Opposition Brief — Arrow Airways, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board

Supreme Court brief1950

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

&

INDEX - &§

Page FE

EE Hei ccn dct hakuhanatehvinercbedchataas bax ey) 1 t

i Cee hoes aiesiy inks sipt ws 66 04 8 oe ANS 4S 6.6.646.50-45 0954.00 6 1 *

Question presented ................. ARROW G4 SW EMSS OSD EO We 2 4

EE ON Gee ces 55 Ss SRARELCCEWN 646065 05S OOO EEO S 2

ASSL RS aya Sh WAG CENA ASS OA CAL SEERMROAN SOOO eenee 2 4

PPTL ee Lee Eee eee 7 x

so ELS 666 ERNE OME A SVS OSS © we pPRS COS UDOT 58 0006 12 t

CITATIONS -

CASES: f

Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v. United States, 316 U.S. ;

ee Pe TC eT OT eeT TCT TERTT CLEP ET TET >» - :

Mallory Coal Co. v. National Bituminous Coal Comm’n, 99 F.2d i

EE i eS te eee nS eee ie hee eee 8 ‘

Federal Power Commission v. Me -opolitan Edison Co., 304 U.S. &

EES EEE Ne RE Ree 10 ;

Prentis v. Atlantic Coast Line, 211 U.S. 210 ...........000000: 11 i

United Gas Pipe Line Co. v. Federal Power Commission, 181 F. 5

2d 796, pending on petition for writ of certiorari, No. 216, this é

AMEE CSREES 2b 605 4S E ENED 6055S eOREAKA + UE LOSE San 7,12 5

Fi

STATUTES: ;

Administrative Procedure Act: f

Gach kan h And hshnnde snes dey inedeuueeiens 16 t

Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 (Act of June 23, 1938, 52 Stat. 973, &

as amended, 49 U.S.C. 401 et seq.): ®

NE ce hdc hany sekpureenevalesnceveeneencua 9 i

EEE, SI RES ag a Gee 10 &

URLS Shih CRW s vav 8s Swe shes obs ckpinces butessees 10 &

NS ORAS Se ee ae ae Ss 9 E

NEESER ROARS ahah cue tes eds wane kendeneeaaahnnd 9 &

ES SERGI SG SEA Se econ On oe nN 9 4

SxSW ARASLA nc A6CKEKS ORNS a4 cbaerenscescadecees 9 &

EL Glob) ai deh Nae in dU nae doeda wc hd eekeuks 9 e

ek cast uldchnenxevonaeannsan 9 5

Miva lawhnndyxacekbeeknsces hansen tegen cased 9,11 &

MM ikiscbinthikbekshashinc«.«00stvebckonans 9 :

i CPP CkSivideduihanscaneesmaed sonnees da RANA SA 10

a er 9

Nr i rane ertn 10

eek oe ead avin codon su Caxsieddasnacs 6, 7, 8, 9, 10

SP RCALE RK KRG EK RRR GROKeK bd Ade ebeebauddneesewee 1

ii Index Continued.

Page

Commodity Exchange Act, 7 U.S.C. 8, 9 .......csecceeeeesenee 8

Federal Aleohol Administration Act, 27 U.S.C. 204(h) ......... 8

Federal Power Act:

Bee, -S2S(O), 16 USO, SOO co sivvikc ccc cciccvces vecwbewe secs 8

Federal Trade Commission Act, 15 U.S.C. 45(¢) ........--.00.. 8

Investment Company Act of 1940, 15 U.S.C. 80a-42 ............ 8

National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. 160(e), (f) .......... 8

Natural Gas Act:

See: 1060), 15 USC. TATED): veicccrcciesctectcvnetecvcces 7,8

Packers and Stockyards Act, 7 U.S.C. 194 ........cceeeeccnnes 8

Public Utility Holding Company Act of 1935, 15 U.S.C. 79x .... 8

Shots ACtGF 1060, 10 USE TT éavcccccc eve veseisccvsans 8

Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. 78y ............ 8

MISCELLANEOUS:

Civil Aeronautics Board’s Draft Release No. 38, issued April 13,

EN OE I BE seas aevevcrssncunceendeutasesiesad 3,11

Civil Aeronautics Board’s Economie Regulations, adopted May 5,

1947:

Pete. Ge. vicisews es VE PRLOVEVGEORORG OOD Re OES HESS ED VOSS RES 5

PRE BOR. £58 chs SNARE Sn CONS D ATS PEEKED Ss CdD ENED ORR OTLS 2

Bet. 208.1, 14 CFR. CIOS Bapp.) SPBT 2. ccvccrvcvsavseee 2

Civil Aeronautics Board’s Regulations:

Serial Nos.:

UE 65 65h 666 Wb. 650 6:455,5.85:056 44 Hi 55S 0bTTIRE. OVO C ES 5

ee Bete Pee eee Te Ree eR ee jd a eee ves 5

ER PUTO MUURIMOE GEO 656i. ce 6k tees ht per vccecere tcc venys 3

TS PUNTA ORINCEE LOOO ois sche se vasesscedcessceanrewsnenies 5

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

Yuthe Supreme Court of the United States

OcToBER TERM, 1950

No. 228

Arrow Airways, INc., et al., Petitioners

Ve

Civi AERONAUTICS BOARD

On Petition fer a Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court

of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit

BRIEF FOR THE CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD IN

OPPOSITION

OPINION BELOW

The per curiam opinion of the United States

Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia

Circuit (R. 54) is reported at 182 F. 2d 705.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the court of appeals was en-

tered on June 5, 1950 (R. 55). The petition for a

writ of certiorari was filed on July 28, 1950. The

jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under Sec-

tion 1006(f) of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938,

and 28 U.S. C. 1254(1).

7 = -

RCE a ORER Sgt y08 naam za ere mage UVR MILE END LENO)

Z

Z

7

Whether a court of appeals lacks jurisdiction

under Section 1006 of the Civil Aeronautics Act

of 1938 directly to review regulations of general

applicability and prospective effect adopted by the

Civil Aeronautics Board pursuant to rule-making

procedures.

2

QUESTION PRESENTED

STATUTE INVOLVED

The pertinent provisions of the Civil Aeronaut-

ics Act of 1938 (Act of June 23, 1938, 52 Stat. 973,

as amended, 49 U.S. C. 401, et seq.) appear in the

pamphlet copy of the Act submitted with this

brief.

STATEMENT

Petitioners are ‘‘large irregular air carriers”

who obtained authority to engage in the common

carriage of persons by large transport type air-

craft between any and all points in the continental |

limits of the United States, and between any such

points and points in territories of the United

States by registering with the Civil Aeronautics

Board (Board) under the blanket exemption pro-

visions of Section 292.1 of the Board’s Economic

Regulations adopted on May 5, 1947." The Board’s

regulations permit these operations subject to the

114 C. F. R. (1947 Supp.) 292.1. This part has been re-

designated and amended from time to time by rule-making

methods in various respects not here material and is currently

designated as Part 291 of the Board’s Economic Regulations.

See 14 Fed. Reg. 1879 (R. 23-39).

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

3

limitations, among others, that tariffs be filed and

observed for the services offered and performed,

and that operations between these points be con-

fined to a highly irregular or sporadic service and

should be so represented to the public.

As part of its effort to control and eliminate

flagrant tariff violations by these carriers, par-

ticularly over selected routes,’ and their practice

of utilizing so-called independent agents who is-

sued their own ‘‘exchange orders’’ or carriers’

tickets, often without regard to the tariff rates of

the performing carriers, and who held out regular

airline service between the same points as agent

for several undisclosed irregular air carriers, no

one of which acting alone could lawfully provide

such regular service, the Board, on April 13, 1949,

issued Draft Release No. 38.° By this release, the

*The majority of violations committed by these carriers

have resulted from operations between New York, Miami, and

San Juan; between New York and points on the West Coast,

particularly Los Angeles, San Francisco and Seattle; and be-

tween Seattle and points in Alaska. The concentration of

carriers over these routes has resulted from the desire for or

economic necessity of participating in this lucrative ‘‘long-

haul’’ traffie.

3 Also, as part of its endeavors to deal with these problems,

the Board has, concurrently with its issuance of Draft Release

No. 38, promulgated regulations which, adopted after notice,

consideration of written comments, and oral argument,

completely revised its exemption regulations (14 Fed. Reg.

1879, R. 23-39). Although notice of revision as proposed was

published (14 Fed. Reg. 420, R. 20-22) and copies were sent

to all holders of Letters of Registration in accordance with

5 SE kena OT a re aaa a

a

4

Board gave notice that it proposed further to

amend its regulations inter alia (1) to require the

large irregulars to reduce in writing and file with

the Board their agreements or other arrangements

with ticket agencies, brokers, or other passenger

traffic soliciting or generating instrumentalities,

and to file copies of all charters or leases of. air-

craft, (2) to require these carriers to issue and

preserve tickets and certain other written evidence

of transactions in air transportation, and (3) to

prohibit them from making agreements or ar-

rangements which would result in the conduct of

regular operations between specified points by a

the Board’s established practice, only two of the petitioners

availed themselves of the opportunity to submit written com-

ment and none of them appeared in oral argument before the

Board.

Under this revision, the validity of which petitioners do

not attack in this proceeding, the Board terminated, effective

May 20, 1949, the blanket exemption theretofore granted to

large irregulars and required these carriers to file application

for individual exemptions orders. The regulations also con-

tained ‘‘Grandfather’”’ provisions permitting holders of Let-

ters of Registration, including petitioners, to continue opera-

tions until determination of their applications for individual

exemption. Although the Board had initially proposed to re-

strict the use of common ticket agents by the large irregulars,

the revised regulations did not contain the restriction; the

findings accompanying the regulations, however, noted (R.

25, 26):

A proposal for further amendment of the regulation

dealing with this and related devices used to evade the

purpose of the regulation is being circulated to the public

for comment concurrently herewith.

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

—

5

carrier or a combination of such carriers or from

holding out such service to the public (14 Fed. Reg.

1895, R. 42-45). A press release issued by the

Board on April 18, 1949 also stated the substance

of the proposed regulation (R. 39-42). None of

the petitioners in this case availed themselves of

‘the opportunity to comment upon the proposals

contained in the Draft Release.

After consideration of the comments received

from interested persons, the Board, on November

4, 1949, promulgated Regulation Serial Nos. ER-

153 (R. 46-48) and ER-154 here involved (R. 48-

53). Regulation ER-153 amends Part 242 of the

Board’s Economic Regulation which relates to the

content and form of reports required of irregu-

lars; the amendment requires the filing with the

Board of all contracts entered into between car-

riers and ticket agents, and further requires the

submission with the carrier’s quarterly flight re-

port of all publicity material issued by the carrier

during the reporting period (R. 46-48). Regula-

tion ER-154 further amends Part 291 of the Eeo-

nomic Regulations, the general exemption regu-

lation dealing with irregular carriers (supra, p.

2, fn. 1); this amendment (1) prescribes the

form of tickets to be used by irregular air carriers,

(2) provides that passengers should be transported

only on the carrier’s tickets issued by the carrier

or its acknowledged agent, (3) requires that writ-

ten contracts be entered into with those ticket and

EYL ESE LBL OED PLES

CE OEE ORO ELE OL SS Nt TI LN LIE = se agg

6

travel agents from whom traffic was accepted, that

settlements of accounts between carriers and

agents be made only upon written invoice contain-

ing certain specified information, and that copies

of such contracts and certain other information

be filed with the Board, and (4) forbids the car-

riers from entering into agreements and arrange-

ments whereby regular services were offered or

performed between the same points by the com-

bined services of the participating carriers (R.

48-53). These regulations were to be effective

December 10, 1949 and applied to the operations

of approximately 95 large irregular carriers.

Invoking Section 1006 of the Civil Aeronautics

Act of 1938 and Section 10 of the Administrative

Procedure Act, petitioners sought review of these

regulations by filing a petition in the Court of Ap-

peals for the District of Columbia Circuit (R. 2-5).

In their petition, petitioners alleged that the regu-

lations attempt to regulate ticket agents over which

the Board is without jurisdiction; that the regu-

lations differed substantially from Draft Release

No. 38 and hence that petitioners were not given

the notice required by the Administrative Proced-

ure Act; that the regulation involved an ‘‘arbi-

trary, unlawful and improper exercise of [the

Board’s] rule-making power’’; and that the regu-

lations limit the licenses previously granted cer-

tain of the petitioners and thus ‘‘deprives them

in part of vested property rights, without notice

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

7"

7

and hearing, by a proceeding to which [they] were

not parties”? (R. 3-4). The court below, in a per :

curiam opinion, dismissed the petition stating that

the provisions of Section 1006, governing review

of the Board’s orders ‘‘is not sufficiently different |

from that in the Natural Gas Act to warrant our

distinguishing this from United Gas Pipe Line Co.

v. Federal Power Commission, [181 F. 2d 796, de-

cided April 5, 1950]’’ (R. 54).

ARGUMENT

1. The question presented by the instant case,

i.e., whether courts of appeals have jurisdiction

directly to review general rules and regulations

issued by the Board, is the same as that involved

in United Gas Pipe Line Co. v. Federal Power

Commission, pending on petition for writ of cer- g

tiorari, No. 216, this Term.

The court below was, we believe, justified in

holding in the present case that the differences be-

tween the review provisions of Section 1006 of the

Civil Aeronautics Act and those of the Natural

Gas Act were not of sufficient materiality to war-

rant a different conclusion. It is true that Sec-

tion 1006 differs from Natural Gas Act’s Section

19(b) (15 U.S.C. 717r(b)) in that it provides that x

the Board shall file with the court a ‘‘transcript of é

the record, if any, upon which the order com- |

plained of was entered’”’ (italics supplied) and

does not specifically provide that the reviewing

SEN RR FIN OTE oO Sta 8 eNO EO

PEL LEME LO EE EET HARES RE

EMAL ERP EE CI LTS SSR EI PEI aa |

8

court may order the Board to take additional evi-

dence.* These differences, we believe, are, however,

overbalanced by the fundamental parallelism be-

tween Section 1006 and the provisions for review

by courts of appeals in various other regulatory

statutes, of which Section 313(b) of the Federal

Power Act (16 U.S.C. 8251) and Section 19(b)

of the Natural Gas Act are typical, and

which, it has become accepted, preclude direct re-

view of general rules and regulations. Mallory

Coal Co. v. National Bituminous Coal Com’n, 99

F. 2d 399, 405-406 (C.A. D.C.). Moreover, the leg-

islative history of the Civil Aeronautics Act does

not disclose any discussion of this phase of the

review provisions of Section 1006 nor does it there

appear that Congress’ attention was directed to

the question here presented. This absence of con-

4 Section 1006 further differs from Section 19(b) in that

Section 1006 does not require a person seeking review to have

been a party to the proceeding before the agency nor does it

make an application for rehearing to the agency a condition

precedent to judicial review. The presence of such require-

ments in the Natural Gas Act, however, merely serve to rein-

force the result under that Act without weakening the con-

clusion here, since these requirements are omitted from vir-

tually all of the review provisions cited in footnote 5, infra.

5 See, e.g., the review provisions of the Federal Trade Com-

mission Act (15 U.S.C. 45(c)); the Securities Act of 1933

(15 U.S.C. 77i) ; the Securities & Exchange Act of 1934 (15

U.S.C. 78y); the Public Utility Holding Company Act of

1935 (15 U.S.C. 79x); the Investment Company Act of 1940

(15 U.S.C. 80a-42); the National Labor Relations Act (29

U.S.C. 160(e), (f£)); the Federal Aleohol Administration Act

(27 U.S.C. 204(h)); the Packers & Stockyards Act (7 U.S.C.

194) ; and the Commodity Exchange Act (7 U.S.C. 8, 9).

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

9

gressional discussion seems to indicate that the

review provided in that section was intended to

conform to the consistent pattern of review by

courts of appeals followed in these other statutes.

Other provisions of the Civil Aeronautics Act

buttress this conclusion by differentiating sharply

between orders, which are made reviewable under

Section 1006, and rules and regulations. Thus,

Section 205(a) empowers the Board to issue and

amend such ‘‘orders’’ and to make such ‘‘rules’’

and ‘‘regulations”’ as it shall deem necessary to the

effective performance of its functions. The Board

is authorized to promulgate rules and regulations

to be observed by various classifications of air car-

riers established under Section 416, the section

from which petitioners’ operating authority is

derived. Rules and regulations are specified as

the method by which safety and operating stand-

ards of genera? applicability shall be imposed.

Section 601. Regulations are required with re-

spect to the filing and posting of tariffs (Section

403(a)), and regulations are contemplated with

respect to other similar actions of general appli-

eability and future effect not required to be taken

on the basis of a record. On the other hand, the

Board in certain instances involving proceedings

to which there are named parties is required to act

by order.’ Orders are contemplated in all cases

®See, e.g., Sections 408(b), 408(e), 409(a), 411, 412(b),

and 1002(e).

—— -~ ——

10

in which adjudicatory action is directed to a par-

ticular carrier or in the various other determina-

tions required to be made upon the basis of a ree-

ord,’ a requirement not imposed in any case in

which the Board is authorized to act by rule or

regulation. The limited nature of ‘‘orders,’’ in

contradistinction to rules and regulations, is em-

phasized by Section 1005(f), which immediately

precedes Section 1006, and prescribes that:

Every order of the [Board] shall set forth

the findings of fact upon which it is based, and

shall be served upon the parties to the pro-

ceeding and the persons affected by such order.

Read in light of these provisions, it would seem

that direct review by courts of appeals under See-

tion 1006 is limited to adjudicatory orders entered

in a proceeding to which there are designated par-

ties and predicated upon findings made in that

proceeding, and that that Section like the review

provisions of most regulatory statutes, precludes

direct review of general rules and regulations. Cf.

Federal Power Commission v. Metropolitan Edi-

son Co., 304 U. S. 375, 384.°

7 See, e.g., Sections 401, 402 (issuance, amendment, suspen-

sion and revocation of certificates and permits authorizing air

transportation) ; Section 609 (amendment, suspension and

revocation of airman and other safety certificates).

8 Cases such as Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v.

United States, 316 U. S. 407, are distinguishable, as we have

shown in the brief in opposition in No. 216, pp. 15-16,

which is hereby incorporated by reference.

eR ESI E ——S

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

—,

11

2. Contrary to petitioners’ implication (Pet. 2,

4), the regulations here attacked involve not ad-

judication but rule-making, and consequently no

hearing was required prior to the issuance of these

regulations, nor are they reviewable at this time

under Section 1006 of the Act. Section 416 of the

Civil Aeronautics Act, pursuant to which the

Board acted in issuing these regulations (R. 45), ;

specifically authorizes it to prescribe operating

rules by ‘‘regulation’’ for the various classifica-

tions of carriers, such as petitioners, established

thereunder.” Moreover, the regulations on their

face undertake to govern the future conduct of an

entire segment of the airline industry,’ and their

promulgation was predicated upon consideration

of regulatory policy of future applicability." Such

regulations clearly involve rule making, not adju-

dication based upon the past conduct of any irreg-

ular air carrier. Prentis v. Atlantic Coast Line,

211 U.S. 210, 226. Finally, petitioner’s implica-

tion is predicated on the erroneous assumption

that the regulations modified their “‘license.’? In

* Petitioners did not even submit comments upon the pro-

posal contained in Draft Release 38, much less request a

hearing. See supra, p. 5.

‘There were approximately 140 Letters of Registration

outstanding to large irregular carriers when Draft Release 38

was circulated for comment.

"As shown in No. 216, pp. 11-13 and fn. 8, neither the

Administrative Procedure Act nor the Constitution requires

an adjudicatory hearing in these circumstances. d

-

12

fact, however, no such modification resulted ; car-

riers such as petitioners, are still free to conduct

all operations heretofore authorized with the regu-

lations merely prescribing methods by which those

operations should hereafter be conducted.”

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully sub-

mitted that the petition for a writ of certiorari

should be denied.

Pup B. PERLMAN,

Solicitor General.

H. G. Morison,

Assistant Attorney General.

Pau. A. SWEENEY,

MELVIN RICHTER,

Attorneys.

Emory T. NUNNELEY, JR.,

General Counsel.

JoHN H. WANNER,

Associate General Counsel.

O. D. OZMENT,

Attorney, Civil Aeronautics Board.

Aveaust 1950.

12 As in United Gas Pipe Line, we do not suggest that these

regulations are completely beyond judicial scrutiny but rather

that they are not directly reviewable under Section 1006. See

brief in opposition in No. 216, fn. 12, p. 15.

w U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1950—902612/P.0. 98

BLEED THROUGH POOR COPY

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.