Appendix — Snow v. Commissioner
Supreme Court brief1974
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
i
Pen a
LIDRARY
SUPREME COURT, U. 5
F
—, EB 20 197.
Volume I MICHAEL RODAK, JR.,
In THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OcrTosBeR TERM, 1973
No. 73-641
Epwin A. AND HELEN B. SNOW
Petitioners,
—V.—
CoMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.
On Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED OCTOBER 12, 1973
CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 7, 1974
INDEX
VOLUME I
Chronological List of Relevant Docket Entries . .
Stipulation of Facts filed in the Tax Court |. .
Transcript of Proceedings conducted before the
Tax Court
Partnership Agreement of Burns Investment Co.
Amendment to Partnership Agreement dated
7-8-66 © 000.00... ——
Certificate of Limited Partnership of Echo De-
velopment Co. |
Certificate of Limited Partnership of Courier
Enterprises .........
Letter from David H. Trott to Robert Boggild
dated 4-28-65
Letter from Wood, Herron & Evans to David H.
Trott, dated 12-10-65
Letter from Wood, Herron & Evans to David H.
Trott, dated 2-22-66 ..
Order of the Supreme Court of the United States
allowing Certiorari, dated 1-7-74 |.
VOLUME II
Taxpayer Snow’s Individual Income Tax Return
for 1966 (Stone Oil Schedules omitted)
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Burns In-
vestment Co. ....
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Burns In-
vestment Co. ....................00.-- 00.
. 102
129
I crt a rarer tne ee
Qilbatatinieisanrwe piled spi iene Aatat id
Partnership Return of Income, 1968, Burns In-
vestment Co. . hee da Gs eade eae en eessas
Partnership Return of Income, 1965, Echo De-
velopment Co.
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Echo De-
velopment Co.
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Echo De-
velopment Co.
Partnership Return of Income, 1965, Courier
Enterprises
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Courier
Enterprises
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Courier
Enterprises
Patent No. 3,498,240, issued to David H. Trott
on 3-3-70
‘Trash-Away” Brochure
Note: The opinions of the Tax Court and the
Court of Appeals appear in the Appendix
to Snow’s Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
at pages 13-44.
Page
143
148
152
157
161
165
169
CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
UNITED STATES TAX COURT
November 16, 1970 —
January 7, 1971 -
November 16, 197] —
June 30, 1972 ~
June 30, 1972 —
Plaintiff Snow’s petition filed
Answer hled by Commissioner
Trial at Cincinnati, Ohio, be-
fore Judge Bruce
Findings of fact and opinion
filed by Judge Bruce
Decision for Commissioner en-
tered by Judge Bruce
a
APPELLATE PROCEEDINGS
~
September 5, 1972 _
July 17, 1973 _
October 12,1973. —
January 7, 1974 a
Notice of Appeal to U. S.
Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Circuit filed by Pe-
titioner Snow
Opinion and Judgment of the
Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Circuit (Tax Court
decision sustained)
Petitioner for Certiorari filed
Certiorari granted
ore, |
Bevce: eM ee cise oh
UNITED STATES TAX COURT
Docket No. 7125-70
EDWIN A. SNOW and HELEN B. SNOW, —
Petitioners,
v.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.
STIPULATION OF FACTS
(Filed November 16, 1971)
It is hereby stipulated that, for the purpose of this case,
the following statements may be accepted as facts and all
exhibits referred to herein and attached hereto are in-
corporated in this stipulation and made a part thereof;
provided, however, that either party may introduce other
and further evidence not inconsistent with the facts herein
stipulated. Either party hereby expressly reserves the right
to object to the admission in evidence of any of the fol-
lowing facts or exhibits, however, on the grounds of ma-
teriality and relevancy.
1. Petitioners Edwin A. Snow and Helen B. Snow were,
on the date of the filing of the petition in this case, resi-
dents of Cincinnati, Ohio. Petitioners filed their joint
Federal income tax return for the calendar year 1966 with
the District Director, Internal Revenue Service, Cincinnati,
Ohio; a true and correct copy of that tax return is attached
hereto and marked as joint Exhibit 1-A.
3
2. On July 8, 1966, Mr. Snow executed what was called
an “Agreement” as a limited partner in an entity known
as the Burns Investment Company. A true and correct
copy of that Agreement form is attached hereto and marked
as joint Exhibit 2-B.
3. Subsequently on April 3, 1967, Mr. Snow along
with all of the other parties to that original Agreement,
executed an amendment to that Agreement. A true and
correct copy of that Amendment to Agreement is attached
hereto and marked as joint Exhibit 3-C.
4. Form 1065, U.S. Partnership Return of Income,
was filed by Burns Investment Company for the taxable
year beginning August 1, 1966 and ending December 31,
1966. A true and correct copy of that tax return is at-
tached hereto and marked as joint Exhibit 4-D.
5. By way of invoice, Crossbow, Inc. billed the Burns
Investment Company as follows:
Invoice No. Date Amount
265 7-15-66 $ 8,684.44
266 7-31-66 4,215.89
279 12-09-66 8,863.73
280) 12-30-66 12,500.00
281 12-30-66 2,516.38
$36,780.44
True and correct copies of all of those invoices are at-
tached hereto and marked as joint Exhibits 5-E thru 9-1.
6. Sometime during March of 1965, Mr. Edwin A.
Snow executed what was called a “Certificate of Limited
Partnership” as a limited partner in an entity known as
the “Echo Development Company.”’ A true and correct
se On AE EY a |
negneecrs:
QPseitttteerar scion.
4
copy of that certificate is attached hereto and marked as
joint Exhibit 10-].
7. Also during March of 1965, Mr. Edwin A. Snow
executed what was called a “Certificate of Limited Partner-
ship” as a limited partner in an entity known as “Courier
Enterprises.’ A true and correct copy of that document is
attached hereto and marked as joint Exhibit 11-K.
8. Forms 1065, U.S. Partnership Return of Income,
were filed by Echo Development Company and Courier
Enterprises for the taxable year 1966. True and cor-
rect copies of those returns are attached hereto and marked
as joint Exhibits 12-L. and 13-M.
/s/ HAROLD W. WALKER
/s/ BURGESS DOAN,
Counsel for Petitioners.
/s/ K. MARTIN WORTHY,
Chief Counsel,
Internal Revenue Service.
5
[1] BEFORE THE
UNITED STATES TAX COURT
. DOCKET NO. 7125-70
EDWIN A. SNOW and HELEN B. SNOW,
Petitioners,
vs.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.
Courtroom. 607, U. S. Court of Appeals
Post Office and Courthouse Building
5th and Walnut Streets
Cincinnati, Ohio
Tuesday, November 16, 1971
Met, pursuant to notice, at 11:10 o'clock a.m.
BEFORE:
HONORABLE J. GREGORY BRUCE, Judge.
APPEARANCES:
BURGESS L. DOAN, Esq., and H. W. WALKER, Esq.
522 Dixie Terminal Building
$ Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
appearing on behalf of the Petitioner.
RUDOLPH L. JANSEN, Esgq., Internal Revenue Service
7504 Federal Office Building
Cincinnati, Ohio ,
appearing on behalf of the Respondent.
* * *
pe
Rd i AM FE ABS ce! tie
* 6
(3] | PROCEEDINGS
THE CLERK: Docket Number 7125-70, Edwin A.
Snow and Helen B. Snow. State your appearances for-the
record please.
MR. DOAN: Burgess L. Doan for the Petitioners.
MR. WALKER: H. W. Walker for Petitioners.
MR. JANSEN: Rudolph L. Jansen for Respondent.
THE COURT: All right, do you wish to make open-
ing statements or wait until after you get the stipulation
of facts in? You can suit yourself. If you wish to refer
to the stipulation in your opening statement you may offer
it now or later. é
MR. DOAN: My opening statement will refer to the
stipulation of facts, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Suit yourself when you want to offer
it. . pret
MR. DOAN: I believe we agree that upon conclusion
of my opening statement we would offer the stipulation of
facts, Your Honor.
THECOURT: All right.
OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF
PETITIONER
By Mr. Doan
<-
MR. DOAN: May it please the Court, the issue to be
decided in this case is whether Petitioner is entitled to de-
duct on his 1966 Federal income tax return his distributive
share of a net operating loss sustained for the taxable year
1966 by Burns Investment Company, a parthership. It is
the [4] Petitioner's position that his distributive share of
the net operating loss sustained by Burns Investment Com-
pany resulted from expenses incurred in inventing, develop-
7
ing and obtaining patents on a special purpose incinerator
device during the taxable year 1966.
It is further the Petitioner's position that a partner is
engaged in the business of the partnership of which he is a
member; that the Petitioner was engaged in the trade or
business of inventing, developing and obtaining patents on
new products for commercial exploitation during the tax-
able year 1966 by virtue of his extensive participation in
various projects, and therefore he is entitled to deduct his
distributive share of the net operating loss sustained by
Burns Investment Company during the taxable year 1966,
since that loss arose from research and development ex-
penses incurred, accrued and paid during the taxable yéar
1966 in connection with the Petitioner's trade or business.
The essential facts to be established in this case are as
follows: the Petitioner was, during the taxable year 1966,
a partner in Burns Investment Company, a partnership,
which was organized and operating under the laws of the
State of Ohio; that Burns Investment Company was formed
during the taxable year 1966 for the purpose of develop-
ing a special purpose incinerator device for the consumer
and industrial markets; and that device is known as the
Trashaway. Burns [5] Investment Company sustained a
net operating loss in the amount of $36,780.44 for the cal-
endar year 1966, of which the Petitioner's distributive share
was $9,195.00 which was claimed on his 1966 Federal in-
come tax return.
The Petitioner was during the taxable year 1966 a part-
ner in a second partnership known as Echo Development
Company which was also a partnership organized and op-
erating under the laws of the State of Ohio. The Echo
Development Company was formed on March 22, 1965
tor the purpose of developing a new consumer product in
the electronics field, namely a telephone answering device.
PEEL AE PH OY
LPOULAE GER OE PB POT RE eG? aD
8
The telephone answering device was completed during the
early part of 1966 and the rights thereto were held available
for sale, during the taxable year 1966.
The petitioner was during the taxable year 1966 a part-
ner in a third partnership known as Currier Enterprises.
That also was a partnership organized and operating under
the laws of the State of Ohio. Currier Enterprises was
in the business of developing a tape recorder for the pur-
pose of obtaining patents on that tape recorder and selling
the rights to it or licensing the rights to it to others.
The Burns Investment Company was likewise engaged
in the business during 1966 of developing the Trashaway,
the incinerator device for the purpose of obtaining patents
on that device and selling the rights or licensing others to
[6] manufacture it.
The Petitioner proposes to meet his burden of proof in
the following manner. The Petitioner and the Respondent
have jointly stipulated that Burns Investment Company
Was a partnership organized and existing under the laws of
the State of Ohio and that Petitioner was a member of that
partnership during the taxable year 1966. A true and
correct copy of the partnership agreement is attached to
the stipulation of facts as Joint Exhibit 2-B and is incor-
porated therein.
The Petitioner and Respondent have further stipulated
that Burns Investment Company filed its Federal income
tax return with the District Director at Cincinnati, Ohio
for the taxable year 1966 and a true and correct copy of that
tax return is likewise attached to the stipulation of facts
as Joint Exhnbit 1-A. The Federal income tax return
will further show that the Petitioner was a partner in Burns
Investment Company. It will show the amount of the net
operating loss sustained by the partnership and the amount
9
of the Petitioner’s distributive share of that partnership
loss.
The Petitioner and Respondent have further stipulated
that Burns Investment Company billed a corporation by
the name of Crossbow, Inc. for an amount of $36,780.44. A
true and correct copy of those invoices are attached to the
stipulation of facts, and incorporated therein as Joint Ex-
hibits 5-E through 9-1.
[7] Oral testimony will show that those invoices were
paid during the taxable year 1966 and will further show the
nature of the expenditures represented by those invoices.
The Petitioner and Respondent have jointly stipulated —
THE COURT: Are you just reading the stipulation?
MR. DOAN: No, Your Honor.
THE COURT: All right. It will be in the record I
assume. ‘I just don’t want a duplication. Refer to it if
necessary to bring out the points that you expect to offer
proof on.
MR. DOAN: The Petitioner and Respondent have fur-
ther jointly stipulated that the Petitioner was a partner
in Echo Development Company during the taxable year
1966 and the partnership agreements will be offered as
Joint Exhibit 10-] to the stipulation of facts. Oral testi-
mony will further show that Echo Development Company
was engaged in the business of inventing, developing and
obtaining patents on a telephone answering device and that
the rights to this device were available for licensing or sale
during the taxable year 1966.
The Petitioner and Respondent have further stipulated
that Petitioner was in fact a member of that partnership.
Oral testimony will show that Currier Enterprises was en-
gaged in the business of inventing, developing and obtain-
ing patents on this tape recording device during the tax-
able year 1966. The [8] Petitioner and Respondent have
reer OOO LINES IE TY NET
. cnindraibiva A
Pe aR Ot Cae pe Te
A ALE EASA LAD Pie Kit BRS Sit Bab ig teh
ee ee es
10
also jointly stipulated that Echo Development Company and
Currier Enterprises have filed Federal income tax returns,
form 1065 for the taxable year 1966, and these will further
show that the Petitioner was a partner in those partnerships.
The Petitioner will show through oral testimony and the
introduction of documents that he was engaged in the
trade or business of inventing, developing and obtaining
patents on at least three devices during the taxable year
1966, namely the Trashaway through Burns Investment
Company, the telephone answering device through Echo
Development Company, and a tape recording device
through Currier Enterprises; and finally, that by virtue
of these combined activities the Petitioner was, during
the taxable year 1966, carrying on a trade or business
of inventing, developing and obtaining patents, and that ex-
penses in question were incurred in connection with that
trade or business. . |
THE COURT: Let me ask you a question. You stated
in the beginning something about the principal issue in-
volved.
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Can you restate that for my benefit?
MR. DOAN: The issue to be decided in the case is
whether the Petitioner is entitled to deduct on his 1966
Federal income tax return his distributive share of a net
operating loss sustained for the taxable year 1966 by Burns
[9] Investment Company which is a partnership.
THE COURT: Very well.
OPENING STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF
RESPONDENT
By Mr. Jansen
MR. JANSEN: If it please the Court, the case does
involve income tax for the year 1966 in the amount of
11
36,247.00. I think that Mr. Doan has adequately stated
the issue involved, and also he has given to the Court some
insight.as to the basic facts involved in this case.
It is Respondent’s position, Your Honor, that at no time
during the taxable yeat 1966 was the Petitioner Edwin
A. Snow in the trade or business of inventing. It is also
our position that at ng time during the taxable year 1966
was the partnership nown as the Burns Investment Com-
pany an existing trade or business.
Your Honor, the parties have agreed to a stipulation of
facts in this casé and at this time I would like to present
a written stipulation of facts together with attached ex-
hibits 1-A through 13-M.
Your Honor the parties have also agreed to an oral sup-
plementary stipulation of facts which includes Joint Ex-
hibits 14-N through 22-V.
THE COURT: All right. You have a stipulation of
facts with Joint Exhibits 1-A through 13-M, and in addi-
tion to that you wish to make an oral stipulation.
[10] MR. JANSEN: That’s right, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Plus exhibits in connection with that.
MR. JANSEN: Well, Your Honor, the oral stipula-
tion —
THE COURT: Wait a minute. Let’s take them one
step atatime. The stipulation of facts together with Joint
Exhibits 1-A through 13-M inclusive will be received in
evidence.
(The stipulation of facts and the
documents previously marked for
identification as Joint Exhibits Nos.
1-A through 13-M were received in
evidence.)
THE COURT: Now you can offer the oral stipulation.
You don’t have that in writing?
ee
Coe see ee
12
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, the oral stipulation re-
lates only to documents.
THE COURT: Then in effect you are orally agreeing
as to the identification of documents.
MR. JANSEN: That's right, Your Honor. Those docu-
ments are numbered and lettered 14-N through 22-V.
THE COURT: All right Joint Exhibits 14-N through
and including 22-V and the oral stipulation in regard there-
to will be received in evidence.
(Oral stipulation of facts and the
documents previously marked for
identification as Joint Exhibits Nos.
14-N through 22-V were received in
evidence.)
THE COURT: Does Petitioner wish to proceed?
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, for our first witness I would
[11] like to call the Petitioner, Mr. Edwin A. Snow.
THE COURT: Well, if it isn’t too inconvenient, I
will permit the witness to stand where you are and you can
stand off to the side and interrogate him. We simply do
not have a regular witness chair here where we can seat
you and at the same time see and hear you.
Edwin A. Snow
was called as a witness on behalf of the Petitioner,
and, having been first duly sworn, testified as
follows:
THE CLERK: State your name and address for the
record.
THE WITNESS: Edwin A. Snow, 2444 Madison Road,
Cincinnati, Ohio.
18
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. DOAN: —
Q. Mr. Snow, where are you employed?
A. Procter and Gamble.
Q. What position do you hold with that company.
A. I’m Vice President and member of the Board of
Directors.
Q. Mr. Snow, how long have you been with the Procter
and Gamble Company?
A. Since September 1, 1933.
Q. Could you briefly describe the positions you have
held with the company?
[12] A. I joined the advertising department, then be-
came Associate Advertising Manager of the Company, then
the Advertising Manager and Vice President for Adver-
tising; then I moved from Advertising to General Manage-
ment. Over the years I managed a number of the operating
divisions of the company and I presently have five operating
divisions under my wing, and that is my present position.
Q. Mr. Snow, we are here primarily concerned with
your Federal income tax return for the taxable year 1966.
Were you actively engaged in any other business activity
in addition to your position with Procter and Gamble Com-
pany during the taxable year 1966?
A. Yes.
Q. And what might I ask was that, Mr. Snow?
A. The principal business was involved in some part-
nerships which were concerned with developing, patenting
and marketing new products.
Q. Do you remember the names of those partnerships?
A. Yes, there was Burns, Echo and Currier, as you de-
scribed earlier.
free ae De aR ae ce!
a Seal eR oe
14
Q. Were those partnerships operated under a written
partnership agreement?
A. Two I believe were in 1966. All of them were in
1966, although earlier in 1966 it was a verbal agreement
I had with the other parties.
[13] Q. When did you become a partner in Burns
Investment Company?
A. Verbally and by agreement with some of the other
partners I would judge around February or March of 1966.
Q. Now, why do you believe it to be January, or did
you say February or March?
A. February or March to the best of my recollection.
Q. Why do you believe it to be that period of time?
A. Because I recall having seen a copy of a letter from
the patent attorneys which indicated that the Burns device
now called Trashaway had certain mechanical features
which would be subject to, probably be subject to strong
patent protection.
Q. Mr. Snow, could you briefly describe the nature
of the business of Burns Investment Company?
A. Yes. It was in the business of developing, patenting,
inventing and marketing the Trashaway incinerator de-
vice.
Q. Now was the Burns Investment Company engaged
in this activity during the taxable year 1966?
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, I’m going to object to
the characterization of the activity of partnership as being
a business. I think that’s what is in issue in this case.
THECOURT: Will you read the question please, Miss
Reporter?
(Question read.)
[14] MR. DOAN: Your Honor, thate’s no characteri-
zation. I merely asked him the nature of the activity.
MS eee igenten a W “ EF Ae NR AS A A
15
THE COURT: I gather he’s asking for the activity of
the Burns Investment Company.
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor, that’s true. This
question relates to the prior question, but in this particular
question he did not mention the term business.
THE COURT: The other question has gone by and
been answered and now we have only this one question
before us. Overrule the objection.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. You may answer the question.
A. Will you repeat the question?
Q. Will you describe the activity of Burns Investment
Company during the taxable year 1966?
A. Yes, we were in the business of inventing, develop-
ing, perfecting, patenting and marketing the device known
as Trashaway incinerator device.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, I'm going to object to
the characterization of the activity as business and move that
the answer be stricken.
THE COURT: On what grounds? You are objecting
to him describing what the business or activity of the Burns
Investment Company was?
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor. The question related
[15] to the activity of the operation. The witness has re-
sponded by indicating that the business of that activity was
certain things rather than indicating what the activity of
the operation was.
THE COURT: I'll overrule the objection.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, may I ask you to describe to the
Court the nature of your activity as a member of Burns
Investment Company during the taxable year 1966?
ch i at iis |
se Gee Soe a es,
fa NASA eh SA
ae ee OS Raat
16
A. Summarizing, I would say working with the other
partners, principally Mr. Trott, counseling on the further
development of the device, selection of the trade mark
name, methods of marketing, and all of the various aspects
that might have to do with bringing this product to market
successfully.
Q. Mr. Snow, you mentioned Mr. Trott. Would you
explain who Mr. Trott is?
A. Mr. Tross is one of the partners, the managing
partner of the Burns Enterprises.
Q. Mr. Snow, did you participate in designing the
‘Trashaway?
A. Only to, I’m not an inventor. It was only to the
extent of suggesting modifications and further improve-
ments, which in my judgment would make the product
more successful and more marketable.
[16] Q. Did you at any time make recommendations
as to the product design?
A. I did.
Q. Were your recommendations adopted by the part-
nership?
A. To some extent, yes.
Q. Mr. Snow, would you say that the design effort that
went into the development of the Trashaway was a sub-
stantial part of the over all development?
MR. JANSEN: Objection, your Honor, the question
calls for a conclusion.
THE COURT: [I'll let him answer. Overrule the ob-
jection.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, is the design of a product something that
can be patented?
17
A. Yes.
THE COURT: You don’t mean as a separate patent,
do you, but it enters into the article for which a patent
is obtained.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, I do mean precisely that.
THE COURT: Are you asking him if the design alone
can be patented aside from the mechanical parts of the
patents?
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor.
{17} THE COURT: All right, go ahead.
THE WITNESS: _ It is my understanding the answer is
yes.
THE COURT: Well, in this case did you get any sepa-
rate patent for design?
THE WITNESS: No, sir.
THECOURT: You don’t need to go into probabilities.
Stick to facts.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. In this particular case, you stated that you became
a partner in Burns Investment Company in February or
March of 1966. Was there an existing model of the incin-
erator device at that time?
A. Yes.
Q. Was that model changed after you became a mem-
ber of Burns Investment Company?
A. Yes.
Q. Was it changed from a design standpoint?
A. Yes.
Q. Was it changed from the mechanical functioning
standpoint?
A. To a degree, yes.
Q. Now, at the time then you became a partner in
eee
wi tA NIE 2 ce Ora ee NR CM more> ————
-= .
18
Burns Investment Company, could you describe what Burns
Investment Company owned or what it had?
[18] A. Well, at the time it had a crude prototype
model, of an incinerator device, and early in the game in
1966 an indication as I said earlier from patent counsellor
that the mechanical system which was used as a basis for
this invention was patentable.
MR. DOAN: Will you please mark this as Petitioner’s
Exhibit 23.
THE CLERK: Petitioner’s Exhibit 23 marked for
identification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identificatidn as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 23.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, I hand you this document and ask you to
_ briefly describe to the Court what it is.
A. This is a document from the law offices of Wood,
) Herron and Evans, patent counsel, stating that in their best
| opinion the device described —
] MR. JANSEN: Objection, Your Honor. The question
__ was what is this document and he’s going into the content.
THE COURT: [I'll sustain the objection. You were
: asked for the identification. It is a memorandum received
: from patent counsel whom you have just named. What
- is the date of it?
4 MR. DOAN: February, 22, 1966, and at this time I
: would like to formally offer it in evidence.
4 [19] THE COURT: Any objection?
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we have no objection.
THE COURT: Document referred to will be received
in evidence as Petitioner’s Exhibit 23. -
19
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner’s Ex-
hibit No. 23 was received in evi-
dence.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, do you remember anything in particular
that might have induced you to become a member in the
partnership known as Burns Investment Company?
A. Yes, several things. First in my judgment, con-
firmed by patent counsel, they had a unique and marketable
way of incinerating or burning trash. Second, I felt that
there was a considerable market for this kind of equipment
and no such piece of equipment was then available on the
market.
MR. DOAN: Will you please mark this as Petitioner’s
Exhibit 24?
THE COURT: Let the Clerk give you the numbers.
I don’t want to get mixed up on the record.
THECLERK: Petitioner’s Exhibit 24 marked for iden-
tification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 24.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, will you briefly describe this document
to [20] the Court.
A. ‘This is a communication from the law offices of
Wood, Herron and Evans, which gives an opinion that the
device described which is fundamental to the development
of what is referred to —
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, objection.
Desi tecstvacicr.ier Ait AS: Sa Gil we a0
20
THE COURT: It is a memorandum received from
patent counsel.
MR. DOAN: Just give the date.
THE WITNESS: Oh, I see. December 10, 1965.
MR. DOAN: At this time I formally offer it into evi-
dence.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, there’s no objection.
THE COURT: Document referred to will be received
in evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 24.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner’s Ex-
hibits No. 24 was received in evi-
dence.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, was Burns Investment Gompany success-
ful in obtaining a patent on this device known as the
‘Trashaway?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you applied for patents im any countries other
than the United States?
A. Yes, in fourteen different countries. It is my un-
derstanding, although I can’t name them, some of these
patents [21] have been issued.
Q. Mr. Snow, is the Trashaway device in production to-
day?
A. Yes.
Q. Can you go out on the market and buy a Trash-
away?
A. Yes.
Q. Mr. Snow, are you active in Burns Investment Com-
pany today?
A. Very active in Burns Investment.
Q. What is your position with that company?
21
A. I'm Chairman of the Board of that Company.
THE COURT: That is a corporation?
MR. DOAN: No, Your Honor, I'll clarify that point.
THE COURT: All right.
BY MR. DOAN
Q. Mr. Snow, has the business form of Burns Invest-
ment Company changed since it was originally organized in
1966? |
A. Yes.
Q. What form is it today?
A. A corporation, and my recollection is that we in-
corporated in 1969.
Q. Mr. Snow, you indicated earlier that you worked
with a Mr. Trott.
A. Yes.
Q. Did you meet regularly with Hr. Trott dgring 1966?
[22] A. Yes, rather frequently, possibly an average of
two or three time a month.
Q. Did you have occasion to communicate with him
other than through meetings?
A. Yes, through correspondence and by telephone.
Q. Mr. Snow, you stated earlier that the business of,
I'll rephrase that, that the activity of Burns Investment
Company during the taxable year 1966 was to invent, de-
velop, patent and commercially exploit the Trashaway.
A. Yes.
Q. Did you during 1966 contemplate that Burns In-
vestment Company would manufacture this Trashaway?
A. Not in the original form of the prototype mode. We
were hopeful however that continuing product develop-
ment would lead to a finer product which would then be
available for sale.
Q. Mr. Snow, how was the manufacturing and market-
ing of the Trashaway finally handled?
OE I EE ICN AS AE RE aig
99
A. Handling isa rather broad term. The urd corpo
ration was primarily responsible for perfecting the model
and getting the product ready for market. During the
course of that, what I would term mechanical develop-
ment, we had a number of meetings and conversations be-
tween the partners with reference to how it should be
marketed and various ways of test marketing the product
once it was finally developed.
Q. Now, does Burns Investment Company actually man-
ufac- [23] ture this item today?
A. Iwill say yes and no. Many of the component parts
are manufactured outside, and some of the assembly work
is done by Burns Corporation.
MR. DOAN: Will you mark this.
THECLERK: Petitioner's Exhibit Number 25 marked
for identification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 25.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, I hand you this document and ask you
to briefly describe what it is.
A. It is an illustration of a leaf burner: filed June
10, 1968. I may have a little trouble here because when
you say describe a document, my being a layman and not
a lawyer, a description can be one of many things. I’m
not sure my description is adequate.
THE COURT: You just do your best and let your
counsel —
THE WITNESS: Direct me, and the Judge.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, I offer into evidence at this
time the patent on the leaf burning device which is known
as the Trashaway.
23
THE COURT: That is the patent?
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor.
[24] MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, Respondent has no
objection.
THE COURT: Document received in evidence as de-
scribed, as Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner's Ex-
hibit No. 25 was received in evi-
dence.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, you also mentioned you were a partner
in a second partnership known as Echo Development Com-
pany.
A. Yes.
Q. Would you briefly describe the activities of Echo
Development Company?
A. Again it has to do with the development, inventing,
patenting, and marketing of a new product, and this is a
mechanical device that is referred to as a telephone answer-
ing piece of equipment.
Q. Do you remember when you became a member of
that partnership?
A. Yes, in 1965.
Q. Do you know, Mr. Snow, if Echo Development Com-
pany was successful in obtaining a patent on that telephone
answering device?
A. The answer is yet, it was successful.
THECLERK: Petitioner’s Exhibit Number 26 marked
for identification.
(The document referred to was
[25] marked for identification as Pe-
titioner’s Exhibit No. 26.)
Pee a an ane ee
4 Le ath DT THLE AEIIT take
AD he AD PSB Ri hls AO RYT scl
ee, ET ee
24
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, I hand you this document and ask that
you briefly describe what it is.
THE COURT: Is that also a copy of a patent for this
so-called telephone answering device?
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Then that’s sufficient.
MR. JANSEN: We have no objection.
THE COURT: Are you offering it?
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: The document referred to will be re-
ceived in evidence as Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 26.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner’s Ex-
hibit No. 26 was received in evi-
dence.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, at the time you became involved in Echo
Development Company, were there any plans for commer-
cially exploiting the telephone answering device?
A. Yes.
Q. And how did you propose to do that?
A. Based on evidence better confirmed by patent, it
was felt this might be licensed to some manufacturer for
manufacture and sale.
[26] Q. Did Echo Company hold this patent avail-
able for sale or licensing?
A. Yes.
Q. Mr. Snow, do you remember when that patent was
applied for?
A. I'll have to refer to my notes. This is Currier, is
it not?
25
A. No, Echo.
A. Patent applied for August 15, 1966.
Q. Mr. Snow, did the partnership Echo Development
Company have a perfected model during 1966?
A. Yes.
Q. Was it a working model?
A. Yes.
Q. And did it function?
A. Yes.
MR. DOAN: Will you mark this please?
THECLERK: Petitioner's Exhibit Number 27 marked
for identification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 27.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, will you briefly describe this document?
A. It is entitled ‘Echo Development Company, March
1, 1966 report.”
[27] MR. DOAN: Your Honor, I offer into evidence
the Echo Development Company 1966 report.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we have no objection.
THE COURT: Document referred to will be received
in evidence as Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 27. Is that a fi- -
nancial report?
MR. DOAN: No, Your Honor, it is a progress report
on the development.
THE COURT: All right.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner’s Ex-
hibit No. 27 was received in evi-
dence.)
kh BDC ak Bt PELE BIDE! ey
RCRE EP EDS SAS AED MDS Licey Ast Diet AK aie Ath La Rha NRG Bie 60
MR. JANSEN: Excuse me, Your Honor, may I ask the
date on that document?
MR. DOAN: March 3, 1966.
THE CLERK: March Ist.
THE WITNESS: March Ist.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, you further stated earlier in your testi-
mony that you were a member of a partnership known as
Currier Enterprises.
A. Yes.
Q. Would you briefly describe the activities of Currier
Enterprises? ‘
THE COURT: Is that C-o-u-r-i-e-r?
MR. DOAN: Yes.
[28] THE WITNESS: Courier was engaged in the
business of developing, inventing, patenting, and marketing
an electronic device, in this instance a tape recorder.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, was the partnership successful in obtain-
ing a patent on the tape recording device?
A. Yes.
Q. Was the partnership actively pursuing this venture
during the taxable year 1966?
A. ‘To my recollection, yes.
Q. Mr. Snow, do you remember when the partnership
Courier Enterprises was formed?
A. Yes, in March 1965.
MR. DOAN: Will you mark this.
THECLERK: Petitioner’s Exhibit Number 28 marked
for identification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 28.)
27
BY MR. DOAN:
Q_ Mr. Snow, will you briefly describe this document to
the Court?
A. I assume this is a patent, isn’t it?
Q. Yes.
A. I'm not familiar with these things. It is called End-
less Tape Recorder and cartridge filed November 22, 1967.
[29] MR.DOAN: Your Honor, I offer the letters pat-
ent on the tape recording device in evidence.
MR. JANSEN: No objection.
THE COURT:, The document referred to will be re-
ceived in evidence as Petitioner’s Exhibit 28.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner’s Ex-
hibit No. 28 was received in evi-
dence.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, did you personally participate in the man-
agement development of Burns Investment Company,
Courier and Echo Development?
A. Yes.
Q. What was the purpose of having these separate part-
nership entities?
A. It was two fold in order of importance. First, dif-
ferent individuals and potential partners and investors
might have a different appraisal of the particular profit
opportunity offered by the individual prices, so in order
to form a partnership it was better to keep them separate.
It I liked one and somebody else didn’t like it, an investor
didn’t have to take all three at once. I selected the ones
that had the best profit opportunity for me in my judg-
ment. And the second reason is that if the form of market-
+ dea a |
28
ing took that of licensing to another manufacturer, the
manufacturer of a tape recorder might be a quite different
person than the manufactur- [30] er of an incinerator, and
it gave us some flexibility in making these approaches.
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, you mentioned that Mr. Trott was
the managing partner, I believe.
A. Yes.
THE COURT: Of which one?
THE WITNESS: Of all three, sir.
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Trott was the managing partner of all three
partnerships?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long have you known Mr. Trott?
A. Well, for approximately thirty years.
Q. Have you had an occasion to work with Mr. Trott?
A. Yes, he was one of my associates at Procter Gamble.
Q. And you were, were you then familiar with Mr.
Trott’s business activities?
A. As far as I could at that time, we were involved in
Procter and Gamble and I was quite familiar with them,
yes.
Q. Did you have any other business ventures in which
you and Mr. Trott jointly participated?
A. Not prior to the time that Mr. Trott left Procter
and Gamble to form his own business partnerships.
Q. Mr. Snow, did you become a partner in Burns In-
vestment Company, Courier Enterprises and Echo Devel-
opment Company [31] for the purpose of realizing a profit
on your activities?
A. Certainly.
Q. Did any of the partnerships that I have just men-
tioned have a product or service which it held available for
sale during the year in question, 1966?
29
A. According to my recollection all of them did with the
exception, and I believe I answered this question earlier,
at least in my personal judgment the original crude proto-
type model of the incinerator Trashaway was not then ready |
for sale.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, I’m sorry, I did not hear
the last part of the answer.
THE WITNESS: Could you repeat the answer?
(Answer read.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Snow, did you consider yourself to be involved
in the trade or business of inventing, developing new pro-
ducts by virtue of your activities in these partnerships?
A. Yes.
MR. DOAN: I have no further questions. -
THE COURT: Cross examine.
CROSS EXAMINATION
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, would it be possible for
me to use the podium? Could we position the witness at
this table?
THECOURT: He’s going to be facing you most of the
[32] time. I think we'll keep the arrangement we have.
THE WITNESS: Could I stand here?
THE COURT: Let me determine where you are going
to stand or sit. You stand there at that podium and
answer his questions. It’s inconvenient to try a case in
this Courtroom without a witness stand and not being able
to see the Clerk, the Reporter or the witness. This is
the best we can do under the circumstances.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, you have indicated you have been
hee RLS 4
Wat EAT LAER Bae ben ot
FTE Rink, itl nc lO ORES ie bee FS
ee ee ae eee
: er
ae ARIE EERO OR
30
employed with Procter and Gamble since about 1933. I
assume this has been a full time position since 1933, is
that correct?
A. I have been employed by the company during that
entire interval, yes.
Q. In other words you had been employed on a forty
hour work week basis regularly for that period of time?
A. I don’t punch the clock, but it’s at least that.
Q. Would you say as a rule you put in forty hours
a week?
A. Yes.
Q. More than forty hours a week?
A. Yes.
Q. Fifty hours a week?
A. Probably.
Q. Sixty hours a week?
[33] A. I doubt it.
Q. Fifty-five hours a week?
THE COURT: Well, let’s say as an executive he puts
in at least forty hours a week or more. I think your po-
sition has been more or less that of an executive of Procter
and Gamble, most of that time certainly during the years
involved in this case.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THECOURT: You are still so employed.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Are you required to travel in your position?
A. Tosome extent.
Q. To what extent?
A. In recent years very little, perhaps two or three trips
a year. Earlier I had different functions with the company
where it involved a great deal of travel.
3]
Q. When you say recent years you mean the last three
years?
A. Three to five years.
Q. Prior to this recent period you had to do a great
deal of traveling; in terms of days, ten days, fifteen days a
month, what is it?
A. More like four or five days a month.
Q. What is your educational background, Mr. Snow?
Do [34] you have a college degree?
A. Yes, I was a graduate of Stanford University and
Harvard Graduate School of Business.
Q. And your prior background is in the business area,
Bachelor of Arts and Business, Bachelor of Science and
Business Administration?
A. I'm not sure I understand the question.
Q. What degrees do you hold, Mr. Snow?
A. Bachelor of Arts and Economics, Stanford, Master's
Degree in Business Administration at Harvard.
Q. Have you during the college days, did you take any
courses dealing with engineering?
A. No, sir.
Q. In your own name, Mr. Snow, have you ever filed
an application for a patent?
A. No.
Q. You have no patents ever issued to you?
A. No.
Q. You have indicated on direct examination that you
have known Mr. Trott for approximately thirty years.
Did you know Mr. Trott prior to the time you became em-
ployed with Procter and Gamble?
A. No.
Q. You then met Mr. Trott through your.association
with Procter and Gamble?
32
[35] A. Specifically Mr. Trott joined the company af-
ter I was already employed there.
Q. And have you spent the majority of your services
with P and G in Cincinnati?
A. Yes.
Q. And Mr. Trott, I assume, has done the same thing?
A. No. There was a period, resident of Cincinnati, yes,
and also a resident outside of the country because for a
period he was employed in the International Divisions, in-
cluding one job as manager of our business in Mexico.
Q. Did you have over the period of years a social re-
lationship with Mr. Trott?
A. Yes.
Q. To what extent was there a social relationship?
MR. DOAN: Objection, Your Honor.
THE COURT: [’ll sustain the objection. I don’t see
the relevance.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Are you related by marriage to Mr. Trott?
A. No.
Q. Do you have a daughter or son that’s married to —
MR. DOAN: Objection, Your Honor, I see no rele-
vancy.
THE COURT: What was the question, do you have
a daughter or son, what? Read the question, Miss Re-
porter.
(Question read.) .
[36] THE COURT: Do you want to complete your
question?
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Snow, do you have a son or daughter who was
married to one of Mr. Trott’s sons or daughters?
33
MR. DOAN: Objection, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Sustain the objection unless you can
point out to me some possible relevancy of a question of
that character.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we'll go to the next ques-
tion.
Q. Mr. Snow, let’s discuss a little bit, if you can,
your activity with this Burns Investment Company prior to
the time of the formation of the partnership, in other words
prior to July of 1965. Were you aware that Mr. ‘Trott was
working on this Trash burner concept?
Yes.
And how were you made aware of that fact?
Through discussion with him.
And where did those discussions take place as a rule?
As a rule I would say in his home.
And what was the occasion of your being present
at Mr. Trott’s home?
MR. DOAN: Objection, Your Honor.
THE COURT: What is the relevancy of that question?
Tell me what you're driving at. Maybe I'll understand
it.
[37] MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, the issue involved
in this case is in determining if there was an existing
trade or business in the year 1966 with respect to the Burns
Investment Company. Mr. Snow was a full time executive
with Procter and Gamble, he spent many hours with that
company. |
THE COURT: Now isn’t it a question of whether or
not he is engaged in a trade or business, I gathered from
the opening statements, whether he is engaged in a trade
or business of inventing and developing patents.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, that is true. The issue
does relate to Mr. Snow personally, but it also relates to the
O>O>O>
x tte Sb TE Br MAME Ie nF
ee
34
partnership entity Burns Investment Company. Were My
an existing trade or business in 1966, and it is Respondent's
position that they were not.
THE COURT: You mean that the partnership was not
in existence at that time?
MR. JANSEN: No, Your Honor, we acknowledge the
existence of the partnership but we don’t believe that they
were an existing trade or business from the standpoint that
they were a going trade or business.
THE COURT: [I'll sustain the objection.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Snow, you have indicated that you were aware
of the existence of this product concept that Mr. Trott was
developing at this time. Did you actually perform any
services [38] with Mr. Trott prior to the formation of the
partnership in developing this product concept?
A. I would answer that by saying depending on your
definition of service. I was familiar with the concept, I
had a good deal of confidence in it, I saw the crude proto-
type model demonstrated on a number of occasions, and
participated in initial thinking with regard to how the
product might eventually be marketed, sold, trade-marked
and so forth.
THECOURT: May interrupt and see if I can shorten
this a little bit. Was-Mr. Trott an inventor?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THE COURT: Did he invent this from the mechani-
cal standpoint?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THECOURT: This Trashaway or incinerator, he’s the
one who invented it.
THE WITNESS: Yes. |
THE COURT: And you knew he was working on it.
$5
THE WITNESS: I certainly did.
THE COURT: Before you became a limited partner,
I believe, in the Burns Investment Company.
THE WITNESS: Correct.
THE CQURT: And you had discussions with Mr.
Trott about what he was doing, which eventually led you
into entering into partnership with him.
[39] THE WITNESS: Yes.
THE COURT: For the purpose of putting it on the
market so as to be able to sell it, complete the development,
ell it and make a profit.
THE WITNESS: Hopefully make a profit.
THE COURT: What more do you need?
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we'll turn to a different
area of questioning.
THE COURT: Behind all that whatever the partner-
ships were in, is the principal question as far as Mr. Snow
is concerned whether he was in a trade or business of this
character.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. That's right, Your Honor. Mr. Snow —
THE COURT: I think it’s a little more simple than
you're trying to make it, both of you.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Snow, I hand you what has been marked for
identification purposes as Joint Exhibit 1-A which is, this
is actually your Federal income tax return for the year
1966. Schedule C of that return at item A at the top,
would you read Item A of the tax return.
THE COURT: Well, ask him your question. The ex-
hibit is in evidence. What is it you're trying to develop?
MR. JANSEN: Item A reads principal business [40]
activity, “thoroughbred race horse operation.”
36
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, canes That has nothing
to do with the case.
THECOURT: Heis pointing out what is contained in
an exhibit you jointly filed in this case. This is Exhibit
1-A.
MR. JANSEN: It is Schedule C. I don’t believe the
pages are numbered. It is the first Schedule C shown
on the return.
THE COURT: The return speaks for itself. You're
asking him what it shows on there.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Snow, how many hours during the year 1966
did you devote to this business?
A. Which business.
Q. Item A as indicated on this Schedule C, thorough
bred race horse operation?
THE COURT: Just a moment, I'm evidently looking
at a different one than you are.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, it is the second Schedule C
in the tax return.
MR. JANSEN: Unfortunately, Your Honor, the pages
are not marked or numbered.
THE COURT: Apparently there is more than one
Schedule C attached and you're looking at one of them. All
[41] right, go ahead and ask your question. The exhibit
shows on that particular Schedule C in answer to principal
business activity “Thoroughbred Race Horse Operation.”
Another one over there refers to similar question as oil
operator, M G O Stone Oil Company. I don’t know
whether there are any more in here or not. It’s in the
record. .
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. The question is with respect to the thorough bred
$7
race horse operation, how many hours per week or month
did you devote to that business, Mr. Snow, during the year
1966?
A. Well, that would be difficult if not impossible to
estimate.
Q. Would you try to make an estimate? Would you
say two hours a week, or what exactly —
A. I think that would — (nodded)
MR. DOAN: I object to the relevancy of the question.
THE COURT: The question is how much time he
spent in the business of the thorough bred race horse op-
eration. Can you give any estimate?
THE WITNESS: As I say it would be difficult to es-
timate, but my best judgment would be three or four hours
a week on the average, throughout the year. It’s different
from time to time.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. That's approximately twelve hours a month then?
[42] A. Well, that’s my best recollection.
Q. All right. Now, Mr. Snow with respect to the
other Schedule C, the Stone Oil Company. Did you devote
any time to the operation of that business in 1966?
A. Yes.
Q. Approximately how much time on a per week or
per, let’s make it on a per week basis.
A. In this instance I would estimate approximately an
hour a week.
Q. So with respect to both of these additional businesses,
Mr. Snow, you have estimated that you would devote ap-
proximately fifteen hours per month, in that correct.
A. If those add up in that fashion, yes.
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, directing your remarks to the
Echo Development Company which of course you joined
38
the partnership in 1965. Approximately how many hours
on a per week basis did you devote to that partnership in
1966?
A. I don’t recall.
Q. Did you devote any hours to Echo Development
Company in the year 1966?
A. Certainly.
Q. Could you estimate approximately how many?
A. It would be very difficult because at that time, work-
ing with various partners and Mr. Trott, we had many dis-
cussions, most of them after P and G hours, on the prospects
[43] of these inventions and these devices.
Q. Well, would you say, if you had many discussions,
Mr. Snow, would you say on an average, couldn’t you
give us an average as to approximately how much time was
devoted to this business?
A. Which business?
Q. Echo Development Company.
A. Possibly an hour a week.
Q. One hour a week, approximately four hours a
month?
A. Hmm hmm.
Q. With respect to Courier Enterprises, of which you
were a partner in 1966, approximately how many hours per
week did you devote to that operation?
A. I'd say perhaps an hour. That’s the best off hand
judgment. This is almost impossible to allocate your time
twenty-four hours a day.
Q. I understand that you're approximating. Finally
Burns Investment came into existence during July of 1966,
tax returns which have been stipulated indicate that busi-
ness was commenced on August | of 1966; between August
1 of 1966 and December 31, 1966, approximately how many
39
hours per week did you devote to Burns Development
Company?
A. I can’t recall.
Q. Would you say that the number is similar to the
number of hours spent on Echo and Courier?
[44] A. Similar but I absolutely cannot recall.
Q. Approximately.
A. Even approximately is very difficult. You must un-
derstand that.
Q. You have indicated, Mr. Snow, that you did spend
approximately one hour per week with respect to each one
of these partnerships. How was that time spent?
A. The time was spent primarily in discussions with
Mr. Trott with reference to each of the inventions and
enterprises and prospects, the way it should ultimately be
marketed and at times in watching demonstrations of these
devices.
Q. Were these formal meetings called by Mr. Trott and
yourself?
A. In some instances.
Q. How were the meetings called? Were all the part-
ners present?
A. In some instances, yes. In others, no.
Q. Was there a written piece of correspondence which
summoned all the partners together for a formal business
meeting?
A. I can not recall. My recollection is that we met sev-
eral times on the basis of telephone conversations.
Q. Where were the meetings held, Mr. Snow?
A. Some of them were held in the offices of Cross Bow
which was earlier referred to. That's a corporation in which
[45] Mr. Trott is involved.
THE COURT: We'll recess for lunch until two
o'clock.
wens ne i tl i 6 AS a lan ie A
40
(Whereupon, at 12:30 p.m. a recess was taken until 2:00
o'clock p.m.)
[46] AFTERNOON SESSION 2:00 p.m.
THE COURT: Are you ready to proceed?
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: All right, Mr. Snow, do you want to
come back to the witness stand? And it is a witness stand.
CROSS EXAMINATION (cont’d.)
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, before we broke for lunch we were
discussing the amount of time you spent with Burns and
Echo and Courier and this line of questioning. Now to pick
up this afternoon, on direct examination this morning, you
indicated that one of your activities with Burns Invest-
ment Company was to counsel on the development of the
product. It that a proper restatement of your testimony
this morning?
A. Yes, one of them.
Q. How exactly did you counsel on the development of
the product?
A. The original prototype which embodied the basis
of the path or the mechanical way of putting air into
this thing to get stronger combustion to my mind was
housed in something that was unwieldy, not as portable
as it should be, not as attractive as it should be, so I was
one among others who felt the design could be improved
and would be more marketable or we'd sell more or make
more profit out of it if some further refinements in de-
sign were made, and I had some specific [47] suggestions
along the directions I thought this should take in view of
my own concern.
4]
Q. Do you recall when the suggestions were made with
respect to this particular innovation in the design?
A. Not specifically, but I would judge it was over a
period of time as the design developed. It might readily
have started in late 65 as a matter of fact, at which time
there was a prototype device.
Q. As I interpret your response to that question, this is
one innovation that you have recommended in regard to this
trash burner?
A. Yes.
Q. Can you give us some examples of other innovations
you may have suggested?
THE COURT: Let me ask one question. Were these
suggestions of yours, did they mainly have to do with the
looks of it, or did they have anything whatsoever to do
with the mechanical operation of it? Was it to make it
more attractive looking to a purchaser?
THE WITNESS: Primarily, yes.
THE COURT: Why do you need to go so far into
that?
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we're going to get away
from that area in just a moment.
Q. Mr. Snow, this morning there was admitted into evi-
dence a letter dated December 10, 1965 which was addressed
[48] to Mr. Trott, which you identified the contents of as
coming from Mr. Konold who was a patent attorney.
This is Petitioner's Exhibit number 24.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Mind you, Mr. Snow, this letter is dated December
10, 1965. Are you familiar basically with the contents of
this letter?
A. Yes.
Q. I notice in here that there are various suggestions
made as to how improvements can be made on this design
42
product concept of Mr. Trott’s. Were these improvements
subsequently made to the trash burner?
A. I can’t answer that precisely because I frankly have
not read that letter for four or five years. So the ones
specifically mentioned by the attorneys I cannot be sure
they were followed or to what degree they were followed.
Q. Also this morning, Mr. Snow, you mentioned that
you were active in the marketing of the Burns Development
Company product. Can you recall what marketing efforts
you expended in 1966 in regard to the Burns product?
A. In a general way, yes, and here I might do a little
volunteering. I feel with thirty years with P and G ex-
perience primarily in marketing, I have faced, marketing
problems on scores of products, many hundreds of kinds,
and you face a little expertise here, if you will. This could
be sold through [49] agents, distributors, it could be sold
through direct mail, through television advertising, many,
many different ways in which there was advertising and
marketing, and Mr. Trott and I had many, many conver-
sations as to the probable direction in which we should go
or at least should test various ways and try to find out how
muct it cost in relation to the return we got to find the
best way of putting it to market.
Q. Specifically then, getting back to my original ques-
tion, what efforts did you expend in the marketing field
with respect to Burns’ product in 1966?
A. I would answer a great deal, but I cannot put it in
terms of time. Some times you can see a problem and
see a solution rather rapidly, and other times wake up in
the morning with an idea. You were questioning me
earlier about how much time I put in. I'd say a great
part of my time was not spent in meetings as such but
thinking about the over all problem and trying to get
some points of view.
4$
Q. Mr. Snow, keeping this area of examination in your
mind, with respect to the Burns venture, this morning you
mentioned that Mr. Trott’s concept of this trash burner was
a unique idea.
A. Yes.
Q. Do you recall that?
A. Yes, indeed. I depended on it.
Q. With respect to Burns, at the time of the formation
[50] of this partnership in July of 1965, were you aware
of any guarantees made by any party that a patentable
product would subsequently result from the research and
development work done by Cross Bow Inc.?
A. May I ask you to check your date? I think it was
July 1966.
Q. Right, did I say ’65? It was July 1966.
A. Now may I have the question again?
Q. Sure. With respect to Burns Development Com-
pany at the time of the formation of this partnership
in July of 1966, were you aware of any guarantees which
were made by any party that the ultimate effect of the
research and development work performed by Cross Bow
would lead to a patented product?
A. For myself I had strong assurances from that letter
to which we just referred, from patent counsel, I believe it
was dated December 10, 1965?
Q. Now, Mr. Snow, I mentioned the word guarantees.
Did anybody tell you this product would ultimately be
patentable?
A. Well, they could not, let me say that that letter
and subsequent conversations with more than one partner
of that law firm and with independent people led me to
believe rather strongly that their opinion was correct. I’m
not an expert in patentability, I had to rely on counsel.
Q. Lunderstand that. In July of 1966 then, at the time
44
you made your initial investment in the partnership, did
[51] you feel that there was some risk involved?
A. Yes.
Q. Definitely. So then the venture itself was specula-
tive in nature?
A. Yes.
Q. Mr. Snow, this morning also you mentioned that
in 1966 and I may have misinterpreted your response, that
Burns was involved in a manufacturing process in 1966.
Let me ask you the question this way, to your knowledge
was Burns Development Company involved in any manu-
facturing of any product in the year 1966?
A. Yes, but I’m repeating that to the best of my recol-
lection they were largely assembling components that were
made by other manufacturers along with manufacturing
some themselves. It was not the full manufacturing and
delivery of a unit by someone else to the Burns Corpora-
tion.
Q. Where was this assembly taking place?
A. In the building that’s occupied by the Cross Bow,
Inc.
Q. Were those Burns employees that were doing the
assembling?
A. Some of them may have been, but my recollection is
that Cross Bow undertook to do a lot of this based on an
understanding as to how much of the cost of an individual
would be charged to Burns and how much to some of the
other things they [52] might have been doing.
Q. This morning —
A. May I mention here —
Q. Sure.
A. Some of the same people might have been involved
in work on Echo Development to which we referred earlier,
and there had to be some agreement as to how much time
45
would be allocated to the various partnerships and enter-
prises.
Q. To your knowledge, Mr. Snow, in 1965 at the time
the Echo Development Company, the partnership came
into existence, was the product of Echo marketable at that
time?
A. Yes.
Q. In 1965 at the time of the formation of the part-
nership the Echo product was marketable?
A. Yes.
Q. What efforts did you expend in 1965 in marketing
that product?
A. I counseled with Mr. Trott and others on a num-
ber of occasions as to how it should best be marketed and
we concluded in this instance by trying to interest another
manufacturer in licensing. We then had a patent applied
for our product in undertaking its manufacture and sale
on a royalty basis.
Q. Did you contact third persons in regard to that?
A. I did not personally.
[53] Q. Were you charged with the marketing efforts
with respect to Echo?
A. No, Mr. Trott was principally making the contacts
and several of us, I think quite importantly were talking
with him from time to time about the results and directing
his attention to potential customers.
Q. With respect to Courier in the year 1965 at the time
of that formation, the formation of that partnership, was
that product marketable?
A. Could I cut through this by saying I think Echo
and Courier were in the same situation.
Q. Did you personally make any contacts with respect
to marketing that product with respect to Courier?
A. No, sir.
46
Q. Mr. Snow, we have stipulated in this case the 1965,
1966 and 1967 partnership returns of Echo Development
Company and Courier Enterprises. On none of those re-
turns are there any sales reported and I assume no sales
were ever made during those years?
A. That is true.
Q. Why were no sales made?
A. Because the product itself was never offered for sale
to my knowledge. The marketing effort there and the best
judgment of all of us we should attempt to market the de-
vice and the patent in terms of getting another manufac-
turer to [54] take it on on a licensing basis and undertake
its manufacture and market.
Q. With respect to that effort, what efforts did you
expend in contacting other manufacturers?
A. I personally as I mentioned before did not contact
anyone.
Q. Mr. Snow, directing your attention to the Burns In-
vestment Company only, to the best of your knowledge do
you know if at any time subsequent to the year 1966 serious
consideration was given to abandoning that project?
A. I can only speak for myself and just say that I have
had and continue to have great confidence, and I'd like
to own more of it.
Q. The question is do you know if serious considera-
tion was given by yourself personally or by the partnership
as a whole to abandoning that project?
A. Not to my recollection, no. There might have been
some partner that might have had some misgivings about —
it.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, that’s all the questions I
have.
THE COURT: Any further questions on redirect?
47
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, may I ask Mr. Snow just
two questions.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. DOAN:
[55] Q. Mr. Snow, you testified that you spent per-
haps one hour per week per venture, on Echo, Courier and
Burns. Now, did you mean you spent that much time, was
that the total effort you exdended on these projects?
A. By no means, no. If I answered it in that fashion,
I can’t recollect how much time I spent twenty-four hours
a day five or six years ago. I spent that amount of time ac-
tually in discussion, in meetings, on the telephone or other-
wise, with Mr. Trott, but I was thinking of the problem
for many odd hours as one does in developing a business.
Q. You stated that your area of activity was primarily
concerned with the design, trade mark and the marketing
effort. In your opinion is this the type of activity that you
spend time just thinking about it as opposed to the time
you would spend in actual discussion with for example Mr.
Trott.
A. As I understand your question there is a great deal
of time and effort, if you call thinking about something
effort, when you’re not actually talking with someone or
discussing it with someone.
Q. And it is your testimony you did spend a great deal
of time in that activity, that is mental activity?
A. I’m saying considerable time. I don’t know —
Q. And that time was devoted to these three projects?
A. Yes, sir.
MR. DOAN: No further questions.
[56] THE COURT: You may stand aside. Call your
next witness.
(Witness excused.)
-
K
:
'
z
a
}
Fy
:
q
i
nt
;
Y
:
j
. Or i ore
pe FS BPG:
48
MR. DOAN: We have no further witnesses for Peti-
tioner, Your Honor.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, Respondent would like
to call Mr. David H. Trott.
David H. Trott
was called as a witness on behalf of the Responi-
dent, and, having been first duly sworn, testified
as follows: ,
THE CLERK: State your name and address for the
record.
THE WITNESS: David H. Trott, 2444 Madison Road,
Cincinnati, 45208.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Trott, were you at one time employed by Proc-
ter and Gamble?
A. Yes, I was.
Q. Are you still employed by Procter and Gamble?
A. No. ‘
Q. Are you retired from Procter and Gamble?
A. I resigned.
Q. What year did that resignation take effect?
A. 1963:
[57] Q. Prior to 1963 about how long did you work
for Procter and Gamble?
A. Twenty-two and a half years.
Q. And as briefly as possible, during that period in what
areas were your efforts expended?
A. The areas I was active in were advertising, market-
ing on a somewhat broader basis, and general manage-
ment
49
Q. During that period of time were you associated
with Mr. Snow?
A. Yes, I was.
Q. And exactly what was that association?
A. He was my first superior when I went to work at
Procter and Gamble in 1942. During my years there I
would say he was my superior for a longer cumulative
time than any other person in Procter and Gamble.
Q. Can you explain very briefly the levels of, your de-
velopment within Procter and Gamble, did you hold title
positions?
A. Yes, my first job in Cincinnati after finishing sales
training was as a copy supervisor in charge of development
of advertising copy. I was then a product manager or a
brand manager. I was subsequently an associate brand pro-
motion manager. I was then Vice President and General
Manager of Procter and Gamble in Mexico and I returned
to the United States and was Advertising Manager for the
International [58] Division, a job I held on my resignation.
Q. So in essence your efforts expended for P and G
were in the area of marketing as were Mr. Snow's?
And management.
What college degrees do you hold?
Liberal Arts, B.A.
You hold no degrees in engineering or science?
No, sir.
Prior to the year 1965 have you ever had any other
business ventures with Mr. Snow?
A. Not on any formal basis, no.
Q. I assume then on an informal basis there was some
type of business venture?
A. I guess the answer to that has to be no, there were
no ventures, although Mr. Snow was at all times pretty
conversant with what I was up to.
OPOrO>r
'
50
Q. Directing your attention only to the Burns Invest-
ment Company and the trash burner project, when did the
idea, or was the idea yours for the trash burner?
A. Yes.
Q. At what point in time did that idea come, I guess
you created the idea?
A. Let me answer this way. The identification of what
I thought was the problem and the need occurred in late
‘63, shortly before I resigned from Procter and Gamble.
The idea [59} concerning what to do about that problem,
the problem being the disposal of leaves and trash, the first
idea what to do about that problem did not occur until
1964. The final, what we hoped would be the final resolu-
tion of the problem occurred in 1966.
Q. Approximately how much time between 1964 and
1966 at the time of the coming into existence of the part-
nership Burns Investment Company, how much time did
you devote to the development of that project personally?
A. Between '64 and ‘66?
Q. Right. On a weekly basis or a monthly basis that
you could give the Court an estimate?
A. I would say during that time at least a third of
my time was devoted to it.
Q. And during that same period you were still em-
ployed with Procter and Gamble.
A. No, I resigned from Procter and Gamble in 1963.
THE COURT: When did you say the idea for this
incinerator occurred to you?
THE WITNESS: The concept that there ought to be
an incinerator for the purpose of disposing of leaves and
trash occurred to me in ‘63, at which time I was still
employed by Procter and Gamble. |
THE COURT: All right.
51
BY MR. JANSEN:
[60] Q. Now, Mr. Trott, between 1964 and July of
1966, would you estimate the amount of expense you in-
curred in developing this idea?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Now, involved in this matter today, Mr. Trott, we
have three partnerships, Echo, Courier and Burns Invest-
ment Company of which you are a partner of all three.
Was this identifying the product concept and then the
subsequent development on your own and the partnership
coming into existence, was this general procedure followed
in each instance?
A. With the exception of Echo.
Q. How did that differ?
A. Echo was a project which in a sense I inherited when
I first became involved in Cross Bow. It was a project
then in existence which had been carried on to’a certain
stage of development by the prior owners of Cross Bow.
Burns on the other hand, and Courier, were products in
which I was solely involved at the inception. |
Q. Now, with respect to Burns Development and the
trash burner, can you describe for the Court essentially the
stage of development of that trash burner in January of
1966 or in the early part of 1966?
A. We had built a number of experimental models
prior to that time with varying degrees of success. We had
at that time to the best of my recollection a model and
pretty clear [61] cut specific ideas about how to bring that
model to a state of commercial and practical effectiveness.
We also had the opinion of the patent attorney which has
been identified here before that we had a pretty good
patent position.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, Petitioner's Exhibit No. 23 which
is dated February 22, 1966, and is a letter addressed to you
iaas ebiel Malta ak: wr,
stl alates pt eat og
ee eee
& pk ple MeO San nie Det
SS Pea aA ah ree hole ana at AR,
52
and signed by Mr. Konold, seems to indicate that there
was more than one type of a burner involved.
A. Hmm hmm.
Q. Was there what is called an institutional type trash
burner?
At that time?
Yes.
Yes.
Was that the only burner?
No.
In. January of 1966?
(Shook head.)
The letter refers to two models, Mr. Trott, could
you distinguish between the two models.
A. I preface that by saying to the best of my recollec-
tion, I think we must have had twenty-six or twenty-seven
models. The two referred to I believe are one which was
built around a garden tractor and which used as its power
source the motor of the tractor. The other one was a
wheel-about inciner- [62] ator which had its own inde-
pendent power source.
Q. With respect to both of those models, were they
aimed primarily at the industrial market?
A. No.
Q. I notice in the letter, Mr. Trott, that at paragraph
two of page two it is indicated that the two models of the
leaf burner are big institutional type devices and an ob-
jective is to make a smaller leaf burner which will be
salable to the individual home owners. Do you get the im-
pression from reading that letter that at that time there
did not exist a smaller model which was saleable to the
home owner?
A. I think it would be speculative to say that without
actually having tried to sell a particular model.
POPE PO p
53
Q. Mr. Trott, prior to the time that this letter was
sent to you, did Mr. Konold observe any demonstrations
of your trash burner?
A. I believe so but I can’t be sure.
Q. The last sentence of paragraph one of this letter
indicates “this opinion is based on my ¢xamination cf the .
leaf burner and my discussion with you of the tests which
you have made on them” which would seem to indicate
he did observe the two institutioual models he referred to
in this letter.
Al I thought in your questioning you were referring
to prior to this.
Q. That was my question, yes.
[63] A. Prior, yes.
Q. Where did these demonstrations take place?
A. At Cross Bow.
Q. Mr. Trott, now bearing in mind the nature of the
models as they existed in approximately the early part of
December 1966, would you draw a contrast between that
model and the patented model?
A. From the standpoint of design, mechanical opera-
tion?
Q. Over all, right, from the standpoint of design,
exterior design.
A. Well, the basic difference between the two in terms
of operation again as I recall those models at that time is
this, they had two air inlets, one at the bottom and one
at the top of the burning chamber. Both air spurces de-
rived from the same blower. The model as it now exists
has a single opening at the top of the chamber and none
at the bottom of the chamber.
Q. In terms of the type of drum, the burning unit
itself, how large was the unit that was used in 1966?
A. Somewhat larger than the present one which utilizes
a fifty-five gallon drum.
ee ere: |
‘nat GALE AEE AAA PRE A
VERRALL O62
tr E R s osets
Fes. 6ceale
Ptieadiglnte packith cote haem
54
Q. When you say somewhat larger, would you say
seventy gallons, a hundred gallon drum?
A. I would estimate 70 gallon, 65 to 70.
Q. The partnership agreement, the Burns Investment
[64] Company partnership agreement, Mr. Trott, is dated
July 8, 1966. What efforts did you expend prior to that
date with respect to third parties to raise capital to be
used in the development of the trash burner?
A. I gave the partners who had joined with me in
Courier a synopsis of the project, described it to them,
asked if they were interested in the project, and that was
all.
Q. So what you're saying is that the only parties who
were contacted were partners in another of your ven-
tures?
A. That’s right.
Q. Mr. Trott, why was the partnership formed in
1966?
A. To form a legal vehicle for this particular venture.
Q. Was it also formed in order to raise capital in
order to continue the development of this project?
A. Yes.
Q. What is your present association with Cross Bow,
Inc.?
A. I’m President and sole owner.
Q. And when did that association begin?
A. It began, I believe, in 1964 when I bought a twenty-
five percent interest. I gradually increased that until I
took over sole ownership I believe in December of 1965.
Q. So that in the year 1965 at the time both Echo and
Courier entered into agreements with Cross Bow you
owned approximately twenty-five percent interest in Cross
Bow?
A. Twenty-five to fifty.
55
[65] Q. And then subsequently in the year 1966 an
agreement was reachet with Burns and you still owned
twenty-five —
A hundred percent.
You owned a hundred percent in 1966?
Yes.
From whom did you buy the stock of Cross Bow?
From Robert Boggild and William Dale.
Is the Robert Boggild the same individual who was
a partner in both Echo and Courier?
A. Right.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, can you give us an example of, in
the year 1966, of the type of services or products that were
sold by Cross Bow, Inc.
A. Yes, in 1966 our commercial activities apart from
product development which was our primary activity con-
sisted of making and selling a novelty item under the
trade name Drinklight, and doing job shop work for cus-
tomers in the fabricating and machining business.
Q. Isee. Was that Cross Bow’s sole product in 1966,
the Drinklight?
A. It was the sole product manufactured in volume.
Q. Were other products manufactured?
‘A. We made other products for other people, but none
of them in mass production.
Q. Isee. Does Cross Bow itself have a manufacturing
[66] plant?
A. Yes.
Q. Which is located where?
A. 5240 Worcester Road.
Q. Is that the same location where Cross Bow was
located in 1966? :
A. No, it is not.
Q. What was the address in 66?
Orroroo >
7
,
‘
i
‘
i A la i gh a ie
CSS Se Ng LITT ae el re
56
A. It was Blue Ash Road, I don’t recall the exact
street address.
Q. How does 8120 sound? .
A. There were two places on Blue Ash Road, that’s
why I couldn’t remember.
Q. Does 8120 sound like the correct address?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you presently draw a salary from Cross Bow?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you draw a salary in 1966?
A. No.
Q. During the year 1966 did Cross Bow enter into a
contractual agreement with Burns Investment Company?
A. Not any written agreement that we were able to
determine. There was an oral understanding, an under-
standing within the partnership that the work done on be-
half of Burns Investment would be done more or less on
the same basis we had [67] been doing work for Courier
and Echo in which case there was a written contractual
agreement.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, have you searched your records
with respect to Burns Investment to determine if you could
locate a written contract between Burns and Cross Bow,
Inc.?
A. Yes.
Q. And you have also checked Cross Bow’s records and
you could locate no written contract?
A. The answer is no.
MR. JANSEN: I'm sorry, could you repeat that ques-
tion again?
(Question read.)
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. JANSEN: Would you mark this.
THE CLERK: Respondent’s Exhibit W marked for
identification.
57
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Re-
spondent’s Exhibit W.)
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Trott, I hand you what has been marked for
identification as Respondent's Exhibit W. Can you identi-
fy that document?
A. This is a letter from D. H. Trott to Robert Boggild
dated April 28, 1965, the subject of which —
Q. That’s enough. The D. H. Trott whose signature
[68] appears on that letter is one and the same D. H. Trott
that is here today, is that right? That's you.
A. Right.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, this letter, does this represent
the understanding that existed between Cross Bow and
Courier Enterprises with respect to the work that Cross
Bow was to do for Courier?
A. Correct.
Q. Was there a similar letter which was also written
by yourself with respect to the Echo Development Com-
pany concerning the services that Cross Bow was to render
for Echo Development Company?
A. Right?
Q. Was that letter similar in nature to this one?
A. Yes.
Q. Now concerning the Burns Investment Company,
as I understand your testimony you have indicated that
you can not find a writing evidencing the understanding
that existed between Burns and Cross Bow, is that correct?
A. Right.
Q. Are you sure, Mr. Trott, that there is no. written
contract evidencing any relationship, legal relationship
between Cross Bow and Burns?
A. Not a hundred percent sure, no.
earn eset PRY
on 1h se MTtobe, of
Al NS ht aN cn Od Be
58
Q. You have diligently searched the files of Cross Bow
[69] and Burns and there is no letter to be found.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, I believe counsel is getting
repetitious and he is also leading his witness.
THE COURT: If that’s an objection, it’s immaterial
at this point. I'll let the testimony stand. Avoid leading
and avoid repeating.
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor.
Q. Mr. Trott, do you have personal knowledge of the
understanding that existed between Burns Investment Com-
pany and Cross Bow, Inc.?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. What is that understanding?
A. I believe it is expressed in the invoices which are
a part of the record here, which consisted of a series of
hourly rates similar tothe Echo and Courier arrangement
for different types of work.
Q. Mr. Trott, I notice at Exhibit 2-B which is a copy
of the partnership agreement of Burns Investment Com-
pany, that it indicates that the purpose and business of the
partnership shall be the development of a special purpose
incinerator for the consumer and industrial markets. Now,
this development procedure, is that what Cross Bow was
doing for Burns Investment Company?
A. Yes.
Q. Did Burns Investment Company do any of that
devolp- [70] ment work itself with respect to the product
concept?
A. Yes. I as a partner in Burns Investment Company
did most of it.
Q. Where did that development take place, Mr. Trott?
A. It took place at Cross Bow and in the field.
Q. Now, with respect to Burns Investment Company,
where did that development take place?
59
A. At Cross Bow, Inc. out on Blue Ash Road and later,
well, 66 Blue Ash Road, and it took place at my residence
and in the neighborhood.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, with respect to the year 1966,
approximately what portion of the services rendered by
Cross Bow, Inc. were apportioned to Burns Investment
Company? Can you give us some idea?
A. Icouldn’t. I'd be flying blind.
Q. Okay. Other than Burns and Echo and Courier
during the years 1965 and 1966, did Cross Bow have
contracts with any other parties for doing similar type
work?
A. Yes.
Q. Approximately how many contracts, do you have
any idea?
A. During what period of time?
Q. 1965 and 1966.
A. It might have been as many as twenty-five different
customers.
[71] Q. To your knowledge, Mr. Trott, at the time
that Cross Bow entered into these contracts with the three
partnerships, did Cross Bow make any type of a guarantee
that their work would lead to a patent on any product?
A. No hard and fast guarantee, iron clad guarantee,
no, but the probability was held out that we would get
a patent in each case.
Q. So then with respect to each partnership there was
a certain amount of speculation involved?
A. Correct.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, with respect to Joint Exhibit 2-B,
I notice that the principal office and place of business of
Burns Investment Company was 8120 Blue Ash Road,
that is Cross Bow’s offices, is it not?
A. It was at that time.
Wi tina thal ie alle
60
Q. Now, could you describe for me basically the build-
ing facility itself at 8120 Blue Ash Road?
A. We had approximately five thousand square feet of
space of which maybe on the main floor, of which maybe
a thousand feet was devoted to office, design and drafting,
and the rest to shop and ‘manufacturing facilities. We had
a basement which was probably around four thousand
square feet. :
Q. Now, what portion of that total nine thousand
square feet was used by Burns Investment Company?
A. I can’t answer that, I don’t know. It varied, [72]
depending on what we were doing at any given time. -
Q. Why did it vary?
A. The project would be considerably more active, or
likely to be during the fall than it was during the dead
summer.
Q. When you refer to the project you're referring to
the —
A. Incinerator.
Q. You're referring to the work being performed under
the terms of the oral agreement, is that correct, and the
individuals that were performing that work were Cross
Bow employees, is that right?
A. Except for myself.
Q. Then I don’t believe we can say that any space
occupied by those employees occupied space of the Burns
Development Company. I’m referring to the Burns De-
velopment Company offices and employees, what percentage
of that total five thousand, nine thousand square feet was
used by Burns Development Company employees?
A. If we consider me as an employee of Burns, perhaps
five percent.
Q. Five percent comprising your office? And were
you paid by the Burns Investment Company?
61
A. Not directly, no.
Q. Was your service which you performed billed to the
[73] Burns Investment Company by Cross Bow, Inc?
A. Right.
Q. Therefore your compensation for services performed
on the contract came from Cross Bow rather than from
Burns, and therefore in essence we probably should elim-
inate your five percent space.
A. (No audible response.)
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, on the exterior of this building
was there any sign identifying it as the offices of Burns
Investment Company?
A. No.
Q. Did Burns Investment have a telephone in that
building?
A. No.
Q. Were there to your knowledge any employees in
that building who were compensated by Burns Investment
Company directly?
A. There was a consulting electronics engineer who
had space in that building and did some work for Burns
and was compensated directly by Burns.
Q. Is the Burns Investment corporation also presently
located at the Cross Bow, Inc. offices?
A. Yes.
Q. And those offices are now located on Worcester?
A. Right.
[74] Q. During the year 166, Mr. Trott, are you
aware of any marketing efforts that were made by yourself,
Mr. Snow, or any member of Burns Investment Company
to market a product as such in the year 1966?
A. No.
Q. During the year 1966 were you aware of the Burns
Investment Company having a manufacturing plant of its
own?
sip tele Pree;
So Db ts Bie ok aia ase
62
A. Not per se, no.
Q. Were*you aware or are you aware in the year
1966 of Burns Investment Company having any type of
an office or’ manufacturing plant facility?
A. If you mean its own separate facilities —
Q. Right.
A. ~No.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, we have stipulated that Joint Ex-
hibits 5-E through 9-I, the invoices which were sent by
Cross Bow to Burns Investment Company. I hand you
what has been marked for identification purposes as Joint
Exhibit 5-E which is invoice number 265 of Cross Bow,
Inc. and I ask you, Mr. Trott, would you vefy briefly
describe essentially the work which was performed by
Cross Bow, Inc. on this or for the benefit of Burns Invest-
ment Company.
A. Well, as this invoice shows, it was comprised of
shop time, designer time, and engineering time. The
shop time was the skilled labor devoted to building models,
working models [75] and. prototypes of the incinerator,
and the design and engineering time was work related to
the design and engineering of those models.
Q. Now, with respect to the second item here, designers
318 hours, who performed that design work?
A. As I recall there were, I believe we had two design-
ers on the payroll at that time.
Q. Of Cross. Bow, Inc. $
A. Right. ¢
Q. With respect to the next item, who performed the
engineering work?
A. That was largely Robert Boggild.
Q. Was that engineering work performed at Cross
Bow, Inc?
A. Right.
63
Q. I notice on this invoice, Mr. Trott, it is marked
paid-down here. Do you know who made that notation?
A, Our bookkeeper, I imagine.
Q. Did you personally cause this invoice to be sent
to Cross Bow, Inc., to Burns Investment?
A. To Burns, yes.
Q. Mr. Trott, the next exhibit which is Joint Exhibit
6-F indicates that there was shop work performed and
engineering work performed also. Was that work also
performed at Cross Bow, Inc?
[76] A. Yes.
Q. And did you personally cause this invoice to be
sent to Burns Investment Company?
A. Probably, yes.
Q. I notice on this invoice, Mr. Trott, that there “s are
some notations made at the bottom right hand corner with
respect to the papneen. Who do you think made those
notations?
A. Our bookkeeper I would imagine.
Q. I notice the first date of payment is August 5,
1966.
A. Correct.
Q. This invoice is dated: July 31, 1966 and the terms
are net thirty days.
A. Right.
Q. Now precisely how was this payment transacted?
A. By check.
Q. Could we trace the invoice to the Burns Invest-
ment Company which caused payment to be made? In
other words the invoice is made in Cross Bow, Inc.’s offices.
A. Right.
Q. Is it given to another individual who in turn causes
a check to be issued to Cross Bow, Inc?
A. I issued the check.
Q. You issued the check.
64
[77] A. Or checks.
Q. The date of payment on this Cross Bow invoice,
Mr. Trott, is August 5, 1966 and August 12, 1966. Was
there generally that type of time lag between payments? -
A. I don’t recall. I don’t recall the circumstances
- which led to that type of payment.
Q. Joint Exhibit 7-G, Mr. Trott, is the same type of
invoice from Cross Bow, Inc. and it has design work,
engineers’ work, consultant work and miscellaneous ma-
terials. Was that work also performed at Cross Bow, Inc?
A. Yes, with the possible exception of that consultant
work. I don’t recall exactly what that was.
Q. Joint Exhibit 8-H, Mr. Trott, shows an invoice y
billing Burns for $12,500.00 for project management ser- —
vices. Who performed those services?
A. I did.
Q. That’s a lot of money for management services.
- Could you elaborate upon your specific responsibilities in
billing Burns, Investment Company $12,500.00?
' A. That was, that reflected the amount of work I per-
sonally put in actively managing the project.
Q. Extending from what date?
A. I don’t recall.
Q. Was a portion of that billing attributable for man-
agement services performed prior to the time of the part-
nership?
[78] A. I would imagine so, I ‘can’t recall.
Q. Mr. Trott, Joint Exhibit 9-1, the type written state-
ment of the description of the items is kind of hazy in
there. Could you tell us what that description says?
A. I believe it says “balance on services rendered.”
Q. And would you happen to know when those ser-
vices were rendered?
A. No.
65
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, the invoices that we have just
seen were sent by Cross Bow to Burns for services rendered
during the year 1966. The total amount of those invoices
was $36,780.44. Now subsequent to the year 1966 did
Cross Bow, Inc. also Perform services for Burns Investment
Company?
A. Yes, it did.
Q. Were those services rendered to the approximate
same extent as they were in 1966?
At least.
For how long did this continue?
Until the formation of the corporation.
Which was in what year?
Spring of 69, I believe.
So from January 1 of 1967 to the spring of 1969
the development of this project continued at Cross Bow?
A. (Nodded.)
Q. Was Cross Bow, Inc. compensated for those services
[79] to the same extent they were in 1966?
A. No, they were not.
Q. Have they been compensated to this day for those
services?
A. No.
Q. Now, I believe that you testified before, Mr. Trott,
that one of the purposes of the formation of the partner-
ship in 1966 was to obtain capital for the continued de-
velopment of this product concept, is that correct?
A Ta
Q. Was Echo and Courier partnerships, were they also
created for the same purpose?
A. Essentially, yes.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, I notice in looking at the invoices
from Cross Bow to Burns and looking at the partnership
agreement relating to Burns Investment Company, the
word development and research permeates those docu-
OP>OrO>
eg ey
mnt
om ee
66
ments. At what stage was the development of the trash
burner in 1966 in comparison with the patented product?
A. I don’t quite know how to answer there. We had a
product on which we could have secured a patent at that
time. The product we have now is in some ways essential-
ly different. The product on which we got a patent, ap-
plied for a patent in 69 was no further developed from the
standpoint of being a finished manufactured product than
the project we had in 1966.
[80] THE COURT: Mr. Jansen, could you tell me
what you're trying to develop with this line of testimony?
I’ve let you run on and on, yet for the life of me I can’t
see what you're driving at.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we have covered a lot
in the last half hour and I think I’m about ready to
summarize.
THE COURT: What is the issue here that you're
establishing?
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, we are concerned with
showing that there in fact was no operating, existing trade
or business known as Burns Development Company in
the year 1966. There was no product to sell, the product
itself had not been developed to the point where it could
become acquainted with the commercial market, the office
facilities were located at Cross Bow, Inc. which was the
corporation performing the research work on that project.
Your Honor, we are trying to show that in essence there
was nothing more than a paper existence for all three of
those partnerships.
THE COURT: Was it paper money they paid?
MR. JANSEN: Mr. Trott just indicated that in one
instance he didn’t receive payment, Your Honor.
THE COURT: There were checks mentioned.
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor.
67
THE COURT: All right. I have difficulty in seeing
the issue, but I understand a little better what you're
[81] driving at, but you're taking up an awful lot of time.
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor, I understand.
THE COURT: Cut it short.
MR. JANSEN: We're just about finished.
THE COURT: Aill right.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Trott, in 1966 where were the Echo offices
located?
A. They were domiciled with Cross Bow.
Q. Where were Courier offices located?
A. The same.
Q. So the three partnerships in Cross Bow’s offices were
all located in a facility of which the space was consumed
approximately a hundred percent by Cross Bow?
Were there any markings on the building which
would identify it as Echo or Courier offices?
A. No. Echo did have a telephone because it was a
telephone answering device which needed a telephone.
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, one final question. Subsequent
to the year 1966, at any time did the Burns Investment
Company [82]. either the partnership known as the Burns
Investment Company consider abandoning that trash
burner project?
A. No.
Q. Let me ask the question again. Subsequent to the
year 1966 did either yourself or any other members of
A. Hmm hmm.
Q. Now did Echo have a telephone?
A. No.
Q. Did Courier have a telephone?
A. No.
Q.
68
the partnership known as the Burns Investment Company
consider abandoning that project.
MR. WALKER: Object to that question. This man
can’t testify to what someone else considered.
THE COURT: I think you're asking him to testify
what was in the mind of other people. Maybe you can
bring it out with a different type of question. I'll sustain
the objection.
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Trott, subsequent to the year 1966 did you
personally ever entertain any thoughts of abandoning that
trash burner project?
A. Not the project, no.
Q. What aspect of the project did you consider aban-
doning?
A. An approach on which we had worked at some
length appeared limited and it became quite clear that we
probably would have to take a different approach to it.
Q. When you refer to approach what exactly do you
mean? The outside exterior portion of the patented
burner?
[83] A. It related to the mechanical functioning of
the product.
Q. Assuming you were to have abandoned that ap-
proach, would that have necessitated a complete redoing
of all the efforts that you had expended in the past year
in developing that particular aspect of the project?
A. No. Asa matter of fact we changed the approach
quite fundamentally partially as I explained earlier in
terms of the reduction of air inlets from two to one. We
made some other changes, so in effect we radically changed
the mechanical approach to the product.
Q. At what point in time did that radical change take
place?
69
A. I believe in 1968.
Q. And the subsequent patent application was filed in
1969?
A. I believe so. :
MR. JANSEN: That’s all we have, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Cross examine.
CROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Trott, have you had any training, experience
or education prior to joining Cross Bow in the area of
engineering and inventing product development?
A. Only incidental with Procter and Gamble. The
answer [84] is no.
Q. Mr. Trott, you testified that Burns, Echo and
Courier shared the facilities of Cross Bow, Inc. Did Burns,
Echo and Courier have any need for its own plant, its own
offices?
A. No.
Q. In your opinion as a business man would it have
been wise to incur expenses for rent and overhead that
you did not need? -
A. No.
Q. Mr. Trott, was the partnership income tax return
for Burns Investment Company examined for the taxable
year 1966? .
A. I don’t know. I think so. My recollection is yes.
Q. Did you have a conversation with an Internal Rev-
enue Agent who examined that return?
A. I don’t recall whether I did or not.
Q. You testified that numerous changes were made in
the trashaway that existed when the partnership was formed
in 1966, is that right?
70
A. Yes.
Q. Now these changes that were made, were they a
result of your efforts alone?
A. No, they were not. They were the results of my
efforts, the efforts of the designers and engineers who
worked [85] for Cross Bow, and also the members of the
partnership.
Q. Now did the members of the partnership Burns
Investment Company meet with you regularly during
1966?
A. Yes.
Q. And did you discuss these design changes, mechan-
ical functioning changes at those meetings?
A. Yes, we did.
Q. Did you discuss marketing problems?
A. Yes, we did.
Q. Did you discuss such things as patent position?
A. Ye.
Q. Trade mark?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you discuss whether or not Burns Investment
Company should engage in the manufacturing versus hav-
ing another manufacturer carry out this activity?
A. ie.
Q. Was Mr. Snow present at these meetings during
1966? J
A. He was present at most of them. i
Q. Did Mr. Snow participate in the decision making
process?
A. Yes, very much so.
Q. Did Mr. Snow participate in the over all manage-
ment of this project?
A. To a large degree, yes.
[86] Q. Did he participate in the over all manage-
ment of Courier Enterprises?
71
A. Yes.
Q. Did he participate in the over all management of
Echo Development? “
A. Yes, he did.
Q. Were these partnerships entered into for the pur-
pose of making a profit?
A. Yes, certainly.
Q. Mr. Trott, could all three of these ventures, the
Trashaway, the telephone answering device and the tape
recorder have been developed within one single partner-
ship?
A. They could have been if necessary.
Q. Why did you not use one single partnership?
A. Well, there were two reasons. One reason was
that we didn’t have identical participation in the partner-
ship from one venture to the next. Another reason is
it’s just good business to keep projects like that separated
and isolated so you can evaluate each on its own merits
and judge the progress.
Q. Mr. Trott, you testified that Cross Bow did similar
work for other clientele or other customers during the
same period of time.
A. Right.
Q. Was the work Cross Bow carried on for Burns,
Courier and Echo substantially different from what you
did for other [87] customers?
A. Talking in broad terms of product development, no.
Q. Was your activity as a partner in Burns Investment
Company substantially different from the activity of the
other partners?
A. It was different in that I got much more deeply
involved with the actual technical details of the design of
the product.
Q. Why was that?
‘ a9 sateen
4 a Fon
PE he ee
72
A. Because I was the closest one to the projects, the
only one in a position to watch every detail of development.
Q. In other words you were the general partner or
the managing partner?
A. Right.
Q. Mr. Trott, have you yourself as an individual been
classified as being in the trade or business of inventing?
MR. JANSEN: Objection, Your Honor.
THE COURT: ° Has he been classified as being in the
trade or business of being an inventory?
MR. DOAN: Yes, your Honor.
THE COURT: I don’t believe I quite —
MR. DOAN: The point is that Mr. Trott was a mem-
ber of the same partnership as Mr. Snow and Mr. Trott
has been identified as being in the trade or business of
inventing, yet he has testified that his activities in these
ventures was [88] substantially similar to Mr. Snow’s activi-
ties.
THE COURT: By whom has he been identified?
MR. DOAN: That was my next question, Your Honor.
Identified by the Internal Revenue Service.
THE COURT: Do you want to be heard on your
objection?
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor, I do. Your Honor,
any characterization that may have been made by any
member of the Internal Revnue Service with respect to
Mr. Trott is completely immaterial and irrelevant to the
issues in this case.
MR. DOAN: Mr. Trott was a member of the same
partnership, the same business venture, engaged in the
same activities.
THE COURT: Suppose he had been recognized as
an inventor, would that same thing apply to Mr. Snow?
MR. DOAN: No, Your Honor, but it would apply to
the partnership. Your Honor, we have cases that stand
73
for the principle of law, that a partner engaged in the
business of the partnership, by virtue of being a partner
in a partnership, the individual is engaged in that trade
or business. The Internal Revenue Service has said that
Mr. Trott is in the business of being an inventor.
THE COURT: I'll let you make your record on it,
Mr. Doan, but I’m not sure at this point what weight
or materiality will be given to it.
[89] BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Will you answer the question?
A. Can you repeat it please.
Q. Mr. Trott, have you been characterized or identi-
fied by the Internal Revenue Service as being engaged in
the trade or business of being an inventor?
Yes.
For what year?
I don’t recall.
Was it 1966?
Yes, it could be.
Was it the year in which the partnership return of
Burns Investment Company was examined?
A. I believe so.
MR. DOAN: I have no further question, Your Honor.
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, I have a couple questions
on redirect.
OPOPrOYS
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Mr. Trott, you just indicated that you met regular-
ly in 1966 with some of the other members of this partner-
ship. Generally where were those meetings held?
A. ‘They were held at a number of places. They were
held at Cross Bow, they were held at my house, they were
“4
mia
74
held in the residence of the partners. I can recall at least
two [90] dinner meetings in restaurants.
Q. Did any of those meetings ever revolve around social
events between the partners?
A. Some.
Q. Were any of those meetings ever held at Mr. Snow’s
home?
A... Yes:
Q. Were any of them ever held at your home?
a Tek
Q. Were any of. them ever held at other partners’
homes?
A. Yes.
-Q. Is there a pretty close social relationship existing
between the parties to the partnership?
A. Not as a group, no.
Q. But as individuals, there is?
A. Yes. :
Q. Are you close to Mr. Snow?
A. Yes. '
Q. Now, Mr. Trott, you also mentioned that you en-
tered into this partnership relationship with respect to
each one of these entities for the purpose of making a
profit, is that correct?
A. .\ Yes.
Q. In reading the partnership agreements, the purpose
of the partnership is stated in all three of these agreements
[91] to be the development of a product and obviously
from looking at the invoices research is = done by
Cross Bow, Inc.
MR. WALKER: Your Honor, I'll have to object on
the grounds that counsel is seeking to attack the testimony
of his own witness.
THE COURT: [I'll sustain the objection. You're ar-
guing also.
75
BY MR. JANSEN:
Q. Let me ask this question, Mr. Trott, at what point
in time did you anticipate making a _ profit?
A. When the partnership was formed we anticipated
making a profit very shortly or at least be able to proceed
definitely to make a profit.
Q. At some point in the future.
A. In the near future.
Q. At the time the partnership agreements were —.
THE COURT: Didn't you go over all that on your
direct? You're on redirect now.
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Henor.
Your Honor, that’s all the questions I have.
THE COURT: ‘The purpose if I understand in form-
ing these three partnerships was because they related to
different types of machinery or products?
THE WITNESS: Right.’
THE COURT: One being a lear burner or trash
burner, [92] another being a telephone answering service,
and another a tape recorder.
THE WITNESS: Correct.
THE COURT: Entirely different products. And one
purpose in having three, if I get the effect of your testi-
mony, was to hold cach of those businesses separate and
apart. Am I correct that the development of the machines
or whatever you made, the product itself, was carried on,
the engineering and the designing and so forth was carried
on largely by the Cross Bow Company? |
THE WITNESS: Correct.
THE COURT: You had the ideas and you got the
others to make, whatever you call them, the sample prod-
ucts originally and see if it would work?
THE WITNESS: Right.
~ THE COURT: Am I correct in that?
Pains i + Vis wale ae ih A ih.
Pe ee eT Te
fear
&* ? pe ‘ 2 *
VD RES a ABS LBS cb OCB AAT Si he ile st AOE an AE wh bit hee Soe
76
THE WITNESS: Essentially, yes.
THE COURT: Most of the engineering and design
work then under your supervision was done by Cross Bow?
THE WITNESS: That is right.
THE COURT: And you were managing Cross Bow
and you were also managing partner of these three part-
nerships. Most of the others with one or two exceptions
were limited partners?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THE COURT: You had the main responsibility for
the [93] management and conduct of that business.
THE WITNESS: That's correct.
THE COURT: What was the purpose of bringing in
the limited partners at all?
THE WITNESS: To provide funds and also assistance
in managing the ventures.
THE COURT: _ By assi8tance you mean advice and so
forth as you would get from anybody in the way you
operate and conduct a business? Not in the engineering
or the actual design — :
THE WITNESS: Not in the technical sense, but cer-
tainly from the standpoint of the way the design related
to the objective of the project or what would come out
of the project.
THE COURT: They might offer suggestions but it
wouldn't be in the sense of expert technical advice?
THE WITNESS: No.
THE COURT: All right. What was the extent of the
cash contributions of these limited partners, generally. —
THE WITNESS: In one particular, Burns for exam-
le, I believe that was forty thousand dollars. It’s in one
of the exhibits.
THE COURT: They contributed forty thousand dol-
lars and you contributed an equal amount?
77 .
THE WITNESS: No, I contributed right and title to
[94] the project when the partnership was formed.
THE COURT: You contributed more in the way of
know how and expeftise or the idea.
THE WITNESS: If I may, I'll take Burns as‘an exam-
ple. Prior to the formation of the partnership I funded
the development work. Then when the partnership was
formed, we utilized the funds contributed by the limited
partners. The agreement between Burns Partnership and
Cross Bow or me as the sole owner, was that Cross Bow
would carry the burden for that money to the point of
completion of the project, which we did, and we exhausted
the forty thousand dollars contributed by the partners, and
thereafter it was funded by me.
THECOURT: And that’s substantially the same thing
that happened with respect to the other two partners?
THE WITNESS: Yes, with respect to the work done
after the funds were exhausted.
THE COURT: I see in the Burns Investment Com-
pany the contribution of the limited partners was twenty,
ten and ten, a total of forty thousand dollars. I assume
the partnership agreements show their cash contribution.
THE WITNESS: Right.
THE COURT: Does either side want to ask anything
further? :
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor. At one point you
asked Mr. Arott if any of these partners were invited into
the partner- [95] ship because of their expertise. Mr. Trott
indicated that was not the case.
THE COURT: Expertise with respect to designing
and engineering.
MR. DOAN: Yes, Your Honor, and my point is that
I believe that’s too broad.
THE COURT: Whatever you believe about it, if you
ee eae 8
ee ened
78
want to ask him some questions you may do so. I have
certain beliefs myself.
RECROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Trott, did you rely on Mr. Snow for his exper-
tise in the area of designing products to any degree?
A. No, I did not rely on any technical or engineering
expertise. I relied on his expertise from the standpoint
of being able to evaluate design features from the market-
ing standpoint and other standpoints.
THE COURT: That's somewhat similar to his exper-
tise in the sale and so forth of products produced by
Procter and Gamble? ,
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THE COURT: He’s a good business man, good sales-
man: he knows, I assume, or has a good idea of what may
or may not appeal to the buying public.
THE WITNESS: That's right.
[96] THE COURT: Anything further from either
side.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, this is rather late, I would
like to offer one further piece of evidence.
THE COURT: I haven't cut you off yet.
THE CLERK: Petitioner's Exhibit No. 29 marked for
identification.
(The document referred to was
marked for identification as Peti-
tioner’s Exhibit No. 29.)
BY MR. DOAN:
Q. Mr. Trott, I hand you this brochure and ask you
to describe it to the Court.
A. This is a brochure used for advertising and pro-
_ - sides rest.
79
f
motion purposes in the sale of our incinerator under the
brand name Trashaw@y.
MR. DOAN: Your Honor, I offer the brochure de-
scribing the Trashaway as it exists today, in evidence.
THE COURT: All right, the document referred to
will be received in evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 29.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Petitioner's Ex-
hibit No. 29 was received in evi-
dence.)
MR. JANSEN: Your Honor, if I may, we have pre-
viously identified through Mr. Trott Respondent's Exhibit
W which at this time I would like to offer into evidence.
THE COURT: All right, that has not previously been
offered. That is thie letter from Mr. ‘Trott.
[97] MR. WALIKER: No objection.
THE COURT: ‘The document referred to will be re-
ceived in evidence 28 Respondent’s Exhibit W.
(The document previously marked
for identification as Respondent's
Exhibit W was received in evi-
dence.)
THE COURT: Anything further? Gentlemen, don't
take too much comffort one way or the other with respect
to the questions th'¢ Court has asked. Sometimes I try
to anticipate if I c@™ problems or short cuts that I may
have to finding an ultimate fact, and I don’t want to get
lost in all this maz”:
Is that all now? Anything further in this case? Both
All riglht, the case will be submitted. How
much time do you Want for briefs, gentlemen? Will 45
and 30 be suitable?
MR. DOAN: yes, Your Honor, that’s suitable.
80
MR. JANSEN: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: All right, they will be simultaneous
briefs. Opening briefs in 45 days, reply briefs in 30 days
thereafter. The Clerk will read those dates.
THE CLERK: January 3 for opening briefs, 1972,
and February 2nd, 1972 for reply briefs.
THE COURT: That concludes this case.
(Whereupon, at 3:40 p.m. the trial in the above-entitled
matter was concluded.)
81
Docket No. 7125-70
JT Exh. 2-B
AGREEMENT
Agreement made this 8th day of July, 1966, at Cin-
cinnati, Ohio, by and between DAVID H. TROTT, as
General Partner, and EUGENE W. GILSON, THOMAS
J. KLINEDINST, and E. A. SNOW, as Limited Partners,
WITNESSETH THAT:
WHEREAS, the General and Limited Partners referred
to above desire to form a limited partnership pursuant to
the Uniform Partnership Law of Ohio, Chapter 1781 of
the Ohio Revised Code.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and among the
parties hereto that upon the execution and delivery of a
Certificate of Limited Partnership, a Limited Partnership
shall exist composed of the General and Limited Partners
referred to above, formed pursuant to Chapter 1781 of the
Ohio Revised Code, upon the following terms and condi-
tions:
1. The partnership shall be conducted under the firm
name and style of “Burns Investment Company.”
2. The principal office and place of business shall be
at 8120 Blue Ash Road, Cincinnati, Ohio 45236.
3. The purpose and business of the partnership shall
be the development of a special purpose incinerator for
the consumer and industrial markets.
4. The name and address of the General Partner and
each Limited Partner and the amount of cash contributed
‘he
eee |
att is Slt RAR CID Rath Gore ace
pe ae eee 2 - s
DL Att sb 5 AB AERA a *
Si ates
4
:
3
82
by each Limited Partner, together with the interest in
the profits of the partnership of the General Partner and
the Limited Partners, shall be as follows:
GENERAL PARTNER
Name and Address Percentage
David H. Trott 50%
3351 Stettinius Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208
LIMITED PARTNERS
Limited Amount of Contribution
Name and Address Percentage
David H. Trott 34% All right, title and interest to
3351 Stettinius Avenue a product concept, individ-
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208 ually owned by David H.
Trott, more particularly de-
scribed as an incinerator de-
signed for rapid consumption
and burning of tree leaves
and similar combustible ma-
terials.
Eugene W. Gilson 8% $20,000.00
c/o The -Procter & Gamble
Company
P. O. Box 599
Cincinnati, Ohio 45201
Thomas J. Klinedinst 4% $10,000.00
2531 Observatory Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208
E. A. Snow 4% $10,000.00
Highland Towers
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
The above detailed contributions of the Limited Partners -
shall be paid to the partnership by July 8, 1966.
5. The partnership shall commence upon the execution
and delivery of a Certificate of Limited Partnership in
accordance with the provisions of Section 1781.02 of the
83
Ohio Revised Code and said partnership. shall continue
thereafter until the “business and assets” are sold, until
the earlier death or incapacity of the General Partner or
until dissolved by the partners; provided, however, that
the General Partner shall not cause a dissolution prior to
the accomplishment of the partnership’s purpose as set
out in Item 3 hereof, unless such purpose has been aban-
doned as the business of the partnership.
a ae ee
6. A Limited Partner may freely transfer or assign his
interest to any assignee and such assignee may, at the dis-
cretion of the Limited Partner, be made a “Substituted
Limited Partner’ as defined in Section 1871.19 of the
Ohio Revised Code. Said transfer or assignment, however,
shall not be effective unless the assigning Limited Partner
shall have given notice in writing of the transfer or assign-
ment to the General Partner thirty (30) days prior there-
to. The General Partner, upon receiving such notifica-
tion, shall promptly inform all other Limited Partners of
the transfer or assignment. .
7. The General Partner agrees that upon his death the
right and obligation to make a certain disposition (as here-
inafter described) of his general and limited partnership
interest shall be vested in a committee of Limited Partners.
Said committee shall consist of three (3) Limited Partners,
as follows: Eugene W. Gilson, Thomas J. Klinedinst, and
E. A. Snow. Upon the death or incapacity of one of these
Limited Partners, the General Partner may appoint the
Substituted Limited Partner or any other Limited Partner
to the vacancy so created; in the event that the above-
described death or incapacity of a Limited Partner on this
committee reduces the total number of Limited Partners
on the committee to two (2), then such remaining Limited
Partners shall be the committee described in this item with
all rights, privileges, and obligations granted and imposed
rere |
WA Salih Mg A Nacht Bale at alas 8 dh
Pathe
Ae lavibens trating Cam eee nn
SS mt ce OS sn
as A ee
84
hereunder. In all other circumstances the General Partner
shall not remove or replace a Limited Partner from said
committee, nor shall the General Pariner increase the
number of Limited Partners on the committee, unless the
removal, replacement or enlargement is agreed to by a
majority of the Limited Partners on said committee. The
intention of the General and Limited Partners under this
item is to provide for the continuation of the business of
the partnership in another entity subsequent to the death
or disability of the General Partner. Said committee shall,
therefore, have the right and obligation to form a successor
Limited Partnership within the six-month period following
the death or incapacity of the General Partner. In the
creation of such successor Limited Partnership said com-
mittee may choose and include additional parties as either
general or limited partners, and may establish a general
or limited interest, or both, in such successor limited part-
nership in exchange for the general and limited interests
of the General Partner. In any event, however, the gen-
eral and limited interests of the General Partner shall be
exchanged for a total interest (whether general or limited,
or both) which is proportionate to the interests received
by the surviving partners; such proportions shall be based
on the relative interests held by the General and other
surviving Limited Partners at the date of the General
Partner’s death or incapacity.
If in the judgment of said committee the formation of
a successor partnership would not be feasible or not in the
best interest of all the partners and provided the General
Partner’s legal representatives or guardian shall concur in
such judgment, then said committee shall be relieved from
its obligation to form a successor partnership and it may
in agreement with such legal representatives or guardian
make such other disposition of the General Partner’s
interests as it deems advisable under the circumstances.
85
In the event that a successor partnership is formed or
another disposition is made pursuant to this item 7, then
the inventory and appraisement of the General Partner's
interests required by Section 1779.01 O.R.€. (or a succes-
sor section) shall not be required.
8. The death of a Limited Partner shall not terminate
the partnership business. On the death of a Limited Part-
ner, his executor or administrator shall have all the rights
of a Limited Partner for the purpose of settling his estate,
and such power as the deceased had to constitute his
assignee as Substituted Limited Partner. ‘The estate of a
deceased Limited Partner shall be liable for all of his
liabilities as a Limited Partner.
9. The liability of each Limited Partner for partner-
ship debts shall in no event exceed the amount of con-
tribution stated in this agreement and the certificate as
having been made by each of them.
10. ‘The General Partner shall have sole rights of man-
agement and conduct of the partnership business, and shall
exert his best efforts to the conduct of the business. Unless
authorized by the General Partner, no Limited Partner
may transact the partnership business or act as agent or
otherwise for the firm.
11. All funds of the partnership shall be deposited in
its name in such checking account or accounts as shall be
designated by the General Partner. All withdrawals there-
from shall be made upon checks signed by the General
Partner.
12. Books of account for the partnership shall be kept
.on the accrual basis of accounting and the General and
Limited Partners or their accredited representatives shall
have access thereto at all reasonable times. The books of
on
Vora eaeee
PRRs. ARS SE
niet > ik F 5
BORMAN Ae RI EES Ue
at
Se Ea at ee id OS
86.
account shall be audited each year by a certified or regis-
tered public accountant chosen by the General Partner.
13. The General and Limited Partners hereto shall
promptly make and severally sign and acknowledge a Cer-
tificate of Limited Partnership and cause the same to be
recorded in accordance with the provisions of Section
1781.02.
14. Any amendment, alteration, addition, modification
or qualification may be made in the terms of this agreement
when made in writing and signed by all the partners.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto
set their hands on the day and year first above written.
/s/ DAVID H. TROTT
General Partner
/s/ EUGENE W. GILSON
Limited Partner
2 /s/ ‘THOMAS J. KLINEDINST
Limited Partner
/s/ E. A. SNOW
Limited Partner
ak oie
87
Docket No. 7725-70
Exh. 3-C
BURNS INVESTMENT COMPANY
AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT
DATED JULY 8, 1966
Amendment to agreement made this 3rd day of April,
1967, at Cincinnati, Ohio, by and between DAVID H.
~ TROTT, as General Partirer, and EUGENE W. GILSON,
THOMAS J. KLINEDINST, and E. A. SNOW, as Limit-
ed Partners,
WITNESSETH THAT:
WHEREAS, the General and Limited Partners referred
to above are presently members of a limited partnership
formed on July 8, 1966, pursuant to the Uniform Partner-
ship Law of Ohio, Chapter 1781 of the Ohio Revised Code;
WHEREAS, such General and Limited Partners desire
to amend and modify Item 4 of said agreement by con-
forming such item to the economic considerations that
underly such agreement. a
NOW, THEREFORE, as agreed by and among the
parties hereto that said partnership agreement dated July
8, 1966, shall be amended by the deletion of the entire
Item 4 of the present agreement and by the insertion of
the following Item 4 in its place: =
4. The name and address of the General Partner and
each Limited Partner and the amount of cash contributed
by each Limited Partner, together with the interest in
the profits of the partnership of the General Partner and
the Limited Partners, shall be as follows:
i
| 88
‘ GENERAL PARTNER
z
F Name and Address Pertentage
: David H. Trott 50%
: 3351 Stettinius Avenue
: Cincinnati, Ohio 45208
:
; LIMITED PARTNERS
3 Limited Amount of Contribution
: Name and Address Percentage
; David H. Trott 34% All right, title, and interest to
} 3351 Stettinius Avenue a product concept, . individ-
3 Cincinnati, Ohio 45208 ually owned by David H.
4 Trott, more particularly de-
2 scribed as an incinerator de-
4 signed for rapid consumption
: and burning of tree leave and
{ similar combustible materials.
} Eugene W. Gilson 8% $20,000.00
- c/o The Procter & Gamble
§ Company
P. O. Box 599
: Cincinnati, Ohio 45201
4 Thomas J. Klinedinst 4% $10,000.00
a
BS
Se ae ey eee
2531 Observatory Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208
E. A. Snow 4% $10,000.00
Highland Towers
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
The above detailed contributions. of the Limited Partners
shall be paid to the partnership by July 8, 1966.
Notwithstanding the above percentage of interest for
each partner, if the partnership experiences a net loss for
any fiscal year or period, which loss reduces the total credit
balance in the capital accounts of the partnership to an
amount which is lesser than the total amount of cash
contributed by the Limited Partners to the partnership's
capital, then such portion of the net loss which causes
the reduction in the contributed cash capital shall be
89
shared solely by the Limited Partners in the same propor-
tion that the amount of their cash contribution bears
to the total amount of cash contributed by all the Limited
Partners. And while there exists any reduction in the
Limited Partners’ contributed cash capital and the partner-
ship experiences a net profit in the following fiscal year or
period, then such portion of the net profit which eliminated
such reduction and: restores the total cash contributed to
capital shall be shared solely by the Limited Partners in
the. same proportions as is set out above for the sharing
of any net loss.
Nothing in this Item 4 is intended to modify or change
the express language of Item 9 of this agreement.
The modifications made herein-to the General and Lim-
ited Partners’ interest in the partnership's profits and losses
shall be effective for the fiscal period ending December 31,
1966 and thereafter.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto
set their hands on the day and year first above written.
/s/ DAVID H. TROTT
General. Partner
/s/ EUGENE W. GILSON
Limited Partner
/s/ THOMAS J. KLINEDINST
Limited Partner
/s/ E. A. SNOW
Limited Partner
Bititetitcznciiinn. ae eget a eg eae
90
CERTIFICATE OF LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENT made this day of March, 1965, at
Cincinnati, Ohio, by and among David H. Trott, Robert
Boggild and William Dale, as General Partners, and
George L. Sterne, Edwin A. Snow, Trustee, Edward J.
Noble, L. S. Brucker, Jr., Trustee, and Eugene W. Gilson
as Limited Partners,
WITNESSEAH:
WHEREAS, the General and Limited Partners referred
to above desire to form a Limited Partnership pursuant to
the Uniform Limited Partnership Act of Ohio, Chapter
1781 of the Ohio Revised Code,
NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and among the
parties hereto that upon the execution and delivery of this
Certificate of Limited Partnership, a Limited Partnership
shall exist composed of the General and Limited Partners
referred to above, formed pursuant to the Uniform Limited
Partnership Act, Chapter 1781 of the Ohio Revised Code,
upon the following terms and conditions:
(1) The partnership shall be conducted under the firm
name and style of “Echo Development Company.”
(2) The principal office and place of business shall be
at 8120 Blue Ash Road, Cincinnati, Ohio.
(3) The purpose and business of the partnership shall
be the development of a new consumer product in the
electronics field.
(4) The name and address of each General Partner
and each Limited Partner and the amount of cash or the
agreed value of other property contributed by each Lim-
ited Partner, together with the interest in the profits of
the partnership of each General Partner and Limited: Part-
ner shall be as follows:
Baie” Nl aeons eo en a ne
91
GENERAL PARTNERS ‘
Name and Place :
of Residence Percentage
David H. Trott
3351 Stettinius Avenue 20% :
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208 :
Robert Boggild
8770 Indian Hill Road 10%
Cincinnati, Ohio 45243
é
William Dale . ;
197 Ireland Avenue 10% f
Cincinnati, Ohio 45218 '
LIMITED PARTNERS j
Name and Place f
of Residence Amount of Contribution Percentage F
George L. Sterne All right, title and interest to ;
615 McAlpin Avenue a product concept individually 20% i
Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 owned by George L. Sterne, :
which product concept is more
particularly described in an
Agreement dated February 18, :
1965, between George L. ;
Sterne, David H. Trott, Robert
Boggild and William L. Dale. ;
Edwin A. Snow, Trustee
Highland Towers $35,000.00 10%
Cincinnati, Ohio
Edward J. Noble
Sierra Amatepec 173 $15,000.00 10% ‘
Mexico, D.F., Mexico :
:
L. S. Brucker, Jr., Trustee ’
3045 Erie Avenue $15,000.00 10%
Cincinnati, Ohio
Eugene W. Gilson
7 avenue de lErmitage $15,000.00 10%
Geneva, Switzerland
;
(5) The partnership shall commence upon the execu- |
tion and delivery of these Articles, the payment by and
92
on behalf of each Limited Partner of his contribution to
the partnership and the execution and filing of a signed
copy of this Certificate of Limited Partnership in accord-
ance with the provisions of Section 1781.02 of the Ohio
Revised Code. The partyership shall thereafter continue
until dissolved by the partners, or until the earlier death
or incapacity of any of the then General Partners.
(6) Any amendmenty, change, alteration, addition,
modification, or qualification may be made in the terms
of this contract when made in writing and signed by all
the partners.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have set their
hands as of the day and year first above written.
/s/ DAVID H. TROTT
General Partner
/s/ ROBERT BOGGILD
General Partner
/s/ WILLIAM L. DALE
General Partnet
eee ee Cece ew@oe nen aveeessaseeveeres
George L. Sterne, Limited Partner
/s/ EDWIN A. SNOW
Trustee, Limited Partner
/s/ EDWARD J. NOBLE
Limited Partner
/s/ L. S. BRUCKER, JR.
Trustee, Limited Partner
we eoeenevnereeeneeeeeeee + s eeeeeeee ee ©
Eugene W. Gilson, Limited Partner
93
CERTIFICATE OF LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENT made this day of March, 1965,
at Cincinnati, Ohio, by and between DAVID H. TROTT,
ROBERT BOGGILD and WILLIAM DALE, as General
Partners, and EDWIN A. SNOW, Trustee, EDWARD J.
NOBLE, L. S. BRUCKER, JR., Trustee, and EUGENE
W. GILSON, as Limited Partners,
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the General and Limited Partners referred
to above desire to form a Limited Partnership pursuant
to the Uniform Limited Partnership Act of Ohio, Chapter
1781 of the Ohio Revised Code,
NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and among the
parties hereto that upon the execution and delivery of this
Certificate of Limited Partnership, a Limited Partnership
shall exist composed of the General and Limited Partners
referred to above, formed pursuant to the Uniform Limited
Partnership Act, Chapter 1781 of the Ohio Revised Code,
upon the following terms and conditions:
(1) The partnership shall be conducted under the
firm name and style of “Courier Enterprises.”
(2) The principal office and place of business shall be
at 8120 Blue Ash Road, Cincinnati, Ohio.
(3) The purpose and business of the partnership shall
be the development of a new consumer product in the
electronics field.
(4) The name and address of each General Partner
and each Limited Partner and the amount of cash con-
tributed by each Limited Partner, together with the inter-
sore —
sda PLAY OT OCP
Betti cnrrson: Lae? Pee
94
est in the profits of the partnership of each General Partner
and Limited Partner shall be as follows:
GENERAL PARTNERS
Name and Place of Residence Percentage
David H. Trott
3351 Stettinius Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208 40%,
Robert Boggild
8770 Indian Hill Road
Cincinnati, Ohio 45243 10%
William Dale
197 Ireland Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio 45218 - 10%
LIMITED PARTNERS
Amount of
Contribution
Edwin A. Snow, Trustee
Highland Towers
Cincinnati, Ohio $5,000.00 10%
Edward J. Noble
Sierra Amatepec 173
Mexico, D.F., Mexico $5,000.00 10%
L. S. Brucker, Jr., Trustee
3045 Erie Avenue 4
Cincinnati, Ohio $5,000.00 10%
95
Eugene W. Gilson
7 avenue de l’Ermitage
Geneva, Switzerland $5,000.00 10%
(4) The partnership shall commence upon the execu-
tion and delivery of these Articles, the payment by and on
behalf of each Limited Partner of his contribution to the
partnership and the execution and filing of a signed copy
of this Certificate of Limited Partnership in accordance
with the provisions of Section 1781.02 of the Ohio Revised
Code. The partnership shall thereafter continue until
dissolved by the partners, or until the. earlier death or
incapacity of any of the then General Partners.
(6) Any amendment, change, alteration, addition,
modification, or qualification may be made in the terms
of this contract when made in writing and signed by all
the partners.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have set their
hands as of the day and year first above written.
/s/ DAVID H. TROTT
General Partner
/s/ ROBERT BOGGILD
General Partner
/s/ WILLIAM L. DALE
General Partner
/s/ EDWIN A. SNOW
Trustee, Limited Partner
/s/ EDWARD J. NOBLE
Limited Partner
/s/ L. §. BRUCKER, JR.
Trustee, Limited Partner
/s/ EUGENE W. GILSON
Limited Partner
OR.
PRL IS re ee EE
Dicaiciabatacretissssscte. sons minsiice
96
LETTER FROM DAVID H. TROTT TO
ROBERT BOGGILD DATED 4-28-65
U.S. Tax Court, November 16, 1971
Docket No. 7125-70
April 28, 1965
Mr. Robert Boggild, President,
Crossbow, Incorporated
8120 Blue Ash Road
Cincinnati, Ohio 45236
Dear Bob:
This outlines the basis on which Crossbow will under-
take development work on a compact battery-operated tape
recorder, designated by the code name CINCH, on behalf
of the partnership owning all rights to same, known as
Courier Enterprises.
1. Crossbow will develop CINCH to the working model
stage, and as far beyond as available money may afford.
2. All work will be done on a time and materials basis,
at the following labor rates:
Drafting — $6.00 per hour
Shop — $8.00 per hour
Design — $9.00 per hour
Development Engineer — $12.00 per hour
Chief Project Engineer — $20.00 per hour
It is my understanding that the above rates are com-
petitive in the community to those charged by other shops
engaged in similar work.
97
3. Crossbow will exert its best efforts to complete the
assignment within the funds which Courier Enterprises
has available for this purpose — $20,000.00 in total.
4. Crossbow will make every effort to complete the
assignment within nine months from this date. If in
the sole opinion of Courier Enterprises the progress of
the project is unsatisfactory, it may remove the project
from Crossbow responsibility after one year from this date.
5. Any equipment purchased by Crossbow solely for
use in connection with this assignment, will be charged
to the project and will become the property of Courier
Enterprises.
6. All rights to patentable features, and to patents
thereon, developed by Crossbow specifically in the course
of development work on CINCH, will become the property
of Courier Enterprises.
7. Courier Enterprises will be billed morfthly for time
and materials. No advance payments will be made. On
occasion, however, Crossbow may request a cash advance
when necessary to cover a substantial cash outlay by Cross-
bow, in the amount of this outlay.
<3
8. The confidential nature of Crossbow’s work on
CINCH will be guarded insofar as possible by written
security agreement signed by all Crossbow employees.
Please initial one copy of this letter and return it to
me, as evidence of your agreement.
Sincerely,
/s/ D. H. TROTT
/s/ R. BOGGILD
DHT /do
caniial
(SIM AN YT NOE LV
DIA Saye) RI PN WORE pA PO NN NOPE SMG pated | Pee
POE a ee Oe
Biciseouin "Ais ddr
98
LETTER FROM WOOD, HERRON & EVANS TO
DAVID H. TROTT, DATED 12-10-65
U. S. Tax Court, November 16, 1971
Docket No. 7125-70
LETTERHEAD OF WOOD, HERRON & EVANS
December 10, 1965
Mr. David H. Trott
3351 Stettinius
Cincinnati, Ohio 45208
Re: Cyclone Furnace Leaf Burner
Dear Dave:
This is a report of the supplementary patentability
search which we have made with respect to your cyclone
burner invention. As I understand it, the original search
made in late 1964 was reported orally. I believe at that
time you were advised that there was no chance for patent
protection on the broad concept of a cyclone furnace used
in conjunction with a vacuum cleaner type leaf collector
mounted on a rolling platform.
Your invention has progressed from the time of that
report in the direction of improving the burning apparatus
and you have improved it in three major respects. First,
you mount a diverter at the top of a primary combustion
chamber and create above it a secondary combustion cham-
ber. The diverter has a central passageway projecting into
the primary combustion chamber. Distribution vanes are
secured to the top of the passageway and cause gases and
entrained solids to be swirled in the secondary chamber.
99
The second feature might be called your ignition struc-
ture. This comprises a grate at the lower end of the
primary combustion chamber in combination with vanes
extending across the lower end of the combustion chamber
and spaced above the grate. A secondary air inlet passage-
way is connected to the lower end of the combustion
chamber below the grate. In operation, a few glowing
briquettes are placed on the grate and the secondary air
causes them to glow brightly and ignite any solids con-
tacting them. ‘The vanes serve to break up the high
velocity swirling air in the main combustion chamber,
thereby creating in the space between the vanes and the
grate a more or less gently flowing air which permits the
solids to remain in contact with the briquettes for a sufh-
cient length of time for their ignition.
The third feature comprises the use of a cooling jacket
surrounding the main and secondary combustion chambers
with provision for bleeding secondary air from the main
intake blower to the jacket. The important aspect of
this feature is that a large volume of air is required to
bring the solids into the burner but preferably that volume
of air should be diminished before going into the com-
bustion chamber for too much air will have an adverse
effect on the burning. By taking secondary air from the
main intake, you are able to provide (a) sufficient air
to bring the solids into the system, (b) sufficient air for
cooling, and (c) diminished air, as desired, in the com-
bustion chamber.
We are of the opinion that the Patent Office would be
justified in granting protection to the features as outlined
above. We may encounter some difficulties in obtaining
protection for the reasons discussed below. Our opinion
is based on a search of the Patent Office records and our
study of the pertinent patents located which are as follows:
SC AF ee oma = "
RARER ATONE Mg MERCI TE og
er sel
em
dis a
MEETS MET NE
Bdctsericese ence, va
ye
106
Patent No. Inventor Date
3,202,118 J. J. Baldine Aug. 24, 1965
2,861,423 J. Jerie et al Nov. 25, 1958
2,793,626 E. Hubel May 28, 1957
2,646,758 J. G. Greemen July 28, 1953
2,527,984 E. S. Jeffries, Sr. Oct. 31, 1950
The Hubel patent 2,793,626 and Greemen patent 2,-
646,758 show the concept of two distinct combustion
chambers. Neither shows your concept of two spaced
cyclone chambers located one above the other and separated
by the diverter. Your distinct structure should be patenta-
ble. However, in writing it up, we will be well advised
to develop reasons for its being considered an improve-
ment over structures such as are shown in the Hubel and
Greemen patents. Otherwise, the patent Examiner might
well take the position that your particular structure for
achieving two combustion chambers is merely a matter of
choice not involving the exercise of invention.
The Greemen patent is also pertinent in showing a
grate at the bottom of the combustion chamber. ‘The
Greemen patent, however, lacks the vanes spaced above the
grate which control the flow of air over the grate. None
of the other patents shows that particular structure and
we believe that we should be able to obtain patent pro-
tection to it. -
The Jefferies patent 2,527,934 and the Jerie patent
9,861,423 show a combustion chamber surrounded by
jackets with provision for cooling air to pass between the
jacket and the combustion chamber. Neither shows the
concept of bleeding off a portion of the main inlet air to
attain the results outlined above. In the absence of a
showing of your particular combination, the possibility of
obtaining patent protection exists although we will be
Dat a No = ight ste
101
faced with a position that the bleeding off of secondary
air from the main source is a matter of convenience not
involving the exercise of invention.
I have reviewed the patents which were located during
the earlier search and I see nothing in them which would
alter the opinions expressed above. I am returning those
patents with the newly obtained patents for your consider-
ation. Before beginning the preparation of a patent ap-
plication, I would like to have the patents returned for
such assistance as they will be in the preparation of an
application.
I am not sure that you are ready to have the patent
- application prepared. If you are in the process of con-
structing a prototype utlizing your inventive features, you
may wish to delay the preparation of the application until
the completion of the prototype so that the application as
filed will have the benefit of any improvements and/or
greater understanding of the operation obtained through
the creation of the prototype.
Sincerely,
/s/ BILL
William G. Konold
WGK:st
Enclosures
ae rg ——
PRATT EMERGE FYE
pee eran PT Se
be er eel
eamtasiee dinate tanta: teamed BF Sa rman men om
102
LETTER FROM WOOD, HERRON & EVANS TO
DAVID H. TROTT, DATED 2-22-66
U.S. Tax Court, November 16, 1971
Docket No. 7125-70
LETTERHEAD OF WOOD, HERRON & EVANS
February 22, 1966
Mr. David H. Trott
Crossbow, Inc.
8120 Blue Ash Road
Cincinnati, Ohio
Dear Dave:
This is to confirm the oral advice given to you during
our meeting with Ralph Ross on January 21 respecting
the status of the leaf burner development. I have advised
you that it is reasonable to conclude that the leaf burner
has not yet been reduced to practice within the contem-
plation of Section 102G of the patent laws as incorporated
in the Internal Revenue Code. This opinion is based
on my examination of the leaf burners and my discussion
with you of the tests which you have made on them.
We examined two models anf in general neither of
them performs satisfactorily enough to be a marketable
product.
One of the deficiencies of the first model is that it burned
too hot and this suggests a new approach to the cooling
system.
The second model did not handle fresh leaves too well,
the fresh leaves becoming jammed in their main intake.
Further, and this may be applicable to both models, un-
burned solids tend to drop below the main cyclone air
103
stream into the ignition area and require additional blasts
of secondary air up through the bottom of the device in
order to force these solids into the main stream.
The two models of the leaf burner are big institutional
type devices and an objective is to make a smaller leaf
burner which will be saleable to the individual home own-
er. Since it is obviously more difficult to handle leaves in
a smaller unit than in the bigger units, which have not
yet performed satisfactorily, much development work will
have to be done in the development of the small unit.
The fact situation presents a rather close question of
the applicability of the term “reduce to practice” to your
leaf burner. However, the Patent Office standard for re-
duction of practice is very high. The manner in which
Section 102G is interpreted in patent case law is well
expressed in Field v. Knowles, 183 F2d 593, 601 as follows:
“Thus, in the case of an ice-making machine, it must
appear from the tests relied upon to establish actual
reduction to practice that the machine operated for
a sufficient length of time to demonstrate continued
and adequate production of ice.”
In the present situation, neither of the two models of
leaf burners operated for a sufficient length of time to
demonstrate continued and adequate burning of leaves.
Rather, the tests demonstrate that additional work would
be necessary in order to modify them to the extent neces-
sary for the continuous leaf burning function.
In light of the foregoing, I have advised that the leaf
burner invention has not yet been reduced to practice.
Sincerely,
/s/ BILL
William G. Konold
WGK: st
104
ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE
UNITED STATES ALLOWING CERTIORARI,
DATED 1-7-74
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
JANUARY 7, 1974
SNOW
v.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
No. 73-641
“The petition for a Writ of Certiorari is granted. Mr.
Justice Stewart took no part in the consideration or de-
cision of this petition.”
ee ee TN ene F
APPENDIX —
Volume II
\ . In THE
- SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
Ocroser TERM, 1973
No. 73-641
Epwin A. AND HELEN B. SNOW
Petitioners,
—Y,—
CoMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent.
On Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED OCTOBER 12, 1973
CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 7, 1974
INDEX
VOLUME II Page
Taxpayer Snow’s Individual Income Tax Return
for 1966 (Stone Oil Schedules omitted) ; 105
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Burns In-
vestment Co... eee eee .... 124
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Burns In-
vestment Co. ..—._.................... oo... 129
Partnership Return of Income, 1968, Burns In-
vestment Co. . Deby eeu ee ane aeuean .... 133
Partnership Return of Income, 1965, Echo De-
velopment Co. . ne .. 138
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Echo De-
velopment Co. 6... 143
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Echo De-
Welopiment UG. oc gee ee toe es Gee tees ye 4744: 148
Partnership Return of Income, 1965, Courier
Enterprises... . phe oyeas eh eue ene eyeus 152
Partnership Return of Income, 1966, Courier
Enterprises re _. 157
Partnership Return of Income, 1967, Courier
Enterprises... 60. 6s ca esse eseeceeons -... 161
Patent No. 3,498,240, issued to David H. Trott
on 3-38-70. 8 . 165
‘“Trash-Away” Brochure - -. 169
Note: The opinions of the Tax Court and the
Court of Appeals appear in the Appendix
to Snow’s Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
at pages 13-44.
ee es
pag Le ines a 7 Fu f Sy ABs He ws
LSS 'y OER) sot rhs wi 7 : i. ys
VW on nye. ene SUNN Frat Fes es J. ee SU bad Fm Cae mpm Ces, /- 4
sv} ‘t oP whale bens Ga cae ale we Nw sc. ae ee oe dk 1 4 aoe) * ~ ee *
Alt Ne HF ae | iy for ths year January 1-December 21, 1966, or other taxabie year beginning wae eee sebsoteseconse , he = ee ep ee
i ad
1966, ending wares: DO sactsese U.S. Treasury DSepertmeat—tinternsl Revenue Servier 7 .
Vi First nance and wor'ral (it jornt cetorn. use pret names aud muagle mitials OF both) | Lat nate { Your soc:ab ccuiny oon nr
a (Husbann's, ii joint resus :
= “4
, nl . ° ‘ ’ in LP?’
‘i EDWIN A, ANC HELEN 8, SNOW 268: 10:71:12 A
e “ae sees se a ae
x Home address (tivmber and slreet or rural route) “VY Your oscuo ston
a HIGHLAND TOWERS, 1071 CELESTIAL STREET a EXECUTIVE
@ sacs beescass Seuesssuuwouceceweseces = =
s City, tows or post ° tine, ‘and Shite ZIP cose Vy Wite’ s number: 5 at jovnt retura
!
x CINCINNATI, OH10 45202 =; 269. 0$‘ic10__
A Enter the name and address used on your return for 1959 (if the same os ebove, write “Same'). if hone tiled, Wile’ succup tat
give reason. Jt ch INSIOK from separate to joint or joint to separate returns, enter 1965 Names ond addresses, : one al
SANE
Your present employer and eadress THE P_ & G, COMPAL Y, CINCINNATI, OKIG i. mamas “7p 2 5 “ff 70
Wife’ Ss present employer and address, if joint return i> .
)
Filing Stztus—check oniy one: Exemptions Recular 65orover me ye / -4
; er rum e
la 2 Single 7 . . 2a Yourself . Oo 0}! Lea ee
1b Af Married filing joint return (even if only one had income) | 2b Wife . . MJ O ti i J checkec p > = ss
J¢ 1) Married filing separately. If your husband or wife | 3a First names of your dependent children who lived with
is also filing a return give his or her first name and
v social security number. YOU ossicie vce sienss cinccnceccocaesastosescecsecneicscossesesecescesssdee> (seses0sise ‘
” SEESCHEQULE. Dc cccceseeccesceen
a -
ae Beeson sh aanasesnecnss feassececeavesseanacess Enter number )- m & 2
= ld 7 Geenarried ‘Head a Household 3b Number of other dependents (fram paze 2, Pari |, ine 3)
£ le () Survivine widow(er) with dependent child 4 Total exemptions claimed. . .. ll oll
c _ ARs
-, income 5 Wages, saiarivs, tips. etc. If not shown on attached Forms W=-2 attaa\expidhation > 200,058 _.
= ae 6 — Other income (from page 2, Partil,line8) 2 2 6. we eee MHS STZ
E * ircomeot 7 Tota (edd fines § and 6). 2 2... ek eee tb DEE
*%S both husband & — Adjustmerits (from page 2, Part ill, line 5). 0. 2 ww. __.
re and wiie 9 Total income (subtract iine 8 fromiune 7). 2. wl rs 1Gu ols
& Figurotaxby 10 Tar Taole---if you do nct itemize deductions and line 9 ts less than $5. OCO. find your §
using either tax frum tables in instructions. Do not use lines 1 la,b,c, ord. Enter tax online i2. .
1Oer WA --—— -- -——--—--- -— ---
11 Tax Rate Schedule— |
lia If you itemize deductions, enter total from page 2, Part IV. . j |
if you do not ttenuze deductions, and line 9 is $5,000 or more enter ‘the larger of: i H
Vax (1) 2 Geren line 9 or;
sib (2) $200 ($100 if married and filing separate return) plus $100 for each {| » \ ek
Coinjse exemption claimed on lina 4, above. | 3
tation Deduction unuer (i) or (2) limited to 31, om ae if married and filing mpaa): _
l1lb Subtract line lla from iine Oo... Lo 6 « ke H @ uleee tes.
lle Muliiply total number of exemptions on ine 4, above, by $600 . re 2 696 __
Aid Subtract line 11¢ from iine 11b. Enter baiance on this line. (Figure your tax on this |
amount by using tax rie schedule on pace 11 of instructions.) Enter tax on line 12. YOO 725
\ 1% Tax (from either Tax Table, see line 10, or Tax Rate Schedule, seelinell). 2. > = mn
| 13 Total credits (from page 2, Part V, line 5). 2. 2. . ww kw ee pias
s 14a Income tax (subtract line 13 fromline 12) 2. . . 1 <e a & = & & 4 331,
" me. 14b jax from recomouting prior year investment credit (attach sintemend. : - = - t oe 32
= Greg 6 15 Self-employment tax (Schedule C-3 or FI). we
S Pe seed 46 Total tax (add lines 14a, 146, and15) .. * 28 4. e i en: >| ... 03, 143
Be PSXINCASS 17 Total Federal income tax withheld (aitach Forms we2) SCH 2] ls 4 12 — !
> 18 1966 Estimated tax payments (invita 1ysSover: aymertaliowed csacresit) PH] 3 8, 2§0.i...... :
& 19 Excess F.1.C.A. Tax Withheld (imo or mere *mplcvers—ser page Sofinst.) PP !
== 20 = Nonhighway Federal gassiine tax—Form $130, Rez. lav.—form 2439. CO ;
eo 21_ Total (add lines 17,18,19,and 29). wet RD TE
3 22 = if payments (line 21) are less tiian tax (iine 1€), enter Saiance Cure. Pay in fuil with this return =o. __
© Tax Due 93° | payments (line 21) are larger than tax (line 16), enter Overpayment . . > PD’
<— o R 5 d | Peecccccccccccccccccee- cocees
g OF NeCUNG 24 Amount of line 23 you wish credited to 1967 Estimated Tax. . . . . ee:
= 23 Subtract line 24 from 23. Analy to: ™ US. Savirts Bonds, with cxcess refusded or Refurd qrly .
a Under fenail.2s of perjury, i deciace that | have exairinad tvs Tetuen, INC LU AZ ScCaT Pe vsiNy Schedules etd sisicic rls, ard to tne dest of iay bs vOwlouce and ciel aS Le
correct, and coniplete, uf Prepare ec Pid ferson omer tear taxp art lus secre 13 0.564 Of oi informas en Of waica he was any knowledge. : .
ign oc ce ee *.: neg dt nes Date -.. a - aw
vere” if ont return, Spt HUSBAND AND WiFE UST Slcix creas ai 3. ne ‘hed ins¢me. = ? :
Sign here . LAN | ER, GUY, WALKER & CHATE 1ELO, cl NNAT | 2_.0H 10 45202 Date A/10/67
, nature vw preparer other than taxpayer. Address
mete A ensenen
A Exemptions Complote oniy for dopondents claimad en ii: 2th, rceol Form 1010 — 1900 6— z
(bd) Melstionan'p | (c)ity nsivodinysu send+ | ’e) Anic GU fw red oy 3
(ap DAME CIE Mie Bf 4Ce 13 Needed allach echeduie)
ing year wo B" ce"
home, homorceucur et
4nrgrgyy
tor :
ul lov, 3 bah 5 Ac!
se tone jot | te Uibbi a cee
Of $000 oF more?
D cnsicdsisosscesotesscesssesssesseesoossssesaces I cessossscgoassvessasvecsecossel osssays dasssanescenss Wesssscsccnsesasebanassuseae'e Derssionnicsesassiessese
ere ee ee ree rn Ri:
3 Total number of dependents. fisted above. Enter here and on pace 1, lina Sb . me eanneecwn 4 &F i _
; ee ee ee A AO Wer ee. az! sm Sasi!
PART II. Income from sourcesother thanwages, ctc. | PART IV. itoraized deduciions—Use only if youdo nei use
la Dividends and other distributions on stock (Name of payer— tax table or standard deduction.
write (H),.(W), UJ), for stock held by husband, wife, or Jointly) .......... Medical and dental expense (not compensated by insurance cr
wis ensnbeuessescdnesscecssassueness otherwise)—Attach itemized list. If 65 or over see instructions.
stones SEE..SCH.3 1 Total cost of medicine and drugs . oe |esceesscecceeeneeeee ses
“pct 2 Enter 1% of line 9, page 1. 1 www fe
3 Subtract line 2 from line 1.6 www feceneceeeereeseereees Ieee
seesereeee : 18.60 4 Other medical, dental expenses (include
Total line la. . . 1. eww 2602)... hospital insurance premiums). . . . : |
1b Exclusion (see instructions) 200... 5 Total (addlines3 and 4). 6 6 6 ww focccccccccecceceee t.
le Capital gain distributions. |.............. 106 il cesses 6 Enter3% ofline9, pagel . . . ew
1d Nontaxable distributions . 7 Subtract line 6 from line 5; sce page 8 of
le Total lines 1b, lc, and ld. . . 306 instructions for maximum limitation > >
lf Taxabie dividends (line 1a less line le— Contributions.—Cash— including checks, money orders, etc.
___not less than zero). . . . . . >>| 18,296 GRIN) scorseseeser ans
eineicns (hans oh 7 nT a aac as sbaG5e56%600 ssuasadessiendnese
Za Earnings from savings and loan @SSOC., | =§«-_——|_Csd vrs een eeeeenecsscsecnncssnnsersnesanesscensssnasssesssenssssnnesanasesensasscsssseescaseesins
mutual saViNGS ROM), credit unions, etc, .. gansascsesesesbsbeeebosdousonssussesussssceusaseseeeseescvesscossscses ese
sevssseneee ae 1. Sree €E SCH. bosnieestcsercind
asesessvigesseesbecess Total line 2al : | 1 Total cash contributions. . . saanslt.1.
2b Interest on bank deposits (other than 2 Other than cash (see instructions for required
Mutual Savings) .........re0 eoncescecrocecenecesce statement). Enter total of such items here. |...... 16,932...
r 3 Carryover from prior years (see pagesotust). |...
eevee snecensceesesensce Total line 2o| 209| 4 Total contributions (add lines 1, 2, and _
2c Other interest (bonds, etc.) .....csccssseeees 3—see instructions for limitation)... P| 15,972,
PYITITITITITI TTT ttre Taxes.—Real estate . . . . . . . © [eccccgcccccccccecccce | soave
: ae State and local gasoline «ww ww beccceecsccecerereee lessees
sevesercoessseses senses Total line 2c! 240! General sales (see page I5 of instructions) 2 lo... eeceseelenees
2d Total interest income (lines 2a, 2b, & 2c)> > 449! State and local income ase
3 Pensions and annuities, rents and royalties, Personal iy SEE SCH id
partnerships, estates ortrusts, etc. (Sch. B) 60 propery Total tives > > JOO »0 TT,
4 Business income (Schedule C). . . . |_-23,078! Interest expense.—Home Mortgage. . .
5 Sale or exchange of property (Schedule D). |__ = 1,009! | other (itermize) cecscsssscsscsssesssesesssessensessesssssssssevievensasesviveveseseee
G6 Farm income (Schedule F). . . . . _
7 Miscellaneous income (state nature) ........ SEE SCH V0
naan: stil ; 8 sesseseseues nee ane " Sedsecusasessesestos
Total line 7> > 91 Tctal intercst expense > >} 2,949
8 TOTAL L (ald lines 1f throu we — tera! ; — :
sid oh pare, ling ch. 8 ">rl -15,002 Misceilaneous deductions.—(see page 9 of instructions) ...........
PART Ill. Adjustments
1 “Sick pay" if included in line 5, page 1 (at-
tach Form 2440 or other required statement) ,
2 Moving expenses (attach Form 3903). .
3 Employee business expense (attach Form
2106 or other statement) *_ 28© © © @
seeeee
ee
4 Payments by self-employed persons to re-
tirement plans, etc. (attach Form z950SE) .
5 TOTAL ADJUSTMENTS (lines 1 through 4).
__Enter t here and on pagel, line S. .
SE
errr titi eee ee ee
TOTAL DEDUCTIONS (for page 1, line 11a) >| £i,0/5 ~~
CCE ES SS. Oe
PARTY. Credits
1 Retirement income credit (Schedule B) .
2 Investment credit (Form 3463). 6 6 oe dice...
3 Foreign tax credit (Form 1116). . . . '
4 Tax-free covenant bonds credit. .-. .
EXPENSE A ACCOUNT. TNF RMATION—if h iT]
Or Charged expenses to to ros bane ook ioe ato vee page? of 5 TOTAL CREDITS (add lines 1 thr oughy). 2881
instructions, Enter here and on pave l, line 13. siete nei
PO U5. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 191¢—-@-220-001
1M sims
9 eh tae reserene er
“™ SCITEDULE B Subp eCMehMs SCHCGULUC CY
(Form 1040) | Retivement Income Crean : (0)
US. Treasury Department (From pensions and annuities, rents and royultics, partnerships, and estates or trusts) UYU
SARA OREN TOES Attach this schedule to your income tax return, Form 1040
Namo and address as shown on page 1 of Form 1040
EDWIN A AND HELEN B SNOW .
HIGHLAND TOWERS, 1071 CELESTIAL STREET
CINCINNATI CHIO 452C2
Part I.—PENSION AND ANNUITY INCOME | | amount
A.—General Rule (it you did not contribute to the cost of the pension of annuity,enter the total amourt received on line 6 and omit lines 1 through 5.)|
1 Investment incontract. . . . . 4 Amount réceivedthisyear. . . ee
2 Expected return. . . - + + +445 Amount excludabie (line 4 multi-
3 Percentage of income to be ex- pied By Ene 3) ‘
cluded (line 1 divided by line 2) . %'6 Taxable portion (excess of line 4 over line 5). . Seeds beens boeeee.
B.—Special_Rule— Where your employer has contributed part of the cost and your own contritution will be recovered tax-free within 3 years. ~
if your cost was fully recayered in prior years, enter the total amount received on line 5 and omit lines 1 through 4. | :
1 Cost of annuity (amounts
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.