Brief for the Appellant — Huron Portland Cement Co. v. City of Detroit
Supreme Court brief1960
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
- Ullice-Supreuie-Lourt, U.S.
“LIBRARY ce FIiED
- « BPePRI ae SUR? 1p Ss. : JAN 18 19bU
JAMES R. BROWNING, Clerk |
- Supreme Court fi the United States.
_ OCTOBER TERM, 1959
en
No. 86
——
- HURON PORTLAND CEMENT COMPANY,
a Michigan corporation,
Appellant, .
ve .
CITY OF DETROIT, a Michigan seitehaed corporation,
BENJAMIN LINSKY, Chief, Bureau of Smoke
Abatement, P. J. LAREAU, _ .
Appellees a
»"
—————
>
APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE
OF MICHIGAN
———
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLANT
endless
ALFRED E. LINDBLOOM,
Attorney for Appellant,
1100 Ford Building,
: Detroit 26, Michigan.
OF Counsel:
‘CHARLES WRIGHT, JRs
4t,AURENCE A: MASSELINK,
; _ 1100 Ford Building, — °
> « Detroit 26, Michigan. .
. laterstate Briel & Record Co. ot] Beaadien St.. Detrost 26. Michigas
4 aie
° » a2 4
INDEX.
. ' Page ts
wy \
CPeemenm WEIOW 2.4... cess See 1. -
Jurisdiction ......... Pere Pe Se Tee eee ee 2
Constitutional provision, statutes and ordinance ing ,
PE Sit coker De pede th ity yea ir man es ee
Questions presented 22.2... RARE BE Peery Para? se
CR ee eer ny rer eR enCE eee = ee
Summary of argument............... eyes ants Be, ae
: ” . A : - F a .
Argument:
I. Where Congress has provided for the dnspec-
‘tion and licensing of steamshipse a city: may
i not apply its smoke ordinance to such steam-
ships where the ordinance in effect-prohibits
the use of the equipment on such steamships 7
If. If Congress has not expressly. pre-empted the /
field, the Detroit: smoke erdinance «materially a? sree
affects interstate commerce m matters where Xe
uniformity is necessary... abees paiser ce.
Conelusion .. 5.0.0.0... yoeeeees ee ree Sere on BL
. : °
' APPPENDIX . ,
34 Stat. 68, 46-0 SoC. 362 “(19n2- lk Ree me ad
R: S. See, HO1, 46 ELS. C. 364 (952 ed) .e. ee. da aia °
69 Stat. 86, 46°U. SoC. 399 (1952 ed, Supp. W)..... Bae fs 0
TO Stat. 223, 46 USC. amt (M2ed., Supp. Veo... da sake
“U0 State 224 (h) (¢ ). 44) . oC, 392 (1952 ed... Supp.
Been 2 Dek CA er re eee eevertes ee ~. * e
pms Sh! En GO Te ene ne ora Ree
il
; Paye
53 Stat. 798, 46. U.S. C. 496 (1952'ed.)..... 2... Se:
49 Stat. 1367, 46 U - U. Sas (IRS €d.).. 0. es cae da
. Bee, 2.24 Ordinance, ...... see tees Seeger ce a Da
See, 2 16 Ordinance. AERP ON HAL eye ee eee 6a
LL See. 2 17 Ordinance. weer Reale mrrnm tyne ence ree Ga
See. 2. 2) Ordinance. pees Piece on eae ene eu we aes a
See. 2.21 Ordinance. cuteness Serer Poe PT 3 7a
See. 3.2 Ordinance. peqgoeess See Ty Enea a
v ° XQ
CITATIONS
\ |
Cases: im? 5 ol ls : . " Page
-.. Freeman v. Hewit, 329 U.S. 249. a 7 ee ue ae - 8
Gibbons vy. Ogden, 9 W heat. Re hUsekueaw eee
Hill v. Florida, 325 FS. 5388. 2 he Cw ae weues sets de
Kelly v. W ashington, 302 . S Merry etree 7, 10,17
Morgan v. Vi irginia, goo t’.-&. ae voc ve ache cas - jd
* Napier v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad, : O72,
OOP. sacred Poe gh une oR al MP = oh San eer 11°
People vi Cunatd W hite Star, Ltd. 280. N.Y, 413, 7
ot N. BE. 28. 480.\..:... Gs UA sis Chast asddes cn oe
; ‘Servic Storage & Transfer C olipany Vv. Virginia,
= 0 VU. &. 171... .%: ee Caea ve ead compat ane a * ‘H
Southern Pacific v. A tizora, 3 325 ae lS Pee 16
Constitutional Provision: we:
_ «Article I, See. 8, Cliuge 3...........; ER apie a8 .
ee <a hate a 2 2
in,
United States. Statutes: ~
45 U.S. C., See. 22-34..... Ce een
49 Stat. 1367, 46 ‘ S.C. 263-1952 ed.) 2:5.....-:
69 Stat. 36, 46.0. S.C. 399 (1952 ed, Supp. V)....
70 Stat. 224 (b), "46 U. S.-€. a2 (hb) (952 ed.,
Supp. a ) ete eee eee, cig Se gle ele ele aiacete ace © ane
mil Stat. P24 (©), 46 LC. S..C. 392 (e) (1952 ed.,
BE is. canes caine chadien covet e Cras es |
Detroit Smoke Ordinances: . "
WA eR ee ee oe te oie ea eee
cS 2” Spee Ty Oy gee, Pan tere ed geen Taree
RS fs Earn eA, eS Marana ra ne aera
Es re da nec aor eee eEParkintan,
GFE Nias ss bka te ateeateseustcakrs ens eeags Ke
- Supreme cart of a ‘the United States
»™
aa
esi
+
HURON PORTLAND CEMENT )MPANY,
a Michigan corporatiot
_* Appellant,
: ei ;
- CITY OF DETROIT, a Michigan municipal corporation,
ba Set BENJAMIN LINSKY, Chief, Bureau of Smoke .
ey Abatement, P. J. LAREAU, —
Appellees .
~~
a.
vv
APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE
OF MICHIGAN “ok
%
a
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLAN T
Pete : ° ie
*> a
_ OPINION - BELOW
a “The Opinion of the Supreme Céurt of Michigan (is. “98.
34) is reported at 355 Mich, 227 and 93 N. W. 2d 888.
(1959). . ee cee
bo
ee
JURISDICTION
The deeree of the Supreme Court of the State of Michi-
- gan was entered January 12, 1959 (R. 35). - Notice of ap-
peal to the Supreme Court of the United States was filed +
with the Clerk ‘of the Circuit Court. for the County of .
“Wayne, Michigan (that being the ‘court possessed of the ~
record) on. April 9, 1959 (R. 1). The jurisdictional sch eears
was filed ‘June a 1959. Probable: jurisdiction was noted in
this case on October 12, 1959 (R. 44). . The jurisdiction of
this Court. rests on 28 U. S.C. 1257 -(2).
CQNSETTUEIONAL PROVISION, STATUTES
AND ORDINANCE INVOLVED ,
>.
:
‘Article T, See: 6 Clause 3 of the Feral ANE
grants to Congress the. power: **To regulate Commerce
With foreign’ Nations, and among: the several. States and
with the Indian Tribes; - | |
The statutes compiled under Title 46—Shipping—of the
United States ¢ ‘ode are involved, | T he more ger ones
are: The first paragraph ol " ges OS, 46 UL S.-C. 862
* (1952 ed.) Re S. pipe 46 UL S.C. 364 (1952 ayy 10 Stat.
223 (b), 46.0, ~ C,-301 (1952 a Supp. V); 70 Stat, 224
(b) and (e), 46 — S.C. 392 (1952 éd., Supp. V): 69 Stat.
86.46 UL S.C. 399 (1952 ed, Supp. V): 53 Stat. 798, 46 *
eUl Ss. C2496 (1952 ed.) : 49 Stat..1567, 46 UL SOC. 263 (1952
ed.) These statutes are. lengthy and their pertinent text
is set forth invan append x attached hereto,
Ordinance No. 163-E of tha City of Detroit is ‘affixed.
to page 37 of the record, The more pertinent provisions
3 uf nt
. ‘ i x j
- the ordinance, to wit, Sections: 2.2.A, 2.16, yy Se |
21 and 3.2 are lengthy and are set forth in the ‘appendix:
attac ‘hed he reto. -
‘ eo as: es
QUESTIONS. PRESENTED -
| baie Congress has povided for the inspection and
licensing of: vessels engaged in interstate commerce .and’
appellant’s vessels have been inspected by the United States
Coast Guard and granted permission to navigate on the
Great Lakes and have been enrolled’ and. Jicensed by the’
Treasury Department of the United States to carry on |
coasting and foreign trade, is the smoke“ordinance of the /
City of Detroit, Michigan valid as to’ said. vessels, when
it provides for the inspection. of the boilers’ on the. vesstis |
and prohibits their use, and are the penalty provisions of
said ordinance valid as to appellant's vessels when , the
prohibited smoke cannot always be prevented by the hoilers
inspected, approved and licensed by the United States?
2. Where the smoke ordinance of the City of Detroit,
‘Michigan provides for ag inspection, of combustion equiy--
ment and prohibits use of ceriain. kinds of boilers and
equipment on vessels engaged in interstate and foreign
commerce on the Great’ Lakes, and prohibits the emission
. of smoke which cannot be prevented at all times with boilers
and equipment commonly used on the Great Lakes, does
such ordinanée unduly burden interstaté and foreign com-.
merce in matters where uniformity is necessary under the
Commerce Clause of the Uiiited. States Constitution, Arti-
cle.1, Section & Cl. af aad os
STATEMENT > ch |
Appellant’s flect, which is engaged in interstate ‘com: |
‘merce, consists of four steamships and one motor vessel
-(R. 17, 29). It transports bulk cement from - ‘appellant’s -
mill at Alpena, Michigan to its distributing plants located.
in various cities on the Great Lakes (R. 17). The four -
steamships are equipped with hand fired scotch marine
‘boilers (R. 17). . a «
These vessels are subject to inspection by the T sited
States Coast Guard and the Cgrtificate of Inspection as
to S. S. S. T.. Crapo was introd ced in_evidence as plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 2 (R. 19, 38. 41). This Certificate contains
the folowing sentence: ‘*The said vessel is. permitted to
be navigated for one.year on the Great Lakes” (R. 39).
The vessels are also enrolled with the Treasury Depart-
- ent of the United States Bugeau of Customs. The Con-
solidated Certificate of Knrolgnept and License as to S.S.
John. W. Boardman.was intr duced as plaintiff’s Exhibit:
A ‘(See photostat opposite R. 42). This Certificate which
is issued by the Bureau of Customs contains this litense:
‘License is hereby granted forthe said vessel to be em--
. ployed in earrying on the COASTING AND FOREIGN
TRADE for ONE YEAR :from.the date hereof, and no
longer.” It is conceded that Certificates of Inspection,
like plaintiff’s Exhibit 2, and Certificates of -Enrollment’
and License, like plaintiffs kK xhibit A, wére issued for’ ‘each |
vessel. 7
On Siicdiadie 20, 1955,+Wo criminal .cases were started
in the Recorder’ s Court for the City of Detroit, Traffic and
Ordinance Division. One case named appellant and the
‘ officers of 'S.S. John W. Boardman as defendants awd the |.
#
™ ;
\ ae a
.
other appellant ‘and the Officers of S Ss. S.T. Crapo (R. 18).
In these cases, it was charged that appe ‘Hant and the other
defendants .had violated the criminal. provisions of the
smoke ordinanée of the City of Detroit, in:that the eimis- ,
‘sion of smoké of the kind prohibited by the ordinane © had
_ been permitted for a period of nine‘or ten minutes on De-
cember 12, 1955 while the vessels were docked at the feodt- .
_ of Riopelle Street in the City of, Detroit, Michigan (R._
18)., This ordinance was introduced at the trial.as’plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 5 5) anda copy of the same is attached to ‘page
37 of the record. :
Appellant filed a bill of complete’ in the’ Circuit Court
for the County of Wayne, Michigan, alleging . that its fleet
¢ ; :
. was engaged in interstate and foreign commerce and that
~
the Constitution of the United States gave Congress full
and complete authority and power. to regulate such eom-
merce and that Congress had enacted laws and regulations -
covering the construction, equipment and operations of *
vessels engaged i in interstate commerce on the Great Lakes.
The bill further alleged that appeHant’ s vessels had been
Ri ~ inspbeted and approved by the U nited States Coast Guard
— (R. 5), It was also alleged that it was necessary for its
fleet to dock in ‘the City of Detroit to unload cement and —
during that time full steam in the boilers had to be’ main-
tained and. every four hours the fire under the boilers had
to be cleaned. When a fire is cleaned it:is impossible’ to _
prevent the emission of the kind of smoke prohibited. by
the Detroit smoke ordinance with the equipment which had -
_ Keen_approved. by the United States Coast Guard. (R. 4,
18). Appellant sought’to enjoin the prosécution of the
two criminal cases ‘and to enjoin the enforeement of the.
- Detroit smoke ordinance against it. unless the emission of
the prohibited smoke is caused: by-improper firing or by *
the impgoper. use of the equrpment:on said vessels (R. 7).
a
Gi
G
The SS. S. T. Crapo doc ‘ked at Detroit, 1 in 1855, twenty.
piv times for an average. docking time. of 23.9 ours ane
ws. John Wy Boardman doe ked at Detroit, twenty: -five -
, tee during that vear, with an average stay of 16.2 hours:
(R19). read ive es vx
7 At the trial, it was conceded that the Detroit smoke ordi-
nance could mot be complied with at all times with hand:
fired scoteh imag hoilers (R. 1S). It appeared that the
’ smoke ordinance uld be complied with if oil burning
_ equipment or a well constructed underfeed stoker was in-
stalled on the vessels (R. 14-16). It would cost roughly
| $70,000 to equip either the SS, John AV, Boardman or: the
“SS! SD Ty-Crapo with an underfeed stoker and at least
ye each to equip them with oil aetene equipment
(R. 2 eee, ee
The a eourt filed a written, opinion (R. 16-26) and a
decree was entered: dismissing the bill of complaint (R. 27).
On appes ul to the Supreme Court .of Michigan, the decree >
entered in the trial court was affirmed “(R..28-34,,35).
” ,
SUMMARY OF ‘ARGUMENT
1. Inasmfich as appellant’ s vessels ina their equipment
“have been inspected, approved and lice nsed by ‘the -[nited .
States Coast Guard under authority from Congress, the’
Detroit smoke ordinanc® may not require the inspection’. ,
- and approval of the same equipment or impose criminal
penalties for the emission of smoke which cannot at all
times. he avoided by vésscls having equipment inspected
‘and licensed by the United States Coast Guard.
— 2. The Commerce C lause of the. United States Constitu-
~ tion in and of itself pre-empts the field. where uniformity
a
™
Fy : . ~N
. t “ .
~ @e-.- :
~
°
- ; \ |
‘
is necessary and,. therefore, the Detroit Smoke Ordinance
nay not validly he applied to vesstls engaged in interstate
commerce because it materially burdens such commerce
where uniformity-is necessary. oe
ve Dt 0 ARGUMENT .
; : ae is.
WHERE CONGRESS HAS PROVIDED FOR THE INSPECTION
AND LICENSING OF STEAMSHIPS, A CITY. MAY NOT -
APPLY ITS SMOKE ORDINANCE TO SUCH: STEAMSHIPS.
- WHERE THE ORDINANCE IN EFFECT PROHIBITS THE USE
oF THE EQUIPMENT ON SUCH STEAMSHIPS. srs
Article Zz. Sec, 8 . Clause 3 3, of the Federal Constitution
a
gives Congress. the power, ** “To remilate Commerce with
foreign Watiene. and amonrtg the several States, and with.
the Indian Tribes;". $: :
'D nder this provision, Congress has enacted laws oon.
cerning steamships engaged in’ navigation ahd these laws -
are’ applicable to the — Lakes. These statutes are_
compiled in Title 46.0.8. C. es
Kelly nF ace 302 U.S. . 1, ‘+ i008). With refer-
ence té these, acts, the Court
The federalacts and regulations with respect: to
‘vessets on the navigable waters of the United States
are elaborate.” They are well described in the argu-
ment of the Assistant Solicitor General as a maze
“of reguhition. "Provisions with réspect to steam
vessels are extremely detailed. 46 UL S.C. @ 14,
See, S61 ef seq.” ; °
70 Stat. 224 (b), 46 U.S. C392 (h) (1952 ed., Supp. V)
_ provides that the Coast Guard is to inspect at least once
.
Ss
every two years the boilers, unfired pressure vessels and
appurtenances thereof of all vessels other than passenger.
vessels, “Subséction (¢) provides that the Coast Guard is
to determine to its satisfhetion that the boilers, untired
‘pressure vessels and equipment may he safely emplaved
‘in the service proposed. “There is also contained in this
section this sentence: ‘No boiler, unfired pressure vessel,
or appurtenance thereof shall. be allowed to "be -used if
constructed in whole ‘or in- part-of defective material or
- which-hecause of jts form, design, workmanship, age, use
or for any other reason is unsafe” (.App..la, 2a).
69 Stat. 86, 46. S.C. 399 (1952 ed., Supp. V) provides .
that when the inspection of a steatn Vessel is completed
and the Coast Guard approves the vessel and her equipment
throughout, a certificate to that effect shall be made (App.
~. Sa). Plaintiff's Exhibit 2 (Ro 38-41) is this certificate
and after describing the boiler and other equipment, pro-
- vides: ‘The said vessel is. permitted to be navigated for
“one-year on the Great Lakes” (R. 39). In accordance With
49 Stat. 1367, 46 UL S. C2263 .(1952 ed.) (App. 4a), plain-
tiff’s Ex. A was issued (Sce photostat opposite R. 42).
This exhibit is a consolidated. certificate of enrolhment and -
_ license’ ‘aind it includes the following:
: “LIC ENSK is Kereby granted for the said ‘een
. to he employ ed in carrying onthe COASTING AND
FOREIGN. TRADE for ONE YEAR from the date -
hereaf,-and no longer.” ’
Gibbons v. Ogden, 0. Wheat. l, 43 (1894) : :
“*The word ‘Ticense* means permission, or author-
ity; and a license to do apy particular: thing, is a
permission or authority to, do, that thing: and if:
* granted by a person having power to gfant it, trans:
fers tothe grantee the right to de whateyer it pur-
ports to authorize. It certainly transfer to him all
. : ; ad - sg b Q . ! . v3; “. oe
‘ " =
the rights which the grantor ean transfer, to do~
-What is within the terms of the Jicense.”’
- ° pa “aay .
paig ,
Adinittedly, Congress: under the ‘one ree C ae has
anthirity ty: control .interstate commerce and the two Ii-
Lenser, above: teferred to, under Gibbons transfer to ap
pellant’s vessels the right fo navigate the Greaf Lakes. The
| licenses’ include the right tof use the vessels as equipped
“when inspected’and when enrolled. * ‘.
Section 22% of the Detroit smoke ordinance prohibits
the emission of the kind of smoke which cannot be at all
tithes preven V vessels equipped with hand fired scoteh
marine boilers, (App. da) (RL 1S). See. 2.16 of the ordi-
nance makes it. unlaw ful-to use ¢ uny furnace or other com-
bustion equipment or ‘device i in the city without a certificate
of operation which issues only after Inspection (App. Ga).
See. 2.17, with exceptions not important here, provides for.
an annual inspection of every furnace or other‘combustion ,
ee used Wwythin the city (App. ‘Ga). Under See.
20, if an owner has been previously notified’ of three or
Tore Violations of thie’ ordinance’ within any. consecutive
_ twelve month period, such owner shalk-he notified to show:
cause: before the Commissioner why the equipnient slroul 1
not be sealed. AT the hearing, if: the C ommissioner: ‘finds
that adeqnate corrective means have not been employed.
to remedy the situation, the « equipment shall be sealed
( App. Ga). See, 3.2 prov ‘ides fot av fine of $100.00 or im-
_prisonment of not. more than 30 days upon conviction of
violation of any, provision of the ordinance and that each
day a violation is permitted to exist shall constitute a sepa. |
vate offense (App. 7a).
Thits, the ordinance requires the inspection and approval
of the equipment which hag “been inspected and approved:
-by the United States Coast Guard. The ordinance afso
. 10
provides for the sealing. of ,the equipment, if the owner
ix notified of three or more_violations within “a year, not- |
withstanding the fact that it has been approved «by the-
~- Coast Guard under authority of Congress. “The ordinance
also provides. for fine “and imprisonment for violations. of
the, ordinance which cannot be avoided through the use
_ of equipment expressly approved and licensed by the fed-
eral xovernment. :
Kelly ve W rashington, 302 v; S. 1, 4 (1937). - Here the
“Court was discussing statutes of the State-of Washington
concerning the inspection’ of mator tugs and said:
“The first question is whether the state Maisie.
tion as applied to: respondents’ motor-driven tugs is
in dll respects in confliet with express. provisions of *
the federal laws and regulations.” Wherever such
_ conflict exists, the state legislation must fall. .Gib-
bons v.Ogden, 9 Wheat. 1, 210.”
“Appellant submits that the Detroit smoke ordinance is
in conflict With the express provisions of ‘the federal laws
and regulations in that both provide for the inspection of,
the salne equipment, to wit, the hand fired scotch marine *
boiler. Further, a certificate of operation would not issue
under the ordinance for a scotch marine boiler and, there-
fore, such a boiler could not be used, although it had been
- inspec ‘tod and approved by the United States Coast°Guard.
¢
Kr urther, the smoke ordinance. contains criminal provisions
for its violatio# which cannot at all times he avoided by
Vessels: equipped with hand fired scotch marine boilers
(R. 98). Thais, the use-of equipment which is approved and
licensed by the federal govermnent. for navigation on. the
Great Lakes could cause appellant and the officers ofits
‘vessels to be guilty: of violating the ordinance.
It probably will he argued, that the Detroit ordinance
is aimed: at the prevention of air pollution and not at any
- .
a
. . 2
. .
z ; : 1]
. vk
. . 2°
.
regulation of interstate commerce aml tat it alferts intert-
state commerce, i ated! only ambirectly aad inerdentally,
is Such an areument comple telyiznores the facts. tis true
‘that the. City of Detroit is not directly seeking to regulate -
interst late Commerce, but the ording nee does so when the |
SEUNG rain only be complied with thraugh the use of ce rtiein
equipmelt upon vessels engaged jn interstate cominerces
The ¢gity isy by indirection, saving that only certain equip.
ment Ynay be uséd in interstate commerce, thus preventing
_the use of other equipment. As Congress has already pro-
vided for te inspection of this equipment, tlifre is a direct™
conflict between the acts of Congress and the Detroit
ordinance. . This conflict is emphasized when, it-is realized
that equipment which the Coast Guard has inspected anid
approved throughout may not be used in Detwoit and its
use Way, bring appellant, within the penal provisions of
‘the ordinance. ees |
‘The, Boiler Inspection Act, Sections 2 2-34 of Title 45;
U.8.C. provides | for the inspection of railroad locomotives.
It is not too dissimilar from the acts governing the | INS pec-
tion ‘of steamships. Under the Boiler Inspection Act, the
Court has had-the problem of determining conflicts between .
State statutes and that-Aet. In that.case, we believe the -
-- conflict was much less direct than in our case, for there
the state statutes merely required the addition of certain
equipment, but such statutes were held invalid heeause they
and the Boiler Inspection Act were directed to the same
subject, to wit, the equipine nt of locomotives. Here we
have the ordinance prohibit ® the use of the particular
equipment which has been in all respects nepeeres by the
federal government,
Napier r Atlantic Coast Line’ Railroad, 272. t S. G05, .
G12 (1926). : In Georgia a statute was passed requiring
automatic fire doors on locomotives and in Wi isconsin an-
.
Other statute was passed requiring cah curtains during the
winter. The Court held that bot statutes were
void even if the Interstate Commerce Commission had madg
no order requiring a particular type of fire door or tab
curtain, holding that the Boiler Inspection Act. ‘confer red
- upon the, Interstate Commerce Commission the exclusive
power to specify the sort of equipment-to be used-on loco-°
motives.
The Cou rt sdid: —- oat SOF ——
a
“Did Congress intend that there might still he
- state regulatiom of locomotives, if the measures were
directed primarily toi the pramotion of health and
comfort and affected safety, if:at all, only inciden-
tally? : '
same subject—fhe equipment of locomotives. They
Operate upon the same object. It is suggested that
the. power delegated to the Commissioner has been
' exerted only Ma \fespese to minor changes or addi-
- tions. But-this, If true, is not of legal significance.
‘It is also urged that, even if the Commission has
power to prescribe an automatic fire. box door and
~cab eu curtain, it has not dane so; and that it has made
ho other requirement inconsistent with the state
legislation, This, also, if true, is Without legal sig
nificance. The fact that the- Commission’ hao
_ seen fit to exercise its authority to the full extent”
conferred, has no bearing upow the construction of
the Act delegating the power. We hold that-state
legislation is precluded, because. the Boiler Inspec-
-The federal omit ntate statutes are direc ted te the:
‘. tion Agt, as we construe it, was-intended ‘to éceupy .
the field. The broad scope of the authority con-.
ferred upon the Commission leads Yo that conelu-
sion. Because the standards set-by the C ommission
must prevail, requirements of thie states are pre-
Cluded, however commendable or however different
their purpose.” ——— added.) -
Hill vr. Florida, 325 US
as ena . | -.s ;
**But here, this agent has been enjoined, and if
the Florida law is valid he could be found guilty of
a contempt of doing that which the act of Congress
permits him to do. Furthermore, he could, under
Section: 14.0f-the state law, be convicted of a misde-
meanor and subjected: to. fine and iunprisonme
The collective. bargaini gress lias au-
__therized-contemiplates two parties ‘free to bargain.
and cannot thus be frustrated by. state legislation.
We hold that Section 4 of the Florida. Act is repug- .
nant to the National Labor Relations Act.” ih We
—
Service Storage and Transfer Co. wv Virginia, 359. U.S.
171, 176 (1959). Petitioner ad been granted a certificate
by the Interstate Commerce Commission to engage as a
motor earrier hetwéeen, certain points. Freight from and
to points in Virginia was routed ‘through West Virginia.
Virginia claimed that this was a sham and, that, the.peti-
tioner was guilty of engaging in intrastate freight business |
without permission and fined the petitioner $3,500. Held:
“To uphold the criminal fine’ fiere assessed would
be tantameunt to a partial suspension of. peti- » -
tioner’s federally granted'certificate.”
_. We submit that if the Detroit smoke ordinance i is applie-
able to vessels engaged in interstate commerce, compliance
with such ordinance necessarily dictates the equipment.
which must be used upon such vessels and, therefore, in-
‘trudes upon a field pre-empted by Congress. ;
I.
IF CONGRESS i1AS NOT EXPRESSLY PRE-EMPTED THE.
FIELD, THE DETROIT SMOKE ORDINANCE MATERIALLY
AFFECTS INTERSTATE COMMERCE IN MATTERS WHERE
UNIFORMITY Is NECESSARY. eax %
If the Detroit smoke ordinanee may be validly applied °
to vessels engaged in interstate commerce,-other éities,
Villages and hamlets on re Great Lakes could pass diffe rent
and varying smoke’ ordinawces, One city could pass an
‘ordinance which couldn’t be complied with even though the
vessel had a properly installed underfeed) stoker. An-
“other-eity might pass a smoke ordinance which couldn't he
complied with even if the vesselhad ot burning —
This argunent is not absard because in’ People rv. C unard
White Star, Ltd., 280 N, ¥; 413, 21 N. K.. 2d 489 (1939),
the Queen Mary was’ found euilty of violating .a smoke.
x
‘See of the City.of New: York by a lower court, even .
thong ? the Queen Mary had: oil burning equipnient,
\It is nota valid argument to say that if a vessel has
equipment whieh will comply with the most severe smoke
ordinance, that the vessel. is, therefore, safe, because in
the future an ordinance might be enacted whieh would
require ‘higher standards, It does not’ necessarily follow.
that a smoke ordinance would be unconstitutional even if
it could not be complied) with byva vessel with the best
equipment, The n, too, courts of the various states might
differ on whether a smoke ordinance is. réasonablesetam1--—
reasonable, It follows that if compliance with an ordi-
nance is inseparably connected with the kind of equipment.
on a vessel, esuch ordinance alfects: interstate commerce —
where uniformity’ is required,
es ‘9 . ay
°
The effect wf the Detrpit: ordinance on interstate Got.
Inerce is matertal, dn this case it would cost roughly ‘$70,
OOO0to equip eacef the appellant's vessels with aun unde T-
feed stoker, and at least, $100,000 to equip each vessel with
oil burning eqitipme nt (RR. 2). “Thescost is extremely
material, “ind when that is multiplied by the number a
vesse|s engaged 3 in interstate commerce-on the Great Lakes |
‘ equipped with hand fired ‘scotch marine boilers, the cost °
becomes fantastic. A city, coukl pass a smoke ordinance.
which could be complied with only if some very different.
form of equipinent is used and the cost of which cannot
even be estim ated,
In-the Supreme Court of Michigan, te this case, there -
were several amicus ougree. briefs filed. One was filed on
behalf of Lake Carriers’ Association. In this brief, it .
was stated i in a.footnote: ** At the efose- of the 1957 naviga-
tion season the combined Canadian (282 vessels} and United
States (415 vessels) Great Lakes commercial fleet totaled’
. 697 vessels, including car ferries and passenger steamers.
While the accurate‘ figures are not available, it is estimated
that of the total fleet, 463 burned coal for fuel, 277 being
hand fired, of which 256 have hand fired ante marine
boilers. U ndoubtedly, a great’ many of these vessels dock
vat Detroit. or pass through waters within the hens “| of
the City of Detroit, to- wit, the Detroit River.”
Morgan v. V irginia, 328 U.. S..373 7 (1946). The pro-
visions of the Virginia Code che separation of white
and cvlored passengers on both interstate. .and intrastate. ,
motor carriers. .The claim was made that this statute.
burdened interstate commerce, contrary: td the Commerce
(‘lause, even though Congress ‘had enacted no legislation
on the subject. The state claimed thaet this statute was
e ¥
passe Ad a the police pow er to avoid fri « tiow hetw een the, .
races. Thé C ourt said: | ? eae
The pre ‘ise. degree of a permissible restriction
on state power cannot he fixed generally or indeed
not even for one kind. ef state legislafion, sich as:
taxation or health or safety. There is-a recognized
abstract principle, showever, fhat may be taken as a
postulate for testing whether particular state legjs--
lation in the absence of ac tion by Congress is bevond
state power. This is that the state legislation is in-
_ Valid if it unduly burdens that commerce in matters.
where uniformity ‘is NeEcessArY—NevPssary in the
‘constitutional - sense .of.. useful in accomplishing a
permitted purpose... Where uniformity is essential
for the functioning of, commerce, a state may not .
interpose its local regulation * * *? ;
ee
P. 378: ae Sees
‘*In-the field of transportation, there has heen a:
series of decisions. which hold that where Congress
has not acted and although the state statute affects ,
interstate commerce, a state may validly enact se
legislation’ which has predominantly only a locaLine—— ;
fluence én the course of commerce. It ‘ts equally 4
- well settled that even where Congress has not geted,
state Jegislation or a, fmal court order is invalid
which materially fee ‘ts interstaté commerce,’
“Southern Pac ifie C Ov. Arizona, 325 U.S. 761, 773 (1 M4: 5).
Arizona limited passenger trains to 14 cars, freight trains
to 70 ears...
. “Enforcement of the law in Arizona, while train’
lengths remain unregulated or are. regulated ‘hy
varying standards in other states, must inevitably
result in an impairment of uniformity of efliciont @
railroad operation because the ‘railroads ate sub-
| jected. to regulation Which is. not. uniform -in. ‘its o
Sel applic ation.”
. i oo . °
é ee 1 ‘ . ° 4 a>
‘ o . , 4 \ -
: A ‘
“ar one state may reguiite train lengths; so may |
all the. others, and they Heed not prescribe the sre a
maxinuun limitation, The practical effect -of such
regu ulation i is to cont rol triin operations beyond the
boundaries of the state enacting it because of the
necessity .of breaking up ‘and reasseinbling long”
trains at the nearest terminal points'before entering,
and after-leaying the regulating state. The s°rious
iapediment_to the free flow of commerce by. the
local regulation of train lengths and ‘the practical |
necessity that’ such regulation, if any, must be pre-_
scribed by a single hody having a ‘nation- -wide au-~
thority are apparent.” : phases :
‘Kelly-x. WwW ashington, 302.U. S.1, 14 (1987): |
“Third. The remaining question is whether ‘the |
state law must fall in itS entirety, not becausé of acti
inconsistency with federal action, but "hina geal HA
subject i is one as to which uniformity of-Fegulation
is required and hence, whether or not Congress has ° . |
acted, the State is without authority. Cooley.v.—
Board of ane 12 How. .299, be: Minnesota
Rate Cases, 230 U.S. 352, 399, 400... |
**The state law is a sesailibaitins’ code. While
it excepts véssels which are subject to irispection
under, the laws: of the United States, it.has pro-
Visions which may be deemed to fall within-the class -
of regulations which’ Congress alone can provide,
For example, Congress may establish-standards.and °
desiqns for the structure and equipment of vessels,
and may prescribe rudes. for their operation, which ©
could not properly be left to the diverse action. -.
, . the States. -The State of W ashington ‘night -pre-
scribe standards, designs, equipment and rulés of
one sort, Oregon another, California another, and.
~ So on.”’ | (Emphasis added.)
<i
“SS
validly applied to appellan’s vessels,
Freeman " He wit, 8-11 U. S. 249, 252 (1946), This -case
- involves. the poline< Gross fasouiis Tax, Act of 1950. The
Court’ said: | |
“Our starting point is clear. In two reeent CASES
we_ applied the prinéiple: that: the Commerce ¢ ‘lause :
Was not merely an authorization to Congress to
enact laws for the protection and encotiragement ‘of
commerce ainong the States, but by sits own force
‘. ° ereated an-area ‘of trade free from interference by
the States. In short, the. Commerce Clause even
without implementing legislation by Congress is a’
‘ Innitation upon the pee. of the States. Southern *
. Pacific Co. v. alri: ona, 325 U.S. 761: Morgan vr. Vir-
a spmmey”
ginia, 328 ESS. 3732. In-so deciding we reaffirmed,
upon fullest consideration, the ‘course of ad judica-
tion unbroken through the. Nation’s.history. This _
7 limitation on State power, as the Morgan. case so
‘well illustrates, does not merely forbid a State to
single out interstate commerce for hostile action. A
State is.also precluded fronr taking any action which
may fairly be deemed to‘have the. effect of in ipeding
eae the free flow of trade between States. | It‘is imma-
terial that. local commerce .is subjected to a similar
encumbrance. It niay commend itself to a State to.
encourage .a ‘pastoral instead of an industrial so-
ciety. “That is its concern and its’ privilege.” But to
compare’ a State’s treatinent of its local trade. with
the exertion of its authority against commerce in the
national domain i is: to compare incomparables,””
Tlie operating equipment: on vessels, its. manufacture,
design and characteristics is extremely important to nitvi-
ration ‘Tf every’state, city, village or hanilet’ may inspect. :
such equipment and de cree’ that pr equipment meeting
its requirement may he used, navigation Will soon ce ase. .
i is respectfully ‘subinitted that the Detroit smnoke ordi- .
nance inaterially hurdens interstate Commerce in matters
where uniformity is necessary and, therefore, may not be
Ff 4"
- 19 83-°
“CONCLUSION.
or: ‘the: reasons stiited, it is vlapectfilly submitted that.
the decree of the court helow shold be. reversed and that
the Detroit smoke ordinance be held une onstitutional as
_ to appellant’s vessels, except where. the prohibited stnoke
is caused by improper firing. or by the i improper use of the
f equipment upon said vessels.°, |
eS ALFRED E, LINDBL OOM,
eit ae ye Attorney for Appellant,
Sie | . 1100 Ford Building, |
‘ ‘a Detroit 26, Michigan.
Of Counsel: eS | . eee
CHARLES WRIGHT, eg | a
LAURENCE A, MASSELINK, as
1100 Ford. Building, © - eit ere
$ ‘Detroit 26, Alichigan. a See :
January 15th, 1960. | | | Tne ang tse
APPENDIX —&
a.
4
34 Stat. 68, 46 U.S. C. 362 (1952 ed.). The first para-
graph. is as follows: paar ee
All steam vessels’ navi igating any waters of ‘the
C nited States which are cComnion. highways of com- | ~
merce or open to. general or competitive naviga-
tion, excepting publi¢ vesse:s of the United States,
vessels of offer countries, and boats propelled in
whole oy. in part by steam for aphhcscwm 2 canals, .
shall be subject to the. provisions of ‘title 52 of the
Revised Statutes.
ARS 4401, 46 Us s. C. 364, (1952 ed, ) is as follows:
‘All coastwise seagoing’ vessels, ont veodele navi-
gating the Great Lakes, shall be subject to the navi-
gations laws of the United States, when navigating
within the jurisdiction thereof; and all vessels, pro-
pelled in whole or in part by steam, and navigating
. as aforesaid, shall be subject to all the rules and
regulations established in pursuance of law for the
government of steam vessels’in-passing, as provided -
“by this Title;-and every coastwise: seagoing steanr
vessel subject to the navigation laws of the United
States, and to the rules and, regulations aforesaid,
‘not. sailing under. register, shall, when under way,
except on the high seas, be under the control and di-:
rection of pilots licensed by the Coast Guard.
70, Stat. 223, 46 U.S. {'. 391. (1952 ed., Supp. V) a
follows: . |
(h) The head of the « department | in which’ the.
Coast. Guard is operating shall require the Coast
Guard to inspect before the same shall be put into
service, and at least once in every two years t ere-
an |
Ya
70 Stat. 234, pean S. Cc. 302 (19. 5) ed., Supp. V) provides
as follows: %
“me
4 Stat ute s
after, the hull of each steam vessel, not carrying
passengers; to determine to its satisfaction that
every such vessel so submitted to inspection is of a
structure suitable for the service in which she is to
he employed, has suitable accommodations for the
crew, and is in a condition to warrant the belief that -
she may he used -in navigation, with safety to life,
and that the vessel ix in full compliance | with the.
applicable requirements of this title or Acts anrén-
dators or supplementary thereto and regulations
thereunder; and if deemed ‘expedient, to direct the
vessel to be put in motion or.to adopt any other suit-
able me: ins to test her suflicie ney and that.of her
equipment.
)
(b) The-head of the department in which the,
Coast Guard ‘is operating also shall ‘require. the
-Coast Guard to inspect, b®fore the.same shall be put
into -service and at least once in every two vears
thereafter, the boilers, untired pressure vessels, and
appurtenances thereof, also the propelling and
ment, of all. vessels. subjeat to inspection other than
passenger vessels,
ny
(ce) The head of the department i in wich the
Coasf Guard is operating shall. reqitire the Coast
. Guard to determine to its satisfactionSby thorough
examination that the boilers, unfired préssure ves-
sels, and appurtenances thereof, alse the propelling
and auxiliary machinery, clectrical apparatus anc
equipment of all vessels Which are subject to nspee-
tion under subsections (a) and (b) herein’ are in
conformity with law and the rules and regulations
of ‘the head of the department in which the Coast.
Guard is‘operating, vind may be safely emploved in
the sérvive proposed. “No boiler, unfired pressure |
‘Vessel, or appurtenances thereof shall be allo-.ed to
9
ee
auxiliary machinery, electrical apparatus and equip-*_
9
rd oe
é " ' ~ Statutes : i ja
. \ : bs : .
he used if constructed in whole or in part of. de-
~ fective material op which hecapse ofits form, de-
“+ Sign, workmanship,age, use, or for any other reason
is unsafe, A
69 Stat. 86, 46-0. S.C. 399 (1952 ed., Supp. V). provides
in part as follows: eae
When. the inspection of a steam vessel is com
pleted and the Secretary ‘of the Department in
which the Coast Guard is ‘operating approves the
‘vessel and her equipment throughout, he shall make
‘and subseribe a certificate to that effect. He shall .
.- deliver such certificate to the master‘or owner of
‘the vessel to which it relates, shall keep one copy
thereof on file in his office, and shall deliver one
copy to the official who is performing the duties of
the collector or other chief officer of the customs of
the district in which such inspection has been made,
- Who shall keeyy the same on file in his office.
53 Stat. 798, 46 U.S.C. 496. (1952-ed.) is as follows: ° ;
A register, enrollment, ‘or license shall not be .
granted, or other papers be issued by any collector —
or other chief officer of customs to any vessel sub-
ject. by law to inspection under this’ title (R. Ss.
4: 399-4500) until all the provisions of such title ap-
plicable to such vessel have been fully complied with
and until the copy of the certificate of inspection re-
quired by such title for such vessel has been filed
with said collector or other-chief officer of customs:
Provided, That the license granted to any vessel, if.
presented to any collector of customs at any time ,
AMWithin thirty « ‘alendar days prior to the date of ex-
piration shown thereon, may be renewed by the en-
dorsement by the collector of customs for a period
of one year from the date of expiration shown. on
‘the license, if there be on file in the office of the col-
lector at that time a copy of the certificate of i inspec-.
* tion required by. title 52 of the Revised Statutes,
which is-in force on, the date renewal is made. ||
\
i,
. . .
. ~*~ * .
‘a
Statutes
the 49 Stat 1367, 46 U. S. C. 263 (1952 ed.) is as follows:
| The form of a license for carr ving on the coasting.
trade or fisheries shaH be’ as follows:
—_— yoo
License for ‘arryving on the (here i inser “eoast-
ing. trade’, ‘whale fishery’, ‘mackerel fishery’, or
‘cod fishery” ‘as the case may be).
‘In pursuance of Title LL (RS. 4311-4390),
‘Regulation of Vessels in Domestic Commerce’, of .
the Revised Statutes of the United States, (insert-
ing, here the name of the husband or managing
owner, with Itis o¢cupation and place of abode, and
the name of the master, with the place of his abode), «= -
having sworn that’ the (insert here the description
of the vessel, whether «ship, brigantine, -scow,
‘schooner, sloop, or whatever else she may be); called
the (insert here the vessel’s name), whereof the said
(naming the master) is ‘master, burden (insert here
the number of tons, in words) tons, as appears. by
‘her enrollment, dated at (maming the district, day,
‘month, and year, in words at length, but if she be
‘less than twenty tons, insert, instead thereof, ‘proof
being had of her admeasurement’), shall not be em-
“ployed in any trade, while this license shall continue
‘in force, w hereby the revenue of the U nited States.
shall be defrauded, and having also. sworn (or af-
firmed) that this license shall not be used for any
other vesSel, or for any other employment, than is
Aterein specified, license is hereby granted for the
said (inserting here the description. of the vessel)
called the (insertingthere-the-veessel’s name), to be
employved‘in carrying on the (inserting here ‘coast-
ing trade’, ‘whale fishery’, ‘inackerel fishery’, or
‘cod. fishery’, as the case may be), for one vear from
the- date hereof, and no longer. Given under. my
hand and seal, at (naming the said district), this
(inserting the particular day) day of (maming the —
year. in words at length);’’: : Prov ided, That voxels:
¢
. ° ‘
month), in the vear (specifying the ntimber of the
Smoke Ordinance ja
of five net tons and over — under the laws of:
the’ United States to be enrolled 14 dor fi-
censed for the coasting trade may be licensed for”
the ‘coasting trade. and mackerel fishery’ . and sha!l
be deemed to have sufficient ficense for engaging in ;
the coasting trade and the taking of- fish of every —
-deseription, including shellfish: Provided further,
That the provisions of sections 310 and 311 of this
title shall be, and are made applicable to vessels so
licensed:. And. provided further, That: vessels oper-
ating on the Great Lakes and their connecting and
tributary waters under enrollment and license is-
sued in conformity«with- the provisions of section ~-
258 of this title, shall be deemed to have sufficient \,
license for efigaging in the taking of” fish of every
_ deseription within such waters without change in
the form of enrollment and license prescribed under
the authority of that section. :
SMOKE: ORDINANCE
y Section 2.2A:-" ~ | nee”
— It shall be unlawful within the City of Detroit for
any person, firm or corporation to permit: the emis-
sion of any smoke from any source whatever of a
density equal to or greater than that density de-
scribed as No 2 of the Ringlemann Chart; Pro-
‘vided, That the following exceptions to the pro-
‘Visions of this section shall be permitted :
(a) Smoke, the shade or appeatance of which is
equal to but not darker than No. 2 of the Ringle-
mann ‘Chart for a period, or periods, aggregating
four minutes in any 30 minutes;
(b) Smoke, the shade or appearangé of which is~ .
equal to but not darker than No: 3 of, the, Ringle-
mann Chart for a period, or periods, “Aggregating
‘three minutes in any 15 minutes, When building a
Ga. Saat Cee oe
poe
new fire or avhen bre: kdown of equipment occurs
‘such as to. make it evident that the emission. was -
net reasonably preventable.
Sec tione2, l6:°
It shall be unlawful for any ‘person, firm or cor-
poration To use or operate any furnace or other
combustion equipment er deviee which is subject to
annual inspection, ‘ax hereinafter set.forth, without
a certificate of operation; provided, however, that if
application for such certificate of operation has been
made and the réquired jnspection fee paid, it shalt
he lawful to use such furnace-or other fuel-burning
equipment or device until- receipt of such certificate
or until. notification by the Bireau of its. refusal to
grant such certifie ates , .
“ee : ‘“
Section 2 21t3°" x
Every furnace or other combustion equipment or
» device shalk be i inspected annually and a report and
permanent record made. of such inspection by the
Bureau except the following © ° .
(1) Furnaces or other combustion equipment or
devices installed to he: yt buildings used exe ‘lusivel¥
for private residences containing less than three
dwelling units or flats, and
\
(2) Combusion equipment or devices used ex-
clusively for private reside nees whie h do not con. -
tain a central heating’ plant. |
Section 2.20:
After anv owner, agent, occupant, manager or
lessee of any premises has been previously notified
of three or more violations of this Ordinance within
any consecutive T2-month period: in respect to the
etnission of smoke, seet, cinders, noxious: acids,
fumes, aSes, fly ashcor industrial Mists, the owner,
ad ’ ai , .
:
.
,
x ' . é .
’ Sm oky/Ordinaiie . ae 7a
agent, occupant, ‘manager cor Tessee of said prem-
ises shall be notified to show cause befere the Com-
See missioner net less than ten days from the date ef
notice, why the ¢ equipuent causing such violation
should not le se ued, Sy
(a) T he a ae herem prov ded’ for nav he: riven
by mail directed to the Jast ‘known nate
party to be notified, or if said party or his where-
abouts -is unknown, Poth by posting a notice on or
near the premises at which Nie violations shall hate
occurred, pon said date said violator may appear
vand be heard. Upon such he ring, if the Commis- -
sioner finds that adequate cokrective means and
methods have not been é@mployed to correct the
‘vause of such condition then it shall be his duty to
seal, said equipment until such time as a. Permit i ind
certificate as herein provided have been applied for
ani issued for said plant. ee
ress of the
(i) 0 all be -unlewtel for any person:to break
a seal of any refuse burning equipment, anv boiler
or any, equipment. or device producing heat or
power, that has been duly me by the Commis-
sioner or his authorized represe ntative,
Section 221: | oak st ia
When a certificate of operation is refused in the
* ease of an original inspection or a case of an annual
inspection, the Conunissioner is authorized to seal,
~ lnmediately, the furnace or other combustion equtip-
ment until the downe®, lessee or ofher person re-
quired to. procure the certificate.of operation shall
m * have complied with the provisions of this Ordinance,
- Section 3.2;
Any per ‘son, persons, firm, partnet rship, assecia-
fion or corpor: ation or.any one acting in behalf of.
oie anevid. PELSON. persons, firtin, partnership, association.
or corporates. violating? airy otthe - “provisions of °
4 .
Sa. | - Smoke Ordinance es
this Ordinance shall upon conviction thereof he sub-
ject to a fine of not-more than one hundred dollars
($100.00) or to imprisonment. in the Detroit) House.
of Correction for a period of not more, than thirty
(30) di Ws, or te botli such fine arid’ Huprisonme nt-in
the’ discretion of the court, Each day ‘that a viola-
tion of this -Ordinahce is continued or permitted to
exist without Compiiance shall constitute a separate
offense punishable upon conviction’ in’ the manner
prese ribed i in ‘this section,
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.