Appendix — United States v. Southwestern Cable Co.
Supreme Court brief1968
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
LE ———— a a ne
RSA OFC 7 1967.
APPENDIX .~ |° "7
[RN F- DAVIS; CLERK
SUPREME COURT OF. THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1967 ;
e
~ i No. 363
_- UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND FEDERAL
COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, PETITIONERS,
‘VS.
SOUTHWESTERN CABLE.CO., MISSION |
CABLE TV, INC., PACIFIC VIDEO CABLE
CO. AND TRANS-VIDEO CORP.
- ‘No.428— |
MIDWEST TELEVISION, INC., SAN DIEGO -‘TELE-
CASTERS, INC., AND JACK O. GROSS, PETITIONERS,
. WS.
SOUTHWESTERN CABLE CO., MISSION
CABLE TV, INC., PACIFIC VIDEC?}€ABLE
CO. AND TRANS-VIDEO CORP.
ON PETITIONS FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI Aine
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
; FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT oe
_BILED JULY 13, 1967 (No. 363) AND JULY 27, 1967 (No. 428)
CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 23, 1967
.
. oe
“
- SUPREME COURT OF THE “UNITED STATES e.
i 5: OCTOBER TERM, 1967
.
2
No. 363
a
SE ,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND FEDERAL ~—
«COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, PETITIONERS,
ko | vs. -
| SOUTHWESTERN CABLE CO., MISSION CABLE -
ye TV, INC., PACIFIC VIDEO CABLE CO.
AND TRANS-VIDEO CORP. ) ‘
san ae
-.-’ eae
one 7 No. 428 = :
" MIDWEST TELEVISION, INC., SAN DIEGO.TELE-~_
-CASTERS, INC.,-AND JACK O. GROSS, PETITIONERS,
: . . vs. :
SOUTHWESTERN CABLE CO., MISSION CABLE
ii, TV,.INC., ‘PACIFIC VIDEO CABLE CO.
- AND TRANS-VIDEO CORP.
“ ON PETITIONS FQR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
. TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
ae INDEX |
\ cf , ‘ rege ;
FCC Docket No. 15971 (CATV Rules):
Second Report and Order, March 4, 1966, 2 F.C.C.2d°725. . 1
Memorandum Opinion and Order, May 25, 1966, 3 F.C.C.
WE Goes aac okeeres oi loet eccnasee
Washington, D. C. - THIEL PRESS - 202 - 393-0625 7
\
¥ tte
eee mete . te animate agent sannieen ‘Sianeietat cd
> Mi . ,
e
oe ©
we
“fi ii)
Simnornadum Opinion and Orders Jan. 5, "1967, 6 FCC.
Re 5 he-as we nen eee oes
FOC Docket No> 16786 (in te Midwest Television, Inc.): -
Memorandum Opinion and Order, July 20, 1966, 4 F.C. C.
SURES A eg ed eee ee eee Perr
Erratum to Memorandum Opinion and Order; Slr 26,
ey acs oa as ee ea ee ae 0 ee es
United States Court-of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit:
_Intterlocitory ee ee eee ae be es Pg PEN.
inion, Barnes, J. .......... Peres eee ages
Co curring Opinion, Bly, J, er eee eee ere
-Decrée, Shao per fed ark as See se me eee ee rons oe
a,
| U Oe v
. 5
> -
So
; CATV
% &
ge ee, shes FCC 66-220 |
a ni BEFORE THE hs
| FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
> . « 7 .
, Wasuincton, D.C. 20554
Ni
- In the Matter of: ) : er
AMENDMENT OF Suspart L, Parr 91,To Avorr | Docket No. 14895
; Ruies anv Reeuiations To GovERN THE. :
GRANT OF AUTHORIZATIONS IN THE BusINEss : .
Rapio Service For Microwave Stations To
Retay TEevision SiGNALs TO COMMUNITY | _
ANTENNA SYSTEMS. ; :
AMENDMENT OF Suspart I, Parr 21, To Aporr | Docket No. 15233 -
Rvuies anp Recu.tations To GoveRN_THE /
GRANT OF AUTHORIZATIONS IN THE ESTIC }
Pusiic Pornt-ro-Porint Microwave Rapio
Service ror Microwave Srations Wsep To
Retay Teveviston Broapcast SIGNAKS TO
Community ANTENNA TELKVISION Systems. | ° .
AMENDMENT OF Parts 21, 74,AND 91 To Aporpr | Docket No. 15971
Ruies AnD Reeutations RELATING TO THE | (RM. Nos. 636, 672,
DisTRIBUTION or TELEVISION Broapcast Sic- | 742, 755; and 766)
NALS BY ComMUNITY ANTENNA TELEVISION | *
Systems, anp RevaTep Martrers. 4
\
Seconp Report AND OrpveER oe
. (Adopted March 4, 1966)
‘By THE Commission : CoMMISSIONER BARTLEY DISSENTING AND ISSUING
A STATEMENT; COMMISSIONER COX DISSENTING IN PART AND CON-
CURRING IN PART AND ISSUING A STATEMENT : COMMISSIONER LOEVIN-
* | GER CONCURRING IN THE RESULT AND@SUING A STATEMENT.
‘1. On April 23, 1965, the Commission issued a notiee of inquiry
-and notice of proposed rulemaking in docket No. 15971 (30 FR
6078),*which divided the proceeding into.two parts. In part I the ,
Commission reached an initial conclusion that it has jurisdiction over
all community antenna television (CATV) systems, whether or not
thicrowave facilities are used, and proposed to extend to nonmicro-
_ wave CATV systems the substantive,provisions of the carriage and
nonduplication rules adopted for microwave-served CATVs in dock-
ets Nos. 14895 and 15233. First Report and Order in dockets Nos.
. 14895 and 15233, 30 F.C.C. 683; Memorandum Opinion and Order in
dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233, 1 F.C.C. 2d 524. Part I also invited
comment on varjous auxiliary questions affecting all CATVs which
. Were not resolved in dockets Nos. 14895 and-15233. These have to do
‘with color duplication, educational television stations, station-owned
translatots, and a possible transition period before the carriage pro-
, 2 FCC. 24
Lies ln Temtie>s
U : f wr 4 -
id
2 ~—s Federal Communications Commission Reports
visions are made fully applicable to existing CATV: systems with lim-
ited channel capacity (notice, pars, 33-36). |
2. In part II of the. proceeding the Commission initiated an inquiry
looking toward possible rulemaking on broader questions d by the
trend of CATY-development, including (1) the effect of CATV entry
into major cities on UHF independent stations, (2) the possible need
for limitations on the distance a station’s signal may be extended by
CATV, (3) “leapfrogging,”* (4) program origination or alteration by
” CATV and the related question of pay-TV or combined CATV-pay-
a & . TV operations, and (5) various miscellaneous questions. In paragraph
7. 49 of part II the Commission adopted an interim policy, pending the
outcome of the proceeding, i> tear that a microwave applica-
tion to serve a CATY system in %eommunity with four or more com-
mercial channel assignments and three or more stations in operation.
(or with at least two stations in operation and one or more stations
authorized or applied for) must be accompanied By a clear and full
showing that in the particular circumstances'a grant would not pose a
3 . substantial threat tothe development of independent UHF service in
poe area. <A like showing. was required-for microwave facilities to
j setve a CATY system in an “overshadowed” community where, be-
cause of its proximity to three or more existing stations, any new CHF
’ ‘station would be independent in operation. * In paragraph 50 of part
II, the Commission proposed an imterum rule along similar lines t
govern nonmicrowave CATV entry into such areas. _ ;
’ 3. Comment on part I and paragraph 50 of part II was due at an
earlier date than that specified for the remaining portions of part IT,?
which, it was anticipated, would require more lengthy consideration —
and possibly a further notice to afford an opportunity for comment on
any specific rule proposals of the Commission (notice, pars. 64, 68).
Comments and reply comments on part I and paragraph 50 have now
been fully considered by the Commission. This report and order deals
only with these aspects of the proceeding. * 7 f)
PART I. THE CARRIAGE AND NONDUPLICATION PROVISIONS
3 ; g P
4. In proposing that the substantive provisions of the carriage and
nonduplication rules governing microwave CATV systems be ex-
tended toall CATV systems, the notice emphasized (pars. 27, 30) that
{wo main issues were presented: (1) Whether the Commission caa:
appropriately proceed on the basis of its present statutory authority,
and (2) whether any special problems of substance or. procedure are
posed by rules going to nonmicrowave systems. We turn now to a
discussion of the first issue. oa
5. The threshold jurisdictional question is twofold: (a) Whether
_ the Commission has jurisdiction as a matter of law over nonmicrowave
1“Leapfrogging” means the distribution by the CATV system of more distant signals in
+. preference to signals of stations located much closer’to the system. .
27Commentx and reply comments on pt. I and par. 50 were originally due on June 25 and
July 26, 1965, respeetively. By orders issued on June 16 and June 30, 1965, these times
for filing were extended to July 26 and t. 17, 1965. Formal comments and/or reply
comments have been received from the parties listed in the attached app. A. In addition,
a large number of ‘informal comments or letters from members of the public have been
received and placed in the docket.
2 F.C.C. 2d
CATV
CATV systems under the present provisions of the Communications
Act, and (6) whether it would be appropriate to exercise any such
_ jurisdiction without a legislative enactment on the-subject. In ti
e*
notice we concluded initially, for the reasons set forth in our memo-
randum on jurisdiction attached to the notice, that CATV systedil are
engaged in interstate communication by wire to which the provisions
’ of the Communications Act are applicable (sees. 2(a) and 3(a), 47
U.S.C. 152(a) and 153(a)). It further dppeared to us that the Com-
mission’s statutory powers, particularly under sections 4(i), 303 (f),
(h), and (r), include authority to promulgate necessary and reason-
able regulations to carry out the provisions of sections 1 and 307(b)
of the act and to prevent frustration of the regulatory scheme by
CAFY operations, irrespective of the use.of microwave. However,
we pointed up the following matters (par. 31 of the notice) : ;
While we have initially concluded that wé have jurisdiction, we would
their con:ments fo that case. * Second,s we adhere to our position that
clafifying legislation would be desirable, and have no intention of bypassing
congressional action in this field. Weare clearly concerned here with new
and important questions of policy and law in the communications field.
That being the case, the Commission would welcome (i) a congréssional
guidance as to policy and (ii) congressional clarification of dur authority,
which would lay the troublesome. jurisdictional question at rest. It is our
understanding that hearings will shortly commence. The information
gathered in this proceeding will, we, think, be of assistance to the Congress
‘ in its consideration of the matter. In short, by instituting this proceeding,
we shall gather essential data, both for the Commission and the Congress,
and will have conserved valuable time and be in a position to take final -
effective action in either of two eventualities: (1) Con has enacted
legislation in this field which does not preclude the mmission from
promulgating rules along the lines of those adopted in dockets Nos. 14895
and 15233; or (2) no legislation is forthcoming, and the comments in the
rulemaking proceéding lead to the conclusion that the Commission does
have present jurisdiction to extend the substantive provisions of the rules
adopted in the above dockets to al] CATV Systems, whether or not they use
microwave facilities: In thelatter event, we would be remiss in our statutory °
duties if we had failed to exercite, without undue delay, our existing. juris-
diction and authority to promote a publie interest in ‘this important area.
The rulemaking proceeding instituted by this’ notice will thus be conducted
concurrently with legislative consideration, with final Commission decision
withheld for an appropriate period to afford Congress an opportunity to act.
6. Following the issuance of the notice, H.R. 7715 was introduced
m the House on April 28, 1965, and hearings on the bill- were held
hefore the Subcommittee on Communications and Power of thé House
Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce in Ma and June
1965. In the ‘Conimission’s testimony concerning the bill, it was
stated that the Commission did “not contemplate applying any new
‘rules that we may enact with respect to the rest of the CATV indus-
try until 1966; in other words, until at least after this session of Con-
gress is over and it has had the- ability t6 consider this :problem.”
(Hearings before the Subcommittee’ on Communications and Power .
.H.R. 7715, 89th Cong., 1st :
has been introduced in the Senate, and the 89th Congress adjourned
its first session without enacting any legislation on CATV.
‘e - 2 F.C.C. 24
of the House Committee of ‘Interstate and Foreign Commerce on
i . -
5 ° vate s _ tags - g ~
p. 25.) No bill relating to CATV
>
eat
“
‘ re wastes AOR EE QED
Reet ne eR TERT UE OF f° = PRS aie chiniteiaikess
»
‘
-
4 “Federal Communications Commission Reports
, 3 . i : ; . d ° ‘
7. We think it appropriate, therefore, to take up without further
delay part I and paragraph 50 of the rulemaking proceeding. Here
we note that CATV is tae and expanding at a very rapid rate
(see pars. 31-39, within). We ¢annot ignore the increasing’ risk of
adverse impact on the “public interest in the larger and more effective —
use of radio” (sec. 303(g)) which accompanies the burgeoning CA'TV
development. -See paragraphs 116-117; part, II, within. Further,
it is contrary to sound regulation for carriage and nonduplication to
_ be applicable to the microwave CATV system and or to the »
nonmicrowave, which constitutes the other three-fourths of the indus-
try. And, if the carriage and nonduplication ‘provisions are to be
upplied: to nonmicrowave systems, it would obviously. minimize the
disruption to the viewing public.to do so as soon as possible—before a
large number of incipient CATV systems commence operation and
_ their subscribers become accustomed to service not in compliance with
the rules. It would also appear to entail Jess hardship to the new.
CATY operator to commence operation under the rules than to
“undergo a subsequent conversion. Moreover, removal of the present .
uncertainty would assist local franchising authorities, as well as
franchisé applicants. We have received several inquiries from local |
. suthorities as to when a decision might be expected, with an indication -
in.some instances that action on franchise applications was bein
®vithheld pending our decision. The “introduction of as much stabil-
ity as possible into the planning perspective of those affected by our
regulation” is regarded by us as a “highly desirable objective” (first
report and order in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233, par. 78). For all
‘these considerations, developed more fully within, we think it our
responsibility under the Communications Act to resolve the issues in
-part I and paragraph 50. i ‘ :
_ A. Jurisdiction as a Matter of Law
8. While the comments filed in-support of present jurisdiction out-
number those opposed; there appears to be no need to review the
‘substance of the supporting comments here. ‘The bulk of the sup-
porting comments either restate essentially the same matters set forth
in the Commission’s, memorandum on its jurisdiction and authority
.
* Supporting comments were filed by : National Association of Broadcasters: Association
of Maximum Service’ Telecasters, Inc.: Storer Broadcasti Co.: American Broadcasting
€o.; Westinghouse Broadcasting Co., Inc. ; Fuqua Industries, Inc. ; WTVY, Inc. : Snyder &
Associates ; Western Slope Broadcasting Co.: Black Canon Broadcasting Co.: Mesa Verde
Broadcasting Co.: Houston Post Co.: WKBH Television, Inc.;. Bonnéville - International
Corp.: Mobile Video Tapes, Inc.: D. H. Overmyer: Aroostook Broadcasting .Corp.: Taft
Broadcasting Co.; WJAC, Inc.; Springfield Television Broadcasting. Corp.: Midwest Tele-
vision, Inc. ; West Central Broadcasting Co.; Rust Craft Broadcasting Co.: WGAL Televi-
sion. Inc.: American Farm Bureau Federation ; National Farnfers Union: National Grange :
Tri-State TV Translators Association ; labor organizations affiliated with the AFL-CIO:
cKastern Educational. Network; and commenting jointly, television stations KHOU-TV ;
KOTV. KXTX. WANE-TV, WAVE-TV, WFIE-TV, WFRV, WISH=TV, WIXT,- WMT-TV.
WNOK-TV, WTOP-TV. Opposition—Commenting in opposition to jurisdiction were:
- National Community Television Association. Inc. ; Smith & Pepper (on behalf of 150 CATV
systems) ; Columbia Broadensting System : National Broadcasting Co.: TV Cable Service of
Abilene, Inc.: Entron, Inc.; American Cable Television, Inc.; Meredith Broadcasting Co.;
* .Triangle Publications, Inc.; Jerrold Electronics Corp.; International bt ng we Corp. :
Montgomery Television Assoctation. Inc.: and Journal Co. Other—American yo &
Telegraph Co. and U.S. Independent Telephone Association took no position on the jurisdic-
» tional ore but requested that the carriage and nonduplication provisions be e applied
to CA systems directly rather than to microwave common carriers.
2 F.C.C. 24 Se pace Acted, said
oes
Qe
~
; ae oo
notice, attachment B) or express agreement with that memorandum.*
Since we believe that the case for jurisdiction is sufficiently set forth
in our memorandum,’a copy of. which is attached to this document
for convenient reference (attachment C), we shall discuss only the -
argtiments made in the opposition comments. _ ates
_ .9. The comments urging a want of jurisdiction make three principal
arguments. It is asserted, first, that the Communications Act con- .
' tams no provision granting the Commission authority over CATV
systems.. Second, it is contended that there are specific provisions in
the act which show a lack of authority. And, third, it is urged that
the Commission itself has repeatedly denied jurisdiction over CATV —
systems, that Congress is aware of and has acquiesced in this admin-
istrative interpretation, and that principles of statutory construction
foreclose the Commission fyom now claiming jurisdiction. - We shall
discuss these arguments in order. : ah
- 10. The contention that the Communications Act contains no pro-
vision granting the Commission authority over CATV systems takes
issue with the sufficiency of the statutory base set forth in the Com-
‘mission’s memorandum (pp. 2-7). . We there relied on tlie fact that
section 2(a) states that the “provisions of this act shall apply to all
interstate and foreign communication by wire or radio * *-* and to
all persons engaged within the United States in such communication,”
and concluded that CATV systems are engaged in “communication
by wire,” within the meaning of section 3(a), which is interstate in
. nature. With respect to the provisions of the. act to be applied, we
- stated that the authority conferred by section 303(h) to issue rules
establishing the area or zone to be served by any station includes the
. power to prevent infringement of ‘the rules by. “any person” (secs.
312(b) and 502 of the Conimunications Act), and specifically a per-
son subject. to the provisions of the act, and encompasses authority to
specify by rule the conditions under which the station’s signal ma
be oxteeidied beyond the prescribed service area or zone by CATV.
Moreover, apart from section 303(h), the general rulemaking author-
ity of the Commission (secs. 4(i) and 303 (f) and (r)) includes au-
thority to take necessary action, not inconsistent with the act or law, .
to prevent frustration of section 307(b) by CATV—an “interstate.
communication by wire” to which the act’s provisions are applicable
_ (sees. 2(a) and 3(a) ). |
11. It is asserted that these sections do not suffice to support juris-
diction because it is necessary to find.some specific provision of the
act expressly conferring jurisdiction over the subject matter of CATV.
The authorities cited in our memorandum (pp. 4-6) to the effect that
our duthority. does not depend on a specific reference to CATV or
CATV practices in the act * are distinguished on the ground that they
“While Storer Broadcasting Co. d6ées not agree with the impact argument (Commission's
memorandum, Pp. 4-5) as a jurisdictiona] base, it takes the position that the Commission
now has limit
measures preqosed in pt. I and par. 50.
- 5 National Broadcasting Co. v. United States, 319 U.S. 190, 218-219; United States v.
Storer Broadcasting Co., 351 U.S.-192, 203; American Trucking Association v. United
Stater, 344 U.S. 298, 309-311; United States v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 323 U.S. 612:
United States v.. Wrightwood Dairy Co., 315 U.S..110; Houston, East and West Tezas
Railway Co. v. United States, 234 U.S. 342; Public Service Commission of State of New
York v. Federal Power Commission, 327 F. 2d 893, 897 (C.A.D.C.): ;
2 FCC. 2
PoP IPE ORT ST
é €
«
-
se.
jurisdiction over all CATV systems which is sufficient to support the -
EPIL DL OL ODL ILS,
MAR eal DD
heed bey
<
6 - Federal Communications Commission Reports
concern authority. over unspecified practices of regulated -licensees
rather than the power to regulate unspecified persons or bfisinesses
not licensed under the act. Unless specific authority is required for
regulation of nenlicensees, it is argued, the Commission could utilize
its general rulemaking authority to regulate any business (such as
amusements, program preducers, etc.) which has an impact on broad-
casting or uses communications facilities. ees :
12. The attempted distinction, evén assuming arguendo its validity,
does not fit the situation here. Weare not presented with the question
of whether the Commission’s broad powers to take action necessary
to carry out the provisions of the act include authority to regulate a
business not subject to the act merely because of some impact on, or
use Of, interstate communications under the act. CATV systems dif-
fer from most other businesses in that they are themselves engaged
in “interstate communication by wire,” a business to which the act’s
provisions are expressly applicable (secs. 2(a), 3(a)).7 Moreover,
they physically intercept and extend television signals, and thus have
a untquely close relationship to the regulatory scheme embodied in
sections 303(h) and 307(b). We are not powerless to prevent frus-
tration of our action under those sections b rsons subject to the
act merely because the licensing provisions of the statute are inappli-
cable to them. Sections 312 (B) and (c) provide for the issuance of
a’ cease and desist order against “any person”—not merely any “li-
eersee or permittee”—who has “violated or failed to observe any rule
or regulation of the’ Commission authorized in this act * * *.”
13. It is further asserted that Federal Power Commission v. Pan-
handle Eastern Pipeline Company, 337. U.S. 498, precludes a con-
clusion that. the eral rulemaking power of the Commission
encompasses authority to take necessary action, not inconsistent with
the act or law, to prevent frustration of section 307(b) and 303(h)
~ Ab apace However, the Panhandle case is readily distinguishable.
at case was deviued upon the basis of a specific provision in the
Natural Gas Act which denied the Federal Power Commission juris-
diction to deal with the problem there involved.* Section 1(b) of,the
Natural Gas Act provides that the “provisions of this Act shall.
apply * * * to the sale in interstate commerce of natural gas for’
resale * * * but shall-not apply * * * to the production or gathering
We have not claimed plenary power to regulate any business ‘which may have songe
impact on broadcasting or other interstate communication by. wire or radio. In the juris-
diction&él memorandum we stated that the “Commission.clearly has no jurisdiction over
bowling alleys or theaters, for example * * *%” Moreover, we sought and obtained specific
statutory authority to regulate the manufacture of television receivers shipped in interstate
commerce for sale to the public (Public Law 87-629, 47 U.S.C. 303(s)). There may be
instances, of course, where the Commission's regulatory power appropriately extends to some
~ activities of persans not en in communication by wire or radio. But there is no
“necessity to determine the limits or basis for such authority here.
™Since CATV systems fall within the definition of communication by wire and their
.
ye po are interstate in nature, it makes no difference that they are not expressly men- —
oned by name. The act.applies to “all interstate communication by. wire or radio” and
to “all persons engaged in such communication” [sec, 2(a), emphasis added]. For that
matter, prior to the 1962 amendment incorporating sec. 303(s), the word “television” did
not appear in the act:° Yet, it has long been established that the act applies to television
because it falls within the definitions of “radio communication” and “transmission of
energy by radio” contained in sec. 3. Allen B. Dumont Labs, Inc., v. Carroll, 184 F. 2d 153,
, 155 (C.A. 3), cert. den, 340 U.S. 929..
.* Other Federal Power Commission cases cited in’.the comments, Amerada Petroleum -
Corp. v: Federal Power Commission, 334 F. 2d 404 (C.A. 8), and Pan American Petroleum
Corp. v. Federal Power Commission, 339 F. 2d 694, are similarly inapposite since they in-
volved a lack of jurisdiction predicated upon a statutory exclusion.
2 F.C.C. 24 ae
7 Sr. oA eee & °
\
er
CATV ie as ee 7
of natural gas” {52 Stat. 821, 15 U.S.C. sec. 717(b):). The court held
thatthe transfer of gas leases fell within the exclusion as:to the “pro-
duction or gathering of natural wl and hence lay outside the scope
of the Power Commission’sgegu atory powers. In declining to find
authority in the Power Commission's general, rulemaking powers,
the court stated that the “power to do the things appropriate to carry
out the provisions of the act can hardly be taken to rescind a prohibi-
tion against certain actions” (337 U.S,AK508). By’contrast, there is
no provision in the Communications “Act which specifically excludes .
CATV systems from the Commission’s jurisdiction: ‘On the contrary, -
section 2(a) states that the “provisions of this Act shall apply to all ©
interstate communication by wire or radiq * * * and to all persons
engaged within the United States in such communieation * * *.
[Emphasis added.]” Moreover, Panhandle has been construed nar-
rowly in a recent case arising under the Natural Gas Act, which
,sustained the-Power Commission’s jurisdiction over gas leases for
resale in interstate commerce. United Gas Improvement Co. v.
Continental Oil Co., 381 U.S.392, 403-404. - i ee
14. The —. that the Communications Act contains language
’ expressly excluding jurisdiction over CATV systems is. predicated
primarily on the provisions of section 2(b) and section 214(a) of:
the act. Section 2 Faget that nothing in the act shall be construed
.to give the Commissf6n jurisdiction with respect to “intrastate com-
munication service by wire or radio of any carrier” or “any carrier
, engaged in interstate or foreign communication solely through con- -
nection by radio, or by wire and radio, with facilities located in an
adjoining State * * * of another carrier * * *.” Section 214(a) pro- |
vides, in pertinent: part, thet “no carrier” shall construct or operate 4
.a line without a’prior certifi from ‘he “ommission, provided,
however, that no certificate is required for construction or operation of
“a line within a single State unless such line constitutes part of azxf
interstate line.”s It further states: “As used in this section the term
‘Jine’ means any channel of communication established by the inter-
connection of two or more existing channels.” ee: .
15. We are not persuaded that these sections demonstrate a statuto
_ denial of jurisdiction oveg CATV systems. In the first place, bot
‘sections by their. terms aply to “carriers” and we have repeatedly
ruled that CATV systems are not “carriers” within the meaning of
section 3(h) of the act. Frontier Broadcasting Co., 24 F.C.C. 251;
CATV and TV Repeater Services, 26 F.C.C. 403, 427-428;. WSTV,
Inc. v. Fortnightly Corp., 23 Pike &| Fischer, R.R. 184; Philadelphia
Television Broadcasting Co., et al., ¥CC 65-702 (Aug. 2, 1965). Nor
are television stations “carriers” under section 3(h). Moreover, even
if CATV systems were to be deemed carriers, their operations-are
interstate in’ nature since they are carrying interstate television
signals. A common carrier carrying @levision signals does not fall
within the exemption in section 2(b) (1) because its physical facilities
are located in only one State; it “performs an interstate communica-
tidns service.” Jdaho Microwave, Inc. v. Federal Communications
Commission, 3532 F. 2d 729 (C.A.D.C.) ; Ward v. Northern Ohio Fele-
phone Co., 300 F. 2d 816 (C.A. 6), cert. den. 371 U.S. 820; Pacific
eohes ' f , 2 F.C.C. 2d
a . :
OS TE RTE ER See Rr ge Ca oe ee ee 3? ae
, - 8 Federal Communications Commission Reports
Telatronics, Inc., 4 Pike & Fischer, R.R. 145; and cf. California .
Interstate Telephone Co. v.. Federal Communications Commission,
328 F. 2d 816 (C.A.D.C.).° See also, United States v. American Tele-
phone and Telegraph Co., 57 F. Supp. 451, 454{S.D.N.Y.), aff'd ad
curiam, sub nom. Hotel Astor v. United States, 325 U.S. 837. By
the same token a CATV system, if it were a carrier, would constitute
“part of an. interstate line” for purposes of section 214(a), even
though its facilities were located within a single State. lS
16. The most vigorously ‘pressed argument against jurisdiction is
the assertion og Commission is estopped by past disclaimers of
jurisdiction over ©ATV systems and congressional acquiescence 1n
those disclaimers (see par. 28 of the notice herein). Reliance is
sare on the principle of statutory construction that a consistent,
_ longstanding administrative interpretation is entitled to great weight,
_ particularly where Congress is aware of the administrative determi-
nation and has subsequently amended the statute without changing. -
the applicable section:!° Whatever the force of this principle in other’
circumstances, we do not think that it is dispositive of the legal
question of our jurisdiction here.
17. Initially, it. bears noting that some of the precedents cited #s
establishing a consistent contrary position primarily concerned mat.
ters upon which we do not rely as a basis for jurisdiction. We have
consistently held that-CATV systems are not common carriers within
the meaning of section. 3(h), and hence do not come within the pro-
visions of title II applicable to carriers. Frontier Broadcasting Com-
1 pany, 24 F.C.C. 251; CATV and TV Repeater Services, 26 F.C.C. 403,
i 427-428; WSTYV, Inc. v. Fortnightly Corp., 23 Pike & Fischer, R.R.
‘184. But we have not proposed to depart from this ruling, which has
‘been reaffirmed since the issuance of the notice herein. Philadel hia,
| Television. Broadcasters Co., et.al. v. Rollins Broadcasting, :-Inc., .
‘ - docket No. 15926 (FCC 65-702, Aug. 2, 1965) now pending on appeal
. = (ease No. 19577, C.A.D.C.).* Nor have we depa from our earlier
rulings that CATVs are not engaged: in “broadcasting” within the
meaning of section 3(0) and are not encompassed within saction .
325(a). CAT and TV Repeater Services, 26 F.C.C. 403, 428-430. ,
In areas closer io the claimed basis, for jurisdiction, the precedents do -
not reflect a consistent contrary position." Thus, while we initially
. es ney
SD Lae ev wet or tala
Bad Es retire DI hl tS ha LN a hate
* That the carrier in Idaho Microwave was carrying the signal of a television station
located in. another State is not of controlling significance. All television broadcasting is
interstate in nature. Ward v. Northern Ohio Telephone Co., 300 F. 2d 816 (C.A. 6), cert.
den. 371 U.S. 820; Capital City Telephone Co., 3 F.C.C. 189, 193-1944 Federal Radio Com-
mission v. Nelson Bros. Bond & Mortgage Co., 289 U.S. 266,279. Moreover, tn the case of
’ network programing the communication link between.the network and the station trans-
ae perl additional part of the interstate chain of Gommunication. Ward, supra,
° a le - 4 » .
1° Cases cited to us in this connection include: Hanover Bank, Ez. v. C.1.R., 369 U.S. 672,
686-687 ; United States v. Leslie Salt Co., 350 U.S. 382. 396-397 ; Norwegian Nitrogeon,Co.
v. United States, 288 U.8. 294, 315; Luckenback Steamship Co. v. United States, 280 U.S.
173, 183 ; Cammarano v. United States, 358 U.S. 498. +
' The position of Congress, if it "has acquiesced in the Commission’s rulings, is not clear. .
It is true, as set forth in the noticeénpar. 28. that following our decision in CA and TV
Repeater Services, 26 F.C:C. 403. the 86th pumgrens gave extensive consideration to someé
of the various legislative _ on CATV submitted by. the Commission and others, but ~ |
enacted no legislation. oreover., bills introduced tn subsequent Congresses received no -
action. However, Congress also took no action after being apprised of the partial reversal |
of that decision in Carter Mountain. 29th FCC Annual rt, 1963. Congress likewise’ .
is aware of our initial conclusion ‘as to jurisdiction in the notice herein issued on Apr. 23,
1965. Although a subcommittee of the House Commerce Commitfee su uently held hear-
3. ings on H.R. 7715, no.committee report issued.in the first session of the Congress, and
‘- no legislation on CATV was considered or introduced in the Senate. <~. le :
2 F.C.C, 24
Novtete Z eww fer a Ta ae i Ay TORT
CATV ; io
disclaimed jurisdiction to deny a. common carrier. microwave au-
thorization to relay television signals to CATV systems (/ntermoun-
tain Microwave, 24 F.C.C. 54; CATV and TV Repeater Services, .
26 F.C.C. 43, 431-433), this ruling was later reversed‘in' our Carter —
Mountain decision, 32 F.C.C. 459, which was sustained. on judicial
review. Carter Mountain Transmission Corp. x, Federal Communi-
cations Commission, 321 F. 2d 359, 364 (C.A.D.C.), cert. den. 375 U.S. -
951. In CATV and TV Repeater Services, we disclaimed plenary
power, under section 303°(a), (b), (f), (8), (i), and (r), to “regulate
any and all enterprises which happen to be connected with one of the
_ many aspécts of communications’ (28 F.C.C. at 429)—a power which
is not claimed here. However, we assumed (without a that
CATVs are within the scope of section 3(a) (26 F.C.C. at 428), and .
also found it unnecessary to pass on the question of our authority to
-regulate them directly because of adverse effect on broadcasting (26
F.C.C. at 431). And, finally, we have not previously ruled on the |
ee of whether.section 303(h) encompasses authority to regulate . |
-. CATV. ee ae Benda aaa
18. More important, even if our-past-rulings in this troublesome =
area had _been éonsisten't, we are not estopped from-correcting a ruling
of law which appears. to be‘clearly erroneéus.- Carter Mountain
Transmission Corp. v. Federal Communications Commission, 321 F.
2d 359, 364 (C.A-D.C.), cert. den. 375 U.S. 951; Phillips Petroleum Co.
yv. Wisconsin, 347 U.S. 672; United Gas Improvement Co. v. Con:
‘ tinental Oil’Co., 381 U.S. 392, 404-406.2 As the Supreme Court com-
‘ mented. in the Phzllips Petroleum case, in sustaining the Federal
. Power Commission’s jurisdiction over the sale of gas by gas producers
‘for resale in interstate commerce despite that agency’s consistent past
' disclaimer of jurisdiction, “even consistent error is still error” (347
U.S. 672, 678, footnote 5). Moreover, in United Gas Improvement the
authority of the Powef Commission over gas leases for resale in inter-
state commerce was upheld, notwithstanding the fact that the agency
-had initially concluded. in the same proceeding that it lacked jurisdic-
tion and then reversed itself on remand (on another ground) from a
court of appeals decision which assumed a lack of authority on the
basis of Panhandle (381 U.S. at 404-406). Public Service Commission
of New York v. Federal Power Commission, 287 F. 2d 143, 145
¢C.A.D.C.). ap
- “19. As indicated in the notice,(par. 28), our “jurisdiction to regulate
nonmicrowave CATV systems under the present provisions of the .
- Communications Act is obviously subject to reasonable difference of
' pinjon.” However, the arguments discussed above do not persuade us
that jurisdiction is lacking, and no other bar to jurisdiction has been
brought to our attention. After careful consideration of all the com-.
' Inents we are convinced that the case for present jurisdiction is a
strong one. Accordingly, for the reasons set forth above and in our
memorandum as to jurisdiction (app. C), we conclude that CATV
systems are engaged in interstate communication by wire to- which the
18 See also, Calbeck v. Travellers Ink. Co., 370 U.8. 114, 127, footnote 15 ; Automobile Club
of Michigan v.‘ Commissioner, 353 U.S. 180, 183; Association of Clerical Employees v.
Brotherhood of R. € 8.8. Clerks, 85 F. 24 152, 156 (C.A. 7). “at ig 4
7 F.C. 2d
_ PORES SO RETR Lh TT 7S
* “*
; 10 Fics \ Federal Communications Cogmiscion Reports
} provisions of the Communications Act are applicable (secs. 2(a) and
§ 3(a), 47 U.S.C. 152(a) and 153(a)). We further conclude that our
' ‘ #tatutory powers, particularly under section 4(i), 303 (f), (g), (h);
;
:
and (r)-include authority to promulgate necessary and reasonable -
regulations to carry out the provisions of sections A. 307(b), and
303(s) of the act and to prevent frustration of the regulatory scheme .
‘by CATV operations, whether or not microwave facilities are used.
he rules proposed in part I and paragraph 50 of the notice are within.
our legal authority. > ae
¢
ae
*
,
|B. Assertion of Jurisdiction °\
; 20. We turn now.to the further question of whether jurisdiction
q over nonmicrowa¥e CATV should be exercised at this time. Most
' _ of the comments in support of jurisdiction favored an immediate ex-
i tension of the Carriage and nonduplication requitements to nonmicro-
. wave CATV: systems, and the adoption of an interim policy either
. along the lines proposed in paragraph 50 of the notice or of broader
Scope. However, some of the supporting comments and many of the.
opposition comments took the position that we should not exercise
jurisdiction, even if present, until Congress has legislated on the sub-
ject. It is urged that this would ‘provide needed policy guidelines
, and avoid protracted litigation on the jurisdictional issue. —
' 21. We-stated in the notice (par. 31) that we would “welcome (2)
+ a congressional guidance as to policy, and (2) congressional clarifica-
+ _ tion of our authority, which would lay the troublesome jurisdictional é
s° question at rest.” In this report, we stress again the desirability in
our view of congressional guidance in this important area. But thus
:. far the congressional guidance or clarification has not been forthcorfi-
q ing; and in the present circumstances, our decision cannot properly
turn on a desire to avoid litigation or on the hope of obtaining policy
idance in the CATV field. The Commission has not been “left at
: arge” as to the criterion to be following in performing our statutory
) . duties in the dynamic communications field. National Broadcasting
: Co.v. United States, 319 U.S. 190, 219-220. The public interest touch-
stone provided by Congress afforded a sufficient standard for our
decision to adopt the carriage and nonduplication requirements for:
{ microwave-served CATV systems in the first report and order. in
dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233. Since the “considerations underlying
_ our conclusion that this is necessary in the public interest to avoid %
unreasonable competitive disadvantage and prejudicial effect on exist-
ing and potential television broadcast service apply equally” to
4. nonmicrowave CATV systems (notice, par. 27), there is likewise a
sufficient standard for judgment here. Finally, our action with
to the pa 50 proposal is similarly dictated by the
“public interest in the Sener and more effective use of radio” (sec.
303(g))- . eae
. 22. Most of the comments agree that, apart from the basis for
jurisdiction, there is no significant difference between microwave and
nonmicrowave systems. -However, National Community Television
- Association, Inc. (NCTA), asserts that there is no basis for assuming
2 F.C.C, 2d .
ee : . e “ee . , 4
- rey z r : 4
. .
° 3 >
CATV Sa ireRs 11
Jet ; °% ‘ .
they are alike. It points to no factual distinction. Rather,‘NCTA
renews its contentions in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233 that no. ade-
quate factfinding inquiry has been conducted, and claims further that —
adverse impact has not been established and cannot support an as-
- gertion of jurisdiction. In this connection, NCTA has appended to
its comments the material it submitted before the House subcommittee
in hearings on H.R. 7715. It urges particularly that the 15 days. -
_hefore and’ after nonduplication period is unjustified, and has,nbd
reasonable relationship te the showing of nonnetwork ay ae on
NCTA’s staat has undertaken a study to test the validity of the Com-
- mission’s sample week network study (first report, pars.-104-109),
and has found that the data developed by ihe ommissih supports
its conclusion that delayed programitig occurs most frequehtly among
affiliates in the mountain timezone, and there in one- and two-station
markets. NCTA claims that its study of 33 mountain time zone sta-
tions with CATV penetration shows no adverse consequences (NCTA
comnfents, exhibit A). It points in addition to specific examples of
small market stations which have allegedly increased circulation and
maintained the same or a higher network hourly rate since 1960,
despite substaritial CATV penetration of their service areas (NCTA
comments, exhibits A and B). é ;
23. While the inferences NCTA draws from its studies are sharply
criticized in the reply comments of Association of Maximum Service
_ Telecasters (AMST), we do not think it necessary or useful to set
forth the contentions of each or to discuss their dispute as to indjyidual
. situations. The. NCTA appendixes do not differentiate between
microwave and nonmicrowave CATV systems; ou their face they
constitute an attack on the validity of the first. report and order in
dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233. But the supplementary material upon
which NCTA now relies as indicating a lack of past impact is similar in
nature to the showing there considered at length and ‘would not in
itself warrant reversal of our conclusions." Indeed, NCTA, in rely-
ing upon its showing, simply ignores the two most important ‘grounds ©
of our decision, namely, (z) the fair competition ground, and (i) the
economic impact gr8und, based on the CATV trend in recent years.
Since this is so, it may be well to restate those grounds briefly, and to
take account of current information pertinent to those grounds.
24. In the first report and order in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233,
we concluded that CATV serves the public interest when it provides
program choices not locally available off the air and acts as a-gupple-
ment rather than a substitute for off-the-air television service, fe ;
ing, our principal reasons as follows (par.44): __
“* * * Because of the prohibitive cost of extending the cables beyond heavily
built-up areas, CATV systems cannot serve many persons reached by tele-
vision broadcast signals. Persons unable to obtain CATV service, and
those who cannot afford it or who are unwilling to pay, are entirely de-
pendent upon local or nearby stations for their television service. The
. Commission’s statutory obligation is to make television service available,
* ‘so far as possible, to aU people of the United States on a fair, efficient, and-
' 13 We have decided, for the »e°r” » >t forth in pars. 47-55 below, to delete the provision
for nonduplication 15 days befe’ ; _ °or the local broadcast andcto substitute a require-
ment for nonduplication only on “& «© day as the local broadcast. Thus, our resolution
of this matter affords NCTA substaatie.., the relief it has requested. .
lt
« : _- 2 FC.C.-2d
SER ay NS 6
12
~— tal
o : I a
=e
Federal’ Communications. Commissign Reports
equitable basis (secs. 1 and 307(b) of the Communications Act). This
obligation is not met by primary reliance on a service which, technically,
cannot be made available to many people“and which, practically, will not
be available to many others. Ndr would it be compatible with our respon-
‘sibilities to permit persons willing and able to pay for additional service
to obtain it at the expense of those dependent on the growth of television
broadcast facilities for an adequate choice of services. . ee
25. Our determination to adopt the carriage and nonduplication —
requirements rested orf two basic grounds: (1) That. failure to carry
- local stations and duplication of their programs are unfair competitive
practices, which are inconsistent with the supplementary role of
CATV (pars. 49-57, 76), and (2) that these requirements were ‘nec-
essary to ameliorate the risk that the. bicaseaa CATV. industry
would have a future adverse impact on television broadcast. service,
both existing and potential (pars. 58-75, 77).
26. With respect to the first ground, we found thatthe CATV sys-
tem which fails to carry the local station on its system has in practical
effect cut off the station from access to CATV subscribers (par. 51)..
Westated (par. 57) : a
¥
As a competitive practice, the failure or refusal by a CATV ‘system to
carry the signal of a local station is plainly inconsistent with our belief
that CATV service should supplement, but not replace, off-the-air television
service. The cable system that follows such a practice offers the subscriber
the benefits of additional television service at the price of blocking or im-
peding his access to.available off-the-air signals.* * * ~ . ;
Because it is inconsistent with the concept of CATV as a supplementary
- service, because we consider it an unreasonable restriction upon the local
station’s ability to compete, ahd because it is patently destructive of the
_goals we seek in allocating television channels to different areas and com-
munities, we believe that a CATV system's failure to carry the signal of a
local station is inherently contrary to the public interest. Only if we were
persuaded that the overall impact of CATV competition upon broadcast-
ing would be entirely negligible would we consider countenancing such a
practice. ‘
27. We further pointed out that CATV, thoug® distributing the.
programs of the television broadcast service, stands outside its normal
\program distribution process and fails to recognize the reasonable ex-
“clusivity for which the local stations have bargained in the program
market when it duplicates Jocal programing via the signals of distant
stations (pars. 52-56). We summarized our conclusion that this was
oat oy inconsistent with CATV’s supplementary role as follows
- (par. 57):. -.
In light of the unequal footing on which broadcasters and CATV ‘systems
now stand with respect to the market for program product, we cannot
regard a CATV system's duplication of local programing via the signals of
distant stations as a fair method of competition. We do not regard the
patterns of exclusivity created in the existing system fdr the distribution
F of television programs as sacrosanct. We think/it apparent, however, that
the creation of a reasonable measure of exclusivity is an entirely appropriate
‘and proper way for program suppliers to protect the value of their product
and for stations to protect their investment in programs. We think the
basic congressional judgment underlying: section 325(a) limitation on re-
broadcasting is the same. ‘
Nor do we consider the duplication of existing off-the-air' service to be
consistent with CATV’s appropriate role as a supplementary service. What-
ever the ultimate impact of CATV competition upon the revenues and opera-
tion of competing stations, duplication is highly likely to affect the audience
2 F.C.C. 2d |,
om .. 13
for the specific programs involved. And it does so without generally offer-
ing the public a substantially different service. We believe that a service
such as TV, which lives on the product of the existing @ievision service,
should at a minimum give some measure of recognition to the fundamental
distribution practices which have developed in the parent industry’s com-
petitive program market—to- exhibition rights for which otherg must bar-
gain and pay but which it has thus far been able to use without bargain-
ing by itself or by the stations whose signals it c@rries.- Once. again, unless
we were convinced that the impact of CATV competition upon broadcast-
ing service would be negligible, we would favor some restrictions upon‘the
ability of CATV systems to duplicate the programs/6f, local groadcasting.sys-
. tems, as a partial equalization of the conditions under ch GA d
broadcasting service compete. [Footnotes omitted. |
28. We stated that the foregoing grounds were nage to, justify
latory action” (par. 58) and that “every station affected is en-
titled to appropriate carriage and nonduplication benefits—irrespec-
tive of the specific damage which any individual CATV system may
do to the financial health of the individual station” (par. 76). But,
as stated, we also turned to another ground based on the economic’ .
, impact of CATV upon television broadcast development. .We con- °
sidered at some length the data and arguments before us on the ques-
_ tion of impact (pars. 58-75), finding—as in 1959-8 at it is “impos-
sible, with the data at hand, to isolate reliably the-effects of CATV
competition from all of the other factors which operate to produce
particular financial results in differing settings” (par. 68). However,
taking account of nationwide trends affecting the nature of CATV
offerings, the character of the markets entered, and-the de _of
penetration achieved, we also found it plain that CATV could have
a substantial negative effect upon station revenues and audiences even
though we lack the ‘tools to measure precisely the degree of impact «
(pars. 65-69). We further found reason to believe that the impact
was likely to be “more serious in the future than it has been in the.
past” (par. 69), and stressed our concern with the effest of explosive -
- CATV growth in a critical period for UHF development (pars. 71-
' 72). In sum, the Commission’s judgment on this ground was based
very largely, not upon the past, but -upon the trends which were al-
ready evident and whose dimensions called for action now to assure
the public interest in the future.
29.. The additional showing made in the appendixes to the NCTA
comments is not directed to the above crucial considerations concern- .
ing the trends in the CATV or UHF fields. Instead, it focuses upon ~
certain situations which, it claims, establish that CATV has no ad-
.. Verse impact upon television broadcasting. But each of its examples
is sharply disputed by AMST, which points to significant impact in
some cases or sets forth other factors for the improvement in the
situation of the television station in the face of CATV competition.
For example, AMST notes that several stations whose net wo hourly
rate has not declined since 1960 were already-at or near the minimum
rate for the network involved (AMST reply comments, pp. 27-28,
attachment A, pp. 10-14). It attributes whatever success station
; WLUC-TYV, Marquette, Mich., has enjoyed in recent years to new
management beginning in 1960 and states that the station has suffered
Ter a declitie in average quarterly hour audience while local revenues have
> 2 FCC: 24
. - ese -ynen-caseormen ns LOCOS i TITS
; OTTER don one. + “Rianne me = a 7 at ee Tee ee 3 » Pope epee th tied Pus
= =e Seren
° .
a cecepennn’ Uhlebene edi h ana Linh och ee
ee a
ee
14 F. ederal Communications Commission Reports
remained stagnant (AMST reply comments, pp. 29-30, attachment
A, p. 14). AMST also points out that WBOC_TY, Salisbury, Md.,
following a change in ownership in 1961 and the. infusion of a sub-
stantial financia] investment, extended its hours of operation, im-
proved its programing, and doubled its servite area through a
substantial Egor increase. (AMST reply comments, pp. -51-32,
attachment A, pp. 15-16. | see .
- 80. It would, we think, serve no useful purpose to delve into each
of those situations. For even assuming that it were possible to isolate
the significance of CATV in each situation from other factors (as
it was feasible in the Carter Mountain case, first report, par. 64), it
would not afford greater insight into the crucial aspect of the matter—
the explosive growth and changing character of CATV and its pos-
-_ sible impact upon television broadcasting in the future. -And, as to
that aspect, events since the issuance of the first répoft reinforce the
j ent made by us upon the basis of thé above-mentioned trends
in the industry. For, as the comments in this proceeding show, with-
out dispute in this respect, the trends described in paragraph 65 of
the first report have become even more pronounced. We shall briefly
review those trends in light of their ynportance to our judgment. |
_ 81. In the first report we relied on estimates in the Seiden report
which were based on data compiled in 1964.4 The Seiden’ report
stated (p, 2) that there were approximately 1,300 CATV systems
. i. gpa nd 1.2 million TV homes. The reply comments
ST,
of A filed on September 17, 1965, contain the following estimates
as of mid-1965 (AMST reply comments, attachment A, prepared by
Economic Associates, Inc., of’ Washington, D.C., using data from
Television Factbook .(No. 35) and Television Digest) : : |
Communities with operating CATVs__-- 1, 847
Communities with CATVS franchised (but not yet operating) -..-.-.. woas COO
Communities with CATV applications pending. - 938
While these figures are not tendered as precisely accurate," the rapidly
accelerating rate of growth is confirmed in statistics given by licensees
commenting on the situation within their service areas,’ in the trade
press, and in letters received by the Commission from local franchising »
authorities and other members of the public. Re
_ 82. In addition, the channel capacity of CATV systems is increas-
ing. According to the Seiden report (pp. 2, 54) the usual CATV
—_— in 1964 delivered five signals and 85 percent of all systems
lelivered between three and seven signals. However, there is indica-
tion in the record that most of the new CATY systems have a channel
capacity of 12 channels and many of the older systems are expanding
their original capacity. The T reply comments (attachment A
contain the following table showing the cable capacity for the 753
CATV systems for which it was able to obtain data: *
% This estimate was based on comments filed in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233 and the
report submitted to us by Dr. Martin H.- Seiden, entitled “An Economic Analysis Com-
munity Antenna Television Systems and‘the Television Broadcasting Industry”. (Govein-
ment Printing Office, February 1965), hereafter referred to as the “Seiden report.” ;
3 There are other estimates (see per. 116, describing the Television Digest estimate), but
whatever the estimate, CATV growth is clearly explostve in nature. ~ °
.*E.g., comments of Midwest Television, Inc.; West Central Broadcasting Co.; WKBH
Television. Inc. ; Mobile Video Tapes, Inc.; and Bonneville International Corp
data were compiled from reports in Television Factbook (No. 35), Television Digest,
qv cslionnaires on file at the Commission, and ARB publications. .
2 F.CC.'24 -: :
od
Ra re - _ mor Wy é s
CATV 15
P73
Cc ity, in number of channels (including FM) !
. - CATVs starting paescn es aa hee
, '
: 2 3 4 5 | 6 7 8 | 9 | 10 | il 12
. . ) -
Thru 1951... -.. CEP LPN | om ae a: Soe eee See Se 13%
CEES. pncbeiipanwiishodabilasaheni Se ; wat 96 V..-.0: 1 | Wega! eee eee 15
Re ee eee ee, ey 3 1 «& 1 _) 2 | ER 1Q
EE EE eee Penn Geer 1 )} ee 39 3 3 2 _¢ Bae 20 .*
| ERE SS See ) Grae 43 2 Y eeaee pe Eee eee ll
Dh 2¢deeassenens rabdbeensioate i Ee 3 1 | ee ee a} EA OE 10
SILL dls ss nds beaded sieicariaensh dt fe es eee 9 ar > ef See PRE 5
iii clilinciniatgeietibigeichatigiasendbcgetiel Bitcei fet er Be: nase fae 7
| AF RE ES, PO Aaket “Th ecg); Pameaec! aise 1 “i See 4
Te eee See ree , 2 ER 2 1 5 ES Pe 6
OR a ZERIT! siecle: Ves ieee: |} esas | See! bee "| Sees 9
i ith spihdiadnespnanicsimattenhiat | Ramer eee: | cee inet rem: ¢ TRS geo 16
ee Sees NL Ey 21 1 1 | ae See Se 33
OR eS MEY: COSA Re UN 16 1 2 2 ji == Kf 53
_ 1 | aR: oe Ka ania [et 2 samba “4
Mc cnnsdcinadmunbobanes 3 26 3) 39 M 21 10 22 5 3 256
' Includes expansions subsqquent to starting date. Jgmitations of the source data maké it impossibie
to determine the origin4) ity of most of t Sle .
>.
The expanding channel capacity is also reflected in the answers sub-
mitted to our questionnaire sent to all known CATV systems in connec- -
tion with the transition period question. (See pars. 103-107, within.) .
33. It further appears that CATV activity is accelerating in ‘areas
where there is the test interest in UHF development. The com- -
ments of AMST list all communities or metropolitan areas where
}HF stations were operating, authorized, or applied for as of J rr! 8
1965, and indicate the extent of cplocated CATV activity (AMST
comments, attathment C, table 2).%*’ The results are summarized.by ~
_ AMST as follows (comments, p. 59) :
There are 237 UHF stations and 93 educational stations either operating or
with outstanding eonstruction permits or for which applications are pending
in communities or metropolitan areas with a tetal population of over 112.
million. The cities and metropolitan areas with CATV systems operating,
pending, or applied. for account for at least 85 million people.” At least 145
communities or standard metropolitan areas with UHF stations operating,
authorized, or applied for also have CATV activity. In.68 such communities
or:metropolitan areas where there are already operating CATY systems; at
least 67 have CATV systems franchised but not operatifig, and ‘at -least 93
have CATV applications proposed. ‘ ' ;
_ 84. The situation in central Illinois is described " Midwest Tele-
‘vision, Inc. (Midwest), licensee of VHF station. WCIA, Champaign,
Ill; UHF statiSi WMBC-TV, Peoria, Ill.; and applicant for a new
UHF station in Springfield, Ti” Midwest states that CATV is in
rocess of growth in virtually all o£ the major communities served by
CIA, including Champaign and Urbana themselves.”” Franchise
applications have been filed or proposed in at least 12 communities
within the WCIA grade B service area, and CATV systems are operat-
ing, under construction, or franchised in some 15 more. These 2
communities have a total population of 464,500—nearly one-half o
* According to AMST,- table 2 is limited to the central communities or metropolitan areas
where there is UHF activity, and does not inclyde»CATV activity elsewhere within the
service.area of a station located in the community or metropglitan area.
1® Midwest.is also the licensee of KFMB. San Diego, Cali J ,
* Champaign his one VHF and one UHF station, and/is also the location of a UHF
translator of a Decatur UHF station. \
7 t: . -.2 FCO. 24
‘ ° °
236-331°'0—a6——_-5 . f ,
“ ° os _* >
a . ° « ‘
Ail Nhat ole ee ‘Sere Or at ahi TPAD” ree “4
Pe ‘
*
ab eadg go
jetSiese.
16 a Federal Communications Commission Reports
‘ the total population within WCIA’s grade B ‘service area. Within
the grade B service areas of WMBD-TV.,, Peoria, and of W71AE, Mid-
west’s La Salle translator, CATV is at various stages—from franchise .
roposals to actual operation—in at least five communities, including’
eoria itself. (which has three operating UHF stations and a vacant
UHF commercial assignment). The total urban: population of these
~ five communities is 221.294—between one-third. and one-half of the
total population in the grade B service areas of WMBD-TV and the
La Salle translater. In Springfield (which has one operating UHF™
‘station and yew pending for two new UHF stations) R appli-
cations for CATV franchises are under active consideration in Spring-
field and another community Jocated in the grade B contour of both
proposed UHF stations. . The total urban population of these 2
cities is 92,072—approximately one-half of the total population within
the grade B contour of Midwest’s proposed new UHF station. Mid-
- west states that the proposals for CATV in Springfield, Peoria, Cham-
paign, and Urbana haye all been announced since April 23, 1965, and ~
. that at least eight new CA’EV operators filed applications for local
_ franchises ip central Illinois during the first 2 weeks of July.
-. . 85. A description ofCATV. growth in the Rio Grande Valley of
Texas is given by Mobile Video Tapes, Inc.; the licensee of KRVG-TV
in Weslaco-Harlingen, Tex. According to Mobile Video Tapes, Wes-
laco has a 1960 census population of 15,649 and the — of the
Harlingen-San Benito urbanized area is 61,658. It states that J.
Walter Thompson Cod. (Population and Its Distribution, The United
States Markets, 8th ed., 1961), lists the Brownsville-Harlingen-San
- Benito market (which includes Weslaco) as a class “C” market, the
143d market in the United States, with a population of only 151,098..
The ARB total net weekly circulation of K GV, as of March 1964,
was only 75,100 homes. CATV franchises have been granted in five
towns within its service area and othér CATV systems are proposed.
The communities with CATV franchises, their populations, and the
grade of KRVG coverage are given by Mobile Video Tapes as follows:
Community ° 1960 census | KRGV coverage
Rs cotdinnnccctionwensne Susebsinvhatskhecbhbckgetestsiwankocad 48,040 | Grade A.
iid dkelncbokenncanntsuLeeancsndccngehGitnbcenubocntesecmiel 18, 706 | City Grade.
DRCAI.:.. . .ccccecsanacqesecens= SE ee fF fll
tag a 14,081 | Grade B.
RE .cncenncmnncenpannnesansentnancnecchnotongescanseseeteacesqneceens 14, 106 | City Grade.
a
Mobile Video Tapes pgints out that this “constitates the heart of the .
market—84.4 percent of the population shown by J. Walter Thompson ~
for the entire Renwneville-Hattinese ten Benito market.” ; ;
36. It appears, moreover, that there is significant CATV activity in
the vicinity of fairly large cities with multiple channel assignnfents.
The AMST cemments (attachment C, tables TA, B, and C)*! tabulate:
. the CATV systems in operation, franchised or applied for within the .
71 Corrections to these tables were supplied in an “addendum” to the AMST comments
submitted on Aug. 12, 1965.
sree. =. °C od . ne
ig CAV . 17.
grade A and B contours of existing or potential VHF and UHF
stations in 11 areas:“believed to be centers of considerable CATV
_ ‘activity’ ”: Bakersfield and Sacramento, Calif.; Orlando and St. Pe-
tersburg, Fla.; Rockford, Ill.; Evansville and Indianapolis, Ind.; *
Rochester and Utica, N.Y.; and ‘Columbus and Dayton, Ohio.- The ex- -
tent of CATV penetration is detailed in tables [A, B, and C. All three
_. give separate figures for grade A and grade B contours, for VHF and
- UHF respectively. Table IA shows the penetration in terms of num-
ber of places.in which CATY franchises have been granted or applied
for. .Table IB gives the equivalent data in terms of potential CATV
households ** compared with the total number of households within
broadcast cpntours. Table IC converts the data in IB to percentages
of total number of households within. the broadcast contours.
* 37. The analysis shows that in these 1I areas thereare approximately —
230 places in which a CATV system was operating, franchised, or pro-
_ posed (as of July 8, 1965) within the grade B contours of existing or
potential VHF and UHF stations located in the central community of
each of the 11 markets. These 230 places contain nearly 1,900,000: .
households. In Bakersfield, Calif., an all UHF market, almost two-
thirds of the potential UHF audience is already franchised to CATV -—
systems. In Gtica, N.Y., the figure is 44 percent. If already sub-_ -
mitted or proposed applications result in franchises, a UHF station |
_ in Columbus, Ohio} would have CATVs potentially competing for 60
' percent of its market and a VHF station for more than half. Existing
and pending CATVs in the Indianapolis ‘area involve half the VHF ~
market and about three-fifths of the DHF market. In Sacramento, -
the CATV ‘potential comes to over 40 percent of the UHF market and
nearly hajf the VHF. ' ,
38. Théfe is also widespread CATV activity within major cities.
Our attention has been called to the asserted intent of CATY interests: _
to wire up “almost all American cities—small and large” and 85 per-
cent of all television sets—40 million homes.**. The mber 1965
issué of Television Magazine (vol. -22, No. 12) states that franchise
applications have been filed in San Francisco, Seattle, Pittsburgh,
Baltimore, Fresno, Columbus, Tucson, Birmingham, Providence, and °
Sacramento. Two of the commenting Swe in this proceeding are .
ap licants for CATV franchises in Philadelphia. The comments of ©
alumbia Broadcasting System (CBS) refer to applications for
CATV franchises in Albany and Syracuse, N.Y.; Galveston, Tex.; and —
the grant of a CATV franchise in Wilmington, Del. D.H.Overmyer,
permittee. of new UHF station WDHO-TV in Toledo, Ohio, comments —
that local authorities have granted a CATV franchise for that cit
since the issuance of the joint notice herein. Toledo has two VHF
stations, a UHF educational station, and—according to Storer Broad-
casting Co., receives the signals of four Detroit-Windsor VHF stations, .
off the air and without reception difficulty. Telerama, Inc., an appli-—
cant for a CATV franchise in Cleveland, has filed comments describing.
- a - .
2 The tables use potential. rather than actual audience, i.e., the total number of house-
py wa the broadcast contour, and the total number of households in the community
of the : pple :
® Address 5 Milton J. Schapp, “CCATV—Past. Present,. Future,” Dec. 8, 1964, reprinted
in Television Digest special supplement, vol. 4, No. 50, Dec. 14, 1964, p. 1. . :
2 F.C.C. 24
18 "Federal Communications Commission Reports . £
_ its proposed cable operation for that city which has three VITF sta-_
tions, a UHF educativnal station, and applications, pending for two —
new UHF facilities.2* Taft Broadcasting Co., in a June oe
to deny a microwave application (file No. 6226—C1-P-65) to bring the s ©
three New York independent stations to CATV systems in:the Wilkes-- .
Barre-Scranton area of Pennsylvania, states that in the last 6 months | 4
90 franchise applications have been filed in 54 communities in Lacka-
' wanna and Luzerne Counties. The Scranton-Wilkes-Barre area is -
. served by three UHF stations, providjng three full network services.
39. The most: factually detailed comments on big city CATV were
| submitted by Midwest Television, Inc., licensee of station KIF-MB-TV ]
4 _. in San Diego, Calif. According to Midwest, CATV is growing with,
| great speed in the San Diego area, which is presently served by three
| VHF stations providing the programs of all three networks.* In
: addition, construction permits are outstanding for two new commer-
i cial UHF stations in San Diego and an application is pending for a
:. UHF educational station. Since March 4963, when the first CATV.
' system in the area was franchised, seven additional systems have
'. ‘been franchised. All eight CATV systems are within the grade A
- contour of KFMB-TV, which falls ‘within the Metropolitan San
- |. Diego area; four are located: in Ban Diego itself. While four of the ~
eight systems are not yet operative, two of these ire expeeted to begin —
-operations momentarily. "The operating CATV systems, which do
not use microwave, carry the signals of all seven Los Angeles comnitrs
cial VHF stations and carr#the local stations without affording non-
} duplication protection. Midwest has been unable to obtain the current.
‘subscriber count, estimated at approximately 10,000 homes in Febru-
| ary 1965.2%° However, its engineering personnel recently counted
. drops in a part of San Diego where CATV had beer available for .
* only 8 months, Of-the 159 homes in that area, 58: were wired. for
_ CATV—and. this, Midwest points out, “is an area where -all three
| . stations can be satisfactorily received” (Midwest comments, p. 24). -
-40. The: Midwest comments also describe what.it considefs to be the
effect-CATV oe of this nature have on the audience of the
_ }ocal network-affiliated stations. Southwest Suiveys, an independent
research organization, conducted a survey for Midwest in June 1965, -
interviewing 300 CATV subscribers and 300 nonsubscribers in the San
Diego area. Forty-three percent of the CATV subscribers had been
subscribers for less than 3 months. Midwest states (comments, p..9)
that during the prime evening haurs. of 7:30 p.m. to 11-p.m., when
most of the programs broadcast. by the three San Diego area stations
were network programs, the San Diego area stations accounted for 88
ie oda ey ltrrinanal tL
°
*% Telerama. plans to-carry all loca) stations and-two Canadian stations on a full-time
basis and to carry on a part-time basis on the remaining channels the signals of network
affiliated stations in Detroit, Toledo, Erie (Pa.), and Youngstown and Akron, Ohio. While
. ft does not propose to acquire microwave facilities to bring’in Chicago and New York in- . ©
dependent stations, Télerama gates that if these signals are made available to the Cleve-
- tand area by common carrier facilities, “‘then Telerama may avail itself of the accessibility
to such signals.” Since Telerama submitted its comments, Cleveland has granted a
franchise to Telerama. ere. op i . ;
3 Midwest’s station KFMB-—TV is a CBS affiliate, KOGO (San Diego).is an NBC affiliate, e
and the third station, XETV (located in Tijuana, Mexico, just a few miles from San Diego),
is an ABC affiliate. ae i Mi ; : :
_ San+Diego Telecasters, Inc., permittee of UHF station KAAR-TV in San Diego, esti-
mated as of Aug: 25, 1965, that there are “more than 15,000 sets now served by cable.”
2 FCC. 24 eee
.
4
-
a.
’ CATV - 19
and 97 percent of the total viewing time of nor-CA'TV subscribers
inteyviewed in two different areas and only 62 percent among cable
subscribers. During the hour from 9 p.m. to 10 p.m., Sunday through
Wednesday, when each program broadcast by each of the San Diego
area stations was simultgneously duplicated on CATV by-Los Angeles:
stations, 93 percent of thé nonsubscribers saw them on local stations
whereas only 77 percent of the cable subscribers did: so (pp. 9-10).
Of the cable’ subscribers,.49 percent reported that they viewed a San
Diego channel most; 55 percent named a Los Angeles channel. Of
the nonsubscribers in two separate areas, San Diego stations were
named by 108 and 94 percent, respéctivel » While Los Angeles stations
tvere named by only 5 and.11 percent Gia. ae
41. With respect to nonnetwork viewers, Midwest states that’25 per-
“cent of the.CATYV subscribers namedva Los Angeles independent
station as the channel they .viewed most and only 1 and 2 percent,
respectively, of the two groups of nonsubscribers did so. More than
. 56 percent of the CATV-subscribers (as compared to 11 percent of the
’ nonsubscribers) named at least one Los Angeles independent ‘as one
of the three stations most viewed (id, p. 26). During the period
5 p.m. to 6°p.m., Monday through Friday, there was no duplication
_. by any Los Angeles station of programs broadcast in'San Diego and |
the cable subscriber could watch any one of 10 different programs.
Among nonsubscribers interviewed, 95 percent of those who watched
television during that hour watched one of the San Diego stations.
Among cable subscribers the Los Angeles stations accounted for 52
- percent and the San Diego stations 48 percent (id., pp. 26-27).
42. Moreover, appended to the comments of Columbia Broadcast- ~
ing System (CBS), which is opposed to an assertion of jurisdiction, -
is a further study of CATV ge ea by its office of economic analysis.
The-CBS study points oué that there is a timespan lag \before CATV
impact is felt (CBS comments, exhibit A. p. 27). This is partly be-
cause CATV penetration does not occur al! at once; growth is gradual.
But CBS also states that networks redct slowly to changéS in station
audiences.and that it might take 3 to 5 years for a change in an affili-
ate’s audience to be reflected fully in the relative network rate:
National spot revenues and‘ local advertising, while reacting more
uickly, would still take a considerable time. The study concludes
nt 31) that the “true reasons for the modest impact of CATV thus
far are the relatively small amount of penetration that CATs gen-
erally have in any particular market and the considerable length of
time necessary for the effects of CATV to work themselves out.” 28
43. Like the Seiden report, the CBS study bases its discussion of -
CATV potential and impact on CATV. systems-operating or fran-.
chised as of August 1964. It concludes, therefore, that CATV poten-
tial is limited to communities more than 40 miles from three stations :
providing the service of the three networks (plus some metropolitan
2? Percentages total more than_100 percent because some multiple answers were given.
- % AMST argues that this timelag is not as great as CBS asserts. It states. (re ly com-
ments, p: 22): “However long before an affiliate’s network rate card is affected, adver-
tisers will inevitably drop from network orders those stations which show serious audience
losses. whether from CATV or any other cause. - That this is the likely sequence is demon-
strated by the parallel situation—netwoérk radio, which felt the impact of television by
sharp decreases in station orders long before those stations’ network rates Weregaffected.”
-2 F.C.C. 2d
-
°20 . Federal Communicationg. Commission Reports
area apartment-house-dwellers), an estimated-.6-8 million TV homes.
*] However, the study recognizes (p. 14) that CATV “systems are clearly
moving closer to transmitting points” and states further (pp. 16-17) :
There is a final caveat that must be made at this point. There has been
in the very recent past, and not included in the systems -in our study, a
group’ of applications far CATV systems in communities with three more
than adequate network ices which do not appear to be related to ..
apartment-house reception problems. Thus, applications for franchises have
been made in places like Albany, Syracuse, Galveston, Philadelphia, and
Cleveland, and a franchise has just been granted in Wilmington, Del. * * *
While these do provide alternative programing, we do not know as yet
whether this added factor will be sufficient to make the systems viable. If
these systems are established and thrive, it is clear that the potential for
community antenna systems far exceeds anything that we have talked
about thus far and, in fact, much of fhe country could ultimately become
CATV territory.” sila tae ,
44. In view of the rapidly changing circumstances outlined above,
we can see no point in conducting a further factfinding inquiry with
respect to nonmicrowave CATV as it has existed in the past. The
extensive studies conducted by Dr. Fisher, Dr. Seideny and NCTA in
conjunction with dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233,” and further studies
of CBS and AMST in this proceeding, all concerned nonmicrowave
" as well as microwave CATV systems. Studies of this nature are out
of date almost before we have had time to consider them. Moreover,,.
they are of limited value since they cannot measure some of the most
important factors we are bound to consider. These include the cumue
lative future effect of greater penetration sy CATV. systems fran-
- chised or applied for but not yet in operation, the degree of success
to be achieved’ by CATV systems in bie -aitien or other well-served
. areas, and the effect of the burgeoning CATV activity—if left unregu-
lated—on-the decisions of potential applicants and existing licensees.
} » asto whether to inaugurate or improve service. —_. ag
; 45. What we Said in the first report and order in rejecting NCTA’s .
; argument that regulatory action should not be taken in the absence of ©
-& showing that stations have ceased operation, or are about to cease
operation, applies with equal force to its renewal of that argument
here.** We stated (par. 77) : 7 a
" » See, e.g.. pars. 20 and 32 of the first report and order in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233,
: and p. 49 of the Seiden report. : - ' ;
» The CBS study further asserts (pp. 27-30) that the effects of a rise in CATV pene-
. tration with its depressing effect on station revenues are offset in large Segre by .the per-
3 sistent rise in advertising demand for television time. However, as AMST points out,
q the number of stations ring the advertising demand is also increasing as new UHF sta-
; tions stimulated by the all-channel law commence operations. Moreover, annual broadcast
expenses are on the average increasing apace with revenues. : '
ih “ While the distant signal procedure adopted in y II.will probably have some effect on .
the trends we have been here discussing, we. think that application of the carriage and’
nonduplication requirements to all systems is still required in the public interest. First, |
not daly will this end the present unwarranted discrimination between the microwave and
nonmicrowave system, but it is cajled for on the basis of the fair competition und, dis-
cussed in pars. 26—-27.- Second, as to the economic-impact und we note that in view
of recent growth, there are a 4 ‘substantial number of CATY systems operating on the
date of release of this report with the renga to keep growing to perhaps 50-70 percent
of the television homer in their communities, and thus to have a cumulative effect in areas
such as those noted in the prior discussion (e.g., pars. 35-37). New systems will continue
to’ come into operation. under the interim procedure, and it rg A be important that the
cumulative effect of such systems, after growth to significant figures, be ameliorated to
some extent by the car and nonduplication requirement. _ Most important, the dis-~
tant-signal procedure is interim nature, subject to discontinuation or revision. See
par. 150. carriage and nonduplication rules which we adopt here are not interim—
they are our. best judgment of what the public interest calls for over an indefinite period.
2 F.C.C. 2d
,
AEN Kat OC oh BR sl ae abe clea olaita bi
.
Sah HTT ale hl he eS LAN Shin Aes a Ely
rd aia
sana Hi
vary. : 21
NCTA’s argument that CATV has not yet caused any widespread demise
of existing stations misses the point. -As we have pointed out above, it
would be clearly contrary to the public interest to defer_action until a seri-
ous Joss of existing and potential service had already occurred, or until
pee ner service had been significantiy impaired. Corrective action after
the damage has already~been done, if not too late, is certainly much more |
difficalt. Further, it is difficult, if not impossible,’to attempt to delineate
. With any. precision a factor such as discouragement of entry of potential
broadcasters because of CATV competition. In short, we must plan now.
for the healthy coexistence of CATV and local stations and safeguard the
public from future injury. _Cireumstances have changed since -qur “1969
report and order, and the likelihood or probability of adverse impact upon
potential and existing service has become too substantial to be dismissed. If
studies are in conflict and present a close question as to the precise extent
of the impact, it is not close as to how this uncertainty should be resolved.
This is one of those situations in which the public interest requires that
conditions conducive to the sound future of television “be assured rather
than left uncertain.” United States vy. Detroit Navigation Co., 326 U.S. 236,
241. “This is particularly so, where we have two modes’ of service, one of
which is,almost completely dependent on the other for its product. In such
circumstances, uncertainties should be resolved in favor of insuring the .
healthy growth and maintenance of the basic service.
46. In sum, we have concluded in the first report and order in
dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233 that che public interest requires that
CATV systems carry local stations without duplication for a reason- -
able period, in order to avoid unfair competitive disadvantage to-and
ree goon effect on existing and potential broadcast service. We
1ave concluded herein that we have authority under the present provi-
sions of the Communications Act: to extend these requirements to non-
microwave systems. In view of the rapid surge in CATV growth
since this proceeding was initiated, we think that our statutory obliga-
tions require us to act now in the areas we have proposed. This
will end the present unwarranted distinction between. microwave and
nonmicrowave systems; and will enable us to make the rules effective -
before operations are commenced by a large number of CATV
proposals presently in the franchise or application stage. ;
- -C. Substantive Provisions of the Rules
47. CATV systems, as we recognized in the first report (pars. 43,
‘48) and here again emphasize, have arisen in response to public need
and demand for improved television service and perf@¥m valuable
public services in this respect. CATV (like other auxiliary televi-
sion services) makes possible the provision of a variety of program
‘choices, particularly,the three full network services, to many persons
in‘ areas with no local station and in one- and two-station markets. -
CATV ‘systems also afford a means of providing nonnetwork commer-
cial and educational services to many persons in areas with insufficient
population to support local broadcast outlets of this nature. CATV
systems make important contributions by providing good quality.
reception pf color signals and improving reception of local signals in
areas within the predicted contours of local stations where off-the-air
reception is inferior or precluded because of terrain, manmade struc-
tures, or other factors. We do not intend to deprive the public of
these important benefits or to restrict the enriched programing selec-
. . 2 F.C.C. 2d
PN erm eva Ue: wean NE
ss Ae Hse aM WEL A een us
or
a eo
= %,
. : a
22 Fedcral Communications Commission Reports
ee ee *
.tion which CATV makes available. Rather; ove goal. here is to inte-
grate the CATV seryice into the national television structure ih such a _
way as to promote maximum television service to all people of the.
United States (secs. 1 and 303(g) of the act), both those whe are cable
viewers and those dependent on off-the-air service. ‘The new rules dis-
cussed below are the minimum measures weé believe to be essential to
insure that CATV continues to perform its valuable supplementary
role without unduly damaging or impeding the growth of television
broadcast service. ; |
48. To insure effective integration of CATV within a fully devel-
7 television service, the new regulations will apply aenly to all,
ATV systems, including those which require microwave licenses and
those which receive their signals off the air.*? We have carefully
reexamined the CATV rules currently in effect for microwave-fed sys-
tems, and have made some changes. The microwave rules will be
revised to reflect the new rules adopted for all systems.
49. In brief, under the new rules, a CATV system will be required,
. upon request and within the limits of its channel ——— to carry
without material degradation the signals of all local television sta-
tions within whose grade B contours the CATV system is located,
in order of priority of signal grade. A CATV system will be
required, upon request, to avoid duplication of the programs of local
television stations carried on thé’system during the same day that such
programs are broadcast by the local stations. This nonduplication
protection, as under the existing rules, will apply to “prime time”
network programs (i.e., presented by the network between 6 and
11 p.m., eastern time) only if such programs are presented by the
local station entirely within what is locally considered to be “prime
time.” . Nonduplication protection will not be afforded to programs
which are carried in black and white by the local station and are
available in color from a more distant station on the CATV system. |
Ad hoc consideration will be given to petitions from local television
stations seeking a ter degree of protection than provided by the
rules, or from CATV operators seeking a waiver of the rules, and we
are adopting procedures to facilitate such petitions. Moreover, the
-Commission will continue to give full effect to private a ments
between CATV operators and local television stations which provide
for a different type or degree of protection for the local station than
do the Commission’s rules.**. Ett
50. Thus, the carriage requirements made applicable to all CATV
systems ‘will be substantially the same as those applied to microwave-
served systems by the Commission’s first report, except in certain
minor respects discussed in — 74 and 83 below. However,
the new nonduplication rules embody two substantial changes from
those adopted in 'the first report. First, the time period during which
nonduplication protection must be afforded has been reduced from
15 days before and after local broadcast to the single day of the local
broadcast. Second, a new exemption from the nonduplication require-
EEE >.
2 Excluded from these rules will be those CATV systems which serve less than 50 sub-
scribers, or which serve only as an apartment-house masterantenna. - ° .
3 Private a ments will not avoid the necessity for evidentiary hearing for the im-
portation of distant signals into the top 100 markets (pt. II, below), thoygh such agree-
ments will be considered in our decision. .
2 F.C.C. 2d a
=~ ~ . --* —_
+
2
CATV — 23
. ment has been added as to color: programs not carried.in color by
local stations. We shall discuss the nonduplication changes first
because they are of a major nature.
1.. The nonduplication provisions ay Tocca tal
51. Modification of the ee period.—Nonduplication at ’
the same time that a local broadcast is being carried on the cable is
clearly called for in the public interest for the reasoris discussed above ~
and in the first report.. Simultaneous nonduplication protects the
bulk of the popular network programing of most network affiliates
' and does not affect the time that such programing is available to the
CATV subscriber. Im the first report we further determined that
some measure of protection beyond simultaneous nonduplication
would also serve the public interest on a number of grounds. We
shall not repeat here the reasons set forth in the first report for that
determirfation or for the further judgment that a 15-day before-and-
after period was appropriate.’ == —*
- 52. We have reconsidered the latter judgment and have decided to
strike a different balance in ight of the fact that the rules are now
-being-made applicable to a large number of existing systems and will
affect their existing service to the CATV — public. The sys-
tems which will now operate under the rules for the first time consti-
tute the great bulk of the CATV industry. In addition to all non--
microwave systems, they include a sizable number of microwave
CATVs served pursuant to authorizations granted prior to Decem- ~
1963 when the interim condition cargo an. We recognize
th the imposition of a 15-day before-and-after nonduplication
requirement on systems which have not previously ope in this
‘manner would tend to substantially disrupt the viewing habits of the
CATV subscribers. As NCTA points out (NCTA comments, exhibit
B, pp. 35-38), there is no question but that large numbers of CATV’
subscribers have become accustomed to viewing network programs at
the time they are presented -by the distant affiliates., Although
15-day before-and-after nonduplication was not required where timeli-’
ness was “ry woarw and all distant cit = ms deleted under the
rujes would have been available to the c TV subscriber via the local -
signal at some time within the total 30-day period, the CATV viewer
might ‘not be able to view it on the later date of presentation by the
local station for any number of personal reasons. :
53. We believe it desirable to avoid disruption to the established
viewing habits of the public as much as gr Moreover, we are
seeking to THO to the extent practicable, the valuable public con-
tribution of CATV in providing wider access to nationwide program-
ing and a wider selection of programs on any particular day. Balanc-
ing al] the pertinent considerations, we thinkthat the nonduplication
period should be reduced to the same day for existing systems. Not
only will’ this eliminate the great bulk of delayed nonduplication
requests (see par. 125,.first report), but it will insure that the pro-
gram is available to the CATV audience that same day and, in the
case of network prime-time programs, that samé evening. While
not wholly eliminating any ible change in viewing time on the
pertinent day, this revision clearly minimizes any disruptive effect on
2 F.C.C. 2d
2
eo ee Tyee rf BM eva sorted Core
—_Nee eee
24 F ederal Communications Commission Reports
the CATV viewer. As an incidental benefit, we note that same-day
nonduplication will substantially reduce the areas of possible dispute
* between broadcasters and CATVs in-complying with the rules, and to
this extent will facilitate ease of administration. Ler _
54. Application of « 15-day before-and-after nonduplication provi-
sion to new systems would not, of course, cause a similar disruption
to established viewing habits, since the CATV subscriber would from
the beginning receive service in accordance with the rules. It would
be possible to “grandfather” existing systems ona same-day non- |
duplication basis and make 15-day nonduplication effective only as
to new systems. But there are a number of countervailing arguments.
First, even in the case of the new system, there is disruptive effect to
the extent that the CATV subscriber may not be able to. view pro-
grams from distant stations at the times specified jn his TV guide
(and may be unable to view them at the later date presented by the
local station for any number of reasons). It jg our understandin
that it is essentially for that reason that some broadcasters, althoug
‘ previously entitled under our microwave rules to 15-day before-and-
after nonduplication protection, have requested. only simultaneous
nonduplication. Second, it is obviously preferable to have one set
of rules for all systems and thus to avoid the anomaious situation of — -
millions of CATV subscribers viewing under one set of rules and
other milljons, often neighbors in close-by communities, subjected to ,
a different set. Under the circumstances, we think it better to provide
by rule for same-day nondyplication for all systems, and to safeguard °
the public. interest in the particular instance warranting different
treatment pursuant. to, tlie ad hoc procedures discussed in paragraph
97 below. } Doc ee
55. We also considéred the question of retaining the 15-day before-
and-after nonduplication provision for nonnetwork programing.
Lut, as we have ‘previously recognized, and indeed stress in this
report (pars. 123, 131, infra), 15-day before-and-after nonduplication *
affords, at best, only minimal protection with, respect to the presenta-
tion by local stations of syndicated and film programing. Such pro-
graming is not presented on a nationwide simultaneous or even nearly
simultaneous basis. Retention of the 15-day provision for non-
network programs alone would serve little effective purpose. Stated
differently, thaadoption of a uniform “same day” rule will not, in.our
judgment, significantly affect the protection afforded as to nonnet work
or independent programing. Rather, we have determined that. we
must look elsewhere if we are to achieve effective relief in this respect.
We treat the situation of the independent station in part II below:
_As a general approach-encompassing all stations, we are proposing to
the Congress that it consider the question of extending the rebroad-
cast concept of section 325(a) to CATV. © It may be that regulation
% of this nature would prove a referable and more effective means of
lar network programing, most network affiliated stations should be viable.
mar | fair recognition of the exclusivity contracts of the program
marketplace. Here in, we shall consider requests seeking more
extensive protection“? nonnetwork programing on an ad hoc basis to
“With “same day” nonduplication affording substantial protection to the most popu-
* 2 F.C.C. 2d
s
OREO 0h), Ee ’
o>;
1
- #
>
4
«
4 | fos.
CATV. ) . —
insure thatthe public interest is not prejudiced in the unusual situation:
(although, as stated, we are unaware of any instance where the 15-day
period afforded effective relief in this respect).
56..While conflicting considerations are presented, we believe that.
our resolution eonstitutes a fair compromise. First, same-day non-
duplication is clearly sufficient to take care of the time zone differential
problem, i.e., to preclude a CATV system, which brings programs
_ across either border of the mountain time zone, from duplicating most,
if not all, of a local station’s network programs an hour or two
before or after they are presented locally. Moreover, it will afford
the station affiliated: with more than one network some leeway in pre-
senting what it regards as the most attractive programs of each for
the benefit of the non-CATV audience (and also, the CATV audi-
ence—see par. 115, first report) so long as such programs are pre-.
sented on the same day as the network presentation and prime-time
programs are broadcast entirely within prime-time hours.* This
will, as stated, minimize any disruption to the CATV subscribers. In
addition, we will consider réquests by local stations and CATV sys-
tems for different treatment on an ad hoc basis, pursuant to the sum-
mary procedures discussed in paragraph 97, where possible, or by
evidentiary hearing if necessary. ‘Thus, the station which receives its
network programing by mail, or the station or m which faces
some other unusual problem, can bring its situafion to our attention
for such relief as may be appropriate in the, individual circumstances
- arid warranted by the public interest. Similarly, the CATY. system
ean seek a waiver of the rules. —We stress, in addition, that the Com- .
mission will continue to give full effect to private agreements between
CATV operators and local television stations which provide for a
different type or d of protection for the local station than do
the Commission’s rules. We believe that the above resolution fairly
serves the public interest. If further revisions are needed on the basis
of ourgxperience with these new provisions, we shall of course move
promptly to implement such revisions., \ 4
57. Our decision to adopt same-day nonduplication makes appro-
priate some ofher revisions in the exclusivity: sections of the rules.
First, howevér, we stress thosé provisions which.remain unchanged.
We shall in the provision requiring the local station to present .
prime-time network programing entirely within prifme-time hours in
order to be entitled to nonduplication.** Thus, the CATV system
*In this connection, we note that the amount of delayed network broadcasting in the
“median one- or two-station markets is about 5% and 11 hours per week, respectively. See
par. 108, first report. While this amount is not insignificant and we. recoghize that there
will be some detriment to the public if the local station in the median market curtails
delayed broadcasts because of absence of nonduplication protection, we point out that
the amount of delayed broadcasts is not of too large a nature in the median market, and that
_we would not expect the local station to céase all delayed broadcasts in the absence of
delayed nonduplication protection. .Moreover, the ing liberalization of our translator ~
oe may t in greater availability of off- air service in one- and two-station
ee AMST has requested élimination of the exception fay prime-time programs broadcast
outside-of prime-time hours. AMST urges that this provision is unnecessary because it is
normally in the best interests of the station to carry prime-time programs in prime hours
and the Commission has ample power to remedy any abuse. It is further asserted that
there may be instances where a station reasonably desires, and has network consent. to
carry such programs at other burs. However, a prior ‘ATV presentation does not pre-
clude the station from repeatfng the program outside of prime time if it has good reason
to do so, and it is unlikely that instances of this nature would arise often enough to make
* the loss of exclusivity a significant problem. Since the provision is designed to insure that
CATV subscribers have prime-time programs yt mer | available in the hou ~
——
imum viewing, the public
.
°
26 . Federal Communications Commission Reports
need not. delete reception of any network program which is scheduled.
by the network betwee the hours of 6 and 11. p.m., eastern time, but
which is broadcast by the station —— deletion, ‘in, whole or in
part, outside of the period which would normally‘be considered prime
time for the network programing ii the time zone involved. This
will insure that such programs are available to the CATV subscribers
“in maximum viewing hours.’ We shall also retain the provision that -
the CATV system need not delete reception of any program as to
which time of presentation is of special significance, such as a speech
or — event, except where the pr m is being simultaneously —
broadcast by the local station. And, although it is of greatly reduced
‘significance for same-day nonduplication, we shall retain the provision
that the CATV system need not delete ——- of a network pro-
gram if, in so doing, it would leave available for reception by sub-
scribers, at any time, less than the programs of two networks
(including those broadcast by any stations whose signals are being
carried and whose program exclusively is being protected ‘pursuant ”
to the requirements of the rules) . mp ,
58. However, there no longer appears to be any real necessity, ‘for
_ the provisos to sections 21.712 (g) , 74.1083 (e), and 91.559(e), i.e., that:
(1) The system is not required to maintain the exclusivity of the network
programing of any such station if the system carries the signal(s) of one
or more 1 or higher priority stations (other than a satellite or parent
of the station requesting exclusivity) which substantially duplicates the
network programing of the station requesting exctusivity : and >
(2) The system is not required to maintain the exclusivity of the non- -
network: programing of any such station if the system carries the signal(sd__—
of one or more equal or higher priority stations (other than a satellite or
parert of the station requesting exclusivity) which operatés in what are
normally and usually considered other markets for purposes of television *
program distribution.
These provisions were grounded in the 15-day before-and-after non-
duplication period which protected network programs delayed sub-
stantially beyond the date of network presentation and protected
nonnetwork programs fr a total of 30 days. In view of same-day
nonduplication, we shall provide simply that higher priority signals
carried on the system are entitled fo exclusivity against lower priority
or more distant signals byt not against signals of equal priority.*’
59.. Color duplication.—In the first report and order in dockets Nos.
14895 and, 15233 we decided that the public interest would be served
by some accommodation which would permit a CATV system to dupli-
cate the programs of a local station in color where the station trans-
_ mits only in black and white (par. 143)... However, we did not there
-determine whether such an exception should apply across the board
or whether the CATV system should be required to make a threshold
showing that a certain number or percentage of its subscribers
color receiving sets. Comiment on this question was invited in this
Pp ah sis
60. Most of the comments, from broadcast and CATV interests
’ alike, favor permitting color duplication on an across-the-board basis. »
* Though these modifications stem from-our action in shortening the nonduplication
period, we note that changes of this nature were requested by AMST and ABC under the
15-day before-and-after nonduplication period.
2 F.C.C. 24
°
~~
ys ae 1)
No one has supported the proposed alternative of uiring a thresh-.“. -
old showing: by the CA system. It is — that it is in the.
__. public ‘interest. for color programing to be available to as many per- -.
sons as possible, and that this should be encouraged by the Commis-
.sion pursuant to section 303(g) of the act. The few comments
opposed to making-an exception for color claim that it is unnecessary.
The assert that most stations not already equipped to present net-
work programs in‘color will acquire such equipment now that all of -
the networks have commenced a significant degree of color transmis-
sion. . It is further asserted that the exception would penalize smaller
stations lacking financial resources to convert to color.
61. In light‘of the comments, we have decided to permit color dupli-
cation of local black and white transmissions without requiring any
threshold showing by the CATV system. It may be that most stations
will shortly’ be equipped to present network programs in color. But
in that event is touadanauch have no real cause for complaint in the ©
adoption of a provision which will not adversely affect them. We
think that the exception is in the direction of encouraging the wider
distribution of color programing and that”it is consistent with the
supplementary role d CATV. Any local station finding itself at a:
significant disadvantage can install equipment for the transmission of
_ network color programs “at relatively little expense” (cowfments of
American Broadcasting Co.), which would benefit its non-CATV view-
ing public. Hardship situations may be brought to the Commission
for guch relief as may be warranted by the station’s showing. Ac-
pooner the rwes governing microwave-served CATVs will be-
amended in this respect and the exception will be incorporated in the
rules adopted for all systems. The exception will-also apply where a
- local station, is equip = simultaneous color transmission of net-
work programs, but delay%a color program for later pré&entation on
the same day by means of black and white videotapes.
62. Some of the CATV comments urge us to go further and permit
dupjication of local colorcasts wheré a. CATV system makes a show-
ing that the technical quality of the local signal is substantially infe-
.Tior to another signal. While we would, of course, consider any such
showing on a case-by-case basis, we have no-reason to anticipate any
oe problem warranting action by rule.. We expect that valid
complaints of this nature will be‘rare. In most instances the technical -
y werd of the local signal should be sufficiently good to permit satis-
actory color reception on the cable if the CATV system and the.
station cobperate in good faith to accomplish this result. We would
_ expect good-faith efforts by both to resolve any technical problem
before any complaint is madeto the Commission.
63. Other changes in the nonduplication provisions suggested by the
rties.—The comments of NCTA —— B, pp. 35-38). assert that
t minute program changes by the local station require the’ CATV
operator to bear the labor costs of a manually controlled switching
device or to punch a new tape for the remainder of the week where
an automatic switch is used.. While this assertion was made in the
context of the delayed nonduplication provision, we think that the
broadcaster should afford the CATV sufficient advance notice of non-
' 2 F.C. 24
4
ys .
5s
¥
4
3
i
. &
is
pions dala sat Sanka rane susan lites’ eadncetian 42s
Pape Wa
oe =o *
oe ? “
28 ~—Ss- Federal Communitations Commission Reports
can -
_duplicatior. requests to permit the CATV system to make its program
- schedule available to subscribers,an@to set an automatic switchin
device only once for the entire. week.‘ Accordingly, we shall amen
section 21.712(h), 74.1033 (f), and 91.559(f) to require that the sta-
tion, upon request of the CATV operator, shall give notice under these
sections at least 8 days prior to the: broadcast to be deleted. Since
same-day nonduplication affects priricipally network programs, which
are ordinartly presented at the same time each week during the net-
work seasorr, this amendment should pose no difficulty. for the station.**
“Indeed, in miost instances it would appear that such notice coujt*be
given at the start.of the network season and continued in effect/until
* further notice occasioned’ by charges ‘in the schedule of the network
e 7 é 8
or the local station. ea ae ; A
64. AMST urges that the rules be modified to provide nendupli¢a-
tion protection to local stations which arg not. carried on the dible—.
either because no request. has been:made or because of the'limited chan-
nel.capacity of the system:» It states that carriage has ng essenti#l
relationship to nonduplication-and should not. be-a condition of the
‘latter. We cannot‘agree. ‘If nonduplication were afforded where*the | |
local statiqgn is not carried, the CATV subscriber’ would, in some
instances, be greatly inconvenienced and, much more i in
others be deprived of all opportunity to view the programs involved.
~See paragraph. 51, Sep? 4g mic This is, not the purpose or effect. of
tlie.rules as written, n6r would -it serve the public interest: As set
forth Yn paragraph 68 below, the better procedure where the system's
channel c&pacity is too limited to — full carriage of the local .
. station is to substitute its programs fo
Partial carriage Would retain the availability of the programs to —
r the duplicating outside signal.
CATV subscribers and-at-the same time afford the station some m
.ure of protection. ; ;
_ . 65. Other changes in the nonduplication. provisions requested by |
AMST and’ ABC ‘have been rendered moot by our action in shortening . >
the nonduplication period to 1 day and the modifications we have made
in that connection. Accordingly, we shall,not discuss their conten- —
' tions in this respect. The comments with respect to. nonduplication
of noncommercial educational stations are discussed in a separate sec-
-tion on educational television (sec. 4 below).
2. The carriage provisions -
66. We shall, as stated,. apply to all CATV systems substantially
the same carriage requirements as were adopted fot microwave-served
systems in. the first report.*® .Thus, within the limits of its channel
commercial and educational television stations within whose grade B
"contour the system is located, giving priority : First, to principal com-’
munity signals: second, to grade: A signals: and third. to grade, B
signals. The CATV system need not, carry the signal of any station,
* It has come to our attention that the requesting station may have difficulty in giving
notice where the CATV does not always carry the same signals. Wheréa CATV system
varies the signals carried, it should provide the local stations with a copy of the CATV
. schedule in sufficient time to permit the station to give notice of the, oe to be deleted.
( mi ge ty however, changes stemming from our resblution of the ranslator question
rec. ¢ ow). , ee cigtoa ‘ ; ie
2 F.C.C. 24
She i
_ capacity, a CATV system will be required to carry the-signals of all -
“
%
“CATV © es
if (1) that station’s network programing is substantially duplicated
by one or more stations of higher priority, and (2) carrying it would,
because of limited channel capacity, prevent the system from carrying
thc signal of an independent commercial station or a noncommercial
educational station. Moreover, in cases where (4) there are two or
more signals of equal priority which substantially duplicate each other, -
and-(2) carrying all such sigrials would, because of limited channel.
capacity, prevent the system from carrying the signal of an independ-
ent commercial station or a noncommercial educational station, the
System need not carry all such substantially duplicating signals, but
may select among them to the extent necessary to preserve its ability to
carry the signals of independent commercial or noncommercial educa-.
tional stations. Where a signal is required to be carried, it shall be.
‘ - carried without material degradation in quality, and shall be carried in
full except to the extent that nonduplication of higher priority signals
may be required under the rules. Upon request of the local station,
the signal shall be carried on the system on the channel on which the
» tation is transmitting (where practicable without material degrada-'
- tion) and on no more than orie channel. . Where a-system is not carry-
ing the signal of a grade B or higher priority station, it shall offer-and
- maintain for each.subscriber a switching device to allow the subscriber <
to choose between cable and’noncable reception, unless the subscriber
indicates in writing that he does not desire this device. . me ;
67. Modifications requested by the parties—Some.of the parties -
have requested ‘changes in these provisions. Thus, NCTA urges that
CATV subscribers see no reason why out-of-State stations should be
regarded as local.s It asserts that CATV systems should have the
option to carry more distant signals originating within the same State _
in preference to out-of-Sfate stations placing a grade B signal over thé ©
community. Weagree that there may well be instances where the pro-
. graming of stations located withiii the State would be of greater inter-
est than those of nearer, but out-of-State stations—e.g., coverage of
political eleetions and other public affairs of statewide concern. We
recognize also that there.may be instances where out-of-State stations
_ located in another Stite are of greater community interest than the
- geographically nearer out-of-State stations because of closer com--
munity ties with the third State. Considerations of this nature will
be accorded substantial weight as a basis for waiver of the carriage.
provisions. eo es .
- 68. In this connection, we emphasize.that we intend to make every '
effort, consistent with the public interest, to avoid disrupting existing |’
service to the public in applying the carridge provisions of the rules to
systems now in operation.*® Where, because of limited channel.capac-
ity, a. CATV, system cannot carry all grade B signals without drop-
ping #more distant signal now being carried, we shall entertain a
“request for waiver of the rules pursuant to the summary procedures
discussed in paragraph 97 below and: upon the basis of the showing
specified in paragraphs 104,106. In appropriate circumstances, waiv-
. # As in the case of our present policy with respect to microwave systems. carriage will
not be required where a sufficient showing is made that a predicted, signal is not in fact
present in the community. or that a good signal is not obtainable because of technical
defictencies on tife part of the station. ; :
a °
Sone nwo , — vse
, e = . a
® . _ 2 F.C.C. 2d
is
wales ehh
. ° ‘
ADDI be eihaties te hia aaah. Regs at aiiehinsti . .
petits ails Lily heii
4
=
5
&
RY
4 =
:
_ obvious
30 _ Federal Communications Commission Reports”
ers will be granted, which will permit the system to continue to carry
the distant signal and to substitute the n@@rer signal only where simul-
taneous duplication would occur. Thus, upon such waivers the CATV
viewers would continue to receive all programs to which they were
accustomed, via the-more distant signal when the programs are dif-
ferent and via the local signal when the programs are the same. New
systems can commence operation with a channel capacity sufficient to —
carry both the local and the distant signals; indeed, most new systems
now commence operation with 12-channel capacity. é
69.Section 21.712(f) (2), . section- 74.1033(d) (2), and section
91.559(d) (2) presently provide that where a signal is required to be
carried, it “shall; upon request of the station licensee or permittee, be
carried on the system on the channel on which the station is trans-
Inc., and WKBH Television, Inc., urge that carriage on channel
should be a matter for the-station’s choice. According to WJ AC, the
station should be entitled both to insist that its signal be carried on
another channel, and to select the channel of a lower priority or non-
local station.. AMST claims, on. the,other hand, that carriage on |
channel ig extremely important and oe elem mandatory unless the
~ CATV makes a compelling showing thad this is not technically feasible. —
without degradation. It states thdt the CATV should be required
to take all reasonable steps to eliminate material degradation which
* may result from the CATV equipment. used or inadequate installation.
70. Since sections, 21.712(f) (1), 74.1033(d) (1), and 91.559(d) (1)
already provide that the “signal shall be carried without material _
degradation in quality (within the limitations imposed by the technical
state of the art),” we do not think that any change in subsection (2) is.
- called for. The requirement for onchannel carriage is only operative’.
upon -request of the station licensee or permittee. If this results in:
material degradation, the station can request carriage on another
channel. Moreover, if.the channel capacity of the system is such that
soine er must suffer. material degradation, the. inferior signal
y should not. be that of a higher priority station. First .
report and order in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233, paragraph 135._
However, no reason appears why it is necessary for the station itself
to select the alternative channel. So long as the requirements of the
rules are met, the CATV operator should be free to decide how ‘the
channels on its cable are to be utilized. °
71. AMST further asserts that the CATV svstem should not have
complete discretion under sections 21.712(d) (2), 74.1033 (b) (2), and
91.559 (b) (2) to select amon¢ substantially duplicating signals of equal —
grade where noncarriage of one or more is necessary to preserve its
ability to carry the signals of independent commercial or noncommer-
cial educational stations. ‘It urges that the rule should be modified to
set forth reasonable standards for selection, such as the respective dis-
tances of the stations from the community, relative signal strength,
respective audiences in the community—as measured “by audience
surveys, terrain considerations, and the like. We recognized in the:
first report and order in Dockets-Nos. 14895 and 15233, paragraph 91,
that leaving the selection to the CATV’s discretion makes possible “dis-
2 F.C.C. 2d
oe
mitting (where practicable without material degradation).” WJAC, - —
~s
- Catv | - 34
crimination between local ‘signals in some instances.” We further
~ stated that we would closely exarfine complaints of abuse, particularly -
where the CATV operator has an ownership or other interest;in one of
the duplicating channels. We shall also give particular consideration
to any allegation that the station not carried is one with-closer com-.
munity ties. The criteria suggested by AMST would not do away with
the necessity for case-by-case resolution of complaints. AMST con-
cedes (comments, p. 20) that’ any criteria for determining priority
should not be inflexible and that an opportunity should still be pro-
vided forthe submission of other data to the Commission. In the aa
circumstances, it seems preferable to retain the rule in its present form
until experience in its administration demonstrates what refinements _
might be needed or appropriate.
72. AMST also claims that exclusion of nearby network-affiliated -
stations in order to bring in distant independent stations which do not
lace a grade B signal over the community. of the CATV, should not
permitted since “this would drastically affect the normal off-the-air :
competitive patteri of television service” (AMST comments,: pp. 20-
21). This provision is admittedly a “cdmpromise approach,’ recog-
nizing both that a CATV ye owes its primary duty to the stations
that are closest and place the best signal over its community, and also
that carriage of nonnetwork signals ms y contribute to the diversity of
its service (first report and order in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233, par.
89). The general questions of whether there should be some limit on
. the distance and number of nonlocal signals brought in, as well as the
matter of “leapfrogging,” are <n considered in part IT of this -
proceeding. - Pending resolution of these matters, we shall retain the
rule in its present form. .
73. Next, AMST asserts that the installation of a switching device
. Should be mandatory in all cases, whether or not the.local signal is’
carried,.so that the subscriber will not be foreclosed from off-the-air .
service where the cable system is inoperative or not operating properly.
It is further urged that no — should be made when the ws
scriber indicates in writing that he does not desire a switch, since the -
requirement.could easily be avoided by a “small-print” waiver in: the-
subscription contract. While these suggestions may have some merit,
we do not think they warrant a revision of the rules. The rules are
‘ designed to protect local stations in areas which are crucial and essen-
tial to preserve and encourage service to the public. For the reasons.
stated in paragraph 51 of the first report, particularly that going to
“sheer incanvenience of switching * * *,” we do not view this area as
one of great significance, requiring further revision, . ;
74..A further change suggested by AMST does, however, appear.
to warrant modification of the rules. Sections 21.712(d) (3), 74.1033
(b} (3), and 91.559(b) (3) now provide that .where a CATV system.
operates within the grade B or higher priority contour of both a
satellite station and its parent, carriage’of one will relieve the system
of any obligation to carry the other. AMST points out that this
would allow a CATV system in, or very near to, the same community
as the satellite to carry only. the parent station, causing the satellite
to lose audience for which it may be originating some local programing
"2 FCC. 24 ae
' 236-331 O—e6— 6. -
.
ey ee ne a! ORE so
i 32
and reducing its incentive to originate programs. It urges that satel-
- delayed broadeasts have later presented only a portion of t
a
.
AN gen IE oe
ein PA A SA Sy so NB 2s
Federal Communications Commission Reports
lites should be treated like any other station in accordance with the
prescribed priorities. Since satellites operate on. assigned channels
and possess the potential to develop into regular stations, there is a
strong public interest in encouraging them to do so. ‘ Accordingly,
: ‘sections 21.712 (ad) (3) and (g) (3), 74.1033 (b) (3) and (e) (3), and’ °
91.559 (b)(3) and (e) (3), together with the note to those sections,
will be deleted. , Lary
75. And, finally,“ AMST suggests that CATVs'be required to re-
frain from deleting or altering any portioti (including advertising)
of signals carried pursuant to the rules. ‘Such a requirement is im-
licit in the carriage provisions and we would so rule upon complaint.
he addition of an explicit provision doés not appear necessary in.
the absence of some evidence of abuse. In this connection, we note
that it is asserted in the comments of NCTA that some broadcasters .
who have requested systems to refrain from advance 5 apioeme of
1e program.
Since the CATV system is relying exclusively upon the signal of the
local station to’bring the program to its subscribers, the station has an
obligation to present in full any program for which nonduplication
is requested. Again, upon complaint we would rule spent 3 See:
ica
also paragraph 158, first report. . Moreover, same-day nonduplication
the changes occasioned by our disposition of the translator questions
(sec. 3 below), the carriage requirements of the new rules will be the .
same as the provisions now governing microwave-served systems.
3. Translators -
77. Part I of the notice in this proceeding (par. 36) requested com-
* ments on two questions concerning translators: (1), Whether CATVs
‘should be required to carry and not duplicate the signals of station-
owned translators operating beyond the parent station’s grade B con- .
tour,*? and (2) whether translators should themselves be precluded
from duplicating the: programs of local stations.
78. With respect to the first question, the parties have expressed .
- diverse views. The CATV .interests and some of the broadcasters argue -
against extending any protection to translators outside the grade B
contour because. such translators are operating outside the normal
service area of the parent. station, do not provide'a local service or
possess the poteiitial for developing into regular local stations, and are
relatively inexpensive to construct and operate. It is further asserted
>
“1 AMST also asks that the definition of substantially duplicating network: programing .
(secs. 21.710(f), 74.1001(e) (6) and 91.557(f)) be modified to apply only to a situation
where two or more stations are primary affiliates of the same network. While such a defini-
_ tion might have been equally one eer as an original matter, we do not think that any
difference between the two is signi
An additional proposal of AMST that the substantially duplicated concept be retained
only fof purposes of carriage has in effect been granted in view. of the matters discussed in
spar. 58 above.
@ Under the rules adopted in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233, station-owned translators
located within the grade B contour are ‘treated as extensions of the originating station
(secs. 21.710(b), 74.1001 (e) (2), and.91.557(b)). Such translators will be treated the same
under the new rules. é : : te
.2 F.C.C., 2d
will greatly reduce the likelihood of any incidents of this nature. *
76. Accordingly; apart from the provisions relating to satellites and -
nt enough to warrant redoing the rules at this point. -
mv nie
CATV © | 33
that translators should not be protected because they may impede the
establishment of local stations. ) mn
79: AMST, Storer Broadcasting Co,, NAEB, and the Farm Bureau
urge, on the other hand, that all translators ( including those not station
owned) should be carried in order to provide an-incéntive for the estab-
lishment-of translators. ‘Translators, they claim, should be encouraged
because their service is received off the air free and covers a wider area
than cable service. They would exempt translators from the carriage
requirement where: (1) The CATV system is carrying the translator's
parent station, (2) the CATV system is within the grade B contour of
a station whose programing is substantially duplicated by the trans-
lator, or (3) the translator is supplying programing which substan-
tially duplicates that of another translator whose originating station is
closer. Nonduplication rotection is not sought for the asserted.
‘reason that translators do not provide a local service or posses$
potential for developing,into regular local stations.
80. We sharé the view that the public interest is served by encour-
aging expanded use of translators to bring television service to persons:
in rural areas and communities not.now receiving adequate local tele-
vision broadeéast service. - Apart from the fact that tithelator signals
are received free and reach persons outside the urbanized areas served
by CATVs, one of the major recommendations of the Seiden report
was that. incresdsed consideration. be’ given to: the expanded use of
translators. The report states-(p. 22) : é Xoo see ms
Consideration should be given to the use of translators as a tool of struc-
tural policy. They require a substantially smaller investment than CATV
and are compact, highly mobile, and can be sold in the secondary market.
In general they provide the flexibility necessary in an industry in which
structural policy must be kept free to adapt to technological and demo-
graphic change. Translators are ideally suited as a temporary communica-
tions medium, and their use should be required of broadcast licensees: in
fulfilling their obligations to the public by bringing their signal to all
-, homes in their coverage area. . .
The report,also recommends increased use of translators to broaden the
coverage of UHF stations (p. 90). er oe
81. We have already taken a step in this direction in the report and
order in docket No. 15858, issued on July 9, 1965, amending the rules to
permit 100-w VHF translggors on any channel listed in the Téble of
Assignments unoccupied by a regular television station or satellite.
The rules were also amended to permit 100-w UHF translators on all
unoccupied UHF channels in the Table of Assignments. in lieu of the
previous limitation to the upper 14 channels. In addition, we have
recently proposed to permit the use of microwave frequencies to relay
hy Pome to translators (notice of proposed rulemaking in docket
0. 16424, FCC 66-41).
82. In line with this-policy, we think that: CATV should,’. - © ;
upon request, carry the signals of commercial and education trans-
lators operating in the-community of the system with 100-w or higher
power, where the system has the dened capacity todoso. Since non-
_ carriage may efféctively block the translator from avcess to CATY sub-
’ . .scribers (par. 51 of the first report), the inability to reach the central
core of the community may well destroy the incentive to establish
' 2 FCC. 24
nen et wee out
1 Re
oar
b ame
a ° ;
34 % | Federal Communications Commission Reports,
translator service for nonsubscribers in the community and persons in
the surrounding areas. Moreover, we think that same-day nonduplica- .
tion should also be afforded to translators carried on the system.
Translators operating with 100 w or higher power are properly dis-
tinguishable i other translators since they have greater potential
for development into stations, and it is particularly important, that
such development not be impeded by CATV operations.
’ 83. Accordingly, we shall add a fourth priority ta the three already
listed in the carriage provisions of the rules. Fourth; all commercial
and noncommercial educational translator stations operating in the
community of the’ system with 100 w or higher power. As requested in
the comments, exceptions will be added to exempt CATVs from the |
translator carriage requirement where: (1) The CATV. system is”
carrying the originating station, or (2)-the CATV system is within
the grade B conteur of a station carried on the system whose program-
ing is substantially duplicated by the translator. The provisions of
the program exclusivity sections will also be appropriately amended
to require same-day nonduplication upon request of a translator sta-
tion carried on the System.
84. With respect to the second question, whether translators should
be required to refrain from duplicating: local stations, our present
‘policies and rules are as follows: Pending the outcome of this pro-
ceeding, we have been following a policy of conditioning UHF and
VHF translator grants with the requirement that the translator, upon’
request of any station within whose grade A contour the translator
-operates, refrain frorn duplicating the station’s programs .either
simultaneously or within 15 days. ((Lee Co. TV: Inc., FCC 65-483, 5
’ Pike & Fischer, R.R. 2d 257; AY; and Order in Docket No. 15858,
1
par. 12.) Under section 74.732(e)[1) of the rules, the only station-
owned VHF translators authorized outside the grade B contour of the
parent station are high-power (100-w) VHF translators operating ori
. assignments-in the Table of Assignments. Moreover, section 74.732
(e)(2) of the rules provides that a station-owned VHF translator
which is intended to provide recéption within the grade A contour of
another station will not be authorized if there is any duplication,
unless the translator is intended to improve reception within the
principal city contour of the parent station. However, we have waived —
the provisions of section 74:732(e) (1) and (2) where a nonduplication
condition was imposed. ‘
85. Our translator rules and policies are currently in a state of flux.
Part II of this proceeding (notice, pars. 61, 64) proposes a reexamina-
tion of all of our rules and policies relating to auxiliary services to see
if they are holding back or encouraging a variety of off-thé-air serv-
ices. A number of measures were proposed in the comments in docket
No. 14848, which were deemed beyond the scope of that proceeding but
may be pertinent to this reexamination. It was suggested that the
multiple ownership and duopoly rules be amended to allow potential
100-w translator operators to convert these to regular stations and
to encourage television station licensees to apply for them. Other
‘suggestions included proposals for intreased power for existing trans-
lators on other channels; removing the restriction in section 74.732
2 F.C.C. 2d > |
' Car >... 35
(e) (1) on the use of VHF translators by television station licensees
beyond their grade B contour; permitting translators to be used as
relay stations oy? where the need exists; permitting multiple RF -
amplifiers for UHF as well as VHF translators; and permitting UHF
stations to use VHF translators within their grade B contours. More-
' over, AMST has recently filed a petition for a comprehensive, affirma-
tive translator program which is aria considered as a counterproposal
in docket No. 14229, and will also be considered in our resolution of
basic translator policies in part II of this proceeding. _
‘86. We are not in a position to resolve these questions now. More-
over, we still lack sufficient information to determine the extent to.
which the rebroadcast consent provisions of section 325(a) may in
practice limit duplication by translators.** In addition, if translators
were required by rule to refrain from duplication within the grade B
contours of regular stations, a question would be presented as to
whether the “pintenees of section 74.732(e) (1) and (2) continue to
_ serve a useful purpose or should be amended. It would be contrary
to the public interest to delay’a resolution of other portions of part
of this proceeding pending a thorough reexamination of the translator
rules and policies. Nor does it appear adyisable to undertake a partial
revision of the translator rules at-this point merely in order to attempt
to equalize the position of translators and CATVs. In the circum-
See also 4
first report and order; National Broadcasting Co., 20 Pike & Fischer, R.R. 1013; Millers
River. Frencieters, ‘Inc., FCC 63-504, 25 R.R. 516, 518, affirmed in Springfield Television
Broadcasting Corp. v. F.C.C., 323 F. 2d 186 (C.A.
2 F.C.C. 2d
| eed nse tng
, .
36° + ‘Federal Communications Commission Reports
not urgently. needed, to the development ef such community type,
translagors. We shall, of course, consider whether additional require-
ments are appropriate, either upon request’ or on our own evaluation
of a particular situation, and {ll make all translator grants subject iy
tg the outcome of part IT of this proceeding. We will also take into ~ 3
account, where ‘warranted in individual situatfons, the possible dis- }
4 criminatory effect of our interim translator policy upon any existing e
| CATY system competing with the translator. xe "
| 4. Educational télevision stations | i
; 87. The rules adopted in dockets Nos. 14895 and 15233 require the -
"| , carriage of noncommercial educational stations (ETV), but do not
; require .CATYVs to refrain from duplicating their programs. We
. followed this course because those | psn: were primarily con- |
' cerned with commercial stations and many of the considerations dis-
cussed in the first report and-order did not appear to be applicable
to ETV. The notice herein recognized, however, that carriage alone
might not be sufficient to promote the sound growth of local educa-
tional stations. Information vas requested in this proceeding as to
the nature of any furfher* problems of ETV arising from CATV ..
operations and what Commission action might be appropriate.
88.. Other than educational interests, most of those commenting on
this subject were against extending any nonduplicatron protection
to ETV, for the asserted reason that the widest possible dissemination
of educational material is in the public interest. ‘It is further asserted
that CATV competition, has no.economic impact on ETV because it
operates on a nonprofit basis. National Educational Television
(NET),.the National Association of Educational Broadcasters, |
(NAEB); and Eastern Educational Network (EEN) take a sharply
different view in their more extensiye comments: They claim that
local educational stations, though different from commercial stations,
have an even greater need for nonduplication and interim protection
because CATV undermines the Jocal financial support and other local
interest which is vital to ETV operations. : In this,they are supported
by American Broadcasting Co., AMST, and labor unions re nting
employees in the broadcast, CATV, and associated talent mdustries.
89. EEN and NAEB stress the importance: of local financial sup-
port to edycational stations. le tp th Federal grants-in-aid under
SE ee ee» ea, ee eee
Public Law 87-477 are available fpr the construction of educational
- facilities, the operatioris of such stations are almost entirely dependent
upon local financial support. -Opérating income is derived primarily .
from (a) schools and universities, (6) local and State governments, |
and (¢c) contributions and “subscriptions” from the. general public
and «donations by local industries and businesses. Members of the
public and local businesses will lye little or no incentive to support.
the loca] station if ETV is made available on the cable by CATV’s
importation of outside educational stations. As EEN puts it (com-
_ ments, p. 12) ; “It is wholly unrealistic to expect that the public will
be willing to pay twice for educational service—to subscribe to CATV
and to goon > to local ETV.” Diversion of funds provided by
local and area educational institutions and local and State, govern-
ments for inschool television would be even more serious, since these
2 F.C.C. 2d 7
/
/
/
®
CATV->- — 37
sources generally provide over one-half of the financial support for
local educatigna! stations.* If a distant ETV signal is available on
_ the cable, and éan be fitted into local schedules of instruction, local
schools and local and State governments would be much more unlikely
to provide the financial support and other interest necessary to start
a local educational broadcast service. This would be particular! the
- case where the CATV offers to wire the urban schools “free.” Unlike
the local educational station, the CATV is in a position to make such ©
an offer because it does not pay for programs or maintain expensive -
facilities for local program origination and it can recoup the cost of
free school service through subscription fees charged to the general
cilities for delivering educational programs. They are an
part of the educational and cultural life of a community and area. -
. . This is particularly true where ETV is used for inschool instruction.
ETV must plan, prepare, and schedule educational progfaming on
the basis 4 individual school and community neéds, whether the
basic program material is produced by the station itself or outside
sources. The station also provides study guides for use by the teachers
in the schools.. CATV cannot effectively provide this carefully planned
and prepared service by indiscriminately importing signals from dis-
tant educational stations located in cities with different needs and
interests. ; 7 ; ;
91. Moreover, local educational stations serve not only the schools
and populations in the immediate community; they provide service
to the surrounding rural area not reached by CATV. NAEB points
out (comments, p. 2) : y :
Indeed/ it is the rural area with limited budgets, facilities, and puplip
«concentration which has the most pressing need for the teaching resources
of educational television. The specialized language, art, music, or science
teacher who cannot be supported by a rural school system can, nevertheless,
be, enjoyed through the pooled resources of educational television.
In this connection we note also comments filed by the American Farm
Bureau Federation, National Farmers Union, and National G
stating that rural residents, who often are relatively remote from the
entertainment attractions of the city, probably more than other groups -
of citizens in the country, rely ially on radio and television as a
major source of entertainment and informatjon.*
- 92. rem gn. the educational interests urge that ETV stations |
be granted nonduplication protection for a period either the same as
““The Financing of Educational Television Stations,” report of a study conducted by
Educational Television Stations, a divigion of the Natio Association of Educational
Broadcasters, p..19 (1965). ; as ,
“ Apart from ETV, it is stated that rural residents rely specially ‘on local broadcas
giving agricultural information, weather ¢onditions (flood, frost, etc.), pest hazards, an
current market conditions. . :
«
2 F.C.C. 2d
-- i ate
—_
38 Federal Communications Commission Reports =
or much longer than ¢hat accorded to commercial stations.** More-
over, both NAEB and\EEN urge the adoption of procedures to pro-
tect communities with jonal reservations which have not yet
been activated. NAEB requests that the CATV be required to notify
local and area school authorities and ETV. interests of its proposal
7 to bring in a distant ETV signal. In this way, NAEB'States, local
+ - ETV interests would be alerted and could bring the matter to the
‘ Commission’s attention for whatever action or conditidns_appeared
' warranted in.the circumstances. EEN urges the adoption of interim
4} procedlures similar to those proposed for CATV operations in major .
markets in paragraphs 49 and 50 of the notice. aa .
93. The considerations put forth by the ETV interests are nof |
answered by simply stating that the public interest is served by the
widest dissemination of educational material. If CATV ‘operations
should pre udice the establishment of new ETYV stations on the unused |
reserv goers or prevent existing stations from realizing their |
full potential, the result would be a narrowing of the distribution of
educational, material—a loss hitting hardest-persons residing in rural "
' . areas and those unable to afford CATV fees. Asin thecaseofcom- |
- mercial stations, CATV’s proper role is to supplement, rather than
ocal educational broadcast service. The national policy
_ of encoura the full-development and expansion of ET’ is vellscted .
‘| in the grants-jn-aid legislation -(Public Law 87-477) -and has long
' been a matter of deep concern to the Commission (sixth report and
_- order, pars. 33-49). It would be poaty inconsistent with. that
policy to accord educational ions less protection than commercial
- 1 stations if there is any real likelihood of prejudice cong from
‘ “. CATV importation of outside ETV signals. nsidering the con-
\ tinuous financial struggle of ETV and its dependence upon local finan-
cial support and interest, we think that the possibility of adverse
effect is sufficiently strong to warrant some special protection for ETV. |
4. 94. In view of our decision to adopt same-day rionduplication for
+ - commercial stations and since it is asserted that effective nonduplica-
+ tion protection for ETV would require a much longer period, we do
a not think it appropriate to — 15-day, before-and-after nondupli-
7 cation for ETV, as requested by NAEBand ABC. Thereis no agree- 7
4 ment among the educational interests as to what.time period would ,
be appropriate, and even an extensive nonduplication period would ‘°”
not solve the problem of achieving adequate operational funds “for
existing ETV stations. We believe that more effective reliefto ETV =“
can be provided by the approach discussed in the succeeding para-
graph, than by delayed nonduplidation periods such as 15 days before
and after. Therefore, while recognizing that some: measifre other
than nonduplication may be more suitable-for ETV, we shall amend -°
the exclusivity provisiore~include educational stations. The rules
will thus apply cog | to all stations in line with our conclusion
- (par. 54 above) that they should be-the same for all systems. We
will, of course, be alert to guard against the possibility that CATV
may pose a more acute problem for ETV than presently appears, and
© ~e-lje
- The longér “period is sought because of the block distribution process for the NET
_ seheduled service and distribution patterns of regional educational networks like EEN.
2 F.C.C. 2h. pee
Se ee een
to supplant,
o-*
3.
, .
* ‘
- CATV. » : 39
‘would not hesitate to amend the rules should this subsequently prove
necessary. ET’V interests have indicated their intention to keep us
apprised of any worserling developments and are encouraged to do so.
95. Perhaps the most troublesome problem raised by the ETV com-
' ments is the possibility that CATV, by bringing outside educational
signals into communities where educational assignments have not yet
been activated, will siphon off enough local support to preclude the -
establishment of an educational: station. The policy of reserving
channels for educational stations is in recognition of the fact that
some time may elapse before such stations came into being. While the
grants-in-aid legislation has speeded up the process in many —
the reservations still serve a needed purpose which should not
undercut. CATV. provides: a valuable service to.schools and other
subscribers by bringing in ETV which is not: yet locally available.
But this should not be at the expense of preventing a local Service
from ever being established., Accordingly, we shall adopt the sugges-
tion of NAEB that local and area ETV interests and school authorities
receive advance notice of CATV €or to bring in outside ETV
signals. The attached rules (app. D) require the CATV system to
give notice of its proposal to bring¢n a distant ETV signal, at least
30 days prior to commencing service, to the local superintendents of
sc is and to the area and State educational television agencies (if
any). This will enable ETV interests in the area to make objection °
to the CATV system wherg a local station is contemplated. ere
a local ET’ station is reasonably imminent and objection is made to
the Commission, we would not ordinarily approve im tion of the
distant ETV signal unless it has been re. ished after appropriate
proceedings that this would not prejudice the establishment or mainte-
nance of a local ETV service. ze '
96. And, finally, it is asserted by NET and N that, where an
educational signal is carried on a CATV on a channel partially used -
. for commercial signals, the placement of commercial announcements
—. to edueational material carried on CATV jeopardizes the
public imege of ETV and prejudices its position with program sup-
pliers and copyright owners who insist upon noncommercial presenta-
tion. However, we do not think that a sufficient basis has been shown
for the relief requested, i.e., prohibiting commercial announcements
_ adjacent to educational ‘programing or requiring CATVs to devote
channels exclusively to educattonal programing. We cannot under-
take to preserve-ETV or commercial stations harmless from all con-
ceivable prejudice no matter how slight. Moreover, we are reluctant
to interfere with CATV operations any more than necessary in the .
public interest or to impose requirements not shown to be essential.
_CATY systems with limited channel] capacity and those carrying a
large number of commercial signals might find it difficult to devote
channels yee | to ETV. CATVs may also wish to use &duca-
tional signals to fill.in portions of commercial signals which cannot
be carried because of the nonduplication requirements. Moreover,
« Spe nemies of educational TV applicants in UHF (where most of the unused educa-
tiona rvations are) has increa rom 5 at the beginning of 1962‘to 30 as of the end
of 1965; during this period 34 more UHF educational stations went on the air.,
2 F.C.C. 2d -
.
- ‘
EE ae ET Se eT
- 1. Ad hoe procedures
my ,
ees ee en ee fo saracebtibcr as De catiniaiiin det ah
_ carriage, nonduplication, and ET
40 Federal Communications Comanission Reports
since educational stations normally do not have as long a broadcast
day as commercial stations, the CATV system may, wish to provide
its subscribers with other material during the time that the educational
station is not broadcasting. In view of the station identification an-
nouncements made during the course of the educational programing,
it seems to us that the prejudice.to the originating ETV station, if any,
’ would be minimal. ” . -*.
; ‘ D. Procedural Matters :
97. It has been suggested in the comments that the Commission. .
should ‘adopt specific rules providing for summary, nonhearing proce-
dures to handle requests for waiver of the CATY rules or for different
treatment, or affirmative relief. We think the suggestion has merit. - :
The general provision for waiver of any rule (sec. 1.3 of the rules)’ .
does not afford‘an adequate procedure for seeking additional affirma- ,
tive relief or different treatment. Moreover, such procedures would
. be useful to handle requests for rulings on complaintsor disputes. We
recognize that to hold hearings upon each such request releting to
v. would be time consuming. and
burdensome to the CATV systems and stations involv. i
those in smaller communities. In addition, whilesuch procedures
will not apply to the matter of distant s hearind e top 100 markets,
for which a showing made in evidentiary hearjng is required (see par.
141 below), they could be utilized in many instances‘ resolve distant-
signal questions in the smaller markets.
98. Accordingly, we have undertaken in section 74.1109 of the .
‘attached rules to devise flexible and fair procedures which will gen-
_ erally permit expeditious processing of such requests: The procedures
- require a written petition with notice to interested :persons and afford
‘an opportunity for submission of comments or opposition to any re- |
quest and for reply.. Upon good cause shown, the Commission may
shorten the times specified in the rules for the filing of opposition
or reply comments. The petition and all other ee by the.
etailed full showing, .
supported by affidavit, of any facts or considerations relied upon.’
petitioner or interested persons must contain a
In the case of complaints or’ disputes, the steps taken by the: parties
to‘resolve their problem must also be set forth. The Commission will,
where possible, promptly dispose: of the matter on the basis of such.
‘ written submissions. However, additional - procedures; such ‘as oral.
argument, evidentiary hearing, or further written submissions di-
' rected to particular aspects, may be: specified‘by the Commission if
- they appear necessary or appropriate after consideration of the
leadings.** In the event that the petition involves new service. to
ATV subscribers, the Commission will expeditiously rule on the
matter, either in whole or to the extent of determining whether there .
“@ Since ‘petitions under the ad hoe cedures may involve the resolutfon of controversial
* {Issues which in basic fairness should determined on the pleadings of the parties, we shall
amend the exgparte rules to make them applicable to 0 under sec. 74.1109, as well
as to ~~~ $s under sec. 74.1107. The oe discus in par. 9 of the report and
order in docket No: 15381, FCC 65-598, 1 F-C:C. 2d 49, will also apply. : ‘
2 F.C.C. 2d
.
.
4
re
aR whe a“
, particularly ~
ae
_o&
i CATV * : 41
should be a stay or other temporary relief pending such additional _
procedures as may uired (see par. 100 below). ’ :
9. Inforniation to be filed with the Commission by existing CATV
systems; notification by new CATV operations
- 99. Pursuant to our authority under section 403 of the Communi-
. eations Act, alkexisting CATV operators will be required tq, submit —
to the Commission, within 30 days after the effective date of our order
herein, the following information with respect to each of their CATV
systems: (a) The names, addresses, and business interests of all officers,
directors,.and persons having substantial legal or beneficial oe
_interests in each system; ‘*® (b) the number of subscribers to eac
“system both currently and as of February 15, 1966; (c) the television
stations carried on each system; and (d) the extent of any art
or proposed program origination by each CATV system. Any CAT
system whisk is located within the predicted grade A contour of a/
television station in the top 100 television markets (as ranked by
‘ARB on the basis of net weekly circulation of the largest station
in the market) and which carries the signal of a distant station(s),
will also be required to submit a map —— the location of its cable
lines being used to serve subscribers on February 15, 1966.5° It is. -
not practicable to apply the notification provisions set forth below
to the present operations of existing systems, and there is no compre-
. hengive or accurate listing of CATV systems available to apprise
television station licensees or ‘permittees of all existing CATV opera-
tions within their grade B contours. Indeed, we have noted that while
the recent growth of CATV is of an impressive nature, there are con-
flicting estimates as to the. precise dimensions of that very substantial
growth. The information obtained will assist the Congress in its con-
sideration of the Commission’s legislative proposals in the CATV
field, *nd the Commission in its consideration of matters in part IT
. of the notice and petitions described in paragraph 149 below.
100. New CATV systems will be required to notify the licensee or
permittee of any television broadcast station within whose predicted
grade B contour the system will operate and the licensee or permittee
of any 100-w of higher power translator located in the community
_ of the system, with a copy to the Commission, concerning the proposed
operation within 60 days after obtaining a, franchise or eritering into’
a lease or other arrangement to use facilities. In no event may new
service be commenced until 30 days after notice has been given. The
notice shall include the name and address of the system, identification
of the community to be served, the television stations to be distributed, .
and the estimated. time for the commencement of operations. Similar
notification will be-required by éxisting systems which propose to add
new distant signals (at least 30 days prior to commencing service) or
to extend lines into obviously new geographic areas (within 60 days
after obtaining a franchise or entering into a lease or other arrange-
- In stating the ownership interests in a corporation which has more than ting
stockholders, only those stockholders need be considered who are officers or Ph or’ who
directly or indirectly own 1 percent or more of the outstanding vo stock.
© Existing systems in the markets below 100 may subsequently be uired to submit a
mp showing the location of lines as of a specific date ip connection with any petition for
ad hoc consideration of a geographic extension into new areas.
: ' 2 F.C.C. 24
*
4
-revised bgrein) in their present form for a while longer, until CATVs |
i ao 2 . nae
42 - Federal Communications Commission Reports ©
ment to use facilities or at least 30 days pridr to commencing service
where no new local-authorization or contractual arrangement is re-
quired). In addition, as alrea@y indicated, notice to loeal and area
educational authorities and ETV interests will be required at least
30 days prior te commencing service where carriage of a distant ETV
signal is proposed. ch notification will afford the local television
stations and otlier interested persons an opportunity to request carriage
and nonduplication under the rules or to petition-the Commission for
different requirements before service is commenced and thus avoid -
disruption to the public. Where a petition for. ad hoc consideration
is filed with the Commission by any station, CATV system, or other
interested person within 30 days after notice, new systems and exist-
ing systems proposing to add new distant signals shall not commence _ :
new service until after the Commission’s ruling on the petition or on +
the interlocutory question of temporary. relief” pending further pro- }
cedures." In the event that an evidentiary hearing is requiredythe ~
question of whether there should be a stay or other temporary relief ,
pending the. hearing will be expeditiously resolved prior. to the
earing on the basis of the pleadings of the parties and such. addi- i
tional written submissions as the Commission may request.
3. Form and enforcement of the new rules : Yi we |
101. Aside from the obvious distinction that nonmicrowave CATVs :
do not file applications for licenses. with the Commission or use licensed
facilities, no special problems of substance or procedure in making the - —
carriage“and nonduplication requirements applicable to them have oe
‘been called to our 4ttention and none is apparent to us. While the - 2
substantive requirements will therefore be the same for all systems, +
some differences in form or procedure are necessary in the case of the
nonmicrowave CATVs. First,.the obligations will be imposed directly
on the CATV system itself, rather than takiiig the form of conditions
_ on microwave authorizations. Second, enforcenient will be through °
the cease and desist procedures set forth in. section 312 (b) and (c),”
or pursuant to section 502, of the act and will not include other sanc-
tions applicable to licensees. And, third, some change is required in the
provisions requiring notification to all licensees or permittees of tele-
-vision stations placing a grade B or better signal over the community
of the CATV system that a microwave application has been filed ora
request has been made of a common carrier for microwave service.
(See sec. 2 above.) | ito ; |
4. Retention of the microwave rules. 5 : 9
102. It is urged by American Telephone & Telegraph Co. ang. by
U.S. Independent Telephone Association (both in comments in docket
No. 15971 and in its petition for reconsideration of dockets Nos 14895
‘and 15233) that the. rules governing microwave grants should be .
deleted when the obligations are-imposed on CATV systems directly.
We think it best to retain the rules conditioning microwave grants (as
= The matter of extension of lines into new geographical areas by existing systems in
top 100 markets is discussed in par. 149 below. As already in cated, the ad hoc proce-
dures do ‘not apply tounew service involving distant signals in the top 100 markets or
obviate the need for evidentiary hearing as set forth in pars. 141-143 below. @
2 F.C.C. 2d
‘
“% ° 7
CATV ons 43 -
generally are operating in accordance with the new rules. Pending
such compliance, we cannot make the requisite public interest finding
for the issuance of the microwave licensee in the absence of a showing
that the facilities will be used in accordance with- the ‘conditions.
Moreover, the uests of A.T. & ‘T. and USITA are ’primarily
grounded in the alleged burden-to the common«cairiers, which will be
substantially alleviated in this interim period by the revisions made in
the memorandum opinion and order on reconsideration.in dockets Nos.’ -
14895 and 15233, 1 F.C.C. 2d 524. However, once widespread CATV
compliance with the new rules has been achieved, some modification,
. of the microwave rules would clearly appear to be appropriate and we
shall take action toward this end ‘as soon as it is possible to do so.
5. Transition period ;
103. In the first report and order {par. 161) and in-the notice (par.
34}, we stated that we would consider in this proceeding the question
of whether there should be some kind of transition period before the
carriage provisions are made fully applicable to microwave and non-
microwave systems with limited channel capacity. Qo obtain relevant
information, the Commission mailed;a auestionnai¥e to every known
CATV operator. The questions were designed to elicit specific infor-
mation with respect to the effective channel capacity of each system,
the local television signals which might fall within the carriage pro- -
visions of the rules, and the number of channels in use for nonlocal
television signals or other purposes. ‘Responses were received from
1031 CATVs, of which 250 were. microwave-served and 781 were
nonmicrowave. , .
v
104. Upon analysis of the responses, it appeared that less than 20 -
percent of the microwave systems were’ not in comphance with the
carriage provisions, and half of these either had the unused ¢hanrfél_
capacity to come into compliance, or, in view,of plans to expand the
system, would shortly be able to comply. Less than 10 percent of the
microwave systems could not comply with the rules without having to
drop one or more signals currently carried. Accordingly, the Commis-
sion, on December 8, 1965, determined that there was no need to afford
microwave-served systems a ‘general delay in the application of the - °
’ rules relatin
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.