Memorandum for the US as Amicus Curiae in Support of the Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — Offutt Housing Co. v. County of Sarpy
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
-.: a ;
rf UT
. _HARGLD R WILE rk
N oO. “404. aye
Sith Saree out Died Ste
: OctopEr TERM, 1955" |
ae Orrurr USING Company, A Conronation,
: ye z PETITIONER :
_. County or Sarpy and Ropert M. Epy, TREASURER
| OF CoUNTY, OF SARPY, NEBRASKA
9
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF OBRTIORARI LO THE
SUPREMEQOOURT OF NEBRASKA
.
:
bad eis =>
if 2 . wc th : o-
MEMORANDUM FOR THE: UNITED STATES AS- AMICUS
CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITION FOR A WRIT OF : |
CRRTIORARI |
SIMON E. SOBELOFF, : o °
‘Solicitor General,
H. BRIAN HOLLAND,
os Assistant Attorney General,
_ ELLIS N, SLACK,
HILBERT P, ZARKY,
6° _ ERWIN A. GOLDSTEIN, -
, *. LYLE M. TURNER,
' Attorneys;
—_ . Department of Justice,
Washington 25, D. 9.
‘
; eee 22
=)
° 5
a s : . >
> . - >
+f)
>: : 5
site: _” CITATIONS
Cases: : me °
- Kern-Limerick, Inc. v.-Se urlock, 347 US) 110...... > 6,
8S. R. A., Inc: v. Minnesota ; G35 2 Seon
7
> ise
Surplus Trading Co. v. Cook, 281 US. 647....... aH S::
“United States v. Allegheny | & ey 322 Os 174 6
cu Statutes: eh es re
; "Military Loeste: in August 5, 1947, .c. _ 493, 61
Stat. 774, 5 U.S.C. 626s wet 1) 3
REG E Be Aad weew t w ad bld b ok a Pe 4
¢ PIM BN: sre tw ya's Shin Lene Veet cba oe
os Bee 6 oes, avy eesewunbivaeaie shy panies 3, 4,6
ow herry Act, August 8, 1949, 63 Stat. 570, e: 403, Bie
““ 12 US.C. 1748 et MEER ee Wy lGeass rae
See. 805 a bis\aiay Pr eNEr eee tines sche 3.4:
Sec. 807 EAU Ciesla atll wee ee hw uraes we 5
| -" Miseellaneous: 2 : , |
a _ Rept. No. 854, 81st Cong., Ist Sess., aie Se. Sa 2
S. Rept. No. 410, 81st Cong., Ast § Sess.,‘pp. 4-5. . 2
corte *. eg
_
| She Saprem Gjoutof the the Write States
: Oc TOBER- TERM, 1955 ~:
° tee No. 404 - |
- OFFUTT Housing Comrany, a CORPORATION,
; PETITIONER Seek ;
v. :
; Re:
Cou NTY OF SARPY AND ‘Rowanr M. Esy. TRE ASU RER 3
OF COUNTY OF SARPY, NEBRASKA
- ON "PETITION FOR. A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE |
? SUPREME COURT OF NEBRASK. Ac: 4
MEMORANDUM FOR THE UNITED STATES AS. AMICUS a
- CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
beara nee tempt
e
‘
=
to
°
The vu nited States respectfully urges the Court
to grant the. petition fora writ of certiorari whieh -
has been.filed in this case,
The -issue’ which this ¢ ‘ase ] poses is one of im-
portance. to the U nited: States. The litigation. af-
fects the welfare of the personnel of its Armed
Forces, and the Judge Advocate’ Generals of the . ‘
Army and the Air Foreé and-the General € ‘ounsel: - ee
of thie Navy have requested the Solicitor Genertt§——~ “5
&to urge this € ‘ourt to review the décision of the !
Supreme ourt of N Nebraska. F urthe T, the case is
important fo many of the states since it concérns
the proper scope and administration of their :
taxing laws. |
$63148-—55 (1). MR ; wane.
. . “i 2 . » i M
.< ‘ ; -. ; ‘ :
H 3 . P :
$ - .
e
nthe Spree our sf the Wied States :
—OcroBper Ten, 1955
No, 404
OrruTr Hovsing Company. A Corporation, PETE
TIONER . ea
oa
©
COUNTY OF SARVY AND Ropert M: Epy, TRE ASURE Re.
THE COUNTY OF SARPY, NEBRASKA
ON WRIT OF CERTICRARL TO THE SUPREME: COURT OF:
NEBRASKA
MEMORANDUM FOR THE UNITED STATES as AMICUS
CURIAE
The Government shares petitione r’s view that
neither the language, purpose nor legislative his-
‘tory of the Act of August. 8, 1949, ©. 408, 63 Stat.
970, known as the Vo oerry Ayt ; “aid loses a Con
gressional_purpose ‘Lo pe rit state or loc al taxation
of military. housing ‘projects constructed pon
federal enclaves. It likewise agrees that, even
assuming, as respondents urge, that Congress ‘con-.
sented to the taxation of the lessee’s interest in
such projects, the attempt at taxation made in this
: : as <7 vee
Qype pic eolh
;
e :
;
:
“2
ease ix void in that i exceeded. the ¢ Siesesishienal
raiver by imposing taxes measured by the full’
value of Government-owned property.- It is not
the pur aed of this memorandum to repe: tin detail
petitione r’s able and comprehensive diset ussion ‘and
analysis of these i issues, but merely to outline the
re; ASOns die ‘tating the Gov ernment’ s position. :
1, The avowed purpose. of the Wherry Act to
provide clean, adequate and iner pensive housing to
encourage skilled military personnel to remain.
in the armed forces! makes it ‘unlikely that Con- |
' The. legislative history makes it indisputably clear that
the prime: purpose of the Wherry Act was te help servicemen -
obtain low-rent housing within their means. — See I. Rept.
No. 854, 81st ¢ ‘ong.,. Ist Sess., pp. 2, 5 (“the achievement of
‘lower rentals for .the -personnel of the establishment’). 3.
Rept. No. 410, 81st Cong:, Ist Sess., pp. 4-5 (“housing at:
rents within the means -of- as many enlisted ‘persenne ancl
-. junier officers as possible”). ome
"The Aet was passed hecause the armed services need large
humbers of technicians and skilled personnel who have had
many years of technical training. These persons cannot be
replaced on short notice andthe Government ‘seeks to offer
every inducement that will insure the retention of their serv-
ices. One of these inducements is to make good. housing
available om or -agjacent to military installations. To serve
‘the purpose of attracting and retaining the’services of these
persons, the housing must:not only be good, it must alse be
modest in cost. ° . .
The Act attempted fo keep the cost and rentals of the
*. housing projects at a minimum. This, was done by making
‘ available government guaranteed loans, by the eliminaiion
of land and. acqiisition costs through the use of ereremnent
"lands, by restricting the investment in the individual -unit, and
by close supery isign and control of operating costs, profits and ra
rents,
See the Appendix, infra, ps9, for a statistical summary of
the. Air Force’s Wherry Act. projects (supplied by the Air
Force). | : ; Mad .
a a
—*
The basic purpose of the Act of August 8, 1949,
c, 402, 63 Stat . 570, commonly eatled thie ~ Wherry
Act,’ was to provide cleari, comfortable and ade-
quate housing fgr military ; ,personnel and their
families at rentals within their limited. Jeans: aya
The Armed Services need large numbers of tee hni-
Clams and skilled personnel who have had- many oa
‘years of technical training. These persons cannot
be replaced on short notice and the Government
— seeks to offer every inducement’ that .will insure ©
the retention of their services. Oné of these
‘inducements is to make good housing available on
or adjacent to military installations. To serve |
the purpose of att ‘acting and retaining the serv- ”:
~° ices of these persons, the housing must not only
be good, it must also be modest in cost. :
The Wherry Act t-attem| ed to keep the cost and
rentals of the housing projects at a minimum.
ate This was done by making available governinent.
guaranteed loans, by the elimination of land and
re acquisition costs through the use of government
lands, by” restricting the investment in, the indi-
- vidual unit, and by close supe rvision and chive
—_—_—
—_
-* A 7 « =.
of operating: costs, * profits anid rents.<— *
The issue in this ease involves the authority
of local: ‘taxing units to impose ad valorem taxes,
rae ~ where the housing project is located ona uilitaay
rese rvation over which the United Statés CYEVCISES |
=. exe lusive teg islative jur isiction. § 1 lie COMLt Dde-
low has held that the Wherry. Act, by incoxborat-
ing by reference a part of the Act of August 5,
~
3
1947, ¢.. 493, 61 Stat. 774, commonly referred to
as the * Military Leasing Act”, constituted Con-
vressional consent to the exereise of jurisdiction -
by the local taxing authorities. |
‘Tf, as we believe, the court below was wrong
in cone ‘duding that Congress had rectded jurisdie-
tion so as to permit the taxing of property located |
Within a, fede ral enclave, it is. clear that the sov-
ereign jurisdiction. of the United States has been
invaded. And, to the extent that-such taxes have
~~~ been imposed on property belonging to the United
States, it is clear that the sovereign immunity. of
the United States has been violated. Further, to
the extent that these housing projects are. ur-
dened by local taxes, the burden of the tax will be
reflected in increased rentals paid by the military
personnel, thus tending, to. defeat one of the
.purposes of the W herry Act. 3
The dispute in this case is not al. isolated one.
As petitioner has peinted out, military housing
“has been erected and is being ope ‘rated in many
__jitrindietione Hider eireumstane es substantially
the same as those here involved. W ith i increasing :
frequeney, local “authorities are. ASSESSING ad
valorem taxes on like properties located within
_/ other areas over cwhich the United States asserts
the right .to-“exere ise exclusive Jegisia lon, And,
ity ns Uy Cases, local authorities are as OSIM mile -
tary housing prope rties in the same. manner and
~
ee,
‘to the same extent as though the projects were
~ gress would have departed from its established
practice of ~~ to lacal taxation on federal
enclaves only in. the clearest and most. explicit
terms. On i ec if Congress had intended -
to authorize local taxation within a federal en- ~
. clave, taxation whic ‘ might reasonably have heex
expected to hamper one of the pr incipa) objectives
of the legislation by forging rental increases to
cover increased costs; it would have done so in the
plainest language. possible and would not ave
permitted “such an import ant matter of E jurisdie-
- tien to rest on: elaborate implication. . th is"
i Neither, of the pmovisions of fhe- W herr y “Act
relied upon by respondents as ‘showing Congres-
sional] consent can be deseribed as a clear waiver of.
. federal immunity to state taxation. Section 805 _
of the Act (12 U.S.C, 1748d), on: which the court
helow relied, does not in terms mention state tax-
ation. Respondents’ argument and the decision
below justify their conelusion by drawing upon the —
referetice in Section 805 to the Act of August 5,
1947, -¢. 493, 61 Stat. T74,.ecommonly called the
Military Leasing Act. Section. F of the Leasing
Ace (5.0.8.C.. 6265-6) contains angong its provi-
sions the following: “*T he lessee 's interest, made
or created. pursuant to the provisions of this.Act,
shall be made stibjec ‘ft to State or local taxation.”’
_ However, as. petitioner's s brief points out’ in detail
_ (pp. 23-35)! there are no compelling re: isons ‘to
nuike either of the suppositions vital to ‘respond
ents” position- —that the Wherry Act reference to
the Leasing Act was intended to incorporate this
ates 6: . cheers ie
owned, not by the United States, but by the |
lessees: tte oe: BY . ae i
: It is also. a master of obvious importance | to -
the many states. in which these projects are located
that this Court should settle the question whether
Congress has granted. them the - jurisdiction to
impose such ad valorem taxes. Until, there has
been a definitive decision, which only this Oourt
‘an render, the local taxing authorities . will be -
confronted with serious difficulties in. deciding
whether to collect these taxes and in. determining
what to.do with the tax proceeds senate a final
err _tesoluution of the basic issue. .
We think that the lower court erred i in, conelud-
‘ing that Corigress intended to regede to: the states”
and local authorities jurisdiction to tax real prop-
erty within a federal area. Such a retrocession, |
being in devogation of the sovereign’s powers,
should be found only where Congress has.spoken
inf the clearest language; it should not rest on
implication. .The Wherry Act, in referring.to the
Leasing Act, ‘did not clearly indicate that consent
Sano _ was being granted to tax any interest in real |
property where the property ts located in a ‘fed-
éral enclave, if, indeed,.consent to taxation any-
where was . being eranted. Moreover, the ,leg- see
islatiye history, of the W herry and Leasing Acts
Pe eee ould indicate that C ONTESS, undoubtedly did not
er intend that: housing projects being erected on
military instaHations should be subject .to: local
Wo i eer
~
. 4
. a ° e
O_O — — —————
federal enclave.
‘Section 805 of the W hetty Act authorizes each’
~ best serve the national interest: without regard to .
the limitations imposed by’ said Act in respect to.
- the term or duration of the lease ** *’’,, Both the -
“ authgrity to-lease and the Hmitations{mposed with” TEE
respect to the duration of the leaseS-appear in
‘Section 1 of the Leasing Act (5 U.S.C. 626s), Ac-
sentence of Séction 6 -of the Leasing Act, or that -
the.sentence when originally inserted in the Leas-
ing Act was intended by Congress as a consent to
taxa léssee’s interest in property located upon a
~
Secretary of, the Armed ‘Forces to make. leases
‘‘ander the authority of said [Leasing] Act’ upon
such terms and conditions as in his opinion will
cordingly, there is no reason to attribute to"Con-
‘gress an intent to incorporate more of the Leasing
“
Act than the provisions of that section. Nothing
in the language of Section 805 requires ‘that the
balance of the Act be incorporated, and Sections
2 through 5 are clearly_and indisputi ably inappli- |
cabte in the context of the Wherry Ac t. There is
‘certainly no ground for, believing that. thére® was
a special purpose to single out Section 6 of the Leas-
‘ing Act for incorporation.
\
Moreoyer, there is ample room to doubt. Whether
even in the Leasing Act. the controversial : sentence —
of Section 6 was intended: to apply to interests in
property located upon federal ‘enclaves. The pre-
“Mision does not so deélare in ‘terms, No statement
in the legislative history: of the Leasing Aet reveals
such an aim. The purpose of’the Act—to utilize
¥-]
e
D
°
for private enterprise Government-owned manu- _
facturing facilities temporarily surplus to the needs:
of armed ferces; and’ normally l6cated outsi le
federal enc ‘lav es—iloes not require that construc-
_tion. Under these circumstances there is no: war-
raut for assuming. that Congress was re eceding. to
athe states jurisdiction: formerly exclusive to the .
United States. | °
Section 807-o0f the Wherry Act wer) U.S. C, 17488)
_ is the only section of that Act ‘which mentions
. taxation — tly. sut, as the corrt. below conc eded
(R.-199), it-cannot be interpreted as authorizing
the taxes sam by respondenfs in this Gase. The |
-section provides: Nothing in this title shall be.
__ construed to exempt-any real pr operty, acquired and
- held by the [ Federal Housing ] Commissioner under
tltis title from’ taxation by any State or political
ik subdivision thereof, to the s same extent, according
to its value, as other reé ul property is taxed. Phe
section has no application ‘to this case, not only
because the Offutt project was not held or acquired
by the Commissioner, but also bee ‘ause the provi- 4
sion is only negative in oper ation. It prevents .
praperty from becoming non- taxable under certain
‘circumstances, but does not waive existing im-
-munitiés, such as that enjoyed hy property loc ated
upon federal enclaves,
2. Even if Cong ress ‘uiended. by its reference
to the ] easing: Act. in. the Wherry Act’ to subject to
—loeal taxation the lessee’s interest in property
located upon federal enclaves, the taxes imposed
by respondents are invalid in that they exceed the
ae Ce
,
*
ad a
Finally, @ éven if’ it is. cone luded ‘that Congress |
' did intend to grant to’ the states jurisdic tion re a
- tax, the court below plainly disregarded the limi-.
tations i the Statutes whieh it thought, eranted .
" the retrocession. That is, if Congress did recede
tax jurisdiction, it Clearly ‘limited ‘its consent to
the taxing of the. interest of the lessee and did
not consent to the taxation of the property owned ©
_ by the United States as lessor... The court be low,
lidwever, did not limit.its deci cision in this manner,
It upheld the assessment even though there was
no. effort to segregate Offutt ‘Housing Corpany” s
interest and ‘tax only. that inte rest; the. full value
of the property, including the. whole ownership
"interest, as. well as. whatever value proper ap-
‘praisal might attribute ‘to’ the leasehold, was. in-
cluded in Offutt Housing: ‘Company’ s assessment. |
“i United States v. Allegheny County, 322U.8.. Av,
187, shows that such a conclusion: is wrong.
: Respectfully subinitted. | ae
- Spo E. _ SORELOFF, Sa
3: Solicitor Gi ne ral, ‘
Levy g A.- Brian Hounann, ' nee
. Sis tHe ae Asistaut Altornetp General...
| ELiis No SLAck, | :*
— Hinpere DP. Zarny,
2 Erwin A, GOLDSTEIN, -
: : Lyk M. TURNER, :
Be SA tee, oe. |. Attorneys.
Octoper'1955.. - i ithe She
cf
ras
oe ° i °
U SS GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1988.
a
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.