Reply Brief for the Petitioner — Alaska v. Arctic Maid
Supreme Court brief1961
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Oftwe Supreine Court, US.
Teeter COPY bo Se a
. FEB G i9nl-
—_—_ JAMES & BROWNING. Clark
-
AO hen IN -THE
s
uska fen 7 : oa a
hace iO — Supreme Court of the United States
on plate’ a Occonns This, 1060
Oho hota | So. 108
an alien
| STATE
Chithom te
Cif LEASH A f’.?
ARUTIO MADD snd yh The MAID- FISHERERS, ING. Re perm fen?
STATE OF ALASKA, Petit
:
+ °
e ° ¥,
°* ) CPACTIFIC REEFER and PACTFIO REBFER BISTEE TES, Re pendent
Sh) STATE OF ALASKA, Pere z¢
PACIFIC QUEEN and PACTELE QUEEN FISHEUEUS. oR: spouses
; :
STATE OF ALASKA, P:
ALASKA REEFER and ALASKA REEFER PISHe RT S, Br spond:
- s - :
. STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
r Z > v.
NORTH STAR and NORTH STAR PISHERTES, Be spondent,
» STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner, ye
; v. oe Noli
. NORTHERN REEFER COMPANY, GRIME PACKING COMPANY wi
. REEPER UL, Respondent /
On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit ;
' aio °
REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONER
RALPH BE. Moopy
Attorney General of Atacks
, GARY THURLOW (
: Deputy Attormey General - \
KICHARD A. BRADLEY
\ttornes (renmeral
. Assistant
Counsel for Petitioner
$30 Capitel Banding
Fumenau. Nduska
Press or Brron S. Apams, Washincton, D C
. _
CasEs:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ARGUMENT: . | Page |
Cd: The Incidence of the Tax on Freezer Ships i is on
‘the Carrying on of Any Part of a Freezer Ship
- Line of Business Within Alaskan Waters. It Is
’ Not in the ‘‘Freezing of Fish.’’ The Thrust of
the Tax Is Against a Local Activity Carried on
in One or Two Places for the Entire Season,
‘But Not on the Interstate Movement of the
BE SPN nos be cares sccucevesvecnces
TI. Although All Fish Processors in Alaska Pay a
. Business License Tax, Freezer Ships May Not
Complain Because Canneries Are Taxed at a
Higher Rate. - Freezer Ships Are Not. in Com-.
petition With Land-Based Cold Storages and
- May Not Complain About a Different ey
Being Taxed at a Different Rate ............. 8
‘III. No Due Process Rights. of Respondents Are
Being Violated Since Alaska Is Taxing No Ac-
tivity Outside of Its Jurisdiction. Respondents
Are Not Wronged by Being Assessed a Lower
Tax Than Their Competitors aaa iia vanes 15
ME cela ban ase reece eae becs er eer ae nee 16
CITATIONS
- Crenshaw Bros. & Saffold v. Southern Pes: Co., 40 Cal.
.. App. GG, 181 Pace 252 (1919) . 0. cxcovccsccses 5, 6
Mich.-Wise. Pipe Line Co. v. Calvert, 347 U.S. 157
Se <uca vevue ds sau edides ene eeetern seen 4,5
Mullaney v. Anderson, 342 U.S. 415 (1952) hye rere 8
Oliver Iron Co. v. Lord, 262 U.S. 172 (1923) .:....... 16
Singer Sewing Mach. Co. v. Brickell, 233 U.S. 304
| Re rrrr ro ere ee aimed 14
Toomer v. W itsell, 334 U.S. 285 ( _— Seas mEswee os 8
“SraTuTes: ‘ oe:
See. 39-2-19, ACLA 1949 ..... Pera CARAS a eee
- Chapter 43, "Session Laws of Alaska 1949 ............ >
Chapter 66, Session Laws of Alaska 1949 ............ 8
Chapter 94, Session Laws of Alaska 1959 ............ 13
Chapter 116, eaieaae oes of Alaska 1949 . iendkeeses 2°
ee
IN THE «-
prem. Court of the Yuited States
. October Term, 1960
% | oe
No. 106
STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
.* v. :
ARCTIC MAID and ARCTIC MAID FISHERIES, INC., Respondent.
--—
STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
: ¥ v.
PACIFIC REEFER ond PACIFIC, REEFER FISHERIES, Respondent. .
STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
: ; v.
RACIFIC QUEEN and PACIFIC QUEEN FISHERIES,> Respondent.
J
_ STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
: vw -
ALASKA REEFER and ALASKA REEFER FISHERIES, Respondent.
STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
. v.
NORTH STAR and NORTH STAR. FISHERIES, Respondent
STATE OF ALASKA, Petitioner,
v.
NORTHERN REEFER COMPANY, GRIMES PACKING COMPANY and
REEFER it, Respondent. -
On Welt of Cortierari to the United Stabes Court. of Appeals
_ for the Ninth Circuit
REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONER
Po
)
ARGUM |
I
: . é .
-The Incidence of the Tax on Freezer Ships Is on the Carrying
on of Any Part.of a Freezer Ship Line of Business Within
Alaskan Waters. It Is Not on the “Freezing of Fish.” The
Thrust of the Tax Is Against a Local Activity Carried on
in One or Two Places for the Entire Season, But Not On
the Interstate Movement of the Ships Themselves
The respondents profess to be confused regarding
petitioner ’s position as to the incidence of the tax. We
wish to make it absolutely clear that we believe that
there can be only one incidence of the tax and that in-
cidence of the tax is the incidence named inthe first °
paragraph of Ch. 116; SLA 1951—namely, the prose-
cution or attempt to prosecute the freezer ship line
of business in connection with Alaska commercial fish-
-eries. We.believe that the Ninth Circuit Court of A‘p-
peals was right the first time it hear d the case. At that
fat the taxable incident was found to be that part of
the freezer ship business. prosecuted in. connection |
with Alaska commercial fisheries within the limits of
Alaska’s taring jurisdiction, We believe that the Ninth
Cirenuit in its opinion of March 23, 1959 was correct
when it stated that freezer ships were prosecuting a°
freezer ship line of business in connection with
Alaska's commercial fisheries when they sent their
boats into Alaska waters to take fish from those
waters. ‘Freezer ships carry on a number of different
activities during the course of prosecution of a freezer .
ship line of business within the limits of Alaska’s tax- | |
ing jurisdiction. -Among these taxable business activ-
“Sties are the search for fish, the catching of fish,
and when the freezer ship is within Alaska waters
(and we eventually hope to obtain’a juridical de-
termination that, Alaska waters imelude much of
-°f
3 , .
Bristol Bay—see Pet. Br. 12, n. 1), it also in-
cludes -the unloading of the cateher boats into the
mother ship, the freezing of the fish, the moving of the
fish back ‘and forth on the ships for better storage,
and anything else the freezer ship may do while it is
in Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction for the purposes of ob-
taining fish and of freezing the fish immediately there-
after. The state has no desire to leave its taxing juris-,
diction to tax any activities of. freezer ships occurring
outside of Alaska’s taxing Jurisdiction.
This tax is not a startling depar ture from the usual
concept of a business license tax. . Business license
taxes are generally on the totality of the business ear-
ried on within the.taxing jurisdiction. There is no rea-
son to assume that the Alaska freezer ship tax was de-
signed to be any thing differ ent.
We believe that courts have erred on two occasions
in finding the taxable. incident, and they erred because
they strayed beyond the language defining the inci-
_ dence of the tax and wandered into the language de-
scribing the measure of the: tax. -We must confess
that when the trial court did this the Territory of
Alaska was pleased since under its construction of
the statute every fish obtained and processed by freezer’ .
“ships contributed to Alaska tax revenues. However,
~ noW that we have the reasoning of the three-judge panel
of the Ninth Cireuit Court of Appeads available to us
we believe that Court found the law the first time it
heard the case. It held that freezer ships outside of
Alaskan waters which opefate catcher boats within
such waters must accept tax responsibility for the
fish so obtained.. It also held that obtaining fish is an
integral part of the operation of the freezer ships and
that the catcher boats operated by the freezer ship |
4
ae
itself are but an extension of that ship’s operations.
We also agree that if freezer ships stay completely out-
side Alaska's taxing jurisdiction and do not send any
of their boats within Alaska waters, there is’ no way
Alaska can reach these ships by its taxes. We believe
that when the Court of Appeals went: beyond the inci-
dence of the tax in the second opinion and looked
to its measure, it erred in much the same way as the
trial court. This time we were not pleased by ‘the
error, since if the. freezer ships are’ not taxable for
their severance operations, are taxable only on their™
processing operation, and, process entirely outside of
Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction (which may be the situ-
ation in part or most of the cases) Alaska’s tax reve-
nues would be correspondingly diminished.
Uich.-Wise. Pipe Line Co, v. Calvert, 347 U.S. ‘157
(1954), is evidently respondents” leading case. Re-
spondents state at page 20 of their Brief:
“In that case a Texas statute levied a‘tax upon
persons engaged in ‘gathering gas,’ measured by
the entire volume of gas ‘taken.’ } :
The Court had geod reasen for placing. the word
“taken”: in quotes in its opinion and respondents are
correct in leaving it in quotes, since the ‘*taken”* found
in the Texas statute does not connote the usual concepts
that **taken’’ evokes. It also has a different meaning
from the word ‘‘taken"’ in the Alaska freezer ship stat-
ute. Inthe Michigan-Wisconsin case the word ‘‘taken"
is synonymous with ‘treceived for shipment in inter-
state comnierce.’’ -See 347 U.S. at 167. It has no con-
nection with the production of gas. A tax on the
‘gathering’ of gas or on the ‘‘taking’’ of gas, not
being a tax on its preduction, is.a tax which is delayed
4
4)
beyond the step where production and processing has.
ceased and transmission in interstate commerce has
begun. 347 U.S. at 167. The Alaska tax is not delayed,
beyond the step where production has eeased.. The
Alaska tax occurs at a time immediately before and
_. immediately after taking occurs. This production is a
distinctly local activity capable of forming the basis
of the tax imposed. The problem, is complicated since
the fish ‘‘produeed”’ are processed immediately after
they are caught so that they will retain their value.
However, if that- activity occurs outside of Alaska’s
taxing jurisdiction it could not be ‘of interest. to this
Court.or tous. If it o¢eurs within the three-mile limit
or within an inland bay of the State of Alaska; then, of
course, it is-an activity which the Alaska freezer ship
. tax is designed to reach, and as we have argued in our
earlier Brief, is a distinctly local activity, just as is the
taking of the fish.
Freezer ships are not carriers engaged in interstate
_ commerce, waiting to receive gas or grapes for ship-
_ment., The facts of this case are not similar to Cren- -
e
shaw Bros. & Saffold v. Southern Pac. Co., 40 Cal. App.® .
‘603, 181 Pace. 252 (1919) ; Resp. Br, 23, n. 25. In that —
case, Claim, was made against the railrond company for
damage allegedly resulting from nnperfect refrigera- ‘
tion of shipments of grapes. The’ shippers argued that
a valuation clause permitted by the Carmack amend-
ment to the Interstate Commerce Act was not appli-
cable. to a claim based. upon improper refrigeration,
where a separate and distinct. charge was’ made for
refrigeration. The Court rejected the contention, stat-—
ing:
‘Phe charge was distinct, but the refrigeration
itself was inseparably connected with the trans-
6
portation of the fruit, and was an essential part of
the transac tion.’? 181 Pace. at254. 3
_ The Crenshaw case very well illustrates the difference
between a carrier engaged in interstate commerce and
‘a freezer ship operation which is relatively stationary
for a prolonged period -of time and whieh is engaged
in the extraction of resources within-a state. In the
Crenshaw case the carrier had nothing to do with the
production of the grapes which it undertook to deliver
in good condition. Inthe Crenshaw ease it was not the
producer who undertook responsibility for preserving
the product until it could be started on its a to an-
- other state.
The Ninth Circuit observed in dicta at 277 F.2d 120,
125, R. 387, that if the tax were construed to include»
such extraterritorial activity as the movement of the
freezer ship to and from the fishing grounds in Alaska,
the tax would be invalid under the. due process clause
of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments. - Yet in
hypothesizing applications of the law to various factual
- situations, it is wise to realize that the thrust of the law ..
is not. againstynovement of ships from Washington to
Alaska and back, but is rather aimed at an industry
that, as a practic al matter, completes ‘all its activities
in one area. Plaintiff’s Stipulation #1, Exhibit #1
. at R. 39 indicates that when, freezer ships are in the
process of getting fish, their mobility is severely ~
limited. To be of utility they must ‘‘maintain a rea- —
sonably straight line so, that their anchors will not
foul.’” Catcher boats also ‘‘must be given room’’ (R.
39). Homer Kyros, captain of the Arctic Maid, stated
in-his deposition that the freezer ships “anchor off of
[sic] the beach in certain designated areas—I say desig- _
nated—from year to year there are certain anchorages ~
sf
”
ry
7
’ . ‘ C _ se
that -we picked out, and we drop our anchor there for
the season,....”’. (R. 262-263). -(Italies added.)
~This. is not the role usually played by companies
engaging in interstate transportation. No readjust-
ment in application or change. in law is required to
apply the law -to Alaskan owned and operated. ships
which might or might not be conducted by a local
on cannery, more or less as a ‘‘field operation.’’ ‘These
\Sships would have Alaskan home ports and would con-
duct all their brsiness activities within Alaskan water
Theref Me, no aspec ts of the tax inevitably reach og
state edthinerce since, if locally owned, the boat may.
never move or need to move for a profitable operation.
from its field of ss seaeinal
We emphasized in our earlier Brief the :dangers
inherent’ in confusing the act of freezing with the sub-
sequent and entirelyseparate act of transporting the
frozen product to another state: See Pet. Br. 13-14.
By considering a hypothetical and yet possible applica-
tion of the law to a purely Alaskan operation,\and by
showing the ease with-which the tax ‘would apply: to
‘ this Alaskan operation, we hope we have indicated to
the Court how divorced the transportation is from the
freezing. When transportation is shown to be an inci-
dental aspect of the freezer ship line of business, the
_ tlearly intrastate aspects stand out in their true per-
. spective.
; 8. ;
~ 7
x a 1 ; 3
Although All Fish Processors in Alaska Pay a Business License
Tax. Freezer Ships May Not Complain Because Canneries —
Are Taxed at a Higher.Rate. Freezer Ships Are Not in
Competition With Land-Based Cold Storages and May Not
Complain About a Different Industry Being Taxed at a
Different Rate
Chapter 66, SLA 1949, which apdaed a license tax
of $5.00 on resident fishermen as compared to a tax of
$50.00 on non-resident fisheimen and which was later
found to be yneconstitutional [Mullaney v. Anderson,
342 U.S. 419 (1952)] is irrelevant to this case. |Al-
though the text of the tax act does not explain any
underlying Yurpose\it does net appear to be a revenue
tax, but father ‘» salabiaty license fee.’ Moreover,
- the tax is on individual fishermen and is not on the
severance of fish. If it’is true that the tax-is a regula-
tory tax, some discrimination between residents and.
non-residents would be justified because of the greater’
expense of keeping track of non-resident fishermen
(but. not a ten-to-one discrimination). See Toomer vi“ —
Witsell, 334, U.S. 385 (1948). Even if Ch. 66, SLA"
1949 is a revenue-raising tax rather than a regulatory
tax, it is difficult to see why the existence of that reve-
nue tax would have any relevance to a business license
tax levying taxes on businesses according to the value
_ of fish obtained for processing. \They are greatly dif-
ferent taxes and are administered in different fashions.
- 1 Section 5 of the Act requires each buyer of fish to keep a
|
ia
- record of each purchase showing the name of the boat*from which — |
the catch involved is taken, the amount purchased and the names
of all persons on the boat who participated in the trip on whieh
the fish or shellfish. were taken, and makes it unlawful for anyone
to buy fish from an unlicensed fisherman. This suggestg,registra-.
tion for purposes of keeping track of the —* of the fishing 4
effort.
t
9
Respondents state the purpose of the freezer ship
tax is to discourage shipment and out-of-state process-
ing of raw salmon (Resp. Br. 28), and cite a statement
elicited from one of the tax’¢ollectors of the Depart-
ment of Taxation as authority for the statement (Resp.
Br. 28, R. 259-260). An isolated statement of an iso-
, lated territorial tax collector should have very little
evidentiary value in determining the legislative intent
‘in enacting the freezer ship tax. The legislatiye intent .
should be found by considering all of#the
processing taxes as a whole together possibly with any
of the legislative history that may be availabl Up
fortunately no legislative history is available. ” -
All fish processors engaged in business in connection
with Alaska fisheries pay a tax as a result of their en-
gaging in business. See Pet. Br, 6. BecauS+the
amount of fish processed is the measure of the tax aJl
fish bought or obtained by fish processots doing. busi:
ness in Alaska contribute to some extent to Alaska tax,
revenues, Canneries ate taxed most heavily in Alaska.
They. are taxed on their business operations in Alaska
under a tax at 6 per cemt of the valne of the salmon
bought or.otherwise obtained for canning. Freezer
ships are taxed less than either. canneries or ¢annery
ships since they are‘taxed at a rate of 4 pér cent of the
value of ra® fish bought or taken for freezing. This
is understandable sinee, although canneries and freezer
whips are interested in obtaining the same species of
fish for the sarhe ultimate purpose, the total volume of: |
business activities of freezer ships 1s less than the total
volume of-business of Alaska canneries. Salmon, hali- .
but, shellfish, and other fish bought for processing
through freezing, salting, or other methods, are taxed
at 1 per cent. This is understandable because cold
4
e
——_ ©
‘
wp
nm
17
the United States District Court to.decide the amount
of taxes actually due the State upon remand. :
a
Respectfully submitted,
RautpH E. Moopy
Attorney General of Alaska
Gary THURLOW .
Deputy Attorney General ,
Ricuarp A, BRADLEY
Assistant Attorney Generai -
430 Capitol Building ~
Juneau, Alaska
'. Counsel for Petitioner, ~
a State of Alaska .
Dated this 9th day of: _ fe
February, 1961, at | . eva
Juneau} Alaska. ” ‘.
a
a | . : a ; A F
¢ t: 5 ee ° 2 ‘ .; Z e
1 0 Dd ; \-
4
storages are not interested in buying fish ‘‘i Nae
round, > but rather buy higher: quality fish at higher |
prices which have’ been’ treated much more carefully
than. cannery-destined figh, and which inthe great ma- °
' jority of the cases have been cleaned (R. 243-244). Cold
storages are interested | partic ularly in king salmon and
silver salmon, while canneries are interested largely in
red, pink and chum salmon, and to some extent silver.
- salmon (R.*234%235 and 263). Freezer ships are par-
‘tie nilarly interested in red salmon since the bulk of the
fish they catch are caught in Bristol Bay where: red
salmon predominate. The fact’ is that there are three
different industries here. Canneries and freezer ships
are perhaps the most similar in nature in that they are
“interested i in the same type of fish.
‘Moreover, shore-based cold storages freee fish for -
the fresh frozen consumer market; they are not in com-
petition with freezer ships. who can all their _ fish’
(R. 240-251). Fish frozen by a.cannery but not canned
are likewise not in.competition with the freezer ships’
product. Fish obtained by Alaska canyeries for can-
“ning are in competition with fish obtained by freezer
ships, but the freezer ship companies have no reason
to complain. since “the tax on the fish obtaineds
fr eezer ships: is less*than the tax ¢ on fish — by’ .
: canneries. |
The respondents make much of the fact that a tax-.
‘ payer who obtains and freezes salmon for later canning
in- ‘Alaska will pay no tax with respect to the activity
~ of.freezing the salmon in Alaska, while a taxpayer who
obtains and freezes salmon for later canning in an other
state must pay a tax of 4 per cent of its value with |
respect to the same activity. The Ninth Circuit in its’
opinion ‘of March 16, 1959, answ ered this contention:
ae
+
.
. . ‘
ba -_* .
. .
‘ ;
. -
= ;
. a id
8 ° .
’ P . . e
. °
> ‘
Ul
‘*We see no significanee-in the fact that the Alas- .
kan canneries do not pay a tax at the- freezing |
stage on fish which they later can.- This is only an
iMusionary benefit for such fisk will be taxed -at
the 6 per cent rate before they enter thé market to .
compete with appellant® product. The samhe is |
true of the fact that the T@ritory does ‘not collect:
the-1 per cent. freezing tax from shore-based cold
storages on fish which are later cafined in Alaska,
for these fish are likewise subject to the 6 per cent
_canhing tax before they enter the canned salmoti
‘ market.”” (Pet. Br. App. §a) |
‘It would have been more logieal for the Legislature
to have required cold storages to pay taxes for salmon.
which are frozen for later canning in Alaska. In fact,
it may well be that the statute. does .require this and
that the administrative practice .of not requiring this
tax is totally erroneous and without any foundation in
law.y A business license tax or a gross receipts tax is .
generally measured by: some index of the business activ-
‘ity of the business to be taxed, and in the case of ascold
storage any freezing of fish for later canning would
- slogically be part of the measure by which the total tax
liability sheyld De calculated.’ °
ah 7 a - |
Accordingly, it would appear that the Department
of Taxation may_have erred in not considering the
* For example, the volume of business activity might be measured
by. net income, as is the case with the Alaska business license tax
applicable to banks, both state and federal. The business license
tax on banks is measured by the net irfeome of the banks and is
2 per cent of the net income. See. See. 5(b), Ch. 43, SLA 1949.
The volume of business activities of the great majority .of Alaska
businesses is. measured by their gross receipts. Sec. (a) of Ch. 43,
. as amended by .Ch. 128, SLA 1955 provides for a license fee of
$25 plus a sum equal to one half of one per, cent of the gross |
receipts in excess of $20,000 with a tax of one quarter of one per
cent on all gross volume in excess ‘of $100,000. -°
ve , a
o2
~
.
Le,
-, -F.
12.
salmon frozen by cold storages for later/canning in
caleulating their taxes. This is understandable since
freezing of salmon for later canning is an! isolated and
_ unusual activity for a cold storage (R. 343). It is not’
- an activity which*the Legislature would necessarily be
expected to take into consideration in framing a rea-
sonable’ business license tax pyogram applicable to all
fish processors doing business in Alaska, nor is it a
+ business activity which the Department of Taxation
would be expected to take any particular note of. No
one thinks of cold storages as being in the business of
freezing salmon for later canning. This type of activ-
ity only takes place in emergency conditions such .as
when fish suitable for canning. purposes. are caught
early in the. season before the canneries have opened
(R. 344). In'some cases cold storages will hold these
' salmon and keep them frozen until the canneries open. —
_ +The cold storages in Alaska seldom freeze fish “in
the round¥, for canneries. ‘Wallis George, president
*. and manager Of the Juneau Cold Storage Company,
stated in his deposition (R. 344) that during his 27
' years with the company it had only happened two oy
three times: It occurs ‘‘only when the run is so heavy.
that they can’t take care re of them in their own canning
plants” (R. 344). :
- At page 234 of the Cie of Record, James ‘G.
Pinkerton, manager- of the Ketchikan Cold Storage.
was questioned rega¥ding the amount of fish frozen
for later canning by a dand-based cold storage. He
stated that as'a matter of courtesy to their fishermen
the cold storages would take fish undesirable -for the
fresh frozen market and can them (R. 234-235). At
page 239, however, Mr. Pinkerton.admitted that it was
- not ordinarily done.in the course of business and that
‘
418
Fane :
it. was an ‘isolated, incidental thing?’ Laws of the .
Territory and State prohibit the wasting of a natural
Yresource, See 39-2 -19, ACLA 1949; See. 27, Art. I, Ch.
94, SLA 1959. Natural bisiness economies demand
that these’ fish be used, though undesirable for fresh
frozen purposes. However, this type of operation is
outside: the usual Scope of business, of land- based cold
storages.
Furthermore, although cold storage opefators take
all fish, whether the type desired for their particular
operation or frot, they would prefer to avoid freezing ~
fish that will be ‘canned later. It is a process that is
‘expensive’ ‘and the duplication is avoided if possible.’
Several distinctions between-the business of freezer
ships and the land-based cold storages are apparent.
Freezer ships freeze their fish by the ‘‘brine method,’ -
-explained very well im Respondents’ Brief at 8-9,
whereas cold storages use the ‘sharp freeze method”’
‘indicated in. the testimony, of Homer Kyros (R. 270).
If this were the only difference, the tax ‘classification
would probably not he justified.
3 Deposition of Thomas Sidney Parke: Q. Do you know whether
such*operations [Our note: Cold storage for. later canning] have
-been conducted at, for jnstance, the Pelican Cold Storage and
Pelican Packing ompany? A. Yes, I do know that the Pelican
Cold Storage preserved fish—I am not so sure of the year, but I |
believe it was "49, the year they had a big run and they weren't
prepared for it. The canneries weren't geared for it, but I don’t
know of.the Pelican Cold Storage holding fish for the Pelican. Can-
ning Company. [' know that is a very expensive operation to
actually do both types, so it ism’t readily done. Q. How do you
know it is expensive? A.- Just from facts I have been told through-
out the operation. They avoid it if they possibly can. (R. 252) °
* The Pacific Queen in the 1951 season only used the ‘‘air blast’’ -
method. Resp. Br. 9. oe
“
*
14
However, it is not the only distinction. The land-
based cold storage is as it states—land-based, be. paeg
’ the other is a transient operation. See R. “281,
289-90. This“ sitnation.has been ree stig | : this.
Court as an ‘evident difference in the mode of doing:
business.”’ Singer Sewing Machine v. Brickell, 233
U.S. 304 (1914). ‘
Then again ‘the land-based cold storages are in no.
“way competitive with freezer ships. The freezer ships.
and the floating cold storages freeze fish for later can-’
ning only, while most of the fish taken by the land-based
cold storages are frozen for the fresh fish market (R.
74). The differences in the disposition of the fish re-
quire substantially different treatment of the fish. Fish”
frézen for canning are frozen ‘in the round” while.
fish frozen for the fresh fish market are ¢ leaned shortly
after their taking. Freezing ‘‘in the roumd,’’ with the .
entrails still in the fish, tends to lower the final quality
“ahd flavor of the fish while the immediate cleaning and
free zing of fish after they: are caught results in a
“ohfeher quality fish (R. 240, 301-302).““Freezer. ships .
also take seine-caught salmon while the Iand- based eold
> stoyages obtain the more valuable and high priced
trolling- caught kings and cohoes (R. 74). .
_ The freezer ship does hot suffer from discriznination
when compared to a eannery, since the tax on freezer
ships after all the.freezer ship operations are lumped
together will hot exceed 6 per cent whether or. not. the
freezer ships freeze any of their fish or whether or not .
- any of the freezing of the freezer ships occurs within
Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction. If the freezer ships do
any part of their business in Alaska ‘their tax will be
6 per cent even though. there is no freezing of fish
which Alaska taxes could reach. By the same toketi,
°
ee se
TC
MBSE
canneries in Alaska are subjec t to the 6 per anak tax no
matter how many or how few business ac tivities they
-engage in in the process of canning fish. The tax would .
be the same whether or not they caught, loaded, un-
loaded, de-héaded or froze their fish. Certainly, it
would be unreasonable to tax an Alaska cannery an
additional 4 per cent tax, a 1 per cent tax, or any: tax,
if it should freeze its salmon before canning it, since
the tax is not on the canning, or the freezing, pr thé
unloading of the fish on a cannery dock, or the de-
heading, or any other single phase of the cannery ac-
‘tivity, but as in the ease of a freezer ship operation, is
‘on the entire business activity oceurring in Alaska. |
IIT
No Due Process Rights of Respondents ‘an Being Violated
Since Alaska Is Taxing No Activity Outside of Its Juris-
diction. Respondents Are Not Wronged By Being Assessed
a Lower Tax Than Their Competitors
We believe that this Court should decide the due
process clause’ question and classification defense raised
by the respondents, since this Court would necessarily
consider both questions when passing on-the issue of
discrimination. The due process’ defense is clearly in-
upplicable since Alaska does not.seek to tax any of the
activities of the respondents carried on outside of the
taxing jurisdiction of the State of Alaska. The classi-
fication defense is inapplicable if the discrimination
argument is found wanting since the respondents can-
not show themselves wronged by the 4 per cent tax on
their activities as opposed to the higher tax imposed on
cannery activities. The fact that shore-based cold.
storages are taxed at 1 per cent is.of no relevance since
16
they are engaged i in totally different type ¢ of busines’
and are*not in competition with either canneries or
freezer ships. a : , :
Howev er, there is one remaining ground which the
Ninth Cireuit Court of Appeals should: pass on in the
event that this Court should decide for the State. of
Alaska on both of the interstate commerce questions.
Some court must determine the extent of Alaska’s tax-
-ing jurisdiction in order to enable an Alaska court to
determine the exact amount Of the tax liabilities of the
freezer ships. Under any ruling of this Court or of |
the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals regarding the ex-
tent of Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction, it appears.that °
there will probably be some freezer ship operations of
the freezer ship companies- which will be totally out-
_ side of Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction and which will be
tetally exempt from any Alaska taxes whatsoever. This
means that certain issues of fact will eventually have
to-be determined by a trial court as outlined in the con- .
clusion of the opinion of the Court of Appeals dated
March 16, 1959, since withdrawn. (See Pet. Br., App.
18a).
CONCLUSION
Petitioners urge the Court to uphold Alaska freezer
ship tax on thé ground that ifis'a tax on a local activity
and is not designed to discriminate against interstate
commerce. Oliver Iron Co. v, Lord, 262:.U.S. 172 .
(1923). This Court should adso remand the case to the
Ninth Cirenit Court of Appeals to determine the ex-
tent of Alaska’s taxing jurisdiction and thereby ‘allow =
eo?
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Arcu ME St: Page .
LE “The Inc idence of the Tax on Freezer Ships is on
‘the Carrying on of Any Part of a Freezer Ship: .
Line of Business Within Alaskan Waters. It Is
Not in the ‘‘Freezing of Fish.’’ The Thrust of
the Tax Is Against a Local Activity Carried on
in One or Two Places “for the Batire Season,
* But Not on the Interstate Moverdent of the i
ms eee Des ue aeecesce 2
If: Although All Fish Piece in Alaska Pay a
_ Business License Tax, Freezer Ships May Not .
Complain Because Canneries Are Taxed at a
Higher Rate. Freezer Ships Are Not in Com-
petition With Land-Based Cold Storages and
« May Not Complain About a Different Industry _
Being. Taxed at a Different Rate Bae APRN Ele 8
III. No Due Process Rights of Respondents Are
- Being Violated. Since Alaska Is Taxing No Ac-
_ tivity Outside of Its Jurisdiction. Respondents
-Are Not, Wronged by Being Assessed a Lower
Tax Than i © Competiions arate SE seers 15 .
* Concivaion Esvstvewouae Gane os Deserws ae eka eee a
CITATIONS
CASES: :
Crenshaw Bros. & Saffold v. Southern Pac. Co., 40 Cal. :
App. 603, 181 Pac. 252 (1919) ......... 0... eee es 5, 6
Mich. -Wise. Pipe Line Co. v. Calvert, 347 US. ‘157
eee rer yer ere er rere re 4,5
Miillaney v. Anderson, 342 U.S. 415 (1952)............ 8
Oliver Irdn Co. v. Lord, 262 U.S. 172 (1923). ......... 16
Singer Sewing Mach. C o. v. Brickell, 233 U.S 304
Re Pe ree Perel es Pree Cre eT 14°
_ Toomer v. Witsell, 34 U Ss. 385 (1948) .......-. seeee 8
SraturEs: Reg Eee
See, 39-2-19, ACLA 1949 ............2055 ae a
Chapter 43, Session Laws of Alaska 1949 ........:... 11
- Chapter 66, Session Laws of Alaska 1949 ............ 8
Chapter. 94, Session. Laws of Alaska 1959 ............ 13
_ Chapter 116, Session Laws of Alaska — inuke anaes 2
' Pw nae Sa,
vs
; 17
the United States District Court to decide the amount
of taxes actually due the State upon remand.
. Respectfully submitted,
RaupH E:; Moopy
Attorney General of Alaska
’ Gary THURLOW
Deputy Attorney General
- RicHarp A, BRADLEY =
Assistant Attorney General —
430 Capitol Building
Juneau, Alaska
Counsel for Petitioner,
State of Alaska
Dated this 9th day of ;
February, 1961, at - ‘Pe.
Juneau, Alaska. “9
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
. ‘No. 106.—OcroBEr Tere, 1960.
; - On ‘Writ of Certiorari
State of A Petit : “nited
. oO sea etitioner to the Uni States
Court of Appeals for -
_Aretic Maid, et « 8 the Ninth Circuit. ”
- [May 1, - 1961.)
Mr. Justice Dovsias delivered the -opinion of. the
Court.
‘While Alaska was a Territory. the Territorial Lexisla-
ture amended, L. 1951, c. 116,-its taxing statutes to rene,
in relevant part, as follows: °
z “Séction 1. BUSINESSES. IN ALASKA FISH-
ERIES REQUIRING LICENSES: AMOUNTS
THEREOF. Any person, firm or corporation prose-
cuting or attempting to prosecute any of the follow-
ing lines of business in-.connection with Alaska’s
commeftial fisheries shall first apply for and obtain,
on the conditions hereinafter set forth, a license so
to do on the basis of the following poate taxes which
are taiji levied:
A 2
“(by Freezer ships ia ‘aia Sintien cold stor-° .
ages: An annual license tax equal to 4% of the value
. of the raw halibut? halibut livers and viscera, salmon
and bottom fish, shellfish or other fishing resource
‘bought or otherwise obtained for processing through
freezing. The value of the raw material under this
license shall be the actual price paid for same includ-
ing indirect considerations such as fuel or supplies
furnished by the processor or offsets to the cash. value
for gear furnished ete. “Such value shall apply to the i”
o?*
.
lie
2- - *ALASKA v. ARCTIC MAID.
raw material herein mentioned which is procured in
company owned or subsidized boats operated by
employees of the processor ‘or under lease or other
arrangement.”
Respondents ' use efreezer shine te the taking. and
preservation of salmon. along. Alaska’s shores. These
freezer ships use “catcher boats” which respondents. own
or have under contract and which catch salmon off Alaska.
The freezer ships sometimes purchase salmon from iride-—
pendent fishermen.
Bristol Bay’ is a famous fishing nena for. salmon.
When operating in the Bristol Bay area, the freezer ships
- anchor more than three miles from the coast, because of -
the shallow waters in Bristol Bay.: They serve as a base
for their catcher boats that fish within the territorial
waters. In other areas both the freezer ships and the
~ catcher boats stay within the territorial waters.
When the catcher boats—which are shallow-draft and
known as gillnetters—have a load or desire to discon-
tinue fishing or when the open season ends, ‘they return:
to the “mother® ship and unload. The salmon are
usually ‘dumped into quick-freezing brine tanks. At
other times they age placed in freezing compartments
and frozen by blasts of air. The freezer ships even-
tually return to Puget Sound in the State of AV ashington
where the salmon are canned,
_, Alaska, when a Territory, brought ‘these suits in the
District. Court gf Alaska for taxes claimed to be due and
owing under the foregoing Act. The District Court
entered judgments for the plaintiff. 140 F. Supp. 190.
1Qne of the respondents is a Washington corporation. Four
remaining respondents are partnerships all of whose members are
citizens of the United States ard residents of either California or
Washington. The Pacific Reefer Co. is the owner of the *hip Reefer
IJ; as to which & tax lien is asserted to exist by virtue of the activities
af a previous owner. It too‘is a foreign corporation.
~
c
?
ALASKA v.,ARCTIC MAID. 3
It held that the taking of the fish was the taxable event,
_ not the freezing ofthe fish.. * - -
On. appeal the Court of Appeals held that respondents
were taxable for fish caught by their. catcher boats within
- . territorial waters, even though the freezer ships remained -
outside the three-mile limit. In its view the catcher boats
“operated by the freezer ship itself are but an extension
of that ship’s operations.” It held, however, that respond-
ents were not responsible for taxes on fish taken “by
. independent catcher boats but purchased by the freezer
ships’’ outside territorial waters. There was a rehearing
en banc and on the rehearing the Court of Appeals held
”. that the tax incident was not taking fish*but “the freezing:
and cold storage of fish aboard freezer ships.” It held
that the tax could not be levied even if the freezer ships
received the salmon in territorial waters. It reasoned that
‘the freezing and storage of the fish was-an inseparable
part of interstate commerce . and could not be’ taxed
locally anymore than the loading and unloading of inter-.
state carriers. Cf. Joseph v. Carter &, Weekes Co., 330
U. S. 422: Richfield’ Oil Corp. v. State Board, 329 t.s.
69. Accordingly. it reversed the Distri¢t Court. 277 F.
- 94 120. The case is here.on a petition for certiorari which *
we granted because of the importance of the ruling to the
new State of Alaska. 364 U. S. 811. ;
We put to one side the specialized cases such as Rich-
ld Oil Corp. v. State Board, supra, which arise under
tRe Export-Import Clause of the Constitution (Art. I, ©
§ 10, cl. 2) because none of the salmon involved in these
cases was destined to a-foreign country. We also consider
- iprelevant cases such as Joseph v. Carter .& Weekes Co.,
supra, where a state tax was laid on the gross receipts of
a stevedore who was loading and unloading vessels en-
gaged in interstate commerce. -A tax on an integral part
of an interstate movement might be imposed by other
States “with the net effect of prejudicing or unduly bur-
4 ‘ALASKA ». ARCTIC MAID.
dehing commerce” as the Court said in. . Michigan-
Wi isconsin Pipe Line Co. v. Calvert, 347'U. S. 157, 166..
’ We have no such problem here. This tax is one im-
posed on those “prosecuting or attempting to prose-
cute... lines of business in connection with Alaska’s
commercial fishgries.” -The business in questyen is the
one specified in subsection (b): “Freezer ships and
. Other floating cold storages.” To be sure the tax is
‘computed on ‘the “value” of the fish “bought or otherwise
obtained for processing through freezing.” That how-
ever is the measure of the tax, not the taxable eve ~“ The
taxable event is “prosecuting” the “business” of “Freezer
ships or other floating cold storages.” Part of = business
is, of course, tranaporting frozen fish interstate. Yet it
is plain that a freezer ship is more—much more—than
an interstate carrier. Part of its business is freezing fish.
Yet these ships do more than freeze fish and transport
them interstate. Taking the fish directly through their
. own catcher boats or obtaining them from other fishermen
is also a part of respondents’ business. Without the tak-
& _ ing or obtaining of the fish, the freezer ship would have no
function to perform. |
It is clear that Alaska has power to regulate and control
activity within her ‘erritorial waters, at least in the
‘absence of conflicting federal legislation. Skiriotes v.
' Florida, 313 U. S. 69, 75. That case involved a state law
forbidding the use of certain equipment in taking sponges
in waters two marine leagues from mean low tide off
Florida’s coast. We‘upheld Florida’s power to regulate .
sponge fishing in that manner and in that area, as Con- |
gress hac not adopted any inconsistent regulation. See
+ also Toomer v. Witsell, 334 U.S. 385, 393. Alask®'s juris- .
diction to tax respondents’ operations within her terri-
torial waters—whether those activities are taking fish or
purchasing-fish taken by others—is equally clear. See
Wisconsin v. Penney Co., 311 U.S. 435, 444; Ott v. Mis-
sissippi Barge Line; 336 U.S. 169, 174.
ALASKA v. ARCTIC. MAID. | 5
< If the fish were taken or purchased outside Alaska’s
territorial -waters, all of respondents’ business in the
Bristol Bay area would be beyond Alaska’s reach. But
since some of the fish in all of the cases before us were
taken in Alaska’s waters or -otherwise acquired there,
respondents are engaged in business in Alaska when they
ogee their “freezer ships.” For we know from this rec-
‘ord that in this particular business taking and freezing are ~
practically inseparable. Fish are highly perishable and —
cannot be kept fresh very long even in Alaska’s latitude.
The process of gathering fish either through the catcher ©
boats that ‘are part of respondents’ fleet or through inde-
pendent operators is a “local activity” (M ichigan-Wiscon-
sin Pipe Line Co. v. Calvert, supra, 166) in a vivid sense of
the term. We see no reason why our cases involving the ©
taking of shrimp (Toomer v. Witsell, supra) and the
extraction of ore (Oliver Iron:Mining Co. v. Lord, 262
U. S. 172) are not dispositive of this controversy. The
“Oliver Iron case is indeed a first cousin of the present
case. Here, as there, the tax is an occupation. tax. Here. ~
as there, the market for the product obtained locally is
interstate, the taking being a step in a process leading td
- an interstate market. In both the local product is
promptly loaded for interstate shipment. But, in each
there is a preliminary local business being conducted—
an occupation made up of a series of local activities which
the State can constitutionally reach. Catching the fish
or obtaining them in other ways from the. local market is
but an extension of the freezer ship’s operations within
Alaska’s waters,
It is claimed that there was no tax on salmon caught and
‘ frozen in Alaska and destined for canning in Alaska and
that therefore this law is discriminatory against freezer
ships. Alaskan canneries, however, paid a six percent tax
on the value of salmon obtained for canning; * and local .
L. 1949, ¢. 82, §'1 (a), as amended, L. 1951, ¢. 113, § 1.
>
6 ALASKA v. ARCTIC MAID.
fish processors, which sell to the fresh frozen consumer
market, paid a one percent tax.’ The freezer ships do
not compete with those who freeze fish for the retail
market. The freezer ships take their catches south for
canning. Their competitors are the Alaska canners; and
we know from the record that fish canned locally usually
are not frozen.t When we look:at the tax laid on local
_canners and those laid on “freezer ships,” there is no dis-
crimination in-favor of the former and against the latter.
For no matter how the taxon “freezer ships” is computed,
it did not exceed the six percent tax on the local canners.
Hence cases such as Pennsylvania v: West Virginia, 262
_ U. S. 553, 595-596, which hold invalid state laws that
prefer local sales over interstate sales are inapposite.
If there is a difference between the taxes imposed. on
these freezer ships and the taxes imposed on. their com-
petitors, they are not so “palpably disproportionate”
(Harvester Co. v. Evatt, 329 U.S. 416, 422) as to run
afoul ‘of the. Commerce Clause. No “iron rule of
equality”. between taxes laid by a State on different’
types of business is necessary. Caskey Baking Co. v.
Virginia, 313 U. S. 117, 119-121; Morf v. Bingham, 298
U. 8. 407, 414; Capitol Greyhound Lines v. Brice, 339 .
U. S.542, 546-547.
* The judgment is reversed. Since we do not know how
- many fish, if any, were obtained outside Alaska’s terri-
torial waters,» we remand‘ the cause to the Court of
Appeals for proceedings in conformity with this opinion.
¢ Reversed.
*L. 1949, c. 97, Ppp euse nt L. 1951,.¢. 116, §1 (a).
‘Fish are sometimes frozen for local canneries when the run is
more than the canneries can take care.of; but that freezing is merely
an adjunct of the jocal canning industry.
$ Alaska contends that its territorial waters in the Bristol Bay
“area reach .beyond -the usual three-mile limit. That is a claim on
the merits of which we express no.opinion. ‘ &
o °
SUPREME couRT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 106.—Octoser Ter, 1960.
| es Oe Writ of Certiorari |
State of Alaska, re is the Valeek fae
. nas Court of Appeals. for
Arctic Maid, et al. ; the Ninth Ciréuit. —
{May 1, 1961.]
Mr. Justice .HaRLan, dissenting.
It is with’reluctance that I have reached the conclusion |
that this Alaska tax offends. the Commerce Clause of the
Federal Constitution. (Art. I, § 8, cl. 3.)
The Court of Appeals concluded that the taxable pan ;
. under this atatute is the process of freezing fish aboard
ship. 277 F. 2d 120. This conclusion was based on the
words of the statute (quoted at p. —— of the Court’s
opinion), the fact that obtaining fish for local sale or
consumption is untaxed, and the fact that the present
tax “applies whether or not the fish are caught by gill-
. fetters owned by or under contract to appellants.”’- /d.,
125-126. Accepting, as I do, this construction of the
statute, I agree with the Court of Appeals that a privilege
tax directed solely at shipboard-freezing, preparatory to
interstate shipment, exceeds the limitations the Commerce _
Clause imposes upon the States, for in its requirement
of a license such a tax asserts a power to deny what is a
necessary local. incident’ of the right to make interstate
’ purchases. See York Manufacturing Co. v: Colley, 247
U. 8. 21.°
*I also regard the tax as invalid because it in effect charges a toll
for the interstate transportation of Alaska’s natural resources. S¢ée
Brown, Justice Frankfurter—The Qpen Economy, 67 Yale L. J. 219,
_ 232-233. - ;
so ALASKA ». ARCTIC MAID.
As I understand. the* Court’ 8 opinion, it seeks to meet ©
this objection. by denying that the Alaskan tax is imposed
on the privilege of freezing fish aboard ships. It says that
_ the tax is rather upom the local taking or purchase of fish
~ by or for.freezer boats. But even on this view of the
_ incidence of thie tax, I could not agree that the present tax
on obtaining fish by or for interstate freezer boats would
be constitutional in the given circumstances, for I do not
think that Alaska can place a higher tax on the obtaining
and freezing of fish for interstate ‘markets than it places
on the obtaining and freezing of fish for local markets.
See Pennsylvania v. West Virginia, 262 U. S. 553, 596,
597. As shown in the Court’s opinion, under the Alaska .
scheme of taxation freezer boats which operate solely _
in interstate commerce, ‘must pay a tax for taking and
freezing Alaskan fish for later canning in Washington
which is four times that imposed‘on a local freezer whose
product is sold to consumers in Alaska. A shore-based
freezer who sells his .frozen product. to Alaskan canners
_ Pays no tax at all.
For these reasons I would: affirm the judgment of the
_ Court of Appeals.
e
|
ctemntmeenahentliedieeaeinoe a ee
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.