Appendix — Lake Carriers' Assn. v. MacMullan
Supreme Court brief1972
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SP nL oak 1
.
f&
.
4
Civil Action No. 36194,
¢
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT .-
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MIcHican, '
- SOUTHERN DIvIsion. -
LAKE. CARRIERS’ ASSOCIATION,
a corporation,
1411 Rockefeller Building,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113 *
and
Gotan of its ; mefiiber companies:
individually, namely, ‘
“AMERICAN STEAMSHIP
COMPANY, INC,
' a corporation,
1016 Marine Trust Building,
Buffalo, New York 14203
AMERSAND STEAMSHIP
CORPORATION, °
__ a corporation,
1016 Marine Trust, Building,
Buffalo, New York -14203° -
THE REISS STEAMSHIP
COMPANY, . +
.a corporation,
‘2300 Terminal Tower Building,
: Cleveland, Ohio 44113°
GARTLAND STEAMSHIP
COMPANY,.
a corporation, -
2300 Terminal Tower + Building,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113
- GREAT LAKES STEAMSHIP
DIVISION,
Bethlehem Steel veeoies
a corporation,
2600 Terminal Tower Building,
— Ohio ° 44113
. CL ND-CLIFFS
STEAMSHIP CO.,
a corporation,
. 1460 Union Commerce Building;
Cleveland, “Ohio 44115 ‘ ,
CLEVELAND.TA ANKERS, INC,
a corporation,
P. O. Box(@79,
Cleveland, Ohio 44101
ERIE SAND ‘STEAMSHIP : .
COMPANY, <}
‘a corporation,
Foot of Sassafras Stiecé.
Erie, Pennsylvania 16512
THE HANNA MINING CO.,
a corporation, ; .
100 Erieview. Plaza,.
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
HURON PORTLAND CEMENT
DIVISION,
National Gypsum Compafiy 5
a corporation, :
Ford Street, :
Alpena, Michigan. 49707
INLAND STEEL COMPANY,
a corporation,
_ 30 West Monroe Street,
Chicago, Illinois 60603.
THE INTERLAKE STEAMSHIP ©
CO.
Division of Pickands Mather & Co. 5
a corporation,.
2000 Union Commerce Building, .
Cleveland, Ohio 44115
KINSMAN MARINE TRANSIT
COMPANY,
‘a corporation, .
1548 Rockefeller Building,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113 ™
MEDUSA ee eal!
COMPANY,
a corporation,
P. O. Box 5668,
Cleveland, Ohio 44101
‘COLUMBIA TRANSPORTATION
DIVISION,
Oglebay Norton Company,
‘a corporation,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113 .
1200 Hanna Building, {
Cleveland, Ohio 44115° ° |
LAKE FLEET DIVISION,
Republic Steel Corporation,
a corporation,
55 Public Square, .
Cleveland, Ohio 44113
TOMLINSON FLEET ‘
CORPORATION, .
a corporation, <
2900 Terminal Tower Building,
nd
a
g
\ .
ually and as Director; Michigan ~“‘ and as Attorney General for the
Department of Natural Resourcés, State of. Michjgan,
Stevens T. Mason Building, . State Capitol, -
_ Lansing, Michigan 48926 Lansing,- Michigan
1} RALPH W. PURDY; Individually ‘MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF .
and as Executive Secretary, Water NATURAL RESOURCES AND- . -~
; Resources €ommission, THE MICHIGAN WATER RE-
Stevens T. Mason Building, * SOURCES COMMISSION, .
Lansing, Michigan, 48926 : Stevens T. Mason Building,
oo Lansing, Michigan 48926 __
_ Defendants.
. 7 . bd - 7 —s
GREAT LAKES FLEET, ~* WILSON MARINE TRANSIT 4
United States Steel Corporation, ‘COMPANY, — s
a corporation, Division of Litton Systems, Inc.,
1600 Rockefeller Building, ’ acorporation, ~.
Cleveland, Ohio 44113 : 55 Public Square,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113 ;
| Blaintigs | )
vs.
2
RALPH A. MacMULLAN, Individ- FRANK J. KELLY, lAdividually,
*“COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT
AND INJUNCTIVE BELIEF. si;
(Filed March 16, 1971.)
- Plaintiffs say: ,
1. This is an action for.a desieratoey judgment as
:
authorized by’Sec. 2201 of Title 28. of the United States
Code and for injunctive relief as authorized by. Secs, 2281.
and 2284 of Title 28 of the United States Code, and is
brought because there is an actual controversy now exisf-
ing between the parties to the &bove-entitled action as to
the standards of performance for marine sanitation devices
_ applicable to federally licensed commercial, bulk cargo,
* vessels plying the waters of the Great Lakes, and the time
frame ‘within which such standards must be met, as to
which matters plaintiffs seek the judgment of this Court. .
2. Jurisdiction is. grounded on Secs. 1331, 1333, 1337,
2201, 2281 and 2284 of Title 28 of the United States Code;
the Federal Water Pollution Cogtrol Act as amended by.
the Water -Quality Improvement Act of 1970, .33 .U.S.C.
Sec. 1151, et’ seq.; the Steamboat ‘Inspectjon Acts of Feb- —
ruary 28, 1871 and May 27, 1936, 46 U.S.C. Sec. 361, et
POLLED ELE To
«
settee
RELL BAG BERGE HRTEM AGB Do SES PONT RR Sta RY eA " — Ase
: . . y,
a
°
ay g
seq.: the boundasy Waters - Treaty of 1909 between the 7
_ United States.and Canada, 36 Stat. 2448, Treaty Series No.
048; and Article 1 Sec. 8, cl. 3; Article 3 Sec. 2, cl. 1;°
Articlé 6, cl. 2, Amendinent XIV TY Bey! a the Constitution
of the United States.
' 3. The amount in controversy exceeds $10, 000, ex-
clusive of interests ‘and costs.
4. Plaintiff Lake Carriers’ Association is an organi-
zation incorporated under the laws of the State of Ohio
with its principal :place of-business in Cleveland, Ohio.
_ The membership of Lake Carriers’ Association consists of |
21 separate vessel conipanies, of which 19 are the indi- |
vidual ‘plaintiffs named herein. The vessels enrolled in the
Lake Carriers’ Association account for more than 98 per |
cent of the total trip-carrying capacity of the United States
commercial, bulk cargo, Great Lakes fleet.
a Collectively, plaintiffs, other than Lake Carriers’
Association, are the individual owners and/or operators °
of 187 American flag Great Lakes bulk cargo vessels, all
of<which are federally enrolled and licensed for employ-
ment -in the coasting and foreign trade on the waters of
the northern, northeastern and northwestern frontiers,
otherwise than by sea, pursuant to the Act of February 27, .
1877, c 69, Sec. 1; 46 U.S.C. Sec. 258. As federally
licensed vessels navigating’ waters of. the United States.
which are common highways of commerce, plaintiffs’
_ vesselsare subject to the provisions and regulations of the
federalivessel inspection laws administered by the United .
States Coast Guard, the same being Title 52 of the Re-
vised Statutes, 46 U.S.C. Sec. 361, et seq.
6. Article I of the Boundary Waters Treaty of 1909
between the United States and Canada, 36 Stat. 2448,
'_ Treaty Series No. 548, declares that the waters of the
‘ ‘Great Lakes, from main shore to main shore, including
Lake Michigan, shall forever continue free and open for’
.the purposes of commerce and navigation to'the inhabi-
tants and to the ships, vessels and ports of both countries
equally, and said Treaty prohibits enactment of any laws
4
%
¢
a
or regulations. inconsistent with such asa of free
navigation.
7. Plaintiffs;. other than Lake (oe Associatioh, |
are engaged in the business of providing vessel transporta- -
tion, some for their own account:and some for the account
of others or both, throughout the. entire Great Lakes-
St. Lawrence Seaway Systems, serving in interstate and/
- or foreign commerce a variety of ports in the states of.
Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio,
Pennsylvania, New York; and the Provinces of Ontario ©
and Quebec, Canada. The -principal comm :
ported by: plaintiffs are iron ore, fro ports on Lake
Superior to ports’ on lower Lake Michigan, the Lower
Detroit River and Lake Erie; coal, from ports on Lake
Erie and lower Lake Michigan to ports/in Michigan,
Wisconsin, Minnesota and the Province of Ontario, metal-
lurgical and chemical grade limestones, from: Michigan
ports on Lakes Huron and Michigan to ports on,lower
Lake Michigan and Lake Erie; grain, from the head of
the Lakes to ports on the Lower Detroit River.and Lake
Erie. There are also lesser movements of petroleum, gyp-
sum, gravel, sand, cement, coke, pig iron. scrap, and fin-
, ‘ished and semi- finished steel products, involving a variety
__ of ports in different states. All such movements involve -
the performance of a transportation service by federally
licensed vessels in interstate conimeérce over the navigable
_ waters of the United States and sometimes Canada. In
+ performing such interstate transportation sérvices, it is
- almost inevitable, with only a few minor exceptions, for
‘plaintiffs’ vessels to transit the navigable “waters of the
United States which are also. the territorial waters. of
Michigan. Even where a commodity. movement occurs
-between two or more Michigan ports, in most instances —
it constitutes interstate or foreign commerce in that the
vessel at some point in its round trip voyage must pass
through the territorial waters of another state or one of
the Provinces of Canada. .In all, the total bulk commodity
movement for the Great Lakes last year was 223, 404,329
net tons.
BOY
Us (Weal iia sisi ian ed Aceon pie toc 9 fina Pry
PRR TS PMN IS Ny MEER Te pe TO TE ERD ine:
- 8
8: Plaintiffs, as the principal users of the Great Lakes
. for navigational, purposes, aré extremely’ intérested in
“clean water” and preservation of the ecology of the Great »
Lakes, not only because such is in the national’ interest,
but also, because plaintiffs’ vessels utilize‘ these waters. as
their principal source of potable water as well as. boiler
water. Plaintiffs are desirous, within the limits of avail-’
able technology and of protecting the. water ‘quality of °
the Gréat Lakes through the installation on their vessels .
of marine sanitation devices consistent with maritime
health and safety, and the marine and navigation laws
_and regulations, applicable to federally licensed vessels.
Even in the absence of any standards of performance for |
marine sanitation devices, but anticipating that require-
‘ments would be similar to those of shore-side facilities,
many of the plaintiffs have voluntarily undertaken a
program of. installing on their vessels marine sanitation
devices which produce an effluent equivalent to municipal
secondary «waste treatment systems. Plaintiffs have been
_ discouraged from continuing this program, however, be-
~ cause of enactment of a proliferation of’ state and munic-
ipal laws throughout the Great Lakes imposing differing —
requirements despite the amendments to -the Federal
Water Pollution Control Act, enacted April 3, 1970, spe-
cifically dealing with the control of sewage from vessels’
utilizing the navigable waters of the-United States, 33
U.S.C. Sec. 1151, et. seq. Confronted-with a multiplicity
‘of conflicting state, municipal and federal laws and reg-
ulations imposing a variety of vague, uncertain and differ-
ing requirements with respect to the standards of per- ©
formance for marine sanitation deyices, plaintiffs bring
this action for declaratory judgment and injunctive relief -
to determine the constitutional validity as applied to feder-
ally licerised vessels of the Michigan Watercraft Pollution
Control Act of 1970, the same being Act 167, Public net |
of 1970, State of Michigan.
9. Defendant Ralph A. MacMullan is the duly ap- .
pointed, qualified and acting Director of the Michigan —
Department of Natural Resources with official residence
ae iSelr cep 5 r na - ae
9 .
in Lansing, Michigan. Under and by virtue of Act 167,
Public Acts of 1970, State of Michigan, commonly known
as the Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970, the Water |
Resources Commission of..th Michigan Department ‘of.
_ Natural Resources is charged with the enforcement of the
a provisions of said Act. Defendant Ralph: W. Purdy; with
official residence in Lansing, Michigan, is the duly ap- -
pointed, qualified and acting head and in charge of the
Michigan Water Resources Commission and exercises
supervision and control of the individuals employed by
the Water Resources Commission now engaged in enforc-
ing the aforesaid Act. Defendant Frank Kelly is the duly
elected, qualified and acfing Attorney General of the State | =
- of Michigan with official residence in Lansing, Michigan, 7
whose duty it is or may become to prosecute the plain-
tiffs for violations of the aforesaid Act, a copy of which
is attached hereto and marked Exhibit .“‘A.” :
10. Sections 3, 4 and 8 of the aiotessid. Watercraft a
Pollution Control Act of 1970 in particular attempt to E
regulate, direct.and control the disposal of sanitary wastes | y
from federally licensed vessels while in Michigan «waters |
in that such sections provide inter alia: | 4
:
“Sec..3 (2) It is’ unlawful to ee dump,
- throw or. deposit garbage, litter, sewage -or-oil-from
a recreational, domestic or r foreign watercraft used |
for pleasure or for the purpose of carrying passengers, -
cargo or otherwise engaged in commerce on the
waters. of this state.”
§
£
£
4
aa
* * ° € *k *
' “Sec. 4 (2) A persof owning, operating or other-
wise concerned in the operation, navigation or man-
agement of a watercraft having a marine toilet shall
. not own, use or permit the use of such toilet on the
waters of this state unless the toilet is equipped with
one of the following pollution control devices:
<=>
TY SHAFT aR AI
(a) A holding tank or self-contained_ marine
toilet which will retain all sewage produced on the
a 10,
watercraft for subsequent disposal at approved dock-
sideor onshore collection and treatmes® facilities.
(b) An incinerating device which will reduce to
ash all sewage produced on the .watercraft. The ash
shall be disposed of onshore in a manner which will
preclude pollution.”
0 U “ate 0 : *
~ BS bd 7 -
“Sec. 8 . . . Commercial docks and wharfs de-
signed for receiving and loading cargo and/or freight
from commercial watercraft must furnish facilities,
if determined necessary, as prescribed by the com-
' mission, to accommodate discharge of sewage from
heads and galleys, and for deposit of litter, garbage,
trash? or bilge waters from the watercraft which .
utilize the docks or wharfs.” . - ”
11. Section 11 of. the aforesaid Watercraft Pollution
Control Act of 1970 provides that any person who violates
any provision of the-Act is guilty of a misdemeanor and -
shall be fined not more than $500. Since enactment of
the aforesaid Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970, the
Michigan Water Resources’ Commission has maintained a
.. staff of enforcement officers who, at the.direction’ of de-
fendants herein, have threatened plaintiffs with indict-
ments if they enter Michigan waters without the specific | |
equipment required by Section 4 of.the aforesaid Act; -
and plaintiffs, by such threats; are prevented from. using
. and enjoying their own federally licensed property. free
from improper and unlawful molestations and interfer-
ences by the officials of the Water Resources Commission —
of the Michigan Department of Natural Resources in that _
corhpliance with the equipment provisions of Section 4
of the Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970 requires
substantial alterations in the present vessels; that such
alterations cannot possibly be accomplished by the open- _-
ing of navigation which. usually occurs on or about March
°15;. that plaintiffs will not be able to begin operations this
year without violating some of the provisions of the
Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970; that even were
&
ad | moe,
plaintiffs apie to so equip their vessels as to comply with
Section 4 of said Act, which is a physical impossibility,
there are to plaintiffs’ knowledge no. pump-out facilities :
in Michigan or elsewhere suitable for commercial vessels,
and the Water Resources Commission has not promul-—
gated any rules or regulations delineating what is an ap-
proved dockside or onshore collection treatment facility
for® ‘commercial vessels, noy: has it prescribed or deter-
‘mined as necessary the location and nature of the facilities - ~
-commercial docks and wharves must furnish to accom- —
modate the discharge of sewage from ‘heads and galleys,
all as required by Section 8-of the aforesaid Act. —.
12. In the early part of 1968, a:confe ‘was held
pursuant ‘to Section 10 of. t the Fedéral Water Pollution
Control Act (33_U.S-€: Sec. 1160), among the states
bordering Lake Michigan. As a result of that conference
it was agreed, among the several states, that uniform rules ©
and regulations should be. adopted and that controlling
the discharge of wastes from commercial vessels should
be the responsibility of the Federal Government. .There-
after, on April 3, 1970, an Act of Congress was approved,
commonly known as the Water Quality Improvement Act
of 1970, PL 91-224, H. R. 4418, which Act amended the.
Federal Water Pollutio Control Act; 33 U.S.C. Sec. 1151,
et seq., by directing inter alia in Section 13 (8 USC.
Sec: 1163) thereof: |
“(b) (1) As. soon as a after enactment of
this section . . . the Secretary .. . after giving ap- °
propriate pontideration to the economic costs in- |
volyed, and within the limits of available technology,.
shall promulgate Federal standards of performance ~ *
for marine sanitation devices . . . which shall be-
designed to prevent the discharge of untreated or
inadequately treated sewage into or upon the navi-
gable waters of the United States . ..” “*°* * the
Secretary*of the Department in which the Coast .
- Guard is operating shall promulgate regulations,
which are. consistent with’ standards promulgated
under this subsection and with maritime safety and
3
a
ae RORY”
SS a ata ai Sa
USCA aad at OaA a Dials
Sy.
| 212. - 8
the marine and navigation laws and regulations, ov.
' erning the design, construction, installation, and oper-
ation of any marine sanitation ' device. onboard such >
vessels.”
“(2) Any existing vessel equipped with a marine
sanitation device on the date of promulgation of initial
standards and regulations under this section, which’
device is in compliance with such initial standards
and regulations, shall be deemed in compliance with
- this seetion * * *,”
La
~. this section shall become effective for new vessels
two years after promulgation and for existing ves-
sels five years after promulgation.”
““(f) * * * After the effective date of initial
. standards and regulations promulgatéd under: this
section, no state or political subdivision thereof shall
adopt or enforce any statute or regulation 6£ such
- state or. political ‘subdivision with respect to the.
design, manufacture, or installation or use of any
marine sanitation device on any vessel subject .to
the provisions of this section.. Upon. application by a
state, and where the Secretary determines that any
applicable water quality standards . require. such a
prohibition, he shall by regulation completely pro-
hibit the discharge from a vessel of any sewage
(whether treated or not) ‘into: those waters of sueh ~
state which are the subject of the application and
to which such standards apply.” ~ .
13: The Report of the Committee on Public Works
of the United States Senate (Report No. 91-351, 91st
Congress, 1st Session), accompanying S. 7, the companion
Bill of H. R. 4148, which ultimately became the Water
-Quality Improvement Act of 1970, states at page 11, “The
_ Committee intends that, this new: section will assist in
preventing at the earliest possible time permitted by
existing and advancing technology, economics, and other
practical considerations, the discharge into the navigable |
“(e) ( 1) Initial. standards and regulations under
13
waters of the United States of raw or inadequately treated
“sewage from vessels.” Added. the Committee at. page 11:
' “The general enforcement authority to accomplish’
this sectién. has been vested in the department in
which the Coast Guard is operating. This was done
because of the similarity to other Coast Guard func-
tions and the expertise of the Coast Guard in marine
engineering. In order to insure adequate recognition
of marine safety and other transportation aspects, the
Secretary of the Department. in which the -Coast
Guard is operating has been designated, to develop |
_ and promulgate the regulations which pertain to the
' design, installation, and operation of marine sanita-
tion devices and further to certify these devices as
- complying with such regulation Standards. These |
regulations must also assure compliance with the
standards. of performance issued by the Secretary.
It is the committee’s intention that there be close
cooperation and coordination between the, Secretary
and the Secretary of the Department in .which the
Coast Guard. is operating in the development of |
the overall program.’
‘Then stated the Committee, inter alia, at page 12,
“The Committee recognizes that many states have moved
to control inadequately treated or pntreated waste dis-
a charges from vessels and lauds the efforts of those states.-
However, conflicting regulations and standards relative
to® angrine sanitation devices present. * * * ‘potentially |
serious restrictions on interstate movement of commercial
vessels.” In order to avoid these difficulties, the: Commit-
tee stated, it has “ . . . provided for federal pre-emption
of the authority to regulate the design, use, manufacture |
and’ installation of marine sanitation devices.”
14. The Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act
of ' 1970, as applied to plaintiffs’ NW is unconstitu-
tional, null and void for the’ following reasons:
(a) The Michigan Watertraft Pollution Control Act
of 1970 and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as, .
.
OER TROP RIN Mal ees RTM EN, 9*
METERED Do tery (RENE ANY
shoe ae
he ‘ .
ba Ra eR ee Be ae.
°
“8
eo -
=, 4.0: |
. = Y. . a —\ 7
amended by the Water Quality Improvement. Act of 1970,
conflict to such an extent that both laws cannot be en-
forced without impairing federal superintendence of the
field'in that the state enactment-stands as an obstacle to
_the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes
“and objectives of Congress because state requirements
with respect to standards of performance for marine .pol-
lution control devices nullify federal discretion ayer, the
subject. matter and interfere or conflict. with the purposes
or provisions of the federal legislation.
(b) .The clear and manifest intent and purpose of
Congress in enacting the Water Quality Improvement ‘Act
of 1970 was to occupy the field jn.that it adopted a com-’
| plete and comprelfensive system of regulation .for the
disposal of sewage from. vessels on navigable waters, and.
while the required federal standards have not yet been
finalized, the fact that the Congress in enacting subsec-
tion (3) of Section 21 of the Water Quality Improvement
- Act of 1970,.33 U.S.C. Sec. 1155 (j), provided that the. -
Secretary of the Interior shall report to Congress the re-'
sults of such research, studies, experiments and demon-
strations relative to equipment which is to be installed on
_ board vessels designed to receive, retain, treat or discharge
' human body -wastes prior to ‘the effective date of any
standards established urider Section 13 of the Act, dem-
onstratgs .an unambiguous Congressional mandate to the
effect Ah;
devices. Further, through the vessel inspection- laws the
- Congress maintains an extensive and comprehensive set
of controls over ships, and shipping and provides for fed-
, eral inspection of a very broad nature covering the boilers, —
underfired pressure vessels, and the appurtenances there-.
of, also hull strength and ,integrate, safety devices, sani-
, tary conditions, navigational and communications. equip-
’ ment, life saving gear, propelling and auxiliary machinery,
electrical apparatus another equipment of all vessels of
plaintiffs. Michigan, through the enactment of the Water-
craft Pollution Control: Act of 1970, now seeks to change
hat it was occupying the field to the exclusion of |
, all ‘state regulations with respect to marine sanitation
“15
the federal staridards for the structure and equipment ‘of
. vessals by requiring the installation of holding tanks or
_ incinerating devices, equipment which involves a material
o
structural alteration of the vessel and. affects safety and |
- stability which are particularly within the expertise of
the Coast Guard. The vessel inspection laws were enacted
because the Congress‘ “recognized that standards and -de- ~
signs for the structure and equipment of vessels may not
vessel inspection laws and the Michigan Watercraft Pol-,
lution Control Act of 1970 are directed to the same
‘properly. be left to the diverse action of the states. The
subject; the eqtiipment of vessels, and they opergfe upon .- -
trol Act of 1970 is void because the federal ifspection
laws and the’ Feddal Water Pollution Control Act, as
amended by the Water Qualit Improvement Act of 1970,
- were intended | to oceupy thf field.
a
‘(c) If the: Congress has not expressly ore-enifted the:
field, the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act of
Pa
1970 materially 4ffects interstate and foreign commerce
inknatters where uniformity is necessgary.and relates to a |
subjéct demanding exclusive federal regulation 4n re :
to achieve uniformity vital. to’ national-interests in th
plaintiffs’ vessels serve all of the eight Great Lakes states. .
and the two Provinces of . Canada bordering the Great
Lakes; and, in performing a transportation service, it is_
impossible for them togcomply with a multiplicity of
standards in each state or Province. The subject matter
of the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control, Act of 1970
demands material uniformity of regulation so that state ”
action is altogether inadmissible even. in the absence of
federal actioif «
(d) Apart from Article 1 Sec. 8, cl. 3 of the Gonstitus
tion, ‘relating to interstate and foreign commerce, the |
‘Constitution itself adopted and established as part of the
laws of the United States approved rules of general mari-
to them and other matters within the admiralty and mari-
time law and empowered Congress to legislate in respect
* time jurisdiction. The Constitution denies to the: states.
Bo OK
>
>
_ the same object. The Michigan Watercraft Pollutfon Con- |
Gabapentin tsb, bie hs
‘16°! . cs
all power by legislation to contravene the essential pur-
poses of, or to work material ‘ ‘jury to. characteristic —_
features of the maritime law or to interfere with its proper
harmony and yniformity in its international and interstate
relations. Onf¥ the-Congress can, legislate within this
sphere. The installation. and operation of sanitation de-
vices on tommercial vessels. is maritime in nature and
‘all rights, liabilities and’ obligations in connection there-
with are matters clearly within the admiralty jurisdiction.
The installation and operation -of sanitation devices on
commercial‘ vessels plying the waters of the Great Lakes,
involving as it does trade and commerce between and
among some eight separate states and two Provinces of
Canada, is national in character’ and admits and requires
uniformity of regulation affecting alike all the states, and |
Congress alone can act upon it: and provide the needed |
' regulations. The Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control
Act of 1970 undertakes to prescribe exclusive rights and
liabilities, undertakes to secure their observance by heavy
penalties and onerous conditions and provides novel
remedies inconsistent with the uniform maritime law and,
therefore, impairs federal.superintendence and preserva-
tion of the uniform maritime law.
(e) If federal law has not pre-empted the field to the
~ exclusion of all state regulation, then enforcement of
the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970,
until such time as the field has been so pre-empted, co
stitutes the takirig -of plaintiffs: property without due
process. of law in violation of Sec: 1 of the XIV Amend-
ment of the Constitution of the United States in that:
plaintiffs, béfore entering Michigan waters, will be re-
quired to make extensive and expensive alterations to
- their vessels in the installation of holding tanks and/or
incinerating devices, whichSdevices will or may become |
wholly obsolete and worthless upon the promulgation of
federal standards and which devices are of no immediate
benefit to anyone because there are as yet no. waste dis-
charge facilities available for commercial vessels in any
of the ports of Michigan or the ports of any other states.
The. only alternative presently available to such ship
Le)
17
operatiop.weuld be. to discharge holding tanks’ in non-
Michigan waters, thus creating untreated concentrations
’ of sewage in the Great Lakes subject to the vagaries of
wind -and lake current. Further, with respect to those
”
vessels which. merely transit Michigan waters and do not —
‘ touch at Michigan ports, there is no legal remedy for com-
pelling the installation of pump-out facilities, in any other
state. Consequently, such vessels dre precluded from
~ complying with the Michigan‘ Watercraft Pollution Con-
- trol Act of 1970, even were they to install holding tanks
or incinerating devices. + | : , ,
"(f) If federal law has not pte-empted the field to the
exclusion of all state regulation, then ‘enforcement of the
Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970, until
suche time as the field has been so pre-empted, constitutes
a denial of the equal protection of the laws in violation —
of Sec. 1 of the XIV Amendment of the Constitution of
the United States in that such Aset makes it unlawful for
a commercial vessel to discharge overboardany sewage,
- whether treated or not, while at the same time permitting |
-shore-based industry and “municipalities to discharge .
_inadequately treated sewage into the waters of the Great _
Lakes. Requiring commercial vessels to discharge wastes |
ashore into municipal’ waste treatment systems merely:
compounds the problem in that the municipal waste treat-
ment systems in the principal ports of Michigan have not*
yet met the standards for secondary treatment imposed |
upon them by the Michigan Water Resources Commission —
and the Federal Environmental Protection Agency. There
is no evidence that by requiring commercial vessels to
discharge wastes ashore there is any better treatment of
- sewage wastes than the vessels can provide themselves .
given adequate time to comply with anticipated federal
standards. for the performance of marine sanitation de-
vices. . °
exclusion of all state regulations, then enforcement of the
Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970, until
‘such time as the field has been so pre-empted, ‘is violative
of constitutional requirements.of due proéess and the equal
. eo
Be
( g) “If federal law-has not pre-enipted the field to the
et APT WIN WAN tb he
° ?
rt PERI PAT TE + ees SY A © er eR ONT COE Re RR.
QB ucetewis
eS
18
protection of the laws i in that the Act, particularly Sexton
3(4). thereof, is vague and ambiguous inasmuch as it does
~ not specify with sufficient certainty the conduct which it
intends to proscribe and punish, to the extent that men
of ordinary intelligence must guess at its meaning and
differ as to its application with respect to what discharges
render the water unsightly, noxious or otherwise un-
wholesome so as to be detrimental. to the public health or
welfare or to the enjoyment of the Water for recteational
purposes.
(h) The Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act
of 1970 is unenforceable in that the State of Michigan has
not, in compliance with Sec. 13(f) of the Water Quality
Improvement Act of 1970, made application to the Secre-
tary of the Interior to determine whether any applicable .
water quality standards require such.a prohibition in any *
of the water's-of the State of Michigan.
15. The enforcement of the Michigan Watercraft Pol-
lution’ Control Act of 1970 is working upon plaintiffs an
unusual hardship and irreparable injury and damage for
which there exists ‘no adequate remedy at law. Plaintiffs
are under firm commitments for the transportation of
cargo during the ensuing navigation season. To meet these
commitments requires that they enter Michigan watérs -
which they cannot do except in violation of Michigan law.
: Thus, on the one hand plaintiffs are threatened with claims
and suits for the failure to deliver cargo vital to Michigan
and indeed the nation’s commerce and. industry, whil®on
the other hand they are faced with extensive fines and
penalties for violation of the Michigan Watercraft Pollu-—
tion Control Act of 1970. Upon the opening of the naviga-
tion: season, which usually occurs on or about March 15\,
plaintiffs will suffer daily the loss of business and patron-*. —
age in consequence of the enforcement of the Michigan
Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970, and such en-
forcement will in operation and*effect amount to a con-
fiscation of the property rights of plaintiffs in violation: of
the Constitution of the United States.
| 16. A delay in a’vertaining and determining the 2 rights
of plaintiffs will result in serious loss and damage in that _
y
«a
19: |
the navigation season of the Great ‘Lakes is limited and the
plaintiffs’ rights have been, are now and will gontinue to
be violated unless plaintiffs are protected from the unlaw-
ful acts hereinbefore complained of, and the continuation
of such unlawful acts by persons purporting to derive au-
thority from the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control
Act of 1970. The injuries which will inevitably flow from _
- the performance et officials acting under au-
thority of the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act -
of 1970 will be irremediable unless relief be granted by
the Court. | Cc
~ WuerErore, plaintiffs pray: a.
1. That pursuant to Sec. 2284 of Title 28 of the United -
States Code, a District Court-of three judges be convened
to. hear this cause; cr
3. ‘That the Michigan Watercraft ‘Pollution Control
Act of 1970 as applied to plaintiffs’ vessels be declared un-
‘ constitutional, null and void; a
3 That the Court’restrain the defendants from the
enforcement of the Michigan Watercraft PoHution Control .
Act of 1970; | . |
4. That pending the final hearing and determination
of this cause upon its merits the Court issue a temporary
restraining order restraining defendants from enforcing
the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control Act of 1970 and
. for such other and further relief as shall be proper and
necessary.
~ Scott H. Etper,
Attorney for Plaintiffs,
2700 Termina] Tower,
. . Cleveland, Ohio 44113.
Of Counsel:
* JOHNSON, BRANAND & J AEGER, ,
2700 Terminal Tower,
Cleveland, Ohio 44113.
| Joun ARTHUR HAMILTON,
7 3266 Peftobscot Building,
: Detroit, Michigan 48226.
~ momaageeeng
0 a hah, prt
‘2 . é
yi | Mi ttt A AEN he ead Die Raabe a ot
20 -
Verification.
“
STATE OF OHIO, |
CouNTY OF Cuvanoca, SS.
Scott H. Exper, being first duly sworn, deposes and
says that he is one of the attorneys for plaintiffs herein; .
that he has read the foregding complaint and knows the
contents thereof; and that the same aré true to the best of
his knowledge; that each of the plaintiffs has recejyed and
approved a copy of said complaint; that he has i) thority
in writing from each of said plaintiffs to file said complaint
on its behalf; that the reason this verification is being made
by. the attorney and not by the plaintiffs is that‘ the plain-
_ tiffs are exceedingly numerous~in-number and located in
_ several different states; and that the urgency of the action
makes it impractical to obtain such vérification.
OO Scort H. Exper.
(Jurat omitted in printing. )
. 7 7 21 = |
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Eastern District oF Micuican,
| SouUTHERN DIVISION...
(Title @nitted in printing. ) | |
~
AFFIDAVIT OF VICE ADMIRAL PAUL E. TRIMBLE,
US.C.G. (Retired), LAKE CARRIERS’ ASSOCIATION.
(Dated March 16, 1971.)
STATE OF OHIO, m3
CouNTY OF CUYAHOGA, SS. |
Vicg Admiral Paul E. Trimble, U'S.C.G, (Retired),
being first duly sworn, deposes and says: -
.
1. That he-is the duly elected, qualified, ‘and acting —
president of Lake Carriers’ Association, a_non-stock, non-
profit Ohio Corporation. OT .
-
‘2 That the membership of Lake Carriers’ Association ~ |
consists of some 21 companies, 19 of which aye the in-
dividual plaintiffs named herein; that all such companies
_ own and/or operate Federally licensed Great Lakes bulk
cargo vessels.” “ an
- 3: That one of the primary purposes and functions of
- Lake Carriers’ Association is to promote and foster the de-
velgament of Great Lakes commerce.
4. That as ‘of the filing’sf the complaint herein, the
Great Lakes navigation season is currently under way in
that many. vessels are in. the process of fitting out and
ready to sail, that some vessels have already sailed and
that at least two vessels plan to begin operations in Mich-
igan waters today. . Aa Be Be ,
5, That collectively the plaintiffs herein own and/or
operate 187 American flag Great Lakes bulk cargo vessels,
all of which are Federally enrolled and licensed for em-
ployment in the coasting or foreign trade on the Great
Lakes. - | -
6. That enforcement of the Michigan Watercraft Pol- .
lution Control Act of 1970 is working upon plaintiffs an —
’
7‘ FTE REN Te Gel Pl ata ia)
OL RURRRRE SAN SOS RN
BSPabiy
> @
&,,
22
unusual hardship and irreparable ‘injury and damage for
which there exists no adequate remedy at law in that
plaintiffs are under ‘firm commitments for the transporta- —
tion of .cargo suchazs i iron ore, coal, limestone, grain, petro-
_leum, cement, sand, gravel, salt and other commodities,
- and that to meet these commitments requires that..they
transit Michigan waters which they’ cannot do except in
violation of the Michigan Watercraft Pollution. Control Act
- of 1970; that on the_one_hand, plaintiffs are. threatened
_with claims and suits for the failure to deliver, cargo vital ~
to Michigan and the nation’s commerce and industry,
whilé’on the other hand, ff they do perform their trans-.
portation contracts they are faced with extensive fines and
penalties.in violation of the Michigan Watercraft Pollution ~~
Control Act..
7. That the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control
Aet of 1970 is unconstitutional, null and void, and the en-.
‘forcement thereof will, in operation and effect, amount to-
a confiscation of the property rights of plaintiffs in viola-
tion of the Constitution of the United States.
. 8. That any delay in ascertaining and determining the
rights of plaintiffs will result in serious loss and damage
because of the limited nature of the Great Lakes naviga-
tion season and the injuries which will inevitably flow
from the performance of enforcement officials acting under
authority of, the Michigan Watercraft Pollution Control
Act will’ be irremedial unless relief be immediately
granted. - 3 |
9. That plaintifis are now being delayed in the fit-out
of vessels and assumption of navigation, and they will suf-
fer irreparable loss and‘ damage if prevented from per-
* forming their obligations for the movement of cargo.
10. That the imminence of the navigation season pre-_
vents notice to said defendants and a hearing on the tem-
porary restraining order requested: herein.
/
Further affiant saith naught. -
—
PauL E. TRIMBLE. .
* (Jurat omitted in printing.)
a
23
| UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT ©
FoR THE EASTERN DisTRICT OF MIcHIGAN,
‘ SOUTHERN .DIVISION.
(Title omitted in printing.)
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER.
. (Issued March 16, 1971.)
Note: This order is printed in the Jurisdictional State-
oo ment at page 34 and is here omitted.
| ORDER EXTENDING TEMPORARY RESTRAINING
ORDER.
g : “(Filed March 26, 1971. )
Note: This order is printed in the J urisdictional State-
-ment at, page 36 and is here omitted.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EasterN Distrigz-oF MICHIGAN,
'. SouTHERN DIvIsIon.
(Title omitted in printing. )
DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS, OR IN THE
ALTERNATIVE, FOR ABSTENTION.
(Filed April 5, 1971.)
- Now Come defendants, by their attorneys, Frank J.
- Kelley, Attorney General of the State of Michigan, and |
Jerome Maslowski and Francis J. Carrier, “Assistant Attor-
neys General, and pursuant to FR.C.P. 12(b) (6) (7),
move this Court to dismiss /laintiffs’ complaint, respect-
fully representing to the Court:
1. The complaint fails to state a claim upon which
relief may be granted for the reasons that:.
\ a)
(a) Federal standards of performance for marine
sanitation devices ta prevent the discharge of un-
treated or inadequately treated sewage into or upon
the navigable waters of this State, as required under
33 USC, Section 1163, have not been adopted and,
until such standards are promulgated, there can.exist
no conflict between the Federal Water Pollution Con-
trol Act, as amended, and Michigan law, ©
( b) That the appropriate federal agency’s power
to issue regulations remains unexercised and defend-
ants may, as a matter.of law, continue regulation un-
der Act 167, PA’ 1970, until further. federal action is
taken. ;
(c) Congress, by, enactment of Sections 1151(b),
1151(c) and 1160(b) of the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act, as amended, has reserved to the State of
Michigan the responsibility and right to prevent and
control pallution of its navigable waters, thereby sig-
njfying a congressional intention not to preempt the
‘State’s exercise of that power.
(d) The regulation of pollution in the waters of
_ this State under Act 167, PA 1970, isa matter of local |
State interest for protection of the public health,
_\safety and welfare, is a proper exercise of the State’s
- police power and congressional intention to preempt
State regulation is not clearly and definitely apie
in the. Federal Water Pollution Control Act, .
amended.
-(e) The Commerce clause of the federal consti-
‘tution doesnot prohibit defendants from. regulating
pollution of the waters of the State, even though the
State regulation has an impact on interstate com-
merce. :
(f) That, regulation of water pollution pursuant
to authority of Act 167, PA ‘1970, is not in itself the
regulation of interstate commerce but a valid exercise
of the state. police power and all presumptions shoul
be invoked to find that it is constitutionally exercised.
~
250° 7
— (g) That, in the absence of an express contrary
command of Congress not present here, the imposition
of minimum federal, standards of performance for.
_ marine sanitation deviges does not prohibit the adop-
tion-of more stringent state standards.
(h) That Act 167, PA 1970, regulates even- .
handedly ‘all watercraft on the navigable. waters of
this State to.effectuate a legitimate, public interest af-
fording all equal.protection of the laws without dis-
crimination, the statutory impact on interstate com-
merce being only incidental and not ‘constituting a
_direct burden on interstate commerce. |
2. The complaint fails to’state a claim upon which re- |
lief may be granted for the. reasons that: ~ | :
~ &) The Court lacks jurisdiction because the
State of Michigan is immune: from suit under the
Eleventh\ Amendment to the federal constitution.
(b) The Court lacks jurisdiction over the per-
son of the State officers and agencies named herein
for the teason that a suit against said officers and
agencies is a suit dgainst the sovereign State of Michi- ©
gan. .« >
3. The complaint fails to state a cause of action upon
which relief may be granted against the Attorney General,
* State of Michigan, for the reason that said State officer is
not in the first instance charged with the duty and re-
sponsibility of enforcing the criminal provisions. of Act
- 167, PA 1970, ,but acts ‘only in the event of failure ‘of
- prosecution on the local level, such failure to act:not being
shown by plaintiffs. =
4: The complaint does not state a claim upon which .
relief may be granted against defendants, ‘Michigan De-
partment of Natural Resourceg, Michigan’ Water Resources
Commission, Ralph A. ‘geMullan and Ralph Purdy, for
the reasor that said State\officers and State agencies are
without authority to enforce the: penalty ‘provisions of
Section 11 of Act 167, PA 1970. ,
— 26 | i
© §, Alternatively, fhe State defendants request this
Court to refrain from taking any further action: in these
proceedings until plaintiffs institute’an actionsin the State »
courts for détermination of the constitutional validity of
Act 167, PA. 1970, which ' issue of State law can only be
authoritatively construed in; the State tribunals.
_ 6. Alternatively, the State defendants request that
the complaint be dismissed by reason of failure to join in-
dispensable parties, the prosecuting attorneys of this State
_who are charged with the duty and responsibility, in their
respective counties, of enforcing the penal provisions of .
Section 11, Act 167, PA/1970, pursuant to the statute in
such case made’ and: provided a“ 49.153; MSA 1961
- Rev. Vol.‘5.751). - Ps |
This motion is based upon. the. records and files of
this Court. .
WHEREFORE, defendants pray that the above entitled
. complaint be dismi sed with prejudice:
FRANK J. KELLEY,
"Attorney General,
JEROME MasLowskt, ,
FRANGIS J. CARRIER, )
Assistant-Attorneys General,
By: Francis J. Carrier,
Attorneys for Defendants.
Business Address:
630 Seven Story Office Bldg.,
525 West Ottawa Street,
* Lartsing, Michigan 48913.
Dated: April 5, 1971. - oo a
%
many insufficiendg
nr a ra
UNITED $8TATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN District oF MICHIGAN,
SOUTHERN DIVISION.
» (Title omitted i in ‘PenaoE. ) ; /
| ANSWER TO GOMPLAINT FOR’ DECLARATORY .
JUDGMENT. AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.
bo | (Filed April 26, 1971.)
Reserving all manner of benefit arising out of the
and inconsistencijgs of plaintiffs to
‘upon which relief can be granted,
g the grounds alleged in support of
state a cause of ac
and expressly. rese
' defendants’ motion to dismiss, or in the-alternative, for.
' abstention, now comes the Attorney General, State of
Michigan, on behalf of defendants, and answering. the
_ complaint filed in: this cause, “says:
1. Answering paragraph, one, defendants admit olaine
tiffs seek a déclaratory judgment in the above entitled ©
cause pursuant to the statutes enumerated in said para-
graph: As to the remaining allegations of said parageePs,
defendants deny the same. :
2. Answering paragraph two, defendants admit plain-"
tiffs claim jurisdiction on the statutory and constitutional —
grounds therein alleged. Further answering said para-
graph, defendants admit plaintiffs allege jurisdicti under
the Boundary Waters Treaty of .1909 and say tha} said
treaty is irrelevant and”immaterial to the issues of, fact
‘. and law presented for determination in this cause. AS to .
the remaining allegations of said ‘paragraph not specifically
answered, defendants leave plaintiffs to their proofs.
3. Answering paragraph three, defendants lack in-
formation sufficient to form a beljef as to the jurisdictional
' averments therein alleged’ ‘and leave plaintiffs to their
proofs.
4. Answering paragraph four, defendants are with-
Ef knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief.
to truth of said allegations and leave plaintiffs to their
(
‘N
x
yy
\
- 28
ener Further answering said paragraph, iteadants al-
lege that plaintiff, Lake Carriers’ Association, -is without
authority to vicariously assert the constitutional rights of
the individual plaintiffs named herein and allege further
that said Association is not the real party in interest en-
titled to prosecute suit in this proceeding.
Further answering paragraph four, defendants allege
that this proceeding is: based upon plaintiffs’ claim that a
State statute is preempted by, or in conflict with, the
Federal Water: Pollution Control Act, as amended (33
USC’S 1151, et seq), and said issue of law involves the
* comparison of two statutes, rather than claimed abridg-
ment of federal constitutional guarantees, as alleged by
plaintiffs.
. 5. Defendants lack information sufficient to form a
“belief as to the allegations of paragraph five and leave
plaintiffs to their proofs, except that defendants admit the
individual plaintiffs, other than Lake Carriers’ Associa-
tion, are the owners and/or operators of 187 American
Flag Great Lakes bulk cargo vessels.
6. Déféndants are without sufficient ifformation to
form a belief’ as to the allegations of -paragraph six, ex-
cept to say that” ‘eonsideration of the Boundary Waters
Treaty of 1909 is irrelevant and immaterial to the issues
of fact and law before this Court, and Rerenants leave
plaintiffs to their proofs. ~ ae
7. The Attorney General, Stateof Michigan, does not
have sufficient information to form a bélief as to the allega- :
tions of -paragraph-seven, except that the allegat ions re-
cited in the first sentence of said poreerenk seven are ad-
mitted.
*8. Answering paragraph eight, ieendiente are with-
out sufficient information to form a belief as to the allega-
tions that plaintiffs are interested in “clean water,” preser-
vation of thé ecology of the Great Lakes, or that said -
parties are desirous of protecting the water quality of the
Great Lakes through the installation of marine sanitation °*
devices consistent with maritime health and safety.
> pa
~)
ra
’
of
29
Further answering said paragraph, defendants say
that numerous commercial and other vessels utilizing the |
waters of the Great Lakes; including vessels of the Ford
Motor Company, the ited States Coast Guard, and the >
_ United States:Corps of Engineers have voluntarily under-
taken a program of installing marine sanitation. devices
meeting the requirements of Act 167 of the Public Acts of.
1970, State of Michigan.
Further answering said en defendants deny |
that a proliferation of state laws throughout the Great
Lakes inipose different requirements despite the amend-
ments to the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and, in
support of the denial, state that federal standards of per-
formance for marine sanitation devices on plaintiffs’. -
vessels; as defendants are informed and believe, are not
omulgated to date and, if promulgated by the Environ-
mental Protection Agency under 33 USC §.1163(b), the
effective date of the standards is unknown.
Further answering said paragraph, detendants. Say
that regulations required to be promulgated by the Coast
' Guard under that statutory section have not been drafted
to date, the effective date of said regulations is unknown
‘and, as matter of law, until regulations promulgated
by the United States Coast Guard are effective, the stand- .
ards adopted by ‘the Environmental Protection Agency
may not be made effective. Further, that upon the promul-
gation of federal standards by the Environmental Protec- .
tion Agency, said standards will not be effective as applied
to plaintiff for five years, for "existing vessels, and two
years for new vessels.
| Further answering said paragraph, dstendants deny
that plaintiffs have any legal basis for the de¢laratory and
‘ injunctive relief here sought. As to the remaining al- |
legations of said paragraph eight not’ specifically an-
swered, defendants deny the same.
9. Defendants admit the allegations recited in “the
first, second and third sentences .of paragraph nine, ex-~~
‘cept that defendants deny that Ralph W. Purdy or Water
Resources Commission, Michigan Department of Natural
/
\¢
}
a
ON RMR RAT GPE pom re
..
_? e 30
Resources, are. charged with enforcement of the penal pro-
'- visions of Act 167 of the Public Acts of 1970, State of
_ Michigan. Defendants admit Frank J. Kelley is the duly .
elected, qualified and acting Attorney General, State of’
Michigan, with official residence in Lansing, Michigan, and
deny that it is the duty of said state officer to prosecute, in
the first sentence, violations of Act 167 of the Public Acts
of 1970, State of Michigan.
- 10. Answering paragraph ten, deendanis edit that
sections 3, 4 and 8 of Act 167 of the Public Acts of 1970,
State of Michigan, as alleged by plaintiffs, regulate and
controlthe disposal of garbage, litter, sewage;or oil from
federally licensed ships while in Michigan: waters. As to
the remaining allegations of said paragraph not specifically
answered, defendants deny the same.
11. Answering ‘paragraph eleven, defendants admit
- ‘that section 11 imposes penalties for violation of Act 167.
of the Public Acts of 1970, State of Michigan. As to the
remaining allegations of ed paragraph, defendants deny
the same and, in support of the denial, say that plaintiffs
have filed this suit just days prior to the opening of the
1971 shipping season, that Act 167 of the Public Acts of .
1970 was enacted eleven months prior to the filing of suit,
to-wit: on April 3, 1970 and that, contrary to: the allega- .
tions of said paragraph, plaintiffs had ample time to make
- alterations to their vessels to effect compliance with the
requirements of said State statute; and that plaintiffs have -
not, and are not now, being prevented from the use and ©
enjoyment of their properties by alleged improper and
- unlawful molestations and interference of defendants, or .
-of any of'them, as claimed by plaintiffs. As to the remain-
- ing allegations of said paragraph not specifically answered,
defendants deny the same.
12. Answering paragraph twelve, defendants admit
that a conference was held in the early part of 1968 by =.
the conferee states bordering Lake Michigan, and deny
that the conferees agreed discharge of wastes from com-.
‘mercial vessels should be the responsibility of the federal
_ government.
A
/
31°
Further answering said paragraph, defendants ad-
- mit that on or about April 3, 1970, the Water Quality Im-°
provement Act of 1970 was enacted, amending the Federal
Water Pollution Control Act, as alleged in paragraph’
twelve of the complaint* except that defendants point out
that § 1163, as so amended, provides. that “As soon \as
possible, after April 3, 1970, and subject to the provisions
of section-1155(j) of this title, the Secretary ... . shall pro-
mulgate Federal standards of performance for marine
sanitation devices . . .” [33 USC § 1163(b) (1) ].
~~ As to the remaining allegations of said paragraph —
twelve not specifically answered, . defendants deny the
same.
13. Answering paragraph thirteen, defendants state
that plaintiffs’ reliance upon committee reports, allegedly
expressing the view that the Federal Water Quality Im-
provement Act of 4970 would preempt state authority, is
irrelevant in'this proceeding for the reason that the com-
mittee report is not the statute enacted by Congress, nor
do those portions of said report recited by plaintiffs neces-
sarily signify the intention of Congress in enacting the
federal Statute. a i
Further answering said paragraph, defendants say ~
that section 1 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act,
as amended, expressly declares the policy of Congress to
recognize, preserve, and protect the primary responsibil--
ities and rights of the States in preventing and controlling -
water pollution: [33 USC § 1151(b) ], the right or juris-
diction of the States with respect to their waters (includ- ~
ing boundary waters) remains unimpaired [33 USC
§ 1151(c) |, and the Congressional declaration of state par-
ticipation is only prohibited after the effective date of the -
initial standards and regulations promulgated untler this
section [33 USC § 1163(f) |. .
¢
14. Answering paragraph fourteen, defendants deny
each and every ‘allegation therein, the. allegations of said
paragraph.and ‘each ofits subdivisions, (a),-(b), (ce), (d), -
(e), (f), (g) and (h), being contrary to both fact and law.
AIG a chars we ots
‘Dated: April 23, 1971.
©. onhp ctanriciani coer
7
“ 8 30 :
Further answering said paragraph, defendants. say .
that Act 167 of the Public Acts of 1970 is valid and con-
stitutional in all respects, is a proper exercise of state legis-
lative power for the purpose of. promoting the public
health, safety and- welfare and its enactment does not un- |
duly burden interstate commerce of these plaintiffs. Fur-
ther, that Congress has not exhibited its intention to pre-
empt said state statute by enactment of the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act, -as amended (33 USC §-1151 et
seq).
15. Answering paragraph fifteen, defendants deny the
allegations of said paragraph and each and every sentence
thereof in form and substance. |
16. Answering paragraph sixteen, defendants deny
each and every allegation recited therein.
Wuererore,’ defendants pray that the complaint be ©
dismissed with prejudice and with costs to defendants.
° Frank J. KELeEy, ,
me Attorney General, ;
JEROME MASLOwsSKI,
FRANCIS J. CARRIER,
Assistant Attorneys General.
, By: FRANCIS J. CARRIER,
Attorneys for Defendants.
| 33 | |
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
‘Eastern District OF MICHIGAN,
; SouTHERN DIVvISION.
(Title omitted in printing.)
|. STIPULATION OF FACTS... —
(Filed June 8, 1971.)
Lake Carriers’ Association is a non-stock, non-profit |
Ohio corporation, the membership of which ¢onsists of 21
_ separate companies owning and/or operating a total of 194
- Great Lakes bulk cargo vessels. Of the 21 members of the
Lake Carriers’ Association, 19 are individual plaintiffs in ..
_ this case. In all, such 19 plaintiffs.own and/or operate av
total of 187 Great Lakes bulk cargo vessels, such plaintiffs
and their vessels being identified ir¥ the membership book-
let of Lake Carriers’ Association attached hereto, made a
part hereof and marked Exhibit A. | \
All of the vessels owned and/or operated by plaintiffs
are federally enrolled and licensed for employment in the
coasting and foreign trade on the waters ‘of the northern,
- northeastern and northwestern frontiers, otherwise than ~
‘by sea, pursuant to: the Act of February 27, 1877 (46
U.S.C. Sec. :258). All of plaintiffs’ vessels are subject to
the provisions and regulations of the federal vessel inspec-
_* tion laws administered by the United States Coast Guard,
the same being Title 52 of the Revised Statutes (46 U.S.C.
Sec. 361, et seq.). . | ’ an
In all, as of J anuary™1, 1970, there were a total of 442
vessels in excess of 1,000 tons on the Great Lakes. Of
this total, 263 were vessels of United States registry, hav-
ing a combined tonnage of. 1,802,776 gross tons, and 179 —
were vessels of Canadian registry having a combined ton-
(nage of 1,576,165 gross tons. The composition of the
Great| Lakes commercial fleet is more: fully described on
pages 40, 41 and 42 of the Annual Report of Lake Carriers’
Association for the year 1969, annexed.hereto, made a part
hereof .and marked Exhibit B. -
ty Son Gt De
wee TA
ital masoge
QM ee!
PUN LS LAIRD yen gard ete ls
4 Fa a
iL) LER RADARS EA TPN AIRES RAS I ABE Se Ma
34
Plaintiffs are engaged in the business of providing
vessel transportation; some for their own account and
some for the account. of others, or both throughout the
entire Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Seaway System, serving
in interstate commerce.and/or foreign commerce a variety
of ports in the states of Minnesota; Wisconsin, Illinois,
Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York; and the
Provinces of Ontario and Quebec; Canada. .The principal .
trade patterns of the Great Lakes are as shown by the
seriés of flow charts attached hereto,-made.a part hereof
and marked Exhibit C. These charts, prepared by the
_ Great Lakes Regional Statistical Office of the Corps of.
Engineers for the year 1964 (the last year for which such
charts are available) show by principal commodities the
commerce of the Great Lakes. and fully demonstrate the _
interstate and foreign nature of that commerce. The trade —
patterns shown are typical of those existing today, the
only difference being in the volume of the cargo move-
-- ment. The lake bulk freight commerce by years is shown
on pages 952, 53 and 954 of Exhibit B. It is stipulated and
agreed that the Annual Report of Lake Carriers’ Associa-
tion for the year 1969 (the Jast year for which such Report
is available) actually reflects the water borne. commerce
- of the Great Lakes insofar as American and Canadian
registered vessels are concerned and is ‘entered into evi--
dence. Further, it is stipulated and agreed that plaintiffs’
vessels are. engaged in interstate and foreign commerce.
During the 1969 shipping season, consisting of a pe-
riod of 281 days, there were 14,059 passages through the
Detroit River, exclusive of sand carriers and passenger |
vessels. Of the total, 6,052 represented Great Lakes ves-.
sels: and 979 were ocean vessels upbound. In the down-
bound direction, there were 6,049 Great Lakes vessels and ~
979 ocean vessels or a total of 7,028. Thys, there was an’
average of 50 passages per day or one vessel every 29
minutes. ’
With respect to the commerce at Sault Ste. ‘Marie,
Michigan and Ontario ene 1969, there were 13,494
> ‘
35
transits -of the United Sites locks and 4 455 anita of
Canadian locks or a total of 17,949 passages.
Scorr H.- Exper,
o Attorney for Plaintiffs.
' JEROME MASLOWSKI,
» Assistant Attorney General,
State.of Michigan.
UNITED“’STATES DISTRICT COURT
Eastern District or MIcHIGAN,
SOUTHERN DIvISsION.
of
° MEMORANDUM OPINION DISSOLVING TEMPORARY
RESTRAINING ORDER AND DISMISSING COM-
PLAINT WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
(Filed and Entered July 12, 1971. )-
‘Note: This opinion ‘is printed in the Jurisdictional
Statement at page 21 and is here omitted.
4
4
|
i
.
:
36
. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Eastern District OF Micuican,
SOUTHERN Division.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS.
(Filed May 6, 1971.)
Proceedings had and testimony taken in. che above-
o
‘entitled and numbered cause before the Honorable George
’ Clifton Edwards, Jr., Circuit Judge, the Honorable Damon
J. Keith, District Judge, and the Honorable Philip Pratt, .
District Judge, at Detroit, Michigan, commencing on Mon- °
| day, April 26, 1971, in the forenoon.
APPEARANCES:
JOHNSON, BRANAND & JAEGER,
_ 2700 Terminal Tower Building,
‘Cleveland, Ohio 44113,
By Scott H: ELDER, Esq.,
t) ~. and |
Foster, MeEapows & BALLARD,.
3266 Penobscot Building,
Detroit, Michigan. 48226, _
By Jonny ARTHUR HamMI.Ton, Es@.,
_ For the plaintiffs. -
Frank J. KELLEY, Attorney General,
630 Seven Story Office Building,
525 West Ottawa Street,
2 Lansing, Michigan 48913,
By. JEROME Mas.owskI, Es@., and
Francis J. CARRIER, Es@.,
Assistant Attorneys General,
For the defendants.
2
37 .
(25)
_ Davip Grou, being duly sworn, was examined and
testified as follows: 7
_ -Drrect EXAMINATION by Mr. Elder. *
~ Q. Mr. Groh, would you please tell us your present
occupation? A. My present occupation is vice president, :
marine manager of Interlake Steamship Company, which
in turn ig owned by, or is a division of Pickands Mather,
which in turn is a. wholly-owned subsidiary of Diamond
‘Shamrock Corporation. = . = .
_ * “oe * *
(26) Q. What is your educational background, Mr.
Groh? A. My background is, attended the University of
Michigan; I obtained a Bachelor of Science degree in 1944
“in the School. of Marine Engineering and Naval Architec-
ture. .
Q. Did you have any further education after that?
A. From there orf,.as it was in a practical sense, military ©
- service, United States Navy;’an from there, upon dis-
charge, as a—I served in the Engineering Department at
the Detroit Edison Company for a short term; and then
. proceeded to Great Lakes Engineering Works, the ship-
‘yard, as it existed in this area at that time; then for the
last 23-years‘I have been associated at the present occupa-
; fion previously described. =
~ 'Q, What hag been the nature /of your -duties with
Interlake Steams) Company? A. My duties through my
tenor of employment have been involved, with, first, the
_mechanical end of the business, that is, the ship structure,
’ ship machinery, maintenance, improvements (27) of. these
- items; and then in later years, as a little closer related to
the business aspects, of dispatch, cargo, business manage-
ment, to.the:present position I am holding. |
Q. How many ships does Interlake Steamship Com-
pany operate? A. Interlake owns 15 Great Lakes vessels
2 are on charter, being operated by others. |
and presently is operating 13 of these directly; the other
Nar
Cd = Oo - oe - - - . a
. : ™ . . ‘ . .
, , . , ,
. , .
. .
. @Q. t is the nature of these vessels? A. The
nature of the vessel is that they are typical Great Lakes
vessels, outfitted for the carrying of bulk cargo, what is
termed the straight-deck vessels, in that they do not un-_ -
_load themselves as they aepens on shore facilities for their
unload. -_
They have the capability of operating within the Great
Lakes system as far east, really, as Anacostia Island}which
is in the Gulf of St: Lawrence. -That is not the normal |
- trade but they have this capability. They are in size, have
_ the ability to transport from twelve thousand tons, land
tons, bulk, material, up to twenty thousand tons.
> ‘
* * * * *
(28) Q. Now, what commodities do you carry in |
your vessels, Mr. Groh? A. We carry) principally iron
ore and then in a secondary fashion, com and stone.
Q. Now, would you please poinf out on the chart ‘of .
the Great Lakes which we have here, principally in the
iron ore trade, what ports you tradé to and from and then
name the ports, please, so that they Will be on the reeord?
A. Well, our loading of iron ore all takes place in this
north shore area of the Minnesota ports; and. it would be
predominantly at this port, Zaconite Harbor better than
_half of our material is loaded here. The balance is split
- between the ports of Silver Bay, two Harbors,.at Duluth
. and Superior itself. So that entire 80-mile stretch of
\shoreline represents the loading location of all of our
‘iron ore as for our fleet. We then discharge this ore—-
there is a general split. of the trade, after you depart the -
lower end -of the St. Mary’s River and it goes, in our
situation, about equally split, down into Lake Erie and :
-. over into, Lake Michigan.
(29) In the Lake Michigan area, we dischaspe prin- :
cipally at one-of several docks in the’ Calumet ‘River; also
very heavy tonnageat Indiana Harbor, in this area; and
now this last year, there is a new port called Burns Harbor
—it is in connection with a new steel mill—and we do.
trade in this area. On the other side,. the Lake Huron,
‘Lake Erie situation, we discharge iron ore principally at —
-_ ‘39
Toledo, Huron, i prait, very heavy at Cleveland, ‘Ash-
7
tabula,.and occasionally at Conneaut and very heavy into -
Buffalo. |
That is a general description of liens we load ore
_ and where we discharge it.
Q. How about coal? A. Our coal covement is all up-
bound and we have two principal movements; one is coal
loading at Toledo and this is coal that is of metallurgical
quality, and we discharge that across to Milwaukee. It is
- for the purpose ‘of making coke. Our second major move-
ment of coal is @ loading here in the same Calumet River
area. This’ is steam coal and this proceeds on the uphound
' voyage to Taconite Harbor for power-plant operation. -
_ How about the stone? A. Stone is a—represents
less*than ten per cent of our trade. Stone is loaded at the
ports here, Rogers City, and also (30) Presque Isle, so-
called Stone Port; and this in turn would be discharged in
our case’to the same steel plants here, into Lake Michigan,
‘ or, Lake Erie, as I previously mentioned, used in comnec-
tion with the steel industry.
Q. What about grain? A. Grain is a spasmodic com-
modity, as I didn’t mention it before, we do oceasionally
take a load of grain, actually, we arevin the process of doing
it right now. Grain is loaded in this Duluth-Superior area,
and for the most part is discharged at Buffalo. And that is, ©
we have three’ships ‘so engaged at this very moment, all
three of which are paralyzed in the ice in the Buffalo area.
Q. Then, in your testimony, Mr. Groh, you indicated
then that only in connection with-stone do you actually
touch at a Michigan port?.A:. That is correct. That would _
be our only normal trade that. we have been conducting as .
on a year-to-year. basis, that is, Michigan—of origin in
Michigan.
Q. Now; how many men in your crews? A. They
- range from thirty to thirty-five. —
' Q. Now, how smtch liquid or waste or Pytiatever you
. want to call it is@enerated per day on a vessel, per man?
A. Well, wé ia made, as best we can, several measure-
; ments,of this and we come to an amount in the néighbor-
hood of 125 sat ¥ gallons of liquid per man per _
a
ae
‘\'a
\
\
x
@ And what woul this— A. am being a minimum |
‘kind of number. __
\ Q. What does this include? A. “Well: this would, in-
clude wash: water, or drains from. the normal | ‘showers,
, -alsg the vehicle water as to handle sanitary facilities.\ :
/ Q.. Well, now, considering the nature of your trade
and the number of fen-in your crews and the amount of -
water generated and so forth, have you given any con-
. Sideration or made any calculation with respect to holding
tanks? ‘A. Yes, we have, ~~
Q. What were: those calculations? -A.“Well, we feel 7
* that with our trade pattern that. we would have to ‘have
holding tanks capacity in the order of not less than 20,000
gajlouis at either. end of the véssel, a total of 40. |
3
Q. A total of 40,000 gallons. Why is that? A. Well;
it is principally | to take care of the time element, involved. |
In our trade pattern, as I tried to describe it here, we have
some long trips,. as far as the Duluth to Buffalo, where
__ we have'to transit the-two connecting rivers and of course
__ just the sheer mileage element. of it, it’s‘a long, a long trip |
‘’ and oné that js quite (32) susceptible to delays. And, in
- fact, that is the large delay we are running into right now,
two of those. vessels that I mentioned in the’ Baiffalo
area, two of the three have been in voyage now some
thirteen days “without benefit of eeayy any opportunity
to. use.a shore facility.
Q. Well, now, in. planning soinething like this, ‘the
'- size tank you will putin, why do you plan to contain all
of it rather than just the human waste? A. Well, as we
~under’stand ” it, this is where we would have to. go, even-
~ tually, that this,is not our first, approach. We would prefer
“to treat the sanitary waste but if we are under a ‘no- *—
- discharge situation, we must look at all containment then.
Q. Do you. now what a noxious substance is? A.
Well; I think I would know one if I were close to it. How-
ever, I don’t know a legal. or a normal definition, no.
Q. So, it would be your position, then, Mr. Groh, if
‘ you were to. put in.a holding tank, you - would want to:
_contain everything SO that any noxious substance would =
\ e
41.
be covered?. A. Yes, it would. There is a great expense
in the time element of reconstructing a vessel and if we
-are going to do this, we would certainly want to have the
feeling that when we were doing it, it would cover the
‘entire situation. —
?
(33) Q. Now, how Lie a tank would this be at each —
end? A, Well, we are talking about a tank that is, oh,
in the order of twenty by ten by thirteen or about the
size of a one-and-a-half car garage at either end of the
vessel:
(Wiereuten plaintiffs’ proposed Exhibit No, 2
marked by the reporter.) © .
Q. Now, Mr.. Groh, would you please examine this
document that has been marked as .Plaintiffs’ ‘Exhibit 2.
and indicate what it is, please? A. Well, this is 4 profile
_ of a deck plan of one of the larger ships of our fleet. This ~
isa 25,000 tonner which would represent in turn as large
a ship as you will find on the lakes today.
Q. Would you please point out to the court the
*various spaces there and what is located in the space?
A. This ship is a cross section and, moving back from the
bow is this area up to where I have the pointer, is termed
- the. forepeak and this is the collision bulkhead, and;
normally, this is really a void space preserved for the
protection . of the vessel and also may include some
machinery this day and age, as with the bowthruster.
This would be the area where this. machinery weuld now
be located. However, you don’t usually put serviceable
gear, not gear that you are going to ‘use daily.
(34) In the next atea, from here to here, is normally
ternied the blind hole—blind. And this area is used for
starage now of potable. water, drinking water, which the
vessel does have to carry, and that is this tank that is
cross-hatched right in the center of this blind hole area.
Above this level are all living quarters for the crew and,
the vessel.
From this point aft are the cargo holds. in this case;
- in this ship, there are four holds, one, two, three, ‘four;
{ ;
“af
- of course, the edudaaa and the aa tania ee "for:
ne |
Sn ae eee —
oth jerear, emma ns me rns: SRO RBIS SPAN! FAS Ab BRE OE PEAR IONE > EA ay
e
42 |
and which bangs you to the: machinery section, from
here aft, below the ‘so-called spar deck level, from this
level down is all occupied by the vessel’s propulsion equip-:
ment; fuel tanks, and associated equipment to make |
thé vessel serviceable. From this deck up, once again,
is the living quarters, primarily supplying the rooms for
the afterend crew and also back aft is the galley, all -
of the commissary spaces are located aft. a
Q. What is the space underneath the cargo hold?
- A. That is ‘& ballast tank which you see here. It is an
inner bottom but it is used for ballast water. The entire
| length: of the vessél. The tanks aft under the (35) engine
_ space are also used for feed water, pure water, for use
in the’ boilers, reserve feed water.
Q. Now; if you were to put, these large tanks in, Mr.
' - Groh, where in this particular vessel would. you be able
: to put them? A. I am not too sure.. There is no“space
that is left open and unused as it is all used for some
purpose right now. So in a sense you would have to
either relocate existing or pack in tanks,, maybe this tank
that I referred to as a 20,000-gallon tank, you certainly, |
aren’t going fo put that up against your drinking water -
tank. There would‘have to‘be a void. It might have.to be
separated in a number of smaller tanks, actually, to get
-that kind of capacity. ;
. There is no hope of using a ballast tank for untreated +
sewage as this seems extremely impractical. Back aft, ;
you have the same problem as ‘there is no open space
that, in which—now, ,Back aft, here, there is a tank that
is used for drinking water. That wasbuilt into the vessel
originally and there is no.other open space other than
relocating, as I am not too sure that is a practical solu-
tion, or going up on deck. And, to go on deck, it brings
other problems of carrying a weight that high in the ves-
sel, it would have to (36) be a substantial construction
~as to handle such a tank of that size and weight high up
in the. ship.
Q. Why is it not practical - to put untreated sewage
in your ballast tank?, A. Well, because all of these tanks,
‘of course, are the main structure of the vessel and they’
~
| 43 —. ——
are subject to periodic inspection ‘to maintain this struc,
tural integrity of the vessel, and this happens, of course,
on short: notice, if there is any suspect of the ship’s hull
envelope, has suffered damage, or as also happens, even
without suspect of damage, every year, at least once an-
- nually, inspections are ‘carried out within the -inner bot-
toms; and then, of course, we have a five-year requirement
for both the American Bureau of Shipping and the Coast
Guard in which there is a total inspection of all spaces.
Q. How is this inspection made? A. It is made by
men actually entering the tanks and:examining, crawling
in the tanks physically with a. Hight and a small hammer |
and to actually visually inspect the structure within the
tanks. . . ;
(37) Q. Going back to plaintifis’ Exhibit 1, Mr.
Groh; where would pump-out facilities have to be estab-
lished if you were to put these tanks in your vessels? ..
‘A. Well, in order ‘for us to conduct our normal trade in
a businesslike manner, we would have to have pump-out :
stations at all-of the—at one end of the—at one end of
the.other, we would have to have, or ptobably both, at the
loading ports and unloading ports, so, I think we are
talking about a pump-out station at basically every port
I mentioned. These ports, as far as loading, however, or
on a practical-basis, the loading period is so short in time
and you are shifting the vessel, if you are under an ore
dock from spout to spout, this is realy not a very practical
spot that you would pump out while you are loading.
_ The more practical pump-out would’ be. at discharge,
at- an: ore receiving facility where you normally (38)
would be in port from, oh, an eight-hour, an. eight- to’
ten-hour period, and not repositioning the vessel during
that périod; but that would, of course, mean that you —
would need pump-out facilities. at all of those various
ports that I named earlier.
Q. In other words, for the servicing s of your,,trade,
ae would have to establish ports outside of Michigan?
. Oh, yes. |
Q. In other states? A. Oh, yes.
a]
4: 7X
2 RMA Sa Sec ME CONN So tp Stal EI MAB PN ab Sie DRAB
44
Q: All right, now, Mr. Groh, what is your relation-
ship to the Lake Carriers’ Association? A. Well, I am
naturally a member, but I am also the chairman of the
Fleet Engineering Committee.
Q. What is the Fleet Engineering Committee? A
FEE PRE ROE LS Sw Pa
‘Well, the Fleet Engineering Committee is a standing com- »
mittee which treats with problems that are basically of
a mechanical nature to the ships; as propulsion, as serv-
ices of a mechanical nature, ‘boilers, main engines, and,
of course, all the associated systems that go with the ship, ,
like your refrigeration, the drinking water system, and,
of course, we have been: consitlering for some time the
treatment of sewage. -
'Q. In what form has this deliberation takeh, in what.
form has (39) it taken? A. Well, the, most recent time
is we have been involved with reviewihg what the various.
ships. of the members of the association have done with
their vessels: ‘as far as equipping them and looking—from |
that experience, looking ahead to what’ we would recom-
mend should be done in the future. And we did Beveloy
a report along these lines.
Q. And what would you recommend? A., Well, our |
-recommendations included a, well, a test program; and_
the test program in turn was split into three, three parts.
We were going to look at incineration and also at
what we called full holding and partial. holding. And“the
partial holding was where you would have a treatment .
plant which would remove the most. obndxious material.
It would treat the effluent and of course then discharge
the’ effluent at some known quality, but, would seemi to
have the advantage to us that of reducing the total volume
as to be handled aboard ship. Those were ‘the -three
principal areas which. we fe deserved further investiga- a
tion.
Q. Well, now, on this partial containment system that
you mentioned, what would be the result in ports, for
example, (40) when youcome to the dock? A. Well, if
we still had to pump dut the effluent ashore?
Q. Well, could you retain the effluent? A. Well: we -
could—we could contain it while: we were in port.
° .
j Pon nee ee
45 |
Q. That’ what I mean. A. Yes, we would have. the
ability-to contain’ it. while we were in port that eight or
ten hours. If it was then acceptable as when we were
away from the restricted waters, so as to discharge this,
_ yes, we could make a practical attempt at a lamas that
incorporated this as a concept.
Q. In other words, actual treatment aboard the vessel
‘then? A., Yes, it would be treated.
Q. What level of treatment do you. think you could
achieve? A. Well, I would think we could achieve, well, - 7
some of the ships have in a sense treatment that is similar
to primary now and I would think that we could come to
-a secondary level without too great.a difficulty.
ok * *& sk
Q. Now, Mr. Groh, I hand you here a document -
marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 3. Would you please tell us
what that is? A. Well, this is a listing of ships that -
7 have. been equipped with sewage treatment equipment
_and that obviously was prepared by American Shipbuild-
ing: Company because they (41) are the people who have
built this equipment to date.
‘Q. What is the nature of that equipment? A. Well,
fgom the ships involved here, by their names and I can
recall the time they were built, this is the equipment that
"is of a macerating-chlorinating type.
Q. How does it compare to pennery treatment? A.
It compares very, very well. |
Q. Such as. primary treatment on land? A. Very
close to primary treatment. _
Q. Now, Mr. Groh, I hand_you here a document
meted as Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 4. Would you examine that
and tell us what it is, please? A. Well, this.is a kind of
initial listing only this picks up the vessels’ names and
time from the biogest development, in other words, you.
‘might call this a second generation of the sewage treat-
ment equipment.
* Q. What is the biogest? A. Well, the biogest is a
sewage treatment plant which is on the aerobic concept,
46
you actually use compressed air along with the holding of
the material and, it is by admitting the air and the oxygen
in it, you have a digestive process going on. This is really
approaching, in many ways, (42) secondary treatment.
Q. The same as in the municipalities? A. Very close.
Q. Now, Mr. Groh, is it practical with this biogest
system to provide a holding tank after the effluent has
been treated so that you could retain your waste in port?
A. I believe it would be, yes, once again, if we did not
have to hold materials, you see, as I said, on loading time
of eight to ten hours, say, give it another two hours, some-
thing like ‘twelve hours as retention time is where we
would discharge no .effluent whatsoever, I think that is
practical.
Q. But then you-would have to discharge it out in ihe
. lake on the run, is that right? A. That’s right, after you
have cleared: port, you go well beyond shoreside facility,
- we would then look forward to discharging the effluent,
'.the treated effluent.
- Q. What other devices. have you attempted to de- |
velop—I am thinking specifically of other vessels now. A.
' Well, in our own case, we have taken on the trial of an-
incinerating situation as we haye equipped two-of our
vessels strictly on an experimental basis, a trial basis.
_ They are just now in operation this last two weeks. , The
one ship here’ has made a preliminary report and we still
have’ some problems -aboard. So far,- the information is
(43) sketchy, of course, but. we seem to have a problem
of incinerating, of -handling the volume. We can inciner- .
ate but we are, by observation, not: by measurenient yet,
‘but bysobservation, trying to vaporize too much. volume —
for the set-up that we ‘have. :
Q. Why is volume a problem? A. Well, the volume in
_ this case, this happens to be a—we are putting the material
into the main boilers of the vessel hoping to make use of
the—as muth of the parent equipment in the ship as pos-
sible. . If we could introduce this into the hot zone of the.
* boiler, we had hopes that it could be vaporized and the
material completely incinerated. However, you can see
“y
47
that if you .admit too great a volume in any one area of
the furnace, ‘you just absorb too much heat from the fur- -
nace to totally do the job and instead of the material va-
. porizing in a sense whilé it is airborne and passing up .
through the passages of the flues of the boiler, you are
getting still condensation dropping to the floor of the
boiler, in this case, through the grates. That is what we
can observe as being an obvious thing, too much volume.
Q. Well, what other devices are you familiar with that
might be in the experimental stage? A. Well, there <i
| ‘several others. There are devices of the electrical-chemica
type.. These have been developed by (44) different man
facturers. And they have keen—have been or are cur-
_ rently on test in vessels who are > members of this associa-
tion.’
-_ Q. Do. these devices iavolve overboard discharge?
A. Yes, they do.
Q. That is* because of the volume problewi? A. Yes,
I would say that is primarily it.
* * * k *
Cross EXAMINATION by Mr. Carrier. .
> a es s | oo
(47) Q. What is. the length of the trip, please?
A. I was trying to figure miles for you. The normal
~ round trip to Buffalo—in the frain- ‘trade, is that what you
are asking?
Q. That was the question. A. Well, in the grain trade,
it has a lot of time to it, as an-example, bécause of the slow
loading and slow unloading. The trip would be about
twelve days. o.
of * * * *
_(48) Q. All right, now, can you tell us the amouht of
flush water per man per day that would be required on
these toilets? A. Well— - -
- Q. Let me— A. It would be an estimate.
Q. All right, sir. “A. Because very few of the systems.
are separated. enough to totally measure it; but I would
say roughly one-third of that 125. |
Q. Roughly 40 gallons; is that correct, sir? A} In that
neighborhood, yes. 5 | f
“ %& oe x x *
(49) Q. Okay, sir, now, taking the number of men
that you have signified in your prior testimony and as-
‘suming the number as thirty men times forty gallons per» -
man times the twelve days, well, what resulting gallonage
do you get? A. I get—the exact numbers I get, 14,400.
; a re ee ee ° .
(50) Q. ‘All right, just roughly tell us, if you will, by
converting, that twenty two forty long—I don’t have the
figures—at twenty two forty, how many tons do you have?
A. You are obviously going to have about fifty tons.
Q. All right. Is that the weight of the holding tank
_ that is ‘required, sir? ‘A, Well, that is the weight of the
fluid.
' Q. All right, now, how souch j is the weight of the ‘arile
proper minus the fluid, if you know? A. Well, I don’t
‘know exactly— ar . :
a * “KS
(51) Q. Al right. Now, let me ask.you one more.
* question, Mr. ‘Groh: In your opinion, if a wire tank,
that being the weight of the liquid, how seriously would
. that affect the stability of the vessel, if at all? A . Well, it
would depend on its location.
~ Q. Let’s assume, sir, that it was ae on the center .
line amidship? A. Low? -
aoe Q. Low, sir. A. Well, if it-was low snouas and the
tank was fully pressed up, as a full weight, you had no
free surfaces, for instance, at this point it would be an add
on to stability. : .
Q. There would be no detrimental ‘effect as to std-
bility; is that correct? A. Not if it was so located.
%* *k * * *
&
4\
(52) Q. In the biogest system, am I correct that the
sewage wastes are placed in a collecting tank for fast
All A. The wastes go into one large vessel, yes.
Q. All right) A. One large tank. :
Q. And then is it not true that the ‘overflow goes into
a second (53) vessel? A. That’s right. . a
Q. And in that second vessel, as I understand it, it is
aerated; is that correct? A. It is aerated.
Q. And then the wastes-are fed into a third vessel or.
{
compartment; isn’t that true? A. (Nodding).
Q. And then they, are sprayed with chlorine; is that
‘correct?
., Judge Keith: Excuse me, sir, would you please
answer because Mr. Cushran can ’t get that when you |
are shaking your head.
The Witness: Oh; yes> yes, that , is the general
_ description. of the macerating— 7 »
Q. And'I suppose if the chlorine treatment is effec-
tive, that is fine, and if not, the contaminated waste, is put
. overboard; is that correct? A. ‘Well, yes, the waste goes,
overboard. | °
* Q. And if it.is contaminated, it remains that way?
A. Yes, if the plant has not been ee as it should, it
does go overboard. ,
|
a (55) Q.* * * Is it true, witness, that the Manitowac’
oe System utilizes a straight holding tank on their ves-
sels, if you know? A.:I have- heard that. I do not know
it to be a fact. .
Q. And that the Amenean ear Company of Whiting,
Indiana, has equipped the vessel Tamoc ee
galley water, and . sanitary water? A. I have likewise
heard that but ‘could not verify it.
Q.'And that the American Oil Company have
| equipped similar retention systems on the vessels Amoco .
of Indiana and Amoco Illinois? A. That I do not know.
isconsin with.
‘.a complete sewage retention system including sewage,
i
. é »
50
. Q. And that: The Munson, which is. owned by U.S...
_ Steel,-is equipped with a G:E: unit, being an electro-me-
chanical incinerator. Do you know that? A. Yes, I know
that.
. five tons? A. I believe that to be correct.
Q. And that that G.E. unit separates: solids and incing-
rates them. Do you know? (56) A. I don’t know that it~
it still has an effluent, to the best of my knowledge. . ©
Q. And, are you aware that on the Hobinson, which:
is owned by ye Steel, that that vessel is equipped with
the Zimmer-Hyde chemical, méchanical incinerator? A. :
. Yes; also they have a liquid disposal problem. »
Q. And is it not true that the Zimmer system con-
sists of chemical treatment and filtration of the waste? A.
It does.. And then the liquids still have to be disposed of
somehow.
Q.. And ‘isn’t the eitinent under that system passed
through an evaporator for boiler feed water? A. That is «.
one method of using. the effluent, yes.
Q. And under that system, isn’t the’ resulting 4ludge .
burried in the boiler? A. This is still in test.
Q. Well, I know all of these systems are experimental,
sir, but don’t you agree that that is the manner in which ©
the Zimmer system works? A. ‘Yes, it works on that con-.
cept.:
Q. All right, sir. ane are you aware, witnéss,: that
'S.S. Consumers .Power owned by. the American Steam-
ship Company has installed the Zimmer system? A. Yes. :
* -(57).Q. And that Johnson Shipping’ Limited, of To- -
_ronto, has completely fitted its. vessels with self-contained
toilets? A. What was that name again? ~
Q. Johnson Shipping, Limited, of Toronto. A. Ihave
no knowledge of that.
Q. And that the Wisconsin-Michigan Steamship Com- ©
pany has installed total retentiom holding tanks on their
vessel, The M-V Highway 16? A. I have.heard that said.
Q. And that the: electrical toilet ‘known as Incineret-
®
4 ; »
Q: And that that GE. unit is but eleven by seven by_
five feet in dimensions and weighs but 10,000 pounds or
~ jae _
~
or | cates Det Sa OA ‘
“ ; e ; 7 . 5 1
~ Urifial has been ‘installed on vessels of the Wisconsin Steel
Company? A: They have some type of toilet..
Q. You are not even familiar with their system, are
you? A. Not.under that cemenaieey as—what did you
call it?. > ~
Q. Incineret-Urinal, sir. A. This is what company, wt
- International Vatiesicr?
Q. Wisconsin Steel Company, sir. A. ‘They, have one ~
vessel. (i
_- Q. They have oné vessel] with that system; is that cor-
‘rect? ‘A. Not to my knowledge. '
Q. Okay. A. That is not correct.
Q. Were you aware that total retention systems are .
_ provided on (58) six vessels of the Ford Motor Company?
‘A. That. they are planning? |
; . Q. No, they are on. Were you aware of that? A. No,
I am not aware of that.
(61)
Re-Direct EXAMINATION by Mr. Elder.
Q. Mr. Groh,: you indicated you had some docks:
Would you point out where that dock is, please? A. This
dock is located. at Detour, Michigan, in the lower part of-
the St. Mary’s.
- Q. Have you. installed. pump-out facilities? A. No,
we have not.
Q. Why? A. Well, two very big reasons.’ Ope is that
we would have no idea of what kind of size of piping, lo-
cation of the connections on the dock face; we have no
idea of what we are going ‘to match up with. And then
the secondary hold up is probably even primary in nature
because there is no place to discharge the material after
it were pumped ashore. If there is no munici al sewage
treatment plant in (62) the entire area.
Q. So if you did have a pump-out station, here would
be no place you could pump it—there is n ‘municipal
system? A. That i is correct.
a a
‘a
w
a
. _ , = Se: 7
Re-Cross EXAMINATION by Mr. Carrier.
ee Q. DidI understand from you, witness, that you testi-
.-+ | fied that the treatment ‘aboard the’ ship was commensv- :
ae rate with primary treatment, or did Ismisunderstand you?
AL _In%onnection.with the older style, maderator-chlorina-
oe
Q. Yes: At —as produced by American Ship Build- ’
‘ing Company,— . 3
. —. @ Yes. A. —that i is correct: _ vhs
of, + Q. I wanted to ask you, in the course_df‘your edu- ~
cation, do you have a degree in sanitary engineering? A.
No; I do not. | . Cow .
Q. Then, basically, I ‘mean, unless you had that com- .
g petence, could you distinguish between primary and sec-:
ondary treatment? ys A.. Well, it would. be best left. to
others. _ , : | ; ?
¢
. ta (65) |
. CLARENCE McTev1a, being se sworn, was examined _
and testified as-follows: :
¢ Direct EXAMINATION: by Mr. Elder.
Q. Captain McTevia,. what is your present occupa-
tion? A.‘}, am*retired now. Shipmaster.
.. , Q. And what license’ of aaeter A. Master— -
A. Master of ail waters and Great Lakes pilot, from —
“Cape Pinhead on Lake Ontarjo to Duluth in Superior.
_. Q. When did, you retire, Captain McTevia? A. Just
this spring, April’7... *
| Q. Of this year? A- That is correct. |
, Q. How many years. experience - have 5 you ‘had on the
* Great Lakes? A. 37 years. |
—.-Q. How long i in the capacity of a licensed officer? A.
Since ninet een—spring of 1941. * :
Q. How long were you a master, active master? (66) .
OA Seventeen. years. . aN : :
. * ee * * 5
53.
(67) Q. Now, re would like you to examine the chart.
of the Great Lakes and. with respect to these vessels, show
the relative trades of these respective vessels, starting first
of alt with the Carrolton. A. marsing on the Carrolton,
then?
Q. All right. A. The Carrolton, she ran, carried’ pig
iron from Buffalo to Saginaw, up into Saginaw. And we
“used’to go up to Calcite and load stone for Republic Steel.
in Buffalo and go back to load pig iron. again for Saginaw.
’ That was the Carrolton. va
- In ’55, I traded between Toledo ‘and Ashland, Ash- *
~ land, Wisconsin, carried bulk iron ore, it was confined to
bulk iron ore until the fall of the year. Ee the ast
- seven, trips I remember; the last seven trips we come out _
of port inland down to—down to Buffalo, down to Black |
Rock Canal, through Tonawanda.
| Judge Pratt: Would you give the states in addi-
tion to the ports, .please?-
The Witness: All right, sir. Let's 7 Ee se:
(68) Buffalo, New York, pig iron, to Saginaw, Bay .
City, Michigan. Then we carried stone from Rogers City,
Calcite, back to Buffalo, New York. .° \
Then we go to 1955, on.the flat decker. We carried
iroh ore out of Ashland, Ashland, Wisconsin, down to To-
ledo, Ohio. And then on the last seven trips we carried
stone out of Port Inland, Michigan to-Buffalo, New York. .
Now we go into the self unloader in 1956. That was
‘a dandy. We carried coal out of Sandusky, Ohio, for TS...
ledo, Ohio, loaded coal in“Teledo; Ohio for Detroit; and
occasionally, we used to carry coal out of Sandusky. to:
Erie, Pennsylvania. We had 223 loads that year. Fifty-
_ six. Fifty-seven was the E. G. Maguire. That was prac-
tically the-same. We carried coal out of Sandusky for To-
ledo, loaded . coal at Toledo’ for Detroit, occasionally we
took a load of coal from Toledo to Napier, Napier, Wiscon- .
sin. Then we would go across’ the lake to Manistique. or
‘Grand Haven and load building supplies for Sarnia, On-
tario and Windsor, Ontario. Fifty-six, Fifty-seven.
34
_ Q. ‘In ’58; I was on en E. “fate” biaically with
the same trade, between bn 4 and Detroit, Marblehead
. tto.Cleveland, Ohio. Fifty-eig
(69) In ’59; I was on.the steamer Sierra. “She was
. another,self unlgader. And we traded out of Gran@ Haven:
to Racine, Grand Haven to Keriosha, Wisconsin, yes, Wis=
consin. Then from—carried building supplies, stone, sand -
and. the likes of that. And occasionally we load bitumi-
- nous coal out of Soyth Chicago fer Oak Creek, Wisconsin;
then back again to Grand Haven, to Manitowa, Ludington.
Most all of the—most all of the shoreline there of Michi-
gan, almost all the ports.
| Let's see, fifty-nine; sixty. -
In sixty, I sailed the J. R. Senvibar: We ran . between
gsouth Chicago and Racine and I was in that trade there
for two and-one half years,°a round trip every twenty-
* two ‘hours, carrying coal to Wisconsin Electric, Oak Creek.
Then in sixty-three, I sailed the W. W. Holloway
from Toledo to Detroit, almost exclusively. between To-
ledo and Detroit.
And, let’s see, then in avy tive I sk the steamer
Ashland and she sailed between: Silver Bay, Minnesota
to Buffalo, New York. ‘That whole season, except for
three trips-to-Toledo.. That was in the first year. .
* (70) The second year, we started out the. season be- -
tween Silver Bay; Minnesota to Buffalo,.New York and
after about two and one-half months, we started to éarry
coal from Toledo,’°Qhio to Buffalo, down the Black Rock
Canal to Tonawanda and Periot, New York. That's right
on the Niagara River. ; 6
-“Let’s see, sixty-six, sixty-seven. In sixty-eight, that’
was a short season. We sailed between Silver Bay, Min-
~ nesota and Toledo. |
_ Sixty-nine. Then, in 1970, the last peasen 1 was on,
we dealt exclusively between Silver Bay, Minnesota and
=
a!
Toledo, Ohio.
. I think I have covered all the Great Lake, mast every |
- port. NN 7
(Whereupon Plaintiffs Proposed Exhibit No. 5
; marked by the diana )..
-\
°
— ——us what the jines-signify?-AAll-are—separate—courses, a a
~~
“
you mean, well, you could say that.
‘ ° ; . : x
2. 3 .- fe a . - ?
-, Now, Captain, I would like you. to look at this |
chart which has ‘been dnarkeg. Plaintiffs “Exhibit J — A.
wd
Yes.
Q. and you notice these various fines going up the
lake and so forth? A. Yes..
Q. Would yousplease explain to the court what those -
| lirfes are? A. Well, let’s start out, start with Mackinac. - —
These are (71) downbound courses. They are separated, |
the upbound and downbound' courses. The upbound
steamer, and in case of ; foggy weather, it keeps them
separated. . |
This: downbound, this is. a thirty mile stretch here, E
you come’ on by, you come down. here to 205, 186, ‘then .
_ you: come, you dispatch yourself from Chicago, on by the
gas buoy, most all. traffic goes down there. Then they
run either to Gary, Indiana Harbor, south_Chicago: a
the likes of that.
Now, these are all upbound courses, all the four ‘up- |
’ bound courses’ from. different departure points, but they
-all-cofiverge up here at,Big Stable. They come: upbound...
off Point Betsy and come up-around between Sleepin
Bear, north and south Manitou—there is the North Mani- °
tou Light, up by way of Maisley Passage, up to White -
Shoal and then they. join again at Straits of Mackinac.
~ Q. Now, you will notice these lines, would you ‘tell
all separate courses, all indicate the—it. says northbound,.
it’s quite obvious; and it gives the courses and the dis-
tances.
Q. Aren’t they sometimes called limits? - A. No, I
have never heard it referréd to as limits. They (72) a are—
there is north, you know,—
Q. Well,— A. Northerly limits and easterly limits,
Q. Don’t you mean by limit, how far east or “west .
you are supposed to go when you are on this course? A: *
You are supposed to stay right on your course, you know.’ |
» You can drift off in case of bad weather in the. fall of
J
the year. It is not unusual for us to go right up along
ud
oo
P iantet el IE A ORL sian Cota OS Siskin ms Ps
FS aka aaah accbaline
- and three quarters.
(Whereupon ~ Plaintiffs © Proposed ’ Exhibit 6
| 56
the shore hére, up either southbound or | but
you are supposed to adhere to: these courses, that is, as
close to them as possible. a -_
Q. All right, Captain, I fave a pair of dividers here.
Q. All right.—and. tell us, please, how - far off:
upbound course is from, we will.say, Grand Haven, s
with Grand Haven? A.:Grand Haven: Let’s také the-
course here out of Vern’s Ditch, ‘Vern’ S Harbor. _Approxi-
mately 30 miles. . 7
Q. You pass 30 miles from the shore® . That’s ‘he
I want you to step down— A. Surely. ..
hod
-easterly course, the one out of Indiana’ Harbor is even
further, and from south Chicago is even further.
(73). Q How far is that course off? A. The westerly |
course is 38 miles. .
\ Q..How about Muskegon? A. Muskegén, let's s take
the westerly, just exactly 30 miles. -.
-Q. All right.‘ How about the point of Big Sable point?
A. Forty-three miles off.
Q. Forty-three. You don’t. even have to measure
that? A. No, it says so right on there, see.
-Q. I see. A. You don’t have to.
Q. How about the next poe, A.: Point Beta. five.
marked by the reporter. ) ; ;
“9. Captain, -I would like you to examine this chart
: that ‘has been marked Plaintiffs Exhibit_6-and tell us what.
it is, please? A. -A chart of Lake Huron. |
Q. And’ would. you indicate the-courses on oe pee
~~ have the B. P. O. ‘location, ‘which’ isn’t on i eve. Siac chie.
with the (74) Lake Huron Light, we have the southbound
courses. This is the southbound course, up right through
here, up to Detour. This separates here at Lake Michigan.
Now, leaving Detour, this is downbound, the downbound
' courses. Now, this here, we didn’t pick this downbound
his. ¥
o Kye
-
>
.
. , nn a
37 met
course out of Cove Island—it i is separated. This here i is the ,
-upbound to Cove Island.
Q. Now, on the downbound « course, Captain, how. far
off Harbor Beach does it measure? A: Twelve miles.
-.Q. Twelve miles? A. Twelve miles.
Q. How about on the upbound? ‘A. Upbound is five.
Q. Five miles Sff the Beach?.-A. Five miles off.
- Q. Where if the next—how about up around Alpena *
there to here? A. Up around Alpena,, you pass, I think
it is—yes, four and one half miles off. -
Q. ‘So, at-no time are you closer than four and one
half miles to shore? A, No, no, no, not at any time.
(75) (Whereupon Plaintiffs’ Proposed Exhibit 7
marked by the reporter. )
‘Q. Now,, Captain, will you examine this - -chart that
bas been marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 7 and tell us what it
is, please? A. It.is a chart of Lake Superior. —
. Q. Will you indiéate the courses, the usual veestl
tracks, on that chart?. A. The southbound coursé, starting
at Whitefish Bay, on up to Manitou Island, Eagle’ Harbor,
Outer Island, Devil’s Island, and then this takes you into —
Superior, Superior. Wisconsin _—
_ Q. How far off Manitou Island do you pass? A.
Three and one half miles.
Q. And what is the other closest point you come to?
A. The other closest point would be five miles off Copper
_ Harbor or Eagle Harbor, that is the closest, and your five
—four and three quarter miles off of this point. And you
are only a mile and a half off of Whitefish.
= Q. What is,located at Whitefish Point? A. It’s White-
___fish Point ‘Light and a coastguard station. , .
Q. Just a coastguard station there? A. Justa coast-
‘guard station, that’s correct.
Q. There is no village or city there? (76) A. No,
none right i in that area, no.
Mr. Elder: Your honor, I would like to move into’
- evidence Plaintiffs’ Exhibits 5, 6 and 7.
J udge Edwards: Any objections?
s
CE RIO PAES OR TMB el sn eS
.
38
Mr. Carrier: No objection. .
Mr. Maslowski: No objection.
. «Judge Edwards: They will be received: ,
: , Is the point of all this, Mr. Elder, that any re--
'.* quirement of emptying these tanks would mean going ~
off course? ‘
the—_
‘J udge Edwards: Why are we being treated to this .
lesson in Great Lakes geography, then? ‘
towns and. villages along the shoreline discharge” di-.
rectly into the lake. ATI of these. cities with one or >
two exceptions. have just primary treatment.
Judge Edwards: I see. And you. are going to
‘show this later on? | ; a
aan _. Mr. Elder: Yes. ,
— - Judgé Edwards: And that is your equal protec- .
tion, I suppose? .*
Mr. Elder: Yes. .
(77) JI udge Edwards: All right.
_ Mr. Elder: Also, we are showing that the vessels,
so). forthe most part, aré way out in the lake where you
\. _ are getting greater dispersal of sewage’ rather than
just a-short pipe from the shoreline. |
Judge Edwards: All right.
\
a Q. (By Mr. Elder, continuing) Captain, did
bring some other charts with you of your own? A. Yes,
‘on the desk’ there—no, that’s not them, back there on the
. Seat.
Q..Oh. You will have to put these i in order, Captain,
_ Start with the head of the St. Mary’s River. A. You have
got the St. Mary’s River first? Oh, yes. _
sf? Mr. Elder: Could you mark this?
. (Whereupon Plaintiffs’ a aad Exhibit 8
marked by the reporter.)
> QQ. Will you examine this ch4rt that has been marked
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 8, Captain, and tell us what it is. A.
Mr. Elder: No, your honor, we want.to show that’ | .
Mr. Elder: Because, your honor, all the cities, ~~ -
‘ s°
. ° °
; .
e o.
. ° OS: -
59°C; . . -
Pa
. : . te
- =
These are my own, private charts. I renew them every.
year. I put my own courses in.: I do this so I can navigate
in fog and radar. This is the head of the Sault River. ‘Here
“is Gros Cap here and the Internatienal Boundary Line.
¢ This is the International Boundary Line right here. . ;
.. (78) Q. Would yeu explain your course.in relation-
ship to the International Boundary Line there? ‘A. Here.
is your-International Boundary Line here, ‘and I am on
—* . Q. Now, Captain, the reporter can’t get it down when
vyou,say up here. You have to refer to specific points. A.
@h, I see. As we go on Gros Cap, I am in the waters of ©
United States jurisdiction.. Arid as I come down to Round
' * ¢Island, the Round Island turn, I come back into the Cana- |
' dian: waters. Now’ I amin Canadian waters and’I go ;
around by Point Aux Pins. And after I leave Point Aux
- Pins, now I go down into the U. S. waters again and I pass
way down here and I kegp going down here through the
_ Sault locks, down into the lower rapids cut, I am in U. S.
waters all the way. Now, that’s the first, that’s the start
/ . of the Sault River. Do you want the next one down?
fo aad Q. Take the St. Clair River next. A. St. Clair River?
4 Q. ¥és. A. Okay. ‘This is Detroit. This is th’ St.
_ Clair River, that one right there. ° oe a .
_ (Whereupen Plaintiffs’ Proposed Exhibit * 9
marked by the reporter.) _ ; ‘
' - (79) Q. Captain, examine Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 9;if you |
would, please, and tell us what it is. A. This is the head -
of the St. Clair River. It will take you down into the Flats, ©
_northend of Lake St. Clair. - ; et
_ Q. Please explain your courses in relation -to the In,
ternational Boundary Line, will. you? A.- The Interna-
tional Boundary Line .runs moré of less right down
through the center of the St. €lair River until you get
down to Stag Island. Then, well, you are here in Gnited
States waters and I always refer to the old channel, strict-
ly in Canadian waters there. ° a . 2 ‘
_ Now you come down below Stag Island and we are -
still on the United States side until you get to. the lower
9 - N60)
Pf”
-end of Stag Island. And now we are back and forth, we
are in Canadian waters.’*I would say we are probably in
Canadian waters two-thirds of the time the,rest of the way
- down to the St. Clair River. .
| Q. This ‘is downbound? A. ‘This is downbound. And
upbound you are almost the same.
Q. All right, now, how about going spbound | on the ©
St. Clair River? A. Well; starting at the lower, end of the»
. Flats cut-off, this is strictly Canadian. Now you are in
Canadian waters almost all the way up to Algonac. Arid .
here you see-saw. (80) back and forth. First you “re
in Canadian waters and then you are in U. S. waters. .
] + - - Q. How about on the right, way g:p the river? A.
; - The rest of the way up the river you are mostly on the |
United States side. Occasionally you will move over when. .
you get up to Indian Point, Port Ffuron. That’s it, right
at your left hand. :
Q. Left hand? A. Yes. You might find. they aresthe
same, upbound and downbound. —
Q. Yes. os : )-
(Whereupon Plaintiffs’ Propesed Exhibit No. 10. *
marked by the reporter. ) ~.*
Q. Now, Captain, I ask you to examine the diiart |
- marked as Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 10 and tell us what it iss
please?. A. Detroit River. «© —
Q.. Would you explain the courses, both upbound id
. . downBound with respect to the International Boundary
; Line? A. This is called the head: of the Detroit River, the
; upper end of Belle Isle. You can see where the, Inter-.
national Border Line crosses at the coastguard station.
The coastguard station at the head end of Belle Isle is just:
5 inside, just on the side of the United States: Now we are
‘* “ ° in’Canadian waters almost all the way down thg river.
) (81) You See my courses that I have laid 6ut here are
4: almost’dead in line with the International Boundary Line
: - |* until we get dowrf to Zug Island and then-we veer off |
: - slightly.to the right there. Then come down to the Fight- _
| ing Island. Channel and after we pass half-way down Bal-
= Me NG
. lard’s Reef, we are in Canadian waters again‘all the way . Pe
down, © te 7 |
- Q. Now, A. At’the head end of this, here is thé
‘downbound chanrtel here and theye is the boundary
line here and we are in Canadian waters all tte way down
until we get almost down to the Detroit River Light where
-
_ We go back into the United States waters. a
" . Q. Now, hoy about the course on the upbound voy- _
age? A. Upbound, naturally, this: being a channel, you #
don’t go wandering off much, from the downbound chan-.
_ nel, just to keep out of the downbound guy’s' way., But,
_, after we pass the Detroit River Light, now we’are exclu- |
sively in the—we.are in -the Amherstburg channel, all
Canadian, all Canadian, up through here. N OW we are up
__ as far as the Livingston Upper Light, halfway: up Ballard’s
_ Reef, back into'U. S. waters again., - - age
- Now we are almost=theh yo y are ‘in United States
_ waters until you get up to. Zu sland, just above the '
Rouge River, the Rouge River gut, Now we are back (82)
’- in Canadian wars. Going upbownd, we. try toystay in-
Canadian waters, just inside. We can’t € over ajquarter _
of a mile off the beach or else Canada is calling us up_and ‘
telling us we are-exceeding the speed limit: We. are only - |
allowed eight miles an hopir, eight miles an hour, a~quarter
of a mile off. Beyond the quarter, we are Allowed ten.
. * Q. Now, Captain, in the Detroit River, will you tell: .
us how_the current sets? A. Yes. Well, in‘the Amherst- ._
--burg channe]l— © . . ’ ..
_.. Q. Well, could you start up at the. head ofjthe— A. -,;
- You want to come down? a Se we
- Q. Yes. Come down’ the river. A. Okay. Here we -
have—we are coming from Peche Island, the front range is
-over here. We come down from here. We have a terrific ¢,
. $Setdown through here. All the current sets, you go right
- straight down through here. 7 |
- Q. Could you tell us which way it.is eeriing in rela- .
. tion to the next boundary? A. It is Setting to-the west.
It is setting to the west here, until after we get in here
and make lee on Belle Isle and the we more or less lose
é ; °
62
_ this all the way down. You just -stay in “the center. -
* You don’t veer. The current all sets over to the lower
' side of (83) the river. ©, \
e
Q. You mean the westerly side? A: On the westerly =
side, yes. Then you come down into the Fighting Island
North Light, your set is to. the westward here. also, :
_ extremely to the westward, you got a tremendous current
going down through here. The ship just seems to want to
go right sideways, you have got to be very vautious* in
making this turn ‘here. |
And now after we get to the lee of Grassy Island, the
current is more or less right straight behind you, right
straight behind you here. ‘And in this case where ‘the
current comes down the side of the channel, is when it
~ will set you over on this side. And then you come down =
einto Ballard’s Reef ‘and here wt have a tremendous set.
It sets to the westward, southwestward. We have all this °
‘current coming down through here and it sets you to the
_ westward here. — ; |
Now, in the case of entering the Livingston channel,
here we have a current that just seems to want to keep
passing right straight down to the Amherstburg channel
so we got to be very. cautious here.
Now, you come here, ‘you are Boing towards. the east,
towards Canada again. Now, we ‘pass down through the
Amherstburg (84) channel, . the Livifgston channel.
Now, the current, after we pass through the dikes, will
start. you to the east again, well, naturally, because the ~
flow is around in this way, down to the eastward...
Q. Will you look at Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 9, Captain, and
~would you tell us how the current sets in the St. Clair
River -with respect ‘to the International Boundary Line,
you see, from Canada to the United States, and so forth?
A. Okay. Coming downbound through the rapids¢ this is
’ the Port Huron Rapids, where the International Boundary
Line®, right down through the center. The current here
‘is in all directions: It’s a regular whirlpool, right in this -
area here. But down here is g strange thing. This current
comes down ‘and it sets, backwards and gomes up around ~
Y . ~
= a
. e .
i¢)
s
here, like here, nl sets all the way up in here, up to the 7
bridge here, it goes in the opposite direction, where’ on
one side you might have a current of three and | a half or |
four miles an hour here, but over here, it’s the reverse,
coming backwards, trying to. get in here. is i difficult.
‘The current is all; goes up inside hére. :
Now, let’s.go down past. the traffic buoy. The current
is more or Jess down through the center of (85).the river
here. It will split here. There is quite a current comes
down and it sets eastward, more or less wants to come
down toward the Canadian side. Then we -pass down.
through St. Clair, the current is more or less right behind
- you. Now, we come down here to Recourse Point and this
‘is the area where I live, right in here, and I watch the ice
flow, and this ice goes down, right down inside this~—stays . .
right close to this beach.
Q. Which beach is: that, Captain? A. This is the
between Recourse Point and Marine City. Now the cur--
_rent is.more or less right behind you until you get down
into, by Algonac, and here. the river splits, the north:
channel and the center channel, north and south channel.
‘In here we have a tremendous current, here the current
sets to the west. It follows this.old channel. The channel
_is down through the south channel, through here. Until
,\ we get down to southeast pin Light Point: Now,-the river -
is divided. This is the old southeast bend channel. This
has been dredged out. There is,a tremendous current t goes:
through here and the ship wants to set right down on n this,
point. So you have to “hold up. The current | is all going
to the (86) westward.
Q. Then, generally, is it true, Captain, that the—the |
majority of the river, the. current sets to the side, from
the Canadian side to the American side? A. Yes, yes, it
oS uh-huh. -
(89) Q. Now, Captain, assume that you were to re-
_ quire every vessel passing through the Detroit River to
stop and pump out holding tanks, what would happen? |
beach, -you know, this is-the east Chandler township area —
~
4
|
:
OP: mets We ra decay ger: —— Re epee
“yee
wage nse mn rer2y mama oe re
5
~
. 64
A. This is—this i is really re on It couldn’t possibly—
you ‘would have a backup clear to Buffalo.- You would
have steamboats;waiting hours on ‘end. I know what it’s
like because I had to ‘stop at the Consolidated Fuel to put
-on fuel. It takes us about an hour or an hour and ten
minutes or an hour to put that fuel on therg. In no time,
there will be four or five boats backed up befind you wait-
ing to put fuel on.
Q.-What would be the situation if you had a pump- .
out station there, we will say, at Benton Harbor—noj (90)
Benton Harbor, but Muskegon? A. This is nother ridi-
‘ culous—this is impossible. You couldn’t possibly work it
out. You would have boats again backed up, all.that stuff —
out, all those steamers out of Chicago, Indiana Harbor,
~ Gary, they would be. all backed up there. You couldn’ t—
no, it’s not—it’s ridiculous, to even think of it.
Q. So, if you did this, you would actually be taking
sewage from vessels in other states and putting it into
Michigan? A. Exactly, you would be going from Illinois,
Indiana and Wisconsin into Michigan and “dumping it,
dumping the sewage. |
(91) }
Cross ExaminaTIon by Mr. Carrier’
Q. Captain, you signified on your exhibits there. that
you had set certain upbound and downbound courses; is
that correct? A. Yes, that is correct.
Q. And i isn’t it true that those courses are only fecom-
5
‘mehded as distinguished from mandatory? A. They are.
my own courses. In the rivers, we have no designated
courses by lake carriers.
Q. So that there are no candators upbound and
downbound courses; is that correct? A. We must stay in
safe waters, that’s all. \
rt +, & ;
(92) Q. Let me ask you this: As you transit the De-
troit River waters,.do you shut down the sanitary system?
A. No.
_
a , . «
e°
; : 65
Q. And, certainly your responsibility in navigating a
ship doesn’t have to do with whether. someone is using
' the urinal; is that correct? A. No, definitely not.
Q. Okay. Now, if you did pump out: at’ ‘the twelve |
mile limit, twelve niles off shore, isn’t it entirely possible
- that your sewage might be picked up by,a passing vessel?’
is one close by.
| it true, sir, that some vessels on the
open waters of the Great Lakes do in fact draw in .water
for drinking purposes? (93) A. That is correct.
* * * KS : ,
Hartow B. MEno, being auy 2 sworn, was examined
and testified as follows:
Direct EXAMINATION by Mr. Elder.
(105) Mr. Elder: I asked him if he had made any
calculations as to the size of holding tanks that would
be required on an average Great Lakes vessel, con-" -
sidering the variety of trade. ~ t
' Judge Edwards: Well, you can answer that ques-'
tion, Mr. Meno, and I guess you can answer it*yes or
no.. Have you made such calculations?
The Witness: I have.
Q. Would you tell us = results of. your calculations,
please?
Judge Edwards: I think we “will let the witness
- testify. .
A. Well, I figured that a tank about eoudiily ten by |
twelve by fifteen feet, ‘which is 18 hundred cubic feet,
_which would hold roughly 13°thousand five hundred gal-
lons forward and aft,-should satisfactorily, under normal
‘ circumstances, and without unanticipated and accidental:
delay, suffice as a holding tank for the normal operation of
.
/
66
a ship. Now, that would be two tanks, roughly ten by.
twelve by fifteen feet, one at each end of the boat.
Cross EXAMINATION by Mr. Carrier. eo
(109) Q. And on, let us say, the South Chicago to
Muskegon two-day run, you: wouldn’t need a very large
tank, would you? A. Well, if you were trading—if you
were trading regularly South Chicago to Muskegon, or if
you were ‘trading regularly from one stipulated port. to
another stipulated port, and in the trade of.that sort, why,
then you would just have to’ figure as to how many hours
you were between docks—
Q. Yes, sir. A. —and how many hours it will be to *
completé a round trip. | »
Q. All right, sir. Now, you sndicated that. “the fiitings
aboard ship and the fittings at the emptying facility had to.
coincide; is that correct, essentially? A. Yes.
Q. Would there be any reason why you couldn’t
dump the sewage into an open manhole that is connected
with an existing sewer system? (110) A. Qh, no, no, you
could pump into that as well as anything else.
~ (112)
CHARLES SPOONER, being duly sworn, was examined
and testified as follows:
Direct Ex AMINATION by Mr. Elder.
, Q. What is® your occupation, Mr. Spooner? A. I am
chief engineer of the marine consultants and designers, a,
firm. of naval architects and remodelers at Cleveland.
~Q. What is’ your educational background, Mr.
Spooner? A. I was graduated from the University—or,
Cornell University in 1934 with a degree of mechanical a
engineer; and in 1935, a degree of Master of Science in
engineering from the University of Michigan.
Q. Have you had any experience teaching? (113) A. _
I taught at the University of Michigan from 1936 until (_
2
67 .
1953 in the department of mechanical and then mechanical -_
and marine e gineering.
Q. What you do after you left:the Warversity of
Michigan? A. I went: to the Great Lakes Engineering
Works, which is a shipyard ih River Rouge, Michigan, as
assistant chief engineer at that ‘point for a matter of three
years or so; and. then became the chief. engineer of the
yard.
Q. What was Great. Lakes Engineering? A. They
used to have a variety of terms applied to them, but, gen-
erally, it was a repair yard in lean times and it was a
‘ building’Shipyard and construction shipyard in good times. .
Q. Approximately how many ships did you build
there while you were chief engineer? A. During the period
1956 to 1960, we constructed’ three new vessels, two of
* which were maximum size. ‘ |
Q. After you left Great Lakes Pnginesn ing, where did
you next get employment? A: I went over to Cleveland
_and joined the firm of Marine Consultants and Designers,
‘which was at that time called H. C. Donner Associates.
Q: Tell-us briefly what does a firm of naval architects
-do? A. We are involved in new ship construction and
. ownership (114) reconstruction and conversion, changing |
the nature of the—depending on the-ehanging nature of _
the trade—new construction would be a matter of, in the
past nine years, since I have beeh with the company, a
little over nine years: we have constructed about nine new
vessels in various, yards—gulf coast, east coast, one in Ire-
land—and, we are involved.at the present time with two ~
_ new ships on the Great Lakes.
_ Q. Now® you say you are involved in construction.
You don’t mean the actual ‘construction itself? A. We are
_ responsible—we were responsible in one vessel for the
contract plans and specifications and have been consulted
since that time upon occasion: ih connection with the de-
velopment of the design by the shipyard, did the detail
work—I am speaking of the new U.S. Steel vessel which
_ is currently building at Lorain. The other vessel is the.
Stewart J. Court, which is the new thousand footer con- |
structed at Erie, which is nearing the final stages of com-
POON ay SPREE OUT EN op yates . a
pletion. On this vessé¥Se were ‘responsible for: the entire
detail design as well as the preliminary.
~ <Q. You actually designed the vessel? A. ‘That is cor-
rect.
Q. And what are the dimensions of those veneels ‘Mr.
- Spooner? (115) A. The U. S. Steel vessel is 858 feet by
105 foot beam. The depth, I am not quite sure of,. but it is ©
about thirty one and a half feet. The Stewart J. Court,
which is the Litton—Litton built for Bethlehem, is one
thousand feet overall length, one hundred and five foot
beam and a forty-nine foot depth.
Q. What type of sanitation devices are being provided’
on those vessels? A. Both of these vessels -are provided
with the.American Ship biogest units. of their latest design.
The equipment for these, vessels was selected approx-
imately, I guess, three years ago. Both are under contract, on eal
for some such ‘period as that. 2! \
_* Q. Now, if you were requested to make a calculation:
_or design and installation for holding tanks for Great
Lakes vessels, what elements or factors would you con- _
sider?. A. We would begin with the length of the proposed
voyage, the number of. personnel aboard, the €xpected’ .
speed of operation, in other words, the overall elapsed time |
is of the esstnce as far‘as the particular part of it is con-
cerned. The size of the‘holding tank would be, to my way ©
" of thinking, equaliin size to the fresh water tank (116) or
greatér, depending on the method of operation. )
Q. What about contingencies such as storms or ioe
or delays, such as the failure of open locks, ° that type of
‘thing? A. It certainly should be provided for. I would
gather that you are getting at the size-of the fresh water
storage tank and therefore the size of the holding tank.
' The quantity of water which we Have been using in the
last several years is in the order of 40 thousand gallons for
a vessel that will have a five or six day round trip, based
on four thoysand gallons per day, which in turn is based
on approximately thirty to thirty-five men.
. Q. Now, have you made a:calculation such as you
have mentioned here with respect to holding tanks? A.
Well, -if we are expected to hold the entire quantity of
ee
water which would be coming to us in the period of, say,
five days, or six days, if that is the normal round trip, it
would be—it has to be somewhere close to the Same vol-
ume that is stored in the potable water tanks, or, if it is
not stored: there, it has to be—potable water, can, of
course, and is picked up out in the open. lake, in clean
water, and put into these storage tanks so that conceivably .
your holding tank’ must be bigger than yOu watee storage
~ tank. | | ,
a (117) Q. Mr. Spéoner, I ask. you to examine Plain-
tiffs’ Exhibit 14, marked for identification 14, and tell. us
what it is please? A= This is the capacity plant which is
prepared by Great Lakes Engineering Works fot a vessel;
__ No. - 301, which is the Edmund Fitzgerald, being the first ©
vessel built with 729 feet overall length and 75 foot beam, ;;
which is at that point the maximum.size that was to be
permitted ‘through the MacArthur Lock.
Q. What size capacity tank did she have for ate? |
_ A. She has very close to twenty thousand gallons aft and
twenty-two thousand thousand gallons forward, in ‘the
potable water tanks.
_ _ Q. Would you point out those tanks, please? A. This
is the forward one in the dark hold and this is the aft quae
underneath the fuel bunker. —
Mr. Elder: Your honor, I offer this in evidence at
this time, just .to show the relative size of (118)
these particular tanks to the vessel. -
_Judge Edwards: Any objection?
Mr. Maslowski: No objection. «..
‘Judge Edwards: It may be received. .
(Whereupon ‘ Plaintiffs’ Proposed Exhibit . 15:
- marked by the reporter.)
| Q. (By Mr. Elder, continuing): Now, Mr. Spooner, I
-; hand you a document marked Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 15.
Would you examine that and tell us what it is, please? A.
. This is the midship section drawing for hulls at Lorain, .
867 arid 868, which respectively are the steamers Philip R.
_ Clark and Arthur M, Anderson.
—
i ae
| (Shows Proposed Exhibit to opposing counsel.)
Q. Now, Mr. -Spooner, ‘if the owners were to request
you to install holding tanks, where would you recommend
they be placed in the vessel? -A. In this particular series
_of vessels, it is conceivable that the holding tanks could be ~
placed within the side tanks as individual tanks, con-
structed that the hulk structure can be examined all .
around, and, hopefully, that they could be piped which”
would mean really that you would have to have four tanks
in the vessel, two forward and two aft, adjacent to the
quarters; and. also adjacent to the lo¢ations where the
pumps could be used (119) and the piping connected.
Q. Would you indicate on that drawing, please, that
exhibit, «where the side tanks. are? A. To you, orato the
court? (Turhing to bench.) .The side tank is this area
here. This is the top of the tank. The bottom is connected -
to the inner bottom tank’ her There is ng subdivision
‘ between the two. And it is Sxccivable that in an area
“such as this or an area such as this, the tank, or the series ~
_ of tanks could be gonstructed. If it is in a constricted
area, the tank would be of an odd shape and it would be
‘eonatracted most expensively—very expensive to build
because of the location and the shape. The other locations,
then, of the side tank, would ‘involve considerable change
in the vessel itself to be able to maintain the capability of
- handling-cargo in the normal fashion.
Q. Would you actually take a fencil and indicate. on —
_. that exhibit: where those side tanks are? A. Yes, sir.
- (Complying with request.)
| Q. Now, how does this vessel “compare With the. older
vessels built between, say, 1907 and 1940? A. With re-
spect to the nature of the structure?
Q. Yes. (120) A.- Primarily, the structure is today,
or at this time, because actually, these vessels were .con-
structed in 1952: At the time that they were constructed,
the change had pretty largely taken place from riveting
to welding. There is still a fair amount of riveting in the.
seams of the’shell, but the—outside of being larger and
_ being refined in some details and designed around the fair
9 °
* as the biogest system with later holding tanks that hold
a 3 es "1:
amount of welding, the midship section of an older ship. 8
does not look very far different from this. . |
_ Q Was that with respect to side’ tanks? A. With
" -respect to side tanks and the bottom side shell arches,
which is what is shown on this print. e 4
| Q. Now, would you recommend such a holding tank -
- installation? A. I would. hope that there would be some
other way to build them than to put in holding tanks at
this location in this type of vessel. I do not recommend
the use of side holding tanks, no: © | |
Q. What would you recommend? A. I believe Rat
“a well designed treatment plant can produce a satisfactory
grade of effluent such as to cause no more difficulty or® ‘
nuisance than current systems that. are used in munic:-
ipalities, ae | =
Q. Are there such. systems available for vessels? ._
(121) A.There arene tis«s 7 . =,
Q. Now, what are they—let me-strike that.. Would -
it be feasible, Mr: Spooner, ta have an mstallation such
eRe
the treated effluent so that you could prevent discharge
in ports and congested. areas? A. Yes, I would say that _
would be a very feasible way to do it. The treated material
coming from thesé units could be stored for a reasonable
length of time in such tanks as the ballast tank, if that
would be agreeable. : a
a | (122)
Cross" EXAMINATION by Mr. Carrier.
Q. Were you present in court this morning, witness,
when we discussed the biogest system as a three-compart-
ment system? A. I believe I heard that .statément made. -
. Q. Can you tell me whether or not the biogest sys-
tem, the three-compartment system, would in fact be
larger than the holdirfg tank you propose here? A. The
biogest system, I do not believe, is a three-tank holding
system or a three-tank system. It consists of a multiplicity
of passages and tanks. The sludge material along with
-~
¢
; ? »
netted Rule wy alate. phy oa RRNA
Ney Rens
< . ‘ | Bef
Ne 5
the after maceration is recirculated and is reinjected tir
after time until the sludge is digested. There is a very
small amount of solids that «are fn suspension: carried on
and: when it is finally gotten to the last tank, it is chlo-
rinated and there is a timing device that holds it until
chlorination has been able to destroy a kifge percentage
--of-the coliforms, and- from there xt is “pumped over . into ©
_. a proposed holding tank such*as'mentioned here. The
‘ size of the unit is roughly six feet: by-eleven feet in base,
but about #x and a half to seven: feet tall, for a piece of
‘equipment that can Handle approximately 50 men.
_ 7
ti a * * * -
Oe
(127) Judge Edwards: Mr. Spooner, before you
leave the stand,— »° .
| The Witness: Yes, sir.
Judge Edwards: —I would like to ask you a
question or two. It seems as if the thrust’ of your
testimiony.is that if you had to do something about ~
the pollution problem arising from shipping “hat you
_ would prefer heading toward the idea of an internally
contained treatment plant on shipboard? —
The. Witness: Yes, sir. — |
‘Judge Edwards: Is. that correct * os
The Witness: Yes, sir, that is correct. |
Judge Edwards: As a matter of fact, that would
end up being more expensive in terms of capital cost
and operation than the holding tank’ problem absent
the layout problem, would it not? © .
The Witness: It would be my opinion that it
. would be very much less: costly to put a treatment
plant aboard the ship. ee et a” ~~
Judge.Edwards: Why?
- e (128) The Witness: The units cost in the order
of magnitude of twelve to fifteen thousand. dollars’
per unit; and in the vessel .of this: classification, it
_ ‘Would require two units. You .are into about 25
thousand dollars for hardware, something. like’ this.
The piping aJready exists in this‘particular vessel *
connected ‘to the central tank so it would be a mat- —
é
\
oy
73,
ter of replacing the very rudimentary unit that is
presently in and putting in the new biégest chong
' The total cost to the vessel would be something, I
would guess, around 5@ thousand dollars.
To put ina holding tank of suitable size, which
i am predicatmg on this physical size of the fresh
water tank, I would be willing to estimate that. a3
125 to 150 thousand: ‘So ¢
Judge Edwards: Is: this _ simply because of the -
additional’ size?
The Witness: .There is fie amount of steel in- : :
volved: and it is located—if/ would be located in the
ship in a very awkward plhce to get at. It would be
very costly to put in; the steel of the tank, to put in .
the welding and construction in. such a confined’
locatio
‘mentioned, is around five and one half to ‘six feet ,
across and ten, eleven feet long and six and one half
dge Edwards: What re the es sizes,
roughly—is it two to one, fdur to one?
The Witness: Per cost?
(129) Judge Edwards: No, ‘in terms of the ac-
tual size of the tank units*involved in the treatment
tank facility and the holdifg tank (facility?
The Witness: The treatment tank facility, as I
feet high, approximately, the size of it. The holding
tan®® in the location such: as this, if wedo it the way
my sketch showed. it originally, would be eight and
one half feet tall, which*is the available space verti-
cally. It would be an average breadth of about five
feet and in order 'to contain with one tank, to contain
ten thousand: gallons, it would have to. be thirty-five
feet long. -:
Now, tHere is that space in the tank, in this side -
tank, but. you have to have roughly four of these :
things to get up to the volume that you have in your
fresh water tanks. There, are other ways ‘to do it, -
most ef which would ,be equally expensive—other
places to locate the tanks.
PENS TaN OTC pee os ere
rs)
—
“\ ; f | 74
&e |
(131) Juidge Edwards: Might I ask another ques-
| tion of you, Mr. Spooner: Since the probability is
{3 _ strong that you are not one of those who has to crawl
through the ballast tanks, what is your view as to.
= whether or not it is feasible under some cirgyfin-
stances to use ballast tanks for holding tanks?
(132) The Witness: Why, I-have been there. I .
have done it. And I would certainly hope I would.
never be asked to go in one that had been used for
a containen like this.
Judge Edwards: I don’t think that would be a
good answer, but does that, mean that under all cir-
cumstantes you would have todo that? — |
The Witness: No; I- would say that your—if you
put raw material in against the_hull. structure of one
of these vessels, you ‘would be asking for some serious
trouble because. I would not anticipate anybody
would care to examine things ery closely. There are
many places where sludge and other material of that
type would hang up.and would create a very un- —
pleasant, at the very least, situation in the tank.
Judge Edwards: Well, really, this may be per-
fectly obvious to you, but the Act says tliat under all
circumstances there has to be inspection of the— -
The Witness: The hull structure.
Judge Edwards: —the bailaét tanks?
. The Witness: Yes, sir.
Judge Edwards: All right. THat is dat I really
wanted to know.
t
aaa a
oe
ae
15
| (133)
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Carrier.
Q. Let me ask you this, please, Mr. Spooner: With ©
the holding tank, there is essentially nothing mechanical
_ that can go wrong; isn’t that true? A. Except the settling |
out of the solids to the extegt where they may be difficult
to dislodge and also except for the fact’ that improperly .
operated, without any mechanical devices, you must de-
pend on a fair amount of chemical added to maintain the
material in a not too suitable septic condition. © )
* * * *
- (137):
Joun E. Kinney, being ‘duly sworn, was examined
and testified as follows:
Diregz, EXAMINATION by Mr. -Elder.:
Q. What is your occupation,- Mr. Kinney?’ A. Sani.
tary engineer consultant, ‘self-employed. _ oe
Q. Where do you reside, Mr. Kinney? A. Ann Ar-
bor, Michigan. | se |
Q. What is your education? A. Bachelor’s degree in
‘civil engineering with a major in Sanitary engineering, |
in 1941; Manhattan College; Master in civil engineering
with a major in sanitary from Cornell University, 1942. —
Q. What has been your experience? A, I have worked -
with the New York State Department of Health, with
the—in the United States Navy, CB’s, in water supply
for. the Marines; and with utilities in the Philadelphia
Navy Yard; for a consulting engineering firm in Spitz-
berger, for five years with the Ohio River Valley Water
Sanitation Commission, the Eight-State Compact to clean
up the Ohio basin; and since 1954 I havé been self-
employed. = _ * (1
- Q. Was all this éxperience you just described in con-.
uy
nection with sanitary engineering? A. Yes, in the broad
scope of water management,.water supply, (138) waste .-
' disposal. -
e
P-.
1° ARIE Reem aWCR ey 01
76
Q. Are you a registered professional engineer? A. I
~am in five states, including Michigan...
Q: In what states, please? A. Michigan, Indiana,
Ohio, Pennsylvania* and ‘New York.
~Q..What professional societies do you belong to? A.
Several, including the American Society of Civil Engi-_
"neers, the Nativral Society @f Professional Engineers,
American. Society of Testing Materials, American Water
Works, Sewage Works and some others.
Q. By whom are you generally: employed in your
consulting work? A. Principally with industry, but I have
been and am acting as a consultant to state agencies, to
municipalities, to civic groups and am on the Interior
Department’s Advisory ° ‘Committee on: Water Data for:
Public Use. - _ .
. Q. Before what Congressional Committees have you
appeared? A. Before the House and Senate Public Works’. ¢
Committees, the Government Operations Committee, In-
Nero, working with the House Public Works Committe
an advisory capacity to the majority and minority on)
legislation for the last six or seven years.
Q. To what publications, if any, do you contribute?
A. Well, presently I am a contributing ‘editor to InpusTRY
WEEK.and InpuSTRIAL WaTER ENGINEERING. <
(139) Q. What is it—what is that publication? A.
The—in both of them, they ,are b e trade journals for— -
the one for industrial managenfnt, the other one for
people who are active in the mae ‘management field,
' either supply, re-use or as treatment.
Q. Now, you indicated your field is sanitary engi-
neering. What does that encompass? A. Well, in the
broad scope, it covers the scope of all the areas that are.
related to the health of man, it includes water, air, land +
dispo8al,rodent control, disease factors.and while I stay |
‘on a peripheral activity in the others, my role is essentially
in the water end of it, but. the decisions in air or deci-
agions in water or decisions on land: affect the others. They
are not able to be separated. |
Q. Now, what is the basic purpose of pollution con-
f
? oe ine Se SS
77 |
trol and how is it defined in bens of standards? A. The
purpose is to provide for the utilization of resources, to
protect the uses that are deemed in the best public in-
terest. We are using water as such as a resource for
health, for public water supply, for recreation, fisheries, .
for navigation, industrial water usage. The idea*is to de-
termine the: usage that is to be protected and then the
aMinition. of the standards of quality necessary to protect
those uses and then develop an implementation (140)
plan to achiévé those objectives, which is essentially the
heart of the and the objective of the, Federal.Water Pol-
lution Control Law and the state law.
Q. Now, how does one relate performance standards .
to the standards designed for the‘protection of water uses?
A. Sometimes that can be quite difficult. The idea is to
develop the quality that is needed in the receiving water
for’ the- protection of the use and the. normal degree of
treatment that would be necessary for individual sources
of waste that would achieve those objectives. Sametimes
for administrative purposes or administrative ease, we
reduce these standards down to uniformity of discharge
or control at point of discharge. The difficulty, though, is
that once that is separatéd from the stream standards:as
such, there is never a guarantee that achieving that -ob- _
jective will accomplish the result you want. oe
It also works the other way. You can dino far
on a performance deal and actually provide a. prohibi-
tion on a discharge. You may accomplish the protection
of the water use you are looking for but you end ‘up pay-
ing a penalty by interfering with other—with some other
use, or additional cost. It may cause an air pollution
problem; it may use additional cost of money that could
go into better advantage (141) in other areas of the en-
vironment. ‘°. - | 7 _ po
Q. Now, public law 167 of Michigan was adopted to
‘protect the waterways of Michigan. Does it in fact? A.
In my opinion, it really doesn’t. It can under some cir-
cumstances. It. can also cause difficulties under others.
* The principles on which we are operating with waste
a
2
78
‘ treatment is to provide something that will be reasonably
reliable, be able to provide a degree of tréatment that will -
" protect the usage and then where possible provide for |
further advantage to dispersal types of devices. What we
are looking for is to maintain a minimum concentration.
When you collect waste on a ship and bring it ashore,
actually what you are doingxis concentrating it further
‘ at a given point. Our volluen problems are essentially
_ along the shore. ‘They are not out here in the water.
The problem then, by bringing it ashore, you further
increase the requirements necessary for treatment on
shore or at the shore before they can be discharged. For
small vessels, for small boats the matter of convenience
of collecting them on the ship or in the small boat and
bringing them ashore is reasonable.
~ On small inland lakes, it is highly reasonable to
prevent any kind of discharge i in the waterways, but when
(142) it comes into the larger activities, the objective is
to accomplish the quality of treatment, the water quality
desired as quickly as is possible. :
When the administrative rule which calls for _—s ,
able treatment devices was changed in the law to eliminate
that and limit it totally to holding tanks and/or incinera- .
tion, it meant that until such time as equivalent treat-
nfent devices are provided on shore, instead of accelerat-
ing pollution abatement from ships, we are actually delay-
ing it because we are bringing the wastes ashore to a
_ point to provide for treatment that now does not. exist.
Q. Are there pollution control device$ used an land
er ashore comparable to the biogest system? A. Yes; one
ofthe big difficulties that we have had in pollution abate-
ment.has been to develop these facilities that could be used
for small installations, a small number ‘of homes, a°shop-
_ping district, small resort area; and the trade has. devel-
opéd ‘a package unit that for all practical purposes holds
the sewage long enough to burn it up, to reduce the
organic matter down to t#e point where it is mostly ash. ~
These facilities are used on shore. They. discharge
into very small brooks. They are permitted under state.
s
19
law in areas that’ are recreational areas. And I have (143)
‘personally experiences, controls and checks in areas where
these residual streams is practically the’ total flow from”
one & these that went down to a: . park where children
-were playing in, because while there is ‘still a bacterial °
count, the time is long enough so that the pathogenic
count which carries the disease is pretty well burned out.
If there is chlorination in addition, why the chlorination
will assure the final destruction of the pathogenic bacteria.
And, actually, the application of a similar type unit
. then on ship should be identical in principle, as what you
are going to be doing is providing a facility to make a
- water that is acceptable for quality that is not noxious, it
is not unwholesome. It seems to me as though the equities |
would require the same kind of treatment devices in both
places. Since putting these. on ships can be done ch |
faster and accelérating the program rather than wait for
the on shore treatment to build up. to it7 we would take
_eare of the pollution from the‘vessels “uel faster than
by taking that route.
Q. Have you seen the biogest system? A. Yes, I
have. a
Q.’ Would you describe it for us? A. ‘Tt is a self-con-
‘tained unit which is about six-by ten or (144) twelve,
some seven or eight feet high, six or seven feet high. It
‘is a series*of tells wherein the waste water is put through. :
a grinder, a comminuter type operation, tears down—tears
down the heavier solids into small particles, and then by
- re-cycling it, you build up the biological activity in there *
that actually converts the organic matter over to carbon
dioxide and water. This is the same principle that we have
in the activating sludge plants for the large cities or these
package plants for small communities. By holding it in
there, if it is properly designed and operated, the residual
discharge is going to be uniform day in and day out.
Now, as far as-the operation is concerned, one of the
requirements when the trade was working on the units for
‘small communities or small groups, or areas, was to recog-
nize that you are not going to have qualified operators ?
%
at ate
7) .
‘running a plant at all times for each community. as, I
mean, for a shopping district, so that what you want to do
is to build in something that i is virtually fail-safe: These
are. Some states require a meter or actually a recording
meter;on the dévice so that they can go around to check it
_ to make sure that the motors have ‘been running through
_the whole period of time. As. long as they run, the results
are’ going to be acceptable. FE tn ne
(145) Q. Now, Mr. Kinney, it has been suggested
that fhese vessels could use their ballast tanks as holding.
tanks for raw.sewage. Do you have any comment on cared
.A. One of the difficulties that we encourage (sic) i
. municipal treatment units is the accumulation of ene g
in—against metal surfaces. Even though the solution ©
may be aerobic, the contact between metals and the solids
_.goes anaerobic which means that there is no oxygén’
present. The decomposition of that product is exceedingly
acidic and you begin to have considerable deterioration —
and corrosion of the metal. _
To take a holding tank in a ship which really wast
designed for easy flushing or cleaning, to allow the settling,
the material to be standing in there for a period of time.
-. would mean that the solids would settle out. While you
might be able to pump them, pump out the bilge water
that might be in there or replace it with other water,
unless there was an actual inspection of it and a thorough
- flushing each time, you could well have settling solids that
over a period of time would give you the corrosion that
you are not interested in obtaining, taking much of.a hold
on the bottoms of ships.
Q. Is there any particular health problem in connec-
- tion with holding tanks? (146) A. They can be controlled
_. by the amount of chemicals that are added, but when you
‘add chemicals to maintain odors, you can. alsg find that if
your ship is going to be running for a longer period of time
than expected, the waste waters become quite septic. The
health may not be impaired but the odor is such as would
give rise to objection. ©
Then there is another possible difficulty, too, and that .
~ is in order to keep the bacterial activity from really gen- .
a1
erating in there, to give off gas, “and unless this-control is
maintained— incidentally, if it goes anaerobic, the gas that
is given off is.a combination of methane and carbon
monoxide which is explosive. We have learned the hard
way that you have to design sewage treatment facilities to
prevent—to antetpate the pessibility ar an explosive mix-
ture.
_But assuming that you could aintain the qualiges Ye)
that the explosive mixture didn’t develop, which would
mean that you would be adding some type of a bacterial
static chemical to bring about bacterial action. Comes the
_day when you pump direct into the municipal sewage
treatment plant, the sewage treatment plant will receive a
slug load. The city of Detroit could well dilute it out. This
kind of waste discharge into a small community, particu-
larly if they had secondary treatment, would meu a")
' the operation of the treatment plant. :
One of.the biggest difficulties that we have in ome
munities are small industries or laundries dumping batch
loads. They do upset the municipal plant. I would hate
to see a program established_that.would actually promote
. operating difficulties by bringing these slugs into the small
community;and 40,000 gallons out of a ship would bea
~ slug load or it could even be a slug load for the city of
Detroit, depending on how close to the sewage treatment
plant it is discharged.
Q. What is primary treatment? A. Samar treat-.
ment is—provides for the precipitation of solids that wil ©
normally settle within two hours retention time, because,
you know, everything organic uses about one third of the
oxygen demand of the waste water and it may or may not
be followed by chlorination for sterilization purposes.
Q. What is secondary treatment? A. Secondary treat-
ment, the solids in sewage are about one-third soluble
~. and one third colloidal—very fine—that could be precipi-
tated with chemicals—one third’ of them will -dissolve.
The secondary treatment is taking the effluent from this
primary settling and adding a bacterial action (148) to try
to tend to destroy the colloidal and dissolve solids.
>
82
Q Can you equate ihe biogest in ‘cums ‘of whether
it is primary or secondary treatment? A. The package
aeration units are considered secondary- treatment and
with the data that.I saw from the public health servige
review, we are checking on these, on actual shipboard
operation. It qualifies very nicely as secondary treatment.
There is about 85% removal of the organic matter.
Q. Taking a few of the ‘port cities around the lakes,
Mr. Kinney, such as Detroit and Muskegon, what is the
status of their waste treatment program, do you know? -
~ A. From talking with people at the state on the status,
we are into: the area yet of primary treatment or with
the addition of chemicals for chlorination,’ and directed
towards a secondary treatment: program, but, there are
some very real delays in the financing of them. —
Q.° What type of treatment does Detroit have now?
A. Detroit has the equivalent of primary treatment but
_they are starting in on a- construction program to go
towards the secondary. Mr. Remus was complaining this
noon to the federal administrators that they are not get-
ting the money that was intended to carry. ‘So@here is a
real question (149) whether it would be the equivalent
of secontlary treatment.
, Q. You don’t know when Detroit will have the equiv:
alent? A. (shaking head negatively )
Q. What is the particular pollution problem in, tie
Detroit. River as far as Detroit is concerned? A. Well,
there is much talk about the effect of the Detroit wastes
on Lake Erie, but if we.take a look at the’pollution prob-
lem in terms of the solid load, in terms of the—which
can settle in the river and cause considerable sludge
deposits, the organics which can consume oxygen and the -
nutrients which can encourage the bloom of algae, the
primary plants take care of the sludge deposits. The
- Detroit River really doesn’t have an oxygen problem
whatsoever as long as the secondary treatment nee won't ©
make a change in the river whatsoever.
pede part,-to go after, the nutrients level, since
- Detroit will.still be discharging at a point into the close »
83
4 ?
.to share waters, even with a ninety percent reduction of
phosphates, the nutrient concentration will still be high |
enough td trigger a bloorA. This is one of:the ironies -of.
designing according to regulations. They could disperse ©
it across the river and accomplish the-protection of the ©
\. downstream river at a much cheaper operation, but it is
we
\\the same (150) principle in terms of dispersal from-a
waste treatment as from a device, as long as it is away
frqm shore, or a ship. :
2
*:. es. Ee
* (153) - ‘(By Mr. Elder) Can you give us a defini-
tion-of sewage? A. The definition in the sanitary engi-
neer’s field is the waste from the—domestic sewage is the
waste from humans, galleys, c mercial establishments
and homes and if takes all body Wastes. It. is a quality
in water such that it would impair use. - It is definitely
‘untreated or inadequately treated, but treated sewage is - |
not sewage. Treated sewage is an acceptable water supply.
And that’s (154) where I differ with the definition that
is maintained in Public Law 167 where sewage is human
_ waste, whether it is treated or untreated. If it is treated, :
then it is no longer sewage, if it is adequately treated.
Q. This is my last question to you, Mr. iinacy:
. Would:.a properly designed and operated biogest unit or .
some similar biological unit providing treated water which
_is—which if discharged into the watérways, would be such.
. as to. prevent it being rendered noxious or unwholesome’
- otherwise? - :
Mr. Garden: Oh, I think that calls fora complete’ -
legal conclusion, your honor, definitely.
Judge Edwards: Noxious or unwholesome—the
only thing that I can see that is objectionable about
a ig that I won't know what noxious means, either,
ich is the objection that the plaintiffs are making.
I think we will let him explain his opinion on this.
- treatment, if it doesn’t render it as acceptable so that
it is no longer noxious or unwholesome, we
a a,
: \
The Witness: Very frankly, with this kind of _
eina.
"\
IRE arty
~ oho Se RNNE
feet Roth HE eo ceencd AON
eo
84
_ real exercige in futility, in putting in these waste
treatment plants. Very frankly, the operdting, tightly-..
| operated (155). waste treatment plants do render
- water acceptable and not noxious -or unwholesome.
3 : .
Se - 4
%
Cross EXAMINATION by Mr. Maslowski.
— Q.-Mr. Kinney, just what is wrong with, say a ship
containing its sewage in the holding tank as far as a pol-
‘ution control device is concerned? A. It will: depend on
whether or not the device is such a ship as the Bob-Lo
tidn of solids and has got a quick pump-out, I would think |
that would be an excellent device, but as far as‘ being a
otal remedy, I think that the other. devices are much
o
which stays close to-port, short hauls, if the holding tarik |
dna designed so that it-won’t have the accumula- .
referable and I think the damages or the difficulties that 7
are inherent in the holding tank are not all gnswered. °
(156) Q. Well, what’s wrong with a holding ‘tank,
for ‘example, Iet’s. be specific. A. -It’s difficult—I thought
I had beeft. before.- Holding tanks, if the purpose is to
provide an acceptable water quality, the purpose of the
whole treatment dévice is to provide a water that is ac-
ceptable for quality, and if the idea is to accelerate that
acceptable water quality, there are other devices and other
means available that can do exactly the same thing that
would be preferred, but in terms of the ‘holding tank
itself, if a holding tank can be small, easy ‘pump-out, and
would have no difficulty. Holding tanks for small boats
‘make sense.
Q. How small of a boat are we talking about now?
A. Talking about the size that would not have mechanica
‘capacity on it to be operated continuously or if the operat=:
ing activity of the boat would be intermittent.
Q. Doesn’t a holding: tank have thié advantage, that ;
the sewage. that is generated aboard. ship is discharged in
this holding tank and it is kept there and then finally the
ship.gets to.a selected paint. and it discharges that sewage
$
~ ©
- 4
% « _
X
~
relatively frequent pump-out, the holding_tank in_ itself.
; 4 oo ee | ; a |
, . : . "85 . ¥ 7 |
at that selected point—isn’t that the advantage of a hold- 4
ing tank? (157) A. I think’ that’s one ‘of the real dis- —
advantages. a y
Q. Why? A. To put 40, 000: gi llons fom one of . hese es 4
into a small municipality in. terms of, the treatment plant, — €.
T-would hate to be the operator of the plant every time
you dump. .
Q.: Aren't. you making = an assumption that every
time— A. Uh-huh. | _*
» —that they are going to unload ‘the holding tiaks, =
it is going4o be iff a small treatment facility and there
ing to be some kind of disadvantage? Let’s assume
- that we have a good treatment plant. What is the dis- at
advantage going to be then?.. A. Only—I am not arguing mi
about jt being good treatment. I am fully Cepeeting you
are going to have good treatment in all communities.
What,I am arguing here is that this unit, once it is estab- _ |
lished as a¥equirement, should be available to be dumped ,
-in.any port that‘ you reach.
If you have got the possibility of diluting. out, largé
volume, such as in Detroit, then you would have an an- é
swer, but in terms of the small town, to-bring this kind 4
of a slug around, you hold it for five days and it is go
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.