Transcript of Record — McAllister v. Magnolia Petroleum Co.
Supreme Court brief1958
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ME COURT,
; “ *. Sait ae a
- ‘ . e % ae eae : ase ‘
. ’
se ae rs °:
ws * ,
is . 3
tre ¥ 26 i. xs
Ce oe
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
- OCTOBER ise 1957
UY iy
oe
No, 93°
eg McAPLISTER; PETITIONER,
vs. ’
M AGNOLIA PETROLEUM COMPANY Bo
ON WRIT OF. CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS OF THE
STATE OF TEXAS! FIFTH.SUPREME JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
+
e ” s
Fs ae ;
s :
| INDEX oe 7
. Original” Print
Record from the Distriet Court of Dallas County, Texas,
- 134th Judicial District | ee .
Caption (omitted in printing) ... Cyt. ene e eee sence: A -
File endorsement only appearing on plaintiff's original
«petition showing date of filing of ‘original action in
a farris © ‘ounty, Texas, as August 27, 1958 .........+-- ein
‘ Defendant? s third amended original answer :..:....... 7: ees
is laintiff’ s first amended original petition Per ene ee eat we © 5
Statement of facts (E xcerpts ‘From ) Poe. ore re ater ee 1 10
Appearances eed cats Up ate eee ae Teer eee Soeiiae ree ot
Deposition of Captain 1 Ferdinand Dressef read .......... 4 10
Testimony, of Richard Andrew ‘McAllister——direet. Sleeree.s 22 20
sis te OVNRNNNO ois occ ee vi caceneieecess Me ee io 28
Testimony of Richard Andrew Me Ailiste r—dire ret. Tere ‘2o 24
.'. Offer in evidence ...... oWes bach aes cA RES AS ERC ERS °65. . 4%
Testimony of Richard Andrew “Me Allisttr- direct Ceaawet > ae 43
/. —Scross ..2..4.- « 81 52,
Testimony of Richard Andrew MeAllister—(reealled) cross 237 65
. Offers in evidence ........% er . 285 89
:
“il
z ; Index Continued
*
oi
«
Testimony of Richard Andrew McAliister——cross ep
eta —Fedirect ......
va) re if _—recross ......
BE. H. Young—<«irect .......55...25. path neh ee:
Offer: in evidence ee oe eee Ey te aT ge Sa ae
Testimony of E. H. Young—direct ne ree eae es
—CTOSS +. 0.000000: feeers ee ee
PGEINOOE Kiccteccu sot wunk sa
Ay _.. =Precross ..... Torre. ee
meNeOe ss cans sh @akeess os eee
.Plaintiff’s Ehibit Ne, 35 (xeerpfs) ....... Seer Te
Defeadant’s Exhibit No. 7- (Excerpts) SP re ee are
Stipulation (regardi ing life expect ancy y°of pl untiff and
Original Print:
286
329
etl.
368°
381
38i
388
423
“426
427
“428
60
112
118
; 13}
138
138
142
159
161
162°
162
“4302 164
value of « Foliar.) oe € 8 -&% ¢. 6.2 & eaves. 8. 0 «6 5..6 0 ¢.9 2. $2 ¢ 6.8.4 8.6 432 164
Plaintiff rested ..... ae ant RoW e CON EHO lueidekes eee: 1 ae ee
Testimony of Frank Riess—direct “....... Pe ae 4339 165°
Offers in evidence Sere ate ate wee a ran Sieg) ies ape eee 439 168
Testimony of Frank Riess—direct ..... 0.0. ¢.e.0ecee ee: 446 168
—(TOSS ...... TEER ens 479 189
vs ok hn, EE ee ee 507 204
GBor th Ovigemee bs saree scese ns ned UAKta eats Canes 510. 206
Testimony of Frank Riess—recruss /.........5.06 eevee 513 208 »
J. V. Gibson—direct /.......... Var ee Bete Ns 514 = 208
gene hy. SCE CE PE EEE OTR * 523 213
ome FOGIFOCE «2 ac cree ge peer csesees 526, 214
* —recross o 64 ¢€. 6°08 66.8 27 88 “ gee. 6 a s 2.9 8.9 526 o14
Testimony of Cecil M. Rhodes—direct Ei aide lth Coe gh At 528 214
o Offer i QRCROE aoe oe eG co oe een as EVES sae cies a 542 "222
Testimony .of Céeil M. Rhodes—divect <i<.ce cases oe 542 222
. Offer. in evidence ieee ts i We dvaawe's BSAC R ENE UE A ee a7 238
Te ‘stimony of Ceeil My Rhodes—direet FREES ieee es . 573 238
| See ea Pe PD ro oe 239
a 3 —Fedireet ne. ccseis ese: ff 60% = 253
; . W=FOCFOSS: wee ces eewecece 609 257
Ferdinand B. Dressel—direet ike ee 612. ° ‘258
—~—-Cross Ti) oe ee et Oe le *? * 2 620 26;
ne ;—redirect ..... eae a riurards 631 268
John Pullin—direct 202s. cues cc cote wae ans 634 269
e—-CTOSR ....... revere re ern eae. 655. 2806.
a Se —redirect ....... PME Se iN ciem ee Rs Ye ee 288
ei. BOVE PTR eer rey ee Mawes fp: 674. 290.
; te Rosson— direct ..... Spe rer rT en 677 291
° George Rosson (recalled)—direct .... yee 767 30]
: Pek eiee cease ma 772 304
Ray mond L. V andeveer-—dire ee ere ee 788 312.
——CTO8B oo. ee ee we man coer S08 322
. errs re 811 - 324:
4 —TlCTOSS ....5..-. re pe i+ 326
.Testimony of Raymond L. Vandeveer—redirect ....... ms 815 —° 326
—TeECTOSS .....-...: 817 327
Harry A. Barkley—direct ........0-+--05: lage oo. 327.
Motion ‘to strike the. evifonge: and denial thereof ae Pee
Testimony of Harry A. Barkley- —¢ross .. he cat ee rea. Bee 2a
* Offers in (eee. as. ce Sees are eiarye as e eres R25 531
Defendant rests ..... ee pert ere rire Te eer ee ee 2: 332
-
2
. '. Tndex ‘Vontinued |
Te ‘stimony of Mrs. aoe A. McAllister—direct ....... 842
Richard A, Me Allister (recalled )-——redirect ..... 845°
7 epee : . -—C(ross .....2, 848
| ; —redirect ..... 850
: ——Feeross .. 0... 852
- B. YV. Ashton—direct ...%.....:..;5 Belseeeeecne 854
Defend: ant’s bill of exception. hee nk hea ee ses See Can ws 858
Testimony of George Rosson (ree: alled ) Patik a's Mane ane eas 858
Offers:-in evidemee i... oo. odes inscses ereeees eutveesass 865 ..
* os : :
‘ Reporter’s and counsels’ certificates (omitted in printing) .. 867
7 Judge’s approval to statement OF TAGE Ses ass Dak Pe acais oo oa. Se
Defendant’s exhibits: .........cceeciewsees es ERG ROTAUE, 868
No. i---Page from Log of the J. C. Stephens including the
period of October 18, 19, 20, 1950 2.5 eee cece ceeds 869
. No. 3-~Page from catalog of Heintz Mfg. Co. show! ing. .
pictures of Treads and measurements .........5...6-. 871
Defendant’s exhibits:
» No. 4—-Weekly report of re Petroleum Company.
véssel (J.C. Stephens) for week ending October. 24, 1950 - 872
‘No, 22—Page. from Log of the J. C. Stephens including the
period of October 21, 22, 23 and SR: Re ee are :° 873
No. 30—Diagram showing experiment: al setup used in
determining the coefficient of friction betweén shoes and
“Vil
Original Print
332
334
335
.
38
337
338
340 °
‘346
344
344
345
- 345
ME | ERO ER TELE ETT eee ee ¢ - S7e
No. 3: $4) aption only of ck cposition of Burke Y¥. Ashton, :
‘ete. Eee we Gate taaes cukewky es i Paks sh aan ‘Sansa 75 355
‘Plaintiff’ 8 trial amendment ...:..... PETECEEUPE CT Eee - 876 355
Charge und verdict ..... Vi oden dees canbe e tates aiV anaes 1 357
Plaintiff’s requested instruction No. 1 ...2...... picsianst = oan 368
Plaintiff ’s special issue «2... ces es ences + eek Rae Sees 894 309
Plaintiff ’s requested issue AP Eee ee Pe SOE (895 369
Plaintiff ’s Fjeetions and exceptions to the court’s charge .. 896 370
. Stipulation re single question set out by Jury oWeweseses 910 381
Judgment eevee ge cc Ree ee ORM ne ee sere eT ore 911 38),
Clerk’ %,€ ertificate (omitted in printing) ena eee wana “ ' . 928 3B5
Plaintiff ’s motion for new trial. o........0 ccc ace eee eee: 929 395
2 Affidavit: of Leslie J- Bird ........6....... Shatin oe ack . 942 40€
Affidavit, of UB. BON nc stesccvekes ba carn eta ke oaweces 945 » 408
Affidavit of J. A. Foster ....,.... 0c cece ree Meee ee 947. 410
Affidavit: of J.B. Piatt ......... 56: ma teveuesves Sere we 949. °412
Affidavit of Duard Terry ...... § Pe ga NA ged gn Pye 952 414
“Afidavit of James H. PS eo oe eee ee 4.16
‘Order overruling plaintiff’s and defendant? s motions for
new tiial and notice of appeal ......... einige sas bags ee oe + 958 418
Appeal bond. (omitted in printing) RR TY pg eat GAL Pe or Q58a 419
Clerk ’s certifiedte (omitted in printing) ......... eevee ‘ 959 . 419
Proceedings in the Court of Civil Appeals for the Fifth °
Supreme Judicial District at Dallas, SEN eon iiaeetars 960 419
- Stipulation carding the question sent out by the jury for
WetTOCTAOOS, CUE... gcc cc eee sae re ET eer re ee Ce 960 419
Opinion, Dixon, Ch. J. ar it DAL AS so reet SF ss lege ee hr ek 962 421
iv Index Continued 8
Original Print
Judement ooo ewccseressgsccts. erg AS eet ee 970 k 487
_ Appellant 's otion for esctg a Ce OC re — “eo
Order overruling motion for rehearing - of Nes eee Puree vas: ee 436
| Opinion on rehearing, Dixvw, 5 ie eee cert elias ve he -¢ 382 - 436
Proceedings in the Supreme Court DURE cscs ees: S88 437
Petitioner’s ypplication for writ of eTror—see separate index - O84 438°
Reply to application for writ of error—see separate index ... 1042. 482°.
Order refusing applicatien for writ of meer <..5.: ue ress 1055. . .490 —
Order overruling motion for rehearing .......+->- ieee ees Raate) ee 498)
Order granting motion’ for leave to proceed in forma. pepe
and petition for writ of certiorari ......-.- re , 1057 - $9)
. Py ig
‘ay ~ 2 °
~« > ;
w
a »
\ e
. e . «
4
a ;
@
: . :
4
iS can estar oe
s. | : :
gl. ENDORSE ME VT ON INSTRU WEN i aay fs
“ * -90186-A, Richard McAllister vs-Magnolia Petroleum
Company, Plaintiffs Original Petition,” Filed “April 50,
1954, BILLESHAW < District Clerk, Dallas County, Texas,
‘s/ Buford Dep : | |
' Kiled Angus it 2 ° 195: 3, J. W. Mills, District Clerk, Harris”
County, Texas, a. ‘s/ A. AL. Wtivhards, Deputy, |
POON THE. DISTRICT. COURT OF. DALLAS
: COUNTY, TEXAR, THTH GRUDICLAL, DIS:
PRICT | pnts
Fh Tit le omitted iB
Ps Defendant's s Third Amended Ofigina’: Answer—Filed seiaaie te
& + - 29,1955
To tne Honorapie Jcpce or Saab Court:
Now Comes defendant, Mahenoa Petroleum Company,
in the above entitled and ninnbe ced. tause, and im answer
io plaintité’s s orrgmal petit jon world show the court:
ay POR ee eee mre eee
I.
De fendant’ denies -each and every allegation contained
in said original petition and detri: inds strict Pret the reat,
and of this it puts itself upon the country.
& Defendant specially. denies the allogntionis. of plaintitf’s
+ * original pen contained in Paragraph TT thereof, that
the M/V di, C..Sreprens and- its portholes were unsea-
worthy or not water-tight, or that the steps leading from
the ,erew’s lounge io the galley were covered w ith spa
water, oil, grease, and other slippery substanee,-but. woul ;
affirmatively show. that, on the:certrary, the M/V J, ¢
STEPHENS Was a start and seaworthy vessel. ine every
S respect the 19th day of October, 1950, was’ practically
new and) in new condition, designed and outfitted for the.
uses fot which it was intended and utilized, manned by an
adequate experienced crew with all.of the safety appli-
ayes and devices availabie, aut the time-of its construction,
.
ca
8°
2 ; me
«>. e *
| ~ Defendant, de riving that plaintiff fell as alleged, would
show tliat the steps leading from the-lounge to the erew’s
gallery are-so ‘constructed that there is-a-metal hand rail
on the port side of the vessel. alongside the steps, so placed
‘and designed to be used. by any ‘person Zong up or down
the steps,- and that, in addition. thereto, there is located
~ » another hand:rail commonly called a grab iron which
(G is affixed in’a horizontal position and attached to ‘
the overhead in the galley, so designed and located —
as to be used by a person coming’ down tlie steps, and when
so used will prevent a- person from falling from said steps.
That at the time the aHeged fall occurred the steps ‘in
question were virtually. new, having been original equip-
ment in. the vessel, Which. was: itself built, and placed in.
service fess than’a year before thie alleged accident oe-
~ eurred; that such steps. were of aluminum construction.
with alternative strips of abrasive forming’ the’ treads sé
~ designed. and installed as to minimize slipping by one us-
-ing the steps. Defendant would show that plaintiff’s
fall, if any ‘he sustained, was not eaused or contribted
‘to be’ caused by the unseaworthiness of the vessel, ‘or by
“any act of negligence on the part. - the: defendant or its,
employees, but that. the fall, if. it occurred, was’ solely
eaused or was Gontributed to be Oieas! by ihe conduct of
the plaintiff in the following particulars, to-wit: ix
(a) Plaintiff attempted jo dexe ‘end the ladder: without
facing the steps thereof.’ * ~, oe
(b) Plaintiff attempted to deseend tlie ladder without
using or without properly. using the hand rail and grab
iron “provided for that purpose. -\ . tp
(¢) Plaintiff knew or should have known of the presence
_of sea water, if any was present, w hich this defendant, de-
nies, upon the steps of the. ladder, and failed’ to correct
such condition by swabbing. or mopping the same from the
steps or having the same -done- before descending thie
+ ladder.
That each of these acts by plaintiff either separ ately or
@jointly @mstituted a. failure ‘oO use, due care for his own
safety, which rvesulted-in. the injury complained of and
either was the sole cause of the aécident or was such
H -contribetory -negligence: as proximately caused. the
lee .
i all aie
,
—
“of <
ie
»
«)
a f ¥ a ¥
un eae cay
injury And sliould “be ‘considered in mifigation of plain-
-tiff’s daniage, if any. P fi ne ant 3
4 .
..
res x i +
Defendant, denying that plaintiff fell as alleged, woud
show the court that immediately hefore plaintiff attempted.
‘to go down the steps from which he alleges that. he fel}
he had beerr upon-a weather deck of the boat aiding in liz at
-. handling; that such weather dick was exposed to the rain
and the sea and-that while’ upon such weather deck tte
plaintiff -had gotten the soles of his shoes ‘wet with water
gand that ge condition was the. sole proximate cause of
: : plaintiff. Cea: ce
*the fall, ia the alternative, 7 the fail, if-any, the
result. of an. unavoidable accident, or, In the alternative,
plaintiffs .atteampted descent with his shoes slippery and «
wet was such efn act of negligence which proximately caused
or eontribared to the’ fall, any, ‘and should be taken
into account in iitie ation of any damage suffered. by the
ae A <
Pleaeding: alternatively, ebofendant would further, show.
“the court that the fall, iftany sustained by the defendant,
was the result of the. heavy seas and weather and without
negligence of either plaintiff. « wv defendant, and-was thus
an. “unavoidable accident. | .
. s
Be ici, ee ys
” Ples iding: alternatively, defendant would further show
that the fall, if any sustained by defendant, was solély the
result of an act of God, and: the heaty weather and seas.
and wind accompanying .the tropical | storm Was the sole
entise of the plaintiff's: | all an id injuries, i>ary.s
ny >
.
y fas: ee Rs _ @
Pile: ading further, this defendant would show that
ae the plaintiff's cause of action for maintenance should
not now be permitted because of the long lapse of
time and. delay which plaintiff has occasioned by. failure
to pre viously assert.a claim-therefor from! and after Octo-
her 19, 1950 to August 27, 1958, and that the same. 1s barr eck:
by laches, and of this if prays judgment of the court.
*
Sr : §
: 8g. te ‘ : pa
P leading further, ‘defendant would show that plaintiff’s
cause of action for personal injuries suffered, if any, and —
based upon the: alleged unseaworthiness of the vessel is
barred by the two year statute of limitation, Article 5526,
Revised: Civil Statutes of Texas: Wherefore, defendant
prays that plaintiff take nothing by reason thereof and
that defendant haves judgment for its eosts.
9.
a> ; a
Pleading further, defendant would show that plaintiff’s
cause of action fer personal injuries suffered, if any, which. °
is based upon that certain Act of Congress on Mareh ’ Dd, -
a C. 158, See. 20, 38 Statutes 1175, amended June 5, _
, c.. HG, Seé. 33-41. Statutes 1007, being also known |
as va Jones Act, . See, 688, ‘Title 46 of the United States ~
Code Annotated, was not brought within thé period pre- -
seribed in sueh Act. Wherefore, defendant prays judg-
ment that plaintiff take nothing , against it,;and that it
have judgment for its costs. >
W HEREYORE, premises considered, defendant prays ‘mat.
upon a -final ‘hearing hereof it have judgment t that the
- plawntiff take nothing against it, and thai it -be discharged
with its: costs.
Baru A, Bie
CuHas, Bb. Wauuace .
/$/ Frank C. Bolton, Jr.
Frank C, Boiron, Jr.
fee Ne ee ae
aa
ae | Dallas, Texas
13 8 . Attorneys for Defendant,
. Magnolia Petroleum Company
[Tile e ndor sement omitted |
shown. Cate
eo faire * ng ; PD |
KIN THE DISTRICT COURT: OF - DALLAS.
COUNTY, TEXAS, 134TH JUDICIAL DIS-
ee: eee rie ae,
-(Titlé omitted).
Plaintiff’ 8 First Amended Original Petition—F ed, February | 28,
1955.
_ To THE ‘Juper OF Sarp Court:
“Now: ComEs Ricwarp McALLister, hereinafter: -styled |
plaintiff, ‘complaining of MsGNouia ‘PETROLEUM ‘COMPANY,
hereinafter designated ‘as defendant, with leave of Court
_ had and obtained files this his First Amended Origing | Pe--
tition, and for cause of action would respectfully show vour —
‘Honorable Court As follows: | o.
yf ;
That plaintiff i is a resident citizen of Flowstn, Harris |
County, Texas; that the defendant is a corporation duly
organized under and by virtue of law upon w hom service
has already ‘been had. :
ot ee eer,
Plaintiff would show that on. or about the 2nd. -day of
February; 1949, he was employ ed by the defendant herein
as an engineer aboard: its seagoing vessels, including the |
M/V J.C. SvtepHens, at wages of approximately Four Hur
dred Five Polliars ($405. 00}. per month; ‘plus roon end
‘board and on otlier terms and conditions, gil of which wili
be shown during the trial of this cause.
“Til
Plaintiff would show that on or about the 19th day te
of October, 1950, while employed as an engineer aboard —
‘the M/V¥V-J3.-€- SvEPHENS: owned and operated by the de-_
fendant herein, and while in the discharge of his reguiar:
duties as an engineer on saiqd vessel, and while walking
- down the stairs leading.to the galley, he slipped and feel
~—_—--~
to the deck helow injuring. his back and other parts"
2p of his body, a’ hereinafter more fully shown. That.
said fall proximately causing plaintiff’s j injuries Was | |
caused by the negligence of the defendant and/or the un-*
seaworthiness of the vessel J. C, STEPHENS, as hereinafter
<
\ e : a,
, heen: . 6
= 9 2
ip laintiff allewe 's that Ils said injuries: and the coup ies
tions resulting therefrom, as aferesaid, We re proximately
caused. and: contributed: to be eaused byethe negligenge of
a defendant; its master, officers, agents and employees
n the following partic alars, among others, to-wit:
‘1) Inneglige antly failing to’ have and kee ‘p the portholes
over and near the stairs ke adine to and from the valley
of the J. C. STE PHENS watertight ; og Oe -
- |
2) dn neglige ntly failinggto Keep the portholos, a.
‘and attachments in proper “working condition: SO that
water/inay not leak through the Mn; eee
3) In negligently { failing to -keep she portetos gaskets -
and attachments in proper repair 50 that water niav not
“leak through them:
4) in pe rinitting. the condition of deaking portholes over
and near’ the stairs leading to and from said galley to
exist thus creating? a danger to all of those using sill
Stairs ;
A) In negligently pe rinitting thre portholes over “and: nea
the stairs leading to and from: tpie § galley -of the if ¢.
STEPHENS In a L cond! tion th nt: water Ww vould leak ‘through
them;
&} In negligently having. oil, grease, or other slippery
substance on the stairs le ading to “and from. the galley ri
of the J. L, ‘STEPHEN NS;
7) In negligently ailing to remove said oil, grease, or,
_ otiier siipvery substance from.said stairs: me
M - 8) In negligently. having the deck above the galley.
Ina condition so that the water and/or water and.
vil would leak thre mehesuch deck and an to the stairs
leading to and from the galley of the J.C. Srepne NS;
4) In noligently failing to keep the deck above the gilic Vv
vatertight ;. ; | |
10) In neglige ntlv pe dere a a condition to exist where
water and oil mexed and acecuinulated on. the stairs lead.
: ‘ing to and from the galley of -the J. Co STEPHENS,
ios mc ° eer
%
ap eS ge ee ee
‘ &
=
And plaintiff. states: tlat' ach and alt ‘of the foregoing .
eoneitions , facts and cirewustances were well known ‘to. the
defendant, its master, and Chief Mate, agents, servants and
“employees, or in the exercise of orginary care, the same
should have been known ‘the thei, sand tha oph- and all
of -the aforemie ‘ntioned Fact is, conditions, pean See and
E>.
caety of oinission as well AS COMMISSION, constituted negh-
-genee onthe part of said defendant, its agents, servants,
employees and Master, and the failure to use ordinary eare,
~and-each and all, taken singly and in conjunction with each
other, ‘proximately ‘aused and eontributed to eause plain-
tiffs injuries and resulting complications, disabilities and
damages of which he herein complains.
vy. ae
° ‘\ J
Plaintiff further alleges that as a -eoncurrent cause of
the injuries sustained by him was the unseaworthiness of”
the said J, C. SrepHENS, proximately cadsing his injuries in’
that the portholes on said vessel’ were utises aworthy, Le.,
they were not watertigiut; that by reason of such unsea-
worthy portholes Wiierever said® vessel would encounter
‘seas which would strike at‘or near the area where the port-
holes are located, or by reason of sea spray at sea
N water would ecofhe thr ough s said leakiig or otherwise
unseaworthy portholes causing said water to fall or
accumulate and/or remain on said stairs leading to. and
-frem the galley: which either by itself, or in connection
with other slippery substance that may have accumulated -
on said stairs caused plaintiff” x injuries, as hereinabove
alleged, — as ae a:
Plaintiff would further show that ead vessel Was "umsea-
worthy in that the wleek above said galley was not water-
tight so,that any water that would aceumulate.on the deck
or. be on the deck, instead of draining through scuppers or
remaining.on. said deck, would. come through said éciling
into the galley and on to the stairs: ‘les ading to and from
said galley... That the portholes were leaking and wnsea-
worthy .and the gaskets were improperly placed so that
sea water would leak ‘through, causing said staits to be
_ wet and slippery, that.singly and together with the oil and
“grease on said steps caused a serious and dangerous eon-
| pre to exist to those w orking j in that area and particularly
{6 plaintiff, herein. | Glas
Lae
4
“7?
: VL
Plaintiff would further show that, as hereinabove al-
“leged, when he was attempting to walk down the stairs
_Jeading to the galley he stepped on one of the steps form.
* ing said stairs, and as ‘he did so, hé slipped and fell down
the ladder and ometg the deck below seriously injuring plain- ~
- tiff’s back, left shoulder: and legs; that the tendotis, -Ifga-
ments, blopdvessels, bones, cartilates in between his verte-
-brae have been seriously bruised, ruptured and ‘torn ‘apart;
that the pain imhis back radiates to the right buttock and
to the poatepuiaters! aspect of the thigh and leg down to his:
ankle; that his condition has become progressively ‘worse
so that now he ca not stand for anv lenght af time
DD without ‘great pain, particularly in his ri ight leg;
-@. that he has difficulty hending’ over or straightening
~~ further hy reason) of tlie injurv to his back he suffers.
- from protruded ntertortobiral dise, or dises; that his en-
tire hervous system has beon effected thereby, and plaintiff
is unable to sleep at night and: has become hiehly Pervous.
Plaintiff knows no trade er'profession w hereby he may
earn a living save-as a seaman and work. involving hard
manualslabor; and that as a résult of said injuriés and the
complications therefrom plaintiff has been unable to con-
tinue in such employment; that. bis ability ‘to’ work -and
earn money has been seriously diminished and impaired.
Plaintiff has been unable to work from the: day he left de-
fendant?s empl/vment to the time of ‘the filing. of this
amended petition, and, therefore, has suffered loss of wages
from said date to the date of trial and will suffer loss. 6f
wages and ability to work and earn money in the future,
‘so-that his earning capacity has been seriously diminished
and impaire d. | Plaintiff has. suffer ‘ed, suffen ‘s and will Gon-.
tinue.to suffer for a long time in the future physical pain
and mental anguish; that be will have to undergo a Serious”
and painful operation’ on his spine, all of whieh will be’
acco pamed with severe and agonizinggpain-‘and leave per-
manent and fasting disabilities. Thaf he is unable now
and has been unable to obtain medical eare = attention
from the United States Public Héalth Service faciities,
and, therefore, he has spent - reasonable and nee essary
inoneys for doctors bills, hack braces and back supports,,
and Will, have to: spend Inoneys fer operations, hospitals
.
. «
cand’ nurses expenses in the future, which together with the
‘loss of Wages te the date of -trial, his lest or diminished
Capacity to earn money. in tlie future has caused? plaintift
to suffer serious damag es; that. from, the date of this trial
~ plaintiff has a life expectaney of thirty- six (356) ,
P . vears, thirty (30) of witelt at least would Have been
fruitful years, as a result of Which plaintiff has been
damaged i in the sum of One Hundred Twenty-five Thousand
Dollars ($125,000.00), consisting of wages to the date of
trial, loss of earning capacity. in the future, and past, pres-
ént and futnre necessary’ and reasonable medical. expenses.
for ‘doctors, hospitals, nurses, appliances, and medicines.
‘ re
|
ures 1 GS Oe oahbe ee rex:
That while plaintiff wag so employed by’ the defendant
as a member of the crew of the J. C. Srepuens, and while -
ithe perfor lance of his duties and in the regular scope :
s .
of his. enmployme nt, he suffe red serious and disabling tn- |.
juries, as a result of which he has be ‘aay and still is disabled
from. performing his duties as a seaman and by ihe
thereof he is entitled to iaintenance under the law;
well as by. contract, from the daté of his injuries untiP-his
condition wil! become static, exclusive-of any days he may
have beer confined in’a U nited States: Marine Hospital, at -
the rate of Night Dollars (8.00) per day, or the contrae-
tual rate-:then applicable for wnaintenance ; without preju-
- alee to his right fo claim, inaintenance in the future and
beyond.the dateAhe Court or jury mmav ‘determine at. the
‘trial ef this Mise, i! the facts show that he is entitled to
such mainfénance. | | |
Viti
Plaintiff has elec ted-to bring nd maintain his suit as
an action for damages at-law with the right’ of. trial by-
jury in complance with and under’ the provisions of that
certain Act of Congress om Mareh 5, 1! 119, C. 153, See. 20,
38 Statute 1175, amended June 5, 1920, C. 250, See. 33,.41.
Statute 1007, being also known ds the Jones Ac ‘t, See, 688
- Title 46 of the U nited States s C ode. a
>
W. HEREFORE, ~ Premises Coansiperep, Plaintiff | lpravs that
citation Issue and oy ser ved upon “the said défe nd: wnt,
() . Magnolis 4? etrole cum C ompany, in form and mtanner
3 ; | :
: ee, “or
id. ae .
e
@
‘e
required by law, requiring the defendant to “appear and
‘answer herein, and that upon final hearing hereof plain-
tiff have judgment against said def fendant in the: sum
of gine’ Hundred Twenty: five Thousand Dollars | ($125,-
600.00), plus such maintenarice as plaintiff may show him-
self entitled to receive, without prejudice to his right te
future maitenidne, together with interest thereon from the
date o¢ said injvry, all eosts of court, and all such other
and further relef. te which he may. . entitled in the
premises, No ae
ee Mannestit, & Waricat,
; By /s/ Arriu & J. MaNpeu
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
(File endorsement omitted)
»
Pe
1 IN THE. DISTRICT COURT OF DALLAS
COUNTY, TEXAS, 134TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
‘No. 90186-G:
ticreARD MCALLISTER
" 2 6 Oe ad
MaGc#orta PerroLeumM Company:
Statement of Facts
APPEARANCES:
Wrigut & Maxve.t, By Mr. A. J. inten L, for P laintift’
, Mr. Frank -C. Botton aid Mr. Jé E. Earnest, for De-
fendant « |
Be Ir Remembered that upon a trial of the above entitled
and numbered cause in the 134th District’ Court on the 7th.
“day ef Mareh, 1955, before Hon.-Charles KE. Long, Judge
of said court, and a Jury the following proe eedings were
‘had: ia,
— *< * * * ' & oa ee
4... Mr. Mande ll: We offer the Deposidion. of ¢ ‘aptain
fi erdinand B. Dressel. as follows: a
(Reading from beginning of deposition through to bottom ©.
‘ fam Q : f Pte
c of Page 104, as follows: )
| : FERDINAND B: DRESSE lL. was called as a witnéss by
the plaintiff, aud being fir st duly sworn, testified us follows:
Direct. Examination | |
By Mr. Mandell: ae eee
; :-o. Mre Yressel, where doy you live, ini sir? - i live
ay in Morgan City. —
=. 8 What 1s the addreset . 1123 F oe: Street. - ~ :
3 _ Who’ are“vou employed. by? A, Magnolia | etroleiun
C ala | |
) ~Q. Tow long’ have you been employed by them? A. Go.
/ ing on seven years. ~ ate !
1 Q. In what capacity have you been emploved by. them?
j A. WwW ell, T lave heen employed as a amate, but now Tsai
F- alternate captain. | :
= QO, On what? A. On the Motor Vv Se oe 8 Sidious.
2 Q. In 1950, in what capacity were you aeoree bv
3 > -the Magnolia. Petroleum Com Bree A. T-was em-
— - ploved in- 1948 as a mate. :
(). What about 1950? A. Well, 1950 eon alt crnate
= «Captain. .-.: | Rei ite eae
(). Alternate Captain? In such .capacify .as alternate
Captain. did ‘you serve_on-the J. C. Stephens? A, 1 am’
.sorry, sir. J didn’t get it. - . he. aes
3 (). Did you serve in the eaps dcity of Captain.on the J.C.
|. Stephens? A. T ‘hat is right, yes. aes 7
. Q. Now, the JC. Stephens is a seagoing vessel?. It goes.
- outin the Gulf of Mexieo and hack? A. That i is right. |
gf And how many does if have in the crew? A. Three.
©. had who are they? Who are these thece? A. Well,
you mean at that time? oe noe wai A
a (. Yes. E.don’t mean the names. I mean the capacities,
a ot have a Captain! “A. Got a. captain, an engineer and
_ * a seaman. , 7
a Q).. Now,>who has charge of thé navizatien ot the boat?
Ae ae : | : |
Q). The Captain? A. Yes, ‘gir. | -.
Q.. Who < is charge. of cleaning and keeping the
3 6 galley and the passengers’ lounge clean? A. The
: deekhand, sir. | aH | te
; \ 7 |
'$
vai , 4
12 :
(). Ww ho‘ has charge of thé engine room? >A. The engi-
meer | |
Q. W ho has charge of ke eping ‘the engines clean? A,
The engrneer. o os :
Q. What does.that boat dot What is. is. function? A,
Well, it transports personnel from the Gulf to town, 7
. Q. Whose personnel? A. Magnolia Petroleum Com-
pany: : | 2 ie eercaal )
(@, In cther words, it is used to transfer Magnolia Petro- »
teum Company, cniployees from amg some place into
wherever you carry them? Is that correct? A. That is
shor ak ves, sir | aaa pe eae |
Now, do vou remember having an employee .. the
name of Afr. McAllister, this gentleman,sitting at my right
here? A, Ves; ‘sir. , | oan .
Q. In what capacity was he emp! loyed on the Stephens?
~ oe engineers | | , .
: When he worked as an engineer, he was also an em-
“lon oof the Magnolia Petroleum Company, w as he not?
A. Yes, sir, he. was. a
(). And, the J.€ ste phens i is a boat ow ne : end oper uted
bv. .the .. Maenotia: ‘Pétroteum — Compaiiy?-~ “A? That is-—~
isnt, at B 8
7 - *Q. Now, as an ‘engineer, did Me. \llister, have the
duty to keep and maintain the engines and see that
the boat, rai properly from an engincer’s standpoint? A.
That is right, sir,
Q). Now, do you remember having any port holes that
were leaking’on the JC. Stephens? A. Port: holes. sir?)
Q. Yes, sir. A. No. We didn’t have any port hole leak-
ing, sir. ; ss ae |
(). Didn’t have any water coming through the port holes?
A. We had water coming i through the lights on the side,
re — -as windows. |
Well, when T nse the term Snort hole’? T mean ae-
Luz ily a port hole on the side of the ship, in the skin of the
ship. vA>AV¥et; Tinisunderstood you-hecause we don’t have
_any port hole on the side. We only have two port holes on—
the front-and we have Windews all about the boat.
(). You,.don’t have any port holes‘on the side of the ship?
A. No, sir...
_Q. On the side | of the Stephe ns? A. No, Sir. |
"Nae
i nh eh pees
Ce eae
DE PN See are
. :
: Tat | ’
Se.
Sir.
ning Page 105; line 9.
13
Q. No windows at all? “A. There are w indaw s above the |
deck, yes, sir. They are in the house.
S ‘Mr. Bolton: He is ‘calling ‘windows’? what you are
calling ‘‘port holes’’. That is where your trouble is.
Mr. Mandell: Allright. We will call them windows.
Q? Mr. Mandell: Did water come.through the windows?
A. Yes, sir, occasionally, when it is rough. ie:
Q. Those windows are dogged down, aren't they? You
ean close them real tight, enn’ t you? ‘A. Yes, sir. That
right. eee
(). And they have Sabber gaskets around them? A.. Yes,
Q. What is the rubber gasket for? A. ‘The rubber " gas-
ket is supposed to stop the water from coming in.
Q. It is supposed to be av ater tight io keep the water out?
“A. Yes, sir. .
. Did it keep the water out? ALN Not all the time, no, Sir.
¢- Now, when it didn’t keep the water out, what w ould ©
ac water fall onto? A. The water fell én the floor anid
nay they have.a scupper pipe to take care. of that.
Q. Did. it fall on the’steps? A. Sometimes’ it did, ves,
Qe} Now. I suppose ‘that happened when you had
<< 9 _ seas splashing against the window or port holes or
whatever vou call them.
o
Mr. Bolten: We object to that AS Ci iene fora conelusion
of the witness. — - 7 a) :
' The Court: Overruled: os) aeons Ss
Mr. Bolton s Note our exception.
A. That is right.
| tte, er” -
° — : . By ?
Mr. Mandell continued. ee Deposition begin-
—
Q.. Mr. Mandell: Ts that true or not? A. Yes, jt could
he, |
Q -
Q. And that’ is the reason, is it-not, Captain, why these
gaskets are around those windows or port holes, in order
to keep water away either from the deck or from. steps?
That j is. trne, isn’t: it? A. That i is true. :
14 — he
. Q. Xet I believe you did: testifiy, didn't vou, Captain,
tliat on oceasions when you had water sufficiently rough
to be against the side of the port holes or windows or what-
ever you call them, why w beg would at times get.on | those.
steps and on the deck?. A. That Js right. ;
© Now, these steps that we are talking about ‘are. the
ly steps leading from thie passengers’ ‘lounge to the’
10 galley below? A. 1 guess that Is what-you: are ta}k-
ing aliout. at : : |
Mr. Bolton:’ What was his answer, please?..- |.
(The last answer was read.)
- A. He has been talking of steps... ° Sipe i Ay
(). Mr. Mandell: Those are the steps {am talking about.
A. Tsay J assume that is the steps he Is speaking about.
Q. Anyway, thé answer you gave me had reference to
those steps, did it not?, A. I imagine so. That is the only.
steps we have except tw o little steps from the phot house
to the lounge ffoor. :
qQ. All I am trying to find out is this: When I w as talk
ing about the steps, you understood I was talking about the
steps from the passengers” lounge to the galley? . You un-
derstood that, didn’t you? A. Yes, sir.
(). Now, Captain,vif you wre to walk from the passen--
gers’ lounge to the galley; W hich. way would you be facing?
“A. Well, that would be depending on? w hich way vou go.
down the steps, because vou can go backward or forward,
Q. Well; which way do you vo? <A. Well, frankly, I
ean’ ’t answer that because I am so ae ‘customed to the steps
I don’t even notice them. , «
11 «SQ. Well, if I were a deckhand or an engineer‘on .
your hoat and you were in the galley drinking coffee |
and you saw me wi alking down looking forward— <A. Yes.
OQ. —would 3 you stop,me? A. Well, not tmless you was
just a new man. - If you had been with me some time, well,
it is understood that vou should know how to go down the
step. | -
Q.. Well, Captain, you are just looking at mes. sitting
right there with ‘a ‘cup of coffee in vour hand, looking’
straight at me. Would you see anything wrong in me
walking down those steps looking forward? A. Well, ves.
T would say the safest w ay is to go down backwards.
—efr cts Swi” Seer eee,
- ees ea
f ¥ i x v ~ a ; . me
;: hae ee Sp " 15
Q. Is that lg you go down? A. No. Tf just said _
that a while ago.” I don’t even know which way. I gy be-
cause I am accustomed to the step, but T meg an 3
_Q.:Why do you say—I am-sorry. I-didn’t mean to.stop
you W hy do you'say that vou: would go down the steps .
backing up? W hy do you say that is the safer?’ A. Well,
because those steps is| somewhat like a laddér and every-
body goes down a ladder backing up. Like I said, they.
don’t do it, but that w ould be the safest way.
(). Weil, when. vou talk about e. ladder you rs
12, titkine about abort: a stepladde Yr, aren't you? A.
Yes. . \ ;
. Q. Now, on-a ladder You can put your ‘foot, the ball. of
the foot, the center of the foot right on, the rung, can’t
you? Answer out loud F Reeause the reporter is: not oo
at you. Did you say yes? “A. Yes, sir. wee
Q. And the ball of the foot ‘would be: resting on 1 the rung:
-and the front of your foot would be sticking out, wouldn’ t
‘it? A. That is right. |
Q. Now, vou wouldn’t be able to stick it out on the steps
leg dine from the passengers’ lounge to the mess roon: or
to the ‘galley. would you, hecause that has a plece of. steel
right behind it, doesn’t it? A.- That is right.
Q. So the safest way to go down that step is to have
your foot and your heel right on Ht, looking Forw: ard ?
«
~e
Mre Bolton: We object to that*as @ alling tes a conc ‘lusion
and invades the province of the Jury.
The Court: Overruled. a \iee
“Mr. Bolton: Note our.exception.
?Whereupon Yr. Mandell continued reading from the
deposition, Page 107, line 17.) | +
13+) =: Mr. Bolton: Object to it as pea for’ a: conclu-
.” "gion. : |
Q.. Mr. Mandell: Isn’t that torrect ?
Mr: Bolton: ‘And leading. |
“A, Well, you couldn't stick your heel any further than
vou could. the fr ont of your foot on those steps...
QQ. Mr. Mandell: Then vou.wouid at least sce where vou
are going, wouldn’t you? “A. If you was looking forward,
9 >
you mean? .
* : . ya ° “9:
16
>
J
Q. Yes. es Yes, sir, if you w were looking at the step while
vou were going down. — Pyne |
Q. You ‘would. be’ in a much letter nosition, would you
not, In Ww alking down those steps by looking forward than
by backing up? Wouldn’t you, Captain? A. Well; as I
said, if you were looking at the step you could probably |
see better going forward. bss
‘ Q, Why certainly; » And you don’t remember now which
way you, ge dawn, whetl her vou go down forwi ard or back:
ward? A.No. T have been doing it so long. As T say, 1
: | would try. to tell von which way Tsou. down, | wowldn’
he right, because J just don’t sees ee ar ies
~ Q. Now, Captain, you have beet’ out on that boat many
"times: Ww hen the we: ther was rough? A. Yes, cuite a few
times. .
140 (y If you have to go pick ap some 1 men on & barge °
or on a drilling rig ‘and the weather is rough, why
that doesn’t stop you fram going out there, aves it? A: No,
sir. There is very few times it has hee n too rough to stop —
us. ° ‘ .
@. In other words, that boat is Aosta” to be used ih
weather conditions eventhough they: are roneh, isn’t if?
A. Lam‘sorry. I didn’tsquite unde rstand Vou.
. That boat is built to be used even in rough w eather,
sr " it?. A. That. is right.
| Do you ever remember being caught ina hurt ricane iM.
thet boat? A. No, ft hi ven a beer 1 caught ina hurricane in
it.
Q.-Po you ever. remember being in water on that boat
where you were afraid. you coul In’t make it? A. No, |
sip a
Q. Now, you might have : stayed in or did vou ever stay |
and not start on a voyage hécause there was going to bi a
big storm? JA. Well, vy has heen a fow times when they
WW roulday’ t let us go out. : 5
Q). That is right, bat as man times as you have gone. out,
do you remember of any time having hoon 6 Sp in a bad
storm? A. No. We-have never heen caught an qv
AW | bad storm out there.
Q.- Do you remember the. time when vou signed the
logbwok showing that Mr. Me. \Nlister received am injury or
pe and fe ol and twisted his back: A. Yes:
a
-
.
toe
'
a o » Tek
Q. Do you remember the we: ather conditions that existed
cat that time? A. Well, 1 don’t know exactly. When. Mr.
‘MeAHister lola me that he fell dow n the step, [told him
to pat it in the logbook that it happened. °
| Well, if it is recorded on, the same day that it: hap-
= pe ga then he must have told you that it happened on the ,
sume day 2 A. It was put in the same day that he told me
: it happened. naa | |
Q..And if. your logbook shows, it happened, on eae
.19, 1950, the nit must have hi ippe med on the sate day? .A.
Well, it is right that he put it in there on the day that he
‘told me. :
Q. That is right. 1 will show you the loabaok. That ria
“your signature, doesn’t it? That is your’ “sigpature? A.
Y es, > care
in! And it says, “R.A. MeAllister slipped: on wet ladder
teps leading from lounge to thé galley. Twisted back and —
left shoulder.’’ Signed with yotir name. Now, under:
+ 16 what date is that entry? A. That is the 19th. —
om Q. October 19, 1950, and about a line and half he--
. 1éw this. you have, ‘Friday, October 20°’, don’t you? Is
that Written if there, “Friday, October 20, 195077" A. Yes. |
| Q.; Sq, by jooking at the logbook you know: that this mat-
‘ter Was reported to vou the same day that it happened,
according to. this logbook? ? A. According to the logbook,
yes. | | .
g Mr. Bolfon: We object to the two questions end answers,
Za (Line 4 throngh 14) and ask that they: he strieken for the
reason that they relate to a-time approximately. four years
after the occurence of the event, and they arg teo rentote:
t
q
3
‘to have any evidentiary value at all: Pia
; The Court: Swstained. - : - ee
|
& . (Pages 112, lines 4 through 13, copied for Bill of Ex-
ception.) | eee : .
. Q. Do vou remember when you had that beat in for re-
pairs and you got a carpenter to fix it so that it would stop:
leaking so much water through the port holés?. A. Tt was
in for repairs last year. Last summer. ee mye ear
(). One of the troubles was that it was leaking water
as threugh the port holes?) A. Well, we give the whole
17 ~* eabin a general repair last summer, ves, sir.
aA
1s
7 A.
(). Was one of the troubles that it was leaking water
through the port holes? |
2
(cee tee ee ae
ses A
iW here upon Ms: Mandell continned reading from the
; de position. ) } : ;
A. Tt was leaking water tlirough. Some of the port gles.
and general vepair all over: the -cabin, EF mean allethe.
windows, ay pene | ee eke
(). As a matter of fact, in one instance, ‘( Captain, you.
yourself put something around these port holes to stop the
water from splashing on these stepy? Do vou remember |
that? Do you know what dumdum is?) A. Yes, ete
.
i ros
Mr. Bolton: We object.for the-reason that’ it is too re-.
mote and should not \be-détermined whether it was eon-
nected ‘with the Gecurrence in question.
The- Court: ‘Overruled. |
- Mr. Bolton: Note our exception.
(Mr. Mandell eontinued reading from ‘the: deposition
Page 112, line 22, ending Page 115, through line 11.)
“iY. Well, Pdon’t. Do vou remember putting some dtimdum.
“ground the port holes. or windows t6 stop the w ater
AG tes splashing -on the stairs? A. Yes, sir.)
| And the reason you did that, yeu nee it was
iiiabeisian for That water to splash on the stairs because
oe mieont fall” —_ fet hurt? A. Y es, sir.
Allright, - .
Mr. Bolton: I hate to.keep: bot rrupeine vou. We under-
stand that [Po sm objectitig to leading questions ‘to the cap,
tain? | |
Mr. Mandell: Yes: ‘sir, and [ nadératand that vou just
made vour objection, even though it-came a little late. ° It
doesn’t matter. |
Mr. Boulton: Tt comes late, but you ean phe ik
“question while we, are here. |
\fr. Mandell: T don’t object to it. | )
Mr; Bolton: What. IT want to say is this: Do vou w ant
me to make that objection to «6 ach. one of these questions
. F . 4
4
ve
19°
!
to the Captain, since it seems to be your Position that you
--enn ask him leading questions? pat eet
Mr. Mandell :?1 think IT ean ask him leading question,
that be a leading question. | i=
"Mr, Bolton: Yes. « ,
-Mr. Mandell:. But T would appreciate vou making the
objection. But I say this—that I don’t mean to say to-you
/ -that this objeetiow cate too late. T knew you were
19 - about to make tha ebjection and that objection \ Was
. timely and properly made. Pale Sr |
Mr. Bolton: Well, we understand. The only thing Tam:
‘asking is that-it is your position that you can ask leading
questions 6f the witness beeause he is the ¢ ‘aptain. Then
it isn’t necessary for me to make, but a blanket objection.
"Mi. Mandell: fw ould prefer that we live up to, the agree-
mentthat we made, thatthe ohjeetions are’ to be made tor
Jeading questions and non-responsiye answers, on that
right.? Be aes er ee
Mr. .Bo:ton: Yes, sir, I understand the agreement, -but I
hate to. interrupt and make. objee tions all the time.
Mr. Mandell: That is all right. You can interr “apt me
and make your, objec tion any time you vant to. T have been
inter rupted before. -. | ace
“ Mr.-Bolton: Allright. . : Sy
.Q. Mr. Mandell: Captain, after this entry of October 19,
1950 was made, do, vou. remember Mr. MeAllistér having
trouble with his.back? “A. Not right away, no, sir.
Ras But you do remember that sometime after he did?
| remember some time after that he teld me that he was
ire hir some kind of protector and it was*bothering him.
: — &. Do you remember when he went to be ope rated
; 20. on Fs a hernia? A. Yes, sin
| De you re member that this other deckhand bad
to help be from-time to time because he-couldn’t do the
' is like he used to? A. No, I don’t remember that.
. You don’t rerhember that? As long as Mr. MeAlhs-
7 was working there he was a eareful and faithful em-.
ployee, was he not? He tried to-do a good job? A. Yes,
sir.” feo ee a
(From the Redirect Examination, Mr. “Mandell read from |
the Deposition, starting Page 116, Jine, 15, through to the
end of the Si ali )
—
n
Ca
Ys,
0.
?
Q. Cantal, you have been an alternate mate. : a that
> you mean that you had charge of the boat before you.ac-.
tually became ¢ Captain? “Is that right? A. Well, ‘what
mean by alternate, there is only one master for one‘ vessel
and we work one week off and one week on-and therefore,
_1T am alternate Captain and Captain while I am on.
Q. Oh. T-understood that you said you were a mate be-
fore. Did you work as a mate on these boats? A. Well,
I caine to work with Magnolia as‘a mate on one of the
tughoats for seven days and then they give me-a boat after
- that. 3
27 ' Q.- But your exper ienee for a number of years here
has been as ‘a captain oi these bodts?. You mean by. |
alternate that you W ork sever days on and seven “days off ;
A. Yes, sir. y
-Q. But your experience has heen that of a captain? 7 A.
: Yes, sir. E >
Mr. Mandell’ That is all.
. . an
&
t }
RICH ARD ANDREW Me: ALL [S'TER, tite Plain-'
tiff, being first. duly sworn, ‘testified as follows:
Direct Examination . : ;
By. Mr, Mandell:
Q- Siate vour name, please, Sue \. Rickard Poarew
MeAlliste?: » ot ss
ae. Where w ere ‘you born? A. i ae Woras,
. What yea A. Ovtober the first; 192%...
5 How bone! okidine did-yvou have. A. T went to the
tenth grade in High Seliool. 3 in ot
- (). And what did you do after, that? > A. T went in ‘the
‘Ne ras ;
tiow old ¥ were you when vou cot into the N avy? A. |
JW as ee ; :
Did you do any -work any piace at all hefore you, :
joined the Navy? - A. Noysir.
Q.. When you lived. ine Mexia-anrd went to ainee). what.
did vour Daddy do? SM. My father was al pumper in the oll |
| field. |
Q. All right, did vou do anv baeniie at‘ all -hefore vou
. : a
—
ad
2
| went into the Navy? A. No, sir, fot on Wy own,
oS se ee Ss Rie cee
Q. Weil, did you w ork on ‘the farm aft all, whether
it was on vour own or. anybody else? “A. Yes, sir, during
the summer school vacation, I picked cotton, chopped -cot:
ton, and when I was just*a young boy, my- father was-on
the farm in Wise Coutty arid I did w ork on the farm, pick-
ing cotton, chopping cotton, various things on.the farm.
eo Q. When you w sets you joined. the Navy? A,
Yes, sir. |
Q. And how Gas did you remain im the Navy? i: IT was
in the ial three years two months and fifteen days, [ be-
lieve it wa
(). Do a re member when you were discharged from the
‘Navy? A.°Yes, sir, I was discharged on January 26th,
1946. : ie ar
., After you were discharged from the Navy, what .did.
Ngee A. Iw ent on tha-farm with my father.
And where was your ‘father farming at that time?
. Just be low W axahachie, T will say it w as ‘ibout twenty- -
nine niiles south of W axahachie,. a little place called Avalon.
(). And.who did you live with at that time? A. 1 lived
with my father. | iets
Q. Whe was living at your f father’ s house, besides,
s
4 ‘you? ‘A. There was’my father and my mother and
>
~ yey two younger sisters. Bet ere
(). Now, how long did you remain: working on the faim
with your Daddy when you got throngh with the. Navy?
A. I helped Dad get)a crop started, and we got it laid by,
and then I went to California that fall. cc
- QW hereabouts in California did you ge to? A. T went
io Coronado, California to an older brother. of qnine.
(. What did you do in Coronado?’ A. T went to work
‘as a-laborer and in a construction, gang.
Q. How long did you work there? A.-I w ouid, Sale. _ap-
proximately three wees. ae
-.Q. Then ‘what did you do? A. From there, I went to Los.
Angeles, California., I went to work as a mechanic for the
Golden Gate. Creamery in dos Angeles.
Q. How tong did you work there? A. I worked for
Golden Gate for approximately thirteen months. er
Q. What sort of work did you do for the Golden Gate
- Creamery? A. Twas a truck mechani.
o
22
a ®
~@. Did you repair trucks?) A, Trucks and the rompeey
automobiles, yes, sir.
Q. Allright, and thie ni what did you dé alter hese
20 thir teen months? «A. | eame back home and my Dad
| was having trouble getting bis crop gathered. |
-eame back home and helped | my‘! father gather his. crop
there in Avalon. seer |
(). Hi: Al long ‘did vot: stay Melnuas your Diddy with his
erop? Well, it was wiles three months; | would say,
until Novem r of-that year. - | a
(). 1940? A. Yes. Waar aoe
Q. All uae -What sort of work did you do after you:
completed hel ping vour Daddy? A. T went to Grand Isle,
Louisiana, as an-engineer on a 104-feot Diouiaeed Rescue Boat
as-second engineer. :
Q. And who did you work for? A. Theat was ee Mr.
J. L. Taylor in Houston; > ; |
Q. And how long did: you work as an engineer on those:
boats? A. I worked for Mr. Taylor, I believe it was thir-
teen months, sir. i i mek Ae} :
ee Be ay did you work after that?) A.J went to work ©
for the Magholia Petrolgum Company in Morgan City,
Louisiana. . |
QQ. Now, when you went tow ork for the Magnolia Petro-
‘leum Company at Morgan City, in what capacity did-vou
‘serve, what job did they give -you? A. When I first went
- __to work for M: venolia Petroleum, I went to work as
26 a relief engineer on the B.A. Little, a tug boat that
the Magnolia owns there in Morgan City.
Q. And how long did you work on the ug, Little? Fak
don’t know the exact time. I worked ow there,:T guess,.
ahout three months, and then T went off on the Magnolia’ ae |
other boats as a relief engineer, if someone would : gO ON
racation on the other boats, I would take their job over,
just on all of Magnolia’s boats... =» -
— Q. Did you ever work on the .F. C; Stephens, On the Motor
Veosel, J.C. Stephens?- A. Yes, sity 1 was one of thie first
engineers that went on the Motor, Vesse I J. Co Stephens
when she came down from Baltimore, Maryvland..
Q. Do your emember about when you are started work-
ing on the J.C. ‘Stephens? A. Yes, sir, I believe it Was -
November the Dist. Ce
:
Q. In what year? A. 4949. ease
q. How long did you remain on thre “J.C. Stephens? A.
I believe- I stayed on the Stephens for two and a halt or
| thr ee years
(r Do. you now remember the last date of vour employ-
“ment? with the Magnolia Petroleum Company”? o.
- Yes. , ome
97 - '‘ Q. Whatisit? A. September the 30th, 1953%
(). Well, actually working, how long, was it Au-
‘oust thg 19th? A. Yes, sis Angust -the.19th. was the, last
day I actually se ‘rved ‘on. one of the Magnolia’s Petroleum
c OrNPany?s_ hoats..
Q. Now, in September your relationship was severed, is.
that correct?) A; Yes, sir, I was officiaily terminated as of |
September the 30th. | |
(). But die aa Was the last dav of your. er
anent? ?. A. Yes,'s
“Q. To am baka you fore loa pec sone
whieh you have, Mr. Bolion. ts
Mr. Bolton: Yes, sir. |
Q). Mr. Mandell: I will ask you to look nit, the m and see
whether you recognize these to be pictures of the J. C:
Stephens, on which vou served.
Eee eigen Exhibits 1- through 1 3 marked by OSE L)
A. -Yes, s :
Q. Are these pictures, pictures of the J. (*, Ste phi anid
various parts of it® A. Yes, SL. 3
OF PERS IN EVIDENCE
Mr. Manlell: Tt it please the C ourt, we will offer im evi- ”
denee. Puarntire’s Exuyteits 1 through 13.
28 = Mr. Bolton:. We have no objections, :
—Q. My. Mandell: Exhibit No..1. is a pictute look-
ing forward on the forward part of the vessel. And Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit No. 2. shews the port on the left side of the
“yessel. Plaintiff’ s Exhibit No. 3.. shows the star-board or
right side of the vessel, looking forwatd. Plaintiff’; HiX-
hthit No. 4.-shows .the stern or back end of the vessel,
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No, 9. shows particularly the three win-
dows: or port. holes over the steps inside .that- lead from —
the galley ta the room above the lounge off of the lounge to
the oy ralley 1 below, ys laintiff’s Exhibit No. 6..shows the -en-
“
i :
‘trance to: the uae from the aft end or the back end of
ethe vessel. Plaintiff's Exhibit No: 7. ‘shows part 6f the
“lounge with the chairs upon which the men that are being |
transported sit and in one place, three steps going ‘up into
the whéel house, and the beginning of the steps going down _
iute the galley with one, two, three windows that you see
froin the outside. Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 8. shows the very
beginning of the steps with the hand rail and the: place.
whére the first step before you put your foot on the first
step, going into the galley. You only, see the first. step
there. : | ol
Exhibit of Plaidtitt, N 9. shows part of the steps after
Jeaving the. ratio about four steps, the rest of
29 the steps are obscured because’ of this table in the
galley. -We will have another picture showing that.
. Exhibit No. 10-shows part of the galley anid the tabie and —
shows some of the. here onthe walls cov-
ered with aluminum which will be éxplained Jater on,
Plaintiff’s Exhibit Ne. 11. shows the part that we conld
not see before in No. 9, You see the picture. is taken from
an angle showimg all of.the steps going down in a flooring
on a decking in the galley. Plaintiff’ s Exhibit No. 12.
shows the wheel house above the g alle ‘y and a pace to sit
down anda place for standing on.your fect, and Piaintiff’s
| Exhibit No. 13. is part of the flooring jooking down on the °
wheelhouse with mats fiere and there’ above the lounge as
well as above the galley.
Q. Mr. Mandell: What was the’. . Ste phens used for
during the time that you were fuiiied as’engineer for
them? A. The J.C. Stephens Was used for transporting
personnel to and from rigs to the shore. and bi eck with, the
Magnohta personnel and equipment. : )
Q. What was: your job, what duty -did you have about
that vessel? A. My duty aboard the J.C. Ste ‘phens was
| as engineer, was seeing ‘that the engimes were in
30 proper working condition, as to all maintenance in
the engine room, cleaning ny engine room:
@. Who had charge of the navigation of the vessel? A.
The Captain, sir. | ern
Q. And who aboard the vessel had ch charge of ke eping the
galley and the steps leading a the galley to vy lounge,
and thew heelhouse clean? A . T he deckhand,
ese eS a ee
. x 3 e\ 6)
vi : : ; a ? ; e .
Q. Was. the Stéphe MS ‘equipped. with plac es for sleeping —
quarters? A. Yes, sir, we had’ sleeping quarters for four
men in the forward peak of the vessel.”
Q). Now, I have shown yow'some. of these pictures and L
ani particularly ealling your attention to Plaintiff’s’ Ex-—
hibit No. 5.. Now, you notice this three windows here- or
port holes—will you please} tell the jury, over what area
inside of the vessel’ were these port holes looking onto!
AL 'Bhe twe port holes here are le: wing directly above the
ain ieading from the lounge to the galle Vv below,
Q. I show you Plaintiff’s Exhibit. No. 7, and ask you if
vou eft show the jury, by keeping both of these pictures,
one 6n top of the other, like this. °
Mr. Bolton: Which two. windows did. he. say were right
over the jadder?
31. °Q, Mr. Mandell: Wii you oe point out which
two-windows were right.over the ladder? A. All three
of them, these two and -this one, are actually right. ahove
the jadder. This one is sort of behind the | ladder right
above, and these two here are right above the ladder.
Q. Allnight, now, lookine at Plaintiff’s tixhibit Ne. 7,
ean vou find that inside of these three windews? A. Yes.
(). Can you point out those for us? A, That. shows the
inside looking forward on the two here. Bs his. one here is
the inside of this window here.
Q. Now, w hen you say, **this window ois vou are
speaking about. the window. right above the ‘S’? in
Stephens? A. Yes. 3 em ae
And the fwo: windows vou are talkimg about are im-
satlately below thé-—sayv up to the letter ‘fe?’ of JC.
Stephens? |
Mr. Bolton; There are two $6S’s’? in Stephens. |
Mr. Mandell: If vow are walking on the steps ‘gong
down, which of the windows are ee Meaibae: above. vou?
If vou oe down the ladder? .
().. Yes, sir... A. These two he ‘re are directly above you
as you go down. | ; | ,
Q. Allright. Now, TE will show vou. a picture that
has been introdueed in evidence . and marked Exhibn.
Do you recognize this picture? A. Yes, sir.
a Allright. What is this thing that looks like a hand
railing, where does .it begin and where does tf extend to?
A. That is an sluminim hand. rail en the port side of the
26
vessel, right along side the ladder going down to the galley.
Q. Does this hand rail exte ‘nd all thé way down to”the
end of the steps,-of the stairs? A. No, sir, I would say it
goes about two-thirds of the way down. — ee
(). Now, do vou notice also on the same Plaintiff's Kx.
hibit "No. 8, you see a little bit of a beam that runs port
ship? A. Yes, , as |
. Q. From one side to the other? A. Yes.
q.. Do you notice that? A. Yes,-that is—they call that
a grab rail, |
Q. Well, talking about the beam there. A. Yes, a
Q. And the grab rail is on-this beam? A. Yes.
(). ‘Now, if voware standing on the deck before vou
~3¢ stép dow - on the first step below, from where you
. are standing, I believe yéu say this handrail is on
-vour left? A. Yes, sir. | _
- Q. Is that correct? A. Yes, sir. nae a
Q. Can you, like any persen of ordinary heighth and
‘ovdin: ary size hands reach for the grabrail back here? A.
No, sit, you, couldn’ t reavh it from the top landing of the
ladder. | . 7 : | : |
Q. When can you re — it? A. Well, you. -could-reneh it
fairly easy from about the third step dow n.
Q. You would haye to walk one, two, “three, and then:
vou can reach it, is that correeb? A. Yes, sir.
{). On'the occasion that you served on the. Stephens, w as
this the kind of job that you served on thirty days of the
months or thirty-one days? A. No, sir, we worked seven
days straight, twenty-four hour call and then we were off
for seven days. at which time we would go back for an--
other seven.days. We would work seven days and we were
off seven days. : i |
Q. Where were your headquarters? Where would you
leave from?- A. Morgan City, Louisiana.
34 G@. -And where would you go? A. Well, we Wonka
xo down the Atechasalia River out inte Afchasalig,
Bay, into the Gulf to the Magnolia Drilling Barges or what-
ever Magnolia might have out there that they would want -
to-send us out.to. . 7
(). Well, what woukl vou go there for? A. Well, the
reason We. would go out there w ould he to change the crews
on these drilling barges, but we hi ive gone out there just
See See Vee
aad
20 |
with supplies, just take a load of supplies out tO one of
the barges. —. .
. Q, How often would you go out? > Would yon go out once |
every day or onee every week or what? A. No, sir, we. +
went every day. As a rule, we would go every day. “T heye
would be times when maybe we Ww ould mjss a, day,“if we
didn’t have a regular schedule through “run ‘and there
wasn’t any supplies or anything to take out,- and we W ould
usually say that we w ould run every day. — aie :
Q. During the time that you have be ‘en going out with —
the z C, Stephens to the various. rigs, did vou ever have,
occasion to go into crossways, or spray to hit the ‘se foot-
holds shown 1 in Plaintiff’ S Exhibits Nos. 6. and 7.2? A. Yess
“SIV. e |
Q. No. D. aad o I am talking aboul these two, these two
that I am ‘pointing at over here. A. Most any time
35 . that we would go in the Guif, the spray would hit
‘ the bow, the waves would hit the bow, they would.
break: and the spray would come over the boat.
(). Wher that happened, what, if anything happe med to
hes: area immediately below the footholds oy windows, Yor
whatever yeu may call them? A. ltew ould get wet.
Q. W hat. Ww ould get w att - A.W ell, the deck, the bulk-
“he: nds. the ladders, anything that might he below those port |
4
holes would get wet. |. : |
Q. Now, wah ladder are you talking ahout? o The
ladder leading © trom the passenger lounge ‘to the galley
below.
Q. Is ee oe the stair as shown-in ) Plaintitt’ s Ex-'
Ir: bit te Ltt: A: Yes.
~Q. This is Fi stairs that you.are talking about? A: Yes, .
Q. Did you yourself have any occasion to. see any sea_
water Janding: or hitting or raining on the stairs leading
from the lounge to the galley ?, A. Yes, sir,-' have seen if
any number of. times, any time that we would get owt into
the Gulf where the ‘spray would hit us, a would come’
thr ough. :
Q. Was that condition 1 repor ted by you to ihe Mas-
36°. ° ter of the vessel? A. Yes, -sir.
Q. Were you present when the condition was re-
ported by the Master, to any of the officers of the Magnolia
STI Just answer that ves or no, and then we will
go into it. <A. Yes, sir, I have.
a
=) e,. . . “~ ? . ° =e . .
2 uo ee ° o . .
-
Did you receive an injury or did something happe note
you\while vou wee on the J, Cf Stephens? A, Yes, sir, |
hurt ney back on the J. €. Stephens, | yee hae
Qo Pell ‘us, Mr. MeAllister, if you reed], when T asked
you betoxe w hether you were present when a re port on the
leaky condition of the ‘port holes. was made to an officer
of the Mag#olia Petroleum Company, was that before of
after the incide nt of your injury? AS Well, it: was before
and after. — -\ .
Q. Let’s talk about before, now. Do you know to whom—’
T am talking about what you yourself have seen and-heard,
snd in -vour presence, to whom those reports of the condi-
tion of the port holes avere made? A. Yes, they have been
Kp to the Marine F her ue
Who is that? “A. Mr, Dusty Rhodes, and also to the
Pa Foreman that we have Bw, Mr. Dupree. | ‘
Mr. Bolton: We would like to object to and have str ickéen
-any reports that were tuade to the Marine Foreman
By poy, unless they show the date or time withr refer-
ene? to theedate that they elaim the i injury occurred.
Mr. Mandell: IT am getting to that, Your Honor:
The Court: Allmelt.
Q: Mr. Mandell: T am talking desk Mr. ay of
ihe reports. that you know, of any that) were made in vour
- présence before the time of your injury. A. Oh, that was.
made‘to Mr. Rhodes. ) |
—Q. Was it ever made to this gentleman whose nametvouw
mentioned a minute ago, before you were injured, that is
the question. A. No, not before.’ : |
(. Well, we are limiting it only to the time before vou.
were injured. A. No, sir, not to Mr. Dupree.
©. Was it ‘made to Mr. Rhodes? A. Yes, sir,
| 0. Now, tell me when vau started working on the J. C.
Stephe ns, were those port holes, se that you could open
ne A. Yes, sir, we could open them, but seldom ever.
- Well, IT wilt soa to that later. Were they so that thev ,
wane open them? . A. Yes. | pee |
Q. How did vou open them? . A. Well, they had
38 dogs holding them down. They just unserew the
| dogs and lift them up. Sal :
().- When the vessel first came, and after T helieved von
testified it was leaking, what kind of dogs did that vessel
4 Cm
7 F ‘
come equipped with! 7A. Whe in T-first came down there, it
had the east aluminuy dogs around the ports.
(). Aftr some:time you were on that vessel and afte: i vou
were Injured, w hat happened-to those east aluminum,dogs?
A. They froze up,’the electrolysis and corrosion front the
sea water, they froze and twisted off. . |
| Q. When they twisted off, did you have, occ: asion to eXx-/
-amine the.frame, the inside frame of the port holes nen!
to the glass?) A. Yes, sir: ) |
Q. What was fhe condition of that frame? A. Well, alt
around the ports where the water had been balding, if tad
started—1it would just sort of oxidize and get soft, and the
seams were opening up..+ pe |
(). What was the condition of. the gaskets « airound tliere’
after thaf eondition developed? - A. W eli, the vaskets—we
-eouldn’t line them-up no more. The electrolysis built up,
- the corresion nehind would push | them out? to where. we
“+ couldn’t keep them flat. |
Q. Do-you reme! niber when I read this deposition
i of the ¢ Japtain, and he said something about duim-
_— dum? What is dumdum? A. That’s ‘a plastic base
material, —you sort of use it - like a Peet, T guess vou
would) say. ! |
(). Is it a caulking atta for. caulking the, windows
‘there? \ A. Yes, it is a plastie caulking compound. -
Q. During the time that you were aboard the \ -essel and
hefore the time vou. receiv ‘ad the injury, did. vou- yourself
see the Master attempting to use this dumdum or caulking
material to. stop the leakage?, A. Yes, sir, T have.
QQ. Nid it step the leakage? A. No, sir.
Now, at your request, what type of dogs were. finally
: eed’ 2 A. I had some brass ones made.
Q. Did you use those dogs andy attach them to. the port
holes or windows? A. Yes, sir, [ installed them myself. -
- Q. What happened when you would: attempt to ‘tighten.
. these brass dogs so as to make these port holes or windows
water tight? oA. Well, I could tighten the dogs down, | |
had them made to where T conid put a’wrench on it here
~ and-pull them down, but after I got them tight, the
40 frame of the window or the dog receivers, fhat is
~ amade onto the side of the>windéw frame, it bnckied,
hulled it-down and the window fr ame itself would buckle.
' Q. Now, when it. would buckle, Ww hat would happen every
time water would hit the port holes?) A. Well, after i had
buekled- out, the water could come, in around the gh ass it-
self, between the glass and the frame. |
ms Did you yourself see the water come in? A, Yes, sir,
. Do you know what the window frame was made out
a : A: We ll, yes, sit, it was‘some sort of cast aluminum.
4). Well. was. it ‘alununum? mach it was some alumi:
nun material. ‘ ; -
q). Do. you know what the upper sirueture of. the vessel
was made of, speaking. of the upper structure by the white
line? A, Yes, sir, everything above the weather deck was
alyminum, ee
(). Did you notice. what the condition of the. overhead
- pulkhead or ceiling as we anndlubbers would eall it, in the
sare *? Did yeu notice the condition? A. Yes, sir.
“What. was the condition? [ an talking about again
prior to October the 19th, 1950, before vou reeeived the
injury? A..Well, T would say in the ceiling of the galley
we had these perforated. aluminum sound proofing,
t1 ..-T. guess: you would eall it; put up there ‘for sod
proofing, and behind that, we had this. rock wool in-.
sstiation, .and when we would gef in the seas, the water
would come through. .It would drift from all these little
holes in. this perforated aluminum, onto the galley deck
and the steps, the steve, table, anythicg, our bedding and
'. all got wet. . é
Now, IT am ‘showing you Plaintifi ’s Exhibit No. 10,
wiich shows a bulkhead or the wall of the galley ‘~ Do vou
recognize it?’ A. Yes, sir, | |
~ (). Now, on looking’ at this. do vou see some of this per-
forated sluminum you ars talking about? A. -Yes, sir.
4). Ts there any di ffe ‘renee hetween the type cf material,
so fay as you know, that-is on this buikhead with the ma-
terial, that vou had on the overhead eeiling in the galley? .
A. Well, it nsed to.be the same. : : ees
_@. Dam talking about before October 19th, 1950. Was it
Oe same like-this? A. -Yes, sir.
Now, then, ‘you notica as here thev have sheets
hea they’ come together, do you notice At A. Yes.
ae eae po a
_ peli These sheets that we are, talking istient show n
> , Flagg s Exhrbit: No. 10.— were they put sto-
\
- ose a ees a
ee rosim ‘lariy, the same way on the eciling of the galley:
. Yes, sir. + .
a And did you “yourself. notice wi iter coming through
the upper deck threugh the ceiling and onto the galley?
A. Yes, sir, T have on Various occasions. . | :
— Q. So that the jury may understand what we are -talk-_
ing about, do you recognize.this to be a United States Coast
Guard photostatie map of the area shown—trem Morgan
City down to the various ‘places that vou would go?) A.
Yes, that is the same waters. ot |
Q. Would you point out to the jury where Morgan City.
is? A. This, (Pointing on Plaintiff’s Exhibit 14. .) is. Mor-
gan City, on the Atchasalia River.
Q. Show which way, the. course that your boat: ‘generally.
followed in order to-get out to the various locations of the
Magnolia Petroleum’ Company. <A. ‘Well, we would take
two routes—if it. was in the daytime, we would go down
the Atehasalia River through the Atehasalia Bay and out
hy this light house.— there’s a Coast Guard light: house
there right at-the Channel. | rs |
Q. What’s the name of this island?) AS That’s Eugene
Island light house. | . SoMey
Allfight: As And there is a beacon, on out
$3 to—well, Number’ Seven Beacon would be the first
heacon out, and from this-point here, we went to——
Mr. Bolton: [f the Court please, we object to his testi-
mony about anything. out m the Gulf unless he: connects if
up to show his i injury. happened out bevend Num her Seven
seacon. :
~The Court: Objection’ sustained. :
A. Well, from this point -here, we were going im any
direetion out. We had rigs all ont in here over as. far as
there is.a ship show light, back over hi ere, ‘That's Mareh
Island. | :
Q. You did go out into the Gulf of Mexieo wherever those.
locations were? A. Yes, \ vherever they might have their
loedtion, 9 8 : 3
(Q). During the { time that you went, out to these locations,
did vou have oceasion to meet the typeof weather that
caused swell or spray to hit these windows or port hoies
that we have on the port side.of the J. C. Stephens, tha:
ven have shown to the Jury? A. Yes, we very seldom ever
4
< 29
¢) kad
~W vent out that there w asn’t a enough spray - to wet the hoat,
—ivell, from the forward part of the cabin most any time ”
we would go out, we would get wet from the spray, pr the
waves breaking agt ainst the bow. and the wind bringing it
over, ve eee
. Q. Now, then, did you see, besides yourself, at- -
44 tempting to fix these dogs and tlie Master of the ves-
: sel attempting to caulk these windows, did you see
anyone else hefore October 19th, 1950 attempting to werk
on-these port holes oY windows, trying to’s4op the water
“A. Yes, we had a carpenter there in the ‘vard that. worked
on them sveral times. ,
Q. What is his name? A. Mr. E. C. Smith. :
Q. You say you did see him work there? <A. Yes, sir, I
helped him-at different times, we'would work on'them!? —
Q. Explain as far as you know, from the day that you.
joined the J; C. Stephens ‘until vou left them,—was the
frame of that port hole-.or window ever changed? <A. No,
Sir. \
Q). Directing your atteytion to the time that youl say you,
received your injury to your back, whiclf so far is shown
to have been on October 19, 1950, when did you leave Mor-
gan City immediately before this accident or injury took
place? .A. Well; the injury. took place ona Thursday. We
left Morgan City Wednesday morning, the. morning be-
fore. | . penis
— Q. Allright, now, did, you leave in the morning about
what time? A. Well, as near as I can remember, we
45 left around noon Wednesday. | :
_ Q. Where did the JoC. Stephens go? A. T believe
we went to Block. 126, which is just almost due south of
Number Seven Beacon. ~ |
Q. You mean further out than Number Seven Beacon?
A. Yes: : 3 3
— Q. Now; Number Seven Beacon, I believe you pointed
out, is substantially somewhere around here where f am -
pointing? A. Yes, :
Q. Well, not here. Over there, approximately the spot.
Mr. Bolton: Well, it ‘appears onthe map, Mr. ——
Mr. Mandell: All right. |
Q). Now, that is of cours¢—an that was further out, you
say, down’ there? A. Yes, ‘it was, about twenty miles, I
would say, past Number Seven Beacon.
FQ. And’ what was vour purpose of going to bat Pia
on that day?) A. We carried a cre W, at roughneck crew out
to Block 126 to swtich crews. |
Q. Whose roughneck crew was-it?. A. Magnolia Pe-
ge um Company, | : oe fi
All right, and did vou pick anybody up there? A.
Yes, sir, 1 don’t remember just how many, but we aid -
Af} piek up aierew there at the time that.we brought
the other crew out,: ~
Q. Is that what you generally did, or usually do?_ A.
Yes, sir, we bring a crew out and. thev go to work and then
there it a crew eectting off and we bring them back. to
town, | ie Paes cee .
QQ. Now, did you vessel at that time, move along side or
tie up along side a drilling rig? A.‘No,-sir, not the rig
itself. The barge—the drilling barge is pulled up to: the:
rig and we.tied along side the barge.
Q). You tied up to theb arge?. A. Yes. | ore
Q. You let the men off and‘ took s@me on? A, Yes, sir,
as I remember it, that is where we went.
Q. Where did you take these men? A, We brought them
back to this light house, this Coast Guard Light House-at
_Kugene Island. - oar aes ak |
(). What vou eall Hugene Stina ? A. Yes. .
@. And I will mark it Eugene Island. Did the men that
you brought from Bloc k 126 get off at Eugene Island? A.
Yes, sir. , :
47 “Q. What did ‘you and your crew do? A. We went
" ae bed after that erew got off. -s i
G:- And how long did vou P gers: tied up at Bu gene
Island?) A. As | remember, e left Eugene Island at two
o’elotk Thursday morning. — She
Q. And. where did you go?) A. To Number Four drilling
harge anchored off of Number Seven Beacon.
Q. You went to Number. Four. drilling barge at Nuniber
Seven ‘Beacon, is that the place we marked on the map.
which is Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 142 A. Yes, Sir.
aw hat did you do then? Did you tie up there? A.
Yes, sir, we tied up there for a few inoments. We pulled
along side. I believe. we puiled along side-and we picked
up six men, J believe, six or seven: ee
Q. You pulled. along side what? OA, This Nuraber Woer
drilling: barge. |
\
Q ow then, have you ev er seen those drilling barges *
ta tiine to time that vou-have been on it?) A. Yes, SY,
I have been all over them.
Q. And did you notice the condition of those drilling
barges? A. Yes, sir, | have. ;
Q. Generally what is their condition? A. Well,
48 they are throughout the inside of the barge, you mean ?
(). On top ofthe barge. .A. Well, on top there is
about fourteen feet, guess, above water. They have:an |
ental weather deck. The¥ store various things that they.
use’on the drilling rigs. Inside—well, en the weather deck
there, one of>the parts of the boat that gets wet, a kind of
weather deck, is«where they Have all of. their mud roulls,
the mad pumps and all of the ae hinery that they use- 6
Aad the drilling rigs:
- Q. Did you. notice whether or not-many times you have
been there as’ to. what the,condition of, the barges. were,
whether they had.any dil or grease or-anything o6n- them?
A. Yes, sir, in the pumprof#n,-or it is ter med the mudroom,
- why it is always slushy, with drilling mud that they mix
and ‘the mud pump, then the oil from all of those. - They
have a lot ef enginés ta there on this. same level. | ‘
{).. Can you tell the jury what kind of weather vou had -
when you first went out on Ogtober 18,—I believe vou tes-*
tified ‘vou went out the dav before, didn “t you? ‘h, Sea
sir. 5 | : - ap
Q). What was the weather that dave ie ‘Well, it was,
the day before, it: ‘had been a little rough, but it wasn’t
| too bad, not near enough to keep us from going out.
49°. Q. In any event, what ‘was the weather condition.
while vou were tied up there at Eugene Island? A.
Well, it was sort of a tail-end of what they call a tropical:
disturbance e-there, 1 guess.. [t was cahini Ng down: ang the |
weather was gétting pretty good. -
~Q. Well, what Tam trying to vet vousta teil the jury is,
whether it. was eetting worse or more intense or was it
sort of calming dewn as compared to the tine vou first
went out and the time you left Eugene Island: to. go to
Number Seven Beacon. A. Oh, it, had clamed down quite a
bit. It Was passing over, 2
Q. Not withstanding the fact that it-was calming. down,
aan vou tellus whether.or not, keeping in mind that. this _
Was smal! erart and infand water, was it still considered |
° > re)
Oy
“2 > eaepetanetans
rough weather?? A, No, sir, not in there where we were.
We were; from where that hghthouse there is—it Is shallow
water~-well, What we ‘term ‘* Protected water
Q@. Keeping in imind the kind of weather that vou had
at that times did you have any of the spray or seas hitting
the port holes, particularly the port hokgs over. the area
that we have shown above the-lad der. ie ading to. and from
lt don’t have. to be much of a spray, if you have got
OO a little bit of wind, it all goes together and carries
it around, — ee ees ot heey. . eta
—— Q. When you are enginetr in the engine-room, where
/is your duty, where are you supposed to be at all times?
A. Well, Lam either in the engine-room or right at it.
~Q. At the time that the vessel tied up at Mugene ‘bsland,
who actually ‘tied up the vessel, nbout two.o’elock or four
—o’cloek in the morning: maybe, how long did it take you to
get from Eugene Island to Number Seven?. A. It is about
a forty-five minute run. It is not very far, but it is in
shallow water, and you have to run slow. ?
That is if you |] {t about two’e’clock; approximately ’
| when would you aay that vou reached Number Seven
+. Beacon? A. Well, we ‘would get up ai two and maybe wWe-
/ would get under way by about two-thirty, warm the en-
| gines up and tlien w eV would get under way probably. a littie
; ae three o’clock. : : | 7
; . Sometime ee three-thirty and four o ion you
» were at the Number Seven Beacon? . Is that correct? A.
As near as I ean remember, ves, sir. 420 3 | ¢
~Q. I believe vou testified that: you had to tle up to those
’ barges over there? A. Yes, sir. ae
~ . Who tied up the vessel? A. The dec k- hand and my-
. , self.
2 OL Q. W here would the sone hand go to? “A. The.
deck-hand takes the bow line andthe engineer catches.
» the stern-line. It makes it a lot easier,for the Captain to
have two men to catch the lines instead of just one.
| Q. Tam showing you P laintiff’s Exhibits Numbers 3 and
14: i want you'to show this jury where you were standing
_ when ‘you were tying up to the dock, I am showing you
5. now, Plaintiff's lixhibit No. 4.. A. Well, i would. usually -
| stand inside the well: deck, he IPs if We would cast the line >
oh
the galles?) A. ¥es, we still had some wind and a spray. «
<a
9g —
on the port side, | would be here, and if 1 e aught the. line |
on the starboard side, | would be back along here.
YW). De you now. remember. which side you were on? A.
As I remember, | was on the starboard side, ox 2s
Q. So you were on the side where’ the flag is? “A. Yes,’
. And where was the eka? A: He.would be up
here on the bow. | :
Q. Do you remember whether it was necessary. for you
to get out on the outside in the weather or were you able —
to stav inside and underneath that canopy? A. Well, when
we would come alongside, why they always have the deck-
hands on the barge would }low the whistle as Vou. get
there, and the deekhands would come ont,—W ‘hich they
would throw: ‘hime a line and then they. would make
2 it fast over there, and on the Stephens they don’ t
‘make it neeessary for us to get out.
. Well, is it your testimony then that vou did Or did
not get out? A. No,-sir, I did not.
Q. You did not get out? A. No, sir. :
Q- Allright, sir. When you let go the lines, did you
‘also help let go the-tines? A. Yes, sir, ——- :
Q..And did .you find it necessary to’ get out on the”
~veather-deck—1 am talking about—well, did vou: actually |
stand inside undefneath that canopy or did- you have: to
go out on the wéather-deck? A. No, sir, when [ catch the
lines the re, E throw my Iie from iene and | don’t. use’
fhat aft-bit, I use the stern-quarter bit. That stern-quarter:
‘bit is just maybe twelye- or fourteen, ine ‘hes inside of the”
Ww 7 decks. | |
. About how long did the operation take tying up and
| tae eo the line, picking up your men? <A. Well, from.
the tine that we came along side, tying up, getting the
men, aboard and letting it vo, it. W oald be maybe fiye OF": SIX,
minutes. — . es .
(). ss sir, when you got ‘through your job, where
vas your station next, when ¥ YOu gf eh through } lett ing
‘Ba * - 80 the line? A. Ir “Le enginercom.
Q). Allright, in avliee to get to the enginerooin,
‘what route is there available to vou? A. Well, I would
—jeave the well deck and I would go through the passenger’s
lounge.and into the galley and then back aft te my engine-
room. %
. | 7 a — (Recess) a oF
Mr. Mandell: Mr. MeAllister, in order to get back—
| - the way, Tt tetieve vou said that you he ‘Iped tie up. Whi’
q did vou have to go back to the engine room? A. Well, that
is inv job in the engine room. W ed, they were niyv pesponsl-
bility. | "Smee, |
Q. Now, then, what route did you follow’ to get to the
engine room! A. T went fr6m the aft deck there-—we
ull go throngh thé passenger lounge and down to the :
galley. | a ie. Oe Re Cet er em st”
* Q, Now, then, speaking going through the passenger
| foaitiae: is that part of the aft port which is aitahacla up by
a canopy, Ray that correct? A. Yes. : ee
), As shown in Plaintitf*s Exhibit No, OF A. Yes.
oF . -And you walk into the lounge? A. Yes, that. ds
the passengers lounge..- ; | we
— Q. And then down to the galley shown in this picture
over here right next to the lounge? A. Yes, sir, that is the
passengers lounge there. |. : .
Q. And then down there into the galley 1 ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. From the monient that'you stepped out, began to step
out from the passengers lounge onto the first step of the
galley, I want yeu to, explain ‘to the jury exactly. what,
happened. A. You mean from the time I did what?
Q. You walked from your station—when you let go the
line, you walked into the lounge, did you not? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You walked forward into the lounge until you get
to the part to walk inte the galley? A. Yes, sir.- | |
Q. Allright. Now, at the time, I believe vou ‘testi ified,
that the weather ‘was such‘that sprays and seas were hit-
ting the port holes right’ over the steps | leading to and
From the galley? A: Yes, sir. - , :
_ Q. Now, then, I. want-you to tell the jury exactly what.
happened ‘from the. time you stepped from the lounge onto -
- the first step, on the. stairs leading to the galley?
oo A. Well, first from this approach, there is a littfe
vestibule- like right there abeve the ladder, and I
stepped onto the ladder, that. has got this hand rail right
hy the side of it. When, you are walking - down, why -you
just grab the handrail and vou-step, and as I stepped, mvy-
foot just -shpped right. out from under me and .my heels
hit on the ladder going down and they have a fire ex,
‘tinguisher right on the Duikhead es rignt after you
get to the bottem, and any. shoulder struck that, as. I went
_down with the force of iy fall, vulledd ne sideways —L lost
my grip on this handrail and my feet hit the deck ‘ane
then I went on down—and then my se aut, andsright after
-that—there was a galley table, and my feet went in “under
the galley table, and that is where I stopped.
a hen vou fell, what part of your body hit. the deck?
A. M y: heels. and then -ny seat,
. You mean you just ‘sat down hard? A. Yes.
0. Now, did vou-feel any pain at that time? “A. Yes,
sir, when T hit that, well, I didn’ t feel my sheulder so imnuch,
well I didn’t even notice my shoulder right then. ‘Mv
‘shoulder got sore afterwards, but the pain that T feit.
was right in the small of anv back. [| had:- a—well, like
ore burning sensation. there, and mv legs were numb.
56° LT was-sort of stunned-like. = S
Q. "lam showing vou here Plaintiff” s Exhibit No.
11. Js that tte fire extingr isher vou are’ ta king about. i‘
A. Yes, sir.. s j
(). And. what: part of tis deck: did vour Muttoclan hit?
A. Right here at the foot of the ladder. | |
-Q..And your feet went underneath that table? A. Yes.
Q. Now, what did vou do-after you fell? AL Sir?
(). What did you do? A. After I fell? re
Yes. A. Well, I got-up. We have some chairs there
around the galley table and [sat down for a while. — ©
4. Who-was there when you fell?) Do you remember?
A. Well, the deekhand was right belind me; Mr. Ashton
was-our deckhand at that time.” He was toming down right:
‘behind me and he helped me up and T sat down in.a chair
there and [I staved there for a while and | got up. and got
straightened up and went on into my enginéroom. -
Q. Did von have occasion to go look at the stairs from
which vou slipped?) AL Yes, Mr. Ashton and T looked a
at.’ Well, if vou. slip on something vou are sates
57 to know what vou slip. on, and Mr. Ashton-and I
. looked at the step. You éould see the imprint of
mv foot where it slipped. 6ff: Well, U passed my hand on
it and. it was-ol,a sort ofa filim-like of oi] and water on
the step.
an
me
Q. At that time did von notice whether or not water
was Coning through the port holes above these steps? A.
Sir, it was coming through there and the deck above too.
().. In view of thesweather condition ths if crifted at that
time or at any time when you have that pitehiig or relling
of the vessel hee Use of the weather condition, is. there any
way that either Vou ‘or anyone else could Keep those steps
elean from water or anything wet? A. Well, no, sir, not
unless vou just stood right therewith a mop and just con-
tiniously mopped. ° When the boat, would roll and. that
water would splash in, if vou would Just stand the re mop-
ping it would be the only way to keep it, up.
Q. After vor inspected it and saw the, condition’ of. the
stair with water and oil on ity what did vett.do? A. T went
on into my engine room. me
Q. W hat: was the condition of your back at ‘that tine?
A. Well, after [ sat there for a while, when | got up, |
Jegtiots ‘stoop. F would have.to squat down. The passage
" port hote or hateh, they would call it, going into my
engine room well vott have to stoop to go in, and
as after that, I couldn’t stoop or, bend over. I had to.
just squat, bend my .knees and lower my head, vou
know, as you go through. vane
Q.. Did ‘vou ever have. any. such. ‘litte ulty with vour bae k
ere ‘before. ;
‘Q. Now, Mr. Me Allister, ‘that happened on, the 19th, and
[ behave you said that you came to wayk to report on the’
nua OT) Bs 18th, the day before, wasjit not? A. Yes,
| 0). Ancol holiéve Vou testified that, you worked seven
days only?.. A. Yes, sir. -
Q. Did vou continue working those seven days from
before? A. No, sir. “TF had never had mV ; back in that
WwW ednesday until the following Wednesday? A. Yes, sir,
[ worked out there that whole week,
_@. What was the condition of: vour back.frorm the minute —
vou fell until vou finished out there the seven davs? A..
Well, I never could kend over after that, and I had those
pains down the sides ef my legs. It sort of paralyzes vour
‘leg, hke you lose the feel of them, vou éan’t-keép your
balance. ; ; : . ‘ \
Dive Allright. New, during that time were you—state
vhether, the vesser was in any water that: had any, roll in
“ Cre ingae 2 ii nn °- © | ; - |
whie h’ the Very vessél rolled cand: pitched? how were
a ven able to havigate. by vour self? ? A. Well, when we
— rere flaving | ‘Vhoxe, What we woul: 1 calla pretty ‘rough +
spe tere andthe ne was rollipg axe pite hing; [ didn “te .
7 Ape SO rood. a * 7
Well, aa dick you at \- W a thiit. emia of
de "Woat, from the wave s hitting ityit jarred the whole boat
and the rocRine nad rolling just continuously holdigg on
to see all the Brneevou are always under a strain.
| What lid thht de to.vour back afer vou got hurt’
A. “Wye Hin that type of ‘weather, I stayed pretty close to
Sis *htaek. Eh act this Ashton, the devkhand “on the re—they
would help me‘out; makesmy rownds for mé, ind every
hogr or so then | would get up and make the round myself. ,
(a Naw > when yon got hepne— awhat did vor do aftertyou
ot home? AL | went to, ity family doctor. :
4) \ tie is he? A. That’s Dr. Borwnelle the re in Morgan
-
noo Dee
a (" Uy. wi : ° ¢ . ow
ae (). Thats is ‘thee sane p ‘ice Where the. Magnolia’ iis
yet hen adquarte rssthére in Louisiana? “AT ¥és.,sir.
And whit did. Dr. Borwnetle ‘do for you? A. Well, he.
leave mecan @ yuunim ition, put me oon hits table, aud asked
: me how Hurt ome and told ane, well, he was
e . P is t s e ~¢ e .
_ * 5 {pe i
Mi going (o- :, Y A :
Q..No, Wait a minute. “You are not permitted to
‘say what Jr. Borwnelle told vou; byt you are, permitted
rage Say ‘what he did to vou. Did hé give you anything to
wear on, VoOur bac 1 A. Yes, sir, he t tapeal mi buck Up ee
fromn— welk, up te my ribs down to my rump. At that time, &
that’s all he did. | . | a
x @. Did that-help vou any? -A. "Yes. str. a ae &
‘ t). Pyiel vot atte ‘mpt to-go back to work! A. Yes, sir, |
went back to work the next week, ) ae
~ QS Hhow cid your back feel at that. time? ~A. Well, b still.
couldn't stoop, or conttda't solacwbuy eh heavy. - Well, just’
tm may duties throughout | the boat there, I had a pretty
vough go®ef it there” " .. : nage
(). Affer vou rested awhile, did your: back, seen tosbe:
vetting a Inftle’ better? At Well, vow can, get. yourself
straightened up and you can ged around, not that I would
say] got better, bi? T got myself straighté ned up and J
went kai avbout TAY fluties,
2
“ oa . £ .
: . a . a ee | 41
oe a : ee ;
Q. Did. Dr. Borwne He fin: ly? reseribe sonic thing for vou
ty wear? “AL Yes, sir, I wot a hak brace to wear inde yuk
ae lothes. . ‘
a). Is that someghi ng that Dr. Bors nelle: avid Vourto
. vet? a” 5 Ear Sean : :
6b QL And where. did You eh it » A, In New Or,
* leans. ‘ PASO oa .
P . - ?
Q.°%And how long did “yon wear “that? A. Well, 1 word
Ht. a L yyould say it lasted for a year or better.
«4 And when that wore out what did vou dot A. Well,
& eae tuv log book. : ; :
. (). No, gid veuw finally get another one? x, Yes, ale
got another pelt. | omer :
n 4). Alright. © Did your ¢: sadition get better or worse ‘as
, Thine Went any! A. We ll, at se romped. to vet just progressively
ro Worse. BS .
: Q. Did vou yee seek the ndviee of a seca New
Grleans?) A. Yes, sir: ! - :
Q). And:«who was that? That was Dr. Battalore. “
().. Do von kuow yO or not he was an orthopedic
surgeon? - A. Yes, sir, he was'a specialist in that type of ,
work. aes ; _
Q@. Did he examine vou? *\. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you reme mbar whether or. Rot that was in Mareh
of rage A. March the 12; 1 believe, 1953. ape.
. Did vn tell vour eniplover where you were going?
: A. No, sir, £ don*t—when T got off 1 just went over
|= G2 there. It wasn't on-—-- v
.
want you to answer this next questién -yes “ar na: Did he
advise you What you may have to do? A,-Yes, sir,
Q). Allright. Right after vou received that advise, did
vou report back to yotur-employer? A. Yes,-sir, |
(). Whe did you talk to? A. | talked to Mr. Rhodes.
Q- This gentleman sitting here?s: A. Yes, sir.
— Q.. And what position did? Mr. Rhodes Aave? A. I -be-
lieve he. had bee mn advanced.,
Q..To what?, A. An Assist tant Production Foreman, ‘|
helievet : , 3
(). Anyway, did vou: then talk to Me Rhodes as the rep
resentative of die Magnolia: Petroleum CC ompany? A> Yes,
SU.
(), Allright. After Dr. Battalora exanuy] lvou, 1.
:
(Q). What did you tell Mr, Rhodes at that time! AaWell,
‘TL told hin’ what. the doctar had said and—— A
Q. W Nee/ did voursav? A. Well, T told him. what tin: 4
‘doctor had told ine and told ti im that I wanted’ to gd to the
‘hospital, . : :
: 'Q. ‘Did you or did’ you ‘not, tell him theit vou Ww canted
63 the Company to take care of the operation, that the.
‘door advised it? > A: Yes, sir, 1 told him that I
had had the accident: 6n the: job there, Me the Magnolia’ s
hoat, that T thougkt. that the Company should pay uy hos-
pital bills hice ce ar =
Q. ‘What did Mr. Rhodes tell you about that? ‘A. behind
he asked nie about my. own insurance, i
Q., Welly did he say go ahead and have our ‘ope tration?
A. Well, “no, as | remember,,they wrote me out some slips
and told me to go-to a Marine Hospital in New. Orleans.
~Q. When was that?. A. | delieve-—— } |
(). sii as that.ih July? YN, J believe it w ae teat “before
‘lgit. ko wrote Senie lettérs. ‘He was voing to write a letter
for ine to the’ Company. L believe he wrote a letfer to Mr.’
Lew’ Avres, Whi WAS 2 production foreman, .| believe he
was. ves :
_Q. My quéstiqn ix, did the € Olnpany at hat time imake:
ar rangemes ts at any priyate hospital ov with any -private -
phystwian so sora yore could have an 6peration on aur
back? A: No, sir, Lfaited té get any arrangement.
©. That was some ae m- Mareh, 1953—did your condi--
tion get better or Rong trom Marei. to Saly? A. No, sir,
it got w sedi ; at " ;
Did Fou athe naga ad@your employer for some -
O4 . “na with referc nce tovour pliysieal condition? «A.
he = Yes, sir, Thad an interview ‘with the District Super-
-iptendent and well, he told-me about his ease, that he had. .-
— — ; Pe ete
Welk, lets hot vet into some other, eases. “Let's stick
to vours. Now, just tell us whether he did make. arrange-
ments for you to have an spenation at the hospitak or
froma private physician. A. No, sir [ vtill didn’ t get no
si a hehe . :. : ay .
, Allright, was it at that, bime that. vou hot a letter
ce vour © dinpay to prese nt yourself to the U.S. Publie
Health: Ser vice at New CrleanS? . A, Weill, it was 2 little
while after that, yes, sir. oe ee a
® ? ° : i. s ’ °
*e
t Ya
; si
.
.
ata i ae
~ Q. Allright, did vou at that time, go to the New Orleans
Hospitaj! A. Yes, Sir, T-went just as soom as I got the
slip that entitled me to treatment at the Hospital.
:Qe Ast an American Merchant Seaman? A. Yes, sir.
Q@. Allright: did you: report tor the hospital-in New Or-
leans region? A. Yes, sir, 1 went to New Orleans...
‘QQ. How: long were vou kepr—I mean. were you an ‘in-
patient or an ont:patie mt? AL Weil, T guess vou wotdd call
it an out- -pati¢nt, T went there, they gave ne an ¢ xamina-
tion, X-Rays, and told me that they were going to put me
“in the ‘Hospital. there,
° °
"65 _ Q. They told vou that they were going’ to put
_ Vvew in the Jospitak there, Did vou vourself Racusbet
to be-sent to the Galveston Hospital? AY es, sir, | talked
bs
to this Dr. Wong. . : Soy
Q. Tell us whe ther vou requested to he sent to the Gal-
veston Hospital? A. Yes, sir. i eg
(). And why did vou do that? A. Well, it wend make
ita lot easier for my family. My folks live in Hot ton, and
with my wife ¢ and children, it would make it-a lot handier
t they weré in--l could deave them With my-folks there in
Houston’ and Galveston is net far from there, if I could
just as Well-go to Galveston, | would hake it lot easier on
). Allright, now, ‘did’ the ‘vy transfer you to the east a]
at p ona A. Yes, sir, T went back to the Company and
also requested of the Company tliat | could go,to Galveston,
and they made nfe out a slip.ta go the Galvestorgil. ospital.
Q. Is this. the copy of the slip that they made out? A.
Yes.’ “Eda
(). Adiiessed to the Hospital in Galveston? ’ Yes,
ss)
Bee OFFE R IN EVIDENC Da
‘This lxhibit is marked Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 1b. We?
offer it in ev idence e,\
“¢€6.. Mrs Bolton: No objection.
Q. Mr.-Mandell: Did vou present this to the Ma-
rine Hospital? A. Yes, I tony rt to Galveston and was ad--
antted there. : +s
Q. Were you adinitted to the hospit: r or did you receive.
out patienttreatments first? A, W ell, | had’ what they
call an out patient tre atment, when I first went there,
ease ae ¢ ca ear
»°
4
_paralyzed.. Lb just conidn’t ‘get around.
s] r.
44 | Seog aeeas aye pene
Q." Hicw long did vou \ have: out patient treatinent? A.
. For two weeks. .- \ ° .
Q.. And then did they put vou ie the Hospital? A. Yes,
after ‘that, [ went in, was a as an in patient there
in Galveston, }
Q.. And how: logis did vent remain an in patient there?
oY Pden’t remember exactly. ; 3
Q. Was it from Junl 28rd, 1988 until ed the 4th,
19537 -A. Yes, sir, I believe it was. .
. At the trme when vou were discharged from the hos-
pital, did you feel somewhat better after that two weeks
there? A. Yes, sir, they took pretty good eare of me there
and | was feeling somewhat better. — . ;
Q). Alivight after vou left August the sth, did you then
return to your employer?. A. seas sir, | went back ta Mor- -
gan City, Lotisiana.
(). Did-yvou attempt to work after that? A. Yes
sir, * Spe
Q. Were you able to work after that?’ -A. No, sir? I.
worked a few days. gone Eig eT 3
Q. And then what happe med? A. l just couldn’t take it.
I had: to get off. rs pare ee tas
Q. What hurt ‘vou? A. Well, my hack and-my legs; first
one leg and then the other, sometime both legs, sort: of
-
Gi
Q.. Did vou finaliy have to leave on August: the 19th,
1953, have. to.leave that employment? A. Yes, sir, 1 left -
again to Ap back to the Hospital °°; : s
Q)-Pid vou try to get back into the hoshpital A. Yee,
sir. .; ;
(). W ere you able to get hack into the Hospital? - A. No,
Q..W Ue they would not’ ieceive you in the Hospital,
avhat did you do, where did you come to? A, . went to
Houston.
Q: Shortly ther after, did: you see a sisuiine in Hous-
ton?’ A. Yes, sir, I-saw. Dr. Battalora.
‘Q. In Houston? A. No, sir, that was-—Battalora was in
New Orleans. I saw Dr. Brodsky in Houston. .
68 Q.° What kind of a physician is Dr. Brodsky, what -
-y kind of work does he do? Is he an * orthopedic sur-
geon?’ A. Yes sir, hé j is an orthopedic speci ialist in that.
f vf * 3 40
aa * as ~Atlrieh a? e You been idby his care since? ‘As Yes,
sir, k have been under his ¢ are ever since, |
Q. Now, sometime in January of 1954, did? ‘vou, ee
to get back into the hospital, or ta obtain héspital trea
ment? A. Yes, sir, 1 went back - Galveston, and they ‘told
me I wasn’t entitled to get hack.
(). At that time, aftér August 19th, 1953, on until Jano-
ary 1954 when You went back to the hospital, did you have
any kind of attempt to work?’ A. Yes, sir, I tried several
jobs, tried to get several jobs. — - | 7
Q. Did you get some kind 6f work? A. Yes, sir, | went
to work at burial park, Brookside Memortal, | Wwelic ‘ven
was, there in Houston. 3
. Was that the Bookside Memorial’ Park? A. Yes, sir.
(). Allright. About hew long did you work there? A.
l wenke « there about five or six weeks, 1 am pretty sure
it war's. ;
Q. Now, during the time, what kind: of work did vou do
there? A. Well, [was what they called a maintenance man
, on law mowers and. the little trucks that they use in
69 the cemeteries, dragging equipment around.
Q. Did you eperate thetn er did you keev them in
repair? A. No, sir, | repaired them. |,
Q. Were yeu able to do that work without any pain? A.
iiss sir, Thad a rig eoncrete shop there. [ was the only
‘man, just the one epair man, and I -worketKin this little
conerete shop, concrete deck, and j just finalty had to hay
off of that job. "
Q. Well, did vou work titnapriincree five. or six. wecks or
did you have to take off some ‘time?’ \. Well, I took off one
_ time, yes, sir. hoses “.
i. ~Q. How long? A. I Inissed three days ner
: q). What happe ned after ‘that? ? T he Vv liv ed. wie off,
Q). Now, did you work any more ae 193 pt all? A.
.« No, sir. :
Q). In 1954, did you do any work or. “try to do any work?
Oey See at Oe
(). Did you try toda any ; work in 19; 4 A. Yes, sir, I
tried working as a carpenter’s helper, |
A). And ave’ did you.try-to work for? A. That was a
“Mr. John Landry: My father “gof ine on there. AV
~ Q. How long did you work there? - A. About a
month, .
Y
7 (). Were vou able to, ao that work withoat any
pain? A. Well, no, ‘sir, they wouldnt--1 conldn’t get
on any. scaffold. We were deing Just general reyiair, I
couldn't climb the ladder, | couldn’t get to the roof to.
put the reofing on and | laid off, Thad to Ja¥ off?—- Phe
yeve I didii’t miss but’a week en -that job. | .
Q. Were you able to de. that. work without any pain or
disahilitv? A. No, sir. :
“@Q. Did vou have another job during 1954? .4. Yes, ater
they faid me off there wen? cut to the’ Mus seum of I* ine.
— there in Houston and got Qn as a janitor.
. How tong did vou work there? A. T worked a week.
5 Were. vou able to de that work?) A. No, sir, my job
tie ‘re Was sweeping and handling these marble statues and
the big pictures that weighed a way up in the pounds, just
the fr ame, and I just couldn’t ft them. L conldn’t. move
the i marble around: T just wasn't table to beld up to it.
Q. Didfthey keep you on that job? A. No, sir, I went to
work on a Monday and on Wednesday morning: they told
me that they would let me avork out thie week and then
they: let me go, |
ie eT oe showing 4 you yeur withh olding statement
for 1953—of Richard Andrew MeAllister—is this
your Social Seeurity Number up here? “A. Yes.
Q. 465-22-0197, Now, how mauch did veu earn for the time
that tou worked that six weeks? A. $587 405.
Q. Then at John Landry Company, Inc. that vou worked
for in 1954 about a month, [ helieve you said, How ‘nue ‘h
did vou earn. there? ns 7
Mr. Bolton: Are vou offering that? /
Mr. Mandell: No, Lam just letting him use that to re ef resh
od
‘his memory.
Mr. Bolton: I object to that, to him ugg that, because
he, di dnt prepare that. 1 don’t want him to refresh his
ntemory trom 2a ene
The Court: Do vow object. to them on the bagis that
they are not memorandums spi alas this witness?
© Mr. Bolton: Yes, sir.
The Court: T will sustain the objection. SG
Q. Mr. Mandéil: Were there any. other jobs that you,
he cP besides these three? A. No, sir. a
6). Have you earned any other kind of money wiht the.
Pas
en ee 47
exception of these—whatever Tnoney, you earned ts
72°. from these-employers?) A. No, sir, J have not.
~ Q. Now, this-work that, vou did for Landry Con-
pany, Inc. and’ for the Memorial Park and for the Muse ate
ot Pine ATS in Houston,—were vou able tooddey that work
without anyv-pain or difficulty?) A. No, sir, Pw asn't,
— Q. Now, before October the: 19th, 1950, tell the jury what
other injuries, if any, vou ever received. A. Well, used te
ride a motorevele befere ft got married and’ b had a little
brush burn on that, spills, skin your -elhows ‘or something
like that, and then Thad a back injury with Magnotia,
Q. When was that? <A. | believe that was in Getober,
1949, _& at _
4. Now, tell the jury just what happened, what boat
were youon? A, T was on the D. A, Little, one of the Mag.
nolia’s tugs. We had taken a load of cemént eit to one
of tlre barges in the Gulf, and the deekhands and 'the rougk-
necks.off of the bange we re untoading this cement, and we
would always—-the boat crews, if we could, we would give
them a hand, and F picked up a load of this cement here—
[ was helping them shift the piles so it would make it easier
be, for them to pick it up and put on the buckets that
8 they lift it off with onto ‘the barge. - 1 picked up a
bag of cement and [ turned around and went to piace
it onto this other pile to where they: could pick it, up and
put it in the bucket, and-as J went to set it down, the boat
lurched against the line and | lost my balance and I fell
over against this stack of ceme nt, and it was what the
| doctor said was a sprain in my back, a sprain or muscle.
_Q.-What doctor was this? «A. That was Dr. Guesmard
at Morgan City. ;
(). And what did he do for vow?) A. He'tapeod mv baek
up and told me I eould go back to work.
Q. Did vou go back to work?) A. Yes, sir 7
(). Did you “have any trouble with it at all from that
time on until your second + ha be ? A. Na, sir, | wore. that
tape about three days. and thei: | took: the t tape off and I.
have ever been bothered with it sine: >,
Q. Did you ever have. any other injury to your back ex:
cept this slight injury of October 1949 and this injury of
October 1980)? A. No, sir, that was the only times. ><
‘(). Did you. ever file a claim. before in your life? A,
No, sir, os ai Ae TaN aor ,
b
e
48
Q. Did ody ‘ever have auy lawsuit before, in voyr
: hfe? M me © , a /o j
74 «> Q. Tell the jury whether there was any: other way 4
3 “of your fretting to the galley, that carly -nrorning of,
October Oth, 1950, except in going broim the actual deck
under the canopy info the lounge ahd dow n the steps mto_ ,
the galley. Al Yes, sir, | could have gone down either side
of the cabin, down the weather deck into the wheelhouse
aml then from the wheelhouse down into the lounge and
then back inte the galley and into the engineroom. Ueould
have went, down either side of the boat. ~ ee a
Q. Now, speaking about-the side of the Doat, Fam show-
ing von Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 2.) Can vou point out te.
the jury what other way vou could have gone: except the
way vou did go? A, Well, | could have—out from the well
deck, I could have come up the side.of the.boat between the
ceabin and tie outside railing of the boat into the wheel-
heuse and then from a Wheelhsttse to the Jaunge and then
down. , |
(). "Now, if vou had done so, how much space is there to
walk ¢ on between the outside edge of the vessel and down
to the bulkhead?) A. | guess there is abont twenty-four or
ye ngs six in¢thes, -
_ Is there any railing in between? A. No, sir. |
ms What was the condition of the weather at that time
with reference as to whether or not the boat was
75>). rolling and pitching? A. Well, yes, sir, it-;was rolling
: and pitching: it'wasn’t bad.. We were in protected
waters there, what we eall protected water, shallow water,
the ‘re off of Number Seven Beacon. — . ; 3
~ (. Now, whati s your practice or what did. vou do on
_ thesmorning of Oct: ober the 19th before you walked into
“your—into the .galley—you stepped on’ the: step, with ref
erence to your shoe, A. Well, | had been out on the dec k
—that weather that we weré having, it was wet-<well, |
. always keep a very clean éngine room: That is one thine
that I-was always particular about, was iy éngind, room,
and we have there on the “boat. some mats, there between
three feet long or two feet long, big thick miats. a
() Something like these shown on Plaintiff's Exhibit
No.,132 A. Yes, sir, that looks like the same ones, We
kee .p a mat at each entrance to the boat there to cle: an our
> 7
a
.
Se ee ee, Cee See
ets
"well,
. a | 49
feet of pa I got into the boat ‘TL cleaned thy feet, wiped
my feet on my mat the re andl walked on down the aisle 3 in,
> the crew lone, OF passenge rs Jounge and then on down to
the galley. ” . . ;
(). While you were®nnder the care af Dr: ‘Brod ky, did
Dir, Broadskyv have some X-Rays taken of your back? °A,
3 Yes, sir. ‘8
ee. (). dn his own office? AG Dr. Brodsky?
a Q. Yes, ia his own offiee?. A, ‘Yes; thetne iW” Hous
a ~; 8 sean eet SENET at
_). Now, then, “after, vou “had heen treated by. him for
some. time, dk he have t a speck ul test made on your spine?
A, Yes, sir, he sent me up tea place there in‘Houston, Dr. -
po ‘ry; Turner & White, | believe it was.
. What did they do to you over there? A. Well, they r
, the on this table _ ran what they call aemyve logram,
or something like that. < | .
(). Well, what did "ea do? Do vou know?) Did‘vou feel
waat they did.te you? AsYes, | could feel it,
Q). Well, what was it? A. Well, they injected this fluid
‘in your spine, th 4
Q.. W ell, did vou foel diet stick a needle in Your spine?
A. Yeas, sir. : es See a mt
ae , sah
). Well, anyway, did they = you that test? AM Yes,
ae 3 “ * .
Q. And what after effect did you have from tliat? A.
Well, they told me to go right home and lie down just as
quie kas I could get home. . TL had br ought -sbiieone
wi to drive ane back liome,.and I had to eall him up
~ that night again to get some medicine,
7
. Well, what hurt you, that is what] want you to tell
us: A. Well, it.was my back and thy head. I hadra very
severe headache after that mve logram.
Now, Mr. McAllister, from the day that you were ‘ine
jured, Oetober the 19th, 1950, to this date, did: vou, ever
havea day that you have-been free of pain in. vchir back ?
A, No,_ sir, not entirely. .l have good day s—well, days
when «T feel pretty good,— ~Well, my legs don’t bother mie,
When it is just in my back, | can make it around pretty
(). Was it painful? AX. Yes, sir, they had to hold you on -
\
50
= e.. : '
(). Even during. those days what happens if vou walk
as much as two or three blocks? A. Well, I just have, to’
sit down. . Mv legs just give out on me:
(). Are vou able to sleep at. night, all-night? A.,-Well,
souvetimes ‘T get a pretty good hight’s rest. As a rule,-]
don’t rest teo well. ea |
Q). What happens then?” = Weil, it’s just like 1 can’t
vet comfortable. [can’t get inva position to w ner ‘re it Jets st.
went quit bothering me. a:
. What won't quit wothering you? A. WwW ell mv bac ko
and those pains down my legs...
78 () What happens when you suddenly turn?) “ea
Well, .£ just’ don’t do that any more. [ just don’t
turn fast, Well, it just shedts those pains down. into my
. legs and into Wy fe “ets it just paraly zes me, like, and numbs -
wiv legs. oo
Me
~~
Q. 1 assume that hefore October 19th, 1950, you some
times did conzh and sneeze, did-vou not? A. Yes,.-sir.
Q. Did it-ever bether you before. Oetober aera 1950,
are vou would either cough or sneeze? A, No, sir
Q. Now, what happens since October 19th, 1950 when
you either cough or sneeze? A..Well, it doubles mé lip.
Q. Where do you reel pain? | A. Well, tt is right-in the
small of iny hack and down ei each side of my legs and my
‘feet. ) ee
Q). Mr, Me Allister, did You ever have any’ diffic “ulty ar:
any pain in. having a bowel movement before October
19th,. 19502 -:A..No, sir.’ -. io? aN
(). What hajipens. now when you have to strain VOUrse lf
during such procedure? . Well, i just can’t strain. There is
pain and | can’t strain. ngs
Q. Do you knew of any work that. you can do ex-
79 Jeept one invoiving hard manual labor? A, Well, no,
; wir, I-never did get too good an education, and well,
that’s just-all [’ve ever done. [ just don’t know. T am
just not mentally equipped /By sections ine ped.to do :
otlier:than manual labor. ;
Mr. McAllister, during the time. that you were employ ed,
at the’ Magnolia Petroleum: Company, what -was your
monthly wages during 1953? 7A, Well, $405.00 at the time
I was laid off, that?s what I was drawing.
_—Q. “Per month? A. Yes, sii
a
7 ée . . “O1
2. That, medns that vou worked a yin on and. a week *
off? A. Yes, sis. - =.
Q. But vou got paid for the: Full noni? A. Yes, sir .
). And you were on-twenty-four hour duty, always on |
call: daring. the time that you were working?. A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, ‘addition to that, of course vou got vour board
ahd room? A. Yes.” We gat*board and—we got sa ac
a month plus room and: board.
Q. Mr. McAllister : When did" you wet married ? A. im.
1948... ° oe. .
| - .Q. During the tine that you woebed for the Mag-
St) nolia, Petroleum Company, did ¥ou ever get on these
drillini | barges witli drilling equipment out in. the
Gulf of: Mexico, did you ever see them? A. Did ] ever se @
the barges? t- ie a cael
Q. Yes. A.’Yes, sir. § - he > .
Q. Could you tell whether or not they had oil and grease
on them? A, Well, ves, sir, they Vv have got oil and grease
on them.
Q. uring the time, rer ae October. A, 1950, when
you took employees: of October the _J8th,*to the drilling
barge, were thev all employees of the Magnolia Petrofeum
Company? A. Yes, sir) every man on the boat was.
-Q. Did you have anybody: nt that jme on Qetober the
: 18th who was onthe boat who Was “noggan employee of the
Magnolia Petroleum Sas es ny? A. Not to my knowledge,
no, SIP, Othe et t er
-Q), Well, ‘You woud oc. wouldn't, von, ‘if there were
others? A. Yes, I know practically everybody that worked
for the Magriolia at that time.
(). At the time on the evening of October the 18th: ‘when
vou took some men off of the drilling barge and bigaeht
them to Engene Island, can you tell. this jury: whether.
not they were all employees ot the Magnolia Po.
81° troleunr Compariy at.that time? A. Yes, SIP, there
were. ; .
Q. And at the time, on the morning of Oc tober the 19th, ‘é
loo, when vou lett: around three o’clock in the morning.
from Kugene Iskind to-Be: acon’ Number Seven to pick up
employees, apd take them w herever you were supposed to
take them, did vou have employs 6s of the Magonlia Pe
troleum C a sci A ? A. Yes,
?
®
52 Pee Oe f
“Q. Was there anyone else? As No, sir’
(). Except Magonlia Petroleum Company employees, on
there that vou took back en that oceasion? (A. No, sir °¢
AQ. Now, where did yout take these employees? oS The
“ones that Wwe picked up Thursday morning?
Q. Yes. A. We took them to our hore port there j in Mot
gan City, Louisiana. — . roe
" QQ. No inore questions, | .
Cross xamination © 0). 2 ¢
Ry Mr. ‘Bolton : } é estes
» ‘
-Q. Mr. Me. \lister, while you worked on that enew
82 fox ( ‘aptain Dressel ‘often vou kept the log, did you
nor?’ A. 1 did, sire | ney
Dg you reirember whether or not you kept the log
on ake. October-tie Sth?) A, Yes, sir, 1 did.
(). Does the log entry that you niade there then cor rectly
reflect what took place at that time? A. Will vou say ‘that:
again ?
Q. Are the entries oni in the log correet, does the log
‘how what actualy happened at the time? -A. Yes, -sir.
(). Will you mark this, please? (Page 64 of the» Log
marked - Defendant's pare 1.) Will you examine De-
fendant’s Mxhibit No. . _ being Page 64 af the hog there,
of what purports to iS the, Log of the J.C. Stephens for
the--well, for a long period of time, but including the
pe viod: of October the 18th and 79th and .20th, of 1950. , r, ee
Allright. (Inspecting the Log.) hee
Q). Is this the Log of the Stephens?, A. Yes, sir.
® .
e
.
Q. And this -writing following Wednesday, October the,
“18th, be winning with the entry at 10:30, is that your writ-
ing? A. Yes, it is. ~
.@. And is this your writing on ‘Friday, October
&3 ihe 20th? A. Yes, sir.
. + Q Do vou know whose writing upper irs in the
Log before W ednesday the ear) A. Yes, I do. :
Q. Whose “writing is that?. A. That. is Mr. George Ros-
son’s writing 2. |. sai a ote
= ‘He is on the other erew, is he not? A, Yes, sir.
. QQ. He is the Captain -of the alternate: crew on “the
"Stephens? A. Yes, sim 9-7 | se
a ; . : ’ \
(). And Suey, ORE Gca his writing? A. Yes, sir.
(). Now, | believe vou testified earlier that vou took the’
- boat out from Morgan City—I will ask you to. examine
the.Log ‘there and scé if if doesn’ t indi¢ate that instead
of that, that you relieve the erew at the quarter boat at
Lot 9? A... Yes, that’s right. :
© Q:. ‘That you leave the crew at the quarter boat? A.
Yes. 2
_ Q. They were on the meek: and you came on board
the Stephens? A, Yes. ;
‘Q. And you boarded it at the — boat, 18 that right ’
A. Yes. *
S84 Q. So you aid not bring the Stephe ns on from
hee Morgan City on Wednesday, is that right? w-Fhat’s
right. ae
Q. Do vou remember how van wot owt? A. No.-
Q. There were other erew Hoats:or tug bents oer other
metheds of transportation that would have taken you =
there, ig that right? A. -Yes, sir
— . Now, then, at the. time, you came on board : the
Stephens and was“standing hr tie Q beat, is that right?
A. Weil, that’s an abbreviation for the quar te ‘yr boat.
(). Allright, now, the quarter hoaf was called Magnolia
Inn, Was it not? ‘A. Yes, sir. .
Q. That was Ab old hull of an old. river steamer, wasn’t
it, that had been converted into quarters and two-seat crew
and it has got-a half -wgy point between Morgan City “and
the Gulff A. It was old paddle boat that had been eon-
verted to a sort of a-roominghouse there at the Magnolia
Inn.
* Q. And you eel that asa way-point, “halfway station
so to speak, between the Gulf, between the rigs and the .
— Gulf and, Morgan City, is that right? A. ‘Yes.
85. +. Q. That was the place where you relieved the crew’
on the week that you went to work i in’ whieh you fell?
A. Yes,-sir. ®
Q. Now, that Q boat was tied adock, was it not? ? Wasn’t
= at the way it was moored ‘ott th®re, to a dock? A, Well,
a littl slip- like and atso tied to the dock |
“@ Allright, and the dock was on the channel side, —the
dock’ that it Was tied to was between. the channel marked’
Bouyed Chéfnel, ‘and the boat, wasn’t it, or else the boat,
e
8
4 . , 4
itmight be said, riding in The elge of the channel! A.W edly
* ae
it was behind the dock. a
Q. It was behind the doc k, In other words, the dock :
was betaveen fhe Channel and the Q beat, the quarter heat?
A. Yes, sir. ;
Q: Now, when the ye phens dovked the ‘re, did it ‘dock’a
the dock, is that where it tied up, to the dock that was in-
the ‘channel! ? A. Yee, we tied along side the doe k or what-
_ever. happe ‘ned to bé there, 3
Q. Yes, sir. A. Another | one of tie boats.
Q). “You might have’ some other boat there and if vou.
did, you would tie alongside that boat and -cross over info
the dock if you wanted to go to the Q boats is that. right?
A. That’s right. > mews omer
86 Q. Now, then, I want vou'to. look her e at vour log
entry on Thursday, Oc ‘tober the 19th. First though, |
tell me where is the last entry whick you made.on Wed-
nesday, October the 18th. -A. W ednesday, October the. 18th
“the last entry of that day was 18:30, arrived at Magnolia
Inn, or ‘at Magnolia quarter boat.- ;
Q: Allright, 18:30 fe us landlubbers Is 6: 30 in the even-
ing, is it not? A. Yes, sir. ea
(). And that was in October? A. Yes, sir.
(). About the middle of October? VA. Yes, sir!
Q. It would be ‘pretty close to, getting. dark about time,
wouldn't it A. Well, no, sir, it ‘$ not dark at that time, not
in October. . | re
Q. Allright, but that’s the last entry on the. Log and that
indicates that that’s the last time the boat was used during -
that day, is that right?) A. Yes, Sir, 9).
Q.-Now, then, the next entry on October the 19th, that’s
also in your handwriting, isn’t it? A. Yes, sir. . :
Q. And what is that.first entry and what time does
/ 87. it show? A‘..0400 departed. Magnolia Inn.
Q. Now, then is that the correct time? I believe
you testified it was around .0200, or maybe you got under
way around 3:30?: A. Yes, sir. :
Q. Now, this would be the correct time, would it not?
A. T ‘his would be the time of departure, yes, sir, = /
. Time of de parttre. “Now, then, when you departed,
did you have anybody on board other than the crew? A.
- No,-sir. | |
~
“HD.
<Q. If would show. in the log if there was. Sefieheds else
on hoard, would ‘tit? A. Yes, sir.
Q! So only the evéw. Wax On hoard w ben ve fi de parted
the Q boat?’ A. Yes, sit ; a
(). Nnd tlien yoir next entry is at 200, is. rt riot oe
OO, ves, sir. os oa ee
ee Read. that entry. ae es * Arrived, sbarge N@, Six “id
sng Seven Beacon.’
. Now; that is a peint whieh vou fiave indicated Mink
Das Ween iiarne “ut Jie recon PhaimtHP’s kixhibit No. 4, with the
X down here, is ‘that right? A Yen. <2). é
; (). And- this other XN northeast of there, ts < the ap:
SS oproxnnate “loc vation (of where the quarter boat was?
A. That would be-the lighthouse, ves, SIF.
Lighthouse, and the quarter’ hoat was neat to. they
erie A. Yes, sir.
(). Now, then, all of that trip, whieh thee Log shows, took :
you @ t hour, was made ina dug channel around shallow.
Water, Wasn7iit?) 24, Welt, it, Is in shallow iri Lwoulditt:
— it was dug. .
2». Well, vou are in a uaa 7 ane? “Ne “Yes,
Yow say you’ don’t know whether othe pie Wits.
aa or not, put it really is a shallow water entry! A.
‘Yes, ittis a bouyed channel. wile , ra
(). Bouved channel, And ii is deeper in the channel
than it is outside the channel? A. V ery little.
- Q. Your entry’ there on the—your next entry there’ is.
‘first let me ask vou this—when von cast off from the Q
boat, from tre dock alongside the () boat, if vou Were docked
immediatels or if vou were not, ts the channel wide enotigh
te make-a biy. wide tur or does the Captain hack, diwey
and. head back down the channel, asstiming: that he was
headed the oPhe ‘yr direction and wanted to go back ” out to
Beacon No.- 7—assuming that he. was ¢ headed—
89 let’s assume he was headed toward Morgan City,
that would: he away from Beacon No: 7, ‘wonldin’t it?
A, Yes. * . | ral gptet it AO
Q. And that he wants to turn aronnd and xo hack to”
Beacon No. 7, how did‘ be. do that? pe Wal that would
he according to Mie Catain, however ev feel is thle satest.
Well, did they ordinarily Irecke ek head out or did
they take the it’ s not a sea hoat ee of hoat, is it? oa
No, sir. ¢ ‘ , :
. .
9° * - 3
e
: ¢
wh om :
It is handled “more like “a tug or oecan-golng -cratt’ ob
than a speed beat? «A. Yes, sir : : eA
we
fg. Te maneuvers if with his engine aud ordin: arity would:
hack aveay into. tht ¢ hannel and then head back out wouldn't
he? AsoWelll if be was headed tipstream, as a’ rule +he
Worth go the nl, : | ) ; ¥G :
oe Miright. A. And then back #way from the—away
Leg his doc ‘kK. = :
Xe “Yes. He owonld miieuver his Ship away Trow his
doce, aud ie ‘ay nake— ON, Male his tir. ee : +
). Make his turn, It cis ‘hot. possible: With a ship the
. size ofthe Stephens to pull out and? turn like -yor 4
-, 90. --do a oles heat, that just Zips arotnd the corner! \
AY Yes, "we had turned that wav. :
Q.You could do that in this chatinel ¥ A. Yes, sir.
re ae \w ean well, bat von don"t auch thik vou did-that
mornins, do Vout ‘That's not the Way vou ordinarily did
st? oA. Well, it’s caceording te which way: we were going
>
tO @o. . ad v4
Q) Well, we -knaw we are going to 29 acs ot to Beacon
No. 7, don’t wees A.’ Yes, sir. @ ; ‘
():. Now; -then, ew do vou make the turn—how do vou
think the tur vould be: made? A: Well,. vou Avoulda’ t hac ie
aff of there, hechus se there is a shell reef pight behind that
dowk there, or just! going out from that- Beacon, there is a*
~hell reef there. ae a: |
~ @). Allright, 2A. He would make bis tarn to wefawayv, in &
eide r for the tidle netto eatel him aiid put itn tn bad shape — &
right there in those reets-you would yy alfion. up the chan-
nel and make his turn anf é ao glown. *, ce
_ Well, puiling on uy is a matter of ,a few, hundred ;
tora tew hnndred vards: Gr so. in orders to. clear and
aes his turn. What. Lam getting at, he Waidatt
"| have had to rumtpee anne bany length of distance? ‘a
~~ No, sir, nota long Ways. 7" ore
(). Now, then, while’ the ship. was lying alongs ide the Q .}
heaf, von al! stavd on board, did you not, vour quarters :
were On hoard ?. A. On honrad ee pris
bee
i), Oh ebosared the ste “phe he. A een gir a4 f
Q. There are foyr bunks in that forward hole? A. Yes. fF
wo Now, then, while you were aboard there rat nigdit.
was there any water cowing in vour quarters. A. Well, I
”
Lo
-
p7
coulde’t say offland. ff if was nating, if would have |
Oo °
Heens ’
Did it fain in veu - re We qingrte rs Qhace® AL Well,
net to say "hat it world. <t rain direeth ri dhe bat it 44
rained against the ees tv ae driph in it. :
Yes, sir. The hous® vou are talking about is” the
wheelhouse, the deck ap there. where the ¢ “Aapti un Starids,
with windows around it?) A. Yes. ;
Q. While we were: waiting here, we haye brought inte
the courtroom ii boat : he Toot boat whieh purparts io be
agship model o Y the KP Bin Ste phehs.- A. Yes..
' yee 3 em ni me appear to vou to be as the
2 Stephens is?) AL Yes, sir. & et
Q. Th logking at it as vou are now, if appears to
esl a true like HESS ‘of thie: Stephens, does it ae 8 { A. WN rea-
egnable enough.
© a ‘i he questi n that, I hiad: asked al ete Wwe stopped
Was, whe ther or aot om the night before vour rut. onl Octo
ber the 1th, vou remembered whether any water had
val ee : RA e lg Benge let Phy NY ketal BE <a? ees *
COTE LELo the crew 8 APUA Pers, A. No, sirt) offhand, H
couldn't say for sure whetherdit had or not,
rer ‘ ‘ ‘ oa
Phe crew's quarters are Jocated dn the: deck "plow
the main weather deck of the shipel ‘orward of the wheel
house, ao r partially forward of. the cies epar tially
© hairk aden the wheelhouse, is. that correct? A; Yossi Vr
=
eg Bist on Sigs level below?) A, Yes, <1r.
(). Now, the windows which yoy stated that vou thought
ae ee have leaked in areund the windows ‘of the
house-—are thesé. for W vard widows here those windows? A,
Yes, she. ey
. SNe first, lot me ‘ask vou whether. the Stephens tied
atonyside of the dock wall take water enough over. the bow
14 get water on those windows 2 A, Nowpwould vou renestt
‘
eer ey please, : ‘ther
19 2° Qo sav, wheir the Stephens is tad" dtongside a
| Bi k as i@ Was From 1s: ‘or TS00 te 0400 on the 19th,
will it take whter over the bow cheugh to get water on
these windows, a spray on these windows, spray froin the
cea, ALT hare never seen if happer, mo, sir
(). You hate never seen it happen. Well, van Woulk tn t
oYdinariiy tie your ship up where that could happen, Hye
eause that “would be pretty © rewih ‘alongside * the ‘dock,
ty
os : ores ne “
| A get reas
* would? A. We H, unless a ship would conie paest, and ere-
safe a Swell that wonk lL breax-against the side of ite |
Q. While the ship is not under way and tied up along-
side the dock, have vou eyer seen waves over the bow ot
the shiyrenangh to get these three windows. you hi ive been
talking about, these three forward lower wimlows. on ‘the
port wide, wet? A. Not tomy knowledge, no, sir. °
Q. You never hive seen that happen white Ahe ship was
: Be up alongside the dock? AL No, sir.
. - Now, then, this whee lhouse, as an eave, so to speak,
a @oynd -the forward. part, govering.-and protecting
the forward windows or ports, dpes M not? A, In what
3 Sense, you mean it is’ protecting them? wok
: Q. Lt overhangs it, it wAild protect it some ftom
4 og rain? A. Yes, sir, i! it was falling straight down.
: Now® then, Gs it vour. testimony that rain ard:
aa will come through the windows 6f this: wheel-
-honse in such amounts as to seep down below and, get the
tintles ard the crew's quarters wet? oA, Not in the galley, |
no, sar. [& wilk drip tlowif onto the bunks, ae $
Treat will drip ontethe bunk? A. Yes. .
From rain alone?) A. Yes. ~
Now, then, to get tlie walley wet, | presume that, ins
8 sonic kind of sea water splashing, breakang up 4xhead,
“breaking. on the windews over encugh period of time to
eet wor through there in quantities, water on the deck,
water i vour ‘statron below i “and then drip down into the
' galley, ts that right? AS Tt will if you are Washing dow
.Q.. Tf veu are washing’ down with a hose on the-dee
ee inside, is that what vou mean?* A. Inside of what?
. Inside the wheelhouse.” A. No, vou don’t use the hose
inside the wheelhouse. ‘3? | haat
: _. QQ. Allright, where nre vou going to be .w: whing
qy down? Tell aheut that. A. Well.gyou wash the
whole boat down, from the weatherdeck “up.
Q. Allright, wifh-a'fresh water hose? A. Yes, |
Q). That is when vou are back in Morgan City? AL Yes,
at ae dock. - -, Bieta 0 ole nes Sr
And that water directed from the hose will get the
bank wet?. A. y es, :
. Will it get the galley wet? A. Yes, sir. © +
Allright, now, then, back’ te our trip en the 19th: We.
fir te the boat ar: und or © ‘Ise [ had.already turned around
a
g.
%
on
arfd he aded toward ‘the Beacon No. 7 lights, and in the
course there, it’s always. the sume, is it not,.it has. to 20
the way the channel course goes, isn’t ‘th at chanve! course
ten, degrees true? Ar T don't remember here what that .°
course is, sir. a oe ee es.
Q..Well, you car ‘look at the chart and see. if that ts
"approximately right? «A. Yes, it would be pretty close,
if : wasn't right. ? .
Allright, vou have on OCC: isiot Is conned the ship around |
it et haven’ tvou? A, Vs, sir.
— Q. Do you remember where the wind was frony
% — that enbiruing ? A. No.. ay Sgt coe
(). Nos, we-are starting out trip, two hours later
now than vou testified earlier bees ise the log shows: 20400
instead of .0200, isn’t that yight? A. (0300; 1 beheve we
said, but the log says .6406. | ?
. Allrieht! so the log entry ix correct?) A, Yes, stp.
Q. You left at 0400 and the log entry says vou arrived
at- Barge No. 6,—I believe You have alre ady testified it...
night have heen Barge Neo, 4? A. Well, I didn’ t reme auibe v
the names nor the number of the barges. .
Q.. Alipight, bat the barge vou did arrive at is a barge
which is mentioned in the Log? "4 That’s riggt.
~Q. And that is Barge No. 67. A..Yes, ein + +
(); And that was at 05002 A, Yes, sir,
(y. Now, the n, | believe you testified thai when vou vot
-there—did vou have, to make any: unus wal number of at-
_ tempts to land, or were you able to come right alongside
and land at the barge?) A. Well,.1 don’t remember having
any difficulty, no, sir. pean 3
. Q: Now,. then, during the landing, .vow. have left
Q7° your engineer's station and come ahead to help
handle the stern Iynes. had you not?’ A.- Yes, sir.
Q. Do-vou renfember what side of the Stephens you
brought alongside of.th. barge? A. No, siz, Dow ouldn’t. ss
tor sure which side that we bias alongside, but. 1 Sit
fees it was the starboard side, 1 my memory serves ms.
right. « , .
(). Your best. recollection ix that it was the’ starboard
sida. ‘Now, then. the starboard side of tlie Ste phens j ix this
sidé over here. It ix the righthand side of the boat if vou
are facing forward? A. Yes, sir.’ ; 5 Cake
fad
i.
60 Soar ame a sea:
Now, then, vow would have observed the landing be-
CAUSE vou weke out there’ In time to make ‘af, weren'|
you? .A. No, safe | don’t make no landing. + :
Q. Well, don't ven help ont on tife lines at the landing?
‘Well, do -vou «lo it after it, is immediately alone.
Side? A. Yes, sil Se : ¢ «
oe Q: You secure the Stephens. to the harge as soon as it.
comes alongside and vou caf, vou do that in-order to keep
"it from bumping up—, A. Yes.
(). And besides von want to take vour passgngers
f ’ 5 yey ‘
“9S sa) bepobee A. Yes, sir:
‘That's true. Now, then, ihere deta: or there
are two beep: landing levels on the barge, alongside of
which vou could have come?’ A. Repeat that, please.
(). Ave ‘there to places on. the barge that vou could
land vour boat?) A. Yes, we could land on ‘@ither side of
oes sip batrie or port or starboard. eee :
.Is there only -ene innding on each side of the barge
or are there two landings on each side? A! Landings?
Q). Or place to-land,. place te get onteon the barge. A,
Well, T eness- ‘you contd erawk over ye how, 1f eh were
aoimind to, but we always landed rights#fonge es of it, but
as far as-iust beine one place to. ad 3 we could | and Trem
the stern of the barge all the wav to where it would rise-
the machinery deck, To helieve they call if, the forward
| Q. Awd the bow? A. Yes, the hok of the boat—it. is
huilt, theehull is something simiar to that boat.
©. And it is vont best recollection that vou don’t know,
but vou think. he had the starboard side’ alongside ? NN
ve Fs sir,
OO And your Ipg enthy shews that fifteen minutes
| fs ¥ vou made vour ke unding that you left and headed
hack to Maggan Citv. Now, that’s true, that’s the way il
phar it?- A. Yes: sir,’ Se ro
‘And Eo beheve vou-etestified that ail vou did, that
vou did not get out from the Steplhe ns.on the narge your:
sel! during that time? A. No, sir. |
Q. Do vou know wheter Ashton iat _A. No, sir.
4), You don’t knew whether he did or net? A. T-don't
know whether he did or not. | ee ae)
(. Now, his station is up focward?) A. Yes, ain
a) Seid
dp
. bd e
ae Handling the line prebi ably ran from this bit or arountt
Pi, fone located somewhere in fuere, is that right? A. Weil,
if we landed .on. the starboard’ side, he would eateh if on
“that: forward quagter cable there. |
Q). Right-in this location? A. Yes, sir, either there where
that winch line up at the front there — aie ae 3
_, Q. This is tue winch line ae A. f can’t see, what-vou
ee ee ee a a
» are pointing at. era
: Q.. There isa ices line on sa nies :pheis: that is
| 4000 further up oy the bow than any of the machinery?
: A. Yes, sir. . ;
q Q. And. he would have caught. his line—the line would
have been permanently aitached to the barge and seeuted
from the barge to the Stephens. You didn’t east your.
line over, or did you?) Where did the line come trom? °A.
: i oe our own lines. : seth
You used your own ne and you cast it No the barge |
ri Oe than the barge casting the line to you? A. Yes.
~Q. And during that operation you stood on the—I be-
lieve you call this-the wellgjeck, and with the rope or ne:
and cast it to the bargehand, is that right: , ALA deckhand
"2 a harge. > | 4 9
And vou inade that secere, didn, tyvon? Wan you up:
se at approximately this place?) A. Yes, sir.
(). Up here where these bits and what’s the other thing
called? +A, And the cable. ,
(). The cable and hits are located, but on ihe at arboard
. side over here, your line was fixed to that. at the time, von
cast it over, is that Pieht? A. As neartas 1 caneremember,
ves, ar
BT SS ae Ee TER, ee Gan IN TSG ee ESL ME RMN Se eR Me Coty) ae Soe eh
a : cs .
~ ;
). Allright. Now, then, that did put vou out ex
10] bake to. whatever weather there was, did n’tait? A.
Y es, SIF. ‘ e .
You were under tliis canopy; the. « canopy 1s there—
that’s the vav the boat appe aTseand the way you kept
it?) A. Yes, : |
Q). The rain would get on von there?) A. Tf it was rain-
ing, ves, sir. ‘ et ;
“Q. Hf it was raining. T will ask you whether or not it
was raining. A. As | say, | don’t wumerahie ihe etast .
weather condition. Ss
Q. Well. new, I will ask you whether or net, vou told
me when T took your deposition about a vear anda half
3 x ;
. ° - 4
. - 3 < .
7 : : “g { *
ee ee ee ee te ee ee a ee ee ee ee
62 -. i ath Pa “4
ago, that on ‘that occasion it Was raining. A. Raining when
we tied up? et.
~Q. Yes. A. Tt could have been raining, yes, sit.
Q), Whatever vou testified to then, is cormect—isthat—
+eht? A. & ‘would SAV so, ves, sire. foes
(). But you Say now you are nat sure; is that right? JA.
a sir, that’s right. ie Mie ; :
3, Milright. Now, then, if the boat had just been-on its
way for an hour on ite wavy-out, and any kind of spray at
all from the wind, if vou were going downwind, and vou
badd any. sind of a bow spray, did you kick up mueli
“102 * with your twin ‘screws — there? ps Downwind.
(). Going down vind, \ ves, the wate r Following you’
as oo Sir, . i ¢ ~ :
W ell, did the spray ever get on this weatherdeck here?
re ios sir, when it ‘seeps, ves, SIT, it does.
Q. Well, does it get on there when you are in the chan-
nel, like you made this rnn this night? A. Yes, sir.
QM. So the deck was Probahly -wet, do you remember
whether if was wet or not? A. T couldn't sayyno,-sir, and ,
be positive. | couldi’t say that it absolutely was wet.
Q. You don’t remeraber whether it was wet or not wet?
A. No. It would be wet if we went down a channel whether
ae as. raining or.not. /
Well, if it had been raiming, it von wet for sure,
te Int it? A. Yes, “sir.
@. Now, then, when vou left the — after vou had cast
vour line off and started Batk into Morgan Citv, and you.
tarted down to your. station on the trip that vou made
Hire and reht there when vou fell, vow went through these
doors, two doors here, did you. net? A. Yes, sir. °
Pe ae Now, there is a high: combing there, is there
not? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Acmatter of two cor three feet that vou have to. siep -
a fae A. About two or two <i a half feet, ves, sir
(). Would. that be about as long as this? (Indicating)
A. Yes, siv, that would be pret tty close to the height. :
Q. | haye in my-hand, speaking’ about—at a point about
ihre ‘ejnches long, 1s thaf the way vou wourd say?) A. Yes.
~ Q. Now, that conbing—it is “i: water- tigint heel asus.
i Te to keep the water ont of the we ‘il-deek from the lonnge,
does it not? A. It’s w ater. tight in what respect?
. ; ) ; fs s * sash 63
Q. Well, will water from the well-deck flow onto the
lounge, the deck, rae lounge on the in oot = Not
from the deck itself 1
——<-Fhelieve you “iit it woe not. W bat Was your an
swer?- Tam sorry. A. The deck itself— on the lee K there
jg-a water-tight bulkhead. 7 ae
(). Now, you came ocak those doors,¢did vou not?
A. Yes, SIT, . .
Now. then, de.von remember whether they
weather, we keep them closed...
(). You just say what vou did do. You don’t have any
indepe mdent recollection of this time? i ‘sir, uot af
ys being opened or closed. « ? | |
Mr. MeAllister, | have removed from the mgdel, the
sae structure, ts that not right? A. Yes, “sir. |
Including the entire wheelhouse, deck and. wheelhouse
ann the wheelhouse super ‘structire?) A, Yes, —
“PE wish vou would look at-this to satisfy voursell that
re things are about ae they enght to be. Can yeu
here and look’? A, eae ca In In-respeet to this—— « °
i A etl ie Me el oe ee | i Sel
‘fact of there being a rubber matting around the middie
lounge? A. Yes, . Si
And with respect to there heing. two d6ors ‘which
opened Wa this Thahner, one door One wing ton lackler which
side openingyito a ladder that goes down into the lounge?
_ Q, Twas going tevask you that next. Now, this
105. bulkhead which is the first end board forward of the
» boat. That bulkhead eéitinued on to meet this
cowling oo dées it net? A. Yes, sir.
QO. -Phere is ne communication between the two spaces
through wee ‘h the ladder is ran2s A. No. * or
~Q. A solid bulkhead. This should have gone clear out
‘to the door here to the cowling there, - Now, in those re-
spects sand particularly with reference to: the location of
the laddertand of the hand-rail and the grab-rail, does
that truly represent that position there within reasonabie
limits? A, Yes, sir, vou can sure tell what it is by looking
‘at it,
ee ee eee ee, Oe mee Te ees eee ee
* F
: wr eee nee free ae Fe ere eS Pe ee ee Sen eS Lee
| : ‘$ 5 ab :
.
}
104-0 were opened o¥ closed?) A. No, sir, well, in rough
xOeS Up inte the wheelhouse, and the.door’on the porch.
see well cnoagh to do that, ride you want to come down. -
QO. With respect to the location of the stairs, and the.”
°
ov
64 So eee aes,
Now; Mr. “MeAllister, where. was this mat that you
wiped your feet on, that you told Mr. Mandell about aS,
you came in? A, We kept a | muat he Tre fight as you come in,
fram this.
Q. The point here ‘that you mentioned the eis justvover
the COMIN as You walk forward from the well deck: A.
Yes, sir. - Lon
Q). Just as vou ste 4) in the lounge? A. Yes, sir.
().. Now, Is that the pdace where vou had aomat on that
. .oeension? A. Yes, they kept one there at all things,
We. And. you wiped your feet on that mat? A. “es,
« str, TL always did. | .
Q. Do you remember doing if on that occasion? A, Yes,
A always did. - : 7
a). I know vou said you alway: . ado, but do vou reme smber
doing it on this time, or do you just say that ‘because you
remember that you always did and meant to always do it?
A. Well, | will say Baya 1 did, because I know I wiped my
feet before I go in the boat ‘at any time on the weather
deck:
(. But you don’t remember this partic ular time inde.
SorRES from other times, that you’ actually wiped your
feet; do vou? Yow mean that you just know you did be me
eause vou always did?) A. Yes, sir.
Q. But vou don’t remember anything that occurred while
you were Wiping your feet this time that made vou remem-
ber this? A. No, not as makingrit any different from any |
other time. :
Q. Now, then, was there any other mat in veur oun
there? A. Yes, sir, there is this back area here on the
“deck of the boat. - There is a rubber-—that is this area,
nhoat here “te here it's a raised rubber matting like yon
-see In barber shops and other plaees. |
QQ. Yes. A. You can roll itt up,.to take it, out and
| clean if, ae : |
1OF Q. Now, the lounge chairs—those are the reclin--
ing aircraft-type lounge ¢ ‘hair? A. Yes, :
And those are called—this area froin aft of the doors
that we talked about, or hatches on the port side AL’
Leading to the galley. ee |
_ Q: Leading to tlie Dalley “clear att te the cowling, is’
Ww omy vot call the Jounge? ” A. Yes, the Passengers lounge.
That's the. passengers lowfige ? A. Yes, SIP,
rae
5
# ” Pao . ‘ : E ° 65
j »
). Now, fie Apac0e—tlie: passengers ‘lounge is entirely
ene a with a cabin? A. Yes, sir.
(). Consisting. of windows ‘and sides? * A, om sir |
Q. Such as- . removed from this model here -a few
moments ago» <A. Yes, sir.
. Now, then: s as You go on, your trip ae non this trip
that you made on that date. the combing betwee ‘en the stair’
landing or the deck forward or the deck aft, aft of the,deor
here -there is a combing thére, is there not?? A, At the
down, ves,
~e. 6=6ClCAT the a And the door, a part of the tide
WS fits into it? A, FB, | SIP. 3
(Recess antil-‘Tuesday, Mareh 8th, 1955
a
RICHARD-A. McALLISTER, the plaintiff, being
ree ‘alle d to the stand, testified as follows: :
Lo
J
Cross Examfnation
By Mr. Bolton:
Q.. Mr. MeAllister, at the time you were on the’ eee
vesterday, t believe we had been rodlowi ing your progress
of the oecasion of October the TStheat about five o'clock,
short}y after five or five-fifteen a.m., after vou lad cast
off the stern line, you testified: you stepped over the comb-
ing and wiped vour feet and walked down the rubber mat
and then’ vou turned slight], to your left to approach thé:
cutrance to the stairs le ading into the gailey? A. That’s
_ fone
That is’at the point ¥ we we re, I he lieve, is that right?
i ‘Yer, sir, | helieve so.
Q. Now, then, [ believe you further testified that in this
partic lar are a the model did. not correctly depict to. the
ship i that this bulkhead was run longitudinally along
the fore and aft of the ship, extends all the way into and.
‘is apart of the door section so fhat there ts no communi.
cation between the space.oeccupied by the ladder cae
Jlownward from the wheelhouse to the lounge deck and.
“the Sphice-oretpided_by_the landing and hy ic Jadder
© ORS ‘leading downward from the lounge into the valley,
e
.
OO ° cee ‘ N a ‘
is, that right® Just: exactly what do you mean by no
communication between them? A. Well, the bulkhead ¢omes
all the way into the door span. ye
That's righi. You ean’t go in between it, vou have
to vo out and around?. A, ae one door and then inte
the nest one. > ate a “ee
A). Allright. Now, then, Mr. McAlliste ry as vou sti Litted
down the Jadder, te ll me exactly as well as vou ccan, just
how von stepped: -Al Well, siry ak PE remember it, this little
approach there or vestibule f cuess vou would’eall if, is a
ianding above, that ladder there. Well, as T just walked.
otc ) es ame ers et ee ;
That is the level of the deck itself—you had stepped
Bed the three inell or four ‘inch combing and had gotten
on the -deek again, the same Jevel as’ the deck won had
ui stepped over, is that correct? ~AL Yes, sur.
And the combing there ista part of the door fitting,
Is ea correct? “A. Yes, sir.
().. And that ‘endide is wide enough, easily wide
239 enough to stand upon, isn’t it? AL Yes) sir.
*(. With both feet?) A. Yes. ;
mS There ix 10 question about, WM? ° “AeJt istas wide as
she ladder, fs | es i ee poe ee :
(. Well, if it is es wide as the lndder—but how «aleep
Ws it Prous. a phe combing forw: ane It is two or three
feet, nav be four feet there,-isn’t it, a liitle landing ?> A,
Be | would say if’ Was two pty a half Feet. :
There was no problem about; vetting both feet firmly
Seca on that landing?) AP No, sir. Pani:
Allright, now, then, from there, what did yvau de?
Do-vou know whether er not von had. both feet down flat
or were you continuing to walk as’ vou started inta the
lndder® did vou hesitaie im ariv wav? T will just ask it,
‘nal war. AL No, sir, as 1] walked through,. i just took:
hold of the handrail and made ma step to the ladder,
New, we will stop just a seeond. At that pointy vou
Were not ‘carrying anything at all, were you? A. No, sir,
Pdtdnact have anvthing in omy hand,
(). — in your hand? . A, No, sir.
ae, (‘Phen was there any emergency or anvthing of
24000 that kind that .was.éausing von to hurry? A, No,
sir, | wasi@t hurrying.
a
ore a ite eyes 67
Q. You were vo! mg back at vour normal rate of move.
ment? A, Yes, ; as coups eee
4 Without havirig an emergeney?, A. Yes...
Allright, nowythen, the ladder itself—and I wil! shew -
vou Ee | would like for the Court Reporter to mark
as an eases ‘This is a pine hoard on which has oe
Jmneunted ¢ 1 step and What aypears to be a “portion . of
step. “Now, then, T will tell von that we will econneet thi
and prove tli: at that approximately twenty-one inch section
of step there is ax step _ ‘h was at. the tine af vour -fall,
the top’step of a ladder leading trot the lounge intos the
galley. Now, does.that lock to you te be that step? A,
Yes, sir, it is similar te it. lit looks like it might be ite —
Q. L notice these, littl splashes of paint there. ‘The
‘ladders’ on the Steps were painted yellow, were they not?
A. ae sir, Netat the time ef mis fall, they were not,
Well, have they been since painted vellow, or de :
vou gins ) A. tL don't know about how. the yellow got there.
They weren't yellow at the time I Was a-merber of the
crew on the beat. ike fe :
24 (),. Now, then, allright. That of course doesn’t
enter. into our problem. Now, then, this ste ‘pis
fade, is it net, of metalewith a black: strip of some kine,
“an abrasive strip between the strips of metal which ee
longitudinally: glong the length of the strip? A. Yes, it
appears to be aluminum.
Q. .The metal dppears to be aluminum with sort of
how would vou deseribe if? Would you say that it is an.”
abrasive substance such as vou might find ‘in aw abrasive
2 erinding wheel, something .of that kind? ‘A. It is a ‘rough
ig ves, sir. Towouldn't say what if is.
(). Albrreht, | will sav further that. the evidence will:
Tei shew that this step was removed trom the Stephens
on pr about—and T think it’s on, the 29th day of November,
[4 Now, that was approximately —it Was a little over. |
four?vears after’ the date af which you say you fell, is that
not right? A. Well. this’ is not all of this step.
Well, this is the tread of the step, is it net? “A, Yes,
sir, There is.a metal - plece that should: he out. forward
of. ae oar. : i;
. Well. this is the entire tread of the step. A. There
Was'a piece like this mounted om the step, yes, sir,
q es
. © 0). Allright, but this isthe tread. “In other’ wor ds,
249 that’s fhe part-that yeur foot is on?, A. No, sir, Ba
necessarily. >
). Well, it-is the part that ties that on mar the ‘ate ‘p, is it.
a andthe only part that lies flat on the step?” A. Yes, sir,
111:FE is mounted on the step. ” | hm:
. Isn't: that datlorl—we. may not be t talking about the
8 ame thing—I don’t believe we are talking about the Sane
‘thing. Lam yot. much of a carpenter, ut. | believe the step
“has a riser nid it has a™Step, in comiton usage, Tlaven't
. you heard tt spoken: of thateway? Now, the part that vou
“are talking about is the portion of the riser or is a portion
of the support for this,is that right?) A. Well, 1 guess you
avould sdy Git it would be the support for this. .°> |
Q.:‘The support for that? A. Yes, sir |
(y Allright, so this is the partion’—thid, ‘the step of
a step is the part on which you put vour foot apd this is
the step of that part of the ladder, is it not, that’s the
“surface that was exposed for use in. going up and down
at-that particular level, the top level! A. 78 and the
ither)part that extends past it.
Q. PT will ask you to look at Plaintiff? s exhibit No.
Pye @ot- it in’my jiand here. It has been tied | in
evidence, antl if this is the step which. was taken,
243° from the Stephe ns Soi which was there on that date:
ith ‘that picttire, it would have been right here,
would? 1?- A. Yeu Say tor We 2.
Q. Now, this picture was taken since November, xe it is
nota picture of this ste ). You were down there last week
_ n this picture was taken?> A. Yés, sit ;
Arid rN “this were removed. in ees why this
W nen ‘t there,\but this picture depicts where this, partic afar
ae of jnetaleame from? A. Yes, sin, |
Vhat’s.ight? A. Yes, sin. :
S Now, do L understand your testimony now, vesterday
and-by de postion to be that vouf foot shipped on the step,
the top step?: A. As Lstepped, ‘ves, sir, my foot went out
sg under me. | \ |
That’s the top ome? -A. Yes.
6. It was fot the deck, but was the step. -It was not”
the deck that Yeu stepped, from that you slipped on, but
“the slip: occurred when vour foot was being: placed ¢ con this
step? A On the step, yes. ;
9
) (). Now, then,--now, that step Is SIX Jnchres wide—
"244 -* that. looks sont SIX diches te you, doesnt it! A,
Yes, sir. . :
And your foot Is loneer than six inelies, ist wz? A..
ahah soe
{). Now, then, wien you go up a step and go up this par-
ticular flight of steps, vou tannot get your entire foot or
‘shoe on that if vou face it completely. forward, can vou, |
mean if you don’t turn vour foot, fs it possible Tor vou to
“et your shoe entirely updn a tread ag wide, even when
vou are facing the | adder coing up? A. Unless vou went
down sideways, no, sif. : - mas
Q. Allright, that’s what J meat unless. vou went down
sideways. But facing it) forward. and putting vour foot
straight thro@eh, veur show will not entirely fit upon the
sy a A. No. | ere !
. Your shoe‘is too ‘s ng, is that correet? A. Yes, sir.
- ° But im going*up that’ step in that’ manner—in. going
ap the step, if vou put your foot clear through, [ve- cot
— now Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 11, that is one of the
Hetures that were tuken dow? there last week Or Sy WHeN .
vou were there at the time? A. Yes, :
Q. TP call your attentionsto the fact. that—inel-
245. dently, are these steps ef the same widtli alt the
wav up, as far as vou know? A. To Nhs kiowledge,
hee STF, | : ;
As far as vou ‘know. they are the same width. from
he bottom step. clear to the top, and this being the fop
step? ‘A. Yes, oo.
_ Q. Now: alter vou uk above the second step, as vou
See ie in that picture, at this point whee my peneil is on
sthe endhoard side of the ladder, there appears to be a verti
cal plate, Is that right?) [t's vertical, Ht goes wo and doWn,
and it is this plate right here that I am talking about, at
“this point vehi here, A. Now, are -you taiking about this
piece right here?
Q.-No, Iam talking about the piece which is-in back of.
the tread. . A. Par tof the wbulkhead, Ves, Sir,
(). Part of the bulkhead > A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that part Is vertical? - A. Yes, sir. ©
(). Straight up and dewn from the deck? “A. Yes, sir,
Q). Now, then, from,that port forward, upward rather.
70
ahs
2 . : . 2 es x
. 2
: 9
, #.
not forward, from that part up t! 1e » ladder, there is a age
likewise a metal plage -of some kind hack’ of ity
246 there? A. Yes; .
Q, This area right here? A. And this area here
as far as we can see an this partic ‘ular picture | A. Yes, 31).
Q. Now, then, that plate is at an angle, is it not! ¥.
The s same angle as the step. + OF
The same angle as the back, of ‘the ste] p? <A. Yes, sil :
Now, then, in going up the ladder and facing for-
eae and not as vou suggest putting your foot at an anele,
‘vou are able to put the toe and hall of. vour foot and that. .
portion of your shoe that’ coyers the toe and’ ball of your
foot on the step, clear’ back up until it hits whatever is in
back of there, this metal .plate, isn’t that right?) A. Well,
now, maybe I am thinking different than you, bat when: vou
turn it facing forward, are vou facing torw: ard of the hoa!
or vou-facing forward of what?
(). | mean to be, facing the eee A. Yes, EST,
facing the ladder.
Q. Now, then, in that positron: anil in making that climb
at that time, you can get vour. foof\ax far through as this
hack, Now, you are looking athe, front edge of the steps
cand. gor wauld be the hack édge of the step? A. Yes..
247 > Q. This would. be the part that would be against
_ the back? A. Yes. -
« ().. And so as ‘you put vour foot on there, you can wel
through a full width of the step until your toe or the
leather around your: tor of your shoe strikes whatever
backing there is? “A. Yes. |
Q. Kither the vertical one or the one that slants back
wards’at the same angle as the ste ep: Aw Yes,
(J. Now, in that position, and going forward on the lad-
der, I mean facing -the ladder, “going. up on the ladder, vou
vet the maximunr amount, the most amount-of your shoe
that vou can‘get in going up the ladder Rithout turning:
your shoe one way dy the other, isn’t that right? A. You -
mean you can put your shoe on the ladder going up?
(). T mean, you prt your shi on the Imlder, but I say
you ¢an put more of your shoe on the lac ler going up—
A: Than what?. | cae |
Q. Than ia any other position. A. Well, no, sir,.I wouldn't:
say you could. , |
”
isn’t that right? "A, Accordingo. the way -the step: issbailt,
Pe, es
Q. Exece yt by turning your shoe? 4. Well, vou could pitt
the same distance if ovon haut: sour shoe in the opposite direc
ie sae as you could in the forward ‘directioa,
248° -(). You mean ‘put vour heel at.the back ol the
wise aach time? A. Yes, sit :
. But vou don’t waik.down steps heel first, do vou, wher
you ra down the: ste ps you reach over With vour toe ane
reach the ste iD ahoack rather than walk down on vour heels,
sa
. LT niean on any step. It ix just the way vow are built.
: Rs s not any h abit or auVvthing, when von ste p dawn, vou
reach out—vour ‘toe is What you are lowering, vou cant
lower your heel any, can you? A. You mean ettended past
the end of your foot, no, sir. |
Q. You can’t lower vour heel anv niore than vour foot,
‘bat von can lower your toe down there’ Just a Tittle int?
‘NN. Lower than.vour heel, ves) sir, :
(). Lower than vour heel, and When Vou et ia! steps,
the eerdinary type of steps, any time--let’s forget cahotit
this timé for a mimite, but vour ordinary wav when vou
“are going down steps is tb regeh down with vaur toe far’
G& ° . ° ° . %
ward anid the first coitact Vou mautke in Lome down is AAP
the forward part of your foot, the hall or toe of vour foot,
isn’t that right? oA. Well, k don now, It looks to me
lke your foot wonld hif, not necessarily to any it
24" vou are going down the steps, why should vour Loe
hit first any more than the rest: of vour foot? .
_Be CAUSE VOUF toe’ is out ine front ef vour heel. Tt is.
faite extended, it will reach out further than your heel,
it will.reagh down further. © You. can. put your toe down,
‘further than vou can put vour heel, cA, We Hif von are
walking down steyis, vou don’ t vo just toue he your toes
eS LER. '
No, [don’t mean to say that. But Lam talk the about
= first part of vour foot that toue ‘hes. the step when you
go down, is vour toe or ‘the ball of vour foot, isn't that
right? A. Wi HN, 1 don’t know that that would be right,
Ho, Sof ae ; ; ,
Q. Allright, well, bark then—we are going to talk about
‘these steps on the Stephens, and we are falking about’ a
man being down in the g: ules aoe starting up. Now, fhen,
~
be
~¥
doesn pit Ais heel lon ie step first the re, certainly,
does he? A, Not i! he is got We as NO, sit.
4). Le puts his pe end, doesn’t he! - Reac les lor it with
hyn toes? A. Yoss = “els
(). And. he takes his balance, takes his weight on, that
foot and he brings it down to balance awd at that point,
however lone his [pot Is and however-far he has got
J50 itin here, he vatehes and. balances: his weight’en that
o° foot, ard then he takes inother a ls forward and
does the-same thin ig with his other foot, loosn‘t hie? A.
trive me thay question again. T don’t think T understand,
von, | don’t understand what vou are taiking about:
Q. Well, T certainly want von to understand. | don't
want to mislead vou, Towant’us to understand each other.
Whit b am-asking you ts, that when-sa man ascends the
‘steps, woes up the steps and-he is facing the wav he is
_
°
Ves, sIr. ; . < 3 F i °
GQ). Allright, he first steps ape—now he doesn’t step up
with his heel, does he? dle stepsiup with his toe? AL On
his particdlar step you. couldn’t put your Heelon it, no,
gong, face afte the andrail fon his’ right hfnd?. A,
ee es go ~
SQ. Allright, yon step up with vour toe, and you put
vour foot through either all the way or-you put it throng oh
enough to get a eripy with vour feet? A. Yes. Ses
(). Or
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.