Transcript of Record — United States v. Brown
Supreme Court brief1954
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OcToBER Tree, 1954
No. @@B.. “<< &
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER,
Vs.
PETER BROWN
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED MARCH 24, 1954
CERTICRARI GRANTED APRIL 26, 1954
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OcTOBER TERM, 1993
No. 654
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER,
Vs.
PETER BROWN
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
INDEX
Proceedings in the U.S.C.A. for the Second Cireuit
Statement under Rule 15 (b)
Reeord from U.S.D.C. for the Southern Distriet of New
York
Summons, (omitted in printing)
Complaint
Answer
Iuterrogatories
Answer te ‘nterrogatories
Notice of motion for summary judgment, ete.
Affidavit of John M. Foley, read in support of motion
Affidavit of Lee S. Kreindler, read in oppositien te
motion
Opinion, Dimock, J.
Order and judgment appealed trom
Notice of appeal
Stipulation as to contents of record (omitted in print-
ing)
Stipulation of attorneys approving reeord (omitted in
printing)
Clerk's certificate (omittted in printing)
Opinion, Frank, J.
Judgment
Clerk's certificate (omitted in printing)
Order granting certioran
Original
—
!
l
ig
Is
19
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETFR BROWN ]
] In United States Court of Appeals for the Second Cirenit
PeTeER BRowN, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT
aqgamst
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DEFENDANT-APPELLEE
STATEMENT UNper RULE 15(R)
On April 9, 1952, the summons and complaint were served. An-
swer Was served on the 26th day of September. 1952.
This appeal is taken from an order and judgment made by LJ.
Dimock, U. 8. D. J... dismissing the complaint herein,
The plaintiff's notice of appeal was filed on the 6th day of July,
1953.
No property was attached; no questions were referred to a com-
missioner, master or referee.
2 Summons. (Omitted in printing.)
| Title omitted]
3 In United States District Court
COMPLAINT
Plaintiff, by Harry EF. Kreimdler, his attorney, for his complaint
against the defendant, respectfully shows to this Court and alleges:
Firsr: Plaintiff at all times hereinafter mentioned was and now
is a citizen of the United States, resident and domiciled in the State
of New York, City and County of New York.
Sgconp: That this Court has jurisdiction by reason of Seetion
1346 of Tithe 28 of the United states Code and chapter 171. of
Title 28 of the United States Code, known as the Federal Tort
Claims Act.
Tuirp: The claim for relief is in an amount in excess of $3,000.
Fourtu: That defendant, the United States of America, through
its employees and through the Veterans’ Administration, a Federal
ageney, at all times hereinafter mentioned, did, and now does, operate
a hospital at 180 West Kingsbridge Road, the Bronx, New York.
Fiera: That the plaintiff was duly admitted into said hospital
on October 1, 1951, for the purpose of having an operation performed
upon his left knee.
sixtH: Phat on October 4. 1951, plamtiff’s left knee was operated
upon by the defendant, the United States of America, through its
emplovees
~ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Vs. PETER BROWN
Seventit: That the defendent, the United States of America,
through its employees, in a grossly negligent and enreless
} manner, permitted a defective tourniquet to be applied
the plaintiff's left leg during said operation.
kicarn: That the defendant, the United States of Americs,
through its emplovees, in a grossly negligent and careless manner
applied said tourniquet to the plaintiff's left leg; that the defendant,
the United States of America, through its employees, in a grossly
‘areless and negligent manner, did not promptly remove said tournt-
quet from the plamtiff’s leg, but negligently and carele sly contin J
to increase the gaessure therein. Le |
NintH: That at ail times during said operation, plaintiff was
under the complete control of the defendant; that he was ufder the
influence of a spraal anesthetic, and that he was not able to see
or feel the appheation of said tourniquet.
Tentu: Thot as a result of the said negligent and careless act.
and without any contributory negligence on the part of the plain-
tiff. the plaintiff was severely injured. He was confined to said
hospital for approximately sixteen (16) weeks, and was thereafter,
and is new, required to report to said hospital each day for ireat-
ment. Plaintiff has lost all sensitivity in portions of his left leg below
the knee and has lost control of certain of the muscles in that
portion of his leg, and is unable to walk without the aid of orthopedic
braces. Plaintiff has suffered and will continue to suffer great
physical and mental pain and anguish and has lost much time from
his employment with consequent loss of earnings and his earning
capacity has been permanently impaired.
Eieventu: That by reason of the premises, plaintiff has been
damaged in the sum of $100,600.
5 Twevrtiu: Plaintyf has at all times born true allegiance
to the Government of the United States of Ameriea and has
not in any way voluntarny aided, abe tte? or giver encouragement to
rebellion against said Government.
Wuerrrore, plaintiff demands judgment against the defendant
in the sum of $100,006, besides the costs and disbursements of this
action.
Harry EF. Kreinpeer.
Attorney for Plaintiff.
Office & P. O. Address.
51 ¢ *hembers Street,
porough of Manhattan,
City of New York (7).
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN 3
6 In United States Distriet Court
The detendant, United States of America, by its attorney, Myles
J. Lane, United States Attorney for the Southern District of New
York, for its answer to the complaint herem alleges as follows:
1. Denies any knowledge or intormation suficient to form a
belief as to the truth of the alle tions contained in paragraphs
“First,” “Second.” “Third.” “Fourth.” “Fifth.” “sixth,” “Ninth,”
and “Twelfth.”
2 Denies the allegations contamed in paragraphs “seventh,”
““eaghth.” “Tenth” and “Eleventh.”
Wrererore, the defendent, United States of America, demands
judgment against the plaintiff, dismissing the complaint herein,
together with the costs and disbursements of this section.
Dated: New York, N.Y.
My es J. Lane,
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York,
Attorney for Defendant.
By: Joun M. Forry,
Assistant United States Attorney,
Office and Post Office Address:
United States Court House,
Foley Square,
Borvagh of Manhattan,
City of New York.
4 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
In Tue Unrrep States Districr Courr
INTERROGATORIES—March 5. 1953
The defendant requests that the plaintiff, Peter Brown, answer
under oath in accordance with Rule 33 of the Federal Rules ot
Civil Procedure the following interrogatories:
1]. State -whether or not plaintiff is a veteran.
2. If the answer to Interrogatory No. 1 is in the affirmative. state
the date and the nature of plaintiff's discharge.
3. If the answer to Interrogatory No. 1 is in the affirmative, iden-
tify the branch and organization in which plaintifi saw serviee and
state the period or periods of plaintiff's service.
4. If the answer to Interrogatory No. 1 is in the affirmative. state
whether plaintiff was ever injured or wounded while a member of
the Armed Forees.
5. State whether or not plaintiff was admitted to the Veterans
Administration Hospital at No. 130 Kingsbridge Road. Bronx. New
York, as a result of his veteran's status.
6. State whether or not plaintiff at the time of his admission in
said hospital suffered from any service-connected disability or dis-
abilities. If the answer ‘to this interrogatory is in the affirmative.
specify the nature of sueh disability or disabilities.
8 7. State whether plaintiff received at any time a pension
from the defendant or one of its agencies. Hf the answer to
this interrogatory is in the affirmative, state how and under what
circumstances such pension was awarded, the amount of said pen-
sion and the awarding ageney.
New York, N. Y.
Mytrs J. Lane,
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New
York, Attorney for United
States of America,
by Jousn M. Foury,
Assistant United States Attorney,
Office and P.O. Address:
United States Courthouse,
Foley Square, Borough of Manhattan,
(itu of New York, N.Y.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN J
i) In Unitep States District Court
ANSWER TO INTPRROGATORIES
Answering interrogatories dated March 5, 1953:
1 Yes. Plaintiff is a veteran.
2. Plaintiff was discharged on August 6, 1944. ©. D. D. Section 2.
3. The plaintiff saw service in the Army Air Force from October
27, 1942 to August 6, 1944. He does not have the reeerd of all
organizations in which he served within the Air Force, but he does
remember serving in the 60th Air Depot Group and the 487th Bomba-
dier Training Squadron among others. He was discharged from the
Air Force unassigned.
4. Yes.
5. Yes
6. Yes.
7. Recurrent dislocation of the patella.
Yes. Pension was awarded by the Veterans Administration
upon application of the plaintiff at the time of discharge. The
original pension was for 30°, disability.
zx
It has varied since then from 100 to 100%, .
(Sworn to by Peter Brown, March 13, 1953.)
6 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
10 IN Unirep Stares District Court
Notick oF Motion--Marci: 24, 1953
SIRS:
PLease Take Novice that the defendant, United States of Amer-
ica, Will move before a motion part of this Court to be held on April
2. 1953, in Room 506, United states Court House, Foley square.
New York, at 10:00 A. M., or as soon thereafter as counsel ean be
heard for a summary judgment disuissing the complaint hereim or
in the alternative, for an order dismissing the complaint for failing
to state a claim within the juri<diction of this Court or in the aiter- :
native, tor an order dismissing the complaint for frilure to state a
claim upon which relief can be granted together with such other and
further rehet as to the Court may seem just and proper.
New York, N. Y. .
Yours, ete.
My es J. Lane,
Vnited States Attorney for the
Southern District of New
York, Attorney for United
States of America.
Office & Post Office Address:
United States Court House,
Foley Square,
New York 7, N.Y.
To:
Harry E. Ereinpver, Esq.,
Attorney for the Plaintiff,
51 Chambers Street,
New York, N.Y.
11 In Tue Untirep States District Courr
Arripavit or Joun M. Fotey, Reap ix Support or Motion
State of New York:
County of New York, ss:
Southern District of New York,
Joun M. Porry, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
Taman Assistant United States Attorney for the Southern Di--
triet of New York. To am in charge of the above matter and am
fully famuliar with all the facts and eireumstances therem.
This affidayt is subnmutted im support of an applieation fer an
order granting a summary judgment in faver of the defendant pur-
suant to Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure or in the
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. 12TER BRON i
alternative for an order dismissing the complaint pursuant to Rule
12 of the Federal Rules of Civil Preeedure
This is an action instituted under the provisions of the Federal
Tort Clams Act by s veteran to recover damages for personal in-
juries allegedly sustained by him while a patient at the Veterans
Administration Hospital at 130 West Kingsbridge Road, Bronx, New
York. The plaintiff. in answer te interrogatories propounded to
him by the defendant has stated that he was admitted to this heos-
pital as a result of his veteran status and at the time of admission
he was suffering from a serviee-connected disability.
In O'Neil vv. United States, decided February 19, 1953,
the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cireuit granted
the Government's motion for summary judgment. This case is
identical factually with the instant suit.
12 A copy of the O'Neil opinion is annexed to this affidavit.
No purpose will be served by paraphrasing the holding or
legal reasoning contained therein. It is sufficient to note that the
Court held that the Government i= net liable under the Fedefal Tort
Claims Act for injuries sustained by a discharged serviecman, and
that lis proper avenue for relief is in the compensation statutes.
Section 31, Public Law 141, 73rd Congress, 38 UL S.C. 5O1tad,
Wrererorr, it is respectfully praved that a summary judgment be
entered distuissing the complaint as only an issue of law is to be
resolved, or, in the alternative, an order be entered dismissing the
complaint under provisions of Rule 12 of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure.
isworn to by John M. Foley, Mareh 24, 1953.)
13 In Tue Usitep “tates District Court
Arripavit or Lee S. Kremnpier, Reap is Opposition to Morton
State of New York,
County of New York, ss:
Ler S. Kremnp er, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That he is associated with Harry FE. Kreindler, Esq., attorney
for the plaintiff. That he has possession of the file and is familiar
with the contents thereot.
That this affidavit is submitted in opposition to the defendant’-
motion for summary Judgment dismissing the complaint herein, of
in the alternative for an order dismissing the coemplaimt for failing
te state a claim within the jurisdiction of this Court, or in the alter-
native for an order dismissing the complaint for failure to state a
claim upon whieh relief ean be oranted.
That this is an action brought to recover jor serious personal m-
juries sustained by the plaintiff when he was a patient at the Vet-
s UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
erans Administration Hospital, at No. 130 Kingsbridge Road. Bronx.
New York, on October 4. 1951.
That the plaintiff served in the Army Air Force frown October 27,
1942, to August 6, 1944. He was honorably discharged ou August 6,
1944, with a service-connected disability (C.D. 1D). Section 24.) The
plaintiff hed been injured in the left knee Juring mijitary operations
in New Guinea. Following his injury he was hospitalized until Au-
gust, 1944. He was able to walk. but upon any sudden or strenuous
movements, his left leg would beeome dislocated. On Marel 8,
1950, he was operated upon by the Veterans Administration, for the
purpose of “cleaning up” the knee joint. His leg continued
4 to dislocate frequently, however.
Pursuant to his status as a veteran, the plaintiff was ad-
mitted to the Veterans Administration Hospital, at 130 Kingsbridge
Road, Bronx, New York, on October 1, 1951, for examination and
possible treatment. It was decided at that time that another opera-
tion should be performed on his left knee for the purpose of prevent-
ing the leg from disloeating. The operation was performed on Oe-
tober 4, 1951. It was to be a so-called bloodless operation, requiring
the appleation of a tourmquet on the left thigh. The tourniquet
was applied by an operating room attendant in the employ of the
Veterans Administration. The tourniquet was defective in that the
pressure gauge Was not registering and an excessive amount of pres-
sure Was applied to plaintiff's leg. The attendant should have realized
that the tourniquet was defective as soon as it was applied, bur he
did not. As a result of the excessive pressure having been applied by
the tourniquet, the nerves in the plaintiff's leg were seriously and per-
manently injured. The plaintiff was confined to the hospital for
approximately sixteen weeks thereafter, and for a long period after
that was required to report to the hospital each day for treatment.
He lost all sensitivity in portions of his left leg below the knee, and
has lost contro! of some of the muscles in that portion of the leg.
He is unable te walk without an orthopedie brace and at this time
it appears that he will never regain the full use of his leg.
The negligence alleged on the part of the defendant consists of
tie appheation of the defective tourniquet by employees of the
defendant, and their failure to recognize the defective and dangerous
condition of the tourniquet.
1 The plaintiff brought tias action under the Federal Tort
Claims Act, 28 USCA 1346, 2671, ef seg. A summons and
complaint was served upon the defendant on April 14, 1952, and
after numerous extensions of time to answer, the defendant's answer
was received by the plaintiff on September 26, 1952. The answer
consisted of general dental.
The defendant has now moved to dismiss the complaint on the
ground that the government is not hable under the Federal Tort
Ciaims Act for injuries sustained by a discharged serviceman while
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Vs. PETER BROWN -)
in a Veterans Administration hospital, and that the plaintiffs
exclusive remedy is in the compensation statutes, 38 USCA SOLA
There is no question that the plaintiff received a pension trom the
goverment upon his discharge, nor does the plaintiff deny that this
pension lias been mereased as a result of the mjury he sustained in
the Veterans Administration Hospital in 1951. We vigorously con-
test, however, the defendant's allegation that an award under the
compensation statutes constitutes a bar to the bringing of an action
under the Tort Claims Act.
The injury sustained at the hands of the government's emplovees
in October, 1951 was a new and different injury trom the reeurrent
disiocation of the patella that the plaintiff had when he entered the
Veterans Administration Hospital.
The Federal Tort Claims Act, under which the plaintiff ix pro-
ceeding, Was passed by Congress in 1946, long after the compensa-
tion statutes became effeetive. The Act permits actions to be
started against the government for the negligence of governmental
emplovees. Its language is general in scope. [Tt provides (28 UL Ss.
(A. 2680) for twelve specifie exceptions, The plaintiff's action
herein does not fall within any one of these exceptions or a combina-
tion of any of them, nor is there anything in the Compensa-
i tion Act (88 US. CA. SOLA) providing that that Act is the
exclusive remedy for a veteran.
Thus, the government is arguing that new and different excep-
tions be read into the Tort Claims Act. The government ove: looks
the facet that the Tort Claims Act was passed in 1946, when Congress
was unquestionably cognizant ef the rights and remedies of veterans.
Brooks v. Tnited States (1949), 337 v. = 49. 69 S. Cr. 918. The
government also overlooks the faet that eighteen Tort Claims bills
were introduced in Congress between 1925 and 1935. All but two
of them contained exeeptions denying recovery to meribers of the
armed forees. When the present Tort Claims Act was introduced
the exeeption concerning servicemen had been dropped. Tt was this
Act, passed without any exelusion, that was passed in 1946, and is
the present law. Brooks v. United States, supra.
Rather than argue the law in his affidavit, the Assistant Untied
States Attorney has cited the recent case of O'Nedl vv. United States,
decided 2.19.53 by the Court of Appeals for the Distriet of Co-
lumbia Cireuit. T have read this ease carefully and examined the
authorities cited therein. LT have found this decision to be squarely
in conflet with the decision of the Court of Appeals for the First
Cjreuit in Santana v. United States (1949), 175 Fed. 2d 320. and
the decision in Bandy v. United States (D.C. Nevada 19504, 92 Fed.
Sup. 260. In my opinion, the O'Neil ease is in confhet with the
Supreme Court decisions m Rrooks vv. United States (19491. 337
US 49.695. Ct. GIS. and Feres v. United States (1950), 340 Tos.
135. 71S. Ct. 153.
.
1” UNITED STATES OF AMEKICA VS. PETER BROWN
Santana «. United States (1st Cirenit 1949), 175 Fed. 2d 320. 1. «
ease squarely in pownt. This alse was an action under the Federa!
Tort Claims Aet. The plaintiffs were the heirs of Manuel Rev. a
veteran who obtained admission to a Veterans Administratton Ho--
pital subsequent to his discharge. The complaint alleged
17 that he died as the result of the negligence of the emplovees
of the hospital in earing for him.
The United States made the same arguments in that ease as i
does in the ease at bar. Ut argued that there was a comprehen-ive
system of special statutory benefit for serviee-connected myjuries;
that Congress in enacting the Tort Claims Act must have intended
to exelude such elaims from it; that despite the general language of
the act and the fact that the act itself contains twelve specific exeep-
tions, none of whieh excludes an ex-servieeman from its benefit<, 1
should be read as impliedly excluding such elaime.
The District Court dismissed the complaint, but the Court) of
Appeals reversed. The Court of Appeals said, at page 322:
“In our opinion, the decision in the Brooks case hes eom-
pletely underminea the arguments of the government in the
case athbar ° ° °
“In the ease at bar Manue! Rey was not in the service at the
time of the negligence complained of. He had returned to
private life as a discharged veteran and imelusion of his e¢laim
within the coverage of the Tort Claims Aet would involve no
problem of the ‘subversion of military discipline.’
“With respect to the remaining argument that Congress pre-
sumably did not intend to include discharged veterans within
the coverage of the Tort Claims Act insofar as they already are
covered by a ‘comprehensive system of special statutory bene-
fits the Supreme Court in its decision in the Brooks ease, in
the language above quoted expressly discredited that argument
even as applied to servieemen.”
1S The Court in the O'Neil! case, supra, at page 4 of its
opinion, passed off the Santana ease by simply saying that it
“was decided before the Feres case.”
The Feres case. however, in no way overrules or distinguishes the
Santana ease, and, in fact is inapplicable t) the case at bar. The
Feres case (Feres v. United States (1950), 340 U.S. 135, 71 8. Ct.
153). actually involved three cases.
In the Feres case itself, the first of the three eases, the decedent
perished by fire in a barracks while he was on active duty in the
service of the United States.
In Jefferson vv. lnited States, the second of the three cases, the
plaintiff. while on active duty in the army was required to undergo
an operation. Fight month. later, after his discharge, a towel marked
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN 11
“ES. Army” was discovered and removed from his stomach The
complaint therem alleged that the towel was neghgently Jett there
by the original army surgeon,
In Girogas v. United States, the third of the three cases considered,
the complaint alleged that the deceased met bis death while on
active duty beeause of the negligent medieal treatment rendered to
lum by army surgeons.
It is thus apparent that all three cases concerned neghgence of
army personnel which cause injury to servicemen while on aetive
duty. The Court said, at page 138: 4
“The common tact underlying the Cuvee cases i that each
claimant, while on active duty and not on furlough, su-tamed
injurv due to negligence of others in the armed forces os
“This is the ‘wholly different ease” reserved from our decision
in Broalks v. Tonited States, 337 U_s. 49, 52, 69 S. Ct 9S, O20).
931. Kd, 1200."
In its opinion, the Court repeatediv refers to and limits rts deci1en
to servicemen on active duty, or “in service.” | Referring
9 again to the Brooks case, the Court said, at page I46:
“The injury to Brooks did not arise out of or in the course ef
military duty. Brooks was on furlough, driving aleng the tagh-
way under compulsion ot no orders or_duty and on no military
mission. A government owned and operated: vehicle collided
with him. Brooks’ father, ridin’ in the same ear, reeoyered tor
his injuries and the government did not further contest 7 judg-
ment, but contended there could be no liability to the sons,
solely beeause they were in the army. This Court rejeeted the
contention, primarily because Brooks’ relationship while on
Jeave was not analogous to that of a soldier injured while per-
forming duties under orders.” :
It is thus clear that the Feres decision did not and does not apply
te a discharged veteran who is not under orders or on active duty
In no wise did it limit or overrule the Santana decision, Om the
contrary, it specifically limited the implied exception to the Tort
Claims Act to cases in which the plaintiff was on active duty
In the Brooks decision (Brooks v. United States [1949], 337 Tos
39 695 Ct. 918), the Court said, at page 50:
“The question is whether members of the United States Armed
Forces can recover under that Aet ¢Tort Claims Neth tor
injuries not incident te neir service.”
Page Jl:
“The statutes and terms are clear The Voorn ile for Dhnetriet
Court pirisdietion over any claim founded on negligence brought
against the United States. We are not persuaded that ‘any
12 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
clam means ‘anv elaim but that of servicemen.” The
wi statute does contain twelve exceptions. None exclude
petitioner's elaimes.”
Page a:
We are dealing with an saeeident which had nething to do
with the Brooks armiv esreers; imjuries not caused by their
service exeept im the sense that all human events depend upon
what has alreedy trinspired. Were the aceident incident to the
brooks serviee, a wholly different ease would be presented.”
Page 53:
“Provisions in other statutes for disability payments to seryv-
rcemen, and gratuity pavments to their survivors, 38 U.S.C.
TOL indieate no purpose to forbid tort aetions under the Tort
Clias Net) Unhke the usual Workmens Compensation Statute,
ee 35 Pos. ©. 905, there is nothing in the Port Claims Act or
the Veterans Laws whieh provides for exelusiveness of remedy
* © * Tn the very aet we are construing, Congress provided
for the exelusiveness of the remedy in three instanees, numbers
weds. 410th) and 423 tnow 28 UL Ss. C. A. 1346, 2672. 2679)
and omutted any provision which would govern this case.”
The Ned! ease. supra, also relies on Johansen v. United States,
343 Ul S. 427 (1952), and Lewis v. United States, 89 U.S. App.
by © 21, 190 B24 22 61951). Neither of these cases, however, has
anvthing te do with either the Tort Claims Act or the Veterans
Compensation Aet. Both of them wee questions of workmen’s com-
pensation as provided for under the Federal Emplovees Compensa-
tion Net of 19916 465 US. CAL T51, ef seg). The Johansen case
held that having collected workmen's compensation, a ¢crvilian
21 emiploves on a publie vessel could not sue the United States
under the Puble Vessels Act of 1925 (46 U.s. C. A. 781. ef
vy + wineh allowed libels in adioirality.
In the Levos ease a member of the United States Park Police
Poree was shot by another member of the same police foree engaged
with hon in the course ef duty pursuing two fugitives. It was held
that the Ped ral Emplevees Compensation Act was the exclu ive
remedy
Barreda footed States (D.C. Nevada 1950), 92 Fed. Supp. 360.
oease qn pomt. however. The plaintiff therein was a veteran who
had been discharged with a rhenmatie fever disability. inenrred
hile am sercctee He sshsequently entered a Veterans Administration
Hostal to seeemve examination and treatment, if necessary, of the
rheumatic disabilitv. In the course of receiving heat treatments, he
was placed in an eleetric cabinet bath. Despite his complaint, he
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN 13
Was kept there too long. He became unconscious and suffered serious
burns. On his action brought under the Tort Claims Act. the Court
rejected the government's arguments that the plaintiff had made an
election of remedies by obtaining compensation under the Veterans
Compensation Act, and that his disability (the resulting scars) was
a service-connected disability, for which he could not reeover under
the Tort Claims Act. The Court awarded $15,000.00 to the plaintiff.
In summary, there is a confliet of decisions in the Cireuit Courts
and the District Courts. The better law, and the law that conforms
to the Supreme Court decisions in Brooks and Feres supports our
contention that tae plaintiff? herein may pursue his remedy under the
Tort Claims Act.
Wirererore, I respeectfull, pray that the defendant's motion be in
all respeets denied.
(Sworn to by Lee S. Kreindler, April 9, 1953.)
22 Ix Unitep Stares Distrrier Court, SovrTuHern District oF
New Yor«
Opmxton BY JupcGe DimocKk-—June 3, 1952
Memorandum
This motion raises the question whether a discharged veteran who
has siffered further injury as a result of treatment of service incurred
injury inoa Veteran’s Administration Hospital and is receiving
additional disability benefits for the resulting injury may recover
under the Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S. C. 2671, ef seq. There
is a square conflict of authority on this point. Holding that such a
recovery may not be had are the recent cases of O'Neil v. United
States, D. C. Cir., 202 F. 2d 366, and Pettis v. United States,
D.C. N. DD. Cal., 108 F. Supp. 500, while the opposite result was
reached in Santana v. United States, 1 Cir., 175 F. 2d 220, and
Bandy v. United States, D.C. D. Nev., 92 F. Supp. 360. 1 accept
the reasoning of the O'Neill case.
The motion to dismiss the complaint for failure te state a claim
npon which relief can be granted is granted.
Dated: June 3, 1953.
BE. J. Dimock,
Tnited States District Judge
14 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
23 In United states District Court, Southern District of New
York
ORDER AND JUDGMENT APPEALED From—June 23, 1953
This cause having come on for hearing on the defendant's motion
to dismiss the action in that the Court lacked jurisdiction of the
subject matter of the claim asserted therein under Rule T2thi of
the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and the Court having heard
the argument of counsel thereto, it is, on motion of J. Edward Lum-
hard, United States Attorney for the Southern District of New
York, attorney for the defendant.
OrpereD that the defendant’s motion be granted and the com-
plaint be and the same hereby is dismissed, and it is
FURTHER OrpERED that the defendant, United States of America,
recover eosts as taxed in the sum of $20.00 from the plaintiff Peter
Brown and that execution issue therefor.
Dated: New York, N. Y., June 23rd, 1953.
IK. J. Dimock,
U.S. D. J.
Judgment entered June 23rd, 1953.
WituiaM V. ConNELL.
Clerk.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN 1
24 in United States District Court
NoTice oF Apprat— June 30, 1953
Notice is hereby given that the plaintiff Peter Brown hereby
appeals to the Court of Appeals for the Second Cireuit from the
order of the Honorable Edward J. Dimock, United States District
Judge, dismissing the complaint herein, and from the judgment dis-
missing this action, together with costs as taxed in the sum ot
$20,000, entered in this action on June 24, 1953.
New York, N. Y.
Yours, ete.,
Harry FE. Kreinper,
Attorney for Plaintiff-Appellant,
51 Chambers Sitrcet,
New York 7, New York.
To:
J. Epwarp LumBarp, Esq,
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York,
Attorney for Defendant,
(Office & P.O. Address)
United States Court House,
Foley Square,
Borough of Manhatton,
City of New York.
25 STIPULATION AS TO CONTENTS OF RecorD (Omitted in print-
ing)
26 STIPU LATION OF ATTORNEYS APPROVING Recorp (Omitted in
printing)
27-28 Clerk’s Certificate to foregoing transcript omitted in print-
ing.
16 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
29° In United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
No. 87
Argued December 18, 1953
Docket No, 22826
| Title omitted |
Before’ CLuark, FRANK and Hinecks, Circuit Judges
Appeal from a final order of the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York, Judge Dimock. Rerversen.
Harry FE. Kreinpier (Lee 8. Kreindler, ef counsel), for appellant.
J. Eowarp Lumbarp, United States Attorney for the Southern
District of New York (Milton kK. Wessel, of counsel), for appellee.
30 Plaintiff brought this suit against the United States. assert-
ing a claim under the Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U. 3. ©.
sees, 1346(b), 2674 and 2680.) The United States moved for sum-
mary judgment. On the basis of the complaimt, the answers of the
‘plaintiff to interrogatories and the affidavits filed 'y both parties
the facts presented were as follows:
Plaintiff served in the Army Air Force from October 27, 1942 to
August 6, 1944. During that time, while on active duty in New
Guinea, he was injured in the left knee. He was hospitalized until
his honorable discharge in August, 1944. At that time he eould
walk, but upon any sudden or strenuous movements, his left leg
would beeome dislocated. On March 8, 1950, “he was operated upen
by the Veterans Administration, for the purpose of ‘cleaning up’ the
knee joint.”
As, however, “his leg continued to dislocate frequently,” he asked
to be and was admitted, on October 1, 1951, to a Veterans Adminis-
tration Hospital in New York. It was then decided that it would
be well to perform another operation on the knee to prevent the
leg from dislocating; it was to be a “bloodless operation, requiring
the application of s tourniquet to the left thigh.” In faet, on
October 4, 1951, a tourniquet was thus apphed by an operating room
attendant in the employ of the Veterans Administration. As the
tourniquet was defective, in that the pressure gauge did not register,
an excessive amount of pressure was applied. “The attendant
should have realized” the defect as soon as the tourniquet was ap-
plied, but he did not. As a result of the excessive pressure, the
nerves in the plaintiff's leg were seriously and permanently injured,
Plaintiff was awarded a pension bv the Veterans Administration
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN V7
at the time of his honorable discharge. This pension was increased
because of the injury he sustained as a result of the operation in
1951.
31 On these facts, the United States contended that plaintiff's
sole relief was under the Compensation Act, 38 U.S. C. see.
Ola. The District Court, agreeing with this argument, made an
order dismissing the complaint. Plaintiff has appealed.
Optnton—January 5, 1954
FRANK, Circuit Judge:
Admittedly, plaintiff's claim is not within any explicit exeep-
tion contained in the Tort Claims Act. In Brooks v. United States,
337 U.S. 49, the Court refused te read in an exception covering
injuries to a serviceman, where the event exusing the injury was
not “incident to the service.” In Feres v. United States, 340 U.S.
135, the Court considered three cases relative to injuries incurred
while on aetive duty in the armed forces. In one of these eases,
the injury resulted from negligence during the course of an abdomi-
nal operation; in another, death resulted from negligent medical
treatinent by army surgeons. The Court said: “The eommon fact
underlying the three cases is that each claimant, while on active
duty and not on furlough, sustained injury due to neglizence of
others in the armed forces.” The Court held that, on these faets,
the federal statutes expressly providing compensation for injuries
of those in the armed service are exclusive “where the injuries arise
out of or are in the course of activity incident to service,” and that,
accordingly, for such injuries there can be no reeovery under the
Tort Claims Act.
In the instant ease, the plaintiff. while in active service, had been
injured in the left knee during military operations in New Guinea.
He received his discharge from the army in August 1944. Seven
vears later, in 1951, pursuant to his status as a veteran, an opera-
tion was performed, in a veterans’ hospital, by employees of the
government's Veterans Administration. on his left knee, for
32 the purpose of preventing the leg from disloeating. Due to
negligence in the course of that operation, he reeeived a
further serious injury on which he grounded his suit. Plaintiff is
receiving veteran's compensation for this injury, under 38 U.S.C.
Ola!
‘Tt is to be noted that 38 U.S.C. 5014 covers compensation not
only for an aggravation of an existing injury, but also for a new
injury, suffered as the result of hospitalization or surgical treatment
furnished under the compensation statute.
18 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. PETER BROWN
We think that these facts do not bring this case within the doctrine
of Feres v. United States, since no injury of which plaintiff now
complains was sustained while he “was on active duty and not on
furlough.” Moreover, we do not agree with the government's con-
tention that plaintiff's claim is to be deemed merely an aggravation
of his original injury and that it is therefore to be regarded just
as ifat had happened while he was on active duty.
The lower federal courts, in deciding similar eases, have disagreed
with one another. O'Neil v. United States, 202 F. (2d) 366 (App.
DD. C.j favors the government's argument. However, it relies on
Feres v. United States which, we think, not in point, and on Johan-
sen V. United States, 343 U.S. 427, which we also regard as inapposite
since it involved an interpretation of quite different statutes.2 Also
favoring the government is Pettis v. United States, 108 F. Supp.
500.4
On the other hand, Santana v. United States, 175 F. (2d) 320
(C. A. 1), and Bandy v. United States, 92 F. Supp. 360, sustain
plaintiff's contention. With them we agree. It is urged that those
decisions were rendered before Feres. We think that argu-
33-34 ment untenable, in the light of our interpretation of Feres.
Of course, we have not considered defenses the govern-
ment may assert on the merits such as, e.g.. New York decisions
limiting the halnlity of a hospital operated as an eleemosynary
institution,
39-36 In United States Court of Appeals for the Second Cireuit
Peter BROWN, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT,
v.
UNITED STATES, DEFENDANT-APPELLEE
JepGMENT-—January 5, 1954
Appeal from the United States Distriet Court for the Southern
Distriet of New York.
This cause came on to be heard on transcript of record from the
United States District Court for the Southern Distriet of New
York, and was #rgued by counsel.
QIN CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, it is now hereby ordered, adjudged,
* There the Court, referring to the Feres case, spoke of it (343
U.S. at 440) as relating to “soldiers on active duty.”
4 Lewis v. United States, 190 F. (2d) 22 (App. D. ('.). related to
an injury to a member of the U.S. Park Police incurred while on
active duty.
UNITED STATES OF AMEKICA VS. PETER BROWN 1
and decreed that the judgment of said Distriet Court be and it
hereby is reversed in accordanee with the opinion of this court.
It is further ordered that a Mandate issue to the said District
Court in accordance with this decree.
A. Dantet Fusaro, Clerk.
37 Clerk's Certifieate to foregoing transeript omitted in print-
Ing.
38 Supreme Court of the United States, October Term, 1953
No. 654
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER.
VS,
Peter Brown
OrpER ALLOWING Crertiorsri—Filed April 26, 1954
The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is granted, and the case is
transferred to the summary docket.
And it is further ordered that the duly certified copy of the
transcript of the proceedings below which accompanied the peti-
tion shall be treated as though filed in response to such writ.
Mr. Justice Jackson took no part in the consideration or deci-
sion of this application.
Tl U.S GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1986 nooaet foes
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.