Petitioners Brief — Delta Air Lines, Inc. v. Summerfield
Supreme Court brief1954
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
#itED
_ ova 71983.
Anemos E. Sigouaienh, Dostetikos Generabof the United
States, and Tae Unrrep cerainbaneed on behalf *
of the Reena Some :
{
"on Wott of Crtorat 9 thé United States (
J
for the District of Golumbla Circuit
of Counsel:
R..8. Maven,
2 e President Legal,
Ita Air Lines, 2s
* es es omen eet a ee
Panes or Braow 8, Adancs, Wasmmmetont, D, C.
tg meth ; " Past ache
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
Page
pinions below .....-...eeseeeee eee eeeeeeereeees ee
NR fav vee deb sti cn dverwe¥eesbeeseasevens 2
estions presented ........+..eee eee ee creer ee eeeee 3
tatutes involved ...........ceccccccccccenececcces 3
ESERIES POO OPOT TET TTY TIT TALL TEE teat 3
pecification Of errors ..........e.e eee e sees cence 12
ummary of Argument ...........eeeeeeeeeeee cence 13
\rgument :
I. When the Board, under authority of the Act,
separately classified the domestic and interna-
tional operations of C&S as separate rate-making
units, it was no longer empowered by the Act,
when fixing air mail rates in the international
division in 1951, to apply in reduction of the
‘‘need’’ of C&S for the 1948-1950 period in its
international division any portion of the earnings
which were realized during the same period in the
domestic division under final and unchallenged air
mail rates fixed in 1948 in a separate proceeding
for the domestic division ...........+..+e++e5- 17
SSS EELS PELLET EPCOT TCE CE ETE 17
A. Tf, in fixing the air mail rates in the interna-
tional division of C&S, the Board must also
determine the ‘‘need’’ of the carrier as a
whole, the express authorization to ‘‘fix differ-
ent rates for... different classes of service’’
of an air carrier becomes meaningless, con-
trary to well recognized principles of statu-
tory construction ..........ccscscsceccseees 19
B. Well-established principles of rate-making in
existence at the time the Act was passed con-
firm a construction of Section 406(b) of the
Act which authorizes the Board to fix air mail
BLURRED COPY
aT
Page
rates for a territorial unit less than the car-
rier’s whole operation and which prevents re-
capturing earnings under a closed rate ...... 23
’ C. A construction of Section 406(b) of the Act
which would require the Board, in fixing mail
rates in a properly classified international
rate-making division, to determine ‘‘need’’ for
the carrier during a past period in its domestic
division (where rates had been final and un-
challenged) and, thereupon, to consider re-
ducing or increasing the ‘‘need’’ of the inter-
national division for that period, is contrary
to the intent of the Act as revealed in the
expressly stated purposes of the Act and as
construed by this Court .................... 28
1. The finality of previously established final
rates would be destroyed and a cost-plus
basis of rate-making would result ......... 28
ii Index continued
2. The profits of the stronger domestic services
of carriers operating both domestic and in-
ternational services would be applied to
financing the international air services and
this would jeopardize the national air policy
of the United States and defeat a basic in-
Ge ee SIE occa ik ca hese osctweaudiess 30
a. The history of the development of our
national air policy, and the rejection of
the ‘‘chosen instrument’’ as related to
the objectives of the Act ................ 30
b. The decision of the court will jeopardize
the national air policy ................. 34 |
3. The financial stability of air carriers, one
of the principal objectives of the Act, would
be impaired by unduly delaying the finality
Oe Es chines wics ae ne eee 37
4. It would be impossible for air carriers en-
gaged in both domestic and international
air services to compete effectively with air
BLEED THROUGH- POOR COPY
Index continued iii
Page
carriers engaged exclusively in domestic
services with the result that the domestic
public interest would suffer and one of the
principal objectives of the Act would be
DO onic cin ndedeswonscuuedecavisens es 41
D. Contrary to the Postmaster General’s asser-
tions, adopted by the court below, the Board’s
prior administration of the Act does not sup-
port the contention that it must, as a matter of
law, apply earnings realized under a final and
unchallenged mail rate in one division in re-
duction of need determined for another divi-
sion in a subsequent proceeding ............ 43
IL. If, contrary to the contentions of Petitioner,
Section 406(b) of the Act requires the Board, in
fixing mail rates for a rate-making division, to
‘‘take into consideration ... the need ...’’ of the
carrier as a whole, then the Board’s action should
be upheld as a valid exercise of its discretionary
QTE oo ccc evecccccscunesvevscenevdenwenss 48
DAO one din id ae edn ibanhvadeee ete teres 48
A. At no time was there any finding by the Board
in the domestic division of C&S that the car-
rier’s ‘‘need’’ was limited to a return of 7.4% ;
or that any earnings, under the sliding-scale
future mail rates therein fixed, would be ex-
cessive; and, therefore, there is no automati-
cally determinable ‘‘corpus’’ of ‘‘excess’’
earnings as the court below assumed ........ 49
B. The Board in the proceeding below did ‘‘take
into consideration’? the ‘‘need’’ of the air
carrier as a whole and its decision was a valid
exercise of its discretionary authority ...... 53
BLURRED COPY
_
lv Index continued
CITATIONS
CasES: Page
American Airlines, Inc—Mai Rate Proceeding, 3
Re RED cigvbiesduneyecnvusdsews sees
American Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board,
Eee Come Gar COO, Coe, TOE)... ecveviacecevss
American Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3
ee EE oc Nowe Seve ccerowsesevereve 40
American Toll Bridge Co. v. Railroad Commission of
California, 307 U.S. 486 (1939) ................ 25, 27
Arizona Grocery Co. v. Atchison, Topeka, & Santa Fe
Ry. Co., et al., 284 U.S. 370 (1932) ..............
Baltimore & Ohio R. Co. v. United States, 345 U.S.
EN Fete k a chs ca bukees oe b ie ts ke eee 58
Board of Public Utility Commissioners v. New York
Telephone Co., 271 U.S. 23 (1926) .............. 26
Board of Trade v. United States, 314 U.S. 534 ae 56
Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 1 C.A.A. 353
areata beads ted ike vid 4b6e kee ens 20
Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 8 C.A.B. 971
ese eared cde wae ian eae 46
Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 9 C.A.B. 607
SP cis soc bal aig bh ne 64a AES ds 0On as 46
Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 11 C.A.B. 431
cocks ana car ebay hes ctdnwuaeeeda 46
Braniff Final Mail Rate Case, CAB Order No.
E-7815, Tentative Decision, October 13, 1953 .. . .38, 47
Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc., 9 C.A.B. 786
SS Re tee Se re 5, 7, 46, 50, 57
Chicago & Southern Airlines, Inc., Domestic Opera-
tions, Statement of Tentative Findings and Con-
clusions, CAB Order No. E-5869 (1951) ......... 23
Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc—Mail Rates for
Route Nos. 8 and 53, 3 C.A.B. 161 (1941) ....48, 44, 45
Chicago and Southern Air Lines, Inc. vy. Waterman
Steamship Corporation, 333 U.S. 103 (1948) ..... 31
Colonial Airlines, Inc., Bermuda Rates, 9 C.A.B. 20
UBER es ala pes a ee 46
Colonial Airlines, Inc., Bermuda Mail Rates, 12
EN i artic us ak nas baile dw wina'nones 46
Continental A. L., Mail Rates, 8 C.A.B. 825 (1947) .. 6
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
Index continued Vv
Page
Delta Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Latin American
Operations, Statement of Provisional Findings and
Conclusions, CAB Order No. E-7738, Sept. 21, 1953
29, 32, 36, 47, 53
Eastern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3
C.A.B. 733 (1942) .....--ccecccccscccsecceceees
Fifteen Per Cent Case, 178 1.C.C. 539 (SUE? sxasee 26
Florida Power & Light Co. v. City of Miami, 98 F.
(2d) 180 (C.C.A. 5th 1938) ...-.-- see neces eee rs 25
Georgia Railway & Power Co. v. Railroad Commis-
sion of Georgia, 262 U.S. 625 (1923) ............ 26
Gilchrist v. Interborough Rapid Transit Co., 279 U.S.
150 (IDBD) .. cn cccccnscccscsnesvevsscccesscecs 25
International Ry. Co. v. Prendergast, 1 F. Supp. 623
(D.C. W.D. N.Y. 1932) .......-2 eee rere ences 25
Keifer & Keifer v. Reconstruction Finance Corpora-
tion, 306 U.S. 381 (1939) ........ eee eee ee eee 18
King v. United States, 344 U.S. 254 COREE) ovecesn- 58
Logan City v. Public Utilities Commission, 77 Utah
442, 296 Pac. 1006 (1931) .....-.-.- seen ees eee 28
National Airlines, Inc., Statement of Tentative Find-
ings and Conclusions, CAB Order No. E-6344,
April 21, 1952 ........ ese e cesses teen cece 47
Northwest Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, 10 CA.B. 1
IE BA cist sccnelvdescxexapouiees tavas' 46
Northwest Airlines, Inc., Trans-Pacific Mai Rates,
12 C.A.B; 256 (1950) .......-ccceescecscccccccs 46
In Re Northwestern Bell Telephone Co., 164 Minn.
979, 204 N.W. 873 (1925) ....------s eee seen 25, 28
Pan American Airways, Inc., Alaska Mail Rates, 6
CLA.B. 61 (1944) .......---ceccecceeees 43, 44, 45, 46
Pan American Airways, Inc., Latin-American Rate
Case, 3 C.A.B. 657 (1942) ......-. ee eee ese ee ee 44
Pan American Airways, Latin-American Mail Rates,
6 C.A.B. 85 (1944) ..... 2. cece cece sce s eee e neces 45
Pan American-Grace Airways, Inc.—Mail Rates, 3
CLAW. SEO (1O8B) .. 0. nese cccscescorscscvnces 40, 46
Pennsylvania Central Airlines Corp., Motions, 8
ee YN: ere rrreee ris 28, 46, 47
Pioneer Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rate, CAB Order No.
E-7225, March 13, 1953 ........----- see eeee ees 20
In re Public National Bank of New York, 278 US.
101 (1928) ......- eee ee cece eens ee eereeeeces 18
BLURRED COPY
—
vi Index Continued
Page
Summerfield, Postmaster General, et al. v. Civil Aero-
nautics Board, Nos. 11259 and 11324 (D.C. Cir.,
EE 4s cu newness kaekess caeul deatawesoes
Transcontinental d& Western Air, Inc. v. Cwil Aero-
nautics Board, 336 U.S. 601 (1949) ....2, 14, 19, 24, 26,
“98 29, 30, 40, 47
Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aero-
nautics Board, 169 F.. 2d 896 (D.C. Cir. 1948) .... 40
Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates,
SS EE vs Sind ey steudbendesuaeeea 46
Transcontinental d& Western Air, Inc., Transatlantic
Mail Rate, 7 C.A.B. 421 (1946) ................. 46
Transconinental & Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 10
EE cu Sak nouscbuebevdbeeneaed ce 46
United States y. American Trucking Associations,
OD ood ce cnavess sand eunavewke 18
United States v. New York Central Ry. Co., 279 U.S.
EE nil k ints. cd neeeoraGeh bade uwrned anus 26
Wabash Valley Electric Co. v. Singleton et al., 1 F.
Supp. 106 (D.C. S.D. Ind. 1932) ............... 24
Wabash Valley Electric Co. v. seaeees 287 U.S. 488
SE cca Liines besa bed oewebceneteeneanee 24, 25, 27
STaTUTEs:
Civil Aeronautics Act, Act of June 23, 1938, ec. 601,
52 Stat. 977, as amended, 49 U.S.C. 401, et seq. ... .3, 60
Dio euuGyacadedes vase tekerseaeoee 30, 37, 56, 57
ES clic bbe Gene ede dh aaueuanitereeeaee 31, 56
PC cieneads coh eer eb wkdeden tauren 37
TC. cwuni tense ve serene suv dae ene 37
eves cae hu ncee canna 8, 17, 23, 31, 56
Sec. 406(b) ............ conan 4, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15,
17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23,
25, 28, 43, 46, 48 49, 55,
56, 57, 58
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
Index Continued vii
Page
Reorganization Plan No. IV, Sec. 7, June 30, 1940,
UE SD vec cevecnsiccaseeceruseieuteseet ves
Transportation Act of Feb. 28, 1920, ec. 91, Sec. 422,
41 Stat. 456, 488-491 ...... 2... cee eee eee re eeee 26
Wis. Stat. (1929), Section 196.03(2) .......----++- 25
MO TBC. GAB (8)... cccccvccccvccccvesccccceses 2
OB UGC. VEGA) 2 once ccccccccvvcccresccscsecces 2
ConGcRESSIONAL MaTERIAL:
83 Cong. Ree. 8500, 75th Cong., 3d Sess. (1938) ..... 38
Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Aviation of
the Committee on Commerce, United States Senate,
79th Congress, Ist Session, on S. 326 .......-.-- 33
Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and
Foreign Commerce, House of Representatives, 80th
Congress, 1st Session, on Bills Relative to Over-
seas Air Transportation ...........--+.+++esee- 33
Hearings Before a Subcommittee of the Committee
on Interstate and Foreign Commerce, United
States Senate, 80th Congress, Ist Session, on S. 987
33, 34
E.R. Rep. No. 2254, 75th Cong., 3d Sess. (1930) .... 38
MISCELLANEOUS:
Baird, Should the Rate Making Unit be Fixed by
Statute, 1 U. Chi. L. Rev. 451 (1934) ..........-- 25
Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation
of Subsidy From Total Mail Payments To Domes-
tic Air Carriers, September, 1951 ...........---- 5
Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation
of Subsidy from Total Mail Payments to United
States International, Overseas and Territorial Air
Carriers, June 1952 ........-.--e cece cee eases 34
Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation
of Subsidy from Total Mail Payments to United
States Air Carriers, September, 1953 Revision . .35, 38
Civil Aeronautics Board, Annual Report, 1940 .... 34
Civil Aeronautics Board, Economic Regulations, Part
D411, 14 CPR 41... cece ccc cverereccssess 22
C.A.B. Official Airline Route and Mileage Manual,
Oe" Seer rere rrr rr ree
C.A.B. Recurrent Report of Mileage and Traffic Data
34, 39
2 Sutherland, Statutory Construction (3rd ed. 1943) 18
BLURRED COPY
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
b. a
IN THE
Supreme Court of the Gnited States
October Term, 1953
No. 223
Dera Arr Lings, Inc., Petitioner,
v.
Artuur E. SuMMERFIELD, Postmaster General of the United
States, and Tue Unirep Srares or America, on behalf
of the Postmaster General, Respondents.
On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit
BRIEF FOR THE PETITIONER
OPINIONS BELOW
The opinion of the Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit (R. 68-76) is not yet reported. The opin-
ion of the Civil Aeronautics Board (R. 51-60) is not yet
reported.
BLURRED COPY
2
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the Court of Appeals was entered o
May 4, 1953 (R. 77). Petitions for a Writ of Certiora:
were filed July 31, 1953, by the Civil Aeronautics Boar
(No. 222) and by the Petitioner (No. 223). The Actin
Solicitor General subsequently filed a Memorandum i
which he stated that he did not oppose the granting of th
writ. The writ was granted October 12, 1953. The juris
diction of this Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254 (1
and 49 U.S.C. 646 (f).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Whether, when the domestic and international oper
tions of the same air carrier have been classified as sep
rate rate-making units, the Board is empowered by th
Civil Aeronautics Act to apply any of the revenues derive
from the carrier’s domestic services during a past three
year period of final and closed air mail rates in reductio
of such earrier’s requirements for compensation under th
Act on its international division, in a proceeding where ai
mail rates for such international division are being fixe
retroactively for the same period.
2. Whether, if, contrary to Petitioner’s contention, th
answer to Question 1 is in the affirmative, the Board ma
exercise its discretion as to whether or not, for reasons o
public interest, any such possible application of revenue
derived from the carrier’s domestic division shall he mad
in whole or in part, or not at all, in fixing air mail rates fo
the ecarrier’s international division.
3. Whether the decision below by the Court of Appeal
effects a recapture of earnings of the air carrier unde
closed air mail rates in its domestic division contrary to th
construction of the mail rate provisions of the Civil Aero
nautics Act laid down by the United States Supreme Cour
in Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronau
tics Board, 336 U.S. 601 (1949).
BLEED THROUGH-— POOR COPY
» a
4, Whether the Board, in fixing mail rates for an air car-
rier may give weight to rate-fixing policies desirable in the
public interest for the air transportation industry as a
whole and, therefore, for the particular air carrier (for
which mail rates are being fixed) as an integral part of
such industry.
STATUTES INVOLVED
The pertinent provisicas of the Civil Aeronautics Act of
1938, as amended, * which will be referred to as the Act,
are set forth in the Appendix hereto.
STATEMENT
Chicago and Southern Air Lines, Ine. (C&S) ? during the
period relevant to this case conducted domestic air trans-
port operations over routes extending between Chicago and
Detroit, on the one hand, and Houston and New Orleans,
on the other, and international air transport operations
over routes extending between the two last mentioned cities
and Caracas, Venezuela via Havana and Kingston. The
certificates of public convenience and necessity for both op-
erations authorize the transportation of mail, persons, and
property.
This case concerns the fair and reasonable rates for the
transportation of mail in the international division of C&S
fixed by the Board on October 18, 1951, for the period Jan-
uary 1, 1948 to December 15, 1950; and involves the ques-
tion of whether earnings of the carrier experienced in its
separate domestic division during that period under final
air mail rates fixed by the Board on July 28, 1948, and un-
challenged during such period must, as a matter of law, be
1Act of June 23, 1938, c. 601, 52 Stat. 977, as amended, 49 U.S.C. 401,
et seq.
2Chieago and Southern Air Lines, Inc., has since merged with Delta Air
Lines, Ine. (Delta) by statutory corporate merger, Delta being the surviving
corporation. Delta was substituted as the intervenor below subsequent to the
decision of the Court of Appeals (R. 78).
BLURRED COPY
a
used to reduce the carrier’s mail pay requirements in its
international division.
Pursuant to Section 406(b) of the Act, the Board is em-
powered to ‘‘fix different rates for ... different classes of
service’’. In accordance with its unvarying practice in
cases where a single air carrier conducts substantial in-
ternational operations in addition to domestic operations,
the Board classified the international and domestic opera-
tions of C&S into two separate rate-making divisions. Some
of its related policy reasons as expressed in the opin-
ions of the Board below were: (a) ‘‘many considerations
which enter into the fixing of an international rate are dif-
ferent from those entering into the establishment of a do-
mestic rate’’ (R. 20); (b) the desirability of achieving
maximum incentive, by replacing a carrier’s temporary air
mail rates on a ‘‘eost-plus’’ basis with permanent final rates,
is such that it is undesirable to delay putting a carrier on
final rates for its domestic system pending the completion
of a proceeding designed to set final rates for the interna-
tional system (R. 19, 20); (ec) it is desirable ‘‘to maintain
the comparative status between those domestic operators
which have foreign routes as against those which do not
have foreign routes’’, not only in order to encourage in-
centive by creating ‘‘class rates’’ for groups of domestic
carriers within which each carrier must compete in secur-
ing revenue and in controlling costs, but also because of
the administrative desirability of preserving ‘‘a compara-
tive status between carriers’’ so that the Board can ‘‘ana-
lyze the operations ... within a class in the light of the re-
sults achieved by others within the same class’’ which is a
rate-making procedure proven ‘‘to be the most satisfactory
and practicable available to the Board’’ (R. 54-55) ; and (d)
the fact that ‘‘if the domestic air transport system can be
4
BLEED THROU GH-— POOR COPY
5
kept financially sound, the public must ultimately benefit”’
(R. 54). *
Accordingly, the Board in different proceedings, con-
cluded at different times, set final and different mail pay
rates for C&S’s domestic and international divisions.
The domestic case was completed first. In July of 1948
the Board fixed final ‘‘need’’ mail rates‘ effective January
1, 1948, for the air carrier operations of C&S over its do-
—_———-
$On this important consideration the Board said (R. 54):
‘‘Tf an offset policy were adopted, the almost invariable result would
be that, as in the instant case, the profits from a carrier’s domestic op-
eration would be used to sustain any international operations it might
have. Recognizing this likelihood, we hesitate to burden the more robust
segment of the industry with the obligations of the economically weaker
part. For if the domestic air transport system can be kept financially
sound, the public must ultimately benefit, putting aside any consideration
of the obvious advantage of reduced rates of mail compensation. Thus,
we anticipate that if the carriers’ earning position continues strong, re-
ductions in the domestic fare level will be possible, thereby giving impetus
to the further development of the industry. In addition, with improved
earnings, the domestic operators should be able to benefit the public and
themselves with more modern aircraft, and with improved methods afford-
ing safer and more efficient operations. We cannot escape the thought
that if we allow international operations to be carried on the back of
domestic operations, we shall be subjecting the latter to an unjustifiable
strain.’’
4The Board fixes two types of rates of compensation for the transportation
of mail under Section 406 of the Act (infra, Appendix). One is called a
‘‘gervice rate’’. It is subsidy-free and is fixed in terms of mail actually
transported, such as 45 cents per ton-mile for the Group I class of subsidy-
free domestic air carriers (American Airlines, Inc., Eastern Air Lines, Inc.,
Trans-World Airlines, Inc., and United Air Lines, Inec., herein sometimes
referred to as ‘‘American’’, ‘‘Eastern’’, ‘‘TWA’’, and ‘‘United’’, respec-
tively) and 53 cents per ton-mile for the Group II class of subsidy-free domes-
tie air carriers (Braniff Airways, Inc., Capital Airlines, Inc., Delta Air
Lines, Inc., National Airlines, Inc., Northwest Airlines, Inc., and Western Air
Lines, Inc., herein sometimes referred to as ‘‘ Braniff’’, ‘‘Capital’’, ‘‘ Delta’’,
‘‘National’’, ‘* Northwest’’, and ‘‘ Western’’, respectively). The service rate
includes allowances for costs allocable to the mail service and for a rate of
réturn on a portion of investment allocable thereto. C.A.B. Administrative
Separation of Subsidy from Total Mail Payments to Domestic Carriers, p. 8
(September, 1951). The other type is the ‘‘need rate’’. In order to meet
the ‘‘need’’ standard set forth in Section 406(b), this type of rate includes
compensation greater than would be included in a service rate. Customarily
a ‘‘need rate’’ is fixed in terms of a formula geared to aircraft miles flown.
BLURRED COPY
6
mestic air routes. This decision of the Board is reported
in Chicago and Southern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, 9
C.A.B. 786. In that proceeding the Board estimated the
revenues which would be received by C&S from traffic car-
ried (other than mail) in the domestic division and the ex-
penses of conducting its operations therein. The difference
between such revenues and expenses is known as ‘‘break-
even need’’. After making appropriate allocations of total
investment between the domestic and international divi-
sions, it determined the exact amount of investment for
rate-making purposes which C&S would require to conduct
its domestic operations and upon which a fair rate of return
(profit element) was allowed.
The Board then proceeded to establish ‘‘need’’ mail
rates for C&S’s domestic division which would cover C&S’s
‘“break-even need’’, as determined by the Board in the light
of the objectives of the Act, and to allow for a fair return
on investment allocated to that division. At 9 C.A.B. 786,
810-811, it stated that it was adopting a sliding-seale for-
mula for the payment of these mail rates related to the per-
centage of passenger seats occupied to the seats available
(load factor), whereby the estimated effective mail rate
per revenue plane mile flown would be gradually reduced
as the load factor increased.™
4a Thus the estimated effective mail rate per revenue plane mile flown, at
a load factor of 60%, was 26¢. An increase in load factor to 70% or 80%
would cause the rate to drop to 17¢ or 8¢ respectively. 9 C.A.B. 786, 811.
The Board stated that it was adopting the sliding-scale type formula for
‘“the same reasons that we relied upon in applying the sliding-seale formula’’
in Continental A. L., Mail Rates, 8 C.A.B. 825 (1947). There the Board had
pointed out that: ‘‘.... A sliding-seale rate formula should serve in the instant
case to minimize the possibility of frequent rate revisions attributable to
uncertainties in predicting Continental’s passenger traffic. The public inter-
est will also be served by providing the carrier with an effective incentive
for maximum development of its routes consistent with economical and ef-
ficient management, since Continental will earn proportionately greater profits
with the increasing development of its traffic potential, while at the same time
the burden on the Government through need mail payments will be progres-
sively reduced.’’ 8 C.A.B. 825, 840.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
7
From the excerpt from the Board’s decision set forth in
the footnote below ° one further very important fact may be
ascertained. On the basis of the facts then before it, the
Board accepted the estimate that C&S would achieve a pas-
senger load factor of 60.09 percent. The Board also esti-
mated that such a load factor would yield a rate of return
after taxes of 7.4 percent. But the Board did not intend
this as a fixed rate of return to be built into C&S’s mail
rate. As can be readily ascertainable from the table in-
5‘*,. . The operating income per revenue plane mile before Federal income
taxes, and the rate of return on recognized investment after income taxes at
38 percent, for various load factors indicated, are presented below. .
Percent return
Operating on recognized
Revenue income before investment
passenger income tax, per after income
load factor revenue mile taxes at 38%
Percent Cents Percent
DC aiiweauiks cy see whew anaes —3.85 (@)
Pode e run teas 65a Samoa ewe 3.87 3.6
Pe ee Pat er eee ke 7.90 7.3
Oe anode aoe nevaeeeeirire een 11.03 10.2
SD cdcinn noord eben eeuTane einen 14.16 13.1
1 The loss of 3.85 cents per revenue mile is equivalent to a loss of
5.7 percent on recognized investment, without allowance for Federal
tax credits.
‘‘From the above tabulation, it appears that C&S under honest, economical,
and efficient management may be expected to earn a rate of return, over an
annual period, of 7.3 percent, with a 60 percent annual revenue passenger load
factor. At the forecast passenger load factor of 60.09 percent, the estimated
rate of return after taxes is 7.4 percent. It should be noted that with an
average annual passenger load factor of 60 percent, the average base mail rate
will amount to 29.8 cents per airplane mile, but the average effective mail
rate will amount to approximately 26 cents per revenue plane mile flown.
‘¢An extra cushion against unforeseen developments will be provided to the
extent that C&S succeeds in developing additional revenues from express,
freight, and incidental sources above the level forecast for the future period.
Similarly, any economies which the carrier’s management succeeds in accom-
plishing through effective cost controls or improved operating procedures and
techniques, which serve to avert or mitigate anticipated increases in prices
and to decrease operating costs below the unit cost of 116.6 cents per revenue
plane mile estimated herein, will inure to the carrier in the form of higher
earnings.’? Chicago and Southern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, 9 C.A.B. 786,
812 (1948).
Si
BLURRED COPY
a"
cluded in the Board’s decision as quoted in footnote 5, the
Board anticipated and intended that C&S’s rate of return
would vary with the load factor it experienced. Further-
more, regardless of the passenger load factor experienced
by C&S, the Board anticipated and intended that any
‘‘economies’’ which the Company’s management effected
would ‘‘inure to the carrier in the form of higher earn-
ings’’, and, accordingly, increase the rate of return.
Thus the Board found air mail rates to be fair and reason-
able for C&S under which the rates of return on the invest-
ment allocated to the domestic division would vary, up or
down, depending upon the passenger load factor and/or
cost level experienced by C&S. The Postmaster General
was a party to the proceeding and did not make any objec-
tion to the rates fixed.
Throughout the years 1948, 1949, and 1950 the mail rates
established by the Board for C&S’s domestic division re-
mained unchallenged by the Postmaster General or by any-
one else. As required of all air carriers, C&S filed quarter-
ly reports with the Board which were available to the pub-
lic and which showed the results of operation under such
rates. Pursuant to Section 406(a) of the Act (infra, Ap-
pendix), the Postmaster General, at any time during this
period, could have filed a petition with the Board seeking a
revision of the rate and the Board would have been required
to hold a hearing and render a decision thereon.
Three years after its final order fixing the rates for C&S’s
domestic operations and in a proceeding separate from that
in which the final rates for domestic operations had been
fixed, the Board determined the final ‘‘need’’ mail rates
for the air transport operations of C&S in its international
division. In its Statement of Tentative Findings and Con-
clusions issued on May 18, 1951 (R. 6-48) and Order to
Show Cause of the same date (R. 49, 50), it proposed to fix
a mail rate for C&S’s international division retroactively
for the period from November 1, 1946 to December 15, 1950,
and a different ‘‘need’’ rate prospectively from December
8
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
9
16, 1950. It is that part of the mail rates set in this pro-
ceeding for the international division during the retroac-
tive period January 1, 1948 through December 15, 1950,
which is now before the Court.
The Postmaster General filed objections to the Board’s
Tentative Findings and Conclusions issued in the inter-
national division rate proceeding. He now claimed that
the earnings which C&S had achieved during the period of
1948 through 1950, which reflected revenues from com-
mercial services and compensation pursuant to the final
mail rates set in 1948 for its domestic division, included
‘‘excoss’’ earnings in the amount of approximately
$654,000; and that this amount was ‘‘other revenue”’ which
under Section 406(b) of the Act, must, as a matter of law,
be applied in reduction of the amount of the ‘‘need’’ of the
air carrier for the same period determined by the Board
to be required for C&S’s international division in the 1951
proceeding. The Postmaster General, overlooking the
fact, as noted in the portion of the Board’s de-
cision in the domestic rate case quoted in footnote 5
above, that the Board had set variable rates of
return on the estimated investment allocated to C&S’s do-
mestie division depending upon the passenger load factor
and/or cost level experienced by C&S, focused entirely up-
on the sentence that ‘‘at the forecast passenger load factor
of 60.09 percent, the estimated rate of return after taxes
is 7.4 percent.’? Claiming that this rate of return had a
special legal significance over and above any of the other
variable rates of return which the Board anticipated and
intended C&S to receive depending upon the passenger
load factor and/or cost level it achieved, the Postmaster
General asserted that the maximum earnings to which C&S
was entitled was this 7.4 percent figure applied to the ac-
tual investment allocated to the domestic division during
___—
5aSee pp. 4-5 of the Answer of Postmaster General to CAB Order to Show
Cause, No. E-5385. By stipulation filed with this Court, citations to the un- k
printed portions of the record below may be included in the briefs.
|
BLURRED COPY
—_—e
10
the years 1948 through 1950. As noted above, the 7.4 per-
cent return was one of many possible rates of return which
the Board anticipated C&S might receive if (a) it achieved
the forecasted 60.09 percent passenger load factor, (b) it
maintained the exact cost level which the Board estimated
it would experience, on the facts then before it, and did not
achieve any of the ‘‘economies’’ which the Board specific-
ally stated might be achieved, with a consequent increase
in earnings, and (c) it maintained the exact level of invest-
ment estimated by the Board, on the facts then before it,
which it had allocated to, and allowed for, the domestic di-
vision. As a matter of fact, as a result of economies ef-
fected and of accounting adjustments (largely in deprecia-
tion accounts, R. 65) the reports of C&S to the Board indi-
cated that C&S had averaged a rate of return throughout
the years 1948, 1949, and 1950 of 12.51% on its actual in-
vestment allocated to the domestic division. It is the vol-
ume of earnings reflecting the difference between an appli-
eation of one of the many rates of return estimated by the
Board in the 1948 domestic rate case as achievable by C&S,
namely 7.4 percent, to actual investment allocated to the
domestic division, and the 12.51% return thereon actually
experienced, amounting to approximately $654,000, which
the Postmaster General now claims as ‘‘excessive’’
and must be applied in reduction against the ‘‘need’’
determined by the Board to be required for C&S’s interna-
tional operations in the proceeding now before this Court.
There were three positions taken regarding this issue in
the following procedural steps before the Board, and subse-
quently before the Court of Appeals.
The Postmaster General continued in his assertion that,
in determining the ‘‘need’’ of C&S in 1951 in the interna-
tional division rate case for the period 1948 through 1950,
the Board must, as a matter of law, look back to the actual
experience of C&S during this same period during which
it was operating under a final mail rate order established in
1948 for the domestic division, and apply in reduction of
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
——,
11
the international ‘‘need’’ what the Postmaster General
claimed as ‘‘excess’’ profits on the domestic division as
computed above.
C&S asserted that, as a matter of law, the Board could
not reduce the international ‘‘need’’ determined by the
Board in the 1951 proceeding by an amount representing
a portion of its earnings on the domestic division, on the
grounds that ‘‘the C&S domestic rate has been finalized
and closed since 1948’’ and ‘‘having remained unchallenged
for the entire duration of their existence, the Board is not
legally empowered to revise such rates retroactively or to
disturb past earnings arising thereunder.’’* The Board’s
staff, represented by Bureau Counsel, also questioned the
Board’s power to make the reduction requested by the
Postmaster General (R. 53).
An alternative position, taken by both C&S and Bureau
Counsel, was that the Board could refuse to reduce the in-
ternational ‘‘need’’ by C&S’s earnings on its domestic di-
vision as a valid exercise of its discretionary authority
granted under Section 406(b) of the Act.
The Board in its opinion accompanying its final order
affirming the action proposed in its Statement of Tentative
Findings and Conclusions, rejected the Postmaster Gen-
eral’s contention that, as a matter of law, it must make the
reduction requested by the Postmaster General. It did not
decide the question of whether, as a matter of law, it could
not make the reduction requested by the Postmaster Gen-
eral, but rather held that it could decline to take such
action ‘‘if there are sound reasons for not doing so as a
matter of economic policy.’’ (R. 53-55)
Following a denial of the Postmaster General’s Petition
for Reconsideration (R. 62), the Postmaster General filed
a Petition for Judicial Review with the court below of the
orders of the Board fixing the mail pay of C&S on its in-
SPD ee a.
6 Answer of C&S to Postmaster General’s Petition for Reconsideration, p. 2,
dated November 26, 1951, filed in the record in this proceeding before the
Board.
BLURRED COPY
12
ternational division (R. 2-6). The court below held, Judge
Prettyman dissenting, that $654,000. derived from the do-
mestic operations constituted ‘‘all other revenue of the air
earrier’’ which the Board must, under Section 400(b) of
the Act, apply in reduction against the ‘‘need’’ of the car-
rier’s international division as determined by the Board.
Judge Prettyman would have affirmed the Board’s decision
on the ground that when Congress gave the Board power
to fix different air mail rates for different classes of sery-
ice, it meant for the Board to make separate calculations
for such different classes and not to take into considera-
tion factors unrelated to the service for which the rate is
being fixed. (R. 75-76) But, he stated, that if that position
should be in error, the soundness of a complete separation
of the foreign from the domestic division persuaded him
that the Board could act as it did. (R. 76)
SPECIFICATION OF ERRORS
The Court of Appeals erred:
(1) In holding that the Civil Aeronautics Board, in fix-
ing air mail rates for the international division of C&S
as a separate class of service and as a separate rate-
making unit from its domestic division, was empowered by
Section 406 of the Civil Aeronautics Act to apply any of
the carrier’s earnings in the domestic division in reduction
of the carrier’s ‘‘need’’ for mail compensation in its inter-
national division;
(2) In holding that as a matter of law the Board is au-
thorized, and required, to effect a recapture of past earn-
ings in the domestic division of C&S, in which mail rates
which had long been closed and with respect to which no
proceeding was pending, by applying such earnings in re-
duction of the carrier’s ‘‘need’’ for mail compensation in
its international division in a subsequent proceeding in
which the only issue was the fixing of mail rates for the
international division separately classified as such for rate-
making purposes;
BLEED THROU GH— POOR COPY
oo
13
(3) In holding that the direction of Section 406 of the
Act to the effect that the Board, in fixing air mail rates
for a particular class of services of an air carrier, shall
take into consideration the ‘‘need’’ of the carrier for cer-
tain developmental purposes, includes a requirement that
the Board go outside such class of service and ascertain
whether there are any other revenues of the air carrier
arising in some other class of service which could possibly
be so applied in reduction of such ‘‘need’’;
(4) In assuming, and in effect holding, that Chicago and
Southern had received excess earnings on its domestic
services ;
(5) In holding, if the Court of Appeals was not in error
in its holding specified in (1) above, that Section 406 of
the Civil Aeronautics Act does not vest discretion in the
Board to determine whether it should apply in reduction
against the carrier’s ‘‘need’’ for air mail compensation
on its international division any portion of other revenues
of the carrier derived from its domestic division in which
a final and unchallenged mail rate had been fixed;
(6) In holding that the Board’s determination was un-
lawful insofar as it gave effect, for reasons of public in-
terest, to rate-making policies of importance to the air
transport industry as a whole in fixing the rates of a single
earrier which is an integral part of that industry; and
(7) In setting aside the order of the Board.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT :
I
The application of the past earnings of the domestic divi-
sion of C&S, reflecting commercial revenue and compensa-
tion under final and unchallenged mail rates, in reduction
of the ‘‘need’’ of C&S for mail compensation of its inter-
national division is not authorized by Section 406(b) of the
Act. While that section, in stating the standard to govern
BLURRED COPY
14
the Board in fixing mail rates, provides that the Board
shall take into consideration, among other factors, the
‘‘need of each such air carrier for compensation for the
transportation of mail sufficient . . . together with all
other revenue of the air carrier’’ to enable the carrier
to meet the statutory objectives, these references to the
‘‘need’’ and revenues of the ‘‘air carrier’’ are qualified
by other language in the Section. This other language
is an express provision that in fixing mail rates, ‘‘the
[Board] ... may fix different rates for ... different classes
of service.’’ This latter authority necessarily embraces,
consistently with well-recognized concepts of public utility
rate-making, the power of the Board to establish separate
territorial units of the carrier for rate-making purposes and
to fix rates for a unit smaller than the carrier’s whole op-
eration. The meaning of the statutory references to
‘‘need’’ and revenues of the ‘‘air carrier’’ must be con-
strued so as to give effect to the Board’s authority to es-
tablish separate rate-making units.
The Board’s action in 1948 in fixing final mail rates for
C&S’s domestic division as a separate rate-making unit
was a lawful and unchallenged exercise of its powers under
Section 406(b); and, therefore, the ‘‘need’’ of C&S which
Section 406(b) directs be taken into consideration by the
Board in the present international division proceeding must
be construed to refer only to the international division of
C&S for which rates are now being fixed.
A contrary construction of Section 406(b) would impute
to Congress an intention to abandon the established princi-
ples of public utility rate-making: (1) that the rate fixing
agency has power to fix rates for territorial units less than
a utility’s entire operations and (2) that final and unchal-
lenged rates cannot be retroactively reviewed or revised.
This Court in Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil
Aeronautics Board, 336 U.S. 601 (1949) has expressly held
that the Board is not authorized to fix mail rates retro-
actively to a period in which a final rate previously fixed
was in effect and unchallenged.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
15
A construction of the Act which would permit the appli-
cation of past earnings of the domestic division of C&S,
reflecting commercial revenues and compensation under
final and unchallenged mail rates, in reduction of its ‘‘need’’
for mail compensation in its international division would be
contrary to the basic objectives expressed in the Act in that
such construction: (1)would create a cost-plus system of
rate-making for those carriers which operate both domestic
and international services, (2) would jeopardize the estab-
lished overall national air policy of the United States with
respect to international air transportation by creating eco-
nomic conditions which might well result in the operation
of United States international air routes by a single car-
rier, a policy heretofore rejected as undesirable to the
national interest, (3) would impair the financial stability
of air carriers by destroying the finality of earnings real-
ized under final mail rates and (4) would hamper the devel-
opment of domestic air services by making it impossible
for air carriers engaged in both domestic and international
services to compete effectively in domestie services with
air carriers engaged exclusively in domestic services.
II
If, contrary to Petitioner’s contentions as summarized
above under I, Section 406(b) is to be construed as requir-
ing the Board to ‘‘take into consideration ... the need...’’
of the carrier as a whole whenever it fixes mail rates, the
Board’s decision in the case before this Court is a valid
exercise of this discretionary authority.
The Board in its decision did not find that the actual
earnings of C&S on its domestic services, reflecting com-
mercial revenues and compensation under the final mail
rates fixed in 1948, were in excess of fair and reasonable
rates for that service or in excess of the carrier’s need for
that service. In its 1948 decision, the Board had fixed a
sliding-seale of mail rates variable according to the actual
load factors (ratio of passenger seats occupied to passenger
BLURRED COPY
16
seats available) which C&S might develop and, as the
Board expressly recognized in that decision, the rates of
return on investment which C&S might realize under thos¢
mail rates could vary from 3.6% at a 55% load factor t«
13.1% at a 70% load factor. The Board also pointed ow
that the benefits of economies and improvements in opera
tions would ‘‘inure to the carrier in the form of highe
earnings’’. The reported earnings of C&S during the pe
riod in question were 12.5% on its investment allocated t
the domestic division. The Board has not determined that
any part of this 12.5% return represents legally exces:
earnings.
In its decision fixing mail rates in the international divi.
sion now before this Court the Board did not ignore the
domestic earnings of C&S. On the contrary, the Board took
note of the fact that C&S had earned on its domestic divi
sion a return of 12.5% on investment. It then considerec
in detail the question whether any portion of those earning:
should be applied in reduction of the ‘‘need’’ which wouk
otherwise be found to exist in relation to the internationa
services. The Board concluded that considerations of pub
lie interest which are set out in detail in the Board’s opin
ions, and which are clearly within the contemplation ot
the objectives of the Act, required that the mail rate:
for the international services should be fixed withow
any reduction in such rates to reflect any part of the
domestic earnings. The court below did not find tha’
the considerations of public interest which the Board re
cites in its decision as controlling its determination of it:
treatment of the domestic earnings were arbitrary or ea.
pricious or outside of the statutery objectives. Clearly
therefore, the Board’s action is an entirely proper and an.
thorized exercise of the broad discretion granted expressly}
to the Board by the Act in the fixing of mail rates necessary
to meet the statutory objectives.
BLEED THROU GH—- POOR COPY
17
ARGUMENT
lL WHEN THE BOARD, UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE ACT,
SEPARATELY CLASSIFIED THE DOMESTIC AND INTERNA-
TIONAL OPERATIONS OF C&S AS SEPARATE RATE-MAKING
UNITS, IT WAS NO LONGER EMPOWERED BY THE ACT.
WHEN FIXING AIR MAIL RATES IN THE INTERNATIONAL
DIVISION IN 1951, TO APPLY IN REDUCTION OF THE
“NEED” OF C&S FOR THE 1948-1950 PERIOD IN ITS INTER-
NATIONAL DIVISION ANY PORTION OF THE EARNINGS
WHICH WERE REALIZED DURING THE SAME PERIOD IN
THE DOMESTIC DIVISION UNDER FINAL AND UNCHAL-
LENGED AIR MAIL RATES FIXED IN 1948 IN A SEPARATE
PROCEEDING FOR THE DOMESTIC DIVISION.
Introduction—It has been the consistent practice of the
Board in all cases of air carriers engaged both in domestic
and in substantial international operations to establish sep-
arate rate-making divisions for these two different classes
of service. The Board has specific power to do this under
the provisions of the first sentence of Section 406(b) which
authorizes it to fix ‘‘different rates for .. . different classes
of service’’. The Board, having thus established such sep-
arate rate-making divisions in such cases has consistently
proceeded to fix rates for each division in a separate pro-
ceeding. This has had the effect of treating the words
‘air carrier’’ in the second sentence of Section 406(b) as
if those words meant the division of the air carrier for
which rates are being fixed.®
The Postmaster General (and the court below) come
forward with a position never urged before and claim that
8 Section 406(a) of the Act (infra, Appendix) empowers and directs the
Board to fix and determine, after notice and hearing, fair and reasonable rates
of compensation for the transportation of mail by aircraft. The first sentence
of Section 406(b) provides that ‘‘In fixing and determining fair and reason-
able rates of compensation .. . the [Board] . .. may fix different rates for...
different classes of service ...’’ (Emphasis supplied.) The second sentence
provides that in determining the rate in each case the Board shall take into con-
sideration, among other factors, the ‘‘need of each such air carrier for compen-
sation for the transportation of mail sufficient to insure the performance of
such service, and, together with all other revenue of the air carrier, to enable
such air carrier under honest, economical, and efficient management, to main-
tain and continue the development of air transportation to the extent and of
the character and quality required for the commerce of the United States,
the Postal Service, and the national defense.’’ (Emphasis supplied.)
BLURRED COPY
ie iw
the words ‘‘air carrier’’ as used in the phrases of the second
sentence of Section 406(b), ‘‘need of each such air carrier”
and ‘‘all other revenue of the air carrier’’, should be con-
strued literally to mean the air carrier as a whole, including
all divisions.
Petitioner submits that complete reliance upon the literal
import of the words ‘‘air carrier’’ as used in the second
sentence of Section 406(b) to establish Congressional intent
in regard to the problem at bar, is in error. As this Court
has declared, if the literal import of words used in a statute
is not consistent with ‘‘the policy of legislation as a whole”
or will lead to ‘‘absurd results’’, they will be modified.®
The controlling guide to Congressional intent under these
circumstances are the canons of statutory construction to
the effect that a part of the statute must be construed with
reference to the leading idea or purpose of the whole act
so as to induce an harmonious whole,”® and that if there is
doubt in one section of the act, another may be used to
expand or restrict its meaning.”
With this in mind, Petitioner develops the following argnu-
ments in the subsections below in support of its Point I
as stated above:
First, Petitioner asserts that Congressional intent in
granting the Board power ‘‘to fix different rates for...
different classes of service’’ in the first sentence of Section
406(b) must be considered in determining the content of
the words ‘‘air carrier’’ in the second sentence of Section
406(b) ;
Second, Petitioner asserts that Congressional intent must
be much more clearly shown than it is in Section 406(b) be-
fore those words can be construed to break with the estab-
lished principles of rate-making existing at the time the
9 United States v. American Trucking Associations, 310 U.8. 534, 543 (1940).
10 In re Public National Bank of New York, 278 U.8. 101 (1928); 2 Suther-
land, Statutory Construction (3rd ed. 1943), p. 336.
11 Keifer & Keifer v. Reconstruction Pinance Corporation, 306 U.S. 381
(1939).
BLEED THROUGH= POOR COPY
19
et was passed, and subsequently thereto, wherein a rate-
1aking body had the power to fix rates on the basis of a
srritorial unit less than company-wide operations, and that
final and unchallenged mail rate could not be retroactive-
y reviewed or revised. Particular reliance in this connec-
on is placed upon the decision of this Court in T’ranscon-
inental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 336
1.8. 601 (1949) where it was decided that the Board did
ot have authority to fix a new mail rate for an air carrier,
etroactive during a period in which a final rate previously
xed by the Board was in effect and unchallenged because,
mong other reasons, Congress did not intend to break
rom established traditions of rate-making ;
Third, Petitioner asserts that the intent of the Act, as
evealed in its expressly stated purposes and as the Act has
een construed by this Court, is in direct contradiction to
he construction of Section 406(b) urged by Post-
naster General and adopted by the court below; and
Fourth, Petitioner asserts that, contrary to the conten-
jon of the Postmaster General that the Board’s prior ad-
ninistration of the Act supports his contention, the Board
1as consistently prescribed that a final and unchallenged
nail rate had integrity and could not be retroactively re-
vised without jeopardizing many of the basic purposes of
the Act, and that this construction of the Act by the agency
trusted with its administration, is entitled to great weight.
A. If, in fixing the air-mail rates in the international division
of C&S, the Board must also determine the “need” of the
carrier as a whole, the express authorization to “fix differ-
ent rates for ... different classes of service” of an air carrier
becomes meaningless, contrary to well recognized principles
of statutory construction.
Petitioner submits that the first sentence of Section
406(b) where the Board is given authority to fix different
air mail rates for ‘different classes of service’’ of an air
carrier has an important bearing upon the meaning of the
second sentence. It submits that the words ‘‘air carrier’’
BLURRED COPY
20
in the second sentence must be construed to mean a division
of an air carrier in a situation where the Board has utilized
its power under the first sentence and has established a
division in which it has set a final rate. This construction
will render the statute an harmonious whole.
This point is immediately evident by focusing upon the
Congressional directive in the second sentence of Section
406(b) that the Board is to ‘‘take into consideration, among
other factors’’, in fixing and determining mail rates the
‘‘need”’ of the air carrier ‘‘for compensation for the trans-
portation of mail sufficient,’’ first, ‘‘to insure’’ the perform-
ance of the mail service, and second, ‘‘together with all
other revenue of the air carrier, to enable’’ it, under ‘‘hon-
est, economical, and efficient management, to maintain and
continue’’ the developmental purposes, including national
defense purposes, of ‘‘air transportation.’’”
If the Postmaster General and the court below are cor-
rect, this determination of ‘‘need’’ must be made in every
ease for the air carrier as a whole."® Under this
12TIn this connection Petitioner submits that the court below misconstrued
the second sentence of Section 406(b) when it said (R. 72) that the ‘‘duty of
the Board in fixing ‘fair and reasonable rates of compensation’ under Section
406(b)’’ is ‘‘in each case to ‘take into consideration, among other factors
. .. all other revenue of the air carrier.’’’ Petitioner submits, however, that
the statute cannot be so read grammatically. The Board is directed to ‘‘take
into consideration’’ the ‘‘need’’ of the carrier with its dual purposes, and
not merely ‘‘all other revenue’’ which is a very different legal concept from
‘“need’’. This misconstruction of Section 406(b) which automatically suggests
‘‘offset’’ to the mind, coupled with a misunderstanding of the Board’s intent
in the domestic mail rate case to set a variable rate of return, rather than a
' specific rate of return from which a ‘‘corpus’’ of ‘‘excess’’ earnings could
be automatically determined, may account in a large degree for the error
of the court below.
13 The determination of ‘‘need’’ is usually a complex process, emerging
after exhaustive consideration of what services performed and to be per-
formed should be underwritten as being required by the commerce, national
defense, or Postal Service of the United States (see, e.g., R. 24; and Braniff
Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 1 C.A.A. 353, 359 (1939)), of which services and
equipment are justified under the economical and efficient management stand-
ard (see, e.g., Pioneer Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rate, C.A.B. Order No, 13-7225,
March 13, 1953, p. 4), of what costs should be allowed or disallowed, of what
investment should be recognized as constituting the rate base, of what profit
element should be allowed, and so on.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
21
emise the determination of ‘‘need’’ by the Board in
48 for C&S’s domestic division alone, upon which
based the carrier’s domestic mail rates (and which
1s not objected to by the Postmaster General), was
error because the ‘‘need”’ there determined was not for
e carrier as a whole. According to them, whatever was
ne in the domestic division proceeding in 1948 was of no
fect because, the Postmaster General and the court below
sist, that when the Board determined ‘‘need’’ for the
ternational division in 1951 for the 1948-1950 period, it
as in error in not determining need for the carrier as a
hole at that time which, of course, would constitute a re-
‘termination of the ‘‘need’’ for the domestic division since
at division is part of the whole.
By such a construction of Section 406(b) the action of
e Board in 1948 in setting final mail rates for C&S’s
ymestic division is given no final effect. At most it can
» considered as setting temporary rates, subject to subse-
ent adjustment in a later rate proceeding.
The result of such a construction is to write off the power
hich Congress granted the Board in the first sentence of
ection 406(b) to fix rates (not limited to fixing ‘‘tempo-
ary’? rates subject to complete revision at subsequent
mes) for different classes of service. The position of the
‘ostmaster General, to which the court below raised no ‘
bjection, that it does not question the Board’s authority
> fix rates separately for different operating divisions of
he air carrier, while, at the same time, insisting that
‘need’? be determined for the carrier as a whole (R. 71)
s simply incomprehensible in its inconsistency because the
tatute cannot be construed in two opposite directions at
nce. 5
The provisions in the first and second sentences of Sec-
ion 406(b) harmonize naturally. As Judge Prettyman in
is dissent below indicated, the concept of different rates
‘or different services has a definite bearing upon ‘‘take
ee os
BLURRED COPY
22
into consideration’”’ in the following sentence (R. 75-76).
He then said,
‘¢. . . When the Board is fixing a particular rate it
should take into consideration factors related to that
rate, and none other. Such is plain sense, a sort of
rule of relevancy.”’
This position would cause the words ‘‘air carrier’’ in the
second sentence to be construed, as Petitioner submits they
must be construed, to mean that when the Board commits
itself to fixing rates for a division (i.e., class of service),
such words mean that division of the air carrier; and that
they mean the international division of C&S under the
facts of this case.™*
Such a construction would prevent rendering meaning-
less the words ‘‘classes of service’’ and would make the en-
tire Section fit together properly.
Before turning to other evidence of Congressional intent
supporting this conclusion, a brief answer should be given
to the argument that authority to set a final mail rate in
one division of an air carrier independent of others impairs
the control of the Board over grants of subsidy contrary to
the intent of Congress. This argument is without substance.
One of the most comprehensive reporting systems in the
field of regulatory agencies has been established for air
carriers by the Board.” The air carriers file exhaustive re-
ports of their traffic and financial experience at frequent
intervals which are open to the public. The Board and its
14 It might be noted also that the words ‘‘air carrier’’ as used in the second
sentence must be construed as having a different meaning than their literal
meaning in another connection to which surely there would be no objection.
If the Board exercises its power under the first sentence of Section 406(b) to
set a rate for a ‘‘class of air carriers’’, then the term ‘‘air carrier’’ as used
in the second sentence must be construed as in the plural, ‘‘air carriers’’, in
order to make sense of the Section. The construction Petitioner advances in
a case where the Board exercises its power to set a rate for a ‘‘class of
services’’, reaches a similar result.
15 See. 407, 49 U.S.C. 487; Civil Aeronautics Board, Economie Regulations,
Part 241, 14 CFR 770.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
23
staff, and the Postmaster General, are at all times informed
by this means as to whether or not it appears that a divi-
sion should have its ‘‘need’’ redetermined.
Thus the Board can, and frequently does, institute a new
rate proceeding under Section 406(a) of the Act on its own
initiative to reduce the existing final mail rate. The Post-
master General, too, has the authority to file a petition re-
questing a reduction in the mail rate and could have taken
this action at any time during the 1948 to 1950 period in
which the final domestic mail rate of C&S was in effect."®
B. Well-established principles of rate-making in existence at
the time the Act was passed confirm a construction of Sec-
tion 406(b) of the Act which authorizes the Board to fix air
mail rates for a territorial unit less than the carrier’s whole
operation and which prevents recapturing earnings under a
closed rate.
In determining the validity or invalidity of the construc-
tion which the Postmaster General and the court below
wish to give to Section 406(b) of the Act, which would de-
stroy the finality of the rate established by the Board for
(&S’s domestic division, attention must be focused upon
the established traditions of rate-making existing at the
time the Act was passed and the question of whether Con-
16 Actually, the Board on October 1, 1951, reopened the domestic division
rates of C&S (CAB Order No. E-5747) and reduced the domestic rates (See
Chicago and Southern Air Lines, Inc., Domestic Operations, Statement of Ten
tative Findings and Conclusions, CAB Order No. E-5869, November 15, 1951;
and CAB Order No. E-5956, December 19, 1951, making rates final).
It should also be noted that the power of the Board to protect the public
interest against excessive subsidy payments exists under any set of circum-
stances including those not present in this proceeding. As illustrations, if a
carrier is on a final ‘‘need’’ rate in one division involving an element of sub-
sidy, and is on a final ‘‘service’’ rate in another division, and it is felt
that the earnings under the service rate are excessive, the Board under the
power of Section 406(a) can reclassify both divisions into a company-wide
rate, which would have the affect of reducing subsidy through a lower average
rate, or the Board could consider benefitting the public by reducing the passen-
ger and property rates on the domestic division which would have the affect
of reducing earnings.
BLURRED COPY
z.
gress intended in the Civil Aeronautics Act to make a radi-
cal break with such traditions.
In the only other proceeding to come before this Court
involving the mail rate provisions of the Civil Aeronautics
Act, this Court gave a meaning to statutory language in
dispute contrar) to its literal import upon the ground,
among others, that to construe the language literally would
be to ascribe a Congressional intention ‘‘to break with these
traditions of rate-making.’’ ”
The authorization in the first sentence of Section 406(b)
which provides that the Board ‘‘may fix different rates for
... different classes of service’’ of an air carrier is Con-
gressional reflection of the universally accepted tradition
in rate-making, in existence prior to the passage of the
Civil Aeronautics Act as well as subsequently thereto,
whereby public utility regulatory agencies are vested with
the authority to fix rates on a territorial unit embracing
less than company-wide operations. Often a rate on less
than company-wide unit has been required on the basis of
the governing statute, '* but more frequently the determina-
24
17 In Transcontinental g¢ Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 336
U.S. 601 (1949) this Court was called upon to construe the language in Section
406(a) of the Act (infra, Appendix) which empowers the Board to fix and
determine the fair and reasonable rate of compensation for the transportation
of mail by aircraft and ‘‘to make such rates effective from such date as it
shall determine to be proper ...’’ The Court held that a rate could not be
made effective prior to the commencement of the rate-making proceeding even
though the literal reading of the general phrase ‘‘make such rates effective
from such date as .... [the Board] shall determine to be proper’’ would not
appear to so limit the Board. After noting that the ‘‘language of Section
406(a) ... reads like a typical public utility rate-making authority .. .’’,
the Court stated that ‘‘the rates of carriers and other utilities fixed by public
authorities, while usually prospective, are sometimes made retroactive to the
date of the commencement of the rate-making proceeding . . .’’ but ‘‘so far
as we are aware, they have never been made retroactive to an earlier date.’’
The Court concluded that ‘‘the language of the Act does not suggest that
Congress intended to break with these traditions of rate-making.’’ 336 U.S.
601, 604, 605.
18 Wabash Valley Electric Co. v. Singleton et al., 1 F. Supp. 106 (D.C. 8.D.
Ind. 1932), aff’d. sub nom Wabash Valley Electric Co. v. Young, 287 US.
488 (1933).
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
_—
25
tion of the proper unit for rate-making has either been spe-
cifically committed to administrative discretion by statute,’
or, in the absence of such express statutory authoriza-
tion considered a matter for administrative discretion. *°
A broad expression of those principles was given by this
Court in the Wabash Case:
‘‘Normally, the unit for rate making purposes, we may
assume, would be the entire interconnected operating
property of a utility used and useful for the conven-
ience of the public in the territory served, without re-
gard to particular groups of consumers or local sub-
divisions. But conditions may be such as to require or
permit the fixing of a smaller unit ...’’
Such was the rate-making tradition at the time the Civil
Aeronautics Act was adopted which is reflected in the pro-
visions of Section 406(b) of the Act authorizing the Board
‘“‘to fix different rates for ... different classes of service
9
es
(1925) ; Wis. Stat. (1929), Section 196.03 (2) which provides that ‘‘ For rate-
making purposes the Commission may consider two or more municipalities as
a regional unit where the same public utility serves said municipalities, if in 4
its opinion the public interest so requres.’’ See Baird, Should the Rate
Making Unit be Fixed by Statute, 1 U. Chi. L. Rev. 451 (1934).
3
19In Re Northwestern Bell Telephone Co., 164 Minn. 279, 204 N. W. 873
20In American Toll Bridge Co. v. Railroad Commission of California, 307
U.S. 486 (1939) the commission refused to include in a proceeding to fix
| rates for a certain toll bridge an investigation of the tolls of another bridge
| owned by the same company. The company protested. The Court held at j
p. 494 that:
‘‘In the first instance, at least, determination of the proper unit for
rate making was for the commission. The Antioch bridge is not used or
useful to render any service covered by the Oarquinez tolls; appellant’s
duty to operate either bridge is independent of its obligation to operate
the other. The record discloses no basis on which it reasonably may be
held that by limiting the investigation to the Carquinez tolls the com-
mission abused its discretion, ...’’
Cf. Gilchrist v. Interborough Rapid Transit Co., 279 U.S. 159, 211 (1929);
Florida Power & Light Co. v. City of Miami, 98 F. 2d 180, 184 (C.C.A. 5th
1938) ; International Ry. Co. v. Prendergast, 1 F. Supp. 623, 626 (D.C. W.D.
N.Y. 1932).
21 Wabash Valley Electric Co. v. Young, 287 U.S. 488, 497 (1933).
BLURRED COPY
26
Contemporaneous with the rate-making tradition just
discussed wherein a rate-making body may set a rate based
upon a unit less than company-wide operations, is the tradi-
tion that a rate looks to the future and, as such, when final
and unchallenged, is not subject to revision with respect to
completed transactions. This principle is established by
numerous decisions of this Court. *
That this fundamental tenet of public utility rate-making
was carried over into the Civil Aeronautics Act has been
specifically held by this Court in Transcontinental & West-
ern Air, Inc. vy. Civil Aeronautics Board, 336 U.S. 601
(1949). There it was decided that the Board did not have
authority to fix a new mail rate for an air carrier, retro-
active during a period in which a final rate previously fixed
by the Board was in effect and unchallenged by the initia-
tion of a rate proceeding. At 336 U.S. 601, 607 the Court
said:
‘«. . a construction which would make it possible
to revise rates retroactively to any point of time would
22 Arizona Grocery Co. v. Atchison, Topeka §& Santa Fe Ry., 284 U.S. 370
(1932); Georgia Railway and Power Co. v. Railroad Commission, 262 U.S. 625
(1923); Board of Public Utility Commissioners v. New York Telephone Co.,
271 U.S. 23 (1926); United States v. New York Central R. Co., 279 U.S. 73
(1929). It might also be noted that at the time the Civil Aeronautics Act was
passed Congress had before it, in the ‘‘recapture provisions’’ of the Transpor-
tation Act of 1920, 41 Stat. 456, 489-91 (1920) adding Sec. 15A, pars. (5)
through (18) to Part I of the Interstate Commerce Act, a specific scheme for
recapturing excessive earnings which could have been, but was not, incor-
porated into the Civil Aeronautics Act. Under the ‘‘ recapture provisions’’ of
the Transportation Act individual railroads which earned more than a fair
return under uniform rates set for all railroads or groups of railroads were to
hold any amount in excess of such fair return as trustee for the United States
and this sum was distributed one-half to a reserve fund to be maintained by
the carrier and one-half to a general railroad revolving fund to be maintained
by the Interstate Commerce Commission. These provisions were repealed by
the 1933 amendment to Sec. 15a, 48 Stat. 220 (1933), 49 U.S.C.A. Sec. lia
(Supp. 1953), upon the recommendation of the Commission. Among the reasons
given by the Commission for repeal of the provisions was the fact that they
encouraged ‘‘extravagant expenditures by the more prosperous companies
when times are good’’ and that they hung ‘‘like a cloud over the credit of
many companies when times are bad.’’ Fifteen Per Cent Case, 178 I.C.C. 539,
581 (1931).
BLEED THROU GH— POOR COPY
27
be a real innovation which should have a more solid
basis than our predelictions. We cannot but feel that
if the rate-making power were to be put to such a novel
use, the purpose would have been made clear. It is too
unprecedented a departure from the conventions of
rate-making to rest on mere inference.’’ (Emphasis
supplied)
Summarizing, therefore, Petitioner submits the follow-
ing: (1) The Postmaster General has admitted that the
Board has the authority ‘‘to fix different rates for
different classes of service’? (R. 72). This authority is
confirmatory of a long recognized principle of rate-making
in existence at the time the Act was passed that rate-
making bodies may fix rates on a territorial unit less than
company-wide operations; (2) this Court has declared, on
many occasions, both before and after the passage of the
Act, that an unchallenged final rate has integrity and can-
not be retroactively revised; and (3) these two firmly
established tenets of public utility law were in existence at
the time the Act was passed, and Congress was un-
doubtedly aware of them. Accordingly, in the absence of
any specifically expressed intent to chart a new course,
entirely contradictory to this tradition, it must be assumed
that Congress did not intend that the Board would have
power to recoup now what the Postmaster General asserts
were ‘‘excess’’ earnings under a final and unchallenged
mail rate for C&S’s domestic division.”
23It cannot be argued that the integrity of a rate is somehow diminished
because the unit upon which it is based comprises a territorial unit that is
something less than company-wide. Such a rule would render completely
meaningless the power to fix rates on the basis of smaller units which has
been specifically recognized by this Court as part of the rate-making tradi-
tion. (See Wabash and American Toll Bridge Co. cases cited in footnotes
18 and 20, above.) Thus, assume that an electric company serves 20 com-
munities and in the course of time final rates are set on a municipal basis
for each of these communities. Unless each of these final rates has integrity,
it would mean that every time the citizens of one community sought a de-
crease in their particular rate, or the company sought an increase, revision
of each of the other rates could be brought into question. Such action would,
BLURRED COPY
28
C. A CONSTRUCTION OF SECTION 406(b) OF THE ACT WHICH
WOULD REQUIRE THE BOARD, IN FIXING MAIL RATES
IN A PROPERLY CLASSIFIED INTERNATIONAL RATE.
MAKING DIVISION, TO DETERMINE “NEED” FOR THE
CARRIER DURING A PAST PERIOD IN ITS DOMESTIC
DIVISION (WHERE RATES HAD BEEN FINAL AND UN.
CHALLENGED) AND, THEREUPON, TO CONSIDER RE.
DUCING OR INCREASING THE “NEED” OF THE INTER.
NATIONAL DIVISION FOR THAT PERIOD, IS CONTRARY
TO THE INTENT OF THE ACT AS REVEALED IN THE
EXPRESSLY STATED PURPOSES OF THE ACT AND As
CONSTRUED BY THIS COURT.
1. The finality of previously established final rates would be
destroyed and a cost-plus basis of rate-making would result.
If the system-wide ‘‘need’’ of an air carrier must be
determined as a part of the rate-making process each time
a rate-making division proceeding is before the Board, it
means that where mail rates are being fixed for a period in
the past, any other division which was supposedly on a final
rate will have to have its ‘‘need’’ redetermined (whether
a net profit or a net loss results) and reflected in the
system-wide ‘‘need’’ of the carrier. Such supposedly final
rate will not in fact have been final. Not until the last
division rate of a carrier is closed will any rate in reality
be final. This clearly is a cost-plus system of rate-
making.** In the experience of the Board the international
of course, constitute a revision of the entire rate schedule which would make
the power to set individual final rates in the first place meaningless. ‘‘It is
not the law that the commission may not act upon one rate, or the schedule
at one exchange, without at the same time acting upon all or any other rates
within the state.’’ Logan City v. Public Utilities Com., 77 Utah 442,
449, 296 Pac. 1006, 1009 (1931). See also, In Re Northwestern Bell Telephone
Co., 164 Minn. 279, 204 N. W. 873 (1925), where the court held the Commission
could change the rate in one municipality, without readjusting all rates of the
company within the state.
24The Board has stated its view of the cost-plus system in Pennsylvania
Central Airlines Corp., Motions, 8 C.A.B. 685, 697 (1947), aff’d. sub nom
Transcontinental and Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 336 US.
601 (1949), as follows:
‘“Contrariwise the suggestion of the parties to this case is that we
assume the responsibility of making up losses incurred over a period of
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
29
division rate cases are more difficult and require much more
extended periods of time before decision than in the case
of domestic divisions (R. 20). If, therefore, every time
an international division rate for a past period is being
fixed the system-wide ‘‘need’’ of the carrier for the same
period must be determined, the advantage in many cases of
final domestic rates at an early date disappears and the
whole system goes on a cost-plus basis for that period.”
time during which management either did not believe the rate to be an un-
reasonable one or, if it held such a position, did not see fit to inform
us of that fact. On its face the suggestion asks us substantially to put
all so-called efficient managements on a cost-plus basis. This would ob-
viously be a reversal of past policies of rate fixing for it would have a
natural corollary—the corollary that was freely admitted in this case—
that earnings of air carriers in excess of a fair and reasonable rate
would be subject to recapture. Such a policy would tend to sap man-
agement of those very incentives that in a private economy are essential
if we would strive for efficiency.’’
25The Board has emphasized this cost-plus point again recently in Delta
Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Latin American Operations, C.A.B. Order No.
E-7738, Statement of Provisional Findings and Conclusions, adopted Septem-
ber 21, 1953, at p. 14, as follows:
‘«. . . Mail rate proceedings are lengthy and complex. Fixing rates in
separate proceedings for the two divisions as separate units gives the car-
rier the incentive to maximum efficiency in at least one division until the
rate for the other division is reached and closed. And, since the Board may
at any time reopen the rate for either division, there is little danger of
excess subsidy mail pay. On the contrary, to adopt a policy which would,
in effect, preclude a final rate status for separate divisions of carriers
such as Delta, would, by remitting the carrier to a cost-plus basis until
all divisions were closed, inevitably result in fixing cost-plus rates for
substantial periods of time. This would be unsound as a matter of policy
since subsidy support would be likely to increase due to the lack of a full
incentive.26
‘¢26 See also Transcontinental and Western Air, Inc. Vv. C.A.B., 336 US.
601 (1949) ’’.
Even though rates are being determined for a rate-making division pri-
marily for the future, there is always a substantial period of time between
the originating date of the proceeding and the final rate-fixing order. If the
system-wide determination of ‘‘need’’ were required, cost-plus methods of
rate fixing would have to be adopted to some appreciable extent and the
incentive to do well on closed rates would be impaired.
BLURRED COPY
30
Furthermore, if, as a matter of law, the application of all
domestic earnings over some minimum rate of return is (as
the court below held) required in reduction of the ‘‘need”’
of the international division, it would be a breach of the
Board’s duty to fail to reopen any final international divi-
sion rate as frequently and as often as it appeared that such
domestic earnings might become available. In other words,
the rewards for financial progress domestically would
have to be snatched away so promptly to further finance
the international division as to make the effort to improve
in the domestic division of questionable value. In addition,
almost perpetual rate-making periods could well result.
All approaches under the decision of the majority below
lead in the direction of the cost-plus system. The incentive
to do well on final rates, a condition which is in the public
interest (R. 21), particularly in the domestic division, would
be impaired if not destroyed. This Court has stated that
the cost-plus system of regulation ‘‘would not harmonize
with the apparent design of the Act.’’ (Transcontinental
and Western Air, Inc., v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 336 US.
601, 606 (1949)). This is a compelling reason to construe
Section 406(b) so as to give a rate-making division of a
carrier the integrity and independence which will permit
rate-making with finality therein at the earliest possible
time.
2. The profits of the stronger domestic services of carriers op-
erating both domestic and international services would be
applied to financing the international air services and this
would jeopardize the national air policy of the United
States and defeat a basic intent of Congress.
a. THE HISTORY OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF OUR NATIONAL
AIR POLICY, AND THE REJECTION OF THE ‘‘CHOSEN
INSTRUMENT’? AS RELATED TO THE OBJECTIVES
OF THE ACT.
As shown by the Declaration of Policy in Section 2 of
the Act,?° among the chief aims of the Congress was the
26 Infra, Appendix.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
31
development of an air transportation system ‘‘properly
adapted to the present and future needs of the foreign and
domestic commerce of the United States, of the Postal
Service, and of the national defense’’; the regulation of
air transportation in such manner as. to foster sound
economic conditions therein; and the use of competition to
the extent necessary to assure the sound development of
such a system.
Domestically, full control over the expansion and
development of the air transportation system was given to
the Board.2” But internationally there was a different dis-
tribution of power. The President was given control of
the route structure; but the function of supplying
financial support when and as necessary was vested in both
fields with the Board in Section 406 of the Act.
With respect to one paramount issue the President had
the unanimous recommendation of all agencies directly in-
terested in our air transportation system. That related to
the question of whether the United States should adopt the
so-called ‘‘chosen instrument’’ policy of having only one
United States air carrier operating in the field of inter-
national operations. Prior to World War II a single
United States air carrier system, Pan American World
Airways (Pan American)” operated this country’s entire
system of international air services (other than trans-
27 Control over routes comes from Section 401 of the Act, 52 Stat. 987, 49
U.S.C. 481; and control over financial support comes from Section 406 of the
Act, infra, Appendix.
28 Sections 401 of the Act, 52 Stat. 987, 49 U.S.C. 481 and Section 801 of
the Act, 52 Stat. 1014, 49 U.S.C. 601, as construed by this Court in Chicago and
Southern Air Lines, Inc. v. Waterman Steamship Corp., 333 U.S. 103 (1948).
The Board carries out the President’s decision by issuing the appropriate order
carrying that decision into effect. In the exercise of the international route
expansion and development function the President has, with the advice of the
Board and broadly speaking, in accordance therewith, built for the nation a
large and expanding route system of international operations. (See infra,
n. 32).
29 This system is regarded as including Pan American-Grace Airways, Inc.,
(Panagra), 50% of the stock of which is owned by Pan American.
BLURRED COPY
border operations into Canada). During that War, con-
tracts made by the military establishment with United
States air carriers resulted in extensive world-wide opera-
tions by some who had theretofore operated exclusively in
domestic service. As the War closed, questions of national
air policy stood for attention and resolution. Should the
‘‘chosen instrument’’ policy be adopted? If not, what other
operators should be placed in the field? Considerations of
national defense, foreign relations, foreign and domestic
commerce, the Postal Service, and of other matters were
involved.
As a result of exhaustive high level consideration given
to the matter, the ‘‘chosen instrument’’ policy was rejected.
The Board recently summarized the situation with respect
to our national air policy and the resulting participation
by domestic carriers in the international field, as follows ;*°
32
‘*This policy reflects economic realities if the various
carriers operating both domestie and _ international
services are to be expected to continue to operate their
international services. It may be noted here that it
is not through happenstance that, with the exception
of Pan American and Panagra, all United States in-
ternational air transportation service is rendered by
carriers which also operate domestic divisions. Rather,
this is the result of a long and arduous policy devel-
opment yarticipated in by all branches of the Govern-
ment. Having adopted the policy that the objectives
of the Act, the national interest, and the public con-
venience and necessity would best be served by a system
of regulated competition in international air transpor-
tation”? in contrast to the socalled ‘chosen instrument’,
similar considerations have moved the Government to
adopt the policy of certificating domestic carriers to
perform international services. Thus, in the North At-
lantic Route case* the Board emphasized the experience
of the domestic operators, their existing organizations
30 Delta Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Latin American Operations, CAB Order
No. E-7738, Statement of Provisional Findings and Conclusions, September
21, 1953, at pp. 10-11.
BLEED THROU GH— POOR COPY
Se eee Me ear
33
of trained personnel, and their ability to promote and
develop the international service through their domes-
tic systems, in deciding that the public convenience and
necessity would best be served by certificating domestic
carriers to operate transatlantic routes. This policy i
was approved by the President and was implemented
in later route cases in which Braniff and C&S were
certificated to Latin America, and Northwest across
the Pacific. And, as indicated above, the international
services of these carriers have been regarded as sep-
arate rate-making units for which separate final mail
rates have been established. ’’ :
‘«22 American Export Airlines, Transatlantic Service, 2 C.A.B. 16
1940).’’ :
‘«23 Northeast Airlines, et al., North Atlantic Route Case, 6 C.A.B. 319 t
(1945).’’ ¢
Substantial international air services have been assigned
to these air carriers who are also engaged in domestic air
transportation.” The ‘‘chosen instrument”’ policy, though
thus rejected, survived as an issue and has received exten-
sive consideration, but without success in the Congress. No
bill to establish the ‘‘chosen instrument’’, of which there
were several which were pressed vigorously, has ever passed
the Congress; and thus, though repeatedly offered the op-
portunity, Congress has not changed the carefully devel-
oped national air policy referred to above under which our
post-war international air transportation system has been
developed.*”
ADO Ree
PONG ITN at
31 TWA has 30,119 internation] route miles authorized, Braniff has 7,870
such miles, Northwest has 14,984, and Delta has 3,270. Pan American’s
total authorized mileage is 155,858 (Civil Aeronautics Board, Official Air-
line Route and Mileage Manual, Part II-International and Overseas Section).
SAFES OP ARE ME Se PENS MS PEE,
ACEO REN
32 See, e.g., Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Aviation of the Com-
mittee on Commerce, United States Senate, 79th Congress, 1st Session, on S.
326; Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce,
House of Representatives, 80th Congress, Ist Session, on Bills Relative to
Overseas Air Transportation; Hearings Before a Subcommittee of the Com-
ATE eT Me
| ES
BLURRED COPY
Na ROE MUERTE iPOD FTE AI By Te ae ae ate . ene i
34
The national air policy, loaded with considerations of
national interest affecting our world-wide relationships,
has thus been implemented. The achievement of one of the
principal objectives of the Act—i.e., to develop an air trans-
portation system adequate to meet the national needs—
has been accomplished in the foreign field by the Presi-
dent (with the advice of the Board and, on the ‘‘chosen
instrument’’ issue, with the advice of all departments and
agencies interested in the national air transportation sys-
tem). The decision of the majority of the court below jeo-
pardizes that achievement; and if permitted to stand,
threatens to reverse the unanimous decision on the ‘‘chosen
instrument’’ issue.
b. THE DECISION OF THE COURT WILL JEOPARDIZE
THE NATIONAL AIR POLICY.
As the Board has put it, in speaking of carriers engaged
in both domestic and international operations, (1) the do-
mestic segment is the more ‘‘robust’’, and the international
segment is the ‘‘economically weaker’’, part of the air
transport industry (R. 54); and (2) ‘‘... the percentage of
subsidy to total mail payments is substantially greater
for the international air carriers as a group than for the
domestic air carriers.’** The Board has commented re-
mittee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce, United States Senate, 80th Con-
gress, 1st Session, on S. 987.
The volume of services has grown. In the fiseal year ending June 30, 1940,
a pre-War year, Pan American, then alone in this new international field
carried 175,000 persons, 98,300,000 passenger miles (CAB Annual Report,
1940, p. 43). In the 12 months ending December 31, 1952, United States air
carriers in their international and overseas services carried 2,877,000 passengers,
2,087,000,000 passenger miles. Of this amount, Pan American alone carried
1,412,000 persons, 1,779,000,000 passenger miles (C.A.B. Recurrent Report of
Mileage and Traffic Data).
33 Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation of Subsidy from
Total Mail Payrients to United States International, Overseas, and Terri-
torial Air Carriers, June 1952, p. 3. Thus for the current fiseal year ending
June 30, 1954, the Board estimates that TWA, Braniff, Northwest, and Delta,
will receive in their domestic operations $9,974,000. of service mail pay and
$500,000. of subsidy (constituting 4.7% of the total), whereas with respect
BLEED THROU GH-— POOR COPY
a oN STA | ae
a
4
35 |
cently concerning the effect of offsetting domestic earn-
ings against international ‘‘need’’ as follows:
‘*It is against the background of this carefully and
deliberately developed policy of long standing that the
impact of the offset proposal must be weighed. So |
viewed, we believe that to follow a policy of offset can
only invite serious consequences far outweighing any
short term advantages the proposal may appear to
have. Indeed, while it may be true that application of
the offset proposal in this proceeding may reduce the
immediate subsidy bill to the Government, in the long
run increased subsidies are likely to result rather than
savings. In the first place, Delta, as well as the other
carriers similarly situated, may well be induced to with-
draw from international operations. At present, no
U. S. international carrier is able to operate without
subsidy** and this condition may prevail during the
forseeable future. In contrast, the domestic services
of many of the carriers operating internationally have f
reached the point where they require no subsidy. In- }
3
Athttwne
SEES. OME OULU De 2 SE A
cluded in this category is Delta, here involved, which
is in a position to produce adequate earnings on its
domestie division, without Government subsidy. Faced ‘
with a poliey which would drain such earnings from :
its domestic division, which it has developed to a stage é
of self-sufficiency, it is not unlikely that Delta as well “
as other carriers would be reluctant to continue inter- :
national service. :
‘‘Delta’s domestic competitors who do not operate
iniernational services are in a position to utilize domes-
tic earnings to improve their service, add new equip-
ment, and engage in promotional activities, while with
an offset policy Delta’s earnings would be utilized to
support its international service. Its domestie com-
petitive position, under such circumstances would cer-
PPE EE HOR NS
sel he
to the international operations of these air carriers they will receive $5,629,-
000. ef service mail pay and $12,727,000. of subsidy (constituting 69% of
the total) Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation of Subsidy from
Total Mail Payments to United States Air Carriers, September, 1953 Re- 3
vision, Appendix 4 and 9. For Pan American’s international operations the
estimate for the same year is $10,995,000. of service mail pay and $28,667,-
000. of subsidy (constituting 72% of the total) (Ibid, Appendix 9).
OG SIME SINS TD Na
BLURRED COPY
WEA MEA LIE LP AAA IDA TIE NOL ELE tie APS ee ee
— oa aa
36
tainly deteriorate with the result that the carrier would
either seek to withdraw from international operations
or would reach a state where its domestic service would
again require subsidy.
‘‘Nor would carriers in a position to effect mergers
which would otherwise decrease the subsidy bill be
expected to press for such consolidations. A graphic
example is Western Airlines, a domestic carrier oper-
ating under a subsidy free mail rate, which has indi-
cated that it is no longer interested in a_ possible
merger with Pacific Northern Airlines, a Territorial
carrier having an estimated annual subsidy need for its
States Alaska service of $777,000, if an offset principle
is to be applied.
‘Assuming that Delta should follow the course we
have indicated foll: adoption of an offset princi-
ple, and be permitt::’ | abandon its international serv-
ice, a replacement would have to be found either in the
form of a new earrier or an existing carrier operating
in the same area. The first alternative would tend to
increase the subsidv bill since the savings inherent in
a single established organization operating two divi-
sions would not be present. Parenthetically, it may be
pointed out that no question of offsetting domestic
earnings could arise in these circumstances. Likewise,
the experience and know-how of an established carrier
would be lacking. On the other hand, to replace the
service with an existing carrier would inevitably tend
to limit all American flag service to one carrier in con-
flict with the policy of competition which has been so
laboriously evolved. Clearly the reversal of so well-
established a policy should not he done indirectly
through a mail rate proceeding not subject to Presiden-
tial review and approval.’’ **
‘624 Except ‘‘stub-end’’ services such as those operated by American
and National which are not truly international services as we are die-
cussing them here.
‘£25 The subsidy bill to the Government for the domestic services of
C&S is estimated to have been reduced by $539,000 annually as a re-
sult of the Delta/C&S merger.’’
———-
34 Delta Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Latin American Operations, Statement
of Tentative Findings and Conclusions, C.A.B. Order No. E-7738, September
21, 1953 at pp. 11-13.
BLEED THROU GH— POOR COPY
37
Thus, Petitioner submits that the Act should be con-
strued by this Court so that where the Board has estab-
lished the domestic and international operations as sep-
arate rate-making divisions, domestic earnings will not be
siphoned into the international division, and thereby avoid
jeopardizing the continued operation of our national air
policy which has been established and implemented with
Presidential approval in order to achieve one of the major
objectives of the Act.3*
3. The financial stability of air carriers, one of the principal
objectives of the Act, would be impaired by unduly delay-
ing the finality of earnings.
The Declaration of Policy of the Act® states that the
Board should regulate in such manner as to ‘‘foster sound
economic conditions’’ in air transportation; and that com-
petition is to be invoked to the extent necessary to assure
the sound development of the air transportation system.
Section 406 of the Act should he construed to speed, not
retard, the realization and continued maintenance of this
objective. The legislative history of the Act makes it clear
34a International air services must be performed willingly and aggressively
if the objectives of the Act are to be realized. One of the standards which
the Board must find that the applicant for a route meets is that it should be
‘‘willing’’. Section 401(d) of the Act, 52 Stat. 987, 49 U.S.C. 481(d)(1).
If, as the Board points out in the statement of its views quoted immediately
above, a carrier engaged in both domestic and substantial international opera-
tions is handicapped in its efforts to compete domestically with carriers
engaged exclusively in domestic service by a principle requiring the domestic
to support the more costly international service, it certainly will cease to be
‘‘willing’’ in the aggressive development and expansion of the volume of its
international operations. The action of the President in deciding that the
earrier should perform a service for the nation in international service will
be undermined. In this connection, it should be noted that the Act, in recog-
nition of the special circumstances under which foreign air transportation
is conducted, omitted that class of service in providing that ‘‘It shall be the
duty of each air carrier to provide . . . adequate service ...’’ Section 404(a)
of the Act, 52 Stat. 993, 49 U.S.C. 484(a).
35 Infra, Appendix.
BLURRED COPY
2 ee aie ns.
VkO OF) wag
38
that one of the chief aims in its enactment was to provide
financial stability in the air transportation industry.*™
One phase of this prime objective of the Act is the de-
velopment of the air transport industry to a point where
it will be financially self-sufficient, i.e., free from dependence
upon subsidy (R. 19). It seems apparent without argu-
ment that becoming free from dependence upon subsidy is
one of the greatest of all forward steps toward ‘‘sound
economic conditions’’. For the fiseal years ending June
30, 1954, and June 30, 1955, the Board estimates that all
of the ten major trunk air carriers (with one exception to
a comparatively minor extent) will be conducting domestic
operations on a basis entirely free from subsidy.** These
carriers are American, Eastern, TWA, and United, con-
stituting Group I on a 45 cents per ton mile service mail
rate, (this being a common rate for this class of carriers)
and Braniff, Capital, Delta, National, Northwest, and West-
ern, constituting Group II on a 53 cents per ton mile serv-
35a‘‘The result of this chaotic situation cf the air carriers has been to
shake the faith of the investing public in their financial stability and to
prevent the flow of funds into the industry. Col. Edgar S. Gorrell, president
of the Air Transport Association, representing substantially all of the
scheduled American-flag air lines, testified before your committee during
the public hearing on H.R. 9738 that $126,000,000 of private capital has
been invested in the present air-transport system and that 50 percent of this
investment has been lost ...’’ H.R. Rep. No. 2254, p. 2, 75th Cong. 3d
Sess. (1930) on H.R. 9738 which was substantially similar to 8. 3845 which
became the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938. Congressman Lea, who managed the
Civil Aeronautics Act on the floor of the House also stated: ‘‘We want to
give financial stability to these companies so they can finance their operations
and finance them to advantage.’’ 83 Cong. Rec. 8500, 75th Cong., 3rd Sess.,
May 7, 1938.
36 Civil Aeronautics Board, Administrative Separation of Subsidy from
Total Mail Payments to United States Air Carriers, September, 1953 Re-
vision, Appendix 4 and Appendix 5. The one exception is Braniff, whic: has
certain less remunerative local service operations included; but action has
now been proposed by the Board which would eliminate all subsidy domestic-
ally from the mail rate to be fixed for Braniff’s domestic operations for the
current period. Braniff Final Mail Rate Case, C.A.B. Order No. E-7815, Ten-
tative Decision, October 13, 1953. The Postmaster General has filed Exceptions
and a Brief in support thereof.
BLEED THROUGH-— POOR COPY
. . —— —— LADD E DI ESN TREO pr > eee
Bie -
39
ice mail rate (this being a common rate for this class).**
Thus TWA, Braniff, Northwest, and Delta, the four domes-
tic air carriers who are engaged in substantial international
services, have domestically (in which they perform the
much larger portion of their business) achieved this en-
viable goal of self-sufficiency.**
The ernstruction of the statute contended for by the
Postmaster General would, as shown in earlier portions of
this brief, make any domestic division rates of Braniff,
Delta, Northwest, and TWA, essentially and substantively
temporary in nature until the final rates are fixed in the
international division, in some eases years later;** for if
system-wide ‘‘need’’ must be determined whenever final
rates are fixed, as the court below held, then the results of
operating under a domestic division rate are tentative un-
til the loss suffered or the profit realized therein is reflected
in the subsidy granted or withheld in the final international
division rate. Thus, the stability implied from the Board’s
above-mentioned subsidy free classification of these four
carriers, 83% of whose business is domestic, loses much,
if not all, of its meaning; the stability dependent upon the
apparent self-sufficient status of domestie operations
achieved by Braniff, Delta, Northwest and TWA becomes
illusory; and no confidence could be placed thereon. Great
confusion as to where the carrier stands financially would
result. It will not be fostering ‘‘sound economic condi-
tions’’ if the Board is forced to follow this course.*®*
387 Tbid. As to Braniff, note the exception mentioned in the next preceding
footnote.
38In 1952, 83% of the volume of the principal air service performed by
these four Companies occurred in their domestic divisions. C.A.B. Recurrent
Te ee ee
Report of Mileage and Traffic Data. i
39 Thus, e.g., TWA commenced international operations on February 5,
1946. Final mail rates in its international division for the intervening period if
have not yet been fixed.
39a ‘*, . . If the Board could redetermine rates for a past period when the
earrier has made less than an adequate profit, or no profit at all, it could do so
when the carrier has made more than an adequate profit. The statute makes
no differentiation. The financial confusien which would follow from the lat-
BLURRED COPY
40
The importance which the Board has attributed to sound
economic conditions has been so great as to have caused
it to refrain from the recapture of earnings realized dur-
ing the pendency of a mail rate proceeding, even though ad-
mittedly excessive earnings were realized during the pe-
riod;*° and in this connection the Board has stressed the
adverse effects of such a policy of recapture on managerial
incentive to accomplish increased economies in operation,
the question mark which it would write upon all of the air
earrier’s financial statements, and the consequent impair-
ment of its ability to raise capital.”
ter conclusion seems obvious. No rate order would be final. No dividend
declaration would be secure. No large commitment would be conclusively
feasible. No offering of securities would have a firm foundation. We find
no indication that Congress meant to create so great uncertainty.’’ Trans-
continental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 169 F. 2d 893
896 (D. C. Cir. 1948) aff’d, 336 U. 8. 601 (1949).
,
40 The Board has held that it has the power to reduce mail rates back to
the date of the institution of the rate proceeding. American Airlines, Inc.—
Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C.A.B. 323, 325-333 (1942). However, the Board has
repeatedly refused to recapture earnings realized between the time of the
institution of the rate proceeding and the date of decision. Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc.—Mail Rates 3 C.A.B. 550, 565 (1942); Eastern Air Lines,
Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C.A.B. 733, 742-743 (1942); American Airlines
Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C.A.B. 770, 776 (1942).
41In the Pan American-Grace Airways, Inc., Mail Rate Case, cited in the
footnote above, after discussing various considerations adverse to recapture
(including some growing out of World War II), the Board stated, at p. 565,
with respect to the possible recapture of past earnings, though within the
rate proceeding period:
‘«, . . It would in all likelihood reduce managerial incentive to accom-
plish increased economies in operation. Management could hardly be ex-
pected to exert itself energetically to such purpose with the ever-present
fear, however unfounded it might be, that money saved through increased
economies would be taken away. It must be granted, too, that such a
policy writes a question mark across the carrier’s financial statements
which purport to reflect its true financial condition; for such statements,
upon which investors may have relied, may subsequently be rendered mis-
leading by a retroactive order of the Board. To tlie extent that such im-
cidents create uncertainty as to the carrier’s financial position they tend
to impair its ability to attract capital, and a program of debt financing
on terms unfavorable to the carrier would inevitably result.’’
BLEED THROUGH-— POOR COPY
41
In the case of C&S the disturbing effect to economic con-
ditions would be particularly acute by the substantive recap-
ture which the decision below requires. The entire air trans-
port industry, the financial world, and all concerned relied
upon the Board’s announced policies favoring final mail
rates and fostering of sound economic conditions. Not
until 1951 was it ever conceived by anyone that C&S’s 1948
domestic rates were other than final, as would be the case
if the Postmaster General’s success in the court below is
permitted to stand. No financial stability, no accurate
credit rating, no stable balance sheet position, no dividend
policy, and no ability to raise private capital can struggle
through such uncertainties as are piled up by the decision
of the court below.
EM ER ee PE Pe ee
domestic and international air services to compete effec-
tively with air carriers engaged exclusively in domestic
services with the result that the domestic public interest
would suffer and one of the principal objectives of the Act '
would be defeated. f
Domestic air carriers operatiug international routes com-
pete in their domestic services with air carriers engaged
exclusively in domestic services.
As has been pointed out above, international air services
are economically weaker than domestic air services.
| As a result, the air carriers engaged in both types of H
services would be subjected, under the decision of the court
below, to a constant draining off of their domestic earnings ¢
for the financial support of their international services. On f
the other hand, the domestic earnings of carriers engaged
exclusively in domestic air services are not subject to that
diversion. :
Under such circumstances the air carriers operating both
types of service could not maintain the same level of domes- i
tic earnings as their domestic competitors, and, therefore,
4. It would be impossible for air carriers engaged in both ;
?
BLURRED COPY
necessarily would compete at a great disadvantage. This
condition would jeopardize important public interest ob-
jectives with respect to domestic air service which are
within the purposes of the Act.
This point can be made clear by a simple example. Peti-
tioner today competes extensively with Eastern Airlines.
If Petitioner’s profits on the more lucrative domestic routes
(upon which it now has a service mail rate) are to be
drained off to support the less profitable international
routes, then Petitioner is at a severe competitive disadvan-
tage. Eastern, without such a drain on its profits, will
have a large body of earnings which it can direct towards
securing public support on the routes over which it is com-
petitive with Petitioner by securing larger, faster, and
more attractive equipment, by more extensive advertising,
by more frequent schedules, and, indeed, possibly by lower
passenger and cargo rates.
The increasing public acceptance of air transport in re-
cent years has made it possible for the Board to place a
substantial number of domestic air carriers on uniform
service mail rates for domestic services without including
any element of the subsidy payments. As indicated above,
ten of the thirteen domestic trunk-line air carriers, inelud-
ing Petitioner, are now receiving only service mail pay-
ments. With this elimination of subsidy, flowing from ade-
cuate domestic commercial earnings, further improvements
in the amount and stability of domestic earnings can open
the way for reductions in domestic passenger and cargo
rates, increases in the volume of air-coach services, and
other benefits to the public.
But it is axiomatic that domestic passenger and cargo
rates must, for competitive reasons, be substantially the
same as between carriers. Consequently, the level of do-
mestic earnings of those carriers operating both domestic
and internatienal services, depleted by the offset required
by the decision of the court below, would provide a higher
floor to domestic passenger and cargo rates than would
BLEED THROUGH-— POOR COPY
ae J oO ee ed ae
| :
4
, 43
otherwise be the case—unless the Board should abandon its
policy of uniform service mail rates for such carriers.
Either of these alternatives would be contrary to the gen-
eral public interest objectives of the Act.
Pe
D. CONTRARY TO THE POSTMASTER GENERAL’S ASSERTIONS, :
ADOPTED BY THE COURT BELOW. THE BOARD’S PRIOR j
ADMINISTRATION OF THE ACT DOES NOT SUPPORT THE
CONTENTION THAT IT MUST, AS A MATTER OF LAW, AP-
PLY EARNINGS REALIZED UNDER A FINAL AND UNCHAL-
LENGED MAIL RATE IN ONE DIVISION IN REDUCTION OF
NEED DETERMINED FOR ANOTHER DIVISION IN A SUB-
SEQUENT PROCEEDING.
ORO ON oe AES
The court below in seeking the proper construction of
Section 406(b) of the Act as applied to this case relied upoa
what it considered to be the ‘‘established construction of
the Act by the Board which should be given weigiht.’’
(R. 72) In support of this conclusion it noted that the Board
in the past has stated that the ‘‘need’’ referred to in Sec-
tion 406(b) of the Act is that ‘‘of the air carrier as a whole”’
and that the air carrier is the ‘‘ primary unit around which
the national air transportation system was to be developed
through the instrumentality of air mail compensation.’’
Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc.--Mail Rates for Route
Nos. 8 and 53,3 C.A.B. 161, 190 (1941). (R.72) It further
noted that this principle was reaffirmed in Pan American
Airways, Inc., Alaska Mail Rates, 6 C.A.B. 61, 67 (1944).
(R. 72).
The court below was in error in relying upon these cases
as an established construction of Section 406(b) insofar as
they might furnish any precedent for this proceeding. On
the contrary, the Board’s decision in this case that it was
not required, as a matter of law, to make the offset re-
quested by the Postmaster General, is in complete accord
with its prior administrative practice.
A reading of the 1941 CaS Case makes it clear that the
Board was there undertaking to establish the entire system
of the carrier as the base upon which to determine mail
BLURRED COPY
6 DTN DR PP OLIVIA 5 LS ADP LDL ALE A CBE, ERIM
44
payments. Within this framework the legal question was
posed of ‘‘whether the Board may make allowance for the
conduct of a passenger and property operation on which no
mail is carried in fixing the rates for the transportation of
mail over the earrier’s system.’’ 3 C.A.B. 161, 187. The
Board concluded that it was precluded ‘‘from confining its
consideration of the carrier’s need to that manifested on
a segment of its system upon which mail is carried to the
exclusion of its need on particular certificated segments of
its system serving commerce and the national defense
alone.’’ 3 C.A.B. 161, 190. The language which it used,
quoted by the court below, was intended to support the
conclusion that, within the framework of a system-wide
rate-making unit, all operations of a carrier, including its
non-mail operations found required by one or more pur-
poses of the Act, should be taken into consideration be-
cause such non-mail operations formed part of the system.
Obviously, therefore, there was no question in the 1941
CéS Case involving an effort to establish a division. The
case is not in point.**
The court below also relied upon Pan American Air-
ways, Inc., Alaska Mail Rates, 6 C.A.B. 61 (1944), wherein
the Board denied subsidy mail pay on Pan American’s
Alaska division because of excess earnings from its Latin
American division. But the language of the Board in that
case must be read in the light of the sui generis problem be-
fore the Board and its findings in the earlier first opinion
in the Pan American Airways, Inc., Latin American Mail
Rates Case, 3 C.A.B. 657 (1942). In the latter case the
Board had instituted a proceeding in 1939 looking to the
establishment of mail rates for Pan American, thereby ere-
ating an ‘‘open’’ mail rate period. The Latin American
Mail Rates Case was, after being reopened, ultimately de-
cided simultaneously with the Alaska Mail Rates Case in
43 The other cases relied upon in the Postmaster General’s brief to the
court below, p. 11, except for the Pan American division cases, diseussed be-
low, are distinguishable from the instant proceeding upon the same grounds.
BLEED THROU GH— POOR COPY
1944. Thus, until 1944 both the Latin American and the
Alaskan mail rates were ‘‘open’’ so that instead of recap-
turing, as it could have, in the Latin American Mail Rates
Case the ‘‘excessive’’ earnings realized by Pan American
during the pendency of that proceeding and then awarding
‘‘need’’ mail compensation for the Alaska division in the
Alaska Mail Rates Case the Board did the much simpler
act of equalizing the situation by leaving both divisions
where they were. This is an entirely different situation
from Petitioner’s case where the Postmaster General wants :
the Board to ‘‘offset’’ earnings realized in one of C&S’s 3
divisions during a closed period in which the rate was final
and unchallenged against mail pay requirements deter-
mined for another division in a subsequent proceeding some
three years later! Furthermore, there is another signifi-
cant distinction. In the Latin American Mail Rates Case
the Board, after finding and declaring the amount of the
‘‘exeess’’ earned during the pendency of that proceeding
stated that while it would not recapture the same by retro-
actively lowering the rate during the pendency of the pro-
ceeding, such ‘‘excess’’ earnings should be placed in a spe-
cial reserve account; and the Board stated that it intended
to take such ‘‘execess’’ earnings into account in determining
‘‘need’’ thereafter for other divisions of the carrier. Thus,
in lieu of recapture, something analogous to a trust fund
was created and notice was given to the carrier that the
fund would be applied as indicated. This certainly dis-
tinguishes the ease from Petitioner’s ease. If the Latin
American Mail Rates Case had been closed, as was Peti-
tioner’s 1948 domestic rate case, during the period in which
the earnings in question had been accumulated, the Board
would have had no power to recapture throagh the device
of a *‘trust fund’’ for later application elsewhere.
Petitioner therefore submits that the court below was
in error in relying upon the 1941 CéS Case and the 1944
SEERA EF ZITAT INN AIRS aL ARNO aC RNIN TONNE ME
Phe Nan ld
Thorsen attra
44 The Latin American Rate Case was subsequently reopened to revise the
amount of ‘‘excess’’ earnings because certain amounts had been erroneously
omitted in determining the investment upon which a rate of return was
allowed in the original opinion.
BLURRED COPY
PIPETTE TERE LE FINI ey BTR GOI a
1 AOA REARS PCE ALLEL PIO BOSE EADS AGA
46
Pan American Alaska Mail Rates Case as an ‘‘established
construction of the Act by the Board’’ governing this pro-
ceeding, as has been developed above. Petitioner further-
more submits that for the Board to have ruled under the
facts of this case, as the Postmaster General urged, that
the ‘‘need’’ referred to in Section 406(b) is the need of
the carrier as a whole, and, therefore, the Board must off-
set a portion of the earnings realized under the final and
unchallenged domestic mail rate against the ‘‘need’’ de-
termined for the international division, would have been
contrary to its prior administrative practice.
First, it would have been contrary to its holding in Pan
American-Grace Airways, Mail Rates, 3 C.A.B. 550, 561
(1942) that it could, in the exercise of its discretion, refuse
to recapture excess earnings even though they were realized
during an ‘‘open’’ period.
Second, it would have been contrary to its unvarying
policy to classify international and domestic operations
into two separate rate-making divisions where the inter-
national air transportation operations are of substantial
proportion.” In doing so the Board has stated that ‘‘we
believe the foreign and overseas operation should stand on
its own feet for mail-pay purposes’’.4® Such a statement
45e.g. Transcontinental § Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C.A.B. 595
(1945) ; Transcontinental § Western Air, Inc., Transatlantic Mail Rate, 7
C.A.B. 421 (1946); Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 8 C.A.B. 971 (1947) ;
Colonial Airlines, Inc., Bermuda Rates, 9 C.A.B. 20 (1948); Braniff Airways,
Inc., Mail Rates, 9 C.A.B. 607 (1948); Chicago § Southern Airlines, Inc.,
Mail Rates, 9 C.A.B. 786 (1948); Northwest Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, 10
C.A.B. 1 (1949) ; Transcontinental § Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 10 C.A.B.
803 (1949) ; Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, 11 C.A.B. 431 (1950); North-
west Airlines, Inc., Trans-Pacific Mail Rates, 12 C.A.B. 256 (1950); Colonial
Airlines, Inc., Bermuda Mail Rates, 12 C.A.B. 737 (1951).
46 Northwest Airlines, Inc., Trans-Pacific Mail Rates, 12 C.A.B. 256, 257
(1950). See, also, Pennsylvania Central Airline Corporation, et al., Motions,
8 C.A.B. 685, 703 (1947), where the Board noted that in the order fixing
TWA’s domestic rate it had ‘‘specifically provided that the rate was not to ap-
ply to the international operation, for which we subsequently, in a separate
proceeding, fixed a temporary rate. This has the effect of a determination
that TWA’s domestic and international operations are separate units for
rate-making purposes ...’’ (Emphasis supplied)
BLEED THROU GH- POOR COPY
reagent . PIR Pe A AA RLEE IRIE LAE SOE ERED
47
of policy, made prior to the decision in this case, is obvious-
ly contradictory to any alleged administrative practice
which would mean that the Board must consider the ‘‘need’’
of international and domestic operations as a whole in such
a manner as to require an ‘‘offset’’ of earnings under the
domestic division against the ‘‘need’’ of the international
division. In this proceeding,” and in subsequent proceed-
ings,** the Board has spelled out even more carefully its
view that the accomplishment of the objectives of the Act,
can, in a case where domestic carriers have substantial in-
ternational operations, only be achieved by separate mail
rate divisions where each will ‘‘stand on its own feet.”’
Finally, it is obvious that there was direct precedent in
the Board’s administrative practice, upheld by this Court,"
which would have contradicted any holding that the Board
was required to apply any portion of earnings realized
under a final and unchallenged mail rate against ‘‘need’’
determined in a subsequent proceeding. The Board has
already expressed opposition to any construction of the
Act which would further the incentive-destroying cost-plus
system of rate-making,”® and repeated this observation as
grounds for its decision in this ease. (R. 19-20)
47 See Statement, pp. 4-5, supra.
48 National Airlines, Inc., Statement of Tentative Findings and Conclusions,
CAB Order No. E-6344, April 21, 1952, pp. 2-3; Delta Air Lines, Inc., Mail
Rates, Latin American Operations, Statement of Provisional Findings and Con-
clusions, E-7738, September 21, 1953, pp. 7-15 (see excerpts quoted at pp. 35-36,
supra); Braniff Final Mail Rate Case, Tentative Decision CAB Order Na.
E-7815, October 13, 1953, pp. 4-9, particularly p. 5 where the Board said
‘*,.. the furtherance of the basic objectives of the Act, including the develop-
ment of economically sound domestic and international air transportation sys-
tems and the avoidance of monopolistic control of United States international
air transportation, requires the treatment of Braniff’s international and domes-
tie divisions as separate rate-making units.’’
49 Pennsylvania Central Airlines Corp., et al., Motions, 8 C.A.B. 685 (1947);
aff’d. sub nom Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. vy. Civil Aeronautics
Board, 336 U.S. 601 (1949).
50 See excerpt from the Board’s decision in the Pennsylvania Central Airlines
Case, supra, n, 24.
BLURRED COPY
le ee Cals
a ° a...
Poo Yep Oe WER. went we a ame
‘
48
Under these circumstances Petitioner submits that the
court below was in error when it asserted that there was
an established construction of the Act by the Board which
would stand as any precedent to support the position of
the Postmaster Genera] in this proceeding. The contrary
is the case. Prior administrative practice naturally led to
the Board’s rejection of the Postmaster General’s demand
that the Board was required, as a matter of law, to make
the ‘‘offset’’ he requested. This administrative practice,
geared, as it is, to the achievement of important objectives
of the Act, should be accorded great weight by this Court
in construing Section 406(b).
Il. IF, CONTRARY TO THE CONTENTIONS OF PETITIONER,
SECTION 406(b) OF THE ACT REQUIRES THE BOARD, IN
FIXING MAIL RATES FOR A RATE-MAKING DIVISION, TO
“TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION ... THE NEED...” OF THE
CARRIER AS A WHOLE, THEN THE BOARD’S ACTION
SHOULD BE UPHELD AS A VALID EXERCISE OF ITS Dis
CRETIONARY AUTHORITY.
Introduction. In the preceding portion of this Brief the
Petitioner has argued that the Board lacks the power to
take the action which the Postmaster General has requested.
If this Court does not agree, however, then Petitioner
argues, alternatively, that the Board’s decision should be
upheld as a valid exercise of the discretionary authority
delegated to it by Congress under Section 406(b) of the
Act when, after taking into consideration the ‘‘need’’ of
the air carrier as a whole, it concluded, for reasons of public
interest, which are within the objectives of the Act, that
the mail rates for the international division should be fixed
without any offset to reflect in such rates any part of the
domestic earnings.
Before presenting this argument (in Section B below)
it is necessary to discuss the question of whether there is a
body of ‘‘excessive’’ earnings in the domestic division, as
the Postmaster General contends. This must be done be-
cause it is only within the framework of an understanding
BLEED THROU GH- POOR COPY
49
of what the Board actually did in the proceeding below that
it can be determined whether the Board properly exercised
its discretionary authority. In Section A below, therefore,
Petitioner analyzes this matter and argues that there is
not now, and never has been, a specific body of earnings
which the Board has determined to be ‘‘excessive’’ over
what the carrier ‘‘needed’’ for its domestic system. Much
of the error which Petitioner claims was committed by the
court below can be attributed to the assumption that there
is such a body of legally determined ‘‘excess’’ earnings,"
and to a misconstruction of the manner in which the Board
below exercised the authority delegated to it by Congress
in Section 406(b) of the Act.
A. At no time was there any finding by the Board in the domes-
tic division of C&S that the carrier’s “need” was limited
to a return of 7.4%; or that any earnings, under the sliding-
scale future mail rates therein fixed, would be excessive:
and, therefore, there is no automatically determinable
“corpus” of “excess” earnings as the court below assumed.
As shown in the Statement,®? the Board in 1948 fixed
‘‘need’’ mail rates in the domestic division of C&S to
operate from January 1, 1948, forward. The Board did
not find just one rate fair and reasonable. It found that,
subject to the inevitably changing circumstances of the
future, and with a particular view toward providing the
management of C&S with incentive itself to change for the
better certain of those circumstances (such as load factors
and cost levels), a ‘‘sliding-seale incentive mail rate form-
ula’’ ** should be established. The Board said that this:
51It is to be noted that there was no necessity to discuss the nature of the
earnings on the domestic division (which the Postmaster General claims were
‘fexcessive’’) in Part I, above. This was true because, regardless of whether
or not a portion of the domestic earnings realized had been legally declared
‘‘excessive’’, Petitioner claims in Part I that the Board lacked the power
to deal with them in the international division proceeding.
52 Supra, pp. 5-8.
539 C. A. B. 786, 810-812.
BLURRED COPY
or
PN PE ET
ae
OEE ST Oe Se
ee TNR A DOP ET TIT
SSRI RE LT EE iy AR IPYS BS OCH ETT
on MISS om
PO BINE RRA PL
Co EPI BED IO DD! CE CB
50
‘«. . . sliding-secale incentive mail rate formula... will
fix a mail rate which will be reasonable in terms of an
attainable passenger load factor and will decline with
increases in the passenger load factor at a rate designed
to allow a progressive increase in the profit earned by
C&S.’’? (Emphasis supplied.)
The Board’s Appendix 12 to its opinion sets forth 27
airplane mile rates at 1 percent interval changes in the
passenger load factors ranging from 55% to 81%,” and in
the Board’s Order, it stated:
“It is Ordered, That the fair and reasonable rates
of compensation to be paid Chicago and Southern Air
Lines, Ine... . are hereby fixed, determined, and pub-
lished to be as follows:
‘«. . . For each month during which the average
passenger load factor ... does not exceed 56.99 per-
cent, a base rate of 34 cents per airplane mile; for each
month during which the average passenger load factor
exceeds 56.99 percent, a base rate per airplane mile
which shall be less than 34 cents by 1.05 cents per
airplane mile for each 1 percent, or fraction thereof, by
which the average passenger load factor exceeds 56.99
percent, provided that in no event shall the base rate
per airplane mile be less than 8.5 cents; .. .’’
Thus, the Board did not find just one mail rate fair and
reasonable; it found an infinite number of rates derived
from the formula between the stated maximum and mini-
mum ceiling and floor to be fair and reasonable. No action
by the Board in the domestic proceeding ever changed this
finding.
5449 C. A. B. 786, 811.
559 C. A. B. 786, 826.
56 Ibid, at 786-787. There was a change reflected in the base rate to take
effect on and after the carrier extended its international services beyond
Havana, Cuba (due to adjustments in allocations between foreign and domestic
costs and investment) but no change in the formula. The Board’s Order
placed these rates in effect. 9 C. A. B. 786-787.
BLEED THROU GH- POOR COPY
e777" SL + 9 EDGER AD ce OAS APOE ATL NCB ALA AY ME HE 8
51
As shown in the Statement,” the rate of return on invest-
ment was estimated by the Board to be 3.6% at a 55% load
factor, 7.3% at a 60% load factor, and 13.1% at a 70% load
factor. C&S had estimated a load factor of 60.09% for the
future.** Admittedly, such an estimate could not be infal-
lible. The Board accepted it; and then stated:
‘*. .. We have adapted this load factor to a sliding-
scale mail rate formula which permits the mail rate to
vary inversely with changes in the passenger load
factor and thus compensate to a substantial extent for
any errors in the forecast of load factors.’’ ®
Actual earnings for the 1948-1950 period in question in
domestic operations, reflecting commercial revenues and
compensation under these mail rates as reported to the
Board amounted to a 12.5% return on domestic investment
(R. 19, 53).° The Postmaster General seizes upon the
difference between a 7.4% return which, under the 1948
estimates would have been earned under static conditions
at the C&S forecast load factor, and the resulting actuality
of a 12.5% return (such difference being approximately
$654,000.) and labeled it ‘‘excess’’ earnings. He has erred
in his construction of the facts. As shown by the Board’s
Order quoted above, the infinite number of rates between
the ceiling and the floor established were found to be fair
57 Supra, n. 5.
58 This, under the formula and estimates, would have produced a 7.4%
return.
599 C. A. B, 786, 805-806.
60 Actually, the improved showing was achieved through economies effected
(specifically encouraged and hoped for by the Board—supra, n. 5, last para-
graph) through accounting adjustments not represented by dollar income—
and through the sale of equipment as shown by a stipulation filed with the
Board. (R. 65) (See, also, p. 3, n. 1, in the brief of the Board to the
court below). This stipulation, reporting operating net profit and investment
of the domestic division for the 1948-1950 period, did not have any bearing
upon the question of what was in excess of ‘‘need’’ because, under the Act,
only the Board can determine ‘‘need’’.
BLURRED COPY
grea
met
ROLLE FT: EAE LANE LI ELOY NO TG NIE TROT OY I NS ee NI
ss
se
SOREN IH PEL TPN III NEELAM ORS ah BERN TR
52
and reasonable. The amount actually earned was within
those limits.”
There is absolutely no basis for giving this amount of
$654,000, composed in a substantial part of accounting ad-
justments (R. 65), any status as ‘‘excess’’, or ‘‘excessive’’,
or as having any legal significance as being outside the
range of rates fixed by the Board to be fair and reason-
able—because it is not.
61 The Postmaster General stated in his brief to the court below (p. 9):
‘*. . . In the instant case the Board awarded domestic ‘need’ subsidy
which it estimated would yield a return after taxes for the years 1948-
1950 of 7.4% on property allocable to domestic operations. In fixing
foreign subsidy pay, it gave the carrier a 7% rate of return after taxes
for those years. Thus the Board in effect found that C&S ‘needed’ a
7.4% return on domestic and a 7% return on foreign operations.’’
As indicated above in the text, there is no such finding by the Board.
62 The Board has recently so stated specifically. C&S was merged into Peti-
tioner on May 1, 1953. This necessitated a new rate proceeding for the inter-
national division. In the proceeding in that matter, although as a result of
the merger all subsidy requirements have been eliminated in the domestic divi-
sion, the Postmaster General is contending that all estimated earnings over
what will produce some minimum rate of return on domestic investment should
be used to finance the estimated international future ‘‘need’’ of the merged
carrier in the international division. In commenting upon the relationship of
the decision of the court below to that problem, the Board, referring to the
fact that the court below had reversed the Board and held that it ‘‘had erred
in not offsetting the ‘excess’ earnings generated by the domestic division
against the need of the international division in fixing mail rates for the latter
operation’’, stated in a footnote:
‘«The term ‘excess’ earnings or profits, as that term was used in the
Board’s opinion in the Chicago and Southern case, in the opinion of the
Court of Appeals, and here, refers only to earnings in excess of a stated
rate of return on investment. The Board had no occasion to determine
in the Chicago and Southern case, and the Board does not determine here,
how much, if any, of these ‘excess’ earnings should be considered as ex-
cessive in the sense that these earnings are avail:>le for or should be off-
set against the mail rate for the international division, since in both the
Chicago and Southern case and in this case the Board’s decisions rest upon
a policy determination to treat the domestic and international divisions
as entirely separate for rate-making purposes, including the fixing of
final class rates applicable to more than one corporate air carrier. A de-
termination that earnings are excessive in this latter sense obviously re-
quires more than a mere subtraction of actual or estimated profits from
BLEED THROUGH-— POOR COPY
a
53
B. The Board in the proceeding below did “take into considera-
tion” the “need” of the air carrier as a whole and its deci-
sion was a valid exercise of its discretionary authority.
The Postmaster General’s contention is that in fixing
rates for the international division of C&S in 1951, the
‘‘need’’ of the carrier as a whole must be taken into con-
sideration. The court below appears to have adopted his
contention (R. 71).
If the Act is to be construed as requiring this, the deci-
sion of the Board in the proceeding below fully complies
with the requirement.
In its Statement of Tentative Findings and Conclusions
adopted May 18, 1951, in the proceeding before the Board
(R. 6-50), the Board expressly referred to the existence and
amount of the domestic earnings of C&S (R. 19). It then
discussed at length in the Statement the relationship of
those e#fnings to the international rates which should be
fixed for C&S in the light of public interest factors which
the Board analyzed and felt were pertinent to a determina-
an estimated rate of return on investment. See, e. g., our opinion in the
General Fare Investigation Case, Order No. E-7376, May 14, 1953.’’
Delta Air Lines, Ine., Mail Rates, Latin American Operations, Statement
of Provisional Findings and Conclusions, CAB Order No. E-7738, adopted
September 21, 1953, p. 6, mimeographed copy, n. 10.
As noted above, there is no legal basis for saying that there was any
earnings in ‘‘excess’’ of the ‘‘need’’ of C&S in its domestic division in the
1948-1950 period. However, the court below erroneously thought differently.
On the assumption it made, it was easy to take a second step in error and
apply such an assumed ‘‘excess’’ in reduction of international division
‘‘need’’. This was particularly easy to do in the light of the way the court
below erroneously quoted the statute by making ‘‘take into consideration’’
apply to ‘‘all other revenue’’ rather than to ‘‘need’’ as the statute reads (see
supra, n. 12).
63 However, the effect of the decision of the court below is to deny the
Board’s power to determine the carrier’s ‘‘need’’. The court directs that
$654,000 of the domestic earnings are to be regarded as in excess of the car-
rier’s domestic ‘‘need’’ for the 1948-19*9 period. This is an unauthorized
invasion by the court of a question committed by the Act to the Board’s dis-
cretion. In considering the ‘‘need’’ of the carrier as a whole in fixing rates
in 1951, the Board clearly is authorized to make an overall determination of
the actual ‘‘need’’, as it appeared in 1951,
BLURRED COPY
Te
Sie ae is ie ad
NS a Re TS
54
tion of the relationship of the domestic earnings to the rate
to be fixed for the international services (R. 19-20).
In its subsequent final opinion and order fixing the inter-
national divisien mail rates, the Board reviewed again the
relationship of the actual domestic earnings to the interna-
tional rates to be fixed and the considerations of public in-
terest involved in the alternative methods of treating such
earnings in fixing C&S’s international division rates (R.
53-55).
The Board’s extensive consideration of the domestic
earnings of C&S in the international rate proceeding below
coupled with its consideration of the C&S international di-
vision clearly was a consideration of the ‘‘need’’ of C&S
as a whole.
In its opinions in the proceeding below, the Board made
detailed findings with respect to the factors of public in-
terest which it found to be pertinent to the determination
of the relationship of the domestic earnings to the interna-
tional rates to be fixed. It concluded that to determine
that domestic earnings should be used to sustain interna-
tional operations would have serious consequences, undesir-
able from the point of view of the public interest (R. 55).
Specifically the Board expressly considered the treatment
of the domestic earnings in the light of the following fac-
tors: (1) That the international services are almost in-
variably weaker than domestic services and the offset
would, therefore, economically burden the domestic opera-
tions (R. 54); (2) that if the domestic air system can be
kept financially sound, the public must ultimately benefit
(R. 54); (3) that if the carriers’ domestic earnings position
continues strong, reductions in the domestic fare level will
be possible (R. 54); (4) that with improved domestic earn-
ings, carriers operating domestic services should be able
to benefit the public and themselves with more modern air-
craft and with improved methods affording safer and more
efficient operations (R. 54); (5) that to allow international
operations ‘‘to be carried on the back of domestic opera-
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
55
tions,’’ would subject the latter to ‘‘an unjustifiable strain’’
(R. 54); (6) that it was desirable to maintain the compar-
able status between domestic operators which have foreign
routes as against those which do not have foreign routes,
in order to permit the fixing of uniform domestic mail rates
for groups of carriers and thus create conditions more
favorable to efficient eperations (R. 54-55); and (7) that
the offset principle would establish an undesirable ‘‘cost-
plus’? system of rate-making for C&S and other carriers
operating both types of service (R. 19-21).
The Board concluded as a result of this consideration that
the domestic earnings should not be ‘‘offset’’ in fixing the
international rates and it fixed such rates on the basis of
such consideration and that conclusion (R. 55, 58-59).
The statutory directive in Section 406(b) against which
the above consideration by the Board must be measured is
not a narrow, mechanical one: but is a directive that the
Board shall ‘‘take into consideration . .. the need’’ of the
air carrier for compensation sufficient to enable it ‘‘to main-
tain and continue the development of air transportation’’
in accordance with the statutory objectives. The imple-
mentation of such a Congressional mandate is not some-
thing which can be done by any rigid formula or with mathe-
matical precision. On the contrary, the very scope of the
directive indicates clearly that by Section 406(b) the Con-
gress intended to give the Board the broad measure of dis-
cretion necessary to bring into play in the determination of
‘‘need’’ and the fixing of mail rates all considerations of
64In its final opinion below the Board expressly said that it was ‘‘not
deciding the question of our legal power to make such an offset’’ (R. 55).
In view of this, since, after reviewing in the opinion the facts with respect
to C&S’s earnings and needs the Board decided that C&S should retain the
domestic earnings, it takes such earnings into consideration in the sense that
the existence and effect of such earnings was a part of the process of deci-
sion. The conclusion is inescapable that the Board decided that C&S needed
its actual domestic earnings. Had the Board decided otherwise it would have
been necessary for the Board to decide the question of its legal power to
make the offset.
BLURRED COPY
56
public interest which the Board should find to be in further-
ance of the statutory objectives.
The soundness of this approach to the meaning of Sec-
tion 406(b) is clearly confirmed by the general breadth of
the discretionary authority given to the Board by the Act
asawhole. Any effort to limit the wide sweep of discretion
reposed by Congress in the Board when, in the determina-
tion of mail pay, the Board is authorized to ‘‘take into con-
sideration’’ the ‘‘need’’ of the air carrier ‘‘sufficient . . . to
enable’’, among other things, the maintenance and contin-
uance of the development objectives of the Act, is utterly
inconsistent with the entire scheme of the Act.”
To begin with, Congress has set forth in Section 2 of the
Act basic purposes thereof which it has required that the
Board ‘‘shall consider’’ in ‘‘the exercise and performance
of its powers and duties under this Act’? which would in-
clude, of course, the duty to fix mail rates under Section 406
of the Act.”
An analysis of other broad grants of authority to the
Board by Congress points up the broad area of judgment
and discretion which it must exercise. Thus Congress gave
the Board power over the establishment of routes,” pas-
senger and property fares and rates in domestic air trans-
65 The basic nature of rate-making under any statute involves a broad
ambit of discretionary authority on the part of the rate-making agency. As
this Court said in Board of Trade v. United States, 314 U.S 534, 546 (1942):
‘*The process of rate-making is essentially empiric. The stuff of the
process is fluid and changing—the resultant of factors that must be
valued as well as weighed. Congress has therefore delegated the en-
forcement of transportation policy to a permanent expert body and has
charged it with the duty of being responsive to the dynamic character
of transportation p: >dlems.’’
66 The Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit has noted that
the provisions included in Section 2 under the title of ‘‘ Declaration of Policy’’
are ‘‘peremptory’’ and ‘‘are as much an enactment by the Congress as is
any other section of the statute.’’ American Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aero-
nautics Board, 192 F. 2nd 417, 420 (D. C. Cir. 1951).
67 Sec. 401 and 416 (b), 49 U. S. C. 481, 496 (b), domestic routes. As to
international routes, see supra, n. 28.
BLEED THROUGH- POOR COPY
ee ee oe Ans
57
portation,” mergers, consolidations, and acquisitions of con-
trol,®* interlocking relationships,” power to dispense with
the operations of the ‘‘antitrust laws’’™ and the responsi-
bility to provide financial assistance where necessary to
maintain and continue the development of air transporta-
tion through ‘‘need’’ mail rates.** The Board even has
the power to grant exemptions under certain circumstances
from the provisions of the economic regulation Title of
the Act.”
The vast scope and magnitude of the discretionary power
intended to be conferred by the Congress thus emerges.
Under Section 2 of the Act, the Board must, in connection
with exercising its power to set mail rates, among other
factors, consider the ‘‘encouragement and development of
an air transportation system properly adapted to the pres-
ent and future needs of the foreign and domestic commerce
of the United States, of the Postal Service, and of the na-
tional defense.’’ This is not a simple assignment. It is one
for expert judgment by the Board and requires considera-
tion not only of the effect of any proposed action upon the
individual carrier or carriers concerned, but the effect upon
other carriers and upon the public.”
68 See. 1002 (d), 49 U. S. C. 642 (d).
69 See, 408, 49 U. S. C. 488.
70 See, 409, 49 U. S. C. 489.
71 See, 414, 49 U. 8. C. 494.
72 See. 406, infra, Appendix.
73 See. 416 (b), 49 U. S. C. 496 (b).
74In the second to last paragraph of the opinion of the court below, it notes
its decision in Summerfield, Postmaster General, et al. v. Civil Aeronautics
Board, Nos. 11259 and 11324 in which, in an opinion by Judge Prettyman, it
held that profits derived by Western Air Lines, Inc. from the sale of an air
route certificate with operating equipment cannot be excluded from revenue
for the purpose of providing an industry incentive. The Court then states
that ‘‘we see no essential difference between that case and this.’’ (R. 72)
It is not clear whether the court below was thereby intending to incorporate
by reference as one of the grounds for its decision in this case its holding
in the Western Case that the Board cannot, in determining mail rates, con-
BLURRED COPY
58
It would be completely inconsistent with the broad ambit
of discretionary power delegated to the Board by Congress
in the Act, as well as with the broad discretionary language
of Section 406(b) itself, to conclude that the consideration
given to the ‘‘need’’ of C&S by the Board in its decision
below was not a lawful and appropriate discharge of its re-
sponsibility to ‘‘take into consideration’’ the ‘‘need’’ of
C&S for mail compensation sufficient to enable it ‘‘to main-
tain and continue the development of air transportation to
the extent and of the character and quality required for
the commerce of the United States, the Postal Service, and
the national defense.’’
sider the development of air transportation generally but must focus upon the
development of the single carrier or carriers before it in an individual pro-
ceeding. Judge Prettyman, who wrote the opinion in the Western Case, stated
in his dissent in this case that he did not find the problem of the Western
Case in the present case.’’ (R. 73-74). Petitioner submits that Judge Pretty-
man was right for, as indicated above, many of the findings upon which the
Board based its decision relating to the ‘‘need’’ of C&S were findings directly
affecting C&S alone. Petitioner also submits, however, that the holding in
the Western Case is in error. Broad questions of national air transportation
policy and their effect upon the public obviously must be considered in the
determination of mail rates if the objectives of the Act are to be achieved.
Reference to the Declaration of Policy in Section 2 of the Act indicates that
Congress never had a ‘‘keyhole’’ approach under which elements entering into
the ‘‘need’’ of a carrier ‘‘to maintain and continue the development of air
transportation’’ could fail to encompass the entire air transportation system
of the nation. Such a narrow view has surely never been held in the rate-
making tradition where the effect of a proposed rate upon the public interest
has always been an element in rate making. Baltimore ¢ Ohio R. Co. v.
United States, 345 U. S. 146, 150 (1953); King v. United States, 344 U. 8.
254, 263, 264 (1952).
meee =f ees Aa teres Ce ee ee on ae ee
59
CONCLUSION.
For the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully urged that,
the judgment of the court below should be reversed, and the
orders of the Board of which review is sought, affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
L. Wetcu Poeue,
Attorney for Delta Air Lines, Inc.
Of Counsel:
R. S. Maurer,
Vice President-Legal,
Delta Air Lines, Inc.,
Municipal Airport,
Atlanta, Georgia.
Pocue & NEAL,
805 15th Street, N. W.,
Washington 5, D. C.
November 17, 1953.
—— ws am ees oo
60
APPENDIX
The pertinent provisions of the Civil Aeronautics Act of
1938 ', as amended, are as follows:
DECLARATION OF POLICY
Sec. 2. In the exercise and performance of its powers
and duties under this Act, the [Board] shall consider the
following, among other things, as being in the public inter-
est, and in accordance with the public convenience and
necessity—
(a) The encouragement and developnfent of an air-
transportation system properly adapted to the present and
future needs of the foreign and domestic commerce of the
United States, of the Postal Service, and of the national
defense ;
(b) The regulation of air transportation in such manner
as to recognize and preserve the inherent advantages of,
assure the highest degree of safety in, and foster sound
economic conditions in, such transportation, and to improve
the relations between, and coordinate transportation by,
air carriers;
(ec) The promotion of adequate, economical, and efficient
service by air carriers at reasonable charges, without un-
just discriminations, undue preferences or advantages, or
unfair or destructive competitive practices;
(d) Competition to the extent necessary to assure the
sound development of an air-transportation system prop-
erly adapted to the needs of the foreign and domestic com-
merce of the United States, of the Postal Service, and of the
national defense ;
(e) The regulation of air commerce in such manner as
to best promote its development and safety; and
(f) The encouragement and development of civil areo-
nautics.
1Act of June 23, 1938, ec. 601, 52 Stat. 977, as amended, 49 U.S.C. 401,
et seq.; Reorg. Plan No. IV, Sec. 7, effective June 30, 1940, 5 F.R. 2421.
BLEED THROUGH— POOR COPY
61
RATES FOR TRANSPORTATION OF MAIL
Authority to Fix Rates
Sec. 406 (a) The [Board] is empowered and directed,
upon its own initiative or upon petition of the Postmaster
General or an air carrier, (1) to fix and determine from
time to time, after notice and hearing, the fair and reason-
able rates of compensation for the transportation of mail
by aircraft, the facilities used and useful therefor, and the
services connected therewith (including the transportation
of mail by an air carrier by other means than aircraft
whenever such transportation is incidental to the trans-
portation of mail by aircraft or is made necessary by con-
ditions of emergency arising from aircraft operation), by
each holder of a certificate authorizing the transportation
of mail by aircraft, and to make such rates effective from
such date as it shall determine to be proper; (2) to pre-
scribe the method or methods. by aircraft-mile, pound-mile,
weight, space, or any combination thereof, or otherwise, for
ascertaining such rates of compensation for each air carrier
or class of air carriers; and (3) to publish the same; and
the rates so fixed and determined shall be paid by the Post-
master General from appropriations for the transportation
of mail by aircraft.
Rate-Making Elements
(b) In fixing and determining fair and reasonable rates
of compensation under this section, the [Board], consider-
ing the conditions peculiar to transportation by aircraft
and to the particular air carrier or class of air carriers,
may fix different rates for different air carriers or classes
of air carriers, and different classes of service. In deter-
mining the rate in each case, the [Board] shall take into
consideration, among other factors, the condition that such
air carriers may hold and operate under certificates an-
thorizing the carriave of mail only by providing necessary
and adequate facilities and service for the transportation 7
of mail: such standards respecting the character and quali-
ty of service to he rendered by air carriers as may be pre-
scribed by or pursuant to law; and the need of each such
7 So in original.
BLURRED COPY
RE eS
62
air carrier for compensation for the transportation of mail
sufficient to insure the performance of such service, and,
together with all other revenue of the air carrier, to enable
such air carrier under honest, economical, and efficient man-
agement, to maintain and continue the development of air
transportation to the extent and of the character and quali-
ty required for the commerce of the United States, the
Postal Service, and the national defense.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.