Brief for the Petitioners — Utah Pie Co. v. Continental Baking Co.
Supreme Court brief1967
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
a Pets b Retayey contract was entioimpetitive .
ms
Ree ee 4 wae
: Subject Index Se
Opinion: below .........00.ccencececeece secs iS Vis es St 1:
Quiestionie ‘presented ....<i.s2n..cc0sSegerseapecescee ses aee
_ A. Questions presented by ‘hie petition PASE ere <p er 20
ce Questions assigned by the court ... cicnnae ve eG ue a ee ie
\ Statutes involved ce ee i eich Cini ink pike eyekieod 6
* Statement pays pas SRO ENO SON TE dioceses ss 7
1. The product involved is frozen fruit pies Sorry sop .
2. Petitioner was a small family sila i with long
oe experience in the pie business’. . > mks gbie Casha ees be 10
3. Utah Pie marketed frozen pies in nine western states . Brug
_ 4. There was evidence that advertising allowances are as
price cuts a6 homdbhas er Pp yeeeetees 6 iadrs aha et ne
5. Respondents were all aches conglomerate ‘corpora- oe
"i tiqns with vast financial resources i vis pV ays seeeneee 15”
& 6. Utah Pie's case against Pet 0.0... 000seeeeseee, beep ¢
a. Pet's price discriminations tis A Siok oe
(i) Overall discriminations shown. by annual | aver- ;
; age prices cee atogeeccateceowesesens je eeeee eq: %B..
| ii), Pet-Ritz/Bel Air discriminations feces a
. - (iii) Pet Ritz/Pet Ritz discriminations Seeks pes 24 5
° + (iv) Swiss Miss/Swiss Miss discriminations ...:... 27
b. There was evidence of Pet’s ‘predatory tactics in its— ‘
sng ener ten cn QT
(i) . “Investment spending” .........-. eevee Soe. 27
(ii) Industrial espionage ..............0.0.02000 28
(iii) The Swiss Miss fighting brand... cen nies ee as +s; Sl
(iv) Discriminafions themselves ‘as evidence of intent 32 ©
$2 >
2
° - . AF : Se e ‘Page |
x2 a, 1. Pettine's cae against Céraiin pengseveRecceseer OO!
a. Carnation’s price discriminations me eye poeeee BF
. Carnation’s sales, in all. markets er Seeeeaes sigeicnd 40
_ @ Carnation’s sales were at a loss’ planned in advance 41
-. 8. Petitioner’s ease against Continental ..:........:...%% 44 :
5, tee Continental's Mortis ON eo act Seren,
Ce. « Ccatiisaital sntee in’ significant and sustained
me price discrimination in plaintiff’s trading area .... © 48
d. The evidence showed that Continental intended to
injure plaintiff, ;.............seeeeeeeees ehaniees 52
9. The evidence showed: that: respondents’ price discrim-.
inations had.an injurious impact upon Utah Pie ..... 54
_@ The evidence showed. that petitioner’s ‘prices were
2 driven down .......-. Fesecescccsesowessceceeees OD
. The evidence showed that petitioner’ market —
declined ......... Mey eutorencsaee e4pentesns sts 6x Ede
ce. .The jury verdicts ¥ were well within the evidence . 57
Summary of argument ........ aeteeees Sweundessouneesscs 59 |
‘Argument ckvisp an Goavenvisdes Weeseccvccseces sida aie .. 66
‘£ ‘Redpondents’ conduct vewid, an “incipient” threat ae
competition under Clayton Act standards ,........:.. 66.
_& Sections 2,°3, and 7 of the-Clayton Act embody the es
I NE a hasan ces cdioranedastensdcdeqeeedss * 66
‘‘. Sections 2, 3, and 7 of the Clayton Act all deal with :
the misuse of market power to foster monopoly .... ‘67 :
1S @ Ti ange conglomerate enterpre i » thret to com
* petition without More ..:...6..eeeeeeececseeeeees «69
d. Discriminatory pricing by- haden Siihiadaill enter-
coe threatens nate etepcccevcewecenesens 71
Gy Maryand Baling Gon =. aéeense peaie’ 74
~
Sa
3 Svasuoe Enver .
a7 ay
Clayton Act principles i in reversing the jury in this case
i Page
3. The Court of Appeals has ignored ali ofthe controlling
17.
a. The Court of Appeals ignored high and apparently
growing concentratidhi in this industry ............
b. The: Court of Appeals apparently considered each
“respondent’s ie Seen te ears bel
- oceurred in a vacuum Ps Oe TT Tee ee ee
i Discriminatory price cuts by a major competitor ‘ih-
jure a.competitor ‘by depressing market prices as’
well as by diverting business ....................
4, All respondents engaged in substantial price —
ON 2 ink voiens Vad hs oh Ck pk s ob bad Clik Picea sk
a. The Court of Appeals Lesree both the facts and the :
applicable law in assessing the -extent ot respond.
ents’ price discriminations Pee PETAL Ste.
b. Respondents’ quantity discounts were not justified. ;
. Pet’s: private-label discriminations were substantial,
sustained, -and posed a serious threat, to competition
‘d. Respondents discriminate without satutory —
, tion at their peril .........%55 oteseccecgsccceces =
5. Evidence of intent to destroy a competitor deoearis a
jury finding of an incipient threat to competition | apaee
| a. Discriminatory low prices charged by respondents at
places distant from their plants are evidence of
| “predatory PN wa pve cenk shh eccicocke pines chic. ie
b. Sales’ at a loss are a classic peediiely practice, in-
tentionally engaged ‘in by all respondents .........
ce. Utah Pie was the principal target of Pet’s and
Continental’s ‘discriminations as shown by direct
evidence .......... EM badhie S 66s back eos hace sacs ee:
(i) Continental's discriminatory prices were admit-
edly aimed directly’at Utah Pie ......:..... 101
(ii) Pet's discriminatory ‘prices were aimed at Utah -
(iii) Industrial espionage is a common concomitant
of monopoly and evidence af predatory intent 108 -
?
-
Pe eae ee an eee
sn
at - Page
iv) Pet employed the Swiss Miss as a “fighting
' brand” in Utah Pie’s trading area .......... 105. =
6. The Court’ of Appeals invaded the jury’s province by -
accepting: and relying upon controverted evidence and
inferences unfavorable to Utah Pie ..... rind bs aie cas 106
- The tables appended to the Court of Appeals’ opin-
ion confliet with other evidence and inferences in the
he Cesk af Aueiale lon Sele’ to wake ony. dle.
tinction between wholesale and retail market areas
FOF PICT 0. we ceeescrcasescccesccesececssecumess 11
. The Court of Appeals accepted Pet’s controverted .
evidence ‘ on the Safeway contract ...... ste eennnee 112
The jury was not required, as a matter of law, to
accept Pet’s cost justification for the discriminatory
Bel Air price .......-sccccsescsccccccscoscececs 115
‘The Court of Appeals ignored the evidence of the
~ adverse impact of respondents’ -price discriminations
‘ on the goodwill of the Utah Pie Co. eheduhacs fee 119
‘The Court of Appeals: placed undue emphasis on
post-complaint ' evidence hsucas ‘eauesevtias seceeans . ae
ie lie oe iaiicld crite Gaston ood. on
abuse of discretion . <phbben.besensebeetndvercveccs$ ce 121
D. Sasee as Wines escgion te ead haues de 122
UE IN 5 icc oo a oe ck vnhabacnniienwoese 121
¢. If this court affirms the judgment and order of the
®
Court of Appeals directing the District Court to
enter judgment for respondents, may Utah Pie then
make a motion for a new trial under Rule 50(c) of
‘the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure within 10 days:
. Gf. the: District Court's entry of judgment for re-
spondents? ..........66: So ccerccecvesccoscescese 128
d. If under the order of the Court of Appeals, peti-
tioner cannot make-a motion for new trial under
” Bule 50(c) (2) ‘within 10 days of the District Court's
4
7 an toe ks rate cing Nyce 8. pr é
- Weade v. Dichman, Wright & Pugh, 337 U.S. 8019... 130 _
e. Does Rule 50(d) of the Federal Rulée of Civil Pro
cedure provide the Court of Appeals with any
authority to direct: the entry of judgment for re-
—spondents? ..............66. PPP bis: SO EEES ROG es 137
8. Utah Pie should have judgment for cost, including a
reasonable attorney’s fee Peete eeeeeeeseeeeeeesenens
Comelesiem iis vice cciccces’s te beeees Te eeeeee eee eeeeeeeees
. _
“Table of Authorities Cited: ~
ry
tet ate tent
Cases. Pages
| Alles Corp. v. Setieo Products, Ine, $29 F.2d 567 (6th Cir. |
1 I Bh is g he i SEN KAUR SB GSN hs 68 nk bis on ve 95
American Can Co, Ladoge Canning Co, 44 F-26 768 (7th
Cle BO Se Fk as cb ite See ind see Sue ys » 141 .
American eis Co. v. United States, 147 P 2d 93° (6th
. Gir, 1944), affirmed 328 U.S. 781, 66 S.Ct. 1125. ....76, 83, 104
American Tobacco Co. v. ‘United States, . 221 US. 106, 31 :
J MME IR lg iesl ak - tai uc haa co hicsehans bce catasi 68, 81,-97
_ Anderson v. Shipowners Association, 31 F. 2d head (9th Cir,
SEN. oo day Cad eet wtss PERG OL DGceNs op ap b cup ceescesss 121
Atlantic & Gulf Stevedores, Inc. v- ee 369 US. 855, ee
"Se TED LADUE) rckck ised etevvevecccsdccceBige sds 139 ©
Atlas Scraper & Eng’r. Co. v. Pursche, 357 F.2d 296 (9th
es Se eK vnc wap dsbalietn ins ri np cn seen nignncee 128
Automatic Canteen Co. v. FTC, 346 U.S, 61, 8 S.Ct. 1017 116
Balian Tee Cream Go. v. Arden Farms Co, 231 F.2d 356 -
(1955), cert. denied 350 U.S. '991.......5.......00ee0e- - 95
‘> Ben Hur Coal Co. v. Wells, 242 F.2d 481 (10th Cir. 1957), ‘are
ene, Dee BIE OE OIG ic nck ncvcge Sccdecccsiccecin 95
Bigelow v. RKO Radio Pictures, 327 U.S. 251, 66 S.Ct. 574 119
Broadcast Music Co. -v. Havana Madrid Restsurant, Corp.,
175 F.2d 77 (2d Cir.: 1949) ..... TeSGnawevcrthtuserisss 107 -
Brown Shoe Co. v. United States, 370 US. 294, 82 S.Ct.
Se ik Geka eds vadoviswiess wwice 59, 66, 68, 95
Byrd v. Blue Ridge Rural Elec. Co-op, Inc., 356. U.S. 525,
78 S.Ct. 893 (1958) ..... 2. eeeeeeee nesses eeeneee 65, 134, 139
Cone v. ‘West Vinginia Pulp & Pape Co., 330 U.S. 212..
Sika RAMOS ate CECE TR oC CME 600 6 6 bbb 02% 5, 6, 65, 130, 140
Continental Ore Co. ‘v. Union Carbide & Carbon Corp., 370
U.S. 690, 82 S.Ct. 1404... 4..... ccc eeeseteceecees 64, 105, 108
Corn Products Refining :Co,v. Federal Trade Commission, ~
324 U.S. 726, 65 S.Ct. 961... en ROP ORE Oe 72, 88, 96,97
E. B. ‘Muller & Co. v. FTC, 142 F.2d 511 (6th Cir. 1944).. 9%
E. Edelmann & Co., v. ederal Trade Commission, 239 F.2d iar
152 (7th Cir. 1957), cert. denied 355:U.S. 941, 78 S.Ct.
Taz or Avrmonrries Crrep | hee
s
SRA 5) tDa Sigh had “ear alia .. 108
Empire Rayon Yarn Co., Ine. ‘v. American Viscose pated
354 F.2d. 182 (2d Cir. 1965), overruled 1966 Trade Cases
Para. 71,841; petition for cert. filed, 85 . USL, Week,
SB ee yc MELEE LTT ee “88
Fleniken v. Groat Aeron Indemnity Co, Mo Pa w08
ag Cir. — os e0e be egeg¥ideld pbc ve dct Leeds 128
cosev deb Wieecvn wen bbe te ikied tudeabiile +60, 6, 68,76, 83, 95
FTC ¥. Borden Co, ‘on Gn a ek tne sosidh ee
FTC v. Cement. Institute; 333 US. 683, 68 S.Ct. 798... .87, 6%
- FTC v. Consolidated. Foods Corp., 380 U.S. 594, 85 S.Ct. a ae
FTC v. Morton Salt Co.; 334 U.S. 37, 68 S.Ct. 822 need :..72,89 . «
FTC v. Simplicity Pattern Co., Inc., 360 US. 55, 79 S.Ct.
BOOP © se sess cueeeewieesccchssbooneteir here 88
Garman v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co.,, 175 F.2d 24 (aa.
Oe BOE ak 565 href onn.g'o4 90h e558 vii 132
. Gerber Products Co. v. Beech-Nut Life Savers, 160 F. rae
SUB GEDICY, TBS Ee A re aa . 88
Giant Food, Inc. v. FTC, 307 F.2d 184 Os. Cir. 1962),
@@rt. Gohphed- SIZ TS. O90. oo occ cs cnceincn ss cane a's soo. BB
Glasser v. United States, 315 U.S. 60, .62 8.0t. Mos cscs 107
Globe Liquor Co. v. San Roman, 332 US. 571, 68 S.Ct. 246
ppECEN She Sete dsob is eeubaNcOS ies boat tcbctcle se 6, 65, 130
| Gunning v. Codlay; 281 U.S. 90, 50:S.Ct. 281............,. 108
_ Guyott Co. v. Texaco, Inc. _. F.Supp. — (D. Conn.
. (1966) 1966 Trade Cases. Para. 71,835... . $id bd Pacle’ s 0% 88
H. J. Heinz Co. v. Beech-Nut Life Savers, Ine, 1 181 F. Supp.
452 (S.D.N.Y. 1960) ...... iar bib.te dideabcs Shin wack) aaika uae 73
Hartley & Parker, Inc. v. Florida wevernas Corp, 307 F >
916 (5th Cir. BOUR) s gns. bs diinst tie pineactiddddaedads. - 86°
' International Business Machines Os. v. United’ States, .
‘ - 298 U.S. 181, 56 S.Ct: 701:....... bE Feet cs SRE 68
—Tmtaraatioal, Salt Co. v. Unie, State, 02° U8. 02, 68 By
S.Ct. adh hashes ceeceeeeeeess ge ewecds Sees evees vee s 60, 68
viii Be ee of
§ eee Pages
Johnson v. N.Y.; N.H. & H. R.R. Co., wie 73 S.Ct.
' RD SOO) i heb oo iC A OWA 6 oo ei tle isin bc bb bcc clk chose’ 128
. Joseph E. Seagram & Sons, Ine v. Heseter, 962 US. om, :
is “FTC, __ Fea (5th Cir. varades 1966 Trade , ‘ -
> Open Pat BIG 5h eicesulacidccecceinedobececes 94
Lavender v. Kuin, 327 U.S. 645, 66 S.Ct. 740 sig deste det i 107
Lessig v. Tidewater Oil Co., 327 F.2d 459 (9th Cir. 1964), .
cert. denied 377 U.S. 993..... By a aiplak «butt SPIN Mei sbade. 95
Lioyd’s of London\v. Cordova Airlines, Ine., 283 F.2d, 659.
(9th Cir. 1960) :......... DL sah a Mivid 6. Beale uhins SAGO @ 182
Lorain’ Journal v. United States, 342 U.S. 143, 72 8.Ct..181 95 °
Maryland Baking Co. v. FTC, 243 F.2d 716 (1957) SEE Pee 74,75
‘ Moore v. Mead Service Co., 190 F.2d 540 (10th Cir. 1951) 94
Moore v. Mead’s Fine Bread Co,, 348 US. 115, 75 8.Ct.148 —
Nashville Milk Co. v. Carnation Co, 355 U.S. 373, 18 8.Ct. ‘
962 (1958). °.:..-... ‘Ticpie nd laa ern aia ba ee 133
NLRB v, Dinion Coil Co., 201 F.2d.484 (2d Cir. 1952) .. . 107
National Dairy Products Corp. v. United States, 350 F.2d.
$21 (8th Cir. 1965), vacated, remanded on other prounide, pies
: F cinay OR, CA IDNR. ccs aun anion bikae k's ae 100
- anes S HRM Gn v. Komen, 964 US. 41, ‘
Palmer v. Hoffman, 318 US. 109, 63 S.Ct. Dees 118°
4 ‘Byte, 368 US.. 464, 82
Se SET eae eg a +» 62, 107, 139
Quack Ting v. United San, US. 417, 11 S.Ct. 733... 107
Quinby v. Morrow; 340 F.2d 584’ (2d Cir. 1965).......... 132
“RB. Macy & Co. v--FTO, 306 F.2a 445 (2a Gir, 1964)... 64, 86
Samuel Goldwyn ¥. Twentieth Century Fox, 828 F.2d 190, ed
141
i 1 A MC CAROAS SAGs. ond Ckubntied G6 99 708s ob\pedwineticts }
Samuel H. Moss, Inc..v. FTC, "yas F.2d 378 (24 Cir. 1945),
cert, denied 326 U8. 784, 66 8.Ct. 44:..........0.04. - 78,81
ie
~~ 7
»
‘Tanta ov Avrnonrmms Orren sped: ix «
psn stacy Mal Gis Op 821 US, 62, 64
S.Ct. 724 ¢ (1944) son snahsmuenbinas ions ouiais dB ORGLF AML Seed
19651, ict, denied 206, U8. 114. ‘icpnhetad Sh the iad atest 88
ie Ot ai i 1, 51.
Tri-Valley Packing Ass’n v. FTC, 329 F.2d 694 (9th Cir.
4968): cscecc doacdcs sudedavaies duendeu cM peSbaii 86
: “Union. Leader Corp. v. sg of ‘New England, Ine,
180 F.Supp: BOP + onsparcbessse eect eves een ince: ‘120
-.,. United ‘States v. American. Tobaeeo Co., 221 US. 106, 31. .
A I os 5 seh AS Hi cpt Obes RedRkk. CoG 68, 81,97 .
United States v. Borden Co, 370 U.S. 460, 82 S.Ct. 1309
= SsAe eons sdnihs nnn enewepibelt ino, te ve ses + 89, 116, 117,
“United States v. Continental Can Co, 378 US. 441, 84 S.Ct.
IED voccccccetepoonpespenepbecienen ca Ts ,64, 120
United States v."du Pont & Co., 351 U.S. 377,76 S.Ct. 994 ..77
United States. v. General Electric Co., 82 F.Supp. 788 (D.:
p, ND. IMB): Soe cies deed ccalivecsssbee sie 108
United ‘States v. General Motérs, 384 U.S* 137, 86 S.Ct. 1321 104
United States v. Griffith, 334 U.S. 100, 68 S.Ct: 941.....:.76,77.
United States v. Grinnell Corp., 384 U.S. 563, 86 S.Ct. 1698 77
United States v. Pabst Brewing Co., 384 U‘S. 546, adie
"| MOREE paves been theessisjansaeneesdideiccc lo 60, 68,80 |
United States v. Paramount Pictures, Inc., 334 U.S. 131, 68 |
WH OIE vive iccsecctikeieignt "16
| United States v. Parke, Davis, & Co,, 362 U.S. 29, 808.0.
SE OM IER kT ccrtalada ie on sn - 120
- United States v. Penn-Olin Cheinical Oo,, 378 US. 158, 84 |
BOE TI oo osseous ecuasevsbeds eatesa, obs evans .78, 79
~
+s
dl fs ‘ : . . ? %
a 8 me
eri meisks Hause
x : - “TABLE OF Avrsorrries Crrep
United States v. Philadeiphia National Bank, 374 U. S, (823,
PL EEE nts cngnetna acdacedeadse an sebedasumek « 66
United States v. Von’s Grocery Co, "384 US. 270, 868.64.
“IBS TBs Daina kaiaihohun nd sisbwacs 4ceiean ae
Volaseo Products Co. v. Lloyd A. Fry Roofiig Co, 346 F.2d
' 661 (6th Cir. 1965), cert. denied. 382 U.S. Wvcirincese: TB
Walker Process Equipment, Inc. V. ‘Food inery and |
_~ Chemical Corp., 382 U.S. 172, 86 S.Ct. 347...3%5........ 68 .
~ . "Weade y. Dichman, Wright & Pugh, 337 U.S. 801, 69 S.Ct. :
"4396 (1949) untae kbetiueheascdewhes 6, 65, 130, 133; 135, 139
_ White Motor Co. v. United a 372 U.S. 253, 83 S.Ct. :
696 (1988) NaRed Gosh ba Ses VERS ebab kb eeResbbSe shucks 139
Yorkshire Indemnity Co. v. Roosth & Genecov Prod. Co,
a2 F.2d 650 saat Cir. 1958)... 2662.5 edeneeeeecescuax 182
. United States Constitution, Amendment VII ..,........,..6, 110
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure: ae Gin ile
Bulle GO (S08 WS. GB CAGES) ) onc ce ccccccvcccceeses5%-6
Rule 50 (as amended January 21, 1963, effective July
1, 1963, 374 U.S. 885, 83 S.Ct. 27).: bieakideaabnes we 5,
6, 9, 30, 65, 121, 127, 128, 129, 130, 181, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140
RM hc eA lice peeuats cakes yscosesnavniens th
Rule 60(b) .......... Giukanskawe viens sauNen hacen 139
Supreme. Court Rule
WAND OE is ie ich Heaaadss iSew cient 141
ree Soriss!
Section 2 38 Stat. 730, §2 (1914), as -amended by
Robinson-Patman Act, 49° Stat. 1526, §1° (1936),. 15
gc EMRE RARE Rr ae Rem
picckusaeubs 4, 6,7, 59, 61, 66, 67, 68, 73, 86, 88, 89, 98, 95, 125
_
a= a.
a Bi 4 — a 3 Pn Aw Pages
Section 3, 38 Stat. 731, §3 (1914), 15 U.S.C. §14_—Ct«;
GUNS Ss evacacscatice ds cnbdnnneuronent 6, 59, 66, 67, 68
“Section 4, 38 Stat. -731, §4 (1914), 15 USC. §15
Mk | 1 RRR Ps eS HS soe 6,141
Section 7, 38 Stat. 731, §7 (1914), amended by 64°. -
_ “Stat. 1125 (1950), as amended, 15 U.S.C. §18 (1964)
palate Wihetebide nknep Diga is bbuth onal 6, 59, 66, 67, 80
Section 16, 38 Stat. 737, §13 (1914), 15 U.S.C: §26 |
. (1964) Coe reece nee eeeececccccceeces reteeeseeees © 6S
Sherman Act, Section 1 .........6....cccccccceccscsecee 7
28 U.S.C. Section 1254(1) \.........cscccececccceee. ee |
28 U.S.C. Section 2106'.......... PE ee wenistecice, 20
Kaplan, Amendments of the Federal Rules of Civil Pro--
cedure, 1961-1963 (II), 77 Harv. L. Rev. 801, 818-820
aplication ck gud Miektanewassaiuiececdocs - 186°
‘Robinson, Joan, Economics of Imperf Competition, 179
(London, 1984) ......... Pee eee eee cecedeceecenes Sore 96
28 U.S.C.A. Rule 50: pocket part (1965) p. 185 ........... 138
Atty. Gen. Nat'l Comm. Antitrust Rep. 178 ........ ‘ess OM
Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monop-
‘oly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 88th Cong.,
2d Sess.,. Economic Concentration: Part I, Overall and
~ Conglomerate Aspects ................... shaggdghiiurs 69, 71
Iu the Supreme Court
| ai “or THE sel As ae
| ‘uited States
‘Ooronsn ns, 1966 .
oo y ‘ . No. 18 --
Uran Pre Company, pee Fonts cr2
"Petitioner,
| Cowrmmnral Baxine Company, Carnation
Company, and Pet Mix Company, Ee
Bre es seme ey
_ On Writ of Certiorar fo the United States Coort of Appels
ee for the Tenth’ Cirouit .
[BRIEF FOR THE PETTTIONER il
Spee
OPINION BELOW Fee
The opinion of the Court of Appeals: ( (1451) is re-
ported at 349 F.2d 122 and CCH 1965 Trade Cases aig
e.
2a if ie
“2 ee a
JURISDICTION
The dads. of the: Court of Appeals was entered on
May 25, 1965 (B.: 1526). The petition was filed on August
23, 1965, and was granted November 15, 1965 (R. 1527).
_ The ducindiotinn . this Court rests-on 28 U.S.C. aie
4 RE 8
‘
, : > QUESTIONS. P !
A Questions Presented by the — |
The Court of Appeals reversed. judgments entered on -
jury. verdicts i in favor of petitioners because it found no
evidence’ sufficient to support the jury’s verdicts ‘that
' respondents’ price discrimination were reasonably. likely
© to substantially lessen competition or to tend to create
' @ monopoly, within the meaning of Section 2(a) of the |
~ Clayton Act as amended by the. ‘Robinson-Patman Act.
The undisputed facts showed :
a. ‘That petitioner was & small - corporation, with
limited financial resources, engaged solely in the business
of making fresh and frozeii pies, which it. sold in the inter-
mountain area, where it had the only pie plant; ~—- |
b.. Respondents were all ‘large corporations, each en-
gaged in a variety of businesses of which its frozen pie
business was a small parts .--\.:
o,_ Respondents all had substantial. resourees in tho
; fm of, multi-million dollar over-all profits;
d. Respondents all distributed frozen pies fhronghout :
* all or most of the — States; :
e.° -, Respondents all “sold, substantial Lanihanrs of frozen
pies in the area in which they. competed with petitioner at
a
-
©
" prices below the ,prices which respondents charged for
kh Ea kc on SR aR a auc Ap
' not compete with petitioner ;,
f. Respondents had net losses on their sales of frozen
pies in the area in: which et did —— with ~ s
| tioner ; and ea
g. Prices in petitioner’ 8 ‘trading area tell and Peti-
tioner’s market share declined. _
The questions presented are: ihe |
“1. Are these facts alone sufficient to sustain a jury’s
verdict finding a reasonable likelihood of a substantial
_ lessening of competition or a tendency to create a mo-
nopoly arising out of respondents’ price discriminations?
2. Are these facts sufficient to sustain the jury ’s ver- -
‘dict if there is also evidence that there were 200 manu- -
factarers of frozen pies in the United States, but: that
only petitioner and ‘respondénts made more than sporadic
sales i in the area in which petitioner sold frozen pies?
8. Are these facts sufficient to sustain a jury’s werdlict
if there is also evidence that each respondent’s price dis-
criminations were. motivated by predatory intent directed
at petitioner?
a. Is evidence that a respondent planned in ad-
vance’ to: take losses on frozen pie sales in the area ~
in which it vir with petitioner evidence of
os predatory intent? ;
db. Is evidence ue a Suciaaibek indulged in. in-
dustrial espionige to obtain information for use
against iia cid evidence of Predennry intent?
—
4
2
ce Is evidence that A iagpeiitantte discriminatory
: joo ps daipetitbondlbe tiniest oan Sis daahty hela ,
Pe. previously prevailing price levels evidence of preda-
tory intent? ? 1 :
4. Can a difference between a manufacturer's scien
for its proprietary, ‘‘name’’ brand in one geographic area
and the manufacturer’s price, for a substantially identical .
<‘ private label’? product in a different geographic area —
be an unlawful price discrimination under Section 2(a)
of the Clayton Act as amended by the Robinson-Patman
_ §. ‘Is diversion of business to the discriminating seller
the only criterion of competitive effect of a manufac
. farer’s discriminatory price for a ‘‘private label’?
“ product, or should the Court of Appeals also have con-
sidered evidence of the impact of discriminatory prices
for private label products upon the general price level
in the market as a whole, and its probable. ultimate effect
upon the structure of the market? :
GB Did the Court of Appeals, in overturning the jury’s.
verdict on grounds of insufficient evidence, usurp the func-
. tion of the j jury, and deny petitioner’s. constitational right °
to trial by jury, by failing to consider the evidence tn the
light most favorable to petitioner, and by failing to give
: petitioner the benefit of all reasonable inferences from
_ the evidence so considered! pone :
a. Did the Court of Appeals, in overturning the
jury’s verdict, improperly treat an ‘‘advertising al-
‘Jowance’”’? as a ‘‘discount” where the unequivocal
testimony of several witnesses was that an adver
—_—— ;
$=.
b. Did the Goiik of Appeals, in overturning the
jury’s verdict, improperly rely upon the testimony
-of interested defense witnesses who petitioner con-
tended were lying, and whose waaay: was a@ prin- ©
cipal issue in the case? ©
C. Did the Conrt' of Appesla, ta ovédturaing: the
jury’s verdict, place unwarranted reliance upon post-
complaint evidence: by ignoring the reasonable in-
ference that respondents ameliorated their pricing
; practices after the complaint in. this action was filed?
-~. 1%. Could the Court of Appeals properly disregard the
evidence of respondent Continental’s Denver price dis- .
criminations, on the- grounds that the District Court’s
charge did not submit that issue to the jury, and then —
order entry of ere in favor of asrcenenaly withent,
‘a new trial?
8B Questions hedened by the Court.
‘1; Whether, if this Court affirms the jets and .—
ake of the Court of Appeals directing the District Court .
to enter judgment for respondents, petitioner can then
make a motion for new trial under Rule 50(c)(2) of the
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure within’ 10 days of the
District Court’s entry of judgment for respondents? ©.
2. Whether, if under the order of the Court of Ap
= peals, petitioner cannot make a motion for new trial under .
: Rule 50(c) (2) within 10 days of the District Court’s entry
of judgment against him, the order of the Court of
Appeals directing the Distritt Court to enter judgment
for respondents is compatible with Rule 50(b) as ’inter-
preted by this Court in Cone v. West Virginia Pulp &
.
Paper Co., 330 U.S. 312; Globe Liquor Co: v. Son Roman,
. 332 U.S. 571; and Weade v. Dichmann, Wright é Pugh,
337 U.S. 8011 x
3: Whether Rule 50(d) of the Federal Rules of Civil —
Procedure’ provides the Court of Appeals with any au-
Ae thority to direct the entry of judgment for respondents?”’
d ~
S onemegemnnnteiiadinet
STATUTES INVOLVED
- The statutory provisions’ involved are Section 2 of the
Clayton Act, 38 Stat. 730 § 2 (1914), as amended by the
- Robinson-Patman ‘Act, 49 Stat. 1526, 41 (1936), 15. U.S.C.
$13 (1964), and Sections 3, 4, ‘and 16 of the Clayton Act, |
. 38 Stat..731, §§3, 4, and 16 (1914), 15 U.S.C, §§14,°15 - .
and 26 (1964) ; Section 7 of the Clayton Act, as amended, -
38 Stat. 731, $7 (1914), as amended 64 Stat. 1125 (1950),
15 U.S.C. §18 (1964); Fed. R. Civ. P. 50; 308 U.S. 63
(1988) ;-and Fed. R. Civ. P. 50° as amended Jan. 21, 1963,
_ effective July 1, 1963; US. Const. amend. VII.” These
: en ee ee See mee Ci
‘e 4 A
.
-*
“hee,
.
i
1 :
|. STATEMENT © fe
This is. a. ‘primary. line’’ price ‘discrimination case
_ brought .by petitioner hereinafter “Utah Pie’’) against = |
three of its competitors (respondents ‘‘Continental;’ © = -
‘Carnation’? and ‘“‘Pet””)* (R. 16-20). Utah Pie had jury
| verdicts that respondents had individually violated Sec-
a
tion 2(a) of the Clayton Act as amended by the Robinson-
Patman Act, in their sales of frozen fruit pies in the Utah --
trading area, to the injury of’ Utah Pie in stated amounts
(R. 4142, 1405-1406). BEA, cee:
After the verdicts, each respondent. ‘eile: a inaisibins to
set aside the. verdict against it and to enter judgment ’
n.o.v. in its favor in accordance with its previous motions |
for directed verdict, each motion was denied (R. 50-59,
1416, 1420) and the court entered (ge judgments. and
44
decree from which respondents appealgd (R. 45-49, 59).
' The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth
. Circuit reversed all three judgments, and ordered entry
3 of judgment for each respondent (R. 1526).
_ The grounds for the Court of Appeals’ decision were
that the evidence was insufficient, i in each case, to support
a jury finding that respondents’ discriminatory low prices
Clayton Act as amended by the Robinson-Patman Act, to the
ithe deine Salted ‘tn: ed thet camentiobin bod atenslind 46.00
prices, and had agreed to try, by that means, to destroy peti- aS,
-tioner’s business in: violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act
(R. 48, 47, 1406). Petitioner did not appeal that issue. 3
The jury did find that petitioner had violated ‘Section 2 of he
injury of respondent Continental in the amount of one dollar
(R. 45, 1406): The trial court entered judgment for petitioner
N.0.¥.; Continental appealed, and the Court of Appeals Bey
with instructions to grant petitioner & new trial (R. 45,
1508-1511).
These matters are not aia on as Petition.
for frozen pies in Utah Pie’s trading ‘area a threatened com-
petition or tended, to create @ monopoly. ‘Specifically, the —
ede of Appeals ‘said that’ none of ‘the respondents
. by price differences or’ other acts, had substantially ~
iced competition, or tended to create a monopoly, -
or injured, destroyed, or- prevented competition with it
in the Salt Lake City market, _or that there was & reason-
. able. possibility that [respondent], by. pride differences or
” other acts, ‘would de so in the future . ” ” (B. 1502,
1504 and 1507; See also R. 1453). 5, : ae
Before’! fewing the facts of these, cases, the Court of .
_ Appeals stated its standard of review as follows: |
‘“‘Certain facts, if set out and considered in isolation;
_ would, present .a distorted picture ‘of tlese cases. To ete
get a true perspective of them, the whole factual
picture and the relation of each of the facts to eath —
other must be brought into proper focus . <— (
1458).° f° ee
‘The Court of Appeals then proceeded to bring the facts
‘of the cas¢é into what it. considered to be the. ‘‘proper
feos as set ‘forth. in st opinion (R. 1451; 349. F.2d
; “The eviden relied upon. by petitioner to sustain the
verdicts showed the following facts: :
1. The Product Involved Is Froxgn Fruit Pies. ae,
Utah. Pie and respondents all manufactured ‘ol sold
frozen fruit pies 8 inches in diameter and weighing from
20 to.24 ounces apiece . (R. 103, 199, 216, 220, 509-510,
_ 879, 1103). ‘The weight differences are. not. readily ap-
parent from inigertion ai 679-680, ‘879, 881, om je
rd
° t
. The sight inch Soke’ pies involved in this Liowwalt are
‘manufacturéd. for ultimate resale, frozen, through food :
stores to consumers (R. 879-880). They are- baked i in the,
home (R. 969, 1012). ‘The flavors of pies. involved i in this -
o
case are apple, cherry, boyseuberry, blueberry, -peach, ; ig ¢:
pumpkin and mince (RB. '67, 525).
The frozen pie industry i is félatively * young, AR. 1010).
Utah’ Pie entered the’. industry: by freezing some of its J
pies, instead of baking them, in 1957, (BR. 524). Respond-
ents all entered the industry by: way of acquisitions (R.
270, 271, 274, 391, 450). They acquired ‘their pie plants’
at various tinies ‘during the year 1955 ( Thid.). Growth
of the industry has ) Tapid . (RB. 1053, 1220-1221, and 3
. see-Pl: Ex, 62; 'R, 487,.2323; Pl. Ex. 64; R. 436, 503, 602,
_ 2275). . F
Entry into the industry is easy, particularly for manu-
_ . facturers such as Utah Pie, which already had pi¢-making
facilities and a freezer locker (R. 524, 1011).. There was .
testimony that: there Awere over., 200 pie mariufacturers
in the United States at the time of. trial (R. 1011). Never-
theless, the evidence showed that the great bulk of the
frozen pie business i in the United States was in the hands
‘of the . three respondents, ‘and one other manutacturer :
(PL. Ex. 61; R. 436, 503, 602, 2275).
te shina of its conclusions that the frozen pie i: “% “4
ness in Utah Pie’s trading area: was competitive, and a
was likely to. remajn so, the Court of Appeals noted that
_over thirty. brands of frozen pies were sold in the ‘States |
of Washington, Oregon, Utah, Arizona and Colorado (R. :
1456). However, as: Pet’s exhibit A-27 (R. 893, 5824)
shows,’ respondents were — to identify ‘only nineteen
A
OEE NI Ee City at any time
in the ¢alendar years 1957 through 1961 (D.. Ex. A-27;R.> -
‘ egg, (5824). Of. these’ brands, nine were. packed either by
. petitioner or’ respondents (Ibid.). Of the remaining ten
2G 2. psaionrarcieetinnn resersy ee
and 1961 (Itid.). Utah Pie has the only pie plant actually
peice intermountain area (R., 175,9482-483, 1115-
“Dr. ponannny wiondee economic : seiieaih identified:
: and respondents introduced in evidence, a study showing
-. the southern Idaho and Salt Lake City sales by frozen pie.
Soe manufacturers other than Utah Pie and respondents (D.
+ ike Bett Mc ANG §827).- The.ghare of: these, ‘‘others”’,
terms, dropped from about 18.7% in: 1959 to
12.8% in 1960, to about 8.2% in 1961 (D. Ex. A-35;_
B. 1065, 5827; ;-Pl. Ex. 62; R. 437; 2328). 1961 sales of the
. “others”. were ‘actnally lower, in absolute terms, than
their sales’ in 1960, despite a rapidly expanding market
(Thid.):. Dr, Anderson identified 7 firms selling in 1958. ee
ay ts
nd 1900, 9 fire: ling t= 1960.8 selling fm 1961 (BR.
pet).
: a, ) | |
ae - beatae Pio bela, 3 a
sets as hak Pid Diag tia Tea meiepaiaatle :
ee owned by the Bighy family ot Salt Lake City (R..-505-
306). At the.time of trial it had been in business for
ee - nome 30 years, anaking fresh baked pies which it, sold
s s sin, 1, Nevada, Colorado, New. ‘Mexico and Wyoming -
ee esi in deg oom geen poate Se:
family (R. 506). tea 3 Ore ote
Ta ghont Angst of 1957, Vink: teoaip sioeihigaplin ee
_as well as baking them: (R. 524)... In:the ensuing four ‘fiscal
‘ y SS ; is * ts
. : . as ‘ :
% - zt .. é - > *
> . i= : : : % : mes a
. =. x . : - . eee «A
if : ri *e ; ; Sy:
2: + © ; :
* <4 | e = +> < PBS ; ‘ a
oe : 3 : ; ers
< _aited sechlng dn, sight peadiscelghstagaee
* im grade sehool (BR. 475,; 482, 505,506,522). Of the 18.
I ansircspectocige aes te leprterciaeuss erg Oo “i:
- years,-it sold frozen pies in. the states.of Utah, Idaho,
Nevada, Wyoming, Montana, Colorado, California, Oregon
and Washington (Pl. Ex. 82;-R. 527, 3616). “At the time ee
-. Of trial,” substantially all of Utah Pie’s business: was'in
pies, and mostly frozen pies (D. Ex. \A-46; ‘RB. 997, 5850).
; “In September 1958, Utah Pic opened’ a ‘iow pie plant a
-(R. 695). : It was’ a ‘well-managed plant with an advan- z
tageous location (Ry 175).A quality control man for t Safe-
way Stores, who inspected the ‘plant, saidthat the: produe-
: tion machinery was satisfactory and that. the plant. was
the cleanest he had-ever been in (R497):
“Utah: Pie's product’ throughout the period in contro:
versy , was a 24 ounce, 8.inch diameter, frozen fruit, pie in,
the flavors apple, ‘cherry, boysenberry, blueberry, pumpkin, une
_ mince (Bs. 67,. 525, 879). A peach flavor was added in
August 1960 (Pl. Ex. 4,R, 67, 1530). Petitioner's original
Mond see: Pie’ (B. 808). Later, it added “Frost.
’'N Flame,”’ which was a “‘controlléd label” in Utah: and
"Idaho but which was Utah Pie’s brand elsewhere, includ: “
ing Denver (R. 553-554, 780).. Petitioner also,. packed
“Sonny Boy”’ private label for Roundup. Grocers in
| Spokane, Washington, a ‘“Mayfresh” private labeF for Z :
Tame Court 0 Appeals vetdes td: taptnesh’ ad *coureed”
~ label (Bu 1486). For ete SL aT a CRON
- not Utah Pie (B.. 729). Fe
a . : ete : : &
a «
"Ste ties Sects igi Wheel
ramp and nlnt pi wader ho paste “Bel Air” | .
; © laiel’ for Safeway. (R 516-517, 54, 729, 769, 814-818).
The quality and efficiency of petitioner’ . operation was
“attested to by the general’ manager of Pét’s Frozen Foods a
"Division (and Pet’s ‘tindustrial spy’’) who appeared and
_ testified, ‘a8 ‘a “technical man, that inadequacies in Utalr
Pie’s' rilethods could all be very éasily remedied in the SS
event that Utah Pie: secured an:order from Safeway. (R.
~ 936-937). ‘Respondents’ brokers and salesmen ‘testified that -
: petitioner’s pies were of high quality (B. 175, 971). Utah
Pie’s witnesses testified to Utah Pie's. methods, capacity
- and quality control (R. 476-477,. 486," 505-506, 524, 568) .
and underwent thorough crose-examination oe 492-499, :
512-514). ale
#
3. Utah Pie Markated Frozen Pies in Nine’ Western States.
“Before it added its line of frozen. pies in. 1957, Utah 2
Pad shin enh tresht bak? ic inthe ‘tales! Of. Utah,
Nevada, Colorado, New Mexico and Wyoming (R. 524).
During the four years ‘preceding the filing of the coth-
- plaint in’ this’ action, Utah Utah Pie sold frozen: fruit pies in
the states of ‘Utah, ‘Idaho, Nevada, "Wyoming, Montana, :
‘Colorado,’ ‘California; Oregon: and Washington “(Pl Ex.
$2 R627, 9616; "Pl. Ex. 91; ‘RB. 351, , 4420). Utah Pie:
chad brokers’ in ‘Denver (R- 581)" ‘and Portland (R. 778).
“Dr. Anderson, the Utah State Professor retained by the -
a jointly. as an economics expert (R. 1059,
es 1087), testified that Washington, Oregon, Montana, Wyo- wy
oti?
respondents .j
ming. and. Denver;. Colorado, were within thé ‘‘relevant
- mit” ot Utah o's busines CR, 2151116); Pig :
ee an
AE ag -
. Bt ; : oe oe
‘ . 3 . ; - yen . : cant
. :
s
| GOA Whotendira tt Gal€ Lak City Wore resold. in
‘Id 5 et cee
Bs ger treme .
/ ‘Throughout the trial, evidence of. Utah’ ‘Pie's
<etlaite ts weighed Vinee ced es Soe ation -
or failure came in-through a yariety of witnesses and -
documents. Places repeatedly referred to: ‘include Denver *
(R. 581-537, 539-540, 546, 564-565, “575, 583, 591-592),
Spokane (R. 588-539, 575); Seattle (R, 538-539, 575); :
‘Portland (RB. 538, 542, He), and California: (B:. £40541, :
576).
- specifically to. Utgh Pie’s sales in Denver and: ‘general
__, market conditions there (R. 742-761). 3
The Court of Appeals minimized. Utah Pie's sales out. :
side of the states of Uiah and Jaaho;, re
. its ‘sales, otitzide, of Wiah, and: southern: Ldaho
idusion the period involved in this ae 1958. to
. 1961, ‘were negligible, See Appendix ‘I’ attached
._ hereto.” as (Opinion, BR 1458). ities
"But Appendix Ito the Court off Appesis opinion was Bes:
limited to the apple flavor; the evidence shows: that. Uteh :
Pie made the following proportions of its all-flayor. sales
outside of Utah and Idaho in the years in issue: :
pes 1958— 2.0% - a
BE Fic siya shoe
“oS 5 2: 1960-22.2% 9b
cies) 196L—18.8% »..
(Bonne: Pl, Ex. 82; R52, 26)
sages
Continental called 6 éne Doil Sinith as w witsins to tetity |
OS
-_ Qpurage customers to. buy. ‘One ‘snch inducement was an
- “off the face” or.“‘off, invoice” price. cut, showing a re-
the ‘oustomer (B. 110-112. 462, 1030-1031). Another type
of inducement. was an “advertising allowance” which did .
not _ reduce the invoice price which the customer was
‘ated to pay, ‘but did entitle him to a payment upone
‘proof “that he had advertised. the respondent's produet
Ce 110-112, 158-159, 1687-689, 697, 985).
In order to obtain: the ‘advertising allowanee, fou
_tome ras tiot_only 1-to advertise: by brand ‘name,
pit a aleo.to Sh, in a shin for allowance—which was not '
-_ nedessarily’done, in. all instances - (BR. 158-160, 689, 697,.
- 1095). “Where ‘a manufacturer offers an’ advertising al-
lowance’ it gets ‘consideration which it does not get for an
yr nary prise ake rertagns ‘ot of its brand (R. 697, 985,
——
ee
Tigee Beg eT Ne a <
er aake of. Continental, Carnation ind Pet all testified
ai a ng allowances ‘are not price cuts (R. 110-112,
io % 681-689, 1030). Carnation often used. both an
advertisin we @ and én off-invoice price ‘cut simul-—
“tancoualy Salt Lake’ (PL. x29 cn alana
5351, 5353). Bae 4
Th Aap mrt B
~4Ip effect, the ‘advertising allowance is a discount, —
and fixes the net ‘por case price of the pies pur
or — oe AIT oe
t -! x .
pire e ‘ ”
ms
:
on from list price on the face of the invoice sent to -
ind hl ‘al ‘offered at ag eal agp to’. en- f
Bo $a Se
LB
{lee teat hapa domi pata ca :
tables of pricés purporting to. show \minithal. discrimina-
tion in respondents’ prices (BR. 1515-1521, 1523-1525). The
tables are based upon the assumption that price cuts and i
advertising allowances: are ; the same = Lied 1467, 1485,
Ce BBFe ries heirsity be ; ee
When respondents’ pricing bibdetions’ are examined oe
the light of the testimony thet advertising ‘allowances are ;
not price cuts, a different pattern emerges. As will. ap- -
pear hereinafter, Utah Pie’s price comparisons do ‘not - aes
_ eorrespond to those of the Court of Appeals; ‘since. Utah
_° Pie relied ‘upon thé evidence that advertising allowances.
are not discounts, while the Court of ‘Appeals: Fejected it.
: 6. Respondents Were Al normons Gonglamerie Corporation:
| With Vast Financial Resources.
Respondents are all corporations ‘with ‘sinaal sili "ee
in the hundreds of millions of dollars and profit in the
_ millions or tens of- millions’ of dollars (Pl. Ex. 31; B.
_ 256, 2202): Frozen fruit pies were a-minor portion of
each respondent’s business (Pl. Ex. 21; RB. 235, 2161,
2163;-Pl. Ex. 22; BR. 241, 2167, 2168; PL. Ex. 23; RB. 245; -
_ 2175, 2176,2477; Pl. Ex. 26; R.. 378, 2180; PL Ex. 31; R.
256, 2202). Respondents were three of the four largest
sellers of frozen pies in the nation. FA, Bi Oh > haat
608, 2275, 2294). 7 :
een * Conny 65 feopondlepa, titgh Pie Ges ligula cen e
Ex, 92: B. 551, 4586; D. Ex. A-46; BR. 997, 5847, 5848). °
- ‘For its teal your onding Ouober 3, 161, Uiah Pie
# showed record frozen pie 5 of $407,841.25 (PL. Ex. 92;
B. S81, 4586). ‘However; Utah ae ee
. a *
: % sie Ot a cae shee
oe int gh it of ALI a previ a yO ee
Y your (De Bt Art y-Bs 90, et). ee
se 4 ‘Dah Pie's Casa gna inst Pet. eee :
oes ‘Pet got into the: frou ile Waslabed, br hctyeizing the
Crystal Canning-Co., which had previously acquired the
2 RISE Pie Go, widen bad plant Jn, Mchions (R. 391, ©
1009-1010), ‘Pet subsequently acquired additional. plants
es in Fresno, California, and Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
ag (B 1009-1110). oe
ei, fa Bid'e tal eal cated of alk peodints Tasca in every
| fall fiscal year covered ‘by the damage period of: the case
(Pl: Ex. 31; RB. 256, 2202). Ttq amallest overall sales in any ~
_ of those years was $181,847,999. (ibid.). Its smallest net
| "profit before taxes in any of tiose’ years was in exooss:
_ of $7 million (Ibid.). However, Pet consistently lost.
monéy on ‘frozen. pies: throughout the damage period of
this ease'(PL Bx. 21; Ro 235, 234-236, 2161, 2163-2164).
| -- one en le ete cede rh
| Ex 5 21, 2181). ,
fo opin
“ Pet's high-priced ‘proprietary pie abel is , Pet Bite”
(B. 1024). Pet’s losses on: Pet-Ritz in its Selt Lake.
A (C= A ogni orspaaierpietien al
ae .
. perenne Gr
oe operation. % is seen in. ‘the. spreticend,
aE Seite he retsee :
A Enon
_ Hii i tit gy nt anibeanipiotgs oat eg
or (loss)*? (PL Ex. 7; Beaoo, 1928-1998; paséim). There- - -
- " after, they show “net” lose+-thé operating Jossés reduced iF a
: uddeemne tae “eS
_ B, 409, 1999-2045, passim): fe ee
* Pet's marketing ‘efforts in Salt Lake City (to ay ie
_ ing of the rest of Utah Pie's trading area) were markedly e
successful, volume-wise, if not profit-wise. In 1988, A ees
‘had 16.4% of the total Salt Lake market (PL Bx. 62;
R. 487, 28%). In 1961, Pet had 294% ‘of the’ total - ‘
_. Salt Lake ‘market, although its ‘nearest plant ‘was
"hundreds of milés away (Ibid.). In the year. 1959, Eo 0 ee
sold more frozen fruit pies in Salt Lake thin any other’
seller, and had 35.5% of the total market (Ihid.). Pet’s
share of the, advertised brand »market (ie, other. than.
' private. labels) was even more pronounced; . by 1961 Pet :
was- easily, the largest seller, wih shape: 29%, fp
market (Pl, Ex. 96; B, 581, 4592, 4598). .
Pot also had the largest market share of the United
. ‘States’ Teqeei (youn. ia: msarhtt Jes 16B ani 3080 ee
|. (BL Ex. 61; B. 436, 504, 602, 2275), ows. :
‘After 3057, Pet's Saree pin filante tn’ California, Mish.
gan and Pennsylvania supplied’ the.entire United States:
(B. 1010): Pet's ‘pies were sold on Srp
* peas (B, 1098) ha Baoan
: “Pet's original “Pet Ritz’? visit: was ah: eight as os
.. Pie weighisig..24 ounces (R.'1024), Tn 1060 Pet peters k G
its 20 ouhes ce" “Swiss ‘Miss’* pie ‘which
, ‘with: . , the economy ‘pie factor of the ie - ez and ese
s eset repeal eran
“Pet aloo packed “Bal Air”? iab@ pies for Safeway
pe "Stores under a requirements contract (PL. Ex. 42; B. 1064,
” 9926). The Bel Air pie is ‘substantially the same
*” product’? as the Pet-Ritz pie (B. 405). Pet-Ritz pies and
Bel Air ‘pice were stipulated to be of ‘like grade and
quality’ (R. 1373). Pet’s sales of Bel Air label pies began
: in 1959 and continued through to the date of the com-
plaint, (D. Ex. A-35; R. 1065, 5827, 5829-5832). The Safe-
way Bel Air business was highly important to Pet,
: amounting to 63,000 dozen pies (126,000. cases) in the
immediate Salt Lake City ares in the years 1959, 1960
and" 1961 (Thid.). Pipes, ee eter, ek Tere: Sarin ap
organization i in Denver i eed
fe
a: Pet's Pris Diectimizistions. —
| "ect acto wn by Asal Average Prot
- ° Onan overall average basis, Pet realized lower net
“prices in its Salt Lake Division ‘in 1958 and 1959 than it~
did im the rest of ite frozen pie bypiness nationwide As
? shown’ by PL. Hx'24 (BR. 877, 2178), based ‘upon Pel's
internal | , Pet’s average net sales price per dozen
| frozen t pies in its Salt Lake Division was $4.30 as
= against an. average net sales price of $4.46 per dozen for
all other. Pet divisions (RB. 246-247). In 1959, Pet’s Salt
"Lake pie prices were lower than its average prices every-
:. where else on 8 gross. | ($4.68 in Salt Lake ve. $4.71 -
all other divisions) well as on a net basis ($3.91 in
it Lake, ve, $4.13 everywhere’else) (PL Ex. 24; B. 377,
_, Pet's, sales, volumes in pat 1958, and 1959, were
ra per Pet Divisions, esenee 97126271) (id).
In 1960 ‘anid: 1961;* Pet's, Pet-Ritz sales pricés Were shee a ite
lower in Salt Lake than they were on an'ovérall basis ie
(PL Ex. 25; R. 378, 2179, 2180). Pet-Ritz‘average prices,’
_ sede su sat, pee oes Lot theme: pone elie lies faa.
$f 1900 ; : irene f
web dee *(Bouree: PLB 3; 8 i
: (i) Pee mite Bel Ate Discetmindtioas [UROL a abet gtil ae |
‘At all times, Pot musinteined ° bwp-pelas “aypledl ty
‘which it sold ‘Bel Air”* label pies to Safeway at‘prices :
- substantially below the ‘prices of “‘Pet-Ritz’* p pies 'ée ike”
grade and quality (Pl. Ex’ 42; R. 1021, 1054, 2226; Aa
‘Ex. 43; B. 406, 29; Pl. Bx. 46; Bai, ‘2241, 228; od
a lel ahaa Wea? Seti ald Wed te
egal on bigs aa 7 sie tone ob ($1.54 per dozen) in -
Utah Pie’s trading area (Pl. Ex. 42; R. 1054, 2226, 2240).
. Comparing the price which Pet was charging in North-. ee
erm California for its Pet Bits pie with the price it was He
ebarging Safeway for Bel Air pies for Salt Lake, eee
Se ee
ae A244. o% 4
Ms Bask 2 ve e + 45
LIN tei) baa Beever ee
ig fT 54 41 , «4% > . 3 fs F. is a4
yi NERA TDD FY 2 RR OST? 7 A oe iF 4 i GES
. ¥ > - ‘ .
Ps
‘Stilanive PL x: 42; R, 1041, 1054, 2228, 2240)
2 he ceo attetoernemame ene SAN
: “associated with the problems of the frozen pie business
wig: (B. 1009) was unable to explain why Pet’s basic Pet-Rity %.
: ap ooo ag hygeapheahageninp ~
- in California (R. 1054). Pet’s Conteoller could not ex- |
plain it, either (BR, 404). _ atest
Using Pet’s invoices as @ sonree- of California prices
amd -Pet’s own: D. Ex. A-35. (B. 1065, 5827, 5837-5838,
- | 5644) asa adurce of Salt Lake City prices, it is possible
_ to show: ‘prevailing patterns of. discrimination between .-
. Pet’s California prices for. Pet-Bitsand. contemporaneous .
eee ‘sales of pies of' “like grade and quality’* (both Bel Air
and Pet-Ritz;. R,. 1373). ‘The relevant invoices may be.
found: in. Pl. Exs. 116-122, & 993, 3g: 4836, 4947, 5034,
5098, 5280; 5250, 518).
lass vielag Pete pelon Snocinisations reveled in
the abore sources are contained in Appendix B to this,
-_ pion ia California in substantially every month from July, ae
rie.
"Phos tables show sales’ of Pot ita epple and. cherry
1959, through May, 1961.‘ ‘They show sales of Pet-Ritz
so er pi Sat Latin 9 ont 22
Wovens Ss SE
MAF”
>: oY
s
/
* months for which the record contains evidence ‘of isle
-of a Pet-Ritz apple pie in Galifornia,: They: show sales
of Bel Air apple pies in Salt Lake at still lower pricss for —
. 18 out of 18 months for which thé record shows both gales
= Nicene aReRREaE RRL ares
-
Those. tables show salee’of Pet-Rits cherry. pigs. in Salt
_. Lake at prices lower than sales in California in 18 out‘of
20 months for which the record contains evidence of a
sale of &, Pet-Ritz cherry pie in California, They show. -
sales.of Bel Air cherry in Salt Lake at still lower prices -
for 18 ont of {8 months for which the record shows sales
‘ot: Ret Mts a) California. 2 sien, of Bul, fn, Balt
Lake. fey .
.. The Court of Appeals jenaion the Misteissinaiioda she:
"tween. Pet’s San Francisco: prices for: \Pet-Ritz and. its
Salt. Lake prices for Bel Air, except to note that ‘“. .
~Pet’s costs of manufacture, sale and delivery of [Bel Air]
‘pies were $0.4980 less than such costs. of -like pies. sold
under its regular labels, and that’the difference in price
to Safeway of such Bel-sir pies and the price which such
'- like ‘pies sold to other customers only $0.4275. The’
Ape aha oy : Set AS et ,
> . . aa : \ . rc ty ¥ re . } ae .
. é .
ee
-&
__ difference in cost justified the differ er.
n
the cost justification proviso in 2(a) ‘of the ae Ase
. .’” (BR, 1465, 1501),
- In fact, the only documentary evidense of a cost, just
;
:
...
e
Seaton for Pet's price differences other than the Safoway ee.
- ae Pe R,..1041, 1054, 2996)
_ ‘only: the last five, months prior, to, the filing of the, com-
Bint (PL Ea. 48; R106, 223; PL Ex. 44; 4
ae ae
°
“en, * "
ie e ° J
me +
\
goat), Thesé iconpiatitions are soba averages ‘of al oe
) : °
‘ and costs over a large area and all flavors of pies (Ibi
ae : They purport’ to ‘justify -a price difference of no more
- than $4980. per. case, although the price differences often -
“exceeded that figure by substantial smounts.. ow table
a above).
The. Court of ioppeale® other reason : for negiceting the
tnpaot of Pet's Bel Air enlen in Utah Pie's trading ares )
+ owas “3 because it was clearly established by uncon-
‘tradicted sae ‘ancontroverted evidence that Safeway “was
Se, - not willing in those “years 1959, 1960 and 1961 to pur- sie
'-"* ghase frozen fruit pies from Utah Pie, for the reason
that it was unable to perehade Utah Pie to install means
‘and procedures that would insure uniform quality of
Air frozen fruit pies produced by ‘Utah Pie and sold by’
' Gt to Safeway”” “(R. 1472, 4501).
_ However, Gaylen Rigby, Utah Pie’s sales: ‘manager,’
<2 ~ testified directly that’ Safeway: not only was willing to
_ purchase a general line of, Bel Air flavors for: its Salt .
Lake ‘and Denver divisions from Utah Pie, but that he
“bought a year’s supply of fruit in reliance upon the Sate-
-
way, bayer’ & recommendation that he do‘se (R. 549).
‘Ross: Rigby, . Utah. Pie’s. plant engineer, testified at
‘ length, to the effect that Utah Pie’s quality ‘control did,
"+ in fact, satisfy Safeway on the ‘pumpkin and mince pies"
a whieh Utah Pie packed! under the Bel Air label (R. -492-
498," 497). He testified that. a. set. of closing plows re- _
to pack pies in Safeway’s Bel Air boxes would '
- “nave ‘ost $1400 and would have taker! about § hours, to
« — = Bictog a
~
a,
e os
‘ .
_ Pet: got all of the Safeway Bel Air business ‘except a
. | portion of the seasonal pumpkin and’ mince pit’ business .
(R. 1138). Pet’s exclusive contract. with. Safeway. pre-
cluded Utah Pie from competing for the general line.of —
Bel. Air business in Salt Lake and Denver where, it-had
the advantages of convenient location and low labor costs :
(PL Ex. 38; R. 386, 2212). There were ‘very few Points,
‘* where they: [Utah Pie] would have a prob ” with
Safeway (PL Ex. 38; R. 386, 2212, 2214; 932, 936).
’: Sateway’s Bel ‘Air pie sold in large quantities in Salt .
- Lake (D. Ex. A-35;-R.-1065, 5827, 5830-5832). It sold -at.
(B. 704-705;, 1027, 1138).
retail at.a comparatively low price (D. Ex. A-35; R. 1065;
- » 5827, 5835-5844). The low pricing structure-‘of - ‘the Bel *
Air-pie produced by Pet probably had a depressing effect
| ont the prices of frozen pies-in.all markets. where Safeway
- was @ competitive factor (R. 695, 715, 720, 724, 751, 815).
Safeway Divisions did not limit | their purchases. to
| ‘Safeway’s. own Bel Air brand—they .purchased '‘‘Utah -
Pie’* brand pies, and the brands of the other respondents, —
' from time to time (BR. 544, 698, 707, 1027, 1188). If. the
‘Safeway Divisions wish to stock “Bel Air’, they must :
| obtain it through. Safeway’s buyer, not directly from the
manufacturer, but they are not obligated to stock “Bel :
Air”’ if they don’t want ‘to, ant sometiines do not do 80
~
—>- 2 .
5 hltagh i aim dapgeaned. thik hath nan: Aleit, ae.
Petition between: ‘Bel Air and other brands, for the custom
‘of the Safeway Divisions; the Court of Appeals held, with
respect to Pet’s' sales of Bel Air piés in -1959, 1960. and
ag
ae - teMfhose sales + afford no support sai Utah Pie’ 8 2(a)
: reheat wal Ge aia
“The Court of Appeals acknowledges Pet Ritz /Pet-Ritz
price differences but attempts to minimize them as ‘‘al-
most. inconsequential” in volume with a chart. limited to
apple flavor .(R. 1470). In fact Pet sold over 35,000 dozen
(70,000 -eases) of Pet-Ritz pies in the immiediate Salt
Lake area from 1958 to 1961 (D. Ex. A-35; RB. 1065, 5827,
5829-5832). In addition to the evidence that Pet’s dis-
- griminatory prices may have diverted substantial business
6)
«
> -
~ °
to Pet, there was evidence that a general reduction of
‘the price. structure in Utah Pie’s trading area hurt Utah
Pie on the sales which it did make (PL Ex. 4; RC;
| 1530; Pl, Ex. 3; ‘BR. 552, 4587; ‘PL. Ex. 100; R. 585, 4604). ‘
“In its analysis of Pet’s pricing practices, the Court of
Appeals relied in part on. Pl.) Ex. 112 (R. 4713) (See R.
- 1467). That exhibit was identified as the underlying ‘work
: papers: for some of ‘respondents’ exhibits (R. 627 -628).
It ‘should be considered in. the light of the evidence
which shows that an ‘‘off invoice’? allowance is a price
cut, whereas an ‘advertising allowance”’ is not (R. 110-
"112, 160, 462; 689, 1030). ‘The Court of Appeals expressly :
tock the opposite view in considering Pl. Ex. 112: “By
lowest absolute price is nieant the list price, less-any deals
- offered, whether direct discounts from the invoice price or ,
advertising allowances”’ (R. 1467). ‘The Court of Appeals
“thas thas relied upon the right-hand ‘column of PL Ex. 112
Tneaded “absolute price” (Re 4713, 4714-4765) — than |
: ee center eolomn — ‘‘invoice net price.”
we
fad ¥ @ 25 | “ ,
aig invoice net sie a ‘aia 9 eae ia ‘pon
“which to base. a comparison, the pattern of Pet-Ritz/Pet-
' Ritz price differences between ‘Northern California’ and
Utah Pie’s trading area in 1960 and the pre-complaint “
portion of 1961 emerges (PL Ex. 112; .R. 4713; com-
pare on ‘apple prices R. 4770-4771. with R. ‘ATT4, ATT5;-
4776, 4779, 4780 and 4782; compare ‘on cherry | prices R.
4783-4784 with 4787-4791, 4792, 4793 and.4795; compare
on boysenberry prices R. 4796-4797. with R 4801, 4802, aoe
-. 4804, 4807. and 4808; compare oa posh sprints Th AS
4823 with R. 4826, 4827, 4828, 4829,-4831, 4832 and d 4834),*
Despite the freight of about $.30-$. 35 (B. 254, 663) from :
California ,to Salt Lake, Pet’s “net invoice’? prices for
Pet-Ritz apple, cherry, boysenberry and peach were equal”
to or:lower than Pet’s prices in Northern. California. dur- 7
ing 1960 and. 1961. (PL: Ex. 112; R. 627, 629, 4713; per
" comparable pace sheets, supra). Whenever there was a
' - diserimination, the low price was in Utah Pie’s trading i
area (Ibid.). | 4 Boh ns
s * The “following table showi- the Pet Ritz “invoice. net? 4
' pricing pattern for apple in 1960 and the first 8 months.
wae — : 3
Fo oe
| Colorado 31900. p CR ATIOATT ATT) Boisa sheia®
Be . re . Saas A961? be 8 - bg 0
oS Wyoming. 0 0 sT104TT1, 4182) | 6 Ree
: | - : iy 0
‘Utsh “sa eerroatti e718} 5, aorta 2
ae mt ne 0
es Tdaho' "i rare 8 0.
Phe eit : ee 3-4 0°
" ‘Montana’. . ogy 4T10-4771,4776) 8 e.;
es OT yggge 4 0
= = of. R
"The pattern ‘on ‘cherry, pies, the second largest selling
flavor (D: ‘Ex! ‘A-35; R. 1065, 5827, 5898), was almost the
- jamnd ‘as for ‘apple (PL fx. 112; B.'627, 629, 4713, 4783
- 478A, 4787-90, 4792, 4793 and 4795). The éqeeption ‘was
‘ie State “of Wyoming, in ‘which’ there “was ‘a. discrimina-
tory low price in’ every one of the eight relevant months _
of 1961. (Ibid.). At no time: in 1960 or in the’ relevant
‘eight months of 1961 was the price ‘of Pet-Ritz cherry .
lower in Northern California, near the plant, than it was |
where’ plaintiff was doing business (Ibid.). A similar -
aca on wagon Wt oe with some . ie
“variations, prevailed with ee the other Pet-Ritz
sesvors (ibid): :
Salt Lake as against $3.17. in Northern. end
Reno, Nevada (PL. Ex. 112; R. 627, 629, 4712; see B: 4715,-
” 4717, 4722, 4723). There was thus no actual“‘‘discrimins-
tion”’, as Utah Pie caleulates-it, although the pricé differ-
“ence of $08 per dozen was substantially less than the
' fréight of $30 to $35 per dozen from. Pet’s. plant in
California: to Salt Lake (RB. 254, 663). beg.
| But Swiss Miss did sell at prices below ‘the Northern‘ 3
|. California and Nevada price in other parts of Utah Pie’s
‘ trading area’ on a delivered i invoice net price, basis. While
“ apple and cherry were sold at $3.17, invoice net price’ in
Northern California (PI. Ex. 112; R. 627, 629, 4712, 4715,
4722) they were selling substantially below $3. 17. for ex-
"tended periods in parts of Idahd (Ibid. B. 2716, 4730),
. » Wyonting (Ibid., R. 4719, 4725) and Colorado ayer R.°
" 4720, 4124). x
b. There Was Evidence of Pet's Predatory ‘Tactics in Its Dealings in
Petitioner’ s Trading Area.
(1) ‘Investment Spending’ 3
Pet engaged in a program of intentional, ela.
“below-cost, sales of frozen pies, financed with money **bor-.
rowed : ; from our total corporate operation” (BR. 1019,
1050-1061). This. practice was ‘referred to as ‘investment |
‘spending?” R. 400-401, 1018-1019).
. ‘There was. evidence that Pet’s ‘‘inveatment spending”
; program was aimed at petitioner; a memorandum written,
3 ot 1 Pet’s Swiss Mies, apple and’cherry pies . -
Ba eee “consistently sold at $3.25 per dozen. invoice net.-price in
3 ; : * 5 et% Ge
hy Pet’s intermonntain area sales manager. stated, under .
“Unfavorable Factors Affecting Results”, that “despite
xt sendy roth gener there are factors at work
that'‘dig' holes in our’ operation. Utah’ Pies in the ‘Salt
| ako Diataict are 4 constant ‘check’ ee =
eS A Se)- Riya. 5
328 er ae, oe ve
| Go) Rate Melon,
Pet also engaged i in: industeial espionage of petitioner’ 8
plant, -At a crucial moment in the negotiations for: Safe-
_, lway’s Bel Air business, Schenk, fhe Genera} ‘Manager of.
Pet's Frozen Foods Division inspected pétitioner’s plant -
” under false pretenses and prepared a report on his find-
ings (B. 928-949; PL Ex, 38; B. 386, 2212-2214), The -
_ report was addressed to, Dittman, contract. sales manager
. for Pet (PL. Ex. 38; ‘R. 386, 2212; R. 950, 957-958). The:
| report ‘was to. be used by Dittman in disparaging peti-
* tioner. to Safeway (BR. 934-935). Copies of the report Were:
_ Gireulated to L. G..Leutwiler, vice-president of production
of Pet’s Milk Produets Division; Gordon Ellis, President .
. of Pet’s Milk Products Division. and 8. P. Harter, Pet’s
‘Beniot Vieo President (B. 9333, PL Ex. 38; ; BR. 386, 2212).
Subsequently, Pet got the Safeway business (at. a dis-
_griminatory price) | and petitioner’ lost out (RB. 549-550;
-. PL Ex. 4; BR, 1054, 2226). Gaylen Rigby, Utah Pie's sales
- “minager testified that he had sctually been promised
fa int are oarreentema tajpedl analy
visit, Eto petitioner’s plant (BR. 547-549). Young, .
a “the Safeway buyer denied that le had ever promised to ~
“eit ean “i Sik “hebben odin Cad
oe oaalty! — a
°
7
29°
Noung; the Safeway ininaes ald denied oie any’ sep zs
sentative of respondent Pet had ever talked to hi about
: conditions within petitioner’ 8 plant: (R.: 1187), owever,
“lack of: technical quality control personnel?” was one: of
the -4‘points you might’ use”? listed in Pet’s’ ‘espionage
" memdrandum compiled for its Safeway “contractor ’ ne- -.
- gotiator (PL Ex. 38; R. 3862212, 2214) And this. point coh
was’ raised by Safeway tn its. diafings with Utah Pie
(B. 492).
‘On the other hand there was sili (aot abjectod a
to): ‘that a Safeway quality control man who had ‘in-
- spected petitioner’ 8 plant had said that it was the cleanest ae :
‘he had ever. been in (R. 497). Young then testified that —
the Safeway. quality control inspector was ‘not qealitiog!”
to make the inspection (B. 1157-1158).
Although Young, the. Safeway buyer, was not dimployed a
by a party, there was evidence that his interest might be
greater than appeared at ‘first blush. A Pet internal’ i
- meniorandum. (Pl. Ex. 47; BR 412, 2252-2253), said’ in —
part 4,8 . Young will act as’a door opener for our salés
people. . or The:memo went on to say ‘/.. . Young will.
encourage the Safeway Sales Division to stock Pet-Ritz
. flavors of 8” fruit pies that are packed under the Bel Air .
label, particularly with those divisions that are currently |
stocking 4 pie that competes with Pet-Ritz, both i in. quality :
and price, Young will send me ‘a blind copy. of the letter
that goes to each Safeway Division, with the yuan »
~ ing our mén are not to at this, letter.”? (FL Ex. 475
412, 2252, macy k :
} | , ‘ ‘
. ae
. . e
'. $0 3 Stee:
¢ : . od
ee (Wiliam Harsha, President of Pet's Milk Broduets Di- |
igs _wision, identified PL. Ex.'47 as a ‘memorandum which I (ee
" wroteto myself. ..’? (BR. 1024). It was a ‘‘reminder for -
ee my own: personal use . . .”? (B. 1024, 1035).' But. when
We Harsha: was’ asked if ‘his own ‘memorandum ‘spoke the —
ie truth, he equivoeated—‘‘agreed”’ meant ‘‘agreed’”’ ‘in one Capek
place, but not in another; there was no discussion about
a ‘‘blind copy’’ with Young;. there was no agreement or — i
understanding that the Pet men were “not to. quote’ the
ue letter of which Pet was to recsive a bling copy (R. 1036-
| " Young testified flatly thkt Gayton Rigily’s testimony to.
the effect ‘that Young had told him to buy fruit for ‘Bel
Air pies was ‘false’ ,(R. 1139). ‘He also testified that
statements in Harsha’s jpemorandum were ‘‘not true’’
Br MMs. 0006 oo ; :
« David. Dittman, Administrative Manager. of Pet’s
& Frozen’ Food Division, also testified (R. 950 et seq.). He
said that he ‘did not discuss Schenk’s’ espionage’ report
. APL Bx. 98). with Schenk although he asked Schenk to
‘obtain thé information (BR. 957-958). He further testified
‘ .. thatthe ‘‘never used any of those pointa’’.which Schenk
es ‘had: suggested: he’ ‘might use” with Safeway ws! bee
eis Pl. Bix. 88;) B. 396, 2212, 2214), nif) i
a Veo ‘ Cordnael't6t Utah’ Pie specifically raised the. question
poets ot Hareb, Ditinan’ wad Young's vreity in afgunent
| We thie fary CR 1255-1262): Pie )
ie: Ns cdeh ll Ned elns Vasailils and ecvabitly ot wit.
"esses ‘wis 'e major issue in the ease when he begat his he
fommation: — iF. Bap BRT ar RE ah
» ° . , ;
4 ; 4 ie YS sy ne 4 : , ry 3
nt 9 meee j Bt IE , . ‘. bad : »
D hh f , @ 7 - 4 i ~
‘ t. . 3 uns 2 ; A
os “Tog rs : 2 u . eS a . f eegs, ,
’ - ¥ 5 é ¢ . . ¢ P
.
. ¢. 4 ‘
‘
& ; J
ot
AP \ .
at |
a ‘Mr, Lamb: May i plete the Cour adios and
- gentlemen of. the jury: one
any canine 90. ya ostaieseegihibe x este ;
, never had’ one of my witnesses: accused. of: being a :
diag, Three of my witnesses were accused by the op-’ .
position of being a liar—the head bfyer for the
_ Safeway Stores, the president of the Milk. Products -
. Division of Pet Milk Company, Mr. temgeed chief. -
contract beset for thé Pet = hte ree Oh.
1310).. ‘<
’ Faced with boii open conflicts in ‘he “ideas the
tGen of Appeals said that the evidence was “free from. -
-‘ gubstazitial dispute, except for a few statements of opin-
ions or conclusions ‘not. based on any substantial under-
_ lying ,proof’?’ (RB. 1454) and went on to rely specifically ~—
upon the cae da of Dittman’ and Toung,. (BR. 1475-
1476):
.. “Of course, Pet's conduct was ‘ nioaaiiie ‘and
_ _. is ‘not to be condoned. However, the informationon-
tained ‘in Dittman’s report was never conveyed to |
Safeway personnel. Dittman so testified, arid ‘so. did |
‘Young, Safeway’s. bayer. It. thus appears that’ thie
' . Dittman report, was never used -by Pet in its’ aie
petitive efforts with Utah Pie’’ bane Mae )
‘dtl ‘The wisn Miss Fighting Brand.
_ Another . predatory tactic which the perish showed
| Pet had employed was its, ‘fighting brand”’, ‘Swiss Miss. .
ee | The. Swist Miss Pio was 4 ounces: lighter than’ the:
- Pet-Ritz and Bel Ait brasids; and sdld: at) ially:
lower prices. (D, Ex. A-85;R, 1065, 5827, 837-5838,
re .
- i
. * : .
~
< e Pog
588), ‘However, the. public ordinarily cuits. tell the aif.
. ference between various weights of 8 inch pies’ (R..879-.
880, 1108). ‘The purpose of. the Swiss Miss was to“. ...
t price competition without endangering the consumer _
| concept - of .Pet-Rifs quality’ (PL Ex. 61; R. 436, 602, _
2275, 2276). ‘The “price ‘competition’” which Pet had eS
‘mind was ‘‘., . the economy pie factor of the market, .
‘ and these ‘generally are the regional pie brands:.. .”’ (Re.
~. 1028, 1056). Although Pet-Rits had larger sales ‘volume
than Swiss Miss: nationally (PL .Ex.. 21; R. 235, 2161,
2165) Swiss Miss outsold Pet-Ritz almost 13 to.1.in Salt |
os Lakg in 1961 (PL Be. 2; RB. 487, 2328).
| * Ge Dinan Reman eines of Dae
“as Dr. Anderson, ireapedideiite’-"o0 Soueorion expert, put
| of ne | pricing as “tone of the i (R. .
Teh
) ev’ teway Contract Wan Andcompetie.
oS Although. both - Pet’s. Harsha and Safeway’s: cared
“< denied that Pet’s Bel Air con was a ‘requirements’
« contract (BR. 1040, 1148) it showed on its. face that ‘
was for a minimum of 1,000, “cases in 1960 (PL Ex:
“gps Ri 1041; 1064, 2226, 2228). ‘Pi qui |
" were’ showwnt as alimost 2,000,000 eases in an appendix to,
the. contract (B. 2236).: ‘The. contract stated ‘‘Seller agrees.
_ trinmabafantars: aneh_peck inveesordance with such ost
mates = - ih estat aaeenne eationes eee Pe:
ts of pies _—
deleted from a draft of. the contract a provision which
read “Tf seller’ is‘ unable to deliver the 2,000,000 case
quantity, buyer shall: have the right to procure supplies
oe other packers i in the amounts seller is unable to de-
r’?? (Pi. Ex. 42; RB. 1041, 1054, 2226, 2238).. In fact,
uy the exception’ of pumpkin and mince pies, Safeway
nevér: purchased Bel Air from: any supplier ‘other than .
Pet during. the life of the contract. (R. 1150).
. Dr. ‘Anderson agreed that if it turned out to be a fact :
_ that’ the Pet-Safeway contract for Bel Air pies. was a
total réfjhiréments contract, that would be a highly anti-
: competitive fact (BR. 1124-1125). . 3
7. Petitioner's Oase Against Carnation. ae
Carnation entered” the frozen pie business by acquiring
“Mrs, Lee’s Pies” in 1955 (R. 450). With that purchase,
. Carnation acquired the ‘‘Simple Simon’? label and two °
plants, one of which became Carnation’ s ‘Torraiice plant’
(R.. 1202). ‘Carnation’s 8-inch frozen fruit pies were the
Ne : same 24 ounce weight as Utah Pie’s (R..'1208).
Carnation had total saies of over $378,000,000. in 1958
* (PL Ex. 31; RB. 256, -2202). Its total sales increased in
~every year from 1958 to 1961 (Ibid.). Its smallest net |
‘profit before taxes in any of the years 1958-1960 was in
. excess of $18,000,000 (Ibid.):; “However, in the Pacific x
Northwest and Mountain States, where it. competed with
_- Utah Pie, Carnation’s Frozen Foods Division had net
> Josses.. {on ‘all frozen products, including pies) “before
, taxes in- 1959, 1960 and 1961 (Ibid.). —_ — for —
were not available (Ibid.). Sees *:
of ‘s
- ae
oe -
EES BRS
3
oe
Local SERMONS
’ Carnation pricing was on a delivered basis, by zones;
. it did not offer pies on an f.o.b. plant basis (R. 451, 453).
Carnation did‘ not : maizitain the same price within its - ; .
price zones; its price. within zones varied because, of the i
¢
“competitive situation” (R. 1173): Mae te
‘3: & Garnstion’s Price Discetmbintions : voce | =
_. During the damage period of this case, Carhation con- °
gistently charged lower prices in plaintiff’s trading area
than the prices. which it was charging in Northern. Cali-
’ fornia, an area of stable prices and- consistent profits.
_ (The exhibits showing. Carnation’ 8 prices are. Pl. Exs.
64; 65, 66 (B, 454, 2331, M68 and 2402) and Carnation’s
Exs.. C-B, -C-C, G-D, CE, and C-F (BR. 470, 5722-5766).
In order to gét, its pies from Los Angeles. to Salt Lake, eae
Carnation liad transportation expense of $.35 per dozen, s
35
lists: aa bis cedened yp “off the face of the. invoice” |
price-Feducing deals.**.
the true’ nature ‘of Getesticn® 8 Secctmiithins in ‘all
flavors, based on the evidence that “‘off- the. face”’ price -
- redtfetions are price cuts but that. ‘‘advertising: alow:
ances’’ are not, is ‘shown by the following table: —
——
- @
showed on the face of the invoices (R. 459-460). ‘Cabiation also
_. offered “advertising allowances” which, according to the -Mer-
chandise Manager of Carnation’s Frozen Foods Division were not
price cuts (R. ee
The Court of Appeals prepared a chart. (Appendix VH to its
opinion) which purports to set forth Carnation’s “absolute price”
for ‘apple flavor in various a It defined “absolute price” as
pacar #
_Bim nr Gout ot Appaale Appendix VE, iting the ori
Carnation’s price for apple flavor was lower in Salt Lake than else.
wee he ae a ee ee
months i 1961 (R.. 1518, 1524). s ws
36
CARNATION’S ACTUAL PRICE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN na
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA AND SALT LAKE ie
Caower Price in Utah) ake
< We. of days Price difference
from eo . (inclusive) ha Flavor
5: 1908 ee ; . auc : . “a :
, - Nov. 12-Dec. 81 GR dA - iG =
: |
#
-
:
E
"Nov. 12- Des. 81 gy
i
“Nov. 12-Dee. 81: - 50
wel: om
Rg
1
B
{INNA
‘Mar.7-May6. (641.
May9-June17 40
3 vay 11 Pely 1 ae
| uly 19- July 81 |
aed Rear 90. ai )
2 &
Be
*
8
Oct. 8-Nov."11
bie)
*
Se
Oi Jui 8 (81) 80
Ost. 12-Nov. 15: 35 :
Nov. 16- Jen. 16 (0) a dats
ot | Ste
19
boysenberry
ser
mince
pumpkin
pumpkin
ae Dee. 3:
ee 5D ; , mS os re ny
1
\
wv
;
i
fe +)
° § «6
mse a
‘
=
Cd
&
.
s
.
. 2 4 7.
> .
e : :
-
: Oe .
e .
.
: | 5 fe) %
‘ i °
a
-June§-Joly7 BBB
aly 10- Ang. 18 BS, gg ae
‘ee 21 - oo Ae
2
oh
imp
ee
Ang. 21-Sopt 29 40
FE
®
| see SSS, res ma xo so a
Carnation’ s Northern California list prices are shaw
. on its ‘‘Zone 1’’. price lists, Pl. Ex. 64; ‘RB. 454, 2331, et.
, , BON The. comparable price lists for Carnation’s ‘‘Zone 7
Hs 2,”? which includes Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Utah and ~
Montana are Pl. Ex. 65; RB. 454, 2368, et seq. Price lists .
Rani comparable time berets appear as follows}. elinc <:
>
£”
>
&
Se a Ee
$8 |
PriceZistMo. -° BifectiveDete: .- Zonel” ~ == Zone®
412 .-. Nov.3,1959 ©. B.2348 - RB. 2383
_ 12a Feb. 1,190 -B.2349 00 = ——
2B May 11,1960 R.2350' K.238 ~~
- 138A July 19,1960 - R.2351 B.2386.. °
13B°- July 25, 1960 ee
14... Oct. 1, 1960 R. 2352 BR. 2389
144A —«- Oct. 7,1960 —=—ss«&BR. 2854 —
144A —* Oct. 12,1980 = ——_—sé#B 23911
14A Nov..16, 1960. R. 2355 —
-15.° Jan. 16, 1961 R. 2358 RB. 2394
15A Feb: 6,1961 -B.23859.
1616A . Apr.17,1961- B.2360 RB. 2396
6B May 8, 1961 R.2398
17. Aug. 21, 1961 B. 2361. B,2400
The Northern California ‘‘deals”” are summarized in.
D. Ex. CE; R.. 470, 5748. The last ‘‘off the face’’.
(0. F”): price cut in that area (ie. reduction of Zone 1.
price): ‘endéd December 31, 1958 R. 5751. But ‘‘off the
- faeé’’ price reductions from the Zone .2 price lists -in
‘Sale Lake were a regular occurrence through 1961 D.
Ex. C-F;.R. 470, ‘5760-5766. Carnation also. had sub-
: stantial “off the, face’’ reductions from. Zone 2 prices
in Spokane, often coupled with ‘‘merchandising”’. allow-
ances D. Ex. C-B; “R. 470, 5722-5728). oes Boxe,
<Oatnation’s two largest selling flavors in Salt Lake |
_ were apple and cherry, in that order. (D. Ex. C-0; R.
1163, 5775; D: Ex.’ A-35; R. 1065, 5827, 5829-5832). The
“persistence *of Carnation’s discriminatory pricing, par-
5. sieiilarty' im those two pl is — by the following
. .: . i . ‘
: eee 39
, - “ ; -
ee
IN ALT LAKE WAS BELOW ITS ACTUAL PRIOR.
IN NORTHERN: CALIFORNIA eas
ieee “ Ymtberof Days ce
Flavor . 1960 ~~ 1960 4961s
‘Apple. ° 3600 ggg ie eggs
Cherry MOR BOS agg 255 &
Peach 80 ag 255
Boysenberry 50° 114 (9.
- Pumpkin « 60 23. BB
ae ~— Minee 50- 201 B:
- ‘Sof 272 pl prior to September 29, 1961, ;
Eas The discriminations shown in the jectaaians tables. pat
" . largely - the result’ of ‘‘off the, face’? (‘‘O.F.”?).. deals my
Salt Lake (D. Ex. C-F; BR. ‘470, 5760-5766). List prices. ae
were usually the same’ in Northern California and in
. Oregon, | Washington, Idaho, ‘Utah and Montana, particu- :
larly on the ‘apple, cherry and peach .flavors (see. table
of ‘comparable price lists, supra). As previously shown,
> last ‘‘off the face’’ deal in Northern California was in
: 1958. (D. Ex. C-B; BR. 470, 5722, 5751-5759). Consequently,
‘the only time Carnation ever had 9 ‘‘natural’’ discrimina- =~
tion with the difference in price reflecting the difference - ‘ ~
. in cogf, was in the very rare instance in which the Salt.
Lake list price; less an ‘‘off the face’ deal, if any, still
exceeded the Northern California’ list price.’. ©. -:
‘Carnation’ 8 price: ' discriminations between Nérthera
as California “and Salt Lake ‘City’ were largely the result of ie
"local ‘off the face” reductions from ‘Carnation’s- “Zone
_ 2” pricé lists (PL Ex. 65; R. 454, 2368) not matched ‘by:
any ‘‘off the face” price reductions from Carnation’s 5.
J
’ . gubstantially identical base’ ‘price list covering Northern
California (PL Ex.’ 64; R, 454, 2831), as shown sbove :
© (compare D. Ex. C-E; RB. 470, 5748 with D. Ex. 0-F; R.
470, 5760). = ; oo S
.. But in October, 1959, Carnation ‘published a uetaruts es
price list for Colotado (PL Ex. 65; R. 454, 2368, 2382):
: In May; 1960, it published a separate price list for Wyo- Sis
. Ting and Colorado’ in Zone 2A. (Pl. Ex. 65; R. 454,
2368, 2385). Its July, 1960, price list di¥erged from the
Bs: price list. published on the same date for Oregon, Wash-
4 ington, Idaho, Utah and Montana (compare R. 2387 with
R. 2388. Pl. Ex. 65; R. 454, 2368). Thereafter, the sep- |
arate. treatment of ‘Colorado and Wyoming ‘was main-
tained throughout the relevant period of this lawsuit
~ (Gompare RB, 2387 with:R. 2390;.B. 2391 with R. 2392;
R, 2394 with R. 2395; BR. 2396 with R. 2397; R. 2398 with
R. 2399; R. 2400 with R. 2401, Thid.). This resulted, at.
one point, in a discrimination in list price between North-
em California (high) 2 and Colorado and Wyoming. (low):
of $.58 per case on apple, peach and cherry pies (Ibid.).
- Since there were no price-reducing offethe-face ‘‘deals’’
in effect in Northern. California at the time, the price —
7 ists lone showed ininimum diatrimination of $.58 pe
ease’ on ‘those flavors. ~ ent ited ?
A b Oarastion's Saleen A Masi
’ here; can, be no doubt that. ireaiige actually =
; ‘sales. _ot. its “various: quoted prices . throughout. the por-
Z ic mn of the. United States-in which it was offering frozen’
. Plies pies for sale. Pl. Bx. 6 (R, 449, 1829, et seq.) is a series.
7 of Carnation’s i ahi hice and. loss” statements, ce
pies in the thousands and tens of ‘thousands of cases”
which bear ménthly summaty of ‘sales volumes, by” -
\- area, in’ the upper right-hand corner, broken, down by
\, type of: product, They show consistent sales.of 8” fruit
for substantially every month of 1959 through 1961, in:
elusive, in the Southern ‘California area, the Northern
California area and the Pacific Northwest and Mountain *
: States area (Pl. Ex. 6; Bs 449, 1829). .: oe
~ Carnation’s sales in all areas’ were the sash of ex-
tensive exposition by Carnation’ s ‘‘sales manager for the.
| West’” (R. 1189-1194). Carnation’s sales in’ Salt Lake ‘
were shown in two (inconsigtent)’ exhibits offered by re-
_ spondents (D. Ex. C0; RB. 1163, 5775; D., Ex. A-35;. R.
. 1065, 5827; compare R. 5175-5176 with Be 5829-5832),
C. Oarnstion’s Sales Were at a Loes Planned in. Advance,
Carnation’s sales of frozen fruit: ‘pies in Salt Lake in |
-1960,. resulted i in losses ranging up to $84’ per dozen on
a sales price. averaging $3.04 per dozen ‘(P1.° Ex. 28; R.
561, 2184, 2185). In Salt Lake, Carnation’ 8 frozen: pies
"generally. sold’ at a loss throughout the Years 1959, 1960 |
and 1961 (Ibig.). | . be
During the: same period, vai nt arnation ae oe eee
profits in its Frozen Food, Division in Northern | Cali-
* fornia “and. the Western Division as 8 whole, (PL Ex, 22;
«B.A, 2167, 2168)..; z eo As
: Carnation forecast its Sesieg in oe intermountain area j
Seth Pl Ex. 5; RB. 446, 1 B),
-
-@ .
Division (R. 442). But the ‘merchandising ‘iinnnigte”” was
himself oblivious to. the fact that the Carnation Frozen.
Foods Committee .was . planning lossés ‘in his area; he
‘said *** *'* it’s not my responsibility’” (R. 1179-1180). age"
The responsibility for .approving. Carnation’s programs
' for. selling at a loss “would be the frozen food commit-
tee’? (R. 1180). That’ committee ‘was originally organ-
_ ; ized as a management committee of the executive com- .
' mittee of the board”’ (R. 1197; see’ also Pl. Ex. 69; RB.
* 458, 2512; PL Ex. 70; R. 458, 2517; Pl. Ex. 71; R. 458,
- 2522; Pl. Ex. 72; RB. 458, 2524; PL Ex. 73; R. 458, 2526;
| PL Ex. 74; R. 458, 2527).
‘Carnation’ s ‘‘Sales. Manager for thé West’’ was like-
_. Wise oblivious to the fact that sales in his area were
sales below cost (RB. 1194-1195). He did fot know. who
- the man was in the Carnation organization who fixed
Carnation’ 8 gales price” (BR. 1194).
Carnation management was not oblivious, however, to .
- the’ tax corisequences of its losses on ‘frozen pies in the
context of 4 generally profitable corporation. The budg-
. ets. of Carnation’ s Frozen Foods Division contained an |
‘item called ‘‘ reserve for income tax’’ which reduced’ the
ee Division’s , losses approximately the Bony f of the
ue corporation’ s tax benefit ‘to arrive at “net profit. after
’ tax.?? (PL Ex. 5; R.. 446, 1656, 1670, 1686, 1688, 1694,
1700, 1707, 1725, 1729, 1736, 1740,. 1750, 1754, 1758, 1763,
: ‘1164, eee ere, 1774, aioe — 1786, 1792, 1816, 1820,
a aoalapit VE |
uy Ef i 5 1959 profit ef loss projections. can be
| — in tabular form: 08, follows:
+. °
»*
’ Spee 6
Sa
43
i Profit Areas sider | tamara y g
_ Southern Calif. $ 96,448 Mountain States . ($12,048) : -
Northern Calif. 81,508. Pacific Noxthivest ( 18,229)
Ari ali ie 8,816 — Mex PRE LESeds he at
- $181,272 . ($25,877) ©
3 “(PL Ex, 5; R 46, 1656, 1663)
In comparing actual results (as: opposed” to. Dndget
projections) of. profit and loss, it can be seen that Car-
‘ nation had consistent losses in its Frozen Foods, Division
JM} eee >|
GN $ yh ity a Lit © ,
im the Pacific Northwest and Mountain States territory,
but consistent high profits in the, Northern ‘California
- tertitory;(Pl. Ex. 22; R. Al, 2167, 2168)., These profits —
atid losses: ‘may be represented in tabular.. ome to, the
.- | nearest dollar, as follows: sah t's
Morthern California ; Pac. W. W. & Mountain States
1959 $4976 | 6 16,54R)
1960 123,017 (, 78,245) ~
Tic Wd, occ ee
‘Total 5. $252,554 ° ($141,413),
-. ’. Doctor Anderson, respondents yonomics- expert, testi-:
. fied that sales by a large. cor Np i aR
_ giopal market, where that loss’ was nlanned in advance,
would be evidence of some ulterior motive (BR. 1122-
1124). He also testified that if a company sold ‘at’ lower.
- prices 750 miles from its plant than it did at ‘the plant —
- door that it indicated “Jess than perfect pricing” and -
3 ‘was ‘unnatural’ (R. 1130). He further testified that the -
| Brice decline in petitioner’ s trading’ area, might, have
been the result of predatory pricing As “one, of. ‘the a
poesibiliti ” of tip-ttls).
‘dpa ‘Continental entered. the‘ frozen food busi-
— by acquiring the Morton Packing Company on No- ,
\.. vember 30, 1955 CR. 271, 274). In the years 1958 through
4 > $964; -Continental had total net gales in excess of one
5 Aare and one-half billion dollars (Pl. Ex. 31; R 256, 2202).Its °
total net. profit before taxes was almost ‘setenty-five mil- -
‘Tion dollars (Ibid.).: By any. index, Continental’s “Mor-
‘ton’ was one of the two largest selling brands of frozen —
eas fruit pies”in the United States (Pl. Ex. 61; R. 437, 602,
‘B . 72275; R. 274). Fruit pies were just a part of the broad
eS “Morton” line ‘of frozen products (R. 71-72, 274, 649).
~e ; Continental’s “Morton?” brand was well known in Salt
%and over the years covéred by the complaint, Mor-' oe
ton. was a~<‘price leader,’’ affecting the market price
_ even on: small volume (R. 804-807).- Its 1961 Price cuts eae
» Salt Lake increased its volume-773% over the average wf
the three preceding years (D. Ex. A-35; R.: 1065, 5827,
829-5832). . . ¥
Continental’s gross ales of biciiie foods in “certain:
western states, (Regions VII and VIII through | 1960 and
* Wal thereafter) ‘(R. 242-245 ; Pl. Ex. 28; R. 245, 2175)
: were. “lightly i in | of three million dollars for the”
years 1958 through , but there was & $12, 500 loss
instead ofa profit (PL Bx. 81; R. 256, 2202). :
‘Respondent Continental’s frozen ei pies . ee sale |
’ - thronghout: the United States were made in just three _ is
plants: Crozet, Virginia, Webster City, Tows, tid (afte ~—
February 1961) iby ‘a contract packer in Watacnville, |
@alifornia ‘(R. 11, “72, 762-763 ; ‘Pl. Ex. 18; RB. 121, 2184).
Continental shipped f ‘frozen fruit pies Jong distances back .
| and forth across the continent fiom time’; time’ (R: 7 ;
73, 266, 532-534). Salt Lake was the ‘midway ‘point’ —
na te tg |
me esmstonis: wecser a ie) stairs AOL
cae Continental’s Morton Pic.
In. 1961, Continental was saling 0, 22-cunce pple pie
to buyers in Salt Lake for $2.55-per dozen (PL Ex. 14;
R. 114, 2057). At tlie same time, it was offering Safeway
a 24-ounce apple pie at $3.10 per dozen (R- 100-101). The *-
» difference .in the cost, of. Beptaction,. was P-) to = cénts .
| per dozen (R 122). ° ae
‘ Kitchin, vice-president i in charge of Continental’s f rial
_* pie production: testified that on inspection of 22 and 24-
* ounce pies, “obviously the pies appear: to look the same’’
(RB, 289). He was eorroborated by Halvarson, Morton’s
aig regional sales manager, who agreed that the only dif-
ference in appearance was that the 22-ounce pan had a
slightly sharper slant, very difficult to discern (R. 680).
There was, testimony’ that on the retail level most con-.
sumers cannot tell the difference between a 20-ounce, a
22-ounce and a 24-ounce pie (R. 678, 879-880, 1103). ‘Pet’s
: 20-ounce Swiss Miss sold at. wholesale and at retail prices
. higher than those of heavier competing pies (R. 167-168,
682, 702-708, 824-827, 1103; ‘D. Ex. .A-35; R. 1065, 5827,
5841, 5843). In- preparing his. market share study, re- fe
_spondents’ economics expert concluded. that, “consumers —
buy pie. as pie and not’ by the ourtve”? (R. 1108),
. Nevertheless, ‘0s’ Qoutt. ofAgiosble/vlewsd ‘the prions
of the 22-ounce Morton pie ‘on CeSeren omnes’? basis.
(R. revit Se
. =
w + ) = &
, ' 8
. . ‘
° : ;
d. Continental’s Marketing System. EW “aks
~ Continental refused 40 quote prices f.o.b. its plantas it
: aia a zone delivered price system with various qevi- |
: ations ‘between renewed _ ‘within ‘its zone (R. B,
©. 780). ‘ye |
. ‘, Continental ‘gla its. ‘orton: te ie foods thromeh *
: brokers (R. 649). The brokers were paid on a confinission :
basis, based on sales volume, not profits: (Pl. Ex. 19; R.
"4 132; 9158). “Moreover, Halvarson, Continental’s sales man-
- Sager respensible for dealing with brokers, was paid a
-.. bonus to increase sales volunie" without regard. to whether
‘e the sales were at a profit or at a loss,’ and he did. not.
know whether the ‘sales he made were e profitable to Con-
: tinental or not (R: 275-276, 687). ..
ee - Céiitinental’s broker in Salt Lake’ as of September 26,
1960 was ‘Stanley Chapman (Pl. Ex. 19; R. 132, 2158).
-He. testified that he. was. contacted, by Halvarson, Fe-
; gional, sales manager for Continental ‘about two weeks, |
ten days, it might have even been a week”’ (R. 150) after
-@ telephone conversation *in which he had told Gaylen
- Rigby, Utah Pie’s sales ‘manager, that. ‘the was going to wa
- obtain another frozen pie account, one that was a national
brand; that he was going to get .. . Utah Pie.” (R. 560:
~ Compare R. 149). Hatvarson placed the date on which
he contacted Chapman as October 14, 1960 (R. 660). The
letter by which:Chapman was appointed, however, showed
that he had actually: been hired by Morton on September
+ 26, 1960, prior to that conversation, and. prior. to his ~
threatening conversation with Gaylen Rigby as 559-560;
Ex. 19; iuaiuaiae
a
Saji eel edi id iting
promotional allowance on Morton. frozen pies (R.. :661,.
679).° About eight months later, Continental took ‘(Chap-.
Tan’s recommendation to cut its apple pie price to-$2.55- ae
per dozen, plus freight, for its Salt Lake. customers. (RB.
674-675). This price was Continental’s lowest price any- *
"where, and the lowest price Salt, Lake had ever seen (R.
670-671, 727; D. Ex. A-35; R. 1065, 5827). Continental’s
ES avowed purpose was to get.new business, not keep an _
existing customer (R. 675). The $2.55 offer was first
made ‘in mid-June of 1961 (Pl. Ex. 15; BR. 104, 2061)..It .
‘was renewed effective. July 31, expiring on eT - _— ;
. Sass R. 113, 2062, 2067): “ {ate
‘Safeway bought two shipments of Morton pies; when
Safeway ran out of the first shipment of pies it bought on :
- the second shipment, and spent a “three or 60 wets
running through that shipment . (R. 695-696).
offer was in effect more er less continuously from — :
16.through August 12, 1961 (see Pl. Ex. 14; R. 114, 2057;
PL Ex. 15; B. 104, 2061; Pl. Ex. 16; R. 113, 2062, 2067).
Continental’s. sales in Salt Lake at $2.55 per dozen
- “were not only lower than any -previous price of any _.
seller, but $1.45 per dozen lower. than .a contentporaneous .
- gale’ of: 1800 dozen apple pies. to Fox’ Markets in Los‘ ©
Angeles, California (Pl. Ex. 10; R. 80, 2052). One day ~
prior to the sale to Fox Markets (at $4 per dozen) Con- .
tinental sold 550 dozen apple pies in -Ogden, Utah for
. $2.59 per. dozen and 25 dozen apple - pies in Seattle. for . .
” $3.50 per-dozen (Pl. Ex. 10; R. 90, 2052; Pl. Ex. 11; R.
91, 2054; Pl. Hx.'12; R. 81, 2055; B.’79-81).
= “a -«
° 2}
.
Ad e
9
“10m July 20, 1961, Continental sold apple pies in Oak- »
" Jatid, California, at $3.76 per dozen (PL Ex. 13; R. 84, |
2056). ‘Oakland is 90 to 100. miles from Centinental’s
- * Watsonville plant (R. 84). Eight days: later, Continental
s6ld: 1,000 dozen apple pies to Grocers ‘Wholesale i in Salt
Lake at:$2.55 per dozen, freight prepaid (PL. Ex. 145 R.
114, 2057). Although Continental’ produced “testimony to”
the effect that the “*PPD”’ notations on some of its $2.55
‘apple: pie . invoices “were in “error,” it is undisputed
_that any Salt Lake buyer could have a ‘‘nickup allow-
~ ance’? of 30 cents per dozen,’ ‘yesulting. i in a price of $2.55
*. fo.b, Watsonville, California; for Salt Lake buyers (R.
626-627 ). The freight from Continental,’s California plant ...
to Ogden, Utah was $.30 per dozen (R. 86, 668).
C Ocutinental Engaged in Significant and Sustained Price Discimins
tion in Plaintiff's Trading Area.
: Prior to 1961, Continental sold relatively few, Morton.
pies in Salt Lake’ City (Pl. Ex. 110; R. 623, 4705; D. Ex.
7 a sai -35; R. 1065, 5827, 5829-5831). It did, however, sell
substantial quantities throughout other important parts
_. Of ‘petitioner’ s trading area (see Denver invoices, Pl. Exs.
oT 83 and 89; R. 536-537, 2625 ; Pl. Ex. 78; R. 536-537, -
* Pl, Ex. 79; R. 536-537, 2987; Pl. Ex. 80; R. 536-537, ;
366+ PL Ex, 83; R. 588, 3617; PL Ex. 89; R.-542, 4405;
“Washington ‘invoices, Pl. Exs. 84.87; R. 538, 3618; PI.-Ex..
* 85; R. 588, 3796; Pl. Ex. 86; R. 538, 3984; Pl. Ex. 87; R. -
| 538, 4188; Oregon invoices, Pl. Ex. 88; R. 542, 4373).
= There were substantial and continuing didtrtnitinktions
in the prices: which Continental charged for its Morton
pies in Denver, = after Utah Pie’s initial suc- |
cats in ealtag «Frost ‘N Flame” pie théve in the fll of”
1959. From a price of $5.16 per dozen for apple pies ‘in:
October’, 1958, and $3.93 in May, 1959, ntinental’s price
descended to $3.65 per dozen in December, 1959 (R. 542;
Pl. Ex. 89; B. 542, 4405). In February 1960, apple pie
| ‘was as low as $3.35 and in October 1960, it was down to. |
$3.20 (R. 542). In June 1961, Continental’s Morton apple -
pie went as low os $3.00 in Denver (Ibid.). At that time,
Morton apple pie was selling for some $4.00 per dozen in .
Los Angeles’ (Pl. Ex. 10; R. 80, 2052). Continental’s
. Morton’? was one of the two largest selling brands in:
| Denver (B..752), :
In Ja anuary 1960, Morton apple a pela in Crozét,
Virginia, was selling at $3.35 per dozen in Denver, freight
- prepaid by the seller (R. 534). At that time, Continental’s *
Morton apple pie was selling for $3.80 per dozen in. Vir-
ginia, where the plant was located: (ibid).
Some of the pies which Continental sold in Deriver were
produced at its Crozet, Virginia, plant, others were Pro;
duced at its Webster City, Iowa, plant (R. 534; Pl. Ex.
- 83; RB. 533, 3617). Petitioner had a freight advantage on
sales in Denver over Continental with respect to Con- |
tinental’s: plants in — Towa Pale a (R.
541). - Fi: wie
_ Utah. Pie introduced evidence on Continental’ frozen 3
pie sales .in Denver, Oregon and Washington (Denver—
Pl. Ex. 77; R. 536-537, . 2625; PL Ex: 78; R. 536-537, |
2773; Pl. Ex. 79; R. 536-537, 2987 ; Pl. Ex. 80; R. 536-
§87, 3855; Pl. Ex. 83;.R. 533, 8617; Pl. Ex. 89; BR. 542, ©
- 4405; 5; Washington—Pl. Ex. 84} R. 538, 3618; PL Ex. 85;
. ° °
. a
° 9 50
- . ae
BR. 638, 3796; Pl. Ex. 86; B. 538, 3984; PL Ex. 87; R.
_ $98, 4188; Oregon—Pl. Ex. 88; R. 542; 4873). :
. Utah Pie. submitted damage exhibits claiming damages
for all ‘of those areas ag against. Continental. (Pl. Ex. 95;
_ -B. 574, 4591; PL Ex. 97; R. 581, 4598; ‘Pl Ex.'98; R. |
583, 4600). | |
Except for Utah Pie’s claim agua: Pet for loss of .
Safeway Bel: Air business in‘ the Denver Division of
‘Safeway (PL Ex. 95; R. 574,-4591; PL Ex. 99; R. 584,
4602) Utah Pie’s entire Denver claim was against Con-
" tinental (PL Ex. 95; R. ne Pl. Ex. 98; fe 583, .
“Coded for ‘Utah Pie arieeed his contentions with
respect, to Denver, Oregon and Washington at length (R.
1236, 1238, 1269, 1271, 1275, 1276, 1342, 1343). Conti-
nental counsél also made reference to those. areas in his
- argument: to the jury (R. 1291, 1293). He- said ‘‘And
then there have been charges against: Morton in the Den-
ver market...’ and proceeded to > discuss, them at length
(BR 1298).
PL Ex. 111 was used by ssintinlinia” ‘eeke aceounting ex-
: pert in preparing certain charts, and was identified as
having | been prepared by Continental counsel from Mor-
“ton price’ lists and deals (R. 627, 629, 4707). It shows &
~ persistent pattern of discriminatory Bris with Denver
as the stig area:
April 20-Nov. 1 $1.7714 $1.95 1it%e¢
Nov. 2-Nov. 14 1.62%, 1.95 B216¢
Nov. 15-Dec. 31 LITY¥ "196 — 17144
. 3 eee High Price 3
Jan. 1-31 $1.80 $1.95 15¢
! L.A. & Ariz. .
Feb. 2-13 165 — 1.95 30¢
L.A. & Ariz. |
Feb. 14-28 1.80 1.95 15¢
- Aris
Feb. 29-Mar. 27 1.65 (195° 30¢-
Mar. 27-April 3 . 180 | 1.95 15¢
May 2-May 14 1.65 ' L.79% 1
y 2-May Avis & GF. : 444
May 30-June 18 1.65 1.79% ~ 1
July 4-Dee, 31 1,60-1.80 1974, = =—«-_- 1T%-3 Te
Arizona ;
1961 ‘
Jan. 1-May 29 - $1.50-1.821, $2.00 _ 1DA4-50¢
June 5-June 17 Lap OCT ee 15¢
+ June 30-Aug. 13 1.50-1.8244 - . 2,00 —— 1TYe-50¢ en
_ Aug. 14-Sept. 3 182% - 2,00 17
time
(Pt Be. 111) & a, e9, e707
a
See
“While not as clear ab PEE. 111 chicka: the record
_ contains only a few California invoices) the Continental’
invoices also show a discriminatory: low price pattern’ in .
Salt Lake and Denver as compared with Seattle and —
other distant parts of Utah Pie’s trading area. A table
of such discriminations, baséd upon actual sales reflected
in Continental invoices is attnened as. } Seems C to
this brief. - es stg
| Continental’s ' ‘own Witnesees.. and exhibite make re-
: peated references to Denver. (See R, 643, 650, 655; D. Ex..
M. 26; R.: 684, 5454). Continental produced a Denver wit-
ness ‘at the trial to testify about Utah Pie’s marketing _
efforts. there, and general ‘market . conditions in that city :
(R. 742-761). ecigapk
Nevertheless, the Court of Appeals held that all
tioner’s judgment may not be sustained. in = part =
Ze reference to. the Denver market: .
. “It isa theory clearly not submitted to the jury
, by the court in its. charge, nor passed.on by the jury”’
(. 1505). ete
a The Bvidence Showed That Ocatinental Intended to Injure Plaintifl.
Continental’s ‘discriminatory low prices were aimed di- .
rectly at Utah Pie; Morton’ 8 ‘vice-president in charge of
production, admitted it on the stand (R.. 69, 86, 121), So.
did Morton’s regional sales manager; he had said that
Morton’s loWest price | in ‘Salt Lake ‘‘was aimed at him
[Utah Pie] as a’ competitor to get business in his cus- —
tomers’ account”’ (BR. 648, 671).
_ Gontinental’s $2.55 ‘price for a dozen apple pies in June -
‘of 1961 v was below even the bare -cost of pees, sale
fo
58
sell ditecs RR: Ana 00; Ri 268,. 2187). Making allow-
“ances for Continental’s other costs, there were losses con-
tinuously from late 1958 -on Continental’s frozen pie sales
‘in the Salf Lake area (PL Ex. 29; B. 268, 2187; see: also
B, 127, 246, 636-642, 673). ;
Continental lost money overall on its frozen food oper--
. ations for the four years 1958-1961 in: the Regions where
it competed with Utah Pie (PL Ex. 31; R. 256, (2202).
Hereford, general accounting manager of the Morton S
Division of Continental, identified respondent’ . exhibits *
M-25 (R, .634, 5453) and M-26 (R. 634, 5454) which pur-
port: to show that Continental’s frozen pie sales in Utah: _
and Idaho were profitable (R. 634), He testified, however,
that if Continental’s costs had been allocated in those ex- -
‘hibits on the. ‘same basis which Contjnental used for its. .
own internal purposes, . there would be a loss (R. 639. A
640). Hereford testified that if Continental’s whole . busi-
néss showed ‘‘ gross profits’? like -those in its pie oper
tion,-it would be bankrupt (R. 640-641).
However, the Court of Appeals adopted as its own, ‘ond.
appended to. opinion as Appendix VI, a ‘chart substan-
‘tially identical to Continental ’s exhibit M-22, purporting
to show Continental’s $2.55 price was above. cost. ( Com-
pare R. 1522 with D. Ex. M-22; R. 643, 5450). :
The Court of Appeals summarized its ‘saalyais a8 bh
lows :
“Invoices of sales of Seidl pies sh: Cantina in
the Salt: ‘Lake City market during the. ‘period 1958 to
January, 1962, inclusive, showed 142 items were sold Ve
ata + Profit and three — one in aS, one in ne
” ‘
~
. °
; 54 y , .
‘ ° a9 . .
42 and: are January, 1962, at's loss, before allocation:
~ of overhead costs. Its. over-all sales. showed a profit —
before deduction of overhead. After such allocation,
an ‘overall loss was reflected. Had Continental been
able to develop & substantial volume of sales in such
"market, it no doubt would: have been able to realize “
a profit after overhead was charged.’”’ (R. 1483).
9. a Ties Rampombade’ Oe |
tions Had an Injurious Impact Upon Utah Pie. ote
- Utah Pic claimed injuries of three sorts:
(1) loss \of profits due to depressed, prices; (2) loss of
profits due to- reduced volume; and (8) injury to the good
will value of its business (PL Ex. 95; BR. 574, 4591). Dtah
Pie demonstrated that respondents’ activities had driven
frozen pie prices down sharply in the period after it en-
tered the business (See Pl. Ex. 4; ‘R. 67, 1530; Pl. Ex. 98;
~ 'R. 552, 4587; D. Ex, A-35; RB. 1065, 5827). Utah Pie ‘dem-
onstrated that in spite of its uniquely Sdvantageous :
location, its high quality product and its modern and
- efficient plant, its market share had diminished drasti-
" v qally (PL Ex. 96; B. 581, 4592): Unchallenged testimony -
aiso-proved « diminution in'the good will value of Utah
iness of $75,000 (R. 570). Although the evidence —
1961 (PL. Ex. 92; -R.'551, 4586), the jury :
asked to find that Ats growth: would have ‘been substan-
». tially greater in = of respondents’ oe dis-
criminations At Kei ings ' ‘
<e
55
a “ho Bvidence Showed ‘ont Petitioner's Price, Were Driven Down.
* The decline in prices which petitioner ‘realized | on its
pies is clearly demonstrated for the immediate Salt Lake’ é
area by the study prepared by Dr. Anderson, respondents’
economies*expert (D. Ex. A-35; R. 1065, 5827). His study
shows a. decline in the. average price which petitioner re-
ceived ‘for Utah brand apple pie from $2.15. ‘per case —
, ($4.30 per dozen) in February of 1958 to $1.60 per case
($3.20 per dozen) in’ August of 1961 (Pl. Ex. 93; R. 552, :
. 4587; D. Ex. A-35; RB. 1065, 5827, 5835-5836 “price”), a
decline of about 26%.
~ The picture for Utah Pie’s centize siatteatinin area Was.
very similar to that shown by Dr. Anderson’s more lim-"
ited study of the Salt Lake-Boise area ide Ex. 4; R. 67-°
69, 1530). ays z
Utah Pie ppostiited to the jury daniage charts setting
_ forth the amounts of’ damages which they asked the jury.
‘ to find, predicated upon. the jury’s. determining prices —
: __Which would have prevailed in plaintiff’s trading area but
for respondents’ price discriminations (PI. Ex. 95; RB. 574, -
| 4591; Pl. Ex. 96; R. 581, 4592; PL. Ex. 97; R. 581, 4598;
PL Ex. 98; R. 583, 4600; Pl. Ex. 99; ‘R. 584, 4602; Pl. Ex.
100; R. 585, 4604; PL Ex. 101; R. 586, 4606) .
"nai was direct testimony by a “defense witness that -
- in the absence of. respondents’ price reductions, ‘the price
level.in the market would have stayed about $3. 70:
- $Q. ‘Now, Mr..Degenhardt, assume for. me, if you
- will,” that none of the three defendants’. prices had
changed in the Salt Lake City market from 4957 on,
that they stood ‘at the ’57 price; would the a ites
«sh .
in ihe market have stayed at $3.70 or above per ee
| <i dozen? te Mag
A I would say 80, yes.’’. (R. 125)”
be the Bridence Showed That Petitioner's Market Share Dectined.
In addition to damages regulting from an erosion of the
~~
prices which it was able to obtain. for its products, sen
4 _. tioner suffered a very substantial loss of business.
, Petitioner’ s share ‘of the market for ‘advertised’?
7 brand pies (i.e., other than private label) declitied dra-
. matically from 1958 to 1961 (Pl. Ex. 96; R. 581, ' 4592).
Starting with 70.41% of petitioner’ s and respondents’
total sales in 1958, Utah Pie dropped steadily each year
to 33.64% in: 1961 (Ibid.). By contrast every one ‘of the
respondents’ shares increased; Pet moved up steadily
__ ftom 17.32% in 1958, to’ 37.94% (and the largest seller’ of
~ advertised brands in-the market) in 1961. ‘(Ibid.).
Shown graphically, pétitioner’s market share in the im-
mediate Salt Lake City area for its advertised TO was
as follows:
"Utah Pie 3
~ 1958 - 70.41%
MR s - 58.69%
7 ees e
Ma A OGL, | 33.64%
(Soares: Pl. Ex. 96; ‘R. 581, 4592)
Dr. Anderson, respondents’ economics expert (R. 1059,
1087), testified that he was ‘‘certain’’ that there is a stis-
" tinetion between enjoying 8 brand business as against a
B aeacd’ brand business and that a substantial, loss of
snide share: ‘by an independent of it of its ‘brand prodnet
“could be’’ a competitive injury (RB. 1148-1119), although -
he contended that the. ‘‘Swiss Miss’’ market share could ©
‘. not properly be compared with the marketshare of peti- pee
tioner’s ‘‘Utah Pie’ brand (R. 1119).
; " Considering sales of all brands sisting private labels
_and brands of sellers “other” than parties to the law- -
suit, petitioner’s marketshare of the immediate Salt Lake
City area’was as follows: bel
; Utah Pie a
: wae: G 66.5%
PMS i 5 84.4%
1960 | B96
Pe Gee ae
(Computed from-R], Ex. 62; aps
RB, 437, 2823.) a)
Halgren, vieo-president of Caidiadica: testified :
. _ “Inereasing distribution doesn’t necessarily mean
a - increasing sales, and it doesn’t mean by any. means
: that you are keeping pace with the market. Some-
tinies the market grows from 100,000 to 200,000 cases -.
in a single year. If you don’t grow with that, you are
“not getting your share.’’ (R. 1220-1221; emphasis
en : : are
‘es The Jury Verdicts Were Well Within the Evidence )
Petitioner’ s damage calculations as to Pet would have
supported a verdict for $261,046 actual damages (PI. Ex..
95: R. 574, 4591). In fact, the jury returned a verdict of —
* | eg ‘.*
"\4
. °
- 58 : ‘ig
: .
44,197, well within the damages - -shown by the evidence.
against Pet (R 41, 1406).
Petitioner’ 8 damage. calculations would have seni’
re verdict of $381,197 against Continental (Pl. Ex. 95; R. _
- 574, 4591). In fact, the jury‘returned a verdict of $24, 994
(BR. 41, 1405-1406). ‘
~ Petitioner’s damage calculations woul have supported
a verdict for $98,892 against Carnation (PL Ex. 95; R.
- 574, 4591). In fact, the jury asuen a verdict of —
> ™ ae
ae oe CU ee
- Shoe Co. v. United States, 370 US.
Ts MNB1506. _eilalpoiitne tains
° - ~
* : toy « ‘
hin . <
ith: od e :
Why ‘ -
SER —
as. SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT’ nthed
i heads ten ectault line prive-discrimination cases in _
which Utah Pie kad damage verdicts against the three
respondents for their regional price-cutting j in Utah Pie’s oe
trading area (R. 41-42, 1405-1406). -
The Court of Appeals set aside the verdict’ « on the sole
: ground that Utah. Pie’s evidence was insufficient to show |
that any of the respondents . by price differences: or .
other acts, had diahatnndiehiiy nana competition, or
tended: to create .a. monopoly, -or injured, destroyed, . or
. prevented competition with it in the Salt Lake City mar-
. ket, or, that there was a reasonable possibility that ;
[respondent], by price differences or other acts, woulddo . *:
so in the future. . ...”’ (B. 1502;. 1504, 1507).
The J udgment of the Court of Appeals remanded the
ease ‘{. . . with instructions to enter — for _ the
defendants’ (R. 1526). 2 oo
In reaching that conclusion, the Court of Appéals as
completely misconceived the ‘‘incipiency’™ test. which is
embodied in Section 2(a) of the-Clayton Act as amended
by the Robinson-Patman -Aet. Sections 2, 3 and 7 of the
Clayton Act outlaw certain trade practices where their
- effect ‘‘may be te substantially lessen
- tend to create a monopoly. .. .’’ This a j
substantially the same ear all three s
, 294, 329, 82 S.Ct. -
In testing the likely effect of respondent’s price discrim- .
i inations, the * Clayton Act decisions of ‘this Court: are | |
‘controlling. ‘They. include, among many others, such cases.
ae *- ae i ee
as United States v. Pabst Brewing Co., 384 U.S. 546, 86
S.Ct. 1665; United States. v. Von’s Grocery Co., 384 U.S.
270, 86 S.Ct. 1478; International Saji Co. v. United: States,
~ 332 U.S: 392, 68 S.Ct. 12; FTC v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc.,
363 U.S. 536, 80 S.Ct. 1267; Moore v. Mead’s Fine Bread
Co., 348 U.S. 115, 75 S.Ct, 148.” a ees |
_ Respondents’ t size, and large overall . profits,
coupled with | their demonstrated willingness to inten-
* tionally take losses on particular products at particular
_ times and places, gives rise té a reasonable inference that
s sompetition | is-endangered. — ; |
- All ‘Tespondents entered the frozen pie tiaatinnbs by way
of acquisitions. They rapidly became (if they were not at
__ the outset) the major “‘national’’ manufacturers of frozen
fruit pies, using their total corporate resources to finance
a their growth. Although entry into the industry was-said
> -to be easy, the industry was shown ta_be highly concen: - |
trated, with these three respondents among the four
largest producers in the nation. i.
Shisd IeiCerher saps; Silly cater tn fet Tas: City, -
‘with 30 years of history in the pie business. It began to
freeze some pies in 1957, and rapidly obtained the largest
market share of any seller in Salt. Lake. Utah Pie had the -
advantage of having the only frozen pie plant in the ‘
ae intermountain area; respondents’ nearest western plants
. were. all in. California. Respondents’ nearest plant to the
east. was Continental’s, i in Webster City, Towa. _ ;
From its. high point in 1958, Utah Pie’s ‘market share ”
oe Salt Lake City fell off sharply i in 1959, rebounding only —
tightly in 1960 and 1961. Réspondents all: ‘maintained or :
o : ; ‘ ee
a
increased their market shares in Salt Lake, but prices
dropped substantially. The ‘‘others’’ (ie. sellers other —
than respondents and Utah Pie) achieved their greatest -
Salt Lake City market shares in 1959, dropping off to a
ee ee
spondent in 1961. ;
‘Utah Pie had much the same experience in ataiilpllai
to sell in outlying parts of its trading area. After initial
success in Colorado (especially Denver), Montana, Wy-
’ oming and Nevada in 1958, 1959 and 1960, Utah Pie lost '
ground in its fiscal 1961 (in absolute terms, not merely
market share) ina rapidly expanding market. .
Utah Pie showed \that each respondent had engaged in es
‘important price discriminations at relevant times, - with
low prices in ‘Salt Lake City and in other parts ‘of Utah
' Pie’s trading area. Utah Pie asked the jury to infer, on
- the. dasis of . all of the evidence in the case, that each
| respondent’s price discriminations were reasonably likely
to substantially lessen competition, or -to tend to create
a monopoly, that they were. unlawful, and that- they had
injured Utah Pie in ‘amounts S greatly in excess of the
jury’s verdicts. |
The jury found fin Uteh Pie. The Court of ae
found. for respondents. The decision of the Court of
Appeals cannot: he permitted to stand; it would substan-
tially eliminate private enforcement of Section 2(a) of the
Clayton Act. .
Under Clayton Act standards, the jury’s decision was.
clearly..reasonable solely on the basis of the “‘structural’’
facts summarized above.
. pee,
But: there was additional ‘evidence. of respondents’ |
- “eonduet’? (and the intent behind that conduct) which the
: ‘jury could also have weighed’ in reaching its verdiets.
That evidence showed respondents’ intent to injure or
destroy competition in general and Utah Pie in particular. 7
It consisted of express statements to the effect that price
cuts were aimed at Utah Pie (by Continental) and indus-
trial espionage and ‘a ‘‘fighting brand’’ (by Pet) as well
as general inferences of intent to be drawn from sales at
a loss (all respondents) and calculated advance planning
for sales at a loss (by Pet and Carnation). There was .
also the testimony of respondents’ economics expert that -
respondents’ discriminatory pricing was itself ‘‘unnat-
ural,’’ in addition to other ciroumsjaniel evidence of .
respondents’ intent. ©
The Court of Appeals passed. over all of Utah Pie’s
‘intent’ evidence as if it had no relevance at all to the -
proceedings. Its strongest statement ‘regarding any of the
evidence was that Pet’s industrial espionage was ‘‘repre- .
hensible and is not to be condoned”’ (R. 1476). It treated
the evidence as irrelevant to the issues in the case:: In thus
dismissing evidence of respondents’ predatory intent, the
"Court of Appeals has disregarded this Court’s injunction
that facts are for jury evaluation where ‘‘. . Fmotive and
intent play leading roles . . . and hostile. aiieaeas thicken
the plot.” Poller v. Columbia Broadcasting System, 368 :
US. 464, 473, 82 S.Ct. 486, 491.
In reversing the judgments for Utah Pie, the Court of
Appeals committed a number of subsidiary errors in inter-
preting the facts and-in applying the law to those facts.
. Among those errors are the following:
oe
—It completely, and expressly, disregarded the impact
of Pet’s Safeway contract, under which Pet supplied
Q
private label ‘‘Bel-Air’’ pies at prices very substantially
below Pet’s prices for its own ‘‘Pet-Ritz’’ pies, although
eee
and quality (R. 1373).
—It considered only -whether Pet’s price Sideriantnaticas
on Safeway Bel-Air pies precluded. competitors from the. -
_ business of packing Bel-Air for Safeway; it disregarded
the fact that Bel-Air competes with other brands even for. .
‘the business of the. Safeway stores themselves (B 544,
. 698, 704-705, 707, 1138; Pl. Ex. 46; ‘R. 411, 2249), -
—It held that Pet. had proved a ‘eost justification”
defense to its Pet-Ritz/Bel-Air discriminations as a mat-
_ ter of law although Pet made no attempt to explain the
* documentary evilence purporting to relate to its costs,
’ and although there’ was no. documentary evidence what- .
ever on Pet’s costs for almost 15 months in the me
_ of the damage period.
—It disregarded the effect of respondents’ price dis-
criminations upon general. levels of prevailing market
- prices, apparently on the assumption that the only ad-
verse effect of a price discrimination cognizable in law
| is a diversion of business froni one seller to another.
—In assessing the extent of : respondents’ ’ price dis-
criminations, it treated advertising allowances as idéfitical
_to straight price reductions, despite repeated testimony to
the contrary (R. 110-112, 160, 462, 687-689, 1030) and in
direct conflict with much, considered legal authority dis- -
| tingnishing between advertising. allowances and oie re-
| ‘siibateees R. H. f. Macy & Co. v. FTC, 326 F.2d 445,
. 449-450 (2d Cir. 1964). :
Tt based its opinion in material part upon “respond--
- ents’ post-complaint conduct, which was quite “probably _
modified in response to the pending lawsuit, and which is
‘in any event not conclusive. See United States v. Conti-
nental Can Co., 378 US. 441, 463, 84 S.Ct. 1738, 1750.
‘ibye ‘expressly excluded from its consideration Conti- © é
nental’s discriminations in Denver, although the whole \
“course of the trial, the evidence and the argument clearly \
showed that Denver was at all times : Li of Utah Pie 's .
“ease against Continental.
—It: viewéd: ‘each respondent’s discrimiintions as if
_ they had occurred in a vacuum, “‘. . . tightly compart-
_mentalizing the various factual ‘components and wiping -
the slate clean after scrutiny of each’’: (Continental Ore
_. Co. v. Union Carbide & Carbon Corp., 370 U.S: 690, 699,
2 S.Ct. 1404, 1410), in contravention of Standard Ou Co.
of Calif. v. “United seees, 337 U.S. ‘298, 314, 69 S.Ct.
- 1051, 1062. -
By its re-evaluation of tite. evidence of the cas Sits
"acceptance of controverted testimony adverse to U F Pic, |
and its persistent refusal to draw reasonable inferences —
in support of the verdict, the Court of Appeals has flag-
rantly invaded the province of the jury, in violation of the
Seventh Amendment to the ‘Thited States Constitution.
With respect to the Court of ‘Appeals’ instruction on.
remand, there was error even if.the Court of Appeals’
Be correctly held Utah-Pie’s evidence insufficient to sustain
its verdicts. Under usual canons of construction, the re-
=)
">
i.
.
mand with ‘instructions to ‘die ‘aliaiea on the de-.
fendants’’ would not permit Utah Pie to make a motion’
for a new trial ‘under FRCP 50(b). Therefore, it is in |
direct conflict with this Court’s: decisions in Weade v.
’ Dichman, Wright and ‘Pugh, 337 U8. 801, 69 S.Ct..1326;
Cone v. West Virginia Pulp & Pager Co., 330 U.S. 212, .
- 67- S.Ct. 752; and Globe Liquor Co. v. ». Son Roman, S82
US. 571, 68 S.Ct. 246. ad
Although Fed. R. Civ. P. 5O(a) permits an peels to
conditionally urge reasons why he should have a new
trial, it does not have application when the ‘potential
grounds. for a new trial are not: reasonably foreseeable _
until the Court of Appeals has decided the case. Althoygh
| ‘Fed. R. Civ. .P. 50(d) assumes a power in the Court of —
Appeals to remand a case for judgment without possibility
of a new trial, it does not permit such a remand in this
ease, Justice requires that if Utah Pie must be denied its
‘judgment on the existing verdictss it is’ at least entitled
ey to a- new trial. Byrd v. Blue Ridge Rural Elec. Coop., 356 &
"US. 525, 78 S.Ct. 893 Weade v. Dichman,- Wright and
Pugh, 337 USS. 801, 69 S.Ct. 1326, |
%
' lessen comp
os 1596, ae |
aa ‘The Salita win Mee tee to the Clayton Act,
i ~ (196A); 00 Appendix A to thie brie. ee
. ra A . ’
66 wie
™ ,_* . a ‘
-
“ight 8% ’ + ABGUMENT | : a8
1. RESPONDENTS’ CONDUCT POSED AN ‘‘INCIPIENT’’ THREAT
_TO OOMPETITION UNDER OLAYTON AOT STANDARDS.
a. ‘Bections 2, 8, and.7 of the Clayton Act timbody the Same
Test.
Sections 2, 3 ‘and 7 ,of- the Clayton ‘Act® Giteke sub-
stantially identical language: (‘‘may be to substantially
ition . .. or tend to create’a monopoly. [of]
[in] any line of commeree’”). This Court has consistently
_construed that language to ‘have the saine meaning in all
‘ three sections, United States v. Philadelphia National _.
Bank, 37: S. 321, 365, 83 S.Ct. 1715,°1742; Brown Shoe
Co.. mited erage? 370 U.S. reer 329, 82 S. Ct. 1502,
gave. Section 2 a new emphasis: and’ direction in ‘‘sec- .
ondary line’, cases involving ‘discriminations . between
competing purchasers, but the original application’ of. the
statute to ‘‘primary | line”? cases was retained. FTC v.
, Anheuser-Busch, Inc., 363 U.S. 536, 543-545, 80 S.Ct. 1267,
-* 1271-1272.
‘Although the i issue.in 5 Anheuser Bustls wen the definition
. of “diserifnination,”’ this Court went on to say ‘‘it might
Oe argued that the existence of predatory intent bears
“upon the likelihood of injury to competition, and that a
" —price reduction below cost tends to establish such intent,’’
“(363 U.S. at 552; 80 S.Ct. at 1276, footnotes omitted).
Where, as here, ‘the below-cost discriminatory selling is
9 enormously powerfal — en? in ithe trad-
" Oet. 15, 1914, © 323, §§ 2, 3, pa 7, 38 ‘Stat, “730, 731, as
dimended 49 Stat. 1526, 64 Stat. 1945, 15 U.S.C. §§ 13, 14, and 18
f
ae ae ; ; | a - 4
es ae. 2S
ih ub vette bine
"periods, and planried in advance,.the —_ is not Tt
5. it is ‘dispositive: be
e four years 1958 through 1961, respondents
lective losses ‘of $212,126 on rrOsee pies ‘in
best year (Compare Pl. Ex. 31; R. 256, 2202 with D. Ex.
A-46; BR. 997, 5847). Respondents’ losses” “amounted to ~
. 396% of Utah -Pie’s: net worth in its best year, or 1,560% ;
-of Utah Pié’s net income before taxes in its best ‘year -
(Ibid.). 3
. However, DS! 2 collective net - ‘pedis before
taxes on their overall business. in the years 1958 through
_.1961 amounted to $198;799,551 or 339,500% of Utah Pie’s
* net pre-tax earnings of $53,840 in those years (Compare ae
Pl. Ex. 31; B.1256, 2202 with Pl. Ex. 92; R. 551, 4586).
- Under ‘applicable Clayton Act standards, as construed
by this Court i in cases under Sections 3 and 7, as well as
2(a), there can be no- doubt that the regional . price dis- .
criminations indulgga i in by respondents with that kind of .
market power were reasonably likely to substantially
- lessen competition or tend to create a monopoly and that =:
Utah Pie is entitled be its judgment." ‘
»
_b. [fections 2, 9-and 7. of the Clayton Act All’ Deal With the :
| Misuse of Market Power. to Foster Monopoly.
Market power is a relative thing, a matter of aie It.
can be based upon some exclusive right, such as a patent
or trademark. It can also. be based upon sheer, over-
‘whelming size. , Market power as such i is not unlawful. |
: — - : 8 .
<o_
> —
ee But. ‘market power is ‘also. iss jonah: teal, for the S.
S * vaclpaajpioa at more market: power, and, ‘altimately;: of et
~~ monopoly power. Market ‘power canbe extended. Sections _
a _, 3,8 and 7 of the Clayton Act were designed to prevent. |
a ~ sueli, extension by three methods (mergers, exclusive deal-.
_ ing, and predatory 1 local: price-cutting) which had commonly, :
| heen used: by the great 19th Century trusts to turn market
- - power into monopoly.: FTC. v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc., 363.
/ +. U.S. 536, 543, 80, S.Ct. 1267, 1271. See. also Standard Oil
Go. United States, 221 .US.. 1, 31. S.Ct. 502; United
Slates v. .. American, Tobacco Co., aL US. 106; 31 8.Ct..
= — Schemes te, inion Sack ‘power - through Siar ¢ con-.
_ > tracts ‘are ox wip under Section 3. of the Clayton Act
even | though- the- seller’s market power in the tying ——
ae “product falls. far ‘short, of. monopoly. : ‘Thus tie-ins. to.
: _ patentad items are universally’ held to violate Section 3 of
the: ‘Clayton Act (see e.g. International Salt Co. v. United
States, 382 U8: 392, 68 S.Ct. 12; International Business.
es ', Machines: Corp. v. ‘United States, 298 US 131, 56° S.Ct.
ps. 701). although | & patent, as “such, need not. jonfer power
pices amounting | ‘to. “monopoly”, Walker Process ‘Equipmeni, e
bias Ine. v. eee Mainly oad Choa Cork, U8. Co
+ SERCH BT, BH ‘
pee ~ ‘Similarly, ‘this. ‘Court ‘has. ‘ epeatbaty strick ‘dowh |
ae ‘{nergéray” both ‘horizontal -atid.;vertical,: im cases. ‘where:
SS —— ing compa és, nor the surviving com.
ee : : opols ae ee ienen'Y.
ates oF ~i : ae towns U.8:545) 26 S.Ct) 1665; rears
rood barca er Ohed fid OCR eee.
Re oF
TAF py bk}
ees viable competition :
an Dat as foRows:
. . .
3° 2 - Wwe Ys = ag 4 ‘
| 24 ai tie a> Sate ee:
, -? St ee x
4
. . ¥ - - ‘
sees, ® = : oe
oe Te Ly Sng tie oP Opa oe
: tion Without More. aii a Bah ae ba vA
Neither bigness nor ‘diversification 4s: itself illegal, But g
_. as Dr. Corwin Edwards ‘has demonstrated, the combina-
tion of those cleménts\ may rents ‘@ serious theft to
‘‘The mere fact that diversified gotda are sold by a .
single enterprise is not, of itself, ground for concern. ~~. -— ie
: So long as this takes place ons small scale in a set- petals:
' .. ting in which diversifigation gives the, diversified. firm
no unusual power, specialized firms can and do com- ae
-fenlt taba piel ebay af CaO OE. a ARE
» ficant effect, Qpon the ‘quality of ‘competition. But the”
question arises’ whether bani brut ‘the’ ee
. Of. conglomeration." 2 Rear tra “De ace
"After examining ‘some “of ‘the characteristica of. con- =e :
glomerate enterprise, Edwatds, answers his aeatinn in: ee
he ee ey saoiiee. may oe: Y
- “pignificant power. This power is not measured by the. -
_ size of the conglomerate’s, market share in particular
markets. It extends to markets in which the con-
~~ glomerate’s market share is too small: to eonstitute
Bae monopoly or participation in oligopoly, It as derived -
ee from two facts: First, that the enterprise has re .. -
fee ‘sources much larger tlian those of most of its
: competitors;. and second, that ‘these. resources: are .
a Ey ae tame eaten ae
~
>
o
Vt
Blade em nf wy: It 2 ons RS RE ey, SIGE
"<*+4 big frm has advantages over, smaller Fval jut
_ because if is big. Money is power. A big firm can out-.
bid, outspend, and:ontlose a small firm. It.can adver-
. tise more intensively; do more ’ intensive and extensive‘ .
_ esearch, buy up the inventions of- others, defend its -
legal.
ats or alleged rights more. thoroughly, bid
_ higher fete,
resources, acquire the best locations
wees - and the best technicians and executives. If it overdoes
its expenditures, it can absorb losses that awe bank-
| Fupt.a small rival...
“Because! 4 large. eae | lal ng in ‘many bes
_. markets, it can. divert income from one market to an-
ie : other. It can
- profits in another, or make investments i in production
' for one market with resources derived from another. . -
_ This fact gives a conglomerate exceptional leeway in-
; ‘market policy and exceptional possibility of i imposing
. its will upon its more specialized Tivals, "
| ‘Whereas a specialized firm dependent upon a single oh
- market cannot. afford: to lose substantial amounts of
5 ~“money” ‘for a {i é
pe i teed Gd BET att Ao
“It can pursaé longrun ‘profit regardless‘ of shortrun
Bioorg deicchagen homer ion aol
gee pede Tar le mare aoa
. < _ Similarly a eongk peeps eh aubetlinn cn it
Yi eae Tt can. adjust its prices so that
ducts upon which it encounters vigorous competi-
cas SEP
<s 1%
-
‘its losses in one market from : Se
of time, a con-_
‘tla! RS 6 “ide io caer cack of the overhead .
- ey > ii eo tet Pte See total
*. | eespwofit; while products: that ‘are: ‘less competitive carry: .
= aes. onan in Ripa gh :
re 1252). " ;
ad hy
- *
-
“as “competition i is ‘not saleby: Widliaten ‘over’ the * .
singhijecieahe's entite field of activity, such ‘subsidiza- -
/tion an be an enduring handicap for specialized —
competitors. The conglomerate can maintain its
in those Darts of its field of operation in which other
- enterprises ‘are more efficient,” (Ibid. Pp. 42-43).
"Drs Walter Adams of Michigan State University ‘also
testified before. the Senate Sabcommittee on. the baliject: of °
conglomerate: ‘corporate ‘structure. His conclusion :
. the basic objection to ‘the , conglomerate structure ees
in , Amerioan industry is that there are no -advantages
‘in terms of efficiency: that this kind of bigness confers. S
This is almost bigness for the sake of —_ os ase | :
my a
d. Duerniry Pong by Taree CoglmarteBeerrine
‘In this case, as ea big et ek Oe)
in action. Each was willing to, and did, take losses on its
frozen fruit pie sales in Utah Pie’s trading area (PL Ex.
31; R. 256, 2202). Carnation and Pet planned?the losses i in -.
advance (B. 397, 400-401, R. 443-445). And ° yet every
: respondent showed multimillion‘ dollar overall profits. in .
every year from 1959 through '1961° (PL Ex. 31; BR. 256,
2202). Indeed; Pet never earned less than $7,000,000 for a
full year, Continental nevér earned Jess than $15,000,000.
rssh rene a gape mee ae
in net profit before taxes (Ibid.). ha as
- Whatever : the practice be éailled (ie. in veatieait” ;
: spending’*-or* ‘contribution to profit”? or something elsé)
respondents all subsidized ‘their frozen pie sales in’ Utah 3
Pie’s ee ene ae eee ee :
7 other alin (PL Hix! 15, 256, 220). ‘They. obtained es
_..’" farther sublidy, not available to a:single-product, regional” *
: _. fitm,'iwthe-form of income fax deductions; the subsidiza- '
- . tion was done with “‘tax dollars” (Be 641). This is ree =
flected not, only in ‘the law permitting © a _ conglomerate ease
‘- enterprise to consolidate its tax return (Int. Rev. ‘Code of &
: 1954, $1501, et seq.) but also in'the actual figures which a
‘Tespondents used to show their profit and loss on the busi-
I dss cncscerses "R. 409, 1926; PL Ex. §; R. 446, 1656). ae
, The threat to competition which Dr. Edwards 4nd Dr
:
)
~ Ailes Sed io tie lal testimony is ‘real. These
respected authorities conclude. that the mere existence of ©
a conglomerate is a threat to conipetition. Surely,-2: jury
tee of reasonable men, could conclude that three large: con- -
ee. omiérates, all selling at ‘subsidized. iseriminato ices
be in the trading area of a single, spall competitor, pose-a—————
a ie . fexitial lessening of competi-. * :
#e tion, of even of a, tendéney to:créete a monopoly. i eee
fe The better-considered decisions under ‘Section '2.of the: B
_. Gayton Act’ bear ont'the jury’s conclusion. This. Court.
‘hes, ‘Mobeerved: that See. 2(a) does not require ‘a finding.
_adwatnshil cnspetitions "Tas atnkale tn Sphigned to
Teach’ euch: discriminations ‘in their incipiency’, before .
the Sharm to'comipetition is ¢ffected. It is enough that they
ane = erential iat ‘Corn Products Refining
Fn elle ARR EI gy IE — OR a I
. 3
: ‘ x: O78 Fk ve y Par
: . . ‘¢ . 4 ° LA
a. i Bone ee ers ooh ins eee
: ; \ . : ia S Fd ioe ?
: ie , :
XA
» Cir, 1957), cert. denied 355'US8. 94, 78 S.Ct 426, ‘Cons
%
pare United ‘States v. Penn-Olin Chemical Cos; 378. US.
158, ‘116-177, 84 S.Ct. ‘1710, 1720. ae ce.
Assuming arguendo ‘that an. actual i injury & competition
is required, Utah Pie satisfied that burden. For the injury
to. competition requirement of ‘Section 2(a) (15. Us. C.
3 13(a)) means only that the “lower ‘price must ‘prevent, or. -
\ tend to prevent, competitors from taking “basinéss away
_. from_the’ merchant which t they’ -might have got, had the
.,. merchant not lowered. his price below what he was ‘gharg- ;
ing elsewhere”. Samuel H. Moss,. Ine. D. FTC, 148 F.2d
878, $79 (2d Gir, wr cert. denied 1 89. ue Thy: 66.8.Ct. :
ott, | |
tee territorial price sediastSeae made aggressively ieinat
weaker competitors injures cortpetition within the?mean-
: ing of Section 2(a). H. J. Heine'Co.'v. Beech-Nut Life -
’ :“Savers, Inc., 181. F. Supp. 452; 464 (S.D.N. ¥. 1960). ‘And -
oe: . injury toa single paepettior 2087 constitute ‘the Fequisite
$
. gutting : . . held to: be ‘foreign’ to, any- legitimate com-
_ mnercial' competition’ even. prior to. the: Robinsofi-Patman
a
injury. (Ibid.)... ee : . eggs
Here, dethdanta have pa in ve cme of ania
ae Act:?? ‘Moore v. Mead’s Fine’ Bread ‘Co.; 348. US. 115,
120; 75 S.Ct. 148, 151. They are, in. the language Of
ae Moore v, Mead, “interstate c ubines”’
_ petitive advantage ‘‘not by reasoh of )
= ciency but because of. their strength « “to
2 pee ware” eA) cae i. 7 8. Ot. at 150); are
ORY pMEIE NR HANS, ge a se A eae Actas
S ae iy Bite é § me Sd :. a .
an)
é :
Ss co oe very areal ee of the
-) FOURTH:
is entire United States. frozen pie market (Pl. Ex. 61; R.
436, 602, 2275). the Conrt of Appeals placed. great em:
"Bpoaiy wee, Bek, Hin meteet share Je nese :
Salt Lake City, area. At,said:.
: “Moreover, a. contention thst Utah. Pie | was. “entitled :
"to hold the extraordinary market. share percentage of ae
66.5, attained in 1958, falls of its own ‘dead weight. To
“approve such a contention ‘would be to-hold that Utah_
‘Pie was ‘entitled to ‘maintain’ a position which
approached, if'it did not in fact amount to» mono-
poly, and could not exist in the face of prope: and ~
“_- healthy eqmpetition:” (B. 1507). |
“ar i ning a the poor to apport a eaggetion ;
that the jury concluded that Utah Pie was ‘‘entitled to
-: > hold’? any particular market share; the verdicts were
: general in. form (R. 41-42, 1405-1406). Ta closing’ argu-
Q ment Utah Pie's coursed ‘made the — ‘remarks on
"tte abject =”
wy 4 fy
LY,
LO SP mes
SD ape ee)
Rae em oe y en ees pet ont ommend <r
Ae) es . oe é ;
colt debuale alii Ucould ta Toeeuson
- ‘Otaly Pid Company ‘has séro. So. So.as betwoen:the Utah
ng Tee, al ie rd bee ee aie :
~~ spologize tr 70 percent. We are prepared to —
> takerDr. Andersor sh etody: of that area, sremared io
Sy es . mery Eben ie Be . ¥ & g
es Cre wt . : > ; . .
‘ “ee as Finer TRIGA ANS tar i : > ee ve
LOVE 9 . os SESS . . < . . 7
g
Pie aind the hare hd have a hrandred ‘percent. --
power to exclude others. from: selling’ in Salt .
ge 5 __ ence t the pie business, an advantageous location, clédal,
"2 tad: 10 a enh ol a wa fh
' situation would hare, been: (Be 1269)... 5. Oh: Bhee? S es
th REDS beige Gee
Th his charge, ‘the Disthet ‘Court i bruc the jury?
oe “In other words, the plaintiff, if it is entitled to re- a aga
cover, would be entitled tore the ‘amount by ~~
_ which its profits weré’ reduced bythe violation of the
‘ antitrust laws, nd he te at you i a eee
i there was: such a reduction.’ (Be 1360). cee eg. eas
Nem wl rr kno win oon the jr ahd Sk
_ on Utah Pie’s market share ‘‘but for’? respondents’ Widla- ee
» aia; i ‘ning wotlk gly aloes aad esaiaade |
ost of et salen, rded rin and'iary fo pod at
ie i ee agar |
“(B. 41-42, 1405-1406). 7 5 ae
Bub it ites-jery. didi de tone hod el Weak ole al.
"have had 66.5% of the markét’in'‘Salt Lake. City. absent _
| respondents’ violations, it: would certainly not ‘constitute
‘monopoly of even that! limited: ared. Utahi Pie had-mo
- oven Imilding pie plants across the street from ‘ts, owns: ee
“What: Utah Pie did ‘have was the benefit’oF long éxpéri-. ee
___, Sflctent plant, = good prodiuct, and willing Wworkére (ROW,
505-506, 524,971, 1115-1116). ‘And the aot is thetit' gia nee
' obtain 66.5% ‘ofthe business in the’ , ‘area of ..
ee Saf Inte ity ah edi mn ins stn ih es
Se oe ae ee seit tee
: __ The Tenth Cirenit’s. analy eS a
) Beagrie pnagonnie our om er
és eS
: tie ys tbe
ei Fe iene inde io ged” eh Bee
fn ‘
16
ree
heute in FTC: v.: ‘Anheuser Bisch, ‘Inc., 363 US. 536, ;
544, 80 S.Ct. 1267, 1272. There, the record showed that —
Maryland Baking had charged discriminatory prices in
the marketing area of a small competitor with the result
that, the small competitor’s “market. share had fallen from
913% to'58.2% (See FTC Docket No. 6327, 52°F TC 1679,
1682 (1956). The Fourth Circuit said: 1
<Tbore tt teed’ Chat eo pzloe ent “iran Initiated
} for the purpose of driving the competitor out of busi”
ness ‘and. that it deprived the competitor of . :'. about —
+ ‘half ita volume ‘of business in the product in question. :
..(Dhe contention that petitioner’s actions didnot affect
; rr eae
ccna h diovassion” (2488 F.2d at 718). ee 4
Phe Fearn it held that a decline Ries 91.3% to
. Pr adetesringee urt competition. The Tenth Circuit
"held ‘that 2 drop' from! 66.5% to.45% could not. Utah Pie
* yespectfully urges that the Fourth Cireuit’s analysis is
e correct, and ‘the: ‘Tenth’s is faulty. There is nothing
ee nae ee
share near its plant. So long 2s sellers in neighbor-
. ing. geographic areas offer..p competition, and as
| long as entry.is free, the. concern-may well have a
large pottion of, the local market without exercising any pieee
reel, control over, pricing or entry...
: “The hallmark of thé ‘monopoly’? rofirred'to in Section
- @ of the Gherman Act is:the power td exclnde competitors
_ oF eotitrol iptice, or both. United States v. Paramount |
Pi tures, Inc, 334 US. 131,/143, 68 S.Ct. 915, 922; United
States, v. Griffith, 334 T.8. 100, 107, 68 S.Ct. 941, 945;
spenerions Rataree Gere. Goliad States, 998. U.8..781; 20, ,
: | @ 80k Um, um ‘
ts
ORL te LOL LOE ELLE ES AO BA, OLE AA CELL Ee te ra A ORR I IY MOI TRU te Ge ma:
hp em
| “As this Court observed in Grifith, supras “anyone who.
__ Owns and operates the’ single: theatre in ‘a. or who-
acquires the exclusive right to exhibit a. filmi, has. a mono-._ NA
poly in the popular’ sense, But he amally doe uot Vat
Section 2 of the Sherman Act unless he has qu
maintained his strategic position, or sought ‘to ¢ Da
dhis |
monopoly, or expanded it by means of those restraints of eo
‘trade which are cognizable under Section 1.’” (334 US. at rae
106; 68 S.Ct. at 945). | ret ate ’
Utah Pie ‘had the ouily 3 pie phi in the taterrnonnitats s
area (B, 175, 482-483, 1115-1116), Its position was entirely.
_ analogous to the man ‘‘who operates a single theatre i In a
town’’. Respondents, by, contrast, pose the- real threat to
competition, because. they have demonstrated. not-only the
: ability “but ‘the willingness to sell at places and prices of :
» their oii choosing without regard ‘to profit, or any other ‘
ae -disciplining ‘factor of the market place. Compare United .
' States v. Grinnell Corp., 384.US. 563, 86 S.Ct. 1698. It -
+ gould fairly be said that respondents had ‘‘the power to
: control. prices ‘or exclude competition.” United. States v.
7 du Pont ¢ Co., 351 US. 377, 391, 76 8.Ct. ee
7 ee puta ovvind oF ApwAAkA wan minrot ats. Or ‘ecw on:
_ TROLLING OLAYTON AOT PRINOIPLES IN REVERSING THR
JURY IN THIS (ASE.
“Atlan anysing: the dash’ of tis cabm, the ‘Gop ab
Appeals concluded. that respondents’ regional Price-cut- _ :
ting was unlikely to lessen competition or to tend to create
Dodie dl One cane ones: te
; nhs :
SRS ARAL : ng 8 2 ie : ;
a <neonmachty:dninghed ahsitnliy every tect wich this
ae Pc AE A PR EER ts 4
‘ : Se SN yee Ns ay £3 Sta uy
Ree 7 agg heapiag) pee
3 ic or reysinyry eae ats thie sur-
. high concentration which. has already been
So ee ieves in this new industry." Resp pondents accounted for _
pie “more than 66% of all ‘quality’? pies: sold in the United >.
*- States in the year ending June, 1958 (Ph Ex. 61; R. 436,
60, 2278, 2294). Continental was the largest — ne
in the “‘price” pio category (Ibid). ee
ae respondents’ study of the Salt Lake City Market,
-all “other”? ‘sellers combined (ie, not parties to this
: action) hed a maximum market share of 18.7% in 1959,
: which declined steadily thereafter to 8.2% in. 1961—a .
pe ‘are hse Gan Gal of gay singe ronpoedent sts ist ae
* dicyengh eee, se: teatinney, that Gace ak, 200
- .gellers ‘of frosen pies .in’ the United “States (R.1011)
. respondents’ evidence showed: only: a. dwindling’ handful —
‘who attempted to’sell in Salt Leke City as respondents’ | .*
_ discriminations there made competition progressively a
"more difficalt from 1959 to 1960.to 1961 (R. 794,965). As
_ DeBe"A-27 (Ri 898; 562) shows; ‘Tespondents ‘were"able ~
.. / "to" identity’ only "19 ‘brands ‘advertined at’ retail in ‘Balt —
ake City: in the calendar years 1957 through 1961. Of
". these bra § ‘9 were: ‘packed hy either ‘petitioner ‘or re- “4
spondent e.< Of te Serene refine oer 3
3 POAT. +
only 4 were advertised in both 1960 and 961 quips @
_ almost total exclusion’ of. competition: from’ Salt» Lake -
| Gity ja hard to explain on the axis of geographical
factors. Petitioner had the onlj®frozen pie plant in the
intermountajn area, to be sure, ‘but respondents managed —
to blanket the United States -with their f frozen pies from
a maximum of .three pie plants each. The obvious -
.inference_ is that petitioner remained in the. Salt Lake
Market only beci
ents sold in that
price discriminatiox
olistic motives. wi
The Court of: Anil cvaiidagay: ignored this concentra-
. tion in assessing the arguably probable “effect - of
‘Tespondents’ ‘ discriminations. Compare’ United Btates . Se
- Von’s Grocery Co., 384 U.S. 270, 86 S.Ct. 1478, in. which
this; Court found a merger resulting i ina concentration of
75% of the business in the merger partners to be so *
‘obviously unlawful as to not merely justify: a finding of
‘illegality but to actually. eompel it.
In this case, the jury saw clearly the threst t0.0nipet eoue
. tion which the Court of Appeals would not e¥en det it 2)
ay consider. The Court: of Appeals accepted, as if ordained
by higher law, that respondents were ‘*national’* sellers,
and that Utah ‘Pie was not (R. 1456, 1498). It nowhere 2
; stopped to consider how respondents became ‘national’ x e
© sellers, of where Utah Pie’s regional market might have
extended-in the absence of respondents’ diseriqninations.
Compare United States v. PennDlin Chemical Co., 378
UB. 158,. 84 -S-Ct. 1710, ‘in which the possibility- thet’ a
"competitor would wank ‘into a new market was held
‘
Q
ad
éd for. ulterior and: monop-
ae ee ae |
cdiplitek iui ipanibelt init tecomiellie ina *
= Sane cee tendesenietivety tected partcipy-
“tion |in a. joint venture. ° |
lie Gaal 18 AAGbOAG! thio iguiibdd Ys avd Sard.
: concentration of the frozen pie business in Salt: Lake
ee -(inferentially due ‘to’ respondents’ price’ discriminations).
; _ Compare United States 0. Pabst Brewing Co., 384° U.S.
: "546, 86:S.Ct, 1665,.in-which this Court held that ‘‘Con-
es "gress, in, phasing Section 7 . “s . Was concerned with
"arresting concentration in the. American economy, what-
aS “ever, ite’ couse, in its incipiency.”” (38 U.S. rh, exain
ae B,C, 1600; es A). of
& - the yf ot pees ‘hanereelty Considered Each Re
:Reeeeat’s Fetes Dinncrtontions o» 2k Thay Hat. Occurred in -
‘@ Vacuum = ~
The Court of ikpests appsrentiy considered the pricing .
practices of each of the respondents in a vacuum, paying ‘
_ no attention to the Paket, that each respondent ’s discrimi-.
i nations: occurred, in a ‘context of. similar discriminations .
pect other respondents. f Geko es: re a
It is axiomatic. that Section 7 merger cases itaiee’ |
. the: ‘same ‘«incipiency”” standards as must govern this
aS case) are decided upon @ review of all of the market fac-
_ tors; ‘including. trends‘ toward concentration through mer-
gers'of firms not parties to the suit, or indeed trends ;
- ion from any. cause, whether identified
oF not See United States v.. Pabst Brewing Co., Suaderes
M6 552, 86 8.Ct. 1665, 1669 (1966).
a hequalty. clear that. market habayion: re ee not
Deore tn vaca Be conarid in asaing the rob
a.
if * © ¥ + .* > a fess 3 a
roe : ‘ ok,
: 3 . - e
Pie @ Se ee hy
° 2
ee “able: demnigelihiee: effect of slits contracts. under. Section: a :
| of the Clayton Act. Thus, in Standard Oi Co. of Calif. @
eRe a pant heme ares: 106i; thin: Court'0b-
served :
*: ln view of the videspryed, aenkien of wick con-
tracts by Standard’s competitors and the availability
of alternative. ways of obtaining ‘an assured market,
evidence that competitive activity has not actually de-
clined is inconclusive. " prolly Sernhediec dhe Fs
is nee ‘emphasis added) a 18
There i is no reason wis, mi jury should not, have ¢ con-
"i S cidneod, | In assessing the discriminations of each respond- .
ent, the. fact. that competition in the market for frozen
pies was already in great jeopardy as a result of the
; pricing practices of the other respondents, :
6 wins iain,”
wt Mie ee
_ Diverting Business. : hee
Loeal price cutting by’a large: competitor is - Aikely. roe
divert. business to the discriminating seller, and this effect
ee is relevant in aSsessing the impact of : the discrimination.
See e.g. Saimuel H. Moss, Ine. v. ‘FTC, 148 F.2d aD, 379
_ (2d Cir. 1945).- Ce ‘
~ But local. _price-cutting ‘as: ‘ene to Sete the. local = |
seller to meet the discriminatory price, and niay result in.
: a his destruction even though he keeps the business, if the
price is: low enough. ‘See e.g. American Tobacco Co. v..
United States, 221 U.S. 106, 182, 31 S.Ct. 632, 648. nas
There is no ‘reason in law or logio why the jury could
~ ga ‘have eonsidered the eC atai effects: of. Te”
"gpesiiecite hecciasinntionaliga'-woll on their binimens-divétt-
|, ingieffecta. And yet itis clear from the opinion’ of ‘the
4 Court-of: Appesle'that the’ Court of Appeals id not eon-
sider this effect.
"The Court of Appeals doce not spell out its reasons for
: ardi the price-depressing | effects of respondents’ :
discriminations. It ‘simply assumes that respondents’
- prices were “meeting” each other’s prices, or the prices
of Utah Pie (R. +1464, 1481, 1482, 1492, 1499). In discus-—
sing the impact of respondents’ ‘pricing, the Court of .
. Appeals talks only of its. business-diverting aspects (R.
— : 1468, 1471-1475, ‘1477-1478, 1483, 1500-1508).
~The Court. of Appeals also repeatedly. emphasizes that
'” Utah Pie’s prices “were the lowest in the market (R. 1469,
1470; 1486, 2489, 1491, 1499, 1501, 1502, 1505, 1507). Those
_. statements are. not .a:fair reflection, of the record; Utah
Pie’s ‘controlled “‘Frost ’N Flame”’ label was quite con-
- sistently ‘lower than respvadenits’ 24-ounce proprietary
brands (as it was usually lower than Utah Pie’s “Utah”.
brand) (D. ‘Bx: A385; RB. 1065, 5827): But is was not al-
“ways lower than Pet’s “‘Swiss: Miss’ nor was it below
- Continental’s “Morton” at the time when Continental was:
making massive sales at unheard-of low prices: (Ibid.).
‘Mthe legal flay isin aisuming that discriminatory —
price péeduction' ‘which ‘does ‘not ‘wadercut a competitor .
: canndt be unlawful, of at least cannot depress the com-
__ petitor’s price. The ‘cates have repeatedly recognized that
. a ‘premium’? ‘brand, such as respondents’ nationally ad-
; ‘wertised labels, nay be‘ in competitive equilibrium with -
Se ree stk eeentehy Maher. veien, Bee
Fre Vv. ssi tealt titag a Ines 363: ere 586):588). etieibi 3
"1267, 1269; ‘American’ Fobacce. Conve: ‘United Btates, 328
U.S. 781, 806,66 S.Ct: 1125) 41 *'Gerber Products Go,
@, eee _— a 160 ) F Sap oi: ‘GDN.
1968). blow ants. tod
+ \ And the faicts acca it’ share Atti sales” of oe
_ Pet-Ritz, Simple Simon and Morton labels ‘appear to have - <
all been. responsive to price,’ ‘the ‘market’ was! far from :
being perfectly “elastic”. At high prices )
__less, at_low-prices they sold 1 more, but the range: of price ©
over which ‘respondents could make some sales ‘was sub-
stantial (D. Ex. A-35; R. 1065, 5827).:The jury could have
‘inferred that at non-discriminatory prices, - Tespondents
could have made. some sales, and that when they decided |
to increase volume by , story pricing, they not
only diverted business but. ‘also. Tedueed _— levels gen- ©
erally. | NTT LOSSSe metstid
eo
©
e: * :
= 5 ALL, RESPONDENTS sities wittiorasiecnn'
i _ PRICE DISORIMINATIONS, Bede a
. Because the Court of Appeals ignored both the law and
_ the evidence relating to. ‘*price,”?. (and because it com-
pared the wrong prices and the wrong marketing area) it
: roan eee Petes Carne mene Here os
nations by respondents... . K %
-In fact,’ although their pores vais nibiiesbty, ||
all respondents engaged in 2(a) price discriminations of -
significant proportions. Compare. Volaseo, Prod P ts Co. a
Lloyd A. Fry Roofing Co., $46 F.2d 681. (6th Cir Cir, 1965)
: _ cert. den. 382 U.S. 904. r
By.
—
with’ very’ indifferent! sade
a ~
S 3 Patty yeincipal wee was the !‘Bek Air’: private Tabel
2 jpdcls te el ini massive quantities throughout : Utah Pié’s
ze trading “area at a highly: discriminatory price. (See Staté-
Merit; | supra; “pp. 1928, and. Appendix B to-this brief).
° Miss”, at sometimes.
&
_ Pet also sold large quantities ef the proprietary “Swiss y dae
iscriminatory prices in Utah Pie’ Bf
trading ares, “and lesser ¢ quantities of its” ‘proprietary. ‘ “Pot.
Ritz”’ at substantial, discriminations in price. (See tate-
» Continental’s brand was “Morton.’’ -Continental’s
"gales im Silt Lake‘ City itself were fairly small until 1961,
but: when ‘Continental cut its price, it cut it to $2.55 per
dozen. ($1.28 per ease), deeply below its lowest ‘previous -
. price, ‘and deeply below the’ price of all, of its competitors |
(RB. 670-671; Dix, A-35; BR. 1065, 5827, 5842). The result .
waa 4 massive diversion of | business.. to. Continental;
bulging warehouses for the buyers, weeks in which buyers el.
strove to.,work off stocks purchased at. Continental’s
‘sensationally low prices, ‘anda dramatic decline in Utah
Pie’a prices: (BR, 696-696; 795; Pl; Bx.,98; B, 552, 4587). “
Continental made substantial sales to other purehagers |
ainatihy’ prides in" other” parts. of “Utah Pie’s
ain; ‘area,’ including ‘Denver. '(See Statement, ‘supra,
‘pe a AL C to this briat): Utah Pie tried,
Washington and Colorado: (BR. eared R 169-770, 8.
Sete euanranie rs |
“ment, svera, pp. 24-26, and Appendix B to this brief) te
to get’ started ‘in’ Oregon, - |
.
‘ ¢
eet a ee
| Si cat ee anette Canoe
substantial, and resulted:in respectable volumes: of sales
Bee Cerne se Belt Lebe Car eer aera,
of Utah Pie’s trading area (Ibid.), 3
.: Tinh Pitrlies ‘et ont the evidense hidwitg wesgesidente? :
discriminations in detail in its Statement, supra. Suffice :
it to say at this point that under the isiterpretation of the
' evidence which Utah Pie, urged upon the jury, each-re- :
‘spondent engaged in, di 8 ‘which resulted in
very substantial sales of pies at low, discriminatory prices ,
in- Utah’ Pie’s trading area, that these discriminations
were essentially all in one direction during the relevant |
1959-1961 period, and that they depressed prices in Utah ae
Pie’s trading area as well as diverting business from .
_ Utah Pie and ‘‘other”” competitars, to respéndents. ‘ ‘ i
ee
: a. “arts Bonito‘ appedie Thiel iim id's’ anil tad ap
ae h- ~-whrenbactmeererrdentwesn trier rg: wercdleices
see ~ Discriminations. .
fet sha tangy yption ‘Wenctntatiog ite ot ‘Sea
pare prices. In’ order to, compare prices, one..must first.
define what is meant, by ‘‘price.’’ In this case, the Court
of Appeals comparéd what it called respondents’ “‘abso-
clute”’ prices, defined as follows:
_. “By ‘absolute price’, is, meant the list price, less any
deals offered, whether direct. discounts from 4
Z or allowance: for advertising.” (Re 1488; see also | 3
: : gat sae bee eae ree ged ies
“The Court of? ‘Appeals has thi treated sdajaltana |
SS 2
7 es:
a ,
. fo.)
‘ing area as Seccnsedeeateiiiad: of- séigoaidoni straight
‘price cuts ‘within Utah Pie’s: trading area. The effect of |
. such treatment is: ‘td-thinimize the duration and: extent of
-Tespondents’ discriminations.
“There is no warrant in the eviderice in this case, and
none: in law, ‘for the sone of ee. calculations of .
“price.” Sep ‘biadi .
The ‘amrebotted testimony of Feailidenti own execu-
- tives was that an advertising llowance is not a price’ cut ©
= 110-112, 160, 462, 687-689, '1030).. i.
~The law i is to the same effect, Section.2(4) of the Robin-
_son-Patman. Aet i is the “advertising allowance”’ section of-
the Act. Giant Food, Inc.: ‘v. FTC, 307 F.2d 184 (D.C. Cir.
_ 1962), cert. denied 872 U.S. 910; ‘Southgate Brokerage Co.
D.- FTC, 150 ‘F.2d. 607 | (4th Cir. 1945), cert. denied 326
TS. ‘474. The Courts of Appeal. have repeatedly dealt
- With fact. situations. presenting claims under both. 2(a)
“nd 2(d): of the Robinson-Patman. Act and have treated
them as quite’ distinct offenses. See. Tri-Valley Packing
. "Ass'n vii FTC, 829 F.2d 694 (Sth: Cir, 1964); Hartley &
i Parkeriioes: v. Se eeteeare Lenk 307 F.2d 916 oe.
ir. 1962) 2) i) ne 28
The aebatai eid: din ota and 9(4) of ‘the
_ Robinson-Patinan ‘Act was ‘@xpressly considered in R, H.
; Macy 'é Co. .v. FTC, '896 F2d 445 (2d Cir. 1964) in which
- Maey’s obte ed rom its suppliars allowances apparently
intended to be ‘used salely”?. for the. institutional pub-
; licity”” of, Macy's RF Fa at 449). ‘The Second Circuit.
: vendor to a buyer who did nothing but put. the ago yi:
“ his pocket; tad oN asta to ben ietion Rm ae:
_ discrimination.” (326 ‘F.2d at 449-450). . oe k +i
'. Here, there is no question ‘of ‘a a Spaniels 4Opatting
thé money in his pocket.” The advertising ‘allowances’ of
all respondents were payable only upon later request upon
2 proof that the respondent’s produet had in’ fact bepn ad: - :
wvertised (R. 158-160, 689, 697, 1095). Conceding that an
advertising allowance was an inducement which: respond-
ents used to help sell pies, there is no basis’in fact or ‘in
law for treating advertising allowances as dollar-for-
- dollar offsets. to the straight price. cuts which’ respondents
3 employed in Utah Pie’s trading area. - saci )
7 “Indeed if the Court of ‘Appel could properly consider
| recjiadente? advertising allowances at all in this 2¢a)
case, it should also have considered the “‘service’” which ..
respondents: provided their Utah area buyers i in’ — nf
pies into the Intermountain. area at the same price
was, offered to California buyers at their: plant doors; it is
‘not disputed that respondents’ freight ‘costs from ‘their
parr pon ges homo wt apiece chad
dozen (B. 254, 663, ‘T70). . ;
Respondents all used delivered price systeins, dteorb 3
their freight costs in their ‘delivered prices (B 73,451, °
453, 740, 1028, 1173). i ; |
3 There i is some authority for the proposition that freight
absorption (and thus varying ‘‘mill net”? prices) can give
rise to a-violation of Section 2(a) even though delivered
prices paid by customers ‘remain’ the: same everywhere. 2
See FTC v. Cement _— 333 US. sad 68 BE me
.
‘
o 88
°
% “PTOvi:A.B: Staley Mfg. Cos, 804 US. 46, 65 S.Ct. mm; '
. Corn’ Products: Ref. Co. v: FTC, $m US. "726, 65 8.Ct.
: 961; Guyott Co. v. Texaco, Ine, F.Supp. piss
ae ‘Conn. 1966) 1966 Trade Cases, Para. 71,835, }
| But Utah Pie tried this cise on the basis that while
- freight absorption may be important evidence ofa seller’s ”
2 intent, price discriminations for purposes of Sectiom2(a)
- ghould ‘be established ‘by reference to invoice net ‘prices,
without reference to other factors such as advettising :
allowance, promotional assistance, freight absorption, or
_ the like, which men einen eer under se a ;
|. Sections of the law, .
| _- Whatever the pessible "aehdilink is in distinguishing be:
‘tween: fake brokerage ‘under Section 2(c) and straight
priéé discrimination under 2(a)* there is no basis in law
or logic for’ blurring ‘the distinction between, 2(a) price.
euts and 2¢d): advertising allowances. On. the contrary,
. there is every. ground for maintaining a. careful division
between the-two types of conduct in view of the, differing
- demands of the sections:as to proof of ‘‘incipient’’ com-
petitive: injury, cost.justification, ete. See FTC v. Sim-
aeotaeirettre On Inc., 360 US. 55, 70-71, 79 S.Ct. 1005,
i. Respondents’ Quantity Discounts Wore Met Juried.
sn eioieersndyncanitian eguigaate 3
substantial discounts of up to $14 ‘per case for ‘fall.
. truck’? purchases (Pl.-Ex. 8; R. 89, 2049; Pl. Ex. 16;R. °
113, 2062; Pl. Ex. 41; R. 396, 2223; Pl. Ex. 64; R. 454, |
2331; Pl. Ex. 65; Th dt, 2068; PL Ex. 66; = i es “A
“PLE 765 R. 474, 2590). |
' Pet made effective use of its quantity discounts: it per- :
mitted Safeway to. combine shipments of Bel-Air and Pet:
Bite sles go:na tn obtain the et ‘if Sew tbe op
less-than-truckload shipments of Pet-Ritz (Pl. Ex. 46; RB.
411, 2249, 2250; Pl. Ex, 47; R. 413, chee dor
: 121; BR 996, 5250). at
| At one point, Carnation was 'éiéting $1,000 in the eid ef,
of a separate, off-invoice rebate in Seattle for purchases
of fall-track quantities, with the privilege of combining —
fruit pies and cream pies’to obtain the ‘‘full track’? price ©
plus the rebate (PL Ex. 71; R. 458, 2522; PL. Ex. 72; R.
458; 2524; Pl. Ex..126; R. 1181; 5340). (For a time, Seattle
buyers were receiving an advertising allowance i in addi-.
__ tion (PL. Ex. 72; R. 458, 2254; Pl. Ex. 126; R, 1181, 5340).
There. was no ‘contention made that these quantity dis
counts’bore any relationship. to actual differences in costs. ce
of manufacture, sale, or delivery. Having. failed to justify _
; their quantity discoffnts in terms of cost,. respondents may.
not complain if the’ jury considered | price tee \
resulting in part from such discounts. FTC »v. Morton Salt -
Co., 334 U.S. 37, 68 S.Ct. 822. United, States: v, noe
Co., 870 U.S. 460, 82 8.Ct. 1300. ie
~
te
In ‘niltig price comparisons of respondents’ prices,
“Utah Pie has used actual face-of-the-invoice ‘prices where —
Bone are: evidenced by i invoices. ‘Where prices, have been ; ;
' shown. by Yeference: to price. lists, ‘‘full truck’’. (ie. -
. lowest) prives have been used to-show prices in both high-
- price and. low-price areas. Comparison based upon. ‘‘ex
warehouse’’ prices in the high-price areas as against ‘full =
track’? prices in eh inal areas would show even greater :
ox price, differences.
0. Pet's Private Label Discriminations Were Substantial, Sus-
tained, and Posed s Serious Threat to Competition. muy os
: Daring the relevant, period of this case, Pet made all of
the private-labél “*Bel-Air’’ pies purchased by Safeway
‘ Stores, except fora few pumpkin and mince pies (R. 517,
1150). The quantities involved were very substantial over-
all, and in Utah \Pie’s trading area. (PL Ex. 42; R. 1041,
- 1054, 2296, 2236; D. Ex. A-35; R, 1065, 5827, 5829-5832).
The ‘*Bel-Air”’. pies which Pet sold in Utah Pie’s trading
“area ‘were sold at prices greatly below the prices which
Pet charged for its Pet-Ritz pies elsewhere. (See Appendix ©
B). Pet’s Bel Air and Pet-Ritz brands were stipulated to
be of “ike grade and quality.’” (R, 1373).
In FTC ». Borden Co., 383 US. 637, 96 BC, 1092, this
_ Court. held. that discriminations between’ prices of pro- _
prietary brand goods and physically identi private label
~ goods are cognizable under ‘Section 2(a) of Clayton “
- Act. Consequently, there was an undoubted “‘ discrimina-
> tion’? between the price which Pet charged for Bel Air
in Utah ‘Pie’s ‘trading area and the ‘price which* Pet .
cares ‘for its propeictery Pet-Rits: pies, elsewhere, ¢
°
Vv
‘ s ; 5
. oo:
"= o . a
. ‘
‘The: Court of ‘Appeals disuhiseod: the: evidence Of th
_ discriminations: on, two: grounds: » = oT ies He cada sorlin 7
“1. That: Utah: Pié would not lave: ‘had: the’ sandions
business in any ‘event, . and thus suffered no: steer
Mn, 1501) gpd as Nias A
2 That Pet’s lower price foi the Bel Air pie’y was bost:
' justified within ‘the meaning of ‘the proviso. of aca ;
> 2(a) of the Clayton ‘Act (R 1468, 1501). - PEE WOES
The analysis is Faulty on a number of grounds, Both =
era,
"tn tha Mee panels ea spiny tis ;
“Utah”? brand. competed directly. with ‘the. “Bel Air”
brand for Safeway’ » ‘business (PL Ex. 46; R. 411, 2049).
s factual and: legal. mes hat
| The Galt Lake Division of Safeway’ Stores was free’ to :
. stock Bel Air or other brands ‘as it chose (R. 698, 707,
1138, 1146). It was also free to buy proprietary brand
items (including Utah Pie’s ‘‘Utah’”’ label, ‘Carnation’s 3
“Simple Simon’’) as indeed, from time to time, it did
(BR. 544, 698, 701, 707, 1126, 1138). Pet’s Bel Air prices
were usually below Utah Pie’s prices for ‘‘Utah’’. brand
(D. Ex, A-35; R, 1065, 5827, 5835, 5836, 5644). ‘Tn 1961, aay
Utah Pie’s sales of ‘‘Utah” brand to coy declined
in a growing market (R. 817).
If stores in the Salt Lake and Denver -divVisions Leg ;
Safeway, wanted to purchase Bel Air pies, they. were
obliged to purchase pies packed by Pet through Safeway’s, :
buyer at Safeway headquarters in California (R. 1138).
‘He resold: Bel ‘Air-pies to the Safeway Divisions sub-—
stantidlly, at’ his cost (H."1141)/"Thus’ any diserimination
i Wb petonn hes Pet iaegi Salen toy Bal te
-
> > P 2 +, .
4 : . :
< - tae ~"
” . : . .
= 3 pies had-a direct and immediate impact upon the sales of :
other sellers competing against the Bel Air label for the a
: business of ‘the vatious’ aaa Divisions bia Ex. 46;
R, 411, 2249)...
In addition to diverting business from other sellers to .
itself, Pet’s discriminatory pricing of the Bel Air pies -
? undoubtedly tended to depress prides generally in. Utah
. Pie’s trading: area (BR 71, 720, 724, 751, 815).
a Furthermore, there was evidence that absent Pet’ s very
substantial discrimiriations in Bel Air prices vis a vis
" { Pet-Ritz, Utah Pie would have had ‘some of the Bel Air.
_fruit pie business ; (other than ‘pupkin | and mince) .
diréctly. There was testimony that Uteh Pie was in all
essential respects qualified . to pack for Safeway | (BR, 175, |
476-477, 486, 505-506, 524, 936-937; Pl. Ex. 38; BR. 386,
2212), Alan Young, the Safeway. buyer, said that he was f
“pot. satisfied with Utah Pie’s quality control (R,/ 1139),
’ : but “his testimony is flatly ‘contradicted by. the evidence
: thet ‘Safeway’ 8 inspectors were. emjnently satisfied with
__, Utah’Pie’s plant and product (BR. 497) and that Young had
~ himself told Utah Pie’s salee manager’ that Utah Pie .
gould have some of the Bel Air business and that he
eee er iert cea ce SAT-
“Sy. :
Ss 'rinally, the Court: of ‘Appeals was mistaken in holding
that as a matter of law the jury was ‘equired’to find.
_ | Pet’a’ price discriminations on the ‘Bel: Air brand cost.
e justified, as. ‘more ally’ disenssed! infra. aii cen *
Rae To a certain degree, Pet's Bel-Air pies ee Ble aT es
: way. pesegiedr: dempete. with | its, own ili aad
Sago bein itn Sy sms snd timed: <
on Bel-Air sold in Utah clearly did not compete with Pet-Rits
sold in Northern, California,. and Pet: did not need ‘to
worry ‘about adverse effects of low Bel-Air prices in Utah | #2
upon its Northets California sales of Pet-Ritz pies. With
Bel-Air and Swiss Miss both selling strongly in Utah Pet .
could, and apparently did, let its Pet-Ritz sales dwindle 3
without ‘losing its “meng market Oise ntade in Utah. = Ex:
62; R. 437, 2323).
Thus, although Pet Rits outsold Swiss Miss ‘nationally :
in 1960 and 1961 (Pl. Ex. 21;"R. 235, 2161, 2165) and
: although Pet sold roughly the same volume of Bel-Air and
Pet Rits pies in its 1961-62 fiscal year (Pl. Ex. 43; BR. 406,
2243; PL. Ex. 44; R. 407, 2247) its ratio of sales in 3
praia ie! secur uns : Ca
eat gers ao of Dalat nae A OBE
eee ee
' 55.6% , S629 254% -
ie Computed from PL Ex. 62; R. 437, 2323).
eect Discriminate Without Batatry Justification
. Respondents - ‘should have eee to a. “one-price”
_*” policy,‘ absent their ability to prove. cither & cost justifice =
3 tion, or a ‘good faith meeting of competiti ”* defense, or
a “changing conditions of the market?’ semana Tes 8
"Tis later provin of Seon 2(0) rend Spa A eteaetaee
vy aa ginal far, St Sng Hin stained ea “
94°
Faced ‘with the necessity of charging’ a single price -
7 everywhere (unless a special justification for a difference
_ existed) respondents would have had to decide whether
- to. raise their price-war prices in Utah Pie’s trading area
or give their ‘other customers outside of Utah Pie’s trad-
: ing area the benefit of the same prices as they were charg- —
ing in competition with Utah: Pie.-They probably would
have compromised,.. givirig buyers in respondents’: high
price area some price relief, and relieving sellers attempt-
. . ing to participate in the Intermountain Market of emer,
a below-cost, destructive competition. — :
In April of ‘this year, this Court upheld New York’s
~ statute designed to assure to its citizens the lowest prices
_ at which liquor is sold in any part of the United States.
- Joseph E. Seagram & Sons, Inc. v. Hostetter, 382 U.S.
924, 86 S.Ct. 10. Although states might lack the’ power to
enact similar legislation . with ‘respect to commodities
| other than liquor, the policy behind the statute is clearly. 3
reasonable. Compare La Peyre v.. FTC, F.2d —_.
(5th Cir. 4966); CCH Trade Reg. Rep. Para. 71,881.
~ aetnal or imminent deteHlovation of perishable 2 ae
solescence-of seasonal goods, distress sales under court process,
eS ae ee
ree Ss CC by:.judi- -
: Wap. 178, citing Mo ri
oore ¥:
ih'Cir. 1951). ;
%
Seg REET k
B slatesca tore regina Rn &
PORTS A JURY FINDING OF AN INGIPIENT , THREAT TO
COMPETITION. —
One sure way to eliminate dompetition is to climiahte
one’s competitors. And one good way for a large, diversi:
- fied corporation to eliminate a specialized, rpgional eorh-
_ *petitor is by ‘regional price-cutting in: the’ specialized
competitor’s products. (See FTC v. re ~
363 U.S. 536, 543, 80 8.Ct. 1267, 1271). ° rest absse Yor
In agsessing the’ probability that.“a’ regional’ price
euttr's' pele dislddtnadion 57 sily Wai ave >
_ effects upon competition, a jury can properly look to the
discriminating seller’s intent, since “the actor is, better - | ‘
able than others. to judge the practical possibility of
achieving his illegal objective.’’ Lessig v. Tidewater Od .
Co., 327 F.2d 459, 474 (9th Cir. 1964), cert. denied: 3
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.