Joint Appendix — Power Reactor Development Co. v. International Union of Electrical, Radio & MacHine Workers
Supreme Court brief1961
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
cuseisteand wen if RRL meee Sore te iat Bs re SA aA hr ese
Peg Le ae,
‘ni
Seb
arte
Os i LT OR ROY ee a OE oO aS
Re ee
w eo
ae Bee es
.
+
te
Ss RAN piatomee Re ES
=
INDEX
Voitume_ I
_~ Oral Testimony Taken Before the
Hearing Examiner ............
WITNESSES
Acker, Ernest R.
Direct Examination by Mr. Reid
J
Cross Examination hy Mr. Sigal »
Cross Examination by -
Mr. Maslowski ..............
Cross Examination by
Mr. Morrisson ..............
Recerd
age
262
269-273
273-279
327--341
345-346.
379-381
387-388
448-449
467-469
494-502
505-509
513-515
636-640
690
" 707-708
729-733
- 761-763
778-794
826-827
Appendix
age
Coe
II.
Record | Appendix
Page. age:
Re-cross Examination by’
ee Re heer e: 841-843 6263
Bethe, Hans A. heh :
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal \1145-1147 64-65
Fields, Kenneth £. | :
Cross EXamination by Mr. Sigal 2705-2707 65-67
el 2743-2744 67-69
2753-2754 69
McCullough, C. Rogers aes :
Cross Examination by 5
Mr. Morrisson ........... ... 2999-3003 70-73,
Milis; Mark | ;
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal 3278 73-74
2 ° = ‘ $
Radley, H. Monroe
Direct Examination by .
EEG, PROPPOON. oo ce ks aa 3285-3286 74-75
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal 3286-3305 75-90 °
Cross Examination by | :
Mr. Claytor ..:.0..5.7...0: 3305-3318 91-101.
~ Cross Examination (resumed) by | : ae
Mr. Claytar’..../.......6.003 3320-3322 101-103
‘Re-direct Examination by "ele i |
Mr. Morrisson .............. 3322-3325 103-105
“TIL
: ; hicnad ae Aprendir.,
; ; : Page Page
Re-crosy Examination by a
Bs MS os cc as ces 3325-3326 105-106 -
Wolman, Abel ~
Cross Examination by .
Mr. Claytor ......... -tscoacse | QeOd—Geel-. 107-110
Acker, Ernest R. (recall) >
- Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal 3392 “111
. \ 3398-3403 112-116
~~ 3408: =—s«446
3432-3484 117-159
Cross Examination. (continued) by - .
GME sto 3486-3528 ° 159-193
3536-3539 193-196
. _ 3542-3545 196-199 |
3557-3558 199-200
. Fields, Kenneth E. (recalled)
Cross Examination (resumed) by :
Pe ere rr rte - 3570-3585 200-213
if 3603-3604 ~ 213-214
3614-3616 214-215
Cross Examination by e |
“| Mp. Clayter 1.00.00... Mee - 3621. + 25.
| McCarthy, Walter J.,-Jr. (recalled)
‘Direét Examination by | |
Mr. Claytor ... <6... .csac.... 3870-3873 216-218
Iv.
EXHIBITS .
Exhibit Acker 1-A—PRDC-AEC Re-
processing Agreement .........-.
Exhibit Acker 1-B—EF«hibit A to.
PRDC-AEC Reprocessing Agree-
OE ia iinwis Cai sheseundenees wh
Exhibit Acker 2—Power Reactor De- .
velopment Company Enrico Fermi
Atomic Power Plant Project—
Statemert of Source and Applica-
tion of Cash during Period of
. OperGtions 2.1... ccc cccscesecees
Exhibit Acker 6—Summary of Reae-
tor Plant Equipment and Devices
* to be Purchased and Installed by
APDA for Testing and to be Trans-
ferred to PRDC at Salvage Value
. After Test......... icdaksaeene ss
Exhibit Acker 7—PRDC Construction
Cost E:.:mates ....... eseedaeses ,
Exhibit Acker ‘10—Back-up Material
for Operation Period Cash Flow
Schedules ............. eyrrrrre
Exhibit Acker 12—Letters of PRDC-
Members Waiving Regulatory
Agency Approvals as Condition up-
on Coutribution to PRDC; Only
, One Sample Printed ............ °.
Record .—
. Page
4409-4412
4413
4557-4570
4573
Appendix *
age
220-225 .
_ 225-226
.226-239
° -
: + €. . 4 .
pict ab aie, i pty hy Dat tt Sie nd Sie RD OO SY Sr 5 ~ ‘
iit abl aepirai tin) CRIES Sh ia re Sa et hin ee 2 ie < SRaaee ee: eae ee
Bir eita ees i TT
;
t
Pf
Exhibit Ackey 13—Orders of Regula-
~ +» tory Commissions with Respect to
(iuarantee Agreements and Contri-
butions; Only One Sample Printed
= Exhibit Acker 20-—-Summary of Mate-
oe ea nene Le
‘"xhibit Acker 26—Phitonium Rev-
enues Based on Plutonium Price of
$12.00 per Gram After June 30;
1963 on Unesealated and Escalated
GUN otvanswnwksbeua sees Pp ee
Exhibit Acker 27—Revised Estimate
of Waste Disposal Equipment.....
Exhibit Acker 28—Actual and .Antici-
pated Expenditures by PRDC and
APDA Combined Applicable to
PRDC Reactor Project ..........
Exhibit Acker 29—PRDC Commit-
ments and Expenditures on Re-
GE hbo 6 cadbaveccuneceuk weees
Intervenors’. Exhibit 3—United
States Atomie Energy Commission
Plutonium Guaranteed Fair Prices
—U. S. Federal Register—June 6, -
1957, Vol. 22, Page 3985 .........
Record
Page
4594-4601
4731-4732
4751
4752
4753-4756
4757-4759
Ap %endix
Fu ve
324-534
335-336
337.
338
’
338-342
343-345
345-348
¢
@
A
-
Ss
SRR ARO CER
s abi a Cea E
74
2 Sp ad Baath oO RARE RLS LAS Gets Rie
as ated r . - oun
by ary: Se, SA eee tte te el a BOOS
Rare LES PBR SES iat PAs e nd vette
s
p
¢ 270
Oral Testimony Taken Before the Hearing Examiner
ERNEST R. ACKER
seit * * -,
[262]
Direct Examination by Mr. Reid
Q. Mr. Acker, on'pages 7 to 8 of your testimony you
stated that the publie utility companies that contribute to
PRDC have assets in excess of: $2 billion. Do you wish to
add to or correct this statement? A. There was an omis-
sion there, Mr. Reid. It should have stated that the utility
member, companies and contributors of PRDC have com-
bined assets in excess of $6. billion and that their total
equity amounts to in excess’of $2 billion.
1260)
Q. Mr. Acker, have you had prepared a revised state:
ment of source and: application of cash during the operat-
“
_ ing -— .
[270]
period 1961 to 1970 w hich reflects these changes i in proces-
sing costs? A. Yes.
Q. ‘Does this staterrent also contain schedules which
reflect the effect during the operating period of the alter-
‘native tax ruling which you have requested that the con-
tributions to PRDC. are not taxabie income even if PRDC
itself is not held. to be totally exempt f rom income taxation?
A. It does. , | ’
-
7
270
Q. Are you acquainted with. the data on ‘which the
schedules included in-this revised statement of source and
application of cash have’ been prepared? A.. I am.
-Q. Is this the revised statement of source and applica-
tion of cash during the period of operations to which you
have referred? A. It is.
Mr. Reid: Will the Reporter mark this as Acker
Exhibit No. 2. 7 |
(Acker Exhibit No. 2 was marked for identifiea-
tion.) rs ad
Mr. Reid: Mr. — ‘we offer in evidence
Acker Exhibit No. %, the statement of Souree and
application of cash during the period of operation.
The Presiding Officer: Is there objection to the
[271]
receipt of the. document whien has been -deseribed
as Acker Exhibit No. 2?
Mr. Sigal: I understand that Acker Exhibit No.
2 i a revision of the Exhibit 29 now in the record.
Is that correct?. :
Mr. Sigal: Mr. Kyle, I maké the same objection
- to this exhibit that I did to Exhibit 29.
* Mr. Reid: Very well.’ -
-.Mr. Morrisson? |
Mr. Morrisson: I have no objection. |
The Presiding Officer: The objection wilh be
overruled and the document wilMbe received.
(Acker Exhibit No. 2 was received in evidence.)
“By Mr. Reid: .
Q. Mr. Acker, would you refer to each of the individual
272
*
schedules in png Exhibit No. 2 and identify it: briefly.
A. Sehedule No. a statement of Souree and applica-
tion of cash aa vith ten-year operating period assum-
ing that the company has no federal income tax liability.
Mr. Sigal: May I request, Mr. Acker, that you
kéep your voice up. I am sorry, I don’t hear you.
very well. ac
The Witness: .Sehedule No. 2 is a statement of |
source and application of eash during the. ten-vear
operating perted
assuming that the company has’ federal income tax
liability and that contributions are not taxable in-
come.
— Schedule No. 3 is a statement of source and ap-
plication of cash ‘during the ten-vear ‘operating
period assuming that the company has Federal in-
come tax lability and that’ the contributions are
‘taxable income.
Schedule No; 4-is a calculation of Federal income
‘ tax payments during the operating period assuming
that the contributions are not taxable income.‘
Schedule No. 5 is a calculation of annual deprecia-—
tion assuming that contributions are not taxable in-
come. ° x
Schedule No. 6 is a caleulation of Federal i income
tax payments during the operating period’ assuming
that the contributions are taxable income.
Schedule No: 7 is a caleulation of, annual ‘de-
preciation assuming that the contributions ‘are tax-
able income.
j
272
By Mr. Reid:
Q. Mr. Acker, a little fuller explanation: of Schedule
‘Nose 3. Does that take into account the ®xcess of the cost
of this plant.over an ordinary plant? - A. Yes. One in-
come tax deduction that is assumed for the purpose of
~ Schedule No. 3 is that the difference between the cost of
this reactor plant and the cost of a conventional plant of
the same Capacity would be considered by the Treasury
Department as research and development expense deduc-
tible . °
_, [273]
for Federal income tax purposes.
Mr. Reid: I see.
Youemay cross-examine. _
Cross Examination by Mr Sigal .
-Q. Mr. Acker, on page 8 of your testimony ‘you gave a
brief review of the development of the reactor project with
which we are now concerned, and this review goes back
to April 1951. We are interested in getting a little more
detail on that history than vour testimony provides. Will
you tellus how this ‘whole matter started? A. T think
this is the original concept of Mr. Cisler and some of his
associates. “In the Detroit Edison and the Dow Chemieal
Company people evidencing theer interest in the prace-|
ful development of the atom and notably in the produe-
tion of power from nuclear fission.
Q. For what purpose were they interested in deve lop-’
ment of a reactor? A. Looking to the future use of
nuclear energy for the production of power, and that of
course being based on the tremendous available resources |
Go ' 4
ee
274
in nuclear energy, the-nuélear materials in the surface
of the earth. 7 . |
Q.. Did they at that time, that is, in 1951, indieate to
“the AEC the basie-conditions under which they thought
- that such a reactor could be developed?: 1 am now speak-
-. ing with
[274]
particular reference to the financing of such a project. A,
I am not competent to testify as. to that, Mr. Sigal.
Q. You have no— A. I Was not a party te those
discussions, - 7 :
Q. You were net a party to them? =A. T was not a
party to those discussions.
Q). You mean you were not individually present? A,
‘No. My company was not associated with this group ai
that time. ee
Q. Therefore when, did your company’ become interest.
ed in this project, Mr. Acker? A. In 1955, according te
-Iny ‘recollection. 2 ey
Q. You have no personal kriowledge of what went on
prior to 19552 A. Except by diseussions with the indi-
viduals involved.
Q. You have no know ledge, then, of the shbject I am.
just raising with yout A. No personal knowledge, no,
except as I obtained from discussions.
+ Q. What discussions did’ you have with the individuals
involved concerning the period prior to 1955? A. When
our company was interested in becoming a’ member of the
group T had long discussions with Mr. ( isler and with some
of his people and with other members ‘of the APDA
organization. They informed me.as to the background of
wz?
275
[275]:
the formation of the organization and its purposes.
Q. Then they did not -tell you anything about their
original notions of how this should ehe financed, did they?
Sa nner .
Q. Were you advised, for example, at any time that in,
December 1951 the Dow Che mical-Detroit Mdison project
submitted a report to AEC in which they. stated that: pri-
vate investment in-nuclear power was not feasible **with-
out government guarantee for private capital expended
and a subsidy for the materjals and power prodneed’*?
A. Tam not familiar with that particular statement.
Q. That statément, Mr. Acker appears on page It of a
report submitted by that) prejeet and is marked) No.
TID-10077.. Do you know what contributions AEC made
to the study project which Dow Chemical and Detroit Edi.
. son were interested 92. A. Merely as a result of diseus-
sions, as I said before, with, Mr. Cisler and representatives
cof APDA,. IT knew that the government was giving assist-
anee but I was not pepsonally. familiar with the character .
of such assistance or the extent of it.
Q. Were you infermed by Mr. C islor that the AEC a
that time, 1951, agreed to contribute $725,006 to the soa
and that Dow Chemical and Detroit Kdison together would
contribute $725,0007 A. No, | wasnot familiar with that.
c [276]
QQ. This al appears, Mr. Acker, in this report that
I have just mentionede | ‘ E
Are you familiar with the facet that in the summer of 1952 ~
AEC made it known to the people in this project. that
¢
f
$ o | : 277
it did not intend to provide a guaranteed market for pri-
Vvately produced fissionable material and suggested that
all study groups direct their attention to so-called power
only reactors? A. No.1 sam onot fomiliar With that, Mr.
Sigal. As T have said, l was not a party to any of those
diseussjons. ge ;
Q. You are not familiar, then, Mr. Acker, with the dis-
cussion Which extended over a considerable pe rod with |
respect to the relative merits of single purpose and dna!
purpose reactors? AL Only te the exte nt that. I world
be familiar with them by reading. |
. You got Hothing about that from Mr. Cisler or his
associates? ALT ean‘t reeall that [did specifically,
Q. Were vou informed of the sate ‘ty problems that the
\ Study group was considering with’ reference te the
Powe r
reactor? AL Lo was familiar with those at the time- that
my company came into the APDA organizatia®.
Q: TL call your attention to the following language on
(277] ‘
page 14 of this report to AEC before | quote that. * This
is with neferonee to the matter of safety and exclusion.
(Quote:
— Exelusion area, no fnatter how large, is-not the answer
to the atmospheric contamination problem. Instead the
reactor enclosure “must be designed to contain sufficient
of the fission products to vliminate the hazards to surround-
ng territory resulting from reactor failure."’
Are you familiar with that subject matter? Were you
told about the problems involved? A;
Ww. ka Se A ee eT
_ 7 ae eee et tg Pee Na ce Bre TE aT aD Fite Mahe: Fea apn ae” Be Bs RS Ty
LTE Te ae NTN ey eT NTT TT :
Yes, I have been
A party to many discussions. I was atthe time that our &
SHIT Eee A
277. . .
company came into APDA and bave been since, on that
whole question. |
Q. But you were hot: aware the Statements that
were made at that particular period on.the subject by
* Dow Chemical? Al Not during that period, Mr. Sigal. ~
Q. Are-you aware, Mr. Acker, that-on April 14, i954,
AEC entered- into a new agreement in which ABC agreed
~~ to do $300,000 worth of the work involved in this study
project? A. No, Lam not personally familiar with that.
Q. Are you aware that the primary purpose of the
study was, or to put it in the language of the report, quote,
“/ mphasis has been placed on the subject of nue ‘lear acel-
dent.’ < ‘: .
Were you aware of that?) A. Tam not.
Q. This report also states, Mr. Acks 'r, at page 4 72 that,
[278]
= quote, ** Some effort has been devoted to studies of other
-
- types of reagtors, Then-it goes on to say at page 795,
quote, ‘*In view of the urgency felt by private enterprise
to construct a working, full size power breeder -it is con-
cludéd that the best interests of the group will be served
by continuing the major effort on the fast breeder.”’
“Are you familiar ‘with that matter, that statement or
the attitude described?) A. T am not familiar with the
statement, as I have said before. As far as the attitude-
expressed is concerned, it seems to be entirely consistent.
If you want. my opinion and based on what has transpired
since, ave believe that the fast breeder ‘reactor holds the
‘greatest promise from. the standpoint of the conservation
of nuclear fuels. and the ultimate economy of a pro-
duction through the use of nuclear energy.
8
=—
ee:
.
Pee
Q. Mr. Acker, perhitps you didn’t get the quete clearly,
Let me read it again : ‘‘In view of the urgency felt by
' private chterprise to construct a working full size power
. breeder, it is coneluded ‘that the best interests of the
group will be served by continuing the major effert on the
fast. breeder.’ a ‘ane,
‘The group referred to in this. statement of course is
private enterprise, A. . I would think it referred to the ;
“group tuat was ‘ :
1279)
involyed in the project, ae
Q. Then you are still of the position that private enter-
“prise will be hest served by building a full size power
breeder? A. T would interpret it that way, Mr. Sigal.
I would interpret it to mean that the best interests of
the group as those responsible for the’ provision of the
power requirements of their
customers, would be best
served by this action. 7 |
~Q. You aré not familiar-of ¢ourse with the document, _
as’you stated? A. No, Iam not. at.
Q. Or the discussions that went on at the time
are vou?
That is right. 7 ;
A.
[327]
By Mr. Sigal: a
Y. Mr. Acker, calling your attention to Exhibit XXI,
the first page. Do you have it before yout A. Yes.
(). Article 1, Section A, the first sentetice contains this
statement, quote: “*APDA will furnish to PRDC without
charge a complete design
EOE AEA RR co Mle ANTE LSS ELT RS 4 AREAS MS SDT Singer Oe OE AD er RAD aR SbaN Abide:
' Pode ae
for those components of the
i]
ee eee ee
207 oe | ) | |
\ : ¢ ;
reactor plant within and including the secondary contain-
ment vessel and for the primary coolant loops which col-
lectively are
[328] fe
herein referred to as the reactor proper, as identified on — bs
exhibits A and B.of this agreement.”” | ' ‘
Do you know what those components will cost APDA hi
‘o produce?’ A. I don’t think I have a statement of the | |
cost of those particular components. I can furnish it. | i
8
~Q. You have no knowledge of your own on that matter?
A. 1 have a statement of all of the components which
APDA ‘will furnish to PRDC. - He
. Q. Aostatement of all the components? A. Yes. ~
Q. You mean a list of them? A. Yes. a
Q. Yes, but I am asking you do you know the cost of
the components listed in paragraph At A. That could |
‘be identified from the -list’ which I have. I haven’t a ee
separate list as to these specifie ones.: I have those in- q
eluded in both A and B. ab .
Q. Does that list give the price of each item? A. It
gives the estimated cost of the item as we have included . |
it in our cost estimate. . | ;
<> Q. Your answer is, then, that it does give the cost
of each item. A. It doesn’t give the cost, Mr. Sigal.
It gives the estimaic of the cost at which cach item is
included in the _
[329] :
- PRDC construction estimate. In other words, it gives the. -
cost which we will be relieved of by reason. of receiving
these components from APDA.
10
_ 330
Q. Are you drawing. a distinction between the actual
s cost of the item and the cost that-is included in the esti-
mate? A. I am drawing a disinction between tbe cost to
APDA, which is purchasing and erecting this equipment,
and the cost at which those items are included in our cost
estimate, that is, PRDC cost estimate. :
Q. I see. Do you have, then, a ‘statement showing the
cost to APDA of each item and the cost to PRDC of. the
same item, and so on, for all the items which APDA will
transfer to PRDC. A. I want to be sure that I under-
stand your question and that I am giving you a responsive
answer. I have a list which shows the items, the cost
attached to each item in the PRDC construction estimate.
The cost.to PRDC will be nothing because they will reeeive
this equipment. in APDA without charge.’ The cost to
_ APDA has only been determined of course to the extent
that orders have actually been plated and bids for the
equipment have, been received from manufacturers.
Q.. Do you have that list??. A. Yes. r
Fhe Presiding Officer: Vill this be an exhibit,
Mr. Reid? © is
[330]
’ Mr. Reid: Not ours, no.
Mr. Sigal: Shall we mark this Acker No. 62
The Presiding Officer: Acker No. 6. -The docu-
ment will be marked Acker No. 6 for identification.
(Acker Exhibit No. 6 was marked for identifica-
tion.) ’ :
The Presiling Officer: ‘Will you furnish the Re-
porter a copy? ~
Mr. Claytor: Yes, we wilh. ”
f
°
11 ; ,
330
By Mr. Sigal: :
Q. Is this list which we have. identified as Acker No. 6
complete for all of the equipmen. anc devices which APDA
will provide to PRDC? A. Yes, jt is. : i
—Q. You have listed in the first column the ‘estimate
material cost. What does the estimated material cost
cover? A. It covers the finished cost “of the particular
piece of equipment referred to.
Q. That is the manufacturing cost? A. That is right.
Q. Does that inelude design cost?) A. No, it does
not. |
Q. Does.it include engineering eost? A. To the exten
that the manufacturer, did any engineering in connection
with it, yes. ae. .
[831]
Q. But to the extent that APDA did any engineering,
it dees not? A. No, it does not.
Q. Are you familidr with the estimate of the design
‘and engineering costs to APDA of these items listed on
Acker No. 62 A. Not specifically, no. -
(). Are you familiar generally? A. Yes, I know what
APDA has spent and proposes to spend for design and
development costs. .
Q. But you do not know what the design and engineer-.
ing costs are specifically with, ‘reference’ to each one of:
these items? A. No, I don’t.
(). The second colund is headed estimated installation
labor. What labor is that? A. That is the labor of erect-
tion on the site of these various items of equipment.
Q. Is APDA going to install each of these items in
the reactor plant of PRDU? A. That is right.
.
12
BARE Sa CE RS |
Pe NE Ar ea VTP g Re A Te OUT tw
Re Wursre tT yetg t at past | ; "e
‘A.
333
Q. At what point does PRDC accept transfer of these
items—prior to installation or when the installation is
complete?) A.- After APDA had completed the tests.
[332]
Q.. And before installation? A. No, no. After they
have complet ted their tests of the complete installation? -
Q. Of the complete installation? A. That is ‘right.
Q. The tests you are referreng to are the tests in the
reactor itself? A. The test of this particular equipment
which APDA is going to build and finance itself.
‘Q. You have listed a column entitled contingencies.
Do you know how the figures ‘were arriv ed at there? ~A,
Those contingencies are the portion of the contingency
items included in the PRDC construction cost estimate |
which relate to these various components.
Q. Do you know how the figures were determined?
A. They represent varying percentages of the direct.
material and labor costs.
Q. -Well you explain that satel’ A. In some
eases where the design is completed, where we have re-
ceived ‘manufacturers proppsals or made contracts with
manufacturers for the manufacture of the equipment, the
‘contingeney item might -be -10 per cent.
Q. You say it might be 10 per cent. How do you— |
I can fdentify particular items if you are itnerested
incknowing that. .
[333]
Q. Yes, take a particular item on which you say the
‘ contingency is 10 per cent, how do you arrive at the 10
per cent? A. That is based on experience in estimating
13
333
conventional steam station plants. Where we don’t have ¢
the background of experience that we have in connection
‘with éonventional piants, we would use‘anything from 15
per cent up to 30 per cent contingency. So it is a judg-
ment figure,-Mr. Sigal. Those are judgment figures.
Q. You mean based on. past experience? A. Based-
on past experience or current experience based’ on’ the
exposure to unknown or uncertain elements.
Q. Let us take the very first item, reactor vessel.
You have a contingency there of $171, 600 age inst a total
cost labor and material of $1,144,800. A. Yes.
-Q. Wiil you tell us how you arrived at that contin:
gency? A. On the basis of a percentage applied to that
direct material and labor cost. bas”
Q. Yes. How did you arrive at the percentage? We °
are now talking about a reactor vessel which has never
been built before. -A. That is included, Mr. Sigal, in’
a-vategory listed in our construction estimate, which is
—* ‘an exhibit in this case, under. a heading called reactor
plant construction. I
eae [334] ae
beg your pardon. a.moment. ne referring to his
papers.) |
That is included under’ a heading in our construction :
‘ estimate called reactor: plant equipment, and the reactor
vessel is included in a group of material as.to which
we.have assigned 2 contingency: item of 15 per cent.
The. particular reason for that is that the reactor vessel ,
itself is the largest single. element in that category and
we have.a proposal and have placed an order with the
Combustion Engineering C ‘ompanly for that reactor vessel
‘ata — “which i is shown. ;
14
i y,
SLEEPY EER er PEABO REIS Fa es
bas be ȴ +
PS ie
=f
OE gr Pee cA
DS lis Bn NO eo erg lae’>
LC wite Ot aiesed
ag MES
335
@. You placed an order fur the reactor vessel at the
price which is shown? A. No, because there are ther
. elements aside from just the purchase of the reactor vessy!
itself. Of the $1,062,000, the reactor vessel, based on the
proposal af Combustion Engineering, is $915,800.
Q. What is that figure? Is that the. contract price?
A. That is. the Combustion Engineering proposal on
which an order has been placed with Combustion Engineer
ing. nn :
_ Q. For the reactor vessel?) A. For. the reactor ves-
o eee
Q. Why did vou charge $1,062,000 for. that item? A.
T say there are other items included there.
Q.. In this reactor vessel item?, A. That is right.
~Q. What other items are included?
[335]
A. There is an allowance for extras ae as: loop stub
'. piping also, thermocouples, expansion joints, for. nuclear
operation, We have an item to cover escalation. There
is heating system material., That is heating coils for
keeping the sodium fluid dutlug ‘the reactor -shutdbwn.
There i is the exection cost. There is the rest of the reactor
vessel. Therevis the reaction cost of the heating system.
Q. Is that all ineluded ° in the million dollar item? A.
There is steel shie ding. The entire item which we have
listed here as reactor-yessel, steel shielding, internal str "ue-
tutes, and heating system, in our estimate adds: up to
$1,37 3,900. We will receive this vessel and other portions
of that equipment from APDA to the extent that it relieves
that total cost of $1,373,000 by $1,316,000. .
335 | : / : . . . -
Q. What is the difference? What does that difference
represent? A. The difference is in items whieh PRDC
will itseif provide..
Q. Mr. Acker, getting to the uestion that I asked you
originally, how did you ‘determine or how did APDA
determine this , contingency of $171,600 for ‘the item
of reactor vessel?! Did they’ apply just a = mathe-
matical formula and say ‘‘This is what it will
*, or was it related to some more specific information
and possibility. A. It was a mathematical application of
” he?’
15 per cent
; , [336]
to the material and labor costs based-ot our judgment
as to the exposure that \ e had for contingencies for this
class of item. |
Q. Wet experience have you had or has PRDC had
with the building of reactor vessels?) A. This is our
first experienve. ,
Q. So you can't rely on your experience to determine
what the contingency is, can yout A. Generally«speak-
ing, that is right. Maybe, but I would like to point out
again, as [I said, that the major portion of the tést. of.
this item is based on a proposal and an order which is
already placed at a figure. So as to that portion of the.
total we see ho reason that we should go any further than
u 15 per cent contingency. fi .
Q. Then your -centingengy is not related to the ques-
tion of whether or not PRBC has dc.ermined the prob-
lems of safety with 1espect to the reaetor vessel? * i
don't understand your question. -
Q. I would like to know, Mr. Acker, whether thir eva.
4
16
p” . a 337
tingency reflects to any extent any problem or doubt with
respec] to whether or not the reactor vessel as designed.
Will meet the neyd. AL This contingency iteni, Mr. Sigal,
is not intended ‘to provide fo cha. os in the design or
So structure of the’ equipment. :
. ‘ ; ”
[337] |
AQT see. Thai is irue with every contingeney item
Which is mentioned in this estimate and inthe other
estimates. that you have submitted? A. That is true,
except to the exte ut that the “design of some of the items
may not have heen completed as vet and if modifieation
of those items is necessary then the contingeney- item
would cover the cost of the modification, .
Y. But generally speaking, certainly, so far as. what.
you have presented hére, the contingencies do not include
the cost of design if chang s are required? — A. It might
cover some of the cost of design’ changes hut not the
construction of @ new picee of equipment which is te.
replace one whieh js included here. : :
LN W hether or net it does incluile design costs, you
are not certain? I< that true? A, T am not saving,
Mr. Nigal. that i: would inelude no: design costs but we
have other provisions for research and design changes
Which may be necessary in the future,
QQ. Se in any event with respect to these various esti. AS
mates the item @f contingwnecies is not intended to, cover \
the design costs with reference to changes that may be
required in these items? A. It may be adequate in somes _
| itistanees to cover the design changes, ‘That is the point
lam tr ‘ng to make. _ |
YQ. Do vou know of any instance where it might. he
Hy ;
ca
338 |
[338]
adequate? A. In the ease where we may have applied
30 per cent contingency knowing that we had only a con-
ceptual design and didn't yet have a definitive design 30
per cent might be adequate. I am not saving there is
nothing available there for design change. ;
Q. Can you point out any specific item w here the con-
tingency might be suffiicent for that purpose? A. I would
say as to. any item where we have up to, say, 30 per gent
contingency: it is. entirely possible that .a portion of that
that would be available for design changes. |
Q. .Some portion? A. Yes. 0°.
_Q. Can you say what portion? A. No, I can not.
The distinction that I am trying to draw, Mr. Sigal, is 4
that we do-not intend the contingency items to provide
for any changes.in the-constr uction of pieces of equipment
cr to take eare of modifications of pieces of éyuipment a
which have to be substituted for items included here.
Q. You mentioned in the course of your statement that — -
the contract includes escalation. Will you explain the word
escalation?. A. Escalation is the provision you make
for increased labor and shop materia} costs.
1390)
Q. What provision have you made for escalation? A.
There is a total in this classification of items which in-
eludes the reactor vessel of $91,000.
Q. Is nat escalation item part of the figure that is
given here as to the cost of the,jtem? A. Yes.
Q. Is that true with respect to all other items? Do 4
the¥. all contain escalation provisions? A. As to I- wonld
1S
F
sav the bulk of the items in our construction estimate, we —\,
have allowed for escalation, yes.
s
Q. Is there a flat percentage, of escalation? A T ean
_ not tell you, Mr. Sigal, the exact basis on w hich the eseata- .
tion is determined. Tecan tell you who made ‘the estimate
and-get the information for vou if you wish to have it.
Q. Do you have with you the work sheets for the various
estiniates that vou have j provided with resp eet tc costs and
expenses? A. Ido not.
Q. Do you.expect to have them? A. T hadn't expected
that they would be required. If they are, they ean be made.
available, I should think.
Q. A request) was made, Mr. Acker, that the work
sheets that you used dr PRDC used with respeet to ‘he
various estimates be available. You know the various
statements | ‘
[340] . 7
you have submitted on costs, ‘operating capenses, and so
on. We are interested in ¢xamining those work sheets
whenever questions may arise. A. It is a very voluminous
record, Mr. Sigal.
Q. Of course vou are “‘undoubtediy in’ a better position
to know than we are. We are interested in heing able to
check those work sheets from time to time. Can they be
made available tomorrow? A. T don't. believe that: is
possible, ) ‘
Mr. Claytor: Mr. Sigal, I think that the detailed
work sheets to which you have made reference are
a ailaole here in the form of ‘further, breakdowns
and analyses of each item in the construction esti-
mate. + With respect to the construction estimate |
Lo
ili
1!
fs
340
gi
ans hs
&.
it, please? .
we can make thosé available to you now. With re-
spect to any other items I.think we would have to ser
whith items they are. Certainly. with respect 0.
the construction estimate we have this available a
you wish it. a, :
Mr. Sigal: Can you give me a copy? -May 1 have .
® .
ee ea eas 1
J am also requesting the ‘work sheets. jee the other
exhibit:, Mr. Claytor, the operating expenses dur-
pe construction, and income sad operating ex-
penses during.operation. They may be made avail: ~
able. o-
Mr. Claytor: Yes.
I would suggest thet as T hand these to. you ‘they he |
[341]
marked for identification fer the future. This would s
be Acker Exhibit No. 7, work sheets on ¢onstruc-
tiori estimate, Application Exhibit No. XX VIT.
2 33 aash é
oe ee AP) a oF
* ee @ :
[345]
Did you have anything to do with the organization ~
0 | ee :
(346) :
Re.
7
of PRDC, Mr. Acker? A.- Yes. I was one of the origina: be
members. | | 4
Q. Are you familiar with the circumstances under ”
which it was organized? A. Ob, yes. Very early in the
organization of PRDC I was apnointed chairman of the
1)
;
)
Cee ee eee eee
riod,
° 379
finance committee and I later on became vice president of |
ihe Company.
QQ. Mr. Acker, there are now.21 members of PRD, is
tat correct? A. That is correct. £
Q. Is there any obligation on the pai of these mem-
bers to continue their membership for any particular
length of time? A. No. ,
4). Aside from any written-commitiient whieh the mem-
hers may have gives to PRDC is there any additional eom-
mitment for contributions by these members to PRDC® -
A. No.’ es ; wk
e . *
[379]
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. The first sentence: of. Article | says that it will
cofitinue an eect for a period of ten years, but in ‘no
event besxond December 31, 170. Your. own statenent
indieates that. you will‘ not operate this plant beyond 1970.
Do you knov why AEC gave vou an allotment ‘for 23
years voing up to 1980? A. Just a moment, Mr. Sigal.
[don't think I have ever stated in any testimony that we
would net operate this reactor plant beyond 1970. Iteis”
. Gir intention to operate it for a ten-year period.
Q. That is 1970, A. For this purpose. But we have
lever stated that we would not operate it beyond that pe-
. You have not stated that? A... No, sir.
(. Is it your intention to operate it beyongl 1970? A.
leant say —* would depend upon the results of our
- Operation -during\the ten-year period.
(). In that ease, Mr. Acker, may | call your attention —
=)
shen yaahoemell
_ 379
to what you said on page 24 of your testimony about the
middle of the page. Your statement begins, ‘*The period —
projected for the experimental operation of the reactor BR
plant upon | i
[380].
completion of the test year 1960,-is ten vears. We feel
that at least the ten ’years will be required to study ade- |
quately the eéonomic and technical aspects of the opera: ©
tion of the fast breeder reactor as a facility for the’ = Pe
duction of steam, usabie for the generation of electricity.” .
_ Ts that statement not inconsistent with what you have a
just said? A. I don’t think so. -. a:
Q. You think that this says that you will operate for <<
more than ten years? A. No, I don’t, but my statement, ©
Mr. Sigal, was that we had never made the statement that |
we would not operate beyond the ten year period. d
Q. Oh, I see. All you have done is make an affirmative —
statement that vou will operatefor ten years? A. That — a
‘is right.
Qs. I see. A.. That is geared to the period: that we "ae
think necessary to prove out the economics of the plant.
Q. It is your position that nene of the statements yo. |
have submitted here indicates that it is not your intention —
to go beyond ten years? A. That is right. - , “a
Q: That it is not your intention not to go beyond ad a
periea?
[381]
A. There are two negatives in there. T will have to thick
about that. . >
Q. I will state it affirmatively. Is it not true’ tnat the 4 4
29.
388
statements you have submittéd indicate that PRDC will
operate fer only ten years? A. That is not true.
Qe That is not true? A. No.
[387] }
Q: On the next page, page 7, in paragraph E it says,
‘The Commission will and hereby does waive its use
‘charge for special nuclear material used in connection with
the project for the period commencing with the effective
date of this contract and endiny five years after comyhence-
_ment of operation of the reactor plant as established in
accordance with the provisions of Article I.’?:
Tf this contract is signed, say, this month, March 1957,
‘and thé plant doesn’t go into operation until sometime in:
1960, ean you explain why the Commission would provide
special nuclear materials for the period ‘between the effec-
tive date of the contract and the date when the ractor
goes into operation? A. During that period the fuel
elements would be Cx
<¢
>. [388] - ,
[38g] °
| expected to be fabricated and Seite nuclear material is
necessary for that purpose.
Q. In 1957? A. Not necessarily i in 1957.
» Q. The allocation provides for nuclear materials from:
the effective date of this contract. That is what it says
here. Why would you need nuclear materials in 1957? A.
3 T don’t think we do. I think we are cheduled to need them
mn 1958. hey : .
Sud i
«
PN tae
ESR 2
Feiss Oe
or
Die os,
388
Q. That is what the agreement provides. A. I can’t
see any objection to that, Mr. Sigal. : 3
ee ¢ ® & | 2
[448]
« Q. Asa matter of fact, this whole project rests on the
proposition that it can not operate unless AEC buys
plutonium produced in this reactor? A. I think that is
a fair statement. It could be operated—No, I thik that
is a perfectly fair statement.
7 ’
[4491
Q. In: any ev wi certainly PRDC wili not operate this
plant if it can not sell its plutonium to the governnient,
to AEC? A. That is true. :
[467]
Q.. As a matter of fact, I assume you know, Mr. Acker,
that no fast breeder reactor has been built which has
survived all tests made? A. I think that is a fact.
Q. So there is now no experience in any organiza-—
tion, be it AEC or PRDC, with respect to the building of
a successful fast breeder reactor which is safe.
[168]
A. I would not make that statement, Mr. Sigal.
Q. Because you have no ne of it yourself? A.
That is right. \
Q. You say that the risk to PRDC is roughly the cost
24
494
of building the reactor, naniely, about $40 million. Well,
what— A. I would say it is contributions to which the
_ wember conipanies are committed plus the amount of the
loan which they will haye guaranteed.
Q. That is about $38 million? <A. - About $38 million.
‘Q. What provision has PRDC made to meet that risk? .
A.» That financial risk? > —
* Q. Yes. A. I don’t know that it has made any pro-
vision. If it had made provision, Mr.-Sigal, it would not.
he a risk. |
Q. ” When yowsay that there is a risk in proceeding now
are you asserting that if the schedule can no{ be met,
PRDC will abandon the project rather than put any more .
money into it in order to build it at a later date? A. No,
I am not saying that at all. .
Q. All right, then, I am asking you what. arrangement
has PRDC made to meet the risk that its original plans
may not work out? A. -It has made no arrangement.
Whatever arrangements
[469].
were made would depend on the circumstances at the time
that it was faced with that decision,
eo eo sd
[494]
By Mr. Sigal: ste
Q. Mr. Acker, will you look at page 5 of this exhibit, .
this summary? A. I have it, Mr. Sigal. ;
Q.. That shows at the end of the total estimated plant
cost; is that right? A. That is right.
25
494 ee
Q. $32,400,000? “A. That is right. ;
'*Q. That does not’ include, does. it, certain other. engi-
; neering and research matters that are necessary during .
construction ? ‘ ! |
For éxample, ; that item does not ‘neds the $5 million
that PRDC says it will spend during constructien, does
it? -A. That is right. ; |
QQ. Can you tell us w hat is the actual cost of construc-
tion, including all items spent during the period that you
eall the construction period? A. That’ would be shown
"on page 7. Do you have a page 7 to your exhibit? ak
; /. :
| [495] | :
Q. Yes. A.. $43;216,000. . -
Q. Is that cash outlay by PRDC? A. No, that includes
$7 million, received in test equipment and devices_ and
‘research-and development expense by’ APDA.
Q. .So aecording to that figure, fhe amount of money °
~ actually expended by PRDC w ould be $36,216,000; is that
right? “A. That is right.
- Oo If that is the amount actually expended during. that
period, what amount will PRDC have in its reserves at
the time that cotistruction is completed? A. As I remem-
ber it, Mr. Sigal, PRDE€ will have a balance at the end.
of the-construction period of $3,499,000. |
Q. How do you deriye that figure? P I think that
is stated in my testimony,: Mr. Sigal.
_ The Presiding — Officer: Page 13 of your testi-
mony?
By Mr. Sigal: . . 8
€). You stated that in | the first. paragraph on page 13.
Si F..) 2 . Qe
» ~
ac
496
Can you tell us bow you derived this. figure? A, Yes,
*
anticipated total resources of PRDC, including the: $7
mitiion from APDrA,. dsy $45,540,000, The reactor cost,
overall, includiag the $7 Million value placed on the contri-
hutions of APDA, is $43, : 216,000, and the difference, I” -
think,’ is $9,394.00. . i
If you add to that the provision for working capital
(496)
Ww hich we expect to fees at. the end. of the construction
period i in-hand, you get'a total of $3,499,000. *
Q. If you are going to include that. $1,175,000. -as ‘a
statement of your excess Over costs® nh certainly you
ought not to include that same $1,175 ee the statement
of your construction expense,, should you, Mr. Acker?
A. It depends on how you want to show it, Mr. Sigal.
pn is a provision which must be made and must be
‘ailable during. a construction period involving expendi-
sped of this size to provide pr meeting payroll, meeting
all kinds of expenses from time to time.™
It, in effect; Mr. Sigal, is the amount that you hope to
maintain and expect to maintain and should maintain in®
your bank account #6 meet whatever disbursements are
necessary, Tt is not considered as an expendable ifem, j in.
other words. It is a provision for evening out your ex-
penditures*over a-period.:
Q. It is not a fund or a sum that you 1 spend? A. That
Is right. ‘ : r
Q. So to %all it a cost of. construction, as you do on
page %, is stretching it. a little, isn’t it, Mr. Acker? A, I
don’t think so. I think it is an item that any .0dy faced
with the construction of any plant must take into eon-
e Nee ‘ °
°
496 ig
sideration: The money must be provided whether it is
expended or left over-at the end of the period. . It has
to. be fn hand and has ‘to be in the bank available for use.
oe re [497] aes
Q. In any event, your statement, is that this is not a tis
that you intend to expend? A. That is right.
“Q. During the construction peri dt: A. That is right.
You will see. by the same token, Mr. Sigal, that it is con-
finued all through the spennee period, as well.
_ Q.. Yes. ve
- Does this construction estimate, this exhibit, indicate
all the expenses, that ‘you anticipate having during the‘con- .
struction period? A. It does.
Q. This does not cover any expenses that go ne the’
-eonstruction period, does it? A.. Let me check that. °
Yes, this includes an item of $550,000 for initial opera-
tion from’ low to full load which covers the cost of the’
test year which immediately follows the completion of |
construction. ‘
W hy did you include that item in the construction
estimate if this i is not aitributable to construction? A. It — 7
is a question of judgment as to where to put that kind of
item, Mr. Sigal. Is the test year. part-of the construction
period or is it a part of the operating period?. ‘That is
just a question of semantics, it seems to me.
m™
[498] |
QQ. In. your opinion, at least as this exhibit reflects, the
test year is part of the construction period? “A. To the
extent that we hav e-ineluded -the cost of conducting the
an
a . | 28
499 |
test: during: the test year in the construction estimate. It
might be put that way. Ti really doesn’t make any differ-
ence, Mr. Sigal. You have to-maké the proVision either
way; however you want to characterize it. .
Q. This is for the purpose of analyzing your statement,
Mr. Ackers “All T am asking is, is it not true that PRDC
judged this to be a construction cost inasmuch as it included .
the item in its construction estimate? A, I suppose that
_inference could be drawn. It seems to me it is academic.
Q, Is it’a fair. statement to say that in your testimony
whenever you refer to construction and its cost, you refer
to the matters ‘which are jneluded. jn this construction esti-
mate? A.. That is right. ;
> Q. . Will you examine Item L,. that is, the detail on the
preoperation testing after construction? A. Yes, é
{). The introduction .to this Statement—by the way, I
am quoting fromAtem L in Aeker Exhibit No. 7 for iden-
tifieation—quite: “% ; .
4 - “This capital item is an expense that occurs be-
fore the plant is ready for commercial operation.
It includes
[499]
only operating expenses and does not include any
of the costs of money or taxes other than social
security taxes. a
“The expense i§ incurred after completion of the
plant construction and before it becomes critical. It
includes final adjustments to all plant equipment,
minor changes-and an item for inspection’and testing
of the initial loading of core and blanket elements.
3 ‘Tn addition, the expense covers several weeks that
Poe
: -
°
499
are required for thie progressive loading of the re-
actor -eore, carefully: measuring’ the approach to
criticality after the addition of, one-third of the core -
elements anid again after each additional element is
added to the core. The hold-down plate is lowered, |
the reactyr locked, - control rods lowered -after .
each. element addition.’
The cost of that item is $350,000, estimated. — A. Right.
Q. The deseription there indicates what has to be done
up’to the point of reaching criticality, doesn’t it? A. That
is right, up to the point of beginning of operation = the
plant. . . :
Q. The actual imecuaiu’ A. That is right..
Q. Of: course, it includes, as it says, the insertion of
nuclear fuel into the reactor? A. Yes. . Obviously that
can’t be done until we get an
[500] ~ y
operating permit. | |
Q. ‘Is that so? A. That is right. , |
Q. Where does it say that, Mr. Acker? A. It semi
~ say that.
Q. You know that of your own knowledge! A. I believe
. that to be the fact. ;
Q. Is there anything in the record which: “$0 indicates?
A. Not that I know of.’
Q. Will-you turn over to Item N which j is titled, ‘*Tnitial
Operation, Low to Fufi Load’’?
‘‘This allowance provides for the cost of one year’s
operation that,is required to bring the reactor to a
condition of safe operation at full load. After the
reactor becomes critical it is loaded to give a small
30
G
en ne
“501
heat output and the control and safety rods-.operated
‘to determine their effectiveness. These tests are
repeated many times in the process of calibrating
control roads and proving that the safety rod char-
acteristics dre satisfactory.
‘After these tests which require several months,
other tests estimated to take about six months will
be performed. These tésts- required to prove reactor
| stability include a Jong series of tests with oscillat-
ing reactivity applied to the reactor core with pro-
grammed reactor’ a
[5019
loadings and oscillator frequencies.”
A. Right. —— ee
Q.. Are you prepared to explain that second paragraph?
* ie Te erat Ce
ie (Laugliter.)
You knew the answer in advance, Mr. Sigal.
Q. In any event, Mr. Acker, it is clear from this state-
ment that this refers to a procesy which is involved in the
~ operation of the reactor after it reaches criticality? A.
That is true, Mr. Sigal. - : : |
Q. I assume you are aware of the fact that perhaps the
most dangerous period in the life of a reactor is the moment
of bringing it to criticality? A. I cannot state that as a
nuclear expert, Mr. Sigal, but- just as a layman I would
assume that that would be a proper statement.
_ This operation obviously is another that could not be
undertaken until we have an operating license. res
Q. Under this statement, Mr. Acker, it appears that the
“501.”
preoperation testing in the initial operation to full load
will begin somewhere around 1959 or 1958? A. It is sched-
uled for the end of 1959. ‘The preoperational testing would
be at the end of 1959. The initial operation low to full load
is scheduled for 1960.
Q. -The entire year? You mean it will begin in 1960T
- (502) : .
A. That is right.. Our program and all of our operating
schedules have set aside the full year 1960 for that opera
tion.
Q. Will you look at Figure No. 1 which was referred to
before in Mr.. Amorosi’s testimony?
You will note there on. the right-hand side of that
figure, under 1960, that the pxeoperation testing is to begin
in December of 1959. The criticality date is set at Decem-
ber 15, 1959, according to this picture; is that right? . A. |
According to this statement, that is true. I think there is | |
a difference in terminology.
Q. Mr. Acker, I don’t know whether the PRDC repre-.
‘ “sentatives differ i in their use of these words, but this figure
uses the precise language that you have used” in, the con-
structionestimate. A. That is true, Mr. Sigal.
Q. Thjs whole year of 1960 is shown as devoted to pre-
operation testing.” If a year is devoted to that, then it _
would appear that another year, 1961, will be required for
the second operation, namely, the initial operation low to
' full load, according to your own statement. A. .Mr. Sigal,
that is not the intent. There is a confusion of terms here,
~ and I will readily admit it. The preoperation testing as_.
included in Mr. Amorosi’s exhibit is the item which we dis-
»>
*
506
cussed before in our construetion estimate designated N,
Initial Operating, Low to Full Load:
# > +.
[505]
ita I think I asked es earlier about a possible
breakdown of the $5 million &timate on research and de-
velopment by PRDC, and your statement was that that
. Wasn’t available. A. That is right, there is no specific
schedule of proposed research and development expense.
That is an allowance for whatever we may do or be re-
quired to do:
Q. There is an item of $4 million by APDA for similar
work. Is there any breakdown of that? A. That is in-
1959, which is in evidence in this proceeding.
Q. . You have no other breakdown’ than what appears
on that exhibit? A. I have none.
Q. You are aware, are you not, Mr. Acker, thatthe ex-
- eluded in the APPA budget for the years 1957, 1958: and
perts and consultants for PRDC anticipate that there may -
[506]
be substantial. changes in components dtring the course
of construction and prior to the time they actually get
‘into operation?. Are you aware of that? A. During the
course of construction?
Q. Yes. By ‘‘construction’’ I am: taking it up to the
_ ~point of actual operation. A.’ There may be changes re-
’ quired as a result of the test of the APDA equipment and -
devices which they propose to furnish to us.
Q. Or as a result of the rescarch work done by APDA
33
506 ee bs aa ar
. or PDRC there may be changes required? A. That is con-
ceivable; yes. Ea , i
Q. Or work done by AEC? A. That is conceivable.
Q. Or any eonsultant that you may use for this pur-
pose? A. Yes. The reason that I qualified what I said
previously was that all that work that you refer to will
be in the course of completion during this three-year con-
struction period ficcessively.. If the result of some of the
tests that are to be made show that changes are required
in any of the proposed components of the reactor plant
before they are actually fabricated, then, of course, we will
not be subjected to additional cost for new items.
Q. What happens if you learn about these things after
the designs are frozen? x
ae a [507]
A. Then we are exposed to additional costs for new design.
If the piece has been. fabrieated, we are ee exposed
to the cost of replacement.
Q. What provision ‘have you made to meet that con-
tingeney? A. We have $5'million, as I told you, which is
unassigned for the most part.
In- addition, in our estimate we show as the estimated
cost to us of the efaipment and devices which APDA will
furnish us about $4,100,000. In our financial statement
we have estimated the value of those pieces of equipment
and devices at $3 million.
That is in on both sides of the equation. We have con-
sidered that as a cost in our financial schedules and we
liave considered it as a receipt. We could have put it in -
dollars on either side. .The difference between ‘that’ $3
million which we have in our financial schedules and the
OL aAB Hay Oeste eh | attain He ange oe oe a
°
ean eh BE so DA
iene vmtrintteny,
508°
#4,100,000 which is included for the same items in our con-
struction estimate, perhaps $1,100,000, would be available -
for such changes and adjustments as hdve to be made.
YQ. So your estimate, then, is that you will have $1
million available for that ‘purpose? .A. We will have $1
million, plus whatever portion of ihe $5 million which wéuld
be available for the purpose, as well. . 3
Q. Let us assume: Mr. Acker, that the amount required:
to make the changes exceeds $5 million or $6 million.. What
[508] :
will PRDC do to meet that contingency?, A. Mr. Sigal,
you are asking me personally. I am not the least bit con-
cerned about that. These ‘companies will: have put in $25
million, and will have put into APDA reserve previously
$6,700,000, something on that order. ‘With that kind of |
investment in a very important project, I see no possibility
—-if you want to quahify it, I will say no reasonable pos-
sibility—that these companies would not come forward and
put up the additional money required to‘complete the job
which they had undertaken. :
Q. The fact is, Mr. Acker, that PRDC does not have the - -
resources now, it doesn’t have any comniitments to take ~
care of any of the contmgencies you are now mentioning,
does it? A. Yes. - po
: Q. What is ‘the provision?, A. It has the $1,100,000
that-I spoke of, plus whatever portion of the $5 million that
could be used for that purpose. ace ,
Q. My question to you was, suppose the additional costs
exceeded $6 million? Where. is PRDC going ‘to get the
money? A. I thought I indicated that very clearly, Mr.
"-
oo)
508
Sigal, that it would come in*my opinion from the member
companies who, I think, would be glad to put up the addi-
tional money required.
Q: My question to you, Mr. Acker, i is, is. it not: true
Rag. a
that-at the present tinre there is no commitment from any- .
hody ;
‘eal
any member of PRDC, to give oné cent more than they have
row committed themselves to give ‘in these lette ters of com-
mitment? A. That is perfectly true, but I would like to
say that it would be most difficult to get anybody to make
a commitment for an unknown amount. ©
“
*. *
[513] °
' By Mr. Sigal: ; ;
Q. ‘Do you know what force that containment vessel is
planned to contain? A: I am not qualified in that field,
Mr. Sigal.
_ Q. If it should turn out, Mr. Acker, that the estimate
is. wrong, is it not quite possible that the entire vessel
_ will have to be rebuilt? Qbviously, ‘if if is too weak to
*-eontain the force for which it is intended— A. If the
calculations upon which the sfréngth of the vessel was
_based are wrong, it might have to be rebuilt or it might
have to-he reinforced or an additional might have. to is
— outside. ‘Anything might happen. .
Q. Are you aware that there is a serious question in
i3 case as to what nuclear accident might have to be con-
-fained or the force of such an accident? A. Yes, I am
aware of that.
36
i. é
A ARO“ eacas te tat ata Ld S00
515 -
-Q. Hasn’t PRDC gone ahead and wade its plans with
respect te the kind of vessel it will order Without waiting
for final experimental results on this question?
[514] cs . # %
A. That is true. -Those experimental results would be.
expected to confirm the theoretical calculations of the
engineers and scientists who have made the assumptions.
on which the design was based. Peay :
The Presiding Officer: Mr. Acker, did. you ‘finish
your statement? — . * |
The Witness: -Yes, I. did.
By Mr. Sigal: ‘4 |
{)..- That vessel would have to be ordered and built prior
to the time that those experimental ‘results: are available,
won’t it, Mr. Acker? A. That is right. That is one of
the financial risks that we are assuming,
Q. Are you prepared to say that the members of PRDC
will go so far as to pay for the complete rebuilding and
' redesign of the reactor in the event the experiments show
serious fault in the whole structure? A. You mean just
the reactor itself, or the reactor plant. .
Q. I mean the whole project. Are they prepared to -
start from seratch to redesign and-rebuild the reactor? A.
No, T am not prepared to say that, Mr. Sigal. »
QQ. Let me eall your attention, then, Mr. Acker, to this
statement which appears in the testimony of Mr. Bethe, .
page 56. \
[515]
AL I have-it, Mr. Sigal.
515
Q. I’ call your attention to the last full paragraph on .
page 56. I will read it.
‘*To measure in particular the prompt positive’
temperature coefficient, we shall reduce the flow of:
coolant to a very small amount, possibly shutiing it
off completely, and wé shall use very low power,
_ perhaps_one percent of normal operating power. If
then the power oscillation is in phase with the re-
activity oscillation, this indicates a positive prompt
-temperature coefficient; if it has the oppdsite phase,
then the temperature coefficient is negative. If in
this experiment, contrary to what I betievexwill be
the fact, the temperature coefficient should turn out
to be positive, we shaii take the reactor apart and.
redesign it.’’ —
Did Mr. Bethe make that statement with the authority
of PRDC officiais? A. I have no knowledge of on what
basis he made taat statement.
Q. You are not prepared to state that PRDC wiil take
the reactor apart and redesign it if it turns out that it is
so seriously defective as indicated? A. Iam not prepared
to state that. That would be a management decision, Mr.
Sigal, obviously, which could be made only at the time and
under the eireumstances. .
. (636) °° 4)
Q. Since we are on that exhibit, I would. like to ask |
just a few more questions.
Mr. Acker, I would appreciate: it if you would make one
more mathematical calculation. ‘Have ‘you brought your .
© +
“Ny
38
BUM ies
iD
la DSUs ah geass ie
637
tide rule this morning? AL No, | aid not, sir, It-is in
Poughkeepsie, ’ . . i
Qa We calculated the figures derived from dividing the
estimated income of PRDC for plutonium sales by 106 for
each. year; is.that ‘right? A. That is right.
~ Q. We, 1 think, did not finish those calculations.
The figure 106 per year is taken from Intervenor’s Ex-
hibit No: 1, which shows that PRDC estimated the produc-
tion would be 106 kilograms of plutonium per vear; is that
right? A. Yes, _@ cs
Q. Now, assume that that figure 106 is. ‘an average an-
‘nual production. for 10 years; that would mean the total
production
[637]
for the 10 years would he 1060 kilograms ; is that right?
A.. On that assumption, yes. oe
Q. On that assumption, yes. ,
Will you please divide the figure- 48,623,000 by 1060? A.
That is approximately $46. on .@
Q. Per gram? A. Per gram. mes ;
Q. Mr. Acker, f think you heard Mr. Morrisson, counsel *
.
°
: for ‘AEC, state yesterday that the price per gram of
plutoninm which the AKC will pay to licensees:who produce
it beginning July 1,°1962, will be $12. 7
Mr. Chytor: b object, your Honor. That is an
incorrect statement, I believe,
Mr. Sigal: T thought that is what was said. -Tf-
that is not correct, let me read to you, Mr. Acker,
the release issued by AEC on this subject dated No-
vember 18, 1956; ;
The Witness: Yes.
3g
637
By Mr. Sigal::
re, “The Atomic Energy. Commission. has estab- —
lished guaranteed fair prices to be paid for plu-
_tonium and Uranium 233 produced in atomic re-
~ actors operated under license-in the United States
and delivered to the Commission for the one-year ;
_ period beginning July 1, 1962.
“The prices ate, for plutonium metal, $12 per.
a gram. For Uranium 233 nitrate, $15 per gram of
> U- a8.
s
‘ : a
ce °c 638 |
- [638] age
‘These prices are ome on the ‘éstimated -fuel
value of the materidJs and are identical with those
* .* to be. paid fo; these products of reactors abroad
- fueled with material supplied by the United States.’’
we “A. Yes. :
& Mr. Sigal:. I ‘pid like to call Mr.: Claytor’ s°
‘ attention to the language Mr. Morrisson used yester-
day if he still has any question about it, on page E
600 of the transcript: .
‘“‘There is a further. unclassified price of $12 a
gram which has been guaranteed from June 30, 1962
to June 30, 1963.’’
Mr. Claytor: That is right. “I thinkayou said
_ after 1962. I got the. impression that applies to the
‘rest of the period.
Mr. Sigal: I had no such intention. :
Mr. Claytor: Wery well. It is correct now, any-
; way. 9 .
Mr. Morrisson: “} think we should clarify the
gn* me,
40°" -
ra
bd
so Pah aay oni JIE ee eee
- °
Ce ene
on which these figures are
ae oie oS ll
| .
é , se ae A
record in one ‘other respect, Mr. -Examiner, Mr.
Sigal’s statement was that I said that the $12 price,
Was the price which the (dmmission would pay.
That is not what I said. T said that is a price which
has been guaranteed. i
. The Presiding Officer: noticed that; yes,
Mr. Sigal: | greatly appreciate the correction. T
‘think that is very illuminating. | think the ap-
propriate — 8
.
~ [639]
argument will come at a‘later date as’ to what the
‘significance of the difference is, -
By Mr. Sigal: =
Q. PRD presumably Was aware of this release at the
.time it was made, would you not say, Mr. Acker? That
is, November 18,1956? -A. Yes. We have a copy of it.
°Q. You have a copy of it? A. Yes, ,
Q. You stated céarlicr that jthe Exhibit XXIX which
gives the estimates of income for the operating period was
prepared in the latter part of December, 1956: is that
right? It is dated December. 31, 1956. A. That is right.
But in all fairness, Mr. Sigal, we have been making studies
“
7“
based for some period before
that time,a matter of months. So that some of the figures
reflect considerations which were determined a long time
prior to December 1956. e
Q.> You mean that the considerations that you had in
mind in December 1956 did not include the announced
price, or this announcement of AEC in November 1956?
A. They took that into consideration; ves.
5 a |
a a
. 2
Y
639 =
*Q. In so far aS any calculations for the year beginning
July 1, 1962 are concerned, they presumably took into con-
- sideration this announcement of AEC, did they not?
; [640]
A: They certainly did.
Q. And furthermore, with respect to any calculations
for the years thereafter, they took into consideration this
announcement of the AEC? ‘A. They took into considera-
tion, Mr. Sigal, evérything that we knew. at that. time.
. Q. Everything that. you knew in pretest of 1956?
A. —* is. right.
‘ ¢
« (690)
Q. And at the present time vou have no commitments
of any kind from your member companies or banks for the
contribution or loans in.exeess of the amounts which have
previously been- testified to, is that — A. That is
— .
s € *
_ Cross Examination by Mr. Maslowski
[707] . | *
Q. There has been,a considerable amount of discussion
in so far as the loan guarantee is concerned, dnd in so far
as this assistance is concerned that the members of APDA .
may be giving PRDC. Were there any special reasons for
"this kind of a setup? “A. Do you mean with the two dif-
ferent organizations?
42
LNs rey
al te ei Sn ne >
729
Q. Yes. A. . Yes.” The APDA group was a group in--
terested) primarily oe Ber
[708]
in research and development, and the ereation of a con-
ceptual design and study of the whole problem of, the ap-
plication of nuclear fission to the production of electricity, .
or heat that could be used for the production of electricity. |
Th®LRDC group represents such members of APDA, with
‘several. others added, who were interested in carrying the
research and development work on from that point, and
actually putting up their money to construct a demonstra:
‘tion reactor plant. It just represents a difference in the
particular interests of the members of each group, bearing
in mind that there are a number of companies that are
common to both.
* s+ &
.
“
Cross Examination by Mr, Morrisson
| [729] |
Q. As. I understand your testimony, of the other day,
Mr. Acker, you indicated that the contingencies in general
are not intended to.cover design changes. Is this correct?
A: That is my understanding, == os
Q. What provision, then, have you made to cover the
cost of possible alterations in the designs of the reactor
*
plant? A. To cover the alterations, the cost of the re-
‘ design, or of the equipment that might have to be sub-
stituted for something already purchased? |
(). Let’s cover it both ways. First of all, the possibility
“729
that design changes may be be made prior to the time the
equipment is ordered, which increases its cost; secondly,
the possibility that design changes may. be made after
equipment has been obtained so that it is necessary to
_ serap that equipment and substitute something else.. A.
We have discussed before in this proceeding the
| [730]
$5 million allowance that{we have in the PRDC over-all
cost estimate for research and development work. I would
think that design changes would be covered by that item.
You will remember that there i is an aggregate of $142 ,000 of
~ eontraets allocated to that ttem to date. In addition, the
amount at which we have the test equipment and devices
to be received from APIA, included in our cost .estimate
‘the approximately $4.1 million, whereas, in our financial
. figures, we have taken that in at only $3 million. So the
difference would be available in our resources to take care
.of equipment changes. I would. think that the $5 million
would be available for design, and approximately $1 mil-
lion would be. available for changes in equipment. If either
ot both items were not sufficient to take care of modifica-
tion of plant equipment, we would expect.that our member
companies: would’ be glad to put up whatever additional
amount were required. There are, however, no’ commit-
ments on their part to do so.
a: want to come back to that in a moment., Let | me
ask you this: Is the $5 million intended as a provision
for increased procurement costs that might result from
design changes, or increase in construction cost? A. No,
it is not. It could be, if there were any available, but
——
44
731
that is not the intent of the item in the ceatiiliinds esti-
mate. “It is for research and development, re- design, any-
thing of that ‘kind.
shed [731] =
on]
Q. And there are a nimber of. -at least, possibilities in
which additional research and development might he found.
necessary? A. That is right.
Q. Let me‘ inquire a little more about this $1 million
item which, as T unde ‘rstand, is the difference between the |
#4.1 million, ‘in Which there is ineluded in the construction
estimate the cost of those components w hich APDA will
procure, and the $3 million which is charged as APDA’s
contribution to the project. Tsthat a correct explanation?
A. Right. : ;
Q. Exhibit XXTI to the license application, or suppose
eall it license Exhibit XXI—~
The, Presiding Officer: To distinguish it from
Acker?
Mr. Morrisson: Yes.
By Mr. Morrisson:
Q. That is the agreement between PRDC ant APDA?
A. That is right.
Q. Article 1-B of that agreement states, does it not,
that the equipment and devices referred to in that article
will be transferred on a where-is, as-is basis, and APDA
will be compensated therefor on the basis of the’ salvage
value of such equipment .and devices as determined by
agreement. Is not this $1.1 million. then, an amountyw hich
PRDC | ie.
ae
\
BE)
‘
732
[732]
is obligated ito pay to APIA in compensation for the equip-
ment and devices which APDA will transfer? A. No. In
connection gvith the salvage value, discussions between _
- APDA and#RDC fix the basis on which the salvage value
will be caleulated, and it. has “been _agreed—that-it would,
—be-the sérap value of the metal involved in the APDA
test facilities and devices. Based on calculations as to the
quantities of various classes of ‘metal involved and the
serap_ values of’ such metals, the salvage value, for purpose
of calculation at, this time, is indicated at about $55,000.
Q. Where does that appear in the cost of construction
that PRDC would pay? A. I don't think it appears, Mr.
Morrisson. .
Q. This is not a final agreement as to the salvage value,
but it is the present basis of the discussion? A. That is
* our estimate of what it would be at this time, that is right.
Q. Then is not the actual contribution made by, APDA
to this project, that is, in addition to the $4 million which
it is to put up for research and development, is not its ac-
tual contribution the difference between $4.1 million, which
it will pay for these components, and the $55,000 which
it will receive for tham? A. I would say that-was a a fair
statement.
Q. This is the amount that APDA will “ out-of- pedhiet
in connection with its participation in the construction
: [733]
of this component test facility? . A. Yes. . If its costs are
in accordance with our estimates and our own cost, estimate.
46
ee
PUN oR Lentils
.
isis teeth
*«
. 762
[761]
QQ. Has the management of PRDO considercd the magni
tude and cost, of these possible changes and made any. de-
‘terminations as to w hether the financial ar rangements w hich
they_have made will be adequate to take care of thissort of
change? A. Tam really glad to have ihe opportunity to
clarify our position on that matter, Mr. Morrisson. | he-
lieve I testified previously in answer to Mr. Sigal’s question -
somewhat along the same, Tine to the effeet that Ww hen we
were
(762)
faced with whatever #ecommendations we might have from
Dr. Bethe in particular it would be a management decision
at the time depending on the circumstances. Twas thinking
as the chairman of. the finance committee of PRDC at that
time principally in the financial concept. So far as the
safety ‘features of this reactér are concerned, it is the
full intent of the manageme nt of PRDC to accept and
abide by the recommendations of its consultants, its nuclear
experts in this fieled-sand in particular and specifically, if
you will, Dr. Bethe. I can not conceive that the manage.
_ ment of PREC would go forward with this project if there
were any question by thetr own consultants as to the safety
of the reactor, and of course it is ébyious that the reactor
can not. be’ operated Without’ a license, from the AEC » and
wit is my understanding that they, teo, have tobe satisfied
as to thé safety 6f the reactor.
As aguinst the possibility of éhanges having*to be ‘elie
in connection with the recommendations of our consultants,
| will say that we do not have the complete financial situd-
tion that we might be faeed with covered. by firm commit-
47
se oe eeeges
\ Be :
ments at this time, but | express my own opinion, as a re-
sult of discussions with my associates in this project, that
haying gone forward to the extent that we have in finaneing
this project and with the interest that we have in its comple-
tion, 1 have every confidence that these companies will put
up the additional funds necessary to take care. of whatever
©
adjustments,
[763]
- changes, modifications are required.
Q. You say this is your opinion’ based on diseussions
with your associates. Has this matter specifically been
diseussed with the member companies? A. We have had ,
many discussions, Mr. Mérrisson, as to the future possibili-
ties in connection. with modifications and changes of this -
reactor plant.
[778]
Q. This comes to a question I was going te take up with
' you anyhow. On the table that shows the caleulation of
‘steam revenue you have shown an increase in net, plant’
capability starting from about 103,000 kilowatts in 1961 and |
increasing to 155,000 in 1966, and subsequent years? ee
Right.
Q. This corresponds, I take it, to a similar ineresase
in the table entitled ‘Calculation of Plutonium Reserves,”’
it says here, but I think that should be “Revenue”’, should
it not? A. Where-is that reference?
Q. There is a small sheet as part of Acker fixhibit No.
10 entitled ‘‘Caleulation of «Plutonium Reserves.’’ I be-
lieve the word should be ‘*Revenue’’ rather than ‘*Re- -
48
ED! Bath Wal RL, eee eet Menai fo toy
779
"serves.’’ These pages are not numbe red ed can t identity
it more directly than that.
That show’ an increase in reactor power level. expressed
in megawatts of heat running from 300 in 1960 up- to o-
by 1966, and subsequer, years. me
| (779)
A. That ix true, Mr. Morrisson. [ would like to eall at-
tention to the fact that quantities of plutonium produced
are omitted from this exhibit in as much as they would
lead to possible calculations from which the price schedule
‘for the plutonium could be derived Again the assump-
tion on which we have based, our’ plutonium revenues is
that the eurrent’ classified schedule will continue in effect
throughout the operating period.
Q. I was asking you at the: moment only about the re-
~ actor power level and the‘change in that power level which
is shown on these two exhibits. A. I would like jus: to
clarify what I said a little further, and that is that my
understanding i is that the present price, schedule for ‘pluton-
ium provides for different prices for different qualities of
plutonium. The price announéed for the period beginning
June 1, I think it is, or July 1, 1962 through July 4, 1963,.
is published as a base price, and our plutonium revenue
figures are based. on’ the assumption that-there would be
different prices available during that year and thereafter
for different qualities.of plutonium.
The _Presiding Officer: Should that pre ibit be cor-
rected so the word ““reserve’’ is changed to ‘‘re-
venue’’?
Mr. Claytor: TI think we should note on the rec-
ord that the heading of the sheet entitled “*Caleula-
49.
779
tion of Plutonium Reserve’? in Acker Exhibit No.
10 for identification
' [780]
should read. ‘*¢ ‘aletilation of Plutonium Baw rnay >
not ‘*Calculation of Plutonium Réserve.’’
‘The Presiding Officer: Very well, the amendaient
may be made.
Mr. Morrissgns. Thank you. ai
< .
* * *
[781]
Q. Does this manning table cover the personnel. re- \’
quirements for the entire, plant which will be operated
by PRDC? Let me clarify my. question. In APDA 115
which is in
e
F782]
the record as-an exhibit to the lieense ‘application—
Mr. Claytor:: Exhibit X-A to the License applica-—
tion, =
Mr. Morrisson: On vage 106 there is a plot plan
of the plant which shows various structures, the re-
actor: building itself, the steam generator house, ‘the
central house for electrical equipment, the sodium |
and gas building, the service building, a building i
for decay storage, a sewage plant, holdup tanks for
waste disposal, railroad tracks and various other
things of that kind. This manning table rep-
resents, does it, the personnel force. required to
maintain and operate all of these buildings and the
associated grounds? *
50
CEPA Natt
i tal? Moe Was oe aotnie
4
Nii cee bas ek 4
Phat j is right. .
783
A. That is true.: |
Q. If you will come back.to the figures on-steam and
plutonium revenue, on the steam revenue figure you have
projected here an availability factor which starts at 40 per.
cent and rises.ultimately to 80 per cent. A. That is right.
Q. How does this compare with a plant availability fac-
tor on a new conventional generating plant?” A. It would
depend greatly, of course, on the use to which the plant
was put, whether it was a base load plant-or was "being used
as a peak load carrier.
Q. Let us assume a base load plant. A. On the average
I.would say that the ——
o.
[783]
factor’ might be considerably (Mader for: a canventional-:
steam plant, than the ultimate figure of 80 per cent which °
we have projected. an
_Q. Higher than the ultimate hai of 80 per cent? A.
Q. In the initial years what sort of availability figure
would yon assume on_a conventional plant? A. It would
be very much higher if you could fit it in to the base load of
the company.
~Q. Assuming you could-use the power? A. Yes.
Q. In your situation here Detroit Edison is obligated,
is it not, to buy whatever steam the plant produces whether
or not Detroit Edison can ‘use that steam? <A. That is
right. . an \
Q. So there is no siabiioin: of fitting it. into a. load, the
plant will sell whatever stearn it can produce? As That is
right. ,
Q. This factor is therefore a factor which reflects your
Ay
~ 783
judgment-as td what is new a reasonable estimate of what
- the plant can produce? A. That is right, and one factof of
the rate paid by Detroit Edison takes into account the
availability of the plant.
Q. This is quite an uncertain item, is it not, at the
[784]
_present stage. of development of the plamt? A. Yes, itvis.
Q. In other words, the actual availability could be
substantially higher than you have ‘shown here? A. It
could be higher or lower. A
‘Q. Orit could be lower? A. That is correct.
Q. I note that the steam agreement, which is one of the -
exhibits to the license application here, Exhibit XXV on
page 11, in paragraph numbered D, states that ‘‘In view
_ of the experimental nature of the project of the company
- extended shutdowns of reactor plant may be required in
addition to regularly scheduled shutdowns for nuclear
material loading and for maintenance.’
Have you taken that possibility into account in project-
ing this availability factor of the plant? A. We have to
the extent that they can be taken into account with the.
knowledge that we presently have before us, Mr. Morrisson.
Q. Is it your assumption that these shutdowns are more
likely to occur, in the early period than in the later period
of‘operation? A. I would think so, or during the oom
period of operation.
Q. This is perhaps a detail. but just as a matter of —
[785]
interest wliy is it that the availahility factor is shown at a
lower figure in 1967 than in 19662 A. That is because of
52
uw
ee
e 786
2 ; . et ‘ ; _
allowance being made for scheduled shutdown for a part -
of that vear.
| Q. A scheduled shutdown for what purpose? A. For
general overhaul and maintenance.-~
Q. Isee. Is that the only such general scheduled shut-
«down that you have allowed for or are there others? A.
I can not say in detail, Mr. Morrisson, but I would say. thaf
there is provision in these assumptions of availability factor
for incidental shutdowns from time to time. This is a
scheduled proposed shutdown. =
Q. Now if you will turn to the table entitled ‘‘Caleula-
tion of Plutonium Revenue” you have testified, have you.
not, that these revennes are based onthe assumption that .
certain prices Which have been gyaranteed for a limited
period of yeas will continue applicable throughout the
operating period of this. reactor? A. ‘That is right, Mr.
Morrisson. aes at )
Q. This is only an assumption, is it not ? A. That isa
pure assumption. ae
© Q. So the actual revenue figures could differ substantial-
ly from those shown on this chart, depending on whether
that assumption turns out-to be valid? -A. : That is trite.
[786]
' Q. These figures are also based on certain assumptions
as to plutonium production, and you have explained that
the detail figures on plutonium production ¢an not be
given here. A. That is right.
Q. My question, however, is, given the present state of
knowledge about the reactor, do you believe it is possible
to estimate now with a high degree of reliability what the -
quantities of plutonium produetion willbe. or is this also
53
786 ees } ne
&
tainty? A. No, Mr. Morrisson, am advised by our staff
and consultants that on the basis of specific assumptions as_
to power Jevéls, and so forth, the production of plutonium
ean be accurately estimated. oes,
Q. But this does depepd upon specific assumptions as to
power? A. That issright.
Q. This reactor has not yet ‘been built. Can Vou say
With assurance that it will achieve 100 electrical kilowatts of
power equivalent or that it will not achieve more than 150?
A. No, I-don’t think that I can say that specifically for
myself. Any statements made,.any assumptions made, are
sbased on theoretical calculations of our staff and con-
sultants. ° |
_ (787)
Q. In ,other eet these sniamiitiens are based on
the best-information available to you at the present time?
A. That,is right. te,!
Q. But any projection as to the physical fact with re
spect to. the operation of @his reactor in terms of the
power it will achieve, the quantities of plutonium it will
produce, the quantities of steam it wi!! produce, are all
merely estimates at this point based on the projected
operation of a plant Mees has not yet been built? A.
7s aint é
\
‘
\ Q. Besides which there is not much operating experi-
ence of this character? A. I believe you could say, Mr.
Morrisson, if the assumptions are sound, the results can be
accurately caleulatéd. — , rah De
Q. Yes, I understand. that. The same observation
may ‘be true with respect to the quantities of material
4
‘a factor which is subject to a considerable range of uncer- /
+
788
whieh will have to be submitted for chemical processing
and thergfore the cost of chemical frocessing@is it not?
A. Yes, that is very true. :
Q. Gan you tell me whether the data on whieh this
table was based assume a reloading cyele under which the
plant will be shut down for reloading once a week of wheth-
er they assume a change in. that reloading cycle?’ A. I
am not competent. to testify as to the projected
ae {788]
reloading eycle, -Mr. Morrisson.
Q. Who would be competent on that? “A. Mr. Amorosi:; -
Q. Then if I ean summarize.a little bit the pieture on
the operating side we have identified a number of kinds
a uncertainties with respect, to the operating costs and *<
revenues of the plant, and when I use the word ‘‘uncertain-
ty’’, Mr. Acker, I don’t use it in any critical sense. I am®
inate trying to point out that in the state of our knowledge,
with this being frankly an experimental plant it simply is
not humanly possible to project these costs and revenues.
With the degree of assufance that one ‘might have with a
conventional ‘plait. Isn’t that so? A. That is certainly
true. The very reason for the construction and proposed
operation of this plant; Mr. ener is to remove these
uncertairities. e
Q. Your purpose in building the tain is to find pany
What these, figures will be? A. Exactly.
Q). That is right. We have identified a number of fac-
tors of this kind as to which, while you have estimates
which you believe to be as valid as you can make them,
there. are elements of uneertainty. Perhaps we could clas-
sify those into two types. One type. concerns the physical ©
e
Dd
788
facts of operation of the plant, what power loads will be |
achieved, what bur nup
+) [789] | i
a
it will-achieve, what quantities of plutonium ‘it will pro-
duce, what quantities of material will have to be proc-
essed chemically, and the like. This is one area where
there are sume uncertainties. -A.. That is very true.
®.. Another area to which we have reférred voncerns
the prices which you will be charged or will, pay for cér-
tain of these things, including the price for plutonium
which is guaranteed for a limitéd period, including also,
I believe—and correct me if I am wrong—the cost for
chemical processing as'to which you have a preposal cov-
ering the period up to 1967, I believe. A. That. is right.
Q. And incidentally, that proposal itself indicates that
there may he some adjustments, does it not? A. That is
right. . ,;
Q.: Finally, there are use charges which are " computed
on the basis of a Commission price for uranium which
also is not. a guaranteed price throughout the period of
operation? A. That is.true.
Q. Perhaps ‘when I was. talking about the physical
facts I might have mentioned also the manpower require-
ments, ‘some of which also will have to be firmed up fol-
lowing the submission of more detailed information on
some of the oper ating pr ocedures of the plant.
[790] ; a
_ That is right. ‘
Q. “So there are these kinds of areas as to which pre-
cise prediction is diffieult at t the present time? A. That
Js very true.
G6
Sgt ABR. Wa ite olf iicinaceat AY 7 oy decease picts & be
. A 791
Q. What you have attempted to de, as I understand
this, is to give your best estimate based on present in-
formation, recognizing that the actual outcome might be
very different, that it might be more favorable or less
favorable? A. That is perfectly true. We are up against
_the same thing that we would be up against at the start
ov beginning of any commercial enterprise. The areas of
uncertainty here are greater, however.
~@ * eh
Q. Has dave been diggussion by the management of
PRDC or with the member companies as to what your
siuation would be during the operating period should '
you fail to receive the revenue which you have projected
on the schedules or should your costs exceed those which
have been projected on these schedules? A. There has
heen no specific discussion to that effect. : ;
(). Has there been reeegnition of the possibility that
[791]
conditions could be such that the ‘operation of the plant
would result.in a net cash deficit? A.- Oh, yes.
Mr. Sigal: Mr. Examiner, I think there is a
limit to the extent to-which this kind of question
should go. Mr. Acker said in response to the pre-
vious question there hed been no discussions. That
“seems, ta mie to settle that question. Now Mr.
Morrisson goes on and asks for recognition, What
does that mean? The look in somebody’s eye?
There have been a lot of questions like this ‘by Mr.
; Morrisson indicating the kind of answers that are
* desired, and it is-no satisfactory explanation ‘to say
that this is cross examination.
7
791
Mr. Morrisson: Mr. Examiner, I have asked my
question and it has been answered. I don’t think
there is a question outstanding unanswered.
The Presiding Officer: Very well. You may pro-
ceed, Mr. Morrisson: » a
By Mr., Morrisson:
Q. Have you computed, Mr. Acker, the values of the
inventory of source and. special nuclear material which
will be in the possession of PRDC or under its custody and
control during the operating period? A. Yes, those fig-
ures are available. © - Se oes
Q. I don't think they appear on any of these exhibits,
although [| think they can be determined by computation
from
ar ae
the figures which You have given for either the use charge
_ or the value of its waiver? A. I think you are right, Mr.
Morrisson. 1 think they appear for the years during which
the use charge would be applicable assuming that the
waiver, of the use charge would be made. | a
Q. I think you gave a quantity in kilograms but not
a value. -Let me get it at this way: It is my’ understand-
ing that the value of the inventory during most of .the |
operating period from 1961 on would range somewhere
between 16 and 18 million dollars.. A. I believe that is
correct. 4
Q. Is that substantially correct? A. Yes,
Q.- What provision have you made or do you antici-
pate making to reimburse the Atomie Knergy Commis-
« sion in the event that this inventory or part of it were .
destroyed or rendered unusable? A. IT can’t say that any
3
aS
ad AE Rie Se Le
TES HIN
Alpe
ee Can ne Ona
.
793
a
_ Specifie provision has been made, but I would like to call
attention to the fact that some of the member companies —
of PRDC have guaranteed the bank joan of $15 million.
If there were.financial obligations of PRDC which would
not permit it to take care, of all of its operating costs,
such costs as you indicate and also service its debt, the
member companies would be ealled |
[793]
upon to make good on such guarantees. So in effect we.
-have a reserve of $15 million for contingencies not. re-
flected in these figures which could be used as against any.
additional ecsts that are not reflected here. .
In other words, if our operating expenses were so much
highér than are ‘indicated here or some other element of
“cost such as you suggest entered into our operating cost |
we would be in the position of possibly not being able to
take care of the repaying of our debt.’ In that event we
conld call upon our member companies to take care of the
repayment of the debt, and to the extent that we have
provided for it in these estimates such funds would be
available to meet other- operating costs. ;
Q. You will be paving off. principal on the long-term
bank foans, will you not, at the rate of. $2 million a year
beginning with 1964? ‘A. .That is right, and I think it is’
a higher figure in the last year. | ;
Q. With a higher figure the last year,that is right. -
\° the exte1t that that principal is paid off the member
‘ompanies will have been relieved of the obligation under —
their guarantee? A. That is right. . 2 aes
Q. So by the beginning of 1970 their aggregate obliga-
tion will be only $3°million and not $15 million?
59
794
[794]
A. Yes. That is a very excellent point. Tt is a decreas-
ing reserve, in other words, Mr. Morrisson.
Q. T again ask vou, sir, supposing something. untoward
should happen which resulted in the’ destruction or in
rendgring unusable this inventory of special nuclear ma-
terial in the vear 1970; what provision vould be made to °
take care of the obligation to the Commission. for the,
charge for this loss of material? A. T can not say at this °
time, Mr. Morrisson. That is something I would like to
discuss with my associates. I think it is a condition we
would have to meet at the time, depending upon the cir- :
cumstances at the time. a. |
Q. You are aware, are you not, that one of the Com-
mi:sion charges for special nuclear material under See-
tion 70.23 of the regulations is a charge for the use, con-
‘sumption or loss of the material? A. Yes Ro I under-
stand. .
— Q. So as the testimony stans at present yeu do not
know what provision the company has made to mect this.
charge should it arise? A: Not in the event of the loss
. or destruetion of a substantia] portion of the inventory.
ul
*
[826]
By Mr. Morrisson:
Q. Mr. Acker, I would like to come back ence again
“to the question which we’ were discussing hefore as to
the possibilities that might arise here either that the con-
struction estimates will,be exceeded or that the operating
A G0
a
epee eater wie}
ase teeta
GUERIS RD WE Al i A RIDE AM Miah oe Mig
—
- there ate possibilities.
_ a 827
“ . 2
- ‘ o
situation will be less favorable than it jiias been shown
/ . . . . » =~
» be on these ¥arious exhibits which have been sub-
mitted] think we agreed that there are some possibilis
ties that-either of these events might oeeur, A.- TI think
—
-Q. Can you tell me as specific ally as you are able to,
What discussions have been had svith the member “com-
_ panies with respeet’ to the possible demands that might be
made on. them for additional: contributions? A. Mr.
Morrissoii; all of the peaple who are. involved in this
project representing their individuab member companies
are corporation executives. They deal. every day with the
possibilities of things that may happen in the future. They
have to project their businesses into the future ‘to deter-
-mine what additional financial support they have to get,
What théir operating results may be, whether they can sup-
port the additional investment which must be made in the
business. We are al! aware of the fact that this is a more
diffieult field in which to prognosticate the future than the
field in which we are ‘doing business. We have many times
discussed the possi- ;
. [827] |
. at
bilities that there may he additional etnande sialie on us,
hut nobody has made any commitment as to w hat he would
do under those cireumstances. That is a contingeney which
We expeet to meet when it arises, and my own personal
conviction is that this group will go forward in support of
this project and see it through to completion.
o ’
.
il
827
Re-cross Examination by.Mr. Sigal ed
_ [sat]
Q.- No, no. T didn’t make my statement clear. I said
that your calculation was based on several assumptions.
I will say your-caleulation was based on several consid-
erations, one of which was the current price-paid for plu-
tonium, a second one of which was this $12 guaranteed
price of January 1, 1962. Do you recall that testimony?
A. I do not, Mr. Sigal. I think whenever I talked about
our, estimates of plutonium ‘revenues IT have always said
: (842) S
that our assumption and our only assumption was that the -
current price schedule which is now: classified would, be
maintained and available to us throughout the entire ten-
year operating period,
[843]
Q. Then please explain your position, Mr. Acker. A.
I have said several times that our assumption was. that
- the present ‘schedule of plutonium prices, classified, would
remain in effect and would be available to us during the
ten-year operating period.
Q. You made that assumption in December 1956? A.
Yes, P : ; :
Q. Although you knew at that.time that AEC had made
an. announcement to the effect that the guaranteed price
* for plutonium after July 1, 1962-wonld be $12 per gram,
is that right? A. That is right, Mr. Sigal.
62
°
ne
850
(). ’ What: reason did yoy have to believe that PRDC
would receive a sum different than the $12 guaranteed
price after July 1, 19622 A. We had no reason to believe
that that ean be demonstrated. That is an assumption,
as T’said originally, that we made.
[849]
(). Did vou ‘discuss With any individual mémber of
PRDC what such member would do in the event the funds
committed or guaranteed for PRDC would not be suffis
cient to meet its expenses?. A. Yes. ] discussed it with
many of them. |
(). Can you name the individuals with whom you dis-
cussed it and the nature of the conversation ? A, I think
‘if vou will. look: at the names of the members, the ¢: astees
of PRDC, that would be my answer.’
(). You discussed it with every one of them?
[850] .
A: I have discussed it with them as a group. Ihave dis-
cussed it with many of them individually,
-Q.- Was there any conclusion drawn on the question of
What they would do in the event there was not enough
money to meet the obligations of PRDC over and above the
contributions and the guarantees? A. None whatsover,
hut I felt it my duty as chairman. of the finaneial commit-
tee, Mr. Sigal, to ‘point out to them this possibility. The
schedules themselves show need for temporary loans,
and they are all on notice that we may ask them to advance
funds to take care of such temporary borrowing.
g0 pins .
Q: But none of them said to you what he would dot
Ps None of them wancand any commitment whatsoever.
HANS A. BETHE — io
[1145]
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal
Q. Dr. Bethe, I cak your attention to the following
colloquy ‘between Mr. Caiimon, Chairman | of the Appro-
priations er and Mr. Strauss, ¢ ‘scoala of AEC,
which appears —
| [1146] :
in the same volume at page 239. A. Yes, I have that.
Q. In order to get the,context, I would like to read Mr.
Cannon's statement first: | |
. ‘‘Let -me ask this. We discussed yesterday in
exhaustive detail the roadblocks and bottlenecks in”
the negotiations in order to get Detroit Edison into
‘construction of this fast breeder reactor. Here is.
another cause for delay, and it was not mentioned to.
us. I cannot understand why it was not mentioned
to the committee when we were discussing these other
causes for delay. Furthermore, we discussed yes-
terday. the danger connected with the possibility of
these plants getting out of control. We discussed
‘that in detail, and still we are not told what was the
cause for failure to approve’ designs of this plant.
© --
64
a ee er Tar wh; este Wittens tid GH
ie Tae | 1147
+
* la
that: we are sO unxious to get along with. W hy was
fhis. not mentioned to us, Mr. Chairman?
“Mr. Strauss: It was. It was stated that this .
fast breeder was the most hazardous of all the
reactors.”’
Do you have any ‘comment on the statement of Mr.
Strauss? Po
Mr. Claytor. | object to a question of. ‘*Do yon
have any comment on a statement’’. ;
The Presiding Officer: I think so, Mr. Sigal. I
will sustain the objection. -
a.
By Mr. Sigal: ae
(). In the light of these statements, Dr. Bethe; . are you
inclined to make. any change in the testimony that you gave
with respect to the hazards of a fast reactor? A. No,I am. —
not inclined to make any changes. I did mention in my
Written testimony various areas in which special investi-
gations are needed for the safety of fast reactors. Similar-
ly the Safeguards Committee letter of June 6 mentions vari-
ous areas. These are essentially identical. .Obviously there
are areas wh.ch require special atteution.: Obviously these.»
areas have to be dealt with, although I have no knowledge
whether this isso, I presume the gentlemen who have made
such comments as you mentioned have in mind that these
various areas have to be cleared up in detail.
e
* * *
KEN NNETH E, FIELDS ae
cs. * * &
2705
[2705]
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. I was going to get to the second point of that.answer,
Mr. Fields. Aside from any published regulations, are there
any kind .of standards, criteria, considerations, published
or unpublished, ‘which the AEC has established to assist
in determining whether or not. an applicant is financially
qualified” to engage in the proposed activities? A. TI have
a problem on that question, on informally. T don’t see
how a standard could be established if it is informal. We
. will use our judgment on the financial qualifications in line
with this particular regulation. Now whether this is in-
‘formal or how you term this, I presume that we will do so
on the basis of this record, using our ‘best judgment and
opinion as it is developed in this hearing, and to set these
matters down as a regulation I doubt whether one could do
this in,too great detail. One will always rely on judgment
in arriving at these findings: and determinations on this
point. : ioe
But in any event, insofar as I know, there are no other
regulations by which we eurre: itly have in hand to make this
determination. _
Q. Then I gather, vou also sale there are no written
criteria, whether in regulation form or otherwise, which
would be applied by the Commission in determining financial
qualifications of applicants.
[2706]
A. I am not aware of any; no.
Q. In regard to section 50.60(C) (2), which I mentioned
66
fb eee ec prea S ei IP UN eee wa Ne a)
ere ' 2743
earlier, that section states that in order to obtain approval
of the Commission of an application, the applicant be finan-
cially qualified to assume respotisibility for the payment of
Commission char: ges for special nuclear material, and to
undertake and carry out the special use of the nucledr
material fer a reasonable time. _
What standards, ‘if any, has AEC established in order
to determine the financial qualifications of an applicant
under this section? A. Here again I believe the answer is
the same. I am not aware of a written, published or other-
wise set: forth standard for judging ‘this. It is again‘a
review of the specific license application and the judgment
issued at the time as.to the qualifications.
Q. When you say at the time, you mean at the time
that the license is issued? Is that what you mean? Or at
the-time the application is considered? A. It may be a
judgment then or when the actual transfer of the material
is to take place ;, yes.
Q. Are you finished with your answert A. Yes, I have
finished.
Q: Then with respect: to the time of the determination,
you say that with respect to the transfer of nuclear ma-
terials,.
[2707]
the détermination will be made and the criteria established
either at the time the application is considered or at the
time the nuclear material is transferred.
s
[2743]
By Mr. Sigal:
Q” Certainly it is true, is it not, that AEC hes not es--
bi
‘
‘
.
2743
“tablished any guaranteed price for plutonium based on its.
fael value for tHe akin after: June 30, 1963. A. That i: is
correct.
-Q. Now, . Mr. F ihn A. “Could I put Rarerese on this
further point to clarify my previous answer?
Q. . Surely. Go ahead. A. I think the record should
' show that this. belief on my part as to where the value of
plutonium may- “go does not rest alone gn any technical
knowledge I have, ‘ef the nuclear fuel processes. Essen-
tially this is not a belive based on any technical qualifica- -
tions I have as a nuclear Scientist or nuclear engineer, but
on the belief that ifat. proves to be of value in nuclear power
plants. that there will be many other: factors that determine
the value in relation to other materials % aswell.
Q. Assume that the record shows, Mr: Fields, that if
PRDC receives only $12 per gram for the plutonium which
it expects to pr oduce i in this reactor it will be many millions. .
of dollars short of the incotne it needs to operate the re- |
actor, does AKC have any criterion applicable to this ,cir-
cumstance for the purpose of determining whether or not
PRDC is financially qualified to operate the reactor?
[2744]
MrMorr isson : sf )bjection.
Mr. Sigal: This is an entirely different matter
‘from what we considered before.
Mr, Mortiseds: It still goes to the question whether
there are any criteria on the issues of financial quali-
fication other than those already set forth in the
published regulations of fhe Commission. That has -
been answered many times.
6S
p>
Pa 6 Si SSR ON naan Wilh Saati a
7
« 2754
Mr. Sigal: I would like to have an answer for the
record, a -
Phe Presiding Officer: : I think he-will testify that
there is no criterion outside of those published in the
Federal Register.
The Witness; That is true:
* . *
[2753]
Q. Is there any agreement or arrangement of any kind
between AEC and PRDC relating to the charges which AEC
will make ‘for the tise of special nuclear materials after
June 30, 19602 A. Just a m. aute. The charges we will
make to PRDC for the use of special nuclear material?
Q. Specifically for the uranium which you will deliver to
PRDC. A. There is a provision in the contract that waives
the use charge for five years, I believe, of the operation *
the plant, after a license is issued to operate.
You are perhaps not referring to this?
[2754]
Q. I want to make it eléar. I am _ asking now. ia the ,
period after the period of the waiver. A.” Icknow of no
agreement for anything beyond what is in me contract on
' that waiver provision.
Q. _The contract makes a provision for ” waiver of |
use charges? A. ‘Fea.
Q. For the first five years after the license is granted? ,
A, Yes,
. mt -
4
ape ne
2754
C. ROGERS McCULLOUGH
_ + (2999) .
a |
Cross Examination.by Mr. Morrisson
Q. Dr. McCullough, there has been a great deal of dis-
“eussion in this proceeding about. the whole problem of
evaluation of reactor hazards, the special techniques. and
‘special problems which have beer presented by such evalua-
tion.
I would like to inelpde in the record a statement of your. ;
general views on these questions of hazard évaluations,
and for that purpose I would like you to look at the tran-
script of the hearings before the Joint Committee on Atomic
Energy on Governmental Indemnity for Private Licensees
and AEC Contractors Against Reactor Hazards, at pages
47 and 48, the passage that I have marked, and ask you if
you still agree with the views expressed in that passage?
ene [000
Mr. Morrisson: If he says that he does, Mr. Ex-
aminer, then I would like to have that passage read
into the record as a portion of Dr. McCullough’s tes-
timony, rather than take the time of asking specific
questions addressed to this point, “because I think it
well expresses the point I am trying to get: at.
The Presiding Officer: Very well.
Mr. Morrisson: For reference, { am starting at
the middle of page 47 and carrying through to the
second full paragraph on page 48,
70)
one.
Se Tie, ee
* 3001
The. Witness: Do you wakli me ‘to read this to
myself? se
The Presiding Officer: Yes, sir.
Mr. Morrisson: Just to be sure that you concur
‘now in the views ‘expressed in that passage,
The Witness: I aecept this. .
The Presiding Officer: Let Mr. Maslowski see
it, please.
In order to save time, the statement. may be in- ,
corporated in the record at this point, if that is
agreeable with you, Mr. Morrisson.
Mr. Morrisson: Yes, Mr. Examiner.
(The information referred to is as follows:) |
Dr. Me Cullough: I think this is the right atti-
‘tude, sir.
[3001]
‘Care must-be taken to insure that there is a low
probability of: accidents with nuclear reactors be-
cause these machines sfore fission products. I think :
it is worth reiterating that these products are more
toxie per unit weight thah- any other industrially
known materials by a factor of a million to a billidn.
‘It depends on what standards you take. If these
materials should be permitted -to escape there is
a-possible hazard to large numbers of people and
many square miles of territory.
«‘*Because of this possibility of a major denies,’
even though i it has a low probability, it is justifiable
to take unysual precautions that the design, construc-
tion, and operation are sufficiently conservative.
“*T think it is worth while. pointing out that for
=~
ai
3001
oe
the first time in-any major industrial development
an attempt is being made to foresee: the possible acci-
dents or disasters, and to take positive steps to .
prevent them. The introduction of this new philoso-
phy poses difficult problems. But because of the po-
tential hazard to people, and even future genera-
- tions, it is Imperative to face and solve these prob-
lems... °
‘‘Tt should be made clear:that the hazards associ-“
ated with nuclear reactors or any other peaceful ap- .
_ plication of atomic energy are related to the highly
~ toxie
13002]
radioactive materials which are generated.
‘These facilities that we are talking about. do not
have an explosion hazard in the sense of a possible
detonation which would devastate large areas by
blast or heat effect. :
‘‘The nuclear reaction is an extremely dynamic
one. A nuclear reactor can increase in power level
thousfinds of times in a fraction of a second if. it is
improperly designed and controlled. There is ‘no
other machine that I am aware of that has this
possibility of such sudden changes in energy ‘out-
put. 6 oy
‘*As a result, fuel elements, control elements, and
the structure.-of the reactor itself can be melted
or even vaporized if a nuclear runaway accident
-should happen. By the proper careful design and
the inclusion of ‘reliable controls and safety devices,
‘
3278
it is believed that nuclear runaways can be prevent-
ed or, at least, reduced to a very low probability.
‘‘Qne must recognize that the best known devices
a
are not infallible. Even such well-known things as
railroad rails break, turbine shafts shatter, trolley
wheels come off and locomotive braking systems fail.
One must admit that thete is always a possibility
that a reactor accident ean occur.
‘The dynamics of a nuclear reactor are such that
[3003]
if a nuclear runaway is once started no human being
can respond rapidly enough to stop it. However, re- .
actors can be designed to be self-limiting. Precau-
tions in maintenance and operation can be taken.
The reactor thus can be prevented, in all probability,
from ever starting a nuclear runaway.”? s
MARK MILLS
[3278] :
Q..
~ Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal:
Do you see anything urgent so far as either the nu-
clear aspects are eoncerned or the social aspects are con-
cerned that this schedule be adhered to. A.- I have a feel-
. Ing this is really outside of my competence, but let me an-
swer a little bit indirectly. Practically all advanced tech.
‘nological developments take’place with a sort of combined
.
mr ey
3278 3 EAs oe
construction and research and development pe necessary
dovetailing of these things and it seems to me that just
how this is done really pretty mueh, has to be left up to the
people doing it. They are the ones who can see the best
‘ways to schedule different parts of the job in view of de-
velopment information they see coming along that will in-
fluence, in view of the fact*some parts of it are not sensi-
tive to the kinds of information that.they believe is likely to
be developed and pertinent and so on. |
[3285]
* Mr. Morrisson: Mr. Radley, will. you take the,
stand, please.
H. MONROE RADLEY was called as a witness and hav-
ing been first duly sworn, was examined and testified as -
‘follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Morrisson
Q. Will you state your name and address for the ree-
ord? A. H. Monroe Radley, 3701 R Street, N. W., Wash-
ington, Dd. ¢.
; Q. Are you the H. Monroe Radley. who auieaeks narra-
' tive testimony consisting of nine pages which was recent-
lv filed in the proceeding? A. I am.
Q. Mr. Radley, will you look at page 2 of that testimony
on the first line. -It states ‘‘From 1942 to 1948 I was an
engineer’? and so forth. Are those dates correct? A.
That should be 1943.
Q. 1943 to 1948? A. That is correct.
Mr. Morrisson: Mr. Examiner, the date- was |
74 ;
a Se
ee ee
—~, -
a:
3287
»
‘
changed in ink on the copy that was filed with the
| reporter this —
[3286] _
morning. T neglected to call attention to it at that
time,
The Presiding Officer Perfeetly all right. -
Mr. Morrisson: That i is all [ have. “
The Presiding Officer: Ver y well. Mr: Sigal, you
- may cross examine.
Se
Cross Examination by Mr. Sigal
Qy. Mr. Radley *, On page 6 of your statement, you say
that PRDC appears to you to have under estimated the
cost of on site labor’ A. Yes, that is true.
Q. You give your reasons for your conefusion. Can
you give us some statement ‘of the order of magnitude
of the under estimation of that labor cost? A. I think that |
_ is. where a considerable pertion of the overrun is found.
. The present estimate of on site labor is about $3
million, isn’t it? A. I believe it is $5 million.
Q. lam sorry, ves. A. $5,235.000.
Q. In your view it is an under estimate by some sub-
stantial figure? A. Yes.
\. Ts it two million, three million?
[3287] 7
A. Lam not prepared to say the exact amount.
« Q. But nevertheless it is substantial with reference
to the total amount of the estimate of on site labor. <A.
Yes, that is true. :
3287
Q. And you point. out that your conclusion is based
on the ratio of on site labor to total labor cost as shown
by the construction of similar projects by AEC. How many |
projects are you familiar with in the AEC program? A.
You mean reactor projects? /
Q. Yes. A.) I have all construction program.
Q. I-see. In so far as the rest of your entire. experience
with AEC is concerned, both general construction and con-
- struction of reactors, what does: your experience show with
reference tothe ratio of on site labor cost to ‘total con-
struction cost? A. Let me put it this way. Here we have
‘a ratio of $18,233, 000 for ‘material and $5,235,000 for | For.
Usually the labor portion will run much ‘higher than that °
on projects of this typee
Q. You have a ratio here of say 18 to 5. A. Yes.
‘Q. Can-you give us the ratio that you found to be ©
ihe cas in your construction experience otherwise? A.
Sometimes it runs as high as six to four or
?
[3288]
something like that.
(). That is six for total construction cost to four for on
site labor? A. Yes. This depends on how the accounting
‘is earried on. Different construction firms and’ estimators
carry on accounting in ‘different manners. So that one
can?t be too precise about these ratios.
Mr. Claytor: Excuse me, Mr. Sigal. You said we
were talking about a ratio of six to four, and I
think the record is quite unclear as to whether we
are talking about -six material to four manor.
The Witness: Yes. ;
Mr. Claytor: Or six total to four labor. It was
2
76
Se ere ee Lee ne nay ay ee
i ala a ata Died
7
mem wi e
ie a) ‘
se aa " "3289
used one Way one titne, and. another.
The Witness: Six material to fofir labor.
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. Would you say this ratio of six -to four would be.
most common in your experience with AEC? A. I would |
prefer to say it4s not unusual. <A lot depends, as [ said,
on how the accounting is carried on. 1 really could not say
that there was any real average. _ Es
_ The Presiding Officer: Does-that include-the in-
direct labor, too?, |
‘The Witness: The indirect labor down here is in
item J on this estimate. This is just straight direct
labor cost | 3 .
[3289]
versus material.
By Mr. Sigal:
- Q. You stated oh page -7 that not a sufficient amount
has been allocated to indireet and overhead expenses in
connection with the construction of this project. You point
out that the company. has allocated $3. miliion to cover
these, expenses. .
Can you give us some indication of how much more
than the $3 million would be required for this in your opin-
ion? A. Very often ratios of 20 or 2) per cent are shown
for that item.
-Q. What is the relationship? A. Let me clarify that.
The total labor and material in this case amounts to
$23,468,000. Very often the indirect and overhead costs
will be. show n as 20 per cenit or .25 per cent, something like
that, dgpending on how these things are defined.
ss
YS)
3289
Q. Taking the figure of $23 million as shown here, the
overhead and indirect expenses on the basis of your experi-
ence would run somewhere between four and five. million °
dollars, rather than $3 million? t A. In many estimates it
does.
“Q. You state inthe next paragraph on page 7 that the
silainibiia cost of i it and design — as shown
by
- [3290]
ay company’s ential is $900,000, and you feel that thé
estimate should be st least twice as bigh as.the figure used .
by the company. What do you base your conclusion on? A.
Upon engineering costs that have been reported on, our
projects.
Q. Is there a usual percentage of engineering cost with
relation to total construction cost? A. I quite: often use
“15 per cent.
Q,. Was that based on your experience with government
projects? A. Yes, that is true.
Q. So if that formula were ‘applied in this case, you
would take 15 per cent of $32 million or roughly: $5 million!
' A. The base on which you would apvly the 15 per aent
- would be less than that. You would use the construction
costs. The $32 million inchudes taxes and some other. things
like that. :
Q. So’ what you would relate that to, then, if 3 you ex-
clude the taxes, it would come to about $28 million, would-
n’t.it? A. I would have to add some of these items on
page 5. -I don’t know just what the total would be. One
might say roughly $27 or $28 million. ., Shae
Q. Let us assume it is $28 million. Then the engineer-
Ngee
78
3292
ing cost according to your estimate would be over 4 mil-
lion.
[3291]
A. Using this figure that I-often use, yes.
Q. I say using the figure of 15 per cent. A. Yes, but
I don’t want to say that is my estim ate for this: project.
,Q. You say your estimate for this project is at least
$i 800,000. A. At least $1,800,000, yes.
Q. At: least ‘that. You also say, however, that it is’
common on government projects with which you are famil-
iar to find that the engineering costs run about 15 } per cent
of the actual construction cost.. A. That is true. The
way we carry on our accounting, that is. ‘PRDC may do
it differently and that may not apply to PRDC specifical-
ly. “
The Presiding Officer : How much have they spent.
already? aj
The Witness: I don’t know. Not too much so
far, I don’t believe.
The Presiding Officer: I thought it was more than
$900,000. Is that figure available? .
Mr. Claytor: How much PRDC has aiready. paid
to the architect- engineer?
“The Presiding Officer :” No, how. much they have
spent for the cost of engineering design and ex--
penses. ;
Mr. Claytor: I don’t een that istice ia yet in
[3292]
evidence.
Fo
=
The Presiding Officer: That is the reasen I am -
‘asking the question.
— Mr. Claytor: I don’t believe itis. You mean do
we have it. We certainly don’t have it right here.
The Presiding Officer: Why don’t you dig it out
and let us find out what that figure is, if you will? ©
Apparently, Mr. Claytor, this witness does not know,
but I would like to have the figure in the record.
By Mr. Sigal: ve
@. You point out further on this same page, Mr. Radley,
that the company has estimated its waste disposal system
‘ at a cost of $34,500. Are you in any position to estimate
the cost of a waste disposal system for a reactor of the
PRDC type and size?’ A.. Not in a very good position.
Q. Do you think there is anything in the record justify-
ing the company’s estimate of $34,500? A. I am sure that
is too low.
Q. Whit experience is there available to anybody with
reference to. the cost of waste disposal system for a reactor
—a nuclear reactor? A. You mean a reactor of this type
using sodium? ro =
Q. Of this type or any type. Who.would have the ex-
perience? | “
[3293] |
A. We have experience on water systems.
Q. Does anybody have any experience on sodium sys-
tems? A. I think it is somewhat limited at this date.
Q. Where would that experience be at the present time!
Who would bave it and what would it be based on? A.
There might be a limited amount on the basis—you mean
for projecis of this magnitude?
80
Aitabictid «
3294
Q. Let us start with projects of this magnitude. “A. I
don’t know of any source of information on sodium sys-
tems. Ns | bs
Q. ‘Let us take sodium systems smaller-than the PRDC
reactor. Is there any information available on such reac-
tors? A. 1 think there is perhaps a limited amount on the
EBRI. But I wouldn ‘t think that would be comparable.
Q. Is it correct to say that there is no experience now
available either to AEC or anybody else with respect to
the cost of a waste disposal system for a sodium reactor
using sodium as a coclant? A. By experience, you-mean
actual cost data on one that has been built?
Q. Yes. A. I don’t think there is any cost data on a
system for a’ plant of this size that is available;
Q. So in your opinion PRDC has no basis for that
- _ [3294]
estimate of $34,500? A. I think that was. brought out by
the testimony, wasn’t it? nea |
The Presiding Officer: I think on page 7 he tes-
_ tified it was tco low. ° ;
Mr. Sigal: eHe testified?
The Presiding Officer: Yes, he testified it was too
low. .
Mr. Sigal: I am saying that PRDC has no basis
for its estimate.
“The Witness: 1? think ay eer said in his .
testimony there was really no basis for the esti-
mate.
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. In order that we may get some notion of the magni-
-&-—A
81
3294
" ts c wis 2 e . 2s
_tude.of the cost, can you give us some ‘indication of what
a waste disposal system for a reactor ofthis type costs?
A. For a water system, yes. On the PWR we are spend-
ing- about $3 million. :
Q. $3 million for the pressurized. water reactor? A.
That is a round figure.
Q.. For the disposal system of the shippingport reactor?
A. That is my information. - ; ;
Q. - As far.as you know, is“there any reason to expect
that the cost of a waste disposal system, for the —— re-
. actor woeld be any less?”
>
- [3295]
A. I think se.
Q. To what extent? A. I don’t think, the problem is
perhaps as acute, although T am really not an authority on
waste disposal systems. : ;
Q. But so far as your available experience on the cost
of waste disposal systems is concerned,.you do have this
- information with respeet to the pressurized | w ater reactor?
» A. Yes, I have that.
Q. And that shows $3 million. A.- Roustly. .
Q. Is that system completed acid A. It is under con-
struction.
2>Q. So that $3 edition even n there is an estimate or is that
a fixed figure? A. I think it is a fairly firm estimate.
‘Q. You say on page 8 that the company has allowed
only $17,200 for miscellaneous parts and in your opinion
this should be 20 to 25 times higher. So can we say roughly"
in your opinion the, firure would be around $400,000? A.
_ that. &
Threento | four hundred thousand dollars, something like
32 |
—-.
=
oe
. oe ta
: 3297
Q. Then in the same paragraph you make reference to
~ the $100,000 allowance for plant equipment adjustments,
which should be doubled, and you said this should be
doubled or
FES ae aS Oe eS
tripled, Can you make a choice there? Can we quadruple
it for the sake of variety?’ Av I think the testimony ought :
io.stand the way it is. ewe
Q. You will put it between two and three hundred thou-
sand dollars? A. Yes, something like that.
) Q. Then the next paragraph on the same puge, you say
while it is difficult to point out line items in the estimate
which appear ‘to be out-of line from your experience, you
.. hevertheless point out some of them, which are estimated
_ at too low a figure. Can you be a little more.specifie about
_ the particular items you have mentioned? You:say, for
example, ‘that $30,000 for heating, lighting and ventilation
is too low. What wou!d be nearer to the probability as you
see it?’ A. Ordinarily for buildings of this type, heating, -
lighting and ventilation will run 20 to 30 per cent. I think, .
this particular building will: have to have a fairly costly
ventilation system.
Q. That is 20 to 30 per cent of what? A” Of $428,000
That may be somewhat high, though. eS hg
Let me correct that and say 15 to 20 per cent.
- Q. So that the cost at ‘the minimum: in your opinion
would be around $75,000? is Yes, perhaps.
[3297]
Q. That would be chow 15 per cent. So‘ftar.as the
figure for the element decay and storage building is econ-
§3
be
——
s .
: w
. -
, e 7
A .
: é
ar”
3297 .
cerned, are you satisfied’ with that figure? You did not
mention thit as one of the items which you underestimats va.
But I wonder whether you considered that in connection -
with the other. — ’ . -
f The Presiding Uftieer: What was that magnet
Mr. Sigal: The $4: 28,0100 figure. “ee
The Witness: | Kave no information on the size
of that structure at all. There is a sketeh in APDA
115 and this ¢stiaate, so it PS a little difieult for me
to say much about whether it is too small.
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. The next item mentioned is the cost per eubie yard
for the concrete work around the reactor. Is that item
included in another figure or didn’t you just give any figure
_ for that at all?) A. That is given in Acker Exhibit 7.
Q. Yes, but I mean you don’t state any figure for it.
A. The figure is $57 a cubic yard for the reinforcing steel
and forms... My expe rienee is‘that conerete areund p reac-
tor will cost consicde rably more than that. Several times
that figure... ark y 7
(). Several times $572 A. Yes, dependiig on condi-
tions. | don’t know too much _
[3298]
bout this job as to the details. I just have these sketches.
But it could easily cost $125 or $150 a yard for. this par-
ticular concrete . 7% —
Q. So what does it come to? A. 1 really don’t know.”
I made up no amount for that.
Q. Does the exhibits give the number of eubie yards?
Mr. Claytor: Could t ask if we are talking about
ae 84
ee an
3299
Hem B-l in Acker Exhibit 7, just to be sure which
eenerete it is? : ;
The Witness: Yes, that is the concrete Tam talk-
ing about. Opis ists
The Presiding Officer: Is that the hot cave?
Mr. Claytor: Re ‘actor foundation, vessel founda-
“tion and external conerete work.
The Witness: 2,130 eubie’ yards.
Mr. Claytor: Lo beg your pardon. That is item
B-3. | | a |
The Witness: You are ‘right. ;
Mr. Clastor: That is why I was confused as to,
wy hether it Was item, B-1 or B-3.
The W ithess ; It is the inte rnal work around the
reactor. That is B-3.
Mr. Claytor: Just to clarify this, if 7 may, Mr.
Radley, this entire item is estimated at $1, 488,400.
Mr. Morrisson: Mr. Chairman, may I ask if the
_ Witness has this exhibit™before him?
[3299] -
The Presiding Officer: “He may have. it.
The Witness: Yes, it is Acker 7.
Mr. Sigal: I thought he*had it.
‘Mr. Morrisson: | wanted to be sure,
By Mr. Sigal:
Is that correct? A. That is correct, with contin-
rencies,.
Q. Yes. On the basis of your estimate what would that
figure com» to, or whieh item in that group of figures would
_ You changet A. I would increase the allowance for con:
ca
3299
Q. From what to what? A. I really have not intended
to increas¢., I merely point out this as one of the items
in the estimate which appears to be low to me.
Q. In any event, as fdr as this particular item is con-
cerned, you would say that the cost would be two to three
times as high as _ they estimate? A. Just the coiicrett,
which is really not a large part of this.
| Q. Just the concrete? A. Yes.
Q. You don’t make any comment on the rest of it?. A.
- Not on the total amount. oe : °
The Presiding Officer: Isn't it a fact that they
have
[3300]
-under estimated everything here in Acker 7 with
relation to these costs? I read your testimony and I
~. Was ‘concerned a little bit because it Iooked as if
- they were under estimating everything.
The Witness: I don’t mean to give that impres-
‘sion that everything was under estimated.
The Presiding Officer: A lot of things. There is
a lot under estimated in that Acker exhibit, is that |
right? — 5
~ The Witness: a ‘that j is the burden of my. testi-
mony, I presume. ,
The Presiding Officer: That is the way I read it.
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. The next item you wisiiianaid. ‘-. Radley, is the
hot cave for two cells of $378,200. What would your esti-
mate of that'be? A. I really have no estimate for that hot
cave, but I think that is lov. Hot caves are very difficult to
~ 86
. ae 3301
estimate unless you have all the details. | think for the sort
of work they will be dong they will spend more than that:
for the cave. :
Q. Can you give seme notion of where it might land?
A million? A, Perhaps a half million. .
The Presiding Officer: Under estimated?
The Witness: No, the-total cost might be half a
2 [3301]
- million doilars, let us say, roughly, _
| By Mr. Sigal: °
- Then you go on to say that it is probable many costs .
* £ e . .
have been overlogked since each line item in the estimate
has’ to inelude éertain work: related thereto, and is not
mentioned or deseribed, and’ you point out electric Wiring -
between buildings. Did you make any attempt to list the
various items which may have been overlooked or under
estimated? I mean a more complete list? You have given
some examples. - 1 wonder if you would try to be more ex-
haustive? A. I could give a few more examplés. I think
the core will turnout to be under estimated.
- Q. What do you have to say about that?°A. The amount
given seems low for a Eroject of this size by comparison
‘with other cores, : |
Q. To what extent? _A. IT really have no idea as to
what it will cost. a:
Q. Can you give us your experience with other cores?
A. Cores can cost as much as $10 million. *
Q. Iam sorry. A. Cores ean cost as much as $10 mil-
lion. : ae <a is |
Q. What does this. estimate show for PRDC?T A.
ee
$205,000. a
e
° 3
ad
. .
—_—_—_—_-—-—-— _~
“NEE
P .
. .
.
3301
Q. Are you in xny position to give any more specific
figure for the -PRDC roactor on *the basis of your ¢
[3302]
experience? Al Now 1 cat go beyond saying that the
amount given seems low tome...
Q. What other items have been under estimated?’ A.
Item .B-2 in Acker 7, containment vessel, shows an allow-
ance for extras for air lock, doors of $30,000. I think that. —
is quite low. Air locks are quite expensive;-and | am sure
thiat the $30,000 is inadequate. ;
Q. What is your experience with air locks as to cost?
A. I would say for this project they may cost between
one hundred and two hundred thousand dollars.
Q. <Any other items? A... That is all. .
. Q. In your opinion as your testimony has indicated,
there are probably many other itéms which have been either
overlooked or under‘estimated? A. I think that is true.
Q. You state at the bottom of page 5 of your testimony -
that the nuclear portion of the project will cost ‘several
million dollars more than $32,400,000 estimated by PRDC.
If we add up simply the estimates you have made with their
qualifications, on the specific items mentioned, it would
appear that the under estimate is somewhere in the neigh- -
borhood of four to’ five million dollars. Would you say
that is a fair st&tement, Mr. Radley? . os.
[3303] .
A. The testimony I lave offered sts a number of items
which support my opinion that the reactor is under esti-
mated. But these various examples are not intended to —
add up to give an overrun. — .
88
‘ " Ore $304
Q: I know you did not intend them, but I. am trying
to draw some conclusions. Obviously this all relates to
cost, and your figures must be ‘used and examined with
all flexibility that you have suggested they should possess.
But nevertheless, your testimony shows that with respect to_
site labor, the under estimate runs into millions. The
same thing with reference to overhead expenses, and also
the waste disposal system. We can go on with these vari-
ous items. Certainly to say ‘that the total lias been under
estimated by five million dollars is. being very conservative,
isn’t it, Mr, Radley? A. I think I have gone about as far
as I am prepared to go on the basis of the information I
have when T use the’ words several millions. ;
Q. Several millions is anywhere from three to ten, isn’t
it? A. ‘The dictionary says more than two, but not many.
Q. Are you familiar with the speech that Admiral Rick-
over gave recently on the matter of engineering problems
and so forth, and the manufacturing problems with respect
to reactors? The speech was discussed in Mr. Amorosi’s .
testimony. .
[3304] —
A. Idon’t believe am. @ :
Q. On. page 2, you,point out that you have made esti-
Mates for many types Xv reactors and made or reviewed
estimates of projects unddr construction. On the basis of
your -experience, ‘can: you tell us what differences have
developed between the estimated cost for construction and
the actual cost of construction of the various reactors which
have been built by or under the AEC’s direction? A. The
PWR is an example which has gone from $37,750,000 to
$95 nillion, 7 .
29
“EE
vo
3304
- © Q. That is not yet t completed, is it? A.. It is .not
- finished. yet. es
Does it appear that the gost will be around $55
million? A. Yes, that isthe present estimate. —
-Q. What other.reactors can you mention? A. The —
engineering test reactor has gone from $15 million to $17 .
million, but that is not a power reactor. That is.a research
reactor. The Army package reactor is a fixed price proj-
ect, so we don’t have, anything on that. lands |
Q. It is the builder who rules it out on that-and not
AEC. What about the sodium reactor experiment? A,
_-T have some rough figures or that for the construction
portion. From an original figure of $10 million it has.
gone to $18,5 million,
[3305]
| Q. That is still in the process of construction or is that
completed? ‘A. I believe it ’s substantially completed now. °
Of course, that is a research project. There is a consider- |
able research. .
_Mr. Morrisson: I believe that reactor has gone
critical. — .
The Witness: That is my understanding. It is
‘substantially completed. oe
By Mr. Sigal:
Q. Can you mention any others? A. I might mention
the boiling water reactor at Argonn which was builf
substantially for the ‘estimate of $4.5 willion. It is now
$4.6 million. Those are some examples.
Mr. Sigal: That is all, we ¢
The Presiding Officer: Thank vou, Mr. Sigal. Mr.
_Claytor, you may cross examine.
90
&
Ota eae eo | 3306
Cross Examination by Mr. Claytor
Q. Mr. Radley, first of all, with respect to the item
of miscellaneous spare parts- which we discussed a few
moments ago, it would be possible, would it ‘not, either to
include a very substantial allowance as an initial capital
cost for a large initial supply of miscellaneous parts, or
it might be possible to inchide instead a large operating:
allowance for
[3806]
the purchase of miscellaneous spare parts in your operat-
ing budget, with a proportionately smaller initial supply,-
would it not? A, Yes, you can do your accounting ‘that
way. ; .
Q. So that if it were done that way, obviously the
amount of initial sapply of spare parts to be included in
your-construction budget would be lower thang they: other-
wise would. A. Yes. The ‘accounting’ could be carried
on that way. — ;
The Presiding Officer: You amortize spare parts,
don’t you? ae
The Witness: We ordinarily would inelude a
large supply. of spare parts. %
The Presiding Officer: But you would amortize
them, wouldn’t you, over a, period of years?
The Witness: | don’t know
By Mr. Claytor: . iam
Q. Now I would like to discuss for a moment the figure
for engineering design and expenses of $900,900, item P
on Acker Exhibit 7° I think you said that it would be
redlistic to use an estimate for engineering services of
°
9]
s
—— ———
3306 a r
at least $1,500,000 for this, A. At least twice as high as
the $900,000, that is correct.
Q. That would be $1,800,009.
[3307]
A. That is right. -
Q. You-took ‘into consideration, didn’t you, that the
work called for by this item is to be performed under con-
tract with Commonwealth Associates? A. Yes, I know
of that. | ‘ ae
~ Q. In connection with estimating the costs that would
be incurred in performing this work, 1 would iike to get
some idea of what kinds of costs you assume would be
incurred. What kinds of costs would be, defrayed by this
figure of $900,000 or $1,800,000, the estimated figure? A.
You would like to have me tell yok what engitieering -
design— ;
Q. I would like to have you tell me what costs you
assumed would have to be covered when you gave the
opinion that it ought to be at least twice the figure that
- we estimated. A. That is what is commonly termed en-
gineering design. |
Q. Yes. But what costs are commonly covered by engi-
neering design expenses? - A. The cost of making initial
working drawings. The cost of making the as-built draw-
ings when the job is completed. The cost of expediting.
The cost of inspection of the work which I. understand is
to be done by United Engineers for a fixed fee. I have
taken that into account. Is it United Engineers?
Q. Are we not now mixing up the item for engineering
[3308]
services, erection supervision, which is United Engineers
92
od
eT ee eee oe
- a
.
3309
and Constructors, and design and engineering item of
$900,000 Which is Commonwealth Associates only? A,
No. [ am not mixing up anything. United Engineers is
doing the inspection. Isn’t that correct?
WY. That is right. A. 1 am not contusing construction
superintendence With engineering at all,
Q. I just wanted to be-suré, Tam thinking abopt analyz-
ing. the costs that would be ineurred by Commonwe: alth
Associates in rendering: these s services. For example, |
assumé that you have asstimed that the cost would then
include Commonwealth Associates direct payroll costs of
their employ ees engaged in this work—hourly rates times
"the number of hours with adjustments for payroll taxes,
workmen’s compensation and things of that sort. “A. What
‘is your question?
Q. My question is, have you assumed that one of the:
items of cost which Would be included in ‘this. heading,
engineering services, would be the direct payroll costs in-
curred by Commonwealth Associates for its~ employees
engaged in this work? A. ‘Commonwealth As.ociates are
to do the engineering,
Q. At cost. In order to estimate w hether or not the
costs are correct,;we must know what kind of costs are
Weing defrayed by Commonwealth Associates.
£3309]
The Presiding Officer: Mr. Claytor, let him’ an-
swer the question now. He is entitled to answer the
question. es
Mr. Claytor: He is tadeod: .
The Witness: You say they-are going to do it at
cost. W hat do you mean by cost?
93 . ,
3311 | ‘ .
q. af has nothing vw do with this figure of approximaie-
a her SS) million? A. No, they would not be charged in there,
yp & Could you teil what the figure of $3-million which,’
* you say is not sufficient for indirect and overhead expenses,
what type of work vou have assumed is covered hy that
figure? . a OS
* - sey: — @
A. Just. what is given back here in item J. That. is ay
defined. Shall) I read it?
Q. If you mean thé two paragraphs under J? A. Yes.
(). You have assumed that this figure is to cover that
work? A. Yes, thatgis what is stated here. I would point
out there is an et getera in the first paragraph which leaves
me at # little bit of a loss. ,
Q. You take into consideration that a major portion *of
the work under J is to be performed by United Engineers
and Constructors w.der a‘coritract, or did you éonsider
that is an entirely separate item? I just. want to be sure
we understand each other. A. United’ Engineers and Con-
struc’ ors are doing the inspection, which is a phase of:the
engineering. Is: “my memory correct, that, for $225,000,
which nasn’t anything to do with this item at ant
Q. 1. think the ‘evidenee—
- The Presiding Officer: ees scaalniby know the
‘answer to that question? Is-the witness’ statement
eorrect, or do you know?
ee Mr.-Morrisson: I don’t recall, |
~. s Mer. Claytor; Mr. Acker’s testimony in the record,
I believe, you will ‘find is-to. the effect that United
[3313] ;
Engineers and Coustractars are to perform = the
an er 3
A mereen rem wig.”
4
oe | | | 3314
° é “» ‘ 5c oe
services covered under item J of Acker Exhibit 7
pursuant to a contract. That of this item of
$2,077,000 approximately: $225,000 is to be ‘fee ‘to
United Engineers and Constructors pursuant to the
contract, * = <a : : ’ x
The Presiding Officer? Let me ask YOU Deepftestian
off the reeord. . <j
(Diseussion off ‘the record.)
By Mr. Claytor: © a ,
-‘Q. One other question on this item before you put that
aside. A, | have not answered that question yet.
Q.. We are leaving that aside uniil-we can investigate.
- The Presi ding Offeer: We will straighten it out
«in the marning that $225,000 figure. [ wish counsel
- ~ would together on that and agree what it® repre-
sents. |
. Mr. Claytor:
~ . One other question with respect to the figure which
you described as indirect and overhead expenses in econ-
nection with the construction of the project. I would like
to know if you have assumed that there is a'so ineluded in,
‘this item the overhead expenses to PRD of going forward
with the construction of the project. That is to say, such
expenses to PRDC of its office, its ordinary offiee person-
nel, its supervisory pefsonnel at. the office and the
. [3314]
field and that type of expense. A. T have not considered
this from the standpoint of what does what. Yori have u
capital cost estimate here of $32,400,000, and you’ have
material arid labor given in vdur estimate. It is Gustemary
for those items te mean direct charges,
. OT
3316 : | ees
i e
three assistant managers, a secretarial’ foree, one or twe
° . « , .
vontracting officers and two or three people Who assist in
. the expedition of the work. his is on their payrolh. A.
S
They correspond with aii construction contractor's
.
ne . “5
[3317]
management staff. :
Q. No. Their job would: le solely. to coordinate the
various contractors, primarily it is an office management
On such an assumption would not the expenses of
_foree, On such ¢
maintaining such .an office force “normally: fall within this:
item, an item of indirect and overhead expenses whith
would be part of. the construction cost estimate? A. They.
might or might not, depending on how the job’is handled.
Sometimes owners carr y on quite an activity in connection
with their projects. ° oe .
Q. If such expeyses were included in your indirect and
overhead expense iten’ obviously the item would be larger
than if all those expenses were not included 1 in the item. A.
Is that a question? ‘
(. That is a question. A. The more you putin the
larger it gets. .
@. So that if an.item of: iaiiee et and overhead expenses
does not in fact include the eést of fuaintaining an office,
,a@ number of eniployees, seeretarial service and such,
obviously such an item would be smaller in the constrne-
~
tion estimate than it would be if those expenses were in faet
included, wouldn't it?) As This is-an abstract quesfion?
Q: Yes. A. Naturally. That doesn’t necessarily apply
to this, © ° , peas
. [3318} ° ,
though. | — ? ey :
| on oe
err enimne
cada
3520
‘The dig ties Mr. Claytor, [ think it
woul Lhe oa dod, tine to take A recess until in the
_ morning.
a ( ‘laytor: TLBas roing to ‘another item anyway,
. Examiner.
ae Presiding Officer: Let the record show that
we will be in recess until 10 0’¢lock tomorrow,
(Thereupop at 4:25 p.m. a recess was taken until
Tuesday, Jum 18, 1957,at 16:00 a.m)”
4
(3320)
The Presiding Officer: The hearing will be in or-
der. at aH
Whereupon,
H. MONROE RADLEY resumed the stand as a witness,
and, having been previously duly sworn, was examined and
testified further as follows:
The Presiding Officer: You. ma¥ proceed.
Cross E ramination. (Re sumed) by Mr. ( heuer.
Q. 1 have just two or three mere questions, Mr. CR ad-
‘ley, ; : .
( ‘ould Talirect your attention to Item B-3 of Acker Ex-
hibit.7? When you said, Mr. Radley. that, in your opinion,
the estimate fer conerete work in¢luded in this item was-
low, did. you mean that the material estimates per unit
volume were low, the labor estimates were low, or that.
hoth were low? A. -T think it is largely a labor mnatter
here. Vt is largely dabor. % >
101
he
3320 § |.
Q. It is fargely labor costs included there that were
low? A. Yes. | | | .
Q@. You think, then, that the material costs on that item”
are about right? A. Well, it i? a wttle difficult. Ypu see,
you take this
[3321]
item conde mix. in place. That includes hath material
and labor, —t presmine fst y-conerete ont there, TF
think it-is ‘large ‘ly in the labor.
Q). So on that-item it is the $10 per unit per ‘cubic vard .
labor cost that you partic ularly had in mind? A. Yes.
Y. Now, could [trefer vou to the next page, Item B-4,
the sub-item heating, lighting and ventilation? . ( ‘ould ‘you |
give me some idea of what proportion of that expense you
have assumed is heating, what preportion is lighting, and
What proportion is ventilation? A. [haven't made as-
sumptions on that basis. T inerely took it as a percentage
of the total. — - ‘ :
Q. As a percentage of the tot: il? AL As a pereéntage *
_of the total cost. |
(J. So that on the basis of the analysis you have made,
vou eouldn’t break it dow np! A. T-couldn’t do that here.
I probably’ gould in my office. T believe T said yesterday
that I theught probably the ventilation requirements were
underestimated for this sort of a facility.
Mr. Claytor: Mr. Examiner: yesterday vou asked
me if T could obtain an approximate figure:for the
amount of engineering services and expenses to
Cocnmonwealth Associates that. have been paid: to
date. T have an approvimaté figareas of nah
ey
Ww2 ~
-
ee
3322
[3822] «
the end of May. T hat is $325.90, otit af a total es-
timated amount -of ‘* #0),0000. Ng ere
The Presiding Officer : Thank vous Mr. Claytor.
Mr. Claytor: That is all J have. Mr. Examiner.
~The Presiding Officer ; I< there anv re-direct: of
this witness? ; .
Mr. .Morrisson: T have one or-two questions, Mr, -
Re-direet Evamination by -Mr. Morrisson
Q). Mr. Radley, de you hate a copy ‘of the transeript of ~
the testimony which you gave vesterday? A. Ygs..
Q. Will yeu look at piage 3300, at the question of the
Presiding Officer beginning at the bottom of. 3299, Yebur
answer says **T mean to give that imprpasion that every-
thing was underestimated.’’ ®
I wonder-if a negative was left ont of that answer. A. T)
intended to say yesterday, and I think T did say, ‘‘] don’t
mean to give the impression that everytinng was under-
estimated.’” T.think the word ~ don’t” was omitted in
error there, in the transcript. :
@. In other words, your position is that there are a
number of specifie items in Aeker-7 which you regard as °
being underestimated, but not that everything in Acker 7
_%
[3823]
is indevontnnsied? A. That. is correct,
(). And that vou also regard the over-all figure of 324
‘nillion as underestimated?, A. That is correct.
Q. “On the following page. 3301, you refer to the core
?
‘
2
He
4
- 300°
eed would be defrayed by this
r
.
By Mr. Clayton: rt, ao
Qe: We have a contract with ( ‘ommonwealfh Associ iates
of whieh vou are aware AL Yes,
~Q.. Phe contract is not for a tixed fee but provides that
the work will be pe formed at cost. Now, what Lam trying:
to do is to find out what costs ro assumed in saying the —
’ figure should be, at le rast 1800300.) W hat costs vou “SST .
| ane $1,800,000, Al The
cost of Commonwealth Associates, engineers, plus over-
head, ‘plus Commonwealth Associ ales’ overhead \costs.
Q. So you bave assumed what we wonid he de-
fraying here would be first—I am trynig to do it dna little
more ‘detail—pas rotl costs of Commonwealth. Associates. |
A. T dof think we are eofting anywhere in discussing
a alth Associates accounting procedures. T said
engineering would.ran around $1,800,000-at le ast. — %
Q. Lain trying to test the basis on which you have
reached the figure of $1,800,000, since the figure
Se [3310]
> necessarily, Mr. Radley, on the basis of the evidence already
in the: record depends upon the costs -to Commonwealth
: Associates. In. giving the opinion that the costs would be
at least $1,800,000, vou must have assumed that certain
expenditures by Commonwealth Associates would have to
he covered by the $1,800,000. Tam trying to explore what
expenditures by Commonwealth - Associates vou assiimed>
would be covered. A. Engineering costs. Maybe I ean
answer it this way. Exgineering eosts consist basically of :
two things. One is the direct charges and the overhead
charges, e |
The Presiding Officer: Let him answer the qués-
tients. f at wo
——
331
; ron
,
*
M&.-Clavtor. ! thought lie tinished, Mr. Examin-
er. d
Phe Witness: [ finished, s
bv Mr. Claytor: ; ; ee y
“ee - Q. So direct expe Nses of doing the work ine luding pay-
. roll, incinuding out of pocket expenditures for travel, and
so forth, A. T rave ‘l, telephone, ¢ Xpediting.
(). Plus a fair share for ove Then alloc able for che job.
A. That is the us ual practice,
Q. How about a reasonable fee or profit to the e wer -
ing firm? A. Yon an said eae! is not ie jude S iN, i here
ge 13311]
-@. Tam asking you. I think the evidence is silent about .
Whether the it is included or not. ‘lam trying to find
out whether.if giting your opinion that the figure should
~ be $1,800,000 you assumed that figure of $1,800,000 would
include: in accordance with normal. practice a. reasonable
fee or profit to Commonwealth Associates. A. Lypresume
, because. when I said 15 perce.t included for engineering
is a®ough percentage, actually the profit on these engineer-
ing contracts i*not of sufficient mepersonee ~ make much
difference one way or another. '
Q. Now. T would Ike to turn %o cians item, ‘the item
Which you deseribe in-Your direct testimony on page 7 as
indirdet and overhead expenses in connection with the con-
struction of thes project. Tt is your assumption, is it not,
that this is te include the construction engineering super
vision by United Engineers and Constructors? A. |
we better look’ at the testimony on United Envineers, |
think they are just: ‘doing inspection on this for $225,000,
which hasn't anything to do with this at all.
~
mL)
think: —
3314
Q. Thai is right.. A. To w hith there are certain in-
direet costs which are ee here as $2,977,000,
Q. That is right. : A, That is a standard construetion
accounting procedure. pinata of who «oes that, these
costs: are going too low,
QQ. And in aecordance witht stapidarrel « construction and
accounting procedures, one of the indireet costs that would ©:
“be included in a figure such as this would normally be the
ordihary indirect everhead expenses of running w hatever
office has to be run, having vour own employees supervise
to the extent that they do supervise your actual construe-
tion, consultation with your contractors, and that type of
fhing is an item of jndirect and overhead expense. ‘That
is the only question I have. .A. What is your question?
~Q. My question is this.’ In accordance with ordinary
construction and accounting precedure, do you include in
[3315]
indirect and overhead expenses, ‘the heading for indirect
and overhead expenses, such items as the cost of running
the office, the cost of having your own employees coordinate
the work of the different contractors and what I would
eall general overhead...
The: Presiding Officer: Mr. “¢lavtor, it ean’t be
both indirect labor and overhes id. It has to be one
or the other now, : :
Mr. Claytors The way he deseribes: this item in
°*
his testimony, Mr. Examiner, is indireet and over-
head. expenses. My inquiry’ is to find ont if the
type of expense which | have described is normally
covered under that heading.
The Presiding Officer: Tt cannot be indirect laber
and overhead at the same time It has to be one
. ~ or the other. '
. —. Mr. Claytor: This is so.) Lam asking whether it
is cotisidered to be an indirect expense or an over:
head expense, efther or both. |
The Presiding Officer: That is a tair question.
The Witness: “The question in accounting term-
inology | would say this item includes both indirect
and ov erhead costs. pao ionisonans
By Mr. Claytor:
Q. By which you include the types ol expe aditures |
have just mentionéd. °- @
&>
[3316]
_A. ‘Right here on.J the whole thing is spelled out..
Q. My difficulty, Mr. Radley, may partly be with ‘the
deseription in J. The description in J does not specifically
mention such.items as the eost of renting an office, for
instance, the cost of maintaiiing supervisory personnel on
the payroll, and I would assume that if there are such eosts”
in connection with the construction of a project, regular
construction and accounting procedure would -eall for
those Gosts to be included in an item suelf as this. A. That
-is my understanding of J.
Q. Thank you. A. Let me correct that. T don't want
to say that what you said is right. I want to sav that item
J deseribes their costs.
* . @. Yes, T understand that item J deseribes our cost.
I still feel we must clear up this. Perhaps I can get at it
this way. es ;
Let.us assume that-# reactor constrnetion project from
the beginning of construction has on its pavroll a manage
a
»
ne 99 —
\
@ °
3323 Re ee ns ?
as being possibly underestimated. lni-the. first: place, vor
stated the core, estimate as $205,000, 1s “not the actual
figure on Acker-7 somewhat lhigher than that, when one
_takes into aeeount imstallafion cost and contingencies? A,
-¥es. Twas speaking from memory, The 205 is for the fuel
elements only, I believe.
Q. Do you have the actual installation cost? It is’300-
Z
and-some thousand, 1 isn ‘t it , A. I think it is about ae.
a
installed. k .
Q. You stated in the leer ‘part of ps age 3301, that cores:
can cost as much as $10 million. Did. you mean in so shat-
ing to imply that you thought the’ core for this reactor.
might cost as much as $10 million?. A. | No, 1 did not.
Q. Mr. Radley, you have stated in your testimony in
rather general terms that you believe the construction cost
had been ‘underestimated by. several million dollars. Are
you prepared to give an estimate as to what you believe the
construction of this projet will cost?
[3324]
A. Nov am not. ' hae a
Q. CAn you indicate why 4 you do not feel in a position
to give a specifie estimate on -this construction eost? A.
It is because of the la@k of ifformation on the project, the
uncertainties that remain.
“= Q. In other words, you a not feel tha’ the opportunity }
that you have had to review this project, the information
that has been available to-you, has placed you in a position
in Which vou could give th: Lond of estimate that yeu would
normally be expected to give on a COMMISSION project, is
that right? A. That is true. : 29
i). Do ven helieve it ds possible that this project could
; 5
™ ee
CURR ORN, wLBUCKT She SE
a)
he constructed for the estimated cost of $32,400,0007 A..
Ido wot, . e .
Q. Mr.Radley, as T understand the reeord, there is an-
excess available to the company of a little over $2 million
between.what the company has stated as its cash require-
ments, and the funds available to them ‘througl. cammit-
tents and loans. - c : 7 |
Let me explain how. 1! arrive: at that figure.
Mr. Acker, at page 16 of his written téstimony, states
the eash requirements. at $36,216,000, ® This is arrived, at
by deducting from the total, cost of $43,216,000/" ain amount
of $7 million which is.sfated to be a contribution by APDA..-
That figure of $36,216,000 is less by-a little more |
[3325]
>than $2 million than the -total of, commitments of
$23,540,000, and bank loans of $15 million, to all of which
Mr.- Acker has testified. -
So there is a difference here of somew hat more than $2.
million. Z ae
Do you believe it likely that the construction cost of the
reactor will exceed the ‘estimated Cost by more than $2
million? <A. I do.
Mr. Morrisson: hat is all T have.
The Presiding Officer: ‘Ts there anything further
of this witness? 2° o
Mr. Sigal: we
Re-cross Examination by Mr. Sigal
Y. You have ‘tated that you do not have suflici nt in--
formation to enable you toogive a specific estimateon the
total const ruetion cost, is that right? A. Yes.
15> eS
$3Za
Se Q. Can you-staie what additionai types ef information
you would need from PRDC in order te arrive at’a spe-
cific estimate? A. 1 can give you sort of a general idea.
Q. That is all | am asking for, yes. A. ¢ Tife sketches in
the APDA-I15 are not adequate, for one thing, to show the
size of- the buildings. . They are not
[3326]
deseribed very completely. There are not yery many di-
mensions anyplace. Theré are a great inany uncertainties
as to what is reqaired in the project. There is a general: 3
lack of information throughout. : “.
Q. When you say a general lack’ of information, you are
now talking about the design of the building? ~A. Well,
that is just an example. |
' ~¢ Yes. ‘All right, are there any additional types of
information ttt you could get frojy a report, say, on their
. accounting procedures? Would #6u want that? A. That
would be helpful, too, yes. a
Q. Do you think that thére is enough information pro-
vided now to determine what the operating costs would be?
A. Tam not qualified on operating costs.
(). “Would you not want. the same types of information
with respect to everhead, indirect casts, and-so forth, with
respect to wperating costs and accounting as you would
for coustruction costs and accounting? _A. I say, operat-
ing costs are out of my field. |
Mr. Sigal: That is ail. .
The Presiding Officer: 1+ there anything further
of this witness?
If-not, vou may be exeusedse Thank vou, Mr’ Rad-
lev. :
% . . ~
1thi, : ©
3436 |
QY. And you are assuming au inereasé in all vour der |
eosts, all your other prices, at 4.2 pereent a vear? AL Not.
necessarily 4.2 percent a year, Mr. Sigal. That is on the
basis of the escalation formula provided for in the schedwie © |
for the price of plutonium. ‘
(). The escalation is based‘on ~ increase in the BLS
cost of living figures? A. ‘That Gs right. |
Q). Can you estimate that there is going to be this in-
crease in the price of plutonium over this ten-year period? .
A. I certainly can estimate it, yes.
Q. I mean, what is the rational basis of your corelu-
sion that the prices are going to go up at the rate of 4.2
percent a year? A. On the basis of the. trend from 1955
to‘date. T hat. i is the best thing I know of.
Q. You think’ the prices will continue to go up yearly
on that trend? A. I think itisa realistic assumption for
this purpose, - 7 ;
'- Q. Nevertheless, you have no
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.