Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — United States v. Carlo Bianchi & Co.
Supreme Court brief1963
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
INDEX ©
7 '
Opinions below
_ Jurisdiction - -
— Question presented. ¥s
Statutory and cBntract provisions involv ed..
Statement —_... *
. Reasons for granting the writ. !
Conclusion. _..—. -
CITATIONS _
Cases: :
ann —
/
——
mm
nS |
—
i]
Allied Paint & Color Works, Inc. v. United States,
No. 27236, C.A. 2, decided August 29, 1962-.
‘Blake Construction Company, Ine. v. United States,
296 F. 2d 393- S evacandadéagsnecedcesdl=covnses
‘Fehlhaber v. United States, 138 C. Cls. ‘571, certiorari
denied, 355 | Bette Te eegeaee epee oe .
H. L. Yoh Company v. United States; C. Cls. No. 435-
455, decided April 7, 1961_.-.------.-----------
Hoffmann v. United States, 276 F. 2d Ee
Kihlberg y. United States, 97 U.S. 398-..--.- .---
Langoma Lumber Corp. v. United States, 140 F. jue.
460 affirmed; 232 F. 2d 886__.-.......-.:-------.
Lowell O. \West Lumber Sales Company v. United
ae SD Ree eee error
L. W. Foster Sportewear, Co. ¥. United- States, 145 wa
Supp. ee oe aa cael oes eaain
Mann Chemical Laboratories, Ine. v. United States,
174 F. Supp. 563-..--.
_ M. Berger Company v. L ‘nited States, 199 F. ‘Supp. 22
McKinnon v. United States, 178 F. Supp. 913, reversed,
I Bi aso Kav 5 eden nsawe sends snny /
Ripley v. United States, 202 US. a. <; oie Sis
United States v. Gleason, 175 U.S. 588-- - --
United States v, Hamden Co-operative Creamery Co.
185 F. Supp. 541, affirmed, 297 F. 2d 130_---..---
(1)
Td
Conm—-Canthasind i —
United States v. McKinnon, 280 F. 2d 908 _ oA 7
United States v. Moorman, 338 U.S. 457.. 11
_ United States National Bank of Portland . vo “United he
- States, 178 F. Supp: 910. aoe ees Py
United States v. Wunderlich, 342.U.S. 98. Sy eee ae 10
Volentine and Littleton v. United States, 136 C. Cis. 638. 5
Volentine and Littleton v. United States, 145 F. SePP-
EER ae SE rary GALS Seen ek er RS A 11
Wells & Wells, es v. United States, 269 F. ‘2d 412_- 7,9
Statutes:
Act of May 11, 1954, 68 Stat. 81 (Wunderlich Statute)
(41 U.S.C.;381-829)...,...-...2.... _ 2-3, 5, 6,9, 10, 11
28 U.S.C. 1346(a)(2). MPS CR NE nee 7
Miscellaneous:
H.R. 6214, 82d Cong., 2d Sess... se 10
‘H.R. 6301, 82d Cong.; 2d Sess......___-__--______- 10
H.R. 6338; 82d Cong., 2d Sess...) es , 10
H.R. .1839, 83d Cong., Ist Sess___....---.--------- 10
H.R. 3634, 83d Cong., Ist Sess:... .-.._-.-_.. bales 10
H.R. 6946, 83d°Cong., 2d Sess_..... -._._---_-----. — .
Hearings Before the Subcommittee of the Senate
Judiciary Committee on 8. 2487, 82d sind , 2d Sess.,
wee 80, Slee.........%- SO
H. Rep. 1380, 83d Cong., 2d Sess... beeen “. 10, 11, 12-
S. 2432,.82d Cong., 2d Seas... ........------------ 10
S: 2487, 82d Cong., 2d Seas... ....-.----.--/------ 10
S. 2
ne Come, B06 Gee... <2: 22-22-22. 42---ee |
' ; |
2
%
in the Supreme Court of the Gnited States -
= _ -. OCTOBER TERM, 1962 — -
| | ) ) ot
No. —
UNItep .STATES; PETITIONER
v. oe
CarLo BIANCHT AND Company, /ANC.
; / ,
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARY TO THE UNITED
STATES COURT OF CLAIMS —
The Solicitor General, on - behalf of? the United
_ States, prays that a writ of certiorari issue to review
the sdterlocutory judgment of the Court of Claims —
entered in this case on J anuary 14, 1959, made final
by the judgment. of that court entered on May 9,
1962.
"OPINIONS BELOW oy
"The opinion of the Court of Claims of January 14,
1959 (App. A, infra, pp. 15-21) is reported at 144 C.
‘Cls. 500. The opinion of the Court. of Claims of
May 9, 1962 (App. B, infra, pp. 52-53) is not yet
‘reported. |
; . JURISDICTION
. The final judgment of: the Court of Claims was
entered on May 9, 1962.. A timely petition for -re-
: (1)
eT
hearing was denied on July 18, 1962. Che jurisdie-
tion of this Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C, 1255(1).
Whether, where a contractor has specifically agreed,
pursuant to a standard clause in government con-
tracts, that the administrative decision on a factual
dispute arising out of the contract is to be “final and
_ conclusive” and the Act of May 11, 1954, similarly
' provides that “such decision shall be final and con-
clusive unless * * * not supported by substantial evi-
dence,’’: the Court of Claims may upset such a
decision without regard to the substantiating ev idence
‘ before the administrative authority and solely on the
- basis of evidence presenbett in a de novo trial to that
court.
STATUTORY AND eee ‘PROVISIONS INVOLVED
1. The Act of May 11, 1954, 68 Stat. 81. (Wunder-
lich Statute) (41 U.S.C. 321-322) provides:
§ 321. Limitation on pleading contract-provi-
sions relating to ws wand: standards of
. review.
No provision of any contract entered into by
the United States, relating to the finality or
conclusiveness of any decision of the head of
any department or or banked r his duly author-
ized representative or in a dispute in-
volving a question arisin pa such contract,
' shall be pleaded in any y4 lit now filed or to be
filed as limiting judicial review of any such
decision to cases where fraud by such official
‘or his said representative or board is alleged :
Provided, however, That any such decision shall ’
3
be final and conelusive unless the same is fraud-
ulent or capricious or arbitrary or so grossly
erroneous as necessarily to imply bad faith, or
is not supported by substantial evidence.
822. Contract-provisions inaking decisions —
final on questions of law.
No Government contract shalt contain a pro-
-vision making final on a question of law the
decision of any administrative official, repre-
. sentative, or board.
2. The “Disputes’* or “Finality- Clause”’ Article of
the contract here involved provides ae infra, pp.
22-23) :
Article 15. Disputes —Except ‘as otherwise
specifically provided in this contract, all disputes
concerning questions of fact arising under this
* eontract shall be decided by the contracting officer
subject to written appeal by the contractor.
within 30 days to the head of the department
concerned or his duly authorized representative,
whose decision shall be final and conclusive |
upon the parties:hereto. In the meantime the
contractor shall diligently proceed with the
_ work as directed.
This action arises out of respondent’s claim for cer-
tain unanticipated costs allegedly incurred by it in
performance of a Government contract. The Court -—
of Claims’ findings disclose ‘the following pertinent
facts:
On or about J aly 3 3, 1946, the respondesit entered
into a contract with the United States for the ¢con--
strnetion of an earthen dam across Canacadea Creek,
%K
4
Almond, Steuben County, New York (Abe. 21). The
work was to be performed _ stri¢t accordance’.with
the specifications, schedules and drawings for an esti-
mated consideration of $3,330,330. Ibid.
The present action concerns a claim by the respond-
ent for additional compensation for unanticipated ex-
‘penditures allegedly incurred asa result of subsurface
conditions which were e tered during operations
_under the con ‘which were alleged to be mate-
tially different from those described in the drawing
and specifications.’ On May 5, 1947, the contracting
officer formally denied | the respondent’ s claim (App.
35-36),
The respondent appealed under the “Disputes”’
Article of the contract (supra, p. 3) and was
accorded a hearing by the Corps of Engineers Claims
and Appeals Board (App. 37, 50). At this hearing,
the respondent presented its evidence and contentions
at length.” In a written opinion dated December 9,
1948, the Board denied the claim (App. 51).
This action was then filed by respondent in the
court below. The Government’s initial defense was
that the administrative denial was supported by sub-
* Specifically, the assertion is that respondent is entitled to
an equitable adjustment for the costs of installing permanent
tunnel supports sincé’ the weathered and unstable condition
of the rock through which the tunnel was blasted wan, in its
view, an unforeseen condition.
* At the hearing before the Board the only witnesses called
on behalf of respondent were its general superintendent, a
civil engineer, the engineer for the Cabot Construction Com-
pany, respondent’s subcontractor, and a gfologist, although five
other prospective witnesses, all of w testified at the trial
before the Court of Claims, were presgnt at the time.
_
stantial evidence on the record as a whole and that,
pursuant: to the so-called Wunderlich statute, supra,
pp. 2-3, the administrative decision was therefore
conclusive on the parties (App. 20). The court, how-
ever, refused to review the administrative record to
determine whether it contained substantial evidence
supporting the Board’s decision, stating (ibid) :
In our opinion in Volentine and Littleton v.
United States, 136 C. Cls. , holding that
the trial in this court should not be limited to
the record made before the contracting agency,
but should be de novo, we recognized ‘‘at t:.>re —
were logical weaknesses in our position. We —
concluded, however, that the intent ef Congress
in enacting the Wunderlich Act was in accord
with our conclusion, and we adhere to that con-
clusion in this ease.’ | |
After a de novo trial, at which a total of fifteen wit-
‘nesses testified,‘ the court concluded that the evidence —
did not support the administrative decision. Ibid.
"In Volentine and Littleton v. United States, 1236 C. Cls. -
638, 650, Judge Laramore, dissenting, recognized the logical
weakness in the court's position and urged that a “common
_ sense application of the Act * * * , considering the back-
ground of the legislation and the administrative procedures
available to aggrieved contractors,” required that judicial
review be confined to the administrative record unless it is
demonstrated that because of the procedure employed by the
appeals board the contractor was unable to adequately present
his case. . '
* As the Government pointed out in the Court of Claims, by
‘ presenting only four witnesses before the Claims and Appeal
Board respondent deprived that Board of fair opportunity
to decide the'case on substantially the same evidence that had
been presented inthe Court of Claims. *
/
Bok 7
courts, have had oceasign to ‘consider the question
there raised.* AH of the courts which have passed
upon the question, with the exception of the Court of
Claims. are of the view that administrative: decisions
rendered under the Standard Dispute Article of gov-
ernment contracts are to be reviewed on the adrainis-
trative record and sustained if supported by substan-
tial evidence. If a plaintiff ‘sues, however, in the
Court of Claims, rather than in a district court, he
niay obtain a trial d¢ nore. , :
#28 U.S.C. 1946(a) (2) imposes a $10,000 ceiling on district
court jurisdiction ovee government contract claims. Accord-
ingly, most government contract litigation is in-the Court of
Claims It is highly! signifieant, therefore, that such a wide-
spread conflict has ey developed on the precise issue here
involved. a
* AMied Paint & Cdlor Works, Inc. ¥. United States, No, 272%,
CA. 2, decided Au vo, 1962: Welle & Wells, ine. vf ‘nited
States, 269 F.2d 412 (CA. 8): Lowell O. West Lumber Salex
vo nited States, 270 F. 2d 12 (CLA. 9); United States v. Me-
Kinnon, 230 F. 2d M8 (CA. 9): Hoffmann v. United States, 276
F. 2d 199 (CLA. 10)$ Langoma Lumber Corp. ¥. United States,
140 F. Supp. 460 (E\D. Pa), affirmed, 232 F.2d 886 (CA. 3):
Mann Chemical Lahakutovies, Inc. ~. United States, V74 F. Supp.
Met OD. Mas): ZL. W.\Foxts + Sportawear Co. v. United States 145
F. Supp. 448 (ED. Pa): (sited States National Bank of Port-
land +. United States\ 17% F. Supp. 910 (D. Ore.): United
States ¥. Hamden Co-kperative Creamery Co. 1x3 F. Supp.
M1 (ED. N.Y.\, afi , 207 F. 2d 130 (CA. 2); M. Berger
Company <. United States, 199 F. Supp. 22 (W.D. Pa.). But
ef. Blake Construction Company, Ine. ¥. United States, 26 F.
2d 393 (CA. D.C.), holding that a determination which was
outside “agency expertise” (Whether there were grounds for
reformation of a contract) should be made by the district court.
The Bloke decisiom distinguished this type of determination
from issues as td excessiveness of profits and performance in
conformity with contract: <pecifieations,
eo \
t - . .
.9 ; re . - :
te . p \ : ~ -
i , en!
: - | % “ ' t * 6 : ; “ e 7 ‘ ba :
- The* most recent; pronouncement on the issue is
ie found in Allied Paint -& Color Works, Inc. v. United |
States, ‘No. 27236, C\A. 2, August. 29, 1962 (not. yet - ¢
ported), App. C, infra, a a oting that appel- ae
lant had not been precluded from introducing before the’ |
_ administrative | tribunal whatever evidence it wished to
x present, the the Seéond Circuit approved the district
court’s refusal to take additional testimony in decid- |
ihg the issues before it and affirmed-its action in con- °
| fining - review to the administrative record... 'In -the
: course of its opinion, the Court of Appeals, adverting -
to gopsfli - in decisions, said (App. s uifra,
_- The law ‘is quite unsettled whether a district.
court reviewing the“administrative ruling of —
_ one of the contract disputes: boards should grant
a trial dé novo and take testimony, or w hether
‘it ‘should: erat its review. to the’ record "made:
before the: ‘administrativ e board. -The Court of — ;
«Claims: has generally held that a trial de. novo 4 -
~~ should. be granted. Volentine and Littleton v.
United States, 145-F. Supp. 952 (Ct. Cl. 1956). ote
-Fehlhaber Corp. v. United States, 151 F. Supp.
817 (Ct. Cl.) vert denied, 355 U.S.’877 (1957)...
“The distriet courts and the courts of. appeals, on
the other hee have tended to restriet court.
‘ review to a review of the administrative record.
United States v. McKinnon, supra; Lowell O.
— West Lumber Sales v. United States, 270 F. 2d
. 12 (9th Cir. 1959) ; Mann Chemical Labs., Inc.
_ v. United ‘States, 174 F.:Supp. 563 (D. “Mass.
-1958) ; L: W.: Foster Sportswear, Inc. 145. F;
- Supp." 148 (E.D. Pa. 1956): United. States ©
Nat'l Bank v. United States, 178.F. Supp. 910
o"
oe”
| (D. Ore. 1959). But. ate Blake iui Lo. 0. W: ‘
United States, supra,* * * |
The Ninth Circuit. has also held that faithful ad-
herence to the congressional. purpose underlying the ..
AS underlich Act and respect for the integrity of con-—
tractual provisions providing for a final and eonelu-
sive administrative determination of factual disputes
require that the. distriet court. be ‘hound by the* acts
- revealed in the’ administraitiy e record if supported by
Sra evidence. Lowell O. West Lumber Sales -
| . United States, 270 F. 2d 12 (C.A. 9); see, also,
“cKivwon v. United States, 178 F: Supp. 913-(D.
Ore.), rev érsed : ‘on other grounds, 289 F. 2d 908 (C.A.
9). Similarly, ‘the Court of Appeals for the Tenth
Cireuit ‘has held that the administrative decision is
final-unless, in terms of the Wunderlich statute, it is
_**not supported by substantial evidence.”’ Hoffmann
v, United States, 276 F. 2d 199, 200. (C.A. 10). T®ese
h decisions make it clear that on factual disputes there ~
_ is no de nove review in the district courts.’ bat
2. Eight years: ago, Congress, in_ the “Wunderlic ‘he
statute,’’ defiried the scope of judiei lal. review: of
administrative determinations of. factual - disputes
* This result is + nieaaaiei by Wells Wells, Ines
_ Onited States, 269 F. 2d 412 (C.A‘ 8). .Although- the ros ;
-of Appeals there held that appellant-contractor was not in a
position to urge on appeal -for the first time that the district
‘ court erred -in ‘not trying the case de novo, the opipion makes .
it plain that, for the purpose of the substantial evidence test
~ mm the Wunderlich statute, the reviewing court is limited to.
the record and evidence before the administrative board or |
_ agency, 269'F. 2d at 415. See, also, Z ae Lumber Corp. v.
United States, 140 F. Sepp. ind (E.D. Pa
886 (€. A. 3)- OY
), affiratéd, 232 F. 2d
10 —
under the “firnality’’ clause ‘of standard form govern- .
ment contracts... Act of May 11, 1954, supra, pp. 2-3...
In prescribing limited judicial review, the pertinent
| language unequivocally declares that the administra- °
tive decision ‘‘shall be final and conclusive unless + #.
not supported by substantial evidence.” * The refer-
ence to “substantial evidence” would cer ‘tainly appear
to point to the evidence developed in the record
before the administrative agency. Any other conelu- -
sion does violence to thé evident purpose that weight
be given to a decision made with the specialized
knowledge of the government officials ‘de — by
the contracting parties. 2
We shall not attempt in this petition a full exposi-
tion of the legislative ‘history. .We point. out, how- |
; “--. ever, that various bills were submitted to Congress,"
"and that Congress failed to adopt measures which
\would have provided for more. “expansive review." —
'’ The statute also denies conclusive effect to any administrative
determination which is “fraudulent or capricious or arbitrary or
so grossly erroneous as. necessarily to imply bad faith * * *.”
See supra, p. 3. . These exceptions are not involved here.’
. 1°, 2482 and 2487, 82d Cong., 2d Sess.; H.R. 6214, ‘6301, and ©
6338, 82d Cong., 2d Sess.; S. 24, 83d Cong., 1st Sess.; H.R. 1839
and 3634, 83d Cong., Ist. Sess.; H.R. 6946, 83d Cong., 2d Sess.
" There is no doubt that Congress passed’ the Wunderlich
statute in order ‘to make <ertain that judicial review of an
administrative. decision under the disputes clause ‘would not be
limited to the sole ground of fraud but would also. be available
where the:contractor establishes “arbitrariness and | capricious-
_ ness.” H. Rep. 1380, 83rd Cong., 2d Sess., p. 4. In-this
respect, Congress can be sajd simply to have codified the view,
many times reiterated by this Court prior to its decision in
United States v. Wunderlich, 342 US. 98, that the administrative
A
or
n- ees ee aa
‘One: of the pear which. failed to obtain iden a
‘pointedly omitted all reference to the “substantial
-evidence”’ rule and provided for a de ‘novo, trial. See
| ‘Hearings before a Subcommittee of the Senate
Judiciary Committée on S. 2487, 82d Cong., 2d Sess. =
Feb. (15, 1952, pp. 33-35. We note also that the
pertinent committee reports reflect a clear Congres-
sional understanding that the. parties would present
all of their evidence before the administrative agency
Thus, in reporting the. W underlich bill out. taxarabix, ;
the House Judiciary Committee Report explained—
resolution of a factual question under the disputes clause must be
~ sustained unless it is capricious or so grossly erroneous as to neces-.
sarily imply bad faith, or fraud. See, ¢.¢.. “Wihlberg v. United - .
States, 97 U.S. 398, 401, 402: United States v. ae 1T5-U.S.
588, 602, 609; Ripley v. United States, 222 U.S. 144, 148; United
States v. Moorman, 338 U.S. 457,461. But a pre- Wunderlich
decisions in no way justify ‘the type of extraordjnary de novo
review sundertaken - by the court. below: in its decision in the
present case and in Volentine and Little fon. v. United States,
145 F. Supp. M52: Fehthaber vi United States, 1388 C. Cis. 571,
‘certiorari denied, 355 U.S. sir: and H7. Lb. Yoh Company. V
> United States, C. Cls., No. #35455, decided April 7, 1961.
12
It has been brought to light in public hearings —
that it is the exception rather than the rule that
contractors in the presentation of their disputes
} } he + ht . . bhi } . ¢} =
. . J . : c .
is _the-exeeption-rather_than the rule that—eon-
tracters—in-the—presentation oftheir disputes
are afforded an’ opportunity to~ become ac-
- quainted with the evidence in support of the |
Government’s position. It is believed that tf
the standard of substantial evidence ts adopted
this condition will be corrected and that the
records of hearing officers will hereafter con-
tain all of the testimony and evidence upon
which they have relied in making their. deci-
sions. It would not be possible to justify the
retention of the finality clauses in Government
contracts unless the hearing procedures. were
conducted in such a way as to require each
party to present openly its side of the contro-
- versy and afforded an opportunity of rebuttal.
_ [Emphasis added.] [H. Rep. 1380, 83d Cong.,
2d Sess., pp. 4-5.]
_ 3. The overwhelming majority of formal govern-
ment construction and procurement contracts contain
a “disputes” clause comparable to the one involved
here. The Court:of Claims is the principal forum
in which contract claims against the.government are
filed. Such suits may also be brought, however, in the
, 1B
district courts (note 6, supra). Certainly, a uniform
rule .of procedure | should apply’ irrespective of. the.
forum chosen. The administrative. boards involved
and the parties to the administrative proceeding are
entitled to know’ whether the administrative trial is
merely a “trial run” or a proceeding in which the
parties are obligated to put in their entire case.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons,. it Is respeetfully sub-
mitted that the petition for a writ of certiorari should
be granted. ' | —_—
. wa ARCHIBALD 3 :
Solicitor General.
‘ JoserH D. GuiLFoyLe,
Acting Assistant Attorney General.
Joun G. LAvGHLIN, Jr.,
Harvey M. GOLDBERG,
Attorneys.
OcToBER 1962.
APPENDIX A
Gn the United States Cour of Claims
No. 466-54 .
(Decided January “14, 1959)
CARLO. BIANCHI AND COMPANY, INC. v. THE
'* * UNITED STATES .
|
|
Mr. Robert W. Nnoe for the plaintiff. Messrs. Robert F.
Bradford and William H. Matthews were on the briefs.
Mr. Martin E. Rendelman, with whom was Mr. Assistant
Attorney General George Cochran Doub, for the defendant.
Coad mel .
_
Ru
OPINION
Mappen, Judge, delivered the’ opinion of the court:
‘The plaintiff claims. that/in performing a contract with
the Corps of Engineers of the War Department, it en-
countered changed conditions within the scope of Article 4_
of its contract which caused it to incur extra expense for
which the Government should lve paid but did not.
The contract was made in July 1946. The plaintiff was to
build an eatthen dam across Canacadea Creek at® Alniond,
Steuben County, New York.* One item of the work was the
blasting through rock of a tunnel some 710 feet long. The
blasted area was to be approximately 17. feet in diameter
and the finished hore after the construetion of the concrete
lining was to be 13 feet in diameter. All of the work under
the contract was completed on time, the contract completion
date. as extended, being June 36. 1949,
The Army Engineers had om ns test borings. in ‘the area
through which the tunnel was to be built... The inv itation for
bids, upon which the plaintiff had acted in submitting its
bid, contained the <!andard provisions requiring the bidder
to investigate the <ite and learn all that could he learned
\
16
about the conditions which would be encountered in the per-
formance of the contract. The plaintiff made a thorough
examination of the nature of the rock, wherever it was ex-
posed in the area, and of the logs of the test borings made by
the Army Engineers. The logs of the borings indicated that,
except for a distance of about fifty feet at each end of the
tunnel, over which the rock covering would be relatively
shallow, the rock through which the tunnel would pass would
be “unweathered”. rock, i. e. rock without seams in which
clay or mud had accumulated, The importance of the un- -
weathered condition of the rock is that such rock would
better remain in place in the roof of the tunnel without ver- __
tical support when the tunnel was blasted through.
The specifications contemplated instability of the rock for
fifty feet at each end of the tunnel. They provided for the
insertion in these locations of strong steel ribs set four feet
apart, with steel “liner plates” one-eighth of an inch thick
on top of them.
The plaintiff's excavation subcontractor, experienced in -
tunnel work, blasted out the tunnel. A good deal of rock
fell from above the required height of the tunnel. The fall
from the blasting and the overbreak was “mucked” out by
the night crew. No cribbing or other temporary protection
against falling rock was used at this stage of the work. The
blasting through of the tunnel was begun in December 1946
and finished by March 12, 1947, all in winter weather.
Lecause of the considerable excess fall of rock while the
tunnel was being blasted through, the plaintiff requested the
Government's resident engineer to authorize the installation
of steel ribs and liner plates through the entire length of the:
tunnel, this additional material to be paid for by the Govern-
ment. The resident engineer replied that unless there were
indications that the tunnel would cave in, such authority
would not be given.
The plaintiff, in ‘correspondence during the next several
months, repeated its request, which the Government repeat-
ediy denied. The plaintiff caused the situation to be
examined by several experts. They found that, throughout
the length of the tunnel, the rock contained seams filled with
mud and clay; that these seams were saturated with water
and offered little resistance to the fall of the rock when its
17
vertical support had been removed. Since the tunnel had
been blasted through in the winter when no moisture could
enter the ground from the surface, which was about 100 feet
above the tunnel, the rock was relatively stable at that time.
When the ground at the surface thawed and the spring rains -
came, the saturation of the seams in the rock occurred or was
increased, as was the instability of the overlying rock.
In the disputation in the writings of the parties, the Gov-
ernment took the position that all that was needed was “tem-
porary protection” sufficient to enable the workmen to safely
clear out the tunnel.and construct the concrete lining. If
that was all that was needed, it was no more than the plaintiff
had contracted -to do, at its own expense. Such protection —
would, apparently, have been wooden cribbing, sufficiently
strong to prevent a relatively small volume of rock from
crashing to the floor of the tunnel.
The plaint iff's contention was, and is, that the réck above
the tunnel was so unstable that unless “permanent protection”
was installed, of a kind which would have to remain imbedded
in the concrete lining of the tunnel, not only would the work-
men be endangered but the tunnel could not be completed be-
cause of the danger of large falls of rocks which would make
it impossible or impracticable to properly construct the con-
crete lining.
On May 5, 1947, the contracting officer formally notified the
plaintiff that it was his decision that no additional steel tun-
nel lining would be authorized to be placed at the expense of
the Government ‘The plaintiff, on May 29, filed an appeal
from the contracting officer's decision. It also renewed its
request to the contracting officer for approval of the steel
permanent protection which it proposed to use. On June 13,
1947, the contracting officer advised the plaintiff that it might
install the proposed steel protection if it chose to-do so, but
that the Government thought that the installation was more
" expensive-than was necessary; that nothing more than tem-
porary protection, which the plaintiff was under a duty to
furnish, was necessary: and that the Government would not
pay the cost of either kind of protection. This letter ;
gested and recommended to the peu a lighter and lees
expensive type of protection.
18 7
The plaintiff in further correspondence, informed the
contracting officer of the advice which it had received from
expert consultants that the type of protection recommended
by‘ the contracting officer would be inadequate and unsafe.
It then proposed a design, of steel protection, with detailed
specifications, and requested approval of the design. - On
August 11, 1947, the contracting officer approved the use of
the plaintiff's design, saying, however, that it was unneces-
sarily strong and expensive and that the Government would
not pay for it unless higher authority reversed his decision.
The plaintiff then proceeded to install the permanent pro-
tection and completed the lining of the tunnel on May 8, |
1948. , ? ote
The Claims and Appeals Board denied the plaintiff’s ap-
peal on December 14, 1948. ‘ai
The evidence does not tell us in detail what the process .
of constructing the lining of the top of the tunnel would
have been, if only temporary protection had been installed,
sv that there would have been no steel ribs and lining plates
to serve as a form forthe lining. Presumably, removable .
wooden forms would have been used and the space above
them would have been packed with rocks and concrete and
the voids filled with cement grouting. Tlie evidence seems
to us to be quite overwhelming that, the condition of insta-
bility of the rock above the tunnel being what it was, it would
not have been practicable to construct the lining of the.
tunnel by that method. There would quite certainly have
been a large number of heavy rock falls during the several
monthsof the construction of the tunnel lining, and the
rearrangement of the fallen rocks and the packing of the
voids in such a way that the arch of the tunnel would sup-
port the unstable weight above it, when the forms were
removed, would have been a difficult if not arrimpossible task;
All the risks of the success of this task would have fallen on
the plaintiff, since it had contracted to construct a permanent
and usable tunnel.
The plaintiff says, and we have found as a fact, that the
- weathered and unstable condition of the rock through which
the tunnel was blasted was an unforeseen condition. The
contract contained the usual Article 4 of Government con-
struction contracts, relating to subsurface or latent unfore-
19.
seen conditions, The Article is quoted in our findings of
fact. The unforeseen condition having arisen, the Govern-
ment was under a contractual duty to pay the plaintiff the
cost of solving the difficulty. The contracting officials were
adamant in their position that “temporary protection” would
solve the problem. It is possible that it would have, but
the evidence to fhe contrary was so strong that it would °
have been foolhardy of the plaintiff to proceed on the Gov-
ernment’s advice, but at the plaintiff's own risk.
We get-from the record the impression that. the Govern-
ment officials, in their correspondence with the plaintiff in
the spring and summer of 1947, kept their minds almost ex-
clusively upon the text of the contract, and paid little atten-
' tjon to the conditions in the tunnel. Those conditions had
changed importantly after the spring thaw and rains had
saturated the unforeseen clay and mud in the seams of the
rocks. ‘The communications of the Gov ernment. ‘officials kept
harking back to the duty of the contractor to examine the
site and the test borings and learn what could be learned
about the difficulties which would be encountered. But the
plaintiff had done that, and had not learned of the difficulties
which in fact developed. The purpose of Article 4 of the
contract was .to insure the an wen that very
contingency. Os
The contract required the contractor to protect its work-
men against harm from falling rocks, and to produce a safe,
solid, usable tunnel. We think the Government officials felt
that they could save the Government money and at the same
time subject the Government to no risk, by standing on the
terms of the contract . If the temporary protection which
they insisted was sufficient did not produce a good tunnel,
the contractor was still obligated to produce a good tunnel,
and the Government could not lose by the experiment.
The Government urges that the plaintiff's difficulties were
of the plaintiff's own making; that if it had proceeded im-
mediately to line the tunnel after it had holed it through,
the rock would not have been so unstable. The Government
urges that the strong current of air which blew through the
tunnel after it was holed through made the rock unstable,
and that the tarpaulin coverings over the openings were not
sufficiently airtight. It would be difficult to maintain an
the roof of which was dri
no significant effect upon stability of the rock in and
above the roof.
“Wunderlich Act”, that decision not have finality unless
it is supported by substantial evi We think that on
consideration of all the evidence, the dontracting officer's
decision cannot be said to have substantial support.
The Government urges that in this case the plaintiff did
not present its case fully to the Claims and Appeals Board,
_.gince it presented only four witnesses before the Board, but
. presented fifteen witnesses at its trial in this court. The
Government says that the plaintiff used the Board as a mere
- waystation in its progress to this court, and thus did not
give the Board » fair chance to decide the case on substan-
tially the same evidence which has been presented in this
court. So far as concerns the difference in the number of
witnesses, several of the additional witnesses in this court
gave unimportant testimony. Se eae,
nesses who did give important imony in this court, did
not testify before the Board.
__ | In our epinion in Volentine and Littleton v. United States,
1 C. Cls. 638, holding that the trial in this court should not
limited to the record made before the contracting agency,
yea t should be de novo, we recognized that there were logical
: in our position. Weconcluded, however, that the
intent of Congress in enacting the Wunderlich Act was in
rd with our conclusion, and we adhere to that conclusion
in this case.
| The plaintiff claims that, in addition to the extra expense
of installing the permanent steel protection in the tunnel, it
a Bh em oO
Se ee ee
a ee ee —_
/ es emma ae
21
have found that there was delay and expense resulting from
the cause alleged by the plaintiff. F.H. McGraw and Com-
pany v. United States, 113 C. Cis. 29.
By stipulation of the parties, the instant proceeding has
been limited to the decision of the question of liability. Our
conclusion is that there is ‘liability of the defendant to the
plaintiff. The amount of the plaintiff's recovery will be
determined pursuant to Rule 38 (c).
It is so ordered.
McLavonuum, District Judge, sitting by designation;
‘Warraxer, Judge; and Jones, Chief Judge, concur.
Laramore, /Udge, took no part in the consideration and
decision of this case. )
Ys FINDINGS OF FACT ”
The gourt, having considered the evidence, the report of ;
Comnyssionet William E. Day, and the briefs and argument
of counsei, makes findings of fact as follows:
1. Plaintiff is a corporation organized and existing pur-
suant to the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts
with its principal office and place of business in Framing-
ham, Massachusetts. :
2. On or about July 3, 1946, the plaintiff and the defend-
ant, acting through the War Department, Corps of Engi-
neers, as a result of competitive bids submitted, entered into
a contract for the construction of an earthen dam across
Canacadea Creek, Almond, Steuben County, New York.
e work was to be performed in strict accordance with the
specifications, schedules and drawings (which were prepared .
by the defendant) for an estimated consideration of $3,330,-
330 based upon unit prices for thé various categories of work
items. The contract provided that work should begin within
10 days after receipt by the plaintiff of notice to proceed,
and be completed not later than 900 calendar days after
that date. The time for completion of performance was
extended to June 30, 1949, by Modification No. 15. The
work was satisfactorily completed on that date and formally
on behalf of the defendant by the contracting offi-
cer by letter of July 20, 1949.
2% Pursuant to Rule 38 (c), by stipulation between the
parties hereto, the trial was limited to the issues of law and
-amount of recovery.
A Tho contract specifications-provided for the blasting
through rock of « tunnel approximately 710 feet long for
the diversion of water. Before placement of the,oncrete
lining, the bore éf the tunnel-was approximately 17 feet in
" . @iameter.. The finished bore with conerete lining in place
_ was 13 feet in'diameter. ‘This ction was brought to recover -
igcreased costs which the plaintiff says it incurred by reason
of ‘changed conditions encountered which required the in-
* stallation of steel tunnel protection in the form of steel arch
_ ribs and liner. plates throughout the length of the tunnel, ©
and also by reason of alleged delays in the work because of
| Se refusal by the defendant to direct the in-
a ation of such support asa pay item.
‘§. Pertinent and material provisions.of the plaintiff's con-
‘tract are as follows:
Axriciz|4. Changed conditions.—Should the contrac-
_tor encounter, or the Government discover, during the
progress of the -work subsurface and/or latent condi- . _
- tions at the site materially differing ° m those shown
~ on the drawings or indicated ‘in specifications, -or
unknown conditions of an unusual nature differing ma-
terially from those ordinarily encountered and generally
ognized as inhering in work of the character pro- ~
‘vided for in the plans and specifications, the attention
of the contracting officer shall be called immediately to.
such conditions before they are disturbed. The on-
_ tracting Officer shall: thereupon promptly investigate
the conditions, and .if he finds that they do so mate-
rially differ the contract shall with the written approval
of the Secretary of War or his dul authorized repre-
sentative, be modified to provide for any increase or. ~
decrease of goat and/or difference in time resulting from
such conditions. oa
Arricus 5. Extras —Except as- otherwise herein =
will be
vided, no.charge for any extra work or material
- gllowed unless the same has been ordered\in writing by —
"fact. relating to the right of plaintiff to recover, reserving
for determination by further proceedings, if necessary, the
(
the contracting officer and the price stated in such order. .
‘a ’ Sw: - 2. eee
- ‘Agricey 15. Disputes—Except as otherwise specifi-
cally provided in this contract, all disputes concerning _
' -questions.of fact arising under this contract ‘shall be
i)
- ™
ecided by the contracting officer subject to written ap~.
i | 2
peal by the contractor within 30 days to the head of the
‘department concerned or his duly authorized .repre- ~
sentative, whose decision shall be final aud conclusive
__ upon the parties thereto. - In the meantime the contrac-
tor shall: diligently proceed, with the work as iwected.
* ae i * :
. % = @ «
_ Articie 25. Accident Prevention.—In orfler to pro- -:
tect the life and health of employees in the pérformance - -
of this contract, the contractor will comply with all
rtinent provisions of the “Safety Requirements for
¥Excavation—Building—Construction” approved by the
Chief of Engineers, December 16, 1941, as revised 15_
March 1943 (a copy of which is on file in the office of
the contracting officer) and as may be amended, and
will take or cause to be taken such additional measures
as the contracting officer may determine to be reasonably
’ necessary for this putpose. The contractor will main-.
tain an accurate record of and will report to the con-
tracting oa in the Naeger _— on the. forms
prescri y the contracting officer, of death,
occupational disease and traumatic wffury arising out of
or-in the course of employment on work under this
‘contract. The one officer will notify the con-
tractor of any non-compliance with the foregoing pro-
visions and the action to be taken. Thecontractor shall,
after receipt of such notice, immediately correct the .
conditions to,which attention has been dirécted. Such
notice; when “served on the‘contractor or ‘his. repre-
*- geritatives at the site of the work, shall be deemed suf-
ficient for the purpose aforesaid. If the contractor fails
or refuses to comply promptly, the contracting officer —
_ thay issue an order stopping all or any part of the work.
“When satisfactory corrective action is taken, a start
* order will be issued. No part of the time lost due to any
such stop order shall be made the subject of claim for
extension of time or for éxcess costs or damages by
the contractor: chee
_6, Pertinent and material provisions of the specifications
_ made apart of the contract are as follows: |
GC-3. SITE INVESTIGATION AND REPRE-,
SENTATIONS.—Thie Contractor acknowledges. that
he has satisfied himself as to the nature and location
of the work, the general and local conditions, particu-
‘larly those bearing upon transportation, disposal, han- -
dling and storage o ential availability of labor,
water, electric power, roads and ‘uncertainties of
anit . j —, ,
e
weather, river stages, tides dr similar physical condi-
tions at the site, the conformation and condition of the
ground, the character. ity and quantity of surface
and subsurface materials to be encountered, the char-
acter of equipment and facilities needed preliminary to
and during the ‘prosecution of the wor [Italics sup-
plied) and all other matters which can in any way affect
- the work or the cost thereof. under this contract. An
‘s failure by the Contractor to:acquaint himself with all _
the available information concerning these conditions:
will not relieve him from responsibility for estimating. -
‘ properly the difficulty or cost of successfully perform-
ing the work. The Government assumes no responsibil- .
‘ity for any.understanding or representations made by
any of its Officers or agents during or prior to the ne- - -
gotiation and execution of this contract, unless (1) such
understanding or representations are expressly sta
in the contract and (2) the contract expressly provides
’ that responsibility therefor is assumed by the Govern- -
ment. Representations made but not so-expressly stated
-and for which liability is not expressly assumed. by the
Government in the contract shall be deemed only for the
a ‘of the Contractor and the Government will
-not be lid@le or responsible therefor. .
a . Ee ° "
TP402. TUNNEL EXCAVATION.—42., Scope—
- The tunnel bore may be driven from either or both ends
by any of the usual methods of tunneling, provided the
driving is continuous and progress is consistent with
that indicated on the — schedule. © 7'emporary
tunnel protection shall be provided where required for
safety of the workmen and shall be placed progressively
after each heading blast [Italics supplied] and prior to
resumption of excavation and drilling operations. The
tunnel shall be maintained free of water by means of
drains “and sump — Tunnel dust shall be kept
undef proper control by wet drilling and —*
The tunne) shall be adequately. lighted and ventilated.
- Only electric or air motorized equipment shall be used in
thetunnel. An adequate power supply shall be available
atall times. All rock projections inside the tunnel neat"
line shall be removed and overbreak beyond the tunnel
pay line shall be backfilled with appro material, com- .
pacted to the required density without cost to the Govern-
ment.. Where and as the arch. ribs and. liner plates are
placed to the designated grade and alignment, the over-
break voids at the crown and haun shall be pro- .
gressively backpacked with selected tunnel excavation in
a way that will hold the completed tunnel protection on
a
25.
dine and grade. Where sucli tunnel protection is not re-
uired all overbreak beyond the tunnel pay line shall’
be backfilled with concrete. Such work shall be done
‘together with placing of the concrete tunnel lining.
/
After the concrete tunel lining is in place and prior to
tunnel and collar grouting. the entire length of the
tunnel shall be — at a pressure not to exceed five
— to complete filling remaining ‘overbreak voids. -
uch grouting ‘including furnishing and placing of
grout pipes will not be paid for as a unit and all costs
‘shall be included in the contract unit price for tunnel
concrete lining. Disposa) of tunne].excavation shall be
in accordance with subparagraph TP3-Old.
b. ere. ema of rocedure shall be in accord-
ance with subparagraph TP3-05 b (3). At the outset
- and as the work progresses throughout the length of
the tunnel, the breaking qualities of the rock structure
_ encountered shall be observed and the spacing, depth,
loading and shooting ~eatience of the holes shall be ad-
justed accordingly so as to keep to a minimuin over-
reak'and shattering of the rock formation outside the
tunnel excavation limits. The‘ Contractor shall be re-
sponsible for all overbreak and shall. replace it with
approved mateyial and placing methods without: cost |.
to th re ent. All blast-loosened rock.still in place
shall be immediately broken out or working conditions © °
otherwise made safe by the placing of temporary
* protection.
TP403, ‘TUNNEL PROTECTION.—a. Scope—
Tunnel protection shall-be furnish and placed as
' pequired for distances of et the first 50 feet
at each end of the tunne u
which includes the under- _
ground portion of the outlet transition. ‘Such tunnel
protection conforming to the cross sectional sha of
the tunnel and transition, shall consist of steel arc ‘ribs
and corrugated steel liner plates as indicated on the
drawings or required, including tie rods ‘and spreaders. —
Liner plates shall be placed before the setting of ribs.
In erecting, each arch rib'shall be properly spaced, set —
to the designated grade and alignment, and in a position
normal to-the tunnelaxis. Each rib shall be connected =X
‘ to each successive one by seven (7) sets of steel tie rods
and pine spreaders, uniformly spaced. The Contractor
shall submit detail drawings indicating fabrication,
_ splicing of ribs and erection methods of the proposed
tunnel protection. No material ——. shall be made
prior to receipt of the Contracting fficer’s written
approval but such approval shall. not relieve the Con-
tractor of his sole responsibility for damage resulting.
S-
~ &
26
from the inadequacy or lack of such protection. Steel
for arch ribs, liner and splice plates, tie rods and éther
items necessary to tunnel protection shall be commercial
products and shapes having the necessary physical and
chemical qualities for the intended purpose and shall
be fabricated according to the best standard practice.
‘The érection of such tunnel protection shall be carried ©
as close to heading blasting as is feasible without undue
ay to tunnel protection in place. =
b. Steel Tunnel Protection Su 8.—Steel arch rib
tunnel.protection supports shall be erected in the tunnel
sections, where tunnel protection is indicated on the
drawings or. directed by the Contracting Officer and
shall be steel’ I-beams of the size, weight and “
and bent to the shape indicated on the drawings.
maximum center to center ors | shall be as designated.
Suitable dowels shall be provided at the invert to main-.
‘tain foot of ribs in proper position. Tie rods and
spreaders shall be installed at the same time.ribs are
set. Blocking and other timber required for erection
shall be furnished by the Contractor. Arch rib —
limited to two for each rib, shall develop t full
strength of the rib. Steel ribs shall be left in place
and embedded in the concrete tunnel lining.
c. Steel Liner Plates.—Steel liner plates for tunnel
ae pane shall be placed in the tunnel sections, where
such protection material is indicated on the drawings
or directed, to furnish cove for the tunnel roof sec-
tion above the Bog ence ends of plates in ad-
joining rows shal) be staggered and half plates furnished.
where necessary for this purpose. Liner plates shall
. be left in place and have concrete tunnel nog Loge
4
yi their inner surfaces. .Liner plats
fabricated corrugated steel plates not less than number
- three (3) gauge, bent to the designated radius and
_pressed into the required shape consisting of integral
‘side with square corners and elongated holes for con
necting bolts, similar and equal to Armco Type 18-inch
section. ;
‘TP404. CONCRETE TUNNEL LINING—a.
Scope\—The entire tunnel bore including the outlet
transition.shall be lined with concrete which shall con-
form to the applicable requirements of Section X. No
tunnel concrete shall be prior to the ee
of the entire tunnel bore, then its placement # be
. to completion. * * * [Italics
supplied)’ ~
ca
TP+-08..PAYMENT.—a. Tunngl Excavation.—Pay-
ment for tunnel excavation will be made at the contract -
unit price for “TunnehExcavation—Unclassified,” Item
No. 10. No payment will be made for excavation be-
yond the pay line and all such overbreak shall be filled
with suitable material or concrete as required without.
cost to the Government. The contract unit price shall
include all costs of drilling, blasting, excavation, haul-
; ing, and di 1 as specified in paragraph TP3-01d.
4 — he ng Ath my - all —_ of fur-
nishing and placing liner plates, and tunnel supports,
incladin tie rods and pipe aprendiors, tified herein or
directed by the Contracting Officer, will be made at the
applicable contract unit‘ price for “Steel Liner Plates,”
Item No. 11 and “Steel Tunnel Supports,” Item No. 12.
egy payments will be made according to paragraph
11-14.
_ ¢. Conerete Tunnel Lining.—Payment for furnishing
_ and placing concrete lining in the tunnel, except the
furnishing of cement, will a made at the Contract unit
og for “Concrete in Tunnel,” Item No. 34. Payment
or. furnishing cement will be made at the contract unit
price for “Cement,” ‘Item No. 36. All of concrete
or repair grouting required to-fill overbreak voids out-
side the peg ne shall, be included in the contract, unit:
price for Item No. 34. \ -
d. Reinforcing Steel-Payment for reinforcing steel,.
placed as shown on the\drawings or directed, will be
made at the contract unit price for “Steel, Concrete Re-
~~ ypgape Item No. 38. (See subparagraph TP10-
re . 7 * a ne
TP10-01. SCOPE OF THE WORK .—The work cov-
ered by this Section consists of furnishing all material
and equipment and performing all labor for the manu-
facture, transporting, placing, finishing, and curing of.
concrete in. the structures included in these specifica-
tions. 7 ; ' |
. -«@ . - -
TP10-22:, MEASUREMENT AND PAYMENT .—.
Concrete. * * *
.b. Portland Cement. * * *
c, Reinforcement.—(1) Measurement of reinforce-
ment will be made of the lengths of bars actually placed
in accordance with the drawings or.bar schedules ap-
proved by the per ey, - Officer, or in accordance with
the instructions of the Contracting Officer. The meas-
ured lengths will be converted to weights for the size of
* “
‘
28
bars listed by the use of the unit weights r lineal foot
in Fe one OG B- the
Contractor, r ;
will be paid for at the contract unit price per pound for
~ plaintiff's chief engineer, president and general superin- —
- tendent visited the site of the Almond Dam and tunnel on
1946. They looked for all open cut rock
in the vicinity of the praposed dam on highways and the
railroad nearby which might disclose the nature of the rock
- that would be encountered in the course of construction. To -
| int themselves as to the type of material to be en-
countered, they examined the area of the dam, the borrow
area sites and any test pits in those areas, the site where
the railroad and the highway were to be relocated, the site
of the stilling basin at the tunnel outlet portal, the site
of the tunnel inlet and the site of the spillway. The
only exposed rock was near. the railroad, acroes ihe valley
from the tunnel and st a higher elevation. They did not
find any exposed rock in-the area laid out for the Almond
Tunnel. They examined the specifications, schedules and
drawings relating to the diversion tunnel included in
the contract work. They examined the logs of{the borings as
. shown in the contract drawings but did not examine the
cores which were available for inspection at. the U. S. Engi-
neer Soils Laboratory at Ithaca, New York.
9. The Cabot firm began the driving of the iunnel on De-
cember 12, 1946. It was engaged prior to that time in open
%
29
cut excavation of rock adjacent to both the outlet and inlet
areas of the tunnel. The existence of mud seams beyond.
the pay line on vertical slopes at the outlet end near the still-
ing basin caused considerable overbreak there, and resulted
in apprehension on the part of the plaintiff and its subcon- —
tractor as to conditions which might be encountered as the
tunnel excavation progressed. On December 10, 1946, rep-
resentatives of both firms went to Baltimore, Maryland to
confer with the contracting officer as to these matters. ‘They
conferred with Colonel J. S. Seybold, who told them that —
he would visit the site. He did so on December 12, 1946, but
did not confer at the site with the plaintiff. The contracting
officer (who was also district engineer at Baltimore) con- —
ferred at the site of the work with the resident engineer. _
As a result of the discussions referred tv above payment of
about $8,000 was authorized and thereafter accomplished
near the outlet area of the tunnel, for overbreak due toa
vertical mud seam.
10. The crew of workmen who were engaged in driving the
tunnel consisted of eleven men and a superintendent on the
day shift who were engaged in drilling operations, and five
- men on the night shift who were engaged in mucking opera- —
tions, that is, cleaning out and hauling away the rock which
had been blasted after the drilling operation. .
11. From the beginning of the work on the tunnel, Mr. E.
F. Diehl, Vice President and Chief Engineer of Cabot Con-
struction Company and Mr. W. D. Dunham, President of
that firm, urged Mr. D. H. Mather, defendant's Resident
Engineer, to make provisions to have additional steel on
_the job to prevent delay in the driving of the tunnel. They
were advised that the ‘only steel which would be provided
would be for the 50 feet at the outlet portal and 50 feet xt
the inlet portal. Cabot proceeded. with tunnel work at the
outlet end, erecting the steel arch supports and liner plates
for the first 50 feet. The roof of the tunnel for the first
50 feet was badly jointed. There we: vertical intersecting
seams filled with mud. The steel arch ribs were placed at
4-foot intervals as the drilling operations progressed. The
liner plates were placed above the ribs. As the drilling con-
tinued beyond the 50 feet at the outlet end, the condition of
the roof was about the same for the next 16 feet. The Cabot
30
tirm requested and was given permission to install four ad-
ditional units of the steel arch ribs and 16 additional feet
of liner plate at the outlet end. In effect, this steel was
borrowed from that which was on hand for use at the inlet
end of the tunnel. When it became necessary to remove
the borrowed steel for use at the inlet end, approximately
5 cubic yards of rock fell from the roof.
12. The plaintiff wrote the following letter to the resident
engineer on December 18, 1946, concerning the borrowing of
steel for the 16 feet of tunnel mentioned above:
Reference is made to a recent discussion ey Oo
had with Mr. Diehl and Mr. Dunham of Cabot -
struction Corporation, relative to steel tunnel supports
in the tunnel outlet transition.
_ - We have a communication from them stating that they
agree to replace stee] supports damaged by blasting and
re} for that reason.
e concur with them in this respect and will replace
_ steel supports so damaged at no additional cost to the
government. .
On I’: ember 20, 1946, the resident ongineer replied to the
above us follows:
The receipt is hereby acknowledged of your i. ‘or of,
18 December 1946 relative to stec! tunnel supports in
the tunnel outlet transiticn. _
The agreement made as stated in your letter is
satisfactory. ,
It is r~ ~¥~¥ ~ cause of the difference of opinion
in this was due to a misunderstanding of the
use to Ww r. of t struction
hich Mr. Dunham of the Cabot Con i
proposed to put the tunnel supports and to
_ clarify the +s position, the following refer-
ences to the specifications are made.
a. TP4-02. Tunnel Excavation. a. ry ater He
rary tunnel protection shall be provided for the safety
of the workmen and shall be placed progressively after
com Ranting Sieet and eres 00 secumgan ¢ exca-
vating end drilling operations.
b. 403. Tunnel L’rotectivn. a. Scope —Tunnel
protection shall be furnished and placed as required for
distances of approximately the first 50 feet at each end
of the tunnel which includes the underground portion
of the outlet transition—The erection of such tun-
nel protection shall be carried as close to heading blast-
ing as is feasible without undue damage to tunnel
protection in place.
/
,
31
According to the specifications, the two types of tun-
nel protection are for different purposes as indicated
in the specifications. It was not considered feasible by
this office to use steel tunnel ion as close to the
heading as may be required for the protection of the
workmen while excavating and drilling without sub-
jecting it to destructive damage, which was the objec-
tion to so using it.
If, in the use of steel yr peaeemen , lieu of
temporary protection, any steel members are amaged
which delay the work, no additional time will be
‘allowed for such delays.
13. On January 10, 1947, the defendant's resident engineer
sent the following letter to the plaintiff : '
This letter wil] serve to confirm the discussion relative
to tunnel protection attended b Mr. Peter Bianchi
President of Carlo Bianchi & Co. Inc., Mr. E. Diehi:
of the Cabot Construction Co., Tunnel Sub-Contractor,
and- Messrs. D. A. Losey and D. E. Mather of the
Government ar me orce. This conference was
held in the Resident Engineer’s Office, Thursday after-
noon, 9 January 1947.
At this time it was understood and agreed that as
stipulated in Par. TP4-03, Tunnel Protection, a. Scope,
that the steel tunnel protection as defined in this para-
graph, would not be placed beyond the first 50 feet of
the outlet end of the tunnel including the transition
section, or to approximate station 27+10. That from
this station. 27+ 10 to 21+ 00 approximately, temporary
tunnel protection as indicated in Par. TP402, Sunnel
Excavation, a. Scope, is to be used. Mr. E. Diehl’s
request to use steel ribs and timber lagging for this
purpose is in accordance .with the specifications, and
- therefore permissible, provided the outside edge of the
steel ribs are set so as not to be inside the outside neat
line of the concrete tunnel lining. and as much of the
timber lagging is removed just prior to concreting as is
consistent with safe working conditions. The expense
is to be borne by the contractor. The material use for
such temporary protection is optional as long as it
-furnishes adequate protection. '
14. Except for the steel arch ribs and liner plates referred |
to above, the Cabot firm drilled the tunnel with no protec-
®on overhead except that which was provided by careful
inspection of the roof as the drilling rig entered the tunnel
in the morning and left in the afternoon. The roof was
ee1208 © - 62-3
32
examined and rock which seemed loose was removed with
scaling bars.
15. The tunnel was “holed through” by March 12, 1947.
—€teanup work commenced immediately by the Cabot firm
but there were rockfalls after the cleanup crew had re-
moved loose rock from the floor of the tunnel. For the *
first 200 feet, the cleanup crew returned to remove rock
which had fallen after they had performed the cleanup |
operations but the rockfalls were so extensive that for the
remaining 510 feet of tunnel there was only one cleanup
without return for further cleanup. The cleanup crew
finished its work on March 25, 1947. .
_ 16. Because of the rockfall experienced during the tunnel
driving operations, Mr. Diehl and Mr. Dunham of the
Cabot firm requested the defendant’s resident engineer, Mr.
Mather, to authorize the installation of steel tunnel sup-
ports and liner plates throughout the length of the tunnel.
They were told by Mr. Mather that such would not be au-
thorized as a pay item unless there was an indication that
the tunnel would cave in: .
‘-47. The assistant resident engineer, Mr. Dale Losey, testi-
fied that in light of the condition that existed at Almond
Tunnel. in April or May 1947 with respect to rockfall, it
would be necessary to install some protection before it would
be possible to line the tunnel with concrete. '
" ~ 48, On April 10, 1947, the plaintiff sent the following letter
to the defendant’s resident engineer : ;
The work involved in excavating the tunnel bore on —
this job has been completed, and it has been driven
Permanent tunnel protection in the form of steel Liner
Plates and Tunnel Supports has been installed for dis-
tances of 50 ft. at each end of the tunnel.
The work of concrete lining the tunnel is scheduled
for accomplishment early in the 1947 season.
It is our opinion that, in recognition of the extremely
hazardous conditions existing inside this tunnel, imme-
diate consideration should be given to the provision of
per tunnel protection. throughout the entire
ength of the tunnel. . ‘
workmen cannot be expected to carry on under
these conditions, which would expose them to the ever-
present risk of serious injury or even death from falling
rock. It can. be expected that they will refuse to enter
the tunnel unless and until these hazards are eliminated.
We su therefore, that we be given immediate
authorization to extend this permanent protection of
steel supports and Liner Plates throughout the entire
lencth of the tunnel, with compensation for same being
-— e to us under the applicable Job Items No’s. li
and 12.
‘19. The assistant resident engineer on April 15, 1947, sent
the following reply to the above-quoted letter :
The receipt is hereby acknowledged of your letter
dated 10 April 1947 relative to tunnel protection.
My position in regard to — request for extendi
contract items 11 and 12 (Permanent Tunnel Lining)
to protect the ‘tunnel bore, between Stas. 21+00 and
27+ 10.5, which is in addition to 50 feet steel lining in-
cluding the outlet transition ‘stipulated for each end of
the tunnel, is the same as stated in my letter to your
company dated 10 January 1947, subject: Temporary
Tunnel Protection. That letter confirmed the approval
at a conference on 9 January 1947, in which Mr. E. F.
Diehl, Vice President of the Cabot Construction Co.,
proposed the use of steel ribs and timber lagging for
temporary protection in accordance with Paragraph
TP4-02. Tunnel Excavation. a. Scope. On 14 January
1947 you were advised erally that your tunnel sub-con-
tractor was using for temporary protection upstream
from Sta. 27+ 10.5, steel ribs’ purchased for Item 12, and
you were advised that their use in temporary protection
would-be approved provided such use was confirmed in
writing. is was done in a letter dated 14 January
1947 signed by Mr. T. A. Coyne. This is evidence of
a Clear understanding that the section of the tunnel be-
tween Stas. 21+ 00 and 27+ 10.5, that temporary tunnel
protection for the safety of workmen was to be used in
accordance with the applicable specifi¢ations.
The fact that your sub-contractor was able-to drive
the tunnel through the section fn question safely with-
out placing such temporary protection does not in any
way relieve you of your responsibility for protection of
the work and workmen os the operations required
for placing the concrete tunnel ining. en ;
In reference to the fifth paragraph of your letter as
equired by the specifications you are responsible for the
safety of all workmen on your contract and shall pro-
vide during construction at your own expense adequate
safety protection for them and the work involved.
.
3
; Therefore the further procurement and placing of con-
\\ tract items 11 and 12 are not authorized.
\, For the Resident ineer :
\
20..On April 23, 1947, the plaintiff sent the following letter
to the resident engineer with a copy to Colonel J. S. Seybold,
District Engineer, Baltimore, Maryland:
Re: Permanent Tunnel Protection
We have received a letter dated April 15, 1947, from
«Mr. Dale A. Losey, Assistant Resident ineer, in
reply to ours of April 10, 1947, on the above subject.
~ ‘We wish to point out that the request contained in our
letter of April 10 does not concern itself with the matter
- of temporary tunnel protection; it is concerned wholly
with the permanent type of tunnel protection as de-
scribed in the contract specifications were
The specifications clearly indicate that Govern-
ment intended installation of permanent steel >
and liner plates to a distance of 50 feet in from
end of the tunnel and for such additional distance as
conditions would require.
within the tunnel was such that should be
made for tunnel The Resident
| ‘took the position the tunnel
ees Say we Saray ay Ser 5 ep Sem
eac
35 |
- In view .of the now known facts. with feference to
the dishodgment or failure of large areas of the tunnel
roof, a condition which could have been anticipated and
Ceatee bad Ge Cepesument cosets te Der ogee *
r permanent tun ection, we now in request
that the pita pees ae me the ~~ - of the
permanent tunnel protection, t r wi neces-
and obvious corrective eaiees inci thereto,
~~ neg some expense. ‘ , I
y we have the courtesy of 2 prompt reply granti
‘to us the above-requested y Ghorleation’ F “s..
21. The letter of transmittal to Colonel Seybold ofthe
copy referred to above, bearing the same date, is quoted
below : ¢€
We are enclosing for your consideration land record
4 copy of a letter which we have today addressed to Mr.
D. E. Mather, Resident Engineer. subject matter
involved is of vital importance to the orderly progres-
sion of this project. It is not our desire to engage in
controversies with the Government, but we feel very
strongly that the conditions now existing could have
been avoided had we been granted the eqtherity we
requested. ‘ Ps.
22. On May 5, 1947, Colonel Seybold sent the following
letter to the plaintiff by registered mail : _-f
of even date addressed to my Resident Engineer re-
qaditional p protection i the tunnbl.
permanent in the t
I have caused an examination to be made of the
contract documents and the circumstances and events
that have preceded your request and I have found as
a. Contract drawing sheet No. 7 shows foundation
exploration data that indicates the type character
of the material that would be encoun during the
tunnel driving and lining operation. -
b. Paragraph SC-7a of the a a <
parties interested in this project that ples of the
materials removed from the foundation ex i
holes were available for } ion at the U.S. ineer
Soils Laboratory af Ithaca, New York.
c. ee tna of the specifications annotated
for the i ion of prospective bid:!ers, certain items
a
36°
- of consequence with respect to site and job conditions.
Your acteptance of the contract indicates that you have
~ satisfied yourself as to these conditions including sub-
surface conditions. o : eee >
, Contract drawing sheet No. 24 clearly indicates:
tunnel. protection 50 feet back from the face of each
. poptalofthetunnel © 7° a,
_ Paragraphs TP 4-03 (a) and\ (c) of the specifica-
the ‘also describes and indicates the limits of. tunnel
'" protection “as required for distances of eaeney .
‘feet-at. each end of the tunnel.” This limitation to
_ hold unless directed otherwise. ee io oe,
- © £, Paragraph TP 4-02 of the specifications contains ©
‘ @ statement that “temporary tunnel protection shall be
provided. where required for safety of the workman.” .
Under the terms of the contractual requirements cited -
above, 1 consider that the Government clearly and in.a
very exact manner indicated the extent to which the
Government would require and assume payment for
rmanent tunnel lining. I also consider that sufficient
Sats was available for you to make a proper considera-
tion of the tunnel-pretection which would be necessary ‘
. fot you to install in order to provide adequate protec:
_ tion against damage to completed work as well as the
safety of your workmen.. — ie SO ee gs
' A review of the records of my Resident Engineer ~
- indicates that he consulted with your representative —
prior. to the commencement of the tunnel work and
advised you fully and correctly as to the extent of both
. the Government’s responsibility and your responsibilit
oo tunnel lining beyond the limits required aad:
i for payment. at cat
“ ee indicates that you were peri- ~. >
odically aware of the gradual deterioration of the rock
in the tunnel which did not commence until the.tunnel
was.completely holed out, yet _ apparently took ne~ ,
.action to protect either yourself or the interest of the
Government. - : " ae ee
-It is my decision, in view of the above finding, that no
further tunnel ee will be placed. at the expense. of
.._ athe ‘Government. Furthermore, my Resident Forces
will be instructed to = that sdecuate precautions .
__be taken to insure the safety of all personnel when your
. tunnel operations are ‘resumed. ' a AS
an Ss to ‘appeal my decision in the matter, you
7s vised of your rights of appeal within 30 days from ~
date of receipt of this letter as provided under the terms
. of Article 15 ofthe contract. ‘i hie ;
37
23. The plaintiff. on May 29, 1947; filed + a timely appeal
from the contracting officer’s. decision. ”
24. On May 26, 1947, following a cinleneies at Baltimore
ee with Colonel Seybold and his staff, the plaintiff wtote the
following letter to tl.e contracting officer:
Reference i is made to the letter which we addressed to
your Resident Engineer on April 23, 1947, and to your
reply dated May 5, 1947 (File +NABVK). p
On the oceasion of our recent conference with you
-and members:-of your staff at Baltimore on May 12, we |
pointed out the importance of proceeding with the in-
. stallation of the tunnel lining, and therefore requested
that the Contracting Gfficer give us an- indication of the.
type and character-of permanent tunnel protection so
that we could place orders for the materials.- In re-
mse to our request the Contracting Officer directed
t at we submit for approval a description of the tunnel
. protection which we would recor
After careful eonsideration, and consultation with
Cabot Construction Corporation, our subcontractor on
~ the tunnel-work, and with our Consulting Engineer, Mr.
Miles N. Clair, Vi ice President, The Thom yo & Licht-
ner &.Co., Inc., Boston, Mass., ‘and with: F: J. Cran-
\dell of Liberty ’ Mutual Insurance Company, Boston, we
are of the opinion that the minimum permanent tunnel
protection which we believe will-meet the requirements
of the situation - adequ uately, and for which we request
the approval of.the Contracting Officer is the use of the ~
same ribs and liner plates as were used in the installation
at the portals, for the entire length of the. tunnel. ;
Due to the fact that this is a situation requiring im-
mediate attention and decision on the part of all con-
cerned, we earhestly suggest that you give the subject
your immediate attention and’ inform us »romptly:
whether or :.0t the above proposed type of tunnel pro-
tection is approved.
In taking these steps to assure progress of the work
‘in the interest of the government, we do not. waive any
- Frights related to the appeal we are taking to the ruling
’ contained in your letter of May [5], 1947. :
25. On June 13, 1947, the contracting: officer sent the plain-
tiff the following letter: -
Reference is made to your letter dated 26 May 1947
wherein you submit a proposal for the safe protection
of your workmen in the tunnel. at Almond — under
years ontract No, W-30- 1s0-<ng- -397.
<°:
Your request refers to “Permanent Tunnel Protec- _
tion”. You are advised that no permanent tunnel protec- ‘
tion will be required to be installed in Almond Dam —
Tunnel in addition to that, protection already installed. —
and psid for under. contract payment items numbers
11 and 12. Also, you are advised that “Permanent Tun-
~ nel Protection” required under this contract is at the
tals only .and is protection designed to withstand
earth pressures.‘ =~ * . ~ .
Temporary tunnel protection as required under the .
provisions of paragraph TP4-02 of the contract specifi-
_. cations is temporary in that its only function is to sup-
' port a ne load and prevent injury to your
workmen. | greatest load to which it will be sub--
jected will be the dead load of the back packed materials.
In paragraph 3 of your letter, you state that you are —
of the opinion that the minimum permanent tunnel
’ protection that will meet the requirements of the situ--
ation adequately and for which you request approval are
' the same ribs and liner plates used at the portals. If
you desire to. use this design of tunnel protection
‘ throughout the tunnel, length, its us& is approved. You-
”. are - or pcigprggata pon this type of installation fe
considered as an over design for the purpose requl
and will be a more costly installation to you thah is
considered necessary. ; ei ee 5
It is suggested and recommended to you that adequate
‘temporary protection may be obtained by using I
‘ribs of about 3 inches 6 pound weight spaced 4 to 8.
feet apart (depending on the overbreak). with 2’’ timber -
lagging. The void area in the arch would then be uni-
formly packed with shale or bank run gravel in a man-
- ner to insure-a uniform load distribution. Protection of
. this kind will be adequate to support the ialling rock
_ Toad ‘as well as the material used in back packing. Fav-
orable consideration will be given to & proposal of
comparable design. : ales ,
"It might be cailed to your attention that a scheme
.. similar to the above was proposed to my Resident Engi-
neer. by a representative of your subcontractot, the Cabot
Construction Company, at the time tunnel excavation
was commenced. . —_ ae
It is to be understood that the contents of this letter
are not to be construed as a reversal of my decision to.
you, dated 5 May 1947 to the effect that no payment ~
would be made by the Government for the additional -
tunnel protection required to complete work under your
contract. : 4
; er
26. In the’ meantime, the plaintiff had requested advice
from F. J. Crandall, Assistant Vice President of the Liberty
Mutual Insurance Company, and Chief — of its Loss
' Prevention Department. This firm was the plaintiff’s car-
reo to workmen's compensation, liability and property
damage insurance. Mr. Crandell was an engineer of pver
30 years’ experience whose specialty. was roof control in
‘tunnel work. Crandell inspected the tunnel on April 14,’
‘1947 for the purpose of determining the safety of. the roof
condition in the Almond Tunnel and whether or not the
conditions required the timbering of the roof section. He
entered the tunnel from each end and observed the condi-
tions existing for a distance of 200 feet from each end. He
did not see the center 300 feet of the tunnel. On April 18,
1947 he sent an eight page report of his findings and con-
clusions ‘to the plaintiff. The letter of transmittal is quoted
below :
Attached you will find'my report regarding the roof
conditions in the Diversion Tutiiel of the Almond Dam.
In addition to the conclusions drawn from this investi-
agation that are incorpurated in the report, I wish to
mention at this time that the installation of the braces,
in the Diversion Tunnel, that will be necessary will, no
doubt, be a dangerous operation. ° Pe ae
The length of time that the tunnel has been. unsup-
- ported has brought the roof into a tréacherous condition,
_ and therefore I believe it advisable to study in detail
the method that you intend to follow in installing the ~
supports.in the tunnel. An actus! recording of the step
by step procedure that will be necessary, would allow
beth yeur organization’ and ours to study the operation
in an endeavor to pre-determine the accident causes that
will exist and therefore be able to determine what should
be done for the protection of the workmen during this
operation. — . oy ee ee.
We would deem it-an opportunity to os with your |
operating persgnnel in the laying out am analyzing of :
their design methods for the installation of the braces -
in order to As the greatest safety for:this dangerous -
phase of the operation. . ee
-.-Crandell found upon his*inspection. and examination that .
the type of rock encountered in the excavation was pri- °
marily shale which showed very thin horizontal bedding
layers with fractures at an angle to the bedding planes.
: 40 ,
The interior which he examined showed “bedding planes of
9- to &inch thickness, while at the portals they were micro-
size. He also found-that.there had been numerous
- failures)of the roof of the tunnel and that the floor of the
t where he had made his observations) was covered
wit} fallen rock for a depth of 2 to 5 feet. Crandell’s con-
clysions in his report.to the plaintiff are quoted below :
Conclusion: | ; eit
‘ It is my opinion that the roof of this diversion tunnel
is so unstable that if left to itself failure will continue
to occur and | voids will eventually show themselves
in the roof of the tunnel. These vada, in all probabil-—
ity will take the shape of a agen. whose base will’ be
. the width of the existing bore and the two legs will be
at an angle of approximately 80° with the horizontal.
- Because of the low modulus of elasticity being ap-
proximately three million pounds per square inch, this
material will deflect ten times as much as steel will, and
in the process of this continuous deflection, microscopic .
fractures will occur that decreases the strength of the
shape. - °
This tunnel ‘is extremely unsafe and no further oper-
cions should be performed unless the roof is supported
from portal to portal. ,
The strength of the shale in these thin bedded areas |
probably averages between two and four hundred
pounds per square inch in tension, and the suppor:s
therefore should be approximately four feet center to
ceiter. es ,
_A large amount of scaling is necessary at the intake
portal to insure the safety of further operations. All
fault sections and frost heave areas should be barred
down: and continual scaling be performed throughout
*. the operation. .
. The portal supports on the intake section of the tun-
nel should be extended at least ten feet outside of the
_ tunnel in ordet to afford protection against falling rock
_ »* from the hillside.
During the winter months, due to the low tempera-
tures, this shale contracted. As the témperatures of
spring and summertime increase, there will be a large
amount of expansion in the rock. This expansion will
throw-stress into the rock that will produce small frac-
_-tures and will continually weaken the ‘structure.. Be-
cause of this expansion medium in the rock, we can look
for greater falls than have already ovcurred, if the con-
dition is allowed to continue without supports.
\
41
In order to assure no tremendous dome failures. it ‘is
important that the rock in this tunnel be supported as
soon as possible and thus stop the movement of the rock
that is now continuing. © : -
27. Other letters were exchanged betweeri the parties, and
on July 25 the plaintiff wrote stating that it had considered
the design of tunnel protection recommended by the con-
tracting officer, and called temporary protection by him, and
that it had been advised by its consultants, and the Liberty
Mutual Insurance Company, that the design was inadequate.
The plaintiff then procecded to outline.a design of steel
tunnel protection with which it felt that it could safely pro-
ceed, being 4-ineh steel ribs, 13 pounds per foot, spaced 4
feet ‘apart, with 14-inch liner-.plates above the ribs. Ap-
proval of this design was therein requested. ©
28. On August 11, 1947, the acting Aistrict engineer sent :
the following letter to the plaintiff:
Reference is made to your letters dated 25 July 1947
and 1 August 1947 relative to-the temporary tunnel
»rotection Which you propose to install under your
Jontract Number W-30-180-eng-397 which provides
for the construction of Almond Dam at Almond Dam,
New York. - | :o /
By letter dated 5._May 1947 you were furnished ‘a
decision by Colonel J. S. Seybold, then District Engi- |
neer, to the effgct that the tunnel protection remaining
under your contract would consist of temporary protec-
tion placed in accordance with paragraph TP 4-02 of
the contract specifications as a safety precaution for
the workmen at no additional cost to the Government.
You have cto ag this decision of the District Engi-
neer ih accorda
- sequent to your appeal you had offered for approval
a proposed plan of protection, the merits and neces:ity
- for which were clearly discussed in a letter to you from
the District Engineer dated 13 June 1947. .
~ Your letter dated 25- July 1947 outlines again the
' plan of protection which you are electing to use. You
also express your views with respect to probable dif-
ferences in cost between your proposed plan and the
scheme suggested by this office as adequate. Your letter
“cites the interests of the Government .in the matter as
an extra and infers a‘ liability for costs-on the part of
the Government. It becomes necessary; therefore, to
advise you that the decision of the District Engineer
and your subsequent appeal will-be reviewed and a. final
~
ance with the terms of the contract. Sub-.
°
42
decision rendered by higher authority as soon as an
orderty processing of your appeal can be accomplished.
In the meantime, severe inexcusable delays to the work
are resulting from your failure to proceed and it is not
beligved that your interests will be furthered by con-
tinuing correspondence on the matter. , .
_ The Government position has been made clear in the
‘previous correspondence and is summarized briefly
ollows: : t Be
a. In accordance with paragraph TP 4-02 of the con-
tract specifications “temporary tunnel protection shal
- be provided whéfe required for safety of the workmen”.
~. The installation of this temporary protection is not
structurally necessary to insure the safety of the com-
tunnel structure and need be only to
‘support a fallihg stone load and backfilled. material in.
the tunnel overbreak area. The design suggested b
this office is considered adequate for that purpose
will be approved for use if you wish to reconsider our
plan. However. since’the safety of your workmen is
your responsibility you must, of course, provide a pro-
‘tection which Bes consider adequate for their safety,
therefore, nu objection will be made to the protection
plan which you propose to use. Under the terms of
the contract all costs will be accrued to you unless found
otherwise by higher authority.
29. The plaintiff, on August 15, advised the contracting
officer, via the resident engi: <r, that its consultants had -
recommended to it that the problem of tunnel protection
should. be referred to eminent and nationally known
- guthority for special study and that this had been done,
and that such authority had concurred in plaintiff's view
that the district engineer’s mmendation concerning such
tunnel protection was inadequate.
30. Mr. Miles N. Clair, a consulting civil engineer with
wide experience in tunnel work examined the Almond .Tun-
nel on May 1, 1947. His examination covered the entire
tunnel from the inlet portal to the outlet porta] downstream.
- He observed dripping water from the numerous silt or clay
joints in the tunne! roof, substantial-rockfalls on the floor
of the tunnel and that the roof was flat in the areas where
rock had fallen leaving triangular shiaped areas 3 or 4° feet
deep. It was his opinion that these flat roof sections were
potential locations for additional falls und that the roof
ho
43
was very unstable. He found that this condition existed
on May 1, 1947, also on August 7, 1947, when he again
examined the tunnel. If[é recommended to the plaintiff that
it shoulu not proceed with the. concrete lining of, the tunnel
unless supports were installed equal in supporting value to
the permanent tunnel protection alréady installed at the.
inlet and outlet portals. Mr. Clair advised the plaintiff
‘that the proposed protection suggested by the contracting
Officer in his letter of June 13, 1947 was not ‘suffie ‘ient and
would be inadequate.
31. Mr. Teslie F. Worse, a senior mine and tunnel inspec-
‘tor in the Division of Industrial Safety Service, Bureau of
Mines, Tunnels, Quarries and Explosives for the State Labor
Department, New York State, inspeeted the Almond Dam -
Tunnel on April 23, 1947. He was accompanied on his -in-
spection by Elferd H. Richardson,-Chief Engineer for the
plaintiff and an engineer from the resident er.gineer’s office.
The state inspector examined the tunnel from both ends
. but due to falling rock was not able to go completely.through
‘ the tupnel. - His reasor for not going all the way through
the tunnel was due to the danger from the root falling. As
_ & result of his inspection, he informed the resident engineer
that he was going to issue a State Orde: which would pro-
hibit anyone from entering the tunnel ex(ept those who would
erect supports to make the tunnel safe’ The resident engi-
neer stated to the state inspector that to put steel protection
in the tunnel would cost- $50,000 and if he authorized this
installation he might end up in Leavenworth. The state
inspector recominended the installation of steel ribs and
wooden lagging or steel linerplates and. stated that such
instaHation would be permanent tunnel protection because it
could not be removed before ne and would be
embedded inthe concrete.
The State Order was directed to the plaintiff on “May 5,
lvé7end reags-a3s follows:
Apri 30, 1947.
You are one jreeted to coraply with the following
uirements of Chap. 50, Laws of 1921, as ainended. |
unnel located Almond Dam Project—8 miles of
Hornell,: Water diversion Tunnel,-County Steuben of
which a are the constructor :
44
1. Immediately erect and maintain omnes timber
or.steel to control roof and rib falls of rock in tunnel.
: Code Rule 1372—Bulletip 25.
2. Permit no one in the tunnel until this timbering
has been done, except men —— in erection of same.
RECOMMENDATION: ] ribs supporting either
2’ I{aleging or ste! plates.
The‘above suquicensente must be complied with IM-
MEDIATELY, unless otherwise specified herein. Ad-
dreas communications .to Bureau of Mines, Tunnels,
<a and Explosives, State Office Building, Albany,
InpustaiAL ComMISSIONER /
: , May 5, 1947
$2. Subsequent to June 23, 1947, the plaintiff engaged an
eminent consulting mining engineer, former Chairman of the
Mining Methols Committee of the American Institute of
- . Mining and Metallurgical Engineers, Mr. J. Murray Riddell,
- to inspect and study the Almond Tunnel and to determine
the nature of protection required before concreting. Mr.
Riddell had extensive experience as a mining engineer in con-
nection with underground operations, particularly in rock
structure tunnels, and is Professor of the Bepartment of
Mining, College of Mining and Technology, Houghton,
Michigan. He examined the Almond Tunnel. His findings
were as follows: The rock in the tunnel consisted primarily
of shale with s very limited ‘amount of thin bedded sand-
stone. The structure was very nearly horizontal and bedly
weathered. The mass was fractured by the joint pianes.
‘There was some fracturing along the bedding planes hori-
zontally. The joint planes, which were irregular in many
_ instances, were filled with seams of mud or mud coating.
Their angle of intersection one to the other varied bet-veen
60° and 90°. Water was dripping from the top of the tun-
nel in a great number of places. The sides of the tunnel
were what he termed as weakened. There was evidence of
rock failures from the roof. There was no adhesion in the
fractures of the rock d€her than the mud or coating of mud,
and this was very poor. There was also water seepage in —
- the fractures from the roof structure and on.the sides of the
_ tunnel. Throughout the tunnel there had been failure of
the roof, the amount of rockfall varying in different places.
- He found that the roof of the tunnel in mining terms would
45
be classified as a rotten top and that throughout the tunnel
the roof was in an unstable condition. Mr. Riddeli was of
the opinion that the Almond Tunnel required permanent
tunnel protection before goncreting and recommended that .
the entire tur ael be-lined with steel sets.
33. Plainti.t proceeded to install the steel ribs and liner
plates throughout the tunnel and completed such stalla-
tion between mid-August and mid-October, 1:N7, following
' which plaintiff proceeded to complete the installation of the
D>
» backpacking above the linerplates, and the cleanup of the
fioor of the tunnel in preparation for the concrete work.
Following the installation of the ribs and liner plates and
the backpacking, it was necessary to do a completely new
job of cleaning out the invert of the tunnel. After the
. cleanup of the tunnel in March 147, sultequent roc k falls
‘occurred and the work of the machinery such as crawler
tractors and trucks and other types of equipment going back
and forth throngh the tunnel and the spillage of material
used in backpacking, caused the flapr of the tunnel to dis-
integrate to a certain extent. All of such loose material had
to be remnoved and the invert washed down before the con-
crete could be placed. Plaintiff, knowing that it would be
necessary to concrete during the winter months, was re-
quired to anf did prepare its concrete batching plant for
winter work which required completely enclosing the plants,
putting in a couple of steam boilers, piping, making installa-
tions to protect the materials before they were incorporated .
in the concrete, and also making provision to protect the
areas after the concrete had been poured. The work de-
scribed was done between mid-October and December 15.
.. Plaintiff commenced the concreting of the Almond Tunnel
on December 15, 1947, arfd 1 completed it on May 8, 1948.
34. The formation and-+nature of the rock ~tructure of the
Almond Dam Tunnel, the logs of the borings and the draw-
ings, were studied and investigated by numerous witnesses
appearing voth for the plaintiff and the defendant. They
included geologists, consulting engineers and engineering |
representatives of both plaintiff and defendant. From the
testimony of these witnesses it is apparent that.vertical in-
tersecting fractures containing mud or clay seams were
_ found throughout the tunnel.
46 . :
35. The vertical intersecting fractures containing clay or
mud seams were the basic cause of the rockfalls throughout
the tunnel. The vertical intersecting fractures divided the
rock into vertical columns. : The bedding planes were planes
of weakness, not open fractures, dividing the rock into blocks
or slabs. Mud was washed down trom above in many of the
joint cracks. When the tunnel was holed through the sup-
port of the columns of rock was removed and they were
supported only by friction along the fractures, and as a
result many blocks and slabs fell immediately after the
tunnel excavation was completed. The weather reports for
the area of the tunnel clearly show that precipitation for the
months of March and April 1947 was very substantial, the
total precipitation for April being 5.5 inches. This resulted
\
in the ground being saturated and the mud in the fractures —
_ being saturated and with water seepage working through
the fractures acting as a lubricant, washing the mud enn
out, caused many blocks of rock to fall.
The excavating of the tunnel took. place during the
winter months—December through March, and during this ,
period the ground above the tunnel was frozen and the
' water was frozen so that the cracks did not loosen up
through the mud seams. This accounted for the smallness of
the rockfalls during the excavation period. The bad falls ©
took place in the spring. These falls indicated that the
tunnel roof was not stable.
36. Another indication of the instability of the Almond
Tunnel was its change in excavated shape during the period
from the holing through on March 12, 1947, to the time
the plaintiff installed steel ribs and liner plates. The rock-
falls during this period changed the tunnel shape on. the
roof, haunches and invert. These changes are apparent from
the cross sections of the tunnel taken by the plaintiff's engi-
neers shortly after the holing through and at later dates
before the installation of steel ribs and liner plates, thus af- .
_ fording a comparison of the rockfall over a period from the
_ spring of 1947 until the fal] of 1947. These cross sections
', taken at 10-foot intervals of the tunnel consisting of 18
sheets were examined by the plaintiff's witnesses and by -
the defendant’s resident eng:neer.
47
The evidence establishes that, as indicated in plaintiff's
exhibit 52, there were many places of flat roof where large
slabs of rock had fallen out and that these large blocks of
rock having fallen out left an irregular roof with much over-
breakage beyond the intended line,-and that this condition
existed practically throughout the tunnel. These conditions
“indicated that the roof was unstable between stations 21+ 00
and 27+ 10.
The resident engineer’from his examination of plaintiff’s
exhibit 52 admitted that the Almond Tunnel had changed
its shape from the time of excavation to October 1947. The
assistant resident engineer of the defendant admitted from
his examination of plaintiff’s exhibit 52 that there was a
change in the invert shape at various stations and that at
certain stations the rockfalls were substantial, ay in
a change in the perimeter of the tunnel.
37. Another inuication ofthe instability of the roof struc-
ture was the fact that it would not corbel and arch well.
~ ~Nornrally in a shale formation a rockfall from the roof would
have a natural tendency to corbel itself and form an arch.
_ This did not occur however, in the Almond Tunnel where
rock fell leaving a flat roof, thus indicating that it would not
corbel and arch well. The flat roof sections were potential
locations for additional falls.
38. The specifications and the logs of the borings indicate
that for the first 50 feet in from the portals it would be ex-
pected that weathered rock would be found. Beyond that
distance the logs of the borings and the drawings containing
the descriptive legends indicate that unweathered rock would
’ be expected to be found in the tunnel interior. The plain-
tiff’s consulting engineer, Mr. J. Murray Riddell, had pre-
pared under his supervision. plaintiff's exhibit 116, based
upon his investigation and observation of the Almond Tun-
nel, including the drawings, logs of the borings and specifi-
‘ations. This exhibit is a drawing @f the tunnel profile
showing the various tunnel drill-holes and whether the rock
expected to be found in the area of each tunnel drill-hole was
weathered or unweathered based upon the designations in .
the logs of the borings contained in plaintiff's exhibit 4-B.
The distinction between weathered and unweathered shale
661298 O- 62-4
48
lies in the difference of the fractures and the presence or
non-presence of mud seams in the fractures. Weathered
rock has fractures and mud seams whereas unweathered rock
May have fractures but joint fractures would be a minor
exception and would not contain clay or mud seams.
The specifications prepared by the defendant's engineers
"were predicated upon the information contained on the draw.
ings including the drill hole legends of weathered and un-
weathered rock.’ From this irtformiation supplied the plain-
tiff the defendant represented that the plaintiff could expect
that rock of an unweathered nature would be found through.
out the tunnel beyond the 50 feet at the portals. Drill Holes
Nos. 13, 31, 32, 33, $7, and ‘59 indicated unweathered rock in
' thisarea. Such rock if unweathered as indicated in the drill
holes referred to would be structurally sound and would not
contain vertical intersecting fractures containing clay or
mud seams such as were found in this tunnel area.
~s The defendant's geologist testified that the logs «f the
cores shown in the drawings at Almond Tunnel were inserwd
to apprise the contractor as to the sub-surface conditions
and admitted that when the logs of the borings show weagh-
_ ered and unweatheréd rock a contractor should be reasonably
entitled to believe that the logs are correct and that un-
weathered rock would be found where shown.
39. It is clear from the evidence that the concreting oper-
ation in the tunnel could only be accomplished by supporting
in some manner the roof of the entire tunnel during the con-
creting tv insure that portions of the roof would not fall into
the wet concrete. This was admitted by the defendant's.
resident engineer and his assistant,
40. The defendant's witnesses drew a distinction between
_ temporary and permanent tunnel protection as to the ohjec-
.tive to be accomplished. They say that temporary protec-
tion is used to protect workmen and ii is still regarded by
them as temporary though it is embedded forever in concrete.
_ As to permanent protection, it is used only to preserve the
shape of the tunnel.
41. Prior to the performance of the work under the con-
tract: in suit, the defendant had had The Arkport Dam and
Diversion Tunnel constructed at « Tocation about four miles
from the Almond Tunnel. The rock in the tunnel at Arkport
49
contained more sandstone which is stronger than the shale
at the Almond Dam. The bore was 8 feet in diameter
(finished bore after ing). In the contract for the
construction of the A Dam and Diversion Tunnel,
the defendant specified that tunnel protection in the. form
of steel ribs and 2-inch wood lagging would be placed if in
the opinion of the contracting officer there was need for
such protection. The need at Arkport must have manifested
itself and the contracting officer so opined because such
_tunnel protection was installed throughout that tunnel. Mr.
_ Mather was the defendant's resident engineer for both the
Arkport and Almond jobs but despite the larger bore, ; corer
rock and shale at Almond, he withheld a recommendation
for the installation of steel supports for the center 610 feet
of the Almond Tunnel. |
42. Plaintiff prepared its bid on the basis that ‘the sub-
surface conditiens ir. ‘Ye Almond Tunne! after excavaticu
would be such that the roof-ef the tunnel would be suffi-
ciently stable ¢o permit plaintiff to-concrete-line the tunnel
without the necessity of first installing permanent tunnel
prvtection beyond the 50 feet at the portals. The flefendant
accepted the bid on that basis. The vertical intersecting
fractures containing clay or mud seams found in the tunnel
and the resulting rockfalls after the holing through of the
tunnel, making it impossible to concrete-line the tunnei
without first installing permanent tunnel protection throug!
out the tunnel, constituted unknown Conditions of an un-
_usual nature differing materially from those which plaintiff
“was justified in believing did exist and from those ordinarily
encountered.
43. The steel ribs installed by the plaintiff in tunnel
beyond the 50 feet at thé portals which had to ‘be left jn
place were embedded in the concrete within the neat line.
44. Plaintiff was ready to start the concrete lining of the
tunnel by May 1, 1947 in accordance with: its progress
schedule and had all necessary. plant and equipnient avail-
able either at the job site or within ready access to the job
site. The plaintiff did not have all of the equipment on the
job site because it was evident from the condition of the tun-
nel that it would be necessary to install permanent tunnel
protection so that plaintiff would not have been able to start
z enid i in his is letter: of transmittal :
ae
|
| siainttie by May 1... Plaintiff. reslized that it would. .
unable to start any concrete work ‘i in the-tunnel auntil: after
permanent tunnel protection had been- erected.‘ Plaintiff.
‘knew that effecting delivery of the supports after obtaining ©
approval for their installation and the work of; installing
them would take several] months. - |" ve
” The- resident -engineer admitted that-if the plaintiff had
had all of the concreting equipment on the job in April 1947,
the plaintiff could not have‘used it, because the plaintiff could
not concrete-line the tunnel without first — in’ pro-
"+. tection, which he termed temporary... - a
>. . 45, The acting district engineer, on Peweary. 10, 1948,
‘transmitted to the Chief of Engifieers, U. S. Army via the
Division Engineer, North‘ Atlantic Division at New York,the ~
contracti cer’s findings of fact, the contra¢tor’s appeal,
contractot’s comments, and his own comments, which con-_
tained a recommendation that the: contracting officer’s de-
* ‘cision be upheld an and thatthe claim for an\extra payment ‘
be denied. Following the above recommendati n, the acting
. . ° _@ 8 2.
“1 If the appeal is. sustained, ‘the con r would. .
be entitled to Pde from the ‘Appropriatio 1x3113
_ Flood Control, Genéral in the amount of approximately
_ $9,000.00, i. * if paid similar to payment’ under items
il nd 1 and would open the possibility for additional
claims for overbreak ahd contingent items throu
the. tunnel. This ‘is a continuing contract and
have nat been ah pees for payment of the instant
claim,
a | te a a or %
a oe
_ 4 On the Division Engineer by dendorsert \ |
ment to the mentioned in the preceding finding;
‘gent it on to the of Engineers concurring in the rec-.
- . ommendation of the District Engineer. . His endorsement ee
began “This appeal, involving approximately $9,000.00
¢¢°” That figure had been mentioned no where except in
the quoted portion of the preseding finding. ~ :, .*
47. The Corps of Engineers Claims and A peal Board on
Jus 1, 1948 held-s hearing on the Piet ‘peel. Wit.
~ nesses were heard on belt of the plaintift and the Govern-
"- ment. ©.
48. On: December 14, 1948, the plaintiff was wot ified of the
adverse: action by the Corps of Engineers Claims 3 and-Ap-.-
péal Board and. the Chief of Engineers upon. the plaintiff's —,
appeal. .
49: From all the evidanie: of record, it is foynd: that the 4 ;
failure and refusal of the resident engineer to recommend
and of the contracting officer to direct the installation of —
_ steel arch ribs and liner plates caused a disruption of the ~
sequentes of operations, as well as delay in the min
ance of the work by the plaintiff. It required that
'. ereting operations, . which the plaintiff could, and: would
bate performed in warm weather, be Secomplished i in whee
eather with resulting loss of efficiency, -
50.’ The finding as to the extent of such: delay is ime
for later determination.
“CONCLUSION oF LAW
Upon the. handing findings of fact, which are made a —
part of the judgmént herein, the court concludes as & matter. _
_ of law that plaintiff is entitled to recover and judgment will
determined a to Rule 38 (c).”
be entered to that effect. ales amount of — will-be re
3
«3
"APPENDIX B
gn the Gnited States Court of aims
No. 166-54 . : ww
(Decided May 9, oy a= y /
CARLO BLANCHE AND'COMPANY, INC. v. THE
UNITED STATES .
eneral William /]. decreas for defendant.
at’ INION : a
PeeeCourione: Hithe court's opinion of ass 14. 1959
(144 Ct: Ch S00). it was decided that the plaintiff was
1. Mattie en for plaintiff. Robert W. K noe vad |
Robert F. Bra gers briefs.
Gerson Bo Nrawer, with hom was cdxadatiant Attorney ;
entitled to dn equitable adjustment for the cost of installing ef - |
_ permanent supports in the tunnel, and the case was remanded
to the Trial. Commissioner pursnant to Ritle o8(e) to
determine the aniount. : 2
‘The Trial Commniss —_. now reported that Items 2
through 7. both inelus%? and Tten’ 16 were reasonably
_related to the cost of: inst: tling the tunnel supports and the
‘damages for the delay ine lout therefo and as a result of
the’ disruption to the bea liane eof. the contract work. The
court agrees. with: the Trial Cominissioner tliat the phan
is entitled to recover for such items, But the cotirt ts ‘of the
opinion thet the pkaiitiff rs calso entitled to reedyer its profit '
oon the cost of installing the’ peymianier: ried SApports and
the work ine ident thereto, whieli are Ttems £4: Yoand 16.
listed in finding 5 of the Conmngissioner’s reports 2.5
defendant, there Was jwéluded 15 percent protit before over
’
.
/ i.
: yi i Bg
ie ; + vA
a : ae
In the plameiths fet 1 which was. accepted by.
i
~
t
cas =
ae
- . _
° ~
=
« \
-
a3
head, taxes and insurance. Plaintuf is entitled to the same
profit on. these items. With the addition of this profit, so
computed, Items ; 3.45 and 16 amount to the following:
Tiein So ¢ Pitditigs Us) aes ; . EMS, 475. ai
Item 4 (Finding Sz). Teena FF
Item 5 + Finding 34)- pas Tae Bee
Item 16. (Finding 0) roe ners Sees Se |
The amount of recover v for Tye Min 2.6 and Tas fou. | Ios:
: the ‘Trial OlAMIssioner and ap proved by the court, is as
follows: . :
. 6
~ ~ Item 2 (Finding 26) > * a _ $8, 442 ON
™ Htemn 6 CF inding 261°, i ; ST IMM. ue
-- Item 7 ¢Pinding 38) . VAS T76 on
Items 2 to Toboth inelusrve. sind Prena a6 as thas amended,
amount to SPE616.56. which reece a Is entitled to,
-
. reeover.
P . Plaintiff ix. not “yahiiied to recover he additional items
elaimed in its amended petition filed March 9, 1959, for the
“reason that the additional’ items claimed therein have no —
relation to the cost_of the-imstalation of the permanent.
ing on the-items allowed abave by. reason of the exechtion
by. the court in its opinion filed on January 141959,
. Judgment willbe enteréd for plaintiff and agair-t the
e defendant in the sume ¢ f SIAL T36.
. Itisso ordered, . loft
as ° - 4 if
vs * PENDING, . ol I} ONMPT ebay ' ' ,
a 3 . ‘ Pe
a 5
! eet “The Cormurt, having = steered Age evic Mehrees the re poet of
Trial ‘Commissioner William Bo Quay. aud the briefs and’
argument of-counsel, makes et Of fact as, follows:
nto between it and the United State. through the Army
Engineer Corps asa flood conte! project. The phuntiff was.
paid about three and one. ‘ alf million dollars for the work,
cis sustaining, i net les~ of S27 000,
were
additional work: done and reisibursement for the increased
e. cysts Occ rasioned by Covermment delves and other: increased |
wide
4
tunnel supports: nos the plyintitl forec led from. na .
of the release, his nietter having heen heretofore determined
1. The plaintiff constructed an ‘earthen. dam and related |
works near Hornell.|New Vouk, persuaat te coutrset entered”
2. This action was nase to_recover “compensation for
Qos
P in
iy
‘costs * * *” due to the failure on the part of the defendant
to author'ze permanent tunnel supports and liner plates in
the tunnel which had been blasted through rock for a distance
ofTiifet. ©»: --
- §. The origingl petition claimed damages totaling $259,-
721.87. This total was made up of the following items
’ claimed : ae
Schedule of Plaintiff's Increased Costs
1. Cost of Removing Extra Overbreak During Original
TREE TE encncencosensccessccsssnnnbeoce . $1,082 7%
2. Cost of Removing Fallen Rock and Extra Rock to Io-
vert Subsequent to Completion of Tunnel Driving
ERTS EE Se eo PE a 9, Olin
3. Permanent Tunnel Supports Installed After March 25,
;, Sei Ra aeidiinnniaehs es.)
4. Backpacking Installation..__..........--.-----....-- 24, OT¥. 15
_5. Additional Concrete Placed__~_.--- sehen cibnicemern 11, 200. 00
tt. Heating Costs—Winter Concrete_____....._..._____- 45, 853. 08
7. Loss of Efficiency—Winter Concrete..........._____ 18, 560. 00
8. Excess Supervisory, Engineering and Administrative
Labo:—period 1-16-49 through 6-30-49____..._ _-_ 35, 250. 01
%. Cost of principal Items of Plant and. Equipment used
and Maintained on Contract after 1-16-49___._.____ 58, 118. 23
; : _ $283, 425. 75
(15% allowance for profit on itema 1-8, incl.)....... 26, 296.12
_ os e $250, 721. ST ’
4. The case proceeded to trial on the issue of liability.
On January 14, 1959, the court decided that the plaintiff was
entitled to recover, with the amount of recovery to be le-
‘termined pursuant to Rule 38{c). Finding 49 of the court
reads as.follows: 7 2
From all the evidence of record, it is found that the
_ failure and refusal of the resident engineer to recommend
and of the contracting officer to direct the installation
of steel arch ribs and liner plates caused a disruption of
the sequences of operations, as well as delay in the per-
formance of the work by thesplaintiff. It required that
concreting operations, which the. plaintiff cotild. and
would have performed in warm weather, be accomplished
in winter weather with resulting loss of efficiency.
5. On March 9, 1959, after leave granted by the court. the
plaintiff filed its second amendcd petition which increased
'
)
ee ee
’ a ' 55
the damages claimed to $680,066.01. This total was made up
of the Smoving! items :
Schedule of Plaintiff's Increased Costs
BY end cl BEA TOTS Pee
2. Gost of Removing Fallen Rock and Extra Rock in
Invert Subsequent to Completion of Tunnel Driv- —
Le an eee
8. Permanent Tunne! Supports Installed After March
:
é
5
EE Oe On me
4. Backpacking Installation__---_.-~_- Aiceminemenina .--- 29,392.12
5. Additional Concrete Phaced__-._...._--.-.----.---- 138, 607. 96
6. Heating Coste—Winter Concrete____.._...-.-.-----. 87, 189. 29
7. Loss of Efficiency—Wintér Concrete_-____..._.--._- 15, 776. 00
& Bxgtes Supervisory, Engineering and Administratiye .
Labor—period 1-16-49 through 6-30-49____.__--- 82, 367. 87
9. Cost of Principal Items of Piant and Equipment used
and Maintained on Contract after 1-16-49_..... © 49,400.51
10. Stockpiling of Impervious Material From Spillway
Excavation, and Later Re-excavating and Placing .
_ same in the Closure Section of the Dam Embank- sail
GEE ncannanesncndes atcnnmessnnsscadcnseusnsctioe 8. 261. 80
11. Excess Costs of odbintaising and Operating Earth
Handling Equipment in Construction of Dam Em-
ee
12. Excess Costs of Supervisory and Engineering Per-
sonnel Employed in Construction of ead Embank- ve
“GANGES crnnncleccqccccctocedacceccencesssecscosee 21, 1N6. 13
18. Salary of Assistant | Sassstatendans in Charge of Con-
crete and Structures May 1, 19480 August 7, 1947 .
(during which period no concrete was poured) Plus
Loes-of his Efficiency During the Period August Ze .
1947 to October 14, 1947_----------------------- 8, 116, 57
14 Cost of Maintaining Equipment for Concrete Opera-
‘tions, Idle from May 1, 1947 to August 7, 1947; also
Loss of Efficiency of such Equipment During the ;
’ Period from August 7, 1947 to October 14, 1947_--- _ 31 257. 03
15. Lose of Efficiency—Winter Rock Excavation for the
Spiliway December 5, 1947 through April 15,1948.. 14, 315. 89
’ 16 Engineering Consultant's Services re Type of Perma- ~~
nent Tunnel Protection Required Prior to Concrete
SAIOND deine patiiecccccetnceeesstapesseccocns um see
*
9600, 091. 55
(19% allowance for prodt on items 2-9 and 1-18
tuct ) : ------ 80,974.46
~——
6
pO a Tt NEE ON ©
ance thereof by the defendant, the 37th and final estimate -
was prepared by employees of the Corps of Engineers for
signature by the appropriate officer of the plainuff. It
showed a balance due plaintiff of $12,236.56. This was re
turned, signed by an officer of the plaintiff, together with «
release executed on behalf of the plaintiff which provided
in pertinent part as follows: '
Now, therefore, In consideration of final B nn go
under such contract in the amount stipulated above, the
——- Contractor hereby re the United
States of Ameria, its officers and from any and
all claims and demands whatsoever arising under or by
virtue of said contract, except as follows:
The contractor ress its iow to pursue Satine,
through appropriate channels, the subject matter o
> the various claims erg! to the Corps of En-
Claims and Appeals Board and docketed be-
that Board as A No. 14. The contractor
reserves the right. to pursue its ‘claim for
ing out of the use or non-use of
w Area Ne. 3; and also its claim
reason of the Government's
the contract the Ripra
i for placement in thé Rail
a
a
i
Executed this 1ith day of February, 1950. .
Thereafter, on March 9, 1950, a check in the sum of $12,-
» 736.56 was issued by the defendant and paid to the plaintiff.
This included a $500 amount which had been withheld on an
earlier voucher. _ c
“ 7. On May S, i47, the contracting officer had sent to the
plaintiff by registered letter his decision as to the installatign
of tunnel supports in the 610 feet of the tunnel which pro-
vided in pertinent part as follows:
It is my decision, in view of the above findi that
no further tunnel lining will be placed at the pont of
the Government. Furthermore, my Resident Forces
will be instructed to ire that te precautions
be taken to insure the safety of al] personnel when your
tunnel operations are
If you wish to appeal my decision in the matter, you
_ ate vised of your rights of appeal within 30 days from
A
r 4
57
date of receipt-of this letter as provided under the terms
of Article 15 of the contract.
& The plaintiff on May 29, 1947 appealed this decision of
the contracting officer by addressing a registered letter to the
Secretary of War in the following terms:
In connection with the provisions of Article 15 of our
contract with the War Department for the construction _
of Almond Dam, we herewith appeal from the decision
of the District Engineer undér date of 5 May 1947,
wherein the District Engineer ruled that “no further —
tunnel lining will be placed at the expense of the Gov-
ernment”.
We respectfully request the opportunity to submit
evidence and a brief in support a our appeal at the ap-
_ppropriate time.
é ill you kindly acknowledge receipt of this-appeal !
9. The above appeal was yyy with the Corps of Engi-
neers Appeal Board as Eng. C&A Board No. 14. After
~ much documentary information was submitted and a hearing
requested, a hearing was held on June 17, 1948 by the Board
in Washington at which plaintiff was heard by counsel and
the testimony of its witnesses. In his opening statement to
the Board, Charles A. McCarron, plaintiff's attorney, stated
in pertinent part as follows:
For the purpose of the record, I am Charles A. Me-
Carron, counsel for ——. Perhaps a brief state-
ment, may it please the Board, of the positica of the
appellant may be helpful in following the evidence as
Wu propose to present it. In many respects there are no
substantial differences bet ween the Government and the
contracter on certain of the basic facts that will elop
in this case. Mr. Fox has clearly stated the position of
the appellant to this extent that the appellant has lined
this entire ‘unnel with ‘steel liner plates and appears
before this Board asking in equity and good conscience
that it- be reimbursed by the Giovernment for the in-
stallation of these steel liner plates which the contrac- .
tor felt were absolutely necessary in order to line this
tunnel and complete the tunnel job because of the
character of the rock that was encountered in the course
of boring this tunnel, rock which could not be deter-
mined by the information available on the contract
drawings and cores that, were taken by the Engineers
prior to award of this contryct/ * * *
58
- 10. Asmay be seen from the cost of performing the work
of constructing the Almond Dam, and its related works, it
was a large undertaking. It required excavation of material .
of various kinds or classes from either borrow areas or cuts
including rock and placement of such of the material as was -
suitable therefor into embankment. In round figures in ex-
cee of 2 million cabic yard&of material were excavated
(aome of which was unusable and therefore wasted or thrown |
" gside) and alout one million six hundred thousand cubi
yards of material were placed in embankment. .
11. The contract provides in part as follows: |
Azriciz 16. Payments to contractor.
. ° °° "" @ e . *
(d) Upon completion and acceptance of all work re-
=— hereunder, the ampunt die the Contractor under ~
is coptract will be paid upon the presentation of a
after the Contractor shall furnished the Govern-
ment with a release, if required, of all claims against the
Government arising under and by virtue of this contract,
‘ other than such claims, if any, as may be specifically
excepted. by the contractor from the operation of the
release in stated amounts to be set forth therein.
* * s *
‘12. The specifications provide in part as follows:
, » * 2 - + *
SW-2. Principal Features. The work to be per-
formed includes the following principal features:
: (1) Diversion and care of stream during construction.
(2) Construction of approximately 1 linear feet
of earth dam.
(3) Construction of outlet works, consisting of intake
structure and operating house, concrete-lined tunnel,
stilling basin, and approach and outlet channels.
(4) Construction of s:ddle type —e, consisting
of concrete ogee spillway weir, a concrete-lined apron,
and approach and outlet channels. to
(5 Constrection of steel service bridge.
tf Construction of railroad protection embankment.
7) Relocation of railroad except ballast and track
~~ (8) Relocation of highway including embankment,
temporar) grave] pe rail and guide
(9) Construction of gravel-surfaced access
properly executed and dul ified voucher therefor,
- 59
10) Construction of lighting and power system.
~ (11) Installation of materials and equipment fur-
nished by the Government. _
The above general outline of 9 features does —
not in.any way limit the responsibility of the Contractor -
to perform all work and furnish all plant, labor and
materials required by the specifications and the plans
and drawings referred to therein.
. o * ° s
GC-5. Progress Charts, and Requireménts for Sun-
| day, Holiday and Night Work. a. The Contractor shall .
within five days or within such time as determined by
the Contracting Officer, after date of. commencement
‘of work, prepare and submit to the Contracting Officer
for approval a practicable schedule, showing the order
in which the Contractor pony to carry on the work,
the. daté on which he will start the several] salient fea-
tures (including procurement of materials, plant and
equipment) and the contemplated dates for completing
the same. The schedule shall be in the form of a
progress chart of suitable scale to indicate appropri-
ately the percentage of work scheduled for completion |
at any time.. The Contractor shal] enter on the chart
the actual progress at the end of each week or at such
intervals as directed by the Contracting Officer, and shall
immediately deliver to the Contracting Officer three
copies thereof, :
. The Contractor shal] furnish sufficient forces, con-
struction plant and equipment, and shall work such
hours, inc re night shifts, overtime operations and ~
Sunday and holiday work, as may be necessary to insure
the prosecution of the work in accordance with the ap-
roved progress schedule. If, in the opinion of the
Sealenclin Officer, the Contractor falls behind the
progress schedule, the Contractor shall take such ste
as may be necessary to improve his progress and the
Contracting Officer may require him to increase the
number of sh: ‘ts, and/or overtime operations, days of
work and/or the amount of construction plant, all
without additional cost tothe Government. _ )
c. Failure of the Contractor to comply with the re-
quirenients of the Contracting Officer under this pro-
vision shal! be grounds for determination by the
Contracting officer that the Contractor is. not prose- _
cuting the work with such diligence as will insure
completion within the time ified. Upon such de-
termination the Contracting Officer may terminate the
Contractor’s right to proceed with the work, or any
o
60
enpatable rt thereof, in accordance with the Delays-
a rticle of the contract.
40-8. Protection of Material and Work. The Con-
tractor shall at all times protect and ergy ae all ma-
terials, supplies and uipment of every
may
(including 'P Be oy Pw be Mme fur-
shed or o ) end all work performed. Al! reason
able eae of the yom Officer to inclose or
a. protect such ll be complied with.
termined by fencting Officer, material,
; aieuee tuple and work performed are not ade-
quately protected by-the Contractor such ry may
be protected the Government and the cost thereof
may be charged to the Contractor or deducted from any
. popapents due to him.
Speci Conprrions
SC-1. Commencement, Prosecution and Completion.
a. The Contractor will be ired to commence work
‘ Ser rary oy Aer pal calendar ee cee after —
date of receipt by of notice to to
said work with faithfulness and cnet andl 6 cum
plete the-entire work ready for use not ot later than 90 900
‘ paper wooly after the date of receipt by him of notice
wre! i preeeee. The time stated for completion shall in-
~ —_ clean-up of the premises.
time for completion of the contract
vit be mses Gaeeemene time lost due to flood -
re poloetye Sy wteped pow ba met oy result of
the stream ve and overtopping upstream
cofferdam orovided it it is built snd mnabitelned as speci-
fied in "Seciion I ‘of these specifications. No extension
of time will be granted for completion of the closure
section of the dam embankment which shall be on,
os, leted du the season in which it is st
ab ragrapk TPS01d) No extension of fime will be
made tet of the protected area after the time
fixed pa completion of the contract plus any authorized
extensions thereof or where the of the work is
due to fault or negligence of the Contractor, as deter-
mirted by the Contracting Officer. Time extensions al-
ptr gnc. The phage oe wh a) w= when
lad aul dase eouiins the day when
watering and clean-up ve been suffi-
! clentiy com to permit ‘Toutes of work within
/
61
the protected areas: provided that the work of: un-
wateritg and clean-up has been prosecuted in as rapid
‘ aft diligent a manner as practicable. Any extension
of time granted,the Contractor due to flooding shall not
* . be a basis of a claim against the Government.
¢. In the event that the total amount actually due the
Contractor for work performed hereunder exceeds the -
total estimated amount due under the contract as set
forth in. Article 1 thereof, the time for completion will
* be extended in pperine that such exces bears to
the total estimated amount due under the contract.
Should the total payments hereunder be less than the
total estimated amount of the contract, the date of com-
pletion as specified in paragraph a above will not be
affected. ;
SC-2. Liquidated Damages. \n case of failure on the
part of the Contractor to complete the work a ithin the
time fixed in the contract or any extensions thereof, the
Contractor shall pay the Government as liquidated
(lamages the suin of $250 for each caleuwlar day of
delay until the work is completed or accepted.
7 . *
SC-7. Physipal Data.
. /«
¢. Transportation Facilities. (1) Highways. State
Highway No. 36 grosses the dam site and is to be relo-.
cated in part under this contract. For protection of
highway traffic ‘during construction, see paragraph,
TP1-0. ~~ __.
(2) pp tian 2 Railroad passes the dam
site and is to be relocated i part under this contract.
The Erie Railroad and the Pittsburgh, Shawmut and:
Northern Railroad serve Hornell, New York. The rril-
roads report sidings at Hornell for the accommodation
ximately 190 cars. The Contractor shall in-
. vestigate the availability of sidings both at the site of
the work and elsewhere and 1 make all
arrangements with the railroads for the delivery of ma-
terials and equipment: For the protection of railroad
. traffic during construction, see paragraph TP 1-04. |
. > . . .
SC-19. Protection of Existing Structures. U’tilities
and Work.. a. The Contractor shall protect all existing
structures, utilities and work of any kind against damage
or interruption of service. Damage or interruption of
service resulting from failure to do sw shall be repaired
or restored promptly by or at the expense of the Con-
tractor. tits
‘ : 62
sir and water lines existing on site at t poder
Commencement of work under the contract. ‘All neces-
er not less 30 days prior to the date —
val. Where possible, utilities will be~
removed well in advance of construction operations, If,
ce 0
of the 30-day required notice Feried,
ys in
relocated by their owners cause de
' the con work, an extension of time for completion
work will be granted equal to the extent
' of such delay
be 5 esis of asim. inst the Government.
SC-20. Damage
.. responsible for
all
\
satisfacti
to Work. The Contractor shall be
work until completion and final ac~
compensation for the repairs of that
t work for which there are Sotgutoble
ma
. a sta8 8 s
° . 2°
‘ ‘ 4,
that such extension shall not”
.
tracting Officer -
“the cause of
we
63 |
SC-23. Work Areas. a. The unds, cnmpentadi: 5
ights-of-way and other ri aedenuery in the opinion
of the ening Olas er for the work under. this con-
tract, including those needed for access roadd, borrow
its and my em will be furnished by the State of
ishing rights-of-way, eas ments, etc.,
but in case the furnishing of - yptee - way.
causes 4 in prosecution of the sated the Contrac-
‘against the Government. ;
+ @ ® . _— * ? ‘ =
+ SC-24. Unwaterjng Wor is. Unless otherwise
specifically authorized, all permanent structures shall be
constructed -“in the dry.”: For this purpose the Con-
"tractor shall provide such cofferdams, diversion channels, -
' drains (including drain tile and French drains), flumes
or other temporary structures, and such pumpsand other. .~
equipment as may be necessary for unwatering founda- .
tions and work areas not included within the scope of
care and diversion of stream as ified in Section 1 of
Part IV of these specifications. Such structures shall be
subject to the approval of the Contracting Officer, but
; sa will not relieve the Coritractor of re-
, — ity for the-adequacy of the work. Upon com- —
pl ion of the work all such temporary structure’ shall _—
_ be removed-from the site. Under ee
ch in-
_ > with concrete after serving the — for whi
. tended. . Separate payment wil] not be made for pump-
ing, iding and removing any tempo protective
' works and we speci ve, and plugging un-
derdrains, but the cost ‘thereof shall be included in the
contract unit prices for the various items of the perma-
_ Mentwork, = “ : SS |
ae e «£2 ie Lie a
SC-27. Cooperation With Other Agencies. While
Ss _ under ye aa is:in progress, Re metas rr of
. the permanent way pavi new highway bri
and the relocation oft sllvead track wake wil
‘carriéd on at the site by other agencies. All agencies
simultaneously on work at the site shall have
‘equal rights to the use of such work and access areas
- 961208 O- 63-5
-
/
“4 ay
‘ * ?
as may be necessary for the conduct bf their respective
Sond ‘The Cetra all od r
_~others working at the site: The Contracjor will not be
‘ments of the contract, it. will
' ment thereof will be made in accordance: with Art
‘Tequired to maintain the nent hi ypaving,the —
new highway bridge or. the railroad t work as such
maintenance
will be thé responsibility of other agennies. |
‘8 8001:
SC-28, Final Examination and To mapa
as practicable after the completion of the entire work or
de by the Contracting Officer at. the site of the work.
If such work is found to comply fully with.the require-
of the contract.
_ Section I. Diversion or Srream axv, Prorecrion oF
TRaFFIC
Ey TP1-01. General. Work under this section shall con-
sist of the care and diversion of the stream and the
protection of highway and railroad traffic. The Con-
tractor shall furnish all equi t, materials, and labor .
required to accomplish the above work, all as indicated
on the .drawi specified herein, or directed by the
Contracting Officer. : Rotel c
_TP1-02. Care and Diversion of Stream During Con-
struction. a. General. At all'times prior to permanent —
’ diversion through the tunnel! the Contractor shall main-
_tain an unobstructed channel 150 feet wide, at valley
floor elevation ,\between the end of the embankment slope . -
_ and the opposite abutment. He shall be responsible for
: hat provided for in —
the
t i . SC-1 will not be allowed
for delays resulting from failuré on the part of the Con-
tractor to provide the neeessary protection.
fety of the work, and additional time other than —
operat uct his operations‘ :
‘.g0 # not to unduly interfere with operations of .
"any divisible part thereof as may be designated in these |
- specifications, a thorough examination théreof will be
accepted, and ond a A |
. b. Onder of work. poe cap | and permanent diver-
sion and control of the stream shall be accomplished as
indicated on the drawings. T:
be. provided during construction of the outlet works.
All other temporary protective works and temporary
_ diversion shall be completed prior to diversion of high-
way traffic. Permanent diversion through the outlet
. works shall be made only upon -written. instructions
from the Contracting Officer (see subparagraph TP6-
0ld)- and when the following minimum items of work
have been completed. .
ry protection shall.
sacipgpnac “al
—_
* 65 . ‘ °
(1) Outlet works’ to elevation 1265, including the
tunnel, approacK and outlet channels-complete, Wnd all
- Tipraparound the intake strutture. ri
. (2) The railroad relocation and protection and high...
way relocation complete; the dam south of the existing
highway to elevation 1320, and remainder of the dam.
= ikment, except the closure section, to elevation
; (3 All other ertinent work that may be directed: by’ nig
., the Contractin cer. By the time the closure sectién -
has been completed to elevation 1300, the ‘spillway ap- .
proach channel: excavation shall be completed to eleva-
tion 1294 and the remainder of the Hiway excavation _
‘shall be completed... All concrete -in the spill
monoliths 4 to. 11 inclusive’ of the weir, shall-be com. ‘
pated by the time the closure ‘section of the damem-. -
bankment has -been ‘constructed to. elevation 7ee. 3)...
* Monoliths 4:to 11-inclusive of the weir shall not'be
constructed above elevation’ 1294 until the closure sec- - «
way, except
_tion of the embankment has been: constructed ‘to eleva- -
tion 1310. All other work shall be completed daring the ‘
season in which .the émbankment : closure section is
completed. oy ee
ce. Temporary Diversion. (1) Stream Channel. The
relocated channel for temporary diversion of the stream
shall be constructed to. the lines, grades, and cross sec-
tions ‘as shown on the drawings. Materials from this as
excavation shall be temporarily stock piled in the pro-
tection levee as specified in subparagraph of? below
and later removed and disposed of.as direct
(2) Temporary Protective Works. A temporary
4 peatection Given shall he constructed upstream from the
"main embankment as indicated on Sheet No. 16 of the
dra Final location and extent of this levee shall
. be submitted by the Contractor for approval of the Con-
—
Officer. The protection levee shall -be con-
f channel excavation materials and will.require
al compaction, The Contractor shall provide
no, s or shall
© protectign of the outlet works effective to eleva-
for
tion 1245 upstream and 1230-downstream. by, leaving. .
‘unexcavated such portions of the approach and outlet.
channels as will provide the’ necessary protection or
otherwise protect the outlet works. If access oe
are made in the protective works, the Contractor shall
_. have gf the site sufficient sandbags to close the openings. .
The tractor shall be fully responsible for the ade-
of the — works except as provided in
paragraph
C-20, and any damage resulting from :
|
E
|
*. \ elevation 1265 at location and to the lines and
Sheet No. 16 of the drawings. It shall be
consisting
and impervious materials as indicated on the
Prior to construction of the cofferdam, the
' construct a permanent blanket on the
the dam embankment, extending from the im-
‘ga > — ad
bn act AZi. o:.
67
pear yr Learns | of lights around and in front of the work,
and the erection and maintenance of adequate warning,
and direction signs, shall be as required by the ©
New York State Department of Public Works, Division
of Highways. |
a ee ’ - . *
_ TP1-04. Protection of Railroad Traffic. The Con- |
tractor shall notify the Contracting Officer not lessthan |
15 days in ‘advance of the date he desires to enter: rail-
‘road p y so that due notice may be given the {
owners. Upon approval by the Contracting Sificer, the /
Contractor shall proceed with the work and continue .
without interruption, completing it in the sho time
oye Work on and adjacent to railroad rty
hall be performed with extreme care and in such # man-
ner that there will be no interruption of rail traffic.
Contractor shall furnish necessary flagmen and
comply with all requirements of the railroad relative to .
his operations. In planning and prosecuting’ construc-
tion. operations on rail - property, the tractor
shall work in close cooperation with the railroad, and
— details of his proposed method of operation
for thé approval of the railroad. On all adjacent
to the railroad the Contractor will be ired to pro-
vide such temporary prectection as may be deemed
by the railroad. The Contractor shall make —
arrangements with the railroad to pay all necessary
costs of temporary protection incl such costs as
the expense of flagmen provided by the railroad.
‘ -s ;
1, clearing of stockpile and — —, maintain-
ry
clearing and grubbing operations may be prosecuted as
the materials are Salter anabuahed m bee the objec-
tionable materials are separated from the suitable —
Secricn VI. EmsaNxuxnt
rotection, the access road, the highwa
on and the leven at Borrow Area 3. . For dumped
oat and rock in downstream toe trench’ see Section’
x Classification of Materials. Pome re er"
r are classified according to t ocation, an
_ method of placing as follows: siti
69
Type Lovetion . Placing
Impervious Core section of dam
Tranaition.
te Station
115+-00, road .
and tem de
24’’ layers—uncompacted
of the dam, in the
= - levee at ‘Borrow Area
: 38 and in the railroad
relocation. -. 12’’ layers—compacted
Random Highway relocation.
' between approximate
Station 115400 and
¢ Station 133+00 and
upstream from Sta-
tion 146+00. 8’’ layers—compacted
Select — Shell section on the ;
Pervious reservoir side of.the < ;
dam and railroad pro-
tection below Station
136+-76, and highway
relocation between
' Stations 136+75 and
_. 1464-00. 12’’ layers—compacted
Pervious Downstream section
- of the dam and_rail-
read protection below |
Station 130+ 00. . 12’’ layers—compacted
Pervious. Central section of the
highway relocation
between Stations
136+75 and 146-400. ’* layers—compacted.
Work. ‘The line shall spread and
tes dy e materials required for the embankments
to the elevations, lines, rads and and cross sections indi-.
cated on the drawings or as established by the Contract- "
ing Officer.
ae Order of Work. The Contractor shall construct
the embankment in sections as indicated on the ph Tee
oa), as specified below - also subparagraph
at
tele
Hn
r o3° rH
sighs
: -
tA
Bans 1
ae
Huse i #4
i
HE
+3
altel
SEL
ine
a
TP6-02. Embankment Construction.
‘s + ° ‘ a .-.
c. Placing and Spreading of Materials. Embank-
oe F shall be deposited in areas of the embank-
ment as directed or approved by the Contracting Officer.
_ The excavation and embankment placing operations
shall be combined as directed by the Contracting Officer
so that the material when compacted will be blended
sufficiently to secure the best practicablé degree of com-
paction and stability.” In general, impervious fill ma-
terial will be used for the core trench, inspection trench,
and the central part of the embankment ing to more
pervious materia! on the outer slopes. e distribution
and gradation of materials shal] be such that the em-
bankment will be free from lenses, pockets, streaks, or
layers of material differing substantially in texture or
- gradation from the surroundin santeriols. When two
or more classes of materials are being placed in a section
of the embankment they shall be systematically spotted,
dumped, and bulldozed so that in any area of the section
there are approximately the correct proportions of the
required materials. After dumping the materials in
the embankment the various classifications of embank-
ment materials shal] be bulldozed or otherwise spread
in layers of the —— thickness specified in sub-
h TP6-015. During the dumping and spread-
ing operations the Contractor shall remove all
roots, sod, and other unsuitable materials as determined
by the Contracting Officer, and di of them in accord-
ance with subparagraph TP2-Ola. Stones having a
_ thickness greater than the permissible thickness of the
spread layer or a surface aren which would cause inter-
ference with the compaction of the embankment ms-
terial, if suitable for dumped riprap or rock in the
downstream toe trench shal! be pl in those sections
of the permanent work and if unsuitable for the above
uses, shall be broken up and scattered-in the embank-
ment to the satisfaction of the Contracting Officer or.
wasted as directed. No embankment material shall be
placed on or against frozen surfaces nor shal] frozen
materials be placed in the embankment. When specifi-
re directed by the Contracting Officer, the Contractor
shall stock pile frozen materials for later use in the
embankment... The use of shale will not be permitted
in any of the permanent en ee that em-
bankments for the highway relocation downstream from
approximate Station 115+00, the actess road, and the
temporary detour at each end of the highway reloca-
72
tion, shall be constructed predominately of shale and
other waste rock with a binder of spoil common ma-
terials. Nesting of rocks will not be permitted and the
amount of binder shal] be sufficient to fill all voids Le-
tween the rocks. In the said highway relocation and
access embankments, stones larger than 2 cubic feet
in-volume shall not project within 2 feet of the fine
__——~ grade and large stones shall not project within 6 inches
_ of the side slope lines.
_ @. Moisture Control. The embankment materials,
before rolling, shall have the proper water content
required for compaction as determined by the Con-
.» tracting Officer. The Contractor may be required to
wet the surface of the preceding compacted layer, the
dumped material before. _—. or the spread un-
compacted layer before rolling. Harrowing or mixing
the spread material may be required whenever neces-
_ sary, in the opinion of the Contracting Officer, to secure
a uniform moisture content. The moisture content shall
be so regulated as to obtain the amount essential] to re-
quired compaction. Should the material be too wet to
permit re compaction by rolling, the rolling and
work on all portions of the embankment thus affected
shall be delayed until the material has dried to the re-
quired consistency. If additional moisture is required,
it shal] be added by any means proposed by the Con-
tractor and approved by the Contracting r.
> oe s s >
_ 13. The Almond Dan, as constructed, is an earthen flood
control dam having three principal] features common to such
dams, (1) a main dam consisting of an embankment con-
structed of compacted earthen materials; (2) an outlet works
for control of the reservoir, and (3) a spillway constructed -
at an elevation lower than the dam, ‘o drain off excess water
in the event of flood conditions. :
The main dam is constructéd to elevaticn 1320 feét. Con-
nected to it and extending upstream on the right abutment '
is a supplemental] extension or “arm” for the protection of a
relocated railroad and a state highway formerly | located
within the dam site which/were contained, in part, in cut be-
low the top elevation of the dam. Paralleling the-axis of the
dam a core trench, the purpose of which was to prevent seep-
age of water under the embankment, was excavated to below
Im accordance with established engineering practice, when references are
made to “right” of “left” it is assumed that one is facing downstream.
-*
the dam foundation extending from abutment to abutment.
The core trench was filled with impervious material and
compacted to the elevation of the foundation. The embank-
“ment was then constructed on top of the core trench. Neces-
‘sarily, the core trench had to be completed before the place-
ment of materials to any extent. could proceed in the area.
- of the foundation immediately above the trench.
. The outlet works, constructed in the left abutment of the
dam, is composed of three principal features, (1) a concrete
‘ intake and operating house which contains the gates and
'. machinery for controlling the flow through the outlet works;
(2) a horseshoé-shaped concrete lined tunnel 710 feet in —
length, drilled through the rock of the left abutment; (3) a
downstream stilling basin from which the flow through the _
tunnel returns to the natural stream bed below the dam. At -
the time of permanent diversion of the creek during the
construction period a permanent approach channel was ex-
cavated in the reservoir area above the dam to. direct the
normal water flow into the outlet works.
The spillway was-excavated in open cut inte rock in a
saddle to the left of the outlet works, the intake thereto being
excavated in rock down to elevation 1,294 feet. Immediately
adjacent to and downstream of the intake is a concrete weir
constructed across the spillway at crest elevation 1,300 feet,
20 feet lower than the crest elevation of the dam. The only
purpose of the spillway is to serve as a “safety valve” to pro-
tect the dam from waghout | in the event of unusual flood
conditions. +
14. In the course of construction there were certain =
tures in the sequence of operations peculiar to Almond Dam
which are pertinent to the consideration of damages i in this
case:
(a) To construct the dam: embankment it was necessary to.
- relocate a branch line of the Erie Railroad passing along the
intended site of the right abutment of the dam. Under the
contract the plaintiff was required to excavate for and pre-
pare a new subgrade for the railroad by cutting back into
the right abutment. The actual work of track relocation was
performed under a separate agreement between the Govern-
ment and the railroad.
74
(b) New York State Highway No_ 36 passed through the
valley generally parallel to Creek and bisected
the location of the proposed dam approximately at its can-
ter. Under its contract plaintiff was required to relocate and
* oonstruct a new highway in the right abutment of the dam in
close proximity to the relocated railroad. The site of the
new highway relocation occupied, in part, the old bed of the
relocated railroad tracks. The fine] surfacing of the new
highway andthe construction of » new bridge scross
Canacadea Creek were performed under a separate agree-
ment between the United States and the State of New York
after plaintiff had completed its highway work. It was s
rement of plaintiff’a contract that traffic over, existing
Tetashie Sd bo aietadiad tntll ho gow blehotg canen
pleted and opened to traffic.
“A telegraph line along ‘the old railroad bed had to be
relocated .by others ‘slong the relocated railroad bed. A
telegraph line and an 8-inch gas main along old Highway
- 36 also had to be removed by others.
‘ 15. In accorddnce with the plans and specifications as set
forth in finding 12, the various portions of the dam relating
_ to the instant claim for damages were required to be Con-
structed \in the following order :
A new subgrade for the open someeed
Po fond — back in right oe
ralroad Sinultanvony wf the construction of the new
dam embankment south of existing
*Hi 5 ery wy hy to elevation 1320.
3) 1 » roadbed for the of State wa
No. 36, of which was located on the site of old
x igoeinl vgn ca i
Sirected Ehoresn ond —__
75
(7) The creek was then to be permanently diverted
dn gh the completed diversion tansiel at which
work could commence in the section of the dam.
(8) The t coff upstream of the closure
section of the dam was thén to be built up to elevation
(9) The ion itself was then to be built up
to elevation 1300."
| (10) Concurrently with the building up of the closure
channel
section to elevation 1300 the spillway a
was to be excavated down to jon 1294. The reason
iversion were set out-so as'to minimize the effect of possible
vy flood conditions occurring during construction and
t prevent destruction of the partially completed dam, with
the resultant risk to life and damage to property which
occur in areas downstream of the work. ss
ly, the required sequence of operations provided
insurance to the Government and to the contractor
from financial loss had a flood occurred during construction
which could top that much of the embankment constructed
to date and result in a washout of theentire dam. :
- "The outlet works was not designed to carry off the flow of
the stream, during periods of flood. High watets in the
Canacadea Creek watershed could be expected normally im
the spring and fall months. However, the hydrographs |
which are a part of the contract plans, show that peak flood —
conditions could be expected during other seasons of the year.
_ ‘The highest flood condition recorded was during the month
of July 1935 when the run-off was 22,000 cubic feet per sc:
ond. This was about four times as great a volume as oc-
\
! ' . ea oe. «
. : . |
— . ‘
e %}
4 6 eek tae
curred during any: ghee period of flooding d ring the sini
1925-1941. It was ‘to protect @ such an unhoped for
contingency that-a heavy flood might occur duri ng! the period
of construction which caused the Governmentengineers who __
designed the dam, and those who prepared the specifications,
to spell out, the phases of truction which. would be re-
quired before the stream ream could be diverted. In. periods when ,
there had been no heavy rains.in the upstream watersheds, the
' stream was very small but there were two or three instances -*
during construction when high water ‘interfered with the | :
work. It can ‘be seen then why it was so important that the
work Of the railroad relocation and highway relocation, and _ |
the embankment along them, plus placement of embankment |
of more than half of the main dam, were required before
the stream could be permanently diverted through the tunnel.
17. The: plaintiff's witnesses have) testified that if. the
plaintiff had not been delayed by t Government in con-~
nection with tunnel -supports, it could have diverted the
- stream through the funnel abou a year earlier that tt did
so and that it could have finished all re aining embankment
in the 1947. work season. This testimony is not convincing
. for-three reasons. First, this would have required a major |
‘ change in the specifications as to how muclr work should be
firfished before permanent stream diversion with the chance
of great damage to embairkinent operations in event of heavy:
flooding as the tungel whs only designed to carry a flow of
4,000 cubic feet per second! withthe water at an eleration of
1,265. feet. The finished.dam wasat 1,320 féet elevation with
_ the crest of the spillway having an-elevation of 1,300 feet.
Secondly, there was Statp Highway 36 crofsing the main
dam area about in the centet and it would hate been-neces-
‘sary to depart from the specification as to the moyement’
of highway traffic during construction. It is true that
this traffic was detoured around the work area from May
to September of ‘1948, but if the stream had been div
in 1947, it would have made this detour extend for a period
. of about a year and one half, instead of from May 1948 to _
i: ae ey -1948. In this connection very great concern was
dicated by the state and county road authorities because -
Highway 36 carried 5,000 vehicles over a 12-hour period
a
a
me, 1%
each day, 1,000 of which were trucks; and aoe vehicles,
Waring the detour, liad to pass over a railrdad grade cross-
ing. Thirdly, the volume of excay ation, and actual place-
ment of embankment, as indicated in the-plaintiff’s payment
- “estimates, clearly. shows that it would not: _ cma
all embankment in the 1947 work season.
~ H&_Althoughi it was important to the progress of the work
‘from an overall] standpoint to coordinate construction of
| the dam einbankment_and-the spillway excavation w ith eon-
struction of the outlet works, which included cgnstruction
of the diversion tunnel, so as not to delay diversion of the
stream, the progress of construction of the dam and spillway
‘could have proceeded to a considerable extent independently
of, and without interference by, eutlet works construction.
The outlet works were ‘physically ‘outside the area of dam
‘embankment and spillway operations. ‘Phe equipment used
in outlet works construction consisted of the-concrete plant -
and related items, whereas dam and spillw ay construction,
prior. to’ diversiorty- employ ed earth-moving and compacting :
equipment such as scrapers, shovels, trucks, sheepsfoot ral- |
ers, bulldozers, ete.
As hereinbefore shown, in accordance avith the plans. and 7
_- sperification’s, before stregm diversion could be accomplished,
the contryctor was required to be at a stage of construction,
--where the failroad hid been relocated, the highway, in part,
relocated on the site of'the old railroad bed and traffic di-
verted thereon, the embankment south of oid State Highway
36 built up to elevation 1320, and the embankment ‘north
thereof built up to elev ation 1300 up to the closure section.
The outlet works, t fore, need not have e sbeert ready for.
stream diversion unti] the aforementioneds steps, with re-
spect to the progress ‘of construction of the: main embank-
" ment, had been reached.
‘ Dam embankment construction on the” other hard was —
related to spillway‘excavation: in that all suitable- common
materials excavated in the spillway were required to be .
utilized for placement in the dam embankment.
19. At the commencement of the work, in August 1946,
plaintiff submitted a progress schedule of work operations
as required: by the contract. Pertinent omen of ar work
were scheduled fnrgen as follows:
' &
78
8—Stripping and common excavation: . — completion
a. Railroad subgrade____.\ icing May 381, 1947
c. Spillway ; nttieeninicnnnn ae ae
4—Rock eacavation: .
_a. Railroad subgrade____: eee --- June 30, 1947
_ © Spillway ; al a --. June 30, 1948
5—Tunnel: nee wie
_” ‘b. Concreting eihinniitbniaigiintininien ... Aug. 81, 1947
| 1—Embenkment, : .-..,Nov. 15, 1948
9—Conorete: As
b. Intake and Stilling Basin pues -.. Nov. 15, 1947 .
Highway No. 36 closed en ------- Apr. 30, 1948
- Permanent stream diversion — ileus Aug. 15, 1948
Job as a whole EE TTD “_.-.. Jan. 15, 1949
The ‘progress schedule made no reference to the time of
temporary stream divérsion provided for under the contract. .
At no time during construction did the plaintiff, by writing —
‘or otherwise, indicate to defendant’s agents that it intended
_ to divert the stream through the completed tunnel earlier
than August 15,1948. : , |
. 20 During ‘the course of construction several key delays —
' affected the time when the dam embankment’ was finally
.built up to the point where stream diversion was permitted
under the contract. 7 ee: .
The plaintiff was\ dilatory in completing the railroad
_ Felocation and subgrade which were scheduled for completion
on June 80, 1947. This was not substantially completed until
October 9;.1947, at which time, because of the possibility of .
freezing conditions that late in the year, the Erie Railroad
Officials refused to relocate ite tracks. This work was not
‘. completed by the railroad until October 1948.
~The delay in railroad relocation in turn delayed relocation
of State Highway -36, part of which was to be on the old :
- Tailroad bed. The highway relocation scheduled for
April 30, 1948 was not completed and opened to traffic until
; October 13, 1948. | ;
| s+ &s Until Mighway 36 was relocated plaintiff could perform
_* ;.” @anr etnbankment operations north of old Highway 36 tos —
_ limited extent only. Construction operations ‘in that area
| “ were restricted by the specification requirements that State
Highway 36, which bisected the dam foundation, remain
, Open to traffic, and that closure section, 150 feet in width at
ere: 19 Pa |
_ the bottom, in the bed of Canacadea Creek, remain open un-—
_ til such time as diversion of the creek could be accomplished.
South: of Highway 36 embankment operations proceeded
in the summer and fall of 1947. “However, during the spring *
and early summer of 1947 very little embankment placement
was performed due .to poor weather conditions. Plaintiff |
later received an extension of time therefor.
21. Realizing that its failure to-timely relocate the state _
highway would result! in. delay of further embankment |
operations plaintiff, in the spring of 1948, took action to
break this bottleneck.
By agreement with the Superintendent of Highways,
Steuben County, New York, which agreement was approved
by the contracting officer and the New York State Depart-
ment of Public Works, plantiff was permitted to detour'the _
traffic from existing Highway 36 via an alternate route over -
a county road known.as Webb’s Crossing Road. The detour
was made effective May 28, 1948. Following'the elimination
of highway traffic through the dam site, embankment opera-
tions: proceeded expeditiously.
In the meantime concreting of the tunnel had been com- .
pleted by May 8, 1948 and sufficient concrete work had also
been completed on the intake works, operating house and. Ze
stilling basin so that by August 14, 1948, when the embank-
ment had: been sufficiently: built up to the required eleva-.
tion, the stream. was diverted through the outlet works.
Construction of the closure section of the dam commenced
immediately thereafter.
Permanent diversion of the stream was thus accomplished
-almost tothe day anticipated by the plaintiff on its original
‘progress schedule. (See finding 19.)
. 22. It is clear. that the work of concreting in the tunnel
"and also in tha.inlet works and outlet works was seriously
disrupted by the failure to authorize the installation of tun-
nel supports earlier than: the letter of authorization dated
August 11, 1947 which was received by the plaintiff about
August 14, 1947.. Th ~‘aintiff in the exercise of gound
. judgment, had engaged .. - ervices of numerous independent
qualified engineers for consultation as to what might be re-
quired in the way of support ‘for the tunnel. It acted on
a *
\
S
061298 O-62-6 ‘
80
the advice of such engineers, and about three weeks before °
authority had‘ been given to install the steel arch ribs and
liner plates in the tunnel, on July 25, 1947, placed its order ~
for the steel. ar ae
23. The plaintiff, on August 15, 1947, promptly began the
installation of the tunnel supports upon receipt of the steel
___¢ ind they were installed by October 8, 1947. The space above
" the liner plates had to be filled with backpacking, rock and
boulders which could ‘be handled by one man crawling be-
tween the liner plates and the overhead in the rock tunnel.
The backpacking operation was finished in October 18, 1947.
24. Since the delay incident to authorizing the tunnel sup- |
' - ports required concreting operations in winter weather, it.
then became necessary to winterize the concrete. plant and
this was accomplished by the plaintiff. Concreting oper-
_ ations in the tunnel commenced on December 15, 1947 and
continued until May 8, 1948. Concreting operations began
in the intake area sometime after J uly 25, 1947 but this work
could not move along expeditiously since the installation of
the tunnel supports and backpacking interferred. The
original plan of work operations submitted by the plaintiff
called for the concreting of the intake and stilling basin from |
early July 1947 to the close of the 1947 work season. These
‘two items were the inlet works on one end of the tunnel and
' the outlet works and stilling basin at the downstream end
_ of the tunnel. . .
25. The original plan of operation called for the plaintiff.
to do the: concreting of the spillway from’ April 15 to
October 31, 1947. It should be noted that’the Jocation of
the spillway was several hundred feet north of and generally.
’ parallel to the area of the stilling basin. | -
28. Subsequent to March 25, 1947, when the initial work
of cleaning up the floor of the tunnel had been accomplished,
after the tunnel had been holed through, there were addi-
tional falls of rock from the roof of the tunnel and the sides.
As « result, befo
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.