Appendix — Falk v. Brennan
Supreme Court brief1973
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
LIBRARY
Suprome Court, 6. &.
RILEQD
SUPREME COURT, U. 8. MAY 12 1973
APPENDIX
JR.,CLERK
Supreme Court of the Gnited States
October Term, 1972
No. 72-844
E. E. FALK, InprvipuALLy AND AS PARTNER IN
Drucker & FALK, Et ALs.,
Petitioners,
V.
PETER J. BRENNAN, Secretary or Lasor,
Unrrep States DEPARTMENT OF LABOR,
Respondent.
On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States —
Court Of Appeals For The Fourth Circuit
Petition For Certiorari Filed December 8, 1972
Certiorari Granted February 26, 1973
Docket Entries
Complaint
Answer :
Plaintiff's Interrogatories
Defendant’s Answers to Plaintiff's Interrogatories ......... 13
Plaintiff's Interrogatories (Second Set) 20
Plaintiff's Requests for Admissions 22
Defendants’ Answers to Plaintiff's Interrogatories
(Second Set) and Requests for Admissions .............. ~~ 28
Order on Final Pre-Trial Conference 32
Stipulation of Facts 40
Order Allowing Certiorari 65
* The previous and Judgment of the courts below are printed in
the Appendix to the Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.
,
Date - PROCEEDINGS
1969
Jan. 30—Complaint filed and summons issued.
Feb. 24—Answer of all Defendants filed by counsel.
Mar. 10—Petitioners’ interrogatories filed.
May 14—Answer to Petitioners’ interrogatories, lodged.
July 23—Petitioners’ request for admissions filed.
Sept. 12—Answer to Petitioners’ interrogatories lodged
5/14/69 filed by leave of Court.
Sept. 12—Answer to Petitioners’ interrogatories (second
set) lodged 9/5/69 filed by leave of Court.
Oct. 9—Stipulations of facts, filed.
1970
Jan. 6—Opinion and Order of Court, that the relief sought
is denied and the suit Dismissed, filed. 7
Mar. 13—Notice of Appeal filed by United States.
1971
Mar. 3—Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals,
reversing and remanded to the District Court for further
proceedings.
June 2—Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the Fourth Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals of the United States, filed.
July 28—Opinion of the District Court for the Eastern
District of Virginia awarding pre-judgment interest.
Oct. 12—Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United
States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit denied.
App. 2
1972
Jan. 28—Entry of final Order in the District Court for the
Eastern District of Virginia.
Feb. 28—Notice of Appeal filed.
Sept. 11—Per Curiam Opinion of the United States Court
of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirming the award of
pre-judgmient interest.
Dec. 8—Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the Fourth Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals of the United States, filed.
1973
Feb. 26—Petition for a Writ of Certiorari granted limited
to Questions 2 and 3 presented by the petition.
[Caption omitted]
COMPLAINT
(Filed in U. S. District Court January 30, 1969)
Plaintiff George P. Shultz, Secretary of Labor, United
States Department of Labor, brings this action to enjoin
defendants E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker, E. B. Drucker, David
Falk, and R. E. Smith from violating the provisions of sec-
tions 15(a)(2) and 15(a)(5) of the Fair Standards Act of
1938, as amended (29 U.S.C. et seq.), hereinafter referred
to as the Act, and to restrain defendants from any with-
holding of payment of minimum wages and overtime com-
pensation found by the Court to be due to employees under
the Act.
I
Jurisdiction of this action is conferred upon this Court
by section 17 of the Act.
App. 3 4
II
(a) Since August 25, 1966, defendants E.E. Falk, A. L.
Drucker, E. E. Drucker, David Falk, and R. E. Smith, have
been and are partners trading as Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th
Street, Newport News, Virginia, within the jurisdiction of
this Court, in the business of selling real estate and in-
surance and managing rental property.
(b) Defendant E. E. Falk resides at 27 Garland Drive,
Newport News, Virginia, within the jurisdiction of this
Court, and since August 25, 1966, has been and is actively
engaged in the control and supervision of the operations
of Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th Street, Newport News, Vir-
ginia, and acts and since August 25, 1966, has acted directly
and indirectly in the interest of said Drucker & Falk in
relation to its employees.
(c) Defendant A. L. Drucker resides at 511 Chesapeake
Avenue, Newport News, Virginia, within the jurisdiction of
this Court, and since August 25, 1966, has been and is
actively engaged in the control and supervision of the op-
erations of Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th Street, Newport
News, Virginia, and acts and since August 25, 1966, has
acted directly and indirectly in the interest of said Drucker
& Falk in relation to its employees.
(d) Defendant E. B. Drucker resides at 23 Garland
Drive, Newport News, Virginia, within the jurisdiction of
this Court, and since August 25, 1966, has been and is ac-
tively engaged in the control and supervision of the opera-
tions of Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th Street, Newport News,
Virginia, and acts and since August 25, 1966, has acted
directly and indirectly in the interest of said Drucker &
Falk in relation to its employees.
(e) Defendant David Falk resides at Kings Mill Dairy
Farm, Williamsburg, Virginia, within the jutisdiction of
App. 4
this Court, and since August 25, 1966, has been and is ac-
tively engaged in the control and supervision of the opera-
tions of Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th Street, Newport News,
Virginia, and acts and since August 25, 1966, has acted
directly and indirectly in the interest of said Drucker &
Falk in relation to its employees.
(f) Defendant R. E. Smith resides at 14 Garland Drive,
Newport News, Virginia, within the jurisdiction of this
Court, and since August 25, 1966, has been and is actively
engaged in the control and supervision of the operations
of Drucker & Falk, 131 - 26th Street, Newport News, Vir-
ginia, and acts and since August 25, 1966, has acted directly
and indirectly in the interest of said Drucker & Falk in re-
lation to its employees.
*
III
The business activities of the defendants, as described
herein, are and since August 25, 1966, have been related
and performed through unified operation and common con-
trol for a common business purpose, and constitute and
since August 25, 1966, have constituted an enterprise within
the meaning of section 3(r) of the Act.
IV
(a) During the period since August 25, 1966, the total
annual gross volume of sales of the enterprise referred to
and described in the preceding paragraph has been not less
than one million dollars ($1,000,000), and some of the de-
fendants’ establishments have had at least two or more
employees engaged in commerce or in the production of
goods for commerce. Thus, each such establishment, since
August 25, 1966, has been and is an enterprise engaged in
App. 5
commerce or in the production of goods for commerce
within the meaning of section 3(s)(3) of the Act, as
amended by the Fair Labor Standards Amendments of
1961, 75 Stat. 65.
(b) During the period since February 1, 1967, the an- —
nual gross volume of sales made or business done by the
enterprise referred to and described in paragraph III of
this Complaint has been not less than $500,000 (exclusive .
of excise taxes at the retail level which are separately
stated), and it has and since February 1, 1967, has had
two or more employees engaged in commerce or in the
production of goods for commerce. By virtue of the fore-
going, defendants’ activities constitute and since February
1, 1967, have constituted an enterprise engaged in com-
merce or in the production of goods for commerce within
the meaning of sections 3(r) and 3(s)(1) of the Act, as
amended by the Fair Labor Standards Amendments of
1966, 80 Stat. 830.
Vv
(a) During the period since August 25, 1966, the de-
fendants have repeatedly violated, and are violating, the
provisions of sections 6(a)(1) and 15(a) (2) of the Act by
employing employees in enterprises‘engaged in commerce
or in the production of goods for commerce and by paying
them wages at rates less than $1.25 an hour during the
period from August 25, 1966, to February 1, 1967; less than
$1.40 an hour during the period from February 1, 1967, to
February 1, 1968; and less than $1.60 an hour thereafter.
(b) During the period since February 1, 1967, the de-
fendants have repeatedly violated, and they are violating,
the provisions of sections 6(b) and 15(a) (2) of the Act by
employing employees in an enterprise engaged in commerce
a
App. 6
or iri the production of goods for commerce and by paying
such employees wages at rates less than $1 an hour during
the period from February 1, 1967, to February 1, 1968,
and at rates less than $1.15 an hour during the period since
February 1, 1968.
VI
(a) During the period since August 25, 1966, the de-
fendants have repeatedly violated, and they are violating,
the provisions of sections 7(a) (1) and 15(a) (2) by employ-
ing many of their employees in enterprises engaged in com- __
merce or in the production of goods for commerce for —
hours in excess of 40 a week without compensating them
for such excess hours at rates not less than one and one-
half times the regular rates at which they were employed.
(b) During the period since February 1, 1967, the de-
fendants have repeatedly violated, and they are violating,
the provisions of sections 7(a)(2) and 15(a) (2) of the Act
by employing many of their employees in an enterprise en-
gaged in commerce or in the production of goods for com-
merce, for hours in extess of 44 a week during the period
from February 1, 1967, to February 1, 1968, and for hours
in excess of 42 a week during the period since February 1,
1968, without compensating them for such excess hours at
rates not less than one and one-half times the regular rates
at which they were employed. .
Vil
(a) During the period since August 25, 1966, the de-
fendants have repeatedly violated, and they are violating,
the provisions of sections 11 and 15(a)(5) of the Act, in
that they have failed to make, keep, and preserve adequate
and accurate records of their employees and of the wages,
App. 7
hours, and other conditions and practices of employment
maintained by them as prescribed by regulations issued pur-
suant to section 11(c) of the Act and found in Title 29,
Chapter V, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 516, in that
the records kept by the defendants fail to show adequately
and accurately, among other things, the hours worked each
workday and the total hours worked each workweek by
many of their employees.
(b) During the period since August 25, 1966, the defend-
ants have repeatedly violated, and they are violating, the
provisions of sections 11 and 15(a)(5) of the Act, in that
they have failed to post and keep posted, at the places of
employment of their employees, a notice pertaining to the
applicability of the Act, as prescribed by regulations issued
pursuant to section 11(c) of the Act and found in Title 29,
Chapter V, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 516.4.
Vill
Section 17 of the Act expressly provides that the District
Courts of ‘the United States shall: have jurisdiction to re-
strain violations of section 15 of the Act, including, in the
case of violations of section 15(a) (2), the restraint of any
withholding of payment of minimum wages and overtime
compensation found by the Court to be due to employees
under the Act. 3
Wherefore, cause having been shown, plaintiff prays
judgment permanently enjoining and restraining defend-
ants, their agents, servants, employees and all persons in
active concert or participation with them who receive
actual notice of the order by personal service or otherwise
from violating the provisions of sections 15(a)(2) and 15
(a)(5) of the Act, and restraining the defendants from
continuing to withhold any payment of minimum wages
App. 8
and overtime compensation found by the Court to be due
to their employees under the Act, together with interest at
six percent a year from the date of the withholding, and
for such further relief as the Gourt may deem appropriate.
Edward B. Friedman
Acting Solicitor of Labor
Jeter S. Ray
Regional Attorney
Sylvia S. Ellison
Chief Trial Attorney
William H. Horkan
Deputy Chief Trial Attorney
Thomas E. Korson
Attorney
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Of Counsel
C. V. Spratley, Jr.
United States Attorney
By Roger T. Williams
Assistant United States Attorney
App.9 —
(Captioned Omitted)
ANSWER
(Filed in U. S. District Court February 24, 1969)
This day come the defendants, E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker,
E. B. Drucker, David Falk and R. E. Smith, individually
and as partners in Drucker & Falk, and file this their indi-
vidual and collective Answer to the Complaint filed herein,
and do deny the allegations of subject Complaint and in
that regard doth say as follows:
1. That they do admit the allegations of Paragraph I.
2. That they do admit the allegations of Paragraph II.
3. That they do not deny the allegations of Paragraph
4. That they do deny the allegations of Paragraph IV.
5. That they do deny the allegations of Paragraph V.
6. That they do deny the allegations of Paragraph VI.
7. That they do deny the allegations of Paragraph VII.
8. That they do deny any allegations of violation as
alleged in said Complaint.
9. That they do deny the prayer for relief, but do assert
that even if there were grounds for subject prayer, it is
barred by the statute of limitations.
Such other defenses as may arise on or before trial of
this cause.
E. E. Falk,
A. L. Drucker,
E. B. Drucker,
David Falk and
R. E. Smith
Herbert V. Kelly, p.d.
Jones, Blechman, Woltz & Kelly
227 27th Street
Newport News, Virginia 23607 .
App. 10
(Caption Omitted)
PLAINTIFF'S INTERROGATORIES
(Filed in U. S. District Court March 10, 1969)
Pursuant to Rule 33 of the Federal Rules of Civil Pro-
cedure, plaintiff requests that, within 15 days of service
hereof, defendants answer in writing and under oath the
following interrogatories, which are continuing in nature
and which, unless otherwise specified, pertain to the period
since January 30, 1967.
1. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants, including the
locations, by street address and city, town or village, of all
such buildings, the owners of such buildings and their
addresses.
2. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants which have tele-
phone switchboards operated by one or more persons paid
by the defendants on their own account or as agents for
the owner of the building.
3. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants in which mail is
distributed, or otherwise delivered, by one or more persons
paid by the defendants on their own account or as agents of
the owner of the building, to the tenants or to boxes or
pigeonholes assigned to the tenants of such buildings.
4. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants where one or more
persons paid by the defendants on their own account or as
agents of the owner of the building regularly receive or
send correspondence pertaining to the defendants’ business
or to the business of the building owner across state lines.
App. 11
5. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants where one or more
persons paid by the defendants on their own account or as
agents of the owner o fthe building regularly use as part
of their duties at such buildings telephone facilities in com-
munications across state lines.
6. Identify the buildings which have been and are being
operated or managed by the defendants where persons paid
by the defendants on their own account or as agents for
the owner of the building regularly order or receive goods,
materials, or supplies used in the operation, management,
or maintenance of the buildings operated by the defendants,
if such goods, materials, or supplies have been shipped
across state lines. |
7. State the gross volume of rentals collected by the de-
fendants trading as Drucker & Falk for each quarter since
January 1, 1966.
8. State the gross commissions or fees received by the de-
fendants in the operation or management of buildings for
each quarter since January 1, 1966.
9. Who hires the employees working in the buildings
operated or managed by the defendants?
10. Who supervises the employees working in the build-
ings operated or managed by the defendants? —
11. Who has authority to fire the employees working in
the buildings operated or managed by the defendants?
12. What is the basis for payment to the defendants by
the owners of the buildings operated or managed by the
defendants?
13. Are the employees working in the buildings operated
or managed by the defendants paid by cash or by check,
—————————w
App. 12
and if by check, whose check? How are the payments de-
livered and by whom?
Sylvia S. Ellison
Chief Trial Attorney
William H. Horkan
Deputy Chief Trial Attorney
United States Department of
Labor
Of Counsel
C, V. Spratley, Jr.
United States Attorney
App. 13
(Caption Omitted)
ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF’S INTERROGATORIES
(Filed in U. S. District Court May 12, 1969)
This day come the defendants, E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker,
E. B. Drucker, David Falk and R. E. Smith, individually
and as partners in Drucker & Falk, and file this their in-
dividual and collective Answer to Plaintiff's Interrogatories,
as follows:
1. In answer to question number one, the apartment
projects managed by the defendants are as follows:
(a) Buildings known as “Andover” owned by An-
dover Investment Company, located at 2501 East Lit-
tle Creek Road, Norfolk, Virginia 23518.
(b) Buildings known as “Armstrong” owned by
Armstrong Investment Company, 3816 Kecoughtan
Road, Hampton, Virginia 23369.
(c) Buildings known as “Bel Meade” owned by
Bel Meade Investment Company, 2506 Atwell Drive,
Richmond, Virginia 23234.
(d) Buildings known as “Bolling” owned by Bolling
Investment Company, 942 Rockbridge Avenue, Nor-
folk, Virginia 23508.
(e) Buildings known as “Bondale” owned by Bon-
dale Investment Company, 7603 Bondale Avenue, Nor-
folk,. Virginia 23505.
(f) Buildings known as “Chamberlayne Gardens”
owned by Chamberlayne Gardens, Inc., 4301 Cham-
berlayne Avenue, Richmond, Virginia 23227.
(g) Buildings known as “Chesapeake” owned by
Chesapeake Investment Company, 3816 Kecoughtan
Road, Hampton, Virginia 23369.
App. 14
(h) Buildings known as “Dresden Arms” owned by
Dresden Arms Associates, 616 Dresden Drive, New-
port News, Virginia 23601.
(i) Buildings known as “Lakeshore” owned by
Lakeshore Associates, 19 Lakeshore Drive, Hampton,
Virginia 23366.
(j) Buildings known as “Peninsula” owned by Pen-
insula Investment Company, 3816 Kecoughtan Road,
Hampton, Virginia 23369.
(k) Buildings known as “Pleasant Manor” owned
by Pleasant Manor Corporation, 3201 York Street,
Hampton, Virginia 23361.
(1) Buildings known as “Presidential Apartments”
owned by Presidential Apartment Associates, 616
Dresden Drive, Newport News, Virginia 23601.
(m) Buildings known as “Presidential” owned by
Presidential Investment Company, 616 Dresden Drive,
Newport News, Virginia 23601.
(n) Buildings known as “Southampton” owned by
Southampton Investment Company, 3816 Kecoughtan
Road, Hampton, Virginia 23369.
(0) Buildings known as “Warwick Gafdens” owned
by Warwick Gardens, Incorporated, 614 Peninsula
Drive, Newport News, Virginia 23605.
(p) Buildings known as “Warwick Marshall”
owned’ by Warwick Marshall, Incorporated, 614 Pen-
insula Drive, Newport News, Virginia 23605.
(q) Buildings known as “Executive Suite” owned by
Greenwood Company, Incorporated, 2705 West Mer-
cury Boulevard, Hampton, Virginia 23366.
(r) Buildings known as “Ivy-Dresden” owned by
Ivy-Dresden Investment Company, 616 Dresden
Drive, Newport News, Virginia 23601.
App. 15
(s) Buildings known as “Mercury” owned by Mer-
cury Investment Company, 1601 Pennwood Drive,
Hampton, Virginia 23366.
(t) Buildings known as “Hampton” owned by
Hampton Associates, 2717 Willard Road, Richmond,
Virgini
(u) Buildings known as “Glenwood” owned by
Glenwood Investment Company, 2705 Byron Street,
Richmond, Virginia 23223.
(v) Buildings known as “Sewell”, located at 400
West Little Creek Road, Norfolk, Virginia 23505,
owned by Sewell Properties Company, 138 - 78th Ave-
nue, Flushing, New York 11367.
(w) Buildings known as “Lakeshore Village” owned
by Lakeshore Village Associates, 2717 Willard Road,
Richmond, Virginia 23229.
(x) Buildings known as “Shell Gardens” owned by
Mr. Abraham Okun, 135 Forsythe Road, Norfolk, Vir-
ginia 23505.
(y) Buildings known as “Queens Terrace” owned by
Queens Terrace Associates, Massey Building, Fourth
and Main Streets, Richmond, Virginia 23219.
(z) Buildings known as “West County Townhouses”
owned by West County Townhouse Apartments, 20
Mellen Street, Hampton, Virginia 23363.
(aa) Buildings known as “Plaza Apartments” owned
by Arlington Hall Realty Company, 11295 Keystone
Island Drive, North Miami, Florida 33162.
(bb) Buildings known as “Newsome” owned by
Newsome Townhouses Apartments, 2013 Cunningham
Drive, Hampton, Virginia 23366.
(cc) Buildings known as “Robin Hood”, located at
5500 Robin Hood Road, Norfolk, Virginia 23513,
App. 16
owned by Virginia Construction Corporation, Suite
203, 117 East 59th Street, New York, New York
10022.
(dd) Buildings known as “Bel Aire” owned by Bel
Aire Investment Corporation, 1513 East Little Creek
Road, Norfolk, Virginia 23518.
2. There are no buildings which are being operated or
managed by the defendants which have telephone switch-
boards operated by one or more persons paid by the defend-
ants on their own account or as agents for the owner of the
3. There are no buildings which have been or are being
operated or managed by the defendants in which mail is
distributed, or otherwise delivered, by one or more persons
paid by the defendants on their own account or as agents
of the owner of the building, to the tenants or to boxes or
pigeonholes assigned to the tenants of such buildings.
4. The only buildings operated or managed by the de-
fendants where there is correspondence across state lines
are Sewell, Robin Hood and Plaza, as named above, where
information is mailed to out-of-state owners.
5. There are no buildings operated or managed by the
defendants with regular communication facilities across
state lines. In the three cases mentioned in answer No. 4
above, there is some telephone communication.
6. At none of the buildings which have been or are being
operated or managed by the defendants do the defendants
or their agents regularly order or receive goods, materials
or supplies used in the operation, management or main-
tenance of the buildings which have been shipped across the
state lines. Any regular ordering is made through local
App. 17
suppliers and the origin of their goods is not known by the
defendants.
7. Gross volume of rentals collected by the defendants is
as follows:
1966
ist Quarter . $1,311,452.28
2nd Quarter : 1,330,638.02
3rd Quarter , 1,512,091.16
4th Quarter 1,657,437.91
NE i ae cae $5,811,619.37
1967
Ist Quarter $1,769,010.67
2nd Quarter Ee tre 1,818,519.05
3rd Quarter 1,998,450.17
4th Quarter 2,079,620.97
Total $7,725,600.86
1968
Ot I iii inet nsetinesiiecneneininsiaidntigaee $2,092,237.23
2nd Quarter 2,144,449.31
Srd Quarter 2,191,971.28
4th Quarter 2,208,428.22
Total $8,607 ,086.04
8. Gross commissions or fees received by the defendants
are as follows:
1966
ist Quarter $ 81,119.54
2nd Quarter 83,730.92
3rd Quarter 93,388.34
4th Quarter 101,827.02
Total $360,065.82
cgay semen sae ters oop —- —e
App. 18
1967
Re CIEE PANGS ac SURI rh ot AY OA SOE 99,057.65
a, Se ET aT SER inners eae a 104,264.86
De Sree ee 116,673.69
Gils Cr a os 114,231.95
Total . we $434,228.15
1968
lle ag. RRS PITS Se amie cress artee Oo $114,992.04
2nd Quarter 112,867.79
3rd Quarter 117,005.78
oarsmen 117,891.89
UI Sicaea adic coisas ab iach $462,757.50
9. Employees working in buildings operated or managed
by the defendants are hired for the owner’s account by
either of the following, depending upon the employment:
Executive Director, Management Department
Assistant Executive Director, Management Depart-
Project Manager
Maintenance Superintendent
10. Employees working in the buildings are supervised
normally by the Maintenance Superintendent or Project
Manager for the project.
11. Employees discharged are normally discharged by
the Maintenance Superintendent for the particular project.
12, Payment to the defendants on buildings managed or
operated by the defendants is on a commission basis on
rents collected.
13. Employees working in buildings operated or man-
aged by the defendants are paid from a special payroll ac-
App. 19
count which is funded by checks drawn weekly on the own-
er’s account and payment is made through this account by
Drucker & Falk by check.
E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker, E. B.
Drucker, David Falk and R. E:
Smith, Individually and as part-
ners in Drucker & Falk
E. E. Falk
A. L. Drucker
E. B. Drucker
David Falk
R. E. Smith
Herbert V. Kelly, p.d.
Jones, Blechman, Woltz & Kelly
227 - 27th Street
Newport News, Virginia 23607
(SECOND SET)
(Filed in U. S. District Court July 23, 1969)
Pursuant to Rule 33 of the Federal Rules of Civil Pro-
cedure, plaintiff requests that, within 15 days hereof, de-
fendants answer in writing and under oath the following in-
terrogatories, which are continuing in nature and which, un-
less otherwise specified, pertain to the period since January
30, 1967.
14, With reference to defendants’ answer to interroga-
tory 1, does the list of buildings contained in that answer
include ail buildings which defendants have managed at
any time during the period since January 30, 1967, or does
it merely include the buildings which the defendants are
managing at the present time? If the list does not include
buildings which the defendants managed during some point
in the period from January 30, 1967, but which the defend-
ants are not currently managing, state the name of the
building or buildings and list the address of each such
building or buildi
15. With reference to defendants’ answer to interroga-
tory 4, state the frequency with which correspondence or
other information (pertaining to the buildings mentioned
in defendants’ answer to interrogatory 4) is transmitted
across state lines, and state whether the employees engaged
in transmitting such information or correspondence are em-
ployed at the buildings or at defendants’ offices located at
131 - 26th Street, Newport News, Virginia.
16. With reference to defendants’ answer to interroga-
tory 5, state the frequency of the communication across
— ee
App. 21
state lines mentioned therein, and list the employees who
were and are so engaged in such interstate communications.
17. With reference to defendants’ answer to interroga-
tory 6, list the names and addresses of all your suppliers
during the period since January 30, 1966, and list all the
supplies which you use and since January 30, 1966, have
used in the operation or management of the buildings
listed in defendants’ answer to interrogatory 1 or any other
building. ee ee
suppliers.
18. Are the personell mentioned in defendants’ answers
to interrogatories 9, 10, and 11 employees of the defendants
trading as Drucker Falk? In any event, list, by name and
home address, each person who holds any of the positions
mentioned in defendants’ answers to interrogatories 9, 10,
and 11.
19. List all the business activities in which the defend-
ants, trading as Drucker & Falk, are and since January 1,
1966, have been engaged.
App. 22
(Caption Omitted)
_ PLAINTIFF'S REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS
(Filed in U. S. District Court July 23, 1969)
Pursuant to Rule 36 of the Federal Rules of Civil Pro-
cedure, plaintiff requests that, within 10 days hereof, de-
fendants admit, in writing and under oath, the truth of the
following statements, which are continuing in nature and
1. With respect to defendants’ management of the build-
ings listed in defendants’ answer to interrogatory 1 (and to
the defendants’ management of any other building), the
defendants, trading as Drucker & Falk, and not the owners
of the buildings, perform the following functions:
(a) advertising for tenants to occupy the buildings
(b) hiring the employees who work at the buildings
(c) firing the employees who work at the buildings
(d) supervising the employees who work at the build-
ings
(e) renting the apartments in the buildings
(f) collecting the rent from the tenants
(g) making repairs at the buildings
(h) arranging with persons (other than the owners of
the building) to have repairs made at the buildings
(i) payment of utility bills for the buildings
(j) payment of mortgage payments where applicable.
If any of the items listed above are performed or paid for
App. 23
by the defendants trading as Drucker & Falk as agent for
the owner of the building, please so indicate with respect to
each item.
2. Defendants regularly deal with the following insur-
ance companies, whose main offices are located in the loca-
tions indicated:
(a) American Casualty Company
Reading, Pennsylvania
(b) Kemper Insurance Company
Summit, New Jersey
(c) Central Mutual Insurance Company
Van Wert, Ohio
(d) Pawtucket Mutual Insurance Company
Pawtucket, Rhode Island
Please admit or deny with respect to each specific item
above.
3. At defendants’ office located at 131 - 26th Street, New-
port News, Virginia, at least two employees are and since
January 30, 1966 have been engaged, as a regular part of
their duties each week, in handling, preparing, mailing, or
otherwise working on insurance policies or other materials
for transmission across state lines to each of the insurance
companies mentioned in Request for Admissions 2. Please
admit or deny with respect to each insurance company men-
tioned in Request for Admissions 2.
4. At Robin Hoods apartments (as identified in defend-
ants’ answer to interrogatory 1, part cc), the defendants,
trading as Drucker & Falk, have collected rents in excess of
one million dollars per year during the period since January
30, 1967.
A a a Se Ne aS
App. 24
5. Defendants, trading as Drucker & Falk, have, since
January 30, 1967, considered their employees at Robin
Hoods apartments to be covered by the provisions of the
Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, as amended by the Fair
Labor Standards Amendments of 1961 (75 Stat. 65) and
have, accordingly, compensated such employees at the rates
prescribed by the Fair Labor Standards Amendments of
1961.
6. As a regular incident of their management of the
buildings mentioned in defendants’ answer to interrogatory
1 (and as a regular incident to defendants’ management of
any other building), defendants, trading as Drucker & Falk,
repair (or cause to be repaired) parts for plumbing, heat-
ing, and airconditioning units.
7. The plumbing, heating, and airconditioning parts
mentioned in Request for Admissions 6 are received by the
defendants after the said parts have moved across state
lines.
8. (a) In their newspaper advertisements for tenants to
occupy apartment buildings which manage, the defendants
mention their trade names but do not mention the name of
the owner or owners of the apartment building.
(b) This practice has been in effect during the period
since January 30, 1967.
Roger T. Williams
Assistant U.S. Attorney
Sylvia S. Ellison
Chief Trial Attorney
William H. Horkan
Deputy Chief Trial Attorney
Thomas E. Korson
Attorney
App. 25
(Caption Omitted)
ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S INTERROGATORIES
(SECOND SET)
(Filed in U. S. District Court August 20, 1969)
This day come the defendants, E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker,
E. B. Drucker, David Falk and R. E. Smith, individually
and as partners in Drucker & Falk, and file this, their indi-
vidual and collective Answer to Plaintiff's Interrogatories
(Second Set), as follows:
14. The answers listed in Interrogatories #1 did list rent-
als managed during period since January, 1967.
15. Correspondence mentioned in Interrogatories #4 did
not go across state lines except where there be out-of-state
ownership as previously referred to and there, operating
statements once per month and frequent occupancy reports
did go to owners.
16. In answer to Interrogatories #16 the telephone com-
munications would be approximately once per month nor-
mally by the manager of the project.
17. To completely answer this question would take an
enormous amount of research and then probably would not
completely answer same; however, major suppliers are as
follows:
Paint—Hampton Paint Company, Patterson Ave.,
Hampton, Va. C. A. Nash, 732 Granby Street, Nor-
folk, Va.
Plumbing & Heating Supplies—Noland Company,
2600 Warwick Boulevard, Newport News, Virginia
>
Soe a aan Nh oa a ee
App. 26
Fuel—Humble Oil Company, Terminal Avenue, New-
port News, Virginia, Virginia Electric & Power Co.,
G. Street, Newport News, Virginia
Carpentry Supplies—R. F. Slaughter Lumber Com-
pany, 50 N. Mallory, Hampton, Virginia
18. The personnel mentioned in Interrogatories 9, 10 and
11 are not trading as Drucker & Falk, and their names and
addresses are as shown on the attached list.
19. Drucker & Falk since January 1966 has been engaged
in real estate brokerage, subdivision development, real
estate management and insurance business. 4
ANSWERS TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS
This day came the defendants and file this, their answers
to Request for Admissions, and in answer do say as follows:
1. That they do deny that Drucker & Falk as such per- |
form all of the activities set forth in paragraph 1 in Request
for Admissions and do aver that much of this work is per-
form by employees located on the project, hired by Drucker
& Falk as agents for owners and for the owners’ account or
by persons previously hired by them as Agent for the Own-
ers’ account. All such employees are employees of the in-
dividual project.
2. That they do admit the statement contained in para-
graph 2.
3. That they do admit allegations of paragraph 3.
4. That they do admit that Robinhood Apartments does
collect its rent as stated but such rents are collected by
employees of the apartments who are employees of the
owners of subject apartment project.
App. 27
5. Statement contained in Request for Admissions 5 is
correct except such employees are employees of the project.
6. Statement contained in request for Admission 6 is in-
correct.
7. Defendants are not aware of the source of equipment
or parts mentioned in request for Admission 7.
8. Request for Admission 8(A) is incorrect since the name
of the apartment project advertised is normally the name
the project.
E. E. Falk, A. L. Drucker, E. B.
Drucker, David Falk and R. E.
Smith, individually and as part-
ners in Drucker ees
E. E, Falk
A. L. Drucker
E. B. Drucker
David Falk
R. E. Smith
Executive Director—Management Dept. — Richard E. Smith
14 Garland Court
Newport News, Va. 23606
Asst. Executive Director—Mgmt. Dept. — Jarvis W. Edwards
3406 Custer Court
Hampton, Va. 23366
Andover—Area Manager — G. C. Wood \
5412 Princess Anne Road
Virginia Beach, Va. 23462
Maintenance Supt, — Frank Caprio
2517 E. Little Creek Road
Norfolk, Va. 23518
Bel Meade—Area Manager — F. O. Keil
Bolling—Project Manager — R. O. Osmond
520 Biltmore Road
Norfolk, Va. 23505
Maintenance Supt. — Thompson Sellers
9569 - 20th Bay Street
Norfolk, Va. 23518
Bondale—Area Manager — G. C. Wood
5412 Princess Anne Road
Virginia Beach, Va. 23462
Maintenance Supt. — A. L. Paolilli
2500 Wyoming Avenue
Norfolk, Va. 23513
Chamberlayne—Area Manager — F. O. Keil
1908 Seddon Road
Richmond, Virginia 23227
Maintenance Supt. — C. K. Topp
4308 Old Broad Road
Apt. #2
Richmond, Virginia 23227
Lakeshore—Area Manager — Larry W. Trent
(No Longer Manager by D & F)
Southampton—Area Manager — Mrs. Christine Hill
Warwick Marshall—Project Manager — W. L. Edwards
Maintenance Supt. — John Davis
5204 Arlington Avenue
Newport News, Va. 23605
Executive Suite—None
Ivy-Dresden—Area Manager — Jacob Drucker
78-D Elizabeth Road
Hampton, Virginia 23369
Maintenance Supt. — R. Fitzgerald
1209 Tyler Avenue
Newport News, Va. 23601
Mercury West—Maintenance Supt. — Paul Sutherland
1601 Pennwood Drive
Apt. C
Hampton, Va. 23366
Hampton Associates—Area Manager — Larry W. Trent
University Apts. #45
(No Longer Managed by D & F) Greenwood Drive
Johnson City, Tennessee
Maintenance Supt. — Roscoe Gardner
$6 Twin Lakes Drive
Hampton, Virginia 23366
Glenwood—Area Manager — F. O. Keil
1908 Seddon Road
Richmond, Virginia 23227
Maintenance Supt. — Fred Johnson
Rt. #2, Box A39
D ‘lle, Virgini
Sewell—Area Manager — G. C. Wood
; 5412 Princess Anne Road
Virginia Beach, Va. 23462
App. 31
Maintenance Supt. — A. L. Paolilli
2500 Wyoming Avenue
Norfolk, Va. 23513
Lakeshore Village—Area Manager — Larry W. Trent
University Apts. #45
(No Longer Managed by D & F) Greenwood Drive
Johnson City, Tennessee
Maintenance Supt. — Roscoe Gardner
36 Twin Lakes Drive
Hampton, Virginia 23366
Shell Gardens—None
Queen’s Terrace—Area Manager — Larry W. Trent
University Apts. #45
(No Longer Managed by D & F) Greenwood Drive
Johnson City, Tennessee
Maintenance Supt. — William Palmer
188 Michigan Drive
Hampton, Virginia
West County—Area Manager — Mrs. Christine Hill
29 Lancaster Terrace
Hampton, Virginia 23366
Maintenance Supt.—None
Plaza—Area Manager — G. C. Wood
5412 Princess Anne Road
Virginia Beach, Va. 23462
Project Manager — B. W. Scott
124 #3 Palm Beach Place
Virginia Beach, Va. 23452
Robin Hood—Project Manager — R. Maurer
5527 Robin Hood Road
Norfolk, Va. 23513
Maintenance Supt. — Lewis Griffith
’ 5424 W. Robin Hood Road
Norfolk, Va. 23513
NOTE: Area Managers, Executive Director and Asst. Executive Director are
all Drucker & Falk Employees.
DR Ae RRP: ONY TREO ENON
Soe ete te a A pT
App. 32
ORDER ON FINAL PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
(Filed in U. S. District Court September 12, 1969)
In conformity with the Local Rules of this Court relating
to pre-trial procedure, it is Ordered that:
1. The parties hereto agree upon a stipulation with re-
spect to certain undisputed facts as follows:
This Court’s jurisdiction of this action under sec-
tion 17 of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938,
as amended (29 U.S.C. 217) (hereinafter referred
to as the Act) is not disputed.
Defendants have been since August 26, 1966, and
are now actively engaged in the control and super-
vision of the operations of Drucker & Falk, 131 -
26th Street, Newport News, Virginia, in the busi-
ness of selling real estate and insurance and man-
aging rental property.
c. Defendants, at all times since August 25, 1966, have
acted directly and indirectly in the interest of
Drucker & Falk in relation to its employees.
At all times since August 25, 1966, at least two of
defendants’ employees at their main office at 131 -
26th Street, Newport News, Virginia, have been
engaged in handling, preparing, mailing, or other-
wise working on insurance policies or other ma-
terials for transmission across state lines to each of
the following insurance companies: American Casu-
alty Company, Reading, Pennsylvania; Kemper In-
surance Company, Summit, New Jersey; Central
Mutual Insurance Company, Van Wert, Ohio; and
Pawtucket Mutual Insurance Company, Paw-
tucket, Rhode Island.
App. 33
. Asa regular incident of their management of rental
property, employees at the buildings managed by
defendants repair plumbing, heating, and air con-
ditioning units.
Substantial portions of the materials mentioned in
(€) above moved across state lines.
. Defendants manage and since August 25, 1966,
have managed (among other buildings) the Robin
Hood Apartments, 5500 Robin Hood Road, Nor-
folk, Virginia; the Plaza Apartments, 124 Palm
Beach Place, Virginia Beach, Virginia; and the
Sewell, 400 West Little Creek Road, Norfolk, Vir-
ginia.
. At least one of the employees at each of the build-
ings specified in (g) above are and since August 25,
1966, has been regularly engaged in telephone and
mail communications across state lines concerning
the operation of the buildings with the owners of
the buildings.
For the period since the first quarter of 1966, the
gross receipts for rentals and other fees or charges
collected by employees in the buildings from the
tenants of the various buildings which defendants
manage has been in excess of $1,000,000 each year.
j. The rents collected from the tenants of Robin Hood
Apartments have been in excess of $1,000,000 per
year during the period since January 30, 1967.
. Defendants have considered the employees at
Robin Hood Apartments, 5500 Robin Hood Road,
Norfolk, Virginia, to be covered by the provisions
of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, as
App. 34
amended by the Fair Labor Standards Amend-
- ments of 1961 (75 Stat. 65) and have accordingly
compensated such employees at the rates prescribed
by those amendments.
With respect to defendants’ management of rental
by -ipye defendants perform the following func-
5
(a) erahases eucenamnenin
(2) Firing project manager at project.
(3) Indirectly supervising the employees who work
at the buildings.
(4) Advertising for tenants to occupy the build-
ings.
(5) Making payments of utility bills for the build-
ings out of project owner’s account.
(6) Making mortgage payments where applicable
out of project owner’s account.
(omitted)
P/T Ex. #3 is a newspaper advertisement for
apartment buildings managed by defendants. This
advertisement is typical of defendants’ advertising
for tenants at the buildings which they manage.
The apartment ‘projects belong to parties other
than the defendants and are managed under a man-
agement contract which provides that employees of
the project shall be employees of the owners and
rental payments as received are deposited in an in
and out account on behalf of the owner and ex-
penses are paid out of this account with the balance
distributed immediately after receipt. Ownership
remains with the owner and not the defendants and
contractual arrangement is one of owner and rental
App. 35
agent. Employees are credited on defendants’ books
as employees of the particular project with each
project having a project manager and sufficient
other employees to handle rental, collections and
p. Employees at each building perform the following
functions under the direction of the project man-
ager:
(1) Renting the apartments in the building.
(2) Collecting the rents from the tenants.
(3) Making repairs at the buildings.
(4) Arranging with persons, other than the owners
of the buildings, to have repairs made at the
buildings.
2. (a) The parties hereto agree that the following ex-
hibits, identified by the initials of counsel, may be intro-
duced in evidence without the*necessity of further proof:
P/T Ex. #1 Plaintiff's Discovery and Answers.
P/T Ex. #2 Schedule of back wages.
P/T Ex. #3. Advertisement.
(b) Defendant's Exhibit #1 will be copy of typical man-
agement contract.
3. (omitted)
4. (a) The factual contention of the plaintiff is that the
employees at the buildings managed by defendants are em-
ployees of defendants.
(b) The factual contention of the defendant is that the
projects managed by the defendant are owned by a multi-
tude of parties who are unrelated to one another and that
the employees are employees of the particular project car- ~
App. 36
ried on their payrolls and paid by them out of their trust
funds. Management of the apartment projects varies and
the employees go with the managed apartments. Em-
ployees are handled as employees of the apartment owners.
Payrolls, etc., are so handled. Relationship of the employees
is as employees of the project owner.
5. (a) The triable issues as contended by the plaintiff
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Whether the activities of the defendants in selling
real estate and insurance and managing rental
property constitute an enterprise within the mean-
ing of section 3(r) of the Act.
Whether defendants’ business activities constitute
an enterprise engaged in commerce or in the pro-
duction of goods for commerce within the meaning
of section 3(s)(1) of the Act, as amended by the
Fair Labor Standards Amendments of 1966 (80
Stat. 830).
Whether the employees at the buildings managed
by defendants are defendants’ employees within
the meaning of sections 3(d), (e), and (g) of the
Act.
Whether plaintiff is entitled to an order restrain-
ing the further withholding of back wages due to
their employees under the Act.
Whether plaintiff is entitled to prejudgment in-
terest on the sums which defendants withheld as
unpaid minimum wages and overtime compensa-
tion from their employees.
(b) The triable issues as contended by the defendant are:
App. 37
(1) Whether Drucker & Falk is an enterprise as de-
fined by the 1961 amendments to the Act or by the
1966 amendments to the Act.
(2) Whether Drucker & Falk is engaged in commerce
or in the production of goods for commerce within
the meaning of those terms as defined by the Fair
Labor Standards Act.
(3) Whether the defendant Drucker & Falk is an
“employer” of the “building employees” at the
various apartment projects within the meaning of
the Act. :
(4) Whether the “annual gross volume of sales made
or business done” by Drucker & Falk for its man-
agement activities is measured by gross rentals or
by commissions received.
(5) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the injunctive
relief requested and/or interest thereon.
Pre-Trial Exhibit #2
The following sheets contain a schedule of back wages
computed for the period from January 30, 1967 to January
30, 1969. The total back wages amount to $27,286.44.
(list of names, addresses, period
covered, and amounts due—omitted)
App. 38
Pre-Trial Exhibit #3
Reprint from Newport News Daily Press,
May 2, 1968
THAT'S US
ALL OVER
(Map Omitted)
SOUTHHAMPTON APARTMENTS
1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom
ry i ary
@ Heat and Hot Water 3816 Kecoughtan Road
@ Swimming Pool 9-5 Mon. Thru Sat.
Phone PA 2-6363
LAKESHORE APARTMENTS
TOWNHOUSE AND GARDEN
APARTMENTS
The Address of the Peninsula’s
Most Fashionable People
@ Townhouse Privacy § © Swimming Pool
© Hospitality House © Dishwashers © Nursery
@ Individually Controlled Air Conditioning
(All Utilities Included)
DIRECTIONS: Drive out Mercury Blvd. to Todds Lane. Turn
north to Lakeshore Village. HOURS: ~~ p-m. Sunday,
1 p.m. 5 p.m. Anytime by appointment. ‘
616 Drive
9 *till 5 Mon. thru Sat.
App. 39
DRUCKER & FALK
where Red Carpet Service is Our Objective
131 26th St. — 245-1541
OCCUPANCY
MERCURY WEST
2 Bedrooms From $125
Including All Utilities
Mercury Blvd. - Pennwood Dr.
HOURS: 11 am.-5 p.m.
Mon. Thru Sat.
Drocker & Falk
1601 Pennwood Dr. 826-6270
App. 40
(Caption Omitted)
STIPULATION OF FACTS
(Filed in U. S. District Court October 9, 1969)
The parties stipulate that:
1. This stipulation supplements and clarifies the stipula-
tion of undisputed facts contained in the order on final
pretrial conference entered on September 5, 1969. Both
stipulations may be introduced in evidence in this action.
9. Drucker & Falk, defendants, is a partnership engaged
sn the real estate and insurance business and, as part of its
function, manages apartment projects for a commission of
rentals. As such, Drucker & Falk manages approximately
30 projects and does so under agency contracts, sample copy
of which is part of the Exhibits in this matter.
(a) The agency contract employs the defendants to man-
age the projects and to either furnish services in and about
renting, collecting rents and managing the properties of the
owner or, in the alternative, for the defendants to furnish
only supervision of these activities, with the owners bearing
all expense for on site clerical and leasing personnel. In
either case in every instance it is specifically agreed in the
contract that management does not include the expense of
operating and maintaining the property and the agreement
specifically provides that all such employees dealing with
operating and maintaining the property shall be the em-
of the owner. The plaintiff contends, and defendants
deny, that the employees are in fact employees of the de-
fendants within the meaning of Segtion 3(d), (e) and (g)
of the Fair Labor Standards Act.
(i) Breakdown where services or supervision is fur-
nished is shown on Appendix A.
App. 41
2(b) The defendants feel their function is to advise the
owners as to its recommendations to establish the major
policy decisions by which the project is to be operated and
to thereby establish the long range maintenance, moderni-
zation and major replacement programs which are designed
over a period of years to insure that the project maintains
its competitive position so as to prolong life of the project at
its highest and best use, producing the highest reasonable
stabilized net cash flow from the property to the owner.
2(c) All rental receipts are collected for the owners and
deposited in a trust account separate from the defendants’
personal account. Such accounts may be and are co-
mingled in one trust account maintained by agent for all
clients or properties managed by the defendants.
2(d) The agent renders monthly or at agreed times state-
ments of receipts, expenses and charges and remits receipts
less disbursements to the owners. In the event that dis-
bursements are in excess of rents collected by the agent,
owners are required to pay to agent such excess amount.
2(e) Defendants in their agreement with owners agree
to supervise advertising and to rent and collect rents or to
supervise these functions, and to stand in the shoes of the
owner in this connection.
2(f) In connection with repairs, maintenance, and al-
terations, defendants have agreed to supervise such and
have in this connection agreed to submit for approval a
written budget for stipulated periods and no expenditures
may be made under such budget except with specific ap-
proval of the owner. Such approval covers all cost of main-
tenance and repair, including wage costs.
2(g) For such services, and, where specified, for the use
of defendants’ employees in rental and clerical services, the
App. 42 f
project owner pays a specific percentage the rental on
the income of the project. The arrangement between the
parties is for a specific period, not less than one year, with
the right for either party to terminate the relationship.
There is no relationship of contract period between any one
of the projects and another.
2(h) In each instance the repair and maintenance em-
ployees are carried on the books of the project owner as
employees of the project owner and the project owner car-
ries a separate employer identification number for income
tax purposes.
2(i) The annual gross income of the individual projects
in which employees in question are employed is not suf-
ficient to bring such employees within the enterprise pro-
visions of the Act until February 1, 1969.
2(j) Maintenance employees employed at projects may
goods passing through interstate commerce but the
ific employees doing such work or the amount thereof
or frequency thereof is not known and would not bring the
employees within the coverage of the Act except should
they be considered employees of Drucker & Falk under
the enterprise theory.
3. Although there are some minor variations from proj-
ect to project, defendants’ practice in managing the apart-
ment projects is as follows:
3(a) The defendants differentiate between the manage-
ment and rental function and the function of maintenance
and upkeep of the apartment projects. Management and
rental employees are, where specified, carried on the payroll
of the defendants, whereas, maintenance and upkeep em-
ployees are in all cases carried as employees of the project
owners.
App. 43
3(b) The defendants in their real estate business have a
management department charged with managing apart-
ments which department is headed by one of the defendants
as Executive Director of the Management Department.
Under him, all on Drucker & Falk’s payroll and not involved
in this suit, are an Assistant Director and six Area Managers
who are responsible for supervising and enforcing manage-
ment policies at a number of projects normally within a
given area. One of these individuals supervises only one
project, but he is on a semi-retired basis.
3(c) Where so specified, rental agents and various cleri-
cal employees, carried on defendants’ central payroll, work
on the premises of the projects, collect rents, operate the
rental office, take tenant complaints and keep the office rec-
ords. These employees at each project deposit the rent and
other receipts collected for the project in a customers ac-
count under the name of Drucker & Falk as agent in the
bank closest to that location. Subsequently, these funds are
withdrawn and deposited in a central customers trust ac-
count for all managed properties maintained at Citizens and
Marine/United Virginia Bank, in the name of Drucker &
Falk as Agents and designated as a customers account. The
first mentioned account generally has a number and/or
name which identifies the specific project. These employees
send the collection information, bank deposit receipts and
other records to defendants’ central office. They are hired,
fired and directly supervised by officials of defendants.
3(d) Each apartment project has a person in charge
who is called “Project Manager” or “Maintenance Super-
intendent”, depending upon the size of the project. These
individuals are directly responsible for the maintenance and
upkeep of the project and are directly supervised by the
Area Manager or other officers of the defendants as agents
for the project owner, and salaries for these individuals are
App. 44
set in accordance with semi-annual budget which is ap-
proved by the project owner.
The Project Manager, or Maintenance Superintendent, is
a person who has the capacity to make normal day-to-day
decisions and to do the day-to-day physical operation,
maintenance, repair and upkeep of the project. He is ex-
pected to make appropriate decisions as to the necessity for
painting, redecorating and the extent of repair or replace-
ment of damaged equipment. 7
The average pay of the Project Manager is $125 per
week with apartment and utilities furnished in addition to
the weekly salary. He is in charge of each project and hires,
fires and supervises the maintenance employees of the proj-
ect. The Project Manager or Maintenance Superintendent
is carried as an employee of the project owner as well as the
employees supervised by him. The Maintenance Super-
intendent keeps the records of hours worked each week by
the maintenance employees and submits the records directly
to defendants central office where the payroll for the project
is made up for the account of each owner. The maintenance
superintendent and maintenance employees of the project
are paid by defendants’ checks which are prepared by de-
fendants’ central office employees and signed by one of the
defendants acting on behalf of their principals. The checks
are drawn on a special payroll bank account kept by the
defendants for all projects. The funds in this special payroll
account are drawn from a central management customers
account covering all projects in the amount required to meet
the overall payroll, with each project owner being charged
his exact payroll amount. The funds in this central cus-
tomers account are the rents and other receipts which the
rental agent deposits in the account as described in section
(c)-of this paragraph.
App. 45
3. (e€) The Project Manager or Maintenance Super-
intendent submits a semi-annual budget request to the Area
Manager and higher supervisory officials in defendants’
organization. Defendants’ officials review and revise the bud-
get and present it, with their recommendation, to the project
owner for approval. The maintenance superintendent does
not normally discuss the formal budget with the owner.
However, the owner normally inspects the property on at
least a semi-annual basis and discusses the project needs with
the maintenance superintendent. This inspection is normally
conducted just prior to the presentation of the budget re-
quest for the following period. The budget as it is approved
by the owner is sent to the maintenance superintendent by
the Area Manager or other Drucker & Falk officials. Gen-
erally, the budget places specific allowances for maintenance
costs such as payroll, painting, grounds maintenance, plumb-
ing, equipment repair, appliance replacement, etc. Within
the limits of the budget the superintendent sets the hours of
work and wage rates of the maintenance employees. The
Area Managers and higher supervisory officials in defend-
ants’ organization have but rarely exercise a veto over the
decision of the superintendents with respect to hiring, firing
and setting wage rates. The superintendents are fairly
autonomous because of their demonstrated good judgment
and performance.
3. (f) Each maintenance superintendent receives bills
for goods and services which he orders for the project and
he sends the bills to defendants’ central office with a voucher
requesting payment. Defendants’ central office employees
pay the bills by checks drawn on the central customers ac-
count described in section (c) of this paragraph. The checks
are signed by one of the defendants.
4. (a) The owners of the projects inspect their projects
from time to time. Some of the owners inspect the projects
App. 46
once a month; other owners inspect their projects twice a
year, generally in advance of budget consideration. When
they visit the projects, the owners are primarily concerned
with the physical condition of the premises, vacancies, and
tenant complaints. They do not make suggestions to the em-
ployees at the project with respect to the wages, hours or
supervision of the maintenance employees; such suggestions
are made as a matter of policy directly to their agents, the
defendants.
4. (b) The maintenance superintendents are in a posi-
tion to know, but may not know, who the owners of the proj-
ect are. Most of the maintenance superintendents know who
the owners are and know that their wages are ultimately
paid by the owner out of rents for the project. While they
may talk to the owners occasionally about the project, the
superintendents look to the defendants for supervision and
4. (c) Over a period of the last six or seven years, there
have been a maximum of five maintenance personnel as-
signed by the defendants from one project to another project
owned by an entirely different owner. In each instance this
was moving a maintenance employee to a maintenance
superintendent job or moving a maintenance superintendent
to a larger project. In all cases, this was accomplished with
the knowledge of the owners. Such transfers were arranged
by officials of the defendants.
4. (d) Over the last five years, defendants have lost the
agency contract at 8 projects belonging to various owners
employing approximately 35 people. Of this total, defend-
ants offered a job to two persons employed by these projects.
Neither of these employees came with the defendants and in
each instance the employees continued working at the proj-
ect and were employed by the owners.
App. 47
5. (a) Most projects managed by the defendants have
an office, storage area, or other central facility from which
the project is managed. Some of the smaller projects do not
have such facilities. The maintenance work at these smaller
projects is performed by employees and equipment from
other projects managed by defendants. The use of these
employees is only after approval of the owner of both proj-
ects and the smaller project is charged with the labor, which
is credited to the larger project. The larger project normally
agrees because of the economic advantage of being able to
employ a half employee when a full time employee is not
needed.
5. (b) Some of the maintenance superintendents and
employees are carried on two separate payrolls of projects
owned by entirely different owners where the projects are
located in close geographic proximity and where the mainte-
nance services to be rendered have identical objectives for
both owners in order to permit economy of operation. In all
instances, this is accomplished with the approval of both
owners. Where the project owner has its own separate
maintenance crew but shares the services of one or two
employees, these shared employees receive two separate
checks, one from each project account. In other instances,
where there is one or more large project and one or more
small project which do not have an independent mainte-
nance crew, the maintenance personnel are carried by the
larger project and provide maintenance service to the
smaller project; in this instance, the shared employees are
paid by one check from one account and the defendants |
maintain an internal accounting procedure so that the other
project may be charged with that part of the employees’
wages utilized by the smaller project.
App. 48
5. (c) Except in the cases provided in section (b)
above, all employees work solely at the project where they
are employed.
6. Some of the projects where the employees involved are
employed are no longer managed by the defendants.
7. None of the projects managed by defendants except
Robin Hood had a total rental income in excess of the
$1,000,000 annual figure set by Congress as criteria for being
an enterprise engaged in commerce or in the production of
goods for commerce. In this instance, the employees of the
project were paid rates in accordance with the Fair Labor
Standards Act. Some of the projects managed by the de-
fendants have total rental income in excess of $250,000. De-
fendants have agreed to pay employees in those projects in
accordance with the Act beginning February 1, 1969, the
date on which the dollar Volume test was reduced to $250,-
000 under Section 3(s) (1) of the Act.
8. For a period of approximately one year prior to the
enactment of the 1966 amendments to the Fair Labor Stan-
dards Act in September 1966, the Department of Labor did
not take vigorous action to enforce the Act with respect to
the activities of apartment house management companies.
This absence of action was due to a thorough study of the
applicability of the enterprise provisions of the Act to those
activities. Some investigations were made during the period
but no enforcement action was instituted in court. Subse-
quent to the enactment of the 1966 amendments, the De-
partment re-asserted its position that the activities came -
within the enterprise provisions of the Act and began sched-
uling investigations in a concerted enforcement effort shortly
after February 1, 1967, the effective date of the 1966 amend-
ments. The investigation that lead to this law suit was
~ started on August 26, 1968. At the fimal conference on
App. 49
October 22, 1968, E. E. Falk, one of the defendants and a»
partner of the other defendants, told Mr. Earl Hawthorne,
the Wage-Hour Investigator that he was aware of the De-
partment’s position that all of the apartment projects man-
aged by the defendants comprised one enterprise and that
all employees in the projects were covered by the enter-
prise provisions of the Act. Mr. Falk stated, however, that
defendants contested the Department's position and had
contributed a substantial sum of money to the National
Association of Real Estate Board to help in the deferise of
Wirtz v. Arnheim & Neeley, Inc., a similar case brought by
the Secretary of Labor in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. That
suit was filed in October, 1967. On instruction from the
Association, Mr. Falk refused to make any settlement or
concessions on the enterprise issue. He agreed to comply
with respect to employees in those projects which were con-
sidered enterprises standing alone. )
Jones, BLEcHMAN,
Woxrtz & Keiiy
Attorneys for Defendants
By Hersert V. Ketry
WiiuiaM H. HorKan
Deputy Chief Trial Attorney
Tuomas E. Korson
Attorney
Attorneys for Plaintiff
United States Department of Labor
Of Counsel
Brian P. Gerrincs
United States Attorney
App. 50
APPENDIX A
1966 1967 1968
Gross rental collected where Tey aa
rental employees furnished
by Drucker & Faulk $5,670,030.13 $6,170,728.41 $6,026,908.97
Gross rental collected where
rental employees furnished
by Owner $ 141,589.24 $1,554,872.45 $2,580,177.07
Projects where leasing personnel on Owner’s payroll:
Plaza Lakeshore Village
Robin Hood Victory Gardens
Lakeshore Association | Newsome I and II
Hampton Association
RAS TN ree ae
are attached as Exhibits A and B.
“Exhibit A”
-adaiemamants AGREEMENT
Ss eds ie mene day
re persian eS. , 19.... between
Witnesseth :
In consideration of the mutual promises and covenants
herein contained, Owners and Agent agree as follows:
App. 51
ARTICLE I
lection of rents, and managing of Owner’s property described
herein. It is understood that except as provided in this
Article, “management” does not include any expenses of
advertising, marketing, renting, leasing, operating or main-
taining the premises.
(b) Agent agrees to deposit all receipts collected for
Owners in a Trust Account, separate from Agent’s
account. Such receipts may be co-mingled in one trust
count maintained by Agent for all or several clients or
erties managed by Agent. Agent agrees that upon special
request of Owners, a separate rate trust account for subject
property will be established and maintained. It is agreed
that Agent will not be held liable in the event of bankruptcy
or failure of any depository.
(c) Agent agrees to render monthly, or at such other rea-
sonable intervals as Owners and Agent may agree upon,
statements of receipts, expenses and charges, and to remit to
App. 52
Owners receipts less disbursements. In the event that the
disbursements shall be in excess of the rents collected by
Agent, Owners agree to pay to Agent such excess promptly
upon demand.
(d) Agent’s employees who handle or are responsible for
Owner’s monies shall be bonded by a fidelity bond.
ARTICLE Ill
Agent agrees to provide the services of his organization
to provide diligent and proper supervision of the execution
of the following authority and powers which Owner hereby
confers upon Agent, all expenses for which Owners agree to
assume.
(a) To advertise the availability for rental of subject
property or any part thereof and to display signs thereon;
to sign, renew and/or cancel leases for the premises or any
part thereof; to collect rents due or to become due and to
issue receipts therefore; to terminate tenancies and to sign
and serve in the name of Owners such notices as Agent
deems needful; to institute and prosecute actions to evict
tenants and recover possession of said premises; to sue for,
in the name of Owners, and recover rents and other sums
due; and, when expedient, to settle, compromise, and release
such actions or suits or reinstate such tenancies. Any leases
executed for the Owner by the Agent shall not exceed one
(1) year.
(b) To make or cause to be made and supervise repairs
and alterations, and to do decorating on said premises, and
to purchase supplies and pay all bills. In this connection,
beginning nee , 19..., Agent will submit to
Owners for their prior approval a written budget for stipu-
lated periods as agreed upon. Agent agrees to secure the
App. 53
(c) Subject to budget approval as set forth in paragraph
(b) above, to hire, discharge and supervise all labor and
employees required for the operation and maintenance of
the premises, with all employees deemed employees of
Owners. Agent may perform any of his duties through
Owner’s attorneys, agents, and employees and shall not be
responsible for their acts, defaults, or negligence if reason-
able care has been exercised in their appointment and
rentention.
(d) Subject to budget approval as set forth in paragraph
(b) above, to make contracts for electricity, gas, fuel, water,
telephone, window cleaning, ash or rubbish removal, deco-
rating, repair, and other services or such of them as Agent
shall deem advisable. Owners shall assume the obligation
of any such contract entered into for their benefit, including
any such obligation which may extend beyond any termina-
tion of this agreement.
ARTICLE IV
(a) Owners agree to hold and save Agent free and harm-
less from damages or injuries to person or property by reason
of any cause whatsoever either in or about the premises or
elsewhere arising out of Agent’s management of subject
property.
App. 54
(b) Owners agree to carry public liability insurance with
limits not less than $300,000 which policy(ies) shall be so
written as to expressly name Agent as a co-insured, covering
Agent in the same manner and to the same extent as Owners,
memorandum copies of which shall be delivered to Agent.
Owners shall carry adequate workmen’s compensation in-
surance and such other insurance as may be necessary for
the protection of the interest of Owners.
(c) Agent shall not be liable for any error of judgment
or any mistake of fact or law; Agent shall be liable only for
such actions or failure to act as constitute wilful misconduct
or gross negligence.
(d) If Owners shall fail or refuse to comply with or abide
by any rule, order, determination, ordinance, or law of any
Federal, State or Municipal Authority, Agent upon giving
twenty-four (24) hours written notice may terminate this
Agreement. \
ARTICLE V
Owners will advise Agent in the event Owners desire
Agent to pay mortgage indebtedness, property or employee
taxes, special assessments, or to place insurance and pay
or any other insurance. As to any such payments to be made
by the Agent, Agent is directed to accrue such sums on a
monthly basis from the Owner’s funds if necessary to assure
sufficient funds on hand by the date payment becomes due
and to pay same.
ARTICLE VI
Agent is clothed with such other general authority and
powers as may be necessary or advisable to carry out the
spirit and intent of this Agreement.
App. 55
Owners agree to pay Agent monthly as compensation for
his services, a management fee equal to four (4%) per cent
upon all rents collected for said property, or such other rate
as may be fixed from time to time for like services by the
Newport News-Hampton Real Estate Board; provided
however that any such rate increase shall go into effect only
after expiration of thirty (30) days subsequent to the Agent
notifying the Owners of his intention to place into effect such
rate increases; and provide further that if such rate increase
is unacceptable to Owners, and Agent is unwilling to con-
tinue management at the existing rate, Owners may termi-
nate this agreement and Agency without penalty upon thirty
(30) days notice to this effect to Agent.
ARTICLE VIII
(a) This agreement shall become effective when executed
for an original term ending on the... se he RS .
ta
(b) Thereafter, this contract shall be automatically re-
newed for periods of one year unless on or before sixty (60)
days prior to the ......... a, ee, ee eee ieee , 19...., or on
agreement may be terminated.
(c) Subject to the provisions of paragraph (d) in this
Article, on or after 0 enmnng 19... either party
may terminate this agreement at any time without penalty
upon giving thirty (30) days written notice.
(d) Should this agreement be terminated in any fashion
by Owners during the original term (except in the case of
App. 56
lowing termination, that monthly sum which equals the
amount which would have been the management fee except
for such termination.
select an arbitrator, and a third shall be chosen by the two
thus designated; and if they fail to select the third within
ten (10 days after their selection, such third arbitrator shall
be selected by the Judge of the Circuit Court of Newport
News, Virginia. The arbitrators shall examine all relevant
facts and reach a determination. A determination signed
be binding upon Owners and Agents. Costs of arbitration
shall be borne by the party against whom the determination
is made. ‘
This Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto,
the heirs, administrators, executors, successors and assigns
of Owners, and the successors and assigns of Agent.
App. 57
In Witness Whereof, the parties hereto have executed this
Agreement, consisting of five (5) pages, and have affixed
or caused to be affixed their respective signatures and have
affixed their seals this ...... day of ee Sabe
Drucker & Falk
131 - 26th Street
Newport News, Virginia
ee (Seal)
Partner
(Seal)
App. 58
“Exhibit B”
MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT
Agreement made this ........
Gee Oo , 19..... be-
tween
all ui designated as as
“Owners”, and Drucker &
Falk, heveinaltes designated
“ Agent”.
Witnesseth:
In consideration of the mutual promises and covenants
herein contained, Owners and Agent agree as follows:
Article I
Owners hereby employ and appoint Agent as the sole
and exclusive renting and management agent to rent, lease,
operate, and manage the Owners property known as .........
Sonerey ek upon the terms hereinafter set forth.
Article II
(a) Agent accepts the employment and appointment and
agrees to use due diligence in the management of the pre-
mises upon the terms herein provided, and agrees to furnish
the services of his organization for the renting, leasing, col-
lection of rents, and managing of Owners property de-
Agent’s personal
account. Such receipts may be co-mingled in one trust ac-
t for subject
property will be established and maintained. It is agreed
that Agent will not be held liable in the event of bankruptcy
or failure of any depository.
(c) Agent agrees to render monthly, or at such other
reasonable intervals as Owners and Agent may agree upon,
statements of receipts, expenses and charges, and to remit
to Owners receipts less disbursements. In the event that the
disbursements shall be in excess of the rents collected by
Agent, Owners agree to pay to Agent such excess promptly.
upon demand.
(d) Agents employees who handle or are responsible for
Owners’ monies shall be bonded by a fidelity bond.
(e) Agent agrees to contribute toward actual annual
expenditure for advertising a sum not to exceed ten (10)
per cent of the management fee received in that year.
Article III
Agent agrees to provide the services of his organization to
provide diligent and proper supervision of the execution of
the following authority and powers which Owner hereby
confers upon Agent, all expenses for which Owners agree to
assume (except as provided in Article II (e) with regard to
advertising) : i
App. 60
(a) To advertise the availability for rental of subject
property for any part thereof and to display signs thereon;
to sign, renew and/or cancel leases for the premises or any
part thereof; to collect rents due or to become due and to
issue receipts therefore; to terminate tenancies and to sign
and serve in the name of Owners such notices as Agent
deems needful; to institute and prosecute actions to evict
tenants and recover possession of said premises; to sue for,
in the name of Owners, and recover rents and other sums
due; and, when expedient, to settle, compromise, and re-
lease such actions or suits or reinstate such tenancies. Any
leases executed for the Owner by the Agent shall not exceed
one (1) year. |
(b) To make or cause to be made and supervise repairs
and alterations, and to do decorating on said premises, and
to purchase supplies and pay all bills. In this connection,
Agent shall submit to Owners for their prior approval a
written budget for stipulated periods as agreed upon. Agent
agrees to secure the approval of Owners on all expenditures
in excess of ten (10) per cent over an approved budget,
except that Agent is authorized to expend funds pending
budget approval for monthly recurring operation expenses
at a rate not in excess of that approved in the prior budget
period. Agent is also authorized to expend funds for un-
budgeted emergency repairs, if in the opinion of Agent such
repairs are necessary to protect the property from damage
or to maintain required services to tenants.
(c) Subject to budget approval as set forth in paragraph
(b) above, to hire, discharge and supervise all labor and
employees required for the operation and maintenance of
the premises, with all employees deemed employees of Own-
ers. Agent may perform any of his duties through Owners
attorneys, agents, and employees and shall be responsible
App. 61
for their acts, defaults, or negligence if reasonable care has
been exercised in their appointment and retention.
(d) Subject to budget approval as set forth in paragraph
(b) above, to make contracts for electricity, gas, fuel, water,
telephone, window cleaning, ash or rubbish removal, deco-
rating, repair, and other services or such of them as Agent
shall deem advisable. Owners shall assume the obligation
of any such contract entered into for their benefit, including
any such obligation which may extend beyond any termina-
tion of this agreement.
Article IV
(a) Owners agree to hold and save Agent free and harm-
less from damages or injuries to person or property by
reason of any cause whatsoever either in or about the pre-
mises or elsewhere arising out of Agent’s management of
subject property.
(b) Owners agree to carry public liability insurance with
limits not less than $300,000 which policy (ies) shall be so
written as to expressly name Agent as a co-insured, covering
Agent in the same manner and to the same extent as Own-
ers, memorandum copies of which shall be delivered to
Agent. Owners shall carry adequate workmen’s compensa-
tion insurance and such other insurance as may be necessary
for the protection of the interest of Owners.
(c) Agent shall not be liable for any error of judgment
or any mistake of fact or law; Agent shall be liable only for
such actions or failure to act as constitutes willful miscon-
duct or gross negligence.
(d) If Owners shall fail or refuse to comply with or abide
by any rule, order, determination, ordinance, or law of any
App. 62
‘ Federal, State or Municipal Authority, Agent upon giving
twenty-four (24) hours written notice may terminate this
Agreement.
Article V
Owners will adivse Agent in the event Owners desire
Agent to pay mortgage indebtedness, property or employee
taxes, special assessments, or to place insurance and pay
premiums upon fire, liability, steam boiler, pressure vessel,
or any other insurance. As to any such payments to be
made by the Agent, Agent is directed to accrue such sums
on a monthly basis from the Owners funds if necessary to
assure sufficient funds on hand by the date payment be-
comes due and to pay same.
Article VI
Agent is clothed with such other general authority and
powers as may be necessary or advisable to carry out the
spirit and intent of this Agreement.
Article VII
_ Owners agree to pay Agent monthly as compensation for
his services, a management fee equal to six (6) per cent
upon all rents collected for said property, or such other rate
as may be fixed from time to time for like services by the
Newport News-Hampton Real Estate Board; provided how-
ever that any such rate increase shall go into effect only
after the expiration of thirty (30) days subsequent to the
Agent notifying the Owners of his intention to place into
effect such rate increases; and provide further that if such
rate increases is unacceptable to Owners, and Agent is un-
willing to continue management at the existing rate, Own-
App. 63
ers may terminate this agreement and Agency without
penalty upon thirty (30) days notice to this effect to Agent.
Article VIII
(a) This t shall become effective when executed
for an original ending on the
im.
(b) Thereafter, this contract shall be automatically re-
newed for periods of one year unless on or before sixty (60)
days prior to the day of , 19., or on or
before thirty (30) days prior to the expiration of any such
renewal period, either party hereto shall notify the other
in writing at the address hereinafter set forth of an inten-
tion to terminate this agreement, in which case this agree-
ment may be terminated.
(c) Subject to the provisions of paragraph (d) in this
Article, on or after , 19, either party may
terminate this agreement at any time without penalty upon
giving thirty (30) days written notice.
(d) Should this agreement be terminated in any fashion
by Owners during the original term (except in the case of
termination for willful misconduct or gross negligence of
Agent), Owners agree to pay the Agent as compensation for
his past efforts, for a period of twelve (12) months fol-
lowing termination, that monthly sum which equals the
amount which would have been the management fee except
for such termination.
(e) Anything in this Article to the contrary notwith-
standing, Owners may upon thirty (30) days notice termi-
nate this agreement without penalty in the event of willful
misconduct or gross negligence of Agent in the management
App. 64
of said property. In the event of dispute as to the existence
of willful misconduct or gross negligence, the matter shall
shall be selected by the Judge of the Circuit Court of New-
port News, Virginia. The arbitrators shall examine all rele-
vant facts and reach, a determination. A determination
signed by any two arbitrators shall determine the dispute
and shall be binding upon Owners and Agents. Costs of
arbitration shall be borne by the party against whom the
determination is made.
This Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto,
the heirs, administrators, executors, successors and assigns
of Owners, and the successors and assigns of Agent.
In Witness Whereof, the parties hereto have executed this
Drucker & Falk
App. 65
ORDER ALLOWING CERTIORARI
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1972
No. 72-844
~
E. E. FALK, Inprvmua.ly ANp as PARTNER IN
Drucker & FALK, ET ALS.,
Petitioners,
v.
PETER J. BRENNAN, Secretary or Lasor,
Unrrep States DEPARTMENT OF Lazor,
Respondent.
February 26, 1973. Petition for writ of certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
granted limited to Questions 2 and 3 presented by the
petition which read as follows:
“2. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act to be covered
an enterprise must have an ‘annual gross volume of sales
* made or business done’ of $500,000. Is this figure to be
measured by the gross rentals collected by the agent or by
that agent’s gross commissions?
“3. Are maintenance workers employed at the buildings
managed by petitions employees of the apartment owner or
of the petitioners?”
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.