Appendix — Hughes Tool Co. v. Trans World Airlines, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1973
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
INDEX
Volume I
t of Relevant Docket Entries
VA Complaint [Doe. 1] A-l
de Referring This’Action to Judge Metzner for
All Purposes, dated August 31, 1961 [Doc. 42]... A-33
© Holic ay’s Answer [Doc. 83]
o strial Order, July 12, 1962 [Doe. 101]
retrial Order, September 21, 1962 [Doc. 122] A-118
rial Order, January 10, 1963 [Doe. 144] A-122
ial Order, January 19, 1963 [Doe. 146]
: Dpinion and Order of Special Master dated J anuary
| ®, 1963, Exhibit C to Bromley Affidavit dated
lebruary 15, 1963 [Doc. 179]
uibit A to the Affidavit of John F. Sonnett, dated
ruary 1, 1963 [Doc. 166]
exhibits B and C to the Affidavit of John F. Son-
pmett, dated February 1, 1963 [Doc. 167]
° 60’s Notice of Position, dated February 8, 1963
| Doc. 174] :
fanecript of Pretrial Hearing, February 8, 1963
‘ cL: Je p 188]
at
iiscript of Pretrial Hearing, May 2, 1963 [Doe.
‘fied
sy
A-ii
Opinion and Order, dated May 3, 1963 [Doc. 191] ....
Opinion and Order of May 3, 1963 Granting Addi-
tional Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss (memoran-
dum endorsed on motion papers dated February
15, 1963) [Doc. 179B]
Judgment of the Court of Appeals on Interlocutory
Appeal, Entered July 10, 1964 [Docket No. 28405]
[Doc. 478]
Judgment of the Court of Appeals Affirming Dis-
missal of the Counterclaims, Entered July 10,
1964 [Docket No. 28406] [Doc. 479]
Opinion of the Court of Appeals in Dockets No.
28405 and No. 28406 [Doc. 478]
Opinion and Order of Special Master J. Lee Rankin,
dated July 30, 1965 [Doc. 481]
Opinion and Order of Judge Metzner, dated Novem-
ber 16, 1965 [Doc. 487]
Transcript of Hearing Before Judge Metzner on
December 30, 1965 [Doc. 498]
Opinion and Order of Judge Metzner Denying De-
fendants’ Motion for a Pre-Hearing Order, dated
January 4, 1966 [Doc. 496]
Order by Judge Metzner of January 4, 1966 Desig-
nating Herbert Brownell as Special Master in
Place of J. Lee Rankin [Doc. 497]
Volume II
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
Robert W. Rummel [Docs. 554-2 through 554-10]
Testimony at Damage Hearing of John B. Connelly
[Doe. 554-11]
PAGE
A-317
A323
A-324
A-326
A328
A-357
A-396
A400
A422
AAA
AAD
A-977
A-iii
Volume III
PAGE
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
Edward J. Morehouse [Docs. 554-13, 554-14] ... A-1209
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
Edward Wemple [Does. 554-15 through 554-18,
554-32] nn ee ee ee A-1243
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
John C. Biegler [Doc. 554-19] A-1527
Volume IV
Excerpts from. Testimony at Damage Hearing of
Gene M. Woodfin [Does. 554-23, 554-24] A-1567
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
Nathan S. Simat [Does. 554-25, -26, -27, -28, -30,
31] A-1575
Excerpts from Testimony at Damage Hearing of
_ L. John Eichner [Does. 554-31, -32] A-1727
Testimony at Damage Hearing of Van Court M.
Hare, Jr. [Doc. 554-32] A-1773
Excerpts from Pretrial Deposition of Robert W.
Rummel [Does. 224, 225, 226] A-1797
Excerpts from Pretrial Deposition of Charles C.
Tillinghast [Docs. 210 through 222] .n.sneesecceneceeeee A-1850
Excerpts from Pretrial Deposition of Emmett O.
Cocke [Does. 228, 231, 233, 235] A-1913
Jones v. Uris Sales Corp.—Master’s Report [not a
part of the Record herein] 7 A-1934
Volume V
Notice of Filing of Report of Special Master dated
September 21, 1968 [Doc. 509] A-1965
Report of Special Master, Filed September 21, 1968
[Doc. 508] A-1966
A-iv
PAGE
Defendants’ Objections to the Report of the Special
Master, dated November 1, 1968 [Doe. 511] ........ A-1967
Opinion and Order, Filed December 23, 1969, Adopt-
ing and Confirming the Report of the Special
Master [Doc. 519] A-2027
Opinion and Order of April 13, 1970 Awarding
Attorney’s Fee and Costs [Doc. 530] -...000000...... A-2060
Final Judgment Entered April 14, 1970 [Doe. 531] .. A-2073
Volume VI
Toolco’s Notice of Motion to Dismiss TWA’s Com-
plaint, August 8, 1961 [Doc. 22] A-2075
Order by Judge Herlands, dated August 14, 1961
[Doc. 25] A-2017
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, September 6, 1961 [Doc. 47] A-2078
Pretrial Order of Judge Metzner, September 7, 1961
[Doc. 44] A-2112
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, October 2, 1961 [Doc. 48] A-2115
Pretrial Order of Judge Metzner, December 18, 1961
[Doc. 354] A-2138
Toolco’s Notice of Motion Before Special Master
J. Lee Rankin, February 15, 1962 [Doc. 66] ........ A-2140
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, February 23, 1962 [Doc. 79] A-2141
Orders of Special Master J. Lee Rankin, April 17,
1962, contained in excerpts from transcript of
deposition of Charles C. Tillinghast, Jr. [Doc.
217) A-2176
Interrogatory Propounded by TWA to Toolco, May
4, 1962 [Doc. 89] A-2197
PAGE
Interrogatory Propounded by TWA to Raymond M.
Holliday, May 4, 1962 [Doe. 90] A-2203
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before J udge Metz-
ner, May 17, 1962 [Doc. 96] . A-2206
Portion of Transcript-of Proceedings Before Spe-
cial Master J. Lee Rankin, June 4, 1962 [Doe.
218] A-2233
TWA’s Notice of Motion and Affidavit of John F.
Sonnett, June 25, 1962 [Doc. 305] A-2234
Affidavit of John R. Hupper, July 2, 1962 [Doe.
315] A-2240
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before J udge Metz-
ner, July 12, 1962 [Doc. 107] A-2245
Pretrial Order of Judge Metzner, July 23, 1962
[Doc. 103] w. A-2267
Pretrial Order of Judge Metzner, July 24, 1962
[Doc. 93] wwe A-2268
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, July 26, 1962 [Doe. 113] ................. A-2270
Affidavit of Robert G. Zeller, August 28, 1962 with
Exhibits A-K [Doe. 110] A-2283
Memorandum Reviewing the History of TWA’s Ap-
plication for Permission to Propound an Inter-
rogatory of Hughes Tool Company Concerning
the Location of Howard R. Hughes, August 30,
1962 [Doe. 106) .... A-2297
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before J udge Metz-
ner, September 6, 1962 [Doc. 355] A-2305
Affidavit of John F. Sonnett, September 14, 1962,
and Exhibits C and D*hereto [Doe. 117] ............ A-2316
Portions of Transcript of Proceedings Before Spe-
cial Master J. Lee Rankin, September 15, 1962
(Doe. 296] A-2389
A-vi
PAGE
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, September 19, 1962 [Doc. 129] A-2391
Portions of Transcript of Discovery Proceedings
Before Special Master J. Lee Rankin, October 25,
1962 [Doc. 226] A-2428
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, October 29, 1962 [Doc. 184] A-2438
Notice of Motion by Tooleo, December 4, 1962, for
Leave to Depose Sessel and Wadsworth [Doc.
338] . A-2461
Transcript of Proceedings Before Special Master
J. Lee Rankin, December 14, 1962 [Doc. 237] ...» A-2462
Transcript of Proceedings Before Special Master
J. Lee Rankin, December 28, 1962 [Doc. 237] .... A-2514
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, January 9, 1963 [Doc. 185] A-2523
Transcript of Proceedings Before Special Master
J. Lee Rankin, January 14, 1963 [Doc. 237] ........ A-2571
Notice of Motion by Toolco, January 14, 1963 [Doc.
145] A-2574
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, January 17, 1963 [Doc. 186] A-2576
Notice of Motion by Toolco, January 22, 1963 [Doc.
147] A-2602
Transcript of Proceedings Before Special Master
J. Lee Rankin, January 23, 1963 [Doe. 237] ........ A-2603
Notice of Motion by Tooleo, January 25, 1963 [Doc.
152] A-2615
Transcript of Pretrial Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, January 28, 1963 [Doc. 187] A-2616
Letter of Chester C. Davis to Judge Metzner, Jan-
uary 29, 1963 [Doc. 448] A-2642
Ae
A-vii
PAGE
Letter of Chester C. Davis to Special Master J. Lee
Rankin, February 4, 1963 [Doc. Eo) A-2645
Letter from John F. Sonnett to Chester C. Davis,
February 5, 1963 [Doe. 459] = A-2647
Notice of Motion by Tooleo, February 6, 1963 [Doe.
VIO] eeeeesenencspneeenenenessecetenersttetnettrteceeteeeec A-2648
UIQ] oeeeeeeseenenevvnecenessnesteesetnetesstesttettteeeseeecc A-2649
Transcript of Pretria] Hearing Before J udge Metz-
ner, February 6, 1963 [Doc. 187] plovhtsiaeciiante A-2650
Affidavit of Bruce Bromley, February 15, 1963
[without exhibits] [Doc, BFE) miteounicrsiemaeemacs A-2676
Affidavit of William C. Chanler, February 15, 1963
[Doe. 179] ; =
Order to Show Cause dated February 16, 1963, and
Affidavit of John F. Sonnett, February 15, 1963
[Doc. 180] ......... ;
Transcript of Pretria] Hearing Before Judge Metz-
ner, February 21, 1963 [Doe. 189] wo A-2704
Order of the Court of Appeals for the Second Cir.
cuit dated June 6, 1963, Granting Leave to Appeal
and Staying Damage Hearing Pending Appeal .. A-2736
Orders of the Supreme Court of the United States,
dated November 16, 1964 Granting Writs of Cer-
tiorari .--. A-2737
Orders of the Supreme Court, dated March 8, 1965,
ismissing the Writs of Certiorari as Improvi-
A-2692
Trans World Airlines, Inc., Nos. 443 and 501 A-2738
Dpinion of the Court of Appeals dated September 1,
1971, in Docket Nos, 34902, 35114, Affirming with
Modifications the J udgment of the District
- A-2739
A-viii
PAGE
Orders of the Court of Appeals, dated September
28, 1971, Denying Petitions for Rehearing and
Rehearing in banc A-2799
Volume VII
PAGE
Excerpts from Transcript of Deposition of Charles
C. Tillinghast, Jr. [Excerpts from Does. 54, 210,
211, 216, 221) A-2800
Vol. 11 of Defendants’ Exhibits to Deposition of
Charles C. Tillinghast, Jr. (consisting of Ex-
hibit 11, with subparts 11-A through 11-T, inclu-
sive) [Doc. 238] A-3220
Opinions and Orders of the Civil Aeronautics Board
with respect to the Hughes Tool Company—TWA
Control Relationship, as follows:
(a) CAB Opinion and Order No. 3210, October
17, 1944 (officially reported at 6 C.A.B.
153) [not a part of the Record herein] .... A-3297
(b) CAB Order No. 4437, January 26, 1946 ... A-3307
(c) CAB Order No. E-922, October 29, 1947 .... A-3309
(d) CAB Opinion and Order No. E-1735, June
30, 1948 (officially reported at 9 C.A.B.
381) [not a part of the Record herein] ... A-3311
(e) CAB Opinion and Order No. E4701, Oc-
tober 6, 1950 (officially reported at 12
C-A.B. 192) ae a part of the Record
herein] A-3333
(f) CAB Opinion and Order No. E-16195, De-
cember 29, 1960 (officially reported at 32
C.A.B. 1363) A348
A-2800
Excerpts From Transcript of Deposition of
Charles C. Tillinghast
(Does. 54, 210-211, 216, 221]
[604] By Mr. Davis:
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, let me try to establish a few inde.
pendent facts, and I would appreciate it if you could an.
swer my questions without feeling the necessity at this
time of explaining the reasons for whatever decision may
have been made.
I can assure you that you will have a full opportunity to
explain anything that was done or was not done.
Isn’t it a fact, in accordance with your understanding,
that the Tool Company, as a result of the 1960 financing,
held a hundred million dollar note of TWA?
A. It is. ao
Q. And that in connection with that 1960 financing TWA
had obligated itself to make an offering to all of its stock-
holders not later than May 31, 1961 of either a hundred
million dollars of debentures or $111 million of debentures,
approximately?
A. Yes.
Q. Is it also a fact, in accordance with your understand-
ing, that the Tool Company had obligated itself to subscribe
to 78 per cent of such an offering, and to also subscribe to
whatever portion the 22 per cent of the [605] stockholders
failed to subscribe?
A. Up to a ceiling of $100 million.
Q. Up to a ceiling of $100 million?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And that the Tool Company could acquire those new
TWA debentures by surrendering all or part of its $100 mil-
lion note in payment?
A-2801
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. That is correct.
Q. Is it also a fact that in May 1961 the Tool Company
asked TWA to consider a delay in the effective date of a
TWA registration statement covering these debentures to
be issued ?
A. That is correct.
Q. Isn’t it also a fact that the board of directors of
TWA in fact refused to grant that request for a delay?
A. Yes.
Q. Isn’t it also a fact that at that time the financial ad-
visers of TWA, namely, Dillon, Read and others associated
with them, advised TWA that it would be unadvisable to
grant the request of the Tool Company for an extension
of time?
A. It is.
Q. Isn’t it also a fact that those financial ad- [606]
visers made that recommendation on the ground that such
a delay might have an adverse effect on the Boeing financ-
ing then contemplated?
A. That is correct.
Q. My understanding is that your conversations with
Mr. McCone with respect to what you have testified to this
morning took place after that action of the board meeting.
A. Yes.
Q. Isn’t it a fact, then, that at the time you were dis-
cussing these matters with Mr. McCone the question or the
issue as to what might or might not interfere with the Boe-
ing financing was uppermost in your find?
A. That was certainly one of the things that was upper-
most in my mind when I was talking with Mr. McCone, yes.
Q. Now I am going to ask you if your recollection has
been refreshed as to whether or not in your conversations
with Mr. McCone, when you were discussing the desirability
A-2802
Tillinghast—Deposition
or lack of desirability to “bail out the Hughes Tool Com-
pany,” or whatever, the Boeing financing was very much
on your mind?
A. Oh, yes, quite.
Q. Isn’t that one of the reasons you gave to Mr. [607]
McCone as to why it seemed to you that it would be un.
desirable to consider the 990 program?
A. I think it probably was, Mr. Davis, yes.
Q. And that it was discussed in the course of these com-
munications relating to the decision that should be made?
A. Yes.
Q. Had you occasion to discuss with any of the lending
institutions involved, or their representatives, what would
adversely affect their financing commitment or arrange-
ments?
A. . At what time, Mr. Davis?
. Q. I am still referring to that same period of time of
from May 15th, if you please, to June 10th, but before the
receipt of the three proposals reflected by Defendants’ Ex-
hibit 10. \Let’s make it June 8th, if you please.
A. Except to the extent that I may have discussed the
matter with Mr. Sessel, the answer is no, I did not discuss
it with the financing institutions. ,
Q. Isn’t it also true that during that period you discussed
with Mr. Breech the things which in your judgment or in
his judgment might adversely affect this Boeing financing!
[608] A. I am sure I did.
Q. Did either Mr. McCone or Mr. Breech suggest to you
that it would be desirable to investigate by communicating
with the principal officers of the major participants in this
lending institution group the question as to whether or not
it would or would not adversely affect the Boeing financing!
A. Again making an exception in the case of Mr. Sessel,
the answer is no.
A-2803
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. You understand my question was not what you did,
but whether either Mr. McCone or Mr. Breech suggested
your doing something or investigating?
A. My answer is that I don’t think that they did sug-
gest that. ;
Q. Did I understand your prior answer, when you said
with the exception of Mr. Sessel, to say that they suggested
Mr. Sessel ?
A. I don’t think that they suggested that 1 talk with
Mr. Sessel. As. you know, Mr. Davis, Mr. Sessel is &@ mem-
ber of the board of directors of TWA, and in his capacity
as a director, I am sure that I discussed this matter with
him at the board meeting on the 17th, if not perhaps before
that. I am not sure at the moment. I am quite sure that
Mr. Sessel expressed [609] the view that it would be a
mistake, so far as the financial institutions were concerned,
to get into a 990 negotiation with Hughes Tool Company.
Q. Before we come to your conference with Mr. Sessel,
I am interested in pursuing what took place between you
and Mr. McCone or you and Mr. Br , and my question to
you is are you quite certain that neither of,them suggested
that you discuss the matter directly with a representative
of the lending institutions?
A. I am quite sure that they made no suggestion. If
they did, I have absolutely no recollection of it at the
moment.
Q. I understand that Mr. McCone also, in the course of
those conversations, suggested the possibility of reducing
the Boeing order in part?
A. Yes.
Q. At the time that he made that suggestion, did you
say to him, “But if we do that, that will change the amount
of the financing arrangements that we have made with the
nding institutions”?
A-2804
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. No, Iam sure I didn’t say that.
Q. What did you say?
A. AsI recall it, Mr. Davis, what I told him was that
I thought that it would be uneconomical to try to [610]
have, fof example, half Boeings and half Convairs, that the
operating—vwell, the operating lack of economy of relatively
small fleets was very great, that from a standpoint of flexi-
bility we would be far better off to have a homogenous
fleet, and that quite apart from the problem of getting into
possible endless negotiations with respect to the 990, and
leaving the whole program in suspense, that I did not
think it made sense, from an operating standpoint, to try
to mix the two.
Q. You consider a fleet of 13 jets a very small fleet?
A. I don’t know that I would say very small, but it is
too small, in our opinion, to be effective from an operating
standpoint. ; .
Q. At that time, and I am referring to the time when
you were having these conversations with Mr. McCone, you
had already made studies investigating the operational
advantages or d‘sadvantages of 990s vs. Boeings or a com-
bination of the two?
A. Oh, yes. Prior to the time that I came with TWA
Mr. “Rummel’s department had made a very extensive
investigation of this subject, and had come up with a recom-
mendation with which you are familiar, and from the time
that this question was first raised by you, I [611] had
a number of discussions, repeated discussions, with Mr.
Rummel on the subject, asking him to review the question
and let me know whether anything that had happened
changed, in any regard, his opinion.
Q. You are now referring to conversations you had with
Mr. Rummel after you commenced to hear from me. I
understand we are talking after May 26th, but I am stil
A-2805
Tilinghast—Deposition
referring to the period when you were discussing this
matter with Mr. McCone, namely, from the time you re-
ceived the May 26th letter and June 8th.
Are you addressing yourself to that period of time in
your answer? ’
A. Yes. I had repeated discussions with Mr. Rummel
about this.
Q. You discussed with Mr. Rummel, during that period
of time, his views as to the possibility of a mixed fleet; is
that correct? _
A. Well, I can’t say definitely, Mr. Davis, that I dis-
cussed that specifically between the 26th of May and the
10th of June. But in this general period I discussed it
with him several times, and was quite familiar with his
views on the subject. ;
Q. I understand that, Mr. Tillinghast. I am trying to
ascertain what was the basis for the statements or [612]
contentions that you were making in your conversation with
Mr. McCone. -
A. Well, at the time that I talked with Mr. McCone and
made this statement I was quite familiar already with Mr.
Rummel’s views on this particular subject.
Q. They had been discussed, then, before May 26th?
A. Oh, yes.
Q. Was it before or after that Mr. Breech suggested to
you that you should not involve yourself personally in this
equipment problem?
A. That was some time prior to my visit to Seattle on
the 25th and 26th of May.
- Q Let me understand. You went to Seattle the 25th
or 26th of May?
A. I went in the afternoon of the 25th, and was there
that evening and on the 26th.
A-2806
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. In connection with your visit to Seattle Mr. Breech
had occasion to comment that he did not think it was
desirable for you to become personally involved in the
equipment selection; isn’t that correct?
A. That is correct.
Q. Am I to understand, then, that between May 25th or
26th and June 8th you nevertheless pursued this question
with Mr. Rummel so as to put you in a position to [613]
make the remarks and comments you made to Mr. McCone!
A. That is not correct, Mr. Davis. I had been pursuing
this question with Mr. Rummel since the 30th of March.
Q. What question had you been pursuing with Mr.
Rummel since the 30th of March?
A. The equipment question generally, and what equip-
ment TWA should select.
Q. In those discussions with Mr. Rummel you also dis-
cussed the 1
A. Yes. Mr\Rummel’s study discussed 990s and several
other different s of ships.
[614] Q. Was that on the basis that TWA was possibly
interested in 990s, or expected to order some, or what was
the nature of your conversation that you had from March
30th on with Mr. Rummel as to the 990s in relationship to
the equipment program of TWA? e
A. Well, Mr. Davis, your question is a little diffuse, but
let me start. A
I first talked with Mr. Rummel, I believe, on the 30th of
March, at which time I think he gave me, although I may
have had it a couple of days before that, his study on the
1961 equipment program, and from that time in March up
to the time that you are speaking about I had a number of
conversations with Mr. Rummel, as well as others, about
this problem, because it obviously was a very major ques-
A-2807
Tillinghast—Deposition
tion, and one that was going to come to a head very, very
Mr. Rummel’s study, covered a number of different ships
of the general sort in which TWA might be interested, and
among others. This study covered 880s, 880Ms, and 990s.
Whether or not the study itself mentions that Hughes Tool
Company had some 990s on order, or whether Mr. Rummel
told me that orally, I cannot at this moment recall. But
early in the game I knew that one of the alternatives [615]
that was under consideration was the 990. As a conse-
quence, again early in the game, I had discussed with Mr.
Rummel the pros and cons of the 990, and in particular the
pros and cons of the thirteen 990s which were under order
by Hughes Tool Company. i
Does that answer your question?
- Q In part.
I believe you decided to become chief executive on March
20th?
A. That’s correct.
Q. One of the things you immediately began to instruct
yourself about, to obtain information, on becoming chief
executive officer was this equipment program of TWA?
A. That was one of the things.
Q. You had a great many other things to do?
A. I did, an exceedingly great number of things to do.
Q You reviewed with Mr. Rummel the studies he had
made previous to your becoming a chief executive officer?
A. That’s correct. ®
Q You weren’t reviewing with him studies which he had
undertaken pursuant to your request?
[616] A. No. This had all been begun before I joined
the company, or before I agreed to join the company.
Q. This was a discussion you had with Mr. Rummel
based upon some written reports that Mr. Rummel had got-
A-2808
Tillinghast—Deposition
ten up, or programs, or presentations?
A. This is a specific study, Mr. Davis, with which |
think you happen to be familiar.
» QQ. I don’t happen to be familiar with it, but whether |
am or not, for the record, will you please answer my ques-
tion.
A. It is a specific study, entitled, as I recall it, “1961
Equipment Program.”
Q. Can you tell us about how much time you spent with
Mr. Rummel studying this program?
A. When?
Q. At the time that you first began to discuss this matter
with Mr. Rummel, and up to the period we are talking
about, which is either May 26th or June 8th?
A. Well, in the aggregate, by June 8th I had probably,
oh, spent an aggregate of, I would guess, 10 or 15 hours
discussing the thing with Mr. Rummel, and I had spent
considerable additional time reading the report and study-
ing the report.
[617] Q. When was the decision made that the Boeing
aircraft was the best suited or more desirable from TWA’s
point of view?
A. The decision made by whom?
Q. TWA.
A. Well, if you mean when was the decision made by the
board of directors, the decision was made by the board of
directors at their meeting in Kansas City on, I believe, the
27th of April.
Q. No, I am not referring to a decision by the board of
directors. I mean the decision or the recommendation
which resulted in a recommendation to the board for action.
I am referring to the conclusion. When was the conclusion
reached, so far as you were concerned?
A. So far as I was concerned?
A-2809
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q Yes.
A. Shortly before the meeting of the 27th.
Q. Of which month?
A. April. ,
Q. During this period between March 30th and April
27th you considered the possibility of 990s as well as Boe.
ings, is that correct?
A. That’s correct, :
£618] Q. Did you also consider, during that period, the
possibility of a mixed fleet?
A. There was some talk of it, yes.
Q What do you mean by “some talk’? Can you identify
the talk, and with whom?
A. I can’t identify it specifically, Mr-Davis. I imagine
I must have talked with Mr. Rummel I am sure that it
was discussed with him. On the 17th—
Q. Which month?
A. (Continuing) —of April, the first day that I took
office, as I recall it, the afternoon was devoted to an equip-
ment meeting which included Mr. Rummel, Mr. Cocke, Mr.
Rourke, Mr. Fellows. I can’t remember for certain—no, it
didn’t inelude Mr. Hall. I think it may have included Mr.
Dunn. I am not positive.
Q. Let me ask you this: Did Mr. Rummel have occasion
to review or revise this original report that he had and
which you discussed with him shortly after you became
thief executive officer?
A. Not that I can recall. Certainly not to any signifi-
tant extent.
Q. So far as you were concerned, then, the recommenda-
tion which was made to the board, which was [619] decided
"pon on or about April 17th—
A. April 27th.
A-2810
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. That was board action?
A. Board action.
Q. I understand that the conclusion as to the recom.
mendation to be made was made on or about the 17th, or
shortly before the 17th.
Mr. Sonnett: What he testified to was shortly
before the 27th.
Mr. Davis: I understand that. Then he found
that was based upon some meeting that was held on
the 17th.
Q. What are the facts, anyway, Mr. Tillinghast?
A. The facts are these, Mr. Davis, if that is what you
want: The recommendation by the TWA operating people
had already been reached before I came with the company.
Obviously this was a matter of such great significance and
importance that I wanted to review this recommendation,
this conclusion that had already been reached, so prior to
coming with the company I talked with Mr. Rummel, I read
the equipment proposal, and the first day that I was there
I had a meeting in the afternoon for the purpose of having
a broader discussion of this to see myself as to whether I
was [620] prepared to adopt this program and recommend
it to the board at its meeting ten days later.
Q. If I understand your testimony, the operating people
had already made up their own mind and made a recon-
mendation before you became chief executive officer?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Then you felt that you as chief executive officer ought
to review it?
A. That’s correct.
Q. As a result of the review that you made of it you
subsequently recommended it to the board on April 27th!
A. Yes.
A-2811
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. What you recommended to the board on April 27th
was, in substance, the recommendation of this operating
personnel group, is that correct?
A. Yes. :
Q. So what was recommended to the board on April 27th
was, in effect, the conclusion reached by the operating peo-
ple of TWA before you became chief executive?
A. That’s correct,
Q. Do you know whether or not that was a program
[621] or conclusion that was prepared by the operating
people at TWA at the direction—at whose direction was
that program or study made prior to your becoming chief
executive officer, do you know?
A. Well, I can’t be altogether positive about that. I
believe that Mr. Rummel’s department generated the study
on its own, and that that study was brought by Mr. Rum-
mel’s department to a point where some action was
required, and at a meeting of the board prior to the time
that I took office there had been an equipment committee
appointed specifically to deal with this problem.
Q MayI interrupt you by asking you to identify this
equipment committee, because up to this point I was think-
ing everything was being done by this operating committee
of operating personnel under Rummel.
A. Well, I can’t remember—I can refresh my recollec-
tion, but at the moment the only people I can be sure of on
that committee were Mr. Leslie, Mr. Cocke—
Q All operating people?
A. Mr, Pierson, I believe, and I believe there were one
or two others, but I can’t remember for sure at the moment.
Q. All operating personnel, in a broad sense?
A. I wouldn’t guarantee that.
Q@ Mr. Sessel?
——
A-2812
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. There may have been an outside director on the
committee. I just can’t recall at this point.
Q. Mr. Sessel, perhaps?
A. I doubt—
Q. Mr. Breech?
A. No, I am sure Mr. Breech wasn’t on that committee.
Q. When you were reviewing these recommendations
did anyone of any importance or significance, or whose
views would be material—
A. My recollection is that it consisted mainly of the in-
side directors.
Q. Inside directors or inside employees?
A. Inside directors; Mr. Leslie, Mr. Cocke, Mr. Hall
But there may have been one or two outside directors on it
I would have to refresh my recollection to be sure, Mr.
Davis.
Q. So this was an equipment program which had been
generated by this personnel at TWA at a time when TWA
was without a voting trust—is that your understanding of
the facts?
[623] A. No. I think it started before there was a voting
trust, and ended after there was a voting trust, because the
study itself was dated in March. I think maybe March 10th
was the date of the study, and it is obviously the sort of
study that had taken quite a time to prepare, and I believe,
although I can’t state positively, that it was commenced
sometime in the latter part of 1960, and reached fruition in
the early part of 1961.
Q. But so far as you know, the new management group
or the new people in control of TWA had not impinged upon —
the study, they hadn’t influenced it in any way, had they!
A. The new management people, you say?
[624] Q. Yes, the new persons who had acquired control
of TWA.
A-2813
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Well, there weren’t any new people in management,
Mr. Davis, until I came in.
Q. What I am trying to say, Mr. Tillinghast, is the
people who acquired control of TWA as a result of the
voting trust did not exercise any influence or direction
which is reflected by this study or report?
A. To my knowledge, Mr. Davis, neither the voting
trustees nor the new directors stimulated, generated or
directed the preparation of ‘this study.
Q. You, some time shortly after March 30th, discussed
this report with Mr. Rummel?
A. The first time was on March 30th, I believe.
Q. At that time the report was fairly well completed,
bat you wanted to review it before submitting it to the
board; is that correct?
A. At that time the report was completed.
Q. That report contained an evaluation of the 990s?
A. It did.
Q. Did it also contain a comparison between the' 990
and what Boeing had to offer?
A. It did.
Q. Am I to understand that it concluded that [625] the
Boeing was more desirable?
A. It did.
Q You had occasion of discussing with Mr. Rummel the
uature and extent to which 990s might be available to TWA
if the decision in fact was to take 990s?
A. Yes.
Q Can you describe to me a little what was said at that
ime between you and Mr. Rummel or with respect to the
availability or lack of availabilty or probable availability
of the 990s?
$A. What I was told, Mr. Davis, and I can’t tie this to a
@eeific discussion, but what I was told was that Hughes
A-2814
Tillinghast—Deposition
Tool Company had some 990s on order, that they possibly
would be available, that whether or not they would be
available, and if so on what terms, wasn’t definitely known.
However, Hughes Tool had some delivery positions which
would be attractive if one were going to acquire 990s.
The 990s were in American Airlines’ cockpit configura.
tion, and if the 990s were purchased there would be a
problem of delay in delivery and a problem of expense in
converting the America cockpit—American [626] Airlines’
cockpit configuration to a TWA cockpit configuration, and
in that connection Mr. Rummel said that he had several
times tried to discuss this question with Mr. Hughes because
it seemed clear to him that if these planes were intended for
TWA, and if TWA were going to take them over, it was
important, had been important for a long time, that they
be constructed with TWA cockpits and TWA systems rather
than with American Airlines’ cockpits and systems, but that
he had never been able to discuss the matter with Mr.
Hughes, and he understood, he had been told by Convair,
that Mr. Hughes had given directions that Convair were
not to discuss the 990s with him or any of the TWA people.
Q. Is that the full extent of your recollection as to what
you discussed with Mr. Rummel relating to the 990s?
A. No, not relating to the 990s. We discussed far more
than this relating to the 990s, but I thought your question
was directed to the availability of the 990s.
Q. That is what I had in mind.
A. Well, as to the availability of the 990s, this is the
substance of—well, I need to add one other [627] thing,
that Mr. Rummel expressed the hope that we would not get
into a 990 negotiation because he felt that if we did it would
be typically long, involved and drawn out, and he felt very
deeply that TWA needed planes just as quickly as it could
get them, and he was afraid that the whole equipment pre .
A-2815
Tillinghast—Deposition
gram would be delayed if we got into extensive negotiations
on the 990s.
Q. Did he indicate at that time that for the terms and
conditions under which the planes were available they
would be or could be ativantageously used by TWA, assum-
ing that the terms and conditions.were not a problem?
A. Mr. Rummel’s view throughout was that if we were
going to get any planes they ought to be Boeings, and that
if we were going to get more planes we ought to get more
Boeings so as to have a more homogeneous fleet.
Q. In other words, it was Mr. Rummel’s position that it
was undesirable from TWA’s point of view to consider
9908, irrespective of any question of terms or conditions or
delivery schedules?
A. Not entirely, Mr. Davis. I am sure that Mr. Rum-
mel believed, felt—I had this discussion with him [628] at
a later time—that there obviously were terms good enough
that TWA should be interested in 990s, but they would have
involved, as I recall the figure, knocking a million dollars
or more off what he assumed computed would be the prob-
able price.
Q| You say you had a discussion with Mr. Rummel at a
tad time.
Are you still referring to the period from March 30th to
April 27th?
A. No, Iam not. Iam referring to a period in J uly.
Q. After this litigation started? .
A. That’s right. 3
Q. I am interested now in what took place during the
Period we are talking about.
A. Yes,
; Q. Did you have any further conferences or discussions
With Mr. Rummel between March 30th and April 17th that
any consequence, relating to this subject?
A-2816
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Yes. 7
Q. May I call to your attention that your calendar ap.
pears to refer to a date on April 2ist with Mr. Rummel,
but that is the only one, I believe, [629] that we have been
able to find.
A. Well, I have the feeling, Mr. Davis, and I may he
wrong here, that I had two meetings with Mr. Rummel
before I took office.
Q. Before you took office?
A. That’s right. I know that I had a meeting with Mr.
Rummel and Mr. Fellows, and that may have been this
meeting on the 30th or it may have been a meeting the fol-
lowing week that we agreed upon when we met on this date.
I know that when I had the meeting with Mr. Rummel
and Mr. Fellows that Mr. Fellows was there to discuss the
traffic problem, and at the meeting of which I am speaking,
at which Mr. Fellows was present, I had already made a
quick review of this document, the equipment program I
spoke about, and I was—wanted to have Mr. Fellows there
because I understood that he was the man who could best
answer the question of if we have all these planes, can we
fill them sufficiently with passengers so that we will earn
revenue with them, and I wouldn’t be positive, but I have
the feeling that I had one preliminary meeting with Mr.
Rummel and then a meeting with Mr. Rummel and Mr.
Fellows before the 17th of April.
£630] Q. Do you recall anything that was said by you
or by Mr. Rummel at the subsequent meetings which relate
to the availability of the 990s, the desirability of the 990s!
A. Well, I haven’t discussed yet the desirability of the
990s.
I have told you, Mr. Davis, about all that I can recall
about the availability of the 990s. I haven’t testified about
the desirability of the 990s.
A-2817
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Did you discuss the desirability? For the purpose
of shortening the record, I am not interested, on the desir-
ability, any more than the report shows, by Mr. Rummel,
unless you discussed whether or not there should be a
change in the report. -
Did you discuss any possible change in his report as to
desirability of the 990s?
A. No. As a mattér of fact, intensive discussions as
to the desirability of the 990s didn’t arise until some time
after the 17th of May, when the controversy with Hughes
Tool Company arose.
Q. There had been little or no discussion as to the de-
sirability of the 990s prior to that time?
A. There had been some discussion, but it wasn’t inten-
sive discussion.
£631] As I recall it, Mr. Rummel discussed with me why
it was that he preferred the Boeing 707 to any of the other
ships, and we briefly discussed each of the other ships and
its virtues and shortcomings, and why it was that he felt
that on balance the 707 was the desirable ship for TWA to
bay.
Q. Can you, as briefly as you can, summarize the rec-
ommendation that was made to the board of directors on
April 27th?
_4. Well, the recommendation was that TWA proceed
with a program for the purchase of 26 Boeing aircraft, con-
sisting of 20 707-1318 and six 707-3318.
Q. Excuse me for interrupting, but to identify, the six
Boeing 707-3318 are # long-range aircraft primarily used
in the international segment?
A. That’s the intercontinental version.
Q. The 20 707-1318 could be best described as short-
_ Fange or medium-range jets?
A-2818
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Long-range, but not as long as the 331.
Q. Was that the competitor, so to speak, of the 9901
A. I believe that has greater range than the 990.
Q. The 990, in fact, is a shorter range than the 131!
[632] A. It is a little shorter than the 131.
The 131B, and these were both fan engine, the 131B i
capable of trans-Atlantic utilization, whereas I do not be
lieve that is true of the 990.
Q. For the purpose of following your testimony, the
discussion you had with Mr. Rummel of the 990s versu:
the Boeing is really a comparison of the 131s of Boeing
versus the Convair 990?
A. That’s correct. The 990 isn’t onperils at all with
the 331B. It is broadly comparable with the 131B.
Q. I believe I interrupted you when you were going t
summarize the recommendation that was made to the boar
when you said it was basically to take 20 131Bs and si
331s.
A. Well, that is all I intended to say. That was th
recommendation.
Q. Between April 27th and your conversation with Mr
McCone had you had any occasion or opportunity to discus
the matter any further with either Mr. Rummel or Mr
Leslie or Mr. Cocke, and I am now referring to the subjec
of the desirability or lack of desirability of the 990s, 0
the nature or extent of the obligation of TWA to the Too
Company.
[633] A. Yes. As a matter of fact, during the perio
from the 17th of May through the period you have—
Q. June 8th?
A. June 10th.
Q. Prior to the June 10th letter, prior to the date of th
June 10th letter, I am saying.
A-2819
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Between May 17th and June 10th this subject was
a subject of very frequent discussion, and including an
afternoon session, Mr. Davis, when you sat with us and
stated at considerable length the reasons that you felt or
reasons that you felt we should take into account.
Q. Can you identify the date of that meeting?
A. I believe that was the 2nd of June.
Do you confirm that that is right? It is not on my calen-
dar here.
Q. I don’t have my calendar with me, but I am willing
to accept that. It is, I am told.
My question is was this conversation or series of con-
versations with Mr. McCone before or after June 2nd.
A.” I can’t distinctly recall these in relation to June 2nd.
I would—my best recollection, Mr. Davis, would be that I
had one before June 2nd and another [633A] after June
2nd, because I recall having told Mr. McCone that we either
were having or had had a discussion of the specific matter
with you.
[634] Q. Were these calls calls that were originated by
Mr. McCone to you or from you to Mr. McCone?
A. Most of them originated from Mr. McCone to me.
Q. But during this period in which these conversations
took place there were some calls from you to Mr. McCone?
A. Well, I think in every instance it was a case where
Mr. McCone had called and I called him back.
Q. Where was Mr. McCone, where did he live or where
was his business? :
A. Well, his home was in California, his business was in
i ornia, but he was in New York a good deal.
Q. These conversations that you have previously de-
tribed this morning, these were long distance telephone
alls, weren’t they?
A-2820
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. At least one of them was. I may have had a tele.
phone conversation with him when he was up at the Wal.
dorf in New York. He made it a habit almost whenever he
was in New York to call me up.
Q. This long distance call or calls that you had with Mr.
McCone, which were originated by him, as you recall, but
probably leaving word that he called, and you called him
back—
A. Yes. ;
Q. (Continuing) —where would he be calling from in
[635] California?
A. I can’t tell you specifically, Mr. Davis, I would know
only that I would receive a slip saying Mr. McCone called,
call operator so and so, and my secretary would get him on
the phone.
Q. You personally do not know where or how you would
go about reaching Mr. McCone by phone without your sec
retary’s assistance?
A. Well, I think I could find—well, I think I could find
him without her assistance, but she took care of the prob-
lem.
Q. But you don’t know where you would be reaching Mr.
McCone in connection with these telephone conversations
we are talking about, is that your testimony?
A. Well, I don’t know specifically. I presume it was at
the Joshua Hendy Company.
Q. Where, sir?
A. In Los Angeles.
Q. That is what I was trying to elicit from you.
I understood your testimony this morning to be that in
the course of that telephone conversation you took some
positive positions with Mr. McCone in connection with what
he was urging you to consider or reconsider?
A-2821
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Texpressed an opinion, yes.
[636] Q. That was based upon what you have described
as to what had taken place as to your study of the equip-
ment program that you have just testified about?
A. Well, it was based upon my appraisal of the whole
situation.
Q. But specifically, it was based upon your study of the
equipment program as programmed by Mr. Rummel and
this equipment committee, et cetera, that you just testified
about? 7
A. It included that.
Q. I would like you to describe, if yon please, what. if
anything, you did following this conversation with Mr. Me-
Cone to confirm your conclusions, if you did.
A. You mean to reconfirm—
Q. Imay have misunderstood your testimony, the record
will show what it was, but I understood it to be as to what
you said and what Mr. McCone said with respect to this 990
program, and the desirability of considering bailing out the
Tool Company.
A. Mr. Davis, this was the subject of very, very fre-
quent discussion in the office. I was discussing it very fre-
quently with Mr. Rummel and Mr. Leslie and Mr. Cocke,
and I can’t recall that as a consequence of this discussion
with Mr. McCone I did anything specific.
[637] Q. Did you ever communicate with a representa-
tive of the Hughes Tool Company for the purpose of find-
ing out to what extent the Tool Company was prepared
to enter into a firm or more definitive commitment that
would make 990s available to TWA, or the terms and con-
ditions under which they would be made available?
A. Yes. I wrote you several times about that.
-Q. Yon are referring to letters addressed to me?
7
A-2822
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. I guess they were addressed to Mr. Holliday. I stand
corrected. I believe they were addressed to Mr. Holliday.
Q. Can you identify those letters more specifically, Mr.
Tillinghast?
A. If I had before me the correspondence covering the
period from the 17th of April up to the middle of June
I am quite sure I could. Also, if I recall correctly, Mr.
Davis, at the meeting on the 2nd of June at which you
were present I asked that if you wished seriously to pursue
this you let us have some very definite terms just as
promptly as possible.
Q. Will you produce at our next session your copies of
letters to either Mr. Holliday or me or anyone whom you
thought was a representative of the Tool Company during
this period that you refer to which you have identified
[638] or described as inquiries as to the availability or
terms of the 990s?
Mr. Sonnett: You will have those, Mr. Davis. It would
facilitate it if you produced the originals, and the witness
can identify—
Mr. Davis: Mr. Sonnett, I cannot identify the letters
from the witness’ testimony. I do not know what letters
he thinks constitute that kind of request. Quite frankly,
I believe that I am fairly familiar with that correspondence.
I must say I have never thought about it in quite this con-
nection. We have been furnished with a great mass of
material, to be sure. It would be very burdensome for us
to try to identify what Mr. Tillinghast is talking about.
I think that we will move more rapidly, since Mr. Tilling-
hast knows what he is talking about, he knows the letters
he has in mind.
I am sure that we left the originals of those documents
in Mr. Tillinghast’s or TWA’s possession, and I am sure
A-2823
Tillinghast—Deposition
it yl be no difficulty whatever, if Mr. Tillinghast is willing,
pursuant to your advice, to identify or produce what he
has in mind. I am perfectly willing to take in place of a
physical production a sufficient identification of the letters
[639] so we may find them among the documents supplied
to us.
Mr. Sonnett: May I ask the witness a question? Maybe
we can facilitate this. .
We are dealing with letters written by you to Holliday
during what period of time?
Mr. Davis: The record shows that.
Mr. Sonnett: Iam sorry. I am just asking the question
because I don’t have in mind at the moment what the
record shows.
‘The Witness: The period May 17th to, oh, the middle
of June.
Mr. Sonnett: Isn’t it perfectly simple to get out of your
files the letters written by Mr. Tillinghast to Mr. Holliday
during that period of time?
Mr. Davis: No, it is not, sir, because Mr. Holliday re-
ceives letters in Houston, Texas, he sometimes receives
letters addressed to him at the Waldorf, and I probably
have copies of them, if he has been efficient, but I still will
not know what letters it is Mr. Tillinghast is referring to.
The ‘Witness: If you will produce copies—
Mr. Davis: Mr. Tillinghast, my position is on the record.
My only question now is whether you will [640] or will
not produce the letters that you have-been referring to as
constituting what you described, you claimed they con-
stitute,
Mr. Sonnett: Mr. Davis, we will produce them. My
only point is I thought you might have them at hand, and
it would save time to go ahead with the documents which
Mr. Holliday received and which you presumably have.
A-2824
Tillinghast—Deposition
Mr. Davis: If Mr. Tillinghast is prepared to identify
the letters more specifically, we may be able to find them.
Mr. Sonnett: How many letters are we talking about!
The Witness: Oh, I would say, both ways, a dozen or
15 letters, somewhere in that vicinity.
Mr. Davis: May we take a luncheon recess now?
The Witness: I am probably thinking of a few telegrams
in between.
Mr. Davis: I would prefer, in this area, Mr. Sonnett,
to have the witness satisfied that he is referring to all of
such documents, and I do not want to assume the burden
of presenting Mr. Tillinghast with what he subsequently
may feel is less than a complete reference to him as to the
documents he has [641] in mind which supports the testi-
mony he just gave.
Mr. Sonnett: You will have them after the luncheon
recess.
Mr. Davis: When would you like to return after lunch!
It is now a quarter of 1:00, ten of 1:00.
The Witness: 2:00 o’clock.
Mr. Sonnett: While we are on the scheduling, I still
have Rummel and Cocke sitting by.
Mr. Davis: I am sure, as I told you before, Mr. Son-
nett, you don’t need to keep either of those gentlemen on
tap. I will give you full, adequate notice, I believe, as to
when we will be finished with Mr. Tillinghast, and when
the next person may be expected—
Mr. Sonnett: All right. I want to know if you are now
able to tell me when you are going to finish with Mr. Til
linghast.
Mr. Davis: I do not know at this point when I am going
to be finished with Mr. Tillinghast, and as soon as I have
any indication as to when I may be through, I will so advise
you.
A-2825
Tillinghast—Deposition -
Mr. Sonnett: How far in advance do you propose to
advise me?
Mr. Davis: As much as I
would you like to have?
Mr. Sonnett: I would like several days’ notice—
Mr. Davis: I will undertake to give you several days’
notice before you have to Produce the next individual.
Mr. Sonnett: On that assumption, you will need Mr.
Tillinghast for tomorro and Friday.
Mr. Davis: There is 1
can. How much time [642]
We are now adjourning for lunch.
Mr. Sonnett: You are not telling me whether you want
this witness tomorrow morning or not?
Mr. Davis: I will tell you that at 2:00 o’clock this after-
matter is I am waiting for a com-
munication—
Mr. Sonnett: If you can tell me at 2:00 o’clock, that is
fine.
Mr. Davis: I wil] tell you when I know,
and not before.
Mr. Sonnett: The witness will be here.
(Whereupon, at 12:45 p.m. a luncheon recess was taken.)
ee
[643] AFTERNOON SESSION
2:05 p.m.
CHARLES C. TILLINGHAST, re
testified
er as follows:
-
sumed the stand and
A-2826
Tillinghast—Deposition
Mr. Sonnett: During the luncheon recess I obtained and
now produce two files containing letters from Chester C.
Davis at 120 Broadway and Raymond Holliday and others
to and from Mr. Tillinghast and TWA, which you asked us
to assemble and produce.
I have them here and now produce them.
I assume you want to mark them.
Mr. Davis: No. I wish you would hand them to the wit-
ness, Mr. Sonnett, if you please.
Mr. Sonnett: I think you ought to mark them before I
hand them to the witness, just to identify them. —
Would you like to mark them plaintiff’s exhibits?
Mr. Davis: No,.I am not prepared to mark them as ex-
hibits, Mr. Sonnett.
[644] Mr. Sonnett: I won’t show anything to the wit-
ness that is not identified on the record by a number.
Mr. Davis: I assure you that I will identify anything
which the witness has identified.
The question, Mr. Sonnett, on the record, is, I believe,
that I wanted this witness to identify the correspondence
which he claimed in his testimony to constitute an effort on
his part to determine from the Hughes Tool Company or
any of its representatives on what terms and conditions
990s would be available to TWA, and I am not interested
at this time in identifying a mass or a file of correspond-
ence.
The question is, I believe, simple enough, and it is merely
for Mr. Tillinghast, with the material which is now avail-
able to him, to identify, and then I will mark for identifica-
tion for this record, all letters, telegrams, or other com-
munications, which this witness claims constitute the sup-
port for his statement on the record that he made an effort
to determine from the Hughes Tool Company or any of its
A-2827
Tillinghast—Deposition
representatives or from anyone whom he thought was a
representative of the [645] Hughes Tool Company, the
terms and conditions under which 990 aircraft would be
available to TWA.
Mr. Sonnett: Mr. Davis, let me suggest to you the
following :
I know you are anxious, as usual, to continue to argue
with the witness, but the subject matter of. your request
was for correspondence to TWA from yourself or Mr.
Holliday or others which the witness thought related to
interference with—
Mr. Davis: You are referring to a different request, Mr.
Sonnett. I am referring to the request I made this morn-
ing, and the request I made was wholly unrelated to the
request I made for the witness to identify the correspond-
ence which he claimed constituted malicious or wilful inter-
ference with the affairs of TWA.
Which request are you now referring to?
Mr. Sonnett: Let me simplify your problem. I thought
I was meeting your request. These, after all, are commu-
nications written by you, Mr. Davis, or your client, Mr.
eHolliday, or others of Hughes Tool. You should be very
familiar with it. :
I thought I was being cooperative in offering vou the file
of correspondence in this area which [646] you requested.
We went to considerable length to get it at this late date
for you.
As to the claims of TWA, the claiths of TWA are that
every document you wrote, Mr. Holliday wrote, was written
in furtherance of the conspiracy charged in the complaint.
If you would like to debate the evidentiary weight of
every one with me, we will debate it, but I don’t propose to
have you engage in an argument with the witness about it.
A-2828
Tillinghast—Deposition
I am producing the documents. Do you want them or
don’t you?
Mr. Davis: You leave them right where they are.
Mr. Sonnett: You mark these as being produced now
and available for inspection as Plaintiff’s Exhibits 1 and 2,
and then you can do what you like with them.
Mr. Davis: Will you use A and B instead of confusing
them with 1 and 2?
Mr. Sonnett: They are plaintiff’s exhibits, so I don't
think there will be much confusion. We went to a lot of
trouble to get these for you, and now you are standoffish
about looking at them, [647] even though it is principally
communications from you and Mr. Holliday.
Mr. Davis: Of course, Mr. Sonnett, I am not going to
take the time to correct every misstatement you make—
Mr. Sonnett: You will never have an opportunity, be-
cause I don’t make them.
Mr. Davis: I told you ten times that Mr. Holliday is not
my client, and you persist in saying that. It is rather
typical of your understanding of the facts.
Mr. Sonnett: You represent Hughes Tool Company,
don’t you?
Mr. Davis: That’s right. Your statement a moment ago
was I represent Mr. Holliday, and I do not believe that
you are not capable of remembering something—
Mr. Sonnett: Is Mr. Holliday an officer of Hughes Tool
Company?
Mr. Davis: Mr. Holliday is an officer of Hughes Tool
Company. You said this morning you do not represent
Mr. Breech. Do you represent every officer and stock-
holder of TWA?
Mr. Sonnett: I represent each of them, and [648] in
that capacity, Mr. Howard Hughes,
A-2829
Tillinghast—Deposition
Mr. Davis: Iy that capacity, you are using your best
efforts for the Haghes Tool Company?
Mr. Sonnett: Certainly.
Mr. Davis: When the time comes, we will have to find
out who you were trying to represent—
Mr. Sonnett: All of the stockholders of the company.
Mr. Davis.
Mr. Davis: Will you mark those two files as Plaintiff’:
Exhibits 1 and 2 as requested, and then I will proceed with
my questioning of the witness.
(Group of documents marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1
for identification, as of this date.)
(Group of documents marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 2
for identification, as of this date.)
Examination (Cont’d) by Mr. Davis:
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, you have before you two files of
numerous documents which have been produced by your
counsel, and I ask you to identify each communication which
supported the statement of yours this morning to the effect
that you wrote on numerous occasions to the [649] Hughes
Tool Company, or representatives of the Tool Company,
with respect to the terms and conditions or the availability
of 990s to TWA.
A. Mr. Davis, without admitting the accuracy of your
characterization of my former testimony, I leafed quickly
through these papers this noon, and my recollection is re-
freshed that I first raised this question at our meeting on.
Jane 2nd, that on June 8, 1961, Mr. Rowe, at my request,
wrote a letter drawing attention to the request I made on
June 2nd—
Q Excuse me for interrupting, Mr. Tillinghast, but so
there will be no misunderstanding, I want you, with respect
A-2830
Tillinghast—Deposition
to each document that is in response to my question, I want
to have it marked as a defendants’ exhibit.
If you please, as you go along, I would appreciate it if
you would refer to the letter, have it marked, and then you
may make any comment or explanation that you wish with
respect to it. It would be helpful if at the same time you
_ could refer to the portion or the portions of any lengthy
letter which you characterized as constituting a request for
information as to the terms, conditions and availability of
the 990s.
Mr. Sonnett: As purely a mechanical [650] sug-
gestion, to avoid further wasting of time, may I sng-
gest that when the witness identifies the date of a
letter, and from and to whom, that instead of stop-
ping with the reporter to physically mark it, we deem
it marked the next defendants’ exhibit. We can phys-
ically do the marking at the close of the session.
Mr. Davis: Let us furnish the witness with some
paper clips then, so we will not spend too much time
in doing that.
Mr. Sonnett: Fine.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, we will have no objection, if you can,
to identifying the portions of a letter if the letter relates to
several subjects, so that it will not be necessary for me
thereafter to pick up each document and ask you to indicate
the portion of the letter which constituted a request within
the scope of my question.
A. Mr. Davis, I do not have with me the transcript of
the discussion on the 2nd of June.
However, I do have a copy here of Mr. Rowe’s letter of
June 8, 1961, and in this regard I call your attention to the
next to the last paragraph.
A-2831
Tillinghast—Dc position
Q. Which reads how?
[651] A. Well, it reads as it reads, Mr. Davis, but this
particular—one particular part said, speaking of me:
“What he clearly said was that if TWA is to consider the
acquisition of Convair’990s it has to have a specific, defini-
tive, written statement of the terms on which they would be
available, including the question of whether or not Hughes
Tool Company would be willing, in effect, to give us a deliv-
ery bond and pay us a penalty for every week of delay from
the deliveries which you state.”
Q. Will you hold that for a second so that we can save
time, Mr. Tillinghast? This was a letter dated June 8th?
A. This is a letter dated June 8th.
Q. Written at your request?
A. Written at my request.
Q. Is that the first communication in answer to my
question, or are you picking them up as you find them? Is
it your recollection that was the first time such a request
was made of Hughes Tool Company? Ft
A. No. The first time, as I have said several times, Mr.
Davis, was on June 2nd, at the meeting which we had in the
board room of TWA, at which you were present.
[652] Q. I have a transcript of that.
A. And of which you have a transcript.
Q. Referring to that comment, is that reference to a
bond where you were requesting that the Hughes Tool Com-
pany give TWA a bond for the performance by General
Dynamics as to delivery dates of the aircraft?
A. That’s correct.
Q. The next communication?
A. The next communication is on June 16, 1961, and
consists of a letter from me to Mr. Holliday. In the first
paragraph 4 of the letter to which I have just referred it
A-2832
Tillinghast—Deposition
is stated: “It should be noted, however, that you have not
even yet advised us of the purchase price of the planes, an
obviously essential term. You have also failed to advise
us of the form in which Hughes Tool Company would want
payment for the assignment of its rights under the pur-
chase agreement, whether in cash or subordinated obliga-
tions, or otherwise. These are all facts that in addition to
the relative advantages to TWA of the Convair 990s and
other equipment must be taken into consideration in weigh-
ing your proposal.” .
Q. This was a letter addressed to Mr. Holliday, replying
to the three proposals in the letter of June [652A] 10th,
which is Defendants’ Exhibit 101
A. That’s correct.
[653] Q. Anything else?
A. That is all that I have discovered so far, Mr. Davis.
Q. Do you have in mind the existence of any other
communication!
to go through the file.
Q. Does that indicate to you that you would like to
change your testimony of this morning?
A. No, it does not.
Q. You feel that this morning you fairly described your
efforts to obtain information from the Tool Company in
the manner that you did?
A. Yes. There were several requests for specific infor-
mation, none of which, so far as I can recall, was satisfied.
Q. The requests for information you are referring to
are those that you have adverted to, including the tran-
script of what occurred on June 2nd?
A. That’s correct.
A-2833
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. And that is all that you have in mind?
A. That is all that I have in mind.
[654] Mr. Davis, I have got to change that, because I
believe, if I recall correctly, that Mr. Rowe had some oral
conversations with you on the subject. I do recall that he
was seeking a copy of the contract. He received a copy of
the contract, and the price schedule was not attached to it.
I believe, as I say, that in addition to what I have re-
ferred to here, Mr. Rowe had either correspondence or con-
versations or both with you on the subject.
Q You recall, then, that Mr. Rowe, in connection with
this letter of his that you have referred to, also asked for
a copy of the contract with General Dynamics relating to
the 990s?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And he received same?
A. He did, minus certain schedules.
Q. Was that request of Mr. Rowe made pursuant to
your suggestion or request to him?
A. Yes. I asked him to get the material.
Q Up to that point TWA had not sought or obtained
to seek @ copy of the contract with specifications referred
to in that contract between General Dynamics and Hughes
Tool Company?
[655] A. Well, now, I can’t answer that definitely.
Whether somebody at some point had tried to get this in-
formation and failed, I don’t know. The only thing I know
for sure is that we didn’t have it.
Q° Did you inquire of either Mr. Rummel or Mr. Leslie
or Mr, Cocke if they had any information as to the price
or how to go about determining the price of such aircraft?
& T discussed that with Mr. Rummel on several occa-
sgt 0 se AEP 2 en Boge
A-2834
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. I am referring to the time that you were seeking
to obtain this detailed information from the Hughes Tool
Company so as to be in a position to make a business deci-
sion.
A. I just can repeat that I discussed that with Mr. Rum-
mel on several occasions.
Q. What did Mr. Rummel tell you?
A. Mr. Rummel told me that they had guessed at a price
computed as best they could what M&ghes Tool Company’s
price would be, but there were several variables in it, and
he couldn’t tell me either exactly what the Hughes Tool
Company price would be or the terms on which we could
take an assignment if there was in fact an assignment.
[656] Q. You understand that it is normal under a pur-
chase contract with a manufacturer of aircraft that the ex-
act price is subject to variation based upon events and
change orders and various details relating to the aircraft!
A. Yes, I am quite conscious of that.
Q. A moment ago you estimated that the commitment
of the Tool Company would be in the neighborhood, as you
understood, of $5 million per aircraft, or $65 million for
the 13—you remember testifying to that effect!
A. Yes.
Q. Was that estimate on your part based upon what
Mr. Rummel had told you in these discussions you had with
him?
A. It was.
Q. Have you had occasion to subsequently find out
whether or not the estimate of $5 million per aircraft is
fairly close to what you would anticipate would be the price
for a 990 aircraft?
A. It is my understanding that it is fairly close to what
I would anticipate the price of a 990 aircraft to be.
A-2835
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Isn’t it also true, Mr. Tillinghast, that in [657] order
to determine the desirability of an aircraft you have to con-
sider the cost of the aircraft for the purpose of determining
whether its nse along various segments of the route of the
airplane will permit you to make money or lose money?
A. No doubt about it.
Q. I thought that you also explained that you had very
carefully studied, between Mf arch 30th and April 27th, a
report of the operating personnel that included their recom-
mendations and evaluations of the 990 aircraft.
A. That’s correct.
Q. Are you trying to tell me now, Mr. Tillinghast, that
these studies made by TWA, evaluating the advantages and
disadvantages of 990 versus the Boeing, this was done with-
out any reliable information of any kind as to the cost of
such aircraft?
A. It was done without any specific advice from Hughes
Tool Company as to the price at which Hughes Tool Com-
pany would in fact assign these aircraft to TWA.
Q. But you knew even at that time, even with your short
experience in the airline industry, or with TWA, that TWA
had traditionally obtained aircraft from the [658] Hughes
Tool Company at the Hughes Tool Company’s cost?
A. T understood that that had happened on quite a num-
her of occasions.
Q. Wasn’t it your understanding that if these aircraft
vere, pursuant to past.ppactices that Mr. McCone referred
to, made available to TWA it would be, presumably, at the
actual cost to the Tool Company, a figure which is not deter-
minable until the aircraft are ready for. delivery?
A. I did not know, and had no way of knowing, in fact,
at what price the Tool Company would make them avail.
ee
A-2836
Tillinghast—Dposition
Q. Am I to understand from your testimony, Mr. Tilling-
hast, that when you were discussing with Mr. McCone the
advantage and lack of advantage of considering bailing out
the Tool Company or the desirability of these aircraft you
had no idea whatever as to what those aircraft would cost!
A. That is your statement. Mr. Davis, not mine.
Q. Iam asking what yours was.
A. No, I had a knowledge of a global figure which 990s
should cost. I had no knowledge as to the terms on which
Hughes Tool Company would in fact make them available
to TWA.
[659] Q. But you knew that the past practice of the
Tool Company had been to make them available to TWA at
no more than the cost of the Tool Company?
A. I knew in a general way what the past practice was,
but I had no way of knowing whether the past practice
would in fact be followed in the future, or, in fact, whether
Hughes Tool Company would make the planes available.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, isn’t it true that at that time you
were concerned in pursuing a financing program with the
lending institutions relating to the Boeing aircraft and that
is what primarily was on your mind?
A. That is not so, Mr. Davis.
Q. Are you aware of the extent to which Mr. Breech
consulted or discussed this matter of additional jet aircraft
with Mr. Rummel?
A. Except for discussions at the April 27th directors’
meeting, and possibly also at the June directors’ meeting,
I have no knowledge that Mr. Breech ever discussed the
question with Mr. Rummel.
Q. Excuse me for interrupting the train of thought, but
it suddenly occurred to me that since your counsel produced
these two files of documents marked Plaintiff’s [660] Ex-
——— Sa
Tillinghast—Deposition
hibits 1 and 2, intermingling two requests of mine, let me
go back for just a moment and ask you now to examine
those two files and identify the documents which you previ-
ously testified constituted malicious and willful or other
kind of interference by-Hughes Tool Company or me or any
representative of the Tool Company.
As before, I would appreciate it if you would clip the
document so that it later may be marked for identification.
Mr. Sonnett: I think I will have to undertake to
answer that question, Mr. Davis. It is argumenta-
tive.
It is the position of TWA that all communications
by you and by Mr. Holliday in this connection were
acts in furtherance of the conspiracy and other vio-
lations of law charged in the complaint.
Mr. Davis: I appreciate that, Mr. Sonnett.
My question is to the witness. You May direct the
witness not to answer if you choose to.
Mr. Sonnett: I advise the witness that your ques-
tion is argumentative, and therefore does not require
an answer.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, you recall testifying, do you [661]
not, that you received and knew of communications by the
Tool Company which you characterized as being unwar-
ranted interference with the affairs of TWA—do you recall
your testimony in that regard?
A. I recall my testimony in that regard.
Q. Do you also recall testifying that you had reference
to dozens of communications and telegrams?
A. Idon’t think I said dozens, Mr. Davis.
Q. Have yon finished your answer?
A. Yes.
A-2838
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Without reference to the number of documents, which
I believe you did testify to at one point, let me refer you to
page 472 of your testimony. Let me start you, if I may, at
page 471, when there was again some discussion between
counsel as to the line of that inquiry.
At the bottom of page 471 you, as a witness, said:
“Mr. Davis, let me say I am referring to all of the
letters you wrote, which were very numerous and
lengthy and considerable, from the period beginning
about the 15th of May and continuing through the
period really up to the present.”
The next question was:
[662] “Those are the communications which you
feel constitute interference by the Tool Company in
the affairs of TWA?
“A. Oh, I didn’t say that, Mr. Davis. I think
some of the letters were appropriate, perhaps proper
statements of position to management, and others
were unwarranted interference in management of
TWA.”
The next question was:
“Will you identify, if not by exact dates, the letters
or the number of letters which you have in mind as
letters which you felt constituted unwarranted inter-
ference in the affairs of TWA?”
Then, if you will recall, Mr. Tillinghast, just subsequently
you felt that they were, on page 473, where your answer
was: ' :
“Well, Mr. Davis, they were so numerous that it
would be difficult for me to recall all of them.”
A-2839
Tillinghast—Deposition
You have before you, Mr. Tillinghast, the file prepared by
your counsel which purports to include all the letters and
communications which your counsel, in support of the com-
plaint, feels constitute unwarranted interference. I am ask-
ing you to identify the —E662A] communications which you
had in mind when you testified as you did.
Mr. Sonnett: Are you through?
[663] Mr. Davis: I have asked a question, Mr.
Sonnett.
Mr. Sontett: You have made various references
to what TWA’s counsel feels or what these files are
supposed to represent in the judgment of TWA’s
counsel, and you are quite incorrect.
They represent an effort to assemble for you, in
response to a belated request, communications from
you or Holliday or others acting on behalf of Hughes
Tool Company to TWA, and, I think, and I am in-
formed, that they represent all of the written com-
munications that we have in the files.
As to their evidentiary significance, Mr. Davis,
this is a matter that the Court is going to have to
determine, and I don’t propose to have you get into
a debate with the witness as to what document proves
what.
These are communications that you sent or re-
ceived or Holliday sent or received. They speak for
themselves. The best evidence of what they say is
in the documents.
I don’t suppose you. want to quarrel with the au-
thenticity of these copies, or of the originals, in
same cases, bearing your own signature, but it seems
to me you are taking an awful lot of time in nagging
£664] at a question of let’s debate what the docu-
_Ments prove.
A-2840
Tillinghast—Deposition
If you call the witness’ attention to any particular
document in the series of communications, you want
to ask him any questions about conferences, discus.
sions, or whatever he did or said in response or in
connection therewith, go ahead.
By Mr. Davis:
°Q. Do you understand my question, Mr. Tillinghast!
A. Yes, I understand your question.
Mr. Davis: May he answer the question, Mr. Son-
nett? ©
Mr. Sonnett: I don’t understand the question, my-
self. >
Mr. Davis: Will you read the question back to
the witness? I know there was some lapse of time
since my question.
Mr. Sonnett: You see, if you put questions with-
out oratory we would be better off. Your reference
as to what TWA’s counsel intended or thought or
believed or how these documents were assembled,
was inaccurate. So I had to*correct it.
(The question was read.)
Mr. Sonnett: I object to the form of\the [665]
question and advise the witness not to answer it.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, will you identify from the material
which is before you the letters or communications which.
you had in mind when you testified as you did at page 471°
and 472 of the transcript?
A. Well—
Q. To avoid wasting time, you need not refer to com-
munications which you described as being appropriate. |
‘am interested solely in your identifying those documents
Saas
A-2841
Tillinghast—Deposition
which you felt were unwarranted interference in manage-
ment of TWA.
A. Well, Mr. Davis, let me first say this, that I think
this whole line of correspondence was for the purpose and »
intent of interfering. unduly with TWA’s purchase of
Boeing aircraft.
But dealing specifically with those letters which-affirma-
tively caused interference, and leaving out the routine
ones—
Q. You mean routine letters of interference? % don’t
want you to leave out anything, Mr. Tillinghast.
A. Then I will have to say, Mr. Davis, that your letter
of May 16, 1961, written to the board of directors, saying
that you had been retained by Hughes Tool Company in
connection with its acquisition and possible distribution of
[666] debentures—
Q. Wasn’t that a letter by me as a member of the firm
of Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett?
A. That’s correct, yes.
Q. It was a letter by Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett to the
board of directors of TWA, dated May 16th?
A. That’s right.
Q. That is one letter that you had in mind as being an
interference with TWA—
A. To the extent that it was part of an overall plan to
interfere with the purchase of Boeing aircraft, although I
suppose the letter, on its face, is, let us say, fairly innocuous
The letter of May 19, 1961, to the Securities and Ex-
change Commission, is, in my view, a clear interference
with the management of TWA.
Your telegram of May 22, 1961 appears to be routine and
A-2842
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Likewise, the telegram of May 22, 1961, which merely
advises of Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett’s withdrawal.
Please clip those. I think it will prevent any possible
error by the reporter as he subsequently marks them, so we
will be sure the court record will be complete as well as
accurate.
[667] Mr. Sonnett: Let’s be clear, so we don't
have any further needless controversy, you are ask-
ing the witness to clip not the telegram from Simp.
son, Thacher advising of their withdrawal, you are
asking him to clip only the ones which he character.
izes as overt and clear indications of interference!
Mr. Davis: I am asking him to identify what he
was referring to when he testified as he did at the
parts in the record that I previously mentioned, Mr.
Sonnett, and since in one of his answers he admitted
that some of them were appropriate, I am telling him
that I am not asking him to identify any communica-
tion which he thought was appropriate.
Mr. Sonnett: Okay. All right. Now we under.
stand what you are supposed to do with the paper
clips.
Mr. Davis: Whenever you are interested to pur-
sue the subject as to what happened in connection
with the withdrawal of Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett
or my withdrawal from that firm in order to continue
to represent Hughes Tool Company so as to bring
out the facts, I will be very happy to pursue that
subject either under oath or in appropriate affidavits
to the Court.
Mr. Sonnett: Mr. Davis, I know the firm of [668]
Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett for many years, and I
regard it as an outstanding and very distinguished
firm.
A-2843 \
Tillinghast—Deposition & -
A. A letter of May 24, 1961, from Mr. Settles to Mr.
Duckworth, which, on its face, is harmless, except in the
light of the purpose for which it was written.
The same—well, on May 25, 1961, there is a letter to Mr
Hocker of the Securities and Exchange Commission, which
I deem to have been for the purpose of delaying the effec-
tiveness of TWA’s registration.
On May 25, 1961 there was a letter from Mr. Settles
addressed to me, on its face unobjectionable, except for the
purpose for whith it was written.
The same may be said for the second letter—I will clip
the two of them together here—from Mr. Settles as of the
same date.
On May 26, 1961 there is a letter from Mr. Davis to
the Irving Trust Company, the Equitable Life Assurance
Society, Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, the director
of Trans World Airlines, and Messrs. Breech, Olds and
Holliday, the purpose of which, in my opinion—the purpose
and effect of which, in my opinion, was to interfere with
the affairs of TWA.
There isa letter dated May 26, 1961, from Mr. [669]
Holliday to Mr. Breech, Mr. Olds and Mr. Holliday, which,
on its face, appears to be harmless,
There is a letter dated May 26, 1961—
Q. Excuse me. I don’t think you finished your last
answer.
Mr. Davis: Read back what Mr. Tillinghast said.
(The answer was read.)
Q. Is that what you said, Mr. Tillinghast?
A. Yes,
Q Iam not asking vou to identify those that you con-
r harmless.
A-2844
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Lamsorry. There is a letter dated May 26th—I will
skip that.
Telegram dated May 31, 1961, from Hughes Tool to
Boeing Aircraft Company.
_ Letter dated May 31st—it should be telegram dated June
1, 1961, from Chester C. Davis to Mr. Rowe.
Telegram dated June 2, 1961, from Mr. Holliday to me.
Letter dated June 4, 1961, from Mr. Davis to Mr. Rowe.
Letter dated June 4, 1961, from Mr. Davis to Mr. Olds.
[670] Letter dated June 8, 1961, from Mr. Davis to Mr.
Breech.
Letter dated June 9, 1961, from Mr. Holliday to me,
which on its face appears harmless, and appears objection-
able only so far as it is part of a plan and conspiracy.
A letter from Mr. Holliday to Trans World Airlines, Mr.
Breech, Mr. Olds, Mr. Holliday, Irving Trust Company,
Equitable Assurance Society, Metropolitan Life Insurance
Company.
Q. When you refer to Irving Trust Company, isn’t it
addressed to Irving Trust Company as agent?
A. Yes, it is.
Mr. Sonnett: You haven’t given the date.
A. Dated June 10, 1961.
Q. Is that what has previously been marked as Defend-
ant Exhibit 10 as containing several proposals (handing
to witness) ?
A. Yes.
Mr. Davis: Actually, the record might show it is
addressed to Messrs. Breech, Olds and Holliday as
voting trustees.
Mr. Sonnett: From?
Mr. Davis: From Hughes Tool Company, by Mr.
Holliday.
A-2845
Tillinghast—Deposition
[671] Mr. Sonnett: The same Mr. Holliday?
Mr. Davis: Oh, yes.
Mr. Sonnett: Now I understand the true meaning
of the song I’m Going To Sit Right Down And Write
Myself A Letter.
Mr. Davis: When they do that, please send it
COD to Mr. Sonnett, because we don’t want to pay
for it.
Mr. Sonnett: I will pay for it. It was worth it,
[672] A. A telegram dated June 20, 1961, from Mr.
Holliday to Mr. Sessel, a copy of which, I think, or a tele-
gram similar to which was sent to each of the other
directors.
A letter dated June 21, 1961, from Mr. Holliday to the
bard of directors of TWA.
A letter from Mr. Davis to Mr. Rowe of June 21, 1961.
letter from Mr. Settles dated June 27, 1961.
Letter of June 30, 1961, from Mr. Davis to Mr. Reed.
I think that covers the list, Mr. Davis, up to the filing of
he complaint.
Mr. Davis: Will the reporter then mark all those
documents identified by Mr. Tillinghast as Defend.
ants’ Exhibit 11, and each document identified with a
letter.
087] Q. Then I believe you testified that the other oc-
ons that you recall, when you discussed the [858] finan-
Lcondition or financial problems, as I understood them,
‘the Tool Company, was in connection with this subordi-
led debenture offering?
A. Yes,
A-2846
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. And that was a discussion at that time that you had
with Mr. Leslie?
A. Yes.
Q. What was the occasion for that discussion? Can you
give me the substance of what was said?
A. Well, the occasion for the discussion, Mr. Davis, as
best I recall it, is that Mr. Leslie came into my office one
day and said that he had been talking with a Mr. Forrester
whom he knew—I believe they both live in Greenwich—and
that Mr. Forrester said that he had been retained just a day
or two before in order to handle a proposed public offering
of Hughes Tool Company share—secondary offering of the
Hughes Tool Company share of our subordinate debentures.
He said that Mr. Forrester wanted to talk with us about
a possible delay of the effective date of our offering 80 a8
to accommodate this. :
I remember saying to Mr. Leslie, or asking Mr. Leslie
what did he think this was all about, and did he have any
recommendation. He went on to say—
[859] Q. “He,” being Leslie? |
A. Leslie. He went on to say that he had been asso¢-
ated with Mr. Hughes for years, and knew him like a book,
and that one thing he knew about Mr. Hughes was that if
he was planning to go across the street to buy a package of
cigarettes, that he would say that he was going in the other
direction to go to the bathroom.
He said, “You better take a good, hard look at this before
you say anything about it.”
We discussed why Hughes Tool Company wished to dis
pose of these. Whether it presaged a decision to sell out its
interest in TWA or whether it indicated something els,
and without having ‘a very clear recollection in my i
just what he had to say about the details of the Hughes Tod
A-2847
Tillinghast—Deposition
Company’s finances, I do recall that there was some discus-
sion of it at that time.
Q. That offering by TWA was one which was being
undertaken pursuant to the agreements entered into in the
December 1960 financing, isn’t that right?
A. That is correct.
Q. That offering by TWA was not designed to raise any
cash by TWA, was it?
A. No, that was merely to re-finance the obligation to
Hughes Tool. ~
£860] Q. The $100 million interim note to Hughes Tool?
A. That is right.
Q. So that the timing of that offering would not result
in TWA having any more or less equity money or working
capital or cash, isn’t that right? .
A. That is correct.
Q. Except perhaps to the limited extent to which the
Tool Company had an option to subscribe to an additional
$11 million-some odd of these debentures?
A. So far as the timing is concerned.
Q. That offering was for $11 million, but only the Tool
Company had an option to subscribe to the additional $11
million ; isn’t that correct?
A. Substantially, yes.
Q. Mr. Leslie discussed with you an approach made to
him by Mr. Forrester; is that correct?
A. Right. .
Q. Mr. Forrester is a senior executive of Merrill, Lynch,
Fenner & Bean; is that correct?
A. He is a member of the firm. I am not sure just what
his seniority is,
©. Yon never had any reason to doubt the bona fides of
Mr “ r or Merrill, Lynch, have you?
0.
A-2848
Tillinghast—Deposition
[861] Q. And Mr. Leslie reported to you that appar.
ently the Hughes Tool Company was interested in making a
secondary offering?
A. That is correct.
Q. And did that indicate to you that therefore the
Hughes Tool Company was interested in effect of realizing
some cash?
A. Well, that would indicate that, yes.
Q. Was it your understanding that the Hughes Tool
Company had furnished a great deal of cash in connection
with the aircraft equipment obtained by TWA as a result
of orders placed, or the transactions which took place in
1959 and 1960?
A. Yes, I was aware of that.
Q. And the Tool Company in connection with the 1960
financing, had received this $100 million interim note
rather than cash? *
A. That is right. =
Q. The $100 million note in effect reflected the cash in-
vestment made by the Tool Company in connection with
the aircraft obtained by TWA?
A. That is my understanding.
Q. And now apparently the Tool Company indicated an
interest or desire to get some cash back; is that right?
[862] A. Yes.
Q. And you thought in your discussions with Mr. Leslie
that there was some underlying motive of the Tool Com-
pany that should be explored?
A. Mr. Leslie raised that question, yes.
Q. That was when Mr. Leslie explained to you that
based upon his prior association with Mr. Hughes, he felt
that Mr. Hughes was likely to go a long way around to buy
a package of cigarettes?
A-2849
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Right.
Q. Was there any discussion at that time as to what
would the Tool Company do with all this cash if it once
got that secondary offering—if it was successful?
A. I think, as I recall it, Mr. Davis, there was some dis-
cussion of whether the Tool Company was hard up and
really needed this money, and what they would do with it.
I don’t remember much of the detail of what was said, but
I know that general subject was discussed.
Q. I would like you to concentrate on that conversation
with Mr. Leslie, if you will, please. I would like you to tell
me whether or not in effect there was a discussion with
Mr. Leslie speculating as to whether or not the Hughes
Tool Company might have in mind a plan for re-financing
the TWA debt to the lending institutions?
[863] A. I believe, Mr. Davis, that there was some men-
tion of that possibility. ;
Q. It was discussed, wasn’t it?
A. I believe it was discussed.
Q. That was an important subject to you, was it not?
A. Not terribly, no, sir.
Q. If you recall, when you were hired as president, one
of the matters of concern to you—whether you raised the
subject or Mr. Breech did—had to do with the possibility
of the Tool Company ever being able to re-finance?
A. That is correct.
Q. And here we were in the same. year, in May of the
same year, and there was a move made by the Tool Com-
pany which on the surface at least appeared desirous of
producing about $100 million in cash, and you didn’t asgo-
os the two possibilities at all in your mind, Mr. Tilling-
?
_ A-2850
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Mr. Davis, I am sure that I must have associated the
two things in my mind in a broad sense. It has been my
feeling, however, that so far as the management of TWA
is concerned, its job is to manage TWA—to try to further
the interests of the corporation and all of its [864] stock.
holders—and not be concerned with matters personal to
particular stockholders.
Q. I am not inquiring at this point as to your views as
to the duties of the management of TWA. I am interested
in what took place when Mr. Leslie reported to you that
Mr. Forrester had been asked by the Tool Company to
develop a program designed to effect a secondary offering
which would have given the Tool Company, or replenished
the Tool Company with more or less $100 million.
A. T have reported it as best I can, Mr. Davis.
Q. Do you think you have fairly and adequately and
fully described your conversation with Mr. Leslie in dis-
cussing or speculating as to what Mr. Hughes or the
Hughes Tool-Company was up to?
A. As best I can recall it at the moment, yes.
Q. Do you have any notes or letters or communications
that you made to anyone else which would help you to
refresh your recollection?
A. Not on this subject, no.
Q. Do you have any notes, in Defendants’ Exhibit 1,
your calendar, that would help you to identify about when
it was you had this conversation with Mr. Leslie?
A. Yes, I can tell you when it was. If I am not [865]
mistaken, it was on the 11th of May, because I believe it
was the day before I sat down with Mr. Forrester and
some other people to discuss this specific request.
Q. As.a result of your conversation with Mr. Leslie,
you asked him to arrange for a meeting between you and
Mr. Forrester and others?
A-2851
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Yes. I believe that the purpose of Mr. Leslie’s com-
ing in to my office was in order to say that Mr. Forrester
wanted to come up and discuss the matter with me.
Q. You find that entry on May 12th, do you not?
A. That is correct, yes.
Q. And Mr. Leslie spoke to you about that on May 11th,
the day before?
A. That is correct,
Q. Before you met with Mr. Forrester, didn’t you call
Mr. Breech to tell him about the information?
A. No, I am quite sure [I called Mr. Breech after I
talked with Mr. Forrester.
Q. You mean on the 12th?
A. On the 12th, yes.
Q. Tell us about your meeting with Mr. Forrester on
the 12th then.
A. Mr. Forrester came up with his lawyer, Mr. Hagarty.
[866] Q. Of the Sherman, Sterling firm?
A. Yes. We discussed this thing, and he outlined it.
Q. What did he outline to you? sy ae
A. He outlined the proposal that they wanted to make.
Q. Who is “they”?
A. Merrill, Lynch—wanted to make for the secondary
offering, and their desire to obtain a week’s postponement
of our offering, in order that they might do a secondary.
I told them that I was very concerned about the fact that
end of the month, by the 31st of May, as I recall it, and that
one thing that I had to be concerned about was whether
or not a postponement of this might interfere in any way
with the consummation of the Boeing program, and the ob-
taining of the commitments necessary to carry out the Boe-
A-2852
Tillinghast—Deposition
[867] Q. Will you explain at this point your under.
standing as a chief executive of TWA, what the relationship
was of this offering by TWA of these convertible deben-
tures, which would not produce any cash for TWA, the
financing arrangements with the lending institutions, which
was related to this Boeing purchase program—
Mr. Sonnett: Would you mind reading that back!
(The question was read.)
A. One of the obvious questions in my mind, Mr. Davis,
was whether or not if ‘we fan into a serious delay on this,
whether or not it might.in any way affect our Boeing financ-
ing. With that in mind, I talked with Mr. Brandi.
Q. Of Dillon, Read?
A. Yes, to ask him whether in his opinion-it would make
any difference one way or another to the consummation
of the Boeing financing. He said he thought it would. He
thought it would be undesirable to get mixed up in anything
that would involve a serious sag in the schedule.
For that reason I was very concerned at the time of this
meeting with Mr. Forrester to see whether [868] or not he
could say anything that would change my judgment.
Qe Let me see if we can get this straightened out in my
mind.
A. May I finish?
Q. Please continue.
A. My judgment that it was.the most unlikely thing that
one could suddenly bring in a third party, and in one week's
time turn an offering of this sort into an underwritten
public offering.
I specifically taxed Mr. Forrester and Mr. Hagarty with__
the question of whether or not they could assure me that in
fact this could be done, and told them my own limited ex-
A-2853
Tillinghast—Deposition
perience in the securities field—told me that even under
the best circumstances it would be most unlikely that one
could do this within that period of time. And I thought if
Mr. Hughes was genuine in wishing to make an offering of
his interest, that we would extend to him every cooperation
on a secondary offering, and indeed the lawyers discussed
how by stickering the prospectus, this could be done imme-
diately following our offer. ;
To come to the end of the discussion, I told Mr. Forrester
that I quite appreciated his interest [869] in engaging in
this activity, but personally I thought it was an impractical
thing to do, and that while it was not & matter on which I
that we go right ahead with it, and extend to Hughes Tool,
if it wished to do 80, every courtesy with respect to a
secondary offering at an immediately following date.
Q. Is that the end of your answer?
A. That is the end of my answer.
Q. Now let us &0 back to May 11th, when Mr. Leslie first
talked to you. Do you understand?
A. Yes.
Q. That was the first time that you heard of the plan of
the Tool Company to make a secondary, is that correct?
A. That is correct.
Q. The next day, the 12th, you met with Mr. Forrester?
A. That is correct.
Q. Am I to understand that between the 11th and the
12th, you consulted with Mr. Brandi of Dillon, Read?
‘VE A. That is correct.
Q. In other words, after Mr. Leslie made his report
tg to the effect that Mr. Forrester wanted to speak to
SS nn
A-2854
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. That is right.
Q. You became concerned and sought the advice of
someone else?
A. That is correct.
Q. The first thing I want you to explain to me is your
concern as a chief executive of TWA, to what was the prob-
lem that you envisaged that required you to consult some.
one.
A. The question in my mind, Mr. Davis, was that raised
by Mr. Leslie, and I will have to amplify slightly what I
have already testified to.
One thing that Mr. Leslie said in the course of this con-
versation relative to Mr. Hughes, was that one of the par-
ticular proclivities was delaying and’ trying to get exten-
sions of time, and if you can’t get it decided the way you
want it now, just postpone it and postpone it.
He raised the question at that time as to whether or not
this would be just the beginning of a series of postpone.
‘ments, the net effect of which would be to [871] derail—
would be to prevent the consummation of the subordinate
debeuture financing on the schedule provided, and by that
derail the Boeing financing which we had until the 3st
of May to complete.
I was naturally very concerned with seeing to it that
nothing was done which would prejudice the Boeing
financing.
Q. I would like to take this one at a time, Mr. Til
linghast.
A. All right.
Q. The 1960 financing required TWA to make this de-
benture offering on or before My 31st?
(A. Right. 1
9 That was an agreement Awe the Tool Company
on the one hand, and TWA on the other, is that correct!
A-2855
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. Right.
Q. And that financing was not going to produce any
cash to TWA—that offering?
A. Not unless we sold more than $100 million.
Q Whether you sold more than $100 million was solely
at the election of the Tool Company?
A. That is right.
Q. Mr. Leslie indicated to you that this request was
about to be made on behalf of the Tool Company, on [872]
May 1ith—that might have the effect of delaying this trans-
action beyond May 31st, if you granted further and subse-
quent delays?
A. That is right.
Q You had a feeling that Mr. Hughes or the Hughes
Tool Company would make repeated requests that might
delay this offering beyond May 31st? That was your con-
cern, was it not?
A. That is correct.
Q. That would have involved possibly: some new agree-
ment or understanding between the Tool Company and
A. That is correct.
Q What I am failing to understand is, the relationship
that obligation to the Tool Company and the financ-
ing of the Boeing acquisition, that you had been negotiating
_ With the lending institutions. ;
Can you explain how you, as a chief executive officer—
was concerning you?! Wha} relationship was there |
between a delay in this offering by TWA, and the finance} g |
of the Boeing purchase? | |
A Mr. Davis, there were really two things that con- |
cetmed me. 4 i
| | 4
|
A-2856
Tillinghast—Deposition
[873] Q. Excuse me for a moment before you answer,
I am not interested at this moment what Mr. Brandi told
you. I am asking you what was concerning you before
you went to see Mr. Brandi.
A. I was concerned about two things. One, whether
this was a diversionary tactic.
Q. Diversionary tactic by whom?
A. By Hughes Tool Company.
Q. Diversion from what?
A. An attempt by Hughes Tool Company somehow to
interfere with and prevent the consummation of the Boeing
deal.
Q. At that point you had not received any letters from
anyone from the Tool Company objecting to the Boeing
deal?
A. That is correct.
Q. In fact, you hadn’t disclosed the proposed Boeing
deal to the Tool Company?
A. Yes, we had.
Q. In what way?
A. In the minutes of the directors’ meeting, and quite
a number of things that Mr. Holliday had received.
Q. You anticipated that the Tool Company might [874]
have some views different from or adverse to those held
by the TWA management with respect to he Boeing
program, is that correct?
A. That question came up in my mind when Mr. Leslie
talked with me on the 11th.
Q. And therefore you were suspicious that this move
by Mr. Hughes or the Tool Company’ might be used ‘in
beg iS that would interfere withi the Boeing program!
-
8 a means of preventing the consummation of the
financing that would caus e Boritg ig possible. |
| |
bait | a4 A oe i \ “
A-2857
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. How could that happen other than possibly the re-
financing of the existing indebtedness, you mean?
A. Mr. Davis, that very nearly did happen as a con.
sequence of your efforts.
Q. The re-financing?
A. No, the consummation of the Boeing financing was
in fact almost upset as a result of your actions between
this time and the two weeks subsequent to that.
Q. I appreciate that. At the moment, however, I am
trying to understand how the successful secondary offer-
ing by the Tool Company, which would have put into cash
$100 million, more or less, how that fact in your judgment,
on May 11th, contributed to your feeling [875] that the
Tool Company might have some devious plan to interfere
with your Boeing program?
A. The secondary offering, the successful secondary
offering in and of itself would have presented no problem
at all, Mr. Davis. What I was concerned about was that
this was not a genuine Proposal, and that the effect of
granting a week’s delay would have been—a week’s delay
which in my opinion was quite unrealistic.
The effect of that would have been to delay and perhaps
prevent the consummation of the subordinate debenture
vhole situation would be upset.
Q Iam having difficulty in understanding, Mr. Tilling-
\ hast, and I want to give ® full opportunity to explain
vhy you concluded that the pest phic you thought
vas remote, perhaps, of accomplishment with just a
week's delay—why the possibility that the Tool Company
A-2858
Tillinghast—Deposition
might realize $100 million in cash, would have an adverse
effect, or mire you down, or bog you down in your Boeing
program.
[876] A. You keep trying to put words in my mouth. |
tried to say before that the consummation of the secondary
offering by the Hughes Tool Company would not have been
any problem whatever.
Indeed, I would have welcomed it. Bat what I was con-
cerned about was not that we were dealing with a secondary
offering, and the realization of money by the Hughes Tool
Company, but rather a maneuver which would have the
effect of preventing consummation of our offering. And
through that would upset and prevent the Boeing financing.
Q. Was there some condition in the negotiations with the
lending institutions in connection with this Boeing financing
that you had in mind, that would be upset, if for any rea-
son this offering by TWA, which was not going to realize
any cash, was delayed beyond May 31st?
A. There was no condition, Mr. Davis. -I can only say
that the consummation of the secondary financing—I am
sorry—the consummation of the debenture offering on the
time schedule originally planned was one of the background
factors in everyone’s contemplation in connection with the
financing for the Boeing plans.
I was deeply conscious of the fact that I had [877] ex-
pended $850,000, and was committed for $187 million, for
which I had to get my financing nailed down, and I wasn’t
going to do anything that carried with it a serious threat
- of unhinging that financing.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, let me lead you a little, if I may.
Prior to this additional financing of Boeing, for this $187
million and a half—the amount due the financing instite-
tions was how much?
A. Before this? |
v
A-2859
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Before the Boeing financing, what was the amount
due to these lending institutions?
A. Iam not sure of the amount actually due at that time,
but the amount of the commitment was $165 million, all of
which I don’t think—
Q. Isn’t it true if the Tool Company realized $100 million
in the marketplace, that it might be close enough to the
goal of refinancing that $165 million?
A. That was certainly a possibility.
Q. And you discussed it? —
A. Yes.
Q. It -was very important to you that the additional
financing with the lending institutions for $147 million be
an accomplished fact hefore the Tool Company could raise a
sum of money that conceivably might [878] permit it to
refinancing the 1960 debt, isn’t that right?
A. No, it is not.
Q. Isn’t it true, Mr. Tillinghast, that in February 1961,
you discussed with Mr. Breech, the Tool Company would
have difficulty in refinancing for additional jet equipment?
A. At the time I talked with Mr. Breech on the 28th, I was
concerned with the question as to whether or not I wanted
to seriously entertain the possibility of becoming a chief
executive of this company. Subsequent to that time, in pur-
suance of the discussions had at that time, I worked out a
contract which I thought put me in a position to call the
shots as I saw them, without concern as to whether or not
the control of TWA stayed in one place rather than the
other ~
At the time you speak of, and since that time, I have tried
to conduct the affairs of TWA in such a way as not to
favor or prejudice any particular stockholder, ind I think
my job is to call them as I see them, without regard to these
ings that you are concerned about. 1
A-2860
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. But it is a fact that the May 31st date with respect
to the issuance of these debentures by TWA [879] was a
time limit [which] had been placed for the benefit of the
Tool Company rather than for the benefit of TWA?
A. So far as I know, yes.
Q. So that if there had been a delay beyond May 3st,
or if in fact TWA should have consented to delays beyond
May 31st, it would have been basically a detriment to the
Tool Company rather than TWA?
A. It would have been a detriment to the TWA if it in
any way affected the Boeing financing.
Q. The only way in which it could have affected the Boe-
ing financing is that the Tool Company would have had a
lot of cash in its pocket?
A. No, it is not, Mr. Davis, and you know a lot better
than that.
Q. Isn’t it true, Mr. Tillinghast, that it was Mr. Breech
who suggested to you that before you took the position you
ought to consult with Mr. Brandi of Dillon, Read for expert
advice?
A. It is not my recollection. At the moment I don’t
have any recollection of having talked with Mr. Breech
about this until after I talked with Mr. Forrester. | Possibly
if I did, but if I did, it doesn’t stick in my mind.
As I recall it, that was something that Mr. [880] Leslie
and I agreed on as the result of this discussion which I have
already described.
Q. Iam trying to refresh your recollection that the first
time you talked to Mr. Brandi of Dillon, Read, was after
your first meeting with Mr. Forrester, and after you talked
to Mr. B who warned you oF fageted fo you
_before you too & position in this my yya° t to com
sult “the ial advisers”? | |
A-2861
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. No. As a matter of fact, I talked with Mr. Brandi
just before I talked with Mr. Forrester.
Q. On the 12th?
A. On the 12th.
Q. After talking to Him on the 11th?
A. Idon’t think I talked with him on the 11th.
Q. After your conversation with Mr. Leslie?
A. No,I think I talked with Mr. Brandi, so far as I can
recall, only on the 12th.
Q Was that-a telephone conversation, a meeting or a
conference? . ;
A. It was a meeting\in my office.
Q. Who else was there?
A. Mr. Leslie, Mr. Rowe was there, I think.
Q. Mr. Rowe, the general counsel of TWA?
[881] A. Mr. Rowe who sits down there.
Q. Counsel for TWA?
A. Yes. I am trying to remember when he got there.
Mr. Reed, I think, was also there.
Q. Of the Hughes, Hubbard firm?
A. Yes.
Q. Counsel for the voting trustees?
A. Yes. At the time of the discussion with Mr. For-
rester—and I think he was there at the time of the discus-
sion with Mr. Brandi as well. I think that is the extent of
it
The Special Master: Let us. take a five-minute
recess,
| (Whereupon, a short recess was taken.)
By Mr. Davis: | ee |
Q Mr. Tillinghast, before the récess, you were about
to finish identify the meeting at your office with Dillon,
ers. But before you resume at that point, I
A-2862
Tillinghast—Deposition
overlooked asking you whether at or about that time you
had a discussion with Mr. Sessel as to what the plans or
purposes or consequences to TWA might be if the Tool
Company was able to raise a substantial amount of cash.
A. No, I don’t think I did, Mr. Davis. I am [882] quite
sure that somewhere within this period, I mean sometime
between the 11th of May and the board meeting on the 17th
of May, I discussed this with Mr. Sessel, and I know Mr.
Sessel was quite concerned that this was a delaying tactic,
and should be dealt with as such.
Q. That was between May 11th and May 17th?
A. Yes. I can’t tell you exactly when it was in the pro.
gression of things, but I know that I discussed the thing
with Mr. Sessel, to get his view as to how the banks would
react to the thing. |
Q. Do you recall more specifically what Mr. Sessel said
to you at that time as to what his ideas were of the objec-
tives of the Tool Company, and the plans?
A. No, I don’t recall discussing that with him as such.
The one thing that sticks in my mind was that Mr. Sessel
said not once, but several times, that Hughes always wants
time, he wants a week if he can get a week, and if he can't,
a day, and if he can’t get an hour, he will want half an hour.
His view was very definite and strong that if we gave 4
week’s delay, then that would be followed by a request for
a further delay and a further delay, and it would be a
endless matter.
[883] Q. Did he express the point of view that sud
delays would be injurious to Af
A. | Yes, he expressed the view that failure to carry outs
consummation of the subordinate debenture ge might
raise questions as to what it all about.
Q. Bate questions in whose melt
NW i
A-2863
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. The financing institutions’ minds, and might preju-
dice the Boeing financing.
Q. You keep referring to problems being raised in peo-
ple’s minds. It is not clear to me that you have identified
to me what problem you had in your mind or you understood
them to be referring to, Mr. Tillinghast.
A. I personally was concerned about the fact that we
had a very short time within which to finalize our Boeing
financing.
Q. I understand that. .
A. And I didn’t want to do anything that might give
anyone any reason or concern for not carrying through with
the financing on the basis of the informal commitments
given. It was my strongly held view then, as it is now, that
when you are dealing in figures of this magnitude, that the
sooner you get the thing signed, sealed and delivered, and
definitely nailed down, the better off you are.
£884] Q. Do you know who Bob Kerr is?
A. Yes.
Q. Who is he?
A. Mr. Sessel’s assistant.
Q. Is he at the Irving Trust?
A. Yes.
Q. Only for the purpose of refreshing your recollection,
Mr. Tillinghast, let me refer you to some notes of a tele-
phone conversation between Mr. Kerr and Mr. Gordon of
the Bank of America. m
Mr. Sonnett: Would you mind marking that and
identifying the source, Mr. Davis?
Mr. Davis: I will identify it.
tn
ai eal
A-2864
Tillinghast—Deposition
By Mr. Davis:
Q. I want you to look at this, and particularly call to
your attention the line which says “Odlum and Bautzer
are in New York scurrying around on this matter. Ben
thinks only one reason why Hughes wants money—to buy
out a voting trust. Crown might come up with balance of
money.” a>
That is dated May 16, 1961. Does that refresh you at all
as to what Mr. Sessel was in fact saying to you as to what
the problems and dangers were?
[885] Mr. Sonnett: Have we identified this docn-
ment yet? |
Mr. Davis: At this moment I merely want to know
if this refreshes the witness’ recollection. We will
get the documents in when we get the Bank of Amer-
ica.
Mr. Sonnett: You have shown something to the
witness. It hasn’t been marked and identified.
Mr. Davis: I will mark it for identification.
(Transcript of telephone conversation, marked De-
fendants’ Exhibit 22 for identification, as of this
date. )
By Mr. Davis:
Q. Now I refer you to Defendants’ Exhibit 22 for
identification.
Mr. Sonnett: These are notes by who?
The Witness: Mr. Gordon, I gather.
Mr. Davis: Bank of America, Bob Gordon’s files.
The Witness: No, it does not.
| Q. That was about the time we are how discussing the
oteeing by TWA? ez
A-2865
Tillinghast—Deposition ;
A. Yes, this would have been about the time I talked
with Mr. Sessel.
Q. And it is your clear recollection that when you dis-
cussed this matter with Mr. Sessel, before the board [886]
meeting of the 17th, that this subject, if not in those exact
words, but the same subject matter did not come up for
discussion ?
A. Mr. Davis, it is not my clear recollection that this
subject did not come up. My only recollection that is dis-
tinct of my diseussions with Mr. Sessel was to the effect
that he was very concerned about this being a delaying and
diversionary tactic, and his feeling. that it would be a
mistake, and maybe spread some doubt and concern among
the financial institutions if we failed to go ahead with the
debenture offering within the time required by the origi-
Q. How about the possibility of the voting trust ter-
minating—that was important, wasn’t it?
A. Not to me.
Q. It wasn’t?
A. Not in this context.
Q. Do you think the termination of the voting trust
might have adversely affected the financing?
A. Tam sure it would have.
Q. When you come right down to it, the interference
that might have taken place in the Boeing financing pro-
gram was that if the Tool Company was able to raise that
much money, conceivably they might make an effort to
[887] terminate the voting trust, and in turn that would
affect the lending institutions, isn’t that right?
A. No, Mr. Davis. The only way the voting trust could
be t ted wonld be by buying out the whole financing.
My rn was hot with that. ' Indeed we expressed the 7
repeatedly ” cooperate in every way—
A-2866
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Expressed willingness to whom, sir?
A. To Mr. Forrester, and it seems to me to other people,
but I know particularly in the case of Mr. Forrester, and
I will stick with him. We repeatedly expressed the willing.
ness to cooperate in every way with a secondary offering
just as rapidly as the Tool Company wanted to do it, and
except for delaying the orderly progression of [our] own
financing plans, we did everything we could to cooperate
with the Too] Company in anything they wanted to do.
Q. Delaying what financing plans, Mr. Tillinghast?
A. Mr. Davis, I have repeatedly testified to the—the
financing that we had to have committed for by the 31st of
May.
Q. You are referring to the financing by the lending in-
stitutions for the Boeing program? |
A. Correct.
Q. And you are saying, as I understand you, that any
[888] delay in the offering by TWA of debentures which
would not produce any cash to TWA, but which would pro-
duce cash to the Tool Company would have an adverse
effect on the lending institution?
A. Might have.
Q. And this would be by reason of the possibility that
the Tool Company might be in a position to terminate the
voting trust?
A. No, those are your words.
Q. Explain in what respects, if you please.
Mr. Sonnett: Explain what?
Q. In what respects would the financing of the Boeing
| program by the lending institutions be adversely affected
because of a y in the debenture rb épeepe i
was not going to sesidell any cash to
A-2867
Tillinghast—Deposition
Mr. Sonnett: I think this has been answered
twice already, but if this is the last time, I won’t
object to it. I think the witness twice covered the
subject matter. What counsel is doing is arguing
with the witness:
A. Mr. Davis, at this point we had informal assurances
from the executives of the financial institutions that they
would recommend to their committees participation in the
financing to the extent required. There obviously [889]
was &@ serious question in my mind as to whether any sub-
stantial delay or change in the program might have the
effect of unhinging some of these informal commitments,
and I was not going to take any chances of having the
financing of the Boeings, even though the chances might be
slight.
I talked with Mr. Brandi, and asked his opinion as to
whether or not delaying the debenture offering might have
an effect on our financing, and his opinion was yes, it might
have a serious effect on it, and on the basis of that I wasn’t
going to take the chance of having this financing abort, and
lose either the Program or the down payment of $850,000.
Q. Now, Mr. Tillinghast, let us go to the meeting which
you had in your office on the 12th of May. Do you recall
you identified Mr. Rowe being there?
A. Yes. ;
Q. Mr. Leslie?
A. Yes, i
Q Yourself?
A. Yes.
Q. And who else?
‘A.| Mr. Forrester, Mr. Hager, and one other person has
4 ) mind—Mr. Joy, who is an assistant o ir. Reed.
| 1 |.Q. Prior to that meeting you had a conversation
_ With Mr. Brandi of Dillon, Read? 4
'
| t
A-2868
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. That’s correct.
Q. And that was a conversation you had with him over
the telephone? ~~“
A. That was a conversation in my office.
Q. Prior to the meeting when these other gentlemen
arrived?
A. Which other gentlemen?
Q. Mr. Forrester, Mr. Carl Rowe, and these others.
A. It was prior to the arrival of Mr. Forrester and
Mr. Hager, but as I recall it, after the arrival of Mr. Rowe
and Mr. Reed and Mr. Joy, and Mr: Leslie.
Q. In other words, Mr. Brandi joined you at your
offices on May 12th?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Before Mr. Forrester and his attorney showed up!
A. Correct. “8
Q. And you were gathering there ahead of time to dis-
cuss what position you would take with Mr. Forrester!
A. Correct. |
Q. That was based upon the report made to you by
Mr. Leslie the day before?
A. In part based on that.
£891] Q. You had not talked with Forrester between
times, had you?
A. No.
Q. Before Mr. Forrester’s lawyer arrived, will you
describe the substance of what took place insofar as it
relates to the subject under discussion, namely, the posi-
tion of TWA with respect to Mr. Forrester’s anticipated
request? ,
A. Yes. We discussed the subject with Mr. Brandi, and
said that we were presented with this request, and we
would like his views on the position that we should take.
A-2869
Tillinghast—Deposition
I said that I was particularly concerned with one thing,
and that is that we had this big program, and to me a
very important program in midstream. I wanted to assure
myself that nothing that was done in this regard might
in any way prejudice the consummation of our financing
with the financial institutions.
I said my own limited experience in the securities field
made it seem to me a little unrealistic about effecting all
of the things that would have to be affected within a
week’s time. I said even under the best of circumstances,
with somebody who had a greater reputation than Mr.
Hughes for being easy to negotiate with, I thought this
was a tremendously ambitious schedule, and [892] that I
personally doubted it could be effected within that period
of time.
- I said, “I would like your views as to whether this might
have any effect on the financing or not.”
He said that he felt that it might have a serious effect
on the financing. The financial institutions were willing
to make the commitments they had made on the assump.
tion that TWA had achieved a degree of independence, and
was free to proceed with programs that it considered to
be in the best interest of the company, and that if you got
into a situation that dragged on and got bogged down in
& controversy of one sort or another, he felt no assurance
at all that you could count on the financing continuing to
be available, and that his very strong recommendation
would be that we not postpone the finahcing, but go ahead—
Q. You are referring to which financing? ;
A. The subordinate debenture financing—but go ahead
on our predetermined time schedule, and if there was a
genuine secondary offering in the wind, that could be
Jandled as such.
A-2870
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Let us take this piecemeal. Prior to this gathering
in your office, to your knowledge had anyone told Mr.
Brandi what the meeting was about?
[893] A. I believe Mr. Leslie had talked with him.
Q. Mr. Leslie was fully familiar with the nature and
details of Mr. Forrester’s request?
A. He was the most familiar one, yes. He had talked
with Mr. Forrester.
Q. Wasn't the purpose of the meeting to find out from
Mr. Forrester what it is exactly that they proposed to do!
A. The purpose of the meeting was for him to explain
in as much detail as he cared to exactly what they proposed
to do, and to obtain TWA’s agreement to a postponement.
Q. Isn't it fair to say that all Mr. Forrester told Mr.
Leslie up to that point was that he had been approached
by the Tool Company to see if they would undertake some
sort of a secondary. and that Mr. Forrester would like to
sit down with you, or whoever, and discuss a program!
A. No, Iam sure that isn’t the case, because I am quite
sure that when this first was mentioned to me, the matter
of the delav was in the conversation already.
Q. But my question is whether or not it is your tes-
timony that Mr. Forrester discussed in detail what he
pronosed with Mr. Leslie on the 11th. .
[894] A. My impression is that most of what had
been disenssed—most of what was discussed in my presence
on the 12th. already had heen disenssed with Mr. Leslie.
Q. And it is vonr understanding that von asked Mr.
Leslie to call Mr..Brandi to arrange this meeting, and tell
him what it is that Merrill Lynch wanted to do?
A. Tt is mv recollection that I asked Mr. Leslie to get
in touch with Dillon. Read, explain the nature of the re
qnest. and get their views as to what effect, if any, it
would have on the new financing.
A-2871
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. And he is the one who arranged for Mr. Brandi
meeting at your office the next day, the 12th?
* A. I believe so..,
Q. You made this suggestion to Mr. Leslie without
having heard from Mr. Breech?
A. That is my best recollection. As I recall it at the
moment, the first time I talked with Mr. Breech was after
I talked with Mr. Forrester. A
Q. These gentlemen met in your office before Mr. For-
rester and his lawyer arrived? ;
A. Correct.
Q. At that time there took place the conversation that
vou described a moment ago?
A. That’s correct. es re
[895] Q. Without having heard what Mr. Forrester and
his lawyer had to say?
A. No.
~Q Somebody must have described what Mr. Forrester
and his lawyer were proposing. Who did that? Did Mr.
Leslie, did you? 3
A. Mr. Forrester outlined— .
Q. Iam talking about before Mr. Forrester arrived.
A. Before Mr. Forrester arrived—excuse me, I mis-
understood you. Mr. Leslie, in the prior conversation, I
believe, outlined what was proposed.
Q. To Mr. Brandi and
no. I think he is an associate.
I understand your prior testimony—
change it if it is not accurate—Mr.
andi in effect confirmed your views, or confirmed the
view that the lending institutions that made advances to
4.2872
Tillinghast—Deposition
TWA on the assumption that TWA would maintain a cer.
tain degree of independence, I believe you said—
A. That’sright
Q. And if there was anything which might take place to
jeopardize that degree of independence, it might have [896]
an adverse effect on the Boeing financing?
A. What he said, as I recall it, was that if this degen
erated into another Hughes controversy, and it appeared
that the company had not achieved the ability to deal objec
tively with its problems, that it might have a serious effect
on the financing.
Q. Mr. Sessel was not there?
A. Mr. Sessel was not there.
Q. So far as you know, how and when was Mr. Sess
first informed about this approach by Merrill Lynch!
A. I can’t say. It would have been by Mr. Leslie or
myself. Which it was and exactly when it was, I can't
recall. °
Q. You believe you may have been the one?
A. Possibly, I think it is more likely that it was Mr.
Leslie, but it conceivably could have been L
Q. Before Mr. Forrester and his lawyer arrived, did
you or Mr. Leslie, or anyone else at that meeting, suggest
that this move by the Hughes Tool Company might be part
of a plan to refund or refinance or terminate the voting
trust?
A. I don’t recall any such discussion, Mr. Davis.
Q. Do you think you would recall it if it had take
place?
[897] A. I think I probably would, but I just don't r
call it at this time.
Q. Do you recall with clarity what concepts Mr. Brandi
was expressing in suggesting that this discussion by Merri
Lynch might interfere with the Boeing financing?
A-2873
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. I think I have already testified as fully as I can about
that.
Q You are satisfied that is as full and as clear a deserip-
tion as you are capable of giving us?
A. At this time, yes.
Q. Do you think there is anything you might do to help
you refresh your recollection? .
A. Not that I can think of, no. If I re-discussed it with
everyone present, it undoubtedly would refresh my recol-
lection somewhat, but as I sit here now, that is the best
recollection I can give you.
Q. Did this group arrive at some consensus of opinion? |
Did anyone express a different point of view in that group?
A. No, I think I summed up the meeting by saying that
I wasn’t prepared to take any reasonable risk of unseating
the Boeing financing, and that unless people could give me
assurances that that wouldn't happen, that it was going to
be my position that we deny the request.
[898] Q. Did Mr. Brandi suggest that perhaps he
ought to discuss it with some of the lending institutions or
their representatives before giving any firm views?
A. I don’t recall any such thing, Mr. Davis.
Q. Do you recall whether or not he telephoned anyone
for the purpose of getting some other points of view?
A. He didn’t telephone anyone from my Office.
Q. Who were the individuals who were negotiating on
behalf of the lending institutions, this Boeing financing?
A. Tam not sure I know exactly. I think it was Mr.
» 80 far as the Irving Trust was concerned—either Mr.
or one of his subordinates so far as the Equitable
it was Jenkins
A-2874
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. You said the senior officer of TWA, negotiating on
behalf of TWA, was Mr. Leslie?
A. That’s correct.
Q. You did not assume any personal functions in negoti-
ating?
A. That’s correct, at this time. On the 29th of May, I
very much got into it, but up until that time—
[£899] Q. Mr. Leslie had been handling it?
A, Mr. Leslie had been handling it.
Q. To what extent had Dillon, Read been participants!
A. They had been very active participants, I believe,
because they were our financial advisers, and they had been
very active in the whole thing. .
Q. You mean they had been. I don’t understand what
you mean by saying “they had been your financial advisers.”
A. They were our financial advisers at the time.
Q. As a continuation of the 1960 financing?
A. They handled the 1960 financing, and then separately
represented us with respect to the 1961 financing.
£914] Q. Was the consummation of the 1961 financing
involved, difficult or complex?
A. I would say it wasn’t nearly as difficult or complex
as I understand the 1960 financing was. It was not, how-
ever, without some difficulties and complexities, particularly
as things developed in the matter.
Q. Will you describe the nature of the difficulties and
complexities that were involved in the 1961 financing, and
if you know, to what extent those were complexities and
difficulties that did not exist in the 1960 financing.
A. I would say this, Mr. Davis, that one of the problems
of the 1961 financing was the fact that at the time I joined
TWA, this had pretty well taken form.
Q. The 1961 financing?
A-2875
Tillinghast—Deposition
915] A. The 1961 fmancing had substantially taken
form. One of the things that were contemplated was the
participation of the Prudential Insurance Company, to the
extent, as I recall it, of $39 million. J |
We had received informal assurances from Mr. Chap-
palear—
Q. Of the Prudential?
A. Of the Prodential, that he would recommdll it, and
he felt confident that his committee would go along.
Then as the result of the publicity and controversy that
was raised by Hughes Tool Company, the Prudential! pulled
out of the deal, and we were then faced with the problem of
what we would do in order to take up the slack left by the
Prudential.
We had various discussions with Dillon, Read. Dillon,
Read, I know, spent a substantial amount of time and effort
trying to find other insurance companies who would partici-
pate in this and take the Prudential’s place without success.
Then later on, when it became apparent that the revenue
and earnings forecast which had been made in the first part
of 1961, in late February or March, I believe, were not being
realized, and that TWA would have a cash problem of meet-
ing the payment schedules under the [916] proposed financ-
ing, then it became necessary to work out a modification of
the'deal, and then more recently, as a consequence, let us
say failure of the Caravelle program to materialize, it was
necessary once again to try to work out with the financial
titutions a further modification of the program.
Twould say if one looks at it by hindsight, the 1961 financ-
ing has been, let us say, more than averagely complicated.
17] Q. I understood you to say that this fee had been
G,at least by the time of the board meeting of July 19,
a?
A. That's correct.
A-2876
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. Were you at that time anticipating those complexi-
ties that developed in connection with the Caravelle pro.
gram, which I understood from your prior testimony was
around September?
A. . No, we certainly didn’t anticipate that at that time.
In July we were in the middle of what I referred to as the
Hughes problems, and the complexities springing from that,
both past and potential, were realized at that time.
I would say this fee of $200,000 was, as I recall, the fig.
ures in Mr. Leslie’s memo, a more or less average fee for
an offering or a financing of this size.
Q. What were the complexities of the Hughes problem
at that time, namely, prior to July 19, 19611
A. Well, I don’t know how deeply you want me to go
into this, Mr. Davis.
Q. As factually as you can.
A. Going back to the period that we were talking about
yesterday, when the question was first raised by Mr. For-
rester of Hughes Tool Company’s desire to have us 918]
postpone for a week the offering of the subordinated deben-
tures—
Q. On May 12th or 11th?
A. On May 12th or 11th—on the 17th we had a TWA
board of directors meeting, at which time it had been
planned to fix the final details of the offering and become
effective the next day.
Q. The price amendment to the registration statement!
A. Yes. As you will recall, you appeared for the first
time at that directors meeting, and made a rather lengthy
statement at the directors meeting, the substance of whic
was that unless TWA was prepared to agree to the exter
sion that was being requested, you were going to file, or yu
were going to object on a variety of grounds to the ade
A-2877
Tilinghast—Deposition
quacy of the registration statement, and in fact, that same
, if you recall correctly, you sent a letter to the SEC,
and we suddenly found ourselves in a highly publicized sit-
uation not calculated to make easy the consummation of the
financial arrangements: ©
Q. Excuse me for interrupting you. You are still refer-
ring to making difficult the financial arrangement in connec-
tion with this convertible debenture issue, all of which was
going to go to Hughes Tool Company? Is that the one you
are referring to?-:
[919] A. TI wasn’t referring primarily to that, but IT
would include that also.
Q. Yon are referring to the publicity—
Mr. Sonnett: I object to the witness heing inter-
_ Tupted in the middle of an answer which was per-
fectly responsive to a question, and then Mr. Davis
attempting to ent him off before he is through. T
think the witness shonld he allowed to finish the
answer which he was in the middle of making wher
he was once again interrupted by counsel.
The Special Master: Let us try to let him finish
his answers.
Mr. Davis: Will yon pick up Mr. Tillinghast’s
answer?
(The record was read.)
By Mr. Davis: .
Q It would help me when yon refer to the financial
“rangements—when you are referring to financial arrange-
ments for the lending institutions, I wish you would identify
it When you are referring to the financial arrangements
ting to the issuance of convertible debentures by TWA,
Wish you would refer to that arrangement and when you
A-2878
Tillinghast—Deposition
are referring to some other financial arrangement, I would
appreciate it if you would identify [920] it. I think it would
save time in the long run if in your answer you would
identify the financial arrangements that you have in mind
A. (Continuing)—the middle of the following week; the
committees of the insurance companies were scheduled to
meet, to give committee approval to the tentative arrang
ment that. had been made for the Boeing financing. We
learned to our disappointment, I think on Wednesday, the
24th, but I wouldn’t be sure within a day or so, that Pro-
dential had withdrawn because the committee would have
nothing to do with this situation.
That, of course, presented us with a difficult problem of
what to do about our financing, and left us in the position
where we had only a week left in which to firm up or
financing under the Boeing agreement, and being short at
that point $39 million.
Q. Have you finished describing the’ complexities in-
volved involving Hughes Tool that had a bearing?
A. At this particular point, yes.
Q. You have been referring to the complexities—you had
in mind in connection the fixing of the fee of Dillon, Read!
A. Among other things, yes. .
Q. In your last answer you referred to the committee—
[921] I believe the committee of the insurance companies—
~ reporting they would have nothing to do with the situation!
Did you say something to that effect?
A. Yes.
Q. Will you please identify the committee, the insurance
company, or whoever was on that committee, and wis!
situation they would have nothing to do with?
A. Mr. Davis, I know this only third or fourth hand
Q. From whom did you hear?
A-2879
Tilinghast—Deposition
A. I believe I heard it from Mr. Leslie, and I believe he
in turn heard it from Mr. Wadsworth, and I believe Mr.
Wadsworth talked with the insurance companies. As it
was reported back to me, the Prudential was not satisfied
that there might not be some way that the voting trust
would be upset, and they didn’t want to get into that
‘tnation ne
“As I recall—it was reported to me that Chappalear told
that you couldn’t re-open this matter with a
id you understand what was meant by saying, “You
could not-re-open the situation with a crowbar’?
A. There was no point in going back and trying to re-
open the matter.
Q Reopen what matter? ° |
0922] A. The matter of their participation in the fi-
~Q. The 1961 financing?
A. Yes, the 1961 financing, Mr. Davis.
Q. Since yesterday, did you have occasion of refreshing
your recollection with anyone, particularly with respect to
the note I showed you referring to Mr. Sessel and his com-
ment?
A. No, I have not, Mr. Davis.
Q Did you make an effort to communicate with anyone?
A. No.
Q You made no effort to refresh your recollection at all
pin what transpired in that period beginning about May
’
A. Ihave been turning a number of these things over
in my mind trying to refresh my recollection, but I haven't
talked with anyone about it.
-— Q Yon didn’t call anyone?
A-2880
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. No.
Q. Mr. Sessel?
A. No.
Q. You weren’t surprised at what had been marked De.
fendants’ Exhibit 22, which are the notes from the Bank of
America, a telephone conversation presumably made by
Mr. Kerr of the Irving Trust? You remember that!
[9233] A. Yes.
Q. That did not cause you to inquire of Mr. Sessel
whether that was true, or what he meant by it?
A. No. —
Q. When was a decision made to refuse to the Tool Com-
pany this week’s extension, or any extension of time that
was being requested through Merrill Lynch?
A. It was made at the board of directors meeting on the
17th, following your appearance at the directors meeting,
and the position that you stated there.
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, I don’t mean when was a record
made of the decision. I am asking you when, in fact, was
a decision made by the TWA management.
A. The decision was, in fact, made on the 17th by the
board of directors. As I told you yesterday, Mr. Davis, at
the time of my discussion with Mr. Forrester, I told Mr.
Forrester that I frankly didn’t think that it was realistic
under the best of circumstances to accomplish this within s-
week. I didn’t think, and he concurred in that, that he or
anyone else could give me any assurance that this could be
accomplished within a week, and that while it was some-
thing that I felt that I would not want to take the respon-
sibility for answering myself, and would want to have my
chairman [924] share my decision, I thought in fairness
I could only tell him that my recommendation would be
that the extension not be granted.
A-2881
Tilinghast—Deposition
I then called Mr. Breech— 2
Q. When was this? ad
A. This was on the 12th. I then called Mr. Breech and
explained to him the request that had been made, the dis-
cussion that had been had, and said that I didn’t want to
make a decision in the thing without discussing it with him.
He said that he thought this was a matter that the whole
board ought to consider, and that neither he nor I should
make a decision.
He said, “Let us plan to take it up at the directors meet-
ing.” }
In the meantime, we authorized counsel to do some pre-
liminary work, so that further time would not be lost if the
hoard decided that we should grant an extension. The mat-
ter, however, was not decided until the board meeting on
the 17th, after your appearance at the board meeting.
Q. In other words, Mr. Tillinghast, you are quite sure
that as chief executive officer of TWA, the decision to deny
this request to the Tool Company was not made by [925]
TWA until the board meeting of the 17th of May, and it
was made at that meeting? .
A. That’s correct.
Q. Yon are quite sure of that?
A. I am quite sure of that.
Q. Would there be anyone else at TWA who could make
such a decision without your knowing it?
A. I don’t believe so, Mr. Davia. . *
Q You had not delegated to anyone else the duty or
responsibility of making the inquiry or the decision f
A. No, this decision t
0 the extent that it was & decision
wonld have been made ei
ither by me or by the board of di-
Tectors. As I told Mr.
Forrester from the beginning, my
own recommendation was against it, and I proposed to take
A-2882
- Tillinghast—Deposition
that position with the board, but no final decision was made
until the board meeting.
£926] Q. I understand that you discussed that conclusion
with Mr. Breech on the 12th of May, is that right?
A. Yes, I did. : °
Q. Did you discuss it with any other director of TWA ¢
prior to the 17th?
A. I think I probably, although I can’t tell you the exact
time or circumstances, discussed it with Mr. Sessel some-
time before the 17th.
Q. So you discussed it with Mr. Breech and with Mr.
Sessel?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you have a recollection of having discussed that
decision or recommendation with anyone else?
A. Well, I certainly discussed it with Mr. Leslie, who was
a director. ve
Q. Do you recall when? :
A. Well, he was present on the 12th, and undoubtedly
discussed it with him sometime between the 12th and the
17th, I am sure.
Q. Any other director that you can recall?
A. Possibly Mr. Cocke.
Q. Mr. Cocke being an officer. I mean with outside diree-
tors primarily. .
A. At this time, Mr. Davis, I have no recollection [927]
of having discussed it with any of the other outside direc
tors. I won't say that it is impossible that I did, but I have
no recollection. a
Q. You are aware, are you not, that on the morning of
the 17th, there was filed with the SEC an amendment to the
registration statement, which contained @ reference to the
fact that TWA had not consented to the delay?
A. Yes.
A-2883
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. And that was something which you instructed counsel
to do in anticipation of the board action on the 17th, is that
correct ?
A. Well, I was aware that counsel was doing it, yes.
Q. Were you aware that the statement filed on the morn-
ing of the 17th with the SEC contained a statement as to
whether' or not TWA would or would not grant this delay
requested by the Hughes Tool Company?
A. I think at that point the material filed with the SEC
just said that we had not agreed to the delay.
Q. So that the language may be clear to you, and without
bothering to mark in evidence the public record, let me hand
you the registration statement of TWA at that time, and
tefer you to page 4, so that you may construe the language
—at least your understanding of what it means. I think
it is the top paragraph, Mr. Tillinghast.
[928] A. Yes.
Q. You construe that to mean merely that TWA had not
agreed to grant the request, but still might?
A. I think it speaks for itself, Mr. Davis, that we had
not agreed to grant the request.
Q. But so far as you were concerned, no decision had
been made to deny or refuse the request?
A. No decision was made until the meeting of the board,
Mr. Davis. As I said before, I knew what my own views
on the subject were, and what I proposed to urge upon the
directors, but no decision was made until the directors’
Q. Let me refer you to Defendants’ Exhibit 22, which
you will note purports to be a note from the Bank of Amer-
ica of a telephone conversation with Mr. Kerr of the Irving
Trust, with Mr. Gordon. You will note a portion of this
reads: “TWA management and board has declined to give
A-2884
Tillinghast—Deposition
a
the extension on advice of own investment counsel who say
a week won’t do.”
That was dated May 16th.
Mr. Sonnett: Have you a typed copy of that?
Mr. Davis: No, not of this one.
By Mr. Davis:
Q. Do you see that?
[929] A. Yes.
Q. You see there is no basis whatever for Mr. Kerr or
anyone else making such a statement, is there?
A. Mr. Davis, the board hadn’t met by this date.
Q. I understand that.
A. I can only assume that Mr. Kerr was predicting what
the board was going to do. _
Q. You don’t think Mr. Kerr was referring to the fact,
when Mr. Sessel and Mr.- Breech got together, that was a
decision?
A. No, I don’t think when Mr. Breech and Mr. Sessel got
together, that was a decision.
Q. You think when Mr. Breech, Mr. Sessel and you got
together, it was a decision?
A. Not in this particular situation.
Mr. Davis: May I have this marked for identif-
cation?
(Handwritten notes from Dillon, Read’s files,
marked Defendants’ Exhibit 23 for identification, as
of this date.)
Mr. Sonnett: May I read the paragraph you re
ferred to?
Mr. Davis: I am not offering that in evidence now.
A-2885
Tillinghast—Deposition
[930] Mr. Sonnett: You purported to refer toa |
paragraph and you incorrectly described the contents
of the paragraph. I think the record should describe
correctly what the paragraph says. :
Mr. Davis: You can read the whole thing into the
record. The exhibit will be part of the record, and
you have a copy of the document.
Mr. Sonnett: You offered me the opportunity to
read it all in the record, and I would like to have it
copied. My initial suggestion was to read the one
paragraph.
The Special Master: Let us have the one para-
graph that the witness was referred to.
Mr. Sonnett: The paragraph reads as follows:
“TWA management and board has declined to give
the extension on advice of own investment counsel,
who say a week won’t do.”
By Mr. Davis:
Q. I am going to hand you what has been marked as
Defendants’ Exhibit 23, Mr. Tillinghast. I represent to
you that these are parts of notes that we obtained from
the files of Dillon, Read. I believe those to be handwritten
notes of Mr. Wadsworth at Dillon, Read. You don’t have
to be influenced in your answer by reason of [931] what
you see on this exhibit. The handwriting may be difficult
It is dated June 13, 1961, and presumably refers to—I
am suggesting it may refer to a telephone conversation be-
tween Mr. Wadsworth and Mr. Sessel.
“Sessel—will be faced with decision. Meeting at
Hagarty-Haycock, Keehn, Somers, Olds, Breech and
A-2886
Tillinghast—Deposttion
Sessel. Ecker for a little while. Will lenders con-
tinue to be lenders without voting trust in either old
credit or new credit.”
“Tillinghast will write short lender to lenders.” |
think it means short letter.
“Answer is no, except not certain on Bank of
America. Tillinghast will come to us and ask us
whether we could replace present lenders for $16
million plus new financing—$147 million—Boeing.”
Then another entry under same date “Attended
closing on subordinated debentures.”
The next entry dated June 14, 1961 is, “Met with
Langmuir, notes attached.”
Do you know who Langmuir is?
A. It doesn’t mean anything to me.
Q. Perhaps from Prudential?
[932] A. I don’t know.
_ Q. Then a note under the heading of June 15, 1961,
“Talked to Leslie. Reported meeting with Langmuir. He
advised us of letter he was writng us, and lenders, re:
Ability to finance.”
You still don’t know who Langmuir is?
A. No, I don’t.
Q. That, in fact, related to what transpired when TWA
received the offer of the Tool Company reflected by its
letter of June 10, 1961?
A. That is correct.
Q. It had nothing to do with the subject under discus
sion, namely, the refusal to delay?
A. This was a month later.
Q. Now continuing with what took place in May, follov-
ing the meeting with Dillon, Read and Forrester on Friday,
A-2887
Tilinghast—Deposition
May 12th, did you subsequently receive a written confirma-
tion of the conclusion of that meeting?
A. A written confirmation of the conclusion of the
meeting? ~ ;
Q. Yes.
A. No, not that I would describe as that, Mr. Davis.
Q. What I am referring to is a letter you received from
Mr. Brandi. I believe you received it from: Mr. [933]
Brandi.
A. Oh, yes. Mr. Brandi at my request wrote a letter
to have at the board meeting on the 17th.
Mr. Davis: May I have this marked for identifi-
-cation, please?
(Letter dated May 15, 1960 to Mr. Tillinghast
from Dillon, Read, marked Defendants’ Exhibit 24
for identification, as of this date.)
gets us both into collog
es money.
A-2888
Tillinghast—Deposition
By Mr. Davis:
Q. Mr. Tillinghast, let me hand you Defendants’ Ex.
[934] hibit 24, and ask you if you can identify it.
A. Yes, I recognize that letter.
Q. It is a letter you received from Mr. Brandi which
referred—confirming the advice they gave you at the meet-
ing of the preceding Friday, namely, May 12th, is that
‘correct?
A. That is correct.
Q. Does this letter accurately confirm the advice that
you received on May 12th?
A. It accurately summarizes the advice given orally on
the 12th.
Q. Are you now satisfied that in your testimony of
yesterday you described all of the reasons given by Dillon, .
Read for the conclusion reflected by Defendants’ Exhibit
249
« A. Repeat that, please.
(The question was read.)
A. Yes.
By Mr. Davis:
Q. And the reasons as so given to you satisfied you!
A. They did.
Q. You did not feel it necessary to inquire of anybody
else to see whether or not others might have a different
opinion or reach a different conclusion?
[935] A. No, I didn’t, Mr. Davis. I was very concern-
ed personally by the things that he mentioned and he ¢on-
firmed, and saw no need for shaleecad investigating the
matter.
A-2889
Tilinghast—Deposition
Q At that time were you aware of the financial arrange-
ments with Dillon, Read?
A. Aware of what financial arrangements with Dillon,
Read?
Q. With respect to the fee payable to them, or fees for
either 1960 or 19617 Do you have to refer to the memo-
randum from Mr. Rowe? I am only interested in your in-
dependent recollection, Mr. Tillinghast.
A. So far as I can recall at this time, I just can’t recall
at this time, Mr. Davis, when I first became—let me think
here. I know I became aware of the arrangement by the
17th, because I know when you appeared before the board,
one of the things you questioned was this fee, and later
you sent a telegram, or somebody sent a telegram saying
that you wanted to withdraw any objection that you had
made to the fee. So I know that by that time I was aware
of the amount of the fee,
How much before that I was aware of it, I would hesitate
to say now. I probably was aware of it at this time, but
I just have no independent recollection of it.
1936] Q. I am sure you didn’t intend to confuse the
facts with your last answer, Mr. Tillinghast. I think I know
vhat you are referring to, but for the sake of the record
let us see if we can’t straighten it out.
The drafts of registration statements filed with the SEC,
tad the next to the last draft, for the first time contained,
& is normal, a description of fees to be incurred?
A. Yes. a
Q And the relationship of the parties?
A Yes.
Q And that registration statement disclosed an amount
tu or payable to Dillon, Read? 7
; It is very likely that was when I first learned of the
A-2890
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. And you were referring to a communication while ]
was a member of the firm of Simpson, Thacher & Bartlett,
to the effect that our various objections to the proposed
financing did not relate to the question of fees?
A. That is right.
Q. Do you recall in relationship to this date of May 12th
pr May 16th when this information came to you about the
fee arrangement, the $750,000 payable in three installments
in 1960, and the question as to the amount [937] of fee
to be fixed for the 1961 financing?
A. My recollection is that the question of the amount
to be fixed as the fee for the 1961 financing came up sub-
stantially later than this. So far as the 1960 financing is
concerned, I have no independent recollection as to exactly
when I first learned about the amount of the fee. I have no
mental association that I can recall that fixes that date
with respect to the 12th of May.
Q. The first time you heard about it, did you find it
shocking, surprising, large, usual, unusual?
A. I thought it was a lot of money.
Q. I understand that, but when you heard about it, did
it impress you as being something indicating that some-
thing out of the order had happened?
A. I knew, Mr. Davis, that a good deal out of the order
had happened. The fee struck me as a very substantial
one, a lot of money. As I said before, this was a heritage
from the past, and on the basis of the knowledge I had, I
had no reason to think it wasn’t quite reasonable for the
services rendered even though it impressed me as a lot
of money you would have to pay.
Q. Did it raise some concern on your part that you
might have to pay a comparable amount with respect to
[938] the $147 million then contemplated to be planned
A-2891
Tulinghast—Deposition
through the same lending institutions, through the same
Dillon, Read? |
A. I certainly hoped and expected that we were not
talking about $750,000 for the subsequent financing, which
turned out to be the case.
Q. .On May 12th you telephoned Mr. Breech and report-
ed what had transpired?
A. That is correct. |
Q. Do you have a clear recollection of that telephone
conversation ?
A. Ihave a recollection of one part of it, and that was
his saying that he or I should not take the responsibility
for deciding this, and it was of sufficient importance that
it onght to be decided by the board.
Q You reported to him the approach made by Merrill
Lynch?
A. That is correct.
Q. At that time he heard of it from some other quarters,
or were you giving him the information for the first time?
A. I think this was the first he had heard of it, Mr.
Davis.
Q. And you told him that you had a meeting with—
(939) A. Mr. Forrester.
Q. That morning?
A. It was in the afternoon.
Q. The meeting on the 12th was in the afternoon?
A. Tam sure it was in the afternoon.
Q. And this telephone call to Mr. Breech was in the
evening?
Q. Right after the meeting?
A. My recollection is that°it was right after the
Forrester meeting.
A-2892
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. After they left?
A. Yes. I may be wrong on that, but I know it might
even have been the next day, but I know following the
meeting I tried to get in touch with him as soon as I could,
to explain the situation to him.
Q. Do you recall whether or not there were other people
in the room when you were talking to Mr. Breech and
explaining to him what happened?
A. I have norrecollection of other people in the room
at the time, Mr. Davis.
Q. Did Mr. Breech show some interest at what you
were telling him?
A. He was obviously interested in it.
(940].Q. Do you recall what Mr. Breech said and what
you said to him?
A. I recall this much. I recall that I went through an
explanation of the request, the discussion with Brandi, the
meeting with Forrester, summarizing what was said in
those discussions. I said I felt very strongly that it would
be a mistake to get started on a program that very likely
would lead from postponement to postponement.
Q. You told him that?
A. I did. That my own experience told me that it was
very unrealistic to expect to do something like this within
& week’s time, and that if we granted a week’s delay, that!
was morally certain that we would at the end of the week
be faced with the question of a further delay. And I felt
that we ought to deny the request but I didn’t want to do
so without discussing it with him and getting his conctr-
rence.
If I recall what he said, he said, “Charlie, this is one
that neither you nor I should decide. We better put this
before the whole board.”
A-2893
Tillinghast—Deposition
Q. When you said to him that based on your own expe-
rience a week was not sufficiently long, what experience
were you referring to?
A. Such limited experience as I had had with regis-
[941] tration statements.
Q. You had had experience with registration state-
ments? ;
A. Limited experience, yes.
Q. Was it your understanding at that time that the same
registration statement that had been prepared by TWA
would be used?
A. With such modifications as were necessitated by
bringing in a new party.
Q. Did you understand why Merrill Lynch wanted a
week’s time?
A. I know what they said.
Q. What did they say?
A. They said they wanted a week’s time in order to pe:-
mit them to put together an underwriting syndicate, and to
make the necessary changes in the registration statement in
order to effect a public offering.
Q. Were you familiar with putting together an under-
writing syndicate? ‘
A. Not directly.
Q. Indirectly?
A. I guess limited.
Q Would yon describe your experfence in putting to-
gether an underwriting syndicate?
[42] A. It is hearsay, Mr. Davis. I never actually en-
gaged di in putting one together. I have been on the
fringes enough to have some idea.
Q Describe as well as you can what indirect experience
" had in putting together an underwriting syndi-
A-2894
Tillinghast—Deposition
A. I was quite active in the distribution by General
Motors of the Bendix stock which General Motors sold, as I
recall it, in the first part of 1947. During the time I was at
Hughes, Hubbard, there were a good many offerings around
the office that I didn’t directly participate in, but got some
impressions about.
In 1950 something or other—I don’t remember when—I
represented the underwriters in an offering of the stock of
the Edo Corporation, and was active in that.
I know enough about it—I don’t represent myself as an
expert in this field. I know you have to have underwriting
agreements, and you have to give information to the under-
writers on the company, and you have to give an opportu.
nity to the underwriters that are interested to investigate
the company. You have to have meetings.
Q. Isn’t it true that all that work, the investigation of
the company, material to be disclosed to the [943] public—
all that work had been done by Dillon, Read and the Chad-
bourne firm, for the public offering by TWA, had it not?
A. Acertain amount of that had been done.
Q. Merely a certain amount of it?
A. May I finish?
Q. Yes, certainly. I was quite aware of the fact that if
you brought in new underwriters, the discharge of their
responsibility would require them to make at least a casual
investigation of the company. I can’t believe that a firm of
the standing of Merrill Lynch would make an offering with-
out taking some steps to familiarize themselves with the
company, the company’s future, the company’s problems.
They would bring in new counsel who would have to go over
the registration statement, educate himself sufficiently to b
in a position to pass the registration statement on behalf of
his client.
A-2895
Tillinghast—Deposition
It would bring in Hughes Tool Company as an active
party, and Hughes Tool Company, as it turned out on the
17th, had many serious questions about the adequacy of the
registration statement.
By the time that you had gotten a new set of counsel in
for the underwriters, by the time you had [944] gotten
Hughes Tool Company counsel in, no one in this world could
convince me there was a reasonable prospect of getting that
offering off the boards and ready to go public in a week’s
time.
Indeed, I said as much to Mr. Forrester, and particularly
to Mr. Hager, his counsel, and Mr.. Hager, in substance
agreed with me, and I said, “What sort of a guarantee can
you gentlemen give me that this can be accomplished within
a week’s time?”
They said, in substance, “Obviously we can’t give vou any
guarantee. All we can say is we will do our best.”
- £945} Q. When vou refer to a week’s time, you are not
quite accurate, are vou? We are talking about a request
made on May 11th. They were seeking a week’s adjourn-
ment from the contemplated May 17th, so it was two weeks’
time, wasn’t it?
A. No, it wasn’t two weeks’ time. I was talking with
them on the 12th of May, which was a Friday, and the
Proposal was to become effective on the 24th, which was
12 days later.
Q. 12 business days? °
A. No, not 12 business days.
Q. 12 days?
A. 12 days including Saturday and Sunday.
-~_ you think that is closer to two weeks, or one
~A-2896
Tilinghast—Deposition
A. That is 12 days. I will say, Mr. Davis,
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.