Transcript of Record — Benz v. Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S. A.
Supreme Court brief1957
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ote
ge O58
Sr ut:
; fs ¥
“ . y
ry
‘
sey
‘a
a hag
ol < x
Wren 2s
ye
Side Pm
aan repeater Silty oe na
_Nos. 14663. 14664 - 14665
ha cont pals
| for the Rite Circuit, .
"WILLIAM BENZ, et al., )
cy ea Coach aes ones Ge a meen
| =... © :
COMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, SA.
. ae 4 3 | Appellee.
M. D. MacRAE, et al.,
_ Appellants,
* . We,
COMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A.,
: _ Appellee.
JEFF MORRISON, et i
1: | "Appellants,
ae ‘VS... p
COMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A.,
| papas:
sie of Record :
Appeals from the United’ States , District Court,
apheseru choke
° ~~
—_—
”
¢s
i Nidtion and Order to ‘Consolidated Qanece |
4 for sels bis aes Pree eee washenees BP,
Notice of ........: OS ae +248, 337, 383
Order. smeared Time to File. Record ~
DM ca eile UN Coa ae we tay te ehw ee an» }3B9, 385. |
Statement of Points ‘on. : ke ti Syatte 4 Es 390
Bond on Appeal, Case No. 6699... ‘ aA \... 249
: Bond on “Appeal, Case No. 6735\.... \. nee AN it 338°
‘Bond on Appeal, Case No. 6745. of ...\. 988
Clerk's ’s Certificate. ............| ay 196, 3A, 387
Final Decree, Case No. 6699. . ius sf shee ses} 246 *
Final ‘Decree, Case No. ala Ne i \ 895
Pym 1 Decree, Casé No. 6745.22... 23.6. ree ;
__ Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, Case i os
No. 6699 ...... ws MES t vee ve RUSE Veen .. 237
Findings of Fact and Conchisions of Law, Case
Oe a ee eee eh dative < kb ees ‘BOR.
—
Eee Findings f Pact and. Conclusions of Law; Case~ y
avevarsre S| nels hides on anne eaRideavlameae a on 369
“Motion to. onsider Original Exhibits... 9 |
Motion to'C nsolidate Causes for Appeal. ..... 3
ee Motion \to Combine Records, Case No.
/ | \U Ooted Adiulting xhibits..... a eli [....,.986
\ | Order Extending ime to File Record on 1 Ap- \
\, peal, Case No. 673 Se LOE ire Beet ae RUF Ce 339 I
Or der Extending Time to File Record'on Ap-
peal, Case No. OTB 6s Be op tet A
Order to Transmit Original Exhibits, Case No. : :
6699 PES Se een Nass sania Goa Jos ese ale a's a. 86
-~Pre- trial Order, Case No. 6699....... \ baie <s 13
Pre-trial Order, Case No. 6735. dn duntd ba hs .aje 299
Pre-trial Deder, | Case No. 6745 sg RE 4 ee
Statement of Points on Which Appellants i =
tend to Rely..... 00... seiseeeeeeese eset 390
; ’
ee
__-- INDEX > te ee
stip pulation Cloniensileia Additional Evidence... 38
“ Stipalation to Consider Original Exhibits. aes 10
- Stipulation. ‘tor Consolidation for’ Trial and see
Pre-trial Exhibits herd hbk bbek oath aa@ess <4 40,
Stipulation for Use of Testimony in Narrative ,- | ‘ |
Form—.......: sae’ nelewee) sake cha ee Seay a4 44
_ Testimony in Narrative Form: cag |W
Anderson, John A.w.... 62.6 (6e...... 94
Benz, William ag LE Ee ee 158 |
’ . Berg, H __ ae ere beedtes keh aba 98
: Carsten, Charles — eo) eee eae 126
Chiesetbaiel: Mkt Ao. 52225204. 3h : 68 .
_ Cowden, Thomas .....:../....... 138,157
‘Hardy, Andrew TR eee a . 178
Johnson, John Sis ee ee ee 07
Johnson, Joseph Be ey ae
| ‘Tohrigon, Joseph ae ...108, 206, 229 ©
_ Kaiser, Frederick W........ a
‘Roiehl, Wane) jee. cen ccece cee 28
© Marvin, Clarence 8.....2......,2.5.2 120"
MacRae, M. D. z.\s “cerns vovescdeees 104
McAuslin, James : Vee yee 180, 192
Mortison, Jeff... 2.20.6... Seas 213
ae
°
.
Transcript of. Proceedings Re Hearing on Ob-
jections to Proposed ar ea of Fact and
* Conclusions of Bae Sic atk asl ckd okies 292
‘Proceedings in USC A. for the Ninth =.
Cireuit . wea ee , 490 © 490)
7 Argument and submission (omitted ‘in
printing) TE ae Ree eT ORE 490
Minute” entry of order directing ‘filing of ote
opinion | and ‘filing: and sn va pete of
| Judgments een 40] 4iK}
Opinion, Marshes, J. 492... 490
Judgments in Nos. 14663, 14664, 14665 501 490
Minute entry of order denying Appel-
ants’ pebition for rehearing : a4 2
Minute entry of order directing filing of |
. opinion on petition for rehearing . © 909 a
Oyfnien denying appellee’s petition gor : me
rehearing re 306 HM
'(‘lerk’s certificate (omitted i in 1 printing) 508
( rder allowing certiorari les hau ee a4
6
‘eee \ page
Testimony i in hexnetive Form—(Continued) : 5-5
ee Pedetsen, Nils Richard........... w+ 108
Pengas, 8. nwsiewisy Jose eveneeteberees Bt
_ Peterson, John ewe PU TERRE PP .
\Giloag, Card. o sa eeis va a
Transcript of. hese and Trial Proceedings. 0252 :
Witness: |
tg) ete, aC ee Pangas, Styliamos | ; a
Oe lS aM eee Shee
\ —cross ere Si Sy Sees ce es ... 279
m3
a a
2: "NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ATTORNEYS |
woop, MATTHIESSEN, wooD & TATUM, |
‘JOHN D. MOSSER, @ -.
1310 Yeon Building,
Portland 4, Oregon ;
GUNTHER F. KRAUSE, . ae
916 Portland Trust Building, , “
Portland 4, Oregon, a
_ For Appellee.
K. C.ATANNER and. --
RICHARD R. CARNEY,
ie 4041 ‘Pacific Bailding, : er we
Portland 4, Oregon, /
_. For Appellants.
?
In the United States Court of Appeals
' \for the Ninth Circuit |
<_ *
| Morfoy, AND.
CAUSES FOR \APPEAL
~ — Ooe now the appellants \in the above-entitled
appeals and moye-the’ Court for an order consoli-
ating the above-entitled appeals for the reason that
, \ y Pear i
iy \ — ° \
\ No. 14663
WILLIAM BE ere ee Li
4 S - 7 \ . » _ Appellants,
‘ ° ee a Ave P VS. dake
ern ERA HIDALGO, 8.A.,:
' Appellee.
_No. 14664
at
M. D. MacRAE, et | al.,
Appellants,
» ” ; Vs. : | .
COMPANIA NAVIBRA HIDALGO, 8.A.,
eee ad Appellee.
| \ . 14665; ai
JEFF MORRISON,. et ee a eee as
. oe RC camaoua
ss Sacdes, ° feces d be |
COMPANIA of VTERA HIDALGO, 8. Ay
: ~L te oe ie Appellee.
DER \ TO CONSOLIDATE
2% causes were tried together \in the Court below, ng
Compania Naviera Hida, S.A ko ge
* 2
4 @ | William Benz, et al., ete. V8.
and their consolidation herein will facilitate the |
preparation of; the Record on ‘Appeal, the Briefs —
. and the Argument of said appeals: /
‘TANNER & CARNEY,
te RICHARD R. CARNEY,
| Attorneys: for: Appellants.
ac.
she a Is Hereby Stipiilated and Agreed by and be-
rect tween the e parties hereto by and through their. re-
si “spective C counsel ‘that the above-entitled appeals may |
be consolidated. fa ’
. [sf RICHARD R. CARNEY. |
| Of ‘Attorneys for Appellants.
[s/f JOHN Dp. MOSSER,
. Of Ze for Appellee,
- Order . |
Bo Ordered: ; pr ds
2 Is/ WILLIAM DENMAN, 32 ‘ ,
* Chief J ele
. [sf WM. HEALY, | Jy. *
: jg) WALTER L, POPE,»
a | — States Circuit J judges.
M.D. MacRAE, et. al
- Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A. - | 7 5
‘In Ni nited States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth. Cireuit
No. 14664
; Appellants,
e -VSs,
COMPANTA NAVIERA HIDALGO. S.A,
) esearch a lo: rg - Appellee.
MOTION TO COMBINE RECORDS ~
Come how: the appellants, and move the Court for ;
~ an order to include, combine and consider as a, part
- of the reeord on appeal in the abo\e-entitled ” cause
ae
_ the following portions of the record on appeal in the. .
-Ngase of William Benz, et al., appellants, vs. Con-
--pania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A,, appellee, No. 14663:
(a), ‘Stipulation for Consolidation of Cases for
Trial. )
(b) The, Pretr ial Exhibits and Stipulation for -.
Bete mon in Nar rative Form. |
) “Transcript of. the Proceedings at the Pre- ‘
» trial : and Trial.
(d) Stipulation Concerning Evidence of Subse-
i Labor ‘Trouble of the SS Riviera. ~ a
~ Xe). ’ Order Receiving Exhibits. .
That the cases of William Benz, et al., laiiiaias
vs. ‘Compania ‘Naviera Hidalgo, S.A., appellee No.*
14663, and Jeff Morrison, et al.,’ appellants, vs.
ot Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S:A., ‘appellee, No.’
14664, and-M. D. MacRae, et al., = Vs.
. %
aie aaa William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
- Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A., ey No.
14665, were tried together in the Court below, and a
single record of testimony and exhibits was de- —
veloped; that this motion is made for the purpose:
of avoiding duplication in the eeenee on appeal in ©
said cases.
TANNER & ‘CARNEY,:
/s/ RICHARD R. CARNEY,
Attorneys for Appellants. ‘
It Is Hereby Stipulated: and “Agreed by and be-
tween the parties hereto through their. respective
counsel that the record on ‘appeal in the above-en-
titled cause may include the aforementioned por- —
tions of the record on appeal in the case of William
- Benz, et al., appellants, vs. Compania Naviera Hi-
a, S. A, appellee. .
Is/ RICHARD R. “CARN: EY, «.
Of Attorneys for Appellants.
os _/s/ JOHN D. MOSSER,
Of venegy for Appellee.
dea —
Serviee of copy acknowledged.
Pb
\
\ %
\
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. \ ..
In the United States Court of Appeal
7 for the Ninth Circuit’ ” \
: : ~ No. 14665
JEFF MORRISON, et al, \
a ery ere aes Appellants |
V8. \
COMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, SA, \ .
Applies. 7 \
|
\ *- MOTTON: TO COMBINE RECORDS -
ee now the appellants, and cohre the Court for
an order to include, combine and consider as a part —
| of the record on appeal-in the aboye-entitled cause
| the. following portions of the record on appeal in
the case of William Benz, et al.,, appellants, vs.
Compania Naviera ee S.A... , appellee, No.
14663: |
(a) ‘Stipulation Soe Conéalidation of Cases for
' Trial.
(b). The Pretrial Exhibits ‘and Stipalation for .
- and Testimony in Narrative Form. .. ° .
(c) . Transcript of the Proceedings at. the Pre-
trial-and Trial. .
: (a) Stipilation Concernjng Evidence of Subse-
quent Labor Trouble of the SS Riviera. - on
(e) Order Receiving Exhibits.
That the cases of William Benz, et al., appellants,
vs. Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S “A. ,vappellee, No.
14663, and Jeff Morrison, et al., appellants, vs. Com-
ro Naviera’ Hidalgo, S.A., —— No. 14664,
\
\
8 William iia et al., etc.,-vs.
and M. D. MacRae, et‘al., appellants, vs. ‘Compania
Naviera Hidalgo, .8.A., apipellee, No. 14665, were
tried together in the Court below, and a single rec-
ord of testimony, and exhibits was developed; that
this motion is made for the purpose ‘of avoiding
duplication in the cords on appeal in said cases.
‘
NNER & CARNEY,
/s/ RICHARD R. CARNEY,
\ Aftomneys for Appellants.
It Is Hereby Stipu ated and Agreed by: and be-
tween the parties hereto through their respective
counsel that the record\on appeal in- the above-en-
titled cause may include the aforementioned .por-
tions of the record on appeal in the case of William |
Benz, et al., appellants, Vv Compania -sigaderpig Hi-
dalgo, 8.A., appellee. : :
ae RICHARD\R. CARNEY,
| Of Attomeys for Appellants.
/s/ JOHN D. MOSSER, |
Of Attorneys for Appellee.
Service of copy acknowledged. ©
[Endorsed]: Filed February 95, 1055.
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S, A. = oe
Sea of Court.of Appeals and Cause. 4
Nos. 14663, 14664 Lind 14665
MOTION TO CONSIDER ORIGINAL
a: ee _ EXHIBITS
“'Come now the inpelidiile and move the Court for
an order relieving them: from printing or reproduc-
ing the following numbered exhibits, and to con-
sider said exhibits in their ‘original form without —
reproduction, for the reason hy said exhibits con-
repair specifica- |
sist of photographs, ship’s articl
tions and other items too bulky to « printed :
Exhibit No. 3—Ship’s Charter.
Exhibit No. 4—-Ship's Atticles.
Exhibit No. 8—Laundry Account Invoice.
Exhibit No. 9—Repair Specifications. ’
Exhibit No. 10—Report of American Bureau of.
Shipping.
- Exhibit No. 11—Packing Slips nd Invoices at
; tactied to Depositions.
Exhibit No. 13—SUP Constitution Booklet.
Exhibits Nos. 24 to 34—Recapitulation of Charter-
ing ‘Transactions,
; ERhibit No. : 52 — - Booklet, Bylaws of —
- Mates & Pilots. |
Exhibit No. 53-—Booklet National Maritin@ Board
Year Book.
Exhibits Nos. 75 to 80—Photorn i. i ngs
r
“en
— a a
10 . William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
Dated February 21, 1955.
. TANNER & CARNEY,
_ /s/ RICHARD R. ‘CARNEY,
ee Attorneys for Appellants,
Service of copy acknowledged. 7
[Endorsed]: Filed d February 25, 1955.
[Title o of Court of t Appeals and Cause, )
Nos. 14663, 14664 nse 14665.
STIPULATION ‘TO CONSIDER ¢ ORIGINAL
ni” hap ee nae EXHIBITS
s. It Is Hereby Stipulated, and Agreed by and be:
weet the parties hereto, through their respective
counsel, that the) Court may grant appellants’ mo-
tion to be relieved fronr printing or reproducing the
exhibits mentioned in said motion, and that the.
Court: may consider said — together with the
printed record herein. |
- Dated February 21, 1955.
/s/ RCHARD. R. CARNEY, —
: Of Counsel for Appellants.
/s/ J OHN D. MOSSER,
rigs Counsel for Appellee.
a
[Endorsed]: Filed Febuary 25, 1955. —
~
No. 14663
Biniten States
~— Court of Appeals —
tor the Pinth Cirenit. . Yi
er
WILLIAM ENZ and ROBE T WILLIAMS, In-
dividually,'and as Representatives of All the
ng of Sailors’ Union of the. Pacific and
Anyone. That Sailors’ Union of the Pacific
Claims to Represent. for the Purpose of Col-
lective Bargaining, Rees
, Pee a Appellants,
vs.
_COMPANTA. NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A,
ees | Appellee.
Ceanseript of Record —
a
Appeal from the United States Distret Court
for the District of Oregon ok
|
be clice
‘ ‘ wad \
° a | . . ‘
> \ ‘ . ‘ .
ee . . °
==—— .
; .
‘Phillips & ‘S Orden.Co., 870 Brandén Street, Sen Francisco, Collf.—4-22-$5
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ‘2B
in‘the United States District Court _
nn fer’ the District. of Oregon
"Civil No. 6699
OOMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, 8.A.,
ie —
a
_ WILLIAM BENZ 5 ok | ROBERT WILLIAMS, In- “s
_ diyidually and as Representatives of All Mem- —
ber of the. Sailors’ Union of the Pacific,
es, : | | - Defendants.
7 PRE-TRIAL ser
This matter eame on’ for pre-trial herein before
‘the undersigned judge of the above-entitled Court
on March 16, 1954, plaintiff appearing through
John D. Mosser ‘and Gunther F. Krause, of its at- .
_torneys, and defendants, William ‘Benz-and Robert
- Williams, individnally, appearing through their at-
torneys, K,C. Tanner and Richard R. Corser upon
consideration of the matters appearing the —
| ings herein.
ry at od ‘Nature of vate : a
This is a suit by the plaintiff to regover
on account of the picketing of its vessel by the de-
- fendants. A preliminary injunction was issued out~ -
- of this Court and an appeal was taken by the de-
fendants to the United States Court of Appeals for
the Ninth Circuit. That. appeal was dismissed. on
/ the ground that the injunction was moot because the
~~ : ~\°
below wholly apart for any claim for an injunction”
*
\ injunctions, as if the same had not beer i issu
; der and. by virtue of the laws. -of the meee ¢ of.
Z
. @ A .
< : z
r ;
~~ J:
/ a
f a
"7% Aye
°
14 | William Benz; et al., etc., vs.
plaintiff? S vessel had: departed. The Court of Ap-
peals stated that. plaintiff’s claim for damages | “is
one which it has the right to prosecute: in the Court
and remanded for fur
monition, | :
“___that wha was determined by ‘the Court /
below in issping s such injunctions is without fur;
ther force or effect, and cannot be relied ‘updn :
- as res adjudicata, as creating an estoppel, or as
the law of the gasé, all to the end that the issues ”
- relating to the ‘glaim of darmages may be tried
by the parties as “free from the effects. of such
99
her) iby ass with the dd-
~~
‘The case is now before this Court on ™ question :
of damages. ' Ls
ee aN ~ . . Agreed ete
; |
The following are admitted by all the eaitien and
no proof ue produced thereupon at the trial:
. j « ri
gaia.
“At dll times herein mentioned plaintiff was and is’
now a corporation duly organized | and existing um-_..
ree .
B |
yon. a:
74
.,
. /™~
et
i
Tee
At all times herein defendatite, Wil- .
liam Benz and Robert” illiams, were and now are
members of The Sailors’ Union of the Pacific, a
voluntary, tmineorporated association having a Sec- _
Setary-Treasurer,- Port: Agents and Ppttoimen. At
4
/
‘ompania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ee 15 |
‘all timés hetein mentioned, the Secretary-Treasurer of
of said Union, its prin pal executive officer, was |
ard is now a resident ‘ofthe State of California. At |
ve times herein mentioned the defendants, Benz and
Williams, were and are now the Port Agent and -
Patrolman, respectively, of said Union in the Port
of Portland, Oregon,.and were citizens and inhabi-
tants of the State of Oregon. Plaintiff is a. citizen -
and inhabitant of -a state or reap different pot.
that of each «. sald defendants,
At all times herein a the Sailors’ Union
ae the Pacific had and now has a membership up-
wards of 5 ,000 men, many of whom are employed
on ocean-going vessels so that it would be imprac-~
ticable and impossible to join all of said. members as —
' defendants inthis suit.“ eet
ge eee Geo
In March, 1952, plaintiff betame the owner of the
‘SS Riviera, an ‘Aimericaybuilt Liberty ship, and at
. -*
-
e
— -
| all times herein mentioned said vessel was regis-
tered at the Port af Monrovia, and sailing under the -
fag, of thie ee of Liberia. - ‘: fe.
cig ae Vi :
Sines March oa degut of. 1952; articles were
_ signed on the SS Riviera for a voyage from Bremen,
Germany, for & period of two years or until thie
earlier return of the vessel to a port on the Conti-
nent of see A true copy of sai )
hibit No. .
. f
—~&
16 ~ Willium Benz, et al., etc., vs.
ticles were signed by citizens of foreign countries.
_ The wage rates specified therein for each crew .
member are equal to or higher than those customar- .
ily paid for similar employment i in the British Mer- _
chant Marine.
.
ides @
e sy
; é °
_ After leaving Bremen, said SS Riviera proceeded «-
to New ‘Orleans, Louisiana, where a cargo of grain
was loaded. Said cargo was carried to and dis-.
charged at a port or ports in India where a cargo of
coal was loaded. Said cargo of coal was carried to-
and unloaded to a port: or ports in Japan. The SS /
Riviera then sailed in ballast to the Port of Port: |
land, Oregon, where it arrived on September 3, 1952,
and docked at Swan Island Dry Dock.
VII.
ae ~The purposes for which the imal’ came to the .
Port of Portland, Oregon, were to complete an
insurance survey, carry out repairs . indicated as
. needed by said survey and voyage repairs, and to
load a cargo of wheat for the carriage of which to
India the said vessel had been chartered by its own-
ers. A true copy « of said charter is Exhibit No..
_ Both the charter for the carriage of. the cargo of
grain from New Orleans and ‘from Portland were
‘caphrtiched fos: under the Aid to India Act. *
) : SIL
On ss Gistecsber.’ 3, 1952, the SS Riviera pore at
‘the Port of Portland, Oregon, ang was docked at the —
Port of Portland Dry Dock at Swan Island. That
ala po
4°
Compania Naviera Hidalgo,S.A. WI -
thereafter and on or about September 9, 1952, twen-
ty-four ‘of the crew mémbers of said ventiel ceased
working on said vessel, went ou strike and refused
to carry out the orders of the miaster; that on said
date the members of the crew demanded their pay
and their transportation to their ports of engage-
ment, and on said date ‘the plaintiff, through the
mastel~of said vessel, told the members of the crew
to either de wey work or they ur ¥ discharged.
From eter, 9, 1952, ail: September 26,
1952, said striking ee of the crew picketed the
vessel. ( On or about September 15, 1952, said strik-
ing members ofthe crew of the SS Riviera desig-
nated the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific as their col- _
lective bargaining pri One of such writ-
ten ———" is Exniiee No..
From the date of said strike up to and incliiling
September 26, 1952, the said striking crewmen of
_ said vessel remained aboard the vessel, continued to
occupy their quarters, refused to continue to work,
aboard said vessel and refused to leave the vessel.
On or about: September 18, 1952, plaintiff filed in r
this Court a possessory libel, bearing Civil No.
~ 6629. On September 25, 1952, said striking crewmen
\ were ordered by order of this Court in said posses-
sory libet ve said vessel and said crewmen, on
September 26, 1952, left-said vessel.
ek caer — William Benz, etal., ett, v8.
- “Baid striking crewmen, immediately upon scsi
the vessel, were arrésted- by officers of the United.
_ States Immigration and Naturalization Service, and |
were held in custody by the Immigration and Natu- -
| — Service until approximately October 24,
1952,.at which time said crewmen were ordered to
_ be deported from the United States. The orders of
deportation did not grant. said crew members per-
mission for voluntary departure. At all times said
Immigration and Naturalization Service was willing
to allow voluntary departure by said crewmen mem-
bers . aboard the SS Riviera if re-employed upon\ J
that vessel ; but said crew members would have re been ~
considered deportees if they had so voluntarily de-
~ parted after the entry of said orders. 3
37% ‘ 5 4% é es
a> 2 i Pages
~ Said striking crew members or others acting for
‘them picketed said. essel from September 26
through October 13, 1952, hen they withdrew their —
picket: line. Immediately r the withdrawal of. .
said picket line and on October 14, 1952, members of
- the Sailors’ Union’ of ‘the Pacific, a voluntary un-
‘ incorporated labor organization, ‘acting ‘pursuant .
to a,resolution duly adopted by said Union, a true
cops} of which is Exhipit No. ...., ‘commenced
picketing said vessel and continued to picket it
until restrained and enjoined from further picket-
ing by this Court on N ovember 26, 1952. All of said -
picketing : at, around or near the Ss. Riviera was at
¢
ofl Compania Naviera H idalgo, S. A.
e
all times conducted in a pi ceful manner~and
“out any violence,
neem XII. e!
Employees of stevedoring and ship repair fi |
and other shore employees ordered to work on the\, ; 7
fused , to--so work while said
said SS Riviera L
pickets representin
Pacific were present, Immediately a
r the re-
‘the Sajlors’ Union of the -
moval of said picket line, employees of, contractors °
_ with’ whom plaintiff had contracted for the repair
and preparation of the vessel t to carry her cargo of
grain to India Tesumed ae on said vessel as re-
V)
rasan’
: XI
On or about October 2, 1952, the said- atviking :
former stew members of the\SS Riviera filed a
‘libel in admiralty, said suit bearing Civil No. 6652.
‘Plaintiff herein filed’ a claim Qf owner and an-
swered said libel. On or about ce) tober: 9, 1952,
_ plaintiff herein filed a libel in admiral y against the
Sailors’ Union of the Pacifi¢, William >—in-
2.
dividually and as port agent of the Sailors’ Union 7
of the Pacific; Robert Williams, individually and as
" ‘patfolman of the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific, said _
suit bearing Civil No. 6661 of this Court. Said
_ libels were consolidated for trial. Libelants in said
Civil No. 6652 and. Respondents in Ciyil No.-6661.
_, both appeared by the same counsel,. Messrs. ‘Tanner
and Carney, at said trial. True: copies of the libel,
answer, findin act and conclusions of law, and :
decree in Ovi No. 6661 are. Exhibits Nos. ....,
chang A A true copy of the opinion of ea
=z
\
20 William Benz,’ ot a., etc., vs.
the Court delivered in said. causes October 22, 1952,
is Exhibit eer
~
~~
Many members of the. hilors’ Union: of the Pa-
cifie are employed - aboard ~Rmerican flag vessels —
earrying grain between ports, including the Port of
d said members and the Union have an economic E
) sat in the United States aii ports in India,
terest in the wages, hours ‘and conditions of em-~
[ployment in said —
A On December 11, 1952, plaintiff paid the decree”
/ of $2,779.60 entered by this Court 1 in Civil ‘No. 6652
on that date.
XVIL.
Defendants would have.continued to icket the $8
| Riviera after November 26, 1952, had they hot been
enjoined from doing. s 80 by. this court.
XVII. fr,
ing the period’ October 14 through November
26, 1952, plaintiff m incurred expenses for °
~. the. operation and maintenance of said vessel in its
idle condition, in the following ae each dacs 7
_ being & per day: Tae, ,
Agency, feesd...,..-..- tc Rete ee $ 15.00 -
- Maintenance of crew members detained ~
- by Immigration ...:.....:..+-++0+- 7.50
=’ Guard at’ship, midnight to 8:00 a.m. .» 16.04 ©
ft ‘ Wharfage—Port of Portland .......... 22.00:
--Wharfage—Albina Engine ..... ; afiees 47.00 :
Compania Naviera Hidalgo,S.A. - 2°
- » Insurance Premiums ........ vaveses, Oo:
. ‘.” ‘Wages, Master and crew ...:........._ 40.00
- . Subsistence, Master and crew..... ere 40.00
_ Miscellaneous. Overhead ...7.......... 528
PR ain sensi evanew beans comers $250.00
AlAs (gous RS
XIX.
“Neither a contract nor collective bargaining agree-
ment ever existed between the plaintiff and William
Benz or Robert Williams of the Sailors’ Union of
the Peektie: : gifts |
Re ».0.@ fi f : w
_ That from September 9, 1952, upon the termina-
tion of employment of - crewmen of the SS --
Riviera, until December ...., 1952, there were ap-
‘proximately twenty-five jobs open for seamen on the
the sa Rivyies,: = bs
Plaintiffs? Contentions of Fact.
The Sailors’ Union of the Pacific has rules and
_ regulations by virtue of which its members act as
an organized body represented by its Secretary-
Treasurer, Port Agents and Patrolmen: Defendants
-<Benz and Williams are: representatives of a class
| eomposed of. all of the members of the Sailors’
Union of the Pacifie. | .
Il. —
“the sieitade of the crew of ¢ the Ss Rivipra who my
- went:on strike on and after September 9, 1952, did
80° o for the. purpose of Soret plaintiff to enter into -
22 4 William Bens al, etc., V8.
new articles with nee for a shorter duration ‘and }
at wage rates and other. conditions more favorable
to them than those contained in the articles then in
effect. bees,
pa pt Aenea
At all.times herein mentioned, plaintiff complied
—“with all the terms and conditions of the said articles -_
opened in March, 1952,-and performed all of its obli- '
gations to. members of. the erew. Be
The. defendants are parties in privity with the ~
. libelants-in that certain. suit) bearing Civil No. 6652
avid. déseribed inore fully in Paragraph XIV vf fi the |
Agreed Facts. | eee tte )
‘ & , anf ; : x : - j
_ The Sailors’. Union of the Pacific ‘acted as the
- collective bargaining agent of said striking former
’ erew members after being so designated by them.
Sitar. Nara VI. | oe.
_. The sole purpose of said picketing by the members °
of the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific was to compel
the plaintiff te re-employ the said discharged, strik-
ing members of the crew ofthe said SS Riviera for
a period shorter than that stated i in the articles, |
anid’ at wage rates and other conditions more favor-
able to them than those stated in said articles.
Ko
- Tiere i is ne labor dispute between plaintiff and
dofdants or the Sailors’ Union of the Pacifie or
v.
_ Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. 7 23
between plaintiff and any ‘members or’ former :
methbers of the crew-of the SS Riviera. .
. oa
r VIEL. are ,
Plaintiff was unable to use its vessel for the period :-
_ from October 14 through Novembef 26, 1952, and _
the sole proximate cause of such Joss of use was ihe
said picketing oF defendants.
Q
| ins. -
As a result of said picketing and acts of defend-
/ ants, plaintiff suffered immeasurable and irrepar-
_abledamage to its reputation for honesty and fair
ing, and its ability to obtain charters for the
SS
further damaged and lost earnings at the rate of,
$800.00 per day. during the period October 14
through November. 26,. 1952; ;.and plaintiff was fur-
ther damaged sna tenet éxpenses at the rate of —
$250.00 per day for the maintenance of said vessel.
and its crew during said period, all_to its total
measurable ‘damage in the amount of $46,200. 00. In
‘addition, thereto, —. threatened to and
would have continued_théir said acts after No-
vember 26, 1952, to plaintiff's continuing damage,
and: in order to mitigate: its said daily recurring
. damages, plaintiff was forced to employ legal coun-
sel and to incur court costs agd other expenses to _
obtain an injunction against further picketing, and’
' thereby suffered special damages ‘in’ the amount -?
7,500. 00.-
iviera has been impaired; and plaintiff was _
Os
4 William Bens, et al, 1. vs.
j | ° a. :
“At all times after the filing of the libel in Civil |
os
No. 6652, plaintiff was ready, willing and able to
- Union of the Pacific
furnish a bond in the amount of $25,000 as fixed by
this Court for release of the SS Riviera, but in-.
terest a re premium. expense on such bond would
have been a needless expense while a picket. line
_ was maintained at said vessel and only have added
_ to the detention damages sustained by plaintiff. To |
nie such fenegee such a bond was not posted.
At all time herein mentioned, the SS Riviers was
engaged in t] le trade.of a tramp- freighter and did -
‘not regularly. carry any particular type or types of
freight or call at any particular port or ports. It
has not called at a ‘ port in the United’ States since -
leaving pow December, 1952.
Defendants’ Contentions of Fact
é
ei | I. hi tae.
The a ea ie William an and Robert Wil-
liams are not the representatives of all of the Sail- _
ors’ Union of the Pacific, but perform in the Port of
Portland only certain limited duties in connection |
with the Saitors’ Union of the Pacific in its Branch
Office in said port. members of the Sailors’ _
not have-such substantially
_ identical interests in thé subject matter of the suitas °
to allow their joinder in\a class suit. : |
i)
_ 'Fhe members of the * of the SS Riviera who
refused. to work after September 9, 1952, did so on
“se @
&
.
‘
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. oo 25 .
acdoant of: the unseaworthiness of the vessel, par-©
ticularly with respect to the sanitatiqn and clean-
liness of the vessel, the food served on the vessel and’ -
the safety conditions and appliances on thé vessel; | e
.- that said erew members considered théir articles
breached and demanded their pay and their trans-
portation to their ports of engagement. The crew
_ members refused: to work and. went on) strike to
“remedy the =e ‘condition of the vessel and
not for ~— Wages’ and articles of shorter dura-
~ tion. | :
It.
| m about October 14,. 1952, until N ili 26,
1952, the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific on divers
- occasions attempted ‘to settle and compromise the
dispute which had arisen between the plaintiff and _
' its former .crew members on the SS Riviera; that -
‘agents of the Sailors’ Union of the Pacifie at-
tempted .to negotiate with representatives of- the
plaintiff in order to determine the persons who
would be employed aboard the SS Riviera and at
_ what wages and under what working conditions said
_ émployment could ,bearranged ; that in so negotiat-’
ing, the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific acted as the
collective baraining agent for the former members
. of the crew of thé’ SS Riviera and-also acted in its
own behalf and for its own interests in protecting
its economic interest in the business and trade in
which the plaintiff was engaged. "
Li tey, erate | |
, The’ ‘plaintiff after the discharge of the former
(26 RY William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
members of the crew of the SS Riviera refused to
émploy members. of the Sailors’ Union of the’ Pa-
cific in the operation of its vessel, and refused to .
operate its vessel under conditions and ess he of
‘employment under which members’ of the Sail a
_~ Union of the Pacific .are employed ort, other vessels ,
: iff the same ¢ trade. ; ; ic ES,
-. The Sailors? Union of the Pacific and its mem- -
bers have an economic interest in the working con-
ditions and- wages of the seamen. employed aboerd
the vessels engaged in said grain, charter trade in
which the plaintiff’s vessel; the SS Riviera, was en-
gaged; that the low wages arid poor working con-
ditions under which the plaintiff operated and -con-
tinued to operate its vessel te#ided to undermine and
destroy the standards set up and maintained by the
Sailors’ Union of the Pacific and other maritime
“unions who have members engaged in said trade;
that as a result of the methods of operation by. the .
plaintiff and by other shipowners operating in a —
_ similar manner,-the plaintiff has been, and still is, .
-able to underbid American shipowners for charters ¢
in said trade, and members of the Sailors’ ‘Union |
* of the Pacific have been, and are now, deprived of
‘employment in said grain charter trade.
AD 3 |
“From September 18, . 1952, to September 25,
1952, the SS Riviera was in the custody of the U. S. -
Marshal pursuant to the possessory’ libel filed by
plaintiff, civil number 6629 of this court. es
\
Compania Naviera Hidalgo,S.A. . 21
(aig eee bial (
From October 2, 1952, the SS Riviera was in the
custody’ of the U. S.’ Marshal and unclaimed and
: unreleased by bond pursuant to the libel. filed for |
wages by the crewmen, Civil No. 6652, and was not ~
released until the decree in said suit as paid 9 on
is December 11, 1952. : ;
WM Tee Type ee £ VIIi. | ,
The idleness of the SS Riviera in he Port’ of
Portland, Oregon, was ‘not proximately’ caused by :
~ any. acts or conduct on the part of the defendants ©
William Benz or. Robert Williams, or on the part
of the Sailors’ ’ Union of the Pacific. /
o
?
. Ue > aeeeeew es |
~The plaintiff was not damaged as the proximate’:
result of the picketing of the SS Riviera.
_. The defendants herein are- not parties in privity
with the libelants in the wage libel, Civil No.. 6652, +
of this Court. —
ee | , ee Lo
~ The »S8 Riviera sailed from Portland, Oregon, on —
- December 23, 1952, with a crew consisting mostly of
_ British and Canadian seamen, none of whom’ was.
“affiliated with the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific. That
* on or about January 10, 1953, when the SS Riviera
reached Honolulu, T. H.., fifteen of said new crew- .
men quit the ship in protest against the ship’s
3 “seummiy drinking water, lousy plumbing facilities,
.
i William Bene, et a. etc., v8,
a) tinual boiler trouble and. general unsanitary’
w king conditions.”” —
laced. before the vessel’s departure. :
When- the vessel reached Bombay on .March. 1,
1953, five members of the crew quit the ship because _
0 _the inadequate food and sanitation, aboard the
"Plaintiff's Contentions of Law
° ~ a ’ | 1 @
®
The Court has jurisdiction of the parties and the
eeriny matter.
| It; 5
This is a true class suit and the members of: the |
7 Sailors’ Union of the Pacific constitute a class and
are represented by. detendants Benz anit. Williams.
. of ITI. Pree
“There is no 5 labor dispute. Anetween plaintiff. and
any of the defendants or the Sailors’ Union of ‘the
at on or about Ja anuary 15, 1953, nine of said
n crewmen returnéd ‘to the ship but. six were
Pacific and there is no labor: ‘dispute between plain-
tiff and any of said members or former members of
the crew of the SS Riviera.
The findings of fact and conclusions of law en-
tered in Civil No..6652 are res adjudicata in’ this
proceeding and: defendants are bound tliereby and
2 9 a fat from relitigating the same and more specifi- eo}
* a
é cae
bie iis: se 7
- Compania Naviera Hidalgo,8.A.. 99 |
cally are estopped from denying’ plaintiff’s Conten-
tentions of Facts II and hamed
LY.
Plaintiff is entitled ta’ a judgment aid decree
are against defendants for its. general damages of $46,-.
200.00 and: its special damages of $7,500.00, and for
its costs and ‘disbursements herein, and to ha¥e ex-
ecution on said judgment ‘and decree. against: °
aa Any funds or property held by or for the -
pinata" use and ‘benefit of members of the Sailors’
Union of the Pacific.
(b): Defendants William Bens and Robert Wil-
liams or any of them.
Defendants’ Contentions of Law
: : ‘ ‘ 8
This Court has no jurisdiction in this suit over
~ the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific or its members’
but only. jurisdiction over William Benz and Robert
Williams i in their individual capacities. . ;
RR a,
.The facts herein do not eenativate the proper’. a
subject matter for a class or representative suit.
2.* . : /
oO aa ara, °° Snare ae !
: _ The damages, if any, sustained by the Pana
. ‘dimum absque injuria because of the existeng¢ of a
‘ labor dispute in at least one of the ‘following par-
ticulars: a at
| Witiam Bens, et al., ete., ve.
(a): That a’ labor dispute existed between the
plaintiff andthe former members of the crew of the -
SS Riviera’ ae the terms and — of
their employment aboard their »essel.
” (b) That a labor: dispute existed siaeces the
jlaintiff and the Suitors’ Union of the Pacific in its:
/capacity as eollegtive bargaining representative for
former members of the crew of the SS Riviera
concerning the terms and conditions of employment .
. aboard said ‘vessel’ and the represe ~“— of the em-
. ployees of the plaintiff. :
(ce) "That a labor dispute existed slain the
plaintiff and the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific con- ~
cerning the working conditions employed by the.
’ plaintiff aboard said vessel in the trade and com-—
merce, in. which said union is engaged. |
(a), That a labor dispute existed: between the
. plaintiff and the ‘Sailors’ Union of the’ Pacific ean-
cerning the employment of members df the: ‘Sailors*
Union of the Pacifie aboard the SS Riviera: |
< fe) That a. labor dispute existed between the \
Sailors’ Union of the Pacific and the m@mbers of
the erew of. the Ss Riviera who did not go on
strike. . %
- This Court is deprived of ‘jurisdiction by reason
of the Norris-LaGuardia Act because of the éxist- -
e _enee of said labor disputes.
Compania N aviera Hidalgo, S.A. 31
| at: Yi vo . Peet y : | ; !
The picketing by the defendants was a lawful -
_exercise of their right of free speech. fee Sars
VI. . ? aes | -
Ry The ‘damages sustained by the. plaintiff as ; the a
. proximate result of the conduet of the defendants is ©
_ too indefinite and uncertain to be allowed. ~.
ate | _VIi. by ry
- The refusal to cross the. picket line by employees.
. of firms who contracted with the plaintiff for the .
loading and * repairing of the SS Riviéra was an in-
dependent, intervening cause of ae 8 damages,
if any, due to the mnie of the vessel, .
i From October 2, 1952, ‘until December 11. 1952,
_ when said vessel was ‘in the custody of the United
States Marshal ‘pursuant to. a libel, the plaintiff
sustained no damages on’ account of the, idleness of
the ered ee : |
‘ TX. e
The Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law en-
_ tered in the wage libel, Civil No. 6652, of this Court,
- afe not res adjudicata in this proceeding and the de-
| fendants herein are e not bound thereby. / __
x
_ Neither William Benz ner Robert\ Williams nor -
o Sailors’ Union of the : Pacific, nor anyone acting
behalf, induced the members of the crew. of ©
tis Riviera to breach their articles of agreement or
contract of employmert with the plaintift and to
<.
“on
a
82.‘ William Bene, et al., etc., vs.
_ strike and to refuse to obey the orders ot the master,
y Of the vessel, ids
-¥ Pe
a ¢
‘The Findings of Fact and Conchusietig of Law |
entered in the libel against the Sailors’ Union of
the Pacific, ‘Civil No. 6661, are res adjudicata in.
this proceeding, and plaintiff is bound thereby, par-
- ticularly with respect to defendants’ Contention of
° Law X.. | :
That the plaintiff cannot split-its cause of action,
-, if any, against the defendants herein, because the | -
injury or wrong, if any,: which is the subject matter
of this suit, was involved’ in a prior proceeding en-
titled Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A., Libelant, v. -
-~ Sailors’ Union of: the Pacific, et al., ‘Hetiondante, ee
being Civil No. 6661 of the files of this Court, upon
'. which judgment was entered prior to the institution
of this suit. .
Issues Relating to J urisdiction of the Parties:
E.
Do the: ‘members. sof the Sailors’ Union of the Pa- |
. -eifie have sufficiently identical interests 1 in the subject
matter of this suit to constitute a class subject to
suit hy ual upon representatives ?
ers | | ; a te
3 Are defendants Benz and Williams, by virtue of |
res, their positions as members and officers of the: Sail-
ors’ Union’of the Pacific and their interests as de-
‘fendants herein, ohttaation: and ie ori persons
|
/
5 said_noion herein “
v 46 riprisedt the histnateniba ot a of the members of
ITI. j
Is a. ae: suit a a proper device to recover damages
for picketing from an unineurporated labor organi-
zation? -
“Jeshes on the Merits - ;
} , «\
a
AG
' Did a labor dispute exist between the plaintiff and
the former members of the crew of the SS Riviera
coneerning the terms and conditions of th employ.
Sania aboard the vessel?
(a) Did the a of the crew. of the SS’
Riviera who went on strike do so for the purpose of
- forcing plaintiff to enter into new articles with
‘. them at wage retes and . other conditions more
favorable tothem than the articles they had signed ?
(b) Did the members - of the crew of the SS
_ Riviera go on strike ‘on ‘account. of the conditions
existing gn the vessel which*they believed made. it —
bc eineadien de
.(e) Did plaintiff comply with all of the terms
| and conditions of said articles and perform all of
its obligations to members of the‘crew of the 88
Riviera ¢ tte ae ony ot
Did a labor. dispute ‘lat’ between the plaintiff
and the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific in its capacity
as collective bargaining agent fot the former mem-
_ bers of the crew of the SS Riviera concerning the,» ’
¢ i P A ile YS
°
a ee » William Benz, et al., etc., v8.
% Ps
‘
tacins ea conditions of. employment aboard |
“Xessel and st representation of said « crew memb
(a) If itis found that the former a sll ;
“broke their articles and deserted their. ‘shipy May.
‘their collective -bargaining—agent ay. ‘vessel
during the term of said articles to inguc owner
* of the vessel to re-employ the formerftrew -members
at wage rates and other conditions more ane,
~ than contained i in the articles? | eS age
MES gw |
. Did a labor dispute exist betw ef the plaintiff and |
the’ Sailors’ Union of the@Pacific concerning the
‘ economic i interest of the Sailors’ Union of the Pa- .
cific and'the working conditions oxieting aboard the
SS Riviera? rae «
Fat VIL. ‘Me nike
Dia a labor dispute exigt between the plaintiff and
- the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific concerning the eni-
ploynient by the plaintiff of members of the Sailors’
Union % the Pacific aboard the SSR Rivieraf —
ms a ee
Did a labor dispute exist. between the Sailors’
- Untion of. the Pacific and the members of the,crew 3
. employed by the plaintiff-on the SS Riviera which
_ crew — did a goonstrike? .\: |
‘Dia the Sailors’ Union of the Pacific pidket the
. 8S Riviera from October 14, 1952, to November 26,
"1952, for the. sole purpose of compelling the Pisin.
' 7a a
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S. A. - -@B-
‘tiff. to se iialay the striking members of the crew
at wages and other conditions more favorable to |
them: than contained in the articles they had signed,
om was said picketing for that purpose andYor in
_ furtherance. of the labor dispute mentioned in para-
~ gaphs V, VI, Vi and VIEL abdvet | ?
\ a —— ba . . 3
- Does! the existence of a labor” ees if any,’
‘render damages, if any,. sustained by the plaintiff
' damnum absque injuria? .
Ne Does the Norris-LaGuardia Act merely limit’ er
the Court’s jurisdiction for the issuance of injunce- |
tions in labor disputes, or does the act define the —
substantive hee of parties in ~ disputes q
enane iSite
Xi.
Was the picketing. _by the Pie ie a lawful
exercise of their right of free speéch\so that the
“damages, if any, sustained “by the eee a
. damnum senses se oe 8.2
.
a
XII. : : er ae
Were the - damages sustained by the plaintiffs if
any,’ a proximate result of the picketing ‘of the -
vessel by the defendants :
(a) “Was the refysal of the employee of con- ¢ x
. tractors.with whom plaintiff had contractéd for re-
pair and loading . of the vessel to cross the picket
‘line an. independent intervening cause of _plain-
9 ’s damages, if any? wr
(b) Were the damages, if any, sustained: by: the
: plaintiff as a aenareeted result of the Pinkesing by
ae
$6. ’ William Benz, et al., ete., vs.
the. defendants ‘too indefinite and uneertain to be
allowed ?
(e) “Was plaintife. deptived: of the uve of the.
vessel by ‘virtue of its being in the custody of the
U. S. Marshal pursuant to a libel*in this Court,
. Civil No. 6652, from October 2, en December : |
11,1952 |. a
(1) Was the vessel i in the custody of the, Marshal a
3 ‘from October 2nd to December 11th, 1952, (pursuant
* to said libel ® a
5
‘
oe
S
~ Xr. th
“What j is the amount of. the deine sustained by
plaintiff - as a proximate result of the’ acts of “de-
fendants, if any? =
hould any sttensind and ‘decree in favor of
plaintiff be entered against the defendants: Beny_
‘and Williams and any funds or property held by.
Sailors’ Union of the Pacific or for the general use ©
and benefit of members’ of the Sailors’ Union of. the
Pacific or any of them; or should it run only against
defendants Benz and Williams or either of them?’
XV.
. Has the plaintiff split ‘its tause of action?
Issues of Evidence “
abs any ae Ni
Are defendants herein bound bythe findings of
_ fact and conclusions of law, entered in - Civil No. |
ra
‘(a) Are defendants. herein ‘aria in —
with libelant 3 in Civil No. e652"
\
\
\
\
\
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A. a oe
at oe XVII. : -
: Ts the. plaintiff ‘hound by the Findings of Fact
and Oonclusions of Law entered in the libel against
the Sailors’ Union of. the Pacific. for damages in
Civil No.-6661 of the files of this court, and estopped
from. pemeeeting ° the questions erin sonidos
g ~]
ede ee Denials
Plaintiff denies defendants’ contentions and de- ,
fendahts deny Plaintiff ’s contentions. nek
3 " Exhibits hi |
’ The parties have ‘entéred into a separate stipula-(_
tion for the trial of Civil Nos. 6699, 6635 and 6645
together, and for the identification and admission
_ of exhibits ‘at said. trial, | ee
The making and entry of this pre-trial code shall :
supersede the pleadings at the trial, and this order |
-. shall not, except by consent of both parties and of
.° the ion be amended unless modified at the trialto. ~~
: prevent mainfest injustice. : °
_ -Dated this 22nd day of March, 1954.
_7s/ GUS J. SOLOMON, »
J “we
Approved:
/s/ JOHN D. MOSSER, \
Of Attorneys for Plaintiff.
- /s/ RICHARD R. CARNEY,
— Of Attorneys for. Defendants.
© adore File March 22, 1954. - J a
«88 ae - William Beng, et al. , etc., Us.
Tr the United States District Court ©
for the District of-Oregon © _
“Civil No. 6699 * =
Bar Me
COMPANIA NAVIERA. HIDALGO, 8.A.,
Ree.
‘S_-Plaintiff,
“a,
™.
ad
WILLIAM BENZ, et al... v rage
ee Saat Defendants.
Civil No. 6735 =~
COMPANIA.NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A; |
| os 7 DS Dlaiintifh 6
pe tae 3 ~ VS. > ae
_ M.D. MaeRAE, et al.,. Pris asi o
, a Defendants.
aa : _. Civil No. 6745
/ COMPANIA NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A,
¢ eo Plaintiff,
ie vs.
JEFF MORRISON, etal,
i * \ + Defendants.
STIPULATION
It is Hereby Stipulated by and between the
parties appearing herein, by and through their re-—
spective attorneys of record, that should the court -
ba
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ~ .. 39
find that evidence relating to the condition of the
SS Riviera and the action of its new crew members
after leaving the Port of Portland while said vessel -
was en route to arid at the Ports of Honolulu, .
Hawaii, and Bombay, India, is relevant. and ma-
terial, then and in that event said defendants may
‘have an opportunity to produce evidence by deposi-
tion or otherwise of said condition of -the vessel,
and said action of its erew members, with respect to ;
the. condition of the vessel: at said. times and places. |
It is. Further: Stipulated that the list of exhibits
and. the exhibits contained in the pre-trial order —
of Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A., Plaintiff, vs.
- William Benz, et al., defendants, Civil No. 6629,
shall also be considered and included as part of the
pre-trial orders of Compania Naviera Hidalgo, |
S.A:, plaintiff, vs. M. D. MacRae, et al., Civil Ne.
6735, and Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A., plain-
tiff, vs... J eff Marxian, et al., defendants, Civil No.
6745.
Dated. at: Portland, Guedon, Mareh 99, 1954.
/s/ JOHN D. MOSSER, ty
Of Attorneys for Plaintiff.
/s/ ‘RICHARD R. CARNEY,
4 ey: Of seat ted for Defendants.
[Endorsed]: Filed March 22, ‘1954.
ai
<< : ret tos " :
| { | | 7 . J.
ry | William Benz, et al., ete, Us. ' =
. [Title of District Court. and Cause. ]
"Nos. “6699, 6735 ad 6745.
“os "STIPULATION
It is Hereby Stipulated. by and between the at-
torneys. for the parties in the above-entitled causes
that said causes may be tried together. :
* It is Purther Stipulated that any. of the testimony
_or other evidence heretofore offered and received in
Civil Nos. 6652, 6661, 6699, 6735 and 6745;~as. re-
corded in thé, transcript of proceedings therein may
be offered at the trial of the ‘above-entitled causes on —
the issues of damages with’ the same effect as if said *
_ witnesses had testified or such evidence had been
offered at such trial, subject only to objections as to
"relevancy and materiality. :
It is- Further Stipulated that the e following Ex-
- hibits have been identified-and may be e offered i in ev}
dence ‘without ' further identification, subject t ob-
- jections as to relevancy and materiality and; in ‘the
. ease’ of exhibits not previously admitted in one of
the causes herein above referred b as to. com-
pean. | i ae
Plaintiff ‘ Exhibits |
oe Peindacitlisk ot Prosecdinas in Civil. No. 6699.
2. Transcript of Proceedings ‘in Civil Nos. 6652:
and 6661. ~ | 7:
. 3.. Ship’s Charter. ‘|
4. Ship’s Articles: (Sub-Exhibit 8, Civil 6652), a
er Exhibit, 2). |
Compania Naviera Hidalgé, 8.4. nt
5. Sheaiinin'’ s Blue Card: “(Peterson), ‘(Sub-Ex-
‘hibit 9 of Pre-Trial Exhibit 2). __ .
6. Seaman’s Blue Card: (Pedersen), (Sub-Exs,
hibit 10 of. Pre-Trial Exhibit 2). ‘
7. Seaman’s Blue Card: (Kaiser), (Sub-Exhibit
11 of Pre-Trial Exhibit 2). dined,
8. Laundry Account, Ship Chandler’s Ssiean
‘ Aarhus, Denmark, ( Sub Exhibit: 12. of Pre-Trial
_ Exhibit 2).
9. «6 Sheets Speeificationa, Job No. 52173% (Sub
Exhibit 13 of Pre-Trial nari 2). 3
10. Report of Ameri Buregu of Shining.
4-17-52, No. 21,623: “(Sub/Exhibit 14 14 of’ Pre-Trial
- rnd ~ Mf
Exhibit2y.- © =~ Ve
lke Deposition of Leslie’ H. Moore and’ 15-a, -b,)
/ (Sub-Exhibit 15 of Pre-Trial Exhibit 2).
“19. Makiki Agreement : (Sub-Exhibit 16 af Pre-
_ Trial Exhibit 2).
‘ 13. SUP Constitution.
14, Affidavit: of WilliameBenz Dated 114-52,
.. with Attached SUP Resolution on —e
> 1B. Libel,,6652..
16. Answer, 6652:
17, a of: Faet and Conclusions of a,
18. ecth 6652.
-19. Libel, 6661" ©
20. Answer, 6661: ie ,
21. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,
A -d, -e, -f, -g, -h, -i, -j and -k: (Packing Slips), . .
ea<:| . William Bens; ota, etc., vs.
. 22, | ‘Decree, 6661. ss:
23. Oral Opinion of October 22, 1952, 6652 and
’ 6661,
“‘Recapitulation of Chartering Transactions”
-in Daily Freight Record nnee of
24. October 14, 1952. Se xh gees
25. October.20, 1952. —— a
26. October 27, 1952. ° yaar |
27. November: 3, 1952. . ’ aS
: * Mavaebet 1952. |
29. November 17, 1952.
30. . November 24, 1952.
31. December 1, 1952.
32. “December 8, 1952.
"$3. December 15, 3952.
34. -December 22, 1952.
eth tes 35. Affidavit of Hans H. W. P. Koster, Dated —
fr = 1145s. | .
36. Affidavit of Frederick Ww. Kaiser, Dated~
> 11-452.
‘37. Affidavit of Ronald ta vies Dated 11-4-52.
_ 38. Affidavit of Fritz Minder, Dated 114-52.
"39: \. Affidavit of Claus H. Diessel, Dated 11-4-52.
' 40. Affidavit of Max A. Klunker, Dated 11-4-52.
41. . Affidavit of Andrew Hogberg, Dated 11-4-52.
_ . 42. “Affidavit of Lawrence R. King, Dated 11-4-52. |
P43. Affidavit of Werner L. Kapels, Dated 11-4-52.
» 44. Affidavit of Paul Check, Dated 11-4-52.
450° Affidavit . of P. Abéysiriwardena, Dated
ee
~
Compania Naviera | Hidalgo, ae.
43
46. Affidavit of Nels R. Pederson, Dated 11-452.
47. Affidavit of Anthony L. Baardman, Dated.
11-4-52..
> ~~
\ . .
48. Affidavit of oe K. * a Dated 11-452,
49. Affidavit of Revinela D. Goldsmith, Dated
—1-452.,
BO. ‘Affidavit of J ohn B. Petersin, Dated 11-452.
51. , Transcript of Proceedings, Civil No. 6735.
52. Booklet. Entitled ‘“‘Bylaws of .West” Coast -
Local No, 90, National Association of Masters, Mates
& Pilots of America, A. F. of L.’ ater 4
| 53. -Booklet Entitled ‘‘The National Maritime :
54:
’ 55.
. 56.
. Board Year Book 1952, alin of Agreements.
Withdrawn.
_ Transcript of Proceedings, Civil No. 6745:.
‘Photograph: (Exhibit 1, y 6745).
Defendant’ S Exhibits’
_ Photograph: (Exhibit 1, Civil 6652
" Photograph: -(Exhibit- 2, Givil 6652
Photograph: (Exhibit 3, Civil 6652 -
Photograph: (Exhibit “4, Civil 6652
Photograph (Exhibit: 5, Civil’ 6652
rs AS
_ Photograph: (Exhibit +6, Civil 65
; Ore 6 “Shangheit” Note to, Master.
a.
*.
~
“4 William Bene, et al; ete,;v8,
83. ‘ Mavinie Guide Article. - |
84.. Newspaper Clipping on, Crew Trouble in
Hawaii. 8 )
85. Affidavit of J eff Morrison.
86. Complaint in Civil -6699.
Batted this 22nd day of Miabeh, 1954.
/s/ JOHN D. MOSSER, * |
& -. .. \ Of Attorneys for Plaintiff. \
~ [s/f RICHARD R. CARNEY,: poe te
(Of Attorneys for Defendants.
* . =
“[endorsed]: Filed March 22, 1954.
[rite of District Court and Cause. :
- Noa! 6699, 6735 and 6745
-
STIPULATION FOR USE OF. TESTIMONY
IN NARRATIVE FORM
It Is Hereby Stipulated and Agreed by and be-
tween the:parties hereto that either party hereto
may; upon appeal to the Court of Appeals, use the
Narrative Statement of Testimony which is at-
tached hereto i in lieu of the transcripts of proceed-
ings which have been marked as pre-trial exhibits 1,
-2, 51'and 55, provided, however, that either party
“may-print in the. Record ‘on Appeal any portion of .
the testimony that has been reduced fo narrative .
oa
| Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ee 45 /
hele: in question ‘and answer form, if such party
_ desires 80 to do at his own expense.
As/ JOHN D. MOSSER,
of Attorneys for Plaintiff.
/s/ RICHARD R. CARNEY, ~ |
/ Of Attorners: tor for Defendant. |
/ \
United States District Court, District of Oregon
' No. Gi. 6699
COMPANIA | NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A.,
Plaintiff,
, Gan
WILLIAM BENZ, and ROBERT ‘WILEIAMS, :
‘- KEte., Et Al,,
Defendants.
_ TESTIMONY IN NARRATIVE FORM
Sie _ JOSEPH JOHNSON |
*, a witness produced on behalf of plaintiff, after be
‘ing duly, sworn, téstified as follows:
I am:a Master Mariner and have been cisuiile Zz
by Compania Naviera healt for about 21% |
Years. I am not now, but. T was formerly, the Master
| of the Riviera. The company that owns the Riviera -
"" incorporated’ in Panama. I do not have a list
\
oie,
Igy me? Py. William Benz, et al., etc., vs. oes ve |
of their stockholders bit I have met the oot =
is, the man that told me he was the/owner df the. |
ship. His name is Mr. Nomenger. H ‘is nota Greek,
/ but so far as I am aware he is: the owner of the
/ ship. I did earlier testify that a cgrporation owned
| oy vessel but so far as I am aware it is owned by
individual. I am not sure that it was a stock
-“¢orporation. When I met one of the owners he told
i me she was the owner, There may be two or three |
'” others for all I know, but I met the owner and he
_said he was the owner. He was. a British subject
~ but he lived in, South Africa. So far as I know no
\. . American citizen owns any. interest in the vessel or
in the company. ——_.. SINGS Ag 3
bas at “Cross-Examination )
By Mr. Tanner:
‘I have worked for. my present employer on one
other ship besides the Riviera. I have been employed,
akout.21% years.. I was employed through the South- ./
ern Steamship Company as agents in London. if
Southern Steamship Company employed me and.
_ this company operates other ships:and employs men
on other'ships. They normally operate | 8 or 9. These
ships are in substantially the same trade as the
iviert.’ They are. not all American built. The —
Riviera was an American-built ship. I couldn’t tell
‘how many of the other 8 or 9 ships: were: built in
“America. I would say about 4. The other ship I -
was employed on was an American-built ship. I
_couldn’t tell whether the owner of. the .Riviera —
- owned these other ships. eed
=> *
Re
| 88 RIVIERA, Her Engines, Tackle and Gear,
ue Cicieadts Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. _ 47
| United a District Court, District of Oregon —
No, Civ. (652 Ne
a "
_H. BERG, Et Al., mt
) » Libelants,
vs. : Was
% aeN
———
oo ae Cay. 6661\,
*
COMPANI IA NAVIERA HIDALGO, S.A., Lat
ROT Rs Ne 2 a li a:
he i ¥8. oz | 5 Bie
/SAILORS' UNION OF THE PACIFIC, Et Al,
na Respondents. |
TESTIMONY IN NARRATIVE ¥ FORM
JOHN PETERSON/
, a witness called-on behalf of libelants, being agiy
sworn, on Direct Examiriation by Mr. Carney, testi-
_. as follows:
’ Tam the chief cook on the, ss Hiviers. I signed
‘on in New Orleans in Apri) of 1952, and served the
“vessel in that capacity until September 9, 1952. The
. Vessel took on very little food» provision in New —
-. Orleans. I didn’t see any American stores on board’
the ship. The next port of call was Bombay. We
stopped over in Gibraltar and Port Said to take on
bunkers and water and things like that. We then
ene bani nie |
\ Respondent: " a
&.
_ board. Most of it was — I ‘called — to .the
aS - Wittiam Bens, eta, etc., te,
(Testimony of John Peterson.). :
went through the canal and stopped at Djibouti and
from there we went to Bombay. The vessel was in
i Bombay four ‘weeks. During that time we took on
food provisions that was mostly meat. , It was very
- bad, meat. It was third class meat, water buffalo.
The first meat, that came aboard came off the dock
and the chief steward said to look out for that® ‘meat
because they probably didn’t want anybody to see, ::
the custonis, there wasn’t any stamps on it at all.
I later prepared the meat for serving. There wasn ss
- any other meat on board the ship and the “chief
"steward. ordered me to use that meat. This was
. while we were lying in Bombay. It was very bad.
I would take 80 ‘pounds, throw 40 ‘pounds overboard
because it was unusable. You couldn’t use it at all. .
When the vessel reached. Portland there was still .
some on board.—At the time the vessel was in Port-
land I was still being ordered sid the chief steward
to use it and serve it. . ex 3
‘The. Court: ‘Do you mean to say ‘that this: was
i decomposed meat and you were ‘ordered to use it a
‘The Witness: ‘es.
‘‘The Court: ‘Di you use it a
‘““The Witness’ I used it, yes.”” :
- “All of the meat got so nailed § you couldn't make |
anything out of it except stew. The only thing you
Cad
could do with it was boil it: While the ship was at
Bombay they took on. 2,000 pounds of frozen meat,
a couple of days ‘pefore we left Bombay=The quality >
of that méat-was the same as thé first that we got on
-
-
al
- Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. 9 .
" (Testimon! of. John Peterson. )
attention of the chief steward: He tnt me to
_ ¢go ahead and\use it. While the ship was in India
ig sa vegetables. ‘I would not call them vege-
tables;) they were rotten. You couldn’t use them.
That was in Bombay. I was able to [1*] use some but
very little. \The chief steward had charge of the —
_ lockers where\the eggs and butter were stored.: I
* could never get a key. Only the chief steward had
a key. He rationed, the eggs and butter. He gave .
‘ me one egg for each of the men, one egg for break-
fast, pne pound of butte for the deck gang crew in
\ \the morning and the eight epastanent he gave them
- a-half a pound of butter and ne more. In the deck:
- department there are 11 men and in the engine de-.
partment there wis 6. That was the usual pro-
cedure that was followed with respect- to butter and
eggs on the vovage.. We had some cereals but. they
were fouled up. They wereilled up with di and
everything, you couldn’t use/ it. There was w, vil ~
in it. I called that to the jattention of the chief —
‘Steward. He just told me fo serve it. Before the .
_ vessel arrived in Portland we went up to the chief
steward and went up ‘and’ told the captain that the
food was’ no good. They wanted to pay off in case
he couldn "t give them better food. this occurred
about four days before we got to Portland. ‘One of
-..the men’ was Kratky. He was the one that later
committed suicide... He was: complaining about , the
» , food. “Everyone eomplained about it.. I never ‘saw
fresh milk aboard the.ship and I have been ‘on the -
at foot of of
pace ont page original Reporter's
Le A
>) ae William Beng, et al., etc., us
( Téstimony of John. Peterson.)
ship since April, 1952." Condensed sweet milk was
served on the ship. Each man- got a can a week.
Then in the morning I got a can to use for/32 men.
To use it I had.to mix it up with water, about. six
or seyen gallons of water and that one can of milk.
The can was about the sizeof a pound, or less. I
would mix that with agjuumber of gallons of water
* about six or’seven gallons. That is what I served to _
the crew for milk. For their cereal in the morning ; :
when they cereal they would put it over the .
dry ereal. When the vessel arrived in Portland
there provisions brought aboard consisting of
some vegetables, that we got the first day we were in
po . then there’ was .a case of eggs and.a case of
fresh fruit, some fruit juice anda few vegetables. ~
_ This is\what is called: port-stores. 'Chey were to be -
used while the ship was in port: The ‘ship was sup-
| ‘posed to be in port until the 12th of September. It
arrived i in Portland September 3. [2]
On Interrogatories Propounded by the Court the
_ Witness Testified: | |
. The officers ate in the salon. They ate the same
food’ except the cereals. The officer's always had
cornflakes and things like that. The crew had oat-
meal and the cornflakes that came aboard out in
India. The meat was taken out of the locker. It 2
was served to the officers, and the crew. The officers:
did not get the same portions of butter and eggs as _
the crew got.. Every morning I divided two pounds ©
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A.- 51
; (Testimorg of John Peterson.) |
of. butter. "Four cans of milk.went to the officers
every morning and in the night time the officers had
another can of sweet eondensed milk and sand-
» wiches and things like that for the night. The crew |
_ did not get any food at night. When the ship ar-
- - yived. in Portland they took on some: port stores.
There was a requisition made for additional stores
- forgoing out to sea. I saw the requisition before it
" went to the ship’s chandler. The chief/steward called
: me up one day ‘and asked what kind of stores we
would need and.I told him. There were many things
“J asked for and he said ‘‘We can’t ask it. We
-won’t get it.’’ There were 300 pounds of beef 02.
dered. For the size of the erew that we were feeding»
on the vessel that. would last about 20 days. The -
ship was getting ready to go to India. The last time
‘we went out from New Orleans it took 42 days. It
would probably take the same for going out there
from Portland. I checked the quantity of vegetables
that were ordered on the list that the chief. steward
prepared. There was very little that he ordered. It
was not enough. It would have been enough for
about 10 days out at sea and we would have been
‘running out. It was only about 10-days’ supply. I
did not see anything on the order such as ham or
‘bacon. Some things like that were served aboard.
< the vessel in India but it was very bad. I com-
plained about it to the chief steward and he said he
just couldn’t get any more, that was all. He was
proud of the list that he’ had made up while in
Portland. We were still obliged while the vessel
a
es
~~ $2 Willian Bens; et al, et, vs.
ae (Testimony of John Peterson. ) |
3 was in Portland to use some of the beef and meat
ES
; and: other products that were picked up in Bombay.
We were still feeding from those supplies while in
Portland and. I was ordered to do it by’ the chief
- steward. I. have served on Liberty ships ‘before as
chief cook and [3] have béen going to sea about six
_-years'as a chief cook. Libelant’s Exhibit-1-is a pho-
‘ tograph which represents one of the .refrigerator
compartments: on the SS Riviera. That is the way:
_ the compartment looked on September 9 at the time
I ceased working on the vessel. The exhibit shows a.
refrigerator fish box. That is where they put the-
meat. There is another room for meat but that is
where we kept it about that time. There was other
meat on the vessel at that time hanging in the other -
room. The meat shown in that photograph is water
buffalo from India. ‘That is the way it was usually
‘stored in the compartment. The photograph was .
‘taken on the 11th but it is a correct representation ~—
a of how the ‘meat looked on the 9th. Exhibit 3.is a
photograph of the oven where we put the bread be-
fore we could bake it. “It would stay for half an-
hour and then the last thing down there on the bot- _
tom line is where we used to put it to bake it. It :
is a. steam oven. There were utensils aboard the
f vessel for working in the galley. They_are shown ‘in |
the photographg They are all rusty. Phe pans were
rusty, too. None of them have been. replaced prior -
to the time ‘I ceased working on the vessel. I re-
quested the chief steward to get some new ones but
we didn’t aie it. The condition of the oven was every
V,
Compania Naviera _—* 53
: (Testimony of John Peterson.)
bad. It was rusty all over. Exhibits 1 pr 3 were —
"received in evidence. nn preparing the food in
gn
the. pans: rust and fo
matter would get in the
- food. There was plenty of rust that came all the —
time in the ‘soup, things I was cooking, bread, every-
thing, stuff like that on the outside. That hap-
pened every time I used it. Exhibit No. 6 is a photo-
* graph of the galley stove and the rest of the things.
that you have to use for cooking. That is the way it
looked on September 9 and it looked that way on
September 11” ‘when the steward department went
_ out on strike. There was rust on the wall overhead é
near the stove and it was fouled up. with grease.
~ The funnel was leaking, running oil and dust and
everything was coming down. This is supposed to
be a-ventilator but it doesn’t work. There was rust
and foreign material on the wall that fell down on
- the food. [4] The condition shown on the photograph
argund the stove was like that since I came aboard.
It had been called to the attention of the. chief -
steward but no arrangements had heen made to re-
pair the conditions. The ventilators, never: worked
ever since I came on the vessel. The meat that was
prepared for the crew was served to the officers but,
-the ‘officers. were served other food in addition.
‘Every-day they got crackers and bread and for their
dinner they ‘could get bread and crackers and cheese
and preserves. Those items were not cerved. to the ©
crew. :
Exhibit 6 was received in evidence. |
~~ ; Wititem Bene al, ont vs.
v
"UTestinnony of J ohn Peterson. ys g
On Cross- Examination - Mr. Krause the Witness’
‘Testified as Follows: : 7
I" am 22 years of age and of Danish nationality.
‘I hold a cook’s license. I received the license from
another chief cook. That is the way .you do it in
‘Denmark. It is a license to serve as chief vook. I
get the license through the Danish and Norwegian
Union.’ T belong to the Danish and Norwegian Chief:
Cooks and Stewards ‘Union. I have gone to sea six
years. I sailed as chief cook on the Nielsen, Hardes,
“Triumph, Hallberg, Riviera, and the. Danish ‘school
ship, the schooling ship we got there. I was not °
chief cook on the training ship, I was learning there,
but was chief cook on the Riviera and the other
‘ ships named. I ate. the foo! that I cooked. There
was nothing: else to eat. Souie of the crew beeame
jll-as the result of eating. the food. They were:
always. complaining that they were sick. The prin- -
cipal thing that a crew does on every voyage is to.
complain, but not the way it was on board this ship.
All of the men became il} as a result of eating the °
food on the, ship. Many of them were able. to per- _
form their duties. The bosun was one that was sick.
‘There was ong day we had some hash on board.the
_. ship and that Was made from the India beef. I know
he got sick in bed. Some of them ‘didn’t have to go .
to bed but they were feeling ill, very ill. The weevil
were. in the packages of oatrieal. The packages
- were sealed when they came aboard qt they were
2
| (Testimony: of John Péterson. ) i
all: lying’ on the shelf in the store room for a time
when. I got aboard. The cocktoaches go through the’
- pac-ages. They would open some of the packages.
You could see them going through. There were plenty
of holes in the packages. [5] The holes, got there
es Companéa Napiera Hidalgo, 8.4 See ee
from the cockroaches; Probably that is the way the ~ |
weevils got there. The packages wert so old lying -
“on the shelf aren I believe... They looked that
way. They too°large a supply of things like
that because /they could buy them. cheaper in Ger-
thany 1 believe. The oatmeal, was regular Quaker
. Oats. The pnly way they ania ve-csened would be
to have some member of the crew open them or.for —
the cockroaches to dig a holé in them. The weevils |
are small things, white and black, some are black
and some.are white. I believe they have legs but I
don’t know how many legs they have. I never.exam- ©
ined them. A: weevil is'a worm and I don’t know
‘that/ worms have legs. I have been on. ships where |
there, are no cockroaches. I have been on ships
‘ where there are cockroaches and they do something
about’ them to get rid ef\them. The. Triumph;and
the Elsa Nielsen are ships I_was on and on which
I never saw a cockroach. The meat that was loaded
in Bombay was water buffalo because the ship’s
chandler told me so. I asked him. And I could see |
the meat: I can tell water buffalo from other cuts
.. of beef and I could see that this beef that we loaded
in India was not real beef at.all. -The beef that we _
- took on at Singapore was Australian beef. I: was
not allowed to use the Singapore beef during the “ |
\ Pas —
\ P epi
¢
56 - . William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
( Testimony of John Peterson.) _
voyage. There was 500 pounds still shiewd when we
_arrived here in Portland. The water buffalo had -
been loaded earligr. It was loaded at Bombay. I did —
not know the kind of articles that I signed ‘on the
ship. . We signed some articles. I know \the only
thing we signed was something about how much
wages we were to réveive and—and what we were
going to do aboard ship. The captain said they: ‘were |
British articles at the time I signed on, -I do not
know what British articles provide with respect to |
the food that is provided in the articles or what the
articles provide as to the food that the crew was to
- receive. On Danish and Norwegian ships they have
to have good food served aboard, plenty of it, and —
there is no rationing of food on board ‘those ships.
On those ships they donot provide how much meat
' ‘the crew is to receive and how many eggs per day
or per week or other things of that sort. I have
sailed as chief cook on those ships.- I did not know
. that the British articles provide for the feeding of
the crew. I- complaint to the Steward that
ed to me that they didn’t have enough eggs
served. to them but they did have one egg a day.
While the ship was in Indian’ ‘waters: the eggs that
were served were so rotten that we couldn't eat
them. They were 80 small that we had to serve
them two. They: were bad. No one’ forced them to
eat ‘the eggs but they could not go around hungry
every day. I did not serve all the men could eat of
mush, boiled meat and things of that sort. We were
‘
Nes
n’t get enough eggs. The [6] men com-.—
Pa i
_ Compania Naviera Hidalgo,S.A. ~ 57
(Testimony of John Peterson.) | |
limited. The chief steward told me to do it. I
couldn 't tell you exactly how much he told me. to
serve. If I had the pots I could tell you the amount.
He told me how, much mush to cook.. There wasn’t »
' much used. I didn’t have mush left over after the
meals ‘were served. All the mush I boiled in the -
morning was used. Very seldom was.there something
left over. When it was, it was used later for food |
in tW@ hash in the morning and things like that.
The only thing they could get as much of as they
wanted was. potatoes. As ‘to the meat I was oly”
allowed to use that much meat for every meal. The
chief steward ‘would see the meat I.took out and he
would say ‘That will be all right.” He was with
me when I went to the locker to get it. We would
take out about 10 or 15 pounds for each meal. There
were about 30, 31 or 32 men. We did not actually
weigh it. When I would take out 80 pounds of meat
I would throw 40 pounds overboard. You could eat
what ‘was left and I served it. We had'to. The |
chief steward would object once in ‘a/while to throw- ~
ing meat overboard that I thought wasn’t fit to use
but I did throw overboard what I thought was unfit.
We came into Portland on September 3 and some
port stores were immediately brought aboard. Three
hundred pounds of*meat did not come aboard at
' that time. That was going to come aboard the day
*“ we were going to leave. No meat came aboard while
| I was there. ‘There were still 500 pounds of Au-
stralian beef. aboard and there was some India beef
7
58 William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
(Heitinieny of J ohn Peterson.) :
aboard, too. We sure heeded some fresh sea to
cook for the créw instead of using that old water
buffalo. They -wouldn’t-allow any beef. to be used
except the water buffalo. We could have discarded ‘
thé water buffalo and used the Australian beef but
we weren’t allowed to do it. The chief steward alt
the [7] not to use the good beef. . ;
On Taterrogatories Propourided by the Court the -
Witness Testified:
—_ great portion of the water buffalo was infected
meat. I would trim jit and throw about half of ‘it »
_ qverboard each time we used any of it. Some of the.
_ meat that I served was infected nels we 6 had to use it.
And I ate bert of it. |
: Recross-Examination Resumed by M r. Krause:
Beef that has been hanging ina refrigerator for a
long period of time always has to be trimmed some ~
before it is served but not that much. And the
longer it has been hanging in the refrigerator the
more it is trimmed. We-trimmed more of this meat
than was ordinarily done and I did it from the first 2
day the beef came aboard in India. I did not join
the strike until the 11th of September. Some of the |
erew went on strike on‘the 9th. We ‘were stil! cook-
ing. I served nothing to the crew ‘that went on
strike after 12 o’clock-on the 9th. We still kept
serving the officers, but we couldn’t do- it the 11th -
because there was no steam so we could not Tight ;
ey
_
- Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. : 59.
\'(restimony of John Peterson.) antigay ©
oe galley. Between the 9th and the 11th my cal
handicapped because there was no steam
\goming up. .The engine crew was on strike. - I
“\eouldn 't do much serving on the 10th and the 11th.
\I joined the strike to better conditions. We were
lalking with our own men in the crew about it. We
did not talk to men from the shore about the strike.
The talk was all amongst ourselves. Later on after
the strike I signed a blue card to the Sailors’ Union © -
of the Pacific. It was five days after the Hth. I _
don’t know who has the card now. Mr. Kaiser, our
spokesman, gave me the card. Up ta that time I
“had not talked to anyone from the shore nor to any-
one from the ship. that was lying aside of us. I did
not? meet any of the members of. the crew: of the
Cotton: State. I was not up at 3 a.m., on September
8. I heard something about it but it was just hear-
say. I know nothing about it personally. Everybody
_was talking about it. Mr. Kaiser did not tell me
_ that he was at that 3 a.m. meeting. It was the chief
_ steward that told me that he got called up in the
morning about that time. That is how I learned
about it. Nobody came to. wake-mhe up. [8]
3 | had to buy the supplies for the ship. for the voy-
age that we were contemplating. I have been making
stores and lists out for Liberty ships.. Under the
Danish law you are supposed to store a ship for
three months. ‘The way we store a ship. with meat .
, and things like that is-to fake on about 1,500 pounds
‘for three months. That is the way we usually store
for vessels with the same numbet of eréw. I did not
~” tables aboard and they were served when we needed
60 ie: . William Bens, et al., etc., iti
(Testimony of John Peterson.) - :
think the Riviera was a Danish ship. I knew she -
was not. What I have been talking about is under
- Danish law. We would use about 500 ‘pounds a
- month. The 1,500 pounds which I have referred to
_ would be all kinds of raw meats, but not cold nieats
and things like that, and it wouldn’t include ham.
“or bacon. We would need: 50 to 60 pounds ‘of. bacon. .
a month and about 100 pounds: of ham. We would
need about 50 or 60 pounds of sausage and ‘cold
meats per month: There was an unlimited supply.
of potatoes and there was plenty of flour but there
were weevils in the flour. The flour was in sacks.
Once in @ while there has been weevils in flour on
ships I have been gn but then we threw the flour out.
' There were Rome vegetables aboard, there was some
' the’ chief steward ordered. We had’ canned vege-
them but we had to almost fall down on our knees
to get them from the chief steward. It was hard to.
get them. But there were still canned | vegetables |
aboard wheri the ship came into ‘port. I would, say
‘that you could find maybe 10 cans “and. maybe more,
maybe a case, but not more than. that of canned.
7 vegetables. We didnot carry fresh bread away with
us from Bombay, We did not have fresh bread
when, we arrived at Bombay. We had been baking
bread ourselves. We took bread aboard in Calcutta
but not-in Bombay. I don’t know how many; about
8 or 10 loaves every day in the morning. We didn’t
have enough to carry us over to Singapore. We ran |
out of it a couple of days before we got there. The
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. 61
(Testimony of John.Peterson. )
fresh bread would eventually begin to mold and
spoil. but you can carry American bread. because it
is in paper packages for about two months and .
nothing will happen to it if you keep it im a cool.
place. That bread is wrapped in eelophane paper.
The bread we got in Calcutta was not wrapped that
way. We did not take on bread in Singapore. From.
Singapore back fo the United States we baked our
own bread. [9] There were some supplies taken on
in the steward’s department at Singapore after the .
meat was taken on. There were potatoes and vegé-
tables and some fruit, too, but very little. The ves-
sel served coffee and we had coffee and tea all
through the voyage. I believe the pans in ‘the kitchen
that got rusted are made of iron. The kitchen staff
was supposed to keep them free from rust: but. ‘w
could not keep anything free of rust that. was foul
with the.rust when we came aboard. We cotild not
keep the rust off because the pots were| not good
pots. There is'a big difference between ae that
you take off the side of a ship before you paint it
and a pot. You can’t paint a pot. You could ‘scrape
the rust off but there would still be some. We’tried
to scrape it off but you couldn’t get it off. After
the crew. quit: work we worked 10 hours up until
the 11th of September. On the 11th there were only ‘
me and the galley boy working when we quit. We
quit about 10 or 11.0’clork, The second cook and the
mess ‘boy had quit before that. They had. gone on
apie: with the ¥ sre. I and the galley boy continnnd
"William Bens, e a, ete, 8
(Testimony of John Peterson.)
on duty until the 11th at about 11 o’clock when we
walked off..The rest of the galley crew began their
strike when the rest of the crew started it. There
were only two of us after the 9th, and after the
“9th the galley was ‘closed. We did not work on the
galley. I swept-out the room in which I was living.
_ [don’t know if the. members of the crew were ex-
- pected .to keep their own quarters clean and swept ~—
out. The mess ‘boys. are the servants that do the
cleaning work on the ship.» “The , galley boy is’ sup-
posed to clean my room. I was not apt (asked?) to_
keep y own room clean. The galley boy has to
make. my bed if I want ‘him 'to.. If I don’t I_do it
_ myself. He never made the bed. for me. He cleaned
_ my room once in a while. The mess boys were sup- hy
~ posed to keep the rooms clean for the-engine room —
and deck crews. We did not have mess boys aboard
the ship..We were short of crew all the time aboard
ship. While I was aboard there was our mess boy
and there was an ordinary seaman working in the
mess. He was working’ both in the crew mess and
-. in the engine ‘room. The ordinary seaman was per- |
..%
forming the duties of mess boy in the engine room -
department and the deck department. The engine
room erew and [10] the deck crew eat in different |
-- Fooms. Ordinarily mess boys are supposed to clean
the rooms for the seamen and for the engine room —
crew and I believe. the ordinary i is supposed to do that
as well. I couldn’t tell you if seamen are supposed
to make their beds and sweep out their own rooms.
- From what I Know the mess boy is supposed to do
_ Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. et 68
that work but I am: not the chief steward on board
‘the ship. The chief steward should take care of that.
Tam only the chief cook working in the galley: Mit is
the galley. boy’s job to keep the galley clean. He
: couldn’t keep it any cleaner because of the rust that.
«was in it. He couldn "get rid of the rust, but other-
wise he kept.it as clean as he could.’ I am complain-
ing about the rust and because there was not enough
equipment for the galley. There should have been
more pots and pans and I have been asking for them
since I came aboard. That was one of the first ques-
tions I asked when I came aboard, but we thought
we could make it anyway. But it makes more work
because’ we have less -pots. When’you make soup
atid potatoes and have to boil your potatoes in the me
same pot, it is hard. We had to make soup and.
potatoes and boil beef in the sdme pot. We would
make the soup first ond then I would. make ‘the stew
and the potatoes or the meat and when the meat
“was stewed I would put in the potatoes or whatever
was left first until we get to make the dessert, that
‘is the pudding and things like that in the same pot.
We had about three pots but still you have to have
- something stewing‘on the stove all the time, but we mt
made out with _ pots that we had.
On Redirect Examination e Mr. fake the Wit- -
I signed articles on the Riviera. When I came
aboard the 16th i talked with the captain’and he .
_ saw my papers, and then. after we left T didn’t sign
ss
6. | CWilliam Benz, et al, whee v0.
( Testimony of J ohn Peterson. >
anything that® day but I. started ani in the
afternoon and on the 23rd after. we had been out six —
days at sea I signed the articles at that time. “After
I signed the articles I had been on the ship 7 days.
The articles were not posted any place on the vessel
nor any place 1 ip the passageways. On our way over
from India to > Portland and while in Singapore we ~
picked up [11], some vegetables and some potatoes.
‘They were ‘not ,ef very ‘good quality and only —
- lasted until about seven days before we reached Port-
-land. There was quite ‘a bit of spoilage among the
food that we picked up in Singapore. Most of the
carrots and things like that went-overboard. The pota- 4
toes that. we picked up’as Singapore were not very ~
_ good. We had some aboard the ship when. we arrived —.
hg in Portland. You can cook thenr but they are not very
good. en you peel the potatoes you have to take
~ about’ half an inch off, atone, yee can. start using
them. ) : :
On Recross-Examination by Mr. Krause the Wit- %
= ness Testified: - PE asa 2 ee
"When I saw the hati I tasked him inde! the. :
ship was going and he told me that we were. going
to India. The ship was loading grain all the time
and L knew where we were goin”. “He didn’t tell me
_ where it was going from India. And he didn’t tell
me how long’ the voyage would | .st. I was willing to
sign for an indefinite voyage. I remember the affi-
, davit which I signed in the state Court case and in
the affidavit. I said the only proysions that were
ue 4
>,
/ | Compania Naviera neues 65
(Testimoriy of John Peterson.) |
- procured in Portland was a small amount of ites
toes and some, fresh bread. I don’t call chicken that
came aboard peat. I can’t say that the 50 pounds of
chicken that came aboard was meat. There was a
case of eggs that came aboard. Maybe/I said in the
state court that there was nothing except tomatoes
and somé fresh fruit. Tomatoes are one kind of —
vegetable but I now say that other vegetables came
° abdard and there was grape fruit. I do not think
grapefruit is a vegetable. I believe there was some
canned milk came aboard bécause there wasn’t any
milk aboard the ship.
On Seismeonetcttin Propounded by the om the
Witness Tesfified : :
| With’ respect to the flour that was on board that
was infested with weevils, we had to take that:
_ througha strainer first but that strainer was not -
fine enough to.take the weevils ‘ut of it so we
started using. it. . ‘Ordinarily the custom witlrrefer-.
ence to flour that is infested with weevils is to. throw
it. overboard: With respect to the cereals that were.
infested with weevils, we let. them lay in water the -
* whole night so all the weevils would come up tothe.
top overnight-and we had to pick them off. There
would still be some left [12] but we were using it. On
~ other ships the practice is to throw it overboard. It
would not be used at all. You find. weevil-infested
flour and cereal. once in a while but never as much
a8 on board this ship. In addition to the water.
66 : William Bens, et hi ete., vs.
(Testiaaing of John Peterson. iy 2
buffalo that we took on at Bombay there was 500
.pounds of Australian beef, but I didn’t yse that
Australian beef during the whole entire trip. There
was no other .meat aboare at that time. After we
left Bombay there was no meat: that. we had picked
up in the United States. We ran out of meat on
' the day when we took on the meat in Bombay. Later
on we took on some Australian beef but we never
used it. Hven after we came into Portland it was
not used. I told the steward that the meat we were
eating was infested but the men were willing to eat
it. The men complained. many times about an insuf-
ficient Amount of butter. We got one pound. in the
morning for the crew of 11 men that w _ were-sitting~
at the sailors’ mess and. half a pound for the six men
- in the engine room mess:’ That was to last for the
; ; whole-day.-I never saw any mafgarine aboard the
ship. With respect to the meat that I said was in-
festedy I would say that it was rotten. You could
~ not use it. I can’t say what was wrong; it was just.
that you had to cut off a piece that was smelling.
There was green in the meat and there was white
stuff on it, just like it was kept too long. On other ,
ships you never see that except where you keep a
piece of meat outside for about a week, something
. like that, and then it would start to get that way.
We hang meat out for maybe two oF three days, but
never a‘‘week. In spite of the spoilage t the chief
' steward prevented me from using the 500 pounds of
| Australian ‘beef which was hanging in the meat
room, J could go in and get it, but I wasn’t allowed -
to. In the ne’ the steward gave. me the iad ;
AL BRIER NEA TI Rte cite attains
| Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A, | «67
(Testimony of John Peterson. )
he gave me a pound of cereal or of oatmeal to cook
"up for them, and i in case of corn flakes he gave me a
tin of milk and I got to mix that up with six or
seven gallons of water.*I know what a gallon is but
J don’t know how many quarts. I can tell you what
- derstand it. We use the litre system. It goes 3. litres -
to the gallon. There were about between 18 and 21
- litres. It would color the milk which was thick and
: sweetened milk. [13]
: On Recross-Examination by Mr. Krause the Wit- 7
: ness Testified : :
~ J gave out to the crew six or seven gallonis of
watered milk and-each man got a pint of condensed
“milk per week. There were 11 men in the deck gang
and that would be 11 pints of milk. They got one
‘tin.gf milk a week-for each man. On top of that one:
tin of milk every day for the galley for use for the
crew. The crew got that tin of milk. I don’t know
what they did with it. They put it in their coffee or
something Tike that. -I didn’t get it. In addition to
what the crew got I got some froin the chief steward
which I ‘had. to thin down. I used .one ean: each
’ morning for the mush for. the entire crew. It made
_. up about six gallons of watery milk that they used
for their mush, the 30 men. The officers did not get
‘the same kind of milk for their mush. You would
have to ask the steward about that; that is none of
my business what the officers got, but I know one
‘ it-was in Danish counting but. you would not un-. ¥ i:
ms ee + ue: oe I \.
68 | Williain Benz, et-al., ete., aa ioe
(Testimony of John Peterson. )
thing—thaYthey had three or four cans of. milk in:
got it in evaporated milk and
_ they got it put ¢ on n the tablethere and they used that
for the cereal, but that never came-from the galley.
. There were about 22 men that used this six or seven -
- ++ gallons of watery milk for their mush; It was thin;
there would not be enough. [14]
watery. milk’ that Tam telling ' you about. It would
be 18 or 21 litres, They had that: each. morning.
_: They had about three-quarters of a litre each morn-
ing on their mush. I had to thin it down or else’.
_” MARK A. ‘CHAMBERLAIN
a witness produced | on behalf of libelants, ‘being
duly sworn, testified on Direct Examination by Mr.
Carney as follows:
@
I am a resident of Gresham, Oregon, and have — E
personally been aboard the. .SS Riviera. The first
_-oeeasion was September 10. T had heard ‘something
- of the conditions on board from men that I knew
who called it to my attention and I went down to.
the ship to see Captain Cowden ‘and a representative
of the company, While I was there I made a tour
ofthe living quarters where the ‘seamen live. I saw
ue the refrigerator space on the ship, I recognize the
te photograph, Exhibit 6, It represents the meat cooler
‘with some quarters of meat there. It looks.as though
z might be the one I viewed on § September 10. I
~ would say it is an accurate representation of what I
Mm
=
| Compania Naviera Hiddlgo, S.A. 6 *
Testimony of Mark A. Chamberlain. ) | ‘
saw on the SS Riviera. With respect to‘the meat in
the refrigerator locker I observed some_of the hind
’ quarters of. g00d beef they said had vome from Au- y
stralia. I think. there were three there and there.”
quarters of other beef hanging back: of those ~
Cieh Ted little or no covering on, It was very bad.
I put my hands ‘on it and it felt slimy. There were .
dark patches on the edges of the meat which to me
: indica ed the. meat was not good for human con-
' sumption.. The general odor was not good but: I
‘would: not say about these particular quarters. of
beef. There’ was a general odor in that refrigerator
compartment. The box was fairly cold. I don’t
_ know what the temperature was but it was colder
than the other. locker through which we had Rar
come, the food locker. I recognize, Exhibit No. 2. .It
_ © looks like some of the rooms of the men ei the
SS Riviera, tenes cabiny. The room in ,the
photograph is typical of the ones I went in there.:
With: respect -to the walls, of the rooms. and their.
- conditions I would say the ‘painting in most: cases °
-- was not too bad. I did not notice the rust. There .
“was rust on the bed. railings. “ The picture shows
the condition of some. of the bunks onsthe ship that
we visited, not all of them. -The mattresses were
. very poor. They were quite bailly soiled’ Some of |
them carried rust on them and some of them had ”
been opened some. t
Exhibits 2 and 6. were received in evidence.
-One of the lavatories-was-stepped up at the time
I was there. The seat was off. There was a verv had |
4 rs
». | pat William Benz, ét al., etc., vs. :
(Testimony of Mark A. Chamberlain.) ¢— |
odor in that particular lavatory. I was in one lava-
tory that was in working condition. With respect
O
to the bathing fucilities and. lavatory facilitjes.of ..
the crew I don’t think they were very goody There ys
was certainly evidence of lack of upkeep all through *
' _» the vessel-the day I was on it, which was on the ©.
10th. A’ good share of the condition could have been |
_ taken care of with some good cleaning by the men -
themselves. There was so much rust that in ‘some, |
cases the.steel and iron metal parts were broken.
away in some cases. Parts of the vessel, I noticed it!.
_J- didn’t notice that, in the quarters. There were
piecés of metal on board the ship “where I noticed
in. particular that had rusted through so much that
. there were holes right through the metal part. Now.
- there was a condition of rust all over the vessel |
which seemed to indicate to me something that was
very bad about the condition of the ship. .
On *Cross-Examination by, Mr. Krause Reverend
Chamberlain festified as follows:
TI Rave been on other ships but-not to go through
the quarters as I did onthis cas¢. I have not made
a voyage on ocean-going vessels. I have been aboard
them here in port. One was ‘a freighter and the
other was a passenger boat which I went aboard be-
fore going aboard the Riviera I do not claim to
have any special knowledge as to what shape a ship
should be kept in. The photograph is typical of some
of the rooms. T.saw two rooms that .were in very 3
. Compania Naviera Hidalgo,8.A. a
(Testimony of Mark A. Chamberlain.)
good order, one of the officer's’ cabins that I was in
when I‘went on later. I went into one-of the rooms’
of one of the men who were not striking. His room '
was clean and in good order. The rooms of the
strikers were disorderly and dirty. The strike @as - -
in existence at the time I went aboard the vessel. I
saw and talked to.the young man“hat was in: the
witness chair just ahead of me. I talked to him on.
board the boat on Repiegber: 10. He said the food ‘
wes all. right and h e-is the same one who testified a
while ago. I was interested ° I went down there _
in finding out what the conditions were. I have had. -
experience in connection with ascertaining the grade
- of condition of meats other than justin household.
- . T was a locker. operator in ’ Gladstone, Oregon, for
three yéars. It was:a cold storage locker and it. had ‘
a frozen locker department. I handled meats in the
refrigerator there. The only training I have had
- in the grading f beef is what I had in experience ix er
_my locker as [ ought and sold meat. I have nev er
been an inspector of meats.
On Initerrogat ries Padunied by the Court the
' Witness T fled: -. . .. .
Except ‘for the Australian beef it looked almost —
like (Wild meat. It was very dark red, parts of ‘it,
and otherwise the edges were quite brown and where
. the sacks were off you could feel the sliminess of the
meat as we would term. the condition of having
72. William Benz, et a. ate:, vs.
( Testtnzony of Mark A. Chamberlain. ».
whiskers. It had little or no covering of fat and it
was meat that could not hang in a locker or in a
cool place too long without: becoming to my way-of ©
thmking bad for human consumption. You would
| have’ to trim a portion:of it away to use it. If you ;
put | meat in a freezing compartment and then put it
“in a locker, there is a breakdown of the cells. I
think that causes it to deteriorate more rapidly. The
locker I was in where I saw the bzw was not in a
locker of freezing temperature. ould,judge the .
temperature to have .been possibly around 45 de-
grees. I would nét be too good at estimating it. I
do not think the ship ’s engines were operating when |
-.I was aboard the ship. Some of the meat I saw-in -
_ the locker was lying on the floor and some was hang-_
ing... I didn’t see the quarters that. were in the’
photograph lying on the floor at that’ time. Some |
.smaller pieces-than quarters were lying on the floor.
Ks I remember the quarters were all hanging. I |
. would not’ be too sure. I felt of the lower grade of
‘meat and it was fot frozen. None I. saw that day
.- *+ Was solidly. frozen. Some people -let beef in order. |
. to.get. the choicest steaks hang until it gets what we
¢all, whiskers and then trim off the outside parts. i
Then the inside is ordinarily edible even thoupirthe
outside had Whiskers. Ifis the outer portions- that
_are exposed to thie air that deteriorates first. If it .
-hangsong enough a beef will turn black just from
the: exhaustion of thé moisture in the end pieces.
Meat -will turn' black if it hangs long enough just
from the fact.of ‘the moisture being drawn out of: it. :
Sore of this meat looked black and T said, it was not
.
Combine Naviera Hidalgo, S. A, —_—.
( Testimony: of Mark A. Chamberlain. )
—._fit -for_human_ ion because that is not- the :
type pf meat that I wo Id ever want to sell myself
- in thé business. I didn’t like that kind of meat for
human consumptien It was not good for human .
consumption, as I saw it, as it appeared to me.
Theré was other beef that I saw there that was all
_ right.! I didn’t examine it too suas .
~-On'R edirect Examination by \ N Carney. the Wit-
ness Testified : . 4 3
pa
~ Some of the heat that I tonichaa I Weseribed as
being |soft and discoloréd, and as having an odor. I
would) say it was. spoiled. - If you have a large
measure of meat sometimes you can save a part of it |
on the inside, but you have to‘ trim away all that
outside and it certainly is not the kind of meat that —
would: be put on the market it seems to me for hu-
_ consumption.
On Recross-Examination by Mr. Krause the Wit-—
-ness Testified: |
. I did not smell the meat itself but earl in the
refrigerator was not good. The quarters that I saw -
- did not smell a bad odor as. though it was all de-
cayed, or‘anything of that sort... *
a ait .
14 i William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
FREDERICK W. KAISER
a witness produéed on behalf: of libelants,- Males -
been duly sworn, on Direct Examination by Mr..
Carney testified as follows: :
}
I am a seaman in the engine room service of the
SS. Riviera and have been going to sea since 1937.
I have sailed on a number of vessels which belonged -
to: the Krupp-Company. One of these vessels was
~ the Rotterdam Zion, After the war I have been on
Panamanian ships belonging to the Socony-Vacuum
Oil Company in New York. I am 32 years. @d. I
served. on the SS Riviera as an oiler and was en-
gaged in Bremen, Germany, March 19, 1952, and
have been ‘in-the service of the ship from that time
up until it reached Portland in September. I was
the ship’ s delegate. That is not an official position.
. I speak for the crew. The master ef the vessel
speaks English but? he does not. speak German.
There are about 16.or 17 of the erew who speak
German and only speak a few words of English.
- There is one member of the crew who speaks Dan-
ish. He understands a few words of English but not
much. He is the bosun, Peterson. I speak both
English and ‘German. I was elected by the crew.
after aon vessel left New ‘Orleans. I would often
the Fea with respect. ra the food that was being |
served on the vessel prior to the time it reached
Portland. I went to the captain on behalf. of th”
Compania N aviera H idalgo, 8.4 A.. .
- (Testimony of Frederick W. Kalged)
crew with respect. to food and living, conditions on
the vessel at sea and at Portland. Tt “was about the
' first of September. Kratky came tome and said, ‘I
feel so sick. I can’t stand it.’’: He wanted to sign
Off the articles and said that if he stayed er he
would ‘die aboard ‘the ship.
about the food-a few times. 1 cant remember -all :.
‘~ I went to the chief steward. and ime to ras
the days. A few times after leaving Bremen I spoke
_. about the food rations that we haven’t jany meal or
any butter or any sausage for the night watch in
the nighttime. I have been asking the chief steward —
for more bread, more butter and saugage“for the -
| nighttime and he refused to find anything. With
respect’ to the meat that was: being served aboard
the vesselI told the steward sometimes it. is not’ .
good, tet the meat was stinking. I s] ow him-that —
sometimes and in the galley he said ‘We don’t have
. another.” I told the cook. I made .a ¢omplaint to
the chief steward in respect to™%tereals that were —
being served.. I told that mostly to th chief cook.
i told him that we couid not use the meat and he
said ‘IT don’t have another. You have to eat it.”” I
have made complaints to the Yecter with respect to
living conditions on the, vessel, the fixtures and .
rooms and other slates “Side the crew lives but I
don’t remember the dates. I was speaking with the —
master about many things, about living conditions |
and about money. We had an appointment with the. .
consulate general in Bombay because tl}e master was
‘refusing to pay people -in Bombay. I|spoke to the:
‘
é
76. Willia Benz, et al., etc., vs.
(Testimony of F | sige W Kaiser.)
master concerning the lifeboats and their condition
on board the ship betors the vessel came into Port-
land. He did not promise to do anything with re-
_ spect to repairing ‘the ‘lifeboats. We told the cap-
tain that. the lifeboats must be overhauled - ‘but she
said that w guld be done later on. I know what was —
wrong with the lifeboats. I do not recall what.
a particular, I told the captain was wrong with .
' the boats. I told the captain. that and the cap-
_ tain‘said ‘That is, not your business. You stay in
the engine room. You don’t ‘iow anything about
that,?’ On September 9 T had ‘been sick. I got in an
accjdent . on September 6 and on September 9 I ‘was
lying in my bed in my room.: I eould not go mpstairs
to tell the captain some|of the things that had hap-.
pened about the strike buit since September 12 I was
back and was doing my ‘job as spokesman for the |
crew. I sent a note to we master on September 9 —
with respect to quitting. I signed: the list that all
the crew went on strike. I couldn’t bring it up. ‘to i.
him. Two other’ guys oent upstairs. I-couldn’t. I
‘lay én my- back. The reason that I and other mem-
bers of the crew quit work on that watch was only
__ living conditions and the food. We refused to work .
under the same living conditions and under the same
conditions of the food. With respect to the living
quarters we did not have a mess boy to clean up the
mess room and some of this must be done by our-
_ Selves, the rooms and halls, and we asked the chief
engineer for a wiper. We wanted a wiper ‘aboard
the ship to make it clean. The mattresses and the
sheets had not been cleaned. The blankets have not
| P
Compania remedy A
: (Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser.).
been good. The blankets had been aia beahine by all:
you ha¥e been sleeping i in your bed.it ig wet. There
was nothing done about the mattresses. ‘They. were
very terrible. You could come in and keep the room
clean, but-the mattresses you could not clean. The
pipes in the toilet had been rusty and were leaking; |
. in the crew’s mess in the engine department’s. mess -
there . ‘was an ice box that you couldn *’t use. The
‘chief engineer refused, to: repair the ice box. ‘We
couldn’t keep our butter in the ice box and we had
' to brush it on our bread, you couldn’t. use a { knife.
Exhibit No. 4 is a photograph of the. toilet and
shower room for the deck department. That is the
way it looked. at about the time’ the crew went on.
strike. With reference to the radiator, it was rusty.
There was no paint aboard the ship to fix it up.
- Exhibit 4 received in evidence. Exhibit No. 5 is
a photograph of the toilet for the deck department
on after deck. There were defects in the toilet.
- .There was water running from it. That was the
way’ the condition was when we went out qn strike
‘on the 9th. I cannot say how long it.had been that
way. The pipe was rustéd and broken and leaking.
1 cannot remember, how long it had been leaking. It
- was a considerable time before the ‘vessel came to
Portland.
“The Court: I just want to tell y you, Mr: Carney,
this witness is painting a much worse picture at this,
trial than he did a wees ago. His testimony was not.
s
——————
——_—— ;
| the crew and in the tropics-you-sweat-more and if
A
a Kim
=r / ; oa ae : yard
7 | = owe “ vs
8 ’ sf . 2
418 William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
f Pertimony of Frederick W. Kaiser. )
f °
; —anywhere near as strong as it is today when he was ;
asked about the condition of that ship.”’
Mr. Tanner: He is-describing the —
now, your Honor.
; Exhibit No. 5 received in evidence. |
IT signed on the ship“at men and ' § was’ on the |
‘vesseb when it was in New Orleans. During all the
time { was on the vessel we only had one fire drill...
But it was nota: drill. It was only the bell ringing -
and everybody was in‘his place but nothing was-
-- drilled, no’ pressure on the-fire. hgses. The captain
. then said, “Well, ‘the fire equipment. . would not
4g work.’’ There was a lifeboat drill held I think about
five ‘times. ‘but the boat was not put oversthe. side. It -
never did go down to the water. The drill consisted
‘of standing near the lifeboats with our life jackets.
’ They try to show that the davits were working to —
rift a ‘boat about 5 feet high and put it a little on the
side and put it back again. That was only one boat
that we did that to, not all four. There. are four
~ lifeboats on the vessel. The boat we moved was the -
forward boat on ‘the starboard side, and once the -
‘after, starboard boat. The boats were never swung
out. and lowered. There were not sufficient men for
a galley boy to take care of therooms. I have never
sailed before on Liberty ships. In our engine room
department there. are three donkey greasers, two
oilers, there are.three firemen, three ‘enginee There —
oe are ten, siete engineer and the chief engi-
neer and sometimes there are eleven men. Later on
7 to 8. Sometimes Shey change. 7 shaven get sick
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. -
CT estimony of Frederick W. ‘Kaiser. ) aes ; .
and some jump shiyf It ds “not always the same .
number but between 7 and_ 8 besides the officers. “ie
There would be two men én ‘each watch, one oiler
and one fireman. There are three watches a day: If
we have 7 men one man will be on day work to do
repair jobs ene a a se filters on watér
_.tanks and make repairs like-paeking. He would be
on ,day work. oe : -
= On. Cross- a ee by Mr. Krause the \ Witeses ier
. Testified : | 3
I was assigned to lifeboat No. 4, It is on the.
port side. ‘The only boat that was raised was the _
starboard boat. The No. 4 boat that I was assigned
to, ‘was never swung out and nothing else was done : :
on it. I saw them swing the No. 1 boat out. When I-
‘Say swung out I meaniit was only a few feet in fieight, |
it was not swung: out overboard and then down. That
_ Was never done. They only lift it a little bit\and put
it back again. “That was all. The davits" were newer
“swung out. You swing the davits only to get-the
boat a few feet from the bottom. It was never
- swung out. To raise the boat off the deck you use a
noe block and tackle that holds the boat and you raise it — -
by hauling on the, tackle. We turned ghe screw, onlys.
to put the boat a few feet-in height but never to
sw ing it out, Never did it.go down. It was on deck ©
all. the time. You have to turn the wheel on the
davit in order to raise the boat off the deck. For
myself I haven't, turned the handle there. It was
e eS uN ae
. not: i boat and I don’t know how fast you must
and I
”.” Saw what was dirty and rfsty but I made no real ,
80. i Sela Benz, ‘a al. ete, vs.
( Testimony of Freder ick ‘W. Kaiser. Py >
turn’ it. ‘The lifebqat hangs on the upper deck. 7
cannot say exactly How you swing them i in-and ut.
‘E nly saw the hanf@ie of the boat. They raise it. by
the handle, I saw them work the handles * abd they
vo ked it up a distance of abgvt.10 mheters..- That is
allz\ At the time Iwas standing at No. 4. They bad
been working on the bottom boat. The crew stay on »
_ one side only you know and I could see what; ‘hey vit
se did. hat is only about 10- steps ‘from, the handle 3
1w that they were trying to put that boat up.
The lifeboats. had been very rusty and the tanks
have not’ yeen good. *I have looked at the tanks my-
‘
>
.
self. I think the best one for you to ask, would be ©
the bosun. That was his job. I did not}look at the
tanks. I know about the boats. I looked in the boats —
myself and I saw they are rust¥ and dirty but as to»
what. happefied with the boats in all particular de-
- tails it ‘is Hest to.ask the bosun. It was his job. and
- he ean tell you. The lifeboats had canvas govers on
them, and.they were lashed down. Lid 16t take the
canvas covers off but when the chief cook got in the
galley one time to use it thére, it was dirty and rusty
and he showed me hat. He showed me one water
tank in the lifeboat what he had to. use in the
kitchén, in the galley. That was very dirty and ~-
rusty inside. It was a-tank, that was not being used *
in /the lifeboat. I. saw the lifeboats midship and I\.
inspection, Whe onlsé inspection ) made was that T
| : 2 § “¥ - >
5 a al : . e
ia a a s ) he ae
| fa ed? Vey
~ | - ay 2"). Pi
) Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ) 81
ctisiaabons! of. Frederick W. Kaiser. 2
saw a lifeboat that had: the cover off “a I looked
into it and it was dirty and rusty.
The mattresses were dirty. I never did he on them o\\
with mx boots on. T was in pajamas like you. I don’t
know whether any of the other members of the crew
would lay on their mattresses with their boots on.
_ T have not been around the ship to look ‘at people
but they come from parents like most other _ 7
and they like-to stay in-a clean, bed and: anybody
who ‘likes that doesn’t. go to bed with his boots: on. |
I never saw any members of the crew fully dressed 4
with their boots on in bed. I: was .with Rev."Cham-”
berlain ‘when he’ went through the rooms. The cap- — —
tain was there and refused to go with ‘him and he
‘told me that is not your job and I was ‘supposed to. —
‘go back to my room..I didn’t see them lying on the ©
beds with their boots on while Rev. Chamber ‘lain was |
inspecting. I do not know when the mattresses were o
placed aboard the vessel or how long they have been.
_ In use. [ came aboard the ship March ' 19. About
their condition I think they are old. I can't say.ex-_
actly how old they are. I was not aboard the ship
§ before March 19. I don’t know about the we} the -
_ Ship. had taken. When you use the mattresses in the.
winter time and when you use them in the fropics it
is different. I can’t say how old they are or how
long they are in use. That is not my business. My
- mattreds was old like the ship. Maybe about @ years.
I held ‘a license so that I could ‘serve as an officer
on a ship and I have a license as Junior Thi n-*
gineer. I think I know my job xs wells , you ‘know
vo . 7 }
ee oi William Benz, et al., ete., vs.
: ( Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser. : |
_ yours. Laas complaining about the fire deilig on
the ship” The fire drills were wrong. The fire equip- ©
” “ment was not ‘proved. The fire hose, the steam either,
- nothing was proved. The -dnly thing was done, the
_ men would have to stay in their-places but the wholé
equipment was never proved. I don’t know exactly |
‘my position during the fire drill. We didn’t have any
real drills, the last ope is now five months ago. I -
don’t know my position in case of a fire. We didn’t ~
have enough fire drills aboard the ship. The places
were posted all ower the vessel, the positions of. the
men for a a for hoat drill but-if you don’t
have the drili. you can’t t_ remember 7 months the
place you have to stay if you have a fire drill. There
were drill notices posted on the ship saying-where
the men were supposed to be but it was changed in
nearly ail the months. They were posted where you
should be for boat drills but it was four. times in an-
other place-where-I-had to stay. I don’t remember —
exactly where I have to stay. There were changes. —
- made for the positions of some of the men: The :
changed positions were posted but they were not
drilled on their positions. I am not ¢omplaining
about my room not being kept clean. I could make
my bed myself. I asked for the wiper to clean my- |
room ‘but not every room. I want him fo clean. the
mess room and wash the dishes. But not to clean,the
room I was living in. The complaint I made was for
the mess room. There was only an ordinary seaman
aboard the ship. He was supposed to wash the
dishes. in the engine room departyrent\ and work
sal
| (Testimony of Frederick W. ‘Kaiser. )
-aboard the ship, too. He was a very young boy.
think about 15 years old and he couldn’t be every-
&
_ Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S. A. 83°
where, The chief cook would know more about the-
duties of this ordiriary seaman that was assigned to
mess duty. The: bosun would’ know ‘more about the
duties. He could tell you that exactly. The im)
butter and sausage for nighttime lunches. Then. we
3 made another request for meat‘that was fit for hu-
man consumption. But the meat we had was not good
: enough for human consumption. I would not feed it -
_to-my dog. We didn’t always have on board ship _
bread and butter and sausage for nighttime lunches.
We didn’t have any sausage. We -didn’t have any
re.
quest for additional food I made was for bread And ©
. butter. with brfad. We would go dewn to work in the -
nighttime on the 12 to 4 watch and the 4 to 8 wateh
with a piece of dry bread. .We had a hot meal at
nighttime for lunch at half past five in ie evening. .:
We did not have food for the nighttime. Ve asked
the captain for more bread and butter and sausage a:
few times and I asked the chief steward and he re- .-
e fhded and he said; ‘‘ You don't get it,’’ and we never
- got it. It was only the officers that got for nighte
time one egg, two slices. of -bread with butter and :
that« was kept in the ice box where’ they could get.
it but the crew. got nothing for the whole night. The
x
engineers sometinges wanted an egg and would want | |
a piece of hread. At no.time While. I was on the ‘ship
was there bead 6r butter br jam or sausage:set out ;
. for the crew inl department to eat at night.
. It was about the i4th or 15th of. ve after |
. \
84 ‘ William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
(Testimony of Frederi® Ww. Kaiser.) | |
we had been on strike 4 or.5 days that I seen the
paper (which was presented to the witness uniden-
_ tified)..I signed a blue.card but not when I went.on
strike on Sept. 9. I was going to the-union hall and
I asked a crew meniber of the SS Cotton State and
__ he told me where-the union hall was in Portland |
'- and I was accompanied by Mr. Hobeck, Goldsmith,
Symonds. That was about the 14th and it was there |
_T first saw this. paper. We went to. the union hall
and ‘asked for help, and since the 9th of September
we did not get any food aboard the ship, We had ‘:
organized the union in Europe that was afiiliated —
with the SUP and so we-asked the SUP to help us
in our strike. That was about the Mth or 15th of
September and Mr. William Benz told -us if you -
want us to aid you you will have to sign your pledge
‘ eard to ITF, and-I said, “O.K. I fix it.’’ That was .
about the 15th that I came back aboard the ship ©
with the pledge cards and I asked the crew members / 7
if they would sign or not.and so the whole erew whe
. went on: strike signed-the pledge cards, That was ©
about the 15th of September. I never contacted the -
union before we went on strike. It was on the 8th
of September that: I got in an accident. I got two
broken ribs in the evening about half past ten. I
never went to a meeting aboard the ship in the.
nighttime. .A few sailors may come aboard the ship
_when you are in harbor to meet a few sailors from
- another ship-and you speak about your conditions,
. just as you would find in the taverns near the harbor
_ where the sailors are talking. They speak about their-
tt
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. 85-
(einai of Frederick W. Kaiser. ) |
‘ship and these American seamen were inter-
"ested to'see a ship like ours. They told we, We are
on another ship here and can we have a look ?”” It
was the SS Cotton State lying right alongside us.
I think there were other sailors that came aboard’
our ship. I don’t remember all the sailors who camé
aboard with crew mémbers of the 88. Riviera. When |
the other sailors came ‘aboard they said they came _
to look around. It. was. not at a meeting. They came
only aboard the ship to take a look and leave the
ship later, that was all. About 3 a.m. of Sept. 8 I
did talk with the other sailors that were on the ship.
They heard about my accident and one looked at my
arm and said, ‘‘How. do you’ feel?’’.and I said,
‘“Goddam it, I don’t feel good, ”? and he said, ‘Oh,
I hope that you are not being so long sick.”’ Thet .
was all that I-spoke with them and thien they left the
ship. We did not‘have:a meeting. On that morning -
no blue cards were passed around. It was on Sept. 9 .
that. we went on strike. As our reason for going on
strike. we told the captain that.we want to have bet- —
ter food, but we don’t believe -him He told us many
things so under these conditions the crew said that
they would never sail again’ under the present condi-
tions. We refuséd to sail again’ with the ship. ‘Sure
we told the: captain something about being shang-
haied. from Bremen. We.were speaking about that
too. When you have a case like that you téll about
all the mistakes that are made that you have aboard
. othe” ship. You talk about them-at+tegethyr and you. .
_ Say. what vou. don't like. We gave the captain a:
; »
~S
~
«86 1 : William Benz, et al., etc., vs. .
(Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser.) .
paper signed by myself and about 24 other mem-
bers of the crew. The paper said, “Because we have
been shanghaied in Bremen for two years; on ac-
count of what the captain promised in this and in
- related cases we want our pay off and home voyage. :
Crew of the Steamship Riviera.”
The point about. being shanghaied was about the:
se biggest point in there. At Bremen we signed articles
March 19 and we had all been in the salon and it was
explained that this ship'is on a coal cargo trip be-
tween the United States and Europe and.we signed
the agreement with the. company in German and
English language, and that says the articles were for
30 days or longer. That means that it was in this -
time for. a trip to the United Stites and back, and
- later on we been at sea wetheard that this ship was not
going. north to the United States to got coal cargo, -
that the ship was going to New Orleans to pick up
grain cargo for India. We neve ver knew that before we
left the harbor in Bremen. The whole story is that we
sign on the payroll on the SS Riviera believing that
we make one trip between Hurope and the United
States and that we could sign off every time we come —
-back to Europe. I signed Ai agreement outside of
Bremen after I had been at sea. ( Respondent’s Ex--
hibit 7 was shown the witness: ) The signature there
_is my signature. It says that T. sign for 30 days or.
longer indefinitely as-tong-as~the ship wanted to
keep me, I read through that before I signed. It is
marked in there for 30 days or longer. That remains
for me that is for one trip.’ That is explained, the -
{ome ania Newtova Hidalgo, S.A. ea 87 |
- ae
_ (Testimony of rederick W. Kaiser.)
second. mate, aboard ship, Mr. Hardy this 30 deve or_/
longer i is for one trip and ft can be this trip in 0
days and you come back you can sign ‘off. The agr&-
nent was with the second mate. The eaptain had»
nothing to do about this 'agreement. That belonged
~* to the second mate and he handed us this agreement
and: we signed |it in the office of the second ‘mate,
Mr. Hardy in his room, That was the contract which
- I signed after the ship left Bremen. (Respondent’s |
Exhibit 8, the ship’s articles, was shown to the wit-
ness.) I signed the articles but I never saw the out-
side of them before we got to New Orleans. Itiwas_
“when I-was asking the.captain about them. [ remem-
her the sheet that has my name but’ it was not put
- together like that..It was only one sheet and the out-
side was not shown to me, only this sheet of paper.
— like that. It is. marked in here my date, my wages
‘and what ship-t been.on, last. ‘That was all that was
shown to me. Nothing - was. explained about mv
agreement. The agreement was net put together in
form like that, it was only one sheet on the top and
i later on in New Orleans Captain Cowden showed m&
an agreement that is like that, but what 4 saw when
T signed w&s this place hére. where T stgned abont'*my
wages, what I-was.to get” ‘on the ship and what ships
1 had been on last: That .is all that I knew about the .
agreement. (The sheet on which the witness’ signa- | ‘
ture appeared was received in evidence.) When I
come aboard the ship I have to sign artieles in the | .
German seamen’s book and also articles hanging _
88° ~—s—s« William Benz, et al, etc., vs.
(Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser.) .
_ out in all mess rooms that-you can read them before *
- and you know what happens. On every voyagé I
have taken I have signed articles and about the .
_ articles on the’ Riviera I knew about the contract
for 30 days. It was for one trip. ‘I don’t know about
this agreement here. This is different. I knew I was
signing articles about a trip between the United
States and Europe. Captain Johnson was present -
“put he did not explain that the voyage was for a
maximum of two years. I didn’t ask the captain how
long we were signing for. I saw in the agreement _
that it was 30 days alone so I did not have to: ask
; again. The agreement was not signed at the time
the articles were signed. The agreement was signed’: «
later on. I signed the, agreement the next day after
we left Bremen and T signed it in the room of the:
second mate, Mr. Hardy. I. think there were three
copies of the agreement signed. They are not kept
in the German Labor office. It is only the German
.,Merchant Bureau. I have not seen anybody from the’
Merchant “Bureau and nobody told me that coming ”
from this German Merchant Bureau. I signed three.
copies and I don’t know what became of the other
two. T got a copy of it. Tt must be in my luggage. - ©
(Exhibit No., 7 was received in evidence:)
Exhibit 8 was received in ev idence.
‘The copy which: was given to me was not signed
by Captain Cowden. I will bring it to court mor-: |
/row. It is‘up in jail with my papers. —. - /
Captain. Cowden and Captaim Johnson were there :
when I signed. the articles. Captain Johnsofi did not’
_ Compania Naviera Hidalgo, 8.A. 89
(Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser. )
explain fully that I was signing for’ a voyage not
‘exceeding two years. With respect to what I meant
by what the captain had promised in the past, I was.
‘Teferring to a few agreements about payment, +
- about ship’s overtime. We had an appointment
aboard the ship with Vice German Consulate Gen-
_ eral, Mr. Pheifer, at Bombay, and the captain
. promised to better those things and it was promised .
that we would get better food. The ptain promised ' \
_ t@ pay wages like wages already’ like. we have in
_ Ship, and overtime pay would be paid 3 in the harbors,
but he refused to: pay it. I asked the captain for that ©
in Kawasaki, Japan, and he refused to pay, so don’t -
— get it. The eaptain promised to pay overtime’ and
_then later on he said he would not pay overtime.
The captain pr omised to- better. the food and to buy
more végetables and nothing was done and that, is
‘what I referred ‘to im the second: provision, of the
paper. Many. of the crew complained to the eaptain
| about the food but I per: ‘sonally did not complain’ to
- the eaptain about the food and the captain did not
- promise me personally that the food would be bet-—
ter, but the chief steward told mé that the captain ,
said the food would be better. It was the’ chief stew-"
ard who made the promise. We did buy better beef
in Singapore, but we cannot uke it when he keeps it
in the ice box; they refused to use it. Then you have
to eat lot of rotten buffalo. Goddam, that is not
promise, that isnot done what the promise was. The.
promise that the captain made was to the whole
crew. ™ j
— sie «ue - ~ a
° —-—= e
90 | William Benz, et-al., etc., vs.
iz (Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser. )
I went on Strike on Sept. 9 and in the meantime I
was working on the ship. The first time-I taljd to ~
- a representative of the Sailors’ Union of the. Pa-
cific was about the 14th.!That was the first date on
which I got the blue cards. I saw Mr. Cochrane
- about the 10th or 11th. I-don’t know. He could have —
been on board the ship on the 8th but I had not been
speaking to him: The first time I got the Makiki
paper regarding the SUP was about the 14th or
15th. It was not before. It was at the time I went
to the Sailors’ Union hall. They did riot give me: the
‘blue cards at that time. I got the bluewards first and _.
then later on they told me about another strike Gn .
the Makiki and I saw that copy. only after*! deliv-
ered the blue card to Mr. Benz, the agent of the
SUP. ‘ithe blue cards were to the ITF. The Sailors’
Union of the Pacific is affiliated with ITF which is
our union in Europe. We are affiliated too. When.
{I got the blue cards on the: 14th or 15th I went
around and got the other members of the crew to
sign them. When I asked them-to sign I told the
men that if we stay in this strike very long we won 4
have anyone to help us and I told them that I. met me
_ that in this c¥se he wanted to give us help. That is
»
the agent of es hall, Mr. Benay and he said
all I said, so-alk
paper. I am positive that I didn’t get the blue eards
2 before the 14th. There were no other blue cards ex-
cept the ones which authorized the ITF to represent
‘us. In Bremen IT helonged to the ITW, that-is Trans-
~ port Workers Union in Germany and itis affiliated
o .
{ B 7 a
e members of the crew signed the ~*
. ee aeee! fe
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, SLA. 91
) estimony of Frederick W. Kaiger. ) : fe:
) the ITF, International pri ng
Jnion. (t I was already a member of the ITW. The
* blue card designated the Sailors’ Union of the Pa-
~ erew joined with you and refused to «
_ eifie as bargaining agent. They didn’t
members. After the strike all the met
refused to ‘work and there were some
mbers.of the
lo work. We
of them who
a8k us. to be.
had- refused to work before the strike.) The captain
‘did not order them to either work or get off.the
ship. He said, “If you want to. go on strike go |
ahead.’’ That was all he said. But he didn’t say that
to me as I was lying in bed. I was_asked by Mr. |
Closterman in the presence of the master whether I,
would resume work, sail with the ship or not and we , 7 .
said we refuse to sail with the ship under present
conditions and I remember so well one British fel-__
low aboard, Mr. Symonds, said to My. Clostérman,
‘Well, under, the present conditions| we Tefuse to
work. ¥ T said nothing about increased wa Tiwas |
satisfied with .the .wages.- I -never. akked for any | -
_ higher wages. I did not request the’ ailors’ Union
a
of the Pacific to secure an increase in wages: I had
not spoken of higher wages with anybody. The gece
tire matter had nothing to do with the wage scale.
It was. only about conditions aboar the ship,, the
food, the liy ing conditions and the sepworfhiness of
the SS. Rivierg, in the particulars to which I have
#7 . testified. After I got out of bed J, was: ‘able to go-—
|. down to the union hall and_also om
~. vessel. At that time I didn*t-picket
i,’
myself: T
to pie “ket the
te |
: Sn
a bites ES
me)
é
Was _ ee
|
92 William Bene, et al. eben vs.
(Testiniony of F rederitk W. Kaiser.) | |
not able because of my broken ribs. I was not sit-_
ting on tlie’ gangway watching the pickets but I-still —
agree with the whole crew. With respect to our food
supplies while we were on strike,-we got some food
from other ships that came in, and there was help
from other sailors. We were not bein supplied-
aboard the ship. We did: not get supplie from the.
Sailors Union of the Pacific except while we were
in. jail, we were supplied scmetimes but that’s all.
While we we on board the ship we, were not fur- .
-nished with as sistance by way of food supplies or.
money by the. ilors’ Union of the Pacific.-We were
“supplied by collections: from longshoremen and we «
got food from other ships’ that. came in “and they
brought food from ‘thebs kitchen and the men from
our kitchen went pis o their kitchen and took food
from there to supply us. That was all. So far 4s I
am concerned I have wot asked - the Sailors’ Union
of the Pacifie to make a new contract with the
owners, | reas
In_ response to a question-frépounded by the
+ Cont the witness testified : |
Ti kage that the SUP, would aid us an give us
help-so: that we. could’ singles a final settlement with °
the company, | that we would \be better supplied and...
the ship would-be im good eondition. and would see.
that:the agreement would be right. I never asked
anybody and nobody \in the crew was expecting to
get higher wages. That was not our idea. The wage
gente’ éal the roa reported. what. the. Sailors
Union had done¥on another ship. I didnot discuss
i
6 *y
ae | .'2
' by the master, not one.
Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S.A. ; 93
ee (Testimony of Frederick W. Kaiser. )
with Mr. Benz of the Sailors’ Union that the Sail-
ors’ Union was going to get me. the same — in-
_ crease that they had got on the Makiki. I was\only
‘asking for help in our case, in this fight for better”
: | conditions, that was all. I did not diseuss with Mr.
- Benz about getting this Makiki wage scale. Nobody
was asking the captain for that as far as I know: |
‘Now I have produced the labor contraét to which
I have previously referred that was signed when I _
joined the ship in ‘Bremen. It was stipulated that
the copy ieee: by the witness was not signed by
the master.’ » ~~
I have seen other copies from: other ‘members of
the crew and they are not signed by the master eiiot
one of them. : |
On Re direct | Exapiisiatiod by Mr. Carney the wit-
a ness testified. as follows:
- I have ~ ecked with the members of the crew witly
‘respect to their.copies of the labor contract. Nearly
—half.of the crew do not have a contract like this. A ‘
few. crewetnembe . signed on in Arhus. ail they
didn’t have a contiact like this and ‘all. the “other «
pe ople who have'a contract like this it is not signed
by- the-master, Ihave. not. seen_any contract signed.
a WI i
‘Exhibits 9, 10’ and 11, whieh respon ent sited fo
~~ have produved, were produced and_puy_in ouiseny: i
o> nent. ,
whigh consists of the blue eards signe by Pete TOD, ;
Pedersen and: Kaiser.
“me F _* William Benz, et al:, ete., v8.
JOHN A. ANDERSON
- a witness produced on behal libelants, being:
duly sworn on Direct Resadustion by Mr. Carney.
testified as.follows: t 3
My name is John A. Anderson and I live at 1718
SW 16th. I am an experienced marine surveyor and
I am a retired steamboat inspector. I hold master’s |
_ license unlimited jn any water and any gross ton-
nage.-T have. been employed here in Portland as a
Marine suryeyor by the government over a period
of 714, years. I am familiar with Liberty type. ves-
sels. ‘At Mr. Carney’s request I went aboard’ the
‘SS Riviera to check the steam smothering sysfem
on October 15. The steam smothering system con-—
sists of steam pipes that lead into the holds for the
purpose of ‘Smothering fire in case of fire in .the.
cargo spaces. The steam’ pipes are controlled.
valves on deck. There is a steel cabinet on deck
where the valves are located and i in case of fire vou |
turn the valves on to the particular space like the
lower hold or the ’tween-decks, paint locker,
wherever the fire happens to be.. I. checked the
valves of the ‘steam smothering apparatus on the
SS Riviera ‘on the after deck No. 4 and No. 5
‘holds. I found that the valves leading into No. 4
_. *tween-decks and No. 4 lower hold weré froze, and. _
+ the pipe leading jhto No. 5 hold was froze, and the
valve leading into the paint locker was froze. There ,
was only one valve. that worked and that was No. 5.
‘tween-devks. The valves would not turn, In my
inion as a mariner and .as a surv eyor of vessels ©
such as~ the Ss Riviera with its steam smothering
2
y
| Cian N aviera H ‘idalgo, S. A. 95
| (' Testimony of J ohn A. Anderson. ) :
gear in the condition I found it, it would not. be sea-
worthy. They would never pass a test for seaworthi-
ness.
»
<
On Cross-Examination by Mr. Krause the witness
testified: * ?
. I tried to turn the valves by hand without using _
. any tool to turn them. They have a little wheel on -
top. I could 1fot move them with two hands and upon
that basis I say they wéte-ffozen. There were no
tools supplied there for the purpose of opening the
‘valves. I have never seen a: rod that fits into the
wheel on top for the purpose of turning the wheel.
_ and TI have never seen such a thing on-any. ship.
Liberty ships are not supplied with those rods for
the purpose of opening thoge valves. The vessel was .
unseaworthy. heeause I could not open the valres
by hand. The seaworthiness of a vessel when they
go to sea is determined by the steamboat inspector.
I*do not know that a vessel is “inspected every time
ih
it goes to sea by surveyors from. the Marine Bureau
and T have been a master mariner. I have heen mas-
ter of vessels for over 20 vears. In our inspection
to determine the seaworthiness of a vessel the vessel
is compelled to have an inspection every year and it
is given a certificate of inspection, and that inspec-
tion record is good for one year. She can make sev-
eral trips during that year without any’ inspection
in between times. With respect to thee carg and so
on, and the inspection that is made before sHe starts”
the vovage, that is a different thing. There
@ } ee! ee a"
96 ——« William Benz, et al., etc., vs...
(Testimony of John A. Anderson.) |
- surveygts. They might come aboard and inspect her
‘ any time they want to./I made my inspection on the ©
: 15th of October. I don’t know anything about when
the valves were last opened. ‘They cannot be opened .
by hand unless it is stronger man than I am. I
Bev 't know if they could ‘be opened with a. bar so
_you could exert more force than you can with your .
hands. [have seen them froze before on other ships
_ where ypji couldn’t do ¢thing to them antik you —
art and chip d some of the rust off
"the uben stem because if you try\to force them with
a handle like you ‘say- you are liable fo- twist the
handle right off. The valve stems are made of some
‘sort of metal. It is a mild steel, I suppose. Not
bronze and I don’t think copper. ‘Tf they were made,
of brass they would not rust,. but ‘there would be-a
lot. of wepyienie that would stick just as bad as rust
will, I think on Liberty ships the valves are made
of iron but I would not, swear that the \entire valve
is made of iron. I have never had one apart. There ;
“may be ‘some brass|parts in there.
nny Exainination by Mr. Carney” the wit-
ness testified : Pte eee
~The valves that Is AE smothering gear
are hegated in a box-shaped metal cabinet. In that
cabinet there is one valve. for the lower hold, No. 4. ’
There is ond valve for the=No. 4 'tween-decks. There.
__is one valve fer lo ne hold No. 6 and one valve for
the No. 5 ’tweeh-decks. There is a master, valve let-
_ ting steam into the cabinet. There is a vfllve for
~S
‘ | \
&
‘Compani Naviera Hidalgo, S. A. - Gf
| ( Tehtienoney Sf John\ A. ‘Anderson. ) ot:
_ the paint locker anqd ‘there is a valve for bleeding .
. the system when yon shoot steam into the holds or:
else you would get the holds "full of water. There are
8 valves altogether. |I would judge the cabinet to; be
30 inches by 30.inches. It avas hard to tell about the:
condition of the valves with respect to rust and that
sort of thing becase they had been*painted black.
' There might be ‘rust under the paint. I wasn’t inter- |
much. I was interested in whether
the valves: would work or not. In my experienge in
testing Liberty pe vessels and in testing: this
_ steam smothering gear, it..is absolutely necessary
_ that these valves in order to be passable, are able to
be turned by hand ‘It would be possible if the tool
was not too long tb use a. tool inside the. box, but the
_ valves are fairly ra together. In my experience
such tools are not ugually furnished. The valves are
supposéd to be worked by hand. If they-do not they
have to be ‘repaired. I djf not see any such-tools as
Mr. Krause described“on the SS Riviera. There
<3 might have been one but I didn’t see any.
ested in that SO
On ‘Riécrcan-Eactitiistion. by Mr. Kebiae the wit- :
ness testified :
The valves have to be set up > tight or else they
would damage the cargo. They have to be-set up.
tight by hand. They are hand-set. The engineers
go over them are not supposed to tighten them with
a.tool in order to make them tighter, because if:a
‘valve is good you only haye to set them by hand,
98 “Witkiam Bins: ve al. , ete., Vs.
( Testimony of John A. Anderson. ).
that’s ‘all. They are supposed to be tight ins, al
have opened up and set a lot of them by hand, al- 3
OW ays by hand.
&
. ss , wet
On Examination by the Court the witness testified :
This was a foreign ship and I do not believé that’
she came under our inspection laws. If she was an |
American ship and was brought in. for repairs be- °
fore the ship could leave it would have to be! certi:
fied and a certifieate issued. by -the American Bu-—
peau. It could be certified by an insurance carrier.
“a
| A. BERG | |
a witness produced by libelants, after Mind duly
sworn \by the interpreter, Frederick Kaiser, upon :
Direct Examination by * ‘Mr. Carney, testified as
follows: tee
I ani first assistant engineer of. the“SS_ Riviera.
.The officer next in command in the engine room is
chief engineer. T signed the articles at Rotter-
- dafisin February, 1952. IT made one trip as second
. asshetant engineer aboard the ship to Norfolk and
later ork March 19 in Bremen I got a job as first. -
assistant engineer. In all my experience on the SS
Riviera there has ever vite any fire. drills con-
ducted where water pressure was actually put on |
the fire hose. During | my employment on the Riviera
I recommended to the chief engineer that additional
fire hose equipment be furnished to the ship and I :
made the recommendation oné week before we came |
to Portland. At sea T spoke to the chief engineer
4
« -
Compania Nat aviera Hidalgo, S.A. 9%
( Testimony. of H EL Berg.)
about repair ‘work what must be done aboard the
ship, and he told me that the fire equipment: must
- be repaired. I requested the chief engineer prior to
coming to Portland that the fire hose and fire- fight- ae
ing equipment be purchased in Portland to bring |
‘the fire-fighting equipment up to standard. The
chief engineer ld me that the time in Portland was
too short, that we cannot repair the fire equipment
-and cannot make anything else. I also told the chief
engineer that the fire hose down below in the engine
room and in the holds were not usable and the chief
- engineer said to go upstairs on deck anid maybe vou
_ ean find other hose and change them for the ones in
_ the engine and: deck department. Gis fetish
~ I know what you mean when you speak of ‘the
steam smothering gear.and I. know what that equi} -
ment is. I had inspected the steam. smothering gear
but I have. not had time to overhaul ‘the. gear, to
unscrew it. The condition of the steam smothering |
gear on Sept. 9.was in'‘very bad condition. It. was
rusty. It was impossible to turn, the valves. All of.
the valves that were on-the deck outside the engine
-room would be rusty after two or three weeks if. they
Ww ere. ‘not serviced and those valves: had: not: been
“serviced. We were short on work. hour the most time
aboard ship.-Ever since I came on board the vessel
the steam smothering valves were frozen and rusty.
It is impossible for a rusty valve to- open by. hand,
* and if I say the valves were rusty they are frozen
too. Tt would be possible to turn the valves by use
of a wrench and it would be possible, too, to break.
100° ‘Willian Benz, eta, etc., vs.
(Senttainniie of H. Berg. y |
the valve in the spindle. To my knowledge ‘ther e
were no plans made while the ship was in Portland
to repair the. walves on the steam smothering gear.
The chief'e erigineer refused to do some of the things
“about the steam smothering valves, There were port:
’ able. fire extinguishers on the ship that: can be lifted
by hand. On September 9 I can’t say whether they -
were working: I could riot “test the’ fire equipment |
and you would have to: test it to know if it was
working. if a ship comes into the harbor to be in-
“spected the whole fire equipment must be tested.
That includes not only the steam smothering but
other fire equipment and all transportable fire equip-
ment must be tested: By the portable. fire equipment _
I mean. the fire ext guishers. If the extinguishers—
are not in use within a period of a year they must —
be tested, or you cannot say if they are working or
not. One was’ tested’ since I came. aboard ship and
that was-w orking but that doesn’t say that all the
others would work... ¢ “ihe
On C ross-Examination by Mr. Krause the witness
‘testified :
: a have ‘been going to sea. since 1938, ‘I sailed, 9.
years in the merchant raaxine. T, was in the Navy be- -
tween 1940 and 1945. T hold a license for ship’s
engineer first: class. That is: the license that means
‘on ships of 5,000 tons. I can sail as chief. éngi-|*
neer on ships under 5,000 tons and on ships of 5,000 |
‘to 10,000 tons [ have a license as first assistant engi- |
neer. With respect to the inspection that I made. -of
\
eS
4.
” Compania Naviera Hidalgo, S. A. 101
(Testimony of i. Berg.)
the steam sniothering system I tried the valves and
saw it was impossible to turn them and I went to the
chief engineer and told him that they must be re-
_ paired. I tried to turmthem with a wrench but it was
not possible to open. tlm. Then I went to the chief,
engineer and asked hin to repair the valves. The
valve ¥ tried to open fvith a wrench was the steam
smothering master v Itts located forward down
_« toward the bridge. From Mere‘ the pipes.go to the
engine room. It is that valvé:that would allow the
steam to go into the holds. The valve is 2 to 244
inches on the inside. The size of (he wheel for turn-
ing thé valve would be about 1 foot. (The witness
indicated with his hand. the approximate size of the
whéel and it was about 10 or 12 inches in diameter. )
Or 10 to 15 centimeters. I last looked at the’ valve
- about. three months ago. I did not say that I made: .
an. inspection of the valves about a week before com-
ing into port.-I spoke to-the chief engineer about |
~ the valves one week before we came to Portland but
I didn’t say that one week before I came to Port-
land IT tested the valves.’ I'well knew that the fire
— equipment must: he repaired and overhauled and it |
_is the duty of the chief engineer that the repair
work be done and if he doesn’t do it he might go too.
jail if an accident should happen about it. It is not
only the. steam smothering equipment aboard thé
ship, there is CO-2 fire equipment in the engine
room that was unusable because the pipes were rusty
and locked in there. It was my job to use the equip-
ment and.not my job to make proof of them, that is
102 William Benz, et al., etc., vs.
(Testimony of H. Berg.)
the job of the captain and the chief engineer. The
only test that I made myself was on the master
valve-on the deck. All the steam pipes, fire equip-
ment was so rusty that it was dangerous to open the -°
master valve and it. could be possible that we would
get many accidents and many people. would be
burned by steam. The steam. pipes for the steam -
smothering valve was the same, in the same condi-—
tion like the pipes for the winches on Weck. Thty -
,were in very bad condition, rusty. If you think they~
can be, opened : vou should go with me aboard the —
_ ship and open the valve. You ican try to open it. It
is a long time now that I was aboard the ship. It was
impossible to open the valve’on deck by a wrench.
It was in Calcutta that I tried to open the valve and
it was iénpossible and it was in Caleutta that I told
‘the chief engineer. That was spout three months .
ago. oo | .
Whereupon, : upon an objection made by Mr.
Krause conceyning the intet pretation which * Mr.
KAiser ‘was “heath of the witness’ answers, Mr.
“Bruno C. Linde was substituted as interpreter and
the witness testified through his interpreter as fol-
lows! - :
- ‘The valves of the steath ‘smothering system must
. be tight SO that no water will get in the cargo. The
valves for the system have to be opened by hand.
The rules and regulations require that they can be
opened by hand. I am talking about international
regulations. Ido not ¢arry a wrench for a-valve in
7
¢
| Compania Naviera Hidalgo, tm - 2
(Testimony of H. Berg.) ae
my pocket. We have hooks for valves and ventila- |
tion hooks on board the ship. The purpose of the
valye ‘hooks i is to tighten the other valves which are
‘ ait and used for the boiler system.
-NILS RICHARD PEDERSEN ene
a witness produced on behalf of libelants, afte eing
duly. sworn, testified through an interpreter as fol-—
lows: — .
I am the scsi of the SS Riviera, ahd’ I signed on
October 3, 1951, and have sailed continuously on the
SS Riviera fi om that time until September 9. I have
been going to sea as a seaman.for from 12 to 13
years. I was hired as an AB from October until |
. shortly’ after Christmas and -then, I ‘was hired as
- bosun from that time until the present. My duties
aboard the ship were to put the men on duty, to see
that they were released at proper times accor ding to
the or ders given by the chief officer. My job together |
with the carpenter’ includes the. work of* the. life-
boats; that they have never been given a chance to
really care for the lifeboats on account 6f so many —
other things receiving priority you might say, such
as the cargo holds and the deck and so on.: From the. —
time I went to work on the Riviera none of the life-
boats have been lowered over the side of the ship.
While I was on the ship 1ioyfresh provisions and _
emergency supplies were ‘placed in‘ the lifeboats |
except water which had been placed in the lifeboats °
after I was hired and was changed twice. I have seen
&
| 104 William Benz, et al.,
es er \
a | Testimony of Nils Richard Ped rsen. )
the equipment in the lifeboats Which is _stored ale
in case of- emergengy. Two of the lifeboats are with-
out any motors in: the boats And the air tanks are
rusty with holes in Aherh.- I saw those lifeboats in |
ow
.
Tt was part of my w
Caleutta before J uly of this/year. Before I stopped
working on the vessels. on Sept. 9, two of the life- |
boats that had deféctiv e air/tanks had been repaired.
The air tanks were taken ont of the boats.in Caleutta
and the ship rw ia Japan for the Pacific
Coast without those tanks in the boats and the life-
"boats were the finally repaired on the Pacific Coast. -
~ The air tanks had not be¢n replaced but the lifeboats
had: been temporarily xed up and supplied with.,
patches over |the -holes./ The equipment. in the’ life-
boats was bélow par, jvery, very bad. When the
patches were put on the boats they remained on their —
cradles. With respect o the condition of the hull of
the lifeboats‘on September 9, their. condition was’
very poor. If one stepped too heavily on it he would
probably go through{ The hull is made of metal.
They- were very rusty/and just about rusted through. --
k to scrape and paint the life-
boats. We were working on fixing up,the boats and
scraping it before painting when the chief officer ,
~stopped.us_ from doirig it because the chief: officer
realized that: if they worked too long on them there ~
would be nothing left and he figured that the boats
would be fixed up by the time they came into the
~ dock on the Pacific Coast. T was not allowed to do
work on this vessel with respect to the lifeboats the .
same as I was allowed to do the work on other ships .,
\
Nite
- Compania Naviera H idalgo, 7 Meee |
(T tationons of Nils Richard Pedersen. )
on which I hi ve had experience. The work that T'was
allowed to dg on this vessel differed from that which
I was usually allowed to‘do: on other vessels. When
'T was sailing on Danish boats I would ask the chief
' officer for a couple of men to fix up the lifeboats in
which case he would get two men and fix up the
boats, whereas in this case I told the chief. officer
_ that they needed-repairs and I was not allowed:to fix
up. the boats accordingly. ests .
. On ee, EA Ee by Mr. Kr sant the W fniode
" Testified :
The voyage I signed for in Ontober: 1951, was con-
- ¢luded. In March, 1952, I signed an for another. voy- .
age. The ship was ina fine condition by the time I
was rehired in March, 1952. The hull of the lifeboats
were made of galvanized iron. I am not a chemist. .
~-and he does know even galvanized iron can-rust. The
: ‘- ¢ = a A : . -
galvanized iron was rusty. The air tanks were re-
moved from’ the lifeboats and taken ashore for
repairs. bdid not say that they were taken ashore in.
Calcutta. While the ship was on the way over from
' Japan the air tanks were in the boats. However, they
were loose and there were holes in them. They had
not been repaired before the trip across the Pacific.
They were brought ashore here in Portland for
repairs. There are two men including myself that
-work on the lifeboats. I worked on the lifeboats 3 to
\4 weeks. Two men besides myself worked onthe life- -
boats. I suyervised the. work. They remoyed the air
tanks and seraped.the inside of the hull and in doing
- / were very old. Maybe they .were there from the time
q>.-
*
/
+106 ~ / 3 : William Benz, etal, etc., Vs.
. (Teatfmony of Nils Richard Peierien. +:
so they went through the hull. They painte od where
they could, where they had a chance. Ail four boats |
_ required repairs pn the hull after the vessel got to
Portland. The provisions in the lifeboats presumably :
the ship was fixst:launched. All the provisions were
there but they were merely unfit for human con- .
sumption. - -The ‘provisions in the two boats with :
motors were in sealed cans whereas in the other
boats the compartments in w rhich the provisions were
eontaiired were defective allowing water to come into —
the provisions. I opened some of the cans of emer-—
_ gency, rations in which the provisions were stored.
_ One was a container with bread and there was metal
around it and it ‘was rusty and I could twist the ¢an
open. The equipment used for the release of the life- .
boats from the ship in case of an emergency was not -
in order, The equipment had been neglected. We had
never been allowed to fix it-tip. The davits could be.
moved out on.the side but they had not been swung.
. The davits could ‘be put out on the outside. of the
ship but it took two men for each of the davits to do .
so on account of-the screws being rusted. With re-
spect to the equipment for the four boats, they had:
one or two life belts and these were even defective.
There were only one or two floating anchors for the
four boats. I-told the chief mate that he had to make
up additional floating anchors but I was not allowed
to-do so. The lifeboats should have been thrown away *
“hecause there wasn’t anything of worth in them. In °
Mareh of 1952, the boats could be put in the water: -
the 11th of September. aver
On Redirect ‘Examination by | Mr. Cimey the Wit.
\
\
\.
‘(Testimony of Nils Richard Pedersen.) é
but I believe the condition of the hoats was as it is
now. It wassimilar to the way they air e now. Before ‘
ic
the men went on strike they had rephired the hgles
in the lifeboats here in Portland. . W ent on strike
ness Testified :
- Repairs i in Portland were culy dons on two ais
“that were leaking. As far as T know no work at all
~ was being done on tlie other boats. It would be usual
tk
-avhen a. boat is. being: repaired in dock that the con-
dition of the other boats would also he cheeked but
they were not. In my experience when lifeboats are
being repaired in other cases they are put in the
water to check them to see if they are tight. How-
ever, that was not done in Portland, So far as I
‘know they were not going to be checked in the water.
leave Portland. As far as I know it was around the
13th or 14th of September, It would have been possi- —
ble to put the. lifeboats in good condition between. —
the time the men quit. working. and the time the
It k do not know when the Riviera was scheduled to —
es\ ~ Compania RCD Hidalgo, S.A. ; 107 ae
.
vessel was supposed to sail if the ship had allowed we
the men to do the work. U p to the time I left the
vessel ‘nothing had been done fo replace the emer-. |
gency equipment in the lifeboats, such as provisions |
. and other emergency equipment.-That was one of the —
reasons why I quit working on the ship on that date
because they’ had not replaced the equipment in the
boats. Wher eupen the libelants rested their ease,
ae
108 ‘William Bene, al, ete., vs. | o
A... Joserit a. soHNSON|
=~,
J
. .a Witness produced on behalf of respondent, the SS _ |
Riviera, ‘after wine duly sworn testified as follows:
>
‘Direet Examination cp
| By Mr. Mosser: 0 ¢" cane
I am. Captain subaiice and ‘my occupation is ¥
master mariner. I hold master’s certificate fropt
Great Britain and have been going to sea a8 am
for 15 years. I was formerly t e master of the/SS
jera; from Juty; 1950, to Mare 1952. My
cessor was .C in Cowden. I had “something o do
with signing on a. crew for the Riviera in March,
1952, at Bremen: The: articles were British: articles
according to the British ‘Maritime Laws, Exhibit 8
is the articles. That is the, set that. was signed at
Bremen. with respect to the libelants in this case. I .
was there.at the signing on of all of the men. When
the men. signed the articles they were told that they 2
grere signing for a period of two Yeaus, not exe eeding |
two years and all conditions of the British’ National
Maritime Board regarding ‘wages and hours, etc.,
would apply I spoke ‘to the men in English. The
chief engineer was there talking German as well. He
is now on the ship: He translated to the men the
remarks that I made, but they mostly understood
what I was saying in English. There was another
agreement with respect to the German seamen made.
up and signed. That agreement ig exhibit No. 7. That
is the type of the original agreement. An agreement
sue-*
‘like that was made for each of the German nationals .
/
oi 1952. That i is Pe
SG
Compania y axiera oH idalgo, 8. A, 109.
( Testimony of Joseph ’ H. J obnsén. a ae
who signed on as sav of the crew in Mareh,
lired by a governing body in Ger- '
many. Captait. Cowden was :present at the time the
| crew was signed on. Captain Cowden with the as-*
sistance. of the ship’ s local agent in Bremen made ~
out the separate contracts. They were all made out —
before the ship sailed from Bremen. Phey had to be. ae
Otherwise the ship would not obtain clearance. They
Were not made out at the time each of the men signed
the articles. It was just shortly after that they were
all made out. ‘The articles were signed first. There
were five copies prepared’ for each man. One was for
, the ship, in care of the master, one for each one of
the ‘seamen, one. for the foreign office, one for the
- agent and one for the seamen’s register. Ohe copy of
each of these contracts ,was filed with the Gerthan
authorities that are supposéd to receive them, Just
one copy ,was signed by both the master and thé —
member of the crew, as far as L am aware, one Copy.
_ Those documents were signed on the.ship at Bremen.
All the. crew signed: on there, One signed on in Egypt —
and individual “replacements - signed on later. I
signed on’a full crew in Bremen. There were com-
| pletely riew articles signed at that time. Some of the
» men who had previously served on the ship signed
off the articles and on new articles at that time. The
articles were signed by all the men who went on the
‘ship at that time prior to the.time the ship left Bre-
men. They signed the labor contracts too: With -
respect to the condition of the ship prior:to March,
1952, and the condition of the ship in Mareh of 1952.
f
x
ap Mem
a 7 Fs
110 “.. _ Wiliam Benz, et al., etc., vs.
(‘Testimony of Joseph H. Johnson. ) he
when I left the ship I would say she was in excellent
condition all over. I had had-my wife aboard the s
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.