Transcript of Record — Federal Trade Commission v. Procter & Gamble Co.
Supreme Court brief1967
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
*
7
° . —
— — „% eee
IN THE
wiel States Court of Aran
Ve
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
No. 15,769
Joint Appendix.
INDEX TO VOLUME 2
| Smooke, Nathan, President, Lady’s
Choice Foods
Stipulation—Nielsen Food Index .
Giachetti, Salvatore, 8
Linco Products A
7688 (Cont. from
Vol. 1)
8212
PAGE
0 5 oo
‘ 7 8 *
: Wess = : 8 „ ̃ ↄ ↄðV ĩðͤ v oe nae os ae =
8 28 aot ee Si dhs suse, 88 See n en n n > .
eee eee pn RE RA eee e 80 eR é ;
7
NN
re
SAAS eee eee e MON
EEE EE rt ²ůù , “ ÿ/ẽn⁸ s 0 ¾¼uQ¹l..u...;;ͤ; Ak · wm p 22 c
WITNESS ot) PAGE
D i kecehee eh ais 858a
c 8592
Hahn, Edwin B., Sales Manager,
Linco Products nn 5 a
5 Fo 6 Sic 0G Rennes oe ae 844a 859a
3 G4 ict en a ceeeaass ene 860a
— „ 862
MacDonald, Neil A., Treasurer,
. Hood Chemical Company
RR SRR ae ea . 863 f
ZE 869 885 2
d 8714 891a
EKunin, Benjamin, Sales Manager,
Hood Chemical Company
Direct e ee
(( .. 892a
5 Redirect C 89a
Olkin, Alfred; 8
Rose. Zum Chemical Company 3
ccc Ä 899
o 2 912
Rinaldi, Vincent, President, No-
Worry Chemical Company N
. 22 Nen 9164
Henkel, William A., Assistant
Treasurer, J. L. Prescott Com-
Z 926
PPT ach cee bases 9292
-- WITNESS JF i
Prescott; Robert, Treasurer, J. L. Te
Prescott Company .
T E
oo o oc |”
er 949a 9
blende 949 N
Brower, Leon, President, Sunlight:
Chemical Corporation 7 care
; Direct •—U — eeees 5 6 953 .
Cross V 973 a
—WAͤ ˙•· 977
Buchman, Solomon 8. "Partner, 3 e
Savol Bleach Company ue a
i I Feguveeeas sah en. . 978
n „
Redirect n 998
‘ulin, Rexford: 4. rie b .
; Gardiner Manufacturing Com- ae ‘ 5
pa *
o 6 1000 a
SG... . e ea
Redirect. .................. 1020a 1021a
NRecross Tee
Jones, J. W., President, Jones
Chemicals, Ine. ü : xP
Direet cece veces 1022a
oo „66 6 1038a
Redirect 1 . 1046
Olsen, r
» search, Topics. Publishing: Oe
_ Direct F 10822
Mendleson, Shine Chairman of
ue Board. Treasurer, B. T. Bab-
Bird. . 1084
Snow, Edwin A., Advertising Man-
ager, The Procter & Gamble
Company —
| Direct 2.......: . 11322
n hice te * 1148a
eee N 1145
Smith” Norman D., Economist, Fed- me Sc
Stipulation—Nielsen Food Index . 1155a .
Case Presented By „ g
\
| 3 v., Viee-President. Ae
Manufacturing, The Clorox Com- a
pany.
eee. «=» Ree 11683
„ SiS a Mess edaeaveis 1186a
pts Redirect ..7......0v..0i00: 1192a *
Leazar, M. A., Vice-President and . —
: Purchasing ——. *
Andy Super Markets av ae
5 Direet l * 11923 5
Wr
N
—
2 .
e *
2
U oe f 4
?
Royer, Arnold L., Manager, Gen-
eral Advertising, re
ran
22
Gs
Direet 533 120 4a
Timpe, bernard F., vice - Pres-
ident, Sales, The Clorox Com-
Direct cen oie 8 ve sh a cer 12112
a Keller, William, ann Buyer,
Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea
chandiser, —— Company
A. C. 5
10
13493 14612
18568 147
*
2
5 Cress ————————— J 1334a -1444a 8
— 0
0
Fellman, Marco F., Partner, .
*
4
ae
Barth and Company ass.
f Direct ee ee ee ee ö epteav ages 1337a
Bissmeyer, Alvin A., Buyer, Co-
lonial Stores, Inc.
*
:
*
. PAGE .
Direct Sane ä
‘Morgens, Howard i oseph, Presi-
dent, The Procter & Gamble Om:
a
Werner, William G., Director, Pub-
lie and Legal Services, The Proc- -
ter & Gamble- 9 a
Rebuttal
*
1 tie C. „ .
g Purex Corporation, Lid. 8
2 8 Harrington, and ee :
Direct. . : 44488 2
ada ae
*
"WITNESS _ 3 3 Fun
Northrup, 5 ack, Director, 1 Market- —
ing Research and Product. Plan-
ming, Purex Corporation, on :
Fae, Direct .......+..+ nak 14940
Smith, Norman D., Economist,
_ Federal Trade Commission,
Direct. ....... 5 1500a
Redireet *5—6*ũ˙22IĩJ4 + SOOM
Stipulations: ioe: | 6
As to testimony of A. E. Gilfil a.
lan, Legal Department, Amer-
“ican Stores Company .....:.. 1509a
As ta testimony of R. A. Gardi-
ner, President, Gardiner Man-
ufaeturing Company, Ine. 1512 ,
As to testimony of L. S. Frantz,
PpPiůee President in Charge of te.
1 a Sales, Loblaw, Ine 1512a
1 . _. As to testimony of Lawrence
Gordon, Executive Vice-Presi-
a dent, —— 5 en.
‘nei Prectedings
Machen Harry, Vice-President,
A. C. Neilsen — 2
Dirset. . 153 -
Stratton, . Economist, |
Federal Trade Commission .... 1552a -
0
°
—
— —
————— ——— *
*
Ves. 5 0 5 ee
Q. Did that subpoena duces tecum call ‘for price lists
used by your company during 1956 and 577 A. I have
it in my folder, if I could refer to it.
| advertising
re
Nathan Smooke—Direct
. Where is it produced, sir? A. In San Francisco
and in- Los Angeles. ö 5
. Where is it sold? A. Throughout the state of
California, and portions of Arizona and Nevada.
25 Q. Are all your company’s products sold in the same
area? A. Ves, with the exception of food produets; We
have some support business, but we do not have any sup-
port business on bleach. : 5
Q. Now, do you sell your products to direct salesmen, or
do you use a broker or distributor setup? A. All of our
sales in California and Arizona are through our direct
-. salesmen. We have a Cal-Zona Company in Arizona, and
we have these brokers, for example, in the Hawaiian Is-
—
lands for our other products.
Q. What factors determine the sales area in which you
sell your liquid bleach, sir? Sees ä
- (Tr. p. 1757)
A. Of course, transportation is the major factor.
„ 1 „ 4
Q. Mr. Smooke, let me ask. you, sir: Is your appearance ca
here today. in response to a subpoena duces tecum! A.
The 24-pints, $2.10 per case; quarts, 12 quarts per case,
- $1.41; six half-gallons, $1.35; four one-gallons, $1.40.
Q. Are those your current list prices, sir? A. This
is the information I have prepared for me by my office. I
believe it to be correct. j eerie
Q. Now, do you know if your company grants any
2
eee ee
7
>
„
„
id
*
—
*
N
yy
44
cf . voa
Nathan Smooke—Direct |
Cr. p. 1758) Ce ees
n or case allowance discounts from those figures
Wich you have given us? A. At the present time, I
don’t; at least, in Los Angeles, we do not have any special
- allowances at this time, and I would have to refer to San
. Francisco at this time to see if they have a promotion at
this time. I don’t know whether they do or not.
2 56% „ „ @ ;
2. Mr. Smooke, in your years of producing and selling
liquid bleach since 1925, have you had ocddsion to become
familiar with or to study the competitide problems, factors
involved in the sale of household liquid bleach? A. Yes,
Ihave. -
Q. What has been the basis of your ‘knowledge or
_familiarity, sir? A. The — contact with competition
in the field: and
(Tr, p. 1759)
wich the problems connected with. the bléach 8
Q. Will o tell us what are the competitive factors
which determine the success or the failure of your 8
in selling household liquid bleach? N
2 6 „ „ „ ‘ 1
1 It is quality, price, service, advertising; all those fac-
tors enter into problems in meeting N |
Buy Mr. Tincher:
Q. All right, sir; would you tell us what you 1 mean by
the factor, service? A. Service in contacting the retail
store, obtaining his order, having the order delivered and
shipped, and properly displayed i in the store.
Q. Will you tell us, sir, what factors your company con-
siders in setting the price, the charges for honbehold aan :
‘ bleach?
*
ee oa ö .
Mues Sat. bre * gies
A. Tt depends onthe price that we have to meet in ode
_ (Tr. p. 1760)
to sell our produeta. These prices are set by what we call
our major competition, and we have to be in line with com-
petition, or we don’t sell our produet.
By Mr. Tincher:
Q. What products do you mean- by “competition sir?.
A. I would say—do you want ane brand names, is that |
it?
Q. Ves, in your sales area. A. I see. well, of course,
there are Clorox, Purex, chain stores who pack their own
bleaches, and companies that pack private label bleaches.
Q. All right, sir; when you said that you have to be in
line with those prices, can you give us a more definite idea
of what you mean by that term? A. Si ur produet
is not a highly advertised product, our price has to be,
our product has to be sold in a price range that would
attract the user to pick our product up off the shelf. ae
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: By that, you | mean it * has 9
to be lower than the leading brand? |
The Witness: It would be, in order to have some move-
ment off the shelf, yes. g ee
! By. Mr. „Tincher:
Q. Vou have personal knowledge, sir, generally 1
of course, of how much lower than the * —
your liquid | 2 0
a (tr. p. 1761)
| ‘each sells for inthe grocery stores
1 * * * * * 7
A. lt would sell from two to three cents per bottle under
the * advertised brands. mi a
* * * * *
„„ PES ALERTS LE AE A ON POLIT Sy OO OL GR Here IE 5 — — — . — — — U— ei A Pt
& ee 7
oe 772 2 5
Nathan Smoołe Direct
Q. Mr. Smooke, does your company allies the
liquid bleach completely, or does it convert or cut a stronger
solution down to the liquid bleach that you sell? A. We
make the actual product that we pack; when we gell a 514,
we make 514. When we sell the 16 percent, we make the 16.
Q. Do you have any knowledge as to the sodium hypo-
chlorite solution of other brands of bleaches sold in the
sales area that you sell your bleach in? A. Only that
the label reads the same as ours does, and we have the
N same strength produet in our packages. aa !
Q. In selling your household liquid bleach, does your .
company encounter any difficulty in obtaining grocery store
shelf space, sir? A. That's a difficult problem at all
times. | *
Q. What approach do you use, or how do you go about
obtaining grocery store shelf space? A. By the per-
sonal contact our salesman has with the store
5 (Tr. p. 1762)
that 101 is calling upon. |
Q. All right, sir, and what methods, or what dice does
Four salesman use per company policy in calling on grocery —
store —— in an attempt to get this grocery store?
* * * 5 *
A. Iam Lede 9 show our product weil make him the
better net or a higher gross on his cost against the selling
‘price, by him knowing that particular groceryman better
than the other salesmen, by using his personal influence
over the groceryman himself, or during the promotions
when we have deals and specials where he can induce
| grocerymen to give him a better break on the shelf or on
‘stacks in the stores.
By Mr. Tincher:
Q. What * of promotions, do you have reference to?
a
A. Oh, either buy so many cases and get so many ‘free, or
so much per case off if they buy a certain number of cases
of bleach products. | ee | ae
. Axe these, then, promotichs aimed at the grocer him- | 1
self, rather than at the consuming public? © A. The pro
motions are aimed either, No. 1, to meet comp ‘ 4
5 (Tr. p. 1763) . i
tition if there is already a deal in effect or, No. 2, if we :
think it is time for our company to put on a deal, of course, me |
everything is aimed to the ultimate consumer, so that we
get her to pick up the product. 3 N
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft think what he is driving
at there is, whether those tools that you have deseribed 1
refer to the profit that the dealer might make on. your
produets. Does that contemplate that he would reduce the
price further? | 5
The Witness: Ves, he would. He would take the deal ;
* . and saving, and pass that along to the consumer. How- , . ‘
"ever, in some cases he might buy in advance and store some a
product in his back room and make a little extra profit on 4
that at a later tine. eats eames oe
By Mr. Tincher: 75 3 „„ 3
Q. Can you tell us, sir, the number of bleach producers
selling in the same sales area that you sell in and, that is, a
K course, to your knowledge? A. Well, there are
Clorox, Purex, Jefferson Manufacturing Company, and „„
ourselves. That is in the 5 ½ percent. .
* » * „„ * “
N Let me ask you, first, do you consider your household
bleach, the 5%, as being competitive with the industrial
7738 335
. 8 2
WEA Sa nA cae
16 percent? |
A. No, they have no relationship to one another.
N : n ee
Al right, sir, I do not want the others, theny
| Caw you tell us, sir, what percentage of your 3
bleach is gold in grocery stores, af distinguished from drug
oy stores, variety stores, or any other kind of stores? A
We do not have any distribution in drug gtores or vari-
ety stores. It is all in grocery stores. | co
Q. Is any one of the liquid bleach producers a 1 ey!
or a stroriger competitor than the other in your sales area?
CFF 2 a
ea 5 a * 5 * * *
i haps (Tr. p. 1765)
1 * — * *
9. How do you determine, or are you able to deteim'~e
thé market share that your product enjoys in your sales
are, liquid bleach, of course? A. We receive the market
analysis made by the I. A. Times here, and various news-
paper throughout the state, that have a service that breaks
(eras 2 down the proportion of the market that each brand enjoys.
ae : . And how does that, —is that a public document pub-
= lished by the L. A. Times or is that something you sub-
scribe to:? A. We're on their mailing list but I believe
ae anybody. can obtain that for information if they oo desire
1 mae “> 8 2 ; :
| 5 oo Tite : : . a
i 2 — Bra. |
17 < 8 . 8 *
if (re. . 1764) ce
1 eet Rs (Tr. p. 1766) „
* n oe „„ :
| es 1 there any special or unique quality about your
bPowsehold liquid bleach. which aids it in sales over com-
petitors brands? A. No. A
te thre ‘any eder brand in yoor sales .
mat st -" which has any unique or special quality which aids it com:
ia 5 ente: A. I don't think sé. ;
\ Se aang @. Does your company produe any soap or detergents? :
ee A. No,- Chey do not, ah ee .
: Nathan Smooke—Direct . mle Rita
0 Or powdered cleanser? ode No.
5 0. Do you do any sivertiaine: of your household liquid , 1
e A. Tes we do.
the advertising of your household Hid bleach |
“T= 7 “ Ba
* 5
: (Tr. p. n 2
oe your products i is general? A. We advertise it 1 aie 8 ;
or less in a family way of advertising where we, for een
_ample, on our radio broadcasts will mention Sanickor or
our Lady’s Choice products and Challenge Oil and so. forth .
We have a number of brand names and we don’t point to-
a “wards any one where we just try to get the names of our ö
produets before the consuming public. paneer A
Q. Is that a quarter-hour radio program, sir, as distin:
‘guished from spots on cae A. ee] all’ we've: ever
Exeuse me, we've had a newscast at noon up North at a
one time which I guess you would consider to be a program. .
3 (@ “Have you used the TV in advertising your products?
. A. We had, at one time. a :
Q. How:koag ago was that, sir?" A. „ I would say about
two years ago.
2. From the view ‘of ‘your company, sir, which is the
most effective media for . liquid — and your
prodycta? 9
5 * * 2
Q. Radio or television? A. I don’t have an answer 8
to that question. That y an argiesent we've hid tnveur firm 8
ee for years. 5 a
e (Tr. p. 1768) 8
* * * 8 *
3
*
ae : eee
; ee F.
* ©
= es Nathan Smoobe—Direct 55
5 e Can you tell un though; sir, why'you are not using .
TV at the present time? 4 It's far too e for
our firm to use. ,
Q. Do you use an) other ela of advertising, do, you
use magazines? A. No, we do not.
And the same for daily newspapers? A. That's 5
right. Nd magazines or newspapers. , |
Q. Is there any reagon in particujar for not using those,
“sir? A. In the high cost of advertising.
Q. Does your company, in selling household liquid bleach,
have any special seasonal ‘promotion of the bleach at any
particular time of the year? A. No e *
larity, on our deals of specials, no. =<
2. Do you have and vou, of course, I mean your com-
pany,” sir, does your company have any direct contact win
the‘ housewife, and by that I mean, do. you go out and
survey housewives to find out what she ig using or what she
- likes, anything of that nature? A. No, we don't.
: 5 Q. I believe vou mentioned a While ago, sir, private,
labels
—
at
*
(rr. p. 17697 .
ed by some groceries, chains. Can you tell us with on :
ence to the price your Saniclor, for example; sells in grocery . |
. stores, the price generally speaking that these private labels
in.cliain stores sell for? A. Our Saniclor will sell for at
least one cent per bottle peck than the eure label
bleaches. | 8 |
5 * * * * # ‘ 2 8 5
2 Is your company affiliated with, sir, or a subsidiary 1
of any other corporations? A. No, it is not. ee 8
Q Iam sorry, that is one of your, or one of my. double-
barreled questions. Is the answer to both parts of the ques-
tion, No, air?” A. We re not a subsidiary of, nor affli-
ated with any other company.
2 .
2
*
ani QI bellows hn mentioned that vou produce some 8
vnd for grocery chang is that correc, sir? A. Yes,
we do.
5.25 sodium hypochlorite solution as your Saniclor *
A. It's the exact same produet. :
Q. Has your, company een expanding its sales
SEER
(Tr. p. 17700
for liquid t bleach i in recent years? A. No, we haven't: 3
Q. Is your .company producing W W at full
capacity? | . No, we're not.
* & 93 *
“Alan 0. Summen- ess x 5
Q. in the pelea dial bleach that you produce the ane ae
r. p. 170 b
Ln Building,
Los Angeles, California,
April 24, 1958.
Met, pursuant to adjournment, at * 00 a.m.
BEFORE: a
ERRETr F. HAYcraFT, Hearing Examiner. °
(Tr. p. 1776) Pe
~ PROCEEDINGS.
* * * 212 *»„*
Alan C. Stoneman - ‘ 8
resumed the stand and testified further as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION (continued)
By Mr. Tincher:
. Mr. Semi th Pres Corporation, l . ;
tional advertiser? A. Les.
—
ath e e
_ Ta
ee Allen c. Stoneman—Direct
, Win hat media does your company vn u. its adverts
ing? A. Our principal media for the last two years
5 been ‘network television, NBC and CBS. That advertising
has been supplemented by some TV spots and radio spots, |
and also by national magaziné advertising, color and black .
and white, and à small amount of newspaper. .
@ All right, sir. Now, do the networks for television
that you have mentioned grant. discounts. for volume or
continuity of advertising? A. Les, chey do. ;
Q. Are you familiar with this discoun cture? i er
> I am familiar with NBC's and CBB’s discount structure. ig
| D uit a args aera
8 . cp thw opr te
‘ advertiser?’ * |. |
: A. Well, e sista, . ö
8 an advertiser can earn on NBC is 25 percent for nighittime, ©
and 30 percent for daytime network television. NBC, up
until two weeks ago, had also a 25 percent. daytime dis- —.— .
a County but they have just increased it.
3 The discount on CBS is 25 percent whether it be day-
time or nighttime television. "2
By Mr. Titicher: ie F
poe d. What is this discount based on, sir? .
count is based on the time purchased, the amount of
and its continuity.
Now, when a ea dur purchases advertising
time on- television networks, is it possible for him to lump
together all his products in attempting to achieve the dis-
0 count rates? A. Yes.
<= Does the Purex Corporation do-that, sir? A. Les.
” (tr. p. 177 — —
* *
POE HAN RRS pew eri 9 1 . ˙ S ep nn ae”
: 7
7792 5 3 oe
‘| Ere eG ‘Alan c. ‘Stoneman —Direci 3 ye?
| Q. What expenditure is required on the. National Broad:
' casting . .
PUES EE; + (Tr. p. 1778)
n Talking 2 as an 8 the ae rate,- NBC
maximum dan r Sbout $8 million to earn the
a maximum discount. N
„ 2. What year would that — 38 The Présent
one. 8
2. At the peseenit time. At the sand ng or in 1957,
Li it makes a difference, 1 don’t know—what: amount
did the Purex Corporation N in e . 1 ease
ue . =:
aur * 6 * * 8 : as ab,
; A. We spent about a million four on NBC. 4 2 4. ae
» Mr. Tincher:.~ <.- ha 75 5
That would be $1,400,000? FF i.
‘Q.. What discount did that entitle your corporation tof „
A. We earned a discount of six percent. 3
I I might explain, Mr. Tincher, that any figures I give you Coop
on our expenditures: will | for time and p program, bot 7
Sai Whereas, the discounts ar¢ applicable to.time buys only, —
221 see. And can: you tell us approximately, sir, what
percentage of your total cost is constituted by sei cost for
h Program, as distinguished from time? 5 „
Crr. p. 177) . i.
Esa er , 1
Show, it was about 1 & fifty piece time — Sse YS —4
emt, cast ay of eT
i ar = a, N .
2 J A vi : 2 75
: 780 ae .
3 *
Ns Alan C. Stineran-~Direct 8
0 ‘ls any discount earned ty the programt A. No
Q. Do you know what expenditure is required on CBS,
on the television to earn
Columbia Broadcasting 8
the maximum discount ne? A. It is approximately
— NDC forth er dame tne |
Q. How. much did your company spend i in the last fiscal
“year, or calendar year,. whichever is applicable, on this.
network? A. We spent about $2,400, 000.
Q. What rate of discount was that; was that ——
_ Programming, also? A. Les. 7
. Give us the breakdown between programming and
time for your company; approximately the same? A..
About fifty-fifty.
Q. What rate of discount on time did you earn from that
_ expenditure? _ A. We earned 15 percent.
Q. Now, sir, are you familiar with discount structures,
if any, in magazines? And, by Oat 1 mean nationally 3
— ;
Cr. p. 1780)
FEC
magazines that we use; at least, with the important maga- 1
zines that we use.
Q. All right, sir. "Yat the atk you if n can tall in what, 25
those magazines are? A. Well, the’ most important
magazines we have used recently are Life, Ladies Home
*
0
Journal, and Better Homes and Gardens.
Q. Would you tell us the maximum discount which an
advertiser ean ohtain on those magazines: A. In Life,
it is 17 percent; in Ladies Home Journal, it is 12 percent;
and, Better Homes and Gardens; it is 12 percent, pee
— Cr. b. 1281)
“Cid poe GON tie „ 2
* wur for the advertioer to qualify ter those maximum die
ee
. .
— — — a
a nm > af
— 7 * 2 — * 2 ROS pete ro retention a . — e r e 8
5 7 : — sia, —
' ge * :
ph r MM ee
5 a 5 Alan C. Stoneman—Diréct 1B 220 ae
| ‘counts? "AL In Life it a about $2,000,000, 1 think is 5
$2,100,000. In Ladies Home Journal—in Better Homes ag
and Gardens it is about a million dollars, and Ladies Home |
Journal about 3600, 000.
ne Q. Now, in. advertising in thése magazines, let me ask.
Pao first, sir, if the figures you have just given us are an ;
AaAnnnxal rate of expenditure? A. Ves. Well, ‘they are
for the advertising ear. When vou start using a national
magazine, you are’ ‘entitled, to establish a year. from the
jf * date that you first start to use the magazine. This year 5
may not fit your corporate year, or the calendar year- thet
. . When. you commence paying, do you pay at the full
„„ list price? A. Les. ees
8 i Q. If at the end of the year you ‘hevs 1 suffi-
ciently so that earlier i in the year prior to paying you would
have Won entitled to a diseount, is there any adjustment ©
made? A. I am not familiar with the detail of the
bdilling praetices, Mr. Tincher, but you would normally, if
for instance we contracted in Life for three ads, we would
pay the rate that would be demanded by those three ads,
but if during that year three or four ee later we de-
cided to run 25 ads in Life, oy 1 KM 2
is 4 *
9 eee
at aie . p12)
we e would get a retroactive discount covering the origina | a
three, if it came within the advertising. year. ” been ttt
Q. Now, of these three magazines that vou have men-
diened, gir, Life, Better Homes and Gardens, and Ladies er ,
Home Journal, has your company earned the maximum, or .
: has it earned any giscount i in its advertising? A. .
have. Our expenditure in Life was to the order of $70,000, 3
and we did not earn a discount. In Ladies Home Journal
we have earned about 4 2 discount, In Better Homes
Fe 7 — 5 325 * 3 = 4 *
8 4 f OGL „ 4 782 uy a ae 4
0 * 0 aa ° a * a 5 a »
Alan C. Stoneman—Direct”
and Gandens we spent about $68,000, and did sae earn a.
Le | (Tr. p. 1784)
By Mr. Tincher: 35 5
Q. Now, returning to television, Mr. — is ete
a difference in television advertising cost to an adver-
tiser having several products to advertise, and an adyer-
tiser having only one produet to advertise?
rr. p. 1785) f g ,
«„ éͤ“ «„ „ „ f
Les, miilti-prodaets are an advantage i in television | 5
ae might use ag a slinple illustration a company with
one produet that could afford the cost of one program,
versus the company with three products that could atord :
tthe cosk of three programs. i
Hea os, \ ‘In tlie cape of We company ‘with three products, they
„ could put each produet on each program, if it were a 30- : [
1 minute program, and thereby, for the same expenditure on
that produet, buy probably twice the audience that you
could buy if you were limited to one program. .
. I say twice the audience, because I am assuming there :
would be a . overlap between the three programs.
, Examiner Haycraft: Take your products, sO
ie 2 r. we can understand your experience. ha
|" "The Witness: Well, we have never been able to afford i
1 over one program, your Honor, but if I had produet A, and 4
I bought television program from seven to seven- thirty, 1
2 .
eee 7 7
O
Aus C. Stoneman—Direct
Cxr. p..1786)
bon of the program, the middle of the program, and
the end of the program. 5
So, I would be advertising my product’A to that same eh
audience three times. oh =
But now, assume that I had product A, B, and C; 1
; buy three programs, and I buy these contiguous, which
wouldn't ‘make too much sense, but let us assume I
do it. I buy the program from seven to seven-thirty, eight
5 to eight-thirty—seven to seven- thirty, anne
and eight to eight-thirty. ,
I would now have nine opportunitiés to advertige, but
instead of putting product A in the first three spots, 1
would put it in the first one, 1 would put product B in the : 3 5
second, and C. in the third.
I could put A in the fourth, and B in the fifth, and G in
3 and B in the N and 3
C in the ninth. piles
*. 1 * ; *
(rr, p. 1791)
By Mr. Tincher: .
Q. N. ow, would you tell us, Mr. Stoneman, what the rela-
tionship is in value between a 60-second television spot,
and a 60-second commercial on a television program?
8 6. L ·ůãůnn . .
A. Well, a 60-second television spot normally is not pur-
N chased; however, it is less valuable than a 60-second tele-
vision commercial identified with a program, because, in
the case of a 60-second commercial tied in with the pro-
gram, you get the additional value of identification with
the program; whereas, in the case of a spot, you are
running into station breaks, you are running into people
„55
B ö .
tee 2 5 84a : .
f be Alan C2 Stoneman—Direet oe 2 e 6
0 Wriens dial of their * set seeking another pro- *
1 ch a oa atc Natal | fy
x 1 8 r. 1792) 6. :
at is not regarded as being 3s valuable as a 60-second com-
N e di | :
8 * 2 * a
RL Sa Oo Gan;
2 * * * *
ee 8 e tn plircheaing e reflonal 60
index from the Nielsen Company, does the Nielsen Com-
pany have standard zones or regions that you purchase, or
Nielsen? a 0
The Witness: ‘No.
es „ „ „
Gs The Witness: No, you must buy the zone that is avail «
| (tr. p. 1798) 3
divided the country into a number of, zones, a total * All
| e “3
iF is as, . | (Tr. p. 1800)
„ 3 Examiner Hayeraft: Have you ever 3 5
other pre uets with the bleaches in a promotional scheme? ;
5 The Witness: No, not recently - 8
= — this }iinttéd to a conibination offer of
anale of two products at the retail level; is that correct? -
. Mr. Tincher: Well, not necessarily two produets. b
kt os Hearing Examifier Haycraft: That is the way you
understand it? ‘ |
a „ The Witness: _ — I understand. |
6 75 3 2
N * * 5
1 0 *
a ! *
may you order a eee zone that you want covered from
| able. That is the standard Niesen ne Nielsen aa :
4
8B |
Alan C. Stoneman—Direct .
Hearing Examiner Haycratt: Bleche liquid bleacher, ae
and other products? :
The Witness: That is richt.
We have not offered combination. ie
By Mr. Tincher: 2 5
Q.- Well, T
sir, Mr. Stoneman, I believe the first day you were here,
you were asked to obtain some information about a contest, 8
that your company had conducted.
Have you been able to obtain that information às to
‘ whether liquid bleach | was included in the products adver-
tised i in that contest? A. Jes, it was..
Se * *
Crr. p. 1803)
3
2 But 1 N like to ask this one question now, which oF
has nothing to do directly with the record when it does.
come in, I don’t believe. And so, Mr. Stoneman, if I may,
sir, my question is, what. did you mean at record 1575
when you said that the Purex test i in Erie, Pennsylvania, 8
was neutralized? ae ‘
are eee .
The Witness: I meant that the test was-cancelled out.
We made the test forza particular purpose, thé purpose
5 being to accumulate users of a new prodict:in a limited 8
area in a short period of time, not only to accumulate a
* few users, but to accumulate enough users so that research-
| ers could go into the market and make a meaningful sur-
‘vey, if they simply picked housewives at random, because
the Purex. market share did not remain at a reasonably =
good level for but a very short period of time, and because
r
. E
*
ee
8
. 2
mots fe.
4 .
+
}
1
— — — ™
* — * 1
By Mr. Tincher: “
: ©, e en joni tall wa how nt of Pure
Se Se Se ree ae cepa te
| grocery stores?
. The Witness: No.
‘ 786a
iste Ales C. Stonevian—Divect 5
nl EA Penis ‘to db ue e Gb Wezen dat Wo.
fr | ant and pt meng ot ö
3 * * * *
*
(rr. p. 1810)
aR Sb ae *
' A. Five percent; approximately Ave percent.
3 F
s (Tr. p. 1811) |
F „
eleanser business, the total 1 * 1966, * also i
a 19577 f
A. The total market of friction cleansers; both in 1956
and 1957, this is at the manufaeturer's price, not at retail
a peices, | is approximately 355 million.
2
(Tr. p. 1812)
7
0 Mr. 8 are the basic competitive problems in
selling household liquid bleach any different than the basic
— problems in selling powdered nn
ot „ „ «©
„ „„ 0 0
©
e (Tr. p. 1814)
* * a oe -*
G Mr. isis aay ta gusset Wo om, hte, fas snk
f ee eres
*
1
„
— >
? Gamble Company acquired the Clorox Chemica | Company
in August of 19577 A. Tes. ;
ee Will you tell us, please, Mr. Sto an, what effect, if
any, this acquisition will have on the li quid bleach —
of the Pare Corporation, Ltd.?
„ „ ‘es. o%
The Mn The acquisition of Clorox by Procter &
Gamble, in our opinion, will have a serious effect upon
Purex’s business, and Purex’s ability to compete in the
liquid bleach business, particularly if the same promotion
i . applied aha ae normally used by Procter & Gamble are :
e to the liquid ‘bleach’ business.
* Oe Say
ig S 1 RS 2 —
D a *
Room 229, f
Federal Building, 5
Los Angeles, California.
‘ April 30, 1958.
Miet, pursuant to adjournment, at 1:00 p.m.
; ; BEFORE: ö
Pn. rel EVERETT F. HAycrarr, Hearing Examiner.
; * 2 © . &
(Tr. p. 1829)
PROCEEDINGS
@.@ @ 9 4.
(Tr. p. 1830)
oo BR ee
Me Regal 447. 5
Your. e egies het ot figures in 447, except
rr which
) 7888
is a volume entitled “National 1313 Investenesite,”
Volume 9, No. 2, January- -December, 1957.
We do not admit that the spot TV figures are copied
(Tr. p. 1831)
8 that.
Hearing Examiner -Haycraft: Do you recognize the’
Exhibit -448 for identification as an 3 source
for such figures?
Mr. Royall: We think that the ‘Exhibit 448 is an au-
“thoritative source.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: It seems : to me’ e the situa-
tion there is that all Commission’s Exhibit 447 except the
figures with respect to TV Spot, that there is no objec-
tion, and they will be received in evidence, but as to that,
it would be necessary for further testimony to be taken.
(The document referred to, heretofore marked
for identification as Commission 8 Exhibit 447,
was received in evidence.)
e % „ „ 2
(Tr. p. 1837)
3
Mr. Tincher: All right, we will take that o one, Commis- |
sion’s 450 for. W is the Erie, Pennsylvania at
tabulation. .
I might state for the record, sir, that there save been
certain changes in ink made on Commission’s Exhibit 450,
and I am informed that these changes were arrived at as a
result of meetings between Mr. Hanson, representing the
Purex Company, and Mr. Larsen, for Procter & Gamble.
: I will show that to them, and see if that is correct
om N 5 N ae,
4
7892
pro ? di >
: : (Tr. p. 1838) i
Ur. Royall: I think that is a misapprehension on the
part of Mr. Tincher. I understand that we did not agree
to any changes on it. There were some—— 5
Mr. Tincher: What I meant was, it was my under
standing, this is just hearsay to me, that vou did find some
: a that needed correcting.
Mr. Royall: Yes, sir, I think there were some errors
in it wad there were some of them that were apparently
corrected, but I think your inquiry is as to the authentica-
tion of it, is that correet2—WW : mre
uur Tincher: That is as corrected, yes. a ee |
Mr. Royall: As corrected.
Would your Honor give us a second to see the changes?
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: 1 would like to have a
copy of the ae if you can spare me one, so I can follow 1
vou. ay 1
A Aal I will give you the new one. I will 1
; : Cr. p. 1839) f . a
have to look at it again. That i is the one just given to me.
- I haven't read it.
Here is a copy of the one they covered, I should like
vou to see also, but for this purpose the first column
aeross the page headed Shares of Total Liquid Bleach
Market is a correct copy of the M. A. Wallach Research
Corporation, some name like that. . ;
_ > Mr. Tincher: M. A. Wallach Research, Ine. 8 .
Mr. Royall: Research, Inc. The second tolumn which +
deals with the average price per unit as headed here also :
was derived from that source.
The column entitled Merchandising in Stores, this is
‘the seventh colamn down, from Wallach
2 4
°
— —
Dee
re
. sufficiently about Mr. Wallach to make a statement ‘that ae
Bee ourselves for the ture, we make no objection to th
Wallach as an expert or experienced researcher.
correeted.
Cohn & Belden document, and I would have to look at it a
_ + changed. There must be ten or fifteen or twenty. How-
ever, we do not make any point that Foote, Cohn & Belden
We can ae thé hia testify, or I ‘can tell you, which-
ever you prefer.
| - witness testify.
and if satisfactory, we wil! put in the record that it has
They were correctly copied from the Wallach. with’ cer .
tain errors whiek I assume have been eo : |
there i is one simple reason for all the amount of mistakes.
- Proceedings 1
to
o: 2 8 RP: @. 85 >
7 Neither Counsel nor our client have 6 able to find 1 4
— qualify him. | Peace
1 for this en obeasion and not to bnd 2
three columns on the ground of disqualification of Mr.
Vour Honor, may I look at that one a second to see if
the changes, the errors on there, 6 :
a 2 2 **
Mr. ure „And. the fourth, sdvertisivig schedule, two
advertising schedules, and the one coupon, were prepared
by Foote, Cohn & Belden, that is, the basic data was. There
were very many mistakes in the take-off from the Foote,
little more carefully to say immediately that it was
is not qualified in this matter.
Mr. Tincher: Mr. Examiner, Mr. Royall i is correct and
(Tr. p. 1841).
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: You had better have the
Mr. Tincher: All right, sir: 3 |
Mr. Royall: But we ‘will compare those, Skee Cie,
# 1 . : * 5 ‘ 2 f 3 2 is 8 4 4 : . ; a
2 % . a . ae 791a er . : ‘ f 89 Y -¢ * 3
Proceedings ©
vom been corrected and if wé find otherwise before tomor-
ro ing, we will ask Your Honor to permit us to doo
— — 80 80 we won't held up the trial. :
No that leaves open the situation of the sixth, I believe
it is the sixth horizontal column, price per unit in store.
The chart indicates that that: was obtained by telephone |
‘call from a Purex sdlesman: All we know about him is
We have not been furnished any figures that would
enable us to check the accuracy of these figures, and m- mt
parison with the only source we have of Clorox does not 1 — i
indicate that we can agree to the accuracy of the figures J
that column has. | 3 Bie he 1
Ur. Tincher: May I inquire, Mr. Royall, is it merelß |
the Clorox prices that you can’t agree on, or all the prices?
Mr. Royall: The only ones we could check were the
* Clorox ones. We were not given any data as I am informed
ae ; „ (Tr. p. 1842) :
enabling us to check the Purex one, though we would like
to have had it, ; „
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Is that all that remains
of the exhibit? | | 15 :
Mr. Royall: No, sir, there is one more.
Now, Your Honor, we were permitted to go to the
Purex records on the last column or two columns, it looks
like it might be denominated either Purex Factory List
and Clorox Factory List, and we find they are correct.
8 E2 1 „ „ * , '
. . (Tr. p. 1845)
: 5 * * 82 * @ ;
: Mr. Royall: Now, Your Honor, as to this copy
this Exhibit 450, which was offered and which is now, has
had certain changes made in it, we would like to request
—
—
>
i 1 57 5
b ; = ie
FF 1 eee .
. that both of them be in the end to the extent they are :
„ Hearing Examiner. Hayéraft ‘What do you mean, both? .
* Mr. Royall: ‘Both the one they prepared first, and the
obs that was prepared second. |
Bit Hearing Examiner Haycraft: No, I am going to let the
3 e t wat ts sep, sny; { will admit, the er
rected exhibit. . f
ee ‘That is richt.
Maite 5 „23% „656
W be) N Crx. v. 1846)
. * * 8 1 * 3
2 5 Alan C. Stoneman
° 8 been previously worn, resumed the stand and testi ,
= futher as follows:
0 . *
DIRECT EXAMINATION (Continued)
By Mr. Tincher: ä aes
. Mr. Stoneman, lot rie hand y you Commission’ s Exhibit
0
*
450, which has been struck, and J just want to ask you a os
res few questions about it.
Hearing. Examiner Haycraft: Now, ‘wait a minute.
"Exhibit 450 has not been struck. 451 was struck.
2 * oS: 6:
; ry Mr. Tincher: : Bs kee
4 : g 5 e. p. 70 at,
ior . Let me ask you, Mr. Stoneman, in the activities \ |
| tes which are reported under the various horizontal columns
15 age reported 80 as to be in the proper time period in the
* vertical columns? A. Tes.
Bi . Now, 1 wonder if you could, for eximple, in the
second horizontal ae average pee per unit sold, vari- .
703% .
Alan C. Stoneman Direct
— ¢
ous abbreyviationg appear there: 1 wonder if vou would 5 .
abbreviation is, and what it
state for the record what the
stands for? A. Quart“ is abbreviated “Qt”; the abbre-
*
viation one-half, the: fraction means half-gallon; the ab-
breviation G“ means Gallon, Be aie ae i
2. And are the various figures which are reported in
cents, sir? A. Yes, the figures reꝑꝑrted in cents are the
retail prices reported by Wallach.
2 „ „ % (Scere ae
„
Q. All right, sir, and in the horizontal column entitled
Merchandising in Stores,” would you please explain what
dhe abbreviation “Dist.” stands for? A. The abbrevia-
dising in Stores” means distribution. :
All right. Now, Commission's Exhibit 450 that you
‘tion “Dist.” in the horizontal column captioned “Merchan-
are holding, under the horizontal columin “Couponing” has
various incorrect notations, will you tell us, if you can, the
reason for the error in that column which has been cor-
“rected?. A. Yes, The original figure of 80,000 which
was struck and replaced by ‘a’ figure, of 68,208, was an
estimated figure of the number of coupons that would be
mailed in Erie. The 68,208 was the actual count of the
number of coupons that were mailed according to Reuben
H. Donnelley’s mailing list for Erie County,
Q. Were the original computations based ‘upon the
original 80,000 estimate, or on the actual mailing? A.
No, I think the original, I think the computations were
taken from the invoicing and coupon redemption. The
coupon cost here includes the coupon mailing as well as
the coupon redemption. 5 e, ee,
Q. All. right, sir. In that same horizontal column on
couponing, is the redemption of coupons, the percent ‘that
*
* .
— —— ee.
— .
* o>
. 5 794 me
Alan C. Stoneman—Direct |
is indicated there, is that when they. were returned to the |
Purex isi Ltd., or returned * the retail grocer
by the
(Tr. p. 1849) g ;
consumer? A. This is’ the redemption .of coupons i in
this column under couponing is shown in the vertical’ col-
- umn opposite the vertical column which carries the date
that we paid the retailer for the coupons; when. we re-
’ * deemed them, not when the housewife turned them in at
(Tr. p. 1851)
Q. Well, let me direct your attention to advertising
schedule—Clorox. You notice, in advertising schedule
- Clotox, you will notice at the end of “Total Advertising”
in both ends, there are arrows indicating the time period
covered. Why, I am asking you now on Purex what the
beginning of the total advertising, r
* 2 „* ite
The Witness: To * ‘a total advertising
schedule for. Purex began on 10/14, and ended on * a
4
: (Tr. p. 18862
. 10/14/67, ane 3/31/58.
ö I would like some com-
ments on the corrections made on your TV spot announce-
ments there!
b Mr. Tincher: Yes, 1 think the document speaks for
itself. I don’t recall exactly.
The Witness: With respect to these corrections on spot
announcements, your Honor, eS nee
Tes.
e be
| , „
the same time period that was contemplated, and they are
given considerable latitude to shift, ag long as it does not
change the overall pieture, or the overall effect, and that
is the reason for these correction.
5 (Tr. p. 1853)
run, and the other is the actual.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: By the other, you mean
the, penned corrections? —
The Witness: The pen corrections are the actual. | ;
s
Buy Mr. Tincher:
2. Then I would ask you the same question, sir, with
i respect to the changes ade in the newspaper" advertising.
* * * * * - :
as I see it, if you will give me a second to add them up,
A. Well, this is a shift in the advertising schedule and,
there is 14, 20, 26, 30, versus 10, 20, 26; there was a
program. I do not kpow offhand what the reason for that
R 1
By Mr. Tincher:
Q. All right, sir, but do you know that thé inked figures
are the correct figures of what was actually run? „A.
*
2 2
Palys
. 5 .
— pee
ELON EN iN BORE ed ea ee
2
n
stamped
4 8 : — * eo Sas : 2 8
Alan C. Stoneman Direct
„ Crp 18s
EE 1 „ „ „*
L notice in the column entitled, “Merchandising i in
ae Stores,” there has been an inked oorreetion in the vertical
column, 16-23, stating ironing board cover 1 6 per-
eent distribution.
I wonder if you could explain to us the : reason for that |
correction? A. Well, this apparently was a posting
_. from the Wallach Reports which was not made, and was
picked up on the second review. This is an addition that
indicates that the ironing board cover offer, this is in the
Clorox colurth, y Sundry, rater than iy erty Pebrhary,
market in early. Jan rather than in early February
reported.
All right, sir; then I notice tn: the couponing hori-
x zontal column, there is an inked correction for the month
of March on the chmulative redemption of coupons. Let
me ask you if you know the. reason for that correction?
A. That was an error in posting.
ee . e r up. 5
N 3 Hayeraft: This is the 1 ex-
hibit, that I have in my hand 28 05 better get it-
—
K
. or. o p. 1962) 8
up and run u pensied “X-wise” * through, this-that has not aa
been received. ~
(The document above: referred to; heretofore’
marked Commission's Exhibit 450 for identifica- +
*
tion, was received in evidence.)
„ d m
i. n ey
x 2 i 5 f 4 0 f . f Baa : .
pe Oe a ee '
ce eeee toe C. Stoneman—Direct ab ay ge on Ae
y Mr. Tincher : 1 „
Q. And on “page 1521, sir, I will refer you to line 4, :
and on all these I am giving you, my question is, if there . 7
is any correction, addition or explanation that needs to be
given. A. The sentence which includes line 4 on page
15621 reads that: vlt also manufactures Drano, which is
2. bowl cleaner which is distributed regionally in te
West.“ That should read: It also manufactures Purnxn !
~ “Grain opener and a bow! 8 : „
5 aie, << panes 3
which is distributed regionally in the West. 2
| 5 * ae es esi us i °
Lau right, sir. And to page 1528, line 7, and in
answer to your response, sir, my question is not just an..
thing wrong, if there is anything that needs to be ex f
plained or added. A. Well, line 7 is incomplete in that 5
New Orleans, Louisiana, should he added as a liquid bleach | aS
‘point of production. _ : 5 i
—
cleaner
„ (Tr. p. 1871) 5
. Mr. Stoneman; you were asked on page 1578 to check
when were the last times you had used price reducing 2 7
coupons to the ‘consumer; do you have that information?
4 May I refer to the page? 1
2 Yes, it is page 1578 line 21. A: Yes, the two
Taeecent uses of price reducing coupons were in Erie, Penn-
gylvania, in 1957; San Antonio, Texas, in 1954.
1 0 And, do you know how Many coupons were used in
the Texas area, sir? A. 250,000. W
a a — S „„
C ME iso
2 23 „% „46 eee
*S9
798
Alan 0. Stoneman—Direct
“(By Me, ae: | is „
5 Let me ask you, sir, you were talking the other day,
you may recall, about freight cost, and glass cost, and you
gave certain percentages. 9
Let me ask you if those percentages are percentages of
55 the selling price, or of the selling eost of the liquid bleach?
A. They are the percentages of the selling price.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Which ones were those?
We don’t want to hunt i in the record.
Mr. Tincher: That, sir, was . 1678, -on two occa- *
sions, Lines 12 and—— .
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: What were the percent
ages he gave? eae
What were the percentages you gave, do y@ remember?
_ The Witness: They were 14 percent, approximate per-
. centages were 14 and 40, and the accurate ä oat
were 38 and 14, and 14.33, I believe.
Hearing Examiner 2 . is an the selling
r ; 7
The Witness: Yes, oe .
‘By Mr. Tincher:
8 All right, sir; then you testified the other day
(Tr. p. 1879) ° 3
concerning Old Dutch Cleanstr . a — agent i
Py it prior to Comet.
Let me ask vou if Old Dutch n first
produet of any kind to have a bleach agent, or the first
ee .
* * * 82 *
A. The first suring cleanser.
{i
Alan C. Stoneman—Cross |
(Tr. p. 1881) \
: CROSS EXAMINATIONS =
By Mr. Royall; = | ere
Pa ae Ger ree ee
™ (Tr. p. 1902) =
a 222 * — : |
Q. Now, Mr. Stoneman, you gave testimony about your
television network programs. I will ask you if all or part
of those have not been cancelled and whether it’s all or
part? i — ;
(Tr. p. 1903) .
A. Those programs have finished, yes.
Q. Are they over? A. You can buy a television—
yes—you buy à television for a certain period and they
have run their course. 5
7
* * * * *
. Q. They have run their course, and you have substituted
. Other forms of advertising for them, haven’t you? A.
~ That’s correct. 5 8
Mr. Stoneman, in your testimony you were asked
bout the new bottle, or new bottle or the new bottle handle
on Purex bleach. That was a pioneer venture you worked
out with the glass company, wasn't it? A. That's right.
Q. What company)? A. That's Latchford Marble. a
„ es (Tr. p. 1904) }
L In connection with the use of sampling for the sale
of liquid bleach, is it not a fact that weight and breakage _
are factors militating against the sampling of it? a. °
Yes. * . « 1 ae
800a
Alan C. Stoneman—Cross
Q. Are you familiar with the Nancy Sasser purchase
price refund promotion? A. Yes, we’ ve used it scaly J
believe in 1953. 7
Q Since then? A. Not that I naire of. ie
Q. That was a sampling operation, wasn't it? A.
a Yes, a very small one.
Q. Mr. Stoneman, did Purex recently advertise the fol-
lowing, “a special ingredient has been added to provide
even penetration, faster cleaning action?“
| (Tr. p. 1905)
me Yes, .
By Mr. Royall:
Q. Now, do you know about when this. was put out?
A. Yes. This is a brochure that was prepared for the
Erie program, Erie introduction. |
Q. Now, in that same program—and_ I show it to you—
J
did not you work out a system for suggested retail price?
A. Ves.
* * * 2 2
„ rr. p. 1909)
* * * * —
Q. Now, 1 believe you testified that, beginaing in Oc-
tober, 1956, you shifted to a direct sales force i in bleach ; ’
is that right) A. That's correct.
Q. I will ask you if from that date until the date of oe.
this merger, which is in question in this ease
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: 1 57.
By Mr. ne 6, ;
(Tr. p. 1910)
0. A 1, 57, if your market share on Nielsen didn't
drop from 15. 2 to 14.77.
0% |
Alan C. Stoneman Crus 5
—
A. Our ‘marketshare on liquid bleach, our rate of.
growth, I will state that a little differently, our rate of
growth on liquid bleach has been less than the rate of
growth of the total bleach market over the period of the
last four or five years.
However, the exact amount of any market deterioration 35
that Purex suffered between October and August, I don't +
have on the tip of my tongue. I would be glad to supply it.
Mr. Royall: I want to make it clear that I was speaking
of the percentage of the liquid bleach market, and does
that help you any in your answer? N .
The Witness: No. We have a number of products, and
a number of reports. I don't attempt to remember them
all. 75
2
* * * * *
(Tr. p. 1917)
Q. Did you testify before the Federal Trade Commissicn
on October 24, 1952, at Los Angeles, California?
| r. 5 1918) =
Hearing Examiner Hayeratt: 5
* * R * *
Incidentally, I take official notice, of course, that thaꝛt
Was a proceeding entirely foreign, on different grounds. I
Just don’t see where you could possibly tie the two to-
gether. — ae
By Mr. Royall: ns
. Mr. Stoneman, did you not in 1952, in October, 1952,
“testify under oath the following:
“Question: I take. it that the competition that your
respondent company has had to meet is more or less
on a price basis, is that correct, Mr. Stoneman?.
*
ee
55 * ene
is that supposed to attack? What are you contradicting?
: I can point it out to you, of course.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: I-sustained the objection
By Mr. Royall:
testify under oath that the most e thing to the
housewife is price?
~ compete with local brands more frequently than we com-
pete
witht Clorox”?
— . *
9 *
— é
—
* — 2
—
Alan C. Stoneman—Croes
“Answer: Les.
Question: . Purely and simply price; quality of
product is not an item?
“Answer: No. Price is the most important factor.“
Mr. Tincher: I object to the question; it refers to past
periods, periods prior to 1952.
Mr. Royall: No, it did not.
| (Tr. p. 1919)
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: What direct testimony
Mr. Royall: Well, he gave a lot of factors, Your Honor.
Mr. Royall: You sustain the objection?
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Yes. 3
Mr. Royall: All right.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Not proper cross exami-
nation, too remote a period of time.
. I will ask yon if you didn’t also at that same period ,
Mr. Tincher: Object, sir. : |
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Sustained.
By Mr. Royall:
Q:. I will sak yon, sir, if you didn’t testify under oath
in October, 1952, speaking of Purex liquid bleach: “We
*
Fr. 5. 1920)
Mr. Tincher: I object, sir.
KR
- “<
c PPP : res 8 —
Fee
Berke Examiner Haycraft: ‘Sustained. _
By Mr. Royall:
a Q I will ask you if you didn’t testify under oath in
October, 1952, that there are oe. bleach manufacturers
in the United States“?
Mr. Tincher: Object, sir. :
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Sustained.
76 & oe "8s
8 3
Room 2295,
Federal Building,
Los Angeles, California.
Thursday, May 1, 1958.
Met, pursuant to adjournment, at 10 bans a.m.
BEFORE:
EVERETT F. HAYcRAFT, Hearing Examiner. |
* . ** * * a 4
(Tr. p. 1926)
PROCEED G8
— oa
* * „ * *
Mr. Royall: Yes, sir, I do, and I would like very much
do ask Mr. Tincher’s attention: to it because this comes
. to me from Mr. Larsen and Mr. Watkins, and I want to’
be sure that we have no misunderstanding about it.
The Counsel met yesterday afternoon with the Govern-
ment Counsel and Purex Attorneys and in general an
. understanding was s reached: about certain of the matters.
* 2 «* * *
We have been advised that it is impossible to determine
>
trom ie Puen records the ne cost to liquid
.
were ene al
— — 2 er
.
at et ee ee
a, a 2
bleach here as sold through brokers or through direct :
salesmen. 2
They also advise that wehre do not show n of
cost to liquid bleach, which is part of the same thing. __
= . that er has attempted to make this
(Tr. p. 192777 1
allocation and has found it impossible. That's what we,
are advised, and it is doubtful if even a N audit
would give vou the facts.
E 2 & „ : :
Sat? esting Examiner Haycraft: It depends on whether or
not you are willing to accept those statements off the rec-
ord or whether you want the gentlemen who advised you. fers
that to make the ‘Statement under oath on the witness
stand. 15 J
Mr. Royall: What I thought; Your: Honor, is—— : .
Hearing Examiner Haycraff: If you are satisfied and
willing to stipulate that that is the case.
i Mr. Royall: I am satisfied unless there is some mis-
5 understanding with ‘counsel for the ‘Other side. If both
counsel say that, I don’t want any witness. I mean, I
would not seek on cross examination on ‘that, because I
75 ‘don’t know enough about it and J have no reason to at this
time think that there is anything except a cortect state-
ment about it. We have nothing to the contrary. .. j
As to the private label bleach sales, Mr. Evans wil!
meet with our accountant here at 2: :00 o’clock, as I under- -
stand, with a summary-of those sales, and the. accountant
will go over them with him and will look into, among
; other things, the allocations and systems used. 3
It seems te me —_— that that conference might,
; (Tr. p. 1928) Pd
solve the ‘situation; but we ssi can't definitely know
until that: time. ;
ail ae
POO, ELE IR FC (magne r rr. 7
, 8050
*
”
By Mr. Royall:
; Alin C. Suden Ctwas
ll Mr. Tincher, does that differ in any way from
* the facts as you understand them?
Mr. Tincher: No, sir. It isshasically o correct,
\
\ 7 a 2 2 2 „ü
(Tr. p. 1930)
8 % a 2 * f
Mr. Royall: L am not trying to argué this thing, Your
Honor. I’m just trying to state the facts. x
Third, we asked fer reports, suryeys, records, all iter 7
\
_ , documents.and memoraridum supporting testimony that a
multiple product line enables a manufacturer to obtain
more shelf space in retail outlets. a
We were informed they do not have such records
* * _* „ * 8
Tr. p. 18
8 * * a *
Alan 0. india
resumed the stand and testified further as follows:
CROSS EXAMIN ATION (cont.)
„ & 3
(Tr. v. 1935) :
* coe «„ *
Qi believe you testified also that ‘the couponing for
ä your Erie promotion was handled by Reuben Donnelly, is
chat correct? A. Ves.
Q. That is an independent organization? J 4 Ves.
Q. Its services are available to any company that they
desire to deal with, is that correct? A. That's correct.”
° a
*
*
8
2 ———
- *
— 5
Re >
* r 1 eee
—
rr
Alan C. Stoneman Cross
Q. Does it sometimes represent a number of companies
- in a joint coupon venture? A. Yes, it does.
‘ * * * .
5 (Tr. p. 1936)
0 aaa now give me ‘Exhibit 448. :
Now, these figures of net sales appearing on Exhibit
443, 8 eased | A. I. don't recall it a
exactly.
Q. Let me give it to you, 2 I couldn’t remember
exactly the form of it, myself. A. Yes.
Q. Now, that does not include any private bleach - or
industrial bleach, does it? A. No.
(Tr. p. 1937)
Q. Those fi are after the deduction of 8
and other discounts for stock protection and special pro-
motional allowances, are they not? A. Yes.
* * *. * &
0. Do you have any schedule of” quantity discounts for
liquid bleach alone? A. Yes.
Can you make that available to us with little dif-
culty? A. Yes, I can tell you. sao aceite
vou from memory.
We have a 2 percent for carload or truckload, and 1
percent for half carload or truckload. That is depending
upon the territory and the regulations that govern truck
shipments. The truckload varies from 900 cases to as low
as 500 cases, and, hence, a half truckload or carload varies
from 450 to 250.
Q. Now, Mr. Stoneman, don’t answer this/ question
until his Honor has ruled on it.
_ Yesterday, I asked you if you were either planning to,
807a
Alan C. Stoneman—Cross
(Tr. p. 1988) »
or were about to, change your 6-cent allowance, and the :
Court excluded that testimony. |
: I now ask you if it wasn’t changed as of today?
A. Is your question directed toward a specific area, or 5
is it directed toward the national?
By Mr. Royall: one N
Q. Will you give me the area, sir, while you are answer-
ing the question? ‘I don’t know. | 5
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: He started to answer
yesterday, I remember, in some area. I am not going—or,
J am going to let him answer, because apparently, there
may be — further testimdny developed by Respondent
on that, an 5 |
what they might be, than some conjecture as to what
they are. . „
A. In the San Francisco territory, I am not sure of the
date, but it is at least a very recent one, within the last
two weeks, we.withdrew the 6 cents per case promotional
SMS
allowance, and substituted a 10-cent-per case cooperative
advertising allowance that had formerly been in effect up
to some point in 1956, I think it was, the spring of ’56.
The present allowance requires proof of advertising for
‘payment, whereas, the previous allowance did not require
such proof. 3
‘ * * *. * *
(Tr. p. 1940)
f „ „ „ „ („
By Mr. Role e , -
The effect of changing from the system that ‘you,
*
*
have been following to the 10-cent system has a net effect
I think I would rather have the facts as to
— —
—— —
a
E
Ry, See
*
ö
,
:
0
* *
ae “Alan C. Stoneman—Croes ay |
et increasing your price’ tn the berhery bs vie Ht is
applicable, does it not? A. It is not! mare true.
Mr. Tincher: I object. .
* — ö Overruled. He std an-
swer. ag eon 5
By Mr. Royall: ene
Q. And that.would be shown by records, would it saad
Bers Thors records micht be very difficult to get. Ifyou =
. p. 1941) „ a
8 a G-cent alléwanes that is paid to direct buyers, your
a cost. 1&6 cents per. case on those cases that are sold to
v
direct r If you have a 10-cent allowance that is paid
on proof of „vour cost is that percent of the
. - cases that you self and which you get proof of advertising.
Now, if 60 percent of the cases supplied you with proof *
of — obviously your cost or be the same. go
„„ „ @- an
(tr. p. 1944),
Q. Mr. Stoneman, who prepared this exhibit? A.
, That exhibit was prepared by. our Market Research De- .
x (tr. 1. 1945) ö
* „ ö 5
Qt Did Mr. Wallach prepare this exhibit? At
don't know, No, he didn’t prepare that exhibit. You mean
did Mr. Wallach prepare the information that he sent to
ust. I don’t ee y
partment. 9
1 By. Mr. Royall: =. |: 0
Q. You said he made reports for other places; what
5
: pice: Shonen Cro
8
were they? 8
| (Tr. p. 1952) a
Mr. Tincher: “Object, sir. It is beyond the ‘scope
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: eee,
By. Mr. Royall: ~
G. Did he make one on n Evansville? nD
Mr. Tincher: Object, sir. 5
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: ‘Sustained!
Mr. Royall: Your aan, 0 I state the purpose of
that?
Hearing 8 Hajeeadt: Well, I don’t W it
was not gorfe into on direct examination with this witness
on Evansville. This exhibit does not purport to cover
| — There i is no exhibit in ae on Evansville,
ek oe an 0
. Royall: Your Honor, they obi him on » Evansville 0
5 on direct examination. pied
(Tr. p. 1953)
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: They asked him about a
It of other things, but no exhibit’ was presented on Evans-
„ ville. That is the thing to be determined here now.
Mr. Royal}: . Apparently, we differ. on it, but I do like
do give you my point of view. I do not conceive that direct.
examination is a complete confine of cross examination.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: That i is my ruling, and
; always has been, Mr. Royall.
Mr. Royall: Yes, ‘I understand.
.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Im order to . the ae ee
record down within some reasonable size. I. always give
counsel sca —— an nn to present their
* g : ~ A 7
» >
— ? e — .
‘
2 SES N 2 228 n 1
R * E eke 5 — ss 8
ie 4 2 4 we * — a oe Soa ais —
8 . 7 K ;
. * 0
| 810 | | :
a 3 !
. N of the complaint, but I do not let them mix it up,
so far as I can. Of course, I’ got myself in a boat a while
ago when I allowed a question I originally sustained the. -
, objection: to. That is just an illustration of what I would
„ be doing if I used more liberal rules of crogs examination. =i
e ä The first thing you know, you would heve your care in, and.
1 N the Commission would not have = ‘iene:
* * oo * *
1 p. 1954)
ik OR . Dev
=
. 0 *
* 82 ** 5 *
G 0 Now, Mr. b een how many other bieach brands
were sold in Erie, Pennsylvania, during this. ae „
I don't know. >
You know that there. were others, a5 you not? A.
Yes. Our study covered 101, Clorox, Purex, and then all
bother brands were thrown in a single category.
2 6 Q You do not mow the names of any of those?
VV
8 The Witness: No, oe 8 are oe
ae „ F ea:
(Tr. p. 1971)
5 on „ „ „„ „ „66
By Mr. Royall: 3
. Let’s put it this way. You did start Beads Oles
© between 52 and 57, didn’t you?. A. Yes. :
Q. ‘What is that product? A. That's a we chlorine
bleach. |
* 5 @ * * * :
(Tr. p. 1984) iia
ere 4 paver, *.
* * 829 9
7 811
oe Stoneman—Cross ae „
Mr. Tincher: Mr. Examiner, while we are talking 50 5
much about the Purex case, will you take official notice —— aay
2 that the complaint in that case was dismissed?
* . Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: l of course, can, but
I don’t see what relevancy that is to this case. | 8
a „ Let me make clear, Mr.-Tincher, that the only reason ü N
8 that any reference is being made to that ease at all, as I
indicated yesterday, is that this witness, if he testified in
that casé to the same facts that he testified to in this case,
9 cS.gctensibly the same facts, purportedly the same facts, then
Counsel for the respondent is entitled to call his attention
to those, that other testimony, if it is contradictory to the 3
18 testimony he has given in this case, for the purpose at Sees
8 impeachment, but that is as far as he can go. e
f That is as far ay Lam going to allow any reference on 1
eee that case. I want no further examination on Mr. 8880 “4 8
gS a „„ ewes of. fo, pk eR „ | 5
(Tr. p. 1988)
„
f 0. ‘Now! Mr. Stoneman, is it not, true that the price of
_ Purex is higher than the price of Clorox, not only in the
Erie situation that you testified about, but in Louisville,
San Francisco, southern Oregon, and perhaps others? ;
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: 228 mean the retail | &
1 price, or the wholesale? 5
1 Mr, Royall: The price at which the Purex Company
7. @ sells. A. Garey, * it is. not true. The Pries of
Purex was ieee
a 5 (Tr. p. 1060) . .
"ig a little higher in Erie and in either Louisville or Evans-
ville; I am not sure which, for a short term 3 à mar-
bet test. *
* *
4
< .
\ a 1‘ « °
* Sr * + *
8123
in ©. Stoneman—Crose’
3 The price of Purer was higher in the Bay area; that i is, 5
San Franeisco, in certain other territories served by our
San Leandro plant, for a short term, during this year.
I would have to refresh my memory to get the exact
dates that was. That term did not extend over ninety _
days, however, and the present price in the Bay area is
just the kame as the pricasof Clorox, as well as in all terri-
’ tories served by the San Leandro: plant, at the present,
time. 7
I think maybe the information you have is out of —
as of * as of today. Ae
« . & * * 2 &
cr. p. 20100
1 Mr. 1 I believe you, “have already testified,
have you not, that the private label bleaches sold at Some-
what lower prices than the Purex bleach? A. Ves.
mee And, therefore, a percentage on the comparison of
the units, rather than a comparison of the dollars, would
result in a slightly higher percentage of the private labels
dleach, would it not? A. Well, you
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Your total business.
4.4 continuing) ‘The comparison given was the percent
of the dollars to the total dollars of sales, so you eannot
compare the percentage of units of private labels to the
total units of sales, because now you are ne pea-
nuts and apples. '
By Mr, Royall: |
Q. Yes, sir, but you.can compare the total units of pri-
vate label: bleach with the total units of Purex blench,
can’t you? 5
3ͤ ͥ ũ „ 5
F
* 7 Q .
813a
Alan C. Stoneman — Cross
“By Mr. Royall: is „ „„
Q. You do have those unit figures, because you testified
(Tr. p. 2011)
as 1 the difference i in market share, whether you figured
one way or the other, didn’t you? A. That's right.
. Yes, Now, we ask for those.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: His question, Mr. Stone.
man, is whether or not if you figured that percentage: of
VFour private brands business on a unit basis would be a
higher percentage than on a dollar basis.
The Witness: That's correct. 5
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Do vou have any idea
of how much higher; do you have a figure on that?
The Witness: Well, instead of being on the order f
114 percent, it would be on the order of about 1. 8 *
—_— is an estimate, your Honor.
+ * „ „„ „„
(Tr. p. 2012)
* 2 #18 «©
Mr. Royall: It bes been suggested off the record, your
Honor, that that would increase the ratio from 1.5 to
somewhere between 1.8 and 2 percent. We will not, under
_ those circumstances, ask for the figures, because we wanted
them only for the ptirpose of getting that determination.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: All right.
Mr. Tincher: May the record show I agree with. coun- 5 ;
a sers 6
~ * * * . *. *
(Tr. Pp. 2015)
* 2 » * *
8I4a_ | |
Alan C. Stoneman. Redirect
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. Tincher: a 6
Q. You testified yesterday afternoon your Tv program * od
schedule had finished. Te |
Would you tell us what Media you are using now in 3
place of TV? A. We are using magazine n ö 0
some newspaper, some ee
: Ctrr. p. 2016), 5 f
radio spots in limited areas. : „
2. Would you tell: us why you did not e the L
program when it aus! ae | | ae, 2
3 | 1 We discontinued the TV program because we had
spent all the money that was budgeted for the current
. "fiscal year, and allocated to T. .
By Mr. Tincher:
F .
Now, I think you will recall, Mr. Sen, that Mr.
Royall asked you if. you were aer with a drop in
market
oe | (Tr. p. 20170 f
5 shave | ao reported in Nielsen from 1952 to 1957 of the .
Purex Corporation.
Do you recall that? A. Yes, eon
And, also, a similar drop subsequent to 9
1956 until August of 1957.
Do you recall that? A. Les.
Q. Now, have you had a chance to check N 33 to see
it the percehtages given you in the question, the market
share percentages, were correct?- A. I. have picked .up
is somé additional data on Nielsen which I have before me
with respect to our market share, Purex’s market share,
. 815
Alan C. Stoneman Redirect
in relationship to the total market. This data is not tabu-
lated on the same for the same periods as the data that
Mr. —" showed me.
F
The Nielsen data i is from June Ist to May 31st, whereas, 15
our fiscal year is from July Ist to June 30th, Nielsen
being compiled on a two-month 3 e two
(Tr. p. 2018)
months not fitting our fiscal period, this is as eee as we
can get to a Nielsen . ir relation to Furer 8
fiscal year. }
. All right, sir. Now, let me ask you if your investiga-
tion of Nielsen does indicate a decrease in market share.
for the Purex Corporation on liquid bleach from 1952
to August 1 of 19577 A. Not for all periods. Specifi-
cally using the period June-July, 1952 to April-May, 1953
as a base period, the following percentage change occurred ©
for the brand Purex liquid bleach; from June-July, 1952,
April-May, 1953 to June-July, 1958, April-May, 1954, a
loss of 4.6 percent.
During this period, the total market expanded 2.7 per-
cent.
(Tr. p. 2019)
* * * *
Q. Now, the period you have just mentioned, sir, was
this prior to acquisitions as described by Mr. Royall in his
questioning to you yesterday? A. Yes, this was prior
to any acquisition of a new product by Purex.
Q. Was this prior to the change from broker system of
— to direct salesmen? A. Yes.
Alan 0. Stoneman—Redirect
Q. Now, let me ask you if your research of Nielsen will
‘indicate whether there has been any change in market
share subsequent to changing from the broker system to
* salesman system? ,
A. Yes. The period, looking at a ak June-July
1955 to April-May of 56, which is the period just prior
to the change to brokerage selling that occurred in Octo-
ber of 56, in comparing that period to the June-July,
1956, April-May, 1957 period, we find that the June-July
56 to April-May, 1957 period is the only period in the
last five years where Purex’s gain in market share equalled .
the gain in total market. As a matter of fact, ft slightly
exceeded it. Purex’s increase was 4.8 percent, and the
gain in the total market was 4. 6 percent. N
(Tr. p. 2020)
The Witness: This period ineludes
several months of direct, selling.
f (r. p. 2023)
By Mr. Tincher: ' ‘
Q. Just one final area of i inquiry, sir: You-testified this a
morning concerning the 90-day period in the San Fran-
cisco Bay area where Purex was selling at a higher price
than Clorox. |
(Tr. p. 2024)
1 do I understand correctly that that is not true
today? A. Yes. N
. Will you explain to use why during this 90-day period
the Purex pricé was higher? A. 4888 that was
817 f N a ;
8 ee * C. Stoneman—Redirect |
about 90 days: I didn’t check the exact dates on it; about
90 days, I think, is proper, is eorreet.
Purex increased the price of liquid bleach in the San
Francisco Bay area coincidental with the introduction of
its new package. This increase was a minor one; it was
s eents on half gallons.and 4 cents on gallons.
Q. Is that a case? A. ‘Per case, ease of half gallons,
case: of gallons.
We put this i inerease in effect because there were 8
extra costs in manufacturing the new produet; however,
our experience in the market and the tendency of the re- .
tailers to take a 2-cent mark-up at the retail—on the retail
shelf as a result of the 1-cent per unit increase discour-
aged us from holding the price in effect and we withdrew
the price just recently. 5 2
2. Now, when you were speaking of 2 cents, was that |
the bottle or case? A. Two cents ker unit.
Q. Two cents per bottle? 42 Ge ae
| (Tr. p. 2025)
A. Ves, 6 cents per case on half gallons is 1 cent per
unit, and 4 cents per case on gallons is 1 cent per unit.
We hoped the retailer would only take a one- cent mark-up
on each type, the half gallon and the gallon, but experi-
_ ence indicated that he took a bigger markup, and the sales
pere not satisfactory so we withdrew the price increase.
Q This is one final, final thing. I would like to show’
you lines 3 through 6, sir, on page 1781 of the transcript. -
* 2 * * *
(Tr. p. 2026)
2 Examiner Hayeraft: Will you read the answer *
and then read what it + could be?
mee
8
S
8183 .
Alan C. — |
The Witness: The answer is: “In Life it is about
two million, I think it’s 2,100,000 in Ladies Home Jour-
nalin Better Homes and Gardens it’s about’a cael |
and Ladies Home Journal about 600,000.”
The statement should have been, I a Your Honor,—
excuse me.
The statement should 3 been, in Ladies Home Jour-
nal and in Better Homes and Gardens it's about a million
dollars, and the balance of the statement and Ladies Home
Journal about 600,000 should be struck. „
N rere,
* * * 82 *
Hearing Examiner Haycraft:
2 * 8 * 5
* would like to 1 the witness explain why the change
is made. In other words, did you consult some records? .
The Witness: No.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Did you make 2 mistake
in your testimony? ? 25
The Witness: I do not believe L “have. This is not ex-
actly what I said.
Hearing Examiner Naperste: Yes, I am sorry to con-
tradict you, it is exactly what you said beoduse I listened
very carefully. I read that transcript.again yesterday.
The Witness: Well, my statement with respect to Ladies
Home Journal, the amount 600,000, was in error or it,
should be about a million dollars.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: All right. | }
That is an illustration of a witriéss, a witness vies a
‘right to correct an erroneous statement in the record,
whether it is his mistake or somebody else's. This happens
to be his mistake. Fr
2
1
*
819
Proceedings
cr. p. 2062)
. f ss |
Room 1310, 226 West Jackson
Chicago, Illinois | ;
Wednesday, May 14, 1958
Met, pursuant to adjournment, at 10:00 a. m.
BEFORE: . | oe
Everett F. HaycraFt, Hearing Examiner.
1 x * „ „„ „ „
(Tr. p. 2063)
PROCEEDINGS
* a * : * *
(Tr. p. 2064)
„„ „ „6 oe 1
Mr. Royall: Yes. Since that time, Your Honor, Mr.
Tincher and I have discussed the matter and had a little
. correspondence about it, which is not necessary to read, I
think, in which he was unwilling for a. stipulation to be
made that it was merely ‘market trend and therefore the . :
matter resolved itself into whether we would stipulate .
whether or not it was, it could be considered a market
share. This morning I presented to these gentlemen a sug-
gested stipulation which with a few small changes which
be attorney suggested, has been I understand agreed upon,
and I want to put it in the record, but I'd like first to give
you our feeling about it. Of course we realize that a
_ stipulation along the lines I have just
| (Tr. p. 2065)
mentioned would facilitate the progress of the plaintiff's .
case, or.the complainant’s case, and would on the other
hand make it unnecessary to have a great deal of testi-
mony as to the method of collecting ‘this evidence, how
Boris
fm,
8208
Proceedings
* arrived at it and so forth. Weighing these consider-
ations we have decided that in order to avoid the delay
incident to 4 lot of testimony as to detail and in aid of
a expedition of the case, we will take the step which certainly
asa general rule is not desirable to facilitate the proof
but we are so anxious for this case to move we will
propose a stipulation with the understanding that it. will
not be necessary to have testimony to cover the same
round which would possibly take a long time. We offer
_ this stipulation in substitution for such testimony. As
‘appears in the stipulation which I will read in a minute
we have ascribed to Nielson really more weight or more
credence, I won't say weight, the matter of weight is still
a matter for the Court to decide, more credence than we
think is. appropriate. -However, we have decided in favor
of that course in order that this case will move. The —
9 lation reads as. follows, Your Honor. .
* * 1
(Tr. p. 2066-A)
- STIPULATION
; The . hereto stipulate that e has as-
_ gserted and, on the conditions hereinafter set forth, the
respondent does not contest, that Nielsen Food Index
figures relating to liquid bleach for the period from Janu-
ary 1, 1952 until December 1957, represent as to retail
grocery stores the actual. quantities and dollar values of
purchases and sales, the inventories and days supplies,
the percentages of market share or movement, the store
count and:commodity distribution, the stock location and
out-of-stock condition, the wholesale and retail prices, and
two special reports and one . * all as .
2 relate to 5 bleach. N
8213
Salvator Giachetti—Direct
It is agreed by the parties that the respondent consents ee
hereto solely in the interest of expedition and my fe
art
admission as to the materiality or relevancy of any
of the said Nielsen Food Indices which might be offe
in evidence, and with the understanding and agreement
that this stipulation does not commit the respondent to
the accuracy. or validity of any part of the Nielsen Food
Index either in any other proceeding or generally, and that
this stipulation is not to be offered in evidence or other-
wise used outside this proceeding and is not to be used
to reflect on any allegation in the answer herein or on
8 any witness of Tespondent, who has testified or may tes-
„ 2066-B)
tify : as to his interpretation or use of the Nielsen Food
. Index or * effect:
(Tr. P. 2067) ?
* 222 „ * ot erm a
g Salvatore Gischetti ae
was thereupon called as a witness for the Commission, and
having been first duly sworn; testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
a By Mr. Deveny:
Q. State your name and address for the ed A.
Salvatore Giachetti, 9222 South Bell Street, Chicago,
_ Illinois.
Q. What company are you affiliated with? 1 With
Linco Products ‘Corporation.
Q. .And what is your position with that company, sir?
X. a of the company,
>
en ™
75 dist
PPP
7 a
8
— sete a} 0
2 * A. Since 1931.
| pes than Linco Bleach?
822
oan 3
Salvatore Giachetti—Direct 2
Q. And how long Mews you been president of the Linco. ;
8 G
* * * * i *
By Mr. ‘ Deveny:
. Will’ you tell us, sir, what We this company 0
is engaged in? A. In manufacturing Linco Bleach. ~~ . .
Q. And does the company produce any — other
rr. p. 2068) - <4 |
A. Dry bleach, ammonia, and liquid detergent. .
Q. And will you tell us, sir, the brand names for these :
other products other than bleach? A: Linco Ammonia,
Linco Dry Bleach, Lineo Fine Fabric Bleach and Linco
Detergent. : .
Q. And is Linéo the Wand n * Ves. N
Q. And where do you anes: your bleach?. A. 2155
West Soth Street.
2. Is that the only tention you n A. Les.
Q. Is that the City of Chicago, sir? A The City of
a What is the chemical sigan of, roughly, of |
your ‘Linco bleach? A. Part. is caustic soda, part is 3
chlorine and water. .
Q. Would this be known as sodium hyperchloride o .
mtion7 A. It is.
2. And what pereentage of sodium hyperchlorie is the ~
‘ solution of your bleach? A. 5. 1
23 „ „60 . f ol
0 Do-yoi manufacture your Bleach, or do you use con-
re centrate? A. We manufacture.
85 (Tr. p. 20690 .;
l
9
‘Salvatore laine sition
Q. Could you tell us, sir, what sales area do you an :
your bleach within? A. We sell in the middlewest;
that takes in Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Wisconsin, part
of Iowa and part of Ohio.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: . You don’t 2855 into Min-
nesota?
The Witness: No.
By Mr. Deveny: ee 8
. Now for the other products. that you described 1
_ you manufacture, do you sell those in the same = your. .
other. produets A. Yes.
5 Q. ‘And what sit of a date organisation do you have,
sir, for the sale of your bleaches? A We. have * 5
five salesmen.
Q. Now, is that the only manner in which you ‘sell.
' bleach, through your own salesmen? A. Yes.
Q. Now do these salesmen sell your other products as as
well as the bleach? A. Yes.
Q. And do you have an administrative oficer or head of
these salesmen?
oe Yes, we hayer 8 district, men and one general
sales manager.
ee ¢ ex:
0. ch pon tall sin, U „
you sell your bleaches and your —your bleaehes first. A:
We sell chains, co-ops and any independent jobbers.
Q. Do you sell to the retail store itself or is there an
intermediate customer? A. We sell to the jobber and ö
the jobber in turn sells it to the stores.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Is that true of chain
stores? You sell direct to chain stores? 8
The Witness: Yes.
2
ered price; is there any limitation upon the sales area of
Cx
Pe
Re —
Salvatore Giachetti Direct
* | * N 1 a
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: And co-ops?’ |
The Witness: Yes, and independent jobbers. © ~
mS
„ 282 6-2 2
„„ ͤq ꝰ re gets,
Q. Are your ‘sales at 2 delivered price? A. Beg
pardon? © ‘ 3 „
2. Ave: your sales made at à delivered. prient .
‘Hearing Examiner —— He means . delivered
to the store.
_ The Witness: 8 . 9 — 4
By Ar. * 5
(Tr. p. 2072) |
2. What you mean, sir, if you sell to the jobber, . the
price is to his location, delivery to His location? Does
that explain it? A. Les.
Q. And what methods of transportation. do you use in N
deliyering your bleach? A. We use truck. 8
Q. Your trucks or independent trucks? „4. Our
Q. When you - deliver at a delivered price i that i ee
elude the freight cost, ee cost? A. It —
cludes everything.
Could you tell us, sir, what sizes of Tiquid bleach
you sell? A. We sell quarts, half gallons, and gallons...
i ‘You do not sell pints I take it? 2 Me \
ffir 89 2
* 2
8
Arr. p. 2073) | ag
0 ‘Now, gutting | back to the freight cost and your deliv- ** *
your bleach, your liquid bleach that would be based on
freight cost? — Jes, 1 would * three hundred miles.
3 : 3 >
= 5 . — . : Ss... « * .
825a |
Salvatore Giachetti—Direct = ae | ie
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Three hundred? ¥ an
The Witness: Yes. 5
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: You feel ‘you can’t af- 1
ford to deliver more than that with your trucks? 1
The Witness: No, we won't be able to compete. 5
Hearing Examiner Havefaft: With people located in ad
another are:? “3
oe
_ The Witness: Ves, sir. .
By Mr. Deveny: . 8 5
Q. That would be the freight basis? A
Q. Could you tell us, sir, what other bleach brands are
sold i in your sales‘territory, in grocery stores? A. Well,
number one, Clofox, two, Fleecy White, three, Hilex ;
Purex, Roman Cleanser.
. Are you familiar with the sodium hyperchloride con-
tent of those bleaches? A. Yes.
2. Are they any different from yours? A. As far as
we know there 8 no difference. 15
. (Tr. p. 2074) 3
: ¢ Ne,
E27 @. * * * sal
7 0. Could you tell us, sir, what tine of retail stores
handle your bleach? A. Any retail = from the
chain down to the small stores. ae
. Q. Would that be in the grocery field as opps to
A. All in the grocery, field. 7
rad
Crr. p. 2075) . 5
“9
; 2 * * R 1
See 0. Is there a. brand of bleach that is a predominant
competitor with your bleach in this area? A. Yes. J
* would say. number one competitor is Clorox.
. . ' ‘ .
*
ie
Salvatore Giachetti Direct
(Tr. „ e
8 2 ma 828 2
0. Does your company advertise its ry sir?
„A. Tes.
Q. Do you advertise your liquid. Wert A. Les.
And in what media of advertising do you employ?
A. We use newspaper, radio and T-V. 7
Q. When you say radio and TV, is that spot advertising
or program? A. Spot. 8 .
And is there any frequency to the beni of using
media? In other words is it a: continuous use of all
these media or is it seasonal in any way? A. I would
+
—
=
say it’s seasonal. We usually have promotion in spring i
and fall, and that’s the time we use TV. especially.
Hearing Examiner a What months would that
be? ° *
The Witness: Well, let's see, from March to J une, Sep-
tember to November. 3
By Mr. Deveny:
2 And why would you not advertise every month?
rr. p. 2078)
— A. Because we find that that is the time that people
use more bleach than any other time.
And why is it necessary, sir, to sheeting: liquid |
bleach if you feel it is necessary? A. Well, we find that
that's the only way to sell it. If we don’t erte, We
won't be able to sell it.
. Have you found any particular media of advartising
to be more effective in advertising your bleach than any
other media? A. Well, I would co gl TV would-be ©
more effective. Ot course it is more costly.
0
7
0 ihn in shite wi, e
produet at a time or how do you werk that? A. We:
advertise all products more or less.
Q. And od would that be, sir?
2 >. @ *
The Witness: We advertise all because we, that’s the 7
only way that we.can sell it. We couldn't advertise just.
one and not the other. Of course the bulk of the advertis- -
ing would be in the liquid bleach rather than the others.
1
By Mr. Deveny: a
Q. Have you ever used any TV programs, ever on-
: sored
a os (Tr. v. 2079) ea
any TV programs, your company. A. Ves.
_ Q. How long ago was that or is it going on at present?
A. It is going on now.
spot
The Witness: No, all spots.
* * * + *
Q. When. you buy this TV advertising, sir, on what 7
time — do you buy your advertising?
+. * * * R
The Witness: We. usually buy what we » call a
| (Tr. p. 2080) |
package spot, which means you get fourteen, fifteen or
twenty spots and you have to accept it any time of the
day.
The Witness: So many a day, or week.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: So many each Week.
2
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: " that a Program a
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: That is so many a day? 8
— . 7
: 0 *
e Ove ith alee * ·”[ü i U *
1 re 8
828
Salvatore GiachettiDiret
| By Mr. Deveny: =
Q. Do you buy that each week? A. No, thirteén |
‘weeks.
Q. Are you able to buy it for a year on a year basis?
A. No; we don’t buy on a year basis.
Q. Why would that be, sir? A. Because we don't use
them all year around. , 2
Hearing Examiner Haycratt: Do they quote to you at
thirteen weeks, a certain number of weeks?
‘The Witness: Yes, the minimum that you can er
thirteen weeks. Then ‘if sii are willing to buy Fnother
thirteen a ;
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: In other words that makes
the twenty-six? /
The Witness: Les.
. Hearing. Examiner Hayeratt: What 65 you Wel
buy? a
The Witness: ‘Thirteen weeks. 7 4
By Mr. iia ae
(Tr. p. 2081)
Q. Do you advertise ena in any media? - A.
No. a
8 * * *
Q. Do you have any re- purchase * with your
customers as to your products? : 9
. ;
The Witness: We don’t have an. agreement, but we
have a ‘policy to repurchase, I guess, if ue can’t sell it.
By Mr. Deveny:
Q. Do you give free merchandise prizes to customers |
selling your bleach? A. Yes.
Q ‘Do you use count and recount in your liquid bleach?
7.
a
— ee |
Salvatore Giachetii Direct 5 —
Heating Examiner Haycbatt: You'd better ee. for
; 33 record what that is. —
3 5. 2082) ie
By: Mr. Deveny: 1 85
Q. Do you understand? A. I 3
Q. Would you explain what it is? A. Suppose vou
want to have a ten cents deal for a salesman; you ‘count |.
the cases, and after thirty days, you re-count them ‘and
see how many they sold.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Count the cases in the-
warehouse and on their shelves?
The Witness: No, just in the warehouse.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft:- And whatever is sold
during that period of 3 vou give them the discount is
that it?
The Witness: Ves. vd
Mr. Royall: What did you say about the answer hefore 8
that? that he did not have it?
Mr. Deveny: He hasn't answered it ie
By Mr. Deveny: -
Q. Now, sir; does your company use that discount—I _
mean, does your company use that count And recount?
A. Very seldom. | :
Hearing Examiner Hayeratt: But you hike aseil it, is
that right? *
The Witness: Yes.
By Mr. Deveny: : ee ae
rr. p. 2083) 5
5 0. On what basis would you use that, sir, if you, let us
say, have used it very seldom? What is the basis for
using it). A. Well, we need cooperation by the sale -
men, the jobber’s salesmen; and then we allow ten cents
a case for the salesman. So we work for thirty days, pro-
4
*
quid bleach producer
8 830a 4
moting and selling Linco, and then, at the end of the thirty
days, they get ten cents a case, whatever is sold.
Q. What is the purpose for using it? A. The purpose
is to get jobbers’ salesmen to sell our product.
Q. I understand A. 1 1 250 send it to the job.
bers’
Q. To the jobber’s en 1 of your own.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: He gets ten cents?
The Witness: Tes. The jobber s salesman.
Q. Is your company affiliated with or a subsidiary of any
other company, sir? A. No.
Q. Does your comp own any interest in any other
cat A. ie
& = *
(r, p. 2084)
: . * * * 4 a
Q. Are you faniiliar with the Nielsen Food Index for
liquid bleaches?. A. Yes. 1
Q. Does your company, purchase that? A. No, we
don't. 8
hy do Jou not purchase the Nielsen Bleach Index?
A. Because it is expensive, an extra expense, and by hav-
ing our sales force in the territory, we don’t think it is
too advantageous. .
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: You don’t think what?
The Witness: By having our salesforee in the terri-
tory, we don’t think it is necessary to have it:
ee * ‘ : qo
„ „% „ „ 5
N. at 7
2 (Tr. P. 20800
323 & ©
| Q. Does your company have any dealer or jobber ‘coop-
4
8 By Mr. Deveny:
f Salvatore Giachetti—Direct
erative merchandising plan on this liquid bleach? A.
Les, we have. ose)
Q. What would that amount to, sir? A. Well, we
allow five cents a case for that advertising.
Q. Why do you offer that, sir? A. Because the whole
bleach * is doing it.
* 5 * * *
Q. * that five cents—how do you figure od What i is
the five cents for? .
(Tr. p. 2087)
1 For advertising in their newspapers. Lou pan we 3
features a quarter in their own newspaper.
Q. Do you require proving or proof the two features
per quarter? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Does your company have an allowance or expenditure
for purchasing in-store 1 space? A. What
Ekind of promotion? ;
Q. I have in mind the floor space, end’ displays, islands,
baskets, off-shelf. A. In some Gp ritory, where we
need 1 .
. : ,
* * * R „
The Witness: Some territory where we need promoting ae
of products, we use a display, floor display contract. >
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: What kind: — f
The Witness: Floor displays. .
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: What does that call for?
What do they have to do?
The Witness: D. the merchandise on An. foor.
(Tr. p. 2088)
Q. What do ‘you pay, or what is your part of the con-
traet? A. We pay ten cents a case for displaying it.
* * * *
4 92
*
aN eee err
— ——
188 yo ee — 9 8 2 a
. 9 . 0 8 — - 8
n * - ‘ te ‘
- . — — ene wee r SS e — C
. : Py
. . ° ee
3 *
— — oe ee :
0 a 3
ws 0 = *
*
‘ 8 4 8
* \ is * . * * : Oo
. 8 = ;
ae tae 2 aw 8 » * — ;
ee eT ec N 5 l oe
“a. - 8 — ‘ * .
882a
Salvator Giachetts Direct
(Tr. 5. 1520 2
2
„ 8 a8
0. a you aware, sir, that the pen & Gamble
: — acquired the Clorox Chemical ‘Company at ap-
ly August 1, 19577. A. Les.
8 And do vou have an opinion as to the effect of t this
. acquisition upon your e .
| oe : 3 The Witness: I have an opinion, yes.
By Mr. Deveny:
3 0. Would you ‘state your opinion?
Mr. Royall: Objection.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Overruled.
9 0 Tee Witness: Well, I would say that. this acquisition
would ¢reate’a situation where Linco’ Company will have
a hard time to compete. . When you stop to look at
: 3 (Tr. p. 2090) 5
the resources that they have, and the ‘type of promotion
Shes that they put up when they buy or put out a new item,
~~. you can see that things are very serious, When they start
‘ a. saturating campaign—that means radio, newspapers,
ä I u, plus sampling coupons, all that put together, inelud-
18 ing floor displays in the stores, which they would be able
‘ to get following all this advertising; and not only that, but
mtdmdey would be able to get probably more shelf space than
5 Pears N eee and all that together would eliminate the
as 5 3 * a 5 „
(Te. 5. 2094)
Oey Oe Sy cine kee ee * 4 7 : 8 5
f * — . :
e N Giachetti ö
vas thereupon called as a witness for the Conimission
dana, oe been first duly sworn, testified.as {pllows:
f DIRECT. EXAMINATION.
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Your name —
The Witness: Mario, M-a- r. i-o, Giachetti
8 e eee
a, p. 2095)
g By Mr. Deveny:
Q. Would you tell us, sir, what compariy you are afflli-
ated with? A. Linco Products Corporation. *
C. What is your position with that N 25 A.
Secretary-Treasurer.
Q. How long haye you held that position? 0 K. a,
: 1981.
Q. How 8 bas the company tien § in ‘hastness? 1
* * * * *
(Tr. p. 2100)
Since dea
Mx. Giachetti, I Would like to hand you Gnmüsie 8.
Exhibit 464 for identification; and ask you if you can
identify that for us, please. A. Tes.
0 * 92% „% % «@ ;
0. 1 e e e Gomme e 4s aba ei
records of the Linco Distributing Company as used in
the ordinary course of business? A. Tes.
Q. Were these figures prepared under your supervision, |
or did-you prepare them? A. Under my supervision.
Q. And normally, in the course of the business of your
company, are your duties such that you would work with |
these books, records, o
: — with them? . Yes.
*
A Looking , Conzidasion Exhibit No. 464, sir, 1
notice that you have totals for the years 1952 through
„ for Linco Liquid Bleach. A. Les.
Mario Giachetti i Direct
@ And this document would actually show the ae
: Axara pareeeyel te Semmes Saehors: 4 On the books,
Cr. p- 2101)
Mr. Deveny: At this time, your Honor, I would like to
offer. res Exhibit 464 for identification into evi-
2 88 N aio :
(rr. p. » 2104)
6 8 ee oS
, 3 ‘Examiner Hayeraft: The Exhibit 464 tor 25
identification will be andes in evidence and placed in =
eamera 4
; 7 2 @ * *
p. 2106)
* 2 * * * *
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: It says “Linco;” it
_ doesn’t say bleach. Unless it says it in the caption. What
does it say in the caption? —
Mr. Doveng: Tproceded myself. I will change the
question. g
By Mr. Dg: 5
QQ You also have the caption “Bright Sail.“ A. Yes.
. Is that a liquid bleach, too? © A. Les.
oe =
Q. One further question on this exhibit: fre these rp- ser
resentative net sales? A. Tes.
Q. Rather than gross? A. Yes.
Ais ok. 22 2 „ „ @
a
*
‘ * ws 3
5 5 :
ö 2 „ *
835 2 > ;
| _ Mario Giachetti—Direct 5
rr. v. 2106) „
: * 2 eh „ : i
0 n you Ge Exhibit. No. 5
465 for identification, and ask you if you can n identity 8 .
that for us. „%%%
1 Witness: ‘That i is the prices. ee ae
: (Te. b. 2109) os |
an Are they private prices? . No; they are prices 4
for all our customers. eres 4
, Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: To your customers? * d
The ee ‘Yes. We sent it to them, or send it to 8 1
them. Tes. ; : | . — —
By Mr. 8 . * N 5 a
Q. Were those prepared Seine your 01 price lists, .
used in the course of your business? A. . Re ON 44
Mr. Der 1 would like to offer this at this ume, ae : .
your Honor. : di
„„ . ¥ 3
7 C2: 7 1
. Examiner Hayeraft: Before you ask any more og
‘questions, let the reporter mark the exhibit as received. :
(The paper referred to, heretofore marked for = "aid
_ identification Commission’ s Exhibit 465,. was re- : 1
Ceeived in evidence, in camera.)
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Proceed.
By Mr. Deveny:
Q. Let me ask: you, sir, the Bright Sail that we .
been speaking of—to whom does your company sell rs
product? * To the AKP stores. a
1 ——
eee es 8 — —
22 — . ]⁵²“AÄ ELIE ̃ . AO PE ESL
- — — 2b — eee .
* 2 ‘+s 8 i NS. ABE, 5 N a a f a 9
. 2 5 he , 8
86a...
: . 5 M oe) 2 — fu t t a D * ; |
“3 Q. And I notice that there is a price difference between
„ the two bleaches, between Bright Sail and Linco. Is there
any explanation for that, sir? Why are they different?
Is there any explanation? A. Tes. Ps ate 3
+ The Witness: They demand a lower price, saying that. -
oe don’t need to advertise and have any salesmen—have
any sales expense with ww can quote a lower 0
5 pe? Err. pt 2121) „„
Price. . 5
5 . At this point, sir, I would like to ask you what other %
brands bf bleach does A&P sell in this area, if you 1 2 ——
K Clorox, Fleeey White, “Linco, and the Bright Sail, as
Tar. as I K.]. Sate |
* * * * *
0. And why would those prices be different under each
of those columns? A. Truckload is of one size at one ä
price, a truckload of mixed merchandise at A different..
price, and less truckload is. a different pries |
5 (Tr. F. 2122)
5 i Cee 5 * nei * * : > .
| Q. Sir, I. notice there are columns headed T/L, P/TL,
+, and L/ TL, and could I ask you, sir, what those particular
, /eq.. symbols indicate or mean? A. Yes. It means truck.
Aoad, part truckload and. less truckload. cae
** N es
Cr. p. 2136)
„ N F ,
Q. I notice, Mr. Giachetti, that there is an offer on these
labels for some nylon stockings. Can you tell us how long
that offer has been in ‘effect? A. About a year and a
roe 0 *
0 BLS ree ; : „
2 °
. Noone os
3 Aarto Giachetti—Direct 1
Uquidating premium? i
7 (Tr. +2137)
2 85 A. Yes.
*
Q. I see. Mr. Giachetti, getting se to the price lists
vou were speaking of early this morning, let me ask you
0 all your customers?: A. Tes.
—
3
te" quantity discounts 1 on that exhibit, does the te
\ Company . any other discount on ‘its liquid bleach?
* * * * *
2 * Not except the two pergent ten days. .
— . ,
i ree a ‘Doe yeux ee produce a ‘dry bleach? „
No, we don't produce it, we sell it.
2 Q, Compared to your liquid bleach, sir, what portion of
Pace . the sale of dry bleach Yeprécent? =
Mtr. Royall: Objection. |
Hearing. er Hayeraft: Overruled
— The Witness: /It is about six percent,
Mr. Royall: What?
Hearing Examiner Met Six percent,
By Mr. Deveny: ks
. 5. 2139) 5
2 Could you tell us, sir, do have jut one type of ~
„ al type? A. We have
wae
4 —
2. 15 that 7 premium that ‘would be termed’ a self.
5 . Is that available to your bleach “eons your
arg. entire area? A Ves a
this. Is the Linco Bléach price on that list the same price io
0. 2 other than the discounts that are. - shown, the
1 gh Pa
t ad ee: $e se 9 o
4 a N 2— Es 2
cane Fa ea j *
ni 2 * * “es ee.
oi \ 4 a 5
& e * A 2
: 838a
| o 6S 3 . ; * ‘ 3
8 * 2 a . — f 4 8 . 17 7
° 32 3 ¢ —— _ <8 5 . 0 —
55 f a 2 3 : - ge
. * : : 4 a é 2 ge
. te 855 g — ‘
a A Plasser .
i E thats the b and that is all
. for fine fabric i item =
11 QAnd the other? A. The other is for heavy: duty
— laundry and it is a chlorine base bleach. 3
1 Q. How long. have you produced the heavy laundry
- bleach, sir? A. The heavy ,
— Q. I mean sold. A. Oh, about seven months.
; . 28 85 the’ fine fabrics? :
2« „„
. And for the fine fabrics, sir? A The fine fabrics ~~
about four years. e 8
a ; E22 „ „% © om 53
‘nm
4
pe eed C Could you tell us, sir, “what factors you 1
. sider in setting the prices of your liquid blenches?.¢
— 2 * 4 * *
The Witness: First thing we have to look at the com-
petition we have. And 5 | :
Py. Deveny: are 0
2. Who would that be in this esst A. Number one
13 _ would be the Clorox, and the next would be Fleecy White. :
„ . When you say. vou must look at your competitors,
what. are 8 referring to, that you must . at?
— eg ; ‘eo „ # «a „ i ! 194
555 ecole 5 5 85 r. p. 2141)
Ke * a ~ 33 * „ „ * 2
ee Le The Witness: Sian edule io ten bn lin wedi
ae too high, too far away from our competition. We are
17 5 es eons bere i
— '? 2 ’ ¢ *
: : 5 —
8 5 3 ™ 1
oe =
„ fi
; — .
Pes —— e f
vf? . i „ ee :
— oF : 3
=< . $
2. Between who? | A. Between Clorox prices and de
Q. spy ys rN thn Cia)
The Witness: No,
By Mr. Deveny:
.Do you have to consider any other factors in pricing
, your bleach? . 2 : ;
8 0
*
252 „2 „„
(Tr. 5. 2142) 5 |
Ine Wie: Yes, we consider our cost „ Be 3
i ö “Cr. v. 2143) :
@ hr any cere eo or ach and he *
Clorox bleach as it stands in the bottle, sir? 24. Not |
that we know. e
a Mor, ths Shon soul ea esdiacs asc oc
8 had some testimony about, is there any difference between
chat bleach and your liquid bleach? ' A, N.
‘ Hearing Examiner Hayeratt: Which bleach!
4
J (Tr. p. 214) | i “3
ers Q. May I catty that and say, may 1 change iy yo
5 tion, Your Honor. company ne ey 7
i — —— — ä —
a od
* 9
f . 4 Meme ä — —
i ae a oe
} * ; * 2 a
& Mario’ Giachetti—Direct | 4
Oe —
(Tr. p. 2145)
A. No, but we have a chemist in the company. 3 5
| Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: F
* 2 . f
oe By Mr. Deveny: 2 5
=e lie Is the production of liquid bleach a highly technical
subject? A. It is not highly technical, but it has to
be exact in the procedure of making it.
Q. What would that be? A Bae e ‘it the -
temperature of the liquid bleach goes up a hundred’ two
degree it becomes a reaction and that will have an unstable '
7 e, it couldn't be sold.
, 2 * * 8 *
Cr. p. 2146)
* * * * * 2 ;
0 Is the machinery expensive that is involved in your
process for producing liquid bleach? Well, I wouldn’t
say expensive; it is costly.
-Q.. What would be the value of the present machinery
you have? A. Machinery including tanks and all of
chat, about two hundred fifty thousand dollars. 6
Q. Is this machinery readily available on the open mar-
| ket? wa e eee
» . sixty day
Q. Is brachinery manufactured asording to a stand
ard design? A. Yes. ,
a „ ©: ‘Clan yon hos el A. No. *
77... Is your company at the present time producing
Acgquid bleach. at its full capacity? A. No, we could
| more.
NN aer due dreumsancs could it produce mol
Hl Whe} weld Yon bars to Got a 3
2 5 „
15 841 oes
Mario Giachetti—Direct
CV
The Witness: Well, we have one shift. We could readily
*
g0 into two shifts and with a little cost produce twice as
ee
Q. Has your company ever considered { panding its
sales territory? A. No, we could not do at unless we
would have a factory in the place where we want to .
expand because of the cost of transportation would be too
high over two hundred fifty miles . :
.
(Tr. p. 2148)
Q. Has your company experienced price increases since
1908, stn? . Nene 08 er 2 igen Dt
Q. And what factors would be contributory to increas-
ing the prices you have? : ‘4% 2817
” . * 89 1 8
The Witness: Mostly the cost, increased cost of bottles
? and to some lesser extent the cost of chemicals and freight 288
on chemicals, —
Q. Are these cost increases, is that it, cost increases to
2 ‘you that would have been reflected in your increase?
A. Tes. .
0. Have you passed all af those cost ineresises on to pour an
f 8 crr. p. 2149)
A. No. 7 | Tarot alae 1. he 8
Q. And why haven't you been doing that?
3 v @:- @!.":
> . 3
f 8
8 D ages ° 8
* . 1 a
ad ac eet Mario Giachetts—Direct,
4 : The Witness; Some time we abgprb it, and some other
8 er e x | eee
as 2. z Way would you ator u art 5
5 2° 2 2 2. a
: Bis The Witness: It we can mans i, well stay within the
add price. 955 aks
We
its liquid bleach? &. Tes. j
Q. When was that, ir? “A. Last year in October, 5
=o 0. Well, could youcexplain what an off price label is?
4. It is printed on the label, fas cents off of the regular ©
price.
* And what—was that used in your entire sales
err. v. 2150): 185
L 1
4 oo d And was there any result that was apparent to yeu
trom the use of this label? A. Jes.
& Was ae eat eee
siete: * The Witness: d 8
2 es end we sold a-little bit better than twice as much as the
erty RO — 3 ree our |
& 2238 p. 2158) N
0 Gould you.tell us Gir what percent of your total
Sross sales is e eee sales of sgt — 23 t
2 ** * * * eS
The Witness: About hhinety-four p a
2
The Witness: Les.
Hearing Examiner Hayefaft: I thought you said the
Rare dry bleach was six percent.
The Witness: Well, all the other products. Probably
ninety-two percent. I don't hade the figures present in
my mind.
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Lou think about ninety- :
two percent?
= 0 5 8 a r. p. 2162)
other stuff left over.
The Witness: Ninety two percent of bleach and eight
all the rest. F ä .
Hearing Examiner Haycraft:. The reason I was ques-
tioning, it came up to a hundred and there was some
a
By Mr. Deveny: „5
2. Would that ninety-two percent include the dry bleach
or exclude it? A. NP. ats
29 @ * * *
.
Mr. Deveny: Miss Reporter, may | have marked as
Commission’s Exhibit 469 for identification a single sheet
ftpypepwritten purporting to give a summary of advertising
for the Linco Distributing Corporation.
(he document referred to was marked Com-
-mission’s Exhibit 469. for identification.) 8
By Mri Deveny:
2. Can you identify that? „ A. Les.
2
+
*
| Mario Giachetti-—Direct 5
Alearing Examiner Haycraft: Ninety-four percent? .
Q. Twould like to hand that to you, sir, and ask you if.
Fou know what that is?? A. Les. . 9 : 2
please, what. that. does show?
°- * .
*
5
— — — —
A. This is the advertising expense “for the years 1952,
1958, 1954, 1955, 1956 and 1957.
Q. 1 notice there is a single figure for each Near. *
> (Tr. p. 2163)
that the total? A. That is the total for the year.
* 8 . 7 5 * *
8 . ® 55
. ˙ SCRE EY STITT EN 8 * 2 7 7
— 2 — 1 — 7 —— an acc eee PETRA e e ene ee
e ‘ ö ; ba
r n : is io
4 *
.
.
7 ‘
; . 2 * \
— 0 N
— a 844a
° ‘ e
* 2 > -
. **, 7 Gi he _Dir 3 my
Q. Does that include advertising only or does that in-
: dude advertising and promotional expenditure? A.
Advertising and promotion.
Q. Was this prepared at or under your supervision? ;
hime
2. 0. A. Ves.
. Are these company book$ and records used in the 8
ordinary course of business of the corporation? A. Les.
Mr. Deveny: I. would like to offer that at this time, and
my understanding .is the witness = it to be placed
in-camera. ; 0
975 „
Slt Ge Sa)
ss o>. 6: €&.:0" 4
(be document referred to, heretofore marked :
Gommission’ s Exhibit 469 for identification, was
received in evidence.)
e
8 crr. p. 21662)
; —
"Edwin B. Hahn
** nN
“Ls > *
was thereupon ‘called as a witness for the one |
and, — been. first duly sworn, testified as fallows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION .
v Mr. Deveny:
e
m you pet sae your name and drt )
9
Edioin B. Hahn —Direct
‘Edwin B. Hahn, 5968 Howard Avenue, Lene; High- i
lands, IIlinois. ig
Qi. Wil you tell us, sir, ca company you are affiliated
with? A. Linco Corporation. 8 .
2. What is your position with that company? A.
General sales manager. :
Q. How long have you been employed i in that position? 3
A. Since November of 1956.
2. What positions did you hold prior to your bi
ment with Linco? . A. Prior to that time, I was a sales
manager for Doeskin Preducts Corporation out of Nex
Tork City, and prior to that I spent some 15 years with
Colgate in the soap division, in both as sales manager.
Q. What are your present duties with Linco? A.
Well, I set up and oversee the — * opera-
tion for the company. pe |
2. Does the ndninistration of the sales force come under 5
(Tr. p. 2167)
: your position? A. That is correet.
Q. Are you familiar, then, with Linco’s promotional ac-
tivities? A. Yes, I am.
Q. And their advertising activities? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you have any familiarity with the budgeting of
80 advertising and promotional allowances? A. Yes, I do.
Q. Are you familiar with the Proctor and Gamble
Company’s promotional activities? A. Yes, I am.
Q. And of their selling activities? A. Yes.
Q. What would be the basis for your knowledge in that
instance? A. Well, I have spent my entire life, adult
. life in the food field, and work as a direct competitor to
Proctor and Gamble for some fifteen years in the: soap
business.
Q. Are you familiar with the Clorox Company's selling
—— since August 1, 19577 A. Yes, I am.
0
Bee ae os ae
Pan h. Habn—Direct
Q. How: . Linco administer its sales area—what is
the breakdown? . ° „ a
9
(Tr. p. 2168) A
A. Of the sales personnel? 5
see Q. Well, first, the geographical area? A. Oh. We
cover the State of Illinois, the entire State of Wisconsin,
about two-thirds of the State of Michigan, half of the
State of Indiaria, and a portion—I am not prepared to
give you the percentage of the a of . and the |
State of Ohio. :
| Bre ci (r- p. 2169) 5
* v — U
Q. Now, can you tell us, sir, how Linco would promote
its liquid bleach, or how does it promote its liquid bleach?
A. We promote our product through means of advertising
media which include newspaper, radio, TV spots, and also
used to supplement that is so-called consumer offers which
8 promotes the produet on through, and sells it through to
the consumer, the consuming publie. :
: fake 8 N „ oe ee oe ees
° 0 Could you define some of them for us? A. Well,
we use off-label Soe which are very :
popular and have been tor seinen years now. |
There have been instances in so-called low spot areas
where. we have used in a limited way couponing activity.
We have used self-liquidating premiums to a lesser degree,
and I believe that just about covers it.
Q. You say couponing is used in low spot areas. Would
that indicate it is not used in or on a full scale territorial
basis? A. We have — or the cumpany has never
—
e AN Dn age 80S og is
oe 847
Edwin B. Habu Direst
ds the best of my knowledge used couponing activities on
an overall basis because of the excessive expense involved.
Now, the other activities that you describe, are they
used on a full territorial basis? A. Yes. So far as off-
label promotion is concerned, that is used on a company-
wide operation. nd : ü
Q. Is there a frequent use made of that? A. Pretty _-
- . generally we confine a bleach: promotion to the spring and
fall of the year, generally for a 30 day period only.
mS; eed | , (Tr. p. 2171)
Q. Let me put it this way. What are the competitive
factors that you. have to consider in selling your liquid
- bleach? A. Well, promotional activities and promo-
tional efforts put behind our line of bleach products in
“order to compete with the competition which we are faced
with in the various areas, to enhance our position in the
market, or in many other cases to maintain our share of
the consumer. usage market in those areas. me
Does that answer your question? ä
2. I think so. What effect does shelf space in the gro-
eery retail outlets have on the sales of your liquid bleach?
A. Well, it is the prime factor. Without adequate and
ample shelf space you are out of business.
2. What ‘determines whether or not liquid bleach will
obtain shelf space? pas ae sah
The Witness: The determining factor as to the amount
of shelf space that you received in today’s super market is
brought about by the amount of pre-selling that you are.
.
able to do in all forms of promotional and advertising
, activity to ereate the turn-over that is neces-
*
— a 5
o WwW”
-*
1
sary in modern- day retailing. 5 :
Edwits B. Hakn—Direct.
(Tr. p. 2172) f
—
Without the so-called consumer demand or consume |
acceptance, you receive no shelt space, /
By Mr. Deveny: pee Se ie wy
ls there a principal brand with which sar compete
in this s s territory i in liquid bleach? . 1 23 say”
on an basis the brand would be Clorox. |
2 Why is that brand a principal competitor? °
* * * 2 *
The Witness: well, I can best explain that to you by
regson of this being the only brand to my knowledge that
is in national distribution. In other words, it is marketed —
5 in a sithetantial way in our entire marketing area.
42 „ „ 2%
(Tr. p. 2178)
0 * 2 * *
te
- Q Does Clorox liquid bleach lend itself to , this tyne of ö
promotional activity we have been discussing?
* * * * *
The Witness: Very definitely, it does lend welt to the
bes of promotional activities that you
(Tr. p. 2179)
5 have been speaking of because it fits into the general
| . house-cleaning product category. 4
+ „„ 2 * „ ;
Q. Is-that a store category? A. Yes.
* © % „6
. What would that category include?
e @74. 8 ©
> <j x
N ‘ 8 es . 7 2 : 8492 “ 5 e
— reat 7 3 f 2
ö Ss — ö a a K
ere | ear
The Witness: That category would include all types of
household cleaning products to take in soaps, detergents, .
cleansers, starches,—anything that is used in a cleansing,
and to include bleaches. — ies oe
Q. Do you have a problem in obtaining shelf space for
.. your Linco liquid blech)? 3 „
Thé Witness: Ves, we do. Currently, based on our
share of the market, we do not feel that we have at this
time the proper shelf position.
on?
"Hearing. Examiner Haycraft: What is your ‘share. of
the market? Boe 5
f ; * * «„ „ „ ;
Cr. p. 2181)
— a W mis
| The Witness: Between 45 and 50 per cent in the city of
Hearing Examiner · Hayeraft: What do you base that
The Witness: Consumer usage. ö a Rass
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Have you made any
study? oe 5 5
The Witness: Tes, from reports received from various
of our direct buy accounts.
Crr. p. 2182)
Q. How do you obtain shelf pace!
be Witness: We obtain shelf space through the promo-
tional efforts on the part of our company in pre- |
Se ; 38503
: Edwin B. Hahn —Direct **
(Tr. 5. 2188)
Ang ‘our ftodnet to the’ Seiner, and also. by reason
of the sales and marketing division of our company urging _.
the retailers to give us proper ä . on our
, 8
e eae
Cr. p. 21840 2 )
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: wen, does it t follow: in, .
that your firm, Linco, has 50. per cent, or approximately
45 per cont of the business of the liquid. bleach in the
N metropolitan are:
(tr. p. 2185)
‘The Witness: We have between 48 and 60 per cent of
dee current bleach busineés in Chicago, but we are not
enjoying 45 to 50 per cent of the shelf space., ,
Hearing Examiner Haycratt: 1 See. Moni, whet, d 70s
kee this estimate af db to 50 per cent af your sales of
liquid bleach on?
The Witness: ‘Well, we don’t use Nielsen, but we have
used the Tribune Panel poll, which is furnished to us
locally here on à regular basis, which shows our share of
the market in ounces consumied, or consumer usage, and s
on, and from reports that are obtained from the
eNOS ee . 1
a
* 4 * . *
„ (Tr. p. 2186) Ec
* * 23 * *
d Ave the basic competitive problems in selling soape,
cleansers, and detergents any different from the basic com- 1
FFF
* oe W y
8514. oo
Edioin B. Hahn—Direct 5
5 The Witness: The same problems exist. ae
, Throughout the entire household sectfon. ‘
4 5 5 2 5 a „ = * * © 3
(Tr. p. 2189)
By Mr. Deveny: A 5 ll |
.o you have any special promotion for fall or spring
house-cleaning drives? A. We pretty generally always
run a special promotion on our liquid bleach. 5
What would be the details of that promotion? How is
that operated? yeti
—
„„ oe, A i ae
A. We make available to all accounts that we do busi-
ness with, an off-label offer which has à tendency to stimu-
nate the movement of the product, and enhance our share
, of the market, or in the cases of markets where we are
battling to get a stronger position mily enhance us again a
Ulttle to get a greater share of. the market.
Do you gain a greater share of the market as a
result of the campaign? A. You do, temporarily. You
ds not always maintain the gain that is made during the
promotional efforts—you drop back, but pretty generally
you solidify your position in the market. >
Q. Does Fleecy White engaged in that type of——
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Who makes Fleecy White,
by the way? Oe pak
The Witness: It is the John Puli Division of Sterling
Drug Company. „ a
e. Does Fleecy White and Clorox use these spring and
fall house-cleaning campaigns? A. Fleecy White, to
a
8522
Edwin B. Hahn—Direct
: tho best of my knowledge, since I have been with the com-
pan, have not used this type of promotional activity. Ap-
parently, they have a preference for marketing their prod- ;
uct at an every-day low price; théy are considerably under
the balance of the bleach
(Tr. p. 2191) .
manufacturers within our marketing areas as far as costs
to the chains or wholesalers are concerned. As relates to
33 Clorox, they have used spring clean-up drives where
-. used a stepped-up advertising campaign, with. point
material to include window banners, shelf. talkers, If
strips, et cetera, et cetera.
Q. Has there been any change in the-1958 spring drive
of Clorox which was apparent to you?
* * 2 * *
The Witness: Well, we have noticed 4 premium offer
which currently is being offered on Clorox; in fact, it is
now in effect, and also stepped-up activity so far as the
TV spots, and a ated advertising is concerned.
By Mr. D
nn your spring and fall house-cleaning campaign of
Linco, do you tie that in with any other product—do you
tie your bleach in with any other produets? A. No, we
promote it on its own. .
G. in what section of the grocery stare do you find
liquid bleaches shelved? A..In the household section.
e@e ** 8 *
cCrr. p. 2192)
eee, eee
bleach and all of your competitors in this area?
- ee Examiner Haycratt: Retail to customers? -
8586
Edivin B. Hahn—Direct
ao
Mr. Deveny: Yes, retailed. 7 ,
The Witness: Well speaking of gallon soe, woukd you
like me to name the brands??? 3
Mr. Deveny: Yes. Bee. |
The Witness: Our product, Linco, in gallon ‘size gener-
ally is retailing between 53 and 56 cents at the present
time. Clorox gallons are retailing anywhere from 55 to 61
in our marketing area and Fleecy/White, which is the
other principal ‘competitor, their prices are ranging from
46—excuse me—from 49 to 55, ä
* 4 * ” *
(Tr. p. 21593)
.
. Let me Press it this way: Do you maintain that
price l in your pricing practice? f
„ „„ „ „
a The Witness: Do we maintain—would you a the quer
tion again?
Hearing Examiner Haycratt: To what extent do you
maintain that differentia] that you are talking about in
your market? You give general range in prices; has |
that always been true?
The Witness: We have. always—we have been pretty
much in the middle bracket. ne
By Mr. Deveny: : 1
(Tr. p. 2194) .
What I am getting at is this: .
do you attempt to maintain that differential between your.
liquid bleach and the Clorox liquid bleach?
Mr. Royall: Objection. - ~
* Examiner Hayeraft: overruled.
854a „
. “Edwin B. Habn-Hirect
The Witness: No. our pricing policies are dictated *
= cost of raw materials, „cost of advertising, and the sales
costs or nisrketing costs. 0. 2
0
——
* * * * * *
2 Let me ask you this: Step by step, how do you deter-
mine the price for Linco? -
Mr. Royall: Objection. He has just testified how.
Mr. Deveny: Linco bleach.
Mr. Royall: He has just testified to that: |
“Mr. Deveny: No, your Honor; I'think he testified with
e ee eee ‘Now I-am getting Back to
the basis of that.
Mr. Royall: I would like to have the. * answer .
read by the reporter. „ Pee
te ae! t,t
| Hearing Examiner Haycraft: You had better listen. to
that previous answer. Read the last answer the witness
made.
* (Answer regd.) 8 „
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: 18 your answer complete?
The Witness: I will add to that, taking i into —
n profft. 5
g a *. 6. 6° ¢@ ° Se
ie : ie a (rr. P. 2204) U ay 5 8 cos
2 22 1 —
. Boom 1310, 226 West Fackoon
3 Chicago, Illinois .. ae
3 Thursday, May 15, 19535
Met, pursuant to 8 at 10:00 a.m. ee:
ee F. mancher, Hearing Examiner.
7 „
*
*
net worth? A; I wouldn't know from erh.
Cpe
>
+
| = . x = ; 855 : 8
lerio Giachetti—Cross 3
© (Tr: p. 2205)
* .
| Hearing Examinér Hayerat: ‘This hearing will come 925
to order.
* Gn
»„»—' „ „ „ : ,
_< Mario Giachetti t:!
‘having been previously condi sworn, resumed the stand and
— further as follows:
* * * * *
so (Tr. p. 2208) :
1 oe „ „ „ @ at Big 1
Gross *
a
By Mr. Roya
(Tr. p. 2215) 3
ae „„ @ @ „ @
. Now, I believe yeu stated, did vou not, that .
Linco Products Corpora n was. incorporated on June 16,
19317 A. Ves, sir.
a
bas :
oi o 4:2
2 And its present net worth is $210, 175
a
one
0. Is that eber A. Whatever the records ow.
Q. What do the records show? * Don’t you know your
0
Q. * 1 is aver $200, 000? A. Tes.
n „
0. Now, the Linco Products Corporation has a net
worth of $086, 468, does it. not?
* * e's *
O
af
* 1
*
*
Q. Its paid-in, capital was “$12, 000, ‘wasn’t it? ay |
—
= .
—— 2 — ———
2
* —
—— uanssietltoll tosis scussbbengennsossrbaistnensisisape sinentwem
* ‘
. *
0
* —
— 5
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: H
> . Now, before the Linco Products Corporation was or-
"856a
I ario Giachetti- Cross
The Witness: Les.
4
By Mr-Royall: © 2
8 8
Q. Have dividend distributions been made from both f
those companies over the years?
Hearing Examiner Haycraft:
1 cr. p. 2217)
8 > e * „ „ * 5
You may answer that question—just that question.
The Witness: About dividends?, = = -
Be you paid dividends?
The Witness: Yes. . ane
„ 0 @e 6-6
ganized, and some time before the Linco Products Dis-
O
a
tributing Company was in operation, you and your brother_
had a partnership business with just a few hundred dollars
investment originally, didn't you? f A. Yes. 8
.
„„ ‘~ (Tr.,p. 2235)
, eos ee,
. Yesterday you gave some’ figures on advertising and.
I don’t want to ask you the amount of the figures because
those figures are confidential. 7
I asked you when did you start newspaper advertising?
(Tr. p. 236
ut 1929 or 1930.
The Witness: A
Reis
_° . 22 2
— Ilm 7]. , NOE ALERT IEE AT TE
5 Mario *
By Mr. Royall: *
z Q. Your advertising methods have varied from time
to time, have they not? A. Yes, sir.
. You have emphasized or have emphaiie on one thing
at some time, and on another thing at another time, is
that right? A. Yes, sir
sir.
Q. And you have learned that . the publie gets
tired of one form of advertising and you use another, is
that right? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that same goes for promotion, does it not? A.
Right.
Q. Now, you referred, I believe, in your r yes-
terday, to television spots. I will ask you if you have not
“had a fiye-minute television program, the. Dorsey Connors
show. | : |
oe. #828, 9 38. 8 |
A. Yes, sir. : apm *
(Tr. p. 2239)
. * R * * .
Q I believe you testified that your bleach was not made
by dilution of a stronger mixture, is that richt? A.
Right.
not? A. Yes.
Q. You can take the stronger solution and by merely
adding water and so on make a liquid bleach of five and a
quarter per cent, can you not? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that is done even by some as vse brands, is it
— A. Les, sir.
Q. Depending on the circumstances. existing. A. Yes,
Q. Many brands of W are made that way, are they :
Wa ati tI enti ent 2 *
Mario Giachetti—Redirect
(Tr. p. 2240)
„ »„„„„%„ „ 8
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
| By Mr. Deveny:
. On the five-minute program that you 11 testified
your company sponsors, during cross-examination, is yours’
the only company, the only ‘company that sponso
- (Tr. p. 2241)
or is sponsoring the show? A. No.
Q. There is no co-sponsor. A. No.
Q. What is the frequency of the program appeari
the air? A. Well, we have two.a day, or three da
week.
2. I am talking about the l can’t remem
the name of the program that Mr. Royall has been talking
about. A. It is a daily program. At night.
Hearing reset! Hayeraft: The n. pro-
ram.
The Witness: It is a fifteen minute program, ~~ we et
five minutes. |
By Mr. Deveny :
Q. Your company has five minutes Gf the fifteen. i
I
Q. What, kind of a program is it? A. Dorsey Con-
nors program. Household hints, suggesting how to =.
the house and gadgets. f
Q. What time of the day does that program appear?
A. That is 10:30. ;
. Isthatam.? A. At night.
. rr. p. 2242)
5 2 „4 „ (4 sy
1 2 . 0 a 2 855 ‘
*
on
>
859 9
ilerto Giachettt—Retross
Q. Why 4 your company manufacture bleach { in the
manner that it does, rather than diluting or concentrat-
ing? A. Because it is more econcantenl.
* # @ + *
RECROSS-EXAMINATION
By Mr. Royall:
(Tr. p. 2243)
. You have got it back on now, haven't you? A. No.
Q. You are going to have it back on in a few. days or
weeks, isn’t that right? A. I don’t know.
* 2 * * *
(Tr. p. 2244)
is ee * * & &
Edwin B. Hahn
2 1 witness called for the Commission, having beth previ-
_ ously sworn, resumed. the stand and testified. further
é follows: 3 @
G
DIRECT ie, (Continued)
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: Mr. Hahn has a corree-
tion to make, too, in his testimony.
The Witness: 1 was asked a question yesterday in re-
gard to our pricing practices and policies, as to what yard-
er stick we used. In other words, we used—well, I made the
statement that we used cost of raw. materials, marketing
costs and advertising costs in connection with our pricing
policies; and I would like to add to that that we have
always paid particular attention to Clorox prices, inas-
much as we were never able to, under the former Clorox
„
AON AO — Ro
By Mr. Deveny:
860a
8 Edwin B. Hahn Direct
8 ownership, watch advertising dollars or come anywhere N
near 9 advertising dollars and ex- 8
(Tr. p. 2245)
penditures with Clorox, and therefore felt that it would
to be our tremendous disadvantage and would in jure the
sale of our produet were we to = our product above
Clorox Prices. :
Q. Mr. Hahn, have you had an opportunity to check
2 ew records to determine ‘what portion: of the
. (Tr. p. 2246) :
1 sales are sold in Metropolitan Chicago? A.
Yes, I have. The figures have been drawn off of our books.
It is 61 per cent, Metro Chicago as — to the balance
of our marketing area.
(Tr. p. 2248)
* * * 2 **
| CROSS-EXAMINATION
By Mr. Royall:
| Trp ss
4, . * * * * #.
Q. I will ask you if seven new brands of bleach did not
enter the Chicago market in 1957, as shown by the Chi-
cago Tribune Consumers Panel, which you referred to.
yesterday. A. I am not familiar with it, but it could
have been many many more so-called bathtub operations
began here on a door to door basis; ‘and they come and go
every week. TCW our
R ä 2
„ : + . * ?
*
— 1% ve comes Me em te nb ee permet i Be raren LA IE OS COS LEA
* .
8613
Edwin B. Hahn Cross
Q. So you have a lot of different competitors, don’t you?’
A. These we do not consider as competition or as com-
petitors. 1
(Tr. p. 2258)
2 »„ % „ „%
Q. You know about this Dorsey Connors show, don’t. vou.
A. Les.
. is that on now? .* rt Yes, sir.
at — „
Resumed?
‘it? |
Q. Yes. A. We 1556 resumed it.
Q. In the past few weeks or months? A. Tes.
2. Now, i in oe Liquid bleach, did you give
7 (Tr. p. 2259)
away from time 0 time free cases? a
The Witness: We have used: it in a promotional way,
not in selling bleach, but as was testified here .
in lieu of cashed display allowances.
2 Crr. p. 2261)
The Witness: May I make a statement?
: (Tr. p. 2262) pie
1 Examiner Haycraft: Yes.
The Witness: I believe testimony was given here yes-
terday that from time to time we used equivalent to cash,
or cash, on a per case basis for floor displays in marketing
*
2
„ L ee eet ie eee hasn’t itt A.
Q. The Dorsey Connors oe. A. Have we resumed
K x:
3 Bdioin B. Hahn—Redirect
3 _areas which we consider to be low spot aréac. This may 8
5 be what vou are re referring to. |
.
(Tr. p. 2269)
N REDIR ECT EXAMINATION | :
e ————— 5 3
err. p. 2270) | ay
Q. Why was ape price increase in 1 of 1958 on
your: liquid. bleach put into effect? A. Well, this was
a combination of factors: ‘increased marketing cost on
an over-all. We had increased cost within all our manu-
facturing facilities, freight facilities, and 30 on, and for
this reason we were foreed: to take an increase in price.
eo 9-2 „ „
(Tr. p. 2273).
ee 9 „„ „
Salvatore Giachetti,
a witness for the Commission, resumed the stand and,
having been en — sworn, testified further as
follows:
: - CROSS-EXAMINATION ©
oa „ 8 „ é
(Tr. p. 2287) -
„ | =. Room 1310 226 West Jackson
(Gee Chicago, Illinois
Friday, May 16,.1958.
Met, pursuant to adjournment, at 3 :00 p.m. -
‘ ” BEFORE:
Everett F. HAycRaFt, Hearing Examiner.
* * @ „ „„
5 8683 a. Tae :
Neil A. MacDonald—Direct —\ ©
| (Tr. p. 2303) Ae
N + * * 8 *
~
United States Customs House
| ; Second and Chestnut Streets
at, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Tuesday, May 20, 1958 din.
Met, pursuant * notice, at 10: 200 o'clock a.m. -. 7
BEFORE
‘EVERETT F. HAYCRAFT, Hearing. Examiner.
_*- 2 © # @
oe Cr. 5. 2300
„ PROCEEDINGS ©
* «„ „„ „ ©
(Tr. p. 700)
Neil A. MacDonald
ws called as a’ witness on behalf of the Commission, and
having been duly — was examined and . testified as
follows: “ae
“(tr. p. 2300
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: What is your fall name?
The Witness; ‘Neil A. MacDonald.
ae ‘ DIRECT EXAMINATION -
By Mr. Tincher: - oe 2
8 . Mr. MacDonald, would you tell us what your occu-
pation or position ia? A. I am Treasurer of the Hood
Chemieal Company, Ardmore, e
es
— 4 —
A
2
i 864a
Ven A. MacDoriald—Direct
Q. What business is that company engaged in, sir?
A. In manufacturing and selling household chemicals.
Q. How long have you been connected with the Com-
pany? A. Approximately 10. years. 4 7
Q. ‘Have you been the Treasurer of the Company during
all that period? A. Yes, sir. ) Saye
. As the Treasurer of the Company, do you have access
to and work with the books and records of the Company?
A. I do, yes. : 4
. Would that apply to the financial books and records?
A. The financial books and records, yes.
. chee 22 2 „ *# ‘
ste (Tr. p. 2308)
„ * 8 * * ‘
0. 1 had you what we have marked as Commission’s
exhibit 472 for identification, and ask you if you will tell
us what that document is, the source of the figures thereon, .
and how they were obtained? A. Well, this document
is a record of the net sales of liquid bleach by bottle size
for the years 1952 through 1957. These figures were taken
from the audited annual report of the Hood Chemical
Company for the respective years. tae |
C. was that work done under your direction and super-
vision? A. This-work was done under by direction.
Q. Can you tell us how accurate those figures are?
(Tr. p. 2309)
7 a . 4 * 2 * ae
The Witness: Because of the way we keep our records,
these figures are accurate, not to the cent, but probably
to the—well, I would say a hundred dollars, in each total.
They had to be arrived at by obtaining the number of
cases of each size that were sold, multiplied by the average
days.
Neil A>MacDonald—Direct —
price of that product, and they are as accurate as figures
could be, taken from the records we have.
By Mr. Tincher:
Q. Now i in your bookisdeping . the way your ac-
counts are set up, is it possible for you to have what you
refer to as the exact down to the last cent figure? A.
It is possible, but it is a lot of work. It could be done, but
I would say it would take, for these six years, it would
take me, and I think I know the records, at least 30 to 45
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: You mean by that that
you would have to take every invoice?
The Witness: We would have to take every invoice, yes
MRS .
Mr. Tincher: I offer Commission’s exhibit 472, sir.
(r. p. 23100
Hearing Examiner Hayeraft: The exhibit will be re-
ceived in evidence, subject to a motion to strike later, if
there is any inaccuracy found. It may be received in
camera. “4,
By Mr. Mucha: e
Q. Let me hand you Commission’ s exhibit 473 for identi-
fication, sir, and I ask you to tell us what that is? A.
This is the regular annual report of the Hood Chemical
Company, — Pennsylvania, which was *
ä snes my N
: (tr. p. 2811)
direction, and audited by Price Waterhouse & Company.
+
*
* mila se Vee sont
=
3 8660
Neil A, MacDonald—Direct
2 Is that a regular Sa ‘of the ‘Company, that
was not prepared for this hearing? A. Iti is a regular
procedure, yes.
Q. Mr. MacDonald, 1 * you Commission’ s exhibit ©
479 for identification and I ask you what it is, who pre-
pared it, and what books it waa taken from? A. This
document is a summary of the advertising and promotional
a expenditures, made by the Hood Chemi Company, Inc.,
Ns this annual report, has it heen sii annually? ee
A. It has been published annually, ves.
Mr. Tincher: I offer Commission’ 8 exhibit 473 for
identification, sir . :
| (ie .
ize ’ > ae te ee 2 * :
~ (The document ‘referred to, 3 88 a
deen marked Commission’s exhibit 473 for identi-
“> fication, was received in evidence.)
4 8 ee
— * * * 9. *
—
aN err. P. 2318)
during 1952 through 1957. It was pre by myself and
my assistants, from the regular n audited records pf
our company's business.
. And are the amounts Selena: oh liquid ‘bleach only,
rather than all your produets?? A. The amounts are
for liquid ‘bleach ,only and do - pertain to any other
produet. 5
Mr. Tincher: J offer Commission s exhibit 479. I believe
ie it — be in ‘camera, as are comparable documénts.
2 „„ @
.
re
* rr Aenne a
re, —— ’ — * ** * K a Ne CNR ey 7
——
a! 1 867 a
Neil A. MacDonald--Direct
(The document referred to, heretofore marked
‘Commission’ s exhibit 479 for identification, was
received in evidence and ordered to be SEALED)
roi * * * 4 * f ae
7 2 - (Tr. p. 2329) Mee
* 2 @ 2 „*
0. Mr. MacDonald, I will show you: now —
Exhibit 481 — and this document is in camera, so we von
8 talk on the record about what the actual figures are but
notice in Section A that there is a/ decrease in 1957 of that
cost factor over what the cost factor was in prior years,
a decrease from 1953. I will ask you if there is any reason as
that you know of for that decrease? A. Ves, there ‘is.
There are two very good reasons, One, which we ‘ike to f
claim, i is more efficient operation, and the
(Tr. p. 2330)
other is the fact: that we moved our plant from Fullerton,
a Penrisylvania, to South Plainfield, New Jersey. 8
And why did that cause a cost decrease, sir? 0 A.
Well, it shortened the haul into the New Vork area.
Q. Is the New York area one of your major markets? 75
N A. One of our major. markets.
Pi (Tr. p. 2331) Bay
* Now, sir; I will show you —— 8 Exhibit 479,
__« once again this is an in camera document 80 we won't dis- 2
uss actual figures but I will indicate to you that there
have been a considerable number of changes by media used
for advertising and I will ask you if you know the answer
as ‘to why these various changes have Occurred? A.
Well, I don’t think anyonejknows the answer, Ws I know
the reason. :
. And what is that; sir? A. Well, one year if you
do a lot of advertising through a certain N and vou
2
. . 0 *
* 0 *
2 N 1
7
Neil A. MacDonald—Direct ;
«
you try another medium, and that is exactly what we have
done. It is very evident by looking at this that in one year
¥ we spent a considerable amount of money through one
medium, I happen to be looking at the newspaper now, and
the next year we spent a very small percentage of that,
and the same applies right through each medium. I think
that’s the best — or answer that I can give.
Q. Well, let me ask yot
your company doesn’t use all the media, rather than con-
*_eentrating and switching back and forth on various single
media? A. Yes. It is a question of cost. We couldn't.
afford to use all the media to the extent that we would get
results from it. ‘You don’t get results in our business from
putting an ad in es ag é
(Tr. p. 2332) 1 @.-
the paper and hoping that that will do from now on for
six months. Our business is one that you must have con-
tinual advertising. You have to, how your product in
some way, talk about it this week and next week and next
week, so on-.
achieve the results you expected or don’t achieve them,
especially if you don't achieve the results you expected
„sir, if there is any reason why
I think the same is true te most of the type of business
* : 4 .
Po MERE PE PEALE Qe 2 :
. 9
9
we are in. We find it that way, anyway, and that is the - |
reason for the fact that we didn’t continue to the full ex-
tent with any one particular. medium.
Q. All right, sir, thank you.
(Tr. K 2888)
aaa
in document,. butsI notice in recent yéars your
company has.commenced selling a pint size of liqui bleach. ~
Will you tell us the reason for that undertaking and, well,
e *
Also, sir, on Commission’s Exhibit 472 which is the
us of the various cases geld and once again it is an
ea, ears 8698 :
7 Nen A. MacDonald—Croos. 3
just tell us that first? A. Well, in certain areas we:
felt there was a demand for it, especially among the,
what would you say, the people that can’t afford to spend haa
much money on any certain given day. eg
Q. :And where are the pint sizes being sold, 1
in Florida, in fact all of them i in Florida.
(Tr. p. 2334) .
’ ; 234 „% # „ „ d
a he CROSS-EXAMINATION
By Mr. mayen: abbas 3 ay ee
N . (Tr. p. 2336 ö we
Ur. Tincher : I would like to state now and have the
record show that I have -instructed the witness in pre-
paring these documents to absolutely have no break out
of private label bleaches and I wauld insist on any inspec-
tion of the books that that irfformation not be made *
aple to respondent. i
Mr. Royall: Well, I would Jet to any such restric:
tion, your Honor. Any information we would get would
be confidential. We are trying to simplify this matter and
he says he has the liquid bleach: figure for both_—— © 5
Mr. Tincher; He said. 15 Had it = ways, sir, in total 8
and also i in break out. 5 es
Mr. Royall: wen, we’ would like: to examine = your
Honor. : ere
Hearing 8 Marat: That. wil be up. to the .. -
witness. If he has no objection to showing you his private
brand sales that is all right, there has been no question
_ asked on flirect which: N involve ¢ or — auch a *
870 a
‘Neil A MaeDonali—Crose 5
cr. P. 2339)
* * * * *
By Mr. Royall: |
* 222 „ # 7
. You 8 of moving your plant to . New
Jersey. When was that move made? A. It was started
9 July of 1957 and, of course, we had to keep in produe-
tion both places, and I would say it was completed so that
production was in the new plant approximately—let us
say—the 10th of September. an that day. It could be
a few days from that either way.
Q. Now, do your records show the size and dapacity of
your
ose N rr, p. 2340)
old plant and your new one? A. No, I don't think it
does. It is pretty hard to gauge the capacity of a plant
that is manufacturing our. product.
2. Manufacturing what? A. Liquid bleach. We have
never run it to capacity, so I can’t ; 2 vou a definite an-
swer on it.
Q. You haven’t got anything in | your books that show
that? A. No, we don't. .
. You would have something in your books as to the
= size and some other facts about it? 4 Yes, you have
the machinery and the size. oa:
Q. Now, is the Plainfield plant now the only plant you
have? A. No, we have four plants. 3
2. Where ate they? A. One is in J acksonville, Flor-
daz one in Lisbon, Ohio; one in Charlotte, North Carolina;
and one in South Plainfield; New Jersey. a
2. Have they also been recently built? A. wel, 1
don't. xnow what you mean by recently? f
5 When was it built? A. The Jacksonville plant i is
, 8718
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
approximately seven to eight years old; the 8 plant
is four to five; the Lisbon plant is an old plant.
* * * * *
(Tr. p. 2341)
oe: 22 * * *
8 REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
By Mr. Tincher:
. Mr. Royall ubs you on cross-examination if the :
price list referred to your private labels. You said No.
Are your private labels higher or lower than the prices
you have given us? A. They are lower. ae
(Tr. v. 2344) N
* * * * *
Benjamin Kunin |
was called as a witness and, after being properly and
duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Will you state your full
name?
The Witness: endend Kunin.
* * „„ „„ „
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. Tincher:
Q. Mr. Kunin, will you tell us what company you are
"affiliated with, sir? A. Hood’ Chemical Company.
Q. And what is your position with that —
A. General sales manager.
2. And how long have you held that position, sir?
A. Seven years.
2. Do you know how long the Hood Chemical Company
has been in existence? A. Well, no; don’t. My tenure
has been since January 1,
*
. 2
7 * 9
= — — oe 1 — er 5 e N 5
we cee taint an eatin AEA a Kae aca Bat ale — 2 . —
8728
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
: rr. p. 2845)
1947. es 8 (est
O. And what were you prior to the time you became
general“? A. The divisionabsales manager..
Q. And what do your duties as general sales manager
consist of, sir? A. Well, supervising all sales, and that
is about the extent. 8 3
d. Do you get out into the field and study market con-
ditions and your company’s products? A. Tes.
d. What products does your company produce and gell?
A. Besides blech! ee |
Q. Les, sir. A. Liquid starch, ammonia, and bluing.
Q. Are all these products liquid? A. Les.
d. Does your company produce and sell any industrial
or commercial bleach? A. No : 8
. Now, what product locations do you have for liquid
. bleach, sir? A. You mean distribution? . 3
Q. No, sir, production. Where is your liquid bleach pro-
duced? A. They are produced at plants in South Plain-
feld, New Jersey, Charlotte, North Carolina, Jacksonville,
Florida, ne aoe
: (Tr. p. 2346)
Lisbon, Ohio. F ö ae
Q. Are all of your other products produced at these
Various locations also? A. Les. 5
d. Is your liquid bleach a sodium hypochlorite solution?
A. Yes. „5 om |
2 Q. Is it a 5.25 solution? A. Yes. : |
d. Does your company manufacture the bleach itself?
A. Lean answer that—normally it is technical—but I can
say Yes to that. 5 a
2. ‘All right, sir. Will you tell-us now the sales area of
your liquid bleach? A. They comprise Philadelphia,
*
>
~~
8
By Mr. on
573
Benjamin EKunin Direct
Pittsburgh, the state of Florida, North Carolina, South
Carolina, — did I mention Pittsburgh?
Q. Yes, sir.
8 Hearing Examiner Haycratt: You didn’t mention New
Vork City.
The Witness: Well, that is a private label operation. It
has nothing to do with our brand.
Mr. Royall: What did he say?
The Witness: That is a private label. operation.
Mr. Royall: Private label operation.
(Tr. 5. 2347)
Q. Now, in these areas that vou have mentioned, sir, do
you serve the rural areas between the metropolitan cen-
ters? A. No, not everywhere. The reason for that is
that our advertising or promotion is e only get support
in the major markets and, therefore, they do not reach
the rural areas to get the benefit of our advertising media,
so that our major markets are those in the prime cities.
Q. And how does a liquid bleach producer reach the
‘rural areas? By what media? A. By local advertising.
Q. All right, sir. Now, does your liquid bleach sell in
the Southern part of the country or just selected areas?
A. Well, only in the areas that I have just mentioned. And
they, of course, I presume would be termed selected, such
as Florida, Philadelphia, Pitaburgh, North and South
Carolina.
Q. And is there any reason, sir for not amg in the
entire South rather than just the Carolinas and the state
of Florida? A. Well, the prineipal reason is, of eourse,
that we don’t have the financial means to expand into
other markets. Financial means, 1 mean by advertising .
and promotional — g
e 1 wes
N ‘
Q. Now, are your company’s other products sold in the
Jes. d ; 2 .- , :
Q. What sort of a sales organization does your com- .
pany have? A. Fodd brokers, principally, with the en-
8%4a
Benjamin Kunin—Direct 3
A brand product must be pre- sold to the consumer and a
that takes considerable finance to do that so that naturally
we just stay within the markets where we can support it =
(Tr. .. 2848)
same general sales area as your liquid bleaches? A.
«
.
use it for a testing ground whenever we have to test pro-
motions and we feel the broker who has many other princi-
pals to represent can’t devote the time to it, so we use
Philadelphia as a moving ground to sell direct and through
that we are able to determine how we could proceed in
other markets. l cone
ception of Philadelphia where we opérate direct through
our own sales office. aa
Q. And. why. is it you operate direct in Philadelphia,
sir? A. Well, we feel it is Heme ground and we can
Q. And is there. any reason why you use brokers in 8
other markets rather than the direct salesmen as you do in
Philadelphia? A. It is more economical. They have
retail staffs to do the work and for us to hire retail men
in each market with a sales representative, why, it would
be uneconomical and, of course, unprofitable.
* * * * *
kr. p, 2349)
1 * 2 /* 4
d. Now, is your liquid bleach sold freight pre bald to
the customer? A. Tes.
. Is there any limit caysed by any factor as to how far
you can sell liquid bleach from your point of production? -
*
—
a
1
875
„ . Benjamin Kunin—Direct
1 well, of course, ‘ie freight factor is very important :
and we try to confine our area within, well, a maximum of
250 miles. We make exeeptions in,some areas where we
have no relief and that is from Lab to Miami,
which is approximately 360 miles, we delivery. That is
the exception we make where we deliver in the larger area
than the 250-mile. It ean be affordable to ship.
Q. And what is the reason for the exception there, sir?
A. It has an old history for, well, back 50 or 60 ‘years ago
our predecessor was very fond of the Miami area and con-
ceentrated in the Miami area and developed that business
to such an extent that it {desirable to keep it. And, nat-
urally, of course, and again I am just speaking in the
context. of a layman when I talk about plants, naturally
we can’t have plants everywhere: so, since our plant has
been in Jacksonville and we have that business in Miami,
why, we make the exception and ship to that area.
(Tr. p. 2380)
Clorox and Roman Cleanser. That is about it.
Q. Is that in the entire area or were you just. speaking
of . Philadelphia? A. Nes. ‘
Q. These other bleaches that you have mentioned, sir,
_are they a 5.25 sodium hypochlorite solution, too? A.
Yes.
Q. Do you have a principal competitor in your liquid
bleach business, sir? A. Well, Clorox is one and then
in the areas, of course, there are local factors. The prinei-
pal competitor in Florida would be—another Principal
competitor would be Roman Cleanser.
In Philadelphia it is principally Clorox and that is all
In — it is Clorox - Austin.
Q. Now, what other liquid bleach . sell liquid 25
bleach i
in the various areas where you sell? A. Of course,
— — ne
we will test television one period and then .
I eI
“<<. 376a
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
d Where is the Austin Company? A. Pittsburgh. .
a * 4. . *
crx. 5. 235)
8 % % %. „%
5 5 , 9 *
Q. Do you sit in on discussions as to . t type of ad-
vertising will be used, how it will be used? A. Tes, 1
do. 8 ö
Q. What has your compariy found to be the most effec-
* 1 media to sell liquid bleach? A. I wish I could have
answer for that. I would be a priceless consultant. We
don’t know. We just hope that through study and through
What expenditure that we have that we strike the best
medium and hope that it hits and it isn’t always sure. So,
„„ Se ss
newspaper another period, and radio another period. There
is no answer to that. ä
Q. Which medium is the most expensive for your com-
~ pany to use A. Television.
Q. Has your company ever had a television program?
A. No.
. Ts there any reason for that? A. Well, it is very
expensive. at 2
Q. Let. me ask you the same question with respect to
radio. Have you ever had a program as distinguished
—
trom spots? A. No, and I can answer spots about
radio very easily. Yoy get more frequency than you do:
in, say, a 15 minidté,-hour or a half hour show, or you take
15 or 20 radio spots a week. You have more frequency,
-we think, therefore, by repeating the message more fre-
quently. It is more apt to register. We prefer spots on
radio rather than we do a show. Saas:
4 „ Na
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
. Now, do you advertise in auy magazines? A. No,
with the exception of a local magazine such as Ever
75 and that was only done in Florida.
(Tr. p. 2353) -
„FE es
Q. Now, what methods of promotion does your company
use in selling this liquid bleach? A. Well, that depends
on the extenuating circumstances. We will either use a—
we principally try to aim at the consumer. We do nothing
to give anything to the grocer, but if we put a case on of
one free with ten, we try to reflect it to the consumer or
| else a two cents a label off the quart bottle.
Q. And why is it that you aim at the consumer; sir,
rather than the grocer directly? A. Since we are not
in the position—well, the grocer is only interested in what
the consumer buys. He is not concerned with a give-a-way
for himself. We feel that we found in our * *
the grocer is only a factor i in
Ae (Tr. p. 2354) :
in channeli ing your merchandise, but the consumer is the
most im nt part of your business who purchases = =
merchandise; so, we aim at the consumer.
Q. Does your company give cents off on labels or cou-
pons for reduced prices? A. We give cents off—well,
we inaugurated a cents off program’ this year and that is
° two cents off on the quart size bleach, three cents off on the
half label. :
Q. Why was that program inaugurated, sir?
(Tr. p. 2355)
A. We felt since we are not in the position to have a
multiple media advertising campaign which would com-
prise radio, newspaper and television, and we could only
+
878a
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
limit e that the next best thing is to try to appeal | |
to the consumer through a price inducement.
Now, how successful that will be we don’t know, we are
just trying it out now.
Q. Is that in your entire area or „ A. No, we are
doing this in Florida for the present. We don’t know
* Whether we will do it here or elsewhere, but for the present
we are doing it in Florida.
Q. Now, is the Hood Chemical Company, Inc., affiliated
with or a subsidiary of any other corporation: A. No,
not to my knowledge. . |
Q. And does your company own any or control any other
liquid bleach producer? A. No. nits —ů—
. Now, sir, are you familiar with the price structure
in retail. stores in your selling areas for liquid bleach?
A. Yes, they vary. Do you want specifically the price?
Q. Yes, if you could give us. a general picture of the
priee structure. A. In Philadelphia it is 18 cents for 7
a a quart bottle, I can’t tell you the half gallon, I’m not fa-
miliar with that. That is the thing that we seem to watch
—the price barometer.
(Tr. p. 2356)
In Pittsburgh it’s 19 cents a bottle. And in Florida it’s
18 cents.
. Q Now, whose prices are these, sir? What brand?
A. Hood 33 bleach, > |
0. Now, what are the prices —these are all etait I .
take it. A. Yes.
Q. And what are the prices in the same areas for the
other liquid bleaches in the retail stores generally speak-
ing? A. Well, you mean — well, Clorox in Philadelphia
is 20 cents a quart, it's 20 cents in Pitteburgh,, it’s. 19
cents in Florida.
879a
| Benjamin Kunin— Direct
Q. How about Roman Cleanser, sir? The Roman |
Cleanser is 15 cents in Florida and that’s
we are concerned with.
Q. Are there any other + Austin Bleach in
Pittsburgh is 17 cents.
Q. Are there also private label brands sold throughout |
‘your area? A. Ves.
Q. And do they sell . or lower than these .
A. Lower. :
Q. Now, the prices that jou 6 given us, wid *
are . A. Les. .
| (Tr. p. 2357
0 Has Care been any ‘change within the last few, years
in those prices with respect to the price differentials be-
‘tween the various brands? In other words, I don’t mean
are the prices still exactly the same as they were, but is
the differential between the various prices approximately
the same as it has been in the past? A. It's about the
¢ sal ne. N ; ; ;
ai. € £2 eH
(Tr. p. 2359)
Q. All right, sir; I think due pending question was
whether or not your company has any cooperative adver-
tising allowance to your customers. A. om on —
six cents a case.
Q. And how long has that been true, sir? A Well,
we went into that about a year ago.
. Why are you using that particular plan, sir? 4
1 Well, competitors have put into their policy a six cents
per case cooperative allowance without proof of perform-
>. ance and. so, naturally, we were compelled to go along.
* 33 72 — ‘ >
880a
Benjamin, Kunin—Direct
(Tr. p. 23607
0 Who are those conipetitors that you speak. of, „ sir?
A. Clorox, Roman Cleanser, and 1 1 Austin. I
don’t know. ee : '
he ae oe ee
-
Q. Now, does this six cent plan require proof of adver-
tising? A. No, it does not. 8
Q. Does your company make 1 allowances or . |
tures for in-store promotions 3 retailers? K. No, we
do not. e 6
Q. Does your company Teceive any: Wee promotions Sy
as a general rule? 5 Not generally, but once in a
while we are lucky and we get one. .
. Efeuse me, had you finished? - A. By 4 good
graces of a storekeeper ‘who perhaps likes our salesman, -
but it isn’t general. - *
Q. Now, is an in-store promotion an aid to. the sale of
liquid bleach? A. It certainly i is.
Q. And can you tell us just briefly, why that is, sir:
A. Well, it receives a distinctive. display and therefore
it has very conspicuous attention. If they put up a 25 èase
display, naturally the * _ is moving around that
_ Misplay - 3a 8
“x, p. 23610
and it attracks attention — as a 4 result if increases the
sale.
Hearing Examiner Hayeratt: Where. are e these 8
usually placed? ver *
The Witness: They call them, in the food store term
+4 it's — end displays. It’s at the end of seme section.
—
* 2 „%„„ % „%
4 Mr. Kunin, what factors does your company Gieidet
in setting the prices it charges for its liquid bleacties? ö
881a
6
Benjamin Kunin Direct
1 A. well, now, I' don't know whether you are getting into hae
my field now when you talk about setting prices. <i
Hearing Examiner Haycraft: Who sets the prices, let's
"find out first. 4
The Witness: The prices are set by the cost. The Cost
Department gets into it and they, of course, go through
the various channels of what the glass costs and the in-
gredients cost, and the price is arrived at. I do not set it.
By Mr. Tincher: . im 8
. Are you consulted at all in establishing that?
Tc,rr. p. 2362) 5
n a . f
2. For what reason are you consulted? A. So that
we have at least cognizance of what the market condition
_ is and whether our price structure will have logic to put
us in the competitive position with the market: ©. .
Q. All right, sir. And in that study is there a price
leader in liquid bleach in your sales area?’ A. A price
leader—— „„ ee hak.
a? ar laa ae
*
Q. Brand leader, excuse me, sir. A. Clorox by far
dominates the bleach sales. Ba: Se he
Q. Now, is there any chemical difference that you know
of or any functional difference between your bleach ahd
the other liquid bleaches sold in your sales aregs? A.
Well, I wouldn't know about—I’ll be specific. I wouldn't
know about Clorox, but generally I would assume that
there isn’t any difference. The reason why I say Clorox,
they have an electrolytical system and there may be a
differencein Clorox; = st >. .
They have what, sir? A. An.-electrolytical—a
method of produeing their bleach. 3
yy
„ ne,
* Benjamin Kunin Direct
; Fr. p. 2363) ae
There may be a difference. Whether it all adds up to 5
and a quarter and like all the: rest of us I can't answer.
2 4 2 4
*
wee (Tr. p. 2365)
= N : * es „ „» „% ae ded : |
. What are the competitive tests in selling your house
hold liquid blech? oe ith ed
—
„„
22 2 2 4 * :
The Witness: That, of course, is contingent upon the
advertising and the extent of the advertising that takes-
place in a market. Now naturally if a manufacturer can
consistently advertise for 52 weeks and run a big line
space in a newspaper every week at all territory levels,
rural and what-not, and secondary markets, of ‘course;
that has the advantage of strengthening your market
VVV
Q. Does any liquid bleach producer so advertise in your
sales grea? A. Clorox considerably. 7.
„ „% 6 °¢ #6,
2 „ |# a
0 Now, sir, what are the competitive tests or factors
that face your company. in obtaining shelf space for Jour
. produets, liquid bleach?
5. 4 a 1 3 ** Me * 4 * : 5 2 : .
The Witness: Well, shelf space is predicated upon the
movement of the produet. If the produet has a pretty geod. *
movement, you will get ample shelf space. If the product is
eS (a
slow, naturally your shelf space will be proportionate to
its movement. re N N
ic}
5 1 Philadelphia, principally private label,
88342
Bonjamia Kunin—Direct .
‘By Mr. Tincher: |
Q. In turn, sir, ‘thei 8 that movement? A.
The. consumer, rata ces getting the consumer to move
it off the shelf?
Q. Can you tell us, sir, just generally speaking, if possi-
| ble and if not please indicate, but generally speaking, how
many brands of liquid bleach grocery Stgres in your sales
area carry on their shelves? A. Generally?
Q. Yes. A. Well, it would be a private label, two
brands. I Would say nnn there would be about three
| bleaches.
Q. And what are. those, generally? 8 n
on the market: N ow, Florida, I can be specific; it would
en Clorox, Roman Cleanser, and 33. In Pittsburgh, it
*
would be Clorex, Austin, and 83. In Philadelphia, it i is
_ Clorox and 33.
Now I am giving you—there are one or two shore, but
I don’t think you could term them as being factors a
Q. And . * sir?
22 1 .
(Tr. p. 2368)
The Witness: They operate on a very limited basis.
0 You say they are very limited, sir. Can you give us
some general idea of how limited .they are, whether they
are -_burely local or just part of a state or—— 2 „
2 * * «„ „ „ 1
The Witness: I will name one, Wonder Bleach, wha
is a little bleach operator and just sells to several agents .
* R 1 * *
A
: By Mr. Tincher:
2
884a
Benjamin Kunin—Direct
5 ,
Q. Have you seen their trends: any 1 other than
'. Philadelphia? A. You see very little of it in Philadel-
phia. It is down now to purely a private label operation.
Q. And what does—— A. One other organization,
to be specific, is Suntex, and they recently were acquired
5 by a new group don’t know who they are; they are
2
just starting. I only. saw an ad in the local food paper, |
called the Food Trade News, where ey are
„ (Tr. p. 2369)
contemplating advertising it and 8 back into the
market. That is why I couldn’t give you anything on these
other so-called. bleach operators in Philadelphia. N
Q. All right, sir, Now this class of operators we have
just been talking about, where in the price structure, in
the retail stores, does their bleach fit in? A. They
would fit in the category of about 16 cents a quart bottle.
Q. And. are their prices corresponding in the other sizes?
A. Ves.
Q. Does promoting a liquid bleach, either through an
off-price label or a coupon or any other way. you would
want to promote it, does that have any effect on the amount
of shelf space or in-store promotions that the product *
promoted will receive?
a 3.7 2 * *
The Witness: Ves, it does, because the store feels that
they have some inducement to stimulate vaca sales and
5 1 will give it more space.
e
Cr. p. 2371)
i . „ . a
Q. Now, can you tell us, sir, approximately what per-
centage of your liquid ‘bleach ‘is sold in grocery stores?
7 9
* .
e tert “? «ꝭ̊ ß xp ß ³»⁰ 3 :
PEO OLE e ne, v
= : POD A EI — 5 0
Nen 4 MacDonali—Crose
A. 1 would say all of it. We have no other—ere—do you
mean. such as department stores, drug stores and—— .
Variety stores? A. That is about it, grocery
stores, all of it. va „
9
(Tr. p. 2874)
„ * *
Hosen 200 Path
ae United States Candin House
, "2 Second and Chestnut Streets
. _ Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Wednesday, May 21, 1958
Met, pursuant, to adjournment, at 10:00 o'clock a. m.
BEFORE: ö N
EVERETT F. nn, Hearing Examiner.
“Cr. p. 2375)
PROCEEDIN GS
Neil A. MasDonald. | .
_ resumed the stand as a Witness and, having been viet
ously ‘duly eri, was further examined and “testified as ee
3 follows:
‘FURTHER CROSS EXAMINATION.
=~ kde Mr. Royal: |
, err. p. 2376)
0 N ow, rere the company 1 more than doubled its busi-
ness since 19488 .
* „ 1 & „* ra
(Tr. p. 2377) a
„ „% ©
2
> „ WW...
° > * : . 1
. 25
‘ 3 g
— acl — 2 — . ů —— — ETE
0 2 ~?
5 8863
Neil A. MacDonald—Cross
A. Well, I would have to refer to figures, but I would
say it has approximately doubled its figures. I would say
not quite doubled.
2. There has been an increase, your figures show, ever
since. 1952, has there not? A. Les.
Q. And that’s been a steady growth and an accelerated
growth, has it not, sir, in t
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.