Appendix — East Texas Lines v. Frozen Food Exp.
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
P la.-
- APPENDIX "A" — ,
Frozen Foop- Express, Plaintiff,
Ezra Taft Benson, Secretary of Agriculture of the United
States, Intervening Plaintiff, |
a oe ae ,
° 3 eee Bees ‘
Unirep States or AMERICA AND INTERSTATE COMMERCE Com-
mission, Defendants,
CC ommoti ic arrier Irregular Route Conference of Amé@rican
Trucking Association et al., Intervening Defendants.
Civ. ‘Nos. 8285, 8396.
United States District Court,
S. D. Texas, Ifouston Division.
Jan. 26, 1955.
Phiiney & Hallinan, — L. Phinney, Dallas, Tex., for
plaintHf.
. Stanley N. Barnes, Asst. Atty. Gen. and Chaitne W..
Buey, Associate Sol., W ashington, D. CG. for | Mtervening.
plaintiff. 7
Maleolm R. Witkey: 0: &. Attys ‘Moaston,..Yex, angl
Edward. M. Reidy, Chief Counsel, and Leo -Pou, Aiaonlake
Counsel, of Interstate Commerce Commission, Washing- ‘
‘ton, D. C., for defendants.
Callaway, Reed, Kidwell & ned Rollo E. Kidwell,
Dallas, Tex., Tod® Dillon & Curtiss, Clarence -D. Totd,
Peter T. Beardsley, Washington, D. C., Baker, Botts,
Andrews & Shepherd, J.C. Hutcheson, -III, and Edwin
N. Bell, Houston, Tex. Macleay & Lynch, David |G. _
Macdonald and Francis W. MeInerny, W ashington, D. ¢C,
Reeder, Gisler & Griffin; Lee Reeder, Kansas City, Mo..
WW. Nisbet, Chicago, HL, Carl Helmetag, Jr., Pudila-
delphia,- Pa., Rice, Carpenter & Carraway, Washington,
D. €., Fulbright, — Freeman, Bates & Jaworski,
%
¥ a ? 3 yal
Be ° B -~
W. H. Vaughan, Jr, Houston, Tex., for intervening
defendants. . | . hee
Before bis TCHESON, Chief C ‘renit Judge, and C ON NALLY
and KENNERLY, District Judges.
Conn NALLY, District t Judge. aU
Filed pursuant to Sees. 1836, 1398, and 22821- 2325, of
Title 28; to. Sec. 1009, of Title 5; and to See. 305(@), of
Title 49. U\S.C.A., each of the foregoing civil actions
attacks anccseeks..to restrain enforcement of an order of
' the Interstate Commerce Commission. ‘Presenting the same
question of law, and substantial identity of parties, the
actions were. consolidated for hearing and trial. The
~
question for d Get teri ination is WwW he ther a number. of d dif erent
commodities, as later noted herein, all of which have their
origin on the. farm or ranch, fall within the scope of the
so-called agricultural exemption, Sec. 203(b) (6) of Part II
of the Inter state Commerce Act (Title 49 v S.CLA. §-301
et seq.). By terms of the last-mentioned ‘statute, motor
vehicles used’ in earr ying property consisting of ‘‘ordinary
~ livestock, fish (including shell. fish), or agricultural (inelud- .
ing horticultural) commodities (not including manufac-
tured products’ thereof)’’, are exempt- from Interstate
Commerce Commission eontrol (save for minor excep-
tions not here pertinent). .The plaintiff in each “of the
. . F 2 S . * 3 .
consolidated actions, being a trucking concern holding a
certificate of convenience and necessity from the Com- —
mission, desires to carry some or all of the commodities
‘in question, unrestricted by the terms of its own certificate,
or by other Commission regulation. ~ Heneé the plaintiff,
supperted to a cénsiderable extent in this contention by
the § Secretary of Agriculture of the United States, urges
upon the Court a broad interpretation_of the statutory
language ‘‘agricultural commodities (not including manu-
factured products thereof)*’, which would have the net
result of enlarging this so-called agricultural exemption.
The € ommission, on the other hand, and those interv enors
e
eee :
who align themselves with the Commission, uPge upon us
that most’ of: the commodities in Guestion, by virtue -of
the treatment. and processing whieh. they receive, either
have lost their identity as ‘‘agricultural commodities”’,
or have become ‘*manufactured products thereof’’. | The -
result agythis argument is drastically to- restrict the scope can
‘of the exemption.
Civil Action 8285: in ; aa
In June, 1948, the Interstate’ Comings Commission, of
its own motion, instituted a proceeding, being MC-C-968
on.its docket, in the nature of an investigate to deter--
mine the nieaning and scope of the term ‘agricul*:ral
commodities (not including manufactured products there-
of’’), as used in the above-mentioned statute. The proceed-_
ing was widely noticed iri the affected trades and industries.
Many interested parties, including the Secretary of Agri-
culture of the United States, -the Commissioners of
Agriculture from.a nimber of the States, associations. of
shippers, motor carriers, and others, intervened. After
extended hearings, during which much’ expert testimony
was offered ato the manner and method of cleaning,
preparing, packaging, ‘and otherwise processing the various
commodities in question, the Comission issued its report
.and order entitled ‘*Determination of Exempted Agri-
cultural Commoditiés”’, 52. 1.0.C. Reports, Motor Carrier
Cases, 511-566. In such report, the Commission announced
its ‘d@finition of such statutory. term,’ which definition it.
then undertook to apply. to the various commodities under
——_—_-—
1“Ty No. MC-C-968, we find that the term . ‘agricultural com-
modities {not including manufactured ‘products thereof)’ as used
in‘ section 203(b) (6) of the Interstate Commerce Act means:
Products raised. or produced on farms by ‘tillage and cultivation
of the soil (such as vegetables, fruits, and nuts) ; forest products ;
live ‘poultry and bees; and commodities produced by ordinary
livestock, live poultry, and bees (such as milk, wool, eggs, and
honey), but not including any such products or commodities which,
as a result of some treatment, ivave, been so changed as to possess
new forms, qualities, or properties, or result in eombination=>
Pan
2
°
ta : a -
a
consideration, and enumerated those which it found to come:
within the statutory language, and those. which it found to
fall without.” e Pherenpon, the proceeding was Terminated
and removed fron: the Commission docket. ®
The plaintiff Frozen Food Express Was not a. party to
the proceeding héfore the Commission. By amended com-
plaint filed here Jul¥ 12, 1954,. plaintiff . alleges that it
desires to carry agr icultural commodities (not including
manufactured products thereof) for hire, to and from. all
points withim the United States, irrespective of the limita-
tions imposed by its. own certificate: that the report of
‘April 13, 1951, deprives plaintiff. of its right .te do so..
Alleging that the action of the C ommissiong int entering the
report in question, was arbitrary, capricious and-unreason- —
—_——Oo
2 We find that the term ‘agricultural commodities’ {not inelud-
‘ing manufactured products thereof)’ as used in section 203 (b) (6)
includes: .(1) fruits, berries, and vegetables which remain in their
* natural state, including those packaged in bags or other containers,
but excluding those placed in hermeticaHy-sealed_containers, thore
frozen ,or quick frozen, and those shelled, sliced, :shredded
| chopped up; (2) fruits, berries, and vegetables dried cata or
artificially; (3) seeds; including inoculated seeds, bit not seeds
_ prepared for condiment: use. or those which havé been deawned,
searified or otherwise treated for seeding purposes; (4) forage,
v4 straw, corn arid sorghum fodder, corn eobs, and stover
(5) (a) hops and castor beans, and (b)-leaf tobacco, but excludirig
redried tobacco leaf; (6) raw peanuts, and other nuts, unshelled ;
(7) whole grains, namely, wheat, rye, corn, rice, oatsy Warley and
sorghum grain, not including dehulled rice and oats, or pearled .
barley; (8) (a) cotton in bales or in-the seed, (b) cottonseed and
flaxseed, and (c) ramie- fiber, flax fiber, and hemp fiber: (9) live
poultry, namely, thickens, turkeys, ducks, geese, and- guineas;
(10) milk; cream, and skim milk. ineluding. that: which has been
pasteurized, standardized, milk, homégenized’ milk and cream,
vitamin ‘D’ milk, and vitamin ‘D° skim milk; (11) wool and -
mohair, excluding cleaned and scoured wool and mohair; (12) eggs,
including oiled eggs, but excluding: whole or shelled eggs, frozen
or dried eggs, frozen’ or dried egg yolks, and frozen or dried egg
albumin: (13) (a) trees which liave been felled’and those trimmed.
eut to length, peeled or split, but not further processed, and (1)
erude resin, maple sap, bark, leaves, Spanish moss, and. ania
(14) sugar cane, sugar heets, honey in the ‘comb, atid Atrained
honey.”’ ;
oe
‘2 ‘oa.
able, that it-constituted-an abuse oLdiseretion and a Viela-
tion of the Corimission ‘s statutory powers, the ‘plaintiff ~~.
‘here seeks an ‘injunction to restrain the Commission and
the United States from, enforcing or recognizing’ the
validity of such report; restraining interference with the
plaintiff's proposed transportation of such agricultural
-eotmmodities (not inéluding manufactured products there-
of), and seeks an order of this Cour{ declaring the report
of the Commission of April 13, 1951,.t& be null and void.
The Secretary of Agriculture has interveywed, denominat-
ing himself ‘Intervening Plaintiff’. makes common
cause with plaintiff in contending That a number of com-
modities* are within the exemption, Several trucking | °
‘associations, and seme sixty songhern and western railfoad
companies, have intervened. These intervenors take a con-
trary view, and support the report of. the Interstate
Commerce Commission. es a
-
[1} We are of tlie opinion that the action may not be
maintained, and must be dismissed, for the reason that the
report and order of the Interstate Commerce Commissi¢n — *
of April 13, 1951, is not an ‘‘order’’ subject to judicial
review under any of the statutes cited. The proceeding
before the Commission ‘was not an adversary one. The
order which initiated it purported to do no mere than
direct that ani investigation be made of the meaning of the
statutory language. Notice was given only to the public.
When the final report and order was fortheoming some two
years later, the only ‘‘order’’ entered was one discontinuing
the proceeding and removing it from the Commission's
docket. “The question is controlled by U.S. v. Los Angeles
*** (1) Slaughtered meat animays and fresh megte;
(2) Dressed and cut-up potiltry. fresh or frezen ;
(3) Feathers; aN eee Ras» : ;
(4) Raw shelled peanats and raw shelied nuts;
~* ¢) Hay chopped up fine; 4
(6) Cotton linters and cottensecd tulls ; , .
- . (7) Frozen. cream,. frozen skim milk. and frozen milk;
(8) Seeds which have been deawned, searified, or inoculatesl.’”
;
. aaa ete . a Jay a
» .&§. LR. Co., 273 U.S. 299, 47S. Ct. 413, 414, 71 L.Ed. 65
holding @ very similar.‘‘order’’ of the Interstate ( iontet
Commission which found, after an investigation, the value
of certain railroad properties, not to be subject to review.
The language of Mr..Justi¢e Brandeis, speaking for a wil:
animous Court there, aptly describes the order in issue
here: :
‘‘The sv-called order here complained of is one which
*does not command the carrier to do, or to refrain from
doing, any thing; which does not grant or withhold
any authority, privilege, or license; which does not
extend or abridge any power or facility; which does
not subject the carrier to any liability, eivil .or
“eriminal; which does not ‘change the carrier’ 5 existing
‘er future status or condition; which does. not deter-
mine any right or obligation. This so-called order is
merely the fermal record of conclusions: reached. after.
a study of data collected in-the course of extensive © -
research conducted - by the Commission, through its
_- employees. It is the exercise solely. of the function of
. investigation.” |
“The proponents of jurisdiction here rely upon Columbia
Broadcasting System v. U. S.,-316. U.S. 407, 62 8. Ct. 1194,
86 L.Ed. 1563. It was there held that an order of the
Federal Comrpunications Commission. promulgating certain:
rules and reguiations requiring that the Comniission deny
a license to broadcasting stations under certain circum-
stances, was subject to judicial review, upon-a showing by
the complaining party of strong equitable considerations.
This authority is clearly distinguishable from the present =
case.-The order there in question was. éntered in the
exercise of the agency’s rule-making power. Such orders,
together with those fixing rates and those determining
controversies before the administrative body, have - long
5 re Ua es as subject to review, U.S. v. Los’ Angeles
-L. R. Co., supra. |
7a
[2] Likewise, the complaining party there’ showed dn |
immediate and continuing threat of irreparable injury if >
the order were not reviewed. It is not so here. The state-
ment of plaintiff that it desires to carry for hire most or
all of ‘the commodities on the Commission’s proseribed
list, and that if it does so, the Commissiom likely: will seek
injunctive relief to restrain plaintiff, shows no basis for
the intervention of a court of equity. Plaintiff will have an
adequate reiiiedy in the event of such interference.
It follows that Ciyil Action 8285 will be dismissed.
Cir Action, 8396: aa |
A complaint was filed December 23, 195 3 with the Inter-
state Comnrerce Commission by Kast Texas Motor Freight
Lines, Gillette Motor Dransport, Inc., and Jones Truck
_ Lines, Ine., charging that’ Frozen Food Express was and
had been engaged in transporting fresh and frozen dressed
poultry, and fresh and frozen meats, and meat products,
for hire, between points in interstate commerce not author-
ized by its certificate of convenience and necessity. Frozen
Food readily admitted that it had been so engaged, but
defended on the theory that-such products all were within
agricultural exemption. The Commission found each of
these produets not to be within-the exemption,and ordered
‘Frozen Food Express ‘to cease and desist from such un-
authorized transportation. The present proceeding was.
‘filed by Frozen Food Express to review that order.‘
While the presen{ action -was pending in this Court, the
Secretary of Agriculture of the United States filed with
the Commission his petition for leave to intervene, pur-
_ suanit to See, 1291, of Title 7 U.S.C.A.- This request was
denied ; and the Seeretary appears here as ‘*Intervening
Plaintiff’’, contending (1) that ‘the proceedings before the®
Commissfon were null and void by reason of the failure
' Plaintiff! has abandoned the contention that meat products are
within the agricultural exemption, and this commodity will not be
further considered here.
—~
‘Sa : a
‘of the Commission to notify _ of the pendency thereof,
See: 1291(a), of Title 7 U.S.C.A.; (2) that the proceedings
should be remanded to the ee m by reason of its
error of law in having denied him leave to intervene; and.
(3) that the cease and desist. order shouid be enjoined by
reason of the alfeged error of the Commission in holding .
fresh and frozen ‘meats, and. fresh” and frogen dressed
poultry, to’ be beyond -the limits of the agricultural
exemption. ih ; poe
The rail carriers’ and truc:: “ag associations which ‘inter-
vened in Civil Action 8285, also appear in this-action. They
support the Commission, and oppose®the position taken
‘by the plaintiff and the Secret tary of: Agriculture.
Armour & C ompany, being engaged at various points in:
the United States in the slaughter of livestock and the
killing, dressing, and sale of poultry, has intervened,
urging that dressed poultry is an exempt commodjty, that _
-meat is not. Sue mas
{3] The position aie by the Secretary of Agriciiture
that ihe proceeding before the Commission was null and |
void in its entirety by reason of the failure of the Commis-_
sion to give him notice thereof, need not long detain us,
The. proceeding there was not-one with respect to *‘rates,
charges, tariffs, and practices’’ relating to the transporta-
tion of tari products, and hence was not one of which the.
Secretary was entitled to notice under the statute. “Sees.
— 1291 and 1622, of Title 7 U.S.C.A. U.S. A Pennsylvania ©
* R. Co., 242 U.S. 208, 37 S. Ct..95, 61 L.Ed. 251; Baltimore
& Ohio R. Co. v..U. S., 277 U.S: 291,. 292, 48 S. Ct. 520,
72 L.Ed. 885; Missouri Pac. R. R. Co. v. Norwood, 283 U S.
249, 51S. Ct. 458,75 L.Ed. 1010.: ‘The Commission likewise
did not commit an error of law in denying the § Secretary” -
Petition of Intervention, filed there while the present pro-
_veeding was pending here. —
[4]: Most able and exhaustive tyeatment is given ‘the
question HOW before us, in so far as it concerns ‘dressed
9a
poultry, by Judge Gavin of the Enited Stafes District
‘Court for the Northern District of Iowa, in Interstate’
—Canmmerce | Commission: v. Allen E. Kroblin, Ine. 112
| Supp. 599, 600, affirmed, 8. Cir. 212 F.2d 555, certiorari
denied $48. U.S. 836, 75 S.Ct. 4. Reviewing the long
struggle between the Interstate Commier¢e Commission in:
its efforts t& restrict the application of the exemption in.
‘question, and the Department of Agriculture and others
Tn seeking to expand it; reviewing the legislative history
of the Motor Carrier Act of 1935, and various proposed
amendments thereto; and considering the congressional
intent which prompted the insertion of the agricultural
exemption, Judge Gavin -coneluded that dressed. poultry
constituted an ‘agricultural commodity’’, and did not -
constitute a “manufactured product thereof 7, Hence, such’
“e
* commodity was within the exemption. It is sufficient to
state that we agree with those conclusions. as to fresh and
frozen dressed poultry. ; ~~
[5] ¢ ‘ounsel for the Commision x urges that this .Court
should disregard the Kroblin case, on the argument. that
the only question before us is one of the adequacy of the
evidence before the-Commission. It-is snid “that the order
which was entered was one yithin the general purview
of the Cothnission’s authority, and that if its findings are
supported by ‘‘substantial evidence’’, this Court has no_
alternative but, to leave it pindhabicitgd While we do not
quarrel with such statement-as a general proposition of ¢
law, the argument. is not convineing in its application to
the present record. The primary facts. before\the Com.
mission were without dispute and were the stbje ot. af
stipulation. Reduced to simplest form, they showed that
— a chicken or duck became ‘‘dressed naan the
chilled. ‘anil in. some cases sei eer ete.
tiori, such ‘‘facts’’ consisted of evidence of so- called.
“oxpert’? nature, that this treatment or processing of the —
“chicken or duck rendered hin a ‘*manufactuged product’.
e
0
10a
”
[6,7] It is apparent that there is only one ultimate find-
ing called for, namely, whether under the type of procéssing
reflected hy the recerd, the product falls within the
statutory definition. The’ question then isa mixed one of
law and fact; calling for. the application of the processes
of legal rensoning and of principles of-statutory construc-
tion.: The fact that the Commission’s: findings are
supportegs by an ‘‘expert’’? who gives his opinion that. a,
dressed chickeii is a manufactured product, does not. fore-
close the-question, nor remove it from-the scope 5 Rg gre
review. Baumgartner v. U. S. .. 322 U.S. 665, 64 S. |
1240, 88 L.Ed. 1525; Lehmann v. Acheson, 3 Cir., 206 F. Sa
592; Galena Oaks Corp. v. Scofield, 5 Cir., 218 F. 2d 217.
[8] In our opinion, fresh and £ rozen meat lake not fall
within the category either .of ‘‘oNlinary livestock’’ or of
‘‘agricultural commodities’’,-and hence is not within the
exemption. Since the enactment of Part TI of the ®iter-
state Commerce Act in 1935, motor vehicles used exclusively
in carrying ‘‘Wgvestock,- fish (inelnding shell fish), or agri-
cultura! cominodities (not including manufactured products
thereof)’’, have been-exempt. By amendment in 1940, the
¥erm ‘‘ordinary’’ was inserted immediately .before the
word ‘‘livestock’’. The term ‘‘ordinary livestoek’’ isy~
; defined ein See. 20(11) of the Act as ‘‘all cattle, swine,’
sheep, goats, horses, and mules, except such as are chiefly.
valuable for. euoowed racing, show purposes, or other
special uses’ | tae
Referring anly to the live: animals, “ordinary livestock’ .
may not be tortured to include the carcassés of slaughtered
meat animals, or the meat which is the product of butcher-
ing. Meat hasbeen regarded generally in the industry a
controlled commodity .for some twenty. years. Congress:
das dealt with. the agricultural exemption on many
oceasions. | ( ‘Yonsidering the ease with whieh the’ Congress
might have added appropriate’ langnage to evidence its.’
intent’ fo exempt fresh or frozen meat from ‘Interstate
Commerce Commission control, if. it so desired, the absence
Os aN yee gee
REL AGs
-.
fy » MA ~
“Py
i Faas
y
BIN
te a 4
a & aan Se
f
“dla
of sesh language indicates that no such intent. was enter-
tained. . ; 3
P
— Nor tity oer’ fresh or frozen, be considered an ‘agri
vultural commodity” for present purposes. The exemption
Ifis, treated the live meat animal in a separate weneric
class from “agricultural commodity’ since the enactient
of the statute; and if. the live animal, on emering’ the
slaughter pen or the packing house, is not-an “agricu tural
‘ecommodity’’, we are unable to.seé how: he becomes ‘one.
on emerging therefrom ‘in the tor of beef or pork. - The
Commission was correct, in our opinion, . in ‘holding fresh.
“and frozen meat to be non- -exempt.
The enforcement of the order of the Interstate C ommerce
io ‘ommission, VMCLC. W605, Fast Texas Motor F reight Lines,
Ine., et al. v. Frozen Food Express, is’ enjoined and
restrained in So far as said order interfered with, —
-or-restrains the plaintiff Frozen Food Express from trans-
eetiae fresh and, frozen dressed poultry in interstaté
commerce (when the motor vehicles used in carrying such
poultry are not used. for carrying any other ‘property or
passengers for compensation). Other relief sought by
_ plaintiff is denied. |
Clerk will notify counsel, ; oe oo
Kennerty, District Judge (eoneurring ‘in .part and
dissenting in part). ne
1 concur with all the foregéing ecpinion except the
decision in Civil Action 8896 with respect to-fresh meat
and frozen meat. | As, to that I respectfully dissent.
I think all of Seetion 303( b) should be given a broad and »
liberal construction, and that Section 30244). (6) should be
‘Construed as including fresh njeat and fro¥en meat. I think
“we should not only follow the 1 asoning of\both the District
Court and Court of Appeals in the’ KroDttr ase with
respect to dressed poultry and frozen dressed poyltry, but
that what is said-is also applicable to, fresh meats end
frozen meats:
a
©
ad
a
“ APPENDIX “B" ie
INTERSTATE COMMERCE ‘C@MMISSION
* . No. MC-C-1605. *
» Kast Texas Motor Freicut Lines, Inc., eT Av.
Boe Shes ie ees
"hry Mee re aS Frozen Foop EXPREss
Submitted Aptil 2, 1954. Decided July. 13, 1954 ng
Defendant’ 8} sith ed operations in the tr rankportafion
of fresh and frozen meats and fre sets ant
. poultry found not to
- in section 203 (b) (6) 0 ‘ Interstate Commerce Act
_andsto he unlawful. Defendant ordered to cease and
desist from - performing a service found io be .
unlawful. — ON \
oo, : ~ - .
. ’
Rollo F. Kidwell, David G. “Macd ald, Francis x
McInerney, and Lee Reeder for complaina
Clarence D. Todd, Dale C. Dillon, and C harleNk. Riddle
for intéervener in support of complainants. be.
Ne
“
— Carl L Phinney’ and boca Hallman for defendant. ag, ie
ee iS Report of the Commission Se, | roe
By THE COMMISSION : y ss ; inh ta
No oral, hearing. has been held in. this proceeding, and
it has been submitted on a stipulated statement of facts.
In view ef the lack of any. dispute as to the facts, the
clarity of the issues, and the desirability of an early
decision, no report of an examiner is deemed necessary.
By complaint filed December 23, 1953 3, Kast Texas Motor
Freight Lines, a corporation, of Dallas, Tex., Gillette Motor,
Transport, Ine., of Dallas, and Jones Truck Lines, Ine., . ;
+
of Springdale, Ark., hereinafter called East Texas, Gillette,
and Jones, respectively, all motor common carriers, allege |
that the defendant, Frozen Foods Express, of Dallas, a
corporation, is, and has been, engaged in the transporta-
tion of fresh and frozen meats, meat products, and dressed’
poultry from, to, and between points not authorized in any
certificate held by it. Complainants seek an, order requir-’
ing defendant to cease and. desist from -the ‘alleged un-
authorized and unlawful operations and such other and
further rehef as may be considered proper in the premises.
By order entered March 4, 1954, the Irregular Route Motor
Comhon Carrier Conference of American Trucking: Asso-
ciations, Ine., hereinafter referred to as the conference,
was permitted to intérvene in support of complainants. »
Complainants transport general - corimodities ~ over
regular routes in an area which includes Tllinois, Missouri,
Oklahoma, Tennessee, and Texas. Defendant is authorized
to transport frozen foods, fresh, foods, including fruits and.
vegetables, -packinghouse produets, and dairy products,
from, to, or between specified points in Arkansas, Cali-
fornia, Whinois, “Louisiana, Kansas, Miehigan, Missouri,
Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, and Wisconsin. It admits
that it has, and now is, engaged in the ‘transportation of
fresh and frozen meats and fresh and frozen dressed
poultry from and to points -not authorized by its .certifi-
cates. Following is-a list of typical shipments transported
by defendant beyond. the scope of its certificates’ during
‘September, October, and November, 1953:
Commodity Weight Origin s Destination
pata) Pounds : Sela
Beef ‘and mutton 26,325 San Antenio, Tex.... Cincinnati, Ohio,
ieee : ; { Norwood, Ohie.
Cutup poultry .. 25,674" Fayetteville, “Ark... { Dayton, Ohio. .
es ca i ‘olumbus, Ohio®
Dressed poultry . 25,276 Bentonville, Ark. |... Columbus, Obie.
— Peer Berkey wePrretere . Turloek, Calif.
Fresh beef ..... 23,061 Fort Worth, Tex. ..- Toledo, Ohio,
Frozen turkevs,... 23,900 Bentonville. Ark. ... louisviile, Ky,
Veul trimmings .. 29,967 Fort Worth, Tex. ... Cincinnati Ohio:
e
Pe: Ida
In each such instance fie commodity other than’ that
indicaied was transported at the same time in the same
vehicle.
fot : 9 . ss ee
Defendant, relying upon Titerstate- Commerce Commis- .°
sion v. Allen B. Kroblin, Inc., 113 F. Supp. 599. whieh was |
affirmg¢d on appeal, 212 F. (2d) 555, contends that -the
operations cofiplained of come within the exemption pro-
_ vided By section 203 (b) (6) of the act, and may. be per-
formed witseut specific authority from this Commission.
Section 203 (b) (6), so far as here material, provides as
f ollows: :
Nothing} in this part, except the provisions of section
204 relative to qualifications and maximum hours of.
service of employees and safeiy of operation or
standards of equipment shall be construed to include
* * * (6) motor vehicles used in earrying property
consisting of ordinary livestock, fish (including shell
fish), or agricultural (including horticultural) com-.
modities (not including manufactured ‘products there-
of), if such metor vehicles are not used in carrying -
any other property, or passengers, for com pensation
: ; “" [Ifalies supplied.
We have involved here the transportation of two. types
. .of commodities, namely, « (1) fresh or frozen dressed
poultry and (2) fresh or frozen dressed. meat or, more”
precisely, those paeckingliouse products dérived froné “the:
slaughter of ordinary livestock. Although, as will: pe seen,
we conclude that neither type of commodity fs within the —
exemption provided “by the statute, the reasoning in’
support of such conclusion differs as to the two, classes —
of commodities. Obviously. the exemption, if any, of
vehicles used .in the transportation’ “of dressed poultry
depends upon whether that conmiodity is-an “agricultural
commodity’? or a ‘*manufactured product thereof.’ In
the case, however, of dressed livestock of those packing-
house products det ‘ived from -the slanghter of livestock,
that issue is not in our opinion controlling.
2
~ &
| vee
As originally enacted in) 1935, section 208 (b) (6)-
exempted transportation performed in ‘*motor vehicles
used exelusively in carrying livestock, fish (inelfding shell
fish); or agrieultural commodities (net including manu-
factured products thereof).”? In 19388 -the section was
ainended to read ‘*motor vehicles used in carrying property
consisting of livestock, fish (including shell fish), or. agri-
cultural e8mmodities (not including the manufactured
products thereof) if such motor Vehicles are not used in
carrying any other property or passengers S for compensa-
tion.’ In 1940 the word ‘‘livestock’’ in the exemption was
modified to read ‘‘ordinary livestock,’ a term previously
defined in seetion 20 (11) of the act as ‘‘all edttle, swine,
sheep, oats, horses, and mules, except such as ate chiefly
valuable for breeding, 1 racing, show purposes, or other
spee ial uses.’’ }
Thus, from the beginning of motor- carrier regulation by.
us an exemption has been provided in section 203 (h) (6)
of vehicles.used@n carrying of ‘‘livestock’* or ‘‘ordinary
livestoeck,’’ and also in,the same section an exemption ‘ot
vehicles used in the earrying of agricultural commiodittes.”’
The latter exemption does- not duplicate the former nor
did it establish-a seeond exemption of vehicles used in
carrying ordinarylivestock. On the other hand, it must be-
concluded that the exemption of vehicles ‘used in carrying
ordir ary livestock ends upon’ the slaughter of. the’livestock -
when it loses its identity as livestock, and that there was
no intent in the same: section to’ provide a further or
second exemption. of - vehicles carrying the packinghouse
products which .result from pe slaughter, on the theory
that such commodities are ‘agricultural commodities.”’
AX congressional intent, had there been one to exémpt the--
transportation not only of ordinary livestock but also of
the products of the slaughter thereof, would tnquestion-
alJy have heen so simple to state that the failure to do so
wegatives any such strained construction of the language —
—etually used to accomplisli that end. “This conclusion con-
~ 16a
forms to that made by us in Dete rivingtion of Exempted
Agricultural Commodities, 52. M. C. C._511, hereinafter
referred to as the Exemption case. agi
The record herein, apparently for the purpose of
_ demonstrating. that fresh meat is in any event a ‘*manu-
factured product”’ of an agricultural commodity, describes
tlie slaughtering provesses at some length. This evideneX ,
° as it relates'to the. processing of livestock is beside the
point if our conclusion is éorrect ‘that the exemption of
vehicles used in carrying ‘agricultural commodities” does
not duplicate the exemption of vehicles. used in carrying
‘Cordinary livestock.’’ : Nevertheless, we shall review it,
briefly and later we sliall refer to other evidence designed
to show that fresh an@ frozen incats which are the products
of the slaughter of ordinary livestock are, in ahy event,
manufactured pr oduets.
3 ad |
Cattle are raised on farms and_ “anches and generally
gre shipped alive by the growers to stockyards operated
by, or in conjunction witli, meatpacking companies. The
slaughtering ‘process begins, only after the animals reach
the stockyards and consists of {1) holding the eattle in
pens, including resting, watering, and feedirig, (2) killing,
including knocking, shackling, hoisting, and bleeding,
(3) skinning and cutting, (4) washing, (5) stamping,
sealing, -and .grading, (6)- hot clothing, and (7) chilling.
.In_ processing » tle animals for slaughter, various:
mechanical and other, aids are employed, such as pens,
runways, pulleys and Pains, overhead conveyors, electric
saws, mechanical slides,- water heaters, ribbon . branders,
and chilling systems. entailing the use of. brine tanks,
pumps, and related gear.
Chickens and other poultry. intended to be used for food
are raised.on farms or by so-called “commercial broiler
houses.’’ Poaltry is raised on- farms prineipally. for the
production of eggs. Their sale for killing is largely in-
eidental to that production, “The corimereial broiler
ae Iva iva ee
houses, on the ‘other hand, are primarily erigaged im pro:
duciug poultry for food purposes. From 3 fo 4 iots. are
ustally raised and marketed during the course of a year.
In most Instances, chickens, turkeys, and other poulyry are
‘shipped alive from the farm or commercial broiler honse
to the processing plant. Only a small percentage of the
total ntynber raised are skilled ‘and processed by the grower.
The principal exceé ptions ure the Loug Island, N. Y., duck
industry and certain’ growers’ cooperatives, which garry.
-on' all’ operations incidéntal to. the marketing of dressed
poultry including the growing, killing and processing. In
the packing plant, the birds are first placed on an endless.
chain and then carried by the chain through the various
stages of processing, which inelude. killing, picking,
pining, Singeing, cropping and venting; washing, chilling,
eviscerating, packaging, and: freezing. Picking, is done
hoth by machinery and by hand, the mechanical picker con-
sisting of revolving drums equipped with rubber fingers.
In some plants the removal of feathers is accomplished. by -
the use of hot w Wax. The usual yethod of chilling ‘is to
place the eaticasses © tm metal baskets which are-then sub-
merged in tanks of ice water Jong enough to remove all |
body heat. - In the eviscer ating process, the body eavity is
eut open and the viscera removed, with the liver, heart, and
vizzard. being cleaned and replaced, i in the carcass. The
eviscerated poultry is then usually wrapped in waterproof
paper and packed with ice ‘in crates or barrels. Various
methods of dry wrapping are also employed. The freezing
‘of poultry must be accomplished as rapidly as possible and
is generally done in a mechaniéally refrigerated room in
which -the temperature is maintained at minus 40
abrenheit,and the air is circulated at speeds up té 70 miles
an hour. After the birds have been frozen by this quick-
freeze me ‘thed, they ave placed in cold storage anti} ready
for shipme mnt. . ioe oe |
The uridine ‘aise contains, in exhibit form, numereus
booklets, manuals, pamphilets, and statistical studies pub-
n~
nn ee
lished in 1920 and later by various Federal agencies, in
cluditrs the Executive Officggof the President and United
States Departments: of Commerce and Labor, indicating
that, Tor industrial classification purposes, the slaughter
of livestock, meatpacking, and the dressing of pou!try are
regarded as manufacturing activities. As examples, in
‘a 1933 publication of the Bureau of the Ceénsus, Enited
“States Department of Commerce, entitled Foreign Com-
merce and Navigation of the United States, meats are
classified as dutiable waperts under the listing of ‘*Manu-
- factured Foodstuffs.”*) Four manuals issued by the-Burean
of the Budget, Executive Office of the President, in 1940,
(1943, 1945, cad 1946, variously entitled Standard Industfial
Classifiéation, Standard Industrial Classifieation Manual,
or Standard Commodity Classification, all elassify meat-
packitig and poultry dressing as manufacturing industries,
and the products thereof as manufactured foods. A 1950
publication. of the United States Department of Commerce:
entitled. Schedule. A Statistical Classification of Imports
into the United States lists fresh. and frozen meats and
dead, dressed, or undressed poultry as ‘‘Meat- Produets.’”?
**Meat Products’’ is listed under the broader classification.
of. * ‘Agricultura il Manufactured Foodstuffs and Bever-
ages.
In the Exemption case, we reported the sesall of an oa a
vestigation ‘instituted on our Kg motion into and eoneern-
ing the meaning of th--tern®*agricultural comniodities
‘(not ineluding | manufactured products thereof)*’ as used
in section 208 (hb) (6). We coneluded that the term ‘‘agrt-
cultural commodities’’ embraces all products raised or
produced on farms by tillage and cultivation of the soil
(such as vegetables, fruits, and nuts); forest products: live
poultry and bees: and commodities produced by ordinary
livestock, live poultry, and bees, snvh as milk, wool, CLES,,
and honey; and that the fiitrenthetical expression ‘not iM-
cluding manufactrred products thereof’? has the effeet of
limiting agricultural commodities to those in tyr natural
4
-
-
eo
Tht,
state and those which, as a result of 1 reating or processiig,
have
not acquired new forms, qualities, properties, or
copbinations. At pawes 546 and 547, in discusying the
identical questions herein issue, we said: |
The words ‘tagricaltufal commodities (not including
manufactured products . thereof)*’ do ret include
ordinary livestock as the latter are separately men-
-> thoned in section 2OS éb) (6). Section 20 (11) of the
act provides fhat ‘The term ‘ordinary livestock, shall
inelude all eatthe, swine, sheep, goats, horses, anc
mutes, except such as are chiefly valuable for breeding,
racing, show purposes, or other special uses. It
necessarily follows that the term as u&ed in section
208 (b) (6) has the same-meaning. - Livestock, such as
race -horses, show horses, and the like do not come
under the classification of ‘‘ordinary livesteck,’? and
the transportation of. animal@ of this type is subject
to the certificate or permit requirements of the act.
Owsley Common Carrier. Application, 31 M. C. C. 778.
Voultry, however, are. included within: the broader
description ‘‘aericultural ‘conmodities.”’ “It is clear
also that certain products of live animals,-such as are
embraced in the definition. of ordinary livestock, are
likewise included; and there is no dispute that wool,
‘at least in the form sheared from the sheep,'.is an agri-’
cultural commodity. These prodnets are in’ them-
selves basie agricultural commodities, separate and
distinet from thé livestock. But slanghtered animals
are jot embraced in the definition of ordinary livestock
and we are impelled to conclude that the products
thereof, sich as fresh meats and meat, products, do not |
fall within the description ‘serieultural commodities
as used in section 208 (b) (6). [t logieally follows that
neither killed poultry nor any products thereof come
withim the term under consideration. We conclude
that poultry other than thattabve is not an agricultural
‘commodity within the qneaning of section 2038 (b) (6).
‘In a repert on povousideration in the Eremption case, 62
M. ¢
mohair and: redried tobacco leaf care within -
exemption
(" 87, 89, we found that cleaned, or 2 raw wool and
the agrieultural
ete
20a
Further, we are of the opinion that birds of the air
-suéh as doves and pigeons are not agric vultural com-
modities. ¢
The facta before us in this proceeding are more complete
as thev relate to. this — ‘ular issue thai® were those
before us in the’ Exemption case, but they contain nothing’
to warrant any different wonbhasloin: On the. contrary,
they confirm the conctusions there reached. °
On.all the evidence now before us, we concinde (1) ‘that
the exemption of vehicles used in earrying ‘‘ordinary —
livestock.’ does not extend to fresh or frozen meats, the
products -of the slaughter. of such livg stock ; (2). that the.
exemption of vehicles used ‘in‘earrying ‘“‘agricultural (in-
eluding horticultural) commodities (not ‘ineliding the
manufactured products thereof)’* does not embrace
vehicles used in carrying ordinary livestock in view of the
specific exemption in the same section. of vehicles used: iti
carrying that commodity; and (3) that the exemption of
vehicles used ‘in’ carrying ’ ‘‘agricultural (ineluding
horticultural) commodities (not including manyfactured
_ products thereof) ** docs net in any event extend to vehicles
used in carrying eithey fresh or frosen meat or fresh or
frozen dressed poultry. *-
Although on somewhat similar frets, at least with respect
to dressing and packing poultry, if was lield,in the Kroblin
case that so-called New York «dressed: poultry or eviscerated
poultry were not ‘manufactured products”” of agricultural
commodities. withiy the intent and meaning of. section
2038 ¢b) (6), we have not acquiesced i in the court’s decision,
and a review thereof has been songht. Until a final decision
-contrary to the findings in the Exemption ease is reached
hy the courts,.we adhere to the conelusion that the trans-
portation of fresh and frozen meats and fresh and frozen
dressed poultry are subject to the certificate and: permit
requirements of the act. In any event, and regardless ‘of
the final outeome of the Kroblin case, it seems clear that
21a. | ’
slanghtered livestock or the predsiets of ihe slaughter of
~divestock are neither ordinary, livesfock nor «as ericultural
‘
commodities as those terms are ‘commonly used and under-
stood. It follows that vehicles used in the transpartation
of slaughtered livestotk or the products of slaughtered
~divestoek do 1ot come Within the purview: of the exemption
_in section 203 (b) (6). | ;
The conclusion that fresh and frozen meats, the products
of the slaugi:ter of ordinary livestock are not ‘tagricultural
commodities’? within the meaning o ‘the statute, finds
definite Support in Southwestern Veediaz Co. vy. United.
States, 208 F.. (2d) 70s, wherein the Court of Appeals for
the Fifth Circuit affirmed ou appeal in a‘ertminal proceed-
ing « finding that vehicles used j in carrying: cow hides were -
not within the exemption of vehicles engaged in carrying °
“aor icultural commodities.”’ In. so doing, the court said:
In a “proceeding hefore the. Interstate “Commerce .
Commission, reported i532 Motor Carrier Cases 511,
the history of the legislation was reviewed, and it was
found that the primary purpose of the partial exemp-.
tion provided in said Section 803 (b) (6)~was to aid
the farmer. in agricultural pursuits; that the words
agricuHural commodities should be construed in their
plain, ‘usual, and commonly accepted sense. The Com-
mission proceeded to group. agricultural commodities
under three general. headines: Those which. dre --
- produced by plauts; those which are produced. con-
tinnally by living animals kept on the farm, such as
milk, eggs, and wool; and live poultry. The only group
inte which cow hides, could possible come would be the
- products of animals, but it is apparent that cow hides
—* woulde not be ineluded within = this’ group, as said
- classification. reférs oniy to the commodities whieh
living animals produce continually and with regularity.
The hide is a part of the aniinal, separable, only npon
its death; it isa product of slaughter only. The Com-
tnission Specifically ey that slaughtered” animals ,
were not embraced’ in. the definition of ordinidry live-
stock, and that the products thereof, suchas. fresh
meat and meat products, did not: fall within the
ae ee
; ‘
ription “agricultural conimodities’ > as used in
on 303 (b) (6). Lt stated that pelts, skins, or
green\and salted hides, are fot agricultural con,
oditic&< within the meaning of said section. The eon
clusion reached by the C ommission is directly in porn
here. ; ;
ry | ay Fag
Considering all of the evidence of record, we find that
defendant’s operations in the transportation of fresh and
frozen meats and fresh -and frozen ‘dressed poultry, in
interstate or. foreign. commerce, are not within the #xemp-
. tion prévided in section 203 (b) (6) of the act, and that’ fo-
the extent to which such transportation is not” authorized
in its certificates,-it is unlawful and should be discontinued
‘An order will he entered requiring defendant to cease
and ail from the performance of the “transportation
found uilaw ful herein. ° Pade i:
e
ow tee
—
25, i
°c . °
. APPENDIX “C”-
: - 7 - ?
IN THE gnu ED STATES DISTRICT COURT
: SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF- TEXAS ° |
: Eanes HOUSTON DIVISION
Civil Action No.- 82396. ; ;
a es an
Frozex Poop Express, ev at, Plaintiffs,
v. oti
U NITED STATES oF AMERICA, Fiver ATE Commerc E
— Com MISSION, ET AL., Defe ndants.
: ae odgment oe ie oe
This action, to enjoin and set aside an order. of. the
nets haces Commerce Commission, having come-on fér final
hearn g on ‘November 16, 1954, hefore a dilly: constituted
‘teu jndge ape Court, convened pursuant to Sections
2284 and 2621-2325 , Title. 28, United States Code, con-
sisting ef the baraarnaie judges; and the Court having
considered the pleadings and evidence, and the briefs and
arguments of counsel for the réspective parties, and being ,
fully advised in the premises ; and having on January 26,
1959, filed herein its opinion, containing its findings of
fact and conclusions of law; now, in acecordancé with the
said opinion, findings, and eonélusions, it is hereby
OndERED, ADJUDGED, AN Nb’ Decreep as follows:
(1) The defendants, the United. States of America and
the Interstate Commerce C Onunission, be, and they hereby
are, enjoined and restr ained from enforcing tlie order of
the said Conimission entered July 13, 1954, jn a proceeding
décketed. by the Commission: as: No. MC-C 71605, and
entitled “Bat Texas Motor Freight Lines, Ine. et al. v.
Frozen’ Food Express ”’, insofar as the said orde r requires
‘the said Frozen Food Express to cease and desist: from
trar sporting, or interferes with its transportation of, frest
3 .-
x eee | : 24a.
and ‘frozen dressed poultry in interstate commerce-for
compensation unless the motor vehicle used in the carrying
of such poultry is at-the same-time being used to carry for
compensation .passengers or other property not within the
exemption frrovided in section 203 (b) (6)‘of the Inter- .
state Commerce Act (49 USC. 303 (b) (6)); and.
_ (2)-All other relief sGight by the plaintiffs herein, ine
: cluding the Secretary. of Agriculture as intervening
_plaintiff, be, and thes same hereby is, denied.
This ‘the 23rd day of February, 1955.
@ eas /8/. JosePH C. acme: JR.
Ne Chief Judge, United States.
Court of Appeals for the
. Fifth Circuit
\ .
~ fal Tuomas M. Kennery |
ae United States District Judge
(t oot ih we Ben C. ConnaLiy
_ United States District jaie
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.