Transcript of Record — Offutt Housing Co. v. County of Sarpy
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
- & : ; : , ae ‘ a3 tai <
| be : -} SRARY
SUPREME ¢ PONERY, u o
_ TRANSCRIPT. OF RECORD
y, :
‘Supreme Court of the United States. 2 |
See OCTOBER TERM, 1955
ete : = rG 404 :
, BB : : “e 2" aes
GX, : “
te LS te : ‘
a «2 4
: TEND % =
Ss ae
“OFFUTT HOUSING COMPANY, A ‘CORPORATION, pee
- PETITIONER,
COUNTY OF SARPY AND. ROBERT M. EBY, TREAS.-
URER VE COUNTY, OF SARPY, , NEBRASKA
; . YS 3
: ‘ See 4 :
5 id ° ? . . ae eS S
=: ~ SST . = ‘ ‘oe os PY ee
“
on WRIT OF CERTIORARL TO THE SUKREME COUR’ OF ‘THE STATE
: OF NEBRASKA
—
= 2 oe} > : .
— a3 3 4 2
"PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 17, 1955
| CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER R it 1965
SUPREME couRT OF THE UNITED STATES :
°
OCTOBER TERM, 1955,
ote
F *, . . ‘ - : :
= 23 ;
: os . . oe
OFFUTT HOUSING COMPANY, he -Somegmarice,
AN ae ‘PETITIONER,
7 vs.
| COUNTY. OF SARPY AND ROBERT M. -EBY,. ‘TREAS-
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE.
- Se Original | Print,
Record fiom the District Court of Sarpy ‘County, Ne- Seek
Weadhag ee Re Se ee ig woke.
_. Amended and supplemental petition ‘for declaratory : ;
pe eS SBR rst © Pamee Pee feed Orta We ee ee Boo eS
. _apClerk’s note re exhibits 02.0.2. aes were ad iS Ape ete. &
_ Answer of of Robert M: Eby............-. shes =. oe
Amended answer of County of Sarpy reg ana pepe 26 10-
Plaintiff's reply to amended answer of: defendant, aoe
County of Sarpy. ..... FET OE A vee oS TRAE Speiak 362 2. 97-..
_ Judgment: and’ decree .:.,......° 3 *. Borvisbae is ae fee
' Exeerpts from bill of exceptions. , by $5 64 Se
Judge’s certificate: to bill of exceptions. . . 64 aT:
ae | ee eee eye Or erey eee fh Goose see
= Napa of William R. Goodall, Jr. ee rsh. » Seeeee |e
<< : BB RE se i ges ie so | 88 37
Herbert S. Weisfield . Fepks paste ee 146 65 |
Jupp & Derweiter-(Inc.), Paw ters, Wasnineton, D. C., Jan. 30, 1946
—
3 _URER ak COUNTY OF SARPY, NEBRASKA
¢ Bhi a}
°.
= wv
.?
OF ERBAGEA ny
s oe
bcasirg
Qe es INDEX.
°
a
INDEX —
ly
Record frets “the Distriet Conrt’ of Sarpy County, Ne- =
braska—Continued >
. Exeerpts from bill of exceptions —Contined e
. _ Testimony of—Contipued S Original |
se -s °. Ralph C. Mason... - ~- 180
: Cee, Wilde | ..c oe. 208
George Nicholson. -.........-. 245
Ernest Nielsen Caieveev ya cawks 3 ere
* Exhibits: BAe SSR Ot
1—Stipulation of. ee 265.
= ” 2A—Tetters “Gated“kprii 21, 1943, June
17, 1942 and November 13, 1942’ 42° front Stes
2-Letter dated’ September 7, 1950 from
Harold C. Stuart, Office” of the Assist-
ant Secretary to, Governor of We
= NR eos eee
‘Henry L. Stimson, Secretary of War.
~ to Governor of Nebraska with return
i POCRUPE e e ;
3—Certification of Need for Military Hons-
ing, ‘dated January 15, 1951.
4—Department of the Air Force Lease for - :
. + Private Housing dated’ January 18, .
1951 and County Clerk’s certification .
' § & 6—Business and Professional Assessment -
schedules 1952 and 1953.
_ 7—Letter dated April 13, 1953 from Rob- |
ert M. Eby to Manufactuers’ Trust
re eas ae Unc re ga meena ak Bis i
_8—Articles of Incorporation of Offutt Hous-
- ing Company of Omaha, Nebraska with
: ss
certificate” of Secretary of “State of i
ee Ns Rete Sets pa ienma eeneD
- 12—Administrative hie and Regulations
for Military Housing Insurance under
“Title VIII of the National Housing ~
= Act—Revised-September 4, 1951... .. :
13-4 ederal Housing Administration—Proj-
ect Analysis Sait + Sig KE pale eis 486
-14— Offutt Housing Company’ 8 Rental Sched-
ule for income producing spate dwell-
ing, dated July 29, 1952.......2....
15—Mortgage dated Febrnary 1, 1951 by and. -
“y '* between Offutt Housing Company and. .
~ Manufacturers’* Trust Company . and.
County Clerk’s certification... -...
16—Limited ‘assignment of rents, dated July
28, 1953 and County enamea certifies-
375,
4820
7
7
= ae _/ wpex SS Ae co
} ‘Meer fom the Dat Ct of Sar Ens,
s+ dated October 21, 1949. :
. {?>: 3 “22—General Motors—Conditional Sale Gén- -
{
ee jas Se ey a ee pa 4us
26, 27, 28 & 29—Clerk’s notes re exhibits. bee
Proceedings i in the a Court of Nebragka.....- iy oS ae
; : % a=
c e * if : Pe —— ; a
> eee no
Be Monae a=
ae a
of Commerce ‘to the ._ United: States 7 ™
See
tract-—Diversified - Financing fees BEE - a0 : 190° |
. 23 & 24—Clerk’s notes re exhibits he eRe 406 191 _
25—Chattel mortgage dated January 21, Ga
193
194 c
TET RET rege ee Petree sata 44 194 ©
* Opinion, Chappell, J. ee ees a nnaere p 44
Order denying motion tor rehearing. RS arent feet. |! o
4
Clerk’s cértifieate...”.. ... orn (omitted in \ printing) 478
Order allowing certiorari ............... este oo pie 479°
Fie > :
<< * . .
° Le : F
*% sche FAS ve
fee A:
c tn oo
' Cr, 3 o~ 8
-@ } *
°o . —_
: . a oy ~
- c °
z -
a2
.
9
z a. !
c
‘oe
; : lz j
‘ a "y
$
\ ae As
* =
va
; :
a] ao
“= co
>
<<
a
> a” => : Se: - ; = . ? ee 2 +S : zZ
_ 9° : ES —= 3
: ‘ as = = ie =. r= = s ay | a - =
aw i ;
~ [ola 1 3] IN THE DISTRICT ec SARPY
cara, COUNTY, NEBRASKA é
= * ‘Doe. U Case Not ‘668% No. 350. : =F
Ty &
“Orrurr Hovstsa- Company; Plaintitt,
; = aa : : — = we vs.
_Oovwry OF Sarpy and I Roverr M. Eni, Pyenaures of County
«Of Sarpy, Nebraska, .Défendants
“AMENDED AND. Sorrcastae: Perrrion FOR ‘Dectafiatony
_Jupemext—Filed June. 17, 1953
SS p
— eimes 1 now the slaintiit 2 a for cause of: action ‘alleges
that: Rae .
3 : :
oe Plaintiff is a Nebraska ‘corporation, with its principal .
place of business: in Cn Douglas County, renrae a, =
eteESS Se peers rs : : = Se ee ee
ts = Deane: ‘the Comity “oF Baipy, hereitiaft@® salir
_, to as «Sarpy County,’’ is a body politic and corporate and
is one of the counties established in the State of Nebraska,
‘and. that the defendant; Robert M. Eby, is.the duly elected,
_ qualified and acting county treasurer - “of the County- of, :
sce le :
| I aoe
This. nihitin is ‘brought under. the: provisions of. the
Declaratory Judgments Act, as provided. for. in Sections _
-25-21,149 to 25-21,164, inclusive, 1943 Revised" Btabates. of
- Nebraska. ; ; cies 7
Air Force assis ‘a / permanent ntieary base of
which Offutt ‘Air Force. Base -is ldeated andy, prior -to
o*° &
poe x?
nited States and is located entirely in Sarpy County, _
Nebraska.. The. Unitéd. States owns adl of the lind on. |
Jangary 1, 1952, the State of Nebraska and ali of ‘the =.
political subdivisions thereof, in accordaace with Sections
72-691 to 72-605, — of the 1943 Revised Statutes. of ae
Fn
= - $ e 3
; : if oe. bli 2 eigen ae
ae : : ee F > : ; oes
f ‘ , - °
wz : f ; et
<
Stas erty on or. within Ruch federal reserve. °
=O :
°
, ? =o ‘ts, Ss Ae : :
ee cae ? z A 2 oe % a; ; a
—= — 3 = o> : - < SSG a . = ah - =
> ee : - ae
° . - ~~ = = . i . .
Wabredkn: shal telling jariediction of all inher: Licinted .
at Offuit Air Force Base, as is shown -by-Exhibit ‘‘A’’ and
- 1"? attached hereto, and made a part of this petition,.
and that at all-times during the year 1952 and: thereafter, ©
" {fol. 4] the State of Nebraska and all political subdivisions _
' thereof have beerpwithout power. or authority to tax prop-,
: : Bern |
Se ee a See as
“yeas 8 of ‘Article I of the Constitution. of the United
States grants t tovthe United States ‘exclusive taxing. ‘juris-
_ - -dittion over all property. located at or ayen “Offutt ae
Ge
= = e ae ‘ “> :
* V I = te a
= 2 ae
<
No part of Offutt Air Fores. Baie is. within any: muni- *
cipality or school district «and .no city or school district
. taxes are e involved i in n this action. Lule ares e.
2 ae ee = : = : VII Che = 3 2
= : A = = ‘ a paocmea . & = 3 = -
“On the 15th day of January, 1951, the United States,
_ by. the Dep&rtment of, the: Air’ Force, in accordance «with.
Force’ Base. Jane
~~ the provisions of Section 1748b-(b-2) 21952 “Cumulative”
~ Supplement to 12 U.S.C.A., certified’ Offutt: Air Force
Base as a permanent. United States military establishment,
as is shown by Exhibit ‘‘B”’ attached ss cpeaae and made
a-part-of this pétition.: at
S 3
| VIII en ap
Sees - At all times since. before Januney: 1g, 1951, Offutt Air.
Force Base has been: the property of the United anes Re
= “used - for military Soaiare ; ees
-
a \ ‘TX = : . 2 : ‘ ‘Sa ote
- oN ae :
.*
5s oerdgume with United States Public Law 211-81st :
Congreas (Se¢tions 1748 to 1748-i, 1952 Cumulative Supple-
‘ ment to 12 U.S.C.A.), commonly known as the ‘Wherry _
: Act,” the United States, by the Department of the Air =
_ Force, on January 18, 1951, leased to the plaintiff for a. —
period of seventy-five (75). years; part of the land.en
which Offutt Air Forée Base is located, as a site for rental —
“housing for Offutt Air dase Base personnel, all, as shown ©
c
2 =e ee i o 2 , = ae = ae = : — : 3.
a.” Ss ie ON ae ea = 2s Z
= oo Exhibit ““C’* attached. hereto. as ede a et of. this =
petition. Such ledse was, on. January 31, 1951, recorded
4in, the office of the Register of Deeds. of Sarpy County, -
(fol. 5] Nebraska, in Book 14 of the Miscellaneous Revords 2
Bt page 567, and auet lease | is still i in: = force and. effect ee
ee © ;
“~~
ja Ge ee i Do ere :
}
Between ‘t the ‘ietaa of January a 4951 wad Ji ne > 23, 19685:
- > plaintiff, in accordance with the ay herry | Ae is financed, es
. erected and ‘completed six hundred ‘and eleven (611). rental ~
_ housing units on the: leafed .premises for the -benefit of . .
personnel assigned to ), duty at: Offutt. Air Force Base, as ° -,
9 & part of the Strategic Air Command, of the. Department Ge:
-of the Air Fosce, whose headquarters is at “Offutt Air:
~~ Force Base, and that ij in accordance with. Section 11 of the
hereinbefore referred ‘to lease (Exhibit C), the buildings
“and improvements, upon completion of the -plaintiff, be-
- came a part -of land owned by the United States, and be-:’
~eame property of. the United Pacer, used exclusively for
‘national milithry, purposes, -
a
; = ; “O
= oa +
. on c ¢ - me
a ge = grt te; “EE: o Fe vais = —
rd a: eS + z © - - a _ e ‘
er
"Desig Reg ‘Hise that the land | on which Offuti a
Wore Base.is located was owned by.thé United States and ~
k ‘used exclusively for military purposes, and after the here- ;
. Inbefore referred . to . rental housing improvements were . —
- eomnpleted thereon, and during the time when such rental
- housing units‘and such buildings and improvements were ;
-real property of the United States and not ‘subject to tax- | ~
ation by the State of Nebraska or,anyof its political sub-
— Givisions, the county. assessor.of teféridant coufity, i in ‘the
_ 6rronedus belief that property located-on Offutt Air Force
' Base was subject to taxation in Sarpy County under‘the | -
_ laws of the’ State of Nebraska and that guch buildirigs and
- improverfiénts’ on Offutt Air Force Base- were ‘taxable
-‘property.of the plaintiff located in Sarpy County, Nebraska, :
did, on June 23, 1952, without the consent or: atithority of
the plaintiff or the United. States, execute and return a- _
- purported -1952 personal property schedule of plaintiff’s. -
property taxable in Sarpy County, a copy of such purported -
schedule being attached hereto, marked Exhibit wid 5 ahs -_ :
e Pa ‘
FA 1 . ; ~ ‘
a>
a
.
”
-omade a part Dareot? “Phat urider Schedule F of as pur- |
the County ‘Assessor listed as peysonal property of. the *-
plaintiff taxabte’in- Sarpy County, “Nebraska, property ing
. the total valuation of $69,900.00 and that under Schedule. *.-
= ( = Ae re : a Bee - ae min a :
EAS |
Pe es aes eet a : 3 Ret
’ E >
-— 4
One
{fol. 6} ported: personal property schedule (Exhibit D),
: °I of such purported personal property schedule (Exhibit ®
awe
‘©
: and void and of: no. = an
--D) said county assessor listed as personal property of the -
BS deta taxable in Sarpy Countyy Nebraska;,: “Improve: °
‘nents -on ‘Leased a =e $759,785.00. ea
* se °
. em: ; : *% oe °°
= 3 ‘ : ae : xa ; 3 foe 5
. The attempted. sietidina or. tating of | all, pemes de
_seribed in .the, purported personal property tax schedule
(Exhibit D): as pérsonal property of the’ plaintiff Subject “,
to taxation in Sarpy. County, Nebraska, and-the levying
“of taxes thereon against the Reitect was illegal, *null
reasons :.- . 4.
“A: On March 10, 1952, Tans 23° ‘1952, “anid thereafter:
: the State’ of Nebraska and: its political subdivisions.
, Were without authority to tax property lopated at pe
oo; =
—? for as following :
~ upon Offutt Air Force Base... _ % 3
¢ B. Plaintiff did -not, ‘either’ on‘ March. 10; “4952, on 4
~~. June 23, 1952, or, thereafter, own any srs ddd ccna on = 3
“Teased land in Sarpy County, Nebraska. -
- -C. Seetion 77-1209, -1943 Revised Statut . of Ne-
*braska, under which ‘the defendants. sought te assess
the aforesaid’ imprévements as the: property of: the
plaintiff and to levy taxes thereon against the. plaintiff, ah
requifed . any improvements taxable under such statute
to be assessed to the owner of such improvements and |
that the owner of the improvements was, on June 23,
~, 1952 and thereafter, the United States, whose property — 4
. .is not subject*to taxation by the State of, Nebraska. or
any of its political subdivisions.
D.. The lands on which the improvements were Idcated
E. The aforesaid improvements at Offuk
.
*
. t
a a
iy roy
on
¢
s were not, during ‘ny part of 1952, “public lands’ ~
- [fol..7] within the purview of Section 71209, 1943 CL
Revised. Statutes of Nebraska. | Es oe.
utvA
, \ir Force :
Base were, at the time of the attempted assessment |
“eA 4 ; o- . os
~ a) ‘ ; :
. bere oom Lor : . ee ; ‘ % ‘
‘ n i, " :
2°
A A Be eee Se
2 o° ~
bers meted as personal come of the, plaintiff and there: =
Bs After, real estate and a part of land owned by the United :
| ‘States and were not personal property, 8 eae
F. Offutt Air Force Base. and ‘the improvements ae
thereon constitute property of the ‘United States, used
_ exclusively for-militagy purposes? ant that under. the
laws of ‘the State of Nebraska and.its political subdj- *
' yisions, neither the land on which Offutt ‘Air Force is_
located nor any inferest: therein or any buildings. or
‘improvements theréon are subject to taxes levied by the
State of Nebraska or” SBpy County. a 8
oo
On the iis of wah nanpestad but illegal yGting-s as” per- |
sonal property of: the plaintiff taxable in Sarpy County, ‘~
Nebraska; the ‘property describéd-in the purported ; 51952
- personal property tax schedule ( Exhibit D) asof the “total
valuation of’ $825,685.00, the defendant, County of Sarpy,
-illezally assessed taxes thereon against the plaintiff in the
-- amount of $10,783.45; that $9,870.55 of such purported tax -
. was the amount, levied and assessed upon the heteinbefore
referred to’ improvements at Offutt Air Forée Ba® based _
upon the erroneous. assumption’ that such improvements at
Offutt Air Force Base wefe personal property of the ‘plain-
__ tiff located in Sarpy County, Nebraska and ‘taxable to the
2 plaintiff. on the basis of the valuation of the same being.
e*$%55,785.00 and that the balance of sajd tax, amounting to.
—® $912.90, was levied and assessed on thé assumption that.
the balance of the property listed in’ such purported per- «
sonal property tax.sehedule (Exhibit D) as the total valua- * ~
tion of $69,900.00 was taxable,in Sarpy County under the
{fol.8] laws of the State of Nebraska.’ The items listed
-, , under Schedule F of. sith purported personal property tax
5° if schedule. (Exhibit D) were, on March 10, 1952 and June 23,
- \1952,.property of the plaintiff located at or upon Offutt Air —
; Force. Ba, but, accord\ng, to the decisions of the courts’
of the United States, this property located on Offutt Air
_ ~ Foree Base i is not subject to: taxation by the State of Ne- -.
.’ .. braska or any political .subdivisions thereof but, ‘however, ”
if sueh ‘property, of the purported assessed valuation of
” 900.00, was, in 1pb2, property assessable and: ‘taxable
a eee ea eo noe,
i . ZA .
1
= -< > * :-“ - - :
: c i : 6 '
4 6 > ¢ s - = < fe :
a5 ; 4 . i tomas te e-
7 : . ae . , patos % z - 2 Z : 3 a
_2 ine Me: Pa ae : ; eo? ae a =,
é 5 ° 3
ene Sarpy County, plaintiff offers to pay this tax ‘inreaa = :
in the: amount°of wa. 90 tod ‘legal i interest. +o os.
©
‘
’
"S
, oe
z = : e F - . : ort
* eo = P a bees ae i 2, : é a Ss Se
ss > e é. $ ; = x ] V ! See Sones | EX . i
- Although the ‘purported 1952 ‘Bary County” tae dee o-
against the plaintiff was illegally levied against the plain-
_ tiff, and although the1952 Sarpy Couaty levy of personal
. “property taxes against the plaintiff-is invalid, illegal, nut,»
and yoid and:of no effect, the defendant, the County of
Safpy,. contends that . all property ‘desctibed in the pur- ; 4
ported 1952 personal property. tax- schedule (Exhibit D)
was verdonal property of the *plaintiff which was legally
assessed as personal property“of the plafntiff located in
Sarpy County and legally taxable therein and further con--
tends that the entire “tax levy of $10; 783.45 is valid. and
"threatens 'to collect the entire tax if the same is not paid.
, Tifat the defendant, Robert. M. Eby, as County Tzeasurer ~~~
“of the County of Sarpy, will attempt to enforce the ied
be tion of said tax if the same is not paid.
- Because of the faets herein alleged, an actual ‘eoisueteies
exists between. ‘the parties to this action and that, under
the provisions of Sections 25-21, 149 to 25-21, 164, 1943 Re-
vised ‘Statutes of Nebraska, and the decisions of the. su-
preme court.of Nebraska, this court. has the power to enter ~~
“a declaratory judgment to settle. the controversy between
the parties on the facts alleged herein. The controversy |
, between between the parties has not been’ the subject to any
-._ [fo 9] _ suit; decision or judgment heretofore. Plaintiff has -.
- no-remedy at law and that a declaratory judgment herein -
wil speedily. and ey settle the eben 4 between
. the e Parties.
: Wherefore, plaintiff. prays: that. this court enter a de- 3
_ ¢laratory- judgment, asap eee and adjudging
that:
cs ‘ eee Offutt Air Piecs Base is séeuubiy reenrved i or’ ac- =
© quired and used by the vane States for military puy- |
‘poses.
°B. The Gtate of Nebraska aid its * political gubdi-_
PON city hee pa :
©e, . en - ‘
‘ ; . ° o
= e < 3 ° * .
co
Meg”
- wistons were, ‘in 1952; and teesithet: ‘withoet power
or authority.to tax property located at. or upon Offutt.
_. Air Force Base, ©
C: Offutt Air Foree Base, the land on: » which: it: is 5 is.
- cated and rental | housing: improvements thereon were, ~
con June 23, 1952 gad ai all‘times théreafter, property
_ of the United States, not subject to taxation Wy the
State of Nebraska or Sarpy County.. ~~
PD. On June. 23, 1952 and at all tintes. theretifie,
ze, rental housing improverhents on Offutt Air Force Base
‘was real estate and not personal property and was a>
-- part of theland on vn Offutt Air Force Base i is lo-
gated. -
“cated waenot during any ead during 1988: a part of
~ public lands.
_F. The - ictal 1952 assessment of: ‘“tepeeve-
-:’ ments -on Leased Lands . . . $755 1785-00" as personal
_ property of the. plaintiff was illegal, nul} and void and
of no effect.
. -G. The purported 1952. levy. of taxes against. ‘in:
plainti fad the defendant on improvements on leased
land o purported value, of $755, 185. 00 was illegal,
. null and ee and of no effect:
-__H. The purported 1952 assessmént of paar listed
in Schedule F of the purported persona! property tax.
A schedule as property subject te taxation in Sarpy
‘County under the laws of the State of: Nebraska, was:
illegal, null and void and of no effect.
a J
a 1. 7.
°
‘I. The property of the p Jaty tiff located: 6 on Offutt Air "
[fol 10] Force Base, t Furniture ard fixtures—
tools and equipment- household appliances, ocated on
Offutt Air Force Base (as shown in Schedule F of ..
Exhibit D) was not subject to taxation in Sarpy County,
in 1952. ,
(es a purported. 1952 levy" of taxes: against - the”
plaintiff on the property listed in Schedule F of the
purported personal property tax manent was illegal,»
“~ hull and void: and of no effect. .
_ KK. The purported. personal sranaity tox Schedule
- made. by the county assessor of Sarpy’County showing -
sain: Jie gs of ta — — to taxation in .
¥°.
._ EK. The land on which’ Offutt Air Foree ‘tens is lo- < ..
Po ee
: gerne County sie the laws of the State of Nebraska =
_be cérrected to eliminate therefrom improvements on. .
3 _, leased land ofthe Valuation of $755,785.00. - :
So Se Ee purported. personal property tax. schedule = ©
'- made by the county assessor of Sarpy County showing ~
personal property of the plaintiff subject to taxation in ~~
‘Sarpy © County under the laws of the-State of Nebraska ..
| > be corrected to. eliminate therefrom: property listed in
aia Schedule F thereof. 7
“-. “ M. "Phe defendant, Robert, M: Eby, as Teeieuret: of
es Sarpy County, and the defendant, County of Sarpy, its = 7
'. Officers and agents, be temporarily and permanently en-. 4
. joined from including any rental housing‘ improve-.
- ments on Off ytt. Air Force Base as personal property —
of the plaintiff | in Sarpy County and from. levying any
_. tax against the plaintiff cov ering such improvements on
- Offutt Air’ Foree Base and from enforcing any tax..
‘against the plaintiff on improvements at Offue Air
s Force Base. - ~
_'N. The defendant; Bokart M. Eby, as gh tavde of ff
Sarpy County, and the defendant, County of Sarpy, its > °
_ officers and agents, be temporarily and ermanently. en-
joined from taxing furniture and fix ures—toois and |
equipment or household appliances. locatéd at or on |
[fols. 11-24] Offutt Air Force Base and from eres i
* any tax thereon’ against the plaintiff. “
fpr, * Other and further relief as’ may be just and equi:
table...
- Offutt Housing Gaps: GorpoPatiée, By 8.)
_ Charles S. Reed, Its Attéiney. :
ON, Beriacs : ee : 3
beeen to by Carl €. Wileon. Jurat omitted in print-
: ge ;
Jules 0. ‘Hendricks, & reciilent of: Sarpy Cony, Ne-
‘wna and the owner of property liable to execygion-therein, |
. hereby enters his REPAErente « as surety for cost in the above so
- entitled action: .
: pa tS Jules O. Hendricks:
[File endorsement omitted. } SL eae one
4
;
- . . te & ° .
. bs \ : . °
< 4 . ~ ‘
eh . ° . - - be i s .
: j ‘ . ‘J P
? ‘ oo ar Dt 4 fee . pon? .
® z : ‘> “6 Dodd a BES FO
’
:
“Bxhibits A, A. 1,.B; C wilt D. ual: o 5 “tte sonitadal.
having also. been introduced i in evidence at:trial as Exhibits
2, 2-A, 3, 4 and 5, respectively, are, to the extent ghat they -
| are -pertin t, printed with the Trial exhibits and accord :
— are 0 not printed a at this eae SA ee ees was
: pel o
~ [fol. 25) Is 1 THE DISTRICT Cover OF Sarpy Coun er,
x ee NEBRASKA ; : a
[Title omitted] _
‘thes OF RoBert M. ‘Epy ;
Comes now the defendant, Roserr M. Epy, Treienuber: of -
the County of Sarpy, Nebraska, and for answer to thg plain-
~ tiff’s Amended and — Petition for Declaratory -
ug so sir alleges: Y
:. :
‘The defendant admits Paragr sph. I of the plainti’s S
_ Amended afd ghee) petition. |
wee : ae
The defendant’ further: denies each and. every s-allegation “eH 9
‘contained in. the plaintiff’s Amended and Supplemental - ea
= —— not hereinbefore, admitted.
. ~ Wherefore, the defendant prays that” the: plaitit s peti
tion may be dismisséd at its. costs. af.
Robert M. Eby, Treasurer of County -of Sarpy, Ne-
braska, ~Defendant. de (S.) Orville ene. °
his Attorney. >... um 3
: : .
Vee “ 4% ae eee is wad &
Duly sworn to byRobert M. Eby. Jurat omited in print-, .
WA ee | Ae ee
10
. [fol 26) Sea THE Disraict Court OF Sarpy Counry, oo a f
3 - ” NeprasKa, 2 | : : :
“= ete [Title omitted) ie Ror : =
ae ‘Ascuivap An@wer | OF County 08 Sanpy—Filed datuary 1, 7
SEs poi . | .
eo ee ke =
iy
Comes now the defendarit; County: of Sarpy, ahd for i
answer: to the smut S pAtition filed herein states: oS
: = »
Defendant admits ‘Panietink II of the plaintiff’s petition, © '
_.that the defendant, County of - Sarpy, is ‘a body politic and °. F =
corporate and that Robert M: Eby is the duly elected, quali; & -
fied and — erty ae of the County of Sarpy.
sae “Ir. ay bate a e.
The defendant admits that @ffutt Air. Force Base is a _
“permanent military base of the United States and is located
ney? in oer Comat N eee Sie
= "
o- ¢ :
; 1
: The delewiank. allogée that on the 18th day of elobes,: :
* 1949 Charles S. James, single, by warranty deed reciting
~ : $1.00 arid other. valuable consideration, with $18.70 revenue
stamps attached thereto, cogyveyed to the Omaha Chamber of ©
Commerce 47.86 acres more or less as follows, to-wit‘ .-§
a Commencing at @ point 6.75 chains past, of the seals
- west corner of the SE14 of said’Séction 35, thence north: *
. 1150 feet, thence east 2644.0%4ect to a point 65 feet”
northo the northeast corner of Lof 6b, thence south -
~ ‘:65feet, thence west 290 feet along the north line of 6h;
ee: eflitinee’ ‘south 360 feet, thence west, 885 feet, thence south
a 725 feet toythe south line of. Section 35; thence west
1469.05 feet.to the place of beginning’ all in Section 36,
Township 14, Range 13 in ase dead madi « Sarpy, Ne. |
, braska, cae eet he
ae (ee eee ee See
Z | ae aa ae, ae ees 7 i ee Re) OR ,
‘[fol. 27] said deed filed October 20, 1949 in. Deed Record _
Book No: 67 at Page 415 in the Register of Deed*s-office -
. in the County of Sarpy,*Nebraska. — ae eae
-The defendant: further alleges that on or about the 21st
) — day of October, 1949 the.Omaha Chamberef Commerce, a
| Corporation, by warranty deed reciting $1.00 and other —
valuable consideration, and no revenue stamps. attached,
- eonveyed to the United States of America said tract of
* land described in Paragaph Lil hereof, said deed being: -
filed April 12, 1950 and recorded in Deed Record. Book No-
67 at Page 537 in The Register of Deed’s office in the
“Countyyof Sarpy, Nebraska. © -- = :
= .That on or-about the 8th day of August, 1949*the 8ist.
Congress of the United States enacted Publie Law No..211
* -amending the. Act of August 5, 1947 (10°U, S. C. 1270)
- knowmas the ‘‘Wherry Housing Act.’’ Section 806 «2 said
lay, as amended, provided and gtanted authority to the ..
: Seeretary of the Air Force, when determined desirable to ~
lease property of the United States of America upon such ©
terms and conditions witbout regard to limitations imposed
by-said Act in respect tb term or duration and further pro- oe
vided that the power vested in the Secretary of the De- - ||
“ partment to revoke any lease made pursuant thereto in the
event of a national emergency shall not apply; and further
- provided that the Secretary of the Air Force is authorized —
' to.sell, transfer and convey, at fair value, as determined
_ by him for use under this title, any right, title, or interest
4 -in any real property under his jurisdiction, notwithstand- _
| © ing any limitations or requirements of the law with respect —
to use or digposition.of such property. Said Act further |
provided in’Section 807 thereof ‘that . kos S
‘.- .. [fol. 28] ‘Nothing in this title shall be construed to. |
exempt any real property. acquired or held by the -
| Commissioner under-ithis title from taxation by any -’ .
- State or political subdivision thereof, to the same ex-
tent according to its value as othér real property is /
taxed.”? ‘ a ki ss bee a 3 : .
o
< :
. nt A :
ye ye | > Teale trea Ti mel itr hd OF LP Stared AP aT att ST
Rea a
. family dwelling consisting 6f 611: ‘units. That the above
The defendant further allege® that on or about the 18th’ |
_ day of Jayuary, 1951 the Secretary of the Air Force and
Offutt Housing Company, a Corporation organized and - .
existing under the laws of the State of Nebraska, with its © |
principal place of business at 918 City National Bank Build: : . |
, - ing, Omaha, Nebraska, in accordance with Title VIII. of
" - ‘said Act of Congress of August $ 1949, entered intio an |
- agreemegt for the-leasing-of the above described property —
and other to the Offutt Housing Corporation, said instru- .
ment filed the 31st day of January,-1951 and recorded in |
Miscellaneous Record No. 14 at Page 567 in the Register‘of — |
Deed’s office in the County of Sarpy, State of N ebraska. --
_ . The defendant further alleges that the above said alleged
lease provided for thg consideration of the sum of $100.00
per annum for a term of 75-years for the use of approxi-
mately 63.05:acres of unimproved real estate for the pur-
et erecting, maintaining and. operating a. multiple
set out lease further provided that said lease would be:
subject to termination only in the event that said lessee |
_ failed to complete said improvements in whole or in‘part, |
or failed to apply for mortgage insurance to the Commis- 7
sioner of the Federal Housing Administration or upon . {
the refusal of issuance of said insurance, or in the event
that the above ‘rental consideratiom be: not paid; that said
-lease further provided that upon thé:exercise of a right
to terminate said lease in accordance’ with Condition 1. .
thereof, the government may at -once re-enter the lease
‘premises and repossess itself thereof and.remove all per-
[fol. 29] sons.therefrom, or may, resort to any. summary
_ avtion to fecover the same and that notice of termination ~~
must be given to any lessee, Commissioner and the pro-
posed mortgagee, if any, as set out in:Paragraph 9, Con-.-
3 ditions Nos. 2 andol7 of said lease, —~
' Defendant further alleges ‘that Conditions 7 and 8 of
said Tease Provide that the lessee, Offutt Housing Com- |
4
a
pany, agrees to comply with. all laws, ordinances and regu- - >
lations applicable to Une leased area with regard -to-eone
| struction, sanitation, leases or permits to do business and ~
$. other matters. That the defendant further agrees to pay —
all taxes-and assessments that may be taxed, assesged or |
imposed. upon the government or upon the lessee with ©
‘respect to or upon the leased premises; that said lease
further provides in Condition 8 thereof as follows, to-wit:
7
“Til ‘the event any taxes, assessment or similar.
charges are imposed with the consent of Congress
.. of the United States upon the property owned by. -
-. the goyernment and included in thig lease (as opposed
- to. the leasehold interest of. the lessee: therein) this
lease shall. be renegotiated so as to accomplish an |
equitable . reduction in the rental provided’ above
.: 6 2-93 = set
- * The defendant further, alleges that said lease provides
in Condition 20 thereof that the lessee at its own cost and
expense, insure against fire the buildings. that ‘may be.
erected hereinafter on said-leased premises, payable to
the lessee and security holder as their respective interests.
' appear. Determination by either party not to: re-build in ~
ease of complete destruction of any, one or more of the -
buildings shall be binding on both partiés of this lease |
and said lease be re-negotiated in accordance therewith. —
- That on or about the 6th day of February, Y951 there.
. was filed in. Book-1 of Plats at page 9§ in the Register
+ fol. 30] of Deed’s office of the County of Sarpy, ‘Nebraska,
-* a purported@ijjan designated ‘‘Rental ‘Housing Project
' ~ Offutt Ait Force Base’’ showing streets, avenues, alleys —“—
and locatiOi- of proposed rental units‘all as shown by
Exhibit “*A’’ attached herete-and miade a part hereof and
attached ‘to this answer. & Serie eo
The defendant further alleges that’on or about the Ist
day of February, 1951 plaifftiff, Offutt Housing Company,
a private corporation organized and. existing under the
aloud?
corporation therein: ~.
fy eae Soe :
1-16-52" Feneral Motor Acceptance | an ec : eee ae =
Corporation, appliances. . 17,228.
1-16-52 CES gs eT Cie, SEs appliances - 16 ,226 00
1- 2. —Firsr Nat. Bank of Omaha — ‘gas dryers 8,701.86
1- Me OED aay) * -, refrigerators - 32,735.50
2-21-52 - Géneral Motors Accept. Corp. furniture ‘- * 15,638.00
3-24-52 Major Appliance Company _ ranges,
Z ‘ of refrigerators teres
2 eae. washers — a , 294.00
4-3--52 First National Bank =, dryers ss , 762. 48
4-3-5 First National Bank _ . refrigerators — ,333 . 66
4-21-52 dryers ; 447 63
tracts filed in the office of the County Clerk
_ . of Sarpy, Nebraska, as follows, to-wit ee
ee
Ds Sega 6 i 2 ees, fe
The . plaintiff -further alleges that 611 nits were con-
. structed on the above described property; that said units -
were constructed by Carl C. Wilson, Ine:; that-Carl C.
Wilson, President, Offutt Housing Company herein, is one:
‘and the sameperson as, Carl C. Wilson, President of Carl
" €. Wilson, Ine. SSR ei hae B re mes
| XI
The defendant further alleges that Offutt Housing Com-.
pany purchased and caused to be delivered, household.
appliances consisting of refrigerators, electric’ ranges,
[fol. 31] washers. and dryers and that the plaintiff, Offutt. —
Housing Corporation, entered into conditional sales con-
of the County
- . | Fifet National Bank
: 15 ae
That on the 10th day of March, 1952 said construction —
was approximately 75% complete ; that the Assessor of the | -
County of Sarpy, Nebraska, on ér about the 23rd of June,
~ 4952, assessed the interest of’ the yilaintiff in and to said
_ nits’ at. $755,785.00; that said assessor further assggsed |
the plaintiff for household applWiapes at $69,695.00, and'that © _
said assessor further assessed the plaintiff for office furni-
ture and fixtures at $205.00, all as personal property of the
plaintiff ; that pursuant to law, levies were set and taxes
figured on said valuations; that said tax. becaine due and
payable on the Ist. of November, 1952, of which one-half:
_ thereof became delinquent onthe tst-or , 1952 an
- the second half on the 1st of July, 1953; that no part of said* ©
taxes levied thereon have been paid and thiat.said taxes are -
*. .now delinquent and unpaid.
That on or about the 26th day of July, 1953 an agreement
was entered into between-Douglas County: Bank of Omaha,
‘Nebraska, a Corporation and the plaintiff, Offutt Housing —
’ - .Company, a Nebraska corporation, and Carl C. Wilson, Inc,
. « [fol. 32] a Nebraska corparation, wherein it-is stated that —
Offutt Housing Company is the owner of 611 housing units
located at Offutt Field, Sarpy. County, Nebraska, con-
~ structed by it under, the provisions of the Wherry Act with
* said real estate being subject to an F.H.A.' mortgage held
“by the Manufacturers’ Trust Company of New. York, said
agreement providing for the assignment of rents for the -
payment of $28,771.56, the payment due the ist of July, -
1953 on said mortgage note, said mortgage ‘note having
_ provided for the. payment of interest and principal on the"
Ist day of July, 1952 in the amount of $22,683.37; said agree- |
* ment bfing recorded on the 12th day of August, 1953 and °
recorded in Miscellaneous Record No. 16 at page 277 in the
office of the Register of Deeds of the County of Sarpy,
- Nebraska.. 8, : * z ' ee Ee ss co fe
| SE SS er
The deferidant further alleges that the plaintiff, Offutt ee
‘Housing Corporation and the persens eceupying seid
MG.
qnelldite family Seallans. are waited to ‘all the sae
and services of the County of Sarpy and State of Nebr&ska ;
that the plaintiff fd said eceupants are entitled t thé”
. .privileges of using the Courts of the County and’ State;
‘that, as shown by the pleadings herein, the plaintiff, Offutt
Housing Corporation, has had available ‘for its use. the |
- » serviees of the County Clerk of the eemty: of Sarpy ind ©
the Clerk of the Distriet Court. — .
Noe We
SS ae ; .
__ fe etna forthe alleges that the 611 multiple family
wellings and household appliances, to-wit: refrigerators, |
: electric ranges and washing machines, were purchased, con-. | 7
' . structed and located in Sarpy. County, Nebraska by the
' ‘plaintiff, said Offutt Housing Corporation ; that the plain-. |
- ‘tiff, said Offutt Housing Company, is.the owner of said 611 A
- multiple family dwellings and household appliances in |
- Sarpy. County, Nebraska, located-on the real estate de- |
-{fol. 33] scribed in the lease ‘agreement set out in Para- . |
-- graph VI hereof; that said property is subject to assess- ~
ment and taxation in Sarpy County, Nebraska ;- that no |
public funds of the United States of America were appro-
. 'priated or-expended for the purchase, erection or acyuisi-
tion of said-property;,that said property is not the property -
“of the United States of America; that there has been no
assessnients or:tax levied on the property of the United
_ States of America and that the tax levied, as alleged in Para-
- graph XIV hereof will not be a burden on the government .
of the United States. of America or ‘interfere in the per- |
‘foreiahes of any Federal function. - .
Phe defendant. farther alleges that the. hoes of the State .
of Nebraska, as set out in Section 77-1728 Revised Statutes
of Nebraska for-1943, that any person claiming any tax to
_ , be invalid shall pay the same to the County Treasurer ander
_ protest and make his claim therefor; as provided in See-
tions 77-1729-33, inclusive, and that the Court herein has:
not jurisdiction to determine or render jodgment erein.
Io
AO Pe ; =6 > e
:
~~ 9
ee ee
a.
“The defendant farther ‘alleges that a i a -aéhoat Ft’
- proper parties defendant ‘herein in th = the State of Ne-.
_braska, Auditor ef Pablie Accounts she State of Ne-
_ braske, Assessor of the County of Sarpy, Nebraskd, the .——- ~
Manufacturers’ Trust Company, snortgagee, and the Unite
. States of Americéa are necessary and. proper parties de-—
|.. fendant ‘and have not- been made parties defendant by y Ahe
se waned . yi,
: xx: §.
‘The detiadast forthe-s r specifically Sieian nea oaks :
allegation in said plaint#f’s petition contained not-herein- |
; after specifically admitted or sp@rifically controverted.
Wherefore, the defendant prays that the 1 caeatag s peti-
tion may be. dismissed at its costs.
- [fols. 34-37] County of Sarpy, Defendant. (8) by -
Devi: Entenman,. County Attorney..
Go:
id
__ printing. : * As 7 era aa
>
a
of fol. 38} hae THE Diermet Covar. OF Sarry County, NEBRASKA, 2
[Title omitted}
Praintivy’s Rerty. TO AMENDED ANswer’ or DEFENDANT,
Cov NTY oF Saney—Filed Febguary 17, 1954
Somes now ‘the plaintiff and: OCr the amended
answer of. County of Sep? and
"Without admitting thie materiality thereof plaintiff ad-~
., mits paragraphs , III, iv, x, and I of defendant's oe
amended answer. f LE OL
17.
‘Daly sworn to by. Orville Entemman, Jurat omitted es
ea ©
es i ios “1
" Plainttf 4 raion the silesaiiona of ei XIL 3 XViL :
3 ~ XVII, Xv and XIX of Catendant s atoended- “answer.
+,
are pate
- Plaintift denies all other allégations contained 3 in defend-
ant’s amended answer, save which may hereinafter be. ad-
sae to ae. true., EEE NS : eS
} As. to Ses v of defendant? s ‘amended answer,
3 plaintiff admits that the 81st Congress._of the United States te
enacted Publie Law No. 211, known.as the W herry Hotis-
‘ing Act, which Act was approved on August 8, 1949, and
- that said Act, as it was amended between August 8, 1949
_ and March 10, 1952, appears as section 1748 to 1748-1, 1952.
Curhulative Supplement to 12: United States Code: An- —
notated.. Plaintiff denies any coriclugions of the defendant |
eontrary>. to the Amport or meaning theteot., 2
_
As to cakageanh VI, ‘VIL, VIII and IX of. defendant’ rg
[fol. 39]. amended answer, the plaintiff admits the execu-.
tion ofa lease dated Vanuary 18, 1951, and alleges that an
exact eopy of said leage is attached to plaintiff ’s amended |
and supplementa tion, marked Exhibit C and made a
- part thereof. Plaintiff denies any: é¢onclusions of the de. ~
fendant WES eTy to. the import or meaning of such lease.
Wo te
ke to paragre 9b XI of defendant? 's aimended. answer, the
pleisitify. withow: cimitting the maferiality thereof, admijts
that on the 1st day of February, 1951, the plaintiff-exeeuted
a mortgage in favor of Manufacturers: Trust Cémpatiy, a
- corporation organized and. existing under the laws of the
State of New York, and that a copy of -said mortgage was -
filed in the office of the Register of Deeds of Sarpy County,,
Nebraska on February 6, 1951, and recorded in Mortgage
Records No. 63, at page 173, of thie records of Sarpy County,
Nebraska, and that Mahibit B attached to the defendant’ s
: ° ee 3
e : sot. : 7 fax: ort 19 io
. ° a . - = Z ® . oe, . or ¥. ' .
amended answer and made a part thereof is an exact‘copy
“Or sie 1ertgaxeso-exemated and so recorded. Plaintiff
| -denies, however, any conclusions of the defendant contrary
to the import or meaning of such instrument. — ~
.
2 ey ; Rc Tart a i 4
. e to Haragraph XIV of defendant’s- amended answer,
| the plaintiff admits that.on the 23rd day of June, 1952,
| the county assessor ofthe County of Sarpy, Nebraska, ex-
» . eguted and: returned a purported 1952 personal property” ~
* schedule, a copy of which is attached to plaintiff’s amended .—
> and supplemental petition, niarked Exhibit D arid made a .
part thereof. The plaintiif further admits that the pur- -
ported taxes levied on the basis. of such purported return
are unpaid. The plaintiff, however, alleges that such pur-.- /
_ - ported levy and purported taxes based upon such purported |
’ tax return are illegal, invalid; null‘and void and of no effect.
‘ Plaintiff further alleges that the property described in the |
~ . purported personal property tax schedule’ (Exhibit D at-.—
_ [fol. 40] tached to plaintiff’s amended and supplemental -
petition) was on March 10, 1952 and on June 3, 1952 lo- .
cated on Offutt. Air Force Base. Se
s
Sona
eo ee Re ee ce
-. As to paragraph XV of: defendant’s amended answer, |.
the plaintiff; without admitting the-materiality thereof, ad-
mits that on the 28th day of July, 1953, the plaintiff and Carl
©. Wilsoti, Inc. entered into a limited assignnient of rents.
in favor. gf Douglas County Bank of Omaha, whiclr assign-
ment of rents was prepared by and worked*by coutisel for -
_ Douglas County Bank of Omaha, a copyiof which is referred
to in paragraph XV of@lefendant’s amended answer. Plain-.
’ tiff alleges, however, that the-execution of such instrument
>. »*in no way changed the ownership or taxability of prM®erty :
_iivolved in this action and further alleges that.said in- —
strumetit was released by Déuglas County Bank of Omaha © -
on the 11th day of February, 1954, a copy of said release
- being recorded. in Miscellaneous Records 16 at page 472_
~in-the ‘office of thefRegister of Deeds of Saspy . County,
Nebraska, on the 13th day of February, 1954. £2
HY
/ Aesee sg: \
“nh
e069 ies
The. slaintitt further & s pécifically : deuion eaclixand ‘every’
allegat on in the deféndant’s, . County . of Sarpy, amended
answer no -herein spent admitted. or ae con: |
troverted. | :: ’
- Wherefore, plaizitifi. prays. for rélief of prayed for. in | its
Ieee ata: and supplemented: petition.
-(S.). Charles S. Reed, Howard W. Selling, Attorneys
for Plaintiff. ea sitar ee ;
[fol. in) ‘Duly s sworn to by Carl C. Wilsdn. Surat, omitted
An PRIMED:
Pe OE fin oa
[Fife endorsenient cmitted.1- os ie
By ee et ee Rie
6 +, on : i at ss Ae ote
“Hol 2) ~ TRile endorsement omitted], es
ae
AIn THE Disrricr Court or Siner Cours, NEBRASKA
| Orrurr House Company, a: Corporation, Plaintiff
2 ; . \ . . 2 t
Va P -—_ . P
9.
County OF Siney d Rosser 2M Ney, 3 Treasurer of County
of Sar y> Nebraska, Defendants’
{
ae : * Jvbomen ‘AND Drcnex—June 15, 1954
_ Now on this 15th day \ f June; 19%)4, the same being one.
of the days of the May 1954 terri? f court, this cause came. on
_to be heard on the amended and\ supplemental petition of
the plaintiff, the gnswer of the defendant, Rolert M. Eby,
- the amended answer of the.defendant, County of Sarpy, and
the plaintiff’s reply to the amended answer of the defend-
-ant, County of Sarpy, and the evidence, and was submitted
to the court, and the court being fully advised in the prem-
ises finds generally for the plaintiff and a the defend-
, ants, and each of them. Ries \
‘After due consideration of. the evide nee, the'vourt finids
- @ . 7 A Se 6 » *.
wae : 2 aie 3 \
=< - e « Bs ° °
g ii ae ee eee ;
k : been actively: and exclusively used as a: purely: mili
. Base. ;
That the dand on which Offut Air Foree Base i is issiad
| ae | ‘ oe
That théallegations contained i in. plaintiff's s. amended and =
supplemental petition are true.
That the allegations contained. in paragraphs. 1, x
-.8-
ae
3
XIII, XV and XVI of the “amended answer of thedefendant, . :
are County of Sarpy, are true and that the. ‘allegations , con- |
_tained in paragraphs VI, Vil and VIII cof pjaintiff’s.reply ~
to amended answer of defendant, County of Sarpy, are trie
°- and that the deed’ filed on April 12, 1950 and recorded ip
-Deed Records 67. at page 537 in the office of the Register of ~
‘Deeds of Sarpy. County, Nebraska, was executed by’ the .
grantor named therein ow the 21st day. of. Nengeety: 1949.
-. The court further finds: pas ee af
. That the court has: jurisdictionof the subject matter of
fhe action. °°
- [foi. 43] That. the court has jurisdiction’ over the pr
- to this action. ~- -- ie
That the peor between. the parties. is jsticiable in 2
this action. -: = ce
- That: thare i is no defect of covontial parties,
The-court specifically firids: 7
Phat Offutt Air Force Base i is > military cpacrvadion of.
the Wnited States and it ‘has, at all times her@in in ey in
stallation.
That the Department | of the- ‘Air Force Shas certified
Offutt Air Force Base to be a pernianent part of the United.
Stages Air Force and that the Seeretary of the Air Force, |
previous to. the “erection ‘of :the. housing. units involved,
certified, that stch housing project Was necessary for the
use of personn¢l assigned.to Offut Air Force Base. —
That all pr
_is real property of the United States.
‘y in. =
erty involved 1 is located | on Offutt Air Force ee
That the rental. units involved were coded’ at Offutt ‘Air i
Force Base and that the réntals therefbr-are substantially —
less than the. — for comparable y fe available”
housing.
That the pro fect * was initiated by theA: Cuinsandina’ Officer
of Offutt Air Force Base determining the rerital -housing
; ‘heed. for its military pareinael, the later approval of the
! o
as : ‘ a
4 $ - af’ x rp
project i the Secretary at Air, followed. by leiecninition”
of project details py-the Air Force and the Federal Housing»
. , Administration, after which prospective sponsors were in-
~ vited to provide the approval number of’ rental housing §
units, . after which. Carl C: Wilson, Ing., one of four pros-
,'-pective sponsors,. was selected, ‘Gark. CG. W ilson, Mnc. not ;
* being the ptefererice of the; ,WSommanding Officer of Offutt — §
_ Air Force Base. Thereufter, in accordance with existing
_ law and Federal ‘Housing Adrhinistration regulations, the
sponsor ¢aused the plaintiff corporation to be organized
“: to act asdessee for the military rental housing project. .
‘That the housing project-was conceived and planned: and |
[fol, 44] -that the additional - necessary and was secured ff
-- through the, Omaha Chamber. of Commerce hefore any .§
sponsor or lessee was sel@ted or established.
That»the maximum rentals ‘to ‘be paid by the FO Pe :
, oftthe housing project were determined on the: basis ofthe —
ability of} Prospective: ‘military: tenants to pay, and that °
before the spongor. of the project was selected, the-pros- |
_. pective lessee, the plaintiff, was required to ‘conform to the
- rental schedule ’ prescribed by the Department of the. Air KS
:. Forte of the United States. of ‘America. |
> ‘Phat ‘thé amount of rentals which the plaintiff may -.-
- . charge: for’ occupancy of the housing units involved was: |
fixed ; by the ‘Federal. Housing Adminjstration Commis-°
. sioner in accorgance with Title VIII of the federal National °:
_ Housing ‘Act and-the regulations of the Federal Housing
Administration Commissioner with concurrence of the De-
aerials of the Air Force of the United-States of America:
’That the rentals to he paid by the pants of ‘the rental ©
housing units in said project cannot be- raised without the .;
- eonsent of the Department of the Air Force of the United
_ States of America. 7
- ..That the: housing units and the de iiacilbiit obiapidicnds is.
2 presently leased only to military personnel of the. United
/- $tates of Anierica assigned to duty at Offut Air Force Base.
That the amount of rentals charged to. the oeeupants of
the rental housing units were fixed upon the assumption
that the property was not taxable and that; in the event .
_ the property involved in this. action should he found to be
taxable, rentals paid by Air Moree personnel tenants, wil
be increased. 3 >
6
é~
AG
i
6
Ps > > 3
*
:e- . Sper Aig oe a ; +94
€ , so, 23
be Fae ime AEN
‘That ‘the eligibility of Air Force personnel to rent-the
Z epaiets involved is determined by Ane Strategic Air Com-
' mand Base C ‘ommander.
That the préperty involved is nef: located in any mu-
nicipality’or scheol district. — :
“Nebraska of notification letters, copies of which wére intro-
-
| duced -in evidepce as Exhibits 2 and 2-A, the United States
of America assumed exclusive jurisdiction over Offutt Air
-Foree Base. andsover all. property involved ‘in this action,
and that upon receipt of such notification jetters, the State
of Nebraska, and its political subdivision, County of Sarpy,
eeded all taxing jurisdiction over Offutt Air Force. Base to
.. the United States -of America. and all property located
‘thereon.
That the United States af America 1 has never ‘by lesleli
tive action ‘consented to the defendant, County: of Sarpy,
fc: taxing the buildings involved in this aetion or {he appli-
_.aneceseand personal property of the plaintiff located therein.-
a: [fol: 45] That.upon recsipt b¥ Governors of ihe Stuite of —
- That the United States of ‘America has never by legisla--
re ‘action consented ta. the defendant, County of Sarpy,
taxing any tangible personal property of. the Plaintiff | lo-
ts cated on. Offutt “Air Force Base. .
That the m6rtgagé executed by the plaintiff’ is not a mort-.
gage on the fee title to the land leased to the plaintiff, »
“That in connection with the: plaintiff hein’ established”
Base and being granted a lease’ of the land on: which the
‘of household appliances: to be furnished by .the plaintiff, -
including gas ranges, refrigerators, washers: and dryers.
[fol. 46]. That on March’10, 1952, a number. of the build-
ings and rental housing units therein had: been fully com-
c
ps .
, of 7
°
That on June 23, 1952, the rental housing units involved
in this action were ‘fully completed and that all-611 rental -
housing units, involved ‘therein had-been certified adwreadly
- for occupancy and that on said date, a large number of
_ such rental units were already occupied by. Air Foree ar
’ sonnel assigned to Offutt Air Force Base.
as lessee of the rental housing project on Offutt Air Foree |
project was.fo be erected, the Department of the Ait Force .
. required the plaintiff to agree that the rentals paid by the
- teriants of the rental housing units should inelude the use |
wigs
came
|
“ pleted and were oseapied by Air Force. personnel seal ae
ta-Offyrtt ‘Air Foree Base and that on said. date, all of the
? buildings had-been structurally completed, except for some . : » ’
remaining -painting, plastering and plumbing connections, ee
‘ ji some of the rental housing units contained therein. % ;
That the plaintiff, in 1952, did not list with the County 4
Assessor of Sarpy County any property involved in this ~
_ action as personal property of the plaintiff sugject to taxa-.
tion in Sarpy County: and that on June 23, 1952, the County
Assessor of the defendant, County of. Sarpy: without. plain- .
: . tiff’s consent or. ‘authority, ‘executed a purported ‘Business
- and Professional: Schedule of. Personal Property,” pur- »
ported to be owned by the plaintiff and subject to. taxation
_in Sarpy, County as personal property of the plaintiff and
that the property described in such: Business and-Profes- -
sional Schedule is the- ‘property involved in this action.
That said schedule listed-under: subdivision F thereof mis- -
cellaneious personal property atia valuation of $205:00 and.
hheteaakola appliances ata valuation of $69,695.00. and that
- in such schedule in subdivision I thereof, there Was listed.
‘g.improvements or. “teased land’? at- a valuation of
_—
: 759, 785.00. oad y .-° BSG Yu . e ae
s
Ph improvements vere s assessed at the. assessor Ss
estimate of the value of the buildings, ‘the same as if the
| - plaintiff had a full and unqualified ownership of the build- —
‘ ings. :
That on “the basis of ae schedule, } purported taxés were
. levied against the plaintiff in the amount of $10,783.45.
‘That $9,870.55 of such‘tax covers. improvements on leased
land at Offutt. Air Force Base and the balanee of the tax,
or $9%2:90, covers taxes levied ag inst the plaintiff 6 prop-
_ erty Rsted under subdivision F 6f such “Busiriess and Pro- :
fessional Schedule of*Personal Property.’”
That no part of: said faxes haye been paid. |
[fol. 47]: That prior to the bringing’ of: this action, thie .
. defendant, Robert M. Eby, Treasurer of the defendant,
County of Sarpy, by a letter dated April: 13, 1953, threatened -
to issue a. distress Warrant to collect sore purported taxes
involved. 3
That plaintift is entitled to the relief pray ed for,
r NR ae, Sys we ORE
\Tierefers, it is Acelared, dotcreined and ‘adjudged that:
ix. = <i : ss ~ ” 25
Offutt Air Force Base is property reserved or acquired =
and used by the United States for military purposes.
The Staite of Nebraska and its political sybdivision were,
.” in 1952, and thereafter, without power or authority to tax
tangiblegproperty located at or upon. Offutt. Air Force
- Base. :
Offutt Air Force Base, the jand on whieh it is ‘located,
/ and rental housing jmprovementg thereon were,~on June
Ga .
93; 1952, and at all times thereafter, property f' the United |
ing improvements on Offutt Air Force Base were real estate
> and not personal property and was a part of the. land on.
which Offutt ‘Air Force Base is loéated.. . .~
The‘land on which Offutt Air Force. Base: is located was
not, during any time during 1952, €.part of public lands.
| ‘States, nol subject .to taxation by the State of Nebraska ar
- Sarpy County.. e585.
-. On Jutie 23, 1952, and at all times thereafter, ‘rental hous:
The purported 1952 assessment of ‘Improvements on
the plaintiff was illegal, null and void and 6f no effect.
_ The purported 195%: levy of taxes against the plaintiff by ..
“.the defendant on improvements on leased land of the pur-
‘ported value of $755, see 00 was illegal, Tull and void and: -°
. Of rio effect. ~ &.
The purported 1952 “assessment of, property ‘Hated: in
5 “Schedule of thégurported personal property: tax schedule.
‘as. property subject to taxation. in Sarpy County under the ©
laws of the State of Nebraska was: s illegal, null and v roid ane
of no. effect. aE
_ leased lands . $755,785.00"? as personal property of ©
The purported property: of the’ plaintiff listed bo .
. Schedule F of the purported personal property tax schedule ~
as property subject to taxation in Sarpy County, Nebraska,
[fol. 48] was located on Offutt Air -Foree Base and was. _
' . not subject to. taxation by the defendant, County of Sarpy.
The purported. 1952 levy of taxes agaist the plaintiff
‘on the property listed in Schedule F of the purported per-
_ sonal property tax schedule’ was-illegaf, null and void and
of no effect. .
‘The. purported personal property tax sidindiake ‘nae _ se
the County Assessor of Sarpy County showing personal. :
26 > : | er ; : ok Pe % ns
property of the plaintiff subject to tenhGin ini Sires County
under the laws of the State of Nebraska should be corrected
to eliminate sherefrom saprovemnents on leised land of the.
- valuation of $755,785.00.
The purported personal property tax schedule made ‘by |
: the County Assessor’ of Sarpy County showing personal
.- property of the plaintiff subject to taxation i in Sarpy County —
under the laws of the State: ‘of Nebraska should-be corrected
to éliminate therefrom proper ty listed in Schedule F thereof. ;
It is further or agp, adjudged and degreed that: |,
ounty of Sarpy, its officers and agents, «
be perpetually enjoined from including im: its. tax -asse& Hf :
The lefendant,
ment schedules any rental housing improvements on Offet
Air Force Base: as personal property- of the plaintift in
Sarpy: County.
* The: defendant, County of Berny: its Bicone and fae |
be: perpetually. enjoined from including in its tax assess-
ment schedules any furniture, fixtures, tools,’ equipment. or 3
household ‘appliances located on Offutt ‘Air Force Base as
personal property of the plaintiff taxable in Sarpy County.
It is further sordered, adjudged and decreed that the |
Defendant, rh of Sarpy, its officers and agents, and . *
“the defendant, Robert M.. Eby, Treasurer of Sarpy County,
be -perpetually enjoined from levying any tax against the ~
plaintiff covering imprevements located on Offutt Air ist | |
Base or enforcing any.tax thereon against, the pilainti
— - Jt-is further ordered, ‘adjudged . and decreed that the
defendant, Couniy of Sarpy, its officers and agents, and the °,
[fols. 49- 63] defendant, Robert,M. Eby, Treasurer of Sarpy.
‘’ County, be. perpetually enjoined from, levying. any tax. .
against the plaintiff covering furnifare, - fixtures, tools,
~ equipment or, household appliances located on rear Air
Force Base. - — ¢
It is further ovdened, adjudged and decreed that thé pur-
ported personal property tax schedule made by the County
Assessor of Sarpy County-on June 28, 1952 be corrected to
‘elimingfe. therefrom improvements on leased land of the
--valuatipn of $755,785.00. :
Tt it further ordered, adjudged and dscrted that the pur-
ported personal property tax schedule made by the County
Assessor of Sarpy County on June 23, 1952 be corrected to-
. a ee ee a : 7 oe
Ee : e : ° ° ° @
3 Ree | Be - . .2T
eliminate therefrom farniture and fixtures—tools and equip.
ment—household APpliiiic?s POPPIN f $69,900
- It is further ordered, adjudged and deeréed that the abe
» ~tiff_recover from the defendants its costs in thts action
baa taxed: at $28.35.
eee By the Goart (S. ) John M. Dietks, Judge.
OK. Orville Biitenman, ee Attorney, 14 June, 1954.
-Lfols. 64.66) In Distaiot Lecxs oF Sanpy County :
_ Excerpts from Bill of Exceptions
/
. ‘Super’ S Cenrirtcate, -T6 Buu. or ‘Excgrrions—Oetaber 1;
: = | 1954 © :
I Hiaveley Certify. that the wit oe following Bill of 8
_. Exceptions in two volumes described as: Volume I, Testi-,
- mony, Pages 1 to-197, inclusive ; Volume II, Exhibits; Pages =
198 to 226, ingusive; contains all of the evidence offered,
“and all of. the: evidence given, -both oral and doeumentary,
upon the trial of this cause, together with all oral motions,
stipulations, offers, objections, and THlings of the Court
‘thereon; that the trial was had at the-time and place stated ©
* herein; ‘and upon application of the Plaintiff this. Bill of
- Exeeptions is allowed by me and ordered to be made a —
_ of the record 1 in this cage. |
“Dated: at Papillion, ‘Nebraska, thig gst ¢ day. of October, -
(een )
s ) John M. Dierks, pistriet J udge:
4
fol. 67] Sa 5 Priockebtncs: ce eee ne, :
‘Monday, Apri 19th, 1954, 9 :00 A M.: . z
2 : * wy ses * ae . 3 3% es : | j
a. : A e /.
OFFERS IN. EVIDENCE : oe
ss Mr. “Reed: I suggest that plaintiff and defendant join
in submitting iain aceccnatei
°, : : : . ue.) =
. be be 4
—_
; )
98° Ee set ;
* Mr. Peteinas.: Yes, the defendant joins in 1 introducing .
into. evidence Exhibit No, 1. sae
Fi ; : F = nt . ; .
* .8 _ . 2 e *
. cider Soe . » 7
as - the Court : It will be received. -
Cie Ge oe | oe we
os MP. Reed: Exhibit I4Sir, is’ Exhibit Sk. hy sataciol to... -—
in the stipulation and ‘the plaintiff ’s petition, and. Exhibit.
2-a is Exhibit ‘*A-1’’ referred to in the plaintiff ’s petition .
~- and in the stipulation; and_ plaintiff offers in evidence: |
Exhibits 2 and 2-a. Any objection? -
Mr. Entenman : I have no objection.” -- - .
Mr., Reed: And I will ask the reporter to mark this
(fol. 68) exhibit as Hexhibit se | ; “6
Fe » . ee I eile
-
Mr: Reed: I would like to state to the Court that Exhibit eae
3, except for the attestation of the Nebraska FHA Director,
is the-same as the Exhibit B attached to plaintff’s petition
and as Exhibit B as referred to in the stipulation. . Do you ....
agree to that, Mr. Entenman? Past < |
Mr. Enter™man: Yes. ae :
© Mr. Reed: And’ plaintiff will offer in evidence Exhibit 3
_ By the Court: Exhibits 2, 2-a and 3 will be received.
; ; we . ey - : - ; . % : 7
Mr. Reed: The exhibit which the reporter has marked
Exhibit No. 4 is-referred to i in the petition as Exhibit ‘‘C’’,
- ON. Do. you agree to that?
the lease, and is referred to in the stipulation ‘ as Exhibit
. Mr. Entenman: Yes, » oon Pel ef
. 3 phe = Ses ue o * mes
< 2
By the Court: It will be received, Exhibit 4.
A) tae
f tae: . . a oe eee or ° *. aes,
A
Mr. Reed: “Mr. Entenman; might we stipulate that:
hibit 5 is an- “exact copy” of an exhibit: referred to in th
o 2 a Se es . a * i ;
: ep
ee
Lgl ite 2 Se Coes 9
ee.
DP EDO SITE ED | A PYR Pee Nore we ek RIPE Fe
m .
‘oO
Lotition as Exhibit up ani referred to in, | the stipulation :
as Exhibit ‘‘D’’, and that it is in ‘the handwriting of
Ernest Neilsen, the County Assessor of Sarpy vient dh :
MagiEntonmas Yes. No objection. Zs
Mr. Reed: Plaintiff will offer in ev idence Exhibit 5.
By. the Court: It. will be received. ie
; _Mr. Reed: That: ‘is the assessment schedule.
2 . - Eee ¢ ; ee +
Mr. "Reedé The Exhibit 6. is the 1953. If it please the
' . Court, this Exhibit 6 is not referred to in: the petition,
and it is not referred to in the stipulation. Exhibit 6 is -
the return schedule, same form as Exhibit 5, for the year
1953; and my theory in offering it in evidence is to ‘show -
‘the theory of necessity’ for- ‘injunctive relief and to show
the amount that: would be involved in: the next subsequent
year. It is in the hatidwriting of the assessor. -
By \the Court: Not made voluntaril but in the hand-
_- writing of the assessor. y
[fol. 7)] Mr. Reed: That is right. |
Mr.|\Entenman: That is not included in our wipulation.
1 didn’t know until new that he-was going to introduce : ©
the 1953... I would object to its being used here or in any.
way. determining the correctness -of. the’ 1953 schedule.
By the Court: It will be received for the limited purpose
for which it was offered; to show that the assessor -pro-
ceeded to assess’ the property involved ‘in eacP succeeding
year by having done so in 1953, and I suppose in a day
or so there will be one for 1954. :
Mr. Reed: That is right. | :
‘Mr. Entenman:, That will not be litigated,” ‘ough; i
any way with the——. 7
By the Court: No, mot involved ‘i in the litjention on the
merits. | *
Mr. Reed: All right, plaintiff Sifers i in ‘euidenss Exhibit
6, and may we agree before the Court rules on it that it
-js-in the handwriting: ‘of the County Assessor, and is. a
eopy of. the involuntary assessment of . the plaintiff in.
1953?
Mr. Entenman: Ww ell, + orale: that Mig; 0 ST |
* By. the Court: Ww ell, is the assessor present in court?
Ks ; ~—
- > * 4 "1 a . :
. e bd *.
: ; . oie an : :
; 30 . As . : .
Mr. Sntenthan: No, he isn’t. In fact he’s very busy.
If I could have’ just. a very few minutes to check it. .
By the Court: Well, we will defer receiving it in evi--
‘dence until you have ‘had ‘a chanc® to check it to see if it
| -[fel. 71]. is in his parol pea but under those -cireum-
. stances it will be received.
Mr. Reed: If it ak the Coutt, Exhibit. 7 isa ‘copy
-of a letter ‘written and mailed by | the defendant Robert
M. Eby, County Treasurer of Sarpy County, to the ad-
dressee shiown, on or about the ‘date shown in the. letter ;
and we have stipulated. that this is:a photostatic copy. of-
.‘a letter signed and mailed to the. shown addresse- at such
time, have we not, Mr. Entenman?
Mr. Entenman: Yes sir. oy
Mr. Reed: Plaintiff will offer in evidence Exhibit 7.
Mr. Entenman: No objection. : \
‘By the Court: It will be received.
ei ee ee Gy et ee . on ae |
ae Mr. Reed: It és stipulated’ between the parties thiat
Exhibit No. 8 is a photostatic copy of the articles of in-
corporation of Offutt Housing Company, and: the certifi- -
gate of the Secretary of State of Nebraska, and on the —
“reverse side thereof shows the filing of a copy in the office
.of the County Clerk of Douglas County, Nebraska. Do
[fol. 72] you dgree to that? %
Mr. Entenmafi: And that they are the plaintiffs bisvein::
. Mr. Reed: Well, they. purport to be: That is dll right.
And that the. exhibit shows the articles of. incorporation ae
of the plaintiff corporation.’ ~.
By the Court: It will be received,
= Reed: Plaintiff sie in evidence Exhibit 8.
‘ a
‘s ‘ ~s 6 &! ; e e 2 . ae e *
br ae : . “ er Noe ee
31
Wiiduaxi R. Geoniia: called as ‘a chili ia
- the Plaintiff, - being mee! his_oath “first t duly sworn, testi-
fied as follows : |
Diteet examination, , cee a
= ‘By Mi. Charles s, Reed: ee
Q. What is your name, please ?
A. William R:- Goodall, Jr. ;
_.Q. What is your business or profession, Sir?
. A. I am the chief, Real Estate Divi peg for the Engi-
@ neers, Missouri River Division. . |
. [fol, 73] Q..Does Offutt Air Force Hy é. within
” your. geographical—is it within the seins” al limits ~
ef the jurisdiction of” your, work? . ;
: A. 268 mr | :
Q. And what is the connection betw een your office and
‘Offutt Air Force Base? 3
A. The Corps of Engineeers acts ‘as real estate iaont
for all-branches in the Army, Air Force and Atomic —
_Engergy Commission.’ | .
et Q. And that includes the installation a
Base?
* -A. Yes. i
Q. And how long inves you. ‘been i in your present position,
Col. Goodall? - |
" “A. Since 1944. ae
Q. And were you in that same type of work ‘when the .
WwW herry: Housing was built -on Oiratt ‘Air Force. Base? .
A. I was. 7
| (Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 9 salad for identification by )
the reporter. ). ;
Q.. Col. Goodall, I wish you would tell the Court at
. Exhibit 9 is.
A. This is ‘a’ map ‘showing the- real estate comprising
Offutt Air Force Base up to February, 1953. ae,
-Q.' Give me the exact date in February it was tant certi-
“ hed. ;
LAL February.’ 3rd, 1953.
- HS - .
* ° a a * a) ae
* 2 e ps : 2 k .
ee
ess
ffutt Air Force
o
" {fol 74] Q. ai right. And that map,-: then; or these"
‘stated here, that is also the federa
symbols, show thé” outside perimeter: of. Offutt Air Force —
' .base up to the 1953 date that the map was last modified?
i oe
(Q. And incidnentally, then, shows ali De Offutt Air For ce.
: Base; the land within that. broken line marking shows all -
“of the real estate which compriseds Offutt Air Earee: Base
at the time bad the last revision?.
A. Yes. - oe
“Mr. Reed: Plaintiff will ae in evidence— - is |
Mr. Entenman: I woe ‘like to cross-examine the | wit~.
ness. -.
3 _By the Court: ‘You may des . a : Sree
By Mr. ‘Entenmai —-
Q: Is it true, Sir, that the con
ies of this map, as he
roperty Seong ae to
the United States Governments = A Sy
—ffok75] A. Yes. oe
. Q. And is that the title that it hae, or the game that it S
has, “Offutt Air Foree Base’’? all of. it?
A. Yes. . : -
-Q.. And this map baka. then, shows all property that is -
| owned by the United States Government i in this area now! ? es
A. As‘ of that date, it does. . hs Seat te
. Q. Asof 1953? ;
BRM re ib
eae Wai os Seer 4 . Rone
-Q. Boss this map show the property. ihiat. was “ieee to}
- the bearinee Housing Company, the plaintiff 3 in this action? Ee =
{fol. 76] A. 1 ean’t answer as of im own anita know]. :
edge. I can perhaps answer it this way: That tract No.
*. 48 was acquired from the, Omaha Chamber of Commerce,
and. it has always been iny understanding that: it wae ac- -
oak for the purpose of building family quarters under
the Wherry Housing.
Q. But this map its®lf doesn't ps the ‘exact tract ‘of
“the lease, er the. deseribed property that was leased? |
. . -
c . x oP is >. ?
Snat S ae
‘é. No, we didn’ t yrepare the lease in. my office, o
Q. And it.isn’t pre on this magi? I mean this Tr act
f°. 16 and Tract 48 there, they are not the ‘prope rty that was
' Jeased, are they?
—A—You couldn’t tell it frei’ this map as to which prop-
erty was leased. patho Seca ;
Mr. Entenman : -Couldn’t tell mS “Alb right, I am going
to object to this exhibit; I don’t see that this helps us ‘in:
any. manner; it co-fuses the issues.
. By the Court: What is the purpose of using it ‘Mr.
Reed? ' ry
Mr. Reed: The purpose of aoe
By the Court: It is not the property involved. |
Mr. Reed: It will be supplemented. The purpose of. .
using it is this: The purpose of- using it is -to essentially
~~ show that all of the housing involved here, and the prop-
erty leased, ‘is within. the perimeter. Now, the only two |
things we have to put together, the lease is now. in evidence,
with the descriptions, amyl that map shows corners and
"measurements; and with those ,two exhibits you can deter-
{fol. 77] mine how much of that was covered by this lease
to the plaintiff cor poration, because you have now in evi-
- dence the lease, which gives the legal’ description, and if
. you will refer to that you will find it. is all’ within the
‘perimeter } ‘of ‘Offutt Air Force Base.
«. = By. the. Court: Isithis a qualified real estate expert?
- - Are you going to have him do that? ie He
| Mr. Reed: No... a oy ee
By the Court: How‘ can I do it? Ee 7
Mr. Reed: .Well, vou get your deseription there, and
your corners age shown tliere, and you can show, and IT
‘intend to-show, I want. to say trvou,. that this-is a preface
‘- to having the Base’ Commander testify as to the location *
-of the housing.” This is preliminary to that." We have
‘another map. that shows ‘the tocation of the housing, but’
I want to get that in as the official certified map of the
engineers as preliminary to the other exhibit. °
_By the Court: All rat . Objection overruled.
; ie: ‘ oh Ih Siok at aaa
e e ret o : ~s. e e A --
8
a:
a, i By Mr. ¥ Reed :
“e —Q. Now, I would like to ask; just explain .i in general the
‘entries that are sliown on that map. You don’t have to
discuss them, but so that anybody will understand what
-.. . the entries are about the tracts, and so forth, along the
site of that map. |
[fol. 78). Mr. Entenman : I object to that. “T believe they
speak for r themselves. ; + gtk oe
Mr. Reed: No, they y Hon’t.
By ‘the Court: Does it. bear a ‘legend, or not? that eae.
9 plains it? 252 -:
co... Mr Reed: The things, that are lesen i" ain not aaking |
*"—<" _ about, Sir. . |
J+ .__-#A. The Tract register shows the tract number, the former Z
_ owner, the acreage, and the estate which has been acquired ;
in this ease it has all been acquired in fee; and then there
mi -are various: notations out to ihe Sacchie sig haters
2 7 : _ By Mr. Reed: eae ed eeranere
: 4
-Q. Now, those are legends. eee
Mr. ’Entenman: I am going to object | to that mae in.
fee’’ there, because’ I-think that would be ealling for a con-.—
‘s 6, clusion of this witness, The title hasn’t been introduced
here in evidence, any record-of that, and it’s not the best
: Britto. if he is going to add that word ‘in fee’’ in here,
how it was acquired. 7
_By’the Court: That can’ he stricken as not the best evi-
dice the record itself is the best evidence.
° Pips y"
|? ig .- ake ‘}. (aan ee” TE es
Q. Now, incidentally, as “te: this: matter of title, isn ! Sita a.
~ [fols. 78-80] fact-that/the U.S. Enginers, in acting as reali °°
< y* estate agents in this bnstance for the Air Force, determines
the title to the property, who has the title to Offutt Air
<~- __ Force Base? 3 Bee
___ A.-¥ou mean who has the title? ‘If the Army——
sa Q. No. Doesn't that come within the seope of the ®x-
'. amination, or supervision, of the United States Army Engi-
neers to determine the nature of the title. “ee by a military.
installation within your district? 3 :
4 2 ° e 7
. . . . y . . . .
ey , . 3 . .
x ry ° . $ : R
Mg ve : . 2 , ; .
° . “ : x , 4
»s «£7 ¢ x . ¥ did Se x ° Z
. o ° . ‘
. . : °
5e 7
.
at | . 3
ik Yes sir. “We ‘always buy whetracts: or certificates of, . is
“title and submit: it to the Attorney: freneral for opinion.
QQ. Now, according to the records if your office, if you
know, . who. has title to the ground described within. those
_ perimeter markings you have previously described?
Mr. Entenman: I object to that as ealling fora conclusion
and not the best evidence. They can’t just put one individual ©
‘ here to give his opinion; that might be invading the prov Tee.
- of the Court, : am quite si sure it wouk! be. —
ad
[fol. 81]. By the Court: Your objection. as not being the.
best evidence is absolutely good; it’s not the best evidence’ -
of title. . . Ee
>
a, SSE Roz; * ere eee PT ia *
Q. Au right. ee your She is the U nited States Depart-
ment of Engineers, which acts as real estate agent for the
‘ [fol. es United States 1 in these defense Projects} |
A. ‘Yes.
Q. All right, ficcording to the records of your ates based
upon abstracts and the records of your office; according: to
the records of your office, who is the.owner of the land in-
cluded i in the perimeter shown on that map, Exhibit: 91
Mr. Enitenman: The same objection, your Honor. ‘Tn the
first: place the rest’of the tract here, outside of the leased —
" premises, is‘not in issue, it. would be irrelevant, immaterial —
and have no bearing on the i issues of this case, or any deter-
mination here who has title-to the rest of the base.
Mr. Reed: g. am going-to get that other map, then, after
I get this map in, Sir,
Mr. Entenmani : And as to the title. to the tract here; I
made the same objection before, that. the. best evidence of
that is the deed itself. -
| By the Court: ‘There i is no » question about that, if Ba ‘are hae
- going to insist on it. .
Mr. Entenman: Asa matter of fact I think they are trying
to show right here, and I want the record to:show that, that
the records of. the title t# the real estate’involved in here
od)
any
a
ar are 5 amaculied by the Register of Deeds Office of Sarpy
County, vis not aad the manent Office. TEESE: Zo
{ : ; : < x
° e *. . . ° ide Oey aN
. . e. .
[fols. 83-85 | By the ‘Court: Yes. It is not. the best’ evi-
dence, what their record shows as to thie title. The ‘best
evidence is the deed records of Sarpy comma Bo
‘you want to insist upon it, and apparently Mr. Enteiman -
does want to insist t epon, Me gees
aed See ie . ee J ry .
Pa NG
[fol. 86] Mr. Reed: ‘Well, that is what I want to kaow::
Iam going to offer to show by this witness what their ..
file shéws as to title, based upén an audit of acquisition. of :
. title and examination of titles to all these tracts as va are
- aequired by the United Sattes. :
Dg you have any objection to that offer?. tile
Mr. Entenman: I do. I object to that.” The record.is- —
_¥ight down here in this clerk’s office; closer than any ©
Engineers office; and that record can be brought in here.
_Why they don’t want to introduce those deeds, I don’t know.
Mr. Reed: There isn’t anythin; dire about it, except I°.
& have to go down there and get certified copies of about thirty :
_. some tracts; and they are all included i in: this audit file, sta +.
in one package. . ax:
Mr. Entenman: There is not that much property involved
- in this. -It only shows two tracts righton the map. ©»
- Witness Goodall: Our files would contain copies only ; ;
they wouldn’t contain the original document.
Mr. Reed: Wel], if your Honor please, anybody. that S|
thinks it’s just this land. ‘acquired by the Omaha Chamber of |
Commerce involved in this housing is badly mistaken ; there
is some of the old. reservation. included’ in this housing a
‘: Jonna 4
‘By the Court: Well, what’ 8 s the difference? J ‘would think :
. You could stipulate that part of it is and part of it.was —
‘acquired from the Chamber of Commerce; but if you want
[ fol. 87] to insist upon objecting,. go ahead.. Nat the. bent
ie ev idence ; is that your objection, Mr. Entenmant -
Mr. ‘Entenman: pee
By the Court: The objection as‘not the best evidence ‘will
Fe,
Beek?
fs ee a = pie
be suchen.” But I aaa that I think you onght to be able
+ to stipulate. on stich a fact as that.
Mr..Reed: Will you stipulate, Mr. Entenman, that hous- =
_ ing invelved in this action is located upon land the title, to
. which is in the United Sfates of America.
Mr: Entenman: No; because I want that deed i in here.” a
By the Court: Why-don’t you put in your stipulation that .
it came ‘through the Chamber of Commerce?. _pEperenty
\. that is what he wants in the record.
ot Entenman: That. is right. I don’t. care about the -
‘By the Court: What és 3s want to keep it out. for?
‘am going to let it in——— are
- Mr. Reed: Wait a minute! I am—— 3 oe
‘By the Court: —so the Supreme Court will have the.
whole picture here; that part of this housing project is on
land acquired by the Omaha Chamber of Commeree-——
Mr. Reed: That’ 's right. 2.
By the Court : —and donated to_the on utt Hoosen for
the very purpose. I think if yor Will agree to that Mr.
; Entenman’ will not insist. upon objecting. ative
° . . at
* : \ . . “es Gre . Ld . - . 3 “ =
+ SA | = Fee ae 7 Or:
i .
oe nce ? .
. . - ; °
=
2 fol. 88] Col, “N. dec called-as a witvoes on behalf. of. | :
- the plaintiff, being capes oath first ear sworn,, testified :
as | follows :
Direet examination.
By Mr. ‘Charles 8. teed; *
- Q What is your. namie?
A. Col. A.J. Beck. =
Q. You area Colonel i in the United’ States ie Foree, Col.
- A. Yes sir. | =
Q. And you are Base ‘Commander. att
Base? co Bie
A. Yes sir. } ier od
Q. And how long have you been. Base-6 nmander?
A. Sinee the 24th of May, 1952. a
Tutt Air Force
v
Oo
oe 7 ?
faite 2a °
Q. “And before that were you ‘taiboned hoe the base?
A. Yes.sire”
--Q: And for what length of time hay you been stationed
on the base?-. |
' A. Thave been at Offutt Air Force ase since ‘October of
1948. ,
Q: You were » there during the fo atian. of the plan for
the housing involved i in this case, were yout
- [fol. 89]. A. Yes sir. . | :
rarees.* ~ lig I wish you would take this ethibit—And.
cae incidentally, Col. Beck, I believe you were an attorney before
you went im the Air Force, were you not? .
‘A. Yes sir; I still am an moet
2 > « : re . J y fp
e : . 7 es. . ' @ e
oo
- Q. Now, i wink to hand you Exhibit 10, a tell is ‘aha :
Exhibit 10 is before any furthey questions. i
patos cages Exhibit,10 i is a plot plan of Offutt Air Force: Base.
@ Q. And that is the base sat is unde your command ?.
fhe? Few wie, |
Q. Is it identical, except asto seale, as Exhibit 9?
A. No sir; it is in much more detail. spe
Q. I know, but is the perimeter the samet se »-
A. I have not compared it—— — th i '
Q. Well, will you just check it now, to be s . P
ae IT doubt if Iam able at this time, Mr.. Reed, to actually ANS
entify each one of | these perimeter lines. | -
“Q. All right.
_A. T don’t believe T am able to do that.
Q.. All right.
A. They Appear. to be the same.
—Q. Now, what i is shown by Exhibit 101 ,
ae Woll, Exhibit 10, as I say, is a plot plan of Offutt Air
iE ffols. 90-94] Forge Base, and shows the perimeter of Offutt ;
. Afr Foree Base and tlie major items of construction within oa
that perimeter. ,
Q: Does Exhibit 10 show all ‘of the Offutt Air Force Base?
- Yes, I believe ‘it oan. Meh gas arg RENT PT oe
aot, aa ae . Bs ge
ig) See “she |
| £53 3 mes fea te , . FBQ .
; ies
[fol. 95] ° Mr. Reed: Now, Plaintiff offers in ev vidence at ;
this, time an os vag:
~ @ ®s ae
4
gp nme erated, soe re,
, fol 6) By the Onieit: Kt will’be received.
“By Mr. Reed :
Q. Col. Beck, you ‘are the Base Commander there?
A.. Yes sia
~*. Q, And who is the owner off the: area wie. you desig.
_ nated on Exhibit 10 as the’lease area?
A. “The United States Government.
Mr. Entenman: Just’ a minute! I object to that as calling’
‘for a conclusion of this witness. It is not the best evi-
dence of the ownershiff.
By the Court: Well, T will let it stand. It isn n't the dest ,
evidenee.
By Mr. Sake
Q. Does. Exhibit 10 portray—does Exhibit: 10° Soaiguais
‘all of the Wherry Housing on bees Air Force Base? -
ce. Bs Yes sir. “Be
sd
[fol 97] By} Mr. Reed? fe vat
Q. What i is the nature of Offutt Air: Base i in the defense
set-up? oe she
A. It is a permanent installation of the United’ States
Ait Force. It is the headquarters of the Strategic Air.
Command and. the 3902nP Air Base Wing. |
Q. Is Offutt Air Force Bage i in its entirety an Air Force
military base? .
A. Yes air. Lies 2
_ Q. Is it in active use as such? ;
A. Yes sir. °
| Q? Has it heesi at all times since. you have been on, the :
*, Base? : | L + .
A. Yes sir. |
oe Col. Beck, are you familiar with the steps tant were
.
i Beat
ci ; 2 i
- en 9.
‘ ‘ ° j ; é
Wa sideration of Wherry Housing.
40 as
» taken and how this Sicnbidine’ bedanis a reality as far as the
“~ procedure 4 i& concerned? . This — Housing on Offutt, —
| Air Foree Base?+ |
A. Yes sir.
Q. AH right, wi)
| you tell the Court the” areentare that
'\ was followed in obthining this military housing; this very:
-‘nilitary housing that }s involved in this action? \ RES: :
_ A. I-won’t be able ty remember dates, however, I can
give a chronology withoutNlates of just about’ the procedure.
= The requirement for hodsing being quite obvious, and
after the passage of the Wherry-Spence Act, the Base
. discussed the’ matter with the Federal Housing Authority;
* [fol. 98] the. State Director in aha, and came to an
_agiomcanes as to the number of units f housing that weré ~—
diately required; requested, thro h channels, con- —
Q: Requested who, through channels?. . 3
“A. Requested the-—ultimately the Secretary 0 “the: die
Force, is about as far as ‘I could,go. Requested t h
_ ehannels to the Secretary of the Air Force that. considei ~
ation be given to the construction of Wherry Housing ait
Offutt Air Force Base to take-care of the serious require- .
_ ment for accommodations of military personel and civilian |
employees,
: The Base then at a later date received authorization to
i proceed to get proposals for the construction of this hous-
ing, and through various means asked firms to make "a
posal for the construction of housing.
. .Q. Now, may I-interrupt? Was that, ‘shronplogically,
before, or after a certificate being issued ‘by the Secretary 3
of Air? ae :
A. The certificate: of necessity,, I- ‘do ‘not recall whether:
it was issued—I dare say. it was issued after the ‘pro- |
posals wef requested, as well as sI remember.
Q. All right. 3 pee
Ro” And that would: > the next ‘thing. The Seckhtaty
. of the Air Foree,.‘or one of his assistants, issued a certifi- -.
_‘eate of necessity in which he declared that the housing was |
necessary; that. the base Was permanent...
Q. Now to tie this in with the exhibit, I. want té hand.
[fol. 99] you Exhibit 3 and agk vou if that is the certificate
; that you are ee: about being issued in this cast ;
y
i
. .] : . . .
= Yessir; this is the certificate. : :
@ °While it- speaks for itself, you might continue’ your x
answer ‘there. It shows--What all does it show?
A. Well,.it shows the number of units, shows the number
of housing units; shows the average morithly rental per
family unit that the houses—in other words, what the cost
of the housing would be, the average cost, for the tenants ;
it eertifies that the housing is necessary; it also certifies &
_* that the base is permanent, and that there is no intention —
- ‘to curtail its activities. That is about the substance of it.
’ Q. Now, I think chronologically’ you have brought us
down on my general question to the issuance of this cer-
_tifieate. Will you ‘continue with the rest of the narrative,
how the housing came into, being then? ~ =o |
A. Well, thereafter there was an -evaluation: of’ the va-
‘rious proposals that were issued, and those. proposals were
again sent forward through channels, where. there were *
probably several cfr aluations, ‘and ultimately a spon-° °°
sor was picked, that is, a man who would obtain a leasd
who would construct the family quarters.
| Q. And,isn’t it a fact that the Carl Wilson: Cofpraiy
~ was picked as ‘the. Sponner in Alt particular, offset
and,
* a “@ : * -' .. : : re. ; *
[fol. 100] -A. That is correct. - ~ y-
-*
oo Me A
- Q. Well, you know, don m7 you, that OffuttHousing Cor-
- ‘poration, the: plaintiff in this case,,was organized in con-
-...nection with this construction? Do you know: ‘that? or not?
A. Bes. I do. know that. | Fs
2
}
= Nass
| i @ eee ag * * .-
;
:
[fol. 101] Q.. All right, Colonel, let me ask another. ques-
‘tion: Colonel, who first determines the cligibility of. people’
ito live i in Wherry Housing on Offutt Air Force Base?
A. I dé, as Base Contmander. y
». Q, Colonel, do you know the. tipe of lin as to their
at connection with the Air, that-are tenants in-Wherry *
Housing at Offutt Air Force- Base? amas _ éalls fora
Yes or no answer. es
“Oo Air Force Base?
A. Tadeo esha a ae eee
. All right. Who are tenants in 1 Wherry Housing at
-A. Military: persquie] and theit dependents.
- ,Q. Is there any civilian person i that is even connected
with Offutt: Air Force Base om
re present tenants at
the Offutt Air.Force Base? | : ORLY.
- A. At the present time, no.
Q. Yes. During the time that you have oes ‘Base: Com- .
--mander has anybody occupied the property as resident
tenants‘except personnel connected with Offutt Air Force
arg ?
“A. No sir.
Q. Now, in -your: narrative of how one of these projects
= comes about, I believe you said that when.the certificate is~
.- issued the Secretary of ae gives the maximum ‘average
monthly yventalg. <)>. *
A. Yes sir. . rere 3
Q. All. right. @Is there’ any fanatics: of. the Air Corie
[fol. 102] thereafter as to'the amount of rentals that may’
°
be charged to tenants: of Wherry Housing at Offutt. a 7
Force Base? *
A. Well, I,-as Base Commander, ‘of course, I wouldn’t
Zo along with any increase in rentals. Lam afraid I don’t .** |
quite understand your question.
-Q. Now, in this’ very’ project here do you: Saiescicek
answer yes or no—do you know whether the rentals were
determined on the assumption - that no Interest in. the
| project ' was taxable, or not.
@
cea en Pe ‘ ett
By Mr. Reed: Napleeneal a ».
ae What i is the fact as to what the assumption was as to
: the taxability. of:any interest in the Wherry Housing proj-
ects at the time the rentals were fixed to the tenants herein?
Pe ree ue :. 7 .. ‘«
. ¢ ‘ t p
Pe
: taxed. ae _- : =
ae increased rental.
os | ae ee
- Tfol 103) A. Po: my keane the FHA in dsincubiies :
the average rental assutned that the project 1 would aot he ©
. ce ¢->.
- @ eS e: ° * *
- [fol. 104] By Mr. Reed:
—Q. Well, -do you know, kpnnniibhiawine in ‘the Air Force
“Procedure, what will happenin case the 5 suagsiede is subjected_
to tax? dust answer yes or no. - :
A. I kuow what the basic procedure seovidex BiG
-. All right. Now I will ask you what the a receauge pro- —
: vides as to that. Rot ee ee
a
7 , me APO es .. @e
+ |
sititels 05) Ai The tenants would ultimately pay any aiai. :
tional costs that. were placed. on the project which resulted
Mr, Entenman: Object ‘to that as calling for pure bondi. ; |
. sion dnd speculation of the part of the witness.
By the Court: Overruled. ‘It Sééii¥,so- obvious that you’
_ lawyers could stipulate, I would think. If ‘you haye fo pay .
taxes it is going to necessitate an increased charge in. the
rental. Of course it isg
By Mr. Reed: . ‘
Q. Col. Beck, based on your experience, was there any
: fats importance so far asthe military effort of Offutt Air Force. .
Base is concerned? Were there -any results obtained one
way or the other by. the obtaining of Wherry Housing ae
~_ that base?
_A. Yessir...
Q. Will you hina that? o :
A. I think that the obtaining of Wherry Housing, and
for that matter I would say the obtaining of any kind of
> housing, had a marked effect on ‘the morale of personnel
_ who make up the headquarters of Strategie Air Command,
-and the headquarters. of the Base having been here at the
time—or, rather, having been one of. the first from SAC to
" come here, the housing situation was rather acute, there was
' [fol. 106] an. extreme shortage of housing, and Pod —
*
_or programs or éfforts were made to build housing, even
to the extent of our forming a plan that we called the SAC
‘Housing Association to building its own housing; to use a ‘
military man to build his own house in-his off time to house
himself; the situation was that acute. “So with the advent—_
. I will say again of any housing, whether itobe Wherry or |
other, the morale of the Base increased, improved consider-
‘ably, and certainly thé effeciency of the personnel was im-
' proved, having that worry off.of their minds. oa
°
* * » . ee * *.
. d : a
[fol. 107] By Mr. Reed: ee .
+ Q, I-will ask the question again, Col. Beck: State to the -
Court the type of personnel that is occupying Wherry Hous-
ing at Offutt Air Force Base. | ? oy cae eae ae
[fol. 108] . A. Military personnel and dependents: ae
b
Q. Military-personnel. And the problem of the Air Corps, .
if there is any; in keeping that type of personnel ‘in. the Air
Peres) ee co: ae ee bee
“A. Well, one of the very major problems facing the Air
«! i : vf + . . : ¢
- Force is -reéhlistment, retention of experienced personnel, . |
of highly skilled and trained personnel. ie ae
_. Q. Well, stop a minute there and tell us what skill they
have to have, ard training; just give them. aS: |
-A.. Well, the skills are so many. | Be ra ie
Q. All right. eS ee |
A. It would be an imposition on the ‘Court: here to go.
‘jnto them. | Bs Sn Sey eS . : Ne
Q Well; generally, res
A. Needless to say the flying of aircraft, the particyjar
aircraft that we have today, jet type aircraft, and the par-
. tieular mission.of the Strategic Air Command, that! is, the
launching and carrying of the atomic weapon, the— ell,
everything that it takes to get that job done requires people
of considerable skill and experience, and. that skill and ex-- ’
perience is obtained only af ter extensive schooling, jand that
of course is’ quite expensive to the taxpayer, to the Air
Foree and thus the taxpayer. - Once these people are. trained
perhaps I could express:it best by using an example, a
radar specialist is trained, and industry would gobble those
- people up as fast as. they can; those are the people who are
\
very—probably the best brains in the television field, and
- . [fol. 109]. related fields of that type. Thus the Air Force, ©
_after training a man, finds #tself competing with industry
"to Tetain that man, arid obviously that man is interested in
. his standard’of living; anything wé do to reduce his stand-
ard of liying causes him to leave. the service, not to remain
init, and to go into industry. ‘The net loss is to the Service,
‘12 of eourse, and the requirement then is‘to re-train another
- man to fill his shoes. In the Air. Force we have a four year’
_ enlistment, that is the minimum, and it differs from the +
~ather services ; we find that it is imperative that it be longer
than the other services because becduse: we can’t begin to.
~ get utilization out of a man until he is quite thoroughly
trained. It is not unustal: to train a man for as long m
“three years, during which time you are putting everything
_in and getting very little out, if anything eut, only to find
that you get, to usé¢ him, actually utilize the skill that you
~~ have given him, for one year, and then lose him completely -
- to industry.. -Frankly, I have, conie to believe that that is
the-single most important problem facing the Air Force.. If
- you are ‘going to retainsthe skill that we need to.do the,job -
that the people want their military establishment to do, we
are going’ to have to find some way to keep those people in ©
the service; patriotism is a fine motivation, but it isn’t
_ motivation enough, if takes a little bit inore than that; a »
mnan has a responsibility to his wife, his family, and in dis-'
charging that responsibility he quite often will evaluate the
[fol. 10} patriotic: ideals and evaluate the esprit de corps, .
the thing that I find so el pt a erin val the thing —
that I like about it, and he will put a cert@in value on it}
when the balances come im he finds that his family is better
~ off and thus perhaps he is better off if he accepts a position
inindustry. irr) eee = |
Q: Now, what has been the experience at-Offutt Air. Force: °
Base in whether or not the getting of this Wherry Housing ©
involved here-has been a factor in improving that. situation,
- in solving that problem at Offutt Air Force Base? | soe
~ A. Lthink we are definitely solving it; it, among a lot ‘of ie
*: . other things’that have been done and are being. done there —
_. have improved the morale at-Offutt Air Force Base.
|. -Q. Would you say it was a major factor?)
A. Yes sir; very definitely so. VE
- Q. Now with this procedure of obtaining this hessiiig sa
fixing of rentals—You have lived ir Bellevue, haven’t you? ,
A. Yes sir..
Q. And you have rented quarters in Bellevue, have you
not? :
ky. Yes sir. °
&
Q.. And you are familiar with ‘the scale of rents outside a
_ the base in that area, are you not? — -
“A. Yes sir.
-Q. Now,. what te ‘the bul as to te eoononiy of the
es reitals as far as the tenan
' [fol. 111] ing as compared with off the base?:
are concerned in Wherry Hous-
A. Oh, Wherry Housing i is hard to compare, because there .
- is no housing to compare it with? I mean there are no other
houses in Bellevue that ‘I know of ; but if you wanted. to com-
pare it on a square footage basis, Wherry ‘Housing. is per-"-
- haps slightly less, a little bit deus. than a — unit,
- ona square footage basis.
Q. Is the ability of your airmen, ‘your personnel, to pay:
x
is that a, basic facior in determining your maximum rentals |
there?”
a é
: a* : * ad “s ‘-s eo: = ed
Ae T don't believe it is, Mr. Reed, I think that’ the ventals
are determined by the computations made, which will tell
what the sponsor is going to have to get out of it to pay off
that mortgage.
Q. Allright. But, now, suppose that that figure woukd be
more than you think your personnel.could afford to pay;
_» would you then-proeeed with Wherry Housing?-
A. It eouldn’t be, Mr. Reed, because the Wherry- Spence -
- Act set a maximum of $9,000.00 per unit; which _immedi-
ately gives you some tag On rents. : ey
‘. : ° :
® ES Piet . . + ° |
‘[fol. 112] Monday, April 19th, 1954, 1:45 P.M. -
ie ed Ee eS “ as eae
- By the. Court : ‘Have you verified the correctness of Ex.
: hibit No. 6? oe
pep ee Se eee ee [bie val
¥ ‘ + E Vy “3 §t-
. _ Mr. Entenman: Yes, I have, your Honor. ° *
| ~ By the Court: Exhibit No. 6'will be received, then.
: *£ i - <-_#- * we *
3 é ;
@.
By Mr. Reed: | |
Q. Col. Beck, how many Wherry Housing units are there -
on Offutt Air Force Base? ee oe
A, 611. _ ae ters) ae
“Mr. Reed: Mr. Entenman, may we stipulate that on the’
basis of the purported 1952. valuation the tax.on the prop- . -
) --erty of‘the plaintiff involved in this action was $10,783.45? . |.
7 Mr. Entenman: And why don’t you put in your gtipula- — ~
| tion, ‘including County and State’’? ae, ;
... Mr. Reed: All right. _The County and State taxes. —
_.,. And may we also. stipulate that on the basis-of thé"1953
valuations and the assessment o¥ the fifty percent of the
[fol. 113] actual. value that the: County and State taxes -
. - would have amounted to $15,865.69.
| 5 _ A: Yes,sir.
Mr. Entenman: Which includes both the improvements—
-. add that there—and the household appliances. By
Mr. Reed: All right. I was trying to, connect that; I said ©
on the same basis as the year before, and they were both
in there the year before. Be
Mr. Entenman: Yes.
| _. By Mr. Reed: : = ; so
-_ Q. Col. Beck, I think you have testified that the land that —
was designated on Exhibit 8 as Tract 48, this map here; -
look at that, please. Are you familijar'with my question?
“> A. Yes sir. , aes aa am,
|. Q.. That was the land acquired from the-Omaha Chamber
_ of Commerce. Isn’t that your testimony? Se
Da Sue -@
|
Q. All right,-when, was that land acquired?
> A. In the fall of 1949, October,
Q. And by whom was it acquired from the Omaha Cham-
ber of Commerce? [linen se eee Sine
A. By the United States Government., =.
Q: You were-in the Base and active in that transaction at
othat time, were you not? ee ,
¢ $5 e > J P
A. ‘Yes sir. : 3 7
Q.. Did that acquisition of that tract ica inything ¢ to do.
with Carl Wilson or Offutt Housing: Company as possibly
[fol. 114} participping in the apenanring of this: ‘project? 3
A, No sir."
aes Q. As a matter of. tact the spousor Was not selected for |
this project. untiltong agter that land was acquired by the >
- United Staies Gov ernment ; is that not a fact?
A. “That i is true. == 2
; Q. T think there were four sponsors s that sulfmitted propo- —
+ sitions, wasn’t there? ;
A. Yes sir. ks '
° + Q. And was Carl Wilson your + top-—did you [penn
him asthe number one preference for sponsor?
A. He was not so recommended,
Q. And will you tell the Court how this land happened to
thi acquired in’ ‘this onlraaed way! this tract | No. 48?
| AS Yes sir. -
- -. Mr. Entenman: I ——— to that question ; first, entess
- there is some sapien nere that the witness i is qualified and
°
knows. a
By the C out: Peden you better lay alittle more foun- —
dation. . | : ee Socrates
By Mr. Ree oe
2. All. right, give us your. ce ade about the back-
’ ground of what I have asked you about; about, how it was
acquired.
A. At the time of the acquisition of this property I was
the’ Judge Advoerte of the Strategie Air Command, and in
{fol. 115] ‘addition to that was working’ on special projects .
with respect to howsiie ‘divectly for. the commanding gen-— .
-eral,.. Strategie Air Command, General Le May; ‘subse- —
quetitly I obtaimed a replacement for myself as Judge Advo-
cate, and went to the office of the ( ‘ommanding General,
_- oceupying the position of Deputy Chief of Staff, Strategic
Air. Command, working primarily on special projects, to a
large extent the project, of. housing. I worked with Mr.
Reed, and with ether members of the Chamber of Commerce,
-- jn the acquisition of this particular property; I have per-
~~ gonally ehpoked the reeords of Sarpy County with sigan
> ‘a!
| gay; the ‘acceptance of this property on. the
é. United States Government. — |
ee | feap -
- tothe tax matter with reference to. this specific property,
and have gone oyér the plat records with the county officials
here with ‘regard to this specifie property. 1 furthey, had
certain things to do with getting tlgs. mth i) anor
Pp
hall 6 "IN .
_ Q. All right. .: Now tell us the background or how this
property happened to -be acquired by the United States in.
x
‘that particular manner! - 3
A. Well, as I remarked carlier, there was a very serious
_ requirement for housing, and there were severa] plans,
at. that’ time: for obtaining housing. There is very little
_ real estate on Offutt Air Force Base that is not used—al-
ready used or which is not ‘in an over-run of runway and
-thus not usable fer construction. No matter which way we .
- turned—and that was even before the Wherry-Spence Act .;
ffol. 116] was passed,’ perhaps before it was even thought
ot—it was obvious that we would have to have some land
on whieh to build anything in the way of housing. General -
Le .May had talked with members of the Chamber of ‘Com- .
) . merce regarding thie acquisition of some property, and sub-- . .
‘. — sequently it was obtained; as I recall, the Chamber of Com- —
merce obtained an option on some forty-eight and a frattion— .
‘acres from, I believe Dr. James, and this option was later
exercised and the property deeded -to the United States
Government, and then accepted by the Seeretary of the Air
Force on behalf of the United States Government.
_ Q. Do you know the reason, the objective reason, why it —
‘was accepted ‘by the United States? =
A. One of the purposes expressly stated was for the con-
struction of housing, although it was not limited to that par-
ticular use ;,it wastin acceptance of property, in other words,
but that was the purpose. x eee ar
-.- Q. Now, was there any restriction in the acquisition of
this as to who the sponsor would,be, as to how the housing
’ would be acquired. or, if it was Wherry Housing, who the
sponsor would be? | Besa ee Ares ess
A. Very definitely there was Not. , ae
Q. And the chain of title on this. passed directly from the
Omaha Chamber of Commerce to the, United States of.
meee eas lorergae : :
Ad .
a .- .
% rae ‘ 4 -.
. ’ S
. s -
.~ .A. Yessir.
60
AL ‘Yes. !
Q. There was never any transferring i in fee to the Offutt
[fol 117] Housing Company o® any company. that Carl ..
Wilson is connected with? . '
A. That is. correct, Sir. . | Z
_Q. Now, Col. Beek, in connection with your. command do
you maintain what is known i hag fe Base Rental Mga t wae
Q. Will you tell the Court what that is? the objects of it,
and what you do... ~ 3
A. Well, the Base Rental Office functions for the purpose
of assisting. people in obtaining family housing. It fune-
tions for me, or through me, or I function through it, per-
“haps I should say;in designating tenants for Wherry Hous- tie
ae ing; and the Base Housing Office also obtaius listings of
«
family housing in the community; in other words, in: Belle-
vue, or Omaha, or Papillion; in order to “tp people in
_ locating honging. :
'Q. Even off-base housing? | are foe
A: Yes sir. | ; . |
Q. Now, Colonel, I believe it is the basic ieitel: the aver-
age rental of Wherry ‘Housing, exclusive of utilities, is
$71.04 a. month, is it not? ines >
A. Yes sir.
Q. State, if you biaeatiineie answ weak the question on a ~
square footage ba-i -is, or there was some mention of it-—hgw
does that: compare percentagewise with square. footage .
space, rental space, off the base? based upon your knowl- .
{fot 18] edge va your records of your Base Rental Office. 2
5, AE A « cS fae Se. econ oot ae
A. Ae I tastified earlier, Mr. Reed, the Wherry Housing :
“js cheaper ; the exact amount it is cheaper i is pretty difficult,
-beeause we would have to have a comparines. ‘
By Mr. Reed: : ae
“i Well, on a square foot baiis,. that you sit 7
A. Well, I would say perhaps twenty- five percent less for:
‘ Wherry Housing than it is for off- base housing; but again
owe have-—there are so many elements to take into considera-
- tion that. 1 can’t state exactly what it would be; but it “is
_ cheaper we know that. Spee Eta
MM - : ‘ BY e P
. . * e - oe? . *. igi fe
¢ .
(fol. ing] Cross-examination. ie | |
es
_ By Mr. Orville Entenman:
Q Now, Col. Beck, you ‘testified on direct examifation —
- that the area as shown on Exhibit 10.is included in the land
or the property belonging to the United States Govern-
ment was al] Offutt Air Force Base.
A..Yes sir, :
[fol: 120] -Q. Now, does’ airy of that yeecerty inelnde what
“a was formerly kriown as ‘Fhe Martin Bomber Plant?
A. Yes sir...
Q. Is that occupied by the onfutt Air Foree Base!
A. Yes sir. ° oe ti ee
Q. Is there any lbnsen on that building? | iS
A.. A part of that building, part of Building ‘‘D”’, which :
* isthe Martin Bomber Plant proper, is under the jurisdiction
eee of the Air Materie}.Commarid with offices in W right Patter-
' son Air Force- Base, and is nat directly under my jurisdic-
tion, that is, for the purpose of management; ‘and that
: portion: ‘is used for the storage of machine tools, over which.
I have no jurisdiction. - Rea
Q. Do you haye any information on how those Machine
tools are brought in there? Is there a lease where—or con- -
tract with some organization—company t
‘A. There is a company which. operates for, with or in
gz conjunction with the Air Materiel Com: and ; the Tumpane §:
_ ~. Company. -
Q.. Was that ‘contract echiead into before: the lease and .
| : _ the contract with Offutt. Houging Company?
| _ Offutt Housing? —
A. I could not tell you the status of that contract. ° = The
‘Tumpane Company has been there for some time, has. oper-
ated there forsometime. ==-———siz. e %
Q.. Are there any other contracts of the nature of the one
- with the Tumipane ‘Company, at Offutt Air Force Base, that:
you Know of? 7
Tfol. 121] A. None that i know of. DRaeh :
Q. And then there is the contract or jee: agreement with
ad
A. Yes.
Q. Now, you stated sins on direct examination: here. that
j the application or r the: procedures followed here i in securing
——o
rss
eR ee ee
e
this Offutt Housing anits, and the scimstesiation, was ‘unde. a
through channels; now, what did you. mean. - by ‘through
’ " channels’? -
= * Well, I meant the normal military ‘deanals: which——_
You were ‘asking for an. Syne of” —ey channels?
Q. Yes.
A. In this case i it eats go trom the ‘3902nd Air Base |
the Chief. of Staff, United States’
Secretary of the Air Force.
“Wing to Headquarters, Strategic: % bree, th thence to -
ree, thence to the
: | a
e * # tt o * ae ae
Q. Now, do you know the maximum amounts that were.
. “granted under this title aid of the Wherry Housing unit?
A.-You. mean the maximum mortgage?
—-Q: Yes.
_ [fol. 122] A. Yes.,
Q. And how far i is. the Offut’ mortgage can that?:
_ A. Lunderstood it was mighty close to it, or right on it;
although I, again, have wee div ided the mortgage by the
: number of units.
Q: What! =. 9° oe
A, I have never done the math- matics, but it was my
understanding that. the mortgage -™ right up to a hilt.
,
te ee * Soe o * *
~Q. Do you ener what the amount was’ that was secured —
under this contract, and under this .proposal?
Ge he | understood it was pretty close to five million dollars;
'Q. Now, you stated that there was amore ‘than one pro-
oe posal. Whio else made proposals, then,’ as Aa are referring
-.tothemt = |
_ A.. Only one that I ean esnenabier offhand, and that was -
_ an organization, McCarthy; I believe that was out of New
y
York. . I don’t remenber the names of. the other proposed *
se. sponsors. ore :
‘Q. Is: there a record kept of that. in- ‘your office at the .
~ Base?
‘A. ‘There will be on ‘the Base, yes. :
Q Now, in stating that-the Offutt Housing was necessary
for military personnel and its dependents, what do y ou mean -
© dependents of ee personnel?
!
?
*
a = Well, I mean
[ 10l. 123] dren my. dependents. If my mother was depend-
-— | ent upon me, she would likewise by my dependent; or father,
_ or anyene else who was legally a dependent.
Q. Well. now, is it possible then in the Offutt Housing
| 7 ‘Units. ‘there that: mothers-in-law or fathers-in-law, or
+ mothers and fathers, may live there too? |
A. If they live with the member. of the/ Military Serviee,
. and4f they are dependent upon that member. . :
Q. They would have to be dependents, though? » |
A.’ Well, yes; unless they were there in a guest status.’
~Q. And. how long might that guest status last? -
A, I don’t think there is any definite period involved., ~
~ Q. Do you know whether or not there) js anys such regula
; Hon, that controls that? _ 7
A. Which regulation? =
' Q. As. to Offutt Housing; either by'3 yon or or Offutt :
<= Housing; , the military authorities, or-——
a. a | really don’t get your question. Regulation doing
ss what?
+ Q. In determining what length of time anyone outside the
I consider" my wife and my two chil- eS
immediate family may live j in those quarters with the. ‘mili- _ :
tary man and-his family. Are there any regulations, t that.
you know ot. ;
A. There are none that. I know of.
Q. Now, our testimony on direet examination you
testified that ‘this would assist in encouraging reenlistments.
What-is the &verage lenge of time. that the’: -airman is
stationed at Offutt/Field? - aba
— [fol: 124] A. Oh, Offutt; I would say pemighly two years;
perhaps a little bit more. ‘ad
_Q. Then he would be transferred to some other saat ;
_ A’ Perhaps. You asked for the.average. It has iced
to do with any individual. On the average. | :
Q. And of course that transfer would apply to any ‘air. -
‘man, whether living at Offutt Housing units or private off —
the hase? : Bere ee ery as
A. Oh, yes. | . | he
Q. Bellevue, ‘Omaha, Plattsmouth, or any other.
A. That is true.’ :
a Now, you stated in your direct examination this morn-
‘ 7 ; drawing of. the leases?” -
aa 25] A. No,I did not. | °
io.” oe
| ing that there’ were no civilian - personnel now onenpy ay
-. Offutt Housing.
A. That is true.
* Q. Has civilian personnel’ o¢cupied that at one. time?
A. I am not cert-in. “If so, it would fiave been limited to’. ’
one or two people; either the electrician, Mr. Babka, or. the |
Base plumber, Mr. Shewan; and I cannot recall whether .
eit one of them has ever lived ers. I. doubt it, but
perhaps they have.
Q. Now, also on direct examination you stated that i in ‘the
‘ould not be taxed. Did yon have siete: to do with the
Vhere were they prepared? —
Force He dquarters. *
Q. And Where do you‘ mean by that? -
“ A. Well,-the Secretary. of the Air Force* prepared’ them;
the office of tlie. Secretary 8f the Air Force.
-Q. In Washington? pee’ 9
A. ‘Yee. ceeN pia tapes a ee
s*° 2 » ; \ * - @, * ; te ¥ 2G .
o By Mr. Entennian: cee!
4
or proposed ieases’ at the time you discussed’ the matters
with the ones who were making the proposals? or whatever. -
“through channels’’ procedure, you. used over there, as you
. (fol. 126] testified this morning?
A. I don’t remember ever. testifying anything even re-
motely resembling that, Mr. ‘Entenman. -T am still a little
bit. dubious. as to what your question is.
Q. Well, were there any -porposed ‘leases, any’ forms of
lease that would be entered into with the Offutt Housing, or
any person—— _
4 A. IT have already sieiad that the baie were made, as
_ far as I know, by the office of the- Secretary of the Air Force.
ee had nothing to do ‘with the preparation of the leases... &
“Q Did : you ever =: a copy of one? | .
‘first proposals of this that it was assumed that. the project
A. The. leases, as well a& T recall, were prepare at Air
Q. Do you know. whether or ‘not these leases were pre- --.
- pared, and did you have any of these copies of these leases - x
<
A. Yes, I have had copies of them in-miy tina on fs is
merous oceasions. .
Q.. All right, did you use those when you were licenine
these proposais for Offutt Housing? |
A. Well, I am afraid I don’t know which ‘proposal.
-(). Well, .did you. use any of the leases? Did you use anys
of the, informatj on which was cortained in those’ leases?
Were you familiar with the legg@at all? =~ ‘
., A. Yés, I was-familiar with t lease, after the. lesee was
executed. .
Q. Well, did the lease toatke's: any provision for taxes?
| A. Specifically,mno, :
Q. It didn’t? {t” 7 | 0°
A. No. . There is a Paragraph which makes some st: e-
' [fol. 127] ment. I. would prefer to read it directly. out of
the Tease, rather than trying to state ‘it. ;
‘° vb 4 . . . 7 " APRS
-[fol. 128] By ss Helemies <: fe es
Q. When did you. Have some discussion | as to cea ‘amount
cof rentals? When was that? |
A. Mr. sng e when was it that I had discussion
rental “3:
‘AT wiv Wosiirery much for ‘the reporter fo read back
a‘statement to that effect. I recall making. no such state-
wih
a @ You were never: present when the rentals were a:
cussed? .when the: amount of the rentals was discussed?
_ A. Yes, I haye been Ji an discussion regarding the amount
: of rehtals. ,
Q. Do vou know when they were determined, the aniount ae
of the rentals, for .the individaal tenants, now,..of the —
[fol. 129] dwelling units there? = =—s_ 3 :
A. No, I wouldn’t récall, that.
Q. You don’t know when they were ‘set and determined!
A. No, I don’t know specifically when they were set and
determined. P
-‘Q. Were you present? = 7_|
_A. No, I was not present.’
. ; 7 @. Then you 5 don? rt know whether the the question of taxation
“"*- ‘was involved or riot? do. you? 7 ae
A. Yes, I dg. #2
Q. How ‘do you kiiow that?
mats ~ A. Well, there’ was a. document from the FHA. that so ¥
: “indicated, ‘itr détermining that, that. it was assumed the ay
_ peepertios Would not be subject to taxation,,
Q. When was that document presented? © :
‘A. I don’t know the -_ of it, - I have seen the docu- .
ment. |
|. Q. Was. that. before, or ated the: lease: was——
ie _, document, Mr. _Eptenman.
eyes
3 ALT am Aynite positive that the statement was nee in|
that analysis that there was an assumption that the project _
“would not be subject to taxes.
A. I don’t know, sinee 4. dont ‘know the date of the if
fol, 130), “Q. But you are positive. that the. taxes were ee
Es not used? o> . nk
-Q. Did you ever observe what: the lease. provided for Ss
: taxes? Do you know what it Providedt ‘
. ~ . . . : ‘s 3
. 8 So eee ces a iL 7
. . - . . . . ‘ .
. A: I kaye’ observ ed what j is in the lease with regard to:
taxes; paragraph. &, specifically... ;
| @iy Mr. r. Entenman :
a Dia you observe that before, or after. you observed :
Se are FHA: ugeacictne! or-
s)
R — wy :
- . ¢ mee . . ,
. .
\ . . ° ha ec? * rer e° a :
eo) ‘ gi . . bs ES a} a :
[fol 131] A. 5 ae aes ‘the dais of the doon2teut
ss you- 7 have referred to. earlier’ which’ stated that it was _
¥: “assuined in. determining ‘the. rentals that. the. property
. °° would not ‘be taxed; therefor-, any date relative to that .
: date I would: not-r t-rymembor; or ‘would not now.
: ,
we 4 .
% . . an i ae . . ‘ ‘
Vw Sy pt ’ .
. me ° ‘ . : > .
x v ‘ A
e =X « ‘
ee ao ad on - <
D oe ‘ .. .
. ‘ eres i |
. F . s . \
. .
+
—
sd
‘ ‘ ‘ . . : . . :
one: . e ; . a % a: ‘ e . r ;
‘ ” ; ° ‘ ° : . =
. ors ° . .
. . 5 , . : . ° :
. "eo . °
_
J Mr. Entenman:
determining the amount.of rent to be paid by the
Pats: ere, the plaintiff, for the leased premises, was that
wh, Ne. through your. department in any wiht
A. No ©
/Q. You had nothing to do with the setting of that value,
oy know nothing about that? ~ - | ar Gat
A. No, I had nothing to do with it.
~ Q. Col. Beck, you ‘state now’ that the Offutt ee
~ now is oceulaied entirely by military personnel or their ae
- dependents. reat
ee A. And their dependents.. eG
Q. And their dependents. Biber .
A. Yes sir. .- . ioe |
Q. Now, do you know the total number, ‘including. the
a fiilitary personnel and dependents, divi ing there?
A. No, I don’t.
-Q. Are they all married?
(fol. 132] -A. Yes, they are all married.
Q. Well,. then you. would assume it would. be twi ice the ye
eit. at least ; is that 'right?) 3
A. At least. “ rages Cs i a.
- Q. Husband and wife. a a ay <_
A, At least that many. ° al |
Q. And.you. have: no. estimate at all of. the number of
children?
' A.-I could give you an estimate as to the Pw a oa.
4 children, yes.
_Q. And what would that be?:
=
A. There are something—roughly two’ children per fam- Sie
<r ily in that project; very close to that.
--Q. That would bean average, then? .
A.- Yes..-I remember last year it. was: something like
BY or—I would say _— close to two. That's sa rouse
gviess, °
Q.. The ese then, asa sallfeet' ‘deduction, would be:
eo% r et of the 611.
ov
oe \rerage.
A. Close to hak
ee germ oe
a Now, Col. Beck, you made a statement ‘on direct » >
*
_ Housing and off the base, as., you, all it, -in Bellevue,
‘ Papillion, «or Plattsmouth ; now, ‘how do you determine
that difference in value? =»
A. Based on_knowledge that Pine both waneal ob-
~primarilly on the base housing, off; which from time
; to time gives me a general indication of what rentals are
doing’ in, the: community; I have stated: that anything I.
ties j that line must be general, but J do get that in-
Bs formation from_time to time.
“=o. Are you ipared to say there what the units would— ©
Have in
you have just given the average rental of the units at
‘Offutt as being $71.04; is that the highest? . -is } there a
variation in the units? :
' A. Yes,.there is. |
- Q. What is the highest rental that is received? Vi
A. As I recall it $89. 00; however; I have a schedule with.
_ ‘me which I could give you exactly ; wat } 480-00, as 4 recall
it, is the highest.
Mr. Reed: Eighty- five. I ia 't want +6 correct you. ‘Net °
rental. ‘That. i is the Base figure.
A. Well, as T say, as well pe I remember.
Bs Tee
By Mr. Entenma.; eee Js
Q. Aird what is the lowest ?-
“A. -I think it was ahout $51.00. About that:
Mr. Reed: If I may, for accuracy, itty. three, I think.
A. OK. I only missed it four.
"By Mr. Entenman:
. Now, what is the differencdsin the accom- odations Of 4
those two? .
A.. Well, there are » two differences, Mr. eteaa one
is the difference in size; and two is, there is a difference ~
iin whether the quarters are occupied by. airmen or officérs..
[fol. 134] Q. Does the location - make ssome difference
_ there? That is, if the entire -unit is: officer personnel, or |
: something, there? Is it—— | oS
Se Ne RS ok
_[fol. 133] servation, discussion with othey‘people, and on
examination as. he comparison of. rental at the Offutt |
aoe
BP ed
e pee areas:
“~—
A. Only. insofar as there is a general. ‘divilios of this
end of the project is o@eupied b¥ officers ; the other end: is
~_ oceupied by enlisted personnel. .
Q. And what proportion. of the 611 units would, you say
-.is reserved. for officers?
A. Three hundred.
Q..Three hundred?! = - .. Ga Rh OE ree
A. Yes. . . o
Q. And the other 311 for enlisted personnel? :
A. That is correct. |
‘Q. Now, does the—in the military: pay is thine any pro-
vision for reimbursement for rent er rental allowance, or
any consideration - paid by the Federal Government for
the rental for the airmen in these units?
A. There is a rental allowance, yes sir. | ‘
Q..And is that the .same whether they are in W sherry, ©
or whether they are. living in Papillion, or Bellev ue, or
‘ Omaha? jae es oe Revenge : ah te eee
paar Yes, it is. | Bulg cttahgathis Roches a
Q. That. is the same?
A. Yes sir.
Q. Do you eae what the rental allowance would = fer :
the enlisted personnell? say the private, or private first
: (fol. 135] . class, or aifman first class? - ‘’
‘A. Well, it. varies, Mr. Entenman; based on, ‘oak the |
grade of the airman; and. two, a factor of the number of —
: dependents, the. number of children he has; and offliand
I don’t remember just exactly what the figures are. |
Q. Well, could you, Cal. Beck, give us the lowest figure
that would ae wail there. if it was an airman with just
his wife, and,/we will say, not much ‘service; or the lowest
rate? *
A. I don’t Ganslace thet or ‘right ai: this moment, -
“gentlemen; it’s obviously available frori the Base, from
any one of the military documents—pay documents, 7,
_ register.
Qu And: do & know what t the highest would bet: :
A. Well; mine,’ in the case of ~ home, lés is s $136.00.
Q. $136:001 — ; 2
ie Yes. ~
-Q. And ie would be— an
Se . That’ Ba colonel.
; 60° st
>» Q. A full. colonel pa es a ; 2 \
A. Yes.
Q. And does that mike any difference whether there is
just the wife and one: or two ‘children? .
_ A. It doesn’t matter; just so you are married:
Q. Is that true of all officers, then?» :
A. Yes. ‘The pumber of dependents weuidn’t matter in
ease of: officers ; it dges i in'.ease of airmen.
” {fol. 136]. Q. But the amount of rental allowance for
officers does vary with grade? oe
‘A. Yes; very markedly.
Q. What would the lieutenant be then? or the lowest _
‘in the ranks?
A. I don’t remember. what it is. Again, it would be
available in the register. :
Q: On Offutt Air Force Base there are dis quarters
owned and maintained, and served, and belonging to the
-. Federal Government; is that correct?
} quarters...
A:.Yes sir. 9 7”
. Q. And they are oceupied by both officers and enlinsted.
men too; is that correct?
A. Yes sir. |
Q. ‘Now, Col. Beck, do the ienea or enlisted men. oceu-
pying these quarters proper, on the base; do they- Teceive .
a rental allowance? A
A. They receive—-They are entitled to a rental allow- :
actually receive it in. their. pay cheek.»
Q. Do they receive td of it?. - ace §
: ied
| A. No. They , forfeit
ance; but they pay it back before they get it. They don’t .
he rental allowanee by taking the :
Q. Now, on direct examination vou stated that you ware,
familiar with- the. acquisition of the Jand by: the United
States Government. gay ta 3
A. “Yes..
‘*
: [fol..137] Q. Particularly’ this ‘tae: from ‘the Omaha
°
ace Commerce ; Was, theré: any -consideration paid ‘
. for that }
A. By the nifed States Goverment?.
Q. Yes.
- A. No.-
t
th
_ times known as the Blue Sky, Housing Corporation i in jest, /
: _ Would it have Been possible for the United States
Gc vernment to condemn and acquire this property? |
A. Yes. ; :
se. ek . pe SP es a
Q:-Have you ‘any explanation why this property: was
ven to the govertiment instead ‘of. acquired and paid fort
oes that have anything to do with. the: ‘securing | of. this ae
housing? that you kriow of... — i
A. I think I could explain it. /When SAC. first ‘came ‘to.
maha: Omaha made ®ertain Calatias to the Air Force.” .-
Jne of those promises, and‘& very major ore, was that there’ * _
would. be- adequate housing for. the personnel of the —
_ Strategic Air Command; and, frankly, ‘Omaha didn’t make.
. good on its proniise. The ‘Chamber of Co led, |
1 orhajps, a little bit by General Le May, came ‘through with,
tii land, made it available, as ‘I nave e stated earlier, for the
construction of. housing; and. at the time the first negotia- |
tions fer obtaining this property were started Wherry |
(fol. 138] Housing—as far.as I’ know: the Wherry-Spence °
Act had not: even: been’ passed, if my- memory serves: Wo
: right ; I definitely know at that time the. SAC Housing Re og |
_ sociation, which I was very closely associated with, some-
we also needed some place to build some houses, that’s the /
oné we were going. to _pbuild by our own efforts; and that, -—
to” the k best_of wy kyiowledge and recollection, is the. way
— this’: gral t came about; it was a bona fide gifpon the part of
- the Chamber of Commerce in part, at least, fulfilling its .
obligation and er to the Air Force when SAC first.
came here. . ;
. Q. Did they show. you any sites in Douglas. County, or the
. City of Ohamat aN ee : :
Ge. —e
* . eee * | *
ae
aN 1 don’t know, Mr. Riteninan, if they dined <a
inyone, I ‘have no way of knowing whether they ‘did or not,
"They didn’t show me any. aaa 7 ety
Q. Now, vou stated on direct examination that at the time. ;
the property was acquired from the-Omaha Chamber of*
Commerce that there had been no- discussion with the Offutt ae
e.
Si ek 3 pe ees
Mg et ee
Housing Company, or organized, or with: Carl Wilson; | is
tha: correct? * ‘
A. As far as I know that i is correct.. I don’t believe that
: Offutt Housing Aenipene was organized at pat. time.
[fol. 139} By Mr. Gr aor
Q.. Col. Beck, in your direct exaniination in "stating that |
the housing difficulty was one of the reasons why it’ was
difficult to get the airmen to re-enlist. If they don t re-
enlist where do-they live? Where dg they go? -
A. T wauldn’t have any way of knowing. I suppose some
of then go home, some of. ean go some place else; I don’t:
know-where they go.
: Q. And-some of them might shy right i in the same area,
es might they not?
_ Your. guéss would be as good as. mine, Mr. Enten-
: man; I don’t know where. they go.
Q. Well, how do you mean ‘there that there would be
“better housing conditions outside than there would ‘in the
. Army? How ‘would the housing conditions be better? How
would that effect the going to another company? I believe -
you said that ‘‘other companies’* this morning, gave you
quite a bit -of competition. after you trained the men in
_radar. . Didn’t you state that this: morning? _
A. Yes, I certainly did.
Q. All right, if they are going to take obdhiions with: other —
companies, where are they ‘going to live? How do. you tié
that ap with the housing problem.
ae [fols. 140:141] A. Well, I think you tie it‘up on the pers
of income rather than the house; you ‘know, if. you have :
enough money. you ean live in‘a castle. .
Q.. Well, is the income better now ou Hide?
‘A: Ob, very definitely it’s better. tside.
Q. hat i is your opinion of it.. Pie ON.
. Well, it depends on the individual ‘who’ s gbing to av
‘hired; you know, as to whether he gets more or less money ;
but these highly skilled technicians, their pay: outside ‘is
ae greater than it is inside, yes sir.. _ 7
Q. Well, that might he tlie difficulty with” the. Army i in
"getting em to pe-snliat, Lnicsaal itn. the seen ceasht
~ . ° > or a
ae f
* 2 ° - » :
. 5 * te,3
a/
A. That’s quite true, but housing is ‘really in effect a part
of the pay. | “oh
Q. Col. Beck, has Ge F ederal Government paid ong, dime
to the Offutt Maaning, the Treasury Oe United States a,
ha 5 oe
. . * 3 ? * .- ee .
A. T wouldn't know that. > 9 ~
Ifok: 142] Redirect examination. .
By Mr.-C harles S. Reed:
et 3 TqOffutt Air Force Base "any ‘school district?
A. It is not, Sir.
Q. Is any of the Wherry anche involv ed in any grea. -
_ in which this Tumpane Company has any connection?. :
.A. No sir;-has no connection ° -with Tumpane Company
' whatsoever, es
Q. Now, in connection with the cross-exAhitnation the
term of—average term they stayed at Offutt ‘Air Force
Base; I want to ask ‘you if you. have similar housing at
other Air. Force Bases to which. your personnel might be.
‘transferred from Offutt Air Force Base? — 3
“A. They do have ‘Wherry, Howring at other’ Air Force
Bases.
* Quite eanarae’:
A: Quite a number of them, yes sir.
! Q. Now one more question: Mr. Entenman asked you if
the Omaha Chamber of Commerce showed you, and others
J
* - showed you, a site in Douglas County that might be used
. for rental housing. Do you-remember, Col. Beck, that this’
_ James tract is the tract that General Le May said that he
wanted? by
A. Yes sir; v ry definitely do. remombex it.
_Q. In other words, thé site for. this housing ‘which. was —
acquired and donated to him by the Chamber of Commerce,
Jit was General Le May that picked thé site, wasn’t it?
As Y¢6 sir, Iteso happens that it is the only site suitable .
for housing, that i is contiguous t r was cd ous to the’
limits, the boundaries of » of Oftatt Air Force ma /
973
ao"
a =
7 / 7
@
64
“Wfol. 143- 144] q). What I am, nition ‘at is there wasn’t -
‘any—-the place that was bought and donated to the United
‘States for housing wasn’t a'site seleeted by the donor, was
‘it? it was one selected by General Le May, and asked. them
to do that, to. facilitate’ housing, i is that correct? . ih
_A. That is correct.
Q: And General Le May is the siinidionaiDiala officer of the
Strategic Air ( ‘ommand, js he not?
| A. Yessir. :
(). And the headquarters of the Strategie Ait Command Aa
= is located on Offutt Air Force Base?. 4
A. Yes sir. | 0 i lee
Q. Offutt Air. Foree ‘Base has a n separate base command,
doesn’t it?’ °° Np iten: oe
A. Yessir. | vei
Q. Fos handling ‘of the base, and ‘Mies imptovenients, it
ee under tlie Offutt Air For¢ée Base. Coinrhand rather
_ than directly under BAUS) isn’t that @ fact?)
A. Yes es .
* ace sist os - + ; Bis . { ‘
rg PLL a. Rigen aol wees be : *-
[tel 145] Redireet examination,
7 By Mr. ‘Charles S. Reedy
. Col. Beck, ‘do your know the reason why the per-
centage allocation between. airmen—which we used to call
enlisted mén in military parlance—and. officers—why the.
percentage of housing units was albothéd 5 as it was between
those two classifications?
A. Yes sir. The percentage of officers oveupy ing: ‘Whetry
Housing in this particular projedt is unusually high: There
are two reasons. One is that \we have more officers at
Offutt Air Force Base than a no}mal bas¢;would have due
__.to tle’ presence of the headquarters of i Strategic. Air
Command; but another and more compeling reason ‘is the
- faet that the officers in effect are ml om rents for the
ing ‘a
airmen, 1 suppose. we, can eall this a rm of socialism |
‘in.a way, in that the officer is receiv higher rental al-.
lowance; or in effect ‘paying more ssn Beat for the same type,
of an accommodation that an airman pays & ‘3 vonsiderably less —
for. 1 ye ioe | . i : , : 9
“Q ‘- this Wherry Housing at- Offutt Air Force Base?
A. Yes sir.
Q. And then you have, theref ore, raised the pere senbnin of .
officers to in turn reduce- the rental to the airmen at the
_ Wherry Housing at Offutt Air Force Base? =~
(fol. 146| <A.-Yes sir, that is exactly what happens, -
. sal ae .— “PRET thoes |
‘Recross- examination.
By Mr. Orville Entenman:
Q. you mean that the officer that would | receive ts ae!
rent hiowahce pays that much rental?” bs
A. ‘No, he doesn’t pay that much; but theres very littie a:
difference between a three’ Bedroom Wherry- unit- that: a
_ officer oceupies arid a thrée-hedroom unit W herry. unit that
an airman occupies,. ‘but the. officer will pay considerably m
more fora unit than the airman pays. It is in effect a sub-
" sidy.
~ Herpert S. Weisrtern, called as a witness on behalf of
the plaintiff, being eye his oath first duly sworn, testified
"as follows:
og : Ae ss : ; ae, ae ts “ E *
Direet examination, Tae we E See =
. By Mr. Charles S. Reed:
Q. Please state your name. _ | .
A. Herbert 8. Weisfield. Do you want my address?
-Q-. Yeu. - ee
Go: ee Alexandria, Vi irginia. Ua
- Q. What is your business?
A. Tam iegal advisor in the Family Housing Group, Dis
Char
<_[fol. 147] rector of Installatiors, Department’ ef the Air * “9
_ Foree, We-also act for thg. Secretary of the Air Force:
a Sin gonnection with family housing, with. headquarters in -
a D.C.: Rar fe ays d
~ 104 , . .
DP wie
™ ; . Bek ag oe, ‘ ie
66
(). Does - your departaent include: what is ‘commonly os
referred: to as W herry Housing?
AS ‘Yes sir. .
G Dnt o
oO
Q. "Who was the’ officer who set up the mechanics - ‘of
Wherr\Housing so far as the Air Force is concerned ?
. A. The Secretary of the. Air -Force’s -office established |
the’family housing group. ‘Is that what you mean. Ax
) Q. Yes, but I have in mind wasn’t it a Col. Elliott who
~ set up the mechaniés as far as the Air Force is congerned? .
A. Well, he was one of the originators of setting up the
procedure ; prior to him there was another colonel. _
‘Q. But you were in Ook Elliott's office, were you not?
A, Toews. 2 eee. ts Sa ON
~ <Q: Whiie he was there, ce SE peeaags Sd
‘A. Yes sir... >. ee od
. Q. Lwill ask you~ ou “ard Col. Beck testify, didn’t ;
yout
A. Ye sir, I did. 7 easy be)
Q. Will you tell the mechanies of the evolution of Wherey
, housing, trying, if you ean, to eliminate duplication of ©
” [fol, 148] hat @ol. Beck testified? }
A. Well, first of all let me say this; that. taking the —
project after it has been transmitted by the particular base,
_™~that is-interested in obtaining Wherry Housing, with their
_ proposals and their recommendations ; then our office is set-
_ up to make a determination as to whether—as to the num- ©
- ber of units that are required for a particular base; we take
that proposal and we examine it very closely, what we call.
the qualifications, the standards that we think it should for -
the military personnel who are going to reside ont; and on
the basis of tht. we then determine what th? fair rental —
‘should. be for those units, and we then iséue a certificate——-
_ ~Q. Well, I want to ask you, before you get into the cer- -
tificate, do you take into consideration the ability of the base 26
personnel ta pay in fixing y your maximum rentals? °°
“A. Yes sir, we'do. ae agers é |
@. Mi right eoshend Bir oe
A.. Well, after,the sponsor has been sélected, and we have
Eo certified that there i is a need for the housing, | we turn the
ae project does not go forward?
. = Ae re hs aoe ie et
certificate over to the ‘maaan he then. ean take it to the
FHA, requesting a-committment to insure, and after cer-
‘ tain qualification’ that FHA requires, as to whether he has
sufficient construction money, whether he can borrow enough ° -
_money, as to whether, he meets all the requirements, they «
will then issue such committment, and attached to this com-
mittment will be.a project analy sis ‘Which sets out: the rents;
” .ffel: 149] and the rents aré the same as they appear in the —
certificatesthat we have issued to the sponsor. : pas
; Q. But if the, rentals in‘the sponsor’s proposal exceeds
- the -Seeretary of Air’s declaration of maximum, then the
* «
- A. That is correct. eee e,.
-Q. Will you continue.
‘A. Then after the commit?#ment has been issued to—Well,
. let me.add this: When. wé issue the certificate we also in
those cases we issue what we'call'a letter of acceptability, |
and under that we give the sponsor a certain amount of time ©
in which to get the project in order and get it under con-
struction, that is, to get his loan, his mortgage, his title
searcheff, and various: things neededsto close it. 3
_.. Q. I Wish to interrupt you again. You assume that we
know the pre-requisites of this certificate. In Air Force —
Housing what must be determined by ‘the Seeretary of Air
_ before a sponsor ean officially contact FHA?’ — ‘
A. We must have it d@laréd a permanent—it must be © 5:
permanenent installation$must be consideredthat it is gong
to be used permanently, a part. of the national defense, niust’
be determined the housing is actually needed there, and we
~ usually when we determine that we don’t program the maxi- -
. mum-amount of housing, because we don’t. want to have too
much housing in a partietlar area, as a maximum we allow
seventy-five percent of what the requirements aré. Is that z
- {fols. 150-151] what you had i in mind, Mr. Reed? —
i: Well, I am just, etek ¢ {és elicit the fact; yes, that was _-
hat I had in niind ‘ Hk. What is the jurisdiction of
the Air Force as to the caus that maybe charged ‘by a
séleetéd sponsor i in the instance where the project is covered |
by a mortgage insurcd by the Federal Hovsing Adminis-
.tration?. | Peete ee Vinee aa
ee
oe Peery fern eee Fae . ee oS ew
68.
project at its inception, which has to be approved by FHA.:
of
-
‘By Mr. Reed:
el” Now, let nye take this ine ‘a this paragraph that a
Mr. Entenman was inquiring | about.
Mr. Entenman Paragraph four.
‘By Mr. Reed:
Q. I want you to refer to paragraph four of Exhibit 4..
A, Yes. ;: +4
Q., Do -you know who srepared the phraseology of t Mhat :
_, ,paragr aph? Just answ er yes or no. 3
' «eA, Yes. a
Q. All right, who. prepared BE as
A. That’s prepared in our legal section in our office. ;
Q. All right. Now, Mr. Weisfield, explain, not as. a
os
conclusion of ultimate conclusion in this case, but explain
tlie reason for the inclusion of that paragraph in a lease -
pertaining to Wherry Housing. -
“gom a i hen?
wae
‘[fol. 152 1 a “The Air Force caisiiltaie the aia t fot! the
A. This paragraph is to operate after’: the insured mort- -
gage. has béen paid off by the sponsor. of the ‘opps ‘cor-
fe poration.
7 is a standardized forn
;fer all the Wherry Housing projects for all the bases
ed throught the country. =
* “<% ee * < eee 7 *
ee? wisi? you ‘would vale. to section eight. ‘In that
Saag" 153-54] phraseology in there there is a sentence start:
_ ing, “In the event any tax assessments or similar charges, Be
_and so forth. .Do you find itt | ae
. A. Yes sir, I do.
Q. Now, I will have to ask you again, I think: Who nie:
| pared the language of the part that I am asking about?
A. Our office... Let Hp preface that-by saying that this —
of lease that we have established .
Q. Well, that will fall in ‘my next. question. "Noi: state’
es are impoeed with the consent of Congress.’
° ~
“the reason for-the inclusion in theze of the sentence which if
| chafaee. ‘In the event any taxes, assessments: or similar —
: che
gas
Ey
| 69
_ A. That section’ was put jn_there for one purpose; that
“. ¢m the ‘event’ Congress vekad cauneal to the taxation of |
| ‘Goyernnient owned improvements, and that exclusive jur ies
diction—say that the United States retained a reservation
by the states of a-power to tax, that if they "had a taxing )
/ statite, wad then could reach such interest.
gs ee beg. ae ail -
— [fol. 155] AL This paragraph: was. ne there to protec if HY CY!
‘any sponsor of a housing project in the event exclusive” ge
jurisdiction is ceded with, that limitation on it, that-th)
: ‘state reserves the -power to tax, that in the event there
is such a tax’ placed upon tlie project that we can re-nego-.
tiate the lease and allow | inerease for those taxes. __
_ By Mr. Reed: Mer Se Ge aso a ge
_Q. Are yon an attorney too Mr. Ww eisfield?
A. Yes sir. 7
+ Q. Are you familiar with the United States stitution that
have to do with the taxing jurisdiction of the United States
in tases of property on Government owned reservations?
-Are you familiar with the United States statutes? .
A. Yes, I am, Sir.
QO. Do you know of any éxisting, or is ‘has. any existing,
Act of Congress which in, the instance. of ceding of ex-
‘elusive sutisdiction by the state upon the acquisition ‘of
additional Government real estate; re-cedes jurisdiction
to th state to tax a Wherty Housing project?, /
[fol156] A. No'sir,Idonot, > pr:
“°
Mr. intetiman. Just a sitinnte : I object to that as calling
for a conclusion of the witness. If: wephave a question. of
state statutes or Federal, Acts it is a/matter of law in this .
case, and mot for, some opinion to be put into the eviderice.
By the Court: Overruled. I will let ‘the answer stand,
; j 3 ‘
z ese + STeLe d _* @ 0%. * * :
f art 3 aA | 7 ti. ° 4 Pat = --
y °
hci A , ¢ . — £ wf . o
Yo a z2%e By Mr. Reed: op ;
Q “All right. As I suidewiiaid it tthe’ work ‘that you are
engaged in is work that nae to do with, including the
tv
a f Cae 4 é :
4 . _ 5 . < 6
PsA é > °
sings : s
\ei .
\ x ; &
~
G °
3 , — gesteds and then he must send that in executed}-theri we
0 eee a : SSE GES ates et cepa eee
F &S
‘securing of ‘aie hocking through? Public. law ou,
* [fol. 157) commonly known as the Wherry Act?
A. That’s right. | |
Q. Now, what other = eae were taken to ‘pring Wherry.
- Housitig. into being on a Government: military. reservation. :
in addition to those. you have related? __
‘+A. Well, after it reaches the committment stage, then we.
“are inayested in getting the ‘construction started on ‘the.
project; so we try.to expedite this matter by setting out
_eertain terms and conditions which the sponsor must meet.
within a specified term in‘which te complete the ‘project— . ;
. or to start the construction, rather, or we will cancel the ©
= certificate ; we usually give them sixt¥* or ninety days;
that means he must have a title search made of the property,
he must get his construction loan,che must also get his per-
- manent mortgagee, providing this. because the construction ~~
_ . Jender will not :take a “permanent thortgage, .it’s\ usually .
taken by a savings bank or insurance -bank; and {then he
must also prepare the lease in accordance with a ‘for
- submit to him, and that lease ig sent back to our o fice for —
examination, and it must. also be in a form we have sug-
-.-—will then subriit it to the Secretary of the Air Force for his
‘signature, either by him or his representative. And when
all those have been taken care of, the mortgage has been
~ secured, the money, and all such, then we have-what is
known as a closing; the closing usually takes place in the -
Federal Housing Adtinistration.office, in which the project |
[fol. 158] is located, and at that time the papers are passed,
-a-mertgage is given to the lender, FHA then insures it,
and all of the rs are put on record; then he’s given
authority: to goa ead-and construct the,project. _ 3
Q. Now,. the selected sponsor, isn’t i requ-red. that he,. |
. that the selected sponsor form a special corporation for any |
particular (Wherry project, a new corporation? »
A. Yes, that is set out by: the on of the Federal
Housing Administration. ~°
Q. They also will be in evidente. And ute there not model _
_ foxms of the formation oi. the. corporation for the sole pur-.
_ Pore ot fyrnishing such defense housing? ee
~~ A. Yes sir; T believe that is correct. ee a
. eX, 2 > oa ; B < .
Sa * ve oe * ~ > *
4K) ; :
eae, § : 3 . es es Sg se
ee 2 Seer ae
‘ _ Cross-eximination. ee sah age Hue a
By Mr. Orville Knteuman:,” Le? ; eects,
Q “Weil, now, Mr. Weisfield, is it correct thei that al
“the steps that you have given are provided ‘by the Wher ,
Housing Act; aren't they; particularly the certificate Fiat
“itis a permanent base and housing ds mended? 3
- A.-Yes sir.
20 Qs ianen'’t those the provisions of the Wherry Housing
“Att. |
A. Yes sit, that is correct.- | } :
_ . Q. Then too,’ isn't it part of the steps that. you. have |
as dena here were required by the FHAgHousing Admjn- _
~ [fol. rai istration before they will insure - a loan of this.
type? . |
AL Te ¥ reqnired by the Act, and ofcourse. the condition
precedent to’ considering «housing project of this type _—_‘£
* is a certificate from the. Secretary of the Air Force,. with,
. ‘these thré¢ conditions are set out. beer
” ee * * a 7 ben ae o.
a 9. Is there some discretion in his Sitabasiabnie whether ee
*. .. or not the lean will be Pacem He has to ‘approve the.
bone don’t ‘he? mre :
_. A. ¥es sir; that is rig
Q Or approve the: rroeturs.
. A. That is right: - om |
> Q. Well now, the fa@t then that the question of com- |
pliance, that is, the amount of revenue or income coming.
‘in. here, i isn’t that to satisfy-the FHA, rather than- enyone—
> else? cd
ce © Not ‘eatively ‘true; it is also to satisfy the Depait-
ment of the Air Foree: ._. = Be
. Q. Well, in what way .would they be obligated nk 4.
A, Insofér as the rental is concerned, the amount of
_rental béing paid, ‘that we get the type of housing needed.
for our military: personnel, and that rental ‘shall not exceed,
shall not be too laces a burden and beyond ° ‘their ability
a Well, FHA i is interested in their — to pai, is isn nt ae
s ttl. eo} A. That is Het, : as |
Q
° °
. -
: - nee
oS . : .
te &
Q Well | them, do you five the power ta cancel this cer. mi
"tificate? : . , 2. oe.
A. Yes sir, we do.” . os :
Q. Under what" authority? Where - ‘you’ obtain that
power? -
ae Under the: “regulations; under our. regulations that.
we have established: .- >:
o Q. How about under the, lease? - |
_-. A. There is no led$e given until after he hao completed ee
7 ‘a the pre- -requisites that I discussed before. In other «ff
words, a lease is the last thing that we give;-he doesn’t:
get the lease until the day he’s ready: to start construc. |
tion, and that we aré& sure that the Fedéial Housing. Com- :
: missioner will insure the mortgage. - . :
° Q. Well, there are provisions in the lease to terminate it
even if you would grant the lease before, aren’t there? - :
A. That is right ; but in our mechanics, the’ way we oper-.
‘gate, we don’t Zive it before. 2 ;
Q. Now, you stated that this tax clause. is contained in 2
here, that if theve were to be taxes paid by the lessee, that —
_ is for’ his protection. | What did you mean, “for his pro-
teetion’’? :
A. Well,.\in- other ‘words, i r-any .of our. projects, and
_ Offutt of course is one, no’ “taxesowere estimated for the
- projeet in determining .the amouit of rental that shall be
.- paid by the tenant. = ae
Q. Well, you mean there. no tax is paid by the Federal |
Government, don’t you? =~ =
- [fol. 161] ‘% That sone ‘part ‘ere. yes sir; that no tax is
“paid by the Federal Government. — |
: Q.. And isn’t that what you are referring | to-in your. tel.
- timony?.
A: Yes; bud in the first part of jeeatank eight, “the
Le lessee. shall. pay to the proper authority whén ds. the same
f- betome due and payable all. taxes, assessments or similar
‘charges which may at any time during the term of this . -
lease may be taxed, assessed or imposed, upon the Govern-
-ment or upon the lessee with respect to or upon the leased
_ property.’’° Now, that first part does talk about interests °
of the lessee in a housing project ; but, again, there we put
>. that in, ‘there. for one specific purpose, as I pointed out_ sae
eae befope,-this 1¥ 8 wee form of _— that we use deduce
oe.
<2. a —,
Coa
; puma that we do a justedictidnin wend the ee
state has reserved the power to tax-when they ceded ex-
clusive jurisdiction ; in those" instances we recognize that —
————
‘there may be a tax, if there-is a tax in svetate: that-eould :
reach such an interest, : ;
- Q. Well, read the rest.of the <=
A. Well, then the last is? ‘in: ‘hb sven es ea - talking
~ about that, any taxes, assessments ;'that is where Congress
would -pass an act Pefatingu the taxing’ of Government .
owned: is et as tinguished ‘from . gprivately: owned
He Ra erect
—Q. And it states that right j in there, isn’t that right? :
“A. That’s right, but there is no-statute on the books - |
“sllowing the taxing of Governinent owned property ; Con- =
—_ffol. 162] gress has not consented to that. —
—Q. All Fight, now turn to paragraph eleven of that.”
A. Yes sir. = am quite familiar with paragraph eleven. =
a el 8 : a
Q. Mr. Weisfield, does the Vokes, Wahibit-&-Keferred to
here, make provisions fe, the setting. of ‘the: rentals for. .
- the. tenants, airmen or whoever else, occupies these units?
A. Yes, on the first. page of the lease. . fe
Q. On what page? ~ ease
‘A. First page. ‘Shall I read itt.
‘Q. Yes. ~
A.- Come down here to, “hereby lddsee to'the les-ce for a:
- period of. seventy- five years commencing on the date of
. final execution of this lease by the Government and by the
. [fol 163] lessee, subject to termination as hereinafter pro- |
vided, the land as hereinafter described, to be used-for the © a
purpose: of erecting, maintaining and.operating a housing
project, | sisting of: approximately 611 units, substan- —
tially in aceorda nee with the outline plans and specifications
‘submitted to the Department of.the Air Force and in aceord-'
arice with the ‘detailed plans -and specifications to be
appréiged by the Federal Housing Commissioner (herein.
~ @ after referred to as the Commissioner). é
Q. Do you mean, then, that in ‘accordance with the out-—
lined plans and. specifications?
-* Yes, he shows us in there when. he submits this anh
-- “the sponser of the housing project. ‘Now, when we reach
___ [fol, 164] page one of the lease? .
— ie
posal, it contains: ‘all that tubcicnation in 1 conneetion. with
dhe plans and. specifications. = ae aco
Q: Well, then; what is the- paragraph four? : se ae
— Well, ‘that paragraph provides, I believe it’s thirty: ~
five years period over which the mortgage is -paid off by
~ that stage we have to have. some arrangement as to the —
' -adjustmens.of. the rent; that is when paragraph four comes __
into being’ because we couldn’t.have any mortgage under
_ 211 unless it is an insured: mortgage, there would be no —
- project; that- takes eare of. the contingency of when the
- mortgage has been paidoff. as
~ . Q. Then you state that the consideration that the Offutt
Afousing Company, the plaintiff in this case, receives is
dependent upon the plans and specifications Rees ta in’
“A. You mean as to the. amount of rent: being siureed? :
. Q. Yes; for thetenants, now, of Offutt Housing.: ate
- A. That is on the certificate; and he must fill—in other-
. .words, whein he has submitted his proposals, with: his.
' - plans: and. specifications, then when the rent has: been de-
termined he must do ‘it in accordance with that, and also -
his committment; the committment#to insure contains that «
- ‘schedule, and that ean’t be changed. . pene
Q. That can’t be changed? » = ie
- A. Unless under certain. circumstances ‘that would show.
Q. Are those included in this lease? any of those: certain
circumstances. I am not talking about if't Commissioner
*:. takes over; 1 am talking as fong as this plaintiff. i is in pos-
_session and operated under this lease; there is no way of
changing the rents or the amownt of rental he will receive?’
. A. Tam not saying that... No, that’s not true. Economic
-conditions may change ‘in connection with operation and —
maintai-ance. a tea = ade oss
oe Ce : SRS Sa
A. Yes; may require. additional funds in oue to’ be
able: to take eare of that additional. overhead; and under
_ approval of the Air Force and FHA, he may get an inerease.
in rental.. That-is correct. =A
Q. Well now, that doesn state in this lease, does it?
A. No sir, but that’s _ att. ges ie
oe
3
ee ae s z ‘3 3 , : 2 : z
a : cas : . y : Tee :
, see lS wee : %
- c ® ! : ad om . - an <1
.Q. There is + nothing about it ‘in this ‘ann; PERE is”
> there? | a
- {68165} A. That’s ‘his contract with the FHA; the coun e
-mittment to insure. - 3
Which is outside the lease, then? : - Be =
A. That’s right. ere a | ee
- Q. Do you have those plats. and specifications available 7
in this particiilar instance? — re
: A. I believe that they will be available i in the FHA office ae
' [believe they willhavesome. -= . 4. ° 4%»
Q. They woule tet . eee
A. I believe so. | Pee eae ee
~>-Q. How long has this td of lease been ‘ubadt-
A. Well, I woyld 1 essing on this form of lease. This.
lease, say, about three years. ~Now,. Sat. ‘is roughly.. ;
‘Q. Now, you know that there is. a — projet, known _
as the Moses Lake Project?
A. Yes:sir,I do. | . Bes owe itr fk Nore tent ae
Q. At Washington. ESS vas ss
A. Yes sir. ; 7 :
Q. Was there a different form of hemes used in that oaast €
Do you,yknow whether there was a different form? or was
‘that the same standard form?
Hes 166] A. That form, : the original form of lease for
Moses Lake, Washington, Air. Force. Base, was ken Sa
different; but was modified later.
By Mr. ntenman: eh :
made? do. ‘peeall?.
ee Clarified paragraph. eleven. . ® pare
Q. And in what way was it clarified? e
_A. To show the true intent of the parties, that the's prop- |
erty belonged to the United States, for the express purpose
of just carrying out the operation of law; that is all. - ©
Q. Now, through your advising the Secretary of the Air,
do you know whether or not Federal funds of any kind have
been appligd or used in this—acquiring of. Cis: housing for ».
military. ‘personnel? | 2 é
ab - 3 : | : aes : : = ree ; 3 | . E =
- Tfol. 167), A No sir, 1 de not know. + =:
. * aE eer S ce
~¢ es im 2 8. --* . .
Q. Well, what security, then, was, given to the FHA for :
- .
i sc loan of wmpney; er to the mortgagee!
hi ee eee » - & ee
’ 3 . $
“ “A, The leas-hold interest in the property.
ee eto Cee Bes
| Redirect examination. ae : oe
- By Mr. Charles S. Reed: eg
Q. You were ‘asked about the authority to make a change
~-in_the everit of ' taxability, on Parergeaearenynn over my
[ene a
: itself, the changing of the rental i in. the event; I am going to
ask you if there isn’t something’ int the Act itself that is
"a ie for the modification in the event? i
A. I would have to refresh my memory on that. :
~ Q. Well, I will ask you—and I want you to look—that’s
.. [fol. 168] the reference I made to, to 1748b-1 there, and the
~next sub-paragraph, the sub-paragraph two.
_A. Yes, it does provide for the adjustment of rents.
Q. Now, your answer, does it not, refers to Section’ 1748,
- little ‘“b’’, (b),.and then (1 and 2), of the 195% Cumulative
Supplement to Title 12, USCA. Is that aay
A. That’s right.
FHA approves: fhe loan. olan loan any money, or
approve a loan? Isn’t-it a fact that what is involved is
~ decision of FHA whether to insure a loan? —
A. That is correct. :
.
Q. Instead of approving a loan: How, the amount paid
- by the sponsor here.is nominal under that: lease here. .
ghink you are familiar with that.
_ A. That’s right... :
—Q. Is that ‘customary it in such tae?
A. Yes sir, and also provided by Public Law 211 that gre
could make the. larid available at a nominal consideration.
oa ee
7
<2 ot
wees
te
" @
Q And what is the i reason feir‘that
A. T keep the rents down. Prt
ge Reeross-examiniation.
-° By Mr: Orville Entenman:
-Q. ial doesn’t that, then, remove the hoperty from: the
‘{fol. 169] Federal jurisdiction? when the Act of Congress :
_ said they could lease it ‘and rent it toa private’concern for
housing?» | = : ae
~ & No air: é
en ie cs Oh: . a | * ee Se
®. Well, anyway the Wherry asian ie ‘does give the
e.
Eecpeiirs of the Air Foree, the Army and the other bra-ches,
t'and lease this ro waited: : doesn ‘t att
A. That’s right.
Q. Even sell it; doesn’t it? -
A. No, I don’t believe there i is ishing in O11 that pro-.
y ides for the sale of it.
. : = E e
. 4 - 2
2
~ @: Now as to the real estate involved i in itself, as to being :
“Ttol. 170] used for this housing; this act provided for the _
- first time that the Secretary. could transfer th the interest, and. .°
as a matter of fact it was of such nature that. it .is non- |
éancellable, the lease ; isn “eit?
A. W ell, the purpose, of’ that, Was so it would ‘a rae
_ security Yor the loan: :
-Q. Yes; and. to be. good seturity wouldn’t it have. to be ©
gubjedt to sale?
A. The whole interest eould be sold, yes ; but nothing else :
~ could be sold.
Q. Whenever the’ secretary of the Army, Navy or Air
-‘detivenians it to be for the best interest of national defense. q
he is hereby authorized to sell, transfer and convéy at fair _ -
valué, as determined by him, for use ‘under this title, any
right, title and interest in real atest’ under. his sang
tion, hae ros sangeet
ex . = . Se rE 6
‘ _ - </ . : game $ =
ao 78 = Ta. as Q- a* f oF =
© e =
ie [We have esi tishinlaal eas sgh ea ee
&. ‘Yes, but you have it, don’t you? »
A. No question ; but I am not too familiar with that right.
. .Q. An@ as a matter of fact isn’t that. right exercised. heres
+ ' ander: the lease you have with Offutt Housing? : 7~
~ A. Yessir, we exercise under the first part of that section. 2.
- Here’s ‘what we exercise, ‘‘Whenever the secretary \ of the
—~Army, Navy or Air Force determines fliat it is desireable, to
_.Jeas@ such property within the rheaning of the Act of August. —
ae the 5th, 1947, to effeetuate the’ purposes of this Title, the * —
- $¥en 37 1] secretary’ concerned is authorized to. lease auch
property, urfder the authority of sai@ Act, on such terms
and conditions as in his opinion will best serve the national
‘interests without regard to the limitations imposed by said
_ Act.in respect to the terms, of the. duration of the lease, and
. the power vested in the secietary: of the department con-
_‘eerned to revoke any lease made Pursuant to said Act in the —
event of a ‘national emergency declared by the President
_ shall not-apply.’’ There is where We exercise our right. -
Q. And that is under the authority that is referred to”
. there?: Q ; eee.
“A. That’s atk: ae : iy —
Q. And, now, from your opinions and operations you, .
have with that, then, do you say now that the. Federal Gov-.
ernment, the Government of the United States, has exclusive - -§
--—Jjurisdiction over the. salen toiiad that was wae! to Offutt |
‘Housing? eae
AS Yes sir. | iy aes S: See
_Q. Exclusive? . oo po cae
. A. Yes sir. ©
Q. The lease means sacthlagt- |
A: No, you are talking about exclusive jurisdiction ; ; you
‘mean that: jurisdiction that has been ceded by the State of :
_ Nebraska to the United States Government? — 3
2 a. Your . ;
A. Yes, we have that; asa a matter of fact, ecg has Deen
no retrovessien of jurisdiction. |
[fol. 172] Q. You. have the same. right? you could kick .
Offutt Housing off of there tomorrow, could yout es
A. .No, we cannot kick them off, I am not saying that;
s
but as far as peer, police power, and all that—— .
_ 2
s . im f ; rs.
. ai apc ; ri = . ie
. 7 c . : oe
2% 4 e - ;
\
Q. Tam wi balling abast the fniterest’ in this real iilate,.
A. We have use and occupancy of’ that, :for=
Q. Well, doesn’t Offutt Housing, the piaintify he rein, have
. that?
A. We have the : use sand oceupaney. of that, fret. a
—-Q. Use sind occupancy. ee oes
A. That’s right. Ce ier a
—Q. For a:period of how xt ee ee ae
ieee Oe a, ae ee ee
- aoe Q: And for the sum of what? | = te 2
ES A. For one hundred dollars a-year.- — ae. of
3 a pa : o
‘ * eo . * a ee :
Redirect examination.
By Mr. Charles S. ‘Reed:
¢ ss | * _* nS oo . - | &, =*
= fol. 173]. “Mr. Weisfeld, I think that on. ¢ross- ‘acnisination
-thority—or. that-you testified that theré@sis no ‘Congressional ~~
: authority. for taxing Government owned propert on _the-——
| Wherry Housing t tract. Is- that-your revolection?
i. A, ¥ee sir, Pe.
Q. Now, I. would like to ask. you whether there. is: any”
“ Ganieeatiaat authority: for receding of jurisdietion to the _
state, receded jurisdiction to the State of Nebraska and its« s
“political subdivisions, of authority te tax fpy- ¥- interest in a
the Wherry Housing at Offutt Air Foree ‘Panel :
A. There is not. SS SET peek a Ss REE Feline
* 3 ° : . o ‘ oo e*. e : "
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.