Brief, Ami Curiae, in Support of Respondents, of National Grange — Mitchell v. Budd
Supreme Court brief1956
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
: . No. 278 ienteaia Sas
SSUSEROIEEEEEE —— :
THE 4
perio Peay the Cnited: ‘States
OC TOBE. . Te RM, 1955
| JAMES P. MITCHELL. Secretary of Labor.
United States Department of Labor, Petitioner,
a ecee VS. Dac :
- JOSEPH T. BUDD, ag et al., Respondents .
| BP IEF, AMICI CURIAE,
i IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS,
of ;
National Grange; . : ;
National Council of Farmer <<.
National Milk Producers Federation, - Praia sige |
United Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Association,
National Cotton Council of America, _
National Cotton Ginners Association, and
_ National Cotton Compress and Cotton Warehouse
Association.
John H, Todd, |
‘1085 Shrine Building
: . Memphis 3, Tennessee.
Of Counsel: Counsel for Amici Curiae
L. James Harmeanson, Jr.
744 Jackson Prace, NW,
Washington. ‘D.C. aa A me
_M. Richard Garsts ane : as . |
1731 Eye Street, NW, |
W ashington, D.C a
Jose ph 0. Parker-
531 Was <hington Buiiding
Washington 5, Le ee Se eS Es
——— ne
ee ——
(=
i
oe lS
4 : L Page~
Introduction. cAnterest: of Amici. Curine ae eas
The [sues Involved. And Their import: ince
+’ Throughout the Nation - 3 : | 56
“ARGUMENT :
—. LA: The-Administrator’s Definition of the
‘ Area of Production is Ultra Vires, . ;
: and Therefore Invalid and Void...) ... 7-10
~B: The Adentatatenvor’ s Definition of the \\
Area of Production Pr oduces WwW idespread ?
and Unlawful Discrimination ‘Between P
Establishments w ithin’ the Only Geogr aphic
Area Defined or Pr escribed j in the
Administrator’ s ‘Regulation... sia A
; * (I) Exaiple of Discrimination Between |
ee Soe ag OR LE ENE LEE,
eae (2) Example of Discrimination Between |
~ Non- amare xx C otton Warehouses ...15
(3): ixarite of Discrimination Between Cotton
Compress-Warehouse Plants Siok 15-16.
C: he Congress Has: Disapproved the Adminis.
tfative Definition of the Area of Produetion,
t i | Both of the {* riteria Employ ed Therein 19-29
Sections 13(8)(6) and 13(a)(10) Express the
Intention of Congress to Proteet the Pariner.
Against the Impact (Direet or Indirect) of the
~. Minimum Wage and Overtifhe Requirements 29-32
a ?
INDEX (Cont'd) .
— z ; : \
‘ | eee
"ERE: The Piling and Re- Piling of Tobsieoegss Not 1-
Manutac ‘turing or Industrial Procéssing. It
Leaves the T obaceo in its “Raw or “Natura! State”
»
IV-A: The: Section 13(a)(6) E xemption. of “Agricultivral
Employment Applies tothe Operations of
Hespondents May and ne Kdward -. 59-40
B: Farmers ‘Hav e Relied, And are Entitled to Rely,
Upon the Interpretations of- the Department of
Labor'in Regarding as Exempt Their Various’
Farm Activ ities and Farmer: Provessing and °
*
.
.
Appendix C Full Text of the Administrator's $e
; Current Definition of the Area ~~
:
Fase of Production Aen Be * 47-48
Within the Meaning of See. 13 sta) ( Hd) | "39-35
| —
: - Servi lieing Activities ESAs coc Micid |
Conclusion. 2) 3 Senukecha SAE ECAR NORTE
ant
Appendix A-— The Relativ ec ‘owdition of Ameriean
ot Agriculture SR SNe BOR LE: TSE 49-45
Appendix B- Portions Pad ixions of the. Fa air
habe Standards Act of 1938,
} : as Amended , ; ieee ee: Fea ; ae 46 E
| TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED
nM ig i | i Page
Cases: ‘
Addison, et al. vy. Holly Hill Frat P rroduets, Ine.
a, C1944) B22 1S. 607, 614 Ck ton:
Biddle wv. Commissioner oLdnte nal Revenue, (1988) ° =
303: US. 573, 582. slat Nagcee ote on ae ap
- Budd, ot al. vs Mitchel 221- F. (2d) 106... ey ace 6
“Helvering § *. Reynolds (1941), 313 U.S. 428, 482... 19.
Jenkins: v. Durkin (C A-d 194), POS Be. (2d) 41... a)
" Koshland v. Helvering (1936), 298 - US. 441, 4472002019. &
; Lawis 4 v. U nion Cc ‘ompress & W: arehouse C'o. (1955) ) :
(No, 39443, S. Gt. of Miss.) Unreported.. menndinmsh *
es Lovyorn v. Miller (CA-5 , 19: 34), 215 F. (2 d) 601. on 14
» Maneja v. Waialua qeetoritencad Gi, (195 0),
349 US. 254, 260, 268 Pees maser rarard Wate eat 36, 38.
:
Méc omb v. Hunt Foods, Ine. (CA-9, 1948). ie
167 F. (2d) 90, 968; Cert. Den. 335 U.S. 845. inode gue
Puerto ities Tobase 0) Mie. Cooperative Assn. Vv.
Com: (C4 A: - 1950), 18] FE. ¢ 2d): | PRE |
Skidmore v. “Swift (19441, 322 US! 134, 10_ at
.Tobin + Trade rm C ee xk Co. (C A-10, 1952) hee }
199 a . (2d) Oe ’ : Dissent at pace 11 Ms Bancyabtcendar 9
_ Traders Compress Cowv. Tobin (Neo. 44r, Oct. Term,
1952), Cerf. Den. 344°U.S. 909.0000 9, 147
US v. American Trucking ASSMs., Ine. (19405, ie
Oe ee a ce a
.
\
TABLE OF AUTHORITIEG ovrep (Cont'd) s
J
: Statutes: ie ees Nee aN re
| . Agricult: ural iat Act. See. 13(p):
AZ UAC. MINS)
“Fair Labor Standards Act of 1988, «. & 676, 4 y 2S Stat.
1060, as amended, e¢. 136, 63 Stat 9 910 (290 U SY ;
a et, seq.)
— See. 3(f) (See App. 'B. pp. 46 for text)......._.5, 336
« Seg x
. See. 6(a)(1)- 1955 Amendments. Sipe nae era Neate ae
Sec. 13(a) (6) (See App, B, p. 46 - een oN
- ~
for text) ~ secrgonicacbimontaccsiteiccssciniy “Ly ely. Chg OEE
NN
‘See: as (Sec App. B, p. 46
FOr teXt) cnennnrnenennnn4T, 19-20, 22,:24-27, 29-38"
Fair Labor Standards Amendments of 1949, i
63 Stat. 910, See. 16(¢). Ree 23-24, 35
ieee
Portal to Portal Act of 1947, 61 Stat. ga. Sa: |
= 29 U S.C. 258, 259... SEI tt od DOR OM TEN TSS
cana oe
Bee ibeieiictins Plan No. 6, T EF. R. 3174, 64 Stat. 12633.
5 Note under 5 2 U.S.C. 611. RR AM Re SRT |
° ; : r
: Mixcellaneoii: ae: Se etary ae
Pe~es ‘olla Fede ral Regu! ations
. ie E ‘Definition of Area of ney: 29 C -F. R. 536.2
cat Text App. € 47- 48 He Cee ; ee 5, 8, 14, 18°
7. , % CEA 5369 (c) prior to Dec, 25, 1946 i %
i ; : : Y. . :
i 29 C.F.LR. 5 96.2 2 (a)(2) Dee. Of, ere 3t, 1948. 34.
29 CER. 536.2 (I3F.R. 7347) /
after Dee. 31; 19480 fo SR
LW x .
- of .
“ TABLE OF auronrnis CITED (Cont'd). : on
‘ > 2 i
: “Congressional Record - J Sous ~ | a
ine * Vol. x} pr. ‘T657, 7654, 660 pie Ree
ep es x pp. 7876, S76, TRIS. hil 30), 1937 ) 24-26, YS-32
‘wh Meme ee ee
"AE ip. Me rae eon ental MER SO Tei
ee oe
Vol. $3 pp. 7325, 7401, 1 i ee
NE eae i is SOR ios ee
as Pa peek i , Sp
“Vol. 95° No. 161, pp. 12804, LP. | ele OOS
: \ ; © . :
ane No, 198, pp. 15201, 15202 ceca
me st .
oS Report 1453, Sist Cong. Ist Sess., - er L Mae
Conference Report on HH, R. 5856. A ARS 22-2 : i eceeres
U. Dept, of Agriculture
Agrieultutal Bibandion, Dee. 1955, Vol. 39;
: Jan. 1956) Vol. 40. Mins? guano a Lat ~#4-45
“ ug ,
Agricultural Statics 19: 54... pe ktehdemnereass, a iv
Farm Income Situation, Oct. 1955. Sieciiciahiint are
Agricultural Researth Service Neg. 55(6) 170.......44
Ss. Department of Commeree j
‘Bureau of the Census. i Ke aie
Cotton and Linters Constimption; Stoe ks, Imports ees Fare ierte .
and Exports, and Active Cotten Spindles, Dee. me
19S; M15-15-6 |
see ae :
et
i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED (Cont'd)
Cotton. Produc tion inthe U nited States
(Crops 1949 to 1954, ane. Bi seas Heer fark 14
es Population, 19 ), feces ae Ponti “ i a arene t, 1 4, 18
" Statistical Abstract of. the U.S. 1955 a ete 440
5 See aS ‘Office of: Business Sosnuadies | |
Survey of Current Business, duly, ree,
; LNs eee C
_ S. Department of Labor, Ww uge-ond Howtr Rivinion
ae = ‘Annual Reports to Consgressy 1939, 1941; 1942. 1948, °
1950, 1951, and 1954... = So 8 12, 13.
Area of Production: Cotton Dec., 1944 Ane 14
| Findings of the A tministrator, Biss: 18, 1946, in the
matter of Redefinition of the “ Arca of Production”’
| as used in Sections:7(c) and 13(a) (10). of the Fair
PORTION te cet Labor Standards Act of 1938; No. D147 (05112)
Dibiteebities Bulletin No. IM. sheet aia
- Websteér’s Internatictal Dic ‘tionary: | « :
a," er 7 BD: Ht
c PA
° Ps e “4 <
a : -
a
~<5%
er.
Sipe Kix ae ‘. IN THE
_ Supreme Court of the Gnited States
OC TOBE R TE RM, 1955
~
Py hie 2a pe No. 278
JAMES BOMITCHEL, Seeretary. of Labor,
United States Departinent of Lathor, Petitioner,
oN 7 Vs. 5
“@OSEPH V. vine JR, etal. cages
3 _ BRIEF, AMICI CURIAE,
IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS,
of
National Grange, :
' National Council of Farmer Cooperatives,
National Milk Producers Federation, 2 | .
United Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Association, 3
National Cottcn Council of America, 3
- National Cotton Ginners Association, and
National Cotton Compress and Cotton: Warehouse
Association.
6
4
aad
der
Written consent of all parties to the filing of this brief,
amici curiae, kas been obtained and filed with the. ‘clerk as pice
| gai ided i in Rule 27.9(a) of Gochescaud
ri.
Tntroduction—Interet of Amici Curiae
a
%
The National Grange ix a national, voluntary, nol- ‘profit,
general farm organizatiog Organized in. 1867, it-is the.
oldest of the national farm organizations. Its organization
includes subsidiary granges in 3° states. Itx piembership
includes: 900,000 individual farmers. Its members produce
prac tically every agricultural and horticultural commodity,
produced in the United sci i, : nal ienhaasy eae
“th
National Council of Farmer. Cooperatives is an: incor-
porated national, Voluntary, “non- profit farm organization |
whose direct: members fre b21 farmers’ marketing and pur-
éhasing HUsiness: assoc iations, nd state organizations of
such ‘atso¢iations, Its membership embraces: some 5,000. ©
local associations,-und approximately 3,000,000 indiv idual
fariners located’ in all 48 states art] Puerto Rico. ‘These
farmers produce, and the business associations represented.
in~the Couneil’s membership market, and in many cases
store, process and otherwise prepare and service for mar-
ket, practically every major type of aerennaie commodity
produced on the farms of America.
National Sth: Produccre Federation is a national, volun-
tary, non. profit association representing through its mem-
“bers and sub- members between 600, and 700 dairy farmer
cooperatives embracing a meinbership of approximately
500,000 individual dairy, farmers located in every sfate of
the Union exeept Nevada. All such dairy farmer members
produce milk, ard in-addition to milk, through those dairy
farmer cooperatives, produce and market éream, -butter,
cheese and prac ‘tically every, other dairy product produced
and marketed in the U nited States. 7
_—
~
~
United resh Fruit and Veget table Association is a na-
honal, voluntary, non- protit organization composed, of and
serving all hranches of the fresh fruit and vegetable indus-
. try. Its membership includes some 2,800 producers, han--
dlers,” packagers, wholesalers ands sh ippers disiributed
throughout the United States.
%
Nat onal Cotton Council of America is a national, volun-
tary, non-profit organization whose membership embraces.
every segment of the raw cotton industry in all of the
eotton-growing states, including eotton farmers, cotton
| ginners, cotton wareiouse and compress-warehouse oper-
Coane
“
ators, cotton-seed : processors, cotton merchants and @tton
spinners, | a Cerio. : if
P ®
National Cotton Ginners Association is.a national, velun-
‘tary, non-profit, association composed of the owners ‘and
" operators of cotton ginning establishments:loc: ated through--
out the cotton-growing states of the’ United States, —with:
the exception of: ginners in Arkansas and Missouri which
currently are not affiliated with thynational association.
National Cotton Compress and Cofton Warehouse Asso-
ciation is a national, voluntary, non- profit association com-
posed of the owners and operators of publie cotton ware-
house and cotton compress- -warehouse establishments lo-
cated throughout the 14 ina jor cotton-fr owing. states.
Ignoting possible occasional duplications of ‘membership,
the above named. amici curiae speak for substantially more .
than four and one-half rillion American farmers who are-
_ directly and personally engaged in agricultural and horti-.
cultural production. Their aggregate memberships also in-
clude the owners and operators of many thousands ‘of estab-
lishments in the United States, in which farmers, horticul-
turists, farmer cooperatives, or independent entrepreneur
_ bailees for hire ‘are engaged ji in the handling, packing, stor-
ing, ginning, compressing, pasteurizing, drying, preparing
in their raw or natural state, and canning of agricultural
and horticultural commodities ‘for market, and in making
cheese, butter and other dairy products, —that is to’ sav all
‘of the operations on agricultural and horticultural com
modities which ‘are subject to exemption from the wage
“and hour prov isigns of the Fait Labor Standards Act under
the exemption corjtained in Section 13(ayY(10) thereof, —to
‘the éxten. that such ‘operations are performed within the
area of production (as defined by the Administrator).
a
7
Unless the Court ‘s deeision is specifically lintited to pre-
%
vent. that result, any determination of the issue relating to
- the validity of the Administrative definition of the ‘tarea
‘of production”’ of agricultural and hortfeulturaNeefimodi.
- ties, (direc tly or indirectly) will have ‘a serious effect upon
‘the majority if not all of the members of all parties to this
brief (except the cotton-seed. processor, cotton merchant
sa cotton spinner members of National Cotton Council
' America and possibly some shipper members of United
patie Fruit and V egetable Association) } — -and, similarly,
_ any determination of the issue relating to application of
the Section 13(a) (6). exemption of agricultural employ-
“ment to the ‘packing house operations of ‘respondents May
‘and King Edward may seriously affect the interest of many
of the farmers embraced within the memberships of Na-
‘tional Grange, National Council of F: armer Cooperatives,
National Milk Produeers Federation, and United Fresh
Fruit and Vegetahie Association. —e
In this Lrief, references to the record will be made by the
letters “RK"’ (Record, King Edward: Case), “RM” (Ree-
ord, May Case), and “RB’’ (Record, Budd Case).
The. duty and authority to define the area of production
of the various agricultural and horticultural commodities
imposed and conferred by Congress upon the Administrator
in Seetion 13(a)(10) of the Fair. Labor Standards Aet was
* transferred to the Secretary of Labor (petitioner) by 1950
Reorganization Plan Number 6, 15 F. R. 3174, 64 Stat. 1263,
set out in the note under 5 U.S. ¢ . 61.1. Therefore, the des-
ignations ‘* Administrator,” ‘‘petitioner,” and “Secretary of .
Labor’ are-used interchangeably a
For convenient reterence, the provisions of See. 3(f), Sec, :
13(a)(6) and See. P3(a){10) of the Act are reproduced in
Appendix B; and the text of the’Administrator’s definition
of the area of production is reproduced in Appendix C
hereto. ; :
The Issues Involved, and Their Inaportance
Throughout the Nation
As between the’ parties hereto, this canse presents two
_ questions whie h may be narrowly stated within the limits
of the case at bar as follows: |
%
1: With re&pect to the. complete exemption. from the
minimum wage and overtime re quirements of the Act con-
tained in Section 13(a) (10) thereof for “any individual
employed within the area of production (as defined by the
Administrator), engaged in handling, packing, storing, . . .
drying, (er) preparing in their raw or natural. state, ... of
agricultural . . . commodities for market"; -~and with re-
spect to the purported definition of the area of production
of all agricultural and horticultural commodities promul-
gated December 25, 1946 (29. C.F. R. 536.2): Is petitioner s
definitive regulation rendered Jnvahd hecause, it provides -
g
that no individual engaged in performing the name oper-
ations ‘will be considered as employed within the area of
production of the commodity involved if he is so employed
in or near a place of 2500 or greater population?
2: Does the complete exemption from the minimum wage
and overtime require ments of the Aet granted by Section
13(a)(6) thereof to any emplovee employed in “agricul
- ture’* (defined in Seetion 3(f) thereof te include “any
practices ... performed by a farmer... as an incident to
or-in conjunction with .. . farming operations, including
preparation for market, delivery to sterage-or to market or
to carriers for transportation to market.) extend, to’ the
‘
-" .
*5r storing, drying, handling, and packing for market of .
ye
SS. Type 62 shade -grown tobacco: hy May and aya
w nd (the farme r- Produc ers of such tohaeco) t
ae 6
s
e
The Cony of Appeals has answ ered both questions: in the ©
; affirmativ e (221 F, (2 d) 406, 410-41 1),
9.
A ‘third question involved (which the Court of _Ap-
a also decided in the affirmative) is w hether respond-
ents’ packing house operations (the storing, piling, drying,
packing, and otherwise handling for market of U!S. Type
62 tobacco) arb included amoug the operations enumerated
in Rection 13(a) (10).
i
The importance and effects of this Court’s determinati:n a
of those questions upon review will extend, (far beyond. the
production, handling, storing, piling, drying, afid packing
for market of ‘U. S.°Type 62 shade-grown tobacco in the
vicinity. of Quincy, Florida) to the production and essential
. Servieing for market of virtually every agricultural and
horticultural commodity, and virtually ev ery farmer and
horticulturist, in the United States. The force of impact of
such determination upon United States’ agriculture and:
horticulture, andthe essential servicing of agricultural and
horticultural commodities for market, will be ‘tremendous-
ly increased. by the increase of the minimam w age. provided’ |
in the | fram T5e: to $1.00 per hour’ effective Mare ‘hod,
1996 (PF. L. 381, 84th Congress, Ist Session; 29 U. S. C.
206: (a)(1)). .
7
/ ARGUMENT
ahs I-A: The Admiaistrator’s Definition of the
Area of Production is Ultra Vires, and .
_ theref ore Invalid and Void
As more fully developed in: Past II hereof, the Con-
rress, in enacting the Act, evidénced a tlear intent te pro-
£ a :
tect‘and exempt the farmer.and the hortieulturist from-any/
impact of the minimrm wage and-overtime requirements,
not only with respect to actual agricultural production, but
also with respect to the services necessary or incidental to
the marketing. of their crops, ; va
. ection, 13(a) (6) of the Act pr ovides elude for
agricultural production, broadly defined ( include all oper-
. Wations performed either by a farmer #r on a farm as an.
incident to.or in conjunc tien with agricultural production.
By Section 13(a)(10), that exemption was extended to a
contprehensive -seriés of specified operations which’ are
~ necessary to the marketing of farm and orchard products,
~-regardless_ of where or by whom ‘suéh operations are .
conducteds so long as they are conducted. within ‘an area
of agricultural production of the éommodity or commodi-_
ties involved. As an.atterthoeght,-it was inferentially pro-
vided. in the conference report, and enacted without eXx- |
Planation-or discussion, that the Administrator should, for
the purposes of the exemption, define the area ot produc- ;
tion of each of the various agricultural and horticultural
commodities. There was no suggestion, or reason to sus-
pect, that. the Administrator would do: otherwise than
simply ouiline the geographic beundaries of the areas
within whieh various farm and orcharc products are-grown,
‘or that the Administrator would ‘not perform ‘this fuuction
as an mpartial agent of Congress and carry out its inten-
--
tion with. respect to this exemption.
.
ras 8
The respective’ Administrators, hentens: have proved
to be—not. impartial administrators, conscie ntiously. under-
taking to carry out the will of Congress—but ardent parti-
sans and advocates of extension (both by legislation and
by administrative fiat). of the minimum wage. and ov vertime
requirements to every possible individual.
Successive ‘Adisidiestnes hens repeatedly wees Cone
gress to repeal this exemption in tts entirety (Annual Re-
ports’ of the’ Administrater and of the W age & Hour Di-
Vision to Congress, 1939, 1941, 1942- 1948, 1950 and 1951).
The successive administrators proceeded meanwhile | to.
issue. successive: regulations (published in Title 29, Chapter
V, Part 536.2, Code of Federal’ Regulations), purporting to
‘dofiaas the area of production of all agricultural-and horti-
cultural commodities. They did so with combinations of
‘“ arbitrary and unrealistic criteria designed to restrict appli-
cation of the exemption to the fewest possible workers.
Thus the area of production of. #gricultural and horticul-
tural commodities (generally, not separately) has succes-
sively been defined by the Administrator by use of criteria.
having no rational or necessary relation to the geographic
boundaries of the areas of agricultural: production of the
respective farm and orchard-products. This has been done :
(a) in terms of the distance which commodities move to,
reach the plants at which the named operations are con-
ducted, (b} in terms of the number of persons engaged in.
the named operations, (¢) in ternis. of the: populations of
places where the operations are conducted, and (d) in-terms.
of the populations of places’ from which farm and orchard
_ products are. transported’ to such establishments. The cur-
rent definition combines such a distance test with a popu-
lation test applied both to plant location and to the points
from which commodities are recvived for servicing. Ta the
instance case the: distance testis not directly in issue be-
cause respondents’ operations vomply with’ its terms.
2
on
9.
To approve thé population test of the Admiaistrator’s
definition, Which is directly in issue, would impute foolish-
ness or fittility to. a clear, Ponséious and deliberate enact-
nent of the Congress, As stated by’ Judge Pic ‘kett, dissent-
ing in Tobin v. Traders Compress. (: peapany “(199 F. (2d)
‘S,atpll):
; e “eogn 0
“Generally the population of a city or town has no
easonable relation to the question of w hether the plant
is located within an area of production. The purpose
oof the Act was to grant an exemption which was
thor cht to.be helpful to the farmers and horticulturists,
and i\-was not intended that the statutory exemption
shoulfl be made | Ineffective: or ‘colnpletely, destroyed by
regulation.’
ck cubliiai was eeciad and appr ved by the. Court
of Appeals‘for the Fifth Circuit-in Jenkins v. Durkin, 208
<p (2d) 941 (19: 54) and “in Lovvorn, v. Miller 215 F. (2d)
601 (1954), as wellas in the instant case.
The majority. opinion .in Tobin Tiabes Compress.
C ompany is the only instance in which any court has ap-
. proved the administrator's current’ ‘definition. As an essen-
tial basis for its decision, that majority i contains
the aang 199 F. (2d) 8 11). ‘that: 3
ae
‘To be sure, the population text does noteeffect diss
crindnation between piants in the same geographical
area, as did the number of emplovees bat condemned
okt cae the ; Addison. C ase,’
The quoted finding was eompletely wit shout support i in-
and in fact. contrary. tothe record (Traders Compress
Company w. Tobin, No. 441 in the Supreme Court of. the.
U.S., Oetober term: 19. 32, Petition for Rehearing ot Order
ee ee a
Denying Petition for Writ of Certiorari, section , pp. 2-3,
and evidence there cited ). | ; ad
That the population test of the Administrator’ s defini
tion ‘produces nlawful diserimination is: clearly show nin
the following 5 h-part (1-B): a =
“a
I-B: The Administrator’s Definition of the Area of.
Production Produces Widespread and Unlawful
Discrimination Between Estadlishments within
+. the only Geographic Area Defined or Prescribed
In the Administrator's ee |
~ Because meee the time available norga reasonable
length of, this brief will permit exhaustive anatyyis of the
data susceptible of judicial notice concern ng alé agricul-
tural and hortic ultural commodities, this disé ussion will
treat with cotton as illustrative of the situation existing
witli respect to the operations: nauied in the Section
13(a) (10) exemption to apply to” Xsuch commodities: gen-
erally, © ; re Rex ;
; | = 3
In ‘‘Area of Production: Cotton,’’ December 1944, U. )
Department of Labor, Wage and Hour and PuabNe oa
tracts Divisions, Hconomiecs ‘Branch, it was indicated that”
1: OF 12,085 ‘active cotton gins «in the cotton-growing
states; 1,562 gins og 11.460 Were inside the vorporate linnts
of places having 2,500 or greater population (1540 CeTISUS )
(p. 32, Table 23). | psa
|
Q Mo
> 9: Of 1,262 non-compress cotton warehouses in cotton-
rrowing states, 56 or 49.66% were located in places of, Be ">
or greater population (1940 census) (p. 35, Table 24).
: ‘ . : J
‘
gees se ee
3: OF€ 320 -eotton® compress-warehouse .plants in the
——“~eotton-growing states, 263 or 82.2% were located in places
J
of 2.500 er greyter population (1940-census) (p. 35, Table
arp).
e >
: Soures es ted for these data are: Bureau of the Census,
Population. 1940, and unpublished data’ for distribution of
cotton gins for the crop vear 1943; and Cotton: Fire & Ma-
—rine Underwriters ¢ ‘lassification ri Cotton es uMpresses,
9
Warehouses and-Wharves ‘for the — 1 wae-O. ee
;
The. same sources (Bureau of tin Census, Population
1950, and unpublished | data for distribution of cotton gins
for the crop year 1954, and Cc otton Fire & Marine Under-—
writers Classification of Cofton ‘Compyesses, Warehouses
and W harves for the season 1955 1-06) show the ¢urrent sit-
uation to be as follows: ; pe
-
1: Of 7,069 active cotton. gins in cotton: -growing states,
more than 1,056-gins or 14.9% are located i in places of 2,500
or gre eyAMpulation (1950 €’ensus).. ee : :
4
at ar 1,252 non-compress, votton warehouses. in cotton-
growing states, 710 or 56.7% are located i in places: of 2,500
Qa
x greater a. ir an (1950 C ensus): | fe
*: > Of 290 cottort compress: warehouse plants in- cotton-
srowing states, 253 or 84.6@,are located in plac es of 2,500
-. or greater population 1s 0 Census). ANT
>
Public eotton storage capacity (as reflected by the ‘vol-
limes of etitton on hand in public sterage ‘December a,
1955) is so distributed j in the cotton -krowing states that the ~
aguregate storage capacity of cotton warehouse plants and
cotton eompress- warehouse plants located at places having
2500 ‘popul: itian or more (190 Census) is proportionatély
greater than the aggregate number of such plants indicated
under 2 anmsl 3, above. (Same current cuthorities, plus un-_
12°
published data of Bureau of the.Census concerning didri-
bation of cotton in — storage,). - .
Bios
In issuing his burrent ‘definition of the area of produe-
tion of agr icultural and . horticultural commodities, .the
-Administrator admitted that his regulation would exclude
from the defirfd area of production about 10% of all grain
elevators because they were located in towns of 2,500 or
greater population (1940 C ensus), —and that his definition a
for-the same reason Would exclude from the defined arez
of pfoduction about one-third of all fresh fruit and vege-
table packing and canning, cheese manufacturing and poul-
try ané egg assembling establishments. (** Finding of the *
= Administrator, December 18, 1946,-In the Mattet of the.
Redefinition of the ‘arga of production’ as used in Sections *
4(e) and,.13(a)(10) of the Fair Labor Standards: Act of
1938,’ U. S. Department of Labor No. D-147(05112), sheet
eG Se of : | a
_ In the 1948 Annual Report of the Wage doit Hour and —
Public Contracts’ Divisions, U.S. Department of Labor, the
Administrator estimated that,- -as of September 1947, ‘under
his (the present) definition of the:area Sf production of
agricultural and ‘horticultural commodities, sonly «336,000.
(28%) of the 1,5 200 000 employ ees engaged in the eperations
named in the Section 13(a) (10) exemption ‘‘may qualify:
for the exemption” (pp. 84, 124-125, Table 23). Table: 23
of that report indicates thiat the proportions of employees ©
engaged in the various operations who “may” be exempt
under Section 13(a)(10) ranged from a maximum of 70%
of the persons employed in. grain elevators and in the
country buying ef grain, to a low of 4% of the persons
jean Nias ; ee i
1In the 1954 Annual besa MD ihe Wage and Hour and Public Contracts
Divisions, U. S. Department of Labor, at p. 58, the Administrator statés that
7233, 000 (19.49%) are (exempt because ) engaged in handling. or processing
icultural’ commodities i in the aee'a of: Production.” n
ae
2.
13°
employed in the wholesaling of dairy products. The report
gives no indication of the extent toe which these results are
attributable to the 2.500 population test, to the application
of the mileage’ or distance test, or to the application. of
both tests combit “ld, . :
“At. pp. 130-131 of that et, the Administrator. evi-
-denced . complete lack of sympathy and . respect. for. the
- Secetign-13(a) (10) exemption and other exemptions ‘granted:
in the Act; and clearly indicated that the administrative
4 policy ‘y with respect to Section 13(a) (10) and such other ex-
eémptions is, not to carry out tle purposes of the _exemp-
tions, ‘but rather to apply the general purposes | ‘of, ‘the Act
to the fields covered by specifier exemptidns.
id *-
7)
It is clear that the Congress had no intention whatever
of authorizing or permitting the Administraf#, by meany
of his definitive regulation, to dise rimjadte Detween estab-
lishments focated within the oe geet area defingd. by
such regulation (: Addison et al. . Holly Hil Fruit Prod-
ucts, Inc. 322 U. S. sel dani, it S Ct. .1215, 122 0 ) (1944)). .
.
In the 1954 ‘Annual Report . thie Ww age sid Hoa and
Publi 1¢ ‘Contracts Divisions, U. S2 De partment of Labor, at
p. 36, the Administrator. in ie issing the evidence , re- ”
/ceived in his 1951 public hearings (conducted for:the pur.
pose of a \ possible redefinition, of the area. of production), :
_. with apparent approval quoted the following conclusion off
the presiding officer at such hearings: ‘* The record con-
tains uncontroverted, evidence of the dise ‘riminatory effects
of the present defifition. of ‘area of 3 production.’ * Here, for.
the first time, is a ‘clean-cut admission by the’ Administrator
of uincontrov erted evidence that disc rimination is created
by his de finitir e requlation in and of itself,
—
me Ree op , ae
ivceee sie. teresa
|The pathosition cited’in the footnote? _ provide the bases
for construction of the following spec ific examples of the
discrimination: ‘réated by the Administrator's definition
between establishments within the only geographic area
preseribed therein with respect to each of the three cotton
meee oper rations’,
-
(
(1): icemaie of Discrimination. Between Cotton Gins
The town of Slaton, Texas. (population 9,036, 1950 Cen-
sus) is ‘located in Lubbock County. which in. 1954. produced -
more cotton than ‘any other ‘county in the United States
- (**Cotton Production in the United States, Crop of 1954.”
set of. Census)..Four cotton gins are located 1 in Slaton.
»
Tf the cirele of ten airline miles radius creneribed for.
cotton gins by the Adninistrator’s definition of the area
of production is drawn’ with Slaton, Texas as its center,
there ar® ineluded -within fhat ten ‘mile radius (but more *
than one airline mile from the corporate limits of Slaton):
2 gins in the village of Witson’ (population 265), and one
-gin each in the villages of Posey’ (population 25), South--
land (population 210), Union (poptilation 15) and MeChing
(popule'tion too se to he recorded by the Census).
The current issues and records of the authorities cited in “Area of Pro-
duction: Cotton,” December. 1944, Wage -and Hour and Publie- Contracts
Divisions. Economits Branch. U. S. Department of ‘Labor (Cotton Fire &
Marine Underwriters “Classification of Cotton Cémpresses, Warehouses and
Wharves” for the 1955-56 season, Bureau. of the Census, Population 1950, and
‘ unpublished records of the Bureau of the ‘Census concerning geographical dis-
tribution of cotton gins in the cotton-growing states), plus Bureau of the Cen-
sus “Cotton Production in ‘the United States,” Crops of 1949 to 1954 and the
“Administrator's definition of the “area of production - (29 C.F.R. 536.2).
8(Specific examples of such discrimination between cotton compress-ware-
house plants are shown more completely in the record.in Traders Compress
Compzay v.- Tobin, No. #41 -in the Supreme Court of the United States.
October term 1952—R. 145. 147,. 243-249, 253-257, 32: and in the record
in Lewis v..U'nion Compress @ Vs ‘arehouse Conlbany, No 39443, in the Su-
_preme Court of. Mississippi (1955) “(R. 19-20). The Leng with respect to
non-compress cotton warchousseméeefully dev eloped (R. in Borrvorn «Moller, .
No. 14894, in the U.S. Court of nn for the 5th Cc ircuit (1954) 2t5 F..
(2d) 601). ‘
ask
(OF Example of Discrimination Deiwor Non. Compress
Cotton Warehouses ea eae omni e: ;
: MS \
+
Athens, ‘Alabama (popiilation € 6,309, 195 0 C ensud) is lo-
rated in Limestone County, which in 1953 produced, 65,257 -_ .
bales of cotton, end in 19. 4: 1. 211 bales of. ‘cotton. ( Al-
though the smallest. county in the state, Limestone County:
during the five years ending with erop-year 1953 produced .
more cotton than any other county in the state e xcept one
e adjoining county, and more cotton per square tnile of. caun-
ty aréa than that adjoining county.) T hree non-compress
public cotton. warehouses are located in Athe ns. 22
® : |
If the circle of 2 20 airline miles radius prescribed for non-
compress cotton warehouses by the Administrator’s defin:
tion of the area of proxluction is drawn with Athens, Ala-
_bama as its center, there® ‘are three other publie non-com-
press cotton warehouses located within that 20 air: ‘line-miles .
ear but more than one mile from the corporate. limits
Athens, which warehouses are located, respectively, _
fe villages of Rogersville (population 531), Madison aa.
~ ulation 580) and Elkmont a 179).
(3): Example of Discrimination ‘Between “G “Bdtton Com.
press-Warehouse Plants *
Greenweod (population 18,061, 1950 ( nsus) is located in
‘Leflore County, Mississippi. During the five crop vears end-
ing With 1953 the State of Mississippi produced one-third
more cotton per square mile gy state ‘area than. any other
e in the Urn. Greenwood ts located in-and surrounded
those Mississippi Counties which consi istently. produce |
more cotton each year than any ‘other counties “in Missis-
sippi. In volume of cotton production eHore County con.
sistently ranks fifth among the &2 Mississippi counties
S ‘ a
s
ge*
es
(fourth im volumg of cotton produced per square mile of)
eounty area ify ine the perrad 19491953). ‘Three public cot-
rd : J ; . ’ .
ton colapress warehouse plantsenre Tovated in Greenwood:
ly the cirele of 0 Cairline miles radius, preseribed fr
cotton, compréss- warehouse - plants by the Administrator's.”
wferinition of the aren’ oF prod, ition, is drawn weth Green-
wood, Mi ssissip pias its ce nter, fe ‘re ure also located within
that Sa radius, but more than one mile from the cor
. porate limuts of Greenwood, (ivee other public cotton com.
press; warehmuse pk ants. loos ated in towns’ of dess tian 3,500°
“popule Mtlon,” Ms unely> Thy tress (population 1,010), citta
Bina {population 1,725), and Ruley ile (population 1 521).
| ate ;
Even if.all e the cotton received at eackt: of the cotton
ins, Hon-compress cottgn warehouses and-cotten conipress-
warehouse plants mentioned in the ahove, illustrations’ is
crown, vad received at th: ose esti rblishme its rom points;
within the respective cine les | havinte. rifdii of 10, 20° and DQ:
celine miles arbitrarily prescribed by the Administ¥ator’s
definition of th area 6! prove tien, ie ioe population
test of the ‘adminis trator’s definition, ba gfnd @ itself, arhi-
trarily evclules from the defined.area of production ot.
6 | .
~ cotton the four eotton wins, the three non-compress cotton
« Ware ec cei the Hyee cottan COMpress: A irehouse
plants Iiented : he wentgrs ‘of the three respective circles
deserubed, -—Imt fneludes withtin the defined area ef pro.
—ductivin of cotter @y other six cotton gins, three non-com-
press cotton’ ware kes. and three coetton compress-ware-
s ‘ . . “. Ae
Shouse’ dlants which are also meluded within those three.
respective grea r areas preseribed by.the Av lministrator’s
‘ale finitio n wet t here, Is Seauritimuy itron of the recent trend, of
popu: ition to shirt from farms to towns and cities; ‘more
: Ehes “examples avould choy ww the same results if the prescribed circ les were.
drawn’ about th: gin, warchousr ar id compress-warehouse lotations ve
populatidlns less than | 500. ets
4
.
. . . ’ ‘ .
. a _¢ a) . " i jin,
. .
. . * ¥ ‘
« ee . - . 2
it ° . i :
’
and mare locations of eottan grins, HON-COMPPess | tton.,
with
wareliorises and co@an compress warehouse plants, .
nae h SUCCESSIVE cons, will he arbitrarily exeluded fron.
trator’ S regulation, ‘Dbyv.a factor (population) which has |
no rational or necessary relation to the fact, or the area,of
cotgon production. : fescue a ae res
a
The authorities agile cited: Show: (a) that from
10.5% (TPennesste) to 26.0% (V irginia) of all ‘eoiton gins lr
the colton-growing oer are excluded -from the defined
area.of productions by the population test alone: (b) that
from zero percent (New Mexico) 1 100% (Arizona, Florida
anc v1 irginid) ef All non-c omnpress cotton warehouses in the
: cotton- crowing states are e ‘xeluded trom tke defined area of
produc tien py the. popul: ition Ae ot alone: and (c) that from
“625% MisSsstppi) through mo re than 80° (Arizona and.
-Eadifornda),. through 90° or more (Louisimia, Oklzhoma,
‘Tennessee and Texas) to. 100° { Alabama, Georgia, New
“Mexico, North Carolina and South C arolina ) of all cotton |
compress*warehouse plants (again w ithout regard to the -
distance test on Cotton receipts) are apbitrarily exeinded |
from the defined aren of production of cotton by the 2,506
population test-of tle Ac lministrator’s de ‘finition, Thus it is
paage impossible for any cotton rmer in: Arizona, Florida
r Virginie to store his cotton ina non- compress cotton
a aes within. thé- defined area of production of cotton.
<
Similarily, if is quite Impossible for any cotton, farmer in
either of the states of Alabama, Georgia, New Mexico,
‘North Carolina or South Carolina to hav e his cotton crop
Stored or ctherwi ise serviced in a cotton ¢ omypress- -warehouse
‘plant within the administratively defined area of produe-
tion of cotton. * sit .
-The latest available data show that more than 99.9% of,
all cottonvon hand in public. storage in the United. States
a
‘the area 6f produc tion of cotton as defined in thie. Admini&- | °
a
RT ek
_
; a ea ~*.
ae, a . . , meee) be Aa, Noy .
be as of December 31, 1955 Was, stored in non: -compress eotton
. warehouses*:and in, cotton compress W arehouse plants” lo-
cated in the cotten-growing states (A.C otton and Jinters
= ‘Come sumption, ‘Stocks, Iniports and Exports, and” Active
tton Spindles“: Dee., 1955: Bureau of. the Ce enstis, Series.
i
4
M1-}-S28 sued Janwary 20), 1956). Se oe i ce
me nes
Snth discrimination between cotton gins, Warehouses and *
+ , compress-warthouse plants, and between, plants engaged in
handling, pac king, storing, pasteurizing, drying, canning,
and preparing in their raw or natural state, of other faryn
and: orchard products for market t,-and in making cheese,
butter and. dther dairy prodygcts, —in practical effect 1 is dis-
°
5 ° Serimination between the agrtcultural proalucers of those.
“\ products because the producer bears the costs of conduct.
. é B
(2) 7 3 oe)
.
Ing such operations.
+
ae Tf the 15-mile cirele presc ribed for oper rations. on fresh
- fruits and vegetables. (by See: i (ii) ef the Ndministrator’ S
“ detinttion) is drawn around fruit- packing facilitiesein Lodi,
San Joaquin Caynty,. California, (popu! ation 13,798, 1950
- Census), there are meluded within that 15-mile radius (but
more ‘than one’ mile from thé corporate limits of Jodi) the
frnit-packiug facilities in the vill ige of Victor, Califgrnia
(population 400, 1950 Census ) Among the.'varidus opera-
tions named in. the See> 1: (a) (10). exemption, such in
ee stances of unlawful discrimination created by -the popala--
. tion test of the Ndministrator’s ‘definition éan, be multiplied.
by Hundreds, and probably thousands.
~
i,
By arbitrarily withholding application of the exemption |
from. operations conducted im’ or near places ef 2,500 or ,
ee greater population, the Administrator's definition increases
‘the marketing costs of all-farmers who rely (and often
must rely) for. the,esse tial serv icing of their crops upon
facilities located'in. or near places of 2,500 or r greater popu-
.
-
St eee
lation” Tf given effect, the Admimistrator’s definition will
“7 rs
null ts the , exemptianr provided by Congress for such sserv-* \
tee establishments and for all farmers w ho patronize’ (and
‘oftenaust patronize) them. ios . , bse
a contrary conclusion. —
-1-C: The Congress has Disapproved the Administrative
Definition of the Area of Production, and Both. of
the Criteria Employed Therein
©
Part I- B, pages S
SD
52-35 of petitioner ‘s brief is d8voted to,
‘angument that, by ‘failing to deprive the Administrator of.
.the power to define the area of production of agricultural
and horticultural commodities, the-Congress in effect, has
approved the, Administrator’s definition, The facts require
.
Su eden ‘amendrient. of the Act! without amending -
_ the Section 13(a) (10) exemption or revoking the Adminis-
trative definition, cannot by any stretch of. the imagination
be construed as ‘Congressional approval, tacit or otherwise,
of the strained ®nd ‘unnatural construction placed npen
that exemption by the A: lministrator, or of any ef the
. x
“yarious administrative. definitions of the aréa of produe-
tion, or of the eriteria of population, and distance (of com,
6
inodity movement), employed in the present, and #arlier
definitions. |
“Where the law is plain the’ subsequent re- ~enactirent of
a statute dees not constitute adoption of its administrative
construction.” Biddle ve C ommisstone x of Internal Revenite
(1938), 303 U.S. 573, 582; Koshland v. Helvering, (19: oN
298 U.S. 441, 447; Helvering v. Re -ynolds. (1947), 313°U. S.
428, 432. | ;
a ; . . o : , n - . . . : F .
Petitioner overlooks the fact that, during. the second ses- __ ,x
sion of the 79th Congress (92 Cong. Ree. 3170, April 5, ae
-
»
0
1946) the Senate ‘adopted 8. 1849 which would apnive made
the me wht h would have amended. Section 13(a) (0) by
ares “*It has ae suggested by thes Adininistrator that,
Mm ¢ P fs
Be ks x
>
- : : : : i “ “= .
.
various amendments to the. Net: The session ended before
that bitl- has acted upon by: the’ House, and the bill’ there®
fore’ never became law. On April 8,:1946, Senator W iley: of
Wisconsin proposed an dumendment from tlie floor, which |
was adopted by the Se mate, and passed by the Senate with
trans ring from the . fdministrator to the Secretary of °
Agriculture the power and the duty to define the. area of
production of farin and: orchard products. In support of his
amendmen t; Senator Wiley said:
the term ‘area. of proditetion’ ~-with respect ‘tothe va-
rrous’ agricultural and hort tienltural commodities-~is }
wnpossible to define, Yi ste i
*T submit, Mr. President, that the ‘area of produc.
ticn’ concept hss not been vivéen a ft: ake triat. No effo
has been nade 't o formulate definitions whieh- are real-
istic, whith take weedunt of the facts and conditions
surrounding the production, proc essing, and market-
“ing of agricultural and hortieulturel commodities, and:
which wonld give effect either ta the letter or the spirit
of the provisions of these exe mptions as contained: in-
the effec tive act. : » '
, ‘With the exce ‘ptions of dry edible beans and Puerto
Rican leaf tobaceo, the Administrator has made no
effort fo issue separate definitians for different com-
modities, despite the great differences between ‘the
actnal areas of, produc tion of the various tommodities.
‘The definitions which the Administrator has isstied
have been strained and tinrealistice and clearly designed.
to restriet the applieation of ‘the exemption to the few-
est possil!ts number of persons. engaged In. the oceupa-
tions named in the exemptions, This has been done by
restri¢ting the definition to-oeeupations on the farm
“ sn <=,
@ ‘ 7
a ‘
eee r . 2]
; peat a ie 2 #1 :
on whieh. fhe commodities eso produwed. hy deg yng
“area off sexe Hon’ a terms ofthe distanee. tehich
COPE af Pig : Sheclram ihe arm Othe pland at whi ich. B
: oe ep
they are ha “leg in terms of the fumbes of persons -
: eng: re ne it} the a raed operaneee er terms of the pop.
ulation of: the gov srg re » processing rst “iblish
nents are located. “Wie courts, including the United
4 ? States Huprenie Court, have + quite properly held such
‘definitions invalid, because, i! given effect, the v would
frustrate the interition of the Congress in enacting the
: exemptions. —- f | PEN OA
- The strained, unreatistie, and injpzoper definitions -
which have been issued probably ‘tre, to a conswlerable —.
exfent, the result oftignorance on. the part ‘of the Aq. .°
ministrator and his statf with respect to the: cirewmn-
x stan@s and conditions | of the actual production, har- +
5 vesting, processing, and marketing of acricultural and*
horticultura corimodities, I gill scarcely he doubted
that they ere also, amo are, the resnlt hy} ‘the intent ofe:
sisi Administrator te inlify—i TRESO far GS po ssiiles—the
rremptions granted by the Congress.’ (imphasis-
aed. (99 C, one. Tee, 3169-70) eee
| EOP So
-.The Senate promptly adopted Senator Wiley’s amend:
ment. (92, Cong. Ree, STO). , tei yes
-Petitioner’s hrief mentions the fact tha * three ‘ye ears later, :
when it voted on ame ndments to the Act CH. — 5894, sub- .
stituted for the provisions of H, R. 58: 36, and- passed’ by the
House August 11, 1949) thes douse of Representatives
adopted the identical ame nde ‘nt propesed by Senator
Wiles .and adopted hy the ‘Senate in ceennection with S.
1349 in 146, However (except by inference at pp. 148-153
at the. separate appends to vhis brief), petitioner also
‘overlooks the faét that a corresponding amendment: (hav-
ine identically the san I purpose Sith Fes pect tf cotton),
and actually defining: the area of prodile tion of: cpt on, Was |
aopted by the Senate... Soe oat Ae ae
oo
OP
As indieateds in -the- separate appendix to ‘petitioner's
brief, pp. 134-153, the identical amendment adopted by, the
House in H. R. 5894 (and 1 in S. 1349 by thea Senate in 1946),
transferring the defining authority to-the Seere ‘tary of Ag-
riculture, had been proposed | in the Senate by Senator Sten-
nis, Due togtie oppesition of (and to) the then. Secretary E
-of Agriculture, the, amendment was not adopted hy; the -
Senate in 1949, ( Actually the amendmentwas never: offered
on thé floor of the Senate). Because of this-situation, Sena-
tor Fastland of “Mississippi proposed | an amendment to
Section 13(a) of the Act _providing that neither the mini-
mum wage nor the overtime requirements ‘should apply to
“the employees of any employer: engaged i ip the qin-
ning, storing, or Compressing of cotton, or in the pric-
essurg- of cottan seed :-PROViDED, That sich employe és
are employed in, about, or in connection with«such oy-
“eration Sor operations; conducted in any county in .
which cotton ts produced as shown in the most recent
annual cotton production report af the Bureau of the
Census.’”’ a \
e ; 4
“That amendment was promptly adopted by the Seriate,
and passed with the bill by the Senate (Cong. Ree. Aug.
31, 1949, Vol. 95, No. 161 pp. 12804, 12811). The purpose
- and effect of that aiendment (like. the. W iley' amendment
of 1946 and the amendment adopted by the House in 1949)
were clearly to rebuke the. Administrator for the eriteria
employed in, defffiing the area of production of farm and.
_ orchardaproductse and also. to prov idea ongressional defi-
nition ofthe area of production of cotton. Therefore, pefi-
tioner clearly errs in stating (p. 147, separate appendix
changes in the ‘area of produetion’ exemption “’,—as, the
managers on the part of the House erred (p. 28, Conference
Report on. H. R. 586, Rpt. No. 1453, H. R. 8ist Congy Ist ,
Sess.) i In saying that : ‘The Senate amendment made no
_ i ss = Me
-to his brief) that “The bill passed by the ‘Senate made no-
.
Pe
= Wee! O° ee
: : =e)
é : x heh -
: = =e ae \ Ab oy bs ea =
/ -¢ : : : : ‘ ‘i Sr. mea . ~ o o
change im eyjsting law.” Tn actaal$substance, the facts are
to the Contrary, as indicated gn page 29 of that Conference ®
dieport. In substance, the ptirpose, and the effect -of the
Senate (Fastland) amendment quoted above (and deé-
scribed on page 29 of fhe Conference Ré port) clearly Were.
‘to extend the area of production exehiption oe Section 13
(a) (10) to the processing of cotton. sé ved, and to define the
,ereaof produc tion of cotton.
(The separate appendix to petitioner's brief (pp. 148-
153) indicates how Senator Fulbright of Agkansas .ex-|s
pressed the disapproval of cotton states Senators .of the
conférence committee ” action of de Jeting both- the House
atiendment and the ht ‘atjendment, pointing out that
they had an. identical * purpose with respect to cotton.) >
: Contrary? to the argument of pe titionen, ind contrary to .
et “ay
_ the authorities cited at wt botfom of page 35 of his brief,
it is nevertheless true tha
, on eve ery. appropriate OCCASION .
since original enactment of the, Rair Labor Standards Act,.
each House of Congress: has: adopted an cunendment tebuk-.
ing the methods and criteria employed” hy the Adiinistra-.
tor in defining the area of productio and depriving hu
-Of that power (on one ‘occasion by the Senate with respeet
0 - cotton only, and on. one oceasion ‘by each House “of
Congress with respect to all farm and orchard products).
In the first instance the amendment failed of enac tment
hecause Congress adjourned hefore the hill was considered
in the House of Representatives. In two later instances suely
‘‘amendments tailed of enactment partly, ie cause of the ob.
‘
jections of Tand to). the then Secretary “of Agric ‘ultureeand
partly hecduse of the dubighis exereise of the tec hnice alitites
of eonfere nee committee Procedure. Senta
Petitioner gravely errs in arguing (Br? pp. 14,°35) that *
See. 16(e) of ‘the Fair Labor Standards Amendments of
P 4 ° : e ‘ a t —e
“«
*
e
.
i, oe =
1949 (63 StatJat 920) “affirmative ly approved” his defi.
nition, Thosé 1949 amendments re-enacted Section 13(a)
(10) without change. Tie general-continuance by See. 16(¢ ‘pi
of the’ then eurrent adininist witive regulations is qualified |
by thie words: **, .. except to the extent that any such ..
regulation (wr) interpre bation. - +. maybe inconsist: at with
the provisions ‘of this ack. 2°. he Administrator's (peti.
.-tioner’s) definition was, mid is, Ine onsistent With the pro;
visions of that Act, and- was, and i , therefore, excepted
from the Sprregt of See. 1G o) of the amendatory act.
“Th ‘all fairness, no D casas say, tat the C ongress sor either
house thereof, has approved, tacitly or. otherwise, the Ad:
ininistrator’s. (petitioner s) definition, or either’ of the’ eri.
teria employed therein. In alf fairness, no onecan de ny that’
on each oecasion when ‘it has had an appropriate opportun-
-aty to do so, each house of. Congress has clearly expressed
~ tural or horticultural commodity.
eo of the Amendment - that: it would actua lly Te-
disapproval ef the Admini: strator’s (petitioner ’s)’ deéfini-.
tion, and undertakey to deprive him of any power to define
the area of production (either of cotton or) of any agricul.
ap
Si} NATORCREYNOLDS— gathered fr om the
move from the provisions of the bill the larger _cold-
starage plants throughout the country. Of e@urse many
"of them we find in thy citiés.of Vew York, Chicago, St.
Louis, Saw Fra neisco, and Seattle” "(mph iss aide Ted)
dl >
SE NATOR SC HWE LLENBACTI:
in the immediate prodneti mare”
SEN \TOR REY NOLDS: “Hut. they would be m
cluded.” Se ae
SENATOR SCHWELLENBACH- ‘No’ Senator,
they would not be: included be cause they are not in. the
rm diate production. area.”” (81.Cong. Ree. 7877)
(Emphasis added.) . Pah des, HE heh re
?
QQ i ‘iF 2
, oie
toe : a
: es ‘ °
#y ff
a = \
CPS .
gS , yr . oa
rks. 2 roy | "«
. > ———
SENATOR CONNALLY :"Mr, President,’ 1 shéuld
“Hike to'ask the Senator fromm Washington a .question.
Would not the effect of his amendment be to éxe rapt all
- industrial warehouses and pie king plants in ap} ple ter-
ritory: * There is no Tipit. Che. condition Is tirat they are.
5 Races packing Plants, and if they are, they are. exempt.”
SENATOR SGHWELLEN NBA “Ha. packing
ee is working upon fresh fruits or wbeet: thles, Jin .
~ their'raw or‘natural state, within the immediate pro-
: ee area, it would, be exempt.” " ( Emphasi sis added)
NATOR CONNALLY: “*My - under standing: is
ie the largest apple-padking plant in the world is Io-
cated.in Winchester, Va..right in the heatt of a great
aprgproducing region. That w oud lie exempt, Ww ould
it not 77% (} ‘unphasis added )
SENAYOR, SCHWELL ENB. A Hh AT the w ‘ork
: done i in ‘that plane i is as described th the amendinent, it’
would be exe mpt.””’ (NOT LE: Winchester, Va. 1930 Ceén-
had a ‘population in. excess of 10,800). (Enrphasis +. -
adtied)
2
Hos . 4
—SE NATOR SCHWE LI ENBAC H:‘*The purpose ae”
‘the ameridment is not for the protection of the packing —
plant or: for* the protection ef the owners of the pack-
ing plant. The cost is paid by the producer. These pack-
ing plants just ig the cost back to the man who pro-
duces the apples. The farmer pays, she bill.’’ (Empha- -
hrs added) (81 Cong. Rec. 7877) :
— The Segtion 13(a)110) exemption, as enacted, WAS @X- |
tended far beyond Senator Schwellenbach’s original inten.
tion to confine the e xemption to fre * fruits and vegetables :
-and to “agric ultural operations.’ The-Schwellenbach
amendment was very substantially amplified, especially by:
the amendments of Senator Borah and of Representa itive
Biermann. rita 7 ar 3p c
=
fens ce
on * : ; =e ow Rs <7
Senator Bors ‘i's amemlivent, which was offered at 8!
Cong. Ree, T7877 and adopted at 81 Cong. Kee. 7947, ex-
“empted¥rom the ove Nine requirement the rece iving, proc: oF
essing and tnanufacturing of milk, eream and butter ”Y
fariner.coope ratives “in dairy production areas.” In the ex
emption: as finally enacted? referenee to farmer coopera a
tives was deleted,-and the exemption Was apphed to both
the minimam wage and the ov eytime requirements, and to
the making. of ‘cheese or butter or othey dairy products”
within the area of scnegiraeme 3
Ip the. final oa in : whieh enac ted, Section #3(a) ( 10): WAS ,
ostantiallysa combination of the Biermann “amendment
The ex:
amendments
The Biernyann sags sarap
‘ ‘ ° —
: out subsection (2) of See Ned : 3 (the Se bined,
Tenbach fimendment as approved, hy.the Honse Labor.
Committee) and insert inlien thereof: “employees
-engaged'in agriculture” includes’ indjviduials emploved
Within the area of predne tion engaged in the handling,
. “Sirik
packing. stering, ginning compressing, processing, pas- <>
te ‘urizing . dr y ing, @r “other Wise | ‘prepar ing agric ‘ultnral
commodities for market.”
The Borah mendinent:
® > Sy io
5 ‘et eae .
‘And. provided further that the provisions of this
pee (¢) shall not apply to employees employed
“mma plant located” m _dairye producing areas, iM. whieh .
.
o~ a i oie ae .. Ses)
p alk, creat or butier fat are received, pro’ Reed, ship
" pe “d,s or manutact tured if ope rate “fe yy a¢ OOpe rative eit
sociation as de Mined 3 in the arm © redit Act of i 33 -
In discussing his. amendment My. Bie rman, among other < e
‘3 “things, said : a i
ae ? ¢ eee bes
: “The dmportant, thing is that the farmer pays the —
«bill for this processing .:.. When. the cost of making
- butter, when the cost of m king cheese, - when the cost
‘ol ginning. cotton incre: mt the. Aatiner Kety. just SO
~much less; and our contention... is that this‘pill, He-
signed in help laber should not be so. worded: that. it
puts another burden -on the agriculture of this roun-
try.” (83 Conge Ree. 7401). ( Kanphasis, ade led}
—
. The above, and similar statements made by the authors
in -the course .of debates on this exemption, demonstrate
the conviction of the authors of thé xemption (a), that the
farmers: pay (or bear in the form of reduced prices for
their crops) the cdsts of per forming fie operations named
in Section 13(a)(10); (b), that the teaches 20 oa
increase in such costs resulting from application: of the
-thinimum ‘wage ‘and overtime . requireinents | of the act: to
such operations -and, (c) that’ this i Is especially true when’
such operations are performed within a geographic. area.
characterized by agric cultural production of the commodity
or commodities. involved. Stik
a Rae
The ae ir language of Section 1 Bin) (10). ‘and its legisla-
tive history, demonstrate the purpose of Congress to ex-
-¢mpt the operations named therein whenever those opera-
“tons are performed within an area. charac terized’ by the
growing of the commodity or commodities involved ‘and
thus, at least to that extent, prevent the wage and overtime
requirements-of the Act from increasing the tosts borne by.
| farmers and horticulturists ine ident to the marketing of
their crops.” ere
° . »
lin its decision ins Lddis Fat ‘a a Hill Fr vit Prod:
ucts, Tne. (329 | * Se007 at: p. 61: 5) the Supreme C ort qrot-
ed a remark ot Representative Biermann on the House -
floorancerning labor differentials hetween large cities and ?
small towns. Mr. Biermann’s remark obviously related to
the abortive -consideration of minimum wage legislation »
during tie preceding session of Congress in w hich’ exten-
skve ‘consideration had been given (in the fixing of a mini-
rium wage) to the. establishment of regional wage differen-
“tials “Tn any event the Court eorreytty concluded in footnote
_ 8): ** Certainly Mr. Biermann did not give the remotest in-
" timation that the ‘area of production’ ‘was meant to convey
any idea other than that which area usually conveys,” °
e
. What Mr. Bieta meant ‘by use of ‘the term ‘large
_ city’? was made ‘clear on the sare page of the Congres-,.
sional Record:
-. **1 do not find fault with the C ommittee on. Labor,
but T think Where: is they are the experts: Who have
- :knowledge regarding the big’ factories in Jersey City,
New York City and some of the otlfer large rities ae
‘the same token We who come from the farm areas are
best qualified to say what terms should apply to labor
‘in thast: areas.’ (83 Cong, Ree, 7401) a tee
As noiea-thove herein, Senator eee stich atio indi-
cated that, while the eold storage of fruits and vegetables
in New York City; Chicago, St. Louis, San Francisco and ~
Seattle would not he subject to his exeraption,-the reason
for exchusion from the exemption w as not the size of those
_aties but the’ fact that they were not within the area of
production. (81 Cong. Rec. 7877). He categorically stated
that the packing of apples i in W inchestery Va., in the center
of: “a great apple-producing region’ would be exempt
\ .
s
IQ
A . ; oF . : 4 7") .
_(beeause Winchester is in the-sired of production, and re-
gatdléss of the fact that the population of Wi inchester Was
more than BO00} (SEC ong. Réc, 787 ). ss
TI: Sections 13(a) (6) and 13(a) (10) Expreds
the Intention of Congress to Protect the -
Farmer Against the Impact (director indi-
rect). of the Minimum Wage and Overtime
Requirements 7
The faudacanial error Of: petitioner's s position* with re-
eee! to the Seetion- [2 342) (6) and, ‘Section 13(a)(10) ex-
eluptions is that he refuses to regoghize that those exemp-_
tions establish a clear C ongr essional policy.--se parate and |
distinct from—and (within the Scope of those exemptit ons Z
diametric: ally opposed tothe general policy of the Act,—
namely, to exchade fram the sc ope of the Act’s- requirements
both (a) every practice performed by a farnier or on a
farra in connection with farming ope rations, and (b) ail. of
the operations nanaed In Section - 13(a) (10) (necessary ‘to
Oaks wane of farnr and orchard products s) when. per-
fapmed™( by ‘anvone) Within an area charac ierized by agri
cultural production. ot the commodity- or commodities in-
volved. That’ polieyyof éxclusion from the Act's require-
mients is, the controlling C orfgressional cde in construing Pa
= apply! ing. those. exeniptions. atehe er
~
Tf a giveemy ployment or oper ration (as here) is within
the letter and the’ spirit of: ‘sither eyemption, the Congres-
sional poliey of exclusion applies, not the general policy.
of: the Act, In such’ circumstances the exe niption, or exelu-
sion, of ‘itself, is | “remedial” in nature and should be lib-
— construed. Se “e Mec owb vo. Hunt F ‘oods, Inc.’ {tA \
. 1948) 167. F. (2d) 905, 308; Cert. os 335 U. S. 845.
ae Sens‘or Pepper, fost manager for the. L949 amend:
ments, and one of the group of Sen nators seeking repeal or |
a)
restriction ‘of these “exemptions, stated’ just prior to\ the.
adoption of the conference report, w hich reenacted, Section |
13(a) (10) intact : Scalar ON fees o 7 eee
*, a
i I think it js the consensus of opinion of the canfer-
wrll condtantiy endeavor to. improve, thé definition at
‘area: of. production’ , ands expecially in the casé of Cot-
ees that they hope the Wage and: Hour Adnrinistrator.
\
- - ton, that he will apply-it a$ liberally as possible.’’ (95 .
Cong. Ree., ( Mit 48, 1949, No. 199, pp. Ee0E 2)
,
‘Neither bill, as it originally passed either the House « OT
Senate, conferred any authority upon, the Administrator te-
define the area‘of production of any farin or orchard. prod-
uct. ‘That authority in its present form was inserted i in the .
‘Act by the conference committee, apparently as an after-
thought, without discussion of explanation, and was adopt-
ed. with the conference report by: each house of Congress,
without discussion or explanation. pk
,@
hoe The Conave ssianal debates in- both houses of Congress,
preceding enactment of the Fair Labor Standards Act in
1938, produced many expre ssions ‘of solicitude for the eco-
nomic plight and. welfate of the farmer,.and of determina-
tion to protect ‘all farmers and horticulturists , so far as
feasible, from any mcrease in the costs of: -prodiicing or mar-
keting their crops (and from any decreese in the prices re-
ceived for their crops} caused .by the application of the
_ Hunimum .wage or overtime requirements of the Act.
_ Senator’ Schwellenbach of Washington was the author of
ne the Senate floor amendment. exempting the packing, stor-
ing, and preparing of fresh fruits and vegetables (81 Cong.
"Ree. 7876) which v was s adopted j in the Senate. (81 on? Rec.
cs aS PET
. Mos* of the Senate debates related-to of f-the-farm. serv--
- 7 ° ° . s
1 « , 2 ‘ ¥
ve : 4 a
@ ’ :
ding of apples in particular, aad fre aad fruits” and, veveta.
bles in- general: Senator Schwellenhs ach” s dame ndtiie int. relat
al only to fresh frets’ and. ‘vegetables. His thinking aumth
discussions revolved around apples: He was. expe dally.
soncerned with ,an exemption whic hi wold, equalize the
sinall farmer (Who has to rely tor the services essential to
narketing upon the, purchasers, or- upon bail es-for- hiye l
with farmers ‘conducting perations lage enowgh to etable
them to perform their own storing, fiteparation, parling,
“ete, for yiarket on’or off the farm {SI Cong. Ree.’ Jay, 30,
1937, pps. 7876-7878). Ue indicated clearly that “the area
of proPuctign, . was infOnded to nreyn simply atty. Legs.
graphi¢é area “characterized bt producti ion of the product or
products i involv ed. face , see ai ee
a Poe en Fo . Iie = F %
SENATOR CONNAL L Y¥2 "The effect of the amend:
nent is to exempt all ‘employees of apple-packirig
plants sis itnot?’’. 7 | os
SEN. VOR SCHWEL LENBACH: ¥ colt | ey are en:
gaged inthe’ area of production and ‘so’ long as the |
apples are in natural ar raw state: ves, Sint’ (ST Cong... |
(876)
“a
“The voseant and current shadition of INsdsepionsh agric “ut
ture certainly continues to justify: the Conn ressional solier
“income had. incre vased hy 60%. (See Appendix A. ‘Tre rot gy
the average cotton farm (like most other ferns) is still
_ tude manifested i in Sections -T (a) (6} ‘and 13 (a) (10) of the
Act. All segments of cur national, economy a - booming.
except agrieulture: E very indicater‘of the econotnie Welfare ®
of agricultute (with the sinule OXCE a. ion of sland Bs saliies &
has fallen substantially,-and. the trend ‘is still downiw: ard,
For 1954, realized net tinceme-“rem farm ad fallen
~
—
we
~
we
oo
21.2% since 1946,- whereas cational disposable persona!
W hile the average s1Z0¢ or Amoertes an Per rrr hes Increasing.
e : “32
ite simall and continge sto justify the ¢ ‘ongressional pur
pose af Section Litay(lOP to kee p small farmers equalized
under the Aéet with the operptors of farms, sujficiently
RE _ large to justify the Storing, packing, pre par: ation for may-
ae oket, Ete . by the ‘farme or. Kare ‘Nample: In 193, 20.9% © of all
estton fs arms were less thi iW five .acres: 5A7O were less
than 2. ae res} and 7 103.9% ‘Were less. than, 30 aeres. (U.S.
DN A. Commodity St: thilization Se rvice, ‘Cotton ‘Division,
unpublished statisties Sa ee. ue yea
_III: The Piling. ‘and Re. Piling of Tobacco Is Not
? oh -, Manufacturing ar Industrial Processing.. It
‘ ; Leaves. the Tobacco in its ‘“Raw or Natural
State’ Within the Mea nin g of Sec. 13(a)
‘et |
as ‘
. 4 t be °
It Is conceded that the tobaceo is in its raw or natural
state when de ‘livered to respondents’ pac king houses. As
the tabaceo loavesy fespondents’ packing. houses it is not
cooked, *Sfinjshed” OV manufactured, nor has it undergone
any mechanical or iartificial processing, ‘The only mechani.
3 cau or artificial factor involved is air conditioning, that
. the regulation of tefnpe rature and humidity ‘within the
acs House, Such regulation of te mperaiure and huinid-
oe
“itv is a beneficial and often neCeSSATY incident to the mere
storage and safekeeping of many farm and orchard prod-
vets (e. @, fruits and veget ables),---sometimes for the -pur-.
_pose of retarding, and ‘sometimes for the purpose of en-.
*oureging natural ripening or drying. it is a normal iaci-
dent of ‘hot house’ farming. Surely the ¢radual drying,
fermentation, and other natural phenomena, Which oceur
‘iring and between the piling and re-piling of leaf tobacco
‘no more. fransmute such tobacco from its raw State than
dines the ripening of. “ruits: or vegetables in storage when
controlled hy the regulation. of temper ‘ature and humidity.
43 - y . te . war
= BN Re e . . n x & aor
‘ - yw?)
Shots : ° as) Pt
: fy . a
2. : yen. acs 3 ¥:
*Allaf the changes whi 1c ri ts ake peace ia teh tobacce an the
‘pac king house are y ‘ontinuation of datural ph mémenae which
bein, and orcur “in vatving degrees, in the tobacco barns .
on the farm (RIK 7-103. (learly the piling and re-piling ial
nof in any way alter the hature of such natural changes. :
‘The purpose and the effeet“aré to provide conditions: con-
ducive to the uninterrupted. continuation off and which in
some, degree hasten these natural processes (the result. pf ..
- placing a relative ly large quantity m one pile) jane to per-
init their more uniform deve opment in all tobacco through- ae
out the pile (which ‘results from remaking the. piles from
time to time, moving tobacco from the inside to the outside °
and from the oaitside to the inside of the pile): ” hese opera-
‘tions simply interpose some degrie of encouragement and
control of these” n: tural _ developments, ° The nature and
result of such. devélopme nts appear to ke analegeous to the
controlled ripening -of tomatoes, avacados, pears, apples
or hananas ‘in storage. In each instance, itis natural fr in-
ternal chemical. and. physical changes to take place which,
when properly ‘controled as to extent and uniformity, make
_ the product suitable, or more suitable, for‘its intended hu-
man cansmuption or use: Neither proce ‘dure involves mann. .
facture, mutilation, or the use of artifice iat catalysts (RK G ‘-
10, 35, 49-53). Surely the resilting product | in either | CASE
is an. agricultural product jn its ‘‘natural state.
es clearly appears that all of the operatians perfornied
- by employees i in respondents’ packing. h@ses corsist of the
- physical. “handling’* of the tobaceo. ‘The ‘*stering” and .
physical s safe-keeping of the tobacco, while: not the primary |
purpose of all packing house operations, Is an inevitable | -
and necessary coneomitamt of all such operations: “ Drying” ¢
is involved. “Packing” js an essential part of such ppera- ae
tions: Thus such operations in the: aggregate include feur of
(“han-
\
the operations ‘specifieally named in the exemption .
.
.
Se
“es °
dling,” ** packing,’
.
‘storing,’ and ‘tdryme’) none of
whic a is qualified dy the phrase “in their-raw or natural
state.’ ae he , b “ 2 °
oe
.
. ¢ . E ° a aoe : : : a
“Preparhre (for ‘market) is the only term in See, 13 (a)
(10) which is qualified. by the words ‘in their raw or na-
. tural stafe.’’ dt does not appear. that any of responde nts”
cingtoyees is.engaged in any activity not envompassed
A ; | SCC
-by the terins “handling”, “packing’’, *‘storing” and *‘‘dry-
ing ". Hawever, #f there were any such activity, it would
fall inevitably within the residual 6r catch-all term *'pre-
sf
par ing in. thei Ir raw or ature i-state,
¢. = 4
The tobacco is ultimately sold ae anne unstemmed,
(RB 141. 142; RK 45, 50, 58). There i is no mechanical proc.
essing operation involved such, for ex cumple, as the grind.
ing of sugar cane 2 and the reduction of the resulting juice
_to sugar or molasses, In Puerto Rico geass Marketina
- Co- operative Assdciation v. MeComb, . (2d) 997 4¢.
°
AL --1, 1950), Administrator (appe 6% a onib conceded,
and bath trial and appellate courts found that tobacco eon-
tinues in its raw or natural state until the stems are re-
moved from the leaves after piling (“bulking’’),
Prior to December p20, 1946, and in his new definition [iro-
smulgated on that date, until January 1, 1949, the Adminis-
trator’s. definition of the area of production of Puerto
Rican leat tobacco erie the exempt operations under
Section 18{a)(10) of the Aet as including the- ** piling,
‘bulking, or otherwise car ug unstripped (iinstemmed) to
haceo for market. 2.77 (29 C. FL R&536.2(e) prior to Deé-
eember 25, 1946: andl 20. FF. R. 536.2(a) (2) from De-
cember 25, 1946 through December 2121948), In an amend.
.iwent of November TS, 1948 (13 FL R. 1947) effec tive’ Jan-
vary 1, 1949, the Administrator deleted frou “his regula-
tion all.references fo Puerto Riéan Leaf tobateo, announe-
= a. : : : ne
®
ing Of leat tobacco 2... will ned provide a basis for exenip-
ing that his purpose was ‘to rake iteclear’’ that the “bulk-—-
ton” under Section sca) c lun. fe
There Js” ne Indgeaiion that the (‘onteess even knew of
+°
the Adrnistrator’s: reversal of -his long-standing interpre.
\
tation, or his re-gonstructibn oot Sec... mineral ux mut
applying to the bulking, of tohagveo. “Phat re-construction -
was and] Is Ine onsistent with Section EF a) TO) as orig cinalls
. enacted, and. as re-enac ted. in I! Mo), any! Was therefore ex-
cepted. from. the gemeral contini: tien of administrative
regulations and inte rpretations, bs Section Lote) ot the 1949.
amendatory Act, Which Is qualified by the words:
except te the ex te nt that anv such... regulation, (or)
inter rpretat on 2... may be inconsistent with ‘the provisions
of this: Aet 0 07. Petitioner errs indeed in ‘arguing (Br.
17-18) that Section ble) “ratified” his reve ‘sal, of the
reasonable and logical cons enue thon, applied for: more-than
ten vears, aes a
°
e
IV-A: The Section 13(a) (6). Exemption of Agri-
cultural Employment Applies to the. Opera.
tions. of oe fla aint May and Hating
Edward
‘Section 13(a) (6) of the “Act erants aconplete exemption
from the mining wage and overtime requirements to
a So ae ~ >a + ° . * ‘ . > .
any emplovee eruployed in agriculture pand Section 3(f)
specifies: what is included within the term “agriculture”
a3 é
.
2
‘As usedin this Act-Cagriculture imeludes ... any
practices... performe “lhy a@Yarmer oo, as an ineident
to orm ‘conjunétion With... ‘Tescin ‘operations, . in
“cluding prepare ition for market (and) delivery .. . to
market ... * (Emphasis added) -
In conimon usage, and according to W ebster? < Interna.
tional Dictionary, the Words **any practices ... pe ‘reformed
\
36
by ‘a-farmer’’ cle ‘arly mean each-practice. pe ‘rformed by Quy
farmer, Otherwise these familiar English words have lost,
their tneaning. When a specific provision of a statute is
clear, autd Consistent in context, there-is no need for re-
course to the some times dubious “light? of eGislative His,
tory. This provision AXPTESSes | (unaided) mC ‘lear and con.
sistent purpose to Bes any farmer in-the pe rformance
ofany practice, so.iong as 0am practice is herd either
°
Meas an incident %o"’" a re conjunction with’? any ‘of the.
previously detailed ‘tarmanp r operations.’ By refere nce to
“Section 15¢e) of the Agricultural M;: irketing Act (12 USC
l14jig¢)) the defimtion of agric ulture is extended to in-
elude the production‘of gum spirits of turpentine, and gum
- as processed by the origina! produc er of the crude
gum (oleoresin) from which derived,’
rosin
Petitioner relies (Br. p. 51) on the following quotation
From Maneja ve Waialua Agriculiural Company, 349 UL S
254,260: es : : : oe
‘Nevertheless, no matter how. Jiroad, the: exemption,
: it Was meant to apply only to agriculture and: we are
left with the proble m of what. is and what i is not prop-
erly included within that term.’
F rom ‘the remainder of the Csert *s Opmion in Waialua, ti
< ’
is plain that this Court-did not mean that the statutory
definition of ‘tagriculture’” in Seetion 3(f) of the Act could —
be ignored in determining What constitutes *tagriculture.”
‘The quoted sentence merety indicates that the Court was
“‘left with the problem’? of ascertaining the meaning of the
words eniployed i in the statutory definition.-For the reasons
which follow, ‘ve think it clear that all of the operations:
here involved fall avithin both the letter and the spirit of that
statutory definition, and ef the exemption provided in Sée-
tion 13(a)(6). If the Court were te reach a contrary conelu-
=
sion, then, not only May and Wing Edward, in their pack
iftg house operations on Type 62 weg “oat Quine y, Florida,
-but all. American agriealture would be: substantially dle.
prived of the exemption now granted in a Act to farmers
in.their off-the-farm storing, se vic ing and processing of
their crops for market. * ; |
W hether an individual proprietors hin, a partnership or a
col rporation, practically every farm e nterprise in the Unit-
ed States, whether large or small, ond Whether it produces
livestoc ‘k, milk, grain, forage crops, seed) cotton, fruits,
vegetables, tobacco or any. other agricultural or horticul-
tural commodity, engages in one or more of the activiti®s
coridueted by resy ondents in therr packing houses. The op-
erations of all farm include the “handlixig” of the prod-
ucts of the farm. A great many farmers and hortieulturists
“pack” their farte products fer market, and ‘store’’. their
farm products for market. Many “dry”? such products “as
apples, grapes, peaches, apricots, ete., for market, Both on.
and off ‘the farm, inany farmers conduct operations much
than the
curing and piling of leaf tolfeco. For ex: unple, many farm-
bb)
more in the natare of ‘industrial processing
ers can their own fruits and vegetables, slaughter and-
lress theirown .poultry_and hogs-precess their own apples
‘into cider, pomace and apple butter, convert maple sap
into maple sv ruy and Maple sugar, mee hanieaily clean their:
own apples, fe te. ; aon
It is Herfectly plain then that the statutéry definition of
' agrie ulture, when it refers'to **fariminme in all its briinches’’
‘and -to ‘any pr actices*, 2. performed by a farmer... as an
ineide nt to ar in conjune ‘tion with suche f arming ape rations,
including preparation for market, delivery. .:. to goegt r
Kte., includes all of the activities heantisneal above, and a
of the ACTIVITIES: »perkormed by respondents’ employees in.
their packing houses on the produc tof their farming. operas
tions. | : =
@
The. levislative hi story” will be seasehed in vain for any
hint that Congress inte snded by the agricultural exemption
.to exempt only sinall farms, or small farmers, or to restrict
the exemption of off-the-farm operations to those per
Forined by farwers or to those performed ‘by farmers
cenert ally, Qu: Wificatien of the performance of farme r prac |
tices by the word “ordinarily ’’ was once proposed (st
Cong. Ree. T6A7), but Was re jected. The ginning their
avn cotton, though nota practice generally performed by
farmers, is unquestionably exengpt when performed by
farmers either on or off the farm (Sl Cong. Ree, 7656, gear
6660, T6972 Mane ja v. i aidlua Agric ultural Co., 349 U.
24, 268).
Tncthe very nature of things,-such farmer practices as -
-those -of respondents herein, and the ‘ginning of cotton,
the washing and cleaning of apples, Ete., can be and are.
. —— only by farmers producing ‘a sufficie nt Volume
» Justify the -xpense of the fae ilitie sand equipment with ,
which to: perform such operations. To the extent that the
farmers’ volumes of .production can -and do justify such
_practices by the farmer, they’ are_practices ordinarily"
_. performed +hystich-a Trine ‘r. To the extent that farmers’ >
velumes of production’ are not sufficiently large to. justify
or permit such practices by the farmers, such operations
are not pe formed by the farmers at-all, and such smaller
farmers -are compéHed-to rely for such services and. proe-.
essing upon bailees-for-hire or. the purchasers of their
products=(one ¢ of the underlying reasons for enactment of
the See ‘tion -: ar) 4 Av) {ex Xeniption).
a he lguislagiva: pur posecof the agricultural exemption Was,
to spare the farmer from additional costs. Furthermore,
C ‘ong ress recognized that farm operations, and the servicinmy
end processing of farm products, unlike industrial opera-
tions, cannot be re ‘Bulated by the clock. The —— and
ime
5)
; 7 te
Q . es
going of the seasons donot await the pleasuré of nian. Sun-
- shine, rain, humidity and warmth are not vet subject to:
man’s contrel. The tiné.td plant and the’time to harvest
ire, determined by ‘the vagaries of nature. Calves, lambs,
and pigs are born at al] hours of thie day and night. lLive-
-stock must be fed and cows rust be milked-eacheday, inelud-
ing Saturdayy,y Sundays and holidays. Plant and animal
‘growth (like the curing and ripening of tobacco in. packing
houses) continues around the clock. Suecessful farming: and
‘farmer-processing or servic ‘ing demand long hours of labor
in certain days, and few hours of labor om ethers. Frost,
presenee or absence of pests, and the incidence of diseage
$
heat, humidity, rainfall, relative day and night temperature, -
are the practical factors governing these demands. In an |
efficient farming or farmér-processing or servicing-opera-
tion, no limitation or regulation of the farmer’s' hours is
_ possible.
.
°
Senator MeAdoo proposed an amendment” to the defini-
tion of agricuiture which would ld have e xempted “any prac.
tices ordinarity-performed: by or for.a farnier as an inci-
dent to such farming, including harvesting, packing, stor-.
ing,, or preparing for market, in the raw or nataral state,»
any products | derived from any of the above agricultural
pursuits." :
~
In support of his proposed amendment, Senator Me
Adoo'described the situation im these words:
2 } . : . ws “a
“These agricultural commodities are bigbly. perish:
able, and the work’ whieh/myst he done by tie packing
houses, and, on the fark § varies greatly with tempera
cannot know whether the-crop must be moved. Sa to
“When it was : elena. out tha .an carlier ame endineat eis adopted by
the Senate covered the situation about which he was concerned, Senator Me.
.Adoo withdrew his amendment. (81 Cong. Rec.-7927-7929)
; : : “
ture varidtions: Twenty-four fours in advance, one
4i) ” “ ©
e ;
fix rigid hours of labor in_such cases would be to-ruin
the producers, as the erop nmst be handled. quickls
with the workers available. The broadening of the de?
nition as T have suggested is not only direrthy In line of
- With the cobject. of iba bill, but, wel] filsa- proteet. thy
farmers, wha. in ris State : iotbast ‘are eniwar ee 10 a
method of marke ‘Ting, packing and handling: thei ‘ire TOPS
— Which nay differ from the methods emploved in other
States. (ST Cong. Ree. 7927).
/.
ee .s
Whether or not 4y farming operation, « ora farr 1er- -proe-
essing or servic ing oNeration, is large or smal, moe thanized
_ or not, the { farmer must perform the farming and the work
of farmer-processing or servicing when he ¢ an, depending —
upon the Yactors and conditfons of nature. For’this teason,
among others, Congress gr anted aecomplete exeanptron fo
abel agric ‘ulture, and to every -practice ‘of every farmer per-
.formed as an incident to or ine onjune tign with his farming |
operations, regardless, of allother factors. Pétitioner here.
_in has ignored that Congressional pot pose .
>
‘IV-B: Farmers Have Relied, ‘and Are Entitled to
__ ~ Rely, Upon the tutetbcetations of the De-
'. partment of Labor in Regarding as Exempt
Their Various Farm Activities and Farmer.
Processing and — Activities.
Concurrently with issuance e hy the Administrator of In.
terpretative Bulletin No. -14, the Administrator issued + 4
press release. indicating Miat such adinimstrative interpre-
tation of the agricultural exemption was made, only after
le nethy conferences with representatives of emplovers, em
f-oyers and other interested, parties, and consultation with
authorities in the U. S. Department of Agrivulture. The re
lease indicated that Labor Department attorneys had- given
intensive study to the legisiative histary of Sectron 13(a)
Awe
.
ae
4} ° ier ores
“awe
16), and that the Departnient had Mf onsidered ePOTOMIE
studies tmade by its economists 1G wssist at in property
certaining ‘the Scope of the exemptions, It was only after
; e ; a le
Jsuch lengthy and intensive investigation s and discussjors
that the Adiminisir: Atos issued ofthe ial «© pinions on the sub
_ject. Those opinions were wid Hy: circulated: throneh Inter
pre tative Bulletin No. . 14, press re ‘le; Ases, I ve. : ne
a: 2 ‘
¢ rr
‘When thoxe. official interpretations were announced, ‘the
fariners of the Nation -relied upon theiti, and were- cuided |
_by them in-cons videving the. compel nsation and workingeeon-|
ditions of the Ir enniplovees. ~Tase Tnterpre tations” (as set.
forth in the-brief of respondents King Edward and. Budd -
—terein) were never modified. Since they are j : harmony
we
to Portal Act’ of 194%, 61 Stat. 88
with both. the language and the spirit of the e casinos pro-
visions, thev deserve the respect which this Court has said
is diie such administrative inte ‘rpretations, Untted. Dhates v,
Amégican Trucking Associations, Inc., et al., 310 U.S. 534,
549. This Court has also said that employers, as well as
courts, may properly resort to such interpret ations for
guidance, Skidmore v. Swift, 323-U. S. 134, 140. The right
of employers to rely, yar the immunity of employers based.
on reliance, on such interpretations liv the Administrator
| cae
or petitioner has been confirmed by Congress in the Portal
89; 29 US... C7 258, 259.
te ‘ oD
ids -
he . Bsa 42 -
Conclusion ra
2 hel ‘. 7 “ za | 4
Phe gyudgiment of the Court of} Appeals should be
affirmed. aes 3 s
Respectfully submitted, ae
JOHN H. TODD, .@
| Counsel for Amici Curlats
Of Counsel: - : ‘S s
LL. JAMES HARMANSON, JR.
~ 744 Jackson, Place, NW.
‘Washington, D. C.
-M, RICHARD GARSTANG tie)
1731-Eve Street, N. W. ;
W. ashington, DC.’ z © .
JOSEP H O. PARKER J
iy 031 W ashington B uilding
bt Washitigton 5,D.C. — - re i
&
v | =
w
eo
“APPENDIX. -
rd s é 4x a
wo The Relative Condition of Ameritan ‘Agriculture
‘
r a
‘Secretary of Agriculture. Benson, spe aking January 16,
1ua6 to the National Coune ‘il of Farmer C O0DE rates ‘in Las -
Au tes. (U SD nw release 137-56, Sheet 5) stated that ‘about
- To nilion farm fi amilic ‘sin this Nation have i incomes of less
an $1,000." Secretary Benson's statement dramatizes the
re neral farm situation : is reflected by” the following acts:
Production expenses of U,. S. farm operators, for 1993
had increased 50% ‘from’ 1946 and 259.4% from’ 1939
(USDA * Lec chsrbieren Sfatisties” £904, p- 487, Table 671).
In total dollars the realized net income of- farny a
_tlons for 19: On had fallen 98°C sine e-+946; and net income
of persons on farms 9.3°% . Dufing tlie s same pe Soy ata
lispoable personal: income incréased By 00.1% (USDA
=A gricultur al Statistics” sede. p. #29, Table G4). |
“In 1954" the realized net ine onie from. farm ing dropped
fartinr: to ‘21. 2 under: 1946 (USDA Agricultural Market-.
ing Service **Farm Income Situation” , October 1955, Table
ly. By way of #ontrast, national asnanihe personal in-
come for 1954 had riken 60° from 1946 (&. S: Department
el Conimerce, Office of Business Economies, “Survey of
‘Current Business’ \duly 1955, pp. 10-11). | |
.
; rN reduction i in farir popul: don is the obvious cause for
Acslight increase in average net Income per capita for the:
farm worker and for the farny pojiui: ation frorn agriculture. ~
Nevertheless, acsimilar, though less extensive, disparity
persists hetween. the income of, the farm @orker sand the
“ctory worker, and hetwee en the 1 Yarn population and the
non-farm population. The average net ingome per ‘apita of
“he farm population from agriculture for. 1954 was up
Ly eo} a
: .
. 2
‘
She
See
as
e Situation’ January 1956, Vol. 40, No. 1, p. 24.).
44
+ 9 2 6 , “oa
¢
3.0% from 1946, whereas the average nist ineomie per capita
for the. non- frm population from non-farf i sources Was up
42.8% from 1946. Similarly the annuai income per farm
_ worker in 1954 was up 3.4%. from 1946; whereas the annual
income per factory worker in 1954 was up 64% from.1946.
(USDA: Agricultural Marketing Service **Farm Income.
Situation’? , October 1955 5, Tables 7 and 8.)
secre a | , te
Farm mortgage debt hag i increased more than 70° since
1946. (USDA Torre Research Service, Neg. 55(6)
170).
Soman with the averages for calendar 1950, prices
paid by farmers in December 1Qoeavere up 9% ; whereas
we received: by farmers. wete down 13.6% (Statistical
Abstract: of the U. S., Bureau of the — , 1955; p. 643,
Table 781! **Agricultural’ Situation?’ - USDA. Agricultural
Marketing Service, January: L9D6, Vol. 40, No. 1% pe 24.)
The farmer’ s share of the retail ar of food in Novem-
ber, 1955 was 39%, a decline of 25 % from the average of
1946). ieSDA ‘Agr icultural Matic 1954) p. 466, Table
699; USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. ‘* Agricultural
Fi armers’ costs of harketin food crops in 1955. were up
4%c from 1954 and up 21% from the avera age of 1947-49,
whiereas’ farmers’ receipts fee food crops were 3% down
ftom 1954 ang. 167% down from the average of 1947 -49,-
This does net mean ‘that feod marketing’ agencies are °
reaping additional profi ts. It indivates’ increases in food
‘niarketing costs. Bor vexainpio, the hourly earning rates of |
wages and salaries in ‘food marketing for 1954 were 51%
Above the average for 1947 -49; though by’ increased pro-
duetivity, total labor costs were held at 39% above the av-
erage for 1947 “49, W ages in. food ee for September :
, 3 4 Fa Robs - @
a
.
” 5 s .
t 4
s <5 . - °
45.
2 -
7 e "Wate
Cs
1955 were 44.05 above theta averawe for 1947-49.-€ ‘arrenit rail
‘freight rates on major agricultural. commoditie ‘Ss are 24%
| Above the aver ase for L947 49, coda:
: “sane
Aateaily food processors", profits) after: income | taxes’
amounted to 1.8% $f sales for Te54t down 21.7% from 1947-"’
19. Food w holesalers’ profits ter income taxes for 1954
‘were 1.0% of sales: down £1:2% trot 4: IAT -49, Chain retail.
food ‘store profits after income taxes for 19: D4 were 1.0%
af rail aca 28.67 % from 1947 “49. cee eene er es Bae
a ernes for all of the: sioea USDA ‘A arisdtuicel Mar-
keting Service, * Agricultura] Situation” - December, 1955,
Vol. 39, No. 12, p. 8), ee ate =
’ : ,
<
-
46 eae
APPENDIX B i oo eer
at Peatiniont Provisions: ‘of the Fair Labor
: Standards Act of 1938, As: Amended - see ie
‘Sec. 3. As used-in this Act— ae OT a, es :
+ & : eral
(f)- “‘Asriculture™ ineludes: farming-in all its
‘Dranchcs anc Among other] ‘Shings includes the cultiva-
tion and tillage of the soil, dairying, the production,
cultivation, growing, and harvesting of any agricul tat-
-al or horticultural commodities Ghicluding ‘eommedi-
ties defined as agricultural conmodities in seetion 15
(g):of the “Agricultural Marketing Act, ax @inended),
the raising of livestock, bees, fur- bearing animals, or
poultry, and. any practices tinchiding any forestry or
‘ lumbering oper rations) performed) by a farmer pf on a
fan as av incident ‘to or in conjunction w ith stich
+ farming operations, including preparation for market,
delivery to storage or. to: market or to. ‘arriers . for
een sich te market. _ mini
PY - ’ »
- Sec. 13(a) The provisions of sections 6 and 7 shall not-
a pply with respect to $ cas eer
” , Pat
~ «
(6). Any employee employed in agriculture or in eon-
neetion- with the operation or maintenance of. ditches,
‘canals, reser ‘voirs, or waterways, not owned or operat-
ed ‘or profit, or operated on a share-erop basis, and.
which are ae exclusively’ for supply and storing»of
< .water for agricultur: al (pirposes; or
4
(10) any basil ilies al doh Med within the ared of pro:
_duetion (as defined by the Administrator), engaged | in
\ oc: - handing, packing, storing, gining , Compressing) pas--
teurizing, drying, preparing | int their. raw or natural
‘state, or exnning of ageieulfurat or horticultural come
riod ities for market, or in making cheese or butter or
other dairy products; « a
47 ee ; tar/ ot *e
| 499
APPENDIX. c
Full 1 Text of Administrator’ s Current Defini ‘ion of the Ande
af Production; 29 ©..F.‘R, 536.2, Federal Register
. December 25, 1946: | ‘
‘Area of Production’? as used in fection Pay ily:
of the Fair Labor Standards Act. |
, es -—f
(a). An iridividual shal] ig regarded asy éniployed in’ the
“area of produe tion” within the meaning of Section 13(a)
(10) in handling, packing, storing, ginning, compressing
| pasteurizing, drying, - preparing in “stheir raw or Fuakaael
state, or canning of agricultural or hrortic ‘ultural eomimodi
ties for market, or in making choe ‘se or tvggter or other
dairy products: aes - hare se
(1) ff the establishnout where he is ‘employed i is lec ated
in the open country or ina rural commitinity and 9 3% ofthe
eommodities-on which’such operations are performéd by the:
establishment come from norm al rurat sources of ‘SUpply |
loeated not: more. than the following air line distiness from
‘the establishment: pe Aa :
» .
°
(i) with respect to the winnists. of cotton: 210 mniles .
(ii). with respect to operations on fresh fruits and
vegetables-- 15 miles; eg es :
(iii) with respeet to the storing of eotton and anv,
operations .on commodities not otherwise specified in
this sub- section. —-20 miles; Ay a
/
-
| (iv) with fespect to the compressing anid compress
ue warehousing 6f cotton, -and operations ° on. tobacco,
- grain, ves dering poultry’ ore es ye miles.
(by) For evinvonebe ot this regulation:
» : oo } ra : . ,
: s : a * ~
(1) ‘Open country or rural cotintty : shall note inelude
any city, town, or urban place 1fse.50 or greater population
OF any area within ek Mes asf al .
. ra Gp
”
° y : 48
»
- one air tine mile of any city, town, or ‘urban place with
a.pepulation of 2.500 uy to but not ineluding 59,000 er
three. air line wilbeit of any city, town ‘or urban place
with a Sette WS ‘of 50) 000. up to but not ine luding
000,000, or
five air line miles of any city ‘with a popwation of
510,000 or greater, according to the latest av ailable :
United States census,
_ : | : N |
_ (2) The conimddities shall be considered to-come from
“normal. rtral sources of ‘supply’ ’ within the Specified dis-
-tanees from-the astablishment if they are received (i) from
farms: within such specified, distances, : or (12) from farm
. assemblers or other establishments through which the com-
modity customarily moves, which are within such speci;
‘fied distances and Joeated: in the open country-or in a
rural community, or (i) from farm assemblers or other |
establishments uot located in the open country or in a rural
community provided. it*ecan be demonstrated that, the com-
modities were produced on farmwithin - ‘such’ specified
distances, be aie
“19 The peviod for determining whether 9 1%. of the com-
modities are received from normal rural sources of supply
shall be the last preceding calendar month in which opera-
tions were carried on for two workweeks or more, except
sthat until such time as an establishment has operated for
‘sfich a caléndar month the period shall be the, time during
which it has been i in operation.
(+) The ereentage of commodities. received from norma!
pe g
-rural sourees af supply within the specified distances shall
he determined by weight, volume or other physical unit of
measure, except that dollar value shall be-used if different
“commodities received in the establishment are eustomarily>
moaraured in physical units that, are not comparable.
2
* sad > ? e . . 2 .
. , : ‘ , 9 7 ~~
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.