Supplemental Jurisdictional Statement — Burbank v. Lockheed Air Terminal, Inc.

Supreme Court brief1973

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

INDEX TO APPENDICES

Page

‘Appendix C. Opinion of the United States District”

Court, Central District of California ...App. p. 1

Appendix D. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of

Law of United States District Court, Central Dis-

trict of California an ‘- ...App. p. 35

Appendix E. In the Matter of the Petition of Jor-

SIN ANNU sdisdicanesstincskestedvktivenceinssumtene App. p. 69

‘apreme Court of the United States

* mee October Term, 1971

mart) No. 71- -1637

Tue City OF BURBANK, a mypnicipal corporation; Dr.

-JagvEY GILBERT, Mayor; Ropert R. MCKENzIE,

Vice Mayor; Councilman Grorce W. Haven; Coun-

,ciiman Ropert A. Swanson; Councilman D. VERNER

Gipson; JoserH N. Baker, City Manager; SAMUEL

<GorLICK, City Attorney for the City of Burbank and

Rex R. ANpDREws, Chief of Police of the City of

_ Burbank, Appellants,

LOCKHEED AIR TERMINAL, INC., a corporation, PACIFIC

_ SOUTHWEST AIR LINES, a corporation, and Ar

_ TRANSPORT ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA,

Appellees.

On Appeal From the United States Court of Appeals

for the Ninth Circuit.

SUPPLEMENT TO APPENDIX OF

JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT.

APPENDIX C.

__ Opinion of the United States District Court,

sae Central District of California.

"United States District Court, Central District of Cali-

pieckheed Air Terminal, Inc., a corpotation, and

_Fatific Southwest Air Lines, a corporation, Plaintiffs,

Ps

aa cae

v. The City of Burbank)''a municipal corporation, *

al.

endants, Ait ‘Transport. Association of Ameria,

ning Plaintiff. No. 70-1075-EC.

MEMORANDUM FOR USE IN PREPARATION OF

PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLU.

SIONS OF LAW, and JUDGMENT.

Filed; September 24, 1970. Siew

The ‘within’ ‘action is for declaratory relief and in-

junction’ whereby the plaintiffs seek to invalidate an

Ordinance of ‘the City of Burbank which prohibits the

take-off by jet aircraft from Hollywood-Burbank Air.

port (HBA) between ‘the ‘hours of 11:00 P.M. (2300)

and 7:00 (0700), the next day. © |

The plaintiff Lockheed Air Terminal, Inc., is the

owner and operator of HBA. Plaintiff Pacific South-

west Air Lines (PSA) is an intrastate carrier.

The intervening plaintiff, Air Transport Association

of America (ATA), is an unincorporated trade asso-

ciation consisting of some 32 carriers commonly known

as scheduled airli The members of the Association

fly approximately 2400. planes, the great majority of

which are jet aircraft. . ;

The Federal: Aviation Administration (FAA) has

filed an Amicus Curiae brief in support of the position

of the plaintiffs.

The City of Burbank and certain ‘public officials

are named defendants. The People of the State of Cali-

fornia (California) filed an Amicus Curiae brief in

support of the validity of the Burbank Ordinance

(BuOr). i

The provisions of Section 1331(a) and 1337 of

tle 28, U.S.C., vest this Court with jurisdiction and

seins

Mhe.issues of law involved are:

‘Has the Federal Government so preempted the

‘fields of the use of air space and the regulation

© of air traffic as to invalidate and preclude en-

forcement of the BuOr?

: ‘Is the Ordinance in conflict with Federal statutes

Sor regulations and thereby rendered unenforceable

~~ by the Supremacy Clause?

®. Would, the. enforcement of the Ordinance result

join intolerable and unreasonable burden on inter-

ak state commerce?

@ Does: ‘the Ordinance constitute an attempted regu-

lation .of the phase of the National commerce

i ‘which, because of the need of National uniformity,

ence ot mniaton be peteaiied by

.-» single authority?

“The admitted facts are set forth in the Pre-Trial Con-

ference Order and are as follows:

ot. Plaintiff Lockheed Air Terminal, Inc., (herein-

after: “Lockheed”), is a corporation organized and

“existing under and pursuant to the laws of the State

Delaware and is doing business in the County of

Los Angeles, State of California. Lockheed, at all

‘Material herein, was and is the owner and oper-

_ or of the Hollywood-Burbank Airport

“$2. Plaintiff Pacific Southwest Airlines (hereinafter

“P5A") is a corporation organized and existing under

and pursuant to the laws of the State of California and

“ is doing business in the County of Los Angeles, State

i iecteuing plaintiff Air Transport Association

Nerica (hereinafter “ATA”) is an unincorporated

sills

trade association, the members of. which include virtual

ly all United States scheduled: interstate air Carriers,

Among its 32. members. are.the following scheduled air

Catriers which use. Hollywood-Burbank Airport: Air

West, Inc.; United Air Lines, Inc.; Western Air Lines,

Inc. Among its other members is Continental Air Lines,

Inc., which obtained authority pursuant to Civil Aero.

nautics Board Order No. 70-5-52, issued May 12,

1970, “to engage in air transportation with respect to

persons, property, and mail . . . between the terminal

point Seattle-Tacoma, Wash., the intermediate points

Portland, Oreg., and San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose,

Calif. (to. be served through the Metropolitan Oak.

land International Airport and the San Jose Municipal

Airport), and the terminal point Los Angeles-Ontar-

io-Long Beach-Hollywood-Burbank-Santa Ana-Orange

County, Calif. (to be served through the Ontario Inter-

national Airport, the Long Beach Municipal Airport,

the Hollywood-Burbank Airport, and the Orange

County Airport).”

4. The City of Burbank is a municipal corporation

in the County of Los Angeles, State of California, hav-

ing power to sue and be sued in its own name;

Dr. Jarvey Gilbert is the duly elected Mayor of the

City of Burbank;

Robert R. McKenzie is the duly elected Vice Mayor

of the City of Burbank;

George W. Haven, Robert A. Swanson and D. Ver-

ner Gibson are duly elected Councilmen for the City

of Burbank;

_ Joseph N. Baker is the City Manager of the City. of

Burbank;

Samuel Gorlick is the City Attorney for the City of

Rex R. Andrews is the Chief of Police of the City

of Burbank.

is

snncliiiads

‘The defendants, Gilbert, McKenzie, Haven,

son and Gibson, constitute the City Council for

a “enforce ordinances for the. regulation of specified

satte within the City of Burbank. Defendant Gorlick

bility of of prosecuting violations of ordinances and sir

fiisdemeanors within the City of Burbank. The defend-

ant, Rex R. Andrews, as Chief of Police, is responsible

for and oversees the enforcement of municipal ordi-

ances including the ordinance here in question.

"6. Hollywood-Burbank Airport was dedicated May

), 1930 and has been in continuous use since that

‘time by both private and commercial aircraft. The Air-

‘port provides services to regularly scheduled commer-

‘ial aircraft as well as to privately owned corporate

‘aid general aviation aircraft. Hollywood-Burbank Air-

port occupies approximately 535 acres, approximately

128 of which are owned by the United States Govern-

ment. The Airport lies mainly in the City of Burbank

‘gad partially i in the City of Los Angeles.

7. The City of Burbank has a population of ap-

peorimately 95,000.

~ 8. On March 31, 1970 the City Council of the

City of Burbank duly: and regularly adopted Ordi-

nance No. 2216, which added Section 20-32.1 to the

j Burbank Municipal Code providing as follows: ©

“Sec. 20-32.1. Aircraft Take-Offs.

.. “(a) Pure Jets Prohibited from Taking Off Be-

: tween 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M.

“It shall be unlawful for any person at the con-

trols of a pure jet aircraft to take off from the

ey

‘Hollywood-Burbank: Airport between 11:00 PM:

Of one day and 7:00°A.M. the next day. oa

‘ _“(b) ‘Airport Operator Prohibited from Allow

bi ing Take-Offs.

“It shall be unlawful for the operator of the

‘Hollywood-Burbank Airport to allow a pure jet

aircraft to take off from said airport between

11:00 P.M. of one day and 7:00 A:M. the next

day.

“(¢) Exception: Emergencies.

“This section shall not apply to flights of an

emergency nature if the City’s Police Department

is contacted and the approval of the Watch Com-

mander on duty is obtained before take-off.”

and said ordinance became effective on May 4, 1970,

The stated purpose of the ordinance is “to prohibit

pure jet take-offs at the Hollywood-Burbank Airport

between 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M.”

9. The defendant officials of the City of Burbank

have publicly announced their intention to enforce

the curfew ordinance.

10. As a result of the process of industrialization

and urbanization, almost one out of every twenty peo

ple in the United States lives in the Los Angeles five-

county area.

11. Hollywood-Burbank Airport is the most cot-

venient airport for the entire San Fernando Valley,

Hollywood, and the cities of Burbank, Glendale, Pasa-

dena, and Alhambra, an area containing a population

of over 2.2 million persons.

12. Hollywood-Burbank Airport has two principal

Tunways for the operation of aircraft. These runways

wn Jame

ie: ate compass ‘bending in: tees of xde-

4) The. “rothsouth runway is situated on an

)) The “east-west” runway is situated on an axis

of 070°-250°. This runway is designated Runway 7

‘when it is used by aircraft landing from the west or

‘taking off to the east, and, Runway 25 when it is

| by aircraft landing from the east or taking off to

west. Approximately 2,250 feet of the westernmost

portion of this runway lie on land owned by the United

os Government.

(©) Aircraft landing on Runways 7 and 15 and air-

craft departing on Runways 25 and 33 do not overfly

‘the City of Burbank.

13. The following types of pure jet commercial air-

craft operate from the Hollywood-Burbank Airport:

‘Boeing 727, Boeing 737, Douglas DC-9. The following

_ types of pure jet business aircraft operate from the Air-

‘port: Jetstar, Gulfstream II, Sabreliner, Lear Jet, De-

villand and Falcon.

. Each scheduled interstate air carrier that uses

ywood-Burbank Airport holds an Air Carrier Oper-

g Certificate issued by the Administrator of the

, Which provides as set forth in said Certificate.

2 ny 2

oes

7 a

saan ie

“4S: PSA holdé Certificate of Publié’ Conveniense

and Necessity issued by the California Public Utilities

A maton wrtichs srenides:Seiseesfetetn sald Cac

ficate. © 9)

16. acts, iieanald Miserttene’ ele: eacshee' these

Hollywood-Burbenk Airport holds an‘ Air Carrier Op:

erating Certificate issued: by the Administrator. of the

FAA, which ‘provides as-set forth in said Certificate,

17. “PSA holds a Commercial Operating Certificate

issued by the Administrator of the FAA, which pro-

vides as set forth in said Certificate.

18. The, Administrator of the FAA has issued

Operations Specifications to each regularly scheduled

air carrier that uses Hollywood-Burbank Airport, which

Operations Specifications provide as set forth therein,

19.. Air West operates Douglas DC-9 aircraft at

Hollywood-Burbank. Airport. United has operated

and operates the following types of aircraft at Holly-

wood-Burbank Airport: Boeing 727 and Boeing 737.

Western operates and has operated Boeing 737 air-

craft at Hollywood-Burbank Airport. PSA operates the

following types of aircraft at Hollywood-Burbank Air.

port: Boeing 727, Boeing 737 and Douglas DC-9.

20. Each pilot of ‘a civil aircraft of United States

registry operated in the navigable airspace of the

United States is required to have in his personal pos-

session a current pilot certificate issued by the Adminis-

trator of the FAA (FAR 61.3(a)). Each pilot of an air-

craft operated by a scheduled air carrier at Hollywaod-

Burbank Airport is required to hold a current air

transport pilot certificate issued by the Administrator

(FAR 61/161), Each flight engineer of a civil aircraft

of United States registry is required to have in his pet- i

selon

l possession a current flight engineer’s certificate

id by’ the Administrator (FAR 63.3(b) ).

want to newly enacted federal legislation,

Airport is required to apply for an

ting Certificate issued by the Administra-

"AA pursuant to Section 51(b) of the Air-

ay Barre Act of 1970, Public

Law 91-258, ........ Stat. ‘, (May 21, 1970), within

j fore s from the date Pt enactment.

The FAA operates the Airport Traffic Con-

SF rower and Radar Approach and Departure Con-

“Mol. at Hollywood-Burbank Airport. In connection with

“Mich operation the FAA has expended approximately

billion on the installation of navigational aids at

ywood-Burbank Airport, including the Instrument

jing System (“ILS”), runway and identification

ht: s, and radar and radio equipment.

« Pursuant to the Federal Aviation Act of 1958,

d USC. § 1301, et seg., the Administrator of the

AA has determined that there exists a need for a sys-

fem that will provide adequate separation between and

Orderly control of the air traffic emanating from points

“Within and without the United States and converging on

‘Tatge metropolitan areas and airports, such as Holly-

Wo Airport. Accordingly, the Administrator

has. established a system for the control of air traffic

“Which provides for such separation, and which operates

Within controlled airspace identified as “control zones”

he “control areas.” Control zones encompass all the

“Mitspace from the surface to infinity within five miles

il the geographical center of an airport. Control areas

‘ip of varying elevations and dimensions, and include

} area surrounding Hollywood-Burbank Airport. The

nian

airspace. within @ controk:zone. below an. altitude with

in 2,000 oa aed came nae

airport traffic area must. maintain two-way radio com-

munication with the control tower (FAR 91.87(b)).

is further required to comply with all clearances

: yf issued by Air Traffic

Control (FAR 91:75(b)). Air Traffic Control over

rect’ conitrol ‘of an* FAA’ Air ‘Route Traffic Control

Center ‘and are‘ required to comply with ‘the clearances

received from that facility: (FAR 91:115, 91.75(a)).

‘24. Prior to the commencement of operations in-

volving ao aircraft landings and take-offs on the two

runways at ‘Hollywood-Burbank Airport, a determins-

raha meebo

‘ie

a5. _ No aircraft may taxi at or take off from Holly.

Weeptiate clearance from Air Traffic Control (FAR

M7) When a commercial jet sirratt is ready

for from its terminal gate, it makes radio

: et with Air Traffic Control. It is at that time

| ty nt hy

? to taxi thereto. Prior to taking its position

y runway, the aircraft is given departure clear-

fe; which ‘includes the assignment of departure. pro

a ps and assignment of a radio beam intersection to

h the aircraft is directed to fly. On receiving its

; on nce ‘to take off,.each jet or other large aircraft

& r quired to conform with all FAA take-off proce-

8 and to climb to an altitude of 1,500 feet above

Mbit surtace ee: tapidly bs practicable. (FAR

Aas Departure clearances for IFR aircraft in-

‘@orporate standard instrument departure procedures es-

‘lished for Hollywood-Burbank Airport by the FAA.

‘Pictorial charts showing these standard instrument de-

ture procedures are published by the Department of

bs merce, United States Coast and Geodetic Survey.

ircra taking off from Hollywood-Burbank Airport

st conform with the assigned FAA departure clear-

cnn all standard IFR departure procedures

; ated therein (FAR 91.75(a), 91.116). Upon

feichin, an altitude and position clear of other traffic,

“of the aircraft is passed from Hollywood-Bur-

Daa Control to the FAA Air Route Control

# located at Palmdale, California.

On entering and operating within the

Slew Airport Traffic Area, jets and

large aircraft must be operated at an altitude of

ast 1,500 feet except when further descent is re-

Ne -12—

quired for: a safe landing. (FAR 91.87(d)(2)) ‘No

equipped with electronic devices that monitor the ILS

‘slope and depict ‘the glide slope position in rela

tion to that of the aircraft on the cockpit instrument

it

ii

¢

slope at. the outer

above

ETE

a

Ht

in Part 97 of. the Federal Aviation Regulations.

the Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR 91. 116).

oe

» In the interest of alleviating noise disturbances

iiseeldonts of communities adjoining airports lo-

d in metropolitan areas, the Administrator of the

A has established regulations that (1) require tur-

: Esesered fixed wing aircraft, approaching for

landi to maintain within the airport traffic area an

¢ of at least 1,500 feet above the surface of the

Gan. Perther, dencent. in. raqeind for 0. wale

iading,” and (2) require such aircraft, when taking

‘tif, to climb to 1,500 feet as rapidly as practicable

4FAR 91.87(d), (f)).

"2. From February 1968 until July 12, 1970, PSA

“@erated a Boeing 727 aircraft which departed the

follywood-Burbank Airport at 11:30 P.M. each Sun-

‘day night destined for San Diego. This was the only

regu scheduled flight taking off from Hollywood-

q Airport between the hours of 11:00 P.M.

an 7:00 A.M. This was an intrastate flight originating

Ys California with its final destination San

29. Since March 9, 1970 PSA .has operated a

eing 727 or Boeing 737 aircraft on charter to Lock-

ed. California Company which aircraft departs from

e Burbank Airport Monday through Fri-

: by at 6:40 A.M. destined for Palmdale. This flight is

‘Being permitted to operate by the City as an emergency

30. Several fleets of corporate jet aircraft use Hol-

y od-Burbank Airport as their home base. Prior to

“Mit enactment of the curfew ordinance, there were at

“#east. three flights per week of corporate jet aircraft

“WBtting the now-proscribed curfew period.

‘ciel ais

o Bhs “bockheed Aircraft Corporation -operates: and

maintains sxilisary defense iplant:feeilisies at Hollywood

Burbank Airport.

The pists urge thatthe BuOr is invalid for de

following reasons: 23 "

("The preemption ‘of the field of efficient

“management of the use of the navigable air space

by the Federal Government by statute and regu-

ations and through’ its‘ agencies, FAA and Civil

Aeronautics Board’ (CAB), «=

(b) The direct conflict between the BuOr and

Federal statutes, regulations .and Certificates of

Public Convenience and Necessity issued to air-

- lines by the CAB, and’

(c) ‘The ordinance is an intolerable and un

_ reasonable burden on interstate commerce.

The. defendant City of Burbank and its officials and

the BuOr, The City urges that the Ordinance is in|

reality a “land use” regulation and that Lockheed, ss

the owner and proprietor of HBA, has the authority to

placé valid limitations on take-offs of jet aircraft dur

ing thé curfew and that the City can, in turn, control

Lockheed with respect to its land use.

“Reliance ‘as ‘to land use is\on a statement of the

Senate Committee in 1968 to the effect that it was not

the initent of the Committee, in recommending the si

noise abatement legislation H.R. 3400, to effect any

Sate Ae the ‘existing apportionment of powers be

tween the Federal and State and local governmeals,

whe

te oad

l the effects of aircraft noise through the exer-

“of land use planning and zoning powers was not

‘Giminished by the bill. S.Rep. 1353, July 1, 1968,

US. Code, Congressional and Administrative News,

3 B, pages 2693-94.

th respect to the Commerce Clause, the defend-

‘argue that in considering the effect of the Ordi-

‘Bance on interstate commerce the Court is limited to the

‘fights out of HBA during the curfew hours and that

the intrastate carrier PSA is involved since that is

anly line authorized by the California Public Util-

off during curfew. There are privately owned jet

es that gacd out of HBA between 11:00 P.M. and

PREEMPTION

~The House Report 2360, 85th Congress, 2nd Ses-

‘ion, on the Federal Aviation Act of 1958, states as

its purpose: “The principal purpose of this legislation

‘# to establish a new Federal agency with powers ade-

e to enable it to provide for the safe and efficient

of the navigable airspace by both civil and mili-

Operations.” [Page 3741.]

hat Act.established the Federal Aviation Agency,

‘Federal Aviation Administration, in replacement

then Civil Aeronautics Administration. The FAA

sted with “plenary authority to—(a) Allocate

pe and control its use by both civil and military

J a

e Senate Report 1811 on the 1958 Act, after

g that the action of the CAB in its control over

ce. allocation and air traffic rules rested for the

The defendants rely on Huron Cement Co. v. De-

troit, 362 U.S. 440 (1959), as authority for their

position that intent to preempt shall not be implied

_“* * * unless the act of Congress fairly interpreted

is in actual conflict with the law of the State.”

[Page 443.] }

‘The Supreme Court further observes that in considere-

‘tion of whether a State law has imposed an undue

burden in interstate commerce, we should be mindful

of the fact that the Constitution, when conferring upon

Congress the regulation of commerce, did not intend

“‘* * * to cut the States off from legislating on

all subjects relating to the health, life, and safety

of their citizens, though the legislation might ind:

senile

affect the commerce of the country. Legisla-

tion; in a great variety of ways, may affect

‘s) commerce and persons engaged in it without con-

q@hstituting a regulation of it, within the meaning of

the. Constitution.’ [Citing cases.] But a state may

“¢/;not-impose a burden which materially affects in-

sts igpagabedndbagigpe ein uniformity of

_ regulation is ee, [Citing cases] [Pages

_ 443-44,]

te Detroit Ordinance which was upheld by the

Supreme Court involved smoke abatement, and had

been violated by one of the ships of appellant company

duly licensed to operate ‘in interstate commerce under

‘regulation enacted by Congress. Air pollution is a

local problem and the purpose of the Ordinance was

toprotect the health and enhance the cleanliness of

the local community.

“The Court concluded that the mere possession of a

Fédéral ‘license did not immunize the ship from the

Operation of the normal incidents of police power, not

constituting a direct regulation of commerce. Further-

More, the Ordinance did not exclude a licensed vessel

from the Port of Detroit, “* * * nor does it destroy

ee ne to free passage.” [Pages 447-48. ]

«Applying the rules in the Huron case to the case

@ bar, we must determine whether the Federal Gov-

émiment, as evidenced by the acts of Congress and

re tgulations involved, intends to fully occupy the field

of control of the navigable air space to insure its ef-

Hide “use. Whether the Ordinance brings to bear an

asonable burden on interstate commerce is also

and will be discussed in more de‘ail la‘er in

sill nae

» The question of: intent to fully occupy the pertinent

field -was considered by the Supreme Court in Napier

v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Co., 272 U.S. 605

(1926): TheGeorgia statute there involved required

curtains and automatic fire-box doors on locomotives,

The Court said that the main question in the three

cases which were involved on the appeal was whether

the Boiler Inspection Act

“* * * has occupied the field of regulating loco-

motive equipment used on a highway of interstate

- €ommerce, so as to preclude state legislation. Con-

- , gfess. obviously has power to do so.” [Citing

__ cases. ]

The Court: said that the Interstate Commerce Com-

mission Boiler Inspection Act applied to locomotives in

interstate commerce even if operated wholly within one

State and not engaged in hauling interstate freight.

The Act did not require any particular type of fire-box

door but the Court said that although the Commission

had made no other requirement inconsistent with the

State legislation that fact was without legal signifi-

cance.

“Tt is also urged that, even if the Commission

has power to prescribe an automatic fire-box door

and a cab curtain, it has not done so; and that

it has made no other requirement inconsistent

with the state legislation. This, also, if true, is

without legal significance. The fact that the Con-

mission has not seen fit to exercise its authority

to the full extent conferred, has no bearing upon

the construction of the Act delegating the. power.

: ln answering the question as to whe

povernmr ent acted

ther the Federal

esl

ville Co., 237 U.S: 597; New York Central R,

Co; v. Winfield, 244 U.S. 147; Napier v. Atlantic

Coast Line R. Co., supra. (3) Or the state policy

May produce a result inconsistent with the objec.

tive of the federal statute. Hill v. Florida, 325

U.S. 538. It is often a perplexing question whether

Congress has precluded state action or by the

choice of selective regulatory measures has left

the police power of the States undisturbed except

_as the state and federal regulations collide. Town.

send v. Yeomans, 301 U.S. 441; Kelly v. Washing

ton, 302 U.S. 1; South Carolina Highway Dept. v.

Barnwell Bros., 303 U.S. 177; Union Broker-

age Co. v. Jensen, 322 U.S, 202.” [Underscored

numbers (1), (2) and (3) added.] Pages 230

31.

In applying the rules in the Rice case, supra, to the

case at bar, we consider the facts and circumstances

here involved.

The terms of the 1958 Federal Aviation Act would

appear to encompass the efficient use and control of

the navigable air space in all aspects of its use by air-

craft. Control was effected of the traffic density by

regulation 14 F.C.R. 93.121-31, in limiting the in-

strument flight rules (IFR) operations in high density

airports, Kennedy and LaGuardia (N.Y.), Newark

(N.J.), O'Hare (Chicago), and Washington National

Airport (Wash., D.C.). In limiting the allocations of

flights as to various classes of aircraft, the number of

flights varied during different periods of a twenty-

four hour day.

By way of comment on the regulations applying to

the above named high density airports, it is reported in

tt.

1 Register, Vol. 33, No. 234, page 17896, Dec.

Figet—par 9, that the allocation of flights was to

s relief from excessive delays, not to correct

y problems. At page 17897, the FAA Ad-

tor says: “* * * the public interest in ef-

convenient, and economical air transportation

fequires more effective use of airport and airspace ca-

oa The authority of the FAA to regulate aircraft

‘gperations to reduce congestien is clear. The plenary

jority conferred by the Federal Aviation Act to regu-

he Maho salt to sour te le nd

niga ae ap eine deemaanmmtnal

ed by practice and judicial decision.”

and the Administrator are fully cognizant

problems created by aircraft noise. The Ad-

, on page 17897 of the Federal Register,

| qgpra, refers to the fact that current scheduling prac-

thes reflect that two-thirds of the international passen-

@ flights at Kennedy airport were scheduled to arrive

ee a incon and 11:00 P.M., but that

mder the allocations imposed some re-scheduling of

. flights might be required. He said that interna-

departures fall off abruptly after 10:00 P.M. and

early it would not be in the public interest, consider-

ing resultant noise disturbances, to encourage schedul-

ig of more flights at later hours. The paragraphs

oe 131 of the regulation referred to above appear

q m page 17898 of Volume 33, Federal Register, supra.

In the instant case, the FAA, on September 4, 1969,

ed a noise abatement order for HBA making run-

way No. 25 a preferential runway for departure from

ri £00 P.M. to 7:00, A.M. (Bur. 7100.5B, para. 5c,

Bits’ Ex. 30). This preference was a noise abatement

j a sure for the benefit of the City of Burbank. See

Pe ON

wiioie

Exhibit A hereto for map including the City of Bur

bank and showing the location of HBA. This map isa

portion of plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 1 herein, to which th

Court has added the numbered runways 33 and 25

together with the direction of’ aircraft approach and

take-off on ali four runways involved.

Further efforts of Congress to control and abate ait.

craft noise are encompassed in the provisions of Section

1431, Title 49, United States Code, passed by Congress

in 1968 and providing for the FAA Administrator to

prescribe such rules and regulations he may find neces

sary to control and abate aircraft noises and sonic

boom.

From the broad scope of Federal statutes and regula-

tions governing and controlling the use of air space and

of air traffic, it would appear that Congress intended

to centralize full and dominant control of the navigable

air space in the Federal Government so as to provide

for its safe and most efficient use.

" Included. in the statutes in this field are 49 U.S.C.

§§ 1301(24), 1303, 1304, 1341(a), 1348 and 1508.

It is true that Section 1506 of Title 49, U.S.C., states

that the provisions of Chapter 20 (Title 29, “Federal.

Aviation Program”) are in addition to the remedies then

existing “* * * at common law or by statute.” De

-fendants also point to Senate Report 1353, July 1,

1968, supra, wherein it is stated: “It is not the intent of

the committee in recommending this legislation to ¢f-

fect any change in the existing apportionment. of pow-

ers between the Federal and State local governments.”

Page 2693. It is to be noted that the Senate Report, at

pages 2693 and 2694, also states: “The courts have

held that the Federal Government presently pee

icesliliaiias

of noise regulation insofar as it involves con-

the flight of aircraft, Local noise control legisla-

| mm limiting the permissible noise level of all overfly-

been struck down because it

can Airlines v.. Town of Hempstead, 272 F. Supp. 226

(USDC., E.D., N.Y., 966). The court said, at 231,

‘The legislation operates in an area committed to Fed-

eal care, and noise limiting rules operating as do those

of the ordinance must come from a Federal source.’

HR. 3400 would merely expand the Federal Govern-

ment’s role in a field already preempted. It would not

change this preemption. State and local governments

will remain unable to use their police powers to control

direraft noise by regulating the flight of aircraft.”

aes

In evaluating Section 1506, supra, and the state-

ments of the Senate Committee, we must have in mind

the Tales governing preemption as announced by the

Court and the provisions of the Commerce

Clause of the United States Constitution.

: In Chicago & Southern Air Lines v. Waterman

Steamship Corp., 333 U.S. 103 (1948), the Supreme

Court states at page 107:

_. “Of course, air transportation, water transporta-

_ tion, rail transportation, and motor transportation

M4 all have a kinship in that all are forms of trans-

_. portation and their common features of public car-

_ fiage for hire may be amenable to kindred regu-

_. lations. But these resemblances must not blind us

ie) 10. the fact that legally, as well as literally, air com-

.meree, whether at home or abroad, soared into a

different realm than any that had gone before.

Ancient doctrines of private ownership of the

uae, ¥ eee

air as appurtenant to land ‘titles had to be revised

to make aviation practically serviceable to our so-

ciety. A way of travel which quickly escapes the

bounds of ‘local regulative competence called for

a more penetrating, uniform and exclusive regula.

tion by the nation than had been thought ap-

propriate for the more easily controlled commerce

of the past.” [Emphasis added. ]

Mr. Pyle, Director of Aviation Development Coun-

cil at La Guardia airport, New York City, testified:

“The approach to the solution of problems in air trans

portation at the local level just does not work. It has

to be done on a national basis because it is a national

operation.” [R. Tr, 349.] He also stated that air trans.

portation was to be differentiated from surface trans-

portation because of the variance in the degree of

flexibility between the two.

In viewing the effect of the BuOr with respect to

preemption and the Commerce Clause issues, it appears

that the Ordinance should be considered from the na-

tional level. The Supreme Court so held as to the rail

roads in Chicago vs. Santa Fe, 357 U.S. 77, 86-87

(1957).

The case of American Airlines v. Town of Hemp-

stead, 2712 F. Supp. 226 (D.C., E.D., N.Y., 1966),

involved an Ordinance regulating noise levels which

denied the lower air space to aircraft and closed the

landing approaches and take-off paths of the Hemp

stead airport. The court said that the decisive. ques

tion was whether the Ordinance “* * * conflicted with

Federal law, or invades a field of legislation reserved

to the National government.”

y

nel cee

Wipdiscussing the test of power to enact the Ordi-

“ees: the court states:

“% ~’ “Such an ordinance as Hempstead’s cannot be

© considered inthe accident of its particular circum-

Sostances. * * * In the perspective of power, the

“Ss ordinance must be tested as if it were one of a set

st sone 2 ara a emg town,

and all, taken together, enveloping the airport.

_ © Diversion of the airport traffic over another Town

_. would then be impossible and each ordinance

_. would be revealed in its inner nature as a direct

_, tegulation of aircraft flight. * * * The question

_ Yemains, may the municipalities that surround an

"airport adopt such ordinances’ as Hempstead’s

"which deny to aircraft those parts of the navigable

air space that cannot be used without causing

.. noise on the ground in excess of specified limiting

_.. noise spectra.

“* * * legislation, whatever its purpose, that

|. denies access to navigable air space by local rule

» ¢amnot but be regarded as a plain and forbidden

_. + exertion of the power to regulate commerce as

$3 such. ** *

*y “But even if the commerce clause were not

_ thought without more to preclude local action of

- the kind here involved, the actual exercise by the

* Congress of the power to regulate in this field is

_.. @ pervasive as to preclude valid enactment of the

es Hempstead Ordinance. It would be difficult to

‘Sy -visualize a more comprehensive scheme of com-

bined regulation, subsidization and operational

. participation than that which the Congress has pro-

‘4. vided. in the field of aviation.” [Pages 231-32.]

—26—

and activities of Federal agencies-in the field of air

~s“The federal regulation. of air navigation and

. air traffic is:so-complete that it leaves no room

nance.” : {Citing numerous. cases.] Page 233.

At page 235 the Court says:

“Local initiative in noise control of aviation

is inherently an effort to regulate a consequence

while’ disclaiming regulation of the cause. It can-

not coexist with a comprehensive system of fed-

eral regulation of aircraft manufacture (through

‘ certificates of airworthiness) and federal regula-

. tion of air navigation and air traffic.”

VIOLATION OF COMMERCE CLAUSE

Congress is vested with the authority to regulate com-

merce among the States by Article I, Section 8, Clause

3, of the Constitution. The rule is well established that

state and local governments may not unreasonably bur-

den commerce by their acts. The BuOr, while it does

not seek to completely deny the use of navigable air

space; does: seek to eliminate its use by jet aircraft

og RE IE RON

‘Continental Airlines, an interstate carrier by virtue

of Cértificate of Public Convenience and Necessity is-

sued by the CAB on May 12, 1970, Exhibit 9, now

serves the Hollywood-Burbank ‘area from the HBA. One

of its scheduled routes ‘is from Burbank to Seattle -and

feturn, ‘The evidence shows that if Seattle impdsed an

‘otdinance ‘similar to the BuOr no jet aircraft could

leave Seattle, or any city inthe Northwest, for HBA after

0 P.M., icicuieies ie“tegui NN Olle Oéate

et P.M., inorder to arrive at the respective

ir s before the nocturnal curfew hour of 11:00

{. Thus, with such an Ordinance in effect in only

fights to and from Seattle would be curtailed to

‘taly twelve hours of the day, not eight hours as in

‘the case of the curfew in force at only one of the air-

The Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity

y issued to scheduled airlines by the CAB authorizes

‘them to fly a specific route or routes and also obligates

‘the line to give adequate service to the cities on their

‘Engineering, of Air Transport Association of America,

ified that a curfew Ordinance, if valid, would be

of ed by virtually all types of local airport author-

ites. [R, Tr. 322.] Mr. Pyle testified in similar vein.

q Tr. 334.]

* The noise problem created by jet aircraft is well

wn and it appears to the Court that a curfew Ordi-

ice, if valid, would promptly be adopted by virtual-

all cities surrounding airports. Considered singly,

h an Ordinance might not impose an unlawful in-

srence with interstate commerce in all cases. How-

, considered on a national level, the Ordinance

Id not stand. Based on authorities discussed herein-

Wwe, the Court concludes, as noted above, that in

mining the effect on commerce the Ordinance is

be considered on a national basis. Mr. Mitchell,

President of Continental Airlines in charge of cor-

it ¢ planning, Mr. Pyle, and General Von Kann,

tified in depth on the effect of such an Ordinance,

ei Ay

2h

—28—

on a-national basis, .on interstate’ commerce as well as

oft the efficient use of the air space, Some 1009 flights

of scheduled:airlines would have to be eliminated or re

scheduled: [Exhibit 52,'R. Tr. 103-06. ] Position prob-

lems as to planes would eliminate 1370-odd additional

flight'operations. [R. Tr. 336.]

Approximately’ 48% of air mail and 42% of air

freight is moved at night.’[Exhibit 55, R. Tr. 337-39.]

It should be noted that no air mail is flown out of

If the experience of Continental is average, the Ord

nance on a national basis would increase costs by 25%

(R. Tr. 261-63) by reason of the loss in the utilization

of aircraft as well as the required purchase of new

planesto meét the concentration of flights within the

permitted ‘hours of. take-off, if, in fact, the re-schedul-

ing of flights so eliminated could be accomplished from

a practical standpoint. Additional maintenance shops

would »also: have to’ be established. by all airlines to

accomplish the required maintenance at necessary lo

cations for proper and efficient use of their planes.

fR. Tr. 302-305.} i

‘. Jt“appears from the evidence that there would be a

very serious loss of efficiency as to the use of air space

if a national curfew were imposed. Obviously, if the use

4); where the Court held the State of Illinois was

out authority to revoke or suspend operations in

‘state of an interstate motor carrier for violation of

w regulating the weight of loads to be carried on

e state’s highways. Southern Pacific v. Arizona, 325

LS.°761, 767 and 775 (1945), where the Supreme

Court held invalid an Arizona Ordinance regulating the

- Sength of trains, the Court observing that if one state

“toay regulate train lengths so may all others, resulting

nas serious impediment to the free flow of commerce.

_ ‘There is no conflict in the evidence adduced in this

ease: and it should be concluded that air commerce, by

“Feason of its speed and volume, requires a single au-

thority in control if it is to be conducted at maximum

‘safety and efficient use of the navigable air space.

as e evidence discloses that air traffic is unique and

- thould be controlled on the national level.

~ ‘The case of Stagg v. Municipal Court of Santa

‘Mon ca, 82 Cal. Rptr. 578 (Dec., 1969), is relied on

by. the defendants in support of their contention that

there is no preemption by the Federal Government of

the field covered by the BuOr so as to make the Ordi-

“Rance invalid and unenforceable.

the Santa Monica Airport (SMA), which was in-

d, was city owned and the California District

wt of Appeals (DCA) held a curfew Ordinance

pied by the City of Santa Monica, which precluded

from taking off from the SMA between

‘hours of 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M. the next

to be valid. The SMA is not used by scheduled

astate airlines. The Appellate Court reversed the

etior Court’s ruling that “* * * the Ordinance was

Walid because its subject matter was preempted by

stati

State law.” The DCA: held that the field was not so

preempted and in the instant case the Attorney General

also: asserts non-preemption of the field by the State,

At page 579 of its opinion, the DCA, in referring to

the Superior Court, says: -

~ “The court found it tiianecessary to decide

’ “owhether there was any federal preemption.”

It observes two paragraphs later:

..... “Preliminarily, it must be recognized that the

- doctrine of federal preemption has no application

here.” .

~The opinion ol the. DCA, 28 to. prrewation, appears

to turn on its conclusion that the curfew Ordinance

was an unreasonable regulation which only incidental-

ly affected the right of flight but did not impair that

right. The Court, after stating its research, disclosed

no Federal or California enactment which directly con-

flicts with the Ordinance in question, states:

: ““Phe United States by virtue of its sovereignty

‘Over navigable airspace has the paramount power to

‘fegulate air traffic. Federal statutes, after defin-

ing navigable airspace * * *, authorize the ad-

ministrator to regulate the use of navigable air-

space and to establish rules governing the flight,

Navigation, protection and identification of air-

craft.” [Page 580.} x

“The Court did not ground its decision on the pro

prietary capacity of the city but did discuss the city's

Tights to regulate its municipally owned airport as a

public utility and the authority of the city to regulate

the use of the airport under Section 50470-74, Cali-

fornia Government Code. [Pages 580-81.)

cides

oma Portal Civic Club v. American Airlines, Inc.,

al. Rptr. 708 (1964), a decision of the California

eme Court in bank, is cited and discussed by

DCA in the Stagg case, supra. The members of

ie Loma Portal Civic Club resided in the flight path

of jet aircraft using adjacent Lindbergh Field in San

Diego. They sought to prohibit such flights at low alti-

= and at such times as to interfere unreasonably

‘with the use and enjoyment. by plaintiffs of their

homes.

| The Court denied injunctive relief but did not find

: ion on the part of the Federal Government as

; ‘g grounds for precluding the relief sought. In denying

‘telief, the Court said:

a “It is clear, therefore, that it would be con-

© trary to the policy of this state to grant an injunc-

Pa tion against flight operations in the vicinity of a

- public airport, conducted by regularly scheduled,

~ - certificated airlines, not alleged to be conducted

. in violation of federal orders and regulations or

in an imminently dangerous manner, and not al-

x p leued to be carried on in a manner inconsistent

with the public interest inhering in the continua-

tion of such service.

o mates ie oe

ess ee & zs

* * *

“We hold here that under the facts of this case,

ie., the operation of aircraft with federal air-

worthiness certificates in federally-certificated,

scheduled passenger service, in conformity with

federal safety regulations, in a manner not creat-

ing imminent danger, and in furtherance of the

public interest in safe, regular air transportation

of goods and passengers, an injunction is not

» available.” [Pages 713-14.]

Site

ae,

“Reference is:also: made by the Court to the right of

landowners who suffer from aircraft annoyances to seek

damages; from the owner or operator of the aircraft or

the::owner: or! operator of -the..airport involved, . It

also points out that itis not making a determination

with ‘respect: to. the rights ofthe parties where private

airplanes and airports are concerned, [Pages 714, 715-

16.] sts

ne Conitt ta cd riehtcane ‘Aibtines'v. Town of Hemp.

stead, 272 F. Supp. 226, supra, also discussed the right

of landlords to -just compensation if overflights are of

such a mature as to amount to a taking of property for

public purposes. [Page 231.]

Prior to the decision in the Stagg case, supra, the

City Attorney of Burbank rendered an exhaustive opin-

ion to the ‘Burbank .City Manager, dated September

22; 1969, wherein ‘he concluded that the City of Bur-

bank -had no power to limit or restrict flights of air-

craft utilizing HBA; Copy of the opinion appears as

Exhibit A to the supplemental memorandum of points

and authorities: filed a Lockheed and PSA

on May 22, 1970...

‘The City Attorney now dacbidin’ that his conclusion

was based on the theory that ‘the State of California

had preempted the area of restriction of flights and

amount of noise emitted by jet aircraft. However, on

page two of the opinion, the City Attorney says:

“The City of Burbank has no power to establish re-

' strictions on’ flights or the amount of noise which may

be emitted by aircraft using the Hollywood-Burbank

airport for the reason that this area of control has bees

preempted by the State:and Federal governments.”

The opinion discusses several of the cases cited by

counsel on both sides in the case at bar‘és well as the.

mn i

*s of the Federal Government in the field in-

, summarizing the opinion it is said, the residents

yicinity of the HBA should limit their complaints

: ckheed Air Terminal and present their views as

ee ney Coates a ar beeeere

of the State of California and that legislative

can only be accomplished by the Congress of

the United States or the State Legislature.

"The problems created by noise from jet aircraft are

serious and disturbing, to say the least. Effective means

‘has not as yet been found to reduce the noise to de-

fired sound levels. In some airports the required use of

‘Gertain runways in take-off will send the aircraft out

\ “gver the ocean or other non-populated areas. However,

im the landlocked, thickly populated area in which

: H BA is located, the use of preferential noise abatement

“minways is helpful to reduce the noise over Burbank

‘Jat it merely diverts it to other populated areas. It

‘Will be noted from Exhibit A hereto that planes taking

‘off on runway 25 are not over Burbank at any time,

“fad the evidence shows that those taking off on run-

“way 15, with destination to the North, turn West after

take-off and are in the Burbank air space but for a

ry short time.

ya scien‘ific and mechanical expertise has not yet

“wlved the problem of noise resulting from the genera-

of power by jet engines. However, if the time dur-

ich the navigable air space may be used is to

sd, the Court concludes that the action must

: from Congress, or its authorized agency, if. the

‘land efficient use of the air space is to be main-

Mined and interstate commerce protected from unrea-

table burden and interference.

7

—34— .

The: plaintiffs ‘are’ entitled to injunctive relict)

prayed, and for their costs of suit herein. tes

ae are requested to prepare, serye

and lodge proposed Findings’ of Fact, Conclusions of

Law and Judgment in accordance with the provisions

ofLocalRule7. = = ,

This Memorandum is not to be deemed a final judg.

ment. |

DATED: September 24, 1970,

/s/ E.-Avery Crary

B. Avery’Crary

United States District Judge

1 a er C re : . 4 ASF. = AS wy z ae aug,

a ay HSy S re NS ; iy

we — Lae itive ifs

nuit

| eg } Rin

A ’ .

at ae . \ ix 3 re] | = Ss

4 18} K

A a a ROR Vi {i ]

SAT HES peat Net

ie a > ' =p q Y et a

‘ - \ ie 4 t re |

a j * ve a 4 “i. tat .

add ‘ f l F |

Rite . >

— = ium : x

— 5,

APPENDIX D.

s of Fact and Conclusions of Law of United

6 District Court, Central District of California.

ited States District Court, Central District of Cali-

Lockheed Air Terminal, Inc., a corporation, and

#& Southwest Air Lines, a corporation, Plaintiffs,

ys. The City of Burbank, a a corporation, et

al., Defendants. ’

__ Air Transport Association of America, Intervening ©

Plaintiff. No. 70-1075-EC. .

FINDINGS OF FACT AND

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

" Filed: November 30, 1970.

.. The within action having come on regularly for trial

on September 15, 1970, before the Honorable E. Avery

Crary, Judge presiding, plaintiffs Lockheed Air Ter-

minal, Inc. and Pacific Southwest Airlines being repre-

sented by Kirtland & Packard, Robert C. Packard

and Winston F. Tyler, intervening plaintiff Air Trans-

port Association of America being represented by

O'Melveny & Myers, Warren Christopher, Ralph W.

Dau and Bertrand M. Cooper, and defendants all

‘being represented by Samuel Gorlick, City Attorney,

Richard L. Sieg, Jr., and Michael R. Murnane, except

‘that defendant Samuel Gorlick is represented by As-

‘fbtant City Attorney Richard L. Sieg, Jr., whereupon

_ tyidetice both oral and documentary having been in-

toduced by all parties, the cause having been argued

Std submitted for decision, and the Court on Septem-

ber + 24, 1970 having filed its Memorandum for Use

iti Preparation of Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclu-

ie

sions of Law, and Judgment, whereupon plaintiffs and

- intervening plaintiff having submitted Proposed Find-

ings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and Judgment,

defendants having filed their objections thereto and

having requested additional findings, and the Court

having heard the argument of counsel thereon;

WHEREFORE, the Court being fully advised in the

premises now renders its decision as follows:

FINDINGS OF FACT

1. Plaintiff Lockheed Air Terminal, Inc. (herein-

after “Lockheed”) is a corporation organized and ex-

isting under and pursuant to the laws of the State of

Delaware and is doing business in the County of Los

Angeles, State of California. Lockheed, at all times

material herein, was and is the operator of the Holly-

wood-Burbank Airport and the owner of all but those

portions of the Airport Described in Findings Nos. 6

and 18 which are held under lease from the federal

government.

2. Plaintiff Pacific Southwest Airlines (hereinafter

“PSA”) is a corporation organized and existing under

and pursuant to the laws of the State of California and

is doing business in the County of Los Angeles, State

of California. —

3. Intervening plaintiff Air Transport Association

.of America (hereinafter “ATA”) is an unincorporated

trade association, the members of which include vir-

tually all United States scheduled interstate air carriers.

Among its 32 members are the following scheduled’air

carriers which use Hollywood-Burbank Airport: Air

West, Inc.; Continental Air Lines, Inc.; United Air

Lines, Inc.; and Western Air Lines, Inc.

<

<4. -The City of Burbank is a municipal corpora-

ion in the County of Los Angeles, State of California,

‘having power to sue and be sued in its own name;

cast Dr. Jarvey Gilbert is the duly elected Mayor of

_. the City of Burbank;

«© Robert R. McKenzie is the duly elected Vice

Mayor of the City of Burbank;

George W. Haven, Robert A. Swanson and D.

~~. Nerner Gibson are duly elected Councilmen for

a < the City of Burbank;

Joseph N. Baker is the City Manager of the

City of Burbank;

_. Samuel wichimde is the City Attorney for the City

> of Burt

Rex R. hudioen is the Chief of Police of the

City of Burbank.

oe The defendants Gilbert, McKenzie, Haven, Swan-

ton and Gibson constitute the City-Council for the City

of Burbank and have the authority to enact and en-

force ordinances for the regulation of specified matters

‘within the City of Burbank. Defendant Gorlick and

the attorneys within his office have the responsibility

‘of prosecuting violations of ordinances and other

mis within the City of Burbank. The defend-

ant Rex R. Andrews, as Chief of Police, is responsible

for and oversees the enforcement of municipal ordi-

“Dances including the ordinance here in question.

6 Hollywood-Burbank Airport was dedicated May

30, 1930, and has been in continuous use since that

¢ by, both private and commercial aircraft. The Air-

t provides services to regularly scheduled commercial

aft as well as to privately owned corporate and

-“

-

wiscileinen

general aviation~ aircraft. Hollywood-Burbank Airport

occupies approximately 535 acres, approximately 128

of which are owned by the United States Government,

The Airport lies mainly in:the City of Burbank and par.

tially in the City of Los Angeles...

war a

proximately 95,000. ».

8. On>March 31, 1970, the City Council of the

City of-Burbank duly and regularly adopted Ordinance

No. 2216, which added Section 20-32.1 to. the Bur-

_ bank Municipal Code providing as follows:

“Sec. 20-32.1. Aircraft Take-Offs.

“(a) Pure Jets Prohibited from Taking Off Be-

tween 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M.

“It shall be unlawful for any person at the

controls of a pure jet aircraft to take off from

the Hollywood-Burbank Airport between 11:00

P.M. of one day and 7:00 A.M. the next day.

“(b) Airport Operator Prohibited from Allow-

ing Take-Offs.

“It shall be unlawful for the operator of the

Hollywood-Burbank Airport to allow a pure jet

aircraft to take off from said airport between

11:00 P.M. of one day and 7:00 A.M. the next

day. :

“(c) Exceptions: Emergencies.

. “This .section shall not apply to flights of an

emergency nature if the City’s Police Department

is contacted and the approval of the Watch Com-

mander on duty is obtained before take-off.”

and said ordinance became effective on May 4, 1970.

re

seviniltines

‘stated purpose of the ordinance is “to prohibit pure

ce-offs at the Hollywood-Burbank Airport between

"7800 P.M. and 7:00 A.M.”

499. The defendant officials of the City of Burbank

‘have publicly announced their intention to enforce the

curfew ordinance.

80. Almost one of every twenty people in the

United States lives in the Los Angeles five-county area.

This-area ‘is served by scheduled air carriers conduct-

ing operations from the Los Angeles International Air-

port and from four “satellite” airports: Hollywood-Bur-

bank Airport, Long Beach Metropolitan Airport,

‘Orange County Airport. and Ontario International Air-

Port.

SH. : Satellite airports are airports that serve geo-

graphical areas immediately adjacent to major metro-

Politan areas which also have one or more hub or ma-

jor airport facilities. Other examples of satellite air-

ports are the Oakland International Airport and San

Jose Municipal Airport in the San Francisco area.

- 42. All of the above named satellite airports are sur-

founded by reasonably well-defined geographical areas

which, ‘by reason of the population they serve and

their stage of urban development, warrant additional

tir services in their own right. Many persons living in

thése various geographical areas find it more conven-

ient and responsive to their needs to have air service

Provided through their respective satellite airports than

continue their dependence upon the hubs.

ae Satellite airports play an essential role in the

ional air transportation system in relieving air and

nd congestion, in reducing air traffic delays at

fy airport centers, and in providing more con-

—49—

venient service to the: surrounding population centers,

which are of sufficient size and economic power tp

justify their own air service. This important role has

been and is recognized and implemented by the Civil

Aeronautics Board in its route investigations.

14. Hollywood-Burbank Airport is an important

satellite airport in. the national air transportation sys

tem and forms a vital: linkin interstate and intrastate

air commerce. It is the most convenient airport in the

-greaterLos Angeles metropolitan area for the entire

San Fernando: Valley, Hollywood and the cities of Bur-

bank, Glendale, Pasadena and Alhambra, an area con-

taining a population of over 2.2 million persons.

15. The Burbank City Council has on several oc-

casions, and as recently as May 13, 1969, requested

and supported additional air transportation services at

the Hollywood-Burbank Airport in various route pro-

ceedings before the Civil Aeronautics Board and the

California Public Utilities Commission.

16. On May 12, 1970, in its Pacific Northwest:

California Investigation, Docket No. 18884, the Civil

Aeronautics Board determined that additional air serv-

ice was required between the Pacific Northwest and

the Los Angeles metropolitan area. The Board

awarded a new route to Continental Air Lines and

provided that this additional service be provided

through the satellite airports in the Los Angeles metro

politan area, including Hollywood-Burbank Airport.

The Mayor and City Council of Burbank expressly

requested and. supported this award of additional air

service. at Hollywood-Burbank Airport.

'_ ¥7. -Hollywood-Burbank Airport is included in the

National Airport Plan promulgated by the Adminis 3

vil Reon

“ttator of the Federal Aviation Administration (herein-

after “FAA”) pursuant to the Federal Airport Act of

1946, Ch. 261, 60 Stat. 170.

ot “48. Hollywood-Burbank Airport has two prin-

Gipal runways for the operation of aircraft. These run-

“Ways are gees by their compass heading in tens

- of degrees.

~.-~ (a) The “north-south” runway is situated on an

axis of 330°-150°. This runway is designated

an ‘Runway 33 when it is used by aircraft taking off

»~ to the northwest or landing from the southeast,

= .and, Runway 15 when it is used by aircraft land-

_ ing from the northwest or taking off to the south-

»- east. Approximately 2,050 feet of the northern-

- most portion of this runway lie in the City of Los

_ Angeles on land owned by the United States Gov-

. . (b) The “east-west” runway is situated on an

. axis of .070°-250°. This runway is designated

Runway 7 when it is used by aircraft landing

_... from the west or taking off to the east, and Run-

- way 25 when it is used by aircraft landing from

_ the east or taking off to the west. Approximately

_. 2,250 feet of the westernmost portion of this run-

see, Way lies on land owned by the United States Gov-

= emment. }

(c) Aircraft landing on Runways 7 and 15

and aircraft departing on Runways 25 and 33

a do not overfly the City of Burbank.

9. Prior to the commencement of operations in-

ing jet aircraft landings and takeoffs on the two

sways at Hollywood-Burbank Airport, a deter-

iiation was made by the FAA that such use of each

nonlin

runway would: not be. unsafe either to persons or prop.

Ae SNM NANT ee

air.

« 20. In' 1969: there, were, appranienstely. 32,000 sir

carries snovesnents at nk Airport sery-

ing 1,178,000. commercial, passengers in interstate and

intrastate transportation. Approximately 97% of these

operations were conducted by pure jet aircraft.

21.. No air mail is presently carried to or from the

pe eR a ee kaa aap eemgmamt:

the airport’s facilities.

a“ Tal chi “thigune!' are pesiertly ‘operates

flights have been operated from ‘the Airport in the past.

23. The following types of pure jet commercial air-

craft operate from the Hollywood-Burbank Airport:

Boeing 727, Boeing 737, Douglas DC-9. The Adminis-

trator of the FAA-has issued ‘a type certificate cover-

ing each of these types of aircraft. Said type certificates

provide that the type to which issued meets the air-

worthiness requirements of the Federal Aviation Regu-

lations. The following. types of pure jet ‘business air-

craft operate from the Airport: Jetstar, Gulfstream I],

Sabreliner, Lear Jet, DeHavilland and Falcon. Com-

parable type ‘certificates and airworthiness certificates

oe

aircraft in air commeree.

94. Bach scheduled interstate carrier that uses

Hollywood-Burbank Airport ‘holds a Certificate of Pub-

lic Convenience and. Necessity issued by the Civil

Aeronautics Board: (hereinafter “CAB”). The certifi-

cates issued to Air West and Continental provide that

‘said carriers’ are authorized to engage im air transpor- _

Certificate issued by the Administrator of the

, Said certificates specify that each of said car-

st a safe operation as an air. carrier of persons,

erty and mail in scheduled air transportation be-

nm the points authorized in the air carrier’s certifi-

of public convenience and necessity.

PSA holds’ a Commercial Operating Certifi-

issued by the Administrator of the FAA, which

j provides that PSA is authorized to operate

i’ commercial operator to conduct common carrier

ra carrying passengers and cargo intrastate on

scheduled basis, PSA holds a Certificate of Public

nience and Necessity issued by the California

Utilities Commission.

- ‘The Administrator of the FAA has issued

ions. Specifications to each regularly scheduled

carrier that uses Hollywood-Burbank Airport. Said

perations Specifications provide that each carrier is

| to operate turbojet aircraft within the navi-

le airspace of the United States in accordance with

istrument flight rules. The Operations Specifications

ed to Air West and Continental provide that said

riers are authorized to use Hollywood-Burbank Air-

et as a regular airport; the Operations Specifications

mC to United and Western provide that said carriers

sell ibis

each scheduled carrier at. Hollywood-Burbank Airport

are ‘spécifically..authorized by each carrier’s Opera

tions Specifications.

28; ‘Air West: operates Douglas DC-9 aircraft at

Hollywood-Burbank Airport. ‘United has operated

and operates the following types of aircraft at Holly.

wood-Burbank Airport: Boeing 727 and Boeing 737.

Western ‘operates: and has: operated Boeing 737 aircraft

at Hollywood-Burbank Airport. PSA operates the fol

port: Boeing 727, Boeing 737:and Douglas DC-9.

29. Each aircraft operated by ‘the regularly sched-

uled carriers that use Hollywood-Burbank Airport has

- been issued’ an: Airworthiness’ Certificate by the Ad-

ministrator of the FAA which certifies that, as of the

date:of issuance, the aircraft to: which issued has been

inspected: and found to:conform to the Type Certificate

therefor and to ‘be.in condition: for safe operation.

"30. Bach pilot of a civil aircraft of United States

registry operated in the navigable airspace of the United

States is required to have :in his personal possession

a current pilot certificate issued by the Administrator

of the FAA:

< 31)°° Bach’ pilot of an aircraft operated by a sched-

uled air carrier at’ Hollywood-Burbank Airport is re

quired to hold a current air’ transport pilot certificate

rican Gircheey wmsemenen

id ~ Each flight engineer of a civil aircraft of United

registry is tequired to have in his personal pos-

season a Earreit fight engineer's cerifcate lel

738. "Pursuant to newly ‘enacted federal legislation

wo oe ee

at oa

cil atin

“gid obtain an Airport Operating Certificate issued by

‘Be Administrator of the FAA pursuant to Section 51-

bc thé Airport and Airway Development Act of

’ Public Law 91-258, 84 Stat. 219 (May 21,

M0), within two years from the date of enactment

ip orde to. continue to serve air carriers certificated by

he CAB. Management of Lockheed intends to apply

4 ¢ such a certificate under the regulations to be

yed by the Administrator gdverning application.

444: The FAA exercises centralized management

‘control over the navigable airspace of the United

$ “The various Air Route Traffic Control Centers

ated by the FAA throughout the United States are

med responsibility for the management and control

¢ entirety of this navigable airspace.

§. The Los Angeles Center, located at Palmdale,

fornia, exercises management and control of the

ein a geographical area of approximately 184,-

‘square miles which is bounded on the south by

i¢ border betwen the United States and Mexico, on

east by the Colorado River, and which extends to

“alifornia to the north and 150 miles to sea to the

6. Pursuant to a license agreement with Lock-

, the FAA operates the Airport Traffic Control

ower and Radar Approach and Departure Control at

ywood-Burbank Airport.

Ane In connection with such operation, the FAA

1a expended d approximately $2 million on the installa-

Pbtuinc ac Hidsruenseit Landing Systemn ("ILS"),

y approach and identification lights, and radar

dio equipment.

lll.

trol over a portion: of its nayigable.airspace, which

portion is for: this purpose defined: geographically and

vertically, ee ep Seem elie eraied at Hat

aR ME

“SF: innate etn Podtdlia tut: ot 088

49 U.S.C. §1301, et seq., the Administrator of the

FAA ‘has’ determined that there exists a need for a sys

orderly control of the air traffic emanating from points

within and without the United States: and converging

on large metropolitan areas and ,airports, such as Holly-

wood-Burbank Airport. Accordingly, the Administrator

has established a system for the control of air traffic

which provides for such orderly control and separation,

and which operates within. controlled airspace identi-

fied as “control zones” and “control areas”. Control

zones encompass all. the airspace from the surface to

' infinity. within. five miles of the geographical center

of an airport. Control areas are of varying elevations

and. dimensions, and include the area surrounding

Hollywood-Burbank Airport. The airspace within a con-

trol zone below an altitude within 2,000 feet above the

surface is defined as the airport traffic area.

40, » Hollywood-Burbank Airport is located under a

control..area, within an. airport traffic area, within a

control zone and under many. converging Federal air-

ways, all of which have been established by the Ad

wns of the FAA pursuant to statutory authority.

Unless. otherwise authorized by FAA Air Tral-

OS ll

the control tower. He is further required to comply _

pan Wee

if clearances and instructions that may be issued

“Traffic: Control. Air traffic control over the air-

-§ait’ within the Hollywood-Burbank Airport Control

‘Pore, including approach control and departure con-

ions to operate its jet aircraft in accordance

With: Instrument Flight Rules (“IFR”). When not

imder ‘the control of an FAA airport control tower,

‘Mitetaft operating under IFR are under the direct con-

tol 0 van FAA Air Route Traffic Control Center and

We fequired to comply with the clearances received

hat facility.

a No aircraft may taxi at or take off from Holly-

d-Bui bank Airport without first receiving an ap-

per priate clearance from Hollywood-Burbank Air Traf-

‘fc Control. Prior to takeoff, pilots of aircraft that are

‘tequired to operate under IFR must file their flight

“plans with the Los Angeles Air Route Traffic Control

“Center. Every fifteen minutes the FAA computer locat-

‘@f at the Los Angeles Center provides updated flight

@eparture information to the appropriate tower facil-

ies and to sectors within the Center. When a com-

cial jet aircraft is ready for departure from its ter-

ial gate, it makes radio contact with FAA Air Traf-

ontrol. It is at that time assigned a runway,/for

off and is ultimately given clearance to taxi there-

1; Prior to taking its position on the runway, the air-

@ 7 ; given a departure clearance, which includes

Me assignment of departure procedures and assign-

fof a radio beam intersection to which the air-

| § directed to fly.

sini ai

43. On receiving its clearance to take off, each jet

or other: large ‘aircraft is required to conform with all

FAA takeoff procedures and to climb to an altitude of

1,500 feet above the airport surface as rapidly as prac-

ticable.; Departure clearances ‘for IFR. aircraft incor-

porate standard instrument departure procedures estab-

lished: for Hollywood-Burbank Airport by the FAA.

Pictorial charts showing these standard instrument de-

parture procedutes in effect at Hollywood-Burbank Air.

port: are ‘published by the Department of Commerce,

United States Coast.and Geodetic Survey. Aircraft taking

off. from. Hollywood-Burbank Airport must conform

with the assigned FAA departure clearance including

all. standard IFR departure procedures incorporated

therein. Control of aircraft crossing the boundary of

the airport.on takeoff is passed to Hollywood-Burbank

gt Control, which controls the aircraft and pro-

vides separation. from other aircraft until the departing

sivceale, ie:seady $o Myare the 9, space, mubdcieges #

~ Ad, De ia i ih aleeeace. bhi

gated to: the Hollywood-Burbank terminal facility des

tined, for example, for San Francisco International Air —

port, control-of' the aircraft is passed from Hollywood-

Burbank: Departure Control to the Los Angeles Air

Route Traffic Control Center located at Palmdale,

California. At about Paso. Robles, California, control of

the aircraft is passed on to the Oakland Air Route

Traffic Control Center, which in turn passes control to

the FAA: terminal facility at San Francisco Intex

tional Airport as the aircraft enters the navigable air

space subdelegated to that facility. The aircraft then 1

saci yioen: te: Con ofthe San Byancieco foe

until the aircraft haslanded. °

‘Hollywood-Burbank Airport without first receiving an

hig Traffic Control clearance, which includes assign-

a the FAA of a runway for landing. In addition

>. egg approach control, the FAA maintains and

ates an Instrument Landing System (“ILS”) which

ron. establishes a three-degree glide slope

@ Runway 7 at Hollywood-Burbank Airport. Each of

arriers is equipped with electronic devices that mon-

ito the ILS glide slope and depict the glide slope posi-

ion in relation to that of the aircraft on the cockpit

instrument.

Mb. On receiving FAA clearance to approach for

landing, the aircraft is required to be at or above the

de slope at the outer ILS marker and to remain at

bove the glide slope until reaching the middle ILS

rker. The outer marker is located approximately 6.1

fautical miles from the approach end of Runway 7,

While the middle marker is located approximately 1.8

‘Mantical miles from the approach end of the runway.

io ‘glide slope altitude at the outer ILS marker is

proximately 2,000 feet above the surface and at the

> marker is approximately 575 feet above the

+. As an additional means of approach control,

‘the Ge. prescribes standard instrument approach

= s which are published in Part 97 of the Fed-

al A’ iation Regulations. Pictorial approach and land-

7 ir s showing these standard instrument approach

Bi in effect at Hollywood-Burbank Airport are

py

published * by the Department of Comimerce, United

States Coast and Geodetic Survey. Approaches to Hok

flight: rules are- required ‘to be in accordance with the

standard instrument approach procedures set forth in

Part 97 of the Federal Aviation Regulations.

47, During every portion of an IFR flight, the air-

craft and pilot are operating under explicit instruc

tions and control of an FAA facility.

48. The navigable airspace in the vicinity of major

air terminals across the United States, including Los

Angeles, is presently congested. This congestion has re-

sulted in extensive delays at a number of the major

airports. This condition exists because the services

required by the American traveling public frequently

exceed the capacity of the nation’s airport system.

49. In exercising centralized management and

control over the navigable airspace of the United States,

the FAA has as One of its goals the efficient use of

such airspace, which include’ the expeditious move-

ment of aircraft. The goal of efficient use of airspace,

sal PMs abate a Sitilct Peden the hil

of insuring the safety of aircraft.

50. The FAA exerts its power to achieve efficient

use of navigable airspace in a variety of ways, includ-

ing the utilization of flow control procedures and high

density airport rules.

aah Flow control is a means of metering aircraft in

order to meet any given traffic condition, Flow control

restrictions are imposed by FAA facilities from time to

time ‘on commercial, business and other aricraft in

order to minimize delays resulting from congestion ot

weather or equipment problems and to accommodate

safely the maximum number of aircraft within the Ait.

—si—

es the number of aircraft that can be accepted within

‘gates: and. may restrict altitudes and/or routes to

‘geflown-during a specified period of time. When an

‘FAA terminal facility or tower encounters a condition

‘Which. will result in airborne delays of 30 minutes or

‘more, the facility notifies its Air Route Traffic Control

‘Genter of this fact. The Center, in turn, will impose

¢flow control restriction on adjacent Centers. A flow

‘gmitrol restriction obligates the receiving center to (a)

¢ ar aircraft on specified routes; (b) establish a sepa-

fation in time, altitude or distance; or (c) limit the

umber of departures in a given period by holding air-

‘gait on the ground. Thus the imposition of a flow

gontrol restriction by San Francisco can and does re-

4 it in the Los Angeles Center’s pete aircraft on the

-*$2. In 1970 the FAA instituted a system of central-

s td flow control. This system is managed by the

A Central Flow Control Facility located at Washing-

4 & Dc. The Central Flow Control Facility coordi-

‘Bates and supervises the flow of air traffic throughout

‘ir Traffic Control System to mimize en route de-

and achieve the maximum utilization of the air

prior . > imposing a flow control restriction, an Air

: oo. Center must clear the proposed

mtriction through the Central Flow Control Facility

Sos an tusure that proper coordination may take

o = telief from excessive delays caused

2 at certain of the major airport terminals

6 United States, the FAA prescribed High Den-

Traffic Airport Rules in December 1968, 33 F.R.

Presteen John F. Kennedy, ba

Ceahdte: Newark, O’Hate and Washington. National

airports as high density traffic airports ‘and restrict the

hourly number of IFR operations (takeoffs and land

ings) at these airpor‘s to a specified number. The total

number of IFR operations is allocated among various

classes of users, namely scheduled air carriers, sched-

uled air taxis, and general aviation which includes

business aircraft. Although the number of operations

allowed varies during different periods of the day, the

rules allocate operations for the entire twenty-four hour

petiod. To operate to or from these designated airports,

aircraft are required to have an afrival or departure

reservation. These rules are intended by the FAA to

work in conjunction with flow control procedures de-

scribed in Paragraph 51.

54,.- Congress and the Administrator of the FAA

are fully cognizant of the problems created by aircraft

noise. Ii allocating the IFR reservations in the High

Density Traffic Airport rules, the Administrator spe

cifically had in mind the problem of the noise disturb- .

ance that would result from encouraging the os

of more flights after the hour of 10:00 P.M.

55. In the interest of alleviating noise disturbances

to the residents of communities adjoining airports lo-

cated in metropolitan areas, the Administrator of the

FAA has established regulations that (1) require tur

bine. powered fixed wing aircraft, approaching for

landing, to maintain within the airport traffic area. an

altitude. of at least 1,500 feet above the surface’ of the

airport “until further descent is required for a. safe

landing”, and (2) require such aircraft; when taking

off,'to Climb to 1,500 feet as vagally as practicable.

<ininn

Qn September 4, 1969, acting pursuant to the

ity. of FAA Order 7100.13, the FAA Chief of

irport Traffic Control Tower, Burbank, Califor-

‘gia issued..an order (BUR. 7100.5B) prescribing a

geise abatement runway use program at the Hollywood-

grbank Airport. This order makes Runway 25 the

Tunway for eres. of turbine Se

aed the subject matter of nighttime takeoffs,

“based upon his authority and expertise, acted to

mize the noise consequences of such operations.

However, in the landlocked, thickly populated area in

ich the Hollywood-Burbank Airport is located, the

‘ase’of a preferential noise abatement runway is helpful

in reducing noise over the City of Burbank, but such

: diverts the noise to other populated areas.

2: Where possible, the FAA has developed stand-

departures which are assigned between

hours of 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M. in order to

ees over residential areas during those hours.

tand d departures are presently in effect at Los

B..Th y federal statutes and regulations and the

5 of the Civil Aeronautics Board and of the Ad-

oe ee

ministrator of the Federal Aviation Administration

have so completely occupied the field-of the regulation

of the use of the navigable airspace and aircraft opers

tions as to demonstrate that Congress left no room for

local regulation such as the Burbank curfew ordi

59. Aircraft have such a range and such speed and

they involve such technical complexity that they have

to be managed on a centralized basis. The transport

aviation industry is unique and must be regulated on

a national basis, both technically and economically, by

the Federal Grovernment. The approach to the solution

of air transporatation problems at the local level does

not work. Regulation on a national basis is required

because air transporatation is a national operation.

60, The federal statutes and regulations governing

and controlling the use of air space and air traffic

touch a field in which the federal interest is so domi-

nant as to preclude enforcement of a local ordinance

such as the Burbank curfew ordinance.

61. From. February: 1968. until July 12, 1970,

PSA operated a Boeing 727 aircraft which departed

the -Hollywood-Burbank Airport at 11:30 P.M. each

Sunday night destined for San Diego, On the average

said flights served about 125 passengers, with an aver-

age of 80 being boarded at Hollywood-Burbank. At the

time: of ‘the imposition of the Burbank curfew ordi-

ao” We

4 gired cancellation of this regularly scheduled com-

‘mers J flight.

oy ‘Since March 9, 1970 PSA has operated a Boe-

jae727 or Boeing 737 aircraft on charter to Lockheed

Company which aircraft departs from the

Hollywood-Burbank Airport Monday through Friday at

640 AM. destined for Palmdale. This flight is being

permitted to operate by the City as an emergency flight.

=63, Several fleets of corporate jet aircraft use Hol-

jywood-Burbank Airport’ as their home base. Prior to

the enactment of the curfew ordinance, there were at

Seereons mene pa nronk 08 compeante’ jo sircent

on Lockheed Aircraft Corporation operates and

‘maintains military defense plant facilities at Hollywood-

Burbank Airport.

6s. On August 29, 1970, Continental Air Lines

; mced regularly scheduled service to Portland and

Seattle from the Hollywood-Burbank Airport pursuant

+10 authority granted May 12, 1970, by the Civil Aero-

‘fiautics Board. These flights are operated utilizing

‘Boeing 727-200 aircraft. In scheduling its flights along

this route, Continental did not provide any departures

Within the Burbank curfew hours.

a Should sufficient demand develop Continental

atici ates adding another flight from the Pacific

orthwest t_through the Hollywood-Burbank Airport.

itis ntal from operating a southbound flight depart-

Sh

ing at that ‘hour. -A’ southbound ‘flight from Seattle

through Portland and San Jose, California, to Burbank

and on to, Ontario can depart Seattle no later than

7:00 P.M. in order not. to. violate the Burbank curfew,

67. “If an’ 11:00 P.M. to 7:00 A:M. curfew on jet

departures were to be enforced at Portland as well: as

at Burbank, Continental would be restricted from orig-

inating ‘flights northbound and southbound along this

Ontario-Burbank-San Jose-Portland-Seattle route between

the hours of 7:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M. Only 12 hours

of the day would be available for originating such flights.

68. In the event of nationwide imposition of cur-

few ordinances, Continental would be able to originate

departures eastbound on its route from Seattle through

_ Denver, Wichita, Tulsa and Houston to New Orleans

only between the hours of 7:00 A.M. and 2:00 P.M.

On its Los Angeles through Denver to Chicago route,

Continental would be able to originate departures east-

bound only between the hours of 7:00 A.M. and 4:15

P.M. The available hours indicated do not take into

account any allowance that would have to be made for

the , delayed arrrival problem that would inevitably

69. The problem of noise created by jet aircraft

is well known, and it appears that if a curfew ordi-

nance. such as that before this Court were held valid,

psoas carl ca age Alaegpedc

sider solely in the accident of its particular

ince because past. experience indicates “that.

uC gis mis highly contagious and that its

spread | to, ‘other localities i is virtually inevitable if. the

FEE SH A oe ens fore, Ag,

ionic

The imposition of curfew ordinances on a na-

‘basis would have a near catastrophic effect on

at air transportation system, adversely affect-

p aviation industry, rien eat anal

d the national economy.

~ Continental Air Lines has 48 departures per

i services would greatly inconvenience the secdiling

blic as well as business and industry. Reduced rates

‘night flights enable many members of the public

: ae Ad ak that Vina, oid thie largest propextion

tinental’s air mail and air freight is carried at

. To replace the cancelled night services. Con-

fal would have to purchase approximately six new

ng aircraft at a cost of between $5,000,000 and

00,000 edch. Continental's operating costs would

eased approximately 25% by reason of the re-

indlintion of aircraft and the required purchase

tional equipment. These costs would be passed

‘traveling public.

‘There is reason to believe that the imposition

itionwide curfew would affect the other certifi-

ir carriers in a manner and to an extent com-

) the effects upon Continental described in

11 and 72.

a; a

74 ~The Burbank curfew ordinances became effeo-

tive on’ May 4, 1970. Between the: hours of 11:00 P.M;

(local time) on. May 4, 1970, and..6:59..A.M. on May

5, there’ were 1,009 scheduled departures of pure jet

aircraft operated by federally.certificated air carriers

from all. airports in the United States. (International

departures and departures. by. scheduled intrastate

carriers and commuter air carriers, are not included in

this total and would increase. the indicated number.)

If. curfew ordinances. suchas that before this Court

were. instituted on a nationwide basis, all of these flights

would have. to, be cancelled. These cancellations would

create. positioning problems for the airlines, which

would result in additional cancellations of flights dur-

ing non-curfew hours. _

15, The scheduling of aircraft is an extremely com-

plex operation. Public convenience must be balanced

with..equipment and .crew availability. In addition,

schedules of the various airlines are interrelated due

to the need to provide connecting flights, For example,

approximately 30% of Continental’s domestic business

comes from providing connections with other airlines.

. 76. » The scheduling-operation is made more com

plex by the maintenance requirements of the air fleet.

Hundreds of component: parts must be maintained on

a ‘timed basis: The: aviation industry performs the re-

‘quired maintenance on its aircraft at night at a limited

number of maintenance bases. Continental, for exam-

ple,: has.its major maintenance facility at Los Angeles

International Airport..Continental’s schedules are work-

ed out.so that an aircraft can return to this facility every

day.or two for maintenance, United Air Lines has six

maintenance: bases, and 12% of its fleet receives re

ee maintenance every night. The imposition off,

cali

ordinances on a nationwide basis would severely

‘“Wapait ‘the efficiency of the maintenance system within

he-aviation industry by requiring the carriers to estab-

al maintenance bases, which would involve

4 i and expense to the air carriers and would

) fisult ina deterioration in air transportation services

‘Wo the public. :

78. The imposition of curfew ordinances on a na-

tor basis would result in a bunching of flights in

those hours immediately preceding the curfew. This

Dunching of flights during these hours would have the

old effect of increasing an already serious con-

jon problem and actually increasing, rather than re-

ing, the noise problem by increasing flights in the

d of greatest annoyance to surrounding communi-

Such a result is totally inconsistent with the objec-

of the federal statutory and regulatory scheme.

Based upon a study made at four major air-

, it appears that over 48% of the nation’s air

is presently carried by flights departing between

hours of 11:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M. The imposi-

f a departure curfew on a nationwide basis

thus” cause at least a one-day delay in the de-

’ billions of pieces of mail transported an-

The air cargo industry virtually depends for its

Ace on its ability to operate at off-peak hours.

ris

| ‘would seriously interrupt and im-

Pade the carriage of interstate passengers and goods and

rT

if

1

iB

the, eb wel cme in ow office

the time available for use of the airspace resulting from

‘iil it

‘Wedd conflict with the federally certificated rights and

ligations of the air carriers.

: relent acters requires a

‘guthority if it is to be conducted with maximum

tafety anc } a0 as to achieve efficient use of the navigable

© it the use of the navigable airspace were cur-

ft trough the enactnent of curfew ordinances on

nv basis, interstate commerce would be sub-

id to an unreasonable burden and interference.

& 5. ‘Any conclusion of law hereinafter recited

sh should be deemed a finding of fact is hereby

pted as such.

_.. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject

tt of the action by virtue of 28 U.S.C. §1331(a)

28 U.S.C. $1337; and jurisdiction over the parties.

This action arises under the Federal Aviation

1958, 72 Stat. 737 (1958), as amended, 49

A. §§1301-1542; the Department of Transporta-

ot

ig Act, 80 Stat. 931 (1966), 49 U.S.C. §§1651-1659

Aeapp: TV 1969); the Airport and Airway Develop-

Went Act of 1970, Public Law No. 91-258, 84 Stat.

; ‘n 21, 1970); the Constitution of the United

Plates, Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 (the Commerce

Cimise), and Article VI, paragraph 2 (the Suprem-

. ‘Cla ). The matter in controversy exceeds the

sy es ailes of $10,000, exclusive of interest and

ei The allegations of the complaint raise issues con-

ing’ an actual controversy concerning which the

‘pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §2201, et seq., will make

gration of rights.

it~

Be pam iataniieite tides, andthe: claien senha

in, this Judicial District. . mn

fe ‘Whe Federal’ Avidtion’ Act ’of1,1958, 72 Stat.

737. (1958), as: amended, »49 -U.S.C.A.. §§1301-1542

(hereinafter the-“Act”), established the Federal Avia

tion Agency, now the Federal Aviation Administration

(“FAA”), headed by an Administrator who is made

responsible under the Act for the exercise of all powers

and the discharge of all duties of the FAA.

“5. ‘The ‘Act vests in‘a single Administrator plenary

authority for ‘all aspécts ‘of ‘airspace management and

specifically charges the Administrator with the dual

responsibility of insuring the safety of aircraft and the

efficient utilization of the navigable airspace.

6. The comprehensive character of the Act demon-

strates that Congress intended to provide the Admin-

istrator with the tools ‘necessary to exercise his plenary

authority. The United States is declared “to possess

and éxertise complete and exclusive national sovereign-

ty in the’ airspace of the United States,” 49 U.S.C.

$1508(a). Haying’ granted ‘to. each’ citizen of the

United: States “the right of freedom of transit through

the navigable airspace of the United States,” 49 U.S.C.

$1304, ‘Congress further defined “navigable airspace”

as all airspace “above the minimum altitudes of flight

prescribed by regulations: issued under this chapter,

‘and ‘shall include airspace needed. to insure safety in

takeot? and: landing of aircraft.” 49: U.S.C. §1301(24).

be Ls “The’ Act Confetred' upon the’FAA and upon it

Administrator broad ‘powers "to ‘regulate air commérce

in thé “public 'interest!”-49° U.S.C. §§1303, 1341(a),

4348. ‘Tie ile’ tern” defied to include “te

reguldtion of’air commerce . rio) Seip promote A

lial

nt and safety and fulfill the requirements of

i defense”; “the control of the use of the navi-

ble airspace of the United States . . . in the interest

and efficiency”; “the development and opera-

tis | fa common system of air traffic control and navi-

3 jon for both military and civil aircraft.” 49 U.S.C.

4 203.

The powers granted by the Congress are not

; ne nt but have been actively exercised. The regu-

‘Iations of the Administrator are of formidable propor-

, impressive detail, and manifest sophistication.

_ The high density traffic airport rules, 14 C.F.R.

-93.121r.131, which regulate the number of IFR opera-

fions at certain major air terminals over the entire 24-

period of the day, constitute control of the use

management of the navigable airspace by the

istrator to the end of insuring the efficient utili-

10. The system of flow control instituted by the

AA, under which aircraft can be held on the ground

order to reduce airbotne delays and congestion,

titutes control of the use and management of the

able airspace in accordance with the mandate

¢ Act, which is to insure the efficient utilization of

To buttress the authority of the Administra-

0 deal with the question of noise abatement, in

8 Congress amended the Act to require the Ad-

strator to prescribe such rules and regulations as

| find necessary to provide for the control and

lent of aircraft noise.

2,_ FAA Order BUR 7100.5B, which establishes

W be as the preferential runway at Hollywood-

: ‘Airport for departures of turbine powered

33 iS

acim

aircraft; between the hours: of 11:00 P.M: and 7:09

ee ee

of noise abatement. tae

"43? “An. orditance ‘such as Burbank’s canst tl

SladlidGalag "2 “in wet GE Ma calor

catnstances, but iiust be weighed ‘and tested as if im-

posed on a nationwide basis.

14. From the broad scope of the Federal statutes

and regulations governing and controlling the use of

air space and of air traffic, it is apparent that Congress

intended to centralize full and dominant control of the

navigable air space in the Federal Government so as

to provide for the safe and most efficient use of such

airspace: The scheme of federal regulation is so per

vasive as to demonstrate that.Congress intended to pre

empt the field and to leave no room for local ordi-

nances such as the Burbank curfew ordinance.

15. Air transportation calls for a more penetrating,

uniform, and exclusive regulation than’ is necessary for

any other mode of transportation. It is a uniquely ne

tional operation in which the federal interest is so dom-

inant as to preclude the enforcement of state or local

laws, such as the Burbank Curfew Ordinance, on the :

same subject.

16.. There would be a very serious loss of efficien-

cy, and the statutory objective of efficient use of the

‘airspace as set forth in the Act would be compromised,

as a result of nationwide imposition of curfews such

as that imposed at Hollywood-Burbank Airport, and

accordingly, the City of Burbank has no power to ep-

act the ordinance in issue in this case.

‘17. Bach federally certificated air carrier is auth

orized and obligated by statute and by its ertificate.

ae

BY

atin ating out of Hollywood-Burbank Airport. Said or-

na : is therefore ‘in direct conflict with federal law

a ve unde the Supremacy Cine (A. Vl

fiicts with the federal right of each citizen of free-

‘domi of transit through the navigable airspace, 49 U.S.C.

@, and is therefore void under the Supremacy

19. Under the Commerce Clause (Art. I, §8, Cl.

| the United States Constitution, the states are not

ed.to have authority (a) to impede substantially

ree wr a of commerce from state to state, or (b) to

ate those phases of the national commerce,

Sichess of the need of national uniformity, de-

# that their regulation, if any, be prescribed by a

le authority.

i" The nationwide imposition of ordinances such

urbank’s Would seriously interrupt the carriage of

a ae

interstate passengers,’ mail, and goods and thereby ‘subi

stantially impede the free-flow of commerce from state

to'state, and, considered on ‘such a national basis, such

psenner a ra

The volume of air ‘commerce, the speed with

Bile it is conducted, the technical Complexity of its

scheduling and ‘operation, and the limited availability

of such of its ‘essential aspects as aifports, aircraft, air

ttaffic routes, and aircraft maintenance facilities all

make national uniformity of regulations prescribed by

a single authority’ a Necessity, so that this phase of the

national commerce may be conducted with maximum

safety and so as to achieve efficient use of the navigable

airspace.

22. Plaintiffs and intervening plaintiff are entitled

to. judgment on their respective complaints for declar-

atory relief that each and every part and section of the

Burbank curfew ordinance’ is unconstitutional, illegal

and void.

23. Plaintiffs and. intervening plaintiff are entitled

to. a decree that, defendant City of Burbank and the in-

dividual defendants, and each of them, in their re

spective capacities as officials of the City of Burbank

charged with the enforcement of the provisions of

the Burbank curfew ordinance, their respective agents,

servants, employees, attorneys and successors be en-

joined and restrained by a permanent order of injune-

tion of this Court from taking any action in pursuance

of said ordinance.

24.. Plaintiffs and intervening plaintiff are entitled

to recover their costs of suit herein incurred.

., 25... Any finding of fact. which should be deemed

a. conclusion of law. is hereby adopted as such, 7

cial

JUDGMENT BE. ENTERED ACCORDING-

ied this 30th day of November, 1970.

/s/ E. Avery Crary

United States District Judge

eae

APPROVED AS TO FORM ()/):

DISAPPROVED AS TO FORM (.. )

RICHARD L. SIEG, JR., Assistant City Attorney

By /s/ Richard L.'Sieg; Jr: -

Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Attorneys for all defendants

except Samuel Gorlick

By /s/ Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Attorney for Defendant Samuel Gorlick

RECEIPT ACKNOWLEDGED this. 25th day of

November, 1970, at 4:00 p.m. __..-

SAMUEL GORLICK, City Attorney, and

RICHARD L. SIEG, JR., Assistant City Attorney,

By /s/ Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Richard L, Sieg, Jr.

Attorneys for all Defendants

except Samuel Gorlick

By /s/ Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Richard L. Sieg, Jr.

Attorney for Defendant Samuel Gorlick

willie

“nthe Matter ofthe Petition of Jordan A. Drefus

a United States of America

' ~ Federal Aviation Administration

=: ~ Department of ‘Transportation

Hs Washington, D. C.

“Yn the matter of the petition of Jordan A. Dreifus to

amend the Federal Aviation Regulations to prescribe

‘aircraft noise regulations for turbojet aircraft opera-

tions at the Santa Monica, California Municipal Air-

ee 9071.

ork DENIAL OF PETITION

“By letter dated July 19, 1968, and supporting letters

dated ‘September 3, 1968, October 1, 1968, January

27, 1969, March 3, 1969, March 6, 1969, March 18,

1969, and. May 24, 1969, Jordan A. Dreifus, on his

‘Own behalf; petitioned for rule making to amend the

‘Federal Aviation Regulations to prescribe noise restric-

tions and limitations for turbojet aircraft operating at

‘the Santa Monica Municipal Airport.

+n support of his request, petitioner makes the fol-

lowing arguments (here condensed): .

© (1) Petitioner’s residence near the airport is becom-

* ing exposed to increasing turbojet aircraft traf-

ter fic and resulting noise.

0) Other airport. neighbors are suing the airport

_ - seeking damages based on aircraft noise.

3) The FAA has the authority under section 307

; of the Federal Aviation Act to issue noise

ee ns Hig of sincratt at the

-. " a ,

(4) New. section: 611 ‘of the Federal Aviation Ag

-igives the FAA the duty-to issue noise standards

governing the flight of aircraft at the airport,

(5) New section 611. of the Federal Aviation Act

has probably obliterated all State or local av-

thority to issue such regulations.

(6) The exclusive jurisdiction of the FAA in the

, field of aircraft noise abatement was upheld in

the case of American Airlines, Inc. vs. Town of

Hempstead, 272 Fed. Supp. 226 (1966).

(7) Under Agency. Order 7110.13,. entitled “Air.

craft Noise Abatement Programs,” the FAA

has instituted voluntary noise abatement proce-

__ dures for airports: including runway use restric.

» tions; air traffic control procedures, and rout

| + -jiags where compatible with safety.

is Failure of ‘the FAA to issue restrictions at Santa

~ | 'Mionica and other airports would allow the

* State and local governments ‘to issue their own

- airport use restrictions. The restrictions would

result in chaos, ‘confusion, interference and

, Obstruction: to aircraft operations, which could.

be contrary tothe national interest. The local .

. Testrictions .could be. arbitrary, unreasonable,

- and obscure, and. could discriminate against

“general aviation” . as. distinct from interstate

commercial carriage or “air transportation.”

Aside from resulting in litigation, local discrimi-

nation against “general aviation” would be con-

" trary to the Federal Aviation Act of 1958, ‘

(9) Failure of the FAA to issue noise abatement

regulations for Santa Monica and other air-

ports would be incompatible with the primary

Rinne

gson-for the Federal Aviation Act. of 1958,

:

Deel aides Seed tulet ‘beibanehit -resitiotions

would ‘not be effective because of the uncer-

*5°© ‘tainty with which they would be met by the

Be Petitioner shaes thats, Seats Monica

Ae unicipal regulation concerning aircraft noise

5 ee eae

to noise levels. specified in FAA Notice of

Rule Making 69-1, the relationship of these

to a Santa Monica Airport noise report, and

er articles concerning the severity of the airport

¢ r makes ‘two basic requests, (1) a general

sest to issue any aircraft noise regulations “as may

or appropriate in the circumstances” to

sve the noise, burden on the neighbors of the Santa

$, in fact, implemented Order 7110.13 (cited

fioner) with respect to the Santa Monica Air-

‘inal

port, in“cooperation with ‘the City of Santa Monica;

This ‘has involved (1) the ‘use ofa noise abatement

runway “when permitted by wind conditions; (2) the

use ofa noise abatement departure. path to avoid con-

gested areas; and (3) the use of raised traffic patterns.

In addition, the FAA monitors .the conditions at the

airport in. order.to anticipate new noise problems, or

possible solutions, at the airport. Further, section 91.87

of Part 91 of the. Federal Aviation Regulations pre-

scribes noise. abatement approach, departure, and run-

way requirements that must be complied with by turbine-

powered and large airplanes. Beyond these rules, and the

FAA’s monitoring of the Santa Monica Airport under

the FAA Order, the FAA believes that further relief

from aircraft noise should involve airport use restric

tions similar to those that petitioner states were is

sued in the Santa Monica City Ordinance. In short,

the FAA at present does not know of any action, short

of the type attempted by Santa Monica, that will satis

fy the needs of the neighbors of the airport or supply

the relief requested. In light’of the above, petitioner's

general request for rule making not of the kind at

tempted by the City of Santa Monica is hereby denied.

‘In *support of _petitioner’s specific request for time —

limitations similar ‘to those attempted by the City of

Santa Monica, ‘petitioner states that such rules “would

‘avoid ‘a major area of possible dispute with surrounding

residents.” The FAA ‘agtees that nondiscriminatory

time restrictions may be an effective and appropriate

means of adapting aircraft noise to the needs of Jocal

communities. Petitioner states that the “final question

for consideration is: what level of government has the

power to so regulate or. resttict: aircraft operations?

ee Tee

| to exercise such power?” With regard to the

tence of Federal power to substitute its judgment for

; of the local governments who own and operate

“gizports, the FAA agrees with petitioner (see petition-

} afguments’3 and 4 above) that the Federal Avia-

fion“Act provides broad powers in the field of aircraft

lowes » with respect to, the question as to which

sl of government would be the proper one to deny

Bie tciraies), the FAA does not agree with peti-

- finer: that new section 611 of the Federal Aviation

‘Ket has obliterated the authority of State or local. gov-

‘ment proprietors of airports (see petitioner’s argu-

“Weat 5 above). To the contrary, Senate Report 1353,

craft Noise Abatement, July 1, 1968, (concerning

added new section 611 to the Federal Aviation Act of

wr ) makes the following statement of Congressional

“Mitent concerning the relation of the new legislation to

al government initiatives, and in so doing adopts

batim. views expressed ‘by the Secretary of Trans-

portation in his letter to the Senate Committee Of June

2, 1968. (emphasis supplied):

“<The courts have held that the Federal Govern-

ment presently preempts the field of noise regula-

tion insofar as it involves controlling the flight of

‘aircraft. Local noise control legislation limiting the

- petmissible noise level of all overflying aircraft

“has recently been struck down because it conflicted

h Federal regulation of air traffic. American

dines v. Town of Hempstead, 272 F. Supp.

§ (U.S.D.C., E.D., N.Y., 1966). The court

ac ink

© Said): at 234; The’ legislation operates: in an ares

-. “ules: operating:as do: those of the ordinance must

“Come: froma ‘Federal: source’ H.R: 3400 would

*- “aerely> expand ‘the Federal-Government’s role in a

‘field: already: preempted.: It would not: change this

preemption. State and. local governments.,will re.

i .Jmain. unable to use their police powers to control

: ne aircraft noise. by. regulating the flight of aircraft,

» » However, the proposed: legislation. will not affect

- the rights of .a State.or Jocal public agency, as

‘ the-proprietor of:an airport, from issuing regula-

') tions:-or: establishing requirements as to the per-

missible level of noise which can be created by

aircraft using the airport. Airport owners acting

| @$ proprietors can presently’ deny the use of their

airports to°aircraft on the. basis of noise consid-

tb “erations s0:long’as-such exclusion is nondiscrimins

tory.

celal: tn “geet siereds:syemneantble. fox te

ciding” how’ long ‘the tunways) will be, so is the

'« Qwner responsible for obtaining noise easements

‘Necessary to permit the landing and takeoff of

+ the -aircraft: The»Federal Government is in no

position to require an airport to accept service by

-o “larger aircraft, and, for.that. purpose, to obtain

‘) maent‘is inno position to require an airport to ac-

| -«Ceptrservice by. noisier. aircraft, and for that pur-

is eee eee: Meera -aeiee emements The

Sogt is the. service desired bythe airport owner

jncmebaiemhde dines olen as

ypsserviee, . dealing with this~issue, the Federal

ars | should not “substitute its judgment .

i ae

or that of the States or elements of local govern-

ment who, for the most part, own and operate our

“Nation's airports. The proposed legislation is not

© designed to do this and will not prevent airport

= proprietors from eee any aircraft on the

fhe broader policy behind the above quoted letter

June. 22, 1968, was earlier stated, in other terms, in

a ) Secretary's letter of March 1, 1968, to the Com-

- mittee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce of the

een Representatives (emphasis supplied ):

© Local communities should, if not inconsistent with

© — overriding national interest, have the option to de-

“© termine the effects of transportation on their en-

©» vironment. . .

The exercise of this and other authority by local

“communities should continue. Local communities

Select airport sites and determine where they best

- “sponsibility for insuring conipatible land use in

Pig ‘the airport environs. They have the necessary pro-

motional, proprietory, planning and land use

© “authorities to carry out this responsibility. They

have a very influential voice in determining the

bade “type of service they warit through their appearances

* in route proceedings before the CAB. In short.

given the limits imposed by aeronautical tech-

‘nology, the community can and should continue

‘to bear a heavy share of the responsibility for

“assuring the compatibility of the air service they

aed and ae with the environmental objectives

ls

arguments:(see. above) supporting federally issued time

0 a cc a es ioral

swered entelenic:: ee

“paeRpiban exgnttinnt' Wie chathaa nah aR decticn 611

has probably obliterated alt ‘State and “local authority

to issue such regulations is not correct. While States

may not use their police power to regulate in any way

the flight of aircraft for noise purposes, State and local

proprietors of airports’ may deny the use

Of their aitports to aircraft on’ the basis of noise con-

ce asst eae neecaeammemaamame

tory.»

5jPetiahedteg's steguensen 6, ‘nates that the case of

AmnaitiaeasAttiie, Eng ¥. Town of Hempstead requires

that the FAA issue time limitations for the Santa Monica

airport is mot. supportable. While ‘this case stated that

noise limiting rules operating as those of the Hemp

Stead ordinance must come from a Federal source,

the .material quoted from the Senate Report distin-

selsiesinespiteea tone he atic tke by a

port proprietors, to exclude aircraft, using their air-

ports, because of noise: considerations. The Hempstead

ordinance: was not .an action. taken by an airport

ReraR ego tne sleseats oes the sizport

+ Petitioner’s: argument: 8, describing the adverse ef.

Seale Utila ilkgiatt nail teal, Te sik. supported

by any facts-or experience known to the FAA. This

form~of locally responsive noise control is clearly in

the national -interest: in the light of the quoted portion

“of ‘the Senate Report. Further, there is no indication

aa

be discriminatively applied. Hag

alc,

Pe argument 9, covering the unification ob-

tive ‘of the Federal Aviation Act of 1958, is correct

bar as-it describes the need for a single Federal

incy-in the field of the safe, orderly development of

m, However, the Senate Report makes it clear

tport. operators by not requiring an airport to ac-

itservice, so it should recognize the proprietary in-

st of airport operators by not substituting its judg-

ent, so. far as acceptance of noisy aircraft by the air-

wt is conceived, for that of the State or local govern-

ntal elements that own and operate the nation’s

+.qs

3 titioner’s argument 10, covering the uncertainty

ty th $ courts, must be answered directly from the con-

fessional intent expressed in the Senate Report: any

tion that would prevent any public airport proprietor

n taking any nondiscriminatory action to exclude

on the basis of noise considerations would ap-

pear to conflict with that express congressional intent.

7. as stated above, the Senate Report states

it the Federal Government should not substitute its

dgment for that of public airport proprietors on the

es oat eoiee s

r resulting judgments concerning the locally de-

lined need to accept or exclude aircraft on the

is of noise considerations.

8 argument 11, concerning FAA authority

strict operations at Washington National Airport is

valid since the FAA is the proprietor of that air-

os would not be a sub-

= on of its judgment for that of a state or local

ern mental proprietor.

=

Be: ’

soa

airport noise. problem is appropriate at

the reasons. mentioned .above, it should

»stated!in Notice 69-1, that the FAA is

types of operating rules for obtaining

noise levels around. airports, and that, wher

Rie NS RoC ge eR pe

they will be issued as a notice of proposed

making for public comment.

In consideration of the foregoing, I find that the re.

rule making under sections 307 and 611 of the

Aviation Act would not be in‘ the public in-

and that the institution of rule making is not

Therefore, in accordance with sections 11.73

11.27 of Part 11 of the Federal Aviation Regula

the petition of Jordan A. Dreifus for rule mak-

ing under Sections 307 and 611 of the Federal

Ht

it

aie

-

Aviation Act, respectively, is hereby denied.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.