Appendix A — FPC v. Texaco Inc.
Supreme Court brief1974
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX A
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL POWER COMMISSION
(18 CFR 2.75)
Before Commissioners: John N. Nassikas, Chairman;
Albert B. Brooke, Jr., Pinkney Walker,
and Rush Moody, Jr.
Procedure for Certificating ) Docket No. R-441
New Producer Sales of Natural Gas)
ORDER NO. 455
STATEMENT OF POLICY RELATING TO
OPTIONAL PROCEDURE FOR CERTIFICATING
NEW PRODUCER SALES OF NATURAL GAS
(Issued August 3, 1972)
1. Pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act, 5
U.S.C. 551, et seg. (1967) (APA) and Sections 4,5,7,8,14,15,
and 16 of the Natural Gas Act', the Commission issues rules
fixing the terms and conditions of an optional procedure under
which it will issue permanent certificates for, and will otherwise
regulate sales of natural gas subject to the Commission’s juris-
diction nationwide, including, but not limited to, the Southern
'52 Stat. 822, 823, 824, 825, 828, 829, 830; 56 Stat. 83, 84; 61 Stat.
459; 76 Stat. 72; 15 U.S.C. 717c, 717d, 717f, 717g. 717m, 7170.
— - |
2a
Louisiana, Permian Basin, Other Southwest, Hugoton
Anadarko, Texas Gulf Coast, Appalachian and Illinois Basins,
Rocky Mountain areas, and all other areas. The rates embodied
in certificates issued pursuant to the rules and amendments set
forth herein will be firm rates, not subject to refund obligation,
as will be more fully explained hereinafter.
2. As we state in the notice issued in this proceeding on
April 6, 1972, (37 FR. 7345, 4/13/72), data available to the
Commission indicates a worsening of the gap between natural
gas demand and supply.
3. The recent report on “National Supply and Demand
1971-1990,” prepared by the Federal Power Commission’s
Bureau of Natural Gas (BNG) shows the level of “unsatisfied
demand” for gas increasing from 3.6 trillion cubic feet in 1975
to 9.5 trillion cubic feet in 1980, 13.7 trillion cubic feet in
1985 and 17.1 trillion cubic feet in 1990.2 Additionally, it is
estimated that between 1971 and 1990, the United States will
require 186.4 trillion cubic feet more gas than will be available,
even after making liberal allowances for pipeline imports, lique-
a gas imports, coal gas, Alaskan gas and reformed
gas.
4. The Future Requirements Committee (FRC) estimates
that the natural gas requirements for the United States will
increase from about 28.2 trillion cubic feet in 1971 to 33.9
trillion cubic feet in 1975.4 Based on information conceming
presently contracted or reasonably assured supplies, the FRC
estimates that the gap between the potential demand for gas
2National Gas Supply and Demand 1971-1990, and Bureau of Natural
Gas, Federal Power Commission, February 1972, p. 3.
3 Ibid, p.3.
4 Future Gas Requirements of the United States, Future Requirements
Committee, Vol. No. 4, October 1971, p. 3.
_-
3a
and the most likely available supply will increase from .9 trillion
cubic feet in 1971 to 3.9 trillion cubic feet in 1975.5
5. The assurance of adequate supplies of natural gas can
mitigate the damage being done to the nation’s environment.
Natural gas is the cleanest burning and least polluting of all the
fossil fuels.
6. Any further aggravation of the gas supply problem
also portends grave implications for the nation’s economic
objectives. Between 1947 and 1970, the nation increased its
annual consumption of energy from 32.9 quadrillion Btu to
68.8 quadrillion Btu, with the share of the total being con-
tributed by natural gas increasing from 13.8 percent in 1947 to
32.5 percent in 1970. During this period, the nation’s real
output of goods and services more than doubled and its real
income per capita increased by about one half. It is inescapable
that the continued growth and productivity of the US.
economy requires adequate and reliable supplies of energy, in-
cluding adequate and reliable supplies of natural gas.
7. Moreover, our efforts to hold consumer costs to the
lowest reasonable level can only be eroded if the nation is
forced to rely more heavily on substitute or supplemental
supplies of gas than would be required if our domestic natural
gas resources were developed in a timely manner. New base load
supplies of substitute or supplemental gas will be available to
consumers only at costs significantly higher than the prices of
currently available domestic wellhead supplies.’ The price per
Btu for many primary fuels is greater than the price per Btu for
natural gas. This comparison is especially unfavorable to the
SIbid., p.3.
6 Mineral Industry Surveys, Petroleum Statement Monthly, Bureau of
Mines, Department of Interior, December 1970, p. 37.
T$ee, e.g., Distrigas Corp., Docket No. CP70-196, et al., opinion Nos.
613 and 613A, issued March 9 and June 7, 1972, respectively, Columbia
LNG Corp., et al, Docket Nos. CP71-68, et al., opinion No. 622, issued
June 28, 1972.
. ,. o
alternative fossil fuels when the costs of storage, handling and
pollution control are included. In summary, if our domestic
natural gas resources are not developed in a timely manner and
consumers of natural gas are forced to satisfy a commensurately
larger portion of their energy requirements by using either
substitute or supplemental gas supplies, ¢.g., imported liquefied
natural gas, propane, reformed hydrocarbons, gasified coal,
imported natural gas, or other fossil fuels, the net effect
higher energy costs throughout the economy, with resulting
inflationary pressures. Higher prices for domestic gas, if paid for
new supplies, will result in a cheaper mix of energy supplies and
thus represent a better alternative.
8. In view of these facts, we are unwilling to leave
untested the producing capacity of the United States. Ou
responsibility to the consumers of natural gas, to assure reliable
and adequate supplies at the lowest reasonable cost, impels us
to that course of action best calculated tospur domestic
exploration and development. To this end, we seek to provide
two incentives to domestic production, both fully congruous
with consumer protection. First, we will certificate sales of gas
not previously deliverable to the interstate market at prices
which are shown to be in the public interest. Second, to the
extent possible, we will lessen rate uncertainty which has
prevailed since the early 1960’s.
9. Studies available to the Commission indicate that vast
quantities of natural gas remain undeveloped in the United
States. Estimates range from 1178 trillion cubic feet to 2100
trillion cubic feet. We seek accelerated development of that
portion of this potential supply which is economically recover-
able, for in development of domestic reserves lies the best
assurance of reliable supplies at the lowest reasonable cost.
10. As will be stated more fully hereinafter, this policy
statement and the optional procedures herein established are
directed at supplies of gas not available to the interstate market
prior to April 6, 1972. The rulemaking does not envisage nor
authorize rate increases for gas already flowing in interstate
commerce through wells drilled prior to April 6, 1972. As new
supplies are found or reduced to a deliverable state for
_—
Sa
dedication to the interstate consumer market, the optional
ures here set forth will become available, but because of
the limited scope of this rulemaking, consumers will not pay
higher rates except for new supplies, and then only to that
extent that the contracting parties establish on the record that
the price to be paid is required by the public interest.
11. While comments were received from various persons,
and associations, we take particular note of those of the
Departments of Commerce and Interior and the Environmental
Protection Agency. The Department of Commerce suggested
certain amendments to the rule as noticed, which have been
adopted here, and expressed support for the proposed rule-
making to encourage gas exploration and development. The
Department of the Interior likewise suggested certain modifica-
tions in the rule, many of which have been accomplished by our
action here, and stated, “(t)he proposed rule-making order in
Docket No. 441 is a strong step toward providing the necessary
incentive that will stimulate exploration and development of
new gas supplies. ...”” The Environmental Protection Agency
concurred “in the FPC’s efforts to try to improve the gas supply
position through procedures which will allow for increased
reliance on market incentives.”
12. Ninety-three persons, groups, Commissions or associa-
tions filed comments or suggestions in response to the Notice of
April 6, 1972.8 A number of those responding to the notice
gaised a general question of the lawfulness of the rule as
| proposed. We shall discuss procedural issues first and then
discuss seriatim the suggestions and comments applicable to the
various provisions of the rules.
PROCEDURAL ISSUES
13. An understanding of the relationship between the
optional certification procedure we adopt herein and area rates
must be based on an appreciation of the interplay between the
Section 7 certificate and Sections 4 and 5 rate provisions of the
Natural Gas Act (Act). That relationship is particularly
84 list of said respondents is contained in the Appendix hereto.
——
important insofar as regulation of producers’ sales of natural gas
in interstate commerce is concerned.
14. Immediately following the issuance of the Supreme
Court’s decision in Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Wisconsin, 34]
U.S. 672 (1954), holding that sales of natural gas by producer
for resale in interstate commerce are subject to the Act, the
Commission initiated producer regulation by issuing Order Nos.
174 (13 FPC 1194), 174-A (13 FPC 1255), and 174-B (13 FPC
1576), requiring independent producers to file applications for
certificates of public convenience and necessity, pursuant to
Section 7 of the Act, and to file their contracts, under which
interstate sales were being made or were proposed to be
initiated, as rate schedules pursuant to Section 4 of the Act.
15. The Commission attempted individual company cost-
of-service rate regulation following the issuance of Orders 174,
174A and 174B. The resultant delays and uncertainty were of
such magnitude that this system of producer rate regulation was
Clearly not in the public interest. Before this was fully
recognized, contracts were filed in the CATCO case [The
Atlantic Refining Co. v. Public Service Commission of New
York, 360 U.S. 378 (1959)] providing for an initial price of
21.4 cents per Mcf.
16. Because of opposition to the increased initial price,
the Commission first issued a certificate authorizing the sale
upon the condition that the producers could charge no more
than 17 cents per Mcf. Since the producers had not commenced
delivery of gas, they exercised their prerogative under the Act
and declined to accept a certificate conditioned to 17 cents.
After rehearing, the Commission issued a certificate (17 FPC
880 (1957)) authorizing the sale at the proposed initial price of
21.4 cents per Mcf because the Commission believed it was
important to make certain that the large volume of gas involved
(approximately 1.3 trillion cubic feet) be obtained for the
interstate market. Additionally, the Commission found that
consumers would be protected because of the rate sections of
the Act which would enable it to reduce the price prospectively
if the 21.4-cent price should prove to be unjust and unreasor-
able after a hearing held under Section 5 of the Act.
6a
Ta
17. The Commission’s order was ultimately appealed by
the New York Commission and Eastern distributor companies
to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reversed the order,
ruling that the Commission was under a duty to hold the line on
prices under the certificate provisions of the Act pending the
outcome of rate proceedings instituted under Sections 4 and
5 of the Act (CATCO, supra, 360 U.S. at 388-390). The Court
pointed out that rate proceedings are normally quite time
consuming and that the public should not have to pay the 21.4
cent rate while a just and reasonable rate was being determined.
18. A large number of Commission orders, which had
granted certificates approving initial rates on the theory that the
prices could ultimately be reduced after the completion of
subsequent rate proceedings, were reversed by various United |
States courts of appeals.? After the courts’ reversal of Commis-
sion orders, the Commission instituted a uniform program of
conditioning producer prices in certificate proceedings so as to
fix initial prices for new sales to the level of previously
certificated sales. The courts consistently affirmed this rationale
employed by the Commission,'® which was a result of its
refusal to consider the justness and reasonableness of the price
at the time the certificate was issued.
9United Gas Improvement Co. v. F-P.C., 283 F.2d 817 (9th Cir.
1960), cert. denied, 365 U.S. 881; United Gas Improvement Co. v. F-P.C.,
287 F.2d 159 (10th Cir. 1961); United Gas Improvement Co. v. F-P.C.,
290 F.2d 147 (Sth Cir. 1961), cert. denied, 366 US. 965; United Gas
Improvement Co. v. F.P.C., 290 F.2d 133 (Sth Cir. 1961), cert. denied,
386 US. 823; P.S.C. of New York v. F-P.C., 287 F.2d 146 (DC. Cir.
1960), cert. denied, 365 US. 880.
10 signal Oil Co. v. F-P.C., 238 F.2d 771 (3rd Cir. 1956), cert. denied,
353 US. 923; P.S.C. of New York v. FP.C. 329 F.2d 242 (DC. Cir.
1964), cert. denied, 377 U.S. 963, affirming “in-line” price determinations
but requiring further consideration of refund conditions; People of State
of California v. F_P.C., 353 F.2d 16, (9th Cir. 1965); F-P.C. v. Sunray DX
Of Co., 391 US. 9 (1968).
——
19. The Commission adhered to a separation of Certificate
and rate issues when it embarked on area rate regulation. Sales
were certificated, but conditioned so that the just and Treason.
able rate to be charged was not established until final judicial
review of the applicable area rate decision was completed.
20. After the Commission had issued its first area rate
decision involving the Permian Basin area (opinion No. 468,
Area Rate Proceeding, 34 FPC 158 (1965), aff'd, Permian Basin
Area Rate Cases, 390 U.S. 747 (1968), efforts were made by
producers to obtain initial prices, pursuant to Section 7, in
excess of the just and reasonable rates fixed, pursuant to
Section 4 and 5, in the area rate proceeding. The Commission |
held that area rates would be used to establish the level of the _
initial rate for new sales, and, therefore, that it would not hold
a hearing under Section 7 to determine new “in-line” rates once
just and reasonable rates had been established. The Commis
sion’s position was upheld in Phillips Petroleum Co. v. F.PC,
405 F.2d 6 (10th Cir. 1969), and Hunt Oil Co. v. F-P.C., 424
F.2d 982 (Sth Cir. 1970), even though the producers had
contended that they should be permitted to introduce evidence
showing that their 1968, 1969 and 1970 costs had increased so
as to require a higher price than the rate level fixed on 1960
costs by the Commission in the Permian Basin area rate
proceeding. The court said the producers were attempting ina
Section 7 proceeding to make a collateral attack on the area
rate proceeding, and that they should ask for a reopening of the
area rate proceeding if the prices established therein were
inadequate (424 F.2d at 98).
21. At the present time, the Commision has completed
area rate hearings in all but the Rocky Mountain area!! and has
fixed just and reasonable rates for all the major producing areas
8a
'\4req Rates for the Rocky Mountain Area, Docket No. R-425,
“‘Notice Instituting Proposed Rulemaking and Order Prescribing
Procedure”, issued July 15, 1971.
9a
in the lower 48 States.!? Court review is pending as to all of the
recent area rate opinions! > except Order No. 411 involving the
Appalachian and Illinois Basin areas.
22. Because our area rate orders remain under attack, at
the present time a producer, even if he is willing to sell at the
rates fixed in such opinions, does not know that those rates will
be affirmed on appeal. Although in the Sunray DX case supra,
391 U.S. 9, the Supreme Court held that a producer cannot be
required to refund below the permanently-certificated rate, the
Supreme Court was not in that case ruling on the question of
whether a certificated rate, based upon an area rate invalidated
through court review, would necessarily be impregnable, and
the certificates so indicate. Consequently, there is no assurance
at the present time that a producer may not ultimately have to
refund some of an initial rate based on a just and reasonable
121n addition to the Permian Basin decision supra, the Commission has
instituted a new Permian Basin proceeding (Area Rate Proceeding
(Permian Basin Area), Docket No. AR70-1, 45 FPC 192 (1971)) which is
awaiting an Examiner’s initial decision. In addition to the first Southern
Louisiana Area Rate Proceeding (Opinion No. 546, Area Rate Proceeding
(Southern Louisiana Area), 40 FPC 530 (1968), aff'd sub nom. Austral Oil
Co. (Southern Louisiana Area Rate Cases) v. F.P.C., 428 F.2d 407 (Sth
Cir. 1970), cert. denied, 400 U.S. 950), the Commission has issued a
second decision regarding the Southern Louisiana area (Opinion No. 598,
Area Rate Proceeding (Southern Louisiana Area), Docket Nos. AR61-2, et
al., issued July 16, 1971). Area rate opinions haye also been issued for four
other important producing areas: Opinion No. 607, Area Rate Proceeding
(other Southwest Area), Docket Nos. AR67-1, ef al, issued October 29,
1971; Opinion No. 595, Area Rate Proceeding (Texas Gulf Coast Area),
Docket Nos. AR64-2, ef al, issued May 6, 1971; Opinion No. 586, Area
Rate Proceeding (Hugoton-Anadarko Area), Docket Nos. AR64-1, et al,
issued September 18, 1970, 44 FPC 761; and Order No. 411, Area Rates
for the Appalachian and Illinois Basin Areas, Docket No. R-371, issued
October 2, 1970, 44 FPC 1112, and Order No. 411-A, issued October 30,
1970, 44 FPC 1334.
13Qpinion No. 586 in Ninth Circuit No. 71-1036, Opinion No. 595 in
CADC 71-1828; Opinion No. 598 in Fifth Circuit Nos. 71-2761; et al;
Opinion No. 607 in Fifth Circrcuit Nos. 72-1114, et al.
10a
determination and upon which the producer relied when it
dedicated a new gas supply to the interstate market. In short,
after some 18 years of producer regulation, the producer does
not know how much it can lawfully charge for sales of natural
gas in interstate commerce nor how much it will get if it
develops and sells new gas to the interstate market. The
producer knows for sure only that once it sells in interstate
commerce it cannot stop deliveries.
23. This uncertainty has impeded domestic exploration
and development. We acknowledge that Section 5 of the
Natural Gas Act prevents the Commission from granting
sanctity of contract, and that a degree of uncertainty will
remain so long as Congress withholds action on sanctity of
contract legislation. We continue to urge the necessity for
sanctity of contract legislation, in the firm belief that Con
gressional action in this field will establish a reasonable level of
prices consistent with adequate service to the consumer by
encouraging development of required supplies and by avoiding
uncertainty factors in producer pricing, thereby attracting
capital at risk at a lower return than would otherwise prevail.
24. To those who have commented on our rulemaking to
suggest that we exceed our authority in contemplating perms
nent certification of producer sales at firm rates not subject to
refund or reduction in later area rate proceedings, we answer by
our foregoing acknowledgment of the supremacy of Section 5
over our administrative regulations and determinations. We
cannot bind a future Commission not to invoke the prospective
operation of Section 5, nor do we attempt to do so. We do,
however, announce our policy to examine the justness and
reasonableness of proposed rates in Section 7 proceeding
instituted under this Section, thus avoiding the uncertainty of
reserving rate determinations for subsequent Section4 or
Section 5 action. To the extent that this Commission can grant
certainty of rates, we do so. Congressional enactment of
sanctity of contract legislation is essential to assure that
contracts dedicating new supplies to interstate markets will not
be abrogated by future commissions.
25. Since mid-1969, the Commission has attempted in
several ways to obtain new supplies of gas for the interstate
market. One was the announcement in Paragraph 12 of its
Statement of Policy in Docket No. R-389A issued July 17,
1970, 35 Fed. Reg. 11638, of its willingness to consider
applications proposing to make sales at initial prices above area
rate ceilings. Relatively few filings have been made under
Paragraph 12, because certificates thereunder are conditioned to
later area rate determinations and are therefore subject to the
same uncertainties as have impeded domestic development in
the past.
26. Another of our efforts to alleviate the gas shortage
was the authorization for emergency purchases. Among other
features, this program involved experimentation with the use of
an expedited certification procedure which encompassed a
determination of a lawful rate. In proceedings under Orders 402
(May 6, 1970, 43 FPC 707), 418 (December 10, 1970, 44 FPC
1574) and 431 (April 15, 1971, 45 FPC 570), all certification
and rate issues are determined in one proceeding. Since the
effective date of Order 431, we have issued 62 certificates at
prices ranging from 26¢ to 40¢/Mcf. Approximately 500 Bcf of
gas have been brought to the interstate market through this
procedure. Neither the Order 431 procedure itself, nor any
certificate issued under it has been the subject of legal attack,
and we have been able to act upon certificate applications by
final order issued, on the average, less than two months after
the application was filed. The results of our experiment strongly
indicate that producer rate regulation can be efficiently
managed, in the public interest, by reaching certificate and rate
issues in one proceeding, particularly if we use the abbreviated
hearing process open to us under our statutes and rules.
27. The disadvantages to the Order 431 sales which have
been made under the foregoing emergency regulations are two:
First, on the whole no long-term dedications of reserves to
pipeline companies have resulted from such sales. While the
temporary sales have been of value in reducing pipeline and
distributor curtailments in deliveries which otherwise would
have resulted, the fact remains that the gas reserve life indices of
the interstate pipeline have continued to decline. Second, Order
431 procedures are available only if the pipeline purchaser is in
an emergency gas shortage situation.
12a
28. These two disadvantages make Order 431 procedures
an incomplete answer to the gas supply problem. Long-term
dedications are essential to reliability and continuity of supply,
and to pipeline financing. And secondly, we seek to prevent
emergency conditions from developing, rather than responding
after an emergency develops.
29. It should be made clear that the optional procedure is
not intended to supersede the procedures currently being
followed in the area rate proceedings. The area rate opinions
have established rate levels for new and flowing gas sales that
are currently being made, and parties may continue to operate
under these procedures. This is an alternate procedure which is
available if the producer is willing to forego certain benefits of
area rate proceedings, in exchange for certainty of its certifi-
cated price, as determined at the certificate stage.
30. As the Supreme Court pointed out in FPC v. Hope
Natural Gas Co., 320 U.S. at 602, 64 S.Ct. at 28, and in FPC y.
Natural Gas Pipeline Co., 315 U.S. 575 at 586 (1942), the
Commission must make “‘pragmatic adjustments” in rate pro-
cedures to stimulate the discovery and dedication of gas
supplies to the interstate market.
31. By the procedures adopted herein, the Commission
now seeks to stimulate the immediate introduction of new,
long-term gas supplies into the interstate market by such a
pragmatic adjustment. Thus it is proceeding under its certificate
authority under Section 7 of the Act. It is unquestioned that
the Commission is authorized to vary the initial terms and
conditions of a contract for the sale of natural gas in interstate
commerce by Section 7 of the Act. Section 7(e) of the Act
authorizes the Commission “to attach to the issuance of the
certificate * * * such reasonable terms and conditions as the
public convenience and necessity may require.” In CATCO
(supra) the Supreme Court held that the “Act does not require
a determination of just and reasonable rates in a §7 proceeding
as it does in one under either §4 or §5.” Jd. at 390-1. However,
neither the Act, or any decision, prohibits consideration of
whether the rate is just and reasonable.
—
13a
32. In determining the terms and conditions under which
it will issue certificates under Section 7, the Commission need
not fix such terms and conditions in each proceeding, but may
promulgate those of a general nature under its rulemaking
authority.
The Commission’s rulemaking authority emanates from Section
16 of the Act, 15 U.S.C. §7170, which es pertinent part
that:
The Commission shall have power to perform any and
all acts, and to prescribe, issue, make, amend, and
rescind such orders, rules, and regulations as it may
find necessary or appropriate to carry out the
provisions of this act. * * *!4
33. The Supreme Court has explicitly held “‘that the
statutory requirement for a hearing under §7 does not preclude
the Commission from particularizing statutory standards
through the rule-making process ***” F PC. v. Texaco, 377
U.S. 33, 39 (1964). The Court held that the Commission may
properly conclude that protection of the consumer interests will
be best achieved if done at the threshhold of certification, citing
legislative history which is particularly pertinent to the Com-
ission’s purpose in promulgating an optional procedure
herein:
* ** The bill when enacted will have the effect of
giving the Commission an opportunity to scrutinize
the financial set-up, the adequacy of the gas reserves,
the feasibility and adequacy of the proposed services,
14This section of the Act has been broadly construed by the Courts.
Mesa Petroleum Co. v. F.P.C., 441 F.2d 182 (CAS, 1971). In Mesa, the
Fifth Circuit stated the Commission’s agency discretion is at its zenith
when enforcing its regulatory authority. /d at 187. Compare Niagara
Mohawk Power Corp. v. F.P.C., 379 F.2d 153 (CADC, 1967). See also
- EPC. v. Tennessee Gas Transmission Co., 371 US. 145, 150-5 (1962);
Superior Oil Co! v. F-P.C., 322 F.2d 601, 610 (CA9, 1963), Certiorari
denied, 377 U.S. 922 (1964), rehearing denied, 377 U.S. 960.
l4a
and the characteristics of the rate structure in
connection with the proposed construction or exten-
sion at a time when such vital matters can readily be
modified as the public interest may
demand * * * [emphasis supplied] (H.R. Rep. No.
1290, 77th Cong., Ist Sess., pp. 2-3, and see S. Rep.
No. 948, 77th Cong., 2nd Sess., pp. 1-2).
34. Recently, the United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit stated that “many of the same
regulatory. objectives which can be attained through ad hoc
proceedings under Section 4, 5 and 7 can also be attained
through the issuance of general rules under Section 16.” City of
Chicago v. F.P.C., 458 F.2d 731, 743 (CADC, No. 23740)
decided December 2, 1971, cert. denied April 17, 1972.
35. In affirming Permian (supra) the Supreme Court noted
(360 U.S., at 772):
The Commission quite reasonably believed that the
terms of any exceptional relief should be developed
as its experience with area regulation lengthens. More-
over, area regulation of producer prices is avowedly
still experimental in its terms and uncertain in its
ultimate consequence; it is entirely possible that the
Commission may later find that its area rate structure
for the Permian Basin requires significant modifica-
tion. We cannot now hold that, in these circum-
stances, the Commission’s broad guarantees of special
relief were inadequate or excessively imprecise.
(Footnotes omitted).
36. The express purpose of this rulemaking is to provide
an alternate procedural framework for producer rate regulation
which will stimulate and accelerate domestic exploration and
development of natural gas reserves. That some modification is
wn,
15a
necessary and required under the present circumstances of a
serious shortage of natural gas can no longer be denied. Public
Service Commission of the State of New York v. F.P.C., CADC,
No. 71-1161, decided March 29, 1972; Louisiana Power & Light
Co. v. United Gas Pipe Line Co., CAS, No. 71-2550, decided
January 14, 1972; F.P.C. v. Louisiana Power & Light Co.,
US. (decided June 7, 1972); Southern Louisiana
Area Rate Cases (Austral Oil Co. v. F.P.C.) 428 F.2d 407 (CAS,
1970); Hunt Oil Co. v. F.P.C., supra.
37. Of particular significance to the instant proceedings is
the District of Columbia Circuit’s recent opinion in Public
Service Commission for the State of New York v. F.P.C., supra.
In approving the Commission’s rule, that a pipeline’s advance
payments to producers for gas to be delivered at a future date
may be included in the pipeline’s rate base, the Court stated
(Slip op. at 12):
It appears to us that what the FPC is attempting
to do in this area is to reach an accommodation of
conflicting interests, through experimentation, that
will result in the proper alleviation of the gas short-
age. In doing so, we think that the FPC is making
policy decisions of the type it was created to make,
and we are reluctant to disturb them. In this very
difficult area of rate-making, when it is uncertain
what will be the ultimate agency determination, and
when it is as yet unknown what will be the results
and ramifications of the experimental policies
adopted by the agency, we feel that the FPC has
demonstrated, as adequately as can be expected
under the circumstances, the basis for its actions, and
we may thus defer to the expertise of the FPC in this
matter. (Footnotes ommitted).
| 38. Finally, as the Supreme Court said in Permian (390
US., at 790):
We must reiterate that the breadth and complexity of
the Commission’s responsibilities demand that it be
16a
given every reasonable opportunity to formulate
methods of regulation appropriate for the solution of
its intensely practical difficulties.
39. Our action in establishing a procedural framework for
Commission action in the field of certificate and rate regulation
is taken under our general power of rulemaking as bestowed by
§553 of the Administrative Procedure Act and Section 16 of
the Natural Gas Act. Our general statement of policy, and rules
of agency procedure and practice here adopted, are not subject
to requirements of notice and hearing. §553(b). In recognition
of the significance of the matters here dealt with, however, we
sought public comment, thereby providing a hearing, within the
meaning of §553(c) of the Administrative Procedure Act.
40. Certain comments filed in opposition to this rule
making suggest that the Commission is abdicating its ratemaking
responsibility by permitting producers and purchasers to set
rates by private bargain. Such is not the case. Our actions in
individual proceedings arising under these new procedures will
answer this objection. We will be, as we should be, judged on
the proper discharge of our duties on the record made before us
in each case.
41. We are firm in our conviction that we must act
in an attempt to alleviate the nation’s shortage of natural gas
supply, and we believe our action herein to be a reasonable and
appropriate measure toward that end. We are mindful that any
rate or rates we may find proper under the alternative metliod
of certification we provide for herein will be binding subject
only to subsequent findings and determinations that may be
made under Section 5(a) of the Act, United Gas Pipe Line Co.
v. Mobile Gas Service Corp., 350 U.S. 332, 344. Contracts ap
proved unconditionally pursuant to the alternative procedure
will be free from any later attempt to impose a refund obliga-
tion. We believe that such an assurance is an alternative that
must be made available, subject to the conditions we attach
thereto.
| 17a
ANALYSIS OF RULE
42. As we stated in the Notice, issued April 6, 1972, the
rule we adopt hereby will not supersede the procedures that
have been promulgated in our various rate opinion and orders
nor supplant the procedures set forth in Docket Nos. R-389 and
R-389A, but will supplement the procedures set forth in Order
No. 431, Docket No. R-418, issued April 21, 1971.
43. Further, the optional procedure will not affect any
certificate proceeding which has been completed or is now
pending under procedures set forth in the various rate opinions
and orders, or under Order Nos. 402, 402A, 431 or our
Regulations 157.22 and 157.29.
COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS
44. We shall not attempt to enumerate or discuss each
comment received or suggestion made about the proposed new
Section 2.75 of the Commission’s General Policy and Interpre-
tations, but shall set forth the comments generally, and our
conclusions as to them. Our discussion of the lawfulness of our
action herein dispenses with any need of discussing the com-
ments made in regard to paragraph “a” of the new Section 2.75.
45. Paragraph 10.b. (1) — The question asked here con-
cerned clarification as to whether acreage dedicated to an exist-
ing-contract under an amendment dated on or after April 6,
1972, would be eligible for certification under the optional pro-
cedure. Because of the questions asked, it has become apparent
that there is some misunderstanding of our intent to apply the
optional procedure to supplies of gas not available to the inter-
state market prior to April 6, 1972. We seek new supplies of
gas, whether such new supplies come from new acreage dedica-
tions, or from newly drilled wells, or by diversion from other
uses. Accordingly, we clarify paragraph 10b.(1) to make it read:
A contract covering the sale of natural gas in inter-
state commerce has been executed for gas produced
from a well or wells commenced after April 6, 1972;
or a contract covering the sale of natural gas in inter-
state commerce has been executed for gas not pre-
18a
viously sold in interstate commerce except under the
provisions of Orders 402, 418 or 431 issued May 6,
and December 10, 1970; April 15, 1971, respectively.
This modification will encourage full development of acreage
previously dedicated to the interstate market, as well as en
couraging exploration for new reserves. We conclude that
expamsion of incentives to include all wells commenced after
April’ 6, 1972, the date of our original notice, will greatly
encourage additional drilling; to the extent that we bring about
additional drilling and production we are securing for the con-
sumer reliable gas supplies not previously deliverable.
In recognizing that prior Commission procedures and
policies, which defined the dichotomy between “new” gas and
“old”” gas on the basis of contract date, have failed to achieve
full development of dedicated acreage, we do not intend, nor
shall this statement be construed as a release of any dedicated
acreage from commitment to the interstate market. Applica
tions tendered under this Section covering gas produced from
new wells on old acreage shall be treated as an application for
certificate amendment and a Section 4 rate increase filing.
46. Paragraph 10.b. (2). — The comments received
requested clarification of the term “All Parties.” Some re-
quested that “Signatory parties” be substituted for the words
“all parties.” However, to limit the obligation to parties who
sign the sales contract would establish a loophole where work-
ing interest owners by merely declining to sign the sales
’ contract, under which their gas is sold, would be able to
obtain .all the advantages of the optional procedure for the
particular sale without giving up any of the advantages the
area rate ceilings would afford them under their existing
contracts.
47. Therefore, we shall not restrict the requirement that
all parties to the contract, except for parties sharing a royalty
interest only, agree. The following revised paragraph shall be
adopted:
All parties whose gas is to be sold under the
terms and conditions of such contract, except for
| 19a
the royalty interest therein, must agree to the sub-
mission of the same for certification in accord with
the provision of this Section.
48. Paragraph 10.b. (3). — In regard to this provision,
all of the comments received opposed the 12-year deliver-
ability life requirement because it is alleged the requirement
too burdensome and unnecessary. We agree that the 12-year
deliverability requirement should be deleted and shall adopt
the following language:
The purchaser under such a contract is a jurisdic-
tional pipeline.
49. Paragraph 10.b. (4). — Of the comments received
pertaining to this paragraph, the majority requested clarifica-
tion of the phrase “all obligations.” We believe clarification is
necessary, and we shall adopt the following language:
The seller under such contract establishes that
he has discharged, or is prepared by an acceptable
plan or program to discharge, refund obligations
prescribed by prior orders or opinions of this Com-
mission. It is provided, however, that any such seller
may make the showing here required without
prejudice to his claim in any case now pending on
judicial review that such obligations were unlawfully
imposed by the Commission.
50. Some of the respondents asked if the optional pro-
cedure is available to affiliate or subsidiary off-system and
on-system sales. We have no intent to exclude such sales.
However, we should point out that such sales will be
examined by the Commission to assure that the proposed
rates are reasonable and in the public interest.
51. Some question was raised as to whether small pro-
ducers are eligible for certification under the optional pro-
cedure? Here again we had no intent to exclude small
producers and we see no reason to do so.
52. Paragraph 10.b. (5). — The major problem the
parties raised with this paragraph is that clarification is neces-
—
sary. We agree. The following language will, we believe, clarify
the paragraph and remain consistent with our amended word-
ing of paragraph 10.b.(1).
The gas covered by the contract offered for
certification is produced from a well or wells com-
menced on or after April 6, 1972; or the gas
offered for certification has not been previously
sold in the interstate market (unless abandonment
has been previously granted or a sale was made
under Orders 402, 418 or 431), nor has an applica-
tion been previously filed with the Commission for
certification of the sale of such gas, except for an
emergency sale under Orders 402, 418 or 431.
53. Other questions were raised in regard to paragraph
10.b. First, will the reserves dedicated under the optional
procedure count toward discharge of refund obligations under
area rate opinions providing for the same? The answer to that
question is no. Provisions for the discharge of refund oblige
tions are components of area rate decisions which are still
pending on appeal.
54. Second, would gas flowing under warranty contracts
qualify hereunder? The succinct answer here is: No. Opening
the optional procedure to warranty gas would necessarily
involve the Commission in modification of the terms of the
warranty.
55. Paragraph 10.c. — Two basic points were raised in
reference to this paragraph. First, how can the seller certify to
conditions relating to the purchaser? The answer is that the
seller does not have to certify to any conditions relating to
the purchaser. Such certification is the sole responsibility of
the purchaser.
20a
- 56. Second, replies requested clarification of the term
“all parties” in the second sentence. The words “all parties”
in the second sentence will be qualified by the inclusion of
the phase “except those having a royalty interest only”, to
conform with the change heretofore noted in paragraph
10.b.(2). Additionally to assist in the clarification of the first
2la
question, the following language for the second sentence will
be adopted.
.... Each party to the application shall certify
to his portion that all parties to the contract desire
certification .. .
57. Paragraph 10.d. — The parties asked here (a) if
individual company rate cases, all Commission actions, and
orders be included under this provision; and (b) would rates
established under the optional procedure be recognized by the
Commission as a basis for triggering price escalation clauses?
58. In answer to the above questions, and to clarify the
provision, we shall adopt the following language:
A certificate of public convenience and neces-
sity issued and accepted under this Section shall not
be subject to change by determinations or orders
whether heretofore made or hereafter to be made in
producer or pipeline rate proceedings initiated under
Section 4 of the Act, and orders issued hereunder
shall not constitute establishment of an area rate;
provided, however, that nothing herein shall limit
the applicability of Section5 of the Natural Gas
Act. Nothing done hereunder shall be recognized by
the Commission as triggering any existing contract
escalation clauses.
59. Paragraph 10.e. — The only major substantive ques-
tion raised by the parties here was whether short-term con-
tracts would be accepted under this rulemaking. We see no
reason to provide that only long-term contracts should be
permitted under the optional procedure.
60. Paragraph 10.f. — Many comments were received
relating to this paragraph requesting clarification of the
phrase: “indefinite pricing clauses.” Many specifically asked if
area rate, Btu, tax reimbursement, compression and dehydra-
tion, and redetermination and renegotiation clauses would be
allowed.
— ay
61. We have determined that so-called “‘area rate
clauses” should not be allowed because area ceiling rates
might then become a floor for all future contracts to be
certificated under the optional procedure. Further, redeter-.
mination and renegotiation clauses will not be Permitted
because rates under the optional procedure would, perforce,
be continually changing. Other types of clauses should be
allowed, and, therefore, the following language is adopted.
No contract shall be accepted for filing if it
includes any type of indefinite pricing clause except
Btu price adjustment clauses, clauses to reflect
changes in state production taxes, and clauses allow-
ing for the recovery of compression and dehydra-
tion charges. Indefinite pricing clauses shall include,
but are not limited to “area rate or FPC clauses”’, a
“price redetermination or renegotiation clause” or a
“special escalation clause.”
62. Paragraph 10.g. — Certain comments were based on
a request that some clarification of the type and nature of
factual support was necessary in light of paragraph 2 through
7 of the rulemaking procedure.
63. We believe that each contract filed under the altern
tive procedures must be considered on the merits of the terms
and provisions within each contract. There certainly must be
some evidentiary basis proffered by the seller-applicant upon
which we can judge whether the contract rate is just and
reasonable. We will, absent a showing of special circumstance,
accept as conclusive the cost findings embodied in our area
rate decisions, as such may be supplemented from time to
time by appropriate Commission order.
64. Paragraph 10.h. — Most of the comments in regard
to this section were made as if Paragraph 10.i. were not
proposed. We belive that most of the objections would not
have occurred if paragraph 10.i. had been read closely. How
ever, even if the information required in this paragraph is not
on file with the Commission so that it may be submitted by
incorporation, we believe the data will be necessary to
properly judge the merits of the contract, and to make a
22a
23a
determination of the propriety of the contract rate.
Therefore, we shall make no change in this paragraph.
65. Paragraph 10.k. — One party filed a comment stating
that the standards were not spelled out as to when the
Commission would hold a formal hearing. It is impossible at
this time to set such specific standards, or to foresee when
possible circumstances surrounding future filings may require
a formal hearing. Therefore no change in this provision will be
made.
66. Paragraph 10.1 — One comment was filed in regard
to this paragraph asking whether filing under the alternative
procedure imputes any implied waiver by the applicants there-
under. Where the waiver of any right may be provided: for
herein, it is an express waiver. To eliminate any doubt in the
tule itself, however, we shall amend this provision to read:
1. A final order of this Commission, issuing a
certificate as applied for, or issuing a conditioned
certificate acceptable to the applicants, shall consti-
tute a final determination that the rates, charges
and services therein specified are just, reasonable
and required by the present and future public
convenience and necessity.
67. Paragraph 10.m(2) — Virtually all the comments
received on this waiver of contingent escalations were firmly
opposed and sought elimination of this condition. We are
impelled to retain this requirement, with one modification.
We strike the phrase “or hereafter issued”, thus limiting the
waiver to contingent escalations provided for in Opinions 595
(Texas Gulf Coast) and 598 (Southern Louisiana). Thus, only
producers with flowing gas production in Southern Louisiana
or Texas Gulf are affected by paragraph 10.m.(2).
68. Our reasons for imposing the conditions are two-
fold: First, contingent escalations are a component of area
rates. Flowing and new gas prices were established in South-
em Louisiana and Texas Gulf Coast with due regard to the
incentives which these escalations provided. Both Southern
Louisiana and Texas Gulf Coast (our only opinions which
—x
24a
establish contingent escalations) are on appeal.
69. Secondly, but of equal importance, we offer the
procedures herein adopted as an optional procedure to func.
tion in parallel with area rate regulation. Were we to cast
aside the waiver required in paragraph 10.m.(2), consumes
would be injured, and producers in Southern Louisiana and in
Texas Gulf Coast (the only producers affected by this waiver)
would be afforded an unfair position over producers in al
other areas. Such unacceptable results would occur because
applications under this Section would operate, in the absence
of paragraph 10.m.(2), not only on new gas- sales but would
also operate to escalate old gas prices as well.
70. By retaining paragraph 10.m.(2) we require, in
effect, an election by producers with flowing gas in Southem
Louisiana and Texas Gulf Coast; they must choose whether
contingent escalations on flowing gas provide ‘a sufficient
incentive to seek and sell new gas to the interstate market, at
area rates, or whether a greater degree of market freedom in
the pricing of new supplies offsets the benefit of contingent
escalation of flowing gas prices. Requiring this election
protects the consumer, as we must, from escalation of both
flowing and new gas rates.
71. We cannot, in equity, permit a producer with flow
ing gas in Southern Louisiana or Texas Gulf to achieve higher-
than-area rate prices for its own new deliveries and still
receive price escalations on its flowing gas through the efforts
of other producers who elect to remain on area rate pricing
for new dedications.
72. The election here required is to be made ona
company-by-company basis, with each company’s decision to
waive Southern Louisiana or Texas Gulf contingent escalations
evidenced by the company’s acceptance of its first permanent
certificate issued under Section 2.75.
73. We emphasize that paragraph 10.m.(2) operates on
an area-by-area basis. For example, a producer with flowing
gas in Southern Louisiana can use the optional procedures for
new gas from any other area without waiving his Southem
25a
Louisiana contingent escalations. Accordingly, while we recog-
nize that paragraph 10.m.(2) may impose a restraint on some
producers, under some circumstances, the restraint is
necessary and, we believe, required by the public interest.
74. Reserves dedicated hereunder will be allowed to
count toward the contingent escalation of flowing gas rates of
ai other producers operating in the area, if such reserves
otherwise qualify for escalation credit under the express terms
of Opinions 595 and 598. This is because escalation of flow-
ing gas rates are an industry endeavor in each area where
contingent escalations are provided for and is not the function
of the discharge of an obligation of any one particular
company.
75. We emphasize also that with the exception of the
one-time election required by paragraph 10.m.(2), the option
between area rate pricing and certification under Section 2.75
procedures here provided lies with the producers on a
contract-by-contract basis.
76. Paragraph 10.n. — The comments received regarding
this paragraph concerned the apparent inconsistency regarding
notice to the Commission provided for in the first two sen-
tences. The comments are well-taken. The words: “after
notice to the Commission” will be stricken from the first
sentence, and the second sentence will be changed to read:
Notice of commencement of deliveries shall be given
to the Commission within ten days after deliveries
first commence, and shall include all pertinent
information concerning the deliveries.
77. Paragraph 10.0.-Many comments filed in regard to
this provision objected to the area ceiling rate limitation for
the period of six months after deliveries are commenced in
accordance with Paragraph 10.n. Such a limitation is, however
a reasonable one, since predicated on the assumption that the
Commission will have acted by final order within that period
of time. The parties may, after the six-month period and
upon the filing of a notice of change in rate by the seller,
continue the service at the rates specified in the contract,
26a
without refund obligation. Six months is clearly an adequate
period for preliminary Staff analysis and review of applica
tions tendered under the optional procedure. Accordingly, by
action to deny or condition certificates prior to the expiration
of the six-month period, we can protect against the impact of
a nonrefundable rate which is not just and reasonable. To
Clarify that which has appeared to concern many of those
responding to this provision, we shall provide that it will be
changed to read:
. - (If the Commission has not made its final order),
the seller upon the filing of a notice of change in
rate pursuant to Section 154.94 of the Commis-
sion’s Regulations shall be entitled to receive with-
out refund obligation and the purchaser shall be
entitled to pay, the rates specified in the
contract... .
78. Paragraph 11.—A comment was received suggesting
that in view of the Commission’s intent, stated in the last
sentence of the paragraph, to encourage long term, large
volume dedications of new supplies of natural gas, the Com
mission should not accept contracts for less than a minimum
term of twenty years. Although it is true that the desired goal
of the optional procedure is to obtain long term commitments
of gas, we do not believe that contracts for less than twenty .
years, or life of lease contracts, should be barred. Our con
sideration of individual applications will reflect due concem
for the desirability of long-term dedications.
GENERAL COMMENTS
79. As we have noted above (paragraph 5) natural gas is
the cleanest burning, and insofar as is known today, the least
polluting of all the fossil fuels. This, of course, is one of the
reasons for its present enlarged demand and desirability as a
tek Sine. in some of our metropolitan areas, “clean-air”
regulations and restrictions have made natural gas not only
desirable, but almost a necessity for some commercial and
industrial users. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
filed its response in this proceeding, stating that in its opinion
ee
27a
the optional procedure we provide for herein will be a major
step towards elimination of the gas shortage and the nation’s
air pollution problem through the addition of new gas
reserves.
80. These rules herein adopted are inherently procedural,
providing an optional method by which to obtain certifica-
tion; accordingly, our rulemaking involves no direct impact on
the environment (such as construction of facilities would) nor
does it indirectly affect the environment through the setting
of rates. Questions of environmental concern may be proper
at the time of certification, whatever the procedure employed
for such certification, but such questions are of no relevance
to the establishment of procedural rules.
81. EPA suggests that the pipelines obtaining these addi-
tional gas reserves should file volumetric information on the
specific end uses to which the gas will be put. This informa-
tion would be used to insure that the gas would be used to
reduce air pollution. EPA recognizes the possiblity that it may
become necessary for this Commission to allocate the end use
of gas and suggests that the data it proposes could be useful
to the Commission in such a program. However, most, if not
all the gas obtained through the optional procedure will go to
supplying existing customers. At this time, we do not foresee
the new and expanded services envisioned by EPA.
The Commission further finds:
(1) The notice and opportunity to participate in this
proceeding with respect to the matters presently before the
Commission through the submission, in writing, of data,
views, comments and suggestions in the manner as described
above are consistent and in accordance with all procedural
requirements therefor as prescribed in Section 553, Title 5 of
the United States Code. Since the amendment prescribed here
does not prescribe an added duty or restriction, compliance
with the effective date requirements of 5 U.S.C. 553(d) is
unnecessary. ‘
(2) The amendment of Part 2, General Rules of Practice
and Procedure, General Policy arid Interpretations, Subchapter
—
28a
A, Chapter 1, Title 18 of the Code of Federal Regulations,
Section 2.75 Optional Procedure for Certificating New
Producer Sales of Natural Gas, as herein prescribed, is
necessary and appropriate for the administration of the
Natural Gas Act.
(3) Since the modifications to the amendments
prescribed herein which were not included in the notice of
this proceeding are of a minor nature, and are consistent with
the prime purpose of the proposed rulemaking herein, further
notice thereof is unnecessary.
The Commission, acting pursuant to the provisions of the
Natural Gas Act, as amended, particularly sections 4, 5, 7 and
16 thereof (52 Stat. 822, 823, 824, 825 and 830; 56 Stat. 83,
84; 61 Stat. 459; 76 Stat. 72, 15 U.S.C. 717c, 717d, 717f,
and 7170) orders:
(A) part 2 of the Commission’s General Rules of
Practice and Procedure, General Policy and Interpretations,
Subchapter A, ChapterI, Title 18 of the Code of Federal
Regulations is amended by adding new Section 2.75, a
follows:
2.75 Optional Procedure for Certificating New Producer
Sales of Natural Gas
a. Notwithstanding any other provisions in the
General Rules of Practice and Procedure of the
Federal Power Commission, or the Regulations
Under the Natural Gas Act of the Federal Power
Commission, applications for certification of future
sales of natural gas produced within the United
States may, at the option of the signatory parties to
sales contracts, be submitted in accordance with the
provisions of this Section. The the extent that any
Federal Power Commission General Rules of Prac-
tice and Procedure or Regulations under the Natural
_ Gas Act are inconsistent ith, the same are
hereby amended to permit the optional procedure
herein set forth.
—....
29a
b. The provisions of this Section shall be avail-
able if each of the following conditions exists:
1. A contract covering the sale of natural gas
in interstate commerce has been executed for gas
produced from a well or wells commenced after
April 6, 1972; or a contract covering the sale of
natural gas in interstate commerce has been
executed for gas not previously sold in interstate
commerce except under the provisions of Orders
402, 418 or 431 issued May 6, and December 10,
1970; April 15, 1971, respectively.
2. All parties whose gas is to be sold under the
terms and conditions of such contract, except for
the royalty interest therein, must agree to the
submission of the same for certification in accord
with the provision of this Section.
3. The purchaser under such contract is a
jurisdictional pipeline.
4. The seller under such contract establishes
that he has discharged, or is prepared by plan or
program to discharge, refund obligations pre-
scribed by prior orders or opinionsof this Com-
mission. It is provided, however, that any such
seller may make the showing here required with-
out prejudice to his claim in any case now pend-
ing on judicial review that such obligations were
unlawfully imposed by the Commission.
5. The gas covered by the contract offered for
certification is produced from a well or wells
commenced on or After April 6, 1972; or the gas
offered for certification has not been previously
sold in the interstate market (unless abandonment
has been previously granted or a sale was made
under Orders 402, 418 or 431), nor has an appli-
cation been previously filed with the Commission
for certification of the sale of such gas, except
for an emergency sale under Orders 402, 418 or
431.
30a
c. If all of foregoing conditions precedent exist,
the parties to the contract may tender the same to
the Commission and request the issuance of a
certificate of public convenience and necessity to
the seller for sales of natural gas thereunder. Each
party to the application shall certify to his portion
that all parties to the contract, except those having
a royalty interest only, desire certification in
accordance with the terms and provisions of this
- Section, that the seller expressly agrees to the
waivers and elections hereinafter provided for in
subsections m and n of this Section, and that all
conditions precedent as set forth in sub-section b of
this Section are met.
d. A certificate of public convenience and
necessity issued and accepted under this Section
shall not be subject to change by determinations or
orders whether heretofore made or hereafter to be
made in producer or pipeline rate proceedings
initiated under Section4 of the Act, and orders
issued hereunder shall not constitute establishment
of an area rate; provided, however, that nothing
herein shall limit the applicability of Section 5 of
the Natural Gas Act. Nothing done hereunder shall
be recognized by the Commission as triggering any
existing contract escalation clauses. ~
e. Applications presented hereunder will be con-
sidered for permanent certification, either with or
without pre-granted abandonment, notwithstanding
that the contract rate may be in excess of an area
ceiling rate established in a prior opinion or order
of this Commission.
f. No contract shall be accepted for filing if it
includes any type of indefinite pricing clause except
Btu price adjustment clauses, clauses to reflect
changes in state production taxes, and clauses allow-
ing for the recovery of compression and dehydra-
tion charges. Indefinite pricing clauses shall include,
3la
but are not limited to “area rate or FPC clauses”, a
“price redetermination or renegotiation clause” or a
“special escalation clause.”
g. A seller-applicant under this Section shall state
the ground for claiming that the present or future
public convenience and necessity require issuance of
a certificate on the terms proposed in the applica-
tion, and shall provide factual support for such
claims. The application shall contain a contract sum-
mary as prescribed in Sec. 250.5 of our Regulations
Under the Natural Gas Act.
h. The purchaser under a contract filed under
this Section shall certify that the present or future
public convenience and necessity require issuance of
a certificate to the seller, and shall provide informa-
tion in support of such certification with respect to
the pruchaser’s (1) system-wide supply, (2) present
and estimated 3-year peak day and average day
demands, (3) present and estimated 3-year require-
ments of customers on its system, (4) deliverability
life, (5) implementation, if any of curtailment plans,
(6) emergency ptirchases of gas under Order 431, or
157.22 or 157.29 of these Regulations, and (7)
purchases of LNG or attachment of other supple-
mental supplies.
i. The information required by sub-section g. and
h. may be submitted by cross-reference and in-
corporation of information already on file with the
Commission.
j. Applications requesting issuance of certificates
of public convenience and necessity as authorized in
this Section shall be processed in accordance with
the procedural requirements, including those relating
to notice, intervention and hearing, set out in Part
157 of the Commission’s Regulations Under the
Natural Gas Act.
32a
k. Pursuant to the authority contained in and
subject to the jurisdiction conferred upon the
Federal Power Commission by Sections 7 and 15 of
the Natural Gas Act and the Commission’s Rules of
Practice and Procedure, a statutory hearing will be
held before the Commission without futther notice
on all applications for certificates under this Section
in which no petition to intervene in opposition is
filed within the time required, if the Commission on
its own review of the matter believes that a grant of
a certificate is required by the public convenience
and necessity. Where the Commission believes that a
formal hearing is required notice of such hearing
will be duly given.
lL A final order of this Commission, issuing a
certificate as applied for, or issuing a conditioned
certificate acceptable to the applicants, shall consti-
tute a final determination that the rates, charges
and services therein specified are just, reasonable
and required by the present and future public con-
venience and necessity.
m. By acceptance of a certificate issued here-
under, the seller-applicant unconditionally agrees to
(1) waive all rights to seek future rate increases
under Section 4 of the Natural Gas Act with respect
to the contract submitted, other than price escala-
tions, if any, as certificated by the Commission; and
(2) waive all rights to contingent adjustment of
flowing gas rates as provided by the Commission in
area rate decisions aeretofore decided, for flowing
gas which the seller-applicant produces in the same
geographical pricing area as the pricing area of the
production covered by the application made under
n. Upon the filing of an application under this
Section, deliveries pursuant to the provisions of the
tendered contract may be commenced, pending
review of such application by the Commission.
ee
Notice of commencement of deliveries shall be given
to the Commission within ten days after deliveries
first commence, and shall include all pertinent infor-
mation concerning the deliveries. Any such deliver-
jes so commenced may be terminated (1) if such
contract for any reason shall terminate or be termi-
nated prior to the issuance by the Commission of a
final order upon review of such application, or (2)
upon the issuance of a certificate containing condi-
tions unacceptable to the party adversely affected.
If the Commission by final order shall deny such
application, or if the party or parties to the con-
tract adversely affected shall not accept the terms
and conditions prescribed by the Commission,
deliveries thereunder shall be terminated. Within
thirty days after termination of deliveries, the seller
shall notify the Commission of such termination,
and shall report the date of termination, volumes
delivered, and revenues received.
33a
o. If the parties elect to commence deliveries as
set forth in subsection n., such deliveries will be
made at rates no higher than the prevailing area
ceiling rate and shall so continue for six months
unless the Commission has made its final orders on
the application at an earlier date; at the end of such
six-month period (if the Commission has not made
its final order), the seller upon the filing of a notice
of change in rate pursuant to Section 154.94 of the
Commission’s Regulations shall be entitled to
receive without refund obligations and the purchaser
shall be entitled to pay, the rates specified in the
contract, and such contract rates shall continue as
the effective rates until the Commission enters its
final order on the certificate application.
(B) The amendment provided for herein shall be effec-
tive as of the date of issuance of this order.
~~
34a
(C) The Secretary of the Commission shall cause prompt
publication of this order to be made in the Federal Register
By the Commission.
(SEAL) Mary B. Kidd, |
35a
DOCKET NO. R-441
RESPONDENTS TO OPTIONAL PROCEDURE
Continental Oil Company
Exchange Oil and Gas Corporation
James Forgotson, Sr.
General American Oil Company of Texas
GHK Corporation
Gulf Oil Corporation
Humble Oil and Refining Company
Inexco Oil Company
Kansas Natural Gas, Inc.
Kerr-McGee Corporation
Lake Washington, Inc., U.S. Oil of Louisiana, Inc.
Marathon Oil Company :
Mesa Petroleum Company
Mobil Oil Corporation
Phillips Petroleum Company
Joint Comments & Suggestions of Twelve Company Producer Group
Shell Oil Compzny
Sun Oil Company
Superior Oil Company
Tenneco Oil Company
Texaco, Inc.
Texas Pacific Oil Company, Inc.
Union Oil of California
Pipeline Companies and Pipeline Groups
American Natural Gas System
Colorado Interstate Gas Company
Columbia Gas System Service Corporation
——ny
36a
Consolidated Gas Supply Corporation
El Paso Natural Gas Company
Iroquois Gas Corporation
Natural Gas Pipeline Company of America, (Peoples Gas Light & Coke
and North Shore Gas Company) .
Northern Natural Gas Company
Pacific Gas Transmission Company
Panhandle Eastern Pipeline Company
Southern Natural Gas Company
Southern Union Gas Company
Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company
Transcontinental Gas Pipeline Corporation
United Gas Pipeline Company
United Natural Gas Company
Pennsylvania Gas Company
Distribution Co’s and Distribution Groups
Associated Gas Distributors (AGD)
Boston Gas Company, et al. (16 Co’s.)
California Distributor Group
Public Service Commission of Missouri
State of California and PUC of California
City of Chicago
Citizens Gas and Coke Utility (City of Indianapolis)
State of Indiana, Public Service Commission
State of Kansas Corporation Commission
Memphis Light, Gas and Water Division (City of Memphis)
State of New Mexico
Public Service Commission of New York
North Carolina Utilities Commission
Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement & Power District
Congressional and Governmental Agencies
Archer, Congressman, Texas
Lloyd M. Bentsen, Senator, Texas
37a
t of Commerce
Congress of the United States, Joint Economic Committee
Concerned Congressmen (21 Members)
Marlow W. Cook, Senator, Kentucky
William P. Curlin, Jr., Congressman, Kentucky
Environmental Protection Agency
Philip A. Hart, Senator, Michigan
Department of Interior
Walter Jones, Congressman, North Carolina
Warren G. Magnuson, Senator, Washington
Wilmer D. Mizell, Congressman, North Carolina
Neal Smith, lowa, and Silvio O. Conte, Massachusetts, Congressmen
Trade and Consumer Groups
and Consumer Federation of America
Consumers Assembly of Greater New York
Independent Natural Gas Association of America (INGAA)
Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA)
38a
Institute for Public Interest Representation (S.0.UP.)
Kansas Municipal Utilities, Inc.
Public Interest Research Group
Other
Hamilton Treadway
Anthony R. Martin—Trigona (P.0.W.E.R.)
Midrex Division (Midland-Ross Corporation)
Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. (Environmental Group)
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.