand of the cosureties for payment of the amount earned
by Daugherty prior to the termination of his right to pro-
ceed and by appropriate bookkeeping entries defendant set
off the sum due Daugherty against his tax indebtedness.
Plaintiffs contend the surety companies had a prior lien
to the amount in dispute and are entitled in this claim to
recover said amount. The law is tothe contrary. It has been
settled that the Government which has funds in its posses-
sion may apply said funds against amounts owed to the
Government by a prime contractor. United States v. Mun-
sey Trust Company, 332 U.S. 234; Standard Accident In-
surance Company v. United States, 119 C. Cls. 749.
The contractor could not, by assignment, transfer greater
rights than he had himself and as a matter of law the Gov-
47A
ernment had the right to set off the sums due under the
contract against the amount of taxes due and owing by
plaintiff Daugherty. Thus, plaintiffs are not entitled to re-
cover on this claim.
The plaintiffs’ third cause of action is for rock and shale
excavation.
The issues presented in this claim are (1) whether defend-
ant misrepresented the materials; (2) whether the shale
constituted a changed condition; (3) if so, whether Daugh-
erty gave notice as required by article 4; (4) whether decision
of a contracting officer, affirmed by the head of the depart-
ment, that (a) there was no rock, (b) there was no notice of
a changed condition, (c) there was no changed condition, are
final and conclusive; (5) the extent of plaintiffs’ recoverable
damages, if any.
The site of the proposed airport was a rugged hilly country
cut by deep ravines with ground elevations varying from
elevation 870 to 917. It was estimated that approximately
two million cubic yards of material would have to be moved
in order to flatten out the site for airport purposes. To
assist bidders the defendant made borings at intervals of
500 feet along the center lines of the runways and notified
the bidders that hand augers were used for this purpose.
Such augers bring up earth in granular form. At stages 33
on the E/W runway and 38 on the NW/SE runway, inter-
mediate borings were made between the regular intervals
mentioned. All borings, 35 in number, were represented by
defendant on the contract drawings. The defendant’s engi-
neer making the hand auger borings, found the soil to lie
generally in three horizons, as follows:
A. Brown topsoil, from zero to six inches in depth.
B. Yellow tan silty clay, six inches to nine feet in
depth.
C. Light tan silty clay and blue clay relatively im-
pervious and hard from nine feet in depth to grade.
The engineer reported also some evidence of shale and
loose rock below grade, but the charts and borings did not
show that plaintiffs would encounter hard shale as found
in later excavation. The borings were not all examined
scientifically, but only four samples thereof were submitted
i
5
> |
RRA SN CA
48A
to the Flood Soils Laboratory for analysis, and the table
of soils characteristics in the contract drawings was appar-
ently based upon the laboratory report. This fact was un-
known to plaintiffs. The defendant did not deliberately
misrepresent the materials it thought would be encountered
or hold back any information it had from plaintiffs.
There was a duty on the part of defendant, if it made bor-
ings, to fully disclose such facts as were found. Ranieri y,
United States, 96 C. Cls. 494, 506. This it did, and we can
find no reason to hold that the defendant misrepresented
the facts to such an extent as to cause a breach of contract
on its part.
The second, third, and fourth issues presented by this
claim are for the purposes of this opinion grouped.
The borings and data made and furnished by defendant
were inadequate, and plaintiffs encountered shale in locations
and amounts seriously in excess of those indicated by the
drawings. In these respects the contract drawings were not
approximately correct. Plaintiff Daugherty’s reasonably
careful inspection of the site gave no indication to him that
he would encounter materials any different from those repre-
sented on the contract drawings.
The total quantity of excavated materials moved was
2,056,262 cubic yards.
In July 1943 plaintiff Daugherty encountered hard shale
and concluded that it could best be removed by breaking it
up with a rooter. A rooter is a heavy blade which projects
into the ground and operates on the principle of a plow.
Daugherty’s rooter had three teeth, but after experimenta-
tion it was found that in some areas the hard shale could more
easily be rooted by removing two of the teeth, thus giving
increased power to the operation. The rooter was powered
by a crawler-type tractor having 110 drawbar horsepower.
The hard shale could not have been removed by pans used in
taking out clay without first rooting it. Considerable quan-
tities of soft shale were also encountered. This was “grad-
ing” and was handled with the same equipment, pans, and
tractors as used on dirt.
The defendant classified the material, now claimed by the
plaintiffs to have been hard shale and rock, as “grading” in
each of the 1943 monthly estimates, and plaintiff Daugherty
494
was paid upon that basis. Daugherty did, however, protest
orally in September 1943 to the resident engineer about such
payment. The following month in a letter to the engineer
in charge of design and construction, he stated that 200,000
cubic yards of hard shale had been encountered slowing
operations but did not claim a changed condition for purposes
of reclassification or payment. Previously Daugherty’s
engineer and two successive superintendents made strong
oral representations about a changed condition to defend-
ant’s resident engineer and his assistants and asked that pay-
ment be made for rock. This was refused upon the basis that
it was being rooted and therefore was grading within the
contract classifications. Plaintiffs’ engineer also told the
resident engineer that he was going to cross section the hard
materials and make claims for additional compensation
therefor. The resident engineer was requested to cross sec-
tion the materials but declined to do so. Plantiffs requested
the resident engineer to have representatives present while
plaintiffs took elevations, but he did not do so. The
resident engineer did not report to the contracting officer the
representations made by plaintiff Daugherty about the
changed conditions encountered until March 30, 1944. The
first such claim was made by the contractor in writing on
February 4, 1944, after counsel had been retained and was
for 193,000 cubic yards of rock alleged to have been excavated
in 1943. This claim was denied February 10, 1944.
Plaintiff Daugherty had not excavated a shale bank near
the runway intersection and when the work was resumed
in 1944 the cosureties contended that this shale constituted
rock within the contract definition. The pertinent specifi-
cations provided as follows:
3.1 General. * * *
All material encountered shall be considered as unclas-
sified excavation unless otherwise specified. The Con-
tractor shall inform and satisfy himself as to the
character, quantity and distribution of all material to be
excavated. No payment will be made for any excavated
material which is used for purposes other than those
designated, * * *
* * * * e
3.3-b Classification of Excavation. <All excavated ma-
terial will be classified as “Grading,” or “Rock
Excavation.”
an semen eng
Tees
50A
(1) Grading shall consist of the removal and satis-
factory dis 1 of all loam, sand, clay, gravel, soft
shale, soft slate, old gravel, broken stone or ituminous
macadam pavements, loose or decomposed rock, boul-
ders of less than one-half (14) cubic yard in volume
and all other materials not otherwise classified under
these specifications.
(2) Rock Excavation. Rock excavation shall include
all solid rock and boulders having a volume of one-half
(14) cubic yard or more, and all shale or ledge rock
which cannot be removed with an extra heavy duty
rooter powered with a crawler-type tractor having 110
drawbar horsepower in good condition and on firm foot-
ing, or a modern power shovel of three-fourths (%)
cubic yard capacity in good condition, without continu-
ous drilling or blasting; although blasting may be re-
sorted to, to facilitate the work. * * *
* * * * a
The special proposal conditions provided in part as fol-
lows:
10. Locat Conprrions: Bidders or their authorized
nts are expected to inspect the site of the work or to
otherwise thoroughly acquaint themselves with local
conditions as may affect performance of the contract
and to reasonably anticipate the difficulties to be en-
countered therein. \
11. Borrncs: Borings where shown were made by
means of a hand auger. Borings were made at. the
hi ag locations shown on the drawings, and the
character and depth of materials found are believed to
be approximately correct.
* * * * *
The contract provided in part as follows:
Arricts 3. Changes.—The contracting officer may at
any time, by a written order, and without notice to the
sureties, make changes in the drawings and/or speci-
fications of this contract and within the general scope
thereof. If such changes cause an increase or decrease
in the amount due under this contract, or in the time
required for its performance, an equitable adjustment
shall be made and the contract shall be modified in
writing accordingly. Any claim for adjustment under
this article must be asserted within 10 days from the
date the change is ordered: Provided, however, That
the contracting officer, if he determines that the facts
justify such action, may receive and consider, and with
the approval of the head of the department or his duly
authorized representative, adjust any such claim asserted
51A
at any time prior to the date of final settlement of the
poten Bg if the parties fail to agree upon the adjust-
ment to be made the dispute shall be determined as
provided in article 15 hereof. But nothing provided
in this article shall excuse the contractor from proceeding
with the prosecution of the work so changed.
Arricie 4. Changed conditions.—Should the contrac-
tor encounter, or the Government discover, during the
progress of the work subsurface and/or latent conditions
at the site materially differing from those shown on the
drawings or indicated in the specifications, or unknown
conditions of an unusual nature differing materially from
those ordinarily encountered and generally recognized as
inhering in work of the character provided for in the
plans and specifications, the attention of the contracting
officer shall be called immediately to such conditions
before they are disturbed. The contracting officer shall
thereupon promptly investigate the conditions, and if
he finds that they do so materially differ the contract
shall, with the written approval of the head of the de-
partment or his duly authorized representative, be modi-
fied to provide for any increase or decrease of cost and/or
difference in time resulting from such conditions.
e
* t * s
Article 15. Disputes.—Except as otherwise specifi-
cally provided in this contract, all disputes concerning
uestions of fact arising under this contract shall be
decided by the contracting officer subject to written
appeal by the contractor within 30 days to the head of
the department concerned or his duly authorized repre-
sentative, whose decision shall be final and conclusive
upon the parties thereto. In the meantime the contractor
shall diligently proceed with the work as directed.
It was agreed that a test would be made to see if the ma-
terial could be handled by a three-quarter cubic yard shovel
without continuous drilling or blasting. The test was made
in May 1944. The shovel handled the materials with diffi-
culty, but was able to do so without drilling or blasting.
The shovel did stick sometimes and it required several passes
with the bucket to get a load, whereas in gravel, dirt, or
clay this would not have been necessary. As a consequence
of the test, defendant declined to pay for “rock.” The plain-
tiffs’ cosureties then completed the contract and were paid
for “grading.” The plaintiffs did not rely solely on the
three-quarter cubic yard shovel but also used a one-yard
shovel which had more power, approximately twice the
IPRS Chit DEERE 5d
sande?
sp eB BGG STR AS! HR IRIE XN ok
Teh BAR eS
52A
weight of the smaller shovel, and was more efficient. The
material could have been moved with the smaller shovel alone
without blasting, but this would have required much addi-
tional time which was not available. Even with the larger
shovel the teeth would break off in the hard shale and both
machines required considerable repair in this regard. This
shale not only was hard to excavate and required more time
than clay, but also did not compact well and required more
loads to the fills, increasing costs.
It will be noted that article 4 of the contract provided
“should the contractor encounter, * * * during the progress
of the work subsurface and/or latent conditions at the site
materially differing from those shown on the drawings or
indicated in the specifications * * *.”
This case in principle is much like the case of W. C. Shep-
herd v. United States, 125 C. Cls. 724, 737, where the court
said:
We do not think there can be any question but that
the wet material was unforseen by both plaintiff and de-
fendant. It was an unknown, subsurface condition
differing materially from that shown by the drawings,
specifications and borings, and one which could not have
reasonably been anticipated from a study of the draw-
ings, borings and samples, or by an examination of the
site. * * * Plaintiff 1s therefore entitled under article
4 o fthe contract to recover the full excess costs of exca-
vating, hauling, and placing the wet material on the fill,
unless limited in his recovery by a matter hereinafter
discussed.
In the instant case we do not think there can be any ques-
tion but that there was an unknown subsurface condition
differing materially from that shown by the drawings, speci-
fications and borings, and one which could not have reason-
ably been anticipated from a study of the drawings,
specifications and borings, or by an examination of the site.
Plaintiffs are therefore entitled, under article 4, of the
contract, to recover the cost of excavating materials different
from those shown on the drawings, specifications and borings,
if notice was given as required by article 4.
Having found a changed condition under article 4, it
then becomes necessary to determine whether Daugherty gave
notice as required by article 4.
53A
This question is also settled by the decision of this court
in the Shepherd case, supra, wherein the court ruled that
calling the attention of the resident engineer to conditions
constituted compliance with article 4 of the contract.
Article 21 (b) of the contract provided that “The term
‘contracting officer’ as used herein shall include his duly
appointed successor or his authorized representative.”
In both the Shepherd case and in the instant case the resi-
dent engineer was clothed by the contracting officer with
authority to be on the job and see that the work was per-
formed. In the Shepherd case the court held that the resi-
dent engineer was the authorized representative of the
contracting officer, that the resident engineer had the duty
to communicate to the contracting officer matters which were
brought to his attention regarding conditions encountered
in the excavation, and that notice to the resident engineer
constituted compliance with the contract. In the instant
case Daugherty protested orally to the resident engineer in
September 1943 and a month later in a letter to the engineer
called his attention to the fact that hard shale had been
encountered. Previously Daugherty’s engineer and two suc-
cessive superintendents made strong oral representations
about a changed condition to defendant’s resident engineer
and his assistants and asked that payment be for rock.
It would be inane indeed to suppose that the resident engi-
neer was at the site for no purpose. We believe as in the
Shepherd case, supra, that the resident engineer was the
authorized representative of the contracting officer.
Plaintiff Daugherty’s responsibility ended when notice was
given to the authorized representative of the contracting
officer. Ifthe resident engineer did nothing, certainly it was
no fault of the plaintiff Daugherty. He did all that was
required of him under the contract.
That plaintiffs’ cosureties made claim of a changed con-
dition in 1944 there can be no doubt. On March 30, 1944,
the resident engineer acknowledged to his superior the fact
that plaintiffs were claiming rock. The claim was made
in writing under date of February 4, 1944, and was denied
February 10, 1944.
When the contracting officer and the head of the depart-
ment denied and failed to recognize a changed condition
54A
where plaintiff encountered 216,755 cubic yards of hard shale
which was not indicated in the borings and contract draw-
ings and which was more difficult of removal than grading,
and when said officers failed to make an equitable adjustment
for removal thereof, the determination was arbitrary and
was not supported by substantial evidence.
Thus, the decision of the contracting officer, affirmed by
the head of the department, is not final and conclusive and
not binding on the parties hereto.
Therefore, we find that notice of a changed condition un-
der article 4 was given the contracting officer and plaintiffs
are entitled to recover because of such changed condition.
Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Company v. United States, 116
C. Cls. 679, cert. den. 342 U. S. 953; Loftis v. United States,
110 C. Cls. 551.
We then approach the question of the extent of plaintiffs’
recoverable damages.
The following are the sums allowed and paid by the de-
fendant on the disputed materials at 25 cents per cubic yard,
the quantities and character of excavation claimed by plain-
tiffs, and the sums claimed therefor :
Cubic Unit Total Balance
yards price claimed Allowed
I iciiniccindninnsennmienly 418,851 | $0.65 |$272, 253.15 |$104, 712.75 | $167, 540.40
OOD ON iis icinictinasnecaasnsese 216, 755 1.35 | 292,619.25 | 54,188.75 | 238, 430. 50
685, 606 |........ 564, 872.40 | 158,901.50 | 405, 970.90
The 418,851 cubic yards of material plaintiffs claim was
hard shale and which had to be rooted was not hard shale
and was removed in part with the equipment plaintiffs admit
using thereon; viz, a rooter with three teeth powered by a
crawler-type tractor having 110 drawbar horsepower, after
which pans were used. There was not blasting. We believe
that the material, while difficult of removal, was grading
within the terms of the specifications, for which plaintiffs
have been fully paid at the contract price for grading of 25
cents per cubic yard.
The 216,755 cubic yards was hard laminated shale of a
type not shown on-the contract drawings nor by the de-
fendant’s original borings.
55A
In May 1944 when the work was almost completed the
defendant caused borings to be made by the H. C. Nutting
Company, a firm of soil experts. Out of some 17 borings,
three were made within the area where the plaintiffs con-
tended they encountered shale and rock in excavation, and
the borings showed shale of various characteristics, together
with some conglomerate limestone. On two of the three
holes the material was hard enough to get core samples with
a rotary core drill with diamond tools for cutting. On the
other holes a sample tube was driven in with a No. 225 ham-
mer using a three inch stroke.
To excavate this material required shovels and sometimes
a rooter with one tooth powered by two tractors, one pushing
and one pulling. The 216,755 cubic yards could not for the
most part have been removed in any efficient manner without
a one-yard shovel supplementing the three-quarter yard
shovel and by being loosened in some areas with a single tooth
rooter powered by two tractors. The job could have been
completed with a rooter powered by one tractor and with the
use of a three-quarter cubic yard shovel, but it would have
taken “forever andaday.” Plaintiffs did not have and were
unable to obtain equipment and supplies required for exten-
sive drilling and blasting.
In the completion of the project the cosureties expended
the sum of $1,584,942.27 of which $487,882.90 wasaloss. The
cosureties have paid up to December 31, 1951, a total of
$493,991.64 which is the sum claimed by them of any judg-
ment rendered herein.
Plaintiffs filed a claim for rock and shale excavation on
February 17, 1945. The contracting officer denied the claim
on June 4, 1945.
In addition, as we have heretofore noted, it was necessary
to use a one-yard shovel, aproximately twice the weight of
the smaller shovel, and even then the teeth would break off in
the hard shale causing considerable repairs and delays. This
shale was not only hard to excavate and required more time,
but did not compact well and required more loads to the fills,
increasing costs.
It is apparent from the evidence that the 216,755 cubic
yards of excavation was not rock nor was it grading within
338960—55——-6
Pe Ca er eee Pee OT EEE eT OT
56A
the terms of the contract for which the plaintiffs were paid
at the contract price of 25 cents per cubic yard. A fair and
reasonable price for excavation of hard shale would be
approximately 65 cents per cubic yard.
Plaintiffs have been paid $54,188.75 at the contract price
for grading.
Therefore, we find because of a changed condition under
article 4 of the contract plaintiffs are entitled to judgment in
the sum of $86,702, which is based upon excavation of 216,755
cubic yards at 65 cents per cubic yard, less the sum of $54,-
188.75 paid plaintiffs at the rate of 25 cents per cubic yard.
The final item of plaintiffs’ claim is for $4,337.91, the
amount withheld by defendant at the termination of plain-
tiffs’ contract for delay under article 9 of the contract.
Article 9 of the contract reads as follows:
Articie 9. Delays—Damages.—If the contractor re-
fuses or fails to prosecute the work, or any separable
part thereof, with such diligence as will insure its com-
pletion within the time specified in article 1, or any
extension thereof, or fails to complete said work within
such time, the Government may, by written notice to
the contractor, terminate his right to proceed with the
work or such part of the work as to which there has
been delay. In such event the Government may take
over the work and prosecute the same to completion, by
contract or otherwise, and the contractor and his sure-
ties shall be liable to the Government for any excess
cost occasioned the Government thereby. If the con-
tractor’s right to proceed is so terminated, the Govern-
ment may take possession of and utilize in completing
the work such materials, appliances, and plant as may
be on the site of the work and necessary therefor. If
the Government does not terminate the right of the
contractor to proceed, the contractor shall continue the
work, in which event the actual damages for the delay
will be impossible to determine and in lieu thereof the
contractor shall pay to the Government as fixed, agreed,
and liquidated damages for each calendar day of delay
until the work is completed or accepted the amount as
set forth in the specifications or accompanying papers
and the contractor and his sureties shall be lable for
the amount thereof: Provided, That the right of the
contractor to proceed shall not be terminated or the
contractor charged with liquidated damages because of
any delays in the completion of the work due to un-
57A
foreseeable causes beyond the control and without the
fault or negligence of the contractor, including, but not
restricted to, acts of God, or of the public enemy, acts
of the Government, acts of another contractor in the
erformance of a contract with the Government, fires,
hoods, epidemics, quarantine restrictions, strikes, freight
embargoes, and unusually severe weather or delays of
subcontractors due to such causes, if the contractor shall
within 10 days from the beginning of any such delay
(unless the contracting officer, with the a. of the
head of the department or his duly authorized repre-
sentative, shal] grant a further period of time prior
to the date of final settlement of the contract) notify
the contracting officer in writing of the causes of delay,
who shall ascertain the facts aoa the extent of the delay
and extend the time for completing the work when in
his judgment the ow of Foct justify such an exten-
sion, and his findings of fact thereon shall be final and
conclusive on the parties hereto, subject only to appeal,
within 30 days, by the contractor to the head af the
department concerned, whose decision on such appeal
as to the facts of delay and the extension of time for
completing the work shall be final and conclusive on the
parties hereto.
As we have previously stated, the delay in completing
the job was due to unforeseen conditions encountered. Fur-
thermore, the contractor did not refuse or fail to prosecute
the work, or any separable part thereof, with such diligence
as would insure its completion within the time specified in
article 1, or any extension thereof.
In the light of the above and our decision as to changed
conditions encountered, we believe the defendant had no right
to withhold said sum as damages for delay. Plaintiff is en-
titled to judgment on this claim in the sum of $4,337.91.
Plaintiff Daugherty rented equipment and _ received
property from the Maxon Construction Company, becoming
indebted thereby in the sum of $875.32. The Maxon Con-
struction Company assigned its claim to defendant.
Daugherty is indebted to defendant in the sum of $875.32, and
defendant is entitled to recover this amount from plaintiffs
on its counterclaim.
Mapven, Judge; Lirrteton, Judge; and Jones, Chief
Judge, concur.
58A
Wuiraker, Judge, dissenting:
The court says the refusal of the contracting officer to make
an equitable adjustment when conditions were encountered
differing from those shown on the contract documents was
arbitrary and not supported by substantial evidence. I do
not believe the record justifies this.
The specifications in section 3.3-b (1) defined grading to
include soft shale, and in paragraph (2) defined rock exca-
vation as follows:
Rock excavation shall include all solid rock and
boulders having a volume of one-half (14) cubic yard or
more, and all shale or ledge rock which cannot be re-
moved with an extra heavy duty rooter powered with
a crawler-type tractor having 110 dmwbar horsepower
in good condition and on firm footing, or a modern
wer shovel of three-fourths (34) cubic _ capacity
in good condition, without continuous drilling or blast-
ing * * *.
The opinion of the majority shows thatthe parties agreed
on a test to see if the material could be handled by a three-
fourths (34) cubic yard shovel without continuous drilling
or blasting. The opinion stated the result of the test as fol-
lows:
* * * The shovel handled the materials with difficulty,
but was able to do so without drilling or blasting. The
shovel did stick sometimes and it required several passes
with the bucket to get a load, whereas in gravel, diri,
or clay this would not have been necessary. * * * The
plaintiffs did not rely solely on the taree-quarter cubic
yard shovel but also used a one-yard shovel which had
more power, approximately twice the weight of the
smaller shovel, and was more efficieat. The material
could have been moved with the smaller shovel alone
without blasting, but this would have required much
additional time which was not avaiable. Even with
the larger shovel the teeth would break off in the hard
shale and both machines required considerable repair in
this regard. * * *
As a consequence of the test made, defendant declined
to pay for rock and insisted that the plentiff was entitled
to be paid only for “grading.”
wey eee
Bs: a
yor
59A
Had I been the contracting officer I might have come
toa contrary conclusion, but I cannot say that h’s conclusion
was arbitrary or not supported by substantial evidence, be-
cause of the provisions of section 3.3-b of the specifications.
This section shows that it was contemplated that shale
might be encountered. If it was soft shale it came within
the scope of “grading” as defined in subparagraph (1). If
it was hard shale, it was to be classified as “rock excavation”
as defined in subparagraph (2). Shale was to be included
within rock excavation only when it “cannot be removed
with an extra heavy duty rooter powered with a crawler-
type tractor having 110 drawbar horsepower in good condi-
tion and on firm footing, or a modern power shovel of three-
fourths (34) cubic yard capacity.” The test showed that
this shale could be removed with a power shovel of three-
fourths cubic-yard capacity. It is true it was difficult to so
remove it, but it was not impossible and, hence, there was a
basis for the contracting officer’s determination that the ma-
terial did not come within the definition of “rock excava-
tion,” but within the definition of “grading.” There were
but two classifications of excavation provided for in the
contract, to wit, “grading” and “rock excavation.” There
was no intermediate classification.
I see no justification for making an equitable adjustment
in the contract price. It is true the borings made by de-
fendant did not show shale, but the specifications show that
it was expected that shale might be encountered, and they
provided payment for its excavation—as “grading” if it
was soft, and as “rock” if it was hard. Under the specifica-
tions it had to be classified as one or the other; there was no
intermediate classification.
There was a substantial basis for the contracting officer’s
determination that this was not rock excavation and, hence,
it must be classified as “grading.” Since there was substan-
tial evidence to support the contracting officer’s decision, it
is binding on us.
I must, therefore, respectfully dissent.
sisson aise:
Sak toes
ia eOPAS.
60A
FINDINGS OF FAOT
The court, having considered the evidence, the report of
Commissioner Marion T. Bennett, and the briefs and argu-
ment of counsel, makes findings of fact as follows:
1. Plaintiff, General Casualty Company of America, is a
corporation duly organized and existing under the laws of
the State of Washington with principal offices in Seattle, and
engaged in the business of undertaking contracts of surety-
ship.
Plaintiff, Central Surety and Insurance Corporation, is a
Missouri corporation with its principal office in Kansas City,
Missouri, and likewise engaged in the general surety business,
Plaintiff, Wacker Corporation, is duly organized and ex-
isting under the laws of the State of Illinois with its prin-
cipal office in Chicago and is the legal successor in interest
of the LaSalle Industrial Finance Corporation to all matters
stated herein. The Wacker Corporation is a nominal party
plaintiff and waives any claim to any part of the proceeds
of the claim asserted in this suit.
N. E. Daugherty is an individual residing in Indianapolis,
Indiana, and at all times sated herein did business under
the firm name of N. E. Daugherty Construction Company.
2. On April 14, 1943, defendant, acting through the De-
partment of Commerce, Civil Aeronautics Administration,
advertised for proposals for furnishing the materials and
performing work required for the construction of grading,
draining, paving and fencing of an airport at Zanesville,
Ohio. The plaintiff, N. E. Daugherty, submitted a bid
which was accepted on May 12, 1943, and on May 18, 1943,
a contract, No. C3ca-2323, was entered into between Daugh-
erty and the defendant, acting through O. J. Starr, Civil
Aeronautics Administration Administrative Officer. The
contract price was estimated to be $1,047,328.00. The ac-
cepted bid price included a unit price of 25 cents per cubic
yard for grading and $1.35 per cubic yard for rock
excavation.
3. On May 18, 1943, plaintiff Daugherty executed and de-
livered to the defendant payment and performance bonds
both executed by plaintiffs, General Casualty Company and
61A
Central Surety & Insurance Corporation, hereinafter re-
ferred to as the co-sureties, in the sum of $418,931.20 each,
guaranteeing the satisfactory performance and completion
of the contract.
4, Plaintiff Daugherty received notice from the defendant
on May 27, 1943, to proceed with construction effective June
10, 1943. The project was to be completed within 150 cal-
endar days thereafter. Daugherty began operations on June
17, 1943. On June 19, 1943, Daugherty assigned to LaSalle
Industrial Finance Corporation all moneys due or to become
due under the contract, as provided in the Assignment of
Claims Act.
5. This suit arises out of the aforesaid contract and
the petition is stated in two counts. Count One of the peti-
tion, a Lucas Act claim, was dismissed by the Court on
January 8, 1952. Count Two is a contract claim covering
the following items with adjusted sums sought:
Equipment rentals and expense__-__- $13, 283. 97
Additional excavation ee - 00
iil FH CRORVAUON one nae ence -_ 138,395.00
Gravel processing plant-_---___- . 6,125.00
Overtime wages . 2,959.85
Delay damages_-- -- 4,337.91
Unpaid balance of contract price 57, 813. 37
RIO ORC VEO rite eae nt ainint oc wean cima nenmunaetas $167, 540. 40
ROCK OCDE ON oi Soman canna capa ane wensemcn canbe 238, 430. 50
503, 886. 00
With exception of the item for additional excavation,
which has been abandoned by the plaintiffs, the items above
will be treated in the order listed.
EQUIPMENT RENTAL CLAIM
6. The proposal conditions stated in part, “The satisfac-
tory completion of the proposed contract depends to a major
extent upon the availability of proper equipment for con-
struction purposes * * *”, The specifications provided, as
to equipment, in part as follows:
2.1 General. The Contractor shall maintain on the job
suflicient equipment of the types needed to complete all
the work in accordance with the requirements of this
specification within the contract time. He may use any
|
eee DSRS
62A
type of earth-moving equipment capable of accomplish-
ete specified ead semined venilia. re F
Daugherty made strong but unsuccessful efforts to get suf-
ficient equipment which was in working order. He fell be-
hind in rental payments on some equipment which was then
withdrawn from the job by the equipment owners. After
numerous warnings that the contract would be terminated
unless progress increased, it was finally necessary to terminate
the right of Daugherty to proceed effective as of November
24, 1943.
7. The defendant, through the Civil Aeronautics Admin-
istration, accepted an offer of the co-sureties to undertake
completion of the project by a letter of intent on November 29,
1943, reading, in part, as follows:
This acceptance is contingent upon your proceeding
with the construction with such diligence as will insure
its completion within the time remaining under the
contract. It is to be understood that any excess costs
occasioned the Government because of delays in com-
Seven this project will be chargeable to the N. E,
augherty Construction Company, as principal on the
original contract, and to you as co-surety up to the limit
of your bonded obligation.
On December 6, 1943, the co-sureties were given a notice to
proceed in accordance with the letter of intent on all work
remaining to be completed, the notice effective on Decem-
ber 7, 1943. Another notice, effective the same date, stopped
all work except clearing, drainage, and fencing, until such
time as a new notice to proceed should issue. Weather did
not permit construction to proceed again until May 10, 1944,
as hereafter noted.
8. In a letter on January 28, 1944, the contracting officer
told the co-sureties that 52 calendar days remained to com-
plete all work under the contract and that in order to accom-
plish the job it would be necessary for them to have sufi-
cient equipment on the site by April 15, 1944, or sooner if
weather conditions permitted, to operate on a full-scale
basis. The co-sureties were requested to advise the defend-
ant not later than March 1 what arrangements had been
made to procure the necessary equipment and were instructed
to list it. The threat was made that the last payment esti-
63A
mate covering work performed by Daugherty would not be
released until this was done and, further, that unless the
defendant was satisfied with the answer of the co-sureties,
their right to proceed would be terminated and the work
given to others.
In a letter on February 26, 1944, the contracting officer
stated no concrete evidence had yet been received that suit-
able arrangements had been or were being made by the
co-sureties, but extended to March 15, 1944, the deadline for
submission of the data requested in the letter of January 28.
Thereafter, by telegram, the co-sureties were advised that the
deadline had been moved back to March 10 and that, weather
permitting, a proceed order might be issued effective March
15. A meeting with representatives of the co-sureties was
set for March 11 in Chicago.
9. In the meantime, on March 7, 1944, the co-sureties fur-
nished the defendant with the requested information, point-
ing out they had already invested almost half a million dol-
lars in the enterprise and had every intention of completing
the contract. They insisted the organization, finances, and
equipment necessary for this purpose were available. At
the conference in Chicago the defendant expressed further
dissatisfaction, however, and informed the co-sureties that
the commitments received for equipment did not appear to
be either firm or adequate in amount. The co-sureties there-
upon promised to get further equipment, made a prompt
effort to do so and by March 21 had made substantial prog-
ress in that direction.
The co-sureties were moving equipment onto the site by
the middle of March and had sufficient equipment there to
resume full operations by April 1944. Normally, grading
and excavation work could have started by about March 15
in that area but there was an abnormal amount of rain and
freezing weather in March and April 1944 which made it
necessary to postpone operations until May. The co-sureties
were permitted to begin work on May 1 and the resume
order was issued May 10, no time being charged against the
co-sureties in the interval.
10. On February 17, 1945, the plaintiffs presented a claim
to the contracting officer for $14,387.19 for machinery rentals
ae
ye
pe staal
r
64A
incurred prior to May 10, 1944. In the pending svit this
sum is reduced to $13,283.97 because nothing is now claimed
for the month of March, the rental expenditures being for
the month of April and up to May 10, the date of the resume
order. It is found that the sum claimed was spent and that
it does not include any rental on equipment owned by
Daugherty. The plaintiffs contend that they should have
been permitted to secure the necessary equipment within a
reasonable time after which a possible resumption date was
apparent or determined. The plaintiffs, however, had no
choice due to the fact defendant withheld a payment, threat-
ened to cancel the right to proceed and in view of the further
facts that plaintiffs had already spent several hundred thou-
sand dollars in winter work and in cleaning up the Daugh-
erty obligations.
11. The contracting officer denied the claim on June 4,
1945, stating:
The lack of proper and sufficient equipment particularly
during the latter stages of the construction influenced
greatly our decision to terminate the prime contractor’s
right to proceed. Since the co-sureties had indicated
that they intended to utilize the prime contractor's
organization in the completion of the contract, we were
concerned about the adequacy of the equipment to be
furnished for this work. For this reason we corre-
sponded and conferred with representatives of the sure-
ties to insure that the completion of this project vital to
the Armed services would not be delayed. Our primary
purpose in these dealings was to ascertain that necessary
equipment would be delivered to the site in time to per-
mit the opening of construction as soon as weather con-
ditions were favorable.
Although weather conditions did not permit further
construction until May 10, 1944, it is held that the Gov-
ernment is no more liable for the cost of the rental on
equipment during this stand-by period than it is for
rental costs on equipment held inactive by reason of
unfavorable weather during the construction season.
Your claim in the amount of $14,387.19 is, therefore,
disallowed.
On June 16, 1945, plaintiffs appealed to the Administrator
of Civil Aeronautics in Washington, D. C., and by letter of
August 22, 1945, the Administrator ruled as follows:
* * * At the time the sureties took over there was no
65A
showing that they were in a position to resume opera-
tions with adequate equipment. The co-sureties had in-
dicated their intention to utilize the prime contractor’s
organization in completing the contract and it is reason-
able to assume that the Gevernment would be concerned
about the adequacy of the equipment to be furnished b
the co-sureties for completing the work. Althoug
weather conditions did not permit resumption of opera-
tions until May 10, 1944, it would not have been good
business practice for the Government to have waited
until that date to satisfy itself that the sureties were
ready to begin as soon as weather permitted. The Gov-
ernment could not afford to defer enforcing the require-
ments of the contract but of necessity had to be certain
that the sureties were in a position to resume operations
with adequate equipment at the earliest possible date.
DITCH ROCK CLAIM
12. Plaintiff Daugherty subcontracted the drainage work
for the airport to the Weikel Construction Company. The
specifications in the prime contract provided, in part:
4.1 General. The unit prices bid for all items shall be
full compensation for furnishing all labor, materials,
equipment, and incidentals necessary to complete work
in accordance with the plans and specifications.
4.2 Pipes and Storm Sewer Lines. All pipe lines will
be measured and paid for per lineal foot in place. Unit
price shall include trench excavation, disposal of exca-
vation material, and backfill, except granular backfill
which will be paid for separately.
The profile drawings of the drainage structures showed
them to be located in an area and in a strata of soil classified
on the boring log as “Horizon C” material defined as “hard,
impervious, silty clay” which was “relatively hard and im-
pervious.” In digging the trenches, rock was encountered
which had to be blasted. It amounted to 2,679 cubic yards
of sandstone and conglomerate. The subcontractor de-
manded payment for removal of rock at the rate of $8.00
per cubic yard. The co-sureties settled the claim for $13,-
395.00 which was computed at the rate of $5.00 per cubic
yard. This was a fair and reasonable settlement. The
prime contract had fixed a price of $1.50 per lineal foot of
pipe in place. The uncontested evidence is, however, that
the subcontract carried a provision identified by one of
hee _)
66A
plaintiff's principal witnesses, the purport of which was
to protect the subcontractor against rock should it be en-
countered. The subcontract is not in evidence. It appears,
however, from the weight of the evidence that rock was an-
ticipated below grade on this part of the job. Blasting is
ordinarily necessary because of the confined nature of this
type of excavation, where hard materials are encountered
and ditch digging equipment will not suffice. There is noth-
ing in the evidence to disclose that plaintiff ever called the
attention of the contracting officer to an alleged changed
condition in connection with this portion of the work.
13. Plaintiffs filed a claim for recovery of the alleged cost
of excavating this material on February 17, 1945. The con-
tracting officer denied the claim on June 4, 1945, stating in
part as follows:
* * * While you found it necessary to blast to remove
some of the material in drainage ditches, it is considered
that from the information shown on the plans, such a
contingency should have been anticipated and provided
for. Fou will note that the borings shown on the log
were all made down the center-line of the runways,
Even at this point, considerably removed from the loca-
tion of the underdrains, shale was shown to exist in
some areas at the level of the drainage trenches. The
profile drawings of the drainage structures showed them
to be located over the majority of the airpo.t area in
the strata of soil classified on the boring log as “Horizon
C” material and defined as “relatively hard and imper-
vious”. A reasonable interpretation of this definition
should have put the bidder on notice that the material
to be encountered was of such hardness as to require
removal, in the confines of a narrow drainage ditch, by
special methods other than with ordinary trenching
machinery. The fact that blasting was resorted to does
not justify a further allowance for the removal of this
strata of impervious material since the price quoted per
lineal foot for placing of the sewer pipes was to include
all expenses incident thereto.
Plaintiffs appealed to the head of the Department who
affirmed the decision of the contracting officer.
GRAYEL-PROCESSING PLANT CLAIM
14. The specifications provided for the uniform mix of
base course materials in accordance with specification CAA
35 A-83a, which stated in part:
67A
3.3. Equirment, General. The base course material
shall be mixed by a travelling mixing machine or by a
central mixing machine. The use of road mix will onl
be permitted when so provided in the proposal. All
equipment must be in good working condition and ap-
proved by the Engineer. Whatever type of equipment
is used must produce a uniform and well-pulverized
Nl alan
On April 24, 1943, a supplement to the above specification
was issued modifying the provisions on road mixing. This
supplement permitted such mixing of base course material,
provided pulverizing-mixing methods and machines were
used. A power-driven, rotary-type pulverizing machine that
would be satisfactory was specified. However, the supple-
ment went on to say—
If the base course material is delivered to the runway
in such uniform, mixed and pulverized state that no
admixture will be required to meet the specified require-
ments, ordinary road mixing methods will be permitted
for mixing in the water without the use of pulverizing-
mixing machines.
15. Production of base course materials was started in the
fall of 1943. Plaintiff Daugherty did not have any of the
mixing plants listed in the specifications but was using a
crushing plant at his gravel pit. The defendant tested the
materials and on or about September 27, 1943, advised
Daugherty that his method was not producing satisfactory
results and would not meet specifications unless a central
stabilizing plant was used. The fact is that some of the
materials were satisfactory and were placed with defendant’s
permission to speed up the job although defendant felt that
properly specified methods were not being used. Uniformity
of mixture was achieved largely by road mixing, but without
the specified pulverizing-mixing machine. Not enough sat-
isfactory materials were being produced, however, without
equipment listed in the specifications.
16. Plaintiff Daugherty brought a pug mill (usable as a
central mixing plant) to the site in September but it was
never placed in operation. When it became apparent the
job would have to be finished the following spring, the plain-
tiff with defendant’s consent and at its suggestion, com-
68A
menced to stockpile base course materials after bad weather
set in about October 23, although base course was placed
occasionally thereafter. The effect of the stockpiling opera-
tion was to mix the materials and, assisted by winter snows
and rains and by moving them a second time in the spring, a
uniformity required by the specifications was achieved. As
a consequence, the pug mill was never used. Stockpiling was
not at the time contemplated by plaintiff as a substitute for
methods listed in the specifications because it would have
required double handling and it became an expedient method
only because the construction season turned unfavorable
before the work was finished. Such a method was not pro-
vided for in the contract. Had it not been used, however,
plaintiff would have had to employ one of the methods con-
templated by the specifications, demanded by defendant, and
utilizing authorized machines.
17. On February 17, 1945, the plaintiffs filed a claim for
the sum of $9,996.79, also named in their petition, contending
that the pug mill was installed at defendant’s insistence
but was never necessary and that the said sum represented
the cost thereof from which the contractor received no use
or value. The contracting officer on June 4, 1945, denied the
claim. The plaintiffs appealed to the head of the Depart-
ment who, on August 22, 1945, aflirmed the decision of the
contracting officer, stating in part:
It must be held that the installation of this plant was at
the election of the contractor since the contract. per-
mitted the use of any one of several methods. It must
be held that the contractor installed the central mixin
plant in order that he might meet the requirements o
the specifications. In any event, in the absence of a
. protest, which the contractor had a right to make under |
the contract provisions, it does not appear that there |
is any basis for a contention that the Government should
bear the expense of such installation.
18. Plaintiff Daugherty owned the pug mill erected as
heretofore noted and in this suit plaintiffs seek payment for |
its having been set up and dismantled under the circum-
stances described above. The evidence on plaintiffs’ costs
regarding this item is meagre but not incredible. It is found |
that the reasonable cost to plaintiffs was $6,125.00.
-
69A
CLAIM FOR OVERTIME WAGES
19. The special proposal conditions which were made a
part of the contract provided in part as follows:
26. RecuLations Reiatine To Overtime Wace Com-
PENSATIONS Executive Orper 9240: (a) On and after
October 1, 1942, all of the requirements of Executive
Order 9240, dated September 9, 1942, relating to Over-
time Wage ae shall be observed by the con-
tractor, during the war, in the performance of this con-
tract, except insofar as it may be determined by the
Secretary of Labor, pursuant to Executive Order 9248,
that the provisions of Executive Order 9240 do not
apply. e requirements of Executive Order 9240 are
as follows:
(1) No premium wage of extra compensation shall be
paid to any employee in the United States, its terri-
tories or possessions for work on Saturday or Sunday
except where such work is performed by the employee
on the sixth or seventh day worked in his regularly
scheduled workweek and as 5 ve se i rovided.
a. Where because of emergency conditions an em-
ployee is eg to work for seven consecutive days in
any regularly scheduled workweek a premium wage of
double time compensation shall be paid for work on the
seventh day.
20. On December 9, 1943, the project engineer called atten-
tion of the plaintiffs to the requirement of Executive Order
9240 as to payment of double time on the seventh day and of
the heavy penalty for not doing so. A list of the names of
531 of those who should be so paid, in defendant’s opinion,
was provided plaintiffs.
On January 20, 1944, plaintiff Daugherty replied to the
notice of December 9, 1943, stating that by agreement with
the union the workers did not expect to be paid double time
but that by paying time and a half for Saturdays and Sun-
days this amounted to straight time for Saturday and double
time for Sunday. Defendant was asked to withdraw its
demand that double time be paid for Sunday and assurance
was given that while the arrangement made by plaintiffs
“perhaps stretched some” the exacting letter of the contract,
there was no intention to violate it, but only to expedite
completion of the job in harmony with all concerned. The
upshot of it was, however, that plaintiffs did pay $2,959.85
70A
to satisfy demands of defendant that the Executive Order
be complied with and this sum was over and above sums
already paid.
21. On February 5, 1944, the contracting officer advised
plaintiffs as follows:
The Department of Labor has recently ruled in response
to an application from this Administration, that the
Wage Stabilization Agreement for the Building and
Construction Trades Industry applies to all defense
- construction carried on by the AA. Consequently,
Executive Order No. 9240 is not applicable and we will
not be required to insist on the observance of the provi-
sion regarding double-time compensation.
As a consequence of this exemption, plaintiffs, thereafter,
were not required to pay double time.
22. On or about December 1, 1944, plaintiffs claimed reim-
bursement of the double-time compensation paid for work
performed on the seventh day. The claim was rejected by
the contracting officer and plaintiffs were notified on De-
cember 29, 1944, that this was so because the provisions of
Executive Order 9240 were a part of the invitation for
bids which resulted in the contract and that it must be as-
sumed that the cost of compliance therewith was taken into
account by Daugherty in preparation of his bid since no
exception was taken to those provisions. It was pointed
out that the order did not require payment for time and
a half on Saturdays and defendant stated that the increased
cost to plaintiffs was not due to the order but caused by
the labor union’s insistence that time and a half be paid for
Saturday work.
23. An appeal was taken on January 25, 1945, to the head
of the Department, as provided by the contract. On Feb-
ruary 17, 1945, and again on June 4, 1945, the claim was
the subject of further correspondence between plaintiffs and
the contracting officer. On June 16, 1945, the appeal to the
head of the Department was outlined in further detail and
the argument made that the labor union at no time claimed
double pay and was not responsible for these increased costs,
otherwise the workers would not have accepted time and
a half payment for the seventh day. On August 22, 1945,
71A
the head of the Department affirmed the decision of the
contracting officer for the same reasons given by the latter
on December 29, 1944.
CLAIM FOR DELAY DAMAGES
24. Plaintiff Daugherty and defendant executed the stand-
ard Government construction contract containing Article 9
as follows:
Artictr 9. Delays—Damages.—lf the contractor re-
fuses or fails to prosecute the work, or any separable
part thereof, with such diligence as will insure its com-
pletion within the time specified in article 1, or any ex-
tension thereof, or fails to complete said work within
such time, the Government may, by written notice to the
contractor, terminate his right to proceed with the
work or such part of the work as to which there has
been delay. In such event the Government may take
over the work and prosecute the same to completion, by
contract or otherwise, and the contractor and his sure-
ties shall be liable to the Government for any excess
cost oceasioned the Government thereby. If the con-
tractor’s right to proceed is so terminated, the Govern-
ment may take possession of and utilize in completing
the work such materials, appliances, and plan as may
be on the site of the work and necessary therefor. If
the Government does not terminate the right of the
contractor to proceed, the contractor shall continue the
work, in which event the actual damages for the delay
will be impossible to determine and in lieu thereof the
contractor shall pay to the Government as fixed, agreed,
and liquidated damages for each calendar day of delay
until the work is completed or accepted the amount as
set forth in the specifications or accompanying papers
and the contractor and his sureties shall be liable for
the amount thereof: Provided, That the right of the
contractor to proceed
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.