Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — United States v. Midwest Video Corp.

Supreme Court brief1972

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

BES 1 3 ;

: INDEX a

: i. ate

Opinions below___.______- Bamba. ab Lh giao rates be

No oS oe oc he cea nennndspebinne 2

~ Question presented_/_._...------ San ubcdueeatomeuieed an 2

Statutes and regulation involved._-_-___- Stix sey wa we 2

; ERS ES TRAE eRe RANE RE ON 2

os Reasons for granting the writ_____- iaedisi scene banue ioe

EEE LS AOE CCIE Dak ck ect aides 13

Appendix A:.__..---- pen ween <citenuneneein cut. - 15

I io roi ccna bankadwaweu Sweatee 30

Meee OER. Se ccs naknpiln otic tikes <2

eo ao pe icnwnecnnddewdechawpend ire

Appendix E__-#. --.2.4----- side cami pirsradvahwots =

Appendix oh cocoa owe aka csn bieuenahtuanus Soci. es

~ o _&

ae CITATIONS 8

\ Cases ; Ms =

=) American Trucking Aissns*v. United States, 344° US.

ss ee le a ae 8 ae

ae Carter Mountain Transmission Corp. v. “Federal Cons. ,

munications Commission, 361 F. 2d 359, certiorari

ea I SA Werks oe in ohn oes ch wc 10

| Federal Communications Commission v. Pott Broad: 3 :

ee” pastas Ge., See Ue 108... we oe 7

Federal Pous Commission v: Transcontinental Gas Pipe |

> ge he 2 Se ee es eee ay ee 10 -

Federal Radio Commission v.. Nason Bros. Bond & aa

“Mortgage Co., 289 U.S. 266...~--_---_--- Pied ed 10

Telephone Co. of California v. Federal Communi-.

c cations Commission, 413 F. 2d 390, certiorari denied,

396 US. 888____- ees tab oe Soe 10, 12

Midwest Televigion, «Inc., 13 FCC. 2d 478, affirmed,

: \ Midwest Television, Inc., et al v. F.C.C., ‘F.2d - 2

1222. {hte be) omiachanaies! Shag ptea 4,5

wm = aa

Hib g.

a To.

i ’ &: \

%

ie ——— pecs soma

es , be 3

National ot: rssdeesicg. Co. A United States, 319 US, Pose ae

Wo i. OT EE Pio SNE DIE at OE EEE i 7; 12- S |

5 _ United States v. ‘Southwestern Cable Go., 392 U.S. 157_ 2,6, 8,9 2 <

| United Stites v. Storer Broadcasting Oo, 351 U.S, 192... nie

va _ Statutes and regulations: ; ree.

Co tions Act of 1934, 48. Stat. 1084, ee kr |

i 47 U.S. 151 eteeg:: | Ree |

r rg a en fen bewcnner esse} Spiel decid ; a BTS

Addenda to Television Peotbook, Vol. Al: 40; Oct. 4, ae

* BOF oe kes PUL SEd RED Sida Pen bhKKbae dan dood OFT

117 Con. Ree. 8. 13628 ‘(daily ed. August 6, 1971,

AEM BAA. ety “13°

: 33 Fed. Reg. RR aes ke cnhewe as ee 8. : :

eee! Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Notice of Inquiry, reece A J

Nop OGG, Od 499 <= - 2s eae nero ste eseeese=-e 3 “4

\.+ Television Faétbook, 1971- 1972, Service Vol,,,p. 8 | a 12.

\ meee . Ce ig PE rs -

- ff ss ™ a 1‘, , >

Se @« s . ra

NO Le eae <I Doak em Poa a Gr.

a5. : . : ; ; , 3

3 . - . e ‘ . ae es

3 x

, >

. “ >

+ : s

) ;

ee <}

: ; j

‘i * eee ’

s

A

? net Pe :

6 ’ :

! he — :

ros %

a

ae

é

7

oo)

°.

. \ <

_2

q* , : OS ae ae aR

a the x Sane Goirt a the iid sins Re

ote tae e ' - Octopue ‘TenM, i971 - lee

No ; 5 A

| Uwrrep Srares OF Aimed AND FepERAL Comminrca-

TIONS Commission, PETITIONERS :

rece v.. a ag

| Mipwest VIDEO, Co P RATION a

of ‘PEITTION FOR:A WRIT OF CERTIORARI 10 THE UNITED STATES |

/

foc

ia - . ot MRS

eo

COURT UF-ARFEALS 208 THR HRT OLSOURE :

| | *

The § Solicitor General, o on behalf of the United States °

and. ‘the Federal Communications Commission, peti-

tions for a writ of certiorari to review the judgment. —

of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth ~

Circuit in this.case. The United States and the Com- —

- mission believe’ that this case presents an important

. issue which ought to be resolved | now by this Court. ba

, The United States has not, however, finally ated

* mined its position with respect to all aspects of the

merits of the case. The views with respect-to the merits |

_ expressed i in this oe are those of the Commission.

. "OPINIONS =

The 0 opinion of. the court of appeals (App. A, infra |

- pp. 1) is reported at 441 F. 2d 1322. The orders,

=

wa ‘

9

Wee 2 : ca”

of the Federal Cokimiidintendione Commission are. re- i

a Mr. Justice Blackmun the time within which to- ‘peti- Ve

» fhe jurisdiction of: this Court is invoked under 28 :

.” 48 Stat. 1064, as amended, 47 U.S.C, 151\\152(a),

‘?.- 153(a), 153(b), 153(d), 154i), 301, 303(¢), 303(r'),

_. ‘ported at 20 F.C.C. 2d 201, 23 F.0.0cp4 825, and 27 -

F.C.C. 2d 778 8 (Apps. 0. D, and E, satiny PP: tule’

JURISDICTION

_ The Gudgment of the court of appeals ves enteréd ae BE |

_on May 13, 1971. (App. B, infra, p. 30). By order ‘of | ov

tion for certiorari was ‘extended to October 9, 1971.

be S.C. TaGE{t). ; : 3

|". QUESTION PRESENTED . ae ,

“Whether the Federal Communications Commission’ eee

rule requiring community antenna television systems . |

with 3500 or more subscribers to ofiginate program-.

ae is’ within, the Conimission’s statutory authority.

cae STATOTE AND REGULATION INVOLVED - ~~

Sections 1, 2(a), 3(a), 3(b); 3(d), 4(i), 301, 308(g),

303(r), 307 (b) of* the Communications: Act of 1934,

* 307(b), are set forth in Appendix F, infra, pp. 68-72. .

- °. The-rule under review is also set-forth in Apes y,

anfra, P. 73... oF .

£3

¢ STATEMENT: — * *. , ’

‘In United ‘States v. Southwestern Cable. Co., "992 a

U.S. 157, ‘this Court héld that community antenna

- television (CATV) systems engage in’ ‘interstate ** *°-

_. communication by wire or radio”’ within the meaning ;

"of Section: ao of. oe Communications Act of 1934,

>

; \ 47 ei 152(a), and: scuisiltaliy, that the Federal :

2 Communications. Commission. has regulatory jurisdic- »:

‘/.- tion yver CATV, at: least insofar as its regulation. is

2 “reasonably* ancillary” to its. regulation of the broad# ©

_ cast. industry. Shortly. thereafter the Commission

_ launched a general i inquiry “to explore the bread ques-

. tion of how best to’ obtain, consistent with the public

- interest standard of the Communications Act, the fyll Pe

benefits. of developing communications: technology for. ™s

the public; . with particular immediate reference to

CATV dechnology and potential. services mes a, ” Nottce. 7 ‘ |

of Proposed Ralemaking and Notice of Inquiry, 15

‘FCC. 2d 448; 33 Fed. Reg. 19028, In particular, the

- ‘Commission juested. comments on whether it, should |

require CATV systems ‘to originate programming, :

+ and, in addition, on. whether advertising should be 2

permitted and whether the concepts pf “equal time”, —

“fairness” and sponsorship identification, applicable ,

_-te--the’, broadéasting reagan hd omely: to) apply to:

CATV. | % ibe

On October 24, 1969,. the: Conithission® Seanad a re-

. ‘port, 20 F.C.C. 2d 201; App. C, infra, pp. 31-56, dealing”

| with ‘the subject: of program origination, or “cable-, |

casting”, by CATV systems. In this report, the Corft-.

_ Inission @dopted a rule which provided ee a CATY , :

system-having 3 500 or more. ‘subseribe ‘May not .:

1 Other areas of inquiry included cites ooneiel »f television

_ Stations and CATV systems under common siaeel the use of ©

'.. some CATV channels provide common carrier service, and

- importation of distant signals into major markets. - 2 ee

* *In setting 3,500 subscribers as a feasible mifimum, size .

for systems required to originate’ programs, “the Commission é

took into account record evidence on the estimated cost of con- |

.. oo. : : . .

-

.”

ae eri

distribute the signals of television broadcast stations

unless it also operates. “to a significa t extent as a.

local outlet by cablecasting” and by having available

. “facilities for local production and presentation of pro-

‘* grams other than automated services“ (App. @ infra,

__,pp. 16-17).° The Commission had observed in its ‘Notice .

-of Rulemaking that the CATV. industry was placing >

igpreased emphasis on program origination, including

-. both local public. service and entertainment programs, .,

and ‘on. providing other nonbroadcast services to the

public such as. time, weather, and. news reports and

advertising.’ On the basis of the comments submitted i in

structing and operating iatlaceaing systems of varying. degrees

of. sophistication and_the statistics of the industry which

showed that. 70% ofthe cablecasting systems currently originat-

ing - programs pad ‘less than 3,500. subscribers and more than —

50% of the-originating systems had less than, 2,000 subscribers.

20 F.C.C. 2d 201, 209-214 (A P- C, énfra, pp. 39-44). .

. 8In -addition, the Commission adopted rules’ which limit. -

. ce ee messages to.the beginning and ‘end of each cable-

m, and to natural breaks or- intermissions within

* the program. Also regulations similar ta those which the Com-

munications Act and Commission rules make applicable to

broadcasters were adopted with respect to cablecasts by candi-

dates for public office, programs dealing with .controversial _

issues of public importance and sponsorship. identification of.

matter the system had been ins to cablecast ot 47 U.S.C.

315, 317).

‘The Commission also referred to its earlier. pee

of. the subject in a recently conipleted CATV ae. pk

ing the San Diego aréa. Midwest Felevision, Inc. F.C.C,’2d

478, affirmed, Midwest Television, Inc. vy. F.C.C., 426 F. 2d

1222 (C. A Bio). Ii -Midwest ‘the Comniission authorized a

test of unrestricted progrim origination without commercials

_.. by CATV systems in the San Diego area, and conditioned the .

carriage “of broadcast signals by gne system Upon a yequirement -

that it operates to g significant” extent as an outlet for non-

@

9

9 .

6 ‘ = a

ne wie making proceeding the Commissi ion coneluded + |

thatsCATV program origination serves the public.

_ interest by providing program diversity and creating

" outlets for self-expression, particularly in those. areas

_ wheré the establishment of broadcast ‘stations has not |”

- ‘proven feasible (20 F.C.C. 2d at 205-206, App. O, infra, >

:: pp. 35-36), and that the most effective way to encourage |

- eablecasting would be to condition “where practicable,

. the carriage of broadcast signals upon a. requirement

for. program origination” (td. at 208, App. C, infra,

" p. 38):5 | isdn eagle aes

! Upon ‘the challenge of respondent, an ‘operator of

_ CATY systems in Missouri, New Mexico, and Texas,

the court of appeals sat aside the program origination .

Tequirement on the ground ‘that the Commission did . -

not have the statutory authority. to adopt it. Citing

‘commercial community self-expression.” 13 F.C.C. 2d at 510.

The decision discussed at some length® (id.. at 503-508 the

benefits to be gained from program origination, in particular _

‘the increase it would provide in the number of local outlets

for community self-expression and for augmenting the pyblic’s -

choice of programs and types of service. - “

°“The use of broadcast signals,” the Commissign stated,

“has enabled CATV ‘to-finance the. construction of high capac- .

ity. cable facilities. In requiring. ii return for these uses of

radio that CATV devote a portion of -the facilities to pro-

viding. needed -origination service, we are furthering our statu- _

tory responsibility to ‘encourage thé larger and more effective

use of radio in the public interest’ (47 U.S.C. 303(g)). The °

requirement will also facilitate the more effective performance

of the Commission’s duty to provide-a fair, efficient, and equi-

-table distribution of television service to each of the several © -

States and communities (47 U.S.C. 307(b)), in ‘areas where.

we, liave been unable. to accomplish, this through broadcast

-media.” 20 F.C.C. at 208, App. C, infra, pp. 38-39. i

/ ‘

v

ene rn:

- Southwestern, ‘supra, the court held: that the ‘cable-

casting requirement was not “ancillary” to the Com- |

mission’s responsibilities in the broadcast. field and. ©.

- that. therefore program origination by ~CATVs was : .

_ beyond the scope of its jurisdiction. The court re-

" jected the .Commission’s contention that the Com-

~ munications. Act’ was - intended to confer ~unified

jurisdiction and broad authority over all of the

nation’s wire and radio communication systems.’

Judge Gibson concurred in the result, conclud-

' ing that the Commission has the necessary authority

over CATV. to adopt the rule} in. question but that

- while the rulé ‘is in the public interest, it does not

- appear that the FCC has shown a sufficient basis.for |

"exercising its authority at this time“ (App: A, infra,

p. 26-29).

| REASONS FOR onaTiNa THE WRIT 7

_ The. Federal Communications Conimission contends’

- that the decision below is contrary to the underlying

| rationale of the Federal Communications Act of 1934,

_ and is inconsistent with this Court’s view of that Aet -

as expressed ih United States y. Southwestern Cable

- Co., 392 US. 157. If allowed to stand, the Commis-

sion believes that the decision will frustrate the Com-.

’ mission’s efforts to. ‘integrate_ “fully the rapidily éx-

panding ~ CATV. ‘industry into the and iat -eom-

. munications ‘system. ne? ng Ps z

The court did not pass on the other rules relating to pro-

gram origination (i$; stipta), stating that since the petitioner

‘could not ~be compelled to telecast, it lacked standing to: chal, ae

@

— — | at

7

1. Congress created. the Federal Communications ee

- Commission in 1934 for the purpose of “entralizing ~

authority heretofore granted by law to several agen- eke

. Ges and * * * granting additional authority” in order

_to “make available, so far as possible, to all the peo-

- ple of the United. States a _ rapid, efficient, N ation-wide

and world-wide wire ‘and radio communication serv-

ice with adequate facilities oe ae Section 1, 47 |

U.S.C. D1. The Commission’s authority extends to | al

“all: pier and foreigh communication -by-wire <

radio” and “to all persons engaged within the United -

States : in “such communication. ” Section 2(a), 47.

U.S.C. 152(a). =.

The scheme of regulation aaa by the Act is "

as the decision below implies, restricted to forms of

wire’ and radio communication i in use at the time the .. .

Act was passed; rather, the Act was also designed to

| meet new developments in the continuously evolving #

uses of wire and radio. With respect to both techno-

logical: and economic regulation the Commission is

given comprehensive powers “to- promote and realize

the vast potentialities of radio.” Natéonal Broadcast-

_ ing Co. v. United States, 319 U.S. 190, 217; see United

States v. Storer Broadcasting Co., 351 U. S, 192, 203 ;'

Federal Communications Commission v.. Pottsville |

| Broadcasting Co., 309 U.S. 134, 138. Thus, with re- .

spect to the Conjningitin’ S rule making powers, Sec-

tion 4(i),-47 U.S. C. 154(i), contains 4 broad grant of

authority to “‘perform any and all acts, make such ~ |

rules ; and regulations, and issue such orders, ‘not-in- _ - atl

| consistent with thim Act, as may be necessary in the

’ ee N

8 7

execution of its functions.’’” These rulemaking pow-_ :

ers are ‘coterminous with the scope of agency regula-

tion * * *.’? American. Trucking Assns v. United

~ ‘States, 344°U.S. 298, 311; see éd. at 309-311.

goo United States Vv. Southwestern Cable Co., 392

US. 157, this Court indicated. that ‘the ‘Coitticamiiba: .

tions Act confers on the Commission essentially the

same jurisdiction over. CATV that it has over the

| broadcasting industry. Rejecting the contention that

the Act ‘‘limits the Commission’s authority to those 7

activities and forms of communication that are spe-

cifically described by the Act’s other provisions,” 392

U.S. at 172, the Court emphasized Congress’ intention ©

that all branches ‘of the wire or radio. communications |

industry be ‘subject. to a_xmified regulatory, system:

- We cannot construe the Act so restrictively..

_. ° Nothing in the language of § 152(a),in the sur-

_. Younding language, or in the Act’s history or

| _“ purposes limits_the Commisston’s authority to -

those activities and forms of communication -

| that are specifically described by the: Act’s other

_¢» * provisions. The section itself states merely that

“the “provisions of [the Act] shall apply to all

imterstate and. foreign. communication by wire

_ or radio * * *.’’ Similiarly, the legislative history :

'- indicates that the Commission was given ‘‘regu- |

_latory power over all forms of. electrical eom-

" Section 303(r), 47 U.S.C. 303(r), similarly grants authority.

“[e]xcept as otherwise provided in this Act * * * from time to

time, as public convenience, interest, or necessity requires. bale 3 al

_ to “[m]Jake such rules and regulations and prescribé such restric- _

- tions and ‘conditions, not inconsistent with law, as may be nec-

essary to carry out’ the provisions of this Act * * *.

wd

°.

*

| “< . j *; . :

; : \ 9 . e

Q >.

munication * * *,”? S>Rep. No. 781, 73d 7

| 2d Sess., 1. Certainly Congress could not in 1934 :

shave foreséen the development of community — «

antenna television systems, but it seems to us —

_ that it was precisely because Congress wished

“*to maintain, through appropriate administra-

tive control, a grip on the dynamic aspects of

radio transmission,” F.C.C. v. Pottsville Broad-

casting Co., supra, at 138, that it conferred —

upon the Commission: a. “unified jurisdiction” *

and “broad authority.”’® Thus, “Culnderlying —

the whole [ Communications Act] is.recognition .5 ©

of the rapidly fluctuating factors. characteristic _

of the evolution of broadcasting and of. the cor-

responding requirement that the administrative.

“process possess sufficient flexibility to adjust it-

self to these factors * * *,? [392 US. at 172-173 ;

footnotes renumbered. ] | ae

eee

‘To be be sure, the-Court’s opinion also noted: that ‘the _

Court was not required in Southwestern to. decide the

_ full scope of the Commission’ S regulatory jurisdiction

. - over CATV, but merely whether the Commission had

Ba | jurisdiction to regulate CATV. in ways which are.

‘‘reasonably ancillary to the effective. performance

of the Commission’s various responsibilities for the

regulation of television broadcasting.” 392 U.S. at 178."

-Relying upon this cautionary Janguage, the court of ©

appeals seems to have concluded that the Commission’s

regulations in the CATV area must be designed only

to prevent harmful competitive effects on the broad-

cast I industry. Such’ a narrow reading of Southwest-.

-8“S. Rep. No. 781, supra, “ gd (footnote by the Court).

“HW Re : Rep. No. 1850, supra, ab hea footnote cp = siege oe

‘

. re oe |

ern is unjustified. In the portion of its opinion quoted

above, this Court strongly ‘suggested that the Com-

_mission’s regulatory jurisdiction over CATV is similar

to its: jurisdiction over other major segments of the

communications industry. ~~ 4

In ‘any event, even if Commission regulation of

CATV must be ‘‘reasonably ancillary’ to regulation

of broadcasting, there is no reason to believe that this

” stdndard would restrict the Commission to regulation

designed to prevent deleterious competition: to the .

broadcasting industry. The CATV industry is depend-

ent for its existence upon tiie broadcast ‘signals that

-. it picks up and transmits. Having become “an } ted

gral part of interstate broadcast transmission,” CATV

operators “cannot have the economic benefits of such"

carriage as they perform and be free of the -neces-

sarily - pervasive jurisdiction of - the Commission.”

General Telephone, Co. of California v. Federal Com-

munications Commission, 413 F. 2d 390, 401 (C.A.D.C.)

» (per Burger, J.), certiorari denied, 396 U.S. 888; see

- also Federal--Radto Commission v. Nelson Bros. Bond —

y& Mortgage Co., 289 U.S. 266; Federal Power Com-_

mission v. Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corp. 365

US. 1, 7; Carter Mountain Transmission Corp. V.

Federal Communications Commission, 321, F. 2d 359

(C.A.IWC.), certiorari denied, 375 U.S. 91. Thus,

even if there must be some connection between the

Commission’s regulation of CATV and its respon-

- sibilities in the broadcasting area, such a connection

is present, when, as ‘here, the Commission attempts —

to. require CATV operators, whose principal product

2.

= .

i

is the vetvanstinineiin, of ecidaiaa signals a. who

serve the same functions in many areas as broad-

: casters, tosmeet some of the. same basic standards of

Tesponsibility to the Public 1 tat are imposed on broad- ;

casters. -

. Indeed, though the court below ae to the

“reasonably ancillary” ] ey jof the Southwestern

case, most. of the majority opinion deals with the-

“court's view of the wisdom of the program drigination

_ Tequirement, which it considered economically buyden- &

some to cablecasters.*° This factor; of course, bears —

not upon the Commission’s jurisdiction, but upon the

- . Qeasonableness of the regulation. The Commission does —

not contend that its authority to regulate CATV is

. exempt ‘from the requirement of reasonableness, and

it recognizes that the question of the reasonableness’

of regulation in the CATV area might in some situa-

; tions depend upon factors different from those. present

in .the regulation of the ‘broadcasting industry. We

submit, however, that the restriction’ by the court

below of ‘the Commission’ S jurisdiction to regulate the —

10 The record -before the Conntniantoti, however, does not sup-" -

. port this conclusion. In considering the financial impairment ,

contentions of the parties, the Commission noted that the record

contained “no data tending to demonstrate that systems with

3,500 subscribers cannot cablecast without impairing their fi-

- nancial stability * * *.”:'The Commission pointed out .that 70%

of the systems already originating programs had fewer than

3,500 subscribers. Moreover, the court failed to consider either

the available data on costs before the Commission or the fact -

that the cablecasting requirement is very flexible (23 F.C.C. 2d

at 826-827) dnd includes specific. guidelines for waiver of the

requirement if cablecasting would in fact be finanttally in-

jurious to a system. 27 FCC. 778, 779-780.

“* ot

X \ ;

See ae 13,

operation of CATV systems is contrary: to’ Congress’ |

-

intention, recognized by- this Court, to establish a

e

_. “unified system of regulation of the “radio and wire’

-~ eommunications industry. Indeed, lack of Commission

jurisdiction, in this field would presumatly open the

. door to disparate state and local regulation of. CATV |

services in contravention of the objectives of uniform —

‘and integrated regulation whi sh Congress sought: to

achieve. Cf. General Telephone Co. of California v. »

Federal: Communications ommission, supra, 413 F.2d

- at 402.° * ; sod os aes

2. There are now morg, than 2,500 CATV. systems in E

‘ ” operation (Television Factbook, 1971-1972, Services ,

Volume, p. 18a) servicing an estimated 15 to 20 million. ©

viewers per day. In ‘addition there are~ more than

2,000 CATV franchises outstanding: which" are not

currently operating, and approximately 2,600 fran- .

‘chise ‘applications pending. Addena to Televjsion Fact-

. book, Vol. 11-40, Octcher 4, 1971 While the growth

7 of CATV is still acceleratipg, its enormous potential

as a communication service to the public is now in

clear enough focus to tinderscore the need:for unified

regulation which will integrate CATV into the existing

nation-wide communication service. The alternative to .

| : Commission regulation is the kind -of ‘fragmented

regulatory pattern and chaotic development which

_ characterized broadcasting in its early years and which —

led: to the enactment of the Gemmunications Act of —

1934. See National Broadcasting Co. v. United. States, -

819 U.S. 190, 211-214. Although CATV itself. had not

yet been developed and was not specifically considered

eit. 0

a

18°

.

‘by Congress: at that time, it was the purpose of the -

Commiinications Act to confer sufficient authority on

-...the Commission to prevent this kind of chaos from

occurring again in the communications field: POS

indeed, the cablecasting rule is part of a compre-

“hensive regulatory program which the Commission. is :

developing to: integrate cable television into the na-

tion’s communications system. Under active consid-

eration, though not yet adopted i in the form of rules,

are a number of related proposals which seek to uti- -

lize the high capacity cable facilities of cATY to pro-

. ‘vide a diversity. of public services beyond that pro-

vided by the retransmission of broadcast signals, such

" as two-way | nori-Voice communication, leased chan-

"nels, public- access: channels, educational channels,.and

others." The restrictive view of the Commission’ s

’- jurisdiction reflected in the decision below casts seri-

‘ous doubt on this entire program. The case thus pre- -

‘sents a question. of great importance to the admini-

. stration of the Communications Act. and to the future

a tear of the communivations industfy. _

CONCLUSION

While-as previously oted (supra, p. 1), the views

on the merits, expressed herein are those of the Com-.

mission, both he United States and the Commission

1 A full statement of the Commission’ 8 “proposals for the near-—

term regulation of cable television” was submitted on .Au-—

" gust 5, 1971, to appropriate committees of the House and‘#én-

ate and appears. at 117 Cong. Rec. S. 18628 (daily ef Au-.

gust 6, aes and 31 soi 24115,

join in urging that the case is asi gnpectant one, which

should be reviewed by. this Court. The petition for al

. writ of certiosari should be granted.

Respectfully ‘submittad. : oR.

3 *” Erwin N. Graswoxp,

7 \ | _ Solicitor General:

RIcHARD W. MoLARen,

_ Assistant Attorney General.

Ricuarp B. Sronz,

_ Assistant to the Solicitor General.

me RcHARD E. Winey,.

— s General Counsel, .

Joun H. Contin, ©

' . Associate General Counsel,

- Epwarp J. Kunumann, =

Attorney, — | |

| Federal Communications Commission.

: OctoBER 1971. +P ake

! j a ,

foe He

bi . ;

f : w

oon

¢ ‘

: > “sf

sed — o

. . *\ ® \

; ; . 1, - ‘

ae haces

+ . 6 iS

a Ye) By 4 . vi R 3

\ 4 a : a,

is eee eee

..

‘ : ‘ : '

-

%

United States ‘of pour oud Ped-

eral Communications Commis--

a,

Vax Oosrmmsovr, Cirenit Judge.

Me ae

Oe ee

“e APPENDIX A eS

"United asi Court of Appeals

- . | FOR THE EIGHTH | CIRCUIT

No. 20,439: 3

Be mere Oe esto eee :

fe - et as

, Midwest Video Corporation, | Ress é

| de alge ae: "On Pétition for Be-

‘view of Orders of —

| ‘the’ Federal Oerh- —

munications . Com- poe

gs ‘mission.

_ eon, + fea ws

ee | Beapoggents. : 9

es (May 13, 197)

- | sit

Co]

‘Before Vax Oogrensous, Grasox and Tay! Circuit J udges.

i EET ee

Fig: ae

als s

Petitioner, Midwest Video Corporation, seeks review of

the first L report and: order adopted by the Federal Com-

“imunications Commission FOC)” on October’ 24; 1969, TO; é

ported at. 20 F.C.C.. 2d 201, and its order denying: recon-

sideration adopted Tunb“$A,- 1970, reported at 23 F.O.C.

24, 825.. The foundation for such orders was laid by notice .

Of erneee rule isco ed and notice of i —s, reported at

\.

’

.

'

&

[ ~ 16

a . ~ i ; , s 3 ; ents 7

‘1 F.C.C. “oa 417 cliting ‘to community antenna television ;

” sgystems (CATY). oO, eos

- Petitioner “opiate CATV systems in Missouri, New’

Mexico and Texas. ‘Some of its systems have microwave

authorization ‘and some systems have~ more than. 3500 _ -

_ subscribers. Petitioner was - substantially engaged in its & °

CATV operations long prior to the institution of the rule

making proceedings here involved.

‘The. FCC, anserting authority to do so en eer tothe

Communications Act of 1934 as ariended, 47 U.S.C.A.

- $151 et seq., adopted: (1) ‘Rules requiring all CATV.

systems with 3500-or more subscribers to produce original

programs to a significant extent and to have available

facilities for the production of such programs after April

1, 1971, as a condition to its right to continue to function °

‘as a CATV system. (2) Rules limiting type of programs ,;—

which CATV systems may transmit upon the basis of a

program of per channel charge. (3) Rules governing the

program origination of all CATV systems. __

Petitioner contends that Congress has not: hg the Com- |

_ munications Act or otherwise authorized the FCC to pre-

- scribe such rules. We agree with the petitioner’s conten-

tion and set aside: the origination rule for: the reasons

hereinafter stated. |

The principal attack is upon the origination rule re- —

ferred to at item (1) above. Section 74,1111 of the Com-

mission’s rules so far as here material reads:o

ad | ‘ay, Effective on and after April 1, 1971, no CATV

. system having 3,500 or more subscribers shall carry

the signal of any television broadcast station unless

“the system also operates to a significant extent as a.

local outlet by cablecasting and has s available facilities

{ |

17 -

for neal: sroduction and presentation of ~ programs:

- other than automated services. ... .

Cable casting is thus defined in § 74.1101:

43) Cablecasting. he term “‘cablecasting’- means

programing distributed on a CATV system which

has been originated by the CATV operator or by

another entity, exclusive of broadcast signals carried ,°

on the system.”?> — : a ; ws

No direct authority. i is eat to the FCC by the Com-

—— munications Act to regulate CATV systems. CATV came

7% _ into ‘existence subsequent to the enactment of the Com-

munications Act of 1934. Consequently it is not surpris-

¢ ing that nothin can/befound i in the Act or its legislative

_ history bearing “spon the intention of Congress with re-. |

spect to CATV regulation. Many effortsto enact legisla-

tion covering CATV have failed to meet with success.

- The growth of CATV has been explosive: Courts have

found the’ issue of the right of the FCC to regulate CATV

. to be extremely troublesome. The concern is not over the.

power ‘of Congress | to regulate CATV but over the au-

thorization: Congress has. actually made. |

Descriptions of CATV systems covering both off-the-air

and microwave: fed types, ‘the function of CATV and the

pertinent history of its development are fully discussed

~— in the FCC reports and in United. States v. Southwestern

. Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157, and Fortnightly Corp. v. United .

. Artists Television, Inc.,.392 U.S. 390. See Black Hills: .

. Video Corp. v. F.C.C., 8 Cir., 399 F.2d 65. No’ need exists’

to re-cover this ground here.

CATV operations are of two a off-the-air and

microwave. Off-the-air systems. ‘capture television and —

radio signals off the air by means of a high antenna con-

$

. *

18>

' vert: or modify the signal by electronic equipment and

carry the converted sighal to subscribers for a fee by

* coaxial cable and wire. Microwave systems use amplifying

. devices to bring distant signals over the air to the re-

' ceiving end of its station from which it conveys the signal ,

to customers in the same manner as off-the-air systems. ‘

The FCC first-asserted jurisdiction over microwave fed _

systems and later asserted jurisdiction over off-the-air

- gystems. The courts appear to ‘attach no significance to

the distinctions between off-the-air microwave fed systems.

See Southwestern: Cable Co., supra, p. 167 of 392. U.S.

+ In any event, the authority of the FCC in our present

case does not appear to turn on the competing use of the

spectrum by ‘microwave fed operations. The rules are

applied in the same manner to both off-the-air = the

' microwave operations. a

| In Southwestern Cable Co., the Baers Court upheld

the right of the FCC to‘require CATV systems to carry

signals of local television stations, the nonduplication of

local programing and the restriction of CATV trans-

’ mission of distant signals: into the one-hundred largest

television markets (except for such: s@vices as existed

on February 15, 1966).

- §uch authority was predicated upon 47 U. S.C.A. § 152 .

(a) making the provisions of: the Act applicable to ‘intér-

state or. foreign:communication by wire or radio’’ and

the broad statements of purposes in 47 U.S.C.A. § 151

directing the FCC to ‘‘make available . . . to all the

‘people of the United States a rapid, afiicient, Nationwide

wire and radio communication service. ~ . *.’’ Reliance

is also placed on § 153(a) and (b) defining wire and radio

communications, and §{§307(b) and 303(f) relating to

‘. providing equitable allocations of broadcasting’ facilities.

/

~

* would be involved. See paragraph 25 of the first repert.

19

The Court in Southwestern Cable. dey way of limitation —

. states :

‘““There is no need here to. determine in detail the ©

limits of the’ Commission’s authority to regulate

CATV. It j 8 enough to emphasize that the authority

which we recognize today under §152(a) is restricted

‘to that reasonably ancillary to the effective perform-

ance of the Commission’s various responsibilities for.

the regulation of television broadcasting, The Com--~

mission may, for these purposes, issue ‘such ‘rules

and regulations and prescribe such restrictions and

conditions, not inconsistent with law,’ as ‘public con-.

- venience, | ‘interest, or necessity requires.’ 47 U.S.C,

§303(r). ‘We express no views as to the Commission’s

authority, if any, to regulate CATV, “under any other

’ circumstances or for any other purposes.”’ _ 392 US.

157,178

The compulsory origination: rule here goes far bead |

the regulatory power approved in Southwestern Cablé Co.

The traditionakCATV operation differs greatly. from that

of originating#programs. For origination, substantial in-

vestment in entirely new and different equipment is re-

quired. Additional personnel is needed for program origi-

nation. The record, as the Commission: ‘impliedly concedes, |

provides no accurate estimate of the increased cost =

|

The Commission recognizes that smaller CATV npetas

tior’s could not afford to proyde origination services and |

concedes that there is no consensus as to the appropriate |

‘cutoff point or ability to provide origination. The Com- |

mission then arbitrarily adopt 3500 subscribers as the

| cutoff point.

‘In paragraph 24 of the first report, the Comission

cites instances ware CATVs, .with more than 3500 sub-

| 20

scribers have lost money on origination. Only approxi-

mately 10% of the existing CATV operations now have

more than 3500 subscribers. At paragraph 4 of its first

report, 20 F.C.C. 2d p. 20, the Comggpsion states: +

‘$4, Those conimenting on behalf of CATY- interests

generally agreed that CATV program origination

serves public interest. and should be encouraged, |

- though they almost, uniformly opposed our: proposal

- to require origination as a condition for the carriage -

>’. of broadcast signals (notice, pars. 15-16). On the

other hand,. broadcast interests—particularly those

without CATV holdings—generally urged that pro-

- gram origination should be prohibited altogether, or — .

at least restricted to local originations of the‘ public

service tyne, and that advertising should be barred.

It is claimed that this is necessary to prevent poten--

tial fractionalization of the audience for broadcast ©

services and a siphoning off of program material and

; advertising revenue now available to the broadcast

service.’ :

. Thus #t appears that both the CATV interests and con-

ventional broadcasters are appaeed to compulsory CATV

origination. ; :; ; -

In Fortnightly, the sires’ Oourt states that- televi-

sion results from the combined activity of brsadsediere

‘and viewers. Aftet carefully analyzing the function of

CATV, the Court holds that ‘the CATV operation: falls

on the viewers’ side . the line, and then goes on to say: ;

‘Essentially, a CATV system no, more than enhances ©

the viewer’s capacity to receive the broadcaster’s

signals; it provides a well-located antenna. with an-

_ efficient conneetion to the viewer’s set. It is true that -

'-a CATV system plays an ‘active’ role in making re-

ception possible in a given area, but so do ordinary

television’ sets and antennas. CATV equipment is’

pines iets. etatete Wikis: Ailes des eke hn Cela

-* and unlike broadcasters, do

21

powerful and sophisticated, but the basic funetion the

equipment serves is. little. different from that served

_ by the equipment generally furnished by a television

viewer. If an individual erected an antenna on a

hill, strung a cable to his house, and installed the

“necessary amplifying equipment, he would not be

‘performing’ the programs he’ received on ‘his tele-

vision set. The. result would be: no different if several — |

people combined to erect a coo operative’ antenna for

the same purpose. The-only. difference ini the case of

* CATV is thatthe antenna ‘system is erected and |

owned not by its users but by an entrepreneur.

‘The function of CATV - -systéms has little in com@.

‘mon with the function of broadcasters. CATV sys-

tems do not in fact broadcast or rebroadcast.’ Broad-

casters select the programs fo be viewed; CATV.

systems simply carry, without editing, whatever pro-.

grams they receive. Broadcasters procure programs

and propagate them to the. public; CATV. systefhs re-

ceive programs that have been released to the public

and carry them by private channels to additional.

viewers. We hold that CA operators, like viewers _

¢ perform the programs

that they, ¥eceive and nai 392 U.S. 390, 399-401.

. The Fortnightly Court ales: retognizes the useful public

. service performed by CATV in making vical no

tion possible i in certain areas. :

The Fortnightly holding that the CATV operator is

- not: a broadeaster and that the operation falls on the

‘viewers’ side of the line affords strong support for the .

petitioner’s contention that the Communications Act does -

. not ie ale the FCC: to compel program origination.

es CATV operators obtain their licenses. or _— a from

state regulatory boards or municipalities. Congress has

=

We find no balance of, sulin babaceat! which” "requires

. Stretching the Act to-confer such authority. In so holding,

we are not Ted on the power of the FCC to permit

oe

rules for such are operators ators who prolate ehovse-to——. nena

originate programs. : ;

It is of some ivaiheane that Congress _ nak au-

thorized the FCC to license CATV operation afd that —

- the Commission has not assumed authority to do so. In

its order denying rehearing, it states: |

“7, We note also other requests by several parties

that we deal-with CATV on a more comprehensive’ -

” basis at this time, covering such issues as licensing,

whether. origination by the CATV operator should be

permitted on more than one channel, regulation of

common carrier’ operations, reporting requirements,

and technical standards. We are not persuaded that .

all of these questions need be resolved before we pro-

. eeéd. with the basic determinations made in the First

' Report and Order of October 27, 1969. CATV origi-

nations are still in their infancy and, so far as we

know, common carrier operations are. still in: the

23 F.C.C.2d, 829,

iiade no attempt by legislation to preempt such authority.

The Commission has not asserted a right to license CATV |

operators. Problems arise with respect to encroachment

on state and municipal rights to franchise CATV. The

- record affords no basis for determining whether the local

franchises granted to CATV operators include or exclude

_ the right to cablecast. In sharp contrast, Congress has

. preempted the field of licensing radio and television opera-

future. These various issues are not being forgotten. _

tors. Provisions with resect to periods for which Seaebe

_may be issued ‘and standards to be applied in Granting

licenses are spelled. out.in the statute. —~ -

‘It is established that cablecasting involves no use of the

spectrum. Cablecasting involves’a new and distinct use

of electronic communication. which does not utilize in

any way the radio frequency spectrum of the broadcast

signals regulated by the Commission.. The Commission’s

power to adopt rules requiring cablecasting to the extent

that it exists must be based on the Commission’ 8 right

to adopt rules that are reasonably ancillary to its re-

sponsibilities in the broadcasting field. Cablecasting’s-

link to television is primarily economic. As held in Fort- .

‘nightly, broadcast signals are dedicated to the public by

broadcast studios and the right to receive and distribute

them may be exercised by any one with capacity to pcapture -

the signals. Sete

“The ‘Uommuiieataoas Act confers no authority to the .

: Commission to favor one mode of electrouts communica-

tion over another.

As “stated by the United. States in ita brief, the public :

interest standard of the Communications Act incorporates .

-the basic national ‘policy in favor of competition as ex-

pressed by the antitrust laws in areas such as this where

the competition does not relate to the use of the radio

frequency spectrum.

In our view, the Commission’ 8. origination requirement

goes far beyond the regulation of tHe use made of signals

. captured by CATV as authorized in Southwestern Cable

. Co. Petitioner is required as a condition to its right to

use the captured signals in their existing franchise opera-

tion to engage in the entirely new and different business

\ -

24

c

- of. originating programs. . Entering into the program.

” origination field involves very substantial expenditures.

Costly -equipment must be purchased: Personnel must be

employed who are skilled in photography; sound produc-

tion, program planning and. direction, and in performing. ©

Such expense will often prove burdensome becausé of the -

limited area the program will reach. See Federal Regula-

tion of Cable ‘Television: The Visible Hand, Chazen and

‘Ross, 83 Harvard L. Rev. 182%. - 9

a A high probability exists -that cablecasting: 4vill ‘not be

_ self-supporting and that the burden thereof would likely

cause substantial increase in the amount that subscribers

are required to pay for CATV service and in some in-'

~ stances may drive a CATV operators out of businesag

In.Frost & Frost Trucking Co. v. Railroad Commission, |

271 U.S: 583, the Court held that the State had aright |

for proper reasons to grant or withhold from its citizens

the right to use, its highggeys for private purposes, but

that the State could not condition the grant of such right

‘Upon. the user becoming a commor carrier. The Court

said:< _ . )

‘‘Having aera to form siote, the act here is an offer -

to the private carrier ‘of a privilege, which the state

may grant or deny, upon a condition, which the car-

rier is free to accept. or reject. In reality, the car-

rier is given.no choice, except a choice between the

rock and the whirlpool,—an option to forego ‘a privi-

lege which may be vital to his livelihood or submit

to a requirement which may constitute an intolerable

_ burden. .

- Tt is not necessary to Sd pal the neccenia that,

as-a general rule, the state; having power to deny

. a privilege altogether, may grant it upon such condi-

_tions as it sees fit to impose. But the power of the

we tn, Pe Ni

fae AE ee RTL RETNA Ne A OnLy

Sezai ait Nas 8

°

. as ks 7 ra 25 _ - . 7 ,

Xi \state in that respect is aot ynlimited; ory one of the

limitations i is that it may not impose conditioris which

. require the relinquishment of constitutional se sasia 4A

27108. 583, 593-94,

| See Interstate Commerce Commission v. Oregon-Washing-

ton R. Co.,:288 U:S. 14; Oklahoma Packing Co. v. Okla-.

‘ homa Gas-& Elettric Co., 10 Cir., 100 F.2d 770, reversed

on other grounds, 309 US. 4. Such principle applios to

our present situation. , ‘

\ FC? . reliance upon the end use. theory set out in Fed-

etal Péwer Commission v.» ‘Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line

Corp., 365 U.S. 1, is misplaced. The Court there held.

that FPC could consider the ead use of the gas in exer-

cising its jurisdiction over gas transmission but then goes

on to say: ‘‘The Commission cannot order a natural gas

company ‘to sell gas to users that it. favors; it can only |

exercise a veto power over proposed transportation and

it can only do this when a balance. of all the circumstances

weights against certification. 2 365° US. 1, 17. . >

In Southwestern Cable Co., “the “FCC took the position

that the regulations imposed were necessary to prevent

deleterious competition by CATVs which would financially |

cripple conventional licepstd broadcasters and discourage

prospective broadcasters) and that such regulation hence

was in the public i interest. The FCC has now changed its

position. ‘and hols the . public interest Fequires, CATV

origination because broadcasters in some areas will not.

- provide adequate servjce. Competition with —— |

television operators is encouraged by requiring cabl

ing and permitting advertising with certain tat

all over the ‘strong protest of licensed broadcasters. The \ |

Commission report itself shows that upon the basis of the

record made, - -it. is mghly: speculative whether arab is,

*_ gufficient expertise. or information available to” support a

finding that/ the origination rule will further the ‘public

interest. ‘There is a distinct possibility that such require-

“ment may /force CATV operators out: of business thereby

‘making ,wnavailable the -recognized useful service pér-

~ formed by CATVs i in areas where distance and. topography. ;

impair avorable reception of television signals. :

old that the FCC is without authority to impose _

the program originating rule on existing cable television.

oper plore. be

Petitioner has igs Pee the pay TV rules relat.

ing to program origination and the rules governing: ‘pro-

gram origination: Petitioner has stated that it has no ™

intention or desire to cablecast. Since we have held that

: petitioner cannot be compelled to cablecast, it would ap-

pear that petitioner has Sno. standing to challenge such.

rules. Moreover, some rules are still before the Com- |

mission on petitions for reconsideration filed by other

_ parties. Under such ‘circumstances, we pretermit con-

_ gideration of the validity of the rules promulgated with

_ respect to CATV operators who voluntarily elect to cable-

”

cast. #

| The order of. the FCC requiring CATV aparehiea. to

originate ‘programs as.a condition to the- continuation of:

their CATV — is set aside.

asda Circuit Judge, concurring. =" VE aly he

I concur in the result. I think the FCC has authority |

~ ever CATV. systems but that the order under review ‘is.

’ eonfiscatory and hence arbitrary.

«dt is certainly in the public ‘abetont for the FCC to

. rege: CATV systems x which partake, of a monopoly in.

g .

Sanaa P RE Nias bois 20 costa SbvAUT PN EL

. . .

)

a: wide

‘ Whethe

ee?

ae

as disseminating and transmitting TV programs in certain

areas. Undoubtedly their operations have a substantial -

effect on licensed broadcasters ; ; and from the. public. view- ‘

iety of programs with improved. reception.

ey do this with less annoying -and irritating

commercials I do not know. It appears to the casual —

viewer that the commercials have over the years become

_ point : oe a real service in offering the public

increasingly longer in length, more frequent and some- .

times louder so that some news programs and some mo-

_ tion picture prégrams ainount to little more than a series

of disjointed commercials. It is thus uncertain whether

the ‘CATV systems would give the public any relief from

‘the ever-increasing commercials; and, of . course, if the

_ CATV systems were allowed to inject their own com-

mercials, this would constitute an “additional irritation

and biael trespass ypon the viewers’ time. This, however,

| is a matter that must await future development.

” Seutiomavbins Cablé recognized the CATV ‘systems’ i

| pact. on TV broadcasting and clearly upheld the Commis-

sion’s authority to meet the issue in that‘vas¢, while noting

that the extent of the Commission’s authority had not yet ©

been judicially determined. Congress, of course, could set

out the limits but has not seen fit to do sa and for a

variety of reasdns might not act upon the problem. The

‘FCC, therefore, will have to regulate the development of

this new and important electronic development i inaaman-

_ ner best: suited to the public interdst, as the need arises :

~ and: the opportunity presents itself.

“he Fortnightly case of course only considered: the :

CATV systems as they are now donstituted ‘as a dis-

séminator and viewer of programs rather than an origina-

. tor or broadcaster. In this light CATV does not violate |

.

6

ca

28 i) - - ; &.

the Copyright Act of 1909. The only import of this. deci-

sion is that it does definitely. classify the CATV: systems’

as transmission facilities rather than broadcasting facili-

ties. Now the FCC, by imposing originating” responsi-

bility of even a limited type on certain CATV systems,

changes their essential operation from that of a pure-

transmission facility to that of at least a limited broad-

east facility. Then once assuming a broadcast: function, |

. the CATV systems would have to be further regulated in

the public interest by the FCC; and of course local origi- .

nation’ in the CATV systems could eventually <open up

many avenues for mass media communication. There is,

and the majority opinion does not rule out, the possibility

that optional or = compliance with the = order

might take place. © ; :

While it appears to me that the FCC’s rule on limited |

~ origination is in- the public interest, it does not appear:

thats thee WAR nes thown a sificienit ” basis Yor exercising

“its authority -at this time. ‘The Commission does have

b authority under gt! US.C. §151, ‘‘to make avail-

able “* * a rapid, efficient, Nation-wide * * * com-

-municatio service with adequate facilities at reasonable .

“charges”’ ; but ‘the Commission’s particular order on origi-.

nation, at this tinte~at least, would be extremely burden-

some and perhaps rembve°from. the CATV field’: many ~ -

enterpfeneurs who. do not hive.the resources, talent and -

- ability to enter the broadcasting ‘field: The order is thus ©

oppressive ‘and arbitrary at this time, but that’ does “hot

mean that with the continued dévelopment of the CATV

systems and with the systems’ impact upon broadcasting,

it might not in the future be advisable and in the public -

* interest to compel origination of local programs. It would

: apes to me. that the CATV — should be permitted

o

-

‘ .

* P

Ba ah. eta ale a Poel Pie is plihew! Boe

2—~O«w

to: remain hassel a iranieniciol: facility at this time,

with allognce for the CATV systems to experiment on

origination without. being compélled to do so.

Another difficulty is in now. assessing future develop.

ment of the CATV systems’ operation. The FCC is to be

commended in ‘attempting to anticipate how this electronic _

phenomenon can and should be used in the public interest.

- This can.be done by allowing experimentation with volun-.

tary origination without Placing a burden that to some .

would be confiscatory. ,

A trae copy...

Attest: - fe 3 o

Clerk, U. S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit.

~

APPENDIX B

J UDGMENT ;

Gnited States Court of. Sippel

. FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT .

- No. 20439.

. ‘Midwest Video ‘Corporation, | . a

- . Petitioner, | On. Petition for

a —_ Review of Or-

7 oe ae ders of the Fed-

United States of America and? ora) Communi-

- Federal Lomanenat Com- cations Commis-

_ mission, os sion. ;

- Respondent.

[September ‘Term, —

. On Consideration Whereof, it is now here ordered |

and adjudged by this Court that the order of the

Federal Communications Commission in this cause

requiring CATV operators to originate programs as a

condition to the continuation. of their CATV opera-

tions be-and is hereby, set aside in accordance with —

the majority opinion - this Court ° this day filed

herein. |

May 13, 1971. | o

A true copy. a

Attest: — ;

-. Clerk, U.S. Court of — Eighth Cireuit.

(30)

31

APPENDIX C ©

£

| CATV fe 201

Ge ee F.C.C. 69-1170

; . . BEFORE THE ‘ ;

° FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION

Wasuineton, D.C. 20554

In the Matter of ;

AMENDMENT oF Part 74, Suspattr K, oF THE

Com™MIssion’s RULES AND REGULATIONS REx- | .

: ATIVE TO COMMUNITY ANTENNA TELEVISION

Systems; AND Inquiry Into THE Devevor- } Docket No. 18397

MENT OF COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY AND ar

Services To Formunate Recuiatory Pot-

‘ JCY AND RULEMAKING AND/OR LEGISLATIVE

PROPOSALS : 7 4

First Report AND ORDER

(Adopted October 24, 1969)

By THE CoMMISSION : COMMISSIONER BARTLEY CONCURRING AND ISSUING |

A STATEMENT; COMMISSIONER Ropert E. LEE DISSENTING AND IS-

SUING A STATEMENT; COMMISSIONER JOHNSON CONCURRING IN THE.

RESULT. . . + 4 . oO

ly The Commission’s “Notice of Proposed Rulemaking” and “Notice

of Inquiry,”. issued on December 13, 1968 (15 F.C.C. 2d 417, 33 Fed_>

. 19028), divided this proceeding into five parts. Under that notice

and subsequent orders, the filing times for comments and reply com- ;

ments on various parts, or portions thereof, were scheduled for different = =.

‘dates. Comments and reply comments on a agraphs 11-20 and 23-25

of part Ili of the December 13th notice peti, reetived and con-

sidered by the Commission. This first rep6oxt- and order treats only

-ome of the matters involved in those paragraphs, i.e., CATV program

-origination, its economic basis and the proposed equal time, sponsor-

ship identification, and fairness requirements... =. *_.-

. . 2. In this connection, we wish to emphasize that in this complex

rulemaking proceeding, it would be wholly impracticable to attempt —

to issue a comprehensive set of rules governing all aspects. Rather, we - .

shall split off parts for action, deferring action on other parts pending

further analysis or further proceedings. Thus, while we ie aie on

‘CATV origination, whether it should be required, whether commer-

cials should be allowed, and certain basic requirements-such as equal

opportunities for political candidates, fairness, and sponsorship iden-

tification, we have not acted on the related diversification issues.

Clearly, with origination, there should be multiple ownership rules,

particularly with respect to cross-ownership of broadcasting and

CATV facilities in the same area. But- since the diversification issues

require lengthier analysis and study, we act now, as we can, in the

above-noted areas. For, it is, we think, of the utmost importance that _

: . 20 F.C.C. 24

446-252 O - 11 - 3. - ¥ remeonipaneee a “osama 8 Se NO MRO SRA TERE OS RS

>

5 ai

32,

202 © Federal Communications Coinmission Reports

we supply needed guidance to the industries involved, to State and

municipal entities, and to other interested persons, as to the Federal. .

regulatory policies in this vital area. Moreover, we note that Co

is considering legislation in this area. While the legislation is believed

to be aimed essentially at resolving the unfair competition issues

treated in part IV of the notice, our policies in the origination area

(pt. III) may also be relevant to the Congress in its consideration .

of the above-noted legislation. We think it desirable, therefore, that

Congress be fully informed of these policies, so that it: may take them .

into account, either as appropriate background to the legislation or as |

matters to be included in the legislation. We state, as we have before,

that in this important new area we welcome congressional review

and whatever guidance Congress may wish toafford. — ;

I, CATV PROGRAM ORIGINATION IN GENERAL -

3. In paragraphs 12-14 of the notice the Commission set fexth its

tentative view that CATV program origination is in the public interest

_and should be encouraged. We further stated our belief (pars. 12, 26)

that the public interest would be served: by encouraging CATV sys-

tems to operate as common carriers on some channels in order to afford

an outlet for others to present programs of their own choosing, free

from any control of the CATV operator as.to content (except as re-

quired by the Commission’s rules or applicable law), and to provide

other Communications services. These tentative conclusions recognize

the great potential of the cable technology to further the achievement

of long-established a arert! goals in the field of television broad-

casting by increasing the number of outlets for community self-expres-

- sion and augmenting the public’s choice of programs and types of

services (notice, pars. 5, 13). They also reflect our view that a multi-

purpose CATV operation combining carriage of broadcast signals

with poco erigination and common carrier srevices, might best

exploit cable channel angen to the advantage of the public and pro-

mote the basic purpose for which this Commission was created : “

ulating interstate and foreign commerce in communication by wire and

radio ‘so as to. make available, so far as possible, to all people of the

United States: rapid, efficient, nationwide, and worldwide wire and

_ radio communication service with adequate facilities at reasonable .

charges * * *” (sec. 1 of the Communications Act). After full con--

sideration of the comments filed by the parties, we adhere to'the view

that program origination on CATV is in the public interest. )

- | 4. Those commenting on behalf of CATV interests generally agreed

that CATV program origination serves public interest and should be

encouraged, though they almost uniformly opposed our proposal to

require origination as a condition for the carriage of broadcast signals

(notice, pars. 15-16). On the other hand, broadcast interests—par-

ticularly those without CATY holdings—generally urged that pro-

gram origination should be prohibited altogether, or at least restricted »

to local originations of the public service type, and that advertising

should be barred. It:is.claimed that this is necessary to: prevent po-

_tential fractionalization of the audience for broadcast services and

‘8 siphoning off of program material and advertising revenue now

_ available to the broadcast service. 7 ‘

os a

33

CATE Sy, * 203

» 5. We are nof. persuaded that the position of the broadcasters has

merit. In the first place, if the public 1s to be provided with additional

program choices and different types of services and chooses to take.

advantage of them, it appears inevitable that there may be less viewing

_ of the previously exiatiing services." However, we do not think that the

public should be deprived of a. opportunity for: greater i eed

merely because a broadening of selections may spread the audience an

reduce the size of the audience for any particular selection. Such com-

‘petition for audience attention is not unfair, since broadcasters and

ATV originators (both the CATV operator and others originating

on,common carrier channels), stand on the same footing in acquiring

the program material with which they compete. aie

6. Sécond, a loss of audience or advertising revenue to a television

station is not in itself a matter of moment to the public interest unless

. the result is a net loss of television service. Federal Communications

Commission v. Sanders Bros. Radio Station, 309 U.S. 470, 475-476;

' Carroll Broadcasting Co. v. Federal Communications Commission,

258 F. 2d 440 (C.A.D.C.). The Commission has repeatedly recognized,

_of course, that a CATV-caused loss or deterioration of free broadcast

service would be detrimental to ‘the: public interest since it does not:

“presently appear that CATV could replace such service for viewers not

economically reached by cable or those unable to afford CATV charges.

However, despite much speculation in the comments, we find no factual

basis in this record or other persuasive reason for concluding that

CATV origination is likely to cause such a loss in the near future (i.e.,

the next decade) .?: - of 3 f 3 : |

' % Contrary to the misconception in.some-of.the comments, the De-

cember 13 notice did not propose to restrict CATV to local originations

or to bar originations of the entertainment type or to preclude CATV

network operations on an interconnected basis, and our finding as to

absence of any real basis for the asserted fears of the broadcasters is

not based on any restrictions of this nature. While we regard aug-

mented — for community self-expression.as extremely im-

portant, the Commission has also sought to promote new national and

ional television networks generally and intends actively to explore

this possibility for CATV (see e.g., notice, footnote 8 and par. 60).

-Our experience in the broadcast field (both commercial and noncom- -

mercial), as well as comments filed in this proceeding, leads us to be-

lieve that the successful inauguration of any new network is not-an

— matter, to-a significant extent because of the high cost and other

diffic

ulties in producing or otherwise procuring programing in suf.

ficient quantity and quality for network operations.* Moreover, CATV .

faces an additional hurdle in that its present subscriber.base, while .

affording fees not available to broadcasters, is nevertheless-far smaller |

than the potential audience open to a new broadcast network. This’

situation might change substantially if CATV systems commenced

2 It is possible, of course, that some of the viewers of the new services may be persons

. who either did not ——_ the old services or who increase their viewing hours in light of the

- added Le napa’ 4 To t extent, CATV program origination may not affect the audience

previously available to the broadcgst service. ‘

2 The above statement is to be ¢Contrasted with the views expressed in Midwest Television,

Inc., 18 F.C. = 478, and pt. IV of — Dec. aa — — as: to CATV operations with

distant signals major markets under present circumstances. :

“8 Another Very important factor in the Uroadcast field is the present lack of competitively

equal outlets in many markets. . ; . : ; . .

~~

4 . .

ELLE DL LLP OLV YOON IS WENGE IDOE IOOLEAS BOLE: ME A ao ee) z

. °

34

204 —- Fedéral Communications Commission Reports

operations in major pe team centers, achieved high penetration

percentages, and found ways to expand their service to outlying areas

through microwave or other technological means. However, we think

that in any event it’ would be a substantial period of time before any

CATV .network -is i# a position generally to outbid the broadcast

' service for the raming now presented by that service or to siphon

off audience and advertising revenue to a degree that might have detri-

mental impact on established broadcast service to the public. See also,

here, the discussion in paragraphs 9-10, infra. :

- 8. Third, and most important, in the event that adverse co lenices

on service by individual stations or broadcast networks should develop

or appear imminent, the Commission can and would take such remedial

or preventative actionias may be necessary to preserve sérvice to the

public. As stated in the notice (par. 14), “the ommission’s authority .

to regulate the use of broadcast signals as a:base for CATV program

origination encompasses power to adopt regulations reasonably de-

signed to prevent such operations from ‘having detrimental con-

_ sequences to the public interest and to promote their development al

lines likely to maximize the potential benefits to the public.” We intesidl

to keep a watchful eye on the progress and impact of CATV origina-

_ tion and will be alert to protect the public against any significant over-

all loss or impairment of television service. © oF

- 9.. In the field of broadcast subscription television, we have already

adopted certain measures designed to avoid any adverse impact on

free broadcast service. Subscription Television, 15 F.C.C. 2d 466, 504—

509. The Commission clearly has the authority, we believe, to impose

similar or other appropriate safeguards for CATV origination. We

_ believe that we should leave this an open matter, for further considera-

tion (if the need arises) either at some later date in this rulemakin

proceeding or in another rulemaking proceeding, to be commence

after we gain some further. experience in this area. .

10. We shall expand briefly on our reasons for now treating over-

the-air and wire pay-TV differently, First, we note that, in the former

field, we have data Frentive Hartford trial. We recognize the potential

of the over-the-air pay-TV service, with its ability to reach large num-

bers of persons throughout the station’s service area, and to obtain

revenues on a per program basis. The development of pay-TV. on -

‘CATV systems iis much more difficult to foresee at this time. ‘There

has been no comparable experiment or test of a substantial nature. The

large community remains to be wired, from almost a zero starting

point. We have not authorized the use of distant signals without pay-

ment as a base for CATV operations in the larger markets. We are

reluctant to take any further action which might inhibit cable develop-

ment in these markets, unless and until experience gives some indica- _

tion of a trend calling for action in the public interest. It may be that

‘CATV systems, while originating some. programing of types which

-might be found on free television, would not obtain such revenues |

that—taking intto account its penetration in these markets *—there

_ would be any significant diminution of fare presently available free’

; - ;

4 We note that, unillike tion with distant signals (see notin. pars, 34, 36), we have

no present indication of the degree of etration CATV, opers g with originations but

no distant ls, might achieve in these large markets. is, however, is :a significant

factor to be included in the public interest. judgment discussed abave. _

20 F.C.C. 24° yo --*

CATV. 205

«to the American public. Finally, we do im one restriction on

CATV designed, ip part, to insure that the public will receive, to

some significant extent, a different service; namely, that the program-

ing originated on cable ‘cannot be interrupted by commercials (i.e:

commercials permissible only at natural breaks). See

paragraphs 31-38. In short, it. appears to us that wire origination

_ operations in the larger markets may fave different, and perhaps more

difficult, problems than over-the-air pay-TV; that we lack any present

substantial experience in this res in the wire area; and that, there-

fore, the public interest would be served for the present by encour-

- aging CATV to experiment and develop its originations free from

restriction as to interconnection or limitations as to types of program-

ing, in the expectation that the end result will be s gnificant added

_- diversity for the public. We stress again that this is simply our con-

clusion as to how best to proceed at this initial stage, aA that as we

gain experience, we can take such action as may be required in the

public interest. ° -_ vi .

11. We also deem it appropriate at this time to amplify our view

that CATV systems should = encouraged, and perhaps ultimately:

required, to lease cable space to others for originations of their own

choice on a local or interconnected basis, in-order to promote diversity

of control over the media of communication and diversity of program

choices as well as to increase the opportunities for television communi-

cation with the public by more wi read sources, We adopt no rules —

at this time, since this is an area: which we believe requires further —

study and analysis of the comments. :

12. ‘The most marked potential of the cable technology for enhanc-

ing communications services to the public stems from its expanding

_channel capacity. CATV cable started with five channels or less; now

generally has 12, and holds promise of 20:40 or snnve:rom a diversity

standpoint, it seems beyond.

the content of communi¢ations on so man channels into the home. For,

it has long been a basic tenet of national communications policy that

“the widest possible dissemination of information from diverse and

- antagonistic-sources is essential to the welfare of the public.” Asso-

ciated Press v. United States, 326. US. 1, 20; Red Lion Broadcasting

- Co., Ine. v. Federal Communications Commission, 395- U.S. 367:

United States v. Storer Broadcasting Co., 351 US. 192; The Goodwill

Stations, Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission, 325 F. 2d.637,

640 at footnote 5; First Report and Order.in Dockets Nos. 14895 and

15238, 38 F.C.C. 683, 699-700. Cee

13. In one sense, as pointed out in the comments, traditional.CATV

operations furthér the Oe of diversity simply by carrying multiple

broadcast signals. While CATV o rators select the signals carried

(within the confines of the applicable Commission rules), they gen-

erally have no control over the content of the communications on the

‘signals selected.’ However, the principle of diversity encompasses

_ more than diversity of control ; it includes also the important factor of

© This kind of diversity is diminished if the CATV operator has an ownership interest in

broadcast stations carried on the system, or if he “pr ms” a channel by selecting pro-

grams from a number of distant stations. In such cases, he is no longer a passive conduit for

~ program services designed>by others.’ ‘ - te -

20 F.C.C. 24

discussion, infra, .

dispute that one party'should not contrél |

. OL EE LILI PO TLE TNE IET

’ . over any extended period of time.*

36

206 . Federal Communications Commission Reports

diversity of program choices available to the public. As reflected in-our

saiiboc to require CATV program origination as a condition for the

carriage of broadcast signals, we do not t ink, _ the present broad-

‘cast mode of operations that significant additional progrant® choice

ean be obtained by. simply adding more. broadcast signals be paved

20-40 channels of programing to subscribers. There are only three

~ national television networks and a large percentage of our broadcast —

sfations are affiliated with these networks. While network-affiliated |

stations also present nonnetwork programs and there are an increasing |

number of independent and educational stations, stations in different

communities’ broadcast substantially the same nonnetwork programs

See, e.g., Midwest Television, [nc.,

15:F.C.C. 2d°478, 484, 501. Thus, beyond basic broadcast services (con-

sisting of the signals of the three networks, one independent, and one

educational station), the diversity gained by cumulative broadcast

_ signals is largely a matter of choice of viewing times, rather than an

~~ real a gO choice in terms of new or different programing. We

-- believefhat much more significant additional choice of programing is

' likely to be achieved in the long run if some cable channels are devoted

. topr origination. yr ates: Se -

14. ile we. have accordingly concluded that, at least for the’

- present, CATV operators should be eligible to engage in program origi-

nation, and encouraged or even required ‘to do so, the December 13

notice proposed to limit origination by the CATV operator (apart from

automated services) to one channel. This proposal is based on our

tentative view that one entity should not control the content of the pro- °

gram materials on all cable channels not used for carriage of broadcast |

signals. It also accords with the a principle in the tele-

‘vision broadcast field that one entity should not be authorized, or have ©

an interest in, more than one television channel serving the same area. —

In other words, the proposed one-channel limitation is ‘designed ‘to

_ promote diversity of control and not to limit the quantity of origination

on the cable or to restrict the opportunities for achievement of maxi- _.

- mum diversity of oe choices to the public. On the-contrary, the

realization of such benefits for the public is the Commission’s basic goal,

and we think that they are more apt to be achieved if others besides —

broadcasters and CATV operators have access tothe cable channel

"capacity to reach the public with cémmunications of their choice, free

from controkby the CATV operator as to content. The comments have

raised the issue of whether there should be a limitation based on per:

centagé of channels (e.g., to take into account the difference between

8 12-channel and a 40-channel system), or whether there should be an

initial period in which the CATV operator would not be restricted to’

only one channel for origination. We shall-consider these alternatives

- in our subsequent reports in this general area of diversification. It is

sufficient to note here that there is clearly need for regulatory action

in this respect. ie |

15. There is also, in our 0 inion, a néed for additional means by

which various entities can communicate with the public via television

¢ Indeed, it is this Which causes broadcaster concern as to methods of afford independent

stations (and network tions to the extent that they present nonnetwor'! a

stations

general about 45 percent of their schedule), some measure of exclusivi fea-

ion by other, more distart broadcast signals carried ‘2 table. ey Seer

_ 20 F.C.C. 24

. 37

CATVe.. gy

at low cost. Access to the public via the broadcast medium is necessarily —

restricted to a few, and those able to obtain a license—though under

an obligation to operate in the public interest—are not common car-

=, Tiers (see sec. 3(h) of the Communications Act) apd generally retain

control over access to their facilities by others. Cf. Red Lion Broad- .

casting Co., Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission,. 395. U.S. .

367. Moreover, cable television service has tended ‘to develop on a non-

competitive monopolistic basis in the areas served, so that only one -

cable enters the subscriber’s premises. Persons who are not in & posi-

tion to engage in broadcast or CATV operations or to acquire time—or

as much time.as desired—on the broadcast media, could nevertheless

obtain television access to the public if a portion of the channel capacity ~.

of a community’s only cable system were reserved for their use on a

common carrier basis. As indicated in the notice (pars. 8, 26), those

desiring such access might include political candidates, municipal and

State governmental authorities, educational ‘interests, civic and pro-

fessional organizations, amateur dramatic groups, professional pro- |

‘gram producers, advertisers, etc. Other entities might well take

eres of the facilities 1f they were made available on this basis.

16. ‘In light of the foregoing, it is our opinion that the public interest

would.be served by encouraging CATV systems to operate as common:

B43 carriers on some channels. Entities desiring to do so should be permitted

' to communicate with the public in a community, or in a particular seg-

ment of a community, or in-a number of communities on a State,

regional, or national ‘basis to the extent that cable facilities ©

are “available and are intercennected.? ‘CATV operators. should -

be able to furnish studio facilities and technical assistance ‘as

part of the service, but should have. no control over program content

except as may be required by the Commission’s rules and applicable.

‘law. And here, again, we think that at present innovation and experi-

. théntation ‘should be encouraged and that such public use of CATV.

facilities should be free from restriction by loéal, State, or Federal

authority (or by private parties) as to the types of program materia]

to be presented (with the exception of possible restrictions applying

to illegal lotteries, obscenities, etc.). However, action will--be forth-

coming only after further study. | _*

17 "We believe it importanf also to set out the Commission’s position

. on two other -matters—interconnection of cable systems and commer-

cials on origination channels. The Commission would feel compelled

too on.behalf-of the public, any proposal which would preclude

CATV systems from leasing channels to others for program origina-

tion of any kind or from interconnecting on a regional or national. .

basis for any purpose, including the distri ution of entertainment type

. programing. We strongly believe that the promise of this new tech- °

nology should not be stifled b foreclosing the possibilities that some

__ of these 20-40 channels might be opened to others on a common carrier

basis and that significant new diversity. of programing and ‘other

\I We recognize, of course, that systems with smaller channel ca acity may have less . J

space to offer for use by others than systems with many channels, and that some may have -

: ‘nothing left after providing for carriage of broadcast signals and CATV origination. In. .

; . par. 25-of the notice, the Commission posed a question as to whether autoniatic services |

4 should be subject to displacement if there is a greater demand for leased chann n can’

be accommodated. A.similar issue might ultimately arise with respect to a possible ceiling

; Fat may be carried where channel scarcity is a factor.

bf |

‘ v

‘a “ "90 F.CC. aa:

‘ —_ . : — — [> Se BOE Pe OE ENROLLEE NOELIA DEL SLL LEM NN PE ESOT

whhig 7 * : ; os

on the number of broadcast signals t

f2 | : ° - . ; © -« ff

208. —s-_—“ Federal Communications Commission Reports

‘ services might be brought to the American people through regional

or national interconnection, including competition to the present three

national television networks. In the domestic satellite proceeding it.

‘ ‘has been suggested that CATV cable channel capacity might be utilized

‘as a means for local distribution of satellite communications. Finally,

we note that the public interest would. be best served by permitting

CATV operators to derive revenues from commercials to help defray

the cost of their originations, or pro ming presented by. others-on .

leased channels, and provide the public with a new type of servi

‘one where commercials occur only at natural intermissions or breaks

‘in program material (see pars, 31-38 below). ‘

. |. YI. SPECIAL RULEMAKING PROPOSALS

\ ..A! Required origination and the econonic basis

18. Origination requirement.—In the December 13 notice, the Com-

mission proposed to requi origination by all but small systems as a

ceondition for the -carriage of broadcast signals (pars. 16-17).

Most of those favoring encouragement of origination {with some ex-

.ceptions such as the city of New York and the Screen Actors Guild)

“were oppee to any mandatory requirement. Apart from jurisdic-

tional challenges, it is asserted that CATV systems should retain

flexibility to do as the judge best, in ‘their own circumstarices, that

origination is beyond the mean of many existing systems; and that a

requirement imposed on a reluctant operator might result in token

_ compliance rather than the initiative and experimentation needed to

develop the full potential. . + a

19. After full consideration of the comments, we remain of the view |

that the — interest would be served by conditioning, where prac-

¥ _ ticable, the carriage of broadcast ‘signals upon a requirement for pro-

.* gram origination. It appears to us that this would be the most effective ©

. ._ way to encourage origination. While ‘such a requirement would make

_ =o difference for. those systems who would voluntarily originate in any

- . ewegi it should stimulate origination by systems which would other*

5

i

"~-___ wise not do so.* Moreover, we think it,reasonable to place this condi- .

tion on the carriage of broadcast signals. The use. of broadcast signals

‘has enabled CATV to finance the construction of high capacity cabie

- facilities.” In requiring in return for these uses of radio that CATV

devote a portion of the facilities to providing needed origination

service, we are furthering our statuto responsibility to “encourage

the larger and more effective use of radio in the public interest” (sve.

303 (g).). The requirement will also facilitate the more effective per-

- formance of the Commission’s duty to provide a. fair, efficient, and

. equitable distribution.of television service toeach of the several States —

®It appears from the comments, for example, that one CATV system (717 subscribers) .

4s required by its franchise to originate, and does originate, a su tantial variety of pro-

.grams for approximately 30 hours a-month. A commonly owned system in the same State

+(1.154 subscribers). is under no such requirement and does not originate any programing.-

® Moreover, we have propo the use of .12-GHz freauencies in a local dis ution service

_ to permit CATV systems to achieve economies in construction and to expand their service

aereas. Notice of proposed rulemaking in docket No. 18452 (F.C.C. 69-141). : -

20 F.C.C. 24.

39°

eo nad barv Mae aes 909

"and communities (sec. 307 (b)), in areas where we have been unable

to accomplish this through broedcast media. : a ire .

20. In, addition, the origination requirement will help ensure that

origihatjon facilities are available for use by others originating on

leased channels. We think that this is necessary as a practical matter if

the public is to take advantage.of any common carrier offering on a

widespread basis. It is unlikely that.man would-be lessees would

possess.their own origination equipnient an studio, particularly those

‘ desiring only occasional tise. For example, political candidates cannot.

make effective use of cable faéilities for communication with the public

unless the CATV system has origination equipment and ‘provides

-technigal assistance: In view of the importance of an informed elec- |

". torate and speech concérning public affairs to self-government, the —

“right of the public to receive suitable ‘acvess to. social, political, es-

thetic, mor#l, and other ideas’ aid experiences”, and the CATV. sys-

tem’s monopoly position over cable access to the subscriber’s premises,

we think that CATV operators have an obligation analogous to that .

of the broadcasters “to give suitable time an attention to matters of .

great public concern” and al$o to have the equipment needed for origi-

nation by others. Red: Lion Broadcasting Co. v. Federal Communica-

tions Commission, 395 U.S. 367 ; 389-394. The Commission is not .

a? insist that CATY do’so as a, condition for the use of

roadcast signals, and certainly for the use of microwave ‘radio fre-

- quencies in the conduct of. its business. Moreover, in authorizing the

receipt, forwarding, and delivery of broadcast signals; the Commission

is In effect authorizing CATV to engage in radio communication, and

_ may condition this authorization ut n reasonable requirements gov-

erning activities which are closely related to such radio communication

ee facilities. Sections 2(a), 3(b), and 301 of the Cemmunications

- 21.-While the public interest would be served by origination on as

many systems as possible, and the public need may be greatest in small -

CATV communities lacking local television broadcast media, we recog-

nize the validity of ‘the argument that-origination may be beyond the

means of some systems. The notice specifically requested suggestions

_ 4s to a possiblé eutoff point for mandatory origination in vn go the —

tion. Some of the comments have been -very helpful in this respect,

ton, Some of th and personnél minimal]y necessary for local.origina- -

particularly those of: TeleMation, Inc.; Winchester TV Cable, Ince: ;

Jefferson-Carolina Corp. : Port Huron TV Cable Co.; Chillicothe Tel-

_ com, Inc.; and the filings based on the TeleMation study (e.g., Jerrold

~ pif

Corp.; Buckeye Cablevision, Inc. ; etc.). :

22. TeleMation, :. manufacturer of cablecasting equipment, ap-

* pended as table I to its filing the following summary of estimated costs

of-construction and operation of five cablecasting systems of varying

degrees of sophistication (ranging from a full color system’ with two -

live vidicon cameras and a:mobile van to a minimum monochrome _. .

System in which the weather channel (TM) doubles as a live camera) : 1°

7° TeleMation’s ertimated costs have been used by a number of those filing on behalf of

20 F.C.C. 24

CATV systems, and have not been challenged in the comments of others.

\

. . 7 . . . . ° a ~

: ; boty 7

: 210’ Federal Commumtsatiove ome Reports |

Costs and technicat data*, A

tame | 6 ati ex's

% : ts it . — | .

poY owl . ; Complete Basic , Small . Minimum "

/ Gaal gs chrome hipme chrome, ; ,chrome :

re iss _ system system _ ‘sygem

aa via . pa \ .

/ Television equi bb pees senna S cxdnes $36,000 . $19, 000 $7,900 - 485 .

>, Btudio matt ton.and furnisHings....- 15,000 90005 § 56300 . 1,600 -....... se ee

"Total facilities cost. .L22..!..2.... 96,000 : 455000" - 27,800 9, 500 4, 485

- Anu prinetpal and intrest oh 8-year ,

‘ of amortization. ............. 22; 200 . 10, 610 6, 315 2, 220 1,050

, Operating costs—Annusl labor Awa oS Revewtieng seme basin’ ~

Titres alia Rist ani unsbamunihthontanauhs 4, 400 _ 14, 400° 045. ° 4,720 - 1,000

Technician . ............. pectdnbsaces 10,150 ‘5, 075° - 2, 550 2, 550 500

. cd bitnccapeesneenanowenaces 4, 000 . 3,000 UE nachete vane hiiiernenanentinnns

+ Botel labor >... 2... .cc2e e000 wees 28, 550 .. 22,478 13, 000 . 7, 270 1, 500

F DEAIMAONENGS... Co dcccaccecaccccadene 2,850 - 1,350 . 820 285 “125

. — eee pibdcactacechthveed 826. ; 240 180 » 100. 50

Promotion... ......,..0..-2-----¢-s4--- 1, 200 600 * 300 SEP cbsdvboctaseae

‘Total operating costs—Annual. -. 84925. > 24,665 14, 300 7,905 1, 675 —

‘Total ahnual cost of facilities and ‘ :

Blvejcors Lewscdhbcagasiice 125 35,175 20, 615 10,025 a 2, 725

Number of subscribers needed to sup- a

' port os sithtahiniiatidinnd renee .,. ween “ 730 430 215 55:

Perment of net subseriber .revenue® \ \

riveded to support cablecasting....... “415. . ~916% $17 421% + On

= > .

ta) o> eee $1,285 Incl Includéd ° Included - Included

Message ehvatenheheaenks 535 $340

News and stock channel . ....... 8, 400. 8, 400 8, 400 B,D. .. teense poste

ipepnenicue anh ewennemadas 9, 600 9, 600 6, 000 ©. 6

& - ~~ _eaiinmaaanbermaneedle :

Rake tellin atatermnne dl 470 470 470 * 470 235

otal pther goste—Optional....... 20, 290 19, 006 15, 405. 9, 210 575

Number of " we

T edational cablec A al 425 305 190 *12

Percent: of .net subscriber revenue . ‘ ‘ —

ata se 4 39 3 a 419 $3

s the notes i its analysis of cabcastingcnats set forth above: tah

3 Line Le overhead -pi; d

Ace Semetbe Wetvediin cachet i includes modulators ewe

Se eee

"Ene Siesieoscr non nae over a S-year period of amortiza-

caste were eotimated as follows: ~ :

¥ benefi 35 percent oth Ge a A costs,

7 ha Peau benefs and © & irre as above. 65 j

oa = yt ome month pcs ee time sh a“ perees

oO t ie aan tee is fees than full ~ bah and min ee ies.

: Z baintenance a 8 paca o facili cok Bat Yaar. nn ry rea

" hour, Studio i¢ assumed to be in operation for programing for approximately 3 Tours er day for 9 anys

... “Se ft be ined lon to regular yt ; promotion expenses. on ’

- directly for euch things ss Tranchise See So ee eat) as 2 prea for revenane 8: “|

. per year per subscriber. : . ; ; cw | A

ee

41

CATV fh A Te 211.

_ 23. According to TeleMation, the complete monochromé cablecast-

ing system includes: : oS ; ie

Two live Vidicon cameras with zoom:lenses. a tn ,

’ One film chain with two 16 mm. projectors, one 35 mm. projector and a film chain

‘ camera. =e ; a,

Minimum necessary lighting and audio equipment to produce professional looking

-. * programs ; Bq a s A

EIA-RS 170 standards for video signal. Cameras are of high Quality with 800 to

1,000 lines of horizontal resolution and a signal to noise ratio of

_ db. . nee Mis

‘Two video tape 1-inch helical scan recorders. }.

Fader type switching with preview. —_...

. Screen splitter special effects generator.

Adequate monitoring and test equipment. « ; ,

Control consolé with necessary remote controls and in m system. :

Automatic weather channel (TM) with slides on same ‘:

~~ thousand square feet of studio space at $8 per ene foot plus $1,000

No mobile van is included, but the equipment.is‘designed so that necessary equip- ~

ment for remote cablecasting can be transported satisfactorily in a station

wagon or other company yehicle. . . \ se

-The basis monochromé system includes ;

‘Single live camera with zoom lens. - eth ay

‘One film chain connected to the weather channel (TM) with one 16 mm. film

projector and one 35 mm. film projector. : :

‘Minimum necessary lighting and audio to produce professional lookihg programs.

-EIA-RS 170 standards of video signal. Cameras are of high quality with 800 to

1,000 horizontal resolution and signal to noig® ratio of approximately 50 db.

Two yideo tape 1-inch helical scan recorders. aR a A ie

-Vertical interval switching with preview,

Minimum monitoring equipment. | Bak Nip, ‘em

Automatic weather channel (TM) on same chagnel. :

“— hundred square feet of studio space at $8 per square foot, plus $500 furnish-:

No mobile van is included but equipment is designed so, that equipment can be

satisfactorily transported ina station wagon or other company vehicle for re-

_ mote programing. | ;

‘ ee Vie

The color system is more elaborate than the above two, whereas the :

small and particularly the minimum monochrome systems are much |

*. more modest? : . . ‘ :

24. There is no general consensus in the comments as to an appropri-

_ ate cutoff point for an origination requirement. Micanopy Group

' . state that origination should not be required for — serving fewer

than. 2,000 subscribers, whereas Garden Spot Cable TV Services, Inc.,

asserts that systems,with less than 2,500 subscribers are not in —-

tion to produce meaningful local program origination, Port Huron

ens is reduced in range and of controls.

t (TM) has © pr

her channel rojection slot for rented

* _., projectors, . : ;

Minimum lighting and audio. - i ; }

One video tape 1 helical scan recorder. a

One‘ weather channel (TM) with reduced number of weather ins a

Four hundred egus © feet of atudic t 94 per square foot rbishing cost.

our hu re Space a r re foot as"

The camera and video tape secedder can enaly be transported in an po ony automobile

for remote cablecasting. ;

° 20°F.C.C, 24

_ cannery inany Gres NE (NLT Var PAR NDAD EWE HRT TREAT CNN RR RMR, i eerenr

il a a a

42

212 Federal Communications Commission Reports

TV Cable Co. states that it lost money on origination for 3 yedrs until it.

reached 3,500 subscribers, and is making ‘a modest, profit with 4,900

subscribers."? TeleMation has appended the cablecasting schedule of the °

- CATV system in South Lake Tahoe, Calif. (3,750 subscribers), which

shows a variety of originations for several hours daily, 5 days a week.

Chillicothe Telcom, Inc., asserts that it is not breaking even with 4,700 4

subscribers, but hopes to do so by the end of 1969.** J efferson-Carolina |

Corp. originated on its system in Cheraw, S.C. (population 5,000), on

- * a minimum budget with modest: capital investment and found that

« Operating expenses were entirely defrayed by advertising revenue; yet

its experience was to the contrary in Lumberton (population neers

mately 15,000). Several parties urge that size should not be the only

controlling factor, as smaller communities lacking other local-outlets

may have a greater need for—and give more support to—CATV

origination than larger communities with-other local media and higher.

demands as to quality. It is ‘further asserted that there should be a |

grace period for experimentation before =, requirement becomes

‘effective. Those commenting on behalf of CAT'V interests are in agree-

‘ ment that advertising should be permitted to help support the cost of :

*., origination. ° . ets — is .

95. While ‘some of the parties. have supplied valuable information

concerning their experience with, origination, its cost and the size of. -

the systems involvéd, it is obvious that the systems discussed in the

comments constitute only ‘a small percentage of. the systems now

engaged in origination and may not typical of the norm. Accord- .

. ing to TV Factbook, sertiées volume (1969-1970 edition, No. 39, pp.

363-a to 591-a), approximately 206 CATV systems are currently en-

gaged in program origination (e.g, local live, film, video tape) 2* and

a substantial number of additional\systems = to originate. Of the .

206 systems currently originating, the number of subscribers is ap-

proximately as follows ; ’ .

, P Number of —

Number of subscribers : Hs 7 . systems

. Under 500......-..---------.--+---------------+---- OE RT ae — 18

500-1000 ------------ ee 36

1000-8000 _—__-.---=-.--—-5 2-22 -- ahaa n nen ene 50

~~ SAT LIS ae nee OnE 39

3500-5000 a oa . i ha Anas an ch anenen 24

Over. 5000.- in coemnnte tisitosintmieegisanncensitaesimnainpitinn inate 39

ots Cae | . :

* See also the.September 22, 1969, issue of Broadcasting M azine, p. 46,

concerning a recent NCTA survey on cablecasting and advertising by

¢ - '

% Port Huron originates 5-10 hours of local public service poceraming .< month with

*black and white ——— which cost $55,500. Present annua operating costs (sharing

rsonnel of a television station at little or no cost to the system) are $72,000, not including.

25, worth of services performed by shared he eg ‘Port Huron does not have muc

poe oy — ulpment:; nor is it equipped for color, though its subscribers fre-

- ‘quently as -guc 7 P * ,

is liieothe has been Sriginating 60 hours a month eince 1064, with commercials since

1967. While it was then forced to use broadcast — costing $200,000 illicothe states -

that it could now purthase the same thing'in CATV equipment for $141,500, Annual operat-

ing costs are $106,250 (sharing some regular CATV personnel). Chillicothe competes for

advertising with two local radio stations and a newspaper, an sells in the same manner

as the radio stations —charging $8 pa spot. ; ie .

_ . 4 These 206 systems do not include systems. originating only automated services (such

as time and weather, news ticker, stock ticker, emergency wirnirg system, fire alarm system,

etc.), music, and/or community and public service announcements. Nor does thie figure

— J ae engaged in. origination where the number of subscribers was not

20 F.C.C. 24...

— : ve

:

43

CATV | 5 213.

its members. Except in a few instances, the record contains no data

about origination by these systems and such pertinent matters as the

kinds and amount of origination, equipment used, cost of facilities, ,

annual operating costs, personn

— 8888, Or the response of the public to such origination efforts. —

26. In the circumstances, we have decided not te prescribe a perma-

will prescribe a very liberal standard for required origination, with a

view toward lowering this floor in the further proceedings, should the

data obtained in. rp. ) Q

desirability of such action. The matter thus remains partially an open

one, to be determined finally upon further analysis and experience.

27. The rules set forth in the appendix hereto (see Sec. 74.1111(a)) -

make the origination réquirement applicable to systems with 3,500:

or more subscribers, effective January 1, 1971. This standard appears -

more than reasonable in light of the TeleMation filing,?® our decision

to permit advertising at natural breaks (see pars. 31-38 below), and .

the 1-year grace period. Moreover, it appears that approximately

70 wien of the systems now originating have fewer-than 3,500 sub-

scribers; indeed, about half of-the systems now originating have fewer

than 2,000 subscribers. We recognize that the 3,500 standard will

- encompass only a very. small percentage of existing systems at present

subscriber levels, less than 10 percent.** However, it should cover most

existing and "new systems in the nation’s] r communities where the .

ng : arge

Commission is see to promote a new kind of CATV operation,

based on good reception of local signals, program origination ‘by the -

CATV operator and others, and possibly the provision of additional

- communications services to the public (see Dec, 13 notice, pars. 46,.

60-61).

28. As pointed out in the comnients, smaller communities lacking ©

other local television outlets, or dependent upon only one, have a

greater need for local origination and may give more support to CATV

origination even if conducted on a comparatively modest basis. A

small monochrome system, modest in equipment aed cost, would never-

In

by too in some respects, e.g. 444 percent interest expense and labor costs

16 The tecond reflects the following with respect to. present system size:

2°

Number of subscribers “percent of © systems as of

; , : Systems, 1969 - 1969

om ws 2

FEN si Ansn iris sencancnunandnplauh sun secdoaduiibimussoimacaaseacace 50.0 1, 130°

500-990 - - 2. escecccnseccenetccrcetcsses - 19.5 « 440

SEP CMO tneninenanguacqnedwopuenmocanguentoeheotecesracctcce 8.0 430

PRI a bo won cccncananisnunnennnavesovennavaenencensccecce 7:5 170

SIBOD IID... 5... nnnewrccnnnsenccccsccaceeccacacedeneccccce serene 3.0 70 ©

UGE FIND sini inven nnassornndinnctsenadapencanenemoniccc ne tet, 10 20°

7 100. 0 2, 260

proceedings establish the appropriateness and

. *. aan

so concluding, we have made allowance for the circumstance that TeleMation’s estimate of costs may ;

s

_ 44

214 Federal Communications Commission Reports

theless permit subscribers to view locally produced programing that

otherwise might not be available at all; Jon example, a te between

local political candidates, a talk by the mayor or a local newscast.

It would also afford a television outlet for advertising by local busi-

nessmen, who may have ne interestin- reach ing the b der -area out-

side of their market served by a television broadcast station. Moreover,

_ the equipment of the small system (camera and video tape recorder)

can be transported in an ordinary automobile.for remote cablecasting.

- The circumstance that so many systems with fewer than 3,500 sub-

scribers (approximately’ 140) have voluntarily undertaken at least

some. origination and a substantial number of others plan to do $0,

‘seems: to indicate a fairly widespread industry belief that origination

by comparatively small systems ia" deonible. Winco any effort in that

direetion is very important in the public inte we urge cable opera-

tors, as does NCTA, to do whatever they can to help satisfy this need.

However, until more information is obtained in the further proceed-

ings, we think that origination by snfaller systerns should continue to’

develop on.a voluntary basis... ~ ae

29. Clarification has. been requested as to the meaning of the phrase.

“operate to a significant extent as a local outlet by originating” (par.

15 of the notice). By significant extent we mean something more than

the rs aggre of automated services (such as time and weather, —

_ news ticker, stock ticker, etc.) and, aural services (such as music and

announcements). Since one of the purposes of the origination require-

ment is to insure that-cablecasting equipment will be available for

use by others originating on common carrier channels, “operation to a

significant. extent as > incall outlet” in essence necessitates that the

CATV operator have some kind of video cablecasting system for the

production of local live and rye oa \ pepgraming (e.g., @ camera and :-

a video tape recorder, etc.). If the cablecasting equipment and tech-

nical personnel are available, there should be a natural tendency for

the OATV operator to use them for some origination presenting local

personages and events. However, as earlier indicated, we do not mean -

- to suggest that origination to a significant extenttould not also include

films and tapes produced by others,’’ and CATV network Programing.

30. We will refrain from any initial regulation relating to the _

hours of origination, categories of pro, ing, the type of cable-

casting equipment, and technical standards. in the

comments, it appears appropriate to afford a period for free experi- -

mentation and innovation by the cable operators. Should it ultimately

- turn out that some requirements are necessary (¢.g., equipment, tech-

nical standards, minimum hours of operation), we are in accord with

the further estion in the comments that it would be reasonable to:

expect more of larger systems than small ones.'* Moreover, we would

11 We noté that TeleMation has appended as exhibit C information about films produced °

by Interpet Productions, Inc., of oun Beach, Calif., for CATV s ms in southern

Hf>rnia. TeleMat‘on states that such programs are geared to cable audiences,-having

been designed to supplement the programing fare available on television broadcast stations.

- The record further indicates that programs produced by-other ‘such organizations are avail-

able to CATV systems, e.g. American Diversified ee. Tenn. ; Leeder Cable

a ices, Ine. -Y.; Programming Corp. of America, Houston, Tex. ; Gridtronics,

Inc., New York, N.Y., étc. . zs ve Lae es ers °

* However, TV Factbook indicates that some smaller systems apparently do more hours

of iocal live origination than some of the larger systems. pnoes .

20 F.C.C. 24+ * ao bere \

- ™ nite ' ' ‘ erro

45

CATV 3 7 215

anticipate that any requirements might be quite liberal at-the outset ..

until the origination operations have had a reasonable opportunity to -

become established, as in the case of television broadcasting where the

required minimum. hours of operation are very small for the initial

18 months and ually increase during four successive 6-month’peri-

ods (sec. 73.651 (a) of the Commission’s rules). 3 7

. 91. Economic basis.—After consideration of the comments, we have

_ concluded that advertising should be permitted at natural breaks in.

originations with no interruption of program continuity. It appears

that advertising support (or some other revenue besides regular sub-

scriber fees) may be necessary to contribute to the financing of local

origination in some communities, ineview of what the record reveals

as to the cost of origination equipment and operating expenses.’ More-

over, advertising support may enable.origination operations by smaller.

systems in smaller communities than would otherwise bé the case,”

ere is also indication in the record (e.g.. the comments of the De-

— of Justice ; those filed on behalf of Jerrold Corp. and others;

eco, Inc.;, Wheeling Antenna Co., and the American Association

of Advertising Agencies) that some advertisers need additional tele-

vision outlets, particularly those interested in reaching. the limited -

“audience pear by a CAT'V system as compared to the much larger

audience within the grade B contour of a teheviehein terehdanss station.

32. There are, of course, other consideratioris which must be weighed. -

The American Civil Liberties Union asserts that advertising on CATV

origination would.subject CATV to the ‘same motivation as the broad-

caster to present programing designed to attract the largest possible

audience. Hence, in order to encourage Pegeer J for minority au-

diences, it is urged that advertising should be prohibited, and that any

- additional financial base to support the costs of origination should be

_ Obtained from additional charges to subscribers viewing the originated

. programs. While this is one of the alternatives proposed in the notice,

we think that considerations of practical necessity dictate a different

course. Some systems in areas where the need for local origination is

. greatest simply may not have enough subscribers to support the costs

of cablecasting equipment and personnel, even if basic: fees are in-

creased or per program fees are charge Moreover, larger systems in

‘ larger communities may be faced wit. higher origination costs. There.

are important Sang benefits to be gained from having cablecasting

equipment available on as many systems as ible for local produc-

- tion of by the CATV operator and others. In our judgment,

these benefits are more likely to be realized on a widespread basis at

an early date if we, permit advertising at natural breaks than if we

insist upon a mode of operation that may be more difficult and take

longer to achieve. .- | Rares Bas Ce ae

- However, we will leave open the question of whether advertisi

should be permitted in conjunction with possible eventual CATV net.

1® Despite the. claimed importance of distant signals to cable operations in major markets,

all of the CATV comments addressing thig, question claim that subscriber fees alone cannot

support origination, and that advertising enue fs necessary. i :

Tt is asserted {n some of the comments that advertising should not be tted for

the. pu of encouraging origination as there is no. guaranty that the CATV operator

would devote the Bann to origination. We do not regard this as sufficient reason for

depriving CATV access to advertising revenue, rticularly in view of our decision to

require origination as a condition for carriage of broadcast signals on larger systems.

‘ _ 20 FCC. 24

$0 cmexvenen SRE EEC RRR ORTH coe omen ipanne eenes : ney . mi

46

@

216 - Fedzral- Communications Commission Reports _

work operations. A broad subscriber base might enablé the production

and distribution of programing financed solely through ‘subscriber

fees. Indeed, CATV systems originating locally. in this manner.may

find some competitive advantage in attracting viewers, particularly in *

- . the Nation’s larger cities. Seo Midwest Television, Inc., 18 F.C.C. |

’ 478, 506, footnete 29. CATV: operators are, of course, free-to origin

without commercials if they c to do so and to experiment in this

area. While we believe that the subscribing public should not be re-

quired.to pay extra fees in order to obtain access to local public service

programing: or presentations by political candidates on' the CATV’s

origination channel, we do not presently contemplate any prohibition

' against higher monthly fees or per program charges for other minority

interest programing, or special charges for other extra services ( e.g,

burglar alarm and fire detection systems, etc.). In short, here again is

| an area requiring further study and possible future action only in the

_ light of such study and experience.. ate wall

34. The potential impact of CATV advertising on television and ._

radio stations in small markets, and on new indépendent stations in

large markets, is also pertinent. The notice specifically requested the

40 ies to address themselves to varying situations in light of the

local broadcast. media, and sought information as to the nature and

effect of existing advertising by CATV systems, including the rates -

charged and the kinds of advertisers attracted. While many of the -

comments on behalf of broadcast interests seek a prohibition against

commercials on adverse impact grounds, their assértions are phrased

. In general terms and do not provide specific information or address

' varying situations. However, a few of the CATV comments do contain

- some information as to existing rates. ;

35. Chillicothe Telcom, Inc., which competes for advertising with~

. two local radio stations and a newspaper, cha $3 per » th

‘same rate as the radio station’.: Winchester TV Cable

hourly rate, and finds that.sometimes advertisers will purchase time

only if its commonly owned AM station, with its larger cove is

- included in the package. TeleMation asserts that the cost of CATV

advertising generally ranges between 35 and 200 percent of. the local

AM radio rate. It appends whet it regards as the fairly typical rate

card of a system with fewer than 1,500 subscribers in Neosho, Mo. °

(population 7,452), which reflects the following:

Movie schedule sponsorship : “ :

During periods available (when no local origination or educational channel

broadcasts) exclusive sponsorship of the channel 9 (origination) movie

schedule: $100 monthly. - etree Ae

‘Profile sponsorship (Monday through Friday schedule): ~

CO NRT See $100 monthly.

Local sports, 4 minutes. incions Do.

Local weather, 4 minutes - Do.

Local featurette, ‘4 minutes____-_....-.-..____._______ Do.

= INCI, Ik MeN isha sthsiicesigceesciids tisaa Do.

1-minute announcement-_-_- ate orice, ae

15-minute, 1 time: specials_____ -@ $50 each.

;30-minute,-1 time specials : ---. $100 each.

‘College basketball : ; . , vy gee

Away from home games (14 games, November through : a

* . Mareh, participation with other sponsors) _._..__=_._____ $60 monthly.

. 20 FCC. 2a °° * _ . °

, Inc., has a $50

ea ea a ne ee ee

an

47

CATV _ aes - »« QT

‘ a4

24 Hour weather channel service: ~ , “n

Trademark or name on any 1 instrument_ $25 menthiy.

‘1 slide on Carrosel saphena fie tists nnunticlanapicnnismintis ws. $15 monthly. .

2 slides on SA ceri sien ninnn crnas dates inblovdint esis $25 monthly.

OD Oi CN i i ii ee ici wi $40 nionthly.

Sponsorship of weather forecast, exclusively (exposure on |

each sweep of camera’) facie etn cunsemniaes --- $150 monthly.

All contracts on’ 13-week minimum, with 10 percent dis-

count for 12-month contracts. __ — cen

TeleMation further sttes that the advertising rates vary from system

to system, and by way of illustration attaches the rate cards of systems.

m Peru, Ill., and-Gallup, N. Mex.24 : ore, es sk

36. Whileadvertising rates var considerably among television and

radio stations, it appears to us that existing CATV rates are much

mere agalogous to typical radio rates than they are to those of tele-'

vision stations generally, or UHF independents in particular. It would

seem to follow that CAT'V advertising on comparatively small systems,

poses a greater possibility of adverse impact on the revenues of radio

stations than on those of television stations, This situation obviously:

could change with the advent of larger systems in larger communities:

For the presént, we do not think that there is any threat to broadcast

service to the public of- sufficient immediacy to warrant a general

rohibition on CATV ‘advertising, or to outweigh the considerations

iscussed above. (par. 31; see Bd our action below limiting such .

CATY advertising to natural- breaks). However, we will examine doc-

- umented claims of imminent adverse impact on the public’s free broad- ’

cast service on a case-by-case basis, and take such action as. may be |

warranted. | 3 one . oS .

“37. In paragraph 17 of the notice the Commission requested com-

ment on the alternative of permitting CATV advertising only at nat-

3 The Peru rate card is as follows: __ : ' f°

Per week - .

1 5 10 06=— lo tC

cements: : :

. Class I (5 p.m. to-12 p.m.)_____...-....- OO eee... ..,4.. $12.00 $9.60 $8.40 $7.80 $7.20

30 eee... 2.2... 9.00 7.2 630 5.85 540.

Class II (9 a.m. to 5p.m,)______.....__. ace, 9.60. 7.68 6.72 6.24 5.76

30 see... ....... 7.20 5.80 - 5.04 4.68 432

Number of times i

1 B % ‘n°

Lotel preyreming: . . es

Class I (5 p.m. to 12_p.m.)___.._.__- joe BR ven coxpncinckecs $75.00 $64.75 $60.00 $56.25

@ sear - 45.00 38.25 ~ 36.00 33.75

| alee 35.00 29.75 28.00 26.75

: PU elk sien icc oe 25.00 22.25 20.00 18.75

; 3 15.00 - 12.75 12.00 11. 25

Class II (9 a.m: to p.m.)____.___...__. 5 ae RT Re ve 60.00 \51.00 48.00 45.60 -

+ | ~eanecetannaeneennes 36.00 31.60 28.80 27.00

‘ __ ROSTER ' 23.00 23.80 -22.40 21.00

od... ROR 20.00 17:00 16.00 15. 00

ind eae ae 12.60 10.20 9.60 9. 00

Note.—Costs video tape advertisement production to be charged to advertisers.

~ Above rates based on normal programing costs. . o

Y

446-252 0-71 -4 wrecat rang ensnsnanaen ro SN I

. U.S. 204, 266,

. under the first amendment, as reflec

48

218 Federal Communications ‘Commission Reports

ural breaks without interruption of program continuity.*? TeleMa-

tion states ‘that it would not oppose reasonable regulations upon the

av of commercials. The Perinsylvania Community Antenna —

elevision Association reports that some of its members have.expressed

the opinion that the so-called magazine format might be more effective

- than ree | commercials throughout the program material.

ATV 0

Individual | perators ee origination have indicated

similar views to'us upon occasion.- Those parties _— claim prin- -

cipally that the Commission has no authority to regulate the placement

of commercials, and, in any event, sicula treat broadcasters .and

CATV systems alike insofar as advertising isconcerned. _-

38. We are not persuaded by the equal treatment argument. One —

service depends solely on advertising revenue, whereas the other has

_ available subscriber fees as well. Moreover, since CATV origination .

has its base in the carriage of broadcast signals, the Commission has

both the power’and the responsibility to see to it that such hybrid op-

erations do not undercut, but rather promote, our regulatory policies in

the. broadcasting field, in this instance the policy of encouraging new

and diversifiéd service to the public without sg awe of other exist-

ing service. We believe that a rule. requiring the placement of adver-

tising at natural breaks in CATV originated material will best further’ .

this objective and would serve the public interest, for: (1) it would ©

- permit CATV to derive additional revenue to help defray the costs,of |

origination ; ** (2) it would provide the public with a new typeof serv-

ice—one where commercials did not interrupt program material at the.

‘whim of the cablecaster; (3) it would afford advertisers a new and

different type of outlet in terms of size and selectivity of audience, as”

compared to radio and television stations and printed media; and (4)

it would be less apt to affect the advertising revenue available to local

broadcast services to the same degree that the alternative of unlimited

CATV commercials might. We conclude that the rule adopted herein.

(see sec. 74.1117 in thé appendix) is reasonabl ancilliary to the effec-

tive performance of our res ibilities for the regulation of broad-

casting, and is within the Commission’s statutory and constitutional]

authority. United States v. Southwestern Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157; Mid-

+» west Television, Inc.,13 F.C.C. 2d 478, 504-505; 15 F.C.C. 2d 84, 91; —

see also discussion, infra, pp. 28-32.

B. Equal time, sponsorship identification, fairness

39. in patagrephe 19-20 of the notice, the Commission proposed to

adopt

‘_ 3 We will consider in the further proceedings the pee of whether a peterneng J should

services stem 2

casting as defined different eae be mabe ton ater:

, and w some n sho ‘or adver-

any, in connection with se of this nature.” :

sad . American Press Co., 297 U.8. 233, and New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 -

8. which several parties rely, are distinguishable. A regulation as to the

placement of C ME ey ome Dey or the reasons set forth above, is not comparable to a

‘deliberate and cal ted device in the guise of a tax to limit the circulation of information —

to which the public is entitied in virtue of the constitutional guarantees,” which the

Supreme Court found bad in Grosjean. Nor does our regulation in any way go to thé con-

tent of the commercials, or infringe As 9 the prot fon accorded to editorial advertising

in the New York:Times Co. case. 2

20 F.C.C. 2d

7

' fairness, and sponsorshi

- conjunction ‘with carriage of broadcast signals. See

- carriage of broadcast signals upon reasonable ee :

_ CATV por origination, was rejected in Midwest 7. ae i:

49

systems engaged in pfogram origination upon a requirement that such

origination be condu i

broadcasts by candidates for public office; a

CATV “219

in accordance with the following conditions: —

(a) A rule condition analogous to section 315 of the Communica- .

,tions Act and section’ 73.657 of the Commission’s: rules concerning -.

(5) A rule condition analogous to section-317 of the Communica- -

_ tions Act and section 73.654 of the Commission’s rules concerning

announcement of sponsored programs; and _— | +

(c) = rule condition analogous to the otantinn referred to in sec-

tion 315(a) of the Comniunications Act and the rules promulgated

thereunder, to afford reasonable. opportunity for the discussion of con-

°

flicting views on issues of public importance. |

Ip view of our determination not to prohibit, but rather encourage,

CATV origination, and to permit’ advertising, we have decided to

adopt the rules set forth in the appendix with respect to equal tim

identification. We believe that these. aca th

paragraphs 40-47

below. . eee ;

_ 40. Despite some challenge to our jurisdiction to impose any require-

_. Ments on CATV origination, there was general unanimity .in. the.

comments that, if origination is to be permitted, it would. be desirable

in the: public interest for CATV to afford equal time to politi

eandidates and reasonable opportunity for discussion of = s

ost o

views on issues of public importance, and to identify sporisors. M

the comments on behalf of CATV interests indicated that they would

have no objection to conducting.their orgination in this manner, and

most broadcaster comments urged that they should be required to do

so, assiming Commission jurisdiction. The comments of ind@endent

entities, such as the American Civil Liberties Union and thg city of

‘New York, also were in favor jf equal time and fairness ents.

‘We think there is no real question but that CATV origination in con-

junction with the carriage of| broadcast. signals should comport with .

these cardinal policies of the Communications Act, which are- so

. important to the American political system and an informed electorate.

Red Lion Broadcasting Co., Inc. v. Federal Communications Com-

- mission, 395 U.S. 367. We shall therefore turn to the basis-for our

conclusion that we have —— to adopt the appended rules,

which provide that no CATV system shall.carry any broadcasting

- signal-if the system engages in cablecasting unléss such es

conducted in accordance with‘ equal time, fairness, and sponsorship

identification requirements patterned after those applicable to broad-

41. The contention that the Commission lacks authority under the |

Communications Act and the first @fneridment to condition CATV’s.

o

Ine, 13 F.C.C.-2d 478, 504-505, and in our opihion denying recon-

ments are necessary in the public interest for a conducted in .

aS

* The rules adopted herein are in some ts simpler than those governing broadcasters. :

* “Should they ve yon conan the Co om can, of course, take appropriate rulemaking -

actjon to modify or supplement these rules- in light of experience. ‘. a |

ok nes eee o 20 F.C.C. 24 |

a porecatrcnmasactreco rama tele arson ONE E YRTIOEA LOY SI NC = Sa nw Ser PS stalls tant GRAAL AE ol

50.

220 | Federal Communications Commission Reports. /.

sideration, 15 F.C.C. 2d 84, 91, on grounds which are equally per-

tinent here. Moreover, the rules set forth in the appendix hereto come

within the jurisdictional standard set forth by the Supreme Court in’

the Southwestern case supra. Ie plearly necessary*to the effective

fag@ance of, our responsibilities for the regulation of television

deasting that we require CATV systems engaged in program

'. origination to abide by the same equal.time and fairness requirements

applicable to broadcasters. The Commission’s responsibility for carry-

ing out the provisions of section 315 of. the ommunications Act

(s@t.315(c)) would be largely thwarted if unequal opportunities were

‘a ed on CATV origination channels. For example, the, CATV

subscriker might ‘tune Kis television set to. channel 2, a broadcast

channel granting equal time to candidates A- and B, and then switch

to channel 3, a CATV origination channel presenting only candidate A.

‘Conceivably, the broadcaster might afford candidates A and B one-

‘ half hour each, on 1 day on channel2, and the CATV operator might

present only candidate. A for several hours for.a number of days on

channel 3. Or. following the one-half hour appearances of candidates

_A and B on broadcast channel 2, the CATV operator might present.

only candidate A forthe next 3.hours on the same channel in place of

broadcast program material deleted pursuant to the Commission's ~

nonduplication rules (sec. 74.1

the Midwest decision, supra. . _ eee ‘

_42. Similarly, the requirement that. broadcasters présent, both sides

of controversial issues of public importance—an ‘obligation inherent ~

‘In the public interest standard and properly imposed on broadcasters

-by the Commission to implement congressional policy (Red Lion

. Broadcasting Co., Inc v: Federal Communications Commission, 395

U.S. 367, 379-386), would be grossly circumvented if the CATV sub-

scriber receives both sides when he funes his television set to a broad-

cast channel at a time when broadcast program material is being pre-

sented but only one side when he switches to a CATV origination

channel or stays tuned to the broadcast channel at a time when CATV .

origination has been substituted for deleted broadcast material. -

43. We think that similar considerations necessitate CATV com-

pliance with the legislative policy reflected in section 317 of the Com-

munications Act, which recognizes that ‘sponsorship identification is

- essential to an es ee te again, our me, requiring such

announcements by broadcasters would be substantially undercut if

CATV originated material presented in conjunction with broadcast

_ Signals failed‘to revea] that the CATV operator had. received money, _

_ Service or other valuable consideration for presenting such material |

(og, a controversial issue program without divulgence of the amity

103 (e) and (f)). See footnote 26 of

seeking to persuade the public). aia

44. We could not, consistent with our statutory responsibilities,

"permit a CATV operator to place broadcast signals in @ setting of in-

equality, unfairness, and hidden sponsorship which would destroy the

_ signals’ integrity and defeat the. purposes of the obligations-imposed

"on broadcasters in the public interest.?* Our statutory authority over

* We ‘wish to make clear that we do‘ not impute such undestrable practices to the. cable

“industry. Indeed, to the best of our o> the systems which originate programing « »

have attempted to treat political candidates and controversial issues fair y.

. ‘20 F.C.C. 2d r . os e ‘ * . 7

tase Magee aot

: power to prohibit CATV systems from carrying broadcast —

t

-tion o

4(i), 801, 303, 307, 308, 309, 315, and 317 of the Communications Act. |

Ch W rather-Alvarez Broadcasting, Inc. v. Federal Communications. |

foreign communication by. wire or

The Commission’s responsibilities are no more narrow: it is required -

to endéavor to “make available * * * to all the Kags of the United —

: e wire:and radio -

communication service * * *.” 47 U.S.C. § 151. The Commission was ex- .

‘munication, whe

munity antenna television systems, but it seems

‘ signals to t

3 | LG

| : FMIM Sse Gig ae

interstate communication’ by: whos nits ‘esiimaain encompites

conjunction with CATV origination that does not afford equ

public importance or reveal program sponsorship. The CATV opera-

tor may conduct his origination in such fashion if he chooses te do so on

a system carrying no broadcast signals. But we cannot’ it the

carriage of broadcast signals under circumstances so patently contrary

to the — interest. We conclude that statutory authority for adop-

the rules in the appendix hereto is contained in sections ,2, 3, :

Commission, 248 F: 2d 646 (C.A.D.C., 1957).

45. We believe that for the reasons developec (supra, pars. 41-44)

our action in this respect is “reasonably anci ary to the effective per-

formance of the Commission’s various ee rpm oma for the -

tion of television broadcasting” (United States v. Southwestern Cable -

Co., Supra, at p. 178). We would also note that Southwestern empha- °

sized the breadth of the Commission’s regulatory power: * ,

The Act’s provisions are explicitly applicable to “all interstate and

i Me. *.* *.” 47 U.S. § 152(a).

States a rapid, efficient, Nation-wide and world-wi

pane to serve as the “single Government agengy” with “unified juris-

iction” and Pa cog authority over all fens of electrical com-

ther by tele hone, telegra h, cable, or radio.” It was

for this purpose given Satie’: authority.” ie this Court emphasized in

an earlier case, the Act’s terms, purposes and ‘history all indicate that .

Conan “formulated -a unified and comprehensive pais system

or the industry:” ¥.0.C. v. Pottsville Broadcasting Co

137. (Footnotes omitted.) Id. 167-168. ae

* Elsewhere the decision states (id. 172-178): Ae

Certainly Congress could not in 1984 have fo

nm the development of com-

s that it was precisely -be-

te administrative control

F.C.C. v. Pottsville Broad-

that it conferred upon the

cause Congress wishes “to maintain, through app

a grip on the dynamic aspects of radio transmissio

casting Co., supra, 309 U.S. at 138, 60 S. Ct. at.

Commission a “unified jurisdiction” and “broad authority.” Thus “Cujnderlyjng- —

the whole [Communications Act] is recognition of the rapidly fluctuating factérs

characteristic of the evolution of broadcasting and of the corresponding require-. *

ment that the administrative process possess sufficient flexibility to adjust-itself

to these factors.” F.C.C. v. Pottsville Broadcasting Co., supra, at 138° Congress in

1934 acted in a field that was demonstrably “both new and dynanite,” and it there-

fore gave the Commission “a comprehensive mandate,” with “not niggardly but -

expansive powers.” National Broadcasting Co. v. United States; 319 U.S. 190, -.

219. We have found no reason to believe that §.152 ‘does not, as its terms sug-

. est, confer regulatory authority over “all interstate * * * communication gee

‘ wire or radio.” (Footnotes omitted.) = - - ris

_ 46. Assuming statutory authority, we think that the claim of first

amendment abridgment is clearly without merit. As stated in Mid-

‘west, supra, no one has a first amendment right to providé broadcast |

he public in a manner contrary to the publio-interest (15.

20. F:C.C. 2d -

i.

imeto > __

political candidates or present both sides of controversial issues of "=

., 809 U.S. 134,

~~

‘

" ee ee NOLS LONE ENE LOT FEE LEE LLL IER MO NE IIE

7 i 2 ‘

. .

"292 ~~ Federal Communications Commission Reports

F.C.C32d at. 91). Nor does the binegenabitnds that CATV pro aura

~\. origination may be économically dependentapon carriagé of broa

Mpeg ve rise to an indirect infringement pf first amendment ater

Since systems use broadcast signals as the backboné of the. serv-—

ice they theyscomé within the regulation of this agency, if

; reasonabty selaned to ublie interest, If the regulation is so related,

it is not boared by the first ent "(see above discussion ; VBC v.

~ U.S:, 319 U.S. 190).2" "The above regulations are clearly reasonably

: related to the public interest. Far from being inconsisent with the first _

amendment—which is of course one of the most crucial aspects of the

public intenest—the regulations promote the Thine of. the first

amendment. “As the sip aoe Court stated i in Re Liort, supra, 395 U.S

at 390:

- It is the purpose of ihe First Atnendment to preserve an satan farket-

| place of ‘ideas in which truth will ultimately prevail, rather than to countenance

monopolization of that markét, whethér it be .by the Government: itself or a

private licensee. Associated Prese.v. United States,,326 U.S.°1, 20 (1945) ; New

.York Times Co: v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254, 270 (1964) ; Abrams v. United States,

250 U.S. 616, 630 (1919) (Holmes, J., dissenting). “CS ]peech concerning public |

:* affairs is more than self-expression ; it is the essence of self- $ Sige ne Garri-

son v. Louisiana, 379 U.S. 64, 74-75 (1964). See Brennan, The Supreme Court

‘ and the Meiklejohn Interpretation of the First Amendment, 79 Harv. L. Rev. 1

(1965). It is.the right of fhe public.to receive suitable access to social, political,

esthetic, moral, and other ideas and experiences which is crucial here. That

right may not constitutionally be abridged either by Congress or by the, FCC. .

Ras In Arg that the equal time and fairness requirements on

rs are consistent with the purposes of the first amendment

ere reasons which also seem equally applicable to Origine

ten . CATV ‘Operator (395 U.S.. at 392) : '

Nor ean we say ‘that it is ‘inconsistent - with: the First Aeiteaiek goa pt

. producing an informed public capable of conducting. its own affairs to require

a broadcaster to permit answe personnel attacks, occurring in the course of

‘discussing controversial issues, or’fo require that the-political opponents of those

endorsed, by the station be given ‘a chance to. communicate with the public.

~ . [Footnote omitted.] Otherwise,’station owners and a few networks. would have

unfettered: ‘power to make time availablé only to the highest bidders,-to com-

munieate only their own views on public issues, people and candidates, and to

permit on the air only those with whom they agreed. There is no sanctuary in

the First Amendment’ for unlimited ‘private censorship operating fn a medium .

not open. to all. “Freedom of the prese from governmental interference under

the First Amendment does not ‘sanction repression-of that freedom. by “arate

interests.” Associated Press v,U.S.,326 U.S. 4, 20 (1944). :

We see no indirect infringement of first amendment rights i in. the

‘rules adopted. herein. : Le

. ae CONCLUSION a?

48. In light’ of the fore regoing, we conclude that the public i ifiterest

would ‘be served: by y adaption of the rules set forth in the ae

_ hereto, effective 30.d A pabticntion of this order i in the ederal

_ It is th immaterial that the reity of encies bes preoe

py dy pt gig also unneceeea sae ree et es ‘n view

operations B Te ne monopolistic basis in

a Ele oats of: = are bubwerbes te

ae roo. 2a o

_=

SAUNA ROROREI NG ER ILE RIED NO EAE GTEC ELE EINE IGE *

nase wen ,

_

s

f

3. Se te

digs yg NS Ts . CATV + x a gs

|

>

a RegisterUpon such entry in force, we point out State or’ local.

regulations or conditions inconsistent with these F y ny

_«, policies are, we believe, preempted. Se Head v. New Mexico, 3140S.

= 424 (1963).?* Authorit} for such rules aré contained in sections 2, 3,

_ 4-(i) and (j), 301, 3038, 307; 308, 309, 315, and 317 of the Communica-

tions Aci e further conclude that a final determination on the other

as

Subject of a er report and order,

pendix hereto Are adopted, effective December 1, 1969, and the Com-

he proposed rulemaking discussed herein should be the

» ab dened Mado at the rules set forth in the ap-

mission retains. full j ction over all other aspects of this

proceeding... — | : oan

7 _ Fepera, Communications Commission -

.° PPENDIX ea

Part 74, subpart K, is amended as follows : J

, 1. In section 74.1101, new paragraphs (j)

_ °° §74.1101 Definitions. ae

(kk) are added as follows:” ’

5

(j) Cablecasting. The term’“cablecasting”

programming

* "a CATY system, which has been originated by, the OATV operator or by another

entity, exclusive of broadcast signals ed on the syst

(k) Legally qualified candidate. The term “legally qualified candidate” means

auly person who has publicly announced that he is.a candidate for nomination by

' & convention of a political»party or for momination or election in a primary,

special, or general election, municipal, county, state or national, and who meets\

the qualifications prescribed by the applicable laws to hold the office for which

#\\ .

he is a candidate, so that he may be voted for by the electorate directly or by -

° means of delegates or electors, and who: :

(1) Has qualified for a place on the ballot, or oa.

(2) Is eligible under the applicable law to be voted for by sticker, by writ-

his name on the ballot, or other method, and (i) has deen duly nomina

by a political party which is commonly known and regarded as such, or (ii) .

nomination

makeg.a substantial showing that he is a bona fide candidate for

je m aN . sai

_ 2 Anew section 74.1111 is added to read as follows : ‘ :

‘$ 74.1111 Cablecasting in conjunction with carriage of broadcast signals.

$ 74.1118 Cadleoaste by candidates for public office.

e > , . ‘ ‘

° : Q

"224 Fs ederal Communications Coley

’ cablecast by aliy such candidate ; And sida fu he , That an one by a

legally qualified candidate on any’: og. Cepeh:

(1) bona fide newscast, Ris ey ‘ ey

(2) bona fide news. .interyjew, . a.

(3) bong fide news docunientary (if the appearance of the candidate i

cidental to the name of the subject or Subjects cqyered by the news

documentary), or :

(4) on-the-spot’ coverage. of bona: fide: news events (including but not lim-

ited to Politica conventions and activities incidental thereto),

shall not,be deemed to be use of the facilities of the system within the meaning

* Henle paragraph

Yore.—The - fairness doctrine is applicable to these exempt categories. See

§ 74.1115. ,

(b) “Rates and practices. fe ,

(1) The rates, if any, chatged all eres candidates for the same Office shall ;

be uniform, shall not be rebated by any means direct or indirect, and shall

not exceed the charges made for comparable use of such. es for. other

purposes.

bho In making facilities ‘available to candidates for public office no CATV

shall make any discrimination between candidates in charges, prac-

: 1 regulations, facilities, or services for or in connection. with the service

rendered, or make or give any preference to any candidate for public office or .

subject any such candidate to any prejudice or disadvantage; nor shall any

. CATV system make any contract or other agreement which shalk have’the .

effect of permitting anf l«gally qualified candidate for any public office to

cablecast to the exclusion of othér legally qualified cahdidates for the same

’ public office.

(c) Records, inspections. Every CATV. system shall keep ‘and permit public

inspection of a complete record of all requests for cablecasting time fnade by or on

behalf of candidates for public office, together with an appropriate notation shew- .

ing the disposition made by the system of such requests, and the charges made, if

any, if the request is granted. Such records Shall be retained fora ‘period of two

years.

(d) Ttme of Beate A request‘for equal opportunities must be submitted to

the-CATV system within-one_week of the day on which the prior use occurred.

(e). Burdew of proof. A candidate requesting such equal opportunities of the

€ATV system, or complainitg of noncompliance to the Commission, shall have

the no sam of proving that he .and hi’. opponent\are legally qualified candidates

for th®same public office. 2

'" 4 Anew section 74.1115 is added to ‘read-as follows:

§ 74.1115. Fairness Doctrine ; Pérsonal attacks; Political. sieeram %

(a) A CATV system engaging in cabléecasting shail afford reasonable op-

portunity for the discussion of conflicting..views on ‘issues of public importance.

- Note.—See Public Notice : Applicability of the Fairness Doctrine in: the Han-

dling of Controversial Issues of Public Importance, 29 Fed. Reg. 1041%

- (b)° When, during the presentation-of views on a controversial issue of public

importance, an attack is made upon the honesty, character, integrity. or like per-

~—senal qualities of an identified person or up, the CATV system shall, within -

-a reasonable time and in no event later one week after the attack, transmit

to the persun or grofip attacked (1) notifieation_of the date, time and ‘idenitifica-

tiori of the cablecast; (2) a script or‘tape (or an accura’

urate Summary-if a script

or tape is not available) ‘of the attack; ahd (3) an offer of a reasonable oppor-.

tunity to respond over the system’s facilities.

(c) The provisions of paragraph .(b) of this section shall not be applicable

(1) to attacks on foreign groups.or foreign public’ figures; (2) to personal at-

tacks ‘which are made, by. legally. qualified candidates, their authorized spokes-

men, or those -with them'in the campaign, on other such candidates,

their authorized spoke: , Or persons associated with-tRe candidates in the

campaign; and (3) to bona fide “newscasts, bona fide news interviews, and

on-the-spot coverage of a bona fide- news event (including commentary or ©

. analysis contained in the foregoing. programs, but the provisions of ee

“(by of this section shail’ be applicable to editorials of the — ).

20 F.C.C. 2a.

ON PEI a hag AiR: lieth cette et sven

. ve re

he OMB RE he a 2)

re ee

'. ing; And provided, further, That advertising material-is not presented on or

antes k,: or brand name hevonm ar Hentification »

. J al « 7 - .

o ~ . .

a 7 og . ie 7 . a

WATW Fe a | 205

aay fs . . c ; aos re oie :

(d) Where a pre pe in an editorial,-tI) endorses or (2) ¢ sa ~

legally qualified candidate of candjdates, the system shall, within 24 hours after

the editorial, transmit to respectively (i) the other qualified candidate or candi-

dates for the same .office or (ii) the candidate epposed in the editorial. (a)

notification of the date, time, and ¢hannel of the editorial ; \(b) a script or tape of .

the editorial ; and (c) an offer of a reasonable opportunity for a candidate or a

spokesman of the,candidate to respond ovér the system’s facilitiés; Provided,

- however, That where. such editorials are cablecast within 72 hours prior to the

. day of the election, the system-shall comply with the provisions of this paragraph

sufficiently far in advance of the broadcast to enable the candidate or candidates

-to have a reasonable opportunity to prepare a response and to present it in a

timely fashion. . ee | ;

5. A new section 74.1117 is added té read as follews:. ,

§$ 74.1117 Advertising, - 4 Pape as de Eis ie.

A CATV system éngaged in ¢ blecasting may present advertising material at

the* beginning and conclusion a each cablecast program and ‘at natural inter-

missions or bréaks within a cablecast, Provided’That the system itself does fot

interfupt the presentation of program thaterial in order to intersperse advertis-

in connection with cablecasting in any other manner.

Nore.—The term “natural intermissions or breaks within a cablecast” means.

any natural intermission in the program material which is beyond the control -

of the CATV operator, such as time-out in a sporting event,’ an‘ intermission, in

" a concert or dramatic performance,.a recess in a city council meeting, an in-

* termission in a long motion picture which was present at the time of theatre

exhibition, etc... eS ; : , “

. 6. A new section 74.1119 is added to read as follows

°

§ 74.£119 Sponsorship identification. - ree ae

. (a) When a CATV’ system: engaged in cablecasting presents any matter for

which ‘money, services, or. other valuable consideration. is either y specd or

indirectly. paid or promised to, or charged or ved by, such system, the system

‘shall make an announcement that such matte¥ is sponsored, paid for, or furnished,

either in whole or in part, and by whom or on whose behalf-guch consideration

-was supplied ; Provided, however, That “service or other valuable consideration”

shall not include any service or property furnished without charge or at a

nominal charge for use on, or in connection with, a cablecast unless it is so

furnished for consid on for an identification in a cablecast of any person,

reasonably related ‘to the use of such service or property on the cablecast. .

‘ (b) Each system engaged in cablecasting shall exercise, reasonable diligence

to obtain from its employees, and from other persons with whom it deals diréttly

. in connection with any program matter for cablecasting, information to enable:

it to make.the announcement required by this section. ' ;

* (e) In the case of any political program or any program involving the dis-

_ cussion of public controversial issues for which any fil 8, records, transcriptions, .

~ talent, scripts, or other material or services. of any kind are furnished, either

directly or indirectly, to a CATV system‘as an inducement to the cablecasting of

such ,an announcement to this éffect shall be made at the beginning and

cokcl n of such program ; Provided, however, That only one such announce-

ment need be made in the case of any such program of 5,minvtes’ duration or

less, either at the beginning or conclusion of the program.

(d) The announcements required by this section. are waived with

feature motion picture: films produced initiajly and primarily for theggre

exhibition.

— Concurrtnc SraTeMENT oF ComMMIssIoNER Rostrr T. Barrier

'._ Although thé report and order herein is lengthy, the results are, .

simply, that any CATV 2% ae:

(a) may originate programs without limitation as to number of

chanhels, aid tagiealee January 1, 1971, any system with 3,500 0%

a ey 20 F.0.C. 2a:

BT ad , ae f 2 | | ,

—y es

”

A

-.-

*

\"

\-

226 * Federal Communications Commission Reports s »

more subscribers is pequired to originate programs to a “significant .

(0) may sell advertising present on ngtural breaks or “inter- *

€@ ‘must comply with the eqiial op a and ‘fairness doctrine

: provisions of salon 315 of ct and sponsorship identification .

eo _ Provisions of section 317 of the Act. ee ‘a

I believe that these provisions serve ‘the public interest. However, ~

~ since there are-certain sponsor in the Report and Order with --

which I do not agree, concur only in the result. oe °

DisseNTING SraTeMENT OF Commissioner Roser E. Lfer * te

: “Withou reaching the merits of the order adopted here, I m

ent on a that the complexion of the Commission is

change by ali ong¢third. Our new colleagues will be’ administer.

ft whee important policy matters here — with which they may

or may not. f the; —° ‘they could conceivably reverse

decision which could be a . .

20 F.C.6. 2a \

v

’

: B :

. 4 , ;

e . . ;

, . x : ; ; ; . .

: | : | |

; | : . |

— Pa . . | a

oo <a

, ao ie = ee :

: ‘ . a |

| 9. .

. . . .

¢ . - ; ; a

e

| ; , s a i

. : SF o ’ ; .

- . wi , & | | | _

7 a. — &

SS ee oe : | |

Les 2

: : 3 :

’ - . .

Bes:

° He

ames im scien, — <e Bop or tig er eee FONE ie alee

—

eee el

: CATV 2 ee

ee ae exes Ta FCC. 70-677"

. _ BEFORE THE - ts

. FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION.

° Wagsurneron, D.C. 20554 * pe it

In the Matter of ee

_ AMENDMENT oF Parr.74, Suppart K, or THE)

? .-Commaisston’s Rures anp REGULATIONS

Rewa — To. COMMUNITY : Antenna TExz- me

* \NISION SYSTEMS; AND INQUIRY INTO THE = °

_ + Devetorpment or Communications Txcx-/ Docket No. 18397

_. (NOLOGy AND Services To FormuiatTe Rec-} - ote

-ULATORY Poricy AND “aseaeaarmem sepa : ‘i - '

-

- ,

‘ LxaisLaTIvE PRoposats | .

ne a, . ee Memoranpum Orrnfon ann OrveR -_ : ‘

. (Adopted June 24, 1970; Released July 1, 1970)

Sy

‘By tae Commission’: Commissioners BarRTLEY AND JOHNSON CON- -

CURRING IN PART AND DISS § IN PART AND ISSUING STATEMENT&; sw

. Commisstoners. Cox ase Witenes CONCURRING INVTHE RESULT. Pod

1. We have before us a number’ef petitions for reconsideration of -

our_First-Report and Order herein, released October 27, 1969,°20 -

FCC 2d 201, 34 F.R. 17651. In that decision, following a-Notice of

- Proposed Rule ae ny * and Notice of Inquiry of December 13, 1968

~ (15. FCC 2d 417, 33 F-.R. agers we ddalt with certain-aspects of . —_- -

pegersr vf antenna mtg ry ( ATV ) service. We same tater: : .

. @ public interest w serve program origination (cable- * Heo?

| wr se over CATY systems, and srotptinat adopted a requirement

for such cablecasting after January 1, 1971 by systems with 3,500 or ©

: more subscribers, leaving to furth roceedings the question of

whether the requirement should be satis tgiplicable tosmaller systems. |

We als —— on cablecasts, limited to the beginning +

and end of each program, and to such “natural breaks or intermis-

sions” within pr as are beyond the control of the CATV oper-

ator. We also ina appl

icable to cablecasti uirements similar to

_ those of Sections 315 and 317 of the Communications Act with respect 7

to equal: opportunities for, political candidatés, fairness in the treat-

_, ment of controversial issues of public im rtance, and :sponsorship

identification. Other issues ls by the ber 13, 1968 Notice

(e.g., diversification of eontrol, common carrier operations‘by CATVs, . ”

'. importation of distant signals) were left for subsequent resolution. ae

_ _ 2. The joint petition for reconsideration of Cablecom-General, Inc., om

_' Communications Properties, Inc., Pennsylvania Community Antenna . pe

Television Association, Inc., Service Electric Company and Texas .

CATY Association, Inc. supports the Commission’s objectives of pro-

— soememasiiiadintiadbiainat tie sheet hntaiiaiaiaiabacie , — s

, ro ‘Se. \

: Ras . be oe

R26 _ Federal Communications Commission Reports —

moting multipurpose CATV operation combining: the carriage of..

\-,° broadcast signals, program origmation and common carrier services. -.

* “ ‘However, it urges that a compulsory is aggre requirement, limita- ¢°

tions.tupon advertising, and the possibility of a dual Federa]-State

regulatory system are utidesirable. With respect to the-origination, or

. “cablecasting,” requirement, it is urged that to compel cablecasting by .

systems not adequately prepared to undertake it will not advance the

iciaiesion's aims, but rather will retérd their realization. The peti- .

tion, urges that there is §s-valid basis for assuming that CATV systems -

not Now originating p#ograms do not have'a valid reason for failing

. to. do so; uncertainties over copyright legislation-and state public. ‘.

. Mtility regulation as well) as.economic problems‘related to capital re-

quirements are referred to as possible. obstacles’ to effective cable- - ‘

_. - casting. To force unprepared. systems to undertake cablecasting, it is ~-—

said, will result onty-in poor service and the discouragement (because

_ of fear of future unknown requirements) of cablécasting-by others .,

_ who might otherwise undertake it voluntfrily. The+pleading states

' that a souhd judgment in this area requires further study of tlie costs’ _

of program origination, and that substantial outlays should ‘not be”

required in the face ef so many uncertainties, including the Commis- |

0 a ment that unforeseen impact upon television broadcast -

— ce would be remiedied in some unspecified manner. In sum, it is-

* _ urged that the industry is making substantial strides.in this area upon

a voluntary basis, and that this situation should not be disturbed.?

3, We have carefully considered these contentions, but are not per- ..

_ suaded that either the public or the CATV industry would be better —

- served by deleting the cablecasting requirement: As the petitioners ~

ie blest is no disagreement about the value and importance of:

cablecasting. Since many systems are now originating, the general

feasibility of origination is no longer in doubt, and we believe that we

- adopted ‘a-reasonable cyt-off point in Jimiting the applicability of ou

rule to systems with at least 3,500 subscribers. The First Report an

- Order covers this issue in detail,? including available data on.costs, and ‘

.. the initial rule adopted in that. document is very broad, permitting § «&

at flexibility\in/cablecasting operations. is have been given no °

daf& tending to demonstrate that systems with 3500 subscribers can- .

not cablecast without impairing their financial stability, raising rates

or reducing tke quality of service. We recognize that there are some

uncertainties, but these uncertainties have not prevented the inaugura- . -

tion of cablecasting by many systems.* Innovative arrangements &re

also possible, such as agreements with educational institutions under

which a channel is made available for the use of the school which, with

. its own studio and other facilities, will produce educational, cultural

1The petition is supported by a resolution adopted by The Pennsylvania Community

Antenna Television Association, Inc. making the same B per and. cere ES igs second

‘that if cablecasting is not self-supporting, subscribers must either face increa charges or

poorer service. ;

st — out that 70% of the systems now originating have fewer than 3500

. remedial action service were threatened in a respect inimical to the public _

interest. < ; 2 ie ; 7 9 _— = ‘

28 F.0.0. 24 ary ,

cast: at re ve . : ess wenn ms arene fam — SER ELD EE A

e . « , . —~ . .

: . . ae : ; °. -

as - OO ———

. . not go_

- channel to a-local radio station, which in turn presents its disc wa,

~

and other programi The CATV - course would: be ex jo

ing and other affairs aré covered ome | a

see to it that local

different ‘channel,’ but the costs of origipation to it-would-bé sharply

‘reduced. We do aot see, therefore, 2 a a for

cablecasting should produce less quality ioh than would other-

wise be produced.‘ The rule adopted is-minimal in the light of the —

potentials of cablecasting and, on our own motion,.we are postponing:

the date Dye ‘originations must commence to April 1, 1971, to afford

addition reparation time.

4. Indeed, cognize that there isa question of whether we should

ond the minimal rule and specify a minimuth ngmber of

for local live origination * (as against presenting primarily

_—~film). We adhere to the judgment, set out in par. 30 of the First

. Report—namely, that it is appropriate to afford a period of free ex-

perimentation and innovation by cable operators. However, there is

one deyelopment- which does require consideration. It has come to our.

attention that some cable operators simply lease their origination

shows over this channel for virtually the entire broadcast day. While:

the cable operator.is perfectly free to enter into arrangements with _

local broadcast. stations during the period of experimentation (subject

, of course to. whatever limitations are adopted with respect to cross-

ownership in thig:field—see Notice, par. om 33 F.R. 18977, 19032-33),

the main pur is to provide an outlet for local expression. As we

stated in the part Report, the very existence of. “available facilities

for local pr

is a most important ‘contribution to the public interest, pines it means

that the mayor, the local political oaindidia

However, if the channel is unavailable for such resentation because

it is leased out to a locat broadcast facility for television. presentation

of its*shows, the above purpose is frustrated. We therefore have,

amended ‘74.1111(a) to make clear that the CATV may not.enter into

Sabie fe alra bar. sean) which inhibits or prevents the substantial use of the

7 le facilities for local programing designed to inform the public

* on.issues of ‘public importance.

5. Finally, Cablecom-General et al. urge that we conduct further

rule making before requiring common carrier service. iby CATY’s, and .

that we act to end the possibility of.confusing dual State“Federal

regulation. Both of these subjects require further exploration beyond -

ber pe 1969, and -..

the bounds df our First Meanie and Order of Octo

cannot appropriately be dealt with here.

6. Several parties.* urge that the Commission, in encoura cable-,

casting, has embarked upon a new course with respect té CATV, which’ -

was previously limited to the role of a supplement to broadcast tele-

vision service. They say that CATV, still founded ‘tpon the carriage —

ccentlhanilbcanciambisioasiasles

2

' #There is always the possibility of: waiver ina 2 particular case, but we, stress that i

y because of —— _—

5 E.g., American Broa Association. of Maximum Servite ecasters,

a group of te oviniow stations (WAVELTY. af al.), the National Association of s, Telgcasters,

_ and the All nnel-Television Society. . ABC also urges full licensing-of CATV. and a re-

signals, matters beyond the

examination of policies-on the carriage of non-local broadcast

— the First Report and Order of October 27 1

-) o> 8 0.0.24 «4

sass tte eR ERE CAEP OD LCL LEO IE A

ATV... thes a gt

iction and presentation of programs . . .” (74,1111(a))° _

tes, those willi ing to discuss.

controversial issues, etc., have a means of to the television viewer.

- Ags 8.

rage “4 co ee . . ° - : :

. 828° Q Federal Communications Commission Reports’

of broadcast signals but now encouraged to originate programs in-

o dependently, : ill be ‘a ‘greater threat to the public’s continued reception

of “free” programs than either agree CATV operations or subscrip-

tion television broadcasting. The latter they seers out,. has been

channelled so as to give the public something di

ming fare. We agree that where cablecasting is accompanied by a |

- ~per-program or per-channel fee, it is akin to subscription television and

presents the same threat of siphoning E program away from free televi- .

ose who can Pay. d, ih the case

Remedial action in-this area should not wait upon the threat. becom

~ actuality..As was the case with subscription television, protection of

..% + preventing siphoning television wind ra from free television broad- .

to subscription television broadcasting will serve to insure that |

‘. eablecasting doesnot merely force the public to pay for what it now .

receives free. They are additionally warranted here because of CATV’s

inability to serve the same audience reached by a television broadcast

_ “jg the case with subscription television, advertising should not be

ermitted where the:public pays directly for the programs. This addi- -

onal economic support should not be necessary, and it would be.

contrary to the public interest. Appendix A hereto adds a new Section

74,1121 to our rules to accomplish these: urposes.” However, we do not .

. believe that cablecasting unaccom nied by roars or per-chan-

nel cha: presents a substantial threat of siphoning, or that.such ~

~ cabl , which we wish, to stimulate, sh d-be restricted to one

munities. The basis for this judgment is that when CATV operates in

its present fashion (i.e., a flat chargein a generally well-defined range), -

it. poses no significant threat o a progremress from the

on of the | ff ad restrictions

to , . ( e: development ot 7

such services, without any resent basis or need for the inhibition. The

ues are honing a real possipiltty. of $2 pe’

‘with 10 million subscribers in Pont States, an Sveti of $2 Re. month per home :

a ;

ue

pertieular areas oeeal coe be probl. t 1s pointed out, for

a em. a

- @l., that with 600,000 subscribers in the Philadelphia area

"part of Docket No. 18397 and are matters we ‘do not fee n-

_ to resolve at this time.* One further matter raised in the Notice of .

Proposed Rulemaking of December 13, 1968 should be dealt with at

lems may now be arising, .

-and that is the prohibition of fetteries. We are adopting a newSection _

by @ newspaper is not exempt from fairness, spohsor idéntification an

- other requirements. The point is fhat we have no intention of

*

mee ol @any is

ke placing upon ‘ordinary cablecasting the restrictions appropriate to

pay-T'V operations, We stress uld we be mistaken in this regard

be permitted on more than one channel, regulation of common carrier

operations, rtfng requirements, and technical standards;”We are .

not_persuaded that all of these questions need be,resolyed before we

proceed with the basic determinations made in the First Report and

Order of October 27, 1969. CATV originations are still in their infancy -

and, so far ag we know, common carrier operations are still in the

future. These various issues are not being forgotten. Some are being

acted on at this time; the others are beyond the pomp | scope of

this time in view of. indications org

74.1116 to meet this problem.

¢~ © 8. The American Newspaper Publishers Association has urged.that

_we add. a new section to make clear @hmat our requirements as te equal

time for political candidates, the fa¥@hess dactrine, political editorials

and pefsonal attacks, advertising, and sponsorship identification re-_

quirements are.not applicable to the dissemination of newspapers. We

and. experience show-the heed fér cortéttive action, we sfiall'take such |

action at the first indication,of the need therefor. ere

7. We note algo other requests by several parties that we deal with |

..CATV on a gore comprehensive basis at this time, covering such

"issues 49 lidensiog, whethey origination by the CATV operator should

in a position —

agree with the thrust of this petition that we did not intend to epply ae

these requirements to the distribution of printed newspapers to

‘subscribers by. way of cable. It does not appear nécessary to amend the

. rule to make this clear. ‘This opinion ‘will constitute the Commissioh’s _

- definitive interpretation of thé rules adopted in the October 27, 1969

Report and Order in this respect. However, we should also make clear

that ordinary cablecasting is covered by the rules. It makes no difference

on this question that a newspaper is the originator of the program ahy

more than it would if a newspaper sponsored a program on a broadcast

station. A news or public affairs p on a broadcast station owned.

the print medium when it is distributed in facsimile by cable, but we

do hold that the publication of a newspaper’ by a party does not put it

in a different geri om: epee rhe it sponsors, or arranges |

to be

to be by our rules, State or local requirements, public service use in

- eon ig tjonal agencies, common carrier service. can best

- be considered in the context of some of the issues mentioned above. Its further

thet, we aSent to require that cablecastefs coordinate educational public

aiblabe ob Tartine exprionee WTR the marr nena tinge ie we beldeve, waneconenry in .

the absence of experience the new medium. We have no reason to t

ed organisa of this general

tions ‘will not be consulted. or,

commer¢ial continuity will be inapprop = used in connection with

question, . propria

4d = patel of wet

be Geatt with tn advance 2¢ ‘some experience indicating its eubstantis and wo best

eGR Secale a ae 28 F0.0. 24 |

approach to it. -

} <

* ¥ ome * -

I RTE AGE RANE ANGI CS amen ner Bash

earn agen

“oe

“oO

. . . he 62 5

&30 Federal Uommunications Commission Reports

for the presentation of a. CATV origination which does fot constitute

the distribution of its newspaper.* “t ¥

9. Accordingly, upon the authority of Sections 2; 3, 4 @) and (i), ;

301, 308, 307, 308 and 309 of thie Communications Act,

forth in Appendix A hereto Are adopted,

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.