Appendix — United States v. Tax Comm'n of Miss.

Supreme Court brief1973

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

In the Supreme Court of the Anited States

Octoser TERM, 1972

No. 72-350

Unitep States or America, Appellant

v.

Strate Tax CoMMISSION OF THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI, ET AL.

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR

THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI

INDEX, OF APPENDIX

Page

Judicial Proceedings:

Docket Entries .............. cc cece cece e cece eee neces 1

In the United States District Court for the Southern District

of Mississippi :

Oo | ne ee ee re ee 5

Application for Convening of Three-Judge District

COMER nau os sh eG oe oe bes eee een ewes 13

A ee ee re ie ee ere 14

Plaintiff’s Answer to Defendants’ Interrogatories (Ex-

Cd a) ee er ee eee eer 19

Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment .......... 24

Plaintiff’s Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment ....... 26

Btinwlation OF Fae cscs 6 isgcscss cs detec ceeyessceis 28

_ Exhibit 8, Memorandum for Secretaries of the Mili-

tary Departments from Thomas D. Morris, As-

sistant Secretary of Defense (Manpower), dated

Beil 15, 3906 5 co ina desseweseocsvswnrcesanaes 42

Exhibit 9, Memorandum for Assistant Secretary of

Defense (Manpower) from Robert H. B. Baldwin,

Under Secretary of the Navy, dated April 22,1966 44

RETEST SERA LR IU AA, 7 TCT EBT SY FRU EE BIW es BOON CED se eens DN paste mean

ii

—

Exhibit 10, Memorandum for Assistant Secretary of

Defense (Manpower) from Arthur W. Allen, Jr.,

Deputy Under Secretary of the Army (Manpower),

dated April 26, 1966......--.-+-+ssrerrertet 49

Exhibit 11, Memorandum for the Assistant Secretary

of Defense (Manpower) from Norman S. Paul, Un-

der Secretary of the Air Force, dated April 26,

IOEE .ccciceccccccccccccscccesccsseseseresee’ 51

Exhibit 12, Memorandum for Mr. Morris from

Stephen S. Jackson, dated May 3, 1966 .....----- 53

Exhibit 13, Memorandum for the Deputy Secretary

of Defense from Thomas D. Morris, dated June 8,

BOOE oc nccccccccccscccccccccosesocsonce® o..-4 54

Exhibit 14, Memorandum for the Assistant Secretary

of Defense (Administration) from the Deputy Sec-

retary of Defense, dated June 9, 1966 .....------- 56

Exhibit 15, Letter to Mr. Charles B. Buscher, Execu-

tive Director, National Alcoholic Beverage Control

Association, from Thomas D. Morris, dated June

Date

11-3-69

11-3-69

11-3-69

F 11-38-69

11-12-69

11-12-69

11-28-69

12-11-69

12-15-69

12-29-69

Docket Enrtrizs

In tHe Unirep States District Court -

FOR THE SourHERN District oF MIssIssIpPr

Jackson Drvision

(Civil Action No. 4554)

Filings—Proceedings

Complaint, original and ten copies, filed.

Applicant of Plaintiff for convening Three-

Judge District Court, original and three copies,

filed.

Summons, original and seven copies, copies

having attached copy of complaint, issued and

handed U.S. Marshal.

Copy of complaint and application for con-

vening of three-judge court mailel Judge

Walter L. Nixon, Jr.

Designation by Chief J udge John R. Brown of

Circuit Judge Charles Clark and District Judges

Harold Cox and Dan M. Russell, Jr., to hear and

determine the cause. Filed and entered OB

1969, P. 1129-1130.

Copy of Designation and copy of complaint

handed Sue for Judge Cox, mailed Judge

Russell and Judge Clark.

Marshal’s return on summons executed as to

each and all defendants, filed.

Motion of Defendants for additional time within ,

which to file answer with certificate of service,

filed.

ORDER: Defendants granted additional thirty

days from date of this order to file an answer.

Filed and entered OB 1969, P. 1223. (copies

mailed attorneys of record)

Letter from U.S. Attorney requesting issuance

of alias summons to all defendants, filed.

(1)

PE SOO ET IES PSL I OL MAES OLE SONI G WEEE EET Be eng. HRMS Ys Poke he ts pease

oo

2

Date Filings—Proceedings

12-29-69 Alias Summons, original and five copies, copies

having attached copy of complaint, issued and

f handed U.S. Marshal.

1-7-70 Marshal’s return on summons executed as to

Arny Rhoden, State Tax Commission, J immie

Walker, Excise Tax Commissioner, Woodley

Carr, Ad Valorem Commissioner, Kenneth

Stewart, Director of Alcoholic Beverage Con-

trol Division, filed.

1-19-70 Motion of Defendants for a more definite state-

ment with certificate of service, filed.

1-19-70 Notice’ of Motion of Defendants for a more

definite statement for 2-20-70 at Jackson,

Mississippi with certificate of service, filed.

5-12-70 ORDER: Motion for a more definite statement

is overruled and prayer thereof denied. De-

fendants are granted an extension of time until

5-21-70 in which to answer. Filed and entered

OB 1970, P. 715 (copies mailed attorneys of

record)

5-21-70 Answer of defendants to complaint, with cer-

tificate of service, filed.

5-22-70 Copy of above Answer mailed Judges Russell

and Clark, handed Anne Crews for Judge Cox

7-15-70 Interrogatories of Defendants to Plaintiff, filed.

8-12-70 ORDER: United States have additional time

until 9-4-70 to answer interrogatories. Filed and

entered OB 1970, P. 1121. (Copy handed U.S.

Attorney, mailed Taylor Carlisle and Guy

. Rogers)

8-19-70 Interrogatories to Defendant Pursuant to Rule

33, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with Cer-

tificate of Service, filed.

9-8-70 Plaintiff’s objections to Defendant’s inter-

rogatories, with certificate of service, filed.

9-8-70 Plaintiff’s answer to Defendants’ interroga-

tories with certificate of service, filed.

Date

10-5-70

2-4-71

2-4-71

2-4-71

2-4-71

9-22-71

9-22-71

9-28-71

3

Filings—Proceedings

Answer of Defendants to Interrogatories by

Plaintiff with certificate of service and attached

copy of letter, filed.

Defendants’ Motion for ‘Summary Judgment

with Memorandum in Support thereof attached,

with certificate of service, filed.

Defendants’ Notice of Motion for Summary

Judgment for hearing on 2-26-71 in Jackson,

Miss., filed.

Defendants’ Withdrawal of Certain Interroga-

tories Propounded to Plaintiff by Defendants,

with certificate of service, filed.

Copy of defendants’ Motion for Summary

Judgment and attached Memorandum in sup-

port thereof handed Judge Cox, mailed J udges

Russell and Clark.

Sfipulation of Facts between Plaintiff United

States of America and Defendants State Tax

Commission of the State of Mississippi, et al,

with attachments, filed.

Copy of above Stipulation mailed J udges Rus-

sell and Clark and eopy handed Jean Nall for

Judge Cox.

Plaintiff’s Cross Motion for Summary Judg-

ment and Opposition to Defendant’s Motion

for Summary J udgment, with attached Plain-

tiff’s Memorandum of Law in Support of Plain-

tiff’s Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment

and In Opposition to Defendants’ Motion for

Summary J udgment, and certificate of service,

filed.

Copies of above Motion and Memorandum

mailed to Judges Russell and Clark and copy

handed Jean Nall for Judge Cox.

Defendant’s opposition to plaintiff‘s Cross-

Motion for Summary Judgment with certificate

of service, filed. (Copy handed Judge Cox.

Date

3-24-72

3-24-72

3-30-72

3-30-72

5-1-72

+

Filings—Proceedings

Copies mailed Judges Dan M. Russell and

Judge Charles Clark ON 9/30/71).

OPINION: Defendants are entitled to sum-

mary judgment on all issues, filed. (Judge

Charles Clark) (Copies mailed attorneys of

record) (Memo to J. Nall)

SPECIAL CONCURRING OPINION:

The complaint in this case is without merit and

should be dismissed with prejudice without any

assessment of costs, filed. (WHC) (Copies

mailed all attorneys of record) (Memo to J.

Nall)

JUDGMENT: the complaint in the captioned

case is without merit and is dismissed with

prejudice without any assessment of costs, filed

and entered OB 1972, Page 401 (Charles Clark,

DMR, WHC) (Copy mailed attorneys; copy

handed Judge Cox and mailed Judges Russell

and Clark) (Memo to J. Nall & J. Speights)

Final J.S. 6 Card.

Plaintiff’s Notice of Appeal to Supreme Court

of the United States from final judgment of

1-30-72, with certificate of service, filed. (Cer-

tified copy mailed Supreme Court)

_A true copy, I hereby certify.

Rosert C. Tuomas, Clerk

By: /s/ 8S. Carter

Deputy Clerk

—

Unirep States District Court

Sournern District or Mississipp1

Jackson Dtvision

Unitep States or America,

PLAINTIFF,

Vv.

State Tax Commission oF THE

State or Mississipr1; Anny RHOopDEN,

Chairman; Jimmiz Watker, Excise

Commissioner ;. WoopLEy Carr, Ad [Filed November

Valorem Commissioner; KENNETH 3, 1969]

Stewart, Director of the Alcoholic

_ Beverage Control Division, Missis-

sippi State Tax Commission; A. F.

Summer, Attorney General, State

of Mississippi; and the Strate or

MississIPP1,

DEFENDANTS.

COMPLAINT

The United States of America alleges the following:

1. The Court has jurisdiction of this action under 28

U.S.C. 1345.

2. Keesler Air Force Base, the United States Naval

Construction Battalion Center, Columbus Air Force Base,

and the Meridian Naval Air Station are located in the

State of Mississippi.

3. The lands comprising Keesler Air Force Base, the

United States Naval Construction Battalion Center, Co-

lumbus Air Force Base and the Meridian Naval Air Sta-

tion were purchased by the United States with the consent

of the State of Mississippi.

4. The State of Mississippi ceded to the United States

and the United States accepted exclusive jurisdiction over

the lands comprising Keesler Air Force Base and the

United States Naval Construction Battalion Center; and

Keesler Air Force Base and the United States Naval Con-

struction Battalion Center are situated on lands over which

the United States has exclusive jurisdiction.

5. The State of Mississippi ceded to the United States

a 5

and the United States accepted concurrent jurisdiction

over the lands comprising the Columbus Air Force Base

and the Meridian Naval Air Station; and Columbus Air

Force Base and the Meridian Naval Air Station are situ-

ated on lands over which the United States and the State

of Mississippi have concurrent jurisdiction.

6. The Officers’ Open Mess, Noncommissioned Officers’

Open Mess, and the Airmens’ Club of Keesler Air Force

Base; the Officers’ Open Mess and Noncommissioned Offi-

cers’ Open Mess of Columbus Air Force Base; the Com-

missioned Officers’ Mess—Closed, Chief Petty Officers’

Mess—Open, Enlisted Men’s Club, and the Navy Exchange

Department of the United States Naval Construction Bat-

talion Center; and the Chief Petty Officers’ Mess—Open,

the Commissioned Officers’ Mess—Closed, the Commis-

sioned Officers’ Mess—Open, the Navy Exchange Enlisted

Mens’ Club, and the Centralized Package Store at Meridian

Naval Auxilliary Air Station are Instrumentalities of the

United States operating with nonappropriated funds, are

entitled to the sovereign immunities and privileges of the

United States, are located in the State of Mississippi and

are or have been engaged in the purchase of alcoholic

beverages for resale to authorized personnel prescribed

by the Secretaries of the Military Departments concerned.

These agencies are referred to hereinafter as ‘‘Instrumen-

talities of the United States.’’ .

7. Under its enumerated powers concerning regulation

of land and naval forces and military reservations. pur-

suant to Art. I, Sec. 8, Cl. 14 of the Constitution of the

United States, the Congress, in Section 6 of the 1951

Amendments to the Universal Military Training and Serv-

ice Act, 50 U.S.C. App. 473, authorized the Secretary of

Defense ‘‘to make such regulations as he may deem appro-

priate governing the sale, consumption, possession of or

traffic in * * * intoxicating liquors to or by members of the

Armed Forces at or near any camp * * * or other place

primarily occupied by members of the Armed Forces * * *”’.

8. Pursuant to the above cited authority, the Secretary

of Defense issued Department of Defense Directive 1330.15

dated 4 May 1964, 32 CFR 261.4(c). This Directive re-

quires that the purchase of all alcoholic beverages for

resale at any camp, post, station, base or other place pri-

marily occupied by members of the Armed Forces within

a

the United States shall be in such a manner and under

such conditions as shall obtain for the Government of the

United States the most advantageous contract, price and

other factors considered.

9. The Armed Services Procurement Act, 10 U.S.C.

2305(c) requires that a contract be granted to the bidder

whose bid ‘‘will be the most advantageous to the United

States, price and other factors considered.” Although the

Act applies only to appropriated fund activities of the

Armed Services of the United States, its requirement that

procurement be at the most advantageous price has been

adopted by the Secretary of Defense in said Directive as

the governing procurement policy for the aforesaid Instru-

mentalities of the United States.

10. The Directive and procurement policy adopted, from

the Act referred to in Pars..8 and 9 hereinabove require

tae aforessid Instrumentalities of the United States en-

gaged in the purchase of alcoholic beverages for resale to

obtain said alvoholic beverages at the lowest competitive

price most advantegeous to the United States.

11. The State of Mississippi Local Option Alcoholic

Beverage Control I aw, Mississippi Code (1942) Anno-

tated, Section 10265 01 et seq., enacted July 1, 1966, im-

poses strict regulatory control on the possession and sale

of alcoholic beverages within the State and vests the

administration of these provisions in the Alcoholic Bev-

erage Control Division of the Mississippi State Tax

Commission.

12. Sec. 10265-01 et seq. of the Mississippi Code (1942)

Annotated, was enacted after the United States obtained

jurisdiction over the lands upon which the aforesaid In-

strumentalities of the United States are situated, all as

described in paragraphs 4 and 5 hereinabove.

13. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the Mis-

sissippi State Tax Commission promulgated Regulation

No. 22 entitled ‘‘Sales to Military Post Exchanges, etc.,

effective September 1, 1966,’’ hereinafter referred to as

Regulation 22, which attempts to regulate, tax and control

Instrumentalities of the United States located in the State

of Mississippi, which are engaged in the purchase of alco-

holic beverages for resale to authorized personnel pre-

scribed by the Secretaries of the Military Departments

concerned.

ee ELAR MT CREEL MLS FT ETRE ANE ERIS YS FIN

8

14. Regulation 22 requires the aforesaid Instrumentali-

ties of the United States to order alcoholic beverages direct

from the distiller and/or supplier or to purchase them

from the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the Mis-

sissippi State Tax Commission.

15. Regulation 22 further requires the aforesaid Instru-

mentalities of the United States to pay a seventeen percent

‘‘mark-up’’ on distilled spirits and a twenty percent

‘‘mark-up’’ on wine, whether purchases are made directly

from the distiller or from the Alcoholic Beverage Control

Division of the Mississippi State Tax Commission. These

‘‘mark-ups’’ are percentages of the normal wholesale pur-

chase price and are added on to such purchase price.

16. When purchasing alcoholic beverages from distillers

or suppliers, the State of Mississippi requires the aforesaid

Instrumentalities of the United States to pay the afore-

mentioned ‘‘mark-ups”’ to the distillers and/or suppliers

and said distillers and/or suppliers to collect said ‘‘mark-

ups’? and in turn remit them directly to the Alcoholic

Beverage Control Division of the Mississippi State Tax

Commission.

17. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the Mis-

sissippi State Tax Commission requires that the ‘‘mark-

ups’’ be paid by the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the

United States when making purchases directly from dis-

tillers and/or suppliers although the State does not handle

the merchandise in connection with such purchases, does

not provide any facilities, and does not perform any serv-

ices in connection with such purchases, the net result of

Regulation 22 being that the so-called ‘‘mark-ups’’ are in

fact taxes.

18. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the Mis-

sissippi State Tax Commission is not a party to purchases

by the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the United States

from distillers and/or suppliers.

19. Regulation 22 requires distillers and/or suppliers

which sell alcoholic beverages to the Instrumentalities of

the United States located in the State of Mississippi, to

strictly observe said regulation and any distiller and/or

supplier who fails or refuses to strictly observe Regulation

22 is considered to have violated the Alcoholic Beverage

Control Laws of the State of Mississippi and is promptly

deprived of the benefits of same including the right to sell

ww

9

his products to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division, the

sole authorized wholesaler in the State of Mississippi; and

in addition thereto he may be prosecuted for violation

thereof and subjected to criminal penalties therefor. As a

result distillers and/or suppliers, fearful of losing the op-

portunity to sell their products to the agencies of the State

of Mississippi and fearful of criminal prosecution, have

refused and continue to refuse to sell their products to the

aforesaid Instrumentalities of the United States without

collecting from these Instrumentalities the so-called

‘“‘mark-up’’ percentages and remitting them to the said

Division.

20. As a condition for doing business in the State of

Mississippi distillers and/or suppliers are required to fur-

nish the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the State

a price list and to agrce not to sell to any of the aforesaid

Instrumentalities of the United States at a lower price than

to the State of Mississippi.

21. Defendants have sought to require each of the afore-

said Instrumentalities of the United States to obtain an

alcoholic beverage permit from the Alcoholic Beverage

Control Division as a condition to purchasing and selling

alcoholic beverages in the State of Mississippi.

22. Defendants are prohibited by the Federal Constitu-

tion from regulating, taxing and otherwise controlling the

procurement of liquor by Instrumentalities of the United

States located in the State of Mississippi.

23. The aforesaid Instrumentalities of the United States

have made these ‘‘mark-up’’ payments under protest to

the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the Mississippi

State Tax Commission either directly or indirectly through

distillers and/or suppliers in an amount in excess of

$319,740.51 since September 1966 and continue to do so

under protest.

24. The acts of the defendants aforementioned have

caused damage to the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the

United States in an amount in excess of $319,740.51 and

will continue in a proportionate amount or more for the

foreseeable future. Such sums paid and to be paid legally

belong to the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the United

States and not to defendants and the collection thereof

constitutes an unjust enrichment to the defendants at the

SSIES TER IR I FE RRO OT YL LY RL ARE AEE! OE Dt Ae

10

expense of the aforesaid -Instrumentalities of the United

States.

25. Regulation 22, as applied to purchases by the afore-

said Instrumentalities of the United States, is illegal and

void and is prohibited by the Constitution of the United

States because: (a) it is in conflict with the procurement

policy established for Instrumentalities of the United

States by the Secretary of Defense pursuant to authority

vested in him by an Act of Congress; (b) it invades and

interferes with the exercise of powers expressly delegated

by the Constitution of the United States to the Congress;

(c) it infringes the Federal Government’s immunity from

taxation by the States; and (d) the State of Mississippi

is without jurisdiction to apply its laws to the lands upon

which the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the United States

are situated.

WHEREFORE, the United States respectfully prays

that:

1. In accordance with 28 U.S.C. 2284(1), this Court im-

mediately notify the Chief Judge of the United States

Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit that this is an action

to restrain the enforcemént of an order made by an admin-

istrative board or commission acting under state statutes

upon the ground of unconstitutionality within the meaning

of 28 U.S.C. 2881, and request him to designate two other

judges, at least one of whom shall be a Circuit Judge, to

serve as members of the Court to hear and determine this

action.

2. Upon hearing of this action, Regulation 22 be declared

null and void and defendants, their officer, agents, servants,

employees, attorneys, and those persons in active concert

or participation with them, be enjoined and restrained

from regulating, taxing or controlling purchases of alco-

holic beverages by Instrumentalities of the United States,

aforementioned hereinabove, located in the State of Mis-

sissippi, either directly or indirectly through distillers

and/or suppliers doing business with the United States.

3. Upon hearing of this action, there be a judgment in

favor of the United States of America and against all

defendants jointly and severally in the sum of $319,740.51

with interest according to law until paid, which sum has

heretofore been paid under protest to defendants directly

or indirectly as alleged; and there be a further judgment

=v

ait

were

11

in favor of the United States of America and against de-

fendants jointly and severally in a sum certain equal to

the amount which the aforesaid Instrumentalities of the

United States may pay in the future to defendants under

protest directly or indirectly in excess of the $319,750.51

already paid to date as stated hereinabove.

/s/ Robert E. Hauberg

_ United States Attorney

/s/ Joseph E. Brown, Jr.

Assistant United States Attorney

“SPAT PE DS LEON rR Re

12

VERIFICATION

Crry or WasHINGTON

ss

District or CoLuMBIA

Major Thomas V. Ball, being duly sworn, deposes and

says: .

That he is an air force officer on active duty, assigned

to the Office of the Judge Advocate General, United States

Air Force; that he is authorized to act herein and to make

verification on behalf of plaintiff herein; that in accordance

with the duties of his office, he has read the foregoing

complaint and that the matters therein alleged are true as

affiant is informed and verily believes.

/s/ Major Thomas V. Ball

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 14th day of Octo-

ber, 1969.

/s/ Audrey Anne Crump

Notary Public

My commission expires Aug. 31, 1971

~

et See -

ORI PONS

Unirep States District Court

Soutuern District or Mississippi

Jackson Division

[Filed November 3, 1969]

(TitLz Omirrep 1n PRINTING]

APPLICATION FOR CONVENING OF

THREE-JUDGE DISTRICT COURT

Plaintiff, the United States of America, upon the com-

plaint heretofore filed, hereby makes application for hear-

ing of this cause and of the plaintiff’s motion for a

permanent injunction herein before a three-judge district

court as required by Section 2284(1), Title 28, United

States Code, and requests that the Chief Judge of the

United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit be

notified pursuant to Section 2284, Title 28, United States

Code, of presentation of plaintiff’s application for injunc-

tion in order that necessary designation of judges for said

Court may be made.

m /s/ Robert E. Hauberg

United States Attorney

/3/ Joseph E. Brown, Jr.

Assistant United States Attorney

>. PLL NEI SAA IT LOL LE PLA ESI aE

a

Ix tHE Untrep States District CouRT FOR THE

SoutTHERN District oF MISSISSIPPI

Jackson Division

[Filed May 12, 1970]

[TrrLz OMITTED IN PRINTING ]

ANSWER

Come now all of the Defendants in this cause and file

their Answer to the Complaint exhibited against them.

L

The Defendants admit the allegations contained in Para-

graph 1 of the Complaint.

Il.

The Defendants admit the allegations contained in Para-

graph 2 of the Complaint.

Til.

The Defendants admit the allegations contained in Para-

graph 3 of the Complaint.

IV.

The Defendants deny the allegations contained in Para-

graph 4 of the Complaint.

V.

The Defendants admit the allegations contained in Para-

graph 5 of the Complaint.

VI.

The Defendants admit that the clubs named in Para-

graph 6 of the Complaint operated with non-appropriated

funds, are located in the State of Mississippi, are engaged

in the purchase of alcoholic beverages for resale, but deny

that they are operated as instrumentalities of the United

States and are thereby entitled to the sovereign immunities

and privileges of the United States.

14

-_

15

VI.

The Defendants admit that 50 USC App. 473 authorizes

the Secretary of Defense to make regulations but denies

VIII.

The Defendants admit that Department of Defense Di-

rective No. 1330.15, dated 4 May 1964, 32 CFR 261.4(c),

has been issued but deny that it can be interpreted to

authorize the purchase of alcoholic beverages for resale at

any location within the United States without violating the

Twenty-First Amendment to the United States Constitu-

tion.

IX.

The Defendants admit the allegations in the first sen-

tence of Paragraph 9 of the Complaint but deny that the

Secretary of Defense has the authority to extend the pro-

visions of the Armed Services Procurement Act to the

procurement of alcoholic beverages with non-appropriated

funds. The Defendants also deny that the military bases

referred to in the Complaint are instrumentalities of the

United States.

». &

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 10

of the Complaint.

XI.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 11

of the Complaint.

XII.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 12

of the Complaint but deny that the clubs referred to in

Paragraphs 4 and 5 of the Complaint are instrumentalities

of the United States.

16

XIII.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 13

of the Complaint but deny that Regulation 22 attempts to

regulate tax and control instrumentalities of the United

States located in the State of Mississippi, which are en- &

gaged in the purchase of alcoholic beverages for resale to

authorized personnel prescribed by the Secretaries of the

Military Departments concerned.

XIV.

_ The Defendants admit that Regulation 22 requires clubs

to purchase alcoholic beverages direct from the distiller

and/or supplier or to purchase them from the Alcoholic

Beverage Control Division of the State Tax Commission

but denies that the clubs are instrumentalities of the

United States.

XV.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 15

of the Complaint but deny that the clubs are instrumen-

talities of the United States.

XVI.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 16

of the Complaint but deny that the clubs are instrumen-

talities of the United States.

XVII.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 17

of the Complaint.

XVIII.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 18

of the Complaint. as

XIX.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 19

of the Complaint.

17

XX.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 20

of the Complaint.

XXT.

The Defendants admit the allegations of Paragraph 21

of the Complaint.

XXII.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 22

of the Complaint.

XXIII.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 23

of the Complaint.

XXIV.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 24

of the Complaint.

XXV.

The Defendants deny the allegations of Paragraph 25

of the Complaint.

XXVI.

The Defendants deny that the Plaintiff is entitled to any

relief, injunctive or otherwise, based on the allegations of

the Complaint and deny that the Plaintiff is entitled to a

judgment against the Defendants, jointly or severally, in

the sum of $319,740.51, or in any amount.

Respectfully submitted this the 21st day of May, 1970.

STATE TAX COMMISSION OF THE

STATE OF MISSISSIPPI; ARNY RHO.

DEN, Chairman; JIMMY WALKER, Ex-

cise Commissioner; WOODLEY CARR, Ad

Valorem Commissioner; KENNETH STEW.

ART, Director of the Alcoholic Beverage

Control Division, Mississippi State Tax Com-

mission; A. F. SUMMER, Attorney General,

State of Mississippi; and the STATE OF

MISSISSIPPI, Defendants.

i a ao POOP Se aOR Pe BE CMeRRS ELE EE ILE SERIE BOT I

18

By: /s/ Guy N. Rogers

Guy N. Rocgrs,

Assistant Attorney General

One of the Attorneys for Defendants

/s/ Taylor Carlisle

TayLor CARLISLE,

Attorney for the State Tax Commission

/s/ James E. Williams

James E. Wiis,

Attorney for the State Tax Commission

In tHE Unitep Srares District Court FOR THE

SoutHern District or MIssIssIpPi

Jackson Drvision

[Filed September 8, 1970]

(Titte Omitrep 1n Prin tino]

PLAINTIFF’S ANSWER TO

DEFENDANTS’ INTERROGATORIES

Major David M. Lewis, Jr., an Air Force officer, assigned

to the Litigation Division of the Office of the Judge Advo-

cate General, United States Air Force, being duly sworn,

deposes and says that the following Answers to Defend-

ants’ Interrogatories are true to the best of his knowledge,

information and belief.

3, As to each of the fourteen alleged federal instrumen-

talities named in paragraph 6 of the complaint:

(a) When were each of these clubs established and

by what authority?

ANSWER: (1) Keesler Air Korce Base: Under the

authority of Air Force Manual 176-3, Airmen’s Open

Mess, established January 12, 1951; Officers’ Open

Mess, established December 7, 1941; NCO Open Mess,

established July 4, 1946.

(2) Columbus Air Force Base: Although available

records do not provide a specific date, the Officers’

Open Mess, and the Noncommissioned Officers’ Open

Mess, were established sometime between 1951 and

1956 under the authority of Air Force Manual 176-3.

(3) United States Naval Construction Battalion

Center: The Commissioned Officers’ Mess (Closed),

established April 29, 1966, in accordance with authority

granted by the Chief of Naval Personnel by letter ref-

erence PERS-G12 MEB, March 30, 1966; Chief Petty

Officers’ Mess (Open), established July 18, 1966, in

accordance with authority granted by the Chief of

Naval Personnel by letter, reference PERS-G12 MEB

dated July 18, 1966; Navy Exchange Package Store,

established October 20, 1967, in accordance with au-

thority granted by the Secretary of the N avy by letter

ad POMEL CEE SIRT NE OOO EE I IHS NB AN os a

20

dated October 20, 1967; Enlisted Men’s Club, estab-

lished as an integral part of the Navy exchange,

February 21, 1967, in accordance with the Navy Ex-

change Manual.

(4) Naval Air Station, Meridian: Enlisted Men’s

Club, established in 1961 on the approval of the Navy

Resale System Office ; Chief Petty Officers’ Mess, estab-

lished April 1961; Commissioned Officers’ Mess

(Open), established October 6, 1960, by authority of

the Chief of Naval Personnel. The Commissioned

Officers’ Mess~ (Closed) purchases no liquor inde-

pendently and procures wine from the Commissioned

Officers’ Mess (Open). The Centralized Package Store

was discontinued in 1967.

(e) Is club membership confined to members of the

Armed Forces on active duty or does it include mem-

bers of the Reserve Components, Reserve and National

Guard, and retired members of the Armed Forces and

of the Reserve Components?

ANSWER: (1) Keesler Air Force Base: Membership

can be obtained in the Officers’ Open Mess by active

duty personnel and their widows, and by retirees and

their widows. Membership is not available to retired

reservists. Members of the National Guard and re-

servists can apply for membership, but their applica-

tions must be approved on an individual basis by the

Advisory Council before becoming a member.

Membership can be obtained in the NCO Open Mess

by active duty personnel and their widows, retirees and

their widows, and by retired reservists and their wid-

ows. Memberships are not available to members of

reserve components or the National Guard.

Membership can be obtained in the Airmens’ Open |

Mess by active duty personnel and their widows, and”

by personnel (and their widows) medically retired

from active duty. Those who cannot obtain member-

ship in the Airmens’ Open Mess are members of re-

serve components and the Reserve and National Guard.

All enlisted personnel in Grades E-1 to E-3 of all serv-

ices in temporary duty, detached duty, or in transit

status at Keesler Air Force Base can become Asso-

ciate Members.

_—

(2) Columbus Air Force Base: The Officers’ and

NCO Clubs both allow membership to personnel of

Reserve units not on active duty and to retired mem-

bers of the Armed Forces. ,

(3) Naval Construction Battalion Center: The Com-

missioned Officers’ Mess (Closed), the Chief Petty

Officers’ Mess (Open), and the Navy Exchange Pack-

age Store do not operate on a membership basis as

such. The privileges and services of each instrumen-

tality are aVailable depending upon the status ‘of the

individual concerned as determined by Naval Regula-

tions, Directives, Instructions and Manuals. The serv-

ices and- privileges of each instrumentality are avail-

able to members of reserve components and National

Guard on active duty for 72 hours or more, and to

retired members of the Armed Forces on the retired

list with pay, including members of the Fleet Reserve

and Fleet Marine Corps Reserve on active duty. In-

active reserve personnel performing scheduled periods

of inactive duty training drills do not have Package

Store privileges.

(4) Naval Air Station, Meridian: Enlisted Men’s

Club membership is open to personnel of the Armed

Forces on active duty, reserve components, reserve and

National Guard and retired military personnel.

The CPO Mess membership is open to all Chief Petty

Officers on active duty stationed at the Naval Air Sta-

tion at Meridian.

Commissioned Officers’ Mess (Open) membership is

limited to members who are cither active duty military,

retired military, officers of the U.S. Environmental

Science Services Administration and the U.S. Public

Health on active duty or on the retired list with pay,

or unremarried widows of officers of the Armed Forces

of the United States who died while on active duty or

on retired list with pay. ,

21

(h) Are the clubs open to any persons other than

military personnel?

ANSWER: In addition to those members listed in

the Answer to Interrogatory 3(e) above, clubs are open

to their dependents and guests. However, guests are

a eee —_ Se

a

22

not allowed to make any purchase or share in any

expense incurred by their hosts.

* e 2 e e

(s) When did the clubs commence purchasing alco-

holic beverages for resale in packaged form?

ANSWER: (1) Keesler Air Force Base: The Pack-

age Store which operates under the Officers’ Open Mess

began operation in November 1956; the Package Store

which operates under the NCO Open Mess began opera-

tion in November 1957; the Airmens’ Open Mess never

has had a package store operation.

(2) Columbus Air Force Base: The Officers’ Club

and the NCO Club commenced purchasing alcoholic

beverages for resale in package form in January 1957.

(3) U.S. Naval Construction Battalion Center: The

Chief Petty Officers’ Mess (Open) commenced purchas-

ing alcoholic beverages for resale in packaged form

after April 17, 1970. (the Secretary of the Navy had

previously authorized the establishment of such sales

outlets at the Naval Construction Battalion Center by

letter dated October 20, 1967); the Navy Exchange

Package Store commenced purchasing alcoholic bever-

ages for resale in packaged form during November

1967 and commenced selling alcoholic beverages in

packaged form during December 1967; the Commis-

sioned Officers’ Mess (closed) and the Enlisted Mens’

Club do not purchase alcoholic beverages, other than

beer, for resale in packaged form.

(4) Naval Air Station, Meridian: The Enlisted

Mens’ Club has purchased liquor for resale in packaged

form since 1961; the CPO Mess was authorized to re-

sume individual package store sales on September 6,

1968 (club records do not show authorization prior to

that date); the Commissioned Officers’ Mess (Open)

purchased alcoholic beverages for resale in packaged

form from March 1, 1962, to March 31, 1967 and com-

menced the sale of packaged liquor again on August

30, 1968.

(x) Were sales confined to members of the United

States Armed Forces?

ANSWER: In accordance with applicable regulations,

sales were generally confined to active duty personnel

an

es

23

and their widows, and retirees and their widows of the

United States Armed Forces, and in exceptional cir-

cumstances, to military personnel of foreign armed

forces stationed at the installation for training pur-

poses.

/8/ David M. Lewis, Jr.

Davip M. Lewts, Jr.

Major, United States Air Force,

Litigation Division, Office of the

Judge Advocate General, USAF.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 2nd day of Sep-

tember, 1970.

/s/ Angeline Johns

Notary Public

My Commission expires April 14, 1972

—

Unrrep States District Court ror THE SOUTHERN District

oF Mississippi, JAcKsoN Division

([Tirte Omittep IN Printine]

DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT

[Filed February 4,-1971]

Now come the defendants herein by their attorneys and

move the Court for an entry of a summary judgment dis-

missing the complaint with prejudice pursuant to Rule 56

of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The grounds of

the motion are that the admissions on file in the complaint

and in the plaintiff’s answers to interrogatories show that

there is no genuine issue as to the material facts. These

facts may be summarized as follows:

A. AS TO THE CLAIM FOR A MONEY JUDGMENT

1. The indirect payments plaintiff seeks to recover were

made out of non-appropriated funds and passed on by the

military clubs and messes making them to their alcoholic

beverage customers.

2. These payments were directly made by suppliers to

the Mississippi State Tax Commission as a condition of

selling alcoholic beverages to Mississippi customers.

B. AS TO THE CLAIM THAT MISSISSIPPI’S COLLECTION OF ITS

WHOLESALE MARK-UP ON SALES TO MILITARY RETAIL OUTLETS

VIOLATES THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION

1. There is no federal legislative authority for conduct-

ing a military alcoholic beverage business free of state

imposed requirements on purchases made for resale.

2. Since June 6, 1966, there has been no federal ad-

ministrative authority for conducting such a business with-

out complying with state laws controlling such purchases.

3. The transactions in question all require the transpor-

tation of alcoholic beverages within the State of Mississippi

and are, therefore, subject to paragraph 2 of the 21st

Amendment to the United States Constitution.

The factual grounds and legal arguments supporting

ot,

Pes) in ee

eis

25

this motion are more fully set forth in the attached

memorandum.

Respectfully submitted,

A. F. SUMMER, ATTORNEY GENERAL

BY:

/s/ Guy N. Rogers

Guy N. Rocers

Assistant Attorney General

Attorney for Defendants

/s/ James F. Williams

. James KE. WinuiaMms

/s/ Robert L. Wright

Rosert L. Wricut

Attorneys for the Mississippi State Tax

Commission

Unitep States District Court, SouTHERN DistTRICT oF

MississiPPi, JACKSON DIvIsION

[Trrte Omitrep 1n PrintINe]

PLAINTIFF’S CROSS MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT AND OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

[Filed September 28, 1971]

Now comes the plaintiffs in the above entitled action by

their attorney to oppose defendants’ motion for summary

judgment and to move the court for an entry of summary

judgment pursuant to Rule 56 of the Rules of Civil Pro-

cedure for the United States District Courts. The basis

of the cross motion and the opposition to defendants’

motion is that the answer to the complaint of the plaintiff

by the defendant, defendants’ answers to the interroga-

tories posed by the plaintiff, and the stipulation of facts

between plaintiff and defendants indicate that the alle-

gations set forth in the complaint of the United States of

America have not been refuted, that there is no genuine

issue as to any material fact, and that therefore the plain-

tiff, United States of America, should be granted summary

judgment, and entitled to the judgment prayed for in the

complaint as a matter of law.

The issues upon which the cross motion of the plaintiff

for summary judgment is based may be particularized as

follows:

A. The State of Mississippi’s regulatory scheme for

collecting ‘‘markups’’ from the military clubs burdens the

exercise by the United States of its constitutional powers

to maintain the Armed Services.

B. The State of Mississippi through the enforcement of

the ‘‘markups’”’ imposed by Regulation 22, has unlawfully

levied a tax on governmental instrumentalities of the

United States.

C. The state law and its implementing regulations have

no force and effect in areas over which the United States

Government has acquired exclusive jurisdiction (Keesler

Air Force Base and United States Naval Construction

Battalion Center.)

27

The factual basis and substantive legal arguments and

citations supporting this cross motion and opposing de-

fendants’ motion are more fully set forth in the attached

memorandum of law in support of plaintiff’s cross motion

for summary judgment and in opposition to defendants’

motion for summary judgment.

Respectfully submitted,

/8/ Robert E. Hauberg

Rosert E. Havuserc

United States Attorney

Southern District of

Mississippi

Jackson Division

By: /s/ Joseph E. Brown, Jr.

JosepH E. Brown, Jr.

Assistant U.S. Attorney

—

In tHe Unrrep States District Court ror THE SouTHERN

District or Mississippi, J ACKSON Division

[Tite OMITTED IN PrinTInG |

[Filed September 22, 1971]

Strputation or Facts Between PuarntirF Unirep States

oF AMERICA AND DeFenDants State Tax CoMMISSION OF

MISSISSIPPI, ET AL.

The plaintiff United States of America and defendants

State Tax Commission of the State of Mississippi, et al.,

herein stipulate that the following facts are true and cor-

rect, without prejudice to the right of any party to object

to any of said facts as incompetent, immaterial or irrele-

vant evidence in this case:

1. Keesler Air Force Base, the United States Naval

Construction Battalion Center, Columbus Air Force Base,

and the Meridian Naval Air Station are located in the

State of Mississippi.

2. The four bases were purchased by the United States

with the consent of the State of Mississippi.

3. The lands comprising Keesler Air Force Base at

» Biloxi and the United States Naval Construction Battalion

Center at Gulfport, Mississippi were acquired in the fol-

lowing manner: .

(a) Keesler Air Force Base. The main base, which,

comprises 1,061.92 acres, was acquired as follows: 717.20

acres by letter to Governor Fielding L. Wright from Harold

C. Stuart, Assistant Secretary of the Air Force, dated

April 19, 1950, and acknowledged April 24, 1950 (Exhibit

1) ; 344.72 acres by general blank letters of acceptance as

follows: (1) letter to Governor Thomas L. Bailey from

Henry L. Stimson, Secretary of War dated January 9,

1945, and acknowledged January 15, 1945 (Exhibit 2); (2)

letter to Governor Thomas L. Bailey from Henry L. Stim-

son, Secretary of War, dated May 12, 1944, and acknowl-

edged May 15, 1944 (Exhibit 3); (3) letter to Governor

Paul B. Johnson from Henry L. Stimson, Secretary of

War, dated May 26, 1943 and acknowledged June 1, 1943

(Exhibit 4).

(b) U.S. Naval Construction Battalion Center. The lands

were acquired by Declaration of Taking filed by the Secre-

28

29

tary of the Navy in the District Court of the United States

for the Southern Division of the Southern District of

Mississippi, as follows: (1) United States of America v.

911.50 acres, more or less, in Harrison County, Mississippi,

G. B. Dantzler, et al., Civil No. 216, filed on April 30, 1942.

Jurisdiction over this property was accepted on behalf of

the United States by letter to Governor Paul B. Johnson

from James Forrestal, Secretary of the Navy, dated

December 14, 1942, and acknowledged December 29, 1942

(Exhibit 5); (2) United States of America v. 2.4 acres of

land, more or less, in Harrison County, Mississipm, Mrs.

Amna J. Ott, et al., Civil No. 224, filed on November 6, 1942.

Jurisdiction over this land was accepted on behalf of the

United States by letter to Governor Paul B. Johnson from

James Forrestal, Secretary of the Navy, dated December

14, 1942 and acknowledged December 29, 1942 (Exhibit 6).

(3) The United States of America v. 223 acres of land in

Harrison County, Mississippi, Mrs. Gladys Finston, et al.,

Civil No. 285, filed on May 5, 1943. Jurisdiction was ac-

cepted by letter to Governor Dennis Murphree from Ralph

A. Bard, Assistant Secretary of the Navy, dated January

6, 1944 and acknowledged J anuary 9, 1944 (Exhibit 7).

4. Mississippi ceded to the United States and United

States accepted concurrent jurisdiction over the lands

comprising the Columbus Air Force Base and the Meridian

Naval Air Station.

5. The Officers’ Open Mess, Noncommissioned Officers’

Open Mess, and the Airmen’s Club of Keesler Air Force

Base; the Officers’ Open Mess and N oncommissioned

Officers’ Open Mess of Columbus Air Force Base; the Com-

missioned Officers’ Mess—closed, Chief Petty Officers’ Mess

—open, Navy Exchange Enlisted Men’s Club of the United

States Naval Construction Battalion Center; and the Chief

Petty Officers’ Mess—open, the Commissioned Officers’

Mess—closed, the Commissioned Officers’ Mess—open, the

Navy Exchange Enlisted Men’s Club, and the Centralized

Package Store at Meridian Naval Auxiliary Air Station

are all nonappropriated fund instrumentalities established

in accordance with the pertinent regulations of the Air

Force and the Navy.

6. Section 6 of the 1951 Amendments to the Universal

Military Training and Service Act (50 U.S.C. App. 473)

reads as follows:

rn

a

The ‘peepee of Defense is anthorized to make stich

regulations as he tnay deem to be appropriate govern

ing the sale, consumption, possession of of traffic in

heer, wine, or any other intoxicating liqaors to or by

members of the Armed Forces of the National Seenrity

sinning Corps at or near any camp, station, post, or

other Pi ave primarily ocenpied by members of the

Armed Forces ot the National Security Training

Corps. Any person, corporation, partnership, of asso

ciation who knowingly violates the regulations which

tay be made hereander shall, anless otherwise ponish

able under the Uniform Code of Military Jastice, be

deemed gnilty of a misdemeanor and be ponished Wy n

fine of not more than $1000 of imprisonment for not

more than twelve menths, or both.

7. On May 4, 1964, the Seerotary of Nefense iasned

Departinent of Defense Directive 1940.15, which reads ns

follewa :

Btihject: Aleoholie Beverage Control.

References:

(a) Section 6, 1941 Amendments to the Universal

Military Training and Service Act, 4) U.S.0. App.

473.

(h) Dol) Directive 1930.1, “Hegniations for the

Control of Aleoholic Beverages,’’ December 17, 195%

(hereby cancelled).

(e) Dot) Instrnetion 4175.2, ‘“Preehase of Dis.

tilled Spirits for Resale by Military Installations

whith are Located in Monopoly States,’’ April 19,

1956 (hereby cancelled).

1. AUTHORITY AND PURPOSK

Under the anthority contained in reference (a) this

Directive assigns responsitility and establishes mni-

form Department of Defense policy governing the

sale of alewholic beverages.

Ih. APPLICABILITY AND SCOPR:

The provisions A this Directive apply to all Poby

vomnponents and to all persons eligible to patronize

on-base orutles selling aleohotic heverages im the United

States and the District of Cotambia.

a1

Iff. RASPONSIBILITY

A, OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF NRFENEE

The Assistant Secretary of Defense (Manpower)

(AS1(M)) shall be responsible for the administration of

this Directive thronghont the Dof),

fh. MILITARY HRPART MENTS

The Secretaries of the Military Departments shall be

responsible for effectively carrying oat the policies of this

Directive and to make and isene implementing regulations

in accordance with existing applicable laws,

[V. GENERAL, POLICY STATEMENTS

A. 8% OF ALCOMOLIC BEVERAGES

The established policy of the Department of Defense

with respect to controlling the nse of aleoholie heverages

by members of the Armed Forces ja to encmmrage absti

nence, enforce moderation, and mmish over indulgence,

This policy can he carried ont most effectively through

COMMANA zpPervision,

B. RESTRICTIVE CONTROTS AND AFFIRMATIVE MFASTRES

1. Restrictive controls shall he established hy Secretaries

of the Military Pepartment which recognize (as the pri.

mary consideration) the varying conditions and require

ments of military service, yet do not discriminate against

individmals im the Armed Foreee by denying them the

rights and privileges of other citizens.

2. Affirmative measnres zhal] he taken, inelnding bnt not

limited to providing (a) character gnidanee, with emphasis

on the harmfnl effects of the immoderate nse of aleoholie

heverages, nving the advice and assistance of chaplains,

and (bh) wholesome recreation, entertainment, and relaxa-

tion for individuals in the Armed Forcee hoth on and off

station, nsing the initiative and assistance of loeal com-

munities and national organizations.

C, COOPERATION

1. DoD will cooperate with all duly constituted regn-

latory officials (loeal, state and Federal) to the degree that

the duties of snch officials are related to the furtherance of

the terms of this Directive, However, the purchase of all

re

32

alcoholic beverages for resale at any camp, post, station,

base or other place primarily occupied by members of the

Armed Forces within the United States shall he in such a

manner and under such conditions as shall obtain for the

Government the most advantageons contract, price and

other factors considered, withont regard to prices locally

established by state statute or otherwise.

2. This policy of cooperation is not to he eonstrned or

represented as an admission of any legal obligation to

submit to state control.

V. AUTHORIZED SALES

A. OTHER THAN PACK AORD ALCOMOLIC BEVERAGES

Appropriate regulations controlling the sale of

alcoholic beverages dispensed by the drink, or heer

sold in other than sales ontlets for packaged alcoholic

beverages, may he promulgated by the Secretaries of

the Military Departments.

B. SALES OTTLETS FOR PACKAGED) ASLCOROTIC BEVERAGES

The sale of packaged alcoholic heverages, other than

heer, may be anthorized on military installations when

the Secretary of a Military Department approves the

establishment of snch sales outlets after determining

that the anthorization will he heneficial to the morale

of the military community.

1. In arriving at anch determinations, the Secretary

of a Military Department will take cognizance of all

pertment factors melnding the following criteria as

applicable :

(a) Estimated number of anthorized patrons per

ontlet if granted.

(hb) Traportance of estimated contributions of pack-

age store profits to providing, maintaining and operat-

mg elnha, meeses and other recreational activities,

(ce) Availability of wholesome family social elnbs to

rilitary personnel in the local civilian community.

(d) Geographical inconveniences.

(oe) Limitations of non-military sources,

(fy) Diserplimary and control problema dne to reatric-

tions rmnpozed bry local law and regulation.

(g) Highway safety.

33

(h) A digest of the aftitndes of community anthori-

ties or civie organizations toward establishment of a

package sales ontlet.

2. An information copy will he lispatched to the

ASD (M) of each action approving the establishment

of sales ontlets for packaged aleoholie heverages, in

eInding the determinations and findings made in ae

cordance with the criteria az stated above.

3. Controls

(a) Purchase and consumption

Althongh individual rationing will not he required,

installation commanders will maintain A continuing

review of the arnount of aleohalie heverages purchased

in the sales ontlete and the rnmber of anthorized pur.

chasers, Tf snch review indicates that the purchases

equated fo the number of anthorized individnals re

snits in an excessive per capita amount, appropriate

control measures will be instituted to assure compli:

ance with Seetion [TV.A or V.B.3.0, as applicable,

(h) Pricing

Prices in anthorized sales ontlets for packaged al-

coholie beverages shall he within ten per cent (107)

of the lowest prevailing rates of civilian ontlets in the

area. Exceptions will he vranted only npon approval

hy the Seeretary of the cognizant Military Department

upon a substantiated showing, to he made in each Cage,

that special factors warrant an exception thereto.

(ec) Diversion

Diversion, to amauthorized persone of packaged al-

roholie heverage« purchased hy memhers of the Armed

Forces in anthorized anlee ontlete, ic a serions offence

and where enhetantiated will he pnniched,

4, Eligibility for patronage of eales outlets

Kligibility for patronage of sales ontlets for aleo-

holie heverages on military installationa will be roe-

atrieted to anthorized personne! proserihed hy the

Secretaries of the Military Departments.

34 =

VI. IMPLEMENTATION

Within thirty (30) days from the date of this Direc-

tive, the Secretaries of the Military Departments shall

submit to the ADS (M) for approval their proposed

implementing regulations.

VII. CANCELLATIONS

References (b) and (c) are cancelled.

8. On June 9, 1966, the following change 1 to Directive

1330.15 was issued:

The following pen change to DoD Directive 1330.15,

‘Alcoholic Beverage Control,’ May 4, 1964, has been

authorized, effective immediately:

PEN CHANGE to Page 2, Section IV.C.1: Delete

the last clause reading as follows: ‘without regard to

prices locally established by state statute or otherwise.’

9. The following memoranda and letter are certified true

copies from the official files of the Department of Defense

relating to said Directive of June 9, 1966:

(a) Memorandum For Secretaries of the Military De-

partments from Thomas D. Morris, Assistant Secretary of

Defense (Manpower), dated April 15, 1966 (Exhibit 8) ;

(b) Memorandum For: Assistant Secretary of Defense

(Manpower) from Robert H. B. Baldwin, Under Secretary

of the Navy, dated April 22, 1966 (Exhibit 9) ;

(c) Memorandum For: Assistant Secretary of Defense

(Manpower) from Arthur W. Allen, Jr., Deputy Under

Secretary of the Army (Manpower), dated April 26, 1966

(Exhibit 10) ;

(d) Memorandum For The Assistant Secretary of De-

fense (Manpower) from Norman 8. Paul, Under Secretary

of the Air Force, dated April 26, 1966 (Exhibit 11) ;

(e) Memorandum for Mr. Morris from Stephen 8. Jack-

son, dated May 3, 1966 (Exhibit 12) ;

(f) Memorandum for The Deputy Secretary of Defense

from Thomas D. Morris, dated June 8, 1966 (Exhibit 13) ;

(g) Memorandum For The Assistant Secretary of De-

fense (Administration) from the Deputy Secretary of De-

fense, dated June 9, 1966 (Exhibit 14) ;

~ (h) Letter to Mr. Charles B. Buscher, Executive Di-

-

rector, National Alcoholic Beverage Control Association,

from Thomas D. Morris, dated June 27, 1966 (Exhibit 15).

10. Mississippi’s Local Option Alcoholic Beverage Con-

trol Law, Mississippi Code (1942) Annotated, Section

10265-01 et seq., enacted July 1, 1966, a true copy of which

is attached hereto as Exhibit 16, imposes regulatory con-

trol of alcoholic beverages within the State and vests the

administration of these provisions in the Alcoholic Bever-

age Control Division of the Mississippi State Tax Com-

mission.

11. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division promul-

. gated Regulation No. 22, entitled ‘‘Sales to Military Post

Exchanges, etc., Effective September 1, 1966,’’ which reads

as follows:

35

Recuuation No. 22

SALES TO MILITARY POSTS EXCHANGES, ETC, EFFECTIVE

SEPTEMBER 1, 1966

Post Exchanges, Ship Stores and Officers Clubs lo-

cated on military reservations and operated by military

personnel (including those operated by the National

Guard) shall have the option of erdering alcoholic.

beverages direct from the distiller, or by making pur-

chases from the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division

of the State Tax Commission. In the event that an

order is placed by such organization directly with a

distiller a copy of such order shall be immediately

mailed to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of

the State Tax Commission.

All orders of such organization shall bear the usual

wholesale mark up in price but shall be exempt from

all state taxes. The price of such alcoholic beverages

shall be paid by such organizations directly to the dis-

tiller which shall in turn remit the wholesale mark up

to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the State

Tax Commission.

The wholesale mark up on distilled spirits is 17%.

The wholesale mark up on wine is 20%.

This was reissued, without substantial change in content,

as Regulation No. 30, dated September 14, 1970.

12. The nonappropriated fund instrumentalities enu-

merated in Paragraph 6, hereof, elected to purchase all of

a EAE RITES SSELY NTT LSM T MN ARR NRRL HIE AIRE NER Oh OWED

—

36

their alcoholic beverages directly from distillers or suppli-

ers. Under protest, but pursuant to Regulation No. 22

(now Regulation No. 30), they paid the aforementioned

markups to the distillers and/or suppliers, and said distill-

ers and/or suppliers collected the markups and remitted

them directly to the Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Con-

trol Division.

13. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division maintains a

wholesale warehouse for the distribution of alcoholic bev-

erages as a service to purchasers. The wholesale services

and facilities are available both to the military and other

purchasers. The Division is required by law to maintain

these facilities whether they are utilized or not. In in-

stances where the nonappropriated fund instrumentalities

listed the Paragraph 6, hereof, make purchases of alco-

holic beverages direct from distillers located outside the

State of Mississippi with shipment being made direct to

said organizations, the Division does not transport, store,

distribute or perform any other direct service connected

with the purchases.

14. By letter dated May 23, 1967 addressed to ‘‘ All Firms

Selling Alcoholic Beverages to the State of Mississippi,’’

the Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control Division in-

formed such firms as follows:

Subject: Sales to Military Post Exchanges, Ship

Stores and Officers Clubs.

You are hereby advised that the following Regula-

tion issued under authority granted by HB 112, laws

of 1966, has not been suspended or amended, therefore,

all provisions remain in force and shall be strictly

adhered to:

Recuuation No. 22

SALES TO MILITARY POST EXCHANGES, ETC.

EFFECTIVE SEPTEMBER 1, 1966

Post Exchanges, Ship Stores and Officers Clubs lo-

cated on military reservations and operated by military

personnel (including those operated by the National

Guard) shall have the option of ordering alcoholic

beverages direct from the distiller, or by making pur-

chases from the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division

of the State Tax Commission. In the event that an

ae e

37

order is placed by such organization directly with a

distiller a copy of such order shall be immediately

mailed to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of

the State Tax Commission.

All orders of such organization shall bear the usual

wholesale mark up in price but shall be exempt from

all state taxes. The price of such alcoholic beverages

shall be paid by such organizations directly to the dis-

tiller which shall in turn remit the wholesale mark up

to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of the State

Tax Commission.

The wholesale mark up on distilled spirits is 17%.

The wholesale mark up on wine is 20%.”’

Any supplier who fails or refuses to strictly observe

the above Regulation shall be considered as having

violated the Alcoholic Beverage Control laws of Missis-

sippi and promptly deprived of the benefits of same;

and in addition thereto may be prosecuted for violating

the act and subject to the penalties set forth therein.

Submitted by:

/s/ A.V. Breacnam, M.D.,

A. V. Beacuam, M.D., Director.

ce: Commanders of Military Posts located in

Mississippi

(Underscoring so in original).

15. By letter dated June 8, 1967, addressed to ‘‘ Aleoholie

Beverage Suppliers,”’ on the subject of ‘‘Compliance With

Alcoholic Beverage Control Regulation No. 22—Sales To

Military Officers Clubs, Post Exchanges, Ships Stores,

Kte.,’’ the Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control Division

informed such suppliers as follows:

Gentlemen: The mark-up regulatory fee required by

the subject regulation must be remitted directly to this

Division on the date shipments are made to the Mili-

tary base. Said fee must be invoiced to the Military

‘and collected directly from the Military (Club) or other

authorized organization located on the Military base.

Any supplier who ships or sells alcoholic beverages to

Military organizations located within the boundaries of

Mississippi without immediately remitting the fee di-

rectly to the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division of

: PRE He RE A a a a a

me se? SP : SESH :

38

the State Tax Commission and collecting said fee

directly from the said Military organization shall be in

violation of the Alcoholic Beverage Control laws and

regulations issued pursuant thereto. Payments by the

Military organizations into an escrow account in lieu

of payment to the suppliers have not been approved by

the State of Mississippi and any such payments per-

mitted by the suppliers shall subject such suppliers to

penalties as provided by law and regulations. In addi-

tion to penalties imposed by law, products presently

sold by the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division will

be delisted.

If this letter is not completely and perfectly clear we

strongly suggest that you contact this office prior to

accepting further orders.

Yours very truly,

/8/ A. V. BEACHAM, M.D.,

A. V. BEACHAM, M_.D., Director,

Alcoholic Beverage Control Division,

State Tax Commission.

AVB:am

(Underscoring so in original).

16. The Alcoholic Beverage Control Division initially

sought to require the said nonappropriated fund instru-

mentalities to obtain an alcoholic beverage permit from the

Division as a condition to purchasing and selling alcoholic

beverages in the State of Mississippi. After their refusal

to obtain such permit, the Division made no further effort

to enforce this requirement.

17. The amount of the markups paid by the affected

nonappropriated fund instrumentalities to suppliers out-

side the State of Mississippi and remitted by them to the

Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control Division has to-

talled $648,421.92 from September 1966 through July 31,

1971.

18. The following Directives, Regulations and Manuals

govern the operation of the clubs and other nonappro-

priated fund instrumentalities of the Air Force and Navy:

Department of Defense Directive No. 1330.15 dated May

4, 1964, as revised June 9, 1966, and applicable to the non-

appropriated fund instrumentalities of all military depart-

ments (Exhibit 17) ; 4 :

, a 39

Air Force Regulation 34-57, dated December 22, 1970,

entitled, The Control of Alcoholic Beverages: Their Pro-

curement, Sale and Use, with Change 1, dated March 25,

1971 (Exhibit 18) ;

Air Force Regulation 176-1, dated J uly 30, 1968, entitled,

Nonappropriated Funds: Basic Responsibilities, Policies,

and Practices, with Changes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 (Exhibit

19) ;

Air Force Manual 176-3, dated May 12, 1971, entitled

Nonappropriated Funds: Operational Manual for Open

Messes and Other Sundry Associations (Exhibit 20) ;

Navy regulations contained in the Manual for Messes

Ashore, 1962, with Changes 1 through 6 (NAVPERS

15951) (Exhibit 21.).

19. The net profits earned by the aforesaid nonappro-

priated fund instrumentalities listed in Paragraph 6 of

this stipulation, from the sale of alcoholic beverages for the

calendar year 1969 and fiscal year 1971, and the use made

thereof, were as follows:

(1) Keesler Air Force Base: Officers’ Open Mess: 1969

—$51,542.10; 1971—$12,554.78. Used for general mainte-

nance of the club. NCO Open Mess: 1969—$55,348.55; 1971

—$20,684.08. Used for gencral maintenance of the club and

purchase of equipment.

(2) Columbus Air Force Base: Officers’ Club: Fiscal

year 1970, with beer sales included, $11,732.62; 1971—

$12,654.43. Used for general maintenance of the club. NCO

club: 1969—$23,241.23. Used for the general maintenance

of the club. 1971—$15,864.87. Put into special reserve fund

for major improvements and decorations.

(3) U.S, Naval Construction Battalion Center: Commis-

sioned Officers’ Mess—closed: 1971—$1,977; Chief Petty

Officers’ Mess—open: 1971—$17,048. Put into clubs’ re-

serve funds and used for additions and improvements to

the clubs. Enlisted Mens’ Club: 1969—$12,385; 1971 —

Enlisted Mens’ Club (Package store), $8,113; Enlisted

Mens’ Club (Bar sales), $20,027. Profits were held for the

club for entertainment, refurbishment and similar purposes

for improving the club.

(4) Naval Air Station, Meridian: Enlisted Mens’ Club:

1969—$12,385 ; 1971—Enlisted Mens’ Club (Package store),

$4,370; Enlisted Mens’ Club (Bar sales), $12,838. Profits

are held for the club for entertainment, refurbishment and

.

>... es at : FREER RYN OLE IO SNES PR EE

a

40

similar purposes fur improving the eluba; CPO Mess: 1969

— $4,755.29; 1971—$6,204. Profits nsed to help pay wages

and other mess administrative expenses; Commissioned

Officers’ Mess open: 1969 $14,154.45; 1971 $8,620. Put

in eluh’s reserve fund and used for additions and in

provements tu the elnb. .

Y4. The following Interrogatories to the Plaintiff and

the Plaintiff's Answers thereto:

“5 What, if any, reason exists why the personnel

at the four military bees named in paragraph 6 of

the conplaint eannot snpply their legitimate needs for

packaged liquor ty prurehases Prom retail stores

licensed hy the State of Misstssisqnt

Answer. The nature and characteristios of mibitary

service and the circumstances and conditions governing

sich service canse Arined Forces personnel and their

families to form theie own community on the roilitary

installation and to remain separated from the snr

rennding civilian community. Members of the Arrnied

Forres are enbject to military diserpline. Their place

of duty assignment and hors of dnty are fixed on fre

basis of the needs of the service and not npon peracna:

preferences of the individnal. Becanse they share the

sane ontlook and the same working and living condi

liens, Service fatnilies look to each other and fo the

installation to which they are assigned for the satis.

faction of their duty and ff daty needs.

The elihe, including their packaged hemor xtotes,

furtish a necessary andl important service to Arraed

Forces personnel and their farnities, Prey provide

tomvernient facqlities fer vff-dniy dining, entertainment,

relaxation and staneernont. To the military conic ity,

they are the eonnterparts of irene Facilities that are

available to civilians tn the eprilian conamomity.

Beeanse they are comoenionthy lated, are oriented

fy the special needs and cirermetances of Series

families, and sre & partiedar earmark of military

life, they eemtritmte ta the extablizhrnent and marn-

tenance of Service mestale andl esprit de corps.”’

6, What if any, reasem exists why fhe alleged

Federal instrumentalitie: narned in paragraph 6 of the

eonnplaint cannot sappiy the legitimate needa of the

aforesaid personnel withers avvicing payment of the

= _

41

wholesale markap on packaged liqnor reqnired by the

State of Mississippi as to all paekaged liquor aold in

the State?

Answer: Vershors of the Armed Fopens sre ath

tioned at installations and tran: ferred therefrom ns the

needs Of the Seryien Hietate, and not on the base of

personnal preferences, seetise Of theen errenmstances,

it ts desirable From pp marnto standpoimt that each

installytion Prurnich substantially similar off Anty Paeih

ties for its military commnnity, melnding elnbs, pack-

aged hanor stores, ete. This poliey aids in easing the

bnirden and ineonveniones of transfers of personnel

from oneinetallation ty another.

The 17 or percent whojecalo mark npon hqnor im

Mississipyst has a enhetantial effeet on the price at

which if ean he sold on the installation. No other

State hae ench a remmirernont, FF the wholesale mark

nia paid by ¢lohs at inetallatione in Mississipypi,

fheir resale priess wonid he hivher than at elohs Jo

cated on installations in other States thremghont the

conntey. Th wonid he ane factor which would make eery.

ee atinstaliations in Mississipen) less attractive than

im other States and weald detrimentally affeet the

norale of Ariod Sop viee: personnel transferring to

mefailations in the State a? We IES) 1c) ae

/s/ Meyer Seolnick

Vevep Searwree

Attorney for the Plasptiff. Vpited taboo af America

fray N. Rogers

(: ¥ No Rages

Assistant Affarney Ceonegal far the State of Moesie

sipyr.

2/ Robert [,. Wrieht

Roerer —, Wormer

Afttarney far Pyotowdayt Ntate Tar Cop mrecion af

the Stato nt Wiewes pr

a ae Perens a ™ 2 = Saliliaribenon

a

42

ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF DEFENSE

WASHINGTON, D.c. 20301

[seal]

15 April 1966

MANPOWER

MEMORANDUM FOR Seecretaries of the Military De-

partments

Recently, at their request, I conferred with the repre-

sentative of the Association of Control States and members

of the State Control Boards of several States. Mr. Charles

B. Buscher, Executive Director of the National Alcoholic

Beverage Control Association, Inc., requested that the

Department of Defense policy concerning control of alco-

holic beverages be changed to provide that military installa-

tions located in Control States would purchase their alco-

holic beverages from the State wholesale distributors. He

stated that all of the Control States except Montana and

Oregon have now amended their laws to permit a discount

to the military installations. This was strongly endorsed

by all of the State representatives present at the meeting,

and assurances were given that they would negotiate with

the military installation representative and agree to a

price which would result in a fair and reasonable profit to

the installations. This was urged as a means of effecting

better control of alcoholic beverages in their States and

minimize alleged diversion ‘to unauthorized persons.

It was also brought out at the hearing that a bill had been

submitted by the Association and introduced in Congress

which would compel the installations in the Control States

to purchase the liquor from these States. They further

stated that they would much prefer to work out an agree-

ment with the Defense Department as indicated above

rather than press for the bill. Failing to secure such

agreement, they indicated that they would seek to have the

bill passed by the Congress and said they were confident

that sufficient support could be elicited to attain passage.

After a full discussion, I advised them that I would look

into the matter further.

Before any conclusion is made with respect to this pro-

posal, I would appreciate your comments on the following

statement which if approved will be reflected in the present

DoD Directive. +

43

“Tn all of the seventeen (17 ) Control States, frequently

referred to as Monopoly States, except Montana and Ore-

gon, military installations located within such States having

separate package liquor stores on said installations will not

purchase alcoholic beverages from any source other than

the State wholesale distributors until they have contacted

the appropriate officials within the State and undertaken

negotiations as to price. If a mutually agreed upon price

has been arrived at, the installations will purchase their

alcoholic beverages exclusively from the State. Where

there is no package liquor store on an installation, the fore-

going is optional and the purchases may be made from

other sources providing deliveries can be made to the

installation in consonance with the law.

Since price is only one factor in determining the most

advantageous contract for the Government, a price which

is mutually agreed upon and which results in an adequate

profit to the installation is a satisfactory implementation °

of the policy of Section IV.C.1 of DoD Directive 1330.15

even though a lessor price might be secured from a private

source outside of the State involving inconvenience inherent

in transactions and shipments from a distant source.”

Your comments are requested not later than 22 April 1966.

Thomas D. Morris

‘ a Se

px os GF Eee eee, Ce FI eT ee Brie Fx ee ee

~—

44

DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY

OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY

WASHINGTON, D.c. 20350

[seal]

; 22 April 1966

MEMORANDUM FOR ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF

DEFENSE (MANPOWER)

Subj: Proposed change to Department of Defense Direc-

tive No. 1330.15 (Alcoholic Beverage Control)

Ref: (a) ASTSECDEF (Manpower) * 15 Apr 1966

Enel: (1) Purchasing of distilled spirits from monopoly

states

(2) Potential additional costs to Navy and Marine

Corps Messes in Maine, New Hampshire, North

Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Virginia

Reference (a) advised that the National Alcoholic Bev-

erage Control Association had requested that the Depart-

ment of Defense require that military activities in control

states (the seventeen ‘‘monopoly’’ states) purchase their

alcoholic beverages from the State liquor authorities. It

was alleged that this would result in better control of

alcoholic beverages in these States and minimize alleged

diversion to unauthorized persons.

This Association has made similar requests several

times in the past. However, in sympathy with strong

objections from the military services, acquiescence has not

been granted. The Secretary of the Navy again objects to

submitting to the request of this Association, the member-

ship of which is composed of ABC Board members in the

seventeen control states. Furthermore, it is highly doubt-

ful that legislation subjecting Federal Government instru-

mentalities to the state controls proposed by the Associa-

tion would advance any further this year than it has in

past years.

In accordance with sound business practices, most Navy

Messes and Clubs have for over thirty years been pur-

chasing their alcoholic beverage requirements directly from

prime sources, the distillers. Distillers’ representatives

make frequent calls, give advice and assistance, and expe-

dite shipments directly from the factory or regional ware-

houses. Prices are at or near the minimum prices paid by

wa i

the control states, and these very reasonable prices apply ~

to all orders regardless of size. It would be impossible to

have any lower prices or any more convenient method of

purchase than this.

Military activities enforce strict regulations to preclude

diversion to-unauthorized purchasers. The decalcomanias

provide positive identification of each and every bottle; the

signed sales slip with pledge not to resell is a further

check. The 1964 DOD regulation establishing military

package store sales prices within 10% of outside prices

further minimizes the temptation to engage in illicit com-

merce. There is no evidence that there are any better

‘controls’? in, the States of Oregon, Washington, and

Michigan (where we are now forced to buy from State

stores) than elsewhere. On the contrary, those States exact

a markup of from 30 to 70% over the cost to military activi-

ties elsewhere. This increases the operating costs of the

Messes and Clubs, in those States by a tremendous amount.

The results are high prices of drinks and packaged goods

to military personnel, lack of profits for Mess maintenance

and improvements, and a deleterious effect upon military

morale.

Enclosure (1) delineates today’s purchasing procedures

in the control states, based upon data provided by the

Distilled Spirits Institute. Discounts to the military from

the State store retail price are: Michigan, 22% and with-

out tax of 8% ; Oregon, none; Washington, 27%. Thus, the

net markups over costs to State stores imposed upon mili-

tary Messes are estimated to be: Michigan, about 30%;

Oregon, about 70% ; and Washington, about 45%.

If it were assumed that we could reach price agreements

with the other five control states in which Navy and Marine

Corps activities are located and if these State Control

Boards offered a markup of only as little as 30%, the addi-

tional annual costs to the fourteen Navy and Marine Corps

activities in the five states would exceed $2,750,000. Refer

to enclosure (2).

In summary, it is recommended that the proposed change

to DOD Directive No. 1330.15 not be made and that the

Pressures from the National Alcoholic Beverage Control

Association continue to be resisted strongly. Military

Mess purchasing methods of long standing are in accord-

“=

a

46

ance with the free enterprise system, sound business prac-

tices, and DOD purchasing policies. The proposed change

would provide no advantages to the military. The increased

costs would be extremely detrimental to morale.

/s/ Robert H. B. Baldwin

Rosert H. B. BaLpwin

Under Secretary of the Navy

. Montana

New. Hampshire

North Carolina

Ohio

Oregon

Pennsylvania

Utah

Vermont

Virginia

Washington

West Virginia

Wyoming

=. wt”

Board

Markup on

Cost

68.0%

66.5%

50.9%

45.5%

63.2%

60.5%

32.1%

42.5%

50.3%

69.5%

79.4%

62.0%

38.4%

44.0%

77.0%

59.0%

19.1%

47

Discount

to retail

licensees

5%

124%% not

including

8% tax

16%%

PEST AD AOR LONE LBL COS ery pee be at ale Dea)

Purchasing of Distilled Spirits from Monopoly States

State Liquor

How Purchased Now

by Military Activities

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Unknown.

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Navy receives all shipments

from outside state. No ob-

jections.

Military activities must buy

from State liquor stores.

Discount is 22% not includ-

ing 8% tax.

Unknown.

Navy receives all shipments

from outside state. No objec-

tions,

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Military activities must buy

from State liquor stores,

with standard markup and

no discount at all.

Navy receives all shipments

from outside state. No objec-

tions except for one small

base which is not fully ceded.

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Shipments to military from

' outside state are permitted.

Navy receives all shipments

outside state. No objections.

Military activities must buy

from State liquor stores.

Discount is 27%.

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Shipments to military from

outside state are permitted.

Enclosure (1)

DEERE SEALY EERE MELA SLOT 8

snaeianaeeenmemennntinne en

48

Potential Additional Costs to Navy and Marine Corps

Messes in Maine, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Penn-

sylvania, and Virginia

Maine $59,445

New Hampshire 66,015

North Carolina 406,445

Pennsylvania 426,186

Virginia 1,827,904

$2,785,995

Enclosure (2)

wae 49

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY

OFFICE OF THE UNDER SECRETARY

WASHINGTON, D.c. 20310

[seal]

26 April 1966

MEMORANDUM FOR: ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF

DEFENSE (MANPOWER)

SUBJECT: Alcoholic Beverage Procurement

This memorandum provides comments on the changes to

DOD Directive 1330.15 proposed in your memorandum of

15 April 1966, which would encourage procurement of alco-

holic beverages by the military services from wholesale

distributors of the Control or Monopoly States, except

Montana and Oregon.

The net effect of the policy change would be to encourage

procurement of alcoholic beverages in fifteen (15) states, at

prices established by the states, instead of in a competitive,

free market. This would reduce the margin of allowable

profit accruing to officers’ and NCO open messes, or other-

wise require selling price increases. The proposal is con-

trary to the current policy that procurement by nonappro-

priated fund activities shall be in the open market, to the

best advantage of the procuring activity, and by a method

of purchase deemed to be the most favorable to the Govern-

ment. There would be no objection to a provision whereby

the wholesale distributors of Control (Monopoly) States

would be given the opportunity to quote prices in free

competition with private supply sources.

It is strongly recommended that the proposed change to

DOD Directive 1330.15 quoted in your memorandum not be

adopted. As an alternative, the following change is pro-

posed:

“It is the policy of the Department of Defense that

alcoholic beverages procured for sale and consumption

in authorized resale outlets pursuant to this Directive,

be procured at the lowest prices, irrespective of source,

consistent with the preferences of authorized patrons.

Additional transportation and handling costs of pro-

curement from a distant supply source, should be con-

a i i

—,

50

sidered in order to insure that the landed cost at the

point of sale is in fact the lowest cost of goods sold.

‘‘Procurement officers within the United States will

obtain quotations from the wholesale distributors of

Control (Monopoly) States in which delivery is to be

made, in determining the most advantageous source of

alcoholic beverages procured for sale and consumption

at Armed Services installations.’’

/s/ Arthur W. Allen, Jr.

Artnur W. ALLEN, JR.

Deputy Under Secretary of the Army

Manpower

DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE

WASHINGTON

Orrick oF THE Unper Secretary

April 26, 1966

MEMORANDUM FOR THE ASSISTANT SECRETARY

OF DEFENSE (MANPOWER)

SUBJECT: Procurement of Alcoholic Beverages in Con-

‘trol States

Reference is made to your memorandum of 15 April 1966

concerning the above subject.

The proposed addition to DOD Directive 1330.15 strongly

implies that non-appropriated fund activities should buy

alcoholic beverages from state wholesale distributors in

the specified states even though their prices may be higher

than prices on the open market. Economically operated

open messes are among the most important fringe benefits

‘ which contribute to our retention program.

The Air Force opposes any directive which would restrict

negotiating for the best possible price consistent with the

laws of the various control states. We believe that DOD

should take no action to limit the gains which could accrue

to the best advantage of non-appropriated fund activities,

including open messes. In its’ non-appropriated fund

procurements the Air Force, as a general rule, prefers to

follow the Armed Services Procurement Regulation policy

of maximum competition. We believe that the proposed

addition to the Directive would not be consistent with the

principle that all procurements should be on a competitive

basis to the maximum practicable extent.

At the present time there are differing agreements with

the various states. In some instances states permit the Air

Force non-appropriated fund activities to make the most

profitable arrangements for the purchase of alcoholic bev-

erages from wholesalers. Others are much more limiting and

it appears that the Association of Control States desires to

impose greater limitations and to force us to buy from the

control states even when their prices are not competitive.

a

52

We believe the proposed directive would confuse the issue

and set the stage for further controversy.

We recognize that the proposed directive is designed to

prevent legislation which would require our non-appro-

priated fund activities to purchase from certain state whole-

salers regardless of price. We do not believe the revised

directive would over a long period of time preclude an

attempt at such legislation. Nevertheless, if legislation is

pursued by the interested states, the DOD should oppose it.

There is a good chance the legislation will not be pursued,

or if pursued, will not be enacted.

For the above reasons, the Air Force believes the pro-

posed statement should not be incorporated into DOD

Directive 1330.15.

/s/ Norman S. Paul

Norman S. Pav

Under Secretary of the Air Force

ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF DEFENSE

WASHINGTON, D.c. 20301

3 May 1966

[seal]

MANPOWER

MEMORANDUM FOR MR. MORRIS

SUBJECT: Proposal of the Control States Association

In view of the strong opposition of the Department of the

Navy and Air Force, it is recommended that this office not

approve the proposal submitted to the Military Depart-

ments for coordination by this office. While the Army’s

report also opposes the proposal as submitted, it does

recommend a substitute. While this counter-proposal is a

satisfactory one, if it were decided to make such a change in

the Directive, it would undoubtedly meet the same oppo-

sition from the other Departments as the proposal that was

sent to them for coordination.

As an alternative, it is recommended that the Directive be

changed to delete the last clause in Section IV.C.1 of the

Directive which states, ‘‘. . . without regard to prices

locally established by state statute or otherwise.” As you

“recall, this clause was specifically objected to by the Chair-

man of the Pennsylvania Alcoholic Beverage Control Board.

Its deletion would not require negotiation with the Monop-

oly States’ authorities no would it preclude it. If you

agree, I think we could expeditiously get at least a “‘no

objection’’ from the other Military Departments. I Kave

discussed this, together with other factors involved,’ with

General Lampert and he concurs in this suggestion, sub-

ject to your approval.

f you approve, I will prepare the necessary papers to

effect this, including a letter to Mr. Buscher.

/s/ Steve

Steruen S. Jackson

8 JUN 1966

MEMORANDUM FOR THE DEPUTY SECRETARY OF

DEFENSE

Several representatives of the Control States Association

and the Executive Director of the National Alcoholic Bever-

age Control Association met with me recently at their

request. All of the members complained of alleged diver-

sion of alcoholic beverages to unauthorized persons in their

states. They urged that the Department of Defense require

that military installations located in Control States pur-

chase their alcoholic beverages exclusively from the state

wholesale distributor. They pointed out that 15 of these

states had modified their laws to give discounts to the

military and that they would negotiate and agree to prices

which would result in a fair and reasonable profit to the

installations. This was advocated as a means of effecting

control and preventing diversion. It was proposed as an

alternative to legislation submitted by them to Congress

which would require all purchases to be made from the

Control States. Although alleging widespread diversion,

they declined to give information which would permit an

investigation and appropriate action if substantiated.

I sent a memorandum to the three Secretaries emphasizing

the necessity of persistent monitoring of the DoD policy and

Service regulations designed to prevent diversion to unau-

thorized persons.

This was followed by a memorandum from this office out-

lining the proposal and requesting comments. The Air

Force and the Navy reported unqualified opposition to it.

The Army objected to it but proposed an alternative which

would require procurement officers for installations within

the Control States to obtain quotations of prices which

would be considered along with the prices from other

sources.

In lieu of the proposal submitted to the Department, I

suggest the following change in our Directive, a copy of

which is attached.-On page 2, Section IV.C.1, delete the

last clause, ‘‘. . . without regard to prices locally estab-

lished by state statute or otherwise.’’ While I am sure the

Control States would want to go much further, this lan-

guage was particularly objected to by the Chairman of one

of the Alcoholic Beverage Con{rol Boards.

Its deletion would not require nor would it preclude nego-

tiation with the states for the most advantageous contract

to the Government.

Informal coordination with the three Departments resulted

in approval by Navy and Air Force. The Army non-concurs

on the basis that deletion could be misunderstood and might

result in litigation. AGC(M) has no objection to the sug-

gested change to the Directive. He notes that the legal

posture of DOD would not be affected.

Recommend signature of the attached memorandum.

Thomas D. Morris

Attachments

2nd page revised by LtGenJ BLampert/vlm/7Jun66

ec: OASD(M) Files

ASD(M)

9 JUN 1966

MEMORANDUM FOR The Assistant Secretary of Defense

(Administration)

SUBJECT: Deletion of Clause in DoD Directive 1330.15,

May 4, 1964

Please amend DoD Directive 1330.15 by making the follow.

ing deletion:

Page 2, Section IV .C.1, the last clause

“‘without regard to prices locally established by

state statute or otherwise.’’

This change is effective immediately. Action addressees

should be requested to submit two copies of revised im-

plementing regulations to the Assistant Secretary of De-

fense (Manpower) within thirty days.

Deputy

27 JUN 1966

Mr. Charles B. Buscher

Executive Director, National Alcoholic

Beverage Control Association

1000 Connecticut Avenue

Washington, D. C. 20036

Dear Mr. Buscher:

I regret the delay in sending this letter due to matters of

paramount importance, including a trip to South Vietnam.

Since my conference with you and the members of your

Association, I have studied the comments of the military

departments on the proposal recommended by your group.

I have also givén careful consideration to the allegations

of widespread diversion to unauthorized persons of

alcoholic beverages purchased at military outlets.

As to the matter of diversion, I can assure you that this

is a matter of continuing supervision in all of the military

departments through the chain of command from the

Secretary to the field. I know that the Secretaries of the

military departments have recently addressed themselves

to this matter of possible diversion. I am enclosing a

recent Newsletter from the Navy. I should point out that

we can act on specific allegations of diversion by authorities

of an Alcoholic Beverage Control Board only if such details

are revealed that would permit Departments to take appro-

priate action.

As to your proposal, the opposition from the Services is

such as to convince me that its adoption is not in the best

interest of the military departments.

However, in our desire to cooperate with the sovereign

states of the Control Group, we have decided to delete the

last clause in Section IV.C.1.. of DoD Directive 1330.15

(attached). This would meet the specific objection of your

group as submitted by the Chairman of the Pennsylvania

ABC Board. It would also remove any possible implication

that negotiation with a state official must be avoided.

Sincerely,

Thomas D. Morris

Enclosures SSJackson/gse/jg/18 Jun 66

(M) Chron File 3D-281/79158

(M) Reading File

Mr. Jackson

57

= nd,

Supreme Court oF THE UnirTep States

No. 72-350

Unrrep States, APPELLANT,

v.

Strate Tax ComMIssION oF MISSISSIPPI, ET AL.

APPEAL from the United States District Court for the

Southern District of Mississippi.

The statement of jurisdiction in this cause having been

submitted and considered by the Court, probable :

diction is noted.

November 13, 1972

% U.S. Government Printing Office: 1973—492-475/429

58

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.