Appendix — Teleprompter Corp. v. Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1974
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
la
APPENDIX A
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
SzpremBer Tze, 1972
No. 353
January 11, 1973 Decided: March 8, 1973
’ Docket No. 72-1800
Cotums1a Broapcastine System, Inc.
Catvapa Propuctions, a joint venture,
Jack Currtox Tz.evision, Inc., and
Dena Pictures [ycorRPorRaTED,
Plaintiff s-Appellants,
Vv.
TELEPROMPTER CORPORATION and
ConLey Execrronics CoRPoRaTIon,
Defendants-A ppellees.
Before: Lumparp, Kavurman and Mawnsrret, Circuit
Judges.
Appeal from a judgment of the Southern District of
New York (Constance Baker Motley, J.) holding that ap-
pellees did not infringe appellants’ copyrights and dis-
missing appellants’ action.
Affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part.
Asa D. Sokolow and Seymour Graubard,
New York, New York (Rosenman Colin Kaye
Petschek Freund & Emil, for appellant
Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. ;
Marshall, Bratter, Greene, Allison &
Tucker, for appellant Calvada Productions
Alexander & Green, for appellant
Jack Chertok Television, Inc. ;
Graubard, Moskovitz, McGoldrick, Dannett
& Horowitz, for appellant Dena Pictures,
Incorporated, on the brief) for appellants.
Robert C. Barnard
(Cleary, Gottlieb,, Steen & Hamilton,
R. Michael Duncan, of counsel,
New York, New York and Washington,
D.C.; Katz, Rosensweig & Sindle,
David Z. Rosensweig, of counsel,
New York, New York, on the brief),
for appellees.
Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton &
Garrison, Herman Finkelstein,
Simon H. Rifkind, Jay H. Topkis and
Paul L. Laskin, New York, N.Y., on
the brief, amicus curiae for -
_American Society of Composers,
Authors and Publishers.
Stuart F. Feldstein, Charles 8. Walsh
and Stephen A. Gold, Washington, D.C.,
on the brief, amicus curiae for
National Cable Television Association, Inc.
Phillips, Nizer, Benjamin, Krim &
Ballon, Louis Nizer, Gerald Meyer
and Gerald F. Phillips, of counsel, on .
the brief, amicus curiae for
Motion Picture Association of America,
et al.
“”
3a
Lumsagp, Circuit Aales:
Plaintiffs-appellants, Columbia Broadcasting ‘ersten,
Inc. (CBS), Calvada Productions, Jack Chertok Television,
Inc., and Dena Pictures, Incorporated appeal from a final .
judgment entered after trial in the Southern District. Ap- —
pellants commenced this copyright infringement action *
against defendants-appellees, Teleprompter Corporation
(Teleprompter) and its subsidiary Conley Electronics Cor-
poration, who own and operate numerous Community An-
tenna Television (CATV) systems throughout the country.
Appellants are creators and producers of television pro-—
grams that were protected by statutory copyrights and
that were initially licensed by the CBS Television Network,
a division of CBS, to its affiliated television stations
for simultaneous broadcast. The complaint alleged that
the teleprompter cable systems intercepted the signals of
television stations broadcasting appellants’ copyrighted
works and then channeled these programs to their paying ,
subscribers without authorization or license, thereby in-
1 The original action was commenced on December 11, 1964. At-
tempts to consolidate this action with United Artists Television v.
Fortnightly, 255 F.Supp. 177 (S.D.N.Y. 1966), aff’d 377 F.2d 872
(2d Cir. 1967), rev’d 392 U.S. 390 (1968), in the district court
were unsuccessful. The parties voluntarily stayed proceedings
in this case while Fortnightly was on appeal. After the Fort-
nightly decision, supplemental complaints were filed on December
15, 1969 and May 17, 1971. ‘
4a
fringing appellants’ copyrights.’ After trial? the dis-
trict court, holding that the reception of telecasts of
appellants’ copyrighted programs by Teleprompter’s
/ % Appellants claim to have been injured because Teleprompter
[ GAT systems ditriesied dels oes ethoreios hate rested
righted to viewers who could not otherwise have received
When a CATV system brings a program into its market
from a more distant television market, ts assert that this
gram when it is later licensed for exhibition by a local station. As
a result, the fee that the station in the smaller market is willing
2 By pre-trial order, the trial of this ease was divided into sep-
arate stages. The first stage, on appeal here, concerned the issue
of whether or not Teleprompter had infringed appellants’ copy-
rights.
5a
CATV systems and the distribution of these programs to
CATV subscribers did not infringe appellants’ copyrights,
entered judgment dismissing the complaint.’ From that
judgment, appellants have taken this appeal.
The pertinent facts were the subject of two lengthy
issue concerns the proper interpretation to be given to
$1(c) and (d) of the Copyright Act of 1909, 17 U.S.C.
$1(c) and (d).* This provision. gives the copyright
holder the exclusive right, inter alia, to perform the copy-
righted work. The issue here, therefore, is whether
Teleprompter’s CATV systems ‘‘performed’’ the copy-
righted works within the meaning of this provision. In
resolving this question, we are not writing on a clean slate,
for the Supreme Court, on somewhat different facts, con-
sidered the meaning of ‘‘perform’’ in this provision in
* “Any person entitled thereto, upon complying with the pro-
visions of this title, shall have the exclusive right:
(e) To deliver, authorize the delivery of, read, or present
the copyrighted work in public for profit if it be a lecture,
sermon, address or similar production, or other nondramatic
literary work; to make or procure the making of any tran-
scription or record thereof by or from which, in whole or in
part, it may in any manner or by any method be exhibited, -
delivered, presented, produced, or reproduced ; and to play
or ‘perfornf it in public for profit, and to exhibit, represent,
produce, or reproduce it in any manner or by any method
(ad) To perform or present the copyrighted work publicly
if it be a drama or, if it be a dramatic work and not repro-
duced in copies for sale, to vend any manuscript or any record
whatsoever thereof; to make or to procure the making of any
transcription or record thereof by or from which, in whole or
in part, it may in any manner or by any method be exhibited,
performed, represented, produced or reproduced; and to ex-
hibit, perform, represent, produce, raga yoaee: it, in any
manner or by any method whatsoever .
6a
Fortnightly Corp. v. United Artists, Inc., 392 U.S. 390
(1968). Relying on Fortnightly, the district court held
that the CATV systems here did not ‘‘perform”’ the copy-
righted works.
The allegations of infringement were limited to an illus-
trative group of copyrighted programs. Similarly, the
complaints charged five specific and illustrative CATV sys-
tems with having infringed appellants’ copyrights, al-
though presumably other CATV systems owned by Tele-
prompter conducted similar activities. As a result, the
copyright claims at issue involve, and are limited to, the
operations of Teleprompter’s CATV systems in five cities
at stated periods: Elmira, New York in November 1964;
Farmington, New Mexico in November 1964, June 1969, and
March 1971; Rawlins, Wyoming in June 1969; Great Falls,
Montana in June 1969; and New York City in June 1969
and March 1971. A knowledge of the operations of each
of these systems is essential to an understanding of our
resolution of the issues.
Elmira: In November 1964, the date of the only infringe-
ment alleged with regard to the Elmira CATV system,
the system had the capacity to carry twelve television
channels. It received and provided its viewers with the
programs of ten television broadcast stations located in
Elmira and in communities varying from 46 to 173 miles
away. Broadcasts from CBS affiliates, as well as from
some stations with other network affiliations, in Buffalo
(119 miles), Scranton (76 miles), Syracuse (64 miles), and
Binghamton (46 miles) were received off-the-air® at the
5 The term, ‘‘off-the-air,”’ will be used throughout this opinion
to indicate the reception of broadcast television signals by means
of an antenna or similar receiving equipment. We use the term,
“‘broadeast,’’ in accordance with the definition given to **broad-
easting”’ in 47 U.S.C. § 153(0). Thus, ‘‘ off-the-air’’ reception does
Seer See note 6,
}
a ee F
en, ee
7a
system’s antenna site on a hill adjacent to Elmira and were
made available to the system’s subscribers. Because of
distance and topographical conditions, satisfactory re-
ception of the stations in Buffalo and Scranton is not
available by means of rooftop antennas in most locations
in and around Elmira. Satisfactory reception of the
Syracuse stations is available only in- some locations in
the northern portion of Elmira. One of the Binghamton
stations can be satisfactorily received from rooftop an-
tennas, but the other station cannot. In addition, the
Elmira system had two channels that were provided by
means of microwave links.* One of these was licensed to
the school system, which originated educational program-
ming that was transmitted by microwave from the schools
to the CATV system for distribution. The second micro-
wave had served to connect the system with an antenna
nearer New York City, where a New York independent sta-
tion was received off-the-air. None of the copyrighted pro-
grams was broadcast by this independent station.
Farmington: On two of the dates of alleged infringe-
ment, November 1964 and June 1969, Teleprompter op-
erated a five-channel system in Farmington. The system
received and distributed to its subscribers the signals of
four broadcast stations, all of which were received off-
the-air on antennas located on a mesa thirty miles from
* A microwave link involves the transmission of signals through
the air. Hiaver,, maleonnee (enamateten Se. eS Seen
easting. A broadcast signal, according to 47 U.S.C. § 153(0), is
transmitted by a broadcaster for ‘‘ [reception] by the public.’’ In
the case of microwave, the signal is focused and transmitted in a
narrow beam aimed with precision at the receiving points. Thus,
microwave transmission is point-to-point communication. The
receiving antenna must be in the path of the signal beam. If the
transmission must cover a considerable distance, the microwave
signal is transmitted to the first receiving point from which it is
re-transmitted to another receiving point, and this process is re-
peated until the signal reaches the point from which it is distrib-
uted by cable to subscribers.
‘
Farmington. Originally, all the stations were from Albu-
querque, New Mexico (144 miles from Farmington) ; later,
a station from Durango, Colorado (43 miles) was added
during periods when one of the Albuquerque stations was
not broadcasting. Because of distance and mountainous
terrain, reception of the Albuquerque stations directly off-
the-air by means of rooftop antennas was not feasible.
However, the Albuquerque stations, including the CBS
affiliate that broadcast the copyrighted programs, were re-
ceived in Farmington on rooftop antennas because they
were rebroadcast by ‘‘translators’’* under a license issued
by the Federal Communications Commission and pursuant
to authorization given by CBS and the station. The moun-
tainous terrain also made it impossible to receive by means
of rooftop antennas the Durango station, which is also a
CBS affiliate. This Durango station, however, entered in-
to a letter agreement with the Farmington CATV
system in which it authorized the latter to distribute the
station’s programming to its subscribers.’
By March 1971, the third date of alleged infringement,
the system had been rebuilt with twelve-channel equip-
ment. At this time, it received and distributed the
broadcasts of nine stations: four from Albuquerque, one
from Durango, and four independent stations from Los
Angeles (600 miles from Farmington). Obviously, the Los
Angeles stations were not receivable from rooftop antennas
in Farmington. These stations were received on an antenna
located approximately fifty miles from Los Angeles and
linked with the Farmington system by a microwave system,
1300 miles in length.
7 A ‘‘translator’’ is a television broadcast translator station that
is authorized to rebroadcast a specifie station’s signals.
® Teleprompter has not attempted to show that this letter agree-
ment amounts to an authorization or license for its carriage of the
copyrighted programs. The parties stipulated that no such au-
thorization or license was requested or received.
9a
On the one additional channel available to the system
in 1964 and 1969, it originated some limited program-
ming, which consisted of general interest programs
such as local news, sports, and movies, an automated time
and weather scan, and occasionally some educational pro-
grams. When the channel capacity had increased in 1971,
the automatic time and weather scan was originated on a
non-broadcast channel ** on a full-time basis. On a second
non-broadeast channel, educational programming was of-
fered. And on the third available channel, the CATV sys-
tem originated twenty hours per week of general interest
programs.
Rawlins: At the time of the alleged infringement, in
June 1969, the Rawlins CATV system had a twelve-channel
capacity. The system received and made available to its
subscribers programming from six b stations, five
from Denver, Colorado (184 miles from Rawlins), on which
the copyrighted programming was carried, one from
Casper, Wyoming (87 miles from Rawlins).' The system
received the Denver stations, which could not be received
in Rawlins from rooftop antennas, off-the-air on antennas
located ninety miles from Denver, and transmitted them by
microwave link to Rawlins. The Casper station was re-
ceived off-the-air on an antenna located at the edge of town.
Because of mountainous terrain, reception of the Casper
station directly off-the-air by rooftop antennas was not
generally possible; however, the Rawlins audience did re-
ceive its broadcasts as a result of rebroadeasts by a
translator. At the time of the alleged infringement, the
only program origination on non-broadcast channels that
© Thats consieted of an antemabed cusneie Ut eimueiell shed cul
weather dials.
10 A ‘‘non-broadcast channel,’’ as used in this opinion, is a chan-
nel that offers a CATV system’s own original programming but does
a ao a as ic +4
10a
the CATV system produced was an automated time and
weather scan.
Great Falls: The Great Falls CATV system was a
twelve-channel system at the time appellants allege it to
have infringed their copyrights. It received and distrib-
uted to its subscribers programming of nine broadcast
stations. Three of the stations (including the one that
broadcast the program whose copyright is alleged to have
been infringed) were in Spokane, Washington (286 miles
from Great Falls), one was in Lethbridge, Canada (163
miles away), two were in Salt Lake City (466 miles away),
and one was in Helena (71 miles away). The system re-
ceived the signal of each of these stations off-the-air by
means of antennas located at varying distances from
the originating stations (17 to 95 miles) and trans-
mitted it by microwave to a point in Great Falls, from
which it was distributed by cable to the system’s sub-
seribers. Because of distance, mountainous terrain, and
the limitations of the individual stations, the Great Falls
audience could receive none of these broadcast stations
by means of rooftop antennas. In addition, the system
received the signals of two Great Falls stations off-the-
air by means of antennas located in the community, and
distributed these signals to its subscribers. On a non-
broadcast channel, the system offered an automated time
and weather scan. On another non-broadcast channel, the
system originated ten hours per week of movies and local
interest programs.
New York: At the time of the first alleged infringe-
ment, in June 1969, Teleprompter’s New York CATV
system had a twelve-channel capacity. By March | the
time of the second alleged infringement, its cap had
increased to thirteen channels. Under the terms of the
system’s franchise, it must receive and distribute all
eleven New York City stations and is barred from import-
ing any stations from outside New York City. From time
lla
to time microwave has been used to connect the system’s
main antenna with two subsidiary antennas. The signals of
the New York stations were received off-the-air by these an-
tennas and distributed by cable to the subscribers. The
New York system, on its non-broadcast channels, offered
several forms of automated originations, in addition to
originating from forty to seventy hours of local and
general interest programming per week. In connection with
one of the latter types of originations, a sports event,
the Teleprompter system sold some commercial time and
interconnected with other CATV systems in the New York
area.
L Fortnightly Corp. v. United Artists, Inc.
The starting point in our analysis of appellants’ copy-
right-infringement claims must, of course, be the Su-
preme Court’s decision in Fortnightly Corp. v. United
Artists Television, Inc., supra. In deciding whether the
Fortnightly CATV system ‘“‘performed,’’ within the mean-
ing of the Copyright Act, the programming that it pro-
vided to subscribers, the Court applied a functional test and
held that the CATV system there involved was functionally
related more to the television viewer, who does not “‘per-
form,’’ than to the television broadcaster, who does ‘‘per-
form.’’ In this regard, Mr. Justice Stewart, speaking for
the Court, said:
The television broadcaster in one sense does less
than the exhibitor of a motion picture or stage play;
he supplies his audience not with visible images but
only with electronic signals. The viewer conversely
does more than a member of a theater audience; he
provides the equipment to convert electronic signals
into audible sound and visible images. Despite these
deviations from the conventional situation contem-
plated by the framers of the Copyright Act, broad-
casters have been judicially treated as exhibitors, and
viewers as members of a theatre audience. Broad-
casters perform. Viewers do not perform. ...
When CATV is considered in this framework, we
conclude that it falls-on the ere oe ae
Essentially, a CATV system no enhances
the viewer 8 capacity to receive the broadcaster’s sig-
-@ -well-located antenna with-an-effi-
Prva connection to the viewer’s television set. (Em-
phasis added.) pp. 398-99.
_ The teaching of Fortnightly is that a CATV reception
service that receives broadcast signals off-the-air from
an antenna or other receiving equipment erected within
or adjacent to the community it serves, and distributes
the programming received to subscribers, does not ‘‘per-
form’? the programs and, thus, is not subject to copyright
liability, even though the subscribers could not otherwise
receive the programs without the aid of CATV. Appellants
correctly note that the operations of each of the CATV
systems involved here were different and broader than
those of the system before the Supreme Court in Fort-
nightly. Fortnightly’s system provided a simple reception
service and consisted of ‘‘antennas located on hills above
each city with connecting coaxial cables, strung on utility
poles, to carry the signals received by the antennas to the
home television sets of individual subscribers.’’ Fort-
nightly, p. 392. Although Fortnightly was decided in 1968,
the litigation in that case had been instituted in 1960, and,
as a result, the Court considered CATV in a state of
technology that was then eight years out-of-date. Hence,
the Court did not have before it a system that originated
programming on non-broadcast channels, that sold commer-
cials on its origination programming, that had the capacity
to interconnect with other CATV systems, that utilized
microwave links in bringing broadcast signals to its sub-
scribers, and that imported signals from stations located
~
}
J
13a
hundreds of miles away from the community that the
system was intended to serve. Appellants’ counsel inform
us that the Supreme Court was made aware of the chang-
ing technology of CATV by counsel for amici and by
counsel for Fortnightly (who represent Teleprompter
here). Indeed, the Court’s opinion in at least two places
implied that it was aware of this fact and was not neces-
sarily laying down a broad rule to apply to all CATV sys-
tems regardless of the nature of their operations.”
The question before us is whether the character of CATV
is so changed by the additional services that the cable
systems here have undertaken that their total operation,
including the reception service, under the Fortnightly func-
tional test, have become functionally equivalent to those
of a broadcaster, and thus these systems should be deemed
to ‘‘perform’’ the broadcast programming that they dis-
tribute. The additional operations undertaken by these
CATV systems, which appellants contend distinguish this
case from Fortnightly and bring about this asserted meta-
morphosis in the character of CATV, are the following:
1) origination of programming on non-broadcast channels,
and the sale of commercial time on such non-broadcast
programming; 2) interconnection with neighboring CATV
systems; 3) use of microwave links in bringing broadcast
programming to subscribers; and 4) the importation of
distant broadcast signals from outside the area served by
the CATV system. We shall consider in order the effect
of each of these operations on the application of the
Fortnightly doctrine to the CATV systems involved.
Il. Non-broadcast Program Origination
At the outset, we reiterate that what is involved here
is the origination of programming on channels not used
- ™ See Fortnightly Corp. v. United Artists, Inc., 392 U.S. 390,
392 n. 6, and 399 n. 25 (1968).
14a
for the distribution of broadcast signals and the sale of
commercials on such non-broadcast channels. We do not
"have before us, and thus do not consider, the question of
what the effect would be on the Fortnightly doctrine if pro-
grams originated by the CATV system were used to replace
selected broadcast programming received from network or
independent stations that would otherwise have been dis-
tributed without alteration to subscribers on broadcast
channels. Similarly, we do not have before us a CATV
system that sold commercials on broadcast programming
to replace the commercials sold and transmitted by the
broadcast station.
Although the Supreme Court noted in Fortnightly that
it was not dealing with a CATV system that originated
non-broadcast programming,” we fail to see why a sys-
tem’s program origination on channels other than those
on which it relays broadcast programming should alter
the result in Fortnightly: Obviously, the system ‘‘per-
forms’’ these programs that it originates for distribution
to its subscribers. However, we do not see the logic in
a ? contention that this program origination serves
to convert chp CATY system into a ‘‘performer’’ of those
programs that it distributes to its subscribers on broadcast
channels. Even though the origination service and the re-
ception service are sold as a package to the subscribers,
they remain separate and different operations, and we
cannot sensibly say that the system becomes a ‘‘performer’’
of the broadcast programming when it offers both origina-
tion and reception services, but remains a non-performer
when it offers only the latter.
In support of their contention, appellants point to Asso-
ciated Music Publishers, Inc. v. Debs Memorial Radio
Fund, Ine., 141 F.2d 852 (2d Cir.), cert. denied, 323 U.S.
766 (1944). In that case, the defendants had argued that
12 Note 11, supra.
15a
they should not be subject to copyright liability for pro-
grams that they broadcast without advertising support but
merely as a service to their listeners. This court rejected
that contention, noting that the programs, even without
advertising, served to increase the total number of station
listeners and thus helped to maintain the station as a suc-
cessful financial entity. Appellants argue that Debs sup-
ports their position that the various functions of the CATV
systems should be considered as a whole to determine
whether the system is functionally equivalent to a broad-
caster, in which event it should be deemed a “‘performer’’
with regard to all programming it relays to its subscribers.
This argument is but a general statement of appellants’
particular contention that non-broadeast program orig-
ination converts the system into a ‘‘performer’’ with re-
gard to broadcast programming distributed to subscribers.
Debs, however, does not support either proposition. The
issue there was not whether the programs had been ‘‘per-
formed’’—indeed, having broadcast the programs, the sta-
tion could hardly contend it was not a ‘‘performer’’—but
whether the programs had been performed “‘for profit’;
and one can readily see that indirect ‘‘profit’’ accrued to
the station in Debs as a result of its unadvertised broadcast
of these programs. That decision is not authority for ap-
pellants’ broad proposition that the operations of a CATV
system must be viewed and evaluated for copyright pur-
poses as a whole; and, thus, neither can it support the
contention that a system’s non-broadcast program origina-
tion converts it into a ‘‘performer”’ of broadcast programs
distributed to subscribers by its reception service.
IO Hy wing Spey vemnon the 2 CATV \
16a
sarily wooden and mechanical in its application of copy-
right law to CATV.”
With regard to the sale of commercial time on non-broad-
cast programming, although this is another step bringing
cable origination programming in competition to some
extent with broadcast programming, again, we do not agree
cwith appellants’ position that there is some sort of “‘spill-
over’ effect by which the system becomes a ‘‘performer”’
with regard to its reception service.
Ill. Interconnection
As noted earlier, Teleprompter’s New York CATV sys-
tem has occasionally interconnected its facility with those
of the two other CATV systems operating in the New York
area. Appellants analogize this activity to the networking
that is common among broadcast stations, and they point
to this as another factor making the New York system
functionally equivalent to a broadcaster. However, the
only interconnection with which we are concerned occurred
_ There was' no intercon-
nection here relating to the reception of any telecast of
" appellants’ copyrighted programs, or indeed of any broad-
cast programming, received by the system and distributed
to subscribers. Therefore, we are not presently in a posi-
_ tion to evaluate what effect interconnection may have on .
_ tems..._In light of the minimal interconnection we have
_ 13 The Federal Communications Commission has adopted rules,
which appear in 47 C.F.R. § 76.201, requiring CATV systems with
more than 3,500 subscribers to commence program origination,
which is known in industry parlance as ‘‘cablecasting.’’ These
rules were suspended pending judicial review of the FCC’s CATV
rules. Although FCC authority over CATV was sustained in
United States v. Midwest Video, 405 U.S. 649 (1972), the FCC
has not yet reinstated the rules.
17a
before us, we must agree with the district court that
‘*[wjhatever this brief interconnection may portend for
the future, it [did] not transform [Teleprompter’s] pres-
ent CATV system into a broadcasting network as [appel-
lants] suggest.’’
IV. Microwave
A relatively recent development in CATV technology
that was not before the Court in Fortnightly is the use of
microwave to transmit a broadcast signal from the point
of its reception off-the-air to the point from which it is
distributed by cable to the homes of subscribers. Typically,
microwave is t into TV
, an activity the effect of which on the issue
before us we shall consider below.** However, the use of
microwave is not necessarily limited to this activity.
Appellants contend that the use of microwave, in and
of itself, is sufficient to make a CATV system functionally
equivalent to a broadcaster and thus subject to copyright
liability for all the programming it receives and distributes
to its subscribers. We are unconvinced by this contention.
Neither do we believe that the use of microwave makes the
system a ‘“‘performer”’’ only of that programming with
respect to which the microwave is used. Microwave utilizes
point-to-point communication and is merely an alternative,
more economical in some circumstances, to cable in trans-
mitting a broadcast signal from one point in a CATV
system to another. Hence, we see no reason to attach legal
14 Although we consider them separately, the use of microwave
and the importation of distant signals are often very closely con-
nected, in the sense that microwave links are the usual means by
which a CATV system imports distant signals. As is evident from
the experience of the New York system, however, it is possible for
microwave to be used apart from distant signal importation, and.
it is in this sense that we consider in this section of the opinion
the effect of microwave on the application of Fortnightly. to CATV
systems. .
||
!
18a
significance, in terms of copyright liability, to the decision
to utilize microwave links.
V. Ingertaten of Distant Signals
Appellants’ final, and in the end, most persuasive con-
tention relates to the fact that certain of the CATV sys-
tems involved here distributed to their subscribers signals
from broadcast stations located many miles from the com-
munities served by the systems. In CATV parlance, this
is known as the importation of distant signals. This
activity was not before the Supreme Court in Fortnightly,
and appellants contend that that decision did not signify
that a CATV system does not ‘‘perform”’ a copyrighted
television program when it brings the signal in from
another community, often from another television market,
and distributes that signal to subscribers.
The CATV system in Fortnightly brought television sig-
nals to viewers who could not otherwise have received
them. However, these signals were already in the com-
munity and were not imported by the CATV system from
another community, as is eyi by the fact that the
system received them from tenna located in or directly
adjacent to the CATV community. It was only because
i in and around the community
that residents could not receive the signals on their re-
ceivers. Thus, it was the office of the CATV system in
Fortnightly to use its advanced antenna technology and
equipment to overcome these adverse conditions and thereby
to bring the signals to members of the community. The
Court held that, in performing this function,
the CATV system did not ‘‘perform,”’ within the meaning
of the Copyright Act, the programming carried on those
i However, in United States v. Southwestern Cable
Co., 392 U.S. 157 (1968), decided just one week before
Fortnightly, the Court explicitly recognized that this was
only one of two major services that CAT'V systems render
19a
to the communities they serve. In this regard, Mr. Justice
Harlan, speaking for the Court, stated at p. 163:
CATV systems perform either or both of two func-
_tions. First, they may supplement broadcasting by
facilitating satisfactory reception of local stations in
adjacent areas in which such reception would not other-
wise be possible; and second, they may transmit to
subscribers the signals of distant stations entirely
beyond the range of local antennae.
When a CATV system is performing this second function
of distributing signals that are beyond the range of local
antennas, we believe that, to this extent, it is functionally
equivalent to a broadcaster and thus should be deemed to
‘*perform’”’ the programming distributed to subscribers on
these imported signals. See Select Theatres Corp. v.
Ronzoni Macaroni Co., 59 U.S.P.Q. 288 (S.D.N.Y., 1943),
cited in Fortnightly, 392 U.S. at 398, n. 23, for the proposi-
tion that ‘‘broadeasters perform.’’ The system’s function
in this regard is no longer merely to enhance the sub-
seriber’s ability to receive signals that are in the area;
it is now acting to bring signals into the community that
would not otherwise be receivable on an antenna, even a
large community antenna, erected in that area.
In Fortnightly, the CATV system distributed the pro-
grams to an audience to which they would not otherwise
have been presented. But the Court did not find this fact
ry op yoo copyright eocgonee. The Court found
new andience.y-prveing i with the serine ofan a
vanced antenna. It then reasoned that, since a on
viewer was privileged to view whatever programs he could
receive using any available antenna, a CATV system should
not be deemed a ‘‘performer’’ for copyright purposes when
it- provided this antenna service as a commercial yenture.
When a distant signal is involved, CATV is again dis-
Er pa fae igh aniery Te ee
Oikaier Sedtiadirts cas Uk Studd ott Sette bees edb to
view the programs even if there had been available in
roth eens Baral ses: edhe quem Dna hertieeyedts < etiie
donk Giceeitiag Gesaniind cach ‘az mlaeare Bika,
that is used to bring the programs from the community
where the system receives them into the community in
which the new andience views them. The viewer’s ability
to receive the signal is no longer a product solely of im-
proved antenna technology; rather, it results from the sys-
tem’s importation of the signal into the CATV community
from a separate, distant community.
As a result, we no longer have a system that ‘‘no more
than enhances the viewer’s capacity to receive the broad-
caster’s signals.’’ Fortnightly, p. 399. We hold that when
a CATV system imports distant signals, it is no longer
within the ambit of the Fortnightly doctrine, and there is
then no reason to treat it differently from any other person
who, without license, displays a copyrighted work to an
audience who would not otherwise receive it. For this
reason, we conclude that the CATV system is a “‘per-
former’’ of whatever programs from these distant signals
that it distributes to its subscribers.
There remains, however, the difficult problem of defining
what is a distant signal. The range of a television signal
is a function of many factors, including the current state
of broadcast and reception technology. Some of these
factors, such as topography, are unchanging in a particular
area. But broadcast and reception technology are in a
constant state of flux. Moreover, in determining the range
of a broadcast signal, it may not be enough to say that
the signal is or is not receivable in the community served
by the CATV system. The fact that the signal can be
21a
received may not be meaningful unless it can project an
image that is acceptable according to industry norms.
Thus, it seems clear that a precise judicial definition
of a distant signal is not possible. The FCC, for purposes
of the CATV signal-carriage requirements, at one time
categorized signals as ‘‘distant’’ and ‘‘local’’ in terms of
their ability to be received a substantial portion of the
time by a substantial portion of the homes in the area by
means of home antennas."* However, we find this definition
unsuitable for copyright purposes because we believe that
any definition phrased in terms of what can be received in
area homes using rooftop antennas would fly in the face of
the mandate of Fortnightly. Thus, in the absence of legis-
lation on this matter, we must undertake to establish some
standard for determining what is a distant signal for copy-
right purposes.
Any determination that a particular television signal
is ‘‘distant’’ must, of course, be made with respect to its
proximity to a specific local area, which we have termed
the CATV community, served by the CATV system and
designated in a franchise issued to it by a state or local
government body or regulatory authority.* To say that a
15This was phrased in terms of the Grade B contour, which
marks the boundary along which acceptable reception of the signal
is expected to be available 90 percent of the time at the best 50
percent of the locations. See 47 C.F.R. §§ 73.683 and 73.684. With
respect to locations outside its Grade B contour, a signal was con-
sidered a ‘‘distant signal’’ hy the FCC. Recently the FCC has
promulgated regulations that give a broader definition of distant
and local signals for purposes of the signal-carriage requirements
of CATV systems. 47 C.F.R. §§ 76.59, 76.61, and 76.63. See 37
Fed. Reg. 3263 (Feb. 12, 1972).
16 The franchise represents a grant to the CATV system of an-
thority to run its cables through the public streets and facilities
of a city, town, or county to the homes of its subscribers.
' Almost 5,000 such franchises have already been granted, with
the number continuing to increase. See Barnett, State, Federal
22a
signal is already in the community, which is to
say there is no need to import it through a relay or re-
transmittal device (such as microwave, cable, satellite,
or the like), is to indicate that it can be received in the
community during a substantial portion of the time by
means of an antenna, such as a large community antenna
or other receiving device, that is available under current
technology. Thus, the meaning of ‘‘distant signal’? must
be determined in light of the current broadcasting and
receiving technology. In this regard, we find .that it is
easier to state what is not a distant signal than to state
what is a distant signal. Accordingly, we have concluded
that—any_signal capable of projecting, without relay or
and Local Regulation of Cable Television, 47 Notre Dame Lawyer
681, 702 (1972). Although the franchises have for the most part
been issued by local authorities such as cities and towns, at least
five states (Connecticut, Nevada, Rhode Island, Vermont, and
Hawaii) have in effect laws subjecting CATV to state regulation,
and more appear to be in the process of enacting such state regu-
latory schemes (e.g., Massachusetts, Illinois, New York and New
Jersey), probably because of the disadvantages associated with
local as compared with state regulation, id. at 698-708. Hence it
may be anticipated that some state agencies may, as part of their
new regulatory schemes, create local franchise areas or regions
within the state based upon community of interest and population
concentrations, as has been done by Connecticut. Id. 701-02.
As used by us, the term ‘‘CATV community’”’ is limited strictly
to the specifically designated local area for which the franchise
is granted by the state or local authority, which may not be ex-
panded or enlarged by interconnection, merger of two or more
franchised areas, or other means. We do not have before us, and
thus do not consider, the hypothetical ease in which the area for
which the franchise is granted is not local, but state-wide or com-
prising a broad region. We are aware of no such franchises pres-
ently granted or under consideration. For the moment, we can
say that the ‘‘CATV community”’ we envision is essentially a local
entity, the parts of which share substantial common interests.
to the
seems to
——_——
which we term the originating community, and the CATV
community are different, and when the signal is initially
received by the system at a location in or near the orig-
inating community and then transmitted to the CA
community by microwave or cable, a strong presumption
arises that it is a distant signal. The alleged infringer
is then under a heavy burden to show that the signal is not
a distant signal—that is, that it would be equally receiv-
able off-the-air in the first instance and would project an
image of similar quality, if there were substantially similar
receiving equipment located in or adjacent to the CATV
community. Unless this burden is met, the signal should
be deemed a distant signal and the CATV system would
not be within the ambit of Fortnightly with respect to that
signal.
Similarly, when the signal is initially received by the
CATV system on an antenna or other receiving device
located between the originating community and the CATV
community, the signal should be deemed a distant signal
in the absence of a contrary showing by the CATV system.
17 By ‘‘relay, or retransmittal,’’ we do not mean the authorized
rebroadcast of the signal by a translator station, or the like. See
note 19, infra, and accompanying text, where we indicate that the
mere use of a translator does not, without more, make the signal
a ‘‘distant signal,’’ as that term is used in this opinion. It should
be noted that microwave transmission, in the context of CATV
distant-signal importation, does not constitute a broadcast or a
rebroadeast. ‘‘Broadeasting”’ is defined at 47 U.S.C. §153(0)
as ‘‘the dissemination of radio communications intended to be
received by the public, directly or by the intermediary of relay
24a
We do not necessarily mean that the antenna or receiving
device on which the signal is initially received cannot in
any case be located outside the city limits of the com-
munity that has franchised the CATV system. We can
envision various legitimate circumstances, such as the de-
sire to take advantage of a tall building, hill, or other
topographical feature, that might cause the system to desire
to locate its antenna or receiving device in an area closely
neighboring the community that it serves. Such an antenna
placement is not motivated by the desire to be.closer to
the signal’s point of origin in order to receive it before
its strength is dissipated and then to transmit to another
location—presumably the motive that ordinarily underlies
a system’s decision to locate its antenna outside the com-
munity that it serves. Therefore, we would treat such a
case in the same manner as those in which the antenna is
located within the CATV community. However, we wish
to make clear that the distances we envision here are small,
and that any system that locates its antenna more than a
few miles from the CATV community should bear the
burden of showing that the signals it receives and dis-
tributes are not in fact distant signals.**
18 Teleprompter has argued that it is insulated from copyright
liability by a license implied in law. This court explicitly rejected
this argument in our Fortnightly decision. United Artists, Inc. v.
Fortnightly Corp., 377 F.2d 872, 880-884 (2d Cir. 1967), rev’d.
392 U.S. 390 (1968). The Supreme Court in Fortnightly refused
to embrace this argument when it rejected the Solicitor General’s
proposed compromise resolution of that case, although it did not
necessarily reject this line or reasoning. See 392 U.S. 401-02.
Teleprompter argues that the terms of our decision on this issue
in Fortnightly would not necessarily apply to the facts presented
by three of the five CATV systems involved here—Elmira, New
York City, and Farmington. In light of our resolution of this case,
we need not deal with this contention with regard to the Elmira
and New York City systems. As to the Farmington system, our
decision with regard to the Albuquerque stations obviates the neces-
sity to consider the license-implied-in-law issue. See Part IV, infra.
On the matter of the Durango station, see note 20, infra. In other
respects, we decline to re-examine our prior decision on this issue
in Fortnightly.
25a
VL. Conclusion
In light of what we have said, we conclude that the
CATV systems in New York City and Elmira were prop-
erly held not subject to copyright liability. In the case
of New York City, it was stipulated that the Teleprompter
system did not at any time import distant signals. As to
Elmira, although it appears that the system did import
and distribute one distant signal from New York City, it
is stipulated that none of the programs at issue involving
alleged copyright infringement were carried by that sta-
tion. The remaining stations distributed by the Elmira
system were stipulated to have been received by an antenna
located on a hill directly neighboring the city, and were
thus not distant signals. Therefore, the Elmira system
was properly held not subject to copyright liability with
respect to programming carried on these signals.
On the other hand, ins CATV system imported
five Denver stations from a distance of 184 miles. It was
on these Denver stations that the programs at issue were
carried. The system received these stations on an antenna
located 90 miles from Denver. Therefore, we conclude
that these Denver signals were presumptively distant sig-
nals and that, in distributing the programs carried on these
stations, the Rawlins system ‘‘performed”’ the copyrighted
programs and thereby infringed appellants’ copyrights.
For the same reason, we hold that the Great Falls system
“‘performed”’ the copyrighted programs, which were dis-
tributed to subscribers through the importation of a signal
originating in Spokane, Washington (284 miles from Great
Falls) and received by antennas located 55 and 67 miles
from Spokane.
The Farmi system provides potentially the clearest
example tant signal importation, in that signals orig-
inating in Los Angeles, California, 600 miles away, were
distributed to subscribers. However, none of the copy-
righted programs at issue were broadcast by any of the
Los Angeles stations. Thus, the importation of the Los
\)
Angeles stations is not relevant to this case, and we must
still determine whether the stations that broadcast the
copyrighted programs were distant signals. The alleged
infringements relate to programs that were carried by
stations located in Albuquerque (144 miles) and Durango,
Colorado (43 miles). These signals were received by the
CATV system on an antenna located on a mesa 30 miles
outside of Farmington. We believe that a distance of 30
miles is too great to sustain an assertion that the antenna
is adjacent to the CATV community. Instead, .on these
facts, we must treat the system as one that has located its
antenna outside the CATV community. Thus, in the ab-
sence of a contrary showing by Teleprompter, the signals
should be deemed distant signals and the system should
be held to have ‘‘performed’’ the copyrighted programs
and thereby infringed the copyrights. _
Of course, each system deemed to have imported distant
signals must be afforded an opportunity to show. that,
although the receiving antenna was located outside the
CATV community, the particular signal could have been
received in a similar fashion by an equivalent antenna
located in or adjacent to the CATV community. We seri-
ously doubt that the Rawlins and Great Falls system
could sustain this heavy burden because of the great dis-
tances involved. However, the situation may be somewhat
different with regard to the Farmington system. The in-
fringement alleged with regard to Farmington concerned
programming broadcast by two CBS affiliates that the sys-
tem distributed to subscribers—one from Albuquerque and
one from Durango. The parties have stipulated that
‘‘[pjursuant to permission granted by CBS and by
[the Albuquerque affiliate], the signals [of the affiliate]
... were rebroadcast [by a translator system] located
near Farmington ... All of the signals embodying the
programs as to which infringement by the Farmington
CATV is alleged . . . were rebroadcast by these trans-
lators.’’
2a
“ It was further stipulated that, as a result of these trans-
lators, ‘‘(t]hese signals . . . could be received by residents
of Farmington on rooftop antennas.”’
* From these facts, we conclude, without the need for fur-
ther showing by Teleprompter, that these Albuquerque
stations could have been received by a CATV antenna
located within Farmington of substantially similar sophis-
tication to that erected on the mesa. Thus, it is clear that
the Albuquerque stations were not distant signals, and
there is no need to remand to the district court for findings
on this point.” On the other hand, the stipulation indi-
cated that the signals of the Durango affiliate were not re-
broadcast and could not be received by means of rooftop
antennas. Thus, if the system is unable to demonstrate
that the Durango station is not a distant signal, it must
then be regarded as a ‘‘performer’’ of the programming
distributed to subscribers on that station. Since the copy-
righted programs were distributed to subscribers on both
the Albuquerque and the Durango stations, this leads to
the conclusion that the Farmington system was a ‘‘per-
former,’’ and thereby infringed the copyright, when it dis-
tributed the programs on the Durango station, but was
not a ‘‘performer,’’ and did not infringe, when it dis-
tributed the same programs on the Albuquerque station.”
1” Although these signals were receivable because they were re-
broadcast by translators, our earlier statement of the governing
standard, ‘‘that any signal capable of projecting, without relay
or transmittal, an acceptable image that can be reached off-the-air
. . - by means of an antenna .. . erected in or adjacent to the
CATV community is not a distant signal,’’ does not make the
Albuquerque stations distant signals. We were not referring to
an authorized rebroadcast of the’ signal.
2° We do not believe that the carriage of the Durango stations
falls within our reservation of decision in Fortnightly on the issue
of license implied in law, since the Durango station’s broadcasts
‘were not\receivable off-the-air by means of rooftop antennas in
Farmington. See 377 F.2d at 884.
28a
Although this result is somewhat lacking in symmetry, in
the final analysis it will probably result in minimal dam-
ages, if any, being imposed on the Farmington CATV
system; for we find it hard to see what damages appel-
lants can have sustained, or what profits Teleprompter
earned, from the carriage of the Durango broadcasts in
light of the system’s simultaneous non-infringing distribu-
tion of the programs on the Albuquerque CBS affiliate. By
the simple turn of a knob, the viewers who saw the pro-
grams on the Durango station could have viewedthem, as
a result of the efforts of the same CATV system, on the
Albuquerque station. However, we think that, unless the
Durango station is shown not to have been a distant signal,
there was at least a technical infringement of the copyright
with regard to that station.
Accordingly, in light of our disposition of the issues on
this appeal, we affirm the district court’s holding that
Teleprompter’s Elmira and New York City CATV systems
did not infringe appellants’ copyrights; we reverse the dis-
trict court’s decision with regard to Teleprompter’s
Rawlins, alls, and Farmington CATV systems,
without prejudice, however, to“Teleprompter to proceed
in the district court within a reasonable time to show that
any of these systems did not in fact import distant signals ;
and we remand to the district court for further proceedings,
including the determination of damages, as are not i incon-
sistent with this opinion.
The complex problems presented by the issues in this
ease are not readily amenable to judicial resolution. As
the Supreme Court said in Fortnightly, ‘‘[wle [must] take
the Copyright Act of 1909 as we find it,’’ and do the best
we can. We hope that the Congress will in due course
legislate a fuller and more flexible accommodation of com-
peting copyright, anti-trust, and communications policy con-
siderations, consistent with the challenges of modern CATV
technology.
Affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
64 Crv. 3814
Cotumsia Broapcastine System, Ixc., Catvapa Propuctions,
a joint venture, Jack Cuerrox Tzxzvision, Ivc., Dena
Pictures, Inc., Plaintiffs,
Vv.
TeLEPRomPpTer Corporation and Contzy Exzcrronics Cor-
poration, Defendants.
APPEARANCES
Rosenman, Coin, Kaye; Personex, Freunp & Ema
575 Madison Avenue
New York, New York 10022
By: Asa D. Sokolow
Renee J. Roberts
James K. Nevling, Jr.
Harry Olsson
Attorneys for Plaintiff Columbia
Broadcasting System, Inc.
MarsHat1, Bratrer, Greene, Auiison & Tucker
430 Park Avenue
New York, New York 10022
By: Royal E. Blakeman
Bertram Weidberg
120 Broadway
New York, New York 10005
By: Alfred C. Moran
Attorneys for Plaintiff Jack Chertok Television, Inc.
Gravsarp, Mosxovirz, McGotprics, Dannett & %
Horowitz
345 Park Avenue
New York, New York 10022
By: Bernard Buchholz
Attorneys for Plaintiff, Dena Pictures, Inc.
Creary, Gorrurms, Steen & Hamitton
1250 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D. C. 20036
By: Robert C. Barnard
R. Michael Duncan
Attorneys for Defendants
Karz, Scurer, Rosensweic &@nv_e
437 Madison Avenue
N ew York, New York 10022
By: Walter C. Schier
David R. Rosensweig
Attorneys for Defendants
Constance Baxer Morttey, D. J. “
I. Introduction *
Four years ago, in Fortnightly Corp. v. United Artists
Television, Inc., 392 U.S. 390 (1968), (Fortnightly), the
Supreme Court developed the test ‘by which the copyright
liability of community antenna television (CATV) systems
was to be measured:' Progress in the CATV industry has
1**CATV’”’ is the term generally applied by the Federal Com-
munications Commission to facilities which receive signals over
the air from telévision stations, modify them and distribute them
by wire or cable to subscribing members of the public who pay
for such service. 47 C:F.R. §74.1101(a). The Supreme Court
has also defined and applied this term. See United States v.
Southwestern Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157, 161-163 (1968) ; Fortnightly
Corp. v. United Artists, 392 U.S. 390 (1968). The CATV industry
—
3la
brought us the inevitable sequel to that case. We are asked
here to decide whether specific differences between defend-
ants’ CATV’s and those in Fortnightly—most importantly, -
transmittal of broadcast signals from stations hundreds of
miles away and program origination—make defendants
liable for infringement of plaintiffs’ copyrights.
Defendants Teleprompter Corp. (Teleprompter) and
Conley Electronics Corp. (a wholly-owned subsidiary of
Teleprompter) own a large number of CATV stations’ :
throughout the United States. Plaintiff Columbia Broad-
casting System (CBS) operates a television broadcasting
network, furnishing programs to approximately 200 affili-
ated television stations. CBS owns copyrights on certain
programs, and, in addition, licenses programs from the
other plaintiffs who likewise produce television programs.
Defendants’ CATV systems receive broadcast television
signals embodying plaintiffs’ copyrighted material and
transmit those signals to the homes of their subscribers.
The parties agreed that the activities of five of defend-
ants’ facilities located in different parts of the country
‘would best illustrate the nature and extent of defendants’
activities for purposes of decision here. These five facili-
ties are located as follows: Elmira, New York; Farming-
ton, New Mexico; Great Falls, Montana; New York, New
York; and Rawlins, Wyoming. The activities of these
five stations, including how and from where they received
plaintiffs’ copyrighted materials, form the basis of a
lengthy | stipulation of facts. It is only the legal signifi-
cance of those facts which forms the core of this dispute.
is also popularly known as ‘‘cable TV’’, ‘‘cablecasting’’, or even
‘*broadband communications’’. By its tone, the designation ‘‘com-
munity antenna television’’ suggests a prejudgment of the issues
in this case, implying as it does that CATV is no more than an
antenna owned by the community. Nevertheless, because of its
widespread use in at least the authoritative legal literature, we
shall use ‘‘CATV’’ when referring to defendants’ operations here.
~
It is also stipulated that none of defendants’ stations had
licenses under the copyrights from plaintiffs or from the
television broadcast stations around the country which
broadcast the plaintiffs’ programs over-the-air, and the
licenses granted by plaintiffs to stations which broadcast
their programs did not authorize carriage of the programs
by CATV systems.
The ultimate question before us is whether defendants
‘*performed”’ plaintiffs’ works within the meaning of § 1
of the Copyright Act..\17 U.S.C. § 1. In Fortnightly, the
facts of which will be stated below, the Court addressed
the issue of whether CATV’s perform. Recognizing that
‘“«[t]elevision viewing results from combined activity by
broadcasters and viewe®s,’’ it held that broadcasters per-
form while viewers do not. The CATV system in Fort-
nightly, the Court concluded, fell on the viewer’s side of
the line and hence did not perform. This conclusion was
reached by analyzing the ‘‘ . . . function that CATV plays
in the total process of television broadcasting and recep-
tion’’; that is, whether the CATV system functioned more
like a viewer or more like a broadcaster. Comparing the
function of the CATV system before it to that of both the
viewer and his equipment and the broadcaster, the Court
found the function of CATV more similar to the former.
It is plaintiffs’? contention that defendants’ five CATV
systems engage in activities different from those of the
CATV systems in Fortnightly, placing defendants’ systems
on the broadcaster’s side of the line. Specifically, the fol-
lowing activities are said to have given defendant’s CATV
systems the function of broadcasters: 1) program origina-
tion, 2) the importation of distant signals, 3) selection of
programs, 4) microwave transmission, 5) interconnection
with other CATV stations, 6) advertising, and 7) sale of
commercials. These activities, plaintiffs charge, were
either not performed by the Fortnightly systems or were
performed to a significantly lesser degree. Singly or to-
spaces sey NN 28 ip RE i aE —
33a
gether, plaintiffs suggest, these differences amount to a-
difference of fanction between defendants’ systems and
those in Fortnightly.
Not surprisingly, defendants stress the similarities be-
tween their operations and those of the Fortnightly sys-
tems. They further contend that, regardless of whatever
else their stations do, with respect to plaintiffs’ programs
Teleprompter is conducting a reception service identical
to the one in Fortnightly.
We are thus faced with the question of the extent to
which defendants’ operations differ from those of the
CATV systems in Fortnightly, and whether these differ-
ences cause defendants to function as broadcasters, there-
fore ‘‘performing’’ plaintiffs’ works within the meaning
of the Copyright Act. For the reasons set forth below we
find that defendants have not performed plaintiffs’ works
in violation of the Copyright Act. Defendants are there-
fore not liable for infringement of copyright.
II. Findings of Fact
Since many of the facts in this case were stipulated by
the parties, these findings will treat only the ultimate facts -
relevant to the decision.
A. Prior Proceedings
This action was commenced on December 11, 1964. At
that time Fortnightly was pending before Judge Herlands
in this District. Efforts to consolidate this case with Fort-
nightly for purposes of trial or appeal were unsuccessful,
and by agreement of the parties proceedings in the instant
case were stayed pending the ultimate decision in Fort-
nightly. Plaintiffs were granted permission to file supple-
mental complaints on December 15, 1969 and May 17, 1971
2 Defendants raise several other defenses we need not discuss at
this point.
to include allegations concerning events up to March 31,
1971. By the pre-trial order of October 23, 1970, trial of
the case was divided into stages. The first stage, which
this opinion addresses, is the trial of the issue of whether
there was an infringement of copyright. A trial to the
court was held from September 21 through 30, 1971.
B. Plaintiffs
CBS as a regular part of its business creates programs
for television and acquires other programs. These pro:
grams are broadcast by television stations which are affili-
ates of the CBS Television Network (an unincorporated
division of CBS); many of these are later placed in syndi-
cation—licensed to individual television stations for broad-
cast.
Jack Chertok Television, Inc:, Calvada Productions and
Dena Pictures, Inc. are independent program packagers
which create television programs that are furnished to
networks and independent television stations.
C. Defendants
Teleprompter Corp. is a New York corporation widely
engaged in CATV activities. Conley Electronics Corp. an
Illinois corporation, isa wholly-owned subsidiary of de-
fendant Teleprompter.
Defendants’ CATV systems, five of which were the sub-
ject of the evidence at trial, operate generally as follows.
Homeowners who subscribe to CATV pay an i ation
fee and a monthly charge. The monthly charge does not
vary with the amount of time CATV is used or with any
particular programs watched. A coaxial cable links the
homeowner’s television set to the CATV facility. By
means of this connection, homeowners receive two general
types of programming on their sets. One is programming
originated by the CATV systems themselves and carried
by the cable. The other type is programming received off-
EL ETE EE I ERE L Ro ET LOTR NS RL ORT OE —
35a
the-air by CATV receivers which has been broadcast by
‘‘regular’’ TV broadcast stations. Frequently, the home-
owner could not receive these signals via his rooftop
antenna.
All of the five CATV’s have the capacity to carry twelve
channels to subscribers, except New York, which has a
25-channel cable link to some subscribers. None of the
CATV’s uses its full complement of available channels.
D. Origination
As mentioned above, Teleprompter’s systems receive
signals from television broadcast stations, modify the sig-
nals, and then carry them to subscribers’ homes by coaxial
cable. In addition, defendants’ systems originate their own
programs. This is done by transmitting programs live, on
videotape or on film from the CATV station on- channels
not then being used for the received programs.
Some of the origination consists of a camera scan of
time and weather information, printed messages, stock
and news tickers, and program listings—what may be
called ‘‘automatic origination.”’
By 1969, all five of the stations were transmitting ‘‘auto-
matic’’ origination, often consisting of time and ‘weather
information, virtually 24 hours a day.
In addition to this automatic origination, the stations
carry varying amounts of other program origination. At
the low end of the scale, the Elmira system occasionally
originates educational programming from a studio located
ina city school. This material appears on the same channel
as the automatically originated programs, replacing the
time message and weather scan during that period.. Aside
from these educational shows, the only origination by the
Elmira station is ‘‘automatic.’’
The Great Falls, Rawlins and Farmington stations orig-
inate more non-automatic programming than Elmira but
36a
less than New York. Though neither Great Falls nor
Rawlins apparently originated any programming of this
nature in 1964, by 1969 both were transmitting an average
of ten hours a week besides time, weather and message
scans. Farmington originated an average of four and a
half hours a day, seven days a week in 1964; three hours
a day, five days a week in 1969; and four hours a day,
seven days a week in 1971.
New York City originated approximately forty hours a
week of ‘‘non-automatic’’ programming during June 1969.
By March 1971 this figure had grown to seventy hours
a week.
Programs originated by the Great Falls, Farmington,
New York and Rawlins systems have a wide range of
content. Though the emphasis varies in different cities,
with a large amount of local coverage by all systems, the
kinds of programs originated by these four CATV systems
are generally similar to those normally broadcast by tele-
vision stations. Thus, Teleprompter originates news,
sports and weather reports, documentaries, educational and
religious shows, discussions, interviews, bingo, sports
events, children’s shows, movies and entertainment films.
The number of hours of program origination is in all
cases substantially less than the number of hours of broad-
cast programming transmitted by the CATV systems.
In originating programming some Teleprompter per-
sonnel perform tasks similar to those performed by people
involved in broadcasting television programs. Some of the
equipment used by Teleprompter stations to originate pro-
grams is also used by broadcast stations.
E. Distant Signals
Since ‘‘[t]he effective range of the broadcast is deter-
mined by the combined contribution of the equipment em-
ployed by the broadcaster and that supplied by the viewer,”’
37a
(Fortnightly, 392 U.S. at 398), it is impossible to define a
precise line between a ‘‘distant’’ and a “‘local’? signal.
The term is applied here only to connote a distinction
between signals ordinarily receivable by rooftop or tower-
mounted antennas and those that are not. The plaintiffs,
at least, place a great deal of importance on this difference.
All of Teleprompter’s CATV systems except New York
receive and carry to subscribers signals not ordinarily
receivable either by house-top antennas or both house-top
and tower-mounted antennas. These systems are outside
the ‘‘Grade B’’ contour of the stations whose signals they
receive and carry.
“The Grade B contour of a television station is the
boundary of a hypothetical area at whose outer limits
television reception of ‘a quality acceptable to the
median observer’ is expected to be available at least
90 percent of the time at the best 50 percent of the
receiver locations, based on expected field intensities
and certain assumptions as to the nature and height
of the receiving antenna, and the capabilities of the
television set. For the Grade A contour the pertinent
figures are 90 percent of the time and the best 70
percent of the locations. These predicted contours are
plotted on the basis of propagation charts and rules
set forth in 47 CFR 73.684.’’ (Stipulation No. 1, 1 60.)
In most instances the signals are received in the locale
where they were broadcast by a receiving antenna. The
signals are then carried by microwave transmission, some-
times hundreds of miles, to a microwave receiving station.
From there the signals would be carried by cable, eventually
to subscribers’ homes.
Teleprompter’s Farmington, New Mexico and Great
Falls, Montana systems best illustrate this importation of
distant signals. Farmington lies 144 miles from Albu-
querque, New Mexico. Due to the distance and rough
38a
topography betweén the two cities, television reception in
Farmington of Albuquerque stations directly off-the-air by
house-top or tower-mounted antennas is not feasible.
Farmington CATV erected off-the-air receiving antennas
on Huerfano Mesa, an elevated point about thirty miles
from Farmington. Signals from the Albuquerque stations
were received there, carried by microwave to the Farming-
ton system’s building in Farmington and then to sub-
seribers by cable.* Signals from a station in Durango,
Colorado were also received at Huerfano Mesavand carried
by Farmington CATV.‘ Though Durango is only 43 miles
from Farmington, mountains between the two cities pre-
vent reception in Farmington by house-top antennas.
Farmington is within the ‘‘Grade B’’ contour of the
Durango station.
Beginning in November 1970 the Farmington CATV
received and distributed signals of four television stations
in Los Angeles, Califernia, in addition to those stations
mentioned above.5 Farmington is over 600 miles from Los
Angeles, so off-the-air reception of the Los Angeles station
by either house-top or tower-mounted antennas is impos-
sible. Signals of the Los Angeles stations were received
off-the-air by antennas forty-seven miles from Los Angeles.
They were then carried by microwave via twenty-three
steps over a roundabout, 1300-mile route to Farmington.
It should also be noted that translators owned by the
San Juan Non-Profit TV Association serve the Farming-
ton area. The association’s operations are supported by
voluntary contributions from Farmington residents. A
translator receives signals from a television broadcasting
’The stations are KGGM-TV (a CBS affiliate), KOB-TV,
KNME-TV, and KOAT-TV.
*KREZ-TV (a CBS affiliate).
5 The stations are KTLA-TV, KTTV-TV, KHJ-TV, and KCOP-
TV.
39a
station, converts the carrier waves of the television signals
to a new carrier frequency, amplifies them, and broadcasts
them into the air. The translators in Farmington received
three VHF stations located in Albuquerque and rebroad-
cast them on UHF frequencies.* Farmington residents could
then receive the signals on house-top antennas. CBS and
its Albuquerque affiliate, KGGM-TV, gave written per-
mission for rebroadcast by the Association’s translators.
The Great Falls CATV imports distant signals by a
similar method of receiving the television broadcasts off-
the-air near their source and carrying them by microwave
to Great Falls. Signals are received in Great Falls from
Spokane, Washington (226 miles), Lethbridge, Canada
(163 miles) ; Salt Lake City, Utah (466 miles) ; and Helena,
Montana (71 miles).
F. Program Selection .
It appears that all five CATV systems carry every tele-
vision broadcast station operating within their own areas.
That is, any station a resident can receive by house-top
antenna will also be brought to him over cable by his local
CATV system. In addition, as we have seen, in all cities
but New York a subscriber receives other, more distant,
stations.”
Where they import distant signals, as described above,
Teleprompter’s systems make a decision about which sta-
tions should be received. Teleprompter has freedom to
choose which signals from other cities to receive and trans-
mit to each locale.
With possibly one exception, the Teleprompter CATV
systems receive the signals of the television stations they
® The stations are KGGM-TV, KOB-TV, and KOAT-TV.
* The New York CATV’s franchise from the City of New York
specifies the television broadcasting stations to be carried by the
CATV system.
40a
carry continuously, and distribute them without editing or
deletion, except for deletion of the signals of distant sta-
tions as required by the FCC’s nonduplication rules. The
one possible exception is the Farmington CATV, which for
a period carried the signals of KREZ-TV i in Durango, Colo-
rado only in the evening hours.
Teleprompter’s systems do not otherwise choose the
sequence or content of programs they receive and carry to
subscribers. Broadeasters determine the nature of pro-
grams to be viewed and the times they will be shown.
A viewer with an ordinary television set, of course,
directly chooses the programs to be seen from those made
available to him by broadcast and CATV.
G. Microwave
As mentioned above, Teleprompter uses microwave
transmission to carry signals from its receiving antennas
to its various local systems. Microwave systems beam sig-
nals from a mirowave transmitting antenna to specific
microwave receiving antennas; these signals cannot be re-
ceived with a television antenna. With one exception these
transmitters send signals from one discreet point to an-
other single specific location. That exception is a device
called an Amplitude Modulated Link used by Telepromp-
ter’s New York facility which sends signals from one trans-
mitter to two receiving points simultaneously.
In some cases Teleprompter owns the microwave equip-
ment it uses SS ew York, some in Farmington); in others
the microwave equipment is owned by an independent cor-
poration (Elmira, some in Farmington and Great Falls).
In all cases microwave serves the same function as cable
in carrying signals from one point to another within the
CATV system.
H. Interconnection
Teleprompter purchased the rights to carry to its sub-
seribers the February 25, 1964 and May 25, 1965 heavy-
eit aa ks a BE aE SNES prs
4la
weight championship fights between Sonny Liston and
Muhammed Ali. The fights were carried live to closed
circuit theatres by an independent company and to Tele-
prompter’s CATV systems in Farmington, Elmira and
Great Falls by AT&T facilities. Defendants’ CATV’s
were linked to the nationwide AT&T circuits carrying the
signals. No additional or separate charge was made to
subscribers for viewing the fights.
Teleprompter’s New York CATV is connected by a
microwave link to the two other CATV systems in New
York City, as required by its franchise agreement with the
City of New York.
I. Advertising
Teleprompter specifically advertises its originated pro-
grams in an effort to attract subscribers. It also advertises
the fact that subscribers can receive distant signals that are
otherwise unavailable. It cannot be said either that the
originated programs are publicized only to attract sub-
seribers to a ‘‘basic’’ reception service, or, on the other
hand that the received programming is advertised in order
to promote the ‘‘basic’’ sale of originated programs.
Teleprompter’s systems sell one basic service which in-
eludes both original programming and programming re-
ceived off-the-air from broadeast stations. Teleprompter
would be most likely to emphasize in its advertising what-
ever it thought would convince consumers to purchase this
one service.
J. Sale of Commercials
Teleprompter’s New York CATV system sold commer-
cials for its original coverage of sporting events from
Madison Square Garden, commencing on January 1, 1970.
These commercial messages consisted of two ten-second
“*billboards”’ before and after the event ( identifying the
sponsor) and two 60-second commercial announcements
42a
during the program. The sponsor paid a total of $300 for
each sporting event. Plaintiff introduced evidence that
Teleprompter intends to increase its sales of commercials
in the future, but during the period covered by the plead-
ings in this case, no other commercials than these were sold.
IIL. Conclusions of Law
Our point of departure in determining Teleprompter’s
liability under the Copyright Act is the Supreme Court’s
decision in Fortnightly. As mentioned above, Fortnightly
held that the copyright liability of CATV ‘‘depends upon
a determination of the function that CATV plays in the
total process of television broadcasting and reception,’’
(at 397). Finding that television viewing results from the
. combined activity of broadcasters and viewers, the Court
concluded that broadcasters perform while viewers do not.
Our task, as the parties recognize, is to decide whether Tele-
prompter’s systems ‘‘function’® as broadcasters or as
viewers.
Though it found the CATV systems before it to be on
the “‘viewer’s side of the line’’ (at 399), the Fortnigstly
Court did not delineate the ‘‘functions’’ of a viewer and
his receiving equipment. Rather, it analogized the func-
tion perfo by CATV to that of ‘‘a well-located antenna
with an éfficient connection to the viewer’s television set.’’
Id. Both ‘‘received and delivered’’ electronic information
(at 399 n.27). Whether this well-located antenna was
owned by one homeowner, several homeowners or an entre-
preneur did not affect its funetion in the Court’s view.
The Court did set forth the important functions of
broadcasters and compared them with the functions of the
Fortnightly CATV systems:
**Broadcasters select the programs to -be viewed;
CATV systems simply carry, without editing, whatever
programs they receive. Broadcasters procure pro-
grams and propagate them to the public; CATV sys-
43a
tems receive programs that have been released to the
public and carry them by private channels to additional
viewers.’’ (citations omitted) (at 400)
Other distinguishing features of broadcasters were added in
a footnote. Broadcasters sell their time and facilities to
sponsors while CATV’s do not. CATV’s, on the other
hand, tharge the public for the right to view their offer-
ings; broadcasters do not. Unlike broadcasters, CATV’s
have no influence on program content and arrangement.
[at 400, n.28, citing Intermountain Broadcasting & Televi-
_ sion Corp. v. Idaho Microwave, Inc., 196 F.Supp. 315, 325
(D. Ida. 1961).].
The Court’s application of functions of broadcasters
and viewers provides only the broadcast guide to analyzing
the function of the CATV systems before us.* Fortnightly
did not make clear, for example, how many functions com-
mon to broadcasters a CATV system must fulfill for it to
fall on the broadcaster’s side of the line or, indeed, the
extent an operation need be carried on for it to be found a
‘*function.’” Nor does Fortnightly deal with instances
where a CATV system simultaneously performs some func-
tions of a viewer and some of a broadcaster, as in the case
before us.
Since under Fortnightly’s functional analysis test, the
Fortnightly CATV systems functioned as viewers and con-
sequently fell on the viewer’s side of the line, our approach
must be to compare Fortnightly’s CATV’s with the ones
before us in order to isolate the differences between the
two. We shall then explore whether those differences,
singly or in combination, cause Teleprompter’s CATV’s to
* Justice Fortas stated in his Fortnightly dissent: ‘‘The vague
‘functional’ test of the meaning of the term ‘perform’ is . . . un-
satisfactory.’’ (at 407). See also Comment, The Copyright Law
and Its Relevance to CATV, 19 Buff.L.R. 65, 81-82 (1969).
44a
‘function’? so differently from those in Fortnightly as to
place Teleprompter.on the broadcaster’s side of the line.
At the outset we can dispense with certain minor fea-
tures of Teleprompter’s CATV’s that do not effect a
significant change in function, though they did not exist
in Fortnightly. These features are the use of microwave,
interconnection, advertising, and the sale of commercials.
Plaintiffs contend that defendants’ CATV’s are operating
like broadcasters by using microwave, since microwave
transmits signals through the air. Broadcasters propagate
signals over-the-air, the argument goes; and since the
microwave transmitters used by Teleprompter do also,
Teleprompter, we are told, is functioning as a broadcaster.
However, a broadcaster sends out signals to the public
while, as we have found, Teleprompter uses microwave to
earry signals from one of its facilities to another; no home-
owner receives Teleprompter’s microwave transmissions.
Its use of microwave is thus completely analogous to the
use of cable as a connecting carrier. Not every over-the-
air transmission of signals by electromagnetic energy is a
broadcast, human speech being just one example.
Nor does interconnection of several Teleprompter
CATV’s with closed-circuit theaters for the Liston-Ali
fights make these CATV systems into a broadcast network.
This interconnection occurred on two separate, temporary
and special occasions. Teleprompter’s CATV’s were inter-
connected only in the sense that several of them were
linked to the same independent nationwide circuits. What-
ever this brief interconnection may portend for the future,
it does not transform defendants’ present CATV systems
into a broadcast network as plaintiffs suggest.
Defendants’ advertising efforts are somewhat similar to
those of the Fortnightly systems. One CATV system in
that case advertised that it afforded access to a greater
number of channels than an ordinary antenna. 255 F.Supp.
45a
177 (S.D.N.Y. 1966).* Teleprompter makes similar con-
tentions about the numbers of otherwise unavailable chan-
nels its subscribers can receive.
The unique aspect of Teleprompter’s advertising is its
mention of programs originated by the CATV; as will be
noted below, the Fortnightly systems originated only time
and weather scans. We fail to see though how emphasis on
its originated programs changes Teleprompter’s function.
This type of advertising demonstrates, of course, that Tele-
prompter felt its unique service would be more attractive
to consumers if original programs were offered. But if any
change in function occurred because ofvorigination, it was
due to the origination itself, not to Teleprompter’s adver-
tisement of that fact.
Nor do we find decisive significance in the sale of com-
mercials to accompany Teleprompter’s origination of sport-
ing events in New York City. While the Supreme Court
described commercial sponsorship as an attribute of a
broadcaster, it was listed as merely one of a number of
indicia of broadcasting not as a sole determinant. The
sale of commercials in the case before us was small in
both the amount of money involved and in relation to
the amount of programming carried by the New York
CATV. Importantly, these commercials were sold and
carried as part of the programming originated by Tele-
prompter, and not in connection with its transmittal of
over-the-air broadcasts. Of course, both types of program-
ming were part of the same overall service, and, realistic-
ally, some of the audience for the commercials was at
least partly attracted to Teleprompter by its ‘‘reception
service.’’? But the commercials were not inserted in the
midst of the received programs, and the sponsor seems
to have geared the commercials closely to the originated
sports events.
* United Artists Television, Inc. v. Fortnightly Corporation.
46a
We come now to Teleprompter’s importation of distant
signals—the retransmission of broadcast signals that can-
not be received on rooftop or tower-mounted antennas.
This function is a salient feature of the Farmington, Great
Falls and Rawlins CATV’s and is also present in Elmira.
It is almost certainly responsible for much of the business
of the first three of these systems.
Plaintiffs contend that Teleprompter is engaging in
broadcasting by bringing signals into a new locale. In
plaintiffs’ view, importation of distant signals differenti-
ates this case from Fortnightly, whose CATV’s functioned
‘*merely as an auxiliary antenna to enhance the quality of
the television picture. ..’’ (Plaintiffs’ pre-trial brief at 8,
19). Plaintiffs thus urge us to limit the copyright immun-
ity resulting from Fortnightly to those CATV’s which
‘‘enhance’’ the quality of picture that can already be re-
ceived in the locale.
A reading of the Fortnightly opinions of the District
Court, Court of Appeals and Supreme Court reveals
that the Fortnightly systems did more than ‘‘enhance’’
poor quality pictures—they in fact brought in stations from
which usable reception could not be had at all. All of the
courts recognized that the Fortnightly CATV’s carried
broadcasts to additional viewers.
Fortnightly involved two CATV’s, one in and around
Clarksburg, West Virginia, and another in and around
Fairmont, West Virginia, eighteen miles from Clarksburg.
Clarksburg is located approximately 82 miles from Pitts-
burgh, 57 miles from Wheeling, West Virginia, and 74 miles
from Steubenville, Ohio—the cities from which it received
broadcast signals. Fairmont, which received the same sig-
nals, is 67, 52 and 65 miles from those cities respectively.
The Fortnightly systems had antennas on hills above
Clarksburg and Fairmont, connected by coaxial cables to
individual subscribers.
47a
District Judge Herlands found that:
“No credible competent evidence was adduced which
demonstrated that the residents of Clarksburg or Fair-
mont, other than the subscribers to defendant’s sys-
tems, could receive a usable and reasonably satisfactory
picture from any of the five stations in Pittsburgh,
Wheeling or Steubenville .”’ 255 F.Supp. at 186, aff’d
377 F.2d 872, 883 n. 14 (2d Cir. 1967).
Judge Herlands also found as a fact that:
‘**The basic purpose of defendant’s CATV systems
... is to process and retransmit signals of a television
broadcast station to areas in which direct reception by
ordinary home antennas of such television broadcast
is unsatisfactory because of distance, intervening topo-
graphical conditions, or similar factors.’’ 255 F.Supp.
at 196.
The Court of Appeals cited Judge Herlands’ first finding
above in stating that ‘‘[t)he hilly terrain in and around
Clarksburg and Fairmont makes reception by normal roof-
top antennas of television programs broadcast by the Pitts-
burgh, Steubenville and Wheeling stations difficult or im-
possible.”’ 377 F.2d 872, 874 (2d Cir. 1967) (Emphasis
added).
The Supreme Court treated the Fortnightly case as one
where most residents of the areas involved could not receive
broadcasts of other than local stations by ordinary rooftop
antennas. 390 U.S. at 391. It went on to distinguish CATV
systems from broadcasters on the ground that the former
“receive programs that have been released to the public
and carry them by private channels to additional viewers.’”
390 U.S. at 400 (Emphasis added).
* In United States v. Southwestern Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157, 162
(1968), decided a week before Fortnightly, the Court stated that
CATV systems ‘‘may transmit to subscribers the signals-of distant
stations entirely beyond the range of local antennae.”’
&
48a
It is clear, then, that Teleprompter’s importation of
signals not receivable on rooftop antennas is no different
from that in Fortnightly. This case differs from Fort-
wighily in that in a number of the systems the antenna
tower receiving the signals is located not on a hill over
the city but many miles away in the vicinity of the broad-
casting station. Farmington, as we have seen, receives Los
Angeles stations whese signals are received off-the-air near
their point of origination and relayed by microwave to New
Mexico. ‘Does this greater distance alone between the
receiving antenna and the CATV station and its customers
change the function of the Fortnightly reception service?
To put the question another way, did the Supreme Court
mean to imply a geographical limit beyond which signals
could not be imported? Though the Court, of course, was
concerned with the system before it, which imported signals
from a maximum distance of 82 miles, there is no indica-
tion that it intended to imply a geographical limit."° In
fact, the Supreme Court in Fortnightly explicitly declined
to make copyright liability dependent on the distance the
1° Justice Fortas, in dissent, may have understood the majority
to have been impliedly limiting the distance signals could be
carried when he wrote:
“It may be, indeed, that insofar as CATV operations are
limited to the geographical area which the licensed broad-
caster (whose signals the CATV has picked up and carried)
has the power to cover, a CATV is little more than a ‘coopera-
tive antenna’ employed in order to ameliorate the image on
television screens at home or to bring the image to homes
which, because of obstacles other than mere distance, could
not receive them. But such a description will not suffice for
the case in which a CATV has picked up the signals of a
licensed broadcaster and carried them beyond the area—how-
ever that area be defined—which the broadcaster normally
serves.’’ 390 U.S. at 407.
It is also possible that Justice Fortas thought that such a geo-
graphical distinction should have been made by the majority but
was not.
49a
broadcast signal was carried by a CATV. There the Court
said:
‘We have been invited by the Solicitor General in
an amicus curiae brief to render a compromise decision
in this case that would, it is said, accommodate various
competing considerations of copyright, communica-
tions, and antitrust policy. We decline the invitation.**
That job is for Congress. We take the Copyright Act
of 1909 as we find it. With due regard to changing
technology, we hold that the petitioner did not under —
that law ‘perform’ the respondent’s copyrighted
works.”” 390 U.S. at 401-402. (Other footnotes
omitted)
Furthermore, the Court’s reasoning in Fortnightly would
not support our creation of a difference between signals
received on a local tower and signals received on a distant
one. ‘‘The effective range of the broadcast is determined
by the combined contribution of the equipment employed
by the broadcaster and that supplied by the viewer.’’ Id.
at 398. Here, the ‘‘viewer”’ (the CATV system) has, by
supplying more sophisticated equipment, enlarged the ef-
fective range of the broadcast, just as the CATV in Fort-
nightly enlarged the range of broadcasts with its tower on
a hill. The Court’s description of a CATV in Fortnightly
** The Solicitor General would have us hold that CATV sys-
tems do perform the programs they carry, but he would have us
“‘imply”’ a license for the CATV ‘‘performances.”’ This ‘*implied
in law”’ license would not cover all CATV activity but only those
instances in which a CATV system operates within the ‘‘Grade B
Contour’? of the broadcasting station whose signal it carries. The
Grade B contour is a theoretical FCC concept defined as the outer
line along which reception of acceptable quality can be expected at
least 90% of the time at the best 50% of locations. Sixth Report
and Order, 17 Fed. Reg. 3905, 3915. Since we hold that the
petitioner’s systems did not perform copyrighted works we do not
reach the question of implied license. Ry
50a
is equally apt for this case: ‘‘Essentially a CATV system
no more than enhances the viewer’s capacity to receive the
broadcaster’s signals; it provides a well-located antenna
with ai efficient connection to the viewer’s set.’? Id. at 399.
What Teleprompter has done is to make its antenna even
more ‘‘well-located’’ and even more ‘‘efficiently’’ connected
to a viewer’s set than in Fortnightly.
If a viewer erected an antenna on a hill, the Court said,
he would not be performing the programs he received. Id.
at 400. Nor, it would seem, would a viewer be.‘‘perform-
ing’’ if he set up a strategically-placed antenna miles from
his home and brought in signals from that antenna. The
fact that the same operation is conducted here as a com-
mercial enterprise by a viewing innovator does not change
its function—which is to ‘‘enhance the viewer’s capacity
to receive the broadcaster’s signals.’ We therefore find
that Teleprompter’s importation of distant signals does
not cause it to function as a broadcaster.
Plaintiffs contend that the importation of distant signals
allows defendants greater latitude in program selection
and that this latitude makes them more like broadcasters
than viewers. We have found that Teleprompter’s prac-
tice of importing distant signals allowed it to exercise dis-
cretion in choosing which distant signals to import. It is
not clear from the record what freedom the Fortnightly
systems had to select the broadcast stations they would
carry. Because they received broadcast signals on a single
antenna located near the area it served, the Fortnightly
CATV’s had less control over program selection than
CATV’s that would mount antennas near selected broad-
cast stations in other cities. But though Teleprompter has
greater freedom of choice than Fortnightly its latitude is
not comparable to that of a broadcaster, which controls
program content and scheduling.
Perhaps the most striking difference between this case
and Fortnightly is Teleprompter’s program origination.
5la
The Fortnightly CATV’s transmitted messages by video
scanner and no more. 255 F.Supp. at 197. The Supreme
Court in Fortnightly did not find this meager origination
of significance and explicitly excluded from consideration
CATV systems originating their own programs. 390 U.S.
at 392 n.6.
Due to the development of the CATV industry, we are
here squarely faced with CATV systems that do originate
a substantial amount of their own programming. We ha
found that the CATV’s originate ‘‘automatic’’ transmis-
sions around the clock, and all originate substantive pro-
grams to some degree, ranging from a few hours a week in
Elmira to seventy hours a week in New York as of March
31, 1971. We have also found that the content of these
shows is not significantly different from those of ordinary
broadcast stations. As far as we can tell, the volume and
variety of program origination by CATV will probably
increase in the future. In fact, though we need not decide
if it is a defense to potential copyright liability as defend-
ants urge, it is worth noting that the Federal Communica-
tions Commission does require non-automatic p
origination by most CATV systems. 47 C.F.R. § 74.1111."
We do not doubt that Teleprompter’s program origina-
tion is similar to that done by broadcasters. These CATV’s
select the programs, propagate them, and have control over
program content and arrangement. Teleprompter’s New
York system sells commercials for a portion, albeit small,
of its originated schedule. Certainly New York originates
at least as many hours of programming as many local
broadcast stations. With respect to its program origina-
tion Teleprompter is functioning as a broadcaster.
™ Teleprompter argues that to find copyright liability because of
program origination demanded by the F.C.C. would be unconscion-
able. Cf. Farmers Union v. WDAY, 360 U.S. 525, 581 11959).
i ——‘_s_N
| 52a
We are thus faced with the question of whether a CATV’s
function as a broadcaster with respect to program origina-
tion affects the nature of the function it performs in receiv-
ing and re-transmitting over-the-air broadcasts. We are
of the opinion that the copyright liability for the ‘‘recep-
tion service’’ should not be affected by what can be consid-
ered an unrelated function—program origination. It is
true that the originated programs and the received pro-
grams are sold to subscribers as a package; nobody buys
one without the other. But the nature of the function of a
CATV with respect to received shows is not changed by
the presence of original material on other channels or at
other times. What Teleprompter is doing to plaintiffs’
copyrighted material, and other over-the-air broadcasts,
is the same whether the CATV’s originate programs or
not. The ‘‘function’’ of the reception service is not changed
by simultaneous sale of original shows, just as it would not
be changed by Teleprompter’s simultaneous delivery of
free ice cream or candy to every subscriber.
Having examined the separate activities which plaintiffs
feel put defendants on the broadcaster’s side of the line it
may be appropriate to look at defendants’ systems as a
whole. It is somewhat difficult to apply either the term
‘‘viewer’’ or ‘‘broadcaster’’ to the CATV systems in their
entirety in this case. As we have already seen, these
CATV’s perform two functions: 1) delivery of the signals
of over-the-air broadcast stations, and 2) transmission of
original television programs. It often cannot fairly be said
that one is the predominant function. The service sold by
Teleprompter is the combination of these functions, not
either in isolation.
Beyond the ‘‘functional test’’ we have discussed at length
and attempted to apply, it may be that the lesson of Fort-
nightly is, as the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals says in
another context: ‘‘broadcast signals are dedicated to the
public.’’ Midwest Video Corp. v. United States, 441 F.2d
53a
1322, 1326 (8th Cir. 1971), cert. granted, 40 U.S.L.W. 3314
(U.S. Jan. 10, 1972).* Certainly, that is one conclusion
that can be drawn from the Supreme Court’s first finding
that the range of a viewer is determined by the equipment
of both the broadcaster and the viewer, and then analogiz-
ing a CATV to a viewer’s antenna. For if a CATV is like
a viewer and a viewer by his choice of equipment can deter-
mine the range of a broadcast, then there seems to be little
limit to what can be done with broadcast signals by
CATV’s. The result indeed may be that ‘‘the right to re-
ceive and distribute [signals] may be exercised by any one
with the capacity to capture the signals.”’ Id. at 1327.
It should be remembered that our task here is to decide
whether what defendants do infringes plaintiffs’ exclusive
rights under the Copyright Act of 1909, 35 Stat. 1075, as
amended, specifically § 1, 17 U.S.C. § 1, by ‘‘performing”’
plaintiffs’ copyrighted works, In construing the Copy-
right Act in the years since 1909 the courts have built on
the basic analogy of the producers of a stage play and their
audience; the producers perform the play, the audience
does not. See 390 U.S. at 395 n. 15. This metaphor was
then analogized to the dichotomy between a listener and a
broadcaster, see e.g. Jerome H. Remick é Co. v. American
Automobile Accessories Co., 5 F.2d 411 (6th Cir. 1925) ;
Buck v. Jewell-LaSalle Realty Co., 283 U.S. 191, 201 (1931),
which in turn was used as a model for differentiating a
broadcaster from a non-infringing CATV in Fortnightly.
We have here carried this analogy yet another step by com-
paring the instant CATV’s with those in Fortnightly. Un-
doubtedly, future technological change, drastic and other-
* It has been observed that this result is quite similar to that
which would follow from defendants’ license-implied-in-law argu-
ment. Comment, supra, note 8, at 79-80.
The issue in Midwest Video is whether the Federal Communica-
‘tions Commission has the power to require existing eable televi-
sion systems to originate p 3
54a
wise, will see the courts asked to take further steps. Per-
haps the time has come to cease piling analogy on analogy
and to await word from Congress.
The copyright monopoly is ‘‘wholly statutory”’, White-
Smith Music Publishing Co. v. Apollo Co., 209 U.S. 1, 15
(1908) and we should perhaps be reluctant to expand an
exception to the general disfavor of monopolies in the ab-
sence of a more precise expression of Congressional intent,
particularly in light of the considerations of national com-
munications policy that Congress may want to bring to
bear on the CATV industry.
In any case, taking the law in its present state, we find
that the CATV’s before us do not function as broadcasters
within the meaning of the Fortnightly test, that they there-
fore do not ‘‘performn’’ plaintiffs’ works, and hence do not
infringe their ights. We, of course, do not reach any
of defendants’ arguments other than those considered
above.
Settle order on five days’ notice.
Dated: New York, New York
May 2, 1972
/s/ Constance Baker Mortiey
Constance Baker Motley
U.S.D.J.
55a
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHEEN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
64 Civ. 3814
Cotums1a Broapcastine System, Inc., Catvapa Propvuctions,
a joint venture, Jack CHERToK TeLevision, Inc., and
Dena Picrurss, Incorporaren, Plaintiffs,
—against—
TELEPROMPTER CorPoRATION and Contey ELECTRONICS
Corporation, Defendants.
_ Judgment
On October 22, 1970, in Pre-Trial Order Number One, this
Court having ordered that the trial of the above-entitled
case be divided into stages and the first stage be the
determination of the basic issue of copyright infringement
and certain other defenses specified in the Order, with other
defenses asserted by the defendants reserved without preju-
dice for trial, if necessary, in subsequent stages; and
On June 15, 1971, in Pre-Trial Order Number Three,
this Court having ordered that the trial of the first stage
of the 16th and 17th Claims for Relief set forth in the
Second Supplemental Complaint be governed by Pre-Trial
Order Number One; and
The issues to be tried at the first stage of the trial having
been formulated by this Court in said Pre-Trial Order
Number One and Pre-Trial Order Number Three as follows :
The basic issue to be tried in this stage of the case
is whether there is an infringement of copyright within
the meaning of 17 U.S.C. §§1(c) and (d) by reason
of the reception, transmission of and making available
(and/or other activities as specified in paragraph IV
hereof, if any, in relation to) telecasts of plaintiffs’
copyrighted programs by means of CATV systems in
Elmira, New York, and Farmington, New Mexico, in
56a
November 1964, as alleged in the Amended Complaint,
and the CATV systems in Farmington, New Mexico,
Rawlins, Wyoming, Great Falls, Montana, and New
York, New York, in June 1969, as alleged in the Sup-
plemental Complaint. Paragraph 1 of the Answer to
Supplemental Complaint and Supplemental Answer is
related to the issue of copyright infringement and shall
be included in the first stage. The defendants’ separate
defenses stated in paragraph 113 and 114, and 115 (f)
of the Amended Answer and 14 and 15, and 16 (f) of the
Answer to Supplemental Complaint and Supplemental
Answer, excluding, however, any allegations therein of
violations of the antitrust laws, may be related to the
issue of copyright infringement, the Communications
Act defense and to the defense of license implied in
law and shall be included in the first stage. (Pre-Trial
Order Number One).
All of the provisions of Pre-Trial Order Number
One are hereby extended and made applicable to the
16th and 17th Claims for Relief in the Second Supple-
mental Complaint, and the trial of the first stage of
such 16th and 17th Claims for Relief shall be governed
by Pre-Trial Order Number One. (Pre-Trial Order
Number Three)
The aforesaid issues having been duly tried before the
undersigned and the Opinion of this Court dated May 2,
1972, having been filed herein, holding that the defendants’
CATV systems involved in this case ‘“‘do not ‘perform’
plaintiffs’ works and hence do not infringe their copy-
rights’’, thereby disposing of the basic issue of copyright
infringement in favor of the defendants so that it is not
necessary for trial to be held or other disposition to be
made on the merits of any of the other issues raised by
the defendants herein and reserved without prejudice for
subsequent stages of the trial; and
57a
The defendants Teleprompter Corporation and
Electronics Corporation having applied to this Court for
Now, THEnerore, upon motion of Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen
& Hamilton, and Katz, Schier, Rosensweig & Sindle, attor-
neys for the defendant Teleprompter Corporation and
Conley Electronics Corporation, it is
Apsupexrp, that the Amended Complaint and First and
Second Supplemental Complaints be, and they hereby are,
dismissed on the merits and that the action herein be and
the same hereby is dismissed; and it is further
Apsuperp, that the defendants Teleprompter Corpora-
tion and Conley Electronics Corporation recover of the
plaintiffs Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc., Calvada
Productions, Jack Chertok Television, Inc. and Dena Pic-
tures, Incorporated the costs of this action in this Court
to be taxed by the Clerk herein pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 116;
and the application by said defendants for legal fees is
hereby denied.
Dated: New York, New York
June 27, 1972
APPENDIX C
Statutes Involved
1. Copyright Act, as amended. Section 1(c) and (d) of
the Copyright Act (17 U.S.C. §§ 1(e), (d) (1970)) provides
as follows:
‘*Any person entitled thereto, upon complying with
the provisions of this title, shall have the exclusive
right:
: = 7
(c) To deliver, authorize the delivery of, read, or
present the copyrighted work in public for profit if it
be a lecture, sermon, address or similar production, or
other nondramatic literary work; to make or procure
the making of any transcription or record thereof by
or from which, in whole or in part, it may in any man-
ner or by any method be exhibited, delivered, pre-
sented, produced, or reproduced; and to play or per-
form it in public for profit, and to exhibit, represent,
produce, or reproduce it in any manner or by any
method whatsoever. The damages for the infringe-
ment by broadcast of any work referred to in this
subsection shall not exceed the sum of $100 where the
infringing broadcaster shows that he was not aware
that he was infringing and that such infringement
could not have been reasonably foreseen; and
(d) To perform or represent the copyrighted work
publicly if it be a drama or, if it be a dramatic work
and not reproduced in copies for sale, to vend any
manuscript or any record whatsoever thereof; to make
or to procure the making of any transcription or record
thereof by or from which, in whole or in part, it may
in any manner or by any method be ‘exhibited, per-
formed, represented, produced, or reproduced; and to
exhibit, perform, represent, produce, or reproduce it
in any manner or by any method whatsoever ;’’
59a
2. Communications Act of 1934, as amended. Section 1, _
3(0), 303(c), (d), and (h), 307(b) and 325(a) (47 U.S.C.
$$ 151, 153(0), 303(c), (d) and (h), 307(b) and 325(a)
(1970)) provide as follows:
Sec. 151. ‘‘For the purpose of regulating interstate
and foreign commerce in communication by wire and
radio so as to make available, so far as possible, to all
the people of the United States a rapid, efficient, Na-
tionwide, and world-wide wire and radio communica-
tion service with adequate facilities at reasonable
charges, for the purpose of the national defense, for
the purpose of promoting safety of life and property
through the use of wire and radio communication, and
for the purpose of securing a more effective execution
of this policy by centralizing authority heretofore
granted by law to several agencies and by granting
additional authority with respect to interstate and
foreign commerce in wire and radio communication,
there is created a commission to be known as the ‘Fed-
eral Communications Commission ’, which shall be con-
stituted as hereinafter provided, and which shall exe-
cute and enforce the provisions of this chapter.”’
Sec. 153(0). “ ‘Broadcasting’ means the dissemina-
tion of radio communications intended to be received by
the public, directly or by the intermediary of relay
stations.’’
Sec. 303.‘‘Except as otherwise provided in this
chapter, the Commission from time to time, as public
convenience, interest, or necessity requires, shall . . .”’
(c). ‘Assign bands of frequencies to the various
classes of stations, and assign frequencies for each
individual station and determine the power which each
(station shall use and the time during which it may
operate ;”’
a
60a
(d). ‘*Determine the location of classes of stations
or individual stations ;’’
(h). ‘‘Have authority to establish areas or zones to
be served by any station.’’
Sec. 307(b). ‘‘In considering applications for li-
censes, and modifications and renewals thereof, when
and insofar as there is demand for the same, the Com-
mission shall make such distribution of licehses, fre-
quencies, hours of operation, and of power among the
several States and communities as to provide a fair,
efficient, and equitable distribution of radio service to
each of the same.”’
See. 325(a). ‘‘No person within the jurisdiction of
the United States shall knowingly utter or transmit, or
cause to be uttered or transmitted, any false or fraudu-
lent signal of distress, or communication relating
thereto, nor shall any broadcasting station rebroad-
cast the program or any part thereof of another broad-
casting station without the express authority of the
originating station.’’
6la
APPENDIX D
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIROUIT
~
At a stated Term of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Second Cireuit, held at the United States Court-
house in the City of New York, on the eighth day of March
one thousand nine hundred and seventy-three.
Present:
Hon. J. Edward Lumbard
Hon. Irving R. Kaufman
Hon. Walter R. Mansfield —
Circuit Judges,
72-1800
CoLtumsia Broapoastine System, Inc.,
Catvapa Propuctions, a joint venture,
Jack Cuertox Texevision, Inc. and
Dena Picrungs, INcoRPORATED,
Plaintiff s-A ppellants,
Vv.
TELEPROMTER CoRPORATION and Contey ELEcrronics
Corporation, Defendants-Appellees.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of
record from the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York, and was argued by
counsel.
On Consiperation Wueneor, it is now hereby ordered,
adjudged, and decreed that the judgment of said District
62a
Court be and it hereby is affirmed in part and reversed in
part and that the action be and it hereby is remanded to
said District Court for further proceedings, including the
determination of damages, as are not inconsistent with
the opinion of this court.
A. Danret Fusaro
Clerk
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.