Appendix — United States v. General Dynamics Corp.

Supreme Court brief1974

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

ESR ESE EE EL rn ee

— =

PEST REVIT TIT

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION, THE UNITED

ELEcTRrIic-CoAL COMPANIES, AND FREEMAN

CoaL MINING CORPORATION

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

INDEX

Relevant Docket Entries

Complaint by the United States filed September 22, 1987

Excerpts from Deposition of Frank Nugent, taken September

10-11, 1968

‘Excerpts. from Deposition of Nicholas T. Camicia, taken

September 17, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of John M. Morris, taken Septem-

ber 25 & October 1, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Frank Frederick Kolbe, taken

October 10, 11, 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, 28, 29, 30, & 31, 1968 __

Excerpts from Deposition of Robert H. Inman, taken No-

vember 4, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Joseph C. Tabor, taken Novem-

ber 8, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Thomas J. Tarzy, taken No-

vember 14-15, 1968

INDEX

Excerpts from Deposition of Burl Charles Jensen, taken

November 21, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Thomas H. Latimer, taken

December 8, 4, & 5, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Joseph J. Gallagher, taken De-

cember 12, 1968

Excerpt from Deposition of William I. Kurts taken De-

cember 12, 1968

from Deposition of Martha Terleke, taken Decem-

ber 16, 1968

Excerpts from Deposition of Charles W. Stadell, taken De-

cember 16, 1968

from Deposition of Harold K. Pedersen, taken De-

cember 18, 1968

from Deposition of John P. Maguire, taken De-

cember 23, 1968 8

f ee

a be eee e, ee d eee

„ ee eee

Excerpts from Deposition of P. W. Dorrane, taken March 20,

1969

F

Excerpts from Deposition of Josephine C. Burton, taken

April 14, 1969

p oleae ween Bareree eddies

Excerpts from Deposition of Aldo P. B) azzale, taken April

14, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Clarence V. Beck, taken April

16, 1969

“ie Oe ee ek ee ee te be ee eee ee

=: INDEX

*

Excerpts from

April 18, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Harold S. Walker, Jr., taken

April 18, 1969

. Paty, Nae

Excerpts from Deposition of Fred E Nicosin, taken May 15,

17177... toa certagreneon neers reo 83:

Macetpts trem Deposition of ‘Themas N. Ward, tales May 8,

Excerpts from Deposition of Reuben A. Redard, taken June

10, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Harry B. Gaunt, taken June

13, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Gordon J. Morrison, taken June

20, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of John Samuel Moore, taken June.

20, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Bernard W. Schotters, taken

June 23, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Leroy M. Abrahamson, taken

June 26, 1969

. toe See ee

F eee SoS on ee eS

Excerpts from Deposition of Jobn E. Organ, taken August

ye eee

VTV

Deposition of Winford C. Peterson, taken

ef e@e eee 8

:

INDEX

*

Excerpts from Deposition of Bruce C. Netschert, taken Au-

gust 20, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Abraham Gerber, taken Au-

gust 21, 1969

Excerpts from Deposition of Peter O. Steiner, taken October

7-8, 1969

The Stipulated Testimony of C. C. Smith, dated December 4,

The Stipulated Testimony of J. R. Sinclair, wan Soy 6,

1969, and attached exhibits 1-4

The Stipulated Testimony of George H. Shipley, dated July

10, 1969

The Stipulated Testimony of George B. Knecht, dated Sep-

tember 8, 1969, and attached exhibits 1-10

The Stipulated Testimony of David G. Hemminger, dated

September 17, 1969

a e eee eee eee

17, 1969

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings before Hon. Edwin

A. Robson, United States District Judge for the Northern

District of Illinois, Eastern Division, on October 3, 1969._

Motion of Frank F. Kolbe to be excused from testifying at

trial, and attached letter dated March 4, 1970

i

8

1211112

1018

1037

Page

Excerpts from Transcript of before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on March 31, 1970:

Appearances 1044

Testimony of John M. Morris

‘ 1046

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 1, 1970:

Appearances 1092

Testimony of John M. Morris (resumed) 3

—cross . 1098

Testimony of Louis R. Tomey

—direct 1105

—cross 1116

—redirect 1128

—recross 1132

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 2, 1970:

Appearances : 1134

Testimony of John M. Morris (resumed) ee

—cross : 1135

—recross —___ 1164

Testimony of Reuben Thorson ~~

—direet

from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 3, 1970 :

Appearances 0

Testimony of Victor H. Wood

—direct 1173

—cross

1164

; :

VI

INDEX

: Page

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 6, 1970:

Appearances a 1219

Testimoiiy of A. H. Davis (resumed) i :

—cross 1219 .

—redirect 1227

—recross 1229

Testimony of Ernest B. Tremmel

—direct 1229

—cross 1250

&

Testimony of Reuben Thorson

—cross 1255

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 7, 1970:

Appearances 1262

Testimony of Robert W. Steele

direct 1263

—cross 1269

—redirect * 1279

Testimony of Thomas H. Latimer

—direct 1282

—cross 1284

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 8, 1970

Appearances 1289

Testimony of E. C. Hill

—direct N 1290

—cross 1305 :

Testimony of Richard Drollinger

—direct 1314

vil

INDEX

from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 9, 1970: —

_Appearances

Testimony of George Gamble

—direct

—cross

—recross

Testimony of Thomas Latimer (resumed)

—cross

. ee ee ae ee

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 18, 1970

Appearances

Testimony of Nicholas T. Camicia

T

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 14, 1970:

Appearances

Testimony of Norman W. Moser (resumed)

—cross

—redirect

S n

2

cross

j

g

242 328 &

VII

INDEX

Excerpts from Transeript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robinson on April 14, 1970: Continued

Testimony of John D. Ames

—direct

—cross

Excerpts from Transcript of of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 15, 1970:

Appearances

Testimony of Daric N. Miller

—direct

—cross

Testimony of Frank Nugent

—direct

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 16, 1970:

Appearances

Testimony of Hollie Hopper

—direct

—cross

—redirect

—recross :

Testimony of Frank Nugent (resumed)

—direct

—cross

—redirect

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 47, 1970:

Appearances

Testimony of Thomas L. Craig

—direct

—cross

—redirect

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 20, 1970: ;

Appearances

INDEX

Page

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 20, 1970:—Continued

Testimony of Peter O. Steiner

—direct 1562

Testimony of Robert H. Quig

—direct 1593

—cross 1598

—redirect 1599

Testimony of Peter O. Steiner (resumed)

—direct 1601

from Transcript of Procesdings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 21, 1970:

Appearances 1630

Testimony of Peter O. Steiner (resumed)

—cross 1631

' —redirect 1672

—recross 1677

Excerpts from Transcript of Proceedings held before the

Hon. Edwin A. Robson on April 22, 1970:

Appearances 1678

Testimony of James M. Folson

direct 1681

—cross 1695

—redirect 1711

*Decision of the Merits entered by the District Court on

April 18, 1972 JS. 1a

Notice of Appeal to the Supreme Court by the United States

dated June 7, 1972 1717

Order of the Supreme Court noting probable jurisdiction,

dated December 11, 1972 1718

* Not reprinted in Joint Appendix. Citation is to appendix of

Jurisdictional Statement.

1385

[1507] NORMAN W. MOSER,

called as a witness by the defendants herein, having been

first duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Please state your full name, sir, and spell your

last name. P

A Norman W. Moser; M-o-s-e-r.

Q What is your home address, Mr. Moser?

A 440 North 22nd Street, LaCrosse, Wisconsin.

Q By whom are you ir?

employed, sir

A I am employed the Dairyland Power -

tive with offices at La Wisconsin. e

[1508] Q What position do you hold with Dairyland

Power Cooperative, Mr. Moser?

A I am chief engineer.

Q Do you have anything to do with Dairyland Power

Cooperative’s power production activities?

A I am in charge of power production for Dairyland.

Q How long have you been with Dairyland Power

Cooperative?

A I started with Dairyland Power Cooperative as a

turbine operator in Genoa Plant 1 in 1941. I was trans-

ferred to the general office in 1945 and became chief

engineer in 1951. However, I have been in charge of

power production since 1945.

Q In your capacities both in charge of power produc-

tion and as the company’s chief engineer, have you taken

an active participation in the company’s plant construc-

tion and fuel procurement activities?

A Yes, I have.

Q Would you briefly describe for us the general area

served by Dairyland Power Cooperative?

A We serve the rural areas in western Wisconsin, the

northwestern tip of Illinois, the southeastern portion of

Minnesota and the northeastern portion of Iowa.

[1509] Q Mr. Moser, I am going to hand you what

has been received in evidence as Defendants’ Exhibit

1386

145. This is a map entitled “Service Area, Dairyland

agg Cooperative, LaCrosse, Wisconsin,” as of June 1,

If you would look at that, please, tell me does that ac-

curately portray the specific service area served by Dairy-

land Power Cooperative?

A Yes, it does.

Q What electrical generating facilities does Dairyland

Power Cooperative have, Mr. Moser? :

A Well, we have three generating stations on the

Mississippi River, one at Cassville, Wisconsin, that has

a capacity of about 52,000 kilowatts. We have a station.

at Alma, Wisconsin, that has a capacity of 205,000 kilo-

watts. At Genoa, Wisconsin, we have our original steam

generating station of 14,000 kilowatts, and our two

newest generating stations, a nuclear generating station

of 60,000 kilowatts, and a new coal-burning station that

went into operation last year of 350,000 kilowatts.

In addition, we have diesel stations, one diesel station

at Twin Minnesota, of 10,000 kilowatts, and one

at Chip Falls, Wisconsin, of 3,200 kilowatts, and

a hydro tion on the Flambeau [1510] River near

Ladysmith, Wisconsin, of 20,000 kilowatts.

From whom does Dairyland Power Cooperative se-

cure the coal which is burned at its coal-fired generating

stations?

A Well, since our plants are on the Mississippi River,

we secure the egal from the Belleville ares oF. O coal in

a general rule. are exceptions of receiving coal in

small amounts from other areas along the river.

[15111 Q You indicated that you at some time last

year brought in your newest coal-fired station at Genoa.

When did you bring that into operation last year?

A That station went into operation in July of 1969.

Q Did this materially increase your coal require-

ments?

A By a substantial amount.

2 What did that lead to in terms of acquiring ad-

ditional coal?

A In acquiring additional coal last year, that coupled

with some of the problems in the Belleville area, i

us to get into the West Kentucky fields a little more

than we had in the past. There were several factors.

1387

First, the river was in flood stage, putting locks out of

operation for about one last year that thoroughly

fouled up our shipping ule. We must receive all of

our coal on the river during the time it is open, about

seven months of the year. One of these months was lost

due to flooding.

the flooding of the upper river, the mines in the Belle

this year? I realize the season is not substantially under

way, but thus far this year, have you encountered these

difficulties?

this time last year, we were approaching the flood stage.

At the present time, there is no indicated flood on the

upper Mississippi River.

Q As a result, have you increased, again, your ship-

ments of coal from the Belleville district?

A Yes. The coal is coming fairly well on schedule this

year.

Q I would now like to show you what has been re-

ceived in evidence as Government Exhibit 90, a table re-

ferred to as “Common Known Customers of The United

Electric Coal Companies and Freeman Coal Mining Cor-

poration,” showing destination points. This particular

exhibit is for the year 1967.

[1513] There are similar exhibits designated as Govern-

ment Exhibits 88 and 90 which cover much the same

information but which are for the years 1965 and 1966.

THE COURT: You said 88 and 90. Do you mean 89?

MR. KEMPF: Yes, 88 and 89. I am sorry.

THE COURT: All right.

MR. KEMPF: This is 90.

THE COURT: Yes.

1388

MR. KEMPF: If I may approach the witness, your

Honor—

THE COURT: You may.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q I would now hand you this exhibit and refer you

to page 2 thereof. 8

The first entry on page 2 thereof refers to Dairyland

Power Cooperative. It indicates that Dairyland Power

Cooperative has received shipments at, I believe, both

Sanne Ree ͤ eee

e. ;

My question is, do you consider Freeman and United

Electric to be competitive for the business of those sta-

tions.

A I do not consider them directly competitive. The

product we get from Freeman is dust. This is shipped

[1514] as a by-product to us.

We do have limits in how much we can receive of this

material.

Q What do you receive from United Electric?

‘ain We receive the wash screenings from the Fidelity

ine.

[1515] C What type of purchasing system does Dairy-

land Power follow in securing its coal, Mr. Moser?

A Most of our coal is on long-term contracts.

Q Of how long a duration are these?

A These are from 10 to 20 years. ;

Q eae ane ey Sean eae Ne

ts

A Well, because of our substantial investment in pow-

— why, we must have some assurance of our

What

gn flexibility as much

ners do have to be designed

ification of coal. This deviation from this

to cause operating problems such as loss of

even inability to keep the unit either at its

on the line at all.

narrower.

Q Have you had any experiences where the use

of a type of coal which did not meet the specifications

P3J2ãĩ i?tße 8

A In this new unit, as I mentioned, we had to go to

28 f

5

44

BS

F

8

5

8 8

gE

Rss

8

=

|

i

5

5

18

f .

i

i

F

— * :

THE COURT: Read the answer.

MR. KEMPF: Just the latter portion.

THE COURT: Just the last part.

(Record read by the reporter.)

BY MR. KEMPF:

nuclear-powered

Has Dairyland Power Cooperative made any decision

what fuel will be used at the next station you add

system?

the next station. We are continually comparing nuc-

Unfortunately, we have to look at the air

1390

pollution problems caused by coal. We are looking at

gas and oil as possible alternate fuels.

Q Are any of the coal-fired stations which Dairyland

Power operates, Mr. Moser, near metropolitan areas?

A No, they are not. You wouldn’t think that we

would have the problem of air pollution, but we have

been sued at our Alma station by three farmers in the

area. This suit has led to a landmark decision by the

Wisconsin Supreme Court, indicating that we are a

nuisance and that the farmers in the area have the

right to sue us for damages.

This is damage eaused by what?

[1518] A This damage, the suit was based on damage

caused by sulphur oxide emisions. |

[1519] Q And what was the damage done to? The

farmers individually?

A The damage was done primarily to the alfalfa

crops, some of the trees on the farm, and some damage

to the farm buildings themselves.

Q When did this decision come down?

A This decision came down in December of 1969.

Q Do you and other executives of Dairyland Power

take an active interest in the subject of the regulation

of air pollution?

A Yes, very much so. Our general manager, John

Madgett, was on the President's Environmental Commit-

tee, and at the present time the State of Wisconsin is in

the process of establishing air pollution rules. I have at-

tended a number of those hearings.

In addition to that you might say I am quite a regular

visitor to the City Council of Alma, Wisconsin, and, well,

just last week I had to face some of the teach-in people

that are getting ready for the environmental teach-in

next week.

Q Will the subject of air pollution have any effect

on the fuel purchasing decisions of Dairyland Power

Cooperative?

A It necessarily will have to, because the [1520] reg-

ulations are coming. We in Wisconsin do not know exact-

ly what they will be. We have a general idea that the

proposed rules are very strict on particulate emission.

1391

As yet they have not established a criteria for gaseous

emissions.

Q Are the people in the rural areas you serve con-

cerned with air pollution? i

A They definitely are. They feel that they have clean

air now and they intend to keep it that way.

Q As a result of the impact of the air pollution reg-

ulations do you think this may affect your fuel purchas- -

ing in the future?

A Yes. We have to look at ways of abating the pol-

lution in existing plants and in future plants. It will

have a definite bearing on the design of the fuel that we

burn. The regulations are dictating to us to a certain

extent the type of fuel that we will be able to burn.

[1521] Q Mr. Moser, what effect, if any, does the com-

bined ownership of United Electric and Freeman by Gen-

eral Dynamics have on the competition for Dairyland

Power Cooperatives’ fuel business?

A We do not feel that it has any detrimental effects,

primarily because we use different types of coal from each

of the companies. In our long-term contracts, we are not

sure and United Electric is not sure/of their reserves,

and we feel that in the competitive field of coal, strong

companies are better than a great number of companies.

MR. KEMPF: No further questions at this time.

THE COURT: You may cross examine.

CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. FUTTERMAN:

Q Mr. Moser, you stated on your direct examination

that your company will be forced to consider other types

of fuels in its future decisions. At the present time is

Dairyland Power purchasing any interruptible gas?

A Yes.

Q And you confine those purchases to the summer.

months, do you not?

A Yes. These gas purchases are for the small [1522]

diesel station that is less than 1 percent of our total gen-

eration. a

25 42868 ga 2

11 10 J

ah

f

E

8

E

3

1

8

:

1

3

8

I- IH

a! 11 1 i 10

ill

275

332456 _. 0 iF

Alz 8 2•J11-13 e

ine

ee

100

Be 32

83 9

eu

I AME e ery ies

i 1 , | final 1 15

e

; 2111 “Eycdeelag tected a2

1 sali 2a Hinge ti

14 15 121721 41521744415 say

113.23 4 a ae 22221775

47352 Ait 1

1 efile TE 112145

Q The dust and the screenings are used for the same

3 to generate electricity, is that right?

es.

Q Mr. Moser, in regafd to your testimony concerning

the possibility of using Western coal for the purpose of

electricity, didn’t you tell me that you thought

there might be a shortage of railroad cars which could

WWW

est

iin

3588 ks

1898

11549]

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

No. 67 C 1632

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

vs.

.GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION; THE UNITED ELEC-

TRIC COAL COMPANIES; AND FREEMAN COAL MINING

CORPORATION, DEFENDANTS

Before HON. EDWIN A. ROBSON, Judge,

Tuesday, April 14, 1970,

10:30 o’clock a.m.

PRESENT:

MR. JOHN THOMAS CUSACK,

MR. ROBERT L. EISEN,

MR. RONALD L. FUTTERMAN,

MR. HUGO SIMS, and

MR. RICHARD J. BRAUN,

appeared for Plaintiff;

MR. HAMMOND E. CHAFFETZ,

MR. REUBEN L. HEDLUND,

MR. DONALD G. KEMPF, IR., and

MR. RICHARD H. IRVING, III.

appeared for Defendants.

ALSO PRESENT:

DR. PETER STEINER.

[1554] NORMAN W. MOSER,

called as a witness by the defendants herein, having been

previously duly sworn, resumed the stand and testified

further as follows:

CROSS EXAMINATION (continued)

BY MR. FUTTERMAN:

[1564] Q Mr. Moser, on your direct examination, you

stated that you were not sure and United Electric is

not sure of their reserves, What did you mean by that?

A No, we did not examine their books.

A No, they have not.

Q If I were to suggest to you that the coal in the

McDonaugh-Schuyler County area is a better quality coal

— 2 coal, would you be interested in

t

MR. KEMPF: I am going to object unless the wit-

ness knows where the McDonaugh-Schuyler area is.

not think Mr. Futterman has laid a proper foundation.

BY MR. FUTTERMAN:

Q Doyou know where that area is?

A No, I am not aware.

[1565] Q Mr. Moser, I direct your attention to what

has been received in evidence as Government Exhibit Nu-

gent Deposition Exhibit 38, and I point on the map to

the McDonaugh-Schuyler County area. If you would like

to come over and take a look at it, you can.

Do you have my question, sir?

THE COURT: Read the question.

(Question read by the reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A It is possible. r

it appears that there would be a transportation p

lem, that this would have to go down probably the II-

linois River and back up the Mississippi River.

I know of no loading docks in that area on the Mis-

sissippi River or the ability to get it over there.

prs

Hat ig

8 2

i- f

Futterman’s characterization

THE COURT: Read the question.

Q (Read by the Reporter.)

THE COURT: He may answer.

é

:

:

5

8

are part of his question.

effect?

11

Mr.

1401

BY THE WITNESS:

A Based on an assumption that reserves are not be-

ing developed, it would be adverse to our company.

BY MR. FUTTERMAN:

Q Mr. Moser, do you know that there is a coal un-

ac naid the maven of easels cui ie tomate

contract.

long-term .

S ˙¹1-⁴ w | eee

[1568] A Tes, I have.

ever, we also have the escalation provisions in all of these

contracts, which are tied to supplies and to labor cost.

[1570] Q Is it not true that if the parties fail to

reach agreement with regard to this price negotiation,

7 ˙ A sae

months and is again subject to price renegotiation the

following January?

A That could be a provision. I haven't read that

contract that recently.

Q Would that be a typical kind of a provision in a

long-term contract?

1402

A We have had provisions that the price was subject

to negotiation or subject to negotiation if price did not

meet substantial competition. Now, I am not sure if

that is in the present United Electric contract or not,

that provision.

Q Mr. Moser, at the present time are Freeman and

W supplying the Genoa station?

es.

Q Did you ever have any conversations with any

officers of the defendants, that is either Freeman or

United Electric, in regard to this case?

A With the officers? I believe not.

Q Did you have any conversations with any rep-

resentatives of the defendants in this case?

A We have had some conversations with the counsel.

11578] REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Mr. Moser, ing the course of your cross ex-

amination by Mr. Futterman, he asked you a number of

questions about your developmental nuclear station at

the Genoa location. Do you consider that the company’s

participation in that developmental project has been a

benefit to the company?

A Yes, it has, because we have developed nuclear

capability in operation so that we are in a position to

consider seriously a nuclear station in our next ex-

pansion.

Q Have you made any preliminary cost projections

comparing the cost of fossil as opposed to nuclear for

your next station?

A We participated in a study with the other power

cooperatives in the area. I believe that study was com-

pleted about a year ago for a nuclear station to be

constructed by, I believe it was, five power cooperatives

in the area.

Did the study indicate that it would be more at-

tractive from an economic standpoint to build a nuclear

or fossil plant?

from either Wyoming or Montana.

This morning you indicated that for a comparably-

[1575] Q You indicated that you had spoken with

Mr. Futterman last week. Had you spoken to him on

prior occasions also in connection with this case?

[1576] A Yes, I believe a week or two earlier I also

had a telephone conversation with Mr. Futterman.

Q Would you describe that as a or

conversation?

A I would say it was the greater part of an

Q Mr. Futterman posed a question to you based on

a number of assumptions. He asked you to assume that

a company had some undeveloped deep reserves and that

the parent company had not developed them. I have a

somewhat different but somewhat similar question to

pose to you.

1404

My question is, I want you to assume that a supplier

with whom you have been dealing is a strip mine

operator and has no experience or expertise in operating

a deep mine. If that supplier came to you and indicated

that notwithstanding its lack of experience and expertise

in deep mining it would like to open some

reserves and sell them to you on a long-term

what would your reaction as a coal purchaser be?

A My first reaction would be to want to see his

deep mining capability. If he had only mined strip in the

past, I would have serious doubts about his capability

of mining deep coal.

[1580] GORDON R. COREY, pe

THE COURT: It is nice seeing you. You may proceed.

I don’t know how good he is on coal. You may proceed.

MR. HEDLUND: We will endeavor to find out, your

Honor.

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Would you please state your name and present

occupation?

A Gordon R. Corey, Chairman of the Finance Com-

mittee of Commonwealth Edison Company.

Mr. Corey, how long have you held the position

of Chairman of the Finance Committee?

[1581] A Four or five years, I guess. I have been in

charge of that at the Edison Company for about, nearly

ten

years.

Q Have you been a director for the same period

of Commonwealth Edison?

?

Q Among the purchasing activities for which you are

responsible, is the purchasing of fuel included therein?

do

LF

ö

i

—

F

|

University. I am a Certified Public Accountant in II-

linois.

Q Could you tell me how long you have been with

Commonwealth Edison Company?

A Since 1939 with Commonwealth Edison or Com-

monwealth Edison subsidiaries.

Q Is Commonwealth Edison an investor-owned public

utility?

A Yes.

Do you know how it ranks in size among investor-

owned public utilities in the United States?

A Well, it is second or third, depending on how you

measure it. In terms of kilowatt hour sales, I believe

it is No. 3.

Q Tell me approximately how large the revenues

of Commonwealth Edison were in 19697

A Something like $750 million.

Q What about the assets of the company, just gen-

ally again?

A Net $2.5 billion.

1271

é

il

1406

[1583] That is net $2.5 billion?

BY MR. HEDLUND:

MR. CUSACK: The Government objects, your Honor.

All this information is in Commonwealth Edison’s annual

report for 1969, which is in evidence as Defendants’

Exhibit 90.

THE COURT: All right. Let’s not be repetitious.

A Yes.

Ne 1 „in aa f 3 nar ae

ego E

a! 1 Hee ! 5 “atl a i

512 a git if 2 § 12 15 2 ili 15

328 2214777 1 f SEG Ghn i

5 3.17 il if 1127 11784521731 |

5 Lea 175 it 15 HH

pe iain 15 4

1 177 fey i gi; 134515 121415 i

i HE af j fuajatidilietl 1115

ee 11 ie a

5

3

3

i

2

4

83

He

47815 25

pee 15215

ak

ue

ii

Ht

baa 1 e boy, is

I 12 ff5

1 e i .

— 8 32 13

0 5

5

rf 152

85

eB 5 2 Fie

12 7 15 Tet

tit 138 1 1

bility

satisfactory with respect to safety and the relia

boiling

Dresden

2

|

91 5

which we finally ordered in 1955 for our

station.

9g

on the development of the concept of the

21135

oT

e

i! ial!

A

11554

ine

Ze

11175

222

115

6.28

2s

ita

+

5 —

sua"

tk debit: seston sue Sealine: ⁵Ä—

further proceedings were had herein, to-wit:)

115951 THE COURT: Off the record.

THE COURT: You may proceed.

MR. HEDLUND: Could I have the witness’ last an-

swer? I think I can carry on without it.

1412

THE COURT: You were interrogating on Dresden

No. 2, Dresden No. 3, and the comparative efficiency of

them, according to my notes.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

A Well, for the—well, that is a large order

question, Mr. Hedlund, but costs were declining

time. That is the economics of scale in the power

field were offsetting the costs of construction

75

8

23851.

ts

resented sort of a low point in the construction

and since then construction costs have been risi

13

1114714

1418

4 1 1811317 48

5 10 1111 . min HP i :

oP HUY HED TE

plated oneal §

bid hie agtalpiipa 3

iy 111155 Kai e att

ay iid ape

alias an if vie ee OG

272281 4283 Es 38 1332 8

Fiel

1414

182 2 glgess 1 27 sas P15. a

bad | 151 fu J A Pei |

i ail; 4 17 2 tan Gs

2 | 5 : 223 8 233 i 8 Ad |

: i 71571113. 1 11. 4315 31. 2

Cpe eee Yl e ih eh 1

5 ij 11511115 tea 225 115 isp a i

jailing dt inal dived |

11135 . Haast 1110 3.

e

188 rete Hf 115715 okt;

in a project for the construction of a prototype

down near Fayetteville, Arkansas, which I believe is al-

most completed, if it is not completed.

We: Seve. uy. agin, Sin: are seat, Se,

breeder projects come back brief the top management

once a month or thereabouts in detail as to the outlook

for the future.

I expect that within the next year or so the Atomic

if I may paraphrase it,

environmental program in the city of Chicago, in which

such things have been mentioned as the increased use

5

i

4

:

g

8

5

N

i

:

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, I think Mr. Hedlund

should indicate what he means by “the Chicago area,” or

at least ask the witness what he means by it.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Corey will explain. :

In terms of the stations in the Chicago area that would

be affected by this program, is what the question is

directed at.

—

of low sulphur coal from outside IIlinois.

{1605] Now, of course, those things add up to more

than 5 million tons; but we also have some growth in

our electric usage. We will be using a lot more urani-

um. But so far as the Chicago

have got the additional oil, the

low sulphur coal from the west, and over a period of a

couple of years it will be at least 5 million tons displace-

ment.

Q And the 5 million tons displaced would be, would

it not, high sulphur Illinois coal, that

phur content of 2.5 percent

A Yes.

mately what percent of the coal produced in the State of

Illinois was 3 by Commonwealth Edison?

A Roughly percent.

Q Is there any other investor-owned utility in the

country that you know of that consumes more coal than

Commonwealth Edison?

A No. I don’t believe I have made an outright com-

parison with American Electric Power Company, and I

am not sure when you said “company” whether you were

referring to holding company or operating company.

[1606] American Electric Power Company produces more

kilowatt hours than we produce, and they are a largely

coal-fired generating company. So taking all of their

bel 1115 1411: 2033 1117 *

HE 11 5 i 0 1111 ii 1

f l l it ate 1 i

111. eee { 11 155 11 1171 be 115

Br ary ee e e

lege Ns E 77251 E AE

171 ay l e 1 15

it php 111 ate 1 1 11 testy 14745

ase i 125

and propounded the question to the witness.

THE COURT: Include it.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q The paragraph concludes:

“If we were to pick out one company and say,

‘We are going to give you a long contract,’ obvi

he'll retort, Well, I will give you the best price I

can, but I have to ve escalation,’ and then you

end up with cost plus.

With that added, do the remarks now that I have read

accurately reflect the remarks of yourself and the other

Q Directing your attention to the last full paragraph

on that page, it states as follows:

{1609] “But once you get a mine-mouth plant, you ab-

solutely have to contract for coal to supply it. The

capital cost on the plant is $120 million. The capi-

tal cost on the mine is about $10 million. Obviously

you can’t be put in a position with a $10 million in-

vestor that holds you up because you have your big

$120 million plant sitting beside his mine. So for

all practical purposes, you have to buy the mine.”

1419

MR. HEDLUND: I think this can be done on cross

examination, but I will finish it.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q It continues:

“That is the situation with our mine-mouth [1610]

7

plant may give a false impression that longer term

coal contracts result from the competition with nu-

which you previously have testified with respect to the

subsidiary of Humble Oil?

A No. That is the contract with Peabody for Mine

10.

[1611] d In your judgment, Mr. Corey, for the energy

system of Commonwealth Edison, will nuclear energy

me

of Commonwealth Edison, the fuel

or energy requirements of will

filiated companies ‘since at least 1959. To your knowl-

has that relationship had any adverse effect on

ee

0.

Q Assuming that United Electric neither owns nor

produces coal having a sulphur content less than 2.5 per-

cent and assuming that United Electric or oth-

E

E

ipl li 1

1 fl

thee 3

732

4 731 i

1421

MR. HEDLUND: May we be off the record, your

THE COURT: We will recess now until 2:00 o’clock.

(At 12:15 o'clock, a recess was taken until 2:00

e’clock p.m. of the same day.)

AFTERNOON SESSION 2:00 P.M.

E

1

|

F

|

5

testified in regard to the commitment of Commonweal

it

gE

|

171

F

es.

Q Is it true, Mr. Corey, t the Commonwealth Edi-

son recently has petitioned the Illinois Com-

merce on for permission to set up a fuel sub-

sidiary?

|

a

[1624] MR. CUSACK: I ask the reporter

identification as GX-135 a 6-page document en

of Illinois, Illinois Commerce Commission,

|

to Cause

(The document was thereupon marked as GX-135

for identification.)

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, I Rand you what bas boss sestomt at

GX-135 and ask you, sir, if you please could identify that

Yes.

Q Excuse me. What. is the date of the petition?

A March 26, 1970.

Q Now, the petition states in part, Mr. Corey, at page

1, numbered paragraph 3:

“Fossil fuel procurement has become increasingly

difficult. The growth of nuclear power has had the

effect of making coal mine operators reluctant to open

new coal mines in and near Edison’s territory.”

A Yes.

Q Mr. Corey, is it true that a subsidiary of Common-

wealth Edison Company is at the present time acquiring

coal reserves in Menard County, Illinois, near the town

of Petersburg? ;

acquainted with the location, but we are

1428

Q Would it refresh your recollection, sir, if the land

23) esther crate cules

Q . Can you give us an approximate number?

MR. HEDLUND: At this point, your Honor, I am go-

ing to object. I believe further inquiry along this line

is outside the scope of my direct examination.

THE COURT: The objection is sustained.

[1627] BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, is it contemplated that when air pollu-

tion control devices are developed, Commonwealth Edison

a

f

the only

minemouth

Edison Company at

TH ore

a a

gas

a

:

f

A

:

yes.

955 is it correct, sir, that Commonwealth Edi-

Company constructed the Will County Generating Sta-

around that time? :

A In 1955, yes.

2 WWW

es.

Q What is the approximate kilowatt capacity of that

— Would it refresh your recollection if I said

A That was what was built in 1955, but we also built

a unit in 1957 that was 280,000 kilowatts, roughly, and

then we built another unit in 1963 that was about [1635]

360,000 kilowatts, I believe, so it is about a million kilo-

Foros

F

A Yes.

Q In 1955, Commonwealth Edison built the State

Line generating station, is that correct, sir?

A It built one unit in 1955. The station itself was

started in 1929. Mr. Insull built the first two units there,

I believe.

Q Is this a coal-fired station, sir?

A Well, again, it burns a lot of gas but it burns both

gas and coal.

Q Is it interruptible gas which is burned at this

station?

A Yes.

Q Approximately what percentage of the total energy

consumed at the State Line station is coal?

A I really don’t have these figures in my mind. I

would say roughly a quarter to a third, but when I say

that I am just picking the figure out of the air, Mr.

Q Would it be any more than a third?

A I doubt it.

[1688] Q You are putting in a foundation and a chim-

ney, is that correct, for another unit? i

don’t know about the foundation. We are leav-

on to build the stack high enough and large

enough so that it will take two units.

Q Would you anticipate, sir, that if another unit is

built at Powerton, that is Powerton No. 6, that this

the next ten or fifteen years additional minemouth coal-

fired ting stations?

* 2)%„%*ͤ ĩ V sir?

es.

Q And the 1969 annual report of Commonwealth Edi-

son Company states that:

“Commonwealth Edison Company has already

spent 853 million on facilities to prevent contamin-

ants from getting into the air.”

e

es.

Q And Commonwealth Edison Company also has plans

to spend substantial additional sums, does it not, on air

pollution control devices?

A Yes, ‘we have plans to spend about 160 to 170 mil-

lion dollars on air and water pollution control specifically

without respect to nuclear in the next few years.

This is with respect to sulphur dioxide to remove it.

177871

vt

of money that

Company plans to spend on its

5

8

:

8

8

a

Can you give us an approximate sum

[1641] BY MR. CUSACK:

referred to in the annual report.

1429

approximation of what I think is in that $170 million

And you have done work, have you not, with the

Humble Oil Company in this regard?

[1648] C Now Mr. Corey, approximately how much

money has been spent by Commonwealth Edison

Company in the development of sulphur dioxide emission

control devices on coal-fired stations?

A I don’t know.

Q Could you give us an approximate figure?

A I just am not able to approximate it.

Q Do you anticipate that within the next five years,

Commonwealth Edison Company, either by developing the

equipment itself or by developing it in concert with others,

will be able to achieve or will be able to develop an ac-

ceptable SO, emission control device on its coal-fired

stations.

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, I think there are two

questions in there. My confusion is with the “achieve”

or “develop”.

THE COURT: I think they are nearly synonymous.

He may answer, It is clear to the witness.

BY THE WITNESS:

A Yes.

1430

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, when these devices are developed, do

you anticipate that Commonwealth Edison Company then

will be able to continue to utilize high sulphur [1644]

Midwestern coal?

A Yes, but I don’t quite like your using the word

“continue”. We intend to reduce the sulphur content of

the coal we burn in accordance with the ordinances and

cut well below the requirements in the ordinances that

are now in effect and are pending, and if and when we

get good sulphur removal processes, then I certainly would

expect that we would and should return to using Illinois

coal. But not until that time happens. I am quibbling

over the word “continue”.

I understand. And based on your belief in the

future of Illinois coal, Commonwealth Edison Company is

in the process of developing coal reserves in Illinois

which will be used when Comomnwealth Edison Company

develops these devices, is that correct?

Acquiring coal, you say?

Q Acquiring coal.

A Not developing.

ls that correct, sir?

A That’s right.

>

Q During your direct examination, Mr. Corey, Mr.

Hedlund asked you in regard to some statements made

in Defendants’ Exhibit 93, the interview in the “Nucle-

onics Week” magazine of April 4, 1968, between you,

Mr. Ward [1645] and Br. Behnke.

Mr. Hedlund asked you in regard to paragraph 3 on

page 5 of this exhibit, which I hand you, and the last

sentence in that paragraph reads as follows:

“If we were to pick out one company and say

‘We are going to give you a long contract’, obviously

he will retort, Well, I will give you the best price

I can, but I have to have escalation,’ and then you

end up with cost plus.”

Mr. Corey, isn’t it true that most of the coal contracts.

to supply Commonwealth Edison Company do have escala-

tion clauses?

1431

A Yes.

[1646] Q Could you tell us very briefly what this

escalation consists of? 7

A It has been a long while since I worked on those

clauses, but they generally are rather informal type

clauses that provide for consideration of escalation in

labor costs, in material costs, changes in—well, there was

no provision for changes in productivity so I will strike

that. Also consideration of changes in the coal market

and changes in taxes and miner’s royalties—that is

United Mine Workers royalty provisions.

However, the clauses are not automatic clauses. They

are clauses which provide for periodic negotiation based

on a renegotiation of the escalation provisions based upon

consideration of these factors. It worked quite well.

Q Mr. Corey, isn’t it true that most of the long-

term coal contracts of Commonwealth Edison Company

are constantly undergoing renegotiation?

A I didn’t realize it, but there is a fair amount of,

from time to time, changes or extensions in the contracts.

Our principal problem the last couple of years, however,

has been to get performance. Everyone in the United

States is short of coal and we just aren’t getting the coal

that is provided for in the contracts.

[1647] That, incidentally, does not apply to United

had that we have had almost complete performance under.

Q It is a very fine company, isn’t it?

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, I would like to hear

that answer.

THE COURT: Are you moving to strike it?

MR, HEDLUND: No, I don’t think so. I would like

to hear it back.

THE COURT: Read the answer, please.

(Record read by the reporter.)

THE COURT: You may proceed.

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q United Electric is a very fine company, isn’t it?

A 1 guess so.

it true, Mr. Corey, that for a number of

Commonwealth Edison was almost solely dependent

— Corey, that in the future

t source of energy to the

Commonwealth Edison Company? Given, that is, [1648]

the development of SO, pollution control devices?

A Yes.

your direct 3 Mr. Hedlund asked

64,814,000 tons. The evidence in this case also shows

that in 1967 the total coal production in Illinois, Indiana

and west Kentucky was 129,500,000 tons.

Approximately what percentage of this production was

consumed by Commonwealth Edison Company in 1967?

MR. HEDLUND: I will object. I believe that ques-

tion implies that there was consumption by Common-

ee ee en oe

Indiana and west Kentucky.

is not clear how y

these different 8 Do gots have the

do, give Mr. Corey the figures, and ask if they bough

coal from those states.

[1649] BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, I direct your attention to GX Weir

ition Exhibit 1, which is a map entitled “Tllinois-

— Kentucky Shipping Coal Mines, January

Mr. Corey, is it a fact that the Commonwealth Edison

Company generating stations purchased coal from

throughout the area set out on this map?

THE COURT: The objection is overruled. He may

answer. He may answer if he knows.

THE WITNESS: What is the question?

(Question read by the reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A In what period?

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q At the present time. :

A Well, not exactly. I don’t think we are

“aby Indiana coal. I could be mistaken with

an ‘insignificant amount, but I don’t think we are taking

any Indiana coal at the moment.

[1650] Until we contracted for some west Kentucky

coal recently because we thought we could get some with

a lower sulphur content down there and have been

disappointed about it, we haven’t been taking any

f

0

i

:

5

1

2

FEE

:

:

g

i

i

75

78

16

4

River in West Kentucky, but generally

taking West Kentucky coal except occasionally to make

up shortages.

Q Do you anticipate that Commonwealth Edison Com-

pany will in the next few months be increasing its con-

sumption of west Kentucky coal?

A Yes. We are in a fair spot, however, on that.

We as an interim measure tried to some buy some West

Kentucky coal, and it is a medium sulphur content, and

it is 2.5 percent sulphur, and this is not low sulphur,

but it is lower than Illinois, and we got it for that

171

with these coal producers?

coal than the Common-

in negotiating

with individual suppliers.

Mr. Corey, do you believe that the Common-

? ‘

It is true, is it not, Mr. Corey, that the Tennessee

523 2

1152

a

55

4

75

22

33

ge

275

32

K

if

uP

4

Do you believe that Commonwealth Edison Com-

pany in its purchases of coal is in a better, a worse or

about the same position as TVA?

A You mean as to its bargaining position?

Q Yes, sir.

Would your answer be the same with regard to

A No.

A Yes.

A I think about the same.

Union Electric?

Q

Edison Company is in a

of coal from these producers?

Valley Authority purchases more

wealth Edison Company?

over the Midwest coal p

We bargain

believe that

*

ad

=

215

Edison

110 Ag: 1 rans ;

Tia | i,

127. 2 1 Hie . :

. 8 5 + 35

be

e

“HE 14 111415 15 pul: aL 13 93

Q Wisconsin Electric Power Company?

A Yes.

A Yes.

Company before the Illinois Commerce Commission, do you

to GX-135, the petition of the Commonwealth

t .

i ply

11 3

2335

43237 24 lte 13115

(Question read by the reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A No, I don’t think you can say that because of our

large low sulphur program, and the coal we have been buy-

ing lately, contracting for that is, from the west is com-

i

i

11

f b

«REE

15

.

Te

|

|

i

an effective SO, emission coal device on its

stations do you anticipate the companies

named and including the Consolidation coal be

principal suppliers of coal for Commonwealth Edison?

A I don’t know. It is a distinct possibility, but I find

it hard to predict what will happen or what may happen

if we are successful in developing good sulphur removal

processes.

i

ge

Q How much more expensive, just generally?

[1660] A Well, it is at least 50 percent more and on

a temporary basis as much as double, but we expect that

our

n

„

i LHL

1 111 ay 2 Ku

1 14 i pe de 125 He

e ne

ij api ib, bel eat ae

adit sete

meme a ee te

1440

in the of 1970.

This has resulted in added expenses to Gen-

Electric, is that correct? It was a turnkey contract,

wasn’t it?

A It certainly was, but it has resulted in added ex-

penses to Commonwealth Edison, too.

Q how much?

A I don’t know, but if we measure it in terms of in-

creased fuel costs it is pretty sizeable.

It is certainly measured in the millions of dollars.

Q Have there been some delays at Quad-Cities, too?

A Yes, all the nuclear units, all the first four units

are delayed approximately a year. Excuse me; that is

overstating it a bit, but between six months and a year

due to a very well-known failure of Babcock & Wilcox

[1664] to meet its schedules in fabricating reactor ves-

sels in its Mt. Vernon Plant and this has been taken care

of with respect to the Zion units by our purchase of an

extra reactor vessel.

Q Sir, did Commonwealth Edison Company invite bids

for coal-fired equipment in conjunction with its recent

invitation for nuclear bids?

A No, because we were already building Powertown

5, and we were able to extrapolate very accurately, I

the cost of Powertown 6 would be.

turbine prices are pretty well a matter of public

r

there. What is the question?

Q Would that cost of $215 be accounted for partially

construction schedule at that

that, but is not an important part of the

Q Would this $215 cost be particularly ascribed to

E22 8

[16661 A Yes, I think again we are talking something

on the order of $10 for that figure. I don’t have it pre-

cisely in mind.

It is in the record in our rate before the

x 1442

MR. CUSACK: May I confer with my colleagues,

your Honor?

THE COURT: You may.

116671 (There was a short interruption, after which

the following further proceedings were had herein,

to-wit: )

MR. CUSACK: Just two more questions, your Honor,

if I may, please.

THE COURT: You may.

reserves and my objection is renewed.

THE COURT: Objection overruled. He may answer.

[1668] BY THE WITNESS:

A Well, we have no specific plans for mining coal.

We do hope it will be strip.

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, who in your company would have the

information as to the amount of reserves you are at-

tempting to acquire in Illinois, coal reserves?

A Mr. Beeman.

ee eee

es.

MR. CUSACK: We have no further questions. Thank

you very much, your Honor.

your Honor?

THE COURT: Yes.

MR. HEDLUND: Could I have, then, about five min-

utes, your Honor?

11670] REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Corey, I believe you testified on cross examina-

tion with respect to regulations on air in the

City of Chicago, and you mentioned that those were not

the only regulations that were looming on the horizon, or

A I think so.

ty, Will County and possibly parts of McHenry County,

though I am not sure. I am not sure whether it includes

Kane County. I think it does.

[1671] THE COURT: You do not follow the Chicago

— definition which carries it into Milwaukee,

owa—

THE WITNESS: We stop short of the Twin Cities

anyway.

ee — — — —

stations, directing your attention to the Ridgeland Sta-

tion and its operation in the next year, who are the prin-

cipal competitors for that station?

A The oil companies. The oil companies with interna-

Isn’t it true too, Mr. Corey, that that oil is going

a BTU delivered standpoint more than

:

E

:

[1672] Q So it is fair to say that just taking the

Ridgeland station, the delivered cost of energy per BTU

is not the sole or indeed even the most significant factor

competition between coal and, in this case, oil?

Is it not also correct, Mr. Corey, that as a result—

let me back away that for a moment. In the past you

gr sie hee

es.

Q As a result of switching Ridgeland from coal to

oil, you will be able to use this gas at other stations,

will you not?

A Yes.

2 e e coal-fired stations?

es.

Q So that to that extent the gas will displace coal

sea) other coal-fired stations, will it not?

Yes.

[1678] RECROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Corey, Commonwealth Edison Company does

some fuel on the basis of the lowest price per

delivered BTU, does it not?

11715 8 i 14

maligen zn 4005

1 lth 1 pit

1 Hy! 2 ub 155 Me : 8.

1111 % 444 12

} 1 1 ja a i

233 222 1215 Fay 725572 5 i :

. e

15 : bee 541 f 4 12975 4.8N

e

coal at that sta-

Yes. {

And the new unit that is being built there at the

cor-

A They are working very hard on it, yes.

* * * *

1685] MR. CUSACK: Tour Honor, at this time the

Government ‘moves the admission into evidence of G-

(The said document was received into evidence as

Government Exhibit 135.)

MR. HEDLUND: I have just two quick questions.

THE COURT: All right.

REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Just so the record is clear, electrostatic precipita-

tors which you referred to in your cross examination by

Mr. Cusack do nothing with respect to sulphur emissions

or sulphur dioxide, do they?

tee ee ‘. e “4

nh

pita May

Ade y

rt ah

.

1 U W

i

8

8

i

8

:

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Would you please, for the record, state your name

pulley

11271141

1448

% 7

5 .

4.

:

E

United

t Company of Buchanan, Michigan.

did you first become a director of

949; I am not sure

Equipmen

When

Electric?

A In 1948, I believe, 1948 or 1

which.

director for

And for how long did you serve as a

dent of United Electric?

was presi

7 g

ae

1111

he

11 1!

nll 1

251489

1

14 fl ae os ea

7 7 10 ! i

. yaks : 3°: 2 3:

; 1115 it “il; 117 14%

Ht 1 21125 ta 15

110 1115 1 it 1 1 ab

age stipes ils 14470 Seid

2 14447 - 81

mil

f

id“

11 i an Hee Bf

Ii pedi ay F : 1175 14

abt 15 1441 ane 1.15

15 5 Ht F 16 1411 ty 11271

115 Halle 112 : at tas .

eee

AE Tee 1-711 Pert li-.

If you will also indicate the basis for that, yes.

: The Government objects, your Honor.

Mr. Ames, would you give me your opinion, please,

the competency and ability as a coal executive of

Mr. Frank Nugent?

A Well, I thought he was excellent.

MR. HEDLUND: I have nothing further, your Hon-

or.

THE COURT: You may cross examine.

CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Ames, is it a fact that from 1959 to 1966 when

e

1453

uch.

"OQ Sir, based on your testimony on direct examination

in regard or not the General Dynamics di-

Q Isn't it a fact, sir, that you were on the board of

United Electric there were plans for United Electric

to develop in the future its underground coal [1708] re-

not be able to buy suf-

to remain in business?

indicate to you that in his

never went that far, but there weren’t any strip

111

1122

:

f

i

;

:

ane ee eile

[1715] Q Mr. Frank Kolbe serves on the board of di-

rectors of the Clark Equipment Company at the present

time with you, is that right? .

A That's correct.

Q And Mr. Kolbe is on the executive committee of

Clark?

A That's correct.

2 32300000

A Yes.

Q In regard to the Truax-Traer merger, isn’t it a

fact that the primary ivation for the merger of Truax

ge

with United Electrie in 1955 was that their mines were

very elose together, both in Fulton-Peoria and in Perry

cussion?

A Well, I wasn’t in on any of it. All we heard were

results or progress or lack of it. „

reasoning behind it, except that it would, as I stated

once before, inerease the total reserves of the eombined

companies.

1456

117171

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

No. 67 C 1632

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

v8.

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION; THE UNITED ELEC-

RH COAL COMPANIES; and FREEMAN COAL MINING

CORPORATION, DEFENDANTS

Before HON. EDWIN A. ROBSON, Judge,

Wednesday, April 15, 1970,

10:50 o’clock a.m.

PRESENT:

MR. JOHN THOMAS CUSACK,

MR. ROBERT L. EISEN,

MR. RONALD L. FUTTERMAN,

MR. HUGO SIMS, and

MR. RICHARD J. BRAUN,

appeared for Plaintiff;

MR. REUBEN L. HEDLUND,

MR. DONALD G. KEMPF, JR., and

MR. RICHARD H. IRVING, III,

appeared for Defendants.

ALSO PRESENT:

MR. JAMES M. FOLSOM

DR. PETER STEINER,

A Yes. We are in the process of building a unit of

A It is about 30 percent.

A We haven't been able to find that much oil in

ar fpadicmarron macula te. Aah? we. caey rice

Q When you decided to burn coal as one of the pri-

mary fuel sources at the new Lawrence station, were you

ee ee

es.

Q Which emissions were you concerned about?

A Well, we were initially, obviously, concerned about

eep

were of the opinion that if

of SO., it might be

1460

gift ce et something in the aren of perhaps

MR. HEDLUND: I am sorry, your Honor.

$400,000.

BY THE WITNESS:

A I would suspect in the area of $400,000.

BY MR. FUTTERMAN:

Q Could you very generally describe the mechanics

Combustion Engineering air pollution control sys-

1 1211115

is Tp 11

I i

ATE 3

1

2214147113

131

4

e t

: 1 0 th I

fit 1 if

nies THLE We

1 i th

He THI 1221

Fab

A We are not aware of any that were available at

that time.

yes, I’m sure there are.

you as familiar, less familiar, or more familiar

stack gas emission control systems as you are

Combustion Engineering air pollution control

feel like we have a rather serious familiarity

ith the Combustion Engineering air pollution control

but we are not familiar with the others.

HEDLUND: Tm sorry, I did not hear that

Q Has your Combustion Engineering air pollution

control system performed in accordance with its guar-

ng air

A We have made the guarantee performance from the

unit, yes.

Q Have members of the trade expressed any interest

in your Combustion Engineering air pollution control

We have had a lot of visitors and a lot of

to us on the phone concerning the subject,

will be the sulphur content of the coal burned

the Lawrence, new Lawrence unit?

It is contemplated, in that it is coming out of the

as to what we are burning coal now, that we

believe

trol

plan

our operating

1

bi- ibi 17282

tt unit, I don’t really think there

5

111 33325

CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

=

[1769]

And about how high?

A It extends upward something, it looks like about

100 or 120 feet.

Q

;

840

#

as

;

15

2

8

2

1

243855

15531

21 15

els:

rhea “1

11

something in the area of $8, $8.50,

Ih

fte iid 22

eae < a ie

9

(ul 2 1

i

„ ae

i fate dl i]

K. 1117 1117 855 :

e

He 1 ail

45 ae 15 Bis AR

1111 i lure

I visited it before it went in service.

Have you visited it subsequently?

1 1 gre fips ey aay oy

Hh gia ih : 11 i 2.

4 ae 5 7 12174 24 332 3

8 1 a 22343 ae 8.8 af

3} = 12 3 f 4 : 171 iy 141.

1332 141312 etal y 322 1150 1

tet it iy Hel Ii ..

e t e

tials 1 fiesta tet apt

8 2 eo 1 8

-l F dl

Heat er

8

1

2 F

te

iii 1 451 5

as Commonwealth Edison or

4 N 11784]

that I don't know anything about Commonwealth Edison

or American Power.

FRANK NUGENT,

. difficult to answer unless you

3 But, say, for other than

Obviously, the size of installation of a base load unit

called as a witness by the defendants herein, having been

first duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:

EE

far as installation in service, to 500,000 kilowatts.

11827]

days.

I do not intend without reason to

MR. HEDLUND: As your Honor is aware, Mr. Nu-

gent’s deposition was taken for some three or four

THE COURT: Yes.

MR. HEDLUND:

recross ground covered at that time, nor do I intend to

repetitive.

THE COURT: All right.

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

For the record, please, sir, would you state your

name and present occupation.

BY THE WITNESS:

11828] i President of Freeman Coal Mining

and President of United Electric Coal :

Q Would you please, sir, for me please de-

scribe your background and experience in the coal in-

dustry.

A I have been in the coal mining busines for about

50 years starting—

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, may I object here.

I think it would save time. I asked Mr. N quite

extensively in regard to his qualifications. It is in the

deposition. I really think it is repetitive. It is in evi-

dence. I I went into it with a fine-tooth comb. I

realy don k it is necessary we all know Mr. Nu-

gent’s

THE COURT: You agree to his qualifications and

background as stated in the deposition?

MR. CUSACK: I certainly do, your Honor.

MR. HEDLUND: I did not mean to go into this with

a fine-tooth comb but just to hit the high spots in terms

of what he was—

THE COURT: Well, it is in the deposition. Let’s pro-

ceed from there.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, when did you first become affiliated

[1829] with Freeman Coal Mining Corporation?

[1830] I that since 1922 you have been with

8 = Corporation as well as others?

es.

MR. HEDLUND: I do not believe this is in the depo-

2 Would you please describe your function for Gen-

eral Dynamics in your capacity as group vice president

Mining Corporation.

A 8 of Material Service and the president

of Marblehead Lime report to me. I am associated with

the Asbestos Corporation in Canada as a member of the

board.

Q You became, did you not, president of United Elec-

tric upon the retirement of Mr. John Morris?

A Yes, sir.

Q How long did you serve in that capacity?

A Mr. Morris retired in November of 1966. I took

over as president to January Ist, 1968.

Mr. Camicia was president from January of 1968 to

April Ist of 1969.

I again took over on April Ist, 1969.

Q You have continued to serve in that capacity since?

118311 A Yes, sir.

Q Mr. Nugent, I hand you what has been received

in evidence as Defendant’s Exhibit 48, and hand it to you,

which is a letter, a printed form letter, dated December

15, 1954, on the letterhead of the Chicago Wilmington &

Franklin Coal Company to the stockholders of CW&F

Coal Company, and signed by George B. Harrington as

president.

Without meaning to characterize the document, but

in the interest of time, I note that this is in effect an

we dat ie a at a ce

I note that in the third paragraph, referring to an

offer that has been made, it states:

party was to

in effect, who is going to acquire

gape igen

1954, i etc Gada ebad tedama ua

+ oe.

i

8 8

a4

ask you, if you know, who the other

1122 11

nee 2 Ae

gs ee, a

ee ee a

*

A Yes.

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, that is in the deposi-

tion very There is no dispute on that matter.

THE COURT: He may answer. That is not going

into it in any great detail.

MR. HEDLUND: I believe he answered, but could

we have it read back?

THE COURT: Read the answer.

A (Read by the Reporter.)

14

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, when, if you recall, did the Crown in-

525632

47 J % HE rt;

11 1. 1 Hs 11239

47 hy 12 kee

2" 8 8 15 ar g 0 4

afr 111111 RH

rE ila 11 .

3 1452 = 88 27427.

py ro LM beth

1 417 2323812315 Heal

0 fd tartare

thie 1 iL 115 $582:

United Electric, continue thereafter?

A Yes, sir, it did.

*

1478

If you recall, at Board meetings—let me stop

Just for purposes of trying to develop this logically,

eS ee ee ee eee

Q

Al fats 15

Iii =

420405

that I suggested to Henry Crown

; and Henry Crown was

there should be a merger

to strike, unless the witness lays a founda-

of Freeman and United Electric?

I think L ean say

1474

iat tien atin met

See eee nhs Ax kee aes he

Hahn

G2 GOT Hilie Ge

Ht 15 1 +.

ill Mie ah ued UE

a tid ane it

1 1 li 11

iyi Wate 11 i

1 1 il 127434

1 l i-

MR. CUSACK: Yes, I have one.

MR. HEDLUND: Do you have a copy for the Court?

(Mr. Cusack tendered a copy to the Court.)

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, may I interrogate the

)!!!! AB gone a ak agi

THE COURT: Yes, you may.

MR. CUSACK: May I join you?

THE COURT: You certinly may.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

in evidence as Maguire Exhibit No. 1, which

is a document dated November 24, 1959, to the share-

holders of General Dynamics the

Dynamics.

Is this merger to which you have just been testifying?

A Tes, sir.

—

1476

wy General Dynamics was interested in merging wih

Material Service? '

A Les, sir, it is.

Q C

The directors expect to achieve this diversification

through development of commercial products stemming

from present programs such as”—and I would like to

take these seriatim.

Number one, the Corporation’s Convair 880/600 jet

transports. '

— What has happened to that program, if you

A Both have been discontinued.

11844] Q It also says, second, Canadair’s. commercial

turbo-prop CL-44 and CL-540 aircraft.

What has happened to these programs?

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, the Government objects

to this line of questioning as being wholly immaterial

and irrelevant to the issue of this lawsuit.

This lawsuit concerns the merger of United Electric

and the Material Service-General Dynamics, and elimin-

ation of competition between Freeman and United Elec-

tric.

THE COURT: Do you have any comment?

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, there is a raft of

evidence offered with respect to General Dynamics by

the Government in this case, and I think that this is

clearly related to that.

1 COURT: He maySanswer, subject to the objec-

BY MR. HEDLUND:

with to the

: er respect turbo-prop

BY THE WITNESS:

A The CL-44 was a spring tail turbo-prop freighter,

Agra oper |

ee but we

262

1477

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, I hate to be picayunish,

but the Government did not order General Dynamics to

divest itself of Liquid Carbonics. It was ordered by the

District Court.

I think counsel should stipulate to that.

THE COURT: Was it in an action filed by the Gov-

ernment?

MR. CUSACE:: Yes, your Honor, it was. But it is an

11846] order of the Court, not by the Government.

THE COURT: All right, the record may so show.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, there is in evidence the fact that at

a Board meeting of General Dynamics of May 25, 1961,

the following:

He outlined the reasons why it might be advisable

sell part or all of the stock

8

of such companies,

1478

that authority be granted to take

Mr. Nugent, I show you what has been received in

as ci Seiecliony teins & ahaak to a tether treme

7 as President of Freeman Coal Mining Corporation,

221274 125

not at that time on the

dated February 5, 1959.

question is, you were

United Electric, were you?

Mr. Frank F. Kolbe, President of the United Electric

I think not.

12335

442115

rn

ve your proposed plan for Buffalo Creek.”

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, I will be moving into

high wall.

1479

[1849] THE COURT: We will go for another 15 min-

utes, to make up for some of the time we lost.

By MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, I hand you ‘what has been received

in evidence as Defendants’ Exhibit 23, which is a three-

page—I’m sorry. I stand corrected. A five-page document,

the first page of which is a memorandum on the memor-

andum stationery of Irving Crown, bearing a date of

6/1 5

Attached to that is a memorandum from JMN to

Frank, dated June 11, 1964.

Attached to that is a three-page draft titled “Presi-

dent’s letter to 8 a

My first question is, vou identify the initials on

the first memorandum on the stationery of Irving Crown?

A It is Irving Crown’s writing, and it is his initials.

Q And does the “Frank” refer to you.

A Tes, sir, it does.

Q Was that memorandum actually prepared on July

16th of 1964?

Qin 1966 what responsibit :

1964, t responsibilities, if any, did [1850

Irving Crown have with respect to United Electric?

A He was on the Board of United Electric.

Q Could you, Mr. Nugent, please, decipher the writ-

ing, read the writing that appears on the memorandum

from Irving Crown.

A “T note all comments are bullish on future. No

hint t we are reaching end of line on reserve replace-

ments? Please see.”

MR. CUSACK: May the record show that there is

a question mark after ts”?

THE COURT: I think the record speaks for itself.

Is this in evidence?

MR. CUSACK: Yes, you Honor, it is. But I thought

perhaps for the purpose of the i

THE COURT: Well, all right.

Proceed.

1480

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, what is dust?

A Dust is fine coal that is removed from, let's say, a

one and a half inch by Zero coal generally for customers

that are prepared to pay a premium price for coal from

which dust is 5 g

Q What is the practice in the past to dispose or

otherwise throw away the dust that was so

11851] from the coal that you have described?

A There were times when, in the initial stages, that

the dust just wasn’t marketable. It presents a handling

problem. And in the early stages we threw it on the gob.

pile. Later we found a market for it. It was sold at a

price under the cost of production. However, the com-

bined realization from the dust and the double screen

size or premium product was profitable.

[1852] Q Then is it true that in the sale of dust by

Freeman, if you will, that you do not actually lose money

by such a sale?

A Les, sir.

And when you say that it is sold below the cost

of production, this is an unallocated cost of production,

is it not, among all of the coal, oil—

A Sold below the minimum run cost of production.

Q Is there any incremental cost in selling dust or

ing dust for sale above and beyond the production

costs for the coal of the sizes from which dust has been

removed?

A Tm not sure that I understand that question.

MR. HEDLUND: Read the question.

THE COURT: Read him the question.

Q (Read by the Reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A If you mean do we incur an additional cost because

we do produce this, yes, we do.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q And you are able to recover that additional cost,

are you not?

A Yes, sir. Yes, sir, we are.

Q You spoke of the difficulties of handling dust.

[1853] Could you tell me what those are, please?

MR. HEDLUND: I would like to hand to the Re-

porter to mark as a defendants’ exhibit—if I may, could

I go off the record?

THE COURT: You may.

MR. CUSACK: Just a minute. May we have a copy?

[1854] MR. HEDLUND: Yes.

(The document was marked as Defendants’ Exhibit

No. 229, for identification. )

118551 BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q I ask you, Mr. Nugent, is the information set

forth on this document with respect to the estimated deep

tonnage dedicated to existing mines of Freeman and

other coal reserves of Freeman true and accurate to

the best of your knowledge and belief?

A nde Poe mn

Q is totals, it not, in the

hood of 488 or 480 millica tone of ena” ee

8 Well, I haven't added them, but I would accept

t.

1482

Q Could you give me an estimate of approximately

what percent of these reserves have a sulphur content of

less than 2.5 percent?

A The coals produced by Orient No. 3, Orient No. 6

arid Orient No. 4.

Q Are in the category of sulphur content less than

2.5 percent?

A 2.5, I thought you said.

Q Yes, 2.5.

A That is right.

Q Would that then mean that all of the reserves as-

signed here to Orient No. 3, 4 and 6, all or substanti-

ally all would be in that sulphur category?

[1856] A Would you state that again, please.

THE COURT: Read the question.

Q (Read by the Reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A Yes, Orient No. 3, 4 and 6.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

2 Your answer is yes, they would be?

A Yes, sir.

Q Would you be able to give me an estimate as to

what percent of the reserves shown on the second page

under the title “Other Coal Reserves” are in a sulphur

content category of 2.5 percent or less?

A All of the Jefferson County reserves may not be

below 2.5 percent. The northern part of our acreage

could well run a little bit above that.

Now, all of the reserves assigned or that may be

assigned to No. 3 and to No. 6 will run in the neighbor-

hood of 1.5 percent in sulphur.

The reserves on the first page assigned to 3 and 6 are

somewhat flexible in that we could use additional re-

serves not now assigned at some future date if it appears

to be economical.

eU see that the totals for Jefferson and William

Counties—those dre the counties for Orient No. 3, 4,

[1857] 5 and 6, are they not?

.

1483

see these total—

A I can’t say that of the reserves unassigned in

‘Williamson County will below 2.5 percent in sulphur.

Q Could you give me some estimate as to roughly

what percentage it would be?

A It would be a guess. I would say half.

Q What about Jefferson County?

A Jefferson County, again, that is not clearly defined

in that the reserves that will be assigned to Mine No. 7

may not all run below 2.5 percent.

Mine No. 7 is the mine that is planned for future date.

Q Of the 97 million tons in Jefferson County, would

half of these reserves be less than 2.5 percent sulphur or

would it be more than half?

A Probably less than half.

[1858] Q There is an advertisement in evidenee, Mr.

Nugent, referring to, I believe, the plans of Freeman to

open up Orient No. 7, Orient No. 8, and a new mine in

central Illinois. What is the status of those plans, if any?

A We have abandoned the idea of opening No. 8. We

had put a manned shaft, a new manned shaft at the

2 ĩ ͤ v

0.

We have room now in reserves only for one more mine

in Jefferson County. That would be No. 7.

Q Would you be able to estimate when Orient Mine

No. 7 will be open?

A Well, not at this moment. We haven’t completed

No. 6. As soon as we get No. 6 finished, which will be

sometime the latter part of this year, we will then go to

work on No. 7. :

Q Can you tell me approximately what you estimate

is for—well, let me ask you this first. What was the

total production’ of Freeman in 1969?

A I would say about 8 million tons, and that is a

guess now. =

What is your estimate for the production of Free-

man in 19707 :

A It will increase. We cut back at No. 5 because

[1859] of some roof problems that we had there. That

mine was producing about 2 million tons a year. We have

1484

cut it back to 1 million tons a year, perhaps a little more.

Orient No. 6 is now producing at the rate of about

8,000 tons a day. By the end of the year, we should have

it up to 12,000 or 13,000 tons a day.

Q Mr. Nugent, I show you what has been received

in evidence as Defendants’ Exhibit 35, which is a copy

of a coal contract between United Electric Coal Com-

panies and Central Illinois Light Company, dated Sep-

tember 30, 1968. I direct your attention to the supple-

ment of that contract and a portion of paragraph 3,

about in the middle, where it reads as follows:

“In the event that prior to the expiration of this

contract reserves of seller in the No. 5 and 6 seams

of coal in Fulton County are exhausted, seller will

make shipments under this contract from present

or planned mines of Freeman Coal Mining Corpora-

tion located in the central Illinois field where the

company has reserves of No. 6 seam coal approxi-

mating 400 million tons.”

My question is, to what does that 400 million tons

refer?

That is coal in place rather than recoverable [1860]

What percentage of recovery—

It is about 250 tons of coal recoverable at the out-

You say 2507

250 at the outside.

Million that would be?

250 million tons at the outside. That could well be

on the high side.

Mr. Nugent, is there a possibility that the Cuba

will close this year?

why?

Well, we are into old works there; we are running

difficulty. When our tonnage gets down to something

300,000 tons a year, it won’t be economical to con-

o operate it.

Why does old works interfere with strip mining?

2. g

I POPOs poke p

tee kos

3

8

2

8

of Fi

1485

A We are digging the No. 6 seam coal. The No. 5

seam underneath it was mined many years ago.

Q Would that have been by deep mining?

A By deep mining, yes.

Q What sort of problems does that pose?

A It is an unstable area.

[1861] Q Are there any properties at the Cuba mine

that you were unable to purchase?

A Yes. We had a tract of land there that for many

years we thought we should acquire, known as the Mur-

phy tract. We though it contained a million and a half

tons of coal. . ate

We couldn't understand why this man wouldn't sell,

and be included in our reserves, because we were able to

pay and could well afford to pay him three times the

value of his farmland. We just did not acquire it. He

would not permit us to drill it and we could never get

an option to drill it. We have mined up to it and around

it.

It now appears that there was not a million and a

half tons there. We ran into some voids and some wash-

outs.

Had we been able to acquire the Murphy tract, we

could have acquired a tract beyond that known as the

Phillips tract. We have given up, of course, and moved

away and their equipment is gone.

We never will know why Mr. Murphy wouldn’t take

a times the value for his land, but it belonged to Mr.

In terms of your mining operation at Cuba, [1862]

would had feasible to move the equipment back, to try to

come to pick up this acreage if Mr. Murphy ever |

changes his mind? 2

A No, sir. We have burned our bridges behind us.

Q Do you recall approximately what the estimated

tonnage was in the Phillips’ tract that you were also

A Well, v= and. I t a

not t wasn’t as great, of course,

but it was a worthwhile piece of land.

THE COURT: Would now be a good time to break?

MR. HEDLUND: Yes, your Honor.

1486

THE COURT: All right. We will recess unti 10:00

o’clock tomorrow morning. Unless unexpected

comes up, we should get started by 10:15 or 10:30 at the

latest and go all day.

Thank you.

(The hearing in the above-entitled cause was recessed

to 10:00 a.m., Thursday, April 16, 1970.)

1487

[1863]

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

No. 67 C 1632

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

vs.

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION ; THE UNITED ELECTRIC

CoaL COMPANIES; and FREEMAN COAL MINING CorR-

PORATION, DEFENDANTS

Before HON. EDWIN A. ROBSON, Judge,

Thursday, April 16, 1970,

10:30 o’clock a.m.

PRESENT:

MR. JOHN THOMAS CUSACK/

MR. ROBERT L. EISEN,

MR. RONALD L. FUTTERMAN, 2

MR. HUGO SIMS, and

MR. RICHARD J. BRAUN,

appeared for Plainitff;

MR. HAMMOND E. CHAFFETZ,

MR. REUBEN L. HEDLUND,

MR. DONALD G. KEMPF, JR., and

MR. RICHARD H. IRVING, III,

appeared for Defendants.

ALSO PRESENT:

MR. JAMES M. FOLSOM

[1864] THE CLERK: Case on trial.

THE COURT: Good morning.

Are there any matters to take up with the Court be-

fore proceeding?

COURT: All right, have the witness take the

(Witness duly sworn.)

HOLLIE HOPPER,

called as a witness by and on behalf of the Government,

was examined and testified in rebuttal as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

O>OporoZoz rorore

1

5

8

y

position did you prior to that time?

General Superintendent of Mining Operations.

How long did you hold that position, approximately?

Nine years.

In reference to your Sun Spot Mine, Mr. Hopper,

the Sun Spot Mine of Ayshire been profitable in the

11

TE fe

tall i fe

i

ear

88 . 1 4445 25

1 EAL

14541577471

15 = 134.

Fee “fs E21

ae

2 4 fl WW WEE M!

3 8 35 g 4 5 ei :

ie . moo Hdd 278

woul si ia agg

ad pa ie te me

8 * * | — 2 2

1 i 1 ane . dy ra

5 34471117 ipsa? 12888821435

A-: ite 15 eite

we have

plans. However,

determine the final

that will

42 Hrd,

ial

3 tel |

:

:

i

3

:

5.

15

15

1

A We have no definite

feasibility studies underway

outcome.

1492

Does Ayrshire plan to open up any new mines in

I think it might be helpful if we

$i] FPA on

191 af il 11 if!

Fal! i ate te

Uns i is lz AA

pay: ff i 1711141117135

111575 4 Br 11 11117 135

128 57 41545 lid] speprs bial

pe cee ai 111 wil 18522

bil lee l.

oP

CUSACK: That is all, your Honor. Thank

—

THE COURT: You may cross examine.

you, sir.

ms

8

—

—

1494

MR. HEDLUND: May we have just a moment?

THE COURT: All right.

(There was a short interruption, after which the

following further proceedings were had herein, to-

wit:)

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, could we have a brief

recess?

THE COURT: I will be recessing again at 11:30.

MR. HEDLUND: Then if we could have just a couple

more minutes.

THE COURT: You may. Let us proceed.

(There was a short interruption, after which the

P

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, I beg leave of Court.

Mr. Futterman reminds me I have to ask one slight ques-

tion, and I would appreciate—

THE COURT: Any objection?

MR. KEMPF: No objection.

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Hopper, prior to Ayshire’s acquisition [1876]

of the two deep mines which you have testified about,

was Ayshire solely in the strip mining business prior to

that time?

A Yes.

MR. CUSACK: Thank you, sir. Thank you, your

Honor.

(There was a short interruption, after which the

following further proceedings were had herein, to-

wit:)

THE COURT: Cross examination.

CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. KEMPF:

' Q Mr. Hopper, isn’t it true that during fiscal year

1967 Ayrshire’s Sun Spot Mine had a rate of return on

investment of roughly between 4 and 5 percent?

MR. CUS ACK: Objection, your Honor. The testi-

mony [1879] was that it had acquired two mines,

MR. KEMPF: My question would clear this up.

1496

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Did you acquire two companies known as the Little

Betty Coal Company and the Carmac Coal Mining Cor-

poration?

A Tes.

Q And they operated the Little Betty and the Car-

mac Mines?

A Yes.

Q You indicated that even someone with more ex-

perience and expertise, in your view, probably would

not have operated the Thunderbird Mine successively.

My question is: Isn’t it quite possible that someone who

did have a greater amount of experience and expertise

in deep mining at that time would not even have opened

the Thunderbird Mine?

A Well, this is entirely possible. This is a case of

judgment.

Q You indicated that the mine was not profitable.

Isn’t it a fact that within two years after the opening

of the mine it was so clear that mine was not going

to be profitable over its life that Ayrshire at that time

wrote off $5 million of its investment in the [1880]

Thunderbird Mine?

A This is true.

Q And I gather that since that time operating losses

have continued?

A Operating losses have continued at that operation

for every year of its life except, I believe, for two fiscal

years.

Q And that was opened in 1959, you testified?

A Yes, sir, it was.

So that in the 11 years, nine of those 11 years

ete 9 has lost money on a operating basis?

es.

[1881] Q In your judgment, Mr. Hopper, if Ayshire

had it to do over again, do you think it would be likely

that they would open the Thunderbird Mine, in view of

what they now know?

A In view of what they now know, absolutely not.

Q Mr. Cusack questioned you about Ayshire’s ex-

ploration activities in Illinois, Indiana and west Ken-

1497

tucky. I would like to ask a few questions along the

same line.

Did Ayshire investigate the possibility of strip re-

serves in Menard County around Petersburg?

A Petersburg, Illinois?

Q Yes.

A Yes.

Q After exploring for reserves in Menard County,

Ayshire decided not to take any options in that area,

isn’t that true, Mr. Hopper?

A This is true.

Q One of the reasons leading Ayshire not to take

options in- Menard County was the fact that Ayshire

questioned the strippability of those reserves that were

located there in view of the depth of the coal and the

unconsolidated nature of the overburden, isn’t that true?

[1882] A This is true.

Q In view of the fact that in addition to United

Electric, Ayshire also investigated and turned down coal

reserves in the Menard County, wouldn’t you agree that

it would be improper to regard United Electric’s failure

to acquire the reserves located there as an indication

that the company was not making serious efforts to

increase its strip reserves?

MR. CUSACK: I object. It calls for speculation on

the part of the witness.

MR. KEMPF: I think this witness is qualified to an-

swer that, your Honor. Mr. Cusack called him to testify

to these matters.

MR. CUSACK: It is pure speculation, your Honor.

THE COURT: The objection is sustained.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Let me look at it a different way. I think this

will overcome that objection.

Wouldn’t you agree, Mr. Hopper, that the fact that

a coal company had devoted time and money to the in-

vestigation of the field such as that located in Menard

County, that that is at least one indication that the

company is making serious efforts to enlarge its strip

reserve holdings?

1498

[1888] MR. CUSACK: Same objection, your Honor.

THE COURT: The objection is overruled.

BY THE WITNESS:

A Yes. I think it would indicate that the company

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q I would like now to ask you about another area

of reserves in the state of Illinois.

Ayshire investigated, did it not, the coal reserves con-

A Yes, sir.

Q At the time of its initial investigation, Ayshire

pot ne ene Ahab e e

pars seed

analysis of the characteristics of the coal, that the field

was not economically strippable?

A Well, I would rather say that it was not—I wouldn't

that it was was not economically strippable. It might

not be an economical operation because we could not

correlate the analysis of the coals to come up to those

analyses as representative of the [1884] field. We had

did reconcile and find what our problem was.

A Well, he had very detailed information and a great

deal of information. Probably the greatest problem that

we encountered in our failure to recognize and support

his analysis was that we did not recognize the procedures

or the manner in which he had obtained his cores and

channel samples for analysis, and this basically was our

problem in not being able to correlate

118851 Q And asa result of that problem, you initially

“ore 1 in that field, is that correct?

e

1499

Q You know also, do you not, Mr. Hopper, that both

Peabody Coal Mining Corporation and Stonefort Coal

Mining Corporation also investigated that field and also

dropped interest in that field?

A I have heard that—I understood that Peabody Coal

Honor, the last answer.

MR. KEMPF: He has indicated he understood this

had happened, and he said he had not heard of the other.

Why don’t we have the answer read back?

THE COURT: I heard the answer. It may stand.

Proceed,

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q I will now ask you a question similar to my ques-

i

eB

Fe

i

1

8 ‘

t

ek

that company was making serious efforts to enlarge

strip reserve holdings?

[1886] MR. CUSACK: I object, your Honor, on

ground that it calls for speculation by the witness.

THE COURT: The objection is overruled. You

have a standing objection to any similar question.

MR. CUSACK: Thank you, your Honor.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q You may answer, sir.

A I think it is a clear indication that they were at-

tempting to find and presumably acquire additional re-

F

1

|

f

E

:

would have to compete, such as specifically Ayrshire's

own Denmark strip acreage?

1500

A Well, I can only answer for that portion that re-

lates to our Denmark Deep, not the Round Prairie, be-

cause e ee eee

coal more cheaply in our strip Denmark field than in

the deep Denmark area.

[1887] MR. CUSACK: Will counsel stipulate that the

situation at Denmark is the same as at Round Prairie,

as indicated by his question?

MR. KEMPF: I will indicate to Mr. Hopper—

I will not stipulate because I am, obviously, like the

witness, he is not familiar with our property and we are

not familiar with his.

I will indicate, however, that the coal is very close to

the field that United Electric owns known as the Round

Prairie Field.

BY MR. FEMPF:

Q Is that not true, Mr. Hopper?

A Yes, I am sure that is correct.

Q Isn’t it a fact, Mr. Hopper, that in attempting to

sell the coal from the Denmark Deep area competitively,

it would be at a competitive disadvantage from a trans-

portation viewpoint in comparison to other deep reserves

held in the Belleville area such as Peabody’s undeveloped

reserves along the Kaskaskia River?

A If and when the Kaskaskia is canalized, they

will be in a better position freight-wise to offer coals to

the market.

Q Isn’t it a fact that the higher sulphur content of

the Denmark Deep acreage might be another factor fur-

ther delaying the development of those reserves?

[1888] A Yes. I believe I stated earlier that I thought

that, due to the new environmental legislation that is

being passed, that it place these reserves in a doubtful

position for their mineability in the very near future.

Q Mr. Cusack asked you about the Denmark strip

acreage. How long did Ayshire control the Denmark

strip acreage before the decision was made to open a

mine there?

A Well, we have held the Denmark strip acreage

since either the year 1926 or 1927.

1501

Q So, that is over 40 years?

A Yes, that is true. We acquired it at a tax sale.

Q Mr. Cusack also referred to the fact that since

1960, mines haven’t been opened on new strip reserves.

MR. CUSACK: I did not refer to that, your honor.

That is not the question I asked.

THE COURT: Would you read the question.

[1889]. THE REPORTER: “Q Mr. Cusack also re-

ferred to the fact that since 1960, mines haven’t been

on new strip reserves.”

MR. KEMPF: “Have” is the word I said, not “haven’t.”

ee CUSACK: I did not ask that question, your

onor.

My question was “Do you know of any other coal

producer which have acquired new strip coal reserves

for the possible development of a new mine in Illinois

since 1960?” ;

MR. KEMPF: I stand corrected.

THE COURT: All right Revise your question.

MR. KEMPF: Yes, your honor.

BY MR. KEMPF:

i

2

A

8

S

1

answer.

MR. KEMPF: I think this one clearly follows up

[1890] Mr. Cusack’s question.

THE COURT: I have ruled. I said that if the witness

knows, he may answer.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Would you like the question back, again?

A Iam not quite sure I understand the question.

. * 1502

THE COURT: Would you read the question, please.

Q (Read by the Reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A Well, if I may, I believe there are two questions

to be answered there. At least I see it as a two-part

question.

THE COURT: Lou are quite right.

BY THE WITNESS:

A No. 1—

THE WITNESS: Ves, sir.

THE COURT: All righ

11891] BY THE WITNESS:

agree with the 30

where in the future.

Now, the other part of the question that I believe I

understood, some of the reserves that have been ac-

* + ern be in the future, I can foresee

they could be immediately

BY MR. KEM:

Just as developed its Sun Spot reserves

shortly after their acquisition?

b (MEE .

!

E

iia 117533

Feilen i

22

A

*

1504

THE COURT: To rebut evidence introduced by the

defendants.

MR. KEMPF: If I might, your Honor, if Mr. Cusack

will stipulate that none of Mr. Hopper’s testimony in any

way rebuts any of the information in this exhibit, I

will be happy to withdraw my line of inquiry.

MR. CUSACK: No, you Honor, I wont.

— COURT: All right. The objection is overruled

MR. KEMPF: Can I have the question re-read?

THE COURT: Read the question.

THE COURT: Can you ask the question

—

2

1505

MR. KEMPF: I have folded the map, your Honor,

to the area which I will be referring to.

THE COURT: All right.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q Would you step down, please.

A Yes.

MR. CUSACK: May I join you?

THE COURT: You may.

MR. KEMPF: I will only be having a few questions,

your Honor, if the witness may stay here.

THE COURT: He may.

BY MR. KEMPF:

Q The Sun Spot Mine is close to the Chicago, Bur-

F

es, sir.

[1896] Q The town of Industry is not near a rail-

road, is that correct?

MR. CUSACK: Objection, your Honor, as being be-

the scope of the direct examination. The Govern-

a railroad,

4

between 800,000 and 900,000 tons per

have been withdrawn from that

between 7 and 8 million tons of coal at

length.

no further questions with regard to the

?

te capital

practice

tely $30

usual

pproxima

may resume the chair, please.

complying. )

PPP

“ee the approximate annual production of

foot?

the normal estimation for cost of a railroad

gal

23281 f

ae ile ar EG

2

9 iin elt

:

a

a

85

<

3 BY MR. KEMPF:

a ,

9 3 393851 432 f 14 45 2 i, as

! 1273 f. 11 i & 75 i i . 110

F 75 play 1 | g i 53 2397

: HE i 1 : 111 iis Mi i

g * n i i E 1122 | 152125 152 1 f

e e e fide |

TH 11 pe aH ie

a atieeydenue- tual fp teettt

eli, Ri- Hi 42 He

1508

it your opinion that two fields

each other, one on side of the road,

other side of the road, and that

completely different equation in determining

it is an economically recoverable field of reserves?

Every field of coal is an individual within its

i and each has its own peculiarities.

MR. KEMPF: Your Honor, I am just about done, if

I might confer with my colleague for a moment.

THE COURT: You may.

(There was a short interruption, after which the

following further proceedings were had herein,

to-wit: )

THE COURT: Proceed.

BY MR. KEMPF: 8

Q Iam going to ask you two questions, Mr. Hopper,

[1902] based on some assumptions. I want you to make

the following assumptions:

U

And assume that the reserves of these mines will be

exhausted in, say, from two to fifteen years, depending

upon the mine.

va Ga

I petal de

2 15 1 445 1

gas 25423 25 7

JJ a | 117

gia] bey! Ab dts

i e OHE

1 Hy aa 11335 1

them within their

I have no further questions,

THE COURT: All right. We will take a five-minute

operate underground

(There was a short recess, after which the following

further proceedings were had herein, to-wit:)

difficulty in

119041 MR. KEMPF:

your Honor.

11906]

REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. CUSACK:

4

t

1

1

f

;

‘

}

1

1

f

1

|

1510

.

reserves in IIlinois available

| that there was approximately 304

aq

those facts, it had to be.

't the general reputation of Paul Weir that he

Isn

Lb Ay i

{f pie 1 i

ies ee

1 ie e te

. An aii git

1435 mandi? 15. a

18 54 . 5 335 nibh

ELE Te DL Hee

TSS i

ing tools.

20 If the Industry Field could be mined with equip-

a0 45 80 isllen abd opehaaint oe te ben on

20 to 30 miles, which equipment was repair, was

paid for and had fully been depreciated, would this be

an important factor in making a mine which was other-

wise thought to be marginal a profitable operation?

A Yes. It would be a very important factor, but you

give me very little information to base a judgment on,

because there are many other factors. I haven’t the

slightest idea of the capability of a tool you may be talk-

ing about.

Q Isn’t the cost of new stripping equipment the major

cost involved in the opening of a strip mine

A A reasonably good rule of thumb is that your major

stripping tool could very well represent nearly 50 percent

of your capital investment.

[1909] Q Mr. Hopper, what do you expect to be the

average.

[1910] Q Do you expect it to be under 30 to 1 on an

. ?

For short periods of time it could be, because when

we speak of average overburdens of for instance 30 to 1,

then during the given period of measurment there are

times when you must be under 30 and times when you

are necessarily over 30 to obtain your average.

Q But for the average continued life of this mine you

would 3 that it would be approximately 30 to 1?

4A Yes.

Q And you wo phones Sun Spot Mine to be profitable

for its remaining

A Yes. We hope for it to be.

Q And in your best estimate, do you think it will be?

1512

A Based on present day trends, I am sure it will be.

2 d Ayrshire benefit from its experience in

regard to the opening and operating of the Thunderbird

Mine

] developed into a strip mine?

A Yes. I know that it is being developed.

Q aide eine Seen: ie ee oo

10 years by a corporation engaged in the deep min-

ing business, do you think it is likely that the strip min-

ing company would make plans to go into underground

mining on its own?

A Are you specifically referring to a complete sepa-

rate entity that would be controlled only by the strip

operation?

Q No. I am talking about a strip mining company

which is controlled, its ownership, its stock control, is in

the hands of another corporation, which is also in the

deep mining business in the same area—based on that

assumption, do you think that it is likely that the strip

mining company would make plans to go into under-

ground mining on its own?

MR. KEMPF: Your Honor, I am not sure I under-

stand the question as it has been modified. Could you

restate it, or could we have it read?

THE COURT: Read the question.

Q (Read by the Reporter.)

MR. KEMPF: You refer to “also in the deep mining

business”, which I do not think your question intended.

[1912] I am not sure.

THE COURT: Are you objecting?

MR. KEMPF: Yes. I don’t understand the question.

At first I thought he had indicated that one was not in

the deep mining business. This latter question indicates

that the other company is also in the deep mining busi-

ness, and I am not sure what Mr. Cusack means.

MR. CUSACK: I will rephrase my question.

THE COURT: Rephrase your question.

1513

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q_ Assuming, Mr. Hopper, a strip mining corporation,

which is controlled by a corporation engaged in the deep

mining business in the same state—do you think it likely

that the strip mining company would make to go

into underground mining on its own?

A Well, I suppose this would depend largely on cor-

porate set-up, but just in answer to your question, I

would certainly think that the strip mining company as

such would not go into the underground mining, but the

company controlling, since they had underground talent,

that they would develop the underground operation rather

than the strip portion of it.

119131 MR.CUSACK: May I have a consultation with

my colleagues just for one moment?

THE COURT: You may.

(There was a short interruption, after which the

1 further proceedings were had herein, to-

wit: —

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Hopper, do you believe that in the future your

company will consider acquiring strip coal reserves in

Schuyler or McDonough Counties, Illinois? I direct your

attention, sir, to—

A That is the area west of our Sun Spot operation?

Q Yes, sir.

F

Excuse me. Where is Brown County?

MR. CUSACK: Mr. Sims, if he may, your Honor,

could locate Brown County for us.

THE COURT: All right.

MR. SIMS: (Indicating)

BY MR. CUSACK:

2 Undicating.)

11914] A Well, we, Ayrshire, are in a position not to

1514

turn down any strip reserves that are of sufficient num-

bers j

Q And Ayrshire is continuing to explore for these re-

carry on an exploration program completely

And you are still prospecting for strip reserves in

Illinois, sir?

A Yes. \

MR. CUSACK: Thank you very much, Mr. Hopper.

THE COURT: Is there any recross examination?

MR. KEMPF: I have one question, your Honor.

RECROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. KEMPF:

nomic mine the course of next five to ten

years in the area of those counties, which is located on

»a line through Industry or west of there, and you can

look at the map, if you would like, sir, to assist you in

making that determination.

A We have done exploration in this general area, and

we don’t think there are reserves of any sizable amount

in the area. We do know, of course, there are small pods

of coal, but they certainly aren’t large enough for any

5

r

1515

[1918]

FRANK NUGENT,

called as a witness by the defendants herein, having been

previously duly sworn, resumed the stand and was exam-

ined and testified further as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

(resumed)

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, would you explain, please, the back-

ground and the function of the corporation and facility

known as Rail-To-Water, Incorporated?

A It is a device that was built a good many years

ago to transfer coal from railroad cars to lake vessels.

Q Is it still in operation?

A Yes, sir.

Q Who owns Rail-To-Water, Inc.?

[1919] A Its stock is owned by a large group of coal

companies. Those same coal companies own some bonds

on the facility.

Does United Electric utilize the facilities of Rail-

To-Water, Inc., to any substantial degree?

A No, not directly. I believe that we have taken

some coal from the Fidelity Mine and mixed it with coal

from southern Illinois in a lake vessel.

Other than that, over the past two or three years,

has United Electric placed any substantial tonnage across

that facility?

A No, sir.

Q Mr. Nugent, reference has been made in the record

by the Government to a possible—well, I don’t know

whether the word was “merger” or “affiliation,” but ei-

ther way, with the Sahara Coal

What if any problems would be involved in such a

A Well, I think some very serious problems. Sahara

employees, workers that belong to the Progressive Mine

Workers Union that are classified by the United Mine

Workers Union as being non-union workers.

i

5

<4

48

‘i

[1921] G Is that the ad in which there is an

A Yes, sir.

apple?

I don’t know what—I think I know

1517

MR. CUSACK:

Honor.

It is the Common Customer chart,

: Oh, yes. If you need it, I don’t need

good notes. N

1001 ae

2 7 l :

145 14 10 105 35 1 1

of U

Freeman Coal Mining

points, 1967.

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor,

witness so that I

10 it

75

A 111

—

Q Mr. Nugent, I hand you what has

in evidence as Government Exhibit 90

entitled “Common Known

Coal

8

the

the

A No, sir. The rate would not be

freight rate would not be competitive.

MR. HEDLUND:

your Honer.

THE COURT

Light Company, had the two companies been independ-

ent, would those shipments have been competitive?

A Again, the coal from the Crown Mine to the Spring-

field plant of Central Illinois Light Company was sup-

plied by truck. The freight rate from the Crown Mine

or Springfield area to the Peoria market would not be

competitive.

Q With respect to the shipments in 1967 from the

M

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, I have to interject an

objection at this time. Mr. Morris during his direct ex-

amination and cross examination went into this most

fully. I think it was at least a half a day. I think this

— repetitive. I think the testimony is identical to Mr.

orris’.

[1925] On that basis, I object.

MR. HEDLUND: Well, I asked Mr. Morris these

questions for 1965 and 1966.

Would the Government stipulate that if I go through

with Mr. Nugent on similar questions, that his answers

for 1967 would be the same?

MR. CUSACK: I believe they would be.

MR. HEDLUND: You will so stipulate?

MR. CUSACK: Yes.

ts ga yt All right. Let the record so show,

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Just to add one last item with respect to these

shipments as discussed by Mr. Morris and as would have

been discussed by you pursuant to the stipulation, what

percent of the total production of Freeman Coal Mining

Corporation is represented by dust?

up by Free-

?

1 7

nion

by

wi

the approximate yearly

1 1 14

Hay id cet

8 71115 11 : 2273 74475 144713775

1172 3 19 9 * Bel

?

a contract been signed between United Elec-

:

:

.< 4

published by McGraw-

portion of the state?

detail.

the names of people who buy coal?

you familiar with the Keystone

generally describe what the func-

and who it is sent to?

Mining Corporation has in the past

American Maize Products Company, has

what is the annual tonnage on that

I think it is about the same.

gone to gas.

~

all of the coal mines in the United

reference book

0 &

—

111.

—— 1 1415

r g.

5

i

:

ue

3

ih

4 5

Q Is that in Roby, Indiana?

A Yes, sir.

lt is in the northwest

A Tes, sir.

A Yes, sir.

Hei 2

it | 5 32

4 l : 11535 5 123

5 rE 12 a4;

iat : sul a

aa hun bi

1 3 7 2 ai

AMET OTE EAL

35 345 try 8 7271

them like

t of any

i

1 ily bee

12115

H- fil ee

—

8

7

qf.

1 17 4 4

g eee

— eee eee — = —--

1522

Q Was United Electric in any position to be able to

bid on that contract?

A No, sir.

Q Are you familiar with the solicitation for bids by

Union Electric for its Sioux Units 1 and 2?

119321 Q Could you tell me what they were asking

for on those contracts with respect to duration of con-

tract and tonnage involved?

a ee

MR. CUSACK: Would you please fix the date—

BY THE WITNESS:

A It may have been—

— COURT: Just one moment.

es

MR. CUSACK: Excuse me. Would you please fix the

date on these negotiations for purposes of the record.

[1933] MR. HEDLUND: For Sioux 1 and 27 I be-

lieve I have done that for Labadie 3 and 4.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Sioux 1 and 2—when were those solicitations, if

you recall?

A Well, I would have to guess, Mr. Hedlund. Prob-

ably five years ago.

MR. CUSACK: I object and move to strike on the

grounds of guessing. Speculation.

THE COURT: Well, his best estimate. Let’s not get

technical. We will be here for another two weeks.

MR. CUSACK: Withdraw the objection, your Honor.

THE COURT: All right.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

I am sorry, sir, but what was the tonnage and the

length of contract?

A 1.5 million tons and I think it was a 10-year con-

tract with perhaps an option for another 10, and that

— mepetinling price at the end of the

years.

Q Was United Electric in any position to bid on that

contract?

factor in coal’s ability to compete? |

A Oh, yes, a very significant factor. With the de-

velopment of nuclear power, that could well be enough

to exclude coal.

Q Are you familiar, Mr. Nugent, with the loans made

by United Electric to General Dynamics in the fall of

19667 5

A Les.

THE COURT: Will this be extensive?

MR. HEDLUND: I will not conclude with him

(Whereupon, at 12:25 o’clock p.m., the hearing in

the above-entitled matter was recessed to 2:00 o’clock,

p.m., the same day and date.)

[1936]

AFTERNOON SESSION 2:20 P.M.

FRANK NUGENT,

called as a witness by the defendants herein, having been

previously duly sworn, resumed the stand and testified

further as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

(continued)

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, are you familiar with the loans made

by United Electric in the late fall of 1966 to General

Dynamics?

*

~

we were receiving on the certificates of [1937] de-

had been purchasing.

leres

mm 6

8

Q Mr. Nugent, following the merger of the old United

Electric into the new United Electric and upon its be-

coming a 100 percent, or rather a wholly owned subsidi-

ary of General Dynamics, from that point to this very

day were there any capital expenditure requests sent by

United Electric to New York for approval that were de-

nied or modified in any extent?

A No, sir.

[1938] Q Were such expenditure requests in fact for-

warded to New York?’

A Yes, they were.

MR. HEDLUND: Does the Government have Maguire

Deposition Exhibit 47?

Your Honor may still have retained a copy of this

exhibit as one of those that was claimed to be privileged.

THE COURT: They are in my chambers some place.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Mr. Nugent, I show you what has been received

in evidence as Maguire Deposition Exhibit 47, which is

a memorandum dated November 1, 1966, from Mr. A. R.

Finberg to H. K. Pedersen, the subject of the memo-

randum being the UEC tender offer.

Have you seen this document before, Mr. Nugent?

A Yes, sir.

Q Directing your attention to the second page of this

document, the last sentence of this memorandum says:

“NB: The funds referred to in this paragraph

are to come to the bank not from General Dynamics

but from the United Electric Coal Companies which

testify.

THE COURT: Motion denied.

[1940] BY MR. HEDLUND:

made a vigorous and strenuous effort to adddi-

Sane cence ty Sheen he ee Bere eet

A Yes, sir.

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, the Government objects.

The witness—he read from board of directors minutes

There is nothing in that minute that indicates a vigo-

rous search for coal reserves in the State of Illinois.

THE COURT: All right. Restrict it to that, with the

right to ask any question.

[1942] BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Were the reserve activities of United Electric con-

Q Mr. Nugent, did you or anybody else connected

with United Electric that was at the same time con-

nected with Material Service or Freeman or _General

A No, sir.

Q Are you absolutely certain of that?

A Yes, sir, I am.

mining possibilities that had come to the attention of

United Electric.

With respect to any and all of those, was it ever your

intention that if those opportunities proved to be eco-

nomically feasible, that the profit from those operations

1527

would adhere to Freeman rather than to United [1943

Electric? :

A No, sir. Rete

Q In point of fact, did Freeman ever take title to

as much as one ton of deep coal that had been brought to

its attention by United Electric? |

me, sir, what information you do

ith that?

A Well, the TVA, we understand, or rather I under-

proposal for the development of what is

Rive acreage which is directly east

non-union operation in Alabama would be operating a

union operation in Illinois, and it ‘would be [1944] most

poration.

acreage

A The Alabama acreage is extremely low in sulphur,

much under 1 percent.

Q Much under 1 percent?

A Yes.

Q Do you know whether this proposal is on a both

or on an either/or basis?

A They must take both.

Q Mr. Nugent, there has been a considerable amount

of testimony in this case and evidence in this case, as

recently as this morning, with respect to the so-called

Industry Field of United Electric. I know that you have

F

le.

f

i

2

1

15

1

.

A No, sir, it is not. There was a time in the

part of 1960 when I suggested that land

at farm prices, that I felt perhaps this

mined after all of the coal in the Fulton

hausted, and that could be some 20 years hence.

117

5711

pared up to some of the more recent material.

Yes, sir.

Are you asking me if that is in the 1965 report?

Yes, sir. ;

Dees Madris; eee secret, sale?

es,

ow could you please explain to the Court, sir,

nited Electric and Freeman

as :

can act as a back-up for the coal sales of United Electric?

A I think I can. I have a very strong feeling that we

ago, or yesterday I believe it was—that when that [1976]

nuclear power is turned on, this market will not be as

it is today, and United Electric needs to have its

under contract, because it will be near the end of

line. In order to accomplish that, we backed it up

Freeman tonnage, and that is the only way the coal

—

A About 72 percent.

How much of the coal was sold, approximately

what percentage, to steel companies for metallurgical

purposes?

A 8 percent.

Q And would the remainder be sales to industrial

11977] users?

General industrial users. Son

Approximately what percentage pro-

was sold to utilities?

Perhaps a little higher than that.

Soros

S

—

.

1

5

8

to general industrial users?

A Les, sir.

Q You testified this afternoon regarding the loans

made by United Electric to General Dynamics. Do you

recall that?

A Les, sir.

Q These loans were repaid, sir, after United Electric

was merged into General Dynamics, is that correct?

A Yes, sir.

[1978] MR. HEDLUND: I am going to object, your

Honor, to the characterization. This has been done be-

fore, and I think the record should show. United Electric

not merged into General Dynamics. United Electric

was

was merged into United Electric. It remains a 100 per-

urpose

MR. CUSACK: Yes. I submit it is a bit of a quibble.

THE COURT: All right. Let’s proceed.

Are you ready to answer?

THE $

MR. CUSACK: I believe he answered it.

THE COURT: Did he answer it? All right. Proceed.

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Sir, this repayment of the $2 million loan of United

Electric to General Dynamics—

ey e Gk may:

1 i ö ii

ici „ fet inn

pl f 15 45 * 5

aff 1 a uh fe 155. atl 3

ane ae 1 11 1 % = &

Hitt 72215721111 8 Ms 121% f

1 ae yee 8 A111 5 8

-i i-

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q You testified, sir, regarding the Belle Rive prop-

erty at Mt. Vernon.

A Yes, sir.

Q This property is being developed by Merle Kelce,

is that correct?

A Well, I don’t know that that is entirely correct.

He have a partner.

On what testimony og ggg ag dae tr

your testimony regarding ve property

On a conversation with TVA. This is not a public

This is a negotiated deal, and the deal has not

made public as yet. When it is concluded, [1981]

In the meantime, there

on the street, which apparently you have

up. That acreage was first called to United Elec-

e's attention in 1928. We went into it again in 1964.

1964, Mr. Y: „who at that time owned the prop-

who owns it presently, then represented that he

tons.

some of the gossip on the street doesn’t quite

as they were presented to us by Mr. Young.

How many tons are in the field now, if you

E

wii

15

f

i

ai

1111

5 5

Q What is the overburden?

A It is pretty high. I have forgotten.

Q Isn’t it over 75 feet?

A It is over 75 feet, and the quality of the coal has

not been definitely determined. The sulphur content

— from 2 percent to 5 percent. We don’t know which

t

ls it No. 5 or No. 6 coal?

= It is a bastard seam coal. It has no characteriza-

[1988] THE WITNESS: May I have the question?

THE COURT: Rephrase the question.

Q Isn’t it a fact, sir, that Mr. Robert Hepburn of

United Electric believed that when United Electrie’s Ful-

A Not at all. Mr. Kolbe frequently had said that he

knew nothing about markets, that he depended

upon Johnny Morris, that Johnny was a good salesman.

I [1984] agreed with that in total.

salesman than Mr. Morris. But

Q Isn’t it a fact that Mr. Morris

Q If it was worth no more than that, why didn’t you

dispose of it?

A Why didn’t we dispose of it? We can’t find any-

body foolish enough to buy it.

Have you ever tried?

A Yes. I would hate, I just wouldn't have the guts

to offer the Industry Field to anybody in the coal busi-

ness. It would be an insult to one’s intelligence.

Let me give you an example, if I may—

60 KE COURT: I think you have answered the ques-

on.

MR. CUSACK: May I have five minutes, your Honor?

Can we take our break now? I think I can finish up in

about 10 minutes with i

THE COURT: All right. A five-minute recess.

(There was a short recess, after which the following

further proceedings were had herein, to-wit :)

[1987] THE COURT: Yes.

MR. HEDLUND: The witness certainly did not tes-

tify with respect to the competition between these two

companies in 1955 to 1959.

MR. CUSACK: Well, would you stipulate that United

Electric and Freeman were in competition from 1955 to

19597 Then we can shorten this.

He may answer. You may proceed.

BY THE WITNESS:

A The question was, did I discuss prices of Freeman

coal and United Eleetrie's coal during that period of

time?

Q With Mr. Morris.

[1988] A With Mr. Morris, I can’t say that I went

back as far as 1954, but during that period, I discussed

prices of United Electric coal. The prices Freeman coal

were of no concern to Mr. Morris. I was policing the

United Electric Sales. Mr. Morris was not policing Free-

man sales.

Q Because during this period of time you controlled

United Electric?

A n

Q Please answer by question.

THE COURT: Read the question.

(Question read by the reporter.)

BY THE WITNESS:

A If “control” mean 51 percent of the stock, no we

did not. We had four members of a 9-member board in

1959. |

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Prior to 1959, did you consider that you controlled

United Electric?

A No, sir.

[1994] BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Is it over $4.25 a ton?

yes.

&

:

;

1

i

.

2

8

i

1

2

No. Fidelity relates to the Bellleville District field.

You say the price is different?

The price in the Belleville District field, because of

the difference in transportation, of course, is different.

I am talking about f.o.b. mine.

f.0.b. mine price, yes, it would be different

Banner. There is no relation between the Belleville

and the Fulton County field. There is a relation

between mines in the Fulton County field.

POP Po >

4

8

EF po

a

[1999] MR. CUSACK: Could you hand Mr. Nugent

copy of [2000] Defendants’ Exhibit 228, please. I know

you have one for the Court. You used it on direct.

MR. HEDLUND: I am not arguing with you, Mr.

Cusack. I am looking for the document.

MR. CUSACK: I think it may expedite it if I just

go over it with the witness. aie

THE COURT: All right.

MR. HEDLUND: It is Exhibit 229.

MR. CUSACK. I am sorry.

MR. HEDLUND: You need a copy, do you, for the

witness, Mr. Cusack?

MR. HEDLUND: (Handing document to witness.)

BY MR. CUSACK:

Q Mr. Nugent, directing your attention DX-229, the

first page, it states that the estimated deep tonnage of

the Crown mine is 20,719,000 tons.

A Yes, sir. :

Q Is that all high sulphur coal, sir?

A Yes, sir.

Q Orient No. 3 estimated deep tonnage of 33,582,000

tons. Approximately what percentage of that is under

2

— apres meer tg oe nee — —

ON 1538

2.5 percent sulphur and what percentage is over 2.5 per-

cent sulphur? :

120011 A All of Orient No. 3 is under 2.5 percent in

the first page of this exhibit, are under 1.5 percent sul-

phur?

rere lere

FK

E

8

—

REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Isn’t it true that these acquisitions were in the

form of an intra-corporate transfer of assets?

A Yes, sir, they were.

Q You referred to the purchase of the Erwin stock.

Was that a stock held by J. Erwin Miller?

4A Yes, sir.

@ He was 2 member of the board of United Electric,

was

A He was at an earlier date, but not, I think, at

that time. I am not sure about that, though.

Wich respect to the Defendants’ Exhibit 63 on the

1

your

ve,

I ha

all

is

t

tha

1540

12012]

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

No. 67 C 1632

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

vs.

Gm Dentists Comonirsait: Tie Dieb H

Coal COMPANIES; and FREEMAN COAL MINING Conro-

RATION, DEFENDANTS

Before HON. EDWIN A. ROBSON, Judge,

Friday, April 17, 1970,

10:30 o’clock a.m.

PRESENT:

MR. JOHN THOMAS CUSACK,

MR. ROBERT L. EISEN,

MR. RONALD L. FUTTERMAN,

MR. HUGO SIMS, and

MR. RICHARD J. BRAUN,

MR. JOHN SARBAUGH,

appeared for Plaintiff;

MR. HAMMOND E.

MR. REUBEN L. HEDLUND,

MR. DONALD G. KEMPF, IR., and

MR. RICHARD H. IRVING, III,

MR. SAMUEL HAUBOLD,

appeared for Defendants.

ALSO PRESENT:

MR. CHARLES BANE,

MR. JAMES M. FOLSOM.

8

THOMAS L. CRAIG

DIRECT EXAMINATION >

BY MR. EISEN:

Q State your name, please, and your address.

A Thomas L. Craig, 506 Lake Elbert Drive, Winter-

haven, Florida.

THE COURT: Will you spell your last name, Mr.

Craig?

THE WITNESS: C-r-a-i-g.

THE COURT: All right, the common way.

BY MR. EISEN:

Q By whom are you employed?

A Tm employed by Wellman-Lord, Incorporated.

Q C

A Just over two years. 5

120351 95 What is your position at Wellman-Lord, In-

12034]

Tuscola, Illinois. I then spent two years with Common

wealth Oil Refining Company of Puerto Rico in their

New York office, all of which jobs were in the manufac-

turing end of the business, or the technical manufactur-

ing end of the business.

I then rejoined United States Industrial Chemicals for

a year, and following that I worked for two and a half

years for International Minerals and Chemical Company

out of Skokie, following which I went into business for

myself, and then joined Wellman-Lord.

ee e generally of Wellman-Lord,

ni ee ee ee

A Wellman-Lord is an engineering construction com-

pany to the fertilizer chemicals and industrial i

industri ä

generally. 4

[2036] Q Could you explain generally what your duties

are with respect to air pollution control.

A Well, I am, as I said, manager of pollution control

for Wellman-Lord, it’s a staff position in that I am

responsible for the ini ion of nearly all of our

activities in the of air pollution control. I, for a

consen

grams; I supply for our Marketing Depart-

ment; I do or have done for me economic and technical

feasibility studies, for ourselves and for clients as they

require it.

Q In the course of your duties, have you become fa-

miliar with the research and development of processes

designed to remove or recover sulphur oxide emissions

from stack gases?

A Yes.

Q Could you tell us briefly what the history of that

activity has been.

Q Generally.

A Well, over the past five years particularly there

t be > — =

of

[2037] stack gases. It started, I would say, about 1966

really in intensity, and the over-all activity has increased

rather dramatically since then.

Q Could you give us the reasons for that increase.

A The statutes country-wide on SO, levels in the at-

mosphere have been made just drastically more stringent,

let’s say, than they had been, and where they have not

been made more stringent, let’s say, the enforcement of

older statutes which had hitherto not been given the time

of day, are certainly being pressed more actively.

Q Could you name the companies and organizations

engaged in developing and perfecting these devices today?

A Well, II start off

1543

there are a number of companies, plus agencies. We have

Monsanto, CHEMICO, Combustion Engineering, Univer-

sal Oil Products, Consolidation Oil—I am sorry—Consoli-

dation Coal Company, I believe, the Division of Conti-

nental Oil, in the United States.

word Q ESSO Research also, or did you mention

t

A No. ESSO Research has announced that they are

active in this field.

Q Where is the Universal Oil Products installation,

if any? Do they have an installation?

A No, they don’t. They have announced an installa-

tion.

Q Where is that to be located?

A It’s going to be in the greater Chicago area some-

where, and I’m not sure as to the exact location.

Q At a Commonwealth Edison generating station?

A I believe so.

Q

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Mr. Craig. I’m sorry. ey

I would like to ask you a question, that is, about a

statement made by Mr. Garvey to the Joint [2039] Com-

mittee on Atomic Energy of the United States Congress,

which is contained in-Government Exhibit No. 272:

(Reading) “During the past 10 years I have on

numerous occasions appeared before committees of

Congress and other governmental agencies to testify

on the ‘state of the art’ of control of sulphur oxides.

At one such appearance before the New Jersey State

Department of Health on October 6, 1967, I said:

‘With all the activity by various research organiza-

tions, we are confident that an economically attrac-

tive approach for the recovery of sulphur oxides from

flue gases will be available in the next three years,

1 45 tah Fl i: i

i

1544

purpose of

your

two and

ave oe

minute. Is there

is, your Honor

is highly

Eisen

the basis

out that

the

24-hour

in

evidence or

if it

a coy af

date of

copies of

introduce

that?

to offer i

ted to the

defendants.

t is true,

in

abided by.

11 115 114 15 i 1124112.

tilt es 155 5 ae

ue Phe: 5 ig

* om

I did not hear the latter part

MR. HEDLUND: And not to be used as an exhibit

to examine witnesses on.

I do not understand, your Honor. I was

just going to ask him to state whether or not in his opin-

ion that was an accurate prediction, or if he agreed with

12041 THE COURT:

that statement.

of your statement.

The statement was made February 25, 1970.

MR. HEDLUND: That is not true.

THE WITNESS: Your Honor, may I ask—really, the

conversation has got me

THE COURT: Will you restate the question.

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Mr. Garvey was quoting a statement that he had

previously made on October 6, 1967 before the State

of New Jersey Department of Health, where he said:

(Reading)

N

A Was that the three to eight percent?

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Three to eight percent. =

some recovery to produce

a saleable product?

A Yes.

Q Would that factor affect the increase in cost with

the installation of a pollution control device?

Engineering process,

as saleable. In fact, they may not be saleable at all.

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Is it possible that with one of these recovery proc-

esses through the sale of the recovered chemical, that a

utility might install such a process without any increased

cost to itself?

1 I cannot give you a yes or no, but I strongly doubt

Q If there was a chemical plant adjacent to an elec-

trical generating station which could use the recovered

THE COURT: The Court directs that you answer.

MR. EISEN: Your Honor, I have to apologize. I did

renin ca acne I will withdraw the question

now.

[2048] THE COURT: All right.

MR. EISEN: I apparently have surprised the wit-

ness with the question, so I will withdraw it for now.

MR. HAUBOLD: Your Honor, I move to strike the

prior question and answer.

THE COURT: Which one, the Court’s question or Mr.

Eisen’s question?

MR. HAUBOLD: Reluctantly, the Court’s question.

THE COURT: It may stand.

Hi 71 98233 gags 5

e a

i in e 4

i e i

ee

1 hy l. 115 1 : 1 11 i

cee ME Ae

e

4

}

}

years

do that yourself, or was that in conjunction

A were seven parties involved in the founding

and the operation of the plant.

-Q Other corporations or municipalities? [2051] Gov-

ernmental bodies?

The second biggest problem was the inability to keep

JJ. ee ey

Q T

A We switched from a potassium based system to

A Yes.

Q Do you make any guarantees?

A Our guarantees are limited to the efficiency of SO,

Any others?

What other companies are there

MR. HAUBOLD: Tour Honor, I object.

THE COURT: Let him finish his question.

BY MR. EISEN:

Q —which, to your knowledge, are offered it a guaran-

teed basis?

A The Monsanto process has a guarantee, and as

for the others, I cannot speak for their guarantees.

Q When you talk in terms of guarantees, at least

MR. HAUBOLD: I object unless Mr. Eisen

a little more clearly what other processes he is referring

to.

THE COURT: Reframe your question.

[2055] BY MR. EISEN:

Q Iam afraid we skipped over something when I was

asking about Wellman-Lord.

Could you describe just generally what the business of

Wellman-Lord Company is with regard to chemical

processes?

A Wellman-Lord is predominantly involved in the

agriculture and industrial chemical sectors. We offer sul-

phurie acid plants, phosphoric acid plants, nitric plants,

phosphate chemical plants, phosphate chemical plants as

related to the fertilizer chemical 3

We offer fluoride and fluorine recovery processes. We

offer processes for the manufacture of fluosilicic acid, a

water fluoridation chemical. We offer process for the

production of hydrofluoric acid, which is used in fluo-

We offer general construction services to industry. We

recently have constructed an aircraft assembly plant,

and we are presently engaged in doing some work for a

major cement company. _

Q That will be sufficient for my next question.

Mr. Craig, do you offer reliability guarantees, reliabil-

ity of operation guarantees, on these processes?

[2056] A We guarantee a production rate. In other

words, the client is given a guarantee that the plant will

produce so many tons per day and we assure him that

the plant will run for so many days per year.

Q Do you give a similar reliability guarantee to the

SO, removal process?

A That's right. Yes.

Q Do you know whether or not there are any sulphur

removal processes presently in operation on utilities in

the United States? =

A I didn’t hear the question.

THE COURT: Read the question.

(Question read by the reporter.)

BY MR. EISEN:

Q That would be utility generating stations.

A I know of the one in the Kansas Power & Light,

in Lawrence.

1553

there any in operation in other countries that

Yes.

MR. EISEN: No more questions.

THE COURT: Any cross examination?

MR. HAUBOLD: Tes, your Honor.

[2062] CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR. HAUBOLD:

Q So, if I understand you correctly, to increase the

iability of the system, an electric utility, for example,

would have to expend considerably more money to install

back-up equipment?

A More. Not necessarily considerably more. More

money, certainly.

facility thus far, has it not?

A Right.

Q At Baltimore Gas & Electric?

A Right. a

lon't it a fact that at the Baltimore Gas & Elec-

trie plant that Wellman-Lord was only able to achieve

PPP

20651 Q ls is a fact that based on the current projec-

tions of Wellman-Lord's in connection with a sodium-

Q And is it not a fact also that you are currently

estimating that cost per ton of coal burned in dollars

„FFF

es.

Q Mr. Craig, can you predict with any reasonable

degree of engineering certainty when the Wellman-Lord

or any sulphur dioxide process for that matter will be.

demonstrated to be economically feasible in an electric

1555

BY MR. HAUBOLD:

Well, in the context of this question shall I say—

I mas “ean [2066] fea-

S

es.

have a device which will permit them

the air nor turn the lights out. They don't have to have

that.

Q Do you have any opinion whatsoever when the

Wellman-Lord process or any other process will become

commercially acceptable? .

A I would say within five years.

Q Mr. Craig, I would like to ask you about some of

the assumptions made in the compilation of some of your

cost projections. We have talked about the current cost

projections which are in excess of those contained in De-

is that correct?

A Right.

Q You also have have you not, that a [2069]

utility purchasing this Wellman-Lord would neces-

Q_ Isn’t is a fact, Mr. Craig, that the economics of

marketing sulphur dioxide or elemental sulphur is highly.

ay S

Yes.

Isn't it also a fact that a plant located in a non-

urban area which would not be adjacent to convenient

transportation to the natural markets for ur or

1

U

—

—

Lain!

F

2

—

e

Hu

1323

Hii

*

„

.

83

were so great that Wellman-

Lord

ellman-

effect, scrapped this system for utility

use,

will qualify that.

fl

system.

Certainly for coals above 1.5

sodium based

„ yes. We recommend sodium

sulph

+}

recommending

power generation

timore Gas & Elec-

you are now

on a utility

in size

not a fact, Mr. Craig, that the

Lord em

to the Bal

®

AN

this project were

electric utili

Have any of the electric utilities which

in the Baltimore Gas & Electric

participated

Q In fact, has any electric utility committed itself to

1557

install or employ the Wellman-Lord process, either sodium

or potassium, on a power generation facility?

No.

ö any money to

Wellman-Lord for development of system?

Did you within the last year, and by “you,” I mean

Wellman-Lord, submit certain cost figures to the Govern-

pore ras re oe ati ibe earbaa sane neces

ect

A We submitted data to Stanford Research.

2: Tevelving the sconeusien: of. tho: spite, to: it pot?

8,

Q You also supplied to them certain information con-

og Se ere e ee e

es.

i

|

12080] REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Mr. Craig, is there a greater problem in getting

rid of pseudo-gypsum than is involved with getting [2081]

7

plants

MR. HAUBOLD: I object unless Mr. Eisen can lay

any foundation as to the witness’ knowledge in terms of

radioactive

THE COURT: Objection sustained. Reframe your .

question. Lay the foundation.

BY MR. EISEN:

Q Counsel asked you whether you have had some

familiarity with Combustion Engineering’s process and

the waste material given off by that process, is that

correct?

A Yes. 8

Q Are you familiar with your contacts in the energy

field with the radioactive waste products given off by

sar sie gg

0.

7 1 5

+ ; 1277

. alt

ay cl,

155 ep

Kia

a er

* R >

—

1118

[2083] BY THE WITNESS:

ng to Mr. Garvey’s three

A Excuse me. Is this referri

to eight percent?

BY MR. EISEN:

12084]

cost?

t percent increase in cost.

Q Three to ei

A Increase in the

Q Yes.

the statement read by

electricity to residential

MR. HAUBOLD: Your Honor

Mr. Eisen concerned a cost of

answer, your

opinion.

=

i

8

s

: ein

A Tes, I have an

Q What is Mat?

7

.

ir

1005

li

= 1561

*

[2090]

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

No. 67 C 1682

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

vs.

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION; THE UNITED ELECTRIC

CoaL COMPANIES; and FREEMAN CoaL Mme Con-

PORATION, DEFENDANTS

Before HON. EDWIN A. ROBSON, Judge,

Monday, April 20, 1970,

2 10:80 O clock a4.

PRESENT:

MR. JOHN THOMAS CUSACK,

MR. HUGO SIMS,

appeared for plaintiff;

MR. HAMMOND E. C

MR. REUBEN L. HEDLUND,

MR. DONALD G. KEMPF, M., and

MR. RICHARD H. IRVING, III,

appeared for defendants;

ALSO PRESENT:

MR. JAMES M. FOLSOM

[2098] PETER O STEINER,

called by the defendants herein, having been first duly

sworn, was examined and testified as follows:

23

1562

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HEDLUND: :

Q For the record, would you please state your name

and present occupation.

A Peter O. Steiner, professor of economics and law

at the University of Michigan.

THE COURT: Would you spell your last name?

THE WITNESS: §&-t-e-i-n-e-r.

ober in Obertin, Ohio in 1948, 2 Master's degree in

economics from Harvard University in 1949, [2099] a

PhD. degree in economics from Harvard in 1950.

MR. HEDLUND: Your Honor, the rest of Professor

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q You have, Professor Steiner, have you not, pub-

lished a textbook on economics with another author?

Lie . it 15

a By ay Tt 253 11275

j + 1755 EE

He dest F 172 +

. 91 11 Hie re

17

N

Steiner, what do you

must first take

What about exhibits that have been introduced

here at trial?

A I believe I have looked at all of these. I don’t

guarantee I remember everything that was in this entire

record.

Q

Q As an economist, Professor

word “competition,” they mean competition in a market.

understanding in what determines that transaction to con-

sider them collectively than to consider them separately;

so that my feeling is one looks at the facts of a particular

set of transactions, looks at the [2108] purpose one has

in mind and attempts to decide which collection of all pos-

sible transactions are best included and which are best

excluded.

It is always a question of defining boundary lines that

includes some transactions and exclude others.

ls it not true that in a sense all such transactions

or all transactions are unique?

A Sure, all transactions are unique but some are

sufficiently similar that there is more than insight in look-

ing at them as a group than in looking at them separately.

Q In looking at them as a group is it necessary to

take a look at or to evaluate the time or the place of the

transaction?

Lie

5

4 11145

ie

190

gebb

3

F

8

:

ge

15

1471

Tres

581475

f

f &

.

: |

72711145

f

2

defined area, and it may indeed

sellers are in a particular area or areas.

15

ef

1

if

i

:

J E

8. 8 1

aft

buyers or in terms of the locations of sellers.

from the home offices of either buyers or sellers.

Q To what extent can the political boundaries of a

state actually define the extent of a market?

I suppose that where there are state laws that

affected the transportation of this commodity, it might

well be that a state boundary in that reach of the law

or that reach of taxes, something of this kind, define them.

8

te

i

i

8 fis

2 11

i

li 78 k 99 ff 8 5547 3

ia Hi: al 5 11 Pall H

i l bags HET andy

412314 cleat? 1771: %

b fin’ se af I E 222858

fall as) gbs ace: 1

1 12 1 511 a 75 ae

F

a 1 17115 HE 32

ee e

14218117 ts bette Eh

In- EH l-

a e

iy (i : P 1 2 le

M

5 i Hie Gyula!

: abe 11 8 11 Wiad 1 175

e fey ie

1111 8 1 alts petit

W aut 14 J itt ltt

8 : 111 11

ili

1

uaa?

8 8

11117

sty Ii

.

157434 f BE 1

Sees 2 15 201 5

* 5

i i

3

E

8 8

a eqs

1 arertitee

2812! RH: 111 „

As e hess E

SES

way we tend to regard monopoly

same

kind of control in the hands of one or a

ber of sellers, is so inherently [2116]

poor performance that without more we

as adverse and it certainly is a signal

|

:

1

2

:

B

111

i

Hl

10

0

i

E

112 af 111471435

easy

prove anticompetitive

further.

Now, just as in the law there are certain extremes

; you can in such and such a set

where we are willing to use per se rules, so I think econo-

hope that there will prove to be some

inherently likely to

and therefore we need not look

of markets

As

8

5

:

8

%

|

it i

:

5

8 BS

os

iE

3"

25

1

I really want to say two things here

But frequently,

—frequently one is not at either one of those extremes

„

> Sec-

portant that

look further

any better than the deline-

and a point that I think is terribl

y im

measured or a market

concentration ratio you

one is at an area where one wants to

ondly,

ation of the market in which it is

a concentration ratio is never

share, and thus to evaluate a

1572

have to be satisfied that it is measured in a proper eco-

nomic market.

There are alternative definitions. Whether it was the

Chicago Metropolitan

N

\

1578

ment exhibits with respect to, not the number of compa-

nies, but the number of “leading companies” and their

Steiner, with the tables prepared by Dr. Bruce Netschert

and his report which is in evi ?

A Yes, I am.

Q And you have read the deposition of Dr. Netschert,

have you? ;

*

1574

this discussion going, they indicate that in this period

of 1957 to 1967 for Illinois there has been a substantial

decline in the number, of Illinois coal producers.

[2123] There is other evidence to indicate that in that

same period of time

I

Fi

:

ing companies” which has also been true for Illinois, and

we see particularly from Dr. Netschert’s tables that there

has nationally been an increase, a dramatic increase in

the size of mines.

I want to now ask you, first, what are the possible

explanations for the decline that we have seen in the coal

industry in the number of companies, the number of

mines and the increased size of the surviving companies,

if you will, and the surviving mines?

A I think you said at the

MR. CUSACK: Your Honor, may I pose an objection

here for the record?

THE COURT: You may.

MR. CUSACK: The Supreme Court of the United

States in the case of United States against Pabst Brew-

ing Company, handed down in June of 1966, stated very

clearly that the cause of concentration and attrition

[2124] and cause for mergers, whatever cause, that the

. or not there was a trend of con-

centrati attrition in the industry regardless of the

cause; and on this basis I object to this line of question-

ing.

THE COURT: He may answer subject to the objec-

tion. The objection may be noted.

MR. CUSACK: Thank you, your Honor.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q Do you have the question, Professor Steiner?

A Yes. I think in the first part of your question you

spoke of the decline of the coal industry. I am not sure

the record does that. You are talking—

THE COURT: Speaking of the terms in decline of

1575

BY THE WITNESS:

of a really dramatic nature of what we have observed

here in a relatively short time which might be due to

require,

pel and thus, if the ind is responsive, lead to a

series of adaptations which lead to changes in the struc.

t 1 2 TI > >

examples of that.

[2126] A second kind of explanation might come from

the supply side, the technological side. You may have

Third, is the kind of explanation which perhaps. Mr.

was urging on us a moment ago. The third ex-

planation would not put primary weight on either an

autonomous shift in demand that led to these changes,

nor a change in the supply conditions that led to them

but, rather, that it was due to the behavior of isti

1576

THE COURT: All right. That may be noted.

[2127] MR. CUSACK: Thank you, your Honor.

THE COURT: Proceed.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Based on the record in this case, of the three possi-

ble explanations that you have suggested for the decline

in the number of companies, the number of mines and

the increased size of those surviving, which of these ex-

planations do you feel best explains the reasons for what

has happened?

A I think the record seems overwhelmingly clear to

me that we have here a demand-induced set of structural -

changes, changes in the nature of demands for coal both

in terms of the decline of the railroad market to vir-

tually nothing, the disappearance or the virtual disappear-

ance or the near disappearance of the home heating mar-

ket, to the tendency for increasing substitution of gas

for coal in the industrial market, but at the same time

the substantial rise in the demand by the electrical utili-

ties for coal has itself been sufficient to explain every-

thing that has occurred.

I think that there are really two phenomena, not one,

in the question you asked me. One is the disappearance

of a very large number of substantially small producers.

[2128] The other is a growth in size, in mine size and,

to some extent, in company size of the quite large pro-

ducers.

I think those are not the same phenomena, but I think

they are both related to these demand conditions. I would

not say there have not been technological innovations,

cost changes, supply changes.

There have been. There have been in the techniques

of mining, as the productivity increases in both the effi-

ciency of the production of coal and its distribution, but

those seem to me, too, to be responses to following on

the kind of changes in the demands for coal that have

made it possible for coal producers to produce in larger

quantities for a rather different market.

Therefore, there have been mergers in this industry

and some of those require explanation outside of this

1577

framework, but it seems to me the basic statistics, the

dominant statistical picture is one that can be readily |

understood in changes of the terms of the changes of

demand and cannot be understood without taking into

account the changes in demand.

THE COURT: Would this be a good opportunity to

take a recess? ;

[2129] MR. HEDLUND: Yes, your Honor.

(There was a short recess, after which the following

further proceedings were had herein, to-wit:)

12130] THE CLERK: The case on trial.

THE COURT: Are you ready to proceed?

MR. HEDLUND: Yes, we are.

THE COURT: You may proceed.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

the change in structure?

A Well, there are a great many examples. I think we

are in an important sense today undergoing a series of

changes in structure provoked by what can be called the

electronic revolution with respect to computers and com-

puterization, automation.

In the automobile industry, the assembly line, which

was introduced in the Model T Ford, clearly basically

transformed that in in its day.

12131] In the textile industry also, I think the syn-

thetics, the chemicals, the introduction of chemical fibers

transforms most of the textile industries and much of

the market structure in those in i

Going even further back, there is the impact of the

open hearth furnace on steel production and so on.

1578

It seems to me dur history is replete with examples

of where a major innovation or a series of smaller in-

novations have gotten to the point where they have simply

generated important structural changes. My feeling is

that the coal industry has not been subject to that kind

of a change over this period. The changes have come

from the things I mentioned a few minutes ago.

[2132] Q There have, however, have there not been,

Professor Steiner, changes in technology in the coal in-

dustry?

A Yes. I think that one of the things that has hap-

pened in response to this shift of the market to very

largely a market, a demand for coal by electrical utili-

ties, has led to markets that can be supplied by large

scale production on unit trains, from large mines, and

this has made, in part, necessary and, in part possible,

the introduction of machinery that is well suited to large-

scale production.

I think there have also been in this industry substan-

tial rises in labor cost and, therefore, a substantial, a

very tic, as it shows in the data, substitution of

capital for‘labor in the production of coal.

As you see the output per man in coal has at least

tripled over the last 20 years and this suggests there has

been capital substitution in both the mining and the trans-

portation, the handling of it.

I think these have been very important changes, but

they seem to me not to have been the innovating changes

that led to the other changes.

Q Returning to the third possible explanation [2133]

for this change in structure, I gather that you do not

believe that the acquisitions or mergers can be put forth

as an explanation for this change?

_A Again, if I might come separately to the two ques-

tions that I tried to distinguish, I see no evidence what-

ever in any of these statistics that the disappearance of

the small producers is due to merger. We do not have a

t deal of data about what has happened to what was

27 companies that reduced to 27, if that is the number,

the approximate number of the companies under 300,000

in Illinois between 1947 and 1967, but I find

1579

Did you mean 1947? 1957 and 1967.

A Excuse nie. I meant 1957 to 1967, over that 10-

year period. I find of thoge small companies which are

not identified, very few of them in terms of the produc-

tion appearing as mergers in any of the mergers that

are listed in the lists that I have seen provided by the

Government.

I think there have been mergers. I think, as I have

looked at those, particularly in this period since 1957,

1959, and 1960, they do not account for very much of

the change in the size in Illinois, at least where I have

looked closely, of the large producers except for [2134]

Peabody.

Peabody clearly has increased its production and its

market share quite dramatically in terms of the series

of mergers. I think if one effectuates, if one regards

the United-Freeman merger as having been affected for

control purposes in 1959, in October of 1959, it seems

to me the sensible way to look at it, as an economist, I

find very few mergers in Illinois of Illinois producers

since 1959, except those that Peabody has engaged in:

I wouldn’t say there have been none because I think

there probably have been, but I remember very few. It.

is quite clear that what has happened, leaving the dis-

appearance of the small sellers, is not a major phenomena

as far as I can see.

These companies, I believe, were producing 25, 50, up

to 100,000 tons of coal. Those companies have found

their market disappearing, and many of them seem to

just have disap

Whether they have failed or whether they have ex-

hausted their mines and quite quietly disappeared, I

don’t really know.

The large companies, Peabody aside, seem to have

grown largely without merger over this period. In [2135]

any case, the basic changes in the phenomenon do not

seem to be merger-induced.

May I say one further thing about a purely statistical

phenomenon. I think there are two phenomena in terms

of growth of size, one of which is real and one is purely

statistical.

1580

[2136] We start’ back in 1957 where we have some-

thing over 125, perhaps it is 145 coal companies in II-

linois. We then have perhaps 80 or 100 of these com-

panies from the small end disappearing.

If nothing else had changed, that mere disappearance

of the small companies would increase the average pro-

duction of the surviving companies and the average pro-

duction of the surviving mines.

That is this statistical phenomenon would result from

the lopping off, if I may use that phrase, of the smaller

companies.

There has been, in addition, a growth in the size, in

the production in both the share of the production and

the production per company and‘per mine of the larger

companies that I think has been real as distinct from

statistical.

I think the data that we have shows that larger mines

are being built and thus companies having the same num-

ber of mines find their production from those mines in

total production increasing. There has additionally, of

course, been, and this is particularly evident in sta-

tistics on Peabody over this ten-year period, there have

been a substantial series of acquisitions of substantial

companies which [2137] increased Peabody’s market share

and thus also the share of the top group of companies

if it includes Peabody.

It is there, it seems to me, only there that I find the

merger explanation of very persuasive force.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q I intend to get back to the specifics of what you

have just testified to, but I want to go on to a dif-

ferent subject right now, if I may. With respect to these

statistics that have been received in evidence as Govern-

ment exhibits relating to structure and relating to the

production shares of each of these companies, I would

like to ask your opinion with respect to whether or not

these exhibits show what they purport to show or, to

put it another way, are they valid or are they misleading?

A I think in many ways they do not show what I

would like to see and, thus, I feel that they are mis,

leading. If they purport to show the relevant measure

1581

of concentration in the proper economic market or the

properly defined market, I think they are distinctly mis-

leading for a number of reasons.

Q Would you give me those?

[2138] A _ I will try to mention some of them. I think

for the reasons we can go into this in more detail when

you want, but I don’t think that Illinois is a proper

erk market in the sense in which I would use that

wo:

I do not think the three-state area of Illinois, Indiana

and west Kentucky is a market.

I think that these figures err in lumping, as if they are

the same products, metallurgical coal and steam coal.

All the evidence I have heard in this case suggests that

those kinds of coal are so different in terms of who uses

them and their cost and how they are used and the pur-

poses for which they are used, that they should be

I thi these figures are misleading if they purport to

show the extent of inter-product competition. It seems

it that way, or a group of buyers who probably should

be separated and treated separately from other buyers,

2140] I think in other ways one can keep going on.

I think that particularly having heard much of the testi.

mony in this record, I am persuaded that is

homogeneous commodity, even steam coal, that things

like sulphur content, things like ash, moisture content,

1582

fusion properties, that these things make it necessary

to look, perhaps, with some care to see in which instances,

in which cases one has to distinguish.

I think that again, or, next, that it is not clear that

where commodities are sold on long-term contracts, where

production this year is likely to represent in very large

extent production committed on a contract signed some

years ago, that production is the proper determination,

if you like, of a firm’s activity in judging, in evaluating

the competition now or the future competition.

It may well be that one has to look at the capability

of a producer to enter into another contract.

If, as I believe the record shows, this is a futures

market, in the sense that what is transacted is a stream

of coal deliveries, it is the potential, and I think the

record in this case suggests the actuality of production

statistics being misleading unless one pays [2141 ]jat-

tention to available uncommitted reserves.

I don’t suppose I have covered all the things that dis-

turb me about those data, but those are at least a few

of them.

Let me say one word further. May I?

THE COURT: You may.

BY THE WITNESS: ”

A (Continuing) I don’t by that mean to say that I

think that approximate statistics, that this is not a

counsel of perfection.

[2142] My criticism of these statistics is not that I

think they are less than fully perfect. It is that I think

they are less good than they should be.

Many of these things I feel critical about should and

can, on the basis of this record, may be looked at and

we can find a more refined set of markets, set of product

definitions, attention to customers and so on.

BY MR. HEDLUND:

Q We have discussed now really just one dimension

or one aspect of the evaluation of the intensity of competi-

tion in the market.

I would like now to direct your attention to the sec-

ond dimension or a second dimension that you mentioned,

1583

which was the performance aspect of the

or coal producers; and I would like to ask you what you

feel the record in this case shows as to the

competition among coal suppliers, and with particular ref-

erence to the electrical utility market in this period of

1957 to 1967.

A I think it has a good deal to say about the

fectiveness of competition. I think we see and

the most dramatic statistic of is one of

I think is in one of Dr. Netschert’s tables, which [

shows that the price of coal per unit energy, that the

8

8

up, when wage costs in the coal industry have gone up

is clearly testament to the fact that the industry and

the competitors in this industry are doing their best to

hold that market, the electrical utility market, in the

face of having lost some of their other markets.

They have sueceeded by one means or another in keep-

ing costs low. I think partly this has been due to a

growth in size, the ability to use more efficient tech-

niques, the ability to achieve unit rates on trains.

I believe the statistics do show, in fact, * coal

freight rates, another one of Netschert’s tables,

gests that they have actually not only

rapidly than other freight rates, but they have actually

decreased in the last 10 years, that the cost per ton of

coal transported has decreased.

I regard all of those things as the kinds of perform-

ance you would expect to see if an industry were fight-

ing very hard to keep its prices low. It is not, of course,

son te vu, Must succeed and, it seems

to me, ave succeeded so ey [2144] get in a pe-

riod, in a decade when industrial prices in general were

rising, rising not negligibly, that coal has kept the price

of its commodity relatively low.

Perhaps another aspect of the same thing is what you

see in the productivity statistics, a sharp increase in the

output per man-day worked over this period. This, again,

is the kind of response you would expect.

il rig LE 5 110 i i 1247 15 1

mail

Fae 17115 17275

ile I e

4

TEE

2775 11117747 sf: 12

933 1 4 r i bat 1111 L f

I 1 toys 8 11 ar

1415 1421 i bh: 11111 (ai: 111

f ea 110 e

1 15 10 i 1115 i belie

ini otis 15 ll 312 2275 Ef 285711132

1151

vif 92

tf eae

12474-4111

4 27 2 5

rf ui :

1 iene

EL

it

:

—

1

0

1

1

HH

:

4

4

*

8

52

Professor Steiner, do you

have with you Government Exhibit 72, which is—I want

to develop this point a little further—Government Exhibit

72 which is the IIlinois production for 1967, and Govern-

ment Exhibit 85, which is the production for the three-

state area?

Do you have copies with you to give the Court?

1587

MR. CUSACK: Do you have an extra copy, your

Honor? It’s in Volume 10 of the statistics,

MR. HEDLUND: Volume 10, Tab 11, your Honor,

and Tab—

THE WITNESS: I have 72, but not 85, Mr. Hedlund.

MR. HEDLUND: I will give you mine. I will give

you my Government Exhibit 85.

Seer What tab number was that, Mr. Cu-

? ‘

MR. CUSACK: Tab 11 for the production in Illinois

of 1967.

MR. CUSACK: Production of coal in Illinois and

121511 western Kentucky of 66-677

MR. HEDLUND: I am referring to 85.

THE COURT: That is No. 25.

MR. HEDLUND: You have that, your Honor?

THE COURT: Yes.

Q Professor Steiner, looking at Government Exhibit

72 and 85, I am going to ask if you could relate in these

statistics in terms of the size of the companies, and

if I may use the term, intramural pressures or challenges

among coal suppliers?

A I wonder if I might have that question read back?

THE COURT: Read the question.

(Question read by reporter.)

BY MR. HEDLUND:

at Ayrshire—

we have eight producers—substantial [2152 producers

1271144 17105 25

fh 114131 a i f bull i

1112 aa fia Hib bs

Ayal! 1522 2 b sf i 1121 :

W

GT a eee ter

1 0 1 10

e

1412 7445 3:

THEE

25 zi 115

* Ruy

142 17351

ged 111227

2 171117

11

11 7771

325 111115 fl

1875 2 2 8

SHIT

*

they show

other things.

*

am sa

the

in

bili

ca

small

54 35

11120

1

;

1

*

i

te

STL

A

i

aba?

1525 EL

573587

11

Vi

ne i

pi

t take, first, the notion of

t. Lin foe ks, for Cal tome

respect to where

customers tend to

[2156] If I mi

their statistics with

coal, I find that their

1590

states; that indeed if I were defining their market area,

it would be defined more by the Mississippi River Valley

than either the State of Illinois or a group of other

states.

MR. CUSACK: oS he Pinte ee

may I say something ay I please have a continuing

objection on the record, your Honor, on testimony in

regard to the relevant geographic market in the light

of U. S. v. Pabst Brewing Company, 384 U.S.

THE COURT: You may have a continuing objection

on that subject.

MR. CUSACK: Thank you very much.

BY THE WITNESS:

A I was talking about why I was unhappy with the

Illinois market.

One reason I am unhappy is, I think a great deal of

the coal that is produced in particular regions of Illinois

is fact shipped either [2157] uniformly throughout

the State of Illinois, nor indeed so limited.

To use perhaps one example, using that Belleville area.

point of view of customers, if I

ng around, if I take a group of, let us say,

located in a portion of Illinois, it is not true

either that they buy all of their coal from Illinois

may, indeed, have much more narrowly areas.

I think that for both of those reasons, and the fact

as I said earlier, that I believe one can do better on the

basis of the data collected either by the Government or

the defendants, we can get a better approximation

the markets, we shouldn’t use that.

I find, secondly, the notion of the Eastern Interior

Coal Province sales area genuinely baffling. I spent a

good deal of time trying to figure out the criteria by

which the Government defined that particular area. It

1 41 ony ees 125

1 ane

8 133 ; 433 as

2 11

1115 11115 15

5 111 74371 i

ie

14 115

ue

125821

I 1 1%

il a gee

EE 15 Alpe 5 21

if 1 5 0 IRE

12171 i] HN

1 16 1

i 1

2 13 11111175 i!

14111514 A 123

711

Mae Hall

3 435 ii Hy 33 i 13 ; 76 115 i

La .

111 11 ag ey t

11 111715 11 4 41 pyle a

e ate

15 141 „ Fle 4 ERE

1 11 i

an 1 1 Bh ecy :

BESS 1177111 f SHI ype ets peabapend iss,

1593

1111 :

i fs rat

211. 2);

7735 f

8

5

1735 in

3355

322

387 be

8

ROBERT H. QUIG,

1

DIRECT EXAMINATION

12173]

1594

Q By whom arè you employed?

A Iam employed by Chemical Construction Corpora-

n

Is that firm sometimes known by the name Chemi-

How long have you been employed by Chemico?

I have been employed by Chemico for three and a

half years?

Q Could you briefly describe for us your experience

in the field of air pollution.

A Yes, for the past three and a half years I have

been employed by Chemico with the title of engineer,

utility operations; and in that time I have been in

charge of the management, control and development of

pollution, the development of pollution control [2174]

systems for use on power plants and other stationary

sources to control various discharges of pollutants.

121751 Q And for how many years, if you know, has

CHEMICO been engaged in the study and research on

pollution? —

A CHEMICO’s corporate business has been for over

50 years in the chemical process industries and for ap-

proximately 25 years in the construction of pollution con-

trol systems.

Q Could you briefly describe your educational back-

ground and the extent to which you have received any

degrees.

A I am a graduate mechanical engineer from col-

lege, Lafayette College, and I am a registered professional

engineer.

I have a graduate degree in Business Administration.

Q Does CHEMICO have a commercially feasible

process for the removal and disposal of sulphur dioxide

gases ve are created by the generation of electric

er

A CHEMICO—yes, CHEMICO has a process to offer

1 the removal and disposal of stack gases from power

plants.

Q Could you explain this process and how it works.

12176] A Yes. We would approach a pollution prob-

lem on a power plant for a disposal effort in that we

Q

?

A Yes, it is.

Q

A

1595

would build a scrubber system whereby the flue gases

discharging from the boiler of the power plant would be

diverted into the scrubber, and at that time absorption

of the SO. would be done by the addition of alkali such

as calcium oxide, and this calcium oxide can be ob-

tained from various sources, limestones and limes in a

regional area.

In the scrubber the calcium oxide reacts with the

sulphur dioxide forming calcium sulphide and sulphate

which, in turn, is discharged to a disposal area similar

to the removal of fly ash or bottom ash from the boiler.

Q And is this process one which, in your professional

judgment, could be installed on an electrical utility gen-

erating station commencing tomorrow?

A Les, it can.

Q Does CHEMICO also have a process for the re-

moval and recovery of sulphur dioxide stack gases?

A Yes, we have a process.

Q Would you explain how this process operates?

A Essentially using the same scrubber arrangement

on the power plant we would add, instead of calcium

oxides, a better absorbent material, and in this particular

case with CHEMICO it is magnesium oxide.

121771 The magnesium sulphide and some sulphate

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appendix — United States v. General Dynamics Corp. · 415 U.S. 486 | Frix